{"records":[{"record_id":"contribution-7bab651a27a417f70ab91220","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76906,"date":"2026-01-26T19:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister has basically just admitted he is failing with regard to affordability. It is so bad that he just had to announce another temporary boost to the GST credit. If prices were actually under control, Canadians would not need another recycled Trudeau-era rebate to put food on the table.\n\nCanada now has the highest food inflation in the G7. Food bank use is at record levels, with millions of Canadians relying on emergency food just to feed their families. A tax rebate helps momentarily but does nothing to address what is actually driving food costs: carbon taxes on fuel and fertilizer, the clean fuel standard and industrial carbon taxes built into every step of the supply chain.\n\nThe Prime Minister once told Canadians to judge his government by the prices at the grocery store, but by that measure his policies have failed miserably, and no tax gimmick can hide—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76906","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister has basically just admitted he is failing with regard to affordability. It is so bad that he just had to announce another temporary boost to the GST credit. If prices were actually under control, Canadians would not need another recycled Trudeau-era rebate to put food on the table.\n\nCanada now has the highest food inflation in the G7. Food bank use is at record leve","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","label":"Nutrition","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a12799101aa2458b26535c8840bcddbc7a2cb093e9d8725271884fb26d2fef9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8cfb8514d29affec63419592c6ee7835e6396c88443355a53128349f11c3e10b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ab164eb6e254bd9bf65ef45","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76907,"date":"2026-01-26T23:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister said something at Davos that sounded like pure common sense. He said, \"A country that cannot feed itself, fuel itself or defend itself has few options.\" Most Canadians heard that and thought, \"Well, of course,\" and yet the Prime Minister does the exact opposite here at home. He talks about fuelling ourselves, and then his government blocks energy projects. He talks about prosperity, and then investment gets buried under years of red tape. He talks about independence, and then Canada becomes more dependent, not less. Canadians are left scratching their heads because the words make sense but the actions do not.\n\nWhen a government keeps saying the right things while doing the opposite, people stop listening to speeches and start paying attention to their bills, their jobs and their future. That is the gap Canadians are feeling right now, between what is said abroad and what is actually happening at home.\n\nAt Davos, the Prime Minister told the world that the rules-based order is ruptured. He warned countries to stop living within a lie and to be honest about the gap between rhetoric and reality.\n\nHowever, here is the reality that Canadians are living with. The rules-based order has not been thrown out the window, especially when it comes to our most important trading relationship. Despite tough rhetoric coming out of Washington, the vast majority of Canadian goods are still flowing into the U.S. under CUSMA, with minimal tariffs and established rules still in place. There are thousands of businesses that rely on CUSMA. They cannot afford anything that puts that relationship at risk. The system is under strain, but it is still functioning. A strong negotiator would have brought stability, not uncertainty, for Canadian businesses.\n\nAt Davos, the Prime Minister also warned against nostalgia. He said we should not hanker after things that no longer are. He told the world that the old order is finished and is not coming back, yet the moment he returned home and reality set in, his tune changed. Faced with pressure from the U.S., our largest trading partner, he suddenly began talking about a reset, about rebuilding the relationship and returning to something closer to what we had before.\n\nMembers can take note of the irony here. Abroad, the Prime Minister tells global leaders that nostalgia is foolish. At home, he asks Canadians to believe he can restore the very relationship he said no longer exists. This is where Canadians bring the conversation back to the basics. If we do not have a pipeline to the Pacific, then we do not really have access to the world. We have one main customer, the U.S., and that means we do not have leverage when things get tense; we have dependence.\n\nWe can talk all we like about diversification and resilience, but until Canadian oil can reach global buyers through a reliable Pacific corridor, those words do not change our reality. This is not about who has the power to act. The federal government has the authority to move projects like this forward. It does not require another announcement or another overseas speech. It requires decisions, permits and a clear timeline.\n\nInstead, what we keep seeing are press conferences, consultations and promises that remain stubbornly in the future. The result is that Canadians stay stuck, rich in resources and short on results. Canada has everything it needs: the resources, the workers and the global demand. What is missing is not vision but the willingness to act. Until the government is prepared to approve projects and turn speeches into action, Canadians will keep living with a gap between what is said abroad and what is done at home.\n\nIf the Prime Minister truly believes what he said at Davos, when will he remove the laws that make pipelines to tidewater impossible?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76907","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister said something at Davos that sounded like pure common sense. He said, \"A country that cannot feed itself, fuel itself or defend itself has few options.\" Most Canadians heard that and thought, \"Well, of course,\" and yet the Prime Minister does the exact opposite here at home. He talks about fuelling ourselves, and then his government blocks energy projects. He talks ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e77d4de05518b10a5f0851229394e714623c09851c39adc1932d280358e5dd78"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a38b2c756f4b731e8dd0e2b2486ad30386fbd594d19e1c413d23488006e63363"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e768a5e8894a462e81accd2b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76908,"date":"2026-01-26T23:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister sold himself as a master negotiator. People elected him to get a deal with the U.S., and now he is telling everyone that our old relationship with it is finished.\n\nI have spoken to local business owners, manufacturers, exporters and family-run companies. They are scared to death about what happens if CUSMA negotiations fail. These are not abstract fears. These are payrolls, contracts and livelihoods hanging in the balance, with no backup plan and no margin for error. If this deal fails, the damage will not be theoretical. It will tear straight through communities, with jobs lost, investments frozen, businesses destroyed and families left picking up the pieces.\n\nWill the Prime Minister stop posturing and start thinking about the people who will pay the price here at home, or will Canadians be left carrying the cost of his miscalculations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76908","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister sold himself as a master negotiator. People elected him to get a deal with the U.S., and now he is telling everyone that our old relationship with it is finished.\n\nI have spoken to local business owners, manufacturers, exporters and family-run companies. They are scared to death about what happens if CUSMA negotiations fail. These are not abstract fears. These are p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0e4e2d6bd5b7a62e407d52157edae60c3d6c81f285a5644b0dc8bb362c5925b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd34bbd1a79046d43939377c3de08a6059019b81e245d617c2cb7ba59d290f43"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12824a05462576e0caec3f26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76909,"date":"2026-01-27T19:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when I was growing up, I learned a core Canadian value: Canada succeeds when people are free to make choices for themselves. In Davos, the Prime Minister signalled different values. He believes markets should not follow people's choices but be set by regulators, banks and global institutions. He believes that individual choice should be replaced by imposed outcomes decided by a small group of elites. However, that philosophy rejects a core Canadian value: freedom.\n\nFreedom is like the family in my riding who took a failing plastics factory, bought by their grandfather in the 1960s, and turned it into a world-class producer of anti-doping kits for the Olympics. Freedom is like the Ugly Potato Day at the Heppell's farm in Surrey, where thousands of kilos of wonky potatoes that grocery stores do not want are given away for free to families who absolutely do want them.\n\nThose ideas do not come from Davos. They come from free Canadians solving real problems in the real world.\n\nNow, that is a real Canadian value we can take straight to the bank.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Potatoes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76909","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when I was growing up, I learned a core Canadian value: Canada succeeds when people are free to make choices for themselves. In Davos, the Prime Minister signalled different values. He believes markets should not follow people's choices but be set by regulators, banks and global institutions. He believes that individual choice should be replaced by imposed outcomes decided by a small ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","label":"Potatoes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Potatoes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","label":"Potatoes","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["015b2939fab0457ac9a61c2c18a6c6abf36856daac2fb840b46ceb4d13ef1b7b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Potatoes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1da8647a8da0c665065d4bcb247d66230ba7fe56e5dc829c56b63b6e4ef226be"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Potatoes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bd9ce9c8dd5e8dc9ab67d30","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76910,"date":"2026-01-28T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister wants to talk about the gap between rhetoric and reality. Well, last week reality came in the form of two police cars in my driveway investigating a report of shots fired on my street. My neighbours are wondering if we are now in the line of fire of some extortionists. Surrey's mayor, Brenda Locke, is asking the government to declare a state of emergency.\n\nConservatives are asking, will the government stop with the rhetoric, restore mandatory minimums and repeal the catch-and-release laws so criminals will feel the consequences?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76910","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister wants to talk about the gap between rhetoric and reality. Well, last week reality came in the form of two police cars in my driveway investigating a report of shots fired on my street. My neighbours are wondering if we are now in the line of fire of some extortionists. Surrey's mayor, Brenda Locke, is asking the government to declare a state of emergency.\n\nConservat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef41d5b57e2a9631a0ae71810a0c86e6de1447cfec19adc9976003246ae93a9d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be73bc43c09ee46560d2786b265b21354ac18ea3c4ac994cfe6c3f920dcecb74"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a4b29f005aa480db9bb09aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76911,"date":"2026-01-28T20:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to present two petitions. The first is from Canadians who are profoundly concerned about the government's plan to expand medical assistance in dying to people whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness. The petitioners make their position clear. They state that mental illness is by nature treatable and recovery is possible. They warn that expanding MAID in these circumstances risks normalizing the idea that people struggling with mental illness should be offered assisted dying instead of suicide prevention treatment.\n\nTherefore the petitioners call upon Parliament to adopt Bill C-218, ensuring that mental illness is not classified as a grievous and irremediable condition for the purposes of MAID.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76911","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to present two petitions. The first is from Canadians who are profoundly concerned about the government's plan to expand medical assistance in dying to people whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness. The petitioners make their position clear. They state that mental illness is by nature treatable and recovery is possible. They warn that expanding MAID in thes","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["746ba78bf4d3d1c8fd7a8f5252e6f631e309cf59d4662b660e97d45c8f87e8eb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["74c6702a28ec7d73c87363dfb59f6ee331980c5bd4ec8cba6d74c44bc4590027"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3c36c5d90dcbd152f404c7c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76912,"date":"2026-01-28T20:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the second petition is from Canadians who are expressing great concern about the assault on religious freedom and freedom of expression contained in Bill C-9, which would remove the long-standing good-faith safeguards for religious expression, raising the risk that Canadians could face investigation for expressing sincerely held beliefs on a religious subject or for citing certain religious texts. The petitioners remind the government, and particularly the Liberal members and Bloc members, that freedom of religion and freedom of expression are listed as fundamental freedoms in our charter.\n\nTherefore the petitioners ask the government to withdraw Bill C-9 and protect the freedom of religion for all Canadians so they can discuss their faith and share their religious texts in the public square without fear of government investigation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76912","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the second petition is from Canadians who are expressing great concern about the assault on religious freedom and freedom of expression contained in Bill C-9, which would remove the long-standing good-faith safeguards for religious expression, raising the risk that Canadians could face investigation for expressing sincerely held beliefs on a religious subject or for citing certain r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["02f6ff80579a1552f890ca517130397328359e8e275f256bc5f381db9d23ce9f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["68a49776ac8fcf0f53d01d0b790d1baa176bb3f53452cecf3115fe09672a0d33"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d8bb0242b9bf34b34a378b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79289,"date":"2026-02-02T19:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, 20 minutes from my place, people can look across the Canadian border at affordable homes that look exactly like the ones selling for double the price in our country. Nearly half of young Canadians now say they have considered leaving their province just to afford housing. Two of my daughters moved out of B.C. to afford a home. Now they want to come back, but prices are worse than ever, and new home sales in Vancouver are down 56%. \n\nDoes the Prime Minister even care that young people are priced out of home ownership?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79289","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, 20 minutes from my place, people can look across the Canadian border at affordable homes that look exactly like the ones selling for double the price in our country. Nearly half of young Canadians now say they have considered leaving their province just to afford housing. Two of my daughters moved out of B.C. to afford a home. Now they want to come back, but prices are worse than ever","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child custody","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child custody","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","label":"Child custody","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48d6189f3678cdb0285d360f5442a8801a01d7872d5f33775b860186de70fcca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0de690cdf25f010015068108","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79290,"date":"2026-02-02T19:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this did not happen by accident. Homes did not just suddenly become unaffordable on the Canadian side of the border. Government policy made them that way, and that is why sales are collapsing. Builders are laying off workers, and young Canadians are forced to leave.\n\n Will the Prime Minister admit that his housing policies are the reason young Canadians can afford a home 30 minutes across the border but not here? Will he finally remove the roadblocks that are driving our talented kids out of Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79290","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this did not happen by accident. Homes did not just suddenly become unaffordable on the Canadian side of the border. Government policy made them that way, and that is why sales are collapsing. Builders are laying off workers, and young Canadians are forced to leave.\n\n Will the Prime Minister admit that his housing policies are the reason young Canadians can afford a home 30 minutes ac","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fdc2c0ebd2755ffd30e374017bd81249f89a36b8a17e4da7de7615b664f7109e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["463a03a7b278295fd9673fb212fe5a6b7baf6a7cf40715a42918b2f8fec72e8d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebfb08877804f4f16d2e476c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79064,"date":"2026-02-03T18:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with my colleague from Tobique—Mactaquac.\n\nEarly in the morning at Heppell's potato farm in Surrey, before most of us are awake, the work is already under way. The ground is damp, the equipment is running, trucks are being loaded, and rows of potatoes that will end up on dinner tables across this country are being pulled from the soil by people who have done this their whole lives. This is a fifth-generation family farm, the same land and the same work ethic passed down year after year. \n\nFarming is never easy. There are weather, pests and timing, and they live with that. What is new is the pile-on from the government. Every piece of equipment runs on fuel that is more expensive because of federal taxes. Fertilizers cost more, packaging costs more, and transport costs more. There is a threat that their land leased from the government, some of the best farmland in the Fraser Valley, will be paved over in the next few years. None of this is optional, and these threats to the farm all come from the Liberal government. \n\nTyler Heppell told me something simple: \"We don't control prices. We just watch our costs climb and hope we can keep going.\" When people who grow our food are worried about whether they can keep farming, that should worry us. We often hear from the government that there are no taxes on groceries. I would like to demonstrate the reality of those taxes and inflationary policies that are forcing food prices to skyrocket in Canada. \n\nLet us take the example of something as ordinary as a single pound of potatoes from the Heppell family farm. That potato starts in the ground. To plant it, the farmer needs diesel to run his equipment. That diesel now carries a fuel standard tax. Before the potato is even grown, policy has already added cost. Then comes the fertilizer. Fertilizer production is energy intensive, which means it carries the industrial carbon tax. That cost does not stay at the factory. It is built into the price that farmers pay. Again, farmers have no choice. They cannot grow potatoes without fertilizer. Harvest time comes, and the equipment runs again. There is more fuel and more tax. The potatoes are dug up, washed, sorted and stored. Storage requires electricity. Processing facilities face higher energy costs, compliance costs and reporting requirements, all of which are government-imposed and all of which are passed along. \n\nThen the potato needs to be packaged. This is where red tape turns into inflation. New federal packaging and labelling requirements mean redesigning packaging, reprinting materials, changing suppliers, updating compliance systems and, in some cases, slowing production lines. Maurizio Zinetti, owner of Zinetti Foods in my riding, told me plainly that none of these packaging changes makes food safer or cheaper. It just makes it more expensive. Every box, label and adjustment adds a few more cents. When packaging millions of units, those cents add up fast. \n\nThen the potato is loaded onto a truck. The trucker pays higher fuel costs because of the fuel standard tax. Those costs are not absorbed; they are charged forward. Finally, the grocery store receives the pound of potatoes. The store did not cause the inflation, the farmer did not cause it, and the trucker did not cause it, but all of them have been handed higher costs, and there is only one place those costs can go. They go to the price tag. That is how inflation works. It is not through greed or climate change but through a steady accumulation of policy choices that make every step of production more expensive. When government taxes the production of food at every stage, it should not surprise us when food becomes unaffordable. By the time that pound of potatoes reaches a Canadian kitchen, families feel it. Prices are up. When people ask why, the Liberal answer is always the same: climate change. \n\nLet us keep following the potato and see if that excuse holds up. Our potato was grown on the Heppell family farm in B.C. Imagine another potato grown just south of the border in Idaho: same crop, same season, same sun, same rain, same droughts, same heat waves. Climate change does not stop at the 49th parallel. Both farmers deal with the same climate risks. Both wake up early and hope the crop makes it through, but as those two potatoes move toward markets, something different starts to happen. The Canadian potato picks up costs that have nothing to do with soil or sky. It carries higher costs because of federal carbon taxes. It carries higher fertilizer costs because of industrial carbon taxes. It carries added compliance costs from packaging and labelling. It carries transportation costs inflated by a fuel standard tax on top of everything else.\n\nThe Idaho potato does not carry those same policy costs, and when both potatoes finally arrive at the grocery store side by side, the Canadian one is more expensive, not because the farmer is greedy, not because the climate was worse, but because our government added more costs to it along the way. That is why food inflation in Canada is now twice as high as it was when the Prime Minister took office. That is why it is twice as high as in the U.S. That is why we now lead the G7 in food inflation. \n\nIf climate change were the main cause, our numbers would move together, but they do not. Climate change is global. The inflation is local. The Prime Minister said that he wanted to be judged by the price of groceries. Canadians have done exactly that. They judge him every time they put something back on the shelf, every time they choose beans over beef, every time they are forced to line up at a food bank to feed their family. This is not a mystery. It is the result of choices made here, added step by step, potato by potato.\n\nLet us follow that same pound of potatoes one last step. By the time it reaches the grocery store, it costs more, not because of the farmer or the climate but because of all the costs added along the way. Canadians see the higher price and they feel it immediately. The government's response is not to remove those costs; instead, it sends out a cheque. The Liberals call it help, they call it relief, but what they are really doing is this. After making that potato more expensive to produce, transport and sell, they are borrowing money to give a small portion of that back. \n\nThe Parliamentary Budget Officer looked at this plan and told us it will cost billions of dollars over the next few years. That money is not coming from savings or from growth; it is borrowed. Let us think about what that means. We add costs to the potato on the way up, the price rises, and then we borrow money to soften the blow. That borrowed money adds to inflation, and inflation makes the potato even more expensive. It is a loop.\n\nA family might get a cheque today that might help for a month, but it does not make fuel cheaper for the farmer. It does not make fertilizer cheaper. It does not remove the packaging rules and transport taxes. All of those costs are still waiting for the next harvest. The potato goes through the same process again, only this time the dollar buys a little less because more money has been pumped into the system with nothing done to fix the cause. That is not a food affordability plan. That is borrowing to cover up the consequences of bad policy. Real relief would be stopping the cost increases at the beginning of the potato's journey, not mailing out cheques at the end and pretending the problem is solved.\n\n We have followed a simple pound of potatoes all the way from the field to the family table. We saw how costs were added step by step, fuel taxes, fertilizer taxes, packaging rules and transport costs, until that potato cost far more than it should. We saw how the government blamed the climate, even though the same climate exists beyond our borders. We saw how its final answer was to borrow billions to send out cheques, which only makes the potato more expensive. \n\nOur Conservative motion offers a different path. Instead of adding costs to the potato at every stage, we say that we should remove the hidden taxes that drive up the cost of producing and delivering food. We should stop treating farmers and truckers as problems to be managed and start treating them as partners who feed the country. We should stop trying to buy Canadians off with gimmicks and tricks that will only end up costing us more. Canadians do not want a cheque that disappears in a month; they want food they can afford every week. If we want fewer people lining up at the food banks, we have to stop making food more expensive in the first place. That starts here with this motion. This is common sense. It is time to let Canadians keep more of their own money, one potato at a time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Potatoes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79064","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with my colleague from Tobique—Mactaquac.\n\nEarly in the morning at Heppell's potato farm in Surrey, before most of us are awake, the work is already under way. The ground is damp, the equipment is running, trucks are being loaded, and rows of potatoes that will end up on dinner tables across this country are being pulled from the soil by people who have done ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","label":"Potatoes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Potatoes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","label":"Potatoes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["44e4f4568be135f929d0f269946f12a27295d1d97a59e39a4703c0e73399b866"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Potatoes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6f7ec39d65c93ccd0f1f06960c6993bceb077cd01f7c9e75a5e5ce51507ac021"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Potatoes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Potatoes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b1808607d01aae2bd2006b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79286,"date":"2026-02-03T18:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I had hoped my speech would help Canadians better understand how these hidden taxes are driving up prices.\n\n Farmers, truckers and grocery clerks do not set prices. Government policy sets prices. We tax fuel, fertilizer, packaging, all these things, the cost of travel for food all the way to the checkout. Our motion says to stop adding costs to the potato and start taking them off by removing hidden taxes and boosting competition so Canadians can afford to eat. That is what our motion proposes, and I hope our colleagues will support it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79286","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I had hoped my speech would help Canadians better understand how these hidden taxes are driving up prices.\n\n Farmers, truckers and grocery clerks do not set prices. Government policy sets prices. We tax fuel, fertilizer, packaging, all these things, the cost of travel for food all the way to the checkout. Our motion says to stop adding costs to the potato and start taking them off by ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e42888a316961850c2299c538102b23aa6ea49e6d081ecfc4d30702db7cff88"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5422dc01b302b6fe57b376a978f1c083f8c71786a6ac5085a9962df085e5cabf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aedf0b34a994b60f9aa95af3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79287,"date":"2026-02-03T18:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think the most important part right now is to focus on our farmers. Giving people a tax rebate, for example, is not a great solution, because it makes our food more expensive. It is not a food affordability plan. \n\nWe followed a pound of potatoes from a local farmer and saw where the costs were added. Instead of removing these costs, the government borrows billions to send some of that money back, which adds to inflation and makes the next potato even more expensive. \n\nCanadians require relief, but what they need is food costs to be less every week. A good solution would be to remove the hidden taxes that are making their lives less affordable, the solution found in today's Conservative motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79287","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think the most important part right now is to focus on our farmers. Giving people a tax rebate, for example, is not a great solution, because it makes our food more expensive. It is not a food affordability plan. \n\nWe followed a pound of potatoes from a local farmer and saw where the costs were added. Instead of removing these costs, the government borrows billions to send some of t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Potatoes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59481","label":"Potatoes","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9a7661e7fd14afdf833e69d10ac2b1aa13818133343682f2c6e584c143d4e83"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["31e4b21756c8886756124b4cf77f9bd04f0c0a5589c1ca654824728b9514842d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12068c6199e42582f5efd444","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79288,"date":"2026-02-03T18:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague is right. We need to focus on the real problem, which is government inflationary policy, if we want to fix this. The Liberals offer excuses, but Conservatives offer solutions.\n\n A potato grown in B.C. faces the same climate change as the one grown in Idaho: same sun, same rain, same drought. However, the Canadian potato costs more because government policy adds costs at every step: fuel taxes, fertilizer taxes, packaging rules and transport costs. If climate change were the reason for our food inflation, then all the G7 countries would feel it the same, but instead, Canada has the worst food inflation in the G7. The weather, the climate, is global. The inflation is domestic.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79288","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague is right. We need to focus on the real problem, which is government inflationary policy, if we want to fix this. The Liberals offer excuses, but Conservatives offer solutions.\n\n A potato grown in B.C. faces the same climate change as the one grown in Idaho: same sun, same rain, same drought. However, the Canadian potato costs more because government policy adds costs","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","label":"Weather","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d93538a099d143d230b5543fa7078f6b716c96a843b10732c3dc395da663d023"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["529b31e5c79b22295cef678a49ab59feae74ffc43e2fbf475bd35d818043d65e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-16bfa9e0342a90489b64b055","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79062,"date":"2026-02-05T21:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have noticed over the last 10 years that the Liberal government has always been very quick to apologize. I am just wondering why the government suddenly seems to be so incredibly hesitant to apologize for something that we know really should not have happened.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79062","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have noticed over the last 10 years that the Liberal government has always been very quick to apologize. I am just wondering why the government suddenly seems to be so incredibly hesitant to apologize for something that we know really should not have happened.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aab1da218a932c23ddccf254","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79063,"date":"2026-02-05T21:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, over the years, I have noticed that the Liberal government is always very quick to apologize. It makes me wonder why the government suddenly seems so incredibly reluctant to apologize for something that we know full well should never have happened.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79063","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, over the years, I have noticed that the Liberal government is always very quick to apologize. It makes me wonder why the government suddenly seems so incredibly reluctant to apologize for something that we know full well should never have happened.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f57591214ed6cdd069a9f98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288367,"date":"2026-02-09T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I just attended an event hosted by SPEATBC in a room full of highly trained engineers and technologists. They were asking whether the next round of manufacturing investment will stay here in Canada or go to the U.S. They want solutions so that their jobs are secure. StatsCan says that we lost 28,000 jobs last month in manufacturing alone. That means fewer shifts, tighter budgets and more families struggling to get by.\n\n The government has to recognize that what it is doing is not working. When will the Liberals listen to our constructive solution to this urgent problem?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288367","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I just attended an event hosted by SPEATBC in a room full of highly trained engineers and technologists. They were asking whether the next round of manufacturing investment will stay here in Canada or go to the U.S. They want solutions so that their jobs are secure. StatsCan says that we lost 28,000 jobs last month in manufacturing alone. That means fewer shifts, tighter budgets and m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15f8453039fcd6360b94130ffc4b3da0c5bcdb5a5eacf34177e24c34a0f05550"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8672d7da1a3588bdb54de735","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288368,"date":"2026-02-09T22:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada needs a pipeline. We are a sovereign, resource-rich nation. We produce energy the world wants, yet instead of building the infrastructure that would allow us to sell that energy at full value, the Prime Minister has tied our economic future to a net-zero framework so complex, so conditional, that we are assured it will take forever and cost the max. It goes without saying that approving a nation-building pipeline is not the responsibility of the NDP Premier of B.C; it is a federal responsibility, and it rests squarely on the Prime Minister's desk.\n\nLet us be clear about what is happening in the background. I want to demonstrate that by following a Canadian dollar, one loonie, through the system as it now stands under the Prime Minister. Let us follow it through the Pathways carbon capture project, which the Prime Minister has attached as a condition to the pipeline Canadians so badly need. \n\nFirst, the carbon capture project itself is risky. It is massive. It is expensive. It is not about affordability; it is about net-zero ideology once again.\n\nIn a normal market, investors look at that and say there is too much risk and no return. Since the free market is not interested in these mega-expensive net-zero projects the Prime Minister wants so badly, what happens next? The government steps in and sweetens the deal. This is called de-risking. Ottawa offers investment tax credits. It builds guarantees and backstops. It creates funds designed to absorb losses if things go sideways to ensure there is little risk for the project investor.\n\nIn plain language, the government tells the investor not to worry because, if this does not work out the way they hoped, the taxpayer will carry part of the risk. Right there, our humble little loonie transmogrifies, as Calvin and Hobbes would say. It changes from a free-market loonie into an insurance loonie. It moves onto the taxpayers tab.\n\nHere is where Canadians should really stop and pay attention. There is talk that our retirement savings could now be part of this. The Prime Minister talks as though pension savings could be a tool for the government's nation-building agenda. However, is that what Canadians voted for? Did they elect him to find a clever way into the CPP cookie jar? Every paycheque, whether for teachers, public servants, even the translators working right now to ensure my words are heard in French, includes a mandatory deduction for their retirement.\n\nThis is their money, and it was deliberately placed out of politicians' reach years ago, which was supported by the Conservatives, precisely so they could not redirect Canadians' retirement savings towards political priorities. Pension funds were designed to be protected from political interference. Their job is to invest responsibly, not to chase ideological projects dressed up as policy.\n\nHere is my key point: We know that, if a project is too risky, it should not qualify for pension investment, but with fancy footwork, the government could de-risk it on the back of the taxpayer and suddenly the project would look safe enough on paper. The spreadsheet improves and projected returns stabilize, not because the risk disappeared, but because middle-class Canadians are now holding the bag. When things go sideways, who carries the risk? Public dollars will absorb losses. The middle-class family will absorb the loss in the form of taxes and inflation. That loonie quietly shrinks in purchasing power.\n\nThis is ultimately a question of integrity and fairness. In a free market, risk and reward go hand in hand. Those who take the risk bear the consequences, good or bad. That connection creates discipline and it forces careful decisions, but when the government alters that relationship and stacks the deck, someone loses. When will the Prime Minister stop hiding behind expensive, inflationary, ideological preconditions and approve a pipeline to get to the Pacific to let Canadians get full value for the resources we have in abundance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288368","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada needs a pipeline. We are a sovereign, resource-rich nation. We produce energy the world wants, yet instead of building the infrastructure that would allow us to sell that energy at full value, the Prime Minister has tied our economic future to a net-zero framework so complex, so conditional, that we are assured it will take forever and cost the max. It goes without saying that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5a4cf463890d8520c7791becda9fd506c3bc7a9503ffaacf9c904a17b1ea0ba7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3f47a48a858f3d64eb4e5738380e661dcceac5bd468fafe86fa8c28018697ef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9741181d83675c81f12f8ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288369,"date":"2026-02-09T22:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians do not need another process or another framework. They need a pipeline. We are a resource-rich country watching other nations move ahead while we debate conditions and caveats. A pipeline to the Pacific is not an experiment. It is not a theory. It is basic infrastructure, the kind Canada has built before and the kind for which they should already be moving dirt.\n\nUnder a Conservative plan, this would be straightforward and less costly. We would approve the project, set a clear route, respect federal jurisdiction and get shovels in the ground, with no ideological add-ons, no extra net-zero preconditions and no endless detours. The reason the pipeline is not built is not because Canada cannot do it. It is because the Prime Minister will not. He keeps adding conditions. He keeps outsourcing responsibility. He keeps pretending a province holds a veto over a project that is squarely federal. Leadership means making a call. \n\nMy question is simple: When will the Prime Minister approve a pipeline to the Pacific so that Canadians can finally get to work?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288369","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians do not need another process or another framework. They need a pipeline. We are a resource-rich country watching other nations move ahead while we debate conditions and caveats. A pipeline to the Pacific is not an experiment. It is not a theory. It is basic infrastructure, the kind Canada has built before and the kind for which they should already be moving dirt.\n\nUnder a Con","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["426453977a94bc69201cf1e864bac028dd3dc267c63ffd1f844f5d2b80dd00e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["743f74344378f7c5b83c1e5efaec0e284e8006e9918a87dd1ebbad1d02c07d98"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5ab32dfe31282c0fe4cd5c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288366,"date":"2026-02-10T19:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, picture a city with gangs demanding protection money from small businesses, where shots are fired at home, where families fear going out at night and people are forced to change their cars and their routines. It sounds like I am describing a slum in a third world country, but it is my hometown of Surrey. What is worse is that when these thugs are caught, they are right back on the street after claiming refugee status.\n\nWill the Liberals support our motion that those charged with or convicted of serious crimes cannot exploit the refugee system in order to stay in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288366","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, picture a city with gangs demanding protection money from small businesses, where shots are fired at home, where families fear going out at night and people are forced to change their cars and their routines. It sounds like I am describing a slum in a third world country, but it is my hometown of Surrey. What is worse is that when these thugs are caught, they are right back on the str","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","label":"Gangs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","label":"Gangs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c5f1910746e26b6c8c9def4bbe93be9bc5b3d3a46bf248385b7937aa0da27869"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["74e9d1de9a1c3c481844ac565239d8b450381da3f51ca41aee4443a464a869e4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9706075cbf3c46665c62246","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288363,"date":"2026-02-12T17:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after years of failed EV mandates, to the tune of $52 billion in subsidies from Canadian taxpayers, the government now wants to spend another $2.3 billion to boost the sales of cars that Canada does not build. The fact is that nearly all previous rebates went to vehicles manufactured outside Canada.\n\nIf the goal is to strengthen our auto sector, why is subsidy money going to support American factories instead of Canadian workers? How will this help the 5,000 families who have lost their jobs in the auto sector?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288363","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after years of failed EV mandates, to the tune of $52 billion in subsidies from Canadian taxpayers, the government now wants to spend another $2.3 billion to boost the sales of cars that Canada does not build. The fact is that nearly all previous rebates went to vehicles manufactured outside Canada.\n\nIf the goal is to strengthen our auto sector, why is subsidy money going to support A","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a011ed167010fc5c872147ed250baf50f37324378ab1570eb8aa86ba8335a7fb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["24d3d7a963b888688ae4c0a9523d1fc12ea5fcce63ae102061fa76a76f4e8161"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2ff4a7fc824698a0f3ff986","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288364,"date":"2026-02-12T21:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we spent $52 billion trying to force an EV transition. Production targets are failing, 5,000 workers have been laid off, and now the government wants another $2.3 billion in subsidies, even though most of its past rebates went to foreign-built vehicles.\n\nIs this about helping Canadian workers or saving face after a failed policy experiment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288364","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we spent $52 billion trying to force an EV transition. Production targets are failing, 5,000 workers have been laid off, and now the government wants another $2.3 billion in subsidies, even though most of its past rebates went to foreign-built vehicles.\n\nIs this about helping Canadian workers or saving face after a failed policy experiment?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e974077f78eef73bcae55eb761364abd80f272c2c082ab5816503e5dbc9ecb4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9ac9eda99e3aeb34375b8117f07c604bcfc5edbdda96278ed5843fdb0edf8534"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ef1b721994c8d43ce2b38e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288365,"date":"2026-02-12T21:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals finally removed the EV sales mandate, which was a common-sense thing we had been begging them to do, but then they imposed a tailpipe emissions standard so strict that only electric vehicles would realistically qualify. As such, the mandate disappeared in the press release, but it reappeared in the regulations. Does my colleague think that Canadians appreciate these kinds of games?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288365","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals finally removed the EV sales mandate, which was a common-sense thing we had been begging them to do, but then they imposed a tailpipe emissions standard so strict that only electric vehicles would realistically qualify. As such, the mandate disappeared in the press release, but it reappeared in the regulations. Does my colleague think that Canadians appreciate these kinds","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e436b97e4cf0f7408e3611720822cb9c7f4ee2dc7843cf54ef04f16b02f7ee3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebc364055a1ababa61121e0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306974,"date":"2026-02-26T19:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, all five of my children are married and raising a family of their own. Like so many young Canadians, they are working hard just trying not fall into debt. Home repairs, music lessons, cadet uniforms, gas to drive kids to activities, and the everyday cost of raising a family all add up. Saving is nearly impossible right now, and 64% of millennials are worried about their future. Parents are doing everything right yet still falling behind.\n\nWhen will the government lower costs so Canadian families can stop worrying about just staying afloat and start planning for their future again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306974","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, all five of my children are married and raising a family of their own. Like so many young Canadians, they are working hard just trying not fall into debt. Home repairs, music lessons, cadet uniforms, gas to drive kids to activities, and the everyday cost of raising a family all add up. Saving is nearly impossible right now, and 64% of millennials are worried about their future. Parent","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","label":"Household equipment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c64955dc44caac590da0acfb1c15e02692bf1cdf2f0a9fca6f72feae67736fb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ce1bf9796f74103664e055b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306975,"date":"2026-02-26T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when I look at my grandchildren, I think about the life they should be able to build: going to university, buying a first home, raising a family of their own and believing that hard work will allow them to get ahead. However, today their parents are struggling just to cover everyday costs, and saving for their own future is slipping out of reach, with household debt now at $2.6 trillion.\n\n How can the Liberal government justify spending today in ways that will fundamentally limit the future of our grandchildren?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306975","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when I look at my grandchildren, I think about the life they should be able to build: going to university, buying a first home, raising a family of their own and believing that hard work will allow them to get ahead. However, today their parents are struggling just to cover everyday costs, and saving for their own future is slipping out of reach, with household debt now at $2.6 trilli","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d69d77dda392bccef04cc73442830511de411cef0a3d79504e989a6bebae9228"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92b19ac26dd448effa3db55d42f795bd262080e9873bc47f02def0d3ed76b8a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ace39550a3b2f6fc552a28b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340094,"date":"2026-03-10T17:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the member for Carlton Trail—Eagle Creek. \n\nBill C-9 did not start out as a debate about religious freedom. It was presented as a modernization measure, a technical reform that we were told would strengthen protections against hatred while ensuring that Canada remained a country defined by tolerance, pluralism and mutual respect. That, at least, was the stated objective when the bill first came to Parliament, yet the legislation has changed in a way that few Canadians anticipated. Even fewer were properly consulted.\n\n During committee, the Liberal government, supported by the Bloc, voted to remove from the Criminal Code a safeguard that has existed for decades, a provision that recognizes that the expression of sincerely held religious beliefs, when offered in good faith, does not constitute criminal hate speech. \n\nThis safeguard was not accidental wording inserted into the law without deep reflection. It represents Parliament's understanding that Canada is home to citizens whose deepest convictions are shaped by many different faith traditions, stretching back centuries. These are traditions that speak openly about morality, human dignity, family life and social responsibility, in ways that may at times challenge prevailing cultural opinion. In acknowledging this reality, the Criminal Code drew an important distinction that disagreement, even profound disagreement, must never be confused with criminal intent.\n\n When religious communities across Canada began raising concerns about the removal of this safeguard, and these were concerns voiced by Jewish congregations, Christian churches, Muslim organizations, Sikh gurdwaras, Hindu temples and Buddhist communities, the government responded by introducing what it described as clarifying language to assure Canadians that nothing essential had changed and that religious expression would remain protected under the bill. However, when we take a closer look at this so-called clarification, a fundamental question arises. If religious expression truly remains protected, if sermons, scripture reading, theological teaching and moral discussions are still lawful, then why remove the explicit protection that guaranteed that certainty in the Criminal Code in the first place?\n\n For decades, the Criminal Code contained something very concrete, a good-faith religious defence that recognized that sincerely held religious teachings, expressed honestly and without the intent to promote hatred or violence, fell outside criminal sanction. That clarity mattered not only because it guided prosecutors when deciding whether charges were appropriate, but also because it reassured ordinary Canadians that the practice of their faith, expressed peacefully and in good conscience, would not suddenly expose them to criminal charges, yet the government now proposes to replace that certainty with verbal reassurances alone, asking Canadians simply to trust that their freedom remains secure, even as the explicit protection that guaranteed them is removed from the law. However, verbal reassurance is not the same thing as protection, so I rise today with a sober sense of duty because the responsibility now falls to the members of the House to defend the religious freedom of Canadians.\n\n Over the past weeks and months, thousands of Canadians, pastors, rabbis, imams, community leaders and ordinary citizens, have taken the time to call and write their members of Parliament, expressing deep concern about this bill and asking that it not proceed in its current form. Despite those voices, the government has chosen to press ahead, even shutting down debate in an ironic twist of government censorship of free speech.\n\n If the government were confident that Bill C-9 represented sound legislation capable of withstanding careful examination, it would welcome debate and allow amendments to be discussed openly. It would permit members of Parliament to do the work Canadians sent them here to do, to examine legislation thoughtfully before it becomes law. Instead, the government that insists Bill C-9 is necessary to regulate harmful speech is now censoring debate on its own censorship bill.\n\n Religious freedom holds a unique place among our democratic liberties because it speaks not simply to opinion but to belief, to the deeply held convictions through which people understand duty, morality and the meaning of their lives. History shows us again and again that, when governments attempt to control belief, even claiming to preserve harmony or protect the public good, the result is rarely unity and almost never justice. Over centuries, societies have learned that peace in diverse countries is not achieved by forcing everyone to agree but by allowing people with very different beliefs to live together without fear that the state will dictate what they must believe. \n\nHistory gives us a lot of examples of what happens when governments try to control belief. A friend of mine recently shared the story of Guru Tegh Bahadur, the ninth guru of the Sikh faith. In the 17th century, during a time of increasing religious pressure in Mughal India, Hindu families from Kashmir were being forced to abandon their faith and convert under the authority of the state. Desperate to preserve their freedom, they travelled long distances seeking someone who would defend their right to follow their beliefs. They turned to Guru Tegh Bahadur, a Sikh spiritual leader, because they believed he understood something essential, which is that freedom of conscience belongs to every person. \n\nGuru Tegh Bahadur could have chosen silence and avoided a confrontation with imperial power, yet he understood that, once a government claims the authority to dictate the beliefs of one community, the freedom of everyone becomes vulnerable. Knowing that risk, he refused demands that he convert or force others to convert. For taking that stand in defence of the right of a faith community to exist, he was imprisoned and ultimately executed in Delhi in 1675.\n\nFor this reason, he is remembered in Sikh tradition as the shield of India, because his sacrifice protected the freedom of others. His life reminds us of a truth that reaches across centuries and cultures, which is that religious liberty cannot be divided. When it is taken from one group, it eventually becomes fragile for everyone. That lesson echoes throughout history, because societies thrive when people are free to speak openly about their convictions, even when those convictions challenge the thinking of the day. Many ideas we now celebrate as moral progress began as minority voices standing against the consensus of their time.\n\n I want to be very clear about why I raise this example. The point is simple, and it is that moral arguments, including those shaped by faith, have always been a part of public life, and history shows that silencing those voices cost society dearly. Few stories show this more clearly than the life of William Wilberforce. \n\nAt the height of the British Empire, the transatlantic slave trade was deeply embedded in the global economy, with powerful institutions defending it and many believing Britain's prosperity depended upon it. To oppose slavery at that time was widely seen as extreme, yet Wilberforce, guided by his Christian faith, believed moral responsibility required action. He began a decades-long struggle in Parliament, standing year after year to argue for abolition, all while facing defeat, ridicule and warnings that his efforts threatened Britain's economy. For nearly 20 years, his efforts failed, but perseverance eventually prevailed when Parliament abolished the slave trade in 1807. \n\nWhat began as an unpopular moral conviction ultimately reshaped law and history. The lesson is clearly that freedom of expression does not exist simply to protect views that are comfortable or widely accepted, but to protect the voices that challenge the thinking of the moment. The lesson is not that every moral argument wins, but that a free society must allow those arguments to be made.\n\n Canada's success as a pluralistic society rests on that principle. People came here seeking the freedom to live according to conscience, bringing different languages, cultures and faith traditions, which could exist side by side because the law did not demand ideological conformity. Faith communities helped build our country precisely because they were free. Long before government programs existed, churches, mosques, synagogues, temples and gurdwaras helped establish hospitals, schools, food banks, shelters and charitable organizations that continue to serve Canadians today. \n\nRemoving religious safeguards from the Criminal Code does not strengthen our democracy; it weakens the legal clarity that allows this pluralism to flourish. Canadian courts have already made it clear that violence, threats and incitement to harm are not protected speech and never have been, which is why these actions are already criminal offences. What the good-faith defence protects is something very different. It is the right of Canadians to express sincerely held beliefs without fear that disagreement itself might one day become a criminal matter. \n\nCanada has never required uniformity of belief to maintain peace. Our strength has always rested on freedom under law and the ability of people with very different convictions to live together without coercion. If the government truly believes religious expression remains protected, then leaving the safeguard in place should present no difficulty because its presence harms no one, while its removal creates uncertainty for many Canadians. \n\nA confident democracy does not silence debate and certainly does not use closure motions to rush through legislation that touches on the freedoms of conscience and expression. In a free country, we respond to ideas we disagree with through debate, persuasion and democratic engagement, not through criminal law and shutting down Parliament to prevent discussion. \n\nCanadians deserve clarity in their law, confidence in their freedoms and a Parliament willing to defend both.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340094","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the member for Carlton Trail—Eagle Creek. \n\nBill C-9 did not start out as a debate about religious freedom. It was presented as a modernization measure, a technical reform that we were told would strengthen protections against hatred while ensuring that Canada remained a country defined by tolerance, pluralism and mutual respect. That, at least, was th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab2fc9f32ae6cba8efe3926e980d07ceee4e38ce26355745fb136e94fb79c85d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15aab28bf954f97f4ad0969d3c3059c279bf8664276852f2931a5344e578c43f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cccb58b2a302e434ffe42e8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340095,"date":"2026-03-10T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, with respect to the issue before us, it is not about supporting protections against hatred. We all support protections against hatred.\n\n However, on whether the government should remove a safeguard that has protected the good-faith expression of religious beliefs for decades, the question Canadians are asking is very simple: If religious expression is already protected, why remove the protection that made it clear in the Criminal Code in the first place? That is the concern faith communities across the country are having, and they have been raising it. That is the concern Parliament should be addressing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340095","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, with respect to the issue before us, it is not about supporting protections against hatred. We all support protections against hatred.\n\n However, on whether the government should remove a safeguard that has protected the good-faith expression of religious beliefs for decades, the question Canadians are asking is very simple: If religious expression is already protected, why remove the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["919012f31d6aa142a660407a87cd4acb8aa62eb9c4e7f96219a795a7666f8108"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a0e0bbb56113afca7ca13333a07e8e3f145bf12b3911273073c4b7f6d2aa089"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e6bd0bb36068ecdc67600a50","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340096,"date":"2026-03-10T17:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as we have repeated many times, the tools are there, and they have not been used correctly. What I have been hearing from Canadians is not political theatre, but genuine concern. Over the past weeks, thousands of people, rabbis, pastors, imams and ordinary citizens, have taken the time to write and call their members of Parliament because they fear the good-faith expression of their beliefs could someday be treated as a criminal matter. When so many Canadians raise that concern, Parliament's responsibility is not to dismiss them or rush the bill through, but to ensure that their fundamental freedoms remain clearly protected in law.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340096","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as we have repeated many times, the tools are there, and they have not been used correctly. What I have been hearing from Canadians is not political theatre, but genuine concern. Over the past weeks, thousands of people, rabbis, pastors, imams and ordinary citizens, have taken the time to write and call their members of Parliament because they fear the good-faith expression of their b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3d818735485c89bf8b8e367ba77672d855f6217c0fb56abc0c2f6d1b1d82cde"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a86c6243ee23c17f31a60e140b3df395f035aaf681c951f14c28211e1bd73ce9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d5d34450b569bb82b003758","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340097,"date":"2026-03-10T17:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague gave a wonderful explanation. The thing that really strikes me the most is that the government told Canadians not to worry because it just added in a clarification clause, yet when we read that clause, it simply says that speech is allowed as long as it is not hate speech. That is not really a clarification. It is just circular reasoning. \n\nThe previous safeguard actually drew a line that Canadians could understand, which is that sincerely held religious teaching expressed in good faith was not criminal. Removing that clarity while claiming nothing has changed is exactly why so many Canadians remain concerned.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340097","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague gave a wonderful explanation. The thing that really strikes me the most is that the government told Canadians not to worry because it just added in a clarification clause, yet when we read that clause, it simply says that speech is allowed as long as it is not hate speech. That is not really a clarification. It is just circular reasoning. \n\nThe previous safeguard act","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f541ce1a829775dfe789226","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340098,"date":"2026-03-10T19:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when the IRGC shot down flight PS752, 55 Canadians were murdered. In the days that followed, I stood with those grieving families in my riding and promised them that Canada would be a place of safety, not a place where people connected to that regime could live freely. However, yesterday at committee, officials admitted that they cannot deport the Iranian regime officials already here. They can claim asylum. They say there are no flights and that their identities must remain protected. \n\nHow is it possible that the victims' families live in fear while members of that regime live safely in our communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340098","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when the IRGC shot down flight PS752, 55 Canadians were murdered. In the days that followed, I stood with those grieving families in my riding and promised them that Canada would be a place of safety, not a place where people connected to that regime could live freely. However, yesterday at committee, officials admitted that they cannot deport the Iranian regime officials already here","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8af8dbf1fbbafcf2ba94cabc4937c94415ed092e1a7d6111c02cf177c6383379"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb801e502759409dd9a160d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340099,"date":"2026-03-10T19:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this threat is no longer distant. It is happening right here in Canada. Last week, three synagogues were shot at. Now an Iranian activist has gone missing. Police are investigating it as a homicide while the Iranian community fears Tehran's involvement. Meanwhile, hundreds of people linked to the IRGC are living freely in our country.\n\n I stood beside PS752 families in my riding and promised that Canada would stand up to this regime. Instead, the government has allowed its agents to operate on our soil. Why has the minister allowed Canada to become a safe haven for a terrorist regime?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340099","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this threat is no longer distant. It is happening right here in Canada. Last week, three synagogues were shot at. Now an Iranian activist has gone missing. Police are investigating it as a homicide while the Iranian community fears Tehran's involvement. Meanwhile, hundreds of people linked to the IRGC are living freely in our country.\n\n I stood beside PS752 families in my riding and p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036616","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036616","label":"Soil","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["42f8a3d72dc120784c2e725ec8fd6d8f0982bcfd544c0dfaa47120adab82c061"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ca4dc48211ad6c35b9ee70536288b7e3582768e50ad00e57d88da034e08003f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8fc955dac0b56ec78120099","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":339535,"date":"2026-03-11T22:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister claims that this Indonesia trade deal is a major breakthrough, yet his own government says the economic impact will be just 0.012% of the GDP by 2040. That is about the value of one tanker's worth of LNG. At the same time, the United States has negotiated billions in the Indonesian purchases of American goods, including energy, agriculture and aircraft.\n\nWhy does my colleague think that the Prime Minister keeps signing deals that look good in a press release, but leave Canada trailing behind our competitors?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:339535","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister claims that this Indonesia trade deal is a major breakthrough, yet his own government says the economic impact will be just 0.012% of the GDP by 2040. That is about the value of one tanker's worth of LNG. At the same time, the United States has negotiated billions in the Indonesian purchases of American goods, including energy, agriculture and aircraft.\n\nWhy does my","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Alternative fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Freight","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Freight","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","label":"Freight","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","label":"Alternative fuels","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e557f0c09780c30914aecc997cd6a521c2844a5fb7ed036828377c62b6dc865"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d41e98c5034592d554b50419d49669dba19f0d03475a26ac39b4ed0b6d07def9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ddd3e7043005fb90cc09fdf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340092,"date":"2026-03-11T23:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to begin with something that happened in my riding, because sometimes the most honest way to understand an economic problem is simply to listen to the people living with it.\n\nA woman named Amy from Cloverdale wrote to me recently. She works hard, pays her bills and tries to live responsibly, but she told me that grocery shopping has become something that she now dreads, not because she is buying luxuries, but because basic food is becoming harder to put in the cart. Meat, once a normal part of meal, has become something she buys only occasionally. When she heard that prices are expected to rise again this year, she wondered whether Canadians will eventually be on their hands and knees, begging the government for relief.\n\nI heard a similar concern when I visited seniors in my riding this week. These are men and women who spent decades working, paying taxes, raising families and contributing to this country, yet many told me that they are now studying grocery flyers and cutting back on foods they never imagined giving up at this stage in their lives. The question they asked is the same as Amy's, and it is very simple: How did it become this hard to buy food in Canada?\n\nThe Prime Minister once told Canadians to judge him by the price of groceries, and Canadians are doing exactly that. The numbers are troubling. Canada now has the highest food inflation in the G7, with grocery prices rising more than 7% over the past year, which is far faster than overall inflation. Coffee and beef are up dramatically. Everyday staples are rising faster than the rest of the economy.\n\nRoughly 70% of the food Canadians eat is produced right here in Canada. When Canadians see food prices rising faster here than anywhere else in the G7, they begin asking whether the explanation lies closer to home than the government would like to admit.\n\nThere is a very simple rule in economics: When governments make something more expensive to produce, the price of that thing eventually rises. When we look at the policies affecting food production in Canada today, we see farmers facing higher costs from the industrial carbon tax on fuel, fertilizer and farm equipment; truckers facing the fuel standard tax, which raises the cost of transporting food across this country; and food producers and processors facing a packaging tax projected to cost Canadians more than $1 billion. \n\nNone of these policies appear on a grocery receipt, but their costs travel through the system, from the farm to the processor to the truck, and finally to the grocery shelf and when they arrive at the checkout counter, which is where Canadians experience them.\n\nWhen I think about where those rising costs eventually lead, I cannot help but think of my own family. I have 22 grandchildren, and like every grandparent, I want them to grow up in a Canada where hard work still allows a family to afford the basics of life.\n\nThe seniors I spoke to were not only worried about prices but asking something deeper, about fairness. These are Canadians who spent decades paying taxes into this country, yet they now find themselves watching every dollar they spend on groceries while government spending seems to grow in every direction. Some of them asked how it is possible that people who paid into this country their entire lives are struggling to keep up with the basics, while individuals whose refugee claims have already been rejected can still remain in Canada for years and continue receiving benefits, including coverage for dental care, prescriptions and other health services that many seniors still have to pay for themselves.\n\nCanadians are patient people, but they expect one thing from their government, which is not to make the essentials of life harder to afford. Canadians like Amy and the seniors I spoke with this week are asking a very simple question: When will the government stop the policies that are driving up the cost of food, so that Canadians can afford to feed themselves again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340092","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to begin with something that happened in my riding, because sometimes the most honest way to understand an economic problem is simply to listen to the people living with it.\n\nA woman named Amy from Cloverdale wrote to me recently. She works hard, pays her bills and tries to live responsibly, but she told me that grocery shopping has become something that she now dreads, not bec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["47afb23e61a0410bb05535e657dccf405b9ab357a07574c2a01b20f309fccf5f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2db145540a1e679caaa47c0a90fe34e3a12354f1829e6633fa45ece1e9b98088"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a120346516dad1ebdb3e9d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340093,"date":"2026-03-11T23:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the families and seniors in my riding who are carefully studying grocery flyers deserve a straight answer about why food keeps getting more expensive. We often hear the government members say it is a global problem, but if that were true, every country would be feeling it equally, and they are not. Canada now has the highest food inflation in the G7.\n\n When we look at where Canadians are being hit hardest, we see that it is not on imported luxuries. Ground beef is up 22%; whole chicken, nearly 13%; pork, more than 13%; and even romaine lettuce has jumped 17%. These are not imported luxuries. These are foods raised and grown by Canadian farmers, yet families and seniors in my community are paying more for them every single week.\n\n Food prices are 27% higher than five years ago, and food bank use has doubled since 2019. People in my riding do not want to have to rely on food stamps. What they want to know is why decisions are being made in Ottawa that keep driving up the price of Canadian food.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340093","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the families and seniors in my riding who are carefully studying grocery flyers deserve a straight answer about why food keeps getting more expensive. We often hear the government members say it is a global problem, but if that were true, every country would be feeling it equally, and they are not. Canada now has the highest food inflation in the G7.\n\n When we look at where Canadians ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723660","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Animal nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723660","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723660","label":"Animal nutrition","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f100990560460920558774e1997a167e024fc649d7ebe7c55b4344195d31161"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["018fe1a58a63bb550677553bc5096036d594a8b5253a5e6b92fb77aa1ebdf785"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-825ac9bf3b725a9b5135cc0c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386407,"date":"2026-03-24T19:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I spoke with a man in my riding who works at a local cabinet manufacturing shop. He works hard and pays his taxes, but his hours were cut because students with expired visas take his shifts for cash under the table. This is the direct result of a system the previous Liberal immigration minister let spiral out of control, where international students came without proper oversight and thousands overstayed their visits.\n\nWill the Liberal Prime Minister admit that this mess started under his previous minister? Canadians, like my constituent, are now paying the price.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386407","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I spoke with a man in my riding who works at a local cabinet manufacturing shop. He works hard and pays his taxes, but his hours were cut because students with expired visas take his shifts for cash under the table. This is the direct result of a system the previous Liberal immigration minister let spiral out of control, where international students came without proper oversight and t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9ade1ec25cfbd79aa3a5302c0c3a7b3346b6c5dff0620b69f6406155c89be8cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7357b55ac01f94d643d8dbec085f2e8857fd370fb6f2b4b0e29b0bcbf4947f5d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b7635a8a45f1c4339efe00f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386408,"date":"2026-03-24T19:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what we are seeing today did not come from one mistake. It came from years of mismanagement by multiple Liberal immigration ministers. One opened the floodgates without oversight. Another failed to enforce the rules, and now the current minister is continuing with more permits, with millions of visas sitting expired or unchecked. Even Liberal MPs have said this minister is not up to the job. \n\nThrough you, Mr. Speaker, I would ask the Prime Minister this. Why are three of the most ineffective immigration ministers in Canadian history still sitting around the cabinet table while Canadians face the consequences of their failures?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386408","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what we are seeing today did not come from one mistake. It came from years of mismanagement by multiple Liberal immigration ministers. One opened the floodgates without oversight. Another failed to enforce the rules, and now the current minister is continuing with more permits, with millions of visas sitting expired or unchecked. Even Liberal MPs have said this minister is not up to t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","label":"Corruption","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b1f5180d918ec97f84b8d574813521cfb27e04e62231461eae74f29a921168c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["babca87bc984edaba1df28b449951eec1ef58f4215055da3567e9bed38032dd4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d566304c2994be0b28106c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386405,"date":"2026-03-25T21:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition regarding Bill C-9. The Canadians who have signed this petition want to remind the government that it has no authority over sacred texts or teachings of any faith community. That boundary is not negotiable. Bill C-9 would overstep the boundary, stripping away long-standing protections that have allowed Canadians to speak and live their faith in good faith.\n\nThis is what the petitioners have said. Canadians are concerned that Liberal-Bloc amendments to Bill C-9 could be used to criminalize passages from the Bible, the Quran, the Torah and other texts. The state has no place in the religious texts or teachings of any faith community. Freedom of expression and freedom of religion are fundamental rights that must be preserved. Therefore, the petitioners call on the Liberal Government of Canada to protect religious freedom, to uphold the right to read and share sacred texts, and to prevent government overreach into matters of faith.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386405","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition regarding Bill C-9. The Canadians who have signed this petition want to remind the government that it has no authority over sacred texts or teachings of any faith community. That boundary is not negotiable. Bill C-9 would overstep the boundary, stripping away long-standing protections that have allowed Canadians to speak and live their faith in good faith.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b885960b9f1b8472949a99095508263da7f79e9aba3d8890ade3f8b28f1d558c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4613a54b67083731eb93a195","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386406,"date":"2026-03-25T22:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is a deep irony in the heart of the bill. The government claims it is about protecting Canadians from harm, yet the first thing the Liberals did was remove the good-faith protection that ensured Canadians could express their religious beliefs without fear.\n\nI would ask my colleague why he thinks the government is so determined to remove good faith from the law and from this debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386406","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is a deep irony in the heart of the bill. The government claims it is about protecting Canadians from harm, yet the first thing the Liberals did was remove the good-faith protection that ensured Canadians could express their religious beliefs without fear.\n\nI would ask my colleague why he thinks the government is so determined to remove good faith from the law and from this deba","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89c54cfe38d2ce2105ac4f89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386403,"date":"2026-03-26T19:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have been hearing something troubling from people in my community. They tell me that the international students whose visas have expired are being told by immigration consultants, \"Just claim asylum. You'll be able to stay.\"\n\nNow people are gaming a system that was meant for people fleeing real danger, and this is clogging the line for genuine refugees who actually need protection. The Prime Minister says that claims are down, but since 2015, the backlog has exploded from 10,000 to 300,000 asylum claims.\n\nWill the Liberals finally admit this is happening and fix it before the entire immigration system loses its integrity?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386403","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have been hearing something troubling from people in my community. They tell me that the international students whose visas have expired are being told by immigration consultants, \"Just claim asylum. You'll be able to stay.\"\n\nNow people are gaming a system that was meant for people fleeing real danger, and this is clogging the line for genuine refugees who actually need protection. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["996328cd296cc3ca1f40a7c5bbcc86be6ec1c80f0cc94fd7e29ee04885a36292"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fbe49d9428c98db8311da22aaf9c46cb7a209e5f5e5bce633b64d2adfc912289"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e240de9cf96f9d828f38abbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386404,"date":"2026-03-26T19:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is not just the abuse of our refugee system that has people in my riding shaking their head. They are hearing about situations like this: a young woman going about her life, when a stranger violated her by groping her not once but twice. He was charged, he was convicted and then he was given a discharge by the judge, and no criminal record, because without a record he can stay in the country and fight deportation.\n\nAfter years of decisions like this, will the Prime Minister fire the ministers responsible for creating this out-of-control immigration system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386404","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is not just the abuse of our refugee system that has people in my riding shaking their head. They are hearing about situations like this: a young woman going about her life, when a stranger violated her by groping her not once but twice. He was charged, he was convicted and then he was given a discharge by the judge, and no criminal record, because without a record he can stay in t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","label":"Sexual harassment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","label":"Sexual harassment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c47c52e78e61a6f53890759c4e22faebb258ce296c4b0692d3185b13f57a74c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["970da0b9faa6936265152f5f8e5b8dff0af62c4c8d974e37dad76a88c2b02c42"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa7729919c1dee13114ac1d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428815,"date":"2026-04-13T16:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a strange and troubling thing in a country as prosperous and progressive as ours that a woman at risk can do everything she has been told to do, to seek help, speak truth and place her trust in the law, and still find herself dead at the hands of her own partner wielding a bloody weapon, in what can only be considered a completely avoidable murder.\n\nBailey McCourt is one such story. She was not a statistic. She was a young mother with two young children, right in my community of Cloverdale. To those who loved her, she was not a headline. She was the centre of a home, a woman trying to build a safe life for her family. Like so many others, she found herself in a relationship that became dangerous over time. There were threats. There was violence. At one point, there was strangulation, which is one of the clearest indicators that the risk had escalated to a level that should never be ignored. \n\nOn the morning of July 4, Bailey's former partner stood before a court and was convicted of assaulting her. The system had, in that moment, all the pieces in front of it. It had the history, it had the violence, and it had the pattern that had been building over time, yet despite all of that, he was released. There was no requirement to step back and ask whether this was something more than a single offence. There was no mechanism that treated violence against an intimate partner as fundamentally different from any other assault. There was no tool that required the court to fully assess whether Bailey was still in danger even after a conviction had just been entered. This is because under the law as it stands, we do not distinguish in any meaningful way between a violent act against a stranger and a violent act against someone in an intimate relationship, a relationship built on trust, proximity and, in many cases, vulnerability. When we fail to make that distinction, we fail to recognize the very real and documented risk that comes with intimate partner violence, particularly when it escalates.\n\nJust hours later, Bailey was in a parking lot going about what should have been an ordinary part of her day. It was there, in that ordinary place, in broad daylight, that her attacker found her and murdered her. She knew this could happen. She had begged to be protected, but the law, as it is written, ensured that the warning signs were ignored, and the inevitable happened. \n\nWhen we look back at that day, the question is not simply how this happened, but why there was no legal mechanism strong enough to interrupt it. Why, after a conviction, was there no ability for the court to say that it needed to take a closer look at this individual, needed a proper risk assessment and needed to determine whether releasing this person put a woman's life at risk? \n\nBailey's case is not just a tragedy. It is a clear example of a gap in our law, a gap between what we know about intimate partner violence and how our system is currently structured to respond to it. \n\nWhen we step back from Bailey's story, difficult as it is, we are forced to ask ourselves a larger question. Was this truly an isolated failure, or is it part of something that we have been seeing for far too long and are just not willing to make the necessary changes to to protect women at risk? \n\nDr. Wendy Aujla, assistant professor of criminal justice at Athabasca University, has spent years listening to women, many of them particularly vulnerable as new immigrants, who have walked this very path, not in theory but in lived experiences, in stories that, when placed side by side, begin to look far less like exceptions and far more like a pattern we can no longer ignore. What she hears time and again are stories not of women who failed to act but of women who did exactly what Bailey did. They reported, they sought help, and they tried to leave, but just like with Bailey, risk was not considered in the context of what had already happened and what was increasingly likely to happen next. \n\nFor many women in the South Asian community, the path to even reaching that point is far more complex than the system is designed to recognize. Their particular cases are often complicated by family honour, language barriers and coercive control inside the home. A system like ours that is seemingly built to protect the perpetrator of intimate violence is very dangerous, especially for women of vulnerable minorities. \n\nWhen we consider what happened to Bailey, we cannot look at it in isolation. It fits into a pattern that has already been identified and already been studied. The knowledge is there. Our laws are ignoring that knowledge. While research like Dr. Aujla's helps us understand the pattern, it is often outside the government and in community spaces where we see just how real and immediate this issue is for women living through it.\n\nLast year, I attended a fundraiser on behalf of The Kaur Movement, founded by Gurpreet Kaur and supported by leaders like Manjot Kaur. The Kaur Movement is a survivor-led network that supports women facing abuse by connecting them to real-time help, such as shelters, legal aid and counselling, while also working to break the culture of silence around domestic violence, especially in the South Asian community.\n\nI went to the fundraiser expecting to hear about advocacy, awareness and the kinds of work many organizations are doing in this space to support women. What I heard that evening has stayed with me because it was not abstract or theoretical. It was story after story of women who have lived through violence, who have tried to seek help and who, in many cases, have found themselves navigating systems that were slow or difficult to access at the very moment they needed them the most. What struck me was not just the severity of what women endure but the common thread running through their experiences, which was the sense that they were often left to carry the burden of their safety on their own shoulders while feeling helpless and afraid because their lives were not as valued as those of the men who perpetrated the violence.\n\nThe Kaur Movement has built something remarkable in response to this reality. It has created a network that responds in real time, connecting women to shelters, legal help and counselling, often at the very instant that they are reaching out. What The Kaur Movement is seeing day after day reinforces what we know: These are not isolated stories but part of a pattern that continues to unfold in communities across the country. Tragedies are playing out time and again due to a lack of laws that protect these vulnerable women in their moment of need. \n\nWe can place these stories side by side: Bailey's life and loss; the careful work of women like Dr. Aujla who study these patterns; and community voices like The Kaur Movement, rising from what they see in reality every day. When we do, it becomes impossible to pretend that we do not understand what is happening.\n\nThis bill asks us to finally align our legal response with what we already know to be true. It asks us to recognize in law that violence within an intimate relationship is not the same as violence between strangers, carrying with it a level of risk and proximity that makes it more dangerous, not less. This bill would begin to correct that by naming the reality for what it is. It would create a distinct offence that acknowledges the nature of intimate partner violence.\n\nThe bill would go further still. It would recognize that when the ultimate act of violence is committed within a pattern of coercive or controlling conduct, when a life is taken by someone who has used that pattern of control and fear as a weapon, it must be treated with the full weight of the law. To name that act as first-degree murder would be not merely a question of punishment but a statement of clarity and a refusal to look away from what intimate partner homicide truly represents. The law has long recognized that killing in the context of other serious circumstances warrants elevation to first-degree murder. This bill would extend that same principle to the killing of an intimate partner where coercive or controlling conduct is present. That context is not incidental to the crime; it is the crime.\n\nThis bill would ensure that when a person has already been convicted of an intimate partner offence within the past five years, or is already at large on a release order related to a prior intimate partner offence, a peace officer could not simply release them at the scene. The decision would have to go before a judge. It would be a safeguard built for moments like Bailey's, where the history is already there, the pattern is already documented and the ordinary process of release is simply not enough to meet the gravity of what is in front of the court.\n\nBailey McCourt should still be here. That is the simplest, most honest thing that can be said. Her children should still have their mother. Her family should not be carrying this weight, nor should they be the ones who must now stand before us and ask that we do what should have been done already. We cannot give Bailey back to her children, but we can decide here and now that her story will not end in silence and that from it will come a measure of protection for those who are still, even today, waiting for the system to recognize the danger they are living with.\n\nLet us pass this bill. Let us act with the seriousness this moment demands and ensure that when the warning signs are there, as they so often are, we do not look back once again and say that we knew and did not act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428815","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a strange and troubling thing in a country as prosperous and progressive as ours that a woman at risk can do everything she has been told to do, to seek help, speak truth and place her trust in the law, and still find herself dead at the hands of her own partner wielding a bloody weapon, in what can only be considered a completely avoidable murder.\n\nBailey McCourt is one such st","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fb9f0c0dc9b20ec02cdbd77436227dbcf43f2d2b15aef92c0b40ae0b03737c7b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["765508715ce98ddfcf177145ee964a226767109b6e7bb6aa6bad952867b401cd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5dbe0f85c5ddab1f0dab19f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428816,"date":"2026-04-13T19:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, affordability has gotten so bad that farmers in my riding are taking to social media begging the Liberal government for gas tax relief. This is planting season, which is one of the most fuel-intensive times of the year. Tyler Heppell, a very popular Cloverdale farmer, said it plainly: When fuel costs go up, food prices go up. It is that simple. Families are already struggling at the grocery store, yet the government keeps collecting billions in extra as prices rise. The Prime Minister says that he is looking at options. Farmers do not need looking; they need action. \n\nWill the Liberals remove federal taxes on gas and diesel before these costs hit every dinner table in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428816","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, affordability has gotten so bad that farmers in my riding are taking to social media begging the Liberal government for gas tax relief. This is planting season, which is one of the most fuel-intensive times of the year. Tyler Heppell, a very popular Cloverdale farmer, said it plainly: When fuel costs go up, food prices go up. It is that simple. Families are already struggling at the g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e48ea20f1fef9f72ba7403f7d7b292017ea9a146bbc6cfc6502c9ce2e7c1adab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["74f43c8b70a04560cbfa0abad6a880edc5031deb912a49e8899e5a8ec4314af8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90ee86d9ed1f73fbb95396e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428817,"date":"2026-04-13T19:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what makes this worse is that the government makes more money the higher gas prices go. Every time the price at the pump rises, the GST rises with it. More pain for Canadians means more revenue for Ottawa. This is not just about high prices. The government is profiting from them. Families are cutting back. Farmers are warning food prices will climb again, and the Liberals are quietly taking in billions more. If they can collect billions extra from higher prices, why not give it back by taking taxes off gas and diesel? \n\nWill the Prime Minister finally give Canadians relief at the pump?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428817","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what makes this worse is that the government makes more money the higher gas prices go. Every time the price at the pump rises, the GST rises with it. More pain for Canadians means more revenue for Ottawa. This is not just about high prices. The government is profiting from them. Families are cutting back. Farmers are warning food prices will climb again, and the Liberals are quietly ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b69d1feb313dc44603c42bb1f93267b1e6e44f8b08048fa34deb99535ed1718d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7ea8b82788cb5747d4f4124f495cebd8ab05875027afde09455e2439f10cc9dd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-295101f9d8b77d13cf28b1df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428818,"date":"2026-04-13T23:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there was a time in this country when the path to owning a home felt clear. If one worked hard, showed up every day, did their job, raised their kids and tried to put a little aside they could build a life. They could buy a home, they could plant roots in a community and they could look at their children and believe with confidence that their children's future would be just a little bit better than their own. That was not a dream reserved for the wealthy. It was not something out of reach. It was just Canada. However, under the current Liberal government, that simple promise has rapidly slipped away.\n\nHere is the thing. Canadians today are not even asking for luxury. They are not asking for mansions or vacation homes. They are not even asking for the so-called American dream. They are asking for something far more basic than that: a home they can afford, a good job they can rely on and a safe neighbourhood where they can raise their family. That is it and yet, even something so simple and so reasonable is slipping further and further out of reach.\n\n I think about two of my own daughters who moved out of B.C. just to afford a home. They want to come back, but prices are worse now and new home sales in Vancouver are down 56%. We see the huge problem in those numbers. However, more important, we hear, in the community and in people's conversations, young families wondering if they will ever own a home, parents watching their kids move farther and farther away just to afford a place and grandparents like me worried that the next generation will not get the same chances we had.\n\n When we look at the facts, it becomes painfully clear why. Today, it takes over half, 52.4%, of a family's pre-tax income just to afford a home in this country. In Vancouver, that number is nearly 90%. In Toronto, it is over 60%. At the same time, Canadians are carrying a record $2.6 trillion in household debt, mostly just to keep a roof over their heads.\n\n Let us think about that for a moment. How do people build a life when nearly everything they earn goes to keeping a roof over their head? One would think that with these challenges, we would see real action, real results and a plan that matches the scale of the problem. Instead, what Canadians have been given is announcements, big ones, bold ones. We were told there would be 500,000 homes built every year. That sounds so impressive. It makes for a great headline, but even the government's own housing agency officials now say they will deliver just a fraction of that. In fact, they are warning that housing starts could drop by over 18%. Right in B.C., new home sales in Vancouver are down 56%. Across the country, CMHC officials are projecting housing starts to fall well below the 10-year average. Therefore, while the announcements get bigger, the results get smaller.\n\n Canadians feel that disconnect from what the Liberals promise us and what they actually do because the truth is, they cannot live on a promise, they cannot raise their children on a headline and they cannot build equity in a press release. At some point, the words have to become something real. They have to become walls and doors, foundations and keys and homes that people can actually afford. Instead, what we have seen year after year is a growing list of programs, each one announced with great fanfare, each one carrying a hopeful name, each one presented as a solution, yet the homes do not get built. When people look past the announcements, they find more red tape and bureaucracy, more layers and more delays.\n\nThe Conservatives have a plan to cut the GST on all the new homes under $1.3 million, tie the federal infrastructure dollars to homebuilding and cut development charges, not just for vote-rich Ontario but for all the provinces. Canadians are beginning to recognize what the Liberals' announcements are all about. It is no plan to build homes, but a pattern of smoke and mirrors. Is the government even trying to actually get something built?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428818","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there was a time in this country when the path to owning a home felt clear. If one worked hard, showed up every day, did their job, raised their kids and tried to put a little aside they could build a life. They could buy a home, they could plant roots in a community and they could look at their children and believe with confidence that their children's future would be just a little b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ebdaf7bc6eff86a56523156ab45d2264fd03f610b448110a4eafe76501fd1ccf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ed29f513678389c63d627ce24604c87b0269f2ff74d43ceb206e6f627d96be1f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a661ef5b5042653f8a1de46c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428921,"date":"2026-04-13T23:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if these programs were working, if they were truly delivering, we would not be here tonight. We would not see families spending over half their income just to afford a place to live. We would not see housing starts projected to fall. We certainly would not see something even more troubling, which is that a growing number of the very people who invest in this country, who create jobs, take risks and build businesses, are leaving.\n\n We are now facing a serious brain drain, with a troubling 40% of top earners looking elsewhere for opportunity, for a place where the cost of living is lower and the path forward feels more certain. When that happens, it does not just affect those individuals. It affects the families counting on those jobs and the communities depending on that investment. It affects all of us, because when investment leaves, when builders leave, when opportunity leaves, we all feel it. However, the Prime Minister goes around saying Canadians have never had it so good. How does he sleep at night?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428921","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if these programs were working, if they were truly delivering, we would not be here tonight. We would not see families spending over half their income just to afford a place to live. We would not see housing starts projected to fall. We certainly would not see something even more troubling, which is that a growing number of the very people who invest in this country, who create jobs, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48a28ee48e71958a5439a0068eb1c4594e6752f213116be347b8da20a644c044"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["785ee58ffbb07bf61a87ea08723298f9f03b58609018cc56e1bf2630eeab2c72"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-955bdd45a7698a9d388ee6c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115358,"date":"2026-04-14T01:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"ETHI","text":"His hand was up before the amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115358","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"His hand was up before the amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68445b47025d51b490347a63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115359,"date":"2026-04-14T01:50:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"ETHI","text":"Point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115359","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d4ec7161861125475981a8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115360,"date":"2026-04-14T01:50:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"ETHI","text":"It seems that Ms. Church has now talked about travel to the moon, travel to England and now travel to France, but is not talking about the motion. I wonder if we can get back to the amendment so we can stop travelling everywhere else. Let's stick to the amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115360","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It seems that Ms. Church has now talked about travel to the moon, travel to England and now travel to France, but is not talking about the motion. I wonder if we can get back to the amendment so we can stop travelling everywhere else. Let's stick to the amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9971f5aa25ea52ada4d7d9d2ec66c0050057615a5e9be98a1e0e43be65ca85ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06a34403a66b7aab7aaefa72","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428814,"date":"2026-04-14T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I held a town hall with business leaders in my riding, and I expected to hear about tariffs and red tape. Instead, the number one concern by far was this: Do we still even own our own homes? \n\nDecisions such as the Cowichan ruling and the Liberals' secret Musqueam agreement are shaking confidence in property rights. Investment is freezing, builders are backing off and uncertainty is growing. People are starting to wonder if we are drifting toward that \"you will own nothing and be happy\" mantra. \n\nIs that where the Prime Minister is taking us, or will he instruct his lawyers to defend the property rights of Canadian homeowners, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428814","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I held a town hall with business leaders in my riding, and I expected to hear about tariffs and red tape. Instead, the number one concern by far was this: Do we still even own our own homes? \n\nDecisions such as the Cowichan ruling and the Liberals' secret Musqueam agreement are shaking confidence in property rights. Investment is freezing, builders are backing off and uncertainty is g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f08437e93c7c59baa67645c55ffa6b989ec772967e98bc051375cdcfe65a3d29"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3cfb336eb5312fc33fa1d0f24c87c8a7869f1e18f28f97db3d756d12367a04be"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad2f0990e9cefa8192f6fdec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115361,"date":"2026-04-14T21:00:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. Mr. Leswick, it's very refreshing to hear you talk about two sides to a coin. That's wonderful. I want to start by taking us back for a moment. When I sat on the finance committee, we studied the fallout from the Panama papers, one of the largest financial leaks in history. What did we hear at that time? We heard that billions of dollars were being routed through shell companies hidden in offshore jurisdictions, shielded from transparency and, in many cases, beyond the reach of enforcement. We heard plain as day that Canada really had a problem and not a small one: a structural one. The agency at the centre of that fight is FINTRAC. This is the body responsible for tracking suspicious financial transactions, identifying money laundering and passing intelligence on to law enforcement. It's literally the follow-the-money agency. Here's my problem. At the very moment when financial crime is becoming more sophisticated, when we're dealing with fentanyl trafficking, organized crime, sanctions evasions and international capital flows, we're now talking about cuts to FINTRAC. I want to connect it to something a little more recent. We've seen repeated concerns about Canadian money—pension money, investment capital—flowing through offshore jurisdictions like Bermuda or the Cayman Islands, and we know that Brookfield, which our Prime Minister is linked to, has investment structures involving offshore jurisdictions. To be clear, offshore structures are not automatically illegal, but that's exactly the point. That's what we learned from the Panama papers. The issue isn't always illegality. It's lack of transparency. It's the ability to move money through complex structures where ownership is obscured, tax obligations are minimized and accountability becomes optional, and that's precisely the space that FINTRAC is supposed to monitor. Let me ask the obvious question: How can we possibly claim to be serious about financial transparency when we're making cuts to the very agency tasked with detecting suspicious financial flows? When it comes to actual enforcement capacity, we're pulling back. It seems to me that it's like installing a state-of-the-art alarm system and firing the security guard. Here's my question for the officials. If FINTRAC is expected to do more, to track more transactions, enforce higher penalties and monitor increasingly complex financial flows, how can it do it with fewer resources?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115361","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Leswick, it's very refreshing to hear you talk about two sides to a coin. That's wonderful. I want to start by taking us back for a moment. When I sat on the finance committee, we studied the fallout from the Panama papers, one of the largest financial leaks in history. What did we hear at that time? We heard that billions of dollars were being routed through shell companies hidden ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","label":"Security intelligence","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7ec8cf2b276a3e8560cedf90766fb100bf61046bd27886f57cc91b38fbe9ca1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3699b81fcef18599bf6a789ea3357c230225b3a8cd6d260a6187a2cad74b07ee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8c88bb7d8af1652d2ec767a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115362,"date":"2026-04-14T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I know at the time when we were doing the study on FINTRAC, they were very clear that they were already under-resourced. Therefore, to me it makes absolutely no sense that they're going to have even fewer resources. I'm concerned about what message it sends to those who are trying to hide their money, to move money or to launder money through our system. FINTRAC was saying they were under-resourced already—you can look it up in committee evidence—and now we're taking even more funds away from them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115362","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I know at the time when we were doing the study on FINTRAC, they were very clear that they were already under-resourced. Therefore, to me it makes absolutely no sense that they're going to have even fewer resources. I'm concerned about what message it sends to those who are trying to hide their money, to move money or to launder money through our system. FINTRAC was saying they were under-resource","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9027df4b26854566f385a614a1bd6ae65cc57fb6acece5ba1e5c978fcc4b1ec8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca10b833ac1506f93265fbb6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115363,"date":"2026-04-14T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I come from a place close to Vancouver. I'm about an hour outside it. If there's one thing we've learned, it's that there's money laundering through housing, opioids and casinos. Honestly, from where I come from, it blows my mind the damage that has been done in that area. Now we're going to have less oversight because we're going to have less money going to FINTRAC, which was, like I say—and I think that was five years ago—already under-resourced. It doesn't make sense to me. We can see the fabric of our Canadian society being hurt by this, and FINTRAC is getting less money.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115363","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I come from a place close to Vancouver. I'm about an hour outside it. If there's one thing we've learned, it's that there's money laundering through housing, opioids and casinos. Honestly, from where I come from, it blows my mind the damage that has been done in that area. Now we're going to have less oversight because we're going to have less money going to FINTRAC, which was, like I say—and I th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79ef6e45dfca737bd65ce4c8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115364,"date":"2026-04-14T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Except there's less money. To me that makes no sense. Five years ago, they were already under-resourced. That's the last of my statements. There's less money and there's more trouble. I don't see this working.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115364","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Except there's less money. To me that makes no sense. Five years ago, they were already under-resourced. That's the last of my statements. There's less money and there's more trouble. I don't see this working.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6846ff7b82d9c1f17168c8c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115365,"date":"2026-04-14T22:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. I'm going to direct my questions to Mr. MacKinnon. Last summer, I had the opportunity to visit the Matsqui penitentiary with my colleague Mr. Caputo. It became very clear that there was a problem there. They've already had multiple incidents of contraband being literally thrown over the fence. It wasn't smuggled in some sophisticated way. They just tossed it over like it was a backyard. We're talking about packages landing inside the perimeter containing drugs, cellphones and even weapons. It got so bad that they had to build a second fence to try to stop it. You would have to throw it harder to get it into the yard. A second fence was their solution. From what the officers are saying, it's not exactly Fort Knox. People are still finding ways around it because fences don't stop the problem. People do. Dog units do. Patrols do. Experienced correctional officers do. What's the government's big idea with this cutting? Are they going to cut searches? Are they going to reduce patrols and the very things that catch this stuff before it spreads through the institution? Here's the part that should concern every Canadian: When this contraband gets inside, it doesn't just sit there. It fuels violence. It creates debt. It drives intimidation. The people standing in the middle of that storm are correctional officers. These men and women are already dealing with some of the highest PTSD rates in the country, and now we're making their job harder. If they already can't stop drugs and weapons from getting over the fence, what exactly is the plan when they start removing the people responsible for catching this stuff once it's in?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115365","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I'm going to direct my questions to Mr. MacKinnon. Last summer, I had the opportunity to visit the Matsqui penitentiary with my colleague Mr. Caputo. It became very clear that there was a problem there. They've already had multiple incidents of contraband being literally thrown over the fence. It wasn't smuggled in some sophisticated way. They just tossed it over like it was a backyard.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036291","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036291","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Military architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036291","label":"Military architecture","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8f93ba07139494ae9aed64ac45d8a3b134d2755d36d739ce3d59cde197a3535f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["018fa4cdaa2c112e415f9b9ec7ed7e0dbafafa10c4aba780f6e20d094dc9760f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05f37a6e4cdf3598edb7f894","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115366,"date":"2026-04-14T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"When we visited, employee morale was at a maximum low. We heard that when they finally have downtime, they go online to look for another job. Admin is putting policies in place that put their lives at risk. I remember that one of the places we went to allowed a mixed-range lunch so everybody could socialize. They said that this, immensely, put much more risk on the officers. I was honestly really shocked by the wilful blindness of admin putting lives at risk like this. I feel like this is just another one of those things. Can you please let me know if this is the same thing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115366","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"When we visited, employee morale was at a maximum low. We heard that when they finally have downtime, they go online to look for another job. Admin is putting policies in place that put their lives at risk. I remember that one of the places we went to allowed a mixed-range lunch so everybody could socialize. They said that this, immensely, put much more risk on the officers. I was honestly really ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unpaid work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","label":"Unpaid work","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90ca0042f452b5ac8af8a0e6460e6720aefdfbd199cfdeba09ad245b1c36ca66"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c567fa71eccb7acd0c616031","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115367,"date":"2026-04-14T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Yes, they were very clear. They said that it distracts them because they have too many people to watch. Someone can distract them over here while someone else attacks another over there. They wilfully continued that practice—I don't know where it's at now. I was shocked to see admin ignoring it and shocked to see the low morale of the staff. Having less staff, I would imagine, makes it even worse.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115367","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, they were very clear. They said that it distracts them because they have too many people to watch. Someone can distract them over here while someone else attacks another over there. They wilfully continued that practice—I don't know where it's at now. I was shocked to see admin ignoring it and shocked to see the low morale of the staff. Having less staff, I would imagine, makes it even worse.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7aaf87820b053a02c7f44c4fca048e55cb4e1ff4cd0af21341ffe0c5d0fcaddb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a65a1667a32f6088a8ff4f55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115368,"date":"2026-04-14T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"That is absolutely what we heard. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115368","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That is absolutely what we heard. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-500f8250330e940629fcc9d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115369,"date":"2026-04-16T16:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I want to start with something that happened during my 2024 by-election because I think it illustrates the issue at hand very well. The Liberal candidate who ran against me publicly identified as Métis during the campaign. It wasn't a passing comment. It was part of how she presented herself to voters. In B.C. and across Canada, Métis identity is not something informal. There are recognized registries and organizations that require documentation, genealogy, community connection and verification. It's a process, and it's intentionally rigorous because it protects the integrity of the identity of people who have carried it through the generations. During that campaign, the local Waceya Métis Society came forward and asked a very straightforward question. They asked her to provide documentation to substantiate that claim. She wasn't able to produce any of the documentation to satisfy their request. What I saw was something more important than a headline at that time. It was a serious breach of integrity without any consequences. The issue basically just went away, and it was clear that the Liberal Party hadn't properly vetted their candidate and didn't require any documentation of her Métis background, nothing. To tell you the truth, I'm not surprised to see these serious breaches in this program that you've documented in your report. If your report shows that these basic verification steps aren't being taken, what is actually in place to prevent the kind of abuse that Canadians have already seen in other contexts from happening here? What are the consequences for cheaters? Do we even care as long as we hit our 5% target? Can you explain the lack of integrity in this 33%?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115369","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to start with something that happened during my 2024 by-election because I think it illustrates the issue at hand very well. The Liberal candidate who ran against me publicly identified as Métis during the campaign. It wasn't a passing comment. It was part of how she presented herself to voters. In B.C. and across Canada, Métis identity is not something informal. There are recognized regist","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22d2d1f31047067bcc8b2115426979bb7d6ee399ebd5b1a68e355abe80a62954"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["89250a5b704648e2b2a2afe951c1828cb121d6ce901498deaefc33c78b1d309c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ce812176891fda08bd0d2db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115370,"date":"2026-04-16T16:30:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I have a very quick question, as I think I'm running out of time. What about consequences? You don't mention anything in here about consequences. I don't see how we fix it if people aren't actually given consequences.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115370","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a very quick question, as I think I'm running out of time. What about consequences? You don't mention anything in here about consequences. I don't see how we fix it if people aren't actually given consequences.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3db3cc2fc44d86c9ea9f604","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115371,"date":"2026-04-16T16:30:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How about consequences for the people who are allowing this to happen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115371","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How about consequences for the people who are allowing this to happen?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","label":"Hazardous materials transport","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bbd335e0d5212b5bb2506b1daba3d103341f93c6c3f41c188c2631d491c63bb4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c26f8f66e415b18dac5e7f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115372,"date":"2026-04-16T17:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I want to take this one step further, because we saw a version of this same issue play out on a national level in the case of Liberal MP Randy Boissonnault. He publicly spoke about indigenous heritage over a period of time, and that identity became part of his public profile. It carried influence. It shaped how he was perceived in discussions about representation and inclusion. When questions later arose about how that identity had been acquired, there was no solid evidence of anything. Again, it became a matter of he-said-she-said, and no one was held accountable. That brings me to your report. Your findings show that, in federal procurement, we've built a system that seems to rely on self-identification but doesn't verify it. In many of the files you reviewed, there was no evidence that officials confirmed whether a business was even listed on the indigenous business directory before awarding a contract. Mandatory audits were skipped. Requirements that exist on paper were not enforced in practice. When I put these two things together—the real-world consequences of unverified identity claims and a procurement system that, by your own findings, often doesn't verify eligibility before awarding contracts—they raise a very serious concern. If we're not doing those basic checks, then we're not just leaving a gap in the system; we're creating a system where corruption is embedded. We are creating a situation where it becomes possible for people to access opportunities that were not intended for them. In so doing, we're not only risking misuse of taxpayer dollars, but also totally undermining the credibility of a program that was meant to support indigenous businesses. We are cheating those who are participating honestly. Your report found that not a single contract enforced the 33% indigenous content rule, and once the work started, no one checked who was doing it. I've seen first-hand how quickly things fall apart when identity is simply claimed and not verified, whether it's in my local by-election or in national controversies, such as that of Mr. Boissonnault. Are the real problems that the government doesn't take verification seriously and that it prefers the optics of reconciliation over making sure it's honest and above board? When should you come back to update us on your report?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115372","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to take this one step further, because we saw a version of this same issue play out on a national level in the case of Liberal MP Randy Boissonnault. He publicly spoke about indigenous heritage over a period of time, and that identity became part of his public profile. It carried influence. It shaped how he was perceived in discussions about representation and inclusion. When questions late","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c1ea037824bcbb43e1e9b7329e89ac84e42f164be0f4019fdf75cb4003063ec5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47bc6cb205a9e018de5a27fad496e1a10bb562ecd47e9e43e68631bffe62d43d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6384718b30f6be13778b077","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115373,"date":"2026-04-16T17:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"After all the announcements and all the promises, did this government build a system that talks about reconciliation but doesn't even do the basic checks to protect it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115373","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"After all the announcements and all the promises, did this government build a system that talks about reconciliation but doesn't even do the basic checks to protect it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","label":"Arms control","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["17bb2b648c49bfdbf6b975e7ae00d41a0b0b9eb12b771f64174ae5d671a5ea14"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e0b43a275b114e393c26713","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115374,"date":"2026-04-16T17:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Did this government not bring in your office to make changes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115374","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Did this government not bring in your office to make changes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["128225278fd3c726ae34ecfbd0b1bda4ab7b371cc8d0a29fe71c73ebc000d2f9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f8642b6c4fd22d861094f7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115375,"date":"2026-04-16T17:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Right, and still we've not been able to make any headway. I appreciate all you're doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115375","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Right, and still we've not been able to make any headway. I appreciate all you're doing.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5cf73376616757f962df86f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300866,"date":"2026-04-21T15:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I wonder if my colleague would talk about this idea of \"Don't worry about it. Students can still access loans. They just don't qualify for grants.\"\n\nCould he give me a bit of a thought on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300866","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I wonder if my colleague would talk about this idea of \"Don't worry about it. Students can still access loans. They just don't qualify for grants.\"\n\nCould he give me a bit of a thought on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2bb081e473c94a3616d0d424","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300867,"date":"2026-04-21T16:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today's concurrence motion is about more than just student grants. It is about whether this country still respects the kind of work that actually keeps the country running. \n\nBuried in budget 2025 is a decision that says if a young Canadian chooses a public institution, such as UBC, McGill or U of T, they can receive a federal student grant, but if they choose one of many provincially regulated career colleges where they train to become welders, electricians, health care aides, mechanics or practical nurses, they will be cut off. It is the same taxpayer, same ambition and same hard work, but different treatment. That reveals something bigger than a budget line. It reveals a bias that says some education is respectable and some is not, and somehow the path that leads to a tool belt is worth less than a path that leads to a desk. That thinking could not be more dangerous right now.\n\nCanada has lost 95,000 jobs this year. Youth have lost over 50,000 jobs. We have one of the highest unemployment rates in the G7, yet the government has chosen to make skills training harder to afford. Think of how upside down that is. We say we need more homes, but we make it harder to train the people who build them. We say we need more workers in health care, but we make it harder for students to train for practical care professions. We talk about growth, but we put roadblocks in front of the very people who know how to make, fix, build, repair and create. \n\nBehind it all is a deeper cultural problem. We have spent too many years pretending that the only education that matters comes wrapped in prestige, as though a polished degree is inherently more valuable than a practical skill, or as though an Oxford education is the gold standard and everything else is a consolation prize. Well, with respect, the Prime Minister would be very wrong about that, because we cannot build a country with consultants alone. Somebody has to wire the house. Somebody has to pour the concrete. Somebody has to repair the truck. Somebody has to keep the systems working. \n\nSkilled work is not second-class work. It is part of the foundation of civilized life. If we start treating the people who do that work as somehow less worthy of support, we are not just making a mistake in policy, but we are teaching a whole generation to undervalue the very work we desperately need to rebuild this country. \n\nOne of the strangest contradictions in Canada right now is that we have an entire country talking about housing shortages, an infrastructure deficit, labour shortages in the trades and a generation of young people looking for a foothold in the economy. Somehow, the government can still manage to make it harder for those same young people to train for the very jobs we claim we desperately need them to fill. There is something almost comical about that, if it were not so serious. \n\nWe complain that homes are too expensive, but seem oddly reluctant to talk about the carpenters, electricians, pipefitters and heavy equipment operators without whom no home has ever been built. We talk about building the country as though a policy announcement will get it done, when, in fact, countries are built the way they have always been built, which is by skilled people who know how to turn raw material into something useful. \n\nHere is why this policy becomes so baffling. At the very moment when we need more skilled workers, more apprentices, more young Canadians learning practical, employable, in-demand skills, the government proposes to pull grants away from students attending career colleges that are doing exactly that training. It is like standing in front of a labour shortage, staring directly at it and deciding the sensible response is to make it harder for the next generation to learn these skills. Do we really want to sabotage the system? Canadians trying to hire skilled people right now need policies that will produce more skilled people, not fewer.\n\n There is another myth we have been telling for far too long, which is the notion that the surest path to prosperity is always the most expensive education, the longest credential and the most polished title on a business card. We have repeated that so often, it has taken on the status of common sense, even though the evidence is piling up against it. Out in the real world, there are countless skilled tradespeople making excellent incomes, raising families, buying homes, building businesses and doing it often with less debt, less delay and, frankly, more certainty than many young people who have been sold the promise that a degree alone is the ticket to security.\n\n There is something off about the way we have celebrated one kind of work while undervaluing another. Many of the people we are talking about, such as welders, electricians, millwrights, mechanics and heavy-duty technicians, are not merely getting by. Many are earning incomes that would surprise the very people who tend to look down on the trades. Why should that surprise anyone? Skill has value. Competence has value. Being able to do something difficult, useful and necessary has always had value. It always will.\n\n Somewhere along the way, we got something backward. We made kids borrow heavily to push them toward jobs that, by the time they have their degree, may or may not exist, while neglecting millions of jobs that exist, pay well and are sitting open because too few people have been encouraged to pursue the skills required to do them. That is not just a mismatch, but a cultural failure, and now this policy threatens to compound that mistake, because when the government says students pursuing vocational paths should no longer receive the same grant support as others, it is doing more than changing an eligibility rule. It is reinforcing the old prejudice that some forms of learning lead to real opportunity while others do not, yet anyone who has looked at the pay stub of a successful tradesperson or has tried to hire one lately knows how ridiculous that is.\n\nIn many parts of the country, a skilled trade is not merely a path to a good living. It may be one of the best paths available. At a time when young Canadians are struggling to see a future they can afford, it takes a special kind of blindness to put obstacles in front of one of the clearest paths to financial independence that we have.\n\n Perhaps the biggest thing we have gotten wrong is that people still talk about the trades as though they lead to only a job, when very often, they lead to something much bigger. This is because a skilled trade is not simply a paycheque. It can be the first rung on a ladder that leads to ownership, independence and entrepreneurship. A young person starts as an apprentice, learns a craft, gains experience, builds a reputation, takes on contracts, buys a truck and hires a helper and then a crew. Before long, what began as learning a skill has become a small business. If that sounds ordinary, it is only because people have been building this country that way for so long that we have forgotten how remarkable it really is.\n\nWe should not take it for granted, because there is something profoundly hopeful on that path. It is one of the few paths where a person can begin with almost nothing but a willingness to work and over time build something of their own. They do not inherit it, but build it. Many of the people doing what the culture calls dirty jobs are, in fact, examples of what self-reliance can produce. Many are entrepreneurs, many are employing others and many are creating opportunities, not just for themselves, but for the next young person looking for a start.\n\n This is not some footnote in the economy. This is the economy, yet in a strange twist, we celebrate the idea of small business while undermining the institutions helping people acquire the very skills that lead to starting one. This makes no sense, because the electrician who starts a company, the welder who opens a fabrication shop, the contractor who builds a crew and the mechanic who opens a service centre are the people taking risks, creating jobs, paying taxes, training others and strengthening communities.\n\nThis is how wealth is created in the real world, which is why this policy strikes me as so short-sighted. Discouraging students from attending career colleges does not just affect individual students, but the future businesses they might have built, the apprentices they might have trained, the workers they may have hired and the opportunities they might have created for others. It narrows not just a training pathway, but an ownership pathway. In a country worried about stagnant growth, weak productivity and too few young people believing they can get ahead, it seems to me that the last thing the government should do is make it harder for young people to enter one of the clearest roads to becoming their own boss.\n\nIf we want to make work cool again and if we want to rebuild respect for hard work, skill and enterprise in this country, we should start by passing this motion and stop punishing the very students preparing to do the work at hand.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300867","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today's concurrence motion is about more than just student grants. It is about whether this country still respects the kind of work that actually keeps the country running. \n\nBuried in budget 2025 is a decision that says if a young Canadian chooses a public institution, such as UBC, McGill or U of T, they can receive a federal student grant, but if they choose one of many provincially","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["190c163c4d26f262e21eceb82aae8e86e89aa08b14909ec7d590ecbe36e4da84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["92fe67d2162e6bb8d87ab20b7ce57a419bfbb3559d43b847d823530969a615ea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a2de53ce778c5aeab18d4b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300868,"date":"2026-04-21T16:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would talk about the fact that instead of giving support, the government has actually put a barrier between the two types of training. Budget 2025 changed the eligibility for the Canada student grant so that students at many regulated career colleges no longer qualified. It is not because their school is unaccredited or because their program is substandard, but simply because of the type of institution they are attending. A student training to become a practical nurse or an electrician at a provincially regulated college now receives less federal support than a student at a public taxpayer institution. They have the same ambitions, along with the same hard work, but they get different treatment.\n\nThe government has created two classes of Canadian students, and this motion asks it to fix that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300868","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would talk about the fact that instead of giving support, the government has actually put a barrier between the two types of training. Budget 2025 changed the eligibility for the Canada student grant so that students at many regulated career colleges no longer qualified. It is not because their school is unaccredited or because their program is substandard, but simply because of the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3f4bd9d583346a3e5a092e2a3bae676bf9363b3d6e715523da0a246dc96cc674"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["57f923e8b83100d80fdf8b0e65f1210d5898bcedc205f5cdc8ec92eab6985225"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e411bfacae64262e39f1b00c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300869,"date":"2026-04-21T17:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think that shows, very clearly, the bias against the lower-middle-class student. This policy hurts those students who can least afford it.\n\n Career colleges disproportionately serve lower-middle-income Canadians who need a faster, more direct path to employment. These are not students with a safety net. Many of them choose a career college specifically because it is the practical, affordable option that leads directly to a job.\n\n Removing grant access does not make that choice disappear. It just makes it harder to afford. It tells young Canadians from a working family that the path they chose to a good career is worth less government support than someone else's path. That is wrong, and this committee agrees.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300869","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think that shows, very clearly, the bias against the lower-middle-class student. This policy hurts those students who can least afford it.\n\n Career colleges disproportionately serve lower-middle-income Canadians who need a faster, more direct path to employment. These are not students with a safety net. Many of them choose a career college specifically because it is the practical, a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e646cd82acd8a48b96a32c488c2ccccd84de9d2244496db9d8be1df1a9415a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["20e9ec19e51240f537f54a92faae83e56d0b348ebae3b49a720d06a3e64ba59d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-622ec4aadbfa66df0eee2d21","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300870,"date":"2026-04-21T17:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we should not need an opposition motion day to defend students against Liberal cuts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300870","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we should not need an opposition motion day to defend students against Liberal cuts.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e50729ee6f449991219d68b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115376,"date":"2026-04-21T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. I think all of us in this room would agree that transparency in a democracy depends on effective access to information. That's why we have laws in this country to ensure access for Canadians. Some of the biggest scandals in this country were uncovered through access to information requests, or ATIPs, whereby ordinary citizens exercise their legal right to ask questions of the government and get answers. An ATIP is one of the most important ways by which a free people holds power to account. Now, when a government knows that its decisions can be examined, abuses are less likely to take root, mistakes are more likely to be corrected and the public is far more likely to get honest and competent government, yet here we are. Your own report shows that you are already struggling under a serious backlog, and now you propose to eliminate positions over the next few years while asking Canadians to believe that service will somehow improve. By what reasoning do you expect that Canadians would accept that fewer people and fewer resources will produce better compliance with the law?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115376","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I think all of us in this room would agree that transparency in a democracy depends on effective access to information. That's why we have laws in this country to ensure access for Canadians. Some of the biggest scandals in this country were uncovered through access to information requests, or ATIPs, whereby ordinary citizens exercise their legal right to ask questions of the government","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf3ce0eaac794072431ef22c4a4a6422d622639caa195decb47aae2abdba6526"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a74f0483069e919f42910e740db68f6ed1bc2e584f5a444b7238d021e0aeae5c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b92084f6a4156d1766665258","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115377,"date":"2026-04-21T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Have you hired outside contractors for help with your ATIPs to get ahead of your backlog?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115377","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Have you hired outside contractors for help with your ATIPs to get ahead of your backlog?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unpaid work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","label":"Unpaid work","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf1e3f4e4cafb2ada9d8b7d59467e07a4c2b4d0b5c9a5122346cea58a97902b4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e1a7dd4ea4a0dcca05b4b55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115378,"date":"2026-04-21T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm asking just about contractors. Have you hired—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115378","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm asking just about contractors. Have you hired—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba86459ba70893dbe01ac97b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115379,"date":"2026-04-21T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. You started off 2025 with nearly 12,000 unanswered. You mentioned now that you're at 6,000, but you're going to cut 87 staff from the office responsible for answering them. How isn't this setting yourself up for failure?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115379","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. You started off 2025 with nearly 12,000 unanswered. You mentioned now that you're at 6,000, but you're going to cut 87 staff from the office responsible for answering them. How isn't this setting yourself up for failure?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9e349515b168f6c91324647ac60005bde5da041de0dc1015995dc17f93d1d23"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b35571373b2bb334c90d89d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115380,"date":"2026-04-21T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You also have a legislated responsibility not to break the law and to make sure those things get answered in a timely fashion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115380","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You also have a legislated responsibility not to break the law and to make sure those things get answered in a timely fashion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54572444982b7ed77bfb5648f14c1c436a45ea5dbdc5d631048121ce5d07a442"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0018fb2b28edc23ab2cc6fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115381,"date":"2026-04-21T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What does the Information Commissioner think about your cost-cutting plan that could force you to break the law? Did she give her stamp of approval on this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115381","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What does the Information Commissioner think about your cost-cutting plan that could force you to break the law? Did she give her stamp of approval on this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ee932ba7bac3f79d7d97ac4ede2a5ae85f27702be79e636088ffca2ce04f4ea"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a61add02904b0b5297c70256","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115382,"date":"2026-04-21T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Has she given you any thoughts on whether your plan looks as though it will work?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115382","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Has she given you any thoughts on whether your plan looks as though it will work?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22d26a54dd9e3410ccd01b53a8eefcc1a08092c7dbc850c31965afef05ad015e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4138b47bc7e29985ae4af4de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115383,"date":"2026-04-21T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I want to go back to the proposals. It's true, basically, that you expect you're going to break the law because of these cuts, but you use the language in your report to say that it \"may impact\" compliance. I don't really understand. You're aware that this is going to be a problem. Canadians need to access information. I'm not sure we should be satisfied with, \"Well, there are lots of different responsibilities and things we have to do, so this may be one thing for which we just have to break the law.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115383","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to go back to the proposals. It's true, basically, that you expect you're going to break the law because of these cuts, but you use the language in your report to say that it \"may impact\" compliance. I don't really understand. You're aware that this is going to be a problem. Canadians need to access information. I'm not sure we should be satisfied with, \"Well, there are lots of different re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f0ef59f2752859b3cd78bc7c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115384,"date":"2026-04-21T22:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"ESDC, or Employment and Social Development Canada, delivers some of the most basic services Canadians rely on when life goes sideways—when someone loses a job and appeals an EI decision, when a disabled Canadian is waiting for CPP disability reconsideration, when a worker files a labour complaint, when a senior calls about their pension or when families are simply trying to get answers about benefits they depend on. Canadians pay a lot in taxes for these services. They have a right to expect them to work in a timely fashion, but your own numbers read like a failing report card. For example, on EI reconsiderations, the target is to get 80% of your cases done within 30 days. You manage it only 25% of the time. On CPP disability reconsiderations, the target is to get 80% of your cases resolved in 120 days. You manage this only 42% of the time. On labour complaints, the target is 60% in 180 days. You manage it only 28% of the time. By any standard, you're failing rather badly, yet, curiously enough, when you look at performance bonus pay, which one would expect to be based on achieving targets, your department shows that 739 executives received their performance bonus pay and 91 executives received extra bonus pay on top of that. How on earth do you think your plan to reduce your staff by almost 40% will not cause further failures—or are you not worried about a lack in service, since it seems you will all get your bonuses anyway, no matter how badly the department performs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115384","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"ESDC, or Employment and Social Development Canada, delivers some of the most basic services Canadians rely on when life goes sideways—when someone loses a job and appeals an EI decision, when a disabled Canadian is waiting for CPP disability reconsideration, when a worker files a labour complaint, when a senior calls about their pension or when families are simply trying to get answers about benef","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67374c85e13be344a2647286","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115385,"date":"2026-04-21T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I was talking to you with regard to the failure to meet targets when the bonus pay was still being paid out. You suggest it's not actually a bonus, although the website calls it a bonus. Why are you cutting employees in the department when perhaps cutting performance bonuses for executives might be more appropriate to enable you to achieve your targets?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115385","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I was talking to you with regard to the failure to meet targets when the bonus pay was still being paid out. You suggest it's not actually a bonus, although the website calls it a bonus. Why are you cutting employees in the department when perhaps cutting performance bonuses for executives might be more appropriate to enable you to achieve your targets?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d08fb7356ee91e422f843213429f86314189aa2a7cc756843d5528d2f3ee540d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96937e369df2f7a6026dbbe7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115386,"date":"2026-04-21T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Obviously, admin has to ensure that the targets are being met. They're not being met, yet executives are getting their bonuses. Before making cuts to staffing and operations, did you ever consider freezing or eliminating executive bonuses until service targets were consistently met?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115386","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Obviously, admin has to ensure that the targets are being met. They're not being met, yet executives are getting their bonuses. Before making cuts to staffing and operations, did you ever consider freezing or eliminating executive bonuses until service targets were consistently met?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c304b6ae07820852e4a2ef62526a3221217f70bfe210128c6eb204a3692e2282"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4ea55143977a5ba978b6236","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115387,"date":"2026-04-21T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm curious: Did any executive have their performance pay reduced because of missed targets, which—as we've already discussed—have been missed badly?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115387","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm curious: Did any executive have their performance pay reduced because of missed targets, which—as we've already discussed—have been missed badly?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unpaid work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","label":"Unpaid work","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8722a81b8e47c34c53c47a5e9b9ecd07209f6211143de4b29137ad22cf4cf25"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2116319c5b512239497b872b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115388,"date":"2026-04-21T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"It appeared to be possibly only four, according to the numbers we see.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115388","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It appeared to be possibly only four, according to the numbers we see.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aea10ff01d60e9f2ee125ac8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115389,"date":"2026-04-21T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Who's in charge of hitting those targets, then? If it's not them, who's in charge of getting those targets hit?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115389","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Who's in charge of hitting those targets, then? If it's not them, who's in charge of getting those targets hit?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69c9737a0e3341be54bdfe4b4963823ee2ebcda836a3ac4198ebac6d6865fe89"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c7354cfff4d81e743118b51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115390,"date":"2026-04-21T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Is no one held accountable when they don't hit them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115390","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is no one held accountable when they don't hit them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","label":"Euthanasia","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5922f25a78f1e02a7db11a2eac404bb72d91b7116783d1c061690a94a8ab6583"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-121a638de18f6559a013963e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300864,"date":"2026-04-22T19:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I took an Uber last Saturday to the Vaisakhi parade in Surrey, and I got to talking with the driver. He told me he had lost his job to AI and now he is driving long hours just to make ends meet. He said that after all the costs of keeping his car on the road, he is making next to nothing. He hardly sees his little boy, who is in kindergarten, yet the Prime Minister told Canadians that affordability is the best it has been in a decade.\n\nIs this really what the Prime Minister thinks \"better\" looks like?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300864","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I took an Uber last Saturday to the Vaisakhi parade in Surrey, and I got to talking with the driver. He told me he had lost his job to AI and now he is driving long hours just to make ends meet. He said that after all the costs of keeping his car on the road, he is making next to nothing. He hardly sees his little boy, who is in kindergarten, yet the Prime Minister told Canadians that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d0f1835c59d61bcf836aab09b15611a3ca40a791615539e8ad8c6f43abe8e85"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-afe7bcc52045e8cf9b575d00","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300865,"date":"2026-04-22T19:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the fellow I mentioned and his family definitely do not agree with the Prime Minister that affordability is the best it has been in over a decade. As a matter of fact, he admitted it has gotten so bad in Canada that he is wondering whether he should even stay. It is no wonder Canadians are talking about leaving. It now takes over half of median household income just to own a home in Canada, and food inflation is the highest in the G7.\n\nHow many more hard-working Canadians have to leave this country before the Prime Minister wakes up and admits his housing and affordability policies are failing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300865","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the fellow I mentioned and his family definitely do not agree with the Prime Minister that affordability is the best it has been in over a decade. As a matter of fact, he admitted it has gotten so bad in Canada that he is wondering whether he should even stay. It is no wonder Canadians are talking about leaving. It now takes over half of median household income just to own a home in C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["92562eb784f9339488c06f464283318fb46220ff8442ae0a121d9006f6c66ebc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d028e7b828953f1b935f8ff8e83de8bb8fe6b88a31c36b1563d9b0a94a68f731"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f9c5d31129263617dd50082","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115391,"date":"2026-04-23T16:00:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. Mr. Blanchette, British Columbia is facing a very serious organized crime problem. In Surrey alone, there have been 87 reported extortion cases this year, and it's only April. Behind those numbers are shootings, arsons and business owners being pressured out of the communities they built. These are coordinated transnational networks operating with increasing aggression. Minister Champagne has been touring the country, promoting the Liberals' follow-the-money strategy as the answer, even though you are told by the Liberals to make cuts to your ability to produce financial intelligence. How will making these cuts help you deliver on that follow-the-money strategy and stay ahead of these networks?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115391","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Blanchette, British Columbia is facing a very serious organized crime problem. In Surrey alone, there have been 87 reported extortion cases this year, and it's only April. Behind those numbers are shootings, arsons and business owners being pressured out of the communities they built. These are coordinated transnational networks operating with increasing aggression. Minister Champag","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034590","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034590","label":"Networks","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60f1868db8c645a42f6880b1114b0285b90dbe707c3e1e1cefd71e3a7249026c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0cc49f1fa36e5fb7bda0d8d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115392,"date":"2026-04-23T16:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What does \"They're covered by another method of finance\" mean? Is this a bit of a shell game?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115392","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What does \"They're covered by another method of finance\" mean? Is this a bit of a shell game?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","label":"Personal finance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b507ccc9578c54541e3f4df9ee6c67f2f3825076e92bc7bdc91d2663af6a9b1e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7092dbd28d08d4b56e8c1792","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115393,"date":"2026-04-23T16:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I understand, from your documents, that, basically, you're shrinking your operational footprint. The wording was about financial intelligence—that you're going to shrink financial intelligence. Now, the Cullen commission documented how these networks work. FINTRAC reports confirm it: underground banking, real estate, casinos, money service businesses and crypto. We know the channels. We know the money moves, and we know we have to stay ahead with our enforcement and that knowledge is useful only if FINTRAC gives it to police. Your disclosures are what give police an ability to open those investigations. If FINTRAC is cutting funding for the production and dissemination of financial intelligence, doesn't that mean fewer files, less information for the police and, actually, less safety for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115393","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I understand, from your documents, that, basically, you're shrinking your operational footprint. The wording was about financial intelligence—that you're going to shrink financial intelligence. Now, the Cullen commission documented how these networks work. FINTRAC reports confirm it: underground banking, real estate, casinos, money service businesses and crypto. We know the channels. We know the m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d191daabf207ef97b3a22016f5a8261c82431c98075f1d26d64453080ada5537"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab4b3f58644e4dd8a8bdc8f9c7f11faa5d86f75659844684b0fbeeeb6d87c29c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d82cbce2707176c49c5bf286","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115394,"date":"2026-04-23T16:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Your document actually says you're cutting funding for the production and dissemination of financial intelligence. That's what the document says.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115394","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Your document actually says you're cutting funding for the production and dissemination of financial intelligence. That's what the document says.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fc58bdd04172d7fd365f3779b3d08c6f8752b248a9769132cea5c8abb7a3188"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ce4732e9200f0ed51aa22e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115395,"date":"2026-04-23T16:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm just going to say it's the CER documents that went to the PBO. That's where it says you're cutting, exactly, the intelligence funding that's needed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115395","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm just going to say it's the CER documents that went to the PBO. That's where it says you're cutting, exactly, the intelligence funding that's needed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332411","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death certificates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332411","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Death certificates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","label":"Colleges","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332411","label":"Death certificates","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","label":"Security intelligence","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["193341f849a12f542bac433c72b6db0dc7a543f705377992b7927ec58f56e96b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ab35e321f8a284109c01091c45d095c839f4efc208a57ffe080ae51836f6be9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3978f4eff224abaa510fc068","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115396,"date":"2026-04-23T16:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm sorry. My time's really short. I have to say that, if your documents that went to the PBO were incorrect, I think that's something that needs to be figured out. Secondly, Minister Champagne 's going around the country, promoting this Liberal follow-the-money strategy. I saw that you're actually going to be requiring and requesting more money elsewhere. To me, that's a shell game. The Liberals are saying we're going to save here, but we're going to ask for more money there. I think Canadians should understand that we were told, during the election, that we were going to save money. Now, in actual fact, we're just doing a little shell game. We're going to show a little bit of change over here while we're asking for more money. We should be making sure that we have sufficient funds, because this transnational stuff is incredibly dangerous, and it's going to become a problem for Canada. You have to explain that shell game thing to me. Why are we doing that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115396","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm sorry. My time's really short. I have to say that, if your documents that went to the PBO were incorrect, I think that's something that needs to be figured out. Secondly, Minister Champagne 's going around the country, promoting this Liberal follow-the-money strategy. I saw that you're actually going to be requiring and requesting more money elsewhere. To me, that's a shell game. The Liberals ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","label":"Foreign aid","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0a7aaae78d75b03fc6d4c627a59f8fc97e53a721067501a29ad1e5fe4cf2649"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10c9bb3069cdc486965dfbb6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115397,"date":"2026-04-23T16:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I have just one more question, then. You guys were very much a part of 200 cases that happened last year, 200 major investigations. Are you telling me that you're going to be saving money on travel, and you're going to be able to do a lot more of those investigations by saving money on travel?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115397","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have just one more question, then. You guys were very much a part of 200 cases that happened last year, 200 major investigations. Are you telling me that you're going to be saving money on travel, and you're going to be able to do a lot more of those investigations by saving money on travel?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["40a503ddd167d1f4c0725fb3b731d7b3118e4f721edb3703a86f24249d2c068a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73b90804d81aa7fb44fcfdb418249fb90a81cdc25ebb6073c889fb3d7f7451d8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da57fd6d909c831ccbc95993","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115398,"date":"2026-04-23T16:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Do you do that with less money? Is that how that works?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115398","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you do that with less money? Is that how that works?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7276357cc444263744f6b6b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115399,"date":"2026-04-23T17:30:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. Mr. Hammond, your department is pretty important. Public Services and Procurement Canada is kind of like the engine room of the government. It buys goods for departments, manages federal buildings and major assets, runs pay and pension systems for public servants, and does a lot more. Looking at your performance numbers, I see that you're missing the mark on a number of things. The simplest way that I can think of to explain this is that you're like a general contractor hired to run an entire home—not just one job but everything: the renovations, the bills, the maintenance, and even making sure that everyone in the household gets paid properly. Right now, that contractor is already missing deadlines, going over budget and not always delivering what was promised. In fact, by your own numbers, only about 6.5 out of 10 projects are being awarded on time, for example. Someone with a contractor who gets only two out of three jobs done on time wouldn't automatically think that the best way to get better results is to lay people off. If you can cut hundreds of millions of dollars without reducing service, why were these efficiencies not implemented earlier?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115399","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Hammond, your department is pretty important. Public Services and Procurement Canada is kind of like the engine room of the government. It buys goods for departments, manages federal buildings and major assets, runs pay and pension systems for public servants, and does a lot more. Looking at your performance numbers, I see that you're missing the mark on a number of things. The simp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a2556886a84c182c672c0c98942e265deb65e2858c5f7334a5431a9af833bf7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3d0efc9ace34c7ede21e44b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115400,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How did the government, after years of underperformance and massive spending, suddenly discover that you could supposedly do that same work for so much less?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115400","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How did the government, after years of underperformance and massive spending, suddenly discover that you could supposedly do that same work for so much less?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["51d09be01d10a56d1a73d29465ba3d2c9ce1edbdda09a137f33c9bc3b856dc2e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-82422960e812ad66577fa7b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115401,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Why would it have taken so long? If you guys are double-doing things, why did it take so long to find those savings?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115401","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Why would it have taken so long? If you guys are double-doing things, why did it take so long to find those savings?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d42dc7f6ce6399eba926b9c80d65385cd143177b997ad32381557c61d6374f2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e14ac7deb5ff71b902fb9f05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115402,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Then you're not regularly looking at that sort of thing, at how you can save money. Is that happening only suddenly, now, because you were told you had to look for savings?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115402","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Then you're not regularly looking at that sort of thing, at how you can save money. Is that happening only suddenly, now, because you were told you had to look for savings?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036438","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nonrenewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036438","label":"Nonrenewable resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c0688308fa9e5b872829632d0ffb59f922dc62026d5db4f89b2a7262dd9de94"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0501f996b1d57f0aeb414313","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115403,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Why did Canadians have to live with missed targets and higher deficit spending, causing increased inflation, only now to be told that the department can suddenly do the same work for less, that you're suddenly not going to be doubling up on things?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115403","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Why did Canadians have to live with missed targets and higher deficit spending, causing increased inflation, only now to be told that the department can suddenly do the same work for less, that you're suddenly not going to be doubling up on things?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6f7a0fdcf23b0b4b101784afa502c6cc467e045b19fa55a0254d5daeeb056cc3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["931847946ecc08f58e7186ba26d883e545dc927cfdf159fa3b191a06d7d2dea2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca65c171f6671cdcddc7ccb6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115404,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"This just happened in the past year, then, or has it been going on for quite some time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115404","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This just happened in the past year, then, or has it been going on for quite some time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39d56f3d64980871553a0b63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115405,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How much is it going to cost us to reduce these extra employees?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115405","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How much is it going to cost us to reduce these extra employees?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97234","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Severance pay","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97234","label":"Severance pay","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c75f58f2ef3420f5d3b518b6dca35aec5c7201d1d87ebc8bb9828cb1820c48ab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b010f06d68727576c6da819e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115406,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Do you have a cost?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115406","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you have a cost?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3aee80152b370fa24c802695","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115407,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What is your estimate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115407","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What is your estimate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4fe6e4f325f06a2fd692d2f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115408,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. This is my last question. I don't have a lot of time. Why should Canadians trust that service levels won't slip further, when you're already failing to meet the goals that were set for you?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115408","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. This is my last question. I don't have a lot of time. Why should Canadians trust that service levels won't slip further, when you're already failing to meet the goals that were set for you?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd7f31ab5ef50586ae755fb04401f8e5ee8af74810fd6899d40689bfe8ee5b64"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6fe4865b4ae832f154218cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726418,"date":"2026-04-28T15:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, Canadians are being told that this is about building a space industry for the future, and of course, we all want to see Canada succeed in that space. However, they are also looking at this and asking a very basic question: How does a government end up committing $200 million of taxpayer money to lease a launch pad that is not even operational?\n\nIs this what happens when we move away from a rules-based, accountable framework, like the one that was built under Stephen Harper, and toward a discretionary, cheque-writing approach that looks a lot more like a Liberal‐style \"enriching close friends\" type of government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726418","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, Canadians are being told that this is about building a space industry for the future, and of course, we all want to see Canada succeed in that space. However, they are also looking at this and asking a very basic question: How does a government end up committing $200 million of taxpayer money to lease a launch pad that is not even operational?\n\nIs this what happens when we move away","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e296b33b5f71435e468c83d7be9505d4c2e2128d0ff266df8666b7c3cb4e5ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5c93503033c461ccda8f07f6d0ba053223843a899805ceb8830d6188d29fe2b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b418cefb842ce1c15bf526c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726421,"date":"2026-04-28T16:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I could not help but notice earlier when one of my Liberal colleagues shouted the famous Buzz Lightyear line, \"To infinity and beyond\" in response to today's space bill.\n\nThat seems to be the level of seriousness this Liberal government has when it comes to such an important issue. This sort of trivialization raises a serious question. When Canadians see this kind of attitude, they wonder whether our legislation is being approached with the rigour it deserves.\n\nWhy are we seeing, in this bill, a shift away from disciplined, rules-based decision-making toward something far more secretive and heavy-handed under this Liberal government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726421","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I could not help but notice earlier when one of my Liberal colleagues shouted the famous Buzz Lightyear line, \"To infinity and beyond\" in response to today's space bill.\n\nThat seems to be the level of seriousness this Liberal government has when it comes to such an important issue. This sort of trivialization raises a serious question. When Canadians see this kind of attitude, they wo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c53860d7911a7ef93a4562228bfefbecd35a8658b665b94f47e1952cc50bdffb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a068c85f2a9072d13e0e620","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726423,"date":"2026-04-28T17:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when Canadians hear \"space launches\", they think of rockets and satellites, but what they should really be thinking about is security, who is launching, what they are launching and who is behind it. This where the bill falls short. There is no clear national security test written into law. Instead, we are told to trust the ministers. They will figure it out later, behind closed doors.\n\n This is an object being launched into orbit over Canadian territory, over our Arctic and over our infrastructure in our communities. Why is the government asking Canadians to trust discretion, instead of putting clear and enforceable security laws into rules that would guarantee that foreign adversaries cannot exploit Canada's space sector?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726423","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when Canadians hear \"space launches\", they think of rockets and satellites, but what they should really be thinking about is security, who is launching, what they are launching and who is behind it. This where the bill falls short. There is no clear national security test written into law. Instead, we are told to trust the ministers. They will figure it out later, behind closed doors.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["712188dc9c50c3699ad992c2c97aa68710edb231c9833ce56a333ebb0a2e0c7a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73af5f7698b1d2d1df24ac5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726427,"date":"2026-04-28T17:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the new Liberal space bill reads like yet another one-sided deal. Taxpayers would cover the risk, while Liberal friends and wealthy private investors would collect the reward. If launches fail, Canada pays. If they succeed, the profits are privatized.\n\nWhy is the government proposing building a space program where the public carries the liability but the benefits are reserved for a select few?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726427","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the new Liberal space bill reads like yet another one-sided deal. Taxpayers would cover the risk, while Liberal friends and wealthy private investors would collect the reward. If launches fail, Canada pays. If they succeed, the profits are privatized.\n\nWhy is the government proposing building a space program where the public carries the liability but the benefits are reserved for a se","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0323b200be804658e98ab6830cd031857660dd06aff81f647780415075eb972a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc8339c77fbd80f829de891d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945773,"date":"2026-05-04T19:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Parliamentary Budget Officer released four reports on the Liberals' costly credit card budget this morning, and the picture they painted, in our briefing with Annette Ryan, was deeply concerning.\n\nHere is what she confirmed. We still do not have clear definitions of what counts as capital versus operating spending, so she cannot verify whether the government is meeting its own fiscal anchors. The trillion‐dollar investment plan still has no timeline, no performance metrics and no real reporting. The housing plan will not meet targets. The defence plan is a massive unfunded risk. The tens of billions in new spending has no clear governance, no updated costing and no transparency on delivery. The money for the $25‐billion sovereign debt fund will be coming from the Bank of Canada issuing bonds to finance it. Who is buying our debt? An IMF report in April flagged that volatile foreign hedge funds now make up a large share of investors, which puts Canada at serious risk.\n\nThis morning's briefing was alarming, to say the least. When will the Prime Minister get serious, stop the credit-card budgeting and let Canadians—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945773","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Parliamentary Budget Officer released four reports on the Liberals' costly credit card budget this morning, and the picture they painted, in our briefing with Annette Ryan, was deeply concerning.\n\nHere is what she confirmed. We still do not have clear definitions of what counts as capital versus operating spending, so she cannot verify whether the government is meeting its own fis","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dfd71dbe2503c252121a77728d82c62bfd33c53955282c82e2a3e2299f2a6ec5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf36cf05be3270813991cf1595399a6206b6b17c07c0a173d113ec61c531fcd8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-679f2e5e369db311e49f5db8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945774,"date":"2026-05-04T23:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a country that cannot keep its streets safe is a country that is totally losing control of its future.\n\nWhat is happening in my community of Surrey and Cloverdale should be a warning to every member of the House. Quiet neighbourhoods are being hit by gunfire. Families are wondering whether they are safe in their own homes, and businesses are being threatened. The rule of law is being challenged in broad daylight. This is not inevitable, but if we do not act with seriousness and resolve, organized crime will continue to test the limits of our justice system and intimidate law-abiding Canadians in their own communities.\n\n Let us begin with what happened just last week. In the residential neighbourhood of Sullivan, shots were fired into a vehicle. One 25-year-old man was killed and another was seriously injured. Investigators have confirmed that it was a targeted act tied to the ongoing B.C. gang conflict. This is a neighbourhood where I door knock regularly. It is the second gang execution there in a month.\n\n What is most troubling is not the violence itself, but the facts around it. In late April, Surrey police confirmed that officers from the gang unit had been reassigned to deal with a surge in extortion. When organized crime required focused and sustained pressure, specialized resources were being pulled in another direction. That should concern everyone. When enforcement is stretched too thin, criminals look for openings. When pressure is not sustained, organized crime adapts. When police are forced to shift limited resources from one serious threat to another, innocent Canadians are the ones left in the crosshairs.\n\n What happened last week was not some isolated gangland shooting in a back alley. It happened in a quiet neighbourhood filled with families, people who had nothing to do with this violence and are now left wondering what could happen next. We need to be clear about what we are dealing with. This is a web of rival gangs and sophisticated organized crime networks increasingly tied to extortion.\n\n The violence is not contained between criminals. It is spilling into our neighbourhoods, our businesses and our streets. When a multi-agency task force was empowered to go after these criminals, there were signs of progress, with more than 30 active investigations, close to 100 judicial authorizations and coordinated action across agencies. Over 100 individuals were being examined for immigration violations linked to those networks.\n\n That is what it looks like when the full weight of the system is applied, but that pressure has to be constant. Organized crime does not disappear because of one announcement or one operation. It has to be confronted every day with sustained enforcement, specialized policing and real consequences.\n\n At the same time, we cannot ignore the pattern of leniency in the system itself. Individuals with serious criminal histories remain in this country when they should have been removed. Offenders breach conditions, reoffend and continue to benefit from delays, reduced sentences or rulings that allow them to stay. Judges have warned of a two-tier justice system, where penalties are softened to avoid deportation while Canadians face the full weight of the law. Even people under deportation orders who are facing serious allegations have been able to exploit the gaps and disappear from oversight or avoid consequences. That is not right. It sends a dangerous message to criminals that the rules are negotiable and the consequences are minimal.\n\n If we want to turn this around, we need sustained support for law enforcement. That means specialized units that remain focused, officers on the ground who are not pulled away at the first shift in priorities, and tools, such as air support, that help police monitor suspects, coordinate responses and stop offenders from operating freely.\n\nWill the government finally stop with the rhetoric, restore mandatory minimums, repeal its catch-and-release laws and ensure that criminals face real consequences?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945774","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a country that cannot keep its streets safe is a country that is totally losing control of its future.\n\nWhat is happening in my community of Surrey and Cloverdale should be a warning to every member of the House. Quiet neighbourhoods are being hit by gunfire. Families are wondering whether they are safe in their own homes, and businesses are being threatened. The rule of law is being ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","label":"Gangs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","label":"Gangs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6a011e53c2095b04487bbb1bc95fc5ac804af678c304ffa96d5bd0d4e48b3d8c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f93969ccf943835baa24dc0d108541482924740019dc569bd6245271b06ae7cf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10a00e761e6ed76772e4f2d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945775,"date":"2026-05-04T23:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if the government is serious about restoring safety for Canadians, it has to act with clarity and resolve. This begins with consequences. Serious repeat offenders, particularly those engaged in extortion and organized crime, must face meaningful jail time, not symbolic penalties but sentences that deter and protect. The new Liberal legislation, which would make it criminal to shoot a gun from a moving car, is completely unserious. These criminals already know they are committing a crime.\n\nWe also need bail rules that put public safety first, not last, and we need to close the loopholes that allow non-citizens involved in serious criminal activity to manipulate the refugee system and remain in this country when they should not. We need to end the leniency that allows people convicted of serious crimes to avoid removal. We desperately need, at the same time, to work with police, provinces and communities, providing sustainable support to dismantle those networks properly and to restore confidence where it has been lost.\n\nWhat is the reason the Liberal government does not take this issue seriously?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945775","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if the government is serious about restoring safety for Canadians, it has to act with clarity and resolve. This begins with consequences. Serious repeat offenders, particularly those engaged in extortion and organized crime, must face meaningful jail time, not symbolic penalties but sentences that deter and protect. The new Liberal legislation, which would make it criminal to shoot a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3428419d21ccc04438170672f453d98c749dfc145690922366c7a09a3db57193"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["10498f046e3f623f289b44d5a6b53c82b7452202ef3474cf2cc7e2c8ea70d901"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-781dcdb81439a16e028b7db8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945771,"date":"2026-05-05T15:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we all agree that U.S. tariffs are hurting Canadian workers. Businesses are being squeezed and uncertainty is growing, but loans are not a solution. Even industry leaders are clearly saying that the tariff is the problem.\n\nI would ask my colleague from the Bloc, if tariffs are the problem, does he agree that Canada needs real leverage, like building our energy resource capacity, to get those tariffs removed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945771","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we all agree that U.S. tariffs are hurting Canadian workers. Businesses are being squeezed and uncertainty is growing, but loans are not a solution. Even industry leaders are clearly saying that the tariff is the problem.\n\nI would ask my colleague from the Bloc, if tariffs are the problem, does he agree that Canada needs real leverage, like building our energy resource capacity, to ge","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d4795a3c6a798cc5018be86ddb4cef23d6008042cd51e77a6c5639063a3e3fba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f679ddb7030d205ee9d40217c88412bea188d5d82704aaa8c608fb07e61f5613"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0dc87f74b5925cc8e80ebd75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945772,"date":"2026-05-05T17:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, 2.6 million Canadian jobs depend on getting those tariffs resolved, and a year in, there is still no deal, no timeline and no negotiation. The Prime Minister cannot even decide if our relationship with the U.S. is broken or stronger than ever.\n\nWhen will the government stop the mixed messages and start real negotiations to remove these tariffs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945772","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, 2.6 million Canadian jobs depend on getting those tariffs resolved, and a year in, there is still no deal, no timeline and no negotiation. The Prime Minister cannot even decide if our relationship with the U.S. is broken or stronger than ever.\n\nWhen will the government stop the mixed messages and start real negotiations to remove these tariffs?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1c7702cd952db8e16acf4e871ddde388af9f038b505246912574bd5b2e12d9d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da314bdf060c433c14e99860f3538a242379d0a82cb548074e30e32830e93844"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9de9e4f1a46f48c4b91058b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115409,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Yes, thank you. Just this week, we heard that your department has referred another individual to police, making it the 10th case of suspected procurement fraud referred for criminal investigation. At our meeting in December, I asked whether you could commit to including fraud data in your department result report. I was quite surprised by your written response, which said that fraud detection data isn't included because it fluctuates and doesn't reflect performance. I want to make it clear: Is it correct that detecting and preventing fraud are core parts of the job?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115409","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes, thank you. Just this week, we heard that your department has referred another individual to police, making it the 10th case of suspected procurement fraud referred for criminal investigation. At our meeting in December, I asked whether you could commit to including fraud data in your department result report. I was quite surprised by your written response, which said that fraud detection data","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aff02bace5a20244a483f12a86ba4e5e4a64fd332e13a856bc8f25a6aed32fe2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2fbb63c2845e87981815b3dd899376539d049917f1a83b2177fe0d871e981483"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9fdb89061fd5227630316c20","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115410,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"If fraud goes up and down significantly, and you have all these new ways of catching fraudsters, logically, it would mean that fraud's something important to track and report regularly. Would you agree? It's a yes or no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115410","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If fraud goes up and down significantly, and you have all these new ways of catching fraudsters, logically, it would mean that fraud's something important to track and report regularly. Would you agree? It's a yes or no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4f15f3008ccfde3bbc3bc74cd6bbcef66781cf8fa6a1861f6dc137e90a2cb1c8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9de03bb43409b244ffacd91c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115411,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Help me understand, why aren't we reporting this in that report? If fraud is serious, we have a tip line, and investigations recover millions and we refer cases to police, why aren't we putting it in your performance report?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115411","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Help me understand, why aren't we reporting this in that report? If fraud is serious, we have a tip line, and investigations recover millions and we refer cases to police, why aren't we putting it in your performance report?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eaa404a5e2fc4b91e96b1cc3ed1a73d70e7d811e317a91def0d3dfee2d4e1acb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d783d3ce0a3cce796ce266c5509ae57c40cd02a7e5f1e2eefe8ae13b4697c16"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-124a43ec69df498da2e2b295","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115412,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. I'll ask my next question, then. Is the latest referral related to the same pattern of subcontractor overbilling, or is it a different type of alleged fraud?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115412","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. I'll ask my next question, then. Is the latest referral related to the same pattern of subcontractor overbilling, or is it a different type of alleged fraud?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["27ef6a867f70a2ca5794b8044a4949c96243a6affce4879607880b84f304fe5f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8ec38306e6b2bee6173ff57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115413,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. When was the PSPC first made aware of this case? When was it referred to the RCMP?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115413","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. When was the PSPC first made aware of this case? When was it referred to the RCMP?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9960d8ddd2093947e5eac6ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115414,"date":"2026-05-05T21:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Do you know how much the value is?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115414","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do you know how much the value is?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ad7342b02d52d077048b403","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115415,"date":"2026-05-05T21:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How many more cases are currently under review that could result in RCMP referrals?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115415","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How many more cases are currently under review that could result in RCMP referrals?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0339eec2a0c3ff9a1bd00c14bed9ba313414f7e52df2ba7e8d1d7088674b8bca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4c195f0175f4bcac9725bcc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115416,"date":"2026-05-05T21:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Can a supplier under active investigation for procurement fraud still receive federal contracts?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115416","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Can a supplier under active investigation for procurement fraud still receive federal contracts?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23f6aaeff3bdc9141c39c9eb839830db10f1933b7ab7a10a151b09431656d6f9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4bf36d0b16d45dad900f104","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115417,"date":"2026-05-05T21:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Really quickly, why is this not included in the performance report? I don't understand.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115417","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Really quickly, why is this not included in the performance report? I don't understand.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["84ba6ba226fc6f8d05010a55135d701ac7eebefc5a949b8e7fa318ceaed0e8d8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e721591a35bfb9772fd77cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115418,"date":"2026-05-05T21:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Perhaps you can explain this to me. If we have all these different dashboards and we're trying to figure out how to ensure that we know your actual.... I'm going to ask Mr. Lightbound this. We're trying to figure out how to understand what kind of fraud is happening, and this is the core job that you have, it's part of your performance, yet it's not given to parliamentarians as a performance report. That makes no sense to me. It doesn't matter how many dashboards you have; the report for Parliament should tell us what—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115418","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Perhaps you can explain this to me. If we have all these different dashboards and we're trying to figure out how to ensure that we know your actual.... I'm going to ask Mr. Lightbound this. We're trying to figure out how to understand what kind of fraud is happening, and this is the core job that you have, it's part of your performance, yet it's not given to parliamentarians as a performance repor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35e69a8c97abaad530f7291a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115419,"date":"2026-05-05T21:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"No. I realize there's an annual report. I'm asking why this isn't in your department report, because it's clearly performance. If there's a huge fluctuation in finding these things, to me that's a performance issue, and that's what we're here to understand.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115419","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"No. I realize there's an annual report. I'm asking why this isn't in your department report, because it's clearly performance. If there's a huge fluctuation in finding these things, to me that's a performance issue, and that's what we're here to understand.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31a914c278b7265424552a4188ded73cfb9f4271657e82556ee9f2fd7bda43d4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ded080af0764643e2d265940","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115420,"date":"2026-05-05T21:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Your wording was about fluctuation as to why we're not getting that in your department performance report.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115420","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Your wording was about fluctuation as to why we're not getting that in your department performance report.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d33fb1985bb735764ba9085efba8cc8a56fcb4f7fee9a262cf2b7f7af900f757"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-590d0d876da9530f5635decb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115421,"date":"2026-05-05T21:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I totally get that. However, when we asked in December, the answer we received was basically that it's because it fluctuates. I don't understand that answer. That's a silly answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115421","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I totally get that. However, when we asked in December, the answer we received was basically that it's because it fluctuates. I don't understand that answer. That's a silly answer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d5b4f42d6f56e8b8305ff6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945770,"date":"2026-05-06T22:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a recent study by the Montreal Economic Institute estimates that the government's buy Canada policy could drive up costs by more than $12 billion a year. During an affordability crisis, does my colleague think paying much higher prices for Liberal vanity projects like Alto rail is the best way to help Canadians keep more of their hard-earned dollars in their pockets?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945770","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a recent study by the Montreal Economic Institute estimates that the government's buy Canada policy could drive up costs by more than $12 billion a year. During an affordability crisis, does my colleague think paying much higher prices for Liberal vanity projects like Alto rail is the best way to help Canadians keep more of their hard-earned dollars in their pockets?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dba57e06daf9034ec52567597a3ca1cfaffb9e08b2f9527b7361b8bf87fd74dc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-506f579ae633b28fae1b802a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115422,"date":"2026-05-07T16:00:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. Since we have the announcement of the new Governor General, I think it's great to speak to Mr. MacKillop, as he's the secretary to the GG. Right now, Canadians are lining up at food banks. They're cutting groceries; they're struggling to keep a roof over their heads, and they're watching every dollar just to get through the month. When they hear about hundreds of millions of dollars having been spent on the Governor General of Canada over the last decade—tied to travel costs, former GG expenses, clothing purchases and speech writing, and now the reports of a Rideau Hall skating rink project—they're rightly asking about who's watching the taxpayers' money. I don't think Canadians are even aware that former governors general can continue claiming expenses after leaving office. On top of their pension, they can claim up to $200,000 a year in expenses for life. Of course, with Mrs. Simon's retiring, we'll have five GGs able to pull on that. Last year alone, more than $550,000 was billed through it by past GGs. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115422","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Since we have the announcement of the new Governor General, I think it's great to speak to Mr. MacKillop, as he's the secretary to the GG. Right now, Canadians are lining up at food banks. They're cutting groceries; they're struggling to keep a roof over their heads, and they're watching every dollar just to get through the month. When they hear about hundreds of millions of dollars hav","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-378b6ed9cba81a93d400f212","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115423,"date":"2026-05-07T16:00:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Who claimed that money and what was it spent on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115423","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Who claimed that money and what was it spent on?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca5af6c86ea2a1c7f6aa9cde7b8eb4c4584668341c0d3358c55df5b1942e8c03"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a40ce545ac9d573f17467b39","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115424,"date":"2026-05-07T16:00:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm sorry. I tried to give as much context beforehand as I possibly could. I was asking who claimed that $550,000 for last year.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115424","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry. I tried to give as much context beforehand as I possibly could. I was asking who claimed that $550,000 for last year.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","label":"Personal income tax","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3de0e98271baae8b52e44d3fbfa19c5e5d718cb5310fe70adee14a3a100cb2ce"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-262c09ce0ef24410d521bee2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115425,"date":"2026-05-07T16:00:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Did they all collect on that? Did they all put in expenses last year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115425","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Did they all collect on that? Did they all put in expenses last year?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1920674d9a9db352b1e419f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115426,"date":"2026-05-07T16:00:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Do we know what it was spent on? Do we have some place in which we can see what it was spent on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115426","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do we know what it was spent on? Do we have some place in which we can see what it was spent on?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6725b0298ee386e2919eeccd64ab14849133426aab1b1f823fff7dee441e23f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-256491b572766581af64a517","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115427,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm sorry. We're wondering whether we can see what it was spent on. Even with my expenses, I have to declare them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115427","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry. We're wondering whether we can see what it was spent on. Even with my expenses, I have to declare them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["674cfd9de87fc5902e25147700206653d42b38cefe6664ac09be627e6ca82684"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7cc4d4e027198199c6c8fc79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115428,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You don't know what it was spent on. Okay. If these are legitimate public expenses, why not proactively disclose them in the same detail that we have to? Right now, we have to take a photo of everything we buy and upload it, so why wouldn't the former GGs have to do that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115428","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You don't know what it was spent on. Okay. If these are legitimate public expenses, why not proactively disclose them in the same detail that we have to? Right now, we have to take a photo of everything we buy and upload it, so why wouldn't the former GGs have to do that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ae89c7b2555394b3c5dd312bcb039a53f261835bec6814d4fe64507f1c98dcd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f884fe85d65d334d9812454b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115429,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"The public does not see what those expenses are. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115429","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The public does not see what those expenses are. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec31798b8c5ed1550b17364a7cbece9f8bca780a9135e7df55b8c9ed503846e2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4826d96e52ad96fa354df36","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115430,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. The best way for me to really demonstrate the problem is by looking at the Governor General's trip to the Middle East in 2022. Mary Simon went to the Arab Emirates, Qatar and Kuwait. The total cost of that trip was about $1.3 million. That included flights, accommodation and hospitality. This committee studied the Governor General's travel because Canadians saw what was going on. The point was to make sure that there was better planning, better cost control and better transparency. Which of this committee's 2023 recommendations on the travel of governors general have been fully implemented?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115430","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. The best way for me to really demonstrate the problem is by looking at the Governor General's trip to the Middle East in 2022. Mary Simon went to the Arab Emirates, Qatar and Kuwait. The total cost of that trip was about $1.3 million. That included flights, accommodation and hospitality. This committee studied the Governor General's travel because Canadians saw what was going on. The point w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5e47a415a1eeeb734ab8f96efbd15fb96968771733f7f3be7ae1efd528428d3a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ff04ea37d6ff49791f4cf917534794f904db3f7d7be831aae9dc5b334c9be2f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-949f22410b816dd8ae5b6502","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115431,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Perhaps we can go backwards, then. If you don't know how many were implemented, do you know how many were not completed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115431","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Perhaps we can go backwards, then. If you don't know how many were implemented, do you know how many were not completed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc4c0f3c20720a77b4e9c06d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115432,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Please provide us with an explanation. What specific safeguards are in place right now to make sure the reckless spending on travel by past governors general, which we saw as Canadians, doesn't happen again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115432","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Please provide us with an explanation. What specific safeguards are in place right now to make sure the reckless spending on travel by past governors general, which we saw as Canadians, doesn't happen again?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","label":"Hazardous materials transport","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d49d3a35edc69d6042622d5b93bab5e0660269890fc24a56ccbf4b3d9ef6570a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5baf2e8b4454759dd871bedb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115433,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"There were reports that the office purchased clothing for Governor General Mary Simon because she had retired much of her professional wardrobe. Canadians want to know whether this practice is going to continue. Will taxpayers be expected to pay for professional attire for the incoming GG?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115433","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There were reports that the office purchased clothing for Governor General Mary Simon because she had retired much of her professional wardrobe. Canadians want to know whether this practice is going to continue. Will taxpayers be expected to pay for professional attire for the incoming GG?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33255bfa87b25e488dd6c675","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115434,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"That's a yes, then. There have been reports about a Rideau Hall skating rink project, including major projected costs, a sole-source contract and donations flowing through the Rideau Hall Foundation. What is the total cost of that project, and how much of it was paid for by taxpayers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115434","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's a yes, then. There have been reports about a Rideau Hall skating rink project, including major projected costs, a sole-source contract and donations flowing through the Rideau Hall Foundation. What is the total cost of that project, and how much of it was paid for by taxpayers?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:187157","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skating","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:187157","label":"Skating","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5a08cbaf7b404183589fd99fa075b5ff0e11bccc4c27a2bca533849f4b53275"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f398dc4bea863bcca9e74179","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115435,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Were donors offered tax receipts, VIP invitations, letters, photos, plaques or any other recognition connected to the project?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115435","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Were donors offered tax receipts, VIP invitations, letters, photos, plaques or any other recognition connected to the project?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6d187311b5b131a9e1d9f00044f87b0f5936d06b0f8e417b81c70f915c771752"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ea5f1cf0f0142fe8d2ffa3a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115436,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What was that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115436","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What was that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-faa8dbb45cebb0d0432246aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115437,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"My time is almost up. I think I have 10 more seconds. At a time when Canadians are being told to tighten their belts, I believe they deserve a clear answer about how public money is being spent at Rideau Hall. We'd appreciate it if we could get more transparency and find out what changes you've made since 2023.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115437","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My time is almost up. I think I have 10 more seconds. At a time when Canadians are being told to tighten their belts, I believe they deserve a clear answer about how public money is being spent at Rideau Hall. We'd appreciate it if we could get more transparency and find out what changes you've made since 2023.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b62de3552a00a0fa85b7437d579412f6e509f1208dbbcbab5423ade41432e46d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecb66a042107a71f4bc28c1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115438,"date":"2026-05-07T16:40:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. My questions are for PSPC. In the spring economic update, there was additional funding for PSPC to run an extra team at the pay centre dealing with the current backlog of cases. With additional funding and a shorter runway to remove that backlog of cases before the new Dayforce system comes in, do you have a timeline for that backlog to be removed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115438","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. My questions are for PSPC. In the spring economic update, there was additional funding for PSPC to run an extra team at the pay centre dealing with the current backlog of cases. With additional funding and a shorter runway to remove that backlog of cases before the new Dayforce system comes in, do you have a timeline for that backlog to be removed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c7b4a63e44a86555f941e9450b0fae807132ad181fa7f2d42c075fed30de0390"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a5c7466da81bfc7fa729dbf227bbc17aba1048412712c06e50d42dbff4b040a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2619334222da4ef2ee401627","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115439,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. How many cases still exist that are older than five years?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115439","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. How many cases still exist that are older than five years?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b671a5bc19281c75ef1c170bb3975497c63ba6f01f23f5b80d277927d113f4a8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbba1b4fc0f3d76b85af5da9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115440,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You do have cases that are over five years old. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115440","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You do have cases that are over five years old. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29fceb5c3ef40fed52689f56142cb80943055831579c5afb9de69fff525f32c1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e911dbbe4570b9c841b92bb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115441,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Have you been using AI, or will you be using AI, to assist in clearing that backlog?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115441","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Have you been using AI, or will you be using AI, to assist in clearing that backlog?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace automation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037678","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Workplace automation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037678","label":"Workplace automation","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["561473e68dfbb49f7980332062df23cbd6593432064f3b2ada05f25a66196c16"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d01678f88cc1cf37a1f7ec8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115442,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Then the question is this: How much is being spent to implement AI?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115442","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Then the question is this: How much is being spent to implement AI?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","label":"Aviation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2bb8fe032382245b92f864e335e7547bd64b33504508d3bb0cfa3cfa77ab741d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84bfcd9ced70c8c44e113522","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115443,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay, I'd appreciate it if you could. I'm going back to PSPC. My colleague had asked a question when the minister was present about PSPC being directed to examine present and future contracts to find savings last fall. Was this exercise part of the CER?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115443","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay, I'd appreciate it if you could. I'm going back to PSPC. My colleague had asked a question when the minister was present about PSPC being directed to examine present and future contracts to find savings last fall. Was this exercise part of the CER?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036809","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036809","label":"Public pensions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c3977d14852f26728fa06770d592385c059718a01a5340edae37a9ca53e4e41a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["980078cd123b79b6a7d3cf31eaf456291414cf41f46e777d8ce9f5a4296e298a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0dca8b3addb4068369ad616","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115444,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How much of the CER savings came from examining contracts for savings?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115444","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How much of the CER savings came from examining contracts for savings?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","label":"Colleges","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8103d89bd256d8a1607282cd3855d365bb1c011e51690855cf93ba0aa5ee0cf2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81daeaa5c7eb176d73ff1f7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115445,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. The interim policy on reciprocal procurement was issued last summer. How much money will no longer be going to firms that fall outside the policy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115445","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. The interim policy on reciprocal procurement was issued last summer. How much money will no longer be going to firms that fall outside the policy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["168103ffe7db5c07c169c5e4625c55763b3b31e45bd0d292a2e216df5f12bb34"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a90b1294b712f47a0ccd6d0fc31bd3e93fb6b48bf9e4496af511aca86df6801"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-464241c97b78aeae00e1c9d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115446,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Can you submit a list to the committee of countries that would no longer have access to Canadian procurement with this policy in place?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115446","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Can you submit a list to the committee of countries that would no longer have access to Canadian procurement with this policy in place?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["77903129bfedb340196a39bc1fa8a0fed302d654a9ae82de38a24b04848f2d3a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c56c6993879e3c77507ff20c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115447,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Does your department plan to make it more difficult for middle-man firms, such as GC Strategies, to bid on federal procurement opportunities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115447","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does your department plan to make it more difficult for middle-man firms, such as GC Strategies, to bid on federal procurement opportunities?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bccc27537b1313cf36e5f6943e73d33770380511e9d869dcb0a3372ae74cb766"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e468b8dae7025caee02423f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115448,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I don't know who exactly in PSPC this question is for. What's the timeline for your department to send the Defence Investment Agency off on its own and kick it out of the nest, so to say? It's been a year already.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115448","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I don't know who exactly in PSPC this question is for. What's the timeline for your department to send the Defence Investment Agency off on its own and kick it out of the nest, so to say? It's been a year already.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f54e53c40e3674260f4514b4774a7538405ad5bdc0b3c93cd25e809f5a8f16ba"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebc7de951fb7e6843f6c2238","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115449,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Is there a timeline?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115449","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is there a timeline?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-58998090576f4fa415d56b6c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115450,"date":"2026-05-07T17:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm going to switch it up and speak with Ms. Boyer, if that's all right. When you were here in March, we talked about concerns about vote 50. The Liberal government was asking parliamentarians to approve $1 billion, but there was no clear breakdown, no list of projects and no real way for Parliament to understand where the money was going. I believe Mr. Matthews called it a \"contingency\" fund set aside for whatever happens military spending-wise—something unexpected. In fact, I realized there already was a contingency fund, and that this was for an extra $1 billion. I noticed that the morning Parliamentary Budget Officer's report confirms exactly what I was saying. The PBO says that this fund may help government move money faster for a defence project, but it also makes it much harder for Parliament to track where the money goes and whether it is spent properly. Basically, parliamentarians were asked to approve a blank cheque. Does that sound like a good plan to you? I am asking as a lawyer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115450","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm going to switch it up and speak with Ms. Boyer, if that's all right. When you were here in March, we talked about concerns about vote 50. The Liberal government was asking parliamentarians to approve $1 billion, but there was no clear breakdown, no list of projects and no real way for Parliament to understand where the money was going. I believe Mr. Matthews called it a \"contingency\" fund set ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4bbbe9b001717ff3acedc6ef27c59ed8cca766dc0c3bcb2033da263babd654d6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92d246fb6662d85aee1250b8c04b72e1f6d5daf7018642ad9abce3138af2c2a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-228eea36be2625bf01d87c8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115451,"date":"2026-05-07T17:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I know. We had this discussion last time. Now I'm asking Ms. Boyer. Is that all right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115451","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I know. We had this discussion last time. Now I'm asking Ms. Boyer. Is that all right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8db3f9793cd27beb81d38969","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115452,"date":"2026-05-07T17:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"My question was, does this sound like a good idea? We have no idea what we're approving. How is it possible? We don't even have a clue about what we're going to spend the $1 billion on, and departments have only a tiny bit of time to spend it. To me, it seems they must know what they want to buy. They just don't want Canadians to know what they're planning on buying.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115452","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My question was, does this sound like a good idea? We have no idea what we're approving. How is it possible? We don't even have a clue about what we're going to spend the $1 billion on, and departments have only a tiny bit of time to spend it. To me, it seems they must know what they want to buy. They just don't want Canadians to know what they're planning on buying.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d000d07fa7cce7e6364c9329","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115453,"date":"2026-05-07T17:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I have a question. Does this continue every year going forward—this $1 billion as an extra contingency fund, on top of everything?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115453","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a question. Does this continue every year going forward—this $1 billion as an extra contingency fund, on top of everything?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7004a0517584224e7f67ecd12e6c30eb01c8ace77e81583130cd92dca9ee32eb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93811f8b80ef87c4244bc021","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115454,"date":"2026-05-07T17:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I have a quick question. One billion dollars is a lot of money. You could pay 15,000 nurses for a year with that money. You could cover groceries for 50,000 families for a full year. Can you please explain to Canadians why, without a clear plan, we are once again being told, \"Just trust us\", especially during an affordability crisis? Canadians don't have a contingency fund on top of a contingency fund. They don't even have a contingency fund right now. Help me make a bit of sense out of it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115454","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a quick question. One billion dollars is a lot of money. You could pay 15,000 nurses for a year with that money. You could cover groceries for 50,000 families for a full year. Can you please explain to Canadians why, without a clear plan, we are once again being told, \"Just trust us\", especially during an affordability crisis? Canadians don't have a contingency fund on top of a contingency ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["441b8618f324a5b530cdd63190bc2f893463b7c84d34ace439ae9ce34b673b51"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c909326fd20bf68d0424e835","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115455,"date":"2026-05-07T17:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How is it possible that you guys don't know this ahead of time? That makes no sense to me. It's $1 billion. Yes, you can speed up spending, but every year, you want a second contingency fund with $1 billion in it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115455","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How is it possible that you guys don't know this ahead of time? That makes no sense to me. It's $1 billion. Yes, you can speed up spending, but every year, you want a second contingency fund with $1 billion in it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b6dabea2ce2a9956d68aa68ffafd8cafe0c171116bd521a7092ba831563bd35a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88006b95d13d57bba3ce7736c6c09169b606659d1fec25a2c1dadbfa7cc3b201"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa580dfb0d7e87cda1431766","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115456,"date":"2026-05-07T17:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Is that every year from now on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115456","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is that every year from now on?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be2b3d40288a380a4c99ed34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115457,"date":"2026-05-07T17:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You already have a contingency fund for that. I don't understand why you need a second one.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115457","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You already have a contingency fund for that. I don't understand why you need a second one.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d58e897214ac7e8477d7ba68d14948fd24f189b8a21e492aa0400da48faad68"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ddca21540286dc97ca9ae8f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115458,"date":"2026-05-07T17:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Basically, this is going to be used for military equipment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115458","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Basically, this is going to be used for military equipment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","label":"Military technology","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7b5ab72b61f03ca26b2bbeef5ca7af410a9274f5d91a887e688b909066e899c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72a89f17d05eaa489d098907","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115459,"date":"2026-05-07T17:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"The PBO says the new $25-billion sovereign wealth fund is financed through borrowing, and the rules for how to operate are still unclear, so what is the annual borrowing cost in dollars?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115459","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The PBO says the new $25-billion sovereign wealth fund is financed through borrowing, and the rules for how to operate are still unclear, so what is the annual borrowing cost in dollars?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ad28cd974a2e82b426c66028eedcaf2e658c430c69b28e5ebafab1cd93070a1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ffb49ddd88d3d55c1c7066e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115460,"date":"2026-05-07T17:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115460","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a45685ccc18062f8780b465","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115461,"date":"2026-05-07T17:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I have 10 seconds?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115461","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have 10 seconds?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0515dfc57152ffd05260a00","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115462,"date":"2026-05-07T17:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Oh, I thought you said I didn't.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115462","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Oh, I thought you said I didn't.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63af8f883e95569da5b50ef4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115463,"date":"2026-05-07T17:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm going to try one more time, if I can, with Ms. Boyer. This is about the sovereign wealth fund. This fund, traditionally, would come from wealth. Norway used oil revenues. Alberta did as well. The gulf states used resource surpluses. Canada is proposing something very different. We're borrowing $25 billion we don't have, adding interest costs to an already strained fiscal picture and hoping the investments outperform the debt. The Parliamentary Budget Officer's report, published this morning, confirmed that this fund will increase borrowing and public debt charges, putting us in a risky position when it comes to market volatility. He also mentioned a recent IMF report, which gave a serious warning: Increased reliance on market-based and foreign financing can amplify vulnerabilities during periods of financial stress. Canadians deserve to know exactly what risks they are being asked to carry. First, can I confirm that Canadians will be paying interest on borrowed money to capitalize this fund?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115463","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm going to try one more time, if I can, with Ms. Boyer. This is about the sovereign wealth fund. This fund, traditionally, would come from wealth. Norway used oil revenues. Alberta did as well. The gulf states used resource surpluses. Canada is proposing something very different. We're borrowing $25 billion we don't have, adding interest costs to an already strained fiscal picture and hoping the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f5527ce1b9bef763f4ff6d9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115464,"date":"2026-05-07T17:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. Can you answer, Mr. Matthews?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115464","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Can you answer, Mr. Matthews?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42535f1404e6703596690f3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115465,"date":"2026-05-07T17:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"That is my question. Traditional sovereign wealth funds are usually built from surplus revenues or resource wealth. Why is Canada building one through borrowing instead?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115465","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That is my question. Traditional sovereign wealth funds are usually built from surplus revenues or resource wealth. Why is Canada building one through borrowing instead?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec5a051a95f30e4719849902573f8ac48b42ed3c828a9e539a34ea8873673d63"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac1dbc7b79cffa4200832bab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115466,"date":"2026-05-07T17:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay, what is the projected annual rate of return that the government is assuming for this fund, and what borrowing rate are those projections based on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115466","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay, what is the projected annual rate of return that the government is assuming for this fund, and what borrowing rate are those projections based on?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56a8e586bdedadf8fe391d9dd716ecf84f32ed7ca3de6f10189c71ad2792599f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-92275ea6f5d3d47d887afa80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115467,"date":"2026-05-07T17:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"If the investment returns underperform the government's borrowing cost, who absorbs the losses?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115467","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If the investment returns underperform the government's borrowing cost, who absorbs the losses?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","label":"Tax fraud","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["afe3b788e9bbdd9334f9e5f57fcf70f5d198e08d16471a22697c59411ddd0544"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c89a8f156524ef833a775c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115468,"date":"2026-05-07T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What role do you play in approving the financing and stuff for this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115468","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What role do you play in approving the financing and stuff for this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e871a544b3325c439b535c4ffeb2c9639a14fa32ef43c2067dcfedd799327ac9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f5a74cfa1d2ad40147a97308","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115469,"date":"2026-05-07T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Would you know if a stress test has been performed for recession market downturn or rising interest rates affecting the fund's viability?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115469","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Would you know if a stress test has been performed for recession market downturn or rising interest rates affecting the fund's viability?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","label":"Interest rates","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e5dd705520dde84d81e203a8713bdba1093b594444dc4f0aa80383f1886f86f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcc4d1df24eacd129461b2ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115470,"date":"2026-05-07T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You have no idea, then. The IMF recently warned that countries relying more heavily on market-based financing and volatile investment flows face greater vulnerability during financial shocks. Would you agree, Ms. Boyer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115470","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You have no idea, then. The IMF recently warned that countries relying more heavily on market-based financing and volatile investment flows face greater vulnerability during financial shocks. Would you agree, Ms. Boyer?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c5d75688e7cf4f3ee572054b15241e3082209ddf67fb72be61544ef56235cd6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f829654b684d469a53d90296","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115471,"date":"2026-05-07T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. How about you, Mr. Matthews?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115471","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. How about you, Mr. Matthews?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54df02a88e6f228006917ece","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115472,"date":"2026-05-07T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Well, what safeguards would be in place to ensure the fund does not increase Canada's exposure to those risks?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115472","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, what safeguards would be in place to ensure the fund does not increase Canada's exposure to those risks?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26f83122ca2bbf64a829a0e68a223b7824cfeedd9bd7aec1ad44bdfb9311b33e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c94b4e9282ae9871e45fcd8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115473,"date":"2026-05-07T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Would you agree that a sovereign wealth fund is supposed to manage surplus wealth for future generations, yet here we are borrowing money to create it? You guys are finance guys. Is it really just a leverage investment fund backed by taxpayers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115473","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Would you agree that a sovereign wealth fund is supposed to manage surplus wealth for future generations, yet here we are borrowing money to create it? You guys are finance guys. Is it really just a leverage investment fund backed by taxpayers?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["36a1e6c23bf6d2a1a89ae6b58396a4586a007bb164398b6fb0eed588a2cc5a8f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e3f037237a52c846a6cb330","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115474,"date":"2026-05-07T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You gave your opinion in regard to the advertising. Can we get your opinion on this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115474","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You gave your opinion in regard to the advertising. Can we get your opinion on this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8018f40e3ff92683b3888b6a6b252fc435f412f0784c5af799dbe0ff7bdc1e1f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d5585c2e2562cacdd63c04f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115475,"date":"2026-05-07T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Do you have any thoughts on why Canadians should trust a plan with public debt charges projected to reach $80.9 billion by 2030-31? Why does the Treasury Board consider this acceptable? What do you consider an acceptable ceiling for debt charges as a share of revenue?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115475","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do you have any thoughts on why Canadians should trust a plan with public debt charges projected to reach $80.9 billion by 2030-31? Why does the Treasury Board consider this acceptable? What do you consider an acceptable ceiling for debt charges as a share of revenue?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ef6c65fb7dd7d5e1e919c96e374e774907e9b740129dbca7726b4e49d0eac2e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24d883cb58ed2e0e358ee8d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035390,"date":"2026-05-25T17:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when the government forces Parliament to shut down debate, Canadians should ask themselves one very simple question: What exactly are the Liberals hoping that Canadians will not notice? The choice to use time allocation is the latest in the government's attempt to shortcut transparency. Debate is cut short, scrutiny is treated like obstruction and billions of taxpayer dollars are pushed through Parliament without good oversight. It is becoming a pattern. They change the rules halfway through the game, dim the lights and hope Canadians cannot see the scoreboard clearly enough to question the result. \n\nHowever, a strong economy depends on trust, trust that the rules are fair, the books are honest and hard work still gets people ahead. Under the Liberal government, Canadians feel like they are in a nightmare game, expected to play blindfolded. Eventually, players stop taking risks, investors stop investing and builders stop building. \n\nMy question is simple. Why do the Liberals keep shutting off the cameras and using technicalities like time allocation when the trust of Canadians is at its lowest? Honesty and integrity—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035390","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when the government forces Parliament to shut down debate, Canadians should ask themselves one very simple question: What exactly are the Liberals hoping that Canadians will not notice? The choice to use time allocation is the latest in the government's attempt to shortcut transparency. Debate is cut short, scrutiny is treated like obstruction and billions of taxpayer dollars are push","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f04cd3634373adae1a3bb264a336bf17a9bf943acfd9a81237b5536e10e22e6d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d7fc94be7aba1580135874f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035391,"date":"2026-05-25T19:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, 11 years ago, people invested in our community because they believed in the future. Families moved there. Builders built there. Small businesses took risks there, but now developers are facing insolvency. Businesses are being extorted. Families are worried about crime and people are starting to wonder if the rules even make sense anymore.\n\nAfter years of mixed signals from the Liberals, sudden policy shifts and weak-on-crime laws, the confidence that built our community is being shaken. When people stop feeling safe, physically, financially and legally, communities start to break apart.\n\nOur leader was in Cloverdale last week talking about crime and property rights because this is no longer some abstract political debate. This is about whether ordinary people can still build a future in Canada.\n\nWhen will the Liberal government realize that central planning is, as always, a recipe for disaster?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035391","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, 11 years ago, people invested in our community because they believed in the future. Families moved there. Builders built there. Small businesses took risks there, but now developers are facing insolvency. Businesses are being extorted. Families are worried about crime and people are starting to wonder if the rules even make sense anymore.\n\nAfter years of mixed signals from the Liberal","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18cfb8f611114fdca45a0939fdd5f680b8b16c914af3d6a1bf916cae7eb6f6d9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["74a2a4f7e1448dc639ced57e37be9cf8512f193285fa50630f6552de714c81b3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de3f790e1d6a62782303b959","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035392,"date":"2026-05-25T22:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada now has some of the highest household debt and least affordable housing in the G7. Food bank use is at a record high. Seniors are skipping meals. Young families are delaying having children. Working parents are choosing between groceries, rent and medication. However, I have heard the Liberals say over and over today that they are improving affordability and that Canada's economy is doing great. \n\nMy question is simple. If life is supposedly getting better, why are so many Canadians feeling like they are falling further behind every single month?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035392","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada now has some of the highest household debt and least affordable housing in the G7. Food bank use is at a record high. Seniors are skipping meals. Young families are delaying having children. Working parents are choosing between groceries, rent and medication. However, I have heard the Liberals say over and over today that they are improving affordability and that Canada's econo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["51bb5a3ce62ac027449de5d9a04a1a8209053972fb9fb07c1ce2c71f468c5358"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["398192c12ae87bc92db551dbbe917d3e1cded57651026b2e483307b8de6f8788"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4b7b85e2bf5f0bc0daa01a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035393,"date":"2026-05-25T23:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, families across Canada know that, when their interest payments start eating up their household budget, something is seriously wrong. That is exactly what is happening with the Liberal government. Debt interest costs have now exploded to $59 billion a year, up 10% in just one year alone. Canadians are now paying more in interest than the federal government sends to provinces for health care. In fact, debt interest now costs more than the GST brings in. \n\nMembers can think about it. Canadians pay taxes and struggle to afford groceries and rent. More and more of that money is simply going toward interest payments instead of the services people need. Is it fair that the Liberals are forcing Canadians to pay thousands of dollars per family just to keep up with the interest on their own reckless spending?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035393","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, families across Canada know that, when their interest payments start eating up their household budget, something is seriously wrong. That is exactly what is happening with the Liberal government. Debt interest costs have now exploded to $59 billion a year, up 10% in just one year alone. Canadians are now paying more in interest than the federal government sends to provinces for health","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","label":"Interest rates","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7653613a2c97ad314906a433c76fa5c9642dd1d736c51b2a86c007440dbbb955"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9a66bc848c0af714e4e5dc36cf3fa2591b712e9a9f6195e39b7646b50bd7d6a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a95c2aa53b8c1caea2be3f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035394,"date":"2026-05-26T00:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada's housing market today looks a lot like a young man driving a road racer down an icy highway in the middle of winter. The engine roars, the tires grip and the driver thinks he is in control and so he presses harder on the gas. Imagine a souped-up, five-litre Mustang with more horsepower than common sense. The speed builds, but suddenly the tires lose traction. The steering becomes unstable, and the vehicle starts sliding. A smart driver would ease off carefully and regain control but, just like a reckless teenager, the Liberal government does not believe in restraint. It believes Ottawa can control markets better than Canadians themselves, and that arrogance is exactly what has driven Canada's housing market into the ditch. \n\nFirst, the Liberals went full throttle on immigration and population growth without building the homes, infrastructure, roads, utilities or skilled labour force needed to support it. Canada added well over one million new residents in a single year, one of the fastest population growth rates in the developed world. The Liberal government drove demand through the roof while supply was trapped behind taxes, red tape, permitting delays and development charges, forcing prices to explode. Young families were suddenly bidding against impossible demand. Rents soared and house prices spiralled. Ordinary Canadians who worked hard and played by the rules found themselves locked out of home ownership altogether. \n\nThe Liberals treated the housing market like a driver flooring a powerful car on black ice and then acted surprised when the whole thing started fishtailing. Then, after overheating the market, the Liberals pulled the emergency brake, cutting immigration and locking us in a dangerous skid. At the peak, they brought one million international students into the country and then abruptly, this year, came to a screeching halt of less than half. However, when a car is already sliding, hitting the brakes too hard does not restore control; it sends the whole vehicle spinning. Adding to that chaos, the Liberals' so-called build Canada approach threw billions of dollars at the catastrophic crash site.\n\n Once again, the Liberals believed they could centrally plan the economy from the top down. They encouraged prefab factories and construction suppliers to tool up for enormous future projects that have not materialized. Billions were announced, bureaucracies expanded, but uncertainty exploded. Development costs climbed even higher. Builders were crushed between rising interest rates, government interference, expensive regulations and constantly changing rules. Instead of stabilizing housing, Liberal central planning created even greater instability.\n\nNow, we are seeing the devastating consequences. Across the Fraser Valley, we have warning lights flashing everywhere. Thind Properties, Maskeen Group, Brivia Group, Coromandel Properties, Square Nine Developments, 14 Property Group, Wade Development, and Everest Group are struggling with receiverships, insolvencies, foreclosures, creditor protection, stalled projects, laid-off workers and families left wondering whether the homes they paid for will ever even be built. This is what happens when government distorts markets long enough that confidence itself begins to collapse. \n\nConservatives believe in a common-sense approach. We believe that the people who know how to build homes are builders, not politicians. We believe government should stop choking developments with taxes, delays, gatekeepers and ideological central planning. We believe in getting government out of the way so the private sector can do what it does best: build. Canadians do not need more politicians grabbing the steering wheel. They need a government with enough wisdom to finally let the country get back on track.\n\n Will the Liberal government admit that its housing policies are the reason Canadians cannot afford a home?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035394","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada's housing market today looks a lot like a young man driving a road racer down an icy highway in the middle of winter. The engine roars, the tires grip and the driver thinks he is in control and so he presses harder on the gas. Imagine a souped-up, five-litre Mustang with more horsepower than common sense. The speed builds, but suddenly the tires lose traction. The steering beco","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["22d582e3d6656c93727814bff916b2bab866a779b65008a82d73ce9a201149c5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["57ce01125ded014a83fb731e50e4edbbf68a6a07e10efaf657ebd34221eef837"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf7728d62edded5b34db4bb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035395,"date":"2026-05-26T00:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what we are witnessing now is the consequence of years of Liberal market distortion through subsidies, red tape and unpredictable government policy. The Liberals overheated the housing market with record immigration levels and developers responded by investing billions, hiring workers and putting shovels in the ground based on the conditions the government created. Then Ottawa suddenly slammed on the brakes. After years of overheating demand, the Liberals abruptly reversed course without a plan, leaving developers watching the market shift beneath projects already under way as rental vacancy rates jumped more than 40% year over year. \n\nHousing projects take years to plan and build. The government cannot pull one policy lever to flood the market and then yank another to choke off demand and expect builders, renters or buyers to have any stability. This is a failure of central planning. The Liberals created this distortion and now Canadians are paying the price.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035395","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what we are witnessing now is the consequence of years of Liberal market distortion through subsidies, red tape and unpredictable government policy. The Liberals overheated the housing market with record immigration levels and developers responded by investing billions, hiring workers and putting shovels in the ground based on the conditions the government created. Then Ottawa suddenl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f713df9dbf32734c3440c7d5587f67b666b78e2f6333581bcc897a6d8602c40f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d2cba106151f7484394ee37e460df6dd5603fcf0412667b6875ad030b35a9dc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7c8755bf69bb076a3cd2077","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035381,"date":"2026-05-26T15:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in the 1970s, during Britain's energy crisis, there was a saying that the government treats taxpayers like lemons; that every time it needs more money, it just squeezes harder. That is exactly how Canadians feel today every time they pull up to the gas pump. Whether someone is a mom driving their kids to hockey in Cloverdale, a tradesman in Langley filling up his truck before work or a senior cutting back on groceries because of gas prices, they all watch the numbers spin higher and higher while government quietly takes a bigger cut every second that dial moves.\n\nIf government revenue rises every time gas prices rise, what incentives do the Liberals actually have to bring that cost down? That is the uncomfortable truth at the centre of this debate. Every time families pull up to the pump and watch those numbers climb higher, Ottawa is standing right there with its hand out. There is the GST, the industrial carbon tax and the clean fuel standard, all stacked one on top of the other on every litre we buy. As Canadians watch those numbers click frighteningly higher, government revenues rise automatically.\n\nAfter months of soaring prices and dogged pressure by the Conservatives, the Liberals finally arrived with a tiny, temporary tax break. They presented it as though they performed some great act of economic heroism. In reality, their plan delivers barely one-third of the relief for barely one-third of the year, compared to what Conservatives had proposed. The Liberals want Canadians to believe that the cupboard is bare, that this is the absolute limit of what government can do, when in fact they can remove all federal taxes on gas and diesel tomorrow morning and give some real and actual relief to Canadians.\n\nHowever, that would require government to give up revenue and modern Liberals have become far too comfortable spending other people's money. Instead of real relief, Canadians are handed a carefully staged announcement designed to generate headlines, applause in Ottawa and just enough temporary relief to dull public anger while families continue struggling under the weight of higher energy costs. Meanwhile, the single mother driving to work, the tradesman filling up his truck, and the senior choosing between groceries and fuel are expected to celebrate crumbs while government continues feasting on the loaf.\n\nThat is why Conservatives brought forward this motion to remove all federal taxes on gas and diesel for the rest of the year and permanently scrap the costly clean fuel standard so Canadians can finally get some relief.\n\n Milton Friedman once joked that if government were put in charge of the Sahara Desert, there would be a shortage of sand within five years. We laugh because we understand the deeper truth behind it, which is that governments interfere too heavily in markets, pile on taxes, add layers of bureaucracy and try to centrally plan the economy from Ottawa boardrooms. The people who can least afford it will eventually pay the price. That is exactly what has happened in Canada.\n\nLet us think about it. Back in 2014, oil prices were sitting at roughly the same level they are today, around $100 a barrel, yet Canadians were paying about $1.37 a litre. Today, that same litre costs closer to $1.87. That is roughly 50¢ more per litre, even though the global oil price is essentially the same. What has changed? Liberal taxes have changed, of course.\n\nOver the last decade, Canadians have been buried under a growing pile of federal costs layered onto energy. This includes the industrial carbon tax, the clean fuel standard and the GST charge on top of the entire inflated amount. We have tax upon tax upon tax, all justified by politicians who never seem to notice that working people still have to drive to work, farmers still have to harvest their crops and families still have to get their kids to school.\n\nHere is the part Canadians are beginning to understand very clearly: Every time gas prices rise, government revenues rise as well. Ottawa profits from expensive energy, while ordinary Canadians are punished by it. That is why the finance minister's comments were astonishingly tone-deaf when he claimed that the Liberals had acted faster and more comprehensively than peer countries.\n\nCanadians are not looking for a trophy in international political theatre. They are looking at their bank accounts, they are looking at their grocery bills, they are looking at the cost of filling up the family vehicle and wondering how much further they can stretch a paycheque that already feels exhausted before it even arrives. Meanwhile, countries around the world cut fuel taxes to help their citizens weather rising costs.\n\nConservatives proposed removing all federal taxes on gas and diesel for the rest of the year to save families roughly 25¢ a litre, or about $1,200 for a family of four. The Liberals' response was to offer barely one-third of the relief for barely one-third of the year, and then they presented it as though they had moved mountains on behalf of struggling Canadians. \n\nMargaret Thatcher understood something modern Liberals never seem to grasp: When governments make energy expensive, they make everything expensive. Energy is not a luxury item. Energy moves food across the country. Energy powers tractors, delivery trucks, ambulances, factories, school buses and construction equipment. When energy costs rise, the cost of absolutely everything rises with it. \n\nCanadians are already at the breaking point. Nearly three-quarters of Canadians say that rising food and gas prices are straining their finances. More than four in 10 Canadians are less than $200 away from not being able to pay their bills. Members can think about that. The cost of one unexpected repair bill, one extra grocery trip or one tank of gas is how close to the edge millions of Canadians are living after a decade of Liberal credit card budgets, inflationary deficits and economic mismanagement. While ordinary Canadians cut back, governments keep spending like there is no tomorrow. \n\nThe truckers delivering groceries pay more for fuel. The farmers harvesting crops pay more for fuel. The manufacturers shipping goods pay more for fuel. Every added cost lands on the kitchen tables of ordinary Canadian families. That is the real-world consequence of expensive energy. This is not a theoretical economics discussion over a catered lunch in Ottawa. These are real families making painful decisions every single day.\n\n The government acts as though lowering fuel taxes would somehow break the economy. When Conservatives are calling for these tax breaks, we were not proposing another complicated subsidy program with more paperwork, more bureaucracy and more consultants billing taxpayers by the hour. We are simply saying that the government should stop taking so much money from Canadians in the first place and let them keep more of what they earn. That is the simplest form of relief possible. \n\nThe government's job is not to stand at the gas pump with its hand out every time Canadians try to get to work. The Parliamentary Budget Officer said that the Liberals' temporary plan would only save the average household about $124 total. Canadians cannot run a family budget on symbolic gestures. Conservatives are proposing relief that would actually have impact. The Liberals simply do not want to give up the revenue. \n\nAt the heart of this debate lies a very simple question: Who should keep that money? Should it remain in the pockets of the men and women who rise early, work long hours, drive trucks, build the homes, harvest the crops and keep this country moving, or should more of it flow to Ottawa, where the government has developed an endless appetite for spending but remarkably little interest in restraint? \n\nConservatives believe Canadians have already paid enough. After a decade of Liberal deficits and taxes, families are not asking for luxuries. They are asking for breathing room. They want to drive to work without feeling punished every time they fill their tanks. They want to walk through the grocery store without calculating what necessities must be left at the checkout counter. Whenever Canadians raise these concerns, they are told by the Liberals that they have already acted, that the economy is doing great and that it is one of the best economies in the G7. Somehow the answer to rising costs is always more bureaucracy, more intervention and more taxes collected from the people who are already struggling to stay afloat. \n\nThe House has a choice to make. We can continue down the Liberal path, where expensive energy is treated as a political virtue, where taxes quietly rise every time families fill their tanks and where government grows larger while ordinary Canadians grow poorer, or we can return to the simple principle that built strong economies in the first place, which is that working people are better stewards of their own money than government will ever be.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035381","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in the 1970s, during Britain's energy crisis, there was a saying that the government treats taxpayers like lemons; that every time it needs more money, it just squeezes harder. That is exactly how Canadians feel today every time they pull up to the gas pump. Whether someone is a mom driving their kids to hockey in Cloverdale, a tradesman in Langley filling up his truck before work or ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["63826a23208dfa3c09440837258f00ce3479a73ecdbc92619867dec128b8e9d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5a49326454459ebba01c49d8afa790f26b4367d800f8d09340268f4516f912eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ca22dad79dc5bf9f9fbd7d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035382,"date":"2026-05-26T15:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this ultimately comes down to priorities. The government has become far too comfortable with collecting more money every time gas prices rise while pretending that higher costs are somehow beyond their control.\n\n However, Canadians do not have the luxury of pretending. They feel these costs every day when they buy groceries, commute to work, heat their homes or run a small business. Despite all the speeches and headlines, the Liberals are still refusing to take the simple steps that would provide immediate relief, which would be to remove all federal taxes on gas and diesel and to scrap the costly clean fuel standard.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035382","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this ultimately comes down to priorities. The government has become far too comfortable with collecting more money every time gas prices rise while pretending that higher costs are somehow beyond their control.\n\n However, Canadians do not have the luxury of pretending. They feel these costs every day when they buy groceries, commute to work, heat their homes or run a small business. D","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4275535c790fd523c7f252e59e201d5063c0ea6a4e787207f57ad1eb01c99e47"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52dfe9e13844b2ea253004d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035385,"date":"2026-05-26T15:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I heard the very same things in my riding. I also heard that, at the end of the day, Canadians are looking for common sense, not political theatre.\n\n The Liberals have created a system where rising gas prices benefit government revenues because every increase at the pump means more tax revenue flowing to Ottawa. Meanwhile, ordinary Canadians absorb the consequences as higher fuel costs ripple through the entire economy, making food, transportation and everyday life more expensive. There is nothing stopping the government from delivering meaningful relief except its own unwillingness to give up the revenue.\n\n Canadians deserve more than symbolic gestures and temporary announcements.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035385","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I heard the very same things in my riding. I also heard that, at the end of the day, Canadians are looking for common sense, not political theatre.\n\n The Liberals have created a system where rising gas prices benefit government revenues because every increase at the pump means more tax revenue flowing to Ottawa. Meanwhile, ordinary Canadians absorb the consequences as higher fuel cost","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff1d510d67bcbd1ec0c30b5a160fb15389c64808b274314f2ad0623c3759b0a6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a0b86a844f1aba94151a4434f872000013db13cec4fa541702db0817bd87b71"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75c7407881d385b7b1abc101","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035388,"date":"2026-05-26T15:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the point is that the government acted too little, too late and only temporarily.\n\n The Liberal plan provides a fraction of the relief that Canadians need, and it is for only part of the year, while the other federal costs remain layered on energy. Even according to the Parliamentary Budget Officer, the average household will only save $124. That may help a little, but it is not serious relief for families facing high gas, grocery, rent and mortgage costs. Canadians need meaningful savings at the pump, not a temporary announcement designed to make the government look like it solved the problem.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035388","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the point is that the government acted too little, too late and only temporarily.\n\n The Liberal plan provides a fraction of the relief that Canadians need, and it is for only part of the year, while the other federal costs remain layered on energy. Even according to the Parliamentary Budget Officer, the average household will only save $124. That may help a little, but it is not serio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b9d25cb7f754ca97bb2712d2957d3a8dcb1326a757218346a771680fa3b689d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb721b86f59d747687bb6799b03c90541c545b177d324832f1fbd113bee77f08"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8200a91da1ff818f45e21581","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035389,"date":"2026-05-26T20:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, economists and business voices across the country are warning that, when people no longer trust the rules around property ownership, investment disappears, housing slows down and affordability gets worse. We are now seeing stalled projects, bankrupt developers and fewer homes being built while young Canadians lose hope of ownership, but the Liberal government calls that fearmongering. Instead of admitting there is a huge problem, they keep acting like everything is just okey-dokey.\n\n Did the Liberals vote down our Conservative motion to protect property rights yesterday because they are completely blind to this very real problem?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035389","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, economists and business voices across the country are warning that, when people no longer trust the rules around property ownership, investment disappears, housing slows down and affordability gets worse. We are now seeing stalled projects, bankrupt developers and fewer homes being built while young Canadians lose hope of ownership, but the Liberal government calls that fearmongering.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3f2295f96e92098d88b257eb73531768a8def3cd9d149549f31ef0d74d0172e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dc49fbba23b0381e28f8698446feba69d214522279c6840a83df0ce275e49433"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-810d4323669d3160e99a0fc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115476,"date":"2026-05-26T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What is your department's definition of \"Canadian\" under this buy Canadian policy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115476","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What is your department's definition of \"Canadian\" under this buy Canadian policy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b95470bfd87642d19cd3c177d2264945f1b1ecb8673c6d2e1f71f0297fc53fb5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fd9c348422bc57fcfd9a330","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115477,"date":"2026-05-26T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. I'm sorry; I have lots of questions. Does the policy require a Canadian head office, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115477","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I'm sorry; I have lots of questions. Does the policy require a Canadian head office, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["423511a9e06abcce0d87e39ae3b7e57e0ac28b3af6ab4b6cac8cf1e467a58d2e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b2f35705e4083dd3b374047","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115478,"date":"2026-05-26T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Could a company that has a Canadian office or post office box but that operates primarily outside of Canada count as Canadian, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115478","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Could a company that has a Canadian office or post office box but that operates primarily outside of Canada count as Canadian, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","label":"Indigenous businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5bfed3e70bc033fad985dfff9bc56aaa38cf63aa8c6d0882200980c57c62f018"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9133ff9e1ecd4bd77c129c40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115479,"date":"2026-05-26T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Could a company that's 100% foreign-owned still qualify as Canadian?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115479","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Could a company that's 100% foreign-owned still qualify as Canadian?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b8384bce6961e91884c24953fcbce6b42a0ad7474d33c8874fc581bea42d14f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32d7a61ad5f22303c9f7d4a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115480,"date":"2026-05-26T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Could a foreign company create a Canadian subsidiary and qualify as Canadian?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115480","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Could a foreign company create a Canadian subsidiary and qualify as Canadian?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1599e5b321e12b34a0e86707518e3d035cd77532cff184f90fe2f3fe78e2398e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66f96ac3493ff49c3f64e045","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115481,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. If a company from a country without a trade agreement with Canada establishes a Canadian subsidiary, registers and files taxes here, maintains a Canadian address and conducts day-to-day business here, could it qualify as a Canadian supplier?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115481","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. If a company from a country without a trade agreement with Canada establishes a Canadian subsidiary, registers and files taxes here, maintains a Canadian address and conducts day-to-day business here, could it qualify as a Canadian supplier?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","label":"Indigenous businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c2671a78d2de0280187b767265a850f1645209fc60ce6bb24e2d838468613438"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5860c4f7c7ccccb160c21b4f9a9952d4bf21f6bd52c9439cde88ef91b5a835a0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9388963473e479d6148acc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115482,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Does PSPC distinguish between Canadian-owned companies and foreign-owned companies operating in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115482","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does PSPC distinguish between Canadian-owned companies and foreign-owned companies operating in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["526937d7f4f414c1b26169259d87c52bf4103c27c4d7e384edcbc8bcf167596a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a24625cd7ef2a6fb0920fb83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115483,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Is that a yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115483","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is that a yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-325421128a20c2a1b4996684","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115484,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Does your department track how many procurements go to foreign-owned firms qualifying as Canadian?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115484","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does your department track how many procurements go to foreign-owned firms qualifying as Canadian?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["046913c11ef86be23d3afcd62bf2c13b7a53073fa72b775dca6177aa71b38f2e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09e09ae4bb83d545c20c4c4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115485,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"When the policy refers to Canadian services or Canadian labour, does that mean labour performed by Canadian citizens and permanent residents or simply work performed by individuals based in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115485","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"When the policy refers to Canadian services or Canadian labour, does that mean labour performed by Canadian citizens and permanent residents or simply work performed by individuals based in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["609f84c1353541c2ca8730611bc2b8ac25fb0a73d865f0c709c0fb4f86293937"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8eed8bd8ab27c828c071b26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115486,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Temporary foreign workers...it includes them, then.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115486","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Temporary foreign workers...it includes them, then.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-631096cf41e0bf4a3b04e0d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115487,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How does PSPC verify where the work is performed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115487","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How does PSPC verify where the work is performed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c72077b86771e381647ac659de4923b3db4cd56c7a0a7291c766a238d988f515"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b1762e9abe13763682c3613f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115488,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Does the policy apply only to the prime contractor?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115488","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does the policy apply only to the prime contractor?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["83855c949736bd5bddebaacefcb14d67d4741978c5fe88ef8fcebf416f2c31aa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67923acfff3e09b41b796e41","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115489,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Your policy will apply to subcontractors as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115489","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Your policy will apply to subcontractors as well.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-357faeaa2a4c6edc50006dc8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115490,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How many levels down the subcontracting chain does it apply?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115490","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How many levels down the subcontracting chain does it apply?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034790","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Decontamination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034790","label":"Decontamination","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["750ff434dd9ca4c5ef98f44af551a18a5eeecefc4b5e2eb2a6bb206b5a957dcd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf89663c616dbf5910f147e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115491,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What percentage of value-added work can be subcontracted outside of Canada before a supplier no longer qualifies as Canadian?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115491","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What percentage of value-added work can be subcontracted outside of Canada before a supplier no longer qualifies as Canadian?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2718e41cac71f36b0acdd84528399e605578551581c4eedaf4adf107a3cd56ae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-859dd3c7003dc7ea8857dc10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115492,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. Has—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115492","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Has—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9205a8086e068458b6aff526","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115493,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I have another question. I'm sorry. Has PSPC defined the threshold in writing for what we were just talking about?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115493","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have another question. I'm sorry. Has PSPC defined the threshold in writing for what we were just talking about?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e476f9a9962c0a5fb7e5ba6d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115494,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Is it in writing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115494","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is it in writing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47b932905ba85ebf57c9a105","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115495,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"It's in writing, then. We could find that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115495","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's in writing, then. We could find that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da66b2eb408558a8d1e3d7cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115496,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"If you can hand that in, that would be great. That would be wonderful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115496","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If you can hand that in, that would be great. That would be wonderful.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64b3197fd8c7c12f5c0fde3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115497,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Who verifies subcontractor compliance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115497","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Who verifies subcontractor compliance?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-108e3c73431705b512c82e25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115498,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How many resources will it take to properly monitor compliance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115498","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How many resources will it take to properly monitor compliance?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["837cb0400cf158194cc3b096e58e9971967d5c585dcd5879db7835ee8085ff78"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcd297f8358ad35e67bd4e4d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115499,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. In any procurement so far, has the government paid more in order to meet buy Canadian requirements?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115499","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. In any procurement so far, has the government paid more in order to meet buy Canadian requirements?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f826884c06fa954d67bdde9b16a4fb1b329fc9a16ac79f76f3d82a658cbea74"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe0c9a268a4014d89e03b162","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115500,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Has PSPC calculated the average cost premium associated with applying this policy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115500","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Has PSPC calculated the average cost premium associated with applying this policy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06001498bf0f17111e9f143716a6aaf3f5c90bd1dcb348c8f818a22126c5bf8b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-339b122e61bf09acdec0ef1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115501,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Do you have a formal audit framework for buy Canadian compliance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115501","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do you have a formal audit framework for buy Canadian compliance?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Internal audits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","label":"Internal audits","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80da464a30334f7ed6d723d5975295a3c48a1bb8c23e52ba256505a16b1a1545"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a8eafe4504ff92300816ec4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115502,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"However, a lot of it is self-attestation. That's what I understood from your answers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115502","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"However, a lot of it is self-attestation. That's what I understood from your answers.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9e9c10c8445b65e3c8daf0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115503,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Will audits be random or risk-based?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115503","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Will audits be random or risk-based?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b3cc330e307a1f834e8499a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115504,"date":"2026-05-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Will they rotate between—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115504","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Will they rotate between—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6a5860025bf6e401a4c0c9e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115505,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Is there a single government-wide definition of \"buy Canadian\"?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115505","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is there a single government-wide definition of \"buy Canadian\"?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privatization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","label":"Privatization","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["070c0845a3aec11256d86859b4ba1472ab35dc2777eb39b86fb10b8fbf9150ee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62f82505d94fdd955270e8ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115506,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"There's no single government-wide definition, then. Okay. I guess I can't ask my next one. Are there federal Crown corporations that are currently exempt from the buy Canadian policy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115506","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There's no single government-wide definition, then. Okay. I guess I can't ask my next one. Are there federal Crown corporations that are currently exempt from the buy Canadian policy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["337ead0aff434378056430157383e9dcf61d0a1e9c6ad9bd127ba08eb69b5d51"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4661dd4ab878021c4c5949bf9dd9b044c3de2eb7be3415627ee5a46cd20d99b8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e426d05c00489c9245d858e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115507,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"That was a yes, then, to that other question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115507","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That was a yes, then, to that other question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f00ee1a16b00cd815ad4764","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115508,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Does the buy Canadian policy apply to procurement conducted outside Canada by federal organizations, or is foreign-based procurement excluded as an exception?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115508","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does the buy Canadian policy apply to procurement conducted outside Canada by federal organizations, or is foreign-based procurement excluded as an exception?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","label":"Imports","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c8b25875d30144f5a02fe66a964953600f34021461153a3f16d0f8e9138dee89"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b8cbb1555581d4c113d9143","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115509,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Have any federal entities formally requested exemption?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115509","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Have any federal entities formally requested exemption?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-630fb371a41ed1f1bb4787d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115510,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You don't know how many exemptions have been granted so far.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115510","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You don't know how many exemptions have been granted so far.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warranties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warranties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Warranties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth certificates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Birth certificates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","label":"Birth certificates","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207491","label":"Warranties","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06ce5756ed73bba0124c08560250e8c0610eb03bc5eefa8efb2141c6ca65f3e2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95ea9ac168135f76666a3551","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115511,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Are exemptions publicly reported?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115511","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Are exemptions publicly reported?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c39ea148ddaa0469c43d137","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115512,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You mentioned that this policy extends to grants, contributions, loans, infrastructure spending and Crown corps. Has Treasury Board fully implemented those requirements government-wide?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115512","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You mentioned that this policy extends to grants, contributions, loans, infrastructure spending and Crown corps. Has Treasury Board fully implemented those requirements government-wide?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["156d1e86e71615957ec2ef7f5c95395d80cd274f11bf625cc9f2663865ce909e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0077a8389b204e00d0eda137","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115513,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. If not, which funding streams are still excluded?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115513","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. If not, which funding streams are still excluded?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62a13d4c17b735ffa86d597f6dc536ec2749cc4dd977b08a4fae3eb7560663c4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0af55d48331d820e1b7a516b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115514,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Has the directive on transfer payments been amended to reflect buy Canadian requirements?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115514","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Has the directive on transfer payments been amended to reflect buy Canadian requirements?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["997d1d1a1d147360eec7e8878bd195dba4afcd33b941c513a1f4b6e193018475"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a8cdbe4ec99e1e8d619a636","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115515,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. Are departments currently operating under interim guidance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115515","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Are departments currently operating under interim guidance?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ed12fbf9faed7b2bba29485","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115516,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Has Treasury Board identified areas in which the policy cannot realistically be enforced?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115516","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Has Treasury Board identified areas in which the policy cannot realistically be enforced?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7533886dd812add2efcd157d5c01137450b7e33fbe19cbb90b9df11a4f161418"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4bd9c40b542c9ea9c3db3373","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115517,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Are there programs for which buy Canadian is voluntary rather than mandatory?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115517","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Are there programs for which buy Canadian is voluntary rather than mandatory?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cbfdecff5c5f8f99bd9d15b9f63925189dd510c85db81c1c384ca2d2e6c4b51b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-426bfc05fbbc7ebca0d9927a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115518,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"When will departments be fully compliant?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115518","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"When will departments be fully compliant?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d271639ce2b02fe7ad71dad8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115519,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Sure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115519","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Sure.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07ee795d312bb123dd929cf5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115520,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"When will all Crown corps be fully compliant?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115520","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"When will all Crown corps be fully compliant?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84be614c71cc89d9c13dba89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115521,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. If a supplier believes a competitor falsely claimed Canadian content, is there a formal challenge process?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115521","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. If a supplier believes a competitor falsely claimed Canadian content, is there a formal challenge process?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","label":"Forgery","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","label":"Imports","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c7d6bb57be6f19ce4ab5b44538da0e9d601f5263749e396ea446c104481a014"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e78b2da915082b7776e88d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115522,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Will audit findings be made public?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115522","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Will audit findings be made public?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45a665548f22806c4b9a86e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115523,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Since, in the main estimates, we see billions in housing-related spending, I just want to focus on the report you did on buy Canada. My first question is this: Given that CMHC already existed, with the myriad other housing financing powers and so forth, did the government need to create Build Canada Homes at all?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115523","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Since, in the main estimates, we see billions in housing-related spending, I just want to focus on the report you did on buy Canada. My first question is this: Given that CMHC already existed, with the myriad other housing financing powers and so forth, did the government need to create Build Canada Homes at all?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["14d481f4044e9bdd342ef00e69ccb866043a6b71c81f71c5059470edc8d96645"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da4000e0e31d3e8cda0fbe3e86d6de2f6cb603161441d97e9ea99781057586a2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca0dd508bca4e3bfed8a6d08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115524,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm just looking for a quick yes or no. You're saying you're going to look into it. That's what I understand.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115524","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm just looking for a quick yes or no. You're saying you're going to look into it. That's what I understand.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-782e740c5cc3ee037f5a9e91","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115525,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay, so my next question is, basically, has the government demonstrated that Build Canada Homes will deliver housing faster than what CMHC was already capable of delivering?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115525","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay, so my next question is, basically, has the government demonstrated that Build Canada Homes will deliver housing faster than what CMHC was already capable of delivering?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b41c56c854e827027fbdad1b8c60aca041a5fa226116b87cb2dac9702014d59e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3edf253ea0a76730743b217f36d20e8a563c87bd6d7a310eb546ec7595d21f03"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1a8399c69ebdf640a5f332a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115526,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. I'm sorry. It's just because I have super short.... I was hoping that you had a quick answer. You're saying affordable goes to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115526","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. I'm sorry. It's just because I have super short.... I was hoping that you had a quick answer. You're saying affordable goes to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-226d0005ac36e757ba59a96b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115527,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. Last night, Liberal MP Leslie Church stood in the House and said: We are building big, we are building bold, and we are building now. We are building at a scale not seen in this country since the end of the Second World War. We are building 500,000 homes.... My question is this: If Build Canada Homes is expected to add only 26,000 units over five years, does that fall short of the government's public promises, and do those numbers align with the member 's assertion from last night?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115527","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Last night, Liberal MP Leslie Church stood in the House and said: We are building big, we are building bold, and we are building now. We are building at a scale not seen in this country since the end of the Second World War. We are building 500,000 homes.... My question is this: If Build Canada Homes is expected to add only 26,000 units over five years, does that fall short of the government","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b813e4bdbd7d7fb3eed2172d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115528,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Do you mean 26,000?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115528","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do you mean 26,000?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4c7b53d1454dd590b564741","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115529,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm more just asking whether the number the member stated and the number we're seeing align. They don't appear to align to me.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115529","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm more just asking whether the number the member stated and the number we're seeing align. They don't appear to align to me.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44354f806d7ec634811e1b6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115530,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. Since Build Canada Homes was announced, and this government supposedly began building \"big\" and \"bold\", as we heard last night, have national housing starts improved or weakened?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115530","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Since Build Canada Homes was announced, and this government supposedly began building \"big\" and \"bold\", as we heard last night, have national housing starts improved or weakened?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["240ee17b0bbe8fca3c72dd6a71792e1f86fd112cfbfffe4cb9ead6724dc33132"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71920070f71c461b28b75b07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115531,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. Is Parliament currently being given a clear breakdown showing how much Build Canada Homes will spend on admin versus actual housing construction, yes or no? Have we been given a number?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115531","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Is Parliament currently being given a clear breakdown showing how much Build Canada Homes will spend on admin versus actual housing construction, yes or no? Have we been given a number?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b34e2ac087331cec190539a775b6d904b1d03c22d103ef3572e537a88a2ece7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-816136a4707ca8bab73716f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115532,"date":"2026-05-28T16:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. Can Parliament currently determine the projected cost per housing unit under Build Canada Homes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115532","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Can Parliament currently determine the projected cost per housing unit under Build Canada Homes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9649b22738bd8bfaaa922f445526d49141d3337998cba3c2e4a7d6f3cc2fbd57"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f04f4ca63480483a510acf1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115533,"date":"2026-05-28T16:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"This is what I have here. If Parliament doesn't have a clean dollars-to-doors breakdown of the $13-billion project, and housing starts are drastically falling across the country, could we say this program isn't performing as promised?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115533","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This is what I have here. If Parliament doesn't have a clean dollars-to-doors breakdown of the $13-billion project, and housing starts are drastically falling across the country, could we say this program isn't performing as promised?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["42610d571aebf8588a620c8d761f34699ed06e9fef286b83c3521641b9de2c6c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["10ae807317ee7d4d09a9185c4c1c32c2aea73383a022117d85dc23d06d2f6cdc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-055d400efe504ccce248e9ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115534,"date":"2026-05-28T16:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm sorry. I have a very short time. If housing starts are weakening while federal housing bureaucracy expands, should Parliament question whether the current approach is working? I think that's what you were speaking to. Should we question it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115534","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry. I have a very short time. If housing starts are weakening while federal housing bureaucracy expands, should Parliament question whether the current approach is working? I think that's what you were speaking to. Should we question it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3cc946939fbc82773941a9cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115535,"date":"2026-05-28T16:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Would it be fair to say Canadians were promised a housing construction boom, but Parliament is currently being asked to approve billions of dollars without clear evidence that those targets will actually be met—or should be met?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115535","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Would it be fair to say Canadians were promised a housing construction boom, but Parliament is currently being asked to approve billions of dollars without clear evidence that those targets will actually be met—or should be met?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["632e8964a2f229c857cbfab87d0699b8b2818befee690852a2e9c71b7dee3512"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8eeabb4ad09391d68121c02","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115536,"date":"2026-05-28T16:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I have just one more question. Should Parliament expect clear performance metrics tied to housing completions before approving large increases in housing-related spending?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115536","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have just one more question. Should Parliament expect clear performance metrics tied to housing completions before approving large increases in housing-related spending?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036797","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036797","label":"Public architecture","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f1587dd3bbacbedca66f9adff3d9473fbad12f816955d2e58a60cd7496a5021a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a98d4a69a056d2176f9e2af7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115537,"date":"2026-05-28T16:25:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"At what point does—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115537","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"At what point does—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e83278ee16afe36c42c57ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084010,"date":"2026-06-01T17:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, Canada is the only G7 country that is in a recession. More than 112,000 Canadians have lost their job in just a few months. Food banks are reaching record levels of usage. Families are struggling to pay their mortgage, their rent and even their grocery bill.\n\nAt a time like this, Canadians would expect members of Parliament to be debating solutions. They would expect their elected representatives to be examining every line of this massive omnibus bill and asking hard questions about it. Instead, the Liberals have decided to shut down debate after only three hours of debate on billions of dollars. If the government's plan is working, why are Canadians falling behind, and if the government is so confident in its plan, why is it so afraid of letting Parliament debate it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084010","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, Canada is the only G7 country that is in a recession. More than 112,000 Canadians have lost their job in just a few months. Food banks are reaching record levels of usage. Families are struggling to pay their mortgage, their rent and even their grocery bill.\n\nAt a time like this, Canadians would expect members of Parliament to be debating solutions. They would expect their elected r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4208a36c775eaea03636dd6a68043db2f14d8fa156a57829565c8fb2b0f06ebd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02ab6364457e4f3e79303a36","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084011,"date":"2026-06-01T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, governments that are confident in their ideas welcome debate. Governments that are uncertain of their ideas shut it down. Canada is now the only G7 country in recession. Jobs are disappearing, investment is leaving and families are falling behind, yet instead of allowing Parliament to fully examine a budget that would affect every Canadian, the Liberals are once again shutting down debate. The government tells Canadians to trust its plan. Trust is earned through openness, accountability and debate, not by cutting debate short.\n\nWhy are the Liberals so determined to prevent Parliament from giving it the scrutiny Canadians deserve?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084011","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, governments that are confident in their ideas welcome debate. Governments that are uncertain of their ideas shut it down. Canada is now the only G7 country in recession. Jobs are disappearing, investment is leaving and families are falling behind, yet instead of allowing Parliament to fully examine a budget that would affect every Canadian, the Liberals are once again shutting down ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dbb1dcd963b70838ab5e1809037a4c5463907fb9b5478605c42b1d17575b08df"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ab4aaa8e89b1a37770789a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084012,"date":"2026-06-01T19:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is the only G7 country in a recession. People vote with their feet when they have no other way to vote, and investors vote with their dollars every single day. Right now they are voting against Canada. More than 112,000 jobs have disappeared in just three months. Behind every one of those jobs is a Canadian wondering how to pay the rent, buy groceries and keep the lights on.\n\n If the Liberals insist this is all because of global conditions, why is Canada the only G7 country in a recession? When will the Prime Minister admit that his policies have driven investment and jobs elsewhere?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084012","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is the only G7 country in a recession. People vote with their feet when they have no other way to vote, and investors vote with their dollars every single day. Right now they are voting against Canada. More than 112,000 jobs have disappeared in just three months. Behind every one of those jobs is a Canadian wondering how to pay the rent, buy groceries and keep the lights on.\n\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2d4f69ac6beb784bad8fe9ab4a57a3a0a0e2268425cc6589373d8f5735d19303"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7f17858c00b8619a2e8880f20cd2b6643dc018b3daecef2943a3e94048d43902"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76926b7744f8530afc06d5f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084013,"date":"2026-06-01T21:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is facing serious economic challenges. Jobs are disappearing, investment is leaving and families are struggling to make ends meet, yet the government has chosen to shut down debate on a massive omnibus budget bill that would affect every region in the country. \n\nI would like to ask my Bloc colleague this. Regardless of our differences on policy, does he believe Canadians are well served when the government limits debate on legislation of this size and importance? What message does it send when a government facing so many economic challenges seems unwilling to allow Parliament the time needed to properly examine its budget?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084013","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is facing serious economic challenges. Jobs are disappearing, investment is leaving and families are struggling to make ends meet, yet the government has chosen to shut down debate on a massive omnibus budget bill that would affect every region in the country. \n\nI would like to ask my Bloc colleague this. Regardless of our differences on policy, does he believe Canadians are we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f74f7fb7c6fca917fa4439451bc184813488db6a1a44155c4b77a78888aebe7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["836cdfaaa456f2f61602a916302ef7eb901140a72712aba52fd4a14de013a699"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-155549a0b5c878fb1709fdc6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084014,"date":"2026-06-01T23:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, every dollar spent on interest is a dollar that cannot be spent on the future. Canadians will pay more than $50 billion this year simply to pay the interest charges on federal debt. That money produces nothing. It creates no jobs, builds no infrastructure and improves no public services. \n\nCould my colleague share her thoughts on the long-term consequences of forcing Canadian families and future generations to carry the cost of today's reckless deficits?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084014","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, every dollar spent on interest is a dollar that cannot be spent on the future. Canadians will pay more than $50 billion this year simply to pay the interest charges on federal debt. That money produces nothing. It creates no jobs, builds no infrastructure and improves no public services. \n\nCould my colleague share her thoughts on the long-term consequences of forcing Canadian famili","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4bb9a9f548c4d917d96af4d5f861f86c73c25d44005352c473d29483e26386d9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a96ae25cea5aca0817d12b2190d2e887573ac49c36e2a57a6cc0dfa0e0b0da7a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9c2639ed2954863628085330","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084015,"date":"2026-06-01T23:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, one of a federal government's values is how it treats those who served our country. Veterans do not need more announcements. They need timely services, reliable benefits and access to the supports they have earned. \n\nWith this budget adding more debt and pushing interest costs above $50 billion a year, could my colleague explain how Canadians can have confidence that veterans will remain a priority when so much of the government's revenue is being consumed simply by paying interest on past spending?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084015","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, one of a federal government's values is how it treats those who served our country. Veterans do not need more announcements. They need timely services, reliable benefits and access to the supports they have earned. \n\nWith this budget adding more debt and pushing interest costs above $50 billion a year, could my colleague explain how Canadians can have confidence that veterans will r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5aeb50cf7b43b37e87d3956a805878cd878841e953489af8a156e566ccb30294"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["83bb51cee986174e8736089f44e850b53cf51678ad60fb4b7d5b328d63186261"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b77258ddce8bb8722f3d2eba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084016,"date":"2026-06-02T00:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, one of the great questions facing any nation is whether it trusts its people more than it trusts the government. That question lies at the heart of the economic challenges facing Canada today.\n\n For most of our history, Canada was a country where ordinary people could arrive with little more than a dollar in their pocket, work hard, take risks, build a business, buy a home, raise a family, and leave their children better off than themselves. It was not because government created prosperity. It was because government created the conditions in which prosperity could grow. New Canadians were allowed to freely create their own opportunities without too much government interference.\n\n Today, however, we see the consequence of a very different philosophy. We are told that every problem requires another government program, another regulation and another bureaucracy to oversee it all. Yet, after years of this Liberal central planning approach, Canadians are not becoming more prosperous. They are barely managing to get by. More than 112,000 jobs have disappeared in the first few months of this year. Youth unemployment has climbed above 14%. Business investment continues to flee the country, and household savings have been used up. Families are working harder while falling further behind. This is the disastrous result of a government that cannot keep its hands out of our pockets or their red tape out of our enterprises.\n\n The government seems determined to argue about whether Canada is in a technical recession. I wonder whether the Prime Minister would use that same ridiculous argument while standing beside a mother waiting in a food bank line, a young person sending out résumés with no response or a family losing their home. Canadians do not experience recession through Liberal talking points. They experience it through lost jobs, missed mortgage payments, shrinking savings accounts and the growing fear that despite working hard and playing by the rules, they are falling further behind.\n\nThis recession is the logical consequence of Liberal ideology. The Liberals have a governing philosophy that believes prosperity can be designed by Ottawa in a boardroom, rather than created by millions of Canadians making decisions for themselves. When a government makes it harder to build, invest, hire or expand, it should not be a surprise when investments leave and jobs disappear. What is especially troubling is that Canada is not suffering from a lack of talent, resources, innovation or ambition. We possess all of those things in abundance. What we lack is a government that is willing to remove the barriers that prevent Canadians from putting those strengths to work.\n\n Every year it becomes more difficult to build, invest, hire or expand, because government has inserted itself into more and more areas of economic life. The result is a system that satisfies almost no one. Those paying for it feel overburdened, while those depending on it often find that it delivers less than promised. Government grows larger, yet the problems it claims to solve seem only to multiply.\n\n Adam Smith understood that prosperity is created when free people are allowed to pursue opportunity and create value for others. We know that liberty is weakened when power becomes concentrated in government institutions. One truth never changes: A nation becomes stronger when its citizens are empowered, not when they are centrally managed.\n\n After years of rising bureaucracy, rising spending, rising deficits, rising unemployment and now a recession, when will the government acknowledge that prosperity does not come from Ottawa treating citizens like incapable children, but from smart, hard-working Canadians—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084016","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, one of the great questions facing any nation is whether it trusts its people more than it trusts the government. That question lies at the heart of the economic challenges facing Canada today.\n\n For most of our history, Canada was a country where ordinary people could arrive with little more than a dollar in their pocket, work hard, take risks, build a business, buy a home, raise a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0a9c904b1daac122c7f79f6926c4bdfe427e3bfb3b5b409c1b4deb8c73058681"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46c76de3c7c437853964b81fcac794d9c8e6639630eb4cce9f83848fad371c0e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60b8f0086b139bb8618e98ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084017,"date":"2026-06-02T00:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, what we are witnessing is not simply a recession. It is the predictable result of a government that believes prosperity can be engineered by Ottawa rather than created by Canadians themselves. For a year, the Prime Minister has promised growth. Instead, the economy has shrunk in three of the last four quarters. More than 112,000 jobs have disappeared. Business investment has fallen. Billions of dollars have left this country. None of this should surprise us. When the government makes it more expensive to build, invest, hire and produce, businesses invest less, entrepreneurs take fewer risks and jobs disappear. Ordinary Canadians are paying the price. Food bank use is at record levels. Household debt is the highest in the G7. Families are working harder and getting less. \n\nWhen will the Liberals stop driving Canadians' decline and remove the taxes, red tape and barriers forcing jobs and opportunities out of Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084017","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, what we are witnessing is not simply a recession. It is the predictable result of a government that believes prosperity can be engineered by Ottawa rather than created by Canadians themselves. For a year, the Prime Minister has promised growth. Instead, the economy has shrunk in three of the last four quarters. More than 112,000 jobs have disappeared. Business investment has fallen.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bbec7453c0685a9c1ec777bfebb4a9f73ebcd1c3dd2bd8796bae5d925fc0e74f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60fb5868930afa85f9faf89c79628f4143aa9cfab25a9b7dfcefc9917359fa9f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-009201dfca2122eda774662f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084005,"date":"2026-06-04T20:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when Canadians hear the government talk about Bill C-16, they probably think it is a bill about protecting victims. They hear about protecting women from abuse. They hear about protecting children from exploitation. They hear about stopping the spread of deepfake pornography. They hear about tougher measures against coercive control in abusive relationships. Most Canadians would hear that list and say, \"Who could possibly be against that?\" The answer is, nobody could.\n\nConservatives support those objectives because we believe victims deserve protection, children deserve protection and families deserve protection. That is the fundamental job of government: protection of its citizens. The problem is that Bill C-16 is a bit like buying a house because the front porch looks beautiful, only to discover later that the foundation is compromised. The government points Canadians toward the parts of the bill everyone likes, while hoping they do not notice the parts that would change everything. Buried inside this legislation is a poison pill that would allow judges to bypass virtually every mandatory minimum sentence in the Criminal Code.\n\nFirst, we need to understand how we got here. Consecutive Conservative governments had established mandatory minimum sentences for some of the most serious crimes in our Criminal Code. We did that because Canadians expect serious offences to carry serious consequences. Child sexual exploitation, weapons trafficking, armed extortion, drive-by shootings and human trafficking were not treated as ordinary crimes, because the harm they cause is extraordinary.\n\nHowever, for 10 years, the Liberal government has systematically weakened the principle that serious crimes must carry serious consequences. Liberal Bill C-75 weakened bail laws and pushed the justice system toward release at the earliest opportunity. Liberal Bill C-5 removed mandatory minimum penalties for a range of serious offences, including crimes involving firearms and dangerous drugs.\n\nTime and again, police officers, prosecutors, victims advocates, premiers and community leaders warned that the government was moving in the wrong direction. Time and again, those warnings were dismissed. Today, Canadians are seeing the consequences. Violent crime has increased dramatically. Human trafficking has increased dramatically. Sexual assault has increased dramatically. Organized criminal networks have become stronger and more sophisticated.\n\nCanadians are witnessing the inevitable result of a philosophy that views punishment, rather than crime itself, as the problem, that views the rights of the criminal as more important than the rights of the victim. That is why Bill C-16's \"get out of jail free\" card is a poison pill that Canadian communities will once again be forced to swallow. The Liberals will say that Conservatives are standing in the way of getting strong laws passed, but I can assure Canadians that Conservatives are standing in the breach, fighting to keep criminals from getting off with a slap on the wrist for serious crimes.\n\nUnderstanding Bill C-16 requires a deeper understanding of the path that led us here. For years, courts have increasingly relied on what are called \"reasonable hypotheticals\" when reviewing mandatory minimum sentences. Rather than focusing solely on the criminal who is actually on trial, the court judges have increasingly considered hypothetical scenarios involving people who do not exist and who never committed the actual crimes in question.\n\nThat trend culminated in the Supreme Court's Senneville decision. The facts of that case were horrific. One offender possessed 475 files, including 317 images of children, most between the ages of three and six, and many depicting acts of sexual abuse I cannot bring myself to say out loud here in the House. Another offender possessed more than 800 images and videos involving children as young as five years old being subjected to sexual exploitation and abuse. That is hundreds of images documenting the abuse of vulnerable children.\n\nMost Canadians would think that the court would consider those offenders and apply the appropriate mandatory minimum sentence. Instead, the court chose this moment to question mandatory minimums altogether. Judges based their decisions on a hypothetical story of a teenager sending a hypothetical intimate photo to a hypothetical boyfriend or girlfriend, and that hypothetical photo was later shared with a hypothetical someone. The court claimed concern that the same mandatory minimum law could apply, even though the case before them was very real and very serious. Because of that hypothetical case, the court struck down Parliament's mandatory minimum sentence.\n\nThe government then had a choice. It could have changed the law to deal with that specific concern while keeping strong penalties in place for serious child sexual exploitation offences. Instead, the Liberals used that court decision as the reason for creating the new get-out-of-jail-free card in Bill C-16. That is why Canadians should look carefully at what the bill would actually do rather than what the Liberals say it would do. \n\nThe government wants Canadians to believe that Bill C-16 is a major public safety initiative. It points to provisions dealing with deepfake pornography. It points to provisions dealing with coercive control. It points to provisions dealing with intimate partner violence. All those measures are designed to attract support. However, while Canadians are focused on those headlines, the Liberal government has inserted this poison pill. It calls it a safety valve, a phrase carefully chosen because it sounds limited, reasonable and harmless. The government insists this power will be used only in exceptional cases, yet when Conservatives proposed reasonable safeguards to ensure that outcome, every safeguard was rejected. Canadians should ask themselves a simple question: If the government truly intended that this be used only rarely, why did it refuse every attempt to define what \"rarely\" actually means? The answer is obvious. The government is presenting Canadians with one bill while pursuing a very different objective beneath the surface.\n\n That objective became even clearer during committee study. Conservatives approached the legislation constructively, because we recognize that there are very good measures that are worth preserving. Our goal is not to destroy the bill; our goal is to strengthen it and ensure that victims remain at the centre of the legislation. We proposed safeguards that would have limited access to the safety valve to offenders with no prior record. We proposed ensuring that sentences would not be reduced below half of Parliament's mandatory minimum. We proposed excluding extortion offences. We proposed excluding aggravated sexual assault. We proposed excluding serious child sexual offences. We proposed excluding some of the most serious crimes that Parliament has already determined deserve firm sentencing consequences. Every one of those amendments was rejected.\n\n Conservatives also proposed stronger notification requirements so that victims of intimate partner violence and coercive control would be informed about release decisions affecting offenders. Those amendments were rejected as well. The significance of those votes cannot be ignored. The government did not accidentally create an overly broad get-out-of-jail-free card but deliberately defended it. It did not overlook the concerns raised by Conservatives. It considered those concerns and voted against them. The result is legislation that speaks passionately about victims while systematically rejecting measures that would strengthen their protection.\n\n Conservatives support stronger protections for women and children, stronger measures against deepfake exploitation and stronger recognition of the devastating harm caused by coercive control. Those objectives are important and need support. Unfortunately, the poison pill at the heart of Bill C-16 undermines all of those goals, because it continues with the same failed philosophy that has contributed to the crime and chaos Canadians are experiencing today.\n\nAt a time when communities are demanding greater accountability, the government is creating new opportunities for offenders to avoid consequences. At a time when victims are asking to be heard, the government is focusing its attention on a get-out-of-jail-free card for criminals. At a time when public confidence in the justice system is already fragile, the government is asking members of Parliament to weaken one of the few tools designed to ensure serious crime receives serious punishment. \n\nCanadians deserve better than legislation that says one thing and does another. They deserve a justice system that places victims first, supports police officers, protects communities and recognizes that public safety is a fundamental responsibility of government. If the Liberals truly believed in the good parts of the bill, protecting women and children against deepfake exploitation, why did they insist on attaching a poison pill that creates yet another get-out-of-jail-free card for serious offenders?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084005","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when Canadians hear the government talk about Bill C-16, they probably think it is a bill about protecting victims. They hear about protecting women from abuse. They hear about protecting children from exploitation. They hear about stopping the spread of deepfake pornography. They hear about tougher measures against coercive control in abusive relationships. Most Canadians would hear ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8feabbd9dfcb31857318c0c424487cdfef4fc7b19690ace331fe3c5b81c044d4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["092c3ee574ac8bdce72c68b7bfc3d167d3c01e2d8d41e1bd53f74031ec59f4a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6311ee2e979cd23829952869","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084006,"date":"2026-06-04T20:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives support the parts of the bill that protect women and children, address coercive control and deal with deepfake exploitation. In fact, many of those ideas came from the Conservatives in the first place. The problem is clause 63. The government wrapped good measures around a poison pill that would let judges go below mandatory minimum sentences for serious crimes. Victims deserve protection, but they also deserve consequences for the people who hurt them. That is why Conservatives tried to fix the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084006","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives support the parts of the bill that protect women and children, address coercive control and deal with deepfake exploitation. In fact, many of those ideas came from the Conservatives in the first place. The problem is clause 63. The government wrapped good measures around a poison pill that would let judges go below mandatory minimum sentences for serious crimes. Victims ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e51f45b7f3cfc4821ca07ccdc5ea096d1bf9fed73b5aba50d201b6e5f7f4da29"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["735c5ba3b8b620e6caf12aafc5edfaa5fa5fe2b552a1d33d233286507c93886b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c4e9cfa7c5123b8a2d23500","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084007,"date":"2026-06-04T20:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives have been very clear from the beginning. We support stronger protections for women, children and victims. We support action on coercive control. We support action on deepfake exploitation. We support stronger tools to protect children online. \n\nWhat we do not support is using those victims as a political cover for a clause that attacks mandatory minimum sentences. The government did not have to attach clause 63 to those protections. It chose to do that, and it chose to reject every Conservative attempt to fix it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084007","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives have been very clear from the beginning. We support stronger protections for women, children and victims. We support action on coercive control. We support action on deepfake exploitation. We support stronger tools to protect children online. \n\nWhat we do not support is using those victims as a political cover for a clause that attacks mandatory minimum sentences. The go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["768a393d5aadf95e9e7bfc23dd09780fc03926dc729852c840e1fc1462de345d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["903f68d207654f908d79669ce5019060eb9a2eff8292ff046edfb1469d35261a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-264259d9d43cd733c25d8b61","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084008,"date":"2026-06-04T20:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I hope I have been able to tackle some of that in my speech, but the arguments we have heard from the Liberal side do not explain why they rejected every reasonable safeguard Conservatives proposed in order to define things. If their release valve or get-out-of-jail-free card is truly only for rare and exceptional cases, why do they not say that in the bill? Why not limit it to first-time offenders? Why not prevent sentences from dropping below half the mandatory minimum? Why not exclude a child sexual offence, aggravated sexual assault or extortion? The answer is simple. The Liberals wanted this power to be broad, and Canadians should be very concerned about it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084008","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I hope I have been able to tackle some of that in my speech, but the arguments we have heard from the Liberal side do not explain why they rejected every reasonable safeguard Conservatives proposed in order to define things. If their release valve or get-out-of-jail-free card is truly only for rare and exceptional cases, why do they not say that in the bill? Why not limit it to first-","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["51f6f660db63bd791222dc57dedd6c50110e0af39f72bbfa3c50d95ef0fae6f1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5199214a2f8ea62383ca470866c38797c6372641f87c73fc0e0866a538857708"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09c38c2c4d575b2c17d31833","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084009,"date":"2026-06-04T20:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if mandatory minimums can be ignored, then they are not mandatory anymore. The government says there would be jail time, but that misses the point. Parliament sets mandatory minimums because some crimes are so serious that there must be a clear floor.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084009","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if mandatory minimums can be ignored, then they are not mandatory anymore. The government says there would be jail time, but that misses the point. Parliament sets mandatory minimums because some crimes are so serious that there must be a clear floor.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["99165a2571c9b3f7b94621784a2692bfb0557e492b8d23600840619596e1ffcb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f3c41269f1e64e16d203991","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085947,"date":"2026-06-08T18:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, Canadians did not need a Parliamentary Budget Officer report to tell them that the economy was in trouble; families knew it when their groceries kept getting more expensive, when their mortgage payments doubled and when young people gave up on owning their own home.\n\nFor years we have been sounding the alarms, yet the Liberals kept telling us, \"Everything is fine.\" Now, the PBO confirms that we have a bigger deficit, weaker growth, lower wages and only a 1% chance of meeting the government's own fiscal anchor.\n\nWhy does my colleague think it took the Liberal government so long to admit what Canadians already knew, and why are they still refusing to change the costly policies that are making life less affordable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085947","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, Canadians did not need a Parliamentary Budget Officer report to tell them that the economy was in trouble; families knew it when their groceries kept getting more expensive, when their mortgage payments doubled and when young people gave up on owning their own home.\n\nFor years we have been sounding the alarms, yet the Liberals kept telling us, \"Everything is fine.\" Now, the PBO conf","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eb12910bdedf678a776cd7fd751a5ba6f3bdb8828b967d38b8f3576b666d4fae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0cf6b04b5546f399942bbafc8dd9bc817385abe08bfbd5f794814f1cd34904bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40e324c739a8164f7ab8059d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085948,"date":"2026-06-08T22:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, earlier today I was speaking with some grandparents from my riding who were actually sitting in the gallery listening to my colleague, our finance critic, speak on the state of our economy. I did not realize they were coming. I am very grateful to have met them downstairs. As they listened to the Liberal members—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085948","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, earlier today I was speaking with some grandparents from my riding who were actually sitting in the gallery listening to my colleague, our finance critic, speak on the state of our economy. I did not realize they were coming. I am very grateful to have met them downstairs. As they listened to the Liberal members—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["521dbd2350a3bfc85c92440145be627e013ce635f076297e4a6e8e75ca2e1a55"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7a500bd934fb589943eb9a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085949,"date":"2026-06-08T22:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the grandparents listened to the Liberal members dismiss concerns about the recession, rising debt and the cost of living. They told me they wished they could call and tell the government what they were seeing in their own lives, as seniors struggling to make ends meet. They talked about grocery bills that keep climbing, adult children who are struggling to get ahead, and their grandchildren facing a future that looks less affordable than the one they inherited.\n\nCan my colleague explain to me why so many ordinary Canadians can see we are in a recession, while the Liberal government continues to downplay the very real economic struggles that families are facing every day?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085949","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the grandparents listened to the Liberal members dismiss concerns about the recession, rising debt and the cost of living. They told me they wished they could call and tell the government what they were seeing in their own lives, as seniors struggling to make ends meet. They talked about grocery bills that keep climbing, adult children who are struggling to get ahead, and their grandc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["332e2d951a6daf84685eca6825ce05013a80f27821be565455653fb63c90c6db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a73c123c1a5538cd65647c33351fc087e990a5c316d67ba1397c5127090777f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb97fe8ed22db03bb4c03884","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085946,"date":"2026-06-11T00:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Liberals keep telling Canadians that their safety valve measure in the bill, or, more accurately, a poison pill, a get-out-of-jail-free card, will be used only in rare and exceptional cases. If that is true, why were they unwilling to exclude serious offences such as aggravated sexual assault, extortion, and child sexual offences? If it is truly meant to be narrow, why is it written so broadly?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085946","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Liberals keep telling Canadians that their safety valve measure in the bill, or, more accurately, a poison pill, a get-out-of-jail-free card, will be used only in rare and exceptional cases. If that is true, why were they unwilling to exclude serious offences such as aggravated sexual assault, extortion, and child sexual offences? If it is truly meant to be narrow, why is it wri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["21838823e6dd755c6f27ecb699ad74b0cef7471ec0359282ac9099dfd1745558"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cf33cde8ea368da53c7a39082fe91c78de854ec46e8553193b5be0cc7b77ea9b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5c8cb4bae7cd0f6e5007d46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115538,"date":"2026-06-11T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I cannot help but notice that whenever the Liberal government creates a program, it seems to help the biggest companies while ignoring the small businesses that actually drive Canada's economy. For example, the steel industry, with us today, contributes about $4 billion to Canada's GDP. Small and medium-sized businesses contribute hundreds of billions, something like 300 times more. SMEs make up 99% of all businesses in Canada. They employ nearly two-thirds of private sector workers and generate roughly half of our economic output. If the goal is to strengthen the Canadian economy, create jobs and increase productivity, where would we get the biggest return? Is it by creating another targeted program for a handful of large companies or by making it easier for millions of entrepreneurs and small business owners to grow, hire and invest? What makes this even more frustrating is that often these large businesses, for example, the steel industry, are largely foreign-owned, well over 50%, whereas SMEs are truly Canadian businesses. They're owned by Canadians and rooted in their communities. They reinvest their profits here at home, yet they're the last to receive attention. The government calls this a strategy to support Canada, but when a program is designed around a relatively small segment of the economy, while businesses that generate half of our GDP are largely left out, it raises a fair question. Are we really focusing on where Canada gets the greatest economic benefit? If we want a stronger economy, the biggest opportunity isn't at the top—no shade on the steel industry—it's in the millions of small and medium-sized businesses that keep our country running every day. My question, Michelle Auger, as we sit here today is this. Can a Canadian SME clearly identify what new opportunities this buy Canadian initiative creates for them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115538","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I cannot help but notice that whenever the Liberal government creates a program, it seems to help the biggest companies while ignoring the small businesses that actually drive Canada's economy. For example, the steel industry, with us today, contributes about $4 billion to Canada's GDP. Small and medium-sized businesses contribute hundreds of billions, something like 300 times more. SMEs make up 9","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6fb35e58888c732585848015cee2d2306a028439717b7e302dbe84c26294a5a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["821ae688effa73ccc2a7f3c3aca1db8d728ccfbd6163c2093eba4e7183e2db53"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4daae37041bec49e47f2db88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115539,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Have you seen any evidence that procurement has become simpler for SMEs since the buy Canadian announcement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115539","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Have you seen any evidence that procurement has become simpler for SMEs since the buy Canadian announcement?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercialization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mergers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036263","label":"Mergers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752259","label":"Commercialization","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c2247f6024cfa1687e48525ef9c2dd6848333d8a83875f5f02a4227cd366ffb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ad36d1f4b2ec218f88d9fde","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115540,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"There's not even information for them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115540","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There's not even information for them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0dada5b76354d771fda5ad23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115541,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Would you say that reducing barriers is often more valuable than creating a new subsidy program?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115541","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Would you say that reducing barriers is often more valuable than creating a new subsidy program?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["63e17df481e9ae9dc39d4c2570b174d98a2bca43b6c4ebf4b1a02d5c2f561437"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57db57e11ef79cd2633674b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115542,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"My husband and I started a business, and I can tell you that we never tried to get any of these programs, because it was impossible. I had exactly that question: Would reducing paperwork help SMEs compete for a government contract? I know the big guys have a massive team that can do this. If SMEs represent 99.7% of our economy, why are we not helping them with a program?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115542","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"My husband and I started a business, and I can tell you that we never tried to get any of these programs, because it was impossible. I had exactly that question: Would reducing paperwork help SMEs compete for a government contract? I know the big guys have a massive team that can do this. If SMEs represent 99.7% of our economy, why are we not helping them with a program?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-878a93fd729899431277399a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115543,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Very quickly—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115543","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Very quickly—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5246ad2352a49e9d0708360","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115544,"date":"2026-06-11T17:00:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"On a point of order, Chair, I think it's very disrespectful, when Ms. Auger is here explaining what the problems are with a program, that she's being badgered.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115544","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"On a point of order, Chair, I think it's very disrespectful, when Ms. Auger is here explaining what the problems are with a program, that she's being badgered.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13d6b2fd74399fe263a12da09a6005d611a27c59aa1587a1c4dab416878f9b8a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb71675ce359a4d38a8216c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115545,"date":"2026-06-11T17:00:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"\"Attacked\" is a better word.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115545","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"\"Attacked\" is a better word.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95571bdfc229c28f5a39dcb1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115546,"date":"2026-06-11T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Mr. Delov, we're seeing warning signs across the housing sector. Metro Vancouver just recorded its weakest home sales market in decades. Pre-sale launches have collapsed, and we actually now have developers entering receivership on completed buildings. If projects stop moving forward, trades workers are going to lose their jobs regardless of what procurement policy Ottawa writes. At the end of the day, trades workers need projects to actually move forward. Would you agree that an announcement from the government doesn't really help workers if the project is delayed or cancelled?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115546","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Delov, we're seeing warning signs across the housing sector. Metro Vancouver just recorded its weakest home sales market in decades. Pre-sale launches have collapsed, and we actually now have developers entering receivership on completed buildings. If projects stop moving forward, trades workers are going to lose their jobs regardless of what procurement policy Ottawa writes. At the end of the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e59e7ffe0debabefd3bea7891c54d71697a63b221d6d7c497130bd1e486385f1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42f2f97118d16f4085aa9ee6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115547,"date":"2026-06-11T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Buy Canadian sounds good, but it has to work on real job sites. Are you concerned that these rules would actually slow projects down instead of helping workers, and actually increase project costs, which we can see are already high?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115547","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Buy Canadian sounds good, but it has to work on real job sites. Are you concerned that these rules would actually slow projects down instead of helping workers, and actually increase project costs, which we can see are already high?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","label":"Indigenous businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f1b99a16e44794481843e1841ca59b4c79a77f41a5893765fdd5b1c490bdd44d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa6e21e7aa6515880004e8f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115548,"date":"2026-06-11T17:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. The last time this happened was actually when my husband was trying to become an electrician—his dad was an electrical contractor, and it was in the Liberal downturn—and we ended up going into greenhouses instead, because there were no jobs. We're seeing that again with what's happening now, so I'm just wondering, how will this second Liberal-caused housing downturn impact the trades?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115548","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. The last time this happened was actually when my husband was trying to become an electrician—his dad was an electrical contractor, and it was in the Liberal downturn—and we ended up going into greenhouses instead, because there were no jobs. We're seeing that again with what's happening now, so I'm just wondering, how will this second Liberal-caused housing downturn impact the trades?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","label":"Greenhouses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034887","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Domestic trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034887","label":"Domestic trade","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","label":"Greenhouses","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fa4c1423acdc234c01fbf97480439887cde8a8fd2c3d8086ed777cf0f0d070d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eba363a5f42ead01fdc0ace2ef54ec7d539f097fdaf6985af02118af058d40c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0daaaa906410acacb0cc99f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115549,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Is there a risk that buy Canadian could become another layer of red tape on top of an already very complicated construction and procurement system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115549","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is there a risk that buy Canadian could become another layer of red tape on top of an already very complicated construction and procurement system?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cacdc9d89c675d172d418438bb0d1ac07a62eb3de1fd8cbb1a6136cda903d97a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-19319925029bc17542f28176","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115550,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Federal procurement is already really complex. If buy Canadian adds more conditions without simplifying the process, couldn't that make infrastructure projects slower or harder to deliver? Therefore, you'd have fewer jobs for your construction workers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115550","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Federal procurement is already really complex. If buy Canadian adds more conditions without simplifying the process, couldn't that make infrastructure projects slower or harder to deliver? Therefore, you'd have fewer jobs for your construction workers.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87154a61cd16dcee7877c02a3b70464a04a7d531dd2cf0f8b99e8b362f581108"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cb4fc05c88b6a57b6c003e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115551,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Mr. Delov, what would you say is the most pressing problem for the construction industry right now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115551","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Delov, what would you say is the most pressing problem for the construction industry right now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["385e85c4dad1ece0610dabe04e4399d6b58cb5c4e82ee0544b2dc7c4f6177048"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c18551c87c9aab8fffec5edb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115552,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You're not concerned about the downturn in the housing market. That's not the main pressing problem right now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115552","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You're not concerned about the downturn in the housing market. That's not the main pressing problem right now.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c56f122225ae7611bd5519b40b8a25da8af58a512d22af90cf4259609f415846"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b19928e66736e09d1b03765c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085945,"date":"2026-06-11T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals want to make it easier to hide information from Canadians by no longer allowing government emails or text messages to be part of an information request. Even the independent Information Commissioner is opposed.\n\nWill the President of the Treasury Board reverse this proposal and defend Canadians' right to know?\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085945","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals want to make it easier to hide information from Canadians by no longer allowing government emails or text messages to be part of an information request. Even the independent Information Commissioner is opposed.\n\nWill the President of the Treasury Board reverse this proposal and defend Canadians' right to know?\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df89cd3728cbbd0805375381","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087862,"date":"2026-06-15T19:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the press reports that Liberal MPs say the President of the Treasury Board is not very present, not very diligent and struggling to master his files. Last week, Canadians watched him stand in this House, unable to answer a very basic question about his own department.\n\n If the Prime Minister demands confidence from his ministers, does he still have confidence in the President of the Treasury Board, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087862","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the press reports that Liberal MPs say the President of the Treasury Board is not very present, not very diligent and struggling to master his files. Last week, Canadians watched him stand in this House, unable to answer a very basic question about his own department.\n\n If the Prime Minister demands confidence from his ministers, does he still have confidence in the President of the T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-502716dfe1e3009d27fb3910","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087863,"date":"2026-06-15T21:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have spent 10 years telling Canadians that the solution to every problem is more government spending. Canadians now face some of the least affordable housing in the G7, record food bank usage and the highest household debt in the G7, and ours is the only country in the G20 in a recession.\n\nAt what point does the government admit that its spending is not solving the affordability crisis, but contributing to it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087863","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have spent 10 years telling Canadians that the solution to every problem is more government spending. Canadians now face some of the least affordable housing in the G7, record food bank usage and the highest household debt in the G7, and ours is the only country in the G20 in a recession.\n\nAt what point does the government admit that its spending is not solving the afford","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab1fecf2e88bf7ab939056b9ff08f343baf859926d43e952fe5a44cf600c1bac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fd3c54d5bce671e6e3cb48b6d574f03a84e48c93260b18c603454a2358630d68"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-880b8f7c7cf33a240593eb52","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087864,"date":"2026-06-15T21:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians keep hearing announcements about new funds, new agencies, new strategies and new spending programs. Could my colleague explain why, after 10 years of these announcements, Canadians are facing higher housing costs, higher grocery bills and lower affordability, rather than the prosperity they were promised?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087864","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians keep hearing announcements about new funds, new agencies, new strategies and new spending programs. Could my colleague explain why, after 10 years of these announcements, Canadians are facing higher housing costs, higher grocery bills and lower affordability, rather than the prosperity they were promised?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e7f496332f924bebf211815098a97799f8e358084adf116564c40cbc2e655140"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4a341f682d21566ed8e530116b08fe8d3dfd3256e0ca173c8f1f33dc2bb003a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2678364095494b9fd50ff189","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087865,"date":"2026-06-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians understand that when a family is struggling financially, the answer is not to keep increasing the limit on the credit card.\n\nCould my colleague explain why he thinks the government believes doubling the deficit and announcing another $48 billion in spending commitments will somehow make life more affordable for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087865","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians understand that when a family is struggling financially, the answer is not to keep increasing the limit on the credit card.\n\nCould my colleague explain why he thinks the government believes doubling the deficit and announcing another $48 billion in spending commitments will somehow make life more affordable for Canadians?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6b3c7b82bd16aad3dca655b9825c18f07ffa0fbccec20b5add1d688a1deb2b8a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a14afdb84f254e2a9ea27ae2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087866,"date":"2026-06-15T23:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay.\n\nThe government has asked us today to accelerate consideration of the spring economic update because we are told time is short. What the government neglects to mention is that much of the time pressure is entirely of its own making.\n\nLet us be clear about what this motion would do. It would force all remaining amendments at committee to be moved and voted on without further debate. That is not a normal legislative process. It is Parliament being asked to do less of its most important job.\n\nA budget is supposed to be a statement of priorities. It is supposed to tell Canadians what the government intends to do, how much it intends to spend and how it intends to pay for it, yet within weeks of presenting budget 2025, the Prime Minister began announcing billions of dollars in new spending commitments that had not been presented when the budget was tabled. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has estimated that these additional measures are roughly $48 billion over five years. Basically, a second budget is being unveiled piecemeal through press conferences and announcements, while Parliament is expected to simply keep up.\n\nThe most striking example is the newly announced Canada Strong fund, a $25-billion sovereign debt fund that did not appear as a central feature of the government's original plan. When a government finds $25 billion for a brand-new sovereign debt fund, only weeks after presenting a budget, Parliament should begin to wonder if perhaps these programs are not emerging from a coherent economic plan, but are being invented on the fly whenever the government finds itself in need of a new announcement. The same pattern can be seen in the government's new commitments on defence and international affairs. Billions of dollars have now been announced for new defence procurement structures, a Defence Investment Agency and a defence industrial strategy. Why do so many huge financial commitments continue to emerge after the government's fiscal plan was supposedly complete?\n\n The Prime Minister has also unveiled team Canada strong, a multi-billion-dollar labour strategy. Then came the government's new electricity initiative. Canadians were told that billions more would be going towards transmission infrastructure, electricity corridors and long-term transformation of Canada's power grid. Once again, the government presented the announcement as though it had just came up with the idea at the last minute. How come these were not in the budget in the first place?\n\nThen, last week, the government announced a $3-billion national food strategy. The government appears to believe that food security can be achieved through creating funds, hubs, agencies, financing mechanisms, planning structures and administrative frameworks. Food security has never been created by government planners. It has always been created by farmers, truckers, processors, retailers and entrepreneurs who bring the food from the field to the table. The announcement contains billions of dollars in new programs, but remarkably little discussion of the policies that have made food more expensive in the first place. Food security depends on farmers who can afford to farm, processors who can afford to process, truckers who can afford to transport goods and businesses that can operate in a competitive environment, yet after years of inflationary Liberal policies that have increased costs throughout the supply chain, the government now proposes another layer of inflationary programs and administration as the solution.\n\nEach one of these announcements arrives with a new price tag attached to the national credit card. Every few weeks, Canadians are presented with another announcement, another commitment, another expenditure and another promise that government spending will somehow unlock future prosperity, yet after 10 years of this approach, Canadians have become entitled to ask a reasonable question: If government spending were the key to economic growth, why have the billions of dollars of new spending not made anything better?\n\n The government would like Canadians to believe that these new programs are finally going to make life more affordable, but it is just an illusion. Every new fund, every new agency, every new strategy and every new spending commitment ultimately lands on the country's credit card. The bill always arrives. It arrives in the form of larger deficits, higher debt, rising interest costs and, ultimately, a higher cost of living for the very people the government claims it is trying to help.\n\n Bill C‐30 is simply the latest example of what has become a familiar Liberal pattern: more spending, more borrowing, more debt and higher costs for Canadians. The Prime Minister promised fiscal responsibility. Instead, this budget more than doubles the deficit left behind by Justin Trudeau, from $31 billion to $72 billion. Outside the pandemic, this is the largest deficit in Canadian history. Canadians were promised a new approach, but it turns out that the new approach means spending way more than Trudeau could ever have imagined.\n\nWhat makes this particularly troubling is that all of this is happening while Canada stands alone among the G20 countries as the only one in recession. The government continues to insist that more spending is the solution, yet with all that spending, Canada is the only G20 nation that has managed to achieve this disastrous distinction. One would think that after 10 years of disappointing results, the government might pause long enough to consider the fact that the remedy it keeps prescribing is actually making the illness worse.\n\nCanadians are already carrying the highest household debt burden in the G7. They are coping with some of the least affordable housing in the developed world. Food bank usage has reached record lows and young families can only dream of home ownership. Seniors are stretching fixed incomes further every month. Working parents are making impossible choices between groceries, rent, transportation and basic necessities.\n\nThe Prime Minister did not campaign on doubling deficits. He did not campaign on larger government and ever-expanding spending commitments. He presented himself as the supposed adult in the room, the person who would restore fiscal discipline, bring competence back to the government and provide a new economic direction for the country. However, only months later, Canadians are looking at a $72-billion deficit, the largest deficit in Canadian history outside of the pandemic, and billions of dollars in additional spending commitments that were not even included in the budget.\n\nThe Prime Minister promised to lower the debt-to-GDP ratio. This budget shows it is rising. He promised spending discipline. Spending is increasing faster than inflation and faster than economic growth. He promised economic renewal. Canada remains the only G20 country in recession. He promised to build faster, yet despite his creating new offices, new agencies and new approval processes, Canadians are still waiting to see any results.\n\nThe concern is not simply that these promises have been broken. The concern is that the government appears not to have learned anything from the experience of the last decade. For 10 years, Canadians have been told that another spending program, another fund, another agency or another strategy will solve the problem, yet the problem continues to grow as the government continues to grow.\n\nThe result is a country carrying more debt, paying more interest, experiencing weaker growth and facing higher costs than Canadians were promised. At some point, governments must be judged not by the announcements they make but by the results they achieve. Now the government has asked Parliament to spend less time examining legislation at the very moment it is asking Canadians to accept more spending, more borrowing and more debt. That is backwards.\n\nWhen a government announces another $48 billion in commitments after tabling a budget, scrutiny becomes more important, not less. When deficits are growing, debate becomes more important, not less. When Canadians are struggling to afford groceries, housing and everyday necessities, accountability becomes more important, not less. Parliament was not created to rubber-stamp government announcements. It exists to test them, challenge them and ensure taxpayers understand the consequences before the bill arrives.\n\nAfter 10 years of rising debt, rising costs and declining affordability, Canadians have every right to ask whether more spending will solve the problem or simply make it worse. The government might not like that, but it is not a reason to curtail debate. It is the very reason debate exists. \n\nThat is why Conservatives support the amendment moved by my colleague from Cariboo—Prince George. His amendment would allow the finance committee to continue its work instead of forcing members to vote on remaining clauses and amendments without debate. It would restore the basic principle that Parliament should examine legislation before passing it. Canadians can no longer afford more of the same, and they certainly cannot afford less scrutiny of the policies that brought us here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087866","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay.\n\nThe government has asked us today to accelerate consideration of the spring economic update because we are told time is short. What the government neglects to mention is that much of the time pressure is entirely of its own making.\n\nLet us be clear about what this motion would do. It would force a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["99e72822facae09fbe6c0c860aa6ded8914132c7c8efaad4b9e27b7539e4bba4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb6101e387dcbcfcf842bb5955106f38f55c8b0cd1bfd651789a08dde23ade51"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4d298f3222d9aada67431a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087867,"date":"2026-06-15T23:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would not agree that the Liberals were elected to make a whole bunch of announcements and get nothing done.\n\n Conservatives believe in the basic principle that government does not create prosperity by endlessly spending borrowed money. We would focus on getting costs down, removing barriers to investments, speeding up approvals, supporting the workers and businesses that actually build homes and grow food, and restoring discipline to federal spending.\n\n Canadians do not need more slogans, funds, agencies and strategies. They need a government that measures success by results: lower costs, more homes, stronger paycheques and a more competitive economy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087867","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would not agree that the Liberals were elected to make a whole bunch of announcements and get nothing done.\n\n Conservatives believe in the basic principle that government does not create prosperity by endlessly spending borrowed money. We would focus on getting costs down, removing barriers to investments, speeding up approvals, supporting the workers and businesses that actually bu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eddb82cea2f88b8e69d43f4e0a0097c00d193110327eeae7f29ccd6592ee619f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc4c3e8255b51ad16ed8dd934d1a19d46976cd599b8a419185ad7d769259a41f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6fdd9e0718dfdeeb78e8d38","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087868,"date":"2026-06-15T23:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, first of all, I would say that there are many examples of where the Liberals have gone wrong in this budget. The PBO found that the government used most of the additional fiscal room for new policy priorities, leaving the deficit track substantially unchanged.\n\n In other words, when the government had some breathing room, it did not use that room to meaningfully lower the deficit or give taxpayers real relief. It used it to fund more spending. That is the pattern Canadians have seen for the last decade: more spending, announcements and promises. However, families are still struggling with groceries, housing, taxes and debt. Conservatives are saying that improved fiscal room should not be treated as permission to keep spending.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087868","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, first of all, I would say that there are many examples of where the Liberals have gone wrong in this budget. The PBO found that the government used most of the additional fiscal room for new policy priorities, leaving the deficit track substantially unchanged.\n\n In other words, when the government had some breathing room, it did not use that room to meaningfully lower the deficit or g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["366de439d55561a35a9c60e3451197a9edaf698546a137aa5d27f3fbd63ad6e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["58b8899330aeafca040906cdda00cf48f221b044aed62b6f4f53c83089b98762"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd58e4c2376b7a6be1871a2b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087869,"date":"2026-06-15T23:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I actually want to talk about the fact that what we are opposing is a process that weakens accountability and a fiscal plan that seems to be planned out on the back of a napkin.\n\n Parliament exists to examine legislation, improve it and hold the government accountable for taxpayer dollars. That should not be controversial. The amendment moved by my Conservative colleague would allow committee work to continue and would remove the parts of the motion that cut off debate and scrutiny. That is a reasonable position.\n\n If the government's legislation is strong, it should survive committee review. If its spending is justified, ministers should be able to defend it. If the plan is working, Canadians should be seeing results. Instead, Canadians are seeing higher costs, weak growth and more debt.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087869","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I actually want to talk about the fact that what we are opposing is a process that weakens accountability and a fiscal plan that seems to be planned out on the back of a napkin.\n\n Parliament exists to examine legislation, improve it and hold the government accountable for taxpayer dollars. That should not be controversial. The amendment moved by my Conservative colleague would allow c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["20d046ed1d35122d920b06eeee42ee1452b8c360c8a8edefcd7f9cc1f9fab790"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["968312e70b875c6f8e57fa6f8215bce1b61f787d55b09c8c852819bffb1c43b9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57f308d402040570eded3990","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115553,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"To follow-up on my colleague's question, can we get you to produce a report on the projected future costs to our GDP due to red tape and regulatory uncertainty?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115553","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"To follow-up on my colleague's question, can we get you to produce a report on the projected future costs to our GDP due to red tape and regulatory uncertainty?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0fd617594ceba5a05f9d33489d6bdbf358345ad746f2cbbe45317ef800042bae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b8927070b1fa3cbf72c68baa0364483482c17bd31f7bb269a0e49aa3bfa318b9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fea7636978cc0434bec2926","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115554,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. The government has said that this year's deficit will be $65 billion, and your office has said it will be closer to $72 billion. Who should we believe, you or the government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115554","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. The government has said that this year's deficit will be $65 billion, and your office has said it will be closer to $72 billion. Who should we believe, you or the government?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["060a2e993812159a5aaf4ff2193b8298b6ecd9bafa467be4254da01dc5c22cb1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fff2bed304a8fa123cf9c611b3fc49a116fd39d020e24ead9844ad4ab485e664"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb11681a4fe84344eb4c5057","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115555,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Could we say that the government's books are in worse shape than the government is telling Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115555","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could we say that the government's books are in worse shape than the government is telling Canadians?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd1a079604c05ea85affe91bd12a2d0f7989898c85942f86defb300074f30ddc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f0e08beb7fbc40303e44e406","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115556,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"The report says that there's less than a 1% chance the government's deficit-to-GDP plan will unfold as projected. For the average Canadian watching at home, does that mean that there's a 99% chance the government's plan will not unfold the way they say it will?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115556","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The report says that there's less than a 1% chance the government's deficit-to-GDP plan will unfold as projected. For the average Canadian watching at home, does that mean that there's a 99% chance the government's plan will not unfold the way they say it will?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0fa41b4645b2ad05d46c7704a5581a3d0b99cdfb1e75e86ad37953272326cd6d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95a7d434e9bd8f497330d0ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115557,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Would you describe that as a significant fiscal risk?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115557","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Would you describe that as a significant fiscal risk?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09c8aeb0918c3b890d0768d84d9ee7c2ad1bf7f0b63f42f6a279e06ca08947d3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57b3e9f9757e817829c6befc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115558,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"If a business person went to a bank with a financial plan that had a 99% chance of failing, they would never get a loan. With that in mind, should Canadians be concerned about the government's current economic situation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115558","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If a business person went to a bank with a financial plan that had a 99% chance of failing, they would never get a loan. With that in mind, should Canadians be concerned about the government's current economic situation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca6cb38f82971efce24de27ce0a22b656ef0fea9c13dccdcb12c43ee76f329fe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cfb681b1074c3387cb167f8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115559,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Does your report suggest that the government has left itself very little room for error if the economy weakens further?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115559","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Does your report suggest that the government has left itself very little room for error if the economy weakens further?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebf4c9d5342aa9b867af2ebcfe45becf3f2ff973b1b0f94b563a4be0e17781a4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-185a7ed0a4d332ddaf7b5529","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115560,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Your office forecasts economic growth of about 1.6%. The Bank of Canada forecasts 1.5%, and the government forecasts 1.9%. Would it be fair to say that both the PBO and the Bank of Canada are more cautious about Canada's economic outlook than the government is?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115560","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Your office forecasts economic growth of about 1.6%. The Bank of Canada forecasts 1.5%, and the government forecasts 1.9%. Would it be fair to say that both the PBO and the Bank of Canada are more cautious about Canada's economic outlook than the government is?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gross domestic product","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","label":"Gross domestic product","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c4a6286b185788c350641876bfbd7bb491ce225d0b903f095da3b0656c70ffe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["23a8b88c9a645cdeacd93f97d7948674a50720cd9d74cef95f0ee9291a813bab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4fbf21fd810db4496f6300cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115561,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Would a difference of 0.3 or 0.4 percentage points in economic growth have a meaningful impact on government finances over several years?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115561","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Would a difference of 0.3 or 0.4 percentage points in economic growth have a meaningful impact on government finances over several years?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["430f6a2b4ced26045d9fc2d5c8a9e411edf9bb00e734616630bc5782820946ee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6987f6703a69d893c19e6021","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115562,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Does using overly optimistic growth assumptions make the government's finances appear healthier than they may actually be?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115562","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Does using overly optimistic growth assumptions make the government's finances appear healthier than they may actually be?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e10eadaf11680d55d7615fc62d22caf216bd0d994dea5986cc944c3401aa8b0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4128163c3e2a1396ec15664d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115563,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What are the biggest risks that could cause the Liberal government's fiscal projections to miss their targets?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115563","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What are the biggest risks that could cause the Liberal government's fiscal projections to miss their targets?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4012d22b58e21039fc7ab7f22933c074e0d3513c8833c504d5933835143e86b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-096d63b39bcab4a9e7778c99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115564,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"If you take away Canada's connection to the U.S. market, basically you take away one of the biggest reasons that companies choose Canada in the first place. Would you say that's a big risk?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115564","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If you take away Canada's connection to the U.S. market, basically you take away one of the biggest reasons that companies choose Canada in the first place. Would you say that's a big risk?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Domestic markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034884","label":"Domestic markets","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e0a9de6de5eb89bd60cfee90fa1e8d669141d1a3b2963fa92ba9817cbf76315b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2e7aad458766f191895762f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115565,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Your office projects that spending will be roughly $6 billion higher by 2030 than the government projects. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115565","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Your office projects that spending will be roughly $6 billion higher by 2030 than the government projects. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","label":"Renewable resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9255ac0cac3d20aefca4cd87c665406099bd0a67be05a9e7694172565afbe276"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c233576208bdad335a8303e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115566,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"That means your office expects government spending to be higher than the government says it will be.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115566","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That means your office expects government spending to be higher than the government says it will be.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9568f99e2148902207ccbce22e2ac027842136f6ed8bd9ca2ca2e32ee4e35aaa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e74195b815b81b7fc51c7ed5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115567,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Does that spending gap remain after accounting for the government's CER initiative?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115567","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Does that spending gap remain after accounting for the government's CER initiative?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0de14beca8270c9892e08cfcbeccacf121b348a4f83aba4a61dd44b6be14c1d0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e3374b648c4892114c21307","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115568,"date":"2026-06-16T22:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Mr. Marcil, the government says that Canada should be our own best customer with this buy Canadian project. At the same time, EDC, Export Development Canada, is helping to finance infrastructure projects outside Canada. I'm trying to understand how Canadians measure the return they're getting from these foreign investments and how to track buy Canadian data at Alstom. The original EDC-Alstom agreement provided for up to $3.5 billion in financing support to pursue and deliver rail and transit projects outside Canada. Can you tell us how much of that financing has already been used to date?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115568","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Marcil, the government says that Canada should be our own best customer with this buy Canadian project. At the same time, EDC, Export Development Canada, is helping to finance infrastructure projects outside Canada. I'm trying to understand how Canadians measure the return they're getting from these foreign investments and how to track buy Canadian data at Alstom. The original EDC-Alstom agree","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bdcb84fde696a62d7f17517df6bc6b40a507ff2113d0722c5af9d3d5a92f78e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e63090e26561bafa9c590360059f4213c5a0e3daf2e5ea94a7d26c5126def6bf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aeac411a423ee85fa123960f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115569,"date":"2026-06-16T22:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you. Can you identify the major projects that have benefited from this taxpayer support partnership?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115569","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Can you identify the major projects that have benefited from this taxpayer support partnership?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c79b54669cab62ddaa12efaef3c22cd9db9fc20e20ef5493f426a87c56db766"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6574eacf36196cc6472334bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115570,"date":"2026-06-16T22:05:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How many Canadian jobs have been created or maintained through those projects?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115570","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How many Canadian jobs have been created or maintained through those projects?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66da02cdd4fb58a868655e9e2b8a63579b9bdc8ea0b3ad2d028df0e5740158b5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-803362bc56170bb9beabc9dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115571,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Is that on buy Canadian content?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115571","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is that on buy Canadian content?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ef860ec4467cd39329c8b4f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115572,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Do they have public reports of your buy Canadian content?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115572","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do they have public reports of your buy Canadian content?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["84b16430c9e1dc55a5d54e20e18d551f4db21656bf05aefeab3c78a18c8dd71c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8af4f37ea226d7a1dd81555","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115573,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Do they have reports on Canadian content issues?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115573","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do they have reports on Canadian content issues?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-750acbbdad7e87853fc9f959","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115574,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How about what percentage occurred outside of Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115574","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How about what percentage occurred outside of Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12bb7b77d93f06fa62d1a4db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115575,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Please do. Thank you. If a project receives EDC support, is there a minimum Canadian content requirement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115575","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Please do. Thank you. If a project receives EDC support, is there a minimum Canadian content requirement?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036415","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Non-repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036415","label":"Non-repayable contributions","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e60c1701ded4ddaa6ca5ab216ac421533ecdac4367eca91a694964f7d0ab4f80"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db29860e98c8fd6ef9586950","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115576,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Right, but is there a Canadian content requirement? This is a buy Canada study.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115576","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Right, but is there a Canadian content requirement? This is a buy Canada study.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2cd2a8add1b4d563e4c5b10bca2ff65079637f86915da82c5ebf27df176457f3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-873ece1d9dba01b4cfe3fc6f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115577,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Yes, I understand that, but you're using Canadian money, and we're asking right here at a buy Canada study what kind of Canadian content we have. How do Canadians track what they get out of buy Canadian content? Should Parliament be able to measure the Canadian economic return generated by this partnership?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115577","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, I understand that, but you're using Canadian money, and we're asking right here at a buy Canada study what kind of Canadian content we have. How do Canadians track what they get out of buy Canadian content? Should Parliament be able to measure the Canadian economic return generated by this partnership?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5b75d5f3579a948eb88dccf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115578,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What due diligence does Alstom conduct to ensure that workers in its global supply chain are not being exploited or working illegally? I understand that you're very heavily involved in China. I think you have 11 projects there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115578","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What due diligence does Alstom conduct to ensure that workers in its global supply chain are not being exploited or working illegally? I understand that you're very heavily involved in China. I think you have 11 projects there.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76908e198a03a1e45c50d9558ec9f8791a7efba376be97436a002525e9056d1f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fad2b44cda579862d3566c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115579,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm specifically asking what your due diligence requirements are.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115579","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm specifically asking what your due diligence requirements are.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1eaec4bc6a99fc4aeeed8b9cf6826a22c09de3198d30dbe104d5c17e177b6755"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6fe5c09f54a1486726590c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115580,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What are they?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115580","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What are they?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1a8f430005a791fbfb805c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115581,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Where do you report?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115581","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Where do you report?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b569cb4cc7f2942901ca194c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115582,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Is the funding—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115582","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is the funding—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e92d9f73a370e60cf77e9aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115583,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'll quickly change. Is the funding you receive from EDC subject to the buy Canadian rules, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115583","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll quickly change. Is the funding you receive from EDC subject to the buy Canadian rules, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b409dc01eb3aa9a44bb708d222f4a5eebf15fa69c0ac79382ef8af97c04f9c53"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c62b07609b7f58d8e77573d8e787a8b713d6eda25bc8067999b0e0a0751dfd8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e74fa8072d96d8c2501b5853","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087861,"date":"2026-06-17T21:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on behalf of the Conservative members of the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying to table, in both official languages, our supplementary opinion. Conservatives welcome the committee's recommendation that individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness be indefinitely excluded from eligibility for medical assistance in dying. This will save thousands of lives.\n\nThis is the position that Conservatives have held from the beginning. Conservatives opposed the Senate amendment to Bill C-7, which set this proposed expansion in motion. We have consistently echoed the warnings of experts that the expansion cannot be implemented safely. We call on the government to accept the committee's recommendation and support Bill C-218, which is already before the House and which would accomplish the policy objective the committee recommends. Conservatives are prepared to work collaboratively with the government to that end.\n\nOur supplementary opinion also notes that over the course of the committee study, as we were examining system readiness for expansion, many witnesses questioned the effectiveness and enforceability of the current MAID safeguards. Conservatives encourage the government to undertake a review of the current safeguards to ensure that no vulnerable Canadians fall through the cracks of a system that is supposed to protect them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087861","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on behalf of the Conservative members of the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying to table, in both official languages, our supplementary opinion. Conservatives welcome the committee's recommendation that individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness be indefinitely excluded from eligibility for medical assistance in dying. This will sa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff783c9c5bee9219ed21d31783355bfc6f495519d251d0e91021dfb6e8232369"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-480676629549c14bc6b36481","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115584,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Mr. Ettinger, Canada Post needs another $1 billion in taxpayer support to remain operational. At the same time, I understand that the corporation has committed itself to a $1-billion net-zero transformation. I'm wondering whether the priority going forward will be becoming profitable or meeting climate targets. Your plan estimates $1 billion to transition Canada Post to a low-carbon operating model. Is that still your estimate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115584","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Ettinger, Canada Post needs another $1 billion in taxpayer support to remain operational. At the same time, I understand that the corporation has committed itself to a $1-billion net-zero transformation. I'm wondering whether the priority going forward will be becoming profitable or meeting climate targets. Your plan estimates $1 billion to transition Canada Post to a low-carbon operating mode","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73372646255dae78095ce84c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115585,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I was looking for a yes-or-no answer. Is that still your estimate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115585","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I was looking for a yes-or-no answer. Is that still your estimate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b89b4ce6771eef7f8b4a6621","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115586,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I asked if your estimate for the transition to low carbon is still $1 billion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115586","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I asked if your estimate for the transition to low carbon is still $1 billion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","label":"Greenhouse gases","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a40cd468a50539b247553ae6efe94dc62cae472e70493b32b3c55f34a0d166ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f76107c2feca6c023bb9d3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115587,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. That's great. I'd like to follow up with a few more questions. Of that $1 billion, how much has already been spent? Perhaps Ms. El-Hage knows.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115587","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. That's great. I'd like to follow up with a few more questions. Of that $1 billion, how much has already been spent? Perhaps Ms. El-Hage knows.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ab1e5ae46d9e72aa6e782d8f14176667d5a337ec4d5b81290b43d5e03e2bc9d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b5884dd0460b3d849bae5c1ac2df66f0397cfda04006137dcbb0cb69c2bbc140"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27ce0b9ee170b2e9fc9b347f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115588,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm wondering how much has been spent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115588","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm wondering how much has been spent.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e98099f37ae95d9c352dda23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115589,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"It would be great if you could do that. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115589","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It would be great if you could do that. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65d018f7b29c943563cc3535","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115590,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I have a few questions in relation to that. Does the $1-billion estimate include the full cost of electrifying 100% of the fleet by 2040, as you have in your transition plan?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115590","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a few questions in relation to that. Does the $1-billion estimate include the full cost of electrifying 100% of the fleet by 2040, as you have in your transition plan?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f1c9b5708c65f59eae7e712179e5ad97c69c2b2e360a48c3b1614349a3334c0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a52b92f02077674ddbc2084c2eb82abf4316e1f2b85e60e249918651d8d7734a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-478ad3ef33bce5486cb310e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115591,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How much have you spent to date, while you were having struggles, on electric vehicles?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115591","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How much have you spent to date, while you were having struggles, on electric vehicles?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24b7f73c70562e7edfb01c98ed6bdba7635dd44eee241c874fa33763dc828259"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5588604554ec14dc21750a04","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115592,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You did not buy electric vehicles.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115592","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You did not buy electric vehicles.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5ee97558b3f4b9d7b9c36ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115593,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Did you put in any charging infrastructure?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115593","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Did you put in any charging infrastructure?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf6708eef71776233912a1e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115594,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Did you put in place any renewable electricity contracts?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115594","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Did you put in place any renewable electricity contracts?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22040bfd8779f9f05a9a0e7e517f3a530b5122513bccc2f48c074a26e2226fef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d72767af33b397b5477f4a6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115595,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How much was that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115595","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How much was that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5f17ea561f1c1236c5736cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115596,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Could you get that to us?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115596","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could you get that to us?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbd56a31ec0387f686a3acc2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115597,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What about carbon offsets?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115597","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What about carbon offsets?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-19afbffc583919c2e0827eec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115598,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Can you tell us how much?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115598","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Can you tell us how much?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e66f1e1479e799ea99a7d6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115599,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What about consultants for this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115599","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What about consultants for this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3dcc2b4a53762547a88129f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115600,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"What about climate reporting and compliance costs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115600","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What about climate reporting and compliance costs?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a573fc4df62d9bc2f3eb119","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115601,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I looked at your report, and it looked very fancy. If you did it with consultants, it looks as if it would be expensive. Has Canada Post updated the estimate to account for inflation and higher capital costs? Are you looking at that with your internal people?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115601","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I looked at your report, and it looked very fancy. If you did it with consultants, it looks as if it would be expensive. Has Canada Post updated the estimate to account for inflation and higher capital costs? Are you looking at that with your internal people?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5fc08d583b297f33447511b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115602,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"You've updated it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115602","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You've updated it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-911d980c55569f27fbce87d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115603,"date":"2026-06-18T16:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"I mean specifically related to this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115603","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I mean specifically related to this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9557ff9b45d3b70461803281","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115604,"date":"2026-06-18T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"We'd like to get those numbers, then. How about the unexpected repair and maintenance cost on the electric fleet? Have you guys looked at that at all?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115604","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We'd like to get those numbers, then. How about the unexpected repair and maintenance cost on the electric fleet? Have you guys looked at that at all?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9295571f259a5108740dfc06c25e7f1f6afbbf38f07924bd2f2017a6cf30cdc2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b55931345da98d57f7a53690","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115605,"date":"2026-06-18T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How big is the fleet?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115605","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How big is the fleet?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-106fbeac700d893a1e0277bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115606,"date":"2026-06-18T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. What is the largest single expenditure remaining under net zero? Is it pretty much everything?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115606","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. What is the largest single expenditure remaining under net zero? Is it pretty much everything?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gross domestic product","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","label":"Gross domestic product","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca086e878614f7888f264b2bb8806e6e0bcb24f199d76ae1699fc72d4969a1cc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6688f4672fd129635ab72ee7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115607,"date":"2026-06-18T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Your report estimates decarbonization potentially saving up to $85 million annually long term. Have those projections been independently validated?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115607","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Your report estimates decarbonization potentially saving up to $85 million annually long term. Have those projections been independently validated?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","label":"Life expectancy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e7ee83dbfed5901e76e290d7eb506ca277028c50d81416864d9466a689a05621"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1bd986d9c34f2439ac2a38aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115608,"date":"2026-06-18T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"How many years would it take for the projected savings to recover the estimated $1-billion investment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115608","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How many years would it take for the projected savings to recover the estimated $1-billion investment?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["592dd5bb237bae8d33c02c50645599bee5fb2adce72079ea97da40a14c6aaee1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c53a3cd8150c5c0be2134a1b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115609,"date":"2026-06-18T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. At the same time that the board approved net zero, was Canada Post already warning about its long-term financial sustainability?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115609","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. At the same time that the board approved net zero, was Canada Post already warning about its long-term financial sustainability?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f58c6d2a47c17429e72f6f52210fb685c9eef195549f8fc8b5a3279f7a22c121"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-535ec78e38aa6c5f3f50a885","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115610,"date":"2026-06-18T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Did the minister responsible for Canada Post review and approve those transition plans while you knew that you were already struggling?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115610","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Did the minister responsible for Canada Post review and approve those transition plans while you knew that you were already struggling?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["054f8d0fb15e8b7497cad82a7efa8dc46fd9253bc2e11e8d629ed64a480ad674"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b90a5e3148b4ea3fd7839aa3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115611,"date":"2026-06-18T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"So Minister Lightbound has been red-flagged.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115611","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"So Minister Lightbound has been red-flagged.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb7242aa23024b38141977f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115612,"date":"2026-06-18T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Did the minister ever direct Canada Post to delay, scale back or reconsider the transition because of your financial situation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115612","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Did the minister ever direct Canada Post to delay, scale back or reconsider the transition because of your financial situation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f90a2b45ccae8f0154518ae6f9f5ccade6036a8643c765904b172d7e2a12e8f0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb2178b8921bb96e46c80ca2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115613,"date":"2026-06-18T16:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Tamara Jansen","venue":"OGGO","text":"Did anyone in the government question whether a $1-billion climate transition should proceed while Canada Post was posting hundreds of millions of dollars in annual losses?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115613","member_id":"bc-mp-105774","member_name":"Tamara Jansen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Did anyone in the government question whether a $1-billion climate transition should proceed while Canada Post was posting hundreds of millions of dollars in annual losses?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["593acebcdf0ba122e97ca0ecd6f85c7b4943e310c5032ee9f54108970aa72ba9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f447317f8b5e39c6f273ef61","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340100,"date":"2026-03-12T15:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is my honour to present petition e-6974.\n\nI want to recognize my constituent TJ Hagarty from Fernie, British Columbia, for his dedication in bringing forward this important issue. Mr. Hagarty's family experienced a significant hardship when they were unable to transfer their son's medical care to Alberta rather than Vancouver due to limitations of the current system.\n\nI am proud to present this petition, which has gathered more than 2,500 signatures from residents across my riding. Since elected in 2019, I have worked hard to support constituents within our health care system. It is my responsibility on their behalf to bring this to the attention of the House of Commons.\n\n Petitioners call on the Government of Canada to work with the provinces to address the barriers in accessing care across provincial boundaries.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340100","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is my honour to present petition e-6974.\n\nI want to recognize my constituent TJ Hagarty from Fernie, British Columbia, for his dedication in bringing forward this important issue. Mr. Hagarty's family experienced a significant hardship when they were unable to transfer their son's medical care to Alberta rather than Vancouver due to limitations of the current system.\n\nI am proud to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8220f95bc5488cae2fec5809c0f253d22d76b719db3e7d0565a6f435686dc8e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0663b8db3c2de75d4aca1ecc75f4cc462546e80ef91980ac659620ec37e1fda9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-244540fd4be25311bc884e63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428922,"date":"2026-04-14T15:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present petition e-7104, with over 700 signatures.\n\n The petitioners call upon the Government of Canada to establish a comprehensive legal framework to protect minors from predatory drug dealers; to monitor social media, target online trafficking and require social media companies to implement policies to prevent it; to enact a federal law against child criminal exploitation based on the approach of the United Kingdom's crime and policing bill; and to empower and require police to thoroughly and effectively investigate all reports of drug trafficking and criminal exploitation involving minors, and to provide witness protection when needed.\n\n Sixty per cent of all illicit drug users in Canada are young people aged 15 to 24, and drug overdose is the leading cause of death among youth ages 10 to 18 in several Canadian provinces.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428922","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present petition e-7104, with over 700 signatures.\n\n The petitioners call upon the Government of Canada to establish a comprehensive legal framework to protect minors from predatory drug dealers; to monitor social media, target online trafficking and require social media companies to implement policies to prevent it; to enact a federal law against child criminal exp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9bab700d00dce31a0c34d8cf2612c9627cfaae0010c8e35e8975a587c1b762ae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["86a8728d0afa089d9a2813b2e6e41c011e0124c1ef074686e400faf3f8b4b583"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77d005443d6a1d1598e3e00b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115614,"date":"2026-04-20T16:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. Ms. Collier, my questions are going to be in your area. You have a generational history of fishing, much like our loggers in the interior and our guides and outfitters. I know that you know you need to have fish to support your family, generation after generation. Why is it so difficult for DFO to sit down and talk with our generational fisher people and get some of the expertise? I struggle with this because you are the real experts who know what's going on, not necessarily an academic who sits in Ottawa. Common sense is not all that common here. It certainly isn't common in this area because of some of the challenges you have. I wonder if you could comment on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115614","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Ms. Collier, my questions are going to be in your area. You have a generational history of fishing, much like our loggers in the interior and our guides and outfitters. I know that you know you need to have fish to support your family, generation after generation. Why is it so difficult for DFO to sit down and talk with our generational fisher people and get some of the expertise","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","label":"Fish farming","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1c1c854a3db9ab39ab8bad9f923c1f42798659074c92af5e841eb8682f7c01c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6645520df7e91d6539f4abe5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115615,"date":"2026-04-20T16:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"FOPO","text":"Here's a really big question: How do we somehow change that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115615","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Here's a really big question: How do we somehow change that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d934da3be06872cc2bb8be41fa94e866459ef6d631908d4ef49ed0a8b77e2b74"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8b8018488955b1421fb5af5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115616,"date":"2026-04-20T16:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115616","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-170454dd22efc71a8c03660a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115617,"date":"2026-04-20T17:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Griswold, not to hammer on this too hard, but did the DFO learn anything from 2025—for example, quicker change? More importantly, you also mentioned in your opening statement having stakeholders at a round table, government officials and indigenous. Do you think the DFO is going to learn from this and perhaps have expertise from actual fishermen who know what's going to happen if it doesn't follow some of the real science you're talking about?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115617","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Griswold, not to hammer on this too hard, but did the DFO learn anything from 2025—for example, quicker change? More importantly, you also mentioned in your opening statement having stakeholders at a round table, government officials and indigenous. Do you think the DFO is going to learn from this and perhaps have expertise from actual fishermen who know what's going to h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4fc38007fc6bbb9fd51c934","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115618,"date":"2026-04-20T17:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay, that's great. That's a good answer. Thank you. Mr. Chu, first of all, thank you for your 34 years in policing, law enforcement, with the RCMP and the New West Police Department.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115618","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay, that's great. That's a good answer. Thank you. Mr. Chu, first of all, thank you for your 34 years in policing, law enforcement, with the RCMP and the New West Police Department.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2335f3f965b5274db41ff48732c80f705debad97539723c06735ce4feb504c03"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["77abadff7584a423fb38eb0468d28b5a5913831235006bce7ea40b8f4a1da77d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5fda0343feb7e1655525165d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115619,"date":"2026-04-20T17:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"FOPO","text":"We talked a bit earlier about the guiding part. The numbers you have for hatchery-origin salmon are somewhat different from those of the DFO. How can we address this? When will the DFO finally bring in experts such as guides to help it develop policies rather than go off and not even listen to what you're saying?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115619","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We talked a bit earlier about the guiding part. The numbers you have for hatchery-origin salmon are somewhat different from those of the DFO. How can we address this? When will the DFO finally bring in experts such as guides to help it develop policies rather than go off and not even listen to what you're saying?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25815dbdb84cba29de6f9804","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115620,"date":"2026-04-20T17:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115620","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb62a0976a4529647ffc772f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085952,"date":"2026-06-08T17:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, coming from a rural area, when I go to the grocery store, people are telling me how expensive everything is, and it is a two-hour trip for me to go to a grocery store. Food prices are so high. Of course, fuel prices are high. I have had no one tell me they have never had it so good. \n\nI am wondering if the member can expand on that. Has he heard that? I cannot get out of a grocery store for two hours, because it is so expensive and people are blaming me for the food prices.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085952","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, coming from a rural area, when I go to the grocery store, people are telling me how expensive everything is, and it is a two-hour trip for me to go to a grocery store. Food prices are so high. Of course, fuel prices are high. I have had no one tell me they have never had it so good. \n\nI am wondering if the member can expand on that. Has he heard that? I cannot get out of a grocery s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93534e53fbb864c47e17b99b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085950,"date":"2026-06-10T19:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada has an incredible opportunity to become a global leader in the resources that power modern economies. In Columbia—Kootenay—Southern Rockies, the communities of Elk Valley and Trail are helping make that possible. Elk Valley is home to a highly skilled mining workforce that produces world-class metallurgical coal, while Trail earned an international reputation in excellence in metal processing, refining and innovation.\n\nSteel is fundamental to energy infrastructure, transportation networks and national defence. The materials required to produce steel are therefore critical to the economic and industrial security. Met coal, also known as steelmaking coal, is recognized as a critical mineral in the United States, the European Union and India. Canada needs to formally recognize metallurgical coal as a critical mineral as well. \n\nAs the global demand for critical minerals and steelmaking materials continues to grow, the workers, the families and the businesses of Elk Valley and Trail remain at the forefront of Canada's prosperity. I thank them for their hard work and invaluable contribution to our country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Metalworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085950","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada has an incredible opportunity to become a global leader in the resources that power modern economies. In Columbia—Kootenay—Southern Rockies, the communities of Elk Valley and Trail are helping make that possible. Elk Valley is home to a highly skilled mining workforce that produces world-class metallurgical coal, while Trail earned an international reputation in excellence in m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","label":"Coal"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","label":"Metalworking industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Metalworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","label":"Coal","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","label":"Metalworking industry","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["adb360b5ed28e5496d382149fea34c902364c955da207af48e0a8b48fd82f6b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Metalworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aa288ace1151bd2045f11e97709bb6fb168c36cea672f91128b4b489b67464ef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Metalworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Metalworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-534ab1f9447df81030fb9dbd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085951,"date":"2026-06-11T00:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Morrison","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to thank the hon. member, whom I have worked with. I appreciate victim services, after being in the RCMP for 35 years. I am thankful for what she has done.\n\nMy question goes back to the issue of mandatory minimum penalties for individuals who commit crimes. Do you think there is enough accountability in our Supreme Court justices? Can we hold them to account so they will actually put people in jail who need to go there for those minimum penalties? I think we are a little bit weak on that.\n\n I just wonder if the hon. member, whom I loved working with, could answer that question, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085951","member_id":"bc-mp-105807","member_name":"Rob Morrison","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to thank the hon. member, whom I have worked with. I appreciate victim services, after being in the RCMP for 35 years. I am thankful for what she has done.\n\nMy question goes back to the issue of mandatory minimum penalties for individuals who commit crimes. Do you think there is enough accountability in our Supreme Court justices? Can we hold them to account so they will actu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15f6db82f622bdc715f47f86e9a4d55243414c1d9f3c148ad896e011e954e131"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6dbe00d7fe45e1de8c08d94b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76898,"date":"2026-01-26T18:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I enjoyed serving with the member for Rivière-du-Nord on the justice committee when I was there in the last Parliament.\n\nI am happy the member raised the issue of the Jordan decision. From time to time, there are delays in criminal trials, and the Supreme Court weighed in with a case called Jordan and set minimum timelines. This hits home for me because there was a high-profile murder in the metro Vancouver area a few years ago. The family members lived in my riding. This is exactly what happened, although then the judge made the right decision by very much doing the calculus that this bill now sets out regarding how to measure delays.\n\nIn the hon. member's opinion, does Bill C-16 adequately answer the challenges that the Jordan decision has introduced into criminal law?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76898","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I enjoyed serving with the member for Rivière-du-Nord on the justice committee when I was there in the last Parliament.\n\nI am happy the member raised the issue of the Jordan decision. From time to time, there are delays in criminal trials, and the Supreme Court weighed in with a case called Jordan and set minimum timelines. This hits home for me because there was a high-profile murd","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fb136bb788d708f97edcd90aee9f9c6910f307caaee66509b54b96aea6530319"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4d597b0c22bbee7a096913e7640678e500657a799b9a803ee8d3b3324a86af55"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee26f50c72ebee286b7d7d00","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76899,"date":"2026-01-26T18:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, among other things, this bill introduces the concept of femicide, which is in response to a shocking rise in intimate partner violence in Canada. Effectively, that provision of Bill C-16 would elevate what might otherwise be second-degree murder to first-degree murder if done in the context of intimate partner violence.\n\nI think we are signalling that we are going to agree with this, but I wonder if the member could comment on whether it would survive an inevitable Charter of Rights challenge.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76899","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, among other things, this bill introduces the concept of femicide, which is in response to a shocking rise in intimate partner violence in Canada. Effectively, that provision of Bill C-16 would elevate what might otherwise be second-degree murder to first-degree murder if done in the context of intimate partner violence.\n\nI think we are signalling that we are going to agree with this","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ac6122b810dbec2a195478240794ea918fe5cbfb38335a2f55f985d28bdead1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["17d012ff3cfd8aa51c10dfc0098791048561bde5dee8a2011a408c103e736637"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2b6fc0ec3ed8277adcd7743","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76900,"date":"2026-01-26T21:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am puzzled about this debate around mandatory minimum sentences. When I read the proposed legislation, it definitely sounded like a back door for judges to be able to determine, with respect to a situation in front of them, that it would amount to cruel and unusual punishment to impose the minimum sentence. That is exactly the argument that judges have been using all along to declare mandatory minimum sentences to be unconstitutional. Therefore, I do not know how we are getting any further ahead, with this legislation, in handling the challenge that the court has thrown at us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76900","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am puzzled about this debate around mandatory minimum sentences. When I read the proposed legislation, it definitely sounded like a back door for judges to be able to determine, with respect to a situation in front of them, that it would amount to cruel and unusual punishment to impose the minimum sentence. That is exactly the argument that judges have been using all along to declar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c8bda2330320cdfa94b79b5405ba9da58b8faf55ffd9e66dc8b941c130e7a2d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f909881bffe4c0d7c51c0ad9c8a5b62024efe01e80a884e212e2541cf194f229"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75cc2927f88e6fa782ca60bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76901,"date":"2026-01-26T22:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am very happy that my colleague raised the Senneville case, which is very problematic. To my reading of that case, the problem is that the Supreme Court of Canada thinks that it can make up hypothetical, imaginary fact situations rather than just dealing with the fact situation that is in front of it.\n\nWould it be an improvement to this bill if we were to prohibit that sort of rationalizing by the Supreme Court?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76901","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am very happy that my colleague raised the Senneville case, which is very problematic. To my reading of that case, the problem is that the Supreme Court of Canada thinks that it can make up hypothetical, imaginary fact situations rather than just dealing with the fact situation that is in front of it.\n\nWould it be an improvement to this bill if we were to prohibit that sort of ratio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8ce30edad533aab80a8df9d45b04d187cdf1f7af83c7fd5fb806d2a779e010c8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29ca6f833561bc1ddf952205f2805c60c8d90c24669a7213b7ad7047ce422bb7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9a204c029596ab3d471378e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76902,"date":"2026-01-26T23:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this bill addresses, in part, the shocking rise of intimate partner violence in Canada and it introduces the concept of femicide, which is the murder of a woman in the context of an intimate partner violent crime. Effectively, what that would do is classify any murder, whether it was manslaughter or second-degree murder, as first-degree murder if it were done in the context of intimate partner violence. I wonder if our colleague would have any comment on whether that would survive the inevitable charter challenge in the first case before the courts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76902","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this bill addresses, in part, the shocking rise of intimate partner violence in Canada and it introduces the concept of femicide, which is the murder of a woman in the context of an intimate partner violent crime. Effectively, what that would do is classify any murder, whether it was manslaughter or second-degree murder, as first-degree murder if it were done in the context of intimat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","label":"Charters","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["29c16ad7cde485d6fb08d95b4531b12ae294561b042f90abb55b9fe5a57931b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c13e3c17306876d3c429088b27bb3ae82c000e216e44d4400527d5edd4990e7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb1b75ff99a6e3c6edbf65f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76903,"date":"2026-01-26T23:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague talked quite a bit about mandatory minimums and addressing the concern that our courts have had, particularly the Supreme Court of Canada, in declaring mandatory minimum penalties to be unconstitutional, contrary to section 12 of the charter. The problem we are facing is that courts have recently come out with the concept of hypothetical fact scenarios. Rather than dealing with the facts in front of them, they conjure up a hypothetical fact scenario and judge the constitutionality of the legislation against that hypothetical fact scenario.\n\nIf Bill C-16 is an improvement, should it prohibit judges from being able to use hypothetical fact scenarios?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76903","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague talked quite a bit about mandatory minimums and addressing the concern that our courts have had, particularly the Supreme Court of Canada, in declaring mandatory minimum penalties to be unconstitutional, contrary to section 12 of the charter. The problem we are facing is that courts have recently come out with the concept of hypothetical fact scenarios. Rather than d","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5dbeb9a8a63b19536927446eda1e857c0eec526c86d8e6d5b2b86f45d4dcf87c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["39cf2d25bc9a7cf69ecad7e2fb0811c19d4d05844c602c8b68e0c858d9547bac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b6bea88f448a10d1d3acf53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76904,"date":"2026-01-26T23:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for asking me a question, and I am going to answer it now.\n\nWhat would I do? We are talking about mandatory minimum sentences and a judge's inclination to conjure up hypothetical fact situations. I was reading section 63 of the proposed act, which would introduce proposed section 718.4 to the Criminal Code. It says that courts may steer around a minimum sentence if the minimum punishment would \"amount to cruel and unusual punishment for that offender.\"\n\nI was optimistic and thinking that \"for that offender\" would rule out hypotheticals. Is that what that section means, just for clarification?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76904","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for asking me a question, and I am going to answer it now.\n\nWhat would I do? We are talking about mandatory minimum sentences and a judge's inclination to conjure up hypothetical fact situations. I was reading section 63 of the proposed act, which would introduce proposed section 718.4 to the Criminal Code. It says that courts may steer around a minimum sentence if ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["18b70c3344602a04d5daa3313f556bf3673c547358138a2ded504670e29c3989"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a791e36459bdf70b42eb634954fd8ae7866356e0c2af29fe00a21d4a81334c14"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f213c493cd14c959820920e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76905,"date":"2026-01-28T19:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister is not keeping his promise to young Canadians to help them buy their first home. In fact, according to the Missing Middle report, things are going in the wrong direction. Home ownership among 30-year-olds is at an all-time low. Less than half think they are ever going to own their own home, and housing starts are not even keeping up with population growth.\n\nHere is an idea. We are feeling generous. Why does the Prime Minister not adopt our policies to cut bureaucracies so that homes get built and first-time Canadian buyers can buy their first home?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76905","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister is not keeping his promise to young Canadians to help them buy their first home. In fact, according to the Missing Middle report, things are going in the wrong direction. Home ownership among 30-year-olds is at an all-time low. Less than half think they are ever going to own their own home, and housing starts are not even keeping up with population growth.\n\nHere is ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0346d70c1d1f295ca7d017d8ad8084da2a3d292305df87aeb5c9ed783fd4758a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ceaddb31f8b1d65a1793e3a01bf5f45efddf189034aa38874013322fca195c5a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f54691ffb556179edc85bc61","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79291,"date":"2026-02-02T22:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-19, the proposed Canada groceries and essentials benefit act, is legislation introduced by the Liberals whereby they would give a handout to Canadian citizens to fill the gap they created in the first place. First, they erode Canadians' wealth by economic mismanagement, and then they give a temporary benefit and boast about their generosity. \n\nPerhaps the member could expand on his earlier comment, which is that the introduction of this legislation is really an admission of failure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79291","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-19, the proposed Canada groceries and essentials benefit act, is legislation introduced by the Liberals whereby they would give a handout to Canadian citizens to fill the gap they created in the first place. First, they erode Canadians' wealth by economic mismanagement, and then they give a temporary benefit and boast about their generosity. \n\nPerhaps the member could expand on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f954fdadece28369827c9463","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79292,"date":"2026-02-02T22:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague's speech was very inspiring.\n\n One thing I have noticed consistently during my years in the House is that when it comes to managing the economy, the Liberals always attack the symptoms and not the underlying problems. It is like taking an aspirin when surgery is required.\n\nThe Bank of Canada has said repeatedly that our lagging productivity metrics, when compared to those of our trading nations, are the problem. It is a crisis, and it is undermining Canadians' purchasing power.\n\nCould my colleague comment on the importance of the government's doing the hard work of attacking the underlying root problems so Canadians can get their purchasing power back again and not have to rely on handouts from the government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79292","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague's speech was very inspiring.\n\n One thing I have noticed consistently during my years in the House is that when it comes to managing the economy, the Liberals always attack the symptoms and not the underlying problems. It is like taking an aspirin when surgery is required.\n\nThe Bank of Canada has said repeatedly that our lagging productivity metrics, when compared to those","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e70f6b5cfc9b9beb139374ee123c0dad9f5b19a36d928bbdcd98c2bea1ca241c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0ce952ad15731cfecc68fc61f810730bc833bff222b1f7df1bd5d6b13d77f4e7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04ebc4afe35eeec58380f002","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288372,"date":"2026-02-09T18:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, we are talking about the creation of a commission for modern treaty implementation, which would replace the very effective work that has been done by the Office of the Auditor General. The Auditor General is responsible for reviewing government operations for accountability, transparency and the effective use of public funds.\n\nDoes my colleague agree that this new commission would have an inferior mandate, in that it would not have to audit the effective use of public funds?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288372","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, we are talking about the creation of a commission for modern treaty implementation, which would replace the very effective work that has been done by the Office of the Auditor General. The Auditor General is responsible for reviewing government operations for accountability, transparency and the effective use of public funds.\n\nDoes my colleague agree that this new commission would h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","label":"Financial audit"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","label":"Financial audit","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ed6cfb6c6042af1b8941ddb1325425a47d80765ec487091efc22aa4133c57f8f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba9c28a143406feb2a386c1d0cd68b44a0bee9ad5a0a8f6dcd8aa04618cc3ad5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4dae0b4c9868ece09c45eb1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288373,"date":"2026-02-09T21:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today we are talking about an act respecting the commissioner for modern treaty implementation. What would it do? The enactment would provide for the appointment of a commissioner of modern treaty implementation. The commissioner's job would be to conduct reviews and performance audits of the activities of the government related to the implementation of modern treaties, or rather, the government's failure to implement treaties. This is a failure that the Office of the Auditor General, another agency of Parliament, has pointed out in numerous reports. For years, the Auditor General has been shouting from the treetops that the government must take the treaty process seriously, and for 10 years, the Liberals have done nothing. They have dragged their feet. \n\nAdmittedly, this is not a problem of just the last 10 years; it has been brewing since the early days of Confederation. However, I must highlight that under the Conservative government of Stephen Harper, Canada negotiated five modern treaties. Since then, in the last 10 years, there have been zero, which is the problem. \n\nThe need to expedite treaties, as I said, goes back to the early days of our history, to the 1850s in British Columbia, when the British Crown claimed sovereignty over Vancouver Island and the mainland, what we now call British Columbia. There were some early treaties under Governor James Douglas, the Douglas treaties, over Vancouver Island. After that, subsequent governors and colonial legislatures dropped the ball. \n\nIn 1871, British Columbia became part of the Canadian Confederation, and at that time, the federal government took over some of the responsibility for treaty negotiations under section 91 of the British North America Act, but it too dropped the ball. This is continuing right now. The Liberals are continuing not to pick up the ball, not to run with it. \n\nWhat are the Liberals doing? They are hiding behind this proposed legislation. They want to appoint a commissioner to take a look at all of this, to see why things have not been happening. This is another unnecessary bill from a government that is lacking creativity. It is becoming a crisis. \n\nThe recent decision of the British Columbia Supreme Court in the Cowichan Tribes case underlines what happens when the Crown does not follow through with its commitments to respect indigenous rights. What do we get? We get community unrest, economic uncertainty and confusion. What did the judge say in that case? She said that aboriginal title is superior to fee simple title, which is a basic form of land ownership that everyone understands and that forms the very basis of our modern capitalist system. Our economy, banking system, financial security, home ownership and retirement planning are all based on the concept of fee simple. \n\nNow people and businesses in the Richmond area, where these lands are, as well as right across the whole province, are worried that their fee simple title is not as secure as they thought it was. What is important too is that banks and financial institutions are also starting to doubt the indefeasibility of fee simple title. We have heard of some big real estate deals collapsing on account of banks feeling nervous. The provincial government steps forward and says it will guarantee those loans, but that is not the solution. The solution is to deal properly and effectively with the first nations people and enter into treaties. \n\nThe land at the centre of this dispute is not in some remote area of British Columbia where the land is still owned by the Crown. No, it is right in the heart of metro Vancouver. There are commercial properties there, shopping malls, residential neighbourhoods and even a jet fuel tank station supplying nearby Vancouver International Airport. Quite frankly, Vancouver cannot operate without these lands staying pretty much exactly the way they are, so we have a very big problem. \n\nWhat is the solution? This speech is not about how to resolve the Cowichan lands challenges. I have some ideas, but that is not what we are talking about. Today we are talking about how we go forward with implementing modern-day treaties so we avoid ongoing issues like this and the economic uncertainty that arises. I raise this case only to point out how important and urgent it is that we move forward. \n\nThroughout B.C., there is a lot of work to be done. I am thinking of metro Vancouver and first nations communities in highly urbanized areas, like the Kwantlen First Nation in my home community of Fort Langley, or the Katzie First Nation in the northern part of my community, or the Semiahmoo in neighbouring White Rock. None of them have treaties, and they are losing confidence in the treaty process, so I welcome the debate, as people in my home province are concerned. \n\nHowever, it is not all negative. There is good news. In British Columbia, there have been some notable success stories in the ongoing quest to implement modern treaties. I want to talk about the Tsawwassen First Nation settlement of 2009.\n\n The Tsawwassen First Nation land, like the Cowichan land, is in metro Vancouver, surrounded by very valuable land. It is close to the port of Vancouver and the B.C. ferry terminal. There is a lot of good farmland there as well. This is one of the five modern treaties that were successfully negotiated during the Harper years, and it is a leading example of what can be done in an urbanized setting.\n\n The treaty transferred 724 hectares of land to the Tsawwassen First Nation community, which now holds it in fee simple. It is something they can take to the bank, which is not something they could have done under the Indian Act. The Tsawwassen First Nation community is acting on that. Its people have developed the land so that it is bringing prosperity to their community. They have a couple of very large shopping malls and industrial properties supporting the nearby port, and there is still lots of farmland available. Of the 724 hectares, I believe 500 is still farmland. This is very rich farmland, right in the Fraser River estuary, which supports Canadian food security and sovereignty.\n\n We have two examples coming out of British Columbia. One is a very good one, the Tsawwassen First Nation, and one is not so good, the Cowichan Tribes case. I suppose the latter might also be a good example of what could go wrong, underlining the urgency of moving forward. \n\nTo get back to the main topic, Bill C-10, an act respecting the commission for modern treaty implementation, people who were expecting that the bill would actually accelerate the treaty process in British Columbia and throughout Canada will be disappointed. The bill is simply about setting up a new bureaucracy to keep an eye on existing bureaucracies that have failed time and again to get the job done. \n\nIn my years in this Parliament, I have observed time and again how the Liberals act. Their politics is performative politics. They want to appear to be doing something about whatever is being debated in the Parliament of the day, the issues of the period. If major projects are being held up because of federal bureaucracy getting in the way, then let us set up a Major Projects Office. If housing is unaffordable and new houses are not being built, then we have an office for that too. Now, if indigenous treaty rights are not being respected, then let us set up a commission. However, it is not necessary. The Liberals appear to be doing something, but in fact, the bill before us would do very little to move the needle forward.\n\n I have just three words for the Liberals: \"Do your job.\" They should stop the performative arts, stop preening in front of the cameras, roll up their sleeves and, finally, for once, do the hard stuff.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288373","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today we are talking about an act respecting the commissioner for modern treaty implementation. What would it do? The enactment would provide for the appointment of a commissioner of modern treaty implementation. The commissioner's job would be to conduct reviews and performance audits of the activities of the government related to the implementation of modern treaties, or rather, the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["641f684516c705e46a78eaeedc1d17dae39b720632d2f921206592904fdee5b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a3644dc6249ff2903b57fde846a1234868fa4f0bdcc6b5aa997727127a595dd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb4894d2fa74bf0f2dbfd415","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288374,"date":"2026-02-09T21:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, indeed, we already have an agent that is responsible for that. That agent is called the Auditor General. The unfortunate part is that the Liberals have not been taking the reports from the Office of the Auditor General seriously. That applies to many matters, including when reports comment on their lack of action on indigenous rights and settling treaties. That should have been done a long time ago. It is time for them to do their job.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288374","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, indeed, we already have an agent that is responsible for that. That agent is called the Auditor General. The unfortunate part is that the Liberals have not been taking the reports from the Office of the Auditor General seriously. That applies to many matters, including when reports comment on their lack of action on indigenous rights and settling treaties. That should have been done a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fd21a5a9348b4a528a4beab8fb1be44efad14295cf1605e5fe52cae5b9b185cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba44951e1f4fbc3665acd0d40f77cf367ab240c228756221fd3c257d68a0851a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf589a2b86233e471c9b8855","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288375,"date":"2026-02-09T21:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to congratulate my colleague from Skeena—Bulkley Valley on the work he has done with the Haisla Nation and others in British Columbia for advancing indigenous reconciliation. I thank him very much for that.\n\nWith respect to accountability, the member pointed out correctly that the Auditor General is the ultimate holder to accountability of the government, and that office is being ignored. I predict that the Liberal government would ignore what this commissioner would say.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288375","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to congratulate my colleague from Skeena—Bulkley Valley on the work he has done with the Haisla Nation and others in British Columbia for advancing indigenous reconciliation. I thank him very much for that.\n\nWith respect to accountability, the member pointed out correctly that the Auditor General is the ultimate holder to accountability of the government, and that office is bei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f593a29c470a2b590c1cc5712dc1ecc2aafd497f48c72746cae0d2e27077cb19"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ec7529c75dcd2b8de253fe8b3391165ce9b0bbcda66c4c2c2e8e580c97f44e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e9d77fd31bfcc04e907e852","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288376,"date":"2026-02-09T21:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, indeed it is the government's job to implement these treaties. As the opposition, our job is to hold the government to account, as it is that member's responsibility as well.\n\n We need the Conservatives to form government. I am thinking of the Harper days when we actually got the job done. It can be done, and we are waiting for the government to finally take action to get the job done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288376","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, indeed it is the government's job to implement these treaties. As the opposition, our job is to hold the government to account, as it is that member's responsibility as well.\n\n We need the Conservatives to form government. I am thinking of the Harper days when we actually got the job done. It can be done, and we are waiting for the government to finally take action to get the job done","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56e934f29162dc27fc9a5a5d09ce254a40e34f285a409fed0ae4c86177ba9923"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29892ce246a34558d9cbfb45","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288370,"date":"2026-02-12T19:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, under the Liberal government, the Canadian dream of home ownership is rapidly fading for young people. CMHC reports that housing construction is actually going to be down over the next three years by up to 18% compared to last year.\n\nWhy do the Liberals not just adopt the Conservative plan to eliminate GST on all new housing construction of up to $1.3 million and help restore the dream of home ownership for young Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288370","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, under the Liberal government, the Canadian dream of home ownership is rapidly fading for young people. CMHC reports that housing construction is actually going to be down over the next three years by up to 18% compared to last year.\n\nWhy do the Liberals not just adopt the Conservative plan to eliminate GST on all new housing construction of up to $1.3 million and help restore the drea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f059f20d56d603cdd3cdb116c13a8e8784b9162eb71b7464b61087c30a17112f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["79666a7179098489fe69b6e9d95add89c6ab9129529cea9b81ea4a2d93e01232"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aaf02e889701a10308478d56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288371,"date":"2026-02-12T19:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that answer is completely unacceptable. The Canadian Home Builders' Association says that, five years ago, new housing starts in the ownership market stood at 69%, the rest being in the rental market. Last year, that number dropped down to 49%. \n\nDespite all the nice talk, clearly the Liberal plans are not helpful for prospective new buyers. Again, why do they not just adopt our plans and help restore the dream of home ownership once again for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288371","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that answer is completely unacceptable. The Canadian Home Builders' Association says that, five years ago, new housing starts in the ownership market stood at 69%, the rest being in the rental market. Last year, that number dropped down to 49%. \n\nDespite all the nice talk, clearly the Liberal plans are not helpful for prospective new buyers. Again, why do they not just adopt our plans","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["99d0002b98b1dd707beddc072899b65f99a7659afc98414894d68038f7d63d76"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bdf301c5e154d4b0ebb993e7d144bbb7742777f3d0b80a3f31939311eb0e5ba5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-912793b302d34361b2263426","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315061,"date":"2026-02-23T20:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-20, a bill from the Liberal government to establish yet another federal Crown corporation, called Build Canada Homes, which would apparently finally find the solution to the economic woes in our housing sector that have stubbornly evaded solutions provided by existing federal bureaucracies. The stated purpose of Build Canada Homes is to \"promote, support and develop the supply of affordable housing in Canada and to promote innovative and efficient building techniques in the housing construction sector in Canada\". I know that sounds optimistic. Let us test that claim, that aspirational statement, against reality.\n\nFor 10 years, we have had a Liberal government that thinks it is smarter than the free market. We hear it again today, that the government has all the solutions to all the problems and that with enough central planning, it can make the market behave the way it thinks it should behave. In my years in Parliament, I have observed time and again that the Liberal government's politics are performative in nature. It wants to appear to be doing something about whatever the problem is that is being debated that day. If major projects are being held up because of federal bureaucracy, well, let it create a major projects office. If military procurement is a mess, let it set up a commission to look at why all the other commissions have not been doing their job. Now, in a situation of housing unaffordability and new houses not being built to keep up with demand, we have a new bureaucracy for that too: a new Crown corporation, in fact. Build Canada Homes, it will be called.\n\nHere is what Canadians will get out of this new corporation. First of all, it will create its own bureaucracy, a board of directors comprising eight to 10 people, a chairperson, a full-time CEO, all of whom will be on the federal payroll. Secondly, it will get into the business of building affordable homes, apparently. It is good timing, I say somewhat facetiously, just as the B.C. government is getting out of that line of business. The headline in the Vancouver Sun over the weekend, screaming on the front page, is \"'A massive step back' for housing\", while David Eby is grappling with a stunning $13.8-billion operating deficit just three years after he inherited a surplus of $5 billion from the previous government. Another headline on the same topic reads, \"Loss of provincial fund upends many affordable rental projects\". People are up in arms about this. They want to know what is going on. The provincial government has made all these promises, and now it is abandoning ship because it does not have the money to do it.\n\nThirdly, this new, highly paid bureaucracy will analyze what is wrong with the current state of affairs in the housing sector and advise government as to what to do, how to tweak things. One of the first reports coming out of this agency, this Crown corporation, no doubt, will analyze the current housing market in Canada and why it is in such a state of imbalance, despite the existence of federal government bureaucracies and best intentions that were supposed to make things better. This is the fourth bureaucracy, now. We already have the Canada Lands Company. We have the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation. We have Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada. I would just point this out: If creating bureaucracies could solve the problem, we would not have a problem.\n\nLet us take a look at the track record of the current bureaucracies. According to CMHC's own recent housing market outlook for 2026, housing starts are heading in the wrong direction, despite all the announcements from the Liberals, below the target necessary to restore housing affordability. A quote from the report sums it up very nicely. It says, \"New home construction is set to decline through 2028 as developers face high costs, weaker demand and more unsold homes.\" Can members imagine this, in an economy where there are not enough homes? This is especially true in B.C, where, the report predicts, \"Housing starts will continue to slow down in 2026, with a more significant decline...in 2027-2028.\" We are headed in the wrong direction.\n\n The Canadian Home Builders' Association had this to say in its Q4 report from last year: \"Setting new record lows in builder sentiment was the unfortunate theme for the [housing market index] in 2025.\" Builders are losing faith in their ability to build homes in the current sector, the environment that the Liberals have created. Ontario and British Columbia unfortunately will \"lead the way in terms of broad pessimism among single- and multi-family builders.\"\n\nYes, it is pessimistic. People want to buy or rent homes but lack the financial resources to buy. Builders are being pessimistic about their ability to meet the demand in face of high costs that drive sale prices beyond what the market can bear. There is a serious imbalance in our economy, in other words.\n\nAs I was preparing my notes, I thought of the famous economist Friedrich Hayek, the free-market economist who spoke about this in his famous 1945 essay, \"The Use of Knowledge in Society\". I will paraphrase it. I just want to highlight that Friedrich Hayek was of the classical liberal tradition of economics, the tradition that the Liberal Party of Canada used to follow until it abandoned all that and Liberals became central planning socialists. That is what they are today.\n\n I will go back to Friedrich Hayek, who had this to say: \"The beauty of the market lies in its ability to coordinate actions without requiring omniscience.\" He also said, \"The fatal flaw of central planning is the assumption that someone knows enough to direct the use of resources efficiently.\" Here is another quote, a third from Professor Hayek: \"No single mind can comprehend the complexity of modern economic activity—only a decentralized process can manage it.\"\n\nThe Liberals do not believe that. They used to believe it, but they do not believe it anymore. They have now abandoned classical liberal tradition to adopt central planning socialism. Today they think they are the omniscience, the single mind that can comprehend the complexity of modern economic activity.\n\nThat is all we need to know to understand why the Liberals are always so optimistic that their next government central planning agency is finally going to solve the problem. If it does not, then the next one will, and the next one after that. They are always optimistic and always dreaming, always with wishful thinking. If Liberal wishful thinking would build homes, Canada would have the most affordable, the most successful and the most balanced housing market in the world, but that is unfortunately not the case.\n\nPeople who expect that the bill would actually accelerate affordable housing construction in Canada will be disappointed. The bill is simply about setting up a new bureaucracy to keep an eye on the existing bureaucracies that have failed time and time again to solve our housing affordability crisis and our housing availability crisis. Young people particularly are paying the price for all this mismanagement.\n\nIn closing, here is some free advice for the Liberals from the free-market Conservatives. We continue to adopt and follow free-market economics because that is the solution to our economic goals: Just get out of the way. What the Liberals have been doing for the last 10 years has not been working, and the newly repackaged commission, the newly repackaged and restructured bureaucracy, would not solve the problem either. We wish the Liberals would just get out of the way and let smart Canadians build homes to meet market demand.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315061","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-20, a bill from the Liberal government to establish yet another federal Crown corporation, called Build Canada Homes, which would apparently finally find the solution to the economic woes in our housing sector that have stubbornly evaded solutions provided by existing federal bureaucracies. The stated purpose of Build Canada Homes is to \"promote, support and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eec0437986adbaced18feef33fb2e91a7cf3ca4291d8955b2a8ea0fdbc78380e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9512e31cf7ffc59c673898f9b9ecad3fc018c1da05ff3c755cd219f0c9b62f5d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b812da054322eb872dd498a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315062,"date":"2026-02-23T20:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the question just underlines what I was saying: Governments do not build homes. People build homes. Home builders build homes. Electricians, drywallers, carpenters and land developers are the ones who build homes. The government just needs to get out of the way and create the environment that welcomes investment so people will actually build homes and so the market meets the demand.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315062","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the question just underlines what I was saying: Governments do not build homes. People build homes. Home builders build homes. Electricians, drywallers, carpenters and land developers are the ones who build homes. The government just needs to get out of the way and create the environment that welcomes investment so people will actually build homes and so the market meets the demand.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["325939ae5555c3b728c5e451f1bb9e2f66e44e8a3060702c7fcda5c5a46d16d9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["331024ddf3583414abce980d09db315341401ada6ad4de87561bb8987aa4952c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-afead01a4995ce98b1919af4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315063,"date":"2026-02-23T20:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the question from my colleague from the Bloc Québécois was a thoughtful one. I live in a community that is highly urbanized, but parts of it are still rural, so I sympathize with the question.\n\n I will revert back to what I had said earlier, which is that the market generally sorts things out. If there is a demand in smaller communities, it will be filled if the government gets out of the way. \n\nIs there a role for government? Provincial and federal governments own a lot of land. Maybe they should put that out into the marketplace. I know there are areas in British Columbia that would benefit greatly from the release of federal lands from federal control. Put it into private enterprise and let us build.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315063","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the question from my colleague from the Bloc Québécois was a thoughtful one. I live in a community that is highly urbanized, but parts of it are still rural, so I sympathize with the question.\n\n I will revert back to what I had said earlier, which is that the market generally sorts things out. If there is a demand in smaller communities, it will be filled if the government gets out of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e0a3bf74503f1647ec3260498870ff710b68db5d87a9cfa320c48a9e918dba8d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e4326ec6e07d9d97898d36613eeaf39081145ea02555bb51be2de815502fc97"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d5aeb274385ee46daf98e0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315064,"date":"2026-02-23T21:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is an important question, but I am really the wrong person to be asking it to. Trying to get into the minds of the Liberals is hard to do, but what I have observed time and again is that the Liberal politics of the Liberal Party of the 2020s is all performative politics. It just wants it to seem that it is doing something. If there is a problem, it has a solution: another organization, photo op or ribbon cutting, and the problem is solved. That is its problem.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315064","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is an important question, but I am really the wrong person to be asking it to. Trying to get into the minds of the Liberals is hard to do, but what I have observed time and again is that the Liberal politics of the Liberal Party of the 2020s is all performative politics. It just wants it to seem that it is doing something. If there is a problem, it has a solution: another organiz","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["38eeed99cad91c92600333487088c4137e9eacc4d3b0039e9b5593ddbce38451"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43a67861dca81f495a10e745","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315065,"date":"2026-02-23T21:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is interesting that every time the member for Winnipeg North stands up, he is accusing us of filibustering. This is an important topic. It is very important for Canadians, certainly in my home province of British Columbia, where housing affordability really is a crisis for young people. These are important issues. We need to be debating them in the House of Commons, and that is exactly what we are doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315065","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is interesting that every time the member for Winnipeg North stands up, he is accusing us of filibustering. This is an important topic. It is very important for Canadians, certainly in my home province of British Columbia, where housing affordability really is a crisis for young people. These are important issues. We need to be debating them in the House of Commons, and that is exa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3ce02f9595bd96cd0aae98692c3ca5fb3485659e48018b295334849e0f627af"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65fad83d7d1844709a2c7c7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306976,"date":"2026-02-27T16:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, despite promising the fastest-growing economy in the G7, the Prime Minister has delivered the weakest. Today, we are the only country in the G7 with a shrinking economy and young people are paying the price.\n\nThe generation that should be building up wealth for the future is instead falling further behind. Personal debt is at an all-time high. Savings are basically non-existent, and millennials are giving up hope. They want to know when the government will create a working economy so that they can have hope for a better future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306976","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, despite promising the fastest-growing economy in the G7, the Prime Minister has delivered the weakest. Today, we are the only country in the G7 with a shrinking economy and young people are paying the price.\n\nThe generation that should be building up wealth for the future is instead falling further behind. Personal debt is at an all-time high. Savings are basically non-existent, and m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d214364c89c2d405c1c087e9338de7b10be145e32eb399fc8f353bbefa358b1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75c9d4181f0229df7a4588592528f83b1cb08d4abb61b6be8b76eae924c84fb9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-edf4164cabdb89c47f0df225","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306977,"date":"2026-02-27T17:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak about a private member's bill sponsored by my good friend and colleague, the member for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. \n\nIt is a great piece of legislation that will amend the Corrections and Conditional Release Act with a focus on victims. It is a simple bill that will have a significant and positive impact on our justice system. Unlike other criminal bills, this one does not create a new crime or further define an existing crime. It does not create new penalties for something that already is illegal. It will have no impact on people who have been convicted of a crime and who are incarcerated. However, it will have a very big and positive impact on victims of crime. \n\nAt the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights, when I served on that committee in the last Parliament, we conducted a study on victims of crime. We learned from many victims and their families that, from their perspective, Canada's criminal justice system feels more like a criminal system than a justice system. That is because the focus is on the criminal: Are they guilty? Do we have enough evidence to convict them in a court beyond a reasonable doubt? What would be the appropriate sentence if they are found guilty, or the appropriate release conditions? \n\nUnderlying all of this, of course, is the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the legal right everybody has to be presumed innocent. That is all important stuff and nobody is arguing about that. We want a criminal justice system that is fair, balanced and in compliance with our charter, but in all of that, where are the innocent victims whose lives have been upended by the terrible acts of the convicted criminal? \n\nToo often the lives of the victims are a sideshow in our criminal justice system. They need to be more front and centre. We want justice after all, not just for the criminal and not just to put people away for public safety or for punishment. We want a true sense of justice for the innocent, so that they too feel that the justice system is working for them. \n\nThat is why I am so pleased that my colleague, the member for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, brought forward this private member's bill to amend the Corrections and Conditional Release Act focusing on victims. In his speech in this chamber a couple of months ago when this bill was first introduced, he shared a personal story about how a crime committed many years ago impacted him and his family, and to this day the impact is still felt. It never goes away.\n\n I am also very pleased that another colleague, the member for Oshawa, has seconded the bill. She too has a connection with this piece of legislation, because it was her predecessor, a member of Parliament, our friend and former colleague Colin Carrie, who introduced a similar private member's bill in the last Parliament. It was called Bill C-320. \n\nAt that time, all the parties agreed it should go ahead and it almost made it over the finish line. It went through the first, second and third readings here. Then it went to the other place for the first and second readings. It then went to committee for third reading. The only thing that was left to do was royal proclamation. What happened to it? It died on the Order Paper when Prime Minister Trudeau prorogued Parliament early last year for the sole purpose of rescuing his faltering Liberal Party from falling over the cliff. I will have more on that some other day, because that is not what we are talking about today. \n\nWe are now here in the 45th Parliament and again it appears we have all-party support for this common-sense Conservative bill that is going to have a real and positive impact on victims and their families.\n\nIn preparing my talking points for my intervention today, I took the opportunity to read the speeches published in the Hansard that were delivered by other members of other parties. It looks like the Bloc Québécois will support it. That is great. We know the Liberals will support it. As a matter of fact, they like the bill so much that they have adopted the substance of it and have incorporated it into one of their bills, Bill C-16, which is a very large criminal justice bill that runs 166 pages. It is at the justice committee right now undergoing a very thorough review. It may come back here, but in the meantime, we are going to keep pushing my colleague's private member's bill.\n\nAs an aside, I am feeling positive. We are seeing a lot of stealing of ideas in the current Parliament, with the Liberals adopting Conservative proposals and calling them their own, proposals that just a short while ago they were criticizing and scoffing at. Now I guess they have finally seen the light. Imitation is the highest form of admiration. I can tell members that it feels really good to be admired by the Liberal side of the House for a change. We do not get a lot of that.\n\nHowever, I do not want to make too much of this recent and probably very temporary sense of goodwill. The chamber is a very adversarial one after all. Let us just settle on this. This is good legislation, and we should push it through as quickly as we can.\n\nI am well into my speech and I realize I have not even said what the bill would do. I can do no better than to summarize with a sentence from the speech I referenced earlier from my friend, the member for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. He said this on November 18, 2025: \"Transparency and accountability are core principles of our democracy, and the bill we debate today seeks to enhance the application of these essential principles, specifically for the benefit of those victimized by crime.\" This is a really good summary.\n\nWhat would the bill do? It seeks to amend the Corrections and Conditional Release Act to ensure that victims receive clear explanations about how an offender's eligibility and review dates for temporary absences, release or parole are determined. Victims and their families would be told not only when those dates will be but also the rationale behind why those dates have been chosen, because we believe transparency and accountability are core principles of our democracy.\n\nWe have heard from victims of crime that Canada's criminal justice system feels deliberately opaque. They feel left in the dark. It does not have to be that way. We can do better. The bill is a small step in that direction. Let us expedite it through the House and the other place, and push Canada's criminal justice system another small step towards true justice for everyone, including victims of crime.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306977","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak about a private member's bill sponsored by my good friend and colleague, the member for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. \n\nIt is a great piece of legislation that will amend the Corrections and Conditional Release Act with a focus on victims. It is a simple bill that will have a significant and positive impact on our justice system. Unlike other criminal bills, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["10442b9baef4a5ce1b6a136671ea1ef491edd78e43b1c704013451d30d0f5689"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["50e99a8ab2bce309e7f8da26b6df04e407c9a4aec807abe1eaec345d74189b8e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c067727bb9064b85ce88487","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340101,"date":"2026-03-12T20:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his speech on Canada accepting the U.K. into the CPTPP. It is my understanding that Canada trades freely with the other countries in that agreement with respect to beef and pork.\n\nDo Canadians have a legitimate concern that the government has failed to come to that agreement with the United Kingdom?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340101","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his speech on Canada accepting the U.K. into the CPTPP. It is my understanding that Canada trades freely with the other countries in that agreement with respect to beef and pork.\n\nDo Canadians have a legitimate concern that the government has failed to come to that agreement with the United Kingdom?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd6ed811a60aaf90c16b4415","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340102,"date":"2026-03-12T20:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-13 is the bill by which the United Kingdom will be brought into the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership, or CPTPP. All of the other countries, and I believe there are 11 of them besides Canada, accept beef imports and pork imports from Canada, yet the United Kingdom is putting up non-tariff barriers to that. I wonder if the member could comment on that. Was that an oversight on the part of the Canadian negotiating team?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340102","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-13 is the bill by which the United Kingdom will be brought into the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership, or CPTPP. All of the other countries, and I believe there are 11 of them besides Canada, accept beef imports and pork imports from Canada, yet the United Kingdom is putting up non-tariff barriers to that. I wonder if the member could comment","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a71a96af964f69f441480370b6dd6a7fa3d539d8539a50ced6a7e77cbf94c37d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cac5632bca460e4897c9468b23032e4c51b7eaf253bc8d3cd3a8dcba5c280280"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc821bfcbda499365684ed03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340103,"date":"2026-03-12T21:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with my colleague from Peace River—Westlock that Alberta grain-fed beef is the best in the world. I love our friends from Great Britain, and I want them to benefit from Alberta grain-fed beef, but here is another thing. I love people from Ontario, and I want them to benefit from the best wine in Canada, British Columbia wine.\n\n I know it is not the topic of the day, but can my friend comment on the importance of British Columbia wine in LCBO stores?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:140019","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340103","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with my colleague from Peace River—Westlock that Alberta grain-fed beef is the best in the world. I love our friends from Great Britain, and I want them to benefit from Alberta grain-fed beef, but here is another thing. I love people from Ontario, and I want them to benefit from the best wine in Canada, British Columbia wine.\n\n I know it is not the topic of the day, but can my","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:140019","label":"Wine"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:140019","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:140019","label":"Wine","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc3e2234bc81cfce5dc9c1fda4922546979e1dd92c38fcc50c7644a9af3f98e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:140019","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18678ee894fb35a5cee070f28d1ce654252811d0ae42168c6ecbc7352adbcc72"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:140019","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:140019","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fdc569d33961a4cd1f4d330f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340104,"date":"2026-03-12T22:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-13 is about bringing the United Kingdom into the comprehensive trade agreement with the Pacific. The member for Courtenay—Alberni mentioned frozen pensions for U.K. pensioners who decide to retire here in Canada. It seems deeply unfair, particularly since the U.K. does not do that for other countries like the United States. As a matter of fact, it seems to be picking on Commonwealth countries. This agreement seems like the perfect opportunity to resolve that problem, yet the Prime Minister has failed to do that. \n\nI would like to hear the member's comments on what that says about the Prime Minister's ability, or perhaps lack thereof, to negotiate good deals for Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340104","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-13 is about bringing the United Kingdom into the comprehensive trade agreement with the Pacific. The member for Courtenay—Alberni mentioned frozen pensions for U.K. pensioners who decide to retire here in Canada. It seems deeply unfair, particularly since the U.K. does not do that for other countries like the United States. As a matter of fact, it seems to be picking on Commonw","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["50ccab5aa1640bb530d5846490207894e955bc0f24c901519c781e5491c196f2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8bf5b017b5550fb86b56d75d8358c699e41c264c58c1e21a83e6373ae5280440"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aeaa4a648a549f19231a26d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340105,"date":"2026-03-12T23:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a couple of weeks ago, I had a round of questions in question period about Canada's housing affordability crisis hitting young people particularly hard. Normally, supply meets demand, which is just economics 101, but the current real estate market is in such a state of imbalance that the new homes that buyers want and can afford are just not being built. That was the basis of my question. \n\nI noted that despite demand, CMHC was reporting a reduction in new housing starts over the next few years. The response I received was that we should just support the Liberals' housing plans, which are the ones that have been missing the mark and causing all the problems in the first place. \n\nI was directed to Bill C-20, the Build Canada Homes act, which a couple of sitting days later I actually had the opportunity to speak to. I am not going to repeat that speech, but I will highlight a couple of quotes from Professor Friedrich Hayek, the 20th-century free market economist of the classical liberal tradition. \n\nI noted, and will note again, that the current Liberal Party has abandoned classical liberal economics and replaced it with central planning socialism. This is why I quoted Friedrich Hayek, because he spent a good part of his academic life attacking central planning socialism and pointing out its weaknesses. He said, \"The beauty of the market lies in its ability to coordinate actions without requiring omniscience.\" He also said, \"No single mind can comprehend the complexity of modern economic activity—only a decentralized process can manage it.\"\n\nThe Liberals used to believe that, but they do not anymore. They have become central planning socialists. They think that they are, in the professor's words, the \"omniscience\" or the single mind that can comprehend the complexity of modern economic activity. They think that just one more little tweak or a little adjustment to our comprehensive plans, one new bureaucracy, and the problem will be solved and the market will start to behave the way they think it should behave. \n\nThe Liberals have failed so far, and they will continue to fail until they understand that the best thing they can do is to just get out of the way of the free market and let the market decide how it is going to be. The answer is not another bureaucracy and not an over-regulated economy. It is just to let the market behave the way it should. Do they agree with that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340105","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a couple of weeks ago, I had a round of questions in question period about Canada's housing affordability crisis hitting young people particularly hard. Normally, supply meets demand, which is just economics 101, but the current real estate market is in such a state of imbalance that the new homes that buyers want and can afford are just not being built. That was the basis of my quest","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["777a4eee32a4447c38716d8edba285796c93ed0a1d46a852e1624650b506ef58"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9743974991890081ebc465152c682cf6c462f66beefea56630f52c31464d2807"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d96a371b9725599fce663375","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340106,"date":"2026-03-12T23:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if all that wishful thinking would actually solve the problem, we would not have a problem. I think the member will agree that we actually do face a housing affordability crisis.\n\nI just want to give a couple of examples of the government getting in the way. In a British Columbia setting, we have the provincial government chasing away investment dollars that drive the pre-sale market, which is one of the pillars of condo market financing. Number two is the national building code driving an aggressive green agenda that is not tied to economic reality. Third is the wild west in development cost charges by municipalities that is taking any profit away from builders. I was talking to one land developer who says that until there is a change in attitude, they are leaving their money in a GIC, which is much safer and returning a better profit these days.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340106","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if all that wishful thinking would actually solve the problem, we would not have a problem. I think the member will agree that we actually do face a housing affordability crisis.\n\nI just want to give a couple of examples of the government getting in the way. In a British Columbia setting, we have the provincial government chasing away investment dollars that drive the pre-sale market,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb117826f3a410ac317580b71d434f1da37d7ec579949bc0365a73e687d441cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd59383480efd00cd45b5a45dd92a8167175c84c4dbb414d97dd820b063c5b82"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d9beeffe214a26cd33c1a35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428928,"date":"2026-04-13T19:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the recent B.C. Supreme Court ruling in Cowichan Tribes calls into question whether private property rights in Canada are secure, creating unnecessary economic risk in our economy. Clearly the Liberals have dropped the ball on this one, and right at a time when Canadians are facing pressure from higher costs and economic uncertainty.\n\nWill the Liberal Prime Minister direct the lawyers to argue that private property rights in Canada must be secure for homeowners, farmers, businesses and investors? It must be number one.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428928","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the recent B.C. Supreme Court ruling in Cowichan Tribes calls into question whether private property rights in Canada are secure, creating unnecessary economic risk in our economy. Clearly the Liberals have dropped the ball on this one, and right at a time when Canadians are facing pressure from higher costs and economic uncertainty.\n\nWill the Liberal Prime Minister direct the lawyers","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a445057cf81aba736eb09b13f2c4037680826bd591c2e3d75dd1d7bf74bd785a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8fda05643c49f8de5881f21a313929a729db845a728b49b6ddb17916e2dc001"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-19262aaebe83fdcbe3b6aea5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115628,"date":"2026-04-16T16:15:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the witnesses for coming here today and sharing their wisdom and knowledge with us as we undertake this study on the state of civic resilience in Canada today. Mr. Gunn, maybe I'll start with you. You talked about voter engagement and the work that your organization has been doing in encouraging young people to get involved. I think that work has borne some fruit. I understand that in the last election, in 2025, voter participation among younger people went up. However, overall, our voter turnout is not that great. There was a record turnout of 80% back in 1958, in the John Diefenbaker landslide. That's sort of the benchmark, and it's been sliding since then. It sort of bumps up and down a bit. Provincially, sometimes it's very low, and in by-elections, it's particularly low. Perhaps you could comment on voter turnout and how that ties into a sense of civic resilience.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115628","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the witnesses for coming here today and sharing their wisdom and knowledge with us as we undertake this study on the state of civic resilience in Canada today. Mr. Gunn, maybe I'll start with you. You talked about voter engagement and the work that your organization has been doing in encouraging young people to get involved. I think that work has borne some f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036076","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Landslides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036076","label":"Landslides","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5cd796f3ed6702d83dd7b6943ee77dd3e3f0b67a0f6757d7138165c38532f985"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1a3ffd03ff75d54aafbf52592513ecee8b1a2941947bc6b820a2859f44fe36b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b80ea52655e794206c2c107a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115629,"date":"2026-04-16T16:20:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Mr. Bridgman, I'll just bring it over to you. You talked about where Canada is in regulating platforms, and I think that you're being critical of Canada being a laggard there. However, we do have Bill C-18 , which became law in the last Parliament. Again, we're talking about civic resilience and civic engagement, so is Bill C-18 a net benefit or a net detraction from that, in your opinion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115629","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Bridgman, I'll just bring it over to you. You talked about where Canada is in regulating platforms, and I think that you're being critical of Canada being a laggard there. However, we do have Bill C-18 , which became law in the last Parliament. Again, we're talking about civic resilience and civic engagement, so is Bill C-18 a net benefit or a net detraction from that, in your opinion?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-764f6e701418f064e5f94f75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115630,"date":"2026-04-16T17:55:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all of the witnesses. Mr. Carpay, I have a question for you. I'm looking at a briefing note that we have from the Library of Parliament, prepared by our very capable analysts, which I thank them for. In it, they cite some Statistics Canada information about the degree of confidence that Canadians have in several of our important democratic institutions, one of them being our criminal justice system. Apparently only 48.2% of Canadians have confidence in our criminal justice system, which seems pretty startling to me. I don't know if you have a comment about that. I know you're legally trained. You talked about the rule of law, equality and race-based policies. You have race-based sentencing, and we have, not to be partisan, what we call catch-and-release bail rules. Now we also have sentencing based on a person's immigration status. We're talking about civic resilience, keeping in mind that's the purpose of my question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115630","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all of the witnesses. Mr. Carpay, I have a question for you. I'm looking at a briefing note that we have from the Library of Parliament, prepared by our very capable analysts, which I thank them for. In it, they cite some Statistics Canada information about the degree of confidence that Canadians have in several of our important democratic institutions, one of th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24945f84a30813797cc17727f01adb1a8f65ad8c041b1883f12464f3e302c23b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-917a94e26d72adefca138435","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115631,"date":"2026-04-16T18:00:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you for that. I want to tie this back to the study of the day, which is civic resilience. I think it is a disturbing stat that more than half of Canadians don't have confidence in this important democratic institution. What does that do to our sense of community and our sense of civic resilience? I know these policies are well intentioned, but maybe they don't work out the way they were intended.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115631","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that. I want to tie this back to the study of the day, which is civic resilience. I think it is a disturbing stat that more than half of Canadians don't have confidence in this important democratic institution. What does that do to our sense of community and our sense of civic resilience? I know these policies are well intentioned, but maybe they don't work out the way they were inte","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d55f88beed73e82145399a30d6d656e382da93e82b9cfe5926ff3ce0697144b6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c36bf9cf05630432f2aa8461","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115632,"date":"2026-04-16T18:00:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"I have 50 seconds for Professor Charlebois. I read that editorial—it was in Canadian Grocer, I think—very recently. You say a healthy food economy depends on a strong middle class. I find it somewhat ironic that after 10 years of the government that wanted to enhance the middle class, which even had a ministry of middle-class prosperity, you talked about the Canadian economy and how things are going in the wrong direction. Could you comment on what a prosperous middle class, or a lack thereof, does to the sense of civic resilience in our country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115632","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have 50 seconds for Professor Charlebois. I read that editorial—it was in Canadian Grocer, I think—very recently. You say a healthy food economy depends on a strong middle class. I find it somewhat ironic that after 10 years of the government that wanted to enhance the middle class, which even had a ministry of middle-class prosperity, you talked about the Canadian economy and how things are goi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8f85f0bba345d39fae75a3c42bb1f7ffd11e25b00fcb7e9e8bef445f8a250e93"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ca41360b4b87d1930d221f4bd025ad0e1b8923e7e5134cc8512693e70a4ce8d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-912fb28da46f1f5b17605fb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428923,"date":"2026-04-16T20:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a couple of the amendments relate to actions of the longest ballot committee, and the bill is proposing to restrict the ability of pranksters, which I am going to call them, on the longest ballot committee to interfere with our election processes. \n\nOne of the steps Conservatives are suggesting is prohibiting a person from signing nominations of more than one prospective candidate. Another one is a prohibition on acting as an official agent for more than one person in one riding. This came up at the procedure and House affairs committee, and one of the questions was whether it would withstand a charter challenge. Section 3 of the charter has been given a very broad interpretation to allow people to participate in the electoral district. \n\nI would ask for the member's comments on whether it would survive a charter challenge.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428923","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a couple of the amendments relate to actions of the longest ballot committee, and the bill is proposing to restrict the ability of pranksters, which I am going to call them, on the longest ballot committee to interfere with our election processes. \n\nOne of the steps Conservatives are suggesting is prohibiting a person from signing nominations of more than one prospective candidate. An","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2498b2437650246f0d44e8bbc9b34083e65085a1521fcfe49a1c12c00b17d304"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["acc61855bff92584ca19b6eeb4e57433c23a4ee96c03acc40b28e20bdb380f0d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1cafab32a53a7acf3cef895","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428924,"date":"2026-04-16T21:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from Ponoka—Didsbury's speech was inspiring. It is a pleasure serving with him on the committee that studied the bill.\n\nWe know that a foreign influence registry is going to be set up. We have appointed a commissioner for that now. I wonder if my colleague could comment on how viable that commission will be now that we have a Prime Minister who is willing to enter into a security-sharing agreement with the police authorities in Beijing, a regime that at one time he said was an existential threat to Canada's security.\n\nHow is that going to interplay with the foreign influence registry?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428924","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from Ponoka—Didsbury's speech was inspiring. It is a pleasure serving with him on the committee that studied the bill.\n\nWe know that a foreign influence registry is going to be set up. We have appointed a commissioner for that now. I wonder if my colleague could comment on how viable that commission will be now that we have a Prime Minister who is willing to enter into a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d5d7e1fb87a19985f5008a520d12790a5fdf9307c98e269ddc17ea4887e2710"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a6c7a8d7fb6dc52a0e1c2862d4ff6725357891b0cc321998ad481307435690a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da3265299b05499b8e0e4a90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428925,"date":"2026-04-16T22:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for his speech on Bill C-25, the strong and free elections act. He mentioned our former colleague, Kenny Chiu, who was elected at the same time as the two of us in 2019. He introduced a foreign influence registry private member's bill, something that the Liberal government should have done but failed to do.\n\n Madam Justice Hogue noted in her report that this was one of the reasons why Mr. Chiu may have lost his election, because of the foreign interference that followed, in the Chinese language on social media to people in his riding, criticizing him unfairly for introducing this private member's bill. I wonder if my colleague could comment on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428925","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for his speech on Bill C-25, the strong and free elections act. He mentioned our former colleague, Kenny Chiu, who was elected at the same time as the two of us in 2019. He introduced a foreign influence registry private member's bill, something that the Liberal government should have done but failed to do.\n\n Madam Justice Hogue noted in her report that th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4279939a7b06f47af35d2c05ca93d90855c04c6e4c56e73d7f90b331f99b0638"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d94f75315f74dea3f44cf93a03eb7fa0259da18d1c8891d2b4badd3b01ba41c3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-212dfffffef1b8a8b3ba5b3e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428926,"date":"2026-04-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today we are debating the strong and free elections act, Bill C-25, the government's response to several recent developments, both local and international, that have challenged the integrity of and public confidence in one of our most important democratic institutions, our elections.\n\n After the 2021 election, the federal government appointed the Hon. Marie-Josée Hogue as commissioner for the Public Inquiry Into Foreign Interference in Federal Electoral Processes and Democratic Institutions. It is a very long name and also a very long report of seven or eight volumes. The commissioner's final report came out on January 28, 2025, about 14 months ago. I am going to read a couple of quotations from the report because they set the context for what this proposed legislation is all about. This is what she had to say at page 3 of her report:\n\nThe first observation I would like to make from the evidence is that it is true that some foreign states are trying to interfere in our democratic institutions, including electoral processes. This is nothing new and comes as no surprise—states have been trying to interfere with each other's business since time immemorial. What is new, however, is the means deployed by these states, the apparent scale of the issue and the public discourse on the topic.\n\nMembers can think about it. We have been talking about AI. We have been talking about the influence of social media on people and the ease of spreading misinformation and disinformation. All of that is affecting our democratic institutions. Today, we were talking about our Canada Elections Act.\n\nIn anticipation of the commissioner's conclusion at the end of seven or eight volumes, she wrote this at page 15: \"I have found no evidence that the overall result of any election has been swung by a foreign actor and have identified only a small number of individual ridings where foreign interference may have had some impact.\"\n\nReading between the lines, the report says that, with or without foreign interference in the 2019 election, we would have had a minority Liberal government under the leadership of then prime minister Trudeau, and we would have had the Conservatives being in the opposition with the member for Regina—Qu'Appelle, who was the leader of the Conservative Party, as the Leader of the Opposition. That would have been the result, and I believe that is what Madam Justice Hogue meant by saying that she saw no impact on the overall result of that election. \n\nIt was the same in 2021. With or without foreign interference in Canada's 2021 general election, we were going to have the Liberal minority government under then prime minister Justin Trudeau, and the Conservative opposition, with Erin O'Toole as the Leader of the Opposition.\n\n I accept Justice Hogue's findings that, in those two elections, Canadians got both the government and the opposition that they chose, but I note that her report also says this, which is highly important in the debate going on today: \"I...have identified only a small number of individual ridings where foreign interference may have had some impact.\"\n\n Therefore, at the macro level, Canadians got the government they chose, but at the local level, maybe they did not get the MP that the majority of people had actually wanted due to foreign interference in our electoral system. That is what we take out of this report.\n\n Justice Hogue drills down and looks at the riding of Steveston—Richmond East. We were talking about that just a couple of minutes ago in debate. This is what the Hogue report says at page 33: \"In 2021, Mr. Chiu, the Conservative Party MP for Steveston—Richmond East, was the target of false narratives related to his proposal to implement a foreign influence registry.\"\n\nIf I have some time at the end, I will talk a bit more about the history behind the foreign influence registry, but for now, I am just going to continue with the Hogue report. It goes on to note that Mr. Chiu and the Conservative Party of Canada requested, very shortly after the election, that these issues be brought to CSIS.\n\nCSIS took on the investigation, but it did not get back to Mr. Chiu and the Conservative Party until almost two years later in the fall of 2023, and then only after media reporting about alleged leaks of the CSIS intelligence report. CSIS dropped the ball. Did it do good work? It probably did, but it was just too late. It was delayed, and it did not keep Mr. Chiu and his party in the loop. \n\nHowever, this story is not primarily about Mr. Chiu, my friend and colleague, and it is not primarily about the people of Steveston—Richmond East, although they are obviously players in the whole story. This is a story about the Canadian public and our confidence, or lack thereof, in our electoral system.\n\nJustice Hogue did not pull any punches when criticizing the government's slow and inadequate response to these allegations. She stated, \"I could not fulfill my mandate to help build public confidence in our democratic institutions if I minimized the ways in which efforts have come up short.\" She was very critical of the government. She went on to list some of these shortfalls. There was slow reaction to issues that were very urgent and very serious and should have been given a much higher level of attention. There was the failure to get information to the right decision-makers and policy-makers, and when the information finally did get to those decision-makers and policy-makers, they did not know what to do with it. They did not appreciate the seriousness of it. This was obviously under the guidance and inspiration of the Liberal government that, at that time, was not taking foreign interference as a serious issue. Also, there was a lack of coordination. There was confusion about the roles and accountabilities. However, in the end, she summed it up with rather a positive tone. She said, \"However, on the whole, I am satisfied that the government now appreciates the foreign interference threat that Canada faces and is serious about responding to it.\"\n\n It was 15 months ago that Justice Hogue wrote that, and here we are, finally, in the next Parliament, acting on it with the proposed strong and free elections act. It is a step in the right direction. We are going to support it to go to committee where I look forward to drilling down to see that it truly answers the legitimate concerns that have been raised in this report that Canadians have about the integrity of our democratic institutions.\n\nHere is one more quote from the Hogue report that I think sums it up nicely:\n\n Foreign interference—and our fear of foreign interference—has taken its toll. For some, their faith in our system has been challenged. I hope that for those who take the time to read this report, what they learn—what I have learned—will not only enhance their understanding of the foreign interference threat but also go some distance in rebuilding the confidence and trust in our democracy. \n\nI hope indeed that Bill C-25 will do exactly that, and that it will go some distance in rebuilding the lagging confidence that so many Canadians have in our democratic institutions. \n\nI would note that, in the last election, the voter turnout of younger people increased, and so that is a reason for optimism. A larger number of first-time voters came out, and once people vote the first time, they are probably going to vote in subsequent elections. Perhaps that curve is going in the right direction. However, unfortunately, overall, election turnout has not been particularly good. How much of that is tied to Canadians' skepticism about the integrity of our electoral system? \n\nI mentioned at the beginning of my remarks that the bill before us is a response not only to international affairs, which I think I talked about quite adequately, but also some local issues that have developed right here in Canada. In the last few general elections and by-elections, a group of local troublemakers or pranksters have interfered with our elections. They call themselves the \"longest ballot committee\". We have all heard of their tactics, most recently in the by-election in Terrebonne. They find loopholes in our election act that allow them to nominate large numbers of people, sometimes in the hundreds, to run in a specific riding. They present themselves as being on a noble quest of wanting to initiate a citizens' forum, as they call it, to review our age-old first-past-the-post electoral system, which they do not like. They found a number of loopholes. \n\n One of the participants actually appeared as a witness at the procedure and House affairs committee a couple of months ago. What they have discovered is that, under the current Canada Elections Act, they can have the same 100 people sign 100 or even 200 nomination forms, nominating 200 different people. They can have the same person acting as a financial agent for all 200 or 100 or however many people they manage to get on the ballot. We want to shut that down. We are saying that this is inappropriate.\n\nI want to go back to their comments about wanting a citizens' forum. I can say that, being a British Columbian, I have some experience with that. We have had quite a lot of experience with citizens' forums and citizens' institutions. Over the years, I think we have had two or three of them.\n\nThese were groups of responsible people coming together, appointed by the government, to have an intelligent and high-level discussion to review our electoral system, and to possibly come up with options with regard to the first-past-the-post system, which, over the years, has been challenged many times. The citizens' forum put the options to the voters in British Columbia on at least two occasions. Both times, citizens, after looking at it, studying it, trying their best to understand how the different options would work, said that they were comfortable with the first-past-the-post system and that they wanted to keep it.\n\nThe pranksters behind the longest ballot committee are very aware of this history. We put it to them. They know it. They knew that if they were to go through that process again, a rational process, a legal process supported by the government, they would be unsuccessful. They thought they would try something else, guerrilla war tactics, instead. That is what they are doing. They are not serious. They know that they will not succeed. They know that this is nothing more than a stunt that is making people angry. They must be stopped. That is what the bill would do.\n\nI am happy to see that the drafters of the legislation have picked up the recommendations of the procedure and House affairs committee by implementing a couple of very important changes. There would now be a prohibition on a person signing nomination papers of more than one prospective candidate. There would be another prohibition on a person acting as an official agent for more than one candidate in the same electoral district.\n\nWe looked at this very carefully. We listened to experts. We wanted to be as flexible as possible.\n\nWe recognize that Canadians have a constitutional right, protected by section 3 in the charter, to be fully involved, in an unrestricted manner, in our electoral system. We want to encourage people to put their name forward and to be candidates. We want to encourage people to run as independents. One does not have to run for a political party. One does not need the endorsement of a party. Someone can just go out, be an independent candidate and get all their friends out to listen to them at the debate. This is all good for democracy.\n\nWe did not want to stand in the way of that. We made this as permissive as possible, and I am happy to see that the government has actually picked up on this. We heard from legal experts that these restrictions are reasonable limitations on Canadians' charter-protected rights to participate fully in the democratic process.\n\nI agree that we need to put an end to the nonsense of the longest ballot committee. I also agree that these changes that we are proposing and which have found their way into Bill C-25 are reasonable and supportable. I want to send this to committee now for a further drill-down, to make sure that they actually would withstand the charter challenge and that they would provide the guidance that people need when they decide to get involved in the democratic process.\n\nI want to go back to my comments about the foreign influence registry. Our former colleague from Richmond East—Steveston introduced a private member's bill. I remember him asking why the government side of the House was not doing this. Many other western democracies have implemented and set up and authorized a foreign influence registry. It is not only China or Beijing but there are other countries as well that like to interfere in western democracies.\n\n Our trading nations, our fellow Westerners, have set up foreign influence registries. Why have we not done that? I believe it is because the Liberal government was not taking it seriously. It certainly was not at that time. Mr. Chiu took the brave step to introduce a private member's bill. I am going to go back to what Madam Justice Hogue said:\n\nIn 2021, Mr. Chiu, the Conservative Party MP for Steveston-Richmond East, was the target of false narratives related to his proposal to implement a foreign influence registry.\n\nHe was doing the work that the government should have been doing and he paid the price for it. I was very disappointed at the time. I still feel sad when I think about Mr. Chiu not being our colleague right now.\n\nI just want to underline that this bill is a step in the right direction. Much of it is supportable. In some things, it does not go far enough. In some things, I think it requires a further drill-down at the committee to ensure the proposals are actually going to meet their objectives. Certainly, we need to also hear from experts to ensure that it can withstand any sorts of challenges in court or challenges by people who want to find loopholes to get around them and find ways to interfere with our democratic institutions. That is what this bill is all about. We want to stop that. \n\nWe want to support our democratic institutions. We want to support our free and fair elections. We want to ensure that Canadians are getting the government that they deserve and that they voted for. We want to ensure that Canadians are getting the local member of Parliament they want to choose and whom the majority are behind.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428926","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today we are debating the strong and free elections act, Bill C-25, the government's response to several recent developments, both local and international, that have challenged the integrity of and public confidence in one of our most important democratic institutions, our elections.\n\n After the 2021 election, the federal government appointed the Hon. Marie-Josée Hogue as commissioner","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a707f9284ea9c2bbbf278aec9ce8a3d75da6cdeed6951bd333c68cdaa7e6e8f1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a09e07344b49cb86ddc5bec5d232a0867150d1140b6ff10939ee75ecd8d834b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5fbfe7f77000a36c9a7750e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428927,"date":"2026-04-16T22:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my next-door neighbour, the member for Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford for a very thoughtful question. Indeed, there have been delays. The member asked me why the Liberal government has delayed that. I do not know. He would probably have to ask someone in of the Liberal government. I know he did not expect me to actually have an answer to that.\n\nHowever, this is the good news. We have now appointed Anton Boegman, the former chief electoral officer of British Columbia, to be the commissioner of the foreign influence registry. His job, number one, is now going to be to set up the registry. He came to our committee. We are optimistic that his appointment will actually be a meaningful one.\n\nHowever, my colleague raised a very interesting point. In light of the Prime Minister signing this security agreement with China, the greatest threat to our democracy, I wonder how effective the registry is actually going to be.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428927","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my next-door neighbour, the member for Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford for a very thoughtful question. Indeed, there have been delays. The member asked me why the Liberal government has delayed that. I do not know. He would probably have to ask someone in of the Liberal government. I know he did not expect me to actually have an answer to that.\n\nHowever, this is the good ne","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e9d96c7ac7cc7f3c041e1b7710f5d8b159d3f34f744e4550535bd76c2ce0072d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d3bf8c744aee7c5c80c917c2aab2eb88d8bace9f8e3ad3351902116380fe07f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d0ff3f0d65f366a76e83270","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300872,"date":"2026-04-20T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbians are living with uncertainty about whether the homes they worked their whole lives to buy are truly theirs. Businesses are hearing from their commercial lenders that they cannot just assume that they can take their fee simple security to the bank.\n\nBetween the Cowichan Tribes decision and the Musqueam agreements, Liberal and NDP governments have cast doubt on fee simple private property rights for thousands of Canadians. Reconciliation matters, but it cannot be pursued through legal confusion. The Cowichan case may take years to reach the Supreme Court of Canada, leaving families and businesses in limbo. \n\nThe Liberals say they will appeal, but here is the problem: They had instructed their lawyers not to argue at trial that fee simple title supersedes all other titles and interests. Appeals are not do-overs, so how do they expect to win an appeal on arguments they are not entitled to raise? How are they going to restore confidence in home ownership and fee simple security, now that they have dropped the ball?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300872","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbians are living with uncertainty about whether the homes they worked their whole lives to buy are truly theirs. Businesses are hearing from their commercial lenders that they cannot just assume that they can take their fee simple security to the bank.\n\nBetween the Cowichan Tribes decision and the Musqueam agreements, Liberal and NDP governments have cast doubt on fee sim","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021238","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021238","label":"Business loans","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["768b97829fba86d049ecd30c2a57b8678aefcd6555b47a12e5533013ef029059"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e83457ba0938c5f702d850c845b166e9642f0a21b458617573f34acb317871bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ef0f5e7dd0da922c93dd31a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300873,"date":"2026-04-20T23:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, last week I raised an issue of deep concern to the people of British Columbia, namely the impact of the B. C. Supreme Court decision in Cowichan Tribes v. Canada and the impact that the decision has on private property rights.\n\nIt is a significant ruling, because it is the first time in Canada's history that a court declared aboriginal title over non-Crown lands, privately owned lands. There have been other aboriginal title cases in British Columbia before, and I am going to highlight one of them, the Tsilhqot'in Nation case of 2014. The court declared aboriginal title over a very large piece of land, 1,750 square kilometres. It was very remote land and it was all Crown land. The Tsilhqot'in plaintiffs in that case were very careful to carve around all the privately held land, so that the claims area was only public land. That was their strategy.\n\nFast-forward a decade to the current case, and the Cowichan plaintiffs took a different, more aggressive approach. Their claims area does include privately owned lands. We are talking about a relatively small piece of land, not 1,750 square kilometres but 800 acres. It is right in the heart of Metro Vancouver and, as any realtor would say, the three most important things about real estate are \"location, location, location\".\n\nThe morning after the decision, 150 private landowners, farmers, homeowners, businesses and a golf course discovered that their titles were now burdened with the aboriginal title designation. That is what makes this decision so unique. It has never happened before in Canadian history.\n\nThis is why I say that the Liberals dropped the ball. Instead of arguing aggressively to defend private property rights, federal counsel, under the direction of then attorney general Jody Wilson-Raybould and then prime minister Justin Trudeau, retreated from their strongest legal defence. This is what the court said in paragraph 2096, \"Canada initially pled extinguishment but abandoned its reliance on this defence in its amended response to civil claim filed November 22, 2018.\"\n\nThe Liberal strategy was to drop its first and best line of defence, that the Crown's deliberate granting of fee simple title to private individuals throughout British Columbia's history had the effect of extinguishing pre-existing aboriginal title. They did not argue that, making it easy for the trial judge to find that aboriginal title still exists on all parcels, including private lands, within the claim area, and that aboriginal title and privately held fee simple title could co-exist on the same piece of land.\n\nMany legal experts have weighed in on that, saying that it does not work, and asking how two title owners could have exclusive and competing interests over the same title. Who wins?\n\nThe judge's answer was that \"Aboriginal title is a prior and senior right\" to other property interests, whether the land is public or private. That is what has people worried. Who actually owns the land?\n\nI will ask the question again. Will the new Liberal Prime Minister direct the federal lawyers to argue that private property rights in Canada must be secured for homeowners, farmers, businesses and investors?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300873","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, last week I raised an issue of deep concern to the people of British Columbia, namely the impact of the B. C. Supreme Court decision in Cowichan Tribes v. Canada and the impact that the decision has on private property rights.\n\nIt is a significant ruling, because it is the first time in Canada's history that a court declared aboriginal title over non-Crown lands, privately owned lands","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3000c9676b69741431cb0f5eb553c4fe10f131de6148d01fdd042ee8b4494b3b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47cca59d4ad363087f27e781efbe378c271bb2dc9d31b2b4938b8b9e076752fb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bfa4271f0be58117bb19af08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300874,"date":"2026-04-20T23:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the concern is that the federal lawyers have dropped the extinguishment argument, which was their first and best line of defence, under the misguided concept or idea that reconciliation requires the federal government not to be too aggressive in defending private property rights. That is the concern here, and nothing that the hon. secretary has just mentioned adds any comfort. Of course the government is going to argue. Of course it is going to appeal, but is it going to argue that line of reasoning?\n\nThere is a great quote from the New Brunswick Court of Appeal, which was addressing a similar fact situation. They said:\n\n...a declaration of Aboriginal title over privately owned lands, which, by its very nature, gives the Aboriginal beneficiary exclusive possession, occupation, and use would sound the death knell of reconciliation with the interests of non-Aboriginal Canadians.\n\n Does he agree with that statement from the Court of Appeal?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300874","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the concern is that the federal lawyers have dropped the extinguishment argument, which was their first and best line of defence, under the misguided concept or idea that reconciliation requires the federal government not to be too aggressive in defending private property rights. That is the concern here, and nothing that the hon. secretary has just mentioned adds any comfort. Of cour","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f5a001884a92a014903a7350b8a17f5f78ecd4fa1cfd3b96e49e2f465df7973"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["826e5176edaaf41e8147ef5310c8857e8e5e24113bb18d164ff279b699ecd666"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c002adeb154c043d0841f01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115633,"date":"2026-04-21T16:15:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the witnesses for being here and for sharing your insights with us on this important study on civic resilience and the state of it in Canada today. Mr. Dehaas, I'll start with you. Your organization is involved with public interest litigation. You've commented on the litigation around the invocation of the Emergencies Act a couple of years ago. I think the trial court and the Federal Court of Appeal have both ruled that the invocation was done improperly and that it wasn't justified. It's now off to the Supreme Court of Canada, so I don't know how much you can comment on it. My question is focused on what this has done to a Canadian sense of civic resilience, which is what we're talking about. I'm not talking about the mischief-makers, the people who were honking their horns and really making a nuisance, but about law-abiding citizens, the people who supported the truckers. For example, they may have donated money on the GoFundMe page. I had phone calls from some of them—good Canadian citizens, some of them good friends of mine—who said they were worried that the government was going to freeze their bank accounts. They wondered what they should do. Perhaps you could comment on this. What does it do to a sense of civic resilience when a people's government turns on them in such an aggressive manner?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115633","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the witnesses for being here and for sharing your insights with us on this important study on civic resilience and the state of it in Canada today. Mr. Dehaas, I'll start with you. Your organization is involved with public interest litigation. You've commented on the litigation around the invocation of the Emergencies Act a couple of years ago. I think the tr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e7064d250bbd7d1c07086789edfc10c56434fd71b19872d77aa93e09a99dc215"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f03d5e88ce97abe924295aea147841fd80b7fc84d88ad8fc506d08b95f95c93"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ac112564a400f3919ca4d75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115634,"date":"2026-04-21T16:20:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you. Mr. Salvo, I'm going to turn to you. I'm very curious about your comments on digital security. I think you used the term \"digital sovereignty\". You were critical of Meta, which you accused of being an international \"foreign-owned behemoth\". Are we better off with a Canadian-owned behemoth? Explain to me what digital sovereignty looks like. Was the problem with Meta or was it with Bill C-18 ?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115634","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Salvo, I'm going to turn to you. I'm very curious about your comments on digital security. I think you used the term \"digital sovereignty\". You were critical of Meta, which you accused of being an international \"foreign-owned behemoth\". Are we better off with a Canadian-owned behemoth? Explain to me what digital sovereignty looks like. Was the problem with Meta or was it with Bill C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["88be73f3a4c22a187c6bbfb469d1fb2d26ba706a6cc936b3009751b9dd3aaaeb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["231539d1eb03137aeadd663afbac0c0bba20ef45afac9aeb5cd0bafac744ec82"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3ef8458048b96b8bd486190","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115635,"date":"2026-04-21T16:20:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"I want to follow up on that. You said we're allowing Meta to do things. How would we prevent Meta from doing them? They're a free company run by free-thinking people. They can make the decisions they want to on whether to co-operate with the federal government when negotiating with digital and traditional media people. It's a free choice. If you had a Canadian company, how would it be any different?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115635","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to follow up on that. You said we're allowing Meta to do things. How would we prevent Meta from doing them? They're a free company run by free-thinking people. They can make the decisions they want to on whether to co-operate with the federal government when negotiating with digital and traditional media people. It's a free choice. If you had a Canadian company, how would it be any differen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0de78196206170d48dea93100138ee59fb9efae5dc0f3b4e1b94b3fde7403878"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b5fa8ff13eb9f3910873f35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115636,"date":"2026-04-21T16:20:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"How else would you—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115636","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How else would you—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6cdbe1f6fabcfc9fa66547a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115637,"date":"2026-04-21T16:20:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"I'm just getting to the good part.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115637","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm just getting to the good part.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26da553f2828f0fff65768a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115638,"date":"2026-04-21T16:35:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you. We'll continue our conversation, Mr. Salvo, talking about what you call digital sovereignty. I like the idea, and we're going to be writing a report at the end of the study, perhaps with recommendations. I would like to see a recommendation around enhancing Canada's digital sovereignty as a way of enhancing our civic resilience. We need to know more about what this looks like. You talked about the foreign-owned behemoth Meta not playing nicely with us, but there's another foreign-owned behemoth that played quite nicely with us. I wonder how a Canadian-owned social media platform you were suggesting might be better behaved. How would that be? For a foreign-owned social media platform to become big and effective, let's say it's going to be headquartered in Vancouver instead of 200 kilometres away in Seattle. How's it going to be better? To grow, it's probably going to have to offer an IPO. Does it make a difference to you whether it does it on the TSX or the New York Stock Exchange?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115638","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. We'll continue our conversation, Mr. Salvo, talking about what you call digital sovereignty. I like the idea, and we're going to be writing a report at the end of the study, perhaps with recommendations. I would like to see a recommendation around enhancing Canada's digital sovereignty as a way of enhancing our civic resilience. We need to know more about what this looks like. You talke","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a59c0070df4ec9fe4a23e34733017935a3adcaea044b1283e31ef014e42e806c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c0d2afef4b64a8e75043718bd3a6123de4dafcc572ce9534a3cc009fcfe02ad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-925026e3e75e6e011af3de95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115639,"date":"2026-04-21T16:35:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Understood, but they are free companies—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115639","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Understood, but they are free companies—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12fe9f7f298a10b019f4e64b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115640,"date":"2026-04-21T16:35:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"—run and operated by free-thinking individuals. I know you would never advocate for more authoritarianism, whether it is from the Kremlin or from Ottawa.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115640","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"—run and operated by free-thinking individuals. I know you would never advocate for more authoritarianism, whether it is from the Kremlin or from Ottawa.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da1bdeded589c0c11c99bf85","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115641,"date":"2026-04-21T16:40:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"I appreciate the insights, but with all due respect, you're not leaving us much to put in a report about digital sovereignty for Canada. I understand it's a challenge to find that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115641","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I appreciate the insights, but with all due respect, you're not leaving us much to put in a report about digital sovereignty for Canada. I understand it's a challenge to find that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transborder data flow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","label":"Transborder data flow","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a62b5bc8d041072532bac49d8d6a182b530167c7a97f4af32333ea6c155a92a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a30d2340350fb0cb97953005","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300871,"date":"2026-04-22T22:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from Edmonton Northwest talked quite a bit about the ambiguity in the treaty and how that ambiguity might lead to confusion between various Métis groups.\n\nI am wondering about the Métis Nation British Columbia. Yes, there is one, and it has jurisdiction over 30,000-plus Métis people. What assurances are there that this will not impact the very important work that they are doing in my home province?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300871","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from Edmonton Northwest talked quite a bit about the ambiguity in the treaty and how that ambiguity might lead to confusion between various Métis groups.\n\nI am wondering about the Métis Nation British Columbia. Yes, there is one, and it has jurisdiction over 30,000-plus Métis people. What assurances are there that this will not impact the very important work that they are","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["06b8a273954088e907e75433e36dbb962e9040576ef827ef26e8b0f8b7b70542"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05875df377018969141bfd9eb8d69472c3c746f46ce32d94e415c33b64e4ff58"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f5eee6be28653a77b4b56c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115621,"date":"2026-04-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"CIIT","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to the witnesses. I'll start with Mr. Manucha. It's nice to have somebody here who knows trade and constitutional law. I'm going to ask you a question along that line. It's fair to say that Canadian courts have taken a generous rather than a legalistic approach in interpreting the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. It probably started with the Big M Drug Mart Ltd. case, which we all had to read when we were in law school. Chief Justice Dickson stated that charter rights must be interpreted generously and purposively in light of the underlying objectives. That led to what some critics called the start of judicial activism. Add to that the more recent development of courts applying a charter values framework to find, for example, that a territorial government had to provide French-language education even to children who were clearly not section 23 rights holders. Never mind what the charter actually said. What was the intent? That brought judicial activism to a new level. When it comes to interpreting sections of the old BNA Act and the Constitution Act, 1982—I'm thinking of section 121, the so-called free trade section of the old BNA Act—courts have taken a very narrow approach to reject initiatives by people, with the Comeau case, for example, or by legislators, for example with the national securities regulations deal. What are your thoughts on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115621","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to the witnesses. I'll start with Mr. Manucha. It's nice to have somebody here who knows trade and constitutional law. I'm going to ask you a question along that line. It's fair to say that Canadian courts have taken a generous rather than a legalistic approach in interpreting the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. It probably started with the Big M Drug","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a2583e671f568e9595b68d34ecb9ce30381ab55ebfa0fbe9690e0586ed3b8bf6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db5faf9b39a5490846489b495616e3c5f8ecafaa246cd40e08cdaa9cb65074b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-064fd083f5119ac570bf5e95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115622,"date":"2026-04-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"CIIT","text":"I think you were suggesting that the Canadian Competition Bureau could be put in charge of regulating and advancing free trade in Canada. Isn't that going to run into the same narrow thinking that the Comeau decision or the national securities regulator decision ran into?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115622","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I think you were suggesting that the Canadian Competition Bureau could be put in charge of regulating and advancing free trade in Canada. Isn't that going to run into the same narrow thinking that the Comeau decision or the national securities regulator decision ran into?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59492","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Free trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59492","label":"Free trade","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40f7569f6bef5329b55c2c539085ce6f39ac62bab9ca4c620ec0a9f37d11e0fb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7828424033b413fee7ed87013f99be6617f570e138bb792288676df5f6a7a4f6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e880bcaa8f4ed335b2f9232d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115623,"date":"2026-04-28T16:55:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"CIIT","text":"One of you gave evidence about the volume of trade between Canada and other countries compared to the volume of trade between the provinces, suggesting that perhaps if we just had free trade between the provinces, we could improve our economy substantially. Are we comparing apples to apples? The trade barriers with the United States are tariff-based and have regulations and differing standards. Among the provinces, it's really just the latter, so are we comparing apples to apples?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115623","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"One of you gave evidence about the volume of trade between Canada and other countries compared to the volume of trade between the provinces, suggesting that perhaps if we just had free trade between the provinces, we could improve our economy substantially. Are we comparing apples to apples? The trade barriers with the United States are tariff-based and have regulations and differing standards. Am","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e205cb3614d2844ec6d12c7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115642,"date":"2026-04-30T16:30:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you, Chair, and thank you to all the witnesses for being here. I'm not sure who this question goes to. It's just to the table. As part of your budgeting and assessment processes, have you had an opportunity to measure the incremental cost of hybrid parliamentary operations? I'm looking at a report from the parliamentary budget office from five years ago. It's completely out of date now. This was when we were in the heart of a pandemic and a hybrid Parliament was created so that Parliament could keep on functioning. There was a recurring operational cost, according to that report, of $4.6 million. That included the Senate. I understand that the Senate doesn't have hybrid sittings now, but there were substantial savings, primarily credited to members of Parliament and senators not travelling and just staying at home. The net savings were $6 million. As I said, that's completely out of date now. My question is whether we track the cost of hybrid Parliament now that we could probably function without it. I'm not sure who that goes to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115642","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair, and thank you to all the witnesses for being here. I'm not sure who this question goes to. It's just to the table. As part of your budgeting and assessment processes, have you had an opportunity to measure the incremental cost of hybrid parliamentary operations? I'm looking at a report from the parliamentary budget office from five years ago. It's completely out of date now. This","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb262d7a73436e5c57b4068b1c9fa7afe1bb96044f35cb67a59f05570dafdfb8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d2ee4fa360d68e47a8a11dab56df47d01c9c06e2c289869be318d8a5832c88a8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ad660099634284f2bfb32c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115643,"date":"2026-04-30T16:35:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Is anybody assessing how many members of Parliament actually make use of hybrid Parliament? I know it's sometimes used at the close of the 10-minute electronic voting, and the Speaker knows this. He always asks anybody who had any trouble to please raise their hand. Every once in a while, somebody online says that they had trouble. It's useful for that, but if that's all hybrid Parliament is being used for, surely we can find a more efficient and cost-effective way of solving that minor problem.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115643","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is anybody assessing how many members of Parliament actually make use of hybrid Parliament? I know it's sometimes used at the close of the 10-minute electronic voting, and the Speaker knows this. He always asks anybody who had any trouble to please raise their hand. Every once in a while, somebody online says that they had trouble. It's useful for that, but if that's all hybrid Parliament is being","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ca5757cd8b38e18f2acde85","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115644,"date":"2026-04-30T16:35:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"I understand the difference. In committees, hybrid meetings are probably very effective—certainly for our witnesses, as Ms. Normandin is able to participate with us today—but the option for witnesses to participate online was available even before the pandemic. That's my understanding. Do we really need a whole hybrid infrastructure just for that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115644","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I understand the difference. In committees, hybrid meetings are probably very effective—certainly for our witnesses, as Ms. Normandin is able to participate with us today—but the option for witnesses to participate online was available even before the pandemic. That's my understanding. Do we really need a whole hybrid infrastructure just for that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c754fdd219f171708bf8dd8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115645,"date":"2026-04-30T16:35:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"That's fair enough.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115645","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's fair enough.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c6b69232dea60c342b55585","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945787,"date":"2026-05-04T19:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister claims that the Liberal government protects private property rights and that it will appeal the Cowichan decision. Here is the problem: At trial, the Liberals dropped the argument that private property rights come first, making it easier for the trial judge to conclude that aboriginal title is a \"prior and senior right to land.\"\n\nHow can the Prime Minister now say that the government will argue on appeal the very opposite, that private property rights come first, when they did not raise it at trial?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945787","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister claims that the Liberal government protects private property rights and that it will appeal the Cowichan decision. Here is the problem: At trial, the Liberals dropped the argument that private property rights come first, making it easier for the trial judge to conclude that aboriginal title is a \"prior and senior right to land.\"\n\nHow can the Prime Minister now say t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f26c5de47cbe36142c2c6857056a966e7cfa67f556fa7b1713456c4f1bd0c85f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eaf9c181f4960d21b6af50d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945786,"date":"2026-05-05T19:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, 81 years ago today, on May 5, 1945, Canadian Forces finally secured the liberation of the Netherlands from Nazi occupation. It marked the end of a hard-fought campaign that began on D-Day in northern France, continued through a bitterly cold winter and brutal fighting along the Scheldt River, and concluded with the liberation of Arnhem and surrounding towns and cities.\n\nVictory came at the high cost of the lives of 7,600 Canadian soldiers. From that sacrifice emerged a deep and enduring friendship between Canada and the Netherlands. It led to a wave of Dutch immigration to Canada after the war, including my own parents, and it continues to be honoured on both sides of the Atlantic. Earlier today, we reflected that legacy with a simple yet elegant flag-raising ceremony here in Ottawa, celebrating the lasting bond between two freedom-loving democratic nations. May the friendship endure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945786","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, 81 years ago today, on May 5, 1945, Canadian Forces finally secured the liberation of the Netherlands from Nazi occupation. It marked the end of a hard-fought campaign that began on D-Day in northern France, continued through a bitterly cold winter and brutal fighting along the Scheldt River, and concluded with the liberation of Arnhem and surrounding towns and cities.\n\nVictory came a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e06aa9c019e2c975d255837f322aaa7359bcffc7241f18618b52d25497f339cd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59a0bf2792f785956a4526e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945776,"date":"2026-05-07T15:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am speaking to the Conservative motion that is on the agenda today, which is calling on the Liberal government to put private property first in the Cowichan case, arguing that private property has priority over all other forms of title. We are saying this because the Cowichan Tribes v. Canada decision created massive uncertainty around fee simple property, the legal basis on which Canadians and businesses alike own their homes and their lands, and I could add their warehouses, their factories, their hotels and their high-rise apartment buildings.\n\nI want to quote from the B.C. Supreme Court decision that has shaken the confidence of the real estate market, homeowners and landowners. This is what the judge says at paragraph 2193:\n\nI agree that Aboriginal title is a prior and senior right to land. It is not an estate granted by the Crown, but rooted in prior occupation. It is constitutionally protected. The question of what remains of Aboriginal title after the granting of fee simple title to the same lands should be reversed. The proper question is: what remains of fee simple title after Aboriginal title is recognized in the same lands?\n\nThis is what is unsettling so many people interested in real estate. What does \"a prior and senior right\" actually mean?\n\nHere is another quote, from paragraph 3551, which is close to the end of the 800-page decision. The judge says, \"A precedent that will follow from this case is that provincial Crown grants of fee simple interest do not extinguish nor permanently displace Aboriginal title, and ss. 23 and 25 of the [British Columbia Land Title Act] do not apply to Aboriginal title.\"\n\nBefore entering Parliament as a member of Parliament in 2019, I spent many years practising corporate, real estate and land development law in the metro Vancouver area. Those decades in law taught me this with absolute clarity: Canada's economic stability rests on the bedrock of secure, indefeasible fee simple title. This principle, inherited from centuries of British common law development, is not an abstract legal doctrine. It is a foundation of our banking system, commercial investment, housing markets and, importantly, the ability of ordinary Canadians to build and preserve wealth. If we undermine that foundation, we undermine our economic stability and civic resilience as a Canadian society.\n\n The whole real estate industry banks on indefeasibility, the principle that says that when a person is registered as the legal owner of the land, their ownership cannot be challenged or defeated. The title is what the title says it is. Nobody had ever questioned the simple principle of indefeasibility until the Cowichan decision last year. One phrase bears repeating: \"[Sections] 23 and 25 of the [Land Title Act] do not apply to Aboriginal title.\" I am not trying to get technical, but these are the sections that underpin the principle of title indefeasibility. Today that principle is less secure than we always thought it was.\n\nThis is the first in Canadian jurisprudence. There have been other cases in British Columbia where the courts ruled that a first nation had met all the criteria for proving aboriginal title. The first one was a 1997 Supreme Court of Canada case called Delgamuukw, which set out the standard for proving aboriginal title in the court of law. There was another important case, 17 years later, called the Tsilhqot'in Nation case, which declared aboriginal title over a large but remote area of British Columbia of about 2,000 square kilometres. All the land in question was Crown land. The Tsilhqot'in Nation was the plaintiff in that case. Its litigation strategy was deliberately crafted to avoid conflict with private property owners.\n\nLet us fast-forward another decade to the case we are talking about today, which declared aboriginal title over a relatively small area of only 800 acres compared to the 2,000 square kilometres in the Tsilhqot'in case. However, this land is right in the heart of metro Vancouver. Any realtor will tell us that the three most important things about real estate are location, location and location.\n\nThe location in question makes the real estate very valuable. It is right in the heart of an industrial part and residential part of metro Vancouver. There are about 150 private landowners. There is a beautiful golf course. A significant landowner's project has now been put on hold. None of them had the opportunity to argue their case in court.\n\nThe fact that the Cowichan plaintiffs did not restrict their claim to publicly owned lands but included privately owned lands makes this case unique. It is in that context that we accuse the Liberals of dropping the ball. A different and more far-reaching strategy on the part of the plaintiffs, compared to the Tsilhqot'in, who restricted their claim to public lands, required a different and more aggressive response from the federal Attorney General lawyers.\n\nUnder the direction of the Attorney General in 2018, the justice department lawyers pulled their punches. At paragraph 2096 the judge noted, \"Canada initially [argued] extinguishment but abandoned its reliance on this defence in its amended response to [the] civil claim filed November 22, 2018\", obviously in direct response to new directives coming from the Attorney General.\n\nThey dropped the ball. They dropped their first and best line of defence, which says that the clear and simple act of the Crown's granting fee simple title to individuals throughout B.C.'s history had the effect of extinguishing aboriginal title, to the extent that future plaintiffs might argue for aboriginal title. We are saying that it is obvious that the government lawyers should have maintained this line of defence, considering the aggressive action by the Cowichan plaintiffs. An aggressive offence demands an aggressive defence.\n\nSome people argue that weakening private property rights is a path toward reconciliation, but Canadian courts have already warned of the opposite. In the New Brunswick case of J.D. Irving v. Wolastoqey Nation, December 2025, the Court of Appeal of New Brunswick put it this way: \"a declaration of Aboriginal title over privately owned lands, which, by its very nature, gives the Aboriginal beneficiary exclusive possession, occupation, and use would sound the death knell of reconciliation with the interests of non-Aboriginal Canadians.\"\n\nThat is not rhetoric. It is a sober legal assessment of the consequences of eroding certainty in land ownership. The British Columbia Supreme Court, in the Cowichan decision, moved in the opposite direction. The court held that aboriginal title can extend to privately owned lands, and that aboriginal title and fee simple ownership can somehow coexist on the same land at the same time. In my respectful view, this is simply not possible. Both forms of title claim exclusive rights to occupy, to develop and to benefit economically from the land. Two competing exclusive titles cannot occupy the same legal space without destroying the certainty that underpins our entire property system.\n\nThe result is not reconciliation; it is confusion. It is not economic opportunity; it is economic paralysis. It is not a path forward; it is a step backward into uncertainty at a moment when Canada desperately needs stability, investment and confidence.\n\nIf the Cowichan decision stands as it is, the consequence will be profound. It risks chilling development, destabilizing markets and deepening divisions rather than healing them. Canada cannot afford a property rights regime that leaves homeowners, lenders and investors unsure if they can take their fee simple title to the bank.\n\nReconciliation requires clarity, honesty, transparency and respect, not the erosion of the very legal foundations that allow our society to function. That is the principle that the Liberal government overlooked when it instructed its lawyers to not use all the tools in their tool box to defend property rights in Canada for Canadians. They dropped the ball, and Canadians are paying the price.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945776","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am speaking to the Conservative motion that is on the agenda today, which is calling on the Liberal government to put private property first in the Cowichan case, arguing that private property has priority over all other forms of title. We are saying this because the Cowichan Tribes v. Canada decision created massive uncertainty around fee simple property, the legal basis on which C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0ea6e993e48b1d8c8e19adaffdc019a2be6ae80076305ca6a8f2a009462acede"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2594542215e68d6010fe15fd9160bdc7dd3679f9e6709b9b514e0c53d4482a80"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a2503ac4b0f42bf072d31fd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945777,"date":"2026-05-07T15:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if I had a half-hour or an hour, I would have talked about all the interesting cases, but I had only 10 minutes. The Haida case is obviously a very important case. It talks about and expands on the principle of the duty to consult. I will not argue with that. There is a duty to consult. We agree with that. We agree that reconciliation is important, but to undermine the private property regime that Canada's economy is built on is not the way forward on reconciliation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945777","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if I had a half-hour or an hour, I would have talked about all the interesting cases, but I had only 10 minutes. The Haida case is obviously a very important case. It talks about and expands on the principle of the duty to consult. I will not argue with that. There is a duty to consult. We agree with that. We agree that reconciliation is important, but to undermine the private propert","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["421d89e076fd659b494ec835ae940710721074f89618a02659f126563e341696"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a049310132c9e719daab447","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945778,"date":"2026-05-07T15:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, normally we would try to argue it in committee, but it got shut down. We have put forward a motion, a proposal, that the House form a committee to look at this issue. In the meantime, we need to argue it in the House. This is very important to Canadians. It is important to people in my riding and to people in metro Vancouver, because they are deeply concerned about the uncertainty being brought by this decision and by the lack of action by the federal government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945778","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, normally we would try to argue it in committee, but it got shut down. We have put forward a motion, a proposal, that the House form a committee to look at this issue. In the meantime, we need to argue it in the House. This is very important to Canadians. It is important to people in my riding and to people in metro Vancouver, because they are deeply concerned about the uncertainty bei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd71ab9ff35f5b25fc6a828c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945779,"date":"2026-05-07T15:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard on a number of occasions that the Liberals appealed the decision as soon as they could. That is just not true. They waited until literally the last minute to appeal it.\n\nMore importantly, the Liberals say they stand for private property rights. However, they did not use all the tools in their tool box to do that. Even though private property owners have not been named as defendants, the Attorney General could and should have been there to defend private property owners, which he did not do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945779","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard on a number of occasions that the Liberals appealed the decision as soon as they could. That is just not true. They waited until literally the last minute to appeal it.\n\nMore importantly, the Liberals say they stand for private property rights. However, they did not use all the tools in their tool box to do that. Even though private property owners have not been named as","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9ee6c347cd6f7ed1dcbd69013f006223bae74078ce49b5c78fa01a18c3f2b787"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8856208c76296852bce64a56fc96ddbdd12c5f3763492da16246212507c078bf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa6a6cd662952aaa68f065ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945780,"date":"2026-05-07T15:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is an interesting comment coming from a member who did not consult with the first nation communities in her riding when she asked to drop the indigenous name from the riding name.\n\nYes, the Liberals today are saying that they will defend private property rights. However, they failed to do it before, and they have now worked themselves into a corner where they are not able to advance some of the arguments at the Court of Appeal that they should have raised at the trial level.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945780","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is an interesting comment coming from a member who did not consult with the first nation communities in her riding when she asked to drop the indigenous name from the riding name.\n\nYes, the Liberals today are saying that they will defend private property rights. However, they failed to do it before, and they have now worked themselves into a corner where they are not able to adva","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["393390058f458415a2d9cf9094b7013f3145fa9feb2455db2471cd13aaff0cbb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee38042591b5a5835b9f9cf410ae38154bd891f6b8764b1b9f2ed7b512ac2174"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99f6745210807f3583d4cad0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945781,"date":"2026-05-07T15:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a great question. Again, it was a short speech, and I did not have time to work everything into it.\n\nI have spoken to a number of the landowners, including a commercial landowner in the region who has a project under way. He had financing in place. He had tenants for the new warehouse complex he was going to build. All of it is on hold. The company is now making an application to the court, doing what the federal government and the Attorney General should have done during the trial many years ago. He is making an application to argue the rights of private property owners.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945781","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a great question. Again, it was a short speech, and I did not have time to work everything into it.\n\nI have spoken to a number of the landowners, including a commercial landowner in the region who has a project under way. He had financing in place. He had tenants for the new warehouse complex he was going to build. All of it is on hold. The company is now making an application","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c61baa14baae50b6743a8eb01ac7972677edb063ca03e15ec295538b221344bf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2dd5be918a88a37d3407b8cef1dc71b01b9e91dd1d46b0c85697bb32e60863b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-348c80318a73fb14178006d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945782,"date":"2026-05-07T16:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals keep talking about misinformation as though the Conservatives, when we raise issues with or weaknesses in the Liberal Party, are spreading misinformation. All we are doing is shedding light on their incompetence.\n\n We have a real-life example in the Montrose application, which the minister has already mentioned. We talked to them. They had a project that was ready to go. It has fallen apart. This is not misinformation. This is the reality on the ground. It is not the Conservatives that are repeating this. These are the facts on the ground that are making life difficult for investors.\n\n Can the minister comment on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945782","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals keep talking about misinformation as though the Conservatives, when we raise issues with or weaknesses in the Liberal Party, are spreading misinformation. All we are doing is shedding light on their incompetence.\n\n We have a real-life example in the Montrose application, which the minister has already mentioned. We talked to them. They had a project that was ready to go. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b909630482699f943cbddf0716a503a94a8866d2f3ed70a5415a2c6fae2291e3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ed3590683518c093bee3fc7d8c60563fc49acf5fa876bb5c1970a2afca43574"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-954f2ba64ce9c43bc5e05017","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945783,"date":"2026-05-07T16:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague from Quebec for her enlightening speech and for explaining the difference between \"fee simple\", coming from British feudal law, and \"absolute title\", coming from civil law. That was very enlightening. \n\nHowever, the same question still applies. Does the member think that absolute title and aboriginal title can coexist on the same piece of land at the same time, or is that an irreconcilable conflict?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945783","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague from Quebec for her enlightening speech and for explaining the difference between \"fee simple\", coming from British feudal law, and \"absolute title\", coming from civil law. That was very enlightening. \n\nHowever, the same question still applies. Does the member think that absolute title and aboriginal title can coexist on the same piece of land at the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b82f9515c74b227d1e1e8152b2d1bd4342dbd9cb6092695ee6960040fe284d26"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e95a87e0ae5ffcd9c646a299","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945784,"date":"2026-05-07T18:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, all morning, we on this side of the House have been raising some of the issues, some of the complexities, that have arisen from the Cowichan decision of the B.C. Supreme Court. It has been suggested by the Liberal side of the House that we are fearmongering or being misleading.\n\nI am very happy that the member opposite raised the issue of the Montrose application. He will be aware that Montrose had a land development project that has now run into complications on account of the Cowichan decision. This is not fearmongering. These are just facts. I wonder if he could comment about that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945784","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, all morning, we on this side of the House have been raising some of the issues, some of the complexities, that have arisen from the Cowichan decision of the B.C. Supreme Court. It has been suggested by the Liberal side of the House that we are fearmongering or being misleading.\n\nI am very happy that the member opposite raised the issue of the Montrose application. He will be aware tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-556fd2026636cd1e7639efe1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945785,"date":"2026-05-07T21:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. colleague from Saanich—Gulf Islands for her very interesting speech and recap of some of British Columbia's history. I am also a history fan, so I have read the whole case and would confirm some of the things she said. \n\nThe member is saying that Cowichan does not stand for the proposition that aboriginal title threatens fee simple title. The problem with that, of course, is that the Delgamuukw case said aboriginal title gives the holder thereof exclusive rights to possession, and fee simple does the same, so there cannot be the same thing on the same piece of land. \n\nI will also note that the Cowichan case was the first time in Canadian history, as far as I know, that a plaintiff first nation group claimed aboriginal title over privately held lands. The Tsilqhot'in case the member cited was only about public lands, so I would challenge her on saying that aboriginal title has no effect.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945785","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. colleague from Saanich—Gulf Islands for her very interesting speech and recap of some of British Columbia's history. I am also a history fan, so I have read the whole case and would confirm some of the things she said. \n\nThe member is saying that Cowichan does not stand for the proposition that aboriginal title threatens fee simple title. The problem with that, of cour","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["89717dfb1bbe99e4eb860e6c53dd11da9903d580a5c6715cccf394d78763b3e1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad89f33a53c6113b1a71ebcac22696914697e80fdface0e592160a8ff6ede3c8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71e34d0109dced1b8ac20874","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084018,"date":"2026-06-01T22:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Liberal government is going to be adding somewhere between $70 billion and $80 billion in additional debt to its already sky-high deficit with accumulated debt of over $1 trillion. If I take the middle point and apply 4% interest to it, that is $3 billion every year just in additional interest payments on an already very high number. \n\nHow does the Liberal government justify adding tens of billions of dollars of debt to the national debt when so many Canadians are already struggling with the cost of living?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084018","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Liberal government is going to be adding somewhere between $70 billion and $80 billion in additional debt to its already sky-high deficit with accumulated debt of over $1 trillion. If I take the middle point and apply 4% interest to it, that is $3 billion every year just in additional interest payments on an already very high number. \n\nHow does the Liberal government justify add","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6181efc031901ce12d64ed7bfaa012bb3efad1c5cd374e6db22edaf729f8feb5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["06a35c9d7a131f62fea1303993852f02ee76c124047c8db3876c13ff14d30e7b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-603421283d1bcc6ffc4918f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115624,"date":"2026-06-11T14:55:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you. I'll try to be fast. Minister Alty, you'll be aware that British Columbia has adopted UNDRIP into its legal framework. We call it \"DRIPA\" in British Columbia. You'll also be aware that the B.C. courts are quite willing to enforce that as positive law, immediately justiciable. I think that is the language they use. You'll be aware that Premier David Eby was quite surprised with that and promised to amend or suspend DRIPA. Then he faced a caucus revolt and backed off from that. In addition to all that trouble around UNDRIP in British Columbia, he is now facing an additional challenge, and that is the challenges from U.S. first nations groups. In September 2025, the Washington-based Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation filed a lawsuit in B.C. Supreme Court, saying that B.C. has the duty to consult with them around mining projects. Then, a couple of months later, the Southeast Alaska Indigenous Transboundary Commission and its 14-member Alaska native tribes did the same. Minister Alty, are you or your government at all concerned that B.C.'s form of UNDRIP is a threat to Canadian sovereignty?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115624","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I'll try to be fast. Minister Alty, you'll be aware that British Columbia has adopted UNDRIP into its legal framework. We call it \"DRIPA\" in British Columbia. You'll also be aware that the B.C. courts are quite willing to enforce that as positive law, immediately justiciable. I think that is the language they use. You'll be aware that Premier David Eby was quite surprised with that and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2cb92e3b3d755a214ccf3181b3ffe465adca4c8568fe2edb3afeda7e383b85fe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d46ec03bd95fc453055b760c9020c85a6c51711a857754f738556de22030d9d9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08986123757715021479a739","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115625,"date":"2026-06-11T14:55:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"INAN","text":"You can comment on national sovereignty.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115625","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You can comment on national sovereignty.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84a19e2892aad40cb3ef4b3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115626,"date":"2026-06-11T15:00:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"INAN","text":"Shouldn't you be having active conversations with the Attorney General of British Columbia around this? It is a direct threat to Canadian national unity and sovereignty that we have out-of-country first nations threatening to hold up national projects.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115626","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Shouldn't you be having active conversations with the Attorney General of British Columbia around this? It is a direct threat to Canadian national unity and sovereignty that we have out-of-country first nations threatening to hold up national projects.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b140128e780c9f9bd029ce0fd0990d566bcae2a9f4f3e3f94bfb0a17a4dce853"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02e2e9f824945e646bac917d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115627,"date":"2026-06-11T15:10:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"INAN","text":"I'll share my time with MP Schmale. Minister Alty, to follow up on our previous line of conversation, I'm surprised that the federal government hasn't been more proactive in these B.C. cases, which are a real and direct threat to national sovereignty. This is certainly a federal matter and could be a threat to the work that the Major Projects Office is trying to undertake as well. They have a big task, of course, having to consult with Canadian first nations. Now they may also have to consult with United States first nations. Minister, could you at least commit to instructing your department to look into this to see how they can work together with their counterparts in British Columbia to curtail this—as I would call it—foreign interference in our business?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115627","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll share my time with MP Schmale. Minister Alty, to follow up on our previous line of conversation, I'm surprised that the federal government hasn't been more proactive in these B.C. cases, which are a real and direct threat to national sovereignty. This is certainly a federal matter and could be a threat to the work that the Major Projects Office is trying to undertake as well. They have a big ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a4a49ec8fb76b0fe1e152f3b2e5d4b58450200b64a6a9f6c6b0df537f21efa5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d5f5b20539a6defcbb1160e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085953,"date":"2026-06-12T16:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, while the high-flying Prime Minister is racking up a $1-million debt for luxury inflight catering, many Canadians are struggling just to put food on the table. There were 2.2 million Canadians who went to a food bank in one month last year alone, but the Prime Minister is living the high life, even though he is leading the only G20 country into a recession. \n\nWill the Prime Minister reverse his failed policies that are causing this food affordability crisis so that Canadians can afford to live again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085953","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, while the high-flying Prime Minister is racking up a $1-million debt for luxury inflight catering, many Canadians are struggling just to put food on the table. There were 2.2 million Canadians who went to a food bank in one month last year alone, but the Prime Minister is living the high life, even though he is leading the only G20 country into a recession. \n\nWill the Prime Minister r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58b4dc08f2b638972017bba4ed5878a7b5a85a2823fc3b4dbc67ee687f09d6b2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b955ef4c67c6c60920ca54d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085954,"date":"2026-06-12T21:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the minister for her speech on this self-government agreement, which she says could inform future agreements.\n\nThere is the Musqueam recognition rights agreement in Vancouver, which has become very controversial. It says that it is not a land agreement, and it goes on to add some comfort that nothing in this agreement is going to impact any aboriginal rights. What is missing is some comfort for the other party, the three million people in Vancouver, who are worried about private property rights. Perhaps it could say something like, \"the protection and inalienability of fee simple property rights for all Canadians\".\n\nWould that be an improvement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085954","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the minister for her speech on this self-government agreement, which she says could inform future agreements.\n\nThere is the Musqueam recognition rights agreement in Vancouver, which has become very controversial. It says that it is not a land agreement, and it goes on to add some comfort that nothing in this agreement is going to impact any aboriginal rights. What is missing i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a52eef291c18ca0be7d74c93d526fec67791c7f96c9c999f217e7e4164cc84b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["200d855196c5f8047d14dc24540bc43959c9f8d16988cbca1606b14e0c0d379c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34f34559f0cd7a1b02fa87c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085955,"date":"2026-06-12T21:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, earlier in the debate today, we heard the minister say that this agreement is a model to inform future treaties, yet the most recent treaty, the K'ómoks Treaty, which my colleague also mentioned, introduces the concept of UNDRIP, a foreign document. This is not made in Canada. Could my colleague comment on how important it is for Canada to stick to made-in-Canada solutions when we are drafting our treaties?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085955","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, earlier in the debate today, we heard the minister say that this agreement is a model to inform future treaties, yet the most recent treaty, the K'ómoks Treaty, which my colleague also mentioned, introduces the concept of UNDRIP, a foreign document. This is not made in Canada. Could my colleague comment on how important it is for Canada to stick to made-in-Canada solutions when we are","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad994aa6256d75de6bf12d69b73db59153076bdb3f3db3f72689df012e523766"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a955d567a0bfe6e0190c48a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115646,"date":"2026-06-16T16:25:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Mr. Assistant Deputy Minister, for being here with us. I too am disappointed that the minister couldn't be here, and likewise Mr. Boegman. That said, you are more than welcome at our committee. Thank you for taking our questions. I too will lodge my concern about the apparent delays in getting this foreign influence transparency registry set up. Mr. Jeneroux noted in an earlier line of questions that it's been two years. You've said, and we've read elsewhere, that two years isn't unusual, but I would point out that it is two years and we're still not set up. The concerns around delays go back further than that. I'm reading from the report of Justice Hogue from the Hogue commission, which she submitted about a year and a half ago. She'd been working on it for several years. This is on page 4 of her report. She noted that, \"trust in Canada's democratic institutions has been shaken, and it is imperative to restore it.\" I'm sure you agree with that. The government agreed with it at the time. Our concern isn't whether the government is concerned but whether the government is acting swiftly enough. I say that in the context of something else that the commissioner noted. I'm reading at the bottom of page 3 of her report: I also note from the evidence that Canada has responded to attempts at foreign interference with measures and mechanisms to better detect, deter and counter them. She goes on, at the top of page 4: That said, the government's response has been far from perfect: I have observed that the government has sometimes taken too long to act, and that coordination between the various players involved has not always been optimal. She goes on to say: Processes by which information had to be passed on to certain decision-makers, including elected officials, have not proved as effective as they should have been. At a third bullet she states: In addition, the government has proven to be a poor communicator and insufficiently transparent when it comes to foreign interference. The measures implemented over the past two years, along with several statements made on the matter, suggest that the government is now prioritizing the fight against foreign interference. This must continue. This is what Justice Hogue said a year and a half ago. She was reflecting on evidence that she had received over the previous two years. This has been going on for at least four years. You can see why there's a concern among some parliamentarians that there appear to be further delays. What can you tell us and what can you tell Canadians to assure us that the government is not only taking this seriously but is also acting on it as promptly as is reasonably possible?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115646","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Mr. Assistant Deputy Minister, for being here with us. I too am disappointed that the minister couldn't be here, and likewise Mr. Boegman. That said, you are more than welcome at our committee. Thank you for taking our questions. I too will lodge my concern about the apparent delays in getting this foreign influence transparency registry set up. Mr. Jeneroux noted in a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c8a86cf04af8a27c1b8aed46ca78a91f46fdd7483779d51ca977bbf8209746ac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22f5299e1719cb2f2e36e0b089707ae782167548900a62127c91bf356f8d3185"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0c7a05b3df18ba09dec1c2b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115647,"date":"2026-06-16T16:30:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you. Canada is not the first country to set up a foreign influence transparency registry. What lessons have you and your department learned from Australia and the United Kingdom—there may be others, but those two in particular—who are close allies of ours with similar legal structures and similar political structures? What lessons have we learned from them that could have sped things up a bit for us?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115647","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Canada is not the first country to set up a foreign influence transparency registry. What lessons have you and your department learned from Australia and the United Kingdom—there may be others, but those two in particular—who are close allies of ours with similar legal structures and similar political structures? What lessons have we learned from them that could have sped things up a bi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed629a9bb0c1653a73fe1633","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087872,"date":"2026-06-18T01:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, earlier in debate tonight, we heard from the Liberal side of the House suggesting that anybody who was opposed to Bill C‐22 was fearmongering and spreading misinformation. However, the very rational debate coming from the member for Vancouver East would suggest otherwise.\n\nAlso, I am reading a Global News story that says that social media platforms, satellite companies and telecommunication companies will consider leaving Canada if and when Bill C‐22 passes because they are afraid they are not going to be able to maintain their customers' privacy, something that they are committed to doing. The secondary concern of these companies seems to be the additional cost of having to maintain digital information for a long period of time.\n\nCan the member for Vancouver East comment on those very rational concerns?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087872","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, earlier in debate tonight, we heard from the Liberal side of the House suggesting that anybody who was opposed to Bill C‐22 was fearmongering and spreading misinformation. However, the very rational debate coming from the member for Vancouver East would suggest otherwise.\n\nAlso, I am reading a Global News story that says that social media platforms, satellite companies and telecommu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a09637884a794b5185c81a09c316b7024b4d86a9fa03b4ee8e60d5f1fb4f4d5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc2a5dba393c37bcc6ae27bae4490742adb768b0ed975b3000dd07b411a2abc3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efa38af966c72d067ca1f064","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087870,"date":"2026-06-18T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in Cowichan Tribes v. the Attorney General of Canada, the B.C. Supreme Court declared aboriginal title over private lands, and the private landowners, 150 of them, are worried. It has been well documented that the Liberals directed their federal lawyers to drop arguments protecting private property rights, to pull their punches and allow aboriginal title to take precedence. \n\nWhere are the results for private landowners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087870","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in Cowichan Tribes v. the Attorney General of Canada, the B.C. Supreme Court declared aboriginal title over private lands, and the private landowners, 150 of them, are worried. It has been well documented that the Liberals directed their federal lawyers to drop arguments protecting private property rights, to pull their punches and allow aboriginal title to take precedence. \n\nWhere ar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6314cd52e61678100f818bd44e793a5e246e3999828bde3f6630e6fa5bd84156"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47585d504d62122e54ad2ac20569c8b4d98c506f954979037a84228813f79f98"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04a38ff0143826021fc28bce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087871,"date":"2026-06-18T20:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tako Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the reality is that the appeal process in British Columbia is going to take years. In the meantime, homeowners in Richmond, British Columbia, and throughout the province are feeling insecure. Here is the reality in the subject territory in Richmond. Realtors are not taking listings, appraisers are devaluing property values and bankers are not lending money on title that they see as insecure. \n\nMy question again is this: Where was the federal government to stand up for private property rights?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087871","member_id":"bc-mp-105811","member_name":"Tako Van Popta","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the reality is that the appeal process in British Columbia is going to take years. In the meantime, homeowners in Richmond, British Columbia, and throughout the province are feeling insecure. Here is the reality in the subject territory in Richmond. Realtors are not taking listings, appraisers are devaluing property values and bankers are not lending money on title that they see as in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af5b0de7933693fbf682c99f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76238,"date":"2026-01-27T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are shocked by their grocery bills. That is because Canada is seeing the worst food inflation in the G7. Paycheques cannot keep up with the prices, yet the Liberals are burdening our farms with fuel taxes and red tape. We need affordability from farm to table. Conservatives are ready to fast-track any bill that would reverse the highest inflation in the G7.\n\nWill the Liberals immediately introduce legislation that would cut red tape and taxes for farmers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76238","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are shocked by their grocery bills. That is because Canada is seeing the worst food inflation in the G7. Paycheques cannot keep up with the prices, yet the Liberals are burdening our farms with fuel taxes and red tape. We need affordability from farm to table. Conservatives are ready to fast-track any bill that would reverse the highest inflation in the G7.\n\nWill the Liberal","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f79d52907df4ad5f81a479e4dfaa615cc82ea5b9873bd8b32cea3820a9ac2333"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a667ffb24fd29ad0ca49177084211cb3e7dd51485675e58ffebcbf2cb2ce59a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8dc6f42494a9a4b94d9b4232","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76239,"date":"2026-01-28T20:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am presenting a petition on behalf of Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay. Petitioners are saying that they have a right to free speech and a right to religion and freedom of expression. They are concerned that the amendments to Bill C-9 presented by the Liberals and the Bloc would be used to criminalize passages from the Torah, the Quran and the Bible. They are asking the government to uphold the right to read and share these sacred texts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76239","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am presenting a petition on behalf of Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay. Petitioners are saying that they have a right to free speech and a right to religion and freedom of expression. They are concerned that the amendments to Bill C-9 presented by the Liberals and the Bloc would be used to criminalize passages from the Torah, the Quran and the Bible. They are asking the go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b4c561deafbce6f081944ca861dea9af94017d6aef1510800137596ad9dc6e98"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["250e08dbbea61f186c56035c97f039b17856e392cd868a989192e4f7b70ef89c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0cd9555e9c7df33cb0885dfb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76240,"date":"2026-01-28T23:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am grateful for the opportunity to rise for the first time this year to speak to Bill C-223.\n\nBefore I begin, I want to extend my warmest wishes for a happy new year to all the residents of Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay. Over the holidays, many of them took the time to write, call or speak to me directly. I want them to know how much I value those conversations. Hearing from them is essential to my work, and I am truly honoured to represent them in Ottawa in 2026.\n\nThe legislation before us, Bill C-223, an act to amend the Divorce Act, addresses an issue that touches families in a deeply personal way. The proposed changes to the Divorce Act are the first in several years, and I appreciate the member opposite for using her private member's bill to focus on such an important area of the law.\n\nFor people who may not be familiar with the the bill, I will say that it proposes a number of reforms to the Divorce Act, the first since 2021. Although I was not yet a member of the House at that time, it is clear that those earlier reforms were significant and that many advocates have continued to call for further improvements.\n\nFrom speaking with people in the communities I represent, people who have been through the family court system, it is evident that inconsistencies in how cases proceed can undermine fairness. Experts have also highlighted how difficult it can be for the courts to properly assess coercive control and psychological abuse, both because of limited resources and because these forms of harm are not always easily defined in law. In addition, despite children being at the centre of these cases, children's voices are still not heard consistently. Alongside this is the very real and very serious issue of parental alienation.\n\nThere is much in the bill that I believe members across the House can support. One provision I am particularly glad to see is the explicit direction to courts not to dismiss allegations of family violence simply because there is no police report or no visible injury, or because parties continue to live together. This is a meaningful change, one that resonates with me personally. Many years ago, a friend confided in me that she would be better off if he had hit her. She was living in a coercive, abusive situation that left no bruises but caused deep harm. Her experience was a reminder that violence is not always physical but is no less real.\n\nThe bill also proposes requiring legal advisers to assess risks of family violence and to develop safety plans, and it would strengthen the ability of courts to consider coercive control and its impact on parent-child relationships. It would further introduce safeguards around the use of direct testimony from children.\n\nIf the bill were limited to these reforms, I expect members would still raise questions about implementation, particularly around the new responsibilities placed on courts and legal professionals. This would be expensive, but it is important. Overall, these are constructive steps.\n\nHowever, I do have concerns with one aspect of the bill: the provision that would prohibit judges from considering evidence of parental alienation in family law cases. As I mentioned earlier, I appreciate the bill's efforts to broaden the types of evidence courts can consider, especially regarding children's testimony and family violence. Family law cases are complex and emotional, and they often require expert input, yet the bill would prevent judges from considering parental alienation, even when supported by expert analysis.\n\nThe bill would allow judges to consider coercive control, often based on expert opinion. I see no reason why judges should not also be permitted to consider parental alienation under the same conditions. Colleagues with legal experience have noted that parental alienation is already recognized in Canadian case law. One colleague from Ontario shared that in more than one-third of proven alienation cases, mothers were the alienated parent, often targeted by the abusive former partner. An absolute prohibition on considering this evidence seems, at best, misguided.\n\nI understand that the bill's sponsor has worked closely with organizations, such as the National Association of Women and the Law. Its contributions are undoubtedly thoughtful. However, its characterization of parental alienation as junk science is not universally shared. As a lawmaker, not a lawyer, I have reviewed the research, and it is clear that many respected voices in both law and social science disagree with that assessment.\n\nI would draw the House's attention to a detailed critique published in Law360 by two distinguished scholars: Nicholas Bala, a professor of law at Queen's University, and Rachel Birnbaum, a social worker and professor at King's University College, Western University. They raise many of the same concerns I have outlined, particularly regarding the risks of prohibiting judges from considering parental alienation altogether. They also reference rigorous scientific and legal research supporting the validity of parental alienation, including studies published in Developmental Psychology and the University of New Brunswick Law Journal.\n\nI want to close by acknowledging the member's sincere commitment to improving the safety and well-being of children. Her intentions are good, and I respect the work she has put into this bill, but good intentions alone cannot form the basis of sound legislation. As debate continues, I look forward to hearing from colleagues across the House. Should the bill proceed to committee, I believe it will require careful study and thoughtful amendment, informed by expert testimony. Our goal must be to craft legislation that truly protects children and supports families through some of the most difficult moments of their lives.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76240","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am grateful for the opportunity to rise for the first time this year to speak to Bill C-223.\n\nBefore I begin, I want to extend my warmest wishes for a happy new year to all the residents of Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay. Over the holidays, many of them took the time to write, call or speak to me directly. I want them to know how much I value those conversations. Hearing f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8f00304f98d8e3fd33b41bfa9007aaed0e7175f1a1a4ee84de83d2a52314e770"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01ccaca4ceb4ad59a0e3a4b25b79fc5c56c920539e04f7473044097f6b21cf2f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d28a758900018162b43bc95f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76241,"date":"2026-01-29T15:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is obvious that Canadians, and Canadian municipalities in particular, have been crying for help from the Liberals for years. They have been burdened with crime and criminals walking the streets.\n\nWhy does the member think this is suddenly such an important issue for the Liberals? They have finally put it on the agenda, as if it were something brand new they had never heard of before.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76241","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is obvious that Canadians, and Canadian municipalities in particular, have been crying for help from the Liberals for years. They have been burdened with crime and criminals walking the streets.\n\nWhy does the member think this is suddenly such an important issue for the Liberals? They have finally put it on the agenda, as if it were something brand new they had never heard of befor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f928e56821b6db59435d5240323af45155dda93cc133f40ae27e66370ee5a0ed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a4f0dc10f278bf71607129234613c631b6f8072aaac37e86d1f54cd1fc84dbdb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d246f54ac5bac5c8d4c0825","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76242,"date":"2026-01-29T17:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am honoured to present this petition from concerned Canadians who are worried about the Bloc and Liberal amendments to Bill C-9. They are urging the government to protect free speech, freedom of expression and freedom of religion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76242","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am honoured to present this petition from concerned Canadians who are worried about the Bloc and Liberal amendments to Bill C-9. They are urging the government to protect free speech, freedom of expression and freedom of religion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["33008024a9a977b4c674d8eff5d47293a38eff7edbe739fb6e8b53988b3a6e15"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bedea9c536593c682b813d94","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76243,"date":"2026-01-29T17:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I will split my time with the member for Cowichan—Malahat—Langford.\n\nI am speaking today on Bill C-16, the government's proposal to address the serious issue of rising violent crime and the growing lack of public safety. Residents in communities across Canada and my riding, including those in Penticton, Oliver, Princeton and Castlegar, tell me things do not feel as safe as they used to. I am hearing this constantly. While our region is the most beautiful in Canada and a place I feel proud to call home, many do not feel safe walking our streets, shopping in our downtowns, visiting our hospitals or clinics, or even at night in their homes.\n\nWithin just the last few months, we have had a firebombing in Castlegar, an attempted break-and-enter with a shotgun in Osoyoos and a shootout in Princeton. These are things we never used to see before, especially in rural towns. Residents have good reason to be concerned. There is a growing and fundamental issue of violent crime in this country that has gone unaddressed by the Liberals for years, but I am not telling the House anything new. The time for change is long overdue. Bill C-16, I hope, can do some good here, but some concerns remain.\n\nWhen I first joined municipal politics, people in the community were concerned about many issues, but crime was not top of the list. They worried mostly about parks, about job security and about taxes. In a decade, things have changed drastically. Now, it is a regular occurrence for people to say they are concerned, cautious or even afraid. In a place like Penticton, residents no longer feel safe to take a summer night stroll on our iconic Lakeshore Drive. The business associations there are clear that \"crime is what we are hearing about, every single day.\"\n\nJust this month, I had a conversation with a mother who lost her son in Penticton to violence. This young man was swarmed, assaulted and beaten until he died. Many residents of Penticton will remember this vicious murder, but what they might not realize is that we are mere months away from a statute of limitations issue. Delays in getting this complex case to court could mean this case, like many others in Canada, is never going to be properly heard, and the victim's family and friends and our small town will never have proper closure or see justice. This is not just justice delayed; it is no justice at all. I urge the courts to provide full and fair proceedings to this horrific case.\n\nSadly, it is not the only one. Why? What has changed in this decade? I suggest it is reflecting a chronic, years-long failure to uphold public safety, the first responsibility of any government. It is reflecting a failure to demonstrate consequences, a failure to provide a swift and fair application of justice for the accused, a failure to provide closure for victims of crime, a failure exasperated by a sluggish court system, and a failure to address a broken bail system.\n\nI appreciate that Bill C-16 tries to find solutions, finally. How does Bill C-16 address this? It is by taking on many of the ideas that the Conservatives have called for, for years. These measures are long overdue in our criminal justice system. After a decade in office, finally, the Liberals have acted.\n\nI give credit to my Conservative colleagues for their work throughout these years to finally get the Liberals to sit up and listen. I am glad to see the Liberals take up the proposal of my Conservative colleague, the member for Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, which would make the murder of an intimate partner automatically a first-degree offence. After the horrific murder of Bailey McCourt last summer, this is a proposal that I know the people of my riding and all of Canada can get behind.\n\nI also see that a new Criminal Code offence has been put forth, prohibiting engaging in a pattern of coercive or controlling conduct toward an intimate partner. I spoke about the importance of considering coercive control in the House just yesterday in my speech on Bill C-223, and I welcome it here as well, but the Liberals have also undermined key policies that matter for public safety and for public confidence that justice will be served, like mandatory minimum sentences. This is a policy that the public, historically this Parliament and the Conservatives have been supporting.\n\nIn my recent survey to my constituents, almost everyone who responded said they wanted violent criminals held responsible for their actions and wanted them to serve mandatory time. Instead, to appeal to soft-on-crime supporters, mandatory minimums in sentencing are undermined again in Bill C-16. Bill C-16 would amend the principles for sentencing, imposing on judges and courts the requirement to impose a sentence below a mandatory minimum sentence, as adopted by Parliament as law, where applying the minimum would amount to cruel and unusual punishment for the offender. This change would enable a path to lower sentences than mandatory minimums require, even for crimes such as human trafficking, weapons trafficking and offences committed with firearms, such as extortion or drive-by shootings.\n\nMandatory minimum sentences for violent offenders are not cruel or unusual punishments. A violent crime itself is a cruel and unusual punishment to its victims, their families and the entire community. This cannot be forgotten. Someone who is convicted of a drive-by shooting or armed extortion deserves to be jailed with a clear sentence set by a democratic body of the House representing the desires of all Canadians. In practice, this bill, as drafted, means that mandatory minimums would no longer be mandatory. That is unacceptable to me. Too many residents, families, seniors and small businesses in my riding and throughout Canada have been victimized and do not feel safe. Canadians have had enough.\n\nI do not come to the House to say \"no\", but to offer a better way forward. I hope that, across parties, we can recognize the positive measures that I have highlighted and split them into their own legislation that stands apart from these sentencing measures. Doing so would allow us to quickly implement positive changes to the Criminal Code while taking these ill-conceived sentencing proposals for fuller debate and study at the committee level.\n\nAfter a decade of catch-and-release Liberal bail, repealing mandatory minimums and increasing violent crimes, Canadians want better from their government. They want their taxes and their government to deliver safer communities, to prioritize them and their families over criminals and to prioritize justice. Let us work quickly to meet the expectations that our communities are demanding.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76243","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I will split my time with the member for Cowichan—Malahat—Langford.\n\nI am speaking today on Bill C-16, the government's proposal to address the serious issue of rising violent crime and the growing lack of public safety. Residents in communities across Canada and my riding, including those in Penticton, Oliver, Princeton and Castlegar, tell me things do not feel as safe as they used","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["74aa8dc5984367dbffbcdbf320a02e94e6ba0f2cded2b60c72efcc4639155243"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2830ad9921cfc708de3bc359a37e948807235d91e40e66e069141825899f541e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce5a744cc79a79a1cd984a2d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76244,"date":"2026-01-29T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, yes, I do appreciate that criminalizing deepfakes is in the bill and that there will be things we will work on in committee, things we agree on, but why has it taken this long to address crime when our communities have been crying for help for years? This is a move in the right direction, but why did it take a decade to get here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76244","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, yes, I do appreciate that criminalizing deepfakes is in the bill and that there will be things we will work on in committee, things we agree on, but why has it taken this long to address crime when our communities have been crying for help for years? This is a move in the right direction, but why did it take a decade to get here?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d6236139a98fb069277aec7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76245,"date":"2026-01-29T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, mandatory minimums are extremely important. When a crime is committed, such as the one that was presented to me by a mother whose child, a young person, was beaten in a playground, or extortion or the crimes that have been happening especially of late, they need to have mandatory minimums. That is what we will be pushing for in committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76245","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, mandatory minimums are extremely important. When a crime is committed, such as the one that was presented to me by a mother whose child, a young person, was beaten in a playground, or extortion or the crimes that have been happening especially of late, they need to have mandatory minimums. That is what we will be pushing for in committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aad57e2bf23111440fa160b569cfe0c2c5f7e47c62cc0fd6d6ca3453eb2ee28e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aab97f1f27996d4104dfa2badab41cf1fc98f37a064d57e04873e6cdec9237dc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1dd638b14a501442a8971aab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76246,"date":"2026-01-29T17:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, without mandatory minimums there is really no way that crime can be specifically addressed in our communities. Right now, municipalities are buckling under the responsibilities and the downloading they have had to take on because of the crime that has hit. It used to be just cities, but now our rural communities are being hit hard. There is no safe place to go, and mandatory minimums need to be brought forward with this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76246","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, without mandatory minimums there is really no way that crime can be specifically addressed in our communities. Right now, municipalities are buckling under the responsibilities and the downloading they have had to take on because of the crime that has hit. It used to be just cities, but now our rural communities are being hit hard. There is no safe place to go, and mandatory minimum","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ddf9428c10fbded8a3d950a0abd25afd3d334a7f3e44161597fce5eb830758a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98c98e37fe81327434f1da1ce308bd480c45f0e4ed11938be9d99245cdeb692e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e9dc3bc856f47cf716f9f11","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76247,"date":"2026-01-29T17:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member has been in his seat for many years, and I wonder why it has taken so long to address these very serious issues.\n\nYes, we will work on this in committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76247","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member has been in his seat for many years, and I wonder why it has taken so long to address these very serious issues.\n\nYes, we will work on this in committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b69b40f4fe689a797897530f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79299,"date":"2026-02-02T19:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay is not just home to the most beautiful rivers, lakes and valleys in all of Canada. It is also home to world-class athletes.\n\nFirst, I want to congratulate my local hockey team, the Penticton Vees. The Vees have a long history of hockey in Penticton. In 1955, they won the world championships; in 2012, they won the national championships; and now, in their first season in the WHL, they just completed a 14-game winning streak. Go, Vees, go!\n\nThen there are siblings Jasmine and Rémi Drolet from Rossland, who will be going for gold at the Winter Olympics this month in cross-country skiing. I thank them for their hard work. The whole community will be cheering them on. No one will stop Canada when we go for the gold.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79299","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay is not just home to the most beautiful rivers, lakes and valleys in all of Canada. It is also home to world-class athletes.\n\nFirst, I want to congratulate my local hockey team, the Penticton Vees. The Vees have a long history of hockey in Penticton. In 1955, they won the world championships; in 2012, they won the national championships; and now","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["29ff34e04bd5925d5db9890e6fe5a306682da23132ec8ac744e4918136b84f71"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dff56925ca2299c72476d898c613379667ae4ec24280071e8caf739c99839dcf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6d48b76e932bd372db04f12","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79295,"date":"2026-02-05T16:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I really appreciate the heartfelt comments of my colleague. It is terrible what happened in Mirabel and what is happening now. The subject of private property is coming up a lot lately throughout the country, as well as the right to ownership of land and the security of owning our land and our families continuing to own our land in the future.\n\nWhy does my colleague think that there is possibly distrust right now in the current government on whether people throughout the country, not just in Quebec and Mirabel, might not be able to continue to own their land?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79295","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I really appreciate the heartfelt comments of my colleague. It is terrible what happened in Mirabel and what is happening now. The subject of private property is coming up a lot lately throughout the country, as well as the right to ownership of land and the security of owning our land and our families continuing to own our land in the future.\n\nWhy does my colleague think that there i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc7e81d389e22262c0f32a9ff483129412e860baa7d35ec268fa96f62f999c36"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-572e46033945247c67441e29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79296,"date":"2026-02-05T17:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from the Bloc mentioned that there is talk of a distrust in government. I am hearing that a lot too. What happened in Mirabel is terrible. There are issues with private property across the country right now that are not being addressed, even in my province of British Columbia. \n\nWhy do you think the people of Canada, or residents, have a distrust in the current government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79296","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from the Bloc mentioned that there is talk of a distrust in government. I am hearing that a lot too. What happened in Mirabel is terrible. There are issues with private property across the country right now that are not being addressed, even in my province of British Columbia. \n\nWhy do you think the people of Canada, or residents, have a distrust in the current government","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1e6f425e8cfd8b73171bbedae3ad36e5bfcd439a61ad73dc9fb000ee58720ec4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66eaff7a0938ffc60a5e9d72","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79297,"date":"2026-02-05T23:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise tonight to speak on the importance of Canada's bountiful natural resources, specifically the industries vital to my home province of British Columbia. \n\nOur forestry industry gainfully employs many men and women across my riding. It has put food on the table and a roof over the heads of Canadians for decades and has the potential to do so for decades more, but Canada's lack of a softwood lumber agreement like we had under the Harper government has left our industry at the mercy of tariffs across four presidential administrations now, all under the Liberal government's watch.\n\nThe most recent lumber tariffs have caused deep concern in my riding, especially in Grand Forks, where the Interfor mill is now operating at reduced capacity, and that is more than some other mill communities in western Canada can say. Thousands of jobs have been lost just recently. Just last month, we saw the permanent closure of mills in Crofton and 100 Mile House, B.C. Similarly, mills in northern Alberta and northern Ontario have recently closed as well. These are not just jobs but entire communities being lost. \n\nThe Liberal government lacks the clear vision and real, immediate focus on where Canada's lumber market needs to be, which is restoring access to the U.S. market. Promises of loans, domestic building and memorandums of understanding in Asian markets are all welcome, but they will not help if our sawmills shut before these opportunities turn real. \n\nThe U.S. represents well over half the market for Canada. Restoring access there needs to be a priority. It should have been a priority for the Liberals when our last deal expired a decade ago. European lumber suppliers operating at lower tariff rates are already trying to seal the supply chain, which for decades has been the lifeblood of lumber communities across Canada and British Columbia. \n\nI also wish to discuss the importance of mining in my riding. Copper Mountain in the Similkameen valley is a vital operation for the region, producing the copper, gold and silver required to build the self-reliant and greener Canada we need. Without these precious metals, electronics and sustainable technologies simply could not function. It is clear that for us to have a prosperous and richer Canada, our critical minerals are essential, but for them to be used they must reach the market. \n\nThe Similkameen, however, has seen the basic infrastructure that Copper Mountain relies on, the roads and bridges, damaged and closed because of greater risks of flooding. The Liberal government promised it would help our region build back after the damaging floods in 2021, but instead of working with the region, it refused. It refused the community's mitigation plan and provided nothing in return. We have gone years without proper mitigation infrastructure being installed. If left undone, this will challenge our ability to mine our critical minerals. \n\nLast month, I wrote to the Prime Minister and several of his ministers about this, calling for him to approve the plan presented by the town of Princeton. I have still received no reply. The government says it wants to be a government of action and not words, yet too often, words on paper are its approach to our natural resources.\n\n When will the government show—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79297","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise tonight to speak on the importance of Canada's bountiful natural resources, specifically the industries vital to my home province of British Columbia. \n\nOur forestry industry gainfully employs many men and women across my riding. It has put food on the table and a roof over the heads of Canadians for decades and has the potential to do so for decades more, but Canada's lack o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["abc777c8a241902f754377c67b92b2d10e82cff31d1dba042061568903d298ec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dce7a55995e8937a9c119218a5d1d44bd6ff1a969641f65a69520d43cd646214"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-350c482c6b96b06e68ad87d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79298,"date":"2026-02-05T23:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate the concern. I wonder why it has taken over 10 years. We still do not have an agreement with the United States, through many presidents, so we cannot blame everything on President Trump. \n\nEnergy workers want to see a pipeline. Forestry workers want to see some kind of deal with the Americans. My particular riding crawls along the United States, so it is important that we keep those. We actually have six border crossings, and that is one of the reasons we need to make the deal with the United States. \n\nHowever, I do want to say I will send the member the letter that I sent to the Prime Minister in the last couple of weeks. These mitigation plans for Princeton were promised since—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79298","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate the concern. I wonder why it has taken over 10 years. We still do not have an agreement with the United States, through many presidents, so we cannot blame everything on President Trump. \n\nEnergy workers want to see a pipeline. Forestry workers want to see some kind of deal with the Americans. My particular riding crawls along the United States, so it is important that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","label":"Border crossing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","label":"Border crossing","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["87bf4eb7a3a0c23b06d573fc54e8dc53bfa06ff6b67e2b92586c23feef38c325"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e87b155212434ae7dfa4cfd46b7efd6a3be57beacc93af354c888d06286434b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b972c4e81fa75ed3ba0a6f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79293,"date":"2026-02-06T17:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Liberal finance minister failed to stabilize grocery prices as he promised to do three years ago. His new one-off rebate will not reduce the cost of a single item on the shelf, and food bank lines in my region will not shrink, yet the Liberals voted against our motion to reduce transport and packaging costs for farmers. \n\nFood inflation must come down. When will the Liberals work with us to cut taxes to bring down the cost of food?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79293","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Liberal finance minister failed to stabilize grocery prices as he promised to do three years ago. His new one-off rebate will not reduce the cost of a single item on the shelf, and food bank lines in my region will not shrink, yet the Liberals voted against our motion to reduce transport and packaging costs for farmers. \n\nFood inflation must come down. When will the Liberals wor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bfd0ff7d0318ed2aaed3cd9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79294,"date":"2026-02-06T19:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, my colleague's speech was excellent. I learn a lot from him every time he stands up in the House.\n\nAs a new member, I was not surprised about the virtual voting, as I knew that existed, but I was surprised by how often some members use it; some are not in their seat very often, and they vote from abroad.\n\nDoes the member think there should be limitations on virtual voting?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79294","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, my colleague's speech was excellent. I learn a lot from him every time he stands up in the House.\n\nAs a new member, I was not surprised about the virtual voting, as I knew that existed, but I was surprised by how often some members use it; some are not in their seat very often, and they vote from abroad.\n\nDoes the member think there should be limitations on virtual voting?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e35459d89a4cc07cdbdd07a1d963be45d56fa0dd5643bb17a395ee9b251b590c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63c88cb789876b096eaf2f11","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288382,"date":"2026-02-09T16:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-230, an act to amend the Financial Administration Act and to make consequential amendments to other acts.\n\nBefore I begin my speech, I would like to very briefly address a tragedy in my community. I recently met with a grieving mother in Penticton who lost her son when he was swarmed, assaulted and beaten until he died. That horrifying event occurred four and a half years ago, yet it has still not gone to trial. Justice delayed is justice denied to the family and friends of victims and to this mother. A full and fair day in court should not take almost half a decade.\n\n Returning to the legislation, I want to thank my esteemed colleague the member for Simcoe North for bringing this important legislation forward. He has been a great colleague to me, and I know he is widely respected across this entire chamber.\n\nThis legislation addresses one of the most important aspects of governance: transparency in our taxes. Now, while there has always been disagreement across the House on how tax dollars should be spent, there has been an agreement among all parties that we should always be able to see where they are spent. This is what makes this legislation so important. It seeks to cast transparency on potentially billions of dollars lost every year with no window for the public to understand why.\n\nJust a few years ago, a Conservative colleague of mine discovered that the Canada Revenue Agency had written off $133 million in taxes owed by just one taxpayer. Was this a person? Was this a corporation? The CRA would not say. The CRA did not have to say. Can Canadians know if this was a person or a corporation that benefited from public subsidies? No. When the Liberals approved $1.2 billion in 11 separate corporate tax debt writeoffs in 2024, were Canadians allowed to know which corporations were involved? No.\n\nIn Canada today, corporate debt owed to the Canadian government through the Canada Revenue Agency can be written off, waived or forgiven entirely in secret. There is no requirement for the CRA to tell Canadians which corporation had these debts written off or the reasons they were written off. There is no explanation of how nearly 60,000 public employees at the CRA were unable to collect these enormous outstanding debts.\n\nThere is a curtain here that disguises millions, if not billions, in lost collections owed to the government. In fact, just last year, the Liberals wrote off $18.4 million in outstanding taxes, and billions owed by corporations. That is not right. Ultimately, these are tax dollars lost that Ottawa would move to collect from Canadians elsewhere to make up the revenue shortfall.\n\nResidents and small businesses in my riding do not often get this type of treatment from the CRA. When their taxes are outstanding, or even just slightly off when filed, they see the letters in their mailbox, the voice mails on their phone and the emails in their inbox. They see interest charges and collection attempts. We see them in our offices regularly. Regular citizens are chased down for small amounts. Many businesses I meet with are frantic because they cannot even get a hold of someone at the CRA, let alone understand what went wrong or why they owe this amount. Sometimes they just need to talk to somebody.\n\nThere are single mothers and older Canadians who do not have the means to pay what might seem like a small amount compared with these huge amounts I have been speaking about, but these people are trying their best to do the right thing, so they come into our offices. They should not have to do that. It is time for fairness and transparency at the CRA. This is a start, and that is why I support Bill C-230.\n\nThe bill would create an accessible, searchable public registry under the Treasury Board. The registry would annually publish a list of all corporate entities that have had debts owed to the government waived, forgiven or written off, if the amount exceeds $1 million. Attached to each case would have to be an explanation, and this is extremely important, as to why the Canada Revenue Agency says it is not worth pursuing millions, possibly billions, in outstanding debt.\n\nWe know this reasoning exists internally at the CRA. It may even be understandable, such as in bankruptcy proceedings, but the registry would make it clear and public. I know there has been some discussion about the million-dollar threshold for reporting, and I believe the author of the legislation says he is open to good-faith amendments to this.\n\nWe should make it clear that the legislation would apply only to corporate entities and is set with that in mind. It is not the purpose of the legislation to shame an individual Canadian or even a family farm that might be going through a bankruptcy proceeding. The focus of the law would be on giving Canadians more information, especially when they see the government seeking to engage in, for example, corporate welfare. It is too common for Canadians to see press releases and ribbon cuttings for public subsidies and tax dollars being used to try to pick winners in our economy, only for those projects or expansions to fall flat.\n\nWe have seen this very recently with the Liberals' approach to the auto sector over the last several years, with shiny deals announced only to be followed up with the downsizing of Canadian workers. Now, if these same companies have their debts written off, there is no way for Canadians to know. The bill would shine a light through this fog.\n\nIn the age of deficits, when the Liberals continue to insist that debt is permanent, that the budget will never be balanced and that we will always be spending more than we take in, it is even more critical to ensure that the money Ottawa is owed is collected. When we set taxes and undercollect, the pressure always pushes the government to raise more taxes to fill the gap. It is vital to ensure that the highest taxpayers do not wriggle out of their obligations, because that pressure will ultimately fall on those who can pay less to make up the shortfall.\n\nProper tax collection is what sets the floor for reducing the tax burden on working Canadians. The record-high amounts that the Liberals have been writing off, with, again, $18 billion written off in just one year, only sets conditions for more tax hikes.\n\nThere were many well-deserved tributes to former prime minister Stephen Harper last week. One of his accomplishments that I did not hear enough about was how, by 2015, he had reduced the federal tax burden to its lowest level in over 50 years. Canadians are no longer the beneficiaries of that sound fiscal policy. To ensure we have the transparency in our tax system that helps to set the conditions for lower taxes, I would call on all members of the House to pass Bill C-230.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288382","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-230, an act to amend the Financial Administration Act and to make consequential amendments to other acts.\n\nBefore I begin my speech, I would like to very briefly address a tragedy in my community. I recently met with a grieving mother in Penticton who lost her son when he was swarmed, assaulted and beaten until he died. That horrifying event occurred four a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15c3b6ca4e66fb3b8168451f71ce70bc15663b5384a275e2c75a4b32b495055b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["79f210ab687b8f5c5d86f672a4b4711bdc84933ca07854ead03086d5a239e177"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2a3b42fd3d795331f4aef6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288379,"date":"2026-02-12T16:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, today a family of five needs a car and decides that, because we live in a democracy and they cannot be coerced into what kind of car to buy, they are going to try an electric vehicle. What does the hon. member say to them? They also want to buy Canadian. They want to help Canadians keep their jobs.\n\nWhat does the hon. member say to them, a family of five, when all that is available to them today is a Dodge Charger?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288379","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, today a family of five needs a car and decides that, because we live in a democracy and they cannot be coerced into what kind of car to buy, they are going to try an electric vehicle. What does the hon. member say to them? They also want to buy Canadian. They want to help Canadians keep their jobs.\n\nWhat does the hon. member say to them, a family of five, when all that is available ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["42e29487017f7ee136fd73bf978b5c183f3cd5a4da6c534b935ccfdbfd8dac26"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fc6dd5d63e5c79e428cd6ca7d3c4b178333f8880955b9f2feba3efa2ef6543e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f61eccf2b240f83ad2858245","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288380,"date":"2026-02-12T23:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I listened carefully to the government members' defence of the industrial carbon tax. They say farmers do not pay it. They say it only applies to large emitters. They say it has almost no impact on households. \n\nLet us walk through this in plain terms. When a farmer in my riding buys a new combine or replaces their tractor, that equipment is built with Canadian steel produced under a carbon price that is rising to $170 per tonne. When they purchase replacement parts, install an irrigation system, upgrade an industrial dryer or build a machine shed, those materials are made from steel and aluminum produced under the same industrial carbon cost. The government may not send the bill directly to the farmer, but the farmer receives it anyway.\n\nStatistics Canada has confirmed that realized net farm income dropped by $3.3 billion in 2024, which is a 26% decline. At the same time, operating costs climbed to $78.5 billion and farm debt rose to 14%. Farmers are not looking for lectures about climate policy; they are trying to cover their costs and plan for the next season. \n\nProfessor Sylvain Charlebois from Dalhousie University has been clear, saying, \"The industrial carbon tax...continues to erode competitiveness in the agri-foods sector.\" He has pointed to the growing cost gap with producers in the United States. That gap matters when Canadian farmers are competing directly with American producers who are not operating under a $170 per tonne carbon trajectory.\n\nWhen Canadians say food costs are too high, they were asking for policies that bring costs down. Instead, they received a temporary one-off rebate. I do not oppose this rebate, but it does not change the cost structure for farm equipment; it sends money back after the price has already gone up. If the policy increases costs at the production level and then we offer rebates to offset those higher costs, that is an admission that the burden exists.\n\nCanadians do not want a cycle of higher costs followed by temporary relief; they want structural change to make things cost less. The government speaks out about being pro-Canada and strengthening domestic supply chains. It speaks about building more here at home, but if something is produced in Canada to be used in Canada, such as steel and aluminum, it carries this industrial carbon cost. This is the same when the government wants to use Canadian-made steel and aluminum in a Canadian-made car, a Canadian-made ship or a Canadian-made bridge. Everything the government wants to build more of in Canada is increased by the industrial carbon tax, while other markets are unaffected.\n\nThe incentive for suppliers to build or fabricate elsewhere becomes higher. For example, the Liberals chose to build B.C. ferries in China instead of Canadian shipyards, which means using non-Canadian steel and no support for Canadian shipyard jobs. We cannot ignore that reality. \n\nThe question is straight forward: If the industrial carbon tax increases the cost of producing the very goods we say we want to build in Canada, is that policy helping affordability or is it making the problem worse?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288380","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I listened carefully to the government members' defence of the industrial carbon tax. They say farmers do not pay it. They say it only applies to large emitters. They say it has almost no impact on households. \n\nLet us walk through this in plain terms. When a farmer in my riding buys a new combine or replaces their tractor, that equipment is built with Canadian steel produced under a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","label":"Incentives","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ff1d22d932a31baf2a55169943beecdcfa52b71196cd0fcfa6bb38771e8047e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33016bd6095d17013aa1da37f0b10969dda68dfc3f2b453a44bfb5bfc54b7b1d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-972f302e39fcff9d9560dc6c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288381,"date":"2026-02-13T00:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, no member of the House is arguing against reducing emissions. The question is whether driving the industrial carbon tax to $170 per tonne, while our competitors in the United States do not face the same burden, is helping the environment or simply pushing production elsewhere. If steel production moves south, emissions do not disappear; jobs disappear, investment disappears and Canadian competitiveness disappears. Meanwhile the farmer still pays more for his equipment, and the manufacturer makes fewer products.\n\nThis is not a debate about caring for the environment; it is a debate about whether the policy is making life more affordable. The government has still not answered that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288381","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, no member of the House is arguing against reducing emissions. The question is whether driving the industrial carbon tax to $170 per tonne, while our competitors in the United States do not face the same burden, is helping the environment or simply pushing production elsewhere. If steel production moves south, emissions do not disappear; jobs disappear, investment disappears and Canadi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6d526cb0772ee3bf30837020f5fe97ad9ba7452298a0315e054d0b7001fdcb44"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c415e7f4c235e76f16b4c2db852b24e7be3e85e877cfda58b716eaeb7118c9c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ef1da0a4654e31504a5b715","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288377,"date":"2026-02-13T16:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the government's own housing agency shows fewer homes being built over the next three years, while home prices will only rise. A third of homebuilders are building less because they are forced to lay off workers. Young men and women in B.C. are seeing the dream of home ownership fading. Years of Liberal homebuilding programs have not delivered.\n\nWill the Liberals adopt our plan to remove the GST on all new homes to help builders build and young Canadians buy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288377","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the government's own housing agency shows fewer homes being built over the next three years, while home prices will only rise. A third of homebuilders are building less because they are forced to lay off workers. Young men and women in B.C. are seeing the dream of home ownership fading. Years of Liberal homebuilding programs have not delivered.\n\nWill the Liberals adopt our plan to rem","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d18c78545c6ebc046c62680a82011d9af78d510222252f1bb41ef049ea92ebc6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d2e086995e897fdc8e069525f9ef5ae1d3b3c37877928a067d76a95542caed59"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95d6d76749f7573cfcb33dea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288378,"date":"2026-02-13T18:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-244, an act to amend the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999, and the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act. \n\nI want to thank sponsor of the bill for bringing forward an issue that coastal, river and lakeside communities across Canada have been raising for years. It is definitely on the right path. This is a huge problem throughout Canada and the interior of British Columbia, which I represent, and also in our beautiful lakes such as Okanagan Lake, where abandoned vessels have caused environmental chaos. \n\n Abandoned and derelict vessels, which are commonly referred to as DAVs, are a growing and serious threat to our ecosystems, our fisheries, our aquatic habitats and the Canadians who depend on them. These vessels pollute our waters, endanger marine life, block navigational routes, pose real safety risks to workers, first responders and entire communities, and affect tourism. \n\nConservatives believe in protecting Canadian waterways and conserving our marine environment. We believe government has a responsibility to ensure the rules meant to protect our oceans and lakes are actually enforced. When vessels operate in Canadian waters, whether they are local, commercial or foreign, they must meet strong standards that keep Canadians safe and protect the environment. \n\nLeaving abandoned vessels to rot and pollute our coasts and beautiful lakes is not an option. We have seen this over and over again in my riding and in the Okanagan Valley. Vessels have sunk at docks, leaked fuel into water or sat for years because no one could determine ownership or responsibility. In many cases, communities are left to manage the environmental and safety risks of these vessels without the resources or authority to act. \n\nFor small communities, whether coastal or lakefront, the cost is overwhelming. They are often forced to choose between letting a vessel sit and pollute or diverting scarce funds away from housing, infrastructure or essential services just to deal with a problem that should never have existed in the first place. \n\nAfter nearly a decade in government, the Liberal response has been more spending and more bureaucracy, with very little to show for it. An example can be seen through the oceans protection plan, where over $300 million has been allocated to deal with abandoned and derelict vessels. Since 2016, that spending has resulted in the removal of just 791 vessels. That is an average cost of more than $379,000 per vessel. \n\nMeanwhile, 1,355 derelict vessels remain on the Canadian Coast Guard's inventory list. At this pace, taxpayers could be forced to spend more than half a billion dollars just to clear the existing backlog. That is not value for money. It is not effective environmental policy, and it is certainly not responsible stewardship of public funds. \n\nThe problem is not a lack of legislation. The problem is a lack of enforcement, coordination and accountability. During testimony before the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans, witnesses, including government officials, made it is clear that federal departments are not working effectively together. Even basic functions, such as managing private buoy regulations, have fallen through the cracks after being transferred between departments. These bureaucratic breakdowns delay assessments, slow removals and leave communities waiting year after year for actions that never come. Municipalities want action, including municipalities in my riding that have been asking for this for years, while Ottawa continues to get in the way of being a partner. \n\nAnother major failure is the vessel registration system itself. Without reliable ownership records, enforcement is impossible. Vessels are sold, resold and resold again, often without ownership transfers being properly reported. When a vessel becomes abandoned or hazardous, officials cannot identify who is responsible and the polluter does not pay; the taxpayer does. The problem is that Bill C-244 attempts to address this issue but would not fix the root cause. \n\nClause 3 proposes to prohibit the transfer of ownership if the seller knows that the buyer is reckless or lacks the ability, resources or intent to maintain the vessel properly. That would be impossible to know.\n\n While the intention may be to prevent pollution, the language is vague and raises serious concerns. How is a seller expected to determine a buyer's intent or financial capability? Are sellers supposed to demand financial statements, conduct interviews or predict future behaviour? What happens in online auctions, which are increasingly common? What about cross-border sales? How long does the liability follow the seller after the sale has occurred?\n\n These unanswered questions create legal uncertainty and risk punishing Canadians who are acting in good faith. Instead of clarity, this amendment risks adding confusion, litigation and unintended consequences, especially when existing regulations are already not being enforced.\n\nUnfortunately, Canadians are now abandoning vessels simply because they cannot afford repairs, moorage or disposal. Even more troubling, many Canadians are being forced to live aboard old, unsafe boats because they have nowhere else to go. We see this constantly in Okanagan Lake and throughout the interior. Vessels are being used now as makeshift housing, but these are boats that were never designed to be lived in. Many lack proper sanitation or waste disposal, creating serious risks of pollution. Others pose fire hazards, safety risks and concerns related to criminal activity. \n\nA housing crisis has now spilled into our waterways, turning a social crisis into an environmental one. That is not compassionate policy. That is a result of years of federal mismanagement.\n\n Conservatives believe in caring for our waters and the people who depend on them. That means ensuring the polluter pays principle can actually be enforced. It means fixing the vessel registration system, so ownership is clear and accountability is real. It means coordinating across federal, provincial, municipal and first nations governments, instead of burying communities in red tape.\n\nI am looking forward to the amendments that will come forward concerning this bill, because the issue is extremely important. Conservatives are ready to work towards practical, accountable and results-driven solutions, ones that would truly protect our coasts, our lakes and our environment for generations to come.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288378","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-244, an act to amend the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999, and the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act. \n\nI want to thank sponsor of the bill for bringing forward an issue that coastal, river and lakeside communities across Canada have been raising for years. It is definitely on the right path. This is a huge problem throughout Canada","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","label":"Marine accidents","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b9ae709bfb1485af0ed4575a642d3faa5d3ba5814d89248b492c1c3d120fac97"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e9a0924be7f5f7a7ac7943714177721c81344b482c1d3395ec19199f2b2d2b5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b4f3e20152d0f174b57e698","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315066,"date":"2026-02-23T19:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, thousands of people in B.C. cannot see a family doctor, yet the Liberals now provide deluxe health care benefits to rejected asylum claimants at taxpayers' expense. The PBO has shown that the interim federal health program has skyrocketed in costs to almost $1 billion. \n\nWill the Liberals support our motion and ensure that rejected asylum claimants do not get better health care than Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315066","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, thousands of people in B.C. cannot see a family doctor, yet the Liberals now provide deluxe health care benefits to rejected asylum claimants at taxpayers' expense. The PBO has shown that the interim federal health program has skyrocketed in costs to almost $1 billion. \n\nWill the Liberals support our motion and ensure that rejected asylum claimants do not get better health care than C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d5b6d14c98655b1f479a7e9f4152a36153a4950a5dd8e35b78c2cb58e9a6c80f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["002f350a545369f2b41fcf8b5e79e71d5b8399345bbef53777ad026c8ee5f3a8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-252fe61df74296b75612a915","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315067,"date":"2026-02-23T19:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what the member did not mention is that Liberals at the health committee are currently filibustering any attempt to even study this program. That does not sound like they are trying to fix anything. They want a cover-up.\n\nConservatives are clear on the solution: no more physio or vision care for rejected asylum claimants. Will the Liberals support our motion and ensure that rejected asylum claimants do not get health care benefits that are superior to those of Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315067","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what the member did not mention is that Liberals at the health committee are currently filibustering any attempt to even study this program. That does not sound like they are trying to fix anything. They want a cover-up.\n\nConservatives are clear on the solution: no more physio or vision care for rejected asylum claimants. Will the Liberals support our motion and ensure that rejected a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["879fc05c70ac7a39036d077874d82d435f3492ab2f6e74704131461a9e006bcc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["676691d43478197c3667f401fd59b56f4d08a50e943511542fdc18855c10e724"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9562cd2ac777082cb7940bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306982,"date":"2026-02-24T18:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to our Conservative motion regarding serious inefficiencies in the federal health care and immigration systems.\n\n For those unaware, let us look at the cold, hard facts that were uncovered by the work of my colleagues and me at the parliamentary health committee last fall regarding the serious effects Canada's dysfunctional immigration system is having on our health care system, especially the effects of the interim federal health program.\n\n It is a fact that thousands of my constituents and hundreds of thousands of British Columbians have no family doctor. It is a fact that residents in my riding often discover their emergency rooms are suddenly closing for hours, if not whole days, because of a chronic shortage of health care workers. It happened just this past weekend in Princeton. It is a fact that residents in my riding must wait months, if not years, to see the specialists they need, sometimes driving on treacherous winter roads to reach them.\n\nIt is also a fact that if someone is, for example, a non-Canadian arrested in Surrey in connection with extortion, or in connection with arson in Ontario, a shooting in Edmonton, or auto theft in the Lower Mainland, they can immediately file a refugee claim for asylum and be granted access to the interim federal health program. For Conservatives, this is not hypothetical. It is a real case, in which these individuals made real claims. Even our premier, David Eby, thought it was outrageous. \n\nConservatives tried to amend Liberal legislation in the committee to fix this. Our amendments would have prevented non-citizens convicted of serious crimes from filing bogus asylum claims in an attempt to escape deportation. Still, the Liberals voted against this common-sense change to our laws.\n\nI know the Liberals will say we should let the process play out. However, even when clearly fraudulent claims filed by violent suspected criminals are rightly thrown out by our refugee board, these people still do not lose access to free specialty health programs. In contrast, they file an appeal, which may take years to be heard due to backlogs averaging up to four years.\n\n Even with a budget of nearly $350 million and 2,500 employees, the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada is growing its backlog year after year. The Parliamentary Budget Officer's report, using IRCC data, shows that this backlog will only grow for the rest of the decade. Even when these bogus refugee claimants are denied at every stage, and the fraudulent visitors lose all rights to remain in Canada and are told they must leave, until and if they are physically walked out of the country, they can still walk down the street and receive vision care or physiotherapy, things that the average Canadian does not have access to.\n\n Here is the worst thing about these departures. The IRCC cannot even tell parliamentarians how many are actually departing. I guess it expects these fraudulent cases to walk out the door on their own and leave behind free health care. That is the interim federal health program as it exists today, as the Parliamentary Budget Officer confirmed when his office appeared before the health committee just a couple of weeks ago. Canadians have increasingly lost confidence in the immigration and refugee system under the Liberal government, and it is easy to see why.\n\n No governing party in this House has ever opposed the admission of real refugees from Syria, Ukraine or Afghanistan. No governing party has ever opposed the interim federal health program. Canada is a generous nation to those who need our generosity. If someone comes to Canada blinded by acid, without a limb, from a war-torn country, no one is advocating leaving them in the street instead of ensuring they have rehabilitative care.\n\nWhat Canadians have come to oppose is the bent shape that our refugee system exists in today. A complete failure by the Liberal government to properly manage the admission of temporary foreign workers and international students into non-essential jobs and fake universities has led to this crisis. \n\nGuests to our country quickly realize they can create nearly endless extensions, with access to special medical care that they do not have in their own home countries, by filing asylum claims that everyone knows do not meet any standard of refugee. I do not blame these people for doing this. It is the government's fault for allowing the loophole to exist in the—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306982","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to our Conservative motion regarding serious inefficiencies in the federal health care and immigration systems.\n\n For those unaware, let us look at the cold, hard facts that were uncovered by the work of my colleagues and me at the parliamentary health committee last fall regarding the serious effects Canada's dysfunctional immigration system is having on our hea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72c75b4d0867194ec83fa583c6ea891af25aa9112c75d7a440d27c8345bb3003"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["087954f368bfaf81db996b1fd96b55e45816ef38fbb300d3807658c0a4820314"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5a2f75ba3bdf8f4b8b7fdcc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306983,"date":"2026-02-24T20:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, rejected asylum seekers quickly realize they can create near-endless extensions for years with access to specialty medical care they do not have in their home countries. It swiftly adds to the backlog, which in turn adds to the cost. By the end of this fiscal year, the annual cost will be $986 million. By the end of this decade, the annual cost will be $1.5 billion. Those are not my figures; they are the Parliamentary Budget Officer's figures. Anyone who doubts these can ask him in person. \n\nHis report also shows that in the early days of the Trudeau government, the number of interim federal health program beneficiaries was around 100,000 and was split evenly between asylum claims and refugee cases. Today, it stands at around 600,000 beneficiaries, more than two-thirds of whom are asylum claimants, with a much smaller number than before being refugees. It is important to note that when these are refugee cases, approval does not mean staying on this program indefinitely but seeing only to some temporary medical issues. At the same time, they are transferred into provincial health programs so they can then potentially work and pay back into our system. Asylum claimants remain on the program entirely through the long and winding Liberal backlog.\n\nAnother reason this federal program has increased in cost from the tens of millions to the soon-to-be billions is the recurring issue we heard about at the committee from witnesses of specialist doctors who are providing these services overcharging the immigration department due to a lack of oversight of billing. According to Dr. Arun Anand, physicians who provide services to claimants are charging the federal government more. He said, \"because it is uninsured and there's less accountability, physicians are more aggressive with their billing practices. They charge premiums on these programs and services\" and \"because services are not covered by provincial plans, physicians can bill up to five times more for their physician fees in these programs\".\n\nI know what the members opposite will tell me. First, it is that I oppose assisting people in need, and that is completely false. I want our nation to be the welcoming nation it has always been, one that welcomes someone like me and the many of us in this room who came from all across the world. What I oppose is people who file false asylum claims being rewarded with specialty health care, benefits like physiotherapy, which too many Canadians cannot access. I am not opposed to someone being saved in an ER. I am opposed to them getting free eyeglasses after they commit extortion.\n\nIf the members opposite would like the policies they say will fix this mess to be studied thoroughly by our Parliamentary Budget Officer, might I suggest they join me at the health committee when I am done here this afternoon to tell their own Liberal colleagues to end the filibustering they have been up to for the last couple of weeks so that we can look into this, find out the truth and make our health system and our immigration system better.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306983","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, rejected asylum seekers quickly realize they can create near-endless extensions for years with access to specialty medical care they do not have in their home countries. It swiftly adds to the backlog, which in turn adds to the cost. By the end of this fiscal year, the annual cost will be $986 million. By the end of this decade, the annual cost will be $1.5 billion. Those are not my f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c6707ad66d0aec8219df7e3376d098cfaa08349884adce36580046c6b1f6f345"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f287b38ea5d113b6d15798d871ae10246c599839eefaf032387d94e68a2863fe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7ea68b3c69f273d81ebaac9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306984,"date":"2026-02-24T21:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am not sure the member was listening. I know that only half of my speech occurred while he was sitting here, but we are talking about rejected asylum seekers, some of them criminals. I think the worst thing is that the government has no idea actually how many there are. If he wants to learn more about this, he can go to the health committee meeting that is happening right now, or he can also look at the PBO report that states that this is going to cost us billions if it continues as it is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306984","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am not sure the member was listening. I know that only half of my speech occurred while he was sitting here, but we are talking about rejected asylum seekers, some of them criminals. I think the worst thing is that the government has no idea actually how many there are. If he wants to learn more about this, he can go to the health committee meeting that is happening right now, or he","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b944ab19a442bcdf9007f76f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306985,"date":"2026-02-24T21:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what I resent is members from the Liberal Party downplaying an issue that is very important for every Canadian. Six million Canadians are without doctors. As for my own riding, I could actually, probably, google my riding right now, because there might be another hospital closed suddenly. It happens on a regular basis. Princeton was just closed a couple of days ago. How would anyone like it if they drove up to a hospital with their child, who might have just broken their arm, and found out that the hospital is closed suddenly because of the lack of doctors and that they have to drive their child an hour and a half to the nearest hospital?\n\nWe need to correct this and that is what furthering this report and supporting the motion will do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306985","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what I resent is members from the Liberal Party downplaying an issue that is very important for every Canadian. Six million Canadians are without doctors. As for my own riding, I could actually, probably, google my riding right now, because there might be another hospital closed suddenly. It happens on a regular basis. Princeton was just closed a couple of days ago. How would anyone l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f8c484399b5914918adde4c327b0e8ac27d6acd164bafa53b42d637949002eb6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["347c8b3ded9c8b42e480e48b19152727e7bdcefa41d8b20d2b354ac8568762fa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-428c8c48666ddefcbaacf93b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306986,"date":"2026-02-24T21:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is a problem across the entire country. This is not focused just on one province. I know that thousands of people in my riding do not have a doctor, and we have this gateway system for health. These issues need to be addressed. As for those rejected asylum seekers and criminals who are avoiding being sent back to their country, and some of them are criminals, this should be addressed so that money is spent on Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306986","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is a problem across the entire country. This is not focused just on one province. I know that thousands of people in my riding do not have a doctor, and we have this gateway system for health. These issues need to be addressed. As for those rejected asylum seekers and criminals who are avoiding being sent back to their country, and some of them are criminals, this should be addre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd8f3543e3ffc28801b639659b6d98efb4174d0e8e1e060c0b89d72151777867"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6da087c1e480c545efb9640fc76291374e647083fcf20fdcb8c9d58835383660"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9b4dee64f6ce5bcbbee3259","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306981,"date":"2026-02-25T22:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is definitely a lack of confidence in the Liberal government. I wonder if the member could tell us again why he does not trust the government to follow through on its promises, in particular, the high-speed rail project.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306981","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is definitely a lack of confidence in the Liberal government. I wonder if the member could tell us again why he does not trust the government to follow through on its promises, in particular, the high-speed rail project.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8833c3996c5cb859ebfd641","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306979,"date":"2026-02-26T22:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after a decade of Liberal promises, housing prices have doubled, down payments have doubled, and now CMHC is projecting that housing starts will decline through 2026, 2027 and 2028. CMHC says we need nearly 500,000 homes per year to end the housing crisis. Instead we are headed toward fewer than half that. The government says 800,000 homes may be permitted over a decade. That is not a housing plan. That is a housing backslide.\n\nThe Parliamentary Budget Officer says the new Build Canada Homes program will build just 5,000 homes per year. That is just 1% of what the Liberals promised Canadians. Private homebuilding itself is slowing as well. New home sales are down 45% in our major cities, the lowest level in 45 years. They are down 56% in Vancouver. Permit applications are down 26% compared to last spring. Why is that?\n\nGovernment-imposed costs now account for 30% to 50% of the price of a new home. Development charges have exploded. When it costs more to get permission to build than it does to build, we do not have a market failure; we have a government failure. The Liberals will stand up and list the billions of dollars they have spent. The Liberal government has indeed created the most expensive housing program in history, but if those billions of dollars in announcements actually built homes, Canada would not be in a housing crisis.\n\nThe housing accelerator fund was supposed to remove gatekeepers. Instead, cities are raising development fees after receiving federal money, while communities like mine have submitted numerous applications for the accelerator fund and have had all their proposals rejected.\n\nThe Liberal government's housing failures are increasingly evident. Many Liberals stood on a promise in 2021 to end chronic homelessness by 2030. Can we find a single Liberal who thinks that they will keep that promise? It will not happen, when the PBO is reporting that the number of chronic homeless people has increased 38% and unsheltered homelessness increased by 300% between 2018 and 2024.\n\nResidents in communities in my region do not need Ottawa to tell them this, though. Penticton and the regional district are buckling under the strain of homeless encampments and people living in their vehicles on forestry roads. I recently spoke with a senior in Castlegar, living across the street from a growing encampment that did not exist just a couple of years ago. Not surprisingly, she feels increasingly unsafe in her own neighbourhood amid rising crime and reports of fires.\n\nLocal services are overwhelmed, and the problem of homelessness is only increasing. That is why Conservatives are calling on the Liberals to stop making promises they cannot keep and start building homes. We asked them to cut the GST on all new homes under $1.3 million to save families up to $65,000 and make projects viable again, to tie federal infrastructure dollars to municipal results and reward communities that are building more, and to end capital gains tax on reinvestment in housing to unlock private capital.\n\nThe Liberals say their plan is working, so why are housing starts falling, sales collapsing, and young Canadians giving up on home ownership? Why are people living in tents?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306979","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after a decade of Liberal promises, housing prices have doubled, down payments have doubled, and now CMHC is projecting that housing starts will decline through 2026, 2027 and 2028. CMHC says we need nearly 500,000 homes per year to end the housing crisis. Instead we are headed toward fewer than half that. The government says 800,000 homes may be permitted over a decade. That is not a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0cf9d385d90e472442d4c6f0e08f7558fc5da9b1cecd869e30dfdeba3b310b64"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["342d4ad83f39b00757e99414c583c687e95add53c5736e493539f9755b976e40"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9dce5792bced5ea836e35f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306980,"date":"2026-02-26T22:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals promised to build at speeds not seen since the Second World War, when returning veterans were in desperate need of housing to start young families. Back then, we provided it in mere months. The Liberals today are proud of the billions they are spending, but the fact is, more young Canadians than ever are delaying, if not abandoning, important life goals like home ownership and starting a family. Too many end up homeless as a result. \n\nAn average home in Canada costs roughly $700,000. Down payments have doubled. Housing starts are falling. Builders are not building. Tent communities are a common sight. After 10 years and billions of dollars, where are the homes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306980","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals promised to build at speeds not seen since the Second World War, when returning veterans were in desperate need of housing to start young families. Back then, we provided it in mere months. The Liberals today are proud of the billions they are spending, but the fact is, more young Canadians than ever are delaying, if not abandoning, important life goals like home ownershi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d82e2ec5161af32f90b3870a23d70354d881627e7d740d4d27b4fa8c54ead23e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["417ffc8db547dc71df48ce187c15a21c795aa0337a73d4fc3451345e5b64f425"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9e1ccaa98fd1ea3af148ecd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306978,"date":"2026-02-27T16:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when are the Liberals going to realize these programs are not working?\n\n I was recently approached by a young mom who told me how hard it has become to feed her children. It was heart-wrenching. I see her face now when I hear that child poverty rose for a third straight year in Canada. Nearly 30,000 more children have fallen below the poverty line.\n\nWhen will the Liberal government end the trend of child poverty getting worse every year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306978","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when are the Liberals going to realize these programs are not working?\n\n I was recently approached by a young mom who told me how hard it has become to feed her children. It was heart-wrenching. I see her face now when I hear that child poverty rose for a third straight year in Canada. Nearly 30,000 more children have fallen below the poverty line.\n\nWhen will the Liberal government en","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Infant nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035871","label":"Infant nutrition","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c9ad667e89340192c8b1b89d503cdf4b6d90bbfee37c86e66018920dae56284a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["869c109ab11e8b4fe206a4a0dac90b99beb3186d446bbb66263c66a7f456ee5e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86d5c5547917172c45c6f567","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340112,"date":"2026-03-11T21:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for his really informative speech. I think we all agree we need to diversify our markets.\n\nWhy does my colleague think Canadians are having trouble believing what the government says it is going to do and are questioning whether any of this is actually going to happen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340112","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for his really informative speech. I think we all agree we need to diversify our markets.\n\nWhy does my colleague think Canadians are having trouble believing what the government says it is going to do and are questioning whether any of this is actually going to happen?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["329a57685daa9df5f03b24d5cc9000ba9db75bee0897548c0e0b7e3bfd3b4428"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5de6bb2d5fe04d76a1bcb453","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340108,"date":"2026-03-12T17:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to the legislation before us: Bill C-13, an act to implement the protocol on the accession of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland to the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership. That is a long name, but the acronym is the CPTPP.\n\nBefore I begin my speech, I want to make a small acknowledgement of a big win in my community. The Keremeos' Similkameen Sparks basketball team proved themselves to be the B.C. champions last weekend, among all schools province-wide. Our whole community is very proud of these amazing young athletes.\n\nSome hon. members: Hear, hear!\n\nHelena Konanz: Bill C-13 comes before the House at a time of concern about global tensions in our trading relationships. Let us be clear that Canada is and always will remain a great trading nation. Trade is the foundation of every strong economy in history, and trade with the United Kingdom is a long and deep part of Canadian history.\n\nThe Leader of the Opposition spoke about this just recently when speaking to British audiences about the potential to strengthen our relationship as allies. That does not mean that we, as a nation, should ever roll over for any agreement. Ultimately, we want to ensure that free trade is reciprocal. That is to say that it is fair. If we are going to give access to Canadian markets, then we need to see access to the other nation's markets in return.\n\nFree trade and fair trade are not in conflict. They are in partnership, or they should be. Bill C-13 should have been a moment for Canada to show strength and strategic thinking on the world stage amid turmoil. Instead, it is another example of a government that consistently leaves Canadians with less than they deserve. \n\nLet us be clear: The United Kingdom joining the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership is not the issue. The problem is how little the government managed to secure for Canadians during those negotiations. When a country like the United Kingdom wants to join a major trade pact with Canada, that is leverage. That is leverage to get more of our products to market and to bring more products that we cannot produce in Canada to Canadians. This point of negotiation is when responsible governments push hard for their own workers, exporters and seniors. However, once again, the Liberals have negotiated a win for someone on the other side of the table when there was much room to secure one for us.\n\nFor the last decade, the government has acted as though it is unbothered by the severe trade imbalances with the U.K. British beef enters Canada duty-free and without limits. According to the Library of Parliament, Britain exported 28.3 million dollars' worth of beef and 3.6 million dollars' worth of pork to Canada in the first half of 2025 alone. Meanwhile, Canada's beef and pork are forced into tight quotas and face trade barriers. Canada exported only 122,000 dollars' worth of pork and no beef in 2025.\n\nThe U.K. still refuses to accept Canada's meat hygiene system, even though it is internationally recognized and it has provided no scientific evidence against it. This was a perfect moment to fix that. The U.K. wanted CPTPP membership. Canada could have insisted on fair treatment for our beef and pork exporters. Instead, nothing changed. The same barriers remain. The same inequities remain. Why did the government not secure real improvements for Canadian producers? It had the leverage, it had the time and it had the opportunity. What the government did not have was the political will to fight for all Canadian interests. \n\nI would also like to mention the thousands of U.K. pensioners living in Canada, including many in British Columbia, whose pensions remain frozen with no cost-of-living increases, no indexing and no adjustments whatsoever.\n\nThese are not all permanent residents. Many became the best thing a person can be: They became Canadian. Still, these seniors paid into the system. They worked in the U.K. They built lives in British Columbia and across Canada, yet they are treated unfairly compared to pensioners who seek benefits from other countries. This, too, could have been addressed at the table while the U.K. sought to join the CPTPP. Instead, there was silence, another missed opportunity. Given the Prime Minister's frequent boasting of a close relationship with the U.K. Prime Minister and with the United Kingdom as a whole, one would think that he would have talked about this. \n\nThe Liberal government might have used this opportunity to advocate on behalf of our agricultural producers or the 100,000 U.K. pensioners during this cost of living and inflation crisis. This is a negotiating pattern with the government. The Liberals have a talent for walking into major trade discussions and walking out empty-handed. Whether it is softwood lumber, steel or aluminum, the result is always the same. Canada gives but gets very little back.\n\nSoftwood lumber is key in my riding, as many members know. Hundreds of jobs have already been lost in my riding during these tumultuous times. This is the opposite of negotiation. We are supposed to give something to get something. Families who rely on lumber jobs in my region have now seen an entire year of the Liberal Prime Minister's travels. He has travelled frequently to the United States and around the globe, promising deals but still not delivering for lumber.\n\nTime is not on our side in the lumber sector. At a time of unrelenting attacks from the Trump administration on our softwood lumber industry through unjustified tariffs, sawmills are closing and communities are losing hope. The Liberal government offers a minuscule increase in domestic production and offers loans that will only be added to increasingly indebted lumber mills, which is why many are choosing to close instead. European lumber suppliers are trying to fill the gap in the U.S. market left by these tariffs. Potential Asian markets cannot cover this hole in the balance sheet for Canadian suppliers. A U.K. market would not fill this either.\n\nCanada's lumber industry has the supply, talent and drive to thrive for decades, but only if these communities can stay together. I implore the Prime Minister and his government to work with forest communities, and with the MPs who represent them across all parties, to make an all-hands-on-deck effort in Washington, D.C., to end the decade-long absence of a softwood lumber agreement that has now lasted four separate presidential administrations, all on the Liberals' watch. We know this is possible. The Harper government secured a deal in only a few weeks. Families in my riding, in the Similkameen, Boundary and the Kootenays, cannot wait any longer.\n\n Is what the House is looking for in any trade agreement not ultimately Canadian-specific gains? Where is the progress on the issues that matter to our exporters? Where is evidence that the government used this moment to deliver wins for Canadians?\n\nThis could have been the moment the government stood firmly for Canadian farmers and demanded the U.K. finally dismantle the non-tariff SPS barriers that block our products. It could have been the moment it stood up for seniors whose pensions have been frozen for decades. It could have been the moment Canada reminded the world that our market access is valuable and not something that is handed out for free.\n\nInstead, we are left with a bill that updates legislation, cleans up tariff schedules and confirms access the U.K. would have received anyway, all without resolving the issues that matter most. It is very disappointing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340108","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to the legislation before us: Bill C-13, an act to implement the protocol on the accession of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland to the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership. That is a long name, but the acronym is the CPTPP.\n\nBefore I begin my speech, I want to make a small acknowledgement of a big win in my ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c438adb94ca1b8449feafb55254a269adea72aef990beaeb18b71d28666918f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7813eb25b5f9ec9e0bb992c18c8642cefa5d5219ca83dfcb5b65808dc0e5ebaa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c2ec6af2385a957314141378","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340109,"date":"2026-03-12T18:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, yes, of course we need to continue creating further trade partners, and that is a good thing.\n\nWhat I mentioned in my speech was that there were things we could have brought to the table that were not brought, which is going to affect many people across this country, including in my riding. One that I spoke about was the softwood lumber and lumber industry. Another was the beef industry, the cattle industry, which affects my riding. What I think we are trying to say is that this could have been a moment in time when we could have really strengthened our trade negotiations, but unfortunately, that did not happen.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340109","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, yes, of course we need to continue creating further trade partners, and that is a good thing.\n\nWhat I mentioned in my speech was that there were things we could have brought to the table that were not brought, which is going to affect many people across this country, including in my riding. One that I spoke about was the softwood lumber and lumber industry. Another was the beef indust","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4fc751446f30b93e40271e2fe7acad26023fed9f0c3f35ecc4d72d7be83257ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["40682e32c92f8c6625f51274b009a7b156b172d4f90c9d9476029f491dcceb25"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e816f1ccbad87a0aeb6a1e18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340110,"date":"2026-03-12T18:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my colleague's very detailed question and explanation of the situation we are in right now across the country.\n\nIt seems as if, with all the travels around the world, the Prime Minister has forgotten that there are whole towns all across this country that are shutting their doors. That is what happens in the lumber and forestry industry because the industry encompasses the entire town. We are not talking about one or two retail stores closing. We are talking about small towns across this country. That needs to be remembered, and we need to have sympathy for these towns, which have survived, many of them, for 100 years or more.\n\nWhen we are at the negotiating table with any new partner, I ask the government to please bring up softwood lumber.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340110","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my colleague's very detailed question and explanation of the situation we are in right now across the country.\n\nIt seems as if, with all the travels around the world, the Prime Minister has forgotten that there are whole towns all across this country that are shutting their doors. That is what happens in the lumber and forestry industry because the industry encompasses th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d325ce55d1e272b411efe7de1587da832a1e7719dc8ebc04596737ec03be3c28"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["34b3e75d8650b8349d9f8cca9e22004f6a38b42e33ea26db89231ba52a7fed90"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-186bf6944d567adf4e488cdb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340111,"date":"2026-03-12T18:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we should be negotiating with countries around the world that have the same moral compass as Canada.\n\nI will give the example of my riding. Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay has one of the longest borders with the United States in the country. I think the member is asking if we should be looking elsewhere. We should, but at the same time, we need to keep this relationship with the United States. Ridings like mine, where we have six border crossings, depend on trade with the United States, so we need to keep our trade and we need to keep negotiating with Washington, D.C. during these turbulent times.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340111","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we should be negotiating with countries around the world that have the same moral compass as Canada.\n\nI will give the example of my riding. Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay has one of the longest borders with the United States in the country. I think the member is asking if we should be looking elsewhere. We should, but at the same time, we need to keep this relationship with ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e79f0866824ed257e284ad36bfd9c837377fc1c09335dabc34b0ba370d09dc43"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["823ce3d9471c0ac8609726f806572aec516892331ad387bfb6478090b7f79e8d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a89cb286db89a97a6609803","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":340107,"date":"2026-03-13T17:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, yesterday in a discussion about unsafe injection sites, I asked the Liberal Minister of Health the easiest possible question: Is injecting fentanyl safe? Instead of giving a straight answer, the minister laughed and said that research shows continuing to inject fentanyl saves lives. Extending addiction does not save lives.\n\n I will ask it again: Does the minister believe injecting illegal fentanyl is safe?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:340107","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, yesterday in a discussion about unsafe injection sites, I asked the Liberal Minister of Health the easiest possible question: Is injecting fentanyl safe? Instead of giving a straight answer, the minister laughed and said that research shows continuing to inject fentanyl saves lives. Extending addiction does not save lives.\n\n I will ask it again: Does the minister believe injecting ill","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d739d1ff400ce473a5bbb42fd74a219503b024d06558efd49e08881c95b33f34"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a26576b16c90de0298eb7d9f3b57c683eb407ec257fbe3f4e62806daff9d033b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-516257a5fd16eac14f26ffd7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386495,"date":"2026-03-23T22:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to speak to Bill C-9, a piece of legislation that has brought forward huge concerns for Canadians of every religious background across the country. \n\nCanadians I speak with in my community are not asking for more censorship. They are asking for safer streets, stronger communities and a government that focuses on real problems. Instead of focusing on these concerns, the Liberal government has chosen to prioritize Bill C-9, a bill that targets some of the most fundamental charter freedoms we have as Canadians: freedom of speech and the freedom to practise our faith. That choice matters because it tells Canadians what the government values and what it is willing to put aside. \n\nLet us take a step back and clearly understand what this bill would actually do. Under the current Criminal Code, there is a narrow and carefully constructed safeguard. Section 319 allows individuals to express, in good faith, opinions on religious subjects or based on a belief in religious texts. It is for all persons of faith, be they Christian, Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist or Sikh. This safeguard is not broad. It is not a loophole and it is not a free pass. It applies only to one specific offence. It does not apply to violence. It does not apply to threats or incitement. These actions are already illegal, and they should be. There is no charter right to hate or to act hatefully. \n\nEven the Supreme Court has recognized that this safeguard is necessary to maintain the constitutionality of Canada's hate speech laws. It exists to ensure that we strike the right balance between protecting people from harm and preserving the freedoms that define us as a democratic society. \n\nBill C-9 would remove that safeguard. That is where the problem begins, because when that protection is removed, uncertainty is introduced into the law. A situation is created where Canadians could face criminal consequences for expressing sincerely held beliefs grounded in their faith, not because they are promoting violence or because they are attacking an individual, but because those beliefs may be interpreted by the state as crossing a line that this Parliament is choosing to make unclear. That should concern every Canadian, regardless of what they believe or if they do not believe in any religion at all. It is about whether the government should have the authority to decide which beliefs are acceptable and which are not. \n\nWe often hear the Liberals point to extreme examples to justify this bill. They talk about hate. They talk about violence. They talk about incitement. However, what they do not say is that all of those things are already illegal. There is no protection in Canadian law for violence. There is no protection for incitement. \n\nExperts who testified before the committee confirmed this. Legal experts, witnesses and practitioners all made it clear that the current law for hate crimes already addresses the scenarios the government keeps raising. When these examples are used to justify this bill, they are not identifying a gap. They are describing conduct that is already criminal. If those laws are not being enforced, then the issue is not the law but enforcement. \n\nHowever, instead of addressing enforcement, the government is choosing to expand its power over speech. That is a very different conversation, because now we are no longer talking about protecting Canadians from harm. We are talking about regulating what Canadians can say and what they can believe. We are not talking about extremists hiding behind religion to justify harm. This is already illegal, and there are no protections for that under current law. \n\nWe are talking about ordinary Canadians: pastors delivering sermons, rabbis teaching scripture, imams guiding their communities, parents teaching their children values rooted in their faith and traditions, and educators discussing religious texts in classrooms. They are the ones who would feel the impact of this change, not the people who seek to sow hate.\n\nI have heard these concerns directly from members of my community. Earlier this year, I met with more than 30 local faith leaders, alongside my colleague from Elgin—St. Thomas—London South. He is a member of the justice committee and has studied this bill extensively. No one in that meeting was seeking to promote hate. They only brought forward concerns that this bill creates uncertainty around what they are allowed to say, teach and share with their own religious communities.\n\nThey wanted me to tell this story to all the MPs in Parliament because they are scared that quoting a religious text could be legally misinterpreted. They are worried that the law is moving in a direction so that they can no longer speak freely without fear of consequences. When we hear that directly from people affected, it becomes very clear that this bill is not as straightforward as the Liberal government claims.\n\nThat concern has also been echoed by organizations across the country. There are not many pieces of legislation that would unite the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops, the Canadian Muslim Public Affairs Council, the World Sikh Organization of Canada, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, the Canadian Labour Congress, the Centre for Free Expression, and Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East. From left and right, these organizations agree that we should not proceed with Bill C-9 in its current form.\n\nIn a free society, people should not have to second-guess whether expressing their beliefs would lead to legal consequences. They should not have to weigh their words against the risk of prosecution simply for speaking openly about their faith. This is Canada. Even if prosecutions are rare, the fear alone changes behaviours. It silences people. It discourages open discussion. It weakens the very foundation of a pluralistic society, and that is not something we should take lightly.\n\nAgain, we have to ask what problem this bill would solve. It certainly is not addressing a gap in the law. Instead, it is removing a protection. At the same time, the government is choosing not to focus on the issues Canadians are actually worried about.\n\nAcross the country, communities are dealing with the consequences of a broken bail system. Police chiefs have raised concerns. Provinces have raised concerns. Municipalities have raised concerns. Canadians have raised concerns. They are seeing repeat offenders released out onto the streets, sometimes within hours, only to reoffend. That is the reality. That is what people are living with. Instead of prioritizing meaningful reform to address this problem, the government is focused on regulating what Canadians can say and what they can believe.\n\nThis bill would not make Canadians safer from acts of hate. The bill would shift attention away from the real public safety issues and toward the regulation of speech. Freedom of expression and freedom of religion are not optional in a free society. They are foundational. They protect the ability to disagree. They protect the ability to question. They protect the ability to hold beliefs that may not always be popular. Once the state begins to decide which beliefs are acceptable, those freedoms become conditional. They become dependent on the approval of those in power. That is not what Canadians expect, and that is not the direction we should be heading.\n\nI will leave my Liberal colleagues with this: If the law already makes violence illegal, if the law already prohibits incitement and calls for genocide, and if experts have confirmed there is no gap that requires this change, then why is the government so determined to remove a safeguard that protects peaceful, good-faith religious expression? More importantly, why is the government choosing to focus on regulating belief instead of fixing the real problems that Canadians are facing in their communities every single day?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386495","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to speak to Bill C-9, a piece of legislation that has brought forward huge concerns for Canadians of every religious background across the country. \n\nCanadians I speak with in my community are not asking for more censorship. They are asking for safer streets, stronger communities and a government that focuses on real problems. Instead of focusing on these concerns, the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ef59ca14921df57cfd3b295c6523cf69302e453317f2fb3b86ef72397ec6e1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0d66fa72a2f9e954130e3473145cc6ddc99c639d34a95eb137f73b6c8628ecfa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f7a4fc82a8945fe48736c73","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386496,"date":"2026-03-23T22:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think this is the question running through the mind of just about every MP of the House, on both sides of the aisle, I am sure, because this is attacking religion, freedom of speech and democracy. Right now, people in our communities are afraid to walk down the street. They are afraid to go shopping. There are elderly people afraid of break-ins at their home. That is what we should be focusing on.\n\nWhy is the government ramming this through? There is no clear explanation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386496","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think this is the question running through the mind of just about every MP of the House, on both sides of the aisle, I am sure, because this is attacking religion, freedom of speech and democracy. Right now, people in our communities are afraid to walk down the street. They are afraid to go shopping. There are elderly people afraid of break-ins at their home. That is what we should ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93e9fb54e55a37a7989dc932f8e5409e2281402bc1df634e36feb5e86d71344f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89136f4b5090b51ce7a16f38","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386497,"date":"2026-03-23T22:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Again, Mr. Speaker, I think this is a question running through everyone's mind.\n\nI wonder what the members on the other side of the aisle are thinking. They must be getting the phone calls I am getting. They must be getting the emails, the written letters and the calls from their local faith leaders who are completely against this because, as I mentioned earlier, they are afraid of what they might say in their next sermon or what they might write in the next column for the newspaper. Parents are afraid of what they might discuss with their children.\n\nIt is baffling why the Liberals would be pushing this through so quickly, and it is actually shameful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386497","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Again, Mr. Speaker, I think this is a question running through everyone's mind.\n\nI wonder what the members on the other side of the aisle are thinking. They must be getting the phone calls I am getting. They must be getting the emails, the written letters and the calls from their local faith leaders who are completely against this because, as I mentioned earlier, they are afraid of what they might","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d3b054e6bed5da032ac8ff192ff1095ffd977b9a168aed61c32fb3190c622a5c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d204fb7ef7e3e8750c6a2d04","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386498,"date":"2026-03-23T22:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member across the aisle for the question he has asked many times today.\n\nI would like to ask the member why the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops, the Canadian Muslim Public Affairs Council, the World Sikh Organization of Canada, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, the Canadian Labour Congress, the Centre for Free Expression and Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East are against this. Many of the member's constituents are against this, I am sure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386498","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member across the aisle for the question he has asked many times today.\n\nI would like to ask the member why the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops, the Canadian Muslim Public Affairs Council, the World Sikh Organization of Canada, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, the Canadian Labour Congress, the Centre for Free Expression and Canadians for Justice and Peace ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b512100df85ef03bd9be80147ba218717782144e13040bfa136a2d8f642622f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-447dfe037a752a179baddfe3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386409,"date":"2026-03-26T16:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling three petitions today on behalf of constituents from Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay.\n\nThe first petition has 1,600 signatures. Residents are asking for the federal government to partner with the province and provide funding for a secondary route from South Okanagan to Kelowna as an alternate to Highway 97. Highway 97 is the only major route between Penticton and Kelowna and has had repeated closures due to landslides, rock falls, accidents, fires and floods, which have caused serious safety risks for residents and visitors who have no alternative route to take to the hospital, schools and jobs. The federal government previously provided funding in partnership with the province to enhance safety trade routes, and the residents are asking for them to build this secondary route.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386409","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling three petitions today on behalf of constituents from Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay.\n\nThe first petition has 1,600 signatures. Residents are asking for the federal government to partner with the province and provide funding for a secondary route from South Okanagan to Kelowna as an alternate to Highway 97. Highway 97 is the only major route between Penticton and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e2cfe0366f3d7126dcfb01e551c1b8bf4a043617587f81598057748b2123cc53"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["012716135622532a9d443240c2f4a05c73b04a1398b987ef81d04ee325fa55f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5aae4aa839a0c7786f8e9ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386491,"date":"2026-03-26T16:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition is on behalf of the residents of Sage Mesa, in my riding in Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, and other communities across my riding and across Canada, who have been on boil water rationing and boil water regulations for many, many years.\n\nAccess to safe, affordable and clean drinking water should not continue to be an issue in Canada. Therefore, they are asking for immediate partnerships with the provincial and territorial governments to bring an end to boil water advisories across Canada for the delivery of clean drinking water.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386491","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition is on behalf of the residents of Sage Mesa, in my riding in Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, and other communities across my riding and across Canada, who have been on boil water rationing and boil water regulations for many, many years.\n\nAccess to safe, affordable and clean drinking water should not continue to be an issue in Canada. Therefore, they are a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d657e89220ec468f8ea671e42c10866347c48d53079217915bc4e7161f4afd20"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b26624937e385eb0ac38a26808c7170e3d5dbf8c6c24875dcbf33e0862c57544"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99cf3d8df88d87fc61c83a46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386492,"date":"2026-03-26T16:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, finally, I am presenting a petition in which my constituents express a deep concern about the proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreation fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia. Constituents are calling upon the ministry of fisheries and oceans to leave the current salmon allocation policy alone and uphold the cultural rights and traditions of all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386492","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, finally, I am presenting a petition in which my constituents express a deep concern about the proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreation fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia. Constituents are calling upon the ministry of fisheries and oceans to leave the current salmon allocation policy alone and uphold the cultura","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["86d6692bd2fc0837d1e7b80b607582e8568f821d22ee6a23a0c10197f1c650b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76fc548198317804f2dfcbbf7d983ff1d623f7241f912bc9a8718f4e2b033f12"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25e323b73326ad2752492dc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386493,"date":"2026-03-26T21:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise to seek answers on the government's natural resources policies. \n\nResidents in my community are watching the war in Iran and the closing of the Strait of Hormuz, which are blamed for the spike in prices at the pump. Just this week, my daughter shared with me that gas prices for her in Vancouver had reached over two dollars per litre. It is not just the Lower Mainland. The average cost of regular gas across Canada reached $1.73 per litre on Tuesday. \n\nThis is not the fault of the Liberal government, but what is its responsibility is the decade-long failure to provide consistent continental access to our Canadian alternative to a global market, while raising our gas prices at home through the fuel standard tax. Let us not forget, it is official government policy to increase fuel costs by 13¢ per litre for gasoline and 16¢ per litre for diesel by 2030. No nation with such abundant resources should have to pay so much more for it.\n\nMeanwhile, allies seeking Canadian energy have been poorly served by the Liberal government. Big promises now do not disguise its past failure to deliver. Promises to build a pipeline to Pacific tidewater in the future, which is already delayed, may I add, do not disguise the loss of Coastal Gateway, which would have been completed by now had it not been killed on the Liberals' watch. \n\nStrong words of support from Quebec Liberal MPs for our energy products today do not disguise the fact that they were the same ones cheering the death of energy east. If the Liberals opposite would like to champion the expansion of Trans Mountain, let it not be forgotten that it was a private project that became so entangled in Liberal regulations they had to buy it and build it with public tax dollars at a significant cost overrun. I voted for the Liberals' major projects bills to see energy projects built faster, but after the Prime Minister's first year in office, they have not approved a single project.\n\nOne of Canada's largest oil producers, Canadian Natural Resources Limited, recently announced that it is halting expansion plans in Canada. The company cited the industrial carbon tax and federal regulatory barriers as creating an economic burden for a long-term growth investment in energy products. At a time of rising gas prices at home and around the world, we cannot let Canadian energy be left on the shelf. Canadians need relief at the pump, and the world needs Canada. They are banging at our door for our energy.\n\nThis is why Conservatives call for the immediate introduction and passage of an emergency energy supply plan to accelerate approval of LNG sites through the major project powers and guarantee a maximum six-month approval time for major energy infrastructure projects. We have no time to waste. Middle East energy powers are saying a continued closure of the Strait of Hormuz could see oil prices surging to $150 a barrel and gas prices four times what they were before the conflict.\n\nWill the government bring forward and approve our plan to lower costs for Canadians and build energy infrastructure faster?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386493","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise to seek answers on the government's natural resources policies. \n\nResidents in my community are watching the war in Iran and the closing of the Strait of Hormuz, which are blamed for the spike in prices at the pump. Just this week, my daughter shared with me that gas prices for her in Vancouver had reached over two dollars per litre. It is not just the Lower Mainland. The ave","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ae47db36c4ea130519972393f802492ea23252de0cfaabd1527401af0b687598"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6db4fd0b52095c206f889472fe9ef843043bd6dfb9b5fbe2b5708f26eb7969f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eec6d963ef7fdad293ee1889","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386494,"date":"2026-03-26T22:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, MOUs will not deliver Canadian natural resources to markets, but pipelines and ports will. \n\nHowever, I want to turn to the forestry sector now. We know that a decade of Liberal ministers negotiating with four presidential administrations has not delivered a softwood lumber agreement, while Prime Minister Harper was able to sign one in mere weeks. New challenges of the second Trump administration therefore demand a new approach. \n\nWill the member opposite support my call for a coalition of members of every party representing forestry communities to go to Washington, D.C., together to make the unified case that the tariffs placed on our lumber sector are not only illegal and unjust but also harmful to both our economies? Will the member join me in supporting an all-party, all-regions team Canada approach that could make the case for forestry to the U.S. Congress?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386494","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, MOUs will not deliver Canadian natural resources to markets, but pipelines and ports will. \n\nHowever, I want to turn to the forestry sector now. We know that a decade of Liberal ministers negotiating with four presidential administrations has not delivered a softwood lumber agreement, while Prime Minister Harper was able to sign one in mere weeks. New challenges of the second Trump ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d1d501d6ef33d1766fea80a2d3d30f8e826ff63c9a3083bee67aab51ac5208ec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["520ffa6cd78bfae2ffbd3d2858a5ebbfe3cf474364427dffc223fac50cc59544"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9c0c832f43e7f3a693a13c83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428964,"date":"2026-04-14T16:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague made an eloquent speech, but I would like to ask the member, how long does he think it is going to take? How many years is it going to take before he feels we can lose our dependency on fuel? He would like to change things so that we are not dependent on it anymore, and yet it is well known that this could take years.\n\nIn my riding of Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, a lot of people cannot afford electric cars. They need to drive trucks because they work in agriculture or they work in professions where they need a large car, vehicles that are not even available as electric at this point.\n\nHow many years is it going to take, and how many people are going to have to suffer if we do not take the taxes off fuel?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428964","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague made an eloquent speech, but I would like to ask the member, how long does he think it is going to take? How many years is it going to take before he feels we can lose our dependency on fuel? He would like to change things so that we are not dependent on it anymore, and yet it is well known that this could take years.\n\nIn my riding of Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Koote","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f52f22187af85526d84fbcea5ae547d4c4dbbb8f4775ff546eff07dbe342b671"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d129ba3f96b46ad5f3af02764e2d003dd27d4a0e13fa8c9603ddc01b19b4a9cd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a72269a38667c1102964751c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428965,"date":"2026-04-14T19:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today, the Liberals announced they are adopting a third of our gas relief plan for just a third of the year, but residents in the Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay do not just drive for the summer. Our plan would take excise, GST and fuel standard taxes off gas and diesel for the rest of 2026. That would cut costs at the pump by 25¢ per litre, saving $1,200 for a family of four.\n\nWill the Liberals end the tax grab and save Canadians 25¢ a litre?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428965","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today, the Liberals announced they are adopting a third of our gas relief plan for just a third of the year, but residents in the Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay do not just drive for the summer. Our plan would take excise, GST and fuel standard taxes off gas and diesel for the rest of 2026. That would cut costs at the pump by 25¢ per litre, saving $1,200 for a family of four","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["13d2ae36627e9cc97bfff24407061c30398707b73bcdb972a9441ea1863dfd68"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ec4c1bb0ba56f6a407b7c0e7e14dfed451659f52bbcec6316493f2f5c08ec8c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2803f888d87e8df7e190c75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115654,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Did you say that I'm first?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115654","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Did you say that I'm first?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-585b5c2afc0f28495cb318f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115655,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"It was Maggie and then me for the speaking order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115655","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It was Maggie and then me for the speaking order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d33f6e2bb4833e4f76ee1c23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115656,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"It was Maggie and me. Do you remember? I was second, Clerk.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115656","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It was Maggie and me. Do you remember? I was second, Clerk.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ffe8a6b76adab2e60d6006d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115657,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Yes, Ms. Chi. I'm sorry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115657","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, Ms. Chi. I'm sorry.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55c6525e7ff7e87eeedec4e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115658,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I have a point of order. Chair, you said that it was Ms. Chi and then me, and because you happened to look over and see Ms. Chi first—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115658","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a point of order. Chair, you said that it was Ms. Chi and then me, and because you happened to look over and see Ms. Chi first—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8e752a3e7667fe2fecc8a0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115659,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"She started speaking....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115659","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"She started speaking....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-882f886be6f187df45c70884","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115660,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I'm going to have to challenge that. I'm sorry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115660","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm going to have to challenge that. I'm sorry.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e27c4fc59f602350d25b8327","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115661,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I'm sorry, Chair, but the reason I need to challenge this is that just 10 minutes ago, I raised my hand and you said, \"I'm sorry,\" and that you saw Ms. Chi first, and then me, and the clerk agreed on that. Ms. Chi then started speaking, and then Mr. Mazier made the motion—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115661","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm sorry, Chair, but the reason I need to challenge this is that just 10 minutes ago, I raised my hand and you said, \"I'm sorry,\" and that you saw Ms. Chi first, and then me, and the clerk agreed on that. Ms. Chi then started speaking, and then Mr. Mazier made the motion—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e219397c50b92912641b8322","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115662,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"You're saying—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115662","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You're saying—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-074ed636988efbc81e2083b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115663,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"—that, at the beginning of the meeting, when you said that Ms. Chi was first and then I was second—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115663","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"—that, at the beginning of the meeting, when you said that Ms. Chi was first and then I was second—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a8ab1180a3936b96d556797","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115664,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"—you made a mistake. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115664","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"—you made a mistake. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c00bf9c0650e268f2dce56b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115665,"date":"2026-04-15T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I have a point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115665","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37374b6aaf357335999be006","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115666,"date":"2026-04-15T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I will say, Chair, that at the time that Ms. Chi was speaking, you allowed her to suspend the meeting. At that point, why did neither you nor the clerk decide that she was out of order at that point? Then we suspended the meeting for 10 minutes after you said that I would be speaking second, then you suspended the meeting, and Ms. Chi was first. We do have it on video.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115666","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I will say, Chair, that at the time that Ms. Chi was speaking, you allowed her to suspend the meeting. At that point, why did neither you nor the clerk decide that she was out of order at that point? Then we suspended the meeting for 10 minutes after you said that I would be speaking second, then you suspended the meeting, and Ms. Chi was first. We do have it on video.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5bf5c3eb738454d2f7427d405a0f235856c5567690bb531bbd76cdf1149497b1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c795a2a27b77d9db6dafaeb9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115667,"date":"2026-04-15T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"—and for making that error. Okay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115667","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"—and for making that error. Okay.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f95f978108f9c4cf3bffb98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115668,"date":"2026-04-15T22:45:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I'd like to speak to the amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115668","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to speak to the amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6d9a05f35b9347bcbdf0a8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115669,"date":"2026-04-15T22:45:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Okay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115669","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97b31ad14df26c4e49dfa55a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115670,"date":"2026-04-15T23:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I'd like to make an amendment to the motion. I'm hoping it will have UC. In section f), I'd like to cross out \"except with Quebec\". In section g), I'd like \"except with Quebec\" crossed out. In section k), I'd like \"except from Quebec\" crossed out. I can start again, if that will help.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115670","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to make an amendment to the motion. I'm hoping it will have UC. In section f), I'd like to cross out \"except with Quebec\". In section g), I'd like \"except with Quebec\" crossed out. In section k), I'd like \"except from Quebec\" crossed out. I can start again, if that will help.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca88cd6efd8cbbf67981c7e2c444541c99720b5e754940a4878c639c8e82d16f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0870f59fbc98e0206e03e14d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115671,"date":"2026-04-15T23:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"That seems [ Inaudible—Editor ].","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115671","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That seems [ Inaudible—Editor ].","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5eb80efce7821655451f7e19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115672,"date":"2026-04-15T23:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"There's one more. In the second sentence of the last paragraph, I would like to strike out \"and in both official languages\".","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115672","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There's one more. In the second sentence of the last paragraph, I would like to strike out \"and in both official languages\".","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083621","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Second language education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083621","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Second language education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083621","label":"Second language education","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4cc56d6c7e6991e0a0efaf4419f20285be6ffc6770a7f69f388616861d1e46b0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03e1a2b6c682fb69cd8d7582","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115673,"date":"2026-04-15T23:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"In the second sentence of the last paragraph, I'd like to strike out \"and in both official languages\". That's it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115673","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the second sentence of the last paragraph, I'd like to strike out \"and in both official languages\". That's it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083621","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Second language education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083621","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Second language education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083621","label":"Second language education","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["682ea707b66deac9eee091d0ecdeedf2aa90e12e5405d8a11e3d65fd94c57236"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17b8d6bc3df5b440a8c1f522","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115674,"date":"2026-04-15T23:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Strike that out. That is it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115674","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Strike that out. That is it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b7c6d399d7d56f736757b1d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115675,"date":"2026-04-15T23:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Can we get UC for that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115675","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can we get UC for that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-033cc1005987769ac0ea2bc3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115676,"date":"2026-04-15T23:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Can we get UC for that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115676","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can we get UC for that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f5696adbf4e1a6cb4add826f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115677,"date":"2026-04-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you to all of you for coming. Thank you for your work in the field of addiction. It's extremely important. This week marks the 10-year anniversary of B.C.'s declaration of a public health emergency due to the overdose crisis, yet more Canadians since then have died of a deadly drug overdose than on every battlefield during the Second World War. Eighteen thousand of them were British Columbians. There is a reason The Canadian Press called this a \"Decade of death\". Overdose deaths peaked during the decriminalization pilot project in B.C. Too many public spaces look unrecognizable compared to even a few years ago. Too many lives are still lost. Dr. Caudarella, during your testimony to the Senate in June 2024, you said, \"supervised consumption sites [should] become more embedded in the overall health and social systems...as a front door to wellness.\" Is it still your advice to the Canadian government today that more drug consumption sites be embedded across Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115677","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to all of you for coming. Thank you for your work in the field of addiction. It's extremely important. This week marks the 10-year anniversary of B.C.'s declaration of a public health emergency due to the overdose crisis, yet more Canadians since then have died of a deadly drug overdose than on every battlefield during the Second World War. Eighteen thousand of them were British Columbia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["45beba828b21fd50056dffa51b341dbb7a21ddfba0769c3f50fc51b28555f52c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d534c2a54198d7d128b5c0359937aaa84b974fb62cbe7ef68be9a94bd0c52376"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bc71c261e07c0146eb477b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115678,"date":"2026-04-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I agree that we need such a system. In my community, if someone at a consumption site needs help, there is none for them. I know you've spoken about these sites being accountable to the community, but many residents feel that they aren't accountable. These sites often create pockets of open drug use throughout communities and leave glass, needles and tablets on playgrounds. In the spirit of community accountability, would you support something like a buffer zone between these sites and local schools or day cares?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115678","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I agree that we need such a system. In my community, if someone at a consumption site needs help, there is none for them. I know you've spoken about these sites being accountable to the community, but many residents feel that they aren't accountable. These sites often create pockets of open drug use throughout communities and leave glass, needles and tablets on playgrounds. In the spirit of commun","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5d5ce689090f70821cd0c632acd6bc0ec3283fa49c2600c8621629230e01b078"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a4e78a7fbc2ea749184ccf4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115679,"date":"2026-04-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Do you think that a consumption site should be next to a playground?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115679","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you think that a consumption site should be next to a playground?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f866bb40d339e69540aff64f78a8eeca2ff01bcaff218f51a4ae35612fdb5651"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09d5b7cd5c225718e4ecf5a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115680,"date":"2026-04-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Do you think they should be? Are you saying that, at times, it could be next to a playground?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115680","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you think they should be? Are you saying that, at times, it could be next to a playground?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6b7cf54841a890bc3ffeb6d8c091ab0c62aae104fb52ad005b52844abf55e218"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fdd6384a3de17746ae5a6f0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115681,"date":"2026-04-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Excellent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115681","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Excellent.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27e479cde674f8b9370ff8ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115682,"date":"2026-04-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Do you believe that a community should be able to vote democratically on where a consumption site should be? I'm not sure that's happening, at least not in B.C. I come from local government, and the community didn't vote on where the consumption sites would be.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115682","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you believe that a community should be able to vote democratically on where a consumption site should be? I'm not sure that's happening, at least not in B.C. I come from local government, and the community didn't vote on where the consumption sites would be.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47b459d6f1a63f192e8fef93ec8febe5a94c823291e2baf77529035ce820e8a3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2eca943b14f4734ac1425649","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115683,"date":"2026-04-16T21:15:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I agree. I think communities should have a vote as to where consumption sites should go. Dr. Caudarella, this is really important: I view the decriminalization pilot project to which B.C. was subjected by Ottawa and Victoria as a costly and deadly failure. I'm not the only one. Even Premier Eby said it did not work. Longer than a year ago, during the last election, he said that it wasn't working. Health Canada officials, who appeared here, refused to explain if they viewed it as a success. However, others disagreed. For example, Dr. Bonnie Henry, B.C.'s public health officer, said she was disappointed by the reversal of decriminalization in B.C. What do you think? Would you want to continue another decriminalization pilot program after the devastation it caused in B.C.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115683","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I agree. I think communities should have a vote as to where consumption sites should go. Dr. Caudarella, this is really important: I view the decriminalization pilot project to which B.C. was subjected by Ottawa and Victoria as a costly and deadly failure. I'm not the only one. Even Premier Eby said it did not work. Longer than a year ago, during the last election, he said that it wasn't working. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2794eaa54dcd6ab97fcadecc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115684,"date":"2026-04-16T21:15:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Do you feel it worked in B.C., yes or no? Did this pilot project work in B.C.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115684","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you feel it worked in B.C., yes or no? Did this pilot project work in B.C.?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a40d2dc0441411d7b5cb6f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115685,"date":"2026-04-16T21:15:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"That's good, but was it successful? Would you do it again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115685","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's good, but was it successful? Would you do it again?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15eac804f94785ec9fd64d62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115686,"date":"2026-04-16T21:15:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"A lot of people died.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115686","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"A lot of people died.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5762737d4d00c775e936f1ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115687,"date":"2026-04-16T21:15:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"A lot of people died.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115687","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"A lot of people died.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df8332c87ce8553ec795f09f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115688,"date":"2026-04-16T21:15:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"It didn't work. I hope it's not being brought back to any community or any province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115688","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It didn't work. I hope it's not being brought back to any community or any province.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09988e447b82dfe44e22248bbf669983c6abfe395eb6819a89818b790e91b6e6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9dc5d5e92ca364ebd085c7b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115689,"date":"2026-04-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I have a question for Mr. Arao. You told CBC News in 2016 that the number of overdoses you were seeing in Vancouver then was excessively high. The number of overdoses in Vancouver is even higher today, as you know, higher across the whole province, and the number of overdose deaths is significantly higher than in 2016. If overdoses were excessively high then, how would you describe them today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115689","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a question for Mr. Arao. You told CBC News in 2016 that the number of overdoses you were seeing in Vancouver then was excessively high. The number of overdoses in Vancouver is even higher today, as you know, higher across the whole province, and the number of overdose deaths is significantly higher than in 2016. If overdoses were excessively high then, how would you describe them today?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97b15e3fa144dfc70e9678c41944cca7135aae19954ac95302e737c2ddb41ec9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c416efabb9a447ceb688b7a8aa5da09b446e693aabf48848c579d57dac61c864"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b5d023d67f61ab86da56033","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115690,"date":"2026-04-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"It's shocking. Mr. Arao, the prevalence of drug consumption sites in B.C. has increased exponentially in the last decade, but so has the number of overdose deaths. Do you view any correlation between these two increases: more sites and more overdoses?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115690","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's shocking. Mr. Arao, the prevalence of drug consumption sites in B.C. has increased exponentially in the last decade, but so has the number of overdose deaths. Do you view any correlation between these two increases: more sites and more overdoses?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ac258c8ed6fa768d508c180fa0ccead7cb714bfd3b8676c2f4ba48a98dec320f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["80bef8acb333c61e03b428b4df94c7857411fb4828468f2fc150bac27c21fc42"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b20e2369582ad017d6065e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115691,"date":"2026-04-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"It doesn't really seem to be working, wouldn't you say? The numbers don't work. We've talked a lot today about data. Your organization works with data. This is very obvious data. I would say that the two numbers are both rising: deaths and consumption sites. Do you think they are correlated?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115691","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It doesn't really seem to be working, wouldn't you say? The numbers don't work. We've talked a lot today about data. Your organization works with data. This is very obvious data. I would say that the two numbers are both rising: deaths and consumption sites. Do you think they are correlated?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e434a37ab5ab63335dff804ceac1dbb35d0d2c08cfdedb26b3a018050a342dd4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f1b28f4efb56b9162e29462ac5f9a42d16d84e473dc615a3aea9d842495d80fd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04de7089f03863861c1c9887","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115692,"date":"2026-04-16T22:15:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"You imagine there would be even more. There's been a lot of talk today about the continuum of care. It's been said that distributing drugs at consumption sites is part of a continuum of care. I wonder if you could answer my question. I've heard a lot about a need for a continuum of care, for example, but in my community, there's no option for that continuum of care. If someone's at a consumption site and decides, as you said, to quit drugs—\"I'd like to quit drugs, and I want help; please help me\"—there's nowhere for them to go. In fact, I was told by a resident involved in this system that in their community, it would be a two-year wait for treatment, and it wouldn't be anywhere in our communities, by the way. They would be sent somewhere else. After two years...I'm sure you understand what that means. It could be death for somebody. What do you say about opening up these consumption sites yet not having a continuum of care in place, especially in rural communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115692","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You imagine there would be even more. There's been a lot of talk today about the continuum of care. It's been said that distributing drugs at consumption sites is part of a continuum of care. I wonder if you could answer my question. I've heard a lot about a need for a continuum of care, for example, but in my community, there's no option for that continuum of care. If someone's at a consumption s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ea4e6a0a62a86295d1a4181e19b63cf3ecb24f857137973a3af97dcbe3d1e1b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9105edecd6ddb314cfe3352c8cc3ed8c960fca3f1072f078494652d9bb482c34"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ea5b30eee5448367d87c27c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115693,"date":"2026-04-16T22:15:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"What do we do? Should we continue to build safe sites, or whatever they are called? Should we continue to build them if there's no treatment available for people to quit drugs, should they wish to do so?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115693","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What do we do? Should we continue to build safe sites, or whatever they are called? Should we continue to build them if there's no treatment available for people to quit drugs, should they wish to do so?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:255569","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Contaminated sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:255569","label":"Contaminated sites","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f011ef06e2fd7ad164aa7602ce3d9ee5462997e81757ff02c3cab97626b6d31b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["71dbf3cea75e76d0d08050b0e5720f3e80b720e8a6b35a1b29678215d969490b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c69e604af1afd11df32bdc22","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115694,"date":"2026-04-16T22:15:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Maybe we should hold off on more consumption sites until we build the system and build the continuum of care. Let's build the continuum of care before we build any more consumption sites. I think that's what you're saying.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115694","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Maybe we should hold off on more consumption sites until we build the system and build the continuum of care. Let's build the continuum of care before we build any more consumption sites. I think that's what you're saying.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90cb5fd4070952de213150293d1c677747bc1aa1ad967c66265a3d3d4fbbd516"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98d83abd6c9662c80d8a7049","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115695,"date":"2026-04-16T22:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Chair, I wanted to ask if you believe that safe consumption sites are working in British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115695","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Chair, I wanted to ask if you believe that safe consumption sites are working in British Columbia.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","label":"Green products","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["220b129868fbb3d46f8287b57df7c12d7dec9e9db537d8fa736b1c182d71a661"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40f9e7d9ffb663334b0deef4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428929,"date":"2026-04-16T23:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the government promised that its approach to addiction would reduce harm and lead people toward recovery, but the evidence shows that this promise has not been kept. Canadians were told that decriminalization, safer supply and supervised consumption would reduce harm and connect people to treatment. That was the promise. However, the reality on the ground tells a completely different story. \n\nAt the health committee, witnesses made it clear that overdose rates have not come down in any meaningful way. Communities are still suffering. Families are grieving. First responders are still overwhelmed. In many places, public spaces that should be safe for children and families are now sites of open drug use, chaos and fear. \n\nIn my riding and across British Columbia, people see this every day. Local governments, first responders and health authorities are left carrying the cost of a federal experiment that never should have been imposed in the first place. We know that when British Columbia sought this decriminalization exemption, no other province followed, not one. No other province came forward to ask to copy this model. That alone should have raised serious questions for the federal government. Instead, the Liberals treated British Columbia like a laboratory experiment.\n\n The Liberals say these policies are about compassion. Conservatives believe in compassion too, but compassion means helping people get better. It means treatment. It means recovery. It means giving people a path out of addiction and not trapping them in it.\n\n One of the most troubling realities raised by local health authorities in my riding is what happens when someone is finally ready to seek help. It can take up to two years to get a treatment bed. Imagine someone finding the courage to say, \"I need help,\" only to be told there is no space, no timely support and no real path forward, but there are more drugs. \n\nWe also heard serious concerns from witnesses about the Liberal approach to so-called safer supply. The theory is that if government provides cleaner drugs, people will eventually stabilize and then seek treatment. However, the second part of that argument is simply not happening. We do not have the treatment in place. Instead, many of these drugs are diverted, sold and exchanged for substances users actually want. That means the government is not ending addiction but actually feeding into it.\n\n Now we have more evidence that calls the Liberal narrative into question. A peer-reviewed Canadian study on the closure of a supervised consumption site in Red Deer found no increase in deaths, no increase in emergency department visits and no increase in opioid-related EMS events after the site closed. In other words, when the site closed, more people actually moved to recovery. That matters because Liberals keep telling Canadians that these sites are the answer, even when the evidence shows that recovery-oriented care delivers better outcomes.\n\n Canadians deserve better than this false choice between neglect and normalization. They deserve a government that will invest in treatment, prioritize recovery and restore hope to families who feel abandoned.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428929","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the government promised that its approach to addiction would reduce harm and lead people toward recovery, but the evidence shows that this promise has not been kept. Canadians were told that decriminalization, safer supply and supervised consumption would reduce harm and connect people to treatment. That was the promise. However, the reality on the ground tells a completely different ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1cc18fa20af4af5f676eb0279b2aced8f79ff8f65542522e16cd1bb03cfb679c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f71909bfc3ebfcfad72dd90b9758a9498eee9ceabbee902224d0ead3083a730f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f09fe2fcdc4e615bc6a2a0a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":428930,"date":"2026-04-16T23:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague across the aisle, who I know cares deeply about this crisis.\n\n We all want the same thing. We want to end this crisis or at least make a move towards ending it. Canadians are living the consequences. B.C. is living the consequences of the model of decriminalization that did not work. Hopefully no other province is asked to go through what we have had to go through.\n\n The Liberals say this is about helping people, yet when someone is ready for treatment, they are told to wait months or even years. That is not compassion. We now have Canadian evidence showing that when access to these sites is removed, more people actually seek treatment.\n\nWhy will the government not prioritize recovery instead of defending policies that keep people trapped in addiction?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:428930","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague across the aisle, who I know cares deeply about this crisis.\n\n We all want the same thing. We want to end this crisis or at least make a move towards ending it. Canadians are living the consequences. B.C. is living the consequences of the model of decriminalization that did not work. Hopefully no other province is asked to go through what we have had ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d330ab58981b6f31fe45f3ec978c9b5cba7bd9b25a8560d0eb1683e6f7ce6dbb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9980aac0bbd64008f37428659ab5023e726d3a02891ad9186c4cbf32dfbb87b5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d75beb89a4e8cf5907aac244","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300892,"date":"2026-04-20T16:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to private member's bill, Bill C-226, which has been brought forward to this House by the member for Fleetwood—Port Kells.\n\nBefore I begin my speech, I would like to quickly congratulate two of my local hockey teams. The first is the Penticton Vees, which will be advancing to the next round of playoffs in its first year of the WHL. The second is the Princeton Posse, which is currently playing in the championship series and truly defines how small towns make for big hockey.\n\nReturning to the legislation at hand, I would like to congratulate the member on bringing forward this legislation. It is an opportunity that not every parliamentarian has so early on in the House. I know, because I am currently working on my own legislation, so I understand the challenge in bringing a bill to fruition.\n\nThe member is bringing forward legislation related to a subject that, no doubt, is raised in his riding as much as it is in mine: grocery prices. Typical for a Liberal bill, this is not going to get the member where he would like to be, which is lowering grocery prices. Grocery prices are one of the biggest topics in my riding. Wherever I go in my region of the country, whether it is Hedley, Naramata, Oliver, Rock Creek, Greenwood, Rossland or Penticton, I hear the same story: \"I can't believe how big my grocery bill is.\" When I talk with colleagues here in Ottawa, the same story emerges. Whenever someone picks up a carton of milk, a package of beef or a bag of carrots, they cannot believe the sticker price.\n\nI think all parliamentarians would welcome legislation to tackle grocery prices, but we have to ensure that it actually actually works to stabilize the price of the essentials that all families rely on. Any bill before us should be judged not by its intentions, but by whether it will, in fact, allow families to create an affordable budget to fill the fridge.\n\nFor those watching at home, this legislation, if enacted, would create the following regulations. It would require the Minister of Industry, in consultation with the provinces, to create a national framework on grocery pricing and unit price display, emphasizing accuracy, usability and accessibility of unit pricing, transparency on price increases and consumer education on unit pricing. The framework would need to be delivered within 18 months, and it would be followed by an effectiveness report after five years.\n\nI believe the member's intention with this system is to create greater transparency in pricing for consumers, which I appreciate, of course, but the creation of a government report is not the enactment of a report or its recommendations. Ultimately, while the minister's office would be asked to create a report outlining standards, there would be no enforcement mechanism.\n\nWe have seen in multiple files departmental reports whose recommendations were not followed through by ministers. As just one example, the federal Competition Bureau studied grocery sector concentration and pricing practices three years ago and made several recommendations to improve competition and consumer options. It is important to note that very few of those recommendations have been enacted, either by the former industry minister who requested that report or by the present industry minister who succeeded him.\n\n There is also the fact that the federal government lacks jurisdiction over grocery pricing, which is ultimately the provinces' territory. There is nothing here in this legislation that lends an understanding of how that gap would be bridged. Ultimately, though, if these challenges could be overcome, I would ask how transparent the Liberal government is willing to be about the added costs to grocery pricing.\n\nFamilies in my riding understand that global events like COVID, tariffs or the wars in Ukraine, Iran and Iraq can affect food prices, but they see less of the government agricultural red tape, the domestic plastic packaging rules or the domestic fuel standards tax. These are all choices of the government that add unnecessary costs, cent by cent, to a family's grocery bills. Is the Liberal government willing to make it clear how its own policies raise the price of Canadian-made food? Considering this is the Liberal government that championed carbon taxes for years while ignoring the impact on families, I have my doubts. Working to undo these unnecessary taxes, fees and red tape would enable this Parliament to act in ways that let families actually see savings. \n\nAll of the Liberal policies I referenced are a necessary added cost to the price on the shelf or in the freezer of the local grocery store. I recently surveyed rural communities across my riding about their experiences with grocery prices. I would like to take an opportunity to bring some of their voices to this debate as well. Norma from Greenwood wrote to me saying that, as a senior with celiac disease, it is ever more expensive for food, and pensions are not keeping pace with the increase in food, gas and power. Norma raises a good point here that, with the costs of groceries certainly impacting young families with many mouths to feed, those on fixed incomes or who live with dietary requirements or limitations on working ability find it equally difficult to ensure an affordable and nutritious meal is something they can put part of a paycheque toward and not a credit card. \n\nDee in Princeton wrote that people should be encouraged to shop at local producers and grow their own food. Having just been to the opening of our farmers' market and to a hunters' fundraiser this past weekend, I could not agree more. Reducing costs for farmers, growers, hunters and anglers to create more local fruits, vegetables, meat and fish is a point raised often on this side of the House and is especially important in rural Canada. \n\nLastly, Simon in Castlegar wrote to me saying that breaking down monopolistic entities that have an oversized level of control over the food supply chain might be a better way to reduce the costs. \n\nFinding ways to reduce market dominance of the five major grocery chains and spur more competition and smaller-sized operations were also part of the Competition Bureau's report that I mentioned earlier, which the government has still not acted on three years later. As a former small business owner, I always want to see us paving the way for more options for residents to buy healthy, local, affordable food. If this legislation provided a path forward to remove unnecessary taxes, fees and red tape that push up domestic food costs, I have no doubt this House would swiftly support it, but relying on reporting mechanisms is not the guarantee we need to spur real action on food prices. \n\nI will continue to follow the debate in this House on Bill C-226 and, should it advance, will look to ensure it is rigorously studied at committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300892","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to private member's bill, Bill C-226, which has been brought forward to this House by the member for Fleetwood—Port Kells.\n\nBefore I begin my speech, I would like to quickly congratulate two of my local hockey teams. The first is the Penticton Vees, which will be advancing to the next round of playoffs in its first year of the WHL. The second is the Princeton Posse, wh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f6edce633dab678c0533858350f351bd966471c21aff58a2e2428f1e99168e90"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["23df749d9ca0ada3e5526364eab51226c476ad454e153b6cb6e2b158c753eced"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c389075b2c8532a4e557ee32","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300887,"date":"2026-04-21T15:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her really interesting speech that hit home. She mentioned this being an attack on rural Canada. Public universities and colleges are not located in small towns, but the private schools, private colleges and career colleges are filling that gap. We want our young people and older people to be able to work and go to school in their communities. For example, there is a lack of dental hygienists. I cannot see a dental hygienist for six to eight months in the interior of B.C. where I live because of a lack of hygienists.\n\nCan my colleague explain how this affects rural Canada more than any other place?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300887","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her really interesting speech that hit home. She mentioned this being an attack on rural Canada. Public universities and colleges are not located in small towns, but the private schools, private colleges and career colleges are filling that gap. We want our young people and older people to be able to work and go to school in their communities. For example, the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:423203","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hygiene","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:423203","label":"Hygiene","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8366d44ef9d485cc694e6e69e9d72a61c1c18268f46c50db9175634bc98da4fd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-91dc983f5f6fbb96156a8f2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300888,"date":"2026-04-21T17:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague's speech really got to the heart of the problem with the policy.\n\nIn my riding of Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, a mainly rural riding, a career college is one of the only choices for many fields. For some reason, the Liberals have decided to attack rural Canada. There are many people who will not be able to get an education if they cannot afford their college education at a career college. What does my colleague think is the reason the Liberals are so determined to limit what people in small-town Canada are able to do to further their education?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300888","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague's speech really got to the heart of the problem with the policy.\n\nIn my riding of Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, a mainly rural riding, a career college is one of the only choices for many fields. For some reason, the Liberals have decided to attack rural Canada. There are many people who will not be able to get an education if they cannot afford their college ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9af7389f52f1f012f847077423281c6387f9c6bdd36fe1e8f4b4da53bda03644"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7c74745088fa560a214d819e478ddd1bbc9bf371a7cd1e30d0661704942a7ed0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b680a6d7b33dff152ba1e54","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300889,"date":"2026-04-21T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this policy creates two classes of students based solely on where they study. In rural ridings like Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, we do not have many choices for education.\n\nWhy does my colleague think the Liberals are trying to limit education, especially in small communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300889","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this policy creates two classes of students based solely on where they study. In rural ridings like Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, we do not have many choices for education.\n\nWhy does my colleague think the Liberals are trying to limit education, especially in small communities?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["204054cccc61d6ed70d0906b00705361b1398417e2968b38ae9953b43c0001d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["caebd7d1be16851a053163407f06f910a7273e0031b85b5c77f4421a02993ae2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69f9133461e935899c114732","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300890,"date":"2026-04-21T17:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I really appreciate my colleague's discussion on this very important issue.\n\nWhat does she think about the fact that in rural communities like Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay there are hardly any choices for people to further their education? This will further limit the choices that my constituents have.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300890","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I really appreciate my colleague's discussion on this very important issue.\n\nWhat does she think about the fact that in rural communities like Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay there are hardly any choices for people to further their education? This will further limit the choices that my constituents have.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["18a210b9fb0454760431f931cd059f58868bdd000b5d6fe4b4e1755939604d61"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e39bfacbe3383ce9f1e38aa79b655843f24e2f97f7d29a36a6ee5db4332c421"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdee15cfc562ad7995b8e1ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300891,"date":"2026-04-21T17:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to continue this discussion in the House, a very important discussion for all of Canada, in particular for people living in rural communities. What we are talking about is the Liberal government's changes in budget 2025, which unfairly exclude career college students from federal grants.\n\nThis obviously undermines affordability and Canada's workforce needs. It also undermines skills training, which everybody in the House is talking about every day, and which we are going to need if we are going to build the housing and the infrastructure that our country needs imminently.\n\nWhat this policy does is create two classes of students, based solely on where they actually study. It should not be up to us in the House to decide who gives a better education or what education anybody should have in the first place. I know that when my kids decided to go to school, I wanted them to be able to decide for themselves where they were going. As an institution, we are really promoting all types of education so that we have well-rounded communities in Canada. \n\nWith this policy, students are penalized for choosing hands-on, employment-based education. It is agreed on this side of the House, and I am sure that everybody in the House actually agrees with this, that many of the programs that are essential to moving forward as an autonomous country are only offered in career colleges. Public colleges are great, obviously. We have some of the best institutions in the world, but when people live in smaller communities, rural communities, such as Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, public colleges and universities are quite a drive away and not accessible to everyone. They do not offer some of the very important programs that are needed. \n\nI will give an example: dentistry or dental hygienists. Right now, I would like to go see the dentist myself and go see the hygienist, but it is a six- to eight-month wait in all of the dentists' offices in and around where I live. If we go to even more rural communities in Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, it will be an even longer wait. That is just one example of what is happening. \n\nCareer colleges play a key role in rapid workforce training. Cutting grants for this particular segment of people who want to be able to further their education would obviously discourage enrolment, reduce the number of graduates and worsen the workforce gaps that we talk about every day in the House.\n\n As for affordability, many students rely on these grants to afford career college programs. Many people understand that this is not a choice between going to a public school and going to a career college. It is not a choice. Many people do not have transportation, particularly in rural communities. We do not have a SkyTrain that we can take to a bigger city like Kelowna. We do not have mass transit. Sometimes the career college that happens to be down the street from one's house or nearby is really the only opportunity people have to further their education and then be able to put food on the table for their family. This is not a fun choice. This limits upward mobility and access to opportunity. I discourage this policy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300891","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to continue this discussion in the House, a very important discussion for all of Canada, in particular for people living in rural communities. What we are talking about is the Liberal government's changes in budget 2025, which unfairly exclude career college students from federal grants.\n\nThis obviously undermines affordability and Canada's workforce needs. It also undermines s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c5dceff282180475329fea0ae5ed187f1fa526dc5bec288b1e7717bc49e0ba93"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca297cbb81dc70aa039b326120b009d1c0764422d727b86d76286e632cafe717"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c67e7af9f0484eb7b5b7b24d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115696,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you, Chair. First of all, I want to say quickly, Mr. Green, it's very important that you answer these questions succinctly and that you actually answer them. If you do not answer the questions the committee members ask, you will be asked to return. Answer succinctly, please, as I have five minutes. Was Telus the lowest bid for PrescribeIT?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115696","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. First of all, I want to say quickly, Mr. Green, it's very important that you answer these questions succinctly and that you actually answer them. If you do not answer the questions the committee members ask, you will be asked to return. Answer succinctly, please, as I have five minutes. Was Telus the lowest bid for PrescribeIT?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9d8dd2a726bd35e2bd588e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115697,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Yes or no—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115697","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes or no—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a84ff97c926d8894ab7ffb12","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115698,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Can we table that, then? If you don't have the answer, you can table that. For my next question, was the $250 million in tax dollars well spent?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115698","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can we table that, then? If you don't have the answer, you can table that. For my next question, was the $250 million in tax dollars well spent?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","label":"Personal income tax","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69d454d75c8a76e69c7d7a490218c21beae00770e316a33729f491064efb072b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1737044bc174d287e2442c43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115699,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you. How widely was PrescribeIT adopted? Do you have the raw numbers, the percentage of prescriptions that went through?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115699","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. How widely was PrescribeIT adopted? Do you have the raw numbers, the percentage of prescriptions that went through?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d77b388128430b188dceef1f9be1c94cdeef1b10c71b30b51655b45b83f90977"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8e10bfe40540152c50d3559","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115700,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"It's 95% of all vendors.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115700","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's 95% of all vendors.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e933e753623a30a73bb6c38a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115701,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Yes. Every question I ask is the committee asking, so yes, that's great. You're going to table those numbers. Thank you. It was promised that PrescribeIT would be financially self-sustaining. Was it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115701","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes. Every question I ask is the committee asking, so yes, that's great. You're going to table those numbers. Thank you. It was promised that PrescribeIT would be financially self-sustaining. Was it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb665cca5c27c19cf00024e767413b79ed796c4446290a53904a63a1e76a4df9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96a084f7aceec8ce282dc216","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115702,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"The goal was to be—the goal—but it never was...?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115702","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The goal was to be—the goal—but it never was...?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15218fa6fc8ee2cd0e41d1f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115703,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"That was the $250 million. Okay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115703","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That was the $250 million. Okay.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee18a07c9fa91b2f4d5ef0d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115704,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"We know that you eventually developed a fee of 20¢ per prescription. How much did the federal government collect in total on the fee from health care professionals?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115704","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We know that you eventually developed a fee of 20¢ per prescription. How much did the federal government collect in total on the fee from health care professionals?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d3426eeb186e9369fcdb362bd30dbb72dc1f5d5677a5c4d935d587e1be40b9e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bccc42bce3ddb7fcfd0816d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115705,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"How much was levied?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115705","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How much was levied?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41ec64efc3dabb8a8e38452b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115706,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Yes, the committee will always...whatever I ask for. If you could table the information, that would be great. You said that it was only pharmacists. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115706","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, the committee will always...whatever I ask for. If you could table the information, that would be great. You said that it was only pharmacists. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f52f7754663effaad94ab6b9a58620086e96b701dda062183187971ec35fdb7b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1bd29e9d094ba956a4c5c4cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115707,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Okay. I have another question, Mr. Green. In Infoway's 2016-17 year-end review, there's a point attributed to you, stating that Infoway's PrescribeIT service \"will reduce inappropriately filled prescriptions for narcotics\" and \"improve the detection of fraud and abuse\". Did PrescribeIT reduce fraud or the abuse of narcotics? Give me a yes-or-no answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115707","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. I have another question, Mr. Green. In Infoway's 2016-17 year-end review, there's a point attributed to you, stating that Infoway's PrescribeIT service \"will reduce inappropriately filled prescriptions for narcotics\" and \"improve the detection of fraud and abuse\". Did PrescribeIT reduce fraud or the abuse of narcotics? Give me a yes-or-no answer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ae6b5294085bd5a02811ea9dba9f58e66356f0d76424d471ff5bda1813c57790"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92597b22c56de40cb073449a5675c4b8b6e036e0e8ae2077b3fba7db46a69d3d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14417513b6f9dbd35f887167","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115708,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Is it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115708","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2cc00c8615a2869be3967a57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115709,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"You have proof that it reduced fraud and the abuse of narcotics, for the $250 million that was spent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115709","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You have proof that it reduced fraud and the abuse of narcotics, for the $250 million that was spent.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ab5f4148746858bbe5b183d2e992e9b85248e9d75a44c8a467fa4b7925dbd21"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5a8d1fa00378edfb40d6ecd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115710,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"PrescribeIT did prevent fraud and abuse. Okay. Our understanding is that you accounted for 5% of all prescriptions in Canada. Does Infoway have any evidence, at all, that there was a reduction in inappropriately filled prescriptions? Do you have those numbers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115710","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"PrescribeIT did prevent fraud and abuse. Okay. Our understanding is that you accounted for 5% of all prescriptions in Canada. Does Infoway have any evidence, at all, that there was a reduction in inappropriately filled prescriptions? Do you have those numbers?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bc9748668fda1d67a28665506345b4edfc9717f25e09a2ca83ddc711ad426d9d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["931c5bea84037d990aaaa8e83f3cc2b2974c5602c8fee62a88dc7212f85b5168"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86e05bfc56f963cc8ff4bcb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115711,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Table that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115711","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Table that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b68badcc42f453c6553d685","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115712,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"That would be amazing. Thank you. On November 19, 2016, the Liberal government committed to reducing the harm and cost of opioids with the launch of PrescribeIT. Given the state of our opioid crisis, did PrescribeIT measurably reduce the harm or cost of opioids in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115712","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That would be amazing. Thank you. On November 19, 2016, the Liberal government committed to reducing the harm and cost of opioids with the launch of PrescribeIT. Given the state of our opioid crisis, did PrescribeIT measurably reduce the harm or cost of opioids in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c55d62252a6a2c3fb5b4cd70b649f1659f625d13e06672c81e8e1b83a955401"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97a9aa206c442d4866ad1793","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115713,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Okay. Can I ask what your salary is?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115713","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Can I ask what your salary is?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f90cf0c0118d3773c5d209ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115714,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"What was your salary in 2025?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115714","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What was your salary in 2025?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-365271c553ba1a805ef8c06c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115715,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"In 2025....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115715","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In 2025....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12dcdd5d5dc42ad395f6d09c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115716,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you. What was it in 2025?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115716","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. What was it in 2025?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-555a706ee938ca43c3a16cab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115717,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"You need to answer my questions, Mr. Green.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115717","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You need to answer my questions, Mr. Green.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-620f2f7d633c97fe2478606c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115718,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Chair, do you mind reminding Mr. Green of his obligations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115718","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Chair, do you mind reminding Mr. Green of his obligations?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49a1115f7ee5ad50f317faf3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115719,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Including bonuses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115719","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Including bonuses.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20e58e56f54433d9f4d378e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115720,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Mr. Green, you know how much you make. You need to tell this committee how much you make. You need to tell Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115720","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Green, you know how much you make. You need to tell this committee how much you make. You need to tell Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","label":"Green products","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","label":"Television","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["912dc801e41c82d3a3dd248846a434b78cc8ae8a562884bf4b5e161dd6802315"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8ba4c66c1f834992761a057","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115721,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"No, you need to tell Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115721","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, you need to tell Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0057d995605f091a5d85b92f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115722,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"You need to table that information, Mr. Green.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115722","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You need to table that information, Mr. Green.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2523bcf6a65d99833548531d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115723,"date":"2026-04-21T23:00:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I want to know if we could request of Mr. Green that he deliver all the documents that have been requested during this past hour by the end of this week.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115723","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to know if we could request of Mr. Green that he deliver all the documents that have been requested during this past hour by the end of this week.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","label":"Warrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["96b1e9b2c3dbb2c1ce53a0a9be987ac09e508bf4671b4c4a7ec5abb96afb6604"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-988922bd4feb4b6771343b6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115724,"date":"2026-04-21T23:00:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I would like to ask of Mr. Green that he deliver everything that was asked for in the past hour by the end of this week. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115724","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to ask of Mr. Green that he deliver everything that was asked for in the past hour by the end of this week. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0544d1174ed83816340fadce38d5ef3ad32dbfa8dedf099b3837a97410e884ac"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b27cc327c4ca27b410ad53a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115725,"date":"2026-04-21T23:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you. I have a few questions. There was $298 million spent on PrescribeIT, and now we're transitioning into another system, another program. That $298 million was spent in eight years. Is it going to be another $298 million in the next eight years spent by taxpayers, by Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115725","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I have a few questions. There was $298 million spent on PrescribeIT, and now we're transitioning into another system, another program. That $298 million was spent in eight years. Is it going to be another $298 million in the next eight years spent by taxpayers, by Canadians?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["76ac93e7b9cbee1c2bcc19336e7b0c14cda8f6b51dc6212705ed2b068364c352"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3876fd7cdd012d921a5ff6e0baaa902a930de0007b18fce3f727d2c6ecf538a8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecbb71241ea0849e6c2a6057","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115726,"date":"2026-04-21T23:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Okay. Why not? Why do you think it'll be a better deal in the next eight years than it was in the last eight years? If things go the way they did, how do you know that you're not going to need to spend $298 million?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115726","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Why not? Why do you think it'll be a better deal in the next eight years than it was in the last eight years? If things go the way they did, how do you know that you're not going to need to spend $298 million?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66625e70602522c662ac3ce8f3a7ae7fb12bcdfad795ad46d651e8cd73ecf1c2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7be34a9f505e1dd8cd2c2fe8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115727,"date":"2026-04-21T23:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Will this be with Telus?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115727","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Will this be with Telus?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e6637f74b0878211a896eb76","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115728,"date":"2026-04-21T23:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Each province is going to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115728","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Each province is going to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-473aee9adb7c6982b83277c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115729,"date":"2026-04-21T23:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Okay. Each province is going to decide what they want to do separately.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115729","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Each province is going to decide what they want to do separately.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["750355653cc4abf49ce15a7bf0c9913a7679d9635ada8de5cc166019bde658ce"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e57d51dcf630f0feebff2052","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115730,"date":"2026-04-21T23:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Given all you've said today about this eight-year failure of PrescribeIT, why should Canadians trust anything else that comes forward? Why should Canadians trust a new system that you'll be bringing forward?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115730","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Given all you've said today about this eight-year failure of PrescribeIT, why should Canadians trust anything else that comes forward? Why should Canadians trust a new system that you'll be bringing forward?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7972591ba3b7b82947d2c149bf8f4b22f7af2391d3b5409a7edbd2a1ba755d07"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6265314035d347c54f29c75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115731,"date":"2026-04-21T23:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"It pivoted after $298 million. That's not really a pivot to me.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115731","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It pivoted after $298 million. That's not really a pivot to me.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e28c02bd48c016a4957a33bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115732,"date":"2026-04-21T23:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"It was for an uptake of 5% maximum. Would your goal be successful with a 10% or 20% uptake? What's your goal?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115732","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It was for an uptake of 5% maximum. Would your goal be successful with a 10% or 20% uptake? What's your goal?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af92155b3af28d242445f8050e947ef968789848fdd4f5d949707e943bcc2a2e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0127daed25193cecae643a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115733,"date":"2026-04-22T00:00:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Don't we still have time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115733","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Don't we still have time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ce3e69a6dac2cbe08bf9ca3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300883,"date":"2026-04-22T22:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are so lucky in the House to have my colleague's expertise. There are a lot of people watching from across the country who may not quite understand, because the bill is very complicated.\n\nIf he were to choose one thing in the bill that we should be focusing on that concerns him, could he mention what it is and what needs to change before we would be supportive of the bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300883","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are so lucky in the House to have my colleague's expertise. There are a lot of people watching from across the country who may not quite understand, because the bill is very complicated.\n\nIf he were to choose one thing in the bill that we should be focusing on that concerns him, could he mention what it is and what needs to change before we would be supportive of the bill?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9104fff7a765cd6a7c1c45e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300884,"date":"2026-04-22T23:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is very concerning when a bill such as this one comes forward and there is so much dissent against it, yet government representatives, MPs, are wondering why we are bringing forward concerns. That is definitely why we are here.\n\n Again, there have been first nations and Métis governments raising concerns, including the Dakota nation, arguing that a failure to consult violates constitutional duties. Treaty 5 nations object, and some first nations say that the MMF participation in government oversteps jurisdiction.\n\n I could keep reading the list, but basically I want to ask this of my fellow MP: What needs to change? It seems as though a lot needs to change. What should we be worrying about when there is so much dissent against the bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300884","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is very concerning when a bill such as this one comes forward and there is so much dissent against it, yet government representatives, MPs, are wondering why we are bringing forward concerns. That is definitely why we are here.\n\n Again, there have been first nations and Métis governments raising concerns, including the Dakota nation, arguing that a failure to consult violates const","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e961689f55c7753ea5386791458080d3ba92a305ab561fad952764d29370fff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8f4c32807696f0e1c5842fdc99a0426bf01e58f1f5f0e305356bd7e3d9b012dc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1370bbb068293e8f9c2593cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300885,"date":"2026-04-23T00:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to speak about the state of our Canadian economy. Let me first state that the entrepreneurial spirit of Canadians will never dim. As someone who came to Canada to help build businesses, I know how thriving an economy this country can have. In 2014, newspapers around the world declared that the middle class in Canada had surpassed that of the United States.\n\n Fast-forward to today and the median household income in Canada is thousands of dollars less in real dollars than in the United States. Even the poorest American states, like Alabama, now have a higher GDP than our richest provinces. Among Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the U.K. and the U.S., the Liberal government now oversees the highest household debt, the most unaffordable housing and the highest food price inflation in the entire G7. \n\nThere is no other country where my colleagues and I would rather live, work or start a business than in Canada. I know that. However, Parliament should not be a place where we sugar-coat uncomfortable facts or try to drive reality away with rhetoric. As a former small business owner, I was horrified to see the CFIB's most recent report. Fifty-five per cent of small business operators would not recommend starting a small business. According to that report, Canada is \"in an entrepreneurial drought\".\n\nSince 2024, more people have been shutting down small businesses than starting them. We all need to buy more locally, but we also need the economic conditions for local businesses to thrive. Canada is losing economic potential in industries of the future, such as AI, robotics and fintech. Canadians are founding new companies in these sectors, but they are founding them south of the border. \n\nStatistics Canada shows that net emigration, those who are leaving Canada, just hit an all-time peak. Canadian emigrants are predominantly young professionals, with 67% aged 20 to 44.\n\n According to the Leaders Fund, nearly half of Canadian founders or entrepreneurs who raised $1 million in 2024 were based in the United States, versus one-third who were based in Canada, including other nations. Nearly 70% of Canadian founders are starting companies elsewhere. A decade ago, 70% of Canadian founders were founding companies in Canada. Canadians with ambition are seeing their future horizons narrowed here at home.\n\nWith my time remaining, I ask my colleague this: Given the support for the Liberals' economic plan, by what year will these cross-border gaps in real income and net emigration shrink instead of grow?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300885","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to speak about the state of our Canadian economy. Let me first state that the entrepreneurial spirit of Canadians will never dim. As someone who came to Canada to help build businesses, I know how thriving an economy this country can have. In 2014, newspapers around the world declared that the middle class in Canada had surpassed that of the United States.\n\n Fast-forwar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9e55571b34d3a60f8d262d948e40a1365e6be0b37355f374353a744f895d9afa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["279aacdec00ed7448826e68909ee28ea425bf29a21f29b5731fcb43117759007"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-599ebe4698f02bf26a06e9a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300886,"date":"2026-04-23T00:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Unfortunately, Mr. Speaker, the member did not listen to my question. It is about entrepreneurs leaving Canada because they cannot seem to make it here.\n\nAll members of the House find the behaviour of the President of the United States insulting. Our sovereignty is non-negotiable, and we will not be held to ransom. At the same time, though, our reliance on the United States is imperative at this point, especially in a riding like mine that has six border crossings. For example, in communities like Grand Forks, north-to-south trade is embedded in the rail line that goes directly from the Interfor mill to U.S. customs.\n\nWe are reliant on the United States, and given that the Prime Minister called these kinds of ties a weakness, can the member opposite explain what this means for local communities in my riding, like Grand Forks, and the 2.6 million Canadian jobs that depend on U.S. trade?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300886","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Unfortunately, Mr. Speaker, the member did not listen to my question. It is about entrepreneurs leaving Canada because they cannot seem to make it here.\n\nAll members of the House find the behaviour of the President of the United States insulting. Our sovereignty is non-negotiable, and we will not be held to ransom. At the same time, though, our reliance on the United States is imperative at this p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9f4379400673139052874f795e67fe965f0d91a9e365eb6387e8993c385bb97b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e076b740f60da9f0954bc5738ab25a7edb76370c39a1f12fbe97e4483aacf927"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a4e8bfd5041581c6a8271f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115734,"date":"2026-04-23T20:45:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you, Chair. My first questions are for Ms. Donaldson. Thank you so much for being here today. You were quoted last week in a BNN Bloomberg article entitled \"Why Canada's health care system is eyeing the global helium shortage closely\". Helium is vital for its use in MRI scans, and there's no hospital in the country that can go without medical imaging. Shipping constraints through the Strait of Hormuz and damage to helium production facilities in Qatar have essentially cut off one-third of the world's helium supply. You told Bloomberg, \"There is no system-wide shortage\", yet you said that there seem to be \"targeted pressures\". This is now the fifth worldwide helium shortage in two decades. My question is twofold. What are those \"targeted pressures\" you mentioned, and, if the conflict in the Middle East persists, how long will it take for Canada to see shortages of helium?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115734","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. My first questions are for Ms. Donaldson. Thank you so much for being here today. You were quoted last week in a BNN Bloomberg article entitled \"Why Canada's health care system is eyeing the global helium shortage closely\". Helium is vital for its use in MRI scans, and there's no hospital in the country that can go without medical imaging. Shipping constraints through the Strait ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","label":"Gases"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","label":"Gases","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["56e3ac43e57a32274f211529a04bcc5696ded9bf063cb612713535106ab8ea1d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9cdffe30d234931c6b0ef015bb2392f75e66a1a852c7ac56f6230b5df0ab36be"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5f37d83c0740665580dcd44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115735,"date":"2026-04-23T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"What you are saying is that at this point there hasn't been a noticeable change in the availability of helium for medical imaging, but this could change in the near future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115735","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What you are saying is that at this point there hasn't been a noticeable change in the availability of helium for medical imaging, but this could change in the near future.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","label":"Gases","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef8e6c5194c984f7ae10262c1035194d8e6e19c0b5c9249333e71b037c82a35a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-267d6969b2dd82ba2452f7ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115736,"date":"2026-04-23T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Canada has the world's fifth-largest helium resources, estimated at seven billion cubic feet. However, we have no liquidation facilities in Canada, so we are completely reliant on shipping helium to the United States. Provinces like Alberta and Saskatchewan want to change this, but federal taxes and red tape are limiting companies' willingness to invest in liquidation plants. Would having helium liquidation plants help to end our reliance on Qatar and the United States for medical helium? Also, do you support federal tax changes to make that happen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115736","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Canada has the world's fifth-largest helium resources, estimated at seven billion cubic feet. However, we have no liquidation facilities in Canada, so we are completely reliant on shipping helium to the United States. Provinces like Alberta and Saskatchewan want to change this, but federal taxes and red tape are limiting companies' willingness to invest in liquidation plants. Would having helium l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288316","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288316","label":"Plants","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["465247f018cfa2b3634fd496348128a7e4fb50d4039e75419bf78fe78faa2276"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-476e10c2162d9200ca13e589","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115737,"date":"2026-04-23T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you. My next question is for Glenn Thibeault. Mr. Thibeault, Canada's Drug Agency recently recommended that public health plans should cover Mounjaro for type 2 diabetes. Mounjaro is like Ozempic in that it's being used as a weight-loss drug in other countries. We know that generic forms of Ozempic are currently under review as well. What challenges should we be aware of, on behalf of the diabetic community's access to the supply of Mounjaro and Ozempic, if these drugs inevitably become used more for weight loss than diabetes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44236","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diabetes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115737","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. My next question is for Glenn Thibeault. Mr. Thibeault, Canada's Drug Agency recently recommended that public health plans should cover Mounjaro for type 2 diabetes. Mounjaro is like Ozempic in that it's being used as a weight-loss drug in other countries. We know that generic forms of Ozempic are currently under review as well. What challenges should we be aware of, on behalf of the di","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44236","label":"Diabetes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44236","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diabetes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44236","label":"Diabetes","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["26b47a00c3b1a5dd6bed7778a5ba0d0f063fa165c2fa045d9c26acc57c7b1ff8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44236","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diabetes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1c99242b7c57c0cdcc5993dd785490524427a9fd5c4ce595c9285be7cfbf1775"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44236","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diabetes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44236","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diabetes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44236","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33a8075c19ff40abe31e0483","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115738,"date":"2026-04-23T20:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Would you say that you're more worried about them being sent to other countries, as opposed to being used as weight loss drugs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115738","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Would you say that you're more worried about them being sent to other countries, as opposed to being used as weight loss drugs?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7cfe62f5da91192d4a2c1432947e2a250b316e40456c8e2c8bbbaed97fd6ae2b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35cf319d1f4faf05b23e3258","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115739,"date":"2026-04-23T20:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115739","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ecb1e59be9d240b32bde514","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115740,"date":"2026-04-23T22:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Could I have clarification, Chair? Did you read that there is no vote?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115740","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Could I have clarification, Chair? Did you read that there is no vote?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7c4f8c808f18f94dedf7eb8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115741,"date":"2026-04-23T22:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I had my hand up first.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115741","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I had my hand up first.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc568631e7fe43e174b43759","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115742,"date":"2026-04-23T22:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I put my hand up first.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115742","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I put my hand up first.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67ff5da664eb36e5b0e9f622","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115743,"date":"2026-04-23T22:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Chair, I have a point of order. I don't think this—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115743","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Chair, I have a point of order. I don't think this—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5fa87cbaf8ff73619f3fefcd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115744,"date":"2026-04-23T22:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"They're not respecting your time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115744","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"They're not respecting your time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc0b0abe82b444beb1aa4217","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115745,"date":"2026-04-23T22:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"They're taking advantage of your time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115745","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"They're taking advantage of your time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-986e80dd87e47f788df04d99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115746,"date":"2026-04-23T22:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"She's not respecting your time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115746","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"She's not respecting your time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fcec0af8de1c61a3110cc10c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115747,"date":"2026-04-23T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Chair, there's a—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115747","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Chair, there's a—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9cfff7d0d9f2011bd941885","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115748,"date":"2026-04-23T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"This is a violation of his rights as a member.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115748","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This is a violation of his rights as a member.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6a787ee4e66f6ba67c2b668e8bfa4145686348d1650d3c671aab462629aff49"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc01044f7fcd220a4657a11d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115749,"date":"2026-04-23T22:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115749","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8642c56aa7075cf525a24662","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115750,"date":"2026-04-23T22:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Yes. I am speaking to the motion of MP Mazier, in which we have an order for papers having to do with the $300-million PrescribeIT scandal. I'm really surprised that the Liberal members are not supporting it, because they have supported bringing in representatives from PrescribeIT and Canada Health Infoway, which was incredibly supportive. Representatives of all parties here voted unanimously to bring in representatives from those organizations next week. If you look back at the debate, they agreed that something was happening that was not being revealed and that Canadians had been ripped off for $300 million. I do not understand why they wouldn't want to get the paperwork necessary to prove that the $300 million was misspent. That's all we're asking for. I'm sure the Liberal members want to see the proof, just as they want to talk to members of those organizations and find out what really happened. I'm sure that the next Liberal member who speaks will speak directly to the $300-million rip-off of Canadian taxpayers; otherwise, they will be called to task. Canadians will want to know why they are filibustering when we need to find out more about this scandal. I really look forward to hearing the next Liberal member sitting here describe to Canadians tonight why they do not want Canadians, along with the MPs who represent them from across the country, to see the paperwork that will prove there was wrongdoing. I really look forward to hearing why these Liberal members do not want to see proof of this scandal.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115750","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes. I am speaking to the motion of MP Mazier, in which we have an order for papers having to do with the $300-million PrescribeIT scandal. I'm really surprised that the Liberal members are not supporting it, because they have supported bringing in representatives from PrescribeIT and Canada Health Infoway, which was incredibly supportive. Representatives of all parties here voted unanimously to b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4cfc933e2317d6058ac6e76f665a7918e5a1ef21c68bf0287ce45514d0285e4b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c64309a2e56bc17c25f059ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300875,"date":"2026-04-24T16:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government spent almost $300 million on a national prescribing software that filled less than 5% of all prescriptions. Now it has cancelled it entirely, yet 85% of the technology used is in the private hands of Telus Health. That is the definition of wasteful spending of tax dollars.\n\nWill the health minister explain to Canadians how she wasted $300 million on PrescribeIT?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300875","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government spent almost $300 million on a national prescribing software that filled less than 5% of all prescriptions. Now it has cancelled it entirely, yet 85% of the technology used is in the private hands of Telus Health. That is the definition of wasteful spending of tax dollars.\n\nWill the health minister explain to Canadians how she wasted $300 million on PrescribeIT?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["baea559707f6a879efaced33ece00d190487aabff8c44e2268250fdb6805bd1b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["554c47d2bb00d761250fc64b179b3de5e50662ed82618edadde145ce3015b07c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ef1d0563d9af654575811d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300876,"date":"2026-04-24T16:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if a private sector staff employee wasted $300 million, they would be fired, but the Liberals have fired no one for their PrescribeIT disaster. I questioned the CEO responsible. He would not say where things went wrong. He even refused to say how much taxpayers paid him.\n\nWhy is the minister hiding the truth on this $300-million boondoggle?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300876","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if a private sector staff employee wasted $300 million, they would be fired, but the Liberals have fired no one for their PrescribeIT disaster. I questioned the CEO responsible. He would not say where things went wrong. He even refused to say how much taxpayers paid him.\n\nWhy is the minister hiding the truth on this $300-million boondoggle?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dcd5147b3e6d96c26512c300046dcff3d5c0fb8525f1f73500fac41504ffd060"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1dd537af76d2bfe6cdded8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300877,"date":"2026-04-24T17:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-25, an act to amend the Canada Elections Act. Our Elections Act is among the most important laws we have as a nation, as it sets out the rules and procedures for our democracy to function. All members of the House believe in democracy, of course. It is how we all ended up here. However, any time measures are brought forward that would change our laws, this could change how we vote and whom we can vote for, and the proposed measures must be considered with a microscope. Any proposed changes to how an election would operate must be considered with strict consideration to make sure the rules of the games would not be stacked in the favour of the party in power.\n\nWe only need to look around the globe to see nations where democratic decline has started because free and fair elections have been watered down by legislative majorities. Canada and many of our allies have avoided this, but the decline of democracy can come swiftly. What once started in a forum in ancient Greece largely disappeared for more than a millennium. Democracy is not a natural occurrence. It must always be reasserted, and changes made to it must be agreed to among the largest possible number of parties and citizens.\n\nGiven that the House now has a Liberal majority government constructed behind closed doors instead of at the ballot box, extra consideration is needed. The proposed changes that are before us could now be passed by one party alone, changing how our elections would be conducted. I know that the minister said in a minority government that he wanted to have consensus support for legislation amending the Canada Elections Act, and he expressed an openness to entertaining supporting other parties' amendments. I hope he keeps his word on this and trusts that members on this side of the House are working in good faith to possibly make further changes.\n\nFor the most part, I think the bill contains many welcome proposed changes, though many are long overdue. Other areas will require careful study by my colleagues in committee.\n\nFor the people watching at home, I will explain that the legislation would make the following changes. First, the bill contains measures to counter foreign interference in our elections, as well as in nomination and leadership contests. Foreign entities would be banned from contributing to third parties at all. Foreign funding would be barred from leadership contests. Also closed would be contributions made anonymously, and funding channels such as money orders or cryptocurrency would be traced. After years of delays by the Liberal government, I am pleased that this would finally be addressed.\n\nAdditionally, the bill would create several new offences and extend existing offences under the act to leadership and nomination contests. The bill would give significant new powers to the commissioner of Canada elections to undertake investigations and to enforce the act, among other measures.\n\nLast, the bill includes welcome measures to counter the disruptive and anti-democratic activities of the so-called longest ballot committee. Under the act as it stands, a candidate must obtain 100 signatures from electors in a riding in order to get their name on the ballot.\n\nThe longest ballot committee, however, identified that the same pool of 100 voters could sign the nomination forms of hundreds of protest candidates who were seeking to get their name on the ballot, even if few or any of them were from the riding. This is clearly an abuse of the Canada Elections Act, insofar as the purpose of that section is to require that a candidate have the support of at least 100 electors, not that the same 100 voters can flood the ballot with an endless list of candidates. It is a low threshold but a threshold nonetheless.\n\nThis point is of great importance because it does touch upon the issue of protests. Protests are in the blood of any democratic system. No country can call itself free if it does not allow for protests. I appreciate that the members of the longest ballot committee wish to make their case for changes to our election system. Canada has a long legal tradition that does not prescribe how these protests should be done. What one person may think is serious, another may feel is frivolous. The law does not discriminate, however.\n\nProtest candidates also have a long tradition in Canada and other democracies. British Columbians still remember the Marijuana Party of Canada. Others will remember the Rhinoceros Party of Canada, which campaigned on jokes. John Turmel is probably the most famous candidate, having run in 112 elections between 1979 and 2024, never once elected and yet never forgotten. In some ways, his persistence is a symbol of our democracy itself.\n\n However, it is not a universal right to subject other Canadians to protests. We are allowed a million ways, for example, to protest at an airport. We are even allowed to run for election to protest an airport. What we are not allowed to do is to stand on the runway and block the plane. \n\nThe longest ballot committee chose to exploit a loophole in the Elections Act to fill ballots with hundreds of candidates, none of whom had any connection to the riding where an election was being held. This strikes against the principle of local representation. As a result of its actions, the metre-long ballots that were printed for voters were enormously burdensome. Other ridings chose to make ballots write-in only, which limited voters' ability to consider their candidate in the voting booth.\n\n If the longest ballot committee wishes to protest our voting system, that is fine. It is not fine to disrupt the ballots for citizens in ridings across the country with long lists of people who do not live there and do not intend to represent them. It also strikes against some of this country's strongest democracy supporters, such as the volunteers who take time every election to assist in the election process with Elections Canada. Forcing them to count enormously long ballots deep into the night is wrong. They give their time freely, with no reward, to ensure our elections are conducted fairly. They are heroes of democracy whom I know every MP in the House respects enormously. We literally cannot have elections without them.\n\n The changes that would be made here to limit the longest ballot committee are simple and fair and will leave a wide amount of space for protest candidates to continue. The amendments brought forward would require that electors sign only one candidate nomination form, as well as that an official agent act for only one candidate per riding. This is good for candidates, voters, election volunteers and even protesters.\n\n As I said previously, I look forward to seeing the bill go forward to committee for further study and possible amendments from all parties. I ask that my Liberal colleagues do not look to pass this legislation unilaterally and operate with an open mind to good ideas.\n\n Lastly, given this is on the subject of elections, it has been almost a year since I was elected myself as the member of Parliament for Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay. On this one-year anniversary, I would like to thank all the residents, whether they voted for me or for others, for granting me the honour of my life, to serve them in our nation's Parliament. \n\nOver the past year, I have come to know the distinct character of this vast region, from the vineyards and beaches of the Okanagan to the mountains and valleys of the Similkameen, the forests and rivers of Boundary Country and the alpine landscapes of West Kootenay. Each community is unique, with its own needs and challenges, and I will work hard to ensure those voices are heard here in Ottawa.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300877","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-25, an act to amend the Canada Elections Act. Our Elections Act is among the most important laws we have as a nation, as it sets out the rules and procedures for our democracy to function. All members of the House believe in democracy, of course. It is how we all ended up here. However, any time measures are brought forward that would change our laws, this co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2390113a5d6cc0daf3de40d88f6940f199162248c5e62112078738b23a193377"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98cf8341220c2fd589eed65676911945b565e4adceb719a0edeb629f0791904c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f2bc518ec99c2e1b7ee8237","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300878,"date":"2026-04-24T17:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am so glad that my colleague and the rest of the cohort here are going to be working on this collaboratively. It is very important. Canadians are watching right now.\n\nOn virtual voting, we would need to make sure that it is fail-safe and that Canadians feel it could not be tampered with. Are we at that point, where they would feel secure with virtual voting? I do not think we are at that point, but I am sure someday soon we will be.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300878","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am so glad that my colleague and the rest of the cohort here are going to be working on this collaboratively. It is very important. Canadians are watching right now.\n\nOn virtual voting, we would need to make sure that it is fail-safe and that Canadians feel it could not be tampered with. Are we at that point, where they would feel secure with virtual voting? I do not think we are at","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b94e98235ba6c2514037f0a118a4344a1ff4d05ea7962b8c34991fd40650502b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-692d4a1a0713c62b4e964e6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300879,"date":"2026-04-24T17:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think there are a lot of issues we need to talk about in committee concerning elections and making sure they are safe, and donations.\n\nThere are ridings like mine that are massive. I am given a certain amount to service my communities and the residents, and also for the election, and in donations, but I will say that smaller ridings have it a lot easier. We have to remember that there are many ridings in Canada where the amount we are allowed to spend is pretty difficult when we look at how big some of them are. I think we should discuss this at committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300879","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think there are a lot of issues we need to talk about in committee concerning elections and making sure they are safe, and donations.\n\nThere are ridings like mine that are massive. I am given a certain amount to service my communities and the residents, and also for the election, and in donations, but I will say that smaller ridings have it a lot easier. We have to remember that the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5239320e3282393824f669eafc3ea4780a319f3f415dd59b8040fb406a8538bf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3161585161f7a678bebce074a852a6648b92436f6494b3c95107494ab721577"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-712b8561979598dd4d629229","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300880,"date":"2026-04-24T17:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think quite a bit needs to be discussed at the committee level, and I look forward to our party collaborating with all parties on this.\n\nI think there should be a discussion, and not everyone agrees with me on this, of course, on whether someone needs to be a citizen to vote in the nomination process. I think it is a really interesting and important issue that should be discussed, and voted on also, because obviously, it does affect elections.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300880","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think quite a bit needs to be discussed at the committee level, and I look forward to our party collaborating with all parties on this.\n\nI think there should be a discussion, and not everyone agrees with me on this, of course, on whether someone needs to be a citizen to vote in the nomination process. I think it is a really interesting and important issue that should be discussed, a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["79b7e9f4bacec13ec804e085f1eb62559fc91f0b476a16d246b7b68bd2c67774"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a0905d5ee2dece5173a440f77b4ebc1ff910b9a9897dd6fffeb2274149853e5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8e5f569947437cb6679c217","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300881,"date":"2026-04-24T18:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is a really important subject. One thing the member touched on, and I just wanted to ask his opinion on this further, is that we are considering changes so that during an election a financial agent could only work for one party at a time. I want to know what he thought about that.\n\nIt is getting tougher to find financial agents because of the red tape and the complications. It is a really big job to volunteer for. Does the member agree that during an election a financial agent should only work for one party?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300881","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is a really important subject. One thing the member touched on, and I just wanted to ask his opinion on this further, is that we are considering changes so that during an election a financial agent could only work for one party at a time. I want to know what he thought about that.\n\nIt is getting tougher to find financial agents because of the red tape and the complications. It is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb6c1db6fc527f8f2843079ebce4c3d58b67213a6e5d8c74e2d9d9c5b2463fdb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4fe635ee766c4882a649f6df89338b1605b2df33d6951c3089e990c9b037848"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ab21502f79ca2f7e9992138","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300882,"date":"2026-04-24T18:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. During question period today, in response to my question on the $300 million the government spent on PrescribeIT, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Health stated, \"our new government has decided to end the program.\" However, just three days ago, Canada Health Infoway's CEO was asked directly in—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300882","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. During question period today, in response to my question on the $300 million the government spent on PrescribeIT, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Health stated, \"our new government has decided to end the program.\" However, just three days ago, Canada Health Infoway's CEO was asked directly in—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9cf177877778231a81acb9e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726459,"date":"2026-04-27T20:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians deserve accountability, as $300 million was spent on PrescribeIT to replace pharmacy fax machines, with nothing to show for it. Liberal obstruction at committee has prevented Canadians from finding out where the money went. That is enough. We need a full investigation.\n\nWill the Minister of Health agree to our call for the non-partisan Auditor General of Canada to investigate this $300-million boondoggle?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726459","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians deserve accountability, as $300 million was spent on PrescribeIT to replace pharmacy fax machines, with nothing to show for it. Liberal obstruction at committee has prevented Canadians from finding out where the money went. That is enough. We need a full investigation.\n\nWill the Minister of Health agree to our call for the non-partisan Auditor General of Canada to investigat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7d63d0e5a89b884cd9b8bac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115751,"date":"2026-04-28T17:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you, and congratulations, Chair. Really, my colleague Mr. Mazier said it all. We're looking for information. It was $350 million, and we're not sure where it went. Let's get the experts in here. The witnesses we had before us weren't able to answer questions. We're here to represent our constituents and Canadians, so let's find out what we don't know—which seems to be a lot. As I said, let's get these guys in here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115751","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, and congratulations, Chair. Really, my colleague Mr. Mazier said it all. We're looking for information. It was $350 million, and we're not sure where it went. Let's get the experts in here. The witnesses we had before us weren't able to answer questions. We're here to represent our constituents and Canadians, so let's find out what we don't know—which seems to be a lot. As I said, let's","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eed317818764c40e03fbce4f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726445,"date":"2026-04-29T23:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to address the taxes that residents in my community pay every single day, specifically gas taxes.\n\n I have requested this opportunity to speak in light of the Minister of Veteran Affairs' recent response to my question on April 14. Her response to my question on these gas taxes was as follows: \n\nBritish Columbians are happy to hear that...we are making a reduction in fuel costs from now until Labour Day. British Columbians are going to use that to go and enjoy our country as they can this summer. Maybe they will also combine that with the Canada Strong pass as they go and explore this wonderful country.\n\n The Liberal minister seems to be suggesting that the purpose of gas tax relief is to encourage more people to take a vacation or to go camping. As fellow British Columbians, she and I agree that our beautiful province certainly is a place families should explore, but it is not the main reason residents in my communities fill up their cars, trucks, vans or SUVs.\n\n A family in Hedley does it to get to the grocery store or a hockey practice. A senior in Rock Creek fills up to attend medical appointments or check in with friends. A forestry worker in Christina Lake needs fuel to get to work and then to get home safely. \n\nDriving is a fact of life for tens of thousands of residents in my community. That is not to mention the hauling, the transporting or the towing that empties our tanks even faster. Subways, electric buses and public bicycles, which I often hear Liberals talk about, are not available in the communities I serve. A job in the forestry, mining or agriculture sector does not just happen right down the street. It takes a lot of gas to get rural school buses going or to get essentials to rural supermarkets, not just in the spring or summer, but in the autumn and winter. That is why it is now costing a lot more.\n\nHigher gas prices truly punish rural communities. That is why Conservatives are offering a full-year gas tax relief plan with zero federal tax on gas and diesel for the rest of 2026, paid for by ending Liberal spending on the gun buyback program, consulting fees and wasteful foreign aid. Our plan would eliminate the fuel excise tax, 10¢ a litre; the clean fuel standard, seven cents; and GST, eight cents, to save every driver 25¢ a litre. This would not just be savings at the gas station as people would also save when they buy an item that has to be shipped to our shelves, where higher transport costs mean bigger receipts.\n\nThe Liberal plan offers no excise tax on gas until Labour Day. Presumably, that is when Canadians will stop camping. Even now, with the Liberal plan in effect, Castanet reports that \"prices at the pumps soared to their highest levels in years\" today in the Okanagan, rising roughly 30¢ a litre from just the night earlier. In my home community of Penticton, every gas station today has it above $1.90 a litre.\n\n My question to the government is as follows: Given these sudden and shocking increases and the instability in the Middle East, why does the member think Canadians will not need gas tax relief past Labour Day?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726445","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to address the taxes that residents in my community pay every single day, specifically gas taxes.\n\n I have requested this opportunity to speak in light of the Minister of Veteran Affairs' recent response to my question on April 14. Her response to my question on these gas taxes was as follows: \n\nBritish Columbians are happy to hear that...we are making a reduction in fu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f94eb2bdfb6db9c1d361145e61a5103ba956217bf0b20572f399764e648928be"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4af8a3d79f6b2a9a1e5ef2ee4fa247c027c84fe74bbbbaca4cdb0bf7ce0f656b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31dc7d607ee86532c033babe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726447,"date":"2026-04-29T23:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we agree that recent gas price hikes were helped by the war in Iran, but will that be over by Labour Day, as the Liberals' policy suggests? Even if the U.S. and Iran ended the war tomorrow, the Pentagon has said it would take up to six months to fully clear sea mines from the Strait of Hormuz to restore shipping. That is not to mention the damage to oil and gas infrastructure hammered by missile attacks. \n\nConservatives believe it is more prudent to provide Canadians with higher, longer-lasting relief at the pump, given the uncertainty abroad. Nations like Australia, Spain and Ireland all cut their taxes more than Canada has in response. On average, Americans currently pay less at the pump.\n\nWill the government take note of our Conservative plan and other plans abroad and cut the tax on gas for longer than just the summer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726447","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we agree that recent gas price hikes were helped by the war in Iran, but will that be over by Labour Day, as the Liberals' policy suggests? Even if the U.S. and Iran ended the war tomorrow, the Pentagon has said it would take up to six months to fully clear sea mines from the Strait of Hormuz to restore shipping. That is not to mention the damage to oil and gas infrastructure hammered","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cf8eb7446fc9c6f11a3166e9d103540eabc7f2aef40529cb3c86c3c2e8cfdd6e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98c76a702d49571ee098d9f37ec9829d9dc53ff6d7939fb8f10027f2b728f081"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6eff83d7633cb48843b61d40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115648,"date":"2026-04-30T16:45:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"CIIT","text":"Thank you. My first question is for Mr. Fulton. As an MP who represents many ranchers in Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, I agree with the intention of the study because I want to see more Pacific beef exports, and so do my ranchers. In fact, they'd like more markets in general, of course. We'd like to focus on more Asian markets. Obviously, those markets come under a lot of competition from Australian beef, New Zealand beef and American beef. Canadian beef producers want to keep and eventually grow our foothold in the Japanese market or in Asian markets. What are the chief barriers that you see limiting Canada from bolstering these export markets?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115648","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. My first question is for Mr. Fulton. As an MP who represents many ranchers in Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, I agree with the intention of the study because I want to see more Pacific beef exports, and so do my ranchers. In fact, they'd like more markets in general, of course. We'd like to focus on more Asian markets. Obviously, those markets come under a lot of competition f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1314eeafe59ef660860fdfe0d3f8dcea3fab1005dd5b15032d2754156369cbd6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0fcfafa3168357479b47228010e9e2131c93ec5a387eae1f97db65b60575b61"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b31d6995cb4523a8eafd5ab0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115649,"date":"2026-04-30T16:50:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"CIIT","text":"That's really good news. You've been to my area of the world and know we have six border crossings with the United States. Even though we need to open up these markets, it's extremely important that we continue to trade with the United States. In fact, we need that trade with the United States. You understand, also, the difficulties with transportation and getting products to market. What is the level of investment needed in terms of rail capacity, port fees or storage for meat exports in western Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115649","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's really good news. You've been to my area of the world and know we have six border crossings with the United States. Even though we need to open up these markets, it's extremely important that we continue to trade with the United States. In fact, we need that trade with the United States. You understand, also, the difficulties with transportation and getting products to market. What is the l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e88dcbd4cf621023ffbfd4a75d46b6a9ae344ca1afcc5847c0170caed8fd9b6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14cf3c5c4e99f38d93a34c3b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115650,"date":"2026-04-30T16:50:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"CIIT","text":"That is really important information. Thank you for bringing that forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115650","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That is really important information. Thank you for bringing that forward.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9556b52a4b187187ae4212ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115651,"date":"2026-04-30T17:20:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"CIIT","text":"Thank you very much. Mr. Nighbor, we have been more than a decade without a softwood lumber agreement. It's important to diversify, I think we all agree, but in my riding, Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, we've already seen shift changes and job losses. My riding has six border crossings to the United States that are vital for the historical U.S. trade that we depend on. If we're looking to hurry on trade with Japan and other Asian markets, what's the pace we need to move? How many mills do you expect might not be able to hang on for another year, two years or three years? Please don't sugar-coat it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115651","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Mr. Nighbor, we have been more than a decade without a softwood lumber agreement. It's important to diversify, I think we all agree, but in my riding, Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, we've already seen shift changes and job losses. My riding has six border crossings to the United States that are vital for the historical U.S. trade that we depend on. If we're looking ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33d43962e3ff4924500f4cb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115652,"date":"2026-04-30T17:20:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"CIIT","text":"Excellent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115652","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Excellent.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ed3932520cc5b4b96c9f664","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115653,"date":"2026-04-30T17:20:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"CIIT","text":"Thank you, Mr. Nighbor. I have to interrupt you. I'm sorry. It sounds like this is a dire situation, but I need to hand over my time to my colleague. However, I'm looking forward to speaking with you more about this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115653","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Nighbor. I have to interrupt you. I'm sorry. It sounds like this is a dire situation, but I need to hand over my time to my colleague. However, I'm looking forward to speaking with you more about this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fbb87ddeab39fec42fc81eee5aca9e0ae27b95e937f5ad701753013a5c89c2d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4bd0f6cfbf55daa8c11e0149","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115752,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I believe that we called Mr. Green because he'd been there for over 10 years. It's important that we have him and the chair of the board. The board chair is who was summoned. I believe that was the intent, no matter what it says. I believe that was the intent of the motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115752","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I believe that we called Mr. Green because he'd been there for over 10 years. It's important that we have him and the chair of the board. The board chair is who was summoned. I believe that was the intent, no matter what it says. I believe that was the intent of the motion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e96f06244becd4fa5e804424","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115753,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I just want to repeat that that was the intent of the motion. I think that's the most important part of what's happening.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115753","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I just want to repeat that that was the intent of the motion. I think that's the most important part of what's happening.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","label":"Dance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e68727fd8eb64c65d5623da477cafbd9247516fb4be4d1df5a640fffbd6952ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f438b0db3d29fd4d5327723b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115754,"date":"2026-04-30T20:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I have a point of order. I believe, after what happened in our last meeting, that Mr. Bailey might be worried that he might be silenced in the middle of the procedure here if there's something that the Liberal members don't want the public to hear.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115754","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a point of order. I believe, after what happened in our last meeting, that Mr. Bailey might be worried that he might be silenced in the middle of the procedure here if there's something that the Liberal members don't want the public to hear.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["753b7aa18b885bc1f86d020d58a6c206dbf503004a7acf5eeb3798c1cd5d03f3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2944f2ae0664d377f8863fa0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115755,"date":"2026-04-30T21:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Following up on that, I want to support the point that when we as a committee ask for information and transparency, we should receive information or documents. There are many documents that we have ordered as a committee that we have not yet received, or our requests for them were voted down by our Liberal colleagues. It's important that we receive as many documents as we can so that we can let Canadians know how their dollars are being spent, particularly in health care. Obviously, from our first year as a committee, we see that we are lacking so many things in health care, such as doctors, health clinics and specialists. This is important. This committee should vote for any documents required by or asked for by a member so that we can receive them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115755","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Following up on that, I want to support the point that when we as a committee ask for information and transparency, we should receive information or documents. There are many documents that we have ordered as a committee that we have not yet received, or our requests for them were voted down by our Liberal colleagues. It's important that we receive as many documents as we can so that we can let Ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-315616a7116f9a9ee66d68d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115756,"date":"2026-04-30T21:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Mr. Kochhar, earlier today I was at the trade committee, where the president of the Canadian cattle commission described the infrastructure bottlenecks that are limiting our exports. He was concerned that there's not enough capacity or hours for CFIA's veterinarians when it comes to measures such as restricted feeder cattle from the United States getting to Canadian slaughterhouses, among other issues. We need now of all times to remain competitive. Given the intention of all parties to see more markets open up for Canadian beef and other meat products, how is CFIA going to avoid continuing to be a regulatory bottleneck to getting goods to market as we're finding increased demand?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115756","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Kochhar, earlier today I was at the trade committee, where the president of the Canadian cattle commission described the infrastructure bottlenecks that are limiting our exports. He was concerned that there's not enough capacity or hours for CFIA's veterinarians when it comes to measures such as restricted feeder cattle from the United States getting to Canadian slaughterhouses, among other is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","label":"Cattle"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","label":"Cattle","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["14efebfe1cf0473ee612caaf423d8a0922fd29539771b3a9923f70e416a92e24"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["854d5c474d001d18f069a209a2b2212c2fb8c5b11893e1158765f26c1396f0dc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b4cf34c87a07c3920189dbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115757,"date":"2026-04-30T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Mr. Kochhar, how many veterinarians has the department lost in recent years compared with how many you're recruiting? I just want a number.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115757","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Kochhar, how many veterinarians has the department lost in recent years compared with how many you're recruiting? I just want a number.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723905","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Animal research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723905","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Animal research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723905","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723905","label":"Animal research","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["77d2b05b11a8214c6bbbd30b4178740632d60c902549f74daac5e1d9e34051a3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c899c372fe0f12de3fe34ac8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115758,"date":"2026-04-30T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Mr. Kochhar, can you table with the committee how much you've collected in fines from cattle ranchers in the last fiscal year and an explanation of how the new traceability requirement will affect them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115758","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Kochhar, can you table with the committee how much you've collected in fines from cattle ranchers in the last fiscal year and an explanation of how the new traceability requirement will affect them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035757","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hunting permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035757","label":"Hunting permits","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","label":"Cattle","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b944ed28388c4434ca731ef106c9ce6795a24b4fe83b73c9092bf3ebcadc43d7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-369bb5be93a5aed289e85e29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115759,"date":"2026-04-30T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"He'll need to table it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115759","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"He'll need to table it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb4154e42a5fe47e5f4c418a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115760,"date":"2026-04-30T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Dr. Reimer, you were quoted by the CBC in April 2019 as saying about drug consumption sites, \"It certainly reduces risks of overdose, [and] connects people to the system\". We've heard a lot that these consumption sites exist within a continuum of care, but these sites, I'm sure you know—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115760","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Dr. Reimer, you were quoted by the CBC in April 2019 as saying about drug consumption sites, \"It certainly reduces risks of overdose, [and] connects people to the system\". We've heard a lot that these consumption sites exist within a continuum of care, but these sites, I'm sure you know—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bbbe4bff95bdd005a0d8519e3fa99dbf51e01750ddaf316ff234e10bc93d4317"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2290d045153a450da4177192","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115761,"date":"2026-04-30T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you for noticing that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115761","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for noticing that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-690e0b4a1f9cb12aa91923ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115762,"date":"2026-04-30T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Yes. Thank you, Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115762","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes. Thank you, Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0537d500da3c57d79a081855","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115763,"date":"2026-04-30T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Dr. Reimer, you were quoted by the CBC in April 2019 as saying that drug consumption sites \"certainly [reduce] risks of overdose, [connect] people to the system\". We've heard a lot that these consumption sites exist within a continuum of care, but I'm sure you know from your role that these sites often exist in places where recovery methods are not accessible at all, even though drugs are very available. I've been told that in my region, it would take two years for a recovery bed to open up to an addict who wanted to access it. In rural areas, this is what happens, as I'm sure you know. Do you believe in the theory of consumption sites? Do you believe that they're really working if treatment centres, detox beds and mental health supports are not accessible for recovery, especially in rural areas?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115763","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Dr. Reimer, you were quoted by the CBC in April 2019 as saying that drug consumption sites \"certainly [reduce] risks of overdose, [connect] people to the system\". We've heard a lot that these consumption sites exist within a continuum of care, but I'm sure you know from your role that these sites often exist in places where recovery methods are not accessible at all, even though drugs are very ava","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1796ef58ec63aa539cb486a330bfb8c3824b693381e10b723d8d484037659464"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3c6f037b54226e939527739333e9a088154a40cb234cf6d5be43d8b1aefb8597"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f0771a1f64a26ffe67983e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115764,"date":"2026-04-30T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Do you believe that drugs should be distributed in consumption sites if these supports are not available?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115764","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you believe that drugs should be distributed in consumption sites if these supports are not available?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ffe03f36703d9fbe95f4d7ec497e40f5f79b1af1ffef5436a6e92a47486b6a8d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9ddff936fd17736cd71b1ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115765,"date":"2026-04-30T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Yes or no, do you believe that these consumption sites should be available if no supports are available, as in many rural areas?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115765","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes or no, do you believe that these consumption sites should be available if no supports are available, as in many rural areas?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7eb23fd31e8901cbed2f9f7a5ae7dd405701a86a7f91eda760ccc12d1b206980"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d794da616fb8ccfa79ab9998","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115766,"date":"2026-04-30T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Dr. Reimer, I ask this because as a British Columbian, I can say that in the last decade we've seen more drug consumption sites and more overdose deaths. You know that, of course, in your leadership position. Advocates for these sites deny that these two numbers are connected—more overdose deaths with more consumption sites. I appreciate that the deaths aren't happening on site, but they are happening, and more often than a decade ago. As Canada's new public health officer and in your leadership position, do you see any correlation between more sites and more overdose deaths?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115766","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Dr. Reimer, I ask this because as a British Columbian, I can say that in the last decade we've seen more drug consumption sites and more overdose deaths. You know that, of course, in your leadership position. Advocates for these sites deny that these two numbers are connected—more overdose deaths with more consumption sites. I appreciate that the deaths aren't happening on site, but they are happe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e66f7cc79bd3bfd235b000a131c36e592147074b9e1c03cd8fbfd4c89b29b49"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ad3de0fc003689b5ce1efb554cffcaffdc1bcee0086e41a6cb175673250d7f7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4df894c37242439fbd36b15e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115767,"date":"2026-04-30T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Dr. Reimer, what should I tell the people in my communities, where people are dying of overdose deaths? What should I tell the people on the streets who are getting drugs off the street and want support but have no support? What should I tell them? In your new leadership position, what message do you want me to bring to them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115767","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Dr. Reimer, what should I tell the people in my communities, where people are dying of overdose deaths? What should I tell the people on the streets who are getting drugs off the street and want support but have no support? What should I tell them? In your new leadership position, what message do you want me to bring to them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdd3a005b3bc20f9b46054dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115768,"date":"2026-04-30T22:45:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Dr. Reimer, would you table your reference binder?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115768","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Dr. Reimer, would you table your reference binder?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-860f0a5757e2c33624129855","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115769,"date":"2026-04-30T22:45:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"That would be fantastic. Thank you. I'm going to cede the rest of my time to Dr. Strauss.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115769","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That would be fantastic. Thank you. I'm going to cede the rest of my time to Dr. Strauss.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["084b5d05212378e96f50e0cf87b54db422e900a7735df1c410c9aeb914e1b278"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-808e3b76e097d769e19e7c29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726438,"date":"2026-05-01T17:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, at a recent health committee, Conservatives moved a motion calling for a full investigation into the Liberals' wasteful, $300-million PrescribeIT boondoggle. The Liberals immediately responded by moving that meeting behind closed doors. As a result, under House rules, I am forbidden from telling Canadians what happened in that meeting for the next 30 years.\n\nDoes silencing MPs on committee work for 30 years show transparency from this majority Liberal government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726438","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, at a recent health committee, Conservatives moved a motion calling for a full investigation into the Liberals' wasteful, $300-million PrescribeIT boondoggle. The Liberals immediately responded by moving that meeting behind closed doors. As a result, under House rules, I am forbidden from telling Canadians what happened in that meeting for the next 30 years.\n\nDoes silencing MPs on co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["707f81235a50133f381d7be9f9da3365c0adb7a880ca691b4fc8abc412cfea43"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc0a1df30bd63f6d44a0e159","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":946032,"date":"2026-05-04T20:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Cowichan decision has left many residents across our communities concerned about their private property rights. The Liberals are now talking about how they will defend property rights in court, but they never made this argument in Cowichan before. Appeals are not do overs. They cannot raise new arguments they never argued before.\n\nHow will government lawyers argue what Liberals MPs are arguing here when they did not do so at trial?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:946032","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Cowichan decision has left many residents across our communities concerned about their private property rights. The Liberals are now talking about how they will defend property rights in court, but they never made this argument in Cowichan before. Appeals are not do overs. They cannot raise new arguments they never argued before.\n\nHow will government lawyers argue what Liberals MP","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d03d23af305e0b8a7733ac52d486f7eb65ca0c1b87cce560063df01ebcec2d6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fab60191579495bfa6670c390c26a62f643cc5f66c7ce541ce418b6a12ff760b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-527e2e4941a470e5a87997a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":946019,"date":"2026-05-05T15:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the member's comments, but what does he think about the forestry sector?\n\nThousands of jobs have been lost and businesses are closing.\n\nWhat is the status of the negotiations for the forestry sector?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:946019","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the member's comments, but what does he think about the forestry sector?\n\nThousands of jobs have been lost and businesses are closing.\n\nWhat is the status of the negotiations for the forestry sector?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3ade36ce6a129b679c51ea725a8bc7d5b1008e013f3cdcd274b5238c0e41303c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["688a49871f2512a9b5f9edeb349356ab7897125db4985d5aa37b741d25434735"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b61ff3df0124d0bc7a039f25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":946030,"date":"2026-05-05T17:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am going to focus a bit here on the forestry industry, which is not talked about a lot. Obviously, we have lost thousands of jobs in that sector.\n\nThe government talked about expanding opportunities in trade as something we definitely need to do. The Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay riding that I represent has six border crossings we depend on and have used historically for trade with the United States. With respect to the industries that are dependent on that cross-border trade, like the forest industry, what does the member think about the very little time spent in negotiations for this sector?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:946030","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am going to focus a bit here on the forestry industry, which is not talked about a lot. Obviously, we have lost thousands of jobs in that sector.\n\nThe government talked about expanding opportunities in trade as something we definitely need to do. The Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay riding that I represent has six border crossings we depend on and have used historically for ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6c1bc54084a800ca0f082ad586a46e468a296828986ce6b65f293ba2c9935ba9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0859270e5dbd018139b9804799f4795032a8de8a687b43e19d5ff2a566e638f9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-38ef0715fe5a4d2503c2b3ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115770,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Dr. Vaughan, can you resubmit those minutes without the redaction?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115770","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Dr. Vaughan, can you resubmit those minutes without the redaction?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-921829b637ac3c0115d48164","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115771,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you. I look forward to seeing that. Dr. Vaughan, Infoway is funded by taxpayers but calls itself a non-profit. You said you look at comparables for salaries. Can you name one other federally funded not-for-profit in Canada that pays its CEO nearly $900,000 a year, as you did Mr. Green?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115771","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I look forward to seeing that. Dr. Vaughan, Infoway is funded by taxpayers but calls itself a non-profit. You said you look at comparables for salaries. Can you name one other federally funded not-for-profit in Canada that pays its CEO nearly $900,000 a year, as you did Mr. Green?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1c7036daa5e5b42f47c51d970043937451ed9136d81d9c4b611259dde58966c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["632d7f3f3b476fac2e05dd2db201401a50a71c6a6dec0fae6271ce596852e58e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78d4d2e6633dc8b758a9301b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115772,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Okay. If you would actually table a few of those examples for us, that would be great, because you must have done your homework when you decided to pay him $900,000.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115772","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. If you would actually table a few of those examples for us, that would be great, because you must have done your homework when you decided to pay him $900,000.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-958be0d47daa40ef99eb23b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115773,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Dr. Vaughan, did Mr. Green sign a non-disclosure agreement prior to his termination as a CEO of Infoway?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115773","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Dr. Vaughan, did Mr. Green sign a non-disclosure agreement prior to his termination as a CEO of Infoway?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47600","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Genetically modified organisms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47600","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Genetically modified organisms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47600","label":"Genetically modified organisms","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["227faa8fd69a461a933163c89100e2fbbbc1608a9454bede85f65715e759729e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-055751ca48e5d557aaf58b25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115774,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Who are you actually discussing that with?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115774","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Who are you actually discussing that with?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-82ecaeed3e4c7f8e472af4a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115775,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Does Canada Health Infoway require all departing employees to sign a non-disclosure agreement after their departure?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115775","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does Canada Health Infoway require all departing employees to sign a non-disclosure agreement after their departure?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3256dba3a92437e625f0a0f8018551eabc692e06ce3e142ed1e59f5316043724"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a6741186c31afb9fcff0aa4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115776,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"What metrics, Dr. Vaughan, did the Infoway board use to determine Mr. Green's performance bonus of over $250,000 last year, if you were planning a change, as you said you were? You said that a change was in discussion. What were the metrics for giving him a $215,000 bonus?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115776","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What metrics, Dr. Vaughan, did the Infoway board use to determine Mr. Green's performance bonus of over $250,000 last year, if you were planning a change, as you said you were? You said that a change was in discussion. What were the metrics for giving him a $215,000 bonus?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f16b2b12b9e8089f1bab18ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115777,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"He was successful, then. Last year, you felt he was on the road to success for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115777","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"He was successful, then. Last year, you felt he was on the road to success for Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3579fe551bbaa70c4fead1e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115778,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"He succeeded last year, but he did so poorly this year that he was fired.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115778","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"He succeeded last year, but he did so poorly this year that he was fired.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3921835ea2ae7197d129712cb5e620fdd8e6751ef3f076dd37591a06dc6f46db"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa601d4994e7e8015ca191db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115779,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Was it a decision made after our last committee meeting?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115779","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Was it a decision made after our last committee meeting?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54751b7fcb75854584c03a4cb7bfbc61bb59fd5bf8a130cf234af63d01df74ee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-685a87c55b368c62758ba112","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115780,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"The focus was on the CEO who made over a $200,000 bonus last year but was.... I think we'll move on. Dr. Vaughan, this morning The Globe and Mail reported that in just three years, Canada Health Infoway spent over $23 million on third party consultants. These include lobbying firms and multinational IT companies. Infoway has 175 employees, so why does a taxpayer-funded organization need to hire lobbyists and consultants to outsource the work it was paid to do by the government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115780","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The focus was on the CEO who made over a $200,000 bonus last year but was.... I think we'll move on. Dr. Vaughan, this morning The Globe and Mail reported that in just three years, Canada Health Infoway spent over $23 million on third party consultants. These include lobbying firms and multinational IT companies. Infoway has 175 employees, so why does a taxpayer-funded organization need to hire lo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dee9c6e71029df0ef5f1274e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115781,"date":"2026-05-05T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Dr. Vaughan, the tendered contracts on the Canada Health Infoway site show a one-time payment of $178,500 to a numbered company, 2184103 Ontario Inc. Who owns that company, and what did Infoway buy for $178,500?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115781","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Dr. Vaughan, the tendered contracts on the Canada Health Infoway site show a one-time payment of $178,500 to a numbered company, 2184103 Ontario Inc. Who owns that company, and what did Infoway buy for $178,500?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["53f5b8b6c1bd231d0179efb216e1e3b6cc010d7a29c9d414b1d5ea7ab3c0d3cc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54e4231a4ec39c9a62b7e04a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115782,"date":"2026-05-05T21:25:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Can you table that for us? Thank you. Dr. Vaughan, the Canada Health Infoway website displays tendered contracts from only 2024 to 2026. Where's the rest of the information? Why does the website contain information from only those years?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115782","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Can you table that for us? Thank you. Dr. Vaughan, the Canada Health Infoway website displays tendered contracts from only 2024 to 2026. Where's the rest of the information? Why does the website contain information from only those years?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historic sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","label":"Historic sites","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e9adecb78ee7595325563d7aef5a993ecd082e7e14503ea1aa5e7cb806cbfb9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a94c55c90bce18f3c0fc1dee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115783,"date":"2026-05-05T22:00:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Mr. Kalra.... Is Canada Health Infoway executive vice-president Abhi Kalra holding any shares or stock options in Loblaw Companies Limited since being hired by Infoway, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115783","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Kalra.... Is Canada Health Infoway executive vice-president Abhi Kalra holding any shares or stock options in Loblaw Companies Limited since being hired by Infoway, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shares","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037106","label":"Shares","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d8df84c9af77c599204152be13ff7fcf790761ecf67e0b316672e1619319638"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe4e7a27925d568e945a492f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115784,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Am I correct that this would be part of the process of screening someone you would hire as an executive vice-president?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115784","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Am I correct that this would be part of the process of screening someone you would hire as an executive vice-president?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["496db57e82b667cfc63920d4ac1a786cbaabf0dae10bdfb3534815bce6366e1f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd8e8a5e5d8a6d5734ad3ae3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115785,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"That would be extremely important, because that person would benefit from these contracts. Could you please find out that information and table it for this committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115785","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That would be extremely important, because that person would benefit from these contracts. Could you please find out that information and table it for this committee?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["83e355d74dcd3ebb51c3fcbc307e7dbca93545d4f23ee796d071a3b5d2b67f91"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c90f14222670e340d24b77b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115786,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Dr. Vaughan, in what year was your CFO hired on an interim basis?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115786","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Dr. Vaughan, in what year was your CFO hired on an interim basis?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0cbae4d4d75fd59615e0fc8bbddcdfa75b05d6e845f51ca2d896e28bcc52fb8d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-916fcd5d162038bc13d2546f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115787,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"We know that he did work with Michael Green. Did Michael Green recommend him for the interim position of CFO?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115787","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We know that he did work with Michael Green. Did Michael Green recommend him for the interim position of CFO?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d3f15e0ce9f6015bf91e1454ae92813386d8ea152595f51e15abdd6c1825d588"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b556789bcb754f7be0497f66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115788,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Does the current CFO continue to be interim?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115788","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does the current CFO continue to be interim?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-931b8682568b7da0d14dc927","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115789,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"He's been interim since 2024. It seems unusual that someone would be interim for more than two years, especially with the number of employees you have. I'm sure you have HR people. Why would you not have gone out on a competitive process for that position?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115789","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"He's been interim since 2024. It seems unusual that someone would be interim for more than two years, especially with the number of employees you have. I'm sure you have HR people. Why would you not have gone out on a competitive process for that position?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c74d29d6d8e9f398a16e6b39ff2351ef28e8a1ee25f587d3ef1176d8033b5f6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae4db02a6502cfdbc63391b8b39286738673278a7adbfb9ed300a84f5631a910"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-629ceaa2f1286f88bf77d14e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115790,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"The new CEO will be able to decide or to help decide who the CFO should be or how the competitive process should go, but Michael Green was not able to do that on a $900,000 salary?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115790","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The new CEO will be able to decide or to help decide who the CFO should be or how the competitive process should go, but Michael Green was not able to do that on a $900,000 salary?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47600","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Genetically modified organisms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47600","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Genetically modified organisms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47600","label":"Genetically modified organisms","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5dc0ecf8a9d3206965699d2454dc566bb77ee6f3fc43e812786c4aac2634567d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78fd503566efa15e8af38adc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115791,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Can you tell me if the current CFO owns any individual shares in public companies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115791","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Can you tell me if the current CFO owns any individual shares in public companies?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["651997b11e1f73ebdf93d2034d048686fb35d924e551238a92f586ecd610137c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22ffc7a6edab0b7cea53f884","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115792,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I think it would be important for you to table that information and for the public to know that before he becomes a permanent CFO, since he's been there for two years. Can you tell me what his salary is, including bonuses?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115792","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I think it would be important for you to table that information and for the public to know that before he becomes a permanent CFO, since he's been there for two years. Can you tell me what his salary is, including bonuses?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0dafe3a60f715cba64d8e671189c8c9703d8d53dbb6a9fcf200da94d1064ee5e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a25a8b7c45381cd49744b5213713f2337a7a363315f048e1cc4f818d7df9277d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efe18c2a18294e3d33fef137","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115793,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I'd like to hear it here for the Canadian people.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115793","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to hear it here for the Canadian people.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f807400c06b0befdee18ca66a280aeb4ad8e651e881df8c42b89df85bde65eb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5782b1a02df6bd43b8ed5b75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115794,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"The CFO's salary has been publicly stated in the media?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115794","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The CFO's salary has been publicly stated in the media?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c57522848b80f372dff82ac449d810b987fbd302f36dc847987ecabb419b4afb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fcbc208f76ed8b4b902e0aac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115795,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Okay. Would you please table that immediately?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115795","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Would you please table that immediately?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fb8e58b969a2c3ab8a6217e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115796,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I have a question for Mr. El-Demerdash. Did you raise any concerns to Canada Health Infoway, the health department or the Minister of Health's office about any possible obstacles or challenges PrescribeIT could face? I think you might have mentioned earlier that you had 56 or 57 recommendations. Is that true? Did you bring forward 56 or 57 concerns?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115796","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a question for Mr. El-Demerdash. Did you raise any concerns to Canada Health Infoway, the health department or the Minister of Health's office about any possible obstacles or challenges PrescribeIT could face? I think you might have mentioned earlier that you had 56 or 57 recommendations. Is that true? Did you bring forward 56 or 57 concerns?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebe5552940f80c0f778b5444e38fe36501eb3d551a6d62f7dc66fe26a8adabb4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3e584e8d47939e60a89ce82","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115797,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"What did they do with that information?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115797","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What did they do with that information?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbde46fbb3807a0f89532b92","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115798,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Do you know if they made any changes, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115798","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do you know if they made any changes, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c71352c872b65a7bad5b6aa2f7dad7635b7195d88b1fc52aa779e460f25a71ee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20f09a870cfcaa93157301c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115799,"date":"2026-05-05T22:45:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"We're going to need to bring this information forward to the Canadian public. Unfortunately, in the last couple of weeks, we've had instances where we've had information that's been behind closed doors that won't be available to the Canadian public for 30 years. Let's not do that again. Let's get this information out. I can't support this amendment, because people want to know now, and I know every MP around this table is wondering what happened to the $300,000— A voice: It's $300 million. Helena Konanz: Yes, you're right. It's $300 million. That's crazy. It's so wrong that we have testimony and witnesses who say, \"It's okay, it's a success. We've lost $300 million, but it's a success.\" It is wrong. Let's get the health minister in here to answer questions. That's her job, and we need to get her in quickly, because again, I'm sure the media and Canadian people are going to want to know why the minister can't come in right away.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115799","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We're going to need to bring this information forward to the Canadian public. Unfortunately, in the last couple of weeks, we've had instances where we've had information that's been behind closed doors that won't be available to the Canadian public for 30 years. Let's not do that again. Let's get this information out. I can't support this amendment, because people want to know now, and I know ever","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["deb56ffbf1fe9752f835464f9e089fa0a8a176205e872e969202b09cb09c8214"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2d4ecf07ed475bc2601846c60c01ec73ffc742341e6865e7f08c311926aa0f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ba63ac3d8c2278b6d35170c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115800,"date":"2026-05-05T23:00:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I support what my colleague just said. It really is respecting her timelines, but she needs to be available for this committee, and that should be before we stop sitting for the summer. I and, I think, all Canadians would appreciate her coming to this committee and explaining what happened with PrescribeIT.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115800","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I support what my colleague just said. It really is respecting her timelines, but she needs to be available for this committee, and that should be before we stop sitting for the summer. I and, I think, all Canadians would appreciate her coming to this committee and explaining what happened with PrescribeIT.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-467dd66e0a64e8d1b8526066","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945802,"date":"2026-05-06T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians need answers on how the Liberals burned $300 million on their failed PrescribeIT program, money that could have been spent on other health care needs. Just last week, the Liberals moved to shut off the cameras at the health committee, sealing the records of that meeting for 30 years. Yesterday, the Liberals shut down the health committee to prevent the minister from testifying.\n\nWhy is the Liberals' $300‐million PrescribeIT failure being hidden from Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945802","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians need answers on how the Liberals burned $300 million on their failed PrescribeIT program, money that could have been spent on other health care needs. Just last week, the Liberals moved to shut off the cameras at the health committee, sealing the records of that meeting for 30 years. Yesterday, the Liberals shut down the health committee to prevent the minister from testifyi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["695b0d23e90ded7c3422bc6ad62a13c464a8fd7cb8e7c28c14fe2f3a638ab828"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13090ecf2f0cb9ea64675563","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945803,"date":"2026-05-06T23:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to speak about a scandal that is only growing in size, complexity and cost to taxpayers.\n\nThe Liberals' PrescribeIT was launched in 2016, promising to put every prescription in Canada into a digital system, allowing our pharmacies to move off their reliance on fax machines. At least $300 million in taxpayer dollars was spent in the following decade in pursuit of this goal. The result was complete failure. This taxpayer-funded boondoggle failed to fill even 5% of all prescriptions and cannot be shown to have replaced a single fax machine. It is now being shut down entirely, with the few partners who used it now likely to have to find someone who can reinstall a fax machine in 2026.\n\nCanada did not invent e-prescription services. Health care systems and private firms around the world have upgraded their prescription systems from fax machines to serve doctors, pharmacists and patients better. We did not have to reinvent the wheel. Only in Canada and only under the Liberal government could yet another government-funded IT project create absolutely nothing of benefit to Canadians.\n\nIt is another ArriveCAN, except with an even higher price tag for taxpayers. In the time that I have spent in the House and on the health committee, it has become apparent to me how much better $300 million could have been spent on our health care system. It could have gone toward health transfers to British Columbia, to hire dozens more doctors, nurses and specialists, especially for rural regions like mine that suffer constant closures of many of our emergency rooms for lack of staff. It could have gone toward treatment beds, to give people with addiction in my province a path to recovery.\n\nInstead, it was hundreds of millions handed off to a quasi-governmental agency, Canada Health Infoway, in partnership with Telus, with nothing to show for it and the vast majority of the IP created left in private hands rather than the public interest.\n\nThis disastrous waste of taxpayer money on the Liberals' $300-million PrescribeIT deserves a full investigation but Conservative attempts to do so have been stonewalled every step of the way. When I questioned Michael Green, the CEO in charge of the agency that oversaw PrescribeIT, Canada Health Infoway, about what went wrong, he could not provide a straight answer despite having worked on the failed Liberal program for 10 years.\n\nWhen I asked how much he was paid, he refused to answer, saying that it was in the public record, but, as his own board chair later admitted, that was a lie. Mr. Green's compensation was not public at that time. There is a reason he wanted it that way. He was paid almost $900,000 when we include the hundreds of thousands of dollars in bonuses and a taxpayer-funded car.\n\nBetween our first and last meetings on this topic, the board of Canada Health Infoway fired Mr. Green to prevent him from returning to answer questions.\n\nWas the $300 million spent on PrescribeIT a good use of taxpayer dollars, considering that it did not permanently eliminate a single fax machine?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945803","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to speak about a scandal that is only growing in size, complexity and cost to taxpayers.\n\nThe Liberals' PrescribeIT was launched in 2016, promising to put every prescription in Canada into a digital system, allowing our pharmacies to move off their reliance on fax machines. At least $300 million in taxpayer dollars was spent in the following decade in pursuit of this go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9bd60c2bc5a42f4ffeac86a18e4c35bf80527bfbb88c65c026567d2d5eda3e28"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd31b0907c63fd273f0ab57d93929fe8220a57e439a27252e74ee250e881991d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10a9d15b943eee56f28a5a33","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945804,"date":"2026-05-06T23:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what Canadians deserve is transparency. Conservatives want to get to the bottom of how $300 million of taxpayer money was wasted on this project, PrescribeIT.\n\nWhen Conservatives demanded that Mr. Green return to the committee to account for the millions of tax dollars that he had been paid for no results, the Liberals voted us down. When the Bloc moved to have the Liberal health minister appear within the next month to testify to her role in this scandal, Liberals ended our meeting entirely. When Conservatives moved to call on the Auditor General of Canada, a non-partisan official, to investigate, the Liberals moved to turn off the camera and seal the records of that committee for the next 30 years.\n\nMy question is simple: Why did the Liberals turn off the camera and seal the records of that meeting for the next 30 years?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945804","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what Canadians deserve is transparency. Conservatives want to get to the bottom of how $300 million of taxpayer money was wasted on this project, PrescribeIT.\n\nWhen Conservatives demanded that Mr. Green return to the committee to account for the millions of tax dollars that he had been paid for no results, the Liberals voted us down. When the Bloc moved to have the Liberal health mini","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02d4a68a09cdc0f35e0f4bd6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945788,"date":"2026-05-07T18:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to an issue of great concern to every British Columbian, which is the impact of the B.C. Supreme Court decision in Cowichan Tribes v. Canada and its effect on private property rights across British Columbia. \n\nIt is the first time in Canada's history that a court has declared aboriginal title over non-Crown lands, privately owned lands. There are 150 private landowners, farmers, homeowners and business owners in Richmond who discovered that their titles were now in conflict with aboriginal title designation. This is not a matter of reconciliation. It is a matter of confusion. It creates tension. It does not create a path forward. \n\nThe Business Council of British Columbia conducted a survey of its members on the current uncertainty regarding B.C. property rights and found that 98% of respondents are very concerned. They are not a little concerned, but very concerned. We have already seen financing for job-created projects, including those for indigenous communities, pull back. \n\nReconciliation remains the goal of every British Columbian I speak with, whether they have called their province home for a few years or for a few millennia. Let us not forget that our indigenous peoples own a huge swath of private property in British Columbia. They too are left in confusion by Cowichan. \n\nOur province wants to prove that the stewardship of British Columbia's many indigenous communities, both on their lands and in many projects of prosperity they are engaged in, can be a model for the nation. What we are not calling for today is for the government to appeal this decision, as it has already, and rightly, said it will do so. \n\nWhat we are asking for is that the federal government engage with British Columbians straightforwardly throughout what will likely be a long judicial process. We ask it to engage with British Columbians who are confused as to whether their private property is still theirs in full and whether their property rights, long an ancient feature of our legal traditions stretching back centuries, are still theirs. We ask it to decry those who use an error of the court to spread hate, and we seek to understand those who do not know if the home, business or property in their name will remain theirs.\n\nThe decisions of the courts will not be swift. Uncertainty will persist so long as Ottawa remains in court and Victoria remains deadlocked. A very real and local example of this uncertainty is occurring in my riding in the community of Okanagan Falls.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945788","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to an issue of great concern to every British Columbian, which is the impact of the B.C. Supreme Court decision in Cowichan Tribes v. Canada and its effect on private property rights across British Columbia. \n\nIt is the first time in Canada's history that a court has declared aboriginal title over non-Crown lands, privately owned lands. There are 150 private landowners","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["493ab0179ccea6d2392394488f91dbee7ec6e312fadc20fd7e8c72123674e245"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c5f37927cadef9edfb165e83c72f10cc54bf8e50816d6189c0d93dffeffa9052"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-94aa141702ce38511cf06aad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945791,"date":"2026-05-07T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, gas prices across Canada remain higher than they need to be, not just because of the war in Iran but because of unnecessary federal taxes. The last time a barrel of oil cost $100 was in 2014 under a Conservative government, and gas prices never reached their current levels.\n\nIn Penticton and Oliver, gas prices are now two dollars a litre, with communities like Castlegar, Grand Forks, Osoyoos and Princeton over $1.90 a litre. We need to offer real relief for longer. Our Conservative plan would scrap all federal gas taxes, the excise tax, GST and the fuel standard tax, for the rest of 2026. We would pay for this by ending Liberal waste, like their gun-grab program.\n\nUncertainty abroad does not mean Canada cannot be affordable and strong at home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945791","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, gas prices across Canada remain higher than they need to be, not just because of the war in Iran but because of unnecessary federal taxes. The last time a barrel of oil cost $100 was in 2014 under a Conservative government, and gas prices never reached their current levels.\n\nIn Penticton and Oliver, gas prices are now two dollars a litre, with communities like Castlegar, Grand Forks, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d5ac43f356d0062651f55bda045df78e9aa8c2e5a1af4b7288fe6f1ada3430e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["53ea81173608291189ff7cdd1192f88d5f38b4ca845712e068810e4bdd0f3b83"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07f0c45cdfe79d0dbaaccd3e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945792,"date":"2026-05-07T20:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a very real and local example of this growing uncertainty is occurring in my riding in the community of Okanagan Falls, whose narrow vote last year to incorporate as a municipality is now being re-evaluated as a whole community. From the decision-making powers of the town council to the municipality's actual name, uncertainty persists because of the title changes brought about by the B.C. government, which now risk serious consequences across the nation.\n\nWhen people of the community of Okanagan Falls, which is 100 years old, no longer know and are waiting to be told what the name of their community they voted to incorporate will be, that is a sign of poor consultation brought on by an error-ridden provincial government. While our motion today is focused on the federal government, I join with my local and provincial representatives in encouraging Victoria to engage fully with every resident and neighbour in the beautiful community of Okanagan Falls with respect to the future of the community.\n\n As for the government across from me, Conservatives are calling for a common-sense approach that keeps the federal government involved with British Columbians throughout the entire legal process. We are calling on the government to put private property first in the Cowichan case at the Department of Justice. Statements by Liberal MPs in the House are not the same as the direction they have provided to their public lawyers, who argued and lost in the Cowichan decision because of that.\n\n Litigation guideline number 14 from \"Attorney General of Canada's Directive on Civil Litigation Involving Indigenous Peoples\" prevented the federal government from defending property rights in the Cowichan case, as many Canadian lawyers have pointed out. This is what the Cowichan decision itself said at paragraph 2096: \"Canada initially pled extinguishment but abandoned its reliance on this defence in its amended response to civil claim filed November 22, 2018.\"\n\nWhat is called the \"principle of extinguishment\", that the Crown's creation of fee simple title supersedes historical indigenous title, was the legal argument on which Canadian governments rested their defence of private property historically, under both Liberal and Conservative attorneys general. It does not cancel any existing treaties. It simply upholds the property rights created through Canadian history, particularly in the last century of property division in British Columbia. It was our best line of defence for property rights, but the Attorney General's guidelines limited its use.\n\n The federal government itself has also created confusion on the intersection of title claims with its own Musqueam Rights Recognition Agreement, which fails to say anything definitive about fee simple property rights, a dangerous precedent going into its appeal. Until the Cowichan case is resolved, it is clear that the federal government should be negotiating the defence of private property rights into its agreements with our first nations.\n\nIt is not that first nations are trying to take private property. They are not. It is that legal agreements create precedents that could cause greater problems in the decades ahead. This creation of legal grey areas is how we got to the Cowichan decision. It should not be continued in agreements like the Musqueam agreement. Legal matters are never simply aspirational. They are law.\n\n That is why we on this side of the House are also calling for the Liberal government to publish a plan within 30 days to protect property rights for Canadians affected by the Cowichan decision and the Musqueam agreement, and appoint a special committee with the mandate to study all legal, constitutional and political steps that can be taken to protect property rights in Canada.\n\nThis should be a multi-party committee that would hold multiple meetings over the next several weeks to hear from legal experts and to develop advice to be published in an interim report by the summer, with a full report to follow later. Both sides of the House feature people of great legal talent, many of whom are indigenous and many more who are familiar with indigenous law. There is no reason they cannot provide the government with clear advice before we rise for the summer.\n\nCanada is not required in international law to pursue reconciliation. We have our own law, and our own lawmakers in the House who wish to find common ground, equal rights and shared prosperity. Section 35 of our Constitution already recognizes and affirms existing aboriginal and treaty rights of the aboriginal people of Canada.\n\nNo one pretends this framework is perfect, but it is our framework, built and improved by all Canadians. Few nations around the world maintain this kind of legal framework with indigenous peoples. It is a process of ever-greater improvement, but to maintain it we need all parties, such as the Crown, first nation leaders and everyday Canadians, who are extremely worried right now, to sit in a common understanding of how we will proceed and how we will recognize the rights of land, property and consultation.\n\nLet us maintain it as legislators of Canadian law. Setting aspirational goals aligned with UN resolutions in our laws does not serve anyone. Real Canadian law and real Canadian reconciliation can serve everyone fairly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945792","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a very real and local example of this growing uncertainty is occurring in my riding in the community of Okanagan Falls, whose narrow vote last year to incorporate as a municipality is now being re-evaluated as a whole community. From the decision-making powers of the town council to the municipality's actual name, uncertainty persists because of the title changes brought about by the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["357f45b8958c62f5152ca6f52b979a9de91e4d861dd0821f500409bf238d9c22"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["015b90dc50f2f8eee8c7e498593e2fad1fa2dbb3266c9534f3b891eae3853e3d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-645866acd0644f8752217ffd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945793,"date":"2026-05-07T20:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I said, first nation leaders, the Crown and everyday Canadians all need to sit at a table in order to proceed. What I do not understand is how the member can say there is not a problem. I know that I am getting calls and emails, and I am getting people knocking on our door wondering if they are still going to own their property in the next little while. I know that the member who just spoke is not from British Columbia, but this is a Canadian issue that needs to be addressed immediately.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945793","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I said, first nation leaders, the Crown and everyday Canadians all need to sit at a table in order to proceed. What I do not understand is how the member can say there is not a problem. I know that I am getting calls and emails, and I am getting people knocking on our door wondering if they are still going to own their property in the next little while. I know that the member who j","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa2fb2bc60768db28ba23b164e07a14a52182c37bdc9eb8751ecdc13fa2535a6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa01ba6875413ceca0afa8fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945794,"date":"2026-05-07T20:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a really good question. Liberals have shut down all communication. Everything we have tried to bring forward to committee has been shut down. I know it is not a good idea to keep pretending the issue is minor, or that somehow Conservatives are stirring the pot and making people scared. Again, how is it that the government does not realize people are scared about the future of their property rights? They are scared to develop. They are scared to invest in Canada right now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945794","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a really good question. Liberals have shut down all communication. Everything we have tried to bring forward to committee has been shut down. I know it is not a good idea to keep pretending the issue is minor, or that somehow Conservatives are stirring the pot and making people scared. Again, how is it that the government does not realize people are scared about the future of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f0b82d7a7d053367cc81fc27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945795,"date":"2026-05-07T20:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is exactly what my colleague said. The government members are burying their head in the sand, pretending this is not something that could grow into something we will not be able to address farther down the road. We need to get together, as I mentioned in my speech. There are a lot of people on all sides of the House who have great experience, legal experience and indigenous experience. We have lawyers on both sides who can look at this and make sure. We need to be leaders. We need to show people they do not need to be frightened, because we are going to do something about this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945795","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is exactly what my colleague said. The government members are burying their head in the sand, pretending this is not something that could grow into something we will not be able to address farther down the road. We need to get together, as I mentioned in my speech. There are a lot of people on all sides of the House who have great experience, legal experience and indigenous experie","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9f4ef28d7e6ea69faf8f659c92e477f8a03bb09dd6bbe7db50759250e2a86553"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80f2ff4aa83e6376f4914eec62ee7dcfe7c964ea6be6982782111d45464ab09b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f220b5eab06cfe8090427c7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":945801,"date":"2026-05-07T20:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member's question just confirms the fact that we all need to sit together. This is what the motion says. We need to sit together and talk about what our next steps are. This is a very complicated issue, and we cannot continue to pretend that it is not serious.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945801","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member's question just confirms the fact that we all need to sit together. This is what the motion says. We need to sit together and talk about what our next steps are. This is a very complicated issue, and we cannot continue to pretend that it is not serious.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a86b27597dc026cfb68b288067dcd72a7a6c6b78a8cf540dd0f9b40c0edcea15"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b508821782f0ab82b3350f36","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115801,"date":"2026-05-07T20:35:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you, Chair. My questions are for Ms. Parmar. Canada created a distinct regulatory framework for natural health products more than 20 years ago. Why was a separate framework necessary, and does it still serve an important purpose today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115801","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. My questions are for Ms. Parmar. Canada created a distinct regulatory framework for natural health products more than 20 years ago. Why was a separate framework necessary, and does it still serve an important purpose today?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","label":"Health care products"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","label":"Health care products","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b43136801298f4fb5b6ea55d25f6395626a3c3a141e50f019fd8c6a56cb8798d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c80ed8d597595f4dd7ddd2b1fabb339a2c38eb06511026d14b7ab777a509391"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43e00da41292ff2612c4f732","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115802,"date":"2026-05-07T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you for that answer. Are there other countries that we mirror ourselves after or that would be good to follow, which are doing this successfully?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115802","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for that answer. Are there other countries that we mirror ourselves after or that would be good to follow, which are doing this successfully?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["10e5c00f037fea90a2bdd7ed04ba27d856cae7b60ee7d1377ff5bf71d89e5320"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6534238c806916136394c65","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115803,"date":"2026-05-07T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I believe you referenced, in your opening statement, a growing amount of market activity occurring outside Canadian regulatory oversight. In your view, what needs to happen to close that gap, while ensuring that Canadian businesses can remain competitive?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115803","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I believe you referenced, in your opening statement, a growing amount of market activity occurring outside Canadian regulatory oversight. In your view, what needs to happen to close that gap, while ensuring that Canadian businesses can remain competitive?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9cd897477f870b7fa2cb2443ee18a1564b85ba903ba1b9ae049ca35c2db52c42"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-986f77635428bc9d55e958fd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115804,"date":"2026-05-07T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"There's $450 million in market activity that occurs outside Canadian regulatory oversight. What impact does that have on Canadian manufacturers and retailers and on investment in domestic production?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115804","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There's $450 million in market activity that occurs outside Canadian regulatory oversight. What impact does that have on Canadian manufacturers and retailers and on investment in domestic production?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66081cc77e0e86389e4a6609351ff9e0a14eb49aff3ba32a90c2157c52542f61"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0e36355359e4b0ac1a1eafa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115805,"date":"2026-05-07T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Is Health Canada aware of the growing amount of market activity occurring outside the Canadian regulatory system, and what is being done about it? We don't have a lot of time, but I imagine that's a loaded question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115805","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is Health Canada aware of the growing amount of market activity occurring outside the Canadian regulatory system, and what is being done about it? We don't have a lot of time, but I imagine that's a loaded question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f1fe1a0a3df03e686e73e28d519bdf4f60bc67f77702a38df85a629780936f9d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b1aaf9e6b9cdbc225503449","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115806,"date":"2026-05-07T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"I believe so. If this motion is passed with these amendments, then they won't need to go home. Why don't we see...? Maybe everyone will agree, and there won't be any more obstruction. Maybe everyone at this table will agree to support this motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115806","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I believe so. If this motion is passed with these amendments, then they won't need to go home. Why don't we see...? Maybe everyone will agree, and there won't be any more obstruction. Maybe everyone at this table will agree to support this motion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c12fc2c35b9a074cad75f9a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115807,"date":"2026-05-07T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Well, it's hard to support the original motion to move on to an AI report when we have not finished our investigation into the PrescribeIT scandal. Over $300 million was used on this boondoggle. I think that word has been used, way overused, during the last week, I have to say, but it's the truth. It's hard to figure out another word to use for it. We had the CEO of the company here, Mr. Green, telling us that he couldn't actually explain anything about it, yet he had been working on this for 10 years. Within a week of our interviewing him here for this study, in which all members around this table were shocked by his answers—if you look back at the tape, you'll see that all members were shocked—and all members wanted him to come back in person, he was fired. I will say that the Minister of Health has not had.... We've been asking her continually in Parliament, over and over again, if she could answer the question, \"What happened?\" She can't answer, so we are trying to get her in here too. She actually said, in Parliament, within this last couple of days, that she was willing to come in here, so let's get her in here. I think the amendment is appropriate, especially when we're looking at AI and especially if we're looking at the situation and making sure we aren't using fax machines anymore. That was the original intent of PrescribeIT. Well, let's go back before we move on to AI. Let's figure out what happened in trying to replace those fax machines. Let's get Mr. Green in here, and let's get the health minister in here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115807","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, it's hard to support the original motion to move on to an AI report when we have not finished our investigation into the PrescribeIT scandal. Over $300 million was used on this boondoggle. I think that word has been used, way overused, during the last week, I have to say, but it's the truth. It's hard to figure out another word to use for it. We had the CEO of the company here, Mr. Green, te","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28c86df979255b0c0bd7f1812c77dbc4d28f95d268dd7072f4fb9e4fb93a8a7e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-514c57b0b72a8f7c1a227ef8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115808,"date":"2026-05-07T21:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you, Chair. I must say that at first I didn't think this subamendment would be necessary after everything that has happened in the last week. I think there are a lot of embarrassed MPs at this table right now who decided last week to force this committee behind closed doors. Now, we have media outlets like The Globe and Mail, the CBC—I could go on and on—that are more worried about how it is possible that MPs around this table could shut out news from Canadians for 30 years. For 30 years, they will not know what happened in those meetings last week. I thought, why would we need this subamendment? Why would we need it? There's no way that the MPs around this table would want to do that again after the embarrassment. They had to answer to their constituents. It's very difficult, I'm sure. There must have been an incredible number of emails and phone calls to their offices and their personal phones. I'm sure they wouldn't want to go through that embarrassment again. Canadians want to trust us and want transparency, and all of us around this table know that, but I see now that just in case there is any chance that an MP sitting at this table—a Liberal MP in particular—might want to hide more news for 30 years, this amendment is necessary.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115808","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. I must say that at first I didn't think this subamendment would be necessary after everything that has happened in the last week. I think there are a lot of embarrassed MPs at this table right now who decided last week to force this committee behind closed doors. Now, we have media outlets like The Globe and Mail, the CBC—I could go on and on—that are more worried about how it is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["959f8ffafe22d7aeaa3f8e0ecdf9f142f5ea7a574514fc34ae6391c836cb5238"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4bcebaa58cb3adb81045be4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115809,"date":"2026-05-07T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"To go back to the amendment, it's obvious that Michael Green is ground zero. He is ground zero. Oh, am I allowed to use \"ground zero\" in a meeting?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115809","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"To go back to the amendment, it's obvious that Michael Green is ground zero. He is ground zero. Oh, am I allowed to use \"ground zero\" in a meeting?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c07c6c129a8d360677ca62e12847965bb73a0495b0b07076be5853594d21b477"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ab7cfc758a5b1130d622a8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115810,"date":"2026-05-07T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"After everything that's happened today, it is obvious that Michael Green is ground zero for this scandal of PrescribeIT—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115810","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"After everything that's happened today, it is obvious that Michael Green is ground zero for this scandal of PrescribeIT—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["926327d3ed5030e387bc8fa44b605ed9a1997ffc0da1d603784c5f9e4398cbee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cecda75b122c483425daf67","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115811,"date":"2026-05-07T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you, Chair. It is obvious, after listening to the members sitting across from us at this table, that Michael Green is ground zero for this scandal. It is also obvious that he actually might want to come here. He may be asking to come here, in fact, because maybe there are things that he needs to expose. It is obvious that there are people sitting at this table who don't want that exposed. It is their duty to the Canadian people to let Michael Green, former CEO of Canada Health Infoway, come in, speak and tell the truth. Allow him to come in and tell the truth about what happened in this scandal. How did this happen? I would like to give him the opportunity to have a voice. It is our responsibility to allow Michael Green to come to this committee, use his voice and tell the truth about what he knows about what has happened in the last 10 years with this scandal.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115811","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. It is obvious, after listening to the members sitting across from us at this table, that Michael Green is ground zero for this scandal. It is also obvious that he actually might want to come here. He may be asking to come here, in fact, because maybe there are things that he needs to expose. It is obvious that there are people sitting at this table who don't want that exposed. It","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1ec61db502b157e749cc6ad4d6eccc6dc25b679f7012b8bc9f83d8c5351e468"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8153a7bb9bb0b9e732a46845","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084020,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the ability to speak today on Bill C-240. This touches my heart, because I would imagine that for all MPs sitting in this room, no matter where they are sitting today, their lives have changed and their communities have changed. I know all Canadian cities have changed, including all communities in the Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay riding. \n\nI want to speak a bit about the city I live in. Penticton is a beautiful city. It is a place where people have always wanted to come to vacation, and possibly even retire, if they reach that point in their lives and have saved up enough money, because, of course, our housing is expensive, like it is in many communities.\n\nUnfortunately, our city, like so many, is filled with chaos right now. I hope everyone here knows they can go and enjoy the city and enjoy the area, but there is chaos because crime rates are skyrocketing. In fact, it was announced last week by our first responders that overdose rates in Penticton increased by nearly 500% in the first quarter of 2026 compared to the first quarter of 2025. This was reported by our fire department.\n\nImagine what being a first responder in Penticton is like right now, when all they are doing is constantly going out to calls and trying to bring people back to life. Imagine how difficult it would be for them psychologically to not fight fires, like they were trained to. We do not have a lot of fires anymore, except for quite a few that are caused by people who are homeless and on the streets. Instead, our first responders are constantly going out and injecting people with some type of drug to try to bring them back to life. Sometimes they are successful and sometimes they are not.\n\n It has ruined our community and our most vulnerable people, who are those are on drugs and living on our streets. It has also ruined our community for many vulnerable people, as we have a very large senior community.\n\nGoing back to Bill C-240, the bill aims to amend the Criminal Code to empower judges to prescribe structured rehabilitation programs for individuals whose offences stem from circumstances that can be addressed through skills development, education and recovery as part of a holistic healing process.\n\n It is important to know that in Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, which is a very big riding in the B.C. interior, there is not one detox bed available. In fact, as a city councillor, a couple of years ago, I was given a presentation by leaders in the community who were addressing this issue. I asked them a question. If someone were to come into our city council meeting right then and say, \"I am a drug addict. I want help. I want to go back to my family\", how long would it take for that person to get into a detox bed or a rehab bed? By the way, this was in public. Members can look this up from the City of Penticton's council meeting two years ago. They told the city council that it would take two years for that person to be given any type of detox bed or any type of rehabilitation. They also said it would not be in our huge riding. They would have to leave the community in two years and go to another community to get help.\n\nWe all know what would happen in those two years. I am sure I will get letters saying, \"No, it's not two years.\" Maybe it has gotten better, and hopefully it has, but it would still be at least half that time.\n\nWe need to give people the ability to go back to their families, and we also need to keep people behind bars who are not safe for our communities. Some of the residents I represent are afraid of even going to the grocery store anymore to shop because there are erratic people walking down the aisles. There has been a huge issue, obviously, since the pilot project to decriminalize drugs in B.C. That was a great experiment put together by the Liberal government and the NDP provincial government. I would like to ask everyone in this great room today, would they like to try that decriminalization project? Let us just see what might happen. \n\nBritish Columbia has the most deaths from fentanyl in the world now. The genie is out of the bottle now. Sure, the decriminalization project has been declared over, but we have not found out the complete chaos that was caused by it; the numbers are not out yet. That will happen, and we will bring them, hopefully, before the Standing Committee on Health, which I sit on, and get the complete numbers, but do we really need them? We all know that thousands and thousands of people have died in British Columbia from that project. I do not see anyone representing any other province wanting to come forward and try it for their communities.\n\nI want to thank MP DeRidder, who—\n\nAn hon. member: You cannot use the name.\n\nHelena Konanz: Excuse me, Mr. Speaker. I thank the MP for bringing forward this bill, and I want to quote her. She said Bill C-240 \"would empower courts to prescribe structured rehabilitation measures, including education, skills training and treatment programs, to be undertaken during custody. These are not soft-on-crime measures. They are smart-on-recovery interventions.\" \n\nWe have to give people the opportunity to go back to their families. \n\nI was given a tour, as a city councillor a couple of years ago, of the penitentiary in my riding, the Okanagan Correctional Centre. At that time, the warden told us city councillors that it was 25% full. We have one of the highest crime rates, in Penticton and area, in all of B.C., per capita, and our correctional centre is only 25% full. The leaders in the community, the mayors of all the cities in the valley, have sent a letter to the province asking to use that correctional centre for exactly what the MP for Kitchener Centre is asking for: to provide rehabilitation measures, education, skills training and treatment, to give these people a chance to go back out in the world and back to their families, if they are able. If they cannot, if they are dangerous people, as we know there are, then they should not be released as they have been.\n\nThis bill would also allow court-ordered rehabilitation measures for offenders. I believe everyone in this great hall knows that people get to a point in their drug use where there is no going back.\n\nI want to thank, again, the MP for bringing this forward, and I hope everyone here votes to support it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084020","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the ability to speak today on Bill C-240. This touches my heart, because I would imagine that for all MPs sitting in this room, no matter where they are sitting today, their lives have changed and their communities have changed. I know all Canadian cities have changed, including all communities in the Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay riding. \n\nI want to speak a bi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c7a4f80272f5d000024cc7b2f469b9f32e2b76d5e261e511fc2809527134e02"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e3b1b5dc970ad8a7ee087f466e01dff8d6858222314814f9fda249d2461bb8c5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34d538133714b0393929674a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084021,"date":"2026-06-01T22:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague mentioned that he is knocking on doors and that his constituents are talking about lower grocery costs, making our streets safer, lower taxes and more affordable housing. I am hearing that at the doors also. I am sure all of us are hearing some of the same things, at least.\n\nWhy does the member think the Liberals would create this bill that is basically ignoring what Canadians are really asking for?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084021","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague mentioned that he is knocking on doors and that his constituents are talking about lower grocery costs, making our streets safer, lower taxes and more affordable housing. I am hearing that at the doors also. I am sure all of us are hearing some of the same things, at least.\n\nWhy does the member think the Liberals would create this bill that is basically ignoring what Cana","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b774efac99997a6ef0e482f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084019,"date":"2026-06-03T20:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are denying Canadians transparency on the $300 million that was wasted on PrescribeIT. At the health committee, they turned off the cameras, shut down meetings and blocked the minister from testifying. Conservatives are prepared to work through the summer to get to the bottom of this scandal. \n\nWhy are the Liberals blocking the health committee from investigating this $300-million PrescribeIT failure?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084019","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are denying Canadians transparency on the $300 million that was wasted on PrescribeIT. At the health committee, they turned off the cameras, shut down meetings and blocked the minister from testifying. Conservatives are prepared to work through the summer to get to the bottom of this scandal. \n\nWhy are the Liberals blocking the health committee from investigating this $30","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-36ead4f4ee846c25a5586bc6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085962,"date":"2026-06-08T19:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, despite handing 300 million tax dollars over to Canada Health Infoway for the government's failed PrescribeIT project, we can see that the Liberals have no interest in finding out why or how this money was wasted. The Liberals have voted down every attempt to get the answers.\n\n The Conservatives have been clear. We will work through the summer to get to the bottom of this. Canadians want to hear the minister and the former CEO provide testimony.\n\n Will the minister tell her Liberal colleagues to end their obstruction and get to the bottom of this scandal?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085962","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, despite handing 300 million tax dollars over to Canada Health Infoway for the government's failed PrescribeIT project, we can see that the Liberals have no interest in finding out why or how this money was wasted. The Liberals have voted down every attempt to get the answers.\n\n The Conservatives have been clear. We will work through the summer to get to the bottom of this. Canadians w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","label":"Corruption","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6cc191c7fe2e596afa7f4e9bb17618fa4e40cd9beb4996eff064376c049eb5d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-caba7abc1f2d792c746369b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085963,"date":"2026-06-08T22:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I always learn so much whenever my colleague stands in the House. \n\nI am hearing constantly from the people in my riding that they are struggling with basic needs, like putting food on the table. I know I am not the only one. I am sure every MP in this room right now, every MP who was elected in the last year, feels the same thing. We know from the data that there is a recession. We know there are issues in Canada, but the Liberals keep denying that anything is wrong. What does my colleague think is the danger of denying issues like this when they are so blatant? I know the Liberals are hearing the same things we are hearing. What is the danger of denial?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085963","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I always learn so much whenever my colleague stands in the House. \n\nI am hearing constantly from the people in my riding that they are struggling with basic needs, like putting food on the table. I know I am not the only one. I am sure every MP in this room right now, every MP who was elected in the last year, feels the same thing. We know from the data that there is a recession. We k","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb2dfd7cbf4991884a6f030483a02fc442bad50ffc73fac20fd437f30fe25016"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6b75beed4692cd9effa9b4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085964,"date":"2026-06-08T23:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague's speech really hit home for me, coming from rural B.C. Not many people would call Kelowna rural, but it is just north of me, and it has the highest unemployment rate now in the country, at over 9%. Then that filters down to all the areas around it, including my riding. I am hearing from constituents constantly about exactly what the member talked about. They are having trouble putting food on the table, and it is a real thing. We are not stirring the pot; it is actually a real thing. I am hearing about it in my office constantly. I am seeing it at the food banks. \n\nWhat is the danger of denying that there is a problem in our country? What is the danger of the Liberals continuing to deny this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085964","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague's speech really hit home for me, coming from rural B.C. Not many people would call Kelowna rural, but it is just north of me, and it has the highest unemployment rate now in the country, at over 9%. Then that filters down to all the areas around it, including my riding. I am hearing from constituents constantly about exactly what the member talked about. They are having t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["39671e020c50a1061d638e142d50aa2bde7474565f92d1be96afe5763cac64ec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e8c8f8ec16efa2fc4ee392446208736eac1eb0a8c89636cde024cce378f9a04f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fa1b11a4a48d049d87a09f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085961,"date":"2026-06-10T00:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, housing is so important right now in Canada. We cannot waste the moment by building more bureaucracy, more talking and not doing. For example, Build Canada Homes is another bureaucracy. In Penticton, housing is getting so expensive. In Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, multiple communities in my huge riding have applied for the housing accelerator fund in the last few years. Not one of them has gotten it.\n\nWhy would we build another bureaucracy when that is not working?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085961","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, housing is so important right now in Canada. We cannot waste the moment by building more bureaucracy, more talking and not doing. For example, Build Canada Homes is another bureaucracy. In Penticton, housing is getting so expensive. In Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, multiple communities in my huge riding have applied for the housing accelerator fund in the last few years. N","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["477478af4ddc83953c35fd168b0c49e035fdceeeb655e5d124ce903e3f2df321"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["90ccaec5bd5930d163f8dc837a0b76e37ed001a2743cbd7228f31fcc3ef93372"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f0b42b2916d5d71365bfe78b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085960,"date":"2026-06-10T23:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, before I begin, I want to give a quick shout-out and congratulations to the kids at Penticton Secondary School, who recently raised, if members can believe it, $80,000 for the Canadian Cancer Society's Relay for Life with the help of Princess Margaret Secondary, Summerland Secondary and many other local organizations, businesses and community members. I congratulate these great kids, and the best news is that people can still donate, at cancer.ca.\n\n I want to start with a simple question. Why does a physician in this country have to fill out the same paperwork for the same drug, for the same condition, over and over again, while their patients wait? That is the problem the bill is trying to solve, and it is a real problem. According to Health Canada's own records, obtained through Order Paper Question No. 1104, the special access program has received over 148,000 requests since 2015. Last year alone, nearly 12,000 requests came through. Many of these are repeat applications for drugs that Canadian clinicians have been successfully requesting for years. These are therapies that are well established and approved by regulators, with real-world track records behind them, yet the system treats every single one as if it is the first time anyone has ever asked.\n\n A physician who has prescribed the same therapy for the same rare condition 10 times must submit a fresh application for patient number 11. They fill out the forms, they wait, they answer Health Canada's follow-up questions, and they wait some more. According to the government's own written response to questions tabled in this House, the average processing time for a special access program request is 4.65 days. That might not sound like that much, but the longest processing time on record was 1,641 days. For patients with serious and emergency needs, even a few days of unnecessary delay can mean permanent, irreversible harm.\n\n The Canadian Organization for Rare Disorders has put numbers to what this costs. Only 60% of rare disease treatments reach Canada at all. Most arrive up to six years after patients in the United States and Europe have access to them. This is the broken system that Bill C-265 is trying to address.\n\n The bill would direct the Minister of Health to establish a standing pre-approved list of non-marketed therapeutic products for serious or life-threatening conditions. Physicians could prescribe directly from that list without starting from scratch every time. Products would be eligible based on prior special access program authorization, a clean safety record or current approval by a recognized foreign regulator. An expert advisory committee would be consulted on the list. However, who those experts would be is not defined.\n\n I want to acknowledge the member for Thunder Bay—Rainy River for his work on this. He has approached it collaboratively and with genuine intent. His background as a physician gives him first-hand understanding of just how much time Canadian doctors waste on repetitive administrative processes.\n\n Conservatives will support sending this bill to committee, where we will work to address our concerns. My colleague from Riding Mountain raised these concerns before, but I will raise them again. \n\nOur first concern is the presumption of approval when two specialist clinicians submit a joint treatment plan. The problem is that the bill places no requirements on these two clinicians to be independent of each other or independent of the treating practitioner. There is nothing in the legislation to prevent the second opinion from coming from a colleague in the same clinic, a supervisor, a business partner or even a family member. A second opinion is only meaningful if it is genuinely independent.\n\n Our second concern is the absence of any exclusion of controlled substances from the pre-approved list. In 2013, Conservative health minister Rona Ambrose took special action to restrict the special access program after it was used to approve access to pharmaceutical heroin for patients with chronic addiction. Those restrictions were deliberate and warranted. The Trudeau government later dismantled them. As currently drafted, Bill C-265 would give the Minister of Health the authority to place substances like dangerous hard drugs directly onto a pre-approved list, from which any qualifying practitioner could order them without individual case-by-case review. \n\nWe have watched the government use every lever available to it to normalize and expand access to hard drugs under the banner of harm reduction. Conservatives are not going to support legislation that would create another pathway for that agenda. The bill's own sponsor has said that diversion of these substances must be prevented. We take him at his word, and we will hold him to it at committee with an explicit amendment to exclude hard drugs from the scope of the pre-approved list. \n\nOur third concern involves who gets to nominate products for the pre-approved list. As written, the bill would allow not just licensed practitioners but also pharmacists, hospitals and medical non-profit organizations to submit products for inclusion. The term \"medical non-profit organization\" is nowhere defined in the legislation. When my colleague from Riding Mountain asked the government in an Order Paper question to tell us how many special access program requests were made, broken down by requester category, whether practitioners, pharmacists, hospitals or non-profit organizations, Health Canada told us that this information is not centrally tracked. That is not good. \n\nThe government cannot even tell the House who is submitting these applications, and now we are being asked to expand the nomination criteria to include an undefined class of organizations with no meaningful guardrails. That appears like an open door that can be abused. Conservatives will propose amendments to restrict nomination rights to licensed practitioners who use the special access program in their day-to-day clinical work. There is a broader point worth making also. The health minister has had every opportunity to reform how this program operates currently and has not done so. \n\nBill C-265 would offer some relief but would not fix the underlying problem. What it would do, if strengthened at committee, is reduce the repetitive administrative burden on physicians, provide a clear and faster pathway to proven therapies for patients who have no other options and do so without opening new doors to hard drugs or creating a regulatory bypass for pharmaceutical manufacturers. If amendments are accepted, the legislation would make a meaningful difference for Canadians who are waiting for treatments that already exist and are already proven. They have waited long enough.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085960","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, before I begin, I want to give a quick shout-out and congratulations to the kids at Penticton Secondary School, who recently raised, if members can believe it, $80,000 for the Canadian Cancer Society's Relay for Life with the help of Princess Margaret Secondary, Summerland Secondary and many other local organizations, businesses and community members. I congratulate these great kids, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e437c3c0ea879aeade13cf7c15078d6b4badf656999d0e2f9a5a3caf5261438e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e74b3405e3258d5597427d287d3eccaec6b57d0570a33f03129a68b74072a274"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc9124b0b125291546c5fe17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085956,"date":"2026-06-12T16:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, 300 million tax dollars were wasted on PrescribeIT. Liberal members of the health committee have refused every request to answer why or how. The Minister of Health and the CEO must testify. Canadians want to know how their tax dollars were wasted on this boondoggle.\n\nWill the Liberal minister agree it is time to stop the secrets, keep the cameras on and investigate PrescribeIT in public?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085956","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, 300 million tax dollars were wasted on PrescribeIT. Liberal members of the health committee have refused every request to answer why or how. The Minister of Health and the CEO must testify. Canadians want to know how their tax dollars were wasted on this boondoggle.\n\nWill the Liberal minister agree it is time to stop the secrets, keep the cameras on and investigate PrescribeIT in publ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax avoidance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax avoidance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","label":"Tax avoidance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3714cf4b910a37ccfb2a8ca5ef888b251cc1b721d2045438c302a200578bca5a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66151b9c8a322a8d7f576141","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085957,"date":"2026-06-12T16:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would take that member more seriously if she did not keep turning the cameras off and voting to seal committee records for 30 years when we call for an audit. Conservatives have been clear that we will work through the summer to get a full accounting on $300 million wasted on PrescribeIT, but they must leave the cameras on.\n\nCanadians want to know: Will they hear about PrescribeIT on Tuesday or will the Liberal parliamentary secretary turn the cameras off again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085957","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would take that member more seriously if she did not keep turning the cameras off and voting to seal committee records for 30 years when we call for an audit. Conservatives have been clear that we will work through the summer to get a full accounting on $300 million wasted on PrescribeIT, but they must leave the cameras on.\n\nCanadians want to know: Will they hear about PrescribeIT o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd83c498d4e6f8099df07a31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085958,"date":"2026-06-12T17:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a couple of petitions from Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, which I am honoured to represent.\n\n The first petition has to do with rural transit, which is vital in our communities. The petitioners are concerned that the Government of Canada's rural transit solutions fund has invested in bus transit feasibility studies in rural Ontario and Alberta, but Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay has been poorly served by the loss of Greyhound buses in 2018, and there is no transit service available for residents that they can rely on.\n\nTransport Canada is owner and operator of the Penticton Airport. Many times, airports are being utilized across the country as hubs for bus services, so the petitioners are asking that we establish in their communities a rural transit options service for residents and communities in Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay and to declare that Penticton Airport be available for private busing operators who wish to utilize it as a passenger hub.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085958","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a couple of petitions from Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, which I am honoured to represent.\n\n The first petition has to do with rural transit, which is vital in our communities. The petitioners are concerned that the Government of Canada's rural transit solutions fund has invested in bus transit feasibility studies in rural Ontario and Alberta, but Similkameen—","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc624972563f75347a8d018bf46ce4f6f0112099cd944ce5df851157fc9850a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e090ecdd2bf3c12bc5e8d8fa84430294bdacf8d2eb6a273a241d2947568e0a30"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b57cdea1949c12112da1536d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085959,"date":"2026-06-12T17:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition relates to the Government of Canada's gun buyback plan. The Liberals call it a gun buyback plan, but it is obviously not working. It should be focused on gun violence and illegal guns being smuggled, from the United States in particular. We have six border crossings in our riding, so one can imagine that residents are very concerned about smuggled guns, as everyone member of the House is.\n\n Instead, right now, the plan places new burdens on law-abiding firearms owners, who already follow some of the strictest rules in the world for owning firearms. The program is expected to cost more than $700 million.\n\nTherefore, the petitioners are asking that the Government of Canada scrap what it calls the gun buyback program, and focus on border security, stopping illegal gun smuggling and going after real criminals, rather than targeting responsible gun owners in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085959","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition relates to the Government of Canada's gun buyback plan. The Liberals call it a gun buyback plan, but it is obviously not working. It should be focused on gun violence and illegal guns being smuggled, from the United States in particular. We have six border crossings in our riding, so one can imagine that residents are very concerned about smuggled guns, as everyone","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","label":"Border crossing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","label":"Border crossing","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9e02c02232e346c74877c1a93d71babb5a08b7d44a71624163ee94bd72936693"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c8dc4f0747490f915ea8df7a3d93a916e57cb2c00226c75e9b7d24c26384c26"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d768d2aff50fd09f8495cb2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087875,"date":"2026-06-15T22:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are the only G7 country in a recession. Two years ago, we had a $40-billion deficit that was considered outrageous by the Canadian people, and now we have an almost $100-billion deficit. In what way does the Liberal government think that is okay?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087875","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are the only G7 country in a recession. Two years ago, we had a $40-billion deficit that was considered outrageous by the Canadian people, and now we have an almost $100-billion deficit. In what way does the Liberal government think that is okay?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0ef7b9759e1e3c9574d8dc4abf10b92344e3860f41bfc266c0e1c3507c3e17da"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["18978363fbd8f9e3162ce11704561290d0781907eb34256deb952c614b2b810f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4839ed9fd0f46280577bc191","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087876,"date":"2026-06-15T22:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I largely share my colleague's view.\n\nI would like to know what he thinks about the fact that the Liberals refuse to acknowledge the economic situation in Canada, that they do not believe Canadians are going through a difficult time, and that they believe everything is fine for the average Canadian.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087876","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I largely share my colleague's view.\n\nI would like to know what he thinks about the fact that the Liberals refuse to acknowledge the economic situation in Canada, that they do not believe Canadians are going through a difficult time, and that they believe everything is fine for the average Canadian.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0ec5b19ffcf1914a9f09635","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087877,"date":"2026-06-15T23:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to the motion as it relates to the Liberal government's spring economic statement. It may be the spring season that prompted the Liberals to use this update to paint a rosy picture of our economy, but the reality on the ground is that the real and non-partisan numbers show a stark picture for residents in my community, especially among working families and struggling seniors.\n\n The economic statement shows spending continuing to rise rapidly and no binding fiscal anchors. The growing deficit will only worsen as the Liberal government borrows more against the national debt. Debt service costs are rising rapidly, eating up more of each tax dollar than total spending on health care or defence. The fact is, Canada's economy has entered a recession. That is not a political talking point but an agreed economic viewpoint for decades. \n\nAny period in which our economy sees two consecutive quarters of declining GDP is widely called a recession. This has been a mantra of economic statistics for decades. If others want to fight over the difference between a recession and a technical recession, the fact remains that there is nothing technical about a weak economy, as the Governor of the Bank of Canada described it just last week. A weak economy is what we see in 2026, when 112,000 more Canadians are out of work in just the first four months of this year and where, by per-person GDP, Canadians still have a lower standard of living than they did in 2022. \n\nWorsening signs like this for Canadian household finances are, sadly, not hard to come by. Household savings fell to the lowest level in two years, with Canada having the highest household debt in the G7 by far. Statistics Canada found that Canadian household debt has outstripped income for six consecutive quarters. Equifax reported that insolvency volumes increased to levels not seen since 2009, up nearly 19% year over year. There are 1.5 million Canadians who have missed a debt payment in the first three months of this year alone, with mortgage delinquency rates climbing 32% year over year.\n\n The Prime Minister promised us he would build the fastest-growing economy in the G7, yet we are alone among the G7 in having our economy shrink in three of the last four quarters. Promises to build quickly and build big to fortify the Canadian economy, through measures like the major projects act, a bill that I voted for, have not come to pass. Canada has neither designated nor started a single major economic project to fast-track a year after we passed that legislation. Instead, years of Liberal laws creating burdensome regulations, high taxes and persistent large-budget deficits have all made it increasingly expensive for businesses to invest in Canada.\n\n I understand that many want to hold on to the belief that the rosy picture the Prime Minister paints of the country is accurate, but looking at his peers outside politics, we see the real story. The Prime Minister's own choice for the non-partisan Parliamentary Budget Officer said that the Liberals' deficits are billions higher than they claim. She showed that promises to reduce government spending are not reflected in rising personal costs, which will also increase by billions of dollars over the next several years. She showed that the government's revenue forecasts will fall short because of expected weaker wages and slower salary growth in a worsening economy. Lastly, she said the government's fiscal plan has a 1% chance of meeting its fiscal anchor to reduce the deficit-to-GDP ratio each year. \n\nAs someone who knows balance sheets in both the private and public sectors, I can say that if a fiscal plan showed only a 1% chance of succeeding, any small business or local government would be revising the plan. Instead, the Liberal government moves forward with more spending and more debt, which will only result in more taxes and more inflation. These are the national figures, but I would like to take a moment to focus on how these national trends are causing real tension in communities like mine in Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay.\n\n A real and growing consequence of higher-than-average unemployment, sluggish wages and food inflation is that more people are turning to local food banks. No one should ever be ashamed of turning to food banks, but government should be ashamed of the worsening affordability crisis pushing more workers, more seniors and groups that have historically not availed themselves of food banks to use their services for the very first time in their lives. The government's allocated funding for food banks is insufficient. It will not curb the worsening affordability curve. We have seen that it is pushing these groups toward food bank services. The Liberal government has overseen the worst rise in food bank use in a generation, surpassing levels during the 2008 financial crisis and the height of COVID-19, and rural Canada is really suffering. \n\nThe amazing volunteers I recently met with at the Boundary Community Food Bank told me that they have seen a 73% increase in demand for their services since 2020, with 25% of their regular clients having only applied within the last year and 20% of their clients working full- or part-time. They told me that they now see over 100 seniors from within this little community needing their services each month, and this is just in the Boundary. It does not cover the Kootenays, the Similkameen, the South Okanagan or Penticton. \n\nSimilkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay has one of the oldest demographics in Canada. Seniors used to be the demographic most likely to donate to food banks. They were more likely to fill out a volunteer form than to apply for a food hamper. That is now changing rapidly. This increased turn for our seniors is leaving them financially vulnerable and less able to participate in their own communities as much as they once did. This is a huge loss. \n\nVolunteers at community events have traditionally been older, partially because they had a little more in their bank accounts to fill an extra tank of gas for volunteer driving, for buying extra hamburgers or hot dogs, or for giving a little more of their day. After speaking with people in my region, and after speaking with colleagues from across the country, I feel that seniors are increasingly unable to volunteer because of the cost of living. \n\nOver the last few years in my region, we have seen the loss of community events, such as those in the community of Penticton. In the last few years, we have lost Ironman, the Pentastic Jazz Fest, Ribfest and Okanagan Granfondo. Service clubs, which in the past were made up of seniors volunteering, are dwindling. It is impacting the entire community as a whole, and many seniors who are facing a financial crunch are considering even more dire options than simply not volunteering. \n\nMy office has heard from too many seniors who have exhausted their benefits and drained their savings and are inquiring into the terms of an application for MAID. It is a horrifying thought that, in Canada, the financial burden being carried by seniors should have them think that the best option is to end their life early, not on medical grounds but because of a harshly rising cost of living. This symbolizes an unaffordable Canada none of us should accept. Unfortunately, the spring economic update shows us little change in course to restore an affordable Canada for workers, families and seniors.\n\nI move, seconded by the member for Oshawa:\n\n That the amendment be amended, in paragraph (b), by replacing the words \"paragraphs (b) to (f)\" with the words \"paragraphs (b) and (d) to (f)\".","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087877","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to the motion as it relates to the Liberal government's spring economic statement. It may be the spring season that prompted the Liberals to use this update to paint a rosy picture of our economy, but the reality on the ground is that the real and non-partisan numbers show a stark picture for residents in my community, especially among working families and struggling s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2a5e74fb096a8fd3f129d01c01ba1f22b2ed1bd2f56f225346e49525e4bd0393"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da34833415ad3f2fa383fee0bc0b98205e316d82f980ab2111f387062362ed2e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-086dd6f587eb32b5fd74adc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087878,"date":"2026-06-15T23:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, any time that anybody is supporting the military in the House, it is extremely important to do so. Unfortunately, the Liberals have not supported it in the past. It is the Conservatives who have stood up for the people who fight for this country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087878","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, any time that anybody is supporting the military in the House, it is extremely important to do so. Unfortunately, the Liberals have not supported it in the past. It is the Conservatives who have stood up for the people who fight for this country.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c2b5338c5a5bdc01cf9cfdbe6e46278538aed1184e49afed5393fe1f58ca934a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d7559d238efec29c5e7039b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087879,"date":"2026-06-15T23:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as my colleague may know, health spending is extremely important to me. I sit on the Standing Committee on Health right now. \n\nI agree that there are certain places where we need an increase in health spending, but we have to make sure that it is spent properly. We cannot spend any more on infrastructure or buildings for which we need to hire more and more bureaucracy. We need to spend it on boots on the ground. We need more doctors. We need more nurses. We need more MRI machines. We need things that would help people actually have a doctor. Thousands of people in my riding alone do not have a doctor.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087879","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as my colleague may know, health spending is extremely important to me. I sit on the Standing Committee on Health right now. \n\nI agree that there are certain places where we need an increase in health spending, but we have to make sure that it is spent properly. We cannot spend any more on infrastructure or buildings for which we need to hire more and more bureaucracy. We need to spen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037111","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shoe industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037111","label":"Shoe industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91334fb224c07ed493a5be46c2ddd148ec0c737a71df27afff654865c3e968e1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["30e851f5bdb218ba74eea6c318b831debacf64beb5485b9e10239d1a8d22d980"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b57b417f31e2af601f91859e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087880,"date":"2026-06-15T23:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is an excellent question. It is obvious. Anyone who runs a business knows that, if something costs more, they are going to have to charge more. It is not even advanced economics. People all over who have small businesses know that it is common sense.\n\n Yes, we need to take away the red tape. We need to lower taxes. We need to take away taxes such as the industrial carbon tax. Especially in my riding, which is extremely rural, any time it costs more to transport goods to a grocery store, the owner of that store is going to have to charge more for that product.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087880","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is an excellent question. It is obvious. Anyone who runs a business knows that, if something costs more, they are going to have to charge more. It is not even advanced economics. People all over who have small businesses know that it is common sense.\n\n Yes, we need to take away the red tape. We need to lower taxes. We need to take away taxes such as the industrial carbon tax. Esp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logistics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","label":"Logistics","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6026bc968698e6b3dc6f253c7239b23e5230c6770ec67a21bef69ef4dcebf57d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4390bdcaec933cdd523ffd14e8cf71fd0f6cb4b04f35bfc717459332fc202882"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e87c501b4f189ec8ed42300","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087873,"date":"2026-06-17T20:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we need to hear from the chair of the health committee as to why he cancelled tomorrow's meeting. Hundreds of millions of health care dollars remain unaccounted for in the $300‐million PrescribeIT scandal. Why? It is because Liberal MPs keep turning off the cameras at the health committee. They turned off the cameras again yesterday. Canadians will not know what was said there for 30 years.\n\nWill the chair of the health committee tell Canadians today why he cancelled tomorrow's meeting, blocking Parliament from investigating PrescribeIT?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087873","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we need to hear from the chair of the health committee as to why he cancelled tomorrow's meeting. Hundreds of millions of health care dollars remain unaccounted for in the $300‐million PrescribeIT scandal. Why? It is because Liberal MPs keep turning off the cameras at the health committee. They turned off the cameras again yesterday. Canadians will not know what was said there for 30 ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-440cb82204a00bbcaf9903a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087874,"date":"2026-06-17T21:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Helena Konanz","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table a petition brought forward by a passionate group of residents in my community who remain deeply concerned that our laws continue to fail to safeguard the victims of intimate partner violence. Most situations of intimate partner violence begin with patterns of behaviour that involve severe mental, emotional and psychological abuse, yet our justice system and our police system too often fail to recognize this abuse and to intervene before the violence begins.\n\nThe petitioners are asking us to look at legislation criminalizing this behaviour in the U.K., Ireland and Australia. They would like the Government of Canada to amend the Criminal Code to criminalize targeted mental and emotional abuse. They are also asking for changes to be reflected in our bail and judicial system, as well as in law enforcement training, so we can recognize and investigate this abuse.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087874","member_id":"bc-mp-105863","member_name":"Helena Konanz","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table a petition brought forward by a passionate group of residents in my community who remain deeply concerned that our laws continue to fail to safeguard the victims of intimate partner violence. Most situations of intimate partner violence begin with patterns of behaviour that involve severe mental, emotional and psychological abuse, yet our justice system and our police ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3310f5af793641e7eeb28f79da93b440cbdec35e55df8194f2d151016d667e7d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3e9fa0cff56e085c26f57180d6f03ab5ed9aaa41b6e046b3876e8668f6c216d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-752a012e9ed305e7529efe1d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76671,"date":"2026-01-27T21:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is a real honour to rise today for the first time in the calendar year 2026 to speak on behalf of the constituents of West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country.\n\nI wish all members of the House a very happy new year. I am looking forward to working in a spirit of collaboration as we get this year under way.\n\nI very much hope things will be different this year. Certainly things started off the right way. I heard the shift in tone from the Leader of the Opposition in response to the seminal speech from our Prime Minister at Davos. I heard the very gracious words that he shared and the commitments to pass some very important pieces of legislation for Canadians.\n\nWhen I heard that the Conservatives wanted to speak on a sovereignty act today, I was very excited to see if we could have a real debate about some of the major issues we have to grapple with to deal with the rupture in the global order and, frankly, the threat we have coming from south of the border, including among other things how that changes how we deal with our national security when we may not be able to rely on the United States.\n\nHow can we unite our nation? How can we work with provinces? How can we work better with first nations in a spirit of partnership? How can we build our ports to access new markets? How can we buy more Canadian products? How can we have a clear-eyed plan to drive prosperity not only today but also deep into the future?\n\nHowever, much to my disappointment, when I actually read what was in the so-called sovereignty act, I saw that rather than dealing with these very important issues, we are getting a rehash of the same tired Conservative policy playbook that encompasses no more than a wish list of the oil and gas industry to gut Canada's environmental protections. Rather than making Canada more sovereign and looking into the future, what the Conservatives are proposing would actually further shackle us to the United States and a world that no longer exists. Rather than working to unite the nation, what has been proposed is to bully and steamroll all who disagree with them. We know that this plan has failed before and would fail again, but now is not the time to be going down that same road and playing these fruitless games.\n\nI think it would be helpful to go through a number of points within the proposed sovereignty act to really point out what it means.\n\nAmong other things, the act proposes repealing the Impact Assessment Act, which, for those who do not know, is a piece of environmental assessment legislation that rationalizes the work that Canada needs to do to ensure that projects are going to mitigate the environmental impacts they have. It allows for better first nations consultation and in fact imposes strict timelines on government reviews of those projects. Frankly, since this legislation was brought in, the reviews of those projects have improved not only in quantity but also in efficiency. This is because what it replaced was the CEAA 2012 legislation, which was so poorly written that projects, after getting approved, would just find their way into the courts and be hung up for years and years.\n\nWhen the Conservatives call the bill the \"no more pipelines act\", I think it is really telling. They do not want to talk about what would replace it. If we do not have any environmental assessment legislation, how would we even look at any different projects? Would everything just get approved no matter what? Notably they do not talk about any of the other major projects we have that could really grow our prosperity. There is no talk of things like a national electricity grid and what that could do to open up prosperity in many parts of the country, reduce electricity costs and open up new sectors.\n\nThe next act the Conservatives propose repealing is the Oil Tanker Moratorium Act. This piece of legislation, which was enacted in 2018, just formalizes what has been a half-century-long agreement of Canadian government after Canadian government. It is in place to do something very important; it is about making sure we are protecting some of the most dangerous waters in our entire country. When the Conservatives talk about why it needs to be repealed, they always bring up the northern gateway project, as if the act were the piece of legislation that caused that project not to proceed. In fact that project was so poorly put together, and the consultation with first nations was so deficient, that nine first nations challenged it in court and had it overturned.\n\nWhen Conservatives say that just removing these pieces of legislation would open up our economy and drive it forward, what they are really hoping is that if we do not consider the environment at all and completely put aside very real concerns that indigenous rights holders have, we can move ahead with these projects.\n\nThe next thing the Conservatives propose taking out is the federal industrial carbon tax. This has been in place in many different forms throughout our country. The first to bring it in was the Province of Alberta. It has led to tens of billions of dollars in investments in projects that have decarbonized our economy in really important growing sectors, as well as to finding ways to make our products less carbon-intensive, in many cases at the lowest possible cost.\n\nTo think that taking the tax away would make our economy more sovereign could not be farther from the truth. By getting rid of this type of mechanism, the country would face limited market access to the European Union as it brings in a carbon border adjustment because it wants its industries to be able to compete around the world. It has this new mechanism it is bringing in starting this year, and it is not the only country. The U.K. is proposing to bring one in. Australia, Taiwan and other countries are looking to do the same. What this would tie us to are countries that do not want to take action on climate.\n\nThe Conservatives also propose getting rid of the oil and gas emissions cap, but this is not even currently in place. Next they propose getting rid of the federal electric vehicle sales mandate. This is a mechanism that was put in place to ensure that Canadians can access electric vehicles. We see around the world that the adoption rate of electric vehicles is going through the roof. In Nepal it is 76%. In China it was 50% last year. The big barrier we have in Canada is that people cannot access the types of electric vehicles they want to buy.\n\nThis mechanism is about ensuring that those cars are available, which also leads companies to invest in the charging infrastructure that makes it better for everybody who has adopted the technology. It is also about ensuring not only that can we buy those cars here but also that more and more of those cars are manufactured here. It is a key part. We know that a key ask of several of the United States automakers is to scrap this program, but that would be a big mistake and would reduce the choice that a lot of Canadians are looking for right now.\n\nNext I want to talk about how the act would remove the federal plastics manufacturing prohibitions. It is important to call this what it is: It is about getting rid of the ban on certain single-use plastic items that were found to be harmful to the environment and to humans. These are things like plastic bags that are finding their way into our waterways, oceans and environment. How does it make our country more sovereign to have more and more waste in our environment?\n\nNext the proposed act talks about removing the federal regulatory restrictions that impede communication and advocacy by Canadian energy companies. Again, it is important to call this what it is: It is about removing the so-called greenwashing provisions, measures that every member of the House voted in favour of just two years ago. These are measures to ensure that when a company makes a claim about itself, it has to be able to back it up with evidence. Essentially this is to deal with false and misleading advertising. Again, I do not see how our country would be more sovereign if we give the ability to companies to lie about the products and services they are putting out there. All it would do is make our country less competitive and give an unfair advantage to companies not taking the action they say they are taking.\n\nThere are many things I would like to talk about, such as how we can make our country more sovereign, how we can improve our national defence, how we can make sure we buy more Canadian and how we can improve our infrastructure. I look forward to questions from my colleagues to that effect.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76671","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is a real honour to rise today for the first time in the calendar year 2026 to speak on behalf of the constituents of West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country.\n\nI wish all members of the House a very happy new year. I am looking forward to working in a spirit of collaboration as we get this year under way.\n\nI very much hope things will be different this year. Certainly th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a4fb796015fa20611d0833b1edd8363214b0ed12f23288c61ba569e2fda0d9c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94518113d30e0cb9e5851a93956250af4e661cdc19c3fc18d4e6554f8b7905e0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e46bd459088f6ad0af9adbb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76672,"date":"2026-01-27T21:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, that gives me the opportunity to correct the record on a myth that has been put out there by many, including the Conservative Party.\n\nFor over 50 years, there has been a moratorium in place on the travel of tankers through the Hecate Strait. It has been in place since 1972. There are no American tankers going through that area. They go around Vancouver Island. Getting rid of the oil tanker moratorium would not mean that we would have more American—\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nPatrick Weiler: Madam Speaker, these are the facts we are dealing with. I would encourage my colleagues from across the way to have a look at that in more detail.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76672","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, that gives me the opportunity to correct the record on a myth that has been put out there by many, including the Conservative Party.\n\nFor over 50 years, there has been a moratorium in place on the travel of tankers through the Hecate Strait. It has been in place since 1972. There are no American tankers going through that area. They go around Vancouver Island. Getting rid of the oil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","label":"Moratorium"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","label":"Moratorium","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["27f35e11ba30bb213b5961bc583c0b2b067d221881f9e39cb7712aa86bf5507b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9782423bc397d56f2a9a1d255ab7a5509d13a6f03e8246298950c449b18d980"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2895a2479d9919d1e67a0e93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76673,"date":"2026-01-27T21:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, my colleague mentioned some facts that are accurate. Most shareholders in many of the biggest oil companies are based in the United States. If we want greater sovereignty, we need to think about the interests being served by the companies we work with.\n\nHowever, I now know that we have a lot of opportunities to improve and diversify our economy. Our government has a plan to make this country a leader in clean energy. That is something we are going to do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76673","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, my colleague mentioned some facts that are accurate. Most shareholders in many of the biggest oil companies are based in the United States. If we want greater sovereignty, we need to think about the interests being served by the companies we work with.\n\nHowever, I now know that we have a lot of opportunities to improve and diversify our economy. Our government has a plan to make thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9fd0422fb47cb04d720225432c27104a231c2ab49788af448abd4fd0d91f1e7b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["598887930cc40bc80256d194ea22fe6040b88d801e598a5cf902bfcadee9540a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4941c5268192e99cbf17122","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76674,"date":"2026-01-27T21:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I do not disagree with the premise of my colleague's question. I think there are actually a lot of ways we can improve how the Impact Assessment Act operates and how it can be more predictable. Frankly, there were a lot of recommendations that came from the task force that looked into it, and I think we should be looking at those right now.\n\nThe act has been in place for about five years. We are looking at reviewing the Fisheries Act. I think it might be time to do the same with the Impact Assessment Act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76674","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I do not disagree with the premise of my colleague's question. I think there are actually a lot of ways we can improve how the Impact Assessment Act operates and how it can be more predictable. Frankly, there were a lot of recommendations that came from the task force that looked into it, and I think we should be looking at those right now.\n\nThe act has been in place for about five ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f299a4c73b6a3d3ba5ae5b98aa4488023dc2bd38bf43e72c03c5efc2d04f0f0f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf9cf0e9df4dcf18bf6aa277","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76675,"date":"2026-01-27T21:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the number of EVs that have come have met the quota that we have for this year, so this is not a pressing issue right now, but we want to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76675","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the number of EVs that have come have met the quota that we have for this year, so this is not a pressing issue right now, but we want to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6fb996a3d92226212d58129b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76676,"date":"2026-01-28T19:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour the extraordinary life of Vi Roden, who recently passed away at the age of 102. A World War II veteran, mother, friend and tireless community activist, Vi believed that if we see injustice, we must act, and she lived by that principle.\n\nIn 1978, after learning of abuses in the women's prison system, she famously phoned the Attorney General at home and made it clear that she would go to the press if action was not taken. He called back and listened, and a royal commission was launched, leading to meaningful reform.\n\nIn 1980 Vi raised the funds to establish British Columbia's first counselling centre for sexually abused children. That initiative grew into Act 2 Child and Family Services, which is now a $25.5-million non-profit serving Vancouver and the Fraser Valley.\n\nEven in her later years, Vi never slowed down. At the age of 101, she volunteered during the federal election campaign, as she had throughout her life, making hundreds of calls because she believed participation mattered.\n\nThe world needs more people like Vi Roden. May we honour her life by carrying her compassion forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76676","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour the extraordinary life of Vi Roden, who recently passed away at the age of 102. A World War II veteran, mother, friend and tireless community activist, Vi believed that if we see injustice, we must act, and she lived by that principle.\n\nIn 1978, after learning of abuses in the women's prison system, she famously phoned the Attorney General at home and made it cl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["57c556e4477b77d0b058151d4fe642ad344c1a75a0e621231331e1fb3fd080a2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5aa9b47c9b8086dc5b769bc53434e9d39e54d2d99d5aff77c207224989696538"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af188d24f914da696672264e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":79300,"date":"2026-02-02T22:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague from Long Range Mountains for her speech and for supporting Bill C-19.\n\nThe member opposite mentioned being honest about the impact of government policies. We have seen in the last year that gas prices have actually been reduced in Canada by about 17% to 20%. At the same time, we have seen grocery prices increase by about 5%.\n\nDoes she really believe that by reducing the industrial carbon tax, it is going to have a significant impact on reducing the price of groceries in Canada? We have already seen that the price of gas going down in Canada has not had that effect.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79300","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague from Long Range Mountains for her speech and for supporting Bill C-19.\n\nThe member opposite mentioned being honest about the impact of government policies. We have seen in the last year that gas prices have actually been reduced in Canada by about 17% to 20%. At the same time, we have seen grocery prices increase by about 5%.\n\nDoes she really believe that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","label":"Mountains","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["77096a35cf0410ae7fa89efd85bf76cdb95577c434f876f2ab381090866f67b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["699f220a90481d41f5b6d3b7bab78d73f287c75f2a7ac62201e61740f71bb5eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a11efa1b403694af8cfdc02","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288383,"date":"2026-02-13T18:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, before I begin, I want to recognize the profound loss being felt by the community of Tumbler Ridge. All members of the House grieve with the families who are mourning. We stand with the students, staff and first responders who are carrying the weight of this unimaginable tragedy. In times like these, we are reminded that in sorrow, we are united as a nation. Canada will hold them in our hearts, not just today and in the years to come, but always.\n\n I want to thank all of the members who have participated in this debate on Bill C-244, the clean coasts act, for their local leadership and for sharing the all-too-familiar stories that I am hearing in my riding as well.\n\n This bill is grounded in a simple principle. Canada's marine environment is not a dumping ground, and coastal communities should not be left carrying the cost of pollution that others create. In coastal regions across the country, residents see the impacts first-hand: abandoned and derelict vessels leaking fuel into harbours and marine infrastructure left to decay, spreading plastic pollution and releasing toxins into sensitive ecosystems. These are not abstract concerns. They affect navigation safety, local economies, indigenous food security and the health of our oceans and waterways.\n\n Bill C-244 proposes two practical solutions to address these problems. First, it amends the Canadian Environmental Protection Act to clarify that marine dumping is a strict liability offence. Because of how this legislation has been interpreted to date, liability is limited to cases where the prosecution can prove that this dumping was intentional. That leaves a troubling loophole where pollution from reckless or negligent behaviour goes unaddressed. The clean coasts act addresses this gap.\n\n Second, the bill strengthens the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act by addressing a well-known tactic. Too often, owners avoid their disposal responsibilities by transferring an end-of-life vessel, typically for a nominal amount, to someone that they know cannot dispose of it properly. That is how vessels become hazards in our waterways.\n\n Some members have raised fair and important questions about how these measures would work in practice, and I would like to respond directly to those.\n\n One question has been about seller liability. Let me be clear: This bill is not about punishing good-faith sellers or ordinary Canadians making responsible transactions. The intent is narrow. Liability rises only where a vessel is transferred knowingly or recklessly to someone who lacks the ability or intention to manage it responsibly. \n\nRelated to that is the question of how a seller can assess whether a buyer is fit. This bill does not require intrusive measures like interviews, credit checks or financial investigations. It requires reasonable care, not a guarantee of the future behaviour of an owner. The objective is to create clear, practical expectations that are not onerous for good-faith sellers while discouraging bad-faith transfers to avoid disposal costs. I just want to recognize that these were questions that came from the member for Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound and the member for Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay.\n\nMembers have also raised questions about enforcement and ownership tracking. We have good news. Since this debate started, Transport Canada has announced a modernization of the pleasure craft licensing system by introducing a five-year licence validity, a nominal fee for applications and renewals, and a requirement for owners to update their contact information within 30 days. However, the responsibility to report these transfers remains with the buyer. This has been a vulnerability that has been addressed by a number of members, including the member for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, and it needs to be addressed.\n\n While these licensing changes are a step forward, we need to make sure that there are sustainable long-term resources to deal with abandoned and derelict vessels where we cannot identify the owner. For that, we need the long-awaited vessel remediation fund, which will have a small user fee and will finance the removal and proper disposal of abandoned and sunken vessels. I just want to note that the member for Courtenay—Alberni brought this up as a need. I look forward to working with him. \n\nThere is also the member for Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères. These vessels should never linger in these places for five years or more.\n\nLastly, there was a concern brought forward by the member for Skeena—Bulkley Valley about the wording of the new strict liability offence. I just want to confirm that this will not affect people that would observe marine dumping. This is only for those who would lead to that by their acts or omissions.\n\n I would just say that all legislation improves through study. If this legislation proceeds to committee, members will have the opportunity to hear from experts, examine the provisions carefully and propose amendments as they see fit, including any measures that are necessary to clarify some of the measures in this act.\n\nWith that, I know this is a problem that all members know exists. I urge all members to support this legislation being sent to the next stage at committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Maritime law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288383","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, before I begin, I want to recognize the profound loss being felt by the community of Tumbler Ridge. All members of the House grieve with the families who are mourning. We stand with the students, staff and first responders who are carrying the weight of this unimaginable tragedy. In times like these, we are reminded that in sorrow, we are united as a nation. Canada will hold them in o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","label":"Water pollution"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","label":"Maritime law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Maritime law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Maritime law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","label":"Water pollution","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","label":"Maritime law","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d2e5cdccb69c86c2b160bb7c203d1bd91a5d75cef2ed596b01e544ddef582b80"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Maritime law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Maritime law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0bacc103d699ccc0436d7400a3939d722535ff8e2a8b18875b86ef33874bc362"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Maritime law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Maritime law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c6ac78484f66e349f7ca8f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":288384,"date":"2026-02-13T18:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to request a recorded division.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288384","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to request a recorded division.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Audiovisual equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","label":"Military communications","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","label":"Audiovisual equipment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["775e92b16ca0415a2e58fb0db749e37ee4f147be55c06696e3aa2eee12b418b1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5236fa5e85e4aef22f4fa7fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315068,"date":"2026-02-23T21:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think we are talking about two different things here. The member opposite mentioned the need to speed up housing writ large and to address a lot of the barriers that are at the municipal level. In fact, we have programs that are doing just that. One called the housing accelerator fund is helping municipalities speed up their permitting systems, and I have seen its impact across my riding. \n\nToday, we are talking about Build Canada Homes, which is an agency to build below-market units. We have a major need for this right across the country. I know the leader of the official opposition has called this Soviet-style housing, which he does not support, but this agency is meant for things like supportive or transitional housing for low-income folks. \n\nI am wondering if the member agrees that this is a need across the country and something that the federal government should be involved in supporting.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315068","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think we are talking about two different things here. The member opposite mentioned the need to speed up housing writ large and to address a lot of the barriers that are at the municipal level. In fact, we have programs that are doing just that. One called the housing accelerator fund is helping municipalities speed up their permitting systems, and I have seen its impact across my r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["22b715b749adf583a4fabccb89b14a18b9b89ab6f32920234ee41c5a836123a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c86e578765e993c4331baac5b45caef690c2a38d6118e539aed115675b4df970"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3e73b38a29c48df5d87378e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306987,"date":"2026-02-26T17:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I also represent a rural region and my riding is also experiencing a labour shortage. I know that the Leader of the Opposition wants to put an end to the temporary foreign worker program. In my riding, it is really important to bring in people from different parts of the world to offset the labour shortage. My colleague spoke of a grandfather clause for people who are already here. I would support that. I want to know what my colleague would do to address the labour shortage in his riding through the measures set out in the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306987","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I also represent a rural region and my riding is also experiencing a labour shortage. I know that the Leader of the Opposition wants to put an end to the temporary foreign worker program. In my riding, it is really important to bring in people from different parts of the world to offset the labour shortage. My colleague spoke of a grandfather clause for people who are already here. I ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82cdf2037f1edf990403b6cce9f02960ee326ef11825051c8d33ca6d5c90782a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4b0540e7e98b1c1e5e485b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386500,"date":"2026-03-23T20:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have the honour to present, in both official languages, three reports of the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans.\n\nFirst is the committee's fourth report, entitled \"Marine and Coastal Protections\".\n\nThe next is the fifth report, entitled \"Equal Opportunities for Coastal Communities: Attribution of Redfish Quotas and Exploratory Lobster Fishing Licenses\". Pursuant to Standing Order 109, the committee requests that the government table a comprehensive response to the fifth report.\n\nLast but not least is the sixth report, entitled \"Main Estimates 2026-27: Votes 1, 5 and 10 under Department of Fisheries and Oceans\".","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386500","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have the honour to present, in both official languages, three reports of the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans.\n\nFirst is the committee's fourth report, entitled \"Marine and Coastal Protections\".\n\nThe next is the fifth report, entitled \"Equal Opportunities for Coastal Communities: Attribution of Redfish Quotas and Exploratory Lobster Fishing Licenses\". Pursuant to Standing ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","label":"Aquatic ecosystems","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["971f6e2b3b8a8086821dd4087b1161ef8cee316b2aead22429b5c44a268707ce"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b48fa1679b3a7d3071ba855e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":386499,"date":"2026-03-24T16:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the parliamentary secretary, in his speech, talked about affordability and gave the real-world example of filling up his car just a week ago and how much that cost has increased. We have seen the price of a barrel of oil go up to almost $120.\n\nGiven that Canada has what some describe as the least fuel-efficient fleet in the entire world, we are seeing that cost right now. As part of the motion from the Conservative Party, the Conservatives are talking about making sure that we align our tailpipe standards with those of the U.S. Looking at this right now, in B.C., the average price of gas is over two dollars a litre, and that is costing people over $18 to drive 100 kilometres. If we had the European standard, it would be below $10 for that same run, and if people were driving an EV, it would be two dollars. \n\nI was hoping the member could speak to why we should maybe not go down the route of aligning our tailpipe standards with those of the U.S.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386499","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the parliamentary secretary, in his speech, talked about affordability and gave the real-world example of filling up his car just a week ago and how much that cost has increased. We have seen the price of a barrel of oil go up to almost $120.\n\nGiven that Canada has what some describe as the least fuel-efficient fleet in the entire world, we are seeing that cost right now. As part of t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0249a86e4945b1b6f4dea3fe987d0f3754d1dc461b4e2a75a7d94ab4370667d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cef6ead13df59d9b75d62255089d8d80ed266175a077f79a7fda7a3bc4a86f45"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8fa2e67826b2827c47fd122","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115849,"date":"2026-04-15T21:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 31 of the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I want to start by acknowledging that we are gathered on the ancestral and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people and by expressing gratitude that we are doing the important work of this committee on lands they've stewarded since time immemorial. Pursuant to Standing Order 108, the committee is meeting to commence its study on the factors determining the opening and closing dates of marine harvesting seasons. Today's meeting is being held in a hybrid format, in accordance with the rules of procedure. Members may participate in person or via Zoom. Before we continue, I would like to ask all in-person participants to consult the guidelines written on the cards on the table. The measures are in place to help prevent audio and feedback incidents and to protect the health and safety of all participants, but particularly the interpreters. Pursuant to our routine motions, I can advise all committee members that the witnesses appearing virtually have successfully completed the required technical testing. I'll make a few comments for the benefit of the witnesses and the members. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic, and please mute yourself when you're not speaking. Regarding interpretation, those participating in the meeting via Zoom can choose between floor, French or English at the bottom of their screen. Those in the room can use the earpiece and select the desired channel. This is a reminder that all comments should be addressed through the chair. With that, I'd like to welcome our witnesses. Appearing by video conference, from the Prince Edward Island Fishermen's Association, we have Ian MacPherson, executive director. In person, from the Sport Fishing Institute of BC, we have Owen Bird, executive director. We're going to begin with opening statements from the witnesses, for five minutes or less, starting with Mr. MacPherson.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115849","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 31 of the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I want to start by acknowledging that we are gathered on the ancestral and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people and by expressing gratitude that we are doing the important work of this committee on lands they've stewarded since time immemorial. Pursuant to Standing Order 10","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Audiovisual equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","label":"Audiovisual equipment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1db8ec8f0eacdba211ec74fcb570e3723bd5f263d6a4c2e36db946efa5d91c2b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["adf2ad3fdc9e3eb7d2ddcf64b43f84e31e0657163f34aba2a8f76272e5fc3494"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1eb3812eb52ed9203b40e2f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115850,"date":"2026-04-20T16:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Colleagues, I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 32 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I will start by acknowledging that we are gathered on the ancestral and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people and by expressing gratitude that we're doing the important work of this committee on lands they've stewarded since time immemorial. Pursuant to Standing Order 108, the committee is meeting to continue its study of the factors determining opening and closing dates of marine harvesting seasons. Pursuant to the Standing Orders, today's meeting is being held in a hybrid format. Members are attending in person in the room and remotely using the Zoom application. Before we continue, I would ask all in-person participants to consult the guidelines written on the table. Pursuant to our routine motions, I can advise committee members that all witnesses have gone through the required testing. For the benefit of members and witnesses, please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic, and please mute yourself when you are not speaking. Regarding interpretation, those participating via Zoom can choose between floor, English or French at the bottom of their screen. Those in the room can use the earpiece and select the desired channel. As a reminder, all comments should be addressed through the chair. For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. For members participating via Zoom, please use the \"raise hand\" function. The clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best we can, and we appreciate your patience in this regard. Before we go to our witnesses, Mr. Small wants to raise a point.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115850","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Colleagues, I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 32 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I will start by acknowledging that we are gathered on the ancestral and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people and by expressing gratitude that we're doing the important work of this committee on lands they've stewarded since time immemorial. Purs","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Audiovisual equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","label":"Audiovisual equipment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9080a18db3d9c01ec0bf39fb624cc260df2028c57efc5aa4c330068b364d2aa9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2594055aca0cddabd917d495","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300893,"date":"2026-04-20T19:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada has what the world wants to experience: stunning coastlines, dramatic mountains and natural beauty on a massive scale. From coast to coast to coast, it is not just landscapes; it is food, culture and distinct local experiences in every region. But what truly sets Canada apart is the spirit of its people: kind, welcoming and easy to connect with.\n\nFrom Newfoundland to Vancouver Island, a strong tourism industry powers communities across our country. In West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country, tourism is woven into the fabric of our life. Whistler's world-renowned mountains and the Sunshine Coast's stunning landscapes provide an unforgettable backdrop for visitors from across the globe.\n\nTourism is about more than just welcoming visitors. The industry helps support one in 10 Canadian jobs and contributes over $44 billion a year to Canada's economy. Coming off the best tourism year in our history, we realize that there is more to do for tourism to reach its full potential, and that is work for all members of the House to do together. \n\nWith that, I would like to wish all members a happy National Tourism Week.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300893","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada has what the world wants to experience: stunning coastlines, dramatic mountains and natural beauty on a massive scale. From coast to coast to coast, it is not just landscapes; it is food, culture and distinct local experiences in every region. But what truly sets Canada apart is the spirit of its people: kind, welcoming and easy to connect with.\n\nFrom Newfoundland to Vancouver ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","label":"Mountains"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","label":"Mountains","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cbac9760c9537d3995a7fb2a62f0c1c795ad4f2149acab1afbadc305525dc88f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d569bf0c69f93e529ec4a86af4f243f82da11932e57517cecae12eda27a12c5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a58d8b8a3d29cbdfd9599397","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115851,"date":"2026-04-22T21:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Colleagues, I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 33 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I want to start by acknowledging that we are gathered on the ancestral and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people and by expressing gratitude that we're doing the important work of this committee on lands they've stewarded since time immemorial. Pursuant to Standing Order 108, the committee is meeting to continue its study of Atlantic mackerel and Atlantic herring fisheries. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Members are attending in person in the room and remotely using the Zoom application. Before we continue, I would like to ask our in-person participants to consult the guidelines written on the cards on the table. These measures are in place to help prevent audio and feedback incidents and to protect the health and safety of all participants but particularly the interpreters. Pursuant to our routine motions, I can advise the committee members that all witnesses appearing virtually have successfully completed the required technical testing. I have just a few comments for the benefit of members and witnesses. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic. Please mute yourself when you're not speaking. For interpretation for those on Zoom, you have the choice, at the bottom of your screen, of floor, English or French. For those in the room, you can use the earpiece and select the desired channel. For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. For members on Zoom, please use the \"raise hand\" function. The clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best we can, and we appreciate your patience. Before I welcome the witnesses, I will note for members right from the start that we probably won't have time to go in camera today, because we're ending the committee at 6 p.m. With that, I'd like to welcome our witnesses. Participating by video conference, we have Barry Darby; Dylan MacIntyre, fisherman; and Dr. Erin Carruthers, senior fisheries scientist from the Fish, Food and Allied Workers Union. From the Maritime Fishermen's Union, we have Martin Mallet, executive director, and Louis Ferguson, assistant director, Homarus. They are both here in person. With that, we will begin our opening statements from witnesses. We will start with you, Mr. Darby. You have five minutes or less.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115851","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Colleagues, I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 33 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I want to start by acknowledging that we are gathered on the ancestral and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people and by expressing gratitude that we're doing the important work of this committee on lands they've stewarded since time immemorial. P","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cd69568cd0b5e91e5e027be7963bf7352ba876dea13f948c21309f3f172328ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b41db904f1dd1edd39e18fd95b19ccc4cadb7cc1974db4612a1ca4ceb7370857"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c294afe3130861438e3c18ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115852,"date":"2026-04-27T16:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Colleagues, we're back. We're now in public. We can continue our consideration of the first version of the report on the review of the Fisheries Act. As usual, the analysts may ask for clarifications to make sure they understand the requested changes as we review the report. I see that Mr. Gunn has his hand up.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115852","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Colleagues, we're back. We're now in public. We can continue our consideration of the first version of the report on the review of the Fisheries Act. As usual, the analysts may ask for clarifications to make sure they understand the requested changes as we review the report. I see that Mr. Gunn has his hand up.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3e140f6ed1696f1a11cecd8b736d8072f17d5b4417eb16a54b6ddf09ab3eea0e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9beb05ced78b790de53ab87b630a3cfac1762022f99d552d156760bd92ddc90c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e48486bfbbca8fe169ccfab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115853,"date":"2026-04-29T21:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 35 of the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I want to start by acknowledging that we're gathered on the ancestral and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people, and by expressing gratitude that we're doing the important work of this committee on lands they've stewarded since time immemorial. I also want to welcome two new members to our committee. I welcome the Honourable Hedy Fry. Welcome back, Mr. d'Entremont. Today, pursuant to Standing Order 108, the committee is meeting to continue its study of recreational and traditional fishing for softshell clams. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Members are attending in person in the room and remotely using the Zoom application. Before we continue, I would like all in-person participants to consult the guidelines written on the cards. The measures are in place to help prevent audio and feedback incidents, and to protect the health and safety of all participants, particularly the interpreters. I will advise members that all witnesses appearing virtually have done the required technical testing. I have a few comments for the benefit of witnesses and members. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating via video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic. Also, please mute yourself when you're not speaking. For interpretation, for those on Zoom, you have the choice at the bottom of your screen of floor, English or French. For those in the room, you can use the earpiece and select the desired channel. This is a reminder that all comments should be addressed through the chair. I'd like to welcome our witnesses. From the Canadian Food Inspection Agency, we have Evelyn Soo, director general, food safety and consumer protection directorate. From the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, we have Alistair Struthers, director, aquaculture policy and regulatory affairs. By video conference, from DFO, we have Céline Gaudet, regional director general, gulf region; and Sylvain Vézina, regional director general, Quebec region. From the Department of Environment, we have Joanne Volk, director general, environmental science directorate; as well as Arash Shahsavarani, director, emergencies and marine science division. We will move into opening statements from the witnesses. You have five minutes or less. We'll begin with Ms. Soo.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115853","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 35 of the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I want to start by acknowledging that we're gathered on the ancestral and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people, and by expressing gratitude that we're doing the important work of this committee on lands they've stewarded since time immemorial. I also want to welcome two new","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","label":"Safety education","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75df7ed91f1b1f9c4712a40ae443c6b6c46cc5c67dd0b6dbde1fe50c4efe81c1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["81b3a3f0a7bba4018d44ce6840dba862a6acd91674e3724b3d2270ead154170c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34656ef61d49a1e840629415","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115854,"date":"2026-05-04T16:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"I would like to nominate my neighbour and my colleague, the honourable Hedy Fry, for the chair position.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115854","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to nominate my neighbour and my colleague, the honourable Hedy Fry, for the chair position.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["008b5541f511f878b8f656182f07825485d59d2b6f8c58badd802b0a9e330cf4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e32e79d3a3ac11058b1f40d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115855,"date":"2026-05-04T16:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. I want to thank our officials for being here in person and also by video conference to answer questions. I want to pick up on a very local concern for me and my constituents. In this study, we've heard from witnesses who have pointed to some localized science and monitoring in Howe Sound, indicating a very low interaction risk of stocks of concern. They referenced a DFO stock assessment in 2022, which found that encounters of Fraser River stocks of concern were very rare, posing near zero risk in Howe Sound. They pointed to a DFO-led reference fishery in 2024, which sampled 354 adult chinook in April and May and found that none identified as originating from the Fraser River stocks of concern. Obviously, a limited mark-selective fishery in this area would deliver significant social and economic benefits, and it's been a big frustration for folks locally that there haven't been retention opportunities. Given the testimony and the available data, what is the primary factor currently preventing DFO from authorizing any retention opportunities in Howe Sound? To what extent is the current non-retention decision driven by biological risk specific to Howe Sound, versus the application of the broader precautionary principle or other management constraints?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115855","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. I want to thank our officials for being here in person and also by video conference to answer questions. I want to pick up on a very local concern for me and my constituents. In this study, we've heard from witnesses who have pointed to some localized science and monitoring in Howe Sound, indicating a very low interaction risk of stocks of concern. They referenced a DFO stock ass","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c03f393820f0a3a02e3c53d27606ffbc7e200f884743c8ef37e076a5631134a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ead474f30b06a77173275e2af7c29a26d823b8a621d010f898f4c76b3cf2018c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f550f99b0348a52a1f172f53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115856,"date":"2026-05-04T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Vigneault. That's some encouraging testimony to hear. I was wondering whether you might be able to speak to what specific evidence, thresholds or changes in conditions would be required for DFO to consider opening up a limited controlled-retention fishery in that area?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115856","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Vigneault. That's some encouraging testimony to hear. I was wondering whether you might be able to speak to what specific evidence, thresholds or changes in conditions would be required for DFO to consider opening up a limited controlled-retention fishery in that area?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","label":"Fishing permits","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e4bcde3cf60a705ad66a9d9b687f232cdbb8e69c4662ef6eb3bd1d5c551d3322"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb42b0aeefc579acce794f34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115857,"date":"2026-05-04T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. I'm going to switch gears and bring up a point that was brought up earlier, which is the rush to get to these fisheries as they're opening up and some of the challenges with in-season decision-making and communication. I was hoping you might be able to speak to how Fisheries and Oceans is improving the timeliness, predictability and communication of in-season opening decisions, particularly for small commercial harvesters who oftentimes, and certainly this is the case for harvesters from my riding, face long travel times and financial risk from uncertain or late announcements.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115857","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I'm going to switch gears and bring up a point that was brought up earlier, which is the rush to get to these fisheries as they're opening up and some of the challenges with in-season decision-making and communication. I was hoping you might be able to speak to how Fisheries and Oceans is improving the timeliness, predictability and communication of in-season opening decisions, particul","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6a024650eeaa0dd9713f04fdf3d035451df2e4b7fa4e4902c172e063ef691a8f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ced252eca8fb06e15cab6e6722f46d4a5dc4a85daa209df797905513917d3499"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6a6c49507a6e38dd656742b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115858,"date":"2026-05-04T17:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I want to pick up on something that my colleague, Mr. Klassen, brought up about mass marking. With the announcement that was made almost exactly a month ago, what concrete changes should harvesters expect in terms of mark-selective fishing opportunities? In what fisheries in particular, if there are particular regions in B.C., can we expect to see those changes first?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115858","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I want to pick up on something that my colleague, Mr. Klassen, brought up about mass marking. With the announcement that was made almost exactly a month ago, what concrete changes should harvesters expect in terms of mark-selective fishing opportunities? In what fisheries in particular, if there are particular regions in B.C., can we expect to see those changes first?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d238ef3e9137e66f92b319378eac3cec60b04b757ba6bb8743c2dba95b909938"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb4aa7522c921959b217026222006f4a87f65e75b36f1c65427f7f198a806d93"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-51c574e7d93c57ca2871764d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115859,"date":"2026-05-04T17:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. You mentioned terminal fisheries. Could you please elaborate what you meant by that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115859","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. You mentioned terminal fisheries. Could you please elaborate what you meant by that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebf05c8d63ca10f44e8273ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115860,"date":"2026-05-04T17:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"That's very helpful. You mentioned the lead-in timeline, the four years or so that we're looking at, once we have mass marking, for when some of those changes can be put into practice. What are some of the operational or regulatory steps that would need to take place before those changes are reflected in new opportunities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115860","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's very helpful. You mentioned the lead-in timeline, the four years or so that we're looking at, once we have mass marking, for when some of those changes can be put into practice. What are some of the operational or regulatory steps that would need to take place before those changes are reflected in new opportunities?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a21fff1d785e693e89aec087e9968d6a437e3a136e0496fa1a7d867aac211866"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ef134ab1d4041fd91aa3ac8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115861,"date":"2026-05-04T17:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115861","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-045aeb362a23fa1bd155dda2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":946075,"date":"2026-05-05T15:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present petition 451-00927.\n\n The petitioners, including constituents of mine from the Sunshine Coast, want to draw attention to the fact that long COVID affects approximately 1.4 million Canadians, causing significant health and economic burdens. The amyloid microclot test is supported by global research. It can identify clots linked to long COVID, enabling targeted therapies. The test has not yet been approved by Health Canada, delaying access to critical diagnostics due to regulatory and validation barriers.\n\nThe petitioners state that Canadians deserve equitable access to diagnostics to address long COVID's impact.\n\nThe petitioners call upon Canada to prioritize the validation and approval of flow cytometry of amyloid microclots as a reference test, to consider funding a pilot program and to implement regulatory reforms to streamline the approval process for lab-developed tests addressing unmet medical needs like long COVID.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Coronavirus diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:946075","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present petition 451-00927.\n\n The petitioners, including constituents of mine from the Sunshine Coast, want to draw attention to the fact that long COVID affects approximately 1.4 million Canadians, causing significant health and economic burdens. The amyloid microclot test is supported by global research. It can identify clots linked to long COVID, enabling targeted t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","label":"Coronavirus diseases"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Coronavirus diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","label":"Coronavirus diseases","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c9045a19d8f653d372cf58d5fe84a850243944287a817bf62da3a68066701550"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Coronavirus diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8409f0fdb12caf1fa00fdc68a5e9b8ac3b8473429ab143ea65b835c074082c86"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Coronavirus diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Coronavirus diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6de872863fa3316136e7d3c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035396,"date":"2026-05-25T21:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the spring economic update has some important new measures on the housing front: a $7-billion investment in the apartment construction loan program to build below-market rental units, and changes to the homebuyers plan.\n\nJust yesterday I met a couple: Jack, a civil engineer, and Sophie, a youth counsellor. They just bought a new home, and they are very realistic about the costs that they are facing right now with some affordability pressures. I was hoping that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Prime Minister could speak a bit more about the measures in Bill C-30 and the spring economic update on housing, and how these are going to improve the outlook for young Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035396","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the spring economic update has some important new measures on the housing front: a $7-billion investment in the apartment construction loan program to build below-market rental units, and changes to the homebuyers plan.\n\nJust yesterday I met a couple: Jack, a civil engineer, and Sophie, a youth counsellor. They just bought a new home, and they are very realistic about the costs that t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f18ecc79324da3628b18ae5b97ca9f9cc86a1ea967a2dbc634ff106dba65d908"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["38aa7d46a805412cc33a8421768c727137f544200a33f3844b5473488db14c98"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-407b2409a6a1d9c1ca90a3a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115862,"date":"2026-06-01T17:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thanks to the witnesses for being here today. I have a number of questions for Mr. Fisher. The Fraser salmon management documents emphasize that in-season decisions are made iteratively as the new test fishery and escapement data becomes available. In practice, how quickly can those updates be translated into changes in the recreational or commercial openings?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115862","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thanks to the witnesses for being here today. I have a number of questions for Mr. Fisher. The Fraser salmon management documents emphasize that in-season decisions are made iteratively as the new test fishery and escapement data becomes available. In practice, how quickly can those updates be translated into changes in the recreational or commercial openings?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d748e904174e4448492138b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115863,"date":"2026-06-01T17:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"I understand how frequently they meet, but how frequently does the new data actually lead to changes in the fishery itself?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115863","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand how frequently they meet, but how frequently does the new data actually lead to changes in the fishery itself?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6b13d1d568c323d88e9a854281eb070b4f41fc711ffa24c2a6ac7d1516f31b1d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e2b1c74e6722314d8f735ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115864,"date":"2026-06-01T17:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. In your view, should there be clearer thresholds or rules for when a concern over a particular stock justifies limiting access to other, healthier stocks—say, in a mixed-stock fishery—particularly in the Fraser, but also more broadly in B.C.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115864","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. In your view, should there be clearer thresholds or rules for when a concern over a particular stock justifies limiting access to other, healthier stocks—say, in a mixed-stock fishery—particularly in the Fraser, but also more broadly in B.C.?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037228","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Stock markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037228","label":"Stock markets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e5ee9b6082a987177a8a69f3eb47bbe2c10df1c3d3d1062f6fe5663785b4f252"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b7189e65e092954edb7309f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115865,"date":"2026-06-01T17:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. As my last question here, Fraser management is often described as requiring coordination among first nations fisheries, commercial interests, recreational fisheries and conservation objectives. When those groups have different interpretations of in-season data, how does that affect the speed of decision-making?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115865","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. As my last question here, Fraser management is often described as requiring coordination among first nations fisheries, commercial interests, recreational fisheries and conservation objectives. When those groups have different interpretations of in-season data, how does that affect the speed of decision-making?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3aeeabc129e8824e6c6ebf4abb36d631eea860fbe2ee05cbdc0336e6d1598c7b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bea9f3b33356b4cd4260de5bf541a45a6d91fe90f9efd3b675aed1f5a7482234"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-301938a9d1de1ab99d9c6f1a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085965,"date":"2026-06-09T19:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, June is National Indigenous History Month, a time to celebrate the histories, cultures, languages and contributions of first nations, Inuit and Métis people across Canada.\n\n In my riding of West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country, we live on the ancestral and unceded territories of the Squamish, shíshálh, Líl̓wat and N'Quatqua nations. Archeological evidence from B.C. shows that indigenous peoples have lived on these lands for more than 14,000 years, representing one of the longest continuous human histories anywhere in the world.\n\n This month, communities across our region are coming together to celebrate indigenous history and culture. Whether attending syíyaya Days on the Sunshine Coast, joining National Indigenous Peoples Day celebrations at the Squamish Lil'wat Cultural Centre or learning about indigenous history from a guided Talaysay Tour in West Vancouver, there are many opportunities to learn from and celebrate the first peoples of these lands.\n\nI encourage all Canadians to take this opportunity to listen, learn and celebrate the rich indigenous heritage that continues to shape our communities and our country.\n\n [Member spoke in Ucwalmícwts]","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085965","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, June is National Indigenous History Month, a time to celebrate the histories, cultures, languages and contributions of first nations, Inuit and Métis people across Canada.\n\n In my riding of West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country, we live on the ancestral and unceded territories of the Squamish, shíshálh, Líl̓wat and N'Quatqua nations. Archeological evidence from B.C. shows t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1d89d3ddf13ae2c256e3a23a0d56c00410eca24319d81d0254877efc7e8a2bee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f856532ae65d4e022b5f6877dd9e5f04e191f8e7fb03a12ce294b8c343565543"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-628f04c95ff9b9c3879f3b21","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087881,"date":"2026-06-15T21:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise in the House on behalf of the people of West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country to speak to Bill C-30, the spring economic update implementation act. \n\nAt a time of global uncertainty, our government is focused on what we can control here at home: building a stronger, more resilient economy, making life more affordable and creating opportunities for the next generation. This is exactly what Bill C-30 would advance.\n\nCanada is already emerging as one of the world's most attractive destinations for investment. Foreign direct investment reached nearly $97 billion last year, which is the highest level in almost two decades. Surveys of global investors are showing that Canada is the most attractive place for infrastructure investment. \n\nWe will need that investment, as our government understands that Canada cannot be overly dependent on one market. For decades, roughly 70% of our exports have gone to the United States. Bill C-30 is part of a broader effort to strengthen Canada's economic sovereignty by diversifying trade, supporting domestic industry and investing in Canadian productivity. Since last year alone, non-U.S. exports have increased by more than 40%, while exports to Europe continue to grow significantly.\n\nImportantly, this legislation recognizes that economic growth matters only if Canadians can actually feel it in their everyday lives. That begins with housing. Across my riding, housing affordability remains one of the defining issues that people raise with me. Young Canadians are wondering whether they will ever be able to buy a house in the communities they grew up in, while families are struggling with rising rents and housing shortages. The spring economic update responds by providing more than $7 billion in low-cost financing through the apartment construction loan program to accelerate the building of thousands of low-cost rental units across the country. Since 2019, this program has already financed over 300 below-market units in the Sea to Sky region alone. I have heard countless stories of how this has changed people's lives, from allowing people to live closer to work to allowing low-income workers to save money for their retirement for the first time.\n\nThe homes and the infrastructure Canada needs do not build themselves. If Canada wants to build the housing, infrastructure, transportation and clean energy projects we talk about so often, we need skilled workers, and many more of them. This is why one of the most important components of the spring economic update is the investment in skilled trades and apprenticeships. The government is launching a nationwide effort to recruit, train and hire up to 100,000 new Red Seal skilled trades workers by 2031 through the team Canada strong program. This creates a direct pathway for young Canadians into rewarding, well-paying careers while helping address labour shortages that are delaying projects across the country. This will support Canadians through the entire process, from discovering the trades to apprenticeship opportunities, completing the technical training and ultimately achieving Red Seal certification. It is also about reducing barriers by simplifying and accelerating the certification pathway so more Canadians can enter this workforce faster.\n\nBill C-30 would also improve labour mobility for tradespeople by increasing the labour mobility deduction from $4,000 to $10,000, lowering the threshold to access it and making it easier for workers to go where their skills are needed most. For workers who spend weeks away from home helping build critical infrastructure and housing, this matters.\n\nThis legislation also contains targeted affordability measures that would make a meaningful difference for Canadians. Between mortgage payments, rising living costs and uncertainty about the future, many young Canadians are feeling stretched thin even after reaching the major milestone of buying a new home. Measures in Bill C-30 like extending the repayment grace period under the homebuyers' plan would provide relief to homeowners to ease pressure during those early critical years of home ownership. Bill C-30 would also reduce the CPP contribution rates beginning next year, helping workers and businesses keep more money in their pockets.\n\nWhile individually these changes may seem modest, in combination with recent measures like cutting Canadian income taxes, cutting the GST on new homes for first-time homebuyers and the groceries and essentials benefit, together they would help lower the pressure on Canadians who are already facing high costs.\n\nThis legislation would also expand support for volunteer tax clinics that help vulnerable Canadians access the benefits they are entitled to. I want to give a special shout-out to Louis and the volunteers behind the local tax clinic on the Sunshine Coast, whose work helps over 3,000 residents each year access benefits and support they might otherwise miss. Their work is a powerful example of community service in action and demonstrates how local volunteers can make a difference in people's lives.\n\nAt a time when global instability has contributed to rising fuel prices, Bill C-30 temporarily removes the federal excise tax on gasoline, diesel and aviation fuel until Labour Day. This is already saving Canadian drivers about 10¢ a litre and providing direct relief at the pump for the families and businesses already dealing with many pressures. In places like Sea to Sky and the Sunshine Coast, residents continue to face inexplicably high gas prices. At all times, but especially right now, the Competition Bureau should be keeping a very close eye on anti-competitive behaviour and potential price manipulation in regional fuel markets like this one, because Canadians deserve fairness, transparency and confidence that they are not paying artificially high fuel prices.\n\nBill C-30 would support Canadian brewers by extending the 50% reduction on excise duty rates for the first 15,000 hectolitres of beer brewed in Canada. That is an amount that covers the full production for over 94% of breweries in our country. For small brewers in my riding, like Coast Mountain Brewing, the Persephone Brewing Company and Backcountry Brewing, this provides meaningful savings that can be reinvested into local jobs, equipment, expansion and community events.\n\nThis legislation recognizes the importance of investing in coastal communities and marine infrastructure. Our government is investing nearly $1 billion in small craft harbours and critical infrastructure that supports fisheries, transportation, tourism and local economies. I have heard first-hand from many harbours, including the Gibsons Landing Harbour Authority, about the growing pressures facing them and the need for upgrades to support increased commercial fish harvesting and future transportation demands. At Gibsons Landing, this includes the planned electric passenger ferry service that could help provide much-needed relief for Sunshine Coast residents.\n\nAt the same time, economic development must go hand in hand with environmental stewardship. Bill C-30 includes more than $160 million over five years to continue protecting Canada's whales and marine habitats on all three coasts. This would build on Canada's broader $3.8-billion nature strategy and the commitment to protect biodiversity and marine ecosystems for future generations. Last month's announcement of a new marine protected area in British Columbia the size of Prince Edward Island reinforces the importance of stewardship of our oceans while maintaining access to sustainable fish harvesting and tourism opportunities. My constituents understand that protecting marine ecosystems is not separate from economic prosperity, but essential to it, because healthy oceans support fisheries, tourism, recreation and coastal livelihoods.\n\nFood security is another key priority addressed in this legislation. As the Prime Minister said in Davos, food security is national security and, \"A country that cannot feed itself, fuel itself, or defend itself has few options.\" In an increasingly unstable world, shaped by supply chain disruptions, climate pressures and geopolitical instability, Canada must strengthen its domestic food production capacity. Bill C-30 and measures in the spring economic update would support that goal through supporting food production and distribution networks and, importantly, by providing immediate expensing of new greenhouse infrastructure. \n\nI have already seen how this is making a difference in my riding. The Líl̓wat Nation broke ground on a greenhouse at one end of it. On the Sunshine Coast, projects like Swiya Farms in Sechelt are focused on building large-scale, sustainable local food systems and supporting community-driven agriculture and long-term food resilience, including a large-scale greenhouse that is being planned.\n\nThese are measures we are building on with last week's announcement of Canada's national food security strategy, which will increase competition to lower grocery prices, boost domestic production year-round and help local products get onto grocery shelves.\n\nI also want to highlight the investment in sports and recreation in the spring economic update. In my riding, we know first-hand the lasting impact sport can have on communities. The 2010 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games left a legacy that extends far beyond infrastructure. They inspired participation, strengthened community pride, supported tourism and created opportunities for young athletes right across the region. We have seen world-class athletes emerge from our communities, including Marielle Thompson and Trinity Ellis, but the true legacy of sports goes beyond medals. It inspires young people to get active, build confidence, develop teamwork and resilience and connect with their communities. That is why the spring economic update has a historic $755-million investment in Canadian sport that would strengthen communities and new sports programs to support national sports organizations and athletes, improve safe sport initiatives and help Canada host major sporting events. \n\n I can see my time is running short, so I will say Bill C-30 is ultimately about building a more resilient, affordable and self-reliant Canada. It would invest in housing, workers, infrastructure, affordability, coastal communities, food security and environmental stewardship.\n\n Together, we can build confidently, deliberately and together.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087881","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise in the House on behalf of the people of West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country to speak to Bill C-30, the spring economic update implementation act. \n\nAt a time of global uncertainty, our government is focused on what we can control here at home: building a stronger, more resilient economy, making life more affordable and creating opportunities for th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ebaffb5a5622b3b87eda48a4335bc6171e0e7a068d18d7ff6292e5b97711c3a4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["40d335e9011a010a20348aa8f22b8d96c246482cee0c31eaa3cb8676a351db41"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7419e32f062a0c16deaf4dbc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087882,"date":"2026-06-15T21:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, oftentimes, we hear concerns from members on the other side about government spending. They seem to forget that many of the factors contributing to the affordability challenges in Canada have to do with external factors, like the trade war we are in right now.\n\nI can tell the member that our investments, including the investments in this spring economic update, like the apartment construction loan program, are making a meaningful difference. They are making life more affordable and they are tackling the main issue driving affordability challenges, which is housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087882","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, oftentimes, we hear concerns from members on the other side about government spending. They seem to forget that many of the factors contributing to the affordability challenges in Canada have to do with external factors, like the trade war we are in right now.\n\nI can tell the member that our investments, including the investments in this spring economic update, like the apartment cons","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ed05c42b5a2d8f9d7ed382cc3ba2435241ce119a4acea87ff284e4324ac9ad7a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["894da60b56acea505c3ded1dfc4310e11c0cc2b7edfde61c0ead9e9b6db6635e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a145f161042b1aebb0b6469","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087883,"date":"2026-06-15T21:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in my speech, I did indeed say a great deal about nature. I believe my riding is the most beautiful riding in the country.\n\nI spoke about the significant investments being made to protect whales and about the measures set out in the nature strategy. I know there are other points my colleague raised regarding pesticides, and I hope that, in committee, we will have the opportunity to investigate this properly to see if there are measures that can help mitigate the difficulties.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087883","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in my speech, I did indeed say a great deal about nature. I believe my riding is the most beautiful riding in the country.\n\nI spoke about the significant investments being made to protect whales and about the measures set out in the nature strategy. I know there are other points my colleague raised regarding pesticides, and I hope that, in committee, we will have the opportunity to in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","label":"Whales"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","label":"Whales","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13735bf61d4a11ba9f98d49550860ca605013849b799dc0c08e0b18a4ec4afce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a10ac512c8fed19986082908b4cda95d9c750d4c4b4735ab5b8ebb19db4da8a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff0b4acca98380a3c85a8872","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087884,"date":"2026-06-15T21:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, certainly, the groceries and essentials benefit is going to be a major benefit for Canadians. It is up to $1,890 for a family of four. This is going to help with the high price of groceries right now, while we roll out our national food security strategy. This gets to some of the more underlining, foundational things we need to change, like more competition in the sector and giving more resources to the Competition Bureau to allow that, and making sure that we are building up our domestic supply chains to ensure that we can get more local products on the shelves.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087884","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, certainly, the groceries and essentials benefit is going to be a major benefit for Canadians. It is up to $1,890 for a family of four. This is going to help with the high price of groceries right now, while we roll out our national food security strategy. This gets to some of the more underlining, foundational things we need to change, like more competition in the sector and giving mo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["45fba636eac22289a289978c048e91b40cebbd0cd80edfc0d598e940e2b4944f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["affc920bdb7d61296840e222a272492b5ed99ee8c285d3cb8cd0042f75c2e3be"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ada3b24bdeb754bdda87b256","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087885,"date":"2026-06-15T21:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will always support more funding going to our ferry system in British Columbia, but I think we need to remember that one is an interprovincial system and one is an intraprovincial system. There is federal jurisdiction to go in between provinces, and there have been significant investments in buying new ferries in the last couple of years. That works out to a benefit of over $700 million, which is actually more than Marine Atlantic is getting for its infrastructure.\n\n I think those things need to be kept in mind, but I will always support more money to make sure that we have a better ferry service in British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087885","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will always support more funding going to our ferry system in British Columbia, but I think we need to remember that one is an interprovincial system and one is an intraprovincial system. There is federal jurisdiction to go in between provinces, and there have been significant investments in buying new ferries in the last couple of years. That works out to a benefit of over $700 mil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fc3cac42e9653898177cb4fab55302f31c196d02c8405d67f5dff08b1ae3d673"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["275b4a109c6948cceb7d9c0c384e636b1e5c6c13d02f9224e4bc7929ed830a37"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75ae9139c75e6c56ec6d805d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115812,"date":"2026-06-16T20:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair and members of the environment and sustainable development committee. It's a real pleasure to be with you today to discuss my private member's bill, Bill C-244 , the clean coasts act. I see some familiar faces, including from the fisheries and oceans committee. I see Mr. Arnold. These issues we're going to be talking about today are issues felt by many coastal communities, including my own in the riding of West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country, where we know the marine environment is inseparable from our communities, our local economies and our way of life. Over the years, I've heard consistently from local governments, first nations, harbour authorities, commercial operators, search and rescue personnel, the Coast Guard and, particularly, residents about the growing challenges posed by abandoned vessels and marine pollution. The clean coasts act would respond to this by addressing two specific gaps in federal legislation that coastal communities continue to encounter in dealing with these long-standing frustrations. The first relates to abandoned vessels. In 2019, Parliament adopted the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act. In so doing, it established new protections, making it illegal, for the first time, to abandon a vessel. Crazily, you could actually abandon a vessel before that without committing an offence. Experience has shown that since then, vessel owners have found ways to avoid their responsibilities under the act. Rather than properly disposing of vessels at the end of their useful life, I've encountered countless examples of unscrupulous boat owners transferring them, usually for nominal amounts, to individuals who lack the means, capacity or intent to operate, maintain or dispose of them responsibly. These are oftentimes vulnerable individuals who are simply looking for a roof over their heads. In many cases, these vessels continue to deteriorate, creating risks to human safety, navigation and the marine environment. I've seen examples of loss of life, even in my own riding, when these vessels sink. There are many cases of communities and taxpayers bearing the cost of cleaning up toxic waste and other pollutants that come out of these vessels when they sink. At major expense, the taxpayer then pays to clean those vessels up off the bottom of the ocean. The clean coasts act seeks to close this loophole by strengthening accountability at the point of transfer. It would prohibit vessel owners from transferring ownership when they know or are reckless as to whether the recipient lacks the ability, resources or intent to prevent the vessel from becoming wrecked, abandoned or hazardous. One way of doing this is by creating a system whereby the boat seller will disclose the condition of the boat before selling it, and the boat purchaser will disclose how they intend to maintain and operate it. This would build on the existing system we have for vessel registration. This proposal complements the recent improvements that were made to that very system by Transport Canada and the pleasure craft licence system to strengthen ownership records and vessel traceability. Together, these measures will help improve accountability throughout the life cycle of the vessel. The second issue in the bill relates to marine pollution. At its core, it's guided by the principle that Canada's marine environment should not become a dumping ground, and coastal communities should not be bearing the costs of pollution caused by others. We see the impacts of deteriorating marine infrastructure when it breaks apart and enters marine ecosystems. We see them when aging docks and other structures release debris into our waterways. Most visibly, we see them when oil and other pollutants are released into the marine environment. A well-known example occurred in English Bay in 2015, when a bunker oil fuel spill caused significant environmental and economic damage. Despite the consequences, establishing the liability proved very challenging, because the existing provisions focus heavily on proving intent. The court found that there was a mens rea requirement involved in that, so the proposed amendment to the Canadian Environmental Protection Act seeks to clarify marine dumping provisions so that accountability doesn't depend solely on proving that intent to pollute when harmful substances are entering the marine environment. It would allow someone who is spilling to still establish due diligence and that they took all reasonable measures. In closing, Bill C-244 , the clean coasts act, is not a complete solution. Preventing abandonment and strengthening accountability are important steps, but they must be accompanied by other practical measures that support responsible vessel disposal, recycling and cleanup efforts. For that, the long-awaited vessel remediation fund is needed. This is a practical and targeted bill. It builds on existing federal legislation, addresses gaps that have emerged through experience and focuses on preventing environmental harm before communities are left to deal with the consequences when they are much more expensive. With that, I look forward to the committee's study and would be pleased to answer any questions that members have. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115812","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair and members of the environment and sustainable development committee. It's a real pleasure to be with you today to discuss my private member's bill, Bill C-244 , the clean coasts act. I see some familiar faces, including from the fisheries and oceans committee. I see Mr. Arnold. These issues we're going to be talking about today are issues felt by many coastal communities, i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035608","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035608","label":"Hazardous waste","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["77a93ff611a8d21347f1e1c3caca73dce942ffa24dc7df81f6209c464123bb37"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["022b338f631f3d662546f7b6e16f075ec893317e919452efa4cacbfb3f0167dc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4c1d2bf202c975ba2af801a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115813,"date":"2026-06-16T20:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"The legislative process for the WAHV Act took place before I was elected. There are things, looking back on it now, that should have been included. This is one part of that. I think it is an unintended consequence. When you prevent people from abandoning their vessels, they're going to find a way around some of their new obligations of properly disposing of them. This is very complementary, and, of course, it builds on what's already in the act. In a perfect world, that would have been addressed from the get-go, but it is incumbent on us to address it now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115813","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The legislative process for the WAHV Act took place before I was elected. There are things, looking back on it now, that should have been included. This is one part of that. I think it is an unintended consequence. When you prevent people from abandoning their vessels, they're going to find a way around some of their new obligations of properly disposing of them. This is very complementary, and, o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42e6214f8049e45f64697a83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115814,"date":"2026-06-16T20:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"What this section does is clarify that this is now a strict liability offence. You wouldn't have a bystander seeing something happening and then being caught under this. This would be just the actual source of the pollution. It may be coming from a vessel. It could be coming from another source. The way the court has interpreted this section is that you actually have to prove that they intended to dump. This changes it, so that it would be interpreted as a strict liability. You would still have to have the due diligence defence, but it would not affect folks who are not directly involved in it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115814","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What this section does is clarify that this is now a strict liability offence. You wouldn't have a bystander seeing something happening and then being caught under this. This would be just the actual source of the pollution. It may be coming from a vessel. It could be coming from another source. The way the court has interpreted this section is that you actually have to prove that they intended to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["064e4ca7a0c29674eb4545b327a3199431eb89f872205554732fa59a12d08414"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5cae16499b39e9e1a0ab786","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115815,"date":"2026-06-16T20:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"I got a legal opinion drafted before I put forward this legislation to address those issues and other issues that came up in early discussions about it. Of course, I can't guarantee how courts are going to interpret things. It will be up to the courts to do that. From the legal advice I've been given, this would be very sound and really focused on making this a strict liability offence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115815","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I got a legal opinion drafted before I put forward this legislation to address those issues and other issues that came up in early discussions about it. Of course, I can't guarantee how courts are going to interpret things. It will be up to the courts to do that. From the legal advice I've been given, this would be very sound and really focused on making this a strict liability offence.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0b12fa55b600600553cdb621c69a27dbc3a9a214be7ff412d11d44b5378b2d13"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1aeeb7766eae5fb9cca0680e2b0cc310a8d824727f8eeed6076b7b720aa47599"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0db8417613ba8c68af87067","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115816,"date":"2026-06-16T20:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for the question. Obviously, there are limits on what the seller of a boat will be able to determine from a buyer of a boat. There is already a system in place for the registration of boats once they're transferred. As you will know, it's on the buyer of the boat to make that change. What this would introduce is a requirement for the boat owner to disclose the condition of the boat and then the person who's buying it to have some type of format showing their ability to maintain and operate it going forward. It would complement what is already in there with the vessel registration system. In a case like the one you're mentioning, it is more than someone coming by and just giving someone some money. You actually have an obligation now to register that boat within 60 days of getting it. This would complement what's already in there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115816","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for the question. Obviously, there are limits on what the seller of a boat will be able to determine from a buyer of a boat. There is already a system in place for the registration of boats once they're transferred. As you will know, it's on the buyer of the boat to make that change. What this would introduce is a requirement for the boat owner to disclose the condition of the boat and t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","label":"Fishing permits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["57bfb874c0a8fd01bb1019601aab25932afa87b1c77fd23181d342449c2ff547"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c6be8bde4561049b41b1f95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115817,"date":"2026-06-16T20:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thanks for that question. I have a similar experience. This was an issue that I didn't understand all that well before I started running for office. I can tell you that, even before I got elected, I had people reaching out to me to fix this problem. It's a problem that drives people crazy, because it involves all different orders of government, in different ways and in numerous different departments. I think it is helpful that we have many officials behind me who will be able to speak to this afterwards, in the next hour. When WAHVA was passed, an important change was made to prohibit abandoning vessels. Earlier this year, we updated our vessel registry system, so we have a better idea of who owns these vessels. Every five years, that will need to be updated, so we have a good sense of who owns those vessels. What this legislation will do is prevent the transfer of vessels to individuals where the current owner knows they cannot maintain or operate them. This will prevent a lot of new hazardous vessels from being out there on the water and causing all of those impacts that you mentioned. I'd say that's one piece of the puzzle. I think the other piece that hasn't been solved at this point is making sure there's ongoing funding to pull those problem vessels out of the water when we can identify the owners, and also having a sustainable system to dispose of and recycle those boats. I think, if we can have all of those pieces in place, then we'll be able to deal with this issue. This legislation will prevent the problem from getting worse. There are other jurisdictions that have already done this. Washington state has a good system in place that we can learn from, and I think this is one step to getting there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115817","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thanks for that question. I have a similar experience. This was an issue that I didn't understand all that well before I started running for office. I can tell you that, even before I got elected, I had people reaching out to me to fix this problem. It's a problem that drives people crazy, because it involves all different orders of government, in different ways and in numerous different departmen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73b1995615cb96a1a982bf1e2a7d81f9a26485805ff94ef9e404b4fda2fcbb5b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["666e504bdb80a4ac4fc73a4aa8ac33a01836ff1f18f29b3f66b91f0d9260e9a4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b5ca893aa03ad3709f24c1a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115818,"date":"2026-06-16T20:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Yes, it's a very considerable cost. We have a program called the abandoned boats program to clean up vessels that have already sunk, but it's out of money and hasn't been recapitalized. It needs to have more money. There isn't funding there. Thankfully, in the spring economic statement, we got more money for the ghost gear fund. Ghost gear is another really damaging form of marine pollution. If we had the vessel remediation fund, which is something the government promised back in 2021, that would be one way of addressing this. There would be a small fee to pay every time you register your boat, in order to make sure you have those funds in the long term. The abandoned boats program runs through Transport Canada. There's a separate one that runs through DFO for small craft harbours. Part of the challenges you bring up is that there are so many different responsibilities here. Transport Canada will get involved if the boat is a navigation risk. DFO will get involved if it is in a small craft harbour. Environment and Climate Change Canada will get involved if it's currently spilling. Now the Coast Guard is part of National Defence, so, in an urgent situation, they can step in and give a private operator the ability to remove the vessel. It is a very complex thing. That's what makes people so frustrated. It allows agencies to point fingers at one another, and the problem doesn't get solved.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115818","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, it's a very considerable cost. We have a program called the abandoned boats program to clean up vessels that have already sunk, but it's out of money and hasn't been recapitalized. It needs to have more money. There isn't funding there. Thankfully, in the spring economic statement, we got more money for the ghost gear fund. Ghost gear is another really damaging form of marine pollution. If we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46fdd8982e5ae534cb5c2ae6e07bb924049a32da1a848f05bdebac5934f99fe8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81ac1ccf073ff6ad90b5901b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115819,"date":"2026-06-16T20:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"It's not a proper disposal strategy. It comes back to personal responsibility. This is your boat. You have a responsibility to properly dispose of it. It's not fair to put having to clean it up when it sinks on the taxpayer or the coastal communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115819","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's not a proper disposal strategy. It comes back to personal responsibility. This is your boat. You have a responsibility to properly dispose of it. It's not fair to put having to clean it up when it sinks on the taxpayer or the coastal communities.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2902f09eefd1993f24f6ec88576923e8ed283a331d5f49d983a72dd276206b24"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d7ccfdb535b8e19866c6c64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115820,"date":"2026-06-16T20:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much for the question. I'm sorry, but I don't have the French version in front of me, only the English version. The original intent, when this law was passed, was that this section would constitute a strict liability offence. In 2015, as I mentioned earlier, there was a spill, and the court that handed down the ruling interpreted the law very differently. The government could have appealed the decision, but it didn't. So this amendment brings us back to the original intent of the law. If you abandon a vessel without following the steps a reasonable person would take, that constitutes an offence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115820","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much for the question. I'm sorry, but I don't have the French version in front of me, only the English version. The original intent, when this law was passed, was that this section would constitute a strict liability offence. In 2015, as I mentioned earlier, there was a spill, and the court that handed down the ruling interpreted the law very differently. The government could have a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f848b36968bd13bdcf86ed66cd4faf6950b992390281f482e6b5c600b74c6375"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6371ba2c5d8efce82609239b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115821,"date":"2026-06-16T20:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Certainly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115821","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Certainly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65e5203c2789cc1f6da81a5a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115822,"date":"2026-06-16T20:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"There are several ways to determine the condition of a vessel, including requesting an appraisal. What's important here is that the person buying the vessel knows its condition. This is the step the person selling the vessel must take. In fact, for the buyer to know whether they will be able to maintain the vessel, they must first know its condition. They can then explain how they intend to maintain that condition. There are different ways of doing this, but the intention must be there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115822","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There are several ways to determine the condition of a vessel, including requesting an appraisal. What's important here is that the person buying the vessel knows its condition. This is the step the person selling the vessel must take. In fact, for the buyer to know whether they will be able to maintain the vessel, they must first know its condition. They can then explain how they intend to mainta","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7167f685ffe348b93d30b630d040a9042d4ed2d4d3184033577e53c5f12fe81"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-029542ab67b8603390af421e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115823,"date":"2026-06-16T21:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"There are limits to the information the person selling the vessel can provide. It is primarily up to the buyer to describe how they will maintain it. It is difficult for the person selling the vessel to do more than that. This won't solve the entire problem, but these are the things the seller can control.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115823","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There are limits to the information the person selling the vessel can provide. It is primarily up to the buyer to describe how they will maintain it. It is difficult for the person selling the vessel to do more than that. This won't solve the entire problem, but these are the things the seller can control.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64ae05d2c8487dc39aacd018c0fbc8771fe5d07d79c20b15f5790d2faae7a277"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37478da26a477fef1671675e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115824,"date":"2026-06-16T21:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that. That could be, absolutely, one way of understanding the condition of the boats. One thing I should have mentioned earlier is that this isn't going to capture all boats. It's going to capture the boats as defined under the WAHVA, which has de minimis and maximum sizes of boats. Obviously, bigger boats are captured by different processes in the shipping act, for instance. However, one way would be just that: having a proper, in-depth assessment of the status of the boat. For the person who is buying the boat, I think you could get financial records, but getting that and verifying all of that information is not within the boat seller's control. What is going to be required here is that they submit, in writing, that they can take care of it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115824","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for that. That could be, absolutely, one way of understanding the condition of the boats. One thing I should have mentioned earlier is that this isn't going to capture all boats. It's going to capture the boats as defined under the WAHVA, which has de minimis and maximum sizes of boats. Obviously, bigger boats are captured by different processes in the shipping act, for instance. However","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f819e50066ccb907737084e6e61c2e771c091a3d251f36ef924dae0bd69f0271"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6bcc5e47ecc719416025ebdd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115825,"date":"2026-06-16T21:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"It's more than that. It's going to say how they can maintain it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115825","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's more than that. It's going to say how they can maintain it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036915","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Reforestation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036915","label":"Reforestation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["16951e2881d912666b5bee2dd92dc595a0e88b872a72f0fda24c3d9799466f5d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd849b0db7912473db61574e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115826,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"I think it's a fair question. Again, there are a lot of different ways in which someone could prove how they would maintain the boat at that point. Having all of that information is not something that every boat seller is going to have, either. It's not their responsibility to prove all of those things, but this is the due diligence that you can do, as a boat seller, as you're selling it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115826","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think it's a fair question. Again, there are a lot of different ways in which someone could prove how they would maintain the boat at that point. Having all of that information is not something that every boat seller is going to have, either. It's not their responsibility to prove all of those things, but this is the due diligence that you can do, as a boat seller, as you're selling it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69cd5d37b4485a03ef5314dc016cb73b88c9a60fa92a85f536eec132f7d3919c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1e22ac619e6586411cdc60d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115827,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Yes. Very much so. To get back to your earlier question, you're not going to be able to show, at the sale, how someone can fully take care of it. However, this will be information that will be on hand, let's say, if this boat does become wrecked or abandoned, or it actually sinks to the bottom. You would be able to show the steps you took, as the boat seller, to ensure that didn't happen, so it is about having that on hand. There will be penalties associated with it if you're not compliant with it. There are fines that could be up to $5,000 for that. This will be more of a procedural thing that they'll be able to show.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115827","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes. Very much so. To get back to your earlier question, you're not going to be able to show, at the sale, how someone can fully take care of it. However, this will be information that will be on hand, let's say, if this boat does become wrecked or abandoned, or it actually sinks to the bottom. You would be able to show the steps you took, as the boat seller, to ensure that didn't happen, so it is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ef322d3e7bcba516c147a476f585ad9b24020b06d453895207b6a64e24d105bd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9823daefe55721927c3fd398a1be207f905b0d274ecf17265a407105bd8089c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4bfbff154a076d216f6ff126","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115828,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Maybe we can get to that in the next round. Essentially, this was just meant to get around those bad-faith sales in which someone is selling this, for a nominal amount, to get around those responsibilities. I can elaborate on that in the next round.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115828","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Maybe we can get to that in the next round. Essentially, this was just meant to get around those bad-faith sales in which someone is selling this, for a nominal amount, to get around those responsibilities. I can elaborate on that in the next round.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f17f9f59ec31a794ac61222b79e2c04da64723baa31a307a36b8f2ccc53aa9d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-531cee843367ce886af8b54d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115829,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"As I mentioned before, this is an issue that is, obviously, a very visible one when you see abandoned and derelict vessels out in the water, and it's a growing issue. From one end, yes, it's an eyesore, but on the other end you're seeing examples of these vessels actually polluting the water and causing major environmental impacts. I can give examples of that pollution leading, in a lot of places where normally clams would be harvested, to first nations no longer being able to do that. We have harbours where boaters are having challenges navigating through them, because there are numerous vessels congregating in different areas. I hear it from marina owners, who are called in the middle of the night by someone who says, \"One of these boats is sinking.\" Then they need to seek the ability, from the Coast Guard, to actually go to clean them up. It's one thing if you're close to an urban area, if the Coast Guard is near that or if you're near where the authorities are. However, in many cases, particularly throughout coastal British Columbia, they happen far away from that, where you don't have that ability to rapidly respond. This then leads to many, many more significant issues taking place. This is one of those issues that I think brings all people together, because they know it's a massive issue. It's one that falls within, or in between, different jurisdictional responsibilities. This is meant to prevent the problem from getting worse.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115829","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"As I mentioned before, this is an issue that is, obviously, a very visible one when you see abandoned and derelict vessels out in the water, and it's a growing issue. From one end, yes, it's an eyesore, but on the other end you're seeing examples of these vessels actually polluting the water and causing major environmental impacts. I can give examples of that pollution leading, in a lot of places ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f134a752d7c5a4192411234226d19f61f7b5d26de65fe86d85eca980a121a163"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d95d9481fbbdb2496966f15b3817ea1fef5b5f8c3b5ff14658fd23c63feba51"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-01a09b928b26f1bb24930162","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115830,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Yes, absolutely. West Coast Environmental Law, Surfrider Foundation, Ocean Legacy Foundation, the Georgia Strait Alliance, Raincoast Conservation Foundation, the Dead Boats Disposal Society, the Howe Sound Biosphere Region Initiative Society and the Marine Life Sanctuaries Society of British Columbia are some of the environmental organizations that have supported it. More locally, in my riding, the Sunshine Coast Regional District has endorsed it, as have the District of Sechelt, the Town of Gibsons, Bowen Island Municipality, the Squamish-Lillooet Regional District, the District of Squamish, the shíshálh Nation and Squamish Nation. You can see that there's broad support for this. There are municipalities that are taking their own action and first nations that are taking their own action. I can tell you that there are some first nations that want to build shipbreaking facilities and have those recycling opportunities take place on their territory. There are municipalities that are taking steps to prevent anchorages in certain areas, so that you don't have those boats that become problem vessels there. All these organizations are doing what they can to address the problem. There are steps that the province needs to take, and there are steps that the federal government needs to take. This is part and parcel of that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115830","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, absolutely. West Coast Environmental Law, Surfrider Foundation, Ocean Legacy Foundation, the Georgia Strait Alliance, Raincoast Conservation Foundation, the Dead Boats Disposal Society, the Howe Sound Biosphere Region Initiative Society and the Marine Life Sanctuaries Society of British Columbia are some of the environmental organizations that have supported it. More locally, in my riding, th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f724ee24bedb883b769ff3f4ef6424703939f33e0285afb937d5c1486f5d045"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e620019aad55eeaac95e4e331352d1d73f32bde8b67a517ed68e31402e2b8a32"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28f7735502109946b3284ba6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115831,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"I can give you a good example of this. There's a bed and breakfast in my riding, in the Porpoise Bay area. This bed and breakfast was actually highlighted by The New York Times as one of the top destinations in western North America, but since that time, this issue has become worse and worse. You have a number of derelict vessels proliferating in the area and major pollution happening. It has now become a major issue for her brand. People who go there are expecting this beautiful natural environment with access to the water. Now they're seeing issues with major pollution. I know that's present in many other parts of coastal Canada. Mr. Greaves would probably be able to speak to issues in his own riding where that's taking place as well. I'd say that's part of it. The other part is that many of these vessels end up becoming navigation risks. That's an issue for folks from within Canada and also those who come from other countries who want to experience what our country has to offer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115831","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I can give you a good example of this. There's a bed and breakfast in my riding, in the Porpoise Bay area. This bed and breakfast was actually highlighted by The New York Times as one of the top destinations in western North America, but since that time, this issue has become worse and worse. You have a number of derelict vessels proliferating in the area and major pollution happening. It has now ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21600abe14554a363dbd8ff5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115832,"date":"2026-06-16T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Only vessels longer than 5.5 metres are subject to the current Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115832","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Only vessels longer than 5.5 metres are subject to the current Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62ec723846520d8f422d0533123caf426a0ba77990f2880b8d2c445290fa0564"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42ed1e95a80256a1ead23131","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115833,"date":"2026-06-16T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"That's a good question. I think it's impossible to have a list of everything that should be done by the various authorities. That's something the courts will be able to determine based on the specific circumstances of each case. I think it's difficult, but the law is based on the principle of what a reasonable person would do in the same situation. If you don't act irresponsibly, you won't be committing an offence under this act. This is something that will be determined by the judges, who will base their decisions on the various arguments presented to them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115833","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's a good question. I think it's impossible to have a list of everything that should be done by the various authorities. That's something the courts will be able to determine based on the specific circumstances of each case. I think it's difficult, but the law is based on the principle of what a reasonable person would do in the same situation. If you don't act irresponsibly, you won't be comm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["11e9d67f820b786516e2429254810b35efe9ed22ebfd40f176cb1bd4575655bc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["afa5784ab3fdf13571eed12a0384f680c8d5a234c1c6425232976da20e71cd79"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cea94a171822734eab1c5111","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115834,"date":"2026-06-16T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much for the question. I think it's a very important one. I'll go back to how the legislation is written here. It says: It is prohibited for an owner of a vessel to transfer ownership of it to a person, if the owner knows that—or is reckless as to whether—the person lacks the ability, resources or intent to maintain, operate or dispose of You don't have to prove it, but if you know this person doesn't meet these conditions, or if you don't take any steps to ascertain this, that's when you would be committing—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115834","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much for the question. I think it's a very important one. I'll go back to how the legislation is written here. It says: It is prohibited for an owner of a vessel to transfer ownership of it to a person, if the owner knows that—or is reckless as to whether—the person lacks the ability, resources or intent to maintain, operate or dispose of You don't have to prove it, but if you know ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f68d0658080b3ba5687cc7e50d4493f2a3ff7e2732c985bffd4d555c8ec7adec"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8da79ccbc6983792c34ba834","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115835,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"My view is that you wouldn't have to get something notarized, but you would have to ask those questions. Again, going back to the original thing, disclosing what the condition—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115835","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"My view is that you wouldn't have to get something notarized, but you would have to ask those questions. Again, going back to the original thing, disclosing what the condition—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc1f76791b66d5a12f03e980dce59f78d463af90c6fae6cd3b0e969d8bf023c2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5489c0b2802939816c5bb13","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115836,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"If Transport Canada wanted to issue a penalty under it, you would have to show this. That's what it would require. It would be....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115836","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If Transport Canada wanted to issue a penalty under it, you would have to show this. That's what it would require. It would be....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic sanctions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","label":"Economic sanctions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc0fc87417e8f6b53a555e3671d70e024e26bac3d10a51c8da259db9ce9246bc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1acac0eb63d851f6ed9c512b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115837,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Yes, you did your due diligence, and remember what the standard is here. You don't have to prove that he meets all these conditions, because those are things that would be very difficult to do, but you have to prove that you took steps to ascertain it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115837","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, you did your due diligence, and remember what the standard is here. You don't have to prove that he meets all these conditions, because those are things that would be very difficult to do, but you have to prove that you took steps to ascertain it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3605547d31a89ef3903cfc2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115838,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Yes, it's exactly that. You would have to submit the statement or the documentation wherein the buyer shows that he has the ability to maintain it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115838","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, it's exactly that. You would have to submit the statement or the documentation wherein the buyer shows that he has the ability to maintain it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13f14e8f4628f0931ed8b7aecd288b6e309545c889bd95ca287126280ef6a595"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0fa23b8f976e6513d94616c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115839,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"This would be enforced the same way right across the country. This is in addition to the vessel registry system.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115839","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This would be enforced the same way right across the country. This is in addition to the vessel registry system.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f5a949ebe0e296c131701891b4039652d28ac47c5203409068bdd44ffb87d1b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7b16a1cb6fe3e0e401554f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115840,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"I know there are.... I think, unfortunately, the time is up. I'd love to get more into that one afterwards. I know in some cases you do need band council resolutions to do those things.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115840","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I know there are.... I think, unfortunately, the time is up. I'd love to get more into that one afterwards. I know in some cases you do need band council resolutions to do those things.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["449e70b7ed460117b86e395bf2598affa01bc4c0a10a0b19bc8f2b4da49544a6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fba6e4a35e9981d268bbb395","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115841,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"I'm sorry, but can you repeat that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115841","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm sorry, but can you repeat that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06884e2edcd76cedf1e706ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115842,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"I think it's all of the above. There was a major legislative gap before the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act was introduced in 2019. I mentioned before that it was not even prohibited anywhere to abandon your vessel. That addressed one of the problems there. One of the issues that have long existed is that we don't understand who owns most boats. It's based on a paper-based system, so it's very outdated. Earlier this year, we introduced a new system, so it's all going to be in one database, and you're now going to have to update the system every five years so we have a better sense of who owns it. Those are really important changes. There are many issues when people don't register when a boat changes hands. These are things that are major gaps in our laws. Then there are major issues in enforcement on the water. Part of the challenge is that so many of Transport Canada's, DFO's and the Coast Guard's resources are centralized in different areas, and many of these issues end up happening far away from them, so there's a lack of capacity in many respects. Frankly, there were a lot of regional bases that were shut down in the early 2010s as well. I can tell you that my riding on the Sunshine Coast used to have a DFO site, and that was shut down in 2012. I'd say that those are both issues that are there, and they need to be addressed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115842","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think it's all of the above. There was a major legislative gap before the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act was introduced in 2019. I mentioned before that it was not even prohibited anywhere to abandon your vessel. That addressed one of the problems there. One of the issues that have long existed is that we don't understand who owns most boats. It's based on a paper-based system, so i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","label":"Fishing permits","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4bb3631cc3bed5b66f3aa15b49bd6d25441eba7066ed12a538791c00c279c965"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60e808d5084e78933a9ee79b20280723bf2da3153ce73a3404b6504fc826fe5f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0751bbf6a29c2bd99198c3dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115843,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"This is one of the areas that are a big gap in Canada, because, in many respects, for a lot of these vessels, to properly dispose of them, you're sending them to a landfill. There are better ways of dealing with it than that. There are a number of different organizations that want to set up shipbreaking facilities and recycling facilities, where you could properly break them down and recover some of the materials in there that are still valuable. We don't have those facilities. We need to invest in those in Canada. Other jurisdictions have them. As a west coast example, Washington state has a lot of those facilities. We also need to make it very cheap for people to dispose of their boats that way, because, if you send it to the dump, it's very expensive. These are some gaps that need to be addressed. I mentioned earlier in my testimony that one way of doing that is the long-promised vessel remediation fund, so you know you're going to have a capitalized fund over the long term for that vessel disposal. Right now, those are not there, and that's one of the other gaps that have to be addressed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115843","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This is one of the areas that are a big gap in Canada, because, in many respects, for a lot of these vessels, to properly dispose of them, you're sending them to a landfill. There are better ways of dealing with it than that. There are a number of different organizations that want to set up shipbreaking facilities and recycling facilities, where you could properly break them down and recover some ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:115951","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trademarks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:115951","label":"Trademarks","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b4f04edf3345865b555fd5d12a7ec56ce62c5472f29088c1d1563a698ee7eb5b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["304477ddd7dfee162f6f13a13958abd743eaafa22445b31cd1b925d1f4f88a8e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ed496b0855d464cd4b97d24","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115844,"date":"2026-06-16T21:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"The abandoned vessels problem is an issue right across the country. It's more of an issue in British Columbia. I couldn't give you an accurate number on how many vessels are identified as abandoned. I can tell you that I think it's a few thousand, but I bet you the actual amount is 10 times that, probably. It's a bigger issue on the west coast, because we have milder winters and more examples of people who live there throughout the winter. There are more pleasure crafts, whereas on the east coast you have more commercial harvesting vessels. It's a bit different. There are certainly issues on the east coast as well. A colleague from Îles-de-la-Madeleine was bringing up pictures, showing me some examples in his riding. It's just that the state of these vessels is different. There are more commercial vessels on the east coast and more pleasure crafts on the west coast. I would venture to say that there are probably some issues in the Arctic as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115844","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The abandoned vessels problem is an issue right across the country. It's more of an issue in British Columbia. I couldn't give you an accurate number on how many vessels are identified as abandoned. I can tell you that I think it's a few thousand, but I bet you the actual amount is 10 times that, probably. It's a bigger issue on the west coast, because we have milder winters and more examples of p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["03a12a1d5c8616830fbf303fdbe1be265ef1e728805ca6b4fca3606df322a20a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c364885b176531f142ee9f2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115845,"date":"2026-06-16T21:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"I love that example, because that show was filmed in my riding, in Gibsons. It's the most-watched Canadian show of all time. I think there's absolutely an opportunity to do that. Part of the challenge right now is that you have to know whether a vessel is actually abandoned. You have to give the person 30 days' notice before you can do anything about it. There's a better way of dealing with these problem vessels. Right now, in our program, they take out individual boats. It's very expensive. If you had someone deal with all the abandoned boats in one region at one time, it would be much more affordable. That could be a fix in the program design, going forward. There's certainly a market for that, because there are valuable materials that can be recovered. Right now, though, we don't have the resources or the proper disposal facilities to deal with it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034868","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Disposal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115845","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I love that example, because that show was filmed in my riding, in Gibsons. It's the most-watched Canadian show of all time. I think there's absolutely an opportunity to do that. Part of the challenge right now is that you have to know whether a vessel is actually abandoned. You have to give the person 30 days' notice before you can do anything about it. There's a better way of dealing with these ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034868","label":"Disposal services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034868","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Disposal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034868","label":"Disposal services","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62f0ac308f2d50b4686dd5832f020dd4c81d36118d2cf5fc7a5255c0d5061afb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034868","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Disposal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00e54945cf91dde482d161097f9b6bcce2a15334526dba4b00bf4afbf8b744b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034868","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Disposal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034868","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb66d8c61c46b12a3a14a08c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115846,"date":"2026-06-16T22:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I want to thank the officials and witnesses here for answering the questions. I want to start with some questions for ECCC about the amendment to CEPA. As I mentioned in my testimony, this was about returning it to its original intent: being a strict liability offence. Before that, the court case very much changed how it was interpreted. I'm wondering whether there have been other cases like this that have come up, ones the government did not advance because of this new interpretation of the law.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115846","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I want to thank the officials and witnesses here for answering the questions. I want to start with some questions for ECCC about the amendment to CEPA. As I mentioned in my testimony, this was about returning it to its original intent: being a strict liability offence. Before that, the court case very much changed how it was interpreted. I'm wondering whether there have bee","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e01c0d227b00c7302635021886740f97149994bf4664e32ed54864ef9ae3011b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c03628ba0059ab1c7c2d610aafa3e2f8c03fe4b08ff5e6420a2b4568d75295c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9fd26865e6073527300feeb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115847,"date":"2026-06-16T22:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"I understand that, for sure. My next questions are for Transport. We've had a good discussion about some of the challenges regarding how you determine the current state of a vessel. There are different ways you can do this. One potential way that was brought up is doing a survey, but that would be expensive and not necessarily fit for purpose for smaller vessels. The other way would be doing a declaration, where you talk about specific aspects of the vessel, like the engine, the hull and what have you. I am hoping you might be able to provide some feedback to the committee on how you would best approach this spectrum of disclosure, based on the kinds of vessels that could be sold.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115847","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand that, for sure. My next questions are for Transport. We've had a good discussion about some of the challenges regarding how you determine the current state of a vessel. There are different ways you can do this. One potential way that was brought up is doing a survey, but that would be expensive and not necessarily fit for purpose for smaller vessels. The other way would be doing a dec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0b50d23fd2831ea16f140463ea369c227e9aace8aa2639d263804aade3779111"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b47242697e37765b00f90e8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1115848,"date":"2026-06-16T22:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Patrick Weiler","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much. With the remaining time I have, I was hoping that Transport could give an update on the progress of the vessels remediation fund.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1115848","member_id":"bc-mp-105918","member_name":"Patrick Weiler","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. With the remaining time I have, I was hoping that Transport could give an update on the progress of the vessels remediation fund.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"International transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","label":"International transport","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5e83ff9514698237c704c59de89fe2fd876f6376b8790c5b70f4bd7cea01c48"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-018508a66e57f72062f21758","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76140,"date":"2026-01-26T17:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola and, in this context, the greater Canadian public. I want to wish a warm welcome back to this chamber to everybody.\n\nI have a question that relates to firearms. We have seen the Liberals preside over an unprecedented proliferation of firearms usage. I checked the bill; I did a search of it. There is one provision that would deal with extortion, and it mentions an aggravating factor. The government in Bill C-5 said that people who extort with a firearm, people who do drive-by shootings, in fact, can serve their sentence on house arrest.\n\nDoes the minister not agree that people who do drive-by shootings should be subject to the previous mandatory minimum of four years for that offence, or for extortion with a firearm?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76140","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola and, in this context, the greater Canadian public. I want to wish a warm welcome back to this chamber to everybody.\n\nI have a question that relates to firearms. We have seen the Liberals preside over an unprecedented proliferation of firearms usage. I checked the bill; I did a search of it. There i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d20d7f351749229e06ac3b2be32bc146378eddcd1f43a930d134e15f48ff33e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d4ffc42a7ebf0e26c6011d2cb26b94b749d51c6545bbf9109e92331cea6fe6c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5dd7f842327bd8a3eb622f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76141,"date":"2026-01-26T18:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I thank my hon. colleague from Brantford—Brant South—Six Nations for his very compelling intervention.\n\nThe question I have for my hon. colleague is the same one I asked the Minister of Justice, but I do not feel we got a satisfactory answer. In their 10 years of government, with Bill C-5, the Liberals legislated that people who do drive-by shootings and extortion with a firearm can serve their sentences on house arrest.\n\nWhy is it that we are not addressing the ferocious gun crime? We have seen extortion go up over 300%. Why are we not addressing this? That is what is killing people, among other things.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76141","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I thank my hon. colleague from Brantford—Brant South—Six Nations for his very compelling intervention.\n\nThe question I have for my hon. colleague is the same one I asked the Minister of Justice, but I do not feel we got a satisfactory answer. In their 10 years of government, with Bill C-5, the Liber","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26536972db7344aeb0d8657df7a4786bb8827f46fa4763847f93b707a35b8d6a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["51ab505c13fb37b9c73087b7b4cb16121d15c35201f8c10d1ec8a9a1f16efb7b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3543b3c3ff294964c7873e81","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76142,"date":"2026-01-28T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there have been discussions among the parties, and if you seek it, I believe you will find unanimous consent to adopt the following motion:\n\nThat, notwithstanding the order made Wednesday, December 3, 2025, Bill C-225, an act to amend the Criminal Code, be withdrawn from the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights and referred to the Standing Committee on the Status of Women.\n\nMotion","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76142","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there have been discussions among the parties, and if you seek it, I believe you will find unanimous consent to adopt the following motion:\n\nThat, notwithstanding the order made Wednesday, December 3, 2025, Bill C-225, an act to amend the Criminal Code, be withdrawn from the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights and referred to the Standing Committee on the Status of Women.\n\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7cea75c5161cc8c96adddb28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":80922,"date":"2026-02-02T17:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI heard the member for Winnipeg North question my colleague, who is a lawyer, about these things. I could not agree more with my colleague about the problems we have. This government took away mandatory jail time, and jail time, period, potentially, for people who do drive-by shootings. \n\nDoes my colleague agree that it was not only negligent but also reckless, given the problems we have with guns, to allow people to serve their sentence on the couch when they shoot at other houses and endanger Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80922","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI heard the member for Winnipeg North question my colleague, who is a lawyer, about these things. I could not agree more with my colleague about the problems we have. This government took away mandatory jail time, and jail time, period, potentially, for people who do drive-by shootings. \n\nDoes my col","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["25bb1afe5799002740f878ac454a5f9ca91ea7aa8ef44b52d51aea31ffad12e4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c68911a4e0ba106f023d679d3eb8eff6b98fd6e78eeead1cc5f2162cab985801"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7041d25d4ad057121636c12e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":80923,"date":"2026-02-02T17:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI want to dispel the canard that is coming from the Liberal side. The Liberals say the Conservatives want to filibuster bills. However, when the Liberals were debating Bill C-9 in committee, a highly divisive bill, the Conservatives said no fewer than 20 times that we wanted to talk about bail. The Liberals have the audacity to stand up in the House and say that we are filibustering crime legislation, when we begged them to talk about crime legislation, not just in December in committee but for the last 10 years.\n\nWhen will the hypocrisy end? What does my friend think?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80923","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI want to dispel the canard that is coming from the Liberal side. The Liberals say the Conservatives want to filibuster bills. However, when the Liberals were debating Bill C-9 in committee, a highly divisive bill, the Conservatives said no fewer than 20 times that we wanted to talk about bail. The L","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f889324f1c6505a8638bfa0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":80925,"date":"2026-02-02T17:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. This is my first time rising substantially in the House since the winter break, so before I begin, I do want to recognize a number of people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\n I want to recognize a life well lived by Rocco Russo, who recently passed. He was a member of my Italian cultural centre, known colloquially as the Colombo Lodge. Left to mourn him are his wife, Cheryl; his children, Christopher, Michael and Robert; and his siblings Sam, Aldo and Sylvia. Rocco gave a great deal to the Colombo Lodge and to the community. He was beloved in the community. May perpetual light shine upon him.\n\nI also learned that, regrettably, Ms. Helen Barnett passed away over the Christmas break. Helen was somebody I got to know when I worked at my first law firm after articling, where I worked with her husband, Francis. Helen gave a tremendous amount to the city of Kamloops, sitting on council and school boards, and working with all sorts of community organizations. She had a vivacious personality, and I am so grateful to have known her. May perpetual light shine upon her.\n\nI was saddened to learn over the holidays of the death of Antonio Spada at 97 years old. Antonio leaves behind to mourn him his wife, Serafina; his children, Joseph and Angie; and his sister Felicia. I have gotten to know the Spada family through the Potestio family, and I can say that Antonio leaves behind a tremendous legacy. If legacy is demonstrated based on what we see following someone's death, following a tremendous life well lived, then we can say that Antonio lived a tremendous life and will be missed. I extend my deepest condolences to Antonio's family. May perpetual light shine upon him.\n\nI was saddened to learn over the holidays that Alice Desmond passed away. The Desmond family members were pillars of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. In fact in Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola there is a street called Desmond Street. I actually worked as a prosecutor with one of Alice's children, Lynett, before she was elevated to the bench. She is now Judge Jung. The family legacy of Alice and her late husband, Pat, cannot be overstated.\n\nAlice leaves to mourn her sisters Evelyn, Edith and Brenda; and her daughters Nola, Tannis, Lynett and Shannon and their families. In fact my best man was named Desmond Sanesh after Alice Desmond and the Desmond family. May perpetual light shine upon her. I extend my deepest condolences to her family.\n\nI was deeply saddened to learn of the death of \"Dar\" Hastings in the 100 Mile House area. She was 83 years old. She gave so much work to the public and to democracy, and she was a great help. She delivered on what she believed, standing up for her values in so many ways. I cannot overstate all that she did. I had the opportunity to visit her in hospital some time ago, which I am grateful for. She really contributed to the life and vitality of the 100 Mile House area, which was part of my riding when I was first elected. She leaves behind her partner, Al Smith; her children, Paige and Tom, as well as Wade and Brian; and her sisters Candice and Jane. May perpetual light shine upon her.\n\nI have a lot to say. Far be it from me to have a lot to say; I am sure a lot of people do, and I often do have a lot to say here.\n\n So much of what the government is doing comes down to trust. I was reflecting on trust in criminal justice, and I do not have a lot of trust in the government when it comes to justice. I do not have a lot of trust in the government, period, and I will give the following example.\n\nIn pre-budget consultations, I sent the Minister of Finance nine letters about Sun Peaks, a community in my riding that has tremendous housing issues. I sent the minister a letter about the housing. In fact, I have sent three emails to the Minister of Housing. This was in private email; for the people at home, I will explain that we have a back channel for private emails, which members communicate with but we do not make public. However, not once has he even given the courtesy of a reply. In fact, I asked him whether he even got my emails, to which he gave what I would call a lame excuse.\n\nHow do we trust a government on criminal justice, when we cannot trust them on the basics like housing? The people of Sun Peaks are wondering when they will get their answer.\n\nWhat about the people of Merritt? Again, we talk about trust in the government, and the Liberals say to trust them on justice, but they would not respond to my letter about Merritt, which experienced tremendous, catastrophic, flooding prior to becoming part of my riding. The provincial government pledged well over $100 million. The then prime minister and a number of ministers here, some of whom are ministers from Justin Trudeau's government, went there and told the people of Merritt that they would have their back.\n\nHow much have the Liberals contributed? It is $5 million; that is it. They were going to have their back for the photo op, but when it came to giving money, they were nowhere to be seen. That is why, when we think about examples of the government and trust, there is an erosion of trust.\n\n I want to turn to something that has been mentioned in the House: the notion of filibustering the bill. In my view, this is the worst kind of politics, because it is actively misleading the public, and here is why. We as Conservatives have been accused of filibustering this and other crime legislation— \n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nFrank Caputo: Mr. Speaker, the member just said that I have been. Let us talk about that.\n\nWhere was the member on Bill C-14 when we were at committee studying Bill C-9, which is a highly contentious bill that I bet the government does not have the guts to bring forward again? It was so contentious and so divisive that we, as Conservatives, asked to shelve Bill C-9 so we could move to Bill C-14, a bail bill. We actually asked the government to move forward on that bill. What did the Liberals do? They stuck with Bill C-9. How are we filibustering bills, when we are asking them to bring forward bills?\n\n I am the last of four speakers today. We are debating the bill. Last time I checked, in the House of Commons, we debate. We could put up more speakers, because I bet no one else is going to rise to debate it, so again, why is there a narrative about filibustering? At the end of the day, we are actually saying that Bill C-16 has elements we are agreeable to and elements that we do not necessarily agree with.\n\nHowever, in a democratic society, it is so important to debate these ideas, such as mandatory minimum sentences, which I have been quoted on. It was quite complimentary to hear that, and I would love to further debate the idea of a mandatory minimum sentence with a safety valve for cruel and unusual punishment, and what that means.\n\nWould we adopt the common law definition of \"cruel and unusual\"? Would Parliament itself legislate something about cruel and unusual punishment, to do exactly what we need to do, which is to say that mandatory minimums should apply 99.99% of the time, and this is what the other 0.01% of the time looks like? That is what we want to do. That is why the bill would go to committee. \n\n I really hope the Liberals stop with their rhetoric, because it is wrong and it is incorrect.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80925","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. This is my first time rising substantially in the House since the winter break, so before I begin, I do want to recognize a number of people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\n I want to recognize a life well lived by Rocco Russo, who recently passed. He was a member of my Italian cultural centre, known ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d8c489769ce6611495f5f02cab3b91ba165505b339620ad18e7156196b1371cd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5265d3a41add76f1c5e75739bed8c2d016ddff7f3940309269bcf3c1490cca02"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0d61beaa3a89309ea50d1fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":80926,"date":"2026-02-02T17:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Just because somebody says it, and says it loudly, that does not make it true, Mr. Speaker.\n\nAt the end of the day, there is a minority government. Its job is to put legislation forward that makes sense. God forbid that we in this place debate legislation. It is our job to debate legislation. What the member calls filibustering, I call the democratic process. How dare the Liberals accuse us of filibustering when we are doing our job?\n\n They think we should walk in here and give them their agenda without question. That is what the NDP did with Bill C-5, and look where that got us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80926","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Just because somebody says it, and says it loudly, that does not make it true, Mr. Speaker.\n\nAt the end of the day, there is a minority government. Its job is to put legislation forward that makes sense. God forbid that we in this place debate legislation. It is our job to debate legislation. What the member calls filibustering, I call the democratic process. How dare the Liberals accuse us of fil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","label":"Minorities","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e42979a586a6253dc068452cb7e6b882abb3bdace9aed6bf3485b3900ca963a2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54935446d056cae300bb0881","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":80927,"date":"2026-02-02T18:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from Quebec for the question.\n\n I actually have something here regarding Jordan. I have a great deal of time for my colleague.\n\nAs somebody who practised criminal law for 15 to 18 years, my view is that the Jordan issue is a substantial one. It has to be addressed by the House of Commons for the reasons my colleague mentioned. The other reason is disclosure. In 1988, I think, when the Stinchcombe case came out, which is the leading case on disclosure, it was not addressed. The House needs to address disclosure, and it needs to address Jordan.\n\n Judicial vacancies are a huge problem, and something we discussed at our convention.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80927","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from Quebec for the question.\n\n I actually have something here regarding Jordan. I have a great deal of time for my colleague.\n\nAs somebody who practised criminal law for 15 to 18 years, my view is that the Jordan issue is a substantial one. It has to be addressed by the House of Commons for the reasons my colleague mentioned. The other reason is disclosure. In 19","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["884b933d6c24ea59fb4304142dbab2de9e215ad314dfcdf5b323d2393b431155"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["99fa2625ff7f97d1cf7f2ea48ca203b1a8ea394b92d59db605c053e3214081e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbe3c55cfc3adb14ed38c6d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":80928,"date":"2026-02-02T18:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am not going to drop it. I would love to drop the bill, because it is thick, but it would make a thud, and I do not want to hurt the interpreters' ears.\n\n It is an expansive bill. The Liberals say we are filibustering. Should we not be talking about a bill of this substance? It is a bill that would do a lot of things, yet forgets a lot of things, like addressing parts of Bill C-75 with respect to bail and parts of Bill C-5 that say people who do drive-by shootings or commit extortion with a firearm or robbery with a firearm can serve their sentences on house arrest.\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!\n\nFrank Caputo: The Liberals are laughing at that, Mr. Speaker. Is it not wonderful that the Liberals think drive-by shootings, robbery with a firearm and things like that are funny?\n\nMy time is up. Let us get this done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80928","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am not going to drop it. I would love to drop the bill, because it is thick, but it would make a thud, and I do not want to hurt the interpreters' ears.\n\n It is an expansive bill. The Liberals say we are filibustering. Should we not be talking about a bill of this substance? It is a bill that would do a lot of things, yet forgets a lot of things, like addressing parts of Bill C-75 w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da4f6d78c1fda1d69700f7a28eb6f2120b031c380719a29165d94afb4630637a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a76d7dfb105c530d575f3ccc306285b717f598d5ab4c03fd884343913efe4f07"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-222f56ee734075cb421e8b95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":80920,"date":"2026-02-03T19:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, with profound sadness, I offer my sincere condolences on the passing of three junior hockey players from the Southern Alberta Mustangs. The families, teammates and coaches in Stavely, Alberta, who cared for Caden Fine of Alabama, and Kamloops' own J.J. Wright and Cameron Casorso, are in our thoughts as they grieve this heartbreaking loss.\n\n Kamloops Minor Hockey had the honour of watching J.J. and Cameron grow up playing in the organization for 14 and 13 years, respectively. Many in the Kamloops community knew these players as teammates and friends. The pain of this tragedy will be felt for a long time, and the memory of these young lives will remain with us always. \n\nThey are gone from our sight but never from our hearts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80920","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, with profound sadness, I offer my sincere condolences on the passing of three junior hockey players from the Southern Alberta Mustangs. The families, teammates and coaches in Stavely, Alberta, who cared for Caden Fine of Alabama, and Kamloops' own J.J. Wright and Cameron Casorso, are in our thoughts as they grieve this heartbreaking loss.\n\n Kamloops Minor Hockey had the honour of watc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["34b059e6a2dc618f0378e012d62bdbf756729798a9db25701d5b0991ff639b76"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f52fbeb077807cec50265d6e4d09b84aef963190423bc87d1a16d9b48bad470"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40de19468a8aba0a71583221","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":290979,"date":"2026-02-10T16:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, on a point of order, the Standing Orders state that members are not to say anything that would bring the House into disorder—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:290979","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, on a point of order, the Standing Orders state that members are not to say anything that would bring the House into disorder—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b0771ad71cda9163bf7dd59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":290980,"date":"2026-02-10T16:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, to say that Conservatives are trying to tarnish all immigrants, as the child of immigrants and somebody who sits with immigrants, that is reprehensible. The member should withdraw the comment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:290980","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, to say that Conservatives are trying to tarnish all immigrants, as the child of immigrants and somebody who sits with immigrants, that is reprehensible. The member should withdraw the comment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6c3d317841ed36b6d02aac140d25ebac02dc721025846d47cb73a23a94fc62c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88b5cadb346cc5bc67ec46e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":290981,"date":"2026-02-10T19:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, extortion is out of control in my home province of B.C., where the rate is up 482% since the Liberals took power. The Prime Minister about 10 minutes ago said that the Liberals are tough on extortion. Perhaps somebody should remind him that the Liberals voted to repeal a mandatory jail sentence for extortion with a firearm so people could serve their sentence on house arrest. That is the opposite of being hard on extortion.\n\n Will the Prime Minister support our common-sense solution to ensure that those convicted of serious crimes cannot claim refugee status, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:290981","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, extortion is out of control in my home province of B.C., where the rate is up 482% since the Liberals took power. The Prime Minister about 10 minutes ago said that the Liberals are tough on extortion. Perhaps somebody should remind him that the Liberals voted to repeal a mandatory jail sentence for extortion with a firearm so people could serve their sentence on house arrest. That is ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ffd94f07fa60e889b4856659","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":290978,"date":"2026-02-12T19:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Debbie Henderson, Flo Bellman and Paul Henderson are in Ottawa today. They did not ask to be here as advocates but have stepped up bravely to represent their family members, Bailey McCourt and Darian Hailey Henderson-Bellman, who were killed by intimate partners. \n\nDebbie, Flo and Paul are just some of the voices fighting for justice after their loved ones were killed by intimate partners. This was not a role they asked for, but they and many others have taken on advocacy to fight the good fight. They have turned their grief into education. They are part of the cries for change, pleading for all sides to listen. \n\nI say to them that they have been heard. It is now our duty, as legislators, not to fail them, Bailey, Darian or other victims. Debbie, Flo, Paul and all those who walk with them have worked tirelessly and we hold them in the highest esteem.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:290978","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Debbie Henderson, Flo Bellman and Paul Henderson are in Ottawa today. They did not ask to be here as advocates but have stepped up bravely to represent their family members, Bailey McCourt and Darian Hailey Henderson-Bellman, who were killed by intimate partners. \n\nDebbie, Flo and Paul are just some of the voices fighting for justice after their loved ones were killed by intimate part","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8892f432d4548aa6e902917","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":307815,"date":"2026-02-24T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a man was recently sentenced to two years less a day for possessing over 2,600 images of child sexual abuse and exploitation material. Let us remember that it is Parliament's jurisdiction to set sentencing ranges. That is why I put forward a bill last Parliament to raise sentences for people who commit sexual offences against kids.\n\nMake no mistake: I believe that every member of the chamber wants to protect children, but if that is the case, will the Liberals commit today as to when they will introduce legislation that will strengthen our sentencing for people who possess these criminal and awful materials?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:307815","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a man was recently sentenced to two years less a day for possessing over 2,600 images of child sexual abuse and exploitation material. Let us remember that it is Parliament's jurisdiction to set sentencing ranges. That is why I put forward a bill last Parliament to raise sentences for people who commit sexual offences against kids.\n\nMake no mistake: I believe that every member of the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8856db5af7eba9d90cae2c055c6c38b9f33d85213d98c97647e79662489036aa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6b4bf80ae97977fe12dea29625f2c7290d986edd6826dc530867fad5365e93c5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21ab94ba649987afc1ef75b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342455,"date":"2026-03-09T17:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI would say to my colleague from Brantford—Brant South—Six Nations that the Liberals talk about historical revisionism and things like that, and then the parliamentary secretary from Winnipeg had the audacity to say that people should not worry as it is all fine and they have nothing to worry about. I have had faith leaders from my community of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola come and speak to me about their concerns with respect to this bill. Where we hear the concerns is on the ground. \n\nWill the Liberals get out of their ivory tower and actually address these things, or are they just going to plow through with a bill that faith communities have serious concerns about?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342455","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI would say to my colleague from Brantford—Brant South—Six Nations that the Liberals talk about historical revisionism and things like that, and then the parliamentary secretary from Winnipeg had the audacity to say that people should not worry as it is all fine and they have nothing to worry about","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65b717089d884d35a9e6cd2375fd7b8413a077818426f555bf0a5af09d03df47"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f55f5d687660d003e6b0017","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342456,"date":"2026-03-09T18:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. The moment we stop discussing and stop debating and that this place is not where we have difficult conversations is the moment that we might as well pack it in. \n\nTo listen to the member, one would think it was offensive that Conservatives and Canadians even question this. I invite him to my riding, and I would actually like him to address this and meet with faith-based leaders to talk about these things. I have met with faith leaders, as have so many of my colleagues. \n\nWill the member take me up on that? If he says nobody is opposed, he should come to my riding and talk about it, so he can hear the real-world fear that people have about this bill. Will he do it, yes or no? I will even pay his way.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342456","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. The moment we stop discussing and stop debating and that this place is not where we have difficult conversations is the moment that we might as well pack it in. \n\nTo listen to the member, one would think it was offensive that Conservatives and Canadians even question this. I invite him to my riding,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50a460a5da74f17949194676c5af6997c563d6bf30b1e5fba7655280f7f8870c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e51e08c6b46eae2a131623bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342457,"date":"2026-03-09T20:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. On this occasion, I rise to present a petition that cautions that the way Bill C-9 is proceeding, it would silence people when it comes to their religious texts and lead to persecution.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342457","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. On this occasion, I rise to present a petition that cautions that the way Bill C-9 is proceeding, it would silence people when it comes to their religious texts and lead to persecution.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["69a0a5afd3c0ace40b13a822607142412f2c9590e8ae7e27cda64297b9c663e8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e10c3a805b832793378562aca65ba8dacda56f059917e4de0599e2bede6aa6b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f23dda825504d5cc966a302","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342458,"date":"2026-03-09T23:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Before I begin, I want to welcome one of our newest constituents, Harper Alice Frang, born February 9 in Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. We wish her and her family all the best.\n\nI listened closely both to the speech and to the member for Winnipeg North and his question. In fact, he is the only Liberal I have heard ask a single question today. We have heard Liberal plan after plan, and every time it is the greatest housing plan.\n\n I am wondering whether my hon. colleague, also of Italian heritage, agrees with me when I say that Canadians and we, in this House on this side, have just lost hope because there is always a new Liberal housing plan and never any results.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342458","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Before I begin, I want to welcome one of our newest constituents, Harper Alice Frang, born February 9 in Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. We wish her and her family all the best.\n\nI listened closely both to the speech and to the member for Winnipeg North and his question. In fact, he is the only Liberal I ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15b313541f96de23a33278972fa1141ab5a83c324579ac10d3b6428ac39936ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea95944e06514f362671b3ba62e97cfaf4b2797fce935019ef7b3e8ba8dead50"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22657385565438ca5a0336f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342139,"date":"2026-03-10T22:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola on an issue about which I am very passionate. One of the reasons is that I actually worked in the federal correctional system, which is completely germane to the bill.\n\nI want to respond to something the member for Winnipeg North said. In all candour, I have not heard a single Liberal speak today apart from the member, and I have been in the House throughout the day. There are other Liberals here, six or seven of them in the House right now, yet we cannot—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342139","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola on an issue about which I am very passionate. One of the reasons is that I actually worked in the federal correctional system, which is completely germane to the bill.\n\nI want to respond to something the member for Winnipeg North said. In all candour, I have not heard a single Liberal speak today apart","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["506d598f5d7d8e49bc00404b35c2868afff94450051fdb4d7d5b8162197a2170"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4edbf26cdfa1134662f569e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342452,"date":"2026-03-10T22:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, with respect, I did not say who was or was not here.\n\nAt the end of the day, here is the problem: The member is talking about who on the Liberal side did not vote for this. As Conservatives, we take our instructions from the people who sent us here. The Liberals can say all they want about not supporting this and that it is never going to pass. Why should we be taking our instructions from the member for Winnipeg North and not the people of Canada—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342452","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, with respect, I did not say who was or was not here.\n\nAt the end of the day, here is the problem: The member is talking about who on the Liberal side did not vote for this. As Conservatives, we take our instructions from the people who sent us here. The Liberals can say all they want about not supporting this and that it is never going to pass. Why should we be taking our instructions","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e4f6cc6d8d8939df7d3ba54","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342453,"date":"2026-03-10T22:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. The member is not permitted to mislead the House. There was Bill C-28, which changed things. He is leaving that out. He is misleading the House. He should—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342453","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. The member is not permitted to mislead the House. There was Bill C-28, which changed things. He is leaving that out. He is misleading the House. He should—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e17005dc50be600f2623c27f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342454,"date":"2026-03-10T23:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, but this is a particularly good occasion.\n\n Before I begin, I want to recognize the work of Anita Price, somebody who faithfully and diligently worked in my office at 100 Mile House, which is no longer in the riding, as well as in our Kamloops office on an as-needed, part-time basis. Anita has just been a stalwart. We thank her for her service to the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Cariboo, the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola and all Canadians.\n\n I also want to welcome to Canada Hunter Rose Friesen, the daughter of Mike Friesen and Brittany Matheson. Mike was a former staff member here on Parliament Hill, who also served a number of Canadians and a number of members of Parliament. We welcome Hunter, and we hope she and her parents are doing well. \n\nOn a more sombre note, I recognize the life of Giovannina Mercuri, wife of Vittorio and mother to Amedeo, Mirella, Rita, Giovanni and Pietro. She passed away, leaving behind many memories of a family who I am sure misses her deeply. I have for some time been hoping for the opportunity to stand to recognize a life well lived. May perpetual light shine upon her. \n\nI also rise today and recognize the life of Alfredo Caputo. Of course, sharing the same last name, we are related. He was pre-deceased by his wife, Fiorina, and his daughter, Luigina. Left to mourn him are Peter, Anna, Rosie and their families. He leaves behind many grandchildren. I was able to just make his funeral last week. He will obviously be missed. As a treasured part of the Caputo family, I wish his family all the best in a difficult time of mourning. May perpetual light shine upon him.\n\nI rise today as well to recognize the life of Dina Piva. I have gotten to know a couple of her sons quite well, especially her son Dennis. I also know Laura and Mario, the other children Dina leaves behind. Her family has done so much for the area, for Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. They are a well-respected family. I know that her children will present her legacy in an amazing way. May perpetual light shine upon her. \n\nThere are so many people on the Liberal benches who I wish could hear this speech. We were misled today by the member for Winnipeg North. In fact, if he disagrees with me, I wish he would rise in his spot right now and call a point of order stating that he did not mislead anybody. He did not state the facts. This is why.\n\n He asked why, when the Leader of the Opposition was in cabinet, he did not deal with Paul Bernardo being transferred to medium security, which is what we are talking about in this private member's bill. It was because the law was different. The Liberals changed the law. With Bill C-28, in the 42nd Parliament, they changed the threshold for correctional custody for all decision-making to what is called the least restrictive measure. That means a person must be incarcerated under the least restrictive measure. That means that if they can be handled in minimum security, they must go there, regardless of how heinous their offence is. The member told the House and Canadians that the Conservatives could have dealt with it and did not. That is completely wrong and, dare I say, very misleading. He was told it was misleading, and he doubled down. That is not what we should expect and accept as members of this House. \n\nI actually visited the jail where Paul Bernardo was held, and Anne Kelly, the commissioner of corrections, on her way out, in my view, did not like what I had to say, because under her watch, the government put out information that was false about my visit, but I was there with a staff member and a union member who backed up everything I had to say. \n\nI went to Paul Bernardo's cell. He walked up, and we came eye to eye. What did the government say? It was that the MP and Bernardo had no interactions. Well, of course we had no interactions. I did not want to talk to the guy. I did not want to shake his hand. He is one of the most vile people in Canada. No, we did not have any interactions, but we actually did come eye to eye. People can look this up on local media in Kamloops, because the correctional union official gave a statement to the media. The fact that Anne Kelly and correctional officials would seek to sully the reputation of a member of Parliament is disgusting, and it is wrong. \n\nIt is the same thing with the hockey rink. Paul Bernardo has a hockey rink there. There were nets that were tilted up so they would not freeze against the rink. The government said that the hockey rink was not currently operational. What does that mean? One thing officials did not say was that the tennis court was not currently operational. For those who are not aware, the hockey rink doubles as a tennis court. I have a photo of it, if anybody wants to see. It has lighting of the kind that we would find at a local park. \n\nWhen the Liberals say, \"What's the big deal?\", I will tell them what the big deal is. Paul Bernardo, in medium security, has access to a hockey rink, tennis court and skates, which the government left out in its defamatory statements. I would challenge any of those members to say it outside of here. They would not say that I am lying. They just like to put 40% of the picture together, which is meant to mislead.\n\n What does it say about us as a society when one of Canada's worst people can go from maximum to medium security? If members do not think that there is a difference, and I believe Anne Kelly told one of the victims there was no difference, there is actually a substantial difference. The perimeter security is the same, two fences, but as somebody who worked in corrections, I can say that if a person goes to maximum security, there is door after door. In medium security, it is often an open concept. \n\nTerri-Lynne McClintic, and this is something that I hope the member from Winnipeg digests, killed an eight-old girl, Tori Stafford. Part of it was a sexual assault. Guess where she is: medium security. She lives in townhouse-style living, and guess what is next to her house in medium security? It is the mother-child program. We cannot make this up. A sex offender who killed a child lives next door to the mother-child program, but the Liberals will tell us, \"Don't worry, the door is locked all the time.\" I can tell members that I know it is not locked all the time, because whether there are kids or not, there are two doors. The front door may be locked, although I walked right in the one time I went there, and saw two young boys, but there is actually a side door as well that is not locked, and I confirmed that the door is never locked.\n\n I challenge the next Liberal speaker, whoever it is, to address this. Think about the Bernardo victims. Look into the camera and say, \"I'm okay with Paul Bernardo being in medium security. I'm okay with Terri-Lynne McClintic living next door to children.\" They will not do it. I am sure we are going to hear what I hope is not a prepared speech, but likely is, read verbatim. What does it say about us? \n\nWe need to implement this bill, not only because it is the right thing to do and not only because Canadians want it, but because justice, with a capital J, natural justice, demands it. The fact that other people in the House do not see that is a shame and a reflection on them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342454","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, but this is a particularly good occasion.\n\n Before I begin, I want to recognize the work of Anita Price, somebody who faithfully and diligently worked in my office at 100 Mile House, which is no longer in the riding, as well as in our Kamloops office on an as-needed, part-time basis. Anita has just be","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["debb2db522863f7c6740f57e948692b91890dcb51194dce85c019a4fd742022b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d1c26ebbcbe3bd1f862c113e5e454a702f8592c18533443df897e0774e33266"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ded70ec0f9c2eafdfb526bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":341892,"date":"2026-03-11T19:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians have compassion over world events. Sometimes those world events spill onto Canadian streets. Such is the case with the situation in Iran. Three synagogues in Toronto were shot up within the last few days. One Iranian dissident was kidnapped, and it is now a homicide investigation. Only one Iranian regime official has been deported. \n\nThe question is this: Will the Liberals agree to table a plan within the next week to show Canadians how they will deal with this Iranian issue so that Canadians can walk their streets safely?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:341892","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians have compassion over world events. Sometimes those world events spill onto Canadian streets. Such is the case with the situation in Iran. Three synagogues in Toronto were shot up within the last few days. One Iranian dissident was kidnapped, and it is now a homicide investigation. Only one Iranian regime official has been deported. \n\nThe question is this: Will the Liberals a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8e26d591fdc415def6b01371b1e68f72b1bb89793ca2ab07f1a19242c963ae4d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1c81e3a30d8e1688a7f613e8771f7e5b39769f10a1aa0a1d167e04e0d03cf92a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b890411da5458cf998d2679","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":387747,"date":"2026-03-23T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals promised 1,000 new police officers in their last election campaign. Let us talk about a broken promise. Just today, we learned that not only have they not hired those 1,000 officers, they are down 3,400 police officers. That means we are down over 4,000 police officers from what they told us we would have in the last election.\n\nAt a time when crime is skyrocketing, how can Canadians feel safe when these Liberals cannot even hire police officers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387747","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals promised 1,000 new police officers in their last election campaign. Let us talk about a broken promise. Just today, we learned that not only have they not hired those 1,000 officers, they are down 3,400 police officers. That means we are down over 4,000 police officers from what they told us we would have in the last election.\n\nAt a time when crime is skyrocketing, how ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e9de00fa2f51f71efcc747f64bcfc36c3208239993d2ac885fc73568e19a428"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7863344a231e9d5ab51dd57b26bf70d25d544a70598469d8fab822891c84f009"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5bddf20747db2b01b8be8c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":387748,"date":"2026-03-23T19:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, he talks about the new cohort that is being hired. Is that part of the 1,000 who were promised, or the 3,400 we lost? The Liberals cannot distinguish between the two. Let us look at the stats. Violent crime is up 55%: failure. Sexual assault is up 76%: failure. Gun crime is up 130%: failure. Extortion is up 330%: failure. The only thing that is going down is the number of police officers in Canada. \n\nWhy can these Liberals not get their act together and hire the police they promised?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387748","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, he talks about the new cohort that is being hired. Is that part of the 1,000 who were promised, or the 3,400 we lost? The Liberals cannot distinguish between the two. Let us look at the stats. Violent crime is up 55%: failure. Sexual assault is up 76%: failure. Gun crime is up 130%: failure. Extortion is up 330%: failure. The only thing that is going down is the number of police offic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9472da37a179eaa09b6e8a5aa6e9a133154e5f4b3c430ca1e8e3080c3591756b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3b80dbb88218bf5e12745a60eee76974b303d3e08eac66ce9e6857031c04ed4c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd93f4880d2dd5b40ae89592","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":387749,"date":"2026-03-23T23:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. Not only is the member delving into misinformation, but he is saying things that will bring the House into disorder, by saying things that are patently untrue. He should withdraw and apologize. It is disgusting.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387749","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. Not only is the member delving into misinformation, but he is saying things that will bring the House into disorder, by saying things that are patently untrue. He should withdraw and apologize. It is disgusting.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["491dce7cfb2e14554ddd27e295c102ccb3e540ae4455fdbb71c590bd2742e527"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44e92d6cffc0fd7a4a21ef2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":387746,"date":"2026-03-25T21:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nEven though my colleague and I are from different parties, we have often found ourselves in agreement on a number of issues. We worked on the justice committee together.\n\nI really want to address something he was speaking about at the end. I have two points to make, and I would love an on-point response or rebuttal from him.\n\nThe first point is that he spoke about the promotion of hatred and what one of his colleagues said, who is now a cabinet colleague. When I see somebody saying something like reading from the Torah is hateful and then that person gets promoted to cabinet, that is a bit of a problem. The second point is that when the Liberals go along with a Bloc amendment talking about protecting religious people who speak and protecting their freedom of expression, that becomes an issue. \n\nThose are the concerns, not what he said. Those are all laudable concerns.\n\nHow would he respond to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387746","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nEven though my colleague and I are from different parties, we have often found ourselves in agreement on a number of issues. We worked on the justice committee together.\n\nI really want to address something he was speaking about at the end. I have two points to make, and I would love an on-point res","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e90a31cd0f65f3a8fa6b6cf121dcd8fcc351ef6e7ddba8cae7ec61eaf860695"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90381c4dbb7d4d59b8ab3dfb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":387745,"date":"2026-03-26T18:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I was the chief critic for the bill. I was the shadow minister as it was ushered through committee.\n\nOne thing I want to say is this: The bill was overly broad. As a party, the Liberals say they love the charter. One thing that will get a bill struck down as unconstitutional is overbreadth, such as use of language like \"may\" or \"any threat\". The bill was a dog's breakfast when it got to committee.\n\nI am proud of the people I sat with on the public safety committee, who looked at the bill, studied it scrupulously and added a proportionality test to it. They sought to add judicial oversight, which was ruled out of order yesterday by the Speaker, and sought to add things like \"necessary\" and \"reasonable\".\n\nThe member for Winnipeg North says that these are tinfoil hat terms; no, these are apple pie when it comes to legal interpretation. The Liberals may not want to have those types of safeguards in the bill. I could say that we as Conservatives will always stand for clear constitutional laws. I invite comments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387745","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I was the chief critic for the bill. I was the shadow minister as it was ushered through committee.\n\nOne thing I want to say is this: The bill was overly broad. As a party, the Liberals say they love the charter. One thing that will get a bill struck down as unconstitutional is overbreadth, such as ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["944d3cddc7e39fd865395ba4ac6f27eef62f396ff7851d626137c8b6b064f5c8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["11986033a40534b791396d8b3f7492fc93e0a2ab4e1d536018367d167595410d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c0af8a21700404b01f06a4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501154,"date":"2026-04-13T16:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that Bill C-225, An Act to amend the Criminal Code, as amended, be concurred in at report stage.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501154","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"moved that Bill C-225, An Act to amend the Criminal Code, as amended, be concurred in at report stage.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e320959371d9c6dce74f0b1c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501156,"date":"2026-04-13T16:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I ask that this be carried.\n\nThe Speaker: On division?\n\nFrank Caputo: No, just carried through a voice vote, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501156","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I ask that this be carried.\n\nThe Speaker: On division?\n\nFrank Caputo: No, just carried through a voice vote, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cdb21a6fb33a1fe5436bb7a30cfc384dfa1b4c7e3487e293bd1850213261b573"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fda2ffdc79b660caec2362c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501157,"date":"2026-04-13T16:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that the bill be read the third time and passed.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I must say, whenever we hear \"when shall the bill be read the next time\", I think that this is the first time I have ever heard, in the House, that it be said, \"Now.\"\n\nI hear the member from Winnipeg chuckling. I think that he is probably a bit disappointed that he did not get that extra word in Hansard. If it was recorded, perhaps it could be attributed to him by the verification desk. We all know that he likes to speak in the House, just as I do. In fact, we should all appreciate speaking in this place. I was reflecting not long ago about this, about how much of an honour it is to be here.\n\nLet us face it. Whenever we have a job, we will have people who take different degrees of interest in their job. For me, I have the ability to stand here on the green carpet of the House of Commons, as somebody who grew up as the child of immigrants in a very middle-class home. My dad was a sawmill worker. My mom was a stay-at-home mom until I was about 10, the last child, when she went back to school to become a legal assistant. Ultimately, I became a lawyer. We see this going full circle.\n\nThe ability to stand here in the House of Commons is not something we should ever underestimate, regardless of which side of the aisle we are on. If I could amplify that point even more, it is an even greater honour when we have what we call private members' bills or Private Members' Business.\n\nI experienced this first-hand last time, through Bill C-291, which was an amendment to the Criminal Code in the last Parliament, to change the name of child pornography to child sexual abuse exploitation material. I wrote that bill. It was then shepherded by the member for what is now Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. \n\nI have my Criminal Code here. I promise that I am not using it as a prop, but one of the things I can say about my 2026 Criminal Code is that this language has now been adopted to reflect the fact that we are no longer using that antiquated language. It is against that backdrop that I rise here today.\n\nI thank everybody here for allowing this matter to proceed past the report stage without the necessity for a standing vote, so that we could get to third reading now. I am optimistic and hopeful that debate could perhaps collapse so that we could be voting on the bill as soon as Wednesday or even today. Hope springs eternal, they might say.\n\nColloquially, this is called \"Bailey's Law\", Bill C-225. This is the first private member's bill that has been brought forward in the Parliament for debate. It is my honour to stand here before us.\n\nBailey McCourt was in her mid-30s. Her abuser was convicted of assaulting her, of choking her and, I believe, of threatening her. Three hours after he was convicted, free on bail, he killed her. That matter remains before the court, so he is obviously accused at this time. I do not believe that there is any dispute as to who the assailant was. The question of his guilt in a court of law will have to be for another day.\n\nFor context, I had actually written the bill about two or three years ago. As most people know, I was a lawyer before I came to this place. I guess I will be a lawyer after I leave this place. One of the things that really bothered me was that we treat assault the same way regardless of context, mostly. For instance, assault in the Criminal Code is under section 266. Whether one beats one's intimate partner or beats somebody up at the bar, it is the same charge. There is one exception that we used to look at a lot, which was assault of a peace officer. Assaulting a peace officer was different. The law certainly recognizes that, sometimes, things should be different.\n\nI thought it should be different for assaulting an intimate partner. Intimate partners are within a relationship of trust and often of financial dependence. It is not uncommon for one intimate partner to make vastly more money. At times of separation or at times of potential separation, that can really be exploitative. There is spiritual dependence oftentimes, and just general codependence. That was something that really bothered me, and that was why I had written a version of the bill in 2023 or 2024.\n\nThe bill never got tabled. After Bailey was killed in early July 2025, the NDP Premier of British Columbia called for the killing of an intimate partner to be first-degree murder. I thought, as a Conservative, that if the NDP premier was asking for this, perhaps we could find a common ground. That is why I put the bill forward.\n\n I want to recognize a number of people who have been impacted by Bailey's tragic killing. Let us not forget her children. Carrie Wiebe was present in the car when Bailey was killed. I sent her a message today giving her an update. We cannot forget Bailey's family, her mother Karen, her father Shane, her stepmom Trish, her sister Paige and her aunt Debbie.\n\nSometimes we see things in the news and become detached from them. One thing I enjoy about this job that is challenging, and I think every member here feels this way, is that when we deal with somebody, whether with respect to an immigration matter, a taxation matter or, in this case, a matter of crime, they are touched by it personally. I can say that when we look somebody in the eye, it touches us personally. If we look at people like Flo and Paul, who appeared at committee, and we hear them speak about their daughter and her tragic killing at the hands of an intimate partner, it really crystallizes within me the necessity for us to challenge the status quo sometimes. \n\nThe law evolves, it should evolve and sometimes it has to evolve more drastically. In fact, the last time I think the law evolved on the issue of intimate partner violence was likely in the early 1980s when an exception to the law of sexual assault with respect to one's spouse was taken out, and rightfully so. A person can sexually assault their spouse. It happens far too often. Therefore, I am very proud to be standing before Parliament today with I believe the support of all parties. We received all-party support at second reading. I hope we will have all-party support at third reading to make the most substantial change to the law of intimate partner violence thus far in Canadian history.\n\nIt is important that we work together. One of the things I often tell people who see us oftentimes as being pugilistic or combative is that there is a time and a place to be oppositional. I am a member of His Majesty's loyal opposition, a role I take very seriously. Without a meaningful opposition, I believe that democracy is imperilled. There is a time to protest. There is a time to debate. There is a time to oppose. There is a time to question. Questioning is fine. In fact, questioning is vital to a robust democracy. I hope if I am ever on the government benches that we have a meaningful opposition. This is one reason why I often take such issue with time allocation, closure and things like that when we have barely discussed a bill. I am very proud to stand before Parliament on this issue. \n\nI was talking about the opposition and why it is important. One thing people may or may not realize is this. If they were to look at the bill before it goes to committee, at second reading and after it has gone to committee, they would see a substantially different bill, and that is okay. In fact, when we work together and make bills better, it is a good thing. I can say, as the sponsor of this bill, that I believe we have made it better. I believe that, in working with the minister's office and my staff, we have made the bill better. \n\nThis may be the last time I get to speak on this bill, so I will thank my staff, Stephanie Rennick, Jesus Bondo and Rofiat Agboola, for helping out and working with the minister's staff. I would like to thank the minister's staff, who have been more than accommodating in meeting with us in order to address this bill.\n\nWhat would the bill do? It would make major changes with respect to homicide of an intimate partner. If a homicide of an intimate partner occurs, that homicide would now be first-degree murder if there is a pattern of coercion or control, or if the homicide occurs during coercion or control. Manslaughter of an intimate partner would now have to be considered with respect to whether a life sentence should be imposed.\n\nA life sentence in Canada is imposed mandatorily for murder generally, whether first-degree or second-degree murder The question then becomes one of parole ineligibility, and we call that a minimum sentence for life. There is actually a maximum sentence for life. A lot of people do not know this, but a person can go to jail for life for breaking into someone's home. That is the maximum sentence a court can impose. The court does not have to impose that, but it can. A court can also impose a maximum sentence of life for manslaughter.\n\nI was a parole officer in my early twenties, and I worked in the justice system for a long time. The last time I saw a life sentence imposed for manslaughter was in 1972. That is a long time ago, yet intimate partner violence continues to be a scourge on our society. Maybe it is high time we address sentencing.\n\n One of the things I have taken issue with is the government's sentencing of sexual offences, particularly sexual offences against children. The way we as society and as Parliament reflect our difficulty or our issue with a crime should be based in part on sentencing: the more repugnant the crime, the stricter the sentence. In some cases we call that denunciation. That is what is talked about in section 718 of the Criminal Code. Sometimes we talk about deterrence, making a sentence so bad that people do not want to do the crime or will think twice before they do it.\n\nHowever, in a lot of respects, we just have to say it like it is. It is happening far too often that intimate partners are dying. This is flying under the radar far too often, unreported or under-reported, so we need to make changes. Often in intimate partner violence what we call the cycle of violence continues on and on. In Bailey's case, there was a cycle of violence. As I recall, there were breaches involved. She had been previously victimized by the offender. It is time to stop the cycle of violence. We need a paradigm shift in this country on the issue, and I hope that Bill C-225 would do that.\n\n My colleague will be speaking on behalf of the party seconder, the member for Cloverdale—Langley City, whom I want to thank for giving up her spot in the order of precedence so we could speak to the bill sooner. Having a team effort like this and having members like the member for Cloverdale—Langley City, who gave up her spot selflessly in order to have Bailey's law advance sooner on third reading, is how we get things done. I am incredibly indebted to the member. I am indebted to every member who has spoken to the bill from our benches, who has supported it and who has met with the family.\n\nLet us get the bill passed right now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501157","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"moved that the bill be read the third time and passed.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I must say, whenever we hear \"when shall the bill be read the next time\", I think that this is the first time I have ever heard, in the House, that it be said, \"Now.\"\n\nI hear the member from Winnipeg chuckling. I think that he is proba","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c69490c15abccc17c4776f35f413f6a3f12d98d6d5e0a1dbc50d60b906ef5501"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f2cf503912b49b30b69f8e558d61949cf20dc44bb75ad4b09e9bc570e3b45fa2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3955d4e3ba8ecc20f2e015a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501158,"date":"2026-04-13T16:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for his contribution. Obviously, sometimes we do have our disagreements in the House, and that is actually healthy.\n\n Therefore, in direct response to the member's question, I will say that the committee process was actually very meaningful. For people who might not know, committee is where we study a bill. When we got to committee, we as Conservatives had agreed to a number of amendments. There were a number of stakeholders who had spoken loudly and clearly on the issue. I know that my Bloc colleagues had thoughts and that my Liberal colleagues and my NDP colleagues had thoughts.\n\nHowever, the fact that we were able to synthesize all those thoughts so quickly into amendments was very meaningful. I believe it was two and a half or three meetings that the committee met for such a lengthy piece of legislation. Normally, private members' bills are a lot shorter. The committee process went as it should: smoothly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501158","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for his contribution. Obviously, sometimes we do have our disagreements in the House, and that is actually healthy.\n\n Therefore, in direct response to the member's question, I will say that the committee process was actually very meaningful. For people who might not know, committee is where we study a bill. When we got to committee, we as Conservatives had agre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f8282b4b428519d36e174df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501160,"date":"2026-04-13T16:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is actually a very important question.\n\n The House voted, I believe unanimously, in the last Parliament on a bill from former NDP member Laurel Collins with respect to coercive control, but I believe it died on the Order Paper when the election was called.\n\n Coercive control is part of the cycle of violence that I just referred to. It is something that goes on and on. It is a part of that violence. Intimate partner violence generally does not just come out of nowhere. There are precursors. There are antecedents that happen, and coercive control is central to that. It is part of the dependence, often financial dependence, that we see, as well as psychological manipulation. Therefore, it is very important that the House recognize the role of coercive control in criminality.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501160","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is actually a very important question.\n\n The House voted, I believe unanimously, in the last Parliament on a bill from former NDP member Laurel Collins with respect to coercive control, but I believe it died on the Order Paper when the election was called.\n\n Coercive control is part of the cycle of violence that I just referred to. It is something that goes on and on. It is a par","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4fbbeabbda733404ce3b06d805c6da0af6571b67afcbbfa23cfadaa51c0379d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7f83a68d1ff45da5ac5563851832c2b47ff0476daaed982eece4a5819850ff0f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-374fba5820465ebca55bf490","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501161,"date":"2026-04-13T16:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I extend my deepest condolences to Bailey's grandmother. I actually was not aware of her being present for Bailey's first and her final breaths. That is very difficult to hear.\n\nIn answer to the member's question, the first thing that we have to address is that there is a problem. If we are unprepared in the House to say that intimate partner violence is a problem, and if we are unprepared to say we have to deal with this, then we have an even bigger problem. This is the first step in addressing that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501161","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I extend my deepest condolences to Bailey's grandmother. I actually was not aware of her being present for Bailey's first and her final breaths. That is very difficult to hear.\n\nIn answer to the member's question, the first thing that we have to address is that there is a problem. If we are unprepared in the House to say that intimate partner violence is a problem, and if we are unpre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f0d6e69d294e5c0343404718fe21e184fc140cabcbb2a5724d53a5915ec503cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b2e01602bf4b4f8d987f56a59abfa44283ea56326da60d84bd42eecc23b6089d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d82a0d665ad25e49710d0fe7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501162,"date":"2026-04-13T17:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I take great interest in this subject matter, both as a lawyer who practised in this area and as the chief critic for the bill.\n\nOne of the things that is very important, I think, to the people who are looking at the bill, to the people who are scrutinizing the bill and to the people who have looked at the bill from an expert point of view is part 2. That is with respect to the retention of data.\n\n I am coming at this from a legitimate point of inquiry. This is not meant to be a gotcha or anything. What I would like the minister to explain is this. The bill would require third parties, as in businesses and service providers, to retain certain information and to do things with that information.\n\nDoes he think that this is constitutionally compliant? How do we know that the government simply is not going too far here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501162","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I take great interest in this subject matter, both as a lawyer who practised in this area and as the chief critic for the bill.\n\nOne of the things that is very important, I think, to the people who are looking at the bill, to the people who are scrutinizing the bill and to the people who have looked a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["645bafe6cf8f13997ebe07241139df9299ce8c70a4ee986bd1277dc0129f4728"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["410bc8ce390d2e42d9589731a63c68d6ca61a120bcf592a62b0591786abc1669"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2a312104eb2d05b76e06193","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501163,"date":"2026-04-13T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nWe are only about an hour and a half into today, and this is my third time rising. What an honour it is to speak in the House of Commons, not only so frequently but also on matters of such import. We are dealing with really important issues today. Sometimes we deal with things that are quite performative in the House, but I can candidly say that, today, this is an issue of fairly significant importance. \n\nBefore I start, I want to recognize one of my very good friends, who is celebrating a birthday. Philip Lee is 48 years old. He is somebody I went to high school with and have known for the past 36 years now. We have had the opportunity to travel together, and he has been a wonderful friend. I would like to wish Phil all the best in the upcoming year. \n\nI also want to recognize two people from Kamloops who accomplished something really significant. Johnny Hicks and Brady Milburn are part of the Denver Pioneers hockey club. That club is part of the NCAA. This weekend, the team was crowned the men's NCAA champion. I congratulate Johnny and Brady, who are both Kamloops products, and the whole Denver Pioneers team. Winning the NCAA championship is a tremendous accomplishment. \n\nWhat brings us here today is Bill C-22, but we have to look at the past to inform how we got here. Bill C-2 was heralded as a cure-all, a panacea, if we will, to all the things that ailed the justice system. If only we could pass Bill C-2, everything would be fine. \n\nUnfortunately, we have heard that before in the House. For years, we were told there were no issues with bail and sentencing, yet here we are now with a so-called new government, with many of the same cabinet ministers as the old government, and we are still dealing with the same issues. \n\nI believe the minister referenced Commissioner Carrique talking about this type of legislation going way back to 1997. In fact, Conservatives put forward legislation on lawful access and were roundly mocked by Liberals. There is a famous quote, which I will not repeat here today, that stemmed from that very debate, and now we hear there is a rush to pass this legislation. I understand why lawful access is so important, but if there was a rush, then why were the Liberals opposed to it in the last decade? If there was a rush, then why has it taken the Liberal government 11 years to bring this bill forward? If there was a rush, then why was Bill C-2 so clumsily drafted? \n\nWe are here because of Bill C-2. In fact, if we look at portions of Bill C-2, we can see that we now have two bills that stem from it: Bill C-12 and Bill C-22. Both of those bills have dramatically remodelled what was contained in Bill C-2. In fact, Bill C-12 renovated so much of the text of Bill C-2 that it underwent further amendments at committee. I believe that my colleague, the shadow minister for immigration, the member for Calgary Nose Hill, did a great deal of work and produced a number of amendments at committee that were supported by the government or the Bloc and ultimately made it into the bill. That bill was a substantially better version of portions of Bill C-2. What do we have in Bill C-22? We have parts 14 and 15 of Bill C-2.\n\n One of the things that always strikes me is how, in the past, Conservatives heard criticisms of omnibus bills. Bill C-2 is about as omnibus as it gets. I think it would have impacted something like 11 pieces of legislation. I do not want to be quoted on that because I cannot remember, but it would have impacted so many pieces of legislation and created pieces of legislation. It is well over 100 pages. It is an omnibus bill to the point where we now have two bills that have stemmed from it, and I think we probably have three or four distinct subject matters that are contained within Bill C-2 that still have not been addressed. The part of Bill C-2 we have before us now is the notion of lawful access.\n\n I am going to focus on what is in Bill C-2, but I will also focus on some of the concerns I have. My hope is that the government will take these concerns legitimately and that we can proceed in the spirit of open and constructive dialogue. \n\nMy colleague for Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound asked a question. He sits on the national security committee, commonly known as NSICOP, which provides secret and confidential advice to the Prime Minister. Those who are on the committee are not permitted to speak about anything that is discussed in committee, and would be subject to very significant penalties under criminal law if they did, but one thing my colleague and friend for Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound spoke about was not only the necessity, from NSICOP's point of view, of lawful access, but also what should be in that legislation. \n\nAs Conservatives, we will always take the position that initiatives to help law enforcement, initiatives that allow those in law enforcement to do their jobs more easily, is something we will always be open to, but we have to make sure that those revisions to the law are both charter-compliant and consistent with the rights of privacy that we believe all Canadians should enjoy. \n\nIn my view, the government has, in the past, tried to overstep its boundaries at times. Bill C-2, in parts 14 and 15, is an example, as it goes so far as to use language like any threat or \"any action\". We saw that in Bill C-8 as well. Bill C-2 essentially wants the government to have access to \"any information\". Well, that goes quite too far. I was happy to see that the government, at the very least, went back to the drawing board. \n\nPreviously, a question from the government was about how the Conservatives could have just passed this in Bill C-2. Well, no, Conservatives would not have passed this in Bill C-2 because Bill C-2 is a poorly written piece of legislation. If Conservatives should have passed it in Bill C-2, then the government should have put forward a better piece of legislation, and I would go so far as to say that the government is admitting such because it has put forward Bill C-22. If Bill C-2 had no issues, if it did not, in the eyes of experts throughout the country, take significant liberties with privacy rights and things like that, then we would not be here today. The fact that the government has put forward Bill C-22 is itself an admission that Bill C-2, in its omnibus form, is, unfortunately, poorly drafted. That is what brings us here today.\n\nWhat are some of the things in Bill C-2? There are three parts. The first part we are looking at is on tools for law enforcement to access digital information. I do not believe this is going to be a controversial part of the bill. Right now, based on decisions from the Supreme Court of Canada over roughly the last 12 years, law enforcement has to write a great number of court orders, which is how I would put it. Another way to put it is \"judicial authorizations\", and some people call them \"warrants\". They often take the form of a warrant or a production order, such as an order to a business saying, \"Is Frank Caputo your subscriber, yes or no?\" Then it would say, \"Please produce all the Frank Caputo subscriber information.\" Those might be two distinct questions. The problem is that this takes time. \n\n Every time somebody has to go and get a court order, somebody has to write up that court order. They have to swear an affidavit in support of that court order. That takes time. As Conservatives, we recognize that when there are inefficiencies in the law, we need to address them. That is something that I do not think people take a great deal of issue with, but sometimes the devil is in the details and we need to ask further questions about those things.\n\n The current process in regard to subscriber information is informed by the decision of Regina v. Spencer. Now, that decision came out in 2014. Spencer impacted the obtaining of production orders, just to put it colloquially. I am sure somebody is going to be looking at the headnote of Spencer and will compare my words. I am just talking generally here, not with the legal precision that I would in court. We are looking at getting production orders for just about everything for which a subscriber may have an expectation of privacy. That would change with Bill C-22. \n\nBykovets was another really key decision of the court, 10 years after Spencer. I believe Bykovets was about the expectation of privacy in a person's IP address. This was significant because most people do not know their IP address. A lot of people do not even know that they have an IP address. If they do know they have an IP address, they might not even know how they get it. When Bykovets said there is an expectation of privacy in that, I believe some legal scholars said, \"Okay, that's interesting.\"\n\nI am not here to take potshots at decisions. I am here to recognize what the issue is. Whenever there is an expectation of privacy, then we need a search that is authorized by law through a court order. That meant a court order was required to get an IP address, even though finding an IP address was essentially akin to finding a phone number in the phone book. That was the analogy, as I recall. Most of us in the House will remember phone books. The member for Kenora—Kiiwetinoong probably does not, but he is probably the only one. The rest of us remember what it was like to get phone books. Let us face it, phone books were everywhere. Anybody could find anything. Anybody, as I understand it, with some semblance of digital acumen would be able to get an IP address, but nonetheless, the courts said there is an expectation of privacy.\n\n These are all issues we are dealing with right now, within the current framework, that part 1 would address. As well, let us not forget that these are often offences against children and terrorist offences. Those are the two offences that are probably of the most interest to the legislators in the House, as in how we address those things.\n\nLet us get into part 2 a little bit. I have skipped over some of part 1 because I want to give part 2 what it requires in terms of debate. Part 2 talks about ministerial orders. I am mindful of the fact that the Intelligence Commissioner now has a role to play within these ministerial orders.\n\nThe thing that I think we need to look at or that I would want more information on, as I craft my position and Conservatives craft our position on this, is that when there is a ministerial order that is secret, the government should be prepared to substantiate why it is secret and if it should be secret in every single instance. For instance, we spoke about NSICOP recently and how everything that is about national security will be top secret. There may be a place to say yes, if it is going to impact national security, but does that mean that every single ministerial order is going to be secret or should be secret?\n\nFurthermore, when it comes to the Intelligence Commissioner, precisely what role would that person play, and how would their independent oversight impact a number of the concerns? One of the key areas that part 2 of Bill C-22 impacts is that it compels third parties to keep information. I want to be very clear here that the information, in my reading of the bill, would still require a warrant. I believe the way the minister explained it was that the information would be kept and then could be accessed. That is, the government does not simply receive the information, but it is present in order to be accessed.\n\nIt is my view that whenever the government tells anybody, including electronic service providers, that they must keep something, including metadata, it is something we need to ask questions about. This is probably one of the biggest issues. As I understand it, the bill's intent is to require that metadata be kept. That can include location services, but it is not meant to include the content. That is my reading of the bill. I think this needs to be closely scrutinized, and I look forward to asking more questions in the next two days of debate here on that very issue.\n\n First, I would love to hear about the constitutionality of the requirement to have a third party keep something so the government can access it. I am not going to stand here and say whether that is or is not constitutional as it is not something I have studied thus far, but I think it is a question Canadians may have. \n\nSecond, on the idea of the requirement that a person's location be kept, who is going to keep that? Where is the data going to be stored? In my riding, we have a huge data storage facility. Are there going to be requirements as to how and where that data is stored and things like that? \n\nThis is a very complicated piece of legislation. I think somebody could read Bill C-22 three times and think they are starting to get a sense of what it actually says. When we deal with pieces of legislation that are quite intricate, obviously we need to develop our positions not only in a careful way but in a way that is sound. That is what I hope to do and what we as Conservatives hope to do.\n\n Is there a mechanism by which web browsing history can be captured under Bill C-22? I think a lot of people would be alarmed if that were the case, from a privacy point of view. The issue of data retention is not a new one. One of the principal issues that I went up against, as somebody who prosecuted Internet offences against kids, was data retention. I was speaking with police officers today, and ISP addresses, in some cases, can actually disappear within as little as 30 days. I am not saying we should not be looking at that. We should absolutely be looking at that, but perhaps there should be limits.\n\nIf we are going to impact privacy rights, maybe that should be based on the offence. If we are looking at a sexual offence, perhaps the terminology we could look at is \"an offence against the person\". All sexual offences are, by their very nature, violent, and I do not mean to dichotomize there. However, with respect to sexual offences, sexual offences against children or investigations into violence against the person, if there are concerns, perhaps there could be a narrowing so there would not be simply a fishing expedition to try to find an offence. Rather, we would be looking at all offences. \n\nI see my time is coming to a close. Before I end, I want to acknowledge three people: Kelly Hunter, a baseball and softball umpire who was inducted into the Kamloops Sports Hall of Fame this weekend; Jessica Hewitt, a speed skater who was inducted into the Kamloops Sports Hall of Fame this weekend; and Glenn Armstrong, a football coach who was also inducted into the Kamloops Sports Hall of Fame. These three individuals have made dynamic contributions to the Kamloops area in sport, and I congratulate them.\n\n With that, I will enjoy any questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501163","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nWe are only about an hour and a half into today, and this is my third time rising. What an honour it is to speak in the House of Commons, not only so frequently but also on matters of such import. We are dealing with really important issues today. Sometimes we deal with things that are quite performa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad9b721af5ef7edd1c7db81ba6d436c14053d9dec08926d2a95b31532b57c5b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["82bb99b1a12c6d95ca085de572b79e9d6c44f4c339b18ecb602099e01f112ac5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86db3cb11f919b054862925c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501164,"date":"2026-04-13T17:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we always need to modernize in law. I actually spoke about it this morning when I was speaking to my private member's bill. The moment we stop pushing here and are complacent, in any law but especially in the criminal law, we have an issue. The law is often years behind when it comes to technology. The member will have heard me reference Spencer, which was a decision from 2014.\n\nAs Conservatives, we will always be open to the modernization of law. Right now, what we are doing and what we are evaluating in debate with respect to this bill is whether this is the right way to modernize the law. There is no issue that we all want less crime and that we all want the police to be able to do their jobs. The question that I have, and that we have, is whether Bill C-22 is the appropriate mechanism to do so.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501164","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we always need to modernize in law. I actually spoke about it this morning when I was speaking to my private member's bill. The moment we stop pushing here and are complacent, in any law but especially in the criminal law, we have an issue. The law is often years behind when it comes to technology. The member will have heard me reference Spencer, which was a decision from 2014.\n\nAs Co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b4a2c23769489883166c460b714b9f43f7dfeb7e12dc7108d47cf9cdee8f2a0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["43e5892787ef197d5995824be1c96adb77720776195d0dacf43fc6b3d1961e16"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f62049d8887f9a383d8041f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501165,"date":"2026-04-13T17:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would agree. Sometimes we get legislation before us in the House and we say that we can all agree to it or that some tweaks need to be made. This Parliament has worked a lot better than the last Parliament did in terms of moving forward things on which we can all agree.\n\nIn specific response to my colleague's question, there are certainly a number of questions that arise within this bill, particularly on part 2. If we are going to address this and develop our positions, I do not think it is a bad thing to ask the questions in debate and to develop our positions from there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501165","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would agree. Sometimes we get legislation before us in the House and we say that we can all agree to it or that some tweaks need to be made. This Parliament has worked a lot better than the last Parliament did in terms of moving forward things on which we can all agree.\n\nIn specific response to my colleague's question, there are certainly a number of questions that arise within this","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6e7b8c6724e32f324e69be5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501166,"date":"2026-04-13T17:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for this very important question. Evidence is required in any sort of prosecution. What my colleague is asking about, in my view, is how we deal with the gaps in evidence that exists now but may not exist tomorrow. That is essentially what I take his question to be.\n\n NSICOP has said there is a gap. For instance, I just mentioned that 30-day gap between ISP addresses and how long they go. This is clearly something that Canadian law has to address. It is an issue that we often have to overcome in prosecuting anything: Where is the data or the evidence now? It is crucially important for us, as a House, to consider that. What is the correct form, though?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501166","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for this very important question. Evidence is required in any sort of prosecution. What my colleague is asking about, in my view, is how we deal with the gaps in evidence that exists now but may not exist tomorrow. That is essentially what I take his question to be.\n\n NSICOP has said there is a gap. For instance, I just mentioned that 30-day gap between ISP addresse","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cafd2a7a8b7ad78096c016faebe6ec009a86d350ec042d56b32b297f84a8a639"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd04afc6b1e7abdfa7a74980036453b0ecee92685101ad0725ac94fbab483e4c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7546be391b1b7b3e66ec65b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501167,"date":"2026-04-13T17:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague from Saanich—Gulf Islands referenced my colleague from Winnipeg North and how much we have debated whether Canada Post can open people's mail, so I am not going to get into that for what would probably be the 32nd time or so.\n\nI do agree with my colleague on the point of Bill C-2 morphing into Bill C-12 and now morphing into Bill C-22, and this tacit acknowledgement of, \"Wow, we really got it wrong. Not only did we get it wrong on one thing, but we got it wrong on multiple things because we are not even pursuing Bill C-2 as a government.\" This is the Liberals' point of view. \"We got Bill C-12 right enough for it to pass and now we are trying to get Bill C-22 right enough for it to pass.\"\n\nWhen it comes to part 1 of this bill, what I do notice is that, for instance, the police or a state actor cannot go and get information from just anybody, a general practitioner, Facebook or groups like that. It is strictly restricted to telecoms, so we can see the government really pulling back on what it was seeking from this. I think that is an acknowledgement that Bill C-2 really did miss the mark.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501167","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague from Saanich—Gulf Islands referenced my colleague from Winnipeg North and how much we have debated whether Canada Post can open people's mail, so I am not going to get into that for what would probably be the 32nd time or so.\n\nI do agree with my colleague on the point of Bill C-2 morphing into Bill C-12 and now morphing into Bill C-22, and this tacit acknowledgement ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47983","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47983","label":"Telecommunications networks","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a8d23976094964a3d7372f58a4e3d3b324db9c6c2d3c7c892546159a1fc396e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a61b58be565c9245b41c8640","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501168,"date":"2026-04-13T17:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-22 is a complicated bill. Bill C-2 was a dog's breakfast, to put it mildly. I do not know that I would be saying that we should build on anything from it.\n\nWe are looking at the bill and the member will know when we have our position. We are going to scrutinize this bill and give it the scrutiny it deserves on behalf of Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501168","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-22 is a complicated bill. Bill C-2 was a dog's breakfast, to put it mildly. I do not know that I would be saying that we should build on anything from it.\n\nWe are looking at the bill and the member will know when we have our position. We are going to scrutinize this bill and give it the scrutiny it deserves on behalf of Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b4ae65a18d805fe3bf80b3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501169,"date":"2026-04-13T17:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, to the best of my knowledge, we have a review period that is required after three years, which is part 3 of the legislation. I would have to go back and look through this very lengthy bill to see whether there is something like that. Perhaps that is something that could be addressed through amendments.\n\nI look forward to hearing my colleagues speak on this bill as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501169","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, to the best of my knowledge, we have a review period that is required after three years, which is part 3 of the legislation. I would have to go back and look through this very lengthy bill to see whether there is something like that. Perhaps that is something that could be addressed through amendments.\n\nI look forward to hearing my colleagues speak on this bill as well.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ddb7fd0676e67944b7370470","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501170,"date":"2026-04-13T18:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI listened with great interest to my colleague's speech. I find where we really part company is on this idea that we should simply pass the bill because the Liberals think it is good legislation. It is not that there should not be scrutiny, because there is a great deal of scrutiny. Here is a quote: \"Part 2 of C-22 enables secret ministerial orders to any digital service Canadians rely on, with no public registry, no parliamentary approval, and no right for Canadians to even know it's happening.\" This is not to say that every piece of legislation here is wonderful or every piece of legislation is bad, but we scrutinize legislation.\n\n The member points to law enforcement. Where were those sentiments on the jail not bail act? Law enforcement wanted the jail not bail act. He stood up repeatedly and voted against it. What is good for the goose is good for the gander.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501170","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI listened with great interest to my colleague's speech. I find where we really part company is on this idea that we should simply pass the bill because the Liberals think it is good legislation. It is not that there should not be scrutiny, because there is a great deal of scrutiny. Here is a quote","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","label":"Birds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4de4676b2bedc475ed8bbc6e7b9bf25dc33fe91f440069fed5a6a7438c51257d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0200e99b148df5213ebf8f09","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501172,"date":"2026-04-13T21:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\n I took great joy in my colleague's speech. One would think that we once held the same job. In hearing my colleague speak, one of the things that was brought to mind, and particularly when we heard questions and comments, is that law enforcement is asking for the legislation. The government uses this as an appeal to the House to do something.\n\nLaw enforcement also asked for the jail not bail act, and I wonder if my colleague could update the House as to how the government acted when law enforcement asked for that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501172","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\n I took great joy in my colleague's speech. One would think that we once held the same job. In hearing my colleague speak, one of the things that was brought to mind, and particularly when we heard questions and comments, is that law enforcement is asking for the legislation. The government uses this","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d31cc8d130d62c8f4854e8511183a76d9ab7e6913ab516df9aa02ea618a072f3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["76d5bd9f1804c91f78e363685955d688a4fa020c76039d562d81e3ce52eef661"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68d3069b089e70d2a4f81ecd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501173,"date":"2026-04-13T22:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I appreciate my colleague's passion and nuanced approach. I did not take him to say in his comments that we Conservatives want to stymie law enforcement. I think it is quite the opposite: We want to have a system that is built on efficiency, has laws that are charter-compliant and gives us the best bill possible.\n\n Thus far, we have heard far too often, in my view, that if we oppose this bill, we oppose law enforcement and the gathering of information lawfully and appropriately. I simply disagree with that assessment. I wonder if he could provide his thoughts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501173","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I appreciate my colleague's passion and nuanced approach. I did not take him to say in his comments that we Conservatives want to stymie law enforcement. I think it is quite the opposite: We want to have a system that is built on efficiency, has laws that are charter-compliant and gives us the best bi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef3af76d89797d579dd9f0f9ff0b29bdbb70c77e42534a2becafa7dc3b2ef332"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f6a7ba38ada9af95fa776cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501174,"date":"2026-04-13T22:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nAs the member spoke about Bill C-8 and Bill C-9, I wonder how those bills, having meandered their way through this House and committee, have informed his position on the issues he is raising with respect to this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501174","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nAs the member spoke about Bill C-8 and Bill C-9, I wonder how those bills, having meandered their way through this House and committee, have informed his position on the issues he is raising with respect to this bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ed3f0e5dd8e38907959afa9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501175,"date":"2026-04-13T22:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I feel that has been a common refrain here today. My hon. colleague has been a tireless advocate, especially when it comes to making sure that our government functions the way it should. She has done excellent work on the public safety committee, in particular when it comes to CBSA. \n\nOne of the things we have repeatedly heard from the government is that we are with it or against it when it comes to this legislation. Can my colleague comment on the difficulty with that type of proposition when our job is not to look at it in terms of black and white, but to look at it in terms of whether we are getting this right or not?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501175","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I feel that has been a common refrain here today. My hon. colleague has been a tireless advocate, especially when it comes to making sure that our government functions the way it should. She has done excellent work on the public safety committee, in particular when it comes to CBSA. \n\nOne of the thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d65db29c47db578d5b53ef188cfd15f90f5724f7b82f56775020c593651d744d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85091e5017354ee8a6dfe04b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501178,"date":"2026-04-13T22:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I will give some background here. My colleague and I both sit on the public safety committee. Bill C-8 came to us at the public safety committee. I felt it was a deeply flawed bill. There were, I would like to say, probably 30 amendments that we went through at committee. I believe the committee process is an important one. We may not always agree with the Bloc, but in this case, the Bloc shared a number of our concerns. The NDP shared a number of our concerns, though it does not actually have standing at the committee. One has to think, when the NDP and the Bloc start sharing concerns with the Conservatives, maybe there is actually something to this. Bill C-8 went through committee and it was long. It was a bit tedious at times, but it was very important for us to address that bill.\n\nCan my colleague comment on Bill C-8 and her experience with that, and how it informs what she believes we should be doing with this bill and how we should be scrutinizing it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501178","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I will give some background here. My colleague and I both sit on the public safety committee. Bill C-8 came to us at the public safety committee. I felt it was a deeply flawed bill. There were, I would like to say, probably 30 amendments that we went through at committee. I believe the committee process is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02cdba6e98010658af89c96bd3f2e2e5a36440b9b430017672c218882e7e49e1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1384f1d5574c87fa1b88c7a4ea060d823c17af0e87b9fd37152385a69c169101"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86bd18ff92e21f85bf284fd9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118258,"date":"2026-04-14T21:35:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses, Monsieur Lebeau and Mr. MacKinnon. Obviously, I've had a lot of dealings with UCCO, and I want to welcome both of you to your new positions. We haven't had a chance to meet formally in committee. Mr. MacKinnon, I'm going to direct some questions toward you. Monsieur Lebeau, feel free to weigh in. Drones are a huge issue and directly impact officer safety. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118258","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses, Monsieur Lebeau and Mr. MacKinnon. Obviously, I've had a lot of dealings with UCCO, and I want to welcome both of you to your new positions. We haven't had a chance to meet formally in committee. Mr. MacKinnon, I'm going to direct some questions toward you. Monsieur Lebeau, feel free to weigh in. Drones are a huge issue and directly impac","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-862f8a63133b1347d06dedeb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118259,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"In fact, they drop contraband, they drop drugs and they drop ceramic blades and things like that, which can be used to stab officers. Is that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118259","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In fact, they drop contraband, they drop drugs and they drop ceramic blades and things like that, which can be used to stab officers. Is that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e11cc6032085c5b361110d380519afe18a2099c64f6de492e26d30d613935371"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["25b632d8e8bff0db98557875110c38f79f3fc15f7d833a0df893e7f818f3c542"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad07753a20e371d7e9ef6e80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118260,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"In fact, it's such a problem and drugs in jail are such a problem that we've seen a number of impacts. Are you familiar with the Fraser Valley Institution, Mr. MacKinnon?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118260","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In fact, it's such a problem and drugs in jail are such a problem that we've seen a number of impacts. Are you familiar with the Fraser Valley Institution, Mr. MacKinnon?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46e9ea2163a416ce3610d84ccf63f67db1b68ae626655d08387a1d8dc5b2e071"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52491ae14c468fd6f22167ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118261,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"Can you comment on the program—I'm not sure if you're aware of the program—in which dogs are brought to the Fraser Valley Institution and inmates tend to them and do things like that? Are you aware of such a program?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118261","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can you comment on the program—I'm not sure if you're aware of the program—in which dogs are brought to the Fraser Valley Institution and inmates tend to them and do things like that? Are you aware of such a program?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102588","label":"Domestic animals","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ef1c589089b5c2f6db4af445d35d8926d53fbe2cb3309abf5abfc662de35534"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-983e24e597002d3df5dda504","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118262,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. Were you aware that a dog actually overdosed on narcotics, as I was told? Is that accurate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118262","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Were you aware that a dog actually overdosed on narcotics, as I was told? Is that accurate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["edbb18a92cb71255e4029bdb4d217782f9d560b18b7d47ded43e8c6c5db2d402"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc5d58989056289bcee594d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118263,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. That's just what I was told. What percentage of job cuts are management versus the front line for CSC?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118263","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. That's just what I was told. What percentage of job cuts are management versus the front line for CSC?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036005","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job promotion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036005","label":"Job promotion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1db9323c627cf21a56623b7354e41c999ed66deb1272e2edff71f2875b596bac"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1987b9bef5aa7f0917b4589","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118264,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"How many jobs are being eliminated from regional headquarters? Do you have any idea?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118264","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How many jobs are being eliminated from regional headquarters? Do you have any idea?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6086d31a7298a05466a8563780c2c2c1d48f5abb05acce1f2abd36124724cd29"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f5ac2aa57d37cf1e015082f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118265,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"As in, we haven't been told or zero...or both?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118265","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As in, we haven't been told or zero...or both?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75de29529602f89101a16d1c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118266,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. I'll assume zero if you haven't been told. How about the national headquarters? How many jobs were set to be cut from NHQ?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118266","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. I'll assume zero if you haven't been told. How about the national headquarters? How many jobs were set to be cut from NHQ?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6b2a18f11357606a97e5cc90b4b60d108b95def63988e86f2c8c1deffbb4a20d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50d915e74a8f71557b70cba5fb68eb76d692354700c22560aa0c6e8f12588227"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a7e27f820381c43d5f51d2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118267,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"Well, I think they didn't inform because it's zero. Would it be fair to say that Correctional Service Canada is a bureaucracy at the national headquarters and the regional headquarters levels?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118267","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Well, I think they didn't inform because it's zero. Would it be fair to say that Correctional Service Canada is a bureaucracy at the national headquarters and the regional headquarters levels?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4df74ca6a4bc657aa77884558729a4200106820cdacac74bdfc7f10e9706e18c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-506807c9ce0318200c28d5f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118268,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"Okay. In terms of the safety and security of officers, I've been to a number of institutions. I worked for federal corrections. This is a vulnerability in part because of small things, like the unwillingness of the CSC to supply razor blades that disintegrate. I think you probably know what I'm talking about. There are razor blades out there that if you go to use them as a weapon, they will disintegrate. CSC doesn't supply those. I know that officer safety is a big issue, and now, when it comes to drones and detection technology, CSC is cutting those types of things to intercept contraband. Will that ultimately make officers more safe or less safe?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118268","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. In terms of the safety and security of officers, I've been to a number of institutions. I worked for federal corrections. This is a vulnerability in part because of small things, like the unwillingness of the CSC to supply razor blades that disintegrate. I think you probably know what I'm talking about. There are razor blades out there that if you go to use them as a weapon, they will disint","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad38294eefb37149f96b8e08ef42242821bd06fd2bdffb0e7142d41d061b9f86"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f09d3a16da40c02f23dda642","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118269,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"I'm going to just speak. Normally, I would like to ask questions, but I have one minute left. I will say this. Being a correctional officer is one of the most difficult occupations. It's one of the bravest occupations. The fact that you have to go to jail and worry about being stabbed by contraband that could be detected by drone and is not—you have to live through that—and that you are putting your lives on the line for a salary that is substantially lower than other peace officers', to me, is repugnant. The fact is that the government is cutting those things that would help protect you, and it is not cutting an ounce of bureaucracy. The government should be ashamed. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118269","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm going to just speak. Normally, I would like to ask questions, but I have one minute left. I will say this. Being a correctional officer is one of the most difficult occupations. It's one of the bravest occupations. The fact that you have to go to jail and worry about being stabbed by contraband that could be detected by drone and is not—you have to live through that—and that you are putting yo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f309479a0925dc6a5326bbeb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118270,"date":"2026-04-14T21:45:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"I just ended so well. Do you have anything to say to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118270","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I just ended so well. Do you have anything to say to that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1afd9b410e1d9716a5f8953f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118271,"date":"2026-04-14T21:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"It used to be that people who assault went to higher security or the SHU, the special handling unit. Is that the case anymore?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118271","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It used to be that people who assault went to higher security or the SHU, the special handling unit. Is that the case anymore?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["347e14c0079f0e8abbf755164ec08cccc93dcc77e162b80433098a137dcd7177"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1cb60db79b7164c5baa5467b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118272,"date":"2026-04-14T21:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"Sometimes, we have a modified segregation unit, the SIU, which an inmate can stay in for only 60 days, but what does the CSC do? It just transfers them to another jail. It does that by charter plane, which costs millions per year. Is that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118272","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Sometimes, we have a modified segregation unit, the SIU, which an inmate can stay in for only 60 days, but what does the CSC do? It just transfers them to another jail. It does that by charter plane, which costs millions per year. Is that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083604","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Civil aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083604","label":"Civil aviation","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c7f22d265722276ec72152bd3504b4bb859061a68957cc1f274bd12bfb89877"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae60dae94cc93c6298b18daf806ce240efb2542f9847d1bf091ebdef6d99854a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a1d1a6f530d50dedb6eb9b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118273,"date":"2026-04-14T21:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"The CSC is literally transferring inmates from jail to jail, because an inmate can stay in the SIU for only up to 60 days. Rather than reintegrate them by law, it will literally just put them in a new jail and say, \"Look. We took them out of the SIU.\" They go from province to province and region to region on charter aircraft. Is that accurate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118273","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The CSC is literally transferring inmates from jail to jail, because an inmate can stay in the SIU for only up to 60 days. Rather than reintegrate them by law, it will literally just put them in a new jail and say, \"Look. We took them out of the SIU.\" They go from province to province and region to region on charter aircraft. Is that accurate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a87639d2dae157314fd20e70c9cd98add28d535caed4a6171431eadb483e890d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c07b1182a44a163492ea027bafec4b32ea283fc27348712c6ec482b0ea91bfc3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d750fb025d90605c740df26b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118274,"date":"2026-04-14T21:50:00+00:00","title":"OGGO","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"OGGO","text":"What a colossal waste of money to transfer inmates by charter aircraft from jail to jail just to comply with unworkable regulations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/OGGO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118274","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What a colossal waste of money to transfer inmates by charter aircraft from jail to jail just to comply with unworkable regulations.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","label":"Aircraft"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","label":"Aircraft","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["85a113457720d70ad1895a05d5b42fcce6bd625095ffb7dbf5419d73b22ebefe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["202b362843ab6f2622d230e286576703011d207d7c4fc70ec1915406feb722be"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17c450b4b0688577ae561f93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501150,"date":"2026-04-15T21:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nThere are a lot of issues in this bill that I look forward to addressing at committee. One of the questions I have is about the role of ministerial orders. I am mindful of the fact that ministerial orders require approval from the intelligence commissioner, but then they then go into what I call a \"vacuum\" because they are kept confidential. I understand why they may need to be confidential.\n\nWould the minister be open to discussing amendments that would require or enable some sort of transparency, whether it be that it is reviewed by a committee or somebody else, so it is not put into this vacuum that lacks transparency when these orders are made in confidence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501150","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nThere are a lot of issues in this bill that I look forward to addressing at committee. One of the questions I have is about the role of ministerial orders. I am mindful of the fact that ministerial orders require approval from the intelligence commissioner, but then they then go into what I call a \"v","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1a1b5efb04173d321a86f145a0d4e8d11081f13fd61277307320266326c9582e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab575ae3022e868fbbc3314c1770921965017e75e599b5cd2964a33cd8812cdd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e8db360554ab140f46190bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501151,"date":"2026-04-15T21:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nOne question I really hope the Secretary of State for Combatting Crime can answer right here and right now is a very clear question that relates to encrypted communications: Would this bill be going after encrypted communications, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501151","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nOne question I really hope the Secretary of State for Combatting Crime can answer right here and right now is a very clear question that relates to encrypted communications: Would this bill be going after encrypted communications, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-23745d6ff62bf84add76a123","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501153,"date":"2026-04-15T22:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. When it comes to getting it right, there is no doubt that we need to address loopholes when it comes to access and when it comes to ensuring that information is available. The question is, how do we get it right? I am approaching this debate with that lens. We have ministerial orders that will not necessarily be transparent under this legislation. They will be in secret.\n\nDoes my hon. colleague have a position on that, namely whether they should all be in secret, or whether some should be in secret in order to protect vulnerabilities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501153","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. When it comes to getting it right, there is no doubt that we need to address loopholes when it comes to access and when it comes to ensuring that information is available. The question is, how do we get it right? I am approaching this debate with that lens. We have ministerial orders that will not n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01589a6e115b25e1919097f0b565d2b0d7f79ebd854627bf571a95f3d0fbc208"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4aa94c58aca788167eeb75cdf9ec18d228e0d53ba3051330e384f740063e3e0e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f1fd104c0ba905f8899be67","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501142,"date":"2026-04-17T15:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nOne of the things my colleague mentioned was Bill C-2. Let us not be naive. We know that the Liberals achieved their majority through a number of deals in the background. What concerns me as a member of Parliament and as a citizen is the fact that we would have been saddled with Bill C-2, a bill that we as Conservatives successfully fought against, and rightly so. There is a time to oppose in this place and a time to support. That was clearly the time to oppose.\n\n I would like the member's opinion on why Bill C-2 failed and whether the Liberals appear to have learned any lessons from that, because we may be in a position where they just force these things through in the future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501142","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nOne of the things my colleague mentioned was Bill C-2. Let us not be naive. We know that the Liberals achieved their majority through a number of deals in the background. What concerns me as a member of Parliament and as a citizen is the fact that we would have been saddled with Bill C-2, a bill t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c4020a16f292527a86f369c5228cfcc839fcdc7403987fe41c1073b5efa66a2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab5eee7f26455debc759f0ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501143,"date":"2026-04-17T15:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thomson—Nicola, apparently back-to-back today.\n\nOne of the things I appreciated about my hon. colleague's speech was the balanced nature of it. I would like to ask him to comment on his role as a legislator here and as somebody who does not blindly accept things. He talked about how we have to recognize things at committee, see things at committee and question things at committee. I am proud to be part of a party that does that. I would ask for his comments on that as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501143","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thomson—Nicola, apparently back-to-back today.\n\nOne of the things I appreciated about my hon. colleague's speech was the balanced nature of it. I would like to ask him to comment on his role as a legislator here and as somebody who does not blindly accept things. He talked about how we have to recognize things at co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3263a1923a8188dbeb470945","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501144,"date":"2026-04-17T15:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nMy colleague has been involved in the justice portfolio, which is really the opposite side of the coin to the public safety portfolio. There is obviously a difference. There is one thing I really would like her to comment on because she has ardently expressed support for this piece of legislation.\n\n I am sure my colleague spoke to Bill C-2 as well, so my question is this: Did she speak on Bill C-2, and is she prepared now to acknowledge the colossal failure it was, which is why we are now here with Bill C-22 in a much more reasonable form?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501144","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nMy colleague has been involved in the justice portfolio, which is really the opposite side of the coin to the public safety portfolio. There is obviously a difference. There is one thing I really would like her to comment on because she has ardently expressed support for this piece of legislation.\n\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8728b36eb3e6429afbaa22e246ad9d1f74e04f18e1c124bd5cd1ac9acfe00ea5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d335e82fef27feaf71e20d8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501146,"date":"2026-04-17T17:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Indeed, it is a pleasure to rise both in my capacity as a parliamentarian for that area and as the shadow minister, or critic, for public safety.\n\nMy colleague hit on a number of issues that are confronting Parliament in the form of Bill C-22. We have seen a number of pieces of legislation come through that are related to Bill C-22. Bill C-2 came, then we had Bill C-12, and now there is Bill C-22.\n\nDoes my colleague agree that the fact that the government has put forward Bill C-22 is a tacit acknowledgement of the failure of Bill C-2, which we were told would be a cure-all for all things ailing Canadian law?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501146","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Indeed, it is a pleasure to rise both in my capacity as a parliamentarian for that area and as the shadow minister, or critic, for public safety.\n\nMy colleague hit on a number of issues that are confronting Parliament in the form of Bill C-22. We have seen a number of pieces of legislation come thro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4a813fa91e69bceab94c4d145203f34522e78187fca3eda63d7f3225880bd22"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6db96b0caff586d423340f91fb6d5d5441e55c52873736da26edaace5baf8ba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a869c8aff4eab6ab605bffd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501147,"date":"2026-04-17T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nI feel there is a refrain being heard frequently in the House today, the welcoming of another member from the government to their seat. That is wonderful.\n\n It is always great to speak in the House. I wish we would have more questions from members of the government. For those watching at home, normally the government would have some questions for my hon. colleague on his speech. It is almost like we are shouting into the Grand Canyon. Hello, hello, hello. Is there anybody there, there, there?\n\nWhy is it that we, as Conservatives, are carrying this debate?\n\nHon. Greg Fergus: Hello, hello, hello.\n\nFrank Caputo: Oh, I hear the hon. member for Hull—Aylmer saying hello back, back, back.\n\n How seriously can we take the government when its members are not even getting up to ask questions on a bill this important?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501147","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nI feel there is a refrain being heard frequently in the House today, the welcoming of another member from the government to their seat. That is wonderful.\n\n It is always great to speak in the House. I wish we would have more questions from members of the government. For those watching at home, norma","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2269ac2827b3a09320d789bd463d143d5ac06defdc8955b1a014b993e8b0732"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b677cc091e677e4c1cc2cce4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501149,"date":"2026-04-17T17:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I just received a message about my earlier Grand Canyon overture, wherein I said, \"Hello, hello, hello. Is there anybody there, there, there?\" That was because, yet again, the Liberals are not asking any questions on a bill that is of critical importance.\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\n Frank Caputo: Mr. Speaker, one of my Liberal friends said I should get credit for special effects. I believe that was what he said from across the way.\n\nI share some of the concerns of my hon. colleague, the member for Saanich—Gulf Islands, about the bill. It is certainly better than Bill C-2, which was a far overreach. I wonder if she would be prepared to comment on how much of a failure Bill C-2 was and how the bill before us is better but still requires amendments, and if she would be prepared to share where those amendments would come from.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501149","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I just received a message about my earlier Grand Canyon overture, wherein I said, \"Hello, hello, hello. Is there anybody there, there, there?\" That was because, yet again, the Liberals are not asking any questions on a bill that is of critical importance.\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\n Frank Caputo: Mr. Speaker, one of my Liberal friends said I should get credit for special effects. I bel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["de9038b8c3874a6306f9bca1fafe775cbd9e8204fc21b5272825537c9e19dbef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bb5bfa245c7e34b43f9ab83d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300966,"date":"2026-04-22T19:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today I am launching a campaign that gives me great pride, and that is to bring back one of the most iconic landmarks in Kamloops, our Red Bridge. The Red Bridge was built in 1936, based on the Howe truss design. It was one of the few remaining functioning bridges of its type in British Columbia. Unfortunately, it was destroyed by arson in 2024, destroying a vital link between downtown Kamloops and the Tk̓emlúps te Secwépemc territory. The loss of this crossing continues to impact commuters, industry and emergency access.\n\nI would like to encourage all people in Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola to sign petitions, write letters and make phone calls to encourage the federal government to support the fast-tracking and rebuilding of the Red Bridge. I am calling on all parties, including Kamloops, Tk̓emlúps te Secwépemc and the province, with the federal government's support, to get the Red Bridge rebuilt.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300966","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today I am launching a campaign that gives me great pride, and that is to bring back one of the most iconic landmarks in Kamloops, our Red Bridge. The Red Bridge was built in 1936, based on the Howe truss design. It was one of the few remaining functioning bridges of its type in British Columbia. Unfortunately, it was destroyed by arson in 2024, destroying a vital link between downtow","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","label":"Transportation safety","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a45305d4ae99c38b604b89d66cea18c6a0080f20ad8725780eca2df5afd47c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d90776689a5c4499af61f4d06af29a6b71e35c1edcaceab2de4ac8dfc9a20e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5010ed5440d3c842557054f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300967,"date":"2026-04-22T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in Canada, those serving two years or more are typically released at two-thirds of their sentence.\n\nAs a former parole officer, I am aware that Corrections Canada can apply to have people detained for the last third of their sentence. It does not look like Corrections Canada did this, and as a result, an ISIS terrorist, who was a recruiter for ISIS, was released into the community.\n\nBefore the public safety minister starts talking about independence for Corrections Canada, he should answer this: Did the Liberal government do everything it could to keep a dangerous ISIS terrorist behind bars for as long as possible, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300967","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in Canada, those serving two years or more are typically released at two-thirds of their sentence.\n\nAs a former parole officer, I am aware that Corrections Canada can apply to have people detained for the last third of their sentence. It does not look like Corrections Canada did this, and as a result, an ISIS terrorist, who was a recruiter for ISIS, was released into the community.\n\nB","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d5bf56cee385fb84bfc93fdc6df5949cf4612dabbd823be42055fd8f037d5278"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3e05f6a8e71d105bc7dfd8f48fc8f2e73209255908bca8a8626b7c93af6fabc6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d74189d4a859775ee6e6ae70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118275,"date":"2026-04-23T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Welcome to all the witnesses. Thank you very much for being here. I found all of your comments interesting. I want to focus on and begin with Dr. Dubord. Dr. Dubord, I found your comments particularly interesting, because I was thinking about the role of organized crime in our ports before you started speaking. I've spent most of my adult life in the justice system, and I think this is widely known among law enforcement circles but is not widely discussed. You talked about members of outlaw motorcycle gangs wearing patches on one day and then working in our ports of entry. Can you elaborate on that, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118275","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Welcome to all the witnesses. Thank you very much for being here. I found all of your comments interesting. I want to focus on and begin with Dr. Dubord. Dr. Dubord, I found your comments particularly interesting, because I was thinking about the role of organized crime in our ports before you started speaking. I've spent most of my adult life in the justice system, and I thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ec6d7c5e9b89b1e98de90318e66888c7ff3ad9ca8a232e5423e6b8288ef14ee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f38a4dc374ff86e2bb600175","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118276,"date":"2026-04-23T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"What I find most interesting about this is that it's not as though it's a secret. You're the chief of Delta. I used to work in British Columbia, so I'm very familiar with that jurisdiction. This is all very well known. It might not be well reported or publicly discussed, but it's something that I think most people in all facets of the port system or the justice system know about. I think I know the answer to this, but is there any requirement to have a security clearance? For instance, if you work in a lot of roles, a clearance is required. You couldn't be a correctional officer, for instance, or work for CBSA if you had ties to the outlaw gangs that you were just describing. I'm mindful that they're government. This isn't government, but access is the key. We often mandate requirements for people who have access to infrastructure, wherein criminality can flourish literally right under our noses. Do you know of any requirements for people, despite having such access, not to be involved in overt criminal behaviour?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118276","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What I find most interesting about this is that it's not as though it's a secret. You're the chief of Delta. I used to work in British Columbia, so I'm very familiar with that jurisdiction. This is all very well known. It might not be well reported or publicly discussed, but it's something that I think most people in all facets of the port system or the justice system know about. I think I know th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["786c855a246362463957bad24dc2855d130faf002a07f728b057439d3d13b84c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7ec0bc276cd0775ae4d95ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118277,"date":"2026-04-23T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I don't mean to pontificate. It's just that if we know people are engaged in crime and we're allowing them into a place where crime flourishes, what do we expect? All of you can weigh in on that. I know it's a rhetorical question, but I would imagine that this is quite frustrating to law enforcement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118277","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I don't mean to pontificate. It's just that if we know people are engaged in crime and we're allowing them into a place where crime flourishes, what do we expect? All of you can weigh in on that. I know it's a rhetorical question, but I would imagine that this is quite frustrating to law enforcement.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ffcea53aeda4214b370128be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118278,"date":"2026-04-23T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes, I would agree wholeheartedly. I know my time is just about up. We have bills that come through here. To me, this is a very non-partisan issue. I'm not sure if it can be tackled by way of a private member's bill. I have one that's being debated on Monday already. I apologize. I encourage my government colleagues and everybody here to listen very well to this. One per cent of containers are being checked at the ports. I was at Deltaport, and it was a mechanism of, \"Well, we do risk-based intervention.\" That is the way I would put it. Anybody with any idea of how things work knows exactly what the risk factors are. If you hang out there for three months, you will know those risk factors. It's not working. I think we need more random searches. I don't know if we have time, but any of you can comment on that, please. Does no one think we have random searches?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118278","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, I would agree wholeheartedly. I know my time is just about up. We have bills that come through here. To me, this is a very non-partisan issue. I'm not sure if it can be tackled by way of a private member's bill. I have one that's being debated on Monday already. I apologize. I encourage my government colleagues and everybody here to listen very well to this. One per cent of containers are bei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05c5130ebe0a5ea72178dbc09a73cae4d2cfacfd241f2905603c731d796da7a3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1051397f38a309c5fb763aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726932,"date":"2026-04-27T16:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Today I am especially honoured to rise in reply to Bill C-225, the private member's bill that I put forward on intimate partner violence. \n\nIt feels as though it was just yesterday, but it was around November when I was speaking about this bill and attempting to persuade this House to pass the bill. It is against that backdrop that I just had a brief conversation with one of my hon. colleagues, the Parliamentary Secretary to the government House leader, and learned the Liberals are going to support and vote for this bill. This is tremendous. This is how things are supposed to work. \n\nI want to thank some people. The member for Niagara Falls—Niagara-on-the-Lake had a profound impact on this bill. He gave up his private member's slot so this bill could move forward. I am profoundly grateful to him, and I think all victims of intimate partner violence and stakeholders are equally grateful. I am similarly grateful to the member for Cloverdale—Langley City, who gave up her spot in the private member's bill rotation. As a result, this bill got to a vote on third reading in what I think is probably record time. It is not very often we see private members' bills get to a vote within five or six months, and here we are at third reading. I am profoundly indebted to both members. I also want to recognize their service to Canadians and their recognition of victims of intimate partner violence. They are part of the solution by advancing this legislation. \n\nI want to thank all who spoke on this bill, particularly, at third reading. I want to thank Bailey's family, Paige, Karen, Shane, Trish, Debbie, Bailey's children and all others who I may not have mentioned who are part of Bailey's family, her loved ones and those who continue to mourn her death. \n\nI want to thank my staff, Rofiat Agboola, Stephanie Rennick, Jesus Bondo, Clare Cyr, Tracy Gilchrist and Christine Savage, for putting up with and navigating through all the ups and downs of this process. There have been a few speed bumps, but, ultimately, we got here. My belief is that we will see unanimous support for this bill when we vote on Wednesday. \n\nI am mindful of the fact that the Minister of Justice's office played a key role in meeting with victims. I mentioned my staff, who went above and beyond and liaised with Zoe Romeo and other members of the minister's staff. There were extensive amendments at committee, and I want to recognize the collaborative nature of the status of women committee and all witnesses who appeared, too many to name in this short speech, but they know who they are. \n\nI also want to thank all those who emailed me and wrote letters saying they suffered in silence from intimate partner violence and those who stopped me on the street, which happens to members of Parliament more than those watching at home might think, and thanked me. A few stand out in my mind. This bill is for them. \n\nWith the assurance that the Liberals will be voting for this at third reading, with my belief that all other members will be supporting this bill and against the backdrop of just having welcomed new members who will get to add their signature to this bill, I am incredibly honoured and profoundly grateful to stand as the sponsor of a bill that recognizes the scourge of intimate partner violence, but, more concretely, addresses the issue here where it should be addressed in Parliament.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726932","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Today I am especially honoured to rise in reply to Bill C-225, the private member's bill that I put forward on intimate partner violence. \n\nIt feels as though it was just yesterday, but it was around November when I was speaking about this bill and attempting to persuade this House to pass the bill. I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d22199b93f7c3aa9c8377a1c24c1f6c88e1a934ec224a53a3730b15e5cd4f782"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ddc2e15db14ab4e81fc8b24c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118279,"date":"2026-04-30T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Ministers, for being here. Minister Diab, how did an IRGC terrorist get a visa to come to Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118279","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Ministers, for being here. Minister Diab, how did an IRGC terrorist get a visa to come to Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91b8bca3a42b6e0bad92a840089589102ebae7e2ec29869604817717a30a756d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc90841a5570bfdcd794087d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118280,"date":"2026-04-30T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister, I don't want talking points. Minister Anandasangaree, do you agree with that, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118280","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Minister, I don't want talking points. Minister Anandasangaree, do you agree with that, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f5f19ca39ebc837b8c7e790","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118281,"date":"2026-04-30T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That's not what I asked. I asked how an IRGC member got a visa. You say that privacy prevents you from telling us about the case. I have a copy of the Privacy Act here. Could you please tell me what section of the Privacy Act shields terrorists from your answering questions about how they got a visa? Minister Diab, which section is it, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118281","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's not what I asked. I asked how an IRGC member got a visa. You say that privacy prevents you from telling us about the case. I have a copy of the Privacy Act here. Could you please tell me what section of the Privacy Act shields terrorists from your answering questions about how they got a visa? Minister Diab, which section is it, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0d9bc6a59cca31c5bd093cec0dd11d08995a6223a9bbb5a2f60d2a0e01349ad9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a288f6ad2ad0f3290b6c6022a67e4cf0b898079297e944d1534ce394d4565133"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62cea1a5601dd1eb7dfa76fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118282,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister, let me be clear. Which section is it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118282","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Minister, let me be clear. Which section is it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-793d5fda55da9520c4bef3f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118283,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You are the minister in charge. Three questions were asked of you in question period. Not once did the Liberal government allow you to get up and answer those questions. I'll ask Minister Anandasangaree. Let me be clear. What section of the Privacy Act shields an Iranian terrorist? What section precludes you, Minister, from answering questions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118283","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You are the minister in charge. Three questions were asked of you in question period. Not once did the Liberal government allow you to get up and answer those questions. I'll ask Minister Anandasangaree. Let me be clear. What section of the Privacy Act shields an Iranian terrorist? What section precludes you, Minister, from answering questions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5cd32bc95b7b725a2c160c7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118284,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister, when was the last time a terrorist got a visa to Canada? I don't know when. Minister Diab, when did this matter first come to your attention?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118284","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Minister, when was the last time a terrorist got a visa to Canada? I don't know when. Minister Diab, when did this matter first come to your attention?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["443d2aaf98c6c20c4e6abf8e20798e5a35305769bdf46f1d1ae1265888bfc9de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fef3f153ac23fa1c4575ef75bfe7fecc40cb48d40c73c53095ba1c7444611da8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d926aa71ac52f915d415130e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118285,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You don't know when this matter came to your attention.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118285","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You don't know when this matter came to your attention.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-696e36c1d204c13ee2365e34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118286,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You did, after Conservatives asked you to do so, but I'm not asking about the designation. We called on your government to do it for years, so let's not pretend you have the moral high ground here, Minister.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118286","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You did, after Conservatives asked you to do so, but I'm not asking about the designation. We called on your government to do it for years, so let's not pretend you have the moral high ground here, Minister.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d628cd79d2241ed93ca652d6bb3f84aedace0a7bcea95a6ddd8eb128c6bc071"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e424f41edbbca8f3bff62c8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118287,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister, if you want a timeline about when planes were shot down and what have you, we can get into that, but that's for another day. Did you sign for or know about this visa, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118287","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Minister, if you want a timeline about when planes were shot down and what have you, we can get into that, but that's for another day. Did you sign for or know about this visa, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719051","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719051","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airplanes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","label":"Airplanes","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719051","label":"Aircraft accidents","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d490627096201b05ab52bf9057326d0e066b1d8f4467899969db00346c79753"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["726131e825770d1475687353086252167f22d7d10ae874d887acd28295ab41ff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3316665514d8ca4b77cdaa6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118288,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Did you know about the visa, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118288","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Did you know about the visa, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff67f8f2a5b1ca16b750e6af9e0a3af88599447485f9b02d22902658c41acf0f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db2156be0c9c54b5cad086ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118289,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I didn't ask whether somebody was admitted.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118289","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I didn't ask whether somebody was admitted.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50326dd6dc334287b1ce2b9d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118290,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Actually—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118290","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Actually—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b8113acbd6c835ad389facb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118291,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes, I took an oath, just as other lawyers have, Minister. One of those oaths was to the rule of law, in my view, and the rule of law demands transparency. There are Canadians here who have suffered under the IRGC. If you will not tell us exactly what you know, will you table your briefing notes for today, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118291","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, I took an oath, just as other lawyers have, Minister. One of those oaths was to the rule of law, in my view, and the rule of law demands transparency. There are Canadians here who have suffered under the IRGC. If you will not tell us exactly what you know, will you table your briefing notes for today, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9cd12fdd365afcc0347fc2d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118292,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I get that, Minister. Here's the problem: It can be a priority, but there can still be a colossal mess-up. I asked how it happened. Did you see something in the Privacy Act? No. The Privacy Act, I guess, doesn't apply there. I've asked repeatedly where in the Privacy Act that is. It took an independent journalist—a whistle-blower—to bring this about to both of you, Ministers. Here's the problem. The TRP visa is there to overcome inadmissibility. He was not admissible. Somebody gave him the visa. Who gave him the visa? Just give us a name.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118292","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I get that, Minister. Here's the problem: It can be a priority, but there can still be a colossal mess-up. I asked how it happened. Did you see something in the Privacy Act? No. The Privacy Act, I guess, doesn't apply there. I've asked repeatedly where in the Privacy Act that is. It took an independent journalist—a whistle-blower—to bring this about to both of you, Ministers. Here's the problem. T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0eacb731ab4ffbf10c5cfedc1823e6d63e6c779ed9f722e373c7e0868dc79654"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-616d3167915771473ce3d9a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118293,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I thought you couldn't comment for privacy reasons. \"Oh, we can comment on that for privacy reasons, but on other things, we can't.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118293","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thought you couldn't comment for privacy reasons. \"Oh, we can comment on that for privacy reasons, but on other things, we can't.\"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66e5b23440994a12da5e9b0219b6aa4447812d3bb9ad983b51561f8f2284eca0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f69ed82af85bae2c6448ec10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118294,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"How many—what number—have you expelled? How many have you expelled? You're the minister. You should know this. Is it one or two? How many from the IRGC have you expelled in the last year? Is it one or two?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118294","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How many—what number—have you expelled? How many have you expelled? You're the minister. You should know this. Is it one or two? How many from the IRGC have you expelled in the last year? Is it one or two?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bece93a6d5f07eb1cac4a27849eaf6e43f37a69a4e8016ac96cfa338101daebc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1855452d4d74d240f14c9e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118295,"date":"2026-04-30T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister Anandasangaree, how many have been expelled—one or two?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118295","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Minister Anandasangaree, how many have been expelled—one or two?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["778f3cda388a5d76bfb834b9c2c2443d68f26d566e9b8fb837fb274ce1ad58aa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed8301a5bec1f7633ecfd20d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118296,"date":"2026-04-30T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister, we have five seconds left. How many have you expelled?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118296","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Minister, we have five seconds left. How many have you expelled?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65c0277838434b2e11ef308a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118297,"date":"2026-04-30T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I asked for expulsions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118297","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I asked for expulsions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c479d9a28765d26abf54db2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118298,"date":"2026-04-30T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"How many expulsions, Minister? How many expulsions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118298","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How many expulsions, Minister? How many expulsions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f7fb3c81c278f750f54359e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118299,"date":"2026-05-05T20:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Chair. Thank you to all of our witnesses. It's so great to have so many people here around the table for such a complex issue. We're going to get to know each other very well in the coming two parliamentary weeks. I never know who to direct my questions to, because there is a lot of expertise here. Whoever is best to answer this, please let me know. I've looked at the definitions. I've looked at the definitions of \"systemic vulnerability\", at how it incorporates the definition of encrypted data to some degree, and at the provision, in part 2, that says a service provider does not have to do anything that would create a systemic vulnerability. I'm going to ask a very direct question. Will this bill cover encrypted data? Secondly, is it intended to be that way? I assume that would be yes. Will this bill cover encrypted data? Could somebody please help me with that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118299","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Chair. Thank you to all of our witnesses. It's so great to have so many people here around the table for such a complex issue. We're going to get to know each other very well in the coming two parliamentary weeks. I never know who to direct my questions to, because there is a lot of expertise here. Whoever is best to answer this, please let me know. I've looked at the definiti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8738aad5ccc34d8473643cdc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118300,"date":"2026-05-05T20:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay, but with all due respect, Ms. Hiegel, you say \"where keys are available\". This bill, as I read it, would require a key to be available, would it not?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118300","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay, but with all due respect, Ms. Hiegel, you say \"where keys are available\". This bill, as I read it, would require a key to be available, would it not?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0bad3595605930c1b2cc2797381ae06c054ce57fcda681178ea2b8cc4f813e5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2aa4d24b28c33480ec7f1d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118301,"date":"2026-05-05T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Perhaps we're on different planes here, because my understanding of part 2, in reading it, particularly in proposed section 5, is that it talks about a base level that providers need to come up to. Am I making sense so far?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118301","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Perhaps we're on different planes here, because my understanding of part 2, in reading it, particularly in proposed section 5, is that it talks about a base level that providers need to come up to. Am I making sense so far?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airplanes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","label":"Airplanes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd85cac1ebc1f30d8ff985eda8b9638127a6a07c07a5222b5a1ec5d9dcc781ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30033431785b74b729234a54","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118302,"date":"2026-05-05T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"If providers need to come up to that base level and they're not there yet, how do they not then have to create a key to come up to the base level that proposed section 5 says they have to come up to? Does that make sense?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118302","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If providers need to come up to that base level and they're not there yet, how do they not then have to create a key to come up to the base level that proposed section 5 says they have to come up to? Does that make sense?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d3ced7bc061c266468e05f3fd7224bae037fd9192756c52bd55874d18fafa1f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87bd730ffc337796c9ecf07e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118303,"date":"2026-05-05T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"No, I meant where there is a service of encryption provided. My question was, will that provider of encryption...? Company A provides an end-to-end encryption service in messages. Will this bill require company A to create some sort of mechanism by which that data can be intercepted and by which the government or the state—when I say \"state\", I think you know what I mean, law enforcement—can access that encrypted data? Is that clear?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118303","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"No, I meant where there is a service of encryption provided. My question was, will that provider of encryption...? Company A provides an end-to-end encryption service in messages. Will this bill require company A to create some sort of mechanism by which that data can be intercepted and by which the government or the state—when I say \"state\", I think you know what I mean, law enforcement—can acces","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5809a8bd58cb7d2de85f7214a308267006126bc8710a43f0fdf07bce166013ef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a4d79091db21b79d6a5c05b51168eeb04323b2de33e53febef366c74d6e416e1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ed2f73cd223943e6f0e6c2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118304,"date":"2026-05-05T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. That's unclear at this point. When I read the bill, I thought, \"Okay, that's it\", but we've also seen correspondence here. If the target of this bill is not encrypted data, my suggestion is that we say flat out, \"For greater clarity, this part does not apply to encrypted data\", and then have a definition. Does it make sense to do something like that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118304","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. That's unclear at this point. When I read the bill, I thought, \"Okay, that's it\", but we've also seen correspondence here. If the target of this bill is not encrypted data, my suggestion is that we say flat out, \"For greater clarity, this part does not apply to encrypted data\", and then have a definition. Does it make sense to do something like that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcf933d2bc08db374f0cef8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118305,"date":"2026-05-05T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"What I'm talking about is a company whose \"secret sauce\", if you'll forgive my vernacular, is providing an encryption service. That is what it does. Company A provides a service that says terminal one to terminal two or contact one to contact two will be encrypted. That is its business model. What I'm asking is this: Will Bill C-22 require it to be able to plug into that encryption and decrypt it for law enforcement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118305","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What I'm talking about is a company whose \"secret sauce\", if you'll forgive my vernacular, is providing an encryption service. That is what it does. Company A provides a service that says terminal one to terminal two or contact one to contact two will be encrypted. That is its business model. What I'm asking is this: Will Bill C-22 require it to be able to plug into that encryption and decrypt it ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f730cb7cdbfa4b716c54bfb5f6c75b1a89a0aec9961643aaae6167622e2004cd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["35ffa1ed5cc2347ab7c436bd34a2c46b5b8b2020ab3ecba6085f34246d4f2ec8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e41e7e75f08621ff643dbe2d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118306,"date":"2026-05-05T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That is exactly what I was looking for, but based on my reading of the bill, when I went through the one definition and then into systemic vulnerability, that wasn't clear to me. My exhortation is this: As officials, please turn your minds to this, because I think there should be, one, an encrypted data definition and, two, something that very clearly says what you just said—that a decryption of encrypted data is a systemic vulnerability—or put it right in the definition of systemic vulnerability. I know this is technical. I hope I'm being clear here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118306","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That is exactly what I was looking for, but based on my reading of the bill, when I went through the one definition and then into systemic vulnerability, that wasn't clear to me. My exhortation is this: As officials, please turn your minds to this, because I think there should be, one, an encrypted data definition and, two, something that very clearly says what you just said—that a decryption of e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d2029d524e9f98372773900e5da4c48e2adeec230a5ae6b7ed07980a8acf9a7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7caaf068ebe016f53ece20a66a9250f85e0d069da91dbc8020478b91000c5e0c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ee1caf5ddf903aa54b9e2e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118307,"date":"2026-05-05T21:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much. It's been helpful to have the officials. One thing I will say at the outset is that I feel like we need three hours with you. I don't say this in jest. This is a highly technical bill. We can't rush this. I have a list of about eight things I want to ask you about. I'm looking up case law further to Madame DeBellefeuille's earlier point about the threshold of \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" versus \"reasonable grounds to believe\". I haven't studied reasonable grounds to suspect in years. With regard to reasonable grounds to believe, I'm familiar with the Storrey decision that a person must subjectively believe that what they're doing is reasonable and that it must be objectively reasonable. That probably means nothing to a lot of people, but these are difficult things to comprehend. When we're wrapping our heads around this, I think having you here for only one hour prior to clause-by-clause consideration is inadequate. I think we need you here a whole lot more, to be very candid. I'll leave that with you and with the chair and with my Liberal colleagues, because we have lots of questions, and I know I've just burned a minute here. This is an important question that comes to the requirement for an electronic service provider to retain data for one year. Is that a de facto seizure that runs contrary to section 8? I understand that a search warrant is required, and that would be the search aspect. Normally there's the search and then the seizure. Is the compulsion to retain data a seizure in itself?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118307","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. It's been helpful to have the officials. One thing I will say at the outset is that I feel like we need three hours with you. I don't say this in jest. This is a highly technical bill. We can't rush this. I have a list of about eight things I want to ask you about. I'm looking up case law further to Madame DeBellefeuille's earlier point about the threshold of \"reasonable groun","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["537410b23abe5224662845e30ec84ebbb8d332a1369086c39a91dc0e9dafcc49"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7dd620749c93e5fcfacf10d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118308,"date":"2026-05-05T21:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I understand that. I'll tell you where I'm coming from on this. In this instance, the state or the government is compelling an action, and that action relates to information over which there is a reasonable expectation of privacy. That's why you need a warrant. The moment you say to provider A that they need to keep this, there's a reasonable expectation of privacy over what must be kept. Is everybody with me so far? Okay. Does that not engage section 8? I might be out to lunch here, but I've been asked this question, so it's something I'm looking to explore.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118308","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I understand that. I'll tell you where I'm coming from on this. In this instance, the state or the government is compelling an action, and that action relates to information over which there is a reasonable expectation of privacy. That's why you need a warrant. The moment you say to provider A that they need to keep this, there's a reasonable expectation of privacy over what must be kept. Is every","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["10a4484eece8f0f17bc0b899a16c3839457570cf312890e8360b7aaffd4003af"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f875dacbe05c36a82d3565acddefd85f738f24185b4a721befcf88e3f53a7bd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8787eaaf4fb0c7d47d351085","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118309,"date":"2026-05-05T21:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118309","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f5a2b26dd30b1e424c9953e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118310,"date":"2026-05-05T21:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Let's go along that line here. The one year is kind of the benchmark. Are you saying...? We could talk about this for the next 15 minutes—this is, again, very important—and I have 33 seconds. What you're saying is that one year is the maximum. It's not the minimum. It's not just the drop-dead date. It's only one year. Obviously, any date is arbitrary. Why is it a year? Why is it not nine months or 15 months or two years? Can you offer anything to help out this committee in terms of why a year was picked?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118310","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Let's go along that line here. The one year is kind of the benchmark. Are you saying...? We could talk about this for the next 15 minutes—this is, again, very important—and I have 33 seconds. What you're saying is that one year is the maximum. It's not the minimum. It's not just the drop-dead date. It's only one year. Obviously, any date is arbitrary. Why is it a year? Why is it not nine months or","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a39d9b061d5ddcd2846d2ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118311,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. I want to pick up on the one-year retention period. If I understand it correctly.... The metadata is generally what we're talking about here, or whatever is contemplated in proposed section 5. Let's just say it's data that can be compelled to be kept. My understanding of what was said before is that one year is the maximum, and one year was chosen because it's like an international standard. There's nothing magic about one year. I understand that. Every number is arbitrary. However, not everything will be kept for one year. Am I clear on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118311","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I want to pick up on the one-year retention period. If I understand it correctly.... The metadata is generally what we're talking about here, or whatever is contemplated in proposed section 5. Let's just say it's data that can be compelled to be kept. My understanding of what was said before is that one year is the maximum, and one year was chosen because it's like an international stan","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","label":"Life expectancy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["68d624bc97541c05db78edb6c4bf14b41f07b38e8132f02fbd030574ccb40622"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-942ab644e0580c22d8178e7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118312,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Who decides what type of metadata will be kept for how long? Say, this type of data, an IP address or whatever, only needs to be kept for six months. Who decides that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118312","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Who decides what type of metadata will be kept for how long? Say, this type of data, an IP address or whatever, only needs to be kept for six months. Who decides that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47952","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47952","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47952","label":"Intellectual property","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a05419385e32a564665dc7ab9c5b5c802112dc74530df42a69af9f68bf8f895"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-937423f627e1ca824ade6a9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118313,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"On first blush, I have an issue with that, because you only have to consider costs; you don't have to make your decision based on cost. It is a consideration. The other issue is that one of the principal discussion points surrounding this bill is how much is left to regulation. Essentially, 90% of this bill could operate on regulation with ministerial orders and things like that. Should we not be spelling things out more in the bill when it comes to certainty? If you're a small electronic service provider trying to implement part 2, wouldn't you be shaking right now and thinking, \"Oh my gosh, how much is it going to cost me to comply?\" There is no certainty regarding what they'll have to comply with.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118313","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"On first blush, I have an issue with that, because you only have to consider costs; you don't have to make your decision based on cost. It is a consideration. The other issue is that one of the principal discussion points surrounding this bill is how much is left to regulation. Essentially, 90% of this bill could operate on regulation with ministerial orders and things like that. Should we not be ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4d43b0dc3032e3714644cbf394e7485fea2d7d930ea8dafe0855f0e52e5b2b2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21135863acfa3d301157f4d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118314,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Again, I'll go back to my prior point. That falls to regulation and it falls to somebody else's decision where there is a consideration about the size and the cost. Ultimately, just because it is considered, that doesn't mean the core provider won't have to do what a ministerial order says. Does that make sense?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118314","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Again, I'll go back to my prior point. That falls to regulation and it falls to somebody else's decision where there is a consideration about the size and the cost. Ultimately, just because it is considered, that doesn't mean the core provider won't have to do what a ministerial order says. Does that make sense?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2de1c83bb1e36b52bfa698c8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118315,"date":"2026-05-05T21:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I appreciate that. I know that some things have to be left to regulation. My view is that a bill like this should be as prescriptive as possible, where it can be, because there is so much left to regulation. For instance, every ministerial order, as I see it under proposed section 7 in part 2, has to be approved by the intelligence commissioner. Is that accurate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118315","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate that. I know that some things have to be left to regulation. My view is that a bill like this should be as prescriptive as possible, where it can be, because there is so much left to regulation. For instance, every ministerial order, as I see it under proposed section 7 in part 2, has to be approved by the intelligence commissioner. Is that accurate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c89c45e87d3eca46f4bcf63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118316,"date":"2026-05-05T21:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Why not a Federal Court judge? I get it. They're both presumed independent. I assume the intelligence commissioner is presumed independent; I can't imagine why. Both are government-appointed. Both are presumed to have perfect knowledge, and I think you know what I mean by perfect knowledge. They are both presumed to have all the knowledge. A Federal Court judge, however, is not beholden to the government. They aren't \"hired\". Their term isn't renewed or anything like that. They can sit until they're 75. Why not have a Federal Court judge play the role of gatekeeper, rather than the intelligence commissioner, when there is at least a reasonable perception of connection to government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118316","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Why not a Federal Court judge? I get it. They're both presumed independent. I assume the intelligence commissioner is presumed independent; I can't imagine why. Both are government-appointed. Both are presumed to have perfect knowledge, and I think you know what I mean by perfect knowledge. They are both presumed to have all the knowledge. A Federal Court judge, however, is not beholden to the gov","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b73bc359394e5e909e859eb4b57207e93af4fc535a247c8f5106e40a72606ee5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-771a2c8e89f8f11850199ecc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118317,"date":"2026-05-05T21:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the ministers and officials. I'll note that we have two Kamloopsians at the table today. That's always wonderful. Minister Anandasangaree, you're off the hook today. We won't be asking you about visas and who gave people from the IRGC a visa. We'll stick to Bill C-22 here. I want to go into something you mentioned, Minister. You talked about this being encryption-neutral. One of the greatest concerns I'm hearing about is encryption. Please don't defer to the analysts. I want to hear your perspective on this. This bill could threaten encrypted communications, based on the way it is written or the way some people are reading it. Can you confirm that the purpose of this bill is not to go after end-to-end encryption, as in party A is using a program to deal with party B that is encrypted and there's no way to decrypt it? Can you confirm that this is neither in this bill nor the intent of this bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118317","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the ministers and officials. I'll note that we have two Kamloopsians at the table today. That's always wonderful. Minister Anandasangaree, you're off the hook today. We won't be asking you about visas and who gave people from the IRGC a visa. We'll stick to Bill C-22 here. I want to go into something you mentioned, Minister. You talked about this being encryption","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["488082c6e7633ce478a396b50eae5a7bf38174935986e651ceba1042edbb6ff3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bf06251946ae62eab6d6c388c4fc97d82791eb8011ad06c2b6cc00dc70ab63b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ea7f9be867857bc318292c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118318,"date":"2026-05-05T21:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'll just ensure one step further: that there's no requirement for company A, then, from point one to point two, to create what some would call a back door, a mechanism by which that information can be accessed. Is that accurate as well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118318","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll just ensure one step further: that there's no requirement for company A, then, from point one to point two, to create what some would call a back door, a mechanism by which that information can be accessed. Is that accurate as well?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e0befe7cef003690cff4ecbb14d53952745b8b5583d350b7713f18fd6065b1d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c2424f47d21e0a6a7b83250","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118319,"date":"2026-05-05T21:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"If there's any ambiguity on that, I trust you would support an amendment to close that, because this is a game-changer when it comes to that bill. I take that to be the case.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118319","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If there's any ambiguity on that, I trust you would support an amendment to close that, because this is a game-changer when it comes to that bill. I take that to be the case.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b5d4cdc662f450918787c577e568213ad8db91c1dcdb8d7f1957f9079f728a35"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2631f216f3d544e7a9e36a16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118320,"date":"2026-05-05T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'll be blunt, Minister. The Liberal government now has a majority. There is a concern that, if there is room there, it won't be addressed. That's why I'm asking you, on the record, if there's a chance that encrypted communications can be targeted by this bill. If that's not the intent of the bill—that's what you said—I don't think it's too much to say, \"Yes, Mr. Caputo, I would support an amendment to ensure that our intent is clear.\" For instance, that could be an amendment that includes a definition of encrypted data in part 2 or an amendment that says that \"systemic vulnerability\" includes a key to encrypted data and the creation thereof. With all due respect, Minister, I don't think it's difficult to say, \"Yes, that's our intent.\" Do you not agree?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118320","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll be blunt, Minister. The Liberal government now has a majority. There is a concern that, if there is room there, it won't be addressed. That's why I'm asking you, on the record, if there's a chance that encrypted communications can be targeted by this bill. If that's not the intent of the bill—that's what you said—I don't think it's too much to say, \"Yes, Mr. Caputo, I would support an amendme","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b878c4a8b6bcfaf6c257550","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118321,"date":"2026-05-05T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"The difference with Bill C-8 , though, Minister.... If you want to get into Bill C-8, that is exactly my cautionary tale. The Liberals voted against just about every amendment that was of consequence. It was the Conservatives and the Bloc that voted for those amendments, that swayed those amendments, with the government often voting against them. Now things have changed. With all due respect, Bill C-8 is not a great example to use. That's why I'm trying to get it on the record. I think I've made my point. You've made your point. Let's move on. The ministerial order is one of the biggest things. One of them, as I said, is encryption; another major issue is the degree to which enforcement and definitions are left to regulation. That's one of the primary criticisms of this bill. I look at proposed section 5, for instance. This is sweeping powers. Proposed paragraph 5(2)(b) says, \"the installation, use, operation, management, assessment, testing and maintenance of any device\". Proposed paragraph 5(2)(d) says, \"the retention of categories of metadata\". Minister, I get why the government wants things to be broad; it's because then you can account for things. However, should we not be defining things where we can define them? I'm pretty sure we're going to have experts who say, \"Do you know what? We can define categories of metadata.\" I'm sure we can define categories of metadata. Those don't change every day. Would you be open to an amendment that says that when we're looking at taking information from people over which there's a high expectation of privacy...? I trust you would support an amendment that would define those types of things.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118321","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The difference with Bill C-8 , though, Minister.... If you want to get into Bill C-8, that is exactly my cautionary tale. The Liberals voted against just about every amendment that was of consequence. It was the Conservatives and the Bloc that voted for those amendments, that swayed those amendments, with the government often voting against them. Now things have changed. With all due respect, Bill","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3b2678f35e4f087e573a060737ea3c328d9f689a18d7a58718e5121caa07a9af"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["112ab1dfa7fdef516e0020e57a2bb3a66ea3bd3e89d0383f3e9e772aa63dd9d5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33982698a7b6d675ff38d91b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118322,"date":"2026-05-05T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Just [ Inaudible—Editor ].","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118322","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Just [ Inaudible—Editor ].","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2e68103ef2280d660d28ca6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949802,"date":"2026-05-06T19:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a surprising project to tell members about. Imagine this: no fences, beautiful townhouse-style living, tennis courts, and fishing in the Rideau River over the summertime. No, I am not talking about a new housing project. I am talking about a jail, a penitentiary in fact, that houses notorious sex offender and child killer Darren Scott Ray. That is right. This person was considered so dangerous that police had to follow him around everywhere he went when he was released for just 72 hours, yet he lives in a jail without fences and with a little slice of paradise, having comforts like a tennis court, a beautiful kitchen and all the freedom in the world.\n\nThe Liberals bungled this with Bill C-83 and their \"least restrictive\" measure. Why is it that somebody who is a child-killing sex offender who needs to be supervised every single minute can live in a place without fences?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949802","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a surprising project to tell members about. Imagine this: no fences, beautiful townhouse-style living, tennis courts, and fishing in the Rideau River over the summertime. No, I am not talking about a new housing project. I am talking about a jail, a penitentiary in fact, that houses notorious sex offender and child killer Darren Scott Ray. That is right. This person was conside","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["753b231150c3a74cafc6a9272a084e7c971e5356817b8212023e9d876f1e5a81"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["74682507fa9d988e8b43439dcc13fb3d4f48b832f52fbf3fb33aa74575201553"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6e04945fb095dd336fb260f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118248,"date":"2026-05-06T23:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"JUST","text":"It's really great to back here at the justice committee. I wonder if I was missed. I just heard a \"no\" from across the way. Mr. Fortin says I was missed. The chair is giving me a hard time and I'm hearing—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118248","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's really great to back here at the justice committee. I wonder if I was missed. I just heard a \"no\" from across the way. Mr. Fortin says I was missed. The chair is giving me a hard time and I'm hearing—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fdeea05e06ce137161c1b09","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118249,"date":"2026-05-06T23:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"JUST","text":"All right. This is for the officials. One of the things I find very interesting in the bill is the importation of \"cruel and unusual\", which has been defined in the jurisprudence. One of the things you said, Ms. Burt, is, \"we can expect\". Is it a grossly disproportionate threshold? Is that still the threshold for cruel and unusual punishment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118249","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"All right. This is for the officials. One of the things I find very interesting in the bill is the importation of \"cruel and unusual\", which has been defined in the jurisprudence. One of the things you said, Ms. Burt, is, \"we can expect\". Is it a grossly disproportionate threshold? Is that still the threshold for cruel and unusual punishment?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87d5dde1d4ed395d683edba41ce9827af1e9607a53451b459351a27fa6242fa9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0fb1d8959a5edd26eafda9e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118250,"date":"2026-05-06T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"JUST","text":"When you say \"gross disproportionality\" and \"we can expect\".... Obviously, there is some ambiguity whenever something is not defined in legislation. Is that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118250","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"When you say \"gross disproportionality\" and \"we can expect\".... Obviously, there is some ambiguity whenever something is not defined in legislation. Is that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gross domestic product","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","label":"Gross domestic product","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a33ff04b5e38cfb11dbbc63a1b40b23e4b9821406a4bfc9acadffdfa8e015861"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a873af4493a0840fac6c45b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118251,"date":"2026-05-06T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"JUST","text":"The Supreme Court of Canada is the highest court in the land, as we all know, and it has taken a living tree approach to all sorts of law. In fact, in the Rodriguez decision—if memory serves, it was in 1993—the judges said there was \"no constitutional right\" to die, as in there was no constitutional right to kill oneself through what we then called euthanasia. Carter came along in 2015. That was a mere 22 years later. That's not very long in the life of the law. Carter came to a completely different conclusion after just 22 years. There was no new statutory law that Carter was based on. Carter wasn't interpreting a different provision of the Criminal Code or of some other federal legislation. Carter was an application that said they wished to engage in what was rebranded as medical assistance in dying, just as Rodriguez was seeking, I believe, to strike down the Criminal Code prohibition on euthanasia. They were both asking the exact same question and the court came to very different conclusions only 22 years later, when the body of law—that which was being considered—was largely the same. I don't think I'm going out on a limb here. The point I am trying to make is that \"grossly disproportionate\" is what the court is saying today. Do you have any idea about what the court will say tomorrow?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118251","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Supreme Court of Canada is the highest court in the land, as we all know, and it has taken a living tree approach to all sorts of law. In fact, in the Rodriguez decision—if memory serves, it was in 1993—the judges said there was \"no constitutional right\" to die, as in there was no constitutional right to kill oneself through what we then called euthanasia. Carter came along in 2015. That was a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","label":"Euthanasia"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","label":"Euthanasia","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["632939f75f737ea57498fea4e61293d101605874fb6aab31bcca3d24e03d2b3e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ba00a6f40dc707c377fb87bd93ad30e14199914d4a332c2d395e758d4848b5a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b7d85c1e1ac758902017bef7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118252,"date":"2026-05-06T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"JUST","text":"Exactly. You said it much better than I could have; you said it so much more eloquently. The point is that nowhere in Bill C-16 is \"cruel and unusual punishment\" defined. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118252","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Exactly. You said it much better than I could have; you said it so much more eloquently. The point is that nowhere in Bill C-16 is \"cruel and unusual punishment\" defined. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5942a81baf0581e0f1856460063b10f96c821e353d68d2819299ee7efc0c2831"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c037e4eacdc650e2fda8846f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118253,"date":"2026-05-06T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"JUST","text":"It's interesting that you say they've chosen to import the jurisprudence, because they haven't chosen to codify the jurisprudence. Isn't that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118253","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's interesting that you say they've chosen to import the jurisprudence, because they haven't chosen to codify the jurisprudence. Isn't that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a6749469a3c6b9701b524b836da2be60a987566c94af660c2ecc97bdc377daf5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ce3cd3eecfe2b64ea60a083","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118254,"date":"2026-05-06T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"JUST","text":"I agree with you that that's what they are saying, but they haven't said.... For instance, the bill doesn't say, \"You will be subject to a mandatory minimum penalty unless the penalty would be grossly disproportionate in the circumstances.\" They didn't say that. Do you get what I'm saying? It is a different.... They're using the section 12 language. They're not using the section 12 test. Do you get what I mean by that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118254","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I agree with you that that's what they are saying, but they haven't said.... For instance, the bill doesn't say, \"You will be subject to a mandatory minimum penalty unless the penalty would be grossly disproportionate in the circumstances.\" They didn't say that. Do you get what I'm saying? It is a different.... They're using the section 12 language. They're not using the section 12 test. Do you ge","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f6bf5b36e3f96d5255bdb313eda73d1e5dbb07273d923b7e1a7e838501ab283"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35835e21f58aaf4b47e5f22c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118255,"date":"2026-05-06T23:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"JUST","text":"That's a really interesting one. I'm going to talk for a second here on outraging society and decency, because in the Senneville case, in the court's eyes, to impose a one-year mandatory minimum would outrage the sense of decency in society. That was the court's decision, whereas I think a lot of Canadians here...and I'm not assailing the court's decision. I'm speaking about what I think, what I hear from constituents, which is that the striking down of that actually outraged a number of Canadians and their standards of decency. One of the interesting things we have to look at is what is in Bill C-16 and what isn't in Bill C-16. I spent far too long dealing with sexual offences against children. One of the highlights in coming to Parliament Hill was meeting Justice Moldaver, who, for those who don't know, was on the Supreme Court of Canada until, I guess, roughly 2020, and maybe 2022 or something like that, and somebody here probably knows better. I met him and I referenced the Woodward decision on Internet luring. I could talk about this for hours.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118255","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's a really interesting one. I'm going to talk for a second here on outraging society and decency, because in the Senneville case, in the court's eyes, to impose a one-year mandatory minimum would outrage the sense of decency in society. That was the court's decision, whereas I think a lot of Canadians here...and I'm not assailing the court's decision. I'm speaking about what I think, what I h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8418b953cac2d90ec3f540e3fa2995093c32bd3e9fa19649446283e6f6ec9e94"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a62929140cb187dde9145f75a4f7a700c740f4828657eef93f3a922edb31d0b0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed51a9ba019289aeaba70187","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118256,"date":"2026-05-06T23:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"JUST","text":"You know? Oh, come on. It would be so insightful, would it not, Ms. Lattanzio?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118256","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You know? Oh, come on. It would be so insightful, would it not, Ms. Lattanzio?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-272cb2b5e259f8f837377b2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118257,"date":"2026-05-06T23:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"JUST","text":"What Woodward said was about Internet luring and its minimum penalties. It talked about this insidious crime and how the range should probably be from three to five years. That was when Parliament had a 10-year maximum. I will make this point very quickly. Nowhere are we dealing with mandatory minimums on sex offences in Bill C-16 , the most insidious types of offences: production of child sexual abuse material, Internet luring, offences like that. It should be there. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118257","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What Woodward said was about Internet luring and its minimum penalties. It talked about this insidious crime and how the range should probably be from three to five years. That was when Parliament had a 10-year maximum. I will make this point very quickly. Nowhere are we dealing with mandatory minimums on sex offences in Bill C-16 , the most insidious types of offences: production of child sexual ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Internet","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","label":"Internet","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c9878d6d2ae68b0c879a4df23e94bfd21f32d7bb6a4fac4801a526f0488951d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e876aaef9cf884dc82e39cc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949799,"date":"2026-05-07T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI have to say I am quite disappointed in the government's response. In fact, I think it is going to have to resile from this response at some point. When I heard the minister say this was just fearmongering, to me, that was completely unbecoming. Is it fearmongering when somebody goes to renew their mortgage and they have to get a higher interest rate because the market is saying that their house is no longer worth the same amount? Crickets. Is it fearmongering when somebody cannot get insurance at the same rate? That has nothing to do with what is being said on this side of the House. It has to do with, really, what is happening on the ground. \n\nThe only reason that the government is dealing with this is because it has been hearing about it. The government is hearing about it because of the reasons I just said.\n\nDoes the hon. member not agree?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949799","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI have to say I am quite disappointed in the government's response. In fact, I think it is going to have to resile from this response at some point. When I heard the minister say this was just fearmongering, to me, that was completely unbecoming. Is it fearmongering when somebody goes to renew thei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1191117f96c85e845965dbf212780dc04c123162a4c8f2fdee4452ff356af4c5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fddfaf0eed6d4f646833e6a82d81ce21721679e622b1a0af709c63d85d6a3ec"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d8b35951711f43755b33c23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949800,"date":"2026-05-07T17:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nThe member talks about all legal options. He is talking like a lawyer here. Why does he not tell us about the idea of estoppel and issue estoppel? Does that arise, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949800","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nThe member talks about all legal options. He is talking like a lawyer here. Why does he not tell us about the idea of estoppel and issue estoppel? Does that arise, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4d976dc55cc9f148a7ae66e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949801,"date":"2026-05-07T17:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nWe just heard from a B.C. member from Surrey. I have to say that it sounded like a bureaucrat wrote the speech. The reason why I say that is that he read the whole speech. In fact, I asked him a question, and he read from a piece of paper an answer that had nothing to do with the question. \n\nMy hon. colleague clearly wrote his own speech. I am wondering what message it sends when the Liberals are just reading talking points and accusing us of fearmongering.\n\nWhy do they not go to the houses in Richmond and the places in Vancouver and ask how people feel about having a higher mortgage rate or not being able to get home insurance? Why do they not do that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949801","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nWe just heard from a B.C. member from Surrey. I have to say that it sounded like a bureaucrat wrote the speech. The reason why I say that is that he read the whole speech. In fact, I asked him a question, and he read from a piece of paper an answer that had nothing to do with the question. \n\nMy hon","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9da5806953701c2ed9516abf535b4f44da850195c4c0e2b10cda2c3735c2f1c5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a1d80669ceb7f615c7e7f5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118323,"date":"2026-05-07T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I call this meeting to order. First of all, it is a pleasure and an honour to be here as your vice-chair chairing this meeting. Thank you all so much. Welcome to meeting 37 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security. Pursuant to the order of reference of the House of April 20, 2026, and the motion adopted by the committee on April 30, 2026, the committee is resuming its study of Bill C-22 , an act respecting lawful access. Welcome to our witnesses. We have Professor Leah West as an individual. We have the chief of police for Thunder Bay, Chief Fleury, and we have chief of police for the Toronto Police Service, Chief Demkiw. Welcome to you all. You all have five minutes to make an opening statement. For those in person, I will endeavour to get your attention when you're at one minute left and then when we're coming down to the end of your time. Hopefully I can do that as well for the people who are by video link. With that, I invite Professor West to make an opening statement. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118323","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I call this meeting to order. First of all, it is a pleasure and an honour to be here as your vice-chair chairing this meeting. Thank you all so much. Welcome to meeting 37 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security. Pursuant to the order of reference of the House of April 20, 2026, and the motion adopted by the committee on April 30, 2026, the committee is r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["026a80899b50bd75cc6a73e7df4f07ca5829e63565dfaa322d011720768a88d8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cfc4db13a03abafba8c8d7ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118324,"date":"2026-05-07T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Professor West. Your timing was perfect. We will now move on to Chief Fleury, and you have five minutes. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118324","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Professor West. Your timing was perfect. We will now move on to Chief Fleury, and you have five minutes. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d67c59f757a1f5cff89fecb9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118325,"date":"2026-05-07T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Excuse me, Chief. Could I interrupt you, please? Could you please take the boom of your microphone down just a shade so it's not touching your skin?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118325","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Excuse me, Chief. Could I interrupt you, please? Could you please take the boom of your microphone down just a shade so it's not touching your skin?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","label":"Whistleblower protection","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c2383e3b450de8dc35355444ea45fece28a94580b18a47d4c79140172ade7a96"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70ae83478740cd0556e4047c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118326,"date":"2026-05-07T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes, I have a thumbs-up. Thank you. I'm sorry to interrupt.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118326","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes, I have a thumbs-up. Thank you. I'm sorry to interrupt.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5415d8ca4534f0116822053","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118327,"date":"2026-05-07T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Chief Fleury. Now we will go to Chief Demkiw for five minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118327","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chief Fleury. Now we will go to Chief Demkiw for five minutes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","label":"Dams","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["613f1dcdbc86fa8eb876f0909c419c553fe7b81f616cbf910611e146c9244eae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a14948758eef46a6e16fa5a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118328,"date":"2026-05-07T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Chief Demkiw. With that, we will get to our first round of questions. I will exercise my prerogative as chair to take six minutes for questions. This is something that I've spoken about with the honourable parliamentary secretary and my colleague from the Bloc. Thanks to all of you for being here. This is an area in which you all have a lot of expertise. I thank the two police chiefs for their service. Professor West, it will probably be no surprise that I'm going to start with you. I wanted to ask you about encryption. This seems to be, for some people, a really big issue. What can you say about encryption when it comes to this bill? Is it sufficiently defined? Is it not sufficiently defined? Where, in your legal opinion, would you land, given what we see in the bill on the definition of \"encryption\"?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118328","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chief Demkiw. With that, we will get to our first round of questions. I will exercise my prerogative as chair to take six minutes for questions. This is something that I've spoken about with the honourable parliamentary secretary and my colleague from the Bloc. Thanks to all of you for being here. This is an area in which you all have a lot of expertise. I thank the two police chiefs fo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9be6533cc8e4626fc958ad538a079206a7d28bddb2409ad9fc980df7eefb98bc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a598ea2c5b66ced7136821f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118329,"date":"2026-05-07T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. I'm going to have you expand on that, please. When you talk about these vulnerabilities, I assume these might be vulnerabilities that the provider might not even know about. Is that accurate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118329","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. I'm going to have you expand on that, please. When you talk about these vulnerabilities, I assume these might be vulnerabilities that the provider might not even know about. Is that accurate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","label":"Whistleblower protection","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8defe87ef146450b63cbc8623fe72f655e39660d61a00cfb5c6e509fb337bc87"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c377e94c2b53523320dacb89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118330,"date":"2026-05-07T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Right, because in the legislation, part 2 would apply to those who meet the definition of a \"core provider\", or if I recall correctly, those who are designated by ministerial order. Is that—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118330","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Right, because in the legislation, part 2 would apply to those who meet the definition of a \"core provider\", or if I recall correctly, those who are designated by ministerial order. Is that—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6c1c0e3c819ed50efe0a21fd178c45acf8b65d71a9c489b8bd059975610d87db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["517864525f857a9243b8c9d3eb541b563baeba71192eb03973c4497a9f97629f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcafe7dada8875574dc3bedc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118331,"date":"2026-05-07T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Theoretically, a business could be designated by ministerial order, and it would then be subject to this. Essentially, if I properly get what you're saying, that's boundless or limitless, in that we don't know exactly who this is going to be applied to. Do I have that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118331","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Theoretically, a business could be designated by ministerial order, and it would then be subject to this. Essentially, if I properly get what you're saying, that's boundless or limitless, in that we don't know exactly who this is going to be applied to. Do I have that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036424","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nonprescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036424","label":"Nonprescription drugs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4767942c46de06d97468e8d57d6796c56644716efdd9e0a350e41cf51afcf2eb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b0ae8889f4daaadb4f52b37","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118332,"date":"2026-05-07T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm going to ask you about something, and this is an interesting question that was brought to my attention. Let's say that a business provider has a capability.... It's Alexa, for instance. That's Amazon, I believe. Is that right? It's something like that. Alexa, theoretically, could listen to your conversations, or every time you say, \"Hey, Siri,\" Siri starts to listen. Could it be possible that if Apple has the ability—I'm sorry to pick on Apple—or any company has that ability, they could say, \"Okay, every time that someone says, 'Hey, Siri,' that app has to start listening\"? The app itself or the provider itself has the ability to listen. It's actually not necessarily asking the provider to create a new power. It's almost asking for it to go one step further. Are you with me so far?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118332","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm going to ask you about something, and this is an interesting question that was brought to my attention. Let's say that a business provider has a capability.... It's Alexa, for instance. That's Amazon, I believe. Is that right? It's something like that. Alexa, theoretically, could listen to your conversations, or every time you say, \"Hey, Siri,\" Siri starts to listen. Could it be possible that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ea15546603997e2fc57f9602cb34972bb774968089e8f0f54dc321f8e0c8ec3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e7cdc7ab64c12651da508ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118333,"date":"2026-05-07T20:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"As I understand it, if such an order were made, that order would not \"possibly\" be secret but would be secret, in which case a whistle-blower couldn't necessarily come forward. I guess the only recourse there for the company that's doing that would be to apply for judicial review. Is that accurate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118333","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As I understand it, if such an order were made, that order would not \"possibly\" be secret but would be secret, in which case a whistle-blower couldn't necessarily come forward. I guess the only recourse there for the company that's doing that would be to apply for judicial review. Is that accurate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035859","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Industrial waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035859","label":"Industrial waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","label":"Whistleblower protection","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e761429106849679bcc7d0d9661e25334489c2e1794ce45bafb5485b4dd26aca"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d72bab4490cbf36be2e2f7bbd9e73aa2dcb4ec5f4628d2f216e3e5b3fa5b38d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03f9fe13d87c8352f0874aa3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118334,"date":"2026-05-07T20:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Right. I suppose that, in this case, the difference might be that the police could say, \"We believe Professor West has committed a criminal offence, and that her use of Siri holds evidence of that. We are going to get a warrant.\" They could get that now. The only difference is that, under part 2, there would be a requirement to bring up the capacity to do that or the capability to do that, whereas right now it would just simply exist—if that makes sense.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118334","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Right. I suppose that, in this case, the difference might be that the police could say, \"We believe Professor West has committed a criminal offence, and that her use of Siri holds evidence of that. We are going to get a warrant.\" They could get that now. The only difference is that, under part 2, there would be a requirement to bring up the capacity to do that or the capability to do that, whereas","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a634fffcc3d4a75a9fa53229","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118335,"date":"2026-05-07T20:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. Thank you. My six minutes are up. Mr. Ramsay, you have the floor for six minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118335","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you. My six minutes are up. Mr. Ramsay, you have the floor for six minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e64df36b6b370aa8a7f9a7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118336,"date":"2026-05-07T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry, Mr. Ramsay. Your time is up. No, I didn't look forward to saying that. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for six minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118336","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry, Mr. Ramsay. Your time is up. No, I didn't look forward to saying that. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for six minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b0704e3c3e5ee44549c1d03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118337,"date":"2026-05-07T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry, Professor. We'll have to pick that up in the next round. We will move on to Ms. Kirkland for five minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118337","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry, Professor. We'll have to pick that up in the next round. We will move on to Ms. Kirkland for five minutes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bff9feb6ab0133fe5c4aa94a70c775f6c83ad455dd66bf7986bd70992a3053af"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b8045e7a6894e6f5d15fce0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118338,"date":"2026-05-07T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'll interrupt for just one moment, please. We have a meeting here. I don't mind whispers; I know that's going to happen. If it needs a meeting, we should go outside, please. Thank you. I'm sorry about that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118338","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll interrupt for just one moment, please. We have a meeting here. I don't mind whispers; I know that's going to happen. If it needs a meeting, we should go outside, please. Thank you. I'm sorry about that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a91aa57361584218e774f1350df968dc70feb87ebc8708d9bc27a1b212a1e85"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed7295a0ead9d82bfde1d7e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118339,"date":"2026-05-07T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Unfortunately, Ms. Kirkland, your time is up. Up next is Ms. Acan for five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118339","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Unfortunately, Ms. Kirkland, your time is up. Up next is Ms. Acan for five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac715c4e82711caa943d0ab5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118340,"date":"2026-05-07T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry, Chief Fleury. We have to cut you off there. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118340","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry, Chief Fleury. We have to cut you off there. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-369958a9df0f5371a683bb07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118341,"date":"2026-05-07T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mrs. DeBellefeuille, your time is unfortunately up. Mr. Lloyd, you have five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118341","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mrs. DeBellefeuille, your time is unfortunately up. Mr. Lloyd, you have five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c36f22bbe8b7b4127e41a7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118342,"date":"2026-05-07T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry. I have to cut you off, Professor West. It's hard to stay within the time limit when we get to the last questions. It's tough but fair. With the final questions, we have Dr. Powlowski.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118342","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry. I have to cut you off, Professor West. It's hard to stay within the time limit when we get to the last questions. It's tough but fair. With the final questions, we have Dr. Powlowski.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["99e3c07641974f52c6913389a2d338623ee9b54cdb2900ff3b3035b96ea89d90"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-907579e26c1867afb711698d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118343,"date":"2026-05-07T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Unfortunately, Dr. Powlowski, that is the last thought of this round. Some hon. members: Oh, oh! The Vice-Chair (Frank Caputo): I'd like to thank all of our witnesses for being here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118343","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Unfortunately, Dr. Powlowski, that is the last thought of this round. Some hon. members: Oh, oh! The Vice-Chair (Frank Caputo): I'd like to thank all of our witnesses for being here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1d0d1c489f7027af9643143ae2f5269a860378deee1bbe223b9fb3323e6a7cb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fd642726da1d046c86c22e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118344,"date":"2026-05-07T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We will suspend to bring the next witnesses on board.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118344","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We will suspend to bring the next witnesses on board.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bcd25c5af886aba4c3179721c49edb5e422984a484263c5c7a170bd996e43a80"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba8bd964f90aeece93264795","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118345,"date":"2026-05-07T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, all, for being here again for the second hour. We have two witnesses here in person and one appearing by video conference. I understand that Mr. Fraser, who is on video, has been sound checked. Thank you for appearing. We also have Dr. Robert Diab from Thompson Rivers University. Lastly, we have Dr. Michael Geist from the University of Ottawa. Professor Diab, could you please go ahead with your five-minute opening statement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118345","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, all, for being here again for the second hour. We have two witnesses here in person and one appearing by video conference. I understand that Mr. Fraser, who is on video, has been sound checked. Thank you for appearing. We also have Dr. Robert Diab from Thompson Rivers University. Lastly, we have Dr. Michael Geist from the University of Ottawa. Professor Diab, could you please go ahead w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cae1986703db3c1babef2477","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118346,"date":"2026-05-07T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Wait one moment, please, Professor Diab. I understand we're having some difficulties.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118346","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Wait one moment, please, Professor Diab. I understand we're having some difficulties.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-342ec506825bc70f91da9ef7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118347,"date":"2026-05-07T21:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118347","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b74b66108f82f95b69aa8bb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118348,"date":"2026-05-07T21:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Professor Diab. In Parliament, we're used to it going down, so I apologize for cutting you off. I would like to welcome MPs Kayabaga and Baber to the table as well. Dr. Geist, please go ahead with your five-minute opening statement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118348","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Professor Diab. In Parliament, we're used to it going down, so I apologize for cutting you off. I would like to welcome MPs Kayabaga and Baber to the table as well. Dr. Geist, please go ahead with your five-minute opening statement.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13ef655ab7c39bf33c9e6ab0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118349,"date":"2026-05-07T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Dr. Geist. Now we move to Mr. Fraser for five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118349","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Dr. Geist. Now we move to Mr. Fraser for five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7f9a1cb3c9c4c3f823ef4f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118350,"date":"2026-05-07T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry, Mr. Fraser. We will have to stop there. I apologize.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118350","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry, Mr. Fraser. We will have to stop there. I apologize.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44a71b4f1ea81b73b29bcff4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118351,"date":"2026-05-07T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"As chair, I will be leading off this round for six minutes. I want to thank all of the witnesses. We have a very academic panel this time. I'm very humbled by the three of you coming to spend your time with us today, and what do you know? We're all lawyers here. That's wonderful. Professor Diab, it's particularly great to have you here as a colleague with whom I dealt at the bar in British Columbia in my time as a prosecutor and also in my time teaching advanced criminal law and sentencing at Thompson Rivers University. I know that everybody's very proud to have you here, so thank you for being here. With that, I want to expand a little on the question of engagement in section 8 when it comes to the requirement of a third party to retain data. Is there a specific case you're relying on there, Professor?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118351","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As chair, I will be leading off this round for six minutes. I want to thank all of the witnesses. We have a very academic panel this time. I'm very humbled by the three of you coming to spend your time with us today, and what do you know? We're all lawyers here. That's wonderful. Professor Diab, it's particularly great to have you here as a colleague with whom I dealt at the bar in British Columbi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc2f3d876288eaa9626b0ce113070c7970016cdfbd1f93e3673b5c51a8bc6049"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-813d07186e60eb3087470a6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118352,"date":"2026-05-07T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. I would like to ask the two professors who are here in person about the reasonable grounds to suspect versus reasonable grounds to believe. It's been a while since I dealt with reasonable grounds to suspect, but my recollection of reasonable grounds to believe is that there has to be a subjective belief, as in you have to personally believe that an offence has been committed, and that belief must be objectively reasonable. That's my recollection. In other words, a reasonable person would say, \"Yes, you have a reasonable belief.\" It's below balance of probabilities, so it's not ultrahigh. It's less than 50%, but above the suspect, which is more than a hunch but less than that. What would you say to the proposition that this is asking for very narrow data and, therefore, we don't have to worry as much that this could be saved under section 1? Would you agree with that, Professor Geist?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118352","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I would like to ask the two professors who are here in person about the reasonable grounds to suspect versus reasonable grounds to believe. It's been a while since I dealt with reasonable grounds to suspect, but my recollection of reasonable grounds to believe is that there has to be a subjective belief, as in you have to personally believe that an offence has been committed, and that b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bf4d82532ab1d4595265c7dacb6c876efb98f5215d5727eff1be6a94debc57a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0bacae2ed23fcdf985b0e4af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118353,"date":"2026-05-07T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I see. To Mr. Fraser online, I mentioned at the last meeting, when I wasn't the chair, that this is a highly technical bill. We had only one hour with the officials. I wanted to address one thing you brought up to this committee. You talked about CSIS wanting to have real-time access. I think the committee may want to ask CSIS about that. For our reference and for our analysts, can you tell us where you got that point, please, in 25 seconds or less?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118353","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I see. To Mr. Fraser online, I mentioned at the last meeting, when I wasn't the chair, that this is a highly technical bill. We had only one hour with the officials. I wanted to address one thing you brought up to this committee. You talked about CSIS wanting to have real-time access. I think the committee may want to ask CSIS about that. For our reference and for our analysts, can you tell us whe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d446fe92503e984c913ce5b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118354,"date":"2026-05-07T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sure we have that. I have 10 seconds left, but we are a bit behind schedule, so we will now go to Mr. Housefather. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118354","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sure we have that. I have 10 seconds left, but we are a bit behind schedule, so we will now go to Mr. Housefather. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9b1a3cd1f7cfcefcbbd3edf0a555a09cbc18325efba4a198c8c1d1b7db3a6ac"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe2cc878582e9d13c1c98727","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118355,"date":"2026-05-07T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We have a point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118355","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We have a point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45b5663ae8e1d16a0bf5da84","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118356,"date":"2026-05-07T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Housefather.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118356","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Housefather.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c20d84332bf66fa59a732907","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118357,"date":"2026-05-07T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry, Professor Diab, but I have to cut you off there. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for six minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118357","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry, Professor Diab, but I have to cut you off there. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for six minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e6141a698a9108ebbd5c1d233b8553f3d52643f0b8147b41684cea3b00a814fc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c54ceb5549dacb4f2a6dad27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118358,"date":"2026-05-07T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry, Mrs. DeBellefeuille and Dr. Geist. The time is done. Ms. Kirkland, your time begins now, for five minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118358","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry, Mrs. DeBellefeuille and Dr. Geist. The time is done. Ms. Kirkland, your time begins now, for five minutes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69e540ad0b1435378e51643212fba25d5fd656d719288cb6ec95f4bfbd8fbd87"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3cd6976c733e9724bd83307f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118359,"date":"2026-05-07T22:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Professor Geist. Next, we have Mr. Zuberi for five minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118359","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Professor Geist. Next, we have Mr. Zuberi for five minutes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3df8846bfb78403e309cb454","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118360,"date":"2026-05-07T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118360","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8ebe379388396e5183c0be4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118361,"date":"2026-05-07T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Professor Geist and Madame DeBellefeuille. Now we will go to Mr. Baber for five minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118361","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Professor Geist and Madame DeBellefeuille. Now we will go to Mr. Baber for five minutes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73d53a675f8e4f1808b1cafa53f497457b443a91709dc3746a06c9cbc12789a8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18aa0c2c6818f39c5adc8083","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118362,"date":"2026-05-07T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Baber, please, if you could just slow down a shade—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118362","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Baber, please, if you could just slow down a shade—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Demining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","label":"Demining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f0de6a09372344ed218eacfd1e23a81e6c16724d0664815b5ace6a5ca1689ae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1ff904ed5e12b98d6ece923","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118363,"date":"2026-05-07T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry. You were just about to give us a brilliant thought, Professor, but that brilliant thought will have to go to Madame Dandurand, if she so chooses. You have five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118363","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry. You were just about to give us a brilliant thought, Professor, but that brilliant thought will have to go to Madame Dandurand, if she so chooses. You have five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","label":"Literature","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9008401d07124c7d6574e3cef43976be721dc55881a591f2952d95f250a27d85"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9a6dd1b32396ab2006e4fae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118364,"date":"2026-05-07T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Let's hear the brilliant thought.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118364","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Let's hear the brilliant thought.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a593d8757fc848771a704c26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118365,"date":"2026-05-07T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Answer very briefly, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118365","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Answer very briefly, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27af20a1044a0b3a81eef4d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118366,"date":"2026-05-07T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Professor Geist. I apologize. I want to exercise my prerogative as the chair, because there's one thing I think we're going to hear about in the next round that I think is very important. I'll ask you for a very brief, 15-second response. You mentioned that 30 days for metadata would be appropriate. Oftentimes, there's not even an investigator assigned to an Internet luring case in 30 days. Bearing that in mind, what would you think about 90 days, given those types of crimes, to address those types of crimes or the metadata that would allow us to address those types of crimes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118366","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Professor Geist. I apologize. I want to exercise my prerogative as the chair, because there's one thing I think we're going to hear about in the next round that I think is very important. I'll ask you for a very brief, 15-second response. You mentioned that 30 days for metadata would be appropriate. Oftentimes, there's not even an investigator assigned to an Internet luring ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2a4fe6478d86fa64d251678e82f1cb61ec77bbab827e483bfd85658255abd0d2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab0edca3debedb82d77b4f65222c2e37dfee08eea22bda8992ff6952b23878d7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0a24628af4ca7213c6103bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118367,"date":"2026-05-07T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We will try to get that in the following panels. Thank you very much. Thank you to our witnesses. We will suspend briefly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118367","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We will try to get that in the following panels. Thank you very much. Thank you to our witnesses. We will suspend briefly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55dcc6289996235a919d3681","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118368,"date":"2026-05-07T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We are now into our third panel. I want to welcome our next panel of witnesses here to speak. We have, from the Canadian Centre for Child Protection, Monique St. Germain; from the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, David Pierce; and from the Peel Children's Aid Society, Mary Beth Moellenkamp. Thank you, witnesses. You have five minutes each for an opening statement. Ms. St. Germain, we will hear from you first, please. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118368","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We are now into our third panel. I want to welcome our next panel of witnesses here to speak. We have, from the Canadian Centre for Child Protection, Monique St. Germain; from the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, David Pierce; and from the Peel Children's Aid Society, Mary Beth Moellenkamp. Thank you, witnesses. You have five minutes each for an opening statement. Ms. St. Germain, we will hear from y","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68907c5dbd586e7efbf19aec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118369,"date":"2026-05-07T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. Mr. Pierce, you have five minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118369","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Pierce, you have five minutes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-574fe88acecdbabaa0e526e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118370,"date":"2026-05-07T22:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mrs. DeBellefeuille, do you have a point of order?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118370","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mrs. DeBellefeuille, do you have a point of order?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07c54815500b9fdfeef08c16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118371,"date":"2026-05-07T22:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you so much. Mr. Pierce, if you could, please speak a bit slower. We do have interpretation. For all witnesses and all members, particularly when we're reading we do tend to read a bit faster. Please, everybody, just bear that in mind. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118371","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you so much. Mr. Pierce, if you could, please speak a bit slower. We do have interpretation. For all witnesses and all members, particularly when we're reading we do tend to read a bit faster. Please, everybody, just bear that in mind. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hearing disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","label":"Hearing disabilities","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4055aba83cd24587f632a6a19779545ed9b26eafd747ae88cf5662d35c03861f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90e73cede9ef7014dea826ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118372,"date":"2026-05-07T22:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Pierce. We'll now move on to Ms. Moellenkamp for five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118372","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Pierce. We'll now move on to Ms. Moellenkamp for five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-507c541349805b15a988f9fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118373,"date":"2026-05-07T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Ms. Moellenkamp. I want to thank this panel of witnesses. I will begin the first round of six minutes now. Ms. St. Germain, you probably don't remember me, but I consulted you when I was writing the bill to change the name from child pornography to child sexual abuse and exploitation material. I first became acquainted with your work when we both attended the same B.C. ICE provincial strategy conference. For those who don't know, the RCMP in Vancouver has a specific unit that investigates Internet and child exploitation. People from all sorts of agencies gathered at the conference. I really appreciated your interventions there. One thing we were talking about in the prior round was how long it takes for an investigation to kick off. I have prosecuted an Internet luring case. A lot of people don't realize this, but the software for a service provider, let's say, Facebook, could pick up an attempt to lure a child. Then, that goes to Washington, D.C., as I recall—it used to anyway—to the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children. I believe it would then go to the national headquarters for the RCMP, and then it would go to the province. Is that somewhat accurate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118373","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Ms. Moellenkamp. I want to thank this panel of witnesses. I will begin the first round of six minutes now. Ms. St. Germain, you probably don't remember me, but I consulted you when I was writing the bill to change the name from child pornography to child sexual abuse and exploitation material. I first became acquainted with your work when we both attended the same B.C. ICE pro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec57b6119fa8b664313b63c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118374,"date":"2026-05-07T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes, exactly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118374","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes, exactly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39c65296a6f6e5febec71071","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118375,"date":"2026-05-07T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That process takes a fair amount of time. I asked one of the legal experts on our previous panel about this. When we're talking about data retention, how long do we need to retain data? I don't think anybody thinks data should be retained indefinitely. You're a lawyer. You understand where people are coming from. We also have to look at how long data needs to be retained in order to have an investigation. In your experience, can you tell us how long it takes for an investigation to kick off to the point where somebody would look at it and say that they need something? For example, it could be a missing IP address that is an evidentiary gap, and if they were to have it, this would help them catch a child predator. Hopefully, I'm being clear.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118375","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That process takes a fair amount of time. I asked one of the legal experts on our previous panel about this. When we're talking about data retention, how long do we need to retain data? I don't think anybody thinks data should be retained indefinitely. You're a lawyer. You understand where people are coming from. We also have to look at how long data needs to be retained in order to have an invest","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a99a6a88aaed075001dcca4d1424b9fe3c8b8b0ec5e0830e321f7ba37ef5aeff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e871b55542a482662e29c6ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118376,"date":"2026-05-07T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I appreciate that. One of the greatest challenges I saw was linking the person in the prisoner's box to the person behind the computer screen or on the phone because you must have a piece of evidence that is linked in every spot. How long does it generally take from the time you get a tip to the point where something can be sent to a police agency?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118376","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate that. One of the greatest challenges I saw was linking the person in the prisoner's box to the person behind the computer screen or on the phone because you must have a piece of evidence that is linked in every spot. How long does it generally take from the time you get a tip to the point where something can be sent to a police agency?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43ad68f6b475ca18f0c6d7ad3d3ad2e60210092cea911d30344d859196462136"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e207406922263225048c5018","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118377,"date":"2026-05-07T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That username is then used to get a production order, ideally, on oath or on affirmation, which is part of what this bill is about. Ms. Moellenkamp, do you have anything to add to this, based on your expertise?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118377","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That username is then used to get a production order, ideally, on oath or on affirmation, which is part of what this bill is about. Ms. Moellenkamp, do you have anything to add to this, based on your expertise?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c79bbc3679ad4e3dec66c4e5ffe166d3df82df016c7c60505dfd779dd015701"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f420f5c02e47d805ee7ebfc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118378,"date":"2026-05-07T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I was just asking how long it takes, in your experience, to kick off an investigation. Do you have any experience with how long it takes? I know you're not a police officer, but I'm trying to gauge that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118378","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I was just asking how long it takes, in your experience, to kick off an investigation. Do you have any experience with how long it takes? I know you're not a police officer, but I'm trying to gauge that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f3c4d0c01bce8298b6ae6dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118379,"date":"2026-05-07T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. I apologize for cutting you off, but we have to move on to Mr. Ramsay for six minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118379","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I apologize for cutting you off, but we have to move on to Mr. Ramsay for six minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ea8e1d12999ee419e3202b3cc9edd6bd01431935a76dc0f5e4e0b06e11cde01"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8db8d1444fa223a035d2937d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118380,"date":"2026-05-07T23:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for six minutes. Thank you, Mr. Ramsay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118380","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for six minutes. Thank you, Mr. Ramsay.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b395637bd00cefc9a9681968","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118381,"date":"2026-05-07T23:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mrs. DeBellefeuille. For the benefit of the committee, we have been running a bit late. It's not because we have not been efficient, but because we have had more opening statements than we are used to. What I would propose, to ensure that we give our next panel the appropriate amount of time, is to now have a four-minute round for the Conservative Party and a four-minute round for the Liberal Party, and then move on to the next panel so that we can finish on time. I hope that is okay. We will move to Mr. Lloyd for four minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118381","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mrs. DeBellefeuille. For the benefit of the committee, we have been running a bit late. It's not because we have not been efficient, but because we have had more opening statements than we are used to. What I would propose, to ensure that we give our next panel the appropriate amount of time, is to now have a four-minute round for the Conservative Party and a four-minute round for the L","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9aec59f32fa6f04cce648bed6399d810af4e9ed88c84a622f0575e3e0a9f9f19"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d38a6fd04fa4b294c5299fe1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118382,"date":"2026-05-07T23:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. Ms. Acan, you have the final four minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118382","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Ms. Acan, you have the final four minutes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03b113d0dc66b9c6fbac98b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118383,"date":"2026-05-07T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Ms. St. Germain. I apologize, but I have to cut you off. I'm really sorry. We are running late here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118383","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Ms. St. Germain. I apologize, but I have to cut you off. I'm really sorry. We are running late here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dff98d36bf0ae3ff3f65c068","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118384,"date":"2026-05-07T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Witnesses, I encourage all of you, if you wish, to provide supplemental information to the committee. You all play a critical role. On behalf of the committee and all Canadians, we are grateful for your work. Thank you very much. We will suspend for as short a time as possible, preferably 90 seconds.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118384","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Witnesses, I encourage all of you, if you wish, to provide supplemental information to the committee. You all play a critical role. On behalf of the committee and all Canadians, we are grateful for your work. Thank you very much. We will suspend for as short a time as possible, preferably 90 seconds.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea0e3ee7955e6275c9efb60912eb77bd2ec4869a9a5d8f9565e27fb9a8c0da06"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73717bf0db9b2303f58e33ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118385,"date":"2026-05-07T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We're back. I apologize if that was a bit aggressive. I want to thank all panellists today. They are excellent, and we have a very distinguished panel. I really don't want to lose any time with them. I want to introduce them. We have, from Meta Platforms Inc., Rachel Curran and Robyn Greene. From NSIRA, we have the Honourable Marie Deschamps, Craig Forcese and Lawrence Mangano. Finally, we have the Honourable Simon Noël and Justin Dubois. We will now have opening statements. I have to vacate the chair for about three minutes. If anything comes up, Madame DeBellefeuille will deal with it. I will hopefully be back in three or four minutes. If not, please go on to the next opening statement. Thank you. We will start with the opening statement from Meta.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118385","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We're back. I apologize if that was a bit aggressive. I want to thank all panellists today. They are excellent, and we have a very distinguished panel. I really don't want to lose any time with them. I want to introduce them. We have, from Meta Platforms Inc., Rachel Curran and Robyn Greene. From NSIRA, we have the Honourable Marie Deschamps, Craig Forcese and Lawrence Mangano. Finally, we have th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d172f72889f43d812b529826","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118386,"date":"2026-05-07T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Ms. Curran. I apologize, but I have to be ruthless with the time. Ms. Deschamps, you have the floor for five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118386","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Ms. Curran. I apologize, but I have to be ruthless with the time. Ms. Deschamps, you have the floor for five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58452785efd8f2d6b438e200116899ae375b965b8b3cce009ea4d8d2298f81ee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2eeb55d98bb6eef91fab8e05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118387,"date":"2026-05-07T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Madam Deschamps was on the Supreme Court of Canada when I was a law student. I just can't cut her off. Voices: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118387","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Deschamps was on the Supreme Court of Canada when I was a law student. I just can't cut her off. Voices: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["237184e0f2d8c4de8656dabe832245c0d8e741baf516713b5698772bab9ec234"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-289fedb5114b3daf874fc201","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118388,"date":"2026-05-07T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Noël, you have the floor for five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118388","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Noël, you have the floor for five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70b00304b8ca455cdb8771b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118389,"date":"2026-05-07T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Noël. We are running a bit late, so I will propose, at least for this round, that we go to five minutes per round. I hope that's okay. I don't want anybody to lose their round. With that, we will begin with Mr. Lloyd for five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118389","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Noël. We are running a bit late, so I will propose, at least for this round, that we go to five minutes per round. I hope that's okay. I don't want anybody to lose their round. With that, we will begin with Mr. Lloyd for five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc70b76abcc10a244c5c8c3d1882b83804ec58fc00282101c0957c23e040b008"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb524bf48fd7212dd5eaec61","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118390,"date":"2026-05-07T23:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much. I'm sorry, but I do have to cut you off there. Next, we have Mr. Zuberi for five minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118390","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I'm sorry, but I do have to cut you off there. Next, we have Mr. Zuberi for five minutes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Demining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","label":"Demining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9136a0c3914d534f9b81a6e76f024c94b7776e78ecea140e2347a4417da6dd6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29234d70241456a70cf80507","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118391,"date":"2026-05-08T00:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Zuberi. You are out of time. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118391","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Zuberi. You are out of time. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9118cf9c3d88c9d0c4352813","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118392,"date":"2026-05-08T00:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mrs. DeBellefeuille and Ms. Deschamps. We'll now go on to Ms. Kirkland, whom I was supposed to recognize earlier. I apologize for that. You have five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118392","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mrs. DeBellefeuille and Ms. Deschamps. We'll now go on to Ms. Kirkland, whom I was supposed to recognize earlier. I apologize for that. You have five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0b76da0e80ebd28d6417aae4d25c6d76061545eb2fb49b71098bf981b9a3c13"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29a99474a60c25294d3f999d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118393,"date":"2026-05-08T00:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much. Thank you, Ms. Kirkland. Now, we go on to Mr. Housefather, please, for five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118393","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Thank you, Ms. Kirkland. Now, we go on to Mr. Housefather, please, for five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f338e9774009ab93db5bf0e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118394,"date":"2026-05-08T00:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Housefather. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118394","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Housefather. Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40c191f685f29714c3f8ac0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118395,"date":"2026-05-08T00:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Madame DeBellefeuille has the floor. I'm pausing the time here. Go ahead, Madame DeBellefeuille. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118395","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madame DeBellefeuille has the floor. I'm pausing the time here. Go ahead, Madame DeBellefeuille. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b30a25797b6561f267264a84","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118396,"date":"2026-05-08T00:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you for your comments, Mr. Noël. Now, we go to Mr. Baber for five minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118396","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for your comments, Mr. Noël. Now, we go to Mr. Baber for five minutes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f4d992ed5e21eef324727f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118397,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Baber. Unfortunately, we're over time. The last member to speak tonight is Mr. Ramsay. Mr. Ramsay, you have the floor for five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118397","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Baber. Unfortunately, we're over time. The last member to speak tonight is Mr. Ramsay. Mr. Ramsay, you have the floor for five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b55bc794bd865651ffe2b898","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118398,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Just a minute, Mr. Ramsay. It's very difficult for the interpreters, as somebody who has once or twice interrupted a witness, I've been told that—but it was only the ministers. Let's start again. Please continue, Mr. Ramsay. Ask your question of the witness, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118398","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Just a minute, Mr. Ramsay. It's very difficult for the interpreters, as somebody who has once or twice interrupted a witness, I've been told that—but it was only the ministers. Let's start again. Please continue, Mr. Ramsay. Ask your question of the witness, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8769e04188df152801223b25c9c9fa542fd0bc3c90a096c9cc3b97ae78fbff5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f3d2d0622acf31ebbf6fdf31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118399,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"It looks like we have another lawyer here. Voices: Oh, oh! The Vice-Chair (Frank Caputo): You have two minutes and 15 seconds.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118399","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It looks like we have another lawyer here. Voices: Oh, oh! The Vice-Chair (Frank Caputo): You have two minutes and 15 seconds.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["194606a085cae9a349820db9d5bdbdd69939c83f027d5edcdaebd75918506a79"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c07f0997062188a843ad7a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118400,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Could you slow down just a shade, please, Ms. Acan, for the interpreters?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118400","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Could you slow down just a shade, please, Ms. Acan, for the interpreters?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035748","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Humidity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035748","label":"Humidity","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eeab1f16b6e8fe24bb2a01d214e7de640870ef7cb2b8e31eff7ae8fe99a080eb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09b968d4fe6dfd078c519af3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118401,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay, let's just let him—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118401","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay, let's just let him—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-951663f22c46c05fd4023f70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118402,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"This may be—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118402","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This may be—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b2f32ff9ec1e23950749b91","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118403,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We were doing so well. We're near the end of the night. I know that different people can disagree on different points and on what they read into things. I take your point, Mr. Baber. I have known Ms. Acan to always attempt to be on the up and up, so this may just be—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118403","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We were doing so well. We're near the end of the night. I know that different people can disagree on different points and on what they read into things. I take your point, Mr. Baber. I have known Ms. Acan to always attempt to be on the up and up, so this may just be—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f8a45258abc4f90fe47996f37fd603f3feabee113f8fdce40b41930fc0d0f0ed"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-553fd898e92bce7a44f7a902","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118404,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay, we are now past.... We are well into debate here. Ms. Acan, could you please ask your question again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118404","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay, we are now past.... We are well into debate here. Ms. Acan, could you please ask your question again?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d818b345ef4cc3c7e41f102","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118405,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes, you have one minute left.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118405","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes, you have one minute left.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b3609bf29243a9f83e907b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118406,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Again, Ms. Acan, you need to slow down.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118406","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Again, Ms. Acan, you need to slow down.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1685ca6fbfd6523e0f6f2736","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118407,"date":"2026-05-08T00:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You have 20 seconds for an answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118407","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You have 20 seconds for an answer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c48caa6510b4d2159bef5f5d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118408,"date":"2026-05-08T00:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We will look forward to those amendments. I know that this has been a very long four hours. I would like to thank the interpreters, the analysts, the clerk and the members. Thank you very much. Have a great night.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118408","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We will look forward to those amendments. I know that this has been a very long four hours. I would like to thank the interpreters, the analysts, the clerk and the members. Thank you very much. Have a great night.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e526e8cd9cdad0ec8c1e06faca9fbe9274c694eba8bfd9cf747f8a6414c1b40c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-935190f44fb57fce3dffac24","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118409,"date":"2026-05-26T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses. I'm going to start with Commissioner Dufresne. Thank you for being here again. Can you please tell this committee how you were consulted on the drafting of this bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118409","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses. I'm going to start with Commissioner Dufresne. Thank you for being here again. Can you please tell this committee how you were consulted on the drafting of this bill?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f7aa3aea3c3beb607a55e7c66d0c94517b214a112738b3cdab906971206f4c1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-687d3f4bc38338d42d0dc7da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118410,"date":"2026-05-26T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Am I correct in saying then that you, as the Privacy Commissioner, were not consulted on what should be in a bill that touches on so many people's online privacy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118410","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Am I correct in saying then that you, as the Privacy Commissioner, were not consulted on what should be in a bill that touches on so many people's online privacy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d9baa3b969a15a4e27113d382c80c71d46a55af3ce3da26ea68a3ee2f616d3a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8702c1d4cd21fd6c372edd68a90847afa922b5500b79d5ebebc9b69d97da90f1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34e49a1c83ba834d84675e4d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118411,"date":"2026-05-26T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm not sure if you've been watching this committee process, Commissioner Dufresne. One of the chief issues I have here is how quickly we are moving. How many eminent witnesses do we have here? We have six very qualified witnesses representing three parties. This really should be divided up into two panels, in my view. I won't get to ask half the questions. Can you comment? Does it feel to you like this has been a bit too rushed? You gave us five or six substantive amendments here. We're not even going to be able to ask you about a lot of them because we're quite short on time, without even getting to other valid points. From your observation, has this been rushed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118411","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm not sure if you've been watching this committee process, Commissioner Dufresne. One of the chief issues I have here is how quickly we are moving. How many eminent witnesses do we have here? We have six very qualified witnesses representing three parties. This really should be divided up into two panels, in my view. I won't get to ask half the questions. Can you comment? Does it feel to you lik","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b57b7b1595e110114a303d1e6c620995fd889ae5ff0b4fcb8b4660ddd29cce8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b7ac2a606940b64e3703185","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118412,"date":"2026-05-26T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm mindful of that. I know you really can't weigh in. Mr. Lefebvre, you have been observing this. Does this not feel rushed to you? It feels quite rushed to me.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118412","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm mindful of that. I know you really can't weigh in. Mr. Lefebvre, you have been observing this. Does this not feel rushed to you? It feels quite rushed to me.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-810d7a3d8334aa9fed64103c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118413,"date":"2026-05-26T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would agree with you. No one is doubting that we want to catch bad people, like terrorists, and—as in my prior life—catch people who abuse kids. There's no doubt about it. You also hit the nail on the head. Not only has this been rushed, but the communications from the government have been awful, if I'm going to be candid about this. The minister would not declare whether he would be open to an amendment on encryption, which is something that you highlighted. I don't know why we're using cute phrases like \"encryption-neutral\". We don't know any of that. Amendments have to be in tomorrow, yet we're hearing from officials on Thursday. We've had one hour from officials. From your standpoint, can you see why it would be prudent to actually study this bill further?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118413","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would agree with you. No one is doubting that we want to catch bad people, like terrorists, and—as in my prior life—catch people who abuse kids. There's no doubt about it. You also hit the nail on the head. Not only has this been rushed, but the communications from the government have been awful, if I'm going to be candid about this. The minister would not declare whether he would be open to an ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9096bbb76e9b217b88871f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118414,"date":"2026-05-26T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I understand. I'm sorry, but I have to cut my time short with you because I'm down to about 45 seconds. Mr. Nadeau, one of the things you talked about was oversight and people getting caught. Right now, the intelligence commissioner has to approve or sign off on a ministerial order. What would you say to an amendment that would require judicial oversight? In other words, rather than the intelligence commissioner, having the Federal Court of Canada.... Rather than having to go through judicial review as an extra step, it would go to the Federal Court of Canada in order to approve a ministerial order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118414","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I understand. I'm sorry, but I have to cut my time short with you because I'm down to about 45 seconds. Mr. Nadeau, one of the things you talked about was oversight and people getting caught. Right now, the intelligence commissioner has to approve or sign off on a ministerial order. What would you say to an amendment that would require judicial oversight? In other words, rather than the intelligen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3fc735b8ea85d54be657bafd6d33b1e42b4a8f5c77513de163d3bb18ad8f832"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec650ad5fdb58e9a99af47ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118415,"date":"2026-05-26T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Chair, I'm fine with MP Lloyd going first. He has a train of thought.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118415","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Chair, I'm fine with MP Lloyd going first. He has a train of thought.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d713cba207141b98e3508a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118416,"date":"2026-05-26T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes. I'll intervene just briefly. Given what Mr. Lloyd has reflected on, that his privilege has been breached, and not even as a prima facie breach but as an obvious breach, I would ask, Mr. Chair, if you and the clerk would be able to canvass the Privacy Commissioner's ability to return next week and, in any event, prior to clause-by-clause consideration. I also think the appropriate remedy here is that we do not have amendments close tomorrow. I think it's very obvious that this is the only remedy in what is already a very rushed process. I think this is symptomatic of the fact that we have been moving very quickly. I do not place any blame on the clerk. These things happen. Mistakes happen. We've had four-hour meetings. We're in the midst of another four-hour meeting. I won't say any more. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118416","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes. I'll intervene just briefly. Given what Mr. Lloyd has reflected on, that his privilege has been breached, and not even as a prima facie breach but as an obvious breach, I would ask, Mr. Chair, if you and the clerk would be able to canvass the Privacy Commissioner's ability to return next week and, in any event, prior to clause-by-clause consideration. I also think the appropriate remedy here ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3abfefc82cd8ed50ccaef3bafa797220e87c8b889d952143ccfd37684b91109"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc34737171fff0f58bfc7c415154e05b370a6129ea5aebe048d075e89ac4fa61"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be8c946bcfd3508f949606f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118417,"date":"2026-05-26T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I am concerned, actually, Mr. Chair. This is something I'm thinking about contemporaneously here. Does a question of privilege not need to be dealt with now, at the first possible instance? I would ask that you please consult with the clerk if we need to suspend. It is important that we get this done right, not that we get this done quickly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118417","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am concerned, actually, Mr. Chair. This is something I'm thinking about contemporaneously here. Does a question of privilege not need to be dealt with now, at the first possible instance? I would ask that you please consult with the clerk if we need to suspend. It is important that we get this done right, not that we get this done quickly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5ae88d0a3b5efbd09f094da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118418,"date":"2026-05-26T21:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I have a point of order, please. For a moment there, I thought it was me and the minister with Mr. Ramsay and our witness, but my point of order has to do with Mr. Lloyd's issue of privilege. I've spoken with the clerk. I would ask that the clerk confirm on the record and that you, Mr. Chair, confirm on the record that you did not see the submission from the Privacy Commissioner, and that the clerk, to the best of his knowledge, did not forward it to you. Is it accurate, Mr. Chair, that you did not see the submission from the Privacy Commissioner?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118418","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a point of order, please. For a moment there, I thought it was me and the minister with Mr. Ramsay and our witness, but my point of order has to do with Mr. Lloyd's issue of privilege. I've spoken with the clerk. I would ask that the clerk confirm on the record and that you, Mr. Chair, confirm on the record that you did not see the submission from the Privacy Commissioner, and that the cler","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d8ba272644e028ee11e787b015bf02c27f3649c6453d84757bcc83e1db8b8dac"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff7a09625744c3c10eb80220","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118419,"date":"2026-05-26T21:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"With the greatest of respect, Mr. Chair, we have to decide how we are going to proceed. If you did not receive this or did receive this, that does impact things. All I'm asking of you, Mr. Chair, is for a yes or no on whether you had seen the submission from the Privacy Commissioner.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118419","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"With the greatest of respect, Mr. Chair, we have to decide how we are going to proceed. If you did not receive this or did receive this, that does impact things. All I'm asking of you, Mr. Chair, is for a yes or no on whether you had seen the submission from the Privacy Commissioner.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f43fe2f2b44b8d826a362997","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118420,"date":"2026-05-26T21:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118420","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4536f950cf256e1a68f8d9ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118421,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Mr. Neuenschwander, first of all, thank you for being here, and thank you to all of the witnesses. It's rare to get an engineer with your qualifications here. I feel like we could have a whole hour just with you. Have you been monitoring the committee process on this bill, may I ask?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118421","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Mr. Neuenschwander, first of all, thank you for being here, and thank you to all of the witnesses. It's rare to get an engineer with your qualifications here. I feel like we could have a whole hour just with you. Have you been monitoring the committee process on this bill, may I ask?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8dba6444949661269b326424","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118422,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'll be very direct. My view is that this matter has been quite rushed. There are a lot of questions and things like that. Do you share that perspective?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118422","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll be very direct. My view is that this matter has been quite rushed. There are a lot of questions and things like that. Do you share that perspective?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d222dc23aa6d3390fb1dddc8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118423,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Would it be helpful if the committee had more time to discuss this bill, in your eyes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118423","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Would it be helpful if the committee had more time to discuss this bill, in your eyes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30bfe2cf3082b60b9a00890c4aef0f843f5696ac5cd19dc517f5b9455cb30e85"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea6b3e6e559d44b80bdaf898","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118424,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Israel, can I ask you that same question, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118424","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Israel, can I ask you that same question, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a242fd88cd463b6da098b07637d83054a1e86d651b4c880e5c93c793b47a65d8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca561d3e60cbde4b13f2e5ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118425,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes, I think that this bill is actually much more technical than Bill C-8 because, with Bill C-8, we could understand what different components meant. I think we'll have a witness in the next round who actually talks about what metadata is. We actually haven't gotten into the technical aspects of this. We have largely heard from people like you—people from Google, people from Apple—about their concerns, but we haven't even had time to delve into the technical aspects as to what this encryption means. Is that with respect to all aspects? Is it end-to-end encryption? I'm not an expert on these things, and we haven't heard about that data or about that analysis from experts. I'm quite concerned. Mr. Neuenschwander and Ms. Patell, you can weigh in on this. The minister was equivocal when I asked about encryption. Even though we as Conservatives will be putting forward amendments that will clearly say that encryption will be offside when this bill is studied clause by clause, are you still concerned with respect to this bill touching encrypted technology?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118425","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes, I think that this bill is actually much more technical than Bill C-8 because, with Bill C-8, we could understand what different components meant. I think we'll have a witness in the next round who actually talks about what metadata is. We actually haven't gotten into the technical aspects of this. We have largely heard from people like you—people from Google, people from Apple—about their con","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["49c8862240b73b7df9515a4b0b3606cb08edd9b7ff286e724dfab9bad623915d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0a1acb0a6ed0449ae08d89847c8bb6ac60a99c15785e32ca9af10f318f4ad735"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c72e401a1450b0fba0e4219f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118426,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Ms. Patell, do you have a comment on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118426","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Ms. Patell, do you have a comment on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b676bec9fc2573497c8ed5f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118427,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm going to ask a question on that. One of the issues that I see here is that the government has tried to put in a check and balance in the form of the approval by the intelligence commissioner, though the order would remain secret. I think judicial review is actually the ultimate form of check and balance. W hat do you say to that, either Ms. Charlet or Ms. Patell?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118427","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm going to ask a question on that. One of the issues that I see here is that the government has tried to put in a check and balance in the form of the approval by the intelligence commissioner, though the order would remain secret. I think judicial review is actually the ultimate form of check and balance. W hat do you say to that, either Ms. Charlet or Ms. Patell?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f86099c1fc2e3f46255992c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118428,"date":"2026-05-26T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Along those lines, would you agree....? This is an exercise in comparative legislation and drafting. One of the deficiencies I think we've had in this committee process is that we haven't heard from experts on EU law or on Australian law, where they keep metadata for even longer but I don't know exactly what categories of metadata they're keeping. Do you see it as a deficiency in this study when we don't actually have people from other jurisdictions, which is something that we heard about from the committee process? Would it concern you, as an outside observer, that this committee isn't looking at other models and hasn't heard from witnesses who are experts on other models so that we can compare them in order to get the best possible outcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118428","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Along those lines, would you agree....? This is an exercise in comparative legislation and drafting. One of the deficiencies I think we've had in this committee process is that we haven't heard from experts on EU law or on Australian law, where they keep metadata for even longer but I don't know exactly what categories of metadata they're keeping. Do you see it as a deficiency in this study when w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["08002f118313803ac898b01802f0e4ec2b7bd33d45c382c41a012761ed018fd2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11dae8d4db0969bca782feae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118429,"date":"2026-05-26T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118429","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37e788e029e8b5f9d8223474","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118430,"date":"2026-05-26T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. Happy birthday, Mayor. It's nice to make your acquaintance over Zoom. It's nice to see you again, Commissioner Carrique. I've had the pleasure of meeting you many times. It's nice to see you, Mr. Van Laer. Mr. Van Laer and I worked together on investigations relating to child sexual abuse and exploitation material. One of the reasons that I invited him here and wanted to hear from him is that we haven't heard from anybody yet who has told us what it's like to kick down a door or what metadata you look for when you're doing child sexual abuse investigations. Mr. Van Laer, I'm going to focus my questions on you for the time being. This bill focuses on metadata. Are you familiar with metadata in the context of child sexual abuse material cases and Internet luring cases? I assume you're aware of metadata and how it all works.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118430","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Happy birthday, Mayor. It's nice to make your acquaintance over Zoom. It's nice to see you again, Commissioner Carrique. I've had the pleasure of meeting you many times. It's nice to see you, Mr. Van Laer. Mr. Van Laer and I worked together on investigations relating to child sexual abuse and exploitation material. One of the reasons that I invited him here and wanted to hear from him i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d9b7da322937fc96556b6d38c4a935ec85d44bec46cb8a4b35f028abe32043b1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60a9810289bc3347a3129add2136814a8d21a3bf1de258604bdf652e1cd04c2b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-899e0fc80b83f10427b487ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118431,"date":"2026-05-26T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"This is something you've dealt with on the front lines. Is that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118431","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This is something you've dealt with on the front lines. Is that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e7fe82e074200f852a746002b0b6f708548c7c92fc313ff287621e65839b82c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc1be0cee62b57616ab0250a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118432,"date":"2026-05-26T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes. You've dealt with cases that we may never have heard about, right up to the Amanda Todd case in B.C.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118432","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes. You've dealt with cases that we may never have heard about, right up to the Amanda Todd case in B.C.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child custody","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child custody","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","label":"Child custody","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6d270dacd43bdc58eb5da4ca6ec30f8d8ed7a233fbac166fed38be2d5942b6d2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-164b28506ccd3c86af6eb5ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118433,"date":"2026-05-26T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Does metadata assist in any way on child sexual abuse cases? Can you tell the committee how? We haven't heard anything like that so far.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118433","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does metadata assist in any way on child sexual abuse cases? Can you tell the committee how? We haven't heard anything like that so far.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036011","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Juvenile court","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036011","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Juvenile court","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036011","label":"Juvenile court","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2364c3e94d1226fe5947069ae4f043e93d28d890b370df557cda5c4187d57886"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-365dec47a0a562c43dc3aaa8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118434,"date":"2026-05-26T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Let's say you get an IP address of a suspected child sexual abuser. What do you do from there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118434","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Let's say you get an IP address of a suspected child sexual abuser. What do you do from there?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035978","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Intranets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035978","label":"Intranets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2231e8481e7b039dca68fcb6aaec767e81f5aa139b2f058a3946aa34ea8fc35"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6862269fdcb774be0e112b49","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118435,"date":"2026-05-26T23:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Once you have that information—you've kicked down the door, so to speak, and you've seized a number of things—what's your timeline, then, for investigation? What role might metadata play in identifying and arresting a child predator?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118435","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Once you have that information—you've kicked down the door, so to speak, and you've seized a number of things—what's your timeline, then, for investigation? What role might metadata play in identifying and arresting a child predator?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","label":"Children's literature","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["540a94eba0fe0cc993ccd6fe687cad22ef5e4a27c943215e5a07b84c3129b21b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f21a00dc1784ac814b4d94f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118436,"date":"2026-05-26T23:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"How long does all of this take?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118436","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How long does all of this take?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a817a3a39b4d1a33c8680c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118437,"date":"2026-05-26T23:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"From there, then, is there a use for metadata in an ongoing investigation? I guess that's my question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118437","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"From there, then, is there a use for metadata in an ongoing investigation? I guess that's my question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["721974963c05fd4933a598770600d5bc5a259a6fc492ed5a7aa90ea5f91e050d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b766aa44c58ac7af589bd33b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118438,"date":"2026-05-26T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I believe it's MP Lloyd.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118438","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I believe it's MP Lloyd.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9de03e1a5d320c66b25b374c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118439,"date":"2026-05-26T23:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like to build on what Madame DeBellefeuille just said, Mr. Van Laer, and get your opinion on metadata and timelines. I feel that one thing we are lacking as a committee is piecing together how metadata assists investigations. Are you following me here so far?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118439","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to build on what Madame DeBellefeuille just said, Mr. Van Laer, and get your opinion on metadata and timelines. I feel that one thing we are lacking as a committee is piecing together how metadata assists investigations. Are you following me here so far?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea6fd1f9ced3aca693bb9036739817d4e74f2b7bc7c3761d77e256f2d7796d09"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f565e3f01294264bc385283","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118440,"date":"2026-05-26T23:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Can you comment on that? In what situations would you need metadata for only 30 days, 60 days, 90 days or one year? Can you envision any sort of scenario here? The bill here says that you have to keep metadata for a year. That is an arbitrary number. Why is it a year? I guess what I'm trying to figure out is this: Based on your investigative experience over the course of thousands of investigations, what is your experience as to how long data should be kept?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118440","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Can you comment on that? In what situations would you need metadata for only 30 days, 60 days, 90 days or one year? Can you envision any sort of scenario here? The bill here says that you have to keep metadata for a year. That is an arbitrary number. Why is it a year? I guess what I'm trying to figure out is this: Based on your investigative experience over the course of thousands of investigation","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d88172330d10a6945b884963","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118441,"date":"2026-05-26T23:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"How often are you missing data in your investigations, would you say?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118441","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How often are you missing data in your investigations, would you say?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2761b74734f29ec7924771be64e96a2b2e7c46a181bc2dfe46dee5580d348bfb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f6400abac7e8105246278dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118442,"date":"2026-05-26T23:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Can you give a timeline? Based on your experience, is there a number you can assign to say, \"Look, right now, electronic service providers keep this data for 90 days, and that frequently shuts us out of our investigations\"?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118442","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Can you give a timeline? Based on your experience, is there a number you can assign to say, \"Look, right now, electronic service providers keep this data for 90 days, and that frequently shuts us out of our investigations\"?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56887","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Electronic commerce","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56887","label":"Electronic commerce","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b0aebc762c0016a5e66d26410e12217fd6ea54caa3137b156eac45f25263e551"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["623e371a13018ddfad9337028527755b5f6ade1e69f7eb3afcdb259f63fe8f5e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7f011bc18c6f2e54df8a487","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118443,"date":"2026-05-26T23:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. Commissioner Carrique, you have spoken at length, and very passionately, about the necessity for this bill. As somebody who comes from a prosecutorial background, I understand that. I think one of the main things I'd like to ask you about...and Mayor Brown is free to weigh in on this as well. This is important legislation, but it's equally important that we get it right—for instance, on the \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" versus the \"reasonable grounds to believe\". Would you support the fact that this is complicated stuff? We can't even agree on a number, for instance, for retaining metadata. At some point, we have to delve into this and get it absolutely right. I don't think there's much room for error here. I feel that the process has been rushed on this. Mayor Brown used the word \"dither\". In my life, I have looked at the ceiling at night in investigations where we could not put the person behind the computer. It sucks. At the same time, we as parliamentarians have to make sure we get it right. What do the two of you say to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118443","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Commissioner Carrique, you have spoken at length, and very passionately, about the necessity for this bill. As somebody who comes from a prosecutorial background, I understand that. I think one of the main things I'd like to ask you about...and Mayor Brown is free to weigh in on this as well. This is important legislation, but it's equally important that we get it right—for instance, on the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["21fe5fbecab2bd8726e35d9c3f8fd64d1a274800a493fea5140571cf453e6511"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9912296d0082e39a29238e20ae93bcdb0cb663930cf451607b2f17a7cb07b434"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aeab88d00e17ed22e65cf646","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118444,"date":"2026-05-26T23:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Go ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118444","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Go ahead.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f35dfa86ca200204aa5f2ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118445,"date":"2026-05-27T00:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I want to thank all of the witnesses. Deputy Chief Milinovich, I took heed of what you said. My colleague Ms. Acan asked you a question and you said that it was going to take a lot longer than six minutes, and I understand why. This isn't easy stuff. This is complex stuff: how metadata leads to an offender, how a production order is authorized.... I mean, we haven't even gotten into that. I don't think that even once we've talked about the test for getting a production order. I think Mr. Van Laer did very briefly last time, but we haven't even talked about that here. That's part of the point I've been making. I know that my Liberal colleagues may think I'm a broken record, but the reality is that this is not easy stuff. This is where we have had lawyers come in here and disagree: knowledgeable lawyers, people who have practised law for a great deal of time. I would love to hear more from you. I know that extortion is a huge issue in your area. You and I spoke—I believe it was just last month—and I really appreciate your passion for trying to bring safe streets to the Peel region. I echo that. The thing that stands out for me—and this goes for all of our witnesses here—is that we all want safe streets. We all want to put bad people in jail. We all want people who hurt kids to go to jail and—I can say on this end—for a very long time. I would hope that my Liberal colleagues would join that, yet here we are, on the precipice of having to deal with a bill that has huge ramifications and huge implications. I'm going to ask you just one brief question, Mr. Rankin. Was there one recommendation that you really hoped would have made it in here and didn't?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118445","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I want to thank all of the witnesses. Deputy Chief Milinovich, I took heed of what you said. My colleague Ms. Acan asked you a question and you said that it was going to take a lot longer than six minutes, and I understand why. This isn't easy stuff. This is complex stuff: how metadata leads to an offender, how a production order is authorized.... I mean, we haven't","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:344215","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Young offenders","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:344215","label":"Young offenders","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b2d247a34a884ac87b5c4f2e28dee910956b443acfd74c5d7f82f0b375d84296"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5a57944a60c45a9b74384d38609a0c6280dc7a30e102bea6c05f941830c64f0f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72db2a8f7a2a709108d85f1b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118446,"date":"2026-05-27T00:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Fair enough. Here is the reality, Mr. Chair. My friend and colleague Mr. Powlowski, when he was asking questions, talked about how he was still figuring this out. We are all still figuring this out. That's why I referenced Deputy Chief Milinovich's comment on how much time we have. One theme that I've been stating throughout, and that I've been stating publicly and privately, is that we need more time with this bill. Yes, we've had three meetings. That's not nearly enough. These have been exhausting meetings. They've been going on for four hours. We're into the fourth hour, and we don't know basic things, such as how long metadata should be retained. I don't think we've actually gotten into the technical nature of how metadata leads to an arrest, which leads to a charge, which leads to a conviction. We haven't even touched on that. We have not touched on what the U.K. does, what Australia does, what the EU does or what Sweden does. We've heard it's 10 months, one year or two years. We have not gotten into that. Speaking as somebody who wants to see bad people put behind bars, I know that we have to balance it with getting it right, period. I don't think anybody around this table wants to have legislation that will not stand up constitutionally. For that reason, I will be moving a motion. The clerk has received copies in both English and French, I believe. This should not come as a surprise to any of my colleagues. I think we as Conservatives have been very transparent on this. We have been transparent on the necessity for more meetings. Mr. Chair, as it stands right now—as it stands right now—we are going to hear from witnesses on Thursday, yet amendments are due tomorrow. We will actually be hearing from officials when the deadline for amendments has passed. I checked with Mr. Rankin. I think we should have an hour or two with just him. It's been a major failing of this meeting, alone, that we crammed in 12 excellent witnesses who could probably have had an hour on their own—each one. We crammed them in, sometimes getting only two rounds. With that in mind, I am putting forward this motion: That, in relation to the ongoing study of Bill C-22, an Act respecting lawful access, a) the study be extended to accommodate further examination of Part 2 of the bill which would enact the Supporting Authorized Access to Information Act, provided that the following witnesses appear separately, for at least one hour each: 1. the Minister of Industry, in relation to the impact on electronic service providers and their industry, 2. the Minister responsible for Canada-US Trade, in relation to trade and security implications raised by American lawmakers, 3. the Secretary of State (Combatting Crime); b) the committee receive an additional 8 hours of witness testimony, provided that the committee prioritize another briefing with departmental officials and hearing the testimony of representatives from Signal, NordVPN, OpenMedia, Centre for Free Expression, Canadian Constitution Foundation, Canadian Muslim Public Affairs Council, Migrant Workers Alliance for Change, and the testimony of Glenn Greenwald, Safiyya Ahmad, Noura Aljizawi, Teresa Scassa, and Jane Bailey, in addition to additional testimony deemed relevant by the committee; c) the chair be authorized to seek additional meeting time to accommodate this testimony in a timely manner; d) the deadline for submitting amendments be extended until the testimony outlined in this motion has been received; e) the chair only be authorized to schedule a meeting for the purposes of clause-by-clause consideration of the bill after the witnesses listed in part a) have appeared, and the number of hours of testimony in part b) have been received. Mr. Chair, we owe it to the people who have appeared and who have told us of the necessity for this bill, we owe it to the victims and we owe it to Canadians to get this right and to get this right the first time. That is why I'm moving this motion. I implore my colleagues to accept this motion. Let's get this bill done. Let's explore it, and let's get it done right. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118446","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Fair enough. Here is the reality, Mr. Chair. My friend and colleague Mr. Powlowski, when he was asking questions, talked about how he was still figuring this out. We are all still figuring this out. That's why I referenced Deputy Chief Milinovich's comment on how much time we have. One theme that I've been stating throughout, and that I've been stating publicly and privately, is that we need more ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["784b0a63fea1f5df093fdbcd7dc8d5d5d20b4beadc657b7815660b41e48830ed"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6f9b07530e6995501cab179","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118447,"date":"2026-05-27T00:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"How's that a solution?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118447","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How's that a solution?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69e2f98f5c4c4a6b034c7991","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118448,"date":"2026-05-27T00:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We oppose. It should be on the record so that we—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118448","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We oppose. It should be on the record so that we—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ccc5aeeb4bc66a7bf07451992c6ebc591229f864e2cf6363dc06717800786b3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60fd82cc4345b813395af820","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118449,"date":"2026-05-27T00:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"No, it should be on the record. I think we should—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118449","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"No, it should be on the record. I think we should—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b42bf50ea04d4b414894af9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118450,"date":"2026-05-27T01:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would respectfully ask that we suspend, and then I'll create my intervention once I've seen the motion in writing. I would like to actually see it in writing, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118450","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would respectfully ask that we suspend, and then I'll create my intervention once I've seen the motion in writing. I would like to actually see it in writing, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035674","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hibernation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Authors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035674","label":"Hibernation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","label":"Authors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e84f5ff460beb2ad60526611cc02b473d29c13c3c6d504c5b905f5a7f132565d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-629ada8460339fc78647ee62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118451,"date":"2026-05-27T01:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I thank Mr. Ramsay for the motion, although I think our motion is far superior. Somebody is going to have to explain some logic to me here. Maybe I missed the boat. When I first raised the issue about officials, I did that in what I believe was good faith. It came about through a private conversation where I said that there are some issues here. We heard from officials for one hour on this bill. When we heard from officials in the one hour, we had very few answers to the technical aspects of the bill. I will reiterate: What we have heard so far on this bill doesn't relate to the technical aspects. It relates to the philosophical aspects. Ninety per cent of what we've heard relates to the philosophical aspects. Even when we hear from police officials, they say that they really need this because it will help them track down people who do bad things. Well, okay, but we haven't really gotten into the mechanics of it, if we're being honest. We haven't gotten into the mechanics of it as far as how that happens. I challenged Professor Geist on this. I don't know if anybody remembers. He was here and I asked him about metadata. I asked him what he thought. He said that a year is far too long. He said, \"30 days\". I asked him what he'd say to the fact that there might not even be an investigator after 30 days. Mr. Van Laer talked about that. Sometimes you have to get a production order. Sometimes you don't know these things. He said that whatever you do, it has to be evidence-based. That was his response. Can we say that so far we have figured out what that number should be? We've heard about stuff that's happening elsewhere in the world—in Sweden, it's apparently 10 months, and in Australia, it's apparently two years—and things like that. That is the very reason I think the officials are so vital. We have not gotten into the technical aspects of this, so when we are talking about this, I still think we need to hear from officials a whole lot more. I'm just going to look at this motion here. The amendment deadline goes to 5:30 on Monday. Yes, we hear from witnesses on Thursday the 28th, but we run into the exact same problem: We have amendments due on Monday, we have officials on Tuesday and then we go to clause-by-clause on Thursday. Why are we hearing from officials after amendments are due? I'm saying this rhetorically. I'm not expecting an answer. I think I would get no answer anyway. Mr. Powlowski looks like he's chomping at the bit to give me an answer. He's just mastered this bill in the last 45 minutes or something like that. I don't mean to make light of this. I take him at his word when he says, \"We don't really get this.\" Okay, Ms. Acan really gets the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118451","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I thank Mr. Ramsay for the motion, although I think our motion is far superior. Somebody is going to have to explain some logic to me here. Maybe I missed the boat. When I first raised the issue about officials, I did that in what I believe was good faith. It came about through a private conversation where I said that there are some issues here. We heard from offici","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a880a12c92b3ec6e5336209eff9ebd02a1c7482bc0f312e2291634ba686584f8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c4a978fc031886a88b6b516","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118452,"date":"2026-05-27T01:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I am still processing what is in this bill. As a result, in order to fulfill our obligation as His Majesty's loyal opposition, we should have the right to hear from officials fulsomely before we have to submit amendments. Otherwise, we are essentially going to a glorified clause-by-clause because, in that case, we're going to hear from officials after amendments are in, which we would normally do in a clause-by-clause setting anyway. We're almost postponing the unavoidable. We're not really following a proper process in that. I reiterate that there has been substantial questioning on this bill, and dare I say, from some people, substantial opposition. We heard today that a lot of people are really in favour of this bill. We have a group that is quite in favour of the bill. We have a group that is quite opposed to the bill. Our job is to try to find some middle ground that puts bad people behind bars and ensures that privacy and charter rights are protected. I think everybody around this table would want to see that. How do we do that when we have amendments that are due before we hear from officials? To me, it is eminently reasonable that we would hear from officials before amendments. I don't understand why we wouldn't do it. For instance, let's look at part 1, \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" versus \"reasonable grounds to believe\". We heard about the lower threshold from Commissioner Carrique. The only time we actually talked about reasonable grounds to suspect versus reasonable grounds to believe was when I asked the question. My recollection of reasonable grounds to believe is that a peace officer personally or subjectively believes that an offence has been committed—not suspects—and that the belief is objectively reasonable. That is reasonable grounds to believe, or it was five years ago when I was still practising law.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118452","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am still processing what is in this bill. As a result, in order to fulfill our obligation as His Majesty's loyal opposition, we should have the right to hear from officials fulsomely before we have to submit amendments. Otherwise, we are essentially going to a glorified clause-by-clause because, in that case, we're going to hear from officials after amendments are in, which we would normally do ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","label":"Minorities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d148befd993d2463f92d9ae7251004a802f6ca5a30cfd0a75667e8dc5a05e8fa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c9e161fd86e1f0534078461063d196848a800a3074084a47cacbfe7be2fcb583"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de53e9079de86620969c6772","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118453,"date":"2026-05-27T01:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I still have the floor, Chair—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118453","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I still have the floor, Chair—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6ef94938991a199c3304e2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118454,"date":"2026-05-27T01:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"—unless Ms. Kirkland really wants the floor.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118454","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"—unless Ms. Kirkland really wants the floor.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8fcba7dff3fc1d71e57afd88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035878,"date":"2026-05-27T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister called Beijing Canada's greatest security threat. That was during the election. Despite this, within a year, he signed a memorandum of understanding with Communist China as it relates to security matters. I have been asking for that memorandum of understanding for over five months. The minister and the Prime Minister have refused to disclose it.\n\nWhen will they produce the memorandum of understanding that was signed with Communist China?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035878","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister called Beijing Canada's greatest security threat. That was during the election. Despite this, within a year, he signed a memorandum of understanding with Communist China as it relates to security matters. I have been asking for that memorandum of understanding for over five months. The minister and the Prime Minister have refused to disclose it.\n\nWhen will they prod","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["19c02db1c5d02e519f7623fa78fa6b01a46a97875c6714218373f5bcec25e58e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f70dce0a80b3b56135623f9c2e6dea80bc5e3b49f19f9cabacfa919320756fd1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a736d3094e1dc96b9135053","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035879,"date":"2026-05-27T20:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if the minister wants to talk about history, let us talk about history. When in the past did a Prime Minister call Beijing Canada's greatest security threat, and then within a year sign a memorandum of understanding? Never before had we heard stories of foreign interference to the same degree. Never before had a Prime Minister said exactly what he said.\n\nWhy is he unprepared to shine the light? The Liberals do not want to shine the light and they do not want to inform Canadians. Will they do it today, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035879","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if the minister wants to talk about history, let us talk about history. When in the past did a Prime Minister call Beijing Canada's greatest security threat, and then within a year sign a memorandum of understanding? Never before had we heard stories of foreign interference to the same degree. Never before had a Prime Minister said exactly what he said.\n\nWhy is he unprepared to shine ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["76446da6a37298f2d01474ea92cc7373e51d0f8cd128cc451ae7a50c301bbb29"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ca504ca9d975c1a62e757dab113ea34796001deae93075756504802561a37b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eed4c324a58a45ff8e1b8081","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035874,"date":"2026-05-28T15:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Today I am presenting two petitions. The first is on behalf of the Iranian community in Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI had the opportunity to meet with Vahab Nazeri and many other people from the Iranian community. They point out the oppressive Iranian regime and all that it has done, a terroristic regime that has killed so many people and inflicted so much damage. They are very proud people, but they recognize that since the ayatollahs took over, there has been no democracy.\n\nPetitioners call on the government to recognize the democratic will of the Iranian people and to engage with Crown Prince Reza Pahlavi as the legitimate transitional authority.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035874","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Today I am presenting two petitions. The first is on behalf of the Iranian community in Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\nI had the opportunity to meet with Vahab Nazeri and many other people from the Iranian community. They point out the oppressive Iranian regime and all that it has done, a terroristic regi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05cc35addc129ce5649fc2a3786c47cb427cc381a147c7e8bf185bd81ff33d5e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98db86b908c2456f63557cb4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035875,"date":"2026-05-28T15:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the second petition, which 51 signatories have signed, notes that Canadians travel worldwide for all sorts of reasons, that viruses such as measles are significantly increasing, that when people return home they are often subject to diseases we do not experience here, and that people do not know about travel health advice being available.\n\nPetitioners therefore call upon the House of Commons to integrate travel vaccine, medicine and health education into the public health system in Canada, to establish a reasonable user fee, to ensure appropriate health data collection and to recognize that public trust can be built in travel medicine and screening.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718399","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Infectious diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035875","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the second petition, which 51 signatories have signed, notes that Canadians travel worldwide for all sorts of reasons, that viruses such as measles are significantly increasing, that when people return home they are often subject to diseases we do not experience here, and that people do not know about travel health advice being available.\n\nPetitioners therefore call upon the House o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718399","label":"Infectious diseases"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718399","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Infectious diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718399","label":"Infectious diseases","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["241d011aab5f33bd78ed9aa5c05cefd2b6b48e96d90ca8077b28405a9fd8feb9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718399","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Infectious diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9ee3ecc72e9db2477a1702235359a88ca00aa2bd0f04994570868630a079550b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718399","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Infectious diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718399","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Infectious diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718399","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e747caff37473a1f6207efe3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035876,"date":"2026-05-28T16:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. What I appreciate about this member is not what he says, but with how much volume he says it. I just do not know. We heard 20 minutes of ranting, raving and nothingness, but one of the things that really caught my ear is when he talked about trade and how they are going to get the best deal. \n\nThe government has not been to the negotiating table since October. The reason it has not been to the negotiating table since October is that it is scared of losing another MP or two and having to go to an election when times look good. The Liberals do not want to deal with the United States so that they can run against him rather than run on their disastrous record. Shame on that member. Shame on the government for not going to bat for Canadians. We need a deal. They are not trying to get one. He should be ashamed for that rhetoric in the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035876","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. What I appreciate about this member is not what he says, but with how much volume he says it. I just do not know. We heard 20 minutes of ranting, raving and nothingness, but one of the things that really caught my ear is when he talked about trade and how they are going to get the best deal. \n\nThe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18373e6a723726dfc68c394cc2e5e986fda08f047f65bc180bbb0596b7eaba3a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69b5bf3ac849bc7d787a04297412264cc98a26242cb4c12167f3ae9554e6fc9b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39f472b4639e9d27fdf244fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035877,"date":"2026-05-28T16:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\n I listened to a question just a little while ago. Before I begin, I will try a bit of French here.\n\nI thank my colleague for his speech.\n\nI want to ask my hon. colleague from the Bloc a question. One question that is really central to what we are dealing with is tax and Canadians' being bitten, so to speak, by death by a thousand financial cuts. If we were to listen to the member from Winnipeg, Canadians have never had it so good because the Liberals gave a tax cut to 22 million people. Unfortunately, people are still lining up at food banks in record numbers. They cannot pay their mortgages, cannot pay their rent and cannot afford a seven-dollar head of lettuce. Unfortunately, that does not get into the rhetoric.\n\nI wonder whether my hon. colleague agrees that we need to lower the cost of living, whether we are talking about digital streaming taxes or inflationary spending when it comes to the government. Does he not agree that we need to address what has become a cost of living crisis in this country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035877","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\n I listened to a question just a little while ago. Before I begin, I will try a bit of French here.\n\nI thank my colleague for his speech.\n\nI want to ask my hon. colleague from the Bloc a question. One question that is really central to what we are dealing with is tax and Canadians' being bitten, so","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a6ed68f86c406d70dde7ef41a6564d38ed386a3129ebf240a485316619bb0596"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c7b34b553bf182730f869e309435ab70ad02b4789c4574130c34711ef7aa0052"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c4f8273c3cc88ec977614d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118455,"date":"2026-05-28T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Welcome, Minister. Thank you to all of the witnesses. Through the chair, I will be directing all of my questions to the Minister of Public Safety. Thank you for appearing. Minister, will you extend the study on Bill C-22 , yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118455","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Welcome, Minister. Thank you to all of the witnesses. Through the chair, I will be directing all of my questions to the Minister of Public Safety. Thank you for appearing. Minister, will you extend the study on Bill C-22 , yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3221febccd8508dbec13ff0405eed70324a7952d06f6d6d161486892a15eb31"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c1ac0d39fc0495b42b3879b3cf6500286c9d91606c06813abe1a1724f6eb2b8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-94831d0bfa3c81b7168bdbe3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118456,"date":"2026-05-28T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Then let's not—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118456","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Then let's not—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d9be7cd6b1bfb71b64f9c59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118457,"date":"2026-05-28T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Will you recommend or advocate for that right here and right now, yes or no? Here's your opportunity. Will you advocate for the committee to extend the study on Bill C-22 ? It has been a disaster so far, if we're being honest. Will you extend the study for that reason? Will you advocate for the extension of that study, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118457","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Will you recommend or advocate for that right here and right now, yes or no? Here's your opportunity. Will you advocate for the committee to extend the study on Bill C-22 ? It has been a disaster so far, if we're being honest. Will you extend the study for that reason? Will you advocate for the extension of that study, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72d805065199d98a821da9c9c72d55bf075cc23a0e2d212e491f87d6609ead91"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49102ca4c54a2e5bb01e2a8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118458,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You don't think we should be hearing from the National Council of Canadian Muslims. Is that right, Minister?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118458","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You don't think we should be hearing from the National Council of Canadian Muslims. Is that right, Minister?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdd98aeb1f0fb0bb69dfdef9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118459,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I don't set them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118459","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I don't set them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0172568cd719585dff5ad6a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118460,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister, let's not kid ourselves here. Your government has a majority. You can pretty well do whatever you want. Let's be clear: You could give the direction to your parliamentary secretary to ensure that more people are heard from, like Signal and NordVPN. You won't do that today. You won't advocate for the fact that we should hear from more witnesses. Do I have that right, Minister?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118460","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Minister, let's not kid ourselves here. Your government has a majority. You can pretty well do whatever you want. Let's be clear: You could give the direction to your parliamentary secretary to ensure that more people are heard from, like Signal and NordVPN. You won't do that today. You won't advocate for the fact that we should hear from more witnesses. Do I have that right, Minister?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ba37d6f944efa98da55b142","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118461,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I have a face for radio, Minister. I'm not making any videos over this one. I'm asking questions on behalf of Canadians. This isn't about videos. This is about a bill that your government—in particular, your department—has rolled out. It has been an unmitigated disaster. It's been a disaster on communications. It's been a disaster on content, and it's been a disaster here in committee. We don't need to talk about making videos. All I'm saying is that you're the minister and the buck stops with you. Don't you think we should have more time to study this, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118461","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a face for radio, Minister. I'm not making any videos over this one. I'm asking questions on behalf of Canadians. This isn't about videos. This is about a bill that your government—in particular, your department—has rolled out. It has been an unmitigated disaster. It's been a disaster on communications. It's been a disaster on content, and it's been a disaster here in committee. We don't ne","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbff833748a92aa9e338f012","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118462,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. Let's take that as a no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118462","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Let's take that as a no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9251626142ecc4e2e838633b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118463,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. That's a no. When are you releasing the MOU signed with China on matters of security and intelligence sharing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118463","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. That's a no. When are you releasing the MOU signed with China on matters of security and intelligence sharing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4abdf6bf54c7d8c0ebbdac50e0641143de7aff9304f4fe346c007832ee1251f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7efc2a87efc89225ce2369c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118464,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Was China designated as...? Did we have a foreign interference inquiry in 2010? My timelines must be off here, because things have certainly changed since 2010, Minister, and you and I both know that. Sam Cooper reported that the reason this isn't being released is that China would have to sign off. Does China need to sign off on this, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118464","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Was China designated as...? Did we have a foreign interference inquiry in 2010? My timelines must be off here, because things have certainly changed since 2010, Minister, and you and I both know that. Sam Cooper reported that the reason this isn't being released is that China would have to sign off. Does China need to sign off on this, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4a7fcd46da967fccb1e2891","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118465,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I don't care about 2010, Minister. I care about whether China has to sign off.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118465","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I don't care about 2010, Minister. I care about whether China has to sign off.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e1a6eb04114cb6ad7bfb84b333c12cb1095e3ceb598900d636387587cdb2523"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52df1fdc8a3c68ea4760a466","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118466,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You are answering questions I'm not asking, Minister. I'm going to ask you this: Does China have to sign off on this MOU being released? That's it. Just give a yes or a no, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118466","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You are answering questions I'm not asking, Minister. I'm going to ask you this: Does China have to sign off on this MOU being released? That's it. Just give a yes or a no, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34b2930105392d28f2418d70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118467,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm not asking about conventions, Minister. Please stop answering questions I'm not asking. Does China need to sign off on this MOU being released, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118467","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm not asking about conventions, Minister. Please stop answering questions I'm not asking. Does China need to sign off on this MOU being released, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03b4815cc9050c14812a16e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118468,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"The convention is for China to have to sign off.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118468","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The convention is for China to have to sign off.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["53846d8866030aaa9ed814155d2d0608d703d9453fcf0f511e4bde9adcd6d1ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75bf0de436f17a91701d6a3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118469,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Let's not.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118469","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Let's not.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26a4528c9fa8ee5d0287c1be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118470,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Also, there wasn't a foreign interference inquiry. We had members of Parliament who lost their seats because of foreign interference. That happened under your government's watch, Minister, so please don't lecture me about Stephen Harper and how things have changed. Does that MOU need China's sign-off to get released, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118470","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Also, there wasn't a foreign interference inquiry. We had members of Parliament who lost their seats because of foreign interference. That happened under your government's watch, Minister, so please don't lecture me about Stephen Harper and how things have changed. Does that MOU need China's sign-off to get released, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f43873b21bc14f11a9bc00d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118471,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Sam Cooper got it wrong...?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118471","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Sam Cooper got it wrong...?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d33b1b7bab3ff3c9bed65897","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118472,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Are you saying that Sam Cooper got it wrong and that China doesn't need to sign off on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118472","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Are you saying that Sam Cooper got it wrong and that China doesn't need to sign off on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ba75e22a58884d0495ed6d712d2078bec4bfebc4c2bcf3c74c12a2ec3e3627e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-083036957de4e370cf32b6ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118473,"date":"2026-05-28T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I didn't ask if you've read it. What he posted says that there has to be sign-off from Beijing. You have skirted around this. You can dance all you want, Minister. It's just a simple question, so I'm going to frame it simply. Does Beijing need to sign off on this MOU being released, notwithstanding the prerogative and notwithstanding Stephen Harper? Does Beijing need to sign off, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118473","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I didn't ask if you've read it. What he posted says that there has to be sign-off from Beijing. You have skirted around this. You can dance all you want, Minister. It's just a simple question, so I'm going to frame it simply. Does Beijing need to sign off on this MOU being released, notwithstanding the prerogative and notwithstanding Stephen Harper? Does Beijing need to sign off, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00a94c6fa77ba2222eba9339","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118474,"date":"2026-05-28T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Your government won't be transparent with Canadians. Is that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118474","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Your government won't be transparent with Canadians. Is that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bc2b095ee6ef615befd0ea3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118475,"date":"2026-05-28T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm not playing games.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118475","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm not playing games.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45d9a0c3dbbff4eabeb17646","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118476,"date":"2026-05-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Minister, you earlier said that it is the \"prerogative\" of this government not to release the MOU with China, but you have not once said whether China would have to consent to the MOU being released, regardless of the prerogative. I'm going to be very clear here. I know you don't like yes-or-no answers, but I think this is one of them: Notwithstanding any of that, does China have to approve the releasing of the MOU—yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118476","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Minister, you earlier said that it is the \"prerogative\" of this government not to release the MOU with China, but you have not once said whether China would have to consent to the MOU being released, regardless of the prerogative. I'm going to be very clear here. I know you don't like yes-or-no answers, but I think this is one of them: Notwithstanding any of that, does China ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11fea44d8f83f7b0aa13c2849bbae73ed73ff6f322f0650c0a8bf34c33d13ebf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5af0ae11c583c74d5ed81c96","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118477,"date":"2026-05-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I didn't ask that, Minister.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118477","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I didn't ask that, Minister.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-38871c4a7ad3feb7720790eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118478,"date":"2026-05-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister, I'm not talking about Canada making decisions in its best interests. This is so clear, and you're obfuscating now. Frankly, you and I are both lawyers. I think a judge might find us in contempt if we were obfuscating this way.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118478","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Minister, I'm not talking about Canada making decisions in its best interests. This is so clear, and you're obfuscating now. Frankly, you and I are both lawyers. I think a judge might find us in contempt if we were obfuscating this way.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db3dcfe271ac217907021bd9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118479,"date":"2026-05-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Fair enough—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118479","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Fair enough—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ca643fba4fe87a623267068","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118480,"date":"2026-05-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Well, we're not getting.... The minister wasn't all that offended. I think the minister takes my point. He would be found to be non-responsive. How about that? The minister would be non-responsive. Minister, please be responsive. I am not trying to offend you, but I'm trying to drill down on this because this is darn important. You talk about Canada being a sovereign country. I am not talking about that. I am talking about whether China has to approve the release—not Canada, not sovereignty. Does China have to approve the release, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118480","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, we're not getting.... The minister wasn't all that offended. I think the minister takes my point. He would be found to be non-responsive. How about that? The minister would be non-responsive. Minister, please be responsive. I am not trying to offend you, but I'm trying to drill down on this because this is darn important. You talk about Canada being a sovereign country. I am not talking abou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c63c836e92c43a8d36dea258","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118481,"date":"2026-05-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118481","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Minister—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98daf511693aba371e5f6553","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118482,"date":"2026-05-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"What are you trying to hide here? What is the government trying to hide? You are not coming clean on this, Minister. You're not.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118482","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What are you trying to hide here? What is the government trying to hide? You are not coming clean on this, Minister. You're not.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c0bb6047efeb4c0035b466cf9d8ef569a1a78e1d58e583a2322f8567ea894de"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b84cc43a7678f1ff4e383abf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118483,"date":"2026-05-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"When will you be clear, Minister?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118483","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"When will you be clear, Minister?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a906f0b8ab96b85e2914d36a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118484,"date":"2026-05-28T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You don't like yes-or-no questions, so I'll say this rhetorically because I won't get a yes or no. Did Stephen Harper call China our greatest security threat? No, he did not. I'll answer it for you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118484","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You don't like yes-or-no questions, so I'll say this rhetorically because I won't get a yes or no. Did Stephen Harper call China our greatest security threat? No, he did not. I'll answer it for you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e36a0d150fea0af118007af92d89e781f5871ce342f4d62e78e1babea375493b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a5fab428135cc37c6333c15","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118485,"date":"2026-05-28T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Did we have a foreign interference inquiry under Stephen Harper? No. I'll answer that for you. Transparency demands that this be released. People in the House—let me be clear—people in this chamber potentially lost their seats because of foreign interference. Your Prime Minister , who appointed you and whom you answer to, said that this is the greatest \"security threat\", and within less than a year he signs a secret memorandum of understanding with the very nation that he said was the greatest threat to Canada. Then you come in here, and you won't even tell us—you will not give a clear answer—as to whether they have to sign off. I don't care about Canada.... If it's only about Canada, that's even worse, because then you're not providing the transparency your government has promised. What is it, Minister?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118485","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Did we have a foreign interference inquiry under Stephen Harper? No. I'll answer that for you. Transparency demands that this be released. People in the House—let me be clear—people in this chamber potentially lost their seats because of foreign interference. Your Prime Minister , who appointed you and whom you answer to, said that this is the greatest \"security threat\", and within less than a yea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["19676c057ab62eda9f132075f1a23d05416b1f34a78815465d901cd3bb309215"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["141e7361bbc4ba8fc37ed3b528613a59fa1cf025aafe7d47220d15c69cfdfd9a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40e5d5d4323ebde2ef92198b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118486,"date":"2026-05-28T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Trade...? Trade relations...? This is about intelligence—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118486","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Trade...? Trade relations...? This is about intelligence—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fbc5607bc39ebdb2c91a17b2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118487,"date":"2026-05-28T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. It took us four minutes to get there, unfortunately.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118487","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. It took us four minutes to get there, unfortunately.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae4c469ab4e5048dd2b008d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118488,"date":"2026-05-28T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry. Please say it again. Say what you said.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118488","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry. Please say it again. Say what you said.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c750489f92e2925ae25ec4c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118489,"date":"2026-05-28T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"No, please, let's hear it. Let's hear it, Minister. What did you have to say?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118489","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"No, please, let's hear it. Let's hear it, Minister. What did you have to say?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc37c1c96a581b8e8e637f7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118490,"date":"2026-05-28T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"No, I'm trying to get answers for Canadians. If you don't want to give them, that's your prerogative. With that in mind, I will be giving notice of the following motion: That, an order of the committee do issue for the government to produce the Memorandum of Understanding on Cooperation in Combating Crimes Between the Royal Canadian Mounted Police and the Ministry of Public Security of the People's Republic of China, signed in January 2026, provided that the document be provided to the clerk of the committee, in an unredacted format and in both official languages, within 10 days of the adoption of this motion. This isn't about clips. This is about Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118490","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"No, I'm trying to get answers for Canadians. If you don't want to give them, that's your prerogative. With that in mind, I will be giving notice of the following motion: That, an order of the committee do issue for the government to produce the Memorandum of Understanding on Cooperation in Combating Crimes Between the Royal Canadian Mounted Police and the Ministry of Public Security of the People'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c185fa5770edc87e2e2aef7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118491,"date":"2026-05-28T21:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Deputy Commissioner Larkin, my staff just sent me something here, so I do have to ask you about this. This is from a Global story posted May 21, 2026. You were here for the minister 's remarks, Deputy Commissioner, so you heard him when he said that the release of the MOU was the sole prerogative of the government. Now I'm reading a Global story by Sean Boynton from May 21, 2026. I haven't even read to the end of it yet. This is what it says in the first paragraph: The RCMP says it won't release the full agreement it signed with China's Ministry of Public Security without Beijing agreeing to do so, despite demands from the federal Conservatives and NDP for answers on what it contains. That was seven days ago. I know I'm putting you in a very difficult position here, Deputy Commissioner, in asking you about the RCMP's position on this. If we need to suspend for a few seconds so you can read the story, I'm happy to do that, as long as we extend because this is pretty important. We just had the minister tell us it's the government's prerogative, and it has nothing to do with China. The story goes on to say: \"The RCMP will not unilaterally make public or share the contents of an MOU with a third party without the concurrence of the other party,\" Percival said. \"As such, the RCMP is not releasing the contents of the MOU at this time.\" Clearly the RCMP's viewpoint is that it needs the agreement of a third party. This is what the story says: The statement added that such agreements are \"a very common practice between national law enforcement agencies\" seeking new or enhanced co-operation, and the RCMP has many MOUs in place with agencies around the world. Then it goes on to say: While the full text of many of those MOUs that were signed with China has been released, the one with China's Ministry of Public Security has not. I wish I had seen this before, when we could have asked the minister about it. I understand that you're probably in a terribly difficult position because you haven't seen this. Are you able to comment on this at all, Deputy Commissioner?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118491","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Deputy Commissioner Larkin, my staff just sent me something here, so I do have to ask you about this. This is from a Global story posted May 21, 2026. You were here for the minister 's remarks, Deputy Commissioner, so you heard him when he said that the release of the MOU was the sole prerogative of the government. Now I'm reading a Global story by Sean Boynton from","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52ac5368f0654dd89421150c8d521acf7499d2a8a742511d8e44d4b87d6daffe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ee48a63a708d0a0ec09a3b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118492,"date":"2026-05-28T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. I have your point. Again, I put you on the spot with a tough question, so I appreciate you giving something very quickly. Is there anything classified in the MOU? Is there anything intelligence-related in the MOU?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118492","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I have your point. Again, I put you on the spot with a tough question, so I appreciate you giving something very quickly. Is there anything classified in the MOU? Is there anything intelligence-related in the MOU?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11e73cb217e69e6b7d73139b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118493,"date":"2026-05-28T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry. I'm nearly out of time. I'll leave you with this rhetorically. I don't understand why we would not release something that is as commonplace as this. You just described it as bland. Why would the government not release it? I know you can't answer that, but this really [ Technical difficulty—Editor ].","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118493","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry. I'm nearly out of time. I'll leave you with this rhetorically. I don't understand why we would not release something that is as commonplace as this. You just described it as bland. Why would the government not release it? I know you can't answer that, but this really [ Technical difficulty—Editor ].","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034596","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer science","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034596","label":"Computer science","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","label":"Arms control","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1078c13b622fc5ee01c94ab539286be8232553ea6d6fa272fb2e698a29992965"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dde18e1af42cd1e62ea3febe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118494,"date":"2026-05-28T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the officials here. The government is in the process of drafting amendments. Have any of you seen those amendments?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118494","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the officials here. The government is in the process of drafting amendments. Have any of you seen those amendments?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f1a0babeed57a5bca8abb49332b7db296e04c671c006a1ac7566210ff4b35450"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43b959c4e987b6f5d6ac2b73","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118495,"date":"2026-05-28T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. Are you able to talk about the government amendments that you've seen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118495","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Are you able to talk about the government amendments that you've seen?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e71f6bd4238abe7f2817e82cd46be6070cce55cbfb7f88e0bef23a5564cc3e2b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e43815869f039cb480249b28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118496,"date":"2026-05-28T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'll continue with you, Mr. Bilodeau. You have been attuned to the fact that there's been a great deal of criticism of this bill. You'd agree that much of that has surrounded part 2. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118496","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll continue with you, Mr. Bilodeau. You have been attuned to the fact that there's been a great deal of criticism of this bill. You'd agree that much of that has surrounded part 2. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1852b605582f5e59267d22fde838e1e79a8d81f3dab0d5f52d3c2feac51b4504"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45380ed6cc736076c2b9471e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118497,"date":"2026-05-28T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"If we're being candid, part 2 deals with encryption and the lack of safeguards therein for encryption. Part 2 also leaves nearly everything to a ministerial order that can be secret, and part 2 fails to identify and define the precise categories of metadata. When I say precise categories, it's that metadata being kept for 12 months. Those are just three of the issues. Would you be in a position, Mr. Bilodeau, to make suggestions or to comment on whether this bill could be split along the lines of part 1 and part 2?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118497","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If we're being candid, part 2 deals with encryption and the lack of safeguards therein for encryption. Part 2 also leaves nearly everything to a ministerial order that can be secret, and part 2 fails to identify and define the precise categories of metadata. When I say precise categories, it's that metadata being kept for 12 months. Those are just three of the issues. Would you be in a position, M","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed08891e542baa966d83f610bdf188c22748a104e28ceba53e6214199e8b2926"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61b3ca182286c0822e498756","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118498,"date":"2026-05-28T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"My reading is that a minister could designate a core provider through a ministerial order. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118498","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My reading is that a minister could designate a core provider through a ministerial order. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66c5c8793bf98abccde6ab2ec8ef22bdeb886b61d2cb663f36cfd58b50adc655"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39a068850abc01c2ea4b7b3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118499,"date":"2026-05-28T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. I'm sorry; I was thinking about something else. I'll move on from that. What I'd really like to know about is end-to-end encryption. We all know what that means. A number of companies use encrypted technology. Let's say it's Apple Health or something like that. We could agree that's very personal information that would be contained on your smart phone about your health. I don't think anybody's going to dispute that. It attracts a high expectation of privacy. Let's say that's encrypted. That's different from end-to-end encryption. A company like Signal offers a service that goes from one end to another and nobody can break it. That's end-to-end encryption. What about when data is encrypted as part of the program? If Apple has the key to that encryption, would they not be required to track that data as part of this bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118499","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. I'm sorry; I was thinking about something else. I'll move on from that. What I'd really like to know about is end-to-end encryption. We all know what that means. A number of companies use encrypted technology. Let's say it's Apple Health or something like that. We could agree that's very personal information that would be contained on your smart phone about your health. I don't think anybody","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3d0dc3876c6348b73898caf59f14afa6a152aa13d5e6e36c42ff8ae51f7d1c28"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f4f9931d4aa092e6e27254726e5ad7d5ef1891e0c09a63698f17180059e7bc05"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41d6a7875b34f769bf4da383","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118500,"date":"2026-05-28T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Hypothetically is what I'm getting at.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118500","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Hypothetically is what I'm getting at.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9fb8557cdb4da4ec28ad4607","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118501,"date":"2026-05-28T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"My point though, sir, is this: It could happen. What I'm getting at is that information that is meant to be encrypted and is itself encrypted could be compromised beyond end-to-end encryption. We're not just talking about end-to-end encryption because we were told that would introduce a systemic vulnerability if somebody had to disrupt that. I'm talking about data that is encrypted, but there is nonetheless a road map to it in the provider. What I'm saying and what you're telling me that's of concern is that encryption that is not end-to-end that is provided by the service provider could then be subject to this bill. Do you get where I'm going with this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118501","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My point though, sir, is this: It could happen. What I'm getting at is that information that is meant to be encrypted and is itself encrypted could be compromised beyond end-to-end encryption. We're not just talking about end-to-end encryption because we were told that would introduce a systemic vulnerability if somebody had to disrupt that. I'm talking about data that is encrypted, but there is n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["55d2f6360c890f8b26a632964636a08700ada4ba0130ec343083570c9b27a79f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f96e483a9a88279e114abe1fe51064525295a14952c9df2ff8972fda452a9ebe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-973f84886b175c17821bb28c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118502,"date":"2026-05-28T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Is that not accurate? Basically, what I'm asking is this: Isn't encrypted data still subject to this bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118502","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is that not accurate? Basically, what I'm asking is this: Isn't encrypted data still subject to this bill?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f7b5ad6b1901167fcf484fe5982f0c45b6de79079f5476349fda1e8759130888"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8f87bcbb8130a225ffcfa18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118503,"date":"2026-05-28T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"In this case—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118503","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In this case—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64880837cd778c7b26e4c851","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118504,"date":"2026-05-28T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to pick up on what Mr. Housefather was talking about. I wasn't planning on going into this, but he makes a very good point. If I understand his point correctly, and maybe I don't, what I understand is a general concern. Who says \"substantial likelihood\" or whatever it is? What about a \"possibility\" or \"plausibility\"? If I could make one suggestion or one thought, it's that business hates uncertainty. The uncertainty in this bill is what's driving business to come out so clearly.... Even if it's a possibility, then what a business.... If I'm a business owner or if I'm advising shareholders or whatever and I have uncertainty, and it's \"possibility\" and they say, \"Well, the recourse is that you have judicial review\", well, somebody might disagree with you. What I want to underscore to the officials is that uncertainty is so pronounced here. When you are advising the government, please recognize that. Even with metadata, we don't know what classes of metadata will be preserved for up to a year. A point that's been made here is that we don't need to preserve anything for a full year. Which is it? I get that you want to put it in regulation and I get that it changes, but the act is silent on those things. I'll open it up for comments, and then I have a question on what I had to say. Does anybody have any comments on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118504","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to pick up on what Mr. Housefather was talking about. I wasn't planning on going into this, but he makes a very good point. If I understand his point correctly, and maybe I don't, what I understand is a general concern. Who says \"substantial likelihood\" or whatever it is? What about a \"possibility\" or \"plausibility\"? If I could make one suggestion or one thought, it's ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["357e4e04be6c9bfa31a10c6c5a2aadeadb3e83de803b330358c30d5d858b2e06"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c0391e6f8ecec32382199e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118505,"date":"2026-05-28T23:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm aware of that, but that's precisely my point. We around this table don't know what that's going to look like. I get that's how regulation works, but the uncertainty.... Again, we come back to that word \"uncertainty\", because it's for up to a year. We don't know what type of metadata is going to take priority. We don't know whether location services are going to be there for up to a year. A year is a long time. I understand that the argument has been made that we need this, but no one has asked, \"Why a year?\" That's another point. We have asked about industry standards. Australia has two years. Sweden has 10 months. There are also nuances there, but there's that uncertainty again. Another reason for uncertainty is in proposed section 14, and that is the duty to assist. If I was a business owner, I think that I could rightfully fear this. Does proposed section 14 not conceivably require an electronic service provider to create hardware or software to bring it up to government standards, so to speak, so that the data can be retained? I hope that question is clear.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118505","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm aware of that, but that's precisely my point. We around this table don't know what that's going to look like. I get that's how regulation works, but the uncertainty.... Again, we come back to that word \"uncertainty\", because it's for up to a year. We don't know what type of metadata is going to take priority. We don't know whether location services are going to be there for up to a year. A yea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["357db6305ecf51a91e852ea94c9e53b31cb4b28a30cddb184a9d74e7634ac291"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b768663ee0faab9d1b66636008f45bc94dfb01f7b46204dee316809539305c4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3574d653e6c396d9f7d53f96","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118506,"date":"2026-05-28T23:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You want uniformity there. When we need information, we want to know it's there. I get that, but when I read this, if you're a small ESP, it might cost a million bucks to get up to that level. How do we, as parliamentarians around this table, say, \"I get why you want uniformity\", but when we are sitting around this table, how do we address that for a small ESP? A million dollars might be the smallest amount they have to pay, but that could cripple a company of that size. How do we respond to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118506","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You want uniformity there. When we need information, we want to know it's there. I get that, but when I read this, if you're a small ESP, it might cost a million bucks to get up to that level. How do we, as parliamentarians around this table, say, \"I get why you want uniformity\", but when we are sitting around this table, how do we address that for a small ESP? A million dollars might be the small","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07686de3f5b58aadc21fdda9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118507,"date":"2026-05-28T23:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Therein is the issue. It is the uncertainty right there. Yes, we're going to factor these things in, but even factoring them in, you and I can't decide what that would look like. That uncertainty, I think, is what is driving a number of the questions here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118507","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Therein is the issue. It is the uncertainty right there. Yes, we're going to factor these things in, but even factoring them in, you and I can't decide what that would look like. That uncertainty, I think, is what is driving a number of the questions here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ab10a2be1e9a9e43a391593bde10b931d51ff69bb2df1a3aa6ff8ec0411202d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2100125e4faf956becbf6bec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118508,"date":"2026-06-02T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry. I'm going to speak about this in my time because I think it's very important to speak about it. Mr. Hatfield, I was going to ask questions about section 8, search and seizure and de facto seizures. Just so that I'm clear, Mr. Chair, is it the policy, when a brief is submitted, that translation has to review it, even though it is translated already? Do I have that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118508","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm sorry. I'm going to speak about this in my time because I think it's very important to speak about it. Mr. Hatfield, I was going to ask questions about section 8, search and seizure and de facto seizures. Just so that I'm clear, Mr. Chair, is it the policy, when a brief is submitted, that translation has to review it, even though it is translated already? Do I have that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b978bfc222fd51749cf3699","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118509,"date":"2026-06-02T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. In the interim, though, prior to translation, can it not be disseminated, and then the translated version, the authenticated version...? I'm trying to choose my words carefully, and I'm not trying to cast aspersions or blame. If a brief was submitted two weeks ago by OpenMedia, I guess I'm asking, what was the delay from two weeks ago to now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118509","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. In the interim, though, prior to translation, can it not be disseminated, and then the translated version, the authenticated version...? I'm trying to choose my words carefully, and I'm not trying to cast aspersions or blame. If a brief was submitted two weeks ago by OpenMedia, I guess I'm asking, what was the delay from two weeks ago to now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1af45008bb34efa0cc99f58f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118510,"date":"2026-06-02T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"When are amendments due?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118510","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"When are amendments due?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf938dceefa01ed812fd4457","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118511,"date":"2026-06-02T20:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I guess I'm a bit concerned because we don't know what we don't know as committee members. By that I mean I don't know how many briefs are outstanding. We have submitted our amendments. Obviously, that's on behalf of the Conservative Party. I have to ensure that His Majesty's loyal opposition is properly represented. We know of at least two that are outstanding, and we wouldn't know about this if we were not having this meeting. It seems to me that the appropriate remedy should be to reopen the deadline for amendments. I'm not going to give away our work product, as a lawyer, but I will say that my staff, who have done an excellent job, go through these briefs; they do review them. They do look at amendments, and they do cross-reference them to the point where—I'm not telling tales out of school—there are 70 amendments we've looked at. Mr. Chair, this is a problem, and I'm not sure how we deal with it. With the greatest of respect—and I'm not trying to throw anybody under the bus—if there are not enough resources for translation, and the government wants to have its legislative agenda passed, then you can't exactly have your cake and eat it too by saying, \"Get this done, but we're not going to allocate the resources to get the translation done.\" I will resume my six minutes, if there's anything left. I'm not sure if the clerk can tell us this. What briefs are currently in that translation line, if you will? Does that make sense? What don't we have that has been submitted?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118511","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I guess I'm a bit concerned because we don't know what we don't know as committee members. By that I mean I don't know how many briefs are outstanding. We have submitted our amendments. Obviously, that's on behalf of the Conservative Party. I have to ensure that His Majesty's loyal opposition is properly represented. We know of at least two that are outstanding, and we wouldn't know about this if ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:115951","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trademarks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:115951","label":"Trademarks","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a9f9511c4b118b762668e2f4c46fa04bcc3363c81e3c38405eea897bad1319c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e22c2bead2e1aa9ae22e154","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118512,"date":"2026-06-02T20:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I have to register for the record, Mr. Chair, that we still don't know what briefs are outstanding. What I would like is—and I would hope that all colleagues around the table would say this—before we move to clause-by-clause.... Amendments were already due. We know right now of two briefs that we haven't seen yet. Are there more? I think the committee has a right to know that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118512","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have to register for the record, Mr. Chair, that we still don't know what briefs are outstanding. What I would like is—and I would hope that all colleagues around the table would say this—before we move to clause-by-clause.... Amendments were already due. We know right now of two briefs that we haven't seen yet. Are there more? I think the committee has a right to know that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fea283b75b257aee89d373e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118513,"date":"2026-06-02T20:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"With the greatest respect, Mr. Chair, I would agree with you that if the brief came in yesterday, the day before or even Friday.... These are briefs that came in two weeks ago. Yes, we do have to draw a line. The question is, when should that line be drawn? If a brief is submitted well in advance of the period in which we are considering amendments, I think we are bordering on a privilege issue. I would shudder to think that anybody around this table thinks that.... This is Parliament, for goodness' sake. We shouldn't be waiting two weeks without even knowing if something is there. It doesn't feel right, to be very candid, that briefs are sitting in the queue, we don't know they're sitting in the queue and we're putting forward amendments. The only alternative is then to table-drop amendments after the fact. Perhaps I'll have something more official to say. I'm just thinking out loud here. The fact that I'm not getting point of ordered speaks volumes, although I might get one now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118513","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"With the greatest respect, Mr. Chair, I would agree with you that if the brief came in yesterday, the day before or even Friday.... These are briefs that came in two weeks ago. Yes, we do have to draw a line. The question is, when should that line be drawn? If a brief is submitted well in advance of the period in which we are considering amendments, I think we are bordering on a privilege issue. I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24beee949941dda082a96426","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118514,"date":"2026-06-02T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"With that one minute, let's talk about what we do know. Ms. Saad, I'm a law nerd—full disclosure. You spoke about section 8 of the charter being engaged. My reading of the bill is that the requirement for data retention is on the third party, those who are covered by the bill, and a warrant is then required to access the data. Can you connect the dots for me, please? I'll ask your colleague to do this as well, in terms of whether a warrant is required. I believe, prima facie, that the search is legal if a warrant is required. Can you help us out there on a charter breach? Am I making any sense here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118514","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"With that one minute, let's talk about what we do know. Ms. Saad, I'm a law nerd—full disclosure. You spoke about section 8 of the charter being engaged. My reading of the bill is that the requirement for data retention is on the third party, those who are covered by the bill, and a warrant is then required to access the data. Can you connect the dots for me, please? I'll ask your colleague to do ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","label":"Warrants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","label":"Warrants","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6efde6834214f41ebfa026d0f3294ddad65a6210ad1205d553dc78fb222e1d8f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a16f686e6d89b10953690ee940b69f9635e46477963d97e112e8af18226d6d8f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73994638ce4205e38009da65","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118515,"date":"2026-06-02T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay, so it's the volume of the data—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118515","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay, so it's the volume of the data—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eec8abff28ff954760645358","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118516,"date":"2026-06-02T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"—and it's the fact that the government is compelling that data to be kept. I don't want to put words in your mouth; I just want to make sure—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118516","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"—and it's the fact that the government is compelling that data to be kept. I don't want to put words in your mouth; I just want to make sure—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bdbc8e7cf311cee2d4ec9368dd4b5a97af1c2c930dedba280e8899c67a391aaf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-360b27d0f89ad4c833525034","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118517,"date":"2026-06-02T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Surgenor, do you share that view?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118517","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Surgenor, do you share that view?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a885cf3b481210fc5cff428","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118518,"date":"2026-06-02T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"May I raise a point of order at this point, please, Mr. Chair?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118518","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"May I raise a point of order at this point, please, Mr. Chair?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d62727201bc704e8a6c3614960442895f644031c693712c400b676637a157fec"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-984e1ca3e9517b1cc0dc428b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118519,"date":"2026-06-02T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I didn't know when the rounds were going to be cut off, so I said I would do it when Ms. Kirkland was done. If Mr. Housefather wants his time afterwards, go ahead. We have not yet received a ruling from the chair on Mr. Lloyd's point of privilege. I know that you did circulate an email, which was not from the chair, so we haven't had that yet. Given what we are dealing with now.... Somebody has contacted my office and said their brief also hasn't been translated. It was submitted eight days ago if we take them at their word, which I'm obviously prepared to do, and Mr. Lloyd raised a point of privilege. I wonder if, at the end of Mr. Housefather's round, you could please advise us on that point, because we do need a ruling on that. If there is no ruling, I would be prepared to revive that point of privilege and add my voice to it, given what we've heard today. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118519","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I didn't know when the rounds were going to be cut off, so I said I would do it when Ms. Kirkland was done. If Mr. Housefather wants his time afterwards, go ahead. We have not yet received a ruling from the chair on Mr. Lloyd's point of privilege. I know that you did circulate an email, which was not from the chair, so we haven't had that yet. Given what we are dealing with now.... Somebody has co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12e2f04e5976c29b6055b8f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118520,"date":"2026-06-02T21:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. You can use my time to finish up your opening statement, sir. Go ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118520","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. You can use my time to finish up your opening statement, sir. Go ahead.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["343aa97396962430f8021b72cd203a5d3af7a0d714360950fd0aabb61cb5de01"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35ded8d61c8041f6085a49be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118521,"date":"2026-06-02T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much. One question I have is this. The government has called this bill \"encryption-neutral\", whatever that means. I have no idea what that means. I think it's a little bit of a cute phrase to try to avoid the question. The minister himself has said that they will deal with encryption. Is it even possible to have any amendment that might satisfy you, given how this process has gone? I'm sure you've been observing it. I'm sure you've seen the rushed nature of this process. The fact of the matter is that we probably need more time on this bill. It's not that we haven't spent substantial time. It's that we've crammed so many witnesses into a short period of time that I don't really feel that we heard adequately from witnesses. Number one, would you agree with all of that? Number two, is there anything that could possibly satisfy you with respect to part 2 on your encryption concerns?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118521","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. One question I have is this. The government has called this bill \"encryption-neutral\", whatever that means. I have no idea what that means. I think it's a little bit of a cute phrase to try to avoid the question. The minister himself has said that they will deal with encryption. Is it even possible to have any amendment that might satisfy you, given how this process has gone? ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a40bf6f3430857355d3d503157249f0cfec9fff6a0e3c56714f71bd39ef68fc6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2eb0d4cb7d55447281ed9eda2acedfba7ae7c92daad8debeb31b268bc89b282"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a97db3ac692ecc24b7aaa9d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118522,"date":"2026-06-02T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. For the other two witnesses, I did mention my view that this bill has been quite rushed. I'm not sure if either of you or all three of you were watching earlier, but we've just found out that briefs that were submitted in some cases over a week ago did not make it to committee, and amendments were due yesterday. It's really begging the question of, if we had an amendment or a proposed amendment, whether we could even debate it. I'm just getting a sense from all of you, given all of that, whether this bill feels rushed. I'll start with you, Mr. McSorley. Then we'll go to the two on video, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118522","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. For the other two witnesses, I did mention my view that this bill has been quite rushed. I'm not sure if either of you or all three of you were watching earlier, but we've just found out that briefs that were submitted in some cases over a week ago did not make it to committee, and amendments were due yesterday. It's really begging the question of, if we had an amendment or a proposed a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e8d5241b77d33b5210ceced192925f745c1e74a2069aae019a378b13694735d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a2509cf853b602e1e22cfd3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118523,"date":"2026-06-02T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Do either of you gentlemen on video have anything to add, in 30 seconds, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118523","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do either of you gentlemen on video have anything to add, in 30 seconds, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-435c9dcca82810f8bb8ff234","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118524,"date":"2026-06-02T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry. I have to interrupt you there, sir. I do have to give notice of motion. I'm giving notice of the following motion: That, in relation to the ongoing study of Bill C-22, an Act respecting lawful access: a) the study be extended to accommodate further examination of Part 2 of the bill which would enact the Supporting Authorized Access to Information Act, provided that the following witnesses appear separately, for at least one hour each: i. the Minister of Industry, in relation to the impact on electronic service providers and their industry; ii. the Minister responsible for Canada-U.S. Trade, in relation to trade and security implications raised by American lawmakers; iii. the Secretary of State (Combatting Crime); iv. the Privacy Commissioner; b) the committee receive an additional eight hours of witness testimony, provided that the committee prioritize hearing the testimony of representatives from NordVPN, ProtonVPN, ExpressVPN, Windscribe, DuckDuckGO, Migrant Workers Alliance for Change, British Columbia Civil Liberties Association, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project, Canadian Council for Refugees, Migrant Justice Clinic, International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group, Ontario Council of Agencies Serving Immigrants, Samuelson-Glushko Canadian Internet Policy and Public Interest Clinic, and the testimony of Glenn Greenwald, Safiyya Ahmad, Noura Aljizawi, Brent Arnold, Teresa Scassa, Jane Bailey, Colin Bennett, Ron Deibert, Lex Gill, Pantea Jafari, Michael Karanicolas, Shera Kelly, Kate Robertson, and Maria Vamvalis, in addition to additional testimony deemed relevant by the committee; c) the Chair be authorized to seek additional meeting time to accommodate this testimony in a timely manner; d) the Chair only be authorized to schedule a meeting for the purposes of clause-by-clause consideration of Part 2 of the bill after the witnesses listed in part a) have appeared, and the number of hours of testimony in part b) have been received. That is my motion. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118524","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm sorry. I have to interrupt you there, sir. I do have to give notice of motion. I'm giving notice of the following motion: That, in relation to the ongoing study of Bill C-22, an Act respecting lawful access: a) the study be extended to accommodate further examination of Part 2 of the bill which would enact the Supporting Authorized Access to Information Act, provided that the following witness","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-609f8984eb2af78446d5e689","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118525,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Chair, thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118525","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b275db6bf56a5717efe0184","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118526,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"This is on privilege, and I would like to move the following privilege motion that, given that (a) the Privacy Commissioner provided documentation to the committee in relation to the study of Bill C-22 but that documentation was not distributed to the committee in a timely manner, preventing members from preparing for his appearance and incorporating his recommendations into amendments prior to the original deadline; (b) OpenMedia provided documentation to the committee, but it was not distributed in a timely manner, preventing members from preparing their testimony; and (c) Apple provided a brief to the committee over one week ago, but that documentation has not been provided to the committee ahead of the deadline for amendments; it be resolved that, in the opinion of the committee, the members' privileges have been breached; that the clerk be instructed to compile the relevant facts and evidence; and that those facts and evidence be reported to the House. Mr. Chair, I don't think anybody likes to move a privilege motion, but—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118526","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This is on privilege, and I would like to move the following privilege motion that, given that (a) the Privacy Commissioner provided documentation to the committee in relation to the study of Bill C-22 but that documentation was not distributed to the committee in a timely manner, preventing members from preparing for his appearance and incorporating his recommendations into amendments prior to th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a5490b38556f577e9d9765f3353b7377946f7c1a2d1a93c30ceb1aca4fff19b6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db9ede2a8124d379fc6c816a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118527,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"With all due respect, that was actually with respect to Mr. Lloyd's point of privilege. We have now learned—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118527","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"With all due respect, that was actually with respect to Mr. Lloyd's point of privilege. We have now learned—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81f76d805a5bbabe06854b34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118528,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I have the floor here, please. We have now learned that— An hon. member: No, you don't.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118528","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have the floor here, please. We have now learned that— An hon. member: No, you don't.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cccf869532c18d6815f16619","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118529,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118529","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3eba568789298e17608f543","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118530,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Well, no, this a different point of privilege—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118530","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Well, no, this a different point of privilege—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-edfc9ced82271e2b83acdee8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118531,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes, there is something else I would like to point out: Amendments were due yesterday. That wasn't the case with Mr. Lloyd's point of privilege. We found out that three witnesses who came here today—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118531","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, there is something else I would like to point out: Amendments were due yesterday. That wasn't the case with Mr. Lloyd's point of privilege. We found out that three witnesses who came here today—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ecce4cadada021a3d761aaefe06ef08f8a7c867a02ff8e1d794fcd187d754707"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7624806c4ad9fca6412d530e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118532,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Privilege takes priority over committee business. It is privilege—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118532","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Privilege takes priority over committee business. It is privilege—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33c77df71194d56ccc406b42","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118533,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You did not rule on my matter of privilege.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118533","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You did not rule on my matter of privilege.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04dd00c43708656c0ae0aa0a143693f0606c138f4f15b549fc8b7ddaf2b5548d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d619f30ee585636c11a8a6a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118534,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"This is something new because we were asked to put in amendments yesterday—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118534","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This is something new because we were asked to put in amendments yesterday—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73b2f6c5a07014d5979ae69e56f27a86532fb03617881871be10a34ba2339a81"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54da102efc783e003d5ca4c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118535,"date":"2026-06-02T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I think it should be, but what do you think?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118535","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think it should be, but what do you think?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e37e8df832f889415bd629d693cbdc5c13d11e7feb685e8d399ee6274e82f569"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdb7d505d40257b31e549285","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118536,"date":"2026-06-02T22:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like to respond to that point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118536","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like to respond to that point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d3bf36019cd206717737bcb127ae805899746bf2c1984be1965dbc3c21aa7063"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9600cd6e6ef4bc6685983d2a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118537,"date":"2026-06-02T22:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Chair, so he gets to call—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118537","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, so he gets to call—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a28482cdea0b43a067d12ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118538,"date":"2026-06-02T22:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I understand, but he called it fake.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118538","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand, but he called it fake.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbbb4fa2c459a496b8cf5737","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118539,"date":"2026-06-02T22:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Is this regarding the point of privilege?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118539","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is this regarding the point of privilege?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-180a492d958d0f5e8e7a04af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118540,"date":"2026-06-02T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Nobody has challenged your ruling yet. You cannot challenge your own ruling.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118540","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Nobody has challenged your ruling yet. You cannot challenge your own ruling.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60f5653bc887231cc52fe4cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118541,"date":"2026-06-02T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I will challenge—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118541","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I will challenge—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3452398b95b67116aa16e074","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118542,"date":"2026-06-02T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would ask for the floor, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118542","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would ask for the floor, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a40fe5a9a01ffb341eecaa7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084134,"date":"2026-06-04T15:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\n I served on the veterans affairs committee and was very familiar with the situation of Jess Larochelle. It pains me to know that he will not have seen what should have been bestowed upon him, the Victoria Cross. \n\nI know my colleague had some additional words he wanted to say in French. I wonder if he could enlighten the House with those words.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084134","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\n I served on the veterans affairs committee and was very familiar with the situation of Jess Larochelle. It pains me to know that he will not have seen what should have been bestowed upon him, the Victoria Cross. \n\nI know my colleague had some additional words he wanted to say in French. I wonder i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b104332ead0a9a574748adaf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084135,"date":"2026-06-04T16:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, and it is particularly important to me to rise today on this point. \n\nNumber one, Bailey's law is languishing in the Senate. It should be passed by the Senate tomorrow or today, and I hope the hon. minister will help with that. \n\nNumber two, I have been quoted on this bill, Bill C-16, more times than I can count. The funny thing is that it is on the issue of the safety valve, and I do not think I have given a single speech on the issue of a safety valve on this bill. \n\nThe Liberals, for years, mocked Conservatives when we talked about constitutionality and said that we were out to lunch, so between 2022 and 2024, I spoke about these issues. I did not assert and support government legislation when it came to Bill C-16 and give my imprimatur of approval. I want that to be very, very clear. \n\nIn my comment here, I want to say very clearly that I believe my words have been misconstrued. If my words are going to be stated, the whole context of it should be stated, particularly when I was stating it with respect to sex offences against children, which the government refused to legislate for years and years. \n\nThe last thing is that I would remind the hon. minister that it is not called \"child pornography\"; it is called \"child sexual abuse and exploitation material\".","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084135","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, and it is particularly important to me to rise today on this point. \n\nNumber one, Bailey's law is languishing in the Senate. It should be passed by the Senate tomorrow or today, and I hope the hon. minister will help with that. \n\nNumber two, I have been quoted on this bill, Bill C-16, more times tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","label":"Gender discrimination","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3ca71b7582ef736037e275da521c7373cc6f852a5e681bbcd634763f1a74fba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dffde8383759b1832ecdbb55dc31ccdc2c2c35df92dc713d01ae66a786ccf5a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-370651aa05f3dc2bf8c0c738","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084136,"date":"2026-06-04T18:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I listened with great attention to my colleague's speech, as the person who wrote the bill along and ushered the bill through to change the name of \"child pornography\" to \"child sexual abuse and exploitation material.\" As somebody who prosecuted Internet luring and offences against children, I took a great deal of interest. \n\nOne of the things the member spoke about was homicide of intimates, which was also addressed in Bill C-225, also known as Bailey's law. Bailey's law is at the Senate right now, and it was studied and amended substantially in the House at the request of the government. \n\nI wonder if that member would be prepared to provide an endorsement to state that Bailey's law should be passed forthwith. Bailey McCourt, for whom the bill is named, was tragically killed in a similar situation to the Henderson murder the member spoke about. Her death happened on July 4 last year. Would the member support this bill coming into effect by July 4 this year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084136","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. I listened with great attention to my colleague's speech, as the person who wrote the bill along and ushered the bill through to change the name of \"child pornography\" to \"child sexual abuse and exploitation material.\" As somebody who prosecuted Internet luring and offences against children, I took ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b79eb48c7658a1439cb557a392e7118920b11f514c86e772221d166b46bee37"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0e30d2bf104be585ea88aa2195889e1b20dc9506cbc2363c6a1eca9de52ea004"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e5aaf0d48e2cd43e1aee304","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118543,"date":"2026-06-04T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much. Do we have all the briefs that were submitted translated, Mr. Chair?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118543","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Do we have all the briefs that were submitted translated, Mr. Chair?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth certificates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Birth certificates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:115951","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trademarks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","label":"Birth certificates","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:115951","label":"Trademarks","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["710f0ea2a3fd36b201ffd4967ec69341b8d905ad9d7ee5145b9b2f024a544c76"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bac888a2222bec55b5a69d32","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118544,"date":"2026-06-04T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"To be clear, because this is clause-by-clause, when I say that.... Various organizations and groups have submitted briefs to the committee. Have all those briefs been distributed? If a brief came in, do we have it now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118544","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"To be clear, because this is clause-by-clause, when I say that.... Various organizations and groups have submitted briefs to the committee. Have all those briefs been distributed? If a brief came in, do we have it now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df2f570c38f78aec2fc51449","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118545,"date":"2026-06-04T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That's fair. I understand that. I'm not expecting a brief that came in yesterday to be translated by today. I think it is fair that we know what briefs remain outstanding and what briefs don't. In other words, if a brief was submitted on Monday, hypothetically, do we have it today? If we're going through clause-by-clause and there were submissions made by stakeholders, we should know whether we have those submissions. I hope I'm being clear in what I'm asking for.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118545","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's fair. I understand that. I'm not expecting a brief that came in yesterday to be translated by today. I think it is fair that we know what briefs remain outstanding and what briefs don't. In other words, if a brief was submitted on Monday, hypothetically, do we have it today? If we're going through clause-by-clause and there were submissions made by stakeholders, we should know whether we ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-903b616feb92c1ddd11ae031","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118546,"date":"2026-06-04T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I understand that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118546","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1cf42fe66be4bfa1006fab91","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118547,"date":"2026-06-04T20:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I don't mean to belabour this, and I'm not trying to throw any shade at the clerk. I don't know how you would translate that, but I'm certainly not attempting to do that. We should know when we are going to have that information. We're about to embark on the first amendment. I don't want to hear a stakeholder say, \"I have a point to make on the amendment, and I submitted a brief last Friday. That brief wasn't available, and now you are on the second NDP amendment.\" This is pretty serious. This is the federal legislature and we are dealing with a very contentious bill, with multiple motions on notice. I don't think it's unreasonable for us to know what information remains outstanding before we undertake scrutinizing and potentially changing this bill. A stakeholder may have proposed alternative wording, but we don't even know if they did so. If they did that yesterday, it's not a problem. I get that. If they did that last week or even Monday, however, I think we need to know whether it's outstanding. That's my position. Mr. Chair, I can't tell you how to do your job. I can only give an exhortation. My exhortation is that we have the most fulsome information possible, and that information becomes possible with more information. I'll leave it at that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118547","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I don't mean to belabour this, and I'm not trying to throw any shade at the clerk. I don't know how you would translate that, but I'm certainly not attempting to do that. We should know when we are going to have that information. We're about to embark on the first amendment. I don't want to hear a stakeholder say, \"I have a point to make on the amendment, and I submitted a brief last Friday. That ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["12d28ba0fd65690419ad282106e0bc40d7aa4fdd19380b2df56c659b1aa9fc25"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7ce4cc0604af7cfb82d777396b50f8b862dfa3aff0eedfb6c510b388b23febbf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f92db09da49f07ece680d0bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118548,"date":"2026-06-04T20:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. First of all, I'm a total nerd, especially on this subject. I'm going to give you one of my real-life examples, and we'll see if I'm getting this. What we're talking about here is what is specifically on the system versus what is accessible to the system. Is that accurate? Okay. One of the first cases of Internet luring that I dealt with was a very disgusting individual who was luring children from the Philippines. He was arrested for more substantive charges. Initially, it was a child sexual abuse material investigation. The RCMP got his hard drive and realized that, whoa, he was actually arranging offences in the Philippines. He was then arrested on that offence. In the search incidental to the arrest, a cellphone was recovered, which was contrary to his condition on the original charge that he not possess any electronic devices. The RCMP did a data extraction, with a warrant. Within that data extraction were all sorts of Facebook communications. Am I right to say that those Facebook communications would not be in the phone per se, but accessible to the phone? Is this the type of thing we're dealing with?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118548","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. First of all, I'm a total nerd, especially on this subject. I'm going to give you one of my real-life examples, and we'll see if I'm getting this. What we're talking about here is what is specifically on the system versus what is accessible to the system. Is that accurate? Okay. One of the first cases of Internet luring that I dealt with was a very disgusting individual who was luring c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","label":"Data processing","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d3ca5d9c5dc41dbca8d75298062869e256a627ab0d4abb83d853ee6ef8b17cf1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58b89efc6006b3c1c4ff63bbbe3be832ca3c4cdf44243bb4d000438c000d345b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2180dc20e1cd18f907ec3c73","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118549,"date":"2026-06-04T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Right. My point is that within our devices we probably don't even realize what's there, most of us. For instance, I was just looking up an investment. I won't get into the details of things, but if it looks at my face and says my password is good, it can then access what's on that website. Is the current practice now to say that by having your device, we have access to what your device allows us to get to? In other words, that investment portfolio is password-protected. We get your password, which now gets us in there, but we have a judicial authorization, as in, a judge has said there are reasonable grounds to believe an offence has been committed and that there's evidence to be found in that place. Is that where it gets us? I hope I'm being clear here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118549","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Right. My point is that within our devices we probably don't even realize what's there, most of us. For instance, I was just looking up an investment. I won't get into the details of things, but if it looks at my face and says my password is good, it can then access what's on that website. Is the current practice now to say that by having your device, we have access to what your device allows us t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","label":"Electronic equipment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","label":"Electronic equipment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c02ae0f0eeb3b9946a77faf2e67c2b68a2b46211173f5d5f0e9cd0167ac1b41d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["03fddf52c76c24158834116523f71d3777abac2e8128d6d13a54ca11ef4a8e52"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bbe0d2aceb5322075f3e690","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118550,"date":"2026-06-04T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Otherwise, a nefarious actor could simply store everything off of their phone. Unless you're a digital guru...which there are out there. There are people who are very careful. People who are nefarious are often very careful. This is to prevent somebody from storing everything that is inculpatory, if you will.... If somebody were to store everything inculpatory and you were to seize their phone, if this amendment were to go through, you wouldn't be able to necessarily get the contents of that inculpatory information because it's held elsewhere, \"outside\" of the device. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118550","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Otherwise, a nefarious actor could simply store everything off of their phone. Unless you're a digital guru...which there are out there. There are people who are very careful. People who are nefarious are often very careful. This is to prevent somebody from storing everything that is inculpatory, if you will.... If somebody were to store everything inculpatory and you were to seize their phone, if","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8a0d8ecd9223319819b232a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118551,"date":"2026-06-04T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That's also an interesting point, because there's a body of case law, as I recall, at least in British Columbia, that talks about waiver of charter rights. My understanding—and it's been a number of years—is that one person cannot waive the charter rights over another person's.... If a person has an expectation of privacy in a device and there is joint control of the device, person A can't waive person B's expectation of privacy. Are you with me here so far?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118551","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's also an interesting point, because there's a body of case law, as I recall, at least in British Columbia, that talks about waiver of charter rights. My understanding—and it's been a number of years—is that one person cannot waive the charter rights over another person's.... If a person has an expectation of privacy in a device and there is joint control of the device, person A can't waive p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e03f8d3275767d2e909c4029","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118552,"date":"2026-06-04T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"If this amendment was to not go through, could you have a situation in which there's a joint cloud, if you will, but you're dealing with the question of who has ownership of it? Would that come into effect as an expectation of privacy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118552","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If this amendment was to not go through, could you have a situation in which there's a joint cloud, if you will, but you're dealing with the question of who has ownership of it? Would that come into effect as an expectation of privacy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["702a814ebf80b0b7dc0a15e018bc09126b13ca460e309528e8f644f291b2c6a1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6fc018b689ae04f34bf3db6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118553,"date":"2026-06-04T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. I think I have enough information to make a decision here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118553","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I think I have enough information to make a decision here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65b639a2dbb4f2072af6c6b5d3955bb5486a133eb65d701f6bff13d47d4782da"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-817fc2263e80b63890cb4252","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118554,"date":"2026-06-04T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Could I hear from the officials? One of the things is, \"limited to the class of computer data specified\". Could somebody please give us different types of classes of data? Would that mean that every type of class would have to be enumerated within a warrant? Does that make sense?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118554","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could I hear from the officials? One of the things is, \"limited to the class of computer data specified\". Could somebody please give us different types of classes of data? Would that mean that every type of class would have to be enumerated within a warrant? Does that make sense?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b399d9768b7d4b696bc3ba9452c333fab9a31006f7066ebf3d0a9b8e4ec72ba"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-130e28b470b972a1af4eee6d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118555,"date":"2026-06-04T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Just so I'm clear, that's not what's here, but would this amendment restore that? Would it have to specify every type of data class of information that could be obtained?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118555","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just so I'm clear, that's not what's here, but would this amendment restore that? Would it have to specify every type of data class of information that could be obtained?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f366b05c123f9de3832e7d6bc713870aca6c1e4b3f358c091f9544d95c576027"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c81721c94ac2a17f6706e947","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118556,"date":"2026-06-04T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"In these current circumstances, a judge still has discretion to put parameters on the type of data. It's not the de facto way. Do I have that right? I'm just trying to get that through my head. I'm sorry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118556","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In these current circumstances, a judge still has discretion to put parameters on the type of data. It's not the de facto way. Do I have that right? I'm just trying to get that through my head. I'm sorry.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5684899bdf02d7d9f24ffb19a59eedbd073f5367302e45cdfcedef6e7e0add36"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-265223c8d90130515dd16541","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118557,"date":"2026-06-04T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Would this amendment then narrow the judge's ability to impose those conditions, or would it fetter judicial discretion in any way?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118557","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Would this amendment then narrow the judge's ability to impose those conditions, or would it fetter judicial discretion in any way?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2eecb5ef134c21baef385af9eb5c5bb225012cae8281556e1579be8e22859434"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-927c55163622dce8260984bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118558,"date":"2026-06-04T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Oh, I see. If a provision says that you need to look at X, Y and Z, then the industry practice becomes to include X, Y and Z because, as you said, it's non-exhaustive. If it's non-exhaustive, that means you can, as you said, include anything. From what I'm seeing, there is limited practical benefit that may come, in your point of view, Mr. Wong, but it could add a layer of complexity down the road. I don't want to put words in your mouth. That's just what I'm taking from you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118558","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Oh, I see. If a provision says that you need to look at X, Y and Z, then the industry practice becomes to include X, Y and Z because, as you said, it's non-exhaustive. If it's non-exhaustive, that means you can, as you said, include anything. From what I'm seeing, there is limited practical benefit that may come, in your point of view, Mr. Wong, but it could add a layer of complexity down the road","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-924b622dd607227434e9caf9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118559,"date":"2026-06-04T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. Those are my questions on that provision.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118559","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Those are my questions on that provision.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22435ac7b451e7d155cb45fc665f54be72e01cb13ca68a65bbd279240a6dbe3a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecab3e342a017318b3515f69","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118560,"date":"2026-06-04T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. I note that Ms. DeBellefeuille said Mr. Wong was a model witness. She didn't call me a model parliamentarian, so I'm a bit hurt by that. Voices: Oh, oh! Frank Caputo: I'll move on to more important things. The way we characterize the definitions in this section is actually pretty important. We're early on in the amendments, but this is a very important amendment, in my view, and a very important issue. Right now we're talking about subscriber information that can be sought from a person who provides a service to the public. I think you touched on this. What categories could be included in that \"a person who provides services to the public\"? What could that include, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118560","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I note that Ms. DeBellefeuille said Mr. Wong was a model witness. She didn't call me a model parliamentarian, so I'm a bit hurt by that. Voices: Oh, oh! Frank Caputo: I'll move on to more important things. The way we characterize the definitions in this section is actually pretty important. We're early on in the amendments, but this is a very important amendment, in my view, and a very ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c38d9fe4e5934b82d2d7f8ea5fdfb4dc67acf6df9c4b4dbaf87900a76cd3b492"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f661f8389b2a44e6c7417909","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118561,"date":"2026-06-04T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I take your point about judicial authorization. I think the point that's being attempted to be made.... Perhaps I shouldn't be so bold. The point I will attempt to make is this. As I understand it, we are looking at a streamlined process in order to get information. Law enforcement has said, \"We spend way too long getting really basic information,\" and this is why we use terms like \"confirmation of service demand\" rather than going out and getting things. If, right now, we're looking at confirmation of service, my understanding was that the whole point of that was to streamline the process and, in so streamlining the process, it was to say the privacy interest that is being impugned or questioned is low. Asking, \"Are you a customer? Are you this? Are you that?\" is for the narrow category of service providers, so to speak. I think we were all thinking of the classic being the IP address, \"Are they a customer of Bell?\" When you start talking about streamlining getting information from a hotel, for instance, and things like that, I think that's a lot different. I'm mindful of questions such as, \"Is this person a client of the hotel. Did they stay there or not?\" To me, that's a much different privacy interest being streamlined than just, \"Is this a customer?\" I hope I'm making sense here. How do you respond to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118561","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I take your point about judicial authorization. I think the point that's being attempted to be made.... Perhaps I shouldn't be so bold. The point I will attempt to make is this. As I understand it, we are looking at a streamlined process in order to get information. Law enforcement has said, \"We spend way too long getting really basic information,\" and this is why we use terms like \"confirmation o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eed35cadc60cff42faf5c84e64387cd3369f6aa2611bdd74f86f7b13129c5901"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73f67f92206882cc64551e7bd274723c6868f9ebf013a25d8f08d85e499f3d1d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e773637c54bbee84db90c13e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118562,"date":"2026-06-04T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"What's the different standard? I must be missing that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118562","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What's the different standard? I must be missing that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0136d951112338c8c5c1e29d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118563,"date":"2026-06-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I see what you're saying.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118563","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I see what you're saying.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aaa8a3b108df2cb3918e4147","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118564,"date":"2026-06-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That judicial authorization is done in a streamlined manner. That's the whole point of this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118564","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That judicial authorization is done in a streamlined manner. That's the whole point of this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["146826ff75b9dfd4e25abb275b6fca20fa6fa63b235844c92c86869a2e1a4b3d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99e620e37308e45435c599e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118565,"date":"2026-06-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"There's no prescription in terms of.... How would I put it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118565","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There's no prescription in terms of.... How would I put it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83eaeaae1e49925833572538","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118566,"date":"2026-06-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"It's commensurate with the diminished privacy interest.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118566","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's commensurate with the diminished privacy interest.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34343a53191053d3217e0497","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118567,"date":"2026-06-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We say that there's a reasonable ground to suspect, not a reasonable ground to believe, because we only want your name and address. Law enforcement should be able to get that based on suspicion, because all we're getting is your name and address. If we were getting your personal details, we would need reasonable grounds to believe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118567","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We say that there's a reasonable ground to suspect, not a reasonable ground to believe, because we only want your name and address. Law enforcement should be able to get that based on suspicion, because all we're getting is your name and address. If we were getting your personal details, we would need reasonable grounds to believe.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3b03381980947c4d31c98333e5e5d20272ee52728d4e679820e04f996c0732c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e9bf4c1c2eb27e6875f5dcc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118568,"date":"2026-06-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Within that context—I guess I've spun myself into knots—how does this amendment change things?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118568","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Within that context—I guess I've spun myself into knots—how does this amendment change things?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9e09abf8dc50a1d3830e4ca15a3a20446876ca5d7b82c68e808c23e59464581d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a47c2f260eedd4e3dd9616f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118569,"date":"2026-06-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"If that's the case, if all we're dealing with are telcos, could you not just go and get a production order that says, \"Give me Frank Caputo's name and address from the hotel he stayed at\"? Could you not just do that? What's the difference there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118569","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If that's the case, if all we're dealing with are telcos, could you not just go and get a production order that says, \"Give me Frank Caputo's name and address from the hotel he stayed at\"? Could you not just do that? What's the difference there?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hospitality industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","label":"Hospitality industry","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","label":"Industrial buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b40d58a336ee31f47ebc0240d1669a0fa0d508d2f0f8fe3166ca55059bf31d2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aaff29dbe1814a74c101767c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118570,"date":"2026-06-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"The status quo is a more arduous process. This is trying to—maybe \"streamline\" isn't the right word—simplify it. The concern—I suppose—from the officials is that if we were to accept this amendment, we would be simplifying it in some respects but not in other respects. The status quo would still exist, which is a general warrant to go and search my house. I can't remember the analogy you used.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118570","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The status quo is a more arduous process. This is trying to—maybe \"streamline\" isn't the right word—simplify it. The concern—I suppose—from the officials is that if we were to accept this amendment, we would be simplifying it in some respects but not in other respects. The status quo would still exist, which is a general warrant to go and search my house. I can't remember the analogy you used.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70372a66523da41dc178cedc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118571,"date":"2026-06-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Concrete examples are always helpful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118571","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Concrete examples are always helpful.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9514af16e7ae57a2a2a20dd2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118572,"date":"2026-06-04T21:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"This is interesting to me. We're going to be getting into the reasonable grounds to suspect and reasonable grounds to believe. If I've understood what you're saying, this all comes down to basically taking this down to the lower threshold of reasonable grounds to suspect for a certain class or a certain amount of information. I'm sorry. I know Mr. Housefather was talking about just getting to it. The whole reasonable grounds to suspect and reasonable grounds to believe discussion is going to occupy a fair amount of time of my questioning. I'll tell you that right now. I know what reasonable grounds to believe is. In my view, reasonable grounds to believe is that you personally believe something—which is the subject of the nature of the belief as a police officer—and that belief is objectively reasonable. A reasonable person would also say that you have a basis on which to believe it. Do you agree? It's been a while for me. Okay. Can somebody help me? What does reasonable grounds to suspect mean legally? I just laid out the legal test for reasonable grounds to believe. I don't know what it is for reasonable grounds to suspect. Can someone help us there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118572","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This is interesting to me. We're going to be getting into the reasonable grounds to suspect and reasonable grounds to believe. If I've understood what you're saying, this all comes down to basically taking this down to the lower threshold of reasonable grounds to suspect for a certain class or a certain amount of information. I'm sorry. I know Mr. Housefather was talking about just getting to it. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["58e16e9c3bece3abed43476ca49be3e2f9e5516b87274268c84c18b4c200a3a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5bcebc105dafb8e290959e632d2d0ddaef8f4ebdbdcca6253ab08c5d7489a789"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae9d6164bfe24b71269c0e08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118573,"date":"2026-06-04T21:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That's interesting, because I always thought reasonable grounds to believe was not to the level of a prima facie case. For a prima facie case there is something there that you can get. Maybe I'm just confused because this is a very technical area of law. When I think of something, it's that you have reasonable grounds to believe that an offence has been committed, and is that reasonable? Mr. Wong, if I take your point, we're talking about \"Has something happened? Yes, it may have happened.\" I suppose that's a bit inconsistent with my understanding, but I might be out to lunch on this. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118573","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's interesting, because I always thought reasonable grounds to believe was not to the level of a prima facie case. For a prima facie case there is something there that you can get. Maybe I'm just confused because this is a very technical area of law. When I think of something, it's that you have reasonable grounds to believe that an offence has been committed, and is that reasonable? Mr. Wong,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7c0213f2df2f6dce8f28392","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118574,"date":"2026-06-04T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118574","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35003bb5bf1bbf6039c2277e6c0f62cde386438504efeb3319634e826c8632c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec1085f2085e078790ead500","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118575,"date":"2026-06-04T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I think what this comes down to—if I have it right, and maybe I don't—is that if the Privacy Commissioner says you shouldn't include pseudonyms, that's the recommendation, but the police are saying that including pseudonyms will help them catch criminals. Perhaps I could ask this. Could someone finish the following sentence? Including pseudonyms will help us catch criminals because.... Please, go ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118575","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think what this comes down to—if I have it right, and maybe I don't—is that if the Privacy Commissioner says you shouldn't include pseudonyms, that's the recommendation, but the police are saying that including pseudonyms will help them catch criminals. Perhaps I could ask this. Could someone finish the following sentence? Including pseudonyms will help us catch criminals because.... Please, go ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["48cafa62434ec4f3e4f6f20c7b511083d49f51881321b974174c625a544cf87a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60e2bcee7c3c0db563a42f5187bc9fbba141911ba670da9cad69763eeb8dde9c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8890c00fe00f746598c08c61","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118576,"date":"2026-06-04T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. I think we need to go one step further. I have a great deal of respect for you, Ms. Gibner, and I know you really know your stuff. I understand that criminals use pseudonyms. I don't have a burner account. I'm very proud of that. A lot of politicians do. I do not have any burner accounts with which I attack political opponents. Why are you laughing, Mr. Housefather? Do you?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118576","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. I think we need to go one step further. I have a great deal of respect for you, Ms. Gibner, and I know you really know your stuff. I understand that criminals use pseudonyms. I don't have a burner account. I'm very proud of that. A lot of politicians do. I do not have any burner accounts with which I attack political opponents. Why are you laughing, Mr. Housefather? Do you?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53eaa203f593d8e76c6763a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118577,"date":"2026-06-04T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You didn't know you could have a burner account, Mr. Ramsay. Good grief—I don't know if I buy that. People use burner accounts, obviously, or pseudonyms. Pseudonyms are used in order to not identify yourself, if we're being candid. Is your point that we want pseudonyms simply because that might be akin to a username? \"Frank Caputo, MP\" is my username, but somebody else might use \"Daffy Duck\" as their main thing. Why is that necessary? Why can't we get the person's information without the pseudonym? That would be the logical point. I think I know the answer, but I think we need to flesh that out based on what Ms. Kirkland was getting at. I think that was the point she was trying to get to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118577","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You didn't know you could have a burner account, Mr. Ramsay. Good grief—I don't know if I buy that. People use burner accounts, obviously, or pseudonyms. Pseudonyms are used in order to not identify yourself, if we're being candid. Is your point that we want pseudonyms simply because that might be akin to a username? \"Frank Caputo, MP\" is my username, but somebody else might use \"Daffy Duck\" as th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f0482d613eec8deb7af256adc5de88b3426ce4a5842e15c90917c7fba832d02"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf4d3e630a5683659c13938d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118578,"date":"2026-06-04T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"The evidence would be predicated on connecting the dots. If I take your point correctly, the dots don't get connected if we don't have the information, and the information we need is sometimes in the form of a pseudonym. Is that the point?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118578","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The evidence would be predicated on connecting the dots. If I take your point correctly, the dots don't get connected if we don't have the information, and the information we need is sometimes in the form of a pseudonym. Is that the point?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034502","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cloning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034502","label":"Cloning","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["38afeb41f68f05c2616a1e85e2d965857a24f896a05cac89816f5c7b9c811e8d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-419ba2a328fe97fac3f16457","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118579,"date":"2026-06-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"\"Muscleman Frank\" or something like that is a very good place to start, Sergeant. I'm being facetious here. Let's ask this. What percentage of people in your investigation use it for child luring and things like that? In my experience, a lot of people use pseudonyms, but a lot of people don't. A lot of the time, when you get a report, for instance, that says this is the person, they will have often logged in with their real name or their Facebook is tied to their actual email address that might be frankcaputo@rogers.ca or something like that. Do you get what I'm saying, Sergeant? No, that is not my real email address. You're going to get bounced if you try to email that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118579","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"\"Muscleman Frank\" or something like that is a very good place to start, Sergeant. I'm being facetious here. Let's ask this. What percentage of people in your investigation use it for child luring and things like that? In my experience, a lot of people use pseudonyms, but a lot of people don't. A lot of the time, when you get a report, for instance, that says this is the person, they will have ofte","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-620299b7f20241091c466dbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118580,"date":"2026-06-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That includes Mr. Housefather's burner account. Sergeant Gilkes, can you elaborate on what I've said? How often does it happen that the pseudonym is so important to an investigation that it's absolutely necessary?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118580","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That includes Mr. Housefather's burner account. Sergeant Gilkes, can you elaborate on what I've said? How often does it happen that the pseudonym is so important to an investigation that it's absolutely necessary?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c8dbd0bccfa22bea094799cbe4326d9fd703d206f92901b06338bcfd6197a0c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-634eaf18b5fb9d5790167782","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118581,"date":"2026-06-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Anecdotal is fine, just in your experience.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118581","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Anecdotal is fine, just in your experience.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-011ac36dd3cafd0b800fb64b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118582,"date":"2026-06-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That I can understand. In your experience, is this a frequent thing? People might use a moniker or a name from the past, a reference to gaming, high school, being a good skateboarder or something like that. The question I'm trying to get at is this: In your experience, is that very frequent, sometimes occurring or seldom occurring? That's what I'm trying to get at. Again, you can only speak to your experience. I'm not trying to qualify you as an expert here. What I think the committee is asking for you to explain is how often this happens.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118582","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That I can understand. In your experience, is this a frequent thing? People might use a moniker or a name from the past, a reference to gaming, high school, being a good skateboarder or something like that. The question I'm trying to get at is this: In your experience, is that very frequent, sometimes occurring or seldom occurring? That's what I'm trying to get at. Again, you can only speak to you","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3048003b2d077d271893703d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118583,"date":"2026-06-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That doesn't mean that you couldn't go and get a production order at the higher standard of reasonable grounds to believe for the pseudonym, does it? You're not precluded from doing that. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118583","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That doesn't mean that you couldn't go and get a production order at the higher standard of reasonable grounds to believe for the pseudonym, does it? You're not precluded from doing that. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71de22b134a89949a7f35d84","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118584,"date":"2026-06-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You're saying that because at one point in the investigation, you may not be at reasonable grounds to believe. You may still be at the lower threshold. Is that accurate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118584","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You're saying that because at one point in the investigation, you may not be at reasonable grounds to believe. You may still be at the lower threshold. Is that accurate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a89b93747dced417e2d4cb6bcd92e39f21fbf9f99c14a806bced076f67a3232f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a43e5b75d0baf2d6ba89f84d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118585,"date":"2026-06-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"This is all about grounds and the difficulty with grounds—or much of this is, really.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118585","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This is all about grounds and the difficulty with grounds—or much of this is, really.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2142beccec5312e2ecbeaa9e9ebbb0387178f970641da361ff453ffde0398a4b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50f56dd1401c0a58113b73f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118586,"date":"2026-06-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"It's interesting because the reasonable grounds to suspect, which Mr. Wong told us about earlier, and the reasonable grounds to believe are common law doctrines. Forgive me and tell me if I'm wrong, but none of that.... Is that anywhere in the legislation? When I gave that definition of reasonable grounds to believe, that was my recollection from a case called Storrey, which is from the mid-1990s about whether you have grounds to arrest. Is that enumerated anywhere in law? I'm not going to look at you, Sergeant Gilkes. Maybe that's something we as Parliament should actually be addressing. If we're talking about grounds to suspect and grounds to believe, the common law can change. Maybe this is something—I'm just thinking out loud—that we as parliamentarians should be considering: whether we need to codify what these grounds actually mean. That may be neither here nor there. I'm sure Mr. Mantle has far more interesting things to say than I do, so I'll pass the floor to him.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118586","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's interesting because the reasonable grounds to suspect, which Mr. Wong told us about earlier, and the reasonable grounds to believe are common law doctrines. Forgive me and tell me if I'm wrong, but none of that.... Is that anywhere in the legislation? When I gave that definition of reasonable grounds to believe, that was my recollection from a case called Storrey, which is from the mid-1990s ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95c952829f0e0b17761c03a3d234888f8c4ce0de63f006e1c683d6caff208f66"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bccffa1f5e2f5645cd9bf906","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118587,"date":"2026-06-04T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I have a point of order, Mr. Chair Just to elaborate on that, when we are no longer considering this clause, can Ms. Kirkland then move her UC motion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118587","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Mr. Chair Just to elaborate on that, when we are no longer considering this clause, can Ms. Kirkland then move her UC motion?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3573568f873b89181edd57aed09d659802d1926289a747eaeb461cd93faaa51"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f3f25b4a7bd950f8ccf22d57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118588,"date":"2026-06-04T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay, so her motion cannot be moved at any time throughout this meeting.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118588","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay, so her motion cannot be moved at any time throughout this meeting.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0c8ce7925a0de72dbecd24b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086106,"date":"2026-06-09T15:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved:\n\nThat it be an instruction to the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security that, during its consideration of Bill C-22, An Act respecting lawful access:\n\n(a) the committee be granted the power to divide the bill into two pieces of legislation:\n\n(i) Bill C-22A, An Act respecting Timely Access to Data and Information, containing Part 1,\n\n(ii) Bill C-22B, An Act respecting lawful access, containing the remaining parts of Bill C-22; and\n\n(b) that Bill C-22A be reported back to the House no later than five sitting days following the adoption of this motion.\n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086106","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"moved:\n\nThat it be an instruction to the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security that, during its consideration of Bill C-22, An Act respecting lawful access:\n\n(a) the committee be granted the power to divide the bill into two pieces of legislation:\n\n(i) Bill C-22A, An Act respecting Timely Access to Data and Information, containing Part 1,\n\n(ii) Bill C-22B, An Act respecting law","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1035928289be9eeebfd56aad6c8e4308e48ee976693089e19ccc71361ff80254"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb2c9880f07cc7c3432cbd6f50ae9dd8fdeb048460bbe2841855b0caa96ad3e3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0061e934f36a63e8d7b4e2d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086107,"date":"2026-06-09T15:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just learned that if I pause for a brief second before it is time to talk, my colleagues will clap. I feel like a professional wrestler who pauses for people to cheer them on. I thank my colleagues for clapping. I wish I had that power when I was out on the street. I would simply pause, wait and listen, and people would clap. I thank my colleagues for edifying me in that way.\n\n It is always a pleasure to rise in this House, but it is a particular pleasure to rise with respect to this motion. I am going to read my motion into the record and expand on it for the next few minutes, because I believe it is an important motion. The motion states:\n\nThat it be an instruction to the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security that, during its consideration of Bill C-22, An Act respecting lawful access:\n\n(a) the committee be granted the power to divide the bill into two pieces of legislation:\n\n(i) Bill C-22A, An Act respecting Timely Access to Data and Information, containing Part 1,\n\n(ii) Bill C-22B, An Act respecting lawful access, containing the remaining parts of Bill C-22; and\n\n(b) that Bill C-22A be reported back to the House no later than five sitting days following the adoption of this motion.\n\nBefore I begin, I want to recognize that my niece was recently engaged. I want to give a shout-out to my niece, Juliana Bradley, and her new fiancé, Dayton Vidovich. I wish them happy nuptials as they set a date. I am very proud to be an uncle to Juliana. We are very proud of the young woman she has become. She is a force in her world as she navigates adulthood, and she is doing so well. We are so proud of her and Dayton, and I wish them all the best in their engagement.\n\n I am going to begin my remarks by speaking to law enforcement and Canadians generally. Conservatives believe law enforcement has not had the appropriate tools to fight crime. I look back on Bill C-5, for instance, which was passed here when then Minister Lametti justified people getting house arrest for drive-by shootings. That was just last Parliament. The Liberals will come in here and say they are tough on crime, yet that law still stands. For extortions with a firearm, drive-by shootings and robberies with a firearm, a person can serve their sentence on house arrest. This narrative the Liberals are pushing about how they are tough on crime and the Conservatives are not is simply untrue.\n\n It has always given me great pleasure to speak in the House. Speaking for the next few minutes on a bill I have devoted substantial time to is something I have looked forward to. With that, I know there is another colleague of mine who has spent a fair amount of time on this. That is the member for York—Durham, with whom I will be splitting my time.\n\nWhere does that leave us? It leaves us needing to have an appropriate lawful access regime that gives law enforcement the tools it needs and also, and this is the big also, respects the charter rights and privacy rights of Canadians. I believe that needle can be threaded. It is the government that drafts this legislation. It is the government that has to convince Canadians that the needle has been threaded. Thus far, when it comes to the committee, the government, to be very candid, has failed.\n\nFor those who do not know a lot about this bill, there are two parts. Part 1 is not all that contentious. Part 1 looks at a confirmation of subscriber information and a streamlined mechanism to get production orders.\n\nThere is a bit of controversy around whether that should be on the threshold of what is called reasonable grounds to believe or of what is called reasonable grounds to suspect. Reasonable grounds to believe is when a police officer has reasonable grounds to believe a crime has been committed and there is evidence present in the records or the place. Reasonable grounds to suspect is, I believe, above a hunch but below that belief, which we call a subjective belief in law. Witnesses have said there are charter considerations under section 8, and if we go to the reasonable grounds to suspect, it might be too low of a threshold. The government has attempted to make the case that there is a limited body of information that would be produced, hence the lower threshold.\n\nI believe we will get through this at committee. The Conservatives have put forward a number of amendments. My colleagues from the NDP and the Bloc have also put forward a number of amendments. That is not the contentious issue. I believe this would be very helpful to law enforcement. Law enforcement has told us this. Right now, law enforcement often has to go on a fishing expedition, going to provider after provider.\n\n I will be very clear. I will be sending a letter to the public safety minister very shortly, saying the Conservatives are prepared to pass part 1 once we get through clause-by-clause. I hope that is sufficiently clear.\n\nMy exhortation to the government is to take what we have so far and give it to law enforcement, because part 2 is highly contentious. I understand that law enforcement has asked for part 2, but in the committee's clause-by-clause process of part 2, the government has failed to convince Canadians that the lawful access regime it has put forward would balance the tools that are required with the charter and privacy rights of Canadians. That is where we stand.\n\n In fact, the government thought it could just ram this through committee. One of my greatest issues with this is how little time there has been. The Liberals may say we have studied this for quite some time, but here is the problem. This is a very contentious and technical bill. We had panels of experts, sometimes with three experts per panel, who gave five-minute opening statements, and then we were all expected to question these experts over a one-hour period. We had literally 45 minutes with three experts. That meant we were not really able to flesh out the details.\n\nSo far, the government has said we need this bill because it wants to catch people who are committing nefarious acts. No one will ever hear me saying we do not want to catch terrorists or child predators. I have spent much of my life on the latter issue. However, we need to catch them in a way that is constitutional, whereby the government does not ask us to give it this, \"just because\". The government failed to come to the committee table, say precisely what we need and why, and tell us how it is going to balance those charter rights.\n\nLet us pass part 1 to give law enforcement those powers.\n\nAt the end of the day, we have spent a great deal of time on this, but we need more time on Bill C-22. I think we should be recalling witnesses. The fact is that we had so little time. We often had three experts on a panel. I would maybe get six minutes, and I am the lead critic on this. That was not enough.\n\nI see my time has come to an end. I will now take questions and comments from my colleagues.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086107","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I just learned that if I pause for a brief second before it is time to talk, my colleagues will clap. I feel like a professional wrestler who pauses for people to cheer them on. I thank my colleagues for clapping. I wish I had that power when I was out on the street. I would simply pause, wait and listen, and people would clap. I thank my colleagues for edifying me in that way.\n\n It is always a pl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5875cc55c00704d5ad84ffb111ceedfbc6a44d33b4608ef2b6863ff37892d865"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6b3976bd996576f03ed7eddef33371ed02ce1540c7bcb43d115b7d2689ce829e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56a34f99badb4407e0517b84","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086108,"date":"2026-06-09T15:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I wish I could take the member to law school for one seminar, because he pontificates like a lawyer and tries to sound like a lawyer, but—\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nFrank Caputo: Oh, he is smarter than a lawyer. Okay, great. Thanks for that heckle from across the way.\n\nMadam Speaker, even the member does not agree. Anybody watching at home cannot hear this, but the member is saying, \"I am?\"\n\n The government members cannot sit here and say that they have been tough on crime. Someone could still get house arrest for a drive-by shooting, I will remind the member.\n\nWhat the member did not talk about is what is in the bill. This is exactly the trap the Liberals have fallen into: Give us this, and to heck with the charter and with concerns of Canadians. This is the arrogance of the Liberal Party, and that is why Bill C‐22 is where it is at.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086108","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I wish I could take the member to law school for one seminar, because he pontificates like a lawyer and tries to sound like a lawyer, but—\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nFrank Caputo: Oh, he is smarter than a lawyer. Okay, great. Thanks for that heckle from across the way.\n\nMadam Speaker, even the member does not agree. Anybody watching at home cannot hear this, but the member is saying,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["776cfbbdba9015456f72070bda63b205aeb18fff9388afa63c1e23ac450b95c8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44be83eec2ec27bed3a1c87b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086109,"date":"2026-06-09T15:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, let us talk about Bill C‐75. The member across the way from Winnipeg talks about being tough on crime as Liberals, but there is more. If someone is accused of an offence, Bill C‐75 says they get bail on the least restrictive conditions at the earliest possible opportunity. Why will the member not rise—\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nFrank Caputo: Madam Speaker, he said that was pre-this government.\n\nWho is in power now? It is the current Liberal government. Who is not acting on Bill C‐75? It is the Liberal government. Who is allowing the status quo to be maintained on Bill C‐75 with a majority? It is the Liberal government. Spare us the rhetoric on Bill C‐75's being tough on crime, until the government is prepared to deal with the least onerous measures bail provisions in Bill C‐75.\n\nThe member should take a seat, because we put forward legislation on this, the jail not bail act. The Liberals voted against it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086109","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, let us talk about Bill C‐75. The member across the way from Winnipeg talks about being tough on crime as Liberals, but there is more. If someone is accused of an offence, Bill C‐75 says they get bail on the least restrictive conditions at the earliest possible opportunity. Why will the member not rise—\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nFrank Caputo: Madam Speaker, he said that was pre-this ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b5f3b704b73b4ca13a186d4d4a8b1efd0b96f908b822d21377c59fab8ab8f9de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c2073c2032228ea1be591b933f4f61b6570e22105428d4f38c6b41000856378"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b773aba846cd9edb7a252af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086110,"date":"2026-06-09T15:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am so glad to have received that comment, because, get this, amendments were due on Bill C‐22, but we did not have briefings. There were actually multiple briefings that were not provided to the committee. Witnesses came to committee, for my hon. colleague's edification, saying that they had submitted a brief days ago. We looked around, and I asked my staff, \"Did we get that?\" They said no. Then I asked the clerk if we had received it, and the answer was no.\n\nThe member talks about briefings, but we did not even have those briefings. It speaks to how quickly this was rushed. We need to slow it down, pass part 1 and leave part 2.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086110","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am so glad to have received that comment, because, get this, amendments were due on Bill C‐22, but we did not have briefings. There were actually multiple briefings that were not provided to the committee. Witnesses came to committee, for my hon. colleague's edification, saying that they had submitted a brief days ago. We looked around, and I asked my staff, \"Did we get that?\" The","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3db7a755d38dd26db3316b71","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086111,"date":"2026-06-09T16:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Those watching at home may not realize this, but MPs have a mechanism by which we can contact one another directly. I sent the minister three emails directly. Candidly, I have sent notes to other ministers and they respond typically within 12 to 24 hours. It shows respect among ministers and members of Parliament to do that. Not once has he responded.\n\nWhat kind of example is the minister setting, as a minister of the Crown, when he cannot even respond to notes from another member of Parliament?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086111","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Those watching at home may not realize this, but MPs have a mechanism by which we can contact one another directly. I sent the minister three emails directly. Candidly, I have sent notes to other ministers and they respond typically within 12 to 24 hours. It shows respect among ministers and membe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c868e3653aa134d1010ef6287017539e57e587b4a08dad94e84ffbd36740e192"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-643055ad425d2b6403d14069","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118589,"date":"2026-06-09T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We are already having extended sitting hours. The last time I checked, I think we are currently sitting for four hours. I'm not sure how fair it is to the staff or to other people here. The reality is that the extended sitting hours were necessitated by ramming this bill through. We had witnesses—often three experts to a panel—and we couldn't even hear from those experts. The reality is that the Liberals have tried to ram this bill through, especially when it comes to part 2. I wrote a letter to the Minister of Public Safety today that has been publicly released. Law enforcement has spoken about two parts. There is part 1 and part 2. Conservatives are prepared to pass part 1 as amended. If I'm prepared to take my colleague Mr. Ramsay at his word, which I am, then we can get part 1 dealt with before we rise. Conservatives will amend part 1. I believe we should amend it, and I hope we will find common ground on some of our amendments. I think that among the Bloc, the NDP and the Conservatives, you see a similar thread running through. If the whole point of this exercise is to get the bill right—and we take what Mr. Ramsay had to say as true—and law enforcement wants what's in this bill, I would hope they would want part of what is in this bill. My exhortation and my suggestion to the government.... I would love to hear from the witnesses on this point, but I know they can't opine outside of questions that are provided to them. The reality is that I think we can give them part 1. I believe that law enforcement has asked for part 1. Then the government can go back to the drawing board on part 2, or we can have further study on part 2. I haven't heard from the government that they are prepared to accept part 1. We will give them part 1—I want to be unequivocally clear—so long as appropriate amendments are made to part 1. I am really puzzled as to why there has not been agreement to say to the Conservatives and Bloc that we should get through part 1, amend it, look at that standard of reasonable grounds to believe versus reasonable grounds to suspect, and split that off. In fact, I had a motion in the chamber today to divide this bill into 22A and 22B. If law enforcement wants part 1 and if one of the issues we have is the confirmation of subscriber information and a streamlined process for production orders, which means there's a court order, can somebody tell me why we wouldn't give that to law enforcement sooner rather than later, if we can come to common ground, which I believe we can, notwithstanding that we still have to go through the process? If we can get through that, why wouldn't we? I hope I'm not jumping the gun here, but I'd love to hear from the officials on whether they would take part 1 if we could get it passed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118589","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We are already having extended sitting hours. The last time I checked, I think we are currently sitting for four hours. I'm not sure how fair it is to the staff or to other people here. The reality is that the extended sitting hours were necessitated by ramming this bill through. We had witnesses—often three experts to a panel—and we couldn't even hear from those experts. The reality is that the L","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["68475e8f990da93ebc007d25839721bf8c02357266b8453f5ca32e513c3c8a28"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-459bf2e7d3ed734cdc39774c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118590,"date":"2026-06-09T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. I have one housekeeping issue. I want to double-check. Do we know whether we have all the briefs that have been submitted at this point?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118590","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I have one housekeeping issue. I want to double-check. Do we know whether we have all the briefs that have been submitted at this point?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da4e44156f20056395bd5604027463247b3f9c081f906b424421c112271be183"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-768064352b03f57a77fd7932","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118591,"date":"2026-06-09T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. I was just double-checking. Thank you very much. Could I be on the speaking list and move on to the subamendment, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118591","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. I was just double-checking. Thank you very much. Could I be on the speaking list and move on to the subamendment, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["230565d97813886152e85ab4270fe2aced75fa513078a24283bb10e691c6c249"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b177d6c2d344d0c746035eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118592,"date":"2026-06-09T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to ask the whole table about this. You heard my initial monologue, if you will. I won't call it a soliloquy. It did talk about part 1, and we are talking about subamending part 1. Within the whole issue of getting through this bill, I think all the officials here would agree that the issue of lawful access has come before Parliament many times, most notably in 2014, I believe. It has now been 12 years. The Internet has changed substantially. I'm not going to ask every person to go through this one more time, but my impression is that from an official's point of view, speaking objectively, there is a need for lawful access. That's why we're all here. That's what we have been told. That's why we had a number of people from your agencies come to committee and tell us that we need the powers that are in this bill. We have parted company, obviously, on the precise powers that are in the bill and whether those should be granted in the form of legislation or whether those should be tweaked or not. At the end of the day, it has been very clear from officials and from witnesses that the current state of crime and the evolution of technology require new tools. I think there's no doubt about that. Where I think we haven't gotten into the meat and potatoes is the \"why\". We've been told, \"We want to catch terrorists and want to catch predators.\" It is the job of the government to convince Canadians. It is not the job of the opposition. The job of the opposition is to scrutinize and to ask questions on behalf of Canadians. That's where I think part 2 has really broken down. Would any of the witnesses be prepared to say that, yes, part 1 is integral to what we do, and these are powers that we need sooner rather than later? Is anybody prepared to acknowledge that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118592","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to ask the whole table about this. You heard my initial monologue, if you will. I won't call it a soliloquy. It did talk about part 1, and we are talking about subamending part 1. Within the whole issue of getting through this bill, I think all the officials here would agree that the issue of lawful access has come before Parliament many times, most notably in 20","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b2360a6f8dfafc9a27de9e181babe5917d39659a0eb5d1ea738e15228aa74421"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3e916639b365e1cf3235a4283cc537c99b62f76c4f494c358d0af4460c91db2c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd44985754dac51b490e08ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118593,"date":"2026-06-09T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I am mindful of that. Part 2 aims at solving crime, and I understand that. I don't think anybody around this table is saying, boy, we want more crime. The question is about getting it right. To Mr. Bilodeau and to all the other witnesses, we have heard from so many witnesses. Frankly, not enough time was given to them because sometimes we had three experts on a panel. If you have an opening statement of five minutes each, that's 15 minutes, and that leaves 45 minutes for questions and answers, sometimes with three outstanding witnesses. Really, we could have had one of them, so we didn't always hear the in-depth knowledge. I sound like a broken record, I know, but I think the chief issue here that we are dealing with is that we didn't get a lot of the technical information. We were told that we needed this, and Mayor Brown touched on that. We need this because we want to catch criminals. I get that, and we get that, but how does proposed subsection 5.2 relate to that? How does the ministerial order relate to that? How do the different categories of metadata relate to that? How do location services relate to that without intruding on privacy, notwithstanding the requirement for a court order? Those are all very live issues in part 2 that I don't think we really dealt with. I apologize. This might not seem like a fair question, but I think it's an apposite question. If given the choice of having part 1 or nothing, I assume the officials would say that we need the powers in part 1. Is that an accurate statement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118593","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I am mindful of that. Part 2 aims at solving crime, and I understand that. I don't think anybody around this table is saying, boy, we want more crime. The question is about getting it right. To Mr. Bilodeau and to all the other witnesses, we have heard from so many witnesses. Frankly, not enough time was given to them because sometimes we had three experts on a panel. If you have an opening statem","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dab0924b31914605914a286ae994f5186ea6f9a3b9c377e6d1441793f3f5336c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6ed130c24472ea99b6e7e91e89d5a92b16fe8d47831a46d713af18d6691b8788"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8932ac24cf140857d039485f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118594,"date":"2026-06-09T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I get that, Mr. Bilodeau, and I'm not trying to put you in a corner. Officials are presumed independent. I understand that, and I still know you all have your own views. I am somebody whose professional life, frankly, revolved around data and its existence or lack of existence and how that created an evidentiary chain or an evidentiary gap, because that was just the way it went. When you had an evidentiary chain, you had a prosecution and a potential conviction. When you had an evidentiary gap, you didn't have an arrest or charges typically. I'm very mindful of that. The point I'm trying to get to is that if part 1 is important, and I know you can't say this or it seems that you can't—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118594","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I get that, Mr. Bilodeau, and I'm not trying to put you in a corner. Officials are presumed independent. I understand that, and I still know you all have your own views. I am somebody whose professional life, frankly, revolved around data and its existence or lack of existence and how that created an evidentiary chain or an evidentiary gap, because that was just the way it went. When you had an ev","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae971ef19c752357838ee97a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118595,"date":"2026-06-09T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"If part 1 is important, then why aren't we passing a piece of important legislation? Can anybody weigh in on whether part 1 would help if it were passed on its own, notwithstanding that part 2 might be important as well? If they're both important, why aren't we passing some of that which is important?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118595","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If part 1 is important, then why aren't we passing a piece of important legislation? Can anybody weigh in on whether part 1 would help if it were passed on its own, notwithstanding that part 2 might be important as well? If they're both important, why aren't we passing some of that which is important?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7bb4147c79e096aa0057c55834cb726868b29359143b4864526cce974479df50"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-341127a4679b31588a970d18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118596,"date":"2026-06-09T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm very mindful of that. The reality is that we've heard a lot of testimony, if we're being candid, especially about part 2, that has left Canadians with questions, in my view. I can't speak for all Canadians, but I'm reading the mail and reading editorials, and we have media here. There are questions about that. I don't think there is the same degree of questions.... I'm not sure if I can ask the RCMP this. I'll be direct. If part 1 were passed tomorrow, would that be of assistance to the RCMP?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118596","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm very mindful of that. The reality is that we've heard a lot of testimony, if we're being candid, especially about part 2, that has left Canadians with questions, in my view. I can't speak for all Canadians, but I'm reading the mail and reading editorials, and we have media here. There are questions about that. I don't think there is the same degree of questions.... I'm not sure if I can ask th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["822516c01c4fd12b16b5e6773cfd622053c2abc330b248270a83a33a4fc92180"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0bfe839b07e3c1fbe6f0211","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118597,"date":"2026-06-09T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Chief Superintendent Burchill, I'm going to hearken back to a lot of the testimony, which was that we are often going on fishing expeditions and that we have 10 service providers and just need to confirm whether somebody is a provider. We're going to look at amendments within that, but my impression from hearing from the witnesses is that they said, \"We need both parts.\" If witnesses and law enforcement want both parts, they clearly want one of them. My point here to the committee, to Parliament and to Canadians is a very clear one: If part of the equation is part 1—which I think we can get to common ground on—and it would help, I don't think it's a stretch for officials to say, \"Yes, that would help us.\" Now, you can't say, \"Please pass it alone.\" I get that, but what I'm trying to get to—and perhaps through silence we're getting there; I don't know—is this: Why wouldn't we give you some of the powers you're seeking when we can come to common ground? On part 2, we're nowhere near common ground. The government came in, and the minister sat, I believe, where Ms. Gibner is sitting. I asked flat out, \"Will you address encryption?\" We got answers like, \"We're open to amendments.\" Now here we are, three weeks later, and the minister is holding a press conference, not to get asked questions but to tell Canadians, \"Whoa. Wait a minute. We're not just open to amendments. We're going to put forward amendments on encryption.\" Three weeks ago it was, \"Well, we'll see. We'll do as we please.\" That was the gist of it. Then we heard testimony for three weeks, and Canadians rightly created an opinion of the legislation in their own heads. Once that happens and Canadians aren't convinced, as a member of His Majesty's loyal opposition, it's not our job to plug those holes, those gaps. I've spoken long enough on this. I know you can't answer the question, but if part 1 is going to help you, I don't know why we're not passing it and dealing with Mr. Mantle's subamendment within that point and Ms. DeBellefeuille's amendment within that point. I think we can get to common ground. I'll leave it at that. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118597","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Chief Superintendent Burchill, I'm going to hearken back to a lot of the testimony, which was that we are often going on fishing expeditions and that we have 10 service providers and just need to confirm whether somebody is a provider. We're going to look at amendments within that, but my impression from hearing from the witnesses is that they said, \"We need both parts.\" If witnesses and law enfor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e7f35e6c5f78b133fd37051c2ce2d757d670e2e545d85f065adbd59e2218ac37"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab14710287eace02ac6773fca88a11101ea28339c57a9a7d8ed93f073ffdf858"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14c80bba0dfe3b31dfce671d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118598,"date":"2026-06-09T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. To the officials, on \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" versus \"reasonable grounds to believe\", is there an analogy to be drawn with section 495 of the code as to the powers to arrest and the reasonable and probable grounds to make an arrest?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118598","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. To the officials, on \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" versus \"reasonable grounds to believe\", is there an analogy to be drawn with section 495 of the code as to the powers to arrest and the reasonable and probable grounds to make an arrest?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["daffcdc03639504f6668d3daa636263d085ec042794947591a29706178029560"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1992e89d47375e01469e8670","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118599,"date":"2026-06-09T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Boy, I had a really good thought going there. Section 495 of the code, as I recall, governs reasonable and probable grounds to make an arrest, and that is based on \"reasonable grounds to believe\", as I understand it. Is there any connection between the powers of arrest versus the reasonable and probable grounds to believe? In other words, are they on the same standard? Would section 495 operate on the same standard as \"reasonable grounds to believe\" if we were to adopt this amendment? I suppose that is a better way to put it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118599","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Boy, I had a really good thought going there. Section 495 of the code, as I recall, governs reasonable and probable grounds to make an arrest, and that is based on \"reasonable grounds to believe\", as I understand it. Is there any connection between the powers of arrest versus the reasonable and probable grounds to believe? In other words, are they on the same standard? Would section 495 operate on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b436a228dfc37ca0cf21fc3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118600,"date":"2026-06-09T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Well, I understand that. I'm not sure I articulated my question properly. Right now, we're debating the standard on which a production order should be granted or not. If I understand Ms. Kwan's amendment, it is to take it from \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" to a \"reasonable grounds to believe\" threshold, unless I'm looking at the wrong threshold.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118600","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Well, I understand that. I'm not sure I articulated my question properly. Right now, we're debating the standard on which a production order should be granted or not. If I understand Ms. Kwan's amendment, it is to take it from \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" to a \"reasonable grounds to believe\" threshold, unless I'm looking at the wrong threshold.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-270ef98839d1cc57a2439530","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118601,"date":"2026-06-09T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay, I must be looking at the wrong thing on my chart. I'm going to consult the amendment directly for a moment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118601","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay, I must be looking at the wrong thing on my chart. I'm going to consult the amendment directly for a moment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d7cd116ab905d3e5028df8da1eac06607c7888897bc6dfe4e3cf30421b17f9cc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8208c9530feebfc75fd91b46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118602,"date":"2026-06-09T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I was actually going to suggest that we suspend now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118602","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I was actually going to suggest that we suspend now.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed86489ecebf28275a48dbb6db97c8d82cc1226f5c0261f143abdc0b7de7c668"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e522ee3d44e34d58072b8448","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118603,"date":"2026-06-09T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Oh, okay. Well, there's no pressure, then, at all. May I ask, Mr. Chair, before I start, whether we have a cut-off time of 7:30?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118603","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Oh, okay. Well, there's no pressure, then, at all. May I ask, Mr. Chair, before I start, whether we have a cut-off time of 7:30?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["413a553b7846002424ff6886012dc420c8edbfb2e51699feb5853abe28c701c0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4e529d884c275460d42985f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118604,"date":"2026-06-09T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"It would be helpful if we knew. I know the meeting started late. I think it would be helpful for all of us. I don't mind working, but I think it would be helpful for all of us to know when the meeting is expected to end. I'm going to come back to what I was saying earlier. I pulled out the provision I noted when I was speaking with Mr. Wong. The point I was trying to make is that right now proposed subsection 487.0121(2) says: The peace officer or public officer may make the demand only if they have reasonable grounds to suspect that (a) an offence has been or will be committed under this Act or any other Act of Parliament; Ms. Kwan's NDP-2 would change it to \"reasonable grounds to believe\". If we look at the Criminal Code, under section 495—this is the point I was trying to make—we see that it says: A peace officer may arrest without warrant (a) a person who has committed an indictable offence or who, on reasonable grounds, he believes has committed or is about to commit an indictable offence; There's the parallel I'm trying to draw. Section 495 talks about arresting on reasonable grounds to believe. Ms. Kwan's amendment talks about making a demand on reasonable grounds to believe. I hope the parallel there is fairly clear. I'm drawing that parallel because \"reasonable grounds to believe\" has been defined in the case law—for arrest, anyway—as being below a prima facie case. It's been a few years, but my recollection is that a prima facie case is a fairly low threshold in law, certainly below a 50% threshold. The point I'm trying to get to is this. Given all of that, is the \"reasonable grounds to believe\" threshold all that high? I get that it's higher than \"reasonable grounds to suspect\", but if in the context of arrest it's below a prima facie case, could it be said that in this context, given Ms. Kwan's amendment, it's actually not that high of a threshold? Am I making any sense here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118604","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It would be helpful if we knew. I know the meeting started late. I think it would be helpful for all of us. I don't mind working, but I think it would be helpful for all of us to know when the meeting is expected to end. I'm going to come back to what I was saying earlier. I pulled out the provision I noted when I was speaking with Mr. Wong. The point I was trying to make is that right now propose","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["795e0bedb2a552a40efa995542888dd0d1a12fbd09e2c95480267b0232c583ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b0fbaa926d082180231842792770be05c8ec84d31e8008b2d7f74bce62a3c9c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54956941131aef3d432f51d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118605,"date":"2026-06-09T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I understand that's different, but if we adopt Ms. Kwan's amendment, the threshold under, say, section 495 is \"reasonable grounds to believe\". The threshold under proposed section 487.0121 would also be \"reasonable grounds to believe\". Do you get what I'm saying here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118605","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand that's different, but if we adopt Ms. Kwan's amendment, the threshold under, say, section 495 is \"reasonable grounds to believe\". The threshold under proposed section 487.0121 would also be \"reasonable grounds to believe\". Do you get what I'm saying here?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30055034f0323655dd30dada","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118606,"date":"2026-06-09T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. Therein is my point. \"Reasonable grounds to believe\" in the context of section 495 is below a prima facie case. That's a fairly low threshold, in my view. It's above a hunch and above \"reasonable grounds to suspect\", but if we're articulating it as below a prima facie case under section 495, would it not be below a prima facie case under proposed section 487.0121? I hope I'm not getting too technical, but that's my point. I'm trying to deduce exactly what the threshold of \"reasonable grounds to believe\" actually means.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118606","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Therein is my point. \"Reasonable grounds to believe\" in the context of section 495 is below a prima facie case. That's a fairly low threshold, in my view. It's above a hunch and above \"reasonable grounds to suspect\", but if we're articulating it as below a prima facie case under section 495, would it not be below a prima facie case under proposed section 487.0121? I hope I'm not getting too ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a289b266d69a94e0a92265b6300cca6451e450d9bf66c6004ceeff511bf41d4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-579dfe5952206bcedec051a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118607,"date":"2026-06-09T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Perhaps I'm not articulating myself here correctly, Ms. Gibner, because what I'm getting at is what is in Ms. Kwan's amendment. Ms. Kwan's amendment was moved, and that is NDP-2. Are we not on NDP-2 right now? A voice: Yes. Frank Caputo: Okay. That's where I think we're getting our wires crossed. I worry, because Ms. Kwan's amendment says—I have it right here—\"demand only if they have reasonable grounds to believe\". The parallel I am drawing is that \"reasonable grounds to believe\" is used throughout the code. If we accept this amendment, \"reasonable grounds to believe\" will be in the subscriber demand section. \"Reasonable grounds to believe\" under the arrest provision has been interpreted to be below a prima facie case. Are you with me so far here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118607","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Perhaps I'm not articulating myself here correctly, Ms. Gibner, because what I'm getting at is what is in Ms. Kwan's amendment. Ms. Kwan's amendment was moved, and that is NDP-2. Are we not on NDP-2 right now? A voice: Yes. Frank Caputo: Okay. That's where I think we're getting our wires crossed. I worry, because Ms. Kwan's amendment says—I have it right here—\"demand only if they have reasonable g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b2445381138efff5cffac582138c6d4ff19a7decf519375aa1fddb03505a5aa2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7aab013143c5f108b7a4c833","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118608,"date":"2026-06-09T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. If \"reasonable grounds to believe\" has been articulated as below a prima facie case when it comes to arrest, would it not be similarly interpreted to be below a prima facie case on \"reasonable grounds to believe\" when it comes to Ms. Kwan's amendment? Do you get what I'm saying?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118608","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. If \"reasonable grounds to believe\" has been articulated as below a prima facie case when it comes to arrest, would it not be similarly interpreted to be below a prima facie case on \"reasonable grounds to believe\" when it comes to Ms. Kwan's amendment? Do you get what I'm saying?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13f4dd04a5a1dac4335b30b758b38aef4cf42a4c3c0ae0f18fcef23228c486ce"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e05c39b585eab5f6af94398e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118609,"date":"2026-06-09T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Is there an analogy to be drawn in the interpretation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118609","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is there an analogy to be drawn in the interpretation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44242","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Earthquakes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","label":"Explorations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","label":"Forgery","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44242","label":"Earthquakes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90511c491d16aa7018eeb37ba842cc01694649fad0b8abedec31d96e0b52995c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bdc72dc0ca4ed35144429ee8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118610,"date":"2026-06-09T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That's a fair comment. You're right. Section 495 engages section 9, which is the right to be free from arbitrary detention. The reason I'm going there is that I'm trying to determine what this threshold actually means. What does \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" mean versus \"reasonable grounds to believe\"? That's what I'm getting at. In the arrest context, it is a personal subjective belief that is below a prima facie case that is objectively reasonable. That's my reading of what the Supreme Court of Canada has said. Where does that leave us, then? What is \"reasonable grounds to believe\" in this context, in your view, versus \"reasonable grounds to suspect\"?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118610","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's a fair comment. You're right. Section 495 engages section 9, which is the right to be free from arbitrary detention. The reason I'm going there is that I'm trying to determine what this threshold actually means. What does \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" mean versus \"reasonable grounds to believe\"? That's what I'm getting at. In the arrest context, it is a personal subjective belief that is ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c595cb0d3dd8eab589959542386c1e5e300907c726d9f1bfe9bc772bf0e1fc29"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bd0d69d67a3e8cb75df8c97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118611,"date":"2026-06-09T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I see. That's helpful, because I took earlier comments to state that \"reasonable grounds to believe\" was above \"a balance of probabilities\". I think that's very important. I know this sounds very nuanced and like we're just hammering at something, but the degree to which somebody must believe is very important for the purposes of this amendment; it really is. We're talking about \"I suspect an offence might have happened\" versus \"I believe it has\". If it goes from a hunch to \"reasonable grounds to suspect\", \"reasonable grounds to believe\" and \"a balance of probabilities\", to me, that's a very important point. When I consider that, and especially when I consider the higher threshold and the issue that was brought up by professors Geist and Diab, for instance, about being worried about section 8 being engaged here—especially if you're looking at a section 1 analysis and thinking about whether we have crafted this as narrowly as possible on the proportionality test—I'm not as uncomfortable with a \"reasonable grounds to believe\" threshold. It's not that much higher than \"reasonable grounds to suspect\". It's higher, but still below \"a balance of probabilities\". To me, that's very important. Do either of you want to comment on that? Feel free. I hope I'm not talking you or myself into circles. Is dinner ready yet? Voices: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118611","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I see. That's helpful, because I took earlier comments to state that \"reasonable grounds to believe\" was above \"a balance of probabilities\". I think that's very important. I know this sounds very nuanced and like we're just hammering at something, but the degree to which somebody must believe is very important for the purposes of this amendment; it really is. We're talking about \"I suspect an offe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["81692edf202be5c57bc6bf6814284f4e7d44dcaf5c9704ce86d9c16de29aa8f5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4950f495060030c850cfb854","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118612,"date":"2026-06-09T23:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm ready. Let's go.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118612","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm ready. Let's go.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b62ba3086bda781771f7a943","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118613,"date":"2026-06-09T23:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Let's pause there. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118613","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Let's pause there. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0477a2f9b34e4948cafcac28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118614,"date":"2026-06-09T23:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"This is very interesting stuff. I find this stuff absolutely fascinating. The one thing that was raised with me in the break, in fairness to the officials, is these are not easy questions. I'm not pretending they are easy, because they are tough, and that's why I'm asking them. We're establishing the threshold of grounds to believe something that you suspect versus something that is probable, as in it's more probable than not in your eyes that something happened or you believe that it happened, as opposed to you think it could have happened, which I think is above the 50% when it's framed that way. One of the questions raised to me in the break that I hadn't considered is this: Is this analysis of \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" versus \"reasonable grounds to believe\" animated or informed by the stage at which you—\"you\" being a peace officer in law enforcement—are in your investigation? In other words, the service demand threshold happens right at the outset. How does that impact \"grounds to believe\" versus \"grounds to suspect\"? Does that make sense? Does it being at the outset of the investigation have any impact?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118614","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This is very interesting stuff. I find this stuff absolutely fascinating. The one thing that was raised with me in the break, in fairness to the officials, is these are not easy questions. I'm not pretending they are easy, because they are tough, and that's why I'm asking them. We're establishing the threshold of grounds to believe something that you suspect versus something that is probable, as i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ac662d5f9ae4ba3d2a585d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118615,"date":"2026-06-09T23:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Could you see a scenario, hypothetically, in which the committee says, \"Okay, this is a lower threshold\"? I'm speaking hypothetically here; I'm not signalling which way I would vote on an amendment. Could it be that simply identifying a subscriber is a much lower threshold of intrusion, as you had put it, and that's why you could justify \"reasonable grounds to suspect\", as in a crime has possibly been committed and we just want to know whether this person is a subscriber? Then once you get to an authorization to get more data about them—that is in the production order, which is judicially authorized—could you not say, \"Well, now you're getting a lot more information and therefore it could be justified that it goes to a higher threshold?\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118615","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could you see a scenario, hypothetically, in which the committee says, \"Okay, this is a lower threshold\"? I'm speaking hypothetically here; I'm not signalling which way I would vote on an amendment. Could it be that simply identifying a subscriber is a much lower threshold of intrusion, as you had put it, and that's why you could justify \"reasonable grounds to suspect\", as in a crime has possibly ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-190842a35e46dc63630f465a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118616,"date":"2026-06-09T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That's fair enough. I'm trying to work this through, and I get that once you have the subscriber demand and the subscriber information, you're only theoretically one step further ahead once you get that authorization for the subscriber information. If I'm taking your point correctly, we're actually not that much further ahead in terms of determining whether there are now \"reasonable grounds to believe\" versus \"reasonable grounds to suspect\". Could you settle a debate between me and my colleague? I won't say who's on what side, but let's say proposed section 487.0121 is the section we're looking at. Let's say that a court says this offends section 8 of the charter—not the way it was carried out, but the legislation itself offends section 8. Would there then be a section 1 analysis of whether or not that is a reasonable limitation on the section 8 charter right to be free from unreasonable search and seizure? In other words, do you perform the Oakes test on the legislation if it's found to infringe section 8?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118616","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's fair enough. I'm trying to work this through, and I get that once you have the subscriber demand and the subscriber information, you're only theoretically one step further ahead once you get that authorization for the subscriber information. If I'm taking your point correctly, we're actually not that much further ahead in terms of determining whether there are now \"reasonable grounds to bel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca8697d22662de9deacc1094c82a060b9129300b788367bfeca4f7866bfdc5d2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bea7f231627a5e5b6f3f9044eb16709b2bef346f55b46da4bfdb968563350e6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac44d8e4694b47b2b5221dc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118617,"date":"2026-06-09T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I understand that. We were just debating whether section 1 would apply, as in whether it could be saved by section 1, but it sounds like that's not your area. That's fair enough. I'll give the floor to MP Mantle. Before I finish, do we know what time we're finishing up here, Mr. Chair?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118617","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand that. We were just debating whether section 1 would apply, as in whether it could be saved by section 1, but it sounds like that's not your area. That's fair enough. I'll give the floor to MP Mantle. Before I finish, do we know what time we're finishing up here, Mr. Chair?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4eff803a8e4582bfca42a8df62838db3e0bef539a9f455ecbc8442f7e263acde"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3bc0cb9a900c1acd79730be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118618,"date":"2026-06-09T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118618","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9545e2cc0e649a58fce78d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118619,"date":"2026-06-10T00:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. Could I hear from the officials on this one? In your eyes, what is the practical implication or impact of this amendment, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118619","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Could I hear from the officials on this one? In your eyes, what is the practical implication or impact of this amendment, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42fe16d39e30bcdf5dc221f640bb0029c0b0273575cf8a76f8fff5e8be8132c2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa871a65cebd5fbf87a4e0ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118620,"date":"2026-06-10T00:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry. I have to look at the bill to get that. When you say that it creates a discrepancy, what precisely is the discrepancy? We may wish to move a subamendment to ameliorate that discrepancy. Is that possible?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118620","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm sorry. I have to look at the bill to get that. When you say that it creates a discrepancy, what precisely is the discrepancy? We may wish to move a subamendment to ameliorate that discrepancy. Is that possible?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30d0842427ab2c899831c4b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118621,"date":"2026-06-10T00:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. I missed that. Can you take me through that a bit more, Mr. Wong? You said there's a give-and-take and that it has something in here that shouldn't be in here. When you say that it shouldn't be in here, do you mean that it's introducing a novel concept or novel wording? If there's something that inadvertently isn't in here, the committee can amend it in order to make it appropriate. I guess the question is whether it is a drafting error.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118621","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. I missed that. Can you take me through that a bit more, Mr. Wong? You said there's a give-and-take and that it has something in here that shouldn't be in here. When you say that it shouldn't be in here, do you mean that it's introducing a novel concept or novel wording? If there's something that inadvertently isn't in here, the committee can amend it in order to make it appropriate. I guess ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f3e171ada5a050a50d46c98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118622,"date":"2026-06-10T01:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Is it workable? I get that it's dismantling and changing how it's drafted, but is it not still workable in the way that Ms. Kwan's amendment—and, frankly, CPC-3 is the same amendment—is drafted?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118622","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is it workable? I get that it's dismantling and changing how it's drafted, but is it not still workable in the way that Ms. Kwan's amendment—and, frankly, CPC-3 is the same amendment—is drafted?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","label":"Military technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1b086ee05fb0fa0f89d17a2b5ef2d7fdede575f03e29135e3f80573cecc97db"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b073176b8068b8448c1c921","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118623,"date":"2026-06-10T01:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. In your view, CPC-3 and BQ-4 are actually workable, but NDP-3 at this point is not workable. Is that accurate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118623","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. In your view, CPC-3 and BQ-4 are actually workable, but NDP-3 at this point is not workable. Is that accurate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["241f36b1bdb9a63402a5aae6657c4dca1ed459c6877d276c955291fa739db9da"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c93fd7e0f0d02d4ab49b4e98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118624,"date":"2026-06-10T01:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"The appropriate thing, then, would be to move on to BQ-4 and let us ask our questions on BQ-4, if that's the case. I don't have any further interventions, but my colleagues may.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118624","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The appropriate thing, then, would be to move on to BQ-4 and let us ask our questions on BQ-4, if that's the case. I don't have any further interventions, but my colleagues may.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","label":"Therapy","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9b705693d41666fa7172486e86e7b2440663bccfd87a43b4a071791c8ffd979"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-258a2696598756fac6b2629d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087984,"date":"2026-06-16T00:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\n First of all, I want to give a shout-out to Stanley Cup champion and Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola product, Logan Stankoven. We are so proud of Logan for winning the Stanley Cup.\n\nTo my hon colleague, the member for Winnipeg North talked about playing games. Is this not the government that shut off the cameras in four committees the moment it got a majority? I ask my colleague, who is playing games?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087984","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.\n\n First of all, I want to give a shout-out to Stanley Cup champion and Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola product, Logan Stankoven. We are so proud of Logan for winning the Stanley Cup.\n\nTo my hon colleague, the member for Winnipeg North talked about playing games. Is this not the government that shut off the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da196024b5381997ac191bfeae9e89942a391656add6134ce8268047773f2eb9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96e232bda50c538930e34dd2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087985,"date":"2026-06-16T02:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nHere we have the same Liberal playbook yet again. There has been so much opposition to Bill C-9, and now the Liberals are insisting on using their majority to, again, ram it through. It is a majority they got not at the ballot box but through floor crossers. \n\nWe have heard from so many groups, including from His Eminence Frank Cardinal Leo from the Archdiocese of Toronto. I am wondering what the hon. secretary of state would say when so many faith groups are opposing Bill C-9. Should the Liberals not be taking a step back on this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087985","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nHere we have the same Liberal playbook yet again. There has been so much opposition to Bill C-9, and now the Liberals are insisting on using their majority to, again, ram it through. It is a majority they got not at the ballot box but through floor crossers. \n\nWe have heard from so many groups, in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41908acdf083618425b6fa419e0544c547002f66ae2c38e44e6c632da74051fd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b01b229cefadbae85a47c5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087986,"date":"2026-06-16T02:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Before I begin, I want to recognize Paul and Elly Major, the parents of Dr. Blair Major, a faculty member of Thompson Rivers University in my riding, on their 50th wedding anniversary. I congratulate Paul and Elly.\n\nWe heard a member talk about people who cannot go to synagogues. There was actually a synagogue that was shot up, and that has now been tied to a terrorist who was then alleged to have been connected to a police officer who has been killed. We have had an unprecedented number of churches being burned with nary a word from the government. We have had people who cannot access their places of worship, and the government has not sufficiently denounced it. Forgive me if I say that the government's words ring hollow after 12 years of inaction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087986","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Before I begin, I want to recognize Paul and Elly Major, the parents of Dr. Blair Major, a faculty member of Thompson Rivers University in my riding, on their 50th wedding anniversary. I congratulate Paul and Elly.\n\nWe heard a member talk about people who cannot go to synagogues. There was actually a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4e9f4932143fa4bf7aef01964db68a881707c22a4b4b8ef78e60830d7fcf461b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e92b1e1a9cf6f649dfc200be9bb22b94f8631be202250db49d60096d827d184f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-814c6c43c1895fc0b8d1718e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087987,"date":"2026-06-16T04:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the residents of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nBefore I begin, I want to recognize the life of Joan Loehr. She was a prominent resident of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. She and her family have given a lot to the community. She leaves behind her children Geoffrey, Regan, Kent, Joel, Jarett and Mary. May perpetual light shine upon her. \n\nThe member for Winnipeg North just talked about religious liberty and not being worried about this impacting religious rights and speeches. My colleague talked about legislative intent. Well, the Supreme Court of Canada grappled with this issue of legislative intent, I believe it was this year, in a ruling, where Parliament specifically said it wanted the legislation to say this. It was in debate, and it was in an amendment, and the Supreme Court of Canada still went against that. \n\nWith that in mind, the uncertainty that this bill would create is part of the issue. What does the member say to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087987","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the residents of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nBefore I begin, I want to recognize the life of Joan Loehr. She was a prominent resident of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. She and her family have given a lot to the community. She leaves behind her children Geoffrey, Regan, Kent, Joel, Jarett and Mary. May perpetual light shine upon her. \n\nThe member","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29a1ca54069577c989fb5cf1268a174b6cab78481eb9a6b6b7ce694f29d3cf37"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["514e5049697bd623c287ed15d6e6b5926d07536f5cda1f9439d5d5a7e0b7eedf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd28f2a063e8cdbb091f106d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087988,"date":"2026-06-16T04:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Before I begin, I want to recognize Hafiza Zalmay and congratulate her on her Bachelor of Business Administration. She and her husband came from Afghanistan. It is a huge accomplishment, so my best wishes go to Hafiza.\n\n My colleague is part of a government that is intent on bringing this bill forward. Everybody wants to protect people with their religious institutions, but as my colleague from Nanaimo—Ladysmith just pointed out, as I was listening to the minister's speech, it is the exact same thing. Right now, nobody can obstruct someone from going into a place of worship and not break the law. Dare I say, I do not know that there is much in this bill that, if one were to do it, they would not already be breaking the law?\n\n However, there are so many controversial elements. Why are the Liberals insistent on this when free speech and civil liberties advocates have spoken about the potential dangers—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087988","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Before I begin, I want to recognize Hafiza Zalmay and congratulate her on her Bachelor of Business Administration. She and her husband came from Afghanistan. It is a huge accomplishment, so my best wishes go to Hafiza.\n\n My colleague is part of a government that is intent on bringing this bill forward","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6c55845f4c5b0a9ee9459303e03b9867f6f5bd4c5f2c1636300f3a0ecdffb405"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c2d154c1d2cd5199cb5f07a658c3869669be034cb534bce87682eb1a9ae927a9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13d0425e0784041c5afc7391","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087982,"date":"2026-06-16T19:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, \"this is not how legislation works.\" That is what the minister just said. Allow me to tell him something. Canadians do not take their orders from the Liberal Party. Conservatives do not take their orders from the Liberal Party. We will scrutinize legislation as we see fit.\n\nWe have heard from Canadians concerned about big brother aspects of this bill. We have heard from civil libertarians, experts, law professors who say we should be passing part 1 and scrutinizing part 2.\n\nWhy will they not pass part 1 and study part 2?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087982","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, \"this is not how legislation works.\" That is what the minister just said. Allow me to tell him something. Canadians do not take their orders from the Liberal Party. Conservatives do not take their orders from the Liberal Party. We will scrutinize legislation as we see fit.\n\nWe have heard from Canadians concerned about big brother aspects of this bill. We have heard from civil libertar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5e64f4019cf16457f062f00da9b520b971dd3330e1f93d62c3a725a076f38bf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["571a90f67c50b1918b0393bdf7423575b69fd141a0ef6d27cc0fa8604fdae891"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8c4205502bd33cfdc3c9074","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118625,"date":"2026-06-16T20:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like to speak on the same point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118625","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like to speak on the same point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b871624fe0d032c677847e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118626,"date":"2026-06-16T20:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"With all due respect, Mr. Chair, I don't think it's well noted. We are parliamentarians. We get to come here, and we get to ask questions. I will not allow anybody to get in the way of anybody asking a question, whether it be a Liberal member who has privilege or a Conservative member. If Ms. Cody wants to ask a question about the bill, about the general nature of the bill and about how the general nature of the bill impacts line 27, or whatever it was, she has the right to do so. The fact that someone doesn't like it is irrelevant.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118626","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"With all due respect, Mr. Chair, I don't think it's well noted. We are parliamentarians. We get to come here, and we get to ask questions. I will not allow anybody to get in the way of anybody asking a question, whether it be a Liberal member who has privilege or a Conservative member. If Ms. Cody wants to ask a question about the bill, about the general nature of the bill and about how the genera","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ba9d9e15fd6df7b75512209","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118627,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I have a point of order. I believe the bells are ringing, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118627","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order. I believe the bells are ringing, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80e09be8a1931a33fc6e77f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087983,"date":"2026-06-17T01:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we request a recorded division.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087983","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we request a recorded division.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8184116ccb8724dd38e6de65","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118628,"date":"2026-06-17T03:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"The MPs are smiling, but I do want to take a moment to thank the officials. I know it can be difficult. We have moments of levity among members, probably because it is now June, and this is the silly season, when it can be very difficult. A lot of people are working 15-hour days, yourselves included. We do thank you for putting on a brave face. I know you're not allowed to show the levity that sometimes we are. We really do appreciate you for being here. I'm not going to take a super long time here—famous last words—because I am going to ask for a washroom break when I'm done—full disclosure. This is something that was actually brought up by professors Geist and Diab. I'm not sure in your preparation.... I know that you all do robust preparation. Professors Geist and Diab appeared on the same panel. Can I ask, did anybody review their testimony on the panel? They both talked about the grounds to suspect versus the grounds to believe. Is this triggering for anybody? One of the things that both of them said, as I recall—I'm pretty sure it was Professor Diab who definitely said it—was that a lower threshold of reasonable grounds to suspect generally would invite scrutiny under section 8. There's always scrutiny under section 8. What I mean by scrutiny under section 8 is perhaps a declaration of unconstitutionality. We can sit here all day and all night, but if a law is declared unconstitutional at the end of the day as having breached section 8 and not having been saved by section 1, all this time we spend is in vain, really. One piece of litigation works its way up to the Supreme Court of Canada, which invariably these types of cases do, and then there's an issue there. I want to ask about this. I would like to ask about the officials' point of view. My recollection is that the professor said that a lower threshold of reasonable grounds to suspect would breach section 8 of the charter. The government doesn't believe so. I've looked at the charter statement, and I don't think that the charter statement really tells you a lot. It says this right is engaged, but we're kind of doing this. It doesn't say, a reasonable ground to suspect will not invite the court to strike this down, because this case and this case established this, and based on that we come to this conclusion. That's what I'm looking for from a legal statement. I think we would all want that from a legal statement. I would like for somebody to address this question. The professor said the reasonable grounds to suspect threshold offends section 8. What do you all say to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118628","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The MPs are smiling, but I do want to take a moment to thank the officials. I know it can be difficult. We have moments of levity among members, probably because it is now June, and this is the silly season, when it can be very difficult. A lot of people are working 15-hour days, yourselves included. We do thank you for putting on a brave face. I know you're not allowed to show the levity that som","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6273cf2bdc632894ed150d56d8d42c756bdcd70cef9e652460938c01a857a9ff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9e74eebb5d1f826361c8c38b3d30000daa3e4a7a1e7f773427f66df37453663e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47cd46040be7aac640d546ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118629,"date":"2026-06-17T03:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Oh, my goodness, yes—far too often.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118629","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Oh, my goodness, yes—far too often.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d3213e3a3c81882dc8c35f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118630,"date":"2026-06-17T03:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm just going to think about this, because you used the breathalyzer example—and I appreciate your bringing that example. The law did change in British Columbia a number of years ago, which basically meant that we didn't really prosecute a lot of impaired driving charges. However, I do recall there were reasonable grounds to suspect that a person had alcohol in their body. Now, as I recall—and I can't remember whether it was an arbitrary detention issue or not—it did have to go through a section 1 analysis. I can't recall whether it was section 8, the search, in terms of providing a breath sample, or section 9, the roadside detention. I always really appreciate, Ms. Gibner, how you engage with the law in discussing this. I think you articulated that quite well. I don't think anybody at the table there would say something along the lines of, \"Look, we really want to put law forward that's unconstitutional.\" Now, we still have to scrutinize that. Of course you're not going to put forward unconstitutional law. I don't think you would have your jobs. With that being said, I think Bill C-2 had blatantly unconstitutional provisions in it. I'm not going to bust out parts 15 and 16 in it. With the greatest of respect to officials, I think that the legislative drafters were told what to put in, and that there was probably language in Bill C-2 that caused nine out of 10 constitutional lawyers to say, \"Yeah, this probably offends the charter.\" The mere fact that something has been drafted, I don't think, is persuasive enough. I take it on its face: \"Look, we're not going to put something in that we know is unconstitutional.\" What we worry about is the grey area. I guess what I'm asking you.... Tell me if this is an unfair question. I asked professors Diab and Geist about this, as I recall. They articulated their rationale as to why this offended section 8. I don't recall exactly how they connected the dots, but I guess what I'm looking for is this: Quite simply, do you disagree? Where do you depart from their analysis? Do you recall their analysis? This was a couple of months ago now, so help me out there, please. If you can't recall, I'm not going to be offended or anything....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118630","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm just going to think about this, because you used the breathalyzer example—and I appreciate your bringing that example. The law did change in British Columbia a number of years ago, which basically meant that we didn't really prosecute a lot of impaired driving charges. However, I do recall there were reasonable grounds to suspect that a person had alcohol in their body. Now, as I recall—and I ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c0b5abd76e7b6d09cc2ddcfdb4fcd172611142e885638dfb689cd5b691d4c3bf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a69d08a3542a8502c5d05b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118631,"date":"2026-06-17T03:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You raised an interesting point. You have both been very articulate in how you have addressed this. Here is one of my questions and, potentially, a concern. You talked about spectrums of privacy. Obviously, one's body probably attracts the greatest privacy interest. However, with these things here, there's a lot of privacy, because they have all of your details. They're essentially walking biographies of who we are, which, in some cases, people might not want other people to know about. It's things like that. They contain substantial information, so they do attract a high degree of privacy. Even the modules in your car.... There's a B.C. Court of Appeal case about the module that records information for the last three seconds before an accident. These are the types of things for which there is still an expectation of privacy. On the spectrum of the expectation of privacy that you've just outlined, Mr. Wong, is there agreement, either academic or jurisprudential, on where these issues here, which are covered in this clause and this amendment, stand?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118631","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You raised an interesting point. You have both been very articulate in how you have addressed this. Here is one of my questions and, potentially, a concern. You talked about spectrums of privacy. Obviously, one's body probably attracts the greatest privacy interest. However, with these things here, there's a lot of privacy, because they have all of your details. They're essentially walking biograp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["18fde5fa87c01b46327947f2bdade0715d76b770a76e0290aba4ec84411c9e35"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4264ca0c7d1ab97644f09c464fc5ce3a3cbea4131f412e9a0c882bba90802334"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24cd73ac33662933a5b8d1be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118632,"date":"2026-06-17T03:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm just wondering, Mr. Chair, if could we have a washroom break, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118632","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm just wondering, Mr. Chair, if could we have a washroom break, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:423203","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hygiene","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:423203","label":"Hygiene","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29272029c67bb65bbb8fec9454c65508441e722bfe8d12b514e725910d8d141f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e34a6bf063b0f47f937abf8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118633,"date":"2026-06-17T03:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That's dilatory.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118633","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's dilatory.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e94a78d02fdb0f3f8d7577e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118634,"date":"2026-06-17T03:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"You are much more robust than I in your fortitude, I suppose.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118634","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You are much more robust than I in your fortitude, I suppose.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bb345586d0cd9596f4c6df64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118635,"date":"2026-06-17T03:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Did we have a motion to adjourn? Do we, really?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118635","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Did we have a motion to adjourn? Do we, really?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e94c2de770b43874fb44852f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118636,"date":"2026-06-17T03:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Who else is on the list?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118636","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Who else is on the list?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6a499bc346f0b8cc22c1dae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118637,"date":"2026-06-17T03:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Oh. Well, this should be good. I'll be fast. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118637","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Oh. Well, this should be good. I'll be fast. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-235c81f6ada2ecbea398b43b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118638,"date":"2026-06-17T03:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Let's have a recorded division, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118638","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Let's have a recorded division, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3bf9fe8a101ca1a75e45ed4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087981,"date":"2026-06-17T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, \"collaboratively\" is the word used by the Minister of Public Safety as to how he would work with Conservatives on Bill C-22 amendments, and yet the government is insisting on using its manufactured majority to now ram this bill through Parliament.\n\n Make no mistake: Conservatives want to put the bad folks in jail. We would pass part 1 of the bill swiftly, but Canadians have questions and experts have questions, and we think those questions should be answered with respect to part 2. Why is the Liberal government insistent on ramming Bill C-22 and part 2 through when we would gladly pass part 1 swiftly?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087981","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, \"collaboratively\" is the word used by the Minister of Public Safety as to how he would work with Conservatives on Bill C-22 amendments, and yet the government is insisting on using its manufactured majority to now ram this bill through Parliament.\n\n Make no mistake: Conservatives want to put the bad folks in jail. We would pass part 1 of the bill swiftly, but Canadians have questions ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56f7c16928dc6e150f6bbbe8b6920539b55660e896cb744d7eeb97a6304b6a50"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87159d767aca217e1bf6f71e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118639,"date":"2026-06-18T03:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I echo what you said about our witnesses. I know it's not easy to be here. Let's face it. Not many people are spending their Wednesday nights on Parliament Hill at 10:48, serving the Canadian public while being bright-eyed, bushy-tailed and always having to be on guard for a question, so we appreciate this. Sometimes, we as MPs may trade barbs. Sometimes we may ask you difficult questions. Sometimes there might be moments that are a bit more serious. Sometimes there might be moments that are a bit more lighthearted. You don't have a choice in that. You have to come here and answer the questions that are posed to you, and you have to be ready for a spinoff question that may come your way. For that, we are grateful. Mr. Chair, we have 30 minutes to discuss this. I'm on the speaking list, and I think that Ms. Kirkland, Mr. Au and Mr. Lloyd will probably be after me. I will say this. We're all ready for summer, but that doesn't mean that summer has started. There is still work to be done. There's work to be done this evening, and there's work to be done tomorrow. At the end of the day, Bill C-22 is a contentious piece of legislation. It was contentious from the get-go. Most people here have heard ad nauseam about my background as a prosecutor, in which the access to data or the access to evidence was central to whether a conviction followed. I understand that. There is no doubt in my mind that lawful access is something that our House, the chamber upstairs, must address—not should, but must. The question is about how we address it. I have now seen what is probably the most aggressive programming motion during my five years here in Parliament. A programming motion basically tells us how and when we must consider something. We have to get through amendments without discussion tonight. That is the gist of it: no discussion on a bill that is probably over 100 pages long. We have to get through the amendments without discussion. Now, say what you want about lawful access. Like me, you may think there is a necessity for a lawful access regime. The question is, what does it look like? You may say you don't want any lawful access because it infringes on your civil liberties, or you may say that you are prepared to trade privacy for lawful access in order to accede to the arguments that have been put forward by some. At the end of the day, we are here to work and we are here to debate. There is one thing we will not do in 28 minutes, and that is debate. The motion that was passed in the House tonight precludes debate. It precludes debate on matters of privacy, on matters that may impact the charter. No, I shouldn't say they may; they do impact the charter. They engage section 8 of the charter, and here we are, talking about provisions that we will pass without debate, that a court will someday be considering. Make no mistake, someday a court will consider the words that we pass on paper here. They will decide the constitutionality of those words, and we are expected to pass those words without debate. That is unconscionable. For 12 years we've had a Liberal government. We got this motion put on us on Tuesday, before we left—Tuesday—not Monday and not the Friday before, but Tuesday. In fact, the Liberal government put forward a wish list of bills they wanted passed. Do you know what wasn't on the list? Bill C-22 . Yes, I'm a bit animated here. The government said they didn't want this bill, but literally at the last minute, Wednesday night, we are talking about amendments that impact each and every Canadian. Make no mistake that on the Conservative side, we all want to put bad people in jail, but this ain't the way to do it. To have amendments rammed down our throats without debate and without discussion is patently wrong. Yes, we will sit here at the table. Yes, we will oblige with the process. We will adhere to democracy. The motion that was passed. That doesn't mean we like it. Moreover, it doesn't make it right. What is happening here may have been duly passed, but it is wrong. One day, in two years, three years or five years, a court may be reviewing our words. They may well look at what happened here tonight and talk about the lack of discussion and consideration when they are reviewing whether amendments put forward, which aren't even public yet.... We can't even talk about this. By the way, who breached parliamentary privilege with the Toronto Star? Am I in the twilight zone here? They don't know. I think my point has been made. We are here, and we are here to work. This is not the right way to work. We will do our jobs. This is not the climate in which we were expected to do our jobs. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118639","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I echo what you said about our witnesses. I know it's not easy to be here. Let's face it. Not many people are spending their Wednesday nights on Parliament Hill at 10:48, serving the Canadian public while being bright-eyed, bushy-tailed and always having to be on guard for a question, so we appreciate this. Sometimes, we as MPs may trade barbs. Sometimes we may ask ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9253883adbe78a6309a7c62b476ae25d47d9a644bb616b9a5e0837a15bc7ff6a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29462b900fffebb5af09b872d20e45828360131d792b161c4dbe68c56a76b506"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b1bba2c346fdc1c3baaffd9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118640,"date":"2026-06-18T04:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Chair, just to be clear as we're jumping into this, is this Mr. Mantle's subamendment that we're talking about?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118640","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, just to be clear as we're jumping into this, is this Mr. Mantle's subamendment that we're talking about?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9d30eccedefd41ea95a690ea2b0a5c86c4c1c5666ddfb56e9fc7a7bd0e6035e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14d2de2052d7c6b652e26c63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118641,"date":"2026-06-18T04:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'll intervene now that I actually have a right to intervene for the next 12 minutes or so. You know what? Laugh all you want. Smile all you want. That was a darn good subamendment, and one that came out of discussion. People may not like how the discussion came about, but that was a darn good subamendment. People may not like the person who proposed it, but if you actually listened to the people who were there at the table, my sense from listening to them, the people on the ground, was that they supported it, and that was the product of what we are here to do. At the very least, we got a chance to debate this. Yes, it got voted down, but at least we got to hear from witnesses. It was a good subamendment, and I think it would have given law enforcement more of what they needed. Too bad for the next, well, I've got 90 pages here.... I think we're on page 10 of my 90 pages. At least we got to debate that one. We're going to be talking about encryption and breaking encryption, whether encryption should be broken, whether encryption that has been or has the ability to be broken should be broken by the state and how that relates to organized crime. If I'm an observer watching at home, I'm wondering why we even send our people to Parliament in some respects, because at the end of the day, if you get four people to cross the floor, one of whom said \"and it's good for me\", that's what democracy comes down to: \"it's good for me\". That actually dictates what happens at this committee: It's good for me. That's all I have to say.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118641","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll intervene now that I actually have a right to intervene for the next 12 minutes or so. You know what? Laugh all you want. Smile all you want. That was a darn good subamendment, and one that came out of discussion. People may not like how the discussion came about, but that was a darn good subamendment. People may not like the person who proposed it, but if you actually listened to the people ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Websites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","label":"Websites","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6cdfb0a36fee50857ea76bebe051afd908c6046d78249c67d7115d66f14e569e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3bbf227e553ccc84f1ac2967","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118642,"date":"2026-06-18T04:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That is what democracy is all about, Mr. Ramsey. You just articulated a point. You just articulated why you're voting for something. I may have voted for that amendment, and you may have voted against that amendment, but you know what? We actually had robust discussion on that amendment. You know what we're not going to have for the next 80 pages of amendments that I have on my spreadsheet? Robust discussion. Thank you, sir. You have just made my point.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118642","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That is what democracy is all about, Mr. Ramsey. You just articulated a point. You just articulated why you're voting for something. I may have voted for that amendment, and you may have voted against that amendment, but you know what? We actually had robust discussion on that amendment. You know what we're not going to have for the next 80 pages of amendments that I have on my spreadsheet? Robust","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb6f8835fb6574a0815548b1fb335c95c202f7b2e905bb92bfcb5b83f2f17bce"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc39d6aed988681973e6a76a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118643,"date":"2026-06-18T04:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Chair, I would invite the chair to assist the committee members. We're going through a lot of amendments. Can you perhaps announce exactly what amendment we're on and what clause we're on? I think that would be of great help. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118643","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I would invite the chair to assist the committee members. We're going through a lot of amendments. Can you perhaps announce exactly what amendment we're on and what clause we're on? I think that would be of great help. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-305afdfb97a0ae70fb12918c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118644,"date":"2026-06-18T04:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"What amendments? This is on BQ—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118644","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What amendments? This is on BQ—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fcfbfb58f6d32f1fdd40f41b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118645,"date":"2026-06-18T04:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Can we have a recorded vote, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118645","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Can we have a recorded vote, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a71fff7702894f5cc7f17a4a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118646,"date":"2026-06-18T04:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 10 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 11)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118646","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 10 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 11)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-437526d6b614a62954f60cb0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118647,"date":"2026-06-18T04:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118647","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7084bec53a2d7437d085b5c816738ab6cea3d9d7228cd64e87b5cf0e464a600"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b645855f17d67ad117e5cbb0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118648,"date":"2026-06-18T04:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 11 agreed to: yeas 10; nays 1)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118648","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 11 agreed to: yeas 10; nays 1)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e78109e04be96160f37cd758","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118649,"date":"2026-06-18T04:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 12 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 1)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118649","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 12 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 1)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0e17864b44956f41d61f491b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118650,"date":"2026-06-18T04:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote for something that is really important.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118650","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote for something that is really important.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc17493a546744a10a137aa0f3073ae56e28aa5edd744484c549052080920ccf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-552708fedd603253f45eecb4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118651,"date":"2026-06-18T04:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 16 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118651","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 16 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c19fca6e90118640561f7a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118652,"date":"2026-06-18T04:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded division, please. (Clause 17 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118652","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded division, please. (Clause 17 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bb2b4a5601ead75bd3554ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118653,"date":"2026-06-18T04:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded division. (Clause 18 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 19)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118653","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded division. (Clause 18 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 19)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1bc08b5183d345d781e858d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118654,"date":"2026-06-18T04:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes, I would like a recorded division, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118654","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, I would like a recorded division, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c343a048f6ec85bcfeddf95e801facb453ad6dbf9b07f2ef8116fa1d31b44621"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3b52476f9c582458f1a2e54","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118655,"date":"2026-06-18T04:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 19 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 20)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118655","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 19 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 20)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81a7a2915802a7181389c993","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118656,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 4; nays 7 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118656","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 4; nays 7 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5731019a33d879854b503b6d758fabf8493e71f69c8f31dfc31cd62499af1e9d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c524f90498c5b053897123c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118657,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Clause 23 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 24)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118657","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Clause 23 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 24)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b905250bb7d295357b0989f11000b89b769d9c95d55cf0f9eecd560fa127f0b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bca7c2d8b0d824831366ea41","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118658,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118658","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87b50970b194525bd9638fb115af74a55c63a0e0cd389e992678538f560a287d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cadc674e5a2ac12abf7b933b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118659,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Clause 24 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 25)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118659","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Clause 24 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 25)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91ade790b510b3c0386de42fdd4e0d032af521f543ce182c44065f8949ac6d06"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b18f72bef281d26aa892561","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118660,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6[ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118660","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6[ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4f582f9f3607be0eade7ef665acd3383baac795eb2b95528ef9a1ecccaaf7bc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04f8caf1c540c9f2da5a9ccf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118661,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Clause 25 agreed to: yeas 10; nays 1) (On clause 26)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118661","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Clause 25 agreed to: yeas 10; nays 1) (On clause 26)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c663eb63f1f40ebae451312a0779f183f92942ccb2b448bb9ed81d0f0df2f70e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a2927a35c2a6baa4248b7e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118662,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118662","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87b50970b194525bd9638fb115af74a55c63a0e0cd389e992678538f560a287d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec9cf595801bea105d1549a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118663,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Clause 26 agreed to: yeas 10; nays 1)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118663","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Clause 26 agreed to: yeas 10; nays 1)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ac350c7cd0782eaad9fa43e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118664,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118664","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f23b6cc485879cd5291d2ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118665,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118665","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dee89b551675820b280b3d81","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118666,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"On division. (Amendment negatived [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118666","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"On division. (Amendment negatived [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86d081d1af5e50362488920b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118667,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118667","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9815cb74f9b2b7bc961a83a16bf01c2f89eb81cb235a58916e6da1fc0088868d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4fd15473668a4db4de57fa1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118668,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 29 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118668","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 29 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e21bc021d18a10759741fc88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118669,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 30 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 31)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118669","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 30 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0) (On clause 31)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["adaa95b0f630f40b91da11bb9288915fed5d6dcbc248e729fc9f90c312d2ad2d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5a5269f9ddcb6300731480c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118670,"date":"2026-06-18T04:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 32 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118670","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 32 agreed to: yeas 11; nays 0)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf3b2d5bccd4f4fa37a19dd3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118671,"date":"2026-06-18T04:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Make it defeated on division. (Amendment negatived on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118671","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Make it defeated on division. (Amendment negatived on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2090d314fe62698fc661e6778fef4a4ccfdcd6c5fdf19c974233c93b813ff547"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-58c787a0051586f1443877b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118672,"date":"2026-06-18T04:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118672","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35003bb5bf1bbf6039c2277e6c0f62cde386438504efeb3319634e826c8632c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2336118fc04a09af0dbeff4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118673,"date":"2026-06-18T04:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Make it defeated on division. (Amendment negatived on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118673","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Make it defeated on division. (Amendment negatived on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2090d314fe62698fc661e6778fef4a4ccfdcd6c5fdf19c974233c93b813ff547"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e482ec01463cd8a292a4582b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118674,"date":"2026-06-18T04:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118674","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35003bb5bf1bbf6039c2277e6c0f62cde386438504efeb3319634e826c8632c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1656dd81a986e2c893f2a59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118675,"date":"2026-06-18T04:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment agreed to: yeas 7; nays 4 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118675","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment agreed to: yeas 7; nays 4 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9287619ed1113fd7d9b23104eb41efe9fc0233f3a3724ef9896ec20f94fbd7e7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10e3ec8b7d676174bfd4dd5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118676,"date":"2026-06-18T04:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118676","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9815cb74f9b2b7bc961a83a16bf01c2f89eb81cb235a58916e6da1fc0088868d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0ac2cc070d1ee73dcc81600","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118677,"date":"2026-06-18T04:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded division, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118677","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded division, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58b66042c4e1167c42bfa80cebc331a8d610edfe4915896e027b36b8b8a9de3f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e16bf51af1513b2410d0d5c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118678,"date":"2026-06-18T04:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded vote, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118678","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded vote, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb3d3374fa88cddc0feab472","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118679,"date":"2026-06-18T04:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded vote.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118679","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded vote.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a4dab7326f885ffdd98ed3e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118680,"date":"2026-06-18T04:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Oh, they are carrying CPC-18? We'll take it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118680","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Oh, they are carrying CPC-18? We'll take it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-874edad58272ebffbf10a063","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118681,"date":"2026-06-18T04:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"No, that's okay. We'll take it, thank you. Some hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118681","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, that's okay. We'll take it, thank you. Some hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-243feb2a3d825eddcde75d28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118682,"date":"2026-06-18T04:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118682","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35003bb5bf1bbf6039c2277e6c0f62cde386438504efeb3319634e826c8632c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-522f4117866963153094e4b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118683,"date":"2026-06-18T04:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Pass it on division.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118683","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Pass it on division.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b62b95115240ea19963bf757","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118684,"date":"2026-06-18T04:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We just said to pass it on division. Let's just pass it on division and move on. It's 11:58, people.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118684","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We just said to pass it on division. Let's just pass it on division and move on. It's 11:58, people.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90edbf5ec1ab7a61c7d3faf6b07d4136040bcc0e861ff75c5a33bf4be9655f42"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b99b60b8c9fa2fda416bb7bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118685,"date":"2026-06-18T04:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118685","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7084bec53a2d7437d085b5c816738ab6cea3d9d7228cd64e87b5cf0e464a600"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ff855f87d0e6210e460fad5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118686,"date":"2026-06-18T05:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118686","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5fc76fe8145da85b56cd2cc9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118687,"date":"2026-06-18T05:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118687","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 5; nays 6 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7084bec53a2d7437d085b5c816738ab6cea3d9d7228cd64e87b5cf0e464a600"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d48c5663ad88e051f164d255","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118688,"date":"2026-06-18T05:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"No. It is rejected on division, please. (Amendment negatived on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118688","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No. It is rejected on division, please. (Amendment negatived on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35c5eb49a8a7ddae58b3ce67fc4c775c015236685e3abcf76e1b1f10664acad7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9ca43697acb656b48acb964","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118689,"date":"2026-06-18T05:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Pass it on division. (Amendment agreed to on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118689","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Pass it on division. (Amendment agreed to on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf46fc72417f19c335339c49c46d3a3f07de288c776b163748706615a4e0f887"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e62bddc667043ef01692e44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118690,"date":"2026-06-18T05:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Let's do a voice vote on this one.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118690","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Let's do a voice vote on this one.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0c438bc0106ee37d9ac68ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118691,"date":"2026-06-18T05:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes, let's do a voice vote on this one.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118691","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, let's do a voice vote on this one.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["89cd64f3c130e1248b2ca5ff7f9b1edc18a207e82ef4db578698ee95431e1553"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-518ee9d1c6deed9ac0b87bb8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118692,"date":"2026-06-18T05:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"It's six to five.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118692","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's six to five.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd654486f5f20e6159727bf2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118693,"date":"2026-06-18T05:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 4; nays 7 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118693","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: yeas 4; nays 7 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5731019a33d879854b503b6d758fabf8493e71f69c8f31dfc31cd62499af1e9d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b30cfadb2a9268ceb5bd1df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118694,"date":"2026-06-18T05:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"On division. (Amendment agreed to on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118694","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"On division. (Amendment agreed to on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1150486383ce175d58506f008f3bd6e53f2df2cdca6eb8f75d7cad3c1755a4f2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-914bb112ddb727fec883263c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118695,"date":"2026-06-18T05:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I have a point of order, Mr. Chair. If it's out of scope, just let us know it's out of scope, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118695","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Mr. Chair. If it's out of scope, just let us know it's out of scope, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cee7a99edab648135094e48bf4565d234eca04b7e69a108d9d570a95807f88b6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8603e786ed197389e3922fb0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118696,"date":"2026-06-18T05:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. We will not challenge.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118696","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. We will not challenge.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e67b17246e37a5ed56a0ace","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118697,"date":"2026-06-18T05:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I challenge the chair, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118697","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I challenge the chair, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f113a23515b032deed5e0076","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118698,"date":"2026-06-18T05:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded division, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118698","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded division, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f0ae3ad1d6b4e629dc027b0bd50553f8ce90a8c1b7dc7e4e0e1e87aec967df2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0db2de654b585a64bdb39adc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118699,"date":"2026-06-18T05:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Pass it on division. (Amendment agreed to on division [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118699","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Pass it on division. (Amendment agreed to on division [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3260196cb2fa8ef39a037d8fb96ecb533efb3ddb4c9b5c81403eb97b30d77fa8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce18d74a49770b8358577e05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118700,"date":"2026-06-18T05:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118700","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I request a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["79566eff4089913d9bb022c83856b9cb78579987088163441de9ae5517f9e7dc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab9f07ad59917394e1d335f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118701,"date":"2026-06-18T05:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"It's quite important, yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118701","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's quite important, yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5603ce83bd6b41caf1fca32d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118702,"date":"2026-06-18T05:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Please do a recorded vote. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118702","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Please do a recorded vote. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5a6e930ebee6da7ba8b7252e41faff057278fb58f2287c8c3cc498007a9187e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3b04d2b2a99b9669e16cf27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118703,"date":"2026-06-18T05:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Please do a recorded division. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118703","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Please do a recorded division. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["14b12267fd1a5dd212236d53179d0d52c5d49747df06a96dfc46375ebe465a7a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e972ea5be47ccd3e7fbea89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118704,"date":"2026-06-18T05:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"Please do a recorded vote. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118704","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Please do a recorded vote. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["255fec19a967b05d835f9f7e5c507daaab2a2f600113d84e5f8dc9794a26b947"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce41a02d988dce7e70f8b903","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118705,"date":"2026-06-18T05:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I challenge the chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118705","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I challenge the chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0bc433783366fcc8b6787a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118706,"date":"2026-06-18T05:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118706","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35003bb5bf1bbf6039c2277e6c0f62cde386438504efeb3319634e826c8632c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55519421f25ddecf910859bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118707,"date":"2026-06-18T05:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded division. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118707","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded division. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a2b2fbcc24e86da864534db74577bfb97b1623f596cfa06a18af80fa1246b9b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac681136cfd12ea4c6c9d6ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118708,"date":"2026-06-18T05:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118708","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35003bb5bf1bbf6039c2277e6c0f62cde386438504efeb3319634e826c8632c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27e99787bc82762d87dc0f19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118709,"date":"2026-06-18T05:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded division. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118709","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded division. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a2b2fbcc24e86da864534db74577bfb97b1623f596cfa06a18af80fa1246b9b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4058969cf9851e9fb725610","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118710,"date":"2026-06-18T05:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118710","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1901189ba929808c7c3b81efbee83aa89d5610f96e2bd2dcd1e3a9fe581b24f6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0730836e396b955a8e326ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118711,"date":"2026-06-18T05:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118711","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["611c36e4339210c137e8c687da2a754de3d19f03f1606b77d3d44454c8aa21c8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c27e9f1ed8e1317426293fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118712,"date":"2026-06-18T05:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118712","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["611c36e4339210c137e8c687da2a754de3d19f03f1606b77d3d44454c8aa21c8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10500ee590dde220646b6ead","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118713,"date":"2026-06-18T05:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118713","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9815cb74f9b2b7bc961a83a16bf01c2f89eb81cb235a58916e6da1fc0088868d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fb9ebcce65f3d563c4233b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118714,"date":"2026-06-18T05:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118714","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35003bb5bf1bbf6039c2277e6c0f62cde386438504efeb3319634e826c8632c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b396773dcae6d02dabba535","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118715,"date":"2026-06-18T05:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"On division. (Amendment agreed to on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118715","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"On division. (Amendment agreed to on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1150486383ce175d58506f008f3bd6e53f2df2cdca6eb8f75d7cad3c1755a4f2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b71b5f8a564d0cda9f6444f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118716,"date":"2026-06-18T05:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118716","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c74d8c5ea7f55b699bd1fa1e467d56e929f23296166e426df5a5a3f12e0ecb88"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de3a0057a157c462acdda12c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118717,"date":"2026-06-18T05:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded division, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118717","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded division, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f28e45614bcac0b3cb37f76a5c3e2f68d7ce8db45c315a19e51e630f3fe19e28"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-014504d347acfe46c6668650","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118718,"date":"2026-06-18T05:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118718","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Amendment negatived: nays 6; yeas 5 [See Minutes of Proceedings ])","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c74d8c5ea7f55b699bd1fa1e467d56e929f23296166e426df5a5a3f12e0ecb88"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a6812cb11adb7d46d9a3bfa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118719,"date":"2026-06-18T05:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"We would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 41 as amended agreed to: yeas 6; nays 5)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118719","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We would like a recorded vote, please. (Clause 41 as amended agreed to: yeas 6; nays 5)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f59637ddeffe36a5258f1b7cf83f69853b66f5e7cddf487eeeaba41feb2209e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4045fcecacc60b950a0f026b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118720,"date":"2026-06-18T05:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"No.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118720","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f598de45668028fdb94d8be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118721,"date":"2026-06-18T05:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I know. I just said no. (Clause 42 agreed to on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ]) (On clause 43)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118721","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I know. I just said no. (Clause 42 agreed to on division [ See Minutes of Proceedings ]) (On clause 43)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1132aed8da9b85b6d29aad2f63050cf90e45efdc9006fe4b1cf69ee71cd972f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22acf1dc211faaadb449a114","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118722,"date":"2026-06-18T05:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"No. An hon. member: [ Inaudible—Editor ] Frank Caputo: I'm voting no, no matter what clause it is. Whether it's clause 47 or 48, I'm still voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118722","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No. An hon. member: [ Inaudible—Editor ] Frank Caputo: I'm voting no, no matter what clause it is. Whether it's clause 47 or 48, I'm still voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1be114463afb7a34d6fa90768169ac3190316506903a11ed89f8a9610bfe20dd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b1be883f96fde9fecb163ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118723,"date":"2026-06-18T05:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"No.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118723","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45a05d8ea477386dbec9720c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118724,"date":"2026-06-18T05:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"That's okay, Jacques. Come to our side. We'll help you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118724","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's okay, Jacques. Come to our side. We'll help you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d83ae92670b3b526c1fa95c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118725,"date":"2026-06-18T05:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"No. An hon. member: On division.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118725","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No. An hon. member: On division.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43539b5c3860881ccc7bb82f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118726,"date":"2026-06-18T05:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Bill C-22 as amended agreed to: yeas 6; nays 5)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118726","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please. (Bill C-22 as amended agreed to: yeas 6; nays 5)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55aa8b681c2b01dc539c3a8086b44e08affa622419a4049da5f99b9ad67391de"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a442e46569cca15cc9b21062","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118727,"date":"2026-06-18T05:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I think we should still vote.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118727","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think we should still vote.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3012ce2c69b5305892c63e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118728,"date":"2026-06-18T05:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"SECU","text":"I would like a recorded vote, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118728","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like a recorded vote, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d3247fb25613a55c49b1d38","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087980,"date":"2026-06-18T15:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Frank Caputo","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nBefore I begin, I want to recognize the life of Ping Beaton. She was a devoted wife and mother. I give my deepest condolences to her husband, Lawrence, who taught me in high school, and her daughter, Geralyn. May perpetual light shine upon her. \n\nWith the greatest of respect to my colleague, I have to say that sounded like a speech that was provided by a bureaucrat. He talked about the Canada investment summit. Can he tell us where that is taking place, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087980","member_id":"bc-mp-111007","member_name":"Frank Caputo","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. \n\nBefore I begin, I want to recognize the life of Ping Beaton. She was a devoted wife and mother. I give my deepest condolences to her husband, Lawrence, who taught me in high school, and her daughter, Geralyn. May perpetual light shine upon her. \n\nWith the greatest of respect to my colleague, I hav","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["732245c683ef7c0ed1faea065b09fa8da137dbdceb63306a14d83e3a4ec52044"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc5fe920d2b37aef664c1177","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76913,"date":"2026-01-26T16:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to welcome everyone back to this place, including Canadians who are watching at home. I am pleased to rise on our first day back to contribute to this debate on Bill C-228.\n\nI want to start by thanking my hon. Bloc Québécois colleague who introduced this bill.\n\nThe context for this bill is important, because it concerns how we, as parliamentarians, understand our role in relation to international commitments that can bind Canada for decades, shape domestic law, and affect the lives of Canadians in very real ways. It is particularly timely as Canada seeks to forge new relationships during a precarious time in international affairs, development and trade.\n\nBill C-228 proposes a new statutory framework for parliamentary scrutiny of treaties before ratification. It would require treaties to be formally tabled here in Parliament, along with an explanatory memorandum, before Canada can ratify them. It would establish a mandatory waiting period of at least 21 sitting days between tabling and ratification. It would define major treaties and require them to receive additional review and advice from our committees. It would also impose additional transparency obligations, including publication of treaties and related documents, while allowing for limited exceptions in urgent or exceptional circumstances provided that Parliament is informed afterwards.\n\nThese are significant proposals, and they raise important questions about balance: balance between efficiency and accountability, balance between executive authority and parliamentary oversight, and balance between Canada's need to act decisively on the world stage and Parliament's responsibility to scrutinize commitments made in Canada's name before they happen.\n\nOne strength of this bill is its attempt to bring clarity and consistency to a process that often feels opaque. Canada's current treaty policy, enacted in 2008 and updated in 2020, requires that treaties be tabled not before signature but only before ratification. This policy provides some visibility to the House but little formal influence. Ultimate authority remains with the Prime Minister and cabinet. This policy is known as the Ponsonby rule, and it was adopted from the U.K., where it has been in place since 1924. It was codified there into a law not dissimilar to this bill by the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010.\n\nThe information provided here when treaties are tabled varies, and the opportunities for meaningful debate are often limited by time or by competing priorities here in the House. Our current process does not provide Parliament with much of a say, let alone a veto. The executive branch, through the Prime Minister and cabinet, retains authority to make, really, all the decisions. The goal of giving Parliament a chance to have more input and debate is therefore worthy. Transparency is not an abstract principle in the world we currently live in. It is the foundation of democratic consent, particularly when treaties affect domestic law, public spending or regulatory authority.\n\nThis really matters at a time when many Canadians feel the government is very far away and makes decisions without consulting them, and where some treaties are seen as limiting our sovereignty. Transparency builds trust, and trust is essential to governance. We seek to ensure that parliamentarians, and by extension Canadians, are not simply presented with a fait accompli.\n\nThis bill tries to distinguish between routine agreements and those that are truly consequential. This reflects a common-sense idea. The more significant the commitment, the more rigorous the scrutiny should be, but the way \"major treaty\" is currently defined in this bill is so broad that it risks capturing nearly every treaty Canada enters into, along with amendments. At the same time, it excludes memorandums of understanding, which can have huge consequences for Canada despite not being classified as treaties under the bill.\n\nAll of that having been said, the bill should not be dismissed out of hand. There is value in examining whether current practice reflects modern expectations of privacy and accountability. Codifying aspects of existing practice, as the U.K. has done, is not radical. Bill C-228 is well intentioned. It reflects a genuine desire to strengthen democratic oversight and public confidence in Canada's treaty process. As drafted, however, it raises real concerns about feasibility and balance.\n\nI look forward to continuing this debate when time permits.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76913","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to welcome everyone back to this place, including Canadians who are watching at home. I am pleased to rise on our first day back to contribute to this debate on Bill C-228.\n\nI want to start by thanking my hon. Bloc Québécois colleague who introduced this bill.\n\nThe context for this bill is important, because it concerns how we, as parliamentarians, understand our role in rela","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90c0b01ef49b5ec2d85387439eefbda474992c0c60d92e933658e956cd291f68"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0b3bc2d8e61abaebb77c555dd816f92128dfd5e671b94a3df66acd76ed60c955"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e5ae6c932d5db4cb7c9e986","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76914,"date":"2026-01-27T19:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives worked with the government to pass Bill C-5, giving the Prime Minister extraordinary power to approve major projects quickly.\n\nThe same spirit of co-operation should bring the House together to support a Canadian sovereignty act, which would cut delays for everyone and put Canadians back in control of our destiny. The Major Projects Office is supposed to be a workaround for government delay and a fast pass for anointed projects, but the Prime Minister's words are moving faster than the work, turning the MPO into another bottleneck to prosperity. This is where our proposed sovereignty act comes in. Productivity is inseparable from affordability. When we build more and export more, productivity rises. Higher productivity drives higher incomes, making life more affordable. Canadians should not be forced to choose between moving major projects forward and getting government out of the way.\n\nThis is why we are putting forward a sovereignty act. We call on all parties to support it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76914","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives worked with the government to pass Bill C-5, giving the Prime Minister extraordinary power to approve major projects quickly.\n\nThe same spirit of co-operation should bring the House together to support a Canadian sovereignty act, which would cut delays for everyone and put Canadians back in control of our destiny. The Major Projects Office is supposed to be a workaround ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4c3d86ea604743c59bb78650e2d5b3e933ef190d00e570fac6430dcaf245b1ef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b5fccd757637120746c8b06425718ce8a5f7e212f9dd1c299c378759499c241"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6378a0e79c7eafa977826069","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76915,"date":"2026-01-27T20:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, near the end of his speech, the hon. member spoke about the MOU with Alberta. We know Alberta has identified some of the very pieces of legislation listed as ones we want to affect through a sovereignty act. These are ones that are impediments to moving projects forward.\n\nMy question for the hon. member is this: Why can we not have both? Why do we have to choose between what he calls a Liberal vision and a Conservative vision? Why can we not have both the major projects and repeal the things that are getting in the way of building Canada for our next generation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76915","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, near the end of his speech, the hon. member spoke about the MOU with Alberta. We know Alberta has identified some of the very pieces of legislation listed as ones we want to affect through a sovereignty act. These are ones that are impediments to moving projects forward.\n\nMy question for the hon. member is this: Why can we not have both? Why do we have to choose between what he call","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59482","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59482","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Railway accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59482","label":"Railway accidents","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["680dad7951c559e932ca7c89e5727e7ed0d0eeadff5a635ab744adc41e4ca8f0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e65e66e807356a889bd4700","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76916,"date":"2026-01-27T21:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, last week in Davos, the Prime Minister outlined his vision to restore Canada's position as a leading middle power in the world. In the prequel to that speech last October, he reminded a room full of young Canadians that it will take time and sacrifice to realize that vision. In both speeches, the Prime Minister framed the hardship we will face in Canada to realize that vision as unavoidable, temporary and noble. He promised to always be straight about the challenges we have to face and the choices we must make as a country.\n\nThe promise of the Prime Minister's Canada appears to be this: Things are going to be hard now, but worth it in the long run. If we just hold on, the future will be better. We will be an energy superpower, diversified abroad and strong at home. This message has gone over well with Canadians who have the assets to weather the coming storm, those seeking stability and soothing reassurance in turbulent times. However, for those Canadians who do not already own a home and those who do not already have those sustaining investments, those people, and especially our youth, are faced with a future that keeps moving further away.\n\nFor them, the struggle is not about great power rivalry or global supply chains. It is about rent that eats up more than half their paycheques, groceries that cost more every month and having two or three jobs that still do not provide enough to live on. For them, Canada has become a country where doing everything right no longer guarantees stability, let alone prosperity. It is a place where they are being told their sacrifice is the price of global leadership, the price of a new world order.\n\nThe question they are asking is, order for whom? For these folks, it feels like Canada is asking them to continually give things up, while asking very little of those who already have the most. They are asked to delay home ownership so asset values of current homeowners can be protected. They are asked to shoulder debt, taxes and rising costs in the name of an abstract national good that never quite shows up in their own lives. They are being told that what they are experiencing is inevitable, the fault of global forces beyond our control. They work, they pay, they comply and the promise of Canada feels increasingly hollow to them.\n\nAcross the board, our youth are the first generation who will be worse off than their parents. Their parents are the first generation that believe their children will not be better off than them. The most dangerous divide in Canada today may be between those who are willing to accept that and those of us who are fighting tooth and nail to change it. When a system only works if the next generation accepts less than the last, that system is not stable. It is living on borrowed time.\n\nThe Prime Minister speaks beautifully about honesty in foreign policy, about taking signs out of windows and about refusing to pretend that old systems still function as advertised. That same honesty is needed at home because we cannot talk about building strength domestically while an entire generation feels weaker every year. We cannot speak of resilience while young Canadians are one missed paycheque away from crisis. We cannot claim to be investing in the future while systematically pricing that future out of reach.\n\nWe are told that Canada must be outward-looking, engaged everywhere and invested in everything: trade deals, partnerships, defence commitments and global leadership. However, a country that is everywhere abroad and absent at home is not strong. It is distracted. Being principled does not only mean standing up on the world stage. It means standing up for the people who live here now, not just those who bought in decades ago. That is why the Conservatives have proposed a Canadian sovereignty act.\n\nThe rhetoric in the summer and fall sessions of the House seemed to pit Liberal ideas against Conservative ones: We could have the Major Projects Office to fast-track anointed projects, or we could repeal the long list of legislation that gets in the way of those same projects. Conservatives let the Prime Minister have Bill C-5, giving him the chance to show Canadians through his Major Projects Office that his big ideas about big government would do the trick for Canadians. However, the Prime Minister's words are moving faster than his work, turning the Major Projects Office into another bottleneck to prosperity.\n\nAfter announcements in September, October and November referring two tranches of projects to the MPO, we have heard nothing. Referring a project to the MPO does not mean that it has been approved, and none of the potential projects of national interest have actually emerged from the black box of the MPO to be formally recognized by cabinet as such, which means that they are not yet, in fact, exempt from the federal laws holding them back.\n\nThis is where our Canadian sovereignty act comes in by getting government out of the way by repealing the federal laws that block development, incentivizing the provinces to fully open their markets to fellow Canadians, rewarding those who reinvest in the Canadian economy to stop the flight of capital from our country and ensuring continued Canadian ownership of Canadian innovations. We do not have to choose and we should not have to choose. We should be able to have the Major Projects Office and get government out of the way for the rest of us.\n\nYounger Canadians are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for a fair deal, for a country that does not require them to sacrifice indefinitely so existing wealth can be preserved untouched, for policies that recognize housing is a place to live before it is an investment, and for a government that recognizes that security starts with food security at the grocery store and that economic strength is measured in whether people can build a life, not just on whether capital can move freely in global markets.\n\nWith the Canadian sovereignty act, Conservatives have taken the sign out of our domestic window on behalf of those without homes and on behalf of those without investments to protect from the changing world order, because those generations no longer believe the government's story about future prosperity. If Canada is serious about building strength at home, that strength must include our next generation. That strength must include those who are struggling, not as an afterthought, not as a talking point, but as a priority. We do not need nostalgia from the past. On that, I agree with the Prime Minister. However, we do need fairness and opportunity in the present.\n\nYoung Canadians are not turning away from this country. They are waiting for this country to turn back to them. If we want them to believe again, if we want them to invest their lives here, then Canada must stop asking them to carry the cost of stability in a disproportionate way. That is what living in truth looks like at home, and that is the path forward that actually lasts.\n\nI say again: Canadians should not be forced to choose between major projects and getting government out of the way. They should be able to have both. That is why we have put forward a Canadian sovereignty act, and we call on all parties in the House to support it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76916","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, last week in Davos, the Prime Minister outlined his vision to restore Canada's position as a leading middle power in the world. In the prequel to that speech last October, he reminded a room full of young Canadians that it will take time and sacrifice to realize that vision. In both speeches, the Prime Minister framed the hardship we will face in Canada to realize that vision as una","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f4663da5a53d21a0e641cd19db396721f4280c96677e282c7d97d1ad0e93ddc0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb2495b2a24b087e28c994045a98b7ac053c06a90e7d054a0bbb90242b469edc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd9e8e824b800ecf4b094c7c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76917,"date":"2026-01-27T21:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I have been thinking a lot about topics like this over the past weeks, and what I think this really reflects on is the concept of agency. Agency is one of the real things that divide us on this side of the House from our colleagues in government on the other side of the House.\n\nWe firmly believe in agency, and we can see it in this concept of the sovereignty act. We firmly believe that if we get government out of the way, the good people of this country have the ability to build their own lives, make their own decisions and move our economy and the Canadian dream forward. That is where we see hope.\n\nOn the other hand, the hon. members across the aisle tend to believe in larger institutions. They tend to believe in bureaucracy and in centralized control of things. I think this is one of the big debates that we are having in this House, and it is going to continue.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76917","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I have been thinking a lot about topics like this over the past weeks, and what I think this really reflects on is the concept of agency. Agency is one of the real things that divide us on this side of the House from our colleagues in government on the other side of the House.\n\nWe firmly believe in agency, and we can see it in this concept of the sovereignty act. We firmly believe t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social structure","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","label":"Social structure","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bcc9d82774c549cca7e1349cef5b37b15a5f734e6d45c06bde57d30991fc097d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea003f81e3fcc99d95a26f2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76918,"date":"2026-01-27T21:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the whole thesis that the Conservatives are putting forward through this sovereignty act is the idea that we should stop the flight of capital outside of this country. We should remove the barriers to investment here, the things that cause Canadians to want to invest in other countries, and help bring that capital and investment back to Canada by removing the barriers to that.\n\nThat is exactly what we are trying to do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76918","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the whole thesis that the Conservatives are putting forward through this sovereignty act is the idea that we should stop the flight of capital outside of this country. We should remove the barriers to investment here, the things that cause Canadians to want to invest in other countries, and help bring that capital and investment back to Canada by removing the barriers to that.\n\nThat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b1d8c5838dd035f0c1f8de04de18d07d95adfe44bb43715db2ff5fdb4c523bbc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8d4b8c6da7f765389f5b79067b6aaf1c09ca464a9ca1b926a56ba86212df3351"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b2e9221c310c2a38abfaec0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76919,"date":"2026-01-27T21:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I think it is incredibly rich for the member opposite, who keeps referring to this as a new government, to look into the past to try to assume that Conservatives cannot change and that we cannot put forward new ideas. From a government with which we have offered to co-operate, it is especially distressing that he continues with the insults and the rhetoric and that he is not willing to work with us on this act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76919","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I think it is incredibly rich for the member opposite, who keeps referring to this as a new government, to look into the past to try to assume that Conservatives cannot change and that we cannot put forward new ideas. From a government with which we have offered to co-operate, it is especially distressing that he continues with the insults and the rhetoric and that he is not willing","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["acc1202c818d637b21abd7874941011ebef1548ac473d56c257b6506d2737995"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa6ef761a23706891fb8622a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76920,"date":"2026-01-27T22:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I request a recorded division.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76920","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I request a recorded division.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d54b99a05df22b2d0021a416","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76921,"date":"2026-01-28T20:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise to present a petition from Canadians concerned about Bill C-9. Faith, as we know, is a matter of conscience, and the petitioners are worried that the state is interfering with their religious texts and teachings, will impinge on religious freedom and lead to government overreach in matters of faith. They are calling on the House to prevent government interference in faith, religious belief and practice.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76921","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise to present a petition from Canadians concerned about Bill C-9. Faith, as we know, is a matter of conscience, and the petitioners are worried that the state is interfering with their religious texts and teachings, will impinge on religious freedom and lead to government overreach in matters of faith. They are calling on the House to prevent government interference in faith, re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ac499315c36c24f7a27a63e45fe11f3d6e9973aee4172abad2a389a5e111a118"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d3de3f1cab12217302aa8fd0a0f783a1088650e3df5e0f573a8c7bd7d6e3bd77"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a7d702fb9f1bbe3e8c5b40f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":80931,"date":"2026-02-03T19:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today is February 3, the first day that 254 forestry workers at the Crofton Mill are out of work. Almost all of them are still without jobs, and another 125 workers will be following them to the unemployment line in the coming weeks.\n\n Since the Prime Minister took office, Vancouver Island has seen a steady drumbeat of mill curtailments and closures. Shifts are being cut, mills are being idled and families are turning to food banks in record numbers. When a mill shuts down, the whole community is closed. Crofton workers met with Liberal ministers in good faith and put forward practical, targeted proposals. They were promised employment, insurance support and transition funding. Ministers looked my communities in the eye and made those commitments. Well, it is February 3. The Crofton workers and others on curtailment in my community are out in the cold and still waiting. \n\nI am asking for an urgent meeting with the minister to discuss the reasonable request Crofton workers made. Our communities deserve more than words and \"someday\" promises. They deserve action.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80931","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today is February 3, the first day that 254 forestry workers at the Crofton Mill are out of work. Almost all of them are still without jobs, and another 125 workers will be following them to the unemployment line in the coming weeks.\n\n Since the Prime Minister took office, Vancouver Island has seen a steady drumbeat of mill curtailments and closures. Shifts are being cut, mills are be","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2ea4ff1f3647ba142688f639c01fbae83a97fa8950f06cc934b511df7fee528b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4f898cd3d0bdc4463367388e80dfe8ada3774ad0dfdb81178e5e604aa3b01eeb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09edc99655430264094cf229","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":80929,"date":"2026-02-05T16:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for talking about the expropriation of land in Mirabel in 1969 and about the impact that decision had on people's lives. That is a painful chapter for many families who lost their homes, their land and their jobs.\n\nLooking back, what lessons does the member think we should learn from that? How can these lessons help governments work better with communities in the future?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80929","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for talking about the expropriation of land in Mirabel in 1969 and about the impact that decision had on people's lives. That is a painful chapter for many families who lost their homes, their land and their jobs.\n\nLooking back, what lessons does the member think we should learn from that? How can these lessons help governments work better with communities in the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7dd598be10d4f9fa3cb1e05c78e47d27fba6babfeb9084247bf5556ecd1feacf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ddd7e3add46692bc6e11fc54","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":80930,"date":"2026-02-05T16:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for raising the issue of the expropriation of land in Mirabel in 1969 and for reminding us of the long-term effects this has had on local families. Many people felt that they were not being heard at the time.\n\nIn the hon. member's opinion, what should the government do today to listen to communities more and to treat them more fairly when major projects are planned?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80930","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for raising the issue of the expropriation of land in Mirabel in 1969 and for reminding us of the long-term effects this has had on local families. Many people felt that they were not being heard at the time.\n\nIn the hon. member's opinion, what should the government do today to listen to communities more and to treat them more fairly when major projects ar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hearing disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","label":"Hearing disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a1f3b2202bd17516e0485d3da70b392f05d8382db6ad60b02b9832590fb351c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7ecb9dabf26a69d562b854ea59b8b4d5af6caaf548787bd80a2129f59a31a48b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb68fae9b8d01a8791e3405e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":307816,"date":"2026-02-25T19:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister falsely claims he has our immigration system under control, but when a non-Canadian on a student visa can spy on his female housemates for six months and not get deported, Canadians know the system is out of control. He recorded them in various states of undress. He recorded them using the bathroom, but instead of protecting these women, Liberal sentencing discounts allow immigration consequences to benefit the offender.\n\nWhen did the Liberals abandon vulnerable women, and when will the Prime Minister finally take accountability and fire his immigration minister?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:307816","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister falsely claims he has our immigration system under control, but when a non-Canadian on a student visa can spy on his female housemates for six months and not get deported, Canadians know the system is out of control. He recorded them in various states of undress. He recorded them using the bathroom, but instead of protecting these women, Liberal sentencing discounts","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["66fc6eb1deb552034bccbf37113c4589478649f87edda180387f0e3c14115fe3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ffc7ed1725b0e9044e6f687da340fe7ce935e65ae5fedcec24a3d43d481d6231"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fe371efce27892fd2cbe5a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":307817,"date":"2026-02-25T19:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is not an answer, and this is not isolated. When a non-citizen can sexually assault someone's 18-year-old daughter twice and not be deported, the system is out of control. This offender was found guilty of sexual assault. The judge knew he would be deported, but then they gave him a discharge and probation, so another criminal stays in Canada. \n\nThe Liberals accuse us of all kinds of things, but their judges are pleading down at the expense of our daughters, so I will ask again: When will the Prime Minister fire his immigration minister and get immigration back under control?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:307817","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is not an answer, and this is not isolated. When a non-citizen can sexually assault someone's 18-year-old daughter twice and not be deported, the system is out of control. This offender was found guilty of sexual assault. The judge knew he would be deported, but then they gave him a discharge and probation, so another criminal stays in Canada. \n\nThe Liberals accuse us of all kind","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["59f98367226186799833011ebae25427213321ddb98a177076dc8e7ffbeaa725"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c21adb255285e42356f0eb51c79bc20775c27fd6909e6731505e193fedfeedc9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-496bd8290b010ca5a9755712","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342466,"date":"2026-03-09T16:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-233, an act to amend the Export and Import Permits Act. In presenting this bill, my hon. colleague from Vancouver East has argued that Canada must ensure that our domestic laws live up to our commitments under the Arms Trade Treaty, or ATT. She has raised serious concerns that are worthy of thoughtful consideration. Indeed, I believe all members of the House share the fundamental goals behind Bill C-233: making sure that Canada acts responsibly on the global stage, ensuring that our exports reflect Canadian values and aligning our policies with both international law and humanitarian principles. The question before us today, therefore, is not whether those goals are worthwhile, because they clearly are, but whether Bill C-233, as drafted, is the best way to achieve them.\n\nI have followed the debate on this bill closely and want to thank colleagues from all parties for their contributions to the legislative record. Their remarks have been well researched, and their arguments have shaped my own position on the bill, which does not actually target any particular country or conflict but seeks to constrain Canadian policy and practice across the board. Because of that breadth, it is crucial for us to think carefully and practically about the impact that passing this bill would have on our sovereignty, our security and our global relationships, and we must be vigilant about avoiding unintended consequences, because the new world order the Prime Minister is fond of speaking of is a complex and dangerous place. Getting that balance right matters if Canada is going to realize its potential as a leading middle power, especially in the context of our geographic location, our obligations to NATO and our other allies, and our international commitments.\n\nWhen determining whether Canada's export approach should change, as proposed by Bill C-233, we must first examine and evaluate the strength of Canada's existing export control regime. In my preparation and research for these remarks, I was pleased to learn that Canada already has one of the most stringent systems in the world for regulating the export of military goods and technology and that our standards not only meet those set out in the ATT but in many respects exceed them.\n\nIn his detailed speech explaining why the Liberal government will not be supporting this bill, the parliamentary secretary for foreign affairs explained that Canada's export control system already places human rights considerations at its very core and that Canada has gone above and beyond the requirements of the Arms Trade Treaty. Canada already applies exemptions more narrowly than any other ATT signatory. We control a wider range of items than the treaty requires, including dual-use goods and nuclear, chemical, biological and missile technologies. Canada imposes stricter denial criteria than those specified under the ATT, including risks of contributing to transnational violence, terrorism and organized crime. Canada also already has and enforces strict controls on Canadians involved in transfers of military goods abroad, even when those goods never actually enter Canada.\n\nThere is a measure of transparency already in place, in the sense that the government has been tabling annual reports to Parliament on exports governed by the ATT since the 1990s, even before the treaty was ratified. As an issue this important should be, our approach to Canadian military exports has been serious and largely non-partisan. To verify these assertions, I reviewed some of the government's recent reports that are available to the public on the Global Affairs Canada website. Current law and practice require Global Affairs Canada to assess whether proposed exports would contribute to peace and security or undermine it and whether they could facilitate serious violations of international humanitarian law. I was encouraged to see that export permits are not rubber-stamped. Applications have been denied, suspended or cancelled on occasion according to the established criteria.\n\nHowever, our analysis of the bill and its potential should not stop there. Every system can be improved, so we must also consider the broader economic and strategic context in which Canada operates. Our defence sector is deeply integrated with those of our closest allies. A significant portion of Canadian defence exports consists not of finished systems but of components and specialized technologies that form part of multinational supply chains. This integrated industrial base supports thousands of highly skilled jobs across our country, enabling Canada to collaborate with partners that share our values in areas ranging from aerospace engineering to advanced manufacturing.\n\nDuring the debate, both the parliamentary secretary, for the government, and the shadow minister for foreign affairs, along with numerous other speakers with expertise in defence and international relations, have warned that Bill C-233 could have significant unintended consequences for that co-operation at a critical moment for global security. They argued, and I agree from my own experience in international affairs, that the exemptions within the current regime are not loopholes but rather necessary pathways for co-operation grounded in shared security commitments, continental defence and decades of military integration.\n\nMy colleagues have warned that this legislation could disrupt defence co-operation, strain alliances and ultimately make Canada less secure. They have cautioned that the legislation has the potential to reshape an entire industrial sector and that those changes could place Canadian suppliers at a competitive disadvantage and hinder Canada's ability to support crucial international partners that are under threat at a critical time. These concerns are not mere hypotheticals in the current international landscape. \n\nCanada's export policies operate within a broader framework of alliances, trade relationships and co-operative defence arrangements. Prudence requires that we approach changes to these relationships with care and a clear understanding of the downstream effects. We must consider how the bill could affect Canada's credibility as a reliable participant in joint industrial and security initiatives. Legislation always produces some consequences beyond its stated objectives. Even well-intentioned measures can have unintended side effects in sectors as interconnected and technologically complex as defence manufacturing. \n\nDuring the debate, a member of the Bloc Québécois made an observation that captures the nuance required here. While acknowledging the motivations behind the bill, he argued that the goal of stronger oversight does not automatically mean that every proposed mechanism for achieving it will work. This is where Bill C-233 falls short. It attempts to address legitimate concerns, but it does so through sweeping legislative changes that could unintentionally disrupt economic stability, industrial co-operation and strategic partnerships.\n\nRather than rewriting the law in ways that could destabilize existing arrangements, we should take the more balanced path of improving transparency, enhancing reporting requirements and strengthening oversight within the current framework. GAC could expand the detail of annual export reports. We could improve parliamentary review of export decisions or invest in additional monitoring of supply chains, addressing concerns about accountability while avoiding unnecessary economic or diplomatic disruption through broad changes in law. We must weigh the moral aspirations behind the proposal against its practical consequences. We must ask not only whether a bill reflects our values but whether it would function effectively in the real world. In the case of Bill C-233, that balance has not been achieved. The mechanisms proposed raise significant concerns about economic stability, industrial co-operation and international partnerships.\n\nLet us commit to continuing the conversation about how Canada can strengthen oversight, improve transparency and uphold the highest standards of responsibility in our export policies while preserving the partnerships, jobs and institutions that Canadians depend on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342466","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-233, an act to amend the Export and Import Permits Act. In presenting this bill, my hon. colleague from Vancouver East has argued that Canada must ensure that our domestic laws live up to our commitments under the Arms Trade Treaty, or ATT. She has raised serious concerns that are worthy of thoughtful consideration. Indeed, I believe all members of th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b5925dfc0fc7e90ea0181758d7b4668aa92e88a9d86588f97b6612365833a5ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce3b9b886a4445b92f213a363b0be88519b6194f84c6a9aa398a01b090421b7c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-424f26eaba2c9fd47843cfbd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342467,"date":"2026-03-10T02:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, at the beginning of this operation in Iran, the Prime Minister was in the same place as the hon. member who has just spoken in the House. Since then, the Prime Minister has described the same strikes as a dangerous escalation, has said that Canada supported them \"with regret\", has suggested that they reflect a \"failure of the international order\", has raised concerns that the strikes appear \"inconsistent with international law\" and has called for de-escalation and diplomacy. However, despite all that disapproval, he has not ruled out the possibility that Canada might want to get involved at some point. There are 700 members of the IRGC in Canada terrorizing and maybe even murdering the Canadians whom the member says we should be worried about as our primary cause.\n\n I want to know if the hon. member will commit his government to expelling IRGC operatives—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342467","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, at the beginning of this operation in Iran, the Prime Minister was in the same place as the hon. member who has just spoken in the House. Since then, the Prime Minister has described the same strikes as a dangerous escalation, has said that Canada supported them \"with regret\", has suggested that they reflect a \"failure of the international order\", has raised concerns that the strikes ap","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22dc11e6d7bd65a34d686440af263e451b3ecdc8c17ad47bcc1f7d852893c1d9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cbc5f749af6094931dc61d87","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342468,"date":"2026-03-10T02:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, an Iranian member of my local community wrote to me to say that Iranians have tried peaceful protest and civil resistance for years, only to face arrest, torture and deadly crackdowns. They have tried diplomacy, and gotten hangings and executions. She wrote to me that a democratic Iran would significantly improve regional stability and reduce the global threats posed by the IRGC.\n\n If the member does not believe in war, but still wants to see quick regime change, what realistic path for change does he believe remains open to the Iranian people?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342468","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, an Iranian member of my local community wrote to me to say that Iranians have tried peaceful protest and civil resistance for years, only to face arrest, torture and deadly crackdowns. They have tried diplomacy, and gotten hangings and executions. She wrote to me that a democratic Iran would significantly improve regional stability and reduce the global threats posed by the IRGC.\n\n If t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d1df9d34cf16b40c4f4a1d1c10610a9aaa1862f2baf78d72a558a163f840229"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec22108414652a9154b0c046","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342461,"date":"2026-03-10T16:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, Canadians are now very familiar with Václav Havel's greengrocer, who displays a sign in his window not because he believes it but because it is what one does, what is familiar and what is required.\n\nIn Davos, the Prime Minister talked about taking the sign out of the window. Today, I want to talk about how the sign got there in the first place, because Havel's parable was a warning, a warning about how democracy and freedom degrade when we create a society where people say what they are supposed to say, regardless of what they believe, and about the problems that arise when the only acceptable speech is narrowed to what is written on signs. As many of those who have immigrated to this great country will tell us, where there are signs in windows, the signs always start out fine. The problem is that there inevitably comes a time when the people in charge change the signs, and by the time they do, it is always too late. There is no more room for dissent, and the people who helped put up the signs find that they have become prisoners in the very system they helped build.\n\nThe problem is that when the signs first go up, people like them. They are reassuring. They create a sense of moral clarity for the majority whose views are reflected in them, but that comfort comes at an unacceptable cost. When societies begin rewarding the display of approved ideas instead of the honest exchange of them, something essential begins to erode. It surprises me that the government of a Prime Minister who invoked Havel's greengrocer would be allowed to do what it is doing today. Members should make no mistake about it. This motion and the sentiments behind it, along with the bill, are a giant sign in a very small window. That is where the real risks to our society begin.\n\nIf the story of Bill C-9 were a play, we would now be in the third act. In the first act, when the bill was introduced, I raised three serious concerns in the chamber, two of which have not been fixed in committee. The first is the vagueness of the bill's definition of hate. Criminal law must be clear and precise. When definitions are vague, they create uncertainty about what speech will be criminalized, and that creates an opportunity for weaponization outside of the criminal system. The second is the reality that the laws we already have in Canada to combat hate and incitement to violence on the basis of hate are not being enforced. Where provincial governments are unwilling or unable to enforce existing words, adding more words is not going to help.\n\nThe concerns I expressed were not Conservative. They are shared by a remarkably broad coalition of Canadians. Religious organizations and civil liberties groups from across the political spectrum have raised similar alarms. Groups as diverse as the United Church of Canada, the Canadian Muslim Public Affairs Council, the Evangelical Fellowship of Canada, the Christian Legal Fellowship, the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops and the rabbinical council of Toronto all sounded the alarm about the bill's potential impact on freedom of expression and religious liberty. A rabbi, a priest and an imam literally approached the bar of the House of Commons, and the government ignored them. Despite those concerns, we moved the bill to committee because we agreed with its stated objectives. No one in the House supports hatred or violence directed at any community. Canadians expect Parliament to confront both.\n\nThat brings us to the second act. At committee, the Liberals and the Bloc Québécois amended the bill to remove the long-standing religious defence contained in section 319 of the Criminal Code. This defence protects statements made in good faith on a religious subject based on belief in a religious text. That is where everything went off the rails.\n\nThis defence has never protected the deliberate promotion of hatred or calls for violence. It exists to ensure that Canadians can express sincere religious beliefs without fear that their words could be criminalized simply because someone else finds them offensive. It also exists so that dialogue can happen that might cause people to change those views. When the Liberal-Bloc amendment passed, it immediately revealed the danger that many of us had warned about. Within hours, people online were celebrating the change and claiming that individuals could now be prosecuted for expressing traditional religious views. That is not what the law actually says, but the reaction illustrates the chilling effect that the amendment creates. It encourages the belief that the Criminal Code can now be used to silence views that people dislike.\n\nCanada's legal tradition has long recognized the importance of state neutrality in matters of faith. Parliament included the religious defence in the hate propaganda provisions because it understood that criminal law must not be used to police religious doctrine. The state must not edit the Bible. Our courts have recognized that balance. In the Keegstra decision, the Supreme Court upheld Canada's hate propaganda laws in part because of the safeguards Parliament had included, including the protection for good-faith religious expression that the House now seeks to remove.\n\nParliament has revisited these provisions several times over the decades, as new groups were added to the Criminal Code. Each time, members across party lines concluded that protecting vulnerable communities and protecting freedom of religion must go hand in hand. Removing that safeguard continues to risk upsetting a constitutional balance that has been carefully managed for decades.\n\nThen, during the parliamentary break, something interesting happened. The government began hearing from Canadians who did not want the sign in the window. Canadians from across the political and religious spectrum were alarmed at the direction the bill has taken. One might have expected the government to reflect and reconsider, but instead it decided to shut down debate on its own bill, just a few minutes ago, which brings us to the third act.\n\n We are now debating Bill C-9 under time constraints because the government is determined to pass it quickly, even if that means passing it in a way that restricts our ability to continue to have dialogue about these topics in society. The irony is difficult to miss. When government seeks to expand the power of the state to regulate expression while restricting debate about those powers, Parliament should pause, because the danger is not only that the law might punish the wrong people. The deeper danger is that it may change how people speak to each other in the first place.\n\n Canada can and must confront hatred, but criminal law must be precise, restrained and grounded in constitutional principles. I return to the very arguments I stood to make in the House in September, in the first act of the discussion on the bill. If we are serious about addressing hatred, I remain convinced and reiterate that the first step is to work with the provinces and municipalities to enforce the laws we already have. The Criminal Code already prohibits the wilful promotion of hatred and the incitement of violence. Those provisions should be applied consistently and effectively. \n\nIf real gaps exist, Parliament can address them, but any changes must be carefully drafted and respectful of the charter rights that define our country. What we should not do is expand vague criminal provisions, remove long-standing safeguards for religious expression and then rush the legislation through Parliament by shutting down debate. That approach does not strengthen public confidence in the law. It weakens it, for those who feel threatened. \n\nA free society should never push its citizens toward the greengrocer's window where the safest choice is to display the approved message and keep one's real beliefs to oneself, and Parliament should never pass a law that risks creating that pressure in the first place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342461","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, Canadians are now very familiar with Václav Havel's greengrocer, who displays a sign in his window not because he believes it but because it is what one does, what is familiar and what is required.\n\nIn Davos, the Prime Minister talked about taking the sign out of the window. Today, I want to talk about how the sign got there in the first place, because Havel's parable was a warning,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e813df3740231df9d142abb738a2902d699f9389bc75602416876fe51a192e3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1f5830e9aceb1387505f1721af726291b6f26c7ec1d46c59dcccfcfd30a64c7d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac8162f04d1b1bc5261465eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342462,"date":"2026-03-10T16:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am not sure that the hon. member listened to my speech. I have just engaged in detail with the views of the government. I am not saying the government does not have the right to pass any legislation it can get through the House. What I am saying is that it ought to think twice about what it has heard from Canadians about the legislation. I am suggesting that the government ought to consider that it is limiting debate on a conversation that is not finished.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342462","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am not sure that the hon. member listened to my speech. I have just engaged in detail with the views of the government. I am not saying the government does not have the right to pass any legislation it can get through the House. What I am saying is that it ought to think twice about what it has heard from Canadians about the legislation. I am suggesting that the government ought t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b5336df5442a33634d2c7f9691f72573cf944eeba6f0d77f208e0a0ce4a4b25"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15ab29510eade76deb43e780","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342463,"date":"2026-03-10T17:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the position that law enforcement officers and criminal lawyers have taken is that the existing provisions of the Criminal Code are sufficient to deal with that situation. The government has not put forward any argument to suggest that the changes that would be made by this bill would result in that arrest. In fact, I would be willing to go so far as to predict right now that the day after Bill C-9 is passed, no one would be arrested who could not be arrested today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342463","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the position that law enforcement officers and criminal lawyers have taken is that the existing provisions of the Criminal Code are sufficient to deal with that situation. The government has not put forward any argument to suggest that the changes that would be made by this bill would result in that arrest. In fact, I would be willing to go so far as to predict right now that the da","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b43e13ba331e7b1cf0abc4b79f68cf6fc4b80c485a6023ad223aad859277dff6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c3ddc43a0fb6ef0efee998dbfddc4e952462f6448426135d31f72bd472179e3e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce6b2c64f35e9f971fc778c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342464,"date":"2026-03-10T17:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, within an hour of the Liberal-Bloc amendment to remove the defence of religious freedoms associated with the Criminal Code provisions in section 319, I received a text from a constituent saying how delighted that person was that these changes had passed so that a whole bunch of people could now be thrown in jail. \n\nI made this comment at committee. I do not for one second think that enforcement is going to change as a result of this bill being passed. I do think there will be a whole bunch of words thrown around, a whole bunch of allegations made, and it is going to take us years to sort out the legal mess that results from people's opinions about the consequences of changing these provisions in the code.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342464","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, within an hour of the Liberal-Bloc amendment to remove the defence of religious freedoms associated with the Criminal Code provisions in section 319, I received a text from a constituent saying how delighted that person was that these changes had passed so that a whole bunch of people could now be thrown in jail. \n\nI made this comment at committee. I do not for one second think that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["53ebf1a0ae80467760a850d8cf2d8f08f48cee28ef69085ed961d4876398805a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["105fde9bb3e537f7978d007fc716b1215c503964acc24d790bd5aa60a178682d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8505fe40c912addc0afc28a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342465,"date":"2026-03-10T19:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Liberals are allowing foreign conflicts to spill onto our streets, and Canadians are paying the price. An Iranian activist is missing, and it looks more and more like Tehran is involved. Meanwhile, hundreds of IRGC agents live in Canada, hanging out in cafés and going to the gym, yet Canadian officials say they cannot deport these terrorists because they can claim asylum, there are no flights to Iran, and their privacy must be protected.\n\n Thoughts and prayers are not going to cut it. Why is the immigration minister still failing to protect Canadians, and why does she still have her job?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342465","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Liberals are allowing foreign conflicts to spill onto our streets, and Canadians are paying the price. An Iranian activist is missing, and it looks more and more like Tehran is involved. Meanwhile, hundreds of IRGC agents live in Canada, hanging out in cafés and going to the gym, yet Canadian officials say they cannot deport these terrorists because they can claim asylum, there are no","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a7a1c0dc666f6ed6a18f9f7595b2acfb2da0243166cfb7c000ecd26da60d3c88"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["149c1939c51dda7d5e68d6b528d4e2fbbc1dcc1ce4841a96c9628129d040fb4c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78298ebf1e3d2ac8319fc263","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342460,"date":"2026-03-11T20:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is my honour to present a petition on behalf of Canadians who are opposed to Bill C-9. They are concerned that this broad and overreaching piece of legislation would restrict freedom of expression and freedom of religion. They call upon the government to not restrict debate on it and to withdraw the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342460","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is my honour to present a petition on behalf of Canadians who are opposed to Bill C-9. They are concerned that this broad and overreaching piece of legislation would restrict freedom of expression and freedom of religion. They call upon the government to not restrict debate on it and to withdraw the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c5040d1500883e7d042d2af08339941011efde11c979599f10771de24c50a6d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6879b7c8d3b7e1a22765603e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342459,"date":"2026-03-13T16:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there have always been conflicts abroad. The government's job is to make sure they stay there, because when they do not, Canadians pay the price. \n\nWe fear a missing Iranian man may have been murdered by Tehran. Three more synagogues were shot at this week and another was vandalized. Meanwhile, IRGC agents continue to live in Canada, hanging out in cafes and going to the gym. Liberals make excuses as to why they cannot deport these terrorists: They can claim asylum; there are no flights; or their privacy must be protected. It is time to protect Canadians.\n\n On behalf of Iranians in my community, I am calling on the Liberals to table a plan within one week to enforce deportations, crack down on regime financing, coordinate sanctions, get their act together on terrorism threat levels and gaps in national security laws, establish the foreign influence registry and stop approving refugee claims without in-person interviews. We need no more talk. It is time to act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342459","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there have always been conflicts abroad. The government's job is to make sure they stay there, because when they do not, Canadians pay the price. \n\nWe fear a missing Iranian man may have been murdered by Tehran. Three more synagogues were shot at this week and another was vandalized. Meanwhile, IRGC agents continue to live in Canada, hanging out in cafes and going to the gym. Liberals","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3e21a10affc2a049a22a78406810463c036876c7534ebc3c2d039b0403f19ef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["25f776e08252806e38cf05ff0a5a694fbe1bc7a2bbd711b635520ffa3467dfff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00cdd9aceb9fbb90fff2f569","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":387751,"date":"2026-03-24T19:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, 153,000 student visa cases were flagged for fraud, with less than 3% probed, and 92% of fraudsters were waved through for shots at work permits, residency and asylum. The Auditor General has exposed an immigration system so broken it cannot enforce its own rules. However, instead of fixing it, the Liberals are going to issue even more permits. Even Liberals say the immigration minister has to go. It is well past time to clean house.\n\nWhy is the Prime Minister still keeping not one, not two, but three failed immigration ministers in his cabinet?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387751","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, 153,000 student visa cases were flagged for fraud, with less than 3% probed, and 92% of fraudsters were waved through for shots at work permits, residency and asylum. The Auditor General has exposed an immigration system so broken it cannot enforce its own rules. However, instead of fixing it, the Liberals are going to issue even more permits. Even Liberals say the immigration ministe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bc8a0e6ae333f2e749e4909145eda1e1d533457fd790001e9b214f21c751a1ef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["de7bcfc2e795d3f72826f98baf39e7c0274f359f696441b489c7e7fbf3248736"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d6000818d5df3923a80b276","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":387750,"date":"2026-03-25T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on the west coast we do not just live near the ocean. We live on it. Time on the water is how we connect with friends, clear our heads and put food on the table. It is practically therapy, and we might even catch dinner, but now the Liberals are putting 9,100 jobs and a $1.76-billion industry at risk with proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy.\n\n Will this east coast minister show respect for our west coast way of life by committing right now to maintaining priority for public fisheries and certainty of public access to salmon to feed our families?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387750","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on the west coast we do not just live near the ocean. We live on it. Time on the water is how we connect with friends, clear our heads and put food on the table. It is practically therapy, and we might even catch dinner, but now the Liberals are putting 9,100 jobs and a $1.76-billion industry at risk with proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy.\n\n Will this east coast ministe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037058","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Seas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037058","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Seas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037058","label":"Seas","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f31700694f7a22cc7e93e54ec8e843a66629e5f47ab5bb07fe0689c97711e599"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6123baf6545414d739a16f21","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501194,"date":"2026-04-13T19:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am from British Columbia, where homeowners are anxious and builders are hesitating to invest. People are wondering if they are going to be able to renew their mortgages. They are asking about the value of their homes. Liberals and New Democrats told their lawyers not to defend our fee simple property rights. They unleashed uncertainty and chaos when we are already struggling with high costs and economic volatility.\n\nWhat communities want to know is will this Prime Minister end the secrecy and instruct his lawyers to protect the supremacy of private property rights or will Canadians have to keep wondering if their homes are truly theirs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501194","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am from British Columbia, where homeowners are anxious and builders are hesitating to invest. People are wondering if they are going to be able to renew their mortgages. They are asking about the value of their homes. Liberals and New Democrats told their lawyers not to defend our fee simple property rights. They unleashed uncertainty and chaos when we are already struggling with hi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["64828d6cdc1c587d5dc8a45792bb559115a321139a6ccc53caca1680db02daac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca710614a58bdf4e0a954c8546b6f9d97c359f0aba57d17cc7031ddccc3359d4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0f797b77ebb8928ad5f8b95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501191,"date":"2026-04-14T18:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, one of the things I appreciate about my colleague's speeches is that she always brings things back down to basics in a way that is very relatable. Certainly, the things she spoke about are very relatable to my own riding. \n\nThe government opposite keeps trying to look to external factors. I wonder if the hon. member would speak to the difference between the impact these higher prices have on the prices that consumers pay compared to the revenues of the government and tie that back to what we are talking about today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501191","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, one of the things I appreciate about my colleague's speeches is that she always brings things back down to basics in a way that is very relatable. Certainly, the things she spoke about are very relatable to my own riding. \n\nThe government opposite keeps trying to look to external factors. I wonder if the hon. member would speak to the difference between the impact these higher prices ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2aa00126f092db19b27a9120038b751b504be5f924c5e773ca19476afcf51a57"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0e750d8a4e34a4b0bdff97e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501193,"date":"2026-04-14T18:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today's announcement amounts to approximately four cents on the price of diesel. Diesel runs the trucks that deliver food everywhere. Diesel runs just about everything on Canadian farms and helps get food and other goods to communities like mine. \n\nGiven the magnitude of the windfall that the government is experiencing as a result of the increase in revenues that come from gas taxes under the current circumstances, how can the government justify not giving every single penny of that windfall back to Canadians at this time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Diesel fuel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501193","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today's announcement amounts to approximately four cents on the price of diesel. Diesel runs the trucks that deliver food everywhere. Diesel runs just about everything on Canadian farms and helps get food and other goods to communities like mine. \n\nGiven the magnitude of the windfall that the government is experiencing as a result of the increase in revenues that come from gas taxes u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","label":"Diesel fuel"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Diesel fuel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","label":"Diesel fuel","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","label":"Agricultural technology","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a3fc2071ec3333a166c0cd74b099cefb5c6e940aa87a347a9f6f8be78e87a8f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Diesel fuel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f5977ee195e582f0d29479ce8186d97c213890f6e94ccbdc4ee47c1e8a681e7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Diesel fuel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a81d23928f063789db2f10f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118776,"date":"2026-04-14T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"Thank you very much for your hospitality in letting me join you today. Dr. Al-Kassem, when was your last trip to Syria?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118776","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much for your hospitality in letting me join you today. Dr. Al-Kassem, when was your last trip to Syria?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hospitality industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","label":"Hospitality industry","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61b2c6eb2fa7710642cd07916670e822b1b5613cf6491287a8e85e4b28a14c6a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af6d09ff64aa6484a96ecaf0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118777,"date":"2026-04-14T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"You've been there quite a lot. I'm quite taken by the fact that a mental hospital has been opened in the north. When you think about the kind of PTSD that comes out of war and the conditions that Syrians have been living under, and that Syrian Canadians have also lived under and the worry that people have about their relatives back home, can you tell us a bit more about that and the innovative things it's doing to treat PTSD from the circumstances that people have lived through?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118777","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You've been there quite a lot. I'm quite taken by the fact that a mental hospital has been opened in the north. When you think about the kind of PTSD that comes out of war and the conditions that Syrians have been living under, and that Syrian Canadians have also lived under and the worry that people have about their relatives back home, can you tell us a bit more about that and the innovative thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bca7c7346107639227a2df411a8ff3f24af550c4ad6a43e0b56a6796b525e675"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dea2b0e9a9e030ed216e97cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118778,"date":"2026-04-14T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"It's always amazing how resilient children are, even in war, but how widespread is PTSD among civilians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118778","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's always amazing how resilient children are, even in war, but how widespread is PTSD among civilians?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43d28b53d0ce9208e2c3b3db69782e2da7058bf0beaf8a40959a8d6417139de3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-afeeb87bd8686051abf26fb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118779,"date":"2026-04-14T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"What kinds of treatments are available in the hospital that you've described in northern Syria, the mental hospital you started?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118779","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What kinds of treatments are available in the hospital that you've described in northern Syria, the mental hospital you started?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c76abaa5e8f9fe749270f1fda76add6c4677dca2d0d67b863d3a8bc14ceb9767"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee2648a413af3c9fd42b8be3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118780,"date":"2026-04-14T22:05:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"You commented near the end of your remarks about how important the next decade will be, within the Syrian context, to see whether Syria will truly be able to separate itself from the proxy wars that have really destroyed it, the wars waged by the likes of Iran and Russia, and the alternative. What are the consequences in your mind of not treating the PTSD that is so pervasive in post-war areas like Syria?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118780","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You commented near the end of your remarks about how important the next decade will be, within the Syrian context, to see whether Syria will truly be able to separate itself from the proxy wars that have really destroyed it, the wars waged by the likes of Iran and Russia, and the alternative. What are the consequences in your mind of not treating the PTSD that is so pervasive in post-war areas lik","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Demining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","label":"Demining","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d3dbe343263bcc3bcd97f2f03ae5f68e1fb65f3a126f5a45c82ace3effdd48f8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a30c7865fd71c50eab4c8f5a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118781,"date":"2026-04-14T22:05:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"You also made reference in your remarks to this work really being meaningful, in that you're getting to work with mostly women and children and really seeing the impact of the Assad regime and its violations of international humanitarian law. Is there any joint work being done with the demographics that you're working with, to be able to also help pull evidence together and assist international investigators in doing the work that needs to be done there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118781","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You also made reference in your remarks to this work really being meaningful, in that you're getting to work with mostly women and children and really seeing the impact of the Assad regime and its violations of international humanitarian law. Is there any joint work being done with the demographics that you're working with, to be able to also help pull evidence together and assist international in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transborder data flow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","label":"Transborder data flow","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b2c74de24873da681e0668a9fad9a73c73fe4f727ea560586d66daa0d5ee16f5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df974990543ef26cbc35ea8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118782,"date":"2026-04-14T22:05:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"Thank you for the work you do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118782","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for the work you do.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f22251fa6aceaf244d8fb99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118884,"date":"2026-04-15T22:20:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Ms. St. Germain, I was really struck by your comment in your opening remarks about how disheartening it is to see the Supreme Court of Canada strike down offences related to the sexual exploitation of children, like they did in Senneville, based on reasonable hypotheticals. While Bill C-16 doesn't prohibit the courts from using hypotheticals in their reasoning, clause 63, the so-called safety valve, makes exceptions in some cases to preserve and signal the importance of mandatory minimums for things like murder and treason. I was wondering whether including offences related to the sexual exploitation of children to the safety valve of clause 63 might address your concerns.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118884","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Ms. St. Germain, I was really struck by your comment in your opening remarks about how disheartening it is to see the Supreme Court of Canada strike down offences related to the sexual exploitation of children, like they did in Senneville, based on reasonable hypotheticals. While Bill C-16 doesn't prohibit the courts from using hypotheticals in their reasoning, clau","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93661830ef5bda775932dd7e3655cb7957332185affeba2efac96a321dbf2ad0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6384d65141a7deea3d8a68e7a8a7ca354170270ff36787d82ec0d964ad9666ba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a1512e3138306f09d86e43c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118885,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"I would love to dig into that a little bit. I'm wondering how it does that. I worry that the cases that would cause the safety valve to be used become the very hypotheticals that then allow the whole offence to be struck down. If you're getting out of edge cases.... If there's a case that's in front of the courts, then it's not an edge case. I worry that they will also decide that those are edge cases as well, and it might actually increase the probability that the law gets struck down. Do you see what I'm getting at?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118885","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would love to dig into that a little bit. I'm wondering how it does that. I worry that the cases that would cause the safety valve to be used become the very hypotheticals that then allow the whole offence to be struck down. If you're getting out of edge cases.... If there's a case that's in front of the courts, then it's not an edge case. I worry that they will also decide that those are edge c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["929adf523da4319285289ab33384e18b7b117b612e5334b75dd7caeaf4707a1c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4491ae5f4c639d57d0d4022f0999972755e4d3738e38a33539b72b0deb167f11"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b8aad91bd6df9a775bdb026","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118886,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"You don't think the defence counsel will then use that to argue that the offence itself, because of the way that it was structured.... You're not concerned that there's going to be additional litigation as a result of this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118886","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You don't think the defence counsel will then use that to argue that the offence itself, because of the way that it was structured.... You're not concerned that there's going to be additional litigation as a result of this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["076118fbafacffaaca2545ff538db5d27c67264fe4455aa050ad9ca1c8acbd30"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b953eca8d581e3992e9e385","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118887,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Right, but it is the mandatory minimum. It's the sentence that actually gets struck down in these circumstances. We get into a bit of circular loop, as you can see from the question itself. Are there amendments that you think would help under these circumstances? Are there amendments that would solve the circumstances that are causing the disheartenment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118887","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Right, but it is the mandatory minimum. It's the sentence that actually gets struck down in these circumstances. We get into a bit of circular loop, as you can see from the question itself. Are there amendments that you think would help under these circumstances? Are there amendments that would solve the circumstances that are causing the disheartenment?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ad64ec89d4a28fcb3fbaaf70de67ca561c1c554ebec4c8a021ca3fa850ec58b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5947a4e1bcd9972c852e2fd4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118888,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Do you think that a one-year mandatory minimum for child pornography is reasonable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118888","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you think that a one-year mandatory minimum for child pornography is reasonable?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036011","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Juvenile court","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036011","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Juvenile court","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43805","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Pornography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036011","label":"Juvenile court","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43805","label":"Pornography","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c9787c896d54c3e5e77a6dc2b6fa81fe93cb8ad7b30faeb2f418bc060d4c0fe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d103b8ab4a98abaddc6e41df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118889,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Ms. Marinos, I'm hoping to take advantage of your keen legal mind today. I'll ask you a few questions about the safety valve provisions. Do you agree that Parliament enacts mandatory minimum penalties to set a clear floor for sentencing? Is that the purpose of it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118889","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Ms. Marinos, I'm hoping to take advantage of your keen legal mind today. I'll ask you a few questions about the safety valve provisions. Do you agree that Parliament enacts mandatory minimum penalties to set a clear floor for sentencing? Is that the purpose of it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ae329cc431cfb3e2f16c698376493743852e31de31e1565f5d728eb905c13ca"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c696de67e696aacd8b894d4fc59caf34d0cadf410048bbafb77e8dabb359ed56"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ca4f5ef3a3ba2be80252119","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118890,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"That's a very good explanation of it. In terms of the safety valve, that's going to allow a judge to go below the floor, if in the circumstances—and it's in the circumstances—the judge decides that the minimum punishment would amount to cruel and unusual punishment for that offender. It allows for that balance to be struck in any specific, individual situation that is in front of the court. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118890","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's a very good explanation of it. In terms of the safety valve, that's going to allow a judge to go below the floor, if in the circumstances—and it's in the circumstances—the judge decides that the minimum punishment would amount to cruel and unusual punishment for that offender. It allows for that balance to be struck in any specific, individual situation that is in front of the court. Is tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037622","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weaving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037622","label":"Weaving","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b5637a4abf5cf659ff915d5cf74ce66f9c3e07464a7f85219519a9e2ceeac87d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["56430f4f5dec5ca2e96d68ab3c2492fefae3bf01b4a187e14574c4cd759cb089"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8cf540f480afe890cd4533e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118891,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"It's based on the circumstances of the offender.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118891","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's based on the circumstances of the offender.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-faa6fdb2805519d8e10dc9e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118892,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"That's the only factor that's laid out in this section. The circumstances of the offender are the only criteria laid out. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118892","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's the only factor that's laid out in this section. The circumstances of the offender are the only criteria laid out. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db37c7bebbcbc7965e15e1befb0c60337b2613186e3fcd6ec3aa5cd4c291f073"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a583252a6f5123879351e34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118893,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"The only circumstance where the nature of the crime comes up as a consideration is in those exceptions that are in the section, which basically amount to circumstances of murder and treason. Is that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118893","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The only circumstance where the nature of the crime comes up as a consideration is in those exceptions that are in the section, which basically amount to circumstances of murder and treason. Is that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b0c0d4ac247aecf11916e4109a0e363fe571afb49af9f253b1cc21e49447b265"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-872ca528d6f172a6ad864d8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118894,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"It's not the impact on the victim of the crime, though.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118894","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's not the impact on the victim of the crime, though.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0db2e83c990579534b7a7cbdcb117d51e6446c94413bd997efdb94072a1b741a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03937d553fde1e527b95ec8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118895,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"It's not through this section, though.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118895","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's not through this section, though.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad824ac88aaeb2488b2b7bd8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118896,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Is there a limit on how much lower than the mandatory minimum the judge can go?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118896","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is there a limit on how much lower than the mandatory minimum the judge can go?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e06ea5519cc7d4156eed7cee457c4035eda0d36633f07def8ab6f8b1155a0c09"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ff14eed94eefa2314562c95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118897,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"If we have two accused who are convicted of kidnapping with a firearm, which has a five-year mandatory minimum, and who have equal participation in the crime but have different personal circumstances, the judge could, theoretically, give one of them a six-month sentence and the other one a six-year sentence, if the judge decided that the circumstances of one of the offenders warranted it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118897","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If we have two accused who are convicted of kidnapping with a firearm, which has a five-year mandatory minimum, and who have equal participation in the crime but have different personal circumstances, the judge could, theoretically, give one of them a six-month sentence and the other one a six-year sentence, if the judge decided that the circumstances of one of the offenders warranted it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036011","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Juvenile court","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036011","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Juvenile court","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036011","label":"Juvenile court","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3b0c0ac81e5d2c18ff2785109db80ef7859dc22cd48b9129e4133d8e74a67ea7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0cef888a865d8e720afc1a0fb3deed863e9177ba65be30f4d236d7b38b8d37dc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-413e7aa3237d08db7caaddcc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118898,"date":"2026-04-15T23:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"There is also the principle of parity. Let me put it this way. If the Supreme Court of Canada can use reasonable hypotheticals, then I've just laid out a reasonable hypothetical. You could have personal circumstances of the accused. How do we explain that to the victim?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118898","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There is also the principle of parity. Let me put it this way. If the Supreme Court of Canada can use reasonable hypotheticals, then I've just laid out a reasonable hypothetical. You could have personal circumstances of the accused. How do we explain that to the victim?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b31b99044188e40b471c7d0e094f1dcab1af5c031668c9218daa2bdfffed62cd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b63811c901649790f788493","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118899,"date":"2026-04-15T23:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"If you're looking at it from the perspective of the victim, then where you're at in this particular scenario is that the two accused have participated equally. The impact on the victim is the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118899","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If you're looking at it from the perspective of the victim, then where you're at in this particular scenario is that the two accused have participated equally. The impact on the victim is the same.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d68a097aeac7c8a3ca2d00b87d4e0030370fc2a0007fcd99b356af112f29624"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9abd3d03faabcd8370b92241","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118900,"date":"2026-04-15T23:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"However, the court is going to put the interests of one of those accused ahead of the interests of the victims.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118900","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"However, the court is going to put the interests of one of those accused ahead of the interests of the victims.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94fc9c52238e65c157d8a397da7cf2c36ad8de0b2cf2e6735d1b70e010ecfd55"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10a8713ccaf20dabc2db3f9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118901,"date":"2026-04-15T23:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-24/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118901","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-edb2e8f5d6b1405d77bbed8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118918,"date":"2026-04-16T16:50:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I want to thank the witnesses for their very insightful comments, but I also really want to compliment the clerk on the way these witnesses were put together and the way they compliment one another, because this has been a pleasure to listen to. Mr. Blask made the point that people feel better connected when they can see themselves reflected in their institutions. Professor Bridgman talked about how AI is restructuring a relatively unregulated information environment. He also talked about the high level of trust that people put in AI. One of you talked about the prevailing \"I get my news here\" perspective. AI fetches the content, packages it and presents it as fact. I think that was also said by Professor Bridgman. What I'd like to do is ask you, Mr. Gunn, what happens when someone builds their own AI model using only sources they already agree with.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118918","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I want to thank the witnesses for their very insightful comments, but I also really want to compliment the clerk on the way these witnesses were put together and the way they compliment one another, because this has been a pleasure to listen to. Mr. Blask made the point that people feel better connected when they can see themselves reflected in their institutions. Pro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["345870d20cc19a754498ec6bc4cbf89d6bff57c1edabf111b4fe14b4ae7fcd7f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["29803c8fef0e8f54527dfa2f7fd1e990356921ede32ad77c0d23685929e476d1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a41e0b39ae3d6d6d011da38d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118919,"date":"2026-04-16T16:50:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"In that context, there's been a lot of focus on the messenger so far, in this session. There's been a lot of focus on AI, and on Meta and the other social media platforms. I think this lets us, as citizens, off the hook in a lot of ways. If an AI system is trained to prioritize what a user already believes, how does a person challenge bad ideas or correct the errors they might be learning in that process?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118919","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In that context, there's been a lot of focus on the messenger so far, in this session. There's been a lot of focus on AI, and on Meta and the other social media platforms. I think this lets us, as citizens, off the hook in a lot of ways. If an AI system is trained to prioritize what a user already believes, how does a person challenge bad ideas or correct the errors they might be learning in that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-234aceb955361a2cb66a8b9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118920,"date":"2026-04-16T16:55:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"What happens, then, when people start to trust those devices you're holding up? What happens when people start to trust those personalized AI systems and those influencers Professor Bridgman was a bit down on more than they trust the sources—the independent experts and journalists? What happens to our civic resilience under those circumstances?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118920","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What happens, then, when people start to trust those devices you're holding up? What happens when people start to trust those personalized AI systems and those influencers Professor Bridgman was a bit down on more than they trust the sources—the independent experts and journalists? What happens to our civic resilience under those circumstances?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f876947b5cf560f43250ab5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118921,"date":"2026-04-16T16:55:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"The question I want to ask there is this: Who should be held accountable for that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118921","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The question I want to ask there is this: Who should be held accountable for that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e22086209b83af28747361abf760de00e4b9245e773bae8181e729387a8f0bb8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43b74fd19b4e940f834e15ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118922,"date":"2026-04-16T16:55:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"Please go ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118922","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Please go ahead.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2c495fd942fb2203a79962d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118923,"date":"2026-04-16T16:55:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"That having been said, do most users actually understand how their custom AI has been trained? To what extent are they actually placing blind trust in something that they can't really evaluate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118923","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That having been said, do most users actually understand how their custom AI has been trained? To what extent are they actually placing blind trust in something that they can't really evaluate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b49ee5077e9445dd2b1d1f09d4c73ebdbbf4668cd9bc66763b9d99c573a24291"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae9b9ce8dab1b97cd24a9aaf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118924,"date":"2026-04-16T17:40:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Professor Charlebois, your research specializes in food systems and supply chains. I come from Nanaimo—Ladysmith on Vancouver Island, where it is often said that we have about three days of food supply at any given time. Food costs in my community are dramatically higher than in many other parts of the country. I could talk to you for days, but I'm going to start with an overarching question around cost. Can you explain a bit about how multiple distribution nodes, supply chain challenges and industrial carbon pricing contribute to the high prices that we experience on Vancouver Island and the worries that we have around food security and sovereignty?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118924","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Professor Charlebois, your research specializes in food systems and supply chains. I come from Nanaimo—Ladysmith on Vancouver Island, where it is often said that we have about three days of food supply at any given time. Food costs in my community are dramatically higher than in many other parts of the country. I could talk to you for days, but I'm going to start wi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e709ed4ab599a39134815142900755253a9773dd8fce85c41646c7a17d9b5704"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6924077a77466f772dc2bfa45e97deab7c641f8798a754cc0299aee7bed4c706"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b94743cd8f3ddd933334796f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118925,"date":"2026-04-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"I will get there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118925","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I will get there.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ab5decc485aa0b079875a9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118926,"date":"2026-04-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"Well, let me—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118926","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Well, let me—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c417748b65a4a5a53623f4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118927,"date":"2026-04-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"Can I start again with a different question?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118927","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can I start again with a different question?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a6683bec28759e0f773ff18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118928,"date":"2026-04-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"Professor Charlebois, can you talk a bit about the connection between food security and civic resilience?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118928","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Professor Charlebois, can you talk a bit about the connection between food security and civic resilience?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebb8943edf845246bd5f5fe930e7e99c6a364a4cd6b67770a5ca6db0ee8e0373"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7fe771b0f47c790c3345ea9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118929,"date":"2026-04-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"In the context of the trust that Canadians need to have in pricing and in government regulation of grocery stores and the cost of food, can you talk a bit about how supply chain issues and things like industrial carbon pricing contribute to the high cost of food in communities like mine?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118929","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the context of the trust that Canadians need to have in pricing and in government regulation of grocery stores and the cost of food, can you talk a bit about how supply chain issues and things like industrial carbon pricing contribute to the high cost of food in communities like mine?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["856a7b64353f69d30ca7a45d214e6e1e23a15dd870a10594196e4f9c1e6c2e46"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-abd37b564b2fd2dde3255fdf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118930,"date":"2026-04-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"When there's a disconnect between people's understanding of how prices are calculated and the information being provided by institutions, what happens to people's trust in those institutions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118930","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"When there's a disconnect between people's understanding of how prices are calculated and the information being provided by institutions, what happens to people's trust in those institutions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29d8748bb6c9d2a6bac2576e8bc0cf0646c423a8003b1bdb5171ab0e6484e079"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-205aa6374cbd8f3fca7caff3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118931,"date":"2026-04-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"PROC","text":"In the context of that information gap, what's happening? What's the trend that you're seeing in your research around Canadians' trust in our institutions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118931","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the context of that information gap, what's happening? What's the trend that you're seeing in your research around Canadians' trust in our institutions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f1c5804eb2558f2fdecaf3a280c8224133f2a7bcdae1280376d2c2c9cb88613"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-687cf66c802fca1034a0a3d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501187,"date":"2026-04-16T18:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the sorcerer's apprentice scene from Fantasia is my mother's favourite. The apprentice arrives, gains access to powerful tools and tries to harness them to make his work easier. He enchants a broom to carry water. At first, it works. The buckets fill and the work is done for him. Then it does not stop. The water keeps pouring. He tries to fix it, but he cannot undo the spell. In panic, he chops the broom in two, only to create more brooms, more buckets and more water. What began as a clever solution quickly becomes something he cannot control and the room begins to flood.\n\nI have been thinking about that story as we debate Bill C-25 because there are parts in this bill that respond to the concerns I hear in my communities. Conservatives have long called for measures to deter abuses like the longest ballot campaigns. We have called for stronger protections against foreign interference, including in leadership and nomination contests. The changes in Bill C-25 start to address the concerns that we have raised around foreign money influencing Canadian elections, and we support these changes. There are a few amendments we think would be prudent: Ballot boxes should be securely stored when polling stations are closed, under triple lock and key. The scope of the expanded offence of making false statements about the results of an election could be clearer. The financial penalties proposed in the bill could be higher.\n\n If we were in the early stages of the sorcerer's apprentice where the brooms were doing their jobs and the buckets were filling as intended, those changes might be enough to restore Canadians' faith in our institutions, but that is not where we are. In the wake of floor crossings and growing regional alienation, there are concerns about fairness in how resources are distributed and a rising sense that decisions are being made behind closed doors for the personal gain of those doing the deciding. For some Canadians, the brooms are everywhere, the buckets are overflowing, and those Canadians are rapidly losing confidence. \n\nIn British Columbia, people notice when elections are called before our polls have even closed. They notice when our tax dollars flow east, but do not come back to fund our infrastructure, our hospitals and our communities. With the recent floor crossings, a growing number of people from across the political spectrum are asking me why they should bother voting.\n\nWhen people start questioning whether their vote matters, we should all take notice because that is not frustration with a single policy or a single party. It is indicative of something deeper, a feeling that their voice no longer carries weight, that the outcome is predetermined elsewhere, that our democracy is not quite functioning as it should. It may be a minority of voices at this point, but once that feeling takes hold, it is very difficult to reverse. People do not disengage all at once. They disengage step by step. First, they question. Then, they doubt. Eventually, they go quiet and stop participating altogether.\n\nThis is not a problem we can regulate away. It is a problem we have to address through how we conduct ourselves as a democracy. In that context, Bill C-25 does some very valuable tinkering around the edges, but it fails to truly meet the moment that we are in. \n\nI have spoken to many of these concerned Canadians. The gap between this Parliament and those agnostics is fundamentally one of trust: trust that decision-makers really see their struggles and understand their hopes and dreams, trust that ministers will do their best to serve Canadians and not enrich themselves along the way. Trust that the person they elected is still who they said they were when they were asking for their vote.\n\n If we are, as the Prime Minister has said, living through a moment of rupture, vulnerable to the whims of a hostile America, then this is a time when Canada needs its best ideas to rise to the top. That does not happen by accident. It happens when ideas are tested, challenged and improved upon through open and rigorous debate. An environment where opposition questions are treated as obstruction is not one where strong ideas can emerge. It is one where the weak ideas go untested. When questions are discouraged, when those who ask them are mocked in this chamber, when scrutiny is dismissed, we materially increase the risk of getting it wrong.\n\nIt is in the national interest to have an opposition that can ask hard questions. It is nation building to stress-test policy proposals in order to find gaps, unintended consequences and missed opportunities. That is how policies are strengthened. That is how we avoid costly mistakes. That is how we move our country forward.\n\nThe moment that we accept the frame that our society is divided into two enemy camps, one virtuous and one irredeemably wrong, our society loses something that is mission-critical. Probing, questioning and challenging are what a healthy democracy depends on. In moments like this, where we need to find and embrace our best ideas, we should be making more room for opposition and questioning, not less. Canada's success depends on every member of this House being able to serve their constituents fully, regardless of which side of the aisle they sit on. That is how we truly arrive at the best ideas. It is not by protecting them from criticism, but by putting them under pressure and seeing what holds.\n\nFormer Prime Minister Diefenbaker was known for the sentiment that there is no bad seat in the House of Commons. Every seat in this place carries equal responsibility and legitimacy, regardless of whether its member sits in government or opposition. This week, there is a much-needed reminder that MPs are here to put Canada first, not to seek power for themselves. A government that serves only the ridings it holds weakens the country and undermines our collective purpose. It divides Canadians and pits region against region. A system that discourages questioning weakens its ability to correct itself.\n\nIn Canada today, a new Prime Minister has arrived on the scene much like the sorcerer's apprentice. He has gained access to powerful tools, and I will concede that he has harnessed them effectively to achieve the majority government that he insists will make his work easier. He has enchanted a certain demographic, the media and some floor-crossers to wield brooms, fill buckets and carry water.\n\nHowever, there are lessons to be learned from the sorcerer's apprentice to ensure the water does not turn into a flood and to stem the tide of disappointment that Canadians are expressing about behaviour in this place. Any MP who cannot effectively represent their riding from any seat in this House has no business being here. Any government that requires MPs to cross the floor to provide for their ridings is one that undermines the foundations of democracy and should be summarily dispatched at the ballot box.\n\nI implore the Prime Minister to recognize these two simple principles: embrace the value of the opposition, especially in this moment, and answer the questions we ask in question period. Stop trying to enchant the brooms and the buckets and be a government that makes space for all Canadians, regardless of the colour of their party banner. If we do that, the best ideas will rise to the top and we will be able to move this country forward.\n\nWe need the government to work with us to strengthen Bill C-25 in committee. If the government does that, then Bill C-25 might help restore Canadians' faith in our system. It might help bring down the temperature and rebuild trust. However, if it does not, we should not be surprised if the brooms and the buckets keep multiplying and the water keeps rising until the floods are upon us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501187","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the sorcerer's apprentice scene from Fantasia is my mother's favourite. The apprentice arrives, gains access to powerful tools and tries to harness them to make his work easier. He enchants a broom to carry water. At first, it works. The buckets fill and the work is done for him. Then it does not stop. The water keeps pouring. He tries to fix it, but he cannot undo the spell. In panic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","label":"Floods","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["89f9da2d38f146fe312e8f9d20557f5e62f698905303427113e26be56f54889c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["025620b5a299efdc0e5370a71138296a5ce9fc995c323b3b9a42280e9b4377ec"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9b3c8830677ae1c8a1f1a43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501188,"date":"2026-04-16T18:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when I knock on doors and I talk to people in my community, there is a sentiment that generally gets all the heads nodding. It is the idea that Ottawa feels very far away right now from those out on the west coast on Vancouver Island. We feel disconnected in a lot of ways from the black box that happens in Ottawa.\n\nThere was a point made in committee this morning, which was the idea that civic resilience is something that bridges the distance between the people and government. There is a lesson that comes out of this and I would urge the government, I would urge the House, to make room for those voices and to spend more time explaining to Canadians what we are doing in this place and why. I think that, along with the changes being proposed in Bill C-25, would go a long way to gaining support.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501188","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when I knock on doors and I talk to people in my community, there is a sentiment that generally gets all the heads nodding. It is the idea that Ottawa feels very far away right now from those out on the west coast on Vancouver Island. We feel disconnected in a lot of ways from the black box that happens in Ottawa.\n\nThere was a point made in committee this morning, which was the idea t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73665a4c4855ee4592d08fbd358fd1153b519f986c64a9536d60bbb9c4e43d47"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b77308c5a31a807e7b84ad9a812776759d176a34e851bd2ab912be4b7fe986fb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9c976a49391bf9467b565b78","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501189,"date":"2026-04-16T18:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for that question, because it highlights where we are heading and what we still need to do.\n\n Bill C-25 addresses the issue of the longest ballot in a number of ways. However, the truth is that it does not matter how many spots are on a ballot or how short it is if the people who are casting their vote do not have confidence that the House will respect their choice and enable the member they elect to serve from any seat in the House and provide for their riding in all circumstances. That is where I think we have work to do. I look forward to working with the government to restore that confidence in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501189","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for that question, because it highlights where we are heading and what we still need to do.\n\n Bill C-25 addresses the issue of the longest ballot in a number of ways. However, the truth is that it does not matter how many spots are on a ballot or how short it is if the people who are casting their vote do not have confidence that the House will respect the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4f7e3ecbde0c98f439b685904bf3f9401fae4279f99427f357a81bce4f69ae9f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["03943dd2b68944aaae23633045579938721217a1652ea4ea4a2683aeca0b2313"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbea4c7213ba36ec07345a13","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501190,"date":"2026-04-16T18:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague for this excellent question.\n\n It is a difficult thing to see someone we have spoken to and shared lots of good conversations and ideas with decide they are no longer on our team. That said, it is one of the fundamental issues in our democracy today. We are living in a world where people are trying to create a distance that does not always exist. We have a lot in common. We need to work together. We need to have every seat in this House matter.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501190","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague for this excellent question.\n\n It is a difficult thing to see someone we have spoken to and shared lots of good conversations and ideas with decide they are no longer on our team. That said, it is one of the fundamental issues in our democracy today. We are living in a world where people are trying to create a distance that does not always exist. We ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035997","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Isolated communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035997","label":"Isolated communities","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["03be94321a6576ba16587aff8119357e3d4a95c3fcb6f7ebd7ae72b80fefa739"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fbe04f4343396a87377389d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118783,"date":"2026-04-16T21:25:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Mr. Epp, has Canada's rapprochement with China created any changes to Canada's approach to Taiwan?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118783","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Mr. Epp, has Canada's rapprochement with China created any changes to Canada's approach to Taiwan?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["59e9f737aa104ca9be9ebe325722e04ab1d8f458c856ff749d909620126dae12"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efcc68d41d223fc9587c7c8367f1eb949b5ea8505c59f899e0678fb47f4e8c8e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ef8a0f60770bce8bb233275d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118784,"date":"2026-04-16T21:25:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"The Indo-Pacific strategy actually commits to \"push back against any unilateral actions that threaten the status quo in the Taiwan Strait\". It also identifies China as an \"increasingly disruptive\" power. Has anything in that assessment changed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118784","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Indo-Pacific strategy actually commits to \"push back against any unilateral actions that threaten the status quo in the Taiwan Strait\". It also identifies China as an \"increasingly disruptive\" power. Has anything in that assessment changed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2eb33f379ed3623a68a22674ee289389f4bc32707c3053c7d98f89c968f7a524"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41a22a8e9d94d0a126114a05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118785,"date":"2026-04-16T21:25:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"Absolutely. I mean, we totally understand that you've been very busy. I'm trying to understand this, though: The world has changed, yet on some level what's being said here is that we're waiting for what seems to be—or is being pitched as—an incremental update to the Pacific strategy. If not much has changed, then why don't we have it? If a lot has changed, then what is actually changing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118785","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Absolutely. I mean, we totally understand that you've been very busy. I'm trying to understand this, though: The world has changed, yet on some level what's being said here is that we're waiting for what seems to be—or is being pitched as—an incremental update to the Pacific strategy. If not much has changed, then why don't we have it? If a lot has changed, then what is actually changing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f3403ceb8cbd023c793e3b7433b1076724bac1b4ea4f3916726e87f2e2d8883"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-433d1dcd092467b85a7a3999","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118786,"date":"2026-04-16T21:30:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"I understand all that, but I'm actually asking a directional question. In the existing policy, Canada is seen as an \"increasingly disruptive\" force.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118786","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I understand all that, but I'm actually asking a directional question. In the existing policy, Canada is seen as an \"increasingly disruptive\" force.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["617e0e54804585c19b649f7b2e6000b6b4274c7bd32bdc2d518135cc93c99b71"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10865c34ee7afa2a3b141c23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118787,"date":"2026-04-16T21:30:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"I'm sorry. China is seen as an \"increasingly disruptive\" force. Does Canada still see China as an \"increasingly disruptive\" force in the region?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118787","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm sorry. China is seen as an \"increasingly disruptive\" force. Does Canada still see China as an \"increasingly disruptive\" force in the region?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6e6970a444273a06d887e63d68989ec732be1280832362dfb7bf4ca9b52ec51"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e43f5c5f125c88cc45b01197","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118788,"date":"2026-04-16T21:30:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"Is it increasingly so?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118788","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is it increasingly so?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e42918aa404bb9d7e96a0fc0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118789,"date":"2026-04-16T21:30:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"It's in our current strategy. Can we expect to see the word \"increasingly\" removed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118789","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's in our current strategy. Can we expect to see the word \"increasingly\" removed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44040081425dc6a12e103f4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118790,"date":"2026-04-16T21:30:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"In the few seconds I have left, I would love to hear from the colonel. Is it the Canadian Armed Forces' position that Canada remains an \"increasingly disruptive\" force in the region?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118790","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the few seconds I have left, I would love to hear from the colonel. Is it the Canadian Armed Forces' position that Canada remains an \"increasingly disruptive\" force in the region?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebda4b7ebc7b1c3383958a9375461191ce35f320d67c9804a7d375021cb21ca5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6d9c9c4709ea8ddf2af3ea5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118791,"date":"2026-04-16T21:30:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"A yes or no would be great.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118791","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"A yes or no would be great.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21025583ca3e4157e1d0a6b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118792,"date":"2026-04-16T21:30:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"I apologize. I mean China. I'm thinking about Canada. That is where my heart always is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118792","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I apologize. I mean China. I'm thinking about Canada. That is where my heart always is.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d95a98d5de063db4185d312","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118793,"date":"2026-04-16T21:30:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"That's not an answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118793","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's not an answer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e5d1a792ab05e96f1d1a1b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501179,"date":"2026-04-17T15:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is an old story about a traveller in the desert. Night had fallen and the air had turned bitterly cold. The traveller had just enough space and warmth in the tent to get through the night, but then a camel approached and asked if it could put its nose inside just to stay warm. The traveller agreed. It seemed harmless. However, then the camel asked to bring in its head and then its shoulders, and before long, the entire camel was inside the tent, leaving the traveller out in the cold.\n\nIt is a simple story, but it carries an important lesson: When we allow something small without thinking through where it could lead, we can often end up somewhere very different from where we intended. That is the caution we should keep in mind as we debate Bill C-22, because this bill is about expanding the powers of the state into the digital lives of Canadians. While each individual step may seem reasonable on its own, we have to ask ourselves where the path we are taking leads.\n\nThere is no disagreement in this House about the goal. We all want law enforcement to have the tools they need to go after child predators, organized crime, human traffickers and terrorists. We all recognize that criminals are using modern technology to hide their activities and that the law must keep pace. Conservatives are always open to modernizing the law. The question before us today is not whether to modernize. The question is whether Bill C-22 gets the balance right. Modernization should not come and need not come at the cost of accountability, and it cannot come at the cost of the freedoms that Canadians expect us to protect.\n\nWe have been here before in this parliamentary session. The government tried to legislate for lawful access earlier in this session when Bill C-2 was introduced as a sweeping solution. It was broad, it was rushed and it raised serious concerns across the board. The fact that we are now debating Bill C-22 is, in itself, an acknowledgement that the first attempt missed the mark. This bill is an improvement in many respects. It narrows certain provisions. It introduces some safeguards. However, improvements do not mean that we have it right. There are still real concerns that we need to work through in committee as this bill wends its way through Parliament.\n\nTo start, I want to talk about accountability. The National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians found that our agencies do not systematically track the challenges they face with lawful access. Let us think about that. We are being asked to expand powers in an area where we do not even have consistent data on what is not working today. Where in this bill, then, is the requirement to track those challenges and report them clearly to Parliament? If we do not measure the problem, how can we claim to solve it?\n\nWe also need to engage with the trust that Canadians have put in us. They are not legal experts. Most Canadians are not reading every clause of this bill, but they still want to feel safe. They want to know who can access their information, under what conditions and with what limits. Right now, those answers are not as clear as they should be.\n\nThis bill would lower the threshold in key areas from \"reasonable grounds to believe\" to \"reasonable grounds to suspect\". That may sound like a small change in the legalese, but it is not. It is a real shift that would make it easier for the state to access personal information earlier in an investigation and it needs to be studied carefully to ensure that it is absolutely necessary and minimally impairing of rights. When we combine lower thresholds with broader powers, we have to be very careful and ask whether we are gradually moving that camel further and further into the tent.\n\nI want to move to data retention. This is something a number of speakers have touched on and it is something I have received a lot of correspondence about from members of my community. In serious investigations, especially those involving children or violent crime, data can disappear quickly. In some cases, it is gone within 30 days. That makes it harder to hold offenders accountable. Yes, Parliament absolutely needs to address that, but the solution cannot be to collect and retain large amounts of data on everyone, regardless of suspicion, indefinitely.\n\n This bill would allow for the retention of metadata, including information that can reveal locations and patterns of life in some cases when combined with other information but nonetheless in a way that has a lot of people worried. We need to be asking basic but critical questions about this: Who is holding that data, where is it stored, how long is it kept and why do we need to apply this broadly instead of targeting serious offences? If we are going to impact privacy rights, then we must do it in a targeted, proportionate and justified way that we can explain to the public. Otherwise, we risk casting a wider net than intended, creating all kinds of concerns and worries in our society.\n\n I want to move on to system vulnerability. This bill would require service providers to build and maintain systems that allow for lawful access. The intention is understandable, but we have to be realistic about the risks. Creating access mechanisms can create vulnerabilities. We have seen cases in other jurisdictions where systems built for lawful access were later exploited by hackers. Canadians have a simple expectation. They do not want back doors into their private communications. Even if this bill does not explicitly create one, we need to be absolutely certain that it does not create independent pathways that could be abused. \n\nAgain, secrecy and oversight are an issue. This bill would rely somewhat on secret ministerial orders and delayed notice. In some cases, individuals may not know their data was accessed for years, if at all. Oversight that happens after the fact is simply not enough. If we are expanding powers, the safeguards must be strong, independent and timely. Canadians need to know that there are real checks in place, not just internal reviews behind closed doors. \n\nFinally, we need to be honest about the broader picture. This bill addresses some challenges in digital investigations, but it does not address many of the issues Canadians are most concerned about when it comes to crime and public safety. It does not address repeat violent offenders. It does not address gaps in bail or sentencing. It does not solve the broader crisis we are seeing in communities across the country. Therefore, we need to be careful not to overstate what this bill would achieve. \n\nOur discussion and our debate today should not be about choosing between safety and freedom. Canadians deserve both. They deserve laws that allow the police to do their job effectively and they deserve to know their rights are protected at the same time. That is the balance we are trying to strike. The current iteration of Bill C-22 is a step in that direction, but is not there yet. We need clearer accountability. We need stronger safeguards. We need to ensure that in trying to solve the problem we are not quietly creating others, because once these powers are granted they are very difficult to take back. That is why we have to get this right, not just for today but for the future, so Canadians can feel both safe and free, not one at the expense of the other. \n\nWhen the camel first asked, it did not ask to take over the whole tent. It did not demand. It asked politely. It asked for something small, something temporary, just enough to take the edge off the cold. That is what makes the lesson here so powerful. The traveller did not make a bad decision out of carelessness, but out of compassion and reasonableness. He thought he was in control of the situation, but step by step, decision by decision, the situation changed until he no longer was. If we are not careful, if we do not take the time to examine all the possible angles and unintended consequences of this bill, we risk finding that the balance has shifted against us, not all at once but gradually, in ways that were easy to justify at every stage along the way, but which nonetheless unduly upset the delicate balance between privacy and speedy enforcement.\n\n I look forward to continuing the debate and discussion on this important topic.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501179","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is an old story about a traveller in the desert. Night had fallen and the air had turned bitterly cold. The traveller had just enough space and warmth in the tent to get through the night, but then a camel approached and asked if it could put its nose inside just to stay warm. The traveller agreed. It seemed harmless. However, then the camel asked to bring in its head and then i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["220ea6f8d90d351f31258da97924a110899f5a4ce3718d333d2ee9cd25d55809"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["62ade9f5d52e6a9b2920932ca7526467a995e75baff90961b6676a75b967b292"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc9683ab4a15efefca4d8f0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501181,"date":"2026-04-17T15:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague for her question.\n\n The hon. member has pointed out one of the really difficult issues that we are grappling with, with this government, which is that the Liberals talk, saying things that people want to hear. They talk about making changes that need to be made, but somewhere behind the scenes resources are not following the matter and Canadians are not, in fact, getting what they need.\n\nThat is one of the main reasons that we really need to think about this. We need to work hard to get this right.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501181","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague for her question.\n\n The hon. member has pointed out one of the really difficult issues that we are grappling with, with this government, which is that the Liberals talk, saying things that people want to hear. They talk about making changes that need to be made, but somewhere behind the scenes resources are not following the matter and Canadians are ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dde8dedc7f518757f7a63da51fd6c7c5e7d80eb6893c5cbfa8b039e16a0fbaff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78e0754bea19191c20a35e58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501182,"date":"2026-04-17T15:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague for giving me the opportunity yesterday in the justice committee to ask questions about this very topic.\n\n It is a good example of how the Liberals give with one hand and take away with the other. It is incredibly important to protect children against predation, online and off-line. I hope that the government will see reason and restore the mandatory minimums for child sexual exploitation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501182","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague for giving me the opportunity yesterday in the justice committee to ask questions about this very topic.\n\n It is a good example of how the Liberals give with one hand and take away with the other. It is incredibly important to protect children against predation, online and off-line. I hope that the government will see reason and restore the mandatory ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["515498163e6e6f209a7bcf3ca7a4d622259943c2e3c7551f57e2abddbf0283aa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["08b2ed45881a282ccc164a9eebc110e1baa6f3996515de4ed9654bac46ee14f7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8801211bdd1938b2f11d887f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501183,"date":"2026-04-17T15:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I really want to thank my colleague for the generosity in her comments. It means a lot to me when one of my colleagues from Vancouver Island recognizes the value that other members bring to this House.\n\nLike the hon. member, I have also looked for examples. The reality is, at the end of the day, suspecting and believing are two different things. The government is creating yet another change that dilutes rights in a way that is unclear, that the courts will have to grapple with, that will add to litigation, that will add to backlogs and that will add to the incredible weighty amount of legal mumbo-jumbo that exists. \n\nI hope the government will think very hard about what we are trying to do here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501183","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I really want to thank my colleague for the generosity in her comments. It means a lot to me when one of my colleagues from Vancouver Island recognizes the value that other members bring to this House.\n\nLike the hon. member, I have also looked for examples. The reality is, at the end of the day, suspecting and believing are two different things. The government is creating yet another ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a546d65752156d0be146fe89566d43f7820264bf98fc4b59b357adaa265d3a12"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e9d4a9ea7a28ebccadf86e705057919d99ff4441068f5cd546b2e1767038c37"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0003e09884bfe502fd1bb17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501184,"date":"2026-04-17T15:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the fact that this bill is coming back to the House on a second attempt to do this shows the contributions that Conservatives in opposition can make to the important work we do in this House.\n\nI want to thank the government for listening to the things we raised the first time around. I look forward to working with them in committee to make this bill even stronger.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501184","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the fact that this bill is coming back to the House on a second attempt to do this shows the contributions that Conservatives in opposition can make to the important work we do in this House.\n\nI want to thank the government for listening to the things we raised the first time around. I look forward to working with them in committee to make this bill even stronger.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5ec8252305d37722b499aa69c1b3b025e298911acd54b8aa9b1d7cf3e41358b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-377efab6c3ef0c8159c7339c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501185,"date":"2026-04-17T16:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is secrecy, uncertainty and anxiety. Between the Cowichan Tribes decision and the Musqueam agreement, the Liberals and NDP have managed to throw private property rights into question for thousands of British Columbians. We need a game plan in this country on how we are going to get from where we are today to reconciliation in an affordable, reasonable manner, but the Cowichan Tribes decision is going to take years to wend its way up to the Supreme Court, while Canadians are left wondering whether their homes are truly theirs.\n\nI ask the Prime Minister, what is the plan to restore confidence in fee simple home ownership, and when are we going to have genuine resolution and—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501185","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is secrecy, uncertainty and anxiety. Between the Cowichan Tribes decision and the Musqueam agreement, the Liberals and NDP have managed to throw private property rights into question for thousands of British Columbians. We need a game plan in this country on how we are going to get from where we are today to reconciliation in an affordable, reasonable manner, but the Cowichan Tr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09c910bbbcba7da53fd68382f150d67eb26ee4a9e6d0e090120c5a3cf4c7afda"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fc724c844173d3fc19f6328","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501186,"date":"2026-04-17T16:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member says he disagrees with the decision and is appealing, but appeals are not do-overs, as the minister should have been told by her lawyers. The \"raise it or lose it\" principle is a core feature of how our legal system works. One cannot raise a new argument on appeal if one did not raise it at trial. My dad used to refer to this as the \"you snooze, you lose\" rule. In Cowichan Tribes, the Liberals instructed government lawyers not to argue that fee simple title supersedes all other kinds. \n\nCan the minister explain how the government is going to win an appeal with an argument it is not entitled to make?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501186","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member says he disagrees with the decision and is appealing, but appeals are not do-overs, as the minister should have been told by her lawyers. The \"raise it or lose it\" principle is a core feature of how our legal system works. One cannot raise a new argument on appeal if one did not raise it at trial. My dad used to refer to this as the \"you snooze, you lose\" rule. In Cowichan ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["49c19511f5e6b9662b41379145f4868935b70a76836af35dcd258f29184625c0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["505efb691e49db0779a8f010089bf6fd5c063e332b59e53830915168854fe955"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d80821e7059ddbf126461b0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118902,"date":"2026-04-20T16:35:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. Ms. Blinco, I want to thank you for coming here to talk about this very important issue of coercive control as it relates to seniors. As you've alluded to in your opening statement, coercive control with seniors is sometimes harder to recognize because independence is something that vanishes slowly under manipulation, pressure or emotional influence, sometimes in a subtle way that often even feels like help. It's a particularly difficult form of elder abuse to recognize. I was wondering whether you might elaborate on some of the more common ways that coercive control shows up in the lives of seniors, especially when it comes to financial scams, exploitations or other criminal measures.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118902","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. Ms. Blinco, I want to thank you for coming here to talk about this very important issue of coercive control as it relates to seniors. As you've alluded to in your opening statement, coercive control with seniors is sometimes harder to recognize because independence is something that vanishes slowly under manipulation, pressure or emotional influence, sometimes in a su","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52bf6d08e1b3c6c1b065465b41a6f74dd8913816a5d2a6e4e13a959c09021418"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7c4b429271b97e1ef3301fd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118903,"date":"2026-04-20T16:35:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"It does. Thank you for taking the time to explain it. Could you also talk about whether there are warning signs that family members, friends and neighbours often miss until it's too late?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118903","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It does. Thank you for taking the time to explain it. Could you also talk about whether there are warning signs that family members, friends and neighbours often miss until it's too late?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["86a7dbda9b477a8c64587a795789cdc04e07a6d807db1cc591e1551dc9856dd6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3141d3af9f132d61ecec7a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118904,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"It sounds like the telltale sign, in this case, is that an adult is supposedly there to help them, yet they are still showing signs of not being helped.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118904","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It sounds like the telltale sign, in this case, is that an adult is supposedly there to help them, yet they are still showing signs of not being helped.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47053eb93df53fc37d90589e16d11ffe1025912983f4d1d62ef01840461388a6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07cd1640079a1dce2bc9f1b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118905,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"From your perspective, is there a way that legislation could better support prevention and not just respond to the harms in the way that Bill C-16 is doing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118905","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"From your perspective, is there a way that legislation could better support prevention and not just respond to the harms in the way that Bill C-16 is doing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["de66df69a8bbd3879d834da38c771f7038ded161614009e51aee3068a25e7465"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1d5b2f8f758f4b973f9b214","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118906,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Briefly, could you expand on the gaps that education and community outreach could help fill when it comes to coercive control as a particularly pernicious and dangerous form of elder abuse?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118906","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Briefly, could you expand on the gaps that education and community outreach could help fill when it comes to coercive control as a particularly pernicious and dangerous form of elder abuse?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","label":"Elder abuse","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["524ad1e97bc0a3641a2142e1cf3727741198ae1ccf1b6111aefd68012f5e785a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ef1eb73b8399132d6ff5e4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118907,"date":"2026-04-20T17:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Ms. Boucher, thank you for sharing your story today. I want to thank you. We often have academics and lawyers here, and it is incredibly helpful and generous of you to share with us your personal experiences of intimate partner violence. I'm hoping that I'll be able to ask you questions that will continue to draw out some of the points you're hoping to make. I want to thank my colleague for reminding us that we are studying this bill in the context of 10 femicides having happened so far in Quebec this year, just in 2026. In your opening remarks, you talked very powerfully about the idea that domestic violence isn't just an event but a process. I am hoping you can talk about the role played by the perpetrator's manipulation of people's emotions in the process.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118907","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Ms. Boucher, thank you for sharing your story today. I want to thank you. We often have academics and lawyers here, and it is incredibly helpful and generous of you to share with us your personal experiences of intimate partner violence. I'm hoping that I'll be able to ask you questions that will continue to draw out some of the points you're hoping to make. I want to thank my colleague for remind","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3140c45f58feb1a31cadf9d2a6d080c15546470f0cd7aa610852021bb23d78b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a388b568d15fbda5c29afb5f8f1af193bde63e109408dd7ae4a6ececb122483"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e23ad7cf63e8ec0f877d347","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118908,"date":"2026-04-20T17:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"In your experience, does that manipulation extend into the criminal justice system? Do the partners come into the process and try to manipulate the courts? Do they try to tell stories about why their sentences should be reduced, why they're really the victim in this scenario and why we should not be so hard on them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118908","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In your experience, does that manipulation extend into the criminal justice system? Do the partners come into the process and try to manipulate the courts? Do they try to tell stories about why their sentences should be reduced, why they're really the victim in this scenario and why we should not be so hard on them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ed4c1d5d55d169178c4c3aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118909,"date":"2026-04-20T17:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"I'm glad you did that. Do you think there should be mandatory minimums in the criminal justice system for the things that lead up to murder but are still intimate partner violence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118909","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm glad you did that. Do you think there should be mandatory minimums in the criminal justice system for the things that lead up to murder but are still intimate partner violence?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["073b28aa329e6822eb85de03a602428be3de28f90bbca764f9010ff9892b799b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28b8576819b73d3b97b78dddaea72873b1c0fab06ea963adc4c1714f92771642"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6223b74147909235f9816715","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118910,"date":"2026-04-20T17:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Do you think there should be mandatory minimum sentences for the steps? You talked about the fact that we build up to murder, that murder is not a single event but a destination or the cumulative impact of this. I'm wondering whether or not you believe there should be mandatory minimum sentences for that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-25/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118910","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you think there should be mandatory minimum sentences for the steps? You talked about the fact that we build up to murder, that murder is not a single event but a destination or the cumulative impact of this. I'm wondering whether or not you believe there should be mandatory minimum sentences for that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce806a2ce8c5895611ef2e50b87bdc02c01c1fc0ec25e2a8e8b23097e9c963b1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47de022709a841c6e87bde9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300969,"date":"2026-04-21T17:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is a small passage buried deep in budget 2025. It sits quietly on page 217. There is no headline, no press conference and no public debate, but for many young Canadians and for communities like mine, it matters a great deal, because in that short passage, the government signals its intent to eliminate student grants for students attending private educational institutions.\n\nAt first glance it might sound technical, even reasonable, to people who believe that everyone should strive for a university degree, but when we take a closer look, it reveals something much bigger. It reveals how the Liberal government values different kinds of work and whom it chooses to support. Frankly, it reveals a blind spot. I know something about that blind spot. I am proud to be both a goldsmith and a lawyer, a tradesperson and a professional. I have made my living doing each of them at different stages of my career. Some people would be surprised to learn which was a better way to support my family.\n\nThe stigma is real. When I introduce myself as a lawyer, people react one way. Yes, there are lawyer jokes, but there is also a measure of respect and deference. When I introduce myself as a goldsmith, as a tradesperson, the reaction changes. I do not need to explain it to the tradespeople watching from home. There is less credibility, as if one path were more serious, more worthy and more important.\n\nI have lived in both these worlds. Doors closed to me when I crossed from the class of people who shower in the morning to those who shower when they get home from work. That is why this issue matters to me, because what is buried in the budget is not just a funding change. It is a signal. It says that some forms of education are more worthy of public support than others. It says that the path through a university lecture hall is valued more than the path through a workshop, a training lab or a hands-on program. That is a mistake.\n\nThere is an old fable many of us learned as children, the story of the lion and the mouse. The lion, powerful and confident, laughs at the mouse for being small and insignificant. What possible value could something so small have? However, later the lion is caught in a net, and it is the mouse, the one dismissed as unimportant, who gnaws through the ropes and sets the lion free. The lesson is simple: Strength takes many forms, and what some dismiss can turn out to be essential.\n\nWhen we need to build at speeds not seen in a century, we need not just lawyers. We need carpenters, scaffolders, welders and Cat operators, including those who got their certificate at private college. If we are facing a rupture, we need all hands on deck.\n\nIn ridings like Nanaimo—Ladysmith, this is not an abstract debate. It is real life. We are a community built by people who work with their hands as well as their minds: tradespeople, technicians, care workers and small business owners. These are people who fix things, build things and keep our local economy moving.\n\nI was lucky to participate last weekend in a repair café, where people came together, with no problem, to help fix things together. Many of us got there not through traditional university degrees. Many of us went to private career colleges. We took focused, practical programs. We learned specific skills that led directly to jobs, in programs in fields like health care support, early childhood education, welding, construction trades, information technology and personal services.\n\nThese are not backup plans. They are essential pathways to work, and for many young people they are the most direct routes into the workforce. That matters right now more than ever. We are living through a time of high youth unemployment. Young Canadians are struggling to find their footing. They are looking for a way in. They are looking for a way to build a life. They are motivated by money, and they want to find the fastest pathway to earning an income that will allow them to have at least some of the things their parents have.\n\nAt the same time, employers across this country are struggling to find skilled workers. We hear it from construction companies. We hear it from health care providers. We hear it from small businesses trying to grow. There is a gap, a real one. One would think that the role of the government would be to help close that gap, to support the pathways that connect young people to real jobs as quickly and as effectively as possible. Instead, what does the government do? It narrows those pathways.\n\nUnder this change, a student attending a public university remains eligible for means-tested grants, but a student attending a private career college, even if they are in a program that leads directly to a job, loses access to the same support. There is the same financial need, the same ambition and the same desire to contribute, but there is different treatment. Why? It is because of the type of institution they chose. That is not fairness. That is picking winners and losers, and it ignores the reality of how our education system has evolved.\n\nPublic universities play an important role. Of course they do. We need strong universities. We need research. We need professional training in fields like medicine, law and engineering. However, universities are not designed to meet everything we need. They are not built for rapid job-specific training. They are not always flexible enough to respond quickly to local labour shortages. They do not offer the full range of hands-on programs that many industries depend on.\n\nThat is where private career colleges come in. They are smaller, more focused, more nimble and more mouse-like. They can launch programs quickly. They can tailor training to local employers. They can provide targeted, shorter pathways. They get people into the workforce in months, not years. For many students, especially those who cannot afford to spend four years out of the workforce, that matters.\n\nLet us imagine a young person in Nanaimo—Ladysmith. Maybe they cannot leave their community to attend a university. Maybe they need to work while they study. Maybe they are looking for a program that gets them into a job as quickly as possible. They find a program at a local private college. It fits their life. It fits their goals. It leads directly to employment, and they might even be able to work part-time while they are in school. However, under this budget, they lose access to grants. What happens then? They take on more debt, they work more part-time hours, they delay their training, or they abandon the path altogether. That is not helping young people. That is closing doors, and it is happening at the same time the government claims to be focused on youth employment.\n\nThat is the contradiction at the heart of this policy. On one hand, we hear about investments in job programs and skills training. There is press conference after press conference. On the other hand, we see a quiet decision buried deep in a budget that makes it harder for young people to access some of the most direct routes into those very jobs. It does not line up, and it reflects something deeper. It reflects a mindset that assigns more value to one type of work than to another. It reinforces class differences that I thought we were trying to dismantle.\n\nCanadians know that dignity does not come from the type of institution printed on one's diploma. It comes from the work itself. It comes from building a home, from caring for a patient, from fixing a piece of equipment, from running a small business, from mastering a craft. I have seen that in my own life. There is a precision in goldsmithing that rivals any profession. There is discipline, creativity and skill. There is pride in producing something tangible and lasting, and yet too often these paths are treated as second-tier.\n\nThis policy risks reinforcing that divide. It is not the message we should be sending. If we are serious about addressing youth unemployment, we should be supporting all credible pathways to work, whether they run through a university campus or a small vocational college. We should be asking a simple question: Does this program help a young person get a job? If the answer is yes, then we should be finding ways to support it, not pulling support away.\n\nThe lion in the fable did not think it needed the mouse, but when the moment came, it turned out that what seemed small was in fact essential. We should not make the same mistake in public policy. Unless and until the government is willing to fund these programs through public universities, private programs like these are essential to our economy. They are essential to giving young Canadians a real chance to succeed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300969","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is a small passage buried deep in budget 2025. It sits quietly on page 217. There is no headline, no press conference and no public debate, but for many young Canadians and for communities like mine, it matters a great deal, because in that short passage, the government signals its intent to eliminate student grants for students attending private educational institutions.\n\nAt fi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1e4f5a4705a7f8dc3f74c8bda14718680c938286dc6f25a1b75169f5e1b5042f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6948d7167b56112927d6e66039dab0185dc4b7d654b7ce65dc3798227217cb35"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ecdb123bcb2feaece7b7cea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300970,"date":"2026-04-21T17:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when the member says that we are only spending one day on this, he devalues everything I have done in my life and my career. This is not a one-day thing for me. I have a trade and a profession, and I value both. \n\nIf the member would look at page 217 of the budget and see what the government is doing to restigmatize and continue to stigmatize the trades, perhaps he would speak to the people on his side of the House and get it changed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300970","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when the member says that we are only spending one day on this, he devalues everything I have done in my life and my career. This is not a one-day thing for me. I have a trade and a profession, and I value both. \n\nIf the member would look at page 217 of the budget and see what the government is doing to restigmatize and continue to stigmatize the trades, perhaps he would speak to the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64dab9e6c9c654bcc22d3ce6bfbed9a1036046cf366070611df726fe526a301c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d675985043e8d039b4358b83427707db80d656989a25f394df6565dd0505afb5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d605c2fa7f95cd42021eb21","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300971,"date":"2026-04-21T17:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the short answer to my colleague is no, I cannot make sense of why the Liberals are attacking us on question after question today as we try to focus on jobs for young people.\n\nI want to highlight the work that my colleague has done on this file. This is something that he has been focused on day after day. I have seen him talk about it to people in my riding when he has come to visit to help support me and my community as we strive to find jobs for young people.\n\nI can assure members that neither my colleagues nor I think this is a temporary thing. It is something we are focused on day in and day out.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300971","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the short answer to my colleague is no, I cannot make sense of why the Liberals are attacking us on question after question today as we try to focus on jobs for young people.\n\nI want to highlight the work that my colleague has done on this file. This is something that he has been focused on day after day. I have seen him talk about it to people in my riding when he has come to visit t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bedd7322768b3c5f883cbc4b1b6be94e2ba6d8c92cd1821e3ba485013cb3da16"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f8d78f75b1e3735877fabe8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300972,"date":"2026-04-21T17:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I do not understand why the Liberals are opposing us on this matter.\n\nWhat I can say to those who are watching at home is that we value what they do and thank them for doing it, and to keep contributing to our economy, because there is a bright future ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300972","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I do not understand why the Liberals are opposing us on this matter.\n\nWhat I can say to those who are watching at home is that we value what they do and thank them for doing it, and to keep contributing to our economy, because there is a bright future ahead.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1169eebd92718655c01c99d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300973,"date":"2026-04-21T21:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, every one of these treaties is a contract, and every one of them is a contract between a first nation or an indigenous group and the Crown. All of them have dispute resolutions. Normally, when someone is in breach of a contract, they contact the other party and tell them they are in breach of this contract. The party either says, yes they are, or no, they are not.\n\nWhy do we need a commissioner to do this job when the government should be looking at these contracts, abiding by them and fixing its behaviour if it is not?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300973","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, every one of these treaties is a contract, and every one of them is a contract between a first nation or an indigenous group and the Crown. All of them have dispute resolutions. Normally, when someone is in breach of a contract, they contact the other party and tell them they are in breach of this contract. The party either says, yes they are, or no, they are not.\n\nWhy do we need a co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1738aa3c4981363f415c4c5049ef5ff1f763fdd3aba8f4aee68cfd67b6bd560f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4be3dbf780ef54cdc304a12fb8793fbca67fbadbace359e14211bd39dd7e5af9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00c9e287b58e50306a13162c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300974,"date":"2026-04-21T21:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a really simple yes-or-no question for the parliamentary secretary.\n\nWould this commissioner be necessary at all if her department simply lived up to its treaty obligations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300974","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a really simple yes-or-no question for the parliamentary secretary.\n\nWould this commissioner be necessary at all if her department simply lived up to its treaty obligations?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cfaac92f252be97daa8e8779","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300975,"date":"2026-04-21T21:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to ask my colleague a simple question. Would this new bureaucracy be necessary if the government and the ministers were fulfilling their obligations under these treaties?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300975","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to ask my colleague a simple question. Would this new bureaucracy be necessary if the government and the ministers were fulfilling their obligations under these treaties?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["59aafe36da9af65919363eff20ab26fb4c466df5c8e5d30c7411f894a9dcf970"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c5e02ea4e14ded8bb458661","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300976,"date":"2026-04-21T22:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I come to the House from the traditional territories of the Coast Salish peoples, including the Snuneymuxw First Nation and the Stz'uminus First Nation. We are also home to a thriving Mid Island Métis community. Getting to know people in these communities has deepened my understanding of the interconnectedness of people to the land, the human connection we all share and the link between our generation and both the past and the future. These concepts have been invaluable to me in shaping how I think about the work we do here in the House.\n\nTherefore, I rise today to speak to Bill C-10, the commissioner for modern treaty implementation bill, in a spirit I hope all members of the House can share: a genuine commitment to reconciliation that is meaningful, reasonable and affordable for the people we serve. While there are no modern treaties currently being implemented in my riding, that does not mean that these issues are distant from us. As we move forward together, we will need outcomes that are clear, durable and widely understood. Most important, we will need to build genuine trust, not just through words but through consistent action over time.\n\nModern treaties aim to resolve broad claims and to create long-term certainty. They are meant to provide a stable foundation for partnership, economic development and self-determination. These are not symbolic documents. They are binding agreements negotiated in good faith that set out how land, resources and governance will work together for generations. When Canada signs a treaty, it makes a promise. That promise must be honoured, but there have been real problems in the implementation of these agreements. That is a serious concern, and it deserves a serious response.\n\nAs I contemplated this debate, I was reminded of a simple story about a village that once built a bridge across a wide river. The village people threw themselves into the task. They hired an engineer and achieved broad agreement on the design. The bridge was constructed, and when it was ready to use, the opening was celebrated by everyone because it promised to connect people and create opportunity. Satisfied with a job well done, the engineer moved on to other projects. One day, a little girl noticed some small cracks in the bridge and reported them to the village leaders, who convened a meeting to see what they should do. Some said the bridge was still strong and the cracks just needed to be filled in. Others said it needed to be replaced entirely. Committees were formed, and reports were written, but the cracks were left untouched. One day, after a heavy storm, the bridge simply gave way. In the end, the problem was not how the bridge was built. The problem was with the way it was maintained. When everyone is responsible for doing something, no one is responsible.\n\nModern treaties are meant to be that bridge. They are meant to connect people, resolve uncertainty and create a foundation upon which opportunity can be built and realized. If not properly implemented, no agreement can deliver the certainty or opportunity that it was designed to provide.\n\nBill C-10 attempts to remedy that problem, and I think all members of the House agree that Crown accountability is essential to reconciliation. We agree that Canada must meet its obligations, not just on day one but every day. We agree that transparency matters, and we agree that reconciliation must move beyond words to real results on the ground. There is less agreement on how best to achieve that.\n\nBill C-10 proposes the creation of a new federal bureaucracy, headed by a commissioner, to oversee the implementation of modern treaties. At first glance that may sound like a practical solution, but when we look more closely, we have to ask a simple question: Would this actually cause the federal government to fulfill its treaty obligations, or would it create yet another layer of bureaucracy mired in paperwork and backlogs, without delivering the outcomes people are waiting for?\n\nBefore I turn to that question, I want to address something that many Canadians are feeling right now. Across the country, and particularly in my home province of British Columbia, there is growing uncertainty and debate around DRIPA, UNDRIP and recent court decisions involving aboriginal rights and titles. Some of those concerns will come to this place, but not today. Bill C-10 is not about expanding rights, redefining land claims or changing property ownership. It would not create new treaties. It would not alter existing ones. It would not affect private property.\n\nThe bill would deal with a narrow question: Once a treaty is signed, will the federal government fulfill the commitments that it made in the treaty? When it does not, the bridge I spoke about collapses, resulting in conflict, protracted litigation, angst and more uncertainty. The concern with Bill C-10 is therefore not about whether accountability is needed, but whether this particular approach would deliver it.\n\n Every one of these treaties has a dispute resolution mechanism. In the recent Musqueam agreement, it is right at the front, almost in anticipation that it will need to be referred to. Moreover, we already have an institution in this country whose sole purpose is to hold government to account. The Office of the Auditor General is independent and respected, and it has a clear mandate to examine whether government programs are achieving their intended results. Creating a place for the activities contemplated for the commissioner for treaty implementation within the Office of the Auditor General would make good use of the tools we already have, strengthened where necessary, rather than creating an entirely new bureaucracy.\n\n This approach would preserve independence, avoid duplication and respect the need for fiscal responsibility, because we also have to be honest about the cost. Every new office comes with a price tag. Staff, administration and reporting structures all add up, in the case of this office, to about $10.6 million over four years. At a time when Canadians are facing real pressures, it is reasonable to ask whether those resources would be better directed toward actually implementing treaty commitments rather than creating all the trappings of yet another bureaucracy.\n\n It is also reasonable to ask, as my colleagues from the Bloc Québécois repeatedly did during their speeches, whether the least expensive option here would be for the Crown and the minister to abide by and implement the treaty provisions so that this additional office would be unnecessary. Where is the ministerial accountability? That brings me to another concern that deserves attention and has been raised by many of my colleagues.\n\n The proposed commissioner would have the ability to report and make recommendations, but not to compel action. If the government has failed to act on existing findings, what assurance do we have that another report and another office would change that? Reconciliation cannot become an exercise in process. It must be measured by progress. Meaningful reconciliation means honouring commitments in a timely and consistent way. Reasonable reconciliation means using existing institutions wisely, avoiding duplication and ensuring that accountability mechanisms are strong and effective. Affordable reconciliation means recognizing that resources are not unlimited and that every dollar spent on administration is a dollar not spent on housing, infrastructure or economic opportunity. These principles are not in conflict with reconciliation; they are essential to it.\n\n Many modern treaty nations support the bill. Their voices matter, their experience matters and their frustration with the modern treaty implementation process is entirely justified. We should listen carefully to what they are saying, but listening also means asking whether the proposed solution would deliver what is needed. Listening means making sure the cracks in the bridge are addressed, not just talked about, studied or reported on. If we are serious about implementing modern treaties, then the Crown should implement them. The minister should focus on clear timelines, measurable outcomes and consequences when commitments are not met.\n\n Reconciliation must bring people together. It must build trust, not erode it. The commissioner should not be a way to avoid ministerial or governmental accountability. That is the spirit in which I approach Bill C-10. The path forward must be practical, effective and focused on results, because at the end of the day, reconciliation is not about creating offices in Ottawa, but about building and maintaining the bridges that we build in a way that makes people even more confident about building bridges, so that we can continue to do that in a way that ensures that the promises behind them remain strong for generations to come.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300976","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I come to the House from the traditional territories of the Coast Salish peoples, including the Snuneymuxw First Nation and the Stz'uminus First Nation. We are also home to a thriving Mid Island Métis community. Getting to know people in these communities has deepened my understanding of the interconnectedness of people to the land, the human connection we all share and the link betwe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5f6eaf59952500628c4d5d7cd1f4b84cce0d31321fba7028b316124536f947f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d1cf3e4db410d4ed36941430e9b5f2a1e1f06f27c66b9790203219380eb576a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc921890cd1607ff113e4aab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300977,"date":"2026-04-21T22:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think a majority of the indigenous communities in the country join me in lamenting the fact that the government does not keep its word.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300977","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think a majority of the indigenous communities in the country join me in lamenting the fact that the government does not keep its word.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["657e8eb4ecf50df39a14844b73adf3ee1e0204360708cb5faa736a2ada22ab56"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0457835eaec90c65a069e3e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300978,"date":"2026-04-21T22:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in my speech, I talked about the importance of building bridges. There is no question that there are things we could do with this $10.6 million that would benefit first nations and that would benefit Canada. The truth is that the reason to avoid spending this money is to keep the commitments and to implement the treaties. If we do that, what we would get in return is priceless. What we would get is reconciliation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300978","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in my speech, I talked about the importance of building bridges. There is no question that there are things we could do with this $10.6 million that would benefit first nations and that would benefit Canada. The truth is that the reason to avoid spending this money is to keep the commitments and to implement the treaties. If we do that, what we would get in return is priceless. What w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fae946d85c6af89a93f2d459f5d7722a303c06caa11081aeefea7df83efab246"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42048ba1b770d01ce49202da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300979,"date":"2026-04-21T22:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am not entirely sure that I see the connection between the notwithstanding clause and the bill that we are speaking about today. What I would say is that the Government of Canada needs to do a better job of connecting and communicating with Canadians so that they understand why it is making the decisions it is making and we can avoid disputes in the first place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300979","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am not entirely sure that I see the connection between the notwithstanding clause and the bill that we are speaking about today. What I would say is that the Government of Canada needs to do a better job of connecting and communicating with Canadians so that they understand why it is making the decisions it is making and we can avoid disputes in the first place.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87ed060cf05b7d8b456ee51e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300980,"date":"2026-04-21T22:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think the hon. member's question is a wonderful opportunity to reflect on how important it is that, as members, we keep our word with our constituents and that we do not break our trust with them. \n\nThe reason it has taken 20 years to get here is that the government has not kept its promise. These treaties need to be implemented, and all people in the House should be honouring their constituents.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300980","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think the hon. member's question is a wonderful opportunity to reflect on how important it is that, as members, we keep our word with our constituents and that we do not break our trust with them. \n\nThe reason it has taken 20 years to get here is that the government has not kept its promise. These treaties need to be implemented, and all people in the House should be honouring their","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["742948af7583b1971769ad5c9f8033b5dd5f9c97733de5646b5f26067cac7cf7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d323d4cd6ed8f84354113a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300968,"date":"2026-04-22T19:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this weekend, a young disabled man was assaulted for the fourth time by a gang in downtown Nanaimo. He was badly hurt but so traumatized that it took his mom a day to get him to hospital while his attackers remain perpetually out on bail.\n\nNothing the Liberals have proposed repeals the principle of restraint, which releases the accused at the earliest opportunity on the least restrictive conditions. The only person whose liberty is restricted here is the victim, who is afraid to go out, lest he be assaulted a fifth time.\n\nWhen will the Liberals recognize that their soft-on-crime policies hurt vulnerable people and repeal Liberal bail?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300968","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this weekend, a young disabled man was assaulted for the fourth time by a gang in downtown Nanaimo. He was badly hurt but so traumatized that it took his mom a day to get him to hospital while his attackers remain perpetually out on bail.\n\nNothing the Liberals have proposed repeals the principle of restraint, which releases the accused at the earliest opportunity on the least restrict","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","label":"Elder abuse","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["252366be5174ceddfcad8d76bccc49aff48fe6120006fb8fcb9823f7d1d3ea5a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5210064429c461482715c637b54c9959e2034228e785e85f740bb0b458c9841f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7813c926f08d4a9f727140a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118911,"date":"2026-04-22T23:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Zille, it's always a pleasure to have someone here from my home province of British Columbia. I want to pick up on your comments about the justice system not being designed with children in mind and the opportunities you described to build on what's being proposed in Bill C-16 in terms of the importance of ensuring that children feel supported, safe and believed. In particular, online child sexual exploitation cases in B.C. have risen dramatically, as you know, more than doubling between 2021 and 2023, with the B.C. RCMP reporting almost 16,000 cases in 2023, which is up from 4,600 in 2021. Bill C-16 does include measures to protect children and address exploitation, but from your perspective, does it prevent repeat harm from known offenders?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118911","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Zille, it's always a pleasure to have someone here from my home province of British Columbia. I want to pick up on your comments about the justice system not being designed with children in mind and the opportunities you described to build on what's being proposed in Bill C-16 in terms of the importance of ensuring that children feel supported, safe and believed. In parti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-36146807a984426e9abb1a75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118912,"date":"2026-04-22T23:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"I was wondering whether you see anything in Bill C-16 that would help prevent repeat harm from known offenders in the context of the explosion in child sexual exploitation cases that we see in B.C.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118912","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I was wondering whether you see anything in Bill C-16 that would help prevent repeat harm from known offenders in the context of the explosion in child sexual exploitation cases that we see in B.C.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a29303bc8a7b8f1ddac969c44573725924dbb725f9f85b182ffc2813b0b3c6db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b427e1e340ba9b355815f0228ead5f40fcdab88b1ac28c357bb277080ff0d092"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89cba734d990406694f87eaa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118913,"date":"2026-04-22T23:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you for that. Could you speak a bit to what happens to a young or disabled person psychologically when they're targeted multiple times by the same individuals?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118913","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that. Could you speak a bit to what happens to a young or disabled person psychologically when they're targeted multiple times by the same individuals?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f55168a49fda25ad50b8756dc3f9ec0b63af64b9505ae9f4b0eb3dc8d03c8122"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ccce572539f821998284e63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118914,"date":"2026-04-22T23:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"While you're doing that, I might turn to the witness from Boost. How easy is it to keep offenders off technology when they're out on bail?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118914","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"While you're doing that, I might turn to the witness from Boost. How easy is it to keep offenders off technology when they're out on bail?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:344215","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Young offenders","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:344215","label":"Young offenders","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8fb916cd48ef38921f7217d68163c57fbcfaf52bb49f8b77934a4be622dc10bb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b53afac878accf3b66514de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118915,"date":"2026-04-22T23:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"JUST","text":"Thanks. I'm coming at this from a place where we've seen high recidivism, and I'll give you an example: A Nanaimo man was arrested just a couple of weeks after being released on a child sexual abuse possession charge. You went into detail about the steps of exploitation. You talked about the grooming and the threats. What I want to ask you about is that every single one of those things is a separate offence. In circumstances when someone, say, shoplifted, was arrested and released, and then stole a car—and we have a lot of situations locally of someone returning to the scene of the crime—what happens is that each one of those counts in terms of trying to decide whether the person will be let out on bail the next time something happens. In child luring cases and in child sexual exploitation situations, a lot of the time we don't actually find out that four or five crimes have been committed until after the person is arrested. The luring is a crime, the threat is a crime and the distribution of the material is a crime, but they are often characterized as one offence. One of the things that Bill C-16 would not do is remove the principle of restraint in bail conditions. I'm wondering whether you think it would be important for this bill to recognize each of the crimes that are encapsulated in a single charge as separate crimes for the purposes of bail.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118915","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thanks. I'm coming at this from a place where we've seen high recidivism, and I'll give you an example: A Nanaimo man was arrested just a couple of weeks after being released on a child sexual abuse possession charge. You went into detail about the steps of exploitation. You talked about the grooming and the threats. What I want to ask you about is that every single one of those things is a separa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["061685b26f1e9e5e67a89865cb2f3cfcfb244e8fe1c6fc3f384617e4f81da186"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bcd06e52adccdd57232a65304d8a38f232ca8bbb88f9f24d9deaadff0abded2a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52ddcdb2a64f764e604b7a94","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118775,"date":"2026-04-23T23:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I want to thank my colleague for his remarks. He really spoke to the question in an incredible way. When I think about this place—and we're currently in the basement of the West Block—I think about the chamber upstairs as being the heart not only of this building but also of our democracy. Every committee in this place has a function that surrounds the room. If that's the case, then the ethics committee might very well be the soul of this place, its conscience. This is my first time coming here to the ethics committee, and I would observe that what we are seeing here today—this evening now—with this amendment to our motion is a deliberate, concerted effort by Liberal members to prevent Canadians from seeing who is influencing our Prime Minister . While I admire their tenacity and, judging by the length of some of their interventions, their lung capacity, that should truly trouble every single one of us in this place regardless of party. This is the second time today that I have had reason to look at a Liberal bench and say that just because you can do something, that does not mean you should. I've reviewed the motion put forward by my colleague, and while it is long, it doesn't ask for anything that should attract this level of defensiveness from the Liberals. We are not asking for something exotic. We're asking for some pretty basic stuff: itineraries, travel records, meetings and who was in the room. As some of my colleagues have made clear, if we were asking for the good stuff, we'd be asking for the menus to find out why we're paying through the nose for airplane food. It is not unreasonable to want to understand whether decisions are, in fact, being made in the public interest or whether access is being shaped by privilege, proximity or power. These are pretty basic, fundamental questions that are asked by ethics committees in parliaments like ours around the world. The reason it matters so much in this case is quite simple. As with any prime minister, the Prime Minister did not come into office as a blank slate. He came with a vast network of global relationships, with deep ties across finance, investment and policy circles and with a very long list of former colleagues, partners and associates who might want something from him. That in itself is not disqualifying, and every prime minister has to navigate this, but it does raise the bar for transparency; it does not lower it. When someone brings that kind of network into public office, Canadians are entitled to know who still has access, who's getting meetings and who is shaping the conversations that happen behind closed doors. Instead, what we're seeing in this committee is delay and obstruction, and that sends a message whether you intend it to or not. What it tells Canadians is that there is something about these meetings that cannot withstand public scrutiny. It tells them that the government would rather run out the clock, as we've seen you do today, than simply address the facts. If everything is above board, there should be no fear in disclosure. If decisions are being made impartially, then transparency should be your strongest ally. Where am I in my notes? There are notes, and the notes have notes, and those notes have notes. If there is transparency here, then transparency should be your strongest ally, but when the response to a straightforward request is to block, to stall and then to talk it out until the clock runs down, people will draw their own conclusions, and those conclusions may not be kind. The ethics committee exists for a reason. We are here to protect the integrity of public office. We are here to ensure that power is not used to favour insiders, whether intentionally or through the quiet pull of relationships and familiarity. We're here to give Canadians confidence that their government works for them, not for a well-connected few. You just can't do that in the dark. You can't ask Canadians to trust the system while refusing to show them how it operates, and you can't claim to be upholding ethical standards by actively preventing this committee from examining the facts. This is not about partisanship, as my colleagues have said over and over again. It's about whether we believe Canadians deserve to see who has the ear of their Prime Minister. They're going to look at the transcripts, information and videos from today, and they're going to make their own judgments. Blocking that information is not a neutral act. It's a choice to shield power from scrutiny and a choice to put political convenience ahead of public accountability. Frankly, I think we should all treat that as unconscionable. If the government has confidence in its conduct, prove it. Let the record speak. Let Canadians see for themselves. For everyone watching at home, I want to be clear about what's going to happen tonight. We're going to sit in this committee until we go upstairs to vote in just a few minutes. What that vote is going to do is add another Liberal to this committee. We are then going to come back down here so the Liberals can stop filibustering and just defeat this motion outright with the majority they've given themselves in this room. Today is a bit of a milestone for me and my colleagues. Tomorrow is the one-year anniversary of my being elected to represent the wonderful people of Nanaimo—Ladysmith. While I haven't always agreed with my Liberal colleagues, today is the very first day they have truly and deeply disappointed me. In choosing to stack this committee—of all committees—and to make this motion the first one they block with their new Liberal government's new majority, they really do look like \"just another Liberal\". The more they engage in keeping information from the opposition's scrutiny, the more it looks, genuinely, as if the real goal is not to protect any legitimate interest but to protect access that cannot be defended in the light. With that, Mr. Chair, I am going to stop. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118775","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I want to thank my colleague for his remarks. He really spoke to the question in an incredible way. When I think about this place—and we're currently in the basement of the West Block—I think about the chamber upstairs as being the heart not only of this building but also of our democracy. Every committee in this place has a function that surrounds the room. If that's","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["941fa7219397ca149bd9c3fce3de0e6803d932e8cbe74c1112069985b37477b1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98dd9494b5ff555507dbaac6be15a24958d03dcfeb58e5a2d4731bb7238e5bdd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd94453bab1dfae094e3570b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726984,"date":"2026-04-27T16:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is rare that a member of the House has to begin a speech with a trigger warning, but while some of what I am about to describe is difficult to hear, it is necessary if we are to fully comprehend why we must act on the issue of intimate partner violence. For far too many people in this country, intimate partner violence is not a topic; it is a lived reality.\n\nMy speech and the bill are dedicated to the victims of intimate partner violence who are watching today. They are dedicated to the family of Bailey McCourt and to all people who did not get the luxury of turning away from what I am about to describe, because these memories that I share today are theirs.\n\nThey are memories of being held down as the air is squeezed from their lungs. They are memories of complete control over their comings and goings, repeated blows and beatings, a knife used in a moment of rage, threats, isolation, abuse of children and pets, the shouting, the quiet calm before the rage, the knowing what that look means, and figuring out how to get the kids out of the room as if that means they will not hear. This is about rape, violence and death at home, in the very place that should have been the safest. It levels me every time I think about it, and we have to think about it in the House.\n\n Some people make it through. Some find the strength to speak. We heard this just days ago at the justice committee, where a survivor described with clarity and composure how control is built piece by piece until there is almost nothing left of the vibrant woman who once was. We heard it in the status of women committee testimony around the bill. However, too many people do not make it through. Bailey McCourt, for whom the bill is named, is dead and unable to speak, killed by a person who was supposed to love and protect her, hours after he was released on bail. Therefore we must speak for Bailey, and more than that, we must act.\n\n Bill C-225 is not symbolic. It is a response to a growing and serious problem. We know that the numbers do not tell the full story. We know that many cases go unreported. Fewer than one-third of victims report to police, which means that what police see is only a fraction of what is actually happening.\n\nEven less is reported on in our communities, which means that what we know, what we hear about, is an even narrower subset, yet in Canada in 2024, there were over 128,000 victims of intimate partner violence. That is 356 victims per 100,000 Canadians aged 12 and older. That is more than one victim for every person who lives in Nanaimo—Ladysmith. If victims of intimate partner violence were voters, they would fill an entire riding on their own.\n\nWomen and girls are disproportionately affected. They experience intimate partner violence at three and a half times the rate that men do. When we consider homicides, we see that the numbers become even more stark. Nearly 80% of people killed by an intimate partner are women or girls. Among minorities and indigenous people, the numbers are even worse. These are not isolated incidents; this is a pattern, and beautiful Vancouver Island is not immune.\n\n Communities on Vancouver Island face high pressure in the system. We see that not just in police files but also in wait-lists and in service demand. Hundreds of people in our communities are waiting for safe housing and support, with hundreds on wait-lists for transitional and second-stage housing. This means that people ready to leave violence often have nowhere to go. It means delay, and delay in these cases can be deadly.\n\nLaura Gover, a 41-year-old mother and a professor at both Vancouver Island University and Camosun College, was murdered this January in her home by her ex-husband, the day before a court date, leaving behind two preteen daughters. Amy Watts was just 27 years old when she was thrown off a cliff to her death by her ex.\n\nIn many of these cases, there are clear warnings signs, prior incidents and opportunities to intervene. Too often, these opportunities are fleeting or missed.\n\nAn abuser does not rely on violence alone. They isolate. They manipulate. They reshape their victim's world until it becomes smaller and smaller. They create a world where their victim begins to doubt their own instincts and lose their identity, then their confidence in the world around them, and ultimately their ability to leave. By the time the physical violence escalates, many victims are already trapped in ways that are not always visible from the outside, and it does escalate. That is what makes this issue so difficult and so dangerous.\n\n Our laws have simply not kept pace with reality. Bill C-225 would take important steps to close the gaps. It would create specific offences for violence against an intimate partner, recognizing that this is not the same as other forms of assault; it carries a higher risk of escalation and a higher risk of death. Bill C-225 would establish that when murder occurs in the context of intimate partner violence, particularly where coercive control is present, it should be treated as first-degree murder. This would reflect the reality that these acts are rarely sudden but rather are the result of a pattern. These provisions would remove the strain on families while they wait to see whether charges will be upgraded.\n\n The bill would strengthen peace bonds by introducing reverse onus provisions, ensuring that people who pose a risk are not released without serious consideration of the danger they present. The bill would allow for a seven-day period of custody for risk assessment, giving authorities the time needed to properly evaluate the threat and to take steps to further protect victims. The bill would address how evidence is handled, recognizing that these cases often involve patterns of behaviour over time, not just a single incident.\n\n These are measured, practical changes designed to intervene earlier and to prosecute more effectively, because there have been too many cases where the signs were there, the risk was known and the outcome could have been different: Bailey McCourt, Laura Gover and Amy Watts. We say their names. These are cases that weigh on our communities and raise difficult questions about whether more could have been done.\n\nBill C-225, Bailey's law, is about doing better. It is about recognizing patterns of abuse before they escalate to the point of no return. It is about giving our justice system tools that reflect what we now understand about coercive control, intimate partner violence and the tools that law enforcement needs to respond, and it is about sending a clear message that this kind of violence will be treated with the seriousness it deserves.\n\n All members of the House have spoken to survivors of intimate partner violence. All of us have tried to comfort grieving families. The question is no longer whether we understand the problem. The question is whether we are prepared to act.\n\nI admire my hon. colleague from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola for bringing the bill forward after extensive consultation. The bill reflects the voices of victims, the work of advocates and the painful lessons learned from cases that should never have ended the way they did: in trauma, in injury or in death. I applaud my colleague for working with communities and in committee to come up with meaningful legislation to push back the evil, to make the system see and to transform suffering into change.\n\n Passing the bill would not solve everything. There is more work to be done on prevention, on support services and on ensuring that people have safe options when they need to leave, but Bill C-225 is a meaningful step. It acknowledges the reality of what victims face, and it would move us closer to a system that reflects that reality. We cannot keep responding after the fact. We must intervene earlier. We must take risk seriously, and we must put the safety of victims at the centre of our approach. That is what Bill C-225 would do, and that is why it deserves the support of every member of the House.\n\n May the memory of each of the victims be a blessing, and may they inspire the House to take all steps possible to end intimate partner violence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726984","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is rare that a member of the House has to begin a speech with a trigger warning, but while some of what I am about to describe is difficult to hear, it is necessary if we are to fully comprehend why we must act on the issue of intimate partner violence. For far too many people in this country, intimate partner violence is not a topic; it is a lived reality.\n\nMy speech and the bill ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e957d43d9015130029d0ad585dd111757fcfeeddb960947024384feeb12fb7f6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a3a9a5b0d591cf9085c2868f349f61f1443ce9f1735065e4975ede298a5d0fc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cbceaaebca7474744f5e7932","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726992,"date":"2026-04-27T17:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I approach the first anniversary of my coming to this place, it is a good chance to reflect on the lessons I have learned. One of the important lessons someone learns in this place is that just because we can do something, it does not always mean it is a good idea.\n\nThe government motion we have in front of us would increase the size of committees, as well as the government's control over them. There is a Conservative amendment to this motion that would simply ensure that while committees are expanded, a small number of them would continue to be able to hold the government to account. It is not about blocking change. It is about protecting the independence and effectiveness of this place.\n\nI would like to ask the government House leader if he can explain why the government would oppose a straightforward amendment to keep committees representative of the House and preserve committees' ability to properly scrutinize government activity.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726992","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I approach the first anniversary of my coming to this place, it is a good chance to reflect on the lessons I have learned. One of the important lessons someone learns in this place is that just because we can do something, it does not always mean it is a good idea.\n\nThe government motion we have in front of us would increase the size of committees, as well as the government's contr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd54afef19e5d1ad5029949c1fdce13715d53de68a89a8964a0f87a79872b02a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d83f2f3d17ced97d81433863","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726959,"date":"2026-04-28T16:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for his informative and enlightening speech.\n\nI have two questions for him. Given the uncertainties in the commercial launch market, what level of risk does he think the government should accept when looking to develop a new industry?\n\nAlso, how can we ensure that taxpayers are well protected?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726959","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for his informative and enlightening speech.\n\nI have two questions for him. Given the uncertainties in the commercial launch market, what level of risk does he think the government should accept when looking to develop a new industry?\n\nAlso, how can we ensure that taxpayers are well protected?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11d78bcb54cc5d924bfa5331e36db11207a8f307c5d85656709d119767169cd7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79cb3ca232e87846544ad335","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726960,"date":"2026-04-28T17:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in communities like mine there is a lot of ambition around space launches.\n\n Communities like mine are still waiting to know when we are going to get a chance to clean up derelict vessels around the coastline. I have proponents in my communities who want to remove the boats, but the Liberals defunded and closed the program. When are you going to reopen it and deliver relief to my communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726960","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in communities like mine there is a lot of ambition around space launches.\n\n Communities like mine are still waiting to know when we are going to get a chance to clean up derelict vessels around the coastline. I have proponents in my communities who want to remove the boats, but the Liberals defunded and closed the program. When are you going to reopen it and deliver relief to my comm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036526","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Offshore area","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036526","label":"Offshore area","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["358a94cba69a9bb33e1c5f7d0d390eda89402712deeb20ba4696b56a33cc460b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db52786a4c7b4606facd5beb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726963,"date":"2026-04-28T17:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to be here today to discuss this important bill. It is a real opportunity to talk about issues that are important to our communities.\n\nThe government has been incredibly ambitious with this bill, talking about the possibility of launching rockets into space from Canada and developing a national space program by 2028. Yet, in front of us we have a bill that is very easy reading because, at only 10 pages, it sketches out the briefest of details around what that program might look like. It is going to be a challenge for the transport committee to think about how to operationalize this and how to think about asking the government where it is heading on this. \n\nOne of the characteristics that is emerging from this government, which we really see in this bill, is a trend towards creating a new organization, putting together very thin details around it and then leaving it to the executive branch of government to sort out, with an incredible amount of discretion. What that does under these circumstances is create a real conundrum. It creates a situation where, as constructive members of a loyal opposition, we want to work with this government to realize the ambitions of Canada and to build Canada into the kind of country that we can all be proud of.\n\nHowever, we find ourselves facing these situations without a lot of guidance from the government about where it wants to go. The ambitions associated with this bill are galactic, but the realities are closer to an abandoned—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726963","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to be here today to discuss this important bill. It is a real opportunity to talk about issues that are important to our communities.\n\nThe government has been incredibly ambitious with this bill, talking about the possibility of launching rockets into space from Canada and developing a national space program by 2028. Yet, in front of us we have a bill that is very easy re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc49441166c01a301c29b1985056ee84910532534763ef24019407a26f4546af"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e7cf0ae280e82d71458b2f643ba1f9cb3eba12726bac6f3db4affce8f37e58f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c81b382a754ff2c3da4e2989","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726970,"date":"2026-04-28T17:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is actually a wonderful opportunity to indicate that I will be splitting my time with the member for Montmorency—Charlevoix.\n\nI was starting to talk about the fact that the bill is incredibly ambitious. It has ambitions of galactic proportions, in fact, looking to be able to launch Canadian rockets into space and to enhance our ability to participate in a space program. However, one of the challenges is that right now, the program looks like a gravel pit or a gravel-covered lot in Nova Scotia. I am sure the site was selected for a good reason. I am sure it provides an optimal location to be able to launch from, but I think it is going to be important from an oversight perspective to be able to look at and examine the economics of this deal.\n\nWe have a very unusual set of circumstances. In this particular case, there was no need, it looks like, from the reports, to actually expropriate this great location. It looks like there was in fact an entity that got there. This was originally, I believe, Crown land and was in fact being leased out to someone who has made what might be a deal of galactic proportions, to be able to lease that space back to the government for a very large amount of money.\n\nWhat I struggle with under these circumstances is that the need to examine this transaction comes at a time when the Liberal government has actually taken steps in the House, in the last 24 hours, to make it harder to do that. I was in the ethics committee last night for several hours, listening to some of my colleagues from across the aisle speak at great length and with incredible lung capacity to the reasons the committee should not, in fact, get access to documents that the members of the committee were seeking in order to examine matters related to the Prime Minister's schedule, to conflicts of interest and to other matters that Canadians really deserve to be able to see into.\n\nUnder the conditions we are in, in this country, if we really are, as the Prime Minister says, in a time of rupture, it is so important for the best ideas to rise to the top. There is only one way for us to get the best ideas, and that is to subject them to detailed questioning and analysis.\n\nIt is in that spirit that we approach our duties with respect to the ethics committee. Of course, everyone knows the government wants to live up to its expectations, but the reason that conflict of interest screens exist and committees like the ethics committee exist is that we are all human. This oversight, and the knowledge that this oversight is there, enables us to be crisp in our adherence to the law and to really have it on our minds all the time, which is so important when we are dealing with taxpayer dollars.\n\nThat takes me back to the bill and to the fact that already, within hours, frankly, of the initiative being announced, we have some questions as to the financial circumstances around the selection and lease of the site. On top of that, what we layer onto that is a bill that is really and truly quite thin in terms of its regulation. It does not answer some really important questions around how decisions are made, preferring instead to leave them to the discretion of the executive branch of the government.\n\nThe thing about the executive branch of the government is that it does not operate in this place. It operates across the street and in various other buildings around the parliamentary precinct. It is so important to have that parliamentary oversight, as we think about questions around the safety and security of something as important as a space program, and as we think about the intelligence implications and the other matters that need to be taken into account when we are launching an ambitious program such as this.\n\nWe are examining the bill at a time when the government has taken some steps, in the last 24 hours, to establish sort of an iron control over committees, which it would be able to use to, quite frankly, stifle debate on these issues. \n\nEarlier, one of my colleagues pointed out that in answer to a question about this act, one of the government members involved in transport, I think it might have even been one of the parliamentary secretaries, was discussing how they would be getting information like this. They would be working things out with the Canadian Space Agency. That is of great concern to us because the Canadian Space Agency, while a very important organization, is not an organization that has its focus on security and intelligence matters. \n\nThere are defence implications to a space program like this. There are commercial implications. There are procurement implications. It really is one of those areas where the more I think about it, the more I see the need for a whole-of-government approach. That is not to create additional bureaucracies but to make sure the legislation is precise and clear enough that different parts of the government, different agencies, understand what their roles and responsibilities are and so that regulations around this program can be developed in a sensible and efficient way that would make sure Canada gets the most out of this program at this very important time. \n\nIf we are going to build our country in a way that creates good jobs for the next generation, then it is so important to handle this initiative in a responsible way. It is going to be up to the transport committee, and I know my colleagues will do a good job in thinking the bill through. \n\nWith that, I thank all of my colleagues, from both sides of the aisle, who have contributed to making this important program launch in a good way. I look forward to answering questions about my remarks.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726970","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is actually a wonderful opportunity to indicate that I will be splitting my time with the member for Montmorency—Charlevoix.\n\nI was starting to talk about the fact that the bill is incredibly ambitious. It has ambitions of galactic proportions, in fact, looking to be able to launch Canadian rockets into space and to enhance our ability to participate in a space program. However, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","label":"Space technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","label":"Space technology","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f3f82e051c7878fc4a21ce58aa7506c16eb13d231a778bbc91cea44f4c34088c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb5dcad56ee708e0d69bd13ad96cd2285aece26e0069e92ae1f8562a2363af43"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56508197eb7b9db218402962","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726971,"date":"2026-04-28T18:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for both his ambition and his optimism around this. \n\nIf the bill does speak for itself, it does so very quietly, because it is quite thin on detail. \n\nYes, we agree with the members across the aisle that there is an opportunity here, and we look forward to probing that opportunity in committee and being able to put some substance on the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726971","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for both his ambition and his optimism around this. \n\nIf the bill does speak for itself, it does so very quietly, because it is quite thin on detail. \n\nYes, we agree with the members across the aisle that there is an opportunity here, and we look forward to probing that opportunity in committee and being able to put some substance on the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["662c68aeda157f04af5ffadf8759d174e08a3651a087c9c2c7a6c7df15a173a7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be191f1e5587c12491e8cb2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726973,"date":"2026-04-28T18:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when I was a little girl, I thought these spaceships went to the moon and beyond through magic and that it was a wonderful, amazing illusion. As I look at this bill, I see yet another example of bills that are magic and illusion in the sense that they purport to put us on even ground with the G7 and to do wonderful and amazing things to propel Canada ahead in the world, but there is an awful lot missing when we look under the covers, including the kind of regulation and detail my colleague just outlined.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726973","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when I was a little girl, I thought these spaceships went to the moon and beyond through magic and that it was a wonderful, amazing illusion. As I look at this bill, I see yet another example of bills that are magic and illusion in the sense that they purport to put us on even ground with the G7 and to do wonderful and amazing things to propel Canada ahead in the world, but there is a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31cb2757baadbaf896cda4b14c25e90b421b4f83c845dcb67b18ebfa629bacdb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efac439b2761c714abd24d01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726975,"date":"2026-04-28T18:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, do not get me wrong. I really respect the fact that the government and my colleagues across the way are struggling to meet the world where it is and to find a good response for Canada in that context.\n\nHowever, there is a disturbing trend, and it does not just come through Bill C-28. It has also shown up in other legislation, like in the acts enabling the Major Projects Office or Build Canada Homes, where there is an ambitious, big, splashy announcement made and promises made that are pie in the sky, sky-high and into orbit, but when we look at the details, the message is, \"Just trust us. We have your back.\" In a circumstance where the government is undeniably popular right now, that is one thing, but I hope Canadians do not end up with buyer's remorse down the road when they find out that power has been consolidated in a group of people who do not know how to wield it wisely.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726975","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, do not get me wrong. I really respect the fact that the government and my colleagues across the way are struggling to meet the world where it is and to find a good response for Canada in that context.\n\nHowever, there is a disturbing trend, and it does not just come through Bill C-28. It has also shown up in other legislation, like in the acts enabling the Major Projects Office or Buil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5bdaa90b526c33ff3a24bfcd1559d77b2f9f5cbfce369d1603730f6e72129476"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a73f3007b0a5d9a0cf80fa46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726981,"date":"2026-04-28T19:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, each April 28th we come together in Nanaimo—Ladysmith, throughout Canada and around the world to solemnly mark a day of mourning in memory of people who have lost their life on the job and to renew our commitment to safe workplaces.\n\nWhether someone is a chef on a ferry, a scaffolder on a construction site, a machinist in a mill or an administrator in an office, every worker deserves to know they will return home safe at the end of the day. Today we remember the people who did not make it home. We stand with the families, friends and co-workers who carry that loss, and we recommit ourselves to making workplaces safe for everyone.\n\nHowever, this day is not only about looking back. It is also about moving forward. It is about speaking up when something is not right. It is about supporting one another. It is about making sure safety is never treated as optional. My door is always open to the workers in my community to discuss federal issues related to the important work they do.\n\nToday we honour the fallen and we renew our commitment to protect the living. Every accident, every injury and every loss of life in the workplace is one too many.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726981","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, each April 28th we come together in Nanaimo—Ladysmith, throughout Canada and around the world to solemnly mark a day of mourning in memory of people who have lost their life on the job and to renew our commitment to safe workplaces.\n\nWhether someone is a chef on a ferry, a scaffolder on a construction site, a machinist in a mill or an administrator in an office, every worker deserves ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a8993328f17d082309ee7ac3f5babaabea8d9e76910931551462a18354f88f0a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3c1782516f51fc855704704ecee3b0ee6207664d43134677468ab4226856cf8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14c3ff29f41ff73908b73bc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726982,"date":"2026-04-28T22:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague has done an admirable job of breaking the update down into its various components.\n\nLike the members of the Bloc Québécois, the Conservatives believe in a smaller but more effective federal government that respects provincial powers by focusing on its core responsibilities. This update provides for the creation of a new federal fund and expands Ottawa's role in directing economic investment. Does the Bloc Québécois support this increased centralization, or does it believe that these decisions should remain decentralized in order to reflect local priorities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Centralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726982","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague has done an admirable job of breaking the update down into its various components.\n\nLike the members of the Bloc Québécois, the Conservatives believe in a smaller but more effective federal government that respects provincial powers by focusing on its core responsibilities. This update provides for the creation of a new federal fund and expands Ottawa's role in direc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","label":"Centralization"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Centralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Centralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","label":"Centralization","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb5b2f8d6d2b4170f0442a6f32b48fb98462bead6790c8deb4bea15b664c2d12"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Centralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Centralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d473c00ab4ead80259d0a133c3cf04b993de5701f46ad2e36857f0f7f0c50ce2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Centralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Centralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Centralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017561","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ffefc15b20d98f34822554f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118754,"date":"2026-04-30T16:10:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"CIIT","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Ms. Young, thank you for your speech, which was interesting. It is lovely to see you. I had the pleasure of visiting the Port of Vancouver a few months ago. From where we sit on Vancouver Island, the Port of Vancouver is an important part of a wider network of ports, including the home ports that we have in Nanaimo, that are working to expand trade with reliable partners like Japan, which has been a stable and important partner for Canada as a Pacific nation. As you know, the Port of Nanaimo has just signed a sister port agreement with the Port of Kaohsiung in Taiwan. The CEO, Ian Marr, has played a real leadership role in the Indo-Pacific through the Association of Pacific Ports. As you know, communities like mine are working to deepen ties with partners in the Indo-Pacific region, like Japan and others, that share our strong standards, domestic values and the rule of law. Could you comment on whether you're seeing stronger coordination among ports in countries like Japan, Taiwan and South Korea that share those common governance and trade standards with Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118754","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Ms. Young, thank you for your speech, which was interesting. It is lovely to see you. I had the pleasure of visiting the Port of Vancouver a few months ago. From where we sit on Vancouver Island, the Port of Vancouver is an important part of a wider network of ports, including the home ports that we have in Nanaimo, that are working to expand trade with reliable partners li","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["48dcd2189ce7aa563fd5d2a7a6540e8fbaa27803d484945f8c7e9262991b99a6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff7ff9f5f986f3bc4519726c1e5a6dab8f0ebdcc46362ca10fa77809cbe5785b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39783dc5ef73b18b8f4eeff1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118755,"date":"2026-04-30T16:10:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"CIIT","text":"In your conversations with those Japanese representatives and representatives from other Pacific ports, have you picked up any intelligence or observations from them around how they feel about Canada's rapprochement...and the tensions that it's creating in the Indo-Pacific?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118755","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In your conversations with those Japanese representatives and representatives from other Pacific ports, have you picked up any intelligence or observations from them around how they feel about Canada's rapprochement...and the tensions that it's creating in the Indo-Pacific?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7754c4d4bcb3c081088b2515989e3959fdff54ae47c2a19e5c8e56d90f91564"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ea91550ff571262f810e597","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118756,"date":"2026-04-30T16:20:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"CIIT","text":"That's great to know. In that vein, can you talk about the potential and the opportunities that we have with short sea shipping to be able to address some of those issues?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118756","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's great to know. In that vein, can you talk about the potential and the opportunities that we have with short sea shipping to be able to address some of those issues?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a43fc5c75078e008a6c760cdb2144ecf923b9069c10ca6d4ece8f13dc0158403"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2d5765c587451e7e54625d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118757,"date":"2026-04-30T16:20:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"CIIT","text":"That's great. I know that our folks are very eager to work on that with you. They see tremendous opportunities to be able to enforce Canada's trade resilience and take advantage of those opportunities. As you know, we've grown some of our Vancouver Island exports with Japan through initiatives that include things like kiln-dried lumber and so on. Given the increased uncertainty in global trade, could you comment on how important it is for the western ports to work together to be able to present that one-network approach to deepening relationships with reliable partners for Canada, like Japan?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118757","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's great. I know that our folks are very eager to work on that with you. They see tremendous opportunities to be able to enforce Canada's trade resilience and take advantage of those opportunities. As you know, we've grown some of our Vancouver Island exports with Japan through initiatives that include things like kiln-dried lumber and so on. Given the increased uncertainty in global trade, co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df5bcf436ca2567a680094bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118758,"date":"2026-04-30T16:20:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"CIIT","text":"In the short time that I have left, I want to turn to the LNG side of things. I'm wondering if you could comment on the increase in our LNG exports and whether we are missing some opportunities in that space, compared to competitors such as the United States.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118758","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the short time that I have left, I want to turn to the LNG side of things. I'm wondering if you could comment on the increase in our LNG exports and whether we are missing some opportunities in that space, compared to competitors such as the United States.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c952007232986496c05d38a535a2023bcdf1b231e80b94523e66c1aa2cd5d795"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d8ffe1d192000b9ae03c19fa236d7a05deb49224470208f167c7bb1f45f38dec"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a8c82160e406b87ff411978","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118759,"date":"2026-04-30T17:40:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"CIIT","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Nighbor, it's wonderful to see you here today. Diversification has been the topic of the day. Can you share with us the important work that the Canada Wood Group does on the ground in Japan and how maintaining that kind of in-market presence is important for Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118759","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Nighbor, it's wonderful to see you here today. Diversification has been the topic of the day. Can you share with us the important work that the Canada Wood Group does on the ground in Japan and how maintaining that kind of in-market presence is important for Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae29dd123b0f03cc7325f414","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118760,"date":"2026-04-30T17:40:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"CIIT","text":"Thank you for that. Of course, we are incredibly proud of Harmac in our community. Given the current challenges with the U.S. market, how much mitigation can Japan really provide, and how important is it for Canadian lumber producers and the people who are a part of your association that Canada gets a deal with the United States?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118760","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that. Of course, we are incredibly proud of Harmac in our community. Given the current challenges with the U.S. market, how much mitigation can Japan really provide, and how important is it for Canadian lumber producers and the people who are a part of your association that Canada gets a deal with the United States?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["087e3b6d9a6f7f14d7409fdf6cfd940d01f06848ff327cd5c3a456b2e00870d6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["090a6651f8f7ebe74a7f5bbf6f9c1fe936f7e8584a75f228c28e2fe731cac383"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f60ebcdb486191979869a5ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118761,"date":"2026-04-30T17:40:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"CIIT","text":"Before I turn back, do you get regular updates from the Canadian government on those negotiations? Do you have a good window into where we're headed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118761","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Before I turn back, do you get regular updates from the Canadian government on those negotiations? Do you have a good window into where we're headed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["894feff3e7e4ea8c2e496ca21ce35963df955442a079e1a3919d1bd0d6746997"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ad58df5f7b61f5e754b19072b683e23053fd81d9c08b3414c85fd601305a8d2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d04ae9445c32de14389af0f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118762,"date":"2026-04-30T17:40:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"CIIT","text":"Turning back to the Japanese relationship and our more global efforts at diversification, I understand that the Canada Wood Group has had its federal funding reduced over the last few years. How is that keeping pace with our competitors? As we look towards diversification, are our competitors investing more in these relationships?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118762","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Turning back to the Japanese relationship and our more global efforts at diversification, I understand that the Canada Wood Group has had its federal funding reduced over the last few years. How is that keeping pace with our competitors? As we look towards diversification, are our competitors investing more in these relationships?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083607","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade promotion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083607","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Trade promotion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083607","label":"Trade promotion","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a6a1479b78cb0252524b610db08e5130901072ec16633dfc4cb2b409fe71413c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5996efaaa013e62318965515","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118763,"date":"2026-04-30T17:40:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"CIIT","text":"As we move forward on this, if Canada does fail to act on this file, who stands to benefit from that, and how quickly could we lose market share? Also, just to get into the mix on the changing relationship with China, can you comment on how the Japanese feel about that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118763","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As we move forward on this, if Canada does fail to act on this file, who stands to benefit from that, and how quickly could we lose market share? Also, just to get into the mix on the changing relationship with China, can you comment on how the Japanese feel about that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d23d11904eb5a45346349ea23793f0c6b4ba03a148b0f9aeed8c0a2bff12066"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f25bfbe610cb2bad9f790ce4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118794,"date":"2026-04-30T20:55:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I want to echo the thanks of my colleague from the Bloc Québécois. You've taken on a really complicated topic, you've reviewed it and you've really put something comprehensive forward. A number of us sit on the human rights subcommittee of the foreign affairs committee in addition to being here, and this means a lot to us. As we've said quite a lot lately, democracy is something that dies in the darkness, and you've really taken steps to shine a light on that darkness through this bill, which addresses six key areas. It brings forward human rights accountability reporting. It defines and recognizes transnational repression. It expands sanctions. It brings asset forfeiture and enforcement timelines into line and into a stronger regime. It helps with transparency and parliamentary oversight, and then it takes that additional step to deal with issues of foreign influence and broadcasting controls. I get a lot of correspondence from Canadians whose families are targeted by foreign regimes and from others who are concerned about transnational repression, foreign interference and disinformation and, of course, the presence of war criminals in Canada. They want Canada to act on things. We've talked a lot about the importance of this bill theoretically. I'm wondering.... You must have spoken to a number of Canadians who shared their personal stories with you. Do you think you could talk a bit and expand a little on the way in which this is going to make a difference and matter to Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118794","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I want to echo the thanks of my colleague from the Bloc Québécois. You've taken on a really complicated topic, you've reviewed it and you've really put something comprehensive forward. A number of us sit on the human rights subcommittee of the foreign affairs committee in addition to being here, and this means a lot to us. As we've said quite a lot lately, democracy i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transborder data flow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","label":"Transborder data flow","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a4707709633e4d782eeee7e068d5d0abf57dbc04d464a6566eeb1b16f8a55de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58447fb8864129c78f558d47fe56aa0c4403197f240c410fef5f738bb0841d0c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6290b97c3fe3f43f80811c39","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118795,"date":"2026-04-30T21:00:00+00:00","title":"FAAE","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FAAE","text":"I want to thank you for that comprehensive answer. I know that the bill does define transnational repression specifically as \"tactics used by a foreign state to intimidate, harass, surveil or threaten individuals or groups located outside the state borders\". I am certain that Canadians who are experiencing those things will take some comfort from the fact that the Government of Canada now clearly defines that activity as being something that is offensive to our values and criminal.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FAAE/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118795","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to thank you for that comprehensive answer. I know that the bill does define transnational repression specifically as \"tactics used by a foreign state to intimidate, harass, surveil or threaten individuals or groups located outside the state borders\". I am certain that Canadians who are experiencing those things will take some comfort from the fact that the Government of Canada now clearly ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08cf4af37aec87b53910a8e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726936,"date":"2026-05-01T16:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, Loaves & Fishes serves more than 15,000 in more than 44 communities on the island. They are vital, and they are growing, with a new 24,000-square-foot warehouse set to open this month. Some 80% of Canadians say food prices have increased more than any other expense. Groceries, without meat or cheese, regularly cost $100 a bag on the island, yet the Liberal government continues to tell Canadians they have never had it so good.\n\nEvery measure we propose, they oppose. How many food bank expansions do the Liberals need to see before they stop their costly credit card spending and actually bring food costs down for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726936","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, Loaves & Fishes serves more than 15,000 in more than 44 communities on the island. They are vital, and they are growing, with a new 24,000-square-foot warehouse set to open this month. Some 80% of Canadians say food prices have increased more than any other expense. Groceries, without meat or cheese, regularly cost $100 a bag on the island, yet the Liberal government continues to te","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","label":"Aquatic ecosystems","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fcb703a422ea4c2305fd6c53e240170df97056a2bb6a02f9ac35b5a2ab56f99b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57e3e5466d9202c93d2ccf8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726938,"date":"2026-05-01T17:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague mentioned several cases where the government failed to consult properly and where it lacked transparency. He talked about a worrisome trend that we have seen this week now that the Liberals have a majority in committee. They have been holding committee meetings in camera and preventing Canadians and other parliamentarians from having access to important information and participating in debates.\n\nCan my colleague tell us more about his concerns?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726938","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague mentioned several cases where the government failed to consult properly and where it lacked transparency. He talked about a worrisome trend that we have seen this week now that the Liberals have a majority in committee. They have been holding committee meetings in camera and preventing Canadians and other parliamentarians from having access to important information and pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d665ece8791369c34e2ae1b2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726940,"date":"2026-05-01T17:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for his thoughtful remarks.\n\nAs he can see from my exchanges with him and his colleagues in French, I want to understand the needs of all Canadians, including those in Quebec.\n\nWe share concerns about forestry and the government's lack of attention to major challenges facing our communities. What struck me was the absence of the term \"substance abuse\". The government eliminated the position of minister of mental health and addictions and does not seem to care about the crisis plaguing my community.\n\nTo what extent could Quebec be affected by this as well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726940","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for his thoughtful remarks.\n\nAs he can see from my exchanges with him and his colleagues in French, I want to understand the needs of all Canadians, including those in Quebec.\n\nWe share concerns about forestry and the government's lack of attention to major challenges facing our communities. What struck me was the absence of the term \"substance abuse\". The governmen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7c18ca1aae908219c3826f9300302e19b89f5af1440da97aac5599f6ce837eda"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8de76a39f062908b02ae18a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726944,"date":"2026-05-01T18:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the hon. member has done a tremendous service to our country today. Not only has she helped those who struggle with addiction, trauma and insecure housing to see themselves here in this place, she has also blazed a path for some of them to get here with her bill, which I will be proud to stand up and second in a moment.\n\nShe inspires me and I just want to provide her with another opportunity to provide any additional advice that she has to share with the people watching at home who might need some of that inspiration as we continue to grapple with our ongoing addictions crisis.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726944","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the hon. member has done a tremendous service to our country today. Not only has she helped those who struggle with addiction, trauma and insecure housing to see themselves here in this place, she has also blazed a path for some of them to get here with her bill, which I will be proud to stand up and second in a moment.\n\nShe inspires me and I just want to provide her with another op","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b06abe3d7867e7f31a9acb1d9c9ab52c3398e696595d2aab6a2b30ecf7a27a29"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d13de25b71a8d26714f47a320eb2e0e1ed599609f8167b346364b6452988b9ae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a543faf910d84d68844b278","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726957,"date":"2026-05-01T19:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I come from a place where we have stunning coastline, innovative businesses, delicious restaurants, talented artists and a mild climate that makes me want to put down whatever I am doing and take the dog for a hike.\n\nWe have much to celebrate, but we also have one of the highest death rates from overdose in Canada, fuelled by an addictions crisis that is ruining people's lives, leaving them with traumatic brain injuries and killing far too many. The numbers have been improving but we are still one of Canada's hardest-hit communities with insufficient services, social disorder, and a crime rate and crime severity index that are both well above the national average.\n\nMany people struggle with addiction without ever committing a crime, but when people live on the street without stable support while dealing with a serious addiction, a significant percentage will inevitably have repeated contact with the criminal justice system. It is a cycle that is hard to break. Addiction leads to instability, instability encourages poor choices and those poor choices lead right back into the criminal justice.\n\nWe have had porta-potty arson with four set on fire in just one night; a person who roamed a busy downtown mall parking lot with a hypodermic syringe attached to a toy bow and arrow; a city worker stabbed over and over again with syringes in a park washroom; addiction-driven assaults with axes, illegal firearms, knives, bricks, bear spray and human feces; and crime on boats, in coffee shops and in homes. I once had a local fire official tell me that the probability of a fire in certain kinds of buildings was 100%.\n\nThese are not organized or rational crimes. They reflect instability and create real fear in our community. The people who commit them often cannot be deterred or treated through the traditional tools of our criminal justice system. That is why I am proud to rise today to second and support Bill C-240, the offender rehabilitation act, sponsored by my colleague from Kitchener Centre. This bill combines accountability with real rehabilitation, taking a practical, balanced and long-overdue step toward improving both community safety and offender outcomes in my community and across Canada.\n\nCanada is one of the only western countries that automatically releases offenders before the end of their sentence, regardless of behaviour. Canada's current approach does not encourage change, it does not reward effort and it does not give Canadians confidence.\n\nThis legislation would allow judges to require offenders to participate in education, training or treatment programs while serving their sentence. It would consider progress in those programs in parole decisions. It would introduce the principle that early release should be earned through demonstrated effort and real change. This comes as recidivism rates in Canada remain too high, with estimates approaching 88% for some populations.\n\nHowever, if prisons are merely storage facilities, if someone walks out of custody with the same skills, the same habits and the same challenges they had when they went in, we should not be surprised when they reoffend. First-time offenders increasingly lack basic education and job skills. Many do not have a high school diploma. Others struggle with literacy and executive function. We just cannot tell a person struggling with both addiction and ADHD, who lives on the street, to show up Tuesday at 10 a.m. and expect them to be there. Education, skills training and treatment programs in corrections are linked to better employment outcomes and lower rates of reoffending by as much as 30%.\n\nI had the chance to see this in action on a recent visit to the Nanaimo Correctional Centre. The Guthrie program is a separate, provincially funded therapeutic community unit within the Nanaimo Correctional Centre that builds life skills, responsibility and practical tools that offenders need to reintegrate into society. Participants are given the kind of responsibility that builds capacity, that teaches them to lead, and that will help them find work and build stability when they return to their communities.\n\nBeing there reminded me that the people who end up in prison for convictions tied to addiction are not just our fathers, sisters and children. They are also our teachers, lawyers and skilled workers. Addiction does not discriminate, and when it takes hold, it can unravel even the most stable lives.\n\nHere is the rub: Programs like Guthrie exist and the expertise exists. What has been missing is a system that consistently and effectively evaluates the people in it for potential rehabilitation, encourages and incentivizes participation, and ties it to outcomes. Also missing are clear incentives and spaces for women, visible minorities and other populations who face systemic and persistent discrimination.\n\nThis bill would provide the federal government with reasons to work with the provinces to create and expand programs such as the Guthrie program, both in and out of correctional facilities, by empowering judges to prescribe structured rehabilitation programs for offenders who would benefit from skills development, education and recovery as part of a holistic healing program.\n\nIt costs roughly $125,000 a year to incarcerate someone in a men's institution and over $215,000 a year in a women's institution. By contrast, community-based programs that support reintegration cost a fraction of that, often as low as $15,000 per person per year, while delivering better outcomes. While corrections-based programs are more expensive, the investment in programs like the Guthrie program pay off in lower recidivism and better outcomes for everyone.\n\nBill C-240 is not soft on crime. It is smart on recovery. It would require parole boards to consider an offender's progress in completing court-ordered rehabilitation programs when making parole decisions. It would also enable stricter penalties for fentanyl traffickers by making trafficking fentanyl in large quantities an aggravating factor in sentencing. \n\nThis is the work I came to this place to do. I am deeply grateful to my colleague from Kitchener Centre for letting me and, by extension, the people of Nanaimo—Ladysmith, play a role in moving this important legislation forward. \n\nOther jurisdictions have already shown that, when accountability is combined with structured rehabilitation, there are better results. In countries like Norway, the system places a strong emphasis on education, work skills and personal responsibility during incarceration. Release decisions are closely tied to readiness for reintegration. When someone leaves custody, they are better prepared to lead a law-abiding life. The results speak for themselves. Norway has some of the lowest recidivism rates in the world. \n\nWe should not copy any one system exactly. Canada has its own context, its own challenges and its own legal framework, but the principle is consistent. If we want safer communities, we have to reduce reoffending, and if we want to reduce reoffending, we need a system that promotes real change, not just the passage of time. \n\nThis bill would take an important step in that direction and would provide powerful incentives for the federal government to work with the provinces to expand programs like the Guthrie program across the country. The bill would do its work carefully and responsibly. It would build confidence while improving outcomes. It would be fair and effective, and it would improve public safety. \n\nVictims and their families want a system that takes accountability seriously, but they also want a system that has a measure of mercy and opportunity for change, and they would really like to see a system that actually stops what has happened to them and their loved ones from happening to others.\n\nBy strengthening the link between rehabilitation and release, offenders have an opportunity to break the pattern to improve their lives. There is sometimes a tendency to frame these issues as a choice between being tough on crime and supporting rehabilitation. That is the wrong way to look at it, because justice requires both.\n\nI think back to what I saw at the Nanaimo Correctional Centre. I did not see criminals; I saw people. I saw people who, with the right support and the weight of expectations, are taking steps to change their lives. I saw corrections officers committed to that goal, and I saw a program that makes a real difference.\n\nThis bill would align with those outcomes. Every time someone leaves custody, they return to a neighbourhood, family, workplace and community. One question we should be asking is: Are they are more or less likely to offend? This legislation would help ensure the answer is the one Canadians want.\n\nFor those reasons, I encourage all members of the House to support this bill, and I am proud to second and support it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726957","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I come from a place where we have stunning coastline, innovative businesses, delicious restaurants, talented artists and a mild climate that makes me want to put down whatever I am doing and take the dog for a hike.\n\nWe have much to celebrate, but we also have one of the highest death rates from overdose in Canada, fuelled by an addictions crisis that is ruining people's lives, leav","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea777c6d35d448354e4aed22774b5628bf22d8cfd264f04a9323f010f5b2edc1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d5d9e9c6076b710f0bc85275857d43cf5f3a664c6740fac25d52739d33d6ae70"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a4ba689ab1582aa04248479","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949813,"date":"2026-05-04T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have painted themselves into a corner. They failed to negotiate a treaty with Cowichan Tribes, so they got sued and lost in Richmond. Now the Prime Minister says he will advance \"viable legal arguments to protect private property\", but the Liberals told their lawyers not to argue the primacy of property rights at trial. By now, it must have dawned on them that an argument not advanced at trial is not viable on appeal, because the minister just told us he is asking private property owners to do their work for them. \n\nThe Liberals talk about negotiation, but the failure to negotiate is how we got here in the first place, so what are they going to do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949813","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have painted themselves into a corner. They failed to negotiate a treaty with Cowichan Tribes, so they got sued and lost in Richmond. Now the Prime Minister says he will advance \"viable legal arguments to protect private property\", but the Liberals told their lawyers not to argue the primacy of property rights at trial. By now, it must have dawned on them that an argument","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9402832494fe3413c078a76398cc5ab5ea04b91312206f38d28011916976ae76"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a5a8e06e67474c943bd2c8c23d4ada8a54c6a339c738d73e1491bc4e207447f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a5d026d0b2b69d76d48a97d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949814,"date":"2026-05-04T23:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-11 was supposed to improve how justice works inside the Canadian Armed Forces. There have been serious and persistent concerns that misconduct, especially sexual misconduct, has not been handled fairly or independently in our military. The government dragged its feet for years. There were three reports done on this matter over a period of seven years. Finally, with the tabling of this bill, the government appeared to be addressing these issues. The initial draft of the bill proposed to move serious cases, including sexual assault, into the civilian courts. Many expected this move to be welcomed and to be seen as a serious step toward better accountability and stronger protection for victims. \n\nThe committee system in the House of Commons is designed to allow members of Parliament to examine legislation in depth. Committees act as the engine room of this place, and every so often we find out in our committees that we were wrong. That is what happened with this bill, because it turns out that our military did not wait for government to act. In the years between the release of the Deschamps, Fish and Arbour reports, our military implemented mandatory duties to report. It trained the chain of command, military police and health care providers. It implemented a victims rights charter and provided access to independent legal supports and access to victims liaison services. \n\nThe military has not solved all of the problems, but it took some pretty big steps forward that make military tribunals the forum of choice for some victims. An incredible, and very credible, group of witnesses came to the defence committee hearings on this bill and told us so. In response, Conservative members of the defence committee worked with members from all opposition parties to improve the bill to respond to the reasonable proposals by survivors and experts that military sexual assault victims be allowed to play a role in determining whether their cases would be investigated and heard in civilian or military courts. They asked for choice, and the committee worked to embed that choice into the bill. \n\nThen, a few days ago, the Minister of National Defence tabled amendments to the bill at the report stage that ignored that advice, dismissed the testimony heard over weeks at committee and effectively restored much of the original drafting. \n\nWhen I last rose to speak to this bill, I tried to drive home the point that this debate is about more than just legislation. It is about trust. It is about whether those who don a Canadian military uniform and serve this country can trust that the system will protect them, can trust it to be fair and can trust it to deliver just outcomes. \n\nYesterday I spoke at a ceremony in my community commemorating the 81st anniversary of the Battle of the Atlantic. We had more than 50 air and sea cadets participate, more than 50 young souls who are the future of our military, souls whom Canada may yet send off to war. The cadets were excellent. They participated in the colour guard, they stood sentry at the cenotaph, and they helped dignitaries lay wreaths. One played the Last Post and Lament on her bugle, another read the prayer for the air force, and another read the roll call of ships lost, while yet another rang the bell. It was beautiful and inspiring, and our community is so very proud of them. \n\nToday, as we debate this bill at report stage, the question of whether those cadets and the many others who serve our country can trust the system still hangs over this chamber. Have we earned that trust? If the answer depends on this version of Bill C-11, it is unfortunately a resounding no. Members of the House worked in good faith across party lines to improve the bill, and we stand by the wisdom of the committee with respect to choice for survivors of sexual assault in the military.\n\nMy support for the bill is contingent on the Liberal government upholding not only the amendments made by Conservatives at the defence committee but also those made by the other parties, including the member of that committee who has since crossed the floor to join the Liberals. Will she now vote against her own amendments and those she supported?\n\n The Liberals have chosen to use their new majority in this House to undo the work of this committee. They have chosen to double down on what we now understand to be a poor choice to push sexual assault cases onto an already overburdened civilian police and court system without providing the resources that local police forces and provincial courts need to deal with military cases. Instead of listening to the experts and increasing the independence of the military justice system, the defence minister wants to preserve his ability to interfere with ministerial directives to ensure that the director of military defence counsel services, the director of military prosecutions and the provost marshal general stay under the thumb of the chain of command. \n\nThese decisions are all ill-advised and would do nothing to improve conditions in our military at a time when our military needs our support. If there is even a perception that decisions can be influenced by the chain of command or by political considerations, confidence in the military justice system will remain fragile. \n\nMy hon. colleague from Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, who served our country faithfully as a navy commander, spoke to that human cost in a way that should stay with all of us. He reminded us that behind every policy gap and every delay there is a person, someone who stepped forward to serve, who put on a uniform and who deserves better from their country. Every time the government fails to protect victims, it means another member of the Canadian Armed Forces is left wondering whether it is worth coming forward. It means another survivor is weighing the risk of speaking out against the likelihood of being ignored. It means another erosion of confidence in an institution that Canadians should be able to believe in without hesitation.\n\n The Minister of National Defence admitted at committee that he did not consult victims himself. He admitted that he did not consult with Justices Arbour, Fish or Deschamps on this file. He admitted that he did not consult provincial justice ministers or provincial or municipal police officers in the more than a year since this chamber considered Bill C-66, the predecessor to this bill. This reflects a disturbing trend that we see through the Liberal approach to our justice system, where government legislation seems to consistently prefer the accused over victims. It also reflects the approach that the government took to Bill C-3 at report stage, when it again used its relationships in this House to undo the work of committee.\n\n In the context of the way that our military has progressed these issues, the request by witnesses for choice in deciding whether to engage the civilian justice system or the military tribunal system makes sense, because in some cases the military system will have conflicts of interest or other issues created by proximity or relationships. In other circumstances, the civilian justice system just would not have enough people with the lived experiences to be able to deal with the facts of a particular case when situated within military culture.\n\n In one case, a witness at committee testified that, as a francophone, she would like to be able to choose the military pathway to ensure that she would be able to have access to services and proceedings in French rather than having to follow proceedings in English, as she would have to do through the serendipities of locations should she find herself serving in an anglophone province.\n\n If cases are going to move to civilian courts, there is work to be done up front with the provinces to make sure they can absorb these cases. If the federal government simply moves these cases by fiat, without ensuring that the system is ready, we risk serious failure, the kind of delay that increases the risk that cases collapse before they are heard and further frustrates those seeking justice.\n\n Canadians have heard promises from the government before. They have seen announcements and commitments, but too often they have not seen results. My hon. colleague from Selkirk—Interlake—Eastman has been persistent in pressing this point.\n\nThis is not an abstract policy debate. It is about real people and their real pain. The government has a choice to make, and my vote hinges on the balance with that choice.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949814","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-11 was supposed to improve how justice works inside the Canadian Armed Forces. There have been serious and persistent concerns that misconduct, especially sexual misconduct, has not been handled fairly or independently in our military. The government dragged its feet for years. There were three reports done on this matter over a period of seven years. Finally, with the tabling ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","label":"Military law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","label":"Military law","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a5b666cd99a8950f8e3301b75dceab82b37044ff457371e3dcc0c548ffe0431"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cf39a143b91f01068001be7d3c70dcbae07c9cab22072b5bcf0e01384790020d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f56a71a2fd7bf33839a54295","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949815,"date":"2026-05-04T23:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I commend my hon. colleague for his desire to support the military.\n\nAs he was in committee, he would have heard that people in the military need this choice in order to be supported. While Madam Justice Arbour's recommendations were right for the time at which they were made, the government took so long to act that there are better ways to address this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949815","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I commend my hon. colleague for his desire to support the military.\n\nAs he was in committee, he would have heard that people in the military need this choice in order to be supported. While Madam Justice Arbour's recommendations were right for the time at which they were made, the government took so long to act that there are better ways to address this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87ad717673e99f941755ffc822a875b6919dbd03ab57f8e01f8ad9bc14ad18c0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9a086bfa6b64581ec528acc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949816,"date":"2026-05-04T23:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his good question.\n\nThis is something that I really struggle with, because we face allegations from our colleagues across the way every day in the House, that we are obstructionist or that we are standing in the way. Yet, this bill offers a phenomenal opportunity for members of all parties to work together to listen to Canadians to make a bill better.\n\nIt hurts my heart that Liberals would use their majority in this way, quite frankly, to strip this House of the good work that was done at committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949816","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his good question.\n\nThis is something that I really struggle with, because we face allegations from our colleagues across the way every day in the House, that we are obstructionist or that we are standing in the way. Yet, this bill offers a phenomenal opportunity for members of all parties to work together to listen to Canadians to make a bill better.\n\nIt hurt","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95f9a7705a3930d2d47f1899771df4c1c2485d44d14f6af069938ebb781c9782"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a03f010caea8b163087cdaf3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949817,"date":"2026-05-04T23:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I had the privilege, before I was elected to this place, of being able to work with Madam Justice Arbour for a year when I worked at the ICTY in The Hague. I know the kind of work that she does. There is no doubt in my mind that the work she did and the report she provided allowed our military to make progress with respect to the issues that are addressed in this bill.\n\nI only wish that the defence minister had taken the time to listen to people the way that Madam Justice Arbour does, and possibly to consult with her so that we could have avoided the mistakes that were made with this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949817","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I had the privilege, before I was elected to this place, of being able to work with Madam Justice Arbour for a year when I worked at the ICTY in The Hague. I know the kind of work that she does. There is no doubt in my mind that the work she did and the report she provided allowed our military to make progress with respect to the issues that are addressed in this bill.\n\nI only wish th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["297cd139df1fbdfcc41f391b3e898dfe9f73886f52615281ba778be96b2582a2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab37429b8f377e4296ab3a56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949812,"date":"2026-05-05T21:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the member's focus on supporting businesses in her community. She displayed a very admirable depth of knowledge of those businesses. Burlington, of course, is a region that is deeply connected to cross-border trade, where jobs and local growth depend heavily on the government being able to address these issues.\n\nShe praised the government's swift action. I am wondering if the member could name a single U.S. tariff on Canadian goods that has been lifted as a direct result of Liberal government action.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949812","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the member's focus on supporting businesses in her community. She displayed a very admirable depth of knowledge of those businesses. Burlington, of course, is a region that is deeply connected to cross-border trade, where jobs and local growth depend heavily on the government being able to address these issues.\n\nShe praised the government's swift action. I am wondering if","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c9f4983b4fe4faf16b17cb51551f9e224d59bcc59ff4bec4b2bfecbad3303b1b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["16a3b18037f99ce4b87b7eb7002f8af5b89337fdc34153fb082227f07aa887cb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8a2772f384ae7b9b5012336","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949811,"date":"2026-05-06T21:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I was in the House for the first part of my hon. colleague's excellent speech and was delighted to be here today for the rest of it. Our ridings have a lot in common, even though they are on opposite sides of the country. They are resource-based. They are filled with families, and they are struggling right now, yet the members across the way continue to stand up and tell us that Canadians have never had it so good and that the economy is all sunshine and rainbows.\n\n I am wondering if the member can talk a bit about what it feels like on the ground under current circumstances in her communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949811","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I was in the House for the first part of my hon. colleague's excellent speech and was delighted to be here today for the rest of it. Our ridings have a lot in common, even though they are on opposite sides of the country. They are resource-based. They are filled with families, and they are struggling right now, yet the members across the way continue to stand up and tell us that Canad","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40e33d36d0b77eb6cd73616d3c16344541b52e004ed94f4cd3bcca362157007c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d0074e51f1025eed0b71c88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118764,"date":"2026-05-07T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Ms. El Bied, I want to pick up where my colleague left off. You were explaining that your department spent $11 million on a flood risk awareness portal that doesn't work, has data that isn't evergreen and no province has yet opted into. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118764","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Ms. El Bied, I want to pick up where my colleague left off. You were explaining that your department spent $11 million on a flood risk awareness portal that doesn't work, has data that isn't evergreen and no province has yet opted into. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8bcf236c3564ec146aac6a043504c6d9349ef4cf09b025756c97316ab3fd7997"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56329714325f04fa7af12f2d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118765,"date":"2026-05-07T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"My understanding is that the reason that B.C. hasn't opted in is that it is not sure that your data matches its data. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118765","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My understanding is that the reason that B.C. hasn't opted in is that it is not sure that your data matches its data. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","label":"Data processing","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d041d9ec23f1f76e27853311f8379783d60c4b6e6d0faad5051e579b1d84384"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f474c62f8f00e0be305c7cda","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118766,"date":"2026-05-07T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"Your data isn't evergreen. Is B.C.'s data evergreen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118766","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Your data isn't evergreen. Is B.C.'s data evergreen?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-251f769be86fbbbc2f7bb006","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118767,"date":"2026-05-07T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay. The report indicates that less than half of the mapping projects that are currently under way cover high-risk zones that your department identified in 2022. Can you tell me how you justify mapping low-risk areas when the most vulnerable Canadians remain unprotected?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118767","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. The report indicates that less than half of the mapping projects that are currently under way cover high-risk zones that your department identified in 2022. Can you tell me how you justify mapping low-risk areas when the most vulnerable Canadians remain unprotected?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["364b6dd26649ba8caf697824b2d5efbe294228cc5c2c5d3ccf36e837897bbe86"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8459bf09ff0be6976520f9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118768,"date":"2026-05-07T17:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"You're saying that dollars are well spent, but we've just established that the portal isn't usable. Commissioner DeMarco noted in his opening statements that government departments have collectively spent more than $230 million to produce tools that aren't useful, usable or produced in a timely manner. As a result, the report concludes, \"Canadians face escalating risks and higher disaster recovery costs\". Do you know who bears these costs in British Columbia?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118768","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You're saying that dollars are well spent, but we've just established that the portal isn't usable. Commissioner DeMarco noted in his opening statements that government departments have collectively spent more than $230 million to produce tools that aren't useful, usable or produced in a timely manner. As a result, the report concludes, \"Canadians face escalating risks and higher disaster recovery","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["428f1d5910e1392cd1cca538f52e8a78e1992b896bfebcc203307c8bfa011953"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b789bea9e8b1eda3a6ef514","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118769,"date":"2026-05-07T17:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"However, do you know who bears the costs? When this government and your department spend money and produce things that aren't useful, usable or produced in a timely manner, as the commissioner and these reports have pointed out, do you know who bears the actual results? Do you know who bears the outcomes of those risks and those costs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118769","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"However, do you know who bears the costs? When this government and your department spend money and produce things that aren't useful, usable or produced in a timely manner, as the commissioner and these reports have pointed out, do you know who bears the actual results? Do you know who bears the outcomes of those risks and those costs?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7073846b0a04a0cde4148c3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118770,"date":"2026-05-07T17:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"It's not the people who die in atmospheric rivers in British Columbia, the people who lose their homes or the people who can't get flood insurance. What we're facing in British Columbia is an increase in the intensity of atmospheric rivers. We're seeing more of these atmospheric rivers on a yearly basis than we've seen in previous decades. What's happening is that we're paying for this twice. First of all, we're paying for it as taxpayers, and we're paying a second time with the losses that result from the floods that affect our homes and communities. You may want to come to these committees and talk about the benefits that accrue in theory, but I can tell you that, in practice, the implications of the failures of these government departments on our communities are measured in dollars, lives and loss of homes. What do you have to say to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118770","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's not the people who die in atmospheric rivers in British Columbia, the people who lose their homes or the people who can't get flood insurance. What we're facing in British Columbia is an increase in the intensity of atmospheric rivers. We're seeing more of these atmospheric rivers on a yearly basis than we've seen in previous decades. What's happening is that we're paying for this twice. Firs","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","label":"Rivers","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d924926ff28ba3182cd395d53456b21ace7ae5efb490389bfecfae6dd816821a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d25d7fd63f8cb47d0e873e08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118771,"date":"2026-05-07T17:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"Is anyone using those tools?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118771","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is anyone using those tools?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-770abdb539ccd7b898432aba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118772,"date":"2026-05-07T17:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"What homeowners in British Columbia are able to use tools for a risk portal that we've just been told the province hasn't opted into?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118772","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What homeowners in British Columbia are able to use tools for a risk portal that we've just been told the province hasn't opted into?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0cabb9bad686c16a8062e22454dfefc31bc4aca7ba8e9c42e013c1cd9f6570d5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ed32c65848276cbf68f04ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118773,"date":"2026-05-07T17:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"You said that's 2029.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118773","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You said that's 2029.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bf44cd6cbf0bb5a75351cfd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118774,"date":"2026-05-07T17:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"ENVI","text":"What I'm hearing from you is that this is a great program, and it's going to do great things for British Columbians. What I'm hearing from the commissioner is that $230 million has been spent on something that's not usable, not useful and not delivered in a timely manner. How do you reconcile that? Since neither of you is going to answer the question, I do have one question for the commissioner. You've produced this report. It is very informative, and it displays quite clearly for taxpayers what value we aren't getting for our money in British Columbia and across the country. Are there any enforcement mechanisms that you have? Is there anything you can do about this, or is the best you can do to put the data out and hope that something better happens?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118774","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What I'm hearing from you is that this is a great program, and it's going to do great things for British Columbians. What I'm hearing from the commissioner is that $230 million has been spent on something that's not usable, not useful and not delivered in a timely manner. How do you reconcile that? Since neither of you is going to answer the question, I do have one question for the commissioner. Y","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a2c3a8576498184b867a0ac54edb0ae3ff9cc1bc01f98139807e0c0de0e864f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9cb6a28010ac3aee02726b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949806,"date":"2026-05-07T18:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the most important changes in life are often invisible at first. Seeds sprout underground before the first shoots appear. A ship that changes course by one degree makes no waves, but ends up somewhere entirely different. A coastline can look unchanged for years, while the tide quietly reshapes it, grain by grain.\n\nOn August 7, 2025, when the B.C. Supreme Court released the Cowichan Tribes decision, nothing happened. No Canadian lost their home. Richmond continued to function. The Cowichan Tribes repeatedly said they never intended to interfere with private fee simple title. Yet, the judge decided, first, that the Cowichan have aboriginal title to land in Richmond, and second, that Crown grants of fee simple in those lands unjustifiably infringe that title. The court did say that private fee simple interests remain valid, but only \"until such a time as a court may determine otherwise or until the conflicting interests are otherwise resolved through negotiation.\" With that \"until\", a seed was planted. Homeowners are now aware that a court could \"determine otherwise\", and many of them are nervous. \n\n At paragraph 3543 of a very long decision, the judge added, \"I accept that a declaration of Aboriginal title may give rise to some uncertainty for the fee simple title holders and it may have consequences for their interests in land.\" Within days, it became clear that uncertainty had taken root. Within weeks, the first signs of a growing set of complications became visible. When a person gets a mortgage, their home is the collateral for the loan. If the mortgagor's title is uncertain, they are going to have a problem. When a person sells a property, they promise valid title. If the seller's title is uncertain, they are going to have a problem.\n\nAnyone who claims to understand the full implication of the Cowichan Tribes decision at this point is fooling themselves. We are now seeing transactions delayed, financing reconsidered and investment decisions paused in British Columbia. The case has already reportedly tanked a $100‐million deal and created complications with mortgage and property transactions. The B.C. Financial Services Authority is recommending independent legal advice before buying affected properties. Real estate agents are adding new clauses to purchase agreements across the province. Title insurers are reassessing risk. \n\nThe Musqueam agreement followed quickly on the Cowichan Tribes decision, adding additional uncertainty. Investors are skittish and wondering what is coming next. Uncertainty is undermining confidence in land-based collateral in B.C. The decision is adding costs we cannot afford and disrupting parts of B.C.'s economy at a time when stability is badly needed.\n\n The problem is not that Canadians are unwilling to support reconciliation. In British Columbia, we desperately want to live in harmony, but anxiety creates strain, and government failure to negotiate treaties that would have provided legal clarity before these issues reached a crisis point is dividing our communities. For years, these Liberals talked reconciliation but dragged their feet on negotiation. They failed to negotiate a treaty with Cowichan Tribes, so they got sued and lost.\n\n Now ordinary Canadians are paying the price. Families trying to buy homes, indigenous communities seeking certainty, municipalities planning infrastructure, and businesses deciding whether to invest in British Columbia face years of legal limbo. Despite their insistence that they are going to appeal the decision and make everything fine again, the Liberals have painted themselves into a legal corner. The Prime Minister admits that property rights are \"fundamental.\" The parliamentary secretary admits that there are \"potentially significant implications, including for private property rights\" that \"could extend across the country.\"\n\nThe Prime Minister and the Liberals say repeatedly that they will make all \"viable\" legal arguments, but here is the problem: Appeals are not do-overs, and the \"raise it or lose it\" principle is core to how our legal system works. People are not allowed to save some of their arguments for appeal, just in case they do not get what they want at trial. If they could, litigation would cost even more and it would never end. My dad used to refer to this as the \"you snooze, you lose\" principle.\n\nParagraph 2096 of the decision states, \"Canada initially pled extinguishment but abandoned its reliance on this defence in its amended response to civil claim filed November 22, 2018.\" In plain English, what that means is that the Liberal government told its lawyers not to argue that fee simple title is superior to all other forms of title, and those lawyers amended the court documents in 2018 to take the argument out. A lot of Canadians are wondering how that could have been allowed to happen. We investigated and found the government's legal directive, still online, that strongly encourages admissions of liability and discourages defences like extinguishment that would support fee simple title. It turns out that the one argument the government needed in a 513-day trial is the one it did not make. That means it is not viable on appeal. \n\nConservatives have repeatedly asked how the Prime Minister is going to win an appeal with an argument he is not entitled to make. In response, we have been accused of \"misinformation\", \"fear and misinformation\", \"fearmongering...spreading misinformation and...causing disruption in the economy of British Columbia\", and worse. \n\nWe are not fearmongering, nor are we spreading misinformation. I have just laid out the problem in plain English. It is not unreasonable to want to understand how the government is going to deal with this very serious issue that is causing unsettling divisions among Canadians. Those divisions are not being caused by Conservatives. They are being caused by a Liberal government that does not make all available arguments, hides its mistakes and attacks anyone who asks how it is going to fix it. \n\nBritish Columbians bought their homes in good faith. They are trying not to lose them in the face of the rising cost of everything and an economic crisis already made worse by government. What is perhaps most frustrating for the homeowners I talk to is that there will be no clarity on these issues any time soon. We are staring down months, if not years, of litigation while the courts sort this out. \n\nThe order itself has not been fully finalized. A 513-day judicial record still has to be assembled. Preliminary motions have to be heard before the appeal can start, including numerous intervenor applications and a motion to reopen the case by landowners who claim they should have been involved from the beginning. The justice minister has indicated that Canada is supporting that application, which will make the case drag on even longer if granted. I cannot help but wonder if the government is doing so in part because reopening the trial might get it that actual do-over. \n\nThis is one of those cases where the process has process, but we got here through a complete failure of political leadership. The government knew this decision was coming. It knew there were more court cases coming. It yielded the field eight years ago, but avoided doing the hard work in that time of creating a clear legislative and policy framework around reconciliation, aboriginal title, private property rights and legal certainty. Instead, it left it all to the courts to be sorted out piecemeal through massive and voluminous constitutional litigation while the government stacks the court with activist judges.\n\nLong trials may work for lawyers billing by the hour, but they do not work for families trying to buy a home, businesses trying to invest or first nations trying to build a stable future. Reconciliation requires clarity, fairness and predictability for everyone. We need a government that is willing to find real solutions instead of continually asking the courts to do its job for it.\n\nI hope all members of this House will support our opposition day motion, in particular our call for a special multi-party committee to study all legal, constitutional and political steps that can be taken to protect private property rights in Canada. Indigenous and non-indigenous Canadians alike need us to work together to come up with solutions to government incompetence on this file. The ship needs to change course, because it is currently headed for the rocks.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949806","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the most important changes in life are often invisible at first. Seeds sprout underground before the first shoots appear. A ship that changes course by one degree makes no waves, but ends up somewhere entirely different. A coastline can look unchanged for years, while the tide quietly reshapes it, grain by grain.\n\nOn August 7, 2025, when the B.C. Supreme Court released the Cowichan Tr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e855eec2c5574ab2b03ffdcdcfe711cf1f58a2899cafeda405bed941989d291d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a6c78c77415d59c7f047fa0cffe0474f54e6c78cffaa4eb811d1e4673d6e3c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8045263eb3df70a21adf7787","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949807,"date":"2026-05-07T18:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I spoke about the negativity that comes across the aisle when we ask questions and raise issues.\n\nStephen Harper delivered the residential school apology in the House. A Conservative government, led by former prime minister Stephen Harper, created the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, which resolved hundreds of specific claims, extended human rights protections on reserve and introduced reforms aimed at improving accountability and transparency for indigenous communities. Were there disagreements? Absolutely, there were. Were there tensions? Of course there were. Reconciliation is not advanced by pretending that nothing meaningful happened before 2015. Some of the most significant steps toward acknowledging historical wrongs and building new relationships with indigenous people happened under Conservative governments.\n\nThe Liberals have asked what we want to do about it, and we have proposed that parties get together, form a special committee and work on this together. We owe it to Canadians, indigenous and non-indigenous alike, to make progress on this file.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949807","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I spoke about the negativity that comes across the aisle when we ask questions and raise issues.\n\nStephen Harper delivered the residential school apology in the House. A Conservative government, led by former prime minister Stephen Harper, created the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, which resolved hundreds of specific claims, extended human rights protections on reserve and intro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0a2115beefc6a3abae503b12ae3c099245282fb6213b5b23e53d67518349c2ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["30626cf54612e790c2e11ed3bb9beecc0600876d72a21f080e743c5eaf42abaa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8adbfacd8264f9db0e665174","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949808,"date":"2026-05-07T18:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have to admit that I am confused by the hon. member's question. Of course we respect the Constitution. As for everything that I have stated in this speech, there is nothing in it that suggests that I want to do anything other than uphold it. \n\nOur proposal is to create a special committee. It is to work together. It is to find a way through this. The reason that I support that proposal is that I believe in reconciliation. I believe in creating certainty. It is important for all Canadians. I hope that the member will work with us to move this forward in a way that is good for everyone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949808","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have to admit that I am confused by the hon. member's question. Of course we respect the Constitution. As for everything that I have stated in this speech, there is nothing in it that suggests that I want to do anything other than uphold it. \n\nOur proposal is to create a special committee. It is to work together. It is to find a way through this. The reason that I support that propo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","label":"Explorations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0fc25e0d945fc18714d884c9298d0a69d259e1e46f9160fb472311cc60ef9fbe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b26b276027cf8549c1867170","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949809,"date":"2026-05-07T18:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I tried to stick to some pretty boring, cold, hard legal facts in my speech. Unfortunately, this is a very complicated case. It has been made more complicated by the litigation decisions that the government made in this particular case. It has been made more complicated by litigation directives that, quite frankly, do not make sense to many Canadians. \n\nIf we are going to move forward on this, we really need to be thoughtful. We need to be collaborative. We need to walk alongside Canadians of all kinds in negotiating real solutions to these problems.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949809","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I tried to stick to some pretty boring, cold, hard legal facts in my speech. Unfortunately, this is a very complicated case. It has been made more complicated by the litigation decisions that the government made in this particular case. It has been made more complicated by litigation directives that, quite frankly, do not make sense to many Canadians. \n\nIf we are going to move forward","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8e54c36691ec91d608fccd9257654a8658b535204fe983f801f92456496c1e46"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba5bfcd89c7a68b9d3c1b71bd1448bce79d96890fde67986d100ebc0f1e2d43e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95f3dd3f7918a9152cf8cd73","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949810,"date":"2026-05-07T21:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I cannot help but reflect that if the circumstances were different, this would have been a very interesting discussion. I thank all of my colleagues for their commentary on case law and for all of the legal arguments that have been made.\n\nI am just wondering if, in the short time that we have left, my colleague might reflect a little on the fact that it is such a tragedy that the government did not actually negotiate a treaty that would have allowed us to avoid all this uncertainty.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949810","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I cannot help but reflect that if the circumstances were different, this would have been a very interesting discussion. I thank all of my colleagues for their commentary on case law and for all of the legal arguments that have been made.\n\nI am just wondering if, in the short time that we have left, my colleague might reflect a little on the fact that it is such a tragedy that the gove","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a68265fc072678796feb02c696210dc43fe38d2891be69ccee5c2bb2c20ed43b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ef9e9f260463020856921c51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949803,"date":"2026-05-08T16:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals failed to negotiate with Cowichan Tribes, so they got sued and lost. They told their lawyers not to argue fee simple property rights, so the one argument they need is not viable on appeal.\n\n British Columbians bought their homes, paid their mortgages and followed the law. They want answers, so we spent the week asking. Instead of answers, we got insults, intimidation and illusions. The legal directive stopping federal lawyers from defending property rights is still on Canada.ca, so Liberal claims about defending those rights are just smoke and mirrors. \n\nDo the Liberals have a plan, or are they going to let judges make property rights vanish before Canadians' eyes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949803","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals failed to negotiate with Cowichan Tribes, so they got sued and lost. They told their lawyers not to argue fee simple property rights, so the one argument they need is not viable on appeal.\n\n British Columbians bought their homes, paid their mortgages and followed the law. They want answers, so we spent the week asking. Instead of answers, we got insults, intimidation and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e76ba819caa01064913e3578a53505c036ad225e86a7e916d1f26a279051d0f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3dd82e38a1527e09a4cdff614d70ed6cfad1b392b62474b6b112aedc07eb367b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e52d287eebfb9fd87fa2ea8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949804,"date":"2026-05-08T18:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for bringing this forward. I am wondering if, in his discussions with families and organizations that have been advocating for this, the member has seen first-hand the way that Health Canada's bureaucracy has created so much paperwork and administrative burden that it prevents people from getting access to health care. How would this bill help?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949804","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for bringing this forward. I am wondering if, in his discussions with families and organizations that have been advocating for this, the member has seen first-hand the way that Health Canada's bureaucracy has created so much paperwork and administrative burden that it prevents people from getting access to health care. How would this bill help?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c2bc5150a679f1ca0e00812326c2a8a8f5770e3a0368b137aefe8faa9da122ce"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc9af98879839f8ab8f24c4f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949805,"date":"2026-05-08T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am grateful for the chance to speak today to Bill C-265, an act to amend the Food and Drugs Act regarding a list of therapeutic products pre-approved for special access. The bill attempts to address a very real and human problem. I laud the hon. member for Thunder Bay—Rainy River for bringing it forward so we can have the collective opportunity to think about and act on this important issue.\n\n As we have heard this afternoon, across Canada there are patients facing serious illnesses, rare diseases, aggressive cancers and rapidly deteriorating conditions whose approved treatment options either have failed or simply do not exist. In those moments, no one cares about ideology or partisanship. What they need is hope. They want time. They are looking for options, for anything that might help when all other doors appear to be closed. That is the purported purpose of the existing Health Canada special access program. Under the program, health care professionals can request access to therapies that are not yet approved in Canada for patients with serious or life-threatening conditions. In many cases, the program has in fact provided compassionate access to potentially life-saving treatments.\n\n Bill C-265 seeks to streamline parts of that process by creating a publicly maintained list of therapeutic products that could qualify for faster access under certain circumstances. There is merit in studying this proposal carefully at committee, and I am pleased to rise today to support doing exactly that, because government systems should work efficiently to respond to real human needs. When bureaucracy creates unnecessary delays for critically ill patients, we have a responsibility in this place to ask whether those processes can be improved while maintaining proper safeguards.\n\n I believe we should also recognize the difficult realities faced by patients living with rare diseases. Members of my immediate family live with a rare disease called hereditary neuropathy with liability to pressure palsies, or HNPP. We are lucky that it was diagnosed within a reasonable time and has so far had minimal impact on our lives. However, many rare disease patients spend years searching for diagnoses, specialists and treatment options. \n\nFamilies become experts themselves because they have no other choice. They monitor clinical trials around the world. They follow developments in the United States and elsewhere. They advocate tirelessly for access to therapies that may still be working their way through Canada's approval process even though they are available elsewhere. For patients in these situations, time matters. It is frustrating, terrifying and a host of other emotions to watch someone we love suffer and in some cases die while bureaucratic rules put up roadblock after obstacle, barrier, impediment and hurdle. \n\nThis issue is particularly relevant for many of our communities on Vancouver Island and across rural Canada. Patients without family doctors already face long travel times for specialized care. Families in rural areas often experience delays in accessing diagnostics, specialists and advanced treatments. Whether we or someone we love is fighting a fast-moving illness, every additional layer of delay can feel overwhelming. Bill C-265 seeks to address that concern by allowing certain therapies to be placed on a pre-approved list for faster consideration under the program. \n\nThe idea deserves thoughtful examination, and many people in the House, including the proposer of the bill, have talked about the issues that need to be studied at committee, so I am not going to go through them here. What I am going to do is thank my colleague across the way for taking the time to really think about what we can do in this place to help real families and real people across the country to live full, better lives not spent chasing therapies they may or may not be able to access in the long run.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949805","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am grateful for the chance to speak today to Bill C-265, an act to amend the Food and Drugs Act regarding a list of therapeutic products pre-approved for special access. The bill attempts to address a very real and human problem. I laud the hon. member for Thunder Bay—Rainy River for bringing it forward so we can have the collective opportunity to think about and act on this importa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","label":"Diseases"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","label":"Diseases","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["efa95eb61775e52fcc1483d98f59759f665482843202825f2b519a934d9018c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f78912ada2a518b19bcf3e5a5bcd10fc41a44e563d59d30c6a9633aaa3df69e1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6aba60dad8d703fc6901823c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118796,"date":"2026-05-28T17:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Madam Chair, thank you so much. Thanks to each of you for being here, particularly given that it's World Hunger Day, and for your thoughtful testimonies. I want to start with Mr. Hetherington. You mentioned that it took you 20 years to get to one million visits, and then over the past three or four years you've seen an increase of 300% or 400% to over four million visits. You also mentioned a huge increase in people with full-time employment. I'm wondering if you're also seeing a shift between what I would think of as occasional to regular use.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118796","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Chair, thank you so much. Thanks to each of you for being here, particularly given that it's World Hunger Day, and for your thoughtful testimonies. I want to start with Mr. Hetherington. You mentioned that it took you 20 years to get to one million visits, and then over the past three or four years you've seen an increase of 300% or 400% to over four million visits. You also mentioned a huge","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-536c566d938720f78c378f75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118797,"date":"2026-05-28T17:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"We're seeing the same thing in B.C. It's really not an Ontario problem; it's a problem across the country. Because I have a limited amount of time, I'll move to Ms. Ramze Rezaee. You represent 400 food security organizations across the country. Are you seeing or are you hearing from your partners that people are accessing these programs who have never been seen before?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118797","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We're seeing the same thing in B.C. It's really not an Ontario problem; it's a problem across the country. Because I have a limited amount of time, I'll move to Ms. Ramze Rezaee. You represent 400 food security organizations across the country. Are you seeing or are you hearing from your partners that people are accessing these programs who have never been seen before?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81b8d8780986db5d6367c4bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118798,"date":"2026-05-28T17:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"This is actually a question that I'd like each of you to answer with a yes or a no. We hear consistently that this is a problem that is growing, that it is accelerating. Do you think we've hit bottom, or do you think the trend is going to continue to get worse? I'd just like a yes or a no from each of you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118798","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This is actually a question that I'd like each of you to answer with a yes or a no. We hear consistently that this is a problem that is growing, that it is accelerating. Do you think we've hit bottom, or do you think the trend is going to continue to get worse? I'd just like a yes or a no from each of you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-335faa03f2f303941b7635ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118799,"date":"2026-05-28T17:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Mr. Hetherington.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118799","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Hetherington.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e65f7392a13ce0036c1c7c34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118800,"date":"2026-05-28T17:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Ms. Secord.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118800","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Ms. Secord.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f5b7ea3e87f3b3ae5e41cb1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118801,"date":"2026-05-28T17:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Ms. Barry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118801","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Ms. Barry.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-810be239d0a5e12184168765","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118802,"date":"2026-05-28T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Ms. Secord, when you have a dietary disability or a disability that is affected by diet, how much worse is it, and how much harder is it in terms of variety, access and location?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118802","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Ms. Secord, when you have a dietary disability or a disability that is affected by diet, how much worse is it, and how much harder is it in terms of variety, access and location?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","label":"Nutrition","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09118fa2eaebd61618fa1233ae00c2801109772fb76776ebc2b7380d464cd806"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ddbbdf54308d0cfe5929f20","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118803,"date":"2026-05-28T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"They're truly half a loaf each.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118803","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"They're truly half a loaf each.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39bdc2e733c490694b5bacab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118932,"date":"2026-05-28T22:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My questions will be for Ms. Giles as well. Most Canadians are familiar, at this point, with foreign interference in our elections. I sit on the human rights subcommittee of the foreign affairs committee. We've been studying transnational repression, whereby, as you know, foreign governments target people—often from their own diaspora communities, but sometimes Canadians who support those diaspora communities and others—both online and in other places. You were talking about the additional threats we are facing in terms of volume, nature and velocity, and you also talked a lot about the technical implications. I want to apply that to our discussions on Bill C-22 . Issues around end-to-end encryption have come to this committee in relation to the bill, and I'd like to get your thoughts on this. Is it fair to say that Canadians who are the subjects of transnational repression in Canada are very dependent on communication mechanisms that have strong end-to-end encryption?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118932","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My questions will be for Ms. Giles as well. Most Canadians are familiar, at this point, with foreign interference in our elections. I sit on the human rights subcommittee of the foreign affairs committee. We've been studying transnational repression, whereby, as you know, foreign governments target people—often from their own diaspora communities, but sometimes Canadians who ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d05a15e60f03959b9defd6c936f35915c3960c347dde65f70e13a0a67ce83c50"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3deb7fa3a333d5c9251a6534","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118933,"date":"2026-05-28T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Is it fair to say that those who are being targeted by foreign regimes would face, in some cases, serious personal danger if some of the secure mechanisms that they depend on are compromised?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118933","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is it fair to say that those who are being targeted by foreign regimes would face, in some cases, serious personal danger if some of the secure mechanisms that they depend on are compromised?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe6040aa4e91c163e8d30b7eb79516bb1456f85c43030c18dcf441d15fa5ee9d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-281d208456f4882f1251c173","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118934,"date":"2026-05-28T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"As we know, these are not hypothetical threats. There have literally been murders in the last year that have been linked to this kind of foreign interference and transnational repression. What I'm wondering is whether the government has conducted any threat assessments specifically examining how lawful access capability requirements could affect communities vulnerable to transnational repression and those who CSIS is helping in this regard?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118934","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As we know, these are not hypothetical threats. There have literally been murders in the last year that have been linked to this kind of foreign interference and transnational repression. What I'm wondering is whether the government has conducted any threat assessments specifically examining how lawful access capability requirements could affect communities vulnerable to transnational repression a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42c806a427faf4ca2fe0f7a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118935,"date":"2026-05-28T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Sometimes when we're trying to help people, we inadvertently have unintended consequences of that. I'm asking about the other implications of it and whether or not the assessments included the possibility that weakened encryption standards or the requirement to have back doors could be exploited by foreign actors looking to do Canadians harm.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118935","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Sometimes when we're trying to help people, we inadvertently have unintended consequences of that. I'm asking about the other implications of it and whether or not the assessments included the possibility that weakened encryption standards or the requirement to have back doors could be exploited by foreign actors looking to do Canadians harm.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9f4608d631debc94f1a8b65394708178c2a89dae5deb78ac748a404ea3706f5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8fb260082e5a664885d5f8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118936,"date":"2026-05-28T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"With all due respect, judicial review is too late when somebody's come up to your doorstep and put a bullet through your front door. The issue that I'm asking about is this. We've had a number of experts at this committee who have made it clear that despite the intentions of this bill, there is the reality that encryption could be weakened. The minister himself has indicated that he is willing to accept amendments on this to get it right. I'm asking you this from a safety and security perspective: Is it important that we get it right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118936","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"With all due respect, judicial review is too late when somebody's come up to your doorstep and put a bullet through your front door. The issue that I'm asking about is this. We've had a number of experts at this committee who have made it clear that despite the intentions of this bill, there is the reality that encryption could be weakened. The minister himself has indicated that he is willing to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31e6fd5fa86d2eb535dea627","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118937,"date":"2026-05-28T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"If we get this wrong.... The question I'm asking you is not about whether or not you believe we've struck the right balance. The question is about if we get this wrong. In the context of the velocity, the volume and the nature, and the changing technology that's out there, is it important to get this right to make sure that people's lives are not at risk?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118937","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If we get this wrong.... The question I'm asking you is not about whether or not you believe we've struck the right balance. The question is about if we get this wrong. In the context of the velocity, the volume and the nature, and the changing technology that's out there, is it important to get this right to make sure that people's lives are not at risk?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa24241a6f86f79393ca2c07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035880,"date":"2026-05-29T16:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as graduation ceremonies take take place in Nanaimo—Ladysmith and across Canada, new grads are facing one of the toughest job markets in years. Unemployment in the Nanaimo census metropolitan area hit 8.7% in April, which is a whopping increase of 2.3% over this time last year. Youth unemployment is up half a percentage point to 14.3% nationwide. Statistics Canada revealed this morning that Canada is the only G7 country in a recession. \n\nOur young people have the talent, determination and ambition it takes to succeed. They have done everything we have asked: studied hard, developed their skills and overcame obstacles. What they need are opportunities to gain experience, build careers and make enough money to put down roots in the communities we call home.\n\nTo the graduating class of 2026, I congratulate them on their achievements. Their future matters and their contributions matter. Canada needs their talent more than ever. We keep fighting for the opportunities they deserve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035880","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as graduation ceremonies take take place in Nanaimo—Ladysmith and across Canada, new grads are facing one of the toughest job markets in years. Unemployment in the Nanaimo census metropolitan area hit 8.7% in April, which is a whopping increase of 2.3% over this time last year. Youth unemployment is up half a percentage point to 14.3% nationwide. Statistics Canada revealed this mornin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["629d34fe4807e1a99290b7cdf9427551e07106a79c127ef01478bd63aa92e770"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d42f7ba249aae7ed6c2dac4045f0dd5ef2eeb309ebbb65c851e9fd0f12e55aff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6f53087492ac48e3ddeedc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035881,"date":"2026-05-29T16:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on World Hunger Day, food security organizations came to the finance committee and told us that more people from more demographics are using food banks more often in Canada. Forty-three per cent of Canadians now say that the cost of groceries severely affects their ability to access food, and food inflation in Canada remains the highest in the G7. \n\nThe Prime Minister promised to lead, and he did: straight to the only recession in the G7. There are more costs, more taxes and more debt on the national credit card. \n\nWhen is the Prime Minister going to show us that he is not just another Liberal and get serious about reducing the cost of food?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035881","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on World Hunger Day, food security organizations came to the finance committee and told us that more people from more demographics are using food banks more often in Canada. Forty-three per cent of Canadians now say that the cost of groceries severely affects their ability to access food, and food inflation in Canada remains the highest in the G7. \n\nThe Prime Minister promised to lead","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f357bd06e9a07ebcc4d47c821b16451a87fc2b074e58fbbfaf1333c60ce825ae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["391b6bc2cdb2e81e85b2ecf2fde88cc3e30074aee6d9de04357d05d93aeda25f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08748fcd7e3a29f151d2597a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035882,"date":"2026-05-29T16:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, two quarters of negative growth mean we are the only G7 economy in a recession. Excuses and deflection will not cut it. StatsCan has the receipts. \n\nLiberals chose to add more debt, more spending and more people. By doing that, they created more pressure on housing, health care and food costs than the system can bear. Every dollar the government adds to the national credit card eventually shows up in the grocery aisle. \n\nWhen the only thing growing faster than grocery prices is the lineups at the food banks, it is no wonder these Liberals have stopped talking about the middle class and those seeking to join it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035882","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, two quarters of negative growth mean we are the only G7 economy in a recession. Excuses and deflection will not cut it. StatsCan has the receipts. \n\nLiberals chose to add more debt, more spending and more people. By doing that, they created more pressure on housing, health care and food costs than the system can bear. Every dollar the government adds to the national credit card eventu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["145e10a09a7319adf50d644daac57e78e078be2e52be23a2ae712a023c61562c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c009f9e8cbccb36009156dbe98fc1001e5596505527aa075b864c3addd6f571"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c700bddc1c5ad830a673c1b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035883,"date":"2026-05-29T18:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the hon. member for Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan.\n\nThe Prime Minister has spent much of the last year arguing that Canada faces a more dangerous, more competitive and less forgiving world. He is absolutely right. Trade relationships are more fragile, supply chains have become matters of national security, and energy, minerals, data, defence production and industrial capacity are no longer simply economic assets but have become instruments of sovereignty. Few serious observers would deny that Canada faces a more demanding world than the one we recognized a decade ago.\n\nThe question before Parliament, however, is whether Bill C-31 reflects the seriousness of that diagnosis. A serious country must be able to build. It must be able to defend itself, educate and train its people, approve projects, mobilize capital, protect consumers and make decisions that endure beyond a single news cycle. The Prime Minister has framed this moment as one that requires ambition, discipline and state capacity. I agree with that premise. What I question is whether Bill C-31 would advance it.\n\n If the challenge is state capacity, the answer cannot simply be layers of state complexity. If the goal is economic sovereignty, the answer cannot be legislation that gestures in many directions while avoiding difficult choices. Bill C-31 is more than 330 pages long. It would amend tax law, financial law, labour law, transportation law and defence procurement law. It would touch housing finance, automatic benefit delivery, crypto asset reporting, the clean hydrogen tax credit, non-compete clauses, air passenger complaints and a defence investment agency, to name just some of the topics.\n\nSome of the measures may be worthwhile. Some deserve support. Others deserve amendment. The problem is that Parliament is being asked to evaluate them all at once. The government will argue that time is short, and it is going to pressure us to pass the bill before the summer recess. A lack of planning on its part should not be and should not necessitate an emergency for all of us.\n\nMajor reforms to defence procurement deserve their own legislation and committee study, as so many of my colleagues have explained today. Lord knows, air passenger rights deserve their own scrutiny. Significant tax reforms need to be thought through. Instead, they are being bundled together in an omnibus bill that makes serious examination more difficult.\n\nWe have already seen how sloppy Liberal drafting has unintended consequences through a number of other bills that have come before the House and that, we have learned, have significantly impinged upon Canadian freedom. Parliamentary scrutiny is one of the institutions that makes good government possible. A government confident in its reforms should welcome rigorous examination rather than continuously dilute it.\n\nThe most revealing aspect of Bill C-31 may be what it does not contain. On April 27, the Prime Minister announced the Canada Strong fund, describing it as Canada's first national sovereign wealth fund. It was presented as a cornerstone of economic sovereignty and nation building. Canadians were told it would help mobilize capital for strategic projects that are so desperately needed and give future generations a stake in national prosperity. A sovereign wealth fund can be a powerful instrument of public policy. It can also become an expensive political investment vehicle if its governance is weak. The difference lies in the design, and the devil, as they say, is in the details.\n\nThere is no statutory framework in Bill C-31 for the Canada Strong fund, no explanation of how it will operate or how Parliament will oversee it. More than a month after its announcement, all we have is a short government backgrounder promising yet another office with yet another CEO and consultations to determine, over the next several months, what the fund will eventually become. That omission matters because it reveals a broader disconnect between the government's rhetoric and announcements and its implementation.\n\nThe same pattern applies to its skills training. The government has repeatedly argued that Canada's future prosperity depends on building the most skilled workforce in the world, and it does.\n\nIt has spoken about the training that workers need to build homes, develop critical minerals, expand advanced manufacturing and strengthen defence production. The diagnosis is correct, yet the legislative response is remarkably thin. Bill C-31 contains measures related to labour mobility and employment. Those may be useful, but they do not amount to a national skills strategy. They do not explain how Canada will train workers at the scale required, accelerate credential recognition, strengthen apprenticeship and completion rates or address the labour shortages already delaying major projects across the country.\n\n The government's language is national. It is big, and it is ambitious. The legislative response is partial. This pattern extends to the economy more broadly. Bill C-31 contains investment incentives, tax changes and reporting requirements. Some may improve the functioning of the tax system, but none constitutes a serious productivity agenda, and productivity is the quiet crisis beneath the politics of affordability. \n\nWe learned this morning that Canada has quietly slipped into a recession, with two consecutive quarters of shrinkage. If Canada produces less per worker than its competitors, wages stagnate. When wages stagnate, affordability deteriorates. Governments can soften the consequences through transfers, credits and subsidies. They can send all the cheques they want, but they cannot permanently compensate for weak productivity, and the spending has consequences at the grocery store and everywhere else in our economy as things continue to get more expensive. That is because prosperity must be created before it can be distributed. \n\nThe same concern arises with the Defence Investment Agency. Canada unquestionably needs procurement reform. Our armed forces require equipment, readiness and capability. In a more dangerous world, faster procurement is not just a bureaucratic preference but a strategic necessity, yet speed is not competence. National security is not an area for weak accountability. The Defence Investment Agency may prove useful. It may not. Parliament has not yet been given sufficient evidence to determine which outcome is more likely. What is clear is that such significant reform deserves its own legislation and its own committee study. It should be examined by the defence committee with witnesses who understand defence procurement, military readiness, industry and national security. It should not be one division in a big budget bill competing for attention with tax rules, air passenger complaints and labour measures.\n\n The central question here is not whether Canada should move faster. The question is whether this structure will make us faster or merely more complicated. A ship that cannot sail does not defend sovereignty. An aircraft that cannot fly does not secure the Arctic. A procurement system that produces announcements faster than equipment does not serve the Canadian Armed Forces. State capacity is not measured by the number of institutions government creates. It is measured by the ability of its institutions to deliver.\n\n The air passenger rights provisions raise a similar concern. The current system is clearly failing Canadians. Complaint backlogs are unacceptable. Delays are excessive. Compensation is often very difficult to obtain. However, consumer protection is not achieved by announcing rights. It is achieved when ordinary people can enforce those rights without needing a lawyer, a media campaign, an MP or two years of patience. That observation applies far beyond air travel. \n\nCapability is not centralization for its own sake. It is not ministerial discretion without accountability. It is not omnibus legislation without scrutiny, and it is not the appearance of motion while standing still.\n\n The Prime Minister often speaks about resilience, sovereignty and national purpose. At a time when Canadians are carrying the burdens of housing scarcity, weak productivity, affordability pressures and global uncertainty, we should insist on something better. We should insist on competence, accountability and results.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035883","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the hon. member for Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan.\n\nThe Prime Minister has spent much of the last year arguing that Canada faces a more dangerous, more competitive and less forgiving world. He is absolutely right. Trade relationships are more fragile, supply chains have become matters of national security, and energy, minerals, data, defence producti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9b6f4bfb84060546a56ac7e5e1469fa823e67d23d01622cae06b917d8e96e3f8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb5190f36ba79793ed2054f49fece0d2f896860bc6881e5bee48fbf1dd2dbea1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-673b3b2fc288972388401c28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035884,"date":"2026-05-29T18:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a central problem with tribunal systems, and I have had experience with them, is they are intended to make life simpler for Canadians. They are intended to be a process that is outside the court. However, as anyone who has dealt with any of these tribunals knows, people inevitably need a lawyer and inevitably need to navigate all kinds of complicated case law. \n\nIf the government is serious about making life simpler for Canadians, it will clear these backlogs and provide redress in a faster, more efficient way, because the longer these cases sit in tribunal systems, the more paper they accumulate and the more complicated they get.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035884","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a central problem with tribunal systems, and I have had experience with them, is they are intended to make life simpler for Canadians. They are intended to be a process that is outside the court. However, as anyone who has dealt with any of these tribunals knows, people inevitably need a lawyer and inevitably need to navigate all kinds of complicated case law. \n\nIf the government is s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d21ac54080d4b6ac8ecaa1a6e583a087756b70cd47a951a34be80349d20fcc2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-faae5c897099034a060ee556","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035885,"date":"2026-05-29T19:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I rise today to speak, I ask for unanimous consent to split my time with the member for Winnipeg North.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035885","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I rise today to speak, I ask for unanimous consent to split my time with the member for Winnipeg North.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49ba01663637093f1a17a133","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035886,"date":"2026-05-29T19:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak in support of Bill C-222, the relieving grieving parents of an administrative burden act, also known as Evan's law. The bill is called Evan's law because it was inspired by the experience of a grieving family whose son Evan died while they were receiving parental benefits. After his death, the family had to deal not only with their loss, but also with the bureaucratic consequences of our EI system, including benefit disruptions, paperwork and administrative requirements during a period of profound grief.\n\nI want to thank the member for Burnaby North—Seymour for putting this bill forward on behalf of every parent who has grieved a baby in my riding and across our great nation. I also want to thank all the witnesses who appeared before the committee and shared their pain.\n\nThe death of a child is every parent's worst nightmare. It is a loss that changes a family forever. In those moments of grief, families should be surrounded by compassion, support and understanding. The last thing they need is paperwork, bureaucratic hurdles, confusion about government benefits or being forced back to work, yet that is exactly what can happen under our current employment insurance system. This bill would address that problem in a practical and compassionate way by allowing parents who have already qualified for parental benefits to continue to receive those benefits for the remainder of the approved period and through other means. It would also provide corresponding protections under the Canada Labour Code for employees in federally regulated workplaces.\n\nI believe this bill reflects values that all members of the House can support, and I am grateful to all parties in the House for coming together to do the right thing. It is heartening, as a member in my first term in this place, to see members who understand that government systems should serve people, not the other way around, and who understand that compassion and common sense are not partisan principles, but are principles that should guide us whenever we legislate. Sometimes the most meaningful changes are ones that affect a relatively small number of people, but make an enormous difference in their lives.\n\nFor the parents impacted by this legislation, the effect will be that government stays out of their lives at a time when the last thing they need is government. Instead of worrying about paperwork, they can worry about each other and focus on grieving. Instead of being wrapped in government bureaucracy, they can stay wrapped in the arms of those who are helping them grieve.\n\nThere is also a broader principle at stake here. One measure of a society is how it treats people during their most vulnerable moments. Government cannot erase grief. No law passed in this chamber can undo the loss of a child. We cannot restore what has been taken away from a family, but we can ensure that our public institutions respond with humanity rather than rigidity. Too often, government programs are designed around standard circumstances. They assume life will unfold according to expectations, yet life does not always follow a predictable path. Families experience tragedies, illnesses, accidents and unexpected hardships. When these moments occur, government systems should have the flexibility and compassion to respond appropriately. Bill C-222 helps move us in that direction.\n\nThe stories behind legislation and the words of those who have spoken in the House today remind us why these changes matter. Behind every policy discussion, there is a real person, a real family and real experiences. I want to thank all of my hon. colleagues for the stories they have shared with us today. I also want to extend comfort to all those who carry burdens that are too heavy to share. Statistics can help us understand the scale of a problem, but they cannot help us understand pain. Words matter. A government that removes unnecessary obstacles and does not kick people when they are suffering from shattering pain matters as well. This bill would recognize that reality. It would acknowledge that stability and certainty have value during a period of crisis.\n\nFor those reasons, I am pleased that we are all supporting Bill C-222, and I want to thank all those involved in this bill for bringing us—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035886","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak in support of Bill C-222, the relieving grieving parents of an administrative burden act, also known as Evan's law. The bill is called Evan's law because it was inspired by the experience of a grieving family whose son Evan died while they were receiving parental benefits. After his death, the family had to deal not only with their loss, but also with the bureauc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1984cad84ddb2de498d673587a5ffacc68d2a72532e2f5da70c59824dbfdd9d2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9004ccf1d8c5bdb5520a7c378bcabb70c08a7b29f3e8e722eb94b62a6e548a70"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d743f108a026f970c979df75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084144,"date":"2026-06-01T17:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, this is a 330-page bill that is divided into 16 divisions, plus the defence investment agency act, as the minister pointed out. It would amend things as diverse as the Bank Act, the Tax Court of Canada Act, the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, the Canada Labour Code, the Canadian Human Rights Act, the Tobacco and Vaping Products Act, and the Pest Control Products Act, a wide variety of acts that also includes the Territorial Lands Act and the Red Tape Reduction Act.\n\nIt is a bill that has had very few hours of debate. In fact, if every one of these things had been brought forward, as I think they should have been, as their own bills, we would have had more time to debate each of those bills in its presentation than we will have to debate the entire act. It really feels as if the government's failure to plan is something it is turning into an emergency for all of us. I do not think it is reasonable. I think that with bills such as Bill C-2 and Bill C-22, the rush and the sloppy drafting have put Canadians' rights at risk.\n\nI would like to know why the member is not going to allow either legislators or the public sufficient time to really think through what would be happening in this very consequential bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084144","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, this is a 330-page bill that is divided into 16 divisions, plus the defence investment agency act, as the minister pointed out. It would amend things as diverse as the Bank Act, the Tax Court of Canada Act, the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, the Canada Labour Code, the Canadian Human Rights Act, the Tobacco and Vaping Products Act, and the Pest Control Products Act, a wide variety o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3514ac97ab845c41065d8d38c90c3186964513bbab6b236d1aaaa7076615ad40"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61744de8428ecf05fd033bbc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084145,"date":"2026-06-01T17:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, when I was first elected, I could not speak one full sentence in French. I spent time learning French so that I could treat my francophone colleagues with respect.\n\nWe have pointed out that the government does not want to debate the bill. Not only does this minister not want to debate this bill, but he also does not want to get into what he calls an identity-based debate about Quebec. For that reason, Quebec's premier called him a disgrace to all Quebeckers.\n\nCan the minister explain why, having alienated Quebec, he now wishes to alienate all Canadians by terminating debate on a 330-page bill after only a few hours?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084145","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, when I was first elected, I could not speak one full sentence in French. I spent time learning French so that I could treat my francophone colleagues with respect.\n\nWe have pointed out that the government does not want to debate the bill. Not only does this minister not want to debate this bill, but he also does not want to get into what he calls an identity-based debate about Quebe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a6cf072e41819064f66e0ddd49299764409857ec4d32d5954fc4e3dd2bd778fd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85b1507ef567e28a2f26be02","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084146,"date":"2026-06-01T18:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member opposite asked about the Red Seal program, which, I would note, was brought in by a Conservative prime minister, John Diefenbaker, who brought the provinces together to recognize credentials across Canada, which is, of course, something that the Liberal government is currently having some trouble with around being able to ship wine across provincial borders. \n\nFrankly, we had proposed expanding the Red Seal program to include a blue seal program so we could get medical personnel and health care workers out of taxis and into positions where they could serve Canadians. I would say that, of course, we support the expansion of the Red Seal program to also include a blue seal program.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084146","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member opposite asked about the Red Seal program, which, I would note, was brought in by a Conservative prime minister, John Diefenbaker, who brought the provinces together to recognize credentials across Canada, which is, of course, something that the Liberal government is currently having some trouble with around being able to ship wine across provincial borders. \n\nFrankly, we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49625","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Seals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49625","label":"Seals","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb1b5dcc4dbf0cfcb09440a206e76d76fa78a34dd23c724b6f2823edd92fce12"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b640dbb5c2ea4aa3c53cf74","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084147,"date":"2026-06-01T18:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, of course, we support the Red Seal program. The issue is that it is one thing buried in a 330‐page bill that we have only had three and a half hours to debate, and which this government has just tried to shut down further debate on.\n\n The challenge is that we have already seen bills come through with sloppy drafting that infringe on the rights of Canadians. Unfortunately, we have to take the bill as a whole. I would also note that while the bill has provisions for a Red Seal program, it is not expanded to a blue seal program that would allow professionals to get into positions where they could practise their professions in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084147","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, of course, we support the Red Seal program. The issue is that it is one thing buried in a 330‐page bill that we have only had three and a half hours to debate, and which this government has just tried to shut down further debate on.\n\n The challenge is that we have already seen bills come through with sloppy drafting that infringe on the rights of Canadians. Unfortunately, we have to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cbce4e8f9b493dc2a45576aee6c6e637acb80a5cefc1c04d4bd77c012637f315"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f2c79d6a745feb99af12f9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084148,"date":"2026-06-01T18:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the big challenge is that we have had three and a half hours to debate 330 pages. Especially at this time when Canadians are struggling, it is obligatory upon us to give them the time that they deserve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084148","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the big challenge is that we have had three and a half hours to debate 330 pages. Especially at this time when Canadians are struggling, it is obligatory upon us to give them the time that they deserve.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c240b7fb83dd4709fe394691","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084149,"date":"2026-06-01T18:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member spoke to one aspect of the 330‐page bill, which has 16 divisions plus the Defence Investment Agency. He was just asked a question about a different part, presumably, of the bill.\n\n Could my colleague speak to the difficulty for members of the House to be able to address the bill in a meaningful way when we have only had three and a half hours of debate, and the government is trying to shut down debate on it, given the complexity and the length of the bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084149","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member spoke to one aspect of the 330‐page bill, which has 16 divisions plus the Defence Investment Agency. He was just asked a question about a different part, presumably, of the bill.\n\n Could my colleague speak to the difficulty for members of the House to be able to address the bill in a meaningful way when we have only had three and a half hours of debate, and the government","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1558e995339e2727f60e68a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084143,"date":"2026-06-03T19:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, were those pages not wonderful in singing O Canada? They have created such a sense of harmony in the House.\n\n There have been discussions among the parties, and if you seek it, I believe you will find unanimous consent for the following motion:\n\nThat, notwithstanding any standing order or usual practices of the House, the deferred recorded division on the opposition motion scheduled for today be taken first.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084143","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, were those pages not wonderful in singing O Canada? They have created such a sense of harmony in the House.\n\n There have been discussions among the parties, and if you seek it, I believe you will find unanimous consent for the following motion:\n\nThat, notwithstanding any standing order or usual practices of the House, the deferred recorded division on the opposition motion scheduled f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","label":"Literature","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb65191abf92ce67207bb5ed51f60daa24cb07cf6a492f9f1bae1f3556df3179"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c27215c4b3315e4d93b08814","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118833,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you very much, Madam Chair. I'm very happy to be here today, and I want to thank you for having me at this meeting. I'm going to ask some questions of Mr. Vigneault, and if anyone else needs to answer them, I'd be grateful if you'd just jump in. The DFO report that we're looking at considers four wind energy areas off Nova Scotia where large wind farms could eventually be built. Am I correct that some of those areas overlap with existing or proposed marine protected areas?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118833","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Madam Chair. I'm very happy to be here today, and I want to thank you for having me at this meeting. I'm going to ask some questions of Mr. Vigneault, and if anyone else needs to answer them, I'd be grateful if you'd just jump in. The DFO report that we're looking at considers four wind energy areas off Nova Scotia where large wind farms could eventually be built. Am I correct","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26e5c54b34485f5ac8356568","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118834,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you for that. Were the people who were doing this report aware of how a wind farm is built?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118834","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for that. Were the people who were doing this report aware of how a wind farm is built?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b98192513579047a6299ac2aa34369a4cbc1709f7709eeeff16b98b4e0a305ab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-58407225ed2978e9e2812a19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118835,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"The question I was asking is, do you have expertise within DFO around how a wind farm is built?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118835","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The question I was asking is, do you have expertise within DFO around how a wind farm is built?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aviation industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","label":"Aviation industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eb3136a29434e077422f83db89c74a46f0f1abc28da061fdced20f59aecd6768"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b09af173a59a6759efb3e0b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118836,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"No, it's not, with all due respect. I'd ask you to stop the clock. We've had a number of discussions about what's in the report and what's not in the report and what the boundaries were. I think it's perfectly relevant to ask what kind of expertise was around the table when people were considering what to include in the report or what not to include in the report.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118836","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, it's not, with all due respect. I'd ask you to stop the clock. We've had a number of discussions about what's in the report and what's not in the report and what the boundaries were. I think it's perfectly relevant to ask what kind of expertise was around the table when people were considering what to include in the report or what not to include in the report.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6a45faa6af69b7c9777a6d2da5eb5fdffa9d97dd5e940995e2acac4b1a1674d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24581552041bc4b52ef0cf27d309c69518dd545609d491f4afceb06191066bda"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e95eb85bb55707647b63f7f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118837,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Are you saying that DFO has no expertise on how a wind farm is actually built?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118837","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Are you saying that DFO has no expertise on how a wind farm is actually built?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef7af0936c7f8d1506ed7d7b2535e6fd1556d7fa3540650928a230f38b728d78"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ffe093aa1422f0688c8d6d78","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118838,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"I wasn't asking about.... With due respect—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118838","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I wasn't asking about.... With due respect—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5b0b94c87a027a3e21e657a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118839,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"I'm sorry, Madam Chair, but I wasn't asking whether or not they assessed the impact. I was asking whether or not there was anyone in the room who knows how a wind farm is actually built.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118839","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm sorry, Madam Chair, but I wasn't asking whether or not they assessed the impact. I was asking whether or not there was anyone in the room who knows how a wind farm is actually built.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01082b04ea9aad81b81e86ba7f17e191a43419bc3b8ae0b9d364671101786dc8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9a7a1283d9adb4e45a93858","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118840,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay. When you were considering what data to include in the report, did you make decisions about what should be included in the report or what shouldn't be included in the report based on the geography that was under consideration?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118840","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. When you were considering what data to include in the report, did you make decisions about what should be included in the report or what shouldn't be included in the report based on the geography that was under consideration?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e296acf7ebf226a9ba8acfef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118841,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Did you focus more on the ocean floor or the water or the surface?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118841","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Did you focus more on the ocean floor or the water or the surface?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036504","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Ocean floor","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036504","label":"Ocean floor","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01fc2eff7368850bcf4b2f7db1c5ae56eb639bd4eaa51f856d0ecc12ff03729c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa1780c699b3df839206cf13","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118842,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"That's what I wanted to get at. You've said over and over again that it's not intended to be the full dataset, so my question is, did you take into account how a wind farm is actually built when you were trying to decide what you should put in that wasn't part of the full dataset?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118842","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's what I wanted to get at. You've said over and over again that it's not intended to be the full dataset, so my question is, did you take into account how a wind farm is actually built when you were trying to decide what you should put in that wasn't part of the full dataset?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e63d863f2c616e57e838b4ae41a7e943184202608dae8e9f1f3cb52c4bbe143d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ed738d10c0f04ac3045675a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118843,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"The question isn't about the impact. If you have 10 datasets and you're telling me that this report was the starting point, there is the possibility that you included in this report datasets one through seven and number nine, but not eight and 10. My question is, did you take into account what might eventually be built there when you were deciding what to include and what not to include? With due respect to the Chair and the members opposite, that is exactly relevant to this report.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118843","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The question isn't about the impact. If you have 10 datasets and you're telling me that this report was the starting point, there is the possibility that you included in this report datasets one through seven and number nine, but not eight and 10. My question is, did you take into account what might eventually be built there when you were deciding what to include and what not to include? With due ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27443edb8d8311075104bcd8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118844,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"If you chose—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118844","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If you chose—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-036b435869f3921aa277e968","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118845,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"In terms of the things you didn't include, why didn't you include them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118845","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In terms of the things you didn't include, why didn't you include them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d0d59a9b0c903ae68236264","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118846,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Are you saying that this report is incomplete?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118846","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Are you saying that this report is incomplete?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b34413419a8877be8e053b7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118847,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Is there—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118847","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is there—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a65dd18dfa8e5aebcfe864e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118848,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"I think it should work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118848","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think it should work.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f07dad4cc801a872b4aa512","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118849,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"I have a point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118849","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c056ef67f08a3d08ef290cbf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118850,"date":"2026-06-03T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"The issue I have is that the motion asked that we receive all documents, not some documents. I was repeatedly shut down for relevance. The document I want to see is the one that asked for this report. The reason I want to see it is that this report is effectively homework that has been delivered. I want to see what the assignment was, because that tells us what this report will be used for. My questions were related to what this report will be used for, and I wasn't allowed to ask them. The documents we are missing are directly relevant and related to the questions I was asking. This meeting wasn't supposed to happen. We were supposed to have two hours after we received all of the documents we asked for, not after we received some of the documents. I want all of the documents. The committee is required to comply with its motions, and right now we see a situation where the motion has not been complied with.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118850","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The issue I have is that the motion asked that we receive all documents, not some documents. I was repeatedly shut down for relevance. The document I want to see is the one that asked for this report. The reason I want to see it is that this report is effectively homework that has been delivered. I want to see what the assignment was, because that tells us what this report will be used for. My que","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8c71ff5e7246678949320cddd3915d3666581d358fda288118356e4d0ce0eaf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c127f715010e1e3897418763","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118851,"date":"2026-06-03T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Paragraph (a) of the motion that led to the production of documents requires \"all documents, including but not limited to memoranda, briefing notes, and internal communications, related to the decision to produce this report, including any requests for its preparation and associated allocation of resources\". We do not have the request for its preparation. There's no agenda here. The only thing I want is all of the documents. I want this committee to comply with the motion. As my colleague said, if someone can show me where we have the \"requests for its preparation and associated allocation of resources\" from the DFO, then I would be happy to withdraw my question. This committee has not complied with its own motion. We get into very dangerous territory in this place when we make motions and then don't comply with them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118851","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Paragraph (a) of the motion that led to the production of documents requires \"all documents, including but not limited to memoranda, briefing notes, and internal communications, related to the decision to produce this report, including any requests for its preparation and associated allocation of resources\". We do not have the request for its preparation. There's no agenda here. The only thing I w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26ef642cce8c4cad0f61b074b31d213c0cdd0b0b1d92c208b65fe89a6243cfde"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-407d36649a6b89493500e3cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118852,"date":"2026-06-03T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Then where are the documents?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118852","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Then where are the documents?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c4beb14221a79b7a70f4a8a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118853,"date":"2026-06-03T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"While we were on break, there was a document that my colleague and I looked up online that was on the regulator's website. It was not included in this package. When I look at the document here—the request for advice that was included—it's very clear that the terms of reference for this say, \"there is need for science advice to inform anticipated project-specific Impact Assessments, as well as science advice to inform more general knowledge gaps regarding potential impacts\". The questions I was asking around what kind of expertise DFO had is relevant to that if that is the assignment. I would like to continue with this meeting. I would like the documents that we didn't get. I would also like, at a minimum, to continue with this meeting and get a chance to ask my questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118853","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"While we were on break, there was a document that my colleague and I looked up online that was on the regulator's website. It was not included in this package. When I look at the document here—the request for advice that was included—it's very clear that the terms of reference for this say, \"there is need for science advice to inform anticipated project-specific Impact Assessments, as well as scie","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ccead15d8e8e90594956ddbfde4581777a4c0899735679f0b0dd6a7f5d39689f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28a7911523010adc6cc549ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118854,"date":"2026-06-03T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Vigneault, was this report prepared in response to \"Science support for offshore wind activity in Nova Scotia\", with request ID 1753?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118854","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Vigneault, was this report prepared in response to \"Science support for offshore wind activity in Nova Scotia\", with request ID 1753?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037647","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wind","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037647","label":"Wind","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4068f8eeff7e5a09aff176e0c5575e6a78a843886738f7dce9d8fb62441626ae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10d098be6d169c2fdda1d39e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118855,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"I understand that. The question I have, though.... The issue requiring science information and/or advice that was outlined in the document specifically references this: The development of an offshore wind industry in Atlantic Canada is likely to impact marine ecosystems and species in new ways that have not been investigated in a Canadian context. Consequently, there is need for science advice to inform anticipated project-specific Impact Assessments, as well as science advice to inform more general knowledge gaps regarding potential impacts of OSW development on aquatic ecosystems.... My question is, did you seek to understand how offshore wind works before you went to gather the data?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118855","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand that. The question I have, though.... The issue requiring science information and/or advice that was outlined in the document specifically references this: The development of an offshore wind industry in Atlantic Canada is likely to impact marine ecosystems and species in new ways that have not been investigated in a Canadian context. Consequently, there is need for science advice to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d68d3c1cebb2db6bf7f72c8df087a926b5aa39d2069805c88fa0558c012ac3a6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-379d07b57868277d8e036e8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118856,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"In deciding what to include in this report and what not to include in this report, did you think at all about the infrastructure that would be required?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118856","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In deciding what to include in this report and what not to include in this report, did you think at all about the infrastructure that would be required?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["faff6e6f2b3d0e7ccb25ae7864b931b6ffed22edfb51aa3da0a6d9096c59d0f8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2e7e4d044cde29944b5f888","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118857,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Given the way the ocean works, when you have a geographic area, are the fish generally unaware of the boundaries of it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118857","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Given the way the ocean works, when you have a geographic area, are the fish generally unaware of the boundaries of it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Oceans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47585","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oceans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47585","label":"Oceans","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["988e129418647f762e516d263a72f16e5840ac60c6e8719a3776950b7728063a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96e50ea7c494aad22a802e0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118858,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"Did you think about the fact that the people doing this assessment might actually need information from outside of the area, given the impact that offshore wind has outside of the immediate location where it's located?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118858","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Did you think about the fact that the people doing this assessment might actually need information from outside of the area, given the impact that offshore wind has outside of the immediate location where it's located?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036526","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Offshore area","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aviation industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036526","label":"Offshore area","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","label":"Aviation industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06d6ab157805d3f47fde6310a88962a0968a769b445d897129ee253fcbe8ada6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43ea39bbb7c4af54c918e1f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118859,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"When it comes to a report like this, is the precautionary principle relevant at all? Do you think about the precautionary principle and the mandate of DFO?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118859","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"When it comes to a report like this, is the precautionary principle relevant at all? Do you think about the precautionary principle and the mandate of DFO?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58ae1a9767e713ba3a6fed49eb56e1f7fa44d513246377cb47aa009771ead3b3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6265763344d67ffc31b67fe3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118860,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"What use is this document to anyone doing impact work?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118860","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What use is this document to anyone doing impact work?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c711dfb8e9eb56b03aa72b375900fbc0ca9dd81aca852754be30e6faee1cb97e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-667c7bf2c5a5a61ef8d50e3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118861,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FOPO","text":"None of that is in this report.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118861","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"None of that is in this report.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a79fa9485b6ff666fd2d316","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118862,"date":"2026-06-04T13:45:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, for welcoming me to this committee. Mr. Jones, my questions are also going to be for you. As I was listening to you speak, I was hearing echoes to some degree of life in my riding. I often tease my colleagues that they have planes, trains and automobiles, but we add seaplanes, ferries and helicopters to get here. Nanaimo, where I live, is actually the largest city on Vancouver Island, at just over 100,000 people, and people are surprised that I often cannot take a cellphone call in my driveway and frequently have to pull over to the side of the road in order to finish conversations with people. I see my colleague Madame Gill nodding. I want to give you an opportunity. If you had an urban federal MP visiting and they spent three days in your area and saw everything you wanted them to see, what do you think would surprise them the most?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118862","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, for welcoming me to this committee. Mr. Jones, my questions are also going to be for you. As I was listening to you speak, I was hearing echoes to some degree of life in my riding. I often tease my colleagues that they have planes, trains and automobiles, but we add seaplanes, ferries and helicopters to get here. Nanaimo, where I live, is actually the largest city o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7c1b731b3a2f70a34da520e9752b5ef2b5b3b16cce8af3d871ad94b5b66da3b0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5697c393e84f8f7e0439d5d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118863,"date":"2026-06-04T13:50:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INAN","text":"That's a great place for me to ask my second question. Where I live, we too are very focused on food sovereignty and food security. There are many federal programs focused on subsidizing costs, but we hear over and over again from people living everywhere in Canada, especially in remote communities, that people would like to be able to provide for themselves. I just want to give you a chance to talk a bit about, based on your experience, what policies would help remote communities like yours become less dependent on subsidies and more economically self-sufficient.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118863","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's a great place for me to ask my second question. Where I live, we too are very focused on food sovereignty and food security. There are many federal programs focused on subsidizing costs, but we hear over and over again from people living everywhere in Canada, especially in remote communities, that people would like to be able to provide for themselves. I just want to give you a chance to ta","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fd1c5125ed0818bd1b3c75aeabe09654eb0f8e0073b44bf25f27ae4952414d5b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-138859617e6693d08b5349e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118864,"date":"2026-06-04T14:55:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. Canada talks a lot about protecting land and developing critical minerals. I want to ask you about how those goals fit together. My colleagues across the table have been asking you about better ways to accomplish our goals to provide for sustainability and affordability in the north. In your experience, do you think it would be beneficial for us to first know what mineral resources are present in the north before governments decide to permanently close large areas to development?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118864","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. Canada talks a lot about protecting land and developing critical minerals. I want to ask you about how those goals fit together. My colleagues across the table have been asking you about better ways to accomplish our goals to provide for sustainability and affordability in the north. In your experience, do you think it would be beneficial for us to first know what min","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a335c50829ca7bedcad91b62f526b84c8a952be218e32190275077f2fdcba74f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c128769e976d71858ed54f7be932b1990a7c89abde67a37efc2c782fdaaf181e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca1012e825b149bac8c609fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118865,"date":"2026-06-04T14:55:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INAN","text":"You talked about elevated expenses in the north. What happens in this environment where everyone knows that 30 by 30 is coming? What happens when companies aren't sure whether land will be available for development in the future? You've talked about a steady decline in exploration over the last few years. How does this—\"threat\" is not the right word—promise of 30 by 30 and the closure of areas impact exploration in the north?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118865","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You talked about elevated expenses in the north. What happens in this environment where everyone knows that 30 by 30 is coming? What happens when companies aren't sure whether land will be available for development in the future? You've talked about a steady decline in exploration over the last few years. How does this—\"threat\" is not the right word—promise of 30 by 30 and the closure of areas imp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","label":"Explorations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","label":"Explorations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["299eca47078c130d604e9ffdc265d540ef01172c3ed67cca99749d9837102f76"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f70c53e6ff7a53c865e44063b17b9ea940690872cd6265aab810f6e15f60c7a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0ec2a2e37a5757505062321","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118866,"date":"2026-06-04T15:00:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INAN","text":"You also talked about the important role played by the Dene, Métis and Inuit in the Northwest Territories in terms of economic development and resource development. There is huge potential for those communities to benefit from mining jobs, contracts and business opportunities. Can you share with the committee your thoughts on how we can make sure that conservation decisions don't accidentally close the door on future opportunities for those communities in the Northwest Territories?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118866","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You also talked about the important role played by the Dene, Métis and Inuit in the Northwest Territories in terms of economic development and resource development. There is huge potential for those communities to benefit from mining jobs, contracts and business opportunities. Can you share with the committee your thoughts on how we can make sure that conservation decisions don't accidentally clos","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df65b8161a9138b681b78756","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118751,"date":"2026-06-04T16:40:00+00:00","title":"AGRI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"AGRI","text":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. Mr. Livingstone, thank you so much for making time to be here. I'm from Vancouver Island, where we have a lot of small farms like yours. I know how busy it is, especially around this time of year, when the chickens are brooding and the calves are calving and everything is starting to sprout, so thank you for making that time. Like you, our local farmers also struggle with labour and land costs, processing, transport and bureaucracy, but I want to ask you about a very specific kind of bureaucracy. I have no idea whether you know this or not, but food is one of those areas that constitutionally is shared between the federal government and the provinces. This means that you often have all levels of government messing in your space, but when it comes time to remove a regulation or when there is something that's existing, something that's a challenge, they often turn around and say, \"It's not me.\" We're dealing with this, particularly near my riding right now. We have things like ALRs and regional districts and municipalities and provincial zoning and all kinds of changes that are aimed at building homes. It has created a bit of chaos in the agricultural space. I'm wondering if you might like to speak to that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/AGRI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/AGRI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118751","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. Mr. Livingstone, thank you so much for making time to be here. I'm from Vancouver Island, where we have a lot of small farms like yours. I know how busy it is, especially around this time of year, when the chickens are brooding and the calves are calving and everything is starting to sprout, so thank you for making that time. Like you, our local farmers also struggle ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c51dc9b06c34213c0b5ea2fa43b53bfc6e10b29ed149ca2ac66ffbb7e144fae8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2922a58a462dd4454c1f51c7caed88c84a0d9ea561d34de4cfd88692872621e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f72ba69ddf2cc20e72039584","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118752,"date":"2026-06-04T16:40:00+00:00","title":"AGRI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"AGRI","text":"You're dead centre on the target. One thing I'd like to invite you to do is to make some supplementary submissions on that to the committee, because no one should need a Ph.D. and the British North America Act to get anything done in this country, and farmers are among the people who really do need that. I want to ask another question before I turn the rest of my time over to my colleague. There is also a tension in the country between food that has to travel long distances and food that's produced locally. Do you think we do enough to measure how much food is being produced close enough to where Canadians actually live?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/AGRI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/AGRI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118752","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You're dead centre on the target. One thing I'd like to invite you to do is to make some supplementary submissions on that to the committee, because no one should need a Ph.D. and the British North America Act to get anything done in this country, and farmers are among the people who really do need that. I want to ask another question before I turn the rest of my time over to my colleague. There i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","label":"Nutrition","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["81f4fa514de91b6f637ec5d2f300d54740a64b95748204828c6a2336e35ef7c6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08d5d38cd20be86425fb0745","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118753,"date":"2026-06-04T16:40:00+00:00","title":"AGRI","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"AGRI","text":"I'm sorry to cut you off. I want to give my colleague a chance to ask a question as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/AGRI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/AGRI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118753","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm sorry to cut you off. I want to give my colleague a chance to ask a question as well.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-288bc8b329d12cd60d2bdb55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084142,"date":"2026-06-04T19:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country in any kind of recession.\n\nMaria from my community worked her whole life but lost her home because she and her husband could not make ends meet. She needs help because CRA made a mistake on her file, but she needed to know we could help her before making the drive to my office, because the cost of fuel is so high that she cannot afford to waste the trip. I hear from more and more Marias every week.\n\nWill the Prime Minister please tell Maria whether her hardship is because Canada is in a recession, or is it just a technicality he will continue to ignore?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084142","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country in any kind of recession.\n\nMaria from my community worked her whole life but lost her home because she and her husband could not make ends meet. She needs help because CRA made a mistake on her file, but she needed to know we could help her before making the drive to my office, because the cost of fuel is so high that sh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["84682547264f425cb0719da902ad87522b36e0b91d81f69836eee660d6382ad0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5733c0a2543d91e480c22fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118916,"date":"2026-06-04T21:55:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you to all the witnesses for their testimony today. Ms. Chouinard, Nanaimo is not on the list of regions with a strong francophone presence, but the francophone community is growing in my riding of Nanaimo—Ladysmith. Nanaimo is a welcoming francophone community designated by Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada. The city offers tailored federal support to francophone newcomers to help them settle in, find employment and integrate socially and culturally into the region. We want francophone newcomers to feel welcome and supported. That's one of the reasons why I'm learning French. However, Nanaimo remains predominantly anglophone, and many federally regulated businesses already face challenges with staffing and compliance. How can these draft regulations help growing francophone communities like Nanaimo without creating rules that are too burdensome for businesses serving a predominantly anglophone community?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118916","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you to all the witnesses for their testimony today. Ms. Chouinard, Nanaimo is not on the list of regions with a strong francophone presence, but the francophone community is growing in my riding of Nanaimo—Ladysmith. Nanaimo is a welcoming francophone community designated by Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada. The city offers tailored federal support to francophone newcomers to hel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33d544d68268a51f1f32c2c406e65979d73b8d8d10e8905e8461037bd75cdeaf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b66cece389c8bc94fca69d8f37d94c2a33ccd91788dc5e8e40940c05fb63fb0d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64c064fbbb3a00bbb5f1d443","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118917,"date":"2026-06-04T21:55:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you. I am yielding the rest of my time to my colleague from Sudbury East—Manitoulin—Nickel Belt.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118917","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I am yielding the rest of my time to my colleague from Sudbury East—Manitoulin—Nickel Belt.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92298","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Inuit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inuit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:735732","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armouries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:735732","label":"Armouries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92298","label":"Inuit","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d383cffdf7f1167f02b99dcd3ad2f1195524db6aa90c0745129049e7d5b0a962"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d81b627b984ec58640e05863","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084137,"date":"2026-06-05T16:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, in Nanaimo—Ladysmith, the addictions crisis is not an abstract policy debate. It is on our streets, in our parks, in our shelters and in the lives of families who are praying their loved one gets one more chance.\n\n Too many people are trying to get clean while living next door to the very thing they are fighting to escape. That is not compassion. That is setting people up to fail. Nanaimo needs every kind of housing, including sober housing. We need safe, stable places for people who have chosen recovery, people who want to rebuild their lives without being surrounded by drugs.\n\n This Monday, June 8, Nanaimo city council is convening a special governance and priorities committee meeting to discuss the urgent need for sober housing in our community. I am pleading with the government to pay attention and to allocate a share of federal housing funds for sober housing in Nanaimo because recovery needs more than hope. It needs a home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084137","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, in Nanaimo—Ladysmith, the addictions crisis is not an abstract policy debate. It is on our streets, in our parks, in our shelters and in the lives of families who are praying their loved one gets one more chance.\n\n Too many people are trying to get clean while living next door to the very thing they are fighting to escape. That is not compassion. That is setting people up to fail. N","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["603f3d5f598768e47d0b8f7bc1128d6db2a295f6035fa67f91253beca7376786"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7ba654bc79f431d4af974f3cd719ae6c721465736baf97f7ec98f0b3fb798482"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a99f437e211a8fa349b07df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084138,"date":"2026-06-05T17:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Bloc Québécois members are great at defending the provinces in the House. I think I heard my colleague say that he thinks the federal government's only role in housing should be to transfer money to the provinces. If that is the case, then what would he do with existing federal agencies, like CMHC? Does he think that the federal government should get out of the housing business altogether?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084138","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Bloc Québécois members are great at defending the provinces in the House. I think I heard my colleague say that he thinks the federal government's only role in housing should be to transfer money to the provinces. If that is the case, then what would he do with existing federal agencies, like CMHC? Does he think that the federal government should get out of the housing business ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["92db4cc66d3b4280fa6e2c4347624dd0e31848b573af9a398b68302ca342ec6a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebbde4bf074e983fb2ecb9e19dd2def69c893383f7c857c46997a9ea68ed1786"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c91b8cc8b4d9141db420cdc1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084139,"date":"2026-06-05T18:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I really appreciate that my colleague has taken the time to talk about the importance of having targets, measures and accountability in bills, and also about how important it is to have different kinds of housing. \n\nI know that the member comes from Vancouver East, which is, like my riding, suffering very much from the addictions crisis. I am wondering if the member could talk about the importance of having sober housing in this environment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084139","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I really appreciate that my colleague has taken the time to talk about the importance of having targets, measures and accountability in bills, and also about how important it is to have different kinds of housing. \n\nI know that the member comes from Vancouver East, which is, like my riding, suffering very much from the addictions crisis. I am wondering if the member could talk about","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9819eee9eeffa5437544dfaa0ecb26df95eff0c7e35e16b06e457efb3a56d5ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95a0c0fb13a5f6cc186bd071","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084140,"date":"2026-06-05T18:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, as the member pointed out in her speech, there is already the CMHC. Ottawa does not lack agencies with housing powers. On top of that, there is also the Canada Lands Company, which already has the power to develop federal land. There is Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada, which already manages federal housing funding and agreements. There is the Canada Infrastructure Bank, which already has the power to finance infrastructure that unlocks housing. The last time I checked, it was a minister's job to knit all of that together and to find co-operation, so I am as baffled as she is that there is yet another Crown corporation being created. I wonder whether or not the issue here might be the minister.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084140","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, as the member pointed out in her speech, there is already the CMHC. Ottawa does not lack agencies with housing powers. On top of that, there is also the Canada Lands Company, which already has the power to develop federal land. There is Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada, which already manages federal housing funding and agreements. There is the Canada Infrastructure Ban","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66c1621ba04f74a2c9dc8c58e93a021ddc07d5ce6f88e98b4cd0d335a4133746"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["77755f3fba20d29fbada6976fd6fc406358a93db1ae34963681f7c8847d6c511"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bfd3fa324c6ecf44c359165b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084141,"date":"2026-06-05T18:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, when it comes to housing, bureaucrats count starts. They count units. They count dollars. They count funds, programs, agencies and promises, but in Nanaimo—Ladysmith, we count something different. We count the months our adult children have been living in the spare room because rent has eaten the down payment they were trying to save for. We count the number of graduates who cannot find a job that pays enough to cover rent. We count the number of people with no home at all as we pass them on the way to work.\n\nBefore I forget, I will be splitting my time.\n\nOn a more serious note, we count the graves of friends lost to addiction, the treatment beds that are not there, and the people who make it through detox only to be sent back to the same chaos they were trying to escape. We continue to measure the distance between the government's language and our reality. That distance is the distance between a young person with a diploma and a job and having no real path to owning a home in the community they grew up in. It is the distance between a person who is coming out of detox trying to stay clean and housing where drug use is not happening down the hall. Those are not separate crises. They are part of the same failure of government. We have lost the link between housing and hope.\n\nCanada does not lack for housing announcements. In the last decade, we have had strategies, accelerators, funds, agencies, accords and photo ops, including some that have their own complete purpose-built backdrop. What we do not have is enough homes that people can afford. In Nanaimo—Ladysmith, we do not have enough of the right homes for people who are trying to rebuild their lives. \n\nNow we have Bill C-20, which would create Build Canada Homes to promote, support and develop the supply of affordable housing. From the speeches, it sounds ambitious. The question is whether it will be useful once the media has packed up and gone home and the sets have been dismantled. All this bill does is create the skeleton. It creates the framework and the corporation itself.\n\nThe government is presenting Build Canada Homes as a generational housing investment, but the Parliamentary Budget Officer says it will only have a modest impact. The headline number is $13 billion, but the Parliamentary Budget Officer says the actual planned spend is $7.3 billion over five years on an accrual basis. The projected result is about 26,000 homes over five years, or roughly 5,200 homes a year across the entire country. This would increase housing completions by only 2.1% above the baseline and address just 3.7% of the estimated housing gap. Even with Build Canada Homes included, planned federal housing spending is set to fall by 56%, from $9.8 billion in 2025-26 to $4.3 billion in 2028-29. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has put the scale of the new housing gap plainly: Canada needs 3.2 million net new housing units by 2035, which means an average of 290,000 units a year for a decade.\n\nThe PBO also warned that this would still not fully solve affordability in every region, because income, interest rates, regional gaps and the kind of housing built all matter, as my colleagues have pointed out in their speeches. That last point matters the most to growing communities like mine, because we do not just need more housing; we need the right housing in the right places for the people who need it. Housing experts have made this same point over and over again. Mike Moffatt's report says, \"Canada needs to build millions more homes, but not just any homes.\" They have to be homes built for today's needs, and getting there is going to require bolder reforms, in our opinion, than those that have been put forward so far.\n\nBill C-20 would not speed up local approvals. It would not give our provinces and municipalities the infrastructure they need. It would not service land, and it would not set binding targets for how many homes will be completed by when, for whom, at what price.\n\nWhat Bill C-20 would do is create another federal bureaucracy on top of at least four others in this space. There is CMHC, which already has the power to finance housing, lend, guarantee loans, invest and run federal housing programs. The Canada Lands Company already has the power to develop federal land. Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada already manages federal housing funding and agreements. The Canada Infrastructure Bank already has the power to finance infrastructure that unlocks housing. \n\nIn other words, the functions are already there, and Ottawa does not lack agencies with housing powers. What it lacks is results. Building another bureaucracy means time spent setting it up. Offices need to be set up, executives hired, mandates written, files moved around and programs reorganized, and that is time and money that could be spent getting homes built. That is the problem. The government is using language that Canadians want to hear, but the structure does not match the urgency of the moment. \n\nYoung Canadians understand this instinctively. We tell them to study, work, save and be patient. Then they graduate into a labour market where entry-level jobs are harder and harder to find, where rent consumes too much of their income and where ownership feels less like a goal than a memory from someone else's Canada. \n\nThis week, a recent software engineering graduate came to a committee of the House to say that he could still not find entry-level work in his field. When asked whether he was working, he said yes, but not as a software engineer. The Liberal MP's reply was, \"At least you're employed.\" That answer reveals something deeper than one exchange. It shows a government that has lowered the bar. \n\nI will continue my speech when the House resumes next week.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084141","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, when it comes to housing, bureaucrats count starts. They count units. They count dollars. They count funds, programs, agencies and promises, but in Nanaimo—Ladysmith, we count something different. We count the months our adult children have been living in the spare room because rent has eaten the down payment they were trying to save for. We count the number of graduates who cannot ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["13fa6858cec0507a921809d5e97c7c5690147dea019591b013a2c6d5ca014bb8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5b468a5b3afd26f37c5d940188f9c738d94077affcf2aa21d53edc6db9e7c5f7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c58f7949c48dccd5d72b906","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086123,"date":"2026-06-08T16:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak in support of Bill S-228, an act to amend the Criminal Code with respect to forced sterilization procedures.\n\nThis is a short bill, but it deals with a grave wrong. It speaks to bodily autonomy, consent, human dignity, the equal worth of every person and the duty of the state to protect those who have been harmed by the systems that should have protected them. Bill S-228 would amend the Criminal Code to make it crystal clear that a sterilization procedure performed without consent is an act that \"wounds or maims a person\" for the purpose of an aggravated assault. It would also define what is meant by a \"sterilization procedure\", including any procedure that permanently prevents reproduction.\n\nAt first glance, some may ask why this change is needed. We already have laws against assault. We already have rules around consent in health care. We already have medical standards and professional oversight. However, the painful truth is that those protections have not always protected people equally. They have not always been clear enough. They have not always been enforced. For too many women, especially indigenous women, racialized women, women with disabilities and others in vulnerable situations, the promise of protection and the promise of consent have been broken in this country.\n\nA forced or coerced sterilization is not a minor medical error. It is not a paperwork problem. It is a profound violation of the person. It takes away from someone the ability to make one of the most personal decisions they will ever make in their life. It will affect their body, their mind, their family, their culture and their future. It is a harm that can last for generations. There is a saying in my own culture that when a person saves a life, it is as if they have saved the entire world. The corollary to that is that a person who prevents someone from making a life is preventing them from creating an entire world.\n\nNo one should be pressured into giving up the ability to have children. No one should be asked for consent while they are in pain, in fear, under the effects medication, in labour or under the control of a person in authority. No one should be treated as though their poverty, identity, disability, race, age, family situation or social standing makes them less worthy of respect. Consent that is forced is not consent, no matter the situation. Consent that is coerced is not consent. Consent given without proper information is not consent.\n\nIf someone has to ask why we need a bill like this in 2026, they are lucky. They are lucky to not know someone who has been in this situation. They are lucky not to have experienced this in their community.\n\n This bill is about drawing a clear line in federal criminal law. It would tell survivors that Parliament sees them. It would tell the health care system that vague language is not enough. It would tell prosecutors, the police, professional bodies and institutions that this is not a grey area and this is not a decision to be made on the fly. This is not something that someone can do because they think it is best in the circumstances. It is violence and it is a violation, and we will have a law in this country that makes it clear that it is to be treated as such.\n\nI want to recognize Senator Yvonne Boyer and everyone who has made it possible for all of us who have spoken this morning to stand in this House today to make it clear that this is not just something that Canada recognizes, but something that we will take concrete steps to prevent in the future.\n\n Everyone in this House believes in the dignity of the person. We believe in personal freedom, but freedom is not real when a person's body can be controlled by someone else. We believe in accountability, but accountability is not real when the people who commit or enable serious harm to another human being in this country face no clear consequences. We believe in equal justice under the law, but justice is not equal when vulnerable people are less likely to be heard, believed or protected. We have an opportunity in the House today to do the right thing, not just for past generations, but for future generations and for those who are still suffering today with the burden of having had those experiences.\n\n The history behind this bill is hard to face. Canada has had a long record of forced and coerced sterilization, often tied to racism, eugenics, colonization and the idea that some lives are less vulnerable than others. Those ideas were not harmless theories. They shaped policies, institutions and medical practices. They harmed first nations, Métis, Inuit and other indigenous peoples in this country. They harmed Black and racialized women. They harmed people with disabilities, people living in poverty and people who were placed in institutions and stripped of control in their own lives. By acknowledging these wrongs in the House, by putting them into the record of this place to be read and seen by future generations, we do not make Canada weaker; we make Canada stronger.\n\n We must also be honest about the fact that this is not only history. Survivors have come forward in recent years. They have spoken about being pressured in their most vulnerable moments. They have spoken of procedures that they did not understand, did not freely choose and did not consent to. They have also spoken of the shame, grief, fear, distrust and deep injury that has come with that. That is a second, additional injury that we have done to those people in this country, on top of the forced sterilization they had to endure without their consent. Many have had to carry that pain in silence, so all who speak to this bill in the House this morning lend our voices to them. We want to make sure they know that they do not have to suffer in silence, but even when they have to suffer in silence, we in this place will suffer with them. \n\nWhen survivors share these stories, our first duty is to listen, but our second duty is to act. Bill S-228 would not fix every harm in this country, but it is a start. Criminal law is a tool. Health care is, of course, largely within provincial and territorial jurisdiction. Professional regulation belongs to colleges and licensing bodies. Hospitals, health authorities, medical schools and governments all have work to do. There must be better training on informed consent. There must be cultural safety. There must be clear reporting pathways. \n\nWhat we have done this morning in the House, and what my colleagues have done with Bill S-228, is a start. We have made a powerful pronouncement about what is to be tolerated in this country. Hopefully, in doing that, we will not only make sure that these atrocities do not happen to future generations but bring comfort to the people who have come to this place to advocate for the bill, letting them know that their advocacy, their actions, the things they have done and the messages they have brought to this place have been heard, that their sacrifices and the things they have done matter and that they have been a part of the solution for future generations. \n\nI urge every member of the House to stand with survivors and with those who were never able to be born, today and always, through this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086123","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak in support of Bill S-228, an act to amend the Criminal Code with respect to forced sterilization procedures.\n\nThis is a short bill, but it deals with a grave wrong. It speaks to bodily autonomy, consent, human dignity, the equal worth of every person and the duty of the state to protect those who have been harmed by the systems that should have protected them. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1801f39d59c6da2fa72cf4016f6c6f08e6d02f3c9e02fad55687bce29673a93a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ba65c9341e6947cbc08cf020005bd62c7af4199d40c38b5f07c79c5fc0ca4654"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20e2b60905aa38b82c3ab71a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086124,"date":"2026-06-08T23:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the hon. member has a lot of expertise in the area of trade. I, of course, come from a riding and a place in this country that is heavily dependent on resources, on trade, on forestry and on north-south exports and imports. Unemployment in my riding is now at 8.5%.\n\nI wonder if the member could talk about how the economy is not being felt the same in different parts of the country and, perhaps, explain to the members opposite why their economic policies are hurting ridings like mine in particular.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086124","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the hon. member has a lot of expertise in the area of trade. I, of course, come from a riding and a place in this country that is heavily dependent on resources, on trade, on forestry and on north-south exports and imports. Unemployment in my riding is now at 8.5%.\n\nI wonder if the member could talk about how the economy is not being felt the same in different parts of the country and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9b74da5b03f410e6f8d4ba0e490ec7769aaa89ecee91e1840b4d55c3a95a5387"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd2543ed40a8fec4b0beddad7b770238dbcbba4164b92eed4a5f2e0f0d4ddb97"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e8a0f16de7929924e6523fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086116,"date":"2026-06-09T17:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-20 aspires to help Canadians build more homes faster and promote innovative and efficient building techniques for the housing sector. The goal matters deeply in communities like Nanaimo—Ladysmith.\n\nAs I said at the beginning of my original speech, I am splitting my time today.\n\n Across the mid-island, families are facing the same housing pressures we see across the country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086116","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-20 aspires to help Canadians build more homes faster and promote innovative and efficient building techniques for the housing sector. The goal matters deeply in communities like Nanaimo—Ladysmith.\n\nAs I said at the beginning of my original speech, I am splitting my time today.\n\n Across the mid-island, families are facing the same housing pressures we see across the country.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["defe9e90d85ab232dd3d80235104f511702abee6ff81d82ae29a3c6d90c97902"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["03cfe7f2d7e6df4511bebc35706640286c9b5266d961e6704b394e4262777275"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6f130cccc3dab1d67d6cb15","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086117,"date":"2026-06-09T17:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, among other things that I am continuing in my speech from the other day, Bill C-20 aspires to help Canadians build more homes faster and to promote innovative and efficient building techniques in the housing sector. That goal matters deeply in communities such as Nanaimo—Ladysmith.\n\n Across the mid-island, families are facing the same housing pressures we see across the country. Young people are wondering whether they will ever be able to afford a home, seniors are looking for options that allow them to downsize while staying close to family and workers are struggling to live near the jobs that keep our communities running. We agree that we cannot meet that challenge with old thinking alone. We need to build differently, build faster and make use of better and new methods and Canadian standards, as well as local business that are already doing the work.\n\nThe mid-island did not wait for legislation. We know we cannot rely on the government to solve our problems for us. Local innovators have already risen to the occasion to make the mid-island an emerging hub for modular and innovative construction.\n\n I recently toured Cueva Homes, which is headquartered in Nanaimo. There, I saw exactly the kind of practical innovation this country needs. Cueva Homes is focused on modular homes, backyard suites, ADUs and smaller housing options that can help communities add supply without changing the character of every neighbourhood. The folks at Cueva Homes are ready to go. These are real homes designed for real lots, and they are built with the kind of efficiency that could help address the housing shortage. They are especially well suited for communities like ours, where many families need options for aging parents, adult children, renters and first-time buyers. Cueva Homes' work also shows why standards matter. When homes are CSA-compliant, even if they are fabricated abroad with a significant proportion of local materials exported from the island for that purpose, communities can have confidence that innovation is not coming at the expense of safety, quality or code compliance. That should be central to the purpose of Bill C-20.\n\nI also want to recognize Wescon Doors, another Vancouver Island business contributing to this same housing ecosystem. Wescon manufactures doors built for our climate and to meet applicable Canadian standards. Businesses like Wescon Doors remind us that housing innovation is not only about the finished home, but also about the local supply chain, components, skilled workers and manufacturers that make faster, better building possible.\n\nIf Bill C-20 is truly about supporting innovative and efficient building techniques, then the government must recognize communities such as ours. We already have businesses working in modular housing, prefabricated systems with high-quality components and climate-appropriate construction. The opportunity now is to connect federal policy with local capacity. Nanaimo—Ladysmith is ready to be part of that solution","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086117","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, among other things that I am continuing in my speech from the other day, Bill C-20 aspires to help Canadians build more homes faster and to promote innovative and efficient building techniques in the housing sector. That goal matters deeply in communities such as Nanaimo—Ladysmith.\n\n Across the mid-island, families are facing the same housing pressures we see across the country. Young","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["91d15ca3e0abe74ad655fada6bdb55a9f6b38d7d5deb43ad8d59b7925ed643d2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a25fa578a89ed1272fbc50d193e73d58036bf751deddcbcc2d56400c3a91e334"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-011bcefa7d7f95e79bcd0be5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086118,"date":"2026-06-09T17:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, for his benefit, I would like to share with the member opposite what I am hearing on the ground.\n\nWe are also concerned about the fact that there are multiple bureaucracies already in place. We are very concerned about Build Canada Homes and making sure that it does not become another Ottawa-driven program that overlooks the builders and manufacturers already solving problems on the ground in communities such as mine.\n\n We would like a commitment from the government that it will help and support practical, CSA-compliant, scalable solutions such as those found in our communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086118","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, for his benefit, I would like to share with the member opposite what I am hearing on the ground.\n\nWe are also concerned about the fact that there are multiple bureaucracies already in place. We are very concerned about Build Canada Homes and making sure that it does not become another Ottawa-driven program that overlooks the builders and manufacturers already solving problems on the g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b2ae728f5598c1a328f9a225be3292d4b62aec9a43c27fce87aa0e3b1a006c4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0f01959309e47e1fb4de114","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086119,"date":"2026-06-09T17:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a very timely question, because just last night in my community, our local city council was holding a special meeting about the need for sober housing specifically. All kinds of housing in our communities came up.\n\n The provinces, especially provinces like mine, are really struggling in the context of this economy. Of course, this means that municipalities are struggling as well. If the government is going to allocate funds toward housing, it really needs to work harder to address those issues in communities like Nanaimo—Ladysmith and beyond.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086119","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a very timely question, because just last night in my community, our local city council was holding a special meeting about the need for sober housing specifically. All kinds of housing in our communities came up.\n\n The provinces, especially provinces like mine, are really struggling in the context of this economy. Of course, this means that municipalities are struggling as we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1a3f6570b90aff11dc689231712d5311a37180855c47a94515b2f41dd67901e0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["26de741475a2737f0fb1ac703988a0942a42398b0a97b7c205d102c09cb554a0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5aaf7f8843fc4bf408e34ebb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086120,"date":"2026-06-09T17:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if the member believes market housing is working well in Nanaimo, he really does not understand British Columbia. We are the missing middle. We have the missing market housing and the missing supportive housing. We are in the throes of an addictions crisis. Last night, we heard testimony about how hard it is for someone to resist the lures of addiction when they are down, homeless and sleeping on the street.\n\n That question was an insult to my communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086120","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if the member believes market housing is working well in Nanaimo, he really does not understand British Columbia. We are the missing middle. We have the missing market housing and the missing supportive housing. We are in the throes of an addictions crisis. Last night, we heard testimony about how hard it is for someone to resist the lures of addiction when they are down, homeless and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2dab4e7a85d89ebedb710c7808cdd7c2742c2a7e0ab71192f313b45fd798d0b1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7c14320f475d82941f4475758f616b9425b0638df64b27e4e30655c712195c50"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0de15a0417c570585b2ea18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086121,"date":"2026-06-09T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member from the other side goes back to the question before and suggests that I was being insulting, when someone was trying to tell me that my community does not need mid-market housing and below, and that we are just fine with market housing. I am sorry, but that is another member who does not understand what is going on in British Columbia or in my riding.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086121","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member from the other side goes back to the question before and suggests that I was being insulting, when someone was trying to tell me that my community does not need mid-market housing and below, and that we are just fine with market housing. I am sorry, but that is another member who does not understand what is going on in British Columbia or in my riding.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0cba2fe4772d5b03be2dcf4d4759c41d73e4ae2254edf9833e1a69e269ada754"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5b70e9413299dd8864a9ff8e9138844fc05ee82c3bb31c6bd564ce08d1b45c42"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea51dc84069bbaa57fdd2a9e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086122,"date":"2026-06-09T23:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when I was growing up, my childhood home backed onto a ravine. It sat near the end of a long street, with no houses for the first few hundred metres. In the winter, I would get off the bus in the dark and walk that stretch home alone.\n\n As a teenager, every sound felt sharp and every shadow felt close, because I knew, thanks to the nightly news, that there was a man out there attacking girls like me. They called him the \"Scarborough Rapist.\" I lived in North York, but the ravines are all connected. I was terrified, even as I tried not to show it. I learned to be careful, to hurry home, to put my key between my fingers, to watch behind me and to never assume that I was safe.\n\n Paul Bernardo never touched me. I never met him. However, he was truly one of the monsters of my childhood. His heinous crimes destroyed families and changed the way a generation of girls moved through the world. He taught us fear before we even had the words to explain it. If my heart rate goes up and if my stomach tightens when I think of Paul Bernardo in a medium-security prison, I cannot imagine how the families of the young women and girls he raped, tortured and murdered feel about it. For them, this is not an abstract fear. It is a gaping wound that never closes.\n\nToday, I rise in strong support of Bill C-232, an act to amend the Corrections and Conditional Release Act, brought forward by my hon. colleague, the member for Niagara Falls—Niagara-on-the-Lake. This bill is clear, modest and necessary. It says that when an offender has been found by a court to be a dangerous offender or when an offender has been convicted of more than one first-degree murder, that person will be classified as maximum security and will remain in a maximum-security penitentiary or a maximum-security area of the penitentiary. This should not be controversial.\n\n In fact, most Canadians I speak to are shocked to learn that it is not already the law. It would have been, except that in 2019, these Liberals passed Bill C-83, which legally requires Correctional Service Canada to place an inmate in the penitentiary that provides the least restrictive environment for that person. While CSC can consider the offender's current institutional behaviour, escape risk, public safety risk if they escape and program participation, it cannot ask whether an offender's crimes are so monstrous that maximum security should be permanent.\n\n If the offender behaves in prison, they are assessed as manageable. If officials conclude they do not currently need maximum control, they can be reclassified. That is how a person can commit the most horrific crimes imaginable and still be moved down to medium security. CSC did not violate the law when it moved Paul Bernardo to medium security. Following public outrage over Mr. Bernardo's transfer, a review concluded the transfer was sound, and followed both law and policy. That means that law and policy are the problem here.\n\n We have to be honest about what prison behaviour can and cannot tell us. Often, the most dangerous offenders are not dangerous because they cannot control themselves; they are dangerous because they can. They can be patient, they can be charming and they can follow rules when it benefits them. We have heard all of this at committee. A clean institutional record does not erase sadism, predation or the court's finding that a person is a dangerous offender, but it can get the move to medium security.\n\n For victims' families, this is unbearable. These families sit through trials, they hear the evidence, they mourn daughters, sisters and friends, and they learn how they were tortured, raped and killed. They live with a life sentence of grief. They cannot unhear what they hear in those courtrooms. Then they learn that the offender has been moved to a lower-security institution, because the focus has shifted from the horror of the offence to the offender's current institutional score. That is not justice, as most Canadians understand it.\n\n Let us be clear about what maximum security means here. It is not about revenge, and it is not cruelty or a rejection of basic human rights. It is a recognition that some offenders have crossed a line so grave that public safety, public confidence and respect for victims demand it.\n\n A dangerous offender designation is one of the most serious findings a Canadian court can make. It is reserved for offenders who have shown a pattern of serious violence, sexual violence or conduct so brutal that they pose an ongoing threat to the public. Likewise, first-degree murder is planned and deliberate, and it falls into the most serious categories of homicide known in our laws. A person convicted of more than one first-degree murder has not made a tragic mistake. That person has taken multiple lives with intent.\n\n Bill C-232 would draw an important line that says dangerous offenders and offenders convicted of more than one first-degree murder must be assigned a maximum-security classification and they must be confined in a maximum-security penitentiary or a maximum-security area of a penitentiary. It would ensure that these offenders are not eligible for unescorted temporary absences. This bill would clearly tell Correctional Service Canada that for a very narrow class of the worst offenders, including household names such as Bernardo, Magnotta and Smich, maximum security is not optional; it is mandatory.\n\nSince being elected, I have spent more time than I ever thought I would with grieving families. I am stunned by the scope and scale of violence against women and girls in this country. I had no idea of the extent to which the Liberal government had tipped the scales in favour of offenders, leaving victims and their families to be traumatized and retraumatized. I am against telling women and girls, or their families, that the people who terrorized them, hunted them, raped them or murdered them can one day be managed in a less restrictive environment because enough time has passed or they are playing well with others behind bars.\n\nI want to thank the member for Niagara Falls—Niagara-on-the-Lake for bringing this bill forward. He has done something important. He has taken the outrage that Canadians feel over cases like those of Bernardo, Magnotta and Smich, who, to the best of my knowledge, all remain in medium-security correctional environments today, and turned it into a practical, legal response. That is what we were sent here to do.\n\nJust this weekend, while at home, I met with a woman who spoke to me about violence, fear and the need for leaders to take domestic violence and violence against children and women seriously. I made her a promise that I would stand up in this place, use my voice and not allow these issues to be softened, buried or explained away by bureaucratic language and fancy legal concepts. Today, by supporting Bill C-232, I am keeping that promise, because violence against women is not an abstraction and violence against children is not a talking point. These are wounds carried by families, communities and survivors who need to know that people in this place are prepared to act.\n\nBill C-232 would not undo the evil committed by Bernardo, Smich, Magnotta and others, whose names Canadians invoke with horror, nor would it bring back Leslie Mahaffy, Kristen French, Laura Babcock, Tim Bosma, Jun Lin or any other victim, but it would say that some crimes are so grave and some offenders are so dangerous that maximum security means maximum security. It would also say to every woman, parent, survivor and grieving family watching this debate that their fear is not irrational, their grief is not forgotten and their Parliament has a duty to stand with them.\n\nI urge every member of the House to support Bill C-232.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086122","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when I was growing up, my childhood home backed onto a ravine. It sat near the end of a long street, with no houses for the first few hundred metres. In the winter, I would get off the bus in the dark and walk that stretch home alone.\n\n As a teenager, every sound felt sharp and every shadow felt close, because I knew, thanks to the nightly news, that there was a man out there attackin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1d2fc3a591eab30eed7b314aef4a44ce759542855a03f8049630282eaf629c33"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["46300d183742647ffac4a1a5b2f114f2e1c65aa462169015d210d8a68a648df3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86de15e5ea6dd44f88d2a0bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118804,"date":"2026-06-10T18:35:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you very much, Madam Chair. I'd also like to ask some questions of the officials. I imagine my questions will be for Mr. Stuart. Mr. Stuart, can you explain why projected CPP assets in nominal dollars alone might not give Canadians the full picture of the state of the Canada pension plan?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118804","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Madam Chair. I'd also like to ask some questions of the officials. I imagine my questions will be for Mr. Stuart. Mr. Stuart, can you explain why projected CPP assets in nominal dollars alone might not give Canadians the full picture of the state of the Canada pension plan?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5777c7653c7fc843f99ac7ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118805,"date":"2026-06-10T18:35:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Does the actuarial report lay out the assumptions that underlie the calculations in the report?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118805","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Does the actuarial report lay out the assumptions that underlie the calculations in the report?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90e844c9b33807efadde52cfdbb06d10d8d63d2a0f74e6ccaef42b9a52ba1f95"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0993c78675cd7ccb92b3766c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118806,"date":"2026-06-10T18:35:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"I'm not trying to challenge that report in any way, shape or form, but just to be clear, when we talk about an amendment to be able to bring the information to the House, what we talk about is presenting it in a form that's digestible by parliamentarians and also in a form.... I believe the next subamendment we're going to talk about—which I will not ask any questions about right now, or expound on—talks about requiring the report to be written in plain English. In plain English, can you explain what kinds of assumptions underlie the inflationary calculations in terms of the difference between the nominal and inflationary rates?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118806","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm not trying to challenge that report in any way, shape or form, but just to be clear, when we talk about an amendment to be able to bring the information to the House, what we talk about is presenting it in a form that's digestible by parliamentarians and also in a form.... I believe the next subamendment we're going to talk about—which I will not ask any questions about right now, or expound o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9f6676cd09360ebfa65225c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118807,"date":"2026-06-10T18:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"I understand that you want to refer to the report, and I appreciate that. What I'm actually asking you to do is to explain that part of the report in plain English in this room. Could you explain, for the benefit of the people who are watching at home and don't necessarily have the benefit of our expertise, how you take nominal rates and turn them into inflated rates, so that it would be simple? Is there a plain English section of the actuarial report that actually does that and that we could read?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118807","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand that you want to refer to the report, and I appreciate that. What I'm actually asking you to do is to explain that part of the report in plain English in this room. Could you explain, for the benefit of the people who are watching at home and don't necessarily have the benefit of our expertise, how you take nominal rates and turn them into inflated rates, so that it would be simple? I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b503708b3dd85e3b7071e97a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118808,"date":"2026-06-10T18:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Just on that, I'm asking him to explain the concept of nominal numbers and inflationary numbers and talk about how we get from one to the other. He's actually referring back to the report. My questions are actually aimed not at talking about the report but at talking about the amendment and the subamendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118808","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just on that, I'm asking him to explain the concept of nominal numbers and inflationary numbers and talk about how we get from one to the other. He's actually referring back to the report. My questions are actually aimed not at talking about the report but at talking about the amendment and the subamendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc5da05f2803651a6ce45b408c6c380e7dae9fe74671ae87fd70b27e773db124"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab84b2381a4e67cf973ed3e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118809,"date":"2026-06-10T18:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you for that clarification. I appreciate it. I appreciate the opportunity to clarify that I'm not asking about the actuarial report. When I talk about a report, what we're discussing is the amendment we want to make, which—without reading it—suggests that the minister has to provide a report to the House within a specified period of time. One of the things we want that report to contain, because we think it is of use to Canadians, is the way that the nominal numbers are converted into inflation-adjusted numbers. With your expertise in finance, distinct from your expertise in helping with or in reading reports, I'm hoping that you could explain how it is that we take nominal numbers for a pension plan and convert them into inflation-adjusted numbers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118809","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for that clarification. I appreciate it. I appreciate the opportunity to clarify that I'm not asking about the actuarial report. When I talk about a report, what we're discussing is the amendment we want to make, which—without reading it—suggests that the minister has to provide a report to the House within a specified period of time. One of the things we want that report to contain, bec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23c81dc389cf142217149bc812566d5b50b824e12e7c6e42cd0c0a7f183a323b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5337530c8ce415b5f5a69157","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118810,"date":"2026-06-10T18:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"I appreciate the point you're making. The amendment and the subamendment relate to a ministerial report. Neither the amendment nor the subamendment, if I am correct.... It isn't the actuarial report. I wouldn't expect it to say, \"Please refer to page 462 of the actuarial report.\" I think the conversation we're having right now helps buttress the reason we're proposing these amendments and subamendments. The question I'm asking isn't about the report. It's about how a person with knowledge of how the CPP works can translate nominal numbers into inflation-adjusted numbers. It is a question independent of the actuarial report. I've asked you the question twice. Maybe the chair can help. Is there a different official present who could answer this question?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118810","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I appreciate the point you're making. The amendment and the subamendment relate to a ministerial report. Neither the amendment nor the subamendment, if I am correct.... It isn't the actuarial report. I wouldn't expect it to say, \"Please refer to page 462 of the actuarial report.\" I think the conversation we're having right now helps buttress the reason we're proposing these amendments and subamend","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["63fd0ab8341ca89526b8be7fb860fb52f109147aa8d9f27b8379f798d325c6f8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-509e9e25cae29f07a55b273a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118811,"date":"2026-06-10T18:45:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Let me see if I can ask the question in a different way. What we are asking for is that a report be tabled in the House that includes projected Canada pension plan assets in both nominal and inflation-adjusted dollars. Can you explain the difference between nominal and inflation-adjusted dollars?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118811","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Let me see if I can ask the question in a different way. What we are asking for is that a report be tabled in the House that includes projected Canada pension plan assets in both nominal and inflation-adjusted dollars. Can you explain the difference between nominal and inflation-adjusted dollars?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c4ae19db86dd56055a837206","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118812,"date":"2026-06-10T18:45:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"I understand the report does that. The question I asked is, how does a person take nominal numbers and turn them into inflation-adjusted numbers? You started to provide the answer to me, for which I am grateful. I'm wondering if you can explain it. I'm really trying to explain this to the people watching this at home. What we're dealing with is a situation where it's proposed that CPP contribution rates be adjusted. That makes a real difference in people's lives. CPP is one of the things that many Canadians depend on for their retirement. In the interest of being able to talk about the value of this amendment and subamendment, I'm trying to explain how the amendment and subamendment would translate data included in the actuarial report—which has finance language that all of us in this room are comfortable with and used to using—into concepts that people can understand, so they can follow along with us and evaluate the work we are doing in the House of Commons. Given that you described taking nominal rates and adjusting them through a formula to reflect inflation-adjusted numbers, can you apply that concept to the assets of the Canada pension plan and explain how we take nominal numbers in the plan, actuarial reports and documents to come, and turn them into numbers that provide an inflation-adjusted...? It's a \"how\" question, not a \"where is it described\" question. It is a basic finance question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118812","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand the report does that. The question I asked is, how does a person take nominal numbers and turn them into inflation-adjusted numbers? You started to provide the answer to me, for which I am grateful. I'm wondering if you can explain it. I'm really trying to explain this to the people watching this at home. What we're dealing with is a situation where it's proposed that CPP contribution","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca09b70db4be711b48801ce73eb2549294a2e4e7deff2051ac4d6260cccd802c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4257996ab5b380063f32afe256c8e38171acb15a48ee16f581690d8824b77616"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-113787d647ae4601d6fe27a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118813,"date":"2026-06-10T18:45:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"I am. That's why I'm not actually asking how he would do this in the report. I'm trying to ask how we do this in the real world. If Canadians are going to be able to understand how these reports are going to work, they need to understand what kind of information they're going to contain. That's how we establish why they're important. It's the idea that you take numbers.... I was hoping that it would be explained by an expert and not necessarily explained by someone like me. While I may have practised a little bit of pension law, I don't happen to consider myself an expert in this area. What I'm trying to get at is the question of what kind of information we are looking for. The Canada pension plan reports numbers. In order to give meaning to those numbers, we use some formulas that reflect inflation, and we turn them into different numbers that give us a snapshot at a different point in time. That's the kind of explanation I was hoping to get.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118813","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I am. That's why I'm not actually asking how he would do this in the report. I'm trying to ask how we do this in the real world. If Canadians are going to be able to understand how these reports are going to work, they need to understand what kind of information they're going to contain. That's how we establish why they're important. It's the idea that you take numbers.... I was hoping that it wou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["680a347cde31acb3ddcf498a63a0266cd2a2bfd282518a17d88106c7e9dd2afa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b0d98b088ec3d918fdd94be773828c60b66453c0dbb3c0f930b2c5b6adf681eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07e0e8dbaa0946d6c02c29b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118814,"date":"2026-06-10T18:50:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"I'm a little bit incredulous about that, Madam Chair, because I'm not asking him to say what the actual report would contain. I'm asking him to describe the kinds of calculations that we do. Even I learned how to do basic calculations in grad school and law school on how you take a number and multiply it by inflation. I don't think we are asking officials to do anything unreasonable when we are asking them to describe, in general, these kinds of calculations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118814","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm a little bit incredulous about that, Madam Chair, because I'm not asking him to say what the actual report would contain. I'm asking him to describe the kinds of calculations that we do. Even I learned how to do basic calculations in grad school and law school on how you take a number and multiply it by inflation. I don't think we are asking officials to do anything unreasonable when we are as","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["214d488502b719cf394c0cb0f488ae3554be306caa2f03276fdbc78bc41496de"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ec4c4f665efc4d4fd63259b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118815,"date":"2026-06-10T18:50:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"I want to say two things on that. The first is that how a report is prepared talks about what goes into it. Part of explaining why a report is valuable is explaining the kinds of things that go into it. How those calculations are made are the kinds of things that help us understand what that report is going to look like. If I've never seen an elephant before, in trying to decide whether or not it's a good thing to have as a pet, you would have to describe what the elephant looks like, how big it is, what its behaviour is and all of that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118815","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I want to say two things on that. The first is that how a report is prepared talks about what goes into it. Part of explaining why a report is valuable is explaining the kinds of things that go into it. How those calculations are made are the kinds of things that help us understand what that report is going to look like. If I've never seen an elephant before, in trying to decide whether or not it'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df465cf25d6b93b39214b269a75603f296ada076013ffaf999690fc95230b52c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ef55699069ab7036364ed8ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118816,"date":"2026-06-10T18:50:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. With due respect, I want to make a comment on this. I've been to this committee before, and this is now my third time on this point. When I was here last night for the first time, the officials were not here, so I didn't have the ability to ask them questions. That is why I'm asking them questions now, because I respect the expertise of the people who work for us in this country, and I would be grateful if they could help us to help Canadians understand why we're proposing this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118816","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. With due respect, I want to make a comment on this. I've been to this committee before, and this is now my third time on this point. When I was here last night for the first time, the officials were not here, so I didn't have the ability to ask them questions. That is why I'm asking them questions now, because I respect the expertise of the people who work for us in this country, and I ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d5fd2419084a3bd722fdd5a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118817,"date":"2026-06-10T18:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"I understand. That having been said, the technical question I was asking was from a mathematics perspective. How do you get from a nominal number to an inflationary number? That doesn't require referring to any part of the actuary's report. It doesn't require referring to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118817","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand. That having been said, the technical question I was asking was from a mathematics perspective. How do you get from a nominal number to an inflationary number? That doesn't require referring to any part of the actuary's report. It doesn't require referring to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33aea9ef3330f580183b0efa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118818,"date":"2026-06-10T18:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Madam Chair, let me ask you a question. There are 15 or so witnesses listed on this notice of meeting. Who is the official who is here to answer the questions that I am posing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118818","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Chair, let me ask you a question. There are 15 or so witnesses listed on this notice of meeting. Who is the official who is here to answer the questions that I am posing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a62a9c7b5f398409b7bcf971","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118819,"date":"2026-06-10T18:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Let me ask this in a different way. There are 10 officials from Finance listed here. Are none of those Finance officials able to answer question about how we...? Are none of those people able to answer questions beyond technical questions within the four corners of the actuarial report?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118819","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Let me ask this in a different way. There are 10 officials from Finance listed here. Are none of those Finance officials able to answer question about how we...? Are none of those people able to answer questions beyond technical questions within the four corners of the actuarial report?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["872054e33eb643387d17e8bcbfc8600a177a61657093ebbe1f303f606f10797c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04db8583ac832c29c3f95a78","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118820,"date":"2026-06-10T18:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Is it not part of the standing rules that during the clause-by-clause consideration of a government bill, officials from the departments concerned normally remain before a committee as witnesses in order—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118820","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is it not part of the standing rules that during the clause-by-clause consideration of a government bill, officials from the departments concerned normally remain before a committee as witnesses in order—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26eb550f615a7fc403495e94b61f6199e1c28f4f84be30e3687ef51ecbcfba77"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d3575e6b14570a3648173fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118821,"date":"2026-06-10T18:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"I think this is now a point of order. I would like to know who of the witnesses are here to provide technical explanations of the effect of individual clauses of the bill and the technical implications of proposed amendments. The questions I am asking are about the technical implications of proposed amendments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118821","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think this is now a point of order. I would like to know who of the witnesses are here to provide technical explanations of the effect of individual clauses of the bill and the technical implications of proposed amendments. The questions I am asking are about the technical implications of proposed amendments.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c4557668fbfdb44d80a376afb24f36ca58c9a1d1e0177e7a3dbce6cbe8a8c59"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba24e21d60c1f84a69a467f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118822,"date":"2026-06-10T19:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"What I'm hearing is that there are no officials who are able to explain how grade 11 economics work. I'm going to ask a different question. I'll turn to a different line of questioning.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118822","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What I'm hearing is that there are no officials who are able to explain how grade 11 economics work. I'm going to ask a different question. I'll turn to a different line of questioning.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4cbcf62c0b9941f48358037c97d200d299c9043fbd82c31031d58f7b1c5575b1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c748b8a57df6d8f0aece69a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118823,"date":"2026-06-10T19:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"It's not the ability of the officials. It's the decision as to who the—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118823","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's not the ability of the officials. It's the decision as to who the—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea7bc2283c41020f8716bf2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118824,"date":"2026-06-10T19:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"I am very happy to withdraw that comment. I think that the officials are more than capable of answering the questions that I have proposed. Let me ask a different question. In terms of the kinds of assets that are valued through the actuarial report, what does that asset mix look like? Are some of the assets liquid and some of them illiquid?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118824","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I am very happy to withdraw that comment. I think that the officials are more than capable of answering the questions that I have proposed. Let me ask a different question. In terms of the kinds of assets that are valued through the actuarial report, what does that asset mix look like? Are some of the assets liquid and some of them illiquid?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035156","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035156","label":"Personal assets","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9260bf260aa5bf57179c514e5a80a883e8222c7f21d36c773cee5e6fc5989248"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d366b3739be1a8d1cb142222","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118825,"date":"2026-06-10T19:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"In terms of the actuarial report, though, does the actuarial report review the different kinds of valuations that are done by CPP officials?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118825","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In terms of the actuarial report, though, does the actuarial report review the different kinds of valuations that are done by CPP officials?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","label":"Financial audit","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b43fc43453c0e756bcad365b20b470ba1adae24e3be9d0ea8ddaf145fbb0a77"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4fb430e493e33a83b105df69","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118826,"date":"2026-06-10T19:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"The question I was asking wasn't about the mix of the investments. Let's say we take an illiquid investment, like a bridge or something that's owned by CPP. There's obviously some kind of nominal value that's applied to that. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118826","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The question I was asking wasn't about the mix of the investments. Let's say we take an illiquid investment, like a bridge or something that's owned by CPP. There's obviously some kind of nominal value that's applied to that. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb50b0c96afa40e3c3a3ded1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118827,"date":"2026-06-10T19:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"The actuary reviews that, not in terms of the wisdom of holding that illiquid asset, but in terms of how the calculations that are done as to how it's valued. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118827","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The actuary reviews that, not in terms of the wisdom of holding that illiquid asset, but in terms of how the calculations that are done as to how it's valued. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","label":"Financial audit","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e4888be9951edc60ae5b6d620f2b49f1f853e01209c40531221a920fa086cea"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c4c5ec14962a114fab1f0862","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118828,"date":"2026-06-10T19:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"The question I have is, do the calculations get harder to make and harder to evaluate when...? Maybe the question should be restricted to whether they get harder to review when the assets are not liquid in the sense that there's not an actual market for them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118828","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The question I have is, do the calculations get harder to make and harder to evaluate when...? Maybe the question should be restricted to whether they get harder to review when the assets are not liquid in the sense that there's not an actual market for them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5aefd169f2a11a8e332fde6b147bf523a607772dd44c94334f6866cbd945481d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a9bfdca613cca976e426f2bbf31c0d6498490649330fef66d1098380a61af73"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ac6d2012a7e8b4c65689dfe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118829,"date":"2026-06-10T19:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Okay. Maybe the best thing for me to do, then, is.... It sounds as though the questions that I have as a parliamentarian are not able to be answered in this setting in the finance committee, and that's okay. It actually leads me back to the amendment and the subamendment. For the people who are watching at home, the reason we are proposing this amendment and subamendment, and the reason we'd like to have a report prepared that includes the things that we're talking about in the subamendment so that report can come to Parliament, is precisely so that we can ask the kinds of questions that I've been asking today. There are questions.... When I go back into my community and talk to people in my community, particularly in the environment that we are in right now, particularly when I talk to people at home who are concerned about their future and concerned about whether or not the CPPIB—CPP—can help them afford a retirement in which they can continue to live, and not even in the style they're accustomed to anymore—I think people are no longer focused on that—but in many cases, just not in their cars. On what they want to know, there's an increasing interest in how these things work. I get asked more and more mechanical questions about how CPP works. People want to know things like, \"With the amount of money that I paid in, why can't I get that amount of money out?\" There are a lot of technical questions asked. What this amendment—particularly the subamendment—does is require information to come to Parliament, where we can ask the kinds of questions that I've been asking this morning. With apologies to the officials that come here—I know they're doing their best to provide us with information—as the chair has quite rightly pointed out, they have limits in terms of the information they can provide and are often limited to the very specific subject matters and technical areas of expertise they have within their departments. This is the beauty of being able to ask questions of members of Parliament, ministers and parliamentary secretaries. Once we get into the House of Commons, one of the amazing things about the institution is that those limitations fall away. Members of the House are required to answer the questions that we ask in the chamber. If they don't answer those questions, they don't have.... I recognize that it's not a luxury, because I know that you would love to answer all of these questions and that you have the expertise to do it, but they don't have the restrictions—that's the word I'm looking for—that we have in these committees. To me, this really reinforces the reason we're asking for the amendment and the subamendment. I would like the opportunity to ask the minister the kinds of questions that I'm asking today. I think it is important to know how we get from the numbers that are in a report in any given year to more.... It's not that they're more realistic numbers, but they're longer-term numbers that relate to different points in time and allow us to really evaluate the health of the plan and the ability of parliamentarians or the plan.... It's really the ability of the plan to be able to withstand the kinds of adjustments we make to it when we change those contribution rates, whether we change them up or down, because while it's true that we've never lowered them before this, it doesn't mean that won't happen in the future. I mean, the government clearly was taking more money from Canadians than it should have been, which is why we're lowering the rates. What I'd like to see and to understand is not just how the nominal to inflationary works for some of the more liquid assets. As we know, the Canada pension plan has liquid assets in the terms of regular stocks and bonds, and it also has things that get traded on secondary markets, which means that sometimes they're easy to buy and sometimes they're harder to buy, depending on what's going on. The Canada pension plan also holds all kinds of illiquid assets that it has to evaluate. I'm going to stop there, Madam Chair, because I think I've made the point that I want to make. It's that when we're in committees like this and are restricted to all kinds of technical points, sometimes that whole picture doesn't come through. With the report that we are proposing and the subamendments that show some of the things that we'd like in that report, I really hope that my Liberal colleagues would also be as curious as we are about how the CPP works and how those things translate into things that ordinary Canadians and I, as an ordinary Canadian, care about, so that we can get better information and make sure our government is serving us all. Thank you very much for that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118829","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Maybe the best thing for me to do, then, is.... It sounds as though the questions that I have as a parliamentarian are not able to be answered in this setting in the finance committee, and that's okay. It actually leads me back to the amendment and the subamendment. For the people who are watching at home, the reason we are proposing this amendment and subamendment, and the reason we'd like ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f7c92816758dbd94ddf67e948dba7774d43928bfb094db96590db760fce86b64"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1e41bb518fd61cc8ae00340fe3c718fe86074a855c8811b6630dc3f7b253eb2a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db50b4035237bd8acb78b8e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118830,"date":"2026-06-10T19:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. The subamendment we're debating now is about making the minister's report practical and understandable to Canadians. To recap, the amendment before us would require the Minister of Finance to prepare a report on the impact—I'm getting there, I promise—of the CPP amendments contained in this division. That report would, of course, look at the financial state of the CPP and at contribution rates. Earlier subamendments dealt with the need for clear financial projections, real inflation-adjusted numbers and plain-language explanations of the CPP's long-term sustainability. What this subamendment does—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118830","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. The subamendment we're debating now is about making the minister's report practical and understandable to Canadians. To recap, the amendment before us would require the Minister of Finance to prepare a report on the impact—I'm getting there, I promise—of the CPP amendments contained in this division. That report would, of course, look at the financial state of the CPP and a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["093bed54458f7aa06fc32009d2cfdd620409e9d459a81d4e054c9383c545444d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21391de0c01cfcbe9018ce55fcc98e9e767a2908df27695cfc4da8951884b0ee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d540bc3840a75e8e69ee4bb4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118831,"date":"2026-06-10T20:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"The words that literally were coming out of my mouth when Mr. Turnbull made his point of order were \"this subamendment\". While I agree with you about repetition, and while I agree with you about the importance of the subamendment, when we are debating a subamendment and when people are trying to follow along at home, I would submit to you that it is not unreasonable to do a sentence or two at the beginning of the remarks in order to say, just for people following along at home, that this is the amendment and this is what it does and this is how the subamendment fits in. I also want to make the point that if I had been allowed to give my remarks, it would have literally been faster at this point.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118831","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The words that literally were coming out of my mouth when Mr. Turnbull made his point of order were \"this subamendment\". While I agree with you about repetition, and while I agree with you about the importance of the subamendment, when we are debating a subamendment and when people are trying to follow along at home, I would submit to you that it is not unreasonable to do a sentence or two at the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41b7f6089678f96813ba3db9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118832,"date":"2026-06-10T20:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"FINA","text":"Getting back to what I was going to say, what this subamendment does is it adds another important piece. It says that the report should \"include representative examples showing the estimated annual impact of the reduction in contribution rates on employees, employers and [people that are self-employed] at different levels of pensionable earnings, [specifically] including earnings of $50,000, $70,000 and the maximum pensionable earnings for the relevant year.\" In plain English, Madam Chair, what that means is that the government would have to show Canadians, through this subamendment, what the contribution rate reduction actually means for someone's paycheque or payroll costs. The reason this matters is that a phrase like \"a reduction in CPP contribution rates\" sounds technical. A phrase like \"40 basis points\" is technical. Many Canadians who are watching this committee at home may not know what that means in real life. They may not know whether it means five dollars, $50 or $500 a year to their paycheque. They may not know whether the benefit is the same for everyone or whether it changes depending on income. What this subamendment would require is that the government spell that out. It would require examples for an employee earning $50,000, an employee earning $70,000 and an employee earning the maximum pensionable earnings for the relevant year. It would also require examples for both employers and employees, and for self-employed persons. That's important because these groups are, of course, affected differently. For an employee, CPP contributions come off their paycheque. If the contribution rate is reduced, what that means is that the employee will see a slightly larger number at the bottom of their pay stub. For an employer, CPP contributions are a payroll cost. If the employment rate is reduced, or if it is increased at a different time, the cost of employing workers will go up or down depending on the direction of the change. For a self-employed person, of course, the impact is different again, because self-employed Canadians pay both the employee and the employer portions. They are both the worker and the employer for CPP purposes, so when the combined rate changes, they feel the full impact of that rate directly. These differences matter. A worker earning $50,000 and an employer employing someone who makes $50,000 are going to see a different dollar impact from someone who is earning $70,000, and of course, someone at maximum pensionable earnings is going to have the largest dollar impact in one direction or the other compared with an employee at the same earnings level, because, of course, they are either paying or receiving both shares, depending on the direction of the change. Canadians, I think, deserve to see those examples in clear terms, because, of course, as we know, Canadians care very much about CPP, because it is one of the main facilitators of retirement. Madam Chair, the reason this is a good subamendment is that it turns a policy change into something that people can understand. When a government announces a change to contribution rates, it can sound like a big deal in one direction or the other, but Canadians should be able to judge that claim for themselves, and they should be able to see what the change means in dollars per year for different types of workers and for businesses. The report should provide that information. If someone earning $50,000 receives a modest annual benefit, then the report should say that. If their deductions go up or down, the report should say that. It's the same for someone who's earning $70,000 a year and someone earning at the maximum pensionable level. I think that the decision to include those three levels in this subamendment is quite a reasonable thing to do, because we think it reflects the space in which many Canadians actually live their lives. If the employer receives a matching benefit, then the report should say that too. It's really important for businesses in this country to be able to understand the impact that the financial decisions we make in this place have on them, because it, of course, will assist them in their long-term planning in their businesses. Even more so, self-employed people often don't have the same resources available to them that businesses do, although small businesses have challenges as well. If a self-employed person receives that combined effect because they pay both sides, then that also should be shown clearly. We don't think that this is complicated, and we really don't think that it should be controversial, because it is exactly the kind of information that Canadians would expect from a government asking Parliament to approve changes to the CPP. The Canada pension plan, as we all know, is funded by contributions from workers, employers and self-employed Canadians. That means that the people who are paying into the plan should be able to see how a rate reduction affects them. The subamendment is also important, because it helps Canadians understand who benefits the most from the reduction. Because a contribution rate reduction is not the same as a flat payment to every Canadian, it doesn't help everyone in this country equally. First of all, it helps only people who are working and paying CPP contributions, and the dollar value depends on how much pensionable income they earn. A person who is unemployed will get no direct benefit from a change like the change that we are seeing being proposed here in this piece of legislation. That's really important, because when the government talks about wanting to help the people who are the hardest hit by the financial crisis that they've, quite frankly, created, it's important to know that those people are in fact receiving no direct benefit whatsoever from these proposals. A senior who's no longer working and is not paying CPP contributions also will get no direct benefit, despite the fact that this government claims to be concerned with those people. A low-income worker, in fact, gets a smaller dollar benefit than a high-income worker, and that actually makes these proposals in some ways regressive, because a worker earning closer to the maximum pensionable amount is going to get the largest dollar benefit from this. A self-employed person earning the same amount is going to see a larger direct effect, because they pay both the employee and the employer shares, but if they aren't employing very many people or they've had to lay people off because of the state of the economy, that is going to be diminished. These are not arguments against showing the examples. These are arguments for showing them, because these examples show the work of the government proposals, and they show Canadians what the impact is of these proposals on them. If the government wants to present this as affordability relief, then Canadians should be able to see how much relief is actually being offered and to whom. By the way, I would add that Canadians who are watching this at home will see the objections of our colleagues across the way to this and will be able to look at who wants to be able to provide them with this information and who does not want to provide them with this information. This is especially important at a time when many Canadians are struggling with the cost of living and paying more for groceries, rent, mortgages, gas, insurance and basic bills. A reduction in payroll deductions or an increase in payroll deductions is going to make a real impact, and while it might be welcome, people deserve honesty about the scale of the benefit. If the benefit turns out to be incredibly modest, then that is going to affect Canadians' views about whether or not this is effective. If employers benefit as well—if this is benefiting large corporations that employ a lot of people—then that's important to show as well. What we're trying to get across with both the amendment and the subamendments to this is that Canadians shouldn't have to guess. Canadians shouldn't have to figure out what their government is doing. They shouldn't have to go to 200-page actuarial reports. They should be getting this information in plain language, clearly, in a way that allows them to assess what their government is or is not doing for them. I would also add that the report and the subamendment with the content that we've asked for, including the subamendments and specifically this subamendment, could really help Parliament assess the trade-offs that are involved in this particular policy choice. At the moment, it's a reduction in the rates, but in a different budget—even under a different government, including a Conservative government—it could be an increase or a decrease. We've talked about that, so I'm not going to go into that in too much detail. There are short-term and long-term effects to this that other subamendments we have proposed and other things we want included in this report would get to. It's very important for Canadians to have visibility to CPPIB. It's CPP and CPPIB, for that matter, because Canadians care very much about how their money is managed. It is really important for Parliament to understand both sides of the ledger. This subamendment is one of the tools that will help them do that. One side of the report should tell us what this means for the plan. The other side of the report should tell us what this means for the people. That, Madam Chair, is balance, and that is the kind of balance we need. We don't think it's enough for CPP to say that it will collect less money or more money. By the way, when it collects less money, what Canadians really should read into that is that the government has actually miscalculated what it would need and is giving Canadians back some of their hard-earned money in this particular case, minus the administrative costs of running the numbers and actually getting the money back. What we've proposed through this subamendment is to know how much Canadians will save and which Canadians will see the largest savings. This is why we've picked the examples. It gives Canadians a range. It shows how the effect changes as income changes. It allows people to see where they fit into this government's priority. The subamendment makes sure the report answers those questions. This is particularly and especially important for self-employed Canadians. Many people don't realize that self-employed Canadians do pay both the employer and the employee CPP contributions, which is a significant cost. These are people running small businesses, doing contract work, freelancing, farming, working in trades, consulting and operating local services. It also includes some people who are piecing together income in ways that don't always fit the traditional employee model. For them, a CPP contribution rate change can have a different impact from the impact it has for a regular employee. If the government is changing those contribution rates, then the report should show the self-employed impact clearly, not bury it in a general statement. The same, quite frankly, goes for employers, because payroll costs matter. For a small business, the cost of employing someone is not just their wage. It includes CPP contributions, EI premiums, vacation pay, workers' compensation, benefits where offered, training costs, and other costs of keeping people employed. A reduction or an increase will affect employers. Parliament should know by how much. I would add that these numbers are going to be useful for provinces and municipalities. One of the major complaints of people who run businesses in this country is that very often, because of the way our federalism works, sometimes the left hand does not know what the right hand is doing. Inadvertently, the federal government, the provinces and sometimes municipalities come out with regulations, really in short order, that often amplify in unintended ways the impact of various provisions, including provisions like these. A small business owner doesn't think in basis points. Certainly, when I ran my business, I did not think in basis points. What we think about is payroll. We think in terms of whether we can afford another worker, another employee or another piece of equipment. In some cases, we're hearing from CFIB and other business organizations about the entrepreneurial drought in this country. People are thinking about whether or not they can afford to stay open for another month. That is why plain examples like the ones we are proposing through the subamendment matter. They matter because they limit spin and the announcement effect that we see so often from this government. Any government can describe a contribution reduction in a way that sounds incredible. It can say that it's reducing payroll costs. It can say that it's helping workers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118832","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Getting back to what I was going to say, what this subamendment does is it adds another important piece. It says that the report should \"include representative examples showing the estimated annual impact of the reduction in contribution rates on employees, employers and [people that are self-employed] at different levels of pensionable earnings, [specifically] including earnings of $50,000, $70,0","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9ce7a75ff9ec24e84fd462089bc86a88823dbfc279789336f6105ab3a5aab3d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92316b57adb20a772eaff4580f9dc435775d967f6a415e0755fb158c639ae138"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7ec10c6bea2f51b0dab62ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086113,"date":"2026-06-10T22:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am grateful for the chance to finish my remarks about Bill C-265, an act to amend the Food and Drugs Act regarding a list of therapeutic products pre-approved for special access.\n\nIn the interregnum between the first and second half of my remarks, members of my community sought me out to discuss how the bill would apply in complex cases. They reminded me of some things that should be considered at committee.\n\nFirst, we should avoid loopholes that could unintentionally weaken Canada's drug approval framework or allow inappropriate products to bypass proper scrutiny. Parliament should closely examine how products would qualify for inclusion on the proposed pre-approved list. While the bill references foreign approvals and clinical evidence, committee members should ensure that those standards are clearly defined and appropriately rigorous. \n\nCommittee members should also study how oversight would function once a product is granted special access. If adverse outcomes occur, what reporting mechanisms would exist? How would Health Canada monitor safety data? Would there be transparency requirements so that Canadians can understand how these decisions are being made? Those are all reasonable questions.\n\nAnother issue that deserves scrutiny is whether pharmaceutical companies could exploit the system in unintended ways. Compassionate access programs should exist for patients, not as alternative market entry strategies for manufacturers seeking to avoid the normal approval process. Parliament should ensure that the bill would not inadvertently create incentives for companies to delay seeking full Canadian approval while still gaining widespread access through an expedited pathway.\n\nLikewise, safeguards should ensure that access remains focused on exceptional circumstances involving serious or life-threatening conditions where comparable approved Canadian therapies do not exist. \n\nClinical judgment really matters in medicine, and I appreciate that the bill acknowledges the role that physicians play in emergency decision-making. However, clear guardrails would still be necessary to maintain public confidence and consistent application across the country. \n\nWe should also acknowledge that access alone does not solve every problem. Many advanced therapies are extremely expensive. Some treatments for rare diseases cost hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars annually. Families already struggling emotionally should not be left facing impossible financial uncertainty after finally obtaining access to therapy. That broader conversation around affordability, provincial coverage and rare disease strategy must continue alongside the bill.\n\nOne thing I hope we can all agree on is that Canadians facing devastating diagnoses should not feel abandoned by their health care system. At the same time, Canadians also expect Parliament to proceed carefully when it comes to medical safety and regulatory oversight. Those principles are not in conflict. \n\nCommittee work exists precisely for bills like this one. It allows Parliament to hear from physicians, rare disease advocates, pharmacologists, regulators, patient groups, ethicists and health care administrators. It allows members to test assumptions, identify weaknesses and strengthen legislation before it advances further. It also allows parliamentarians to hear from patients. Perhaps committee study will reveal areas where the bill should be amended. Perhaps stronger oversight mechanisms will be needed. Perhaps definitions will need tightening to prevent unintended consequences. That is not a flaw in the legislative process. That is the legislative process working as it should.\n\nI also believe that Canadians are increasingly frustrated when Parliament simply shuts down debate at the outset rather than engaging constructively with proposals that may have merit. I think we will see some of that shutting down today on other matters. We should be willing to study good-faith ideas seriously, especially when they concern patients facing life-threatening illnesses.\n\nIn closing, this is an issue that Parliament should be willing to study seriously, because if we can respond and reduce delays in a responsible manner, especially for cases that are exceptional, and empower physicians while maintaining strong safeguards, then Canadians will thank us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086113","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am grateful for the chance to finish my remarks about Bill C-265, an act to amend the Food and Drugs Act regarding a list of therapeutic products pre-approved for special access.\n\nIn the interregnum between the first and second half of my remarks, members of my community sought me out to discuss how the bill would apply in complex cases. They reminded me of some things that should b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a19f572686f86e2e440d6fd63ff65ec87467d963b994a56130526ff731d5b798"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8404459dc25908972e75565030a690f760b90ede96039c42792572f1b468bf37"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0693d770621d31ffaf03bb0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086114,"date":"2026-06-11T03:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as the parliamentary secretary explained in her very clear speech, Bill C-25 would create new rules around knowingly false or misleading election information. I have been doing some reading because the Prime Minister is a fan of Václav Havel. I learned that his first full-length play that was ever publicly performed is quite relevant to this debate. It is entitled The Garden Party. It warns us about systems where official language becomes so polished and circular that people stop asking what is actually true, and people become sort of fluent in a kind of nonsense.\n\nI am wondering if the member could elaborate on the exact guardrails that she would support to make sure the bill targets deception and—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086114","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as the parliamentary secretary explained in her very clear speech, Bill C-25 would create new rules around knowingly false or misleading election information. I have been doing some reading because the Prime Minister is a fan of Václav Havel. I learned that his first full-length play that was ever publicly performed is quite relevant to this debate. It is entitled The Garden Party. It","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["70866c291f9724aa2a656f474909f6ee9232f2ff19279ac99c11618ee9072e46"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33d3a4dbe30056da39242501","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086115,"date":"2026-06-11T03:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have just received this report that the House has adjourned or maybe will adjourn in the near future. I wonder if the member can comment on what the consequences of that would be for summer by-elections, particularly if this bill is not passed, but even if it is passed, in terms of issues that Canadians really care about, like foreign interference?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086115","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have just received this report that the House has adjourned or maybe will adjourn in the near future. I wonder if the member can comment on what the consequences of that would be for summer by-elections, particularly if this bill is not passed, but even if it is passed, in terms of issues that Canadians really care about, like foreign interference?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4e63784d107897f31043110701c2c8d08db276d367387244b8fa8311c4f7f485"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95560e0cb48c2af870c37dfb20759233fbbfdcf773c39b6b36e1f5ccf609793a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a36ea9670f67d9cbf2d95a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118867,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you so much. We're going to try to do this at the speed of cyber. You talked about the need for prevention and described telecoms, banks and financial institutions as.... Is it fair to say that they're supportive and responsive but largely reactive?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118867","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you so much. We're going to try to do this at the speed of cyber. You talked about the need for prevention and described telecoms, banks and financial institutions as.... Is it fair to say that they're supportive and responsive but largely reactive?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d430c65a049123e2091526f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118868,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"No, I'm sorry. It's on the responding side when a scam is happening.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118868","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, I'm sorry. It's on the responding side when a scam is happening.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","label":"Forgery","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc894973bb707519c87350f6c876bd596bbb5a19b45c2657f4462318ce7fe79d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30456df5a4abe55ef0bb26ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118869,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"Let me ask this. Is there anything that stops a scam or a text call from getting through?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118869","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Let me ask this. Is there anything that stops a scam or a text call from getting through?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56887","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Electronic commerce","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56887","label":"Electronic commerce","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["344a1524bd2ce7669acc2e148db5668d047a923c532f0844f29ac54f1b3a68d7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9df8397d4ef068146ca493322d1026493e377f166a1a699ca007adfb137f2ac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-516bcc6439e112cdb4eb2daf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118870,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"Is it happening through voluntary action, or is happening through regulation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118870","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is it happening through voluntary action, or is happening through regulation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["350bd9d18d59bc67d875086e23e1577665697ae9c0dbecded19c50d5c37c9c3b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9c6efcd1d9cc757ee7753f74","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118871,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"Do you know of anything that actually requires telecom companies to report how much scam traffic either is going on in real time or is moving through their networks?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47983","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118871","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you know of anything that actually requires telecom companies to report how much scam traffic either is going on in real time or is moving through their networks?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47983","label":"Telecommunications networks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47983","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","label":"Human trafficking","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47983","label":"Telecommunications networks","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d0d9c9973f29529d29de550cb1ac64c5139b619c88b8126573e16caffc48c5e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47983","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ba648ad47a21c9ccfa65955486042634e9a3813444f9a533a276abb00ca80e5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47983","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47983","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af12c96ececf8148d09eed57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118872,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"Are there gaps?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118872","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Are there gaps?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17604ecc76eeb2f280dc43ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118873,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"Do you have any recommendations on what the federal government can do, using our telecommunications power, to take positive and concrete action that we're not already currently doing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118873","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you have any recommendations on what the federal government can do, using our telecommunications power, to take positive and concrete action that we're not already currently doing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Concrete","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","label":"Concrete","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb83e2a155887fd7b3ed6c161ac0ae3c18ee26c960825c683cb9e04f74a4cf21"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b1ccfdbcc64f52372489a7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118874,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"In that case, could you use just the last few seconds that we have together to give some advice to the folks in my riding who are scared about this happening? What are the warning signs and what should they do first?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118874","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In that case, could you use just the last few seconds that we have together to give some advice to the folks in my riding who are scared about this happening? What are the warning signs and what should they do first?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather warnings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50395","label":"Weather warnings","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6dfbfadd83b2f2a70a8f5d6ae01fa066ec122050c30893bd52e7afa64954dfd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-796b38e5a71a379310d73cc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118875,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"Thanks so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118875","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thanks so much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43c296f079832339ba856e73","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118876,"date":"2026-06-11T18:40:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"Thanks so much. Mr. Smith, I'm going to ask you a few questions. I thought you put it really well when you said that the system has moved to attacking the people who are using the systems—as opposed to attacking the systems—and getting the clients to move money. Of course, the big challenge with that is that it's happening at the speed of cyber. There has been a huge focus on trying to get data after the fact, but prevention, at this point, is largely reactive. Is that fair?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118876","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thanks so much. Mr. Smith, I'm going to ask you a few questions. I thought you put it really well when you said that the system has moved to attacking the people who are using the systems—as opposed to attacking the systems—and getting the clients to move money. Of course, the big challenge with that is that it's happening at the speed of cyber. There has been a huge focus on trying to get data af","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7513ce1b0462b4778283f7e36df7d0b42630e32536c534d4d57260442e078386"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2462fb09648a3fea1ab28cafa595fd6b692b2a468fd763fd05c1be71866b2f5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9268fff50cd91996f1e5a417","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118877,"date":"2026-06-11T18:40:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"Of course, the hard part for you is that the financial institutions really are the face of this. When someone finds out that they've been scammed, the first place they call is the financial institution. In many investment scams, once the money is sent, especially if it's sent through crypto or some kind of offshore platform, recovery is virtually impossible. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118877","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Of course, the hard part for you is that the financial institutions really are the face of this. When someone finds out that they've been scammed, the first place they call is the financial institution. In many investment scams, once the money is sent, especially if it's sent through crypto or some kind of offshore platform, recovery is virtually impossible. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6bc604355efe3a7eaacc8ceeed0a09ce5dbaed15651733de225bb0d8c372392f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b048e7badb14c2533c49e7fdfaac6ae4b0bda70c22f18a0638e623288fc329f4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f6546ce013b214ced24d302","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118878,"date":"2026-06-11T18:40:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"From a systems perspective, you do try to do some proactive things, but from a legislative perspective, the system's still really dependent on the victim spotting the fraud and reporting it after the fact. Is that fair?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118878","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"From a systems perspective, you do try to do some proactive things, but from a legislative perspective, the system's still really dependent on the victim spotting the fraud and reporting it after the fact. Is that fair?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc675b101cacef8850251117b7760d822313a041aad567745d00beca67f2f97c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2825ca67513d28a723972cb6cc1bbd68a57f82ea706462337a0b7089f8e6bc6d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce08d50bfc8834f1e797b5bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118879,"date":"2026-06-11T18:40:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"That's really helpful to know. As a financial institution, do you have any way to police things like big investment ads, other than having someone sit there and behave like the user?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118879","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's really helpful to know. As a financial institution, do you have any way to police things like big investment ads, other than having someone sit there and behave like the user?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","label":"Personal finance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8207c72faaac33a26eb4c676d0b561e0d4cc75e3c97699ef43b7cc3a92a439a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11bcbdb267e5c06ca0295cb1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118880,"date":"2026-06-11T18:40:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"When you talk about the things that you can control, is there anyone who has control over those fraudulent ads and whether or not they're going to appear? Is it the telcos? Who's in the best place to be able to prevent that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118880","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"When you talk about the things that you can control, is there anyone who has control over those fraudulent ads and whether or not they're going to appear? Is it the telcos? Who's in the best place to be able to prevent that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","label":"Forgery","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["862cbbb8bd24cbbd5da4622327e3bb6de67020d88750525bc408e96775ebf1cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e6e5f148dd6f21d087deb5cf15c734c4b02a8f6135e6800ad483e25bfbe6f479"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c976357abb5a889a887122c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118881,"date":"2026-06-11T18:40:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"What do you think the most effective way would be for us, using our federal telecommunications power, to bring all the parties together and, in a compulsory way, address some of the issues that Mr. Quinn brought up and some of the things that you're seeing in terms of losses?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118881","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What do you think the most effective way would be for us, using our federal telecommunications power, to bring all the parties together and, in a compulsory way, address some of the issues that Mr. Quinn brought up and some of the things that you're seeing in terms of losses?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ef9d3c89b9a735a7c22ea5adc14166e4634d19be1d2e84c78b9e1b88efe87d90"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f964d72695f16eb3ea6e019f5b5fe66458d352464c7ae961a271dad15bd2210"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-761a2e798da3b8526ead8000","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118882,"date":"2026-06-11T18:45:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"We see the government moving in a number of different bills, which are sometimes hard to follow, to try to deal with some of the things online. Is there anything in any current legislation that really helps get at the heart of this problem?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118882","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We see the government moving in a number of different bills, which are sometimes hard to follow, to try to deal with some of the things online. Is there anything in any current legislation that really helps get at the heart of this problem?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["70a92b858030644457cfdfbcd756654ee174df2808f9b48e696906427f2d2899"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e8de7209c595b8e443723ed0eb9de62b51a6c44bf4e1c22c576c538e7963d0f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4483d9c2c8987a5b3ba6f3df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118883,"date":"2026-06-11T18:45:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118883","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank so much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83c48b3079c9e6034a2bd98f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086112,"date":"2026-06-11T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague asked a serious question and she deserves a serious answer.\n\nThe position of Canada's independent ombudsman for responsible enterprise has sat vacant for a year. Open cases have stalled, and as a result, victims of modern slavery and exploitation are blocked from justice.\n\nCan the minister tell then House the date for when this important position will be filled, and by whom?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086112","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague asked a serious question and she deserves a serious answer.\n\nThe position of Canada's independent ombudsman for responsible enterprise has sat vacant for a year. Open cases have stalled, and as a result, victims of modern slavery and exploitation are blocked from justice.\n\nCan the minister tell then House the date for when this important position will be filled, and by wh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","label":"Human trafficking","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3887eea05eebde60bb4a27d7e7c590667ec40101e5ce5e76d0c212255af2c951"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41492708fdfac07ab71d784e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118938,"date":"2026-06-11T21:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much for welcoming me to this committee. I'm delighted to be here on such an auspicious day—your birthday. It's interesting to hear the first witness who was here talk about the fact that some people see the proposed changes, the amendment and the subamendment, as limiting the discretion of the judge, or the Privacy Commissioner seems to have proposed it in order to expand the discretion of the judge. Mr. Wong, could you elaborate on that a little bit?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118938","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much for welcoming me to this committee. I'm delighted to be here on such an auspicious day—your birthday. It's interesting to hear the first witness who was here talk about the fact that some people see the proposed changes, the amendment and the subamendment, as limiting the discretion of the judge, or the Privacy Commissioner seems to have proposed it in order to expand the discr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85072159c8d578e33381189c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118939,"date":"2026-06-11T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"As you probably know, there has been great concern about the scope of this bill within our communities. I'm sure that I'm not alone in this room in terms of having received hundreds of emails about this bill. Can you explain a little bit about why you think this is a reasonable limit?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118939","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"As you probably know, there has been great concern about the scope of this bill within our communities. I'm sure that I'm not alone in this room in terms of having received hundreds of emails about this bill. Can you explain a little bit about why you think this is a reasonable limit?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ffa203802b97de35622b50e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118940,"date":"2026-06-11T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"It's interesting that you would say \"usually criminals\". You and I are both lawyers. I don't know whether most of the people who are watching this are lawyers or not, but you talked about certain information that the police have to provide in order to get the judicial order. Can you provide some examples of the kind of information that they have to provide? I think that would go a long way towards reassuring people in our communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118940","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's interesting that you would say \"usually criminals\". You and I are both lawyers. I don't know whether most of the people who are watching this are lawyers or not, but you talked about certain information that the police have to provide in order to get the judicial order. Can you provide some examples of the kind of information that they have to provide? I think that would go a long way towards","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b2ab46a5b1a86bc8fbf99f9a3ac8c049cc4df36c9add837c41ddec0afb426154"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cca5db3b0df5b48f73bf73ec08fe5e87ff8648579b0317428d3123154262dad7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09941615cf0312c266768b0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118941,"date":"2026-06-11T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"It's interesting that you would use the example of phones. One of the things that I'm constantly hearing about in terms of the concern is the year's worth of metadata that is potentially going to be collected under this. I'm wondering two things. First, in the case of phone numbers, to the extent that a person has had a phone number for years and has a network of contacts in their phone, can you explain why you would need a year's worth of metadata to be able to get that kind of information?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118941","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's interesting that you would use the example of phones. One of the things that I'm constantly hearing about in terms of the concern is the year's worth of metadata that is potentially going to be collected under this. I'm wondering two things. First, in the case of phone numbers, to the extent that a person has had a phone number for years and has a network of contacts in their phone, can you e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9776ce37076574a18142188996ac4bf61dcee0cfc8a712a5b902ca75bb79bbdc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bb1d9aaa2c686953f538203","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118942,"date":"2026-06-11T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Just before we—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118942","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just before we—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-588c21d7bbbc1b210d2fb52e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118943,"date":"2026-06-11T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I'll leave that for now. I want to ask a different question specifically about that kind of situation with the phone numbers. Forgive me if I'm wrong, but is it not prevalent for people who are engaged in organized crime to use burner phones specifically for this reason, which is so that their information isn't available?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118943","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll leave that for now. I want to ask a different question specifically about that kind of situation with the phone numbers. Forgive me if I'm wrong, but is it not prevalent for people who are engaged in organized crime to use burner phones specifically for this reason, which is so that their information isn't available?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","label":"Whistleblower protection","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8e3352600cd589b5cb6207035392677e8a69685693878053752409007fb8195"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fb86a534a2b5f1bae1c4dd7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118944,"date":"2026-06-11T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"In terms of the utility, you used an example of being able to get phone numbers. We've established that many of those people use burner phones, so that's probably an example of limited utility. Can you give a different example that might be more relatable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118944","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In terms of the utility, you used an example of being able to get phone numbers. We've established that many of those people use burner phones, so that's probably an example of limited utility. Can you give a different example that might be more relatable?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["432ab867156ee302884bd9e90033855644f10a01c01c648b6b6df04f1ba55e75"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ce57b22695d7cc8b93328c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118945,"date":"2026-06-11T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Just so I have it straight in my head, can you explain what the delta is between the data that would be involved without the Bloc amendment, the data that is involved with the Bloc amendment and the data that's in the subamendment? What does the delta look like? Operationally, what are we doing here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118945","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just so I have it straight in my head, can you explain what the delta is between the data that would be involved without the Bloc amendment, the data that is involved with the Bloc amendment and the data that's in the subamendment? What does the delta look like? Operationally, what are we doing here?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transborder data flow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036624","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal digital assistant","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036624","label":"Personal digital assistant","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","label":"Transborder data flow","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c9ec9d36f28fd8e0ba3d2786f7a12c433177cadffba7bbe40e94234e9476821"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-352fccc5223cf85b3e15a602","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118946,"date":"2026-06-11T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"If I could turn to one of the RCMP witnesses, can you translate... I apologize. I'm so used to this happening automatically. I want to thank all the people who are assisting us today—all of the translators, the technical people and everyone who's here. This is my first term as an elected official, and these are really long and intense weeks. You are the people who are making it possible for us to do this work. We're very grateful for that. Could one of the witnesses from the RCMP translate what I understand legally into the practical and operational implications? What information don't you get from this, as a result of this amendment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118946","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If I could turn to one of the RCMP witnesses, can you translate... I apologize. I'm so used to this happening automatically. I want to thank all the people who are assisting us today—all of the translators, the technical people and everyone who's here. This is my first term as an elected official, and these are really long and intense weeks. You are the people who are making it possible for us to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59927","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military police","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59927","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Military police","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59927","label":"Military police","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1189501008782cefac95503bc4de714fcb3d5123fc2731aced4d3d7fc27ef74c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39f6a4855f4b555756cbc83c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118947,"date":"2026-06-11T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Just following up on that, as you're speaking I'm running through some of the emails that I get from people in my community about this bill specifically. There's a lot of talk about—and we've been focusing on this idea—asking for a judicial order stage, and we're thinking about what kind of information we're looking for in that context. How do we get here? You talked about multiple devices being used for a fraud from the same location. How does this come across your desk in the first place? Is this one of those situations where someone has reported a crime and you're doing an investigation? Or is it something that you would initiate on your own? If I could ask you to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118947","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just following up on that, as you're speaking I'm running through some of the emails that I get from people in my community about this bill specifically. There's a lot of talk about—and we've been focusing on this idea—asking for a judicial order stage, and we're thinking about what kind of information we're looking for in that context. How do we get here? You talked about multiple devices being u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-94a4c5990279edf1dcc349a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118948,"date":"2026-06-11T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes. I would like to ask some questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118948","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes. I would like to ask some questions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf18b94d2b498db833138d98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118949,"date":"2026-06-11T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. When we broke, I think we'd talked a little bit and had some legal discussions about the differences between the wording of the clauses in the original bill and the amendments, and again in terms of the subamendments. I would invite our witnesses here from the RCMP to talk a little bit more about what that practical difference is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118949","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. When we broke, I think we'd talked a little bit and had some legal discussions about the differences between the wording of the clauses in the original bill and the amendments, and again in terms of the subamendments. I would invite our witnesses here from the RCMP to talk a little bit more about what that practical difference is.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","label":"Whistleblower protection","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b2a276efb9375dceee9507922429c55e2a9ded31a0ac244b705aa08a39c6bc03"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0ca8520e1355c930378b37e6812999766d85b08957e977cf8dcd1a630729088"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2defc99c3dd8cf02455e8e3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118950,"date":"2026-06-11T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I apologize for interrupting you. When they say \"defrauded at a bank\", do they mean a complaint of being defrauded that they're making to the bank, or is it a complaint of being defrauded by the bank?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118950","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I apologize for interrupting you. When they say \"defrauded at a bank\", do they mean a complaint of being defrauded that they're making to the bank, or is it a complaint of being defrauded by the bank?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["56bc5d85b014fbc2270b96423263cd9f49780cf6c8128d5fa0af8debbd8e0f4a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["44483c257570bd1a762237cbd8a8c720b61056ab97e9d99528992a7e81e97a8d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85ced084809c3a89766ea69a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118951,"date":"2026-06-11T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118951","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-127fe35a15b04235008b7720","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118952,"date":"2026-06-11T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Do you mean that the bank might say, \"You're right. The sum of $12,000 has been withdrawn from your account, but our records show that you did that on Friday in person here at the bank\"?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118952","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you mean that the bank might say, \"You're right. The sum of $12,000 has been withdrawn from your account, but our records show that you did that on Friday in person here at the bank\"?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fdf65b951ed02bab7d195f9765f73fb96bdc4de4ecfbfe9a5224768f375c7f30"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["12f647d6c6fe73d0dd7904df89cf63ba9c2288bd1042d7c4f569610d48575559"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6801684c3fab2c9e9574df10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118953,"date":"2026-06-11T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"When you say, \"the subscriber information associated with those IP addresses,\" that means that you have the IP addresses, and you geolocate them, presumably.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118953","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"When you say, \"the subscriber information associated with those IP addresses,\" that means that you have the IP addresses, and you geolocate them, presumably.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035978","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Intranets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035978","label":"Intranets","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8f8e305a12e7bfed45b30333e36b5759ba0c1419e3190cd5a188569a840dd69"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9570a4882e91c679131ebae8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118954,"date":"2026-06-11T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"How do you get from having IP addresses to looking for subscriber information?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118954","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How do you get from having IP addresses to looking for subscriber information?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Websites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","label":"Websites","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["536bc5821d4ce8903f39bbf9ad8188bd1a44b2cfe43866ce157a0ddbe94ed48f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2501e59b3d2162836a0d2f42","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118955,"date":"2026-06-11T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"How do you get from there to this clause?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118955","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How do you get from there to this clause?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed9f4b59d813c0da85985f26e922e5b3de081879627dca138e9f048a36fb605c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa3550abfc6ec2357108fbaa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118956,"date":"2026-06-11T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"What you're saying is that you can ask the bank for a production order, but you can't just ask Shaw or Telus or Rogers for a production order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118956","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What you're saying is that you can ask the bank for a production order, but you can't just ask Shaw or Telus or Rogers for a production order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f1d2127a363da86b62929730957431e38b346800d986b45ef2bf5dd42b5fffc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac99ce8dc1453c5c34a08645","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118957,"date":"2026-06-11T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"With regard to the kind of example you're laying out, let's say I have a bank branch in my community where five seniors have gone in that week who are all missing money from their accounts. When the bank goes and does its internal investigation, they realize that in all five withdrawals, the same IP addresses were used. They call you. Now you are trying to figure out where the next piece is on the trail of breadcrumbs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118957","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"With regard to the kind of example you're laying out, let's say I have a bank branch in my community where five seniors have gone in that week who are all missing money from their accounts. When the bank goes and does its internal investigation, they realize that in all five withdrawals, the same IP addresses were used. They call you. Now you are trying to figure out where the next piece is on the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d2cf5c9e39d0114e74044aa3fea535ce3d23741d52fc9be4c9e61a41ea660da6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9448513f0242c1e98c5fe5a6ad4f44d32322c77df508ffa1d65f90f946208fb3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d82c43858ebd4c80e7d7f29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118958,"date":"2026-06-11T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"What are the limits now in terms of associating those IP addresses with a device that this part 1, and specifically this section, is trying to address so that we can tie it to the subamendment? I always want to be relevant.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118958","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What are the limits now in terms of associating those IP addresses with a device that this part 1, and specifically this section, is trying to address so that we can tie it to the subamendment? I always want to be relevant.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48748","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48748","label":"Computer networks","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3913b8c9cef4fba253e9ad6637ed8a45f3a231ecd6d12c401fcfb7e9198185b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4fb005f47e3ea1ed38d54b62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118959,"date":"2026-06-11T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. In terms of this subamendment, it lays out a list of things. The way the bill was originally drafted, the idea was that law enforcement could simply go to a judge and say, \"I'm looking for subscriber information and I want all of it\", or say, \"I just want subscriber information; give me an order for subscriber information.\" Then the Bloc amendment said, well, we're going to limit it to subscriber information specified in the order. Mr. Housefather's subamendment now says that the order can only compel production of subscriber information that is in the Criminal Code definition of subscriber information. Let me ask you this: Is this an exhaustive menu, or is this where, when you go for the order, you just need to specify what it is and the judge will decide whether or not your list is a good list or a bad list? Is there a limit to the menu here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118959","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. In terms of this subamendment, it lays out a list of things. The way the bill was originally drafted, the idea was that law enforcement could simply go to a judge and say, \"I'm looking for subscriber information and I want all of it\", or say, \"I just want subscriber information; give me an order for subscriber information.\" Then the Bloc amendment said, well, we're going to limit it to subsc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc3d9baf6be41ed4428ecb9c8e7185800e3096d04cbf0bfabf7708a3d4953bad"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ae372669213606fb88446f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118960,"date":"2026-06-11T22:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"In this case, is it reasonable to say, then, that Mr. Housefather's subamendment here would not only provide greater privacy protection, but it would also help law enforcement be more specific about what they're looking for?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118960","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In this case, is it reasonable to say, then, that Mr. Housefather's subamendment here would not only provide greater privacy protection, but it would also help law enforcement be more specific about what they're looking for?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f33bf62e4384f80bc13dae82911b4fdcd3131794f7830716cc5369f2aaee3be0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39888696b65ded45b9f18264","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118961,"date":"2026-06-11T22:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I just want to be clear. Again, it's interesting. During the break while we were voting, I got a text from a constituent who said that she was watching. She said some nice things, which is lovely. She's continuing to be concerned about this legislation. She's finding this conversation to be helpful in explaining it, which is nice to hear. It's good to know that the work that we're doing here, if we have you through the afternoon and the evening, is going to be a benefit to people who are trying to understand what's happening in this bill. It's very nice to hear from people. I'm really glad that the people in my community are engaged with this. You have really helped people who are worried. There's been so much confusion between part 1 and part 2 of the bill. We are in part 1 of the bill. As our friends across the table know, one of the things that we've proposed and would like to see is this bill split in order to help Canadians understand that there's this one type of activity going on over here, and there's a different activity going on over there that requires more scrutiny. In this part of the bill, you've done a nice job of explaining the fact that this comes to you because it is initiated. There are reasonable grounds. There is a standard. We may have a bit of a discussion about that in further subamendments and amendments. There is a standard that is applied, and it is a legal standard, so it's not just a fishing expedition. You have to go to a judge. You are going to have to specify that information. The judge is there as a check on what information is allowed to be provided. There are standards of review of your information that come with that. This part might be one of the most important parts that I'd like to hear more from you on. The data is already in the provider's possession or control when the order is received. Can you elaborate on that and talk about how that differs from the kind of data collection and activities that are talked about in part 2 of the bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118961","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I just want to be clear. Again, it's interesting. During the break while we were voting, I got a text from a constituent who said that she was watching. She said some nice things, which is lovely. She's continuing to be concerned about this legislation. She's finding this conversation to be helpful in explaining it, which is nice to hear. It's good to know that the work that we're doing here, if w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90f9c564a605caf7399b9009bf6a07eacfe3263766e731622fb7c4dd9bf95a9f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25c9ba723598d714cfdc14a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118962,"date":"2026-06-11T22:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"First, let's explain it with an eye to being able to differentiate it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118962","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"First, let's explain it with an eye to being able to differentiate it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","label":"Explorations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75df8681b8808063007bd23ad858901515694fe3fb3d80aa70e282e03d4dd598"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-266b10c0164f024d0fe76074","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118963,"date":"2026-06-11T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"That's fair, but when you're talking about network functioning information, for example, that's not information that goes to whether or not a crime has been committed. That's not the kind of information you'd be looking for here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118963","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's fair, but when you're talking about network functioning information, for example, that's not information that goes to whether or not a crime has been committed. That's not the kind of information you'd be looking for here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["348dd08bdf643a030b2c021d93170ec15cc7c14fbee1f78398bdc296910e90c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62d19d968eda5cbb75159952","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118964,"date":"2026-06-11T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I really appreciate the comment. I would like to respond in French, but I'm quite tired. I imagine that you are too. I'm asking about the part of Mr. Housefather's subamendment that talks about the Criminal Code's definition of \"subscriber information\", which specifically includes information that's already in the provider's possession or control when the order is received. What I'm trying to parse through is the question of what information is in the subscriber's control and what information isn't in the subscriber's control. I realize that you had a very long discussion about this in the more general sense of it, but since we are discussing the subamendment, I'm trying to zero in on the information that's relevant to the subamendment from that subset. Does that help?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118964","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I really appreciate the comment. I would like to respond in French, but I'm quite tired. I imagine that you are too. I'm asking about the part of Mr. Housefather's subamendment that talks about the Criminal Code's definition of \"subscriber information\", which specifically includes information that's already in the provider's possession or control when the order is received. What I'm trying to pars","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7bd5e037dd2811f9ec2cf3ec78b46351b77dc7925f32bbd3e7565ecaccaafca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33b181838f9157145abd7418","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118965,"date":"2026-06-11T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. This is in the interest of making it easier for people at home to understand exactly what we are debating with respect to this subamendment because, as you know—you've been here for the conversations—people are very worried about what information is going and what information isn't going. It's the kind of information that is being asked for in this section. Please zero in, as per the chair's request, on the kind of subscriber information that would be retained. It was really helpful to point out that banks are already retaining your records. We want banks to retain our records. When we have to do our taxes, sometimes it's frustrating because you can only get so much digitally, and you have to make requests for records. It's what kind of subscriber information you would be asking for from different kinds of service providers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118965","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. This is in the interest of making it easier for people at home to understand exactly what we are debating with respect to this subamendment because, as you know—you've been here for the conversations—people are very worried about what information is going and what information isn't going. It's the kind of information that is being asked for in this section. Please zero in, as per the ch","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8e468cf4c78f8070986e16b14583315da5c5c3d71d7b228a3a575afb0c69bde4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7f15f585b683ada87122e45fc9df99181eb823c3af3a7479987243df5647d4d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-394d5838c1c4505dcd60134f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118966,"date":"2026-06-11T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Do you think most people know that this information is being saved by telecommunications providers? There's a very small number of telecommunications providers in the country. It's something we complain about on a regular basis. One of the things you said earlier was that one of the challenges with these orders was not knowing what information those providers save. It sounds like you actually know a lot about what kind of information they save. Does it really vary? Do the different phone companies really differ that much in the types of information they keep?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118966","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you think most people know that this information is being saved by telecommunications providers? There's a very small number of telecommunications providers in the country. It's something we complain about on a regular basis. One of the things you said earlier was that one of the challenges with these orders was not knowing what information those providers save. It sounds like you actually know","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["adcabf6fcd6d9ce3f3f6184ca05606a10f247f403fce6540a278c06622e03b22"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8a7941bae373d58dce854e7ff1de0dfa098985aa3e5915184efe125168c89aa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4eb25f8efd73f4f67e1c65d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118967,"date":"2026-06-11T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"How does this subamendment help you with them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118967","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How does this subamendment help you with them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30c05233f309d547b309eee0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118968,"date":"2026-06-11T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"How do these judicial orders help you with those companies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118968","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How do these judicial orders help you with those companies?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13c09d631c528f62e417ea49ed9b6f90d0bf494ca9a1420b1a8697a9078eb275"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aba1965f934f0a30ea60a16c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118969,"date":"2026-06-11T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Then you do end up having some data normalization issues.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118969","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Then you do end up having some data normalization issues.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752353","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Automation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","label":"Data processing","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752353","label":"Automation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76726938dff9a9e3feef93ac52bf92bfe56350e21ad1834133319cfa0ff1ebea"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1f745b6db992fc1a9d6e52c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118970,"date":"2026-06-11T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Well, that's the idea that this company calls this field X, but it's named Y in that company. We have to look at the data and figure out what it is and then match it up to the other field in the other spreadsheet. Say that we're looking for first name, or we're looking for a name, and this company has first name, last name, but this one just has it all in one field, and normalization helps. When you normalize it, you build little programs that help you figure out how to split it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118970","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Well, that's the idea that this company calls this field X, but it's named Y in that company. We have to look at the data and figure out what it is and then match it up to the other field in the other spreadsheet. Say that we're looking for first name, or we're looking for a name, and this company has first name, last name, but this one just has it all in one field, and normalization helps. When y","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9240b4d3aad92cecd53cb1ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118971,"date":"2026-06-11T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I just want to get back into the fact that the whole process we're talking about here is in relation to recommendations that were made by the Privacy Commissioner that we be more specific in the judicial orders. Do you think that this subamendment achieves that balance between people's privacy concerns and the information that you receive? In this kind of order, could you see a situation where you have more information than you needed or less information than you needed through the judicial order process? What are the controls to stop that from happening?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118971","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I just want to get back into the fact that the whole process we're talking about here is in relation to recommendations that were made by the Privacy Commissioner that we be more specific in the judicial orders. Do you think that this subamendment achieves that balance between people's privacy concerns and the information that you receive? In this kind of order, could you see a situation where you","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3e9250a7ad2f7492c73656c69a89e9f0cc22220c028f34fadffc7e6f61ed9ec0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7019ebcc50446c52921218db9b29cf92bf2240503de9f0176aae847da55862c7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e930491477d71ae4b09896a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118972,"date":"2026-06-11T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"In terms of that process, it's interesting, because when Canadians think about the judicial system, they always think about a plaintiff and a defendant, a complainant and a respondent. There's always one side and the other side when you're going to get what we used to think of in plain English as search warrants. Who argues the other side of the argument in this context? Who makes the argument that the information shouldn't be released, that someone's privacy rights apply or that you could have a charter issue later on in the process?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118972","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In terms of that process, it's interesting, because when Canadians think about the judicial system, they always think about a plaintiff and a defendant, a complainant and a respondent. There's always one side and the other side when you're going to get what we used to think of in plain English as search warrants. Who argues the other side of the argument in this context? Who makes the argument tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0ce572b6266fe32ccaefdc4e3f4c3f523a9abfc3ed06a3492e18b334429864e5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0aef0aca86f242a58966a77cb855f0d5dff8b3587b244dd22d743169601d74f6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb63e8afcfbeb8bc1ca920ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118973,"date":"2026-06-11T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"You mean the accused.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118973","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You mean the accused.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63137d418fb0bf4a27e1047b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118974,"date":"2026-06-11T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Just to get at why this is so important, I really want to.... By the way, thank you so much for the weigh-in. You've explained this in simple language that's easy for people to understand. This morning, I was at the industry committee, and we heard testimony specifically about fraudsters and scams against seniors. This conversation is nicely dovetailed in with that. I'm grateful for it because we're doing a series of town halls in my community on it. What I want to do, though, is move to Mr. Nashef for a moment. The stakes on this really go up when we're talking about.... The personal stakes with regard to fraud are horrible, especially when we find ourselves in situations where people lose their life savings or things that are very important to them at a stage in their life when they cannot possibly recoup those. It's horrible, and it affects a small number of people, but that includes not just the victims but also their families. When it comes to fighting terrorism and when it comes to the work that CSIS does, we get into a much larger arena of people who are affected. I'm wondering if you could help me explore how this kind of situation finds its way onto your desk.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118974","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just to get at why this is so important, I really want to.... By the way, thank you so much for the weigh-in. You've explained this in simple language that's easy for people to understand. This morning, I was at the industry committee, and we heard testimony specifically about fraudsters and scams against seniors. This conversation is nicely dovetailed in with that. I'm grateful for it because we'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["834ebd0a8eeb262c42389e300c37629d0a20ec73915dd3b7a044e73c04edd838"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b5017bd5d770cecdafb94a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118975,"date":"2026-06-11T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"This subamendment is not a tool that you would normally use.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118975","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This subamendment is not a tool that you would normally use.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18f4f285faf31ffad0becb12","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118976,"date":"2026-06-11T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"The one thing, though, that I want to touch on for a minute in that context is that when you think about the kinds of activities that CSIS is investigating, a lot of the time all of that has to be financed. If you've paid attention to the news in this country over the last few years, you've seen how the flow of funds from money laundering helps put networks together or is used to finance some of the nefarious things like the transnational repression that's happening in this country. For the people who don't spend their time at the subcommittee for human rights with me, that's the act where foreign governments want to influence what's going on in our country, through the dissidents from their own country who are here. In many cases, they're targeting people who are in Canada for domestic security reasons. Lots of their activities are actually directly connected to the kind of fraud that you see in the simple situation where someone goes into a bank because they're missing money from their bank account. The bank takes notice, because there are 10 people who are missing money from their bank accounts. Then it turns out that it's not just happening in British Columbia, but also there's a bunch of stuff that's missing in Nanaimo, in Montreal and also in a suburb of Mississauga. All of a sudden it's able to be tied to a specific foreign regime that is operating in Canada. In terms of trying to keep Canadians safe, I find it very reassuring that the sort of blanket work that CSIS does isn't grounds for going into this space and being able to get specific information. At the same time, I also find it reassuring that in these situations where you start off with a complaint, and it leads—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118976","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The one thing, though, that I want to touch on for a minute in that context is that when you think about the kinds of activities that CSIS is investigating, a lot of the time all of that has to be financed. If you've paid attention to the news in this country over the last few years, you've seen how the flow of funds from money laundering helps put networks together or is used to finance some of t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["21f965d7e4abbbb569c54a63b02b05c129f56d7809cd0cd578d9e61601df25fb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["949b8284a62552c80f354a5597855ea6c5bd65e8d86b760b12e3c3ea5772fd2f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06a9f37d032bae51dfd52ac8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118977,"date":"2026-06-11T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Oh, I'm talking directly about— I'm sorry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118977","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Oh, I'm talking directly about— I'm sorry.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ca806fa855f1d9c1cceb9a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118978,"date":"2026-06-11T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I know we're not allowed to talk about whether someone's here or not here in the House, but in the context of committee, I want to welcome the member. I'm new as well, and I've been welcomed here. The subamendment that we are talking about specifically relates to the kind of information that law enforcement is able to get as part of a judicial order. As everyone, I think, around the table who's been involved with this bill knows, there are Canadians who are really concerned about this bill. Many of those concerns relate to part 2 of the bill, and that's one of the reasons why we've been proposing to split the bill into part 1 and part 2. Of course, today we're talking about part 2 of the bill, and a specific amendment and a specific subamendment. We were talking about the specific situations in which law enforcement uses the judicial authorizations to be able to get information. In terms of that top-down, general, I hesitate to use the word \"surveillance\", CSIS operates in a very different way from law enforcement. It's a much broader scope and arena. This is law enforcement saying, well, it's much narrower. The tie-in and the way in which this part of the bill, I think, does something really interesting is that it helps law enforcement make the kinds of connections that sometimes lead to CSIS, without getting CSIS directly involved. If I'm correct in understanding the interaction between both witnesses and the questioning, the RCMP may find that there is a connection among a number of frauds, or things that look like frauds, that are happening to seniors in our communities; but it turns out that there's enough similarity that they learn through the IP addresses that, in fact, they can be linked to organized crime. This is really relevant in my community and throughout British Columbia as we cope with the addictions crisis, but also for CSIS as they think about issues of national security. Have I represented your comments accurately in that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118978","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I know we're not allowed to talk about whether someone's here or not here in the House, but in the context of committee, I want to welcome the member. I'm new as well, and I've been welcomed here. The subamendment that we are talking about specifically relates to the kind of information that law enforcement is able to get as part of a judicial order. As everyone, I think, around the table who's be","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1c14fc77d5b1e071e52c07bcaddffb7815fa53c1b367ac848d4fa75a1eefd66b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["511468eed40bba91109e7de0c7e5a68b4fa5a48943838254f4e9c79908e1363f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae02f630769415fe9a31ef4d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118979,"date":"2026-06-11T22:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"What about from the CSIS side of things? Is that a fair representation of how the section of the bill as amended by the subamendment actually contributes to the work you do in a way that doesn't overly invade people's privacy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118979","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What about from the CSIS side of things? Is that a fair representation of how the section of the bill as amended by the subamendment actually contributes to the work you do in a way that doesn't overly invade people's privacy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d5a1c21f4e766a89b7a1719ee6c4bc20d3d0f4d93cedb180120bb4b6bfd9cdd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-628bc37a640d1a7f0f038b34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118980,"date":"2026-06-11T22:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm really grateful to all of the witnesses who have answered my questions. This has been a really interesting conversation. I want to thank Mr. Housefather for this subamendment. I think what I've learned in this, and what I'm inclined to conclude, is this. If we get the rest of this bill right, then this subamendment would help law enforcement in a situation where something has been initiated—it's not a fishing expedition—and has come to law enforcement. They have some information where a legal threshold has been passed, where they believe that they are going to, in the old words, lay a charge, or they feel as if there is something here. They find themselves in a situation where they have enough information to know that and to pull together the kind of argument that will allow them to go before a judge. At that point, the subamendment proposed by Mr. Housefather would help narrow, funnel or specify what kind of information is available off the menu. It isn't quite a complete menu, but at least it's a menu. Law enforcement can then go to the judge and be cognizant of the fact that if there is ever a trial in this case, the accused would invoke section 8 of the charter. They would be operating within the space they're familiar with in Canada—search and seizure, section 8 and privacy rights—and would be able to make a reasonable application to a judge, which would be successful, or not, sometimes. The judge would have control over the process and evaluate whether the information provided or the information requested fits within this fairly well-developed section—now that this committee has done excellent work. Then that judge would make a decision, and that information would be taken forward into some of the other processes we'll talk about in other sections of the bill. I'm particularly heartened to know this, and I think people watching this at home will be as well. When it comes to some of that broader work that CSIS does, the higher-level surveillance of our country in general, this isn't a section they can use to go too far, in the absence of a larger law enforcement file that relates probably to something bigger that would fit into organized crime, terrorism or the kinds of activities that CSIS does. In the context of this particular subamendment, with the Privacy Commissioner's recommendations, the reassurances that came from the RCMP, the really good work and explanations provided by the counsel from the Department of Justice and the reassurance provided by CSIS, I want to thank everybody. This has been a really interesting discussion. I will turn the floor back over to you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118980","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm really grateful to all of the witnesses who have answered my questions. This has been a really interesting conversation. I want to thank Mr. Housefather for this subamendment. I think what I've learned in this, and what I'm inclined to conclude, is this. If we get the rest of this bill right, then this subamendment would help law enforcement in a situation where something has been initiated—it","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fc45983ded984ac6a7e28e3ec7eac07b8e0e7a15d7c5140260b72c69b0d03d08"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["36ac7eb59136e8d1bda25f28698f3583e5ed7c1c4b40312d368878483d80d8ef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-786355cf175be8550b807afc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118981,"date":"2026-06-11T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"On a point of order, I'd like to point out that this is actually the first time I've heard these arguments made, so I was following them. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118981","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"On a point of order, I'd like to point out that this is actually the first time I've heard these arguments made, so I was following them. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7bf5897b681613a375b22ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118982,"date":"2026-06-11T23:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I have a point of order, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118982","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28bc99b3a48ed8563fc31b9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118983,"date":"2026-06-11T23:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"In the context of one of our colleagues having had a heart attack yesterday, that comment was uncalled for. I'd ask you to withdraw it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118983","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In the context of one of our colleagues having had a heart attack yesterday, that comment was uncalled for. I'd ask you to withdraw it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5cce2b40f7af14b65c5a2a0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087995,"date":"2026-06-15T16:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, as my colleague described, waste heat to power is a well‐established technology that captures excess heat from industrial processes and converts it into reliable baseload electricity, while producing no additional emissions or fuel use.\n\nCan my hon. colleague explain how this pan‐Canadian opportunity would be especially beneficial to the forestry sector and other resource sectors in western Canada, and particularly in British Columbia?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087995","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, as my colleague described, waste heat to power is a well‐established technology that captures excess heat from industrial processes and converts it into reliable baseload electricity, while producing no additional emissions or fuel use.\n\nCan my hon. colleague explain how this pan‐Canadian opportunity would be especially beneficial to the forestry sector and other resource sectors in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88055a752f73c962fdb481a4874cdda2d607a23feaf4bceee6e289d91b911ca5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c8681716e17342a74eca2a6031b285925b965a3747a7ab8561983e2632f03d83"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b6b1e453a20b06020602a83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087996,"date":"2026-06-15T17:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I had the privilege of being at the finance committee over the last week or so for a number of the hours the member is speaking about, and I can say that it has not been about filibustering. It has been about asking questions in the only venue that has been made available to us to examine this bill. I have received many emails, phone calls and comments from constituents who are concerned about some of the things that the member for Saanich—Gulf Islands talked about, such as the pesticide clauses and other changes that are happening to a wide variety of bills. For a bill that would touch so many acts, 30 hours is not enough. We need to be able to examine this bill properly. \n\nI am wondering why the government is determined to ram things through without adequate consultation and risk unintended consequences of bills, as we have seen with Bill C-30.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087996","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I had the privilege of being at the finance committee over the last week or so for a number of the hours the member is speaking about, and I can say that it has not been about filibustering. It has been about asking questions in the only venue that has been made available to us to examine this bill. I have received many emails, phone calls and comments from constituents who are conc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["053d04c70aff813efb107c395887542b2f79415d623c0ce546e571356bc63479"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fce92ca20b440446bc2a8cd0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087997,"date":"2026-06-15T17:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, when we sit in a committee with members opposite and officials who are unwilling to answer questions, we make whatever analogies we can to try to convince them to answer those questions.\n\n What we were talking about in committee, which was very important and very serious, was how we explain to Canadians what we are doing with CPP. That is very important to those in this country. Following the supposed filibuster that they are talking about, which was really questions about CPP, I got a phone call from a very senior finance executive who has worked for not one but two of the maple eight pension funds, telling me how important the work we are doing in finance committee is and saying how important it is to produce reports that explain, in plain English, what we are doing in the House to Canadians' pensions.\n\n If the members opposite do not understand how important it is to make sure that there are no unintended consequences through the drafting of bills that affect Canadians' pensions, then I do not know what to do. Perhaps the member could explain why he does not think Canadians should be able to get a full explanation about what the government is doing to Canadians' pensions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087997","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, when we sit in a committee with members opposite and officials who are unwilling to answer questions, we make whatever analogies we can to try to convince them to answer those questions.\n\n What we were talking about in committee, which was very important and very serious, was how we explain to Canadians what we are doing with CPP. That is very important to those in this country. Fol","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b426340a389d0482097ec0801c47e1d0c181f0005907f6e3de5bc3c25ada9c9c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3cd3ad6389c296a7dfb9c627c9dec8372b56354bb71742850785d0a32eb0ba06"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e50794ac7f3f8bd6da6a6172","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087998,"date":"2026-06-15T18:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, Bill C‐30 contains measures that allow cabinet to grant exemptions to certain rules on food and agriculture for up to three years with a possible extension.\n\nDoes my colleague agree that such powers should be debated rigorously and thoroughly rather than being rushed through in committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087998","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, Bill C‐30 contains measures that allow cabinet to grant exemptions to certain rules on food and agriculture for up to three years with a possible extension.\n\nDoes my colleague agree that such powers should be debated rigorously and thoroughly rather than being rushed through in committee?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e380231c2a5ac4a541d51f01f0edc84c9f44dbf04816b8bb7979aab03161b868"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1026fb962ba18ae3af3997e37171dc868104e421a65bdff599f44fbe9a230c78"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3a03a029eb3bf590dca2ad7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087999,"date":"2026-06-15T19:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will remind that member that today the Prime Minister is at the G7 summit as the only leader in the G20 who has caused a recession in his own country, technical or otherwise. He says the data can be uneven. What is not uneven is the pain. Food bank use is at record levels, while two in five Canadians struggle to eat and full-time workers live in people's driveways because a paycheque no longer buys a home. This is all while the Prime Minister's inflight catering bill for just 14 trips could feed a family for 55 years.\n\nWhen will this Prime Minister reverse his costly policies and make good on his announcements so Canadians can afford to live again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087999","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will remind that member that today the Prime Minister is at the G7 summit as the only leader in the G20 who has caused a recession in his own country, technical or otherwise. He says the data can be uneven. What is not uneven is the pain. Food bank use is at record levels, while two in five Canadians struggle to eat and full-time workers live in people's driveways because a paychequ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","label":"Nutrition","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e04debb15be2210f4bf2f20c43c190b0afc1aa11159dd2fb442f4f45c7a281d4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-132cc85b1574ba2798258d05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088000,"date":"2026-06-16T00:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the member for Regina—Lewvan.\n\n If the motion before the House, which we are considering today, is passed unamended, it will force a major fiscal bill through committee, cut off clause-by-clause review after only 30 minutes, deem amendments moved without meaningful debate, skip real report stage consideration, limit third reading to only a handful of speeches and restrict ordinary procedural tools after 6.30 p.m., while preserving special flexibility for cabinet ministers, but not for regular members of Parliament.\n\n That would be a lot, and it would not be a minor adjustment to the parliamentary calendar. It would be a serious and unconscionable shift in power away from Parliament and toward the executive. That is why I rise today to support the amendments and ask the government to reconsider its current plans to ram this important legislation through the House.\n\n Bill C-30 is broad. It would impact taxation, excise duties, fuel taxes, alcohol duties, housing-related rules, labour mobility, worker ownership, greenhouse building, banking payments, transportation information, employment measures, food inspection, pesticides and other areas of federal law. A bill of that breadth deserves Parliament's full attention. The government is asking the House to accept the appearance of scrutiny while bypassing proper review.\n\n If the world is in crisis and if Canada is at a crossroads where we are attempting to do big things fast, to diversify our economy and our trade relationships, then we cannot afford to get this wrong. We need the best ideas to rise to the top, and that is the role of opposition. That is the role of committee. That is the role of clause-by-clause study. There is no boardroom table in a successful company that I know of where no dissent is allowed, where shortcuts get the best results or where the fastest policies are the best policies.\n\n Clause-by-clause study matters. It is where members examine the actual words of the bill, not the press release around it. It is where we ask officials what a clause would do, how it would work, who it would affect and what would happen if were misused. It is where amendments are proposed and can be explained, tested and improved. It is where witnesses, members and sometimes the public catch drafting problems, unintended consequences and overly broad powers before they become law. That is not obstruction. That is how the best ideas rise to the top.\n\n Under the motion, the committee would meet at 9 a.m., and, if clause-by-clause were not finished by 9:30 a.m., the remaining amendments would be deemed moved and then are voted on without further debate. This motion is a stopwatch, and in a time of global crisis, Canada cannot afford stopwatch law-making. The government's inability to manage a legislative agenda is not the opposition's crisis, no matter how much the government tries to bully us into submission.\n\n This week, I spent some time at the public safety committee, examining witnesses about a Liberal subamendment to a Bloc amendment that related to privacy concerns that had been expressed to me by numerous people in my community. Others did the same. By the end of the interventions, we all understood and supported the clause as amended and subamended, and we had explained it in committee in a way that should reassure those watching from home that the clause would not cause undue harm to people's privacy. That is the kind of collaboration the government claims it wants, and when it comes to Canadians' privacy, it is what we all need, so why the government is shutting it down here in the House is beyond me.\n\n The motion would short-circuit report stage. Then, at third reading, it would allow only a very limited number of speeches. Members do not come here as ornaments, here to decorate the government's bills with a few words. We come here to bring the lived and living experiences of Canadians into the policy choices that are before this country. When debate is reduced to a few speeches, those voices are marginalized. Canadians lose the benefit of having competing arguments tested before a vote takes place. In an unstable, volatile world, there is all the more reason for Parliament to take its time to make sure that Canada gets its policies right.\n\nThe proposed amendments would let the committee continue its work and protect the stages of review that help Parliament separate strong policy from weak policy before a law is passed. Some parts of Bill C‐30 deserve much closer public scrutiny than they are going to get, because they raise serious concerns about how the government now thinks about power.\n\nOne of the most troubling examples is the proposed change to the Canadian Food Inspection Agency Act. Buried in this spring economic update bill is a power that would allow cabinet, by order, to exempt persons, things or activities from the application of laws or regulations administered or enforced by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. In plain English, cabinet could create exemptions from food and agricultural rules for up to three years, and then extend them for another three years. That means there could be a possible six-year exemption from rules that exist to protect Canadians, our food supply, our producers, our markets and our public confidence.\n\n Canadians should not have to guess about questions like, \"What is an unreasonable risk? Who makes the decisions, and on what evidence? What notice would Canadians receive and what recourse would they have if the power were used badly?\" Food safety should not depend on vague language and cabinet decisions. Those are all questions that I will never get to ask because of the way the government is planning to ram through this bill.\n\nCanadians expect food safety rules to be clear, public, stable and enforced. They expect science, inspection and accountability. They do not expect broad exemption powers to be tucked into a budget-style bill and rushed through committee.\n\n That same concern appears in the proposed changes to the Pest Control Products Act. Those provisions would allow cabinet to authorize or reinstate the use of a pest control product, even after the responsible minister has determined that the environmental risks are not acceptable, if cabinet decides that the product is needed for economic or food security. That should make every member pause. The regulatory process could say an environmental risk is unacceptable, and cabinet could still step in and permit the product. There may be rare, emergency cases when flexibility is needed, and reasonable people can accept that, but emergency powers should be narrow, clearly defined, transparent, time-limited and subject to strong oversight. They should not be drafted so broadly that Parliament is asked to trust cabinet first and ask questions later.\n\nThese two brief examples demonstrate why clause-by-clause matters and why committees matter. Canadians need more than abstract, procedural debates. We need safeguards. We ought to make space for members to find provisions such as these, ask what they mean, test the government's explanations, hear from officials and affected groups and improve the law before Canadians have to live with it. A government that is confident in its agenda should be willing to explain it, defend its legislation line by line and accept amendments that add clarity, accountability and limits.\n\nCanadians should pay attention, because the kinds of motions we are debating here today are becoming a trend. Too often, the government seems to believe that if it has the power to do something, that is reason enough to do it. That is not how responsible government works. Just because a government can use a procedure to limit scrutiny, it does not mean that it should. The House of Commons is not an inconvenience in the legislative process, and it ought not be treated as such. It is the central democratic forum of this country, where public money is authorized, laws are tested, ministers are held to account and the executive must answer questions before it changes the lives of Canadians. The Prime Minister should be willing to propose and defend his vision for Canada here, in this chamber, reserved for commoners. We are everyday Canadians who deserve answers.\n\n The government has the votes and the procedural tools to force this through, but just because it can, it does not mean that it should. A serious government should not ask members to vote first and understand later. For those reasons, I urge all members of this House to support these amendments. I urge the House to reject this shortcut, protect Parliament's role and allow Bill C‐30 to receive the scrutiny it deserves.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088000","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the member for Regina—Lewvan.\n\n If the motion before the House, which we are considering today, is passed unamended, it will force a major fiscal bill through committee, cut off clause-by-clause review after only 30 minutes, deem amendments moved without meaningful debate, skip real report stage consideration, limit third reading to only a handful of s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be0c3619211e98f9f1869ebe2f69dc613b6b6eade04c86ef9e7b7716e9d5b0ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a44f9aaddb773288f460ff85e56111194e4437d37a0ec55ed9e67890f3ea7aea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78a670a74dbfa2aed34bbef5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088001,"date":"2026-06-16T00:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088001","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44d39b00a9982132a70ca4b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088002,"date":"2026-06-16T00:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, actually, all I need to do is look at what happened in this House with Bill C‐3. It is a bill that went to committee. The committee treated it seriously and amended it. The bill came back to the House, and the government showed what it thought of committees. It rejected all of the amendments and used its majority to ram it through. Now we have a situation where there are advertisements in the United States, with companies saying, \"You can find a connection to Canada.\" We are going to have a big backlog. Americans are suddenly discovering that we have the health care and the country they want.\n\nI do not even know what to say. The government does not respect the parliamentary process or committees, and it is going to have unintended consequences.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088002","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, actually, all I need to do is look at what happened in this House with Bill C‐3. It is a bill that went to committee. The committee treated it seriously and amended it. The bill came back to the House, and the government showed what it thought of committees. It rejected all of the amendments and used its majority to ram it through. Now we have a situation where there are advertisement","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transborder data flow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","label":"Transborder data flow","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ceb56fc2584f8adb576e52a837112aae702af6636e46a2c620cde36ff5b03b9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2cd698c99b8249519e9ecfa3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088003,"date":"2026-06-16T00:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her question.\n\n I brought up two examples in my speech, and here is another one. There is so much substance in this bill to consider. There are recommendations. There are experts whom we need to hear from, but we will not have the opportunity to do that.\n\n As every member on the opposition side has made the point, over and over again, that this is a bill that requires more scrutiny and more consideration, the government members have stood up and accused us of all kinds of things in order to ram their bill through.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088003","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her question.\n\n I brought up two examples in my speech, and here is another one. There is so much substance in this bill to consider. There are recommendations. There are experts whom we need to hear from, but we will not have the opportunity to do that.\n\n As every member on the opposition side has made the point, over and over again, that this is a bill that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-48b6f93e51a34cd0b3fc4ff2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088004,"date":"2026-06-16T00:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I was in committee when the first vote happened after the government received its majority. Members can look at the tapes. I sat there and said, \"We are going to go upstairs, and when we come back down here, the government is going to use its majority to end the conversation in this committee,\" and that is exactly what it did.\n\n This is not a government that is starting conversations. It is a government that is ending conversations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088004","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I was in committee when the first vote happened after the government received its majority. Members can look at the tapes. I sat there and said, \"We are going to go upstairs, and when we come back down here, the government is going to use its majority to end the conversation in this committee,\" and that is exactly what it did.\n\n This is not a government that is starting conversations.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d64be240926763ed955753bfc61acc34ca2f0127446355cab0d5dde13f654881"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb610c38dc69bc40e136b22a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088005,"date":"2026-06-16T02:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have lost track of the number of times I have risen just this week to talk about why the government's inability to plan a legislative agenda should not become an emergency in the House. This is yet another move toward time allocation. I want to remind everyone in the House that the rush the Liberals did with Bill C-3, when they rammed it through the House and undid the amendments that were done at committee, showing a disrespect for the committee process, led to unintended consequences, creating a large document backlog, confusion for families and a very broad path to citizenship for people with a limited connection to Canada. \n\nI see another bill and another set of unintended consequences, and we have gotten so much mail about this. I would like the member to explain yet again why we cannot take the time to properly consider this important legislation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088005","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have lost track of the number of times I have risen just this week to talk about why the government's inability to plan a legislative agenda should not become an emergency in the House. This is yet another move toward time allocation. I want to remind everyone in the House that the rush the Liberals did with Bill C-3, when they rammed it through the House and undid the amendments th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0f36c5b3bbe449e811f2a1bce29c87cf41050499fd2485337018fc497922197d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["478c367d006e73fb7b70f6a507d5ce090db3f9b30228e2a14ee4107a37eeb375"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e125014f0b772fb0c4533c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088006,"date":"2026-06-16T04:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, all members in the House want to combat anti-Semitism, Islamophobia and hate in all of its forms. Our concern is that the bill is performative and that it is more words in a space where there are already too many words. \n\nI would like to know if the minister can tell me who can be arrested the day after Bill C-9 passes who cannot be arrested today and that it is going to result in the elimination of Islamophobia, anti-Semitism and hate, which he says is going to happen when the bill passes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088006","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, all members in the House want to combat anti-Semitism, Islamophobia and hate in all of its forms. Our concern is that the bill is performative and that it is more words in a space where there are already too many words. \n\nI would like to know if the minister can tell me who can be arrested the day after Bill C-9 passes who cannot be arrested today and that it is going to result in the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a6bf87e10cb901eb50c959dfb39863745b53af672d587ca3bf30cfb521f1f565"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63052f59f769f72f088e0901","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087990,"date":"2026-06-16T19:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I suppose it is useful to know that instead of reports, we are going to get consultations. Maybe we will get an answer to the next question.\n\n CPP disability applications are supposed to be decided within 120 days, 80% of the time. Last year, the Liberals managed only 49.3%, less than half. \n\nWhy are disabled Canadians being left for months without income while the minister misses her own deadline?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087990","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I suppose it is useful to know that instead of reports, we are going to get consultations. Maybe we will get an answer to the next question.\n\n CPP disability applications are supposed to be decided within 120 days, 80% of the time. Last year, the Liberals managed only 49.3%, less than half. \n\nWhy are disabled Canadians being left for months without income while the minister misses her","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["83e18aaf1fdeb2a3799cf3562e96cab29bc0f69e4eaf196005dff7efd20f6662"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["094c23dfa40f1d1c215b4b63eeb7c64be95c2464c5390452d7c072e4f81971a9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4664432e656b902055d2cf13","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087991,"date":"2026-06-16T21:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, hate is real, and it is doing damage in communities across this country. No Canadian should be intimidated because of who they are, how they worship, what they look like, where they come from or what they believe. \n\nThe question before us is not whether hate should be taken seriously. The question is whether Bill C-9 would actually make Canadians safer. The problem we hear about again and again is not the absence of words in the Criminal Code; it is the failure to act when people break the law. \n\nCommunities are not safer when Parliament adds more words. They are safer when police respond quickly, when charges are laid where evidence supports them, when prosecutors have the resources to move cases forward, when repeat offenders face real consequences and when victims have confidence that the justice system is willing to protect them. \n\nThe number and range of organizations that have raised alarms about Bill C-9 are stunning. It is not just one political party, it is not just one faith community and it is not just one type of advocacy group. Civil liberties organizations across the political spectrum have warned that this bill risks sweeping too broadly and chilling lawful expression and peaceful protest. A broad array of community organizations from across the political spectrum have warned that vague criminal law can be used unevenly and can fall hardest on the very communities it claims to protect. \n\nProgressive and traditional faith groups alike have warned about the removal of long-standing protections for good-faith religious expression. Legal and constitutional voices have raised serious concerns about the balance between public safety and fundamental freedoms. That breadth of opposition should give every member of the House pause, because when civil liberties groups, religious organizations, community advocates, legal experts and grassroots coalitions from so many walks of life all tell Parliament it is on the wrong track, the responsible thing to do is to listen. It is not to push ahead and dismiss those concerns as being fringe, unserious or misleading. \n\nThe people raising these concerns are not defending hate. Many of them work every day, tirelessly, against hate, racism and violence. Their point, when they came to this place and to the other place to share their views on this bill, was to tell us that bad law can make hard problems worse. Their point has been that criminal law must be precise, fair and enforceable. When Parliament writes vague laws in the name of safety, it can create uncertainty and the opposite of safety for ordinary Canadians, while doing little to stop those who are already willing to break the law. \n\nThat is the core weakness of Bill C-9. It tries to show strength through wording rather than through action or results, and yet it is remarkably confusing and imprecise in its wording. In that, Bill C-9 risks blurring the line between hateful conduct, which must be punished, and lawful expression, which must remain protected even when it is controversial, offensive and deeply unpopular. A mature democracy can punish violence and intimidation without giving the state a vague mandate to police belief, scripture, protest or political speech. \n\nFor the communities that are counting on this bill, the Minister of Artificial Intelligence failed just last night to answer the key question they are asking: Who would the police be able to arrest when this law is passed who they cannot arrest today? How would this bill help bring order to the chaos that has taken over the streets in some communities right now? How would this bill actually stop the bullets, the fires and the death threats? \n\n Instead of providing answers and safety, the government brought forward a bill that has divided communities, alarmed civil society and created uncertainty about how far the long arm of the criminal law would reach. That is not careful work. That is not the careful work that Canadians expect from the House. It is not the careful work that is required when fundamental freedoms are at stake. Opposing the bill does not mean accepting hate. What it means is demanding a better answer.\n\nI will be the last speaker on the bill, not because members of Parliament have nothing left to say, not because the concerns of the groups that have come to the committee to meet with members of Parliament have had their concerns answered and not because the communities that are so worried that they will be affected by the bill have been heard. I will be the last speaker on the bill because the government has chosen to end the debate.\n\nI have said, many times in the House, that just because the Liberal majority can do something, it does not mean it should. Power gives a government the ability to move quickly but it does not give it wisdom. It does not turn a flawed bill into a good one. It does not turn words into results.\n\nIn the coming weeks and months, Canadians will see what the bill would not do. It would not make a synagogue safer when threats are not met with enforcement. It would not make a mosque safer when police do not have the tools or resources to act quickly. It would not make a church, temple, school or community centre safer if the justice system still cannot follow through. It would not reassure vulnerable Canadians if the government confuses passing a bill with solving a problem.\n\nWhen those failures become clear, no one on that side of the House should pretend they were not warned. They were warned by civil liberties groups. They were warned by faith communities of all kinds. They were warned by legal experts. They were warned by organizations from many different walks of life, many of whom rarely agree on much else but agreed on this. They agreed that Bill C-9 is not the careful, enforceable, unifying response that Canadians deserve.\n\nThe government had a choice. It could have listened. It could have fixed the bill. It could have spent the time necessary to work with the provinces to truly hear what they need, not in terms of words but in terms of enforcement, in terms of resources, in terms of real support. It could have brought forward a measure focused on real enforcement, real protection and real accountability. Instead, the government chose closure. They chose more words on paper.\n\nNone of us are safer or more united for those choices. If this government is not interested in meaningful debate, we might as well save our breath.\n\nI move:\n\nThat this House do now adjourn.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087991","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, hate is real, and it is doing damage in communities across this country. No Canadian should be intimidated because of who they are, how they worship, what they look like, where they come from or what they believe. \n\nThe question before us is not whether hate should be taken seriously. The question is whether Bill C-9 would actually make Canadians safer. The problem we hear about again","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63961cf588e5bb9aa09fb7c1208b7da637ea80e4621897cf420b728d6065a02e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["32ddbe5a99362fb891556bfcdfc26c1aa488946ee3314b083e48954ac409ba77"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7830a92688e48824e7316320","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087992,"date":"2026-06-16T22:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have lost track of the number of times I have stood in the House in the last few days to talk about the government's again ramming a bill through the House. In this case, the bill has not had the benefit of second reading, committee study, third reading or report stage. It has not been to the Senate. It has not had the benefit of being studied in either House. It concerns an extremely important area of policy and law in this country, and we have seen the unintended consequences of badly drafted Liberal bills being rammed through the House.\n\n We saw it with Bill C-3, wherein there are unintended consequences, including lots of Americans who are discovering their connections to Canada. We have seen it with the minister's actions when he was the mayor of Vancouver. This is an area that we have to get right, and I would urge the government not to do this. I would challenge the minister to explain why Canadians should not get the benefit of debate on the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087992","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have lost track of the number of times I have stood in the House in the last few days to talk about the government's again ramming a bill through the House. In this case, the bill has not had the benefit of second reading, committee study, third reading or report stage. It has not been to the Senate. It has not had the benefit of being studied in either House. It concerns an extreme","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e24d0bd7edcfe836cf24b2e51bf23dbfd1abd3c90b8de2dc1d0f27a146ec9f63"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4eeebe743eeb935c1647f1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087993,"date":"2026-06-16T22:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard a variety of arguments from this side of the House as to why cutting debate off on this bill is short-sighted, but perhaps one of the most important reasons is because, as my hon. colleague explained, it does not just cut off debate in the House; it also means this bill will never go to committee. What that means is that the experts, the constituents, the members of civil society in this country who might have something to say with respect to this bill, which might actually be useful to the government, will not get the chance to be heard.\n\nI certainly understand why the member does not want to go to committee. I have seen him there, and it is not good, but I want to know why the minister is also cutting off Canadians from having their say about the bill through our committee process.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087993","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard a variety of arguments from this side of the House as to why cutting debate off on this bill is short-sighted, but perhaps one of the most important reasons is because, as my hon. colleague explained, it does not just cut off debate in the House; it also means this bill will never go to committee. What that means is that the experts, the constituents, the members of civi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ea1d58a0a8ea98bc94fdebc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087994,"date":"2026-06-16T23:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill S‐201, the national framework on sickle cell disease act. The bill deals with a serious, painful and lifelong illness. Sickle cell disease is an inherited blood disorder that affects hemoglobin. It can cause chronic pain, severe infections, organ damage, stroke and shortened life expectancy. It affects roughly 6,000 Canadians.\n\n Bill S‐201 would require the Minister of Health to develop and table a national framework on sickle cell disease within one year. The framework would cover training for health care professionals, a national research network and registry, evidence-based national standards, universal neonatal screening, public awareness, blood donation promotion, analysis of a possible tax credit, inclusion in existing disability benefits, and an analysis of whether treatments should be included in public drug insurance plans. A follow-up implementation report would be required within three years. These are serious proposals, some of which are partially implemented or implemented in various provinces. They deserve careful study.\n\nConservatives supported the recognition of June 19 as National Sickle Cell Awareness Day. We support better awareness, earlier diagnosis, improved screening, and stronger care for Canadians living with sickle cell disease. We support practical steps that help patients and families, especially when those steps are shaped by evidence and by the people most affected.\n\nAt the same time, Parliament has a duty to get the details right. As we know, health care delivery is provincial. The provinces run hospitals, manage newborn screening and make many of the direct decisions that determine whether any patient, including those with sickle cell disease, receives care quickly, safely and close to home. A federal framework can be useful if it brings people together, improves data, shares best practices and supports better outcomes.\n\nHowever, it is useless and can even be very damaging if it produces yet another Ottawa document written far from the people who must deliver care on the ground, without taking their needs into account. That is the difference between a framework that helps patients and families and one that sits on the shelf and gathers dust or, worse, is used as an excuse not to act.\n\nWhen the bill goes to committee, Conservatives will seek to ensure that the structural framework discussed in it results in a strategy that would be developed in genuine and respectful partnership with the provinces and territories. Patients deserve the benefit of better coordination. If the federal government uses its convening power well and with intent, better coordination can yield better outcomes. Families need real answers, not announcements.\n\n The same is true for cost. Bill S‐201 would not include a fiscal appropriation, but the framework points to initiatives that could carry major downstream costs. A national research network, a patient registry, public awareness campaigns, professional training, expanded screening, drug coverage analysis, disability benefit inclusion and a possible tax credit all raise financial questions. Compassion requires honesty. Before this framework is finalized, Parliament should require a Parliamentary Budget Officer cost estimate. If the government is asking Canadians to support a national framework, it should be clear about the costs, timelines, responsibilities and expected results. That is not opposition to the bill. It is respect for the patients who are counting on it.\n\nThe bill would also connect with areas where Conservatives have already put forward practical policy. We have supported making the caregiver tax credit refundable. We have called for the disability tax credit to be streamlined and simplified, including automatic eligibility for related programs where appropriate. We have supported safer, faster access to drugs already approved by trusted peer jurisdictions, better pediatric drug data, and a rare disease strategy that supports treatment development. Those ideas matter here.\n\n Patients and caregivers need systems that are simple, fair and practical. They do not need more paperwork, more overlapping programs or federal announcements that create confusion among departments, provinces and providers. They need care that works.\n\nBill S-201 raises this broader question, because it would not be the only bill of its kind. In Parliament, members and senators have brought forward several health-related bills on rare disease access, forced and coerced sterilization, heart failure, fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, food allergies, women's health, brain injuries, ADHD, medical assistance in dying, natural health products, living organ donors, supervised consumption sites, and mental health.\n\nEach of these bills speaks to a real concern and has its own patients, families, advocates, experts and evidence. Some deal with disease-specific frameworks. Some deal with treatment access. Some deal with criminal law protections. Some deal with long-neglected gaps in the system. Taken together, what these bills reveal is something the Liberal government should not be proud of: Canada's health care file is being patched, one private member's bill at a time.\n\nPrivate members' bills do have an important role. They can raise issues government has missed, bring neglected voices to Parliament or force attention where attention is overdue, but in this quantity, they show that they are becoming a substitute for a competent government that actually cares about the health of Canadians. A well-run health file would not need Parliament to keep discovering one gap after another through separate private members' bills. It would not need one bill for one disease, another for another treatment pathway, another for one group of patients and another for one failure that should have been addressed years ago.\n\nThe federal government has a Minister of Health, departments, agencies, regulators, health transfers, data systems and provincial-federal tables. It has the tools to lead while respecting provincial jurisdiction, yet again and again, patients and families are left to organize, to advocate and to wait until someone brings forward a bill. Canadians deserve better than fragmented attention on the health file. They deserve a health care approach that identifies gaps before families have to plead for help. They deserve better data, faster diagnosis, clearer accountability, responsible spending and practical support for provinces and territories. In short, they deserve federal leadership that knows the difference between coordination and interference.\n\nFor Bill S-201, we will work with the government to move the bill forward in a constructive way. We will support better awareness of sickle cell disease, earlier diagnosis, better data, stronger research, improved training for health care professionals and a more diverse blood supply. We would listen to patients, caregivers, clinicians, researchers, community organizations and provinces and territories when they come to committee, but we would also insist on amendments that would make the bill clearer and more useful.\n\nThe framework should be developed in partnership with provinces and territories. It should respect jurisdiction, avoid duplicating the existing national strategy for drugs and rare diseases, use accurate language around guidelines and best practices, include cost transparency and, most of all, be judged by whether it improves care.\n\nPeople living with sickle cell disease do not need Parliament to pass bills that feel good but change little. This debate must result in more than just another report for the Ottawa shelves. Canadians deserve better, which is what Conservatives will continue to relentlessly fight for in the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087994","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill S‐201, the national framework on sickle cell disease act. The bill deals with a serious, painful and lifelong illness. Sickle cell disease is an inherited blood disorder that affects hemoglobin. It can cause chronic pain, severe infections, organ damage, stroke and shortened life expectancy. It affects roughly 6,000 Canadians.\n\n Bill S‐201 would require t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","label":"Chronic diseases"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","label":"Chronic diseases","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1d8092c368301f485293268ad024e4dc2ffe0d31c5acd92dcbb60cc27629520a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5d6ace514351dd7c3f4e407668be019fe3ad51b716cfc00305a358c86e6cd2a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b767233d76051e5b786d0e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118984,"date":"2026-06-17T02:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. As we try to come to a consensus on the amendment proposed by my Bloc colleague, I think it's really important to understand the problem the government says it's trying to solve with this clause, and to stand that solution up against the Bloc amendment. It is similar to amendments proposed by both the Conservatives and the NDP, and it relates to a concern expressed to me by Ms. May. It is really important, at the outset, to recognize that all the opposition parties have taken issue with the way the bill is drafted around this standard. I'm going to have some questions for the witnesses and will try to get to the bottom of this in a way Canadians can understand, because privacy is so important to Canadians. I know there are some people at home who are following this issue closely. Before I get to those questions, though, there's something I would like to say, through the chair, specifically to my colleagues on the other side of the table, because they're the ones supporting the bill the way it's currently drafted, with respect to this standard. When I initially spoke to Bill C-22 in the chamber, the issues around the government choosing the standard of \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" instead of \"reasonable grounds to believe\" attracted a lot of attention. One of our members, who practises criminal law, practically grabbed me by the lapels as I was coming out of the chamber after my speech, to talk about it. Ms. May also pulled me aside to have a conversation about it. The specific reason it's such a big deal to lawyers and lawmakers—it's important that people watching this at home understand—is that these questions.... \"Reasonable grounds to believe\" and \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" are not just technical legal terms. They determine how much evidence and how much work the state needs to do before it can intrude into someone's privacy. I thought Ms. Gibner did an excellent job of explaining the basics of privacy law and the kinds of tests the court uses. I'm not going to reiterate the earlier conversation the committee had with respect to using the lower standard for production orders in general. I think the committee got that vote wrong, and I would have supported the Bloc amendment. The fact that the committee has already made a decision to use that lower standard for domestic subscriber production orders does not automatically mean the same standard has to apply in the international context. That's the context in which we're discussing the standard here. I thought Ms. Gibner did a really nice job of describing Spencer, because that case changed the frame. We no longer look at it and say, \"This is just basic subscriber information or basic customer information.\" Spencer made it clear, from a judicial perspective and a charter perspective, that we're dealing with what can be highly revealing information that attracts a reasonable expectation of privacy under the Constitution. It is useful to think about the ethos of Spencer being here with us in this room, because the way it situates this debate we're having reminds us that subscriber information is not considered to be neutral under Canadian law. It is often a key that connects a person to their digital life. Once that identity is disclosed, that privacy interest is gone forever. Once you know who it is, you know who it is. It's one of those things that are hard to reverse. That's why this standard matters, and it's why the choice of standard in legislation matters. If Parliament chooses the threshold of \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" instead of \"reasonable grounds to believe\", it's lowering the bar for the state. When I say \"the state\", I don't mean it in the sense of the United States, for people who are watching from home. I mean it in the sense of \"the state\": the entity of government that in some ways takes care of us and in some ways has the power to show up at our house and drag us out at four o'clock in the morning, because that is part of the social contract. The social contract that we make is with the state. The charter relates to the things and the role that the state plays in our lives, when we have individual autonomy and when we are part of that collective. It really matters. I sat and listened to my colleague, Madame DeBellefeuille, talk about how the conversation we are having here is not a filibuster. It is not something where we are holding up the work that the government wants to do. It is an inherent part of the work that we do in this chamber. I understand that tempers have gotten high over the last few days and that there is an agenda that the government would like to push through, that there are things they want to do, but we have stood in the chamber over and over again and said that the government's failure to plan a legislative agenda with enough sitting days and enough time to get the work that they want done through Parliament is not something that should become our problem. We should not be rushing through important conversations about things as basic as privacy, especially when these are ongoing conversations that are happening in the courts and that are happening in our communities. I'm not going to reiterate what Madame DeBellefeuille said, but I think it's really important that no one in this room feels that they are being pushed hard—I'm not going to use the word \"bullied\"—into skipping over understanding what these really important standards do, because we're no longer talking about the standard for a regular production order. What we're talking about when we get to this amendment is the same standard as it applies to something called a \"mutual legal assistance treaty\". That is something that serves a slightly different purpose than the production order. My understanding is that a production order, as we think about it, is a tool that's used by Canadian authorities to obtain information directly from companies and enterprises over which Canada has jurisdiction. When we get into mutual legal assistance treaties—or MLATs, as we call them, because who doesn't love a four-letter acronym—what we're doing is we're asking.... I want to make sure I'm correct on this, so please, someone, correct me if I'm wrong. An MLAT actually involves asking another country to use its legal processes to obtain information on Canada's behalf from a company or an enterprise in that country. Have I got that correct? Okay. That's good, because that's where we are in this debate. We are debating the legal standard that should be used when we are asking another country to go and get information from one of its corporate persons, I guess. In Canada, it would be a person, but it would be more of a corporate person or an enterprise. We are asking it to go into its database, into its information, and give law enforcement in Canada information that Canadian authorities can then use. That puts us into a different realm. It puts us over borders and it engages questions around international comity, around foreign sovereignty and around cross-border co-operation, and not just with the United States or even with countries that are democratic. The IP addresses could really be from anywhere. We'll talk about that a bit, I hope, but it's cross-border co-operation that simply does not arise in a domestic co-operation order. I think, as Ms. Gibner pointed out, that what we have in Canada when it comes to our privacy landscape is something to which there is no comparator. There isn't really a Spencer in any of the countries that we're dealing with. It's a way in which Canadian rights and Canadian privacy rights are...\"unique\" is a bit of an overused word, but they're certainly not common, and it requires thinking. That means that we think about these problems in a different way. There's been some conversation around the table. However, I hope the way I've explained this helps make it clear to everybody sitting around the table why it is possible to have one standard for a domestic production order and a different standard for an international production order. Is that a fair summary of where we are, Ms. Gibner? Do you have anything you'd like to add to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118984","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. As we try to come to a consensus on the amendment proposed by my Bloc colleague, I think it's really important to understand the problem the government says it's trying to solve with this clause, and to stand that solution up against the Bloc amendment. It is similar to amendments proposed by both the Conservatives and the NDP, and it relates to a concern expressed to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c88c7d6c956e52a775edc3476228f412c9b4153e14363a7a46c0cea1404ccdbe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb4246b076bc85f6227308c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118985,"date":"2026-06-17T02:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Given that I think we have this wrong—and I think we got it wrong on the first question—I'm actually hoping I'll be able to convince my colleagues through this round of questioning and through our conversation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118985","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Given that I think we have this wrong—and I think we got it wrong on the first question—I'm actually hoping I'll be able to convince my colleagues through this round of questioning and through our conversation.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e247ada6d57df57158db2db3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118986,"date":"2026-06-17T02:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Do we do that in the realm of forced labour? There are countries that have lower labour standards than ours. We have rules that say we shouldn't be importing goods made under conditions of slavery in other countries. Accepting that other countries' legal standards are lower than ours and that, therefore, we shouldn't use a higher standard—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118986","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do we do that in the realm of forced labour? There are countries that have lower labour standards than ours. We have rules that say we shouldn't be importing goods made under conditions of slavery in other countries. Accepting that other countries' legal standards are lower than ours and that, therefore, we shouldn't use a higher standard—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61228e685d60770779646295","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118987,"date":"2026-06-17T02:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I wish I had been here for the conversation about the other clause. I would submit to you that we made the wrong decision on that. I could make an argument, based on Spencer and other legal cases, that there is a material difference between suspecting and believing. Since I don't have the opportunity to make that argument on that clause, I will make it here instead. You may believe that, if we did it differently, you would have the lower standard on this and the higher standard on the other one. I would like you to confirm that the standards don't have to be the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118987","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I wish I had been here for the conversation about the other clause. I would submit to you that we made the wrong decision on that. I could make an argument, based on Spencer and other legal cases, that there is a material difference between suspecting and believing. Since I don't have the opportunity to make that argument on that clause, I will make it here instead. You may believe that, if we did","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["08d3e7448772db5bc7f6492d520aaf48ff94ca1d129c28a1c4dad2b97c989da8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6255db5efd91737aea6e676","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118988,"date":"2026-06-17T02:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Moving on to the clause, I just want to have the conversation about this clause. I want to make it clear that I'm having the conversation about this clause independent of the other clause that the committee already made a decision on. I can understand why the government would want to make it easier and faster for Canadian police to get digital records, especially when the records are held by foreign service providers. That's the goal here. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118988","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Moving on to the clause, I just want to have the conversation about this clause. I want to make it clear that I'm having the conversation about this clause independent of the other clause that the committee already made a decision on. I can understand why the government would want to make it easier and faster for Canadian police to get digital records, especially when the records are held by forei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6883e6305d7f8d5d85584b646ae33c67f2487072b7b108ccbfc82208988efe98"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a31e9e43a3117f4977371cc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118989,"date":"2026-06-17T02:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"What I'd like to understand.... I'll go to Sergeant Gilkes or perhaps Chief Superintendent Burchill—whoever wants to answer this question. The nub originates with law enforcement. When we talked last week about a different amendment, the Liberal.... It was a Liberal subamendment to a Bloc amendment. When we talked about that situation, we were talking about a fairly straightforward fraud situation, where you go to get information under a production order. How do we get to an MLAT? What changes in that fact scenario we talked about that gets us into an MLAT?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118989","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What I'd like to understand.... I'll go to Sergeant Gilkes or perhaps Chief Superintendent Burchill—whoever wants to answer this question. The nub originates with law enforcement. When we talked last week about a different amendment, the Liberal.... It was a Liberal subamendment to a Bloc amendment. When we talked about that situation, we were talking about a fairly straightforward fraud situation","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3bb1a49d0d313d742a78995d6d063f54b14b85dbfb14007b2d67f6fbfd2c42f5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f0a3a424f4f06a27030be5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118990,"date":"2026-06-17T02:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"What kind of complaint? Let's work with a live example. We were talking last week about a situation where someone realizes that funds have been withdrawn from their bank account. How do we get to an MLAT from there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118990","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What kind of complaint? Let's work with a live example. We were talking last week about a situation where someone realizes that funds have been withdrawn from their bank account. How do we get to an MLAT from there?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","label":"Personal finance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eadc5fb3e7c24e8b789bc577684912a33d2740b86c2d586ec954801da35c5dbc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f363f05c2922756325052782","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118991,"date":"2026-06-17T02:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"How would the tool in this bill change that process from a law enforcement perspective?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118991","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How would the tool in this bill change that process from a law enforcement perspective?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db1a596cd92e00a3b136b66db3765a5e8787763029f0fee58ba562e6aba61c4a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-684fa1ec84836a77a6643da1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118992,"date":"2026-06-17T02:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I mean both. Is it no longer necessary to use an MLAT?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118992","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I mean both. Is it no longer necessary to use an MLAT?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f7924203f2a99d8ee5d655618765ba6706f972b69dd99cbddc35363f357e975"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e51a76fae7af88abc6ca7994","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118993,"date":"2026-06-17T02:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Under the old process, did you get what was contained in the records?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118993","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Under the old process, did you get what was contained in the records?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b3bb54c7428bb8e488e32e282b34a9afb7eeb16e35a8c78685ddeab5523d1ef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67b092ade3e64c6993d88cd5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118994,"date":"2026-06-17T02:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Why wouldn't you use this tool to get the content as well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118994","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Why wouldn't you use this tool to get the content as well?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","label":"Software","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["822ca676ed90ea20490319c1093f8ff640d9891843d2b2ed048b52c6217cf383"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4d29040299104feaae5778b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118995,"date":"2026-06-17T02:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Is it now a two-stage process? In stage one, you would still go through an MLAT. Is that correct? I'm seeing a lot of head-shaking, which is great. This is what we need to get to the point where we might end up being able to support these kinds of clauses. It makes a huge difference, when we initially heard a standard that's not the normal one we expect to get in criminal law. It is through these kinds of questions that we get to understand what the difference is. You're no longer using an MLAT. This is a different process. An hon. member: I have a point of order. Tamara Kronis: Instead of using an MLAT, would you go to a judge in Canada, the United States or whatever country? Would you go to a judge in China? Maybe it's the Justice people who need to answer this. In our old scenario, you've identified that someone came into the bank and money is missing from their account. You realize that some IP addresses have accessed this account repeatedly. You realize that they are not in Canada. Where do you go from there? Who gets asked for what, if it's not through an MLAT?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118995","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is it now a two-stage process? In stage one, you would still go through an MLAT. Is that correct? I'm seeing a lot of head-shaking, which is great. This is what we need to get to the point where we might end up being able to support these kinds of clauses. It makes a huge difference, when we initially heard a standard that's not the normal one we expect to get in criminal law. It is through these ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b8e9f568fcfc5d860a6fd2129f8956331c67d3ab04ff07aa412086b9c21464b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fc2ce49d51620fb2174518cd60b45b1b27c24bbaf43de295cf98e7da7b1486db"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fe19519e34c9ca33b90a97c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118996,"date":"2026-06-17T02:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. Getting back to this, in this situation, where the IP address is outside of the country, you're no longer going to go through the mutual legal assistance treaty. You're no longer going to go through the MLAT. What do you do instead, if this passes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118996","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Getting back to this, in this situation, where the IP address is outside of the country, you're no longer going to go through the mutual legal assistance treaty. You're no longer going to go through the MLAT. What do you do instead, if this passes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2125ff38f4c2b4f802fb0fb60943b4842fa07ad1ffc7eadb89f0838ee0d1aa2d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3b703fa0878b3a92dacc700","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118997,"date":"2026-06-17T02:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Then, if I understand it correctly, what this new tool does is give you a way to try to get some of the basic subscriber information, the kind that you would get in a production order, without having to go through the entire MLAT process, without having to go through the mutual treaty process. If, for whatever reason, the country that you're dealing with either doesn't allow it or doesn't accept whatever it is that our court produces, then you would still be able to go back and go at it through the MLAT process. There's no—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118997","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Then, if I understand it correctly, what this new tool does is give you a way to try to get some of the basic subscriber information, the kind that you would get in a production order, without having to go through the entire MLAT process, without having to go through the mutual treaty process. If, for whatever reason, the country that you're dealing with either doesn't allow it or doesn't accept w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","label":"Software","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e17cf28c46d71ed4b979f48c7f7bbd086c57f1312c77487720e177f6c9064f4b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ebddd76cefb4122949ee373b28ac9262639b73c0233cd8829a3357384751776"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7680ce28ac248816898d1ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118998,"date":"2026-06-17T02:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"That's exactly right. There's no double jeopardy aspect of it. If you're early in the investigation, as opposed to much further down the line when you're actually looking for more than the content, then you want to be able to use this tool instead of having to wait and try to find a bunch of other information. Basically, when you run out of other roads, you'll then go into the MLAT process, and it's a much bigger production. Is that a fair way to describe it? I can understand why the desire is there. Before I ask my next question, I want to go back to understanding why it's so important for Canadians to understand the trade-offs that we're making in this process. The exchange that we just had was so helpful. I hope it's been helpful to some of my colleagues who've been interested in this issue and have been chatting about it. We've been chatting about it a lot in the lobbies, behind the curtains and in the hallways. You've helped me understand that it's a much more limited tool, even though it's couched in the international process. It's not even a mini-MLAT. It's kind of apples and oranges. The reason it's so important for Canadians to understand the trade-offs being made is.... As you know, it's very rare that the debate is really about whether law enforcement should be able to investigate a crime. I think everybody wants law enforcement to be able to investigate crimes, and everyone agrees that they should. Where we need to figure out how to draw the line is between public safety and privacy. How much evidence should you have in your possession? How much evidence should be required before the state gains access to increasingly revealing digital information? The fact that digital information is so revealing is what sits behind Spencer. When the legislators choose this threshold, do you think you're expanding through this? What would the standard be? I'm trying to get at whether we're actually expanding the investigative power here. Is the standard for this non-MLAT process different from the standard that would exist if you were going through a full-blown application under an MLAT?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118998","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's exactly right. There's no double jeopardy aspect of it. If you're early in the investigation, as opposed to much further down the line when you're actually looking for more than the content, then you want to be able to use this tool instead of having to wait and try to find a bunch of other information. Basically, when you run out of other roads, you'll then go into the MLAT process, and it","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["467c2cc7d2d24bd65b333c58535c8f6e2c62e94e4edfc0f14cfb975e86ffdfb8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b684524a35a536e3d20c91ba70776c03408d42b5e7a9ed22a393c8aef834bfe4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53c4af9e3e3075c64e97d1e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1118999,"date":"2026-06-17T02:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Here is the question I'm getting at. You've made the case for why you believe it should be reasonable grounds to suspect instead of reasonable grounds to believe for the MLAT process, because all you're asking for—I'm putting \"all\" in air quotes for that—is the basic subscriber information—not the content of the message. You would ask for the content under the full-blown MLAT process. When you do the full-blown MLAT process, is the standard currently, before this law comes into place, reasonable grounds to believe, reasonable grounds to suspect or something totally different?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1118999","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Here is the question I'm getting at. You've made the case for why you believe it should be reasonable grounds to suspect instead of reasonable grounds to believe for the MLAT process, because all you're asking for—I'm putting \"all\" in air quotes for that—is the basic subscriber information—not the content of the message. You would ask for the content under the full-blown MLAT process. When you do ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99f4963d88fa755b466c0bb6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119000,"date":"2026-06-17T02:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"That helps to explain things for me. This has been a really clarifying conversation so far for me. What you're saying, I think, is that when it comes to this new process that didn't exist before this bill was drafted, the reason you picked the reasonable suspicion standard as opposed to the reasonable belief standard is that the type of information that you are trying to get through this is the kind of information that would have qualified under the reasonable belief standard as opposed to the reasonable suspicion standard in an MLAT process. Is that what you're trying to explain?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119000","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That helps to explain things for me. This has been a really clarifying conversation so far for me. What you're saying, I think, is that when it comes to this new process that didn't exist before this bill was drafted, the reason you picked the reasonable suspicion standard as opposed to the reasonable belief standard is that the type of information that you are trying to get through this is the ki","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6cd52ef8f6c778a6a6943e64714f098fbba6be802a2a4e393bbcbd0e43e2a57d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f361c88a18b720b937bf9fa8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119001,"date":"2026-06-17T02:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"You're describing an outgoing request. If the Americans have lower standards, we can take advantage of that. When it's an incoming request for an MLAT, and another country is asking for our basic subscriber information now, before this tool exists, do you use the reasonable grounds to suspect test or the reasonable grounds to believe test? Is it different when they ask for content? What are the standards that are currently being used?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119001","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You're describing an outgoing request. If the Americans have lower standards, we can take advantage of that. When it's an incoming request for an MLAT, and another country is asking for our basic subscriber information now, before this tool exists, do you use the reasonable grounds to suspect test or the reasonable grounds to believe test? Is it different when they ask for content? What are the st","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-720b91a4ec093356daacd6aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119002,"date":"2026-06-17T02:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Right. What you're proposing is a different process where we do, in fact, use a lower standard than the one that is currently being used.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119002","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Right. What you're proposing is a different process where we do, in fact, use a lower standard than the one that is currently being used.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["befc5b5adb0bc81863e14c211685689f367611bcc02d077926e95267dc2ee1a7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2011534683fabf8406a6ed2d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119003,"date":"2026-06-17T02:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"No, the last clause is not law, but it is the wording of the legislation. I think it's still correct. If it were passed the way it's currently written, that is the standard that would be used. That helps lay bare.... To my colleagues, Ms. May and Ms. DeBellefeuille, I hope this has been helpful. I hope that we now understand what we are dealing with. It's that, under the existing tool, the standard that is currently used, no matter what kind of information it is, for Canadians' private information is, in fact, the reasonable grounds to believe test. What's being created here is a new tool that extracts part of that process and applies a different standard that is more permissive. Without putting words in my colleagues' mouths, the reason all three of the opposition parties have put forward amendments to raise that standard in this context and the reason.... I don't believe that Ms. May and the Green Party have an amendment, but certainly I think....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119003","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, the last clause is not law, but it is the wording of the legislation. I think it's still correct. If it were passed the way it's currently written, that is the standard that would be used. That helps lay bare.... To my colleagues, Ms. May and Ms. DeBellefeuille, I hope this has been helpful. I hope that we now understand what we are dealing with. It's that, under the existing tool, the standar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e7d587824b50d63dd15e97b8eb5affccd37dd01f3510d4cadd69e373254f600"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be36b56f33cebe299dddf708","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119004,"date":"2026-06-17T03:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"Do you have an amendment on this? No. Then, three parties have made an amendment to go to the standard that would normally be used for this information in the current court system, and Ms. May has also expressed concerns to me that.... Yes, I'm seeing thumbs-up from Ms. May.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119004","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you have an amendment on this? No. Then, three parties have made an amendment to go to the standard that would normally be used for this information in the current court system, and Ms. May has also expressed concerns to me that.... Yes, I'm seeing thumbs-up from Ms. May.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4f6cf69c21ca113687a1cd840d67123370033ca544c8f1e9c580b8201256331"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-36aa22af5e332a05712af31c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119005,"date":"2026-06-17T03:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I now want to explain why I think...and I really hope that Canadians watching this at home now understand what was actually a very complicated clause. I see my colleague from the Bloc, Madame DeBellefeuille, nodding at this, because I think we're now actually on the same page, and it is that there has been a new tool created, and it uses a different standard from what would be used today for the same information. I certainly understand why law enforcement wants to lower the standard. I really do. At the same time, though, I think it's important to remember the reason privacy rights are so...interesting isn't even the right word. The reason they resonate so much with Canadians is that privacy rights are one of those types of rights that are often lost quietly and incrementally. When I gave my speech on this in the House, my initial speech on Bill C-22 , I talked about a fable. I'm not going to repeat that fable now, because I know that my colleagues across the way are looking for clips. However, I would urge people to look at my speech on Bill C-22 and look at the analogy that was made. It includes a story that talks about how privacy rights are lost incrementally. Privacy rights are often lost quietly. Many people don't know when their information has been sought or disclosed. It is one of the features of this digital age where we have to give up so much of our information if we want to use tools that are available to us. Unlike many other government decisions, the people affected by changes to privacy rights often never have the opportunity to challenge the decision or even to learn that it has occurred. We learn about so many breaches of our information through an email some number of months later. This is something that the Privacy Commissioner has really grappled with over the years. This places a special responsibility on Parliament and on parliamentarians to scrutinize these powers carefully before they're granted, because privacy is not just an individual concern; it is a democratic one. The countries that do not have privacy rights are often countries for which we worry about the state of their democracy. The ability to communicate, to read, to research, to associate with others and to participate in public debate without undue surveillance is part of what allows a free society to function. In every generation, at every stage of our being, we face new technologies and new investigative tools. The challenge for us in this committee is not whether we should adapt to those changes but how to do that while we preserve the freedoms and expectations of privacy that Canadians rightly value. That's why debates over clauses like this matter. They're not merely technical amendments to a statute. The choice between \"believe\" and \"suspect\" may seem mundane to our colleagues across the table, but when all four opposition parties and so many experts have come to committee to highlight the difference between those words, I think it is really important, and it deserves careful scrutiny and understanding. With that, I really want to thank the witnesses again for helping us understand what the difference...what it is that matters here. While I would submit to you that the conversation we've had over the last few minutes has been illuminating with respect to this clause, I think—I hope—it has also explained and validated the reason that the opposition members of this committee, from all parties, voted against this standard in respect of the production orders. I agree with Ms. Gibner. The standard that we apply.... The standard that we give citizens from other countries should not be higher than the standard that we give to our own citizens, but this conversation has revealed that we do have a change. It is a new tool, but it is a tool that allows information that would normally have to go through another process, that would normally attract a higher standard of scrutiny, to be received using a lower standard. What we haven't talked about, and what I suspect one of my colleagues will cover through some of the case law he's brought with him, is why it matters. An hon. member: It's for later. Tamara Kronis: Is it for later? All right. Well, it's going to come up in this. I think we now understand the difference and what we're doing here, but the issue is that the standard of reasonable grounds to suspect as opposed to believe—suspicion as opposed to the higher standard—usually applies in situations where there is exigency. It usually applies in situations where there are special concerns. I would note that this is not a tool that can only be used under exigent circumstances. It's a tool that has been created to be used by law enforcement wherever it sees fit. That is why the standard and the difference in the standard matter. I'll stop there, Mr. Chair, because I think I've done a piece of the work that we need to do in this committee. An hon. member: Encore, encore. Voices: Oh, oh! Tamara Kronis: It's to get us all on the same page on what we're talking about here, what the difference is between the existing standard and the new tool that's being created, and why it matters in the context of privacy law. I hope this conversation will allow us to really be able to make a good decision about which standard we should choose—the standard that already exists or the lower standard that the government would like to use in this bill. It's up to them to justify why using a lower standard is necessary. While the witnesses have been wonderful in explaining how they would use this and what it is, I haven't actually heard the case for why it's necessary. I'll stop there, Mr. Chair. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119005","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I now want to explain why I think...and I really hope that Canadians watching this at home now understand what was actually a very complicated clause. I see my colleague from the Bloc, Madame DeBellefeuille, nodding at this, because I think we're now actually on the same page, and it is that there has been a new tool created, and it uses a different standard from what would be used today for the s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1e74dfce078d62fa50eb9e04afdb556c529404a431f7870d08f28fc8de725e35"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["180f5b36913534b0430ba08da490d6ec7a7c0477ac40c502c00c9976b71a0ecc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f11f1f0881fa76a1228c76df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119006,"date":"2026-06-17T03:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"I have a point of order, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119006","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cca669503d8a5ea395831f75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119007,"date":"2026-06-17T03:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"No one is disregarding what was said. I think we were very clear that we think the committee got it wrong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119007","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No one is disregarding what was said. I think we were very clear that we think the committee got it wrong.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c89766e191165be5f37200dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119008,"date":"2026-06-17T03:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"That's not true.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119008","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's not true.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-853d6070d47a7cc408c81362","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119009,"date":"2026-06-17T03:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"SECU","text":"It wasn't 56 minutes. An hon. member: You had 56 minutes. Let Anthony speak.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119009","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It wasn't 56 minutes. An hon. member: You had 56 minutes. Let Anthony speak.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04ab80bf74b6d5ffe6115aa7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087989,"date":"2026-06-18T20:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tamara Kronis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, here is the thing: The Cowichan Tribe decision introduced uncertainty around how aboriginal title interacts with private property in B.C. While the Supreme Court declined an appeal in Wolastoqey, a refusal of leave is not a decision on the merits and does not create binding national precedent. This leaves Canadians with competing legal approaches on a critical legal question, all while Liberal directive 14, which discourages private property defences, remains in force and a Cowichan appeal is many months away.\n\nB.C. deserves to know now how the Liberals will provide the certainty we need. Where—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087989","member_id":"bc-mp-111025","member_name":"Tamara Kronis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, here is the thing: The Cowichan Tribe decision introduced uncertainty around how aboriginal title interacts with private property in B.C. While the Supreme Court declined an appeal in Wolastoqey, a refusal of leave is not a decision on the merits and does not create binding national precedent. This leaves Canadians with competing legal approaches on a critical legal question, all whil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63845f3952e8fb3c1e3d53b3536fa22745522b3a41a02bfa80bbaf16fee5f2e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["756bc9128939a141c5d6f5eb1effbd7953926c95d5b385f28a16247e5419535d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cff61f2334a76b0b42af2ab7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76654,"date":"2026-01-27T18:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my dear friend and colleague from Kingston for his passionate speech and for talking about the importance of having meaningful dialogue in the House. He spoke about opportunities. British Columbians in Richmond and people from across the country want to know what opportunities we are working on right now.\n\nCould he shed some light on real, meaningful things that are happening for Canada and what our Prime Minister is doing for this country, with a focus on what really matters? Like the legendary artist DJ Quik said, \"If it don't make dollars, it don't make sense\".","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76654","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my dear friend and colleague from Kingston for his passionate speech and for talking about the importance of having meaningful dialogue in the House. He spoke about opportunities. British Columbians in Richmond and people from across the country want to know what opportunities we are working on right now.\n\nCould he shed some light on real, meaningful things that are ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60f2679f88d61f0054a7ce4c4deca4686818b37ff4a7bb95ce1a923964fee9cd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bfb6689a46370bf937c69d7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":290982,"date":"2026-02-10T17:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for all of his hard work, especially on this topic and the challenges we are seeing with extortion and other crimes.\n\nWe all know that as criminal organizations evolve, they look at new ways to do things. Can the member for Surrey Newton let me know what he is hearing on the ground about the kinds of changes being made, and how important people think these changes are that we are bringing forward?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:290982","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for all of his hard work, especially on this topic and the challenges we are seeing with extortion and other crimes.\n\nWe all know that as criminal organizations evolve, they look at new ways to do things. Can the member for Surrey Newton let me know what he is hearing on the ground about the kinds of changes being made, and how important people think these c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e5edf346a6770c7c23b52d1f3008345c8546709ab88523ae232a3e5f8f36702d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a05d781dbedd4fbd17fe0a92894fb00ff6720f9533e75b1fee706820bd8593a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27dada98cbb30e0f809dbde1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":290983,"date":"2026-02-10T20:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for St. Catharines. \n\nToday, I will focus on how our immigration system responds to concerns about non-citizens who are accused or convicted of serious criminal offences, as well as the decision-making process of admitting, investigating and removing a non-citizen. \n\nI want to emphasize how upholding these rules, and the independence of these processes, is critical to our country. Canadians rightly expect that our immigration system will protect everyone in this country and that our laws are applied consistently and respond to their concerns, especially concerns about serious criminal acts. We want the decisions of our justice and immigration systems to be fair, efficient and final, and we expect that these decisions are made thoughtfully, lawfully and in alignment with our democratic values. \n\nSerious criminality has serious consequences in this country. These cases are deeply troubling, and our hearts go out to victims and their families. Our laws are already clear: Individuals who commit serious crimes face consequences. Immigration law is clear that serious criminality has serious implications for admissibility and continued presence in Canada. \n\nBefore going further, it is important to clarify roles. Criminal investigations, prosecutions, sentencing and court procedures fall within the authority of police services, prosecutors and the courts. Those matters are addressed by other departments. My remarks today will focus on immigration consequences under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.\n\nSecurity and public safety measures begin before arrival. Canada's immigration screening process is intentionally multi-layered. It involves Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada; the Canada Border Services Agency; and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service. Every applicant is assessed for criminality, terrorism, human rights violations, organized crime, espionage and public health risks, despite a lot of the misinformation we hear coming from the other side. Screening occurs before travel, at the border, and where necessary, after entry into Canada. This layered approach ensures that the system is responsive, adaptable and capable of addressing evolving threats. \n\nTo enhance our control over the system, our government has prioritized strengthening document control in recent years. Since January 2025, explicit authorities came into force for our immigration and border officers to cancel temporary resident documents, such as visas and electronic travel authorizations, on a case-by-case basis, when new information comes to light that someone is inadmissible or is no longer eligible to hold their document. They also have the authority in more limited circumstances to cancel study and work permits. This helps Canadians keep Canadians safe and migration orderly.\n\n Additionally, we are seeking new authorities under Bill C-12 that would further strengthen the government's ability to manage immigration documents and applications. Included within these authorities are measures that would authorize the Governor in Council to make an order, when it is in the public interest, to cancel, suspend or change groups of immigration documents, to pause or suspend application processing or to stop the intake of new applications on a large scale. These authorities would ensure that the government is better able to manage immigration documents and applications when required to protect the public interest.\n\n This is just one example of how IRCC is continually strengthening control over our immigration and asylum systems to the benefit of Canadians and communities. Additionally, we work closely with domestic and international partners to identify risks, share information and respond to concerns as they are identified.\n\n The system is proactive as well as reactive. When misrepresentation or criminal history is discovered, individuals may be found inadmissible on the grounds of serious criminality and misrepresentation. Officials can move immediately under the law to issue a removal order. \n\nUnder the Refugee and Immigration Protection Act, Parliament has carefully balanced thresholds for inadmissibility and removal based on Canadian law and international obligations, including our obligations not to create stateless people and not to return people to danger. \n\nThe act already contains some of the strictest provisions among like-minded and democratic countries. Non-citizens convicted of serious criminality are inadmissible to Canada. Those sentenced to six months or more of imprisonment have no right of appeal to the immigration appeal division. \n\nThere is no special treatment for criminals, including violent offenders, under Canada's immigration law. Criminal proceedings take precedence over immigration proceedings. When a non-citizen is convicted of a serious crime, they must serve their sentence, and immigration consequences follow. These consequences are set out in legislation and applied through established legal processes. These serious criminal convictions mean people are subject to a removal order. \n\nThe Canada Border Services Agency is empowered to investigate, issue removal orders and carry out deportations. Its work is governed by the laws set by Parliament, following due process. Decisions are subject to review by the courts to place a check against potential errors. \n\nEffective immigration enforcement is not measured by rhetoric but by results, and the results demonstrate that Canada's enforcement system is active and effective. In 2023-24, the Canada Border Services Agency prevented more than 9,000 individuals from boarding flights to Canada and denied entry to 34,000 people at ports of entry. Within Canada, the CBSA removed well over 700 individuals found inadmissible for serious criminality. The results for the first 10 months of 2025 surpassed the results for 12 months in 2024, showing sustained progress. \n\nCanadians want an immigration system that is fast and efficient and that upholds the independence of our judicial and law enforcement systems. That is why our focus has been on a system that carefully screens applicants, responds to new information and applies the laws consistently. \n\nWe have introduced measures to make the system stronger and more efficient. For example, Bill C-12 introduces strong information sharing and coordination across departments, things that are essential to public safety. This measure could reduce the amount of time it takes to detect a problematic security issue and take action. \n\nWhen programs operate in silos, discrepancies and risks can be missed. Bill C-12 would modernize information-sharing authorities within IRCC and with authorized domestic partners to strengthen integrity and improve decision-making. These authorities would allow the Department of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship to share identity, status and document information with domestic partners when there is a lawful purpose for doing so, and that includes with our law enforcement. \n\nThe new information-sharing authorities would reduce duplication, improve efficiency and enhance program integrity. They would do this while protecting privacy. Any new use or disclosure of personal information from these new authorities would remain subject to existing privacy legislation, policies, guidelines and best practices, including privacy impact assessments. These safeguards would ensure that integrity measures are balanced with a strong protection of personal information. \n\nIt is important to be clear about what Bill C-12 would and would not change in relation to criminality and removals. Bill C-12 would not alter existing thresholds for inadmissibility or removal. Canadian law already establishes a threshold for serious criminality for the purpose of inadmissibility, one that, unlike the Conservatives' failed proposals, would not risk targeting the wrong people or providing relative leniency to temporary residents compared to permanent residents. \n\nWe will uphold tough measures to address criminals, as well as the due process that demonstrates to us, to all residents of Canada, that we respect democracy and the rule of law. \n\nCriminals adapt fast, and government must do more than keep up. It must get ahead of them. In that spirit, we will continue to improve the sophistication of Canada's criminal response tools to keep Canadians safe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:290983","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for St. Catharines. \n\nToday, I will focus on how our immigration system responds to concerns about non-citizens who are accused or convicted of serious criminal offences, as well as the decision-making process of admitting, investigating and removing a non-citizen. \n\nI want to emphasize how upholding these rules, and the independence of these ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e27c148d22b11d41e7b01ca1ba07e3dd0b5f2bd71e0fe4b2ce880ffd9b0c906"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f39c38012d9db24a4211b5c65b86694eca92947d5e10061ff0a02d11ad249ed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1bce917cea766174480ecc80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":290984,"date":"2026-02-10T20:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member talked about how we talk tough, but we are doing more than just talking tough. What we are seeing here is a war of words.\n\n Quite frankly, we have made major additions, not only with bringing back mandatory minimum sentences but also with everything from Bill C-12 to Bill C-2, the borders act. We can talk about strengthening something, but we need the Conservatives to stop blocking what we are doing here in this House and come along to make these changes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:290984","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member talked about how we talk tough, but we are doing more than just talking tough. What we are seeing here is a war of words.\n\n Quite frankly, we have made major additions, not only with bringing back mandatory minimum sentences but also with everything from Bill C-12 to Bill C-2, the borders act. We can talk about strengthening something, but we need the Conservatives to stop ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083668","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083668","label":"Language education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["79e1101c85295949ff3391ee90c2eb0fd726c53be5b64a32ee054d6c9fe19c1c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efd8867d79b4d779f05f4011","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":290985,"date":"2026-02-10T20:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I talked about how criminals adapt fast and how we have to stay ahead.\n\n Many of the measures we have introduced, many of which the member just indicated, build upon things that we have done, things like Bill C-70, the foreign interference act. It has many measures that will help us deal with the issues around extortion.\n\n We need to move quickly on all of the measures that have been introduced in this House over the past few months to continue not only to adapt to what the criminals are doing but also to move ahead of them and make these changes quickly. We need the Conservatives to join us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:290985","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I talked about how criminals adapt fast and how we have to stay ahead.\n\n Many of the measures we have introduced, many of which the member just indicated, build upon things that we have done, things like Bill C-70, the foreign interference act. It has many measures that will help us deal with the issues around extortion.\n\n We need to move quickly on all of the measures that have been ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2d3aa0b3fd148ba6529877d19bbef1084916a88ff3f451b84dbd9d0913a145d4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1fddfe95d282b3fc7e99a7583da509684503f51b7725ac2f8bf74a2bdbbca27f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b9b405dd2bc875b915be2d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":290986,"date":"2026-02-10T20:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, whether the member likes it or not, Bill C-16 reinstates mandatory minimum sentences.\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nParm Bains: I have already answered the question. \n\nMr. Speaker, the member needs to read the legislation and join us. Let us make these changes quickly. I know members across the way from British Columbia want this to happen very quickly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:290986","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, whether the member likes it or not, Bill C-16 reinstates mandatory minimum sentences.\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nParm Bains: I have already answered the question. \n\nMr. Speaker, the member needs to read the legislation and join us. Let us make these changes quickly. I know members across the way from British Columbia want this to happen very quickly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7008ca8ddaf21cb4a216a06","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":290987,"date":"2026-02-10T20:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I heard from the member across—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:290987","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I heard from the member across—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83050237c96e140ce7ce69ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":291772,"date":"2026-02-10T20:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard from many members across the way who claim that it would allow house arrest for serious crimes, such as extortion. This is simply incorrect.\n\n Conditional sentences or sentence orders are never available when the sentence is two years or more, which is typically the case. We also maintain mandatory jail time for extortion involving restricted or illegal firearms, as well as extortion connected to criminal organizations. It is clear. It is right there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:291772","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard from many members across the way who claim that it would allow house arrest for serious crimes, such as extortion. This is simply incorrect.\n\n Conditional sentences or sentence orders are never available when the sentence is two years or more, which is typically the case. We also maintain mandatory jail time for extortion involving restricted or illegal firearms, as well","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c99a5fb77d5c7c77e3d3b2db994004f44eda083436e496f56c1fe1af8be0bb23"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["244c92d4847aabcf4d8291518669110ec564ac2fc170d6ffa59b2f8850cd438f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1cef73551f20162f0e9db505","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1148645,"date":"2026-03-11T15:40:35+00:00","title":"An Act to establish a national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"An Act to establish a national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-266","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-266","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1148645","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"An Act to establish a national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7912fde0fe5f506e417e4fb2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342470,"date":"2026-03-11T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in 2025, the port of Vancouver had a record-breaking year for exports, moving more Canadian goods to global markets than ever before. This is a point of pride for the constituents in Richmond East—Steveston, who help power this success every day through their work in trade, transportation and port operations.\n\n Could the Minister of International Trade update the House on what this record-setting year at the port of Vancouver means for Canadian workers and for Canada's growing trade opportunities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342470","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in 2025, the port of Vancouver had a record-breaking year for exports, moving more Canadian goods to global markets than ever before. This is a point of pride for the constituents in Richmond East—Steveston, who help power this success every day through their work in trade, transportation and port operations.\n\n Could the Minister of International Trade update the House on what this re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f6cd299a71704a3427dc323d07595acc436131c30c93e0ce830715077695aecd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c3b0aed2ca14b0b8ee3c5e54134e5a840658034a730419c2d64ca968b0dc252c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d698432f606ac262ccb8d13c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342471,"date":"2026-03-11T20:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-266, An Act to establish a national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present my first private member's bill.\n\nMovement of skilled labour across Canada is essential to the country's economic development, productivity, infrastructure, delivery and competitiveness. However, regulatory barriers, as well as inconsistencies between certification processes across provinces and territories, hinder skilled trades and workers' mobility, and they delay national development priorities like housing, transportation, infrastructure and energy projects.\n\nOn this World Plumbing Day, and as a former aircraft maintenance engineer, I understand the challenges trades workers face when they try to take their skills on the road. My bill would help these workers take their skills from the Pacific Salish Sea to the Atlantic. While respecting provincial and territorial jurisdiction over training, certification and labour market regulation, my bill, an act to establish a national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility, calls on the government to work with provinces, territories, trade skills associations and unions to modernize, harmonize and streamline credential recognition.\n\nI look forward to a spirited debate on this important issue for Canada's future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342471","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-266, An Act to establish a national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present my first private member's bill.\n\nMovement of skilled labour across Canada is essential to the country's economic development, productivity, infrastructure, delivery and competitiveness. However, regulatory barriers, as well ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["11ff1730b0249f2f554e5aca341498ed032c49fde1d3e5f238b2497521964f19"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["784654f42f6f357a3a045b107becb44e234369ee4a787d3319fd2eae05ce922c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3719935b7065933340416106","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":342469,"date":"2026-03-12T19:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, representatives of the Kidney Foundation of Canada are on the Hill this week. March 12 is World Kidney Day, and the foundation is launching its national strategic framework for chronic kidney disease, Canada's first unified road map to move kidney care from reactive and fragmented to proactive, coordinated and resilient.\n\n As someone born with a solitary kidney, who has undergone dialysis and who has received a transplant, I know the importance of early detection, timely treatment and strong medical teams. I am grateful to all the medical professionals and to organizations like Canadian Blood Services that offer hope to patients nationwide. Thanks to the dedicated medical and transplant teams at Vancouver General Hospital, I am here today. I thank the Kidney Foundation for its leadership and its commitment to a healthier future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:342469","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, representatives of the Kidney Foundation of Canada are on the Hill this week. March 12 is World Kidney Day, and the foundation is launching its national strategic framework for chronic kidney disease, Canada's first unified road map to move kidney care from reactive and fragmented to proactive, coordinated and resilient.\n\n As someone born with a solitary kidney, who has undergone dial","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","label":"Transplantation (Medicine)"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0b319a0e632d8f13805a82a4a72dabb9eb39c0f291ada27c955b660391339b2b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d051a2c57ab5a12bb7c897dccd1e89cc07ec5b2aa780da343f12e9baa6efa70"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04863ba5cb25d5af94871d04","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":501195,"date":"2026-04-15T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, global conflicts and chaotic and irrational decision-making with critical oil supply chains have led to increased global prices. While these events seem distant, they are already pushing prices higher at the pump and the grocery store and causing Canadians to rethink where they are booking their summer holiday.\n\nBudget 2025 laid out how Canada's new majority government will create a more independent and resilient Canadian economy. Can the secretary of state lay out how our government is supporting Canadians day to day?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501195","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, global conflicts and chaotic and irrational decision-making with critical oil supply chains have led to increased global prices. While these events seem distant, they are already pushing prices higher at the pump and the grocery store and causing Canadians to rethink where they are booking their summer holiday.\n\nBudget 2025 laid out how Canada's new majority government will create a m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d9d8b3009bf21c27cc65e96995c0ec232bae2746365883969f9e79d90045236"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5553edd3ea1e512f09aa521f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119016,"date":"2026-04-16T16:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today. My first question is for Mr. Kabbara. I'll reference a report on your website. It's titled \"Exporting the Future Economy\". It states that \"exports in clean energy supply chains grew 21% faster than all other exports over the last five years\" and that they're growing faster with partners outside of the U.S. In other words, they're already diversifying our economy, and with the targeted industrial strategy, they could help Canada unlock $600 billion in annual export opportunity by 2035. You spoke quite a bit about this in your answers. Which exports are these specifically, and to which non-U.S. partners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119016","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today. My first question is for Mr. Kabbara. I'll reference a report on your website. It's titled \"Exporting the Future Economy\". It states that \"exports in clean energy supply chains grew 21% faster than all other exports over the last five years\" and that they're growing faster with partners outside of the U.S. In other words, they'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28c23ced45e330aceaad8c735686f0665e25e478e709124fde8fdb7a824dcb03"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a5b115c134baffe2623ca9a4a6df3f30c78d9426f6b67e58d77fbe6e2a88b6c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e96bf61b89ddc67c4a028ea8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119017,"date":"2026-04-16T17:00:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"The report's conclusion indicates, \"Canada must concentrate this strategy on specific supply chain segments where it can achieve scale and capture high value-add\". Which areas can you share and maybe even make some recommendations on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119017","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The report's conclusion indicates, \"Canada must concentrate this strategy on specific supply chain segments where it can achieve scale and capture high value-add\". Which areas can you share and maybe even make some recommendations on?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","label":"Resource development","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dda4388fde70959e68a554dc937af7fa02ac013a298c0d80ac80826e2fc76359"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3eb511d6aaed5a251877090b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119018,"date":"2026-04-16T17:00:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you. I'll give some time back. I know we're waiting for the second panel. I'm happy to oblige.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119018","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I'll give some time back. I know we're waiting for the second panel. I'm happy to oblige.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4501f19b5b635337ed35d53b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119019,"date":"2026-04-16T17:30:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses. Off the top, I'm going to have to dispute some of the things Mr. Hinton has brought to the panel. We're trying to move up the supply chain, not down. This is simply a return. When we're talking about Chinese EVs, they're 3% of the total. That's lower than the total number of imported Kias that come here. We already see the value of Toyota and Honda, with Toyota building cars right here in Canada. I think the alarmist view is a bit over the top. There are 125,000 direct jobs and 500,000 indirect jobs. I'll go to Mr. McKinnon with my questions. We heard a lot from the previous panel. We know what's taking place in the auto sector with respect to the tariffs. Mr. Hinton talked about how there's no inkling of free trade between the U.S. and Canada. I think that's also false. Moving forward, in a recent report, Statistics Canada said, \"Wholesale sales (excluding petroleum, petroleum products, and other hydrocarbons and excluding oilseed and grain) rose 2.0% to $86.8 billion in February. Sales increased in five of the seven subsectors\", with the motor vehicles and motor vehicle parts and accessories subsector up 6.1%. How can Canada's auto sector capitalize on these gains?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119019","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses. Off the top, I'm going to have to dispute some of the things Mr. Hinton has brought to the panel. We're trying to move up the supply chain, not down. This is simply a return. When we're talking about Chinese EVs, they're 3% of the total. That's lower than the total number of imported Kias that come here. We already see the value of Toyota and Honda","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7eee69ee2ace616b52d16955a11d09ceb33a4452dae6654178336e82216423b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d121a2c2e8c99df00b745558fab5ce0381bd49f33b4faa930c460d6be02f22cc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-036d616845921432d54875ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119020,"date":"2026-04-16T17:35:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"The Prime Minister has been clear that Canada needs to strengthen trade and industrial partnerships with reliable allies. Canada recently deepened its strategic partnership with the Republic of Korea by signing a memorandum of understanding to strengthen Canada-Korea industrial collaboration for future mobility, building on other MOUs that Canada has signed with global automakers to promote further co-operation. Is this the kind of partnership you think Canada needs to develop to remain competitive in the future?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119020","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Prime Minister has been clear that Canada needs to strengthen trade and industrial partnerships with reliable allies. Canada recently deepened its strategic partnership with the Republic of Korea by signing a memorandum of understanding to strengthen Canada-Korea industrial collaboration for future mobility, building on other MOUs that Canada has signed with global automakers to promote furthe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0bd2ec00fbd1e0c0b8515d039118c1067709cba36426dc2cc428d7b110be9112"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bfbf57ad7d5dee490921fc96","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119021,"date":"2026-04-16T17:35:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"What if we don't? Could you speak to what happens if we don't make these co-operative deals? We heard from the previous panel that other allied nations are working forward in this way. If we get left behind, what happens?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119021","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What if we don't? Could you speak to what happens if we don't make these co-operative deals? We heard from the previous panel that other allied nations are working forward in this way. If we get left behind, what happens?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Allied forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","label":"Allied forces","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5655fe62b7054b2eb27e62cd83813747174d8e621d0cb16c2956eb21277d47e5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46e77d3cf69c7cc4bf85204a513ebe7b0be80f8ab93c19a41eaea793d693aca1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-796643c7ba234ad4d25dbb7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119022,"date":"2026-04-16T17:35:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"I'll continue along that same pathway. Previous witnesses offered different perspectives on whether Canada should maintain automotive regulatory harmony with the U.S.A., which is looking to roll back the clock on things like emissions standards or keep pace with the EU and other global partners. What's your view on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119022","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll continue along that same pathway. Previous witnesses offered different perspectives on whether Canada should maintain automotive regulatory harmony with the U.S.A., which is looking to roll back the clock on things like emissions standards or keep pace with the EU and other global partners. What's your view on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["10f901a4c27cb2be5ad6eda6f93cd566dc7e67a8755459e39ffecf408428b901"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34854b46a78c7b94c06e94d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119023,"date":"2026-04-16T17:35:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Dr. Fischmeister, you've talked a lot about sovereign sustainability in the context of electronics for vehicles and critical systems. We heard in previous testimony that QNX software, which has already been sold to different Chinese EV manufacturers, would be a great system to use for sovereign cybersecurity protection made and built in Canada. How can we turn our approach to focus more on the software of these connected vehicles, given that many of these cars are really computers on wheels, as we've heard from many people? That question is for Dr. Fischmeister.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119023","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Dr. Fischmeister, you've talked a lot about sovereign sustainability in the context of electronics for vehicles and critical systems. We heard in previous testimony that QNX software, which has already been sold to different Chinese EV manufacturers, would be a great system to use for sovereign cybersecurity protection made and built in Canada. How can we turn our approach to focus more on the sof","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c5f81e5ffbbc5beadc7e473","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119024,"date":"2026-04-20T21:25:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today. We've talked quite a bit about the tariffs and the challenges they're posing. We also heard today that the Supreme Court in the U.S. is starting to pay back some of the tariffs, but I think the real solutions we've talked about here still need to be.... The negotiations need to happen. I wanted to talk a bit, maybe with you, Ms. Vlanich. You talked about Canada's mould, tool and die machine sector, and you mentioned aerospace. I have a background in aerospace. I'm curious. Could you talk a bit about the $16 billion that has been mentioned? The industry exports $6 billion to $8 billion annually from the mould, tool and die machine sector to the U.S. Do you have other figures for the remaining $10 billion, broken down between domestic consumption and non-U.S. exports?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119024","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today. We've talked quite a bit about the tariffs and the challenges they're posing. We also heard today that the Supreme Court in the U.S. is starting to pay back some of the tariffs, but I think the real solutions we've talked about here still need to be.... The negotiations need to happen. I wanted to talk a bit, maybe with you, Ms","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e904f1e761eecf1182a79b03ef94f561bae0bf80ab4bb2f81477c3da9a0997f7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b9dbc70414ac397f322ab770b13288c2acfdcc73e53eedaca923fcb88368b2a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88fdf11ab08d02d9cbe0bb66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119025,"date":"2026-04-20T21:25:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Yes, please, and then maybe give the ripple effects you're talking about with the various sectors—automotive, of course, being the biggest and one we've talked a lot about here—and how these effects will ripple through supply chains to consumers, sector by sector. Are there others? I mentioned aerospace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119025","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, please, and then maybe give the ripple effects you're talking about with the various sectors—automotive, of course, being the biggest and one we've talked a lot about here—and how these effects will ripple through supply chains to consumers, sector by sector. Are there others? I mentioned aerospace.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["99cfa7da3d9d6c2d45cea438986facfb6df66a08dd286029a4db95f763e33cfa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c44627c8c8e4483d77f1aa1211f6856c1d27641b62d596bd2b8e8837375dea4a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a392f5e5c65e06cd2c28d454","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119026,"date":"2026-04-20T21:30:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Again, we talked a bit about the tools and the various sectors. It's hitting all these different sectors. Maybe you can talk a little bit about past difficulties dealing with tariffs. Has that happened? How has your industry responded to that? I'm also wondering how vocal your organization has been and what you're doing right now on the ground in Washington, D.C.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119026","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Again, we talked a bit about the tools and the various sectors. It's hitting all these different sectors. Maybe you can talk a little bit about past difficulties dealing with tariffs. Has that happened? How has your industry responded to that? I'm also wondering how vocal your organization has been and what you're doing right now on the ground in Washington, D.C.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cfd7d051c5249d84121e32a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119027,"date":"2026-04-20T21:30:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Maybe I'll switch to you, Mr. Azzopardi. You talked about being at the table in Washington, D.C. I would ask you a similar question with regard to what you're doing right now. You said you talk to people you're working with. You're calling your clients. Have you gone there? Have you had some discussions? Are they supporting those discussions at the table?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119027","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Maybe I'll switch to you, Mr. Azzopardi. You talked about being at the table in Washington, D.C. I would ask you a similar question with regard to what you're doing right now. You said you talk to people you're working with. You're calling your clients. Have you gone there? Have you had some discussions? Are they supporting those discussions at the table?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67e5865f57d6ff60f044097d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119028,"date":"2026-04-20T21:30:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119028","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14dede6a8adce2817e8c3fad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119029,"date":"2026-04-20T22:20:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Again, thank you to the witnesses for joining us and sharing the troubles that are happening right now in the moulding industry. We've heard from the second panel that there's a lot of uncertainty and unpredictability in planning, and that there are challenges around that. I want to first go to Mr. Jebely. Could you talk about how far in advance you have to place orders for your inputs when you're doing a project and getting an order, and how the tariffs have affected the predictability of your input costs? Ultimately, I want to get to recommendations. We heard a bit from previous witnesses, who shared some recommendations they have for government. Maybe build on some of the things you can share.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119029","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Again, thank you to the witnesses for joining us and sharing the troubles that are happening right now in the moulding industry. We've heard from the second panel that there's a lot of uncertainty and unpredictability in planning, and that there are challenges around that. I want to first go to Mr. Jebely. Could you talk about how far in advance you have to place orders for y","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d7a8ef96d407ae1dc2a95c16814863be24adec5f8589f411a8b944a717964df1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55792cff4433b6d552fa3dad7637b8c7c298eff6b84ca9d6a87e9bd2f0ab7511"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d71d0f67292920bd23bdfc1c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119030,"date":"2026-04-20T22:25:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"In July, the U.S. and South Korea reached a trade deal. It was aimed at avoiding high tariffs before an August 1 deadline. South Korea agreed to invest $350 billion in the U.S. and open its markets. Despite that, we saw Donald Trump announce another 15% tariff on many South Korean imports. Again, the predictability they may have negotiated ultimately did not materialize. We understand this is the type of challenge we're facing as a nation. Again, I want to get some potential recommendations—some low-hanging fruit regarding things we can do. I will switch to Mr.—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119030","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In July, the U.S. and South Korea reached a trade deal. It was aimed at avoiding high tariffs before an August 1 deadline. South Korea agreed to invest $350 billion in the U.S. and open its markets. Despite that, we saw Donald Trump announce another 15% tariff on many South Korean imports. Again, the predictability they may have negotiated ultimately did not materialize. We understand this is the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["85290d6db1939c30a2a2db8156445e3d1d4953137650ce045cfdf2999f82a1b2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["22ca1b5f3b46aa5c2fa507d912a633105eb68763ac630c6377d560e79310ad16"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c98720df01310ed1c9ada077","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119031,"date":"2026-04-20T22:25:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"I'm going to switch to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119031","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm going to switch to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a86f59c6d3b01b1e8884d12","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119032,"date":"2026-04-20T22:25:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"If we're looking at diversifying into other markets, are you optimistic that there's an opportunity to do that now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119032","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If we're looking at diversifying into other markets, are you optimistic that there's an opportunity to do that now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036921","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036921","label":"Regional markets","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["369b40ec72d761186d06f65d5b089856e01472ccdc521c9862ad23b048e566d9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b941eda428ce5fb7dc21d430","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119033,"date":"2026-04-20T22:25:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Yes...to non-U.S. markets.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119033","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes...to non-U.S. markets.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb2319dd3cbbfedf59432d60","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119034,"date":"2026-04-23T16:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all of our witnesses for joining us today on this important and vital discussion on industry. I'm going to go to Mr. Anderson, to include him in the conversation. Earlier in April, the Saskatchewan Industrial and Mining Suppliers Association, the Organization of Canadian Nuclear Industries, and the Southeast Techhub received close to a million dollars in federal and provincial funding to support advanced nuclear supply chains in Saskatchewan. Could you talk about supply chains and advancing innovation and sustainable energy solutions in this whole context of the tariffs that are being applied? Just shed some light on what your thoughts are.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119034","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all of our witnesses for joining us today on this important and vital discussion on industry. I'm going to go to Mr. Anderson, to include him in the conversation. Earlier in April, the Saskatchewan Industrial and Mining Suppliers Association, the Organization of Canadian Nuclear Industries, and the Southeast Techhub received close to a million dollars in federal ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fec500287d32a02764f28acc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119035,"date":"2026-04-23T16:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"I think the rest of the mould-making and tool industries can benefit there, definitely. I will go to Mr. Donally. The war in Iran has caused a significant surge in prices for many of our commodities here—aluminum in my home province of British Columbia as well as Quebec, potash in Saskatchewan, and oil and gas in Alberta. Can this strengthen our position for the CUSMA review, in your view?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119035","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I think the rest of the mould-making and tool industries can benefit there, definitely. I will go to Mr. Donally. The war in Iran has caused a significant surge in prices for many of our commodities here—aluminum in my home province of British Columbia as well as Quebec, potash in Saskatchewan, and oil and gas in Alberta. Can this strengthen our position for the CUSMA review, in your view?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22217aa85cdd4e1e8606486c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119036,"date":"2026-04-23T16:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"I will continue with the Windsor Essex Chamber of Commerce. You have strong relationships with businesses and chambers across the border. You probably have strong relationships through your history of hockey too. What are your thoughts on the actions of the Trump administration and the effect it's had on their local economies? What are you hearing from your counterparts on the other side?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119036","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I will continue with the Windsor Essex Chamber of Commerce. You have strong relationships with businesses and chambers across the border. You probably have strong relationships through your history of hockey too. What are your thoughts on the actions of the Trump administration and the effect it's had on their local economies? What are you hearing from your counterparts on the other side?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5841522073155a463e08a717f0f02cd3ea4d24e89740f47bdc520f4ac4ac7c00"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95a22bb043a5df491ade231f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119037,"date":"2026-04-23T17:00:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Have they shared measurable impacts on their local economies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119037","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Have they shared measurable impacts on their local economies?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["86ec93e6022621cfff1652243e842f238a02cbc09f9d6e600949cc5de2bf7d82"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24e8551021cbcc229ff80ee8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119038,"date":"2026-04-23T17:00:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"There has been a lot said and a lot of news about the Gordie Howe bridge. Again, it's a similar type of question: What's the reaction in the community regarding the bridge coming online pretty soon? I believe the testing is happening right now. What are they talking about on the other side regarding good faith or the lack of good faith, potentially?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119038","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There has been a lot said and a lot of news about the Gordie Howe bridge. Again, it's a similar type of question: What's the reaction in the community regarding the bridge coming online pretty soon? I believe the testing is happening right now. What are they talking about on the other side regarding good faith or the lack of good faith, potentially?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Internet","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","label":"Internet","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5d8d85b7d60712a5924dc9bd60c034a0f63954ad8cfd8c7b1e8773dcb88be275"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["32f86fbeef00ada51cc33be362b283858136dd7d43e21a513a08311940812b42"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72740cdd4f73c4c3e0afd7c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119039,"date":"2026-04-23T17:00:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119039","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-845eaaa174245c3d12a6d14c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300981,"date":"2026-04-23T22:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that Bill C-266, An Act to establish a national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility, be read the second time and referred to a committee. \n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for Milton East—Halton Hills South for supporting this bill.\n\nIt is always a huge honour to stand in the House and speak on vital issues for Canadians. Today, I have an opportunity to speak at length on respecting skilled trades and labour.\n\nAs a former aircraft maintenance engineer, I spent countless hours turning wrenches at a hangar in my hometown of Richmond, British Columbia. When I was campaigning for re-election as MP for Richmond East—Steveston, I did not do it alone. I was supported by electricians, carpenters, construction workers and unions. Builders and everyday Canadian workers share my vision of a community and a Canada that works for them. It is for these Canadians that I tabled Bill C-266, a national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility.\n\nAt its core, this bill recognizes a simple truth: Canada cannot reach its full potential if the people who build it, our skilled trades workers, are prevented from working where they are needed the most. Movement of skilled trades and labour across Canada is essential to the country's economic development, productivity, infrastructure and competitiveness. However, our economy continues to be weighed down by a system of disjointed licensing requirements, certifications and other restrictions. This has evolved into significant non-tariff internal trade barriers.\n\nThe IMF estimates that Canada's economy could gain nearly 7%, or $210 billion, in real GDP over a gradual period by fully removing internal trade barriers between the country's 13 provinces and territories. This is not just inefficient; it is unacceptable. Across this country, from the shipyards of Vancouver to the construction sites of Halifax, from energy projects in Alberta to housing developments in Toronto, employers are facing unpredictability. On one hand, there are acute labour shortages delaying critical projects, and on the other, there are skilled, qualified workers in other parts of the country who are ready and willing to step in, but they are held back by regulatory barriers that make mobility difficult, costly and slow.\n\nA welder trained in Saskatchewan may encounter different certification requirements when attempting to work on major infrastructure projects in British Columbia. These inconsistencies do not improve safety or enhance quality. They create duplication, inefficiency and unnecessary costs.\n\nThe same holds true for major infrastructure projects. Whether it is expanding transit systems, upgrading ports or building clean energy infrastructure, delays in mobilizing skilled labour translate directly into higher costs and missed opportunities. Every week that a project is delayed because workers cannot be certified quickly enough is a week that Canadians are left waiting for essential services and economic benefits.\n\nOf course, there were efforts to correct this growing problem. If we go back to the Agreement on Internal Trade in 1995, it would, \"enable any worker certified for an occupation by a regulatory authority of one Party to be recognized as qualified for that occupation by all other Parties.\" Regrettably, the AIT did not achieve this crucial goal, which is why in December 2014, the federal, provincial and territorial governments began negotiations to strengthen and modernize into the Canada Free Trade Agreement.\n\nThe Red Seal program has been an important step forward toward standardization, allowing certified workers in certain trades to move more easily between provinces. However, not all trades are covered, and even within the program, variations and administrative barriers can persist.\n\nEfforts to harmonize certifications and labour regulations across Canada's economy made limited progress, not because electricians who reside in Manitoba have unique insight into the functions of an electrical circuit compared to electricians who reside in Nova Scotia or the risk to a trucker's safety changes radically when driving from B.C. to Saskatchewan, requiring different regulations and insurance, but because incentives favoured the status quo. Regulators looking to retain their authority and protect regional labour economies had little incentive to loosen their grip and provide easy access to competition from other provinces.\n\nSkilled workers, understandably unenthusiastic about acquiring and maintaining credentials across provinces, could always find ready work down south in the United States. However, this status quo is over. Since President Trump's unacceptable comments about Canada's sovereignty and turning his back on the deal that he signed, applying tariffs to Canadian lumber, steel and cars, Canadians have started to see our relationship with the U.S. in a new light, but more importantly, how we view ourselves and our future in a new light.\n\nThe comfortable norms Canadians took for granted with our American partners, like trust and predictability, no longer exist. While time will tell if this relationship can be repaired, it is clear that Canada must forge a new path. As our Prime Minister has said, we can give ourselves far more than the Americans can ever take away.\n\nBill C-266 is an essential step in charting a new path forward for Canada. I have heard from the Canadian Construction Association, and it said, \"The CCA welcomes the introduction of Bill C-266 and the development of a national framework to modernize, streamline and harmonize skilled trade certification processes. Canada's construction industry is held back by a fragmented internal market where labour mobility restrictions create costly barriers for workers and employers alike.\"\n\nFrom my alma mater, the British Columbia Institute of Technology, Dr. Jeff Zabudsky, who is the president of the BCIT, agreed and said, \"Canada's future prosperity is being shaped by large-scale priorities that rely heavily on a strong trades workforce. Whether it be building affordable and climate-resilient housing or infrastructure to strengthen national security, these national priorities all require a job-ready and adaptable trades workforce.\"\n\nLet me be clear: This legislation does not seek to override provincial jurisdiction, and I look at my friends from Quebec. Provinces and territories would continue to regulate training, certification and labour markets within their borders. That is both appropriate and necessary.\n\nThrough extensive consultations spanning at least nine months, the minister would engage with provincial governments, regulatory bodies, industry associations, labour unions, indigenous organizations, polytechnics and educational institutions. This would ensure the framework is not imposed from above, but built from the ground up, reflecting the realities of those who work within the system every day.\n\nThe framework itself wishes to deliver several key outcomes.\n\nFirst, it would establish a comprehensive inventory of skilled trades across Canada. This may sound straightforward, but it is a critical step. Today, even defining what constitutes a skilled trade can vary among jurisdictions. A clear shared understanding is essential for any meaningful harmonization.\n\nSecond, it would map equivalencies among provincial standards and credentials. This is where the real work begins. By systematically comparing requirements, we can identify where trades are already aligned, where minor adjustments are needed and where more significant differences exist.\n\nThird, and most importantly, it would introduce measures to harmonize standards, reduce duplication and streamline regulatory processes. This would mean fewer redundant exams, faster recognition of credentials and clearer pathways for workers moving between provinces. Consider the impact of this on a carpenter relocating from New Brunswick to Alberta. Instead of navigating a confusing and time-consuming certification process, that worker could benefit from a system that recognizes their qualifications quickly and fairly, allowing them to get to work sooner.\n\nFourth, the framework would support modernization. As industries evolve, so too must the standards that govern them. By coordinating updates across jurisdictions, we can ensure that Canadian tradespeople remain at the forefront of global best practices.\n\nFifth, it would promote ongoing collaboration. This is not a one-time exercise, but a continuous process of improvement. The inclusion of indigenous governing bodies and organizations would be particularly important in ensuring that the framework reflects diverse perspectives and supports inclusive economic growth.\n\nAccountability is also built into the legislation. The minister would be required to table the national framework in Parliament within one year, ensuring timely action. Annual progress reports would track implementation, measure improvements in labour mobility and assess the effectiveness of the framework, and within five years a comprehensive parliamentary review would provide an opportunity to refine and strengthen the approach.\n\nThe bill would create a structured, collaborative process to bring those systems into alignment where possible and to make them more transparent and interoperable where full alignment is not feasible.\n\nThe bill is also about national unity. Canada is one country with one economy. While regional diversity is a strength, unnecessary barriers that divide our labour market weaken us all.\n\nThe legislation represents a pragmatic, collaborative and forward-looking approach to a long-standing challenge. It would respect jurisdiction, engage stakeholders and focus on outcomes. I look forward to collaborating with everyone if the bill advances to committee. I urge all members of the House to support the national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility act and to take this important step toward a stronger and more unified Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300981","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"moved that Bill C-266, An Act to establish a national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility, be read the second time and referred to a committee. \n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for Milton East—Halton Hills South for supporting this bill.\n\nIt is always a huge honour to stand in the House and speak on vital issues for Canadians. Today, I have an opportunity to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bae19040c9fc453bc01c212c90eeb174c924c4af6403c443c7ef72dc9ae8b48c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31d808956d2f05e276838613f4536e9f3c908a6f20330e7cfd8125fa3599b694"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c162bda995a045c0bc04bbf2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300982,"date":"2026-04-23T22:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member has been part of the opposition for many years and was previously in government. This has been a problem for decades, including under the Conservative Harper government and in numerous provincial Conservative governments.\n\nThe truth is that federal and provincial governments have allowed the problem to fester for decades, and it is time to end the status quo. The member opposite knows the government did act immediately in July 2025 to address barriers that the federal government could address alone. Weeks after the election, the Government of Canada removed all 53 federal exemptions from the CFTA.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300982","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member has been part of the opposition for many years and was previously in government. This has been a problem for decades, including under the Conservative Harper government and in numerous provincial Conservative governments.\n\nThe truth is that federal and provincial governments have allowed the problem to fester for decades, and it is time to end the status quo. The member opp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e9f4a47f1e71956005a5424ae5bc60e83afd1cb3c1e72d589bff3937e4ccdec"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a58c7d0f1b9b03b615da101","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300983,"date":"2026-04-23T22:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am surprised to hear that the member believes that things are working well between provinces, as they all are working hard to find ways to remove internal barriers.\n\nWith the bill I talked about today, and I said in my speech, the framework that would be developed would be in conjunction with provinces and provincial labour associations so it would not exclude any province. In the unprecedented climate we find ourselves in now, regulators and trade associations alike have new imperatives to come to the table and find an agreement. Too much is at stake to allow minor differences to hold our country back at this time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300983","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am surprised to hear that the member believes that things are working well between provinces, as they all are working hard to find ways to remove internal barriers.\n\nWith the bill I talked about today, and I said in my speech, the framework that would be developed would be in conjunction with provinces and provincial labour associations so it would not exclude any province. In the u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["189461e267acc72695d2a8ed291decbd2fefc729aa08af79dc941ff13e4310d5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8759c5d1d7269acf81ec3202c8562722097ce0dcb1ac4644b88416a89f6a436c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a65b63074755164b6703fd64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300984,"date":"2026-04-23T22:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for seconding the motion and for talking about young people.\n\nThis is exactly what the bill would do. It would bring respect back to skilled trades and allow young people to think about the possibility of getting involved in something they may wish to do. They may want to be part of the national shipbuilding strategy and to work in Vancouver, but they are located somewhere else and doing their training in Ontario, for example. The bill would allow them to have the vision to be part of our defence programs that we are bringing forward in this country.\n\n I think this is exactly what young people are looking forward to doing: uniting this country and working towards something that matters.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300984","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for seconding the motion and for talking about young people.\n\nThis is exactly what the bill would do. It would bring respect back to skilled trades and allow young people to think about the possibility of getting involved in something they may wish to do. They may want to be part of the national shipbuilding strategy and to work in Vancouver, but they are located so","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["580d6aaa86f0c158a9e85457406314fc0a3a1dff7ce43cd4f7bdd03cc08b2bcb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efb6c879228bb36fe4346062","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119040,"date":"2026-04-27T23:10:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the members here. This is an important committee. We all understand the work we're doing here. Mr. Lewis made some really good points there. We're working on some great studies, with more to come. We'd like to get to the work. We'd like to see reports come out and recommendations be delivered and taken into consideration. That kind of work is really important. It's what we do here. I appreciate the passion Ms. Borrelli brought to the committee. Fighting for your community is extremely important. It's why we're all here. As a British Columbian, I think I'm the only Pacific member here. I represent the Pacific NorthWest Economic Region. If you look at that specifically, it amounts to one trillion dollars' worth of GDP. To those member states and member provinces, including Yukon, that's a big deal. I think one thing that's missing here is that Ms. Borrelli brought the point forward that we do need to rush, but as I think Mr. Lewis answered, we have to understand who we're dealing with and the people on the other side. I had the opportunity to visit Olympia, Washington. I work with the Pacific NorthWest Economic Region, and I visited there. Many of our members here, along with the chair of our committee, went to Washington, D.C. We've made several visits—not just people who are part of specific committees but people at the ministry level and all MPs—because we all care. We all care about what's happening across the border and what that means to us. I have 110 million pounds of seafood off-loaded in my harbour annually. That goes down the I-5 into Washington state. They have issues around.... They need our potash. They need our fertilizer. They need things that are important to their wine sector down there. I come from an aerospace background, so I have a strong understanding of the relationship. Boeing has been in my city for over 100 years now. A cool fact is that the first flight Boeing took was Canada Post, to deliver mail from YVR to the Seattle airport. The relationship we talk about, and the passion everyone wants to bring forward and use towards negotiating things.... We've tried that. We've done that. Many of us have gone there. I've spoken to members from both sides. We've had senator reports written. We've had not only Republican but also Democratic members come to the table. The congresswoman who chairs the ways and means committee brought forward the motion calling the tariffs illegal. We've seen movement from Republican representatives, who are now speaking up as well. PNWER is five states, five provinces and the territories. Beyond the PNWER states, you have 36 states that are now actively working toward a motion to be brought forward in their state legislatures whereby they're looking at a CUSMA or USMCA deal that would last 16 years. Everyone's working actively. A lot of people we're hearing from are also probably saying, just like Ms. Borrelli, that we need to get to something and we need to rush. It's not happening—on either side. There was one statement I heard every meeting. Perhaps the chair and others can attest to this. In every meeting I took in the United States, whether it was in Washington state, in D.C., or in Oregon, we would give them a series of facts on the importance of and the benefits in machinery to the tune of $1 billion annually. They make more money off us. The Spokane region's representative is Congressman Baumgartner, and I spoke to him. He didn't even know, but when we did inform them of some of this information, and they knew what they were missing out on because there's no deal, they said, it's up to the President. It's up to the President. We can sit here, yell and scream about things, and with valid intent, for sure, but if we talk about rushing into something with someone who's very clearly making decisions one way on one day and in another way on another day.... I think that has been very apparent, and I don't think any of us are missing out on the social media that he himself is involved in. I think that's a very big missing piece in here. I don't know if you can add a line in your motion here about rushing to a deal that the President of the United States agrees to. I don't know, maybe we can make some type of amendment or something. I think that it's the premise behind it. We all love it. We want to do this. We want to help every family, every Canadian family. In this study specifically, it was extremely important to hear how much impact the mould-making and tool and die.... I come from, as I said, the aerospace industry, which was a great many years ago for sure, but every industry that I've been involved in.... I've built homes, so I understand that. I'm from British Columbia; we understand how important the western red cedar is for us and the softwood lumber deal. We're hearing things such as that the USMCA deal is most likely pretty good as is, but then we're going to do separate deals on lumber and separate deals on steel. Which one are we going to rush to do? That is my question. I'm not sure that we're getting anywhere with this. I can understand. Look, I typically don't engage in a lot of partisan politics, because there's enough oxygen that gets wasted around here. That's not who I am. I'm a worker. I look at myself as a worker. I do my work, and I try to deliver what I can for my city. I wanted to talk about this today, because we're all working really, really hard, and we know the families that are impacted across the country. We know that, quite frankly, there's a lot of western alienation. We don't really hear much from B.C., so I thought I'd do my bit today, because it's important. It is. There are a lot of things that are happening, and we have a lot of members on the other side from B.C. We know the industries that matter. We have major projects that are important to us right now that we're looking at delivering. If we can, work towards making sure that we can strengthen the things that we can strengthen and not look at saying, okay, we have to rush into certain things. We heard from an experienced, dedicated member in Mr. Volpe, a dedicated person from the automotive industry for years, who gave us some very direct, real answers on what the reality is on the ground. We heard at the last meeting from members, from other experts and representatives from the respective chambers and what they're hearing on the other side. We have the Gordie Howe Bridge and the controversy we saw around that. Again, every road, every bridge, leads back to someone who is putting a dead end on the other side. If we look at how we're going to get to a deal, we do have to take into consideration thoughtfulness, or else we are getting just bogged into something that will not be good for the families, Ms. Borrelli, that you're fighting for, or Mr. Lewis, or others—the families we're all fighting for. Recently, even the polls suggest this. It's not just we who are fighting for this. We heard from Americans. They tend to agree. They don't think the Trump administration is arguing in good faith. They themselves are now saying that. We aren't even saying this here. This motion doesn't say this here. Polls found that, among Republican voters, 53% say they trust Canada. We must be doing something. The Prime Minister must be doing something that's trustworthy at this point for them to think that way. Thirty-three per cent do not. It's 71% for Democratic voters. We are now in a situation where many of us come from a wide variety of different sectors. We all are fighting for those things. I'd like to share some thoughts from recent senators and what they're saying on the other side, if I can find them. I don't want to misquote. We talk about defence. Look at defence. I really want to share this, because it was such an important piece in some of the conversations I had with Congressman Bentz from Oregon. I talked about Boeing and how we have now procured the Boeing Poseidon aircraft and other military defence procurement that we're engaged in right now. There are over 600 suppliers across this country in defence. They are Canadian suppliers, and 300 come from British Columbia. I said that, for interoperable capabilities, we are basically being counterproductive. We're spending twice as much on things that don't need to be spent on at a time when both of our nations need to grow together and protect one another against the challenges we are seeing with over 120 different conflicts around the world right now. Adding to that piece, if we look at everybody from, let's say, the corn growers.... Canada and Mexico are two of the largest markets for American corn growers, and USMCA has been vital in making that happen. We're deeply appreciative of these senators for taking the initiative, sending this letter and highlighting its importance. Everyone wants this. I'm talking about corn growers. I know Ms. Dancho might not like the corn growers' association or something, but they're saying this. The spokesperson for the Agricultural Coalition for USMCA said that they are greatly appreciative of their allies in the Senate for supporting the renewal of USMCA, which \"is vital to the U.S. economy and an important economic engine for rural America...Renewing the agreement builds on the president's success, and we encourage extension due to the vast benefits to U.S. agriculture.\" They're not getting to it. They want it. The National Corn Growers Association and the Agricultural Coalition want a deal. Everybody's saying, \"Let's get to it, let's rush,\" but it's up to one person. That's what I heard when I went there. It's up to the President. Let's get to it. Go back to the Greer report and the Senate finance committee. Ambassador Jamieson Greer did the report and highlighted the grievances they have. When was the last time we heard some of these things that have come forward? Greer wrote, \"The question is whether—in recognition of these shortcomings—anything should be done to change them. Stakeholder views are mixed.\" That means.... All of industry wants something to be done—it's just not happening—to tackle these issues: everything from rules of origin to critical minerals to economic security alignment—trilateral approaches between the U.S., Canada and Mexico, negotiating firmly. This is the most important thing that it says here—the United States said this. In this report, it says, \"USTR's view is that, whatever the USMCA's value to the United States and even North America, the shortcomings are such that a rubberstamp of the Agreement is not in the national interest.\" Are we looking to do a rubber stamp? Are we hoping to just rubber-stamp a deal here? I think that's basically what we're working towards if we look at going back to this motion. I don't feel that it is very pragmatic. It's not something that has a reality attached to it in terms of the real circumstances that are attached to the current situation between these two nations. I'd like to sort of add a bit more here, if I have time. The Chair: You have three more minutes. Parm Bains: I have three more minutes. I think I have one more piece to talk about here. Again, not enough has been said about the relationship between Washington and British Columbia. Washington exports $2.2 billion in services to Canada. If we're talking about just in travel, travel alone is $482 million. Telecom is $441 million. Charges for the use of intellectual property are $436 million. This is good business, great business, between the two nations here. Just in Washington it's $7.9 billion in goods. That's agriculture, chemicals, energy equipment, etc. Who doesn't want this? We've done innovation. There's Harbour Air. I'm sure you have had an opportunity to fly on Harbour Air. The Flying Beaver is a great pub out there, too.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119040","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the members here. This is an important committee. We all understand the work we're doing here. Mr. Lewis made some really good points there. We're working on some great studies, with more to come. We'd like to get to the work. We'd like to see reports come out and recommendations be delivered and taken into consideration. That kind of work is really important","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2a801c8a95e29ee4183cdf213d2299da5195cb93de9c91e196653197fd3e5503"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c8aa7f513fff61e660b8a6fba18334228fa2ee9ae6e4701bfb9b912115c829f4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-94a767bb55b35dce58a658a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":726995,"date":"2026-04-29T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, respecting the spirit of truth and reconciliation, Richmond residents in my hometown are seeking clarity following last summer's Cowichan decision and recent federal agreements with first nations in British Columbia. To dispel the misinformation, it is important that we continue to provide clear, factual information and constructive leadership as Canada moves forward with the important work of advancing reconciliation.\n\nCan the Prime Minister outline the government's position and explain how the government is working collaboratively to uphold reconciliation, while protecting private property rights for residents and businesses?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726995","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, respecting the spirit of truth and reconciliation, Richmond residents in my hometown are seeking clarity following last summer's Cowichan decision and recent federal agreements with first nations in British Columbia. To dispel the misinformation, it is important that we continue to provide clear, factual information and constructive leadership as Canada moves forward with the importan","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a25e28b5e4d48059637f5b35fa9824b4e7091e45cc92a02715fa56385b4f763a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a1ed5e5db1c497256abeeb2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119041,"date":"2026-05-04T21:15:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Minister, for joining us today and for all your hard work in navigating this difficult time of the trade war. My question is around aluminum. As you know, it's very important to British Columbia, my home province, and to manufacturing companies. It's a critical input for aerospace, shipbuilding and, of course, the drone program that's soon going to be assembled in Richmond, British Columbia, and is coming up in the next month. Can you expand on how our new buy Canada policy can support B.C. aluminum integration, not just for major projects, but for the critical sectors I've mentioned?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119041","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Minister, for joining us today and for all your hard work in navigating this difficult time of the trade war. My question is around aluminum. As you know, it's very important to British Columbia, my home province, and to manufacturing companies. It's a critical input for aerospace, shipbuilding and, of course, the drone program that's soon going to be assembled in ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fc0301ae7bc306dff80e36d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119042,"date":"2026-05-04T21:15:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"We are seeing some resilience. I know that Statistics Canada data showed Canada's GDP grew by 0.2% in quarter one, led by the manufacturing sector. It expanded to 1.8%, the largest gain since January 2023. While we work towards a renewed CUSMA deal, and we had an announcement today, could you maybe talk a bit about the support for Canadian manufacturers as they adapt and seek new markets?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119042","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We are seeing some resilience. I know that Statistics Canada data showed Canada's GDP grew by 0.2% in quarter one, led by the manufacturing sector. It expanded to 1.8%, the largest gain since January 2023. While we work towards a renewed CUSMA deal, and we had an announcement today, could you maybe talk a bit about the support for Canadian manufacturers as they adapt and seek new markets?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a68d6b5afac6cbfccf0c1a99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119043,"date":"2026-05-04T21:20:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"I'm going to shift very quickly to EVs for a bit. In my city, we have the largest auto mall. I've met with car dealers, and they're interested in having some stability in what they can sell. They're really excited about some of the announcements about the EVs. One in four new cars sold worldwide is an EV. British Columbia is probably one of the leaders for EVs, as you know. Why is Canada well positioned to take advantage of this global trend?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119043","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm going to shift very quickly to EVs for a bit. In my city, we have the largest auto mall. I've met with car dealers, and they're interested in having some stability in what they can sell. They're really excited about some of the announcements about the EVs. One in four new cars sold worldwide is an EV. British Columbia is probably one of the leaders for EVs, as you know. Why is Canada well posi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7ecf11647c305f6504b0247b17fc3c00c3adfd237b361460b03cb1c781a6fa95"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2670c2859eec8466c68f49ce8e8af78bfe244391036539041ecc16c78a1f2654"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd08b31acf3f891c3097aa87","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119044,"date":"2026-05-04T21:20:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119044","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you so much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b7a3ea30b3402cee01cddc41","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119045,"date":"2026-05-07T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us in this discussion. Ms. Simmons, there have been challenges around scaling for decades, when businesses want to expand. Can you shed some light on how the modularity of Photonic's industrial design appeals to global markets?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119045","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us in this discussion. Ms. Simmons, there have been challenges around scaling for decades, when businesses want to expand. Can you shed some light on how the modularity of Photonic's industrial design appeals to global markets?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d2d83d2647d62b6f7d83fbaaee196a534225aaaeefe38b6e5a0202cc80c59e3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e22ea4e66a8022d5a18601d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119046,"date":"2026-05-07T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Ms. Simmons, you mentioned the U.S. There was a report by Bloomberg indicating that \"Almost half of the US data centers planned for this year are expected to be delayed or canceled...[largely due to] the shortage of electrical equipment...transformers...and batteries.\" How will the architecture of Photonic's design be able to manage these kinds of shortages and bottlenecks? Maybe you can expand on that, and then speak to the challenges that exist in scaling AI-ready data centres in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electrical equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119046","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Ms. Simmons, you mentioned the U.S. There was a report by Bloomberg indicating that \"Almost half of the US data centers planned for this year are expected to be delayed or canceled...[largely due to] the shortage of electrical equipment...transformers...and batteries.\" How will the architecture of Photonic's design be able to manage these kinds of shortages and bottlenecks? Maybe you can expand on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","label":"Electrical equipment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electrical equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","label":"Electrical equipment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","label":"Architecture","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d451b02bf488e86b30cd2650dc04808ceb828fdb111d2ab8d7c6b8d69caea38b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electrical equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13da2c4ccbd0580cba7826d4104787620eae114cf9d2dc1998b882c0ff5f8454"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electrical equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05ba775a5739b916f8a47d58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119047,"date":"2026-05-07T17:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"I'll go to Mr. Perry. In budget 2025 the government announced $1.7 billion to recruit top international researchers. What federal programs or policies could further strengthen recruitment and retention in the AI space, in your mind?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119047","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll go to Mr. Perry. In budget 2025 the government announced $1.7 billion to recruit top international researchers. What federal programs or policies could further strengthen recruitment and retention in the AI space, in your mind?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["babb9b1893cfaa3874c25fe0578a88a7694c4fce5df7ad0d9fe6618758bef9a2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c00eae045bc5a9ce5ea87a764b162fb08112a9f8cfab7f35cb7f8b4c86c6ee87"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8ed7488998f177029e576ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119048,"date":"2026-05-07T18:00:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"I'm from British Columbia. We have a lot of strength in B.C. in this space. How do federal investments in research, infrastructure and talent contribute to what we ultimately want to achieve as a commercialization and industry success?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119048","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm from British Columbia. We have a lot of strength in B.C. in this space. How do federal investments in research, infrastructure and talent contribute to what we ultimately want to achieve as a commercialization and industry success?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c1b5736dfa017bfef2b369ff99a179a0a5afa4c5fd59e93a2f6a5c179555b99"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2522017a523135d6328e0ca0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949818,"date":"2026-05-07T18:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak today on the matter of the Cowichan court decision, as it has understandably raised questions in the House; in my hometown of Richmond, British Columbia; and across Canada.\n\nLet me first say that our government disagrees with the Supreme Court of British Columbia's decision and that we immediately appealed the court decision. As the case is before the courts, it would not be appropriate for me to comment further on the ongoing aspects of the litigation itself. I will, however, provide background on the history of the case and speak about private property interests.\n\nIt is helpful at the outset to understand the scope of the litigation and the number of parties involved. Besides the federal Crown, there are five other defendants in the litigation: the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority, the Government of British Columbia, the City of Richmond, the Musqueam first nation, and the Tsawwassen First Nation.\n\nThe litigation began in November 2014. The Cowichans sought a declaration of aboriginal title to 1,846 acres of land located in the city of Richmond, along with a declaration of an aboriginal right to fish for food in the south arm of the Fraser River. The claimed lands include federal lands owned by Transport Canada and managed by the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority, Richmond municipal lands, and some lands held by private landowners.\n\nGiven the complexity of the issues and the number of parties involved, it is not surprising that the case unfolded over several years. On August 7, 2025, the British Columbia Supreme Court delivered its decision, ruling that the Cowichan hold aboriginal title over approximately 40% of the claimed area, as well as an aboriginal right to fish for food in the south arm of the Fraser River. Soon after the release of the decision, all parties took further steps within the court process. The court's decision is being appealed by all parties to the litigation, including Canada.\n\nSome of the court's findings have potentially significant implications, including with respect to private property rights. Because the decision is not entirely clear on certain points, that clarity is being sought through the proper legal process. I have also been working to seek clarity, and I recognize that the decision has raised questions or concerns.\n\nWe know that Canada defended the validity of fee simple title granted by the Crown at trial. Canada also defended the principle of transparency in this trial, particularly for parties that are not directly involved in this case but that may be affected by its outcome. In 2017, Canada brought an application seeking an order requiring the plaintiffs to notify private landowners within the claim area in this case. The court declined to exercise its discretion to require the Cowichan to give formal notice to private landowners. I should note that every aboriginal title claim is unique, and the reasoning in this decision will not necessarily apply to other cases. It depends on the facts of the case in question.\n\nWith that background in mind, I will turn to more recent developments.\n\nThree related private real estate companies, which I will refer to as Montrose, operate in Richmond and claim they are the largest landowner in the declared Cowichan title area. Montrose has applied to the British Columbia Supreme Court to reopen the trial, be added as a party and file new evidence and argument. Its application would allow the company to present its perspective on how the declaration of aboriginal title impacts its legal and financial interests.\n\nCanada has filed a response to support Montrose's application. It is important for all parties to be heard when they are directly and significantly affected by a court decision. Canada's position is consistent with the application it brought in 2017 regarding the need to provide notice of the trial to private landowners.\n\nIf successful, Montrose would become an official party to the litigation, and the record would be reopened so the court could receive Montrose's evidence and submissions, including submissions related to the impacts of the ruling. The Montrose application is scheduled to be heard before the British Columbia Supreme Court on May 25 and May 26, 2026.\n\nThe Government of Canada respects the right of all parties to pursue their own legal strategies. Canada's approach in this litigation reflects the use of appropriate court process to address legal uncertainty, while continuing to advance reconciliation in accordance with the Constitution. I will add that private property rights are fundamental and that our government will always protect them.\n\nFor the Government of Canada, private property cannot and will not be negotiated. This is not only because our government would never negotiate Canadians' private property but also because, as members all know, private land ownership and land deeds fall under provincial jurisdiction, not federal jurisdiction. It is important to note that any agreement on aboriginal title at the federal level protects private property. In fact, no modern treaty, negotiated agreement or federal approach has led to Canadians' losing their privately owned land.\n\nAs the member of Parliament for Richmond East—Steveston, I have been working and will continue to work with the Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations to address residents' concerns and share constituents' perspectives with the government, and to advocate for the people of our city. At the same time, I will work with the Richmond city council and all levels of government to ensure that the residents of our city are engaged and informed on these matters as they proceed in the months and years to come.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949818","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak today on the matter of the Cowichan court decision, as it has understandably raised questions in the House; in my hometown of Richmond, British Columbia; and across Canada.\n\nLet me first say that our government disagrees with the Supreme Court of British Columbia's decision and that we immediately appealed the court decision. As the case is before","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0f1965700799aabfc154d536c4a59ff5d9fe3960ab07fbdc1994e197cf1c5ee0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11be11e60e2c0b12fa7721378ab1d74b1ffeb5e4f6fb569660b41c96cf7b1a70"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7101d63d4c07164515c3094","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949819,"date":"2026-05-07T18:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think that if we listened to colleagues who spoke earlier, the fearmongering we are talking about has to do with what the members opposite are implying: that private property lands will be taken away.\n\nI come back to the issue at hand. This is a provincial matter. I have outlined how the federal government cannot and will not negotiate private lands. Most of these questions should be directed to the province and the Premier of British Columbia.\n\nA corresponding decision on a similar case happened in New Brunswick. That court of appeal issued a decision in the context of an aboriginal title claim on the issue of whether aboriginal title can coexist with fee simple title. The court found that it could make a finding of aboriginal title leading to compensation for an indigenous nation, but it went the other way. This is a provincial matter.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949819","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think that if we listened to colleagues who spoke earlier, the fearmongering we are talking about has to do with what the members opposite are implying: that private property lands will be taken away.\n\nI come back to the issue at hand. This is a provincial matter. I have outlined how the federal government cannot and will not negotiate private lands. Most of these questions should b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a0b9ea9ce6ccb8989a66a2a3a04a50f0ff85a822f083da0f37751ae094136896"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91255903927bb1e67e9a1fe8e3a53049cfaeccedffb5efb3bf1216855e10e284"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7954b4e0ab168fc6fa26cf2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949820,"date":"2026-05-07T18:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for his hard work on this issue as well.\n\nWith respect to the other members who are involved, the concerns are there. What they have shared is about having an opportunity to be involved in the case.\n\nI would like to mention that the member for Richmond Centre—Marpole, who has been talking quite a bit about this, sat as a Richmond city councillor when this issue was in court. He did not inform residents but is now bringing this issue forward. He also ran for the NDP provincial government that was responsible for the issue at the time, and now we are hearing contradictory information from the other side.\n\nAgain, it begs the question about why misinformation is being brought forward into the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949820","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for his hard work on this issue as well.\n\nWith respect to the other members who are involved, the concerns are there. What they have shared is about having an opportunity to be involved in the case.\n\nI would like to mention that the member for Richmond Centre—Marpole, who has been talking quite a bit about this, sat as a Richmond city councillor when this is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["57f85efebf631b83468c34362b78d2a3a61727bd6040bedfc40669a2d90c8c84"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-574234e6a0a0d060b6e4c413","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949821,"date":"2026-05-07T18:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I stated in my speech, in 2017, the federal government applied to the court to make sure that they notify the residents.\n\n If we look at the question the member has brought forward with respect to the Prime Minister, the Prime Minister is taking responsibility for this country, and he wanted to ensure that Canadians understand that the federal government will not negotiate private property rights.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949821","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I stated in my speech, in 2017, the federal government applied to the court to make sure that they notify the residents.\n\n If we look at the question the member has brought forward with respect to the Prime Minister, the Prime Minister is taking responsibility for this country, and he wanted to ensure that Canadians understand that the federal government will not negotiate private ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c460d23662de130315a20296954f4f60b04cf29df00042ff7eeac210a79435b7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d0e1bdc1f0c088feced8ffa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":949822,"date":"2026-05-07T18:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I talked about the Prime Minister taking responsibility to make sure Canadians know what our position as a federal government is, that we will have their backs. \n\nI will reiterate one more piece. The federal government would never negotiate Canadians' private property, but also, as members know, private land ownership and land deeds fall under provincial jurisdiction. This is why I am stating that this is a provincial matter.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:949822","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I talked about the Prime Minister taking responsibility to make sure Canadians know what our position as a federal government is, that we will have their backs. \n\nI will reiterate one more piece. The federal government would never negotiate Canadians' private property, but also, as members know, private land ownership and land deeds fall under provincial jurisdiction. This is why I am","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f86c2d5056e69f455991ac6f7de65a1854d59e61ce6272134b545027e5b4f1da"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f3a7fa790b76159019ef6fd87bd9cae2cb35e33dad18c2065113b30947244c2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6176cad602f341b5fef61809","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119010,"date":"2026-05-26T22:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today. I feel like I've had the opportunity to work with each of your departments. My hometown, Richmond, British Columbia, is technically below sea level. It has a pretty robust diking system and pump stations. I've had the opportunity to bring a lot of support from government programs into the city to continue protecting it. Richmond is made up of 22 islands, and this includes the YVR, the airport. It includes an industrial island, Mitchell Island, where there are lumber mills. A considerable amount of logistics takes place there. It's part of our 16 communities that make up the largest port network in the country. It also has the largest commercial fishing harbour and brings in 100 million pounds of seafood annually. It's 110 million pounds now, with seafood, fish and crab. Just the harbour itself generates over $220 million for our region in economic output. For us and for Canada, it's an important region. My question may be for anyone, but I'm looking at Dr. Deep. Agriculture is also 50% of the area I represent. We have the largest cranberry producers. We have blueberries, and we have dairy. Anything with respect to this framework is extremely important to this region. Maybe I can ask each of you to weigh in—I'll begin with Mr. Vu—on how this framework will help ensure the economic supply chain and the corridors. Quite frankly, a lot of the corridors are made up of water, with the mighty Fraser River there, the working river. Can you talk a bit about how the supply chain routes and the infrastructure will be protected through this framework?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752541","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Seafood","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119010","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today. I feel like I've had the opportunity to work with each of your departments. My hometown, Richmond, British Columbia, is technically below sea level. It has a pretty robust diking system and pump stations. I've had the opportunity to bring a lot of support from government programs into the city to continue protecting it. Richm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752541","label":"Seafood"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Decentralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752541","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Seafood","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","label":"Decentralization","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752541","label":"Seafood","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["41053f774162c7804e0c98fac5e027f9ff772859daddf288e140db4e0bab3e1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752541","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Seafood","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fb2ef0fa3c2377c1209170be931763736795521068f2266688484b8379b6f24"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752541","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Seafood","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752541","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0eeed545444b2a54d9e301d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119011,"date":"2026-05-26T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"ENVI","text":"Explain that. Is it a reduced pace because of federal support? Do they not have money?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119011","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Explain that. Is it a reduced pace because of federal support? Do they not have money?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e504ab0b7cffce9999539fd36c15ed203dc465bd5ff368ac933542cc3eb8aba"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af34f2ef5b7ac5da594a9d4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119012,"date":"2026-05-26T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"ENVI","text":"I'm curious. Do you work with MDA Space at all? It's also situated in Richmond.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119012","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm curious. Do you work with MDA Space at all? It's also situated in Richmond.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036624","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal digital assistant","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036624","label":"Personal digital assistant","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c55c5cb24aa682a08fe73414a238ea15be6c185560d53d2e1d20d7952ae165a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e126fab8495f182512ed3ddb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119013,"date":"2026-05-26T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"ENVI","text":"Is that for the geospatial things you spoke about earlier?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119013","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is that for the geospatial things you spoke about earlier?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035484","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Geographic information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035484","label":"Geographic information systems","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c4f5821e68274714a38240e95eceaf6e7ce345acb32122a4a37bc06dd05950e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bb6c26818b8b398a0e7abd19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119014,"date":"2026-05-26T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"ENVI","text":"Are you familiar with the region I talked about—the Fraser River? Do you consider that a supply chain corridor?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119014","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Are you familiar with the region I talked about—the Fraser River? Do you consider that a supply chain corridor?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083628","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coastal waters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083628","label":"Coastal waters","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b0569f5e84e6be1f997aabac5d011244a81fdd9493594060e34e142835fc8a0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2846198b4e5b51c7b5506304","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119015,"date":"2026-05-26T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"ENVI","text":"Dr. Deep, maybe I'll get the agricultural piece from you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119015","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Dr. Deep, maybe I'll get the agricultural piece from you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","label":"Crops","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945652","label":"Beans","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aee15121c4d2dc6e0bc9cd5af31d08f79c90d0b4960707410450b4946d68c712"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67047b9d86491a6d10593a57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119049,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to all of our guests for joining us today. My first question is directed to Mr. Lee, from British Columbia. We see how the world is becoming quite complicated, with significant uncertainties putting a strain on public safety and institutions not just in Canada, but globally. How can government identify the risks before they escalate and direct resources where they matter the most? I ask you this because I know UrbanLogiq does a lot of work in different jurisdictions. Maybe you can provide some input there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119049","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to all of our guests for joining us today. My first question is directed to Mr. Lee, from British Columbia. We see how the world is becoming quite complicated, with significant uncertainties putting a strain on public safety and institutions not just in Canada, but globally. How can government identify the risks before they escalate and direct resources where they","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-16fb1d8f64f4248b421257f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119050,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you for that. You worked with the City of Coquitlam in British Columbia on a two-year trial to advance analytics and create real-world benefits. Can you outline some of the outcomes from that partnership?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119050","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for that. You worked with the City of Coquitlam in British Columbia on a two-year trial to advance analytics and create real-world benefits. Can you outline some of the outcomes from that partnership?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","label":"Interprovincial relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0bb46d6d6d2119ffd3360117018408f8bf597805977509faf03bf4efd39ab02b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-acc4fc13621b0cd4680c0544","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119051,"date":"2026-05-28T16:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"A lot of the questions we get about AI are around privacy and the protections people want for their data. What processes does UrbanLogiq utilize to protect data? Ultimately, the committee's role is to try to get recommendations put forward. Do you have recommendations for the government on protecting data?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119051","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"A lot of the questions we get about AI are around privacy and the protections people want for their data. What processes does UrbanLogiq utilize to protect data? Ultimately, the committee's role is to try to get recommendations put forward. Do you have recommendations for the government on protecting data?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec9dfe104e49818a6044769adad3bb65cab1548439f3904a604f414d851fddd2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0f1fe6c8302e67a55765350","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119052,"date":"2026-05-28T16:55:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Go very quickly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119052","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Go very quickly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49c0bc569fcf49b252fbeac0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119053,"date":"2026-06-01T21:00:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for joining us today on this important study. My hometown of Richmond, British Columbia, is also home to MDA Space. We know that's one of Canada's most advanced space companies. I'll begin with Mr. Gallant first, if I could. How is AI fundamentally changing the economics and capabilities of the space sector today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119053","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for joining us today on this important study. My hometown of Richmond, British Columbia, is also home to MDA Space. We know that's one of Canada's most advanced space companies. I'll begin with Mr. Gallant first, if I could. How is AI fundamentally changing the economics and capabilities of the space sector today?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7b127deaf85455acefa052861c194f99efa21a56cdb1841780c0d74f322a659b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed9996d55782fa2d7272bbc55cad9069d5dc815cb3df941154284bf20b786330"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12641223d34cb7eb626eb153","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119054,"date":"2026-06-01T21:05:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you for that. We can look at the global picture of AI and how we compare, as a country, with others in the space domain—the strengths and gaps we may have. Could you talk about whether we're trending the right way, or about the gaps?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119054","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for that. We can look at the global picture of AI and how we compare, as a country, with others in the space domain—the strengths and gaps we may have. Could you talk about whether we're trending the right way, or about the gaps?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a21a22b975a2694442aba8a1aa12c6463a7faadf7816c50be448d12bb5234900"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["840df0315245c0de7bbaccdbdec14cf40115b28178483e264dd8fe3dd435852a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d398798a3a053b23aa1ee78","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119055,"date":"2026-06-01T21:05:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you. I have a quick question for Mr. Reid. You had the deployment of MoonNet. What did you learn from its deployment in lunar orbit that surprised you or changed your approach to space AI? Madam Chair, I'm going to share some of my time with Mr. Bardeesy afterwards, if—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119055","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I have a quick question for Mr. Reid. You had the deployment of MoonNet. What did you learn from its deployment in lunar orbit that surprised you or changed your approach to space AI? Madam Chair, I'm going to share some of my time with Mr. Bardeesy afterwards, if—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12379562114e8ad4d9301cac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119056,"date":"2026-06-01T21:05:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Okay. Could I get that answer quickly?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119056","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Could I get that answer quickly?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d8f4c8dc1550779f5999437","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119057,"date":"2026-06-04T17:05:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today on this very important study. Quite a significant amount of information has come forward, and I thank you for sharing much of that and for focusing on the risk side of things and more recommendations. Ultimately, the committee's purpose is to establish strong recommendations that we can take forward. I'd like to focus on your thoughts about Bill C-22 , which is before us in the House right now and being debated, and about lawful access. In my conversations with many of the police agencies locally here in British Columbia, and even with CSIS, they want more access, the ability to be involved in the lawful access piece and also the financial crime agency. They want to know how they can be engaged in those processes to ensure that they can tackle some of these things. The Australian reference is extremely interesting to me. For most of it, it seems like it's a very doable change in regard to codes of conduct for banks and platforms, verification pieces. Could you share some of your thoughts on lawful access, and any recommendations you have?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119057","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today on this very important study. Quite a significant amount of information has come forward, and I thank you for sharing much of that and for focusing on the risk side of things and more recommendations. Ultimately, the committee's purpose is to establish strong recommendations that we can take forward. I'd like to focus on your th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efb1d17ceb03bf7f1d66984f97fd7f50c80b8466c8b957f416be93a1ab804101"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6041c64493ffc38ff746c12dbce1a1264474ceabe59b8cdc9b74df350644e59d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-042a1e5323c137c9f1c11266","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119058,"date":"2026-06-04T17:05:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Yes, it's for the CBA first.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119058","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, it's for the CBA first.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecae1d02a1681d35e32bcacc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119059,"date":"2026-06-04T17:05:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Could we hear from Mr. Frey from Telus, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119059","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could we hear from Mr. Frey from Telus, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5eef7d8262c0e53fbda0ccde","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119060,"date":"2026-06-04T17:05:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Going on to the cyber-weapon, have you uncovered...? The perpetrators with the SMS blaster have been caught, but you talked a lot about how fraudsters will find a way to move on and move into different areas. Have you noticed different approaches or other technologies that fraudsters are using? What potential investments or initiatives can the government take to combat them on the cybersecurity side?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119060","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Going on to the cyber-weapon, have you uncovered...? The perpetrators with the SMS blaster have been caught, but you talked a lot about how fraudsters will find a way to move on and move into different areas. Have you noticed different approaches or other technologies that fraudsters are using? What potential investments or initiatives can the government take to combat them on the cybersecurity si","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fc03b87fc6591228b13f0a3d8c0640dc3c590476d041c4642a8cdf3672f6b6be"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0198a6ab43a92e8dd832b60389a1262e38e817fdc239b30a9a005c00bab24ccb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e8edea0bdf1ab5a6130a336","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119061,"date":"2026-06-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"I'll stay with you on this. You talked about reforming the AML regime. Can you expand on that? Have we, as a government, spoken enough about that in any way, or is this something that you're bringing forward now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119061","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll stay with you on this. You talked about reforming the AML regime. Can you expand on that? Have we, as a government, spoken enough about that in any way, or is this something that you're bringing forward now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce75305698c2328c17e376c76a20dcc94f54b90b496229cdab6fa93724b5c9ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd5977dbd1c06c96ef29eb0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119062,"date":"2026-06-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you so much. I'll cede the rest of my time to the chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119062","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you so much. I'll cede the rest of my time to the chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7903c573442a5a7a6e5045a9392bd586127e532d04e55f7452f919d2323a9f15"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5543848e2aa5c22c08b2a282","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119063,"date":"2026-06-08T21:45:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today for this very important study. I couldn't help but notice that many of the recommendations coming from Meta and Madam Quaid were very similar. Mr. Shipley, you referenced the Reuters report. I'm going to talk a bit about that and then ask questions of the folks at Meta. Meta projected that roughly 10% of its revenue in 2024 would come from ads tied to scams, banned goods or misleading content. Mr. Camfield, you talked about removing over 159 million scam ads last year alone. These same documents indicate that Meta users were reportedly served 15 billion high-risk scams daily, often letting them run unless 95% fraud certainty was detected. My question to you is this. For less certain violations, Meta instead charged higher ad rates to deter offenders who were effectively still profiting from the potential fraud. Why is Meta's threshold for confidently identifying a scam so high? Why is it 95%?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119063","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today for this very important study. I couldn't help but notice that many of the recommendations coming from Meta and Madam Quaid were very similar. Mr. Shipley, you referenced the Reuters report. I'm going to talk a bit about that and then ask questions of the folks at Meta. Meta projected that roughly 10% of its revenue in 2024 woul","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c70574f85ce2f4ecac50aea2ceb35a8a6ad23f57c69322d6b670edd51e81562d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c17ecbe4a587f5860103553bcb6c30e3dce1b5f667803d051b7dcfe8e0a07e5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13d0d4a7dda13e5ed9f88b02","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119064,"date":"2026-06-08T21:50:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"I'll jump in because of the time. How do you verify the legitimacy, then? Do you do a reverse process of some sort?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119064","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll jump in because of the time. How do you verify the legitimacy, then? Do you do a reverse process of some sort?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011992","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Biodegradation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034490","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011992","label":"Biodegradation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034490","label":"Processing","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0cc415703b54fc24d94703fad82850d98e581093b6d2c519bc6974edea6a9073"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-82b6b4a36a9e25e697250f8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119065,"date":"2026-06-08T21:50:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Finally, before I cede the rest of my time to Mr. Ntumba, the advocacy group Consumer Federation of America filed a similar complaint alleging that Meta failed to block scam ads while charging advertisers more to display their content and rolled back efforts to reduce scams. What is your response to that claim? Afterward, Mr. Ntumba will take the floor.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119065","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Finally, before I cede the rest of my time to Mr. Ntumba, the advocacy group Consumer Federation of America filed a similar complaint alleging that Meta failed to block scam ads while charging advertisers more to display their content and rolled back efforts to reduce scams. What is your response to that claim? Afterward, Mr. Ntumba will take the floor.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:115951","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trademarks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","label":"Forgery","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:115951","label":"Trademarks","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bf59f42b775cd0e349cacc1a84d124acc31d3f4e2a673ef04ac12a64de04a503"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5567d6a0f794003628a94894593b09b10922771560f4806928d7a8d43551d794"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3859e661637940e59a39e9ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119066,"date":"2026-06-08T21:50:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119066","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64f3b589066fbc98ef951951","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119067,"date":"2026-06-11T16:25:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us for this very important study. Mr. Paterson, you shared a story, but there are so many that I've heard from constituents and family members. We ourselves get these calls and SMS messages. It's a rather complex problem that we're dealing with. It's a global issue. We're ultimately seeing issues around extortion. We're trying to wrap around all of these different ways that people are being attacked. I was wondering if you can very quickly share how the cyber-threats facing different organizations and governments differ between Canada and the U.S. Is there a specific vulnerability that you can point to? What do fraudsters most commonly exploit as targets? It could be systems that each government has or the regulations that they have in overseeing some of these platforms like Meta and WhatsApp. Can you share something on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119067","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us for this very important study. Mr. Paterson, you shared a story, but there are so many that I've heard from constituents and family members. We ourselves get these calls and SMS messages. It's a rather complex problem that we're dealing with. It's a global issue. We're ultimately seeing issues around extortion. We're trying to wrap ar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b094d73014c85ae1199e378b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119068,"date":"2026-06-11T16:25:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"I'm going to move to Ms. Corrigall-Brown. A large focus of the work that you're doing and your advocacy around reforming bankruptcy laws is on preventing bad actors from abusing laws and hiding their gains from fraud behind bankruptcy protections. How can we improve this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119068","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm going to move to Ms. Corrigall-Brown. A large focus of the work that you're doing and your advocacy around reforming bankruptcy laws is on preventing bad actors from abusing laws and hiding their gains from fraud behind bankruptcy protections. How can we improve this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","label":"Bankruptcies"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","label":"Bankruptcies","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6d79ba19088faa0e52694d7eae369407eb334e931605daa0d21906d21e00c69f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c80abe1c41cc278d41cbfc46bcb39639b65509e719599a3fa60d872ce1815203"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac1061c7071be8b2457b1ea4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119069,"date":"2026-06-11T16:30:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Quite often we witness people moving. If they commit fraud, they'll move to a different jurisdiction. First, could you mention if the provinces and territories are aligned on this within Canada, and then, could you mention other outside jurisdictions that you're working closely with to tackle this problem and whether there are jurisdictions that can serve as a model for us to compare to?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119069","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Quite often we witness people moving. If they commit fraud, they'll move to a different jurisdiction. First, could you mention if the provinces and territories are aligned on this within Canada, and then, could you mention other outside jurisdictions that you're working closely with to tackle this problem and whether there are jurisdictions that can serve as a model for us to compare to?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Decentralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","label":"Decentralization","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","label":"Bankruptcies","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["028ac962d85a047f8c2a641904a83625d4f43b6b14eaa7d22028aa1efe878bbd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d5f66ce1f568051fc50c7b3c08596e88bb85a7b0619dec849583ab3f6419568"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ffbc163a6a96152b3deaac96","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119070,"date":"2026-06-11T18:30:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Fanjoy. Thank you to the witnesses for joining us. I'm going to try to quickly get into this. Mr. Quinn, I'm from Richmond, British Columbia. It has the longest life expectancy in Canada and a lot of seniors living here. I know you talked about telecoms. We heard from previous witnesses today about the sophistication behind the fraud and the scam compounds. You talked about the emotional side and how clever the fraudsters are becoming. We also heard, previously, about loneliness. They target people who are lonely. Can you talk about some specific gaps and provide recommendations for our financial crimes agency, moving forward? Are you participating in submissions for the financial crimes agency? Also, telecoms provide alerts if there's a call that appears to be a potential scam. Do you wish there were alerts available in the banking system, in some way?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119070","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Fanjoy. Thank you to the witnesses for joining us. I'm going to try to quickly get into this. Mr. Quinn, I'm from Richmond, British Columbia. It has the longest life expectancy in Canada and a lot of seniors living here. I know you talked about telecoms. We heard from previous witnesses today about the sophistication behind the fraud and the scam compounds. You talked about the emot","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d46791599c3f7c1f5a41a026033d68a10a66cacb65f6281be1f9109f109bfd7d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4cad15a8a74d88f9d4a914b832ec7736400dc04928ffe2b342b5bbe85db3b6ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3bd331ab6f2260a619a5b77e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119071,"date":"2026-06-11T18:30:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you. I believe that's my time completed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119071","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I believe that's my time completed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a8fa0440049b0b281e88bdf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119072,"date":"2026-06-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Minister, for your work on this strategy and for working closely with British Columbians and leaders out there on the AI strategy. I'd like you to expand a bit on public safety and the trust pillars you talked about. Among British Columbians and all Canadians, there are skeptics out there. Specifically, we witnessed a tragic incident in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia, that shook a community and our nation. Numerous court cases against AI providers allege that their products have counselled youth to commit harm to themselves or others, so can you talk a bit about the accountability measures that are in place? In this instance, it was ChatGPT that the youth confided in. She was planning to harm others, but the owners, ChatGPT, didn't act in advance. Could you please expand a bit on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119072","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Minister, for your work on this strategy and for working closely with British Columbians and leaders out there on the AI strategy. I'd like you to expand a bit on public safety and the trust pillars you talked about. Among British Columbians and all Canadians, there are skeptics out there. Specifically, we witnessed a tragic incident in Tumbler Ridge, British Colum","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["91598b86c37e220f2a2b22bea4959e92d77dd9ee65875fc44415074c93a65188"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7666e71548707f44922fcfe5a4e209941943223c4a7e2530af86d4b4b1ccbab4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77c32805379dfe7d2552c842","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1119073,"date":"2026-06-15T22:20:00+00:00","title":"INDU","speaker":"Parm Bains","venue":"INDU","text":"Thanks. I want to cede the rest of my time to Mr. Ma.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INDU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1119073","member_id":"bc-mp-111067","member_name":"Parm Bains","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thanks. I want to cede the rest of my time to Mr. Ma.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af8804f03c1e3d1089a6feea734472d291fc94471d4db139f82ba1bc0f24bd28"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8eb4a80ba035f8a071dce936","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76886,"date":"2026-01-26T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, since January 1, there has been a minimum of one extortion case every single day in the Lower Mainland. These are real consequences of the Liberals' failure to take crime seriously. Families and businesses across Abbotsford and Surrey are terrified, and entire communities are living in fear. It is time for the Liberals to fix their soft-on-crime laws that have failed to keep innocent Canadians safe.\n\nWhen will the Liberals stop delaying, finally work with us and restore mandatory minimums for extortionists and repeal their catch-and-release laws, Bill C-5 and Bill C-75?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76886","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, since January 1, there has been a minimum of one extortion case every single day in the Lower Mainland. These are real consequences of the Liberals' failure to take crime seriously. Families and businesses across Abbotsford and Surrey are terrified, and entire communities are living in fear. It is time for the Liberals to fix their soft-on-crime laws that have failed to keep innocent ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c6d745bafaaaae66251b9ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76887,"date":"2026-01-26T20:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise for the fifth time to table a petition on behalf of the residents of Abbotsford—South Langley regarding extortion. Our community is deeply concerned about the increasing prevalence of organized crime, extortion, shootings and intimidation in our community. This new year has seen more extortion cases than the number of days that have passed. Recent daylight shootings, homicides and other violent incidents underscore a broader systemic public safety crisis in our country.\n\nThe petitioners mourn the tragic death of Darshan Singh Sahsi. These residents call on the Government of Canada to reinforce the process of public reporting so Canadians can clearly see how the federal and provincial governments and local municipalities are working together to prevent further increases in violent and organized crime.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76887","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise for the fifth time to table a petition on behalf of the residents of Abbotsford—South Langley regarding extortion. Our community is deeply concerned about the increasing prevalence of organized crime, extortion, shootings and intimidation in our community. This new year has seen more extortion cases than the number of days that have passed. Recent daylight shootings, homicides ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f604a86b103a652868206b3bbc97878c3371fac0bea0f4a1542220b80d2655ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["27f9dcbbd3cbbc2e19234a1b02c33725b56623a6a0fed9beb734e8b6274973c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fbd773831232a9372e3d303","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86058,"date":"2026-02-04T21:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise to present a petition on behalf of the residents of Abbotsford—South Langley, who are increasingly concerned about the severe and ongoing flood risks facing our Abbotsford community.\n\nThese petitioners note that Abbotsford's low-lying geography along the Fraser River has led to repeated flooding that has caused millions of dollars in damage to homes, farms, businesses and critical infrastructure, while also disrupting vital supply chains far beyond our region. They warn against aging and inefficient flood protection infrastructure that is failing to meet today's realities, and point out that meaningful flood mitigation requires urgent investment; moderate, climate-resilient infrastructure guided by science; and community support.\n\nThe petitioners call upon the Government of Canada to take a seat at the table with the province and municipality, to invest in flood mitigation and monitoring, early warning systems and emergency preparedness for Abbotsford, and to deliver clear, actionable flood mitigation measures in the next federal budget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86058","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise to present a petition on behalf of the residents of Abbotsford—South Langley, who are increasingly concerned about the severe and ongoing flood risks facing our Abbotsford community.\n\nThese petitioners note that Abbotsford's low-lying geography along the Fraser River has led to repeated flooding that has caused millions of dollars in damage to homes, farms, businesses and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","label":"Water pollution","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d8ebdc07afc5b4a00ac86392775ca7bca3dd8d1ee2f2774b46185c04a7c2d47"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-409909b14db9edf49fc9627b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86057,"date":"2026-02-05T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada leads the G7 in food inflation; prices are rising twice as fast as in the United States, but yesterday the Liberals voted against the Conservative plan to lower food costs. The industrial carbon tax is driving up costs for farm machinery, fertilizers and food processors. When we tax the farmer, we tax every Canadian.\n\nWhen will the Liberals work with us to cut the unnecessary industrial carbon tax and the 17¢-a-litre fuel standard tax, which are driving up grocery prices?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86057","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada leads the G7 in food inflation; prices are rising twice as fast as in the United States, but yesterday the Liberals voted against the Conservative plan to lower food costs. The industrial carbon tax is driving up costs for farm machinery, fertilizers and food processors. When we tax the farmer, we tax every Canadian.\n\nWhen will the Liberals work with us to cut the unnecessary i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","label":"Agricultural technology","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["168ed3c99922d6c045c15b8cade0857bb993ab82c4d2bae4328f12375a1ea56b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a8e6bafbb38b65bf5315d0ff0cbd31e43bab25a6c774cfbefaa49c681f71916a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53b0d61a1d30c5b86dc60cb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299601,"date":"2026-02-09T20:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, extortion has surged by 330% since the Liberals took office. Across our country, Canadians are under attack, and the Liberals are rejecting Conservative plans to stop this violence. Now convicted extortionists are exploiting loopholes in our justice and immigration systems by filing refugee claims to stay in Canada.\n\n Will the Liberals back our Conservative plan, also supported by B.C.'s NDP premier, to bar non-citizens convicted of serious crimes from making refugee claims, or will they continue to side with the criminals?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299601","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, extortion has surged by 330% since the Liberals took office. Across our country, Canadians are under attack, and the Liberals are rejecting Conservative plans to stop this violence. Now convicted extortionists are exploiting loopholes in our justice and immigration systems by filing refugee claims to stay in Canada.\n\n Will the Liberals back our Conservative plan, also supported by B.C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b70c68325812275d4a61f6eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299597,"date":"2026-02-10T20:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on behalf of my constituents from Abbotsford—South Langley and Canadians who are living in fear, frustration and a deepening loss of trust for the Liberal government. Many feel abandoned and that their safety and their families are being pushed aside. This Conservative motion before the House will help restore confidence in both our justice system and our immigration system. It ensures that the laws of this country protect innocent people and not those who terrorize our communities. This motion recognizes a simple truth: When laws are weakened, when consequences disappear and when loopholes are left open, organized crime does not hesitate to step in, and it is ordinary Canadians who end up paying that price.\n\nSince the Liberals were elected, extortion in Canada has risen 330%, and it is not any better in British Columbia, where I am from. In British Columbia, extortion has risen 482%. In January alone, the Surrey police tracked 36 separate extortion attacks, 36. That is more than the number of days in the month. Those are just the ones that are being reported to the police. \n\nExtortion is not a victimless crime; it is a threat made in the middle of the night, and sometimes in broad daylight. It is intimidation directed at small business owners. It is arson. It is gunfire. It is families being targeted in their own homes. It is people being forced to choose between their safety and their livelihood.\n\nI can speak personally to the impact of this violence. I know and speak to many victims and their families regularly, more regularly than I would like. These are people in our Lower Mainland communities, who live in fear every single day. Families who have reached out to me in my community choose to sleep in their basement with their children, because they are scared of bullets flying through their bedroom windows at night. People are scared to go to their own place of work, businesses they own, because they do not know if they are going to return home that night to their families.\n\nAs a federal representative, I get phone calls and concerns about these shootings more than I would ever think I could. Mr. Satwinder Sharma was shot in broad daylight. His family is still grieving his loss every single day. Mr. Baljinder Garcha's death took Surrey by shock. Until this day, many questions are left unanswered. Mr. Darshan Singh Sahsi, a father, a husband, a son and a dear friend of mine, was someone who was recklessly killed in an extortion attack in front of his own home. Every statistic is a real person, a grieving family and a community left asking why more was not done to stop this reckless violence.\n\nToday, many Canadians are afraid to report crimes because they fear retaliation, and others are left wondering whether anyone in authority is truly listening to them. From Abbotsford—South Langley to Brampton, Surrey, Vancouver, Calgary, throughout the Lower Mainland and across our nation, people are continuing to live in fear.\n\nThis brings us to Bill C-5 and Bill C-75, two pieces of Liberal legislation that sit at the heart of this crisis. Bill C-5 repealed mandatory jail time for serious violent offences, including extortion with a firearm, and the Liberals' catch-and release-plan under Bill C-75 is failing Canadians. Ultimately, the principle of restraint has been twisted into a policy that protects repeat violent offenders, leaving law-abiding Canadians vulnerable. Together, these bills have created a revolving-door justice system, one where an offender can be arrested, released and often released again to commit the same crime within days, if not hours.\n\nThese increases did not happen by accident. They are a direct result of the deliberate Liberal policies that have weakened our sentencing and bail laws. Instead of taking decisive action, the Liberal government has repeatedly voted against common-sense Conservative proposals aimed to address these crises. \n\nThe Liberals voted against Bill C-381, proposed by my Conservative colleague from Edmonton Gateway, which would bring tougher sentences for extortionists.\n\nThe Conservatives are ready to pass laws and help Canadians protect themselves, their families and their homes, but the Liberals are insisting on targeting responsible gun owners and hunters with their gun-grab scam. It is shameful that they are not going after the real problems, which are extortionists. \n\nThe Liberals' failures are not limited to public safety laws; they are also evident in their mismanagement of our immigration system. In the fall of 2025, the Liberals voted against an update to the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, proposed by the Conservatives to bar asylum claims from being made by those who have been convicted of serious crimes in Canada. This was a common-sense change that would have prevented the abuse of Canada's asylum system and deterred non-citizens from avoiding deportation after committing serious crimes.\n\nLet me be clear: Canada's refugee system exists to protect those fleeing genuine prosecution. It is not a shield for individuals convicted of serious crimes. Do the Liberals really believe that an individual who has committed serious offences should be rewarded with Canadian citizenship?\n\nWhen criminals use asylum claims and delay tactics to avoid deportation, it undermines public trust and puts Canadians at risk, and Canadians face the real consequences. In British Columbia, every single one of 14 people who were charged with extortion immediately claimed asylum after being charged. They used Canada's refugee system to delay justice and avoid deportation. This shows how the refugee system, which is meant to protect people fleeing real prosecution, is being exploited by criminals, and Canadians are the ones who end up paying the price. This is why this motion truly matters.\n\nThe motion would call on the Liberal government to bar non-citizens convicted of serious crimes from making refugee claims. If someone has committed a serious violent offence, Canada's asylum system should not be available to them. It is as simple as that. The motion would also put an end to the leniency that lets non-citizens convicted of serious crimes escape deportation. Deportation should be a consequence, not a choice. The motion would also bar non-citizens with active judicial proceedings related to serious crimes from making refugee claims. This is important, as it would send a message to non-citizens, who now believe they can commit serious crimes and avoid deportation by abusing Canada's asylum system. Finally, it calls on the government to repeal Bill C-5 and Bill C-75 so that repeat extortionists stay in jail and cannot terrorize our communities any longer.\n\nThis motion is necessary to end the crisis. Even the NDP Premier of British Columbia called for the law to be changed. While the premier is a New Democrat and I am a Conservative member, there are some political bridges that we actually agree on. It protects genuine refugees, supports our law enforcement and restores confidence once again in our justice system. Most importantly, it puts victims first.\n\nCanadians are asking for action and for leadership. They are asking for a government that takes their safety seriously. The House has a choice: We can continue down a path of leniency, loopholes and rising crime, or we can take a stand for safer streets, stronger laws and real consequences.\n\nConservatives are choosing safety and to put victims over criminals. I urge all members of the House to support this as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299597","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on behalf of my constituents from Abbotsford—South Langley and Canadians who are living in fear, frustration and a deepening loss of trust for the Liberal government. Many feel abandoned and that their safety and their families are being pushed aside. This Conservative motion before the House will help restore confidence in both our justice system and our immigration system. It","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c60d258038b813aa5d5b3da6ccef0dba00af2f83d5fd614a5432614083b3f205"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11ded0004ee7eeaba0726eaa4aadc77efa781ff775cfd19720e38c2f03bdf6cd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b681c40dba24b7ef8dbcf7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299598,"date":"2026-02-10T21:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if my hon. colleague is truly passionate and understands the problem that is happening in B.C. right now, he should understand that our community members, British Columbians and the Conservative Party have been asking for change, not today or yesterday, but for over a year. We have brought forward bills to make sure we can address these root problems. We have been waiting on the government to act for the past decade, but it has not acted. That is the problem.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299598","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if my hon. colleague is truly passionate and understands the problem that is happening in B.C. right now, he should understand that our community members, British Columbians and the Conservative Party have been asking for change, not today or yesterday, but for over a year. We have brought forward bills to make sure we can address these root problems. We have been waiting on the gover","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b78341baba209b8f16a3e7c561f869b82270414ca7eac46fc40e735e8f3523a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66940b577606de817fc8c602","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299599,"date":"2026-02-10T21:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague commented that he does not know anyone who is living in fear day by day. I urge my colleague to come to B.C. to see what we face in our Lower Mainland communities, because this issue is real, and it is alive. There were 36 extortion cases in January, just since the new year. It is insane. \n\nWhat we are dealing with is an extortion crisis. It needs to be dealt with now, not yesterday. That is why we are urging the government to vote for this motion, agree with us and collaborate. Let us work together.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299599","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague commented that he does not know anyone who is living in fear day by day. I urge my colleague to come to B.C. to see what we face in our Lower Mainland communities, because this issue is real, and it is alive. There were 36 extortion cases in January, just since the new year. It is insane. \n\nWhat we are dealing with is an extortion crisis. It needs to be dealt with now, no","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dae365408d7a030e8b083b4924423158a04a5e94f0f4926cc8b50a5ce6a96697"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ac5247b45d5ec5b7b3dcf00e7ee51507d13f8e343e367299b132f960e43a16c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75c75d7f39588733e37ca156","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299600,"date":"2026-02-10T21:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in communities like Surrey and Abbotsford right now, we are hearing from police institutions doing press conferences. They are troubled. They hear the community. The community right now is concerned about these issues. We are trying to work with local municipalities, as well as the provinces. We want to make sure we can bring real results to Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299600","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in communities like Surrey and Abbotsford right now, we are hearing from police institutions doing press conferences. They are troubled. They hear the community. The community right now is concerned about these issues. We are trying to work with local municipalities, as well as the provinces. We want to make sure we can bring real results to Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1817507a282cfaa410c738fdc2de38f97c536633c109a64e9468e44eefe1f23c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9e02759b47ccf4b777f6f9baaef77f54d4afde85991d7d6b55e555462db17520"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20d36f44b61f9d7087344bc1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299596,"date":"2026-02-12T20:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbia is facing a public safety crisis. Extortion is now at record highs and my community members are living in constant fear. Abbotsford police have been clear. They are calling on elected officials to act urgently and work across party lines to confront these ongoing threats. Canadians' safety matters now.\n\nWill the Liberals act today and vote for our Conservative plan, supported by the NDP Premier of B.C., to ensure that those convicted of serious crimes cannot exploit our refugee system in order to stay in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299596","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbia is facing a public safety crisis. Extortion is now at record highs and my community members are living in constant fear. Abbotsford police have been clear. They are calling on elected officials to act urgently and work across party lines to confront these ongoing threats. Canadians' safety matters now.\n\nWill the Liberals act today and vote for our Conservative plan, s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c26f104b62d643042373592cb42f04a531e20573d35d6701a5c08cef3179dd32"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1c44671a22bd9a0fda37f0356fc5f00109804a4ca08acf5fc7cbdce4294e9914"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b99fa766cddac30eb9302b19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310384,"date":"2026-02-24T19:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when the Prime Minister's former chief of staff, the current justice minister and the member for York South—Weston—Etobicoke ran the immigration file, their reckless policies broke our asylum system, overwhelming it to the point that the Immigration and Refugee Board was forced to gut critical safeguards just to keep up. Nearly 25,000 individuals were admitted to Canada without a single in-person interview.\n\nWhy did the Liberals dismantle our critical safeguards for our refugee system and put Canadian lives at risk?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310384","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when the Prime Minister's former chief of staff, the current justice minister and the member for York South—Weston—Etobicoke ran the immigration file, their reckless policies broke our asylum system, overwhelming it to the point that the Immigration and Refugee Board was forced to gut critical safeguards just to keep up. Nearly 25,000 individuals were admitted to Canada without a sing","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","label":"Humanitarian crisis","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["996d955200b64b52eae9914fd4c0b3733dd4985f6da1fd4696d216ccdcf66563"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["446e023ce5c05ae0f1f752600c0ff94e2d6ef8cde0e60f07a090e08bed478d15"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c64d5b94b0c4a4e9265cbe3a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310382,"date":"2026-02-25T21:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on behalf of the good people of Abbotsford—South Langley, who have put forward this petition about the troubling proposal of the Liberal and Bloc amendments to Bill C-9 that would put the religious freedoms of Canadians at risk.\n\nPetitioners are deeply troubled that the amendment would remove the good faith religious defence from the Criminal Code of Canada, which would lead to the criminalization of passages from the Bible, from the Quran, from the Guru Granth Sahib, from the Torah and from other sacred texts and expose individuals to prosecution when expressing sincerely held religious beliefs that the government may deem offensive.\n\nAccording to this, the Government of Canada is being called on to withdraw Bill C-9, to protect religious freedoms and to defend the right to read and share sacred texts free from the government's interference.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310382","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on behalf of the good people of Abbotsford—South Langley, who have put forward this petition about the troubling proposal of the Liberal and Bloc amendments to Bill C-9 that would put the religious freedoms of Canadians at risk.\n\nPetitioners are deeply troubled that the amendment would remove the good faith religious defence from the Criminal Code of Canada, which would lead to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["621c0919bbf3a7f9992d599a58dd65aeac23b2b32c2b6525c0665bc783b7a762"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8372d705c958acb866132413","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310383,"date":"2026-02-25T21:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a second petition as well. I am honoured to rise on behalf of the good people of Abbotsford—South Langley, who are deeply troubled with the proposed revisions to the salmon allocation policy, changes that would severely limit recreational fishery opportunities for the coho and chinook salmon of British Columbia.\n\nPetitioners further emphasize that such changes would have serious consequences for the tourism sector and for the millions of dollars that recreational fisheries contribute to and conserve in the area.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310383","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a second petition as well. I am honoured to rise on behalf of the good people of Abbotsford—South Langley, who are deeply troubled with the proposed revisions to the salmon allocation policy, changes that would severely limit recreational fishery opportunities for the coho and chinook salmon of British Columbia.\n\nPetitioners further emphasize that such changes would have seriou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4b4c2df3152f4e20a3af121453dfbb86f7d052872e450bfecc5dbef79f7f7465"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fe532991d6ac784e2aa223bfbcc5ce6594e73c937ef407ff52847b055c745b9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61206d58c2b1dd61054351da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349210,"date":"2026-03-09T22:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member has highlighted concerns about Bill C-20.\n\nI would like to ask him what he is hearing from the grassroots constituents and the youth of his community. What are their concerns, and what are they saying to him about the current rising unaffordability?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349210","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member has highlighted concerns about Bill C-20.\n\nI would like to ask him what he is hearing from the grassroots constituents and the youth of his community. What are their concerns, and what are they saying to him about the current rising unaffordability?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7ab999db8987342636e4728","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349211,"date":"2026-03-09T22:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the people of Abbotsford—South Langley and I rise on their behalf. They have real concerns with respect to the Liberal House. During the election, the Liberals promised Canadians bold, decisive action on housing. They pledged to create Build Canada Homes, claiming it would solve the very housing crisis that they helped create in the first place; they have failed over and again. It sounded like a plan for hope for the families that are struggling to buy their first home. Today, Canadians are seeing something very different. What was promised as a solution has become more bureaucracy. What was promised as action has turned into inaction. This was meant to bring more homes and hope, but neither was delivered. \n\nLet us remember what was promised. The Liberals pledged to deliver 500,000 new homes every single year. That was a commitment made to Canadians in this country who are struggling to buy their first home. There was a promise made to youth, to the young families trying to get ahead and to the renters hoping to one day own their own home. Now we learn that housing starts have fallen to 212,000 homes per year by 2028, less than half of what was promised. This is a complete failure to achieve what was pledged to Canadians by the Liberal government.\n\n Instead of delivering homes, Bill C-20 would effectively deliver a fourth housing bureaucracy. What is most shocking about this is that there are no set targets. The housing minister confirmed during a press conference on Bill C-20 that, under the Liberals' plan, there are no top-line targets set for the number of homes to be built. It is an utter shock that there are no targets set. How are Canadians supposed to place their trust in the government? Canadians were promised 500,000 homes per year. Now they are told there are no targets at all. How can Canadians have confidence when there is no plan to measure any success? How can we solve a national housing crisis without clear benchmarks for success? It is all talk and no action. \n\nWhen houses start to be built, the Parliamentary Budget Office found that Build Canada Homes would likely add only around 5,000 homes per year. That is 1% of what the Liberals promised. At the same time, construction activity is projected to decline by 18.1% to well below the 10-year historical average. Let me be clear. Prices are projected to rise, construction is projected to fall, and the Liberal government's solution to this is this bill, which only creates more bureaucracy without any set targets. It is just shameful. Build Canada Homes would not solve real problems because it creates a new agency without removing the rules and the delays that make housing more expensive for Canadians. It would not change any zoning laws, settle any case-by-case rezoning fights, set firm deadlines for approvals or cut duplicate fees or environmental charges.\n\n If we do not fix delays, we do not fix costs. If we do not fix costs, we do not fix affordability. Real reform is about creating new programs. It is about removing roadblocks, setting clear timelines, cutting extra taxes and fees, improving coordination between governments and holding departments accountable. That means fixing the system that we currently have, not adding another layer of bureaucracy to it. Builders across the country are saying clearly that we need to see less government in homebuilding, not more. Developers are not asking for new federal agencies, which the government is delivering to them. They are asking for faster approval rates, lower taxes, fewer development charges and predictable rules outlined. \n\nOn this side of the House, we believe that Canadians should have the opportunity to own a home and have access to affordable housing. Yes, we believe that the federal government can play a role in it, but it has to be limited. It should not obstruct; it should take out the bureaucracy. Conservatives have a plan to fight and focus on results. Conservatives oppose adding more bureaucracy and red tape to housing sectors already burdened by slow approval rates and rising costs. More government layers do not solve delays, but make them worse. Developers are clear about the challenges they are facing. We are the only party offering a real plan to address them. \n\nUnder the Liberal government and this so-called new Prime Minister, Canadians are being offered the same approach we have all seen before: more programs, more announcements, more agencies and fewer real results. We have seen this all before with the housing accelerator fund, where billions were spent on studies and consultants, and many of the slow approval processes have stayed in place. Money was added, but the delays remain. \n\nWhat Canada needs is more supply and less red tape with less government interference. It is that simple. Construction workers are ready to build, builders are ready to build and Canadians are ready to buy. What is standing in the way is not the lack of demand, but the lack of supply caused by excessive government interference and rising costs.\n\n Private builders, people who construct the vast majority of homes in this country, are asking for something very simple. They are asking for the government to get out of the way. They want less red tape, fewer taxes, less bureaucracy and more building. This is a Conservative approach.\n\nNearly nine out of 10 Canadians are concerned about housing affordability. This is not a niche issue or a temporary challenge. It is a matter of national stability. Housing supply is not a generational wedge issue. It is an issue that affects everyone, from young Canadians to adults to seniors. That is why the government should care, because it affects everyone and all of us together. When housing becomes scarce and unaffordable, it is more than just an individual strain. It weakens our nation's fiscal health. It reduces productivity and limits economic growth. Scarcity harms us all.\n\n For generations, home ownership has been the centre of a Canadian dream, the promise that if someone works hard, they can buy a home, raise a family and build a secure future. Today, that promise feels increasingly out of reach. Too many young Canadians believe they will never have the same opportunity as their parents did. That is just sad. We must restore the dream of home ownership for the next generation.\n\n We must give Canadians, including families in my community of Abbotsford—South Langley and communities across this nation, a real chance to buy a home, start a family and build a future, without being held back by the government's inefficiency and soaring costs. No one in Canada should feel that they will never get a fair shot at success, yet under the current Liberal government, far too many do. It is time to address the housing supply and the urgency it demands, not as a partisan issue, but as a non-partisan issue, as a national priority that secures opportunity and prosperity for all Canadians.\n\n Conservatives are ready to act and we are ready to work with anyone who is willing to put Canadians first. We have a clear plan that cuts costs, removes barriers, empowers builders and gets homes built. We would increase supply, lower prices and make home ownership achievable for families from coast to coast to coast. It is time for results, not red tape. It is time for action. That is why I urge the Liberal government to take a second look and cut out the bureaucracy and the layers.\n\nThis Build Canada Homes bill is not what we need right now. We need to make sure we can cut taxes and we can fight for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349211","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the people of Abbotsford—South Langley and I rise on their behalf. They have real concerns with respect to the Liberal House. During the election, the Liberals promised Canadians bold, decisive action on housing. They pledged to create Build Canada Homes, claiming it would solve the very housing crisis that they helped create in the first place; they have failed over and again","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8400fc49dd4c21a018458f8ebfdb70e44fdaa3bed7081587f800185802f6ff56"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46b73b598a51c0077c800c87270af2b3848f6bcdcc657253f1463aa148615860"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8a1e9a4a38437f13a40ec3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349212,"date":"2026-03-09T22:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague already knows that the government has been in power for the last 10 years. We have seen unaffordability rise under the Liberal government. That is what has been happening. \n\nMy generation is not succeeding. We are being held back now more than ever. That is the last thing that we need. Another bureaucracy being put in front of us is the last thing we need.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349212","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague already knows that the government has been in power for the last 10 years. We have seen unaffordability rise under the Liberal government. That is what has been happening. \n\nMy generation is not succeeding. We are being held back now more than ever. That is the last thing that we need. Another bureaucracy being put in front of us is the last thing we need.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["44986bcd1fa6a49e551b3aaeba1d52e81218e4b24ae560ee52d099553d7846b5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15efd07365baad35ea7d9baf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349213,"date":"2026-03-09T22:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with my colleague here on this side of the House that there are many problems that the current government is bringing in front of us that it is not addressing. Yes, we do need to work together. We do need to see all stages of the policies that we need to work on to make them more efficient.\n\nI think we would both agree that the last thing we need to do is add another layer of bureaucracy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349213","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with my colleague here on this side of the House that there are many problems that the current government is bringing in front of us that it is not addressing. Yes, we do need to work together. We do need to see all stages of the policies that we need to work on to make them more efficient.\n\nI think we would both agree that the last thing we need to do is add another layer of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ef25143b4ac93f796e35c8e8d6f0d72ebc0abc2fb27c8c5222cb1db7b763cee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7a4b1182568aacd091fcedd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349407,"date":"2026-03-09T22:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when a Conservative government was in power, many family members of mine came to this country. They were able to come here, afford a home and build a life, and they were able to succeed because they saw the Canadian vision. They saw the Canadian promise, the North American promise.\n\nFor myself today, being born in Canada, it is difficult to succeed in this current chapter, in this current year, because everything is getting more and more unaffordable. That is the same thing I hear from my peers, the same thing I hear from all the youth in my community.\n\nThe member who asked me the question is correct. We need to bring change. We need to make sure that we go back to the old ways, to the things that worked, and not add more layers of bureaucracy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349407","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when a Conservative government was in power, many family members of mine came to this country. They were able to come here, afford a home and build a life, and they were able to succeed because they saw the Canadian vision. They saw the Canadian promise, the North American promise.\n\nFor myself today, being born in Canada, it is difficult to succeed in this current chapter, in this cur","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3aa8ec28a25f5669d30ea43b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349408,"date":"2026-03-09T22:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will answer that question very simply. I am from British Columbia. The current housing minister apparently did an amazing job in Vancouver with the housing bureaucracy he created there. We do not see anything getting better currently with the Liberal government. If there is a problem, it is because of the Liberal government. If something is in the way, it is because of the Liberal government. We need to make sure that we bring change. That is what Canadians are fighting for. I urge the members across to stop supporting this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349408","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will answer that question very simply. I am from British Columbia. The current housing minister apparently did an amazing job in Vancouver with the housing bureaucracy he created there. We do not see anything getting better currently with the Liberal government. If there is a problem, it is because of the Liberal government. If something is in the way, it is because of the Liberal g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3614d568c02778a938495ced5fe4a2c6f911c88454dc2b1dd25f0b8231e8e392"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52a8fa19cffe28896b8b1ccee755089113b4f48f9f03f0c2f55510427e8f1157"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6887f1106f3a516eb7ac706c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349208,"date":"2026-03-10T15:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am presenting two petitions.\n\nFirst I rise in support of the Conservative petition regarding the flawed amendments the Bloc and Liberals are proposing to Bill C-9. If passed, they would put religious freedoms of Canadians in jeopardy.\n\nThe residents of Abbotsford—South Langley have voiced their concerns regarding the development of how this may restrict their freedoms. Our Charter of Rights and Freedoms clearly states in sections 2(a) and 2(b) that freedom of expression and freedom of religion must be preserved and are crucial to Canadian society.\n\n Therefore, the petitioners call on the government to protect religious freedoms and uphold the right to read and share sacred texts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349208","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am presenting two petitions.\n\nFirst I rise in support of the Conservative petition regarding the flawed amendments the Bloc and Liberals are proposing to Bill C-9. If passed, they would put religious freedoms of Canadians in jeopardy.\n\nThe residents of Abbotsford—South Langley have voiced their concerns regarding the development of how this may restrict their freedoms. Our Charter o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["153fbc24016ac027793013998f0b1bc712d6fdce7a4defc55d54731e2f35d517"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["723d21c53dcda1e1837ba34bb47733cca9a44bb052604e1eb89181838dfb4efa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1cef04bf97ae86656d00804e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349209,"date":"2026-03-10T15:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a second petition, which I am tabling on behalf of the good citizens of Abbotsford—South Langley who are deeply concerned about the proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia.\n\nConstituents are calling for the Minister of Fisheries to leave the current salmon allocation policy alone to uphold the cultural rights and traditions of all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349209","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a second petition, which I am tabling on behalf of the good citizens of Abbotsford—South Langley who are deeply concerned about the proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia.\n\nConstituents are calling for the Minister of Fisheries to leave the current salmon allocation","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d9a67814559f89c6a07d0cbf3b1b0c3320a23c7e40cc590b5d807871a3247706"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["10acf3627b6c0195780b7ede7ddf4c4b7bdf5ce5b895f5ffd1d4092bf2247cad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08b6d7c15927581f5f1be83c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349207,"date":"2026-03-11T19:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada cannot control what happens abroad, but the Liberals do control the policies here at home that are making life more expensive. Under the Liberals, Canada tops the G7 in food inflation and is the only shrinking economy. The most vulnerable Canadians are the ones who are left to pay the price.\n\nOne in five Canadians over 50 are now living in conditions comparable to the poverty line. After years of Liberal deficits and rising taxes, the seniors of Abbotsford—South Langley, the very people who helped build this country, are struggling to afford basic needs, yet the Prime Minister is pushing ahead with his rebranded carbon tax, the clean fuel standard, and his industrial carbon tax, passing higher prices on to those who produce our food and goods and ultimately to all Canadians. These costs are imposed here at home, not abroad.\n\nWhen will the Prime Minister take responsibility for the policies he controls and scrap the taxes making life more unaffordable for all Canadians, especially our seniors?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349207","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada cannot control what happens abroad, but the Liberals do control the policies here at home that are making life more expensive. Under the Liberals, Canada tops the G7 in food inflation and is the only shrinking economy. The most vulnerable Canadians are the ones who are left to pay the price.\n\nOne in five Canadians over 50 are now living in conditions comparable to the poverty l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b7dd07009073c7ab7beb160ee60a4ede155d5eabbb2b7dfc46d32e213e1c9ae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bc913cf1c4369e9fd152b1e60dc89f2080a24feb6291aba7e51ac94ccfc8d707"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bfb280c1af109c410058a003","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390258,"date":"2026-03-23T19:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, April brings several holidays across Canada, each with its own traditions.\n\n For Christians, it is time to reflect on the resurrection of Jesus Christ and the hope it represents. For many Canadians, Easter is also a chance to spend time with family, enjoy the arrival of spring and, for kids, maybe a bit too much chocolate from the Easter bunny.\n\n For Jewish families, Passover is a time to come together in celebration of liberation and tradition. I wish all Jewish Canadians a kosher and joyous Passover. \n\nFor Sikhs, Vaisakhi is a significant and sacred day. It represents renewal and the core values of equality and selflessness. I am truly looking forward to celebrating Vaisakhi at the Surrey parade and especially here at Parliament Hill. To everyone celebrating, from my family to theirs, Vaisakhi diyan lakh lakh vadhaiyan.\n\nRegardless of what people are celebrating, may April be full of family joy and moments worth remembering.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390258","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, April brings several holidays across Canada, each with its own traditions.\n\n For Christians, it is time to reflect on the resurrection of Jesus Christ and the hope it represents. For many Canadians, Easter is also a chance to spend time with family, enjoy the arrival of spring and, for kids, maybe a bit too much chocolate from the Easter bunny.\n\n For Jewish families, Passover is a tim","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3968c7f3d8a9c261fd975bfba5e51d39f1c06f2881f79c4adf045dc29189c7ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf0b44a94a185c03086b8312c55ef50ac26f6b6fc311e8f1bc67bae70143ea75"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7615612ef19bea1b7a856ce2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390165,"date":"2026-03-24T15:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today in support of a Conservative petition regarding the flawed amendments the Bloc and the Liberals are proposing to Bill C-9. If passed, it would put the religious freedoms of Canadians in jeopardy. My residents of Abbotsford—South Langley have voiced their concern regarding this development and how it may restrict their freedoms.\n\n As our Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms clearly states in sections 2(a) and 2(b), the freedoms of expression and religion must be preserved and are crucial to Canadian society. Therefore, the petitioners call on the government to protect religious freedom, uphold the right to read and share sacred texts and prevent government overreach into matters of faith.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390165","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today in support of a Conservative petition regarding the flawed amendments the Bloc and the Liberals are proposing to Bill C-9. If passed, it would put the religious freedoms of Canadians in jeopardy. My residents of Abbotsford—South Langley have voiced their concern regarding this development and how it may restrict their freedoms.\n\n As our Canadian Charter of Rights and Free","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a610100d5edb039cd84b3d3fe95015985977bad3bf2a26c4eb6849c233d6ec29"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a9cfb4deef352625118c3ca7954ae087e169bf4d5cb977b9912e8ea5ec356e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27cce73ac40f0261e56d3c55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390166,"date":"2026-03-24T15:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a second petition. I rise today on behalf of petitioners of Abbotsford—South Langley to highlight an important issue affecting the growth and safety of local athletes. The lack of adequate training facilities for the home Wolverines Field Hockey Club limits development, compromises safety and restricts competitive opportunities.\n\nTherefore, the petitioners call on the Government of Canada to provide funding assistance through the federal sport infrastructure grant or relief programs, and partner with provincial and municipal bodies to support the construction of a grass hockey field suitable for training, development and competitive play.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390166","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a second petition. I rise today on behalf of petitioners of Abbotsford—South Langley to highlight an important issue affecting the growth and safety of local athletes. The lack of adequate training facilities for the home Wolverines Field Hockey Club limits development, compromises safety and restricts competitive opportunities.\n\nTherefore, the petitioners call on the Governmen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f74ba8f1e54997724c4141093c0d46d31d5d447fbe587f13d43f5997a0370c99"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d29ec4ad9eb3ae27c8dea6aba30a9e01378ad2eabc3c1fd31ca668f3f9955d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7412d4de0be741ffdfb71d4d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715116,"date":"2026-04-14T18:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my question is very simple. The hon. member has been talking about his constituents and how they have been feeling the squeeze at the gas pumps. We see that the Liberals have adopted half of our plan. Could my colleague please elaborate on why they should have stolen the full idea of the Conservative plan that we were proposing, and not just half of it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715116","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my question is very simple. The hon. member has been talking about his constituents and how they have been feeling the squeeze at the gas pumps. We see that the Liberals have adopted half of our plan. Could my colleague please elaborate on why they should have stolen the full idea of the Conservative plan that we were proposing, and not just half of it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac579267720cf6d275c172799c469305cb7064d67fd520c422b010a8d855e194"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c355a13c35c6307ba8df14e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715118,"date":"2026-04-14T19:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Cowichan ruling has raised very real concerns about the security of property rights in Canada. At a time of high costs and economic uncertainty, Canadians should not be questioning the ownership of their homes. \n\nThe Liberals negotiated the Musqueam agreement in secret, with no transparency, leaving homeowners unable to sell and builders unwilling to invest, all during a housing crisis.\n\nWill the Liberals commit to protecting Canadian rights by ensuring no future agreements are signed without clearly stating that private properties come first and are protected?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715118","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Cowichan ruling has raised very real concerns about the security of property rights in Canada. At a time of high costs and economic uncertainty, Canadians should not be questioning the ownership of their homes. \n\nThe Liberals negotiated the Musqueam agreement in secret, with no transparency, leaving homeowners unable to sell and builders unwilling to invest, all during a housing c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["69c65871167f989367aedd2e6ba83c620b0dc39aaba03759fc5def720c69f1b2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e406067d8e42aeaceec33458e9c7e5b7a2c677c218403b53e78956b338f060c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f32f15fff30cfa7ebbd06ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715113,"date":"2026-04-15T21:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on behalf of the residents of Abbotsford—South Langley who are concerned about the lack of adequate sports infrastructure to support local youth and athletes.\n\nThe petitioners note that inefficient training facilities for the home Wolverines field hockey club are limiting athlete development, compromising safety and restricting opportunity for training and competition. They emphasize that access to proper facilities is essential to foster athletic growth, community engagement and safe participation in sports.\n\nTherefore, the petitioners are calling on the Government of Canada to provide funding and assistance through the federal sports infrastructure program and to work in partnership with the provincial and municipal governments to support construction of a new grass field hockey facility suitable for training, development and competitive play.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715113","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on behalf of the residents of Abbotsford—South Langley who are concerned about the lack of adequate sports infrastructure to support local youth and athletes.\n\nThe petitioners note that inefficient training facilities for the home Wolverines field hockey club are limiting athlete development, compromising safety and restricting opportunity for training and competition. Th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Physical disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","label":"Physical disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7fc27622a642ad12a2b5953850e1829cffb132857bebf29371de475e16c73dbe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["38d534d0d060e9b2906e68b555f1a26479cc188a6bb9195dedd129757a995cc5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f72d8d0673c600a88f1c0b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715115,"date":"2026-04-15T21:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a second petition, on behalf of the residents of Abbotsford—South Langley who are concerned about the future management of accessibility in our country's salmon resources. They note that for generations, salmon in Canada has been managed by the common property resource held in trust by the federal government for the benefit of all Canadians.\n\nThe current salmon allocation policy supports conservation, transparency and fair access for indigenous, recreational and commercial harvesting. However, they warn that proposed changes in the policy could remove that foundational principle, undermining public access and stewardship, weakening salmon restoration efforts and risking the concentration of access in the hands of a few.\n\nThey ask that the government revise the principal salmon allocation policy, ensuring that salmon remains publicly managed and conservation efforts stay transparent and effective, while access is also preserved for all Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715115","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a second petition, on behalf of the residents of Abbotsford—South Langley who are concerned about the future management of accessibility in our country's salmon resources. They note that for generations, salmon in Canada has been managed by the common property resource held in trust by the federal government for the benefit of all Canadians.\n\nThe current salmon allocation polic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","label":"Resources conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","label":"Resources conservation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","label":"Fish farming","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bbec23f5428a087e34efa6d87730bb899c999b7f91c9354bafef92b798926e5c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3b3ca18adb0c5b237a82546ce2994f081b8f0598bb97c5e2564bd5294fe1ece9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57d891d594ff479224751cb8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715112,"date":"2026-04-16T15:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in the House. Today I am tabling a petition on behalf of residents of Abbotsford—South Langley who are deeply concerned with the proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook salmon in British Columbia.\n\n For generations, salmon has been managed as a common property resource held in trust by the government for the benefit of all Canadians. Altering this principle risks transforming a shared public resource into an exclusive privilege, which would limit access and erode public confidence in fishery management.\n\n The petitioners call on the Minister of Fisheries to maintain the current salmon allocation policy while continuing to respect and uphold the cultural rights and traditions of all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715112","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in the House. Today I am tabling a petition on behalf of residents of Abbotsford—South Langley who are deeply concerned with the proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook salmon in British Columbia.\n\n For generations, salmon has been managed as a common property re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["05b92c0cd652d8a1ce2e881506e33882d4df69a004cd6d1ad7a1043041ea55e6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a20f1339a3c418a9746f889d591f13284853a2abcedfcca06b4181ff631e92f6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c866d0f76912cee663bb154","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127438,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you to all the witnesses who are testifying here today. It's been a pleasure to listen in on the discussion today. My first question is going back to the used car dealerships and those dealers. How often are they coming across cars with these VINs that are compromised? Could you expand on that, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127438","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to all the witnesses who are testifying here today. It's been a pleasure to listen in on the discussion today. My first question is going back to the used car dealerships and those dealers. How often are they coming across cars with these VINs that are compromised? Could you expand on that, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27dc2e8daf9dd5bfab45f96f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127439,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Tod, would you like to expand on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127439","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Tod, would you like to expand on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c195f75269e3021f1905c563","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127440,"date":"2026-04-21T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"We see how this organized crime thing pivots to ships. We see, in the research, how the police and all the services there are trying to make sure they can get on top of it. You mentioned some pivots. What is your biggest worry factor, given how organized crime is playing out?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127440","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We see how this organized crime thing pivots to ships. We see, in the research, how the police and all the services there are trying to make sure they can get on top of it. You mentioned some pivots. What is your biggest worry factor, given how organized crime is playing out?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bcda1a9bb220e3ad642d88d9bb7a35594d04ae7030caa836432d05fb0088150b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4fa3146f528b4ddd830b6f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127441,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"I also recall your mentioning how crucial it is that CBSA data be shared with all organizations like yours. I want to understand why that is being delayed to this extent. What can we do to make sure we are taking advantage of the information we collect? You follow all the measures. You follow all the protocols. What are the roadblocks here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127441","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I also recall your mentioning how crucial it is that CBSA data be shared with all organizations like yours. I want to understand why that is being delayed to this extent. What can we do to make sure we are taking advantage of the information we collect? You follow all the measures. You follow all the protocols. What are the roadblocks here?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49b8e830169483e3682941fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127442,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"I just got started.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127442","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I just got started.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-253dc37429c5145e80444eaf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301254,"date":"2026-04-22T19:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, everything costs more. Families are deeper in debt and home ownership is slipping away from an entire generation. Canada now stands alone as the only shrinking economy in the entire G7. \n\nThe Prime Minister's legacy is unfolding right before our eyes. Every country in the G7 faces the same global pressures, but the results are worlds apart and Canadians are left to pay that price. From farmers to tradespeople to seniors and young families, the people of Abbotsford—South Langley deserve a Prime Minister who will fight for them. They are tired of the excuses, the recycled speeches and the broken promises. They simply want results. \n\nConservatives have been fighting to end the Liberal government's wasteful spending and restore the Canadian dream once again, where hard work leads to a great life. We will never back down from that promise. It is time for the Prime Minister to get his act together, work with us and bring results for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301254","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, everything costs more. Families are deeper in debt and home ownership is slipping away from an entire generation. Canada now stands alone as the only shrinking economy in the entire G7. \n\nThe Prime Minister's legacy is unfolding right before our eyes. Every country in the G7 faces the same global pressures, but the results are worlds apart and Canadians are left to pay that price. Fro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aaaf4ee3e79cbce973c1c7f7f1824071418eee198fe0cf38f083f523c5882422"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e042c368da6a61bdddfc7a9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127443,"date":"2026-04-30T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much for that, Chak. My colleague Rhonda asked earlier if you were ever briefed about Mr. Taj prior to him ever landing in Vancouver. You guys did not answer the question. Yes or no, were you ever briefed? Could you please answer the question?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127443","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much for that, Chak. My colleague Rhonda asked earlier if you were ever briefed about Mr. Taj prior to him ever landing in Vancouver. You guys did not answer the question. Yes or no, were you ever briefed? Could you please answer the question?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c2d800cd8bdf9ddea1734ba7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127444,"date":"2026-04-30T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm asking about Mr. Taj, who landed in Vancouver. It's the case you referred to that's going on this week. You didn't know which date either.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127444","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm asking about Mr. Taj, who landed in Vancouver. It's the case you referred to that's going on this week. You didn't know which date either.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ca514fc56b8fec2b68d66b2af14f8b9523e1b5f3ec684562a07ae55787f664d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-086d702db4aa75445ccb28ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127445,"date":"2026-04-30T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm sorry; that's my bad. It was Toronto. As to the IRGC agent who landed in Canada, were you ever briefed on that case prior to them landing in Toronto? It's a yes or no, for either minister. Could one of you please just say if you were ever briefed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127445","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm sorry; that's my bad. It was Toronto. As to the IRGC agent who landed in Canada, were you ever briefed on that case prior to them landing in Toronto? It's a yes or no, for either minister. Could one of you please just say if you were ever briefed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d6b0ed6a4185f82b6532a20","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127446,"date":"2026-04-30T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"So you were briefed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127446","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"So you were briefed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2cd295e12768c4df15dd0d40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127447,"date":"2026-04-30T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"You're the minister for a reason. You're at the head of the table. You call the shots at the end of the day. That's what your position is. You are responsible for someone coming into this country when they're not supposed to—when they are inadmissible and they're not supposed to be here. You said that it takes multiple steps to get here. What went wrong under your watch? At the end of the day, it was under your watch, Minister.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127447","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You're the minister for a reason. You're at the head of the table. You call the shots at the end of the day. That's what your position is. You are responsible for someone coming into this country when they're not supposed to—when they are inadmissible and they're not supposed to be here. You said that it takes multiple steps to get here. What went wrong under your watch? At the end of the day, it ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b90a095bbf82db7805e39878","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127448,"date":"2026-04-30T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister, your job is to make sure you serve Canadians. Canadians could have been put at risk because of this mistake, so why was there no stance before this? You said you were briefed; that is what I understand. What steps did you take that failed? What is the reason this person was allowed on Canadian ground at a single point? They were not allowed entry into the country, but they were at a port of entry. What went wrong?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127448","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Minister, your job is to make sure you serve Canadians. Canadians could have been put at risk because of this mistake, so why was there no stance before this? You said you were briefed; that is what I understand. What steps did you take that failed? What is the reason this person was allowed on Canadian ground at a single point? They were not allowed entry into the country, but they were at a port","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9762286cc35f6d74a16c22029c09bd87cce7ea20c64d11d366ec5ee711e3954"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f3f9cca92dd23ca06eaa6d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960700,"date":"2026-05-07T20:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister claims he will defend property rights, but his Liberal government's own website still shows that litigation directive number 14, which was announced as a directive back in 2019, still remains in effect today. The directive instructs federal lawyers not to defend private property rights in court. \n\nWhile the Prime Minister makes promises publicly, his government policies have not changed. Will he reverse his directive today so British Columbians can have certainty of home ownership?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960700","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister claims he will defend property rights, but his Liberal government's own website still shows that litigation directive number 14, which was announced as a directive back in 2019, still remains in effect today. The directive instructs federal lawyers not to defend private property rights in court. \n\nWhile the Prime Minister makes promises publicly, his government poli","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c013d986e649f390f99e92148596e734da6924dbe7f0964b1ae4ec086c6a265e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06dc237f0d2fd93def6f36a50ab63b93a258ce3dd1dcef0c605be988afdb1203"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c925dda09989441ed12aeed1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036320,"date":"2026-05-25T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after 11 years of the Liberals' soft-on-crime policies, Canadians are seeing more crime and chaos on our streets. Since 2015, violent crimes have risen by 55% nationally, while extortion has surged by 330%. In Surrey alone, extortion is up 2,400%. Liberal catch-and-release policies like Bill C-5 and Bill C-75 have led to Canadians' being more vulnerable and less safe.\n\nWhen will the government repeal its failed soft-on-crime laws, restore mandatory minimums and make sure that criminals serve the time that they deserve?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036320","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after 11 years of the Liberals' soft-on-crime policies, Canadians are seeing more crime and chaos on our streets. Since 2015, violent crimes have risen by 55% nationally, while extortion has surged by 330%. In Surrey alone, extortion is up 2,400%. Liberal catch-and-release policies like Bill C-5 and Bill C-75 have led to Canadians' being more vulnerable and less safe.\n\nWhen will the g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28c3c9e81429ec55b935df70dd2a443f8a369b7dfcf77d0c09665aec402624f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["65b864ad88c96f8ca1668973b90dc6f472e538113a0ce71545bc19c48ab639c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8412831a41914c4b8d6193a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036319,"date":"2026-05-26T19:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this week marks the 112th anniversary of the Komagata Maru incident. The Guru Nanak Jahaz is a monumental event for Sikh communities across our nation. ln 1914, 376 passengers, 340 Sikh, 24 Muslim and 12 Hindu, arrived in Vancouver with dreams for a better future. lnstead, they were unjustly denied entry and forced to return home after months in the harbour. \n\nWe remember the hardships faced by those aboard the Guru Nanak Jahaz while also honouring the strength and resilience shown by Sikh Canadians and South Asian communities throughout generations. As a Sikh member of the Conservative caucus, it is an honour to rise in recognition of this anniversary and the lasting contributions Sikh Canadians have made to our nation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036319","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this week marks the 112th anniversary of the Komagata Maru incident. The Guru Nanak Jahaz is a monumental event for Sikh communities across our nation. ln 1914, 376 passengers, 340 Sikh, 24 Muslim and 12 Hindu, arrived in Vancouver with dreams for a better future. lnstead, they were unjustly denied entry and forced to return home after months in the harbour. \n\nWe remember the hardship","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd46b9d718726e176db35600","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127449,"date":"2026-06-02T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. This is an open-ended question to all the witnesses here today. Thank you for being here. Does it feel rushed to you that we don't have enough time to study part 2? Could each of you respond to that, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127449","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. This is an open-ended question to all the witnesses here today. Thank you for being here. Does it feel rushed to you that we don't have enough time to study part 2? Could each of you respond to that, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Euthanasia","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime against humanity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime against humanity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034722","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime against humanity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034722","label":"Crime against humanity","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220581","label":"Euthanasia","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e26a13cbc974f37c3b31d2e90a1baa97713165969ac30628672f8fa715cdf153"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-687eb1d4cb442a0a8acdbc24","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127450,"date":"2026-06-02T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Surgenor.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127450","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Surgenor.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f749ac8b2993c2c874f4f1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127451,"date":"2026-06-02T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"I agree, 100%. Thank you for that. Mr. Hatfield, could you please provide a response as well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127451","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I agree, 100%. Thank you for that. Mr. Hatfield, could you please provide a response as well?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Freight","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Freight","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","label":"Freight","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c617af634ff8e8f966d0c6521b546c847d83965278612d1fee3cf04a203e0c67"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e605b432d0b0a52fdb53b39","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127452,"date":"2026-06-02T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes. It is quite upsetting to be in kind of a dark hole and not have the information we need that is so crucial to the study. I have one quick question for you, Mr. Hatfield. In an open letter of yours, your company argued that certain aspects of the bill would \"create an unprecedented and extraordinarily dangerous surveillance architecture that could impact every digital tool people in Canada depend on every [single] day\". Could you please expand on the specific aspects of Bill C-22 that you believe pose greater risks for Canadians' privacy and cybersecurity, and which amendments would most improve the proposed framework of this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127452","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes. It is quite upsetting to be in kind of a dark hole and not have the information we need that is so crucial to the study. I have one quick question for you, Mr. Hatfield. In an open letter of yours, your company argued that certain aspects of the bill would \"create an unprecedented and extraordinarily dangerous surveillance architecture that could impact every digital tool people in Canada dep","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11f40c461d329d347ee1295f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127453,"date":"2026-06-02T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much. I would like to allocate the rest of the time to my colleague Roman Baber.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127453","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I would like to allocate the rest of the time to my colleague Roman Baber.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d49a275bd60431341b71700","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086445,"date":"2026-06-08T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country in a recession. The economy has shrunk in two consecutive quarters. Per capita GDP is only up 1.5% over seven years, and labour productivity has declined for four years straight. Even the Parliamentary Budget Officer said there is a less than 1% chance that the government will meet its fiscal anchor.\n\nWill the Prime Minister tell us if we are in a recession, or are Canadians only technically doing worse after a decade of Liberal rule?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086445","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country in a recession. The economy has shrunk in two consecutive quarters. Per capita GDP is only up 1.5% over seven years, and labour productivity has declined for four years straight. Even the Parliamentary Budget Officer said there is a less than 1% chance that the government will meet its fiscal anchor.\n\nWill the Prime Mini","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4bec879d46afcc04417fa91c4571abcd712690a0864b2984d35308f4bc07b84d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["689bb4569ad08e9cae1439cda293bc2e5aff423fa7596bc0f16f4935f53c0698"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0cccbf816869e0837c3b63cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086446,"date":"2026-06-08T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukhman Gill","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the fact is that the Liberals caused these economic headwinds. The fact is that the Liberal Prime Minister is the only prime minister who is running this country, which is in a recession. Canadian banks are now warning of economic decline, with Scotiabank forecasting just 0.8% growth for Canada compared to 1.9% in the United States, while BMO projects even weaker growth, 0.5%, in 2026. It is not only that, but the Liberals are already borrowing billions of dollars over their projected costly budget.\n\nWill the Prime Minister finally admit that Canada is technically in a real recession?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086446","member_id":"bc-mp-123517","member_name":"Sukhman Gill","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the fact is that the Liberals caused these economic headwinds. The fact is that the Liberal Prime Minister is the only prime minister who is running this country, which is in a recession. Canadian banks are now warning of economic decline, with Scotiabank forecasting just 0.8% growth for Canada compared to 1.9% in the United States, while BMO projects even weaker growth, 0.5%, in 2026","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1cd8053cbdaa59b3d9210dee651bfabc1f5d5b9ab7776c5de042a5f08bf0a120"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dcc16a6dd3e3b6e4aedce9da850d5cbb4e041a17828cc34b9a5f4a34069928ae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fdb1531ef1243d4a4f7fb4a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76940,"date":"2026-01-29T16:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, last week in South Korea, I joined parliamentarians and activists from around the world at a conference on 2SLGBTQIA+ rights, where I was proud to share our Canadian experience.\n\nAt a time when democracy, inclusion and fundamental freedoms are under attack globally, Canada must lead with clarity and resolve. As the Prime Minister affirmed in Davos, our path forward must be both \"principled and pragmatic\".\n\nFebruary is Black History Month, and this year marks the 30th anniversary of its recognition in Canada. We honour the resilience, leadership and contribution of Black Canadians, and we recommit ourselves to justice and equal opportunity.\n\nLet me be very clear: racism, anti-Semitism, Islamophobia, homophobia, discrimination and hate in any form have no place in the House, no home in our communities and no future in Canada. In moments of uncertainty, Canadians do not turn inward. We stand together. We lead with purpose, and we move forward undaunted and determined to defend the Canada we love.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76940","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, last week in South Korea, I joined parliamentarians and activists from around the world at a conference on 2SLGBTQIA+ rights, where I was proud to share our Canadian experience.\n\nAt a time when democracy, inclusion and fundamental freedoms are under attack globally, Canada must lead with clarity and resolve. As the Prime Minister affirmed in Davos, our path forward must be both \"princ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a08bef6911ea74c0208e2435cc0f688439571fb437a9d3ffe83611d07d095891"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0441a1057730cfc5375beae75471f28b5e9f42aa7030819d96c2d9cee1fbdc93"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54dd9e9283820bd9a9ff2be3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299602,"date":"2026-02-12T19:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, how do we ensure that fear will never defeat us as Canadians?\n\nFamilies in Tumbler Ridge have faced every parent's worst nightmare. Innocent lives were taken, and many other people were injured. To the grieving families, we offer our deepest condolences. Their loss is felt across this country. To the people recovering and to the students and teachers carrying trauma, we stand beside them.\n\nWe thank the teachers who protected their students, the first responders who ran toward danger and the health care workers who worked tirelessly to save lives.\n\nIn Burnaby Central, we come from many cultures and speak different languages, but we stand as one in our promise: Our children should grow up free from violence.\n\nToday we hold Tumbler Ridge in our hearts. We rise together. By choosing light over hatred, solidarity over division, and peace over violence, we deny fear its power. In every choice we make, we uphold Canada, a land of courage and a home of compassion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299602","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, how do we ensure that fear will never defeat us as Canadians?\n\nFamilies in Tumbler Ridge have faced every parent's worst nightmare. Innocent lives were taken, and many other people were injured. To the grieving families, we offer our deepest condolences. Their loss is felt across this country. To the people recovering and to the students and teachers carrying trauma, we stand beside t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","label":"Safety education","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["16d36210d3838de4d287fcbe0197a465337724f7f8447fc3608aa501d0798709"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6196169b95b5f6acd4a316e473cc626cf7ac782ee7724a89ac68f43bf39035e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb16714dd9d4dbc166193bc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316458,"date":"2026-02-23T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Build Canada Homes is Canada's affordable housing builder, and it is already delivering real results. It continues to support projects that provide Canadians with safe, stable and affordable homes, including homes coming to British Columbia through a recently announced partnership.\n\nCan the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure update the House on how this new partnership will help deliver much-needed housing for residents in British Columbia?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316458","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Build Canada Homes is Canada's affordable housing builder, and it is already delivering real results. It continues to support projects that provide Canadians with safe, stable and affordable homes, including homes coming to British Columbia through a recently announced partnership.\n\nCan the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure update the House on how this new partnership will help d","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1ff55527050cf700a68d5bb1d3cf4d408647b63461526524bd8b4fcf19f0159"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cac0acb8008fdd5cc7c02a2aecba1e065640cc469ca777218723b6be233c737f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c5dbcc2a44c21a452501ffd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349414,"date":"2026-03-09T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to celebrate the 50th anniversary of MOSAIC, an extraordinary organization that has shaped the story of inclusion in Canada. For half a century, MOSAIC has stood beside newcomers, welcoming immigrants, supporting refugees and helping families build new lives with dignity and purpose.\n\nIn communities like Burnaby and across B.C., MOSAIC's work has turned challenges into opportunity through language training, employment support and settlement services. MOSAIC has empowered tens of thousands of people to find a place to call home. That is the Canada we believe in. Its mission reflects the very best of our country: compassion, diversity and the belief that when newcomers are supported, all of Canada benefits.\n\nCanada is not defined by where people come from, but by how we welcome one another. Fifty years ago, MOSAIC planted a seed of hope for newcomers. Today, that seed has grown into a thriving forest of opportunity. In celebrating MOSAIC, we are reminded that Canada's strength lies in every hand we hold, every life we lift and every story we welcome, because when we rise together, we all succeed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349414","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to celebrate the 50th anniversary of MOSAIC, an extraordinary organization that has shaped the story of inclusion in Canada. For half a century, MOSAIC has stood beside newcomers, welcoming immigrants, supporting refugees and helping families build new lives with dignity and purpose.\n\nIn communities like Burnaby and across B.C., MOSAIC's work has turned challenges into opportun","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["373e2e6f4e257bc48054d105ac70ab6fe4df92b57c033699261929ad81507f3f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7ca5085ea11571c636f65fff5d27a1734e5f4167e2afcf33edba597cc4380b23"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebec2992cab51fffb5baf7a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349409,"date":"2026-03-10T18:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today in support of the motion before the House because the issue at the centre of this debate is not procedural tactics. It is the safety and dignity of Canadians.\n\nBill C-9, the combatting hate act, was introduced by the Minister of Justice on September 19, 2025. It was then referred to the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights shortly thereafter. Since that time, Parliament has debated the bill, the committee has studied it, witnesses have testified, and amendments have been proposed. The legislation has been examined in detail. In total, Parliament has now spent more than 30 hours debating and studying Bill C-9. \n\nThis is serious scrutiny. This is how Parliament is supposed to work. However, scrutiny must eventually lead to a decision. This motion simply ensures that the House can complete its work and that Canadians will finally see Parliament vote on legislation designed to confront hate and intimidation in our communities. \n\nThe core purpose of Bill C-9 is straightforward: to strengthen Canada's response to hate-motivated intimidation and violence. It would do this in three practical ways. First, it would create offences that prevent individuals from blocking or intimidating people who are trying to enter places like synagogues, mosques, churches, schools and community centres. Second, it would create a stand-alone hate-motivated offence so that when crimes are committed because of hatred toward somebody's identity, the law would recognize the harm clearly. Third, it would address the public display of hate symbols used to promote hatred and intimidate communities. \n\nThese are not abstract problems. They are real experiences that communities across Canada have been facing. We have seen synagogues targeted, mosques threatened and cultural centres vandalized. We have seen people harassed simply for walking into places that represent their identity and community. \n\nWe have seen something else as well. We have seen hate directed at 2SLGBTQIA+ Canadians increase in recent years. As an openly gay member of Parliament, I know personally that hatred is not an abstract concept. It is not something that exists only in statistics or reports. It is something that people experience in their daily lives. It can appear in threats, as intimidation and sometimes in the form of people showing up outside places where communities gather to try to send a message that certain people do not belong. \n\nCanada is not that kind of country. Canada is a country where everyone should be able to live openly and safely. It should not matter whether somebody is Jewish, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Hindu or atheist. It should not matter whether somebody is Black, indigenous, Asian or from any other background. It should not matter whether somebody is straight, gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender or questioning. In Canada, every person deserves to live free from fear. This is what Bill C-9 is about. \n\nIt is also important to understand how this bill came to be. In December 2024, the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights released a report entitled \"Heightened Antisemitism in Canada and How to Confront It\". The report contained a number of recommendations aimed at strengthening Canada's response to hate. Many of those recommendations were reflected directly in Bill C-9. In other words, this legislation is not a surprise. It is the result of a government that listens and actions. It reflects recommendations that were supported by members across party lines. Despite that foundation, the bill has been repeatedly delayed. \n\nOpposition parties play a crucial role in our democracy. Their job is to question legislation, to challenge it and to improve it. In many cases, this is exactly what happens in committee. The job of the opposition is not to stall legislation forever. The job of Parliament is to debate, scrutinize and then decide. Unfortunately, what we have seen in committee over the past several months has not always reflected that principle. \n\nThe Conservatives have raised repeated points of order. They have challenged rulings of the chair. They have attempted to reopen settled motions. On one occasion, a Conservative member spoke for two hours about dogs and cats instead of allowing clause-by-clause consideration of the bill to begin. Canadians expect better than that. \n\n They expect Parliament to treat serious issues with seriousness, because while Parliament debates procedure, Canadians are facing real threats. Jewish Canadians have reported intimidation outside synagogues. Muslim Canadians have experienced harassment near mosques. Black Canadians have faced racism in public spaces. Asian Canadians have been targeted by hateful rhetoric. 2SLGBTQIA+ Canadians have seen protests and intimidation directed at community spaces. These are not isolated incidents. They are part of a troubling pattern. Communities across Canada have been clear about what they want Parliament to do. They want stronger protections and clear laws. They want Parliament to act. Bill C-9 is part of that response. \n\n Some of the debate around the bill has focused on the removal of the religious exemption provision in the Criminal Code. Let me be very clear about this. Freedom of religion in Canada is protected by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and that protection is not changing. Courts in Canada have consistently confirmed that hate propaganda offences require a very high legal threshold. Reading scripture does not meet that threshold. Teaching religious doctrine does not meet that threshold. Practising one's faith does not meet that threshold. In fact, the religious exemption provision itself has never been relied upon in a prosecution.\n\n Nevertheless, when concerns were raised by faith communities, the government listened. In response, a \"for greater certainty\" clause was introduced to confirm that peaceful religious expression, including sermons, teachings and discussions of scripture, is not captured by the legislation. This is how Parliament should work. Concerns were raised, clarifications were introduced, and collaboration took place. However, even after that effort, obstruction continued.\n\n The motion before us today is not about limiting debate. Debate has already happened, with more than 30 hours of debate and more than 30 witnesses heard at committee, for a bill that is only eight pages long. This is thorough scrutiny by any reasonable standard. The motion simply ensures that Parliament can complete the work and move forward to a vote. At some point, democracy requires decisions. Communities cannot wait forever while Parliament debates procedure.\n\n The question before us is very simple. Should Parliament be allowed to vote on legislation designed to protect Canadians from hate and intimidation? I believe the answer to the question should be yes. The Canada I believe in is a country where diversity is our strength and where people of every background can live openly and safely. It is a country where no one should feel afraid to walk into their schools, places of worship or community centres. It is a country where Parliament stands up clearly against hatred.\n\nThis bill is a meaningful step forward. It sends a message that intimidation, harassment and hate-motivated violence have no place in Canada. After months of debate and delay, it is time for Parliament to do its job. It is time to move forward. It is time to vote.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349409","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today in support of the motion before the House because the issue at the centre of this debate is not procedural tactics. It is the safety and dignity of Canadians.\n\nBill C-9, the combatting hate act, was introduced by the Minister of Justice on September 19, 2025. It was then referred to the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights shortly thereafter. Since that time, Pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d3099fc06db661e41ce0853f37f0067e3e3d2320d5656b972b44dff44b8532ed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f93ccad1ad4255e3bc368be63ed01cadf775135d9f930562bb90567f37ed58f6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf22e58dc518970a504eddd5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349410,"date":"2026-03-10T18:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, freedom of religion is fully protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and that protection remains unchanged.\n\nWhen concerns were raised by faith communities, the government listened and introduced a \"for greater certainty\" clause to make it clear that peaceful religious expression, such as sermons, teachings and readings of scripture, is not captured by the legislation. Canadians should be able to practise their faith freely, and this bill respects that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349410","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, freedom of religion is fully protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and that protection remains unchanged.\n\nWhen concerns were raised by faith communities, the government listened and introduced a \"for greater certainty\" clause to make it clear that peaceful religious expression, such as sermons, teachings and readings of scripture, is not captured by the legisla","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1e2689dd0bb99a64eaa3da6a55b3ebddc70ac63dd49c5b67f50f008c8d7f1cb5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["83d3bfbaecf6ad8b27ae3743ac1242927714ce1a55df5ec3b88d44f8299210f6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3191bd9014491536d1c55c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349411,"date":"2026-03-10T18:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, communities across Canada have been very clear that hate-motivated intimidation is increasing and they want stronger protections. This legislation, Bill C-9, responds to real experiences, from intimidation outside places of worship to harassment targeting cultural and community spaces. Bill C-9 would strengthen the law in practical ways so that when crimes are motivated by hatred towards somebody's identity, the law would recognize and address the harms clearly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349411","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, communities across Canada have been very clear that hate-motivated intimidation is increasing and they want stronger protections. This legislation, Bill C-9, responds to real experiences, from intimidation outside places of worship to harassment targeting cultural and community spaces. Bill C-9 would strengthen the law in practical ways so that when crimes are motivated by hatred towa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e616dd4e0bf9ecdead796fec00acb35dd645f1af2ede9b65b17a284afafe4fb9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fbed0c49d3f8035aa0fdae763295c4444c0538298c2310832e1b4e7c1494206f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7062168cc468e0be22cf9fd1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349412,"date":"2026-03-10T18:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this legislation has received extensive scrutiny. Parliament has debated it for more than 30 hours. The justice committee heard from more than 30 witnesses and considered amendments.\n\nDebate is important, but at some point, Parliament must also make decisions. Otherwise, meaningful legislation to improve the lives of Canadians would never be able to make an impact. Canadians expect us to examine legislation seriously and then vote on it. That is what this motion allows the House to do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349412","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this legislation has received extensive scrutiny. Parliament has debated it for more than 30 hours. The justice committee heard from more than 30 witnesses and considered amendments.\n\nDebate is important, but at some point, Parliament must also make decisions. Otherwise, meaningful legislation to improve the lives of Canadians would never be able to make an impact. Canadians expect us","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e07acc154b1af6ba13b3a089d52ca8c63b7d87bb18eed8a89f65b4a09709fd80"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3d6fd6f87dfe0c20c86e114","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349413,"date":"2026-03-10T18:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I mentioned, we have spent more than 30 hours on this bill, and there were more than 30 witnesses who testified before committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349413","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I mentioned, we have spent more than 30 hours on this bill, and there were more than 30 witnesses who testified before committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4405059ef28df8a7536ec63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390259,"date":"2026-03-23T19:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to celebrate the upcoming 95th birthday of Johnny Virani, a respected elder in Burnaby Central and the uncle of former minister of justice Arif Virani. Born in Uganda, his life is a testament to resilience, service and the lasting contribution of seniors to our communities. His legacy shows that our country is strengthened by the wisdom and dedication of those who came before us.\n\nI also want to recognize a group of high school students visiting from British Columbia. Their presence in Ottawa demonstrates that our democracy thrives when young people engage, question and participate. At a time when anti-Semitism, Islamophobia, homophobia, racism, discrimination and misogyny are rising in Canada, Canada will look to young people to raise their voice, lead with purpose and bring people together. It is in this partnership between generations, where the wisdom of our seniors meets the courage of our youth, that we find our strength. We will build the Canada of tomorrow, united, with every generation shaping and moving forward as one.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390259","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to celebrate the upcoming 95th birthday of Johnny Virani, a respected elder in Burnaby Central and the uncle of former minister of justice Arif Virani. Born in Uganda, his life is a testament to resilience, service and the lasting contribution of seniors to our communities. His legacy shows that our country is strengthened by the wisdom and dedication of those who came before u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c01c1aca3fc80dc153e81c889e581faace3725bdbf013f1bbcfc4fecafe782cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92cdffa4a8c80f4d0e4abbd4bd6ce289a28cf0a56eaee99f85b1cc5abeb6cfab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-afd2abc2cb613793f00e0c8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127526,"date":"2026-04-13T16:55:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Zaccour, we know that many victims are delaying leaving abusive relationships because shelters cannot accommodate their pets, which creates a real barrier to safety. From your perspective, are there any legal or policy measures that could accompany Bill C-16 , such as protection orders for pets or better coordination with shelters to ensure victims can leave safely?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127526","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Zaccour, we know that many victims are delaying leaving abusive relationships because shelters cannot accommodate their pets, which creates a real barrier to safety. From your perspective, are there any legal or policy measures that could accompany Bill C-16 , such as protection orders for pets or better coordination with shelters to ensure victims can leave safely?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036775","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property and casualty insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036775","label":"Property and casualty insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["456bbb1454f8aaf5e3a7ef9746ae86e3b91fb41aa640f8c221759d10c405936b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea933c025ef33070571786a9b24ba206aa3102e7ff667e84a465e14ce0d715a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b13554031a0f0383567f912","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127527,"date":"2026-04-13T16:55:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you. There has been discussion about defining \"femicide\" as the killing of women and girls, so based on gender or sex. To ensure legal clarity and that no victims are excluded, how should the law be applied in cases involving gender-diverse individuals, such as, for example, in a gay relationship where one of the partners identifies as a woman? Based on your experience, what approach can ensure the definition remains legally clear, inclusive and focused on the underlying dynamics of gender-based violence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127527","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. There has been discussion about defining \"femicide\" as the killing of women and girls, so based on gender or sex. To ensure legal clarity and that no victims are excluded, how should the law be applied in cases involving gender-diverse individuals, such as, for example, in a gay relationship where one of the partners identifies as a woman? Based on your experience, what approach can ens","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","label":"Gender-based violence","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1fa2d78a46eaf480db473ca719bae516a70c467194b5166494f84cfcf64a12b6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6133b5ca6a5854fa33711381","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127528,"date":"2026-04-13T17:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127528","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-819f8a025bc333503dd9279d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127529,"date":"2026-04-13T17:30:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My first question is for Dr. Giesbrecht. How transformative is the recognition of coercive control for frontline service providers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127529","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My first question is for Dr. Giesbrecht. How transformative is the recognition of coercive control for frontline service providers?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d8532f99ade7a91a567adb84b227f7f53e09b6092434e0c7926c0e4fa45a580"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-123da5f5540ad0c6a5974dd7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127530,"date":"2026-04-13T17:30:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you. Why is the two-year implementation period important for training and system readiness?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127530","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Why is the two-year implementation period important for training and system readiness?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9902539170a81016daa027a563ab630022dfba707e3dac921ffa17a9772b45f4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a238a4e985e3d4274c52471","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127531,"date":"2026-04-13T17:35:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you. What specific training should police and prosecutors receive to apply this law effectively?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127531","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. What specific training should police and prosecutors receive to apply this law effectively?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf14e2586446aaa91baf2a2fdc1d07952869f0e8203a1f245eb0ed90dc3e0ea5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-19ea35516dd0692928af1c81","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127532,"date":"2026-04-13T17:35:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you. Do you believe that making femicide first-degree murder sends a strong enough deterrent message?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127532","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Do you believe that making femicide first-degree murder sends a strong enough deterrent message?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1013163","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Biological warfare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036682","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Poisoning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036682","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Poisoning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1013163","label":"Biological warfare","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036682","label":"Poisoning","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e4f725f43920d685627c021dbe6000ea730b79157b95fbcb0c5b295bbec000bd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["16a600d10e90a25d7a64588f08d8741f1b659cb46acdc41928b7dfb54b53a960"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-708a08f4c3c1032a3eeaa11a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127533,"date":"2026-04-13T17:35:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"How will this bill change the way victims are identified and supported?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127533","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How will this bill change the way victims are identified and supported?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","label":"Disaster relief","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9e4dbce733e5a1a3a0431a5c96b47cba2a673488b5262559ef68e34a69524b7a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5dd811dd9e834afb64f04d5a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127534,"date":"2026-04-13T17:35:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"My final question to you is this: What gaps still exist in protecting women in rural and underserved communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-23/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127534","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My final question to you is this: What gaps still exist in protecting women in rural and underserved communities?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eca2a720777d05b8e1e0dfa75d6b6ef4670ca4ce2c6b915b6f7ca77abb4c55ae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84d56a33efff8253eddf7d68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127535,"date":"2026-04-22T21:55:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the witnesses for being here today. My first question is for the CBA. The CBA often emphasizes the importance of balancing strong protections with charter compliance. How do you assess Bill C-16 in striking that balance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127535","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the witnesses for being here today. My first question is for the CBA. The CBA often emphasizes the importance of balancing strong protections with charter compliance. How do you assess Bill C-16 in striking that balance?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5be9fc1081976e37efe49c9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127536,"date":"2026-04-22T21:55:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Could you please speak to how sentencing-related reforms in the bill, including any mandatory elements, interact with the principle of proportionality and judicial discretion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127536","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Could you please speak to how sentencing-related reforms in the bill, including any mandatory elements, interact with the principle of proportionality and judicial discretion?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28d267c5a8e728ccf34112178e29b6acd02a55d81de97c6a36acf58beb12af6e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d86451744512003e0e304dac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127537,"date":"2026-04-22T22:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Ms. Webb. My next question is for Chief Truong. From your perspective, how are you seeing online harm such as exploitation and sexploitation impacting your own community?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127537","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Ms. Webb. My next question is for Chief Truong. From your perspective, how are you seeing online harm such as exploitation and sexploitation impacting your own community?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b65a5e07ade3ea652edee995b0549343ccea8ea0acf22774b2c35fa76736ff63"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27fe15f7d64637d7266a24f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127538,"date":"2026-04-22T22:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Police services across Canada have raised concerns about youth being recruited into criminal activity online. Could you speak on how this is evolving and whether the measures in Bill C-16 help address this trend?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127538","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Police services across Canada have raised concerns about youth being recruited into criminal activity online. Could you speak on how this is evolving and whether the measures in Bill C-16 help address this trend?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55fca0a312e367d87a29ab17a4d9e447e3946813b0741e928d8897c2230f8ffd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de7d1cfe3c1f1487b794be75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127539,"date":"2026-04-22T22:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"If you could prioritize one change, legislative or operational, to improve victim outcomes, what would that be?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127539","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If you could prioritize one change, legislative or operational, to improve victim outcomes, what would that be?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","label":"Accident prevention","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["174afe6082468e3bed8d33e32a05d2fb96b36b33694c19b96ff4c1f391b38db4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de8d379c16e81e2bea863943","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127540,"date":"2026-04-22T23:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Zille, from your perspective, how important are the protections in Bill C-16 for improving outcomes for young victims?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127540","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Zille, from your perspective, how important are the protections in Bill C-16 for improving outcomes for young victims?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6192b486a79327cd15ac1ea49953b19b4a3a75b09c891970bb2b1aae8c32290b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-16ccc87796236d977056a079","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127541,"date":"2026-04-22T23:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Could you please speak to the importance of trauma-informed approaches when prosecuting offences involving children?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127541","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Could you please speak to the importance of trauma-informed approaches when prosecuting offences involving children?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["651ae281f5203bd646e79ddafb1a2968abdc973183425c8e01f3b1e91bc74883"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1a727f8efc63983bb7515b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127542,"date":"2026-04-22T23:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"How do measures like evidence preservation and strengthened tools for online harm support the work being done by an organization like yours?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127542","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How do measures like evidence preservation and strengthened tools for online harm support the work being done by an organization like yours?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","label":"Workplace violence","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a7875d001fc6088e2d08eceafe75806fe608e8328cf4d55d8977be82a3ba5d9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9208ac3becb7eff7acfddb0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127543,"date":"2026-04-22T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Okay. Are there any additional supports or resources needed to ensure these legislative changes are effective in practice?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127543","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Are there any additional supports or resources needed to ensure these legislative changes are effective in practice?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e3a79458a38b3cae8bb4185cca217822ce3f6a1cdc2a8aee9a292c6e16e0b0d7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8de1b19d6f478f74756879b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127544,"date":"2026-04-22T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much. My next question is for Ms. Hajek. Elder abuse is often non-physical. Does the current legal framework adequately capture coercive and controlling behaviour?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127544","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. My next question is for Ms. Hajek. Elder abuse is often non-physical. Does the current legal framework adequately capture coercive and controlling behaviour?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3fd38d60e12f8b7d905baa426c507c4bb43bdeffefefba26dc54ff2066a3d6d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-040a5327b91c410449b85095","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127545,"date":"2026-04-22T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Would Bill C-16 improve protections for seniors, or do significant gaps still remain?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127545","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Would Bill C-16 improve protections for seniors, or do significant gaps still remain?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff65e0ce9763e11c13cbed00ee1c899fa39a2466751f3ee5eec2d5c527a95ef7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-983f69eaf5a14930962e81bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127546,"date":"2026-04-22T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"In your experience, what are the biggest barriers preventing seniors from reporting abuse?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127546","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In your experience, what are the biggest barriers preventing seniors from reporting abuse?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","label":"Elder abuse","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bfbf1170deee6fdffdd5c827c38217498321c31a48fb2e0f6cf7ca8ac84ba355"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-634571350c6f96288a6dc6bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127547,"date":"2026-04-22T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"I will now go to Dr. Parker again. Your research highlights early warning signs. At what point should intervention occur to prevent an escalation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127547","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I will now go to Dr. Parker again. Your research highlights early warning signs. At what point should intervention occur to prevent an escalation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["630adc2557e15def42831d13606a006d9824c956aca9ec6c65622051834a61ef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d9656cfed70fc50da588f1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127548,"date":"2026-04-22T23:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"JUST","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-26/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127548","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35f69e7f63da39b92a2e6e01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728578,"date":"2026-04-29T19:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, earlier this month, I had the honour of taking the floor at the Assembly of the Inter-Parliamentary Union in Istanbul. As an Asian, an immigrant and a proud gay member of the House, I stand here as proof that representation is about challenging barriers and changing systems.\n\nLet me be very clear: The most powerful force in system change is mindset. Policy reflects mindset, funding follows mindset and programs are built on mindset. If we do not change how we think, we will reproduce inequality more efficiently. If we want different outcomes, we must redesign the system with intention. That means new voices, inclusive leadership and courage over comfort. When we change who decides, we change whom the system serves, and that changes everything.\n\nI urge all members of the House to address barriers facing youth, women, persons with disabilities, immigrants, people experiencing homelessness, and 2SLGBTQIA+ individuals, and to act with urgency to remove those barriers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728578","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, earlier this month, I had the honour of taking the floor at the Assembly of the Inter-Parliamentary Union in Istanbul. As an Asian, an immigrant and a proud gay member of the House, I stand here as proof that representation is about challenging barriers and changing systems.\n\nLet me be very clear: The most powerful force in system change is mindset. Policy reflects mindset, funding fo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","label":"Inequality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","label":"Inequality","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["efa352e0982abf1da53268ff33697b06719544a331ce3303d32dc1b8aaa79587"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["758c1a0ee7b5c1fe762840f04b8bcb61fa310049d219f3fa8712b5dc94aaf2d6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3730092352b634467b15dd4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127521,"date":"2026-05-04T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you both for being with us this afternoon. Mr. Lee, as the national housing strategy continues to evolve, what do you see as its most important success to date, and where do you see the best opportunities to build on the progress going forward?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127521","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you both for being with us this afternoon. Mr. Lee, as the national housing strategy continues to evolve, what do you see as its most important success to date, and where do you see the best opportunities to build on the progress going forward?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6ed709ea5cb52c1dc4cc1103ddf327943720f3b1405af4752779a5453ecf8ab1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ee850b15ead1fc02c4cd3c2bd0fba99e7fa868e3beb50b96a91d4a8b9d1937a2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40b91f5fff557b9d5bd61efc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127522,"date":"2026-05-04T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you. From your perspective, have the federal programs encouraged innovation and construction methods or faster project times in any meaningful way?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127522","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. From your perspective, have the federal programs encouraged innovation and construction methods or faster project times in any meaningful way?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00214ac12a58ad652588bc9b9634afc05d24ada5aaac357f8236d6cc235e6938"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b97e86b0a022075703118316","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127523,"date":"2026-05-04T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you. My riding of Burnaby Central is one of the most expensive places to rent in Canada today. In markets like Burnaby Central, how critical has the federal support been in enabling projects that might not otherwise proceed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127523","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. My riding of Burnaby Central is one of the most expensive places to rent in Canada today. In markets like Burnaby Central, how critical has the federal support been in enabling projects that might not otherwise proceed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3050b39428427267efc3e8a5a33f66ddaf0bb219bb69e7ca426bcb8707e00581"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c2017e5903df8606ca0b3de9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127524,"date":"2026-05-04T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you. Here is my final question for you. Has the federal government support helped improve builders' confidence or long-term planning when it comes to launching new housing projects?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127524","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Here is my final question for you. Has the federal government support helped improve builders' confidence or long-term planning when it comes to launching new housing projects?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8fdd184e35565814d31f6e11c62f613b664d0a43f87436858954366f68665ee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c24b5a92ec2b19a2cf6f04d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127525,"date":"2026-05-04T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thanks.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127525","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thanks.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-034990aa7e72a6e042e7a0b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127479,"date":"2026-05-07T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Commissioner, for being here with us. I noticed that indigenous contracting results were 9.7% in 2023-24 and 3.4% in 2024-25, with a forecast of 9.2% for 2025-26 and a target of 5% for 2026-27. Can you tell us more about these figures and what is driving the changes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127479","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Commissioner, for being here with us. I noticed that indigenous contracting results were 9.7% in 2023-24 and 3.4% in 2024-25, with a forecast of 9.2% for 2025-26 and a target of 5% for 2026-27. Can you tell us more about these figures and what is driving the changes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ebc121def42f764fcf595d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127480,"date":"2026-05-07T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you very much for your effort. Under government-wide priorities, can you speak to the programs that your office is undertaking in relation to the United Nations 2030 agenda for sustainable development?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127480","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much for your effort. Under government-wide priorities, can you speak to the programs that your office is undertaking in relation to the United Nations 2030 agenda for sustainable development?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2bd3a69fa47b403216c56e406a526a917d92da9e1c49a488ca715602aa7586fb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ceb4b90938b1b23ee54c5bfd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127481,"date":"2026-05-07T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you. Your departmental plan places significant emphasis on education and outreach. How important is proactive education in improving compliance with the Lobbying Act, particularly for smaller organizations, non-profits or individuals who might not fully understand the obligations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127481","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Your departmental plan places significant emphasis on education and outreach. How important is proactive education in improving compliance with the Lobbying Act, particularly for smaller organizations, non-profits or individuals who might not fully understand the obligations?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6c435ad125f7bd7973140c60bef1a1dbc8566794e6245841bb485df7a6f7ccea"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb5d7b582481838aafb5fbb6297063ccab455985b782261bb29a277d06476a73"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1637b360edca2115ae3e51c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127482,"date":"2026-05-07T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you. One of the themes in your recommendations is improving the timeliness and consistency of registration and disclosures. From your perspective, how can we modernize reporting requirements in a way that improves transparency without creating unnecessary administrative burden, especially for smaller stakeholders?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127482","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. One of the themes in your recommendations is improving the timeliness and consistency of registration and disclosures. From your perspective, how can we modernize reporting requirements in a way that improves transparency without creating unnecessary administrative burden, especially for smaller stakeholders?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef8a886b54e0a62da8e4dd98933951abb1450d58a5eda94bf40ac5c424e2217a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3ca56c4f88213aa10818f31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127483,"date":"2026-05-07T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Is that why education is way more important?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127483","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is that why education is way more important?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6bcf45a9ccb332e8e9cb153d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127484,"date":"2026-05-07T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you. My final question is this. Recommendation six proposes broader disclosure requirements regarding employees who lobby on behalf of organizations. Can you elaborate more on how that recommendation would improve transparency for Canadians while still remaining practical for businesses and organizations to implement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127484","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. My final question is this. Recommendation six proposes broader disclosure requirements regarding employees who lobby on behalf of organizations. Can you elaborate more on how that recommendation would improve transparency for Canadians while still remaining practical for businesses and organizations to implement?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["095532979b28f88225d5063e5dc194534b60656fbeb06edb04cb5cc359700acc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec1dc23e2eabbfa39f6e5c07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127485,"date":"2026-05-07T21:45:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Commissioner, thank you for being here with us. I have two questions on the main estimates. Your departmental plan highlights ongoing work related to artificial intelligence, including the creation of internal AI tools. Can you please elaborate on how AI is currently being used in your office and what operational benefits will be achieved by AI? Also, how will you ensure that its use will remain aligned with privacy and ethical standards?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127485","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Commissioner, thank you for being here with us. I have two questions on the main estimates. Your departmental plan highlights ongoing work related to artificial intelligence, including the creation of internal AI tools. Can you please elaborate on how AI is currently being used in your office and what operational benefits will be achieved by AI? Also, how will you ensure th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-94fed239e065d687ee2b634c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127486,"date":"2026-05-07T21:45:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you. It's good to hear this. I see that for 2024-25, your actual resource for indigenous contracts was 10.7%, while your planned target for 2026-27 is 5%. Could you explain the factors behind the figures and how your office approaches indigenous procurement as part of the commitment to economic reconciliation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127486","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. It's good to hear this. I see that for 2024-25, your actual resource for indigenous contracts was 10.7%, while your planned target for 2026-27 is 5%. Could you explain the factors behind the figures and how your office approaches indigenous procurement as part of the commitment to economic reconciliation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e050296668f9c960f1da36b517f5cc1b12e4452dbeb720457ade280c79785551"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-429da084360799735ff3288e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127487,"date":"2026-05-07T21:45:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Commissioner. I want to clarify the apparent contradiction between your findings and those of B.C.'s privacy regulator. Your office says that the matter involving OpenAI has been resolved, while B.C. says it has not. In practical terms, is OpenAI currently operating in violation of B.C.'s privacy laws? If so, what enforcement mechanisms or consequences are available for regulators? What are the implications for British Columbians who are using ChatGPT today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127487","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Commissioner. I want to clarify the apparent contradiction between your findings and those of B.C.'s privacy regulator. Your office says that the matter involving OpenAI has been resolved, while B.C. says it has not. In practical terms, is OpenAI currently operating in violation of B.C.'s privacy laws? If so, what enforcement mechanisms or consequences are available for regulators? What","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["92b62b6cb8f3b0f6db9583e073bfc622065b4bb5ebea78746cc92279939679f3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5250a3f1d960d093fa048703eacbc417d924147f201acedbf29f5ce7066e88d1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1084c3a1e4c6da4334aaf446","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127488,"date":"2026-05-07T21:45:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you. Commissioner, the review of the Privacy Act comes at a time when Canadians expect both strong privacy protections and modern, efficient public services. In your view, how can Parliament strike a balance between protecting personal information and enabling better service delivery across government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127488","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Commissioner, the review of the Privacy Act comes at a time when Canadians expect both strong privacy protections and modern, efficient public services. In your view, how can Parliament strike a balance between protecting personal information and enabling better service delivery across government?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2519987b406d3859c477fee7bafcb4abf1103bbf279fa464d89292f7cb1b25bc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82de777e554d7cd3567d0f3d68f95617eba4e731995fae1f501c527a9b3dc82a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31ef72b4d74bb85e3222f89b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127489,"date":"2026-05-07T21:50:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Can you speak to the importance of amending the Privacy Act to recognize that privacy is a fundamental right in Canada, underscoring the importance of enabling service delivery and advancing reconciliation with indigenous people?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127489","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Can you speak to the importance of amending the Privacy Act to recognize that privacy is a fundamental right in Canada, underscoring the importance of enabling service delivery and advancing reconciliation with indigenous people?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11238ca9725bcd85584412eb32a869c317491b35d14ed3eff585603658870d0c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c1319b14070c7d766c747d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127490,"date":"2026-05-07T21:50:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Commissioner.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127490","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Commissioner.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab76981302f7c3db07b100ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127454,"date":"2026-05-25T17:30:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. My first set of questions will be for Ms. Roulet. Thank you for being here today. Your organization works on the ground, directly, with asylum seekers and newcomers every day. Could you share how rapid increases in asylum claims in recent years have affected your organization's capacity for staffing and housing support and your ability to provide quality settlement services?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127454","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. My first set of questions will be for Ms. Roulet. Thank you for being here today. Your organization works on the ground, directly, with asylum seekers and newcomers every day. Could you share how rapid increases in asylum claims in recent years have affected your organization's capacity for staffing and housing support and your ability to provide quality settlement services","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39c892b5626aaae607882184","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127455,"date":"2026-05-25T17:35:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Ms. Roulet, the federal government has emphasized restoring balance and sustainability to the immigration system, and Quebec has recently seen a significant decline in asylum claims. From the perspective of a service provider, how important are predictable and manageable intake levels in helping newcomers receive the support they need to settle successfully?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127455","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Ms. Roulet, the federal government has emphasized restoring balance and sustainability to the immigration system, and Quebec has recently seen a significant decline in asylum claims. From the perspective of a service provider, how important are predictable and manageable intake levels in helping newcomers receive the support they need to settle successfully?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d57d7dc3d18ac103c8cff79adc2bfa9a91d66b64ca32e0962d20d83b4c37f075"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f5959a10d9f311246f11edb4d1e491e0e109452291edd79f28496338b610ed7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9d4f0cb12926339a09b2ae3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127456,"date":"2026-05-27T21:50:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. My first round of questions is for Professor Clark-Kazak. Thank you for joining us today. Professor, your research highlights the importance of coordination among governments, service providers and researchers in refugee policy. What progress have you seen in recent years, and how can the federal government further strengthen collaboration to support a more stable and sustainable asylum system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127456","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. My first round of questions is for Professor Clark-Kazak. Thank you for joining us today. Professor, your research highlights the importance of coordination among governments, service providers and researchers in refugee policy. What progress have you seen in recent years, and how can the federal government further strengthen collaboration to support a more stable and susta","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["08ca6123b7b1759a1531095e4d8a7fcadae39323f488b2443dcb280c904bbd50"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1ae60de6a7649aa2b62f6ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127457,"date":"2026-05-27T21:50:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Given the scale of global displacement and ongoing humanitarian crises, how important is it for Canada to maintain an orderly and rules-based asylum system that balances compassion, operational sustainability and public confidence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127457","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Given the scale of global displacement and ongoing humanitarian crises, how important is it for Canada to maintain an orderly and rules-based asylum system that balances compassion, operational sustainability and public confidence?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3158387db18464e181232747d505a06265fe086aff970592f0765db45aedf629"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb09d07792fd9b257f4ef279","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127458,"date":"2026-05-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Thank you, Professor. Canada has continued to welcome refugees while maintaining one of the strongest immigration systems in the world. In your view, why is it important to recognize both the challenges and the success of the current system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127458","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Professor. Canada has continued to welcome refugees while maintaining one of the strongest immigration systems in the world. In your view, why is it important to recognize both the challenges and the success of the current system?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d9fd59815e6c2a198bbf7b641f37b074a3de98099ccccb8e5d8dbd3c562f9c1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-891f009626b82142f7eeed3e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127459,"date":"2026-05-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Some people have described our asylum system as being in chaos. From your research and experience, is it more accurate to describe the issue as one of capacity pressure that requires better coordination and long-term planning?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127459","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Some people have described our asylum system as being in chaos. From your research and experience, is it more accurate to describe the issue as one of capacity pressure that requires better coordination and long-term planning?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d142a886cac7dbd338af960cf448eb2f155bf48000f7eb2b932e102aeed95bb7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60cc8abc3baf5ec429cb9c02","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127460,"date":"2026-05-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Thank you so much. I will now turn to Ms. Brennan. Ms. Brennan, through your work at Matthew House, what contributions have you seen refugees and asylum seekers make to Canada once they are given the opportunity to settle successfully?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127460","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you so much. I will now turn to Ms. Brennan. Ms. Brennan, through your work at Matthew House, what contributions have you seen refugees and asylum seekers make to Canada once they are given the opportunity to settle successfully?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e5567fbb0bc8a01291aa5aedc3d0deda3c2a46f5dcb7f1d70d8f3049b789f184"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25e3cfbede955e3f0ed96a9d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127461,"date":"2026-05-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"From your organization's experience, what federal policies or operational practices are most important for helping refugees settle quickly and successfully into Canadian society?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127461","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"From your organization's experience, what federal policies or operational practices are most important for helping refugees settle quickly and successfully into Canadian society?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c76cd8c20dbc2d0ddc3c562fb4a102e869ab6422b593ea56487ba5a7cb995175"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8e3b84c93ee773ef3330e8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127462,"date":"2026-05-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127462","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc8214e3680f70805f89743e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036321,"date":"2026-05-29T01:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I will be sharing my time.\n\nI am pleased to rise today to discuss how IRCC's main estimates will drive our economy. The budget, the spring economic update and now the main estimates are guiding our country forward during a very challenging period. The rupture in global order brings us to a moment when we need to build our strengths at home, diversify our markets abroad, and build or renew international partnerships with like-minded countries. Immigration is an important part of that plan.\n\nWhen it is thoughtfully managed, immigration strengthens our country, fills labour gaps, grows businesses and supports critical sectors like health care, construction and emerging technology. However, the immigration system needs to work smoothly. It needs to be aligned with both the needs of our employers and the capacities of our communities. It needs to provide fair opportunities for those who come to Canada and leave everything behind.\n\nThe government has been working hard to improve the immigration system by restoring control, strengthening program integrity and returning immigration targets to sustainable levels. In the 2026-28 immigration levels plan, we set a clear commitment to make immigration levels sustainable. The plan stabilizes targets for permanent residents and reduces arrival targets for new temporary residents. We remain focused on attracting the best talent in the world to build our economy and address the labour shortage, while making sure that communities are growing responsibly. As a result, Canadians are seeing a system that is balanced and reliable.\n\nOur immigration plan prioritizes workers. In 2026, nearly two out of three PRs will fill essential positions across the country. We are inviting newcomers to fill jobs where there are skill gaps. We are attracting global talent to meet our country's unique emerging needs. We are prioritizing industries like artificial intelligence, clean energy, advanced manufacturing, health care and construction.\n\nCanada's international talent attraction strategy is a whole-of-government effort to bring in skilled newcomers our industries and communities need: the best and the brightest. As we begin to attract this talent, we must have a system in place that encourages them to stay and to settle long-term. This is why we are prioritizing skilled temporary workers who are already here for permanent residence.\n\nWe recently announced more details about the one-time in-Canada workers initiative, which will accelerate the processing and approval of 33,000 temporary workers for permanent residence. They are already here, paying taxes and taking part in our communities. They deserve to feel like Canada is their home. Many of those workers are in smaller and rural communities that are facing persistent labour shortages, where local employers depend on them to stay in business. \n\nThe main estimates will support a more efficient system for attracting and retaining newcomers. In 2026, our government announced new measures to make it easier for physicians working in Canada to apply for permanent residence. We are also making it easier for graduate and postdoctoral students to bring their expertise to Canada. The department's digital modernization effort will allow newcomers to understand their applications better and have access to support when needed. New digital tools will help train officers proactively to identify issues and verify information. These tools will also help them process applications faster.\n\nWe need an immigration system that delivers results for newcomers and for all Canadians, and sometimes that means different results for different parts of our country. The system must be able to reflect what makes each of our regions unique and recognize that Burnaby's Metrotown and the east coast fisheries represent very different labour markets. We are partnering with provinces and territories and responding to their economic priorities through programs that respect regional diversity. This includes the provincial nominee program, the Atlantic immigration program, and pilot programs that support rural and francophone communities.\n\nIn a time of global disruption, Canada continues to be a beacon of opportunity, where skilled people from different parts of the world can find their place in welcoming communities, find work in emerging fields and watch their families thrive. We are pulling together strategies and resources to attract the best and the brightest, grow our economy and support our communities. Our government is ensuring that immigration continues to serve Canadians, now and for future generations.\n\nMany people who came to Canada through the Hong Kong pathway are highly skilled, very well educated, hard-working and already contributing significantly to our economy. Many pay taxes, work in essential sectors and are building their lives here in Canada. At the same time, many families still face uncertainty because they do not yet have permanent status.\n\nCan the minister provide an update on the effort to improve processing times and reduce delays for those families as they continue to contribute to Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036321","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I will be sharing my time.\n\nI am pleased to rise today to discuss how IRCC's main estimates will drive our economy. The budget, the spring economic update and now the main estimates are guiding our country forward during a very challenging period. The rupture in global order brings us to a moment when we need to build our strengths at home, diversify our markets abroad, and build or ren","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9a1370b0708651ac632451eb4c086bd9929680921edf27df875aa28f8fe1c8a4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["573066f4ff9354c510aef2d293f1c74550fcdb77416d12c98d9d21a8480c4b3b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6daaa8dd2f45bc6a0fc69dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127463,"date":"2026-06-01T17:20:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the officials for being here today. There have been growing concerns about individuals with criminal records or those charged with serious offences in Canada using the asylum system to delay a removal or avoid consequences. Can the officials explain what happens when an individual facing criminal charges applies for the asylum system, and what safeguards are in place to protect the integrity of the system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127463","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the officials for being here today. There have been growing concerns about individuals with criminal records or those charged with serious offences in Canada using the asylum system to delay a removal or avoid consequences. Can the officials explain what happens when an individual facing criminal charges applies for the asylum system, and what safeguards are in p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e90e78e3bb1ef6afb72adc7f5eb9df85c243290e17ea6d5c93e3f537e4c0a6e4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69d8ace1ad1441d328faa8f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127464,"date":"2026-06-01T17:20:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"There has been some confusion regarding IRCC's use of hotels for temporary asylum accommodations. Can the department clarify whether IRCC is still directly funding hotel stays for asylum seekers and what the current report is for emergency housing support?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127464","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There has been some confusion regarding IRCC's use of hotels for temporary asylum accommodations. Can the department clarify whether IRCC is still directly funding hotel stays for asylum seekers and what the current report is for emergency housing support?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab6078128f568d3f2e142e5d9bb55a698f485588e6184cf1da4ee2595a5d94c3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7853caa5b5c8413a59ca0cbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127465,"date":"2026-06-01T17:20:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Has the department examined policies or incentives to encourage a more balanced distribution of asylum claimants across Canada, particularly to support settlements in regions facing labour shortages and housing pressures outside the largest urban centres, like Toronto and Vancouver?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127465","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Has the department examined policies or incentives to encourage a more balanced distribution of asylum claimants across Canada, particularly to support settlements in regions facing labour shortages and housing pressures outside the largest urban centres, like Toronto and Vancouver?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","label":"Incentives","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["49708c4fa7595cd52719e24767092beabfc674dd40a1603f7fee4833bef3890f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9f27affd43ae8c43bf5c730","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127466,"date":"2026-06-01T17:20:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Many Canadians support a compassionate asylum system, but they also expect a system that is orderly and sustainable. What specific steps is the department taking to restore public confidence in the management of the system or of asylum claims?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127466","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Many Canadians support a compassionate asylum system, but they also expect a system that is orderly and sustainable. What specific steps is the department taking to restore public confidence in the management of the system or of asylum claims?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["156faaed6093da78f146153256861b62daf4800545b55a9770d1ef8794397c8b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ed41b3ce2b1960ef1e8f52d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127467,"date":"2026-06-01T17:20:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"How closely is IRCC coordinating with provinces, municipalities and service providers before relocating asylum claimants to ensure that communities have the capacity to support them properly?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127467","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How closely is IRCC coordinating with provinces, municipalities and service providers before relocating asylum claimants to ensure that communities have the capacity to support them properly?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8fdb887d8ce5dfc2d4a1468c4f1921bbbfc4834b16d5265814797ce0ababcb00"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a679b3afd9827573cdadb3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127468,"date":"2026-06-01T17:25:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Some communities have stepped up to welcome newcomers while others are already struggling with housing shortages and strained public services. How is IRCC ensuring that the asylum system remains fair both to the claimants and to the receiving communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127468","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Some communities have stepped up to welcome newcomers while others are already struggling with housing shortages and strained public services. How is IRCC ensuring that the asylum system remains fair both to the claimants and to the receiving communities?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b952bf240e8c02e961e9bd192cbdc65f4238d788951621a232a02ed9c58a3302"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6eec8215681d167fb659daf7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127469,"date":"2026-06-01T17:25:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127469","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c03cccb490cae96790a5ba99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127491,"date":"2026-06-01T21:35:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Santini, do the current lobbying rules place a disproportionate burden on small businesses and business associations as compared with large organizations with dedicated government relations teams?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127491","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Santini, do the current lobbying rules place a disproportionate burden on small businesses and business associations as compared with large organizations with dedicated government relations teams?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ae7d96fa2576882aa9417116e0bc40d9867788f8f4cf4c73456562522d99469e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["86844a20271f3a264c17ec4ffdc4fe26540b50f7b6af54f94e0c7e763bc077bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02795fb4c0a1d0ae9d5bde62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127492,"date":"2026-06-01T21:40:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Of course.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127492","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Of course.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccefcc9fd1a18f6a5ece5820","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127493,"date":"2026-06-01T21:40:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Yes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127493","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b09359c38a86f98e5f735c44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127494,"date":"2026-06-01T21:40:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Mr. Shore. You stated the following in your brief: Granting the Commissioner of Lobbying independent regulation-making authority would constitute a significant institutional overreach, blurring the line between enforcement and law-making in a manner that is seriously inconsistent with foundational principles of Canadian administrative law. As a member of Parliament, I found that a bit concerning. I want to give you an opportunity to expand on this statement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127494","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Shore. You stated the following in your brief: Granting the Commissioner of Lobbying independent regulation-making authority would constitute a significant institutional overreach, blurring the line between enforcement and law-making in a manner that is seriously inconsistent with foundational principles of Canadian administrative law. As a member of Parliament, I found that a bit c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-017be410e29aed28e594fd46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127495,"date":"2026-06-01T21:40:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"If you run out of time, I would appreciate a written response, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127495","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If you run out of time, I would appreciate a written response, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b290cb8830319de9ccda7aa6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127470,"date":"2026-06-03T21:45:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Let's come back to the study on global talent. My questions are for Mr. Perry and Mr. Carbonneau. What are the biggest barriers related to credential recognition, work authorization and talent mobility, and how can the federal government address them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127470","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Let's come back to the study on global talent. My questions are for Mr. Perry and Mr. Carbonneau. What are the biggest barriers related to credential recognition, work authorization and talent mobility, and how can the federal government address them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a0f6f0f428636a7b01a79e64df5bcc88d399a57409f3a4768c43f2bcb3cbaf9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["003235bdf5bfb6a2e3249be718825fe6314e9f513276742fd6927abea30a2e9f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c19268225e67157cde7a51a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127471,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"My riding of Burnaby Central is home to BCIT and a thriving clean technology ecosystem. How can federal immigration policy better support emerging sectors like AI, clean technology and advanced manufacturing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127471","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"My riding of Burnaby Central is home to BCIT and a thriving clean technology ecosystem. How can federal immigration policy better support emerging sectors like AI, clean technology and advanced manufacturing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034494","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Clean technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034494","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Clean technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034494","label":"Clean technology","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d61b0fde3c5d69f82c41fa526ea18712e56481da29a0bbfe396e116540a9ab9e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b574ba74c376aac69a2ddd5c1243df26eff7329cf7f4c2b51bdbac31f1a93735"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-286aacad1117bdbc4236d846","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127472,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"To what extent does Canada's commitment to diversity and to 2SLGBTQIA+ inclusion influence the decisions of highly skilled workers when they choose where to live, work or innovate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127472","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"To what extent does Canada's commitment to diversity and to 2SLGBTQIA+ inclusion influence the decisions of highly skilled workers when they choose where to live, work or innovate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d96b3c153f2509562cbc854f657f4009892bae140597e0dc1580e6681a70874f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-acd2617425cd62eef7da28b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127473,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Canada competes globally for highly skilled talent. Where are we succeeding and where are we falling behind?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127473","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Canada competes globally for highly skilled talent. Where are we succeeding and where are we falling behind?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db10cc8984958a69127b4339cdf9de1084b35789d04542349b0e74e28a0c5a64"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8682e9e8be191db81ae94fd6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127496,"date":"2026-06-04T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, officials, for being here. How does Canada's lobbying regime compare to those of other leading democracies in terms of transparency, oversight and administrative requirements?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127496","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, officials, for being here. How does Canada's lobbying regime compare to those of other leading democracies in terms of transparency, oversight and administrative requirements?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["925dadc70d9e9c9591e0d3273136619c5bc5c231b6b5125041875ccaafe77dd4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20d7efada0bb80039a4f2796","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127497,"date":"2026-06-04T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"We have heard concerns that some recent proposals or interpretations might not have involved extensive consultation with stakeholders. To your knowledge, what stakeholder engagement informed the commissioner's recommendations, and what role, if any, did the Treasury Board play in these discussions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127497","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We have heard concerns that some recent proposals or interpretations might not have involved extensive consultation with stakeholders. To your knowledge, what stakeholder engagement informed the commissioner's recommendations, and what role, if any, did the Treasury Board play in these discussions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e7f07e83dd417c279c8d65a1fc17f7d7e812f76c463ce5f1a3e05c41e2325d26"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c29cd169a4c6060e7c9a7c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127498,"date":"2026-06-04T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"How important are predictability and regulatory certainty for organizations that must comply with this act? How should they factor in any reforms recommended by this committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127498","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How important are predictability and regulatory certainty for organizations that must comply with this act? How should they factor in any reforms recommended by this committee?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["584996f8ab6d6781b159fd2bbaa3fa3d081fb731d4ed96fac5e709b6ba80c026"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ffd35ef67f41b10e2b8bf36d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127499,"date":"2026-06-04T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"The Lobbying Act seeks to promote transparency, not discourage engagement with government. How can Parliament ensure that reforms do not unintentionally create barriers to participation in public policy discussions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127499","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The Lobbying Act seeks to promote transparency, not discourage engagement with government. How can Parliament ensure that reforms do not unintentionally create barriers to participation in public policy discussions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cde2f94980f7d131852c7bc737bef8738ae489c6c9232f9bdc342e8d62bfd298"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b0ff461251389e4609a58d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127500,"date":"2026-06-04T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127500","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4dcfe3a415de45791a7a3508","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127474,"date":"2026-06-08T17:30:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"My first question is for U15. Burnaby is home to BCIT and Simon Fraser University. I know they are not members of U15, but you might consider adding them. My first question for you is this: Canada's research universities attract some of the world's brightest students and researchers. How does this strengthen Canadian students' ability to do research and enhance Canada's innovation economy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127474","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"My first question is for U15. Burnaby is home to BCIT and Simon Fraser University. I know they are not members of U15, but you might consider adding them. My first question for you is this: Canada's research universities attract some of the world's brightest students and researchers. How does this strengthen Canadian students' ability to do research and enhance Canada's innovation economy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a360e39128ad33476fc3cf90e6ac9e0d9800ddf6f8fa72b1f2d116641af81584"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b192a0fcc3492a59e5823f6e61c28ad586c14936b4103dd77fa5ebc61d2a64c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81508648c870e4ea1c5fc8f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127475,"date":"2026-06-08T17:30:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Can you say that international talent directly benefits Canadian students and the Canadian economy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127475","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Can you say that international talent directly benefits Canadian students and the Canadian economy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5bc0a122213cea4502507f2131cec6683136c42b44d5f7afc3aa86b544a478a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3146048f3e6f3cbb9bea9fe7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127476,"date":"2026-06-08T17:30:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Thank you. As global competition for international talent intensifies, what are the key factors that determine whether leading researchers and graduate students choose Canada over other countries?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127476","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. As global competition for international talent intensifies, what are the key factors that determine whether leading researchers and graduate students choose Canada over other countries?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c156f864f750aa2602e18260acbba27f0d6e04c50bbb8ae96f8a9c547346cca4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9eba75dbbc8d6606cc6a0920","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127477,"date":"2026-06-08T17:35:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"What roles do international students play in Canada's talent pipeline and future workforce?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127477","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What roles do international students play in Canada's talent pipeline and future workforce?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a2dc1010dcbdc682d6b925b5844091ff83accd4e4c68147fca2a7d930d42dc72"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20b24aeca24aaf50198ddc44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127478,"date":"2026-06-08T17:35:00+00:00","title":"CIMM","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"CIMM","text":"Looking at Canada's talent attraction strategy, which measures have the greatest potential to help our universities attract and retain world-class researchers and innovators?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIMM/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127478","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Looking at Canada's talent attraction strategy, which measures have the greatest potential to help our universities attract and retain world-class researchers and innovators?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff1954b25105ab8cc0b14305d1a28f209c145965e95c7c9be72d8bf8facd9dfe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e89d9b042aa14ccf834dc7af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127501,"date":"2026-06-08T22:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Ali, your submission includes recommendations regarding post-employment including a cooling-off period for former designated public office holders. Could you outline the changes you're proposing and the rationale behind them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127501","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Ali, your submission includes recommendations regarding post-employment including a cooling-off period for former designated public office holders. Could you outline the changes you're proposing and the rationale behind them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["068fce3357037c88dbed6cda130e01c2fc1b583c005515e30d834ab2b1202ae9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb802a619cc97a3392fd2bdc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127502,"date":"2026-06-08T22:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Based on your review of other jurisdictions, how do they deal with the cooling-off period for former public office holders?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127502","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Based on your review of other jurisdictions, how do they deal with the cooling-off period for former public office holders?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce06eb2c831c7b7131c9fee7ad94982fe08753eba453ed72897575cca209a593"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39e1de6d2ccf20030d474b94","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127503,"date":"2026-06-08T22:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you. In your submission, you recommend that the proposed amendment to subsections 7(3) and 7(6) of the Lobbying Act apply to paid in-house lobbyists, but not to individuals serving on boards in a volunteer capacity. Could you elaborate on this distinction?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127503","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. In your submission, you recommend that the proposed amendment to subsections 7(3) and 7(6) of the Lobbying Act apply to paid in-house lobbyists, but not to individuals serving on boards in a volunteer capacity. Could you elaborate on this distinction?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8d36d82f868c9fd0da91b9c3cf7cd404716b80da43bdbd6f67d5981043152f1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["99ec04ccd8f4962d1375e499efd6cd3e29383c53a65ad22f7ee182017fe8d143"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7c16b1eb96e26e0ed52bc1d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127504,"date":"2026-06-08T22:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"From your perspective, how can Parliament ensure that the act promotes transparency and accountability while avoiding unintended consequences that could discourage volunteer participation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127504","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"From your perspective, how can Parliament ensure that the act promotes transparency and accountability while avoiding unintended consequences that could discourage volunteer participation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["323a67bdccdd4d1a92ca3c197b849093f5a29156343087a144a065c2224b7140"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7df82b9d219f21458634d662","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127505,"date":"2026-06-08T22:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"In your submission, you recommend maintaining the current requirements set forth in sections 6 and 9, and sections 7 and 10 of the Lobbyists Registration Regulations. Could you explain the rationale for preserving those provisions in their current form?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127505","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In your submission, you recommend maintaining the current requirements set forth in sections 6 and 9, and sections 7 and 10 of the Lobbyists Registration Regulations. Could you explain the rationale for preserving those provisions in their current form?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd3142dade268826c98c573376854503adea15008c90a8c833485c3e0af03ccf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df2f9e307d6a0e012f408b52","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127506,"date":"2026-06-08T22:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127506","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcba79307684ed41497ee5df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127507,"date":"2026-06-08T22:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127507","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea44d660fb362d964368719e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127508,"date":"2026-06-08T23:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Thurlow, I'm from B.C. In your brief, you raised concerns about expanding the commissioner's enforcement power, particularly with respect to administrative monetary penalties. Could you explain those concerns and what lessons, if any, our Parliament should take from the B.C. experience?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127508","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Thurlow, I'm from B.C. In your brief, you raised concerns about expanding the commissioner's enforcement power, particularly with respect to administrative monetary penalties. Could you explain those concerns and what lessons, if any, our Parliament should take from the B.C. experience?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic sanctions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","label":"Economic sanctions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c30c319aa3d6372ee736158ee3964245600c95f34c43d6d3eb3650c1bdda7db5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d3e7bd30d3511095545c170","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127509,"date":"2026-06-08T23:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you very much. Do you agree with the statement that Canada's lobbying regime is full of loopholes or secret lobbying, or do you agree with many of our witnesses who stated that our lobbying regime is one of the most robust and most rigorous in the world, and why?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127509","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Do you agree with the statement that Canada's lobbying regime is full of loopholes or secret lobbying, or do you agree with many of our witnesses who stated that our lobbying regime is one of the most robust and most rigorous in the world, and why?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c4681650e338de45cb1f43bd8a41330541eb462c8a30990371d23cde09e003ac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ef0742795939126b286a92dc990d9b8aa156195b13792f3d50041f4c3b288972"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9bcf7bf09f801d40d89ae535","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127510,"date":"2026-06-08T23:20:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you. Why do you believe the Lobbyists' Code of Conduct should remain focused specifically on the activities of registrants as they communicate with public office holders?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127510","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Why do you believe the Lobbyists' Code of Conduct should remain focused specifically on the activities of registrants as they communicate with public office holders?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7425f836198a80271e042f66e73f4bdf632c318303fdc3ce537dbe491119f0d0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff32d21ecfc7ae3d3536ae95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127511,"date":"2026-06-08T23:20:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"I guess my final question for you is this. From an administrative law perspective, what principles should Parliament consider when assessing proposals to expand the powers of the Commissioner of Lobbying?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127511","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I guess my final question for you is this. From an administrative law perspective, what principles should Parliament consider when assessing proposals to expand the powers of the Commissioner of Lobbying?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3df97a4cd9b417719b4c7c2ad1196d6f1d8e41c28b32f53dd7157c5cbab0ecf2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32fdcefbb31bb48d348233ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086447,"date":"2026-06-09T19:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, happy Pride. Today the Prime Minister and parliamentarians gathered on Parliament Hill to raise the Pride flag and mark the beginning of Pride season in Canada. Pride is more than a celebration. It is a reminder that the rights and freedoms of 2SLGBTQIA+ Canadians cannot be taken for granted. At a time when hate is on the rise and when some voices in the House continue to question the full inclusion of 2SLGBTQIA+ people, Canadians expect leadership to stand firmly on the side of equality, dignity and human rights.\n\nCan the Minister of Women and Gender Equality tell the House how our government will continue to protect the safety, dignity and full inclusion of 2SLGBTQIA+ Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086447","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, happy Pride. Today the Prime Minister and parliamentarians gathered on Parliament Hill to raise the Pride flag and mark the beginning of Pride season in Canada. Pride is more than a celebration. It is a reminder that the rights and freedoms of 2SLGBTQIA+ Canadians cannot be taken for granted. At a time when hate is on the rise and when some voices in the House continue to question the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","label":"Gender equality","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c45104183db5be79ae28e623bec99d6f61aa76a4c954c5b2b167952a3c96c15"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9c9c3dfd29cc5e70632c9ed623eb189a04524877944e40d417b735d99f60efcf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49ba1bc181faaf5785d18f04","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127512,"date":"2026-06-11T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Chair. Minister, can you confirm that the discussions regarding high-speed rail began long before your election to Parliament and long before you became Minister of Finance, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127512","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Minister, can you confirm that the discussions regarding high-speed rail began long before your election to Parliament and long before you became Minister of Finance, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5637cfc02b2c73a59cf00e530ec9b07deeb4d61ef88d93c2c57a3e104a7e670"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e33c6fab5db5df5b3a28586f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127513,"date":"2026-06-11T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Minister. Can you also confirm that the entity now known as Alto was created in 2022, several years before the events being discussed today, and at a time when you were serving as the Minister of Innovation, Science and Industry?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127513","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Minister. Can you also confirm that the entity now known as Alto was created in 2022, several years before the events being discussed today, and at a time when you were serving as the Minister of Innovation, Science and Industry?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["304ce3caa14de386b1db5d28a0e0f1c1d4fe48a63bd8d5afd252dc822f673e5b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-603898a88007a0db97d2cda4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127514,"date":"2026-06-11T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Minister. For the benefit of this committee, could you clarify the reporting relationship between Alto and the Government of Canada and which minister is responsible for the oversight of the Crown corporation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127514","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Minister. For the benefit of this committee, could you clarify the reporting relationship between Alto and the Government of Canada and which minister is responsible for the oversight of the Crown corporation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c3ba6140f20deed82c1101ff91d2041ac957fa84a0f412fa3913beb1266c9f7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3068f08741bbe292759a5735","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127515,"date":"2026-06-11T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Minister. Could you explain what Alto would mean for Canada's long-term economic growth, productivity and connectivity? What would Canada lose by not moving forward with such a project?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-47/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-47/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127515","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Minister. Could you explain what Alto would mean for Canada's long-term economic growth, productivity and connectivity? What would Canada lose by not moving forward with such a project?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036438","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nonrenewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036438","label":"Nonrenewable resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9fff86e99603129fb5938a99be692687f787e63aa83541bd6a751193c11e17ed"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a02f77fd8e8980834332da3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088301,"date":"2026-06-15T19:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Chang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this year, the Burnaby Hospice Society celebrates 40 years of caring for Burnaby. For me, this anniversary is deeply personal. My mom battled cervical cancer for three years. In the final months of her life, she received hospice care. It gave her comfort and peace. It also gave our family the strength to face the unimaginable. \"Be a blessing to others\" were my mom's final words before she passed away. They led me to a life of service and to the House.\n\nHaving witnessed the impact of hospice care first-hand, I know that hospice workers and volunteers cannot change what lies ahead, but they can ensure that no one walks their final journey alone.\n\nI thank every staff member, volunteer, donor and supporter of the Burnaby Hospice Society. In the moments when a hand is held for the last time and a final goodbye is whispered, they are there. They remind us that the soul of a community is not how it celebrates life but how it cares for one another when life is drawing to a close.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088301","member_id":"bc-mp-123520","member_name":"Wade Chang","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this year, the Burnaby Hospice Society celebrates 40 years of caring for Burnaby. For me, this anniversary is deeply personal. My mom battled cervical cancer for three years. In the final months of her life, she received hospice care. It gave her comfort and peace. It also gave our family the strength to face the unimaginable. \"Be a blessing to others\" were my mom's final words before","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Survivor benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","label":"Survivor benefits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1129e192c0e4dde0026ff3e8ecbfca1822bcaa72bca3a8e467d2661b7ab99f74"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-036a59c1bf29ca6ac4d669ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76296,"date":"2026-01-28T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, forestry families on Vancouver Island are struggling. The Crofton mill closed. The Atli mill closed. The Chemainus mill was curtailed until the end of 2026. Hundreds and hundreds of jobs have been lost, but more importantly, already struggling families are now facing dire consequences. The government's handouts and subsidies are not helping those affected and will not save this critical and renewable resource industry.\n\nWhen will the Prime Minister deliver on his promised softwood lumber trade deal?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76296","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, forestry families on Vancouver Island are struggling. The Crofton mill closed. The Atli mill closed. The Chemainus mill was curtailed until the end of 2026. Hundreds and hundreds of jobs have been lost, but more importantly, already struggling families are now facing dire consequences. The government's handouts and subsidies are not helping those affected and will not save this critic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6bbd986a7f26ce1f7dc5a673aa7343bba8b0ee1266746732a47d99b745fc8b7b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4637713d82f4f26e59a1ab04e12c382e0dd1e86f65900e89757133ceb8245fa3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a105209649bf2468a91eeb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76297,"date":"2026-01-29T16:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this week the U.S. ambassador said, \"NORAD would have to be altered\" if Canada were to pull back on the F-35 purchase, suggesting that the United States would have to take over operations to address threats if we did not have the correct aircraft to do it.\n\nOn Monday, at the national defence committee, we heard from the commander of the Royal Canadian Air Force, who said clearly that the F-35 is the only fighter jet with the advanced capabilities that our air force needs.\n\nThis week, the Minister of National Defence said that the file is still \"under review\", but we heard testimony last fall that the review was complete and on the Prime Minister's desk. Which is it?\n\nThe F-35, a fifth generation stealth fighter jet, won the competition the government ran, easily defeating its lesser competitors. It is the only aircraft capable of carrying out the operations required. Our air force is calling for this aircraft and our allies are calling for this aircraft. What more does the Prime Minister need to see?\n\nWhen will the Prime Minister commit to purchasing all 88 F-35s that our air force and our allies need?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76297","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this week the U.S. ambassador said, \"NORAD would have to be altered\" if Canada were to pull back on the F-35 purchase, suggesting that the United States would have to take over operations to address threats if we did not have the correct aircraft to do it.\n\nOn Monday, at the national defence committee, we heard from the commander of the Royal Canadian Air Force, who said clearly that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","label":"Military aircraft"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Military aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","label":"Military aircraft","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9c475535d7affa236de11d9fcd41e9501ca5755e116433004ca2d514f077d954"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Military aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1375b81240a736a59d8e3c156ec185ab14e4bddf87e3e35be694191a1b87570"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Military aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26d39cff5cb26486f28fafc2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76298,"date":"2026-01-29T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, my colleague's speech delved into some positive and constructive criticisms that will help improve this bill.\n\nAs it is written, Bill C-16 would allow judges to ignore every mandatory minimum prison sentence other than for murder and treason. Does my colleague feel that this will help reduce the increased crime rates, and violent crime rates specifically, that we have seen in the country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76298","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, my colleague's speech delved into some positive and constructive criticisms that will help improve this bill.\n\nAs it is written, Bill C-16 would allow judges to ignore every mandatory minimum prison sentence other than for murder and treason. Does my colleague feel that this will help reduce the increased crime rates, and violent crime rates specifically, that we have seen in the co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc9bf7c27d8ea9a7675888170744a094e3d33c467ea4c3b3761cf8909b78bf78"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["22d78aaaaf743251cf5e784a421018192012279c98bc798cb1aca3038cde9a14"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21dbb8cea9501b3421204076","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76299,"date":"2026-01-29T17:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is an honour to stand in the House to represent the great people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford on beautiful Vancouver Island.\n\nI would like to take a quick moment to pay tribute to Wanda Wetteland, a 31-year navy veteran. She was a much-loved and long-time member of Branch 134 Malahat Legion. Sadly, she passed earlier this month, just the night before her wedding. We will remember her.\n\nBefore us today is Bill C-16, the protecting victims act. On January 5, Laura Gover-Basar, a 41-year-old mother from Vancouver Island, was found dead in her home. Her ex-husband has been arrested and charged with her murder. Laura held a Ph.D. and was an instructor at Camosun College, not too far from where I live. She leaves behind two young daughters who will now have neither parent around to raise them.\n\nAllegations suggest that Laura was a victim of intimate partner violence and that her death was the result of this violence. Her ex-husband was supposed to appear in court for failing to follow a court order in a separate matter the very same day that her body was found.\n\nNearly 200 people gathered in Victoria to bring attention to Laura's death and highlight the long-standing problem of domestic and gender-based violence. They are calling for government action, and I believe that Bill C-16 is a good start to bringing justice for victims. Among the positive steps are changes that would make the murder of an intimate partner automatically a first-degree murder charge. This is a measure first proposed by my Conservative colleague, the member for Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, in his private member's bill, Bill C-225, Bailey's law.\n\nRight now, Laura's ex-husband has been charged only with second-degree murder. Under Bill C-16, the law would ensure that her alleged murderer would be charged to the fullest with a first-degree murder charge and also be sentenced to the fullest, as it would come with a mandatory life sentence, life in prison, with no parole eligibility for 25 years.\n\nLaura's tragic case is not an isolated one. As activists pointed out when they gathered in Victoria, this is a decades-long issue that needs to be—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76299","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is an honour to stand in the House to represent the great people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford on beautiful Vancouver Island.\n\nI would like to take a quick moment to pay tribute to Wanda Wetteland, a 31-year navy veteran. She was a much-loved and long-time member of Branch 134 Malahat Legion. Sadly, she passed earlier this month, just the night before her wedding. We will remember","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["17e48ad7c1a2cb8679a94d073234fdade7bc0ba4f9e2f45343345e4e4d4b2d17"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fae8ae80a17bdcd43817c499b31f65db044820512681763a3b01370ac1d46dc0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56bdd3c53a47404f91484218","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76300,"date":"2026-01-29T17:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, Laura's tragic case is not an isolated one, as activists pointed out when they gathered in Victoria. This is a decades-long issue that needs to be solved.\n\nBy making femicide automatically a first-degree murder charge, we would see a vitally important step being taken to bring justice to victims like Laura and their families. It is worth noting that the term \"femicide\" is a little misleading, as the law would apply to intimate partner violence committed by either gender.\n\nAnother positive measure that Bill C-16 would bring forward is the banning of deepfake images of intimate partners. This would keep Canadians, especially women, safe from non-consensual intimate images' being created and shared. This proposal originally came from my colleague, the member for Calgary Nose Hill, and her private member's bill, Bill C-216. From that same bill, provisions that would bring mandatory reporting for child sexual abuse material have also been added to Bill C-16, which would help keep our kids safe from the most despicable of crimes.\n\nBill C-16 would also introduce an aggravating factor for sextortion. This is a step in the right direction, although in my opinion it does not go far enough. My Conservative colleague, the member for Edmonton Gateway, had proposed a three-year mandatory minimum sentence for all forms of extortion, which I would also have liked to have seen in the bill.\n\nFurther, Bill C-16 would affect the National Defence Act, and as a member of the Standing Committee on National Defence, I strongly recommend that we get to study this part of the bill in greater detail. The bill would enable victims to receive information from authorities in the military justice system without being required to make official requests. These changes would allow victims the ability to receive information about their rights and available protection measures, and to receive information from the military justice authorities without being required to make the request. This is a shift from the current on-request framing of the National Defence Act's declaration of victim rights for certain categories of information.\n\nWith CFB Esquimalt, the third-largest military base in Canada, neighbouring my riding on Vancouver Island, these changes are especially important to many members of my community. I believe that these measures would work hand in hand with Bill C-11, which we are currently dealing with at committee.\n\nI am glad to see that Bill C-16 is utilizing some great Conservative concepts, and I hope that my colleagues across the aisle will also incorporate our amendments for Bill C-11, without which there would be reduced justice for survivors of military sexual trauma. We need to ensure that our responses are victim-centred and trauma-centred. Any steps that lead us in that direction are good steps.\n\nUnfortunately, some steps are missed in Bill C-16. As it is written, Bill C-16 would allow judges to ignore every mandatory minimum prison sentence in Canada's Criminal Code, other than for murder and treason. Parliament sets mandatory minimums for heinous crimes, as is the prerogative of elected officials, but if the Liberals allow judges to ignore mandatory minimums, there would effectively be nothing mandatory about them.\n\nAggravated sexual assault with a gun, and human trafficking, would not have mandatory sentences. Multiple violent firearms offences, including extortion with a firearm, weapons trafficking, drive-by shootings with a restricted or prohibited firearm, and many other crimes would not have mandatory minimum sentencing under Bill C-16. This simply does not make sense. Are we seriously talking about extremely violent and heinous crimes without a minimum penalty?\n\nThis part of Bill C-16 is a significant step backwards for victims and their families. This is not a victim-centred approach. Since 2015, human trafficking has increased 84%, sexual assault is up almost 76% and violent crime is up almost 55%.\n\nCanadians need Parliament to co-operatively take real steps to make our streets safe again. Simply put, removing mandatory minimums would not do that. As elected officials, we must do everything we can to keep our communities safe. It is our job as parliamentarians to set consequences for serious crimes like these. Bill C-16, as it stands, would undermine that outright authority. Canadians deserve to feel safe in their neighbourhood, and victims and their families deserve to see justice served.\n\nThere are many aspects of the bill that I agree with. The aspects that are victim-centric and the aspects that are trauma-informed are steps in the right direction that I support in the spirit of collaboration. My concern with the bill lies where victims stop being the focus. I believe that if we bring the focus back to the victims and do not take away parliamentary authority to set mandatory minimum sentences, C-16 could bring some extremely important and needed changes to our justice system.\n\nI hope that my colleagues across the floor will embrace the spirit of collaboration we always offer and be open to our improvements to strengthen the bill to keep mandatory minimum penalties for heinous crimes. We can all agree that we collectively face significant increased crime. With some improvements to Bill C-16, we could work together to bring forward a positive solution for Canada. The ball is in their court.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76300","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, Laura's tragic case is not an isolated one, as activists pointed out when they gathered in Victoria. This is a decades-long issue that needs to be solved.\n\nBy making femicide automatically a first-degree murder charge, we would see a vitally important step being taken to bring justice to victims like Laura and their families. It is worth noting that the term \"femicide\" is a little m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["29f49e1f3af8706601b942f2f79009a83b1495e6e52dd7a603eb7af664eb2a96"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d4066313058c31eba07199d0b577019759a2d6426e66f6c6da7fd4d85d866eb7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d6a46fcb26f92842d10fe74","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76301,"date":"2026-01-29T17:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member opposite seems to be quite angry, but I must say that the Liberals have had almost 11 years to resolve this. The committee tried 19 times to put it ahead of Bill C-9, and it was refused. That was our positive, collaborative way to try to bring this forward in a timely way.\n\nHowever, the bill would take away mandatory minimum penalties for aggravated assault with a gun and for human trafficking. It would take them away for multiple violent offences, including extortion with a firearm, weapons trafficking, drive-by shootings with a restricted or prohibited firearm, and many others.\n\nThe point of my speech, and my answer for the member opposite, is that we would ensure that those mandatory minimum penalties, which are focused on the victims, are in the legislation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76301","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member opposite seems to be quite angry, but I must say that the Liberals have had almost 11 years to resolve this. The committee tried 19 times to put it ahead of Bill C-9, and it was refused. That was our positive, collaborative way to try to bring this forward in a timely way.\n\nHowever, the bill would take away mandatory minimum penalties for aggravated assault with a gun and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ceecb68d8f0447d645c477d7dad32657b8e1afdd638512fed1c9b054b7cc3efb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fc9f9373fda8a49ad9735597b4e5b6548cb45a43ba8257f1ee9b0fa3854aa06b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-499f99fdebc69e328a07f291","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76302,"date":"2026-01-29T17:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the bill is not about the Jordan decision; although it could have impact, the bill is about mandatory minimum penalties, and certainly it is worth exploring the potential impact of the Jordan decision that the bill could have. That is why I have suggested that we need to look further into it and make improvements, including consideration for the Jordan decision.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76302","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the bill is not about the Jordan decision; although it could have impact, the bill is about mandatory minimum penalties, and certainly it is worth exploring the potential impact of the Jordan decision that the bill could have. That is why I have suggested that we need to look further into it and make improvements, including consideration for the Jordan decision.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccabe6e0b8bcfc072eb807e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76303,"date":"2026-01-29T17:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I know that the terrible murder that we speak of happened in or very close to her riding. There is much research that shows that mandatory minimums do reduce the impacts and effects of, specifically, very violent and heinous crimes. It is worth looking at all sources and information as we look to improve the bill. I certainly believe that mandatory minimums are a key part of the prevention of—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76303","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I know that the terrible murder that we speak of happened in or very close to her riding. There is much research that shows that mandatory minimums do reduce the impacts and effects of, specifically, very violent and heinous crimes. It is worth looking at all sources and information as we look to improve the bill. I certainly believe that mandatory minimums are a key part of the pre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["989c8654ca3d763341e0fac4a213633fa1463c4f02531a8e75e3f120c7de76a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2d1fa3936da4b31c25245e71defcd960f21e675ea7d78eea3a14845b5beb4035"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff68a5818725d423e5a05b11","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86060,"date":"2026-02-06T16:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, this week, the Crofton mill on Vancouver Island shut down.\n\n Growing tariffs and lack of access to local raw logs have forced over 30 mills in B.C. to close. The unemployment rate in forestry doubled in the last month. On south Vancouver Island alone, hundreds of trucks are arriving weekly to export raw logs to foreign countries, as approved by this government.\n\nOur proposed Canadian sovereignty act would legalize rapid resource development in Canada, giving mills across B.C. a chance to survive. Will the Prime Minister protect our industries from rising tariffs, reduce raw log exports and work with Conservatives in the face of American threats?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86060","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, this week, the Crofton mill on Vancouver Island shut down.\n\n Growing tariffs and lack of access to local raw logs have forced over 30 mills in B.C. to close. The unemployment rate in forestry doubled in the last month. On south Vancouver Island alone, hundreds of trucks are arriving weekly to export raw logs to foreign countries, as approved by this government.\n\nOur proposed Canadia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01b9471fb30a087f98c83926009ef8eb4f0dea6f9cba838030e8b6755cdb5d20"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["43e6e2073c91144ca19d00372fc7cf4b0053c2f9278f3919a0b6023e32e94132"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14c01ed2cddc66ee19b3ff3d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310385,"date":"2026-02-25T21:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to request unanimous consent with respect to the second vote. I used the app, but it did not work. It registered on the app that I had voted, but when I followed up afterward, it indicated I had not. Therefore, I am requesting unanimous consent to vote yea in support of Bill C-244 for the second vote.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310385","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to request unanimous consent with respect to the second vote. I used the app, but it did not work. It registered on the app that I had voted, but when I followed up afterward, it indicated I had not. Therefore, I am requesting unanimous consent to vote yea in support of Bill C-244 for the second vote.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b71f7c744ab7259be2e687e7ca6fd69008631bb446362d841b09cab1da08b65d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a478c043bfe810a2649369b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310386,"date":"2026-02-25T21:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition on behalf of British Columbian fishers and anglers, calling on the Minister of Fisheries to implement 100% clipping and coded wire tagging programs for hatchery chinook and coho salmon. \n\nCoastal communities in B.C. are being hit hard by salmon retention closures, even as tens of millions of hatchery chinook are released each year. The problem is straightforward. Too few hatchery fish are being marked and tagged, making it difficult for managers to implement marked selective fisheries where hatchery fish can be retained and wild fish released. B.C.'s low marking rate remains a key barrier to retention opportunities.\n\nThis would protect wild fish stocks while allowing selective retention hatchery fish, supporting coastal communities, a way of life, over 9,000 jobs and a $1.2-billion industry. I am pleased to present the petition and I urge the minister to act with urgency.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310386","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition on behalf of British Columbian fishers and anglers, calling on the Minister of Fisheries to implement 100% clipping and coded wire tagging programs for hatchery chinook and coho salmon. \n\nCoastal communities in B.C. are being hit hard by salmon retention closures, even as tens of millions of hatchery chinook are released each year. The problem is str","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["25b0dc2656c697d8c0d4141e167eb58e1378d260ba1b55c43470d4312188fc8b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56a13944fe87e5f96a6aeacbb0188fbdf79092f7d2f0fb75f401d5fab14fc85b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e03847ede41926d2eae11e54","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350196,"date":"2026-03-10T00:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, over 100,000 Canadians are caught in the growing crisis in the Middle East, and they deserve more than vague assurances and last-minute contingency planning. As the threat from the Iranian regime escalated, the government says it deployed consular staff, updated travel advisories and explored possible airspace access. Those are preparatory steps, but Canadians in the region need action.\n\nIn past times of war and crisis, the Canadian government has organized emergency support and assisted in departures, such as Haiti in 2024 and Operation Lumen in support of potential evacuations in Lebanon in 2023. To date, Canada's response to the Iranian crisis has been reactive instead of proactive. When warning signs of impending crisis had been visible for months, plans and preparations should have already been in place.\n\nDoes the leader of the Bloc Québécois agree with my call for the government to work with allies and regional partners to secure safe departure operations without delay; to ensure that needed military personnel, aircraft and consular resources are in place; and to support the thousands of Canadians caught in the Middle East and the over 3,500 Canadians looking for extraction, including those within Iran?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350196","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, over 100,000 Canadians are caught in the growing crisis in the Middle East, and they deserve more than vague assurances and last-minute contingency planning. As the threat from the Iranian regime escalated, the government says it deployed consular staff, updated travel advisories and explored possible airspace access. Those are preparatory steps, but Canadians in the region need actio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8aa4aa20e66155574a37ba6040b848e9396e4472e5bf94b250d364981fbeafb0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df40a2e5ea2377e39fdc8cd7f8359c7ae3070a2136583ea5fb0efc92b69c4e64"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b06de5ab172c6c9e2d59005d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349419,"date":"2026-03-12T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, later today Vancouver Islanders will gather at the British Columbia Afghanistan Memorial in Victoria to mark the 12th anniversary of the end of Canada's mission in Afghanistan and remember the 165 Canadian lives that were lost there.\n\n Canada's mission in Afghanistan was the longest military campaign in our country's history, where more than 40,000 Canadians served. We remember the courage, sacrifice and service of those who answered the call. \n\nIt saddens me to ask, however, why the Liberal government has failed to build the dedicated Afghanistan war memorial here in Ottawa that was announced 12 years ago. It is shameful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349419","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, later today Vancouver Islanders will gather at the British Columbia Afghanistan Memorial in Victoria to mark the 12th anniversary of the end of Canada's mission in Afghanistan and remember the 165 Canadian lives that were lost there.\n\n Canada's mission in Afghanistan was the longest military campaign in our country's history, where more than 40,000 Canadians served. We remember the co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","label":"War memorials"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","label":"War memorials","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b534fe9ab91c7fad099b171b5798591b1560ae25863c631dded25f81ef81f0fd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6fa84b022a459ed62f36fe674cd81fa04492db2f0acb333d8a35a75b4e2e50ee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-541cd5158c5a3453e47e9a26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349415,"date":"2026-03-13T17:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition on behalf of fishers and anglers across British Columbia.\n\nThe petitioners are calling on the Minister of Fisheries to manage the exploding population of invasive predatory pinnipeds and its impact on valuable and vulnerable salmon stocks. The invasive species of California and Steller sea lions consume more salmon than the commercial and recreational fishing industries combined. The petitioners call on the government to work with local communities and first nations to implement a pinniped management program to protect our salmon stocks, which are important to first nations and commercial and recreational fishers, as well as to our southern resident killer whales.\n\n I am pleased to present this petition, and I urge the minister to act immediately.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349415","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition on behalf of fishers and anglers across British Columbia.\n\nThe petitioners are calling on the Minister of Fisheries to manage the exploding population of invasive predatory pinnipeds and its impact on valuable and vulnerable salmon stocks. The invasive species of California and Steller sea lions consume more salmon than the commercial and recreationa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","label":"Aquatic animals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","label":"Aquatic animals","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b0429a8fdb327557bac003dfcdb513cc3326842f393e605dedef7a47263f69b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["117c215c7ff236107b0fc9e0aed2ac673e01a325d2bab89421c0ced1a829f253"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aaadcf3b1103b92b67d435c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349416,"date":"2026-03-13T18:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise today on behalf of the great people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford on Vancouver Island to discuss Bill C-20, the Build Canada Homes act.\n\nSimply put, Vancouver Island, and indeed Canada, is in a housing crisis. There is an entire generation being priced out of home ownership, and far too many, including young Canadians, have lost the hope of ever owning a home. This crisis will not solve itself, and it is the job of the government to take action to fix it.\n\nLast week, I held a round table in Langford specifically to discuss housing with my colleague from Parry Sound—Muskoka, the shadow minister of housing. We spoke to builders, developers, mayors and other local industry leaders to discuss the challenges they are facing, along with possible solutions, to get homes built. They all said the same thing: Extraneous regulations, long and unpredictable approval periods, expensive taxes and the rising cost of materials and services are killing the industry. Companies like Viking Properties, a small developer on Vancouver Island that has successfully built over 400 housing units in the Langford area, including 250 units since 2019, told us about increased fees, development cost charges and the long wait times they face to get permits approved. These all add significant costs to their projects and are holding them back from building at a faster pace. These are costs, by the way, that all end up being passed on to the buyer.\n\nThese are the real problems that are slowing homebuilding in Canada and making housing unaffordable for an entire generation. Compounded delays and skyrocketing costs have created a cycle where buyers cannot afford to buy, sellers cannot afford to sell and builders cannot afford to build. We see this in crumbling housing starts across Canada.\n\nThis brings me to Bill C-20. The Build Canada Homes agency, or bureaucracy, will be the third housing agency created in the last 10 years and the fourth housing bureaucracy, none of which have succeeded so far. The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results, yet here we are, doing the same thing again. Canadians, frankly, deserve better.\n\nBuilding enough homes to meet the demands of a growing population is the only way to make housing affordable again. Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation has said we need to reach a target of 430,000 to 500,000 homes built per year for the next 10 years to meet this demand. Originally, the government promised this new housing agency would build 500,000 homes per year. That was promising, yes, but it was just a promise. So far, it has not delivered.\n\nIn fact, the Parliamentary Budget Officer has reported that the Build Canada Homes agency will build only approximately 5,200 homes per year. That is only 1% of the original promise, 1% of the targeted amount needed to make housing affordable for Canadians again. This simply is not enough. This will not solve the crisis we find ourselves in, so we must rely on our private developers and builders who have the proven skills, ingenuity and fortitude to get this done. To do that, we must address the challenges they are facing so that they can build. Builders across Canada share the same message. They need less government involvement, fewer taxes and quicker, predictable approval times. We need to cut red tape so homes can be built effectively. What we do not need is a fourth remix of the same song.\n\nThe last 10 years have proven that adding processes does not fix the problem. Instead, it adds another layer of reviews, which take time, which leads to delays, which lead to added costs, which lead to higher sale prices. Another government agency is not the answer to the crisis. Under its current mandate, Build Canada Homes will not change zoning laws, eliminate discretionary rezoning, impose firm timelines on reviews, reduce development charges or remove environmental duplication charges, so it will not build enough homes to meet the necessary targets or address any real challenges the industry is facing. Not only does this new agency not address these challenges, but it does not address the root cause of the crisis. We cannot build homes fast enough to keep up with our growing population.\n\nConservatives have put forward alternative solutions that would target some of the industry challenges head-on. One is cutting the GST on all new homes under $1.3 million, which would save families up to $65,000 on new homes, making these builds more affordable. Another is, importantly, tying federal infrastructure dollars to homebuilding, which would encourage municipalities to permit more homebuilding each year with a target of 15% more.\n\nWe have suggested cutting development cost charges by 50%. This was a campaign promise by the government last year, but I am sad to see that it has not followed through. We would also like to see the removal of capital gains tax on reinvestment in new housing in Canada, which would unlock billions of dollars of investments in the country's homebuilding sector.\n\nThese are solutions that tackle the real problems the industry is facing and put the power back into the hands of Canada's home builders. I encourage my colleagues across the way to seriously consider these solutions so we can reach the goal I believe we all share, which is making housing affordable to Canadians. \n\nYesterday in the House, the Minister of Housing told Canadians the reason housing prices are so high is the war in Iran. This is a ridiculous statement to make for a multitude of reasons, none more so than the fact that we know the housing affordability crisis did not start a few weeks ago. It has been years in the making, indeed 11 years in the making, I would suggest.\n\nMy colleagues across the way keep telling us to focus on what we control, so I urge the minister to take that advice. Let us focus on the issues that truly burden the industry: too much government involvement, long wait periods, taxes. These are all the things that destroyed the housing economy in Vancouver when the minister was the mayor there. I spoke about insanity before. Here it is again. More of the bureaucracy, rules and regulations that caused costs to skyrocket in Vancouver when he was the mayor are now imposed on all of Canada under his leadership, and it has been a year.\n\nThe minister knows his grand plan is not working. His big announcements and promises of building at speeds never seen before, catalyzing the housing industry and 500,000 homes per year have gotten us nowhere. Instead of taking responsibility and focusing on positive solutions, the minister has decided to lay blame elsewhere. This is why my Conservative colleagues have put forward a plan, and I have reiterated it in my speech today. Canadians know the reality of the crisis they face, so I challenge my colleagues opposite to look at the reality of the last year of promises and slogans and compare it to the results, compare it to the reality. We have collapsing housing starts. Prices remain unaffordable. Despite lowering, they remain unaffordable to those who have lost jobs, are having their wages cut and are struggling just to pay for everyday costs. The supply levels are plummeting.\n\nConservatives have put forward a plan to unleash our trades, our investors, our workers and our resources so we can build homes quickly. Build Canada Homes will not remove those barriers. It only creates a massive new one. It does not solve the issue of delays. Therefore, it does not solve the issue of costs. Sometimes, the best thing a government can do is simply to get out of the way. I call on all my colleagues in the House. Let us work together to have homes built by builders, not bureaucracy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349416","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise today on behalf of the great people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford on Vancouver Island to discuss Bill C-20, the Build Canada Homes act.\n\nSimply put, Vancouver Island, and indeed Canada, is in a housing crisis. There is an entire generation being priced out of home ownership, and far too many, including young Canadians, have lost the hope of ever owning a home. Thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["77a53691d6ea5c76eacd2611a7bd2ddddb9dec0a42a8d7836ac74e5df53da54c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["849d4424cb2f40a867660a4f719c2a49cbf24aa68e384b27b3537cebdaefa624"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a68c33df7f0ba2d22f2b4cc9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":349417,"date":"2026-03-13T18:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, indeed, we do need to partner with municipalities, but part of that is getting out of the way and removing the extra layers of bureaucracy. I have spoken to builders and groups across south Vancouver Island, and they have said that they have had stuff cancelled and that they cannot afford to do these things, so they need help. As far as the Federation of Canadian Municipalities goes, they are signalling approval, but when they start looking at the realities I have pointed out, such as the cancelled projects and the promises of 500,000 homes that simply are not being built, the reality will quickly sink in that this plan is not working and we need to get out of the way and let our builders build.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:349417","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, indeed, we do need to partner with municipalities, but part of that is getting out of the way and removing the extra layers of bureaucracy. I have spoken to builders and groups across south Vancouver Island, and they have said that they have had stuff cancelled and that they cannot afford to do these things, so they need help. As far as the Federation of Canadian Municipalities goes, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["45290f55765d4d0f975cd582715f2f4744e33ff95f7792786b711d1f0ae5fd37"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7ef5e30b493970ebee82d9d92fe317bae81d810fee15730549441726a587a92"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dac4f9f31c463f65d6bce6cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390261,"date":"2026-03-24T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the recreational fishing industry is facing a review of the salmon allocation policy that could destroy the industry and strip away Canada's historic principle of common property resource access.\n\n The recreational fishing industry supports over 9,000 jobs, generates $600 million in direct income and contributes over $1.2 billion in GDP in British Columbia. \n\nWill the minister commit to protecting historical access to common property resources for recreational fishing, or will the Liberals let yet another vital industry, coastal communities and a way of life on Vancouver Island die?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390261","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the recreational fishing industry is facing a review of the salmon allocation policy that could destroy the industry and strip away Canada's historic principle of common property resource access.\n\n The recreational fishing industry supports over 9,000 jobs, generates $600 million in direct income and contributes over $1.2 billion in GDP in British Columbia. \n\nWill the minister commit ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","label":"Resources conservation","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52703685497e824403b6d2addea029fc1a83fef185b6c5336c08d2c84a632988"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["80f58fe2f7942fc3b110ecc652999defe6ccccf02b932ce36face5087f10d83f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-213e145749594ed1668e24a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390262,"date":"2026-03-24T23:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am humbled to stand here and represent the great people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford on Vancouver Island, and I continue to listen to and bring their voices forward here to Ottawa as their member of Parliament.\n\nOne of the biggest issues I hear about is the impact of crime on our community from people who are just trying to focus on the high cost of living and on raising their families in a safe community. People regularly talk to me about justice for victims as well as compassion and support for those impacted by crime. One way I am able to address this is through my private member's bill, Bill C-235, an act respecting families of murdered and brutalized persons.\n\nThis is an act that would focus on justice for victims and compassion for families of victims of the most heinous of crimes, where a victim is abducted, sexually assaulted and murdered in the same incident, very similar to that of Kimberly Proctor from Langford on Vancouver Island, a community I represent. Kimberly was horrifyingly abducted, raped and murdered in 2010. I give my deepest respect to her family, whom I know are watching today.\n\nI would like to also express my sincere appreciation to all of my colleagues who have sponsored and spoken to my private member's bill, including the member for Brantford—Brant South—Six Nations and my colleague from Selkirk—Interlake—Eastman for initiating this private member's bill over 10 years ago.\n\nThe most important factor that I would like to focus on today and that I would like all members of the House to consider is that this bill is about both justice for victims and compassion for their families and loved ones. By giving judges the option of parole ineligibility of up to 40 years, this bill would be, as we have heard, charter-compliant and would spare the families and loved ones of victims from the retraumatization of unnecessary parole hearings, potentially, every two years.\n\nI have personally sat with families as they recount the horrific process that comes with victim impact statements and the lengthy parole hearing process. The notifications that lead up to the hearings themselves are devastating. Disturbingly, it is well documented that criminals get off on recounting the heinous detail of their crimes solely for the purpose of revictimizing families.\n\nParole hearings are sometimes as little as 15 years after sentencing, based on time served and early parole factors. Presently in these cases, only the murder portion goes to sentencing, knowing that the other crimes will not affect the current maximum parole ineligibility of 25 years, leaving the victim, family and loved ones without justice for the abduction and sexual assault portions of these horrendous crimes.\n\nAnother important part worth noting is that criminals in these most heinous crimes will likely never receive parole. I was unable to find any such cases. These are criminals whom we know have no chance of ever being rehabilitated, but that does not stop the families, of course, from feeling obligated to submit victim impact statements and attend parole hearings, as it is the only way they can give a voice to those who can no longer speak, their family members, the victims silenced forever who can no longer speak for themselves.\n\nThrough debate, we have heard some minor suggestions for improvements discussed, including a more robust appeal mechanism, which is something we could examine in committee and indeed work with legislative counsel to potentially draft as an amendment. Another suggestion was to ensure that the bill would not be retroactive. However, I can confirm that new sentencing legislation is never retroactive. We also heard suggestions to ensure that judges provide clear and exceptional grounds to accompany such sentences. Once again, I am willing to re-examine and strengthen any judicial requirements to justify sentences.\n\nI would like to conclude our second reading of this bill with a few points. Firstly, I would like to remind all members of the House that this bill, previously passed through to committee, received broad, cross-party support and was set to return to the House before Parliament was prorogued in 2021. Secondly, I am open in committee to exploring and making necessary amendments, if required, to strengthen the bill, some of which I have addressed here today. Lastly, which I think is the most important part, I am asking all members to support my bill on behalf of the families I have heard from about the stresses, pressures and devastating impact of ongoing parole hearings and being revictimized by these most heinous criminals.\n\nTherefore, I challenge members from across the House to join me and give broad support to Bill C-235 by voting yes tomorrow and sending it before the justice committee. More importantly, I challenge them to show Canadians that we have listened.\n\nThis bill is about justice for victims. It is about sparing loved ones from the parole hearing process that forces them to relive the worst moment of their lives over and over. By supporting this bill, we can show Canadians that we are prepared to stand with victims' families and loved ones while respecting the memory of those they have lost.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390262","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am humbled to stand here and represent the great people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford on Vancouver Island, and I continue to listen to and bring their voices forward here to Ottawa as their member of Parliament.\n\nOne of the biggest issues I hear about is the impact of crime on our community from people who are just trying to focus on the high cost of living and on raising their famil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1288dc1a6b330c1363513c63134e4ecb071e5f3a232c37132a0b8f258a9ddb45"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["76e2277126f76ef7edea7fc4507a040042f91b621e204dcc524fdafd0355bb5a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f57820dc90d8544f54fd46fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390263,"date":"2026-03-24T23:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I request that we pass this bill on division.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390263","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I request that we pass this bill on division.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3731722def99adb6c572962f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390260,"date":"2026-03-26T19:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Pacific salmon are a public resource owned by all Canadians, not something for the Liberal government to eliminate behind closed doors.\n\n For generations, salmon have been managed as a common property resource for the collective benefit of all Canadians, yet the Liberal government is now considering removing that principle from the salmon allocation policy. The Minister of Fisheries refuses to commit to protecting B.C.'s vital recreational fishing industry.\n\n With only five days left to make a decision, I ask the minister to confirm that Canadians will retain their meaningful public right to fish, or will the Liberals once again turn their backs on coastal communities, recreational fishers and our way of life?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390260","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Pacific salmon are a public resource owned by all Canadians, not something for the Liberal government to eliminate behind closed doors.\n\n For generations, salmon have been managed as a common property resource for the collective benefit of all Canadians, yet the Liberal government is now considering removing that principle from the salmon allocation policy. The Minister of Fisheries r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["804bf0d1b9c515d076b99055f91e562399997e88536a310a8431c4fe13c84255"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fa03f8a40b2d8f4c1eb25b170830032a40f04f571f657311ff0329301591965d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13483f8dd387ae76a219b5fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715120,"date":"2026-04-13T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, residents across British Columbia already face enough pressure from the high cost of living and continued economic uncertainty without wondering whether their homes are truly theirs. The Cowichan Tribes' decision now calls into question all private property rights while damaging reconciliation efforts across Canada.\n\nClosed-door deals without transparency are not in the spirit of truth and reconciliation. The Liberals must do better. They must provide unity and economic stability.\n\nWill the Liberals assure Canadians that all future agreements will put private property rights first while protecting meaningful reconciliation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715120","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, residents across British Columbia already face enough pressure from the high cost of living and continued economic uncertainty without wondering whether their homes are truly theirs. The Cowichan Tribes' decision now calls into question all private property rights while damaging reconciliation efforts across Canada.\n\nClosed-door deals without transparency are not in the spirit of trut","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed682a9c5e663f06cdaee043540687d9ffb22e0580a51fd81441a3d7edba5657"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e482f54b8c9b1159e7390e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127588,"date":"2026-04-15T21:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for being here today, and thank you for your service. I'm glad to ask questions on this important topic. Where do I want to start? I would start with some basics, and we can focus on establishing some ratios. Is there a target ratio for francophones and anglophones in the Canadian Forces across the services?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127588","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for being here today, and thank you for your service. I'm glad to ask questions on this important topic. Where do I want to start? I would start with some basics, and we can focus on establishing some ratios. Is there a target ratio for francophones and anglophones in the Canadian Forces across the services?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59c854b21ae8bf7fed4e121f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127589,"date":"2026-04-15T21:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. I appreciate your efficiency, because you answered three of my questions in one. That's excellent. If you could speak a bit more as to the.... You said the flag officer rate is at 35%. Why is it higher there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127589","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I appreciate your efficiency, because you answered three of my questions in one. That's excellent. If you could speak a bit more as to the.... You said the flag officer rate is at 35%. Why is it higher there?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6eceb8e0bc23af7037eb811","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127590,"date":"2026-04-15T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you for that analysis. Maybe we could also speak to the rate of first nations in recruiting, in current strength and in flag rank.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127590","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that analysis. Maybe we could also speak to the rate of first nations in recruiting, in current strength and in flag rank.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","label":"Military training","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ccde24b923c35f30e2ee5af34495509958dacb7df7450d5b83df4410cfb4788"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e983da8241818f30c5e4d392","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127591,"date":"2026-04-15T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127591","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc3da3aff656bcde9684ad11","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127592,"date":"2026-04-15T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"That would be helpful. Thank you. Quickly, both on the indigenous side and francophone numbers you gave, how does this relate historically, say, over the last 20 years? Is it on par, or are we improving ratios? What is the general trend?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127592","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That would be helpful. Thank you. Quickly, both on the indigenous side and francophone numbers you gave, how does this relate historically, say, over the last 20 years? Is it on par, or are we improving ratios? What is the general trend?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","label":"Rates","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","label":"Water conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93a68bf9f9832bbb1049abb717dd4d74ad5748748f43b44e409ab546935cf32d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99d1d55ae50ee02a998c3f2a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127593,"date":"2026-04-15T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. We've seen a significant increase in permanent residents who are being recruited. Do we have a number or rate of members in CAF who can't speak either official language?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127593","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. We've seen a significant increase in permanent residents who are being recruited. Do we have a number or rate of members in CAF who can't speak either official language?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c323a141355bd5091c0e88ebcc51681a836167c529f72043fbb6d650d4ab474"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d2a66b378284aca85766cc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127594,"date":"2026-04-15T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I appreciate that there's language training. For example, right now, I'm aware of one recruit in basic training who requires a phone to talk—to use for interpretation—in order to operate. I learned about another platoon that has five recruits who can barely speak English or French, or who can't speak them at all. It's causing challenges there. Is the language training you mentioned before or after recruiting?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127594","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I appreciate that there's language training. For example, right now, I'm aware of one recruit in basic training who requires a phone to talk—to use for interpretation—in order to operate. I learned about another platoon that has five recruits who can barely speak English or French, or who can't speak them at all. It's causing challenges there. Is the language training you mentioned before or after","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","label":"Military communications","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33b03036bd1b1a444e20a2d8d79c91d92489d1119f068169741df155b495d5fa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6b96f0a2fbbf1d48006b647a1cc5a8006092f5d9e4ba31accbd6febc33c79256"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6124fa41b7fb835bc4759c01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127595,"date":"2026-04-15T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I would hope they get their language training or proficiency before getting to recruit school. Are there any challenges you can share with us in recruiting and retaining both indigenous and francophone personnel in the Canadian Forces?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127595","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would hope they get their language training or proficiency before getting to recruit school. Are there any challenges you can share with us in recruiting and retaining both indigenous and francophone personnel in the Canadian Forces?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4f4aea0a40c069b382ce0b94cbeb014cc83a28551bce3058eab8fac4d4d4f90f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b305542bbc4983c6c73c2541e714eff55db0365f1d41ca2f1db3dfb53b64771"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-740d5a97d29ad5a255ee4f34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127596,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Chair. I want to return to the French language. What percentage of military courses are not available in both languages?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127596","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. I want to return to the French language. What percentage of military courses are not available in both languages?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036294","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036294","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036294","label":"Military colleges","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d41be6d0c0f319e35e5d2c393a295e6567b798c29eaf957cbd213c4e219a4991"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d3ac2cb3bd38ce16a1417882aacd0d09c8878154aa5cf11eacf77346aea0d9ea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ed4a9c0b6dedf4ecf394a98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127597,"date":"2026-04-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"You stated that there's no limit for ranger recruiting, which is good to hear. The rangers do some excellent work for Canada. Are there plans for new specific ranger units, and might I recommend Vancouver Island?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127597","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You stated that there's no limit for ranger recruiting, which is good to hear. The rangers do some excellent work for Canada. Are there plans for new specific ranger units, and might I recommend Vancouver Island?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-655f88298efbd76fe121cfc8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127598,"date":"2026-04-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Ms. Rahming, you stated that there's no language screening prior to recruiting. You said you do psychological testing. Is that done with doctors, with psychologists? We don't do language but we do psychological testing, you stated.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127598","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Ms. Rahming, you stated that there's no language screening prior to recruiting. You said you do psychological testing. Is that done with doctors, with psychologists? We don't do language but we do psychological testing, you stated.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Deafness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","label":"Deafness","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9218b7336fd798d58a68357c802057a85d804bd90a94b09799b710f71a1fffdd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb8d8f81c7bfb9df08ceed7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127599,"date":"2026-04-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"You said you do psychological testing in the recruiting process.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127599","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You said you do psychological testing in the recruiting process.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d8129a16b195346c3ae517044bd1a649a7ae891fc6c18ce3a98b0c6059c70c6c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24f3ae8dfb58fb122ad9c1e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127600,"date":"2026-04-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you for clarifying that. My understanding is that there's no mental health screening. This ties into the retention issue, because we know that we're below our mandated effective strength for the military and not making gains. This speaks to the retention crisis. They're building, at basic training, temporary housing to facilitate quarters for people withdrawing because they have mental health challenges. They're not in training, but they're being held. Why are we holding these people and not releasing them? It speaks to this retention crisis. Maybe you could speak to that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127600","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for clarifying that. My understanding is that there's no mental health screening. This ties into the retention issue, because we know that we're below our mandated effective strength for the military and not making gains. This speaks to the retention crisis. They're building, at basic training, temporary housing to facilitate quarters for people withdrawing because they have mental healt","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ccc1299385b5828c146f919b77bbb5787c7aa47aff7fa36240fb825bcb3c26b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9255675caf8e5e5082c1c0da3a0068b2c323e98e545a40e4e9ec7295f7c8abcd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bb8a3be05129613697a3002","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127601,"date":"2026-04-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Specifically at basic training, why are we not doing mental health screening before people come into basic training? As I said, right now, there are so many people who are being released for mental health that they have to build temporary shelters just to hold all these people. Why aren't they releasing those people? Are they waiting.... Is there no support for them there? I'm not understanding what's going on. Can you speak to that, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127601","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Specifically at basic training, why are we not doing mental health screening before people come into basic training? As I said, right now, there are so many people who are being released for mental health that they have to build temporary shelters just to hold all these people. Why aren't they releasing those people? Are they waiting.... Is there no support for them there? I'm not understanding wh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01c33d48d3adca79cb8ccd873a2d98bacba3a3c14221397f17aeadb3d006623e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef6dee9c35ff5fa07aa1282b7202267f0641218dd389e6d81ae60f26700da9df"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6cd0c5bcd1025f9dd793d5dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127602,"date":"2026-04-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do they have the facility to rehabilitate them at the recruit school? Part two of that is this: My understanding is that if they haven't completed basic training at the recruit school, they have to pay their own way home. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127602","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do they have the facility to rehabilitate them at the recruit school? Part two of that is this: My understanding is that if they haven't completed basic training at the recruit school, they have to pay their own way home. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037241","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Student labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037241","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Student labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037241","label":"Student labour","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f8a0c5f737e49a65f918aa23728ea7d34dc97e190ff9e245fbb088a732f4289"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3dd60be402baff495db8d1e112796747b82496e348f1bc5f01fdcc71cc836349"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db0c3465bff9c679ffd6ca8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127603,"date":"2026-04-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Thank you for that. I'm assuming that I'm over my six minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127603","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you for that. I'm assuming that I'm over my six minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00671b52d31809aa24fe8f07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127604,"date":"2026-04-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you for your generosity, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127604","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for your generosity, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c05e3100a29081362c29cee6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127605,"date":"2026-04-15T23:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have a couple of quick questions. I will add to your comment, Lieutenant-General, about the use of the naval reserve units in Quebec. There are also naval reserve headquarters and fleet schools, so I think the navy has excellent representation. They do great work in Quebec. I want to revisit one of my earlier questions. Are there any challenges in terms of retention of francophone or indigenous members—specific to those groups? What is being done to overcome these?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127605","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have a couple of quick questions. I will add to your comment, Lieutenant-General, about the use of the naval reserve units in Quebec. There are also naval reserve headquarters and fleet schools, so I think the navy has excellent representation. They do great work in Quebec. I want to revisit one of my earlier questions. Are there any challenges in terms of retention of fran","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["956134430517334e17487a66265284752edff929c9c723f9a842f81ef1f21ef8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["57dbefda81dcdf1378cbbe8e4e1c2e31f0820c782d96707f8a4ac01112ed3698"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5cf9047147948044e24ec0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127606,"date":"2026-04-15T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"There are no specific retention issues, then, within these groups.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127606","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There are no specific retention issues, then, within these groups.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-119b61625ccaf06506da134a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127607,"date":"2026-04-15T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Good. Thank you. How many complaints does the director of official languages receive annually, regarding official language rights in the Canadian Forces? Maybe you could speak about that as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127607","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Good. Thank you. How many complaints does the director of official languages receive annually, regarding official language rights in the Canadian Forces? Maybe you could speak about that as well.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6f4e812627fa2ef8ca46d32cbcacdf144077ef43ad00bedeb28066aa1def5af"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb2ab8233817ac2f7ae627f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127608,"date":"2026-04-15T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Say it in French.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127608","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Say it in French.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-605870141222334ed1941b04","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127609,"date":"2026-04-15T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Very quickly, if I may, are there any specific programs offered for only indigenous members and made specifically for them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127609","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Very quickly, if I may, are there any specific programs offered for only indigenous members and made specifically for them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7ac5739b8659b1b58b17880e1ef8b1bbb50b7feb8f377bb694a1616618b83df"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-088d51c5cb02d4a4001be680","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127610,"date":"2026-04-15T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Are there any specific programs for indigenous members that would support their interest in joining or attract them as an important component of the forces?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127610","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are there any specific programs for indigenous members that would support their interest in joining or attract them as an important component of the forces?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e084d47fbc6d5843d0b65e10beb70639bffa511e1c82eb7d66930d0eb5db287"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b296e34b8c0221a740523da2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127611,"date":"2026-04-15T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Is it the Raven program that you're talking about?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127611","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is it the Raven program that you're talking about?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037232","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Storms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037232","label":"Storms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87fd1571a90f9161b6aed3426e542f7c503123fde84b35e451aad5157671e793"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8206133f78639e1f1b46f4c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127612,"date":"2026-04-15T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127612","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04c6b25d2aba0a567b94dedc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127613,"date":"2026-04-20T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses today. I have really appreciated the questions. I came with a list of prepared questions; however, I have taken so many notes that I hope I can get through them. The testimony has been excellent. In no particular order, I'll start with Dr. Kikkert. I liked your comment that \"We are the people to call when things go sideways\". I really appreciated that. I hope that people who are listening today, online and in the room here, take that to heart. It's a great quote. You mentioned facing barriers. You talked about them being the first resort. You mentioned your three pillars, and making things easier to use and making them the first resort. Do you have any suggestions that we could take to heart on how to make our indigenous units easier to use and a first resort?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127613","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our witnesses today. I have really appreciated the questions. I came with a list of prepared questions; however, I have taken so many notes that I hope I can get through them. The testimony has been excellent. In no particular order, I'll start with Dr. Kikkert. I liked your comment that \"We are the people to call when things go sideways\". I really appreciated th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b43e7be93fb2564ce8921e28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127614,"date":"2026-04-20T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"That leads to my second question. You mentioned streamlining activation. Are there any specific recommendations to streamline that? I can see that being a huge frustration, but it would also limit the capability to force-multiply.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127614","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That leads to my second question. You mentioned streamlining activation. Are there any specific recommendations to streamline that? I can see that being a huge frustration, but it would also limit the capability to force-multiply.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transborder data flow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Audiovisual equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037238","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Streams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037238","label":"Streams","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","label":"Transborder data flow","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","label":"Arms control","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","label":"Audiovisual equipment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0127e17d5143ce844e45adc079d491ac94babef967f2e7d23ea56a25598d0a39"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af89e635793765e7bfacaaa6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127615,"date":"2026-04-20T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Joint rescue coordination centres are often the ones that activate them. Do you feel there needs to be better communication and understanding between JRCCs and the ranger groups?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127615","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Joint rescue coordination centres are often the ones that activate them. Do you feel there needs to be better communication and understanding between JRCCs and the ranger groups?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","label":"Military training","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e58e7e4d1266f0b579287ff6253f4cd3e1122926b8ac65fe5bb869de4448850b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-997b98c3b9039db696327b95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127616,"date":"2026-04-20T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. My next question is for Ms. Teillet. I appreciate the military history background. It's very important to have those stories in the more modern military. You said that attitudes have shifted significantly, and I'm glad to hear that. I think that probably more work needs to be done. You gave an excellent example of two indigenous members who came back from Afghanistan. You said that they were \"well looked after\". I'm very happy to hear that. That, to me, is the type of story that should be spread among people to support recruiting. What improvements would you recommend, such as those types of stories being shared, and what methods? Would they be more traditional methods of sharing that information or more modern methods for getting that positive information out as we continue to improve culture and try to recruit more indigenous members to these units?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127616","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. My next question is for Ms. Teillet. I appreciate the military history background. It's very important to have those stories in the more modern military. You said that attitudes have shifted significantly, and I'm glad to hear that. I think that probably more work needs to be done. You gave an excellent example of two indigenous members who came back from Afghanistan. You said that they","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c3e4a4c8f00a139c73f0b929cda2169975afb7b28e34a42ea1572f77c1d5c470"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1fdef4b5c25e7f1cde6aa5a5fcd964c10ef8bfefbe4e12edfcf1893d89f2ed45"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7e2f2f12d65a9c6b92250a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127617,"date":"2026-04-20T17:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes. We're looking at ways to improve so that indigenous people want to join. If we look at the more modern stories, are those a tool that we could use so things are more positive as we continue to improve culture?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127617","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes. We're looking at ways to improve so that indigenous people want to join. If we look at the more modern stories, are those a tool that we could use so things are more positive as we continue to improve culture?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bac29fa982d594e76736e63e0918180eb947360b52999ec2d047b20dc3d7bc91"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8de4fb1d92afd564fc2bb041","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127618,"date":"2026-04-20T17:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. I'd need another 30 to 40 minutes for all of my questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127618","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I'd need another 30 to 40 minutes for all of my questions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-509aa21959588a29fb12bf6d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127619,"date":"2026-04-20T17:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127619","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd38382804fc0851822ccbf3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127620,"date":"2026-04-20T17:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My first question is for Dr. Scoppio. You said that you agree it's not a problem of attracting; it's rather about recruiting and retention. I like that comment. I couldn't agree more. We've seen some significant issues with recruiting at the schools right now, but I appreciate that you also gave a very specific recommendation—we've been speaking in broad terms—and I would like to explore that a bit. You said that guidelines for family members of indigenous members are not inclusive. How could that be corrected? This was in reference to supports for returning to funerals and other medical emergencies. Could you expand on that a bit so we can learn and have more information about it to potentially make it more inclusive? I think that's a very positive suggestion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127620","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My first question is for Dr. Scoppio. You said that you agree it's not a problem of attracting; it's rather about recruiting and retention. I like that comment. I couldn't agree more. We've seen some significant issues with recruiting at the schools right now, but I appreciate that you also gave a very specific recommendation—we've been speaking in broad terms—and I would lik","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-738800b9c6a2dd6cb7cadd06","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127621,"date":"2026-04-20T17:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"What—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127621","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a953d5775e3ed4e3d1b93d72","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127622,"date":"2026-04-20T17:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I was going to say that if you had other out-of-the-box suggestions that would help alleviate differences between culture, that would support improved recruiting. Maybe you could submit some written suggestions to the committee that would be actual, tangible items. You've given one. I know that for a family, normally it's considered for \"immediate family members\", but there are provisions to allow it if you can prove that somebody, like an aunt, is a primary family member. I would like to move on to your comment about permanent residents. We said we were at 3.3% indigenous members in the forces. You said we needed more permanent residents. Could you speak to that in terms of a percentage that you think would be reasonable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127622","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I was going to say that if you had other out-of-the-box suggestions that would help alleviate differences between culture, that would support improved recruiting. Maybe you could submit some written suggestions to the committee that would be actual, tangible items. You've given one. I know that for a family, normally it's considered for \"immediate family members\", but there are provisions to allow","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-974bb521de25482ef1ab1032","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127623,"date":"2026-04-20T17:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Off the top of your head, do you have a recommendation? Do you think we should be at 100% permanent residents in the military, or 5% or 2%?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127623","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Off the top of your head, do you have a recommendation? Do you think we should be at 100% permanent residents in the military, or 5% or 2%?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","label":"Military law","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66a3e97465a40c912aafb834d8086c9b7247fcc03fcabad62c5c508810c0bd57"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c927c47281d718000d4576d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127624,"date":"2026-04-20T17:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I can tell you that right now we're at about 20% of permanent residents at the recruiting schools.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127624","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I can tell you that right now we're at about 20% of permanent residents at the recruiting schools.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["893b3e114333829d0b633de2c14e32d92782d1a4d99bba88bc7e043d71e00680"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-536499b58b67deb9fe1e4504","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127625,"date":"2026-04-20T17:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Right now in the recruiting schools, on course, they're at about 20% permanent residents.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127625","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Right now in the recruiting schools, on course, they're at about 20% permanent residents.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1571bf2a8b0f2796dd6ac50409848ff9b6c9c5393cd3c3c3651349729a7b2747"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd1879ccece6fd156d86b09b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127626,"date":"2026-04-20T17:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. I didn't hear a recommendation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127626","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I didn't hear a recommendation.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d547c6c34903c9f62dbcf9a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127627,"date":"2026-04-20T17:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you for your discussion on this. I'd like to move to Dr. Lackenbauer. I appreciate your enthusiasm for the rangers. It's a little overwhelming. I've worked with the rangers. They certainly are an inspiring group, and they're well respected within the military. Can you expand a bit on your comment about how they can be part of the reconciliation process within a community? How could they help with that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127627","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for your discussion on this. I'd like to move to Dr. Lackenbauer. I appreciate your enthusiasm for the rangers. It's a little overwhelming. I've worked with the rangers. They certainly are an inspiring group, and they're well respected within the military. Can you expand a bit on your comment about how they can be part of the reconciliation process within a community? How could they help","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1f569e771eb9988bfe8d9a92820d180cedf68b54a2c2666903009c40cf034ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f2b15e23ef8dae154724087","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127628,"date":"2026-04-20T17:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm from south Vancouver Island. I live very close to the 4th Canadian Ranger Patrol Group headquarters. I've worked with rangers. I've worked with the Raven program. We have a large first nations population where I'm from. I'd love to see expanded ranger units on Vancouver Island. Are there steps the communities could take with the Canadian Forces or others to encourage expanding ranger units locally?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127628","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm from south Vancouver Island. I live very close to the 4th Canadian Ranger Patrol Group headquarters. I've worked with rangers. I've worked with the Raven program. We have a large first nations population where I'm from. I'd love to see expanded ranger units on Vancouver Island. Are there steps the communities could take with the Canadian Forces or others to encourage expanding ranger units loc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0eeb8bb80033ea032e00fb2d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127629,"date":"2026-04-20T17:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. No one is saying that—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127629","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. No one is saying that—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb111c8218849518f669a267","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127630,"date":"2026-04-20T17:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127630","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7328d042972d1565c76d3b53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127631,"date":"2026-04-22T22:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. Mr. Maisonneuve, you spoke kindly about people who do what I'm doing, but forgive me, I'm going to speak to you in English today. I also want to say that I will be studying in Quebec this summer for two weeks. Now I will continue in English. I had the pleasure of meeting you in Hamilton at the CPCOE symposium. I agree with you that bilingualism is an important factor of leadership. I agree that this should apply to all rank levels. You mentioned this, but do you feel every rank level should be bilingual immediately or at some point in the training process? I know we explored this a bit earlier.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127631","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Maisonneuve, you spoke kindly about people who do what I'm doing, but forgive me, I'm going to speak to you in English today. I also want to say that I will be studying in Quebec this summer for two weeks. Now I will continue in English. I had the pleasure of meeting you in Hamilton at the CPCOE symposium. I agree with you that bilingualism is an important factor of leadership. I ag","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["51748bad61a289789865a74a1436b2b99c2a138d5df4ce381f8da5235fd9f4d5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f808691848476f891e9ad7540acf7ac535137cf072d7652bdcd25dd768f4b437"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ba96c13f124298cd45ef120","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127632,"date":"2026-04-22T22:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm going to jump in. I want to talk a little bit about what you said about meritocracy within the framework of French and English, and I agree. Did you agree with the current policy in recruitment where recruits are no longer screened for language skills in either official language?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127632","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm going to jump in. I want to talk a little bit about what you said about meritocracy within the framework of French and English, and I agree. Did you agree with the current policy in recruitment where recruits are no longer screened for language skills in either official language?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083651","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083651","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Language minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083651","label":"Language minorities","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6cd8553fd471bb026f759d89c537e2c44ec6b48b74d80c1c6acd9fdaa9dd6aa5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0a68c83eddb3e427b4d635b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127633,"date":"2026-04-22T22:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Are you aware right now that about 20% of the permanent residents are not being screened, and the majority struggle speaking either official language? In a meritocracy, maybe you could speak to the impact this would have on capacity, respect and on the institution. You said it was very important within the framework of French and English. Would you agree also it's not just both languages, but any language?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127633","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are you aware right now that about 20% of the permanent residents are not being screened, and the majority struggle speaking either official language? In a meritocracy, maybe you could speak to the impact this would have on capacity, respect and on the institution. You said it was very important within the framework of French and English. Would you agree also it's not just both languages, but any ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6912e0107d0df41b53e5089","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127634,"date":"2026-04-22T22:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I just want to quickly get to Madam Le Scelleur. Yes, you're right about getting personnel through. In recruiting they've announced wonderful numbers, but those are only for the people entering the system, and about 25% of them are being lost through training issues through the system, so there's a big challenge there. Madam Le Scelleur, I would like to thank you for sharing your story. Very quickly, on the support that you received while you were in the military, not just in theatre, could you make a quick comment on whether you got the services in English and French as you preferred? Also, is that continuing now that you are with Veterans Affairs? I'm aware you're now a veteran. Are you able to access services in your preferred language through their process? Thank you for your service and your answer. I think I'm out of time after that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127634","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I just want to quickly get to Madam Le Scelleur. Yes, you're right about getting personnel through. In recruiting they've announced wonderful numbers, but those are only for the people entering the system, and about 25% of them are being lost through training issues through the system, so there's a big challenge there. Madam Le Scelleur, I would like to thank you for sharing your story. Very quick","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3634c46e4a475e58cee7834f8d41212d5e2e4baa6313c5ad67445bebf04aaa1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3929412eea5c8c26a9b407b4aebfb9b0fb232046b997ebfc16091bbc7776f196"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-300312370dd82b1c366fc8c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127635,"date":"2026-04-22T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Mr. Sauvé, in your statement earlier, you said that approximately 40% and possibly as high as 90% of CF members are seeking mental health support. Are you aware that recruits now are no longer screened for mental health? What impact do you think this will have on training going forward?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127635","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Sauvé, in your statement earlier, you said that approximately 40% and possibly as high as 90% of CF members are seeking mental health support. Are you aware that recruits now are no longer screened for mental health? What impact do you think this will have on training going forward?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b8c30383eb32b22dbabf0f9619381627cda9a9113be1239d8ca917294b2a0252"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67ecd3e17e3f8e9803e549c3c21aa7bcb6534fadd8e576a0b6ca6cdaeb1d2456"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-152438e7de2e56b49f9d330b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127636,"date":"2026-04-22T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. General Maisonneuve, could you comment on the impact as well? I appreciate that this can certainly be treated, but we're sending people into recruit school who don't have mental health training. What is the impact, in your opinion? In that statement about meritocracy—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127636","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. General Maisonneuve, could you comment on the impact as well? I appreciate that this can certainly be treated, but we're sending people into recruit school who don't have mental health training. What is the impact, in your opinion? In that statement about meritocracy—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0df78fa5305f3c08ccba770aa7d07c19a4dabb6ac6f05e3de3175b54a4181f8b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f48c35329369c2f74168ca8cba4867bafa0449f4094529d404b8d2a9301aea7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c30aa29268f2116d30988a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127637,"date":"2026-04-22T23:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm going to jump in because Mr. Bezan has a question, but thank you for your comments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127637","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm going to jump in because Mr. Bezan has a question, but thank you for your comments.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75b1dbb50d356794006dd9e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301256,"date":"2026-04-23T15:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague from Selkirk—Interlake—Eastman for the incredible work he has done in committee respecting victims of military sexual trauma, and the work he is doing to rectify the problems there.\n\nWe heard testimony from civilian police forces that they had significantly limited capacity, sometimes enough to deal with two to three cases of major sexual assault, whereas in their areas, they have data saying that there have been 15, 17 or 20 cases per year. Could the hon. member speak to the capacity of civilian police forces to deal with these cases, and to what would happen with those cases they have no capability to deal with?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301256","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague from Selkirk—Interlake—Eastman for the incredible work he has done in committee respecting victims of military sexual trauma, and the work he is doing to rectify the problems there.\n\nWe heard testimony from civilian police forces that they had significantly limited capacity, sometimes enough to deal with two to three cases of major sexual assault, wh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ba9071d3bb21209bddf5148af09f945eb74ae01d52093b6f507f5111a3f48e4f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e39e3a0aa9952980a8c76ec4f518ec437211bc069177bddd7ef0fc48e11a5e13"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0453cbb2801b69b267489f66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301257,"date":"2026-04-23T17:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her thoughtful and heartfelt words.\n\nWe may hear the party opposite continually refer to the Arbour report, yet much has changed since then, such as the mandatory duty to report and access to the SMSRC. Military members at that time did not have access to victim liaison services or independent legal support.\n\n I was wondering if my colleague could explain why the party opposite continues to refer to the report of Justice Arbour's, who did not testify at committee, and has failed to refer to the Deschamps and Fish reports, which supported that choice for military sexual trauma.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301257","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her thoughtful and heartfelt words.\n\nWe may hear the party opposite continually refer to the Arbour report, yet much has changed since then, such as the mandatory duty to report and access to the SMSRC. Military members at that time did not have access to victim liaison services or independent legal support.\n\n I was wondering if my colleague could explain why ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["13a07510e39115ad3c6bf59d9e255a0196dd4ba7038768d6c41c7b4d8bc5b731"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["212b677f08341fe7c983f6a9c0296d58a27d5c5f2dbfcd9dbdc2181b13df2a5e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fad9e1acc2db87d983424360","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301258,"date":"2026-04-23T18:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, while the member opposite may feel that those definitions are distasteful, there are legal definitions and requirements for levels of sexual assault, and frankly put, the civilian police authorities will not deal with mid and lower levels. They do not have the capacity. It is outside the jurisdiction.\n\nDoes the member opposite feel that predators will have a free pass because they know mid- and lower-level sexual assaults will never be dealt with? They are not within the plan of Bill C-11. This has never been addressed.\n\nWhat is your solution to have mid- and lower-level sexual assaults addressed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301258","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, while the member opposite may feel that those definitions are distasteful, there are legal definitions and requirements for levels of sexual assault, and frankly put, the civilian police authorities will not deal with mid and lower levels. They do not have the capacity. It is outside the jurisdiction.\n\nDoes the member opposite feel that predators will have a free pass because they kno","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["654dda483151e1b9d96df814ffb3efdf59d403a76f660e75d717abf5956d6c39"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["037d88b41e482fd1a349fd98b46f94c6ce2c99cba13dc4d440be1e41e49ea2f9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d21c08cca29f281b6c8c766a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301259,"date":"2026-04-23T18:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise with a heavy heart, but I also rise with a profound sense of duty, a duty shaped by nearly three decades in uniform, by the survivors who trusted me with their stories and by the communities I represent. I rise not for partisanship, not for theatre, but for the people who have carried burdens far heavier than any of us in this chamber will ever know.\n\nI dedicate my words today to the many active members and veterans I have met across Vancouver Island and across Canada. I have spoken with them in legion halls, on bases, in community centres and sometimes in the quiet corners where people finally feel safe enough to share what they have carried for too long. Most importantly, I dedicate my words to the survivors of military sexual trauma who came to committee.\n\nBefore I go any further, I would like to speak to them directly. They were not obligated to share what they shared. They did not owe us their stories, their pain and their truth, yet they came anyway, carrying memories no one should ever have to carry, because they believed that if Parliament finally listened, something might change for the better. They trusted us with the hardest part of their lives, and that trust is something I will not take lightly. It is not something any of us should take lightly. They asked for one thing: choice. They asked not for privilege, not for special treatment, just the basic human right to choose the justice system where they feel safest, can be heard and can be understood. They asked overwhelmingly, consistently and with courage, and I will not stand by while that courage is dismissed.\n\nI also rise today on behalf of all Canadians who expect their institutions to protect the vulnerable, not retraumatize them. I also rise on behalf of the people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, where I live and which I have the privilege of representing in the House. It is a region with a proud and deep connection to our Canadian Armed Forces. Our communities include many veterans, many serving members and many families whose lives are directly shaped by the culture and conduct of the military.\n\nMy riding is home to countless individuals who serve or have served at Canadian Forces Base Esquimalt, one of the largest military installations in the country. It is a base where my wife and I both proudly served, a base that shaped our lives, our understanding of service and our understanding of the sacrifices that military families make every single day. When I speak about this bill, I do not speak in the abstract. I speak for the people I represent and the communities I know. I speak for those who have worn the uniform and those who still do. I speak for survivors across Vancouver Island and across Canada, survivors who trusted us in Parliament to listen.\n\nI served nearly three decades in uniform. I was trained as a presiding officer, and I believed I understood the culture of the Canadian Forces, but nothing prepared me for what I learned after meeting my wife, who is also a survivor of military sexual trauma. Through her, I saw parts of our institution that too many never see, or refuse to see. I saw the cost of silence. I saw the cost of inaction. Since I first joined the navy in the 1980s, the culture around sexual misconduct has changed. Yes, there have been positive improvements, but there is still much more to do.\n\nIf Bill C-11 proceeds without the amendments survivors asked for, without the choices they pleaded for, then not only will we undo decades of progress, but we will reverse them. We will make things worse than we can imagine. At the very heart of the debate is something very simple: choice, the choice for survivors to access either the civilian or the military justice system. It is a choice that already exists, though too few know about it.\n\n What we have before us now is a tale of two approaches. On our side of the committee, we have the testimony of survivors, victims, military police, police and legal experts, those who have lived this reality. Their message was overwhelmingly consistent and deeply human. It was, \"Do not take away our choice.\" On the Liberal side is a plan that ignores the evidence, cherry-picks a few quotes and uses one report while ignoring many others and the voices of so many. It dismisses the voices of survivors and disrespects those who came forward at great personal cost.\n\n If the government removes these amendments, the consequences will be immediate and unavoidable. There will be institutional trauma and revictimization. There will be anger, despair and a profound sense of betrayal among the survivors who trusted all of us to listen and do right by them. Minor cases will go unaddressed. Major cases will go untried. Civilian police forces, already stretched thin, already under-resourced, will be handed cases they have repeatedly said they cannot absorb. They will take on only the most serious of sexual assault cases.\n\n As for the mid-level and lesser cases, they are outside civilian jurisdiction or capability. There is no plan in Bill C-11 to address those cases. There is nothing. This is a complete failure for future victims but will be seen as a free pass to predators. Members can let that sink in. The government will point to low numbers in the military system and claim success. They are already doing it in the House today. However, only a few major cases will go forward, and the rest will be unreported and unactioned. This is not accountability, and it is not reform. Simply put, this is not justice. This is burying the problem, handing it off and burying the people who trusted us to fix it.\n\n I must also address the role of the press. The mainstream media, funded by 1.4 billion taxpayer dollars, has primarily focused on attacking the opposition party and has not covered the survivors' testimony, the amendments we achieved together and the consequences of removing those amendments. Today I challenge the press, directly, to tell this story, interview the survivors, report what they said and explain what is at stake. That is its job. Canadians deserve to know the truth, not the Liberal talking points.\n\nRemoving choices removes protections. The Liberals have been relying solely on the Arbour report, by someone who refused to testify in committee, and yet have failed to mention the Fish and Deschamps reports, which both speak to the benefits of choice for victims.\n\n I want to speak quickly on something I witnessed in committee, something that has stayed with me. As survivors shared their stories, as they spoke about trauma they endured and offered solutions rooted in courage, I looked across the table to members of the party opposite, and I saw a colleague begin to tear up. I saw his humanity. I saw someone who understood deeply the weight of what survivors are telling us.\n\n I say this to every member in the House, especially those with family who serve in the military, maybe their sons or daughters: They must hold on to that humanity. They must not let partisanship smother what was felt in that moment. They must not let party discipline override what they know in their hearts to be right.\n\n Survivors did not come to us as partisans. They came to us as human beings. They asked all of us to do right by them. Emotions must now be matched with action. Compassion must now be matched with courage. We must listen to the overwhelming evidence of survivors and experts, consider all reports and give survivors the freedom of choice.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301259","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise with a heavy heart, but I also rise with a profound sense of duty, a duty shaped by nearly three decades in uniform, by the survivors who trusted me with their stories and by the communities I represent. I rise not for partisanship, not for theatre, but for the people who have carried burdens far heavier than any of us in this chamber will ever know.\n\nI dedicate my words ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3ed3468c20da9b88b6c7cd697b972059a76af675bbb37197bb854ba6ddaa41a7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5e8bb8376929d21a45d3584e5ddcc082b76669f7546a87e9440a29b75718b262"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93496ef95daa340e3aee8eed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301260,"date":"2026-04-23T18:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, again, the Arbour report did not look at what is in Bill C-11, which simply would leave the majority of sexual assault cases undealt with, unreported and unactioned. It is not even in Bill C-11. Therefore, regardless of what the Arbour report says or all of the other reports, the majority of victims and reports support choice. \n\nBill C-11 and the Liberal Party would fail our military in the future. As I directly pointed out, the majority of cases would go unresolved, unreported and unactioned, and that is an embarrassing failure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301260","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, again, the Arbour report did not look at what is in Bill C-11, which simply would leave the majority of sexual assault cases undealt with, unreported and unactioned. It is not even in Bill C-11. Therefore, regardless of what the Arbour report says or all of the other reports, the majority of victims and reports support choice. \n\nBill C-11 and the Liberal Party would fail our military ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["54932a6e18027cc626d0179e4f91c45dab326bea7760de13745dffc746579214"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b19841da8641cccd1db93a2b474a848ad3f09d07dd45bf028c2e830bfbecc17a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-044c5d483d206e3b3e77a3ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301261,"date":"2026-04-23T18:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for all the amazing work he has done over the many years. \n\nSimply put, yes, it will retraumatize them. I started receiving numerous phone calls last night. They came flooding in. It will retraumatize victims now and in the future. Simply put, the amendments that we have put forward would make this work. The victims want the choice, and we are supporting them based on fact, emotion and support. Clearly, a bill that would not address the majority of sexual assault cases and let them go unresolved would be a partisan decision that no sane human would vote for.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301261","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for all the amazing work he has done over the many years. \n\nSimply put, yes, it will retraumatize them. I started receiving numerous phone calls last night. They came flooding in. It will retraumatize victims now and in the future. Simply put, the amendments that we have put forward would make this work. The victims want the choice, and we are supporting them base","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["054bf2ac2393b148a5aec7267d4dd4e22d64f0c5d41b0606ce109832892d8b5c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39e1ddb96ec3c5175525e524","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301262,"date":"2026-04-23T18:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am not going to get into the legal definitions of the various levels. It was delved into in-depth and, as distasteful as it may sound, unfortunately, it is the legal reality that we have to have those levels. \n\nOnly the most serious cases, if there is capacity for them in the civilian system, would be dealt with. The rest would be buried, would not be actioned and would disappear. That is failure, yet burying the truth would be touted as the Liberals' great success.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301262","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am not going to get into the legal definitions of the various levels. It was delved into in-depth and, as distasteful as it may sound, unfortunately, it is the legal reality that we have to have those levels. \n\nOnly the most serious cases, if there is capacity for them in the civilian system, would be dealt with. The rest would be buried, would not be actioned and would disappear. T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ffb5a81fcc3b6f4c470583f44270173ca0c1481b11cb59a32f684f5d55ea28a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa0a481cd6add7677b7e2d45","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301255,"date":"2026-04-24T17:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there are over 12 illegal garbage dumps in the Cowichan Valley, many on Cowichan tribes' land. Some are so large they will take years to remediate. Others are polluting the salmon-bearing Cowichan River. For decades, authorities at all levels have turned a blind eye to this environmental disaster and ongoing illegal dumping.\n\nI wrote a letter to the Minister of Indigenous Services weeks ago demanding that the Liberals identify authorities at all levels, hold them responsible for this travesty and take action immediately. There was no response from the minister, no action and no cleanup.\n\n The Liberals claim to be stewards of our land. Is this just another Liberal illusion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301255","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there are over 12 illegal garbage dumps in the Cowichan Valley, many on Cowichan tribes' land. Some are so large they will take years to remediate. Others are polluting the salmon-bearing Cowichan River. For decades, authorities at all levels have turned a blind eye to this environmental disaster and ongoing illegal dumping.\n\nI wrote a letter to the Minister of Indigenous Services wee","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44186","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Blindness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44186","label":"Blindness","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d02da4a56dbcc1ee12cfb54826f1cd7cce3e1cfa12f04921a86de0ddb43e4a7c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["184c5bc31627c76f3bc8f7a556c7dd44d8c516ed6702152e35d1b6ba6925152c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d8b1a2340abed9472e67353","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127638,"date":"2026-04-27T16:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My questions are for Mr. Guzman. Afterwards, if you could submit the address of your Toronto office, that would be excellent. I'm sure you understand that submarines are highly classified, intelligence-gathering vessels. With your limited defence and military background, what specific steps have you taken to build operational knowledge of defence capability requirements and to understand the strategic threats to the procurement process of these sensitive vessels? Specifically, have you been briefed by CSIS, CSE or others on this file?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127638","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My questions are for Mr. Guzman. Afterwards, if you could submit the address of your Toronto office, that would be excellent. I'm sure you understand that submarines are highly classified, intelligence-gathering vessels. With your limited defence and military background, what specific steps have you taken to build operational knowledge of defence capability requirements and t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4d77cae73fc9bd5972457b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127639,"date":"2026-04-27T16:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"The question is for you. Have you been briefed by CSIS or CSE on the sensitivities of the information gathered and on threat assessments in the procurement process?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127639","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The question is for you. Have you been briefed by CSIS or CSE on the sensitivities of the information gathered and on threat assessments in the procurement process?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["27b5326d4cb851430676fdde243b389b40675afd9e03118d3db3a6ccbb2a2699"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b7c5b638a1ebe32d3e2d2fc8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127640,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Were they from CSIS and CSE? Who were they from?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127640","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Were they from CSIS and CSE? Who were they from?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b139e5b373c88db990f6f922","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127641,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"They were specifically from DND.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127641","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"They were specifically from DND.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc6d73b52e317a9a724a6219","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127642,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. I reviewed the RFI for the submarine project, and—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127642","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I reviewed the RFI for the submarine project, and—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035583","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine installations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035583","label":"Marine installations","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","label":"Nuclear technology","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24f8fb000e9bd2c0d515a1fc5abbe88d3aea96add798e1b601024e70fba3944e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f08430f42f5e75c5d333a7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127643,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Sure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127643","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Sure.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac5cec17e9d05619111c1924","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127644,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. I reviewed the RFI for the submarine project. For the navigation and submarine warfare system itself, it's left open for the prime to define. Why not have a Canadian company in the RFI?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127644","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I reviewed the RFI for the submarine project. For the navigation and submarine warfare system itself, it's left open for the prime to define. Why not have a Canadian company in the RFI?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71c114efe9bec381ad883c1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127645,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Why would you not have a Canadian company do it? We already have a Canadian company with Canadian IP that does all the navigation and submarine warfare systems for our navy presently, some for our Coast Guard, and for 27 NATO and allied navies. Why would that not...? It seems to be a no-brainer. Will you commit to putting our Canadian-owned IP into the submarine project?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127645","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Why would you not have a Canadian company do it? We already have a Canadian company with Canadian IP that does all the navigation and submarine warfare systems for our navy presently, some for our Coast Guard, and for 27 NATO and allied navies. Why would that not...? It seems to be a no-brainer. Will you commit to putting our Canadian-owned IP into the submarine project?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07750b0c6872cde2c98a6426","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127646,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127646","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a599c1f683bc62d4b6ace202","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127647,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I appreciate that, but—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127647","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I appreciate that, but—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-377818114d802743b46fffa4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127648,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm not hearing a commitment. I'd like to move on to my next question, if I could. Thank you. Your RBC biography was, strangely, deleted online when you took this job. It stated that, as head of RBC, you provided coverage for high net-worth families, corporations, institutions and governments. You were also at Goldman Sachs in the global metal and mining section, where you worked with the Prime Minister . Were any of the files you handled connected with Chinese state-owned enterprises or entities listed in OFAC, OSFI or allied registries? Have you disclosed these and any other high net-worth clients? Have you been screened for conflicts with identified hostile states?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127648","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm not hearing a commitment. I'd like to move on to my next question, if I could. Thank you. Your RBC biography was, strangely, deleted online when you took this job. It stated that, as head of RBC, you provided coverage for high net-worth families, corporations, institutions and governments. You were also at Goldman Sachs in the global metal and mining section, where you worked with the Prime Mi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9aa2e9a4ee7aeb8b2c7fd087eeb375642549208c1fdfb85ec9c782b2e435bcc6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd18e3795992b5898b31dd50","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127649,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"It's not typical for this to happen. Normally, they wait a fair bit longer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127649","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's not typical for this to happen. Normally, they wait a fair bit longer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ce7a62e44a8fe7d2a688e50","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127650,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do you feel you should be screened for those connections, then? It sounds like you haven't had—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127650","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you feel you should be screened for those connections, then? It sounds like you haven't had—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b038f4f69c9f12b4a6e60008d3304ee6c96494e37cb37c5c5c7ccec0391ef1b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc552daf9d2ee29d2ab26eda","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127651,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"It's not ethics. It's security screening. This is about national security and intelligence gathering that—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127651","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's not ethics. It's security screening. This is about national security and intelligence gathering that—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","label":"Security intelligence","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["37e48cd061e71c3f8e13df63e951c37c32dd7c79922907eab37cb167eecbbdfa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a9186a84c25b0955cb7712f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127652,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"You haven't been screened yet, though. That's what I—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127652","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You haven't been screened yet, though. That's what I—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca08b8a354c30855bd90ea89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127653,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"You have been. There seems to be a lot of confusion. This is pretty important information—security screening. Maybe you could get back to the committee with a written answer to what steps have been taken for security screening. I want to move on to the recent secret MOU the RCMP and China's Ministry of Public Security signed. It's been called a \"counterintelligence danger\" by former senior RCMP members. Were you briefed on the content of this MOU before it was signed? If not, how can we evaluate the role in terms of law enforcement information-sharing arrangements with adversarial states? Does this create vectors for intelligence penetration into the work the DIA is supposed to do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127653","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You have been. There seems to be a lot of confusion. This is pretty important information—security screening. Maybe you could get back to the committee with a written answer to what steps have been taken for security screening. I want to move on to the recent secret MOU the RCMP and China's Ministry of Public Security signed. It's been called a \"counterintelligence danger\" by former senior RCMP me","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["106055b8583882ff4aa478540213873e7ae41a83854c5cb4ffc91dbbad39cfff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-435e39541f267b45d3fced6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127654,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127654","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccd3998cbb3411422c81edd9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127655,"date":"2026-04-27T17:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate that. Mr. Guzman, is there a firewall between Canada's new bilateral finance engagement with the Chinese Communist Party and the DIA's financial network?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127655","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate that. Mr. Guzman, is there a firewall between Canada's new bilateral finance engagement with the Chinese Communist Party and the DIA's financial network?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","label":"International finance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["433222fb67b95c9847dd38da0278271063000f1a4886b986a2991473dbf9e501"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-717778c4bbd4bb945b58d3d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127656,"date":"2026-04-27T17:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do you think there should be?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127656","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you think there should be?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1eaad20a117f6814a4445fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127657,"date":"2026-04-27T17:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Almost every major platform in your procurement portfolio runs exclusively on Taiwanese semiconductors, a single point of failure. I appreciate that this can't be addressed in the short term, but has DIA modelled this dependency? Do you also feel that the recently signed one China policy that Canada reaffirmed will affect the DIA's ability to engage directly with Taiwanese defence technology companies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127657","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Almost every major platform in your procurement portfolio runs exclusively on Taiwanese semiconductors, a single point of failure. I appreciate that this can't be addressed in the short term, but has DIA modelled this dependency? Do you also feel that the recently signed one China policy that Canada reaffirmed will affect the DIA's ability to engage directly with Taiwanese defence technology compa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a48a7b2c18c5ea7615e5c1dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127658,"date":"2026-04-27T17:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's fair enough. Thank you. Secretary Fuhr said that Canada is \"last to the party\" regarding establishing a dedicated procurement body. We're here now. Have you done a written comparative analysis of the U.K.'s, Australia's or France's defence procurement agencies in looking at differences and areas to replicate, strengths we can adapt here in Canada or weaknesses to look for?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127658","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's fair enough. Thank you. Secretary Fuhr said that Canada is \"last to the party\" regarding establishing a dedicated procurement body. We're here now. Have you done a written comparative analysis of the U.K.'s, Australia's or France's defence procurement agencies in looking at differences and areas to replicate, strengths we can adapt here in Canada or weaknesses to look for?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8fd2a0183458f3fe911c6c9ab91f099286fafd48910a06c6d26ecd77024d9fe4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e98269cb79475b76fe52dd72bf911e1f6bf78b381ab982d942fcd49bcce2d6d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee90a66fcd4f971a2fb7d4fd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127659,"date":"2026-04-27T17:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"No, I absolutely—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127659","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, I absolutely—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-970f0d7b6c9d98e9c965e2a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127660,"date":"2026-04-27T17:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. That's excellent. I look forward to that. Will you commit to a semi-annual appearance before the committee during the duration of your three-year mandate to update us on whether you're on track, the gaps and the performance and just share your lovely demeanor with us here in committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127660","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. That's excellent. I look forward to that. Will you commit to a semi-annual appearance before the committee during the duration of your three-year mandate to update us on whether you're on track, the gaps and the performance and just share your lovely demeanor with us here in committee?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e357ce933c6c15f75bb3dc89d41b1481ba97b8949ebbe922aa21591470bf3ce2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd980b67f968f097920d8719","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127661,"date":"2026-04-27T17:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Well, I'm asking you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127661","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Well, I'm asking you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a69aab9368568e535538341","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127662,"date":"2026-04-27T17:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"China has been identified by CSIS and Five Eyes partners as actively pursuing acquisition of Canadian technology, IP, etc., in all sectors that are relevant to the DIA's mandate. Under what circumstances will the DIA flag supplier relationships? I'm not talking just about primary, but secondary and tertiary contracts, and the relationship to CSIS or the Investment Canada Act national security review process. Who in your organization will trigger that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127662","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"China has been identified by CSIS and Five Eyes partners as actively pursuing acquisition of Canadian technology, IP, etc., in all sectors that are relevant to the DIA's mandate. Under what circumstances will the DIA flag supplier relationships? I'm not talking just about primary, but secondary and tertiary contracts, and the relationship to CSIS or the Investment Canada Act national security revi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["406da118f9fcae1f73d23baff18b7066a08d2703fa08580e552d3e52849727fb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3903274802423acafe53e4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127663,"date":"2026-04-27T17:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"You can answer this first and then go to the other place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127663","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You can answer this first and then go to the other place.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","label":"Explorations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d1151e8312395b28e3601c52c8bd1eba8a8a7ffb266e38aeffe335096dcb809"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b26ac2a44a599065292d916c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127664,"date":"2026-04-27T17:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes, absolutely.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127664","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, absolutely.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33c033ba399778369d525c60","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127665,"date":"2026-04-27T17:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's fair, and I appreciate your understanding of it. Is there a dedicated team, then, within your organization to flag that and point that out?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127665","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's fair, and I appreciate your understanding of it. Is there a dedicated team, then, within your organization to flag that and point that out?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["44dd99418eabfe61c3b766da414c18cb22b889969718522225569ce52a082097"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f64a808a402eb1a617ebee9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127666,"date":"2026-04-27T17:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"You're taking it into consideration, but are you committing to having a team that's going to be dedicated to doing that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127666","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You're taking it into consideration, but are you committing to having a team that's going to be dedicated to doing that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["828c68f366080e66f729cdc6fa548b9e91fe2eea095a19c188ed74e62258140d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c519d442da02d6f341417a15","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127667,"date":"2026-04-27T17:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Does the DIA have a dedicated legal counsel for ITAR and import control expertise embedded into the team?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127667","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Does the DIA have a dedicated legal counsel for ITAR and import control expertise embedded into the team?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2dff16c5f52f9b526801c280ac14f0c4a870885883c5f1559490c80ac373c0a4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08ba38031e4813fc97645606","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127668,"date":"2026-04-27T17:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. I have one last question, if I have time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127668","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I have one last question, if I have time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9cc626670756e35a2696e4fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127669,"date":"2026-04-27T17:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"The U.K.'s National Audit Office produces an annual analysis that flags cost overruns and capability gaps, etc., to identify them before they can become a public scandal. The PBO has a more limited mandate for real-time audits of capital programs. Would you commit today to supporting an annual independent capability audit—not just a financial audit—of whether your programs are delivering the capability? This would be, say, to Parliament for programs exceeding $1 billion, which is your mandate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127669","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The U.K.'s National Audit Office produces an annual analysis that flags cost overruns and capability gaps, etc., to identify them before they can become a public scandal. The PBO has a more limited mandate for real-time audits of capital programs. Would you commit today to supporting an annual independent capability audit—not just a financial audit—of whether your programs are delivering the capab","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d246b61cf0e1247be0d3e1eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728590,"date":"2026-04-27T19:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have signalled their intent to remove collaborative amendments to Bill C‐11 dealing with military sexual assault, amendments that survivors asked for and experts supported overwhelmingly. The Liberals are about to single-handedly undo decades of progress in military conduct. They would make things worse than we can imagine.\n\nAt the heart of the debate is something very simple: giving survivors the choice between the civilian and the military justice systems. If the government removes these amendments, survivors would have access only to the civilian justice system. The consequences would be immediate and unavoidable. There would be institutional trauma and revictimization among survivors who trusted us to listen. Going forward, a majority of military sexual assault cases would go unaddressed or untried. Civilian police forces would be handed cases they have repeatedly said they cannot absorb, and worse, the majority of cases would not meet the threshold for prosecution by civilian authorities.\n\nThe Liberals would be opening the door to predators, abandoning survivors of military sexual assault and deceiving Canadians into believing they care about victims. It is shameful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728590","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have signalled their intent to remove collaborative amendments to Bill C‐11 dealing with military sexual assault, amendments that survivors asked for and experts supported overwhelmingly. The Liberals are about to single-handedly undo decades of progress in military conduct. They would make things worse than we can imagine.\n\nAt the heart of the debate is something very si","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b36145939e17eaa94a5ab9cbcf269df6116398cbd7b84c439a947507d514726"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f0805c3fef5a336e7b7d7eb816460fbf5082894ce19536f80eac5b752aea5a41"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8aa1c3465ce82c7cfe149a00","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728582,"date":"2026-04-28T15:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague for his visionary intervention, where he focused on the crux of the issue, which is poor legislation and accountability.\n\n Yesterday at the defence committee, I questioned the new CEO of the Defence Investment Agency, previously of Goldman Sachs, who is a banker buddy of the Prime Minister. He stated that he has not been screened for national security conflicts of interest with his former high net worth clients who are connected to Chinese state-owned businesses.\n\nI would like my colleague to expand on the parallels in this bill regarding both Liberal insiders and a failure to protect Canadian assets and IP from the intervention of the Chinese Communist Party.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728582","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague for his visionary intervention, where he focused on the crux of the issue, which is poor legislation and accountability.\n\n Yesterday at the defence committee, I questioned the new CEO of the Defence Investment Agency, previously of Goldman Sachs, who is a banker buddy of the Prime Minister. He stated that he has not been screened for national secur","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["407db0be9a9f8359b19b065a15911f3b2d57f29b8cbc04db652704f898b1bc57"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa63b232c074e1a60364314e13fccfff101430f0e973b6c8e412d513562fdef8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0058d8fa47621c5335b91c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728584,"date":"2026-04-28T16:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, 2% GDP, NATO spending compliant, successful recruiting and now a 2028 rocket launch are all Liberal illusions. It is a ridiculous promise unless they are referring to a model rocket. I have heard enough hot air to launch a rocket.\n\nMy question is specific to the components of this legislation. What parts would allow parliamentary review for security screening to protect from foreign interference, hostile state use and the theft of Canadian IP? There is none of that in there. This is all critical. Also, there are components that are missing from the legislation around defence. Could member speak to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728584","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, 2% GDP, NATO spending compliant, successful recruiting and now a 2028 rocket launch are all Liberal illusions. It is a ridiculous promise unless they are referring to a model rocket. I have heard enough hot air to launch a rocket.\n\nMy question is specific to the components of this legislation. What parts would allow parliamentary review for security screening to protect from foreign i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718459","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718459","label":"Air","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["810fb0bb8bf509bd40e5be57ce2dbdc83bdefee51059796990839fb75ceb8ace"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5fd6103f96ad9f3edfabad7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728588,"date":"2026-04-28T20:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have claimed success with military recruiting, when in fact they have managed to meet only their own artificially low thresholds, and the Liberals have claimed success with 2% of GDP spent with NATO, when they know full well that the spending fails to meet NATO's criteria. The bill is short on detail and devoid of security considerations. It has not addressed potential hostile state interference.\n\n My question for my colleague is this: Does he agree that this parking-lot planned spaceport is a closed-door plan reporting to a single minister and not responsible to Parliament and Canadians, or is it another Liberal illusion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728588","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have claimed success with military recruiting, when in fact they have managed to meet only their own artificially low thresholds, and the Liberals have claimed success with 2% of GDP spent with NATO, when they know full well that the spending fails to meet NATO's criteria. The bill is short on detail and devoid of security considerations. It has not addressed potential ho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space station","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037195","label":"Space station","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f74ba38e4569f61cba9e41713936046b339deb677e1cc77a494ad7e1fcc6de1b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1fe91f7da074618fa7d36f42","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127670,"date":"2026-04-29T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for your answers, Mr. Villandré and Ms. Perreault. Unfortunately, I'm going to speak to you in English. I'm very sorry and saddened for what your communities have gone through. I have a few questions for the mayor. You mentioned 1,100 houses being built on the base and associated playgrounds, parks and schools. Would that be on contaminated land or formerly contaminated land, and if not, would it be close to that land?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127670","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for your answers, Mr. Villandré and Ms. Perreault. Unfortunately, I'm going to speak to you in English. I'm very sorry and saddened for what your communities have gone through. I have a few questions for the mayor. You mentioned 1,100 houses being built on the base and associated playgrounds, parks and schools. Would that be on contaminated land or formerly contamin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fee951d3ebbdfea6ba34d06b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127671,"date":"2026-04-29T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"May I ask how many people's health has been affected by this over the years? Is there an approximate number?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127671","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"May I ask how many people's health has been affected by this over the years? Is there an approximate number?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3afe2f4dcab03fe5129cd71b19a14335cd6ce73b5c8cac7fc41f64f5f9cb4387"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-223937652a42e3d7dcc5ac77","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127672,"date":"2026-04-29T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. I really appreciated your comment when you said you didn't want to look back and that you wanted to look to the future. I think it's very positive and healing to hear that. You mentioned a review of some things and you also mentioned better communication. Could you please share some positive, concrete steps—and this is your opportunity to speak to the government through the committee—as a solution from the federal government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127672","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I really appreciated your comment when you said you didn't want to look back and that you wanted to look to the future. I think it's very positive and healing to hear that. You mentioned a review of some things and you also mentioned better communication. Could you please share some positive, concrete steps—and this is your opportunity to speak to the government through the co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa4a3274c23e550ee510acfb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127673,"date":"2026-04-29T22:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127673","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-515c9f36b6aef49a497c85a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127674,"date":"2026-04-29T22:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I have five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127674","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f566d672c2fe58ffc4c9aa16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127675,"date":"2026-05-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you for your service. As we say on the west coast, hych'ka . Ms. Eisan, it was good to see you at the Battle of the Atlantic dinner on Thursday in Halifax. I know you're highly respected by navy leadership there. We see that 20% of recruits are permanent residents—some are in Canada for as little as three months—and there's no language screening now to recruit in English or French. Based on your experience—this is for either of you—will this dilute both important indigenous representation and important French language levels in the Canadian Forces?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127675","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you for your service. As we say on the west coast, hych'ka . Ms. Eisan, it was good to see you at the Battle of the Atlantic dinner on Thursday in Halifax. I know you're highly respected by navy leadership there. We see that 20% of recruits are permanent residents—some are in Canada for as little as three months—and there's no language screening now to recruit in English or","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-066692978e43907b5546162e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127676,"date":"2026-05-04T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Very quickly, maybe you could provide an indigenous perspective on that high number of permanent residents.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127676","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Very quickly, maybe you could provide an indigenous perspective on that high number of permanent residents.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b47254a9509086b3e146c8f02352e615f1d46bd4b8e18a11c679990b8a33c495"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f230bf83ddf73beceacd4588","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960960,"date":"2026-05-04T21:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the significant majority of military sexual misconduct cases will not meet the civilian threshold of the civilian justice system. Of the few cases that do meet that threshold for the civilian justice system, witnesses for the system have testified that it only has the capacity to deal with just a fraction of the cases. \n\nPerhaps my colleague could speak to whether this is just going to make the culture in the military worse and be a free pass for predators.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960960","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the significant majority of military sexual misconduct cases will not meet the civilian threshold of the civilian justice system. Of the few cases that do meet that threshold for the civilian justice system, witnesses for the system have testified that it only has the capacity to deal with just a fraction of the cases. \n\nPerhaps my colleague could speak to whether this is just going t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a8d1226a37f9b1c2eb38873e4a8f89542379ff5bc7d31bad577580d1875927b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3980e4035eab25f0064f44316a0ab7feb18f26faa93deafbdd09694ecb7c19bf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3ee0e3e89b39ce2a896d43b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960961,"date":"2026-05-04T22:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, clearly the member opposite understands neither the bill nor military chain of command. Removing the committee's amendments, ignoring overwhelming evidence of the experts and MST survivors and, even worse, adding amendments without going to committee is not democracy, transparency or collaboration.\n\nThe significant majority of military sexual misconduct cases will not meet the threshold of civilian jurisdiction, and of the cases that do meet the threshold, the civilian justice system has testified that it has the capacity to deal with only a fraction of them. Knowing that, what is the Liberals' plan to prosecute these cases and bring justice in the majority of them? Are they just going to give a free pass to predators?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960961","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, clearly the member opposite understands neither the bill nor military chain of command. Removing the committee's amendments, ignoring overwhelming evidence of the experts and MST survivors and, even worse, adding amendments without going to committee is not democracy, transparency or collaboration.\n\nThe significant majority of military sexual misconduct cases will not meet the thresho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","label":"Wildlife","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["282da61d7c513668e09dceb904bcf0fc20fe8330f13e197cb2882ef32fb8b55a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["68390bdc06e7021a739303d492d5c109cfb16d079273ee80dfab6b9539441041"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d7e35889812a61f99911fe6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960962,"date":"2026-05-04T23:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is curious that the party opposite has the same person ask the same question. They are dogmatically hanging on the Arbour report, whether it be in the House or in committee or in debate, while overwhelmingly ignoring the plethora of evidence and reports.\n\nMaybe the member could speak briefly about why they are ignoring this so much and hanging on one dated report.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960962","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is curious that the party opposite has the same person ask the same question. They are dogmatically hanging on the Arbour report, whether it be in the House or in committee or in debate, while overwhelmingly ignoring the plethora of evidence and reports.\n\nMaybe the member could speak briefly about why they are ignoring this so much and hanging on one dated report.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae149ee1ff85c3035a1c96c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960959,"date":"2026-05-06T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Cowichan land decision and the Liberal-Musqueam agreements signed secretly and outside the treaty process have resulted in economic uncertainty, falling property values and unsettling division among British Columbians, especially on Vancouver Island.\n\nWe need truth and reconciliation. The Prime Minister is failing to deliver either. He is clearly unaware that by handcuffing the government lawyers in the B.C. appeals court, he has now legally handcuffed them in the Supreme Court.\n\nWhen will the Prime Minister explain his plan to protect private property rights now that the government lawyers cannot use the private property argument in court?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960959","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Cowichan land decision and the Liberal-Musqueam agreements signed secretly and outside the treaty process have resulted in economic uncertainty, falling property values and unsettling division among British Columbians, especially on Vancouver Island.\n\nWe need truth and reconciliation. The Prime Minister is failing to deliver either. He is clearly unaware that by handcuffing the go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["742e733fdbb704868f9d2febed7c8c698c31d93caf921ad32bdb84ff42b9ba68"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a49b691cb9f8b9f0e57a0b27caa7106ced7dc9f520650dde441d1507dc4d54e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bed17ba4aa2a2bf6d03b22b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127677,"date":"2026-05-06T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My questions are for the minister. For those in uniform—everyone in the room today—thank you for your ongoing service. On the DIS, my questions go to whether the architecture of that strategy has structural gaps—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127677","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My questions are for the minister. For those in uniform—everyone in the room today—thank you for your ongoing service. On the DIS, my questions go to whether the architecture of that strategy has structural gaps—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","label":"Architecture","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["597eaee2624041830cf73f7fa3bb1756c1585c3fab582e5b7eda046adab405da"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dfcb3ca54b46cdffd867b762","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127678,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Can we pause for a second, Mr. Chair?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127678","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Can we pause for a second, Mr. Chair?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85ec6511132a986ae36c379a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127679,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"How are you doing? Is it better?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127679","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How are you doing? Is it better?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30568c83bbd3c51b5b83faa3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127680,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. I have hearing damage too. I understand. I want to explore some potential structural gaps in the strategy so that we can look at potential improvements before our commitments harden. I'm going to jump back to an earlier question. I've met with multiple SMEs on Vancouver Island and on the west coast. Could you explain better how SMEs can get trusted partnership status? I think page 14 of the DIS uses the term \"formal strategic partnerships\" so that they don't have to defer to primes, which has the potential of adding significant cost and time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127680","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I have hearing damage too. I understand. I want to explore some potential structural gaps in the strategy so that we can look at potential improvements before our commitments harden. I'm going to jump back to an earlier question. I've met with multiple SMEs on Vancouver Island and on the west coast. Could you explain better how SMEs can get trusted partnership status? I think page 14 of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f0bf3b90acb48fe472579520eaff3fc7734da4f0d54c34bc3bf791d6c7e2986d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90e1d42eb34f07482175ba01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127681,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I look for your answer. We can ask this....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127681","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I look for your answer. We can ask this....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42f9a6477c455134a95555db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127682,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Sure. Okay. Let it rip. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127682","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Sure. Okay. Let it rip. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccaf5ee5ae60366d7d09297b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127683,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Will there be a direct path for SMEs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127683","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Will there be a direct path for SMEs?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68f7a8a24b557049adccb7e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127684,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"My time is limited, Minister. If I could move on, you mentioned DIS targets of 70% of defence contracts to domestic firms. You said that was not measured by dollars but by materiel. Can you explain how we measure 70% of defence contracts not by dollars? I'm just quoting you—not by dollar value, but by materiel.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127684","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My time is limited, Minister. If I could move on, you mentioned DIS targets of 70% of defence contracts to domestic firms. You said that was not measured by dollars but by materiel. Can you explain how we measure 70% of defence contracts not by dollars? I'm just quoting you—not by dollar value, but by materiel.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6d0170753a2864e5e1dc0c2886a03148982410923213f747c1429e62d16e5fd6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["345fd00b265f9c9027945fc7ddb651124200e9fe474df128fedb1242cff5738b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3d8f06c434a6c42cf23b200","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127685,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's one contract. Do you measure it by the dollar value? The Prime Minister said that 75¢ of every capital defence dollar currently flows to the United States. We're trying to achieve 70%—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127685","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's one contract. Do you measure it by the dollar value? The Prime Minister said that 75¢ of every capital defence dollar currently flows to the United States. We're trying to achieve 70%—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8de26097fd38dea2ab8032ed118ca6126894a09dbcdf8d74c2599385f79c6760"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed7cbae9d3510ae659aa7069","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127686,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"How are we measuring it if we're not measuring it by dollars, but—to quote you earlier—by materiel value?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127686","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How are we measuring it if we're not measuring it by dollars, but—to quote you earlier—by materiel value?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["798772a1c31bf68e4a7f75d1c3622e1ec10142181f0be207cd8eb26aa77d2c79"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5ae81684b49b8fbe6fb2fc1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127687,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"A Canadian company could have a $1-million contract. Would that weigh equally with a foreign country that would have, say, a submarine contract, and you could say, well, it's fifty-fifty? The dollars don't match up, and I don't see us on a target for reducing that 75¢.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127687","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"A Canadian company could have a $1-million contract. Would that weigh equally with a foreign country that would have, say, a submarine contract, and you could say, well, it's fifty-fifty? The dollars don't match up, and I don't see us on a target for reducing that 75¢.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77338e25485e092fc1e1f16b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127688,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. I appreciate that. Would you accept that the DIS and its 10 capabilities are anchored in the conventional kinetic domain and things we've historically called the military domain? It doesn't appear that they're focused—if you would agree with me—on the prekinetic threats that NSICOP has documented across the civil-military boundary. I'm sure you're well aware of those.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127688","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I appreciate that. Would you accept that the DIS and its 10 capabilities are anchored in the conventional kinetic domain and things we've historically called the military domain? It doesn't appear that they're focused—if you would agree with me—on the prekinetic threats that NSICOP has documented across the civil-military boundary. I'm sure you're well aware of those.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","label":"Military technology","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01273c09419c565406ba3efd7f31c734d1524c95a85d3ee673dfcd11c7117995"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b76bf07782e28f768fa20488","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127689,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"You're confirming, then, that the DIS is designed for the prekinetic threat picture of, say, coercive trade, foreign interference, supply chain weaponization—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127689","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You're confirming, then, that the DIS is designed for the prekinetic threat picture of, say, coercive trade, foreign interference, supply chain weaponization—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015021","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Biological weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015021","label":"Biological weapons","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["555175c7b22fa9144a3b479c1069d60018c26bc87942981b397717eff8668072"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67bc726e840445700fdab6f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127690,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Will you be able to provide us some examples of that from within the DIS? I don't see that in there. I see just a shopping list of stuff to buy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127690","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Will you be able to provide us some examples of that from within the DIS? I don't see that in there. I see just a shopping list of stuff to buy.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:133457","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Toys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036621","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Personal care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036621","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036621","label":"Personal care products","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:133457","label":"Toys","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93e122842b887385e70a12ca0c8698e7518a959f3609cff18376019b972da2fd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c455f79df0e13a3e897c047d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127691,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"It does talk about foreign interference. I will look forward to that. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127691","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It does talk about foreign interference. I will look forward to that. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-395409c2fca191a53f68d4e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127692,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Minister, when I go to the grocery store, I do it one of two ways. Either I go with a list based on meals I plan to make and an inventory of what's in my fridge, or I do it the more dangerous way, which is with my appetite. One feeds a family. The other costs a lot of money and blows your budget. Would you accept that the DIS, as drafted, looks more like a procurement framework than a strategy, and that it's a shopping list without an inventory of the full threat picture? How can we address those capability gaps?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127692","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Minister, when I go to the grocery store, I do it one of two ways. Either I go with a list based on meals I plan to make and an inventory of what's in my fridge, or I do it the more dangerous way, which is with my appetite. One feeds a family. The other costs a lot of money and blows your budget. Would you accept that the DIS, as drafted, looks more like a procurement framework than a strategy, an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1edf4993558842573b07d1bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127693,"date":"2026-05-06T22:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm seeing it more as—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127693","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm seeing it more as—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-595ecebb75af0ce325769737","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127694,"date":"2026-05-06T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My first question is for Ms. Fox. I reviewed the DIS and I could not find how it deals with non-kinetic threats, specifically coercive trade, foreign interference and supply chain weaponization. I note that in the \"State of Canada's Defence Industry Report\", it doesn't even include steel and aluminum as factors. Could you help me understand how it deals with, say, coercive trade?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127694","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My first question is for Ms. Fox. I reviewed the DIS and I could not find how it deals with non-kinetic threats, specifically coercive trade, foreign interference and supply chain weaponization. I note that in the \"State of Canada's Defence Industry Report\", it doesn't even include steel and aluminum as factors. Could you help me understand how it deals with, say, coercive tr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81d0896b472b01c990a22b91","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127695,"date":"2026-05-06T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm not talking about digital systems. I'm talking about the strategy of dealing with coercive trade, foreign interference and supply chain weaponization. It's not a technology; it's a strategy. As I said, the SCDI report doesn't even include steel and aluminum as factors.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127695","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm not talking about digital systems. I'm talking about the strategy of dealing with coercive trade, foreign interference and supply chain weaponization. It's not a technology; it's a strategy. As I said, the SCDI report doesn't even include steel and aluminum as factors.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015021","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Biological weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015021","label":"Biological weapons","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["72f09ba5f2f3dc9638558b61d36067536dc0fb4cd75297bd7deb2a8deaa980cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c3ab58ae73c4c64a8a0bb9a4708f688895c172f1f0347e6e4ad781ff07d4458"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76b0d358f0a96f8140b635a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127696,"date":"2026-05-06T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. I'm glad the intention is there, but I'm just not seeing it in the plan as part of the strategy. My question is now for General Simoneau. The department authenticated the January 27 evaluation from Lieutenant-Colonel Kieley, commandant at the recruit school. Do you accept these findings as the institutional view of the CFLRS period that it covers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127696","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I'm glad the intention is there, but I'm just not seeing it in the plan as part of the strategy. My question is now for General Simoneau. The department authenticated the January 27 evaluation from Lieutenant-Colonel Kieley, commandant at the recruit school. Do you accept these findings as the institutional view of the CFLRS period that it covers?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79b23e205cfdfe6af74a45b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127697,"date":"2026-05-06T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do you accept the report, then?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127697","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do you accept the report, then?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e25406121815b58bc3105472","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127698,"date":"2026-05-06T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. In The Globe and Mail , in 2025, the minister declared a recruitment goal of 12,000 to 15,000 per year. Earlier this year, it was announced that the goal is now 6,900, approximately, and then it was announced, for this year, that there were 7,300 enrolments—not successful passes but enrolments. We know, from Kieley's report, that almost 25% are not passing, so we're clearly not meeting our goals, despite the positive announcements about them. What are the recruiting numbers needed to achieve trained effective strength in the Canadian Forces? What was that path forward? How many do we need this year, next year and the following year, and not recruits but the ones who actually make it through and pass?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127698","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. In The Globe and Mail , in 2025, the minister declared a recruitment goal of 12,000 to 15,000 per year. Earlier this year, it was announced that the goal is now 6,900, approximately, and then it was announced, for this year, that there were 7,300 enrolments—not successful passes but enrolments. We know, from Kieley's report, that almost 25% are not passing, so we're clearly not meeting ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["45d8f977ea5d9fd4a3f413e28f3b8901773779a95fd28c5f65af8e955cb3d412"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cfd2a365781a8e00a40094f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127699,"date":"2026-05-06T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"You said you were producing more, but more against the standard. What are the actual numbers that you need, let's say this year, next year and the following years, to eventually get to trained effective strength? What's the path for that, the actual numbers? Do we know this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127699","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You said you were producing more, but more against the standard. What are the actual numbers that you need, let's say this year, next year and the following years, to eventually get to trained effective strength? What's the path for that, the actual numbers? Do we know this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2434d6a92387429f00a2586f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127700,"date":"2026-05-06T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"For next year, the target is 8,200. It's a 12% increase from this year. The Auditor General reports that the school is already operating at 80% of its capacity, and that there are instructor and critical equipment shortages, even uniform shortages. By what mechanism does the capacity-constrained school absorb a 12% intake increase, and then even more the next year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127700","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"For next year, the target is 8,200. It's a 12% increase from this year. The Auditor General reports that the school is already operating at 80% of its capacity, and that there are instructor and critical equipment shortages, even uniform shortages. By what mechanism does the capacity-constrained school absorb a 12% intake increase, and then even more the next year?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","label":"Equipment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64aeac04432ae24fd9f615c4801f57423ec395765f405cfa565d9850188ab956"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8af747f10ac22083ddf5a97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127701,"date":"2026-05-06T23:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Quickly, if I can, in eight seconds—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127701","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Quickly, if I can, in eight seconds—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72692be025496757ee2397e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960701,"date":"2026-05-07T16:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr Speaker, I appreciate my colleague's excellent intervention.\n\nYou mentioned secret agreements. Could you tell me the risks and explore some of the risks of secret agreements done behind closed doors and their effect on transparency, as opposed to a treaty process that is established through the courts and that is open and transparent?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960701","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr Speaker, I appreciate my colleague's excellent intervention.\n\nYou mentioned secret agreements. Could you tell me the risks and explore some of the risks of secret agreements done behind closed doors and their effect on transparency, as opposed to a treaty process that is established through the courts and that is open and transparent?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0de8493df0783d3817494c236b43680978cfc933ae727e1d3a42b1f887ef66a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9638829533dd46a359b465ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960707,"date":"2026-05-07T16:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on behalf of the great people of Vancouver Island, and especially all of the seniors, families, workers, businesses and, perhaps most importantly, the youth of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford.\n\nOur communities stretch from Langford to Crofton, Thetis Island to Lake Cowichan to Port Renfrew and across the beautiful Cowichan Valley. It is home to numerous first nations, including the Cowichan Tribes, the largest first nation in British Columbia.\n\nWe are a people who love where we live. We are people who take pride in our homes, our neighbourhoods and our future. We are rooted in the lands, the rivers, the forests, the mountains and, of course, the ocean. They are all integral parts of our soul.\n\nToday, we are all worried. The Cowichan land decision has created uncertainty and division that no community, indigenous or non-indigenous, should ever have to face. Be it on the island or across British Columbia, home values are falling, banks are refusing mortgages, sales have stalled, businesses are looking elsewhere or moving away, and anger and division are building. People are lashing out at one another. This is heartbreaking, and it is unacceptable. The Liberal government has offered nothing. There is no clarity, no plan and no leadership.\n\n The language in the Cowichan ruling describes aboriginal title as a \"prior and senior right to land\", effectively creating a groundbreaking precedent putting aboriginal title above fee simple title. In other words, all privately held and Crown land is at risk. This has now created real fear of whether private property rights will still hold weight across British Columbia and, indeed, across Canada.\n\nThese are not abstract legal questions, however. They are conversations happening every night in Duncan, Langford, Shawnigan Lake and Mill Bay and within the Cowichan Tribes. Parents are asking whether their home, their single greatest asset, is still secure. Seniors are wondering whether they can afford to retire and young families are questioning whether they can stay on Vancouver Island at all. Our youth are wondering what Canada will look like in the future. Our first nations are seeing reconciliation sentiment taking a major step backwards.\n\nThrough all of this, the Prime Minister has remained silent. Instead of leadership, we have his litigation directive number 14, which forbids federal government lawyers from defending private property rights. It is a directive that tied their hands in British Columbia's appeals court and will now automatically tie their hands again, this time in the Supreme Court of Canada going forward.\n\n This is not reconciliation. This is the abandonment of all Canadians, and it is deepening division, anger and stress among neighbours, friends and families, which is exactly the opposite of what reconciliation should bring.\n\n British Columbia deserves better, Vancouver Island deserves better and the Cowichan Tribes deserve better. Reconciliation cannot be built on secretly negotiated agreements or confusion. It cannot come at the expense of homeowners, the very stability of our economy or the core of our country.\n\nFor decades, we had a made-in-Canada approach that balanced indigenous rights with the needs of society as a whole through an established treaty process. Section 35 of our Constitution recognized and affirmed these rights. It created a framework that brought stability and prosperity. It was not perfect, but it worked, and now the Liberal government has walked away from that. It has leaned on the declaration of the United Nations, which is an unelected body. It is not Canadian and it is not part of our legal system. The declaration is not binding and was never intended to override private property rights, yet the Liberals are using UNDRIP as if it does.\n\nThe Liberals signed the rights recognition agreement with the Musqueam, which is not a treaty through the court system, but a closed-door, secretly negotiated agreement that failed to explicitly protect fee simple or private property owners and neglected to even mention them. It is an agreement that awarded the Musqueam aboriginal land title over the majority of greater Vancouver, including lands previously awarded to the Cowichan Tribes in Richmond, B.C. They created a conflict between two separate aboriginal titles.\n\n In fact, almost all of British Columbia is potentially under overlapping aboriginal land claims. With the Cowichan decision setting the precedent that aboriginal title is superior to private property and Crown title, British Columbia is in a mess. That precedent has now rippled across Vancouver Island, creating confusion and fear from Langford to Ladysmith and across British Columbia. This is not reconciliation. This is recklessness.\n\nToday, I am calling on the Prime Minister to act clearly, publicly and immediately. Our Conservative plan has four straightforward pillars.\n\n First, put private property rights first in the Cowichan case and restore the extinguishment agreement the Liberals abandoned in 2018. No one should ever have to wonder whether their home is truly their home.\n\n Second, make no agreement without explicit protection for all existing fee simple owners. The secret Musqueam agreement failed to do this. The Prime Minister must correct this mistake and guarantee that all future agreements protect people's homes.\n\n Third, publish a plan within 30 days to protect Canadians affected by the Cowichan decision in the Musqueam agreement. Do not hold a press conference. Do not make a promise. Do not sign an MOU. Publish a real plan with timelines and commitments, delivered personally by the Prime Minister.\n\n Finally, convene a special parliamentary committee to examine every legal, constitutional and political tool available to protect private property rights across Canada.\n\nThis crisis is not limited to the Cowichan Valley. It has spread across Vancouver Island, Richmond and British Columbia, and it will soon spread across Canada. If we do nothing, we will leave future generations with a fractured legal landscape and a broken economy.\n\nThere is a better path, one that respects indigenous rights and private homeowners. We see that path in our Conservative platform. It is practical, economic reconciliation. It will put first nations back in control of their own revenues, reduce bureaucracy and government controls, strengthen local economies, including on Vancouver Island, and bring first nations into the federation as full partners, not wards of the state.\n\n First nations chiefs from across the country and across British Columbia have said the same thing. They want less Ottawa and more autonomy, and they want to build prosperity for their people. Conservatives agree. Reconciliation must be built on partnership, not secrecy; on clarity, not confusion; on respect, not fear; and on truth, not misinformation.\n\nThe Truth and Reconciliation Commission called for both truth and reconciliation. The Prime Minister has failed to deliver either. The great people across Cowichan—Malahat—Langford deserve a government that protects their homes and their future. The Cowichan Tribes deserve a government that respects their jurisdiction and supports their economic independence. Canada deserves a government that understands that reconciliation and private property rights are not competing ideas, but are both essential to a stable and united Canada.\n\nThe Prime Minister has a choice. He can continue down a path of silence and uncertainty or he can act clearly, transparently and responsibly to restore confidence in our legal system and protect the rights of every Canadian. My community is watching, the Cowichan Tribes are watching and Vancouver Island is watching, and we are waiting. It is time for the Prime Minister to show leadership.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960707","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on behalf of the great people of Vancouver Island, and especially all of the seniors, families, workers, businesses and, perhaps most importantly, the youth of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford.\n\nOur communities stretch from Langford to Crofton, Thetis Island to Lake Cowichan to Port Renfrew and across the beautiful Cowichan Valley. It is home to numerous first nations, including","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fce7d60527e1fd49f37d558cd3cb1055d00ef594a9b9beb95a1345004b84898b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["29bac32b3a1e53a1ef4b75573a739889a0b2873cbf0fccd7ee693ac4d7edd2b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b6878be42daf10c5e2b3b62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960749,"date":"2026-05-07T17:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, speaking of disinformation, the member opposite claims that the Prime Minister has defended this, but he continually fails to disclose that he has already tied the hands of the government lawyers with the extinguishment article. He speaks of it being filed immediately when, in fact, the Supreme Court filing was done on the last day, at the very last minute. That is more misinformation.\n\nConservatives are calling for real truth, real reconciliation and real honesty.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960749","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, speaking of disinformation, the member opposite claims that the Prime Minister has defended this, but he continually fails to disclose that he has already tied the hands of the government lawyers with the extinguishment article. He speaks of it being filed immediately when, in fact, the Supreme Court filing was done on the last day, at the very last minute. That is more misinformation","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["456464431257917536bfda7d84da96cb92bd951a84d23246a270e5a215584fc6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["836c64ff02e4341e16b330c556071c44697569fa09262b9d961cecfa2288eca2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87e2b72fe963f8351b5f7314","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960779,"date":"2026-05-07T17:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I really agree with my colleague's statement about empty promises and empty words. People are worried about the value of their property. They are worried about getting mortgages. In fact, it is so bad that the provincial NDP government is now having to back mortgages in affected areas, and it can do that only for a small area. It is going to need to do that for the entire province.\n\nPeople are worried. Property assessments are now coming with waivers saying the property value only stands as long as it is not superceded by aboriginal title. People in my riding of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford are facing real concerns, and they are facing increasing racism and anger. This comes on top of tough economic times as well.\n\n There are very valid reasons for concern, and we are seeing it across Vancouver Island and British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960779","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I really agree with my colleague's statement about empty promises and empty words. People are worried about the value of their property. They are worried about getting mortgages. In fact, it is so bad that the provincial NDP government is now having to back mortgages in affected areas, and it can do that only for a small area. It is going to need to do that for the entire province.\n\nP","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7067d12dcccb3db1bf046775f5c7513d69332b3e4230d96a45490e8b96d9a320"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ae434ae0fe4f873416320c96a245da88b2002ad35802fe44e05661925ec9e9c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4990d06db667966d2bec06d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960781,"date":"2026-05-07T17:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in my comments, I said \"secretly negotiated\". The Musqueam agreement was negotiated behind closed doors. Even the Premier of British Columbia claimed he did not know about it until the actual signing. That is secrecy, not transparency, and it is how the government is failing our country.\n\nAs far as the comments are concerned, I have not heard those comments and I am not in a position to comment on them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960781","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in my comments, I said \"secretly negotiated\". The Musqueam agreement was negotiated behind closed doors. Even the Premier of British Columbia claimed he did not know about it until the actual signing. That is secrecy, not transparency, and it is how the government is failing our country.\n\nAs far as the comments are concerned, I have not heard those comments and I am not in a position ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f846457ec0af60266a2394971dd5dffbfeef029daa586ad018d626437d4ffab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61f111251dd1fac4016224126a167d4687ae4f4d7cf844f2f5c5505e933d1e56"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-51d1cd178813c42ca1772668","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960782,"date":"2026-05-07T17:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite is spending more time blaming Conservatives for the Liberals' own failures than proposing realistic solutions in his address today, which is a typical desperate Liberal tactic. \n\nThe member stated that they would vigorously defend private property with every viable argument. Members may have noticed, however, that he could not say \"every argument\" because he knows full well that the government lawyers' hands are tied behind their backs. They cannot use the extinguishment argument in court.\n\nWhat is the Liberals' plan to vigorously defend it when their hands are tied behind their backs and they cannot even address title and private property, without the extinguishment argument?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960782","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite is spending more time blaming Conservatives for the Liberals' own failures than proposing realistic solutions in his address today, which is a typical desperate Liberal tactic. \n\nThe member stated that they would vigorously defend private property with every viable argument. Members may have noticed, however, that he could not say \"every argument\" because he knows ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["354763b9c43be219c5e7a3b52ca79966ac63e0238c311fc657faba1d017ed368"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-187338f35271741b66e58065","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960783,"date":"2026-05-07T17:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am feeling frustration from across my riding. We keep hearing the words \"all viable arguments\", but we are not hearing all arguments.\n\nWill the Liberals acknowledge what the Supreme Court knows, which was established in the B.C. appeals court, which is that the federal government lawyers will not be able to use the main argument, the extinguishment of land title argument, because they failed to do it in the B.C. appeals court? What arguments will they use in the Supreme Court?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960783","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am feeling frustration from across my riding. We keep hearing the words \"all viable arguments\", but we are not hearing all arguments.\n\nWill the Liberals acknowledge what the Supreme Court knows, which was established in the B.C. appeals court, which is that the federal government lawyers will not be able to use the main argument, the extinguishment of land title argument, because th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a508874a5df7939df67d5a022ae20859b9a07c27e7b99b5a2ebc9fd51455da9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06052ec70b0c9e7ba0e97ecdb24d308a3f3c3214c66d53e57c429eaaa9ef4422"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e063148556255f373a89d30","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960821,"date":"2026-05-07T17:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today Liberals repeatedly failed to answer my question on extinguishment and their failure to use that argument in the B.C. appeals court and, therefore, legally not being able to use it in the Supreme Court. They mislead Canadians, give a false impression and say every \"viable argument\" because they know they cannot say every argument.\n\nIs this just another Liberal illusion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960821","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today Liberals repeatedly failed to answer my question on extinguishment and their failure to use that argument in the B.C. appeals court and, therefore, legally not being able to use it in the Supreme Court. They mislead Canadians, give a false impression and say every \"viable argument\" because they know they cannot say every argument.\n\nIs this just another Liberal illusion?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["748c5e8cd3c8a40af002380661a9f3b78669bf8e867773b7cf41e1a9eeebe461"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc08bde0d42a59f634200af2ccefe26c22b7012005250e6aec9989479cc858be"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f8396132b459116ed32df4f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036332,"date":"2026-05-25T19:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, families on Vancouver Island worked hard, played by the rules and bought their homes in good faith. They deserve certainty about their property and their futures, yet under the Prime Minister's watch, the mishandling of the Cowichan case and the closed-door Musqueam agreement have shaken that certainty. Industry, businesses and homeowners are anxious. Communities are divided. Meaningful reconciliation has been set back by division.\n\n Leadership means bringing people together. The Prime Minister has failed that test. Will he finally show any leadership and support our Conservative motion to protect property rights, restore confidence and unite rather than divide the people he is supposed to serve?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036332","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, families on Vancouver Island worked hard, played by the rules and bought their homes in good faith. They deserve certainty about their property and their futures, yet under the Prime Minister's watch, the mishandling of the Cowichan case and the closed-door Musqueam agreement have shaken that certainty. Industry, businesses and homeowners are anxious. Communities are divided. Meaningf","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96f7c8387c2e66493ff17d39","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127702,"date":"2026-05-27T21:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you Mr. Chair. My questions are through you. Thank you to our witnesses for being here and for supporting Canada's defence industry and, more importantly, those in uniform. Mr. Chair, the defence industrial strategy is a 2030-onward or even 2035-onward instrument, but the operational reality and requirements are right now. Canadian Armed Forces members in the national capital region were recently directed, on May 13, to return field kit because of critical equipment shortages. There are 2,000 Canadians in Latvia leading a brigade, and Russia threatened Latvia at the Security Council last Tuesday. The U.S. paused the Permanent Joint Board on Defence last week, with the Under Secretary of War saying, \"A strong Canada that prioritizes hard power over rhetoric benefits us all.\" The Canadian Press reported that the Pentagon has given Ottawa a classified paper \"laying out priorities for a collective North American defence pact\" but that, according to a senior U.S. defence official, \"Ottawa did not deliver a 'credible' response.\" They cited the F-35 delays as another major irritant. The point I'm trying to make is that the U.S. defence industrial base needs allied production capacity that Canada can credibly provide, including 155-millimetre shells, propellant, energetics, missile subcomponents and counterdrone technology. I'm going to start with a soft question for Mr. Ziadé, just to warm him up for our panel. Specifically looking at the immediate operational needs of Canada, I understand that Ukraine and our allies, and in fact our own personnel over there, are all eager to see modern battlefield disruptive munitions. I'll refer to North Vector's hypersonic or drone intercept missiles. They'd like to see these in their inventories and, perhaps more importantly, for our Canadian men and women. As a small business from western Canada, what do you need to see from this government to quickly build, deploy and train this sovereign capability for Europe and for this critical need right now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127702","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you Mr. Chair. My questions are through you. Thank you to our witnesses for being here and for supporting Canada's defence industry and, more importantly, those in uniform. Mr. Chair, the defence industrial strategy is a 2030-onward or even 2035-onward instrument, but the operational reality and requirements are right now. Canadian Armed Forces members in the national capital region were rec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c92e9e9edb25c02d66d9a7c017d2ed16cc9360fab78305f22839c493d2d233d9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dfb067197c264df1a5e5c1e95bbebfb2872983650e31020ee6eefba906b2d5e7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc20065b2b11b2c79b8d9aa9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127703,"date":"2026-05-27T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. Mr. Mueller, what partnership infrastructure does not exist today that needs to be developed in the next 12 to 24 months to bridge between current operational reality and the long-term aspirations of the Defence Investment Agency? Quickly, could you give me a couple of specific instruments?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127703","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Mr. Mueller, what partnership infrastructure does not exist today that needs to be developed in the next 12 to 24 months to bridge between current operational reality and the long-term aspirations of the Defence Investment Agency? Quickly, could you give me a couple of specific instruments?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d631bb0e6d7f85bd62dc07fd0cc6432df853e185025c8bbab05734ea9cde1c1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f30c6cead43a601c835d20c3fa8048c9968c1071aa4dcc858288e9efdbb793c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f1a54be8753670eb217a76ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127704,"date":"2026-05-27T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. Ms. Lussier, would you agree? Or do you wish to add a comment to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127704","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Ms. Lussier, would you agree? Or do you wish to add a comment to that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83a95eda4bbffa39d9cd2d63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127705,"date":"2026-05-27T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do I have some time left?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127705","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do I have some time left?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2e5cba6c98104cd0b14a7d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127706,"date":"2026-05-27T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127706","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37465324e19e3b8e46e65689","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127707,"date":"2026-05-27T22:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Mr. Ziadé, I appreciated your comments about Canadian expertise and innovation, and I couldn't agree more. However, do you think this committee should consider recommending that the government formally propose to its allied partners, such as the U.K., Germany, France and Korea, an immediate framework for an interval of lend-lease, training and co-development agreements to bridge between current Canadian operational requirements and the long-term 2030-35 DIS deliverables? Please answer briefly with a yes or no. Also, how would your organization collaborate on such a plan to address that short-term challenge, and what would it contribute?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127707","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Ziadé, I appreciated your comments about Canadian expertise and innovation, and I couldn't agree more. However, do you think this committee should consider recommending that the government formally propose to its allied partners, such as the U.K., Germany, France and Korea, an immediate framework for an interval of lend-lease, training and co-development agreements to bridge between current Ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f4aa2a0be511beb7190b7cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127708,"date":"2026-05-27T22:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. I'd like to pivot a little and focus on the Permanent Joint Board on Defence's being paused and Mr. Colby's challenge. This should be a wake-up call, I believe, to all Canadians. Where can Canadian defence production add value that helps close the U.S. production capacity shortfall and, in doing so, let our country answer the Under Secretary of War's challenge with capability rather than rhetoric? I'll start with Ms. Lussier.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127708","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I'd like to pivot a little and focus on the Permanent Joint Board on Defence's being paused and Mr. Colby's challenge. This should be a wake-up call, I believe, to all Canadians. Where can Canadian defence production add value that helps close the U.S. production capacity shortfall and, in doing so, let our country answer the Under Secretary of War's challenge with capability ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f0fc9d04ccb1a45e0f39511940c6ed11a10b9c0e783b65087dc1a44f20cca07a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1bf4f99dc83a69cab9a2f56d58fb5ab8cba14397d6d6053378a9894342f95ac8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5938b3ac8955cc03ae9cad49","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127709,"date":"2026-05-27T22:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. Mr. Mueller, would you care to comment on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127709","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Mueller, would you care to comment on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-def9a893e242bd237d6ea3a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127710,"date":"2026-05-27T22:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. Mr. Ziadé, I'll ask for your organization's perspective on the same question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127710","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Ziadé, I'll ask for your organization's perspective on the same question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db7bfdde21e80a2de9710a3ddd94f749e6cc73f143c28f73649ca2f090af229e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2787de32dc02069a3f770cb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127711,"date":"2026-05-27T22:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's perfect. How much time do I have, Mr. Chair?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127711","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's perfect. How much time do I have, Mr. Chair?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4fc07703ce48e7b657962d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127712,"date":"2026-05-27T22:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Ms. Lussier, very quickly I'll jump back to my initial question in which I was speaking about allied partnerships to deal with the short term, not the long term. Do you think we should be doing these potential lend, lease, training, co-development agreements in the short term for the gap, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127712","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Ms. Lussier, very quickly I'll jump back to my initial question in which I was speaking about allied partnerships to deal with the short term, not the long term. Do you think we should be doing these potential lend, lease, training, co-development agreements in the short term for the gap, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mergers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036263","label":"Mergers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5736a5cd06943621a5e9bc62262c613b4f633d0cbd75581fa9a0a2d5ce3ca747"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c845f186bc9bca28c0f85552883440ecd529b84cad0bde6c24425cd30862e09c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8eea8ca6aa9a1b3d519ee7ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127713,"date":"2026-05-27T22:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"You're waving a hand, Mr. Mueller. Would you agree on the same context there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127713","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You're waving a hand, Mr. Mueller. Would you agree on the same context there?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89bcba8ea6859c1f43c83e79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127714,"date":"2026-05-27T22:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Mueller and Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127714","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Mueller and Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-547b5adec6690feec919aa7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127715,"date":"2026-05-27T23:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Mr. Ziadé, you spoke earlier about the need for stability and decision-making to support and spur on innovation and production. I heard that comment. Right now, the Liberals are still standing up the Defence Investment Agency and the defence industrial strategy, but as we've heard in testimony, this is without embedded strategic threat assessments in those plans, without consideration of prekinetic threats that we're facing and, indeed, without a national defence strategy—surprisingly enough—that would guide economic, strategic and efficient procurement planning. In your opinion, in the context of stability, is this harming the stability? We have this laundry list of shopping that doesn't really seem to have a plan. Is that impacting your decision-making within the industries that you represent?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127715","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Ziadé, you spoke earlier about the need for stability and decision-making to support and spur on innovation and production. I heard that comment. Right now, the Liberals are still standing up the Defence Investment Agency and the defence industrial strategy, but as we've heard in testimony, this is without embedded strategic threat assessments in those plans, without consideration of prekineti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1d5bc35c09283834c27e2b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127716,"date":"2026-05-27T23:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"We have a laundry list of things that we're buying, but we don't have a national defence strategy. We haven't considered prekinetic threats, so we're going to follow this way for a while, and then that way. We don't have that overall guidance. You said you needed stability, and I think that would bring stability. Can you comment, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127716","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We have a laundry list of things that we're buying, but we don't have a national defence strategy. We haven't considered prekinetic threats, so we're going to follow this way for a while, and then that way. We don't have that overall guidance. You said you needed stability, and I think that would bring stability. Can you comment, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-567b592cd3160ace6bc5fb76","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127717,"date":"2026-05-27T23:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Mr. Mueller, would you comment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127717","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Mueller, would you comment?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80d7ebb8f89247106d96863d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127718,"date":"2026-05-27T23:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I agree with you that we wouldn't be able to go anywhere without that. Ms. Lussier, would you agree as well that it's a critical component?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127718","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I agree with you that we wouldn't be able to go anywhere without that. Ms. Lussier, would you agree as well that it's a critical component?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cca8790ddf0e2ecb3a8e8adcbdd4be776a83657fa9f6dbc90b139d901ac61cce"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18d37481e1580e814b2b3f05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127719,"date":"2026-05-27T23:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. Mr. Asselin, would you agree?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127719","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Asselin, would you agree?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e93f092ffc8e172543af4b2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127720,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has costed the announced 3.5% NATO core commitment at $33 billion a year, meaning $159 billion by 2035-36. There's not really a fiscal road map without this national defence strategy, but maybe you could help us with a national inventory. To help us establish this.... We would need this across the country. Could you provide your input on a national inventory of what we have? Specifically, from your respective vantage points in the industries that you represent, what do we have today in numbers of firms, workforce numbers and sectoral capability that your members represent? I'll start with Ms. Lussier and go across. That will give us a snapshot here at the table and show the need that we should probably be well aware of for the entire country, because we don't have this critical inventory to help bring that stability.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127720","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has costed the announced 3.5% NATO core commitment at $33 billion a year, meaning $159 billion by 2035-36. There's not really a fiscal road map without this national defence strategy, but maybe you could help us with a national inventory. To help us establish this.... We would need this across the country. Could you provide your input on a national inven","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f7293a8368924a637dafc70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127721,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Is that in a couple of weeks?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127721","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is that in a couple of weeks?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b0ae42d7ce9ff6651990f1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127722,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"You have. Okay, so we're going to have that framework for Quebec. Would you agree, Mr. Mueller?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127722","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You have. Okay, so we're going to have that framework for Quebec. Would you agree, Mr. Mueller?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["787c1446145fa9f7ea57cffbc734c34de860e8f2ef3689a449ff9bd0da091852"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9bf9cbeb5e3ee456d1ce98c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127723,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. This is happening in Quebec, not from your perspective. Mr. Ziadé, what about the organizations that you represent?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127723","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. This is happening in Quebec, not from your perspective. Mr. Ziadé, what about the organizations that you represent?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bdcba8e70dd58e823f09e5a7b3d3d87e9f8ada29454892d7a13569faab384ed7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6763bf3e69728196bbe2f353","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127724,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"There are all these different sources. Some are being done in Quebec but not in other places. As different organizations, do you think we need a government-led map and inventory as a one-stop shop of our capability to support a realistic strategy? Without it, it seems impossible. Would you agree, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127724","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There are all these different sources. Some are being done in Quebec but not in other places. As different organizations, do you think we need a government-led map and inventory as a one-stop shop of our capability to support a realistic strategy? Without it, it seems impossible. Would you agree, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d272bcffee8ae3614d20794420ea25cce73e50fb76f19bc3a91a929f7a23237"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-878850cbd119448cb3dc7d99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127725,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do we need it nationally? That's what I meant.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127725","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do we need it nationally? That's what I meant.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-728882cd96ae1a53c3cc830f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127726,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"We need a national list.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127726","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We need a national list.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69ab0d45420bc5ed77ec46be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127727,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127727","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4613c97ccea9a6732c2c710a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127728,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes, and don't take too long, as well. Mr. Asselin, would you agree?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127728","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes, and don't take too long, as well. Mr. Asselin, would you agree?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09e7fd9b5180d2dbafccc8fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127729,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Is that just within your organization or for all institutions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127729","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is that just within your organization or for all institutions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9f8e77c59ee71ba297150015149235dac239927e466915377434f65c8dd9650"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6899d234a7116851d3c83de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127730,"date":"2026-05-27T23:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127730","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f711b83680585f7246a87aab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036329,"date":"2026-05-28T15:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise to present petition e-7115, a petition on behalf of Canadians and, more importantly, the great people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, who are concerned about the security and reliability of the digital systems that Canada depends on every day, specifically government digital systems. As we move more online, the software behind those systems must be built with strong safeguards from the beginning.\n\nPetitioners are asking the Government of Canada to take a more consistent approach to secure coding across all federal departments and Crown corporations so public services, sensitive information and taxpayer dollars are better protected. They have provided a detailed list of provisions to facilitate much-needed solutions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036329","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise to present petition e-7115, a petition on behalf of Canadians and, more importantly, the great people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, who are concerned about the security and reliability of the digital systems that Canada depends on every day, specifically government digital systems. As we move more online, the software behind those systems must be built with strong safeguards ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8484767e718fa7af1569c56e06a014978b386c64ae66fe13c06b675b291943dc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["513a5f6c2cf603564b046aa1c568124dd9b784b10659aa82a13164231d3c9340"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4493ac670edbf7c0f8e59d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036322,"date":"2026-05-29T15:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, thank you for allowing my speech to bracket the all-important question and member statement periods.\n\nI will be splitting my time today with the member for Stormont—Dundas—Glengarry.\n\nI am pleased to rise to share my analysis of this important piece of legislation. I want to be clear from the outset that not all of this bill is without merit, but there are provisions within it that deserve serious scrutiny, serious debate and serious answers from the government.\n\nAs a member of the Standing Committee on National Defence, I have a particular and direct interest in division 16 of this bill, the establishment of the Defence Investment Agency act and the amendments to the Defence Production Act, which would be renamed the defence and national security production and procurement act. It sounds complicated. Although buried as a peripheral issue within a budget bill, in reality this is a fundamental restructuring of how Canada processes and invests in its own defence, which deserves far more scrutiny than an omnibus budget process will ever allow.\n\nI want to be direct about something. I served nearly three decades in the Royal Canadian Navy. I served at CFB Esquimalt, one of the largest military installations in this country and the beating heart of our naval presence on the Pacific. It is a base that Vancouver Island depends on and has given more to this country than most Canadians will ever know. When I stand in the House and speak about defence procurement, I do not speak from a briefing note; I speak with 30 years of experience and of knowing exactly what happens when governments get procurement wrong. The government has this part of this bill catastrophically wrong.\n\nBill C-31 is 330 pages long. It touches on everything. That is the first problem. Changes of this magnitude, such as giving a minister up to $1 billion in spending authority with no meaningful oversight, deserve their own bills, their own debates and to be studied in defence committee, not buried inside a budget omnibus bill that only gets sent to finance committee. When we bury such a key strategic plan, we hide it, and when it is hidden, Canadians cannot hold the government accountable.\n\nThis is not an accident but yet another Liberal illusion. It is as if the Liberals have turned Parliament Hill into Emerald City on the Hill. They constructed a gleaming facade, the rhetoric sounds good, industry gets excited, and people are tricked into believing the illusion, while the Liberals ask Canadians to pay no attention to the wizard behind the curtain. Instead of the Prime Minister of Canada, perhaps we should refer to the position as the \"Prime Minister of Oz\". My job is to pull back that curtain to reveal the reality and shatter the illusion.\n\nLet me speak to what the Defence Investment Agency actually is and what it is not. The Prime Minister has hired a CEO, a successful investment banker with no defence experience or procurement background who used to work alongside the Prime Minister at Goldman Sachs. He is now head of the new Defence Investment Agency. It goes further than that. In testimony in committee, this CEO admitted that in his former role as a top-level investment banker, he worked with high-value companies directly connected with the communist government in China. This is a serious security risk. On a file this sensitive, it is a detail we cannot brush aside. He also worked with high-value companies that have direct connections to the defence industry. This presents a very real potential for conflict of interest.\n\nThis is not a risk Canada should be taking on one of the most consequential files this country faces, but here we are. The CEO of the DIA reports to a junior secretary of state, who reports to another minister, who reports to the Prime Minister, not at a cabinet table. There is no direct line of accountability or single point of authority. It is a rather confusing chain that only adds to more bureaucracy, red tape and delays and more boards, advisory committees, consultants and patronage. This is not procurement reform but the illusion of procurement reform. The Canadian Armed Forces cannot afford the difference, nor can Canada.\n\nLet me share some numbers with the House, because the numbers tell the story the government will not. Only 59% of our maritime fleet is serviceable and ready for operations, and that figure only holds because the government retired the entire Kingston class coastal fleet to make the math work. Of our 12 major warships, the navy, through no fault of its own, can barely keep three fully crewed, operational and ready to deploy.\n\nOnly 51% of land vehicles are ready for troops to use. They are worn out and undermaintained. Over $2 billion a year was cut from defence budgets between 2021 and 2025. As for our aerospace fleet, only 42% of our aircraft are ready to fly. Our CF-18s are nearly aged out, and we still do not have a signed contract for the F-35s because the government spent years playing political games with the air force. I will leave the government's failure to keep our beloved Snowbirds flying for another debate.\n\nThe brave men and women who serve at CFB Esquimalt, who serve across the country, deserve better than 42%. They deserve better than 51%. They deserve more than only three operational frigates. They deserve a government that signs contracts, shows stability and has a realistic strategy to build upon, not the illusion of reannouncements and press releases and fancy-sounding new layers of bureaucracy.\n\nIt has been more than four years since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, four years since we heard the language of putting Canada on a war footing. In four years, the only increases in the production of munitions, artillery shells and rockets in this country have come through contracts with the American military, not for Canada but for America. The government never signed the contracts for our own requirements.\n\nWe can announce an agency. We can name a CEO. We can create a board. However, until we put ink to paper and actually buy the equipment our forces need, we have done nothing. Division 16 of the bill does not fix this. It locks in the inefficiencies. It entrenches the old bureaucracy. It gives the minister the power to exclude companies from competition without ever explaining why. It creates the ability to sole-source contracts without accountability. It grants authorities to procure shares in corporations and to replace directors and officers, language that sounds an awful lot like nationalization.\n\nWe have been down this road before. It is called the Emergencies Act. This reeks of the same unaccountable overreach. In clause 310, there is more sole-sourcing. In clause 322, there is a competitive process riddled with exceptions so wide that almost anything can be exempted. In clause 312, there is ministerial power to replace corporate leadership at will. There is no transparency, no explanation and no accountability. \n\nHere is the foundational problem that makes all of this worse. Canada has no national security strategy, a strategy that should be the key foundation upon which the defence investment strategy and the Defence Investment Agency should be built. Without a national security strategy, none of this works. We cannot design a procurement architecture for a mission we have never defined—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036322","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, thank you for allowing my speech to bracket the all-important question and member statement periods.\n\nI will be splitting my time today with the member for Stormont—Dundas—Glengarry.\n\nI am pleased to rise to share my analysis of this important piece of legislation. I want to be clear from the outset that not all of this bill is without merit, but there are provisions within it that de","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4c294c812bc8854d9045e9ca97ed5ce1a2245b8782199085731f9f9a2f27581e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a48fd5dc0b59e32c904ed5cd2730760eab8c809c9aabd0185306c7029fb8ffb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-634618e9de4a93dc29f35e29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036323,"date":"2026-05-29T16:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this morning Canadians learned what many families on Vancouver Island already feel. Canada is now the only G7 country in a recession. The Liberal government's tax hikes, antidevelopment laws and reckless spending have doubled Trudeau's deficit, with Canada now owing over $1.4 trillion. There has been negative economic growth in the last quarter in 2025 and again in the first quarter of 2026. \n\nThe Prime Minister claims that Canada has the best economy in the G7. Reality tells a different story. Every other G7 nation is facing the same tariffs and global headwinds, yet not one of them is in a recession. Only Canada is in a recession. Workers, families and small business owners on Vancouver Island are paying the price for Liberal economic failure and mismanagement. They deserve a government that grows our economy, removes barriers to development and stops loading future generations with debt. \n\nThis recession was a choice and Canadians did not make it. The Liberal Prime Minister did.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036323","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this morning Canadians learned what many families on Vancouver Island already feel. Canada is now the only G7 country in a recession. The Liberal government's tax hikes, antidevelopment laws and reckless spending have doubled Trudeau's deficit, with Canada now owing over $1.4 trillion. There has been negative economic growth in the last quarter in 2025 and again in the first quarter o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff7a7c46a2cfd10d9f89f528815820d794b2702b6a3fca2043344af74a9daeac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["092abd11edd06fe18f1b6417afc9655d7de3d4db75a98ea1f8828337834fab0c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f640e6568f0a3e0f77a1192","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036324,"date":"2026-05-29T17:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am thankful for the opportunity to conclude my remarks. I was speaking about not having a national security strategy for Canada to back up the government's Defence Investment Agency and defence industrial strategy. None of this will work without this key foundation. A procurement architecture cannot be designed for a mission that has never been defined or for threats that have not been assessed. We cannot build an agency to deliver capability to our armed forces when we have not decided what capability Canada actually needs. \n\nThe Minister of National Defence admitted to me in testimony at committee that no consideration of threat assessments, pre-kinetic warfare, grey zone warfare, cognitive operations or PSYOPS is in the defence investment strategy. How could there be? That would require a foundational national security strategy, a strategy the government does not have. \n\nSimply put, the government has put the cart before the horse, and Canadians in uniform will pay the price. Indeed, all of Canada will pay the price. This is the exact opposite of creating a self-reliant and sovereign country. \n\nThe fancy speeches, the hollow announcements and the promises are all illusions. The reality is that it seems as if the Prime Minister is more focused on building his own defence industry oligarchy. \n\nAs Conservatives, we have always stood proudly with the women and men who serve in uniform. We ask them to do dangerous things. We ask them to stand between Canadians and harm. We send them to protect our sovereignty, to serve our allies and to represent our country at its best. The very least we owe them is the right equipment, honestly procured without corruption, without patronage and without a $1-billion slush fund that answers to no one. \n\nVancouver Island is home to both CFB Comox and CFB Esquimalt. The families there are watching, the veterans there are watching and the serving members are watching. They are all starting to see behind the curtain of illusion, and the illusion is starting to crumble. \n\nWe will oppose division 16 of this bill, not because we oppose defence investment, but because we refuse to accept the illusion of it in place of reality. Canada deserves better. Our armed forces deserve better. The people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, who live alongside—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036324","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am thankful for the opportunity to conclude my remarks. I was speaking about not having a national security strategy for Canada to back up the government's Defence Investment Agency and defence industrial strategy. None of this will work without this key foundation. A procurement architecture cannot be designed for a mission that has never been defined or for threats that have not b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0dcb5572b2a2e869a42516eefe0948f0d0e57584d4d3c1c7c126386719a3e4d4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7cd9b0c7590b0f5c050b1d449a409ea0dc01b38a8740e65cd2b8b8818a7e3dcf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3559e1e56252335869ea1cb2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036325,"date":"2026-05-29T17:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite's question was ill-informed. The 2% NATO spending that the government constantly boasts about is truly an illusion. Money was shuffled. The Coast Guard, which is not operationally deployable, was accounted for, and that is not within the NATO regulations. \n\nIn fact, I would like to draw the member opposite's attention to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, the gold and global standard for identifying government and NATO spending, which said that the discrepancy was 0.4%. In other words, Canada has only actually spent, by this gold standard assessment, 1.6%. This is another Liberal illusion, and Canadians need to see that reality. Of note, I will add that Canada was the only country mentioned with such a large discrepancy in our alleged 2% spending. It is shameful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036325","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite's question was ill-informed. The 2% NATO spending that the government constantly boasts about is truly an illusion. Money was shuffled. The Coast Guard, which is not operationally deployable, was accounted for, and that is not within the NATO regulations. \n\nIn fact, I would like to draw the member opposite's attention to the Stockholm International Peace Research I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9757d9a0f12182f26c26f6294b213181b2091bb7784adc2ee0647400eb817873"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3f816cf1eea1f42b7d35c3a3f9cb4919f6990ad98ac66a9761ecd2bc7e323f33"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc54f8d1c2694ce059f84f82","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036327,"date":"2026-05-29T17:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, indeed, there was much fanfare and much excitement from industry as this amazing deal was supposedly announced. This is more illusion, as I alluded to throughout my speech. The Prime Minister of Oz made this great announcement. Let me hold back the curtain and show the reality, right from Saab's press release. On its web page, Saab stated, \"Canada has announced that they will enter into detailed discussions and formal negotiations with Saab [to be potentially] the preferred supplier of Canada's future.... Saab has not signed a contract nor received an order.\"\n\nThat is the reality. Across the way is the illusion, and Canadians are seeing through it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036327","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, indeed, there was much fanfare and much excitement from industry as this amazing deal was supposedly announced. This is more illusion, as I alluded to throughout my speech. The Prime Minister of Oz made this great announcement. Let me hold back the curtain and show the reality, right from Saab's press release. On its web page, Saab stated, \"Canada has announced that they will enter in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["abfc8d241c4adb9ace57d28c2cbbf7457b589da3a835dbabc6a6e88a3d23a5bb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e86af01f331f14f7243bbec5413a67bef5b88e8ebef46f99633f23f68aee086"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8520aabad299325f47ac881a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036328,"date":"2026-05-29T17:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I was looking at nothing but the facts, and I hear the frustration in the member opposite's voice. Clearly, reality is colliding with illusion, and his frustration is building. Let me be clear. With the investments of 1% under the Harper government, they still managed to go to Iraq and Afghanistan, because they had solid, well-founded programs that did not waste money. Right now, we are seeing creative accounting and self-reporting. When the Stockholm Institute reports on actual numbers, we see it is more Liberal illusion, just like their announcements. It is all illusion, and our military is no stronger. In fact, it is weaker under this government's illusion and failure. I am bringing reality.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036328","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I was looking at nothing but the facts, and I hear the frustration in the member opposite's voice. Clearly, reality is colliding with illusion, and his frustration is building. Let me be clear. With the investments of 1% under the Harper government, they still managed to go to Iraq and Afghanistan, because they had solid, well-founded programs that did not waste money. Right now, we a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15f0c2e61d56463f98556354ac4c27bf712fa100ae35703a7ee1fe8e1e9d58f8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a84ba02aeb983966b8998771ed6b1b1f05835d1b401c5eb8a1ea7a3f7902afd3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-284b32a88d71fc47013c5521","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127549,"date":"2026-06-01T16:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to thank the committee for allowing me to be here today. I want to begin by acknowledging someone who will appear before this committee on Wednesday: Ms. Landolt, Kimberly Proctor's aunt. She's agreed to testify because she believes Parliament can do better for families like hers. I ask every member of this committee to hold that in mind as I speak today. Bill C-235 has been tabled in Parliament four times before. In 2019, it passed committee and was set to return to the House for third reading. Then Parliament dissolved, progress died and families kept walking into parole hearing rooms they should never have had to enter. I'm here today to make sure that this does not continue. Let me be precise about what this bill does and does not do. It does not create mandatory minimums, it does not impose new sentences and it is not retroactive. It does give a judge tools—a targeted tool applicable only when abduction, sexual assault and murder were committed against the same victim in the same event. In those cases alone a judge may, after hearing jury input, extend parole ineligibility from 25 years up to a maximum of 40 years. There's full judicial discretion every time. That 40-year ceiling was not chosen arbitrarily. It reflects the consecutive maximum ineligibility periods for all three charges combined. The legal framework is sound. The bill was modelled after Bill C-48 , the multiple murders act, which has already survived a charter challenge. There is a further point that bears directly on that analysis: When a victim was abducted, sexually assaulted and murdered, prosecutors routinely stay the abduction and sexual assault charges and proceed only on murder charges. Under the current law, conviction in all three offences yields the same 25-year ineligibility on the murder alone, so there is no incentive to charge all three. Offenders are, effectively, sentenced only for murder, even when they committed two additional serious crimes. Bill C-235 corrects this. The extended ineligibility is not cruel and unusual punishment; it is proportionate for the three distinct crimes committed in a single incident. I have carefully reviewed the proposed amendments put forward by the party opposite. With respect, I do not believe any of them strengthen the bill. Some are legally redundant. The law already provides what they seek to codify. Some risk making the process more complicated than it needs to be, and some, I would suggest, come close to instructing judges on how to do their jobs, which is precisely the kind of judicial discretion this bill is designed to protect. I'm happy to speak to any of them in detail through questions from the committee. The heinous criminals that this bill targets are never going to be released. We have never found such a case: The Parole Board has been consistent. These are dangerous offenders and psychopaths, but they are permitted to apply for parole every two years, beginning at year 23. They use those hearings not to seek freedom but to terrorize the victims and their families, to recite in gruesome detail what they did, to force families back into that room and crime scene over and over. This bill would eliminate an average of eight of those hearings—eight times a family does not walk back in, eight times a sadistic offender cannot use the process as a weapon against the people he destroyed. Fifteen years ago, 18-year-old Kimberly Proctor was abducted, tortured, sexually assaulted and murdered by her classmates on Vancouver Island. Her killers were charged as adults but, unusually, sentenced under the youth framework, with no chance of parole for 10 years. That outcome falls outside the sentencing scope of this bill, but the parole process that follows, what it costs a family to live through, is exactly what this bill addresses. Her family has already faced multiple parole hearings. They will face more, every two years for the rest of their lives. Ms. Landolt will tell this committee on Wednesday what that costs a family. I will not speak over her testimony. We know the names of the men and women who did these terrible things. Their names are infamous, notorious, and repeated in headlines and courtrooms for decades. Their victims' names are not. These are the names we forget, the names that history has not given the same weight as the monsters who took them: Tori, Holly, Tammy, Leslie, Kristen, Christine, Colleen, Daryn, Sandra, Ada, Simon, Judy, Raymond, Sigrun, Terri, Louise, Sereena, Mona, Andrea, Brenda, Georgina, Marnie and, of course, Kimberly. Their families are still living with what was done to them, and they are still walking into parole hearing rooms they should never have to enter. Together, let's pass Bill C-235 . On Wednesday Ms. Landolt will tell you in her own words what that protection means to a family. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127549","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to thank the committee for allowing me to be here today. I want to begin by acknowledging someone who will appear before this committee on Wednesday: Ms. Landolt, Kimberly Proctor's aunt. She's agreed to testify because she believes Parliament can do better for families like hers. I ask every member of this committee to hold that in mind as I speak today. Bill C-235 ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c77c03c2a84abd1c91381d8c033c3d1a5dba4492e67f409038aa7c7094af6cbb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b2cab7f6cab49bb497730c957d4ebcc7e506a9f05568a23f96f3a5e03809dc9b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9c1e15a9a149d10410262356","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127550,"date":"2026-06-01T16:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"The intent of the bill is that when those crimes are connected in the same series of events, not separated by years or separated at all. I'm certainly open to removing that word. In the case of Kimberly Proctor, it took a period of four or five days, but the events were ongoing and interconnected, so it's events that are interconnected. I am certainly open to removing that word so that there would be no misinterpretation such as that you've expressed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127550","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The intent of the bill is that when those crimes are connected in the same series of events, not separated by years or separated at all. I'm certainly open to removing that word. In the case of Kimberly Proctor, it took a period of four or five days, but the events were ongoing and interconnected, so it's events that are interconnected. I am certainly open to removing that word so that there would","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f14d40003844b0e395b2fa99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127551,"date":"2026-06-01T16:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"It is Paul Bernardo and those types of offenders. I will add further—and you said they get glee—and pardon the term, but it's noted and has been studied and documented that these types of offenders get off on retraumatizing the victims' families. In the Kimberly Proctor case it's even documented that they have shared their crimes in such heinous detail with cellmates that this caused cellmates to have to seek help and be moved. While they know they're never going to be getting out, they actually get off on retraumatizing the families by having a free platform at the parole hearing and going into gruesome detail, as I said in my statement. This is completely wrong and unjust for the families of those I mentioned.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127551","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It is Paul Bernardo and those types of offenders. I will add further—and you said they get glee—and pardon the term, but it's noted and has been studied and documented that these types of offenders get off on retraumatizing the victims' families. In the Kimberly Proctor case it's even documented that they have shared their crimes in such heinous detail with cellmates that this caused cellmates to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["192a1a5e83fb0bc74a7507f306ddc5318ce695958681be08e7a25c4de4c04665"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c76cd267a538ee47053491c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127552,"date":"2026-06-01T16:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"That is correct, and if we go on the past record and the Parole Board's performance, these types of people such as Olson, Bernardo, McClintic, Rafferty and others will not ever get out, but they will, as I said, get off on the gruesome details because they know that they can retraumatize, in this case from a distance. They did it to their victims, and they're doing it to the families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127552","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That is correct, and if we go on the past record and the Parole Board's performance, these types of people such as Olson, Bernardo, McClintic, Rafferty and others will not ever get out, but they will, as I said, get off on the gruesome details because they know that they can retraumatize, in this case from a distance. They did it to their victims, and they're doing it to the families.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["34ba087d29e5dd08fdb710e7caf631d2dba7712422f08632b028cda5f5e4b015"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aaad505ff1b6ad263416afa6c9c53ad79f424bf9d9a63377d567760dd92044c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed614d5e50dd7e7010002744","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127553,"date":"2026-06-01T16:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"As I said in my statement, they would feel that they were being abandoned and that Parliament had let them down. This is the fourth time for this bill. As I said, it was set to pass committee. I hope that it passes committee so that people like Rodney do not have to go through that again and can be spared that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127553","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"As I said in my statement, they would feel that they were being abandoned and that Parliament had let them down. This is the fourth time for this bill. As I said, it was set to pass committee. I hope that it passes committee so that people like Rodney do not have to go through that again and can be spared that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28011d107361016447e5fb7e35ea1b49fedac5da93ed69b132cc6664a01e5a4f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-509a5bfde4d6e1be6286ab0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127554,"date":"2026-06-01T16:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"After the consultations that I did, I felt that we didn't want to take away from our judges who do excellent work. They're the ones who delve into the detail of the cases and get to know the families, the perpetrators and ultimately the criminals. They're best suited, with advice from the juries, to make those decisions. It keeps it out of politics, and it keeps it solely in their hands. It keeps it out of the legislation, and we trust their discretion for the sentencing, whatever it may be, whether it's a period of ineligibility of four years or 10 years. This is designed to trust their discretion. I appreciate your emotion. I just would like to add that, while there are fortunately not many of these cases in Canada, there are still too many, and you can see the impact already in our first two witnesses. They have stories that may not have affected them directly as family members, but the impact is so heinous. You're showing incredible emotion because it was from your area; you're aware of it, so imagine having to hear all of those details as a family member over and over again. How devastating that is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127554","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"After the consultations that I did, I felt that we didn't want to take away from our judges who do excellent work. They're the ones who delve into the detail of the cases and get to know the families, the perpetrators and ultimately the criminals. They're best suited, with advice from the juries, to make those decisions. It keeps it out of politics, and it keeps it solely in their hands. It keeps ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a71c4137bbe1504f1951d01b3722b8ace1fbf2ced55d1ef4d9b3b9a1b12a230c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9f9315a5b1887c195089964e65ec46f58c27e339a8bbc61383518ddb35bd18eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c540c4a6c9582d71f64776b2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127555,"date":"2026-06-01T16:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Absolutely, and I appreciate your question. I'll speak to the first one, prospectivity. The amendment is legally redundant. Charter section 11(i) already prohibits retroactive punishment. All new legislation is prospective by default unless it explicitly states otherwise, which this does not, so this would go forward without being retroactive by default; it's already codified in the law. I don't see any value in it as a pure housekeeping measure, and it would have no effect. I certainly don't object to it, but it's just redundant, in my opinion. As for the National Defence Act, under the National Defence Act, courts martial don't try abduction and murders that are committed in Canada, and the core offences that Bill C-235 targets are those. Military jurisdiction is limited to offences that are committed abroad. It would certainly be worth considering a potential different bill that would address that, but it would be an amendment to the National Defence Act. As for sexual assault, that presently remains within the military. Victims have the choice between either the military or the civilian justice system for now, but recent legislative reform will potentially transfer that jurisdiction to the civilian justice system anyway. The combination of those offences that Bill C-235 , my bill, addresses—abduction, sexual assault and murder—would therefore only potentially apply for overseas cases and, as I said, that would be worthy of being looked at potentially in a separate bill and not conflating the two.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127555","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Absolutely, and I appreciate your question. I'll speak to the first one, prospectivity. The amendment is legally redundant. Charter section 11(i) already prohibits retroactive punishment. All new legislation is prospective by default unless it explicitly states otherwise, which this does not, so this would go forward without being retroactive by default; it's already codified in the law. I don't s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["93fc16b35fe88c68121f5e15e993d66e3c158a493c45b5965ac7dd661caa2ca7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3c4520015af18696dce4ca9adf5d56c64ac7e54079e3f177113f028e932b037"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28fd0bffb5b3f7983fd1a115","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127556,"date":"2026-06-01T16:20:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"That's a good question. The first one was the right of appeal for an offender where a judge would order...extended beyond the 25 years. Extended parole eligibility under Bill C-235 already results from deliberate judicial discretion informed by a jury input. Adding an offender appeal right layers more process onto sentences designed for the most aggravated murder cases. It would undermine the finality and potentially expose victims' families to prolonged litigation, which is precisely what this bill is aiming to protect them from. The Criminal Code already provides for a robust appellate review of sentencing. This amendment, I believe, does not fill that gap. Rather, it would create one.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127556","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's a good question. The first one was the right of appeal for an offender where a judge would order...extended beyond the 25 years. Extended parole eligibility under Bill C-235 already results from deliberate judicial discretion informed by a jury input. Adding an offender appeal right layers more process onto sentences designed for the most aggravated murder cases. It would undermine the fina","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["884ac7884c9fc6a878afe433c17bee61c0155e29155fc4b7f1c41ff04ac70be7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2ffc18e8059f30d94a03331edf387903cd36a07e8e30404313bdde3f8e237e37"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9dc26c953651d54b27f8ab50","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127557,"date":"2026-06-01T16:20:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Judges already provide reasons for their sentencing, whether it's 25 years, 10 years or 40 years in the most heinous cases. This obligation is established in law. A statutory requirement specifically targeting this provision, in my opinion, would imply a distrust of the judiciary. Parliamentarians and Canadians should trust our judiciary. They already include it. Indeed, they give specific answers that are already required. In my mind, it would add procedural weight, and this is designed to be streamlined.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127557","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Judges already provide reasons for their sentencing, whether it's 25 years, 10 years or 40 years in the most heinous cases. This obligation is established in law. A statutory requirement specifically targeting this provision, in my opinion, would imply a distrust of the judiciary. Parliamentarians and Canadians should trust our judiciary. They already include it. Indeed, they give specific answers","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a1db164606994c2d9b3fb77","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127558,"date":"2026-06-01T16:25:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you for the question. We looked at various measures. We wanted to keep this very tight and targeted, such that it would provide deterrence—although deterrence is obviously considered very low when it comes to very heinous individuals. People have said things like, \"Why do the families have to go to the parole hearings?\", but families feel compelled or obliged to give a voice to their loved ones or the victims who are no longer able to speak. That's just one example. Other possibilities do not provide the same effectiveness that we can put into this legislation. There are other ways to mitigate it through the parole process. Legally speaking, this would be a very powerful and effective way to do it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127558","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for the question. We looked at various measures. We wanted to keep this very tight and targeted, such that it would provide deterrence—although deterrence is obviously considered very low when it comes to very heinous individuals. People have said things like, \"Why do the families have to go to the parole hearings?\", but families feel compelled or obliged to give a voice to their loved o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["977198f4ca35bff8551f6f13c894261062421bdb5b563540deaee76039ce3f68"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e79b199713eaafd1245f6cfd69fd5484db8d840c43b4a4164b72a86415dbb438"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4cfae5e96ea480892ac639e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127559,"date":"2026-06-01T16:25:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"That's a fair question, and, yes, I do believe in rehabilitation. More importantly, I believe that criminals found guilty should have the opportunity for rehabilitation. In the Bissonnette case, which was struck down, it was for parole ineligibility periods of 50, 75 and even 100 years. It's very different. In this case, as I mentioned in my presentation, it's just a combination of the total. That's how we arrived at 40 years. There is opportunity for rehabilitation. Furthermore, this was modelled after Bill C-48 , protecting Canadians by ending sentence discounts for multiple murder acts, which also extended ineligibility. It did survive a charter challenge. In the scope of the 40 years, it has survived the charter challenge. It is a long period from the 75 and 100 years within the Bissonnette decision. It allows for the possibility of rehabilitation. However unlikely it may be in this case, I do agree that it is a valid requirement for the possibility of rehabilitation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127559","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's a fair question, and, yes, I do believe in rehabilitation. More importantly, I believe that criminals found guilty should have the opportunity for rehabilitation. In the Bissonnette case, which was struck down, it was for parole ineligibility periods of 50, 75 and even 100 years. It's very different. In this case, as I mentioned in my presentation, it's just a combination of the total. That","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["521fe32959751e95fe966b83a939c702dba583a3fb1ac0f6373df3adc4bdb09f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6d5cf9e559f7d05dc981c72ef35db0dd368d2c8ec3c6883f25fbad3d5f6632c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6184ebec363b7a500195dfe8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127560,"date":"2026-06-01T16:25:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Indeed, I said, \"possibility of rehabilitation\". Regardless, it's not for me to decide what that is. That's what judicial discretion is for. It allows the judges, who know these types of cases and these types of offenders, to be the ones who make those decisions. We should all put our trust in the judiciary to do that. You said that 25 years is not a long time. It's actually at 23 years when offenders can first apply if they're given that chance every two years. However, these are criminals. These are the ones who have taken away lives and who have lasted for more time. The lives that are lost are for more than 25 years. If you're a family member, that 25 years is not a very long period for grieving. As you approach the 23-year period—even in advance of that, as you will hear on Wednesday—preparations in advance of a parole hearing are not just something that turn up at the last minute. There are decisions made, letters received and statements are prepared. It consumes a very long period of time. To summarize, that's not up for us as parliamentarians to decide. That should be with the judiciary.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127560","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Indeed, I said, \"possibility of rehabilitation\". Regardless, it's not for me to decide what that is. That's what judicial discretion is for. It allows the judges, who know these types of cases and these types of offenders, to be the ones who make those decisions. We should all put our trust in the judiciary to do that. You said that 25 years is not a long time. It's actually at 23 years when offen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","label":"Life expectancy","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["626540bea3e66a4891c5fc5ca4ac29772433ba2209e38a0580607c7fe98688c1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bf06463aac6d1777715203cad316f2a51fc581f7e3ea6d090e71c498f2f5c806"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4960256163267c949e1227d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127561,"date":"2026-06-01T16:30:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"I agree with your assessment of crime across Canada. You gave various examples. This bill specifically deals with the most heinous and gruesome criminals. It is focused very much on that. I do agree that victims and families should be put ahead of criminals. I believe very much that this bill does exactly that. I don't really know what else to say beyond that. That is certainly the goal. I think that it will achieve that. We've also seen that in Bill C-48 . You spoke about the court process protecting families. Though not related to this case, my own daughter's boyfriend was murdered. I went with her to trial every day for a fairly long period. The courts were very sympathetic and supportive, but the process can be particularly challenging for families. I have a small window into what families are dealing with in these types of cases, but I wouldn't begin to imagine what they're going through. Regardless of the supports there that you receive, the sympathies that you receive from the Crown and defence prosecutors, and the understanding that they give—I'm not knocking them in any way, because they are positive—it still can be particularly tough on those families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127561","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I agree with your assessment of crime across Canada. You gave various examples. This bill specifically deals with the most heinous and gruesome criminals. It is focused very much on that. I do agree that victims and families should be put ahead of criminals. I believe very much that this bill does exactly that. I don't really know what else to say beyond that. That is certainly the goal. I think t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c71e61e9371d9a0827379edc68125c05dc7aeb1c93e45fa3f022f27ed95dd16"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9308831c0eb8f9e3d74e7fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127562,"date":"2026-06-01T16:30:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"The short answer is, it's about the worst of the worst. It's Clifford Olson, Paul Bernardo and so on. As I said, and I would like to repeat it, fortunately, there are not many of these cases in Canada relative to other crimes, but I think that the impact, as Ms. Gladu showed, is huge for so many people across Canada. This would help bring that support to the families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127562","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The short answer is, it's about the worst of the worst. It's Clifford Olson, Paul Bernardo and so on. As I said, and I would like to repeat it, fortunately, there are not many of these cases in Canada relative to other crimes, but I think that the impact, as Ms. Gladu showed, is huge for so many people across Canada. This would help bring that support to the families.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6a10166b7ba6703968b5191","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127563,"date":"2026-06-01T16:30:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Could you perhaps define for me what a fringe case is? I am not a lawyer. I'm thankful that there are not many of these cases, although every one is too many. They would all be unique. I'm not quite sure what you mean by a fringe case.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127563","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could you perhaps define for me what a fringe case is? I am not a lawyer. I'm thankful that there are not many of these cases, although every one is too many. They would all be unique. I'm not quite sure what you mean by a fringe case.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a4179451eeba8ea67ac8ccae1c70bd0aeddcdb9595d97905cfd7599e9a915b9a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54a4ff75a6cba5104304a439","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127564,"date":"2026-06-01T16:35:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Under a judge's discretion, I think there are many cases where sentencing should be consecutive. Unfortunately, we've seen in a few other areas this has not been approved in the House. For example, I think consecutive sexual assaults should be consecutive. It has to be a balance between deterrence and justice for victims and families, while also allowing for the possibility, however slight it might be, of rehabilitation. I believe that Bill C-235 , although it may sound harsh, based on the harshness of those cases that we've described, finds and meets that balance.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127564","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Under a judge's discretion, I think there are many cases where sentencing should be consecutive. Unfortunately, we've seen in a few other areas this has not been approved in the House. For example, I think consecutive sexual assaults should be consecutive. It has to be a balance between deterrence and justice for victims and families, while also allowing for the possibility, however slight it migh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fe6736bc0af867f73b6ad200be5e4c5312b81f256bac069e280e7d52a69eb104"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4b919bc04b3784332518b20758c96438205f22c459115cab53c099b8da023145"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fa265ff807e7108a1932422","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127565,"date":"2026-06-01T16:35:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"I appreciate your very good play on words. I also couldn't agree more that any new law needs to be taken seriously and scrutinized, such as we're doing through this process in committee and with our witnesses for the next hour. I have nothing against putting in an amendment about making it not retroactive. It's simply redundant and potentially risks setting a precedent for some other case or law. I don't think that it is worth putting in. Perhaps our departmental witnesses could better speak to that, but to me, it's already a law. It is not retroactive. Therefore, it would simply be redundant to put it in. I would keep the legislation cleaner.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127565","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I appreciate your very good play on words. I also couldn't agree more that any new law needs to be taken seriously and scrutinized, such as we're doing through this process in committee and with our witnesses for the next hour. I have nothing against putting in an amendment about making it not retroactive. It's simply redundant and potentially risks setting a precedent for some other case or law. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["708a87224f212aeae1b86f7daecd8cf343d5454b8023504c2736ae27505a0d84"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54f4fa1eef388efaffcca03c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127566,"date":"2026-06-01T16:35:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Why should it be treated any differently from what?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127566","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Why should it be treated any differently from what?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012796","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Bioethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012796","label":"Bioethics","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","label":"Interprovincial relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["730fab51f467f940707feb047d0583dfd2466e962608f459a994a2805a3f42f4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-010427bd57ea983b33a99696","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127567,"date":"2026-06-01T16:35:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Again, I'll state the agreement. It's legally redundant. Charter section 11, provision 11(i) already prohibits retroactive punishment, and all new legislation is prospective by default unless it explicitly states otherwise, which this bill does not. Codifying prospectivity on the face of the bill could invite litigation over the line between clarification and limitation, potentially narrowing the bill's reach in ways Parliament may not have intended. That said, if the committee views it as a pure housekeeping and an important measure, while it has no substantive effect, I don't have a serious objection to it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127567","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Again, I'll state the agreement. It's legally redundant. Charter section 11, provision 11(i) already prohibits retroactive punishment, and all new legislation is prospective by default unless it explicitly states otherwise, which this bill does not. Codifying prospectivity on the face of the bill could invite litigation over the line between clarification and limitation, potentially narrowing the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5614f522db167faadb8f2e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127568,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"That's fair enough. I appreciate your question. As far as mandatory reasons into a decision are concerned, a judge already provides reasons in the sentencing. It's an obligation that's established in law. A statutory requirement specifically targeting this provision implies distrust of the judiciary, and it may invite formulaic compliance rather than genuine deliberation. It also adds procedural weight to a mechanism deliberately designed to be streamlined and victim-centric. If the committee finds comfort in making this explicit in the language, it certainly would have to be very carefully drafted to avoid constraining the very judicial system the bill was designed to create. I feel that it is not necessary, and it would certainly be a fair question to pose of our departmental witnesses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127568","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's fair enough. I appreciate your question. As far as mandatory reasons into a decision are concerned, a judge already provides reasons in the sentencing. It's an obligation that's established in law. A statutory requirement specifically targeting this provision implies distrust of the judiciary, and it may invite formulaic compliance rather than genuine deliberation. It also adds procedural w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9be51b5d9be210155c3be5823172dae898ed8a7c91e92e3341b92ef93b4dc365"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ce2e5987133f02ef670570ae40cce6b89955aa36c8f374588800d503db41bc0a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8048e40fdf743f4605ce53c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127569,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"I'm not here to second-guess what the parole boards do. They're very capable of making decisions. You said 10% and 27%, but these cases that I'm speaking about are a very small percentage of those. In the research we've done, we were not able to find anyone whom the Parole Board has allowed to be set free in this very tight and narrow scope of crimes. Again, it is also left to the judge's discretion to come up with the correct sentencing that would determine when a person would be eligible for parole. There may be cases where it would be after only 12 years, and I would respect that judge's decision.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127569","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm not here to second-guess what the parole boards do. They're very capable of making decisions. You said 10% and 27%, but these cases that I'm speaking about are a very small percentage of those. In the research we've done, we were not able to find anyone whom the Parole Board has allowed to be set free in this very tight and narrow scope of crimes. Again, it is also left to the judge's discreti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a26149b0ad86df4a90ae727f37440200578dd1559aeed5eaeca510e61dcf2376"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["de4e234b81b0efac04129b59fc85a5e629e99b52ee288f9115e2dbf10b01b426"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-572bf953ba07b27ee62720df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127570,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"It's a bit loaded because, as I said, in these cases, we've seen that the parole boards have not found any of them to be suitable for rehabilitation. Yes, to moving it from 25 to 40 years. If somebody had committed these crimes all in a row, independently, with different victims over the course of a week, they would get 40 years. In this case, because it's all the same victim at the same time, the judge stays the abduction. They stay the sexual assault charge. They just prosecute the one, because they're all connected. The perpetrator would be getting 40 years if these were separate cases, but because this is all in one, it's only 25 years. I'm glad to hear your agreement. We have a solid agreement here that we do trust the court's wisdom, the judiciary with input from the judges, to decide when that opportunity for rehabilitation is. I will leave it to the discretion of the judiciary and then the parole boards to make those decisions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127570","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's a bit loaded because, as I said, in these cases, we've seen that the parole boards have not found any of them to be suitable for rehabilitation. Yes, to moving it from 25 to 40 years. If somebody had committed these crimes all in a row, independently, with different victims over the course of a week, they would get 40 years. In this case, because it's all the same victim at the same time, the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b3d4be540709fda23f72da8cf6f994e77211ac983c867879e23ba4be77d6881b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["23414e54ae8224b6b2877b26707178d8c07bf13d8ab12bfcb74b47a6d39e8c84"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5758023d7aeb8f9241195996","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127571,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Baber, for your kind words and thoughtfulness. It means a lot, and I appreciate that. Yes. I will just add that it also requires the same victim and being found guilty of abduction, sexual assault and murder in the same incident, absolutely. Then it would be at a judge's discretion to determine, in the specifics of that case, the length of parole ineligibility. Regardless, there's always a life sentence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127571","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Baber, for your kind words and thoughtfulness. It means a lot, and I appreciate that. Yes. I will just add that it also requires the same victim and being found guilty of abduction, sexual assault and murder in the same incident, absolutely. Then it would be at a judge's discretion to determine, in the specifics of that case, the length of parole ineligibility. Regardless, there's a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4c57b50ece8f961d7472a988311a5a4fd619c10df9f525e673af9d68e6b144e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e94b8a64a0657d8b10ff07a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127572,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Absolutely. As I alluded to earlier, for these types of heinous criminals there is little deterrence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127572","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Absolutely. As I alluded to earlier, for these types of heinous criminals there is little deterrence.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b30a7be674db0172c132db36f152d3fb07ffcb0bc758be51220b6abe273f7d25"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-755029024dc95d629cd37f25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127573,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"If I could finish quickly, the focus is absolutely on the families, which is why my statement focused on the impact that it has on the families. I'm going to a parole hearing in an unrelated case, to support a constituent. I will be able to experience some of the trauma that he's experienced. You're absolutely right. The focus is on the families, preventing the revictimization caused by bringing the families back to the parole hearing where they're in the same room as this heinous criminal and have to hear in gruesome detail from someone about what they did to their loved one who has no voice anymore. Those heinous criminals, as I stated, get off on sharing those details as gruesomely as they can to impact the families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127573","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If I could finish quickly, the focus is absolutely on the families, which is why my statement focused on the impact that it has on the families. I'm going to a parole hearing in an unrelated case, to support a constituent. I will be able to experience some of the trauma that he's experienced. You're absolutely right. The focus is on the families, preventing the revictimization caused by bringing t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c86f5437633a54a820399dce1d4a527174990528d12ed29aaeed26732ecfbab2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a5afd6103907bb866e926ffb8fccf98157ee2bd1edc47b981b32e7c0f39be131"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89b55fab102cdf551d416558","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127574,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Yes, thank you for putting that together. I appreciate your excellent math at 39.6 years, which we rounded to 40. As I answered earlier, if a criminal had committed those three crimes separately, one day after the other with three separate victims, and they were found guilty in all three, they would be facing that type of time, potentially. Of course, that's up to a judge's discretion. Second-degree murder and high treason certainly don't apply in this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127574","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, thank you for putting that together. I appreciate your excellent math at 39.6 years, which we rounded to 40. As I answered earlier, if a criminal had committed those three crimes separately, one day after the other with three separate victims, and they were found guilty in all three, they would be facing that type of time, potentially. Of course, that's up to a judge's discretion. Second-degr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4043d2304154f17742aea6e5ea48db8512f06d5b42ad2f272454dfa8aae3c1dc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c1a50d1e9a84488ad58b964bd5aba034b6a891ba7af4bd682cd081b150f34589"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-585dc76404817ef87a8f3ad6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127575,"date":"2026-06-01T16:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you. I appreciate that there's little time for my answer. I'll be very concise. This is not about mandatory minimums. These are people who are getting life sentences. They may never get out. It's just the parole ineligibility period. It has passed the charter challenge, as it is modelled after Bill C-48 , and yes, these are the worst of the worst. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127575","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I appreciate that there's little time for my answer. I'll be very concise. This is not about mandatory minimums. These are people who are getting life sentences. They may never get out. It's just the parole ineligibility period. It has passed the charter challenge, as it is modelled after Bill C-48 , and yes, these are the worst of the worst. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-093a59152d1f250ec168def8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127576,"date":"2026-06-01T16:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"I very much appreciate your kind words. I offer you much respect, as well, for chairing the committee previously. I know you worked on that bill, so you would have a very solid knowledge. Also, thank you for signalling your support. Your question refers to amendments. I'm certainly open to amendments. For me, it's very important that procedurally and legally it is done in the correct way, so that's what I would want to support. I believe that some do interfere with the process, but I would defer to the departmental experts. It would be best to ask them those questions. I'm certainly open to amendments—not amendments that would provide certainty for parliamentarians but, rather, amendments from departmental officials that would provide accuracy, as recommended, and be procedurally correct. I certainly am open to that. If that is what it takes to get certainty for our parliamentarians, I'm certainly open to that. I've offered my assessment of those based on what I've been able to research, not as a lawyer but as a former naval officer. I certainly will defer and be very open to any potential improvements, corrections or accuracy that departmental witnesses could provide.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127576","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I very much appreciate your kind words. I offer you much respect, as well, for chairing the committee previously. I know you worked on that bill, so you would have a very solid knowledge. Also, thank you for signalling your support. Your question refers to amendments. I'm certainly open to amendments. For me, it's very important that procedurally and legally it is done in the correct way, so that'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c2a5f756199f99a84e73a7205d5b29f468ec0f26d544fbbea9ade5511dd72a0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-418d403d25aafd20b7b69cd0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127577,"date":"2026-06-01T16:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"That's an excellent question, and I thank you for that. As someone who sat through a trial that touched my family and as someone who has seen and learned the process of a jury giving a recommendation, I think it's hugely valuable. The jury members generally don't have a legal background, but they're a temperature for the community, and what they provide is very important. I know that some have said in discussions that it should be only the judge who should do that. I think the jury's input is important. Of course the judge, as you know, has the ability to determine the period of ineligibility, but he takes and considers their input after very detailed instructions to the jury. Having seen that process, I think it's a very valuable process and should certainly continue. I support that fully.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127577","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's an excellent question, and I thank you for that. As someone who sat through a trial that touched my family and as someone who has seen and learned the process of a jury giving a recommendation, I think it's hugely valuable. The jury members generally don't have a legal background, but they're a temperature for the community, and what they provide is very important. I know that some have sai","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["990ba2ed7b9f8aa6588059774d2a502da076bcac5a36146a0e4e5bb6bf25d909"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["92e0cd3cf204e36329a826b999f4ceee91230f62c1614a7add96e886255f5cab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c907c632562c901c1f15b41c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127578,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"I drafted it a fairly long time ago. There were some minor amendments as it went through the legislators, but they were small and technical. It's nearly identical. It was Bill C-266 in the 42nd, Bill C-296 in the 44th, Bill C-478 in the 41st.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127578","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I drafted it a fairly long time ago. There were some minor amendments as it went through the legislators, but they were small and technical. It's nearly identical. It was Bill C-266 in the 42nd, Bill C-296 in the 44th, Bill C-478 in the 41st.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f531f1a3e9efea28e428459f761933c5210bfa7bb6e2c2be163f35dab3eeda5e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc4ef920856a6e233ec18b59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127579,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"I'm fully confident, and thank you for the question. It is modelled after Bill C-48 , which did pass a constitutional challenge. As a result of input from my colleagues and lawyers and people who helped us work on this bill through its previous iterations, I am very confident that it will pass any potential charter challenge.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127579","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm fully confident, and thank you for the question. It is modelled after Bill C-48 , which did pass a constitutional challenge. As a result of input from my colleagues and lawyers and people who helped us work on this bill through its previous iterations, I am very confident that it will pass any potential charter challenge.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86d4caa41e9f5c6db2fc2d5a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127580,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Absolutely, I would. As I said earlier, when I spoke against some of the amendments, it was to make it correct. If there's something that is going to make it better and stronger—and it's not just somebody's crazy idea, but actually a solid, recommended, proven and debated amendment that would achieve the goal of protecting families, which is ultimately the goal—I would absolutely consider it. That's very important, and it would be foolish not to do it. We've tried to consider everything in the drafting of this production over many years, but if there's something that could make it better, then by all means, yes. Thank you again for signalling your broad support for our objectives here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127580","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Absolutely, I would. As I said earlier, when I spoke against some of the amendments, it was to make it correct. If there's something that is going to make it better and stronger—and it's not just somebody's crazy idea, but actually a solid, recommended, proven and debated amendment that would achieve the goal of protecting families, which is ultimately the goal—I would absolutely consider it. That","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78af306899695a9b7c2ab28d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127581,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"I'm not exactly sure how to answer that. If there is anything that would make it better and achieve the objective, without broadening the scope of it, because I think that would get into a whole more complicated process.... If it would keep it tight to the scope of the specific crimes and circumstances of this and achieve results for the families—you will hear the impact on them on Wednesday—I'm certainly open to discussing and making improvements, if required.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127581","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm not exactly sure how to answer that. If there is anything that would make it better and achieve the objective, without broadening the scope of it, because I think that would get into a whole more complicated process.... If it would keep it tight to the scope of the specific crimes and circumstances of this and achieve results for the families—you will hear the impact on them on Wednesday—I'm c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d62e12406e783e9d8954228","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127582,"date":"2026-06-01T17:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"First of all, I believe it will withstand a charter challenge. As far as speaking on a notwithstanding clause is concerned, that would be above...it would need a government-wide or a party-wide consultation to determine the best path forward. I am confident that this will, as Bill C-48 did, withstand a charter challenge. We'll cross that bridge if we get there, but I don't expect that we will.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127582","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"First of all, I believe it will withstand a charter challenge. As far as speaking on a notwithstanding clause is concerned, that would be above...it would need a government-wide or a party-wide consultation to determine the best path forward. I am confident that this will, as Bill C-48 did, withstand a charter challenge. We'll cross that bridge if we get there, but I don't expect that we will.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88c1b7ca8cfd39a9b888ae3402f985196124dd7377d235fe2be0c88f6d71a424"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de93793993471604857f9bdb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127583,"date":"2026-06-01T17:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Modifying the process to help families outside of legislation covers only part of what this legislation does. That would certainly be an independent project, which I'm sure people are always considering and looking at. Let's stay focused on what this is. This legislation is about helping the families, providing potential deterrence and ensuring that all three of those charges would then be answered for and dealt with in court, and not just stayed. There are other processes, and they're independent and separate from this. We're staying focused on this particular process so that we can help victims with something that is within our power. If parole boards or other organizations look to help families, I commend that as well, but I'm staying focused on this particular mission.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127583","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Modifying the process to help families outside of legislation covers only part of what this legislation does. That would certainly be an independent project, which I'm sure people are always considering and looking at. Let's stay focused on what this is. This legislation is about helping the families, providing potential deterrence and ensuring that all three of those charges would then be answere","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fda4e38f49f7934db80e3fcd98ac4556b1cc8437f80f9c76e9860ccb74021ca6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf6938de41ff6cffd3200347","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127731,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's great to have such a large panel of witnesses today. I'm requesting that they make their answers short. I have three questions, and I'm going to try to hear from each. Could you name a document—the single most recent Canadian government planning document—that your firm or organization actually uses to forecast defence demand, and the year it's from?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127731","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's great to have such a large panel of witnesses today. I'm requesting that they make their answers short. I have three questions, and I'm going to try to hear from each. Could you name a document—the single most recent Canadian government planning document—that your firm or organization actually uses to forecast defence demand, and the year it's from?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0428319457406fa4d9e437d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127732,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Is there a planning document to guide you to the capabilities of what you're building or particular products? Is there any document that you can name that's helping you plan your business?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127732","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is there a planning document to guide you to the capabilities of what you're building or particular products? Is there any document that you can name that's helping you plan your business?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501180","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501180","label":"Business services","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f18c49c2edb1860f0db4a2414c36d35bbd9d5e0cb7cd7a5e39783c13778d65f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fa9c656f34e50343cffd19e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127733,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Is there no document particularly you can name?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127733","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is there no document particularly you can name?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a0951bbf9ffb324d1a1b049","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127734,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127734","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88d4c7d67cd0fdfccdd23b4d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127735,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127735","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-abefec01c7a205eda61e950c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127736,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127736","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab9fc1f285c5e102f14ea781","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127737,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm going to try to squeeze in another one here. I have two left. Again from left to right, have you signed any new military contracts since May 2025? I'm not referring to an MOU or that you entered into a discussion or talks, or stuff that we've seen, but an actual signed contract with dollars and work started for the government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127737","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm going to try to squeeze in another one here. I have two left. Again from left to right, have you signed any new military contracts since May 2025? I'm not referring to an MOU or that you entered into a discussion or talks, or stuff that we've seen, but an actual signed contract with dollars and work started for the government.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fa449cfb2ae18a931d671c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127738,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Go ahead, briefly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127738","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Go ahead, briefly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-797eed217e7179bdfaa7ec27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127739,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Is it an agreement with a signed contract with dollars flowing? Is this agreement signed with a contract?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127739","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is it an agreement with a signed contract with dollars flowing? Is this agreement signed with a contract?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e9ee2a63c35a214413270709667126d5b61d1d9cfc84985276279279c51e3139"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0e2aaf0686b40af40e643ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127740,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Since May...?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127740","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Since May...?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ccb14a15f382b4d2aecc037","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127741,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"It was October. Okay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127741","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It was October. Okay.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b7489075f0ad567633131f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127742,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. Very quickly then, we seem to be missing a national security policy as the foundation, the guidance, the threat assessment and the strategic assessment that would underpin or be the foundation for the defence industrial strategy, and then the Defence Investment Agency, to get those contracts going and focus on what the particular needs are. In my opinion what I'm seeing is that it seems to be more willy-nilly all over the place as opposed to focused on what we need collectively as a country, not for your individual organizations. My quick-answer question in the time that I have remaining is this: Would procurement planning, coordination and co-operation, focused and efficient and national in effect, be better, in your opinion, if we had an underpinning national security policy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127742","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Very quickly then, we seem to be missing a national security policy as the foundation, the guidance, the threat assessment and the strategic assessment that would underpin or be the foundation for the defence industrial strategy, and then the Defence Investment Agency, to get those contracts going and focus on what the particular needs are. In my opinion what I'm seeing is that it seems","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e264f5344f014b420a9977a6cab185ac0a517aa78192c81558df199d2947db89"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6fcd69c1c49ee5503207145a20a42b854c04cf4cfe5a917ba118853335665d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ead2dad522c8377b1d8f1e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127743,"date":"2026-06-01T17:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I would agree.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127743","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would agree.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-201dd53bf102ce618f99286c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127744,"date":"2026-06-01T17:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"I agree. Thank you very much for your comment. Do I have any time left, Mr. Chair?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127744","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I agree. Thank you very much for your comment. Do I have any time left, Mr. Chair?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","label":"Gender equality","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9563f9786e1a5c5a3379de4c02178df156e3c5f96bf0767dc78cdc576ccf33b9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0d6f9b8f5ce2dd22f846d9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127745,"date":"2026-06-01T17:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"This is a first. My last question here will be really quick now. We don't have a national inventory of capability, production, companies, assets, etc., the national inventory of everything. We don't have that. I brought this up before. Again, I know it might not be within your own silo of what you do, but in terms of effectively coordinating and efficiently using our dollars, do you think that would be of benefit and something for the government to have to help better plan?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127745","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This is a first. My last question here will be really quick now. We don't have a national inventory of capability, production, companies, assets, etc., the national inventory of everything. We don't have that. I brought this up before. Again, I know it might not be within your own silo of what you do, but in terms of effectively coordinating and efficiently using our dollars, do you think that wou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-605b0a48507022c78da40053","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127746,"date":"2026-06-01T17:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's a shared national inventory. Go ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127746","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's a shared national inventory. Go ahead.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f793d49a319f3569c1f82d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127747,"date":"2026-06-01T17:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do we have time for a quick one?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127747","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do we have time for a quick one?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf2aa53b35a71b45340e9fcd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127584,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all of the witnesses for being here. Thank you to the members from Vic PD for your input on amendments. We're certainly open to considering those. I think they will come in the line-by-line portion. I'd also really like to thank you, Jo-Anne, for your courage, sharing your story, being here to support and, most importantly, speaking to the impact of those parole hearings. I know you've been advocating for many years for both education and other law reforms. This ties almost directly to your case, although there were some minor changes. The main focus is helping us best understand the impact this bill will have. Maybe you could describe in your own words the parole hearing process and what it has meant for your family emotionally and practically. We discussed a few points, but if you could, please share some of those, and then I might remind you of some of the things we discussed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127584","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all of the witnesses for being here. Thank you to the members from Vic PD for your input on amendments. We're certainly open to considering those. I think they will come in the line-by-line portion. I'd also really like to thank you, Jo-Anne, for your courage, sharing your story, being here to support and, most importantly, speaking to the impact of those parole ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d71ed41e2194103ca4838d6e4cf1408acce12eef1420e82f8503d216be4d5f20"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e6c9d6c0def9d1d5e3db749728d289d201425c4fa7221a14d00f5fda0554f127"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b506f859e3930cb7b3ebb0ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127585,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"I have another quick question. Please accept all of our deepest sympathies for what has happened to your family, and thank you for being such an amazing spokesperson for your family. I know it has such an impact on them that you've stepped up to a very difficult role. You've spoken about the timeline and the pressures coming and leading up to the hearing. I apologize if this is too sensitive a question. Without getting into too much detail, how do you feel when you're in the actual hearing, with the offender in front of you, having to relive that and giving that voice for your family member who doesn't have a voice anymore? You have to hear this stuff.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127585","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have another quick question. Please accept all of our deepest sympathies for what has happened to your family, and thank you for being such an amazing spokesperson for your family. I know it has such an impact on them that you've stepped up to a very difficult role. You've spoken about the timeline and the pressures coming and leading up to the hearing. I apologize if this is too sensitive a que","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hearing disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","label":"Hearing disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["296a6b9af234517be60473f746de178da022758166243b5e859ba7bef45ab8fc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eea13b90318ada7449b6c0a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127586,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you. When we were talking earlier today, you actually received a notification on parole, and I could see your stress level shooting up. Some people have suggested alternatives to make the parole process better, including attending remotely. You described to me how, during COVID, you had to attend remotely. Could you share if that was better or worse, in terms of the impact on your family?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127586","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. When we were talking earlier today, you actually received a notification on parole, and I could see your stress level shooting up. Some people have suggested alternatives to make the parole process better, including attending remotely. You described to me how, during COVID, you had to attend remotely. Could you share if that was better or worse, in terms of the impact on your family?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["19e194ccf683810ed36b3aadae3dc50dc4c7406823e7173dd683af665f90cb4d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5239de419969f893a5cb1fc62bcceea0efdde9fc3be79bab7d8739cc6dd91689"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32392b11ca318e444ae2063c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127587,"date":"2026-06-03T22:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much for your courage and your compassion, and for stepping up as a spokesperson for Kimmy and your family. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127587","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much for your courage and your compassion, and for stepping up as a spokesperson for Kimmy and your family. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64e1cd067652564660902e940a9e7b05914d27a5ea60a2fdf53dced2ad209d34"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7cb7fd15fcbe43aec24ab290","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127748,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our panel for their interesting information. Ms. Hadwen, you mentioned the 3.5% NATO GDP goal of spending. What year was that for, if you could refresh my memory?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127748","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to our panel for their interesting information. Ms. Hadwen, you mentioned the 3.5% NATO GDP goal of spending. What year was that for, if you could refresh my memory?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f9175ae42f5a08ef6aa3f8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127749,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"In 2030.... Thank you. Right now, the government has self-reported 2% spending to NATO. Are you aware that this is not verified by NATO, but that it's just self-reporting, and NATO accepts that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127749","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In 2030.... Thank you. Right now, the government has self-reported 2% spending to NATO. Are you aware that this is not verified by NATO, but that it's just self-reporting, and NATO accepts that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","label":"Military communications","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["af743068381c87812474b5c3af87c6433f1ad04574f1f85be867ce0f30004bb9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a41f53714b5097ede58d9cff3da7d7184f92e80fc19ac699deb82eba34c3d820"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-624b0f36b803222f32ce55db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127750,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"It's the 2% that's self-reported to NATO. They just say, \"Okay. Yes, we accept that.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127750","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's the 2% that's self-reported to NATO. They just say, \"Okay. Yes, we accept that.\"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f94c22a9ca7e22fc40bbd1ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127751,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"It meets all NATO standards. In the NATO standard, it says that coast guards would be required to deploy to an operational theatre. They need to have that capability to be counted under that 2% spending, whereas our Coast Guard, as we've heard under testimony, is definitely not capable. I'm giving that as one example of not meeting the proper spending in it's self-reporting to NATO. In fact, I would refer to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, which is the global standard on determining government spending. They've singled out Canada, saying that we've only actually spent 1.5% that has met the NATO spending requirement. We have not met it, according to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute's study, and we have been singled out by them. What makes up that other...? That's a lot of money—another 0.5% of our GDP—that doesn't qualify as NATO spending, according to them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127751","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It meets all NATO standards. In the NATO standard, it says that coast guards would be required to deploy to an operational theatre. They need to have that capability to be counted under that 2% spending, whereas our Coast Guard, as we've heard under testimony, is definitely not capable. I'm giving that as one example of not meeting the proper spending in it's self-reporting to NATO. In fact, I wou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["725d26e6fd8f8b4a66e2a7ddf4c0d06e932aff1d6188441c598a5ca34d4cb86a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41bd1f1466bc6eba8a07407a083fb1b031a34027bcdd5d09f4804227b5e39932"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9fe92c439ee60390e96af8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127752,"date":"2026-06-03T22:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay, that's fair. Is there anyone else on the panel who could explain how that half a per cent of Canada's GDP simply does not meet the requirements of NATO? Is there no one? Okay. I'd like to move on to a different topic. We talked about maximizing spending and the efficient spending of dollars for the defence investment strategy, and I think that's commendable. We also want to get the right things that we need. However, testimony from industry leaders we had here earlier at the committee was that there was no national security plan. They agreed with me that with no national security plan and no national capability inventory, it makes it very difficult for them to work together and to determine what we need to purchase for Canada. Would you agree, then, that we are missing a national security plan as the underpinning to determine what we need in terms of the proper equipment and the capabilities that we wish to bring forward? Perhaps Ms. Folkes can start.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127752","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay, that's fair. Is there anyone else on the panel who could explain how that half a per cent of Canada's GDP simply does not meet the requirements of NATO? Is there no one? Okay. I'd like to move on to a different topic. We talked about maximizing spending and the efficient spending of dollars for the defence investment strategy, and I think that's commendable. We also want to get the right thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["39d0770094351951c0fb656d9d0c7d1d7b98f28fe53e317a38b9f47d2e1cc019"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50c87fb50ae7199b26fb531a17d63a330d74fea45e12747eb45c97ad88f25094"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7db23e6c263c8f254bab408b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127753,"date":"2026-06-03T23:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. Very quickly, then, a national security plan would look at things like cognitive warfare, prekinetic threats, coercive trade, election interference and organized crime. These are things that would determine the threats Canada is facing. I see none of that in the defence investment strategy. Industry has pointed out that we need this national security plan to efficiently guide us. We can buy these tanks, these ships or those rifles, but if we don't know what it is that we need, it does not seem to meet.... I don't know if anyone would agree, but as Ms. Hembroff said, we want to maximize the efficient spending of our money. Without that underpinning, without assessing all these multiple threats that we face, it seems to be willy-nilly. Would anyone agree or disagree with that? If you disagree, why?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127753","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Very quickly, then, a national security plan would look at things like cognitive warfare, prekinetic threats, coercive trade, election interference and organized crime. These are things that would determine the threats Canada is facing. I see none of that in the defence investment strategy. Industry has pointed out that we need this national security plan to efficiently guide us. We can","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3b7cd63ab2d0727d03a56d5de04bd01acc131989466f5c7caea14c56e48098f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3bb3a0a583bef6068c6b476e5322bdbf9e02ef69d60369196f26533dcacc403f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d44bfa81710a3aa8324b321","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127754,"date":"2026-06-03T23:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Does it include some of those threats? Are they even addressed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127754","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Does it include some of those threats? Are they even addressed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d82571fb767afa0e00bff0f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127755,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. How much time do I have, Mr. Chair?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127755","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. How much time do I have, Mr. Chair?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1bd37abe32be497a76a83beafeb0e289b668e60e124dd12e74988d27bafb93f6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f0f7b1a21b96841bf9371291","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127756,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Perfect. Mr. Brandao, you called the defence industrial strategy the North Star. The North Star tells you which way to steer. Could you tell the committee to which current published threat assessment the strategy is anchored?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127756","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Perfect. Mr. Brandao, you called the defence industrial strategy the North Star. The North Star tells you which way to steer. Could you tell the committee to which current published threat assessment the strategy is anchored?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-740307130eaa963a21cd1ac6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127757,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"NDDN","text":"Was there any threat assessment? I listed a whole bunch of them: cognitive warfare, prekinetic threats, coercive trade, etc. We're steering towards the North Star without any guidance on these threats. Was it purely figurative? I'm still at a loss.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127757","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Was there any threat assessment? I listed a whole bunch of them: cognitive warfare, prekinetic threats, coercive trade, etc. We're steering towards the North Star without any guidance on these threats. Was it purely figurative? I'm still at a loss.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015021","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Biological weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015021","label":"Biological weapons","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5998991e0042e23e8a577728abea24a439846f7740071a68c97aec233f844e7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83befa3fcf63cf1e3c3754af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086452,"date":"2026-06-08T19:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country in a recession, and in the past few days, we have learned much more about how dire the state of our economy is under his watch. On Saturday night, in a Lake Cowichan pub, workers told me their biggest worry was affording groceries, but the Liberals' recycled grocery stunt cuts off at only $59,000 for a couple, meaning that full-time workers are shut out.\n\nThe Prime Minister laughed at suffering Canadians in this House last week. Will he stop laughing and start caring so that Canadians can afford to eat?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086452","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country in a recession, and in the past few days, we have learned much more about how dire the state of our economy is under his watch. On Saturday night, in a Lake Cowichan pub, workers told me their biggest worry was affording groceries, but the Liberals' recycled grocery stunt cuts off at only $59,000 for a couple, meaning th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a685da0b5b9a472523a144bf4bd3d16170dd16cb19cafe9253e7cd5666e18a0f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f33534f3837f376728c66c10e5cf096b24de7145240e7e519895f77946e5ceb8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0660861cead557a3278a1026","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086453,"date":"2026-06-08T22:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, behind every announcement from the government is a problem getting worse, whether it is crime, debt or the cost of ordinary life. Canadians have stopped taking Liberal promises on faith because they are now measuring them against their own reality. They fall short every time.\n\nWhen will the government and the member address that they cannot announce their way out of results—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086453","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, behind every announcement from the government is a problem getting worse, whether it is crime, debt or the cost of ordinary life. Canadians have stopped taking Liberal promises on faith because they are now measuring them against their own reality. They fall short every time.\n\nWhen will the government and the member address that they cannot announce their way out of results—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4f799a2d0d0b07db30384f1d31e9dd9f6dd276b3b007ea98c13bf11132c46f0b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8bc7eba99ed7883771544c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086454,"date":"2026-06-08T23:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member is from Halifax, where I served many years in the navy.\n\nThis is $50 billion for the \"most ambitious defence rebuild in a generation\", ships, submarines, fighter jets, the Defence Investment Agency and the defence investment strategy. It all sounds impressive. Here is the reality. The Liberals have left Canada with no national security strategy or national defence strategy. Experts, and even worse, our allies are calling us out. Indeed, the Liberals' own \"Our North, Strong and Free\" plan, which is not a strategy, calls for Canada to have a national security strategy every four years, yet we have none.\n\nDoes the member for Halifax agree that they are putting the cart before the horse and that, without a national security strategy, the DIA and the DIS are doomed to fail?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086454","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member is from Halifax, where I served many years in the navy.\n\nThis is $50 billion for the \"most ambitious defence rebuild in a generation\", ships, submarines, fighter jets, the Defence Investment Agency and the defence investment strategy. It all sounds impressive. Here is the reality. The Liberals have left Canada with no national security strategy or national defence strategy.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","label":"Military technology","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e2688de8bc20546fc39bd5ac10726658eb3747b3d3cab2783e4ee97e6688dab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02e7611f28d61fe6224f9a6a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086448,"date":"2026-06-09T19:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today, I rise to honour a man who has spent a lifetime proving that success means nothing unless one shares it. Bob Saunders has been called a perennial booster of good things, a title that is well earned.\n\n From founding Saunders Subaru to supporting arts, youth, sports, health care, veterans and education across Vancouver Island, Bob has never stopped giving back. I can speak to this personally. As a former Wounded Warriors Canada team runner, I have seen first-hand what Bob's generosity means to those who carried the weight of service long after coming home, not just in dollars, but in dignity, hope and healing. Bob believes that paying it forward and civic-minded people who lead by example inspire the next generation of community leaders. He has lived every word of that and he has inspired me. \n\nRecently, I had the honour of joining Bob and his beloved Norma at a Victoria Shamrocks season opener, celebrating 70 years of marriage and 70 years of making our island better. On behalf of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford and those across Vancouver Island, I thank Bob, Norma and the entire Saunders family. Their legacy is written in the lives that they have changed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086448","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today, I rise to honour a man who has spent a lifetime proving that success means nothing unless one shares it. Bob Saunders has been called a perennial booster of good things, a title that is well earned.\n\n From founding Saunders Subaru to supporting arts, youth, sports, health care, veterans and education across Vancouver Island, Bob has never stopped giving back. I can speak to thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3496a5a83da1c51f0abc51dc7dd02f172e80efef23c8db4d932370d426459798"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bbbb1ff39c0cb6cb381d5bea59c4271a70c55da829450ece885a790d26ac0da7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d80682cbd3721a62cd57a7c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086449,"date":"2026-06-10T02:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the protecting victims act would remove mandatory minimums. It would give judges that freedom. My question for the member opposite is very short. When a victim's offender walks out of—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086449","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the protecting victims act would remove mandatory minimums. It would give judges that freedom. My question for the member opposite is very short. When a victim's offender walks out of—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7b27384e620da188733aabc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086450,"date":"2026-06-10T02:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for both his compassion and his expertise.\n\nThe member examined the fine print of the bill. The party opposite stands here promising to restore mandatory minimums, and on the very next page, would hand the judges' clauses to sentence below them, and no proportionality test. The Supreme Court told us in the Senneville case exactly how to draft minimums that survive. The bill ignored that road map.\n\nMy question for my colleague is simple. When a victim's offender walks out at below the minimum sentence under the bill, who does he believe the party opposite will blame, the court or the bill that was written to let this happen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086450","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for both his compassion and his expertise.\n\nThe member examined the fine print of the bill. The party opposite stands here promising to restore mandatory minimums, and on the very next page, would hand the judges' clauses to sentence below them, and no proportionality test. The Supreme Court told us in the Senneville case exactly how to draft minimums that survive","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["21ef32e2035494816a642f3f209ac0013053b9fa85acb5b953dd2db2d710e367"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7fc44b6474d7404602ec67795bf65fc0a30f9ceba9e9b49e1d7c168bdd5c6c04"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b05d9195d423a119743cd484","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086451,"date":"2026-06-10T04:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the compassionate words from the member opposite, and I acknowledge that much of the bill is going in the right direction and, indeed, is good. However, in one part, the bill promises to restore mandatory minimums, but then later it hands judges a clause to sentence below mandatory minimums.\n\nMy question is simple: When a victim's offender walks out below the mandatory minimum sentence under the bill, who will the member opposite tell the victim to blame: the court or the bill that was written to let this happen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086451","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the compassionate words from the member opposite, and I acknowledge that much of the bill is going in the right direction and, indeed, is good. However, in one part, the bill promises to restore mandatory minimums, but then later it hands judges a clause to sentence below mandatory minimums.\n\nMy question is simple: When a victim's offender walks out below the mandatory mi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c29b43125138bbabb729f0c83d289f37dbd0b16080ba8791da478b4712678152"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["421917384ff7a0976bf775177c10b17342052027f7c7ec00fcaae2176f21bba4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c00418ebbbe30752987d93d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127758,"date":"2026-06-11T22:25:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like [ Technical difficulty—Editor ] questions about the risk of cyber-sabotage in industrial facilities, I think it's incredibly important, despite the snickering we heard from the members opposite. Drawing on my background, as someone who ran the joint operations centre on the Pacific coast, doing security and surveillance there, I can assure this committee that those are real risks that demand to be taken seriously. My first question is for Ms. Harland. In 2017, this committee recommended that the government implement interprovincial or east-west coast electrical grid connections and corridors. Has this happened? Do you think this is still a valid recommendation? Do you see it as something that contributes to the national security and self-reliance of Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127758","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like [ Technical difficulty—Editor ] questions about the risk of cyber-sabotage in industrial facilities, I think it's incredibly important, despite the snickering we heard from the members opposite. Drawing on my background, as someone who ran the joint operations centre on the Pacific coast, doing security and surveillance there, I can assure this committee that those a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1c747f0cf42da3d3cf4e528","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127759,"date":"2026-06-11T22:30:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"RNNR","text":"I'm going to jump in, just to clarify. You said there's more opportunity, but regardless of the opportunity, has it actually happened, other than a few minor projects? Is this something that's going forward, and does it support national security and self-reliance, which are so important? I think all members of this committee would agree to that. Has it happened, and does it contribute? Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127759","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm going to jump in, just to clarify. You said there's more opportunity, but regardless of the opportunity, has it actually happened, other than a few minor projects? Is this something that's going forward, and does it support national security and self-reliance, which are so important? I think all members of this committee would agree to that. Has it happened, and does it contribute? Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ab5f404ffca195502506b29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127760,"date":"2026-06-11T22:30:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"RNNR","text":"Quickly, in the few seconds I have, could you please address the importance of these types of connections with regard to national security and Canada's self-reliance? Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127760","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Quickly, in the few seconds I have, could you please address the importance of these types of connections with regard to national security and Canada's self-reliance? Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a184903b3b62f5c21717ecbcae7b7448f1e268ebcea3e4598355a2e555786bde"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83e689313043e886a6aa4399","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127761,"date":"2026-06-11T22:30:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you very much. I appreciate it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127761","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I appreciate it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20e23dee95012ed6be345ce5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127762,"date":"2026-06-11T23:15:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Exner-Pirot, it's good to talk to you again, and I appreciate the work that you did on defence committee a few weeks back. I also appreciate your accurate analysis of AI with regard to a security nexus and your comments about putting aside decarbonization to focus on progress and production of electricity. You've spoken about energy as a pillar of national security, and I certainly agree with that. The defence industrial strategy considers critical minerals as a strategic asset. My question is this: Do you think that, say, an energy grid is also a strategic national defence or security asset, and is it just electricity? Would you consider, as you talked about, liquid natural gas and oil as critical to the national security and sovereignty of Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127762","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Exner-Pirot, it's good to talk to you again, and I appreciate the work that you did on defence committee a few weeks back. I also appreciate your accurate analysis of AI with regard to a security nexus and your comments about putting aside decarbonization to focus on progress and production of electricity. You've spoken about energy as a pillar of national security, and I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["47da19181baf508556c38fad078ee2c30dca2ee4005c01a379f8ef8d5cbddc44"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["57fe95a4e0f40bb867cfeaef6c5395692e0dbc06dcf32b032346bcaecdb70eae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebb17a7965e0e1419d85b96a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127763,"date":"2026-06-11T23:20:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"RNNR","text":"I have a few seconds left, and I appreciate your perfect segue. I wanted to hear you talk a bit more about steps that we should be taking, that we haven't taken, to protect these assets from cyber-attack sabotage—prekinetic threats and then, as we've seen in other parts of the world, postkinetic threats. Has Canada taken any steps to protect these critical national security assets, and if not, what steps should we be taking?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127763","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a few seconds left, and I appreciate your perfect segue. I wanted to hear you talk a bit more about steps that we should be taking, that we haven't taken, to protect these assets from cyber-attack sabotage—prekinetic threats and then, as we've seen in other parts of the world, postkinetic threats. Has Canada taken any steps to protect these critical national security assets, and if not, wha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f41d6a5f1555f71ffb3230fb3e22ba5ffcffe080983cb51ca6d833e863954915"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d2371a05cd9d5b5bfce8077","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127764,"date":"2026-06-11T23:20:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"RNNR","text":"I'm running out of time, so perhaps you could submit both your report, \"Blackout\", and anything else you'd like to add on that subject. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for your patience.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127764","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm running out of time, so perhaps you could submit both your report, \"Blackout\", and anything else you'd like to add on that subject. Thank you, Mr. Chair, for your patience.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Authors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","label":"Authors","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b612f51e9842dc988752969586abc65e47e1ee884b3022262b702b7b84192ad"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db87314d5f2dc84f1f19d6a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088302,"date":"2026-06-17T02:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I heard from the member opposite that 11,000 homes were built. Of course, that is assuming agreements. I also heard \"will allow\" four times and \"MOUs\". The government's promise was 500,000 homes per year. Minus 11,000 homes, my calculation says that we are short 489,000 homes for $13 billion.\n\nWould the member opposite agree with my mathematical calculation of 489,000 homes short this year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088302","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I heard from the member opposite that 11,000 homes were built. Of course, that is assuming agreements. I also heard \"will allow\" four times and \"MOUs\". The government's promise was 500,000 homes per year. Minus 11,000 homes, my calculation says that we are short 489,000 homes for $13 billion.\n\nWould the member opposite agree with my mathematical calculation of 489,000 homes short this","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["646404a10e7b6e84bd7335e1b0c960d9bf36f071adf3bb0b13e6a20b27b8dc49"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1f5845cf03c51a74fd74c4ee678065b6bc601fcf7d2f268aadadcb1af4311c69"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3245c57d90a9bdb9018a949","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088303,"date":"2026-06-17T02:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will share my time today with the member for Flamborough—Glanbrook—Brant North.\n\n Before I turn to the business at hand, I would like to share that I was in Hamilton this morning for the change of command of the Royal Canadian Navy. I have had the honour of serving and sailing with both naval officers, Vice-Admiral Angus Topshee and Vice-Admiral Dan Charlebois. After four years of distinguished service and amazing leadership, Vice-Admiral Angus Topshee has turned over command of the Royal Canadian Navy. I think of all the amazing things he did, and he should be acknowledged for his care of those sailors and the others who worked for him. As well, I want to send my congratulations to recently promoted Vice-Admiral Dan Charlebois, who will be taking over command of the Royal Canadian Navy. I have no doubt that he will lead with distinction.\n\nToday, I rise to oppose Bill C-26, an act to authorize certain payments to be made out of the consolidated revenue fund for the purpose of improving housing supply. As always, I rise on behalf of the great people of Cowichan—Malahat—Langford on beautiful Vancouver Island, the seniors, the young families, the trades workers, the veterans, and the men and women who get up before dawn, work hard, play by the rules, yet watch the dream of owning a home drift a little further out of reach every year that passes.\n\n In the Cowichan Valley today, the benchmark price of a single-family home sits above $780,000. Across Vancouver Island, it is close to $800,000, and in greater Victoria, including Langford, the average sale price is now nearing $1 million. However, there are people behind those numbers, and I know many of them by name. I know veterans, men and women who once wore this country's uniform, who are now living out of their trucks. I know forestry and mill workers who have been knocked down by mill curtailments and closures and are now living in campers. I know people who have been taxed out of the very homes they worked their whole lives for, who are now living in trailers and tents. I know young couples who have all but given up on the idea that they will ever stop renting.\n\nWhen I speak about housing in this chamber, I am not speaking simply about a line in a budget. I am speaking about the greatest single worry in people's lives right now. This bill is such a disappointment to me because the people I represent do not need another illusion. They need a home.\n\nThe government has a real gift for illusion. Bill C-26 is dressed up as Emerald City on the Hill, with $1.7 billion announced with a great deal of fanfare, and all of it said to be for housing. What I would ask of every member of Parliament is that they pull back the curtain and reveal what the illusion is. When they do, they will find that the whole substance of this bill is in a single small section that says, \"The Minister of Finance may make payments to the provinces and territories, the total of which is equal to $1.‍713 billion\". It also says, \"The amount of each payment is to be determined by the Minister of Finance.\" Those payments may be made \"at the times and in the manner that the Minister of Finance considers appropriate.\"\n\nThat is the entire bill. There are no conditions attached to it. There is no requirement to come back and report to Parliament, no definition of what \"improving housing supply\" is even meant to mean, and nowhere does the government commit to building so much as a single home. The government claims there will be 11,000 for the $13 billion it is spending. What we are being asked to approve is not a housing plan at all, but a blank cheque, and we are being asked to trust the one man who gets to fill in that amount.\n\nWe have seen this before, and not long ago. Buried inside division 16 of the last budget bill, Bill C-31, was the Defence Investment Agency act. I studied it closely as a member of Standing Committee on National Defence, and tucked away in it was a remarkable power: the authority for a single minister to draw up to $1 billion at a time out of the very same consolidated revenue fund. It is the same fund, the same kind of open-ended discretion, and it is once again being slipped quietly into a budget where most Canadians would never think to look. I spent a better part of three decades in uniform, and I can plainly tell members of Parliament that we do not rebuild a military or a country on a blank cheque, a fancy press release and announcement.\n\n Now, here we are again with Bill C-26. It is a different minister and a different file, but the very same approach. The Minister of National Defence was reaching into that fund $1 billion at a time, and now the Minister of Finance is reaching into that fund for $1.7 billion more. The illusions have many names, and it is my job to pull back that curtain and expose the reality.\n\n This is not a coincidence. It is becoming a habit of the government to gather the money and the decisions into as few hands as possible, strip away the accountability that ought to come with them and trust that the fancy announcement of the day will carry the day. I would gently remind the House where that kind of governing tends to lead. When enormous public resources can be moved around by a handful of powerful people with little real scrutiny, we are no longer describing a healthy democracy. We are describing something closer to an oligarchy. \n\nAn oligarchy is never built one dramatic stroke at a time. Rather, it is built quietly, one billion unaccountable dollars at a time. When money on that scale can move on the say-so of one minister with no criteria and no audit, I think we all know who tends to benefit in the end, and it is rarely the young family in Langford or the senior in Duncan. Instead, it is the well connected and the well placed.\n\nThis brings me to the real question at the heart of this bill. It does not ask us to trust an institution with all of its checks and balances and safeguards. It asks us to trust one man: the Minister of Finance. I think it is fair to ask whether that trust has been earned. \n\nLet us consider the record. The minister told Canadians he had recused himself from the Alto high-speed rail file, one of the most expensive projects in our country's history, because his own wife serves as vice-president at the very corporation building it. He wrote a letter, he announced a screen, and he assured us he had stepped aside. However, when a motion came before Parliament that would have stripped the high-speed rail provisions out of the government's budget bill, the minister did not step aside at all. He stayed and voted to protect the project. \n\nBoth of these things cannot be true at the same time. Either he genuinely recused himself or he voted on a matter that reached his own wife's employer. Hundreds of millions of dollars have already been spent and poured into that project, and the track has yet to be laid.\n\nI do not raise this to make anything personal. I raise it because accountability is the whole purpose of Parliament, and this is the same minister who is asking for the same trust on the same terms, only now the figure is $1.7 billion higher. I have not risen here only to criticize and to show the illusion. The people of Vancouver Island deserve better than what this bill offers, and there is a better way forward, so let me set it out.\n\nFirst, we could tie the money to results rather than to announcements. The funds should flow against real, measurable increases in housing starts and completions that are verified and made public. Second, we would put the conditions in the legislation itself, not in one minister's head. We need clear criteria, clear timelines and clear reporting back to Parliament. Third, we would bring in the Parliamentary Budget Officer and the Auditor General to follow this money, from the first dollar to the last nail, and tell Canadians honestly whether it worked. Finally, we could direct the funding to the communities that are actually developing, improving and building homes, be it on Vancouver Island or across the country, rather than rewarding the ones that stall. That is how a government could actually improve the housing of Canada.\n\nThe people of Vancouver Island are not easily fooled. They have been shown the Emerald City before. What they are asking for this time is a home they can afford in a community they love and a government they can actually trust with every dollar it spends. They are watching this debate right now, and they are waiting. \n\nLet me be clear: I cannot support Bill C-26 as it is written. If it does proceed to committee, it must not pass unchanged. It must be fixed. It must be amended to carry the safeguards I have set out today. We need real conditions, real reporting and real oversight so that every dollar is tied to a home built and not one more announcement.\n\nThe people of Vancouver Island deserve nothing less. The people of Canada deserve nothing less. They deserve a government they can trust and a Parliament with the courage to hold $1.7 billion of taxpayers' money to account. I urge every member of Parliament on all sides to summon that courage.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088303","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will share my time today with the member for Flamborough—Glanbrook—Brant North.\n\n Before I turn to the business at hand, I would like to share that I was in Hamilton this morning for the change of command of the Royal Canadian Navy. I have had the honour of serving and sailing with both naval officers, Vice-Admiral Angus Topshee and Vice-Admiral Dan Charlebois. After four years of d","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e1ddc8abdea8f5805c18f5f41678c1dbd778363579bd5515dcc8d4d2007d040c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e8cf4811072ab1a3376703b44bc335e2790cefb8de4b903c051bc0a17bd73745"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-abd15d3141d5eae2914ef025","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088304,"date":"2026-06-17T02:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, to be frank, I am absolutely not worried what the member opposite thinks, and neither are Canadians. There have been 11,000 homes built so far under a project for $13 billion that is looking for an extra $1.7 billion. Let us be serious. There is absolutely no accountability. The Prime Minister pledged 500,000 homes per year, and there were 260,000 starts last year. My math says we are short 240,000. That is what Canadians care about, not what the member opposite has to say.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088304","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, to be frank, I am absolutely not worried what the member opposite thinks, and neither are Canadians. There have been 11,000 homes built so far under a project for $13 billion that is looking for an extra $1.7 billion. Let us be serious. There is absolutely no accountability. The Prime Minister pledged 500,000 homes per year, and there were 260,000 starts last year. My math says we are","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d36cdba816809ef4e6acb92d5bb98bcd22fa641fe935040ab4cf1a3e4b8f9b61"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-adedb07c249f1c442778de3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088305,"date":"2026-06-17T02:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his great question.\n\nI appreciate my colleague's kind words and the opportunity to speak a little, very briefly in the time I am allowed, about some of the improvements. I laid it out fairly clearly in my speech, but it is about accountability. Look, we love when money is spent to help housing in Canada. We are always accused that we are voting against that and voting against Canadians. No, we are voting against lousy bills that are wasting money and are not building houses, and we have seen that with $13 billion for 11,000 houses. That is what we are voting against. We are voting for Canadians. I encourage my colleague to review my notes and go over the four points for bringing accountability.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088305","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his great question.\n\nI appreciate my colleague's kind words and the opportunity to speak a little, very briefly in the time I am allowed, about some of the improvements. I laid it out fairly clearly in my speech, but it is about accountability. Look, we love when money is spent to help housing in Canada. We are always accused that we are voting against that an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fd814ffde77f30c5c9aa00c2805ce1909d2179baba8e56e5f68f4c0dd616e08e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f4caa16b4cbd14983211348da31072e670a9ae23f2412283528d354ebb5b4a82"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-acfd4b7332d50685adaee267","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088306,"date":"2026-06-17T02:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeff Kibble","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague spoke of accountability and scandal. He listed some of these scandals, and the list goes on and on and on. \n\nMy concern is both the lack of accountability and the illusion. We heard in an earlier statement from the members opposite claims of rejoicing. That is an illusion. We have heard claims, for example, of 2% NATO spending when SIPRI, the global standard for reporting NATO spending, reports it is only 1.6%. It is all an illusion. There were 500,000 homes pledged per year, and only 260,000 starts. Again, that is another illusion. \n\nCanadians are tired of the illusions. They are tired of the scandals, and they are tired of this government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088306","member_id":"bc-mp-123552","member_name":"Jeff Kibble","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague spoke of accountability and scandal. He listed some of these scandals, and the list goes on and on and on. \n\nMy concern is both the lack of accountability and the illusion. We heard in an earlier statement from the members opposite claims of rejoicing. That is an illusion. We have heard claims, for example, of 2% NATO spending when SIPRI, the global standard for repo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa0174b3c4d2f502f8f26128768c3f62e0f5b3eb30f39e7a9550d7f4432eeaf9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c81c3c59e1301ac2a52d4512","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76310,"date":"2026-01-26T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when NATO invoked article 5 after 9/11, we fought the Taliban alongside our allies in Afghanistan. There were 40,000 Canadians deployed, and 158 CAF soldiers made the ultimate sacrifice. Thirty Canadian soldiers received the U.S. Bronze Star for their bravery.\n\nThe Canadian Armed Forces have made and continue to make invaluable contributions around the world. As a nation, Canada will always stand with our allies, including the U.S. As Canadians, we stand behind the women and men in uniform who serve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76310","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when NATO invoked article 5 after 9/11, we fought the Taliban alongside our allies in Afghanistan. There were 40,000 Canadians deployed, and 158 CAF soldiers made the ultimate sacrifice. Thirty Canadian soldiers received the U.S. Bronze Star for their bravery.\n\nThe Canadian Armed Forces have made and continue to make invaluable contributions around the world. As a nation, Canada will ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1da8bb5832d38844fdc23a0c4e16e30aaba8ad834433d08a81eca64e62a4b4b0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c3d533491cd9b4e58d7e2688378dcfb34dd8a7df4b12c4abca91774127ee6167"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9f376482998358196f634e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76312,"date":"2026-01-27T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the rise in extortion-related threats, shootings and intimidation across Ontario and the Lower Mainland is a grave concern. I know how much fear it is causing for families, businesses and our communities.\n\nOur government is advancing expanded legislative powers so that law enforcement has the tools it needs to effectively combat extortion and organized criminal networks. Political opponents in Surrey put aside their differences to act with quick urgency. I am asking their Conservative counterparts to stop obstructing necessary legislation and work with us to provide practical solutions. Our communities need to feel safe at home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76312","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the rise in extortion-related threats, shootings and intimidation across Ontario and the Lower Mainland is a grave concern. I know how much fear it is causing for families, businesses and our communities.\n\nOur government is advancing expanded legislative powers so that law enforcement has the tools it needs to effectively combat extortion and organized criminal networks. Political opp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7859af1280b8084ee0b891b6adaf9305110024e29937fef311a47c8bec193015"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dc698caeb13510c5f9f7fc7cb6d4a91b808990b9cba4fb2b0fd5aa7ed3b7aa4a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f974cb7f048c5e3bb38a746d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86062,"date":"2026-02-03T19:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am confused by and concerned about the member's question. I am confused over the question not being about last week's important announcement. I am concerned that the Conservatives are missing the details of Canada's groceries and essentials benefit. It is a 25% increase to the GST tax credit for five years, with a one-time payment equivalent to 50% this year. It is $500 million to address supply chain disruptions and keep prices down. \n\nThis is important news, and we need to focus on what we are doing for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86062","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am confused by and concerned about the member's question. I am confused over the question not being about last week's important announcement. I am concerned that the Conservatives are missing the details of Canada's groceries and essentials benefit. It is a 25% increase to the GST tax credit for five years, with a one-time payment equivalent to 50% this year. It is $500 million to a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["17fe06fb8cd99ec8fe743dc389c18dd8f7ee2e5786d6007cdb14015b1cc7218b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["17f9b942c38d72d7042fd1ae676ddff70b353d9e347d10c656d5e296708c63ab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8e5c1992ae43071d1cef09b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86061,"date":"2026-02-05T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from British Columbia is asking a question about something that is incredibly important to all Canadians. Guess what: The government has taken steps to address this. We are introducing the groceries and essentials benefit, which is going to put money in the pockets of families so they can acquire the things they need. A family of four will receive up to $1,890 this year and $1,400 for the next four years. We are taking action to support the families in B.C.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86061","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from British Columbia is asking a question about something that is incredibly important to all Canadians. Guess what: The government has taken steps to address this. We are introducing the groceries and essentials benefit, which is going to put money in the pockets of families so they can acquire the things they need. A family of four will receive up to $1,890 this year a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["292ebf0b1d37dee5a3b3f952b79c7c0fe747a688b3ecfb4d7466d3ecea31288a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d19d2175f622bb9c1600cb87","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299603,"date":"2026-02-09T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister has a plan to build Canada. He has laid it out, and we are taking action to advance that. Individuals in British Columbia want to see the investments that we are making. They want to see the major projects move forward. They want to see the new housing, and they want to see us grow this economy to be the strongest economy in the G7.\n\nWe are moving forward with this plan. Can we count on the Conservatives to join us?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299603","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister has a plan to build Canada. He has laid it out, and we are taking action to advance that. Individuals in British Columbia want to see the investments that we are making. They want to see the major projects move forward. They want to see the new housing, and they want to see us grow this economy to be the strongest economy in the G7.\n\nWe are moving forward with this ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a3a9343c91c11622341915b91ce141900e5ce0fc539d2d702ec89cf8b229ef79"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1369dc2937ab3f83b40dba0d954c376b9d439fc68c790bd41ad17cb836822e4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e00c61928364d000384c2e7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350197,"date":"2026-03-12T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we thank all Canadian Forces members and their families for their service to Canada. We acknowledge the incredible contributions that Canadians made in Afghanistan, including the 158 who made the ultimate sacrifice.\n\n Acknowledgement of Canada's serving members is incredibly important, and we continue to move forward with that. I look forward to sharing more with the member opposite in due course.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350197","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we thank all Canadian Forces members and their families for their service to Canada. We acknowledge the incredible contributions that Canadians made in Afghanistan, including the 158 who made the ultimate sacrifice.\n\n Acknowledgement of Canada's serving members is incredibly important, and we continue to move forward with that. I look forward to sharing more with the member opposite i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3891ec4ce590b950b7d470c5300fc4fb4034187df15aae79c41acea1fd16114c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7c5c62eb7a84e043c87b1b7fadc651ddbf3435ef689d6858dbebc0073496eaf6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0c73f3b322f8c67d6023e79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390265,"date":"2026-03-25T21:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that Bill C-9, An Act to amend the Criminal Code (hate propaganda, hate crime and access to religious or cultural places), be read the third time and passed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390265","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"moved that Bill C-9, An Act to amend the Criminal Code (hate propaganda, hate crime and access to religious or cultural places), be read the third time and passed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f249cb87fcfb31e9343daaa4c89f3ccf5b4bc4f67221f2ed33129a800e2f3408"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5175b0a03b5993daa71055b2a3d8464baa9c140423fa6414c0fd53d37d6e704f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c11ed7b8b05fd549bde94214","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390264,"date":"2026-03-26T19:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we will circle back to that question, but today we need to start with the good news for Canadians and for Canada. Today, the NATO secretary general confirmed that Canada has met NATO's 2% spending—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!\n\nHon. Jill McKnight: Mr. Speaker, this historic investment confirms that we are doing our fair share here at home, on the continent and in the alliance, investing in Canada's women and men in uniform. Today and every day, NATO allies know they can count on Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390264","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we will circle back to that question, but today we need to start with the good news for Canadians and for Canada. Today, the NATO secretary general confirmed that Canada has met NATO's 2% spending—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!\n\nHon. Jill McKnight: Mr. Speaker, this historic investment confirms that we are doing our fair share here at home, on the continent and in the alliance, investin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shares","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037106","label":"Shares","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8daaf57fd1aa239fabb1c5b119b21b3fdc52f45b0a53e9f9e394a6216d287d2d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f61ed3232434590bfac5e980348b1317d0ae735e0b92c72432fbc0ac7cc4d38"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b3aea74c6ecb7df86f00998","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715123,"date":"2026-04-13T19:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are helping make food more affordable by introducing the new Canadian groceries and essentials benefit, giving family direct support when they need it most. We have also created the $150-million food security fund to help communities expand access to nutritious, affordable food close to home. That is not all. We are strengthening local food infrastructure across the country so producers can connect more easily with consumers. We are working hard to keep prices down and make more healthy food options accessible for more Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715123","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are helping make food more affordable by introducing the new Canadian groceries and essentials benefit, giving family direct support when they need it most. We have also created the $150-million food security fund to help communities expand access to nutritious, affordable food close to home. That is not all. We are strengthening local food infrastructure across the country so prod","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","label":"Functional foods","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64f4066817621e4e4287a25b6b082c5c9aeed29cfe01b205593f98795f6f9d42"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bcb3839b74637a0265597d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715124,"date":"2026-04-13T19:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we understand Canadians are facing affordability challenges, and Canadians in British Columbia understand there is uncertainty in the world. Canada's economy has been impacted by heightened uncertainty from emerging conflicts and unjust trade decisions. Our government is delivering measures to help Canadians weather current challenges, from automatic tax filings to the groceries and essentials benefit for 12 million Canadians and reducing taxes for 22 million Canadians. Our commitment to improving affordability remains unchanged and unwavering.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715124","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we understand Canadians are facing affordability challenges, and Canadians in British Columbia understand there is uncertainty in the world. Canada's economy has been impacted by heightened uncertainty from emerging conflicts and unjust trade decisions. Our government is delivering measures to help Canadians weather current challenges, from automatic tax filings to the groceries and e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["71f81d32a1d6342fe2b3c56a5830ad3c969af139eb0ae5f9ec75c1599e233265"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e95ee8a66e91e45e96e47dffe6dd3883d7876805fc5787d05ee79db19e013bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b7207ad3ae0caa839c6f141f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715125,"date":"2026-04-13T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as has been said by some of my colleagues, this will not change private property rights. Reconciliation is our path forward for our country, and we will continue to move forward for both.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715125","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as has been said by some of my colleagues, this will not change private property rights. Reconciliation is our path forward for our country, and we will continue to move forward for both.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0aa09be8d13475e99502ac924a059cbb5c952ecfd309946bea649a7cf68bf80b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9ca470102550d68471a298c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715121,"date":"2026-04-14T19:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbians are happy to hear that we are investing in them and that we are addressing affordability for them. They are happy to hear that we are making a reduction in fuel costs from now until Labour Day. British Columbians are going to use that to go and enjoy our country as they can this summer. Maybe they will also combine that with the Canada Strong pass as they go and explore this wonderful country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715121","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbians are happy to hear that we are investing in them and that we are addressing affordability for them. They are happy to hear that we are making a reduction in fuel costs from now until Labour Day. British Columbians are going to use that to go and enjoy our country as they can this summer. Maybe they will also combine that with the Canada Strong pass as they go and exp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Alternative fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","label":"Alternative fuels","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e55f7f49a37237b5703722eb593435467060873e871b27f819049e93689069c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-23f9726a8eb9d4baaf55e940","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715122,"date":"2026-04-14T19:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada disagrees with the B.C. Supreme Court's ruling, and we appealed it on September 8. We are committed to maintaining legal clarity and stability for private land ownership. Further legal clarity is required to address the decision, particularly as it relates to private property rights.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715122","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada disagrees with the B.C. Supreme Court's ruling, and we appealed it on September 8. We are committed to maintaining legal clarity and stability for private land ownership. Further legal clarity is required to address the decision, particularly as it relates to private property rights.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["70d806340a8535637fabafe378c89038b9c288bd5e5098be2217dc5b13b3f3a4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5bfb0af95a2d31355be464a29ed1e098da94665d226b56440d93e431ea502ba7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0c75d0dff4921b37f9c0129","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301265,"date":"2026-04-21T19:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, supporting veterans in their rehabilitation journey is a top priority. While many veterans are seeing positive results in their overall well-being, we know there are still many we can continue to help. That is why I have directed my department to launch an independent review of the rehabilitation program. The goal is to identify where the program is working well and where it can be strengthened so that we can continue to support the outcomes and better support veterans through this transition.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301265","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, supporting veterans in their rehabilitation journey is a top priority. While many veterans are seeing positive results in their overall well-being, we know there are still many we can continue to help. That is why I have directed my department to launch an independent review of the rehabilitation program. The goal is to identify where the program is working well and where it can be st","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e3476a7a1660992c70e11a32664a00be791ac62d9d7b3d07fce9c53cddc3b19e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab45eaeeac0e577cbffa3b1305e1e564141af41ca079a02951d14806013e87aa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b04b14d0d73ee999c0698e9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301266,"date":"2026-04-21T19:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our top priority will always be ensuring that veterans receive improved support, service and rehabilitation outcomes through the rehabilitation program.\n\nSince its launch in 2021, the program has expanded to over 15,000 service providers and has supported more than 23,000 veterans. We recognize that there are always opportunities to improve. I have just said that we are going to be undertaking an independent review. We will continue to put the care of veterans at the forefront of the work that we are doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301266","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our top priority will always be ensuring that veterans receive improved support, service and rehabilitation outcomes through the rehabilitation program.\n\nSince its launch in 2021, the program has expanded to over 15,000 service providers and has supported more than 23,000 veterans. We recognize that there are always opportunities to improve. I have just said that we are going to be un","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["694598bdfc2359e160c74fdd2e78f520560688e889eaffe1c4fba80873c131cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a393ad05402cf6ba4c38a28ca98a4b38e654879cfa6e084fe971a445000f0d1b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42f7fe26758f564fbf59f2f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301263,"date":"2026-04-22T19:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I also attended that Vaisakhi parade in Surrey last weekend, and it was a tremendous opportunity to be in the community.\n\nFor nearly three decades, I ran a small business. I know the challenges that SMEs and entrepreneurs face. I have been there and know how close the margins can be. Things like the savings on fuel and diesel can make a difference for those drivers. It can put money back in their pockets, and it is just one part of the measures we are taking to support Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301263","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I also attended that Vaisakhi parade in Surrey last weekend, and it was a tremendous opportunity to be in the community.\n\nFor nearly three decades, I ran a small business. I know the challenges that SMEs and entrepreneurs face. I have been there and know how close the margins can be. Things like the savings on fuel and diesel can make a difference for those drivers. It can put money b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b6939408e3dc6f35fe4c08dd27019790459d7d4447e4684be1648843c043185a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e6ed8ca5c7ccdaa277f32dbc68dad729bd03eee670066eb1d2c1eb98c6baa950"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fdfd1c6d4b485f2da90933f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301264,"date":"2026-04-22T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are getting support with affordability with the measures we are taking right now. They are getting support with the school nutrition program. We are making changes to support first-time homebuyers. We have brought in the groceries and essentials benefit. We have removed the federal excise tax on fuel until September 7.\n\nThese are measures that are supporting Canadians. My question is why the member from British Columbia is not also supporting these measures to make a difference for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301264","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are getting support with affordability with the measures we are taking right now. They are getting support with the school nutrition program. We are making changes to support first-time homebuyers. We have brought in the groceries and essentials benefit. We have removed the federal excise tax on fuel until September 7.\n\nThese are measures that are supporting Canadians. My qu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c53236a7668aeffb8e6df82bfd0bd501cca2ca76d3dd998342c09c26be2b11c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c91d4c81d372d4aa4b164bfe0701b0ba7c888876b50894bea31353330e3097a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72f907ed6c6fb0b74d19ceb8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127765,"date":"2026-04-27T16:00:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning, esteemed colleagues. Thank you for inviting me to provide updates on some of the work underway at Veterans Affairs Canada. I welcome the opportunity to share the progress we are making to strengthen service delivery and reaffirm our commitment to veterans and their families. At its core, our mandate is simple. When a veteran comes forward, the support they are eligible for must be there without any uncertainty. The most recent supplementary estimates (C) reflect this commitment, with $300.4 million in additional funding for the 2025-26 fiscal period. Looking ahead, Veterans Affairs Canada is forecasting an $8.2-billion budget for 2026-27, an increase of $340 million, or 4%. This departmental budget is higher than the opening budget from last year and in alignment with the closing 2025-26 fiscal estimates. The government remains focused on improving service delivery. Budget 2025 included investments of more than $184 million over four years to stabilize processing capacity for disability benefit applications and build a new path to addressing existing wait times. This investment, combined with the ongoing modernization of VAC's operational processes and IT infrastructure, will ensure that veterans can continue to receive timely, responsive and accessible support. Budget 2025 commits an additional $40.1 million annually to sustain this progress. Even as we align certain benefits and programs to reflect market realities such as the adjustment in the rate of reimbursement for the cannabis for medical purposes benefit, we are maintaining full access to the supports veterans are eligible for. This delivers on the government's commitment to Canadians to invest more, reduce red tape and protect access to services and benefits. It's important to be clear. Veterans Affairs Canada is not facing cuts. In fact, it's quite the opposite. We will ensure that funds are always available for veterans to receive the benefits and supports for which they are eligible. We will ensure funds are always available for veterans to receive the benefits and supports for which they are eligible. The government's responsibility also extends to remembrance. Next week, we will break ground to start construction of the national monument to Canada's mission in Afghanistan. Upon completion, this solemn space will offer veterans, Canadian Armed Forces members and Canadians a place to reflect on the service and sacrifice of all those who served in the mission, those who supported them from home and the 158 Canadian soldiers and seven civilians who gave their lives. It is a place of remembrance, a place of respect, a place to remember the 165 lives we will never forget. In light of this responsibility for remembrance and recognition, along with the Minister of National Defence , I commend the advocacy of colleagues in both the House and the Senate in championing issues of foundational importance to the Canadian Armed Forces—past, present and yet to come. Our government welcomes the opportunity to work with parliamentarians on the recognition of service, be it the individual or the mission. We look forward to working collaboratively to maintain this ongoing conversation as the mission or missions evolve. With regard to e-petition 6661, the government looks forward to tabling a clear, unambiguous response presently. Likewise, regarding Bill S-246 , the importance of getting this review and assessment process right the first time can't be overstated. Current and future veterans need the assurance that the process put in place will speak to concerns for today and tomorrow. For all Canadians, we must ensure that commemoration, commendation and ultimately recognition of Canada's women and men in uniform remain robust and mature. In closing, Madam Chair, I reaffirm the Government of Canada's commitment to supporting veterans and their families. More than 90% of the total estimates are delivered as direct payments to veterans, their families and other program recipients. These investments in Veterans Affairs Canada represent one of the most significant contributions to our government's mission objectives, including being the second-largest contributor to meeting the government's NATO spending target. This is not incidental. It is intentional. Our commitment is clear: We will always be there, for today and for tomorrow. To the veteran community, your service matters, your sacrifice is recognized and your future remains our responsibility. Thank you very much. I am now ready to answer your questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127765","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning, esteemed colleagues. Thank you for inviting me to provide updates on some of the work underway at Veterans Affairs Canada. I welcome the opportunity to share the progress we are making to strengthen service delivery and reaffirm our commitment to veterans and their families. At its core, our mandate is simple. When a veteran comes forward, the support they are","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7adf5b9e6846da816f02128b4c2a89f80037462e8037274307e07a21e90060f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c96d74e74dfb214402235dce62bd682c42066ed926dc2f87dcb2ebe774fcc46"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7b3713133e7553968527afb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127766,"date":"2026-04-27T16:00:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Madam Chair, through you, I would like to correct the record. My colleague is stating something that is inaccurate. There is not a cut to services and benefits for veterans. My colleague has—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127766","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Chair, through you, I would like to correct the record. My colleague is stating something that is inaccurate. There is not a cut to services and benefits for veterans. My colleague has—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55dc22cc9ad42752f95a06fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127767,"date":"2026-04-27T16:00:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"My colleague has stated something that I disagree with. The bureau of pensions advocates is—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127767","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My colleague has stated something that I disagree with. The bureau of pensions advocates is—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d806fde42e6884da9fb0c2daeed81686b5a5c83f7a65e742b2211d4f52a857c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6fd886eedcce901e956060a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127768,"date":"2026-04-27T16:00:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I agree that the bureau of pensions advocates is a service to veterans. We are not cutting the service. The bureau offers free legal advice and representation to a veteran pursuing the appeals process. There was temporary funding as part of budget 2023, which was sunsetting on March 31, 2026. At this point, we are now transitioning back to steady-state operations, which was prior to the temporary funding of 2023.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127768","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I agree that the bureau of pensions advocates is a service to veterans. We are not cutting the service. The bureau offers free legal advice and representation to a veteran pursuing the appeals process. There was temporary funding as part of budget 2023, which was sunsetting on March 31, 2026. At this point, we are now transitioning back to steady-state operations, which was","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad9fcf0c1bd3070abc4979f8896df1cd04f02db8c968d9f372e881d3791d5b70"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["932f9f2070e4c9fe5d5c4ad2ccdde34d7ab0bd524fab72991544eacc81edf12d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4d6a346f6e0810ae048d0e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127769,"date":"2026-04-27T16:00:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"We are returning to our steady-state operations to continue offering to veterans the service of support with their appeals process. We are also, at the same time, as mentioned, with the budget investment of the $184.9 million, modernizing our service delivery and reviewing processes so that we can make investments in technology and tools to equip frontline staff to make decisions for veterans. All of this will enhance the service delivery we offer across Veterans Affairs Canada, including through the Bureau of Pensions Advocates.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127769","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We are returning to our steady-state operations to continue offering to veterans the service of support with their appeals process. We are also, at the same time, as mentioned, with the budget investment of the $184.9 million, modernizing our service delivery and reviewing processes so that we can make investments in technology and tools to equip frontline staff to make decisions for veterans. All","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["56576290ade0e7dec70390aa4683a3fa462881aeff83690b5d18b5e774ade575"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0e4c44789b452a7a2e295e19f21c323ce3bfdd2dfaa70d4280f0296a153050d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-470c66bd04011d04dd0bb84d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127770,"date":"2026-04-27T16:15:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Honouring the bravery and service and sacrifice of our Canadian Armed Forces is sacred and a deeply held commitment that we will be continuing to move forward with. Military honours are fully considered by the Canadian Armed Forces' chain of command. It involves a comprehensive and rigorous review.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127770","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Honouring the bravery and service and sacrifice of our Canadian Armed Forces is sacred and a deeply held commitment that we will be continuing to move forward with. Military honours are fully considered by the Canadian Armed Forces' chain of command. It involves a comprehensive and rigorous review.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","label":"Military law","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94418b9bfe8a537fc2c264617cf1f38ce6b310bfee004e9237724d1125a3817a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a931024a65453084e1b8cbd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127771,"date":"2026-04-27T16:15:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you very much. I think I was very clear, with regard to the bureau of pensions advocates, that this was funding that was coming to a sunset and that we are returning to our steady-state operations so that we can continue to make investments in service delivery, which will include through the services delivered through the bureau of pensions advocates. We will continue to offer this free service to veterans to support them in their reviews, if they undertake them. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127771","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I think I was very clear, with regard to the bureau of pensions advocates, that this was funding that was coming to a sunset and that we are returning to our steady-state operations so that we can continue to make investments in service delivery, which will include through the services delivered through the bureau of pensions advocates. We will continue to offer this free serv","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036809","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036809","label":"Public pensions","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["20ba3db79342628a81c3543720b76f4f02c657eb37156ef050241d6820fb9bd7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb444a8e3829f5328ae9abbd4dd1f89752f930ec7a71fd9c97efe95a5ffc26ee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4ecf1121b211065e6cc55ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127772,"date":"2026-04-27T16:15:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Certainly. Over 90% of VAC's total budget does count towards the NATO 2% GDP calculation. As I mentioned in my remarks, that funding is delivered directly to veterans as services and benefits to their families, and that does contribute to that 2% calculation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127772","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Certainly. Over 90% of VAC's total budget does count towards the NATO 2% GDP calculation. As I mentioned in my remarks, that funding is delivered directly to veterans as services and benefits to their families, and that does contribute to that 2% calculation.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7db7764ab6a6e2b701da307a0c0a794742c36cd63fd1eafd3c4cf29eec5e5120"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8073481c30c5616bfdcf29dcd5466703fa04ae369222a71e5dd8bf93f0817aab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6fe3412300a963746896e353","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127773,"date":"2026-04-27T16:15:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"The comprehensive expenditure review was a very large project to be undertaking. It took a lot of time and intentionality to ensure that we could maintain all services and benefits for veterans. That is core to the foundation of our mission and the work we do, and it is front and centre in the decisions we are making. That was the centre point of undertaking that process. As part of that process, while maintaining the benefits and the accessibility of the cannabis for medical purposes benefit, we reduced the rate of reimbursement to better align with the market rate, while still allowing veterans to maintain access to the program and to their daily per-gram limit, so that they would not have a change or a cut. There were no cuts made to the benefits and programs for veterans.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127773","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The comprehensive expenditure review was a very large project to be undertaking. It took a lot of time and intentionality to ensure that we could maintain all services and benefits for veterans. That is core to the foundation of our mission and the work we do, and it is front and centre in the decisions we are making. That was the centre point of undertaking that process. As part of that process, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2a3f366a18b49c3bffc4f11b75ecfb41a7fd7b75546dc7b850fbfa5058800c54"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ce833c4d85265480640547dbfc65d7d48f55fde4429ffdbad87a99f971f0b05"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b9487713f7ec7b6919b9fbc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127774,"date":"2026-04-27T16:20:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"There have been no cuts to the benefits offered to veterans through Veterans Affairs Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127774","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There have been no cuts to the benefits offered to veterans through Veterans Affairs Canada.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d56e5962e686e64ab2fb502788669fa1c3bbc61841504b49c0ec7a8bbdaa4f94"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af94b81cddeb73a25fde693a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127775,"date":"2026-04-27T16:20:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"As we know, not all veterans have the same experience. Each of them is unique. Each of their needs is unique. As such, the ebbs and flows within our programs and services will adjust based on the needs of the veterans at a given moment. Specific to that program, I have officials with me, and they may be able to add more specifics to the caregiver program if you wish.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127775","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As we know, not all veterans have the same experience. Each of them is unique. Each of their needs is unique. As such, the ebbs and flows within our programs and services will adjust based on the needs of the veterans at a given moment. Specific to that program, I have officials with me, and they may be able to add more specifics to the caregiver program if you wish.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["637c0852e494d7a94b2e6d5fdcc8e9c53815570998685e072ba153c9667342c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["931d5c5c0c4e85ab99225370f05d18c0e35526c884bed0ea9d6f2923358442d6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0e0ad4b1325bd014e6303ee3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127776,"date":"2026-04-27T16:20:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"This monument has been many years coming forward, and it is a significant step that we are reaching the sod-turning in the coming weeks. I think this is an important step that we are moving forward with, and construction will be commencing as we undertake that, with completion expected sometime in 2028. I know invitations were extended to the ACVA committee members to be at the sod-turning, and I hope everyone will have a chance to join us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127776","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This monument has been many years coming forward, and it is a significant step that we are reaching the sod-turning in the coming weeks. I think this is an important step that we are moving forward with, and construction will be commencing as we undertake that, with completion expected sometime in 2028. I know invitations were extended to the ACVA committee members to be at the sod-turning, and I ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42251b9e85b108b5e86402d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127777,"date":"2026-04-27T16:20:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Again, as I mentioned, veterans and their needs will be, at any given point in the cycle of their relationship with Veterans Affairs, at their own individual stage. For specifics like that, I would turn to the officials, who may be able to add more detail.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127777","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Again, as I mentioned, veterans and their needs will be, at any given point in the cycle of their relationship with Veterans Affairs, at their own individual stage. For specifics like that, I would turn to the officials, who may be able to add more detail.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["229e28ea1288a29df092dc9cf3911d26f5cd4cd00536275ffef6b38fd8e0aaa7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7aa338c639b5d2d7081cca3d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127778,"date":"2026-04-27T16:20:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"I would like to ask for a clarification, because it may be a translation issue. You were mentioning the fund that distributed $14.3 million. Was that the veteran and family well-being fund? Okay. Thank you. I just wanted to be sure. The veteran and family well-being fund is, as you mentioned, a fund that has funds available to support projects that support and focus on veteran well-being and care. We fund activities that include research, programs and other things that bring veterans together. There is a robust and rigorous process for receiving and reviewing applications to ensure they meet the eligibility criteria of the program. As it specifically relates to Quebec organizations, I would turn to my department officials to specify how that is divided between Quebec and the rest of Canada. They could provide insight on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127778","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to ask for a clarification, because it may be a translation issue. You were mentioning the fund that distributed $14.3 million. Was that the veteran and family well-being fund? Okay. Thank you. I just wanted to be sure. The veteran and family well-being fund is, as you mentioned, a fund that has funds available to support projects that support and focus on veteran well-being and care.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebfce85e77ce2c0709afb40c677f0324ed485a74700c92464618e9bbe8f68e61"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["000c7bb579f9885829b137bdf9a38aa272b2cf2bb5becbb2663fb81e2649c38f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4bddc2dabcaba859457e7bfe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127779,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"I'm not sure what the $3.30 per veteran refers to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127779","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm not sure what the $3.30 per veteran refers to.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037462","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veteran pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037462","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Veteran pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037462","label":"Veteran pensions","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","label":"Military law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ab94dc91d195d9ce6e9904daa79f758b791a370ebfb6ada5c510944ba68aff7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-306e00e1ffee1da4613a789d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127780,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"I don't have those numbers with me, so I will look to the department to speak to that. In the past, we've had conversations about the availability of services to francophone veterans and about ensuring that they have access to services in the language of their choosing. We are a bilingual country. Whether they are francophone veterans in Quebec or across Canada, we want to ensure they have access to that service. We know that, as recently as September, the average turnaround time for a francophone veteran was slightly better or at least on par with that for an anglophone veteran. I think the difference is 0.9 weeks, where the francophone turnaround time was slightly less. We also know that 30% of Veterans Affairs employees who are making disability decisions are either French or bilingual, to meet the needs of our veterans who choose to have communication in French. Is there the opportunity to continue enhancing these services? There is always the opportunity to grow and improve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127780","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I don't have those numbers with me, so I will look to the department to speak to that. In the past, we've had conversations about the availability of services to francophone veterans and about ensuring that they have access to services in the language of their choosing. We are a bilingual country. Whether they are francophone veterans in Quebec or across Canada, we want to ensure they have access ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e15be68ffdd7b746b2eca50b4fba83551d5460bfa6fe4f760047e68cfd55199c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e5c9066921de2a2e951c024cc8b67c18a4e769858dd82c1ec6a217bfeb7ffe5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da8e492bb8fdcbf0b2436db9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127781,"date":"2026-04-27T16:30:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"I would like to clarify something. You mentioned about not appearing before the committee. Was that in reference to me or to somebody else?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127781","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to clarify something. You mentioned about not appearing before the committee. Was that in reference to me or to somebody else?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["59102ee38a9273e099b5f109ea300552f9267ac67c8929fd4e1f6f895f016911"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b04c143e1bbb23d6bc682543","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127782,"date":"2026-04-27T16:30:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you for clarifying that. I stand with continuing to support women veterans in their experiences, ensuring that they are heard and their unique experiences are represented, and continuing to work with the government to address those needs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127782","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for clarifying that. I stand with continuing to support women veterans in their experiences, ensuring that they are heard and their unique experiences are represented, and continuing to work with the government to address those needs.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a6599671833c50bd18d294e15f2e3dc2bed2b0dde3a7db9213b06243acafc74"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5f4a00fd24382228bb54a66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127783,"date":"2026-04-27T16:30:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"I thank all members of the Women Veterans Council for their commitment and their contributions to a voluntary advisory council. The insights that they offered and the impact they made during the first year were significant. We are—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127783","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thank all members of the Women Veterans Council for their commitment and their contributions to a voluntary advisory council. The insights that they offered and the impact they made during the first year were significant. We are—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a6e3eca70edd7d8824e61d5227c360da2111782be837bc1b8af3eff4640e7f0c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["77d8813c953b07705ecf224cae7c9828a0d3f721d8b31aecf8433f1373e883f3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-027c4a31c1d84e2e5bf40997","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127784,"date":"2026-04-27T16:30:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"As with all government policies, we know it will evolve as goals change. Our focus is on ensuring that veterans are supported in the employment that best meets their needs and skills and where they are in their experiences today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127784","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As with all government policies, we know it will evolve as goals change. Our focus is on ensuring that veterans are supported in the employment that best meets their needs and skills and where they are in their experiences today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5ff3ed06b0d298211806e1aa95b6063b6ccaafce9cd1b1fee0aacbfea91697cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6bdaadf1400dc9d58c483b720877bab4580965099c5b777296fc4351a388062"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a0a7ae2d518fab8c4d9d458","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127785,"date":"2026-04-27T16:30:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"No, I'm not saying that. I am saying that we are looking to expand opportunities to meet the needs of veterans.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127785","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, I'm not saying that. I am saying that we are looking to expand opportunities to meet the needs of veterans.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d61621bdce0bbb5e552f2c78bcc66b79c7ce556256727a549fb212aaecaf0ac2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-690216718cd99fb5fa17e373","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127786,"date":"2026-04-27T16:35:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Madam Chair, I don't agree with the member's assessment—comparing the PCVRS rehabilitation contract and the policy of first right of refusal with the Canadian Corps of Commissionaires.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127786","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I don't agree with the member's assessment—comparing the PCVRS rehabilitation contract and the policy of first right of refusal with the Canadian Corps of Commissionaires.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012796","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Bioethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012796","label":"Bioethics","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a6313ac3ba4cd421e6c641d5abc1df06dd6ad4427c46dc016b39458d6070174"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21c16d1212c2bf9fea73adfc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127787,"date":"2026-04-27T16:35:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"As I've already mentioned, we are making an adjustment back to steady-state operations following the conclusion of the temporary funding. We have the investment of $184.9 million over four years. That is to invest in service modernization and service delivery. The opportunity here is working with veterans at the front end of their journey with Veterans Affairs Canada, in order to support them, engage with them and ensure that the process for reviewing disability applications.... We made investments there so that, hopefully, veterans don't have to go through the appeals process. We are not looking to reduce the appeals. We're not looking to change that. This is about supporting veterans at the beginning—supporting them in their process with Veterans Affairs Canada. The bureau will continue to be available to support veterans, but our hope is that, by engaging with them earlier and putting resources at the beginning, we can support them before they need to get to that point.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127787","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As I've already mentioned, we are making an adjustment back to steady-state operations following the conclusion of the temporary funding. We have the investment of $184.9 million over four years. That is to invest in service modernization and service delivery. The opportunity here is working with veterans at the front end of their journey with Veterans Affairs Canada, in order to support them, eng","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b17450140ba4d293e50c1f5b55c83189933fc182370b198b9c5fe0963ac851cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f91ad9ca36cc0a9dcb8dc949c214709895662b3fde7a61e44204e19f6706c364"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3d1762a03cde4d1f3c0c0a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127788,"date":"2026-04-27T16:35:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you for mentioning that. I have the opportunity to engage with veterans across the country, as many of our colleagues do. While things aren't perfect—that's the truth—what I'm hearing is.... Even as recently as Saturday night, I was engaged with a veteran in my community who said, \"My process has gone smoother than it previously did.\" They are finding that the engagement is improving. We honestly discussed how, yes, it could continue to be enhanced. That is the work we are continuing to do with our investments. Overall, the majority of conversations are about things being okay. They're better than they were. We will continue to make those investments to support veterans in their journey with Veterans Affairs Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127788","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for mentioning that. I have the opportunity to engage with veterans across the country, as many of our colleagues do. While things aren't perfect—that's the truth—what I'm hearing is.... Even as recently as Saturday night, I was engaged with a veteran in my community who said, \"My process has gone smoother than it previously did.\" They are finding that the engagement is improving. We hon","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0de3968b4a1980546c1e5dfe9f496b4be0e23403dfb73cc75af7c2881981e4b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28b8d195baf4ba7e9ab41556a06242f3bf3608754ffe399e4e104711ff9476d9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c77f5b899b1ba77cac7f5b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127789,"date":"2026-04-27T16:35:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Of the $184.9 million, there is $24 million that has been identified for IT infrastructure to support the processes. For the specifics as to what else that means, I would refer to the department officials to break that down further.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127789","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Of the $184.9 million, there is $24 million that has been identified for IT infrastructure to support the processes. For the specifics as to what else that means, I would refer to the department officials to break that down further.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d63c885682973fa9b6379adda7922859b4f2fa0a9aee43188931f18ace0ef11"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e55398f5adef3e2196103094","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127790,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Each veteran's experience is going to be unique. We can't treat all veterans the same, because each of them has their own experience. That would be whether we were comparing two veterans who served in the same conflict or whether we're comparing veterans. Each individual veteran needs to be looked at for their own unique experiences and for their needs in terms of where they are today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127790","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Each veteran's experience is going to be unique. We can't treat all veterans the same, because each of them has their own experience. That would be whether we were comparing two veterans who served in the same conflict or whether we're comparing veterans. Each individual veteran needs to be looked at for their own unique experiences and for their needs in terms of where they are today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e7dcc2200feb239e50d903fbad8f81bb5dcba0d36a9f74d1b69c0795575ef80"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-58bba9b23d7840ada87f13ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127791,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"My understanding of the question is whether we will undertake a review of the PCVRS program. During my previous appearance, I made that commitment of an independent review that will be undertaken of the PCVRS. Work has been progressing on that, and we anticipate having more to share in the coming months.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127791","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My understanding of the question is whether we will undertake a review of the PCVRS program. During my previous appearance, I made that commitment of an independent review that will be undertaken of the PCVRS. Work has been progressing on that, and we anticipate having more to share in the coming months.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05a86ab8ab3528b05c4414ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127792,"date":"2026-04-27T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Madam Chair, I disagree with my colleague's assessments. I think there are many pieces there that I don't agree with. The PCVRS program was brought in for a holistic approach to support veterans in their rehabilitation journey.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127792","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I disagree with my colleague's assessments. I think there are many pieces there that I don't agree with. The PCVRS program was brought in for a holistic approach to support veterans in their rehabilitation journey.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a11fa43a7cdf92ba882f067","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127793,"date":"2026-04-27T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"It is important that we look at as many opportunities as possible to meet the needs of veterans in ways that—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127793","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is important that we look at as many opportunities as possible to meet the needs of veterans in ways that—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f620d404b3b906e0d740150087c7013447124a1fdfa2c501f2314d92fafbf9c0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f92418b049bbe670767d3972","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127794,"date":"2026-04-27T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"That is outside the scope of my expertise or my focus. I disagree with this line of questioning.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127794","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That is outside the scope of my expertise or my focus. I disagree with this line of questioning.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d8fd752c957b108d5ab7de1d4886bf4316f84c6dbe14f646fcc89b86cb5f062f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5370f017d18f3c7ab993193","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127795,"date":"2026-04-27T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"As I mentioned in my answer to our colleague, the work is being undertaken right now to set the scope and the process for the review. We will be going through appropriate channels to have that review undertaken.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127795","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As I mentioned in my answer to our colleague, the work is being undertaken right now to set the scope and the process for the review. We will be going through appropriate channels to have that review undertaken.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2265959aafbedca4bdda87f7036277f1cdc3a2c1866d9fc9e19c2e34df242910"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1068fc30902e11b32889f58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127796,"date":"2026-04-27T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"It will be an independent...of our department that is conducting the review.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127796","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It will be an independent...of our department that is conducting the review.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Internal audits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","label":"Internal audits","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["623a4a207eaca2c1a75e8f29d95d323d78f852e599ac2230ecfb364ec0ead8df"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66d1bec1d6c75b6e9cdebc01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127797,"date":"2026-04-27T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"No, it is going to be independent of the department that is conducting the review.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127797","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, it is going to be independent of the department that is conducting the review.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Internal audits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","label":"Internal audits","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3cb650e659c4d722ca8ff0205657e002829fb049e1e080c5957a46991d258e82"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0beff55696c4d6174660b652","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127798,"date":"2026-04-27T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"As I said, we are in the midst of working through the scoping activity right now to define the parameters of the review. I look forward to sharing more details as we move through.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127798","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As I said, we are in the midst of working through the scoping activity right now to define the parameters of the review. I look forward to sharing more details as we move through.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b9dd9e05861ddefca1b797027f155c38c092275ade2a89ac98d7349add49dd11"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18a943b6288ee3284cdf2f80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127799,"date":"2026-04-27T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Both in the study that was undertaken and in the conversations that I have had with veterans, there are a number of experiences that will be considered, including the veterans' experience, the experience of Veterans Affairs Canada working with the service provider, and the experience of the service providers and the affiliates within the service providers. There are a number of different avenues that we will be looking at.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127799","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Both in the study that was undertaken and in the conversations that I have had with veterans, there are a number of experiences that will be considered, including the veterans' experience, the experience of Veterans Affairs Canada working with the service provider, and the experience of the service providers and the affiliates within the service providers. There are a number of different avenues t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","label":"Explorations","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b04139c88442fc8464bb6604af0590866530472e6efe0f52c1d268be6eca5fbb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ec98be1b6fd6a95de6c28430ff810c0a398c2c06fd1387c5477f21a3a057f95"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fce7c857be6ad082091beab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127800,"date":"2026-04-27T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"At this point, I am focused on defining the scope of the review, so that we can move forward with those steps before we look at the next decision. Right now, it is about how we get the independent review done and ensuring that veterans who are currently on the rehabilitation journey have access to continuous care.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127800","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"At this point, I am focused on defining the scope of the review, so that we can move forward with those steps before we look at the next decision. Right now, it is about how we get the independent review done and ensuring that veterans who are currently on the rehabilitation journey have access to continuous care.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","label":"Research institutes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69aa0e7da8d0e3657e440d202bd2f5956f42b34d246b1af01831edf8d1d3233c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ded4f01fed57b9e21eb809c067754af96cb5fac17158a9102a484b98569396ee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbef5c0dc2ee25bf88d174ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127801,"date":"2026-04-27T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"At this moment, it is too early to determine that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127801","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"At this moment, it is too early to determine that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e7da0afb07f6641a32492d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127802,"date":"2026-04-27T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Madam Chair, my colleague is choosing to make assumptions and to put words in my mouth. I am undertaking the steps to define the parameters of the review first.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127802","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Chair, my colleague is choosing to make assumptions and to put words in my mouth. I am undertaking the steps to define the parameters of the review first.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["601102c50a2137d596e3fa56310cc7aa9768554ed2ca27a802a83c3e60661b00"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49231d830ff16d4ef8813385","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127803,"date":"2026-04-27T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"I would just reinforce that my first and foremost priority is ensuring that our veterans continue to have access to continuous care to support them in their journey. That is fundamental to what we are doing, and that needs to be our number one focus. We are moving forward with the independent review, so that we can look at the program, and the provision of the program, to ensure that it is meeting the needs of veterans.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127803","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would just reinforce that my first and foremost priority is ensuring that our veterans continue to have access to continuous care to support them in their journey. That is fundamental to what we are doing, and that needs to be our number one focus. We are moving forward with the independent review, so that we can look at the program, and the provision of the program, to ensure that it is meeting","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["508918f25d3faa0a5f568c306621c5f76c6d19f966af97ecbbf3f701a47ec616"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c7b9b5b04df8aa87cf704660f30302f0e5da8cd72a7badbd168befaf5fbd1871"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d98c27f110c95bdc34e4514","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127804,"date":"2026-04-27T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"It is a policy of the government that was established in 1945.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127804","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is a policy of the government that was established in 1945.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f24f9125637aaa9b0e22f884fde973a61e41760987dd6edfc88600513d68494"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-214a9dc2b1a28665ff8dc279","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127805,"date":"2026-04-27T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"The policy, as I said, was enacted to support the needs of soldiers who were returning home from the war in 1945 and connect them with employment in guard services. As we've mentioned, today our veterans cover a wide range of skills. They are highly trained individuals, highly educated individuals, and each of them is in a unique and different experience, based on their service and what that has looked like. We are looking to expand our opportunities for employment for veterans, to meet them where they are in their needs, in their availability and in a career of their choosing, one that meets what they would like to do. This can include guard services. It may also include a number of other opportunities. We will be working to support veterans through the veterans employment strategy that has been developed, as we move forward and implement it, and we'll continue to work with the Corps of Commissionaires to offer opportunities in guard services for veterans as well. The time frame for the change is that the policy would be coming to an end in March 2027.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127805","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The policy, as I said, was enacted to support the needs of soldiers who were returning home from the war in 1945 and connect them with employment in guard services. As we've mentioned, today our veterans cover a wide range of skills. They are highly trained individuals, highly educated individuals, and each of them is in a unique and different experience, based on their service and what that has l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","label":"Military training","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d2f5b88082e1e640d020ee07d6dd0b2d2e8910da02507db18528819eec79ec82"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6cfeebb73717650fa392cdb76454a4961d33c386f8cba58bcd53f6f685da83c5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85f8ffbc41b6ac26a878e1df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127806,"date":"2026-04-27T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"It will be an open and competitive process, yes. The Corps of Commissionaires could choose to submit a bid for one of those contracts, and I would expect or anticipate that the Corps of Commissionaires would have the expertise and the knowledge to be able to submit a competitive bid.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127806","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It will be an open and competitive process, yes. The Corps of Commissionaires could choose to submit a bid for one of those contracts, and I would expect or anticipate that the Corps of Commissionaires would have the expertise and the knowledge to be able to submit a competitive bid.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["998b826dfe56bc7acca849ee2c530626d3d30c37d05830945806826aecb911a8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f70ed2c784aed81dcbfddd923055cd1744afe1fadf8dbb25cfef0dff0fa4512b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61af754e264b4abf1d5c88e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127807,"date":"2026-04-27T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"I feel the officials would be the best ones to respond to that question, so I will let them respond.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127807","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I feel the officials would be the best ones to respond to that question, so I will let them respond.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b575c1f5f8761a0664581c27e6b25ad5c619f94e9f62c005e9f1c3e438c354ef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbe2221b7efb39d57aff6935","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127808,"date":"2026-04-27T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"First, I think it's incredibly important to acknowledge the courage of the individuals who chose to come forward and share their stories.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127808","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"First, I think it's incredibly important to acknowledge the courage of the individuals who chose to come forward and share their stories.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cde188360c3d3ed8bba6b203","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127809,"date":"2026-04-27T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"As I've mentioned, the bureau of pensions advocates will continue to be available as a free resource for veterans.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127809","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As I've mentioned, the bureau of pensions advocates will continue to be available as a free resource for veterans.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037462","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veteran pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037462","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Veteran pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037462","label":"Veteran pensions","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c0ca5fa25de121c7ae77d5cbdef46061bb9d1c514136ba47a575bce954031ada"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96181187e764c8fdedc399c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127810,"date":"2026-04-27T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"I look forward to receiving the report on suicide from this committee and to reviewing the recommendations that come forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127810","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I look forward to receiving the report on suicide from this committee and to reviewing the recommendations that come forward.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Survivor benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","label":"Survivor benefits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d74f1be39e343c89ae217631da99f2292d9e9b8544cf536ae351ea0c71ae432e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec6d0013318c2eb93d2c126f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127811,"date":"2026-04-27T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"I've had the opportunity to speak about the veteran employment strategy, but also the entrepreneurship opportunity for veterans a few times. It is something that I think is tremendously important as we support veterans in connecting with the career of their choosing that meets their needs where they are right now. Of that, veteran entrepreneurship is an opportunity on which I think we can continue to work with veterans to explore and to meet their needs. I've had the opportunity to speak with a few veteran entrepreneurs now who have shared the positive impacts that entrepreneurship has had for them in terms of being able to adapt to their needs and give them the flexibility. In some cases, it has allowed them to continue to serve in a reserve capacity while growing their business, which has been a tremendous example. I know that this is something this committee has been studying as well and that a report will be forthcoming with recommendations, and I look forward to reading that as we move forward and build out the strategy to meet and work with veterans.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127811","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I've had the opportunity to speak about the veteran employment strategy, but also the entrepreneurship opportunity for veterans a few times. It is something that I think is tremendously important as we support veterans in connecting with the career of their choosing that meets their needs where they are right now. Of that, veteran entrepreneurship is an opportunity on which I think we can continue","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037462","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veteran pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037462","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Veteran pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037462","label":"Veteran pensions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b9fbd0525b4b8a659725408595ab16d774a599d0bb7c4ca3a3ff3c6d0fdc79ce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e6efdc1390d6dd818787485b1871e081fcd1776692541923e2742f277086409"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63eb213a6ce637767c558c1c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127812,"date":"2026-04-27T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"Yes, it is incredibly relevant to the work that is being undertaken right now. I look forward to sharing more updates.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127812","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, it is incredibly relevant to the work that is being undertaken right now. I look forward to sharing more updates.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5e56d787418eb32c001c14a6062e529d4a12f6becce3cb09f70151eddd5901a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-018613c50027ab9fa8987b43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127813,"date":"2026-04-27T17:00:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"ACVA","text":"We continue to look at and to make investments in protecting Canada and investing in our security and our sovereignty. The veterans are a key component of that, as the individuals who have served this country, who have stood up for Canada and who have defended our sovereignty. We will continue to move forward with recognition of the modern-day veteran and the contributions they have made to Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127813","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We continue to look at and to make investments in protecting Canada and investing in our security and our sovereignty. The veterans are a key component of that, as the individuals who have served this country, who have stood up for Canada and who have defended our sovereignty. We will continue to move forward with recognition of the modern-day veteran and the contributions they have made to Canada","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["523e66db007bb47302e41761435bf1022312c1ffcd355e5ff853a1636e991a6e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c7a38ac2642e4aa4131e992a4fa0610ae9f9f6f9f6fb84c3ca412a5603547713"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1da9a8b7ec02cdf94960482e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728604,"date":"2026-04-29T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, people in Conservative and B.C. ridings are telling me this week that our new government is delivering the things they need. We are bringing major projects, such as LNG train 2 and Red Chris mine, which are going to invest in our natural resources and build B.C.'s economy. We are delivering the team Canada strong program, which is going to recruit, train and hire over 80,000 new skilled workers. This means jobs for British Columbians. This is good news.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728604","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, people in Conservative and B.C. ridings are telling me this week that our new government is delivering the things they need. We are bringing major projects, such as LNG train 2 and Red Chris mine, which are going to invest in our natural resources and build B.C.'s economy. We are delivering the team Canada strong program, which is going to recruit, train and hire over 80,000 new skill","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","label":"Resource development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","label":"Resource development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0e944cb43392ed686b6a86ba5e6c4d8a8f08e194ecaefe55a56b2d1ec8779d9d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["694bc9384f56bdcf564d5b1bec1db9f1defa0c83cf92eeaece9bd3f1f1bd6c20"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8e2844a5f5ce56079c974bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728614,"date":"2026-04-29T19:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I had a conversation with the Greater Vancouver Board of Trade this week, and we were talking about the need for skilled workers in British Columbia. In yesterday's spring economic update, we announced that we are investing in the recruiting, training and hiring of more than 80,000 workers in the skilled trades. We are going to grow the Canadian economy. We are going to invest in those projects. We are doing what B.C. needs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728614","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I had a conversation with the Greater Vancouver Board of Trade this week, and we were talking about the need for skilled workers in British Columbia. In yesterday's spring economic update, we announced that we are investing in the recruiting, training and hiring of more than 80,000 workers in the skilled trades. We are going to grow the Canadian economy. We are going to invest in thos","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63d180f53788ce6bf50cab750533655d8f3c7784ccb26910d1181145eb907d54"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c63d1e0dd5954b23a6b6c2e4f26bdaed4fe1126ebef4d561e6efbf91dd457a4d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8af2afe2d5027599a0dd532","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728619,"date":"2026-04-29T20:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, government policies must evolve as the goals they speak to change. In 1945, the first right of refusal was designed to respond to the needs of soldiers returning from war. Today, this policy no longer meets the needs of veterans. \n\nToday, the average age of a releasing veteran is 34. They have a range of transferable hard and soft skills. These skills are in demand in the Canadian economy. Guard services will continue to be one option for veterans, and I will continue to advance all options for veterans.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728619","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, government policies must evolve as the goals they speak to change. In 1945, the first right of refusal was designed to respond to the needs of soldiers returning from war. Today, this policy no longer meets the needs of veterans. \n\nToday, the average age of a releasing veteran is 34. They have a range of transferable hard and soft skills. These skills are in demand in the Canadian eco","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0873be9807dfee479c5bfd4b892d8e9589f4be638f1d7c7da2c52b945d50d0eb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f605de6f10c28e4a3a15326818ef03491a4b27b43d150edc4171f479d6f57657"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29cd362456183279df8f3cc2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728602,"date":"2026-04-30T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague is from British Columbia, and he is saying that people are concerned that we are not making enough investments in Canadians. We are making those investments in Canadians.\n\nWe know that an ambitious Canada needs skilled trade workers. We are investing $2 billion to encourage young people to pursue careers in the skilled trades. We are investing in a training top-up and a $5,000 Red Seal bonus. We are investing $10,000 per apprentice in SMEs across British Columbia. We are building Canada strong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728602","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague is from British Columbia, and he is saying that people are concerned that we are not making enough investments in Canadians. We are making those investments in Canadians.\n\nWe know that an ambitious Canada needs skilled trade workers. We are investing $2 billion to encourage young people to pursue careers in the skilled trades. We are investing in a training top-up and a $","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bf8a5c36e0902d00c7a7467a16f4a2e6eb701af4cdd7188a718c6010c0c39528"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8eec9acce3617df0cdc0a0266d36eee65a232977cd35d4c0e3889900a549ab45"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27a6faa889f1f153dffd1c07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728592,"date":"2026-05-01T15:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that Bill C-30, An Act to implement certain provisions of the spring economic update tabled in Parliament on April 28, 2026, be read the second time and referred to a committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728592","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"moved that Bill C-30, An Act to implement certain provisions of the spring economic update tabled in Parliament on April 28, 2026, be read the second time and referred to a committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-294e26c00b1ea2d00be6b7de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728601,"date":"2026-05-01T16:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I have a lot of respect for my colleague opposite. Coming from British Columbia, we know that British Columbians want to see measures that are going to support them. That is why things like the groceries and essentials benefit are helping Canadians. It is going to be in their bank accounts on June 5. They want to see measures like the reduction in the fuel tax, which is saving 10¢ a litre, and that is keeping money in their pockets between now and Labour Day. They want to see the steps that we are taking. British Columbia can see that we are doing the work to support Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728601","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I have a lot of respect for my colleague opposite. Coming from British Columbia, we know that British Columbians want to see measures that are going to support them. That is why things like the groceries and essentials benefit are helping Canadians. It is going to be in their bank accounts on June 5. They want to see measures like the reduction in the fuel tax, which is saving 10¢ a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["27da50f5b6a9726036a852de2ff2007e4a1c700308fe2bddb95858f3abfd7da0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2da8f09553cd4a0a3c0c7f8adb10722ff205f41e7b2c5abd3aa61e954a507f8d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad3dc2a4e39ee601d73491d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960965,"date":"2026-05-04T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite is from British Columbia. I know that what people in British Columbia want is the actions we are taking right now. They are seeing the steps we are taking with the groceries and essentials benefit. They are seeing us remove 10¢ a litre off fuel. They are seeing our investments in young people and our economy.\n\nWe are addressing the things that people in B.C. want.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960965","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite is from British Columbia. I know that what people in British Columbia want is the actions we are taking right now. They are seeing the steps we are taking with the groceries and essentials benefit. They are seeing us remove 10¢ a litre off fuel. They are seeing our investments in young people and our economy.\n\nWe are addressing the things that people in B.C. want.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["de8beedde99c16a95ecb161b77035c87ac667bbe892158ad3f28a0bde9c7fa51"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ecd18b1308ed4eba8e3027defd9d60f575cc4d0543ace19822e8284f2bbe54e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29f4ce301e48ee697380e6c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960966,"date":"2026-05-04T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are aware of the impact of fuel prices. That is why we brought them down by 10¢ a litre. We are addressing exactly what the member opposite is talking about. We are also delivering the groceries and essentials benefit, and we made the national school food program permanent to help families. We are doing the work that is being asked for.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960966","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are aware of the impact of fuel prices. That is why we brought them down by 10¢ a litre. We are addressing exactly what the member opposite is talking about. We are also delivering the groceries and essentials benefit, and we made the national school food program permanent to help families. We are doing the work that is being asked for.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75bea15e906272ffb291319550dfb93f171a21051d92345d0488c804663cf794"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["766d004b3d4784d51e1b506ca0a48965ec21d36fed22daaffa258443035b3a40"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c4f58883812b91242bb46f06","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960967,"date":"2026-05-04T19:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank all my colleagues who were able to join us a short time ago for today's groundbreaking ceremony at the site of the national monument to Canada's mission in Afghanistan. This is a long overdue step in ensuring that the service and sacrifice of Canadians, notably the 158 Canadian Armed Forces members and the seven civilians who gave their lives, are remembered.\n\nThe monument will serve as a place of solemn reflection, remembrance and learning for generations to come, a place where Canadians can better understand the contributions made in the pursuit of peace, security and human dignity. For all Canadians, this day is an opportunity to come together in gratitude to honour those who have served and to reaffirm—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960967","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank all my colleagues who were able to join us a short time ago for today's groundbreaking ceremony at the site of the national monument to Canada's mission in Afghanistan. This is a long overdue step in ensuring that the service and sacrifice of Canadians, notably the 158 Canadian Armed Forces members and the seven civilians who gave their lives, are remembered.\n\nThe monument wil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c3ad3d2ab580f90dd57b26a675f1bbeb956d44ffccc075a6430162c0a2b3712d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80e5e773f9cd5bfa1e70828ef29ebd4bb9f2172d5feb18416bb34fade3147156"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bb3e0b04540285d3ea436b35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960968,"date":"2026-05-04T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear. The Conservatives are creating uncertainty and fear. They are intentionally scaring Canadians, creating uncertainty for investors and demonizing government. Our government has appealed, and we will continue to defend private property rights in Canada. I remind the Conservatives— \n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960968","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear. The Conservatives are creating uncertainty and fear. They are intentionally scaring Canadians, creating uncertainty for investors and demonizing government. Our government has appealed, and we will continue to defend private property rights in Canada. I remind the Conservatives— \n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04a7e83454e55e81a82dcf23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960969,"date":"2026-05-04T20:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would remind the Conservatives that real leadership means actually working to address problems, not fearmongering for political gain. Real leadership is respecting the Constitution, respecting the courts and respecting the work of advancing reconciliation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960969","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would remind the Conservatives that real leadership means actually working to address problems, not fearmongering for political gain. Real leadership is respecting the Constitution, respecting the courts and respecting the work of advancing reconciliation.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7826242ef947f507e46b4deed3f4f998637e57954b482dc9d439239313c6fb99"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-edc8a3cad7e2a8f1e05d4901","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960963,"date":"2026-05-07T19:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague across the way for the opportunity to clarify that there have been no cuts to services and benefits offered to veterans. We continue to ensure that veterans have access to the services and benefits that allow them to be successful in their post-service life.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960963","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague across the way for the opportunity to clarify that there have been no cuts to services and benefits offered to veterans. We continue to ensure that veterans have access to the services and benefits that allow them to be successful in their post-service life.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["db7e11c343ffc66fd5e55a47560773acd1416928268d34210617614560d3e7ed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fdad2f2c42989ec1974ba60ce42b44d82a42585d6ebdf59eba5e64567d9821c7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a37fef421589a40fc2071968","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960964,"date":"2026-05-07T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear. What is happening with the opposition is that they are creating uncertainty and fear. They are intentionally scaring Canadians, they are making investors scared, and they are making reconciliation out to be a bad thing.\n\nOur government has appealed. We will continue to defend private property rights in Canada.\n\nReal leadership means working together to address problems, not creating more fear in the world. Real leadership is respecting the Constitution, respecting the courts and respecting the work of advancing reconciliation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960964","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear. What is happening with the opposition is that they are creating uncertainty and fear. They are intentionally scaring Canadians, they are making investors scared, and they are making reconciliation out to be a bad thing.\n\nOur government has appealed. We will continue to defend private property rights in Canada.\n\nReal leadership means working together to address problem","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e718737961742bace9a7d23103e990b8cb0e455f012059db760566820550b233"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9be0b34f4b55a57d8d8719d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036338,"date":"2026-05-25T19:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our colleagues across the way have brought up this issue numerous times, and we have been very clear that we will stand for private property rights and protect those rights in British Columbia. \n\nThis is about creating fear and uncertainty where it is unnecessary, and it is not helping us to move forward as a country, as a province and as a community. We are focused on defending private property rights in Canada, period.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036338","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our colleagues across the way have brought up this issue numerous times, and we have been very clear that we will stand for private property rights and protect those rights in British Columbia. \n\nThis is about creating fear and uncertainty where it is unnecessary, and it is not helping us to move forward as a country, as a province and as a community. We are focused on defending priva","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6583f96d885b0a9d8d0f0809","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036335,"date":"2026-05-26T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our government knows that the path of reconciliation with first nations is how Canada moves forward as a country. Negotiated agreements, like that with Tsawwassen in my riding of Delta, are one solution. With Cowichan, negotiations failed, and the case went to the courts. We disagree with the B.C. Supreme Court decision and have filed our appeal. Our government has always defended and will always defend private property ownership.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036335","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our government knows that the path of reconciliation with first nations is how Canada moves forward as a country. Negotiated agreements, like that with Tsawwassen in my riding of Delta, are one solution. With Cowichan, negotiations failed, and the case went to the courts. We disagree with the B.C. Supreme Court decision and have filed our appeal. Our government has always defended and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["800fd19a2dc34f12274199d83ed54413864b5fc017fa82e4dd1a515401dcf40b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30f9ebe8880ac5c6cb0895ea7e5a0e23436aaadad1c169fac25c07ec8bea0e59"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72a526bef98b6d8113d07f0c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036334,"date":"2026-05-27T21:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that Bill C-31, A second Act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on November 4, 2025, be read the second time and referred to a committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036334","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"moved that Bill C-31, A second Act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on November 4, 2025, be read the second time and referred to a committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["07631d0845029742340f2edf468f00dd2043ccf42dcb6200448cdfcc0f3a2cf6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["053f5b58e49245e4c5c5353a71916fe8616e82fe8e27ccfbf58a1a514a3eb9b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e561aa61608aaa23d922314e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084420,"date":"2026-06-04T19:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for sharing the story of Shirley in his riding. I have news for Shirley. There are steps we are taking to support her. Shirley could be one of the individuals who might benefit from the middle-class tax cut, which is helping 22 million Canadians. She might also be somebody who is going to benefit from the expanded criteria for and accessibility to the disability tax credit. She might also be one of the individuals who is benefiting from the reduction of the fuel tax by 10¢ a litre.\n\nThese are all things that can impact seniors but can also impact all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084420","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for sharing the story of Shirley in his riding. I have news for Shirley. There are steps we are taking to support her. Shirley could be one of the individuals who might benefit from the middle-class tax cut, which is helping 22 million Canadians. She might also be somebody who is going to benefit from the expanded criteria for and accessibility to the disability t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a71d6fb718f49d1d1f2e7a50aa7f22b896b5e091316d0e5371e12f6216ea9df1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["551d5127346d3c26d3e39695202e0d50c6fcdba3442107c71bc46bed561e057d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2978cbdbf379d37713c47a8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084421,"date":"2026-06-04T19:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from Vancouver Island for bringing up that there are some headwinds facing our economy right now. That is why I think it is really important for us to talk about the forestry sector, which I know is really prevalent on Vancouver Island. This week, we announced that we are providing an additional $400 million through regional development agencies, and some of that money is going to be going to British Columbia to support its businesses. We are also investing $130 million in 56 projects to transform the industry, and more than 50% of that is going to British Columbia.\n\nThis is how we are supporting British Columbia—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084421","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from Vancouver Island for bringing up that there are some headwinds facing our economy right now. That is why I think it is really important for us to talk about the forestry sector, which I know is really prevalent on Vancouver Island. This week, we announced that we are providing an additional $400 million through regional development agencies, and some of that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c88bc2479641000c827a3478400b621ba551576957e64a3239b08562fc68dd30"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["423b0829229203df94c873ed271825c9947f3759282bf3c012f28f9cb1091f54"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eccd12353d25296fc5763526","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086456,"date":"2026-06-08T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbians are talking to me about the fact that they see we are facing headwinds for our economy right now. They see the U.S. charging tariffs that have not been seen since the Great Depression. They see the work that we are doing to invest in labour and to invest in good jobs for individuals, and they see the employment numbers coming up. British Columbians are optimistic, and they want us to continue the work we are doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086456","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbians are talking to me about the fact that they see we are facing headwinds for our economy right now. They see the U.S. charging tariffs that have not been seen since the Great Depression. They see the work that we are doing to invest in labour and to invest in good jobs for individuals, and they see the employment numbers coming up. British Columbians are optimistic, a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2122ba31e5d67473289e40511d5324ed9b598254d58d9e2eb84ee34c206ce3d4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9096d16a2582fa0f9e50bd84ef8d48dc61783c636dd87cf9ee06acee546a1311"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4d716f3ff667fc2699c4458","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086457,"date":"2026-06-08T19:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I said, British Columbians see that we are facing headwinds caused by geopolitical events and tariffs. The U.S. has fundamentally changed its approach to trade, raising tariffs to levels that have not been seen since the Great Depression. Canadians want to see the steps that we are taking to address this. They want to see the diversification of trade. They want to see us invest in major projects, and they want to see us invest in Canadian workers. Why can our colleagues not join with us to make these investments?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086457","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I said, British Columbians see that we are facing headwinds caused by geopolitical events and tariffs. The U.S. has fundamentally changed its approach to trade, raising tariffs to levels that have not been seen since the Great Depression. Canadians want to see the steps that we are taking to address this. They want to see the diversification of trade. They want to see us invest in ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["368efd01160d91e319545e49f24d7194b43f45f0d7b2473a6775cce0d3ef12f7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d81d7c657ef198b9b53368db242c8a37f3a21d35820e7789d710a9f3609f414e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d667a7e8812f459621a1dd2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086455,"date":"2026-06-09T19:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from the other side for the question specifically about youth jobs and youth employment. \n\nYouth employment rose by 22,000 jobs in May. Youth unemployment fell by 0.9%, the first decline since January. That means we have more work to do, which is why we have announced a $6‐billion investment in our team \"Canada Strong\" plan, mobilizing skilled trades for the workforce. It builds on youth-focused employment programs, like the Canada summer jobs. Youth in British Columbia see the opportunities ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086455","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from the other side for the question specifically about youth jobs and youth employment. \n\nYouth employment rose by 22,000 jobs in May. Youth unemployment fell by 0.9%, the first decline since January. That means we have more work to do, which is why we have announced a $6‐billion investment in our team \"Canada Strong\" plan, mobilizing skilled trades for the workf","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037241","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Student labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037241","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Student labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037241","label":"Student labour","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["67c786ac13934cf6458e82c635da031de2b7a5bd915b9fc23f6e4fdc1acd62be"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af232829b27c9595ecb9cca053f31fde2c9c3b432a68ceae836ffbdeaa5abc94"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64ea745b6aad1de18ca92520","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088308,"date":"2026-06-15T19:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister is attending the G7 summit today—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088308","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister is attending the G7 summit today—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ae80978d3b666b606b5169c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088309,"date":"2026-06-15T19:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is represented at the G7 summit today as a country that has hit its 2% NATO target this year, as a country that has attracted foreign direct investment at twice the rate of our nearest G7 countries, and as a country that has secured 20 economic and defence agreements over four continents. British Columbians like to see this growth. This is Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088309","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is represented at the G7 summit today as a country that has hit its 2% NATO target this year, as a country that has attracted foreign direct investment at twice the rate of our nearest G7 countries, and as a country that has secured 20 economic and defence agreements over four continents. British Columbians like to see this growth. This is Canada.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecb09bac201ffcd2e9c7542f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088307,"date":"2026-06-16T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jill McKnight","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank all members of the Women Veterans Council for their service to our country and for the advice and insight they offer as a council. Their lived experiences have shaped important conversations, and I remain grateful to the ongoing conversations. It is a voluntary advisory group, and I respect the decision of any member who chooses to move on to other opportunities. I welcome all advocacy on issues affecting veterans.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088307","member_id":"bc-mp-123556","member_name":"Jill McKnight","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank all members of the Women Veterans Council for their service to our country and for the advice and insight they offer as a council. Their lived experiences have shaped important conversations, and I remain grateful to the ongoing conversations. It is a voluntary advisory group, and I respect the decision of any member who chooses to move on to other opportunities. I welcome all","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bb0b81e9b6fdef20f96215102ce99ff824fa7105a68688bf60a2368d84295f64"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d820e2565ff10379e46fa617680f3c13b4090b51abbe3de46c7cb4447abc0884"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf98d675ff4a7e36fd9e3070","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76843,"date":"2026-01-27T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, low-income seniors in Esquimalt—Saanich—Sooke have been asking their government to take action to help fight the rising cost of groceries, and we listened.\n\nWe are helping with up to $950 of food and goods for low-income single seniors with the groceries and essentials benefit. We are also tackling the root causes by developing a national food security strategy to improve seniors' access to affordable, nutritious food. Meanwhile, the Conservatives are blocking everything we do, and they have no good reason for it, just fake news.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76843","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, low-income seniors in Esquimalt—Saanich—Sooke have been asking their government to take action to help fight the rising cost of groceries, and we listened.\n\nWe are helping with up to $950 of food and goods for low-income single seniors with the groceries and essentials benefit. We are also tackling the root causes by developing a national food security strategy to improve seniors' acc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","label":"Personal income","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cfa450d5adabb9988734f2110dd92b54fa9154cb0d3cb393cbca2deb5a98afc1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a2a9ff7523cd73d3b11564326ef7b3e80ceddaadbd15c5173cb0d4958f977a1e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a10198847b867d6db8856afd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76845,"date":"2026-01-27T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are controlling what we can, and we are helping Canadians where they are. We have increased OAS for seniors who are over 75 years old. We have protected OAS, ensuring that it is indexed to inflation, and we just guaranteed that low-income seniors will get the help they need to fight rising food costs with the new groceries and essentials benefit. It would buy up to 950 dollars' worth of food for a single low-income senior.\n\nWe are also tackling the root causes by developing a national food insecurity strategy to improve seniors' access to affordable and nutritious food.\n\nWhat are the Conservatives doing? They are trying to block the real action that Canadians are asking for.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76845","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are controlling what we can, and we are helping Canadians where they are. We have increased OAS for seniors who are over 75 years old. We have protected OAS, ensuring that it is indexed to inflation, and we just guaranteed that low-income seniors will get the help they need to fight rising food costs with the new groceries and essentials benefit. It would buy up to 950 dollars' wor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e3d584d9e3b795841b54513cc75d4da0806e8a6405bfb44eb16bbe2a0e25c11c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e3adbd4578fd63043411850464dcc0fe4509a0f7f2a8cb9aa2b4a16389e3cd6c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b62048ebeb36ac36c1e24389","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76846,"date":"2026-01-28T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the National Institute on Ageing's fourth annual report was just released, and it commends the actions the government is taking. It agrees with us, and its data shows that reducing expenditures in one area can result in an overall reduction in hardship as money is freed up for other household needs. That is why organizations like Food Banks Canada agree that the groceries and essentials benefit will make a real difference in the lives of Canadians, helping them to afford baby formula, helping them to afford lettuce and helping them to afford coffee and toilet paper.\n\nI do not understand why the Conservatives want to be obstructionist about feeding 12 million Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76846","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the National Institute on Ageing's fourth annual report was just released, and it commends the actions the government is taking. It agrees with us, and its data shows that reducing expenditures in one area can result in an overall reduction in hardship as money is freed up for other household needs. That is why organizations like Food Banks Canada agree that the groceries and essentia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","label":"Functional foods","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["78d55f96e552ee6a4a75a97b10441cd8a27677299ef758e0845df0ccdfea3119"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3089e0f8b89449d4d324f60a9edc30898aa9ee04af37f72ccaa4abc9dab10ba0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2848df0bff90003c8d56d1b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76848,"date":"2026-01-28T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, like many of my constituents in Esquimalt—Saanich—Sooke, I grew up in a single-parent household. I had a single mother and a handicapped sister, and making ends meet was really challenging. It is families like this that we have in mind, like the one I grew up in, like the ones that exist in my riding and in that member's riding. They are the ones we want to feed, and Food Banks Canada is supporting what we are doing.\n\nAgain, I do not understand why the Conservatives are opposed to feeding families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76848","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, like many of my constituents in Esquimalt—Saanich—Sooke, I grew up in a single-parent household. I had a single mother and a handicapped sister, and making ends meet was really challenging. It is families like this that we have in mind, like the one I grew up in, like the ones that exist in my riding and in that member's riding. They are the ones we want to feed, and Food Banks Canada","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9bd3aaf35e1d748b3e124b464e181366daa9225c86dcfaf9e07e159662e7ee45"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ef07ee85f1dcb2b1f2f23ffbad49c3c88f098b9cae83609951f23d24cf9cb4c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b23a8387939d01e8c8f9ada","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76849,"date":"2026-01-28T19:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, unlike the Conservatives, our actions are compassionate. Our actions show compassion for seniors. We increased OAS for seniors over age 75 when the Conservatives wanted to bring it down to below age 65. We have protected OAS, ensuring that it is indexed to inflation, and we just guaranteed that low-income seniors will get the help they need to fight rising food costs, which is something we cannot control. However, what we can control is helping families afford the food they need with the groceries and essentials benefit. This will buy up to $950 more food for a single, low-income senior.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76849","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, unlike the Conservatives, our actions are compassionate. Our actions show compassion for seniors. We increased OAS for seniors over age 75 when the Conservatives wanted to bring it down to below age 65. We have protected OAS, ensuring that it is indexed to inflation, and we just guaranteed that low-income seniors will get the help they need to fight rising food costs, which is somethi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","label":"Personal income","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["87abf0b045bc36c286c14762491cc3ed206c498c1b01ca922f2f14f770f0566a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b34a3f67f5febd7bad2a3aa27482a9ee6f584ed54bc35dfebccd31ea6d8d3d23"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5250a52587094a39c5b9308a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76850,"date":"2026-01-29T16:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am a millennial and my friends are millennials. What millennials want is for homes to be built. We want this plan to go forward, our plan to build hundreds of thousands of homes, in my riding and in that member's riding.\n\nI just do not know why the member wants to take the hammers and nails out of construction workers' hands and the electrical wires out of the hands of electrical workers, telling them, \"Tools down, do not build anything.\"\n\nThe member could stop obstructing and hand those hammers back to those workers so that they could build more homes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76850","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am a millennial and my friends are millennials. What millennials want is for homes to be built. We want this plan to go forward, our plan to build hundreds of thousands of homes, in my riding and in that member's riding.\n\nI just do not know why the member wants to take the hammers and nails out of construction workers' hands and the electrical wires out of the hands of electrical wo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b53bf071096b1e13c39755b94b7285c4b89cb35773a8b66e34d498a279a21b58"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["72213f598d5ca00118993479a750812f56d35bb870b4d1cd7ea207bdd0900fe8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a391c8d77a343a846a469ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86069,"date":"2026-02-02T19:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, one delay is one too many, but over 98% of applicants have received their benefits promptly. The department is working hard to quickly resolve any issues that users might encounter. We will continue to improve the benefit payment process.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86069","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, one delay is one too many, but over 98% of applicants have received their benefits promptly. The department is working hard to quickly resolve any issues that users might encounter. We will continue to improve the benefit payment process.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c356ba1b3130bb1ec2c4bd57ea62ec1bfc623722f9ade94c30a71cd8ba64a02"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5df4095ef306eb805268b3397958c9997da7c4fb5b5b0bc1c7ab648f1032f3b0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d4c6b4285d4119451493351","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86070,"date":"2026-02-02T19:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our government protects seniors. We increased the old age security pension. We are providing dental care and building housing for seniors. Now, we are modernizing the digital benefits system so that seniors can enjoy better services.\n\nI invite the member opposite to share their names with me, and we will assist them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86070","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our government protects seniors. We increased the old age security pension. We are providing dental care and building housing for seniors. Now, we are modernizing the digital benefits system so that seniors can enjoy better services.\n\nI invite the member opposite to share their names with me, and we will assist them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","label":"Dental insurance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ff8abdfea4ab3e3c6c649e7533bba3af30810b0ebd7a521bb66d7bae5e2bcd5e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d7682cd78882c3f665c7bd933b5bde23dccbd5665a4af5b911c9524ce9c1f5ab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab9c5fcafef4f49e2da4bdb0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86067,"date":"2026-02-03T19:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is funny that on the one hand the Conservatives chide the groceries and essentials benefit, but on the other hand they are upset that it is not for everyone.\n\nWhen I was the Minister of Service Alberta and had just had my new baby, I suddenly started getting child care benefit cheques that I did not need, but families that did need the money were not getting as much. We are ensuring that the families that need the money are getting the money they need, like the families in Esquimalt—Saanich—Sooke. Single seniors are going to get an extra $950 a year to help pay for toilet paper, lettuce and coffee.\n\nThose are the families that need the money. Those are the families the Conservatives are fighting against. Tell me why.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86067","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is funny that on the one hand the Conservatives chide the groceries and essentials benefit, but on the other hand they are upset that it is not for everyone.\n\nWhen I was the Minister of Service Alberta and had just had my new baby, I suddenly started getting child care benefit cheques that I did not need, but families that did need the money were not getting as much. We are ensurin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6111c32ea558e06e61f6dd65f58d13c8f3eca75d53cff3515ea48ad192bddd7a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f393b6e16ae35a2fb5c9612547af2458dd4eff96f3f5edb432a5d55ee0abd4ba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dfc6602643061b6034160b7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86068,"date":"2026-02-03T19:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, yes, these delays are too long, but more than 98% of all claimants received their benefits without delay.\n\nThe department is actively working to quickly resolve any issues clients may encounter. We continue to improve the benefit delivery process.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86068","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, yes, these delays are too long, but more than 98% of all claimants received their benefits without delay.\n\nThe department is actively working to quickly resolve any issues clients may encounter. We continue to improve the benefit delivery process.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8579200b2b7cec2a0548b99dd3e7b425b5e55a23c0c94a6b07383a09a8a51922"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b53c38d9b2e235c77cd66dfa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86064,"date":"2026-02-04T19:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the OAS transition is complete, and it came in under budget. More than seven million seniors are now receiving their benefits on time thanks to a modern system. The total cost of Cúram covers four separate projects. The $6.6 billion is the amount that was allocated and approved for the project's life cycle.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86064","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the OAS transition is complete, and it came in under budget. More than seven million seniors are now receiving their benefits on time thanks to a modern system. The total cost of Cúram covers four separate projects. The $6.6 billion is the amount that was allocated and approved for the project's life cycle.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cdf23d8dc2b5dd5ecf4085861d9b06cb6081ab391c15d2d5b0d16674688d8d9a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b42efebeb2bdc0aea575d9667a71fd7be5af01f944f5d85cd455583143e2855"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3d6ab98cce86e67568319ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86065,"date":"2026-02-04T19:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if the Conservatives want to know why we are not adopting their plan, the answer is simple: The only person who thinks it is going to work is their leader.\n\nWe are following the advice of Food Banks Canada. We are following the advice of experts. Let me tell the other side what seniors are saying. Dava Houston says, \"Seeing a lot of talk about the Grocery Rebate helping 'no one.' As a senior, I disagree. This benefit is specifically targeted to help those of us on fixed incomes navigate high food prices. It's a floor for people who built this country and need it most.\" At least the Conservatives could stop talking it down.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86065","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if the Conservatives want to know why we are not adopting their plan, the answer is simple: The only person who thinks it is going to work is their leader.\n\nWe are following the advice of Food Banks Canada. We are following the advice of experts. Let me tell the other side what seniors are saying. Dava Houston says, \"Seeing a lot of talk about the Grocery Rebate helping 'no one.' As a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["96921ed4ed7dbf54e5efe8627f79f4f086bde046ffb998502317c8dcce734f16"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d0d3f92063d59b22b2a9908e86787a593b84256c41109c572dc9be1e12b9131"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0cf01ae2ee591b7eac3eefbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86066,"date":"2026-02-04T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what will make a real difference in fighting food insecurity is ensuring that seniors have the money in their pockets that they need in order to be able to buy groceries and to buy toilet paper, coffee and these kinds of items over which the government has no control.\n\nWe are controlling what we can, and that is ensuring that seniors have the money they need in order to afford the essentials they need. That is also why we are ensuring that one million lower-income Canadians can access the benefits they are entitled to, with automatic tax filing.\n\nWe are ensuring that older Canadians get the money they need through the essentials benefit.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86066","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what will make a real difference in fighting food insecurity is ensuring that seniors have the money in their pockets that they need in order to be able to buy groceries and to buy toilet paper, coffee and these kinds of items over which the government has no control.\n\nWe are controlling what we can, and that is ensuring that seniors have the money they need in order to afford the ess","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fad1e65708ee2428868c349502d786f3472d62a1201d9addb211fa3d4abe6cbe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["687bb797571d862eb186cba9e85cb14c1d7d8df4e705aef6d5b69636e5416975"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84d032a412876f6675bde9e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86063,"date":"2026-02-05T19:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our government is protecting seniors. We have increased old age security. We are providing dental care, and we are building housing for seniors.\n\nWe are now modernizing the digital benefits system in order to provide seniors with better service.\n\nI invite the member opposite to give me their names, and we will help them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86063","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our government is protecting seniors. We have increased old age security. We are providing dental care, and we are building housing for seniors.\n\nWe are now modernizing the digital benefits system in order to provide seniors with better service.\n\nI invite the member opposite to give me their names, and we will help them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","label":"Dental insurance","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad42df418eb9abc5b8f91302e5983e3d2fbe9d65fbae7a6bcc2d48a7a1134550"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb7bc52e201dd2d66e34253ec2f42afcb224bddff5d4cf9f9210788a183ddca2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26ef7ee41b4c99c8e7bb6940","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299608,"date":"2026-02-09T19:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the switch for OAS has been completed.\n\nIt came in under budget. More than seven million seniors are now receiving their benefits on time through a modern system. The total cost of Cúram will cover four separate projects. The amount that was planned and approved for the life of the project was $6.6 billion.\n\nI encourage the member opposite to give me their names and we will help them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299608","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the switch for OAS has been completed.\n\nIt came in under budget. More than seven million seniors are now receiving their benefits on time through a modern system. The total cost of Cúram will cover four separate projects. The amount that was planned and approved for the life of the project was $6.6 billion.\n\nI encourage the member opposite to give me their names and we will help them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b1eb6189401472cdefe46153b75763098e02ba8f381ed90d3b36d9989d3c2b83"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6976123640409dd3cf7e79aa1fce6d7263ea365026ad5d70a5eaaa0d99ca3901"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c034ceab36de1ccd741329a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299609,"date":"2026-02-09T19:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the OAS modernization is now complete and it came in under budget. More than seven million seniors are receiving their benefits on time through a modern system. The total cost of Cúram will cover four separate projects. The $6.6 billion is the amount planned and approved for the life of the project.\n\nI invite the members opposite to give me the names of the seniors affected, and we will assist them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299609","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the OAS modernization is now complete and it came in under budget. More than seven million seniors are receiving their benefits on time through a modern system. The total cost of Cúram will cover four separate projects. The $6.6 billion is the amount planned and approved for the life of the project.\n\nI invite the members opposite to give me the names of the seniors affected, and we wi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e81d4fcbe1858054ce13906fe50f1f9738f97b522574cbf7eb50840c35d9efc9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4bc45fe9d6335b6c82d2609525eba2c4272e6b56b79f042c6499ca915952d4b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52290d5b58a2bb771b5379b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299606,"date":"2026-02-10T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will bite. Let us imagine what affordability would look like under the Conservatives in British Columbia.\n\nThey would cut the industrial carbon tax, and nothing would happen, because it does not affect the price of groceries. Then they would follow their plan to get out of the way, a.k.a. do nothing, and there would be no national school food program, no OAS for 65- to 67-year-olds, no groceries and essentials benefit.\n\n From what I have heard, all the Conservatives would offer is thoughts and prayers. Oh, wait. No. They would also obstruct, as they currently are.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299606","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will bite. Let us imagine what affordability would look like under the Conservatives in British Columbia.\n\nThey would cut the industrial carbon tax, and nothing would happen, because it does not affect the price of groceries. Then they would follow their plan to get out of the way, a.k.a. do nothing, and there would be no national school food program, no OAS for 65- to 67-year-olds,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc62306bceca8c1847ba2ad86c562a77c17240b50163ee5598cf157b90dd7fcd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e58dc7291ee09ff10106388c0dd23c43c1bd7e3181731bfdaa91f0d5fe09451"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce98000ee3e67119c476bb28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299607,"date":"2026-02-10T19:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are modernizing a very old system. Doing nothing would have jeopardized the payments of millions of seniors. The backlog cases are complex. They are currently being dealt with, and retroactive payments are guaranteed.\n\nAgain, I invite the member opposite to give me the names of the individuals and we will help them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299607","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are modernizing a very old system. Doing nothing would have jeopardized the payments of millions of seniors. The backlog cases are complex. They are currently being dealt with, and retroactive payments are guaranteed.\n\nAgain, I invite the member opposite to give me the names of the individuals and we will help them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a2d8e9fd3fc32ead9cba681841176a65d2455af826e30988af6001b7ff8eaad"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["670725d73c99d96293d322cb554d742c17f9d46938d58c206d63e0aedf58594b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18ef2d5cc55430b3aad9d1a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299604,"date":"2026-02-12T19:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the OAS system transfer is complete and it came in under budget. More than seven million seniors are now receiving their benefits on time through a modern system. The total cost of Cúram will cover four separate projects. The amount that was planned and approved for the life of the project was $6.6 billion.\n\nOnce again, I encourage the member opposite to give me the victims' names and we will assist them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299604","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the OAS system transfer is complete and it came in under budget. More than seven million seniors are now receiving their benefits on time through a modern system. The total cost of Cúram will cover four separate projects. The amount that was planned and approved for the life of the project was $6.6 billion.\n\nOnce again, I encourage the member opposite to give me the victims' names and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b29fe336aa4a52b494dbd340e6ebac0a28d5cc5a8a4c3a9dccf17bde41776e72"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["904f03796f2b7d3d5c8b2e74c5a00866dfbe5b44b947070b1d096a9ea7fa0d1a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e7b61f5d35df7865446326c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299605,"date":"2026-02-12T19:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are modernizing a very old system. Doing nothing would have jeopardized payments for millions of seniors.\n\nThe outstanding cases are complex. They are being assessed, and retroactive payments are guaranteed.\n\nOnce again, I invite the member opposite to provide me with the names of those who are having problems, and we will assist them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299605","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are modernizing a very old system. Doing nothing would have jeopardized payments for millions of seniors.\n\nThe outstanding cases are complex. They are being assessed, and retroactive payments are guaranteed.\n\nOnce again, I invite the member opposite to provide me with the names of those who are having problems, and we will assist them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7493d8636cd1828a58ebf12fe976d0413cbd5f56f52f293d1168af8a61e7628d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7af2950e9af467c1617663560701302d72f65f306df6db59ee5de139e40bdb8a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1376c8f0d06926bbc25e92b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316459,"date":"2026-02-23T19:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bloc members say they do not know what the money is being used for, but they were on the committees that approved the spending. They know that this money has been used to complete the transformation of a 60-year-old system. If we had let that system stand, people would not be getting their benefits. This program is not costed in a cost-overrun situation, as they would assert. This has cost just over $1.4 billion, and the OAS conversion is now complete. The amount they are talking about is a theoretical approval for a possible four-system transformation. This OAS system is now complete, people are being transitioned, and there are no cost overruns.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316459","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bloc members say they do not know what the money is being used for, but they were on the committees that approved the spending. They know that this money has been used to complete the transformation of a 60-year-old system. If we had let that system stand, people would not be getting their benefits. This program is not costed in a cost-overrun situation, as they would assert. This has","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["54da5ea30a807341f01f7a00ed0447b8b61277005c98fa4b9b75e85c1f4c318f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c1429e728c454f1ac081ecd63380787e9eceea126baccb5a5fee849c2a250d6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb49c24e45f1bceda63ef29f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316460,"date":"2026-02-23T19:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Again, Mr. Speaker, my friends across the aisle know there are no cost overruns. This was a planned, phased project. Just over $1.4 billion has been spent and the OAS project is completed. If there are individuals who are having problems getting payments on time, we invite them to contact us, and we would like them to do so. Those numbers will go down as Canadians transition to an online system. We would really like them to transition to the online system, and this will speed things up.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316460","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Again, Mr. Speaker, my friends across the aisle know there are no cost overruns. This was a planned, phased project. Just over $1.4 billion has been spent and the OAS project is completed. If there are individuals who are having problems getting payments on time, we invite them to contact us, and we would like them to do so. Those numbers will go down as Canadians transition to an online system. W","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47634","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47634","label":"Computer systems","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c6ad7cec619e964466cf183fc15e522258cb2b09f2ad272146c5a68d9283461"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fedbb0ebe5bdce01e9e30f59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316461,"date":"2026-02-23T19:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the conversion to the new OAS payment system is complete. It came in under budget. More than seven million seniors are currently receiving their benefits on time thanks to a modern system. The total cost of Cúram is meant to cover separate projects. The $6.6 billion is the amount planned and approved for the lifespan of the project.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316461","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the conversion to the new OAS payment system is complete. It came in under budget. More than seven million seniors are currently receiving their benefits on time thanks to a modern system. The total cost of Cúram is meant to cover separate projects. The $6.6 billion is the amount planned and approved for the lifespan of the project.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["976be129bbbd0b7dd080dfc08480a27079dbbc5c6667e0c5a9503c3da46d4a38"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c33c257ca9fbb05762fbd3ba8ac9a935956273bb0f1fa3d0e6a047f1b4071967"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2848c5d370907b53ba6538cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316462,"date":"2026-02-23T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am really happy to answer this question and remind the member opposite that years ago the Auditor General warned Harper's Conservatives that the old benefit payment system was outdated and at risk. That means that, under those Conservatives, people would not get their money at all. What did the Conservatives do? They did nothing. That is just their way. They get out of the way and do nothing.\n\nWe have invested. We are modernizing the system to ensure that it serves seniors for years to come. If a problem arises, we will fix it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316462","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am really happy to answer this question and remind the member opposite that years ago the Auditor General warned Harper's Conservatives that the old benefit payment system was outdated and at risk. That means that, under those Conservatives, people would not get their money at all. What did the Conservatives do? They did nothing. That is just their way. They get out of the way and d","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["55ed4152a8aaf6dd2bcae8e63270c56fa5e258a62711df4b74d242b39464a779"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e58ecfb1c62a11cc185dcae06b5454a474317d3f35d5cfffa77387ff60a05c9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15b4b86da6ef4028fa185816","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310832,"date":"2026-02-24T19:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to be perfectly clear. To date, $1.5 billion has been spent. This covers completion of the old age security transformation and initial development for employment insurance, and $6.6 billion is an upper ceiling for all the projects that this covers. This amount may never be spent.\n\nIt would have been cheaper if it had been undertaken between 2005 and 2015, when the Conservatives were in power. They knew that the tech was from 1966. My mother was only 10 years old. Let me be perfectly—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310832","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to be perfectly clear. To date, $1.5 billion has been spent. This covers completion of the old age security transformation and initial development for employment insurance, and $6.6 billion is an upper ceiling for all the projects that this covers. This amount may never be spent.\n\nIt would have been cheaper if it had been undertaken between 2005 and 2015, when the Conservatives","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","label":"Employment insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","label":"Employment insurance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["469fdedad366bfdee7d0d8304ae0f0e261f328a07921adb76b2e1f78bfca1eb7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54bffb75de89e72cc91bdc1bfb30adb65d9ee8e3e5436274780e3bf3c1b9825f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dfbe6ceff724802f86db6c5b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310829,"date":"2026-02-26T19:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the government is taking action on a critical software program. It is a program that was launched in 1966. Let us wrap our heads around that for a moment. My mother was 10 years old. Many of the members on the other side had not been born yet. That is what the Conservatives are suggesting the government move forward with: a system that the Auditor General flagged as a high risk for failure.\n\nWe need to modernize our systems. This system has already brought 7.7 million seniors on board, and more will come.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310829","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the government is taking action on a critical software program. It is a program that was launched in 1966. Let us wrap our heads around that for a moment. My mother was 10 years old. Many of the members on the other side had not been born yet. That is what the Conservatives are suggesting the government move forward with: a system that the Auditor General flagged as a high risk for fa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","label":"Software"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","label":"Software","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c4fe1983ca69ac829b05ea41a33765dfaf05aa1d61059f5b5eb70d8be0bd8c42"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6d0a8dd5cecd091940cfa025fbee8fa6ce82f110dae228c7f091fdd67fcf821"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34a0d50338670b345066a885","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310830,"date":"2026-02-26T19:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it would be nice to be asked a serious question, one rooted in facts or one rooted in numbers. To date, $1.5 billion has been spent. I do not know where the Conservatives' numbers are coming from. Perhaps it is la-la land.\n\nHowever, let us stay in reality here. This benefit system is modernizing something from 1966. We have 7.7 million seniors who are better serviced today. We are modernizing it and bringing it online, things the Conservatives do not give a crud about.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310830","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it would be nice to be asked a serious question, one rooted in facts or one rooted in numbers. To date, $1.5 billion has been spent. I do not know where the Conservatives' numbers are coming from. Perhaps it is la-la land.\n\nHowever, let us stay in reality here. This benefit system is modernizing something from 1966. We have 7.7 million seniors who are better serviced today. We are mod","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e6fc7d9a1e9ec85c19dcd94a623433cdace1f982672a5197f1a730ec54e60b59"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d69895ca45c070d4e67ac01cde747d446a58730ed9b69aebd5536499c6174a4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79890b0287bdd6d1df78a214","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310831,"date":"2026-02-26T19:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I just cannot tolerate the Conservatives talking down the good work of our public servants. Our public servants are overseeing the management of a specialized software program.\n\nI know that the Conservatives might not have any interest or desire to know about IT systems, but this requires specialized training and expertise. These are not jobs that last forever in the government. These are jobs we need to procure for specific reasons. That is what we are doing to make sure that Canadians' dollars are well spent, spent on ensuring we—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310831","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I just cannot tolerate the Conservatives talking down the good work of our public servants. Our public servants are overseeing the management of a specialized software program.\n\nI know that the Conservatives might not have any interest or desire to know about IT systems, but this requires specialized training and expertise. These are not jobs that last forever in the government. These","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","label":"Software"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","label":"Software","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["90e6f25a94a64728cb6a792ac87f3cf52254d9c9eb261422ad7d10690520e355"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b620f4d4df917e32407c103568b8b390b6039176038721cefa085ba60e378102"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-091a4109c302261c55ca6771","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350199,"date":"2026-03-11T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians elected a government they know they can rely on to support the social fabric of this country, including the support of our seniors. That is why we introduced legislation to reduce taxes for nearly 22 million Canadians. We made the national school food program permanent. We launched the Canada disability benefit. We ensured that old age security would continue for those who are 65. \n\nThis is what seniors like Dava Houston are saying. They are seeing a lot of talk from the Conservatives about the grocery rebate helping no one, but as a senior, they disagree. This benefit is specifically targeted to help those on fixed incomes—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350199","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians elected a government they know they can rely on to support the social fabric of this country, including the support of our seniors. That is why we introduced legislation to reduce taxes for nearly 22 million Canadians. We made the national school food program permanent. We launched the Canada disability benefit. We ensured that old age security would continue for those who a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc1fadeea926383e99b98682fbc6a99b185d1bc3234c4dfff7f65f3cb19de3d4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b15f1349d7ce730be750aaeb6a6dc08b9db80ce2bc132d7a1b2783817cb964c1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99c35c186adf26be6653c731","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350198,"date":"2026-03-12T19:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let me be perfectly clear with the member. The government tabled a response at the public accounts committee in January. There were over 50 pages of documentation on the progress of the benefits delivery modernization program that are publicly available and can be found online, so what the member has asked for has already been conducted. Just this morning, he also participated in a technical briefing with the department, where he learned that the benefits system is providing services to over 7 million Canadians and is on track, and that so far the expenditure is under budget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350198","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let me be perfectly clear with the member. The government tabled a response at the public accounts committee in January. There were over 50 pages of documentation on the progress of the benefits delivery modernization program that are publicly available and can be found online, so what the member has asked for has already been conducted. Just this morning, he also participated in a te","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5004205c0cdad107495193ae28d97314d98e5a7c3c12dcef478c328ac791089f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bfe71566e54dcf3be5f2b378866139186853a313f56b243b9e13693d53fa3aeb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9bd11066081650581bf41e8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715127,"date":"2026-04-13T19:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when we went to the polls just about a year ago, I went door knocking in my riding of a Esquimalt—Saanich—Sooke, and I talked to this gentleman named Craig at the door. He said to me that what was really important to him was an income tax cut. Here is the thing, he wanted to know why it would be better to vote for me than for the Conservatives. I said that, if he voted for us, the tax cut was going to come in right away. He would get up to $800 a year. If he voted for those guys, he would have to wait four years. It is not even in their plan until they are theoretically re-elected. \n\nCanadians chose. They chose right.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715127","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when we went to the polls just about a year ago, I went door knocking in my riding of a Esquimalt—Saanich—Sooke, and I talked to this gentleman named Craig at the door. He said to me that what was really important to him was an income tax cut. Here is the thing, he wanted to know why it would be better to vote for me than for the Conservatives. I said that, if he voted for us, the tax","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ce223a607e0e25e8cf1717bee06f4b9ec555409f1ba2d18884acf700c8097679"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46dd6f804da22ae652174d74b97314bb0040973e6d6d974c0ba216f63eb910ba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-817bbd92d918c650859f9bc6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715128,"date":"2026-04-13T19:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as the Secretary of State for Seniors, I talk to seniors across this country and I talk to seniors in Esquimalt—Saanich—Sooke on Vancouver Island. What they tell me is that they cannot trust these Conservatives. They cannot trust them because they have great memories. What they remember is that those Conservatives wanted to cut their old age security from them. They wanted to bring their CPP earning age up to 67. They wanted to make it more expensive to retire and more expensive to age. \n\nSeniors know they can trust the Liberal Party of Canada. They know they can trust the government to have their backs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715128","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as the Secretary of State for Seniors, I talk to seniors across this country and I talk to seniors in Esquimalt—Saanich—Sooke on Vancouver Island. What they tell me is that they cannot trust these Conservatives. They cannot trust them because they have great memories. What they remember is that those Conservatives wanted to cut their old age security from them. They wanted to bring th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7ee858a930598f136fe2358bfdb45485eaa33a1c7c9482e515f2ffcf5f5de32f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6007655c3180a23ad7dc43ad03d669b88184d4c45bc868b41ff858bee347f17a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68ca5fb5c0cb3b13a22ac67d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301448,"date":"2026-04-22T19:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the government is controlling what it can. We know there are a lot of factors outside our control, but what we can control is ensuring that youth get a head start with the Canada summer jobs program, that Canadians get help with the fuel excise tax, that apprenticeships get a $75‐million injection in training and that Canadians get a groceries and essentials benefit that gives them up to $1,400 per year for a family of four to put food on the dinner table.\n\nWe are giving Canadians a boost today and a bridge to tomorrow, while the Conservatives fight—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301448","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the government is controlling what it can. We know there are a lot of factors outside our control, but what we can control is ensuring that youth get a head start with the Canada summer jobs program, that Canadians get help with the fuel excise tax, that apprenticeships get a $75‐million injection in training and that Canadians get a groceries and essentials benefit that gives them up","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b64fc575009553062f45e408b95344556570d8b3d61836f5a64730d80da70610"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7586f2a7d45b79ce8793c047","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728624,"date":"2026-04-27T19:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is very odd hearing the Conservatives talk as if somehow we are not talking about Canadians. We are talking about Canadians here. We are talking about their dollars, and we are talking about where they want them invested. We know, loud and clear, that time and time again we have heard from Canadians that they want us to invest in them, and that means things like the groceries and essentials benefit. That means cutting the fuel excise tax. It sounds like they are saying we are putting money into our personal pockets. We are putting money into the pockets of Canadians, and the Conservatives object to that. We really need to make sure they understand how finances work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728624","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is very odd hearing the Conservatives talk as if somehow we are not talking about Canadians. We are talking about Canadians here. We are talking about their dollars, and we are talking about where they want them invested. We know, loud and clear, that time and time again we have heard from Canadians that they want us to invest in them, and that means things like the groceries and e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fdf85cb8e971a86ea81104dc96b5f0f87b4e70be0f2133033493f7fca66826f2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4d18e862061ee246dc3249fa6e6bc072e29d676b308dbde46b2bac60094c69df"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0fa5e270ed78e292edec3a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728625,"date":"2026-04-27T20:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for highlighting the incredible contributions that she makes to her community for seniors. I have seen it first-hand.\n\nJust last week, I announced over $54 million in funding for the new horizons for seniors program, which will go to more than 2,600 grassroots programs across the country benefiting seniors. With this investment, organizations like S.E.A.S. Centre in the member's riding will offer digital literacy workshops and cultural events to promote healthy, active aging. Whether it is building digital skills or organizing community meals, we continue to invest across the country no matter where seniors live.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728625","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for highlighting the incredible contributions that she makes to her community for seniors. I have seen it first-hand.\n\nJust last week, I announced over $54 million in funding for the new horizons for seniors program, which will go to more than 2,600 grassroots programs across the country benefiting seniors. With this investment, organizations like S.E.A.S. Centre in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c239dba5504a87e131029a402a78c0cad65626274e0cc16f5ddebbdac5d8bacb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b1b465a8331410691451345551f7359b10b852531d4a1064de7cdd31e395489"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b59b4031928a0807107357f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728622,"date":"2026-04-28T19:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when the Conservatives voted against the budget, they voted against the OAS and the GIS. They also voted against the New Horizons for Seniors program, a tax credit for personal support workers and the dental care program.\n\nWhat are the Conservatives voting for? It is certainly not for seniors.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728622","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when the Conservatives voted against the budget, they voted against the OAS and the GIS. They also voted against the New Horizons for Seniors program, a tax credit for personal support workers and the dental care program.\n\nWhat are the Conservatives voting for? It is certainly not for seniors.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e403c7919c14ac0154265db5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036340,"date":"2026-05-25T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we hear no common sense from the other side, and perhaps that is because they do not speak to Canadians.\n\n Over here we are hearing from Canadians regularly, and they know that Canada faces a profound global economic uncertainty right now. That is why we are responding with responsible measures, like protecting seniors from fraud and making the social programs that they rely on efficient and resilient to global shocks. For example, the groceries and essentials benefit will give single seniors almost $950 back in their pockets. This is what it means to be fiscally responsible managers, investing in the public.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036340","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we hear no common sense from the other side, and perhaps that is because they do not speak to Canadians.\n\n Over here we are hearing from Canadians regularly, and they know that Canada faces a profound global economic uncertainty right now. That is why we are responding with responsible measures, like protecting seniors from fraud and making the social programs that they rely on effici","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["16528f823de52b32bb4ef8606a5e0f8edfe6f4f8270f5e742a96b816c1b9a72c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9db5a1f9915505a4de35c3ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036341,"date":"2026-05-25T19:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our government has said time and time again, and has shown through action, that we stand with the people of British Columbia, we stand with private title rights holders and we stand with indigenous people. We are taking the appropriate action, and we are appealing the decision in the courts.\n\nIt is frightening how the Conservatives are attempting to whip up disinformation and scare private property owners, who need to know the government has their back.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036341","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our government has said time and time again, and has shown through action, that we stand with the people of British Columbia, we stand with private title rights holders and we stand with indigenous people. We are taking the appropriate action, and we are appealing the decision in the courts.\n\nIt is frightening how the Conservatives are attempting to whip up disinformation and scare pr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0216c49e717e3fea66fef427f1aae017c0557b3c9d8d3bb81e3164b4e02524ec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f8f60e1b5ad472c1332658c5dda9ca38a75653a34f52b6b5774c111b85a13f5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e74267f692263709a130bd1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036339,"date":"2026-05-28T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is very rich coming from the Conservatives, whose plan is to do nothing. Their plan is to absolutely ignore the needs of Canadians, and we see that when they vote against measures such as ensuring that there is old age security for seniors, and when they put forward measures that would ensure that seniors aged 65 to 67 cannot get old age security. When the Conservatives folks talk about seniors, what Canadians should hear is crickets.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036339","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is very rich coming from the Conservatives, whose plan is to do nothing. Their plan is to absolutely ignore the needs of Canadians, and we see that when they vote against measures such as ensuring that there is old age security for seniors, and when they put forward measures that would ensure that seniors aged 65 to 67 cannot get old age security. When the Conservatives folks tal","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd553892baf0e12071bdd0d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086467,"date":"2026-06-08T19:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians deserve facts, not Conservative fear. Labelling the economy without context does not help workers or businesses. The Bank of Canada has, in fact, cautioned against doing that.\n\n Economies around the world are facing global uncertainty, but Canada is weathering these global headwinds better than many of our peers. Our economy is stable, jobs are being created and we continue to support Canadians through these headwinds.\n\nWe will remain focused on affordability, economic growth and supporting jobs, while the Conservatives remain focused on fearmongering.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086467","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians deserve facts, not Conservative fear. Labelling the economy without context does not help workers or businesses. The Bank of Canada has, in fact, cautioned against doing that.\n\n Economies around the world are facing global uncertainty, but Canada is weathering these global headwinds better than many of our peers. Our economy is stable, jobs are being created and we continue ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6b7855445f2daf0458bf7bae081ce26c52ca3add70468898b24029fba043e4d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["60bbf875868b6c7ea87d500ffd03003ca6e093ca8b59a0ce2298514bdf315f2a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a866eaf6225a327803edaba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086466,"date":"2026-06-10T04:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we know that 76% of appellate-level challenges to Harper-era mandatory minimum sentences were successful. We also know that the Conservatives are saying that they will not support this bill without the addition of mandatory minimum sentences, but more than 217 challenges to the constitutionality of these since 2021 have been made. When the courts frequently strike down mandatory minimum sentences, why do members think the Conservatives want the government to include clauses that would weaken the legislation, increase the likelihood of it being struck down, and take up precious court time and costs on unconstitutional clauses? What do you think their real reason is for—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086466","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we know that 76% of appellate-level challenges to Harper-era mandatory minimum sentences were successful. We also know that the Conservatives are saying that they will not support this bill without the addition of mandatory minimum sentences, but more than 217 challenges to the constitutionality of these since 2021 have been made. When the courts frequently strike down mandatory minim","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3fc6d6e481d7c0ba1c5424ef7fd3a7166d9edb5db56653f383e4a7937f0aec28"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f4d418bbf474481f38dda5806036953b1c4a87853a87229493f278509c6f6d8a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b1201277f0883e9db3b30b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086464,"date":"2026-06-10T19:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Vancouver Islanders in the member's riding and mine deserve facts. Labelling the economy without context does not help workers or businesses.\n\nThere are 22 nation-building projects driving over $125 billion in capital investment. There were 88,000 new jobs in May, exceeding market expectations. Wages are growing almost twice as fast as in the United States. Disposable income rose 2.3%. Household savings are above historic norms. These are the facts, but I have never met a Conservative who did not let the facts get in the way.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086464","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Vancouver Islanders in the member's riding and mine deserve facts. Labelling the economy without context does not help workers or businesses.\n\nThere are 22 nation-building projects driving over $125 billion in capital investment. There were 88,000 new jobs in May, exceeding market expectations. Wages are growing almost twice as fast as in the United States. Disposable income rose 2.3%","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035568","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Growth capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035568","label":"Growth capital","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["44812af47f6ee1f51cd627fd1c2bd327962df8d2bec5eec7d842cf6dbea4577d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c2e21d6f53d75b24f859938e9843620d8cc167f567d84d6eed4a612d4535dc28"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f6707367053f356cda976f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086465,"date":"2026-06-10T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, young people know that this government is there for them. They know that because they have a majority of the new jobs that are being created. They also know that business investment has increased for the second consecutive quarter in Canada. They know that the IMF projects Canada will be the fastest-growing economy in the G7 in 2026-27. They know that this government has a plan that we are executing that has their backs for a good future.\n\n Joe Rogan might be impressed by kettlebells and empty rhetoric, but in the words of the great Shania Twain, \"That don't impress me much\".","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086465","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, young people know that this government is there for them. They know that because they have a majority of the new jobs that are being created. They also know that business investment has increased for the second consecutive quarter in Canada. They know that the IMF projects Canada will be the fastest-growing economy in the G7 in 2026-27. They know that this government has a plan that w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e816d3b1ccd5963bb513ec8ceb2cd5add4a28ace37cbf2693df345b36d7898e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["015fb9e071ddd8c1ed84e34d7cff3b747759499ea7a081e65db435c086f14db2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6c0c53ae79a9d4b2f78ccc9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086462,"date":"2026-06-11T19:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in April, we introduced changes to the new horizons for seniors program, including requiring a CRA business number. For most seniors organizations, this change delivers clearer, fairer standards that increase the program's integrity. For organizations that do not have this number, Service Canada is available to assist all applicants. Members of Parliament are also available to assist applicants. That is why we provided a session to all members of Parliament, so that they could ask their questions, a session that, unfortunately, the hon. member did not attend.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086462","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in April, we introduced changes to the new horizons for seniors program, including requiring a CRA business number. For most seniors organizations, this change delivers clearer, fairer standards that increase the program's integrity. For organizations that do not have this number, Service Canada is available to assist all applicants. Members of Parliament are also available to assist ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1a1582be085474d16625d646b8eb5cac969483abab62c08377034f30fdc0d603"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02813510f204466c6d7e8d8fd3c99a6cfe01e3141a63129b23f232cd30ba65ed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c3b12d8fbc0c201d8649357","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086463,"date":"2026-06-11T19:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, prior to these changes, the new horizons for seniors program was the only grant within the Government of Canada that was not subject to these integrity measures. We are putting this program in line with all other grants and contributions across the Government of Canada. By looking at the clock, I can see that it is June 11. There is lots of time for organizations, and we are there to help them. We will make sure they have what they need to apply for these programs because we want nothing more than to ensure that seniors have access to the important programs that prevent social isolation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086463","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, prior to these changes, the new horizons for seniors program was the only grant within the Government of Canada that was not subject to these integrity measures. We are putting this program in line with all other grants and contributions across the Government of Canada. By looking at the clock, I can see that it is June 11. There is lots of time for organizations, and we are there to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["acd9699d5bde1fe3b5d4fb7d97e21c65b1768f5b4a183f6ed52ddd5b53072263"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e06623efb23f2ebb7de8fc67145bcb336ecfdf55cee295a2da737e93d2c7319"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11e8a5e565d6663fc1d78748","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086458,"date":"2026-06-12T16:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we announced these changes to the New Horizons for Seniors program almost a month before the applications opened up, and we made these changes, requiring the CRA business number, to ensure the integrity of the program. \n\nHere is what CanAge has to say about these changes. It has said that it is pleased to see this important step to ensure the integrity of the program. It believes that the simplified grant format, ease of reporting requirements and significant supports available for community-based organizations ensure that this program remains accessible and inclusive.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086458","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we announced these changes to the New Horizons for Seniors program almost a month before the applications opened up, and we made these changes, requiring the CRA business number, to ensure the integrity of the program. \n\nHere is what CanAge has to say about these changes. It has said that it is pleased to see this important step to ensure the integrity of the program. It believes that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f7e80406cfd0ee0905555bf0a93f1d5847f785f0643ee57e087f26405bb6c86"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["195358416cb25dd2d490475b5cf7717f2986af3e3741bc0459bdd6dd48423ac6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-191a3cc3dda00ec4cfa945e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086459,"date":"2026-06-12T16:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, these changes are important to ensure the integrity of the program, but we also want to make sure that all of the wonderful senior-servicing organizations across Canada have the support they need. That is why Service Canada has provided additional resources to ensure that signing up for the business number is easy. \n\nThere is a 15- to 30-minute process to make sure that this happens online, but there are also supports available to help seniors over the phone. More than that, there are supports through their local MPs' offices. If the member had attended our sessions, he would know that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086459","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, these changes are important to ensure the integrity of the program, but we also want to make sure that all of the wonderful senior-servicing organizations across Canada have the support they need. That is why Service Canada has provided additional resources to ensure that signing up for the business number is easy. \n\nThere is a 15- to 30-minute process to make sure that this happens o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501180","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501180","label":"Business services","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31d6d750aa094367b917fd71531ecec60f7aed4273ea1827d836b9847a77cc4b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eaa6815296786e27b524d544","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086460,"date":"2026-06-12T16:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard from seniors organizations across this country applauding the changes we have made to the New Horizons for Seniors program, which are ensuring that we have doubled the amount available to senior-servicing organizations but also ensuring the integrity of the program for years to come. This was one of the very few grants left in the Government of Canada that did not have these requirements, and this will ensure for years to come that this program is something seniors can rely on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086460","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard from seniors organizations across this country applauding the changes we have made to the New Horizons for Seniors program, which are ensuring that we have doubled the amount available to senior-servicing organizations but also ensuring the integrity of the program for years to come. This was one of the very few grants left in the Government of Canada that did not have t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["24ea763afbadd5b216b21eab123df71cad1db86bde016c166a49bedf8a6463fb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82383abfe03fae92e7fe5b65da554e2b13e765b5418bfa93642e5138988e4941"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-290f44b12e3eacdf57e3766e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086461,"date":"2026-06-12T16:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie McLean","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, seniors across this country know that they can rely on this Liberal government to support them and have their backs. While it is heartbreaking to read about what is happening to some of these seniors, including in Richmond, that party over there would do nothing for them. It would walk away from the problem and say, \"Pull yourselves up by your bootstraps.\"\n\n What we are doing is providing a social safety net, including old age security, the groceries and essentials benefit and the newly announced food security strategy. More than that, we are building over 500,000 homes a year.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035799","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Social security","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086461","member_id":"bc-mp-123563","member_name":"Stephanie McLean","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, seniors across this country know that they can rely on this Liberal government to support them and have their backs. While it is heartbreaking to read about what is happening to some of these seniors, including in Richmond, that party over there would do nothing for them. It would walk away from the problem and say, \"Pull yourselves up by your bootstraps.\"\n\n What we are doing is provi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035799","label":"Social security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035799","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035799","label":"Social security","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["14a1cb88fdaab75edd1b79ff6073f2c1561a7308fe2b58939919fe21b6e3a2d7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035799","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["466cf82db94204011bc8d4dd714b45a9ba82667f903ef50551db1e972c866a64"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035799","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035799","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035799","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035799","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22e49871a1819c7bdbb9fb7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86071,"date":"2026-02-04T19:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour the life and passing of my grandfather, Jacob Sawatzky Sr., whose story embodies the very best of Canada. \n\nBorn in Ukraine, he survived the Holodomor famine and Stalin's Great Terror, in which his father and many others in the family were killed. At 16 years old, he fled his village to find a new life. All he had was a bag of dry bread that his mother had given him. \n\nMy grandfather arrived in Canada alone, speaking no English and with little education. Canada gave him refuge, and he gave back. While working in a factory, he learned English, went back to school and earned a science degree from UBC. He then taught math and physics for nearly three decades, shaping generations of young Canadians.\n\nToday, I wear my grandfather's old tie in the chamber as a tribute to his values. He was proud of his family and forever grateful for a country where he could build a new life.\n\nRest in peace, Jacob Sawatzky Sr. \n\nHe will not be forgotten.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86071","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour the life and passing of my grandfather, Jacob Sawatzky Sr., whose story embodies the very best of Canada. \n\nBorn in Ukraine, he survived the Holodomor famine and Stalin's Great Terror, in which his father and many others in the family were killed. At 16 years old, he fled his village to find a new life. All he had was a bag of dry bread that his mother had given","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","label":"Science education","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7efb112f205d1cbedf77c4b657f6952f4c81f991f64a962dfc8855929ada8096"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c66a9053112e3879d94a482f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299610,"date":"2026-02-12T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today B.C. is observing a day of mourning to honour the victims of the Tumbler Ridge mass shooting. \n\nSchool should be a place where children learn about the world, a place where the biggest stress is a test they did not study enough for or when they are late for class and the bell is ringing, a place where they make friends and catch up with them every day at lunch. School should never be a place where children fear for their lives. \n\nEvery kid deserves a place where they can relax and grow. What happened in Tumbler Ridge is absolutely devastating. Innocent lives have been taken and many more injured. All of British Columbia, all of Canada and so many around the world are grieving. \n\nWe mourn with the families who have lost loved ones and with those who are recovering. No words can make this better, but they must know that they are not alone. Let us hold each other a little closer as we face this together.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299610","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today B.C. is observing a day of mourning to honour the victims of the Tumbler Ridge mass shooting. \n\nSchool should be a place where children learn about the world, a place where the biggest stress is a test they did not study enough for or when they are late for class and the bell is ringing, a place where they make friends and catch up with them every day at lunch. School should nev","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1dd8359ea3642b5a7997fca3f0dd4506e0b64c378f7ca9e08d52aadf0c8ca928"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8834273a5876aea35264fa19fbb5f81733fd785f3a63ca7ac3811df7bbbebc1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f1c4543cebc8f3d82261143","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299611,"date":"2026-02-12T19:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there has been an outpouring of grief and support across this country following the Tumbler Ridge tragedy that occurred on Tuesday. The House has come together to honour the innocent lives lost.\n\nCan the Secretary of State for Combatting Crime please reflect on the mass shooting in B.C?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299611","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there has been an outpouring of grief and support across this country following the Tumbler Ridge tragedy that occurred on Tuesday. The House has come together to honour the innocent lives lost.\n\nCan the Secretary of State for Combatting Crime please reflect on the mass shooting in B.C?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020172","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Burials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020172","label":"Burials","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","label":"Humanitarian crisis","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5643d5d6b57ce31b0d6836aff046ca988826ff118f2ebbfbfbcd3c8c5b4fe94e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1faeb085745518be6384dfcc4d5764fa987a13801229f8fc6eb4d51ffd834ed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b419e79e23efff520279b75d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127814,"date":"2026-04-13T21:10:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for coming today. Over the past several years, the federal government has taken steps to strengthen consumer protection frameworks, including enhanced oversight of financial institutions and expanded tools for consumer awareness. At the same time, we recognize that many Canadians continue to face pressures from high borrowing costs and cost of living challenges. In this context, could you speak to how effective current consumer protection measures have been in supporting Canadians with debt obligations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127814","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for coming today. Over the past several years, the federal government has taken steps to strengthen consumer protection frameworks, including enhanced oversight of financial institutions and expanded tools for consumer awareness. At the same time, we recognize that many Canadians continue to face pressures from high borrowing costs and cost of livin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["611c716cbc478d362507d71ba2140e6c279cc09aa9bfe0a664d2fb0c7388eec4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["824c99acfc92971ea2b7b8e8a40c17b3553448ce4777e5734cc282b86c46f844"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa8fbe07e96646b2d70617f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127815,"date":"2026-04-13T21:10:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. Do you see any opportunities to further strengthen protections in general?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127815","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Do you see any opportunities to further strengthen protections in general?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05e1da9137f38b4952222e6cdaeb9a09a7b577f15062e60296b547129089d074"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db420514e64bc62417575a6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127816,"date":"2026-04-13T21:10:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. That's good to hear. This topic has come up a few times with scam texts and collaboration with telcos. Financial literacy was brought up. I wanted to see if you could provide some context on the younger generation and how they're dealing with financial literacy. Are there any kinds of gaps you'd identify that could be addressed to ensure that younger generations are being more financially literate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127816","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. That's good to hear. This topic has come up a few times with scam texts and collaboration with telcos. Financial literacy was brought up. I wanted to see if you could provide some context on the younger generation and how they're dealing with financial literacy. Are there any kinds of gaps you'd identify that could be addressed to ensure that younger generations are being more financial","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cd188f562769551509f3b8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127817,"date":"2026-04-13T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Schwartz, you mentioned preventative financial literacy. I think this is an important thing to talk about. I was curious to get your take on the rise in online gambling. Have you seen this affect people financially? I wondered if you had anything to say on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127817","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Schwartz, you mentioned preventative financial literacy. I think this is an important thing to talk about. I was curious to get your take on the rise in online gambling. Have you seen this affect people financially? I wondered if you had anything to say on that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5431e594a2e3ee7843212ace","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127818,"date":"2026-04-13T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Are there any things you find yourself repeating a lot when you're giving financial literacy advice? Are there things that more people should be aware of?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127818","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are there any things you find yourself repeating a lot when you're giving financial literacy advice? Are there things that more people should be aware of?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","label":"Personal finance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f39369fa1d47286dd40afaec3c28b7a7945d2386969a0c7f4a15c9b3b38cf9bb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4924954957ed03b23db26515","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127819,"date":"2026-04-13T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Have you been seeing a significant number of people taking on additional debt to pay off other debts?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127819","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Have you been seeing a significant number of people taking on additional debt to pay off other debts?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4261ba9fa9f80811ff08f6ccb286c33876533c8083577ec1a9cb8141b8b4c90e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3894a3dc7f73f5dc1c42ff2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127820,"date":"2026-04-13T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. Are there any other things you find yourself consistently bringing up?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127820","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Are there any other things you find yourself consistently bringing up?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083609","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recyclable materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083609","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recyclable materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083609","label":"Recyclable materials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a257778e115fb6215839f43c6541f0b2d0911ac6e1b1959dd1e09f3f5e254e34"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1efa046813fe0938c9967867","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127821,"date":"2026-04-13T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"For anyone who isn't familiar with your organization, how can they get in touch with you?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127821","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"For anyone who isn't familiar with your organization, how can they get in touch with you?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["841eca704fe281a59f7d182c0adc7579679757cd1572b42b46baae568a225090"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64fa88b8bf15ebda1c5ce54d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127822,"date":"2026-04-13T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Could you speak to the broader economics of everything that's going on internationally, such as the Strait of Hormuz being closed, for example? How do these international events affect people's day-to-day expenses?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127822","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Could you speak to the broader economics of everything that's going on internationally, such as the Strait of Hormuz being closed, for example? How do these international events affect people's day-to-day expenses?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c51c16214b1bd625f98ebe5c03f0712fe3cc2c32129b86cfa70cee3007db9e5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-48571d87dbe496ab81c43482","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127823,"date":"2026-04-13T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. When it comes to federal policy, are there any things the federal government can do to help out with what you're doing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127823","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. When it comes to federal policy, are there any things the federal government can do to help out with what you're doing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["621977d179edcc957d7fab1c3b2d08f2b56c004d4da92b8a4aacced8eafac265"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-331d70f6676c719cbce700ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127824,"date":"2026-04-13T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"What percentage, roughly, of people are thinking about saving? Are there a lot of people who are familiar with how important it is?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127824","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What percentage, roughly, of people are thinking about saving? Are there a lot of people who are familiar with how important it is?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15ca0089a9ce6fbb5d9dc9d6c7bd0284685f708037d4a022062d0d009fbf3819"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17ca21a6d943816b8c01886d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301449,"date":"2026-04-20T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today marks the opening of Canada summer jobs 2026, with 100,000 positions that will be posted on the job bank, which Canadians can visit on jobbank.gc.ca/youth. This is the largest number of summer job opportunities ever, with budget 2025 investing in 24,000 more jobs this summer.\n\nCan the Secretary of State for Children and Youth please explain what this investment means for young Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301449","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today marks the opening of Canada summer jobs 2026, with 100,000 positions that will be posted on the job bank, which Canadians can visit on jobbank.gc.ca/youth. This is the largest number of summer job opportunities ever, with budget 2025 investing in 24,000 more jobs this summer.\n\nCan the Secretary of State for Children and Youth please explain what this investment means for young C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c765f7394ce43050b35ad571c0af0370c2571c60fe5138be16c8734e78b34a10"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["91561b2adb033a51cec111c43767db4114c384384220567659d47e3000ddc9db"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3cdcd53db96db35c8540ca8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127825,"date":"2026-04-20T21:10:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for coming in today. Ms. Bednar, in your opening remarks you were talking about buy now pay later. You mentioned that this has become an increasingly common situation with younger Canadians. I was seeing a joke about an ad where people could finance a pizza, which goes to show how common this is, even for small transactions. Where does financial literacy come into play here? How can we educate the younger generations about what's in the small print? What would you see? What are the first steps we can take to reduce some of this being such a common occurrence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127825","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to our witnesses for coming in today. Ms. Bednar, in your opening remarks you were talking about buy now pay later. You mentioned that this has become an increasingly common situation with younger Canadians. I was seeing a joke about an ad where people could finance a pizza, which goes to show how common this is, even for small transactions. Where does financial literac","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c3812d6668b0b5e698acfb0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127826,"date":"2026-04-20T21:15:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. What would you say are some of the more predatory practices with buy now pay later? Are there certain instances where this is particularly bad? I know you mentioned some good aspects, and that's nice to hear. What would be some negative ones?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127826","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. What would you say are some of the more predatory practices with buy now pay later? Are there certain instances where this is particularly bad? I know you mentioned some good aspects, and that's nice to hear. What would be some negative ones?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d875217fca3f0a56adf65d0d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127827,"date":"2026-04-20T21:15:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"You mentioned some further regulations. What could those regulations look like?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127827","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You mentioned some further regulations. What could those regulations look like?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84323f709a698b81ccac925e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127828,"date":"2026-04-20T21:15:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"What's the best-case scenario? Have we taken all the steps that we should here? How could this look in a good situation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127828","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What's the best-case scenario? Have we taken all the steps that we should here? How could this look in a good situation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e20dff5b74901af84a4aa16a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127829,"date":"2026-04-20T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Mr. Leitão. I would also like to thank the witnesses for joining us today. Ms. Pugliese, in your opening remarks, you mentioned that people often find themselves in debt following a life-altering event. Could you specify what types of events you observe most frequently and how they specifically lead to debt?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127829","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Leitão. I would also like to thank the witnesses for joining us today. Ms. Pugliese, in your opening remarks, you mentioned that people often find themselves in debt following a life-altering event. Could you specify what types of events you observe most frequently and how they specifically lead to debt?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0eca0d6f0634543494b8c734f6b4838be459bf6758186a7a79e0ec04c285c2df"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9ddbee2d7ecfe0d0f5ab04d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127830,"date":"2026-04-20T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you very much, Ms. Pugliese. My next question is for Mr. Cowan. I was having a look at your recent podcast, in which you talk about global changes. We've been hearing at times that explaining these is an excuse. It's not necessarily an excuse. I think it's just important to consider the context. I have about 50 seconds here. How would you explain how these economic shocks can affect consumer confidence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127830","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Ms. Pugliese. My next question is for Mr. Cowan. I was having a look at your recent podcast, in which you talk about global changes. We've been hearing at times that explaining these is an excuse. It's not necessarily an excuse. I think it's just important to consider the context. I have about 50 seconds here. How would you explain how these economic shocks can affect consumer","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d03daf6e6906c02361b77ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127831,"date":"2026-04-23T14:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Dijkema, thank you so much for your introductory remarks. I find very similar concerns when it comes to gambling and how widespread this has become. I'd like to note that the Maryland Center of Excellence on Problem Gambling reports that individuals with a gambling disorder have a suicide rate five to 10 times greater than the general population, and 4% to 40% or higher will attempt suicide. When you think about how common sports betting has become, this is a serious issue. It's become very normalized when it comes to watching sports. Gambling becomes part of what people are doing. You mentioned Marty Deacon's bill. This has been supported by my colleagues MP Bardeesy and Bardish Chagger . I'm very happy to hear that there's some movement there. I share your concerns. One thing I want to ask you about is how real-time betting plays into this. People are watching sports and making these impulsive decisions while the sports are ongoing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127831","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Dijkema, thank you so much for your introductory remarks. I find very similar concerns when it comes to gambling and how widespread this has become. I'd like to note that the Maryland Center of Excellence on Problem Gambling reports that individuals with a gambling disorder have a suicide rate five to 10 times greater than the general population, and 4% to 40% or higher will ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","label":"Gambling"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","label":"Gambling","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3d15bec0203a1b4877d6d7200f87aeb52608ae28e8c55019a8bb6d4a09fa2a7f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2500faf67fc7fe625f49ebea1803d548200ab2372eccb3693d7d4982144055ca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b2b81e3c0cd73ec65e40689","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127832,"date":"2026-04-23T14:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Mr. Dijkema. I actually have a friend who is going through an issue like this. They noted exactly what you said about the facade of sports betting, and how once you're in the app, it becomes slot machines and casino-like gambling methods. That's very interesting. Could you speak a bit to the widespread advertising that we're seeing? With every sports game you're watching, you're starting to see tons of ads being pumped for sports betting. Could you speak to that, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127832","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Dijkema. I actually have a friend who is going through an issue like this. They noted exactly what you said about the facade of sports betting, and how once you're in the app, it becomes slot machines and casino-like gambling methods. That's very interesting. Could you speak a bit to the widespread advertising that we're seeing? With every sports game you're watching, you're startin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","label":"Gambling"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","label":"Gambling","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f1ea7f624560886d6c1549659c47ae3712782d61a59424bd5e7a834df1ce3f41"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cbc676a849b6361755587fc44d745c6800f91c70c21c07e93fa7d01b96b1b41d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88492f0d46a4cf20e4d329b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728635,"date":"2026-04-27T19:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, premiers and MPs from all stripes agree the Sunrise expansion is a major step forward. It will create good jobs, strengthen Canada's energy security and see 38 first nations acquire equity stakes in the project, advancing economic reconciliation while helping us reach new markets.\n\n Can the minister speak to why this project is so important for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728635","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, premiers and MPs from all stripes agree the Sunrise expansion is a major step forward. It will create good jobs, strengthen Canada's energy security and see 38 first nations acquire equity stakes in the project, advancing economic reconciliation while helping us reach new markets.\n\n Can the minister speak to why this project is so important for Canadians?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f68d7d982e73c99e148db2c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127833,"date":"2026-04-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Ms. Schirle, for your opening remarks. You were mentioning the importance of early learning and child care for the economy. I was wondering if you could elaborate on a few things. To start, what's the return on investment when we invest in programs for early learning and child care?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127833","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Ms. Schirle, for your opening remarks. You were mentioning the importance of early learning and child care for the economy. I was wondering if you could elaborate on a few things. To start, what's the return on investment when we invest in programs for early learning and child care?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","label":"Preschool education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","label":"Preschool education","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["706af35b3dc31a473fcdc5a87e506113b78bb6af1e1dd7a60135cc35bc910ad0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c2af6b3a75a035396a5c3b8628ed9d0e08dad3a66a964e5a62e6077d6a8fa6d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc3c0e29174858787340b28f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127834,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"That's very significant. How does this investing in child care allow mothers to perhaps return to the workforce? What is the outcome there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127834","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's very significant. How does this investing in child care allow mothers to perhaps return to the workforce? What is the outcome there?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maternity benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","label":"Maternity benefits","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac1c0ae5f3864c7d38e8353f3d318a0de2b427799f24bfbf3ae0738c0d2233a0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b1443b5478b4c0c91cd27d0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127835,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Are there certain sectors that see specific benefits from this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127835","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are there certain sectors that see specific benefits from this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5b7296d5ca90aefe14336ab00de4b66192263b471ea31b9ccb5680fe310be93"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a354ac29d497341691bf623f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127836,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"That's very interesting. How was the $10-a-day child care rolled out? In your view, could that be continued? Could it be improved?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127836","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's very interesting. How was the $10-a-day child care rolled out? In your view, could that be continued? Could it be improved?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f0da0cbf0dee62305d5a4c3c67832dee5498d1a63605e91b7800a023b0fe807"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dfeaaafe5214a3d33e0d0bc0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127837,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Does access to early learning programs increase the long-term economic outcomes for the children who have access to early learning?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127837","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Does access to early learning programs increase the long-term economic outcomes for the children who have access to early learning?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["917777b78b075efe3e31c61a46f91b8a6d15520eeaf438291757662e85ebf7d1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab8cc63c948d94a50134a8af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127838,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thanks. Do you have any policy recommendations on this topic?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127838","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thanks. Do you have any policy recommendations on this topic?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e44397053ff4be95dfc7b9a0b7d7e0cce2f603028713538c320ebfe0af8d6258"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02309e4b7c1a6789e2259bc9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127839,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"On a similar note, there's a lot of talk about the national school food program making food accessible for people who might not be able to afford it. I wonder if you could touch on that. Has this come to your research?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127839","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"On a similar note, there's a lot of talk about the national school food program making food accessible for people who might not be able to afford it. I wonder if you could touch on that. Has this come to your research?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a26054e3cdabef9e3fda2dfb6cc5a9989bf6d9d112a69ae6c4d3dbb2777a267"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-753baf3214190dc3492b7524","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127840,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you very much. I appreciate that. Ms. Robson, you ran out of time during your opening remarks. Is there anything else you would like to note?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127840","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I appreciate that. Ms. Robson, you ran out of time during your opening remarks. Is there anything else you would like to note?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2938d86fe556f45abf9eb835","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127841,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"On a similar topic, Canada has maintained a focus on fiscal responsibility through declining debt-to-GDP targets over the medium term while still making targeted investments in affordability, productivity and economic growth. To what extent do you believe Canada's current fiscal approach appropriately balances the need for targeted federal spending with maintaining a credible fiscal anchor, such as a declining debt-to-GDP ratio?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127841","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"On a similar topic, Canada has maintained a focus on fiscal responsibility through declining debt-to-GDP targets over the medium term while still making targeted investments in affordability, productivity and economic growth. To what extent do you believe Canada's current fiscal approach appropriately balances the need for targeted federal spending with maintaining a credible fiscal anchor, such a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fd6e75ded674a384d7091d5eef4740277c912a21719a66fa8b1b09e307b21f0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f59ff1d7aeef585a645b7a3e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728630,"date":"2026-04-28T19:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise to mark one year since I was first elected as one of the youngest members of Parliament, born in the 21st century, to serve the people of New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville. This has been a year of collaboration, listening, learning and showing up for my community, and it is an honour of a lifetime. \n\nIn my riding, I have had the privilege of working closely with families, local organizations and, especially, young people. From helping constituents who are navigating federal services to advancing priorities such as reducing the cost of living, my work this year has been grounded in service. I constantly hear about the challenges facing youth, particularly mental health challenges. That is why I have been proud to support the building safer communities fund. It will ensure people feel supported and that they are not alone. \n\nThis year, $1.25 million in federal funding will help nearly 250 young people gain real experience right in my community. This work has been guided by the leadership of the Prime Minister, whose vision continues to inspire us to deliver for Canadians. We are one year in, and this is only the beginning.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728630","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise to mark one year since I was first elected as one of the youngest members of Parliament, born in the 21st century, to serve the people of New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville. This has been a year of collaboration, listening, learning and showing up for my community, and it is an honour of a lifetime. \n\nIn my riding, I have had the privilege of working closely with famil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b39314853a1894e9b1e5d8371784445e3b5eddb9589aeec1ea7b8ac0637d883a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0eab7d40bb9ed97f839b13233badb89e407071cfc5ba2cbc84b480897e4a80dd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70238f2badafe792dd9ff82e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127842,"date":"2026-05-04T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Maybe you wanted to just continue your train of thought from the previous question and finish that thought.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127842","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Maybe you wanted to just continue your train of thought from the previous question and finish that thought.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d2e82641b52b26bbe927a2d873f2c69cd8be863ca3fca1ebee389346479fa5d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18e6536c0f74d7a94525cab6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127843,"date":"2026-05-04T21:45:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I'll just start by saying thank you so much for coming, Governor, and Senior Deputy Governor. It's truly an honour to speak with you again. We've talked about disruptions to the oil market, and we haven't touched on the fertilizer market. I'm curious about how that will affect food prices here in Canada. Is that something you could speak to?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127843","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll just start by saying thank you so much for coming, Governor, and Senior Deputy Governor. It's truly an honour to speak with you again. We've talked about disruptions to the oil market, and we haven't touched on the fertilizer market. I'm curious about how that will affect food prices here in Canada. Is that something you could speak to?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efdee8b8a6b9f76e83fe1fb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127844,"date":"2026-05-04T21:45:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. We've also talked about, of course, the price spikes in oil around the globe. People are seeing that at the pump. What are some of the cascading effects if the ongoing closure of the Strait of Hormuz continues? What is the future?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127844","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. We've also talked about, of course, the price spikes in oil around the globe. People are seeing that at the pump. What are some of the cascading effects if the ongoing closure of the Strait of Hormuz continues? What is the future?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018525","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundary waters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018525","label":"Boundary waters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9837737b225b0d00b575a88fc47b2bc2e8e38915a8b4c551af98f21bae87b17f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aac314dc7a0fcc416c00745d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127845,"date":"2026-05-04T21:45:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I'm sorry. I have about 40 seconds left here. What factors are most important when you're determining your next steps on interest rates?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127845","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry. I have about 40 seconds left here. What factors are most important when you're determining your next steps on interest rates?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","label":"Interest rates"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","label":"Interest rates","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3d2ae86726e978a1a9fbd4b9b0e326cfb28bbb1e000f48c5eda1d00029c077ca"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43efbfdca5ec45dee3da74926e3c0df37d5f33675fcba29c54f880a026f58e45"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2859b2b42f2fa16f25cc9c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127846,"date":"2026-05-04T22:10:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I'll try to keep it brief. Governor, you said that you were encouraged by the federal government's efforts to diversify. That's been a significant focus, with 20 new economic and security partnerships. How do you assess the impact of Canada's trade diversification on global shocks and inflation volatility?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127846","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll try to keep it brief. Governor, you said that you were encouraged by the federal government's efforts to diversify. That's been a significant focus, with 20 new economic and security partnerships. How do you assess the impact of Canada's trade diversification on global shocks and inflation volatility?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b67e85780cc72f7cff0885a88148efe67dfcaafcc4dc93bc772e5efd51c01c6f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb194154cb2e66d9401110c2f54d604230112d6aa694aaa18d4a44844342a2ab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56a70dfa5a536e07357a2863","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127898,"date":"2026-05-05T21:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you, Chair, and thank you to the witnesses. My first question is for Telus Health. Could you walk the committee through how PrescribeIT was originally developed, and particularly how key partners were brought in and how decisions were made about the platform structure and delivery?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127898","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair, and thank you to the witnesses. My first question is for Telus Health. Could you walk the committee through how PrescribeIT was originally developed, and particularly how key partners were brought in and how decisions were made about the platform structure and delivery?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43917502e88048b9aa29ebc12bec1a516ac73608b498f7548bc8a4dffb0aae57"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab950038549263cc68fa81b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127899,"date":"2026-05-05T21:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"HESA","text":"How was that 85% determined? How was that number landed on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127899","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How was that 85% determined? How was that number landed on?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8aa410a5a7fe0bfaa856b39","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127900,"date":"2026-05-05T21:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"HESA","text":"To what extent were there issues with the application itself that might have affected the adoption of this technology, whether in terms of functionality, usability, reliability or integration into clinical workflows?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127900","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"To what extent were there issues with the application itself that might have affected the adoption of this technology, whether in terms of functionality, usability, reliability or integration into clinical workflows?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70318","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adoption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","label":"Medical products industry","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70318","label":"Adoption","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80fba3f890955710edaf56c0b363e8525581d2eaf736b22f99ef353c593066fa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-642dd910d41358e49c25535f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127901,"date":"2026-05-05T21:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"HESA","text":"Thank you. If providers and provinces were not satisfied with the product, what efforts did Telus make to modernize or adapt the program to make it more attractive?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127901","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. If providers and provinces were not satisfied with the product, what efforts did Telus make to modernize or adapt the program to make it more attractive?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercialization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752259","label":"Commercialization","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e65fa21621ad26421387a3c0e01e4888e50ce70b59b7f05725a88448e8d35f59"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c581c3c621c9492f09c358a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127902,"date":"2026-05-05T21:55:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"HESA","text":"How often did Telus update, modify and modernize the product? Did it take steps to solicit customer feedback to inform improvements?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127902","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How often did Telus update, modify and modernize the product? Did it take steps to solicit customer feedback to inform improvements?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037319","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Telework","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037319","label":"Telework","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87041769c57154f15637251768b006da59b418f24c5962c17a63a90573247d2f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13ad952747bf5f567e1c9e0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127847,"date":"2026-05-07T13:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you to the witnesses for coming today. Professor Béland, I have a few questions for you. Thank you very much for your opening remarks. Much of the discussion of fiscal policy focuses on the total amount of government spending. The recent budget, in 2025, emphasized not just the level of spending, but also the quantity and quality of that spending. In your view, how important is it to distinguish between the quantity of federal spending and the quality or effectiveness of that spending when evaluating fiscal policy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127847","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you to the witnesses for coming today. Professor Béland, I have a few questions for you. Thank you very much for your opening remarks. Much of the discussion of fiscal policy focuses on the total amount of government spending. The recent budget, in 2025, emphasized not just the level of spending, but also the quantity and quality of that spending. In your view, how important is it to disting","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ed65b8328b2e9604a2c0edaab8ab430b00cd133e8ad5e98e4424539bf410726"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["95d438172b80096a65a8e16ce5f29ab6370853a1ed14533691d5997db4646d22"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59efc899472f4258afde1717","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127848,"date":"2026-05-07T13:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. Would you consider investments in areas like skills training, housing supply or productivity superdeductions as examples of spending that can strengthen the economy and improve fiscal outcomes over time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127848","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Would you consider investments in areas like skills training, housing supply or productivity superdeductions as examples of spending that can strengthen the economy and improve fiscal outcomes over time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4928ff2e39fff7c18a9ebe59c38844ab13f5d69b0f9382006517f687d30554c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0cc255295bff3f4a6f40c6a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127849,"date":"2026-05-07T13:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. I have another question. A recent analysis by the International Monetary Fund indicated that Canada remains in a relatively strong position compared with G7 partners, particularly in terms of debt sustainability and fiscal capacity. How significant is it that an independent institution like the IMF continues to assess Canada as being in one of the stronger fiscal positions among its peers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127849","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I have another question. A recent analysis by the International Monetary Fund indicated that Canada remains in a relatively strong position compared with G7 partners, particularly in terms of debt sustainability and fiscal capacity. How significant is it that an independent institution like the IMF continues to assess Canada as being in one of the stronger fiscal positions among its pee","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["27ac38d58b507d51d7b371e3eabd5a5f82b5977e08eaa686e9772df5ed5b5c7c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b36048d0b314619b3f38b4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960970,"date":"2026-05-07T19:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today many of us in this chamber wear a vyshyvanka, a symbol of Ukrainian heritage and resilience that has endured through some of history's darkest moments. For Ukrainian Canadians, these embroidered shirts carry identity and the stories of generations who held on to their culture through hardship and persecution.\n\nCanada is home to one of the largest Ukrainian communities in the world outside Ukraine. For more than a century, Ukrainian Canadians have helped shape our country. These roots also exist in my own family. My grandfather came from Ukraine after his family endured persecution under Stalin's regime. He came to Canada in search of freedom and opportunity, and he was always grateful to live in such a welcoming country that allowed him to give back to the next generations. \n\nToday, as Ukraine continues to defend its sovereignty and democracy, Canadians stand in solidarity with the Ukrainian people. To those celebrating, I wish them a happy Vyshyvanka Day.\n\nSlava Ukraini.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960970","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today many of us in this chamber wear a vyshyvanka, a symbol of Ukrainian heritage and resilience that has endured through some of history's darkest moments. For Ukrainian Canadians, these embroidered shirts carry identity and the stories of generations who held on to their culture through hardship and persecution.\n\nCanada is home to one of the largest Ukrainian communities in the wor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0570b8a84741a9dce79c219726dc00dc720082c957bccb051d699239b3123fff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fa2522eb628f10d9db9dbb5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127903,"date":"2026-05-07T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"HESA","text":"On a point of order, Mr. Chair, I just want to clarify that the second hour panel is still staying.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127903","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"On a point of order, Mr. Chair, I just want to clarify that the second hour panel is still staying.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e20030b036c4f3f96981f7e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127850,"date":"2026-05-25T23:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for coming today. Ms. Oliver, I have some questions. Over the past few years, the federal government has taken steps to strengthen the consumer protection framework, including enhanced oversight of financial institutions and expanded tools for consumer awareness. In this context, could you speak to how effective current consumer protection measures have been in supporting Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127850","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for coming today. Ms. Oliver, I have some questions. Over the past few years, the federal government has taken steps to strengthen the consumer protection framework, including enhanced oversight of financial institutions and expanded tools for consumer awareness. In this context, could you speak to how effective current consumer protection measures have","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c416af8301783d9bbfddfb48c9c5bb28a962c1a027a62d278f4a8d3a18d495d6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1bf7578156652732e55c6cc96ed5913de54d4e186b6e647af86740f8071e47cf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3125ac821961f9734cba3eb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127851,"date":"2026-05-25T23:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"No worries. Until recently, banks would make hundreds of millions of dollars off people by charging them various fees. Can you tell us how much the recently announced cap of $10 for non-sufficient fund fees or providing access to accounts for no more than four dollars per month will save Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127851","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"No worries. Until recently, banks would make hundreds of millions of dollars off people by charging them various fees. Can you tell us how much the recently announced cap of $10 for non-sufficient fund fees or providing access to accounts for no more than four dollars per month will save Canadians?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c51a38524cd600e9b6d23c275f7499551c661118385cd4e9d375e61a3aef30b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e0784f2c82f778b0f26f3e073d4fb2d2dbfa855859eb6a0aeda3246d3d0b2d05"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c82e121aa779bd2f5aec73f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127852,"date":"2026-05-25T23:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"There have been concerns around slow transfers and high exit fees, as you mentioned in your opening remarks. How do you see open banking improving data portability and reducing barriers for consumers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127852","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There have been concerns around slow transfers and high exit fees, as you mentioned in your opening remarks. How do you see open banking improving data portability and reducing barriers for consumers?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9acec23289af94944a4c682cafe67fe1520aca62fe3c2610cfb415deba845b8f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["110422ae96dd98d80089a4e91d793c3d9c522bb39fc524ef19a4e08c4e277d2f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b70b9b5d9e16bbbbf13eb64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127853,"date":"2026-05-28T14:45:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you very much, Chair. Hello, everyone. I'm excited to see such a great panel focused on mental health. This is an important opportunity to have a conversation about how budget 2026 will better support mental health care and improve access and services. I have a lot of questions, so I'll try to be very brief here. My first question will be for Ms. Kennell with CMHA national. Since 2017, $5 billion in bilateral investments in mental health and addictions care have supported a wide range of community-based services across Canada, including youth, addiction treatment, crisis response services, rural e-mental health supports and many others. As you said, this funding is expiring on March 31, 2027, at a time when demand for mental health services remains very high and affordability pressures continue to impact Canadians. From your perspective, what impact has this federal funding had on Canadians over the past decade? What lessons should inform future investments in mental health care through budget 2026?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127853","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Chair. Hello, everyone. I'm excited to see such a great panel focused on mental health. This is an important opportunity to have a conversation about how budget 2026 will better support mental health care and improve access and services. I have a lot of questions, so I'll try to be very brief here. My first question will be for Ms. Kennell with CMHA national. Since 2017, $5 bi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["841891b19f056a7a6e6ad2c2713de90a1632238a8721ea737616048726fd51e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d8d49ef2edad367febcb06f9dbaf5854b35be8b24c4e9d9c00caf2b0cb38a2f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af527a7d3df40553732156a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127854,"date":"2026-05-28T14:50:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you very much. I appreciate those insights. My next question is for Mr. Boston with the Canadian Men's Health Foundation. In my riding of New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, I have many unionized trades workers. I often hear about the pressures they face from burnouts and mental health challenges with high-stress work environments. At the same time, the government recently announced the team Canada strong initiative, including a $6-billion investment to recruit, train and hire up to 100,000 new Red Seal workers. As we make these major investments, it's also important that budget 2026 have some dedicated mental health supports for these workers to ensure that they can remain resilient. I just wanted to get your insight, Mr. Boston, on the importance of investing in supports through the workforce, so that people can live happy and healthy lives.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127854","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I appreciate those insights. My next question is for Mr. Boston with the Canadian Men's Health Foundation. In my riding of New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, I have many unionized trades workers. I often hear about the pressures they face from burnouts and mental health challenges with high-stress work environments. At the same time, the government recently announced the t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15f63d27ea1cadc75f622d0298458938176b2f504025bcbc48eabd01b1d0c8b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6069dc4a12a68598b79e12dd84e46713b5631568a3fb703f7a08ed349d6fe448"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f108d509f517bacd70832133","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127855,"date":"2026-05-28T14:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thanks, Kenton. I have about 20 seconds left. Could you speak to the return on investment of investing in these upstream supports?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127855","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thanks, Kenton. I have about 20 seconds left. Could you speak to the return on investment of investing in these upstream supports?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82d80af42fc1f17c0a68ba8450115b2348d848283ecc0bfd47edab90b1093640"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0a00c448c2b6565412f3aab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127856,"date":"2026-05-28T14:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you very much, Chair. Do I have any more time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127856","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Chair. Do I have any more time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c40355aabe5db8908f9ac44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084422,"date":"2026-06-01T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the newly announced Mia-yaltwa Ha'lidzogm hoon National Marine Conservation Area Reserve is a major step forward for marine conservation, indigenous stewardship and coastal communities in British Columbia. \n\nCan the Minister of the Environment tell the House how this initiative will help protect our oceans while creating benefits for local and indigenous communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084422","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the newly announced Mia-yaltwa Ha'lidzogm hoon National Marine Conservation Area Reserve is a major step forward for marine conservation, indigenous stewardship and coastal communities in British Columbia. \n\nCan the Minister of the Environment tell the House how this initiative will help protect our oceans while creating benefits for local and indigenous communities?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f0526d010e042ac10c458a1f331c0ded082c3a7ed3288ddc7c5e76ee95c0944e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f605a2f6bac86badafc7aabbb7dbdd3a0b1f77e335d3ae24c7ae43ad0f4c342"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c135647bfa3df35f571288ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127857,"date":"2026-06-01T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I have a point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127857","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e8b955d80072758b28ee411","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127858,"date":"2026-06-01T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Madam Chair, I wanted to bring this back to relevance to Bill C-30 . Once again, I think we've gone far off topic.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127858","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I wanted to bring this back to relevance to Bill C-30 . Once again, I think we've gone far off topic.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5319391201c56199f33c14586a9ebabeae2cfff39792608d364856878425794e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-baf6989f0f609c31bfd94223","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127859,"date":"2026-06-01T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Minister MacDonald. It's nice to see you again after your visit to B.C. Many residents in my riding of New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville will benefit from the Canada groceries and essentials benefit on June 5, from which a single person could receive up to $950 in support to help address rising costs and affordability pressures, which we are hearing about. We also know that ensuring long-term food security requires a strong and reliable food system. Our government has invested $500 million through the strategic response fund and is establishing a new food security fund to strengthen domestic food production, improve food distribution networks and enhance food security across Canada. Could you elaborate on how these investments will strengthen Canada's agricultural food sector and food supply chains?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127859","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Minister MacDonald. It's nice to see you again after your visit to B.C. Many residents in my riding of New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville will benefit from the Canada groceries and essentials benefit on June 5, from which a single person could receive up to $950 in support to help address rising costs and affordability pressures, which we are hearing about. We","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad35a3cc215fa5376479cbe62c4cbfaeaab7f5c75219a158e9ad2d114c1608b6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b7d23443f1239a3d5a4e3d83c23540504f095f3d4913cdadd9c4788788329bd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cac745f09bd39b6c81bd58cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127860,"date":"2026-06-01T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. You mentioned the port of Vancouver. It was a very informative tour. Looking forward with expanding and building new relationships, how will these increase Canada's food sector and supply chain? What might be some things we can expect coming down the line?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127860","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. You mentioned the port of Vancouver. It was a very informative tour. Looking forward with expanding and building new relationships, how will these increase Canada's food sector and supply chain? What might be some things we can expect coming down the line?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75edbaa55018d53a99982755","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127861,"date":"2026-06-01T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. Madam Chair, how long do I have?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127861","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Madam Chair, how long do I have?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c32e57be5e988727a1b379bc44e94b98e20583088d966244248ed6b04188284"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-848e1d13447146d2ca4f4c63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127862,"date":"2026-06-01T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"What tangible benefits can Canadians expect to see from these investments in terms of food security and affordability?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127862","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What tangible benefits can Canadians expect to see from these investments in terms of food security and affordability?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc8aa559951806c9bc8f09731b0e5a7c8141d38a3d0c15a773502218888a83ab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1e313f92070212154c32504","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127863,"date":"2026-06-01T23:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Minister, for being here. I really appreciate all the great work you're doing for Canadians. In my riding of New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, I have the privilege of representing many union workers, apprentices and families that have helped build our communities and, of course, this economy. The spring economic update proposes $225 million over five years for the union training and innovation program to help union-run training centres upgrade facilities, expand capacity and invest in modern equipment. How will this investment strengthen Canada's training infrastructure and help ensure that workers have the skills needed to deliver the housing, infrastructure, energy and nation-building projects that Canadians are counting on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127863","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Minister, for being here. I really appreciate all the great work you're doing for Canadians. In my riding of New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, I have the privilege of representing many union workers, apprentices and families that have helped build our communities and, of course, this economy. The spring economic update proposes $225 million over five years for the union training an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["71bc392315058e8dbf5a363b8e3e3f7eb11320629cec3744e2c0b27e4a8308d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a3d45e520bf502b6d26bd6a9a47591ecc9a482e4263f24b7efc41a0f1acdf26"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab6b2d54d2ee0f212e25b93c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127864,"date":"2026-06-01T23:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Minister. With the direction of the government, one of the things I'm most happy about right now is the extent to which we're investing in young people. We're helping their education, skills development and pathways into good jobs. With programs like Canada summer jobs, the student work placement program, the youth employment and skills strategy, and enhanced Canada student financial assistance program, we're helping them with experience, training and job opportunities. Can you tell us how these investments are creating opportunities and setting young people up for long-term success?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127864","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Minister. With the direction of the government, one of the things I'm most happy about right now is the extent to which we're investing in young people. We're helping their education, skills development and pathways into good jobs. With programs like Canada summer jobs, the student work placement program, the youth employment and skills strategy, and enhanced Canada student financial as","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96f84f2b5008423a38e42fc2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127865,"date":"2026-06-01T23:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Just to expand on your point about how the government is extending enhanced Canada student grants and interest-free Canada student loans for the 2026-27 academic year, that's expected to help hundreds of thousands of students across the country. I know a lot of people are really struggling with—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Student loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127865","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just to expand on your point about how the government is extending enhanced Canada student grants and interest-free Canada student loans for the 2026-27 academic year, that's expected to help hundreds of thousands of students across the country. I know a lot of people are really struggling with—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","label":"Student loans"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Student loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Student loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","label":"Student loans","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["44a38e8c3c7bc8c8be10b7dcf4d266717b136f9303b3dade407e433baa4006e6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Student loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Student loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f31a4388ee143ceaaf6982ecc22b94ac6db27c34ae8e2966c65b070e3cbc532"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Student loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Student loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c4a13a2b41a803c330cffab9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127866,"date":"2026-06-01T23:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"It's a good job, doing that. Voices: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127866","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's a good job, doing that. Voices: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b28b1f70a481af9954282c07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127867,"date":"2026-06-02T00:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. Ms. Haan, I'm glad to see that the DTC has been well received, the progress there. You mentioned, in your opening remarks, eligibility in modernizing that process, and you mentioned how mental health conditions are not considered for DTC. I was just wondering, could you provide any recommendations for potential steps forward in that regard?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127867","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. Ms. Haan, I'm glad to see that the DTC has been well received, the progress there. You mentioned, in your opening remarks, eligibility in modernizing that process, and you mentioned how mental health conditions are not considered for DTC. I was just wondering, could you provide any recommendations for potential steps forward in that regard?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0bf5d6aa05c6755d6a08efe2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127868,"date":"2026-06-02T00:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"That would be great. Thank you very much. Also, I'd like to congratulate you and your organization on celebrating 50 years of advancing disability inclusion and helping in building a more accessible workforce across Canada. That's huge. That's almost twice as long as I've been on the earth, so that's pretty cool. In your annual report for 2024-25, you reported that 311 youth, including youth with disabilities, gained employment; your organization supported apprentices with disabilities facing barriers to Red Seal certification; and 88% of the clients reported increased job competitiveness at the end of the service. Given that success, from your perspective, how would the measures contained in the spring economic statement improve employment opportunities for Canadians with disabilities, particularly in the skilled trades?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127868","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That would be great. Thank you very much. Also, I'd like to congratulate you and your organization on celebrating 50 years of advancing disability inclusion and helping in building a more accessible workforce across Canada. That's huge. That's almost twice as long as I've been on the earth, so that's pretty cool. In your annual report for 2024-25, you reported that 311 youth, including youth with ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["048e4d5fc46daa2e88c8a5f2f9b94c82bcbff4f3266ce834d80a514583bfd7f2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ab26eeb7ef6035a36a5d9ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127869,"date":"2026-06-02T00:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"That would be great. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127869","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That would be great. Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e1b1673dc74495c46372767","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127870,"date":"2026-06-02T23:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"That sounds good. Thank you very much. It still works. This question is for Mr. Finkbiner. Picking up on MP Church's remarks, could you speak to quantifying the savings to the health care system, the justice system and social services through providing stable housing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127870","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That sounds good. Thank you very much. It still works. This question is for Mr. Finkbiner. Picking up on MP Church's remarks, could you speak to quantifying the savings to the health care system, the justice system and social services through providing stable housing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["44301d69d40baf4cb781ca1d2d2ad0ac2048e128171901f36c630aab78894232"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d644559a304247d2c0ae322e62aa7f8e667c287aa8836bd6d73bdfd383e66a3f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e77a3740f4083d0cf020b7ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127871,"date":"2026-06-02T23:35:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you very much, Chair. Coming back to Mr. Finkbiner with Indwell Community Homes, can we speak for a moment about the barriers supportive housing faces, such as community push-back, health care and staffing costs, and barriers with municipalities? Can you expand on any barriers such as those?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127871","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Chair. Coming back to Mr. Finkbiner with Indwell Community Homes, can we speak for a moment about the barriers supportive housing faces, such as community push-back, health care and staffing costs, and barriers with municipalities? Can you expand on any barriers such as those?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d3ab78339b61da3891a27f5e88a3f38aefab4d39ddd1392c91a16ad79c9229ec"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0833ab0b0df6cca8bfd831fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127872,"date":"2026-06-02T23:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. Have you observed cases where stable supportive housing has enabled individuals to re-enter the workforce, pursue education or contribute economically in ways that might previously not have been possible?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127872","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Have you observed cases where stable supportive housing has enabled individuals to re-enter the workforce, pursue education or contribute economically in ways that might previously not have been possible?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24b1d49795387e687609e010c16d68501e0c83bd88a94b490373f3f3a9d4bee5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08d342787a8f1bd0a7a09017","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127873,"date":"2026-06-02T23:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Could you expand a bit in this last minute on wraparound supports and the continuum of care? What does that look like on the ground?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127873","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could you expand a bit in this last minute on wraparound supports and the continuum of care? What does that look like on the ground?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0288ef475b7bbb10a3826c1395409ede6e6ba6d19e911b0a8095b67b6f1dfd50"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf900fb9a4bd0addac44a5ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127874,"date":"2026-06-02T23:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Finkbiner.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127874","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Finkbiner.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6b8bea55df4e06fcdede60f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127875,"date":"2026-06-03T00:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for coming today. Mr. Gleeson, I have a few questions for you. Strengthening domestic supply chains has become increasingly important across several sectors of the economy given the global disruptions that everyone is facing. How does a stronger domestic phosphate industry benefit Canadian farmers? What impact could that have on fertilizer affordability, supply reliability and agricultural competitiveness?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fertilizers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127875","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for coming today. Mr. Gleeson, I have a few questions for you. Strengthening domestic supply chains has become increasingly important across several sectors of the economy given the global disruptions that everyone is facing. How does a stronger domestic phosphate industry benefit Canadian farmers? What impact could that have on fertilizer affordability","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","label":"Fertilizers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fertilizers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fertilizers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","label":"Soil quality","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","label":"Fertilizers","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["24e5a882b0e46ad3d9d0fa7c256d72e84ce4b3de7ff32c68a8d839f809db30ac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fertilizers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fertilizers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["455b27556ee439a3c9d8e2c8c7641ee1e07b46885602db3eea0b6ac415623c6e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fertilizers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fertilizers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7a52552a26a8b363c0a6afc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127876,"date":"2026-06-03T00:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. In your introductory remarks, you mentioned global factors—perhaps the Strait of Hormuz being closed and other international factors. Could you expand on how that's affecting things right now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127876","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. In your introductory remarks, you mentioned global factors—perhaps the Strait of Hormuz being closed and other international factors. Could you expand on how that's affecting things right now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","label":"Global warming","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a5477ea4c90fd4869a1a627b1b047363827dc1664e168fc247347f365a590e3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d46043556417ea8d3ebbaf59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127877,"date":"2026-06-03T00:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. Of course, a lot of people are facing challenges with the affordability of food—and I would imagine in agriculture, growing the food, the price of fertilizer.... It all has an effect there. Could you expand on that as well, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127877","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Of course, a lot of people are facing challenges with the affordability of food—and I would imagine in agriculture, growing the food, the price of fertilizer.... It all has an effect there. Could you expand on that as well, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f57c4c5c8a3706256f413b054d2622cbbe1b21d20246f5d3ca77c29f865d6aa2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa59eee2040e7a8b6ede0201","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127878,"date":"2026-06-03T00:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. Could you expand on the economic benefits that could result from this proposal and what it could mean for employment or regional development?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127878","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Could you expand on the economic benefits that could result from this proposal and what it could mean for employment or regional development?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d96da94be0ec33bf73201159f73d74a22b5ce2947e87f5b0ce9b7fb74398125"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a478c9893b16e5dc773d1ae8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127879,"date":"2026-06-03T00:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"These were both in B.C., correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127879","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"These were both in B.C., correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2a63df4dd9b4707ca34df3e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127880,"date":"2026-06-04T14:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to all our witnesses for being here today. My questions today are for Mr. Schumann with the International Union of Operating Engineers. I was happy to hear in your opening remarks about the strong support for the spring economic update. You mentioned that it is \"the most significant...investment in skilled trades...in a generation.\" It's good to hear that feedback. I think it's an important time to invest in the skilled trades. Arguably, for a while, the skilled trades were not getting the support they needed. Now, with all of these large-scale projects, we need the workforce to build them, particularly by training up Canadians to do that, so I'm very happy to hear that. I know the members in your union have helped build some of Canada's most significant nation-building projects in B.C., such as LNG Canada, Coastal GasLink and the Site C dam, among many other projects. The spring economic update had measures aimed at attracting investments and accelerating major projects. From the perspective of the union workers actually building these projects, how important is it to restore investor confidence to ensure that more projects move forward? What impact does that have on creating good-paying union jobs across Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127880","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to all our witnesses for being here today. My questions today are for Mr. Schumann with the International Union of Operating Engineers. I was happy to hear in your opening remarks about the strong support for the spring economic update. You mentioned that it is \"the most significant...investment in skilled trades...in a generation.\" It's good to hear that feedback. I th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0bc9cebb535275e986be68931e06bf1b8b52877164d00dd3c0f1a8a9d7f35310"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ea62e7c642ba67f3ab87519cb5c088cb82e37681a0d62b5fa53545060e87a2c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99c7b0b0b30806cc22221539","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127881,"date":"2026-06-04T14:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. My riding is New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, which has a lot of union members and has many people working in the skilled trades. They understand the value of a good-paying union job and the opportunities that apprenticeship training can create. With our government's investment in union training centres, apprenticeships, labour mobility and Red Seal certification, what changes are you expecting to see in the industry? How would these measures help unions recruit, train and retrain skilled workers for the future?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour union training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127881","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. My riding is New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, which has a lot of union members and has many people working in the skilled trades. They understand the value of a good-paying union job and the opportunities that apprenticeship training can create. With our government's investment in union training centres, apprenticeships, labour mobility and Red Seal certification, what changes are","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","label":"Labour union training"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Labour union training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour union training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","label":"Labour union training","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7407208b3abc10de543fa2323320f4c38c83da4b7e0b3987f2de97daaf4ca63c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Labour union training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour union training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ede40806c680a837864cd54641f01b407e3f9a57f765477aa25101e310e099f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour union training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Labour union training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour union training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036060","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-894ef744671969db10c937fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127882,"date":"2026-06-04T14:10:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. How important is it that young Canadians see a clear pathway from apprenticeship to Red Seal certification? You mentioned the apprenticeship training grants and the $5,000 completion bonus. Do you think our government's investments, specifically in unions, will help encourage more young people to pursue the skilled trades?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127882","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. How important is it that young Canadians see a clear pathway from apprenticeship to Red Seal certification? You mentioned the apprenticeship training grants and the $5,000 completion bonus. Do you think our government's investments, specifically in unions, will help encourage more young people to pursue the skilled trades?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7bcb062dd064414c2933de6de6a34f12cfbebacca69039a225e19d22576bc50e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3eee886828558ae05be440ddd61742d8dc745aeb374821686fcacc02447300e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b1762fba13f2ffd1c486335d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127883,"date":"2026-06-04T14:10:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127883","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5050e2f5766fb3f97cd5b07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127884,"date":"2026-06-04T15:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Minister, for being here today. It's good to see you again. I agree with your opening statements. We are facing major economic headwinds, of course, with high energy prices, being uniquely affected by U.S. tariffs and global uncertainty. However, we have a resilient country and resilient people. We're taking decisive action to build our economy and to also help protect our people because, of course, there are a lot of Canadians who are feeling the pressure right now. People in my riding have spoken to me about the difficulty with the disability tax credit. The application process can be lengthy and difficult. It's an important source of support for many Canadians. It helps people access their disability benefits. Can you tell me and this committee how the new measures in Bill C-30 will make it easier for eligible Canadians to access the disability tax credit and the supports that will come with it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127884","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Minister, for being here today. It's good to see you again. I agree with your opening statements. We are facing major economic headwinds, of course, with high energy prices, being uniquely affected by U.S. tariffs and global uncertainty. However, we have a resilient country and resilient people. We're taking decisive action to build our economy and to also help protect","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["445b0ca672bcc3cff44199bacb5dd25008a5fa1baaddc45a66c81aa1ba97edb0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43c63e7609c4eaabcc369266","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127885,"date":"2026-06-04T15:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. Seven FIFA World Cup matches are taking place in Vancouver, British Columbia. Canada has the opportunity to showcase its breweries, distilleries, wineries and other local businesses to a national and international audience. The spring economic update saw our government extend excise duty relief measures, including the 2% cap on annual increases and the continuation of targeted tax reductions for small brewers. This amounts to over $30 million in support. Can you explain how these measures will help Canadian producers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127885","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Seven FIFA World Cup matches are taking place in Vancouver, British Columbia. Canada has the opportunity to showcase its breweries, distilleries, wineries and other local businesses to a national and international audience. The spring economic update saw our government extend excise duty relief measures, including the 2% cap on annual increases and the continuation of targeted tax reduc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9da15848d49b9f0aaae711d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127886,"date":"2026-06-04T17:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Minister, for being here today. I'm really excited to see our government's investments into trade infrastructure. In my own riding of New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, I have a lot of trade routes that go through there. There are a lot of rail corridors and Highway 1. I am just wondering if you could speak to the investment we're making in our rail, especially at a time when we're looking at diversifying our international trade market.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127886","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Minister, for being here today. I'm really excited to see our government's investments into trade infrastructure. In my own riding of New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, I have a lot of trade routes that go through there. There are a lot of rail corridors and Highway 1. I am just wondering if you could speak to the investment we're making in our rail, especially at a time when we're ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6de8481ec9f4f799d5d7f777043b787ec00b42d0a9ac7aafe58e36aa86184bdb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d25629b427edb9b7d048134d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127887,"date":"2026-06-04T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Absolutely. I couldn't agree more. When I heard the announcement of $33 million into the national trade corridors fund for projects in Alberta and British Columbia, I was very excited. It will definitely be benefiting my region. Coming to metro Vancouver's transit infrastructure, the federal government was kicking in, I believe, about $663 million in funding. We had the Mark V SkyTrain cars come in. Could you speak to the importance of having an effective public transport system, especially as densification increases?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127887","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Absolutely. I couldn't agree more. When I heard the announcement of $33 million into the national trade corridors fund for projects in Alberta and British Columbia, I was very excited. It will definitely be benefiting my region. Coming to metro Vancouver's transit infrastructure, the federal government was kicking in, I believe, about $663 million in funding. We had the Mark V SkyTrain cars come i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d26a7bdf3294131252c31bc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127888,"date":"2026-06-04T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you. We've talked about rail. We've talked about public transit. In terms of marine transportation, of course, the Fraser River comes through my riding. In our last few moments here, could you speak to anything the government is doing to help marine transportation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127888","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. We've talked about rail. We've talked about public transit. In terms of marine transportation, of course, the Fraser River comes through my riding. In our last few moments here, could you speak to anything the government is doing to help marine transportation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9a26c392218d3f679d0c4fa0990fa4096b5825ee409aed49d567ac343c8afa8a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["feb10b61666611291c1584b192b3e3fc88609cf0987cc4d1b47b10edca79ed23"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1503522249412d7250abd267","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127889,"date":"2026-06-04T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127889","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1fa77370bbe72d9cd1456293","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086468,"date":"2026-06-08T19:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to commemorate the life of UBC student Kai Smart, whom I worked with on fundraising for mental health. On March 20, at the age of 23, Kai tragically lost his life in an avalanche in Japan.\n\nI would like to share some words written by Kai's parents, John and Julia, who said Kai was a mountain man, an explorer of the world and a lover of people from all walks of life. He was an avid skier and adventurer. In his short life, he experienced more than many do in a lifetime.\n\n What stood out about Kai was how he moved through the world. He connected with people across borders, languages and cultures. He carried curiosity, courage, kindness and humility wherever he went, making others feel welcome, inspired and more alive.\n\n\"Live like Kai\" has emerged as a mantra in the mountain community he called home. In his memory, the Smart family is establishing a memorial fund to support young people making a positive impact.\n\nRest in peace, Kai.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086468","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to commemorate the life of UBC student Kai Smart, whom I worked with on fundraising for mental health. On March 20, at the age of 23, Kai tragically lost his life in an avalanche in Japan.\n\nI would like to share some words written by Kai's parents, John and Julia, who said Kai was a mountain man, an explorer of the world and a lover of people from all walks of life. He wa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","label":"Cultural diversity","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b8620b58da54973078bf88a9c4826e949bb1fae8b784845a733d4dba7c05cf54"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["483d90fd4f37d282ba3aea0eea82955e265f02d2cbcf3f22cee01272162ddc12"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0186d9d25f28d33931d1e60e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127890,"date":"2026-06-09T01:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I have a point of order. I'm sorry, Madam Chair. This has nothing to do with the amendment. Can we get back to what we should be doing here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127890","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order. I'm sorry, Madam Chair. This has nothing to do with the amendment. Can we get back to what we should be doing here?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["477916dbb250f1fff329f8dcaa5683554defd24208b9833d9f41974735e1bc68"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e474418b730355237a4d36d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127891,"date":"2026-06-09T01:15:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I have a point of order. Chair, we're supposed to be talking about the excise tax for alcohol. This is a very long, rambling filibuster. A lot of resources go into this committee and it's clear this isn't going anywhere related to this amendment. I'd like to see if we can bring this back to something that's going to be remotely productive.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127891","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order. Chair, we're supposed to be talking about the excise tax for alcohol. This is a very long, rambling filibuster. A lot of resources go into this committee and it's clear this isn't going anywhere related to this amendment. I'd like to see if we can bring this back to something that's going to be remotely productive.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cbcb49b1d8cda87076b78c77","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127892,"date":"2026-06-10T18:50:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I have a point of order. We are now at 18 and a half hours and counting. We're seeing countless wasted resources. This is obstruction. We need to get things done. We've been on the same clause, I believe, all day. We are looking at a lot longer, provided this continues to be at a constant roadblock. I ask that we keep it relevant and take this somewhere useful and productive.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127892","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order. We are now at 18 and a half hours and counting. We're seeing countless wasted resources. This is obstruction. We need to get things done. We've been on the same clause, I believe, all day. We are looking at a lot longer, provided this continues to be at a constant roadblock. I ask that we keep it relevant and take this somewhere useful and productive.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b39874d03809e60a3c7cabab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127893,"date":"2026-06-10T22:10:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I have a point of order, Chair. I'm hearing a lot of repetition. I know we're talking about the march of time and things diminishing, and I'm feeling my own time on this world diminishing as we continue this filibuster. I just ask that we stick to the clause at hand. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127893","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Chair. I'm hearing a lot of repetition. I know we're talking about the march of time and things diminishing, and I'm feeling my own time on this world diminishing as we continue this filibuster. I just ask that we stick to the clause at hand. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e20ffe87747804eb9b7bd8e5a38e85bc50964da5e7ccb4a4d82adb67d997dc2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c29692c07f3e7ea0a3d2f1fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127894,"date":"2026-06-10T22:55:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I just have a brief point of order on relevance. I know we're talking about Spider-Man. I appreciate the Spider-Man quotes. It seems like we're in a multiverse where time is moving very slowly. I'd appreciate it if we could get from the origin story to more plot development and make some tangible progress on this. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127894","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I just have a brief point of order on relevance. I know we're talking about Spider-Man. I appreciate the Spider-Man quotes. It seems like we're in a multiverse where time is moving very slowly. I'd appreciate it if we could get from the origin story to more plot development and make some tangible progress on this. Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d04af1b7388f617949cd9185","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127895,"date":"2026-06-10T23:15:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I have a point of order about relevance. I know you mentioned that we're—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127895","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order about relevance. I know you mentioned that we're—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["143108a0e7bd8667a37d14846c471a03ec4b8681f4a79f49ea33cf18ccaa4f49"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f475989a3517604267882dd2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127896,"date":"2026-06-10T23:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"I know you mentioned that we're not in a—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127896","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I know you mentioned that we're not in a—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d11bb391ab16193f5690700","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127897,"date":"2026-06-10T23:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Jake Sawatzky","venue":"FINA","text":"All right. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127897","member_id":"bc-mp-123583","member_name":"Jake Sawatzky","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"All right. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0ed6936e839ec21c4df04bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":41813,"date":"2026-01-26T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, last week was a devastating one for forestry workers and their families on Vancouver Island. Just outside Port McNeill, the Atli Chip plant announced it would be permanently closed, and curtailments were announced at the Ladysmith and Saltair locations of the iconic Chemainus sawmill, where my grandfather worked for 30 years. These were good-paying jobs, the type of jobs that built communities up and down Vancouver Island and right across B.C.\n\nThe government promised to stand with these workers, to have their backs. Instead, mills keep closing and workers are being laid off. When will the government's actions and results finally live up to its rhetoric and its words?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41813","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, last week was a devastating one for forestry workers and their families on Vancouver Island. Just outside Port McNeill, the Atli Chip plant announced it would be permanently closed, and curtailments were announced at the Ladysmith and Saltair locations of the iconic Chemainus sawmill, where my grandfather worked for 30 years. These were good-paying jobs, the type of jobs that built co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be2ea5cfd0a3dc65619e78e2ed78d9a9defa072ce8509d5770a0c3ebf4d39dd3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ed8f42039063364f0b2675070a5232075ee2640d1d398b0d6945bd96ef7032c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-516e284e541df7892ba00824","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":41815,"date":"2026-01-26T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a suggestion, and it is to drop the ideological 30 by 30, which stops forestry workers from doing their jobs.\n\nI appreciate my colleague's comments on this issue, and I appreciate the government's promises of support, but forestry workers in my riding and across B.C. cannot eat Liberal promises and they cannot pay their mortgages with a Liberal speech. They need action. They need results. They need the government to actually deliver something.\n\nLiterally thousands of jobs have been lost. How many more mills have to close? How many more people have to be put out of work before the Liberal government steps up and takes this crisis seriously?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41815","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a suggestion, and it is to drop the ideological 30 by 30, which stops forestry workers from doing their jobs.\n\nI appreciate my colleague's comments on this issue, and I appreciate the government's promises of support, but forestry workers in my riding and across B.C. cannot eat Liberal promises and they cannot pay their mortgages with a Liberal speech. They need action. They ne","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80edf2d7aa3723bfd769aad46e13ae3a40cd889315a1ba64784e10555b05995e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["71850e1ce73809111380ddba7b7d5e7b05d6c3e5cd67db853b0d0201765cd713"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d57d6e127228b1557c456834","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86072,"date":"2026-02-05T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have good news. The Canada Energy Regulator has rejected Brookfield's plans to send Canadian hydroelectricity to the United States with almost no benefit to the people who live here, and has instead recommended a full licensing process and review. However, the final decision still rests with the Minister of Natural Resources.\n\nWill the minister commit to accepting the Energy Regulator's recommendations and ensuring that Canada's national interests always come first?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86072","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have good news. The Canada Energy Regulator has rejected Brookfield's plans to send Canadian hydroelectricity to the United States with almost no benefit to the people who live here, and has instead recommended a full licensing process and review. However, the final decision still rests with the Minister of Natural Resources.\n\nWill the minister commit to accepting the Energy Regulat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b69e7267db28a2fa0a35c9a6072105540e0c2c40663b1161f1f3796601d12439"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea3e9dd8c35fd51d2b3660974e1370315cee9bb141a55cccd1eb233da049bbe3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c92c0426f43bbd0c4d7e380","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299612,"date":"2026-02-13T16:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it was 16 years ago this month when Canadians from coast to coast came together to celebrate the most dominant performance in winter Olympic history, with 26 medals, 14 of them gold, and nothing more iconic, of course, than Sidney Crosby's golden goal, which eliminated the United States and reclaimed Canada's rightful place as the undisputed hockey nation of the world. It was a moment etched into the very memory and identity of this great country, a defining moment of national unity and national pride. Whether people were watching that final game from their living room, at a bar or with the thousands crammed outside of LiveCity in Yaletown, as I was, it was one of those rare instances of pure, unadulterated joy. \n\nI know I speak for all members of the House when I wish the amazing athletes representing Canada the best of luck and all the success in the world. To Nate, Sid, Connor and the boys on the ice, let us go get another gold medal.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299612","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it was 16 years ago this month when Canadians from coast to coast came together to celebrate the most dominant performance in winter Olympic history, with 26 medals, 14 of them gold, and nothing more iconic, of course, than Sidney Crosby's golden goal, which eliminated the United States and reclaimed Canada's rightful place as the undisputed hockey nation of the world. It was a moment","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083653","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Ice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"National heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","label":"National heritage","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083653","label":"Ice","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["848f5ef89ba5bec6b260d2a878219c9f67c62b6d06f43be90c62ffd870f73952"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf4ac47bef5b704e6546ef6904ebdab84b7e1264f2b7a8d098d9685dbbd6dc9c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcbb0ed6f4a68d965bcb40ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299613,"date":"2026-02-13T16:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, devastated, anxious and fearful of what the future may hold are just some of the emotions, I am sure, that the 25,000 Canadians who lost their jobs last month undoubtedly feel. These are individuals, like all Canadians, who, even when working, were already struggling with the cost of groceries, the cost of rent and the cost of just getting by. Now, not only are they dealing with a cost of living crisis, but they are also out of a job. \n\nThe Prime Minister promised the fastest-growing economy in the G7. When will his policies deliver anything other than job losses, massive deficits and the highest cost of groceries among our economic peers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299613","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, devastated, anxious and fearful of what the future may hold are just some of the emotions, I am sure, that the 25,000 Canadians who lost their jobs last month undoubtedly feel. These are individuals, like all Canadians, who, even when working, were already struggling with the cost of groceries, the cost of rent and the cost of just getting by. Now, not only are they dealing with a cos","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca673cfb38ac82a465d0e4359859aa945b161c1133e410da58b8c93e251a6127"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["254684e63df43233d83b97c236c5cb96d369654db922f41e5ad335033ad01b43"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37b2f06d6babcc689d89955f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299614,"date":"2026-02-13T16:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, working together is great, but the question was about jobs. \n\nIn the real world, Liberal rhetoric and platitudes do not create a single job. GDP was flat in November. Real GDP is projected to decline. The Bank of Canada says that business investment will remain weak. Meanwhile, 5,400 forestry workers in coastal B.C. are already out of a job. \n\nThe government promised to build nation-building projects and create jobs at a speed we have never seen before. My question for the government is this: Where are these projects and where are these jobs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299614","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, working together is great, but the question was about jobs. \n\nIn the real world, Liberal rhetoric and platitudes do not create a single job. GDP was flat in November. Real GDP is projected to decline. The Bank of Canada says that business investment will remain weak. Meanwhile, 5,400 forestry workers in coastal B.C. are already out of a job. \n\nThe government promised to build nation-b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8e3f6077fecdf978e9afa0956594d4072d1a7a14f1b73a5b99949d2b7afe30aa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cfac016ce187e9b0f5f94537a13a474490bbb92265d3a645ec82f2e5c9cbd553"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-424ec02a35a0cc27fcdd57fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310833,"date":"2026-02-26T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, three weeks ago, the Minister of Natural Resources claimed that the decision to allow Brookfield Renewable Partners to send Canadian hydroelectricity out of Powell River to the United States, with almost no benefit to Canadians, was out of his hands and instead rested with the Canada Energy Regulator. The only problem is that the regulator told me that it made its recommendation to reject the permit two months ago. Since that time, it has been sitting on the minister's desk.\n\nWill the minister commit to accepting the regulator's recommendation and to denying Brookfield this permit?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310833","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, three weeks ago, the Minister of Natural Resources claimed that the decision to allow Brookfield Renewable Partners to send Canadian hydroelectricity out of Powell River to the United States, with almost no benefit to Canadians, was out of his hands and instead rested with the Canada Energy Regulator. The only problem is that the regulator told me that it made its recommendation to re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fab8eed4ac18a2a84dc28a294f6e465d3f6f1864d65b7d075133e41821075746"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7b3677b5ec73363b7f5b572e99e4b90f39795eefbe7f0477f2b58299faab9ba0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ed513592c416b90c5baf6c8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390266,"date":"2026-03-23T21:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what kind of society and what kind of country do we want to be? \n\nIs it one where the government has the power to decide what we can or cannot say, to decide what religious texts we can or cannot read and which opinions we can or cannot hear, or do we want to be a country where citizens are allowed to express themselves freely without fear of persecution or intimidation from the state, where citizens are allowed to voice their opinions, speak their truths and engage in robust political debate, and where we recognize that the price of free speech includes having to occasionally hear things that we disagree with, that are distasteful, that are repugnant and that at times may even contain hate?\n\nThat is the price of free speech, is it not? That is the price of denying government the power to regulate the words we speak and, I should say, that is the price of free speech in Canada today.\n\n In years and generations past, the price paid to protect this fundamental freedom was much greater, measured not in courtrooms, in parliamentary committees or even on the floor of this House but measured on battlefields around the world by the blood spilled and lives lost to defend it. The question of whether to sacrifice some of our freedom to feel more secure and more comfortable is a question as old at least as western civilization itself, but it represents a false choice. Our security, our unity and our strength of spirit as a nation exist not in spite of our freedom but because of it, and attempts by some to erode that for the benefit and glee of others who would regulate, intimidate and control are misguided and wrong.\n\n Over the last 10 years, Liberal governments have consistently introduced legislation that is part of a trend in our country, a trend of increasing the influence of those who would wield the wand of censorship and empowering those who seek to control what we think by controlling what we can see and discuss online. It is a trend of consistently undermining the free expression of individual Canadians and attempting to stifle and socially engineer public debate, whether it was with the former Liberal Bill C-11, which decided the government, in its infinite wisdom, should have the power to manipulate the algorithms and the search results of YouTube, Facebook and other social media companies and thereby influence the information that we see and consume, or the former Bill C-63, which attempted to further criminalize and regulate speech.\n\nNow we have before the House Liberal Bill C-9, a bill that, as originally presented, would have watered down the definition of hate speech and removed important guardrails to reckless and politically motivated prosecutions. It is a bill that, at its very core, would make it easier for the government and any future government to prosecute and jail Canadians based not on their actions but on their words, and make it easier for individuals in positions of authority to wield that power as a tool of intimidation to scare those with minority or unpopular views to seek the safety of self-censorship or else risk the wrath of the almighty state.\n\nWhile at committee, thanks to the determination and perseverance of a handful of Conservative MPs, we were able to remove many of the most dangerous and shameful elements from the legislation. Another new alarming amendment was added. In a deal struck between the Liberals and separatist Bloc Québécois, it was agreed to remove a provision from the existing Criminal Code that prevented the prosecution of Canadians for expressing in good faith the beliefs or words of ancient religious texts, opening the door to politically motivated prosecutions on the basis of religious expression and belief, and in so doing compromising not one but two of Canadians' fundamental charter rights. \n\nTo think that in a country where free speech and freedom of religion serve as two of the foundational principles and values, the bedrock on which this nation is built, a government would seek to criminalize the expression of sincerely held religious beliefs and to criminalize the reading of certain religious texts just seems so outrageous, so absurd and so fundamentally un-Canadian.\n\n This is not an exaggeration. The Liberal chair of the justice committee at the time literally singled out specific passages from both the Christian Bible and Jewish Torah, declaring them hateful in the context of further criminalizing religious speech. Beyond the obvious issues with infringing on the charter rights of Canadians, there is another issue. It is that this bill ignores, deflects and distracts from the very real and the very same challenges in Canada today that it purports to address.\n\n There is an issue in this country with some trying to hide behind the charter right of free expression to genuinely incite violence, but that is already illegal. There is an issue in our country with some attempting to intimidate and obstruct those seeking to practice and exercise their faith, but that too is already illegal. There is an issue in this country of repeat violent offenders assaulting or otherwise harming those for little or no apparent reason, some of which is undoubtedly motivated by hate.\n\n The government's response has been to repeatedly weaken Canada's justice system over the past 10 years and to refuse to aggressively pursue those guilty of breaking Canada's existing laws today, focusing not on those causing immeasurable physical harm in our cities and our streets, but on redirecting finite police resources to chase down ill-defined crimes of speech and on redeploying officers from our communities and towns to Internet message boards, Facebook posts and tweets.\n\n In the last 10 years, under the Liberal government, violent crime in Canada has increased by 50%. Homicides are up by 27%, and more than a third of these murders have been committed by known offenders on some sort of judicial release. This is the direct result of Liberal bills like Bill C-5 and Bill C-75, which have made our communities increasingly less safe by prioritizing the release of violent offenders and by weakening sentences for serious crimes.\n\n If the Liberal government actually cares about the safety and security of Canadians, it should start by fixing the problem it helped create, not by targeting the fundamental charter rights of Canadians, not by making it easier to prosecute speech and not by going after those for expressing sincerely held religious beliefs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390266","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what kind of society and what kind of country do we want to be? \n\nIs it one where the government has the power to decide what we can or cannot say, to decide what religious texts we can or cannot read and which opinions we can or cannot hear, or do we want to be a country where citizens are allowed to express themselves freely without fear of persecution or intimidation from the state","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["20c1da2ea1372f58cc4d07210542aa81977a9c986e04bc21d5e8a19a26009be2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["25a0d64e0b9ef92d30c267ca3cf00b9a17a5ce68b60e1ebfe0cf8fbcc4f6491d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e2e78a78d5a4bfff48c49d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390267,"date":"2026-03-23T21:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know it might be hard for my hon. colleague across the way to understand this, but those of us on this side have deeply committed beliefs when it comes to charter rights, free speech and free expression. We are not making a political calculation. This comes down to a simple question: Do we want to live in a country where the government has the right to decide what we can or cannot say, or do we want to live in a country that, despite the fact that people might say things that we disagree with or find disgusting or even hateful, we still defend to the death the right of those individuals to say it?\n\nI know the type of country I want to live in. I wish my colleague across the way wanted to live in the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390267","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know it might be hard for my hon. colleague across the way to understand this, but those of us on this side have deeply committed beliefs when it comes to charter rights, free speech and free expression. We are not making a political calculation. This comes down to a simple question: Do we want to live in a country where the government has the right to decide what we can or cannot s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3b4c4fdc5834d840ab8a706385dc6bf045367544edc6d4bb29aca289f5faab0a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8c0e17934683aa5313abd7b5659529012d5a831821d8a4d12c52c0f1c041ac5b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49cdc7edfbca8cd2282aab10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390268,"date":"2026-03-23T21:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, further to the point that I just made, the choice is a simple one. As soon as we start placing these restrictions on free speech and free expression, the question becomes who gets to define where the limits are. Where do we draw the line on what we can or cannot say? \n\nThe bill proposes that it is the government that would have the right to look over its citizenry and decide how we are allowed to freely express ourselves. I believe that is a God-given right that rests with every single Canadian, and no government should have the right to control the words that come out of our mouths.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390268","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, further to the point that I just made, the choice is a simple one. As soon as we start placing these restrictions on free speech and free expression, the question becomes who gets to define where the limits are. Where do we draw the line on what we can or cannot say? \n\nThe bill proposes that it is the government that would have the right to look over its citizenry and decide how we ar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["572b921f77cf46179c81c0c88a90a9f193b97e5fc94e08ef871b721304227363"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca661e8dbdb87865b67d79dbcb880de2cc5f4cfade8319bad76e92ba11b033b9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-539f029f468364708f7907eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390269,"date":"2026-03-23T21:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is simply because Conservatives on this side of the House believe in free speech. We believe in free expression, and we believe in freedom of religion. These are the foundational values and principles on which our entire country, the entirety of western civilization, was based upon. Once we start ceding that authority to government, we allow government to control what we can or cannot say. \n\nWho gets to draw the line? Who gets to decide what is or is not permitted or is not hateful? That is not the foundation of a free country. That is a slippery slope to a tyrannical regime.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390269","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is simply because Conservatives on this side of the House believe in free speech. We believe in free expression, and we believe in freedom of religion. These are the foundational values and principles on which our entire country, the entirety of western civilization, was based upon. Once we start ceding that authority to government, we allow government to control what we can or can","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c51b86bd38388bc97ca31a6d2121577f1f36d10e558ec945243adfcad714eeb5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73e6dde8c1fb031765a58652","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390270,"date":"2026-03-23T21:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, over the past 10 years, we have seen violent crime on our streets increase dramatically under the Liberal government. That is an issue that needs to be addressed, and it is not a surge in speech crimes that needs to be dealt with. It is the fact that the government keeps releasing repeat violent offenders back onto our streets over and over again, such as those who assault people and commit all sorts of other serious crimes. One-third of murders committed are by people on release. This is a distraction, and it undermines a foundational constitutional principle.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390270","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, over the past 10 years, we have seen violent crime on our streets increase dramatically under the Liberal government. That is an issue that needs to be addressed, and it is not a surge in speech crimes that needs to be dealt with. It is the fact that the government keeps releasing repeat violent offenders back onto our streets over and over again, such as those who assault people and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["41ae0ca8067ab48052a9acee2b75b880358d7e31e50740088a7aedbbd48cdb34"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ed32ed305870b3090b0edb4e0e9a5d49fb69576316d5e6639fe211c9c18e7dc1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02b857776dc729edcfa8f978","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127910,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Bird, the first question is for you. I know you've been talking about this already, but can you recap and summarize how uncertainty surrounding opening and closing dates for the recreational fishery.... Do you have an example of how this uncertainty has caused or is currently causing economic damage to the industry and individual recreational fishers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127910","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Bird, the first question is for you. I know you've been talking about this already, but can you recap and summarize how uncertainty surrounding opening and closing dates for the recreational fishery.... Do you have an example of how this uncertainty has caused or is currently causing economic damage to the industry and individual recreational fishers?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7700a2b1a82b6547e56ca85f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127911,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"In some ways, in the questions being asked in the public discourse, the uncertainty is already driving real-world economic costs to the industry and recreational fishermen.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127911","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In some ways, in the questions being asked in the public discourse, the uncertainty is already driving real-world economic costs to the industry and recreational fishermen.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1a3f80c5e6274b8bdb63e955af21f878500b8d97ffb72b3b651ac5e7db937ad"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e34640d06eef3075b2fbc4d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127912,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"You touched on a couple of different issues. Whether it's the killer whales off the southern coast of Vancouver Island, whether it's the conversation around the salmon allocation policy or whether it's the conversation surrounding the openings of the sockeye Fraser run, do you have confidence that these decisions by the DFO are being driven by science and by evidence, or do you feel they're being driven by politics and ideology?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127912","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You touched on a couple of different issues. Whether it's the killer whales off the southern coast of Vancouver Island, whether it's the conversation around the salmon allocation policy or whether it's the conversation surrounding the openings of the sockeye Fraser run, do you have confidence that these decisions by the DFO are being driven by science and by evidence, or do you feel they're being ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a17f7db6067560e185a679cfee30970f6d887759bc3f924deb251737c9f4bcd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0210cc66561f57f45af0641","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127913,"date":"2026-04-15T21:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Can you maybe walk me through how this would play out? I remember how last summer there was some concern up in the Port Hardy region that, with the weak stock management of the chinook, the opening or closing dates might change. We sent a letter to the minister , and the date didn't change. In communities such as Port Hardy, Campbell River and down in Nanaimo, Victoria and the Sunshine Coast, what are the economic ripple effects of this uncertainty and if the department were to move forward with changing the opening and closing dates of, for example, the chinook fishery?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127913","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can you maybe walk me through how this would play out? I remember how last summer there was some concern up in the Port Hardy region that, with the weak stock management of the chinook, the opening or closing dates might change. We sent a letter to the minister , and the date didn't change. In communities such as Port Hardy, Campbell River and down in Nanaimo, Victoria and the Sunshine Coast, what","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8e2e761d9920b1721950569","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127914,"date":"2026-04-15T21:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Is it safe to say that some of these coastal communities could be devastated by the wrong decision by Fisheries?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127914","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is it safe to say that some of these coastal communities could be devastated by the wrong decision by Fisheries?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0dd1fda321dd16bda8fc8be7fa3082cb9b152e3156868732face495715743b8c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f73d832d4293013c8141d380","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127915,"date":"2026-04-15T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Zeman, last summer, before the brief Fraser River sockeye opening, my phone was blowing up from fishermen on DFO test fishing boats. Clearly, they knew well in advance this was going to be an above expectation return, and in fact a near-record return. How do you explain DFO's decision when it comes to the Fraser River sockeye opening, why it was so late and why the catch opportunity was so limited?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127915","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Zeman, last summer, before the brief Fraser River sockeye opening, my phone was blowing up from fishermen on DFO test fishing boats. Clearly, they knew well in advance this was going to be an above expectation return, and in fact a near-record return. How do you explain DFO's decision when it comes to the Fraser River sockeye opening, why it was so late and why the catch oppo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e682c334f551ad6c7fe70a09991a4ff6bc61efc2f7e67eb0ee7949991c2c4c2b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba23b83f5ef9b3d6af3679ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127916,"date":"2026-04-15T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"You said it was over 9 million—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127916","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You said it was over 9 million—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ea58246475ea9645b044ce6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127917,"date":"2026-04-15T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"—and you guys were only allowed to harvest 70,000. Is that correct? Is that number, to you, in any way based on conservation concerns or science or evidence? I'm looking at those numbers, and I'm sure Canadians are too, and they don't seem to add up.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127917","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"—and you guys were only allowed to harvest 70,000. Is that correct? Is that number, to you, in any way based on conservation concerns or science or evidence? I'm looking at those numbers, and I'm sure Canadians are too, and they don't seem to add up.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ae107dbe0a31fe69b49f7f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127918,"date":"2026-04-15T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Can you provide some context for people on how long the opening was compared to—if DFO was more reactive—how long it could have been and how much more of a greater opportunity you could have had?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127918","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can you provide some context for people on how long the opening was compared to—if DFO was more reactive—how long it could have been and how much more of a greater opportunity you could have had?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fec95433596209b312151e79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127919,"date":"2026-04-15T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay. Mr. Brown, we're talking again about DFO's reaction time. One thing that confuses me is this: With the advances in technology and capability, you'd think it would be easier now than it was before to model, predict and monitor salmon returns, yet it seems as though decision-making at DFO is slower and more inconsistent. Does that match your experience, and do you have any explanation for it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127919","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Mr. Brown, we're talking again about DFO's reaction time. One thing that confuses me is this: With the advances in technology and capability, you'd think it would be easier now than it was before to model, predict and monitor salmon returns, yet it seems as though decision-making at DFO is slower and more inconsistent. Does that match your experience, and do you have any explanation for it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d386289f8147e1e404ed0862","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127920,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"This is a question for all three of you, for whoever wants to jump in. When you see these decisions being taken that are very hard to explain away, and all of you disagree with them, do you think DFO is reaching these inexplicable decisions through a lack of capacity or incompetence? Is it a certain ideological predisposition or policy that is leading to these decisions, if that makes sense?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127920","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This is a question for all three of you, for whoever wants to jump in. When you see these decisions being taken that are very hard to explain away, and all of you disagree with them, do you think DFO is reaching these inexplicable decisions through a lack of capacity or incompetence? Is it a certain ideological predisposition or policy that is leading to these decisions, if that makes sense?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ce3d364981597e8ecbb657385d12197084bcbecf7a579681687929ba034f53f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4adae7ad0bf77e6da2d2f20","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127921,"date":"2026-04-15T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Do you want to add anything?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127921","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you want to add anything?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbdcee27317153d4ad31ba7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127922,"date":"2026-04-20T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. Ms. Collier, you were talking about the delays and the failure to open the sockeye fishery despite near-record abundance back in 2022, and it happened again this past summer. From your vantage point, do these decisions being made at DFO have any correlation with abundance, science and evidence, or does it seem that they're being made based on ideology or other factors?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127922","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Ms. Collier, you were talking about the delays and the failure to open the sockeye fishery despite near-record abundance back in 2022, and it happened again this past summer. From your vantage point, do these decisions being made at DFO have any correlation with abundance, science and evidence, or does it seem that they're being made based on ideology or other factors?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1f5b9b39dada41923b3532dcda395244868c6f81039660266285c6a9a8e6e777"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["44dccd790a62e72ee8d1cc5ee982014570c373d5f33a5b1941a0f3538d08814d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-19f044644f8112b237be2a4f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127923,"date":"2026-04-20T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Wow. Is it fair to say that fishermen and their families are okay with closures and restrictions if they're genuinely based on conservation concerns but that, on the other side of that coin, if there is abundance, people should be allowed to get out and fish?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127923","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Wow. Is it fair to say that fishermen and their families are okay with closures and restrictions if they're genuinely based on conservation concerns but that, on the other side of that coin, if there is abundance, people should be allowed to get out and fish?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fdd335d5ba6333a24a17c43103c0740cf94c68c0c2c3a1763d8dcafec71916b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0efe13e4f24ccc8eadd0fbcf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127924,"date":"2026-04-20T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Have you noticed how the way the decision-making process around these openings and closings has been communicated to you has changed over recent years? Can you give us a 30,000-foot view and take a look back in time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127924","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Have you noticed how the way the decision-making process around these openings and closings has been communicated to you has changed over recent years? Can you give us a 30,000-foot view and take a look back in time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mergers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036263","label":"Mergers","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d33b6a8de5806f4e1c9217514c6dd72b0a9e7ee382d6043c56ca1479f74653ab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebf60b4a22fade9e127c3ffb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127925,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"You spoke of the financial impacts on your family of this uncertainty around when a fishery was going to open and close. What is the human impact of these delays in decision-making and the uncertainty surrounding them? How has that impacted your life and that of your family?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127925","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You spoke of the financial impacts on your family of this uncertainty around when a fishery was going to open and close. What is the human impact of these delays in decision-making and the uncertainty surrounding them? How has that impacted your life and that of your family?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d93664cd09b921998733b354","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127926,"date":"2026-04-20T16:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. I have another quick question for you, Ms. Collier. Has the uncertainty surrounding opening and closing dates also been exacerbated by the effects of MPAs and other spatial closures in the fishing grounds you're used to fishing in?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127926","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. I have another quick question for you, Ms. Collier. Has the uncertainty surrounding opening and closing dates also been exacerbated by the effects of MPAs and other spatial closures in the fishing grounds you're used to fishing in?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","label":"Fishing permits","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a7ab2a47f85b317f001882001ff5db6b183bd582b88210f12c11501b4563953"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9537149dfa050177bf0661b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127927,"date":"2026-04-20T16:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"You have uncertainty around when you can fish, whether you can even fish and where you will be allowed to send your boats to fish. Obviously, these compound. Do you think this makes it harder and harder for the next generation of fishers to enter the market? Who would make any investments or try to continue in this industry at all?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127927","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You have uncertainty around when you can fish, whether you can even fish and where you will be allowed to send your boats to fish. Obviously, these compound. Do you think this makes it harder and harder for the next generation of fishers to enter the market? Who would make any investments or try to continue in this industry at all?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be151ffab11b5a526f29c6f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127928,"date":"2026-04-20T17:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Summers, off the coast of Vancouver Island, DFO is actively considering additional fishing closures and restrictions on top of those already in place, whether it's for the notional goal of protecting killer whales or weak stock management on the Fraser. Do you believe these proposed closures are based on abundance, science and evidence or on ideology?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127928","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Summers, off the coast of Vancouver Island, DFO is actively considering additional fishing closures and restrictions on top of those already in place, whether it's for the notional goal of protecting killer whales or weak stock management on the Fraser. Do you believe these proposed closures are based on abundance, science and evidence or on ideology?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","label":"Whales"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","label":"Whales","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8695c2d243f194bfe3bb0f624024163505b4e06259708792e762e1bd32dbc1e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47970467ce11b13a7ea79dcdb7fed055e080e2042a2f68e5815f049ca7afe1bf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2ee66b2e1f99ad13aa06799","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127929,"date":"2026-04-20T17:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Why do you think they're pushing ahead with these decisions and not taking into account the views of all stakeholders?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127929","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Why do you think they're pushing ahead with these decisions and not taking into account the views of all stakeholders?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae57374f3571aaa1949c2aa105c6ec705222c5dc620fe41053c65472962d9b6e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67e8b08c5422200d2359a169","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127930,"date":"2026-04-20T17:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Obviously, there's been a lot of talk about the salmon allocation policy review. In your view, could this affect the opening and closing dates for recreational fishers like you?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127930","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Obviously, there's been a lot of talk about the salmon allocation policy review. In your view, could this affect the opening and closing dates for recreational fishers like you?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hunting (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hunting (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","label":"Hunting (Sport)","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4dcac28ecc798b0c4a61b3e219b61932e620ccfb44e3983d9fcefd7bb38856ed"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-82c2c3027a9509b0bd668016","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127931,"date":"2026-04-20T17:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"If the opening date, for example, was pushed back, what would it mean for your business, your family and coastal communities like Port Hardy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127931","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If the opening date, for example, was pushed back, what would it mean for your business, your family and coastal communities like Port Hardy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["17fef6cd8ccc7ffec70413002d80b6c353b0d274c42124a3b8b996ada846d1eb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-caf21b32fddc8e174b225de2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127932,"date":"2026-04-20T17:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Over the past few years, we've had this big increase in technology everywhere, obviously, and a number of resources at DFO. Has the way they've been able to communicate opening and closing dates gotten better or worse in recent years?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127932","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Over the past few years, we've had this big increase in technology everywhere, obviously, and a number of resources at DFO. Has the way they've been able to communicate opening and closing dates gotten better or worse in recent years?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["735444cf34416780e3d12374e9cf9917938c512ca3bedc7e1215733523c2025e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-545d870ceca1a0dcd4734e3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127933,"date":"2026-04-20T17:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"We hear a lot here in Ottawa these days about there being a new government. Have you noticed any changes in how DFO makes and announces decisions since Mark Carney became the Prime Minister?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127933","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We hear a lot here in Ottawa these days about there being a new government. Have you noticed any changes in how DFO makes and announces decisions since Mark Carney became the Prime Minister?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7c6b2086646bf4bad568573979d85add71e62b5a81ec0b28e6cd2945ddeb58d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c8c1be8c195972343d14b7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127934,"date":"2026-04-20T17:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"My next question is for Mr. Griswold. Can you explain why the Fraser River sockeye opening was so late and the catch opportunity so limited despite the near record returns here in the past summer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127934","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My next question is for Mr. Griswold. Can you explain why the Fraser River sockeye opening was so late and the catch opportunity so limited despite the near record returns here in the past summer?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035593","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hatcheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035593","label":"Hatcheries","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["591d49035a35b256eaed3b90d606ca8f374b8e6bcb99ff1e3475dbc723f7f801"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c07a53111e866c76ce94f119","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127935,"date":"2026-04-20T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Did DFO know that well in advance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127935","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Did DFO know that well in advance?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bcacf0e25d6aae4f78d8857","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127936,"date":"2026-04-22T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Mallet, do you believe the decisions at DFO surrounding the Atlantic mackerel are currently being based on abundance and core science, or are they being based on something else entirely?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127936","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Mallet, do you believe the decisions at DFO surrounding the Atlantic mackerel are currently being based on abundance and core science, or are they being based on something else entirely?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","label":"Aquatic ecosystems","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dcbf8a3ed63f28a5192a63fc3a202e3620c742911480e653bd0af7f5bfac2756"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac57ad101ecb85b61d34a69f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127937,"date":"2026-04-22T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Do you believe the United States is doing a better job at managing this resource than we are?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127937","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you believe the United States is doing a better job at managing this resource than we are?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083664","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083664","label":"Resources management","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f368ee949947104997d2f5a525fa2f7a1b264f8013cf1da6758a83fc0b827c1e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c2a6408600c13c989b61b05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127938,"date":"2026-04-22T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"No? What is your vision? Correct me if I'm wrong, but you mentioned in your earlier remarks the importance of having co-management. Do you have a vision for what that would look like?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127938","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No? What is your vision? Correct me if I'm wrong, but you mentioned in your earlier remarks the importance of having co-management. Do you have a vision for what that would look like?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b79e19f158417265a1ead0602ba0116f0dcaced6121a1e011e370f655a0036e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa627b8be81a65162751198c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127939,"date":"2026-04-22T22:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"I want to make sure I'm understanding you correctly. You believe there needs to be balance between the socio-economic and cultural upside that harvesting brings versus conservation concerns, but right now that balance isn't being struck. Is that what you're saying?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127939","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to make sure I'm understanding you correctly. You believe there needs to be balance between the socio-economic and cultural upside that harvesting brings versus conservation concerns, but right now that balance isn't being struck. Is that what you're saying?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035106","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental adaptation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035106","label":"Environmental adaptation","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["470ef1b3d023651345c9e5ef2259afb775319c6b8e32b1de79c531f57f3d0cef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96dbec5b12b95e781a2e94fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127940,"date":"2026-04-22T22:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you very much. Mr. Chair, I'd like to move the motion that I put on notice two days ago respecting a production order for ISED's report and consultations on the aquaculture transition plan for British Columbia. I'm sure we all enjoyed Mr. Small reading his. I know everybody got it in their inbox, so I would like to speak to it briefly. The minister promised thousands of Canadian workers in the aquaculture sector an answer by this past fall about what the federal government's so-called transition plan would mean for them. Workers have been left to wonder if a government decision or directive is about to be issued which will cost them their jobs and make them unable to pay their mortgage or rent or put food on the table to feed their families. This committee deserves to know if the government is planning to put 4,000 Canadians out of work, destroy an entire industry and compromise Canada's food security. This government produced a report, by their own admission, detailing their vision for what this aquaculture transition would look like for British Columbia. The minister said that this report was completed and that she would read it. That was months ago, in October. I hope some members across the way can relate to this. As the member of Parliament for the riding most affected, who was elected to represent these individuals, these families, in the House of Commons and to be their voice, I have been remarkably patient, some might say uncharacteristically patient, on this issue until now. It's now April and we still have not heard anything from the minister , nothing from the department. Canadians deserve answers. This committee deserves answers. Most importantly, the workers in the industry deserve answers. Workers in Port Hardy, Campbell River, Port McNeill, Klemtu, Gold River and Zeballos deserve to know if the department is planning to take their jobs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127940","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Mr. Chair, I'd like to move the motion that I put on notice two days ago respecting a production order for ISED's report and consultations on the aquaculture transition plan for British Columbia. I'm sure we all enjoyed Mr. Small reading his. I know everybody got it in their inbox, so I would like to speak to it briefly. The minister promised thousands of Canadian workers in t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","label":"Aquaculture"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","label":"Aquaculture","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb27b2ff7267b4540a8bef9e33d0fb7086b285de5ef7552fdcbe6b0d4a9faf5c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15567dc53631c49e8f1181278fd4ea07648113f08e569cc0eb6f3152f4e592b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b87446a9460628728b8486d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127941,"date":"2026-04-22T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"I have a point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127941","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a68690a8c1782e7cde45997","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127942,"date":"2026-04-22T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Chair, it has been half an hour now. Mr. Klassen is just reading. I don't know how this is relevant to the production of documents. This is my first year as a member of Parliament. I know there are Canadians watching. What is happening right now? Can a member just talk forever about something that has nothing to do with the motion at hand while we just listen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127942","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Chair, it has been half an hour now. Mr. Klassen is just reading. I don't know how this is relevant to the production of documents. This is my first year as a member of Parliament. I know there are Canadians watching. What is happening right now? Can a member just talk forever about something that has nothing to do with the motion at hand while we just listen?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80a8f850e7ac8347e7b540b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127943,"date":"2026-04-22T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Chair, I think this is now the third time we've asked for relevance. I know you've asked the member to make sure his remarks are relevant. He keeps reading from the same report from 17 years ago. Is this the standard for relevance we want to apply for the rest of this Parliament at the committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127943","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I think this is now the third time we've asked for relevance. I know you've asked the member to make sure his remarks are relevant. He keeps reading from the same report from 17 years ago. Is this the standard for relevance we want to apply for the rest of this Parliament at the committee?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb41a03e05348c8125c65495","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127944,"date":"2026-04-27T16:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. I'd like to move that the committee proceed to the consideration of my motion regarding the production order on aquaculture.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127944","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. I'd like to move that the committee proceed to the consideration of my motion regarding the production order on aquaculture.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","label":"Aquaculture"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","label":"Aquaculture","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b34fd9db72e8063d0213407df8b2a5d63cdb5dc0397a51c2ae9107da77f0c712"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97285ccf2a63e09c7856ebd8bfbc105cce7fa19bd1f30f9c3d41829067d0f1d9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9029f73bc379f5edceeec403","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127945,"date":"2026-04-27T16:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. We obviously brought this production order up last week. We sat here for about 40 minutes while the government filibustered it. This is a super important issue for thousands of workers in my riding and for first nations chiefs who support aquaculture. It's not even necessarily a question about the industry itself. It's a question about transparency and about what's going to happen. Thousands of people do not know if they're going to have a job a couple of years from now and if they're going to have an income to pay their rent or their mortgage. Billions of dollars of potential investment are stalled because no one wants to invest in British Columbia. At the end of the day, for me, this is about transparency and accountability. It's about asking for a report that the minister admitted to this committee was finished and was sitting on her desk—the minister who promised an answer in the fall, who promised an answer in the winter and who promised an answer in the spring. Here we are at the end of April, and still we have no answer. I would welcome the government providing an answer on this issue instead of reading from a report from 16 years ago. The people of this country and the people of my riding deserve a lot better. I'd like to proceed to a vote so we can get the documents and see what they have to say. Then we can hopefully advise the department on an appropriate course of action moving forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127945","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. We obviously brought this production order up last week. We sat here for about 40 minutes while the government filibustered it. This is a super important issue for thousands of workers in my riding and for first nations chiefs who support aquaculture. It's not even necessarily a question about the industry itself. It's a question about transparency and about what's going to happe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1e2c63d4069fcfe7034bfac02410bdd77d2b54902cc625ee1b43c228bc10e46"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1546b8364e2790d65ba6c5a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728638,"date":"2026-04-27T19:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there used to be a political consensus in this country that government, like the rest of us, had to live within its means. This was a shared understanding that money does not grow on trees and that eventually all bills come due.\n\nLiberals shattered that consensus, borrowing more money over the past 10 years than every other government in the history of our country combined. The Prime Minister promised to do things differently. Instead he has somehow managed to spend and borrow even more.\n\nWhen will the Prime Minister end his costly credit card budgets and stop leaving future generations with the bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728638","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there used to be a political consensus in this country that government, like the rest of us, had to live within its means. This was a shared understanding that money does not grow on trees and that eventually all bills come due.\n\nLiberals shattered that consensus, borrowing more money over the past 10 years than every other government in the history of our country combined. The Prime ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75f9785fd72e660fbf7bda4a90c680ac9ed72866b7e61f231bd2676bc6af79fb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["783799b5a5eb4ea1a68d49c6ab0f35332bfeb9652f278c8b0415f5db3905ff45"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b04456a677ab6885d7efaffe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728642,"date":"2026-04-27T19:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, more spending and more debt seems to be the Liberals' solution to every problem they create, forever increasing the size of government and using Canada's credit card to foot the bill. However, all this deficit spending comes with an inflationary cost: the worst grocery inflation in all of the G7, the worst household debt in all of the G7 and the worst housing costs.\n\nWhen will the Prime Minister realize that more spending, more debt and more government is not the solution to Canada's economic problems? The Liberals are the problem.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728642","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, more spending and more debt seems to be the Liberals' solution to every problem they create, forever increasing the size of government and using Canada's credit card to foot the bill. However, all this deficit spending comes with an inflationary cost: the worst grocery inflation in all of the G7, the worst household debt in all of the G7 and the worst housing costs.\n\nWhen will the Pri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["179cb60a9a954908a38a667796388fe091bf56924e5d98e6964bb712863c05a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63e4e23a98b7c4910586ccf1d4b307b33c26daaa32855d85c1f61c962bb47f5d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43f50f933c1aea96b8465633","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728656,"date":"2026-04-27T23:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the member for Dufferin—Caledon. \n\nWhy do we get involved in politics? Why do those in this chamber put their names forward to stand for an election and all that it entails? The answer, of course, varies and is undoubtedly different for different people. Some run for office to seek change in their local community. Others are motivated by matters of principle or feel compelled to act on behalf of deeply held ideas or beliefs. As we have seen recently, others get into politics for the sole reason of furthering their personal interests, cozying up to power and, maybe worst of all, accumulating power for the sake of power itself, even if it means selling out their constituents and betraying those they were elected to represent.\n\n For the first time in more than 150 years of Canadian history, a Prime Minister has sought the almost unlimited power of a majority government in Canada not through a mandate from voters but through deception and deceit, quietly courting a handful of self-interested, duplicitous MPs through backroom deals and who knows what else, effectively overturning the results of an election and concentrating power that he may covet but has not democratically earned. The result is millions of Canadian voters who are angry and thousands who feel as if their vote was stolen, and I can see why. When someone is elected under a party banner, it is not just a personal victory. It is a commitment to the people who supported them and that platform, those principles and that vision for the country.\n\n In the last election, none of these elected MPs communicated to voters that they would consider crossing the floor just months after the vote. That matters, as does the context within which their decisions were made. It has been less than a year since the last election. The major party leaders are exactly the same. The party platforms are essentially the same. The primary issues facing this country, unfortunately, such as the cost of living, increasing crime, a faltering economy and the ongoing trade dispute with the United States, are also the same now as they were one year ago. If these MPs wanted to represent the Liberal Party of Canada and defend the Liberal platform in this Parliament, they should have made that decision before the last election. Then again if they had, most, and probably all, would have lost their seats. Therein lies the problem.\n\nThe Prime Minister is accumulating political power he was specifically and unequivocally denied the last time Canadians went to the polls. We are not just talking, of course, about a handful of individual seats without any broader consequences. We are talking about fundamentally changing the balance of power here in Ottawa, radically remaking the minority government that voters delivered last April, when the Liberal Party and the current Prime Minister were restrained by the need to compromise and consult with opposition parties and were held accountable at committees with production orders, witness testimony and investigative motions. It was a minority government that has now been transformed through backroom deals and floor crossings to a majority that never should have been. It is unethical, it is fundamentally undemocratic, and it has had the effect of essentially disenfranchising thousands of Canadian voters. If a party wants a majority government in this country, it should have to earn it at the ballot box, just like every other government since 1867 in our country. \n\nHere we are. What is done is done, as they say. The next question is, what comes next? It only took a matter of days for the Liberals to tip their hand, moving a motion that we are debating here today to stack committees with not one but two additional Liberal MPs, trampling the oversight powers of Parliament, limiting transparency and laying the groundwork to ram through their agenda. This is from a party that loves to engage in lofty rhetoric about compromise, the defence of institutions and bringing people together. However, at the end of the day, I think what all this exposes is that the only real principle the Liberal Party knows is power, power at all costs, power even as an end onto itself. The Liberals are not about to let something as inconvenient as an election result get in the way.\n\nWhat will they do with all this newly acquired power and the ability to pass essentially whatever they want? We have seen, over the past 12 months, that what the Liberals say they want during an election and what they actually end up doing can be two very different things. For one, they promised to get Canada's fiscal situation under control and to rein in the excesses of Justin Trudeau, who doubled Canada's debt in just 10 years. Instead, under the Prime Minister, the deficit has actually increased. They also promised to prioritize Canadians' public safety after the increases we saw over the past decade in violent crime of 50%. Instead, the first bill they submitted to the justice committee did not target repeat violent offenders at all but rather the free speech of law-abiding Canadians. As for their signature promise, to negotiate a trade deal with the United States by July 2025, well, it has now been a year since the last election. There is still no deal, and the tariffs remain in place. In fact, the tariffs are higher now than they were back then. \n\nMeanwhile, some other legislation that the Liberals actually campaigned on, such as speeding up the construction of projects deemed in the national interest and introduced as Bill C-5, has been supported by the Conservatives and indeed improved through negotiations and the committee process. It all raises the question: For what purpose do the Liberals seek their near-unlimited power today? For what purpose do they seek to upset a 159-year-old Canadian political convention? Is it that they seek to restrict the opposition from conducting inquiries into their many conflicts of interest? Is it to shield the sunlight of transparency by blocking requests and blocking production orders for government documents and reports? Is it that they tend to introduce radical legislation they did not campaign on and know that none of the opposition parties would be able to support? Maybe it is a combination of all three.\n\n One year ago, I was elected in my riding of North Island—Powell River as the Conservative Party candidate. I ran on a clear platform, a clear set of commitments and a clear vision for this country: to stand up for Canada's resource sector, with forestry, mining, oil and natural gas; to target the real criminals in our country, the repeat violent offenders, not those exercising free speech and not law-abiding firearm owners who have never committed a crime in their life; to stop the reckless spending and endless deficits; to get the cost of living under control; and, finally, to get our men and women in uniform the equipment and support they desperately need and deserve, while always standing up for our country. I intend to honour the promises I made and the guarantees to those who entrusted me with their support and their vote. \n\nToday, with the Liberal motion, this patently naked grasp for political power, there is no denying one very simple fact: My job and the job of my opposition colleagues is certainly about to get a lot more difficult. However, that just means we will have to redouble our efforts and work harder than ever before to hold the government to account, to be the voice of our constituents and to be the voice, as always, of Conservative common sense. We can then ensure that the very real concerns and interests of hard-working, tax-paying and law-abiding Canadians are not ignored and that their priorities, through our efforts and our pressure, become the priorities of the government, however reluctant it is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728656","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the member for Dufferin—Caledon. \n\nWhy do we get involved in politics? Why do those in this chamber put their names forward to stand for an election and all that it entails? The answer, of course, varies and is undoubtedly different for different people. Some run for office to seek change in their local community. Others are motivated by matters of pri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc482108182387a9b68ebda1aab50efe00719e940511088d14c007a4d7561fa6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a2c816bd8fd8a0f62d077282e72bfcb34f96bf0b17c209b6becf51d62b4dfb62"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65157bde89f63b8990ba1f9e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728659,"date":"2026-04-27T23:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I was elected to the House to voice my opinions. This is not a quote from me. \n\nWhat I can tell the member, which I totally pointed out in my speech, is that there have been many floor crossings in the history of Canada, but never in 159 years has a government openly courted a large number of MPs to cross the floor to try to change the balance of power in Ottawa and give them a majority government that they did not earn during the last election. This is what is happening today. This is why so many Canadians are angry; this is why thousands of Canadians feel disenfranchised, and this is what we are standing up against.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728659","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I was elected to the House to voice my opinions. This is not a quote from me. \n\nWhat I can tell the member, which I totally pointed out in my speech, is that there have been many floor crossings in the history of Canada, but never in 159 years has a government openly courted a large number of MPs to cross the floor to try to change the balance of power in Ottawa and give them a majori","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c706ee781cbf1d974b49f8823a1c632661c58e44f65ba0967f5759bbd7ff8fb2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a53b03cea46dcf61329c538","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728661,"date":"2026-04-27T23:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the truth is that this is a question Canadians would like to have answered. I do not have the answers. We do not know what conversations were happening behind closed doors. We do not know what was offered or what enticements were made. That is the very essence of the problem. Is the balance of power in this chamber, in this House, about to be upset because of conversations that Canadians were not subject to, did not have a say in and did not have a vote on?\n\nI wish I had the answers to my hon. colleague's questions, and I think Canadians wish they had those answers as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728661","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the truth is that this is a question Canadians would like to have answered. I do not have the answers. We do not know what conversations were happening behind closed doors. We do not know what was offered or what enticements were made. That is the very essence of the problem. Is the balance of power in this chamber, in this House, about to be upset because of conversations that Canadi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1f3f1e5fd47b569c09cda97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728663,"date":"2026-04-27T23:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Parliament and the workings of the House should reflect the democratic mandate given during the last election.\n\n The Liberal Party and the Prime Minister sought, and did not receive, a majority government from Canadians. What they have now done, through backroom deals and who knows what else, is manufacture a majority government. Their first order of business is not to try to do something to help Canadians, but it is to radically stack committees with Liberal members of Parliament.\n\nWe believe in more transparency, more oversight and more accountability for the government, and that is exactly what we are going to continue to push for in opposition, even if the government is about to make our job much more difficult.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728663","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Parliament and the workings of the House should reflect the democratic mandate given during the last election.\n\n The Liberal Party and the Prime Minister sought, and did not receive, a majority government from Canadians. What they have now done, through backroom deals and who knows what else, is manufacture a majority government. Their first order of business is not to try to do somet","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35c037ca1332115f6fe4c9f2bd824b6d3e22c4f5520bddd9770d58b3f671b2a5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4bf02a7fa0fd3c0ada18a048","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127946,"date":"2026-04-29T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Arnold. Mr. Struthers, could you give us a rough estimate of the value of aquaculture to the Canadian economy and, possibly, a breakdown by coast?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127946","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Arnold. Mr. Struthers, could you give us a rough estimate of the value of aquaculture to the Canadian economy and, possibly, a breakdown by coast?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","label":"Aquaculture"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","label":"Aquaculture","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5eda91bcc31ae65a1891153f2794abad81a187c5d0bae3c6c3d026d3df98c28f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7202e2259ab73c254b53f207b9edce73ea1ee81c2895952a5d42597620200efe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f376def0ea4813adedfd942","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127947,"date":"2026-04-29T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Do you have a rough estimate of percentages—obviously, we are talking a lot about clams here—regarding salmon aquaculture as a proportion of the entire aquaculture industry?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127947","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you have a rough estimate of percentages—obviously, we are talking a lot about clams here—regarding salmon aquaculture as a proportion of the entire aquaculture industry?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","label":"Fish farming","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bb5a533ff08962d68f1c2ccaf50da8637f4386e49bfd01312fa816f7c718b07"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-359e65060d2c65cfc5af3877","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127948,"date":"2026-04-29T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"The reason I ask is that, obviously, there is a lot of concern in my riding. I am out in British Columbia. What is going on with the transition plan, I think, just generally.... Whether it is salmon or other forms of aquaculture, we need to ensure that decision-making at DFO is being driven by science, not politics and ideologies. Do you have an update on what is going on with this transition plan and what I should be telling the 4,000 people wondering if they are going to have a job in six months?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127948","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The reason I ask is that, obviously, there is a lot of concern in my riding. I am out in British Columbia. What is going on with the transition plan, I think, just generally.... Whether it is salmon or other forms of aquaculture, we need to ensure that decision-making at DFO is being driven by science, not politics and ideologies. Do you have an update on what is going on with this transition plan","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c79c3b409b26f18fbd3a3ef3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127949,"date":"2026-04-29T22:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"One of the other committees I'm on has worked on a bit of a plan of things that it wants to get done before the summer break. Is that something that is done on most committees and that we have any interest in doing here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127949","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"One of the other committees I'm on has worked on a bit of a plan of things that it wants to get done before the summer break. Is that something that is done on most committees and that we have any interest in doing here?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fb503638df61628d1682d96eb8c3db377e911809e3c05d05c881dd3e11e6ede"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7d8a701a67d8940f5b8e5af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127950,"date":"2026-05-04T16:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. My question is for Mr. Davis, but someone else can feel free if they feel more adequately prepared to answer. Outside of an emergency, do the government and DFO require sign-off or consensus from the Musqueam band when making decisions regarding the fisheries, including pre-season, in-season and post-season decisions, such as opening and closing dates in the relevant area?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127950","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. My question is for Mr. Davis, but someone else can feel free if they feel more adequately prepared to answer. Outside of an emergency, do the government and DFO require sign-off or consensus from the Musqueam band when making decisions regarding the fisheries, including pre-season, in-season and post-season decisions, such as opening and closing dates in the relevant area?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental emergencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","label":"Environmental emergencies","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f147c844bbbecdcc274f389d6e8b2d50480b27ab3a1479adb91bea1fb6d1783b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3fe0f7113bb3b59bb3107870a645ead9990c68eee2e2e29478f3bd0c147c6aaf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a94b661ac2004365cb9d4d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127951,"date":"2026-05-04T17:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Davis, I will jump in here to try to get more specific. I have the text of the Musqueam agreement in front of me. What I'm trying to zero in on are the effects on recreational and commercial fishers with respect to what the government identifies as the traditional territory of the Musqueam nation. The word used throughout the agreement is \"consensus\". I feel you dodged Mr. Arnold's question on caveats whereby the minister is allowed to exercise discretion in the case of an emergency. Outside of an emergency case, do you require sign-off or consensus from the Musqueam nation regarding fisheries decisions being made in this area? It's a pretty clear question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127951","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Davis, I will jump in here to try to get more specific. I have the text of the Musqueam agreement in front of me. What I'm trying to zero in on are the effects on recreational and commercial fishers with respect to what the government identifies as the traditional territory of the Musqueam nation. The word used throughout the agreement is \"consensus\". I feel you dodged Mr. Arnold's question on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be301460468c3138b6626a8925649268a68d734602ad292ea15630cefd729b4b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85c0d629cd27b4eab0fd3c29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127952,"date":"2026-05-04T17:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay. Outside of an emergency, you are not required to reach consensus with the fisheries working group identified in the Musqueam agreement. That's what I was reading in the agreement. If that's the clarification you're providing, that's great. That's what I'm asking about.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127952","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Outside of an emergency, you are not required to reach consensus with the fisheries working group identified in the Musqueam agreement. That's what I was reading in the agreement. If that's the clarification you're providing, that's great. That's what I'm asking about.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc1653c01511cfdca3afb0ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127953,"date":"2026-05-04T17:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Can you provide clarity? I'm asking the questions here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127953","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Can you provide clarity? I'm asking the questions here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7cf26bd86e7f6372862421d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127954,"date":"2026-05-04T17:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay. Thank you. Again, this might be for Mr. Williams, but feel free, Mr. Davis, if you'd like to jump in as well. You said, in your opening remarks, that you work with industries and harvesters to set opening and closing dates. However, this past summer, I was inundated with complaints from commercial and recreational fishermen in my riding and throughout British Columbia about how slow the department was to open the sockeye fishery on the Fraser River, despite early results from test boats that showed, for example, returns being much higher than originally anticipated. Do you share the conclusion of many commercial and recreational fishermen that the department was too slow in opening the fishery?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127954","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you. Again, this might be for Mr. Williams, but feel free, Mr. Davis, if you'd like to jump in as well. You said, in your opening remarks, that you work with industries and harvesters to set opening and closing dates. However, this past summer, I was inundated with complaints from commercial and recreational fishermen in my riding and throughout British Columbia about how slow the depa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c819bec1cf1ecb636e4503346274f941cdad0e5d1e7859fff9da79aefc067d5c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ca0ee5c61aed521585912ba5f0c797990b022fdfc574404581129c2753b5973"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1614664dc000c019de90b0cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127955,"date":"2026-05-04T17:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. The question again is for whoever is best suited to answer, but I'll direct it to you to start, Mr. Williams. It's about the recent decision taken after the International Pacific Halibut Commission reached a conclusion and I believe the Canadian government agreed with this. It was that, for conservation purposes, the total allowable catch of halibut on the Pacific coast should be reduced. Why was the entirety of that reduction borne by Canada and none by the United States?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127955","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. The question again is for whoever is best suited to answer, but I'll direct it to you to start, Mr. Williams. It's about the recent decision taken after the International Pacific Halibut Commission reached a conclusion and I believe the Canadian government agreed with this. It was that, for conservation purposes, the total allowable catch of halibut on the Pacific coast should be","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8969c21c7bf6af2e3df5d9b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127956,"date":"2026-05-04T17:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Is it the position of the department that if we can't agree on how the reduction of the allowable catch should be split between us and the United States, we should just bear the entire economic cost while the United States is allowed to continue fishing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127956","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is it the position of the department that if we can't agree on how the reduction of the allowable catch should be split between us and the United States, we should just bear the entire economic cost while the United States is allowed to continue fishing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","label":"Fishing permits","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19b4e45ef93ea0e57a501c71a6140c653c934010d036cd439fa217b09f52723d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ae4a0cc625f401cfde62336","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127957,"date":"2026-05-04T17:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Were those consequences a form of economic coercion that would have prevented our seafood products from entering the United States?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127957","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Were those consequences a form of economic coercion that would have prevented our seafood products from entering the United States?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752541","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Seafood","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60539","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60539","label":"Products","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752541","label":"Seafood","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1b2ddbc0bb3d72ceca42ed57afbd68ed0448eae0fab0aa193cc50a4df399ce1c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b3e35cca6ed5b6c625ad880","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127958,"date":"2026-05-04T17:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay. The question that I have is how.... What has possibly changed going forward that will prevent that situation from just happening again? The Americans have clearly set the standard that if they use economic coercion on Canada and Canadian seafood producers, we'll just cave.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127958","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. The question that I have is how.... What has possibly changed going forward that will prevent that situation from just happening again? The Americans have clearly set the standard that if they use economic coercion on Canada and Canadian seafood producers, we'll just cave.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d492e66702399dde964edd4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127959,"date":"2026-05-04T17:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. I want to go back to my previous line of questioning around the various co-management agreements that have been announced with first nations as they pertain to fisheries. I think one of the things that are genuinely confusing citizens—including some people on this committee—is that these agreements are.... Presumably, where there are no co-management agreements, you still take into account the opinions and desires of first nations as you would harvesters, as you would recreational fishermen. Are these co-management agreements essentially creating more bureaucracy with no real power, or are you devolving power from the department and from the government to these shared working groups? I can't see how it's not one or the other.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127959","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I want to go back to my previous line of questioning around the various co-management agreements that have been announced with first nations as they pertain to fisheries. I think one of the things that are genuinely confusing citizens—including some people on this committee—is that these agreements are.... Presumably, where there are no co-management agreements, you still take into acco","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e716f88fb4f8e3e6ff88f9d0e1b7147684389750b6d4bd1bc57addc9cb9e2b1b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9219e87312a655ee084436241dfb2ad1165997afe1b56a0319c5f31bb2061cb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd382735f02d009b97d81fb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127960,"date":"2026-05-04T17:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Is there a concern that, as we saw with the Fraser River sockeye fishery, the creation of this new bureaucratic step will slow decision-making at DFO from being rapid? What is the commitment to the department around transparency around some of these decisions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127960","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is there a concern that, as we saw with the Fraser River sockeye fishery, the creation of this new bureaucratic step will slow decision-making at DFO from being rapid? What is the commitment to the department around transparency around some of these decisions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","label":"Fisheries technology","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a663687c61ab726b4aefaee1f7254f12da0d541e58584033b59b730f02d4ed2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c850325a65999b7623601dc9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960975,"date":"2026-05-05T15:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise once again in this House to submit yet another petition on behalf of the people of North Island—Powell River opposing ongoing attempts by a Bermuda-based company, Brookfield Renewables, to receive an unprecedented 30-year export permit to send Canadian hydroelectricity out of Powell River to the United States, in the middle of a trade war I might add, with no benefit to the people who live in the city, the province or our country.\n\nWhile the petitioners are encouraged to hear the process is now proceeding to a more thorough full licensing review, they remain concerned that the granting of a simple permit may still come, and that the power, which used to supply the local pulp mill and support thousands of jobs, may be permanently and irreversibly sent out of the country. The petitioners are outraged that there is still no plan to hold public hearings in the city of Powell River.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960975","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise once again in this House to submit yet another petition on behalf of the people of North Island—Powell River opposing ongoing attempts by a Bermuda-based company, Brookfield Renewables, to receive an unprecedented 30-year export permit to send Canadian hydroelectricity out of Powell River to the United States, in the middle of a trade war I might add, with no benefit to the peo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9e48db062158fba5cf117afaa2bca9998017961523c4563491f973554de24cdd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f780ff2b73a44096d7e63977fc2e06215eb9bcdf97439ad7a0e3ae70e5575299"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1568c1f684497119bdf12fa4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960976,"date":"2026-05-05T19:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what a a colossal and grotesque waste of taxpayer money. How else could one describe the deliberate Liberal decision to double the size of Canada's deficit and add $1 trillion to Canada's debt? It will increase the amount of taxpayer money wasted on interest payments to $80 billion every single year. That is $5,000 per Canadian household not going toward health care, education or roads. That is money taken from the pockets of everyday, hard-working Canadians and squandered.\n\nIf we keep borrowing all this money with no plan to pay it all back, this story will end only one way. It will end with ever-increasing interest charges consuming a larger and larger share of Canada's budget, meaning less money to pay for the essential government services on which we all rely and a deeper hole that will become only more difficult to dig ourselves out of.\n\n I implore the Liberal Prime Minister to put down the shovel, stop digging and restore fiscal discipline and fiscal sanity to this country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960976","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what a a colossal and grotesque waste of taxpayer money. How else could one describe the deliberate Liberal decision to double the size of Canada's deficit and add $1 trillion to Canada's debt? It will increase the amount of taxpayer money wasted on interest payments to $80 billion every single year. That is $5,000 per Canadian household not going toward health care, education or road","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b0ce3740e3d2c9f0f9cd0407e57cab8c408675ed46ea1b1c0824f00d7c42a243"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["53708d92fafb568845a8e16ef8b676c1592d956b9e5130721f744ef72eb74de2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-edd2281a772583df681565e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127961,"date":"2026-05-06T23:05:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"I just want some clarification on what was just said. Are we now...? Mr. Deschênes and the Liberals don't want to include the term \"pinniped\" because they want to restrict the study to only talking about the consequences on one coast of Canada but not the other. I'm open for them to clarify, because I feel like when we passed an earlier study about an issue that was mainly affecting the west coast with regard to the fishery openings with sockeye salmon, we made it broad enough so that it wasn't irrelevant for half of the members sitting at this committee. They could relate to it for their ridings and their coast. I don't know if it's deliberate or a misunderstanding—that we're arbitrarily removing half of the coastline of Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127961","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just want some clarification on what was just said. Are we now...? Mr. Deschênes and the Liberals don't want to include the term \"pinniped\" because they want to restrict the study to only talking about the consequences on one coast of Canada but not the other. I'm open for them to clarify, because I feel like when we passed an earlier study about an issue that was mainly affecting the west coast","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8087726d7e4ccb879740c667676ffb26a94359bf72104a9528d42cc2ad16afe1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec260eab264dd2aea251738842e2a9b80140146a7bcefa5061be9219589f211e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37d41f8a0e6a68e10ff281fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960971,"date":"2026-05-07T21:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, members can imagine waking up one morning in beautiful British Columbia. The sun is out. The birds are chirping. We can see the mountains, the forest and, if we are lucky, maybe even the ocean from our home. Life on the surface is actually pretty good, but that scenic reality masks a much deeper and darker anxiety. The title to that home, that deed that was signed however long ago, may no longer mean what we thought it meant. The financial investment that we built our entire life around, our home that we spent our entire life savings toward, may no longer belong to us, at least not in the same way we thought it did.\n\n I wish I could say this was just some sort of reoccurring bad dream for many B.C. homeowners. However, the truth is that this uncertainty is already their reality today. This past August, the B.C. Supreme Court issued a landmark ruling that has since reverberated across the province and, in time, will undoubtedly reverberate across the entire country. The ruling recognizes aboriginal title over 800 acres of riverfront property in Richmond, B.C., including over the personal homes of individual citizens, declaring fee simple title invalid and ruling aboriginal title as prior and senior title to the land. \n\nWhat does all this mean? No one really knows, which is a big part of the problem. However, the ruling, which is now known as the Cowichan decision, has shaken B.C. politics to its core. Because around 95% of B.C. was settled without formal treaties, the consequences of this decision are not limited to 800 acres in Richmond, but potentially impact nearly the entire province itself. While the decision is, of course, being appealed, and while the result of that appeal remains unclear, the consequences of the ruling are already being felt today. Homeowners are now being taxed on property the legal status of which is uncertain. Some are having difficulty selling their home, while businesses and industry groups have pulled billions of dollars of investment out of British Columbia as one of the key guardrails of the rule of law begins to break down. \n\nWhen a citizen pays their taxes, follows the law, maintains their property and still cannot be certain that they own their own home, something has gone profoundly wrong. Private property rights are not a luxury, not an appendage to our system of government, not some kind of optional add-on to our society, to our democracy. They are quite literally the foundation on which western civilization, capitalism and our economy are built. They form the basis for our savings, our security, our independence and our autonomy as a human being. Without them, we own nothing. We are a slave to our government or whatever other powers there may be. To have them infringed upon so suddenly, so brazenly, so harshly without compensation flies in the face of everything that it means to be Canadian. \n\nIt also wakes up a very important fact, which is that Canada is one of the few democracies in the world today without property rights enshrined in our Constitution. That was left out of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in 1982 by our old prime minister, Pierre Elliott Trudeau, and decades later, we are now living with the consequences.\n\n As a member of Parliament for a riding in British Columbia that itself comprises entire communities with homeowners facing similar legal uncertainty, it is my duty to speak out for my constituents and articulate my position and my views on this issue.\n\n For me, the defence of private property is and always will be a red line. It is not and should never be up for negotiation. It is in every way a fundamental human right, and we must never submit to trade it away to simply appease or placate the latest ideological fad or in the name of political convenience. Every citizen must know that their government will do whatever it takes to ensure that Canadians can trust that what they own is truly theirs without exception. Unfortunately, that is the exact opposite of what the Liberal government in Ottawa and the NDP government in B.C. have actually done.\n\nFirst, in 2018, the Liberal government instructed its lawyers, Crown counsel, to abandon their own citizens, ordering them to discard the long-held legal argument that the granting of fee simple private property took precedence over or extinguished any aboriginal title claim. That directive remains Liberal party policy to this day.\n\n Second, after the bombshell Cowichan ruling, the Liberals should have immediately halted any further agreements or treaty negotiations with first nations unless explicit protections for private property were included. Instead, again, they did the exact opposite, pushing ahead with the controversial Musqueam agreement, which essentially recognized aboriginal title over much of metro Vancouver and nearly one million Canadian homes with zero explicit protections for private property. \n\nIt should be noted that a member of Parliament from within the Liberal caucus called for, in his words, the return of unceded land. Then the Liberals went ahead and negotiated three new, unprecedented quasi treaties, otherwise referred to as living agreements, all of which involved huge transfers of land, money and resources to individual first nations, again with no explicit protections for private property included.\n\nWhen the Liberals and the NDP are pressed on their contradicting claims that they too support the private property rights of Canadians and will defend them at all costs, their rhetorical defence is that they claim they are appealing the Cowichan decision and hope that they will win.\n\n Hope is not a strategy and prayers are not a plan. The uncertainty created by their actions is already having real-world effects today. The Liberal government must act to restore certainty to homeowners now. It must act to restore confidence to businesses and industry and reverse the billions of dollars in investment that is fleeing British Columbia. Just as importantly, the government must act to prevent the further fraying of the social fabric between indigenous and non-indigenous Canadians that its policies have caused.\n\nBefore writing this speech, I actually looked up a dictionary definition of \"reconciliation\", and it is the act of causing two people or two groups of people to become friendly again after a falling out, an argument or a disagreement. In other words, it is about bridging divides and moving forward together. This is precisely the opposite of what the Liberal Party and the NDP have managed to accomplish over the last 10 years. It is exactly the opposite, as they are driving a wedge between indigenous and non-indigenous Canadians, playing identity politics and prioritizing virtue signalling and rhetoric over tangible, real-world results. I see that, instead of creating a framework that would bring Canadians together as one, they created an agenda that has driven them further apart. It is breeding resentment and frustration between communities instead of bridging divides and moving together as one country, Canada.\n\nThe vision behind our nation, from the very beginning, has always been one of working together toward a common goal and of achieving together what we could not accomplish on our own. We need to once again harness that vision to bring back and realize that mythology of Canada. That includes, as an essential component, the mutually beneficial partnership between indigenous and non-indigenous Canadians, from the fur trade to the War of 1812, but for that partnership to truly flourish, private property rights must remain sacrosanct.\n\n There must be no equivocation on the part of the government. It must never allow fee simple title and the rights of private property owners to be abridged or up for debate. In each new agreement with first nations, these rights must be enshrined. In each and every court defence, the case to defend these rights must be made, and if absolutely necessary, if the courts continue to interpret legislation or the Constitution in ways that undermine Canada's sovereignty, our economic viability or the rights of individual citizens, then whatever changes that are needed in that legislation, or even the Constitution, however difficult, must be done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960971","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, members can imagine waking up one morning in beautiful British Columbia. The sun is out. The birds are chirping. We can see the mountains, the forest and, if we are lucky, maybe even the ocean from our home. Life on the surface is actually pretty good, but that scenic reality masks a much deeper and darker anxiety. The title to that home, that deed that was signed however long ago, ma","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb1e487d27e43b450e238593005e5894e34fdf267bce4bfca9fbaa2b7b5b143f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b5af290e5291b06ebcdd0d36cd94856904072002bd09a8d6f3049922ebb2bba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b54978642945c317fdf7ab17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960972,"date":"2026-05-07T22:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with the member across the way. It does not mention private property, and that is the problem. There are no explicit protections for private property in the agreement and we are currently in a legal scenario. We are in legal limbo as we await the appeal process of the Cowichan decision.\n\nAs we said, as the Conservative Party, we have demanded that every new agreement, every new treaty with first nations, must have explicit protections for private property. It is a fundamental human right. That is what we are going to continue to push for on this side of the aisle.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960972","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with the member across the way. It does not mention private property, and that is the problem. There are no explicit protections for private property in the agreement and we are currently in a legal scenario. We are in legal limbo as we await the appeal process of the Cowichan decision.\n\nAs we said, as the Conservative Party, we have demanded that every new agreement, every ne","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0d46d9c8624a2c77e1c986d91a3593172db5dfea6e199106913faa45d644d49e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a881d5b4189342389b4e50de333ed54969b40a2e2ba00905537e90da8c16dfed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bacf1d1fbba66e286fe71ea7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960973,"date":"2026-05-07T22:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the first thing to do is to remove these legal guidelines that have restricted our Crown counsel from defending private property rights with all of the tools in their tool kit. \n\nThere should be no further agreements or treaties made with first nations without explicit protections for private property embedded within.\n\nAs far as what comes beyond that, my position, which I believe is also the position of my colleagues, is that when it comes to defending private property, we do whatever it takes. \n\nObviously, we are going to support the appeal of the Cowichan decision through the courts, but there is no step along this way, along this path, where we are going to allow the private property rights, the fundamental human rights of our fellow Canadians, to be abridged and to be up for debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960973","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the first thing to do is to remove these legal guidelines that have restricted our Crown counsel from defending private property rights with all of the tools in their tool kit. \n\nThere should be no further agreements or treaties made with first nations without explicit protections for private property embedded within.\n\nAs far as what comes beyond that, my position, which I believe is ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f03948affa341950e04454dc3d29b388a1fcb0c7242089591fec19835f29501"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc42d55bb48be9c3299e5ba290695945460767ca2140b982a545aca03dfc4c45"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d139ff2e55a89dd65a858b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960974,"date":"2026-05-07T22:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the mayor of Richmond is simply stating the facts as they are. The federal government and the provincial government in B.C. failed to make legal arguments to defend private property. That is a fact.\n\nHowever, what may be even more inexcusable is that after that court decision was made, they continued to go out and sign agreements, whether they were treaties in British Columbia or the Musqueam agreement, that did not explicitly protect private property in this new era of legal uncertainty that we now find ourselves in. \n\nThat is not fair to homeowners in B.C. That is not fair to private businesses. We need to get a government that is actually putting the private property rights of Canadians first.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960974","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the mayor of Richmond is simply stating the facts as they are. The federal government and the provincial government in B.C. failed to make legal arguments to defend private property. That is a fact.\n\nHowever, what may be even more inexcusable is that after that court decision was made, they continued to go out and sign agreements, whether they were treaties in British Columbia or the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e374155faebbc673f3c4cfa233cbecb669467f10ddecaaf31670cd2907279d8a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd1794c917f2f89f16f851111a6d0da3cc51f17917839422c6f45af762589111"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b895c8c32867704bf977c1a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036343,"date":"2026-05-25T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are outraged to learn that taxpayer dollars went to deceive and lie to individual Canadians, including RCMP veterans. A CBC production used fake websites, fake names and fake companies to lure them into supposed interviews about their lives after retirement, but it was all just a front, a set-up for some sort of twisted humiliation ritual in front of a live studio audience. This is insane.\n\nDoes the minister really think that it is acceptable for the state broadcaster to use taxpayer money to lie and deceive, and to smear the reputations of individual Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036343","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are outraged to learn that taxpayer dollars went to deceive and lie to individual Canadians, including RCMP veterans. A CBC production used fake websites, fake names and fake companies to lure them into supposed interviews about their lives after retirement, but it was all just a front, a set-up for some sort of twisted humiliation ritual in front of a live studio audience. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Propaganda","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44850","label":"Propaganda","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8f49b41e62a7f2f51b921c6f783637991df2054539b4f21cd97da5cc27c5c14"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc753fe45dc2d0dca9fc0db7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127974,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you, Chair. Minister, do you believe that the right to private property is a fundamental human right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127974","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Minister, do you believe that the right to private property is a fundamental human right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bf91bcf44103a0a1442652e410e6a40acd580c21245b923882df20796f7413ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b5dd0a673a0b696856ffc7068a676a585061942a9dd8694d387b79bbb92f1bc5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-089ac0891f50d333290f0f86","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127975,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"It has, especially in British Columbia, as I'm sure you know. Do you believe that aboriginal title should and can exist on top of or in conjunction with the existing fee simple title of individual homeowners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127975","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It has, especially in British Columbia, as I'm sure you know. Do you believe that aboriginal title should and can exist on top of or in conjunction with the existing fee simple title of individual homeowners?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6d249e8286bb2caf2ae2ffc0efd3c912548b81b4ee60ace930b01246f52093d6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["60ae1d5aef45d5262cbb947a2efbc08d47dabdc1c326bfba0e4d5aa850fe482e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04ad6a9e0d2d8237545ddf26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127976,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"Minister, do you believe that aboriginal title should and can exist in conjunction with the fee simple title of individual homeowners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127976","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Minister, do you believe that aboriginal title should and can exist in conjunction with the fee simple title of individual homeowners?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7090e0328a0a78a9472ee4ceaadf7d485ab1b52425442275b4538fe0a1d62dc4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1431cbd9343d6afc32c85377","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127977,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"They have coexisted, aboriginal title and...so on what basis are you appealing the Cowichan decision, then?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127977","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"They have coexisted, aboriginal title and...so on what basis are you appealing the Cowichan decision, then?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f9515dd41a09c4acd8b4ac63597c6e908a433aaa10906f061ec12ca6402117fa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e3d8b293d511f8ec05fe6edaab4e8e8f2397ecae26b51bc0a60a704c12f50d42"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-299b48aae4a71de1fee83dd5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127978,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"Was that not part of—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127978","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Was that not part of—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d0ba10811cdee689904926a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127979,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"Was part of the decision that led to the appeal not the fact that the judge ruled that aboriginal title is existing in conjunction with fee simple title on the private property of homeowners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127979","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Was part of the decision that led to the appeal not the fact that the judge ruled that aboriginal title is existing in conjunction with fee simple title on the private property of homeowners?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6b79e1e5604b3257040173fe553890b8a45be35901e79cbf2bb31fb9742a11bc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e419674ac25c0e386172712","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127980,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"It's a simple question, Minister. I'm trying to get—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127980","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's a simple question, Minister. I'm trying to get—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d8fe62f51c8e3a974e5ac8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127981,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"You have \"build more Canadian homes\" on your laptop, Minister. Do you acknowledge that the Cowichan decision has created uncertainty for homeowners in B.C.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127981","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You have \"build more Canadian homes\" on your laptop, Minister. Do you acknowledge that the Cowichan decision has created uncertainty for homeowners in B.C.?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034613","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034613","label":"Computers","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5fa170b41921584e6ec85218954806dca89f047fa69781f557dec7cc1ab680e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54181a0a08d71e6828e3459c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127982,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"Do you believe it's unjustified uncertainty?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127982","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do you believe it's unjustified uncertainty?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8691fd71ccaaf26d43b3c2d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127983,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"Why are you appealing the Cowichan decision if it's not a big deal?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127983","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Why are you appealing the Cowichan decision if it's not a big deal?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4633e3f9c424404a98e397a0143b69363e7f95c4669db4149930ab88dd69fa77"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1b8ed591edf06ad63e280f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127984,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"Why is your government appealing the Cowichan decision?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127984","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Why is your government appealing the Cowichan decision?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e54a50ceadf6b543aacaef3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127985,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"Okay. That's fine. You believe that on the appeal, it doesn't really matter whether we win or lose, as far as it concerns individual homeowners. You believe there's no threat to their private property, to their title, irrespective of what happens on the appeal.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127985","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. That's fine. You believe that on the appeal, it doesn't really matter whether we win or lose, as far as it concerns individual homeowners. You believe there's no threat to their private property, to their title, irrespective of what happens on the appeal.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a397db44ba39170afda5574325a053737953f528bd1e6f9dd0399b4c438b6fc2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b199f522f962d7dd9ee609aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127986,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"We're talking about housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127986","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We're talking about housing.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37c142a3c36d883a1028a5c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127987,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"Okay. You're just looking for clarity, then.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127987","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. You're just looking for clarity, then.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fd463a646368d06bb453978","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127988,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"I asked you for clarity on whether you believed that aboriginal title should coexist with fee simple title. It would be nice to get clarity from you, Minister, about your government's position on that. I understood that this was the reason you were appealing the Cowichan ruling. On the one hand, you stand up and make—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127988","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I asked you for clarity on whether you believed that aboriginal title should coexist with fee simple title. It would be nice to get clarity from you, Minister, about your government's position on that. I understood that this was the reason you were appealing the Cowichan ruling. On the one hand, you stand up and make—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-882801220708b58daab4da2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127989,"date":"2026-05-25T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"We asked for clarity. I would love some clarity myself. Is there a particular reason that, in subsequent agreements with first nations, including the Musqueam agreement in Vancouver, you did not enshrine explicit protections for private property owners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127989","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We asked for clarity. I would love some clarity myself. Is there a particular reason that, in subsequent agreements with first nations, including the Musqueam agreement in Vancouver, you did not enshrine explicit protections for private property owners?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["becb51a02aeda133bc55c64a59aee475d8674572b4e131824748dba348b3edbf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a98ab9e080bd7d12c8ceb21c42670fc014990bbe94f9ecb6dac7a1ae176e5d7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d17b5add38781260c2b59b4f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127990,"date":"2026-05-25T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"HUMA","text":"There is certainly nothing in there about private property. That was the point I was making. Minister, there's a bit of confusion about the reason your government is appealing the decision, of course. Do you acknowledge that, if you create uncertainty around private property and fee simple title, you can undermine the property value of individual homeowners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127990","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There is certainly nothing in there about private property. That was the point I was making. Minister, there's a bit of confusion about the reason your government is appealing the decision, of course. Do you acknowledge that, if you create uncertainty around private property and fee simple title, you can undermine the property value of individual homeowners?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["56006c12868155b1a9296d0bfe48a7372c5d345870755bc7bd1a63c8325ef3e8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee752acdec363b19ff7ad08b1c2ee769abc6af1bb2fa8628a039fbd10a72df01"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa502420b077ba17dc233ad7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127991,"date":"2026-05-26T16:45:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Christie, as I'm sure you know, there are two hydroelectric dams located in the city of Powell River. The dams were built more than 100 years ago to power the local pulp mill, creating thousands of jobs. They quite literally built the city of Powell River. About 10 years ago, that mill fell into financial trouble. It was forced to sell the dams as distressed assets to a small company called Brookfield Renewables. That company has since applied for an electricity export permit to send that electricity out of Canada to the United States, in the middle of a trade war, with no or very little benefit to the people who live in the region, the province and the country. About one month ago, as the local member of Parliament, I submitted a letter to the Canada Energy Regulator demanding public hearings in the city of Powell River at the earliest possible opportunity regarding Brookfield's permit request. This would give the people who the regulator's decision will affect the most the chance to have their say. Here we are, one month later, and there is still no response. My question for you is, why the silence? Will the regulator commit to holding public hearings in the city of Powell River regarding this very important issue?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127991","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. Christie, as I'm sure you know, there are two hydroelectric dams located in the city of Powell River. The dams were built more than 100 years ago to power the local pulp mill, creating thousands of jobs. They quite literally built the city of Powell River. About 10 years ago, that mill fell into financial trouble. It was forced to sell the dams as distressed assets to a small","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","label":"Dams"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","label":"Dams","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["12864992170d5fbd2cddc10bf4c32c032d1ec1395c316fb6fa7410315ad0e9e0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce4ddb9aabf3f8763a2f0576c3cc2ab30db4f5b1f85a3efb3fb755361bebddab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c41b56e5ad3b9ea2399b088","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127992,"date":"2026-05-26T16:50:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"RNNR","text":"Okay. Thank you. Well, I hope you can pass it along to some of the people you're working with to try to have a more rapid correspondence with the local member of Parliament. We have been waiting a month. If there have been developments, we would like to know. It is very important for the people who live in Powell River, regardless of political persuasion, to have their say on this very important issue. In Canada we like to talk a lot about clean renewable energy, electrification and domestic self-sufficiency, and yet in provinces like British Columbia, endowed with massive hydroelectric resources, in recent years we've become an electricity importer, primarily from the United States. In this context, does the Canada Energy Regulator believe it makes sense to be granting export permits to corporately owned power producers so that they can send the finite electricity that is being generated here out of the country, or is that something that is even part of the consideration?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127992","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you. Well, I hope you can pass it along to some of the people you're working with to try to have a more rapid correspondence with the local member of Parliament. We have been waiting a month. If there have been developments, we would like to know. It is very important for the people who live in Powell River, regardless of political persuasion, to have their say on this very important i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d975126d7ee24ac3d9242437","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127993,"date":"2026-05-26T16:50:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you very much for your answer. Really quickly, Mr. Leyburne, if I can direct a question towards you, how reliant are east coast refineries on foreign oil or oil that transits through the United States at the moment? Do you have that information?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127993","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much for your answer. Really quickly, Mr. Leyburne, if I can direct a question towards you, how reliant are east coast refineries on foreign oil or oil that transits through the United States at the moment? Do you have that information?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"International transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","label":"International transport","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b0f1f8e0a97001db026c605080bf6e53217fd72d0bd327703fad63ce195616c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2abb051985c2595a2007429b2bede8cdb15429477861f94d196410b63f753bd2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ed6ac87c5996b4c6c44c653","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036342,"date":"2026-05-26T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I always thought the role of the media was to hold the powerful accountable and to unapologetically seek the truth. Apparently, however, the CBC views it as trying to deceive and trick individual Canadians into bizarre and intentional traps. \n\nA new TV series from the CBC lied and used fictitious production companies, aliases and made-up stories in an effort to dupe Canadians for the purpose of political propaganda. It deceived RCMP veterans by inviting them to fake ceremonies only to publicly humiliate them. It targeted ordinary citizens who had concerns about land claims and private property rights. It partnered with well-known, far-left American activists to attack Canadian history, Canadian institutions and Canada's first prime minister. It was all paid for using taxpayer money. \n\nThe CBC is a Crown corporation. Its mandate is to serve all Canadians, not to target them, not to deceive them and certainly not to produce political propaganda designed to denigrate their beliefs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036342","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I always thought the role of the media was to hold the powerful accountable and to unapologetically seek the truth. Apparently, however, the CBC views it as trying to deceive and trick individual Canadians into bizarre and intentional traps. \n\nA new TV series from the CBC lied and used fictitious production companies, aliases and made-up stories in an effort to dupe Canadians for the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Propaganda","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44850","label":"Propaganda","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bef5b7a185f690926980560eabb1a4ac7d0ee44ff65ca976da90eeb43ff6125"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8087143a27128ab96e11bc8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127962,"date":"2026-06-01T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. McLinton, I have a question that pertains to fisheries on the west coast. Can I address that to Mr. Dovey? Mr. Dovey, across B.C. we've had a number of examples of indigenous groups, be they first nation band councils or hereditary chiefs, unilaterally declaring an area closed to fishing to non-band members. Have you had any experience with these pronouncements?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127962","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Mr. McLinton, I have a question that pertains to fisheries on the west coast. Can I address that to Mr. Dovey? Mr. Dovey, across B.C. we've had a number of examples of indigenous groups, be they first nation band councils or hereditary chiefs, unilaterally declaring an area closed to fishing to non-band members. Have you had any experience with these pronouncements?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["95d3f76f9afea0bde081c07cb64271a41f990f8d55dec3e293f00c9a77a23f66"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c23a15c2fc837b24334fb83deb2ac809ab19f92bce834b08ce818bcc49111f14"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d866ba8f56a6c95c0d6b1dfd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127963,"date":"2026-06-01T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"We've been told repeatedly at this committee, by DFO officials and the minister herself, that only the federal government has the ability and the right to close areas to fishing. Does DFO clarify this and defend the rights of fishermen to access these areas when the status of these areas becomes uncertain?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127963","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We've been told repeatedly at this committee, by DFO officials and the minister herself, that only the federal government has the ability and the right to close areas to fishing. Does DFO clarify this and defend the rights of fishermen to access these areas when the status of these areas becomes uncertain?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","label":"Fishing permits","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00c442a94891a30268fe06592b36d586c3258e08c319e79166464ae1063f8a9e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b1a43deebcf9b7c9be6cf039","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127964,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"It seems like a situation that would be bad for everybody: first nations, fish harvesters and the rule of law. Do you have a specific example of this happening, how it affected a fishery and what the consequences of this uncertainty have been?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127964","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It seems like a situation that would be bad for everybody: first nations, fish harvesters and the rule of law. Do you have a specific example of this happening, how it affected a fishery and what the consequences of this uncertainty have been?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e31208fbbe94d92a2892b5f385c953f9a8015eb852a4db304bf4d1df91565ae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98da85a2938520bfdbe33ea8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127965,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Just to clarify, was this closure of Kitasu Bay a unilateral declaration? If so, do you have evidence of that—a letter or an email from the band—that you can submit as evidence to this committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127965","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just to clarify, was this closure of Kitasu Bay a unilateral declaration? If so, do you have evidence of that—a letter or an email from the band—that you can submit as evidence to this committee?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bdeace685deeb5effaf8d6a4d6ef10836f242d6027677831057e98ce5bc5552c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-685efab31d20f0e79bee8de6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127966,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Chair, I think I must have cut out or something—there's a technical issue—because I made a specific request. I need to repeat it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127966","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Chair, I think I must have cut out or something—there's a technical issue—because I made a specific request. I need to repeat it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["101275d0b0e7f6b1ae768eca600fd140038219a94b664c2d165e9323b1160f2d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e9a37b6d614c1a9cf476533","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127967,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Dovey, was there a unilateral pronouncement from the band about this closure? If so, do you have evidence of it that you could submit to this committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127967","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Dovey, was there a unilateral pronouncement from the band about this closure? If so, do you have evidence of it that you could submit to this committee?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","label":"Birds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b5ab9daa17b5c10970a63743fb25b6bfec424be43ac576b0218104c610526376"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b02287033ef55154d30f18a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127968,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Yes, please submit that to me. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127968","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, please submit that to me. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28f92e067e7ad891452bfd04","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127969,"date":"2026-06-01T17:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Madam Chair, I just want to enter into the record of evidence a press release from the Gitxsan Hereditary Chiefs related to harvest seasons. I have a physical copy here to share with the clerk. Ms. Mavin, from your experience, do you find that decisions over at DFO regarding the opening and closing of various fisheries are always driven by science and empirical data, or do they at times tend to be influenced, in your view, by politics and ideology?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127969","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I just want to enter into the record of evidence a press release from the Gitxsan Hereditary Chiefs related to harvest seasons. I have a physical copy here to share with the clerk. Ms. Mavin, from your experience, do you find that decisions over at DFO regarding the opening and closing of various fisheries are always driven by science and empirical data, or do they at times tend to be","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2421640a754826b7415c252f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127970,"date":"2026-06-01T17:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"I know you mentioned it in your opening remarks, but if the department fails to open a fishery in a timely manner despite there being abundance, can you detail what the impacts are on fish harvesters and their families?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127970","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I know you mentioned it in your opening remarks, but if the department fails to open a fishery in a timely manner despite there being abundance, can you detail what the impacts are on fish harvesters and their families?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec2f01b421f238575ff788ca50fabdddc64e747c97ebf5830d19c2482e91e9a6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc008402757e779369aafcae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127971,"date":"2026-06-01T17:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"You spoke about both the quick closing of the prawn season last year and then the delayed notification that it was actually opening this year. Do you find that there's a lack of predictable communication from DFO regarding season opening and closing dates?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127971","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You spoke about both the quick closing of the prawn season last year and then the delayed notification that it was actually opening this year. Do you find that there's a lack of predictable communication from DFO regarding season opening and closing dates?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather warnings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50395","label":"Weather warnings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["994287f47d1089f0c432f5378312f9114935d83ef064d90d8129c3818d262cf5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4425901023d5245ca9b4f056","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127972,"date":"2026-06-01T17:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Cormier, did you want to ask your question that was cut off?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127972","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Cormier, did you want to ask your question that was cut off?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2e28b1601579b3d94242508","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127973,"date":"2026-06-03T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"FOPO","text":"Chair, I'm going to yield my time to Ms. Kronis.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127973","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Chair, I'm going to yield my time to Ms. Kronis.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3a36cb4a7d8ec06100f190db2e5a2ee1f80e9ff930c2f3d4f656ab74d1e354f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9ad26cc71fa49722bab4d8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086469,"date":"2026-06-10T19:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"There used to be a promise here in Canada, Mr. Speaker, that if a person worked hard, paid their taxes and followed the law, they could afford a home, groceries and a decent standard of living. Now, after 10 years of the Liberal government, for most Canadians that promise no longer exists. According to a new survey from the United Way, 60% of Canadians now feel anxious about their finances, 38% struggle with food insecurity, and 40% are losing sleep.\n\n When will the Prime Minister acknowledge that his policies of more spending, more debt and jet-setting around the world are just not delivering real results?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086469","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There used to be a promise here in Canada, Mr. Speaker, that if a person worked hard, paid their taxes and followed the law, they could afford a home, groceries and a decent standard of living. Now, after 10 years of the Liberal government, for most Canadians that promise no longer exists. According to a new survey from the United Way, 60% of Canadians now feel anxious about their finances, 38% st","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87c0c80b085d6b3c4734092d5827ec24f9e9cd0979af15c1ea82d85f348ff047"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04773c4c95941889181fe47a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086470,"date":"2026-06-10T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I can tell the House that most people on Vancouver Island know one thing, which is that the economic policies of the Liberal government have been hurting young Canadians the most, young people who can no longer afford homes in the communities they grew up in, whose jobs have been shipped overseas or taken by temporary foreign workers, whose streets on which they play have been flooded with dangerous drugs and whose futures have been mortgaged this year alone with $80 billion in new debt. \n\nWhen will the government reverse its policies and stop throwing the next generation under the bus?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086470","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I can tell the House that most people on Vancouver Island know one thing, which is that the economic policies of the Liberal government have been hurting young Canadians the most, young people who can no longer afford homes in the communities they grew up in, whose jobs have been shipped overseas or taken by temporary foreign workers, whose streets on which they play have been flooded","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46717dbe1162024e61f4fba10e71691c543db503f0f9d82617afa623c977ee9b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c15fb036fa0004f83b1f62410e413f77b84b312180bd29237ac19def74bf5a38"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7cf0fc79def4b8e9e5a8477b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088310,"date":"2026-06-17T21:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Aaron Gunn","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition to provide our beloved police service dogs with the veterinary care in retirement that these valued police partners deserve.\n\n The petitioners recognize that these dogs serve faithfully alongside police officers right across Canada, providing protection, detection and life-saving support to Canadians and members of law enforcement. It is support that often results in injuries or the development of service-related conditions. Disappointingly, in Canada, there is currently nothing to assist with the veterinary costs of looking after our K-9 friends after they have finished serving Canada with such distinction.\n\n Therefore, the petitioners are calling for all police service dogs who have completed three years or more of active duty to have their veterinary care fully covered for all injuries directly linked to their policing service, and 50% covered for the remainder of their general veterinary care. After their service to this country and their fellow officers, it is the least that we can do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088310","member_id":"bc-mp-123586","member_name":"Aaron Gunn","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition to provide our beloved police service dogs with the veterinary care in retirement that these valued police partners deserve.\n\n The petitioners recognize that these dogs serve faithfully alongside police officers right across Canada, providing protection, detection and life-saving support to Canadians and members of law enforcement. It is support that often","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55d247c34d1495ce885f77bdfedc85974dbedd271c8826bede879ebdcf1c4c2e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87751bfc641b44e0982ef3b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70421,"date":"2026-01-28T22:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is of interest to me that, as my colleague pointed out, while the Prime Minister called the Canada-Indonesia CEPA a game-changing agreement, it is comparably disadvantaged with respect to the agreements Indonesia has with the U.A.E. and the EU.\n\nI want my colleague to elaborate further. What does this kind of situation reflect? Is it because of incompetence on the part of the government or any kind of failure on the part of the federal government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70421","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is of interest to me that, as my colleague pointed out, while the Prime Minister called the Canada-Indonesia CEPA a game-changing agreement, it is comparably disadvantaged with respect to the agreements Indonesia has with the U.A.E. and the EU.\n\nI want my colleague to elaborate further. What does this kind of situation reflect? Is it because of incompetence on the part of the gover","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f966b2921185edd58545065972926c09e976e5750e32f6e392c2249283e18c22"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["744a6af516970cc3d48f6bf1299f4cf36997423e2997bd30760792fb03e16384"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c2cc091484d4bb56796a523","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86073,"date":"2026-02-04T23:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, once again, we have seen this before. The Liberal government is trying to address a structural problem by providing short-term relief measures. As we have seen in the past, when these kinds of measures are temporary and short-lived, they do not help the cost of living. While these programs are being offered, the cost of living is still rising.\n\nI want to challenge the government to provide one example of these kinds of measures creating long-term, sustainable and measurable reductions in grocery prices. If this has not worked before, why would the government believe that this time it would work?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86073","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, once again, we have seen this before. The Liberal government is trying to address a structural problem by providing short-term relief measures. As we have seen in the past, when these kinds of measures are temporary and short-lived, they do not help the cost of living. While these programs are being offered, the cost of living is still rising.\n\nI want to challenge the government to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["acd04fd606004f5bab533fffedbb5043677865777365264e3be25e3d69bbdd03"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f4dab737e2a2da7d82ff0c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299615,"date":"2026-02-13T00:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Cowichan decision is not a small local dispute. It is a Canada-wide concern. It raises fundamental questions of property ownership. The court found that aboriginal title may exist over lands currently held in fee simple by private owners. That finding carries significant implications for Canada's land title system, a clear system built on certainty. \n\nFor generations, when the Crown granted fee simple interests, those grants were understood to provide certainty of ownership. One of the doctrines historically relied upon to support that certainty was the extinguishment argument, the position that historical Crown grants were treated in law as having settled questions of aboriginal title in those lands. This has long formed part of the legal architecture underpinning property ownership in Canada. \n\nHowever, during the Cowichan litigation, the federal Liberal government made a deliberate decision not to advance that argument at trial. That was not a procedural failure; it was a directive to the federal counsel. The extinguishment argument, central to fee simple certainty, was not defended. \n\nSince that ruling, uncertainty has spread beyond one region. Land title questions are surfacing elsewhere in British Columbia, including most recently in relation to land claims in the Kingcome Inlet area. When foundational legal principles appear unsettled, the ripple effects extend far beyond the original case, yet the federal government has provided no clear public explanation of its directive, no detailed legal justification and no clear statement of principle. Filing an appeal does not explain what doctrine the government now stands behind. If this reflects a policy shift, Canadians deserve transparency. If a new framework is being adopted, it should be clearly communicated. \n\nThe government's decisions have consequences. In Richmond Centre—Marpole, families are concerned about the security of their homes, which are often their life savings. Lenders are raising questions. Developers are pausing projects. Large and small businesses are reassessing long-term plans. On October 23, 2025, the City of Richmond wrote to the Attorney General urging restoration of the extinguishment argument on appeal and seeking clarification. There has been no response. City council subsequently passed a motion calling for federal action. There has been no meaningful engagement. \n\nMore than 500 residents attended a public session seeking answers while provincial officials stepped in to provide reassurance. Property law cannot operate in governmental ambiguity. Certainty underpins mortgages, development, taxation and long-term investment across this country, and the federal government carries the ultimate responsibility for securing property ownership in Canada. \n\nWill the Liberal government explain why it directed its lawyers not to advance the extinguishment argument, what legal principles it now intends to defend and what immediate steps it will take to restore certainty and confidence for Richmond residents and Canadians across this country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299615","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Cowichan decision is not a small local dispute. It is a Canada-wide concern. It raises fundamental questions of property ownership. The court found that aboriginal title may exist over lands currently held in fee simple by private owners. That finding carries significant implications for Canada's land title system, a clear system built on certainty. \n\nFor generations, when the Cro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["863b7e02ca42fd9b0f0150e338005c7fd24f237746408fd0313fa75ff61b7881"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ffb2f45180f394173308a2b4add7ad21ddbd84972b59ccde0bb8945d84c68ff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76c7364e43b17ce2cae23fb1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299616,"date":"2026-02-13T00:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, first, I believe the residents of Richmond do not buy the argument that since the case is before the courts, we cannot make comments. The B.C. government and the Richmond city council have made comments, so it is not right for the federal government to be silent on this issue. \n\nSecondly, to say that the government has appealed is not enough. It filed an appeal at the very last minute and without a clear direction about what it is going to use as the grounds for the appeal. \n\nOnce again, will the Liberal government retract its directive to its counsel and use extinguishment as the grounds for appeal in this case?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299616","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, first, I believe the residents of Richmond do not buy the argument that since the case is before the courts, we cannot make comments. The B.C. government and the Richmond city council have made comments, so it is not right for the federal government to be silent on this issue. \n\nSecondly, to say that the government has appealed is not enough. It filed an appeal at the very last minute","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fcf65db6de574cd3c86b96ccbbb862f009d0c1517bad5ccc26e80d722881f6c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-213b91ffbcae174f7ef6544d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310834,"date":"2026-02-25T19:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are tired of new titles and moving offices. They do not want more announcements. They want results. They want homes.\n\nThe government now proposes another federal housing body, but we already have the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, infrastructure Canada, the Department of Finance Canada and the Canada Lands Company all working on housing, land and financing.\n\nIf all these agencies already exist, what exactly would the new body do that the others cannot? Would it build homes faster? Would it cut permits? Would it remove taxes like the GST on new homes? No, it would simply add overhead and administrative delays.\n\nHousing affordability will not improve by multiplying paperwork. It is time for the Liberal government to cut red tape, get out of the way and let builders build.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310834","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are tired of new titles and moving offices. They do not want more announcements. They want results. They want homes.\n\nThe government now proposes another federal housing body, but we already have the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, infrastructure Canada, the Department of Finance Canada and the Canada Lands Company all working on housing, land and financing.\n\nIf all","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c02ac1b5fbf53fb07e298ff451289253339f722f142310387ecadde2eb0801aa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca6f40b23d02c05d6b8a1215d0eab03755b0e287efa2f1a8ecb1b99d7ef96a31"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a017aa0d354218982dc53968","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350201,"date":"2026-03-09T20:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, residents from Richmond Centre—Marpole and hundreds of thousands of Canadians across the country are standing against Bill C-9 and for the protection of religious freedom in Canada. \n\nThe petitioners note that the Liberal-Bloc amendment adopted at committee would remove the good faith religious defence from the Criminal Code. They warn that this change would allow the state to persecute individuals for sharing passages from sacred texts, such as the Bible, the Quran, the Torah and other religious teachings, if they are deemed offensive. \n\nCanadians understand that freedom of expression and freedom of religion are cornerstones of a free society. People of faith should never have to wonder whether expressing their beliefs will bring the power of the state to their—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350201","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, residents from Richmond Centre—Marpole and hundreds of thousands of Canadians across the country are standing against Bill C-9 and for the protection of religious freedom in Canada. \n\nThe petitioners note that the Liberal-Bloc amendment adopted at committee would remove the good faith religious defence from the Criminal Code. They warn that this change would allow the state to persecu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4b42d08548f3d3c33a3018c0c4068368c3f10ef0e77da18f6bb68ab56a3db04d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d401fcbd17af1798ed98d4fbb679d7a2c3b37da721f3f477ca8be2a28551703"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dfbe8c28cf54f0c93bfe564f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350202,"date":"2026-03-09T20:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, therefore, the petitioners call on the Government of Canada to withdraw Bill C-9 and protect the rights of Canadians to read, share and speak their religious convictions freely.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350202","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, therefore, the petitioners call on the Government of Canada to withdraw Bill C-9 and protect the rights of Canadians to read, share and speak their religious convictions freely.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4daa9e878b4712d226aeb459a5864bc7a7b9cf487006d5c5d22fb7e819953504"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8bf84e45c44bff48eb56c343df871c12de74255524558764d2d4f1dc0971a92a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7294f2fae4e1c4205a56fce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350204,"date":"2026-03-09T20:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have another petition to present. \n\nThe petitioners are seriously concerned about Bill C-9 and amendments adopted at the justice committee. The petitioners believe that these changes remove long-standing protections for good faith religious expression. They fear that this would allow the state to intrude into religious teachings, sacred texts and the peaceful expression of deeply held beliefs. They affirm that freedom of expression and freedom of religion are fundamental rights in Canada, and they should be protected from government overreach. \n\nTherefore, the petitioners call on the Government of Canada to withdraw Bill C-9 and to uphold and protect religious freedom, including the right to read, share and teach sacred texts without fear of criminal sanction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350204","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I have another petition to present. \n\nThe petitioners are seriously concerned about Bill C-9 and amendments adopted at the justice committee. The petitioners believe that these changes remove long-standing protections for good faith religious expression. They fear that this would allow the state to intrude into religious teachings, sacred texts and the peaceful expression of deeply held beliefs. T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3288f469269f112bf51ee2f1228605608a08711df81c37abda4a153dc28b085c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d468a37b19a01b21a4001f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350205,"date":"2026-03-09T20:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"The last petition I am presenting is on the same theme. \n\nPetitioners warn that removing the good faith religious defence from the Criminal Code risks criminalizing the reading and sharing of sacred texts, including the Bible, the Quran and the Torah. They believe that this opens the door to persecuting Canadians for expressing deeply held religious beliefs. They remind the House that freedom of religion and freedom of expression are fundamental rights of a free and democratic society. \n\nTherefore, the petitioners call on the Government of Canada to withdraw Bill C-9 and to protect religious freedom by preventing government intrusion into matters of faith.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350205","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"The last petition I am presenting is on the same theme. \n\nPetitioners warn that removing the good faith religious defence from the Criminal Code risks criminalizing the reading and sharing of sacred texts, including the Bible, the Quran and the Torah. They believe that this opens the door to persecuting Canadians for expressing deeply held religious beliefs. They remind the House that freedom of r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d8b8ba8c1fc6351a51b6ffa49fd78059c5b52db79b0d40d7b9f2a051baafc4ce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea26c9afc30cb06d8ca3caa97933c517a22a39ecc34e9f74bd9e93b4d819ce68"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9cf4c5bdfc38ca5d1dfe5001","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350206,"date":"2026-03-09T22:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians understand very well that the best predictor of future performance is past results. That is why Canadians have every reason to be skeptical about the Liberal government's latest housing promise. For nearly a decade, Canadians have heard the same story repeated again and again: a new announcement, a new strategy, a new fund, a new target. Each time, the government assures Canadians that this time the housing crisis will finally be solved, but when we examine its record carefully, a troubling pattern emerges. \n\nIn 2017, the government introduced what it described as a historic initiative: the national housing strategy. It committed more than $115 billion in housing spending over 10 years. It promised to drastically improve affordability, reduce homelessness and expand the supply of housing across the country. Billions of dollars were allocated. Targets were announced. New programs were created, but what actually happened? \n\nDuring roughly the same period that the government was rolling out these plans, housing prices in Canada nearly doubled. Young Canadians are increasingly locked out of home ownership. Families are struggling with rising rents. In many major cities, housing affordability is now among the worst in the world. The government announced another plan, then another fund and then another target. \n\nThe housing accelerator fund was introduced with the promise that it would help build hundreds of thousands of homes by cutting red tape. Then another national plan was released, claiming that Canada had the strategy to solve the housing crisis. Now, once again, Canadians are told that this time the government has found the solution. This time, we are told a new federal housing agency will fix the problem. \n\nCanadians have heard this before. Each time a new program is announced, the government claims the housing crisis is about to turn a corner, yet each time the targets are missed, the timelines are extended and the crisis deepens. At some point, we must ask a very basic question: Why should Canadians believe that this new promise will succeed when all previous promises have failed?\n\nAnother question must also be asked. Canada already has multiple federal bodies involved in housing policy. We have the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, which has long been the federal government's primary housing agency. Infrastructure Canada funds projects tied to housing development. The Department of Finance designs housing tax policies and financial programs. Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada is responsible for implementation of the national housing strategy. On top of that, the Liberal government has created additional structures over the past decade, including the federal housing advocate, the National Housing Council and multiple new program administrations. \n\nWith all of these institutions already operating in the housing space, Canadians deserve clarity. What exactly would this new agency do that cannot already be done by the existing agencies? What specific function is missing from the current system? \n\nIf this new agency is truly necessary, Canadians deserve to hear other answers as well. What existing programs will be streamlined? Which agencies will have their responsibilities reduced? Which bureaucratic processes will be eliminated to avoid duplication and more red tape? If this new agency simply adds another layer of administration, then Canadians are not getting more homes. They are getting more bureaucracy. \n\n Housing affordability will not improve because we create more government entities. It will improve when we build more homes faster and more efficiently. That is why Canadians are skeptical when they hear the Liberal government's latest announcement.\n\nThis brings us directly to Bill C-20. Once again, the government's answer to real problems is not reform, but reorganization. Instead of fixing the delays that prevent homes from being built, the government proposed to create another federal housing body.\n\nLet us consider the Minister of Housing's own record. He is now leading in the so-called new housing plan. When he first ran for mayor of Vancouver, he made a bold promise that street homelessness in Vancouver would be ended by 2015. It was a clear commitment that he widely publicized, but by the end of his time as mayor, the number of homeless had increased, housing prices in Vancouver had soared and Vancouver became one of the least affordable housing markets anywhere in the world. That record matters. Once again, Canadians are being told that the same leadership, ideas and approach will now help fix the national housing crisis.\n\nTo conclude, Canadians have seen a pattern for more than a decade: promises made and promises broken. Billions have been spent and bureaucracy has expanded, yet the homes Canadians need are still not being built. Canadians are told that this time it will be different. Canadians do not need another layer of bureaucracy; they need homes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350206","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians understand very well that the best predictor of future performance is past results. That is why Canadians have every reason to be skeptical about the Liberal government's latest housing promise. For nearly a decade, Canadians have heard the same story repeated again and again: a new announcement, a new strategy, a new fund, a new target. Each time, the government assures Can","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["692952682643130793acdc7aeb6f84db6db1884ce492b802d8555f2ef30dee00"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21c368c68c8d7974b42f45f53a4823f85132469b6513538334924b5e1e1d2e5a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0b4176776c65e4249f61b06","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350207,"date":"2026-03-09T22:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I do not understand how recycled ideas could be disguised as new operations. We have seen repeated announcements in the last decade promising the same thing. Recycled ideas will not bring hopes or homes. It is not even a dream; it is just a disillusion. I do not understand why these recycled ideas could be disguised as new.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350207","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I do not understand how recycled ideas could be disguised as new operations. We have seen repeated announcements in the last decade promising the same thing. Recycled ideas will not bring hopes or homes. It is not even a dream; it is just a disillusion. I do not understand why these recycled ideas could be disguised as new.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47f8232e27253d8e8c1a3617ada7cc14e962cb90b92848817f44007627d8d3dd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-792835e783eaa45985782d35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350208,"date":"2026-03-09T22:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I agree that the federal government has a role to play in providing affordable housing to Canadians. However, I have the experience of being a city councillor for the last 12 years, and my experience has been that first, the federal government always downloads everything to the local government and second, the federal government does not consult. There is a lack of consultation, and at the end, the federal government does what it wants to do, and it does not provide the means that the local community could provide in a better way.\n\nIt is better for the federal government to get out of the way and let local governments and other partners work to make things better for our communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350208","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I agree that the federal government has a role to play in providing affordable housing to Canadians. However, I have the experience of being a city councillor for the last 12 years, and my experience has been that first, the federal government always downloads everything to the local government and second, the federal government does not consult. There is a lack of consultation, and a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4c8b4b774d51df87c6fc50b911d997be8cc1a519cf713683c9adf725f9e906e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["327123837c543239d49f039b0afff06418075f59d8ac792b9cca678583eccbb7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b1c268d4527181a54731b0d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350209,"date":"2026-03-09T22:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr Speaker, what we hear, day in and day out, in our communities is how unaffordable things are, including housing. It is because all kinds of bureaucracy, taxation and added costs in building new homes have created this problem, the crisis that people are facing right now.\n\n Again, the lack of consultation by the federal government has resulted in inappropriate solutions for the problems that people are facing. I was told that before the launching of this new agency, the Richmond City Council was not consulted. They have no role to play in giving feedback and inputs to the new agency. This is one example where the lack of consultation is a problem.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350209","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr Speaker, what we hear, day in and day out, in our communities is how unaffordable things are, including housing. It is because all kinds of bureaucracy, taxation and added costs in building new homes have created this problem, the crisis that people are facing right now.\n\n Again, the lack of consultation by the federal government has resulted in inappropriate solutions for the problems that peo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e812dd738a905cff3c3cdfbe52db64213bc9cb58fa106fef0e984ef871711e85"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cf0e648115c3e51da5dd72865e881147b0adce60a8e2e72071dd875819db6189"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-963c9c91f42c2e5aa579f6b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350210,"date":"2026-03-09T22:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, once again, we do not need more bureaucracy and we do not need more reports to build more homes.\n\n Let me give another example. Just last week, Richmond opened 84 units of affordable low-income housing, without federal funding. Cities can do it. They do not have to be told what to do. They need the opportunities, freedom and resources to build homes, not another layer of bureaucracy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350210","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, once again, we do not need more bureaucracy and we do not need more reports to build more homes.\n\n Let me give another example. Just last week, Richmond opened 84 units of affordable low-income housing, without federal funding. Cities can do it. They do not have to be told what to do. They need the opportunities, freedom and resources to build homes, not another layer of bureaucracy.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bfa42e7c893c93921ed2e4cccfefc4f747c06fa6afb7b8e0ca52ffd12f30e750"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["59fece9d0336dbf937d372fb32a82e97dfa7aa9a4843eb8bd853fdcc04b6d39f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8829d8d7588d3400a06fe2b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350211,"date":"2026-03-09T22:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my response to that question would be that we do not need the federal government to direct us on what to do. Each community would have its own priorities, needs and the best way to resolve them.\n\n Again, using Richmond as an example, in the past 15 years, because Richmond has a good housing strategy, we were able to build thousands of homes in partnership with the building community, not with any government funding from the Liberal government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350211","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my response to that question would be that we do not need the federal government to direct us on what to do. Each community would have its own priorities, needs and the best way to resolve them.\n\n Again, using Richmond as an example, in the past 15 years, because Richmond has a good housing strategy, we were able to build thousands of homes in partnership with the building community, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d2fae6b8eb4e55fbd8b86d9b13ea5a23df8f7ca33916e20a671153c0e4a562c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3bea40a90b15e2252e108983448a71a9d6a7b61e1957963ed65acd0cea7b9bd1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb6418a95e1b159081aeb2dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350212,"date":"2026-03-09T22:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in my riding, this is exactly what I hear, day in and day out.\n\n People need homes, not allocated or dictated by the federal government on what type of housing they should have. They do not need to rent for life. They want to have the opportunity to save enough money to own their own home one day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350212","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in my riding, this is exactly what I hear, day in and day out.\n\n People need homes, not allocated or dictated by the federal government on what type of housing they should have. They do not need to rent for life. They want to have the opportunity to save enough money to own their own home one day.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c0de7e2b9e121c3aa79274a03f557501f191c08e8bcd9d5c68f3ede39cc74f10"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0251960d567dbeed4a3334e44f71251b9f5d60c379aa98e56852ff9ac4f4b10f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84bfcccf6d776c983458eb5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350200,"date":"2026-03-11T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr Speaker, what happens abroad may be beyond our control, but the Liberal policies making life more expensive are not. \n\nOur seniors are paying the price. Seniors are being forced to work, with retirement slipping further out of reach. The National Institute on Aging reports that one in five Canadiens over 50 is now living on the poverty line, yet the Liberals are making it worse by sneaking in carbon taxes that drive up the price of essentials.\n\n When will the Prime Minister take responsibility for what he can control and scrap the Liberal policies that are making life unaffordable for Canadians, including seniors?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350200","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr Speaker, what happens abroad may be beyond our control, but the Liberal policies making life more expensive are not. \n\nOur seniors are paying the price. Seniors are being forced to work, with retirement slipping further out of reach. The National Institute on Aging reports that one in five Canadiens over 50 is now living on the poverty line, yet the Liberals are making it worse by sneaking in c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["229060258910388430df80cf29fd0e110a0f657e656e1ad66658de56a6674781"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6a6f483bcb4abc67550269536ebcb24c070977372b9673a1dcdb45210e7c4039"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70371ec1f83c3a8454c003b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390271,"date":"2026-03-23T20:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard from many members of Parliament today that they have received a lot of responses from a wide range of religious groups and leaders.\n\nOn the other hand, we keep hearing from the other side that people and religious leaders are being misled or are being fed misinformation, as if this is an insult or a put-down to these groups. Does my colleague want to comment on that? Is this a put-down or an insult?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390271","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard from many members of Parliament today that they have received a lot of responses from a wide range of religious groups and leaders.\n\nOn the other hand, we keep hearing from the other side that people and religious leaders are being misled or are being fed misinformation, as if this is an insult or a put-down to these groups. Does my colleague want to comment on that? Is ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f799d4c9be85cb818908b2224561d21627157f4375f5bbe5e49f660416dd8092"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f5029b4cb43bbf21a12ec29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715133,"date":"2026-04-13T19:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in the Cowichan land claim case, the Liberal government instructed its lawyers to abandon the fee simple argument, the very cornerstone of private property rights in Canada. That decision has created real uncertainty for homeowners, businesses and everyone who depends on secure land ownership in this country. By stepping back in court, the government is effectively walking away from defending Canadians' property rights. \n\nWill the Prime Minister reverse this decision and direct its lawyers to fully defend fee simple ownership, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715133","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in the Cowichan land claim case, the Liberal government instructed its lawyers to abandon the fee simple argument, the very cornerstone of private property rights in Canada. That decision has created real uncertainty for homeowners, businesses and everyone who depends on secure land ownership in this country. By stepping back in court, the government is effectively walking away from d","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1b3211a5b6d3d0663c746f2959b5c8768d4a504ebd387f82952d6a768b8c1f70"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b35ab5fb143ce1e2011d990b6602c4f911871ca3577dd2d215f83ecdff1d51c5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5088b3735b4c74b5b34dc752","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715135,"date":"2026-04-13T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the government says it supports private property rights, yet it negotiated the Musqueam agreements behind closed doors without protections and consultation with affected communities. That approach is creating uncertainty for homeowners, businesses and investors who rely on transparency and stability. Canadians still feel their property rights are not safeguarded by this Liberal government.\n\nWill the Liberals match their words with action and commit to a full, legally binding transparency agreement and to protecting private property rights in all future agreements?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715135","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the government says it supports private property rights, yet it negotiated the Musqueam agreements behind closed doors without protections and consultation with affected communities. That approach is creating uncertainty for homeowners, businesses and investors who rely on transparency and stability. Canadians still feel their property rights are not safeguarded by this Liberal govern","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54d5dea2c9754503ba8e060292bd37d615cd0934b6092e01043fe1bac1f6cbb1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e215a7a23414f748052b4ddc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715136,"date":"2026-04-13T22:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-22, the lawful access act. Let me be clear from the start. Canada needs lawful access, but Canada must get it right.\n\nConservatives believe in law and order. We believe that police must be given the tools to stop criminals, dismantle organized crime and protect the most vulnerable, especially in a digital world. Today, this is a real problem. Our laws have not kept up with technology. The investigations are stalling. Evidence exists but cannot be accessed in time, and criminals take advantage of the gap. Bill C-22 is trying to fix this and that goal is necessary, but we must be prudent and use good judgment. In fixing one problem, we must not create another. We must not weaken the rights that we have and that we are trying to protect.\n\nMy office has heard from many people in my riding of Richmond Centre—Marpole. They understand the need for safety. They understand the threat of organized crime. They are asking for something simple: balance, accountability and restraint.\n\nOne concern raised by my community is the requirement for companies to build surveillance capabilities into their systems. That concern is straightforward. If we create access points into secure systems, we must be absolutely sure they cannot be abused. If they are, we do not just create tools for law enforcement; we create targets for bad actors. \n\nWe have already seen what can happen. In 2024, a major cyber-attack known as Salt Typhoon targeted telecommunications infrastructure and compromised sensitive communications systems. That operation has been widely reported as having involved highly sophisticated state-backed actors. This is the environment we are operating in today.\n\nThe question is not whether we need lawful access; the question is how we implement it safely and without introducing new risks.\n\nAnother concern raised by people in my riding is data retention. Bill C-22 would require certain providers to keep metadata for up to one year. The intent is clear. When police have legal authority, the data is there to help investigations. That makes sense.\n\nPeople in my community are asking what the limits are. What are the safeguards? Even metadata can reveal a good deal about a person's life, where they go, who they contact and when those interactions happen. To be fair, this data is not freely available to the government. Law enforcement still requires proper authorization, including warrants in most cases. The bill does not allow the collection of content such as messages, browsing history or social media activity under these provisions. That distinction matters, but concerns remain. How do we ensure this stays targeted? How do we prevent this from expanding beyond its original intent?\n\nConservatives will be ready to hold the government accountable for any overreach. There are also serious questions about oversight. The bill allows for ministerial orders that can require companies to develop specific technical capabilities. These orders require approval from the intelligence commissioner but there is a clear gap. The Privacy Commissioner of Canada has no formal role in this oversight process. That raises a fundamental concern. If these powers affect the data and the digital lives of Canadians, why is privacy not formally embedded in the oversight structure?\n\n Oversight must be balanced. Security considerations cannot come at the expense of privacy protections. Both must be present, and both must be strong. \n\nAnother concern is the scope of the bill. Part 2 would apply broadly to electronic service providers. This does not just mean large telecommunications companies. It could include messaging platforms, cloud service providers and email services. In other words, it could apply across the entire digital ecosystem that Canadians rely on every day. This is a very wide scope, and with a wide scope, the safeguards must be stronger. People I represent are asking for clarity. Who is covered? What exactly is required of them? Where are the limits? Without that clarity, there is a real risk of overreach, intended or otherwise.\n\n A third concern is transparency. Under this bill, ministerial orders could be issued confidentially. There would be no public registry, no direct parliamentary approval and no guarantee that Canadians would ever know when those powers were used. That is a serious issue because lawful access in a democracy must not only be lawful but also be transparent and accountable. When significant powers operate behind closed doors, public trust begins to erode, and once that trust is lost, it is very difficult to rebuild. We should be careful not to move from a system grounded in reasonable grounds and judicial oversight to one where information is collected first and justified later. This would not be a small shift. There would be a fundamental change in the relationship between citizens and the state. Many Canadians are concerned that this bill could enable further surveillance architecture if not properly constrained.\n\n We must also consider the burden placed on companies. They would be required to build and maintain systems, comply with strict technical requirements and face penalties for non-compliance. This would affect not only large telecommunications providers but also smaller and emerging companies. We must ensure that this would not discourage innovation or create barriers to entry in Canada's digital economy.\n\nNow, there are strong parts in the bill. It would give law enforcement agencies faster access to basic information, clearer legal tools for digital evidence, emergency powers when time is critical and improved co-operation with international partners. These are tools that police have been asking for, for many years, and we recognize that. However, supporting these objectives does not mean we ignore legitimate concerns. It does not mean we stop asking questions. One resident wrote to me about Bill C-22, saying, \"Privacy is the shield of free people.\" Another resident wrote, \"A free society should not treat everyone like a suspect.\" These are not extreme views. They are common sense.\n\nOur approach is clear. Conservatives will focus on ensuring that data retention is limited, justified and proportionate; strengthening safeguards around technical requirements; clarifying the scope and application of the bill; and ensuring strong, transparent and balanced oversight, including the role of privacy protection. If this bill is to move forward, it must earn the trust of Canadians. Canadians want safety. They want police to succeed. They want criminals held accountable. However, they also want their rights respected, their data protected and their government to act with restraint.\n\n This bill would include a review after three years. That is a step in the right direction, but we should not wait three years to fix what we can improve today. The choice is not—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715136","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-22, the lawful access act. Let me be clear from the start. Canada needs lawful access, but Canada must get it right.\n\nConservatives believe in law and order. We believe that police must be given the tools to stop criminals, dismantle organized crime and protect the most vulnerable, especially in a digital world. Today, this is a real problem. Our laws h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b645a56d788a3e3908de45c560565aea328cfa78d2c4a3ed804b64be30319393"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b181541d554cb46ae736619de704a82679ba424cb842dadea3eafac0e1c340e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-041cf6b206a16a53678ffe41","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715137,"date":"2026-04-13T22:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr Speaker, I totally agree with my colleague that this is a very sensitive subject, certainly to Canadians who care about their safety and at the same time care about the protection of their privacy.\n\n As I mentioned in my speech, there are some parts of the bill that are very useful and would move us forward in protecting our safety. However, at the same time, it is the duty of the House to very carefully scrutinize the other parts of the proposed bill so that we can make sure that Canadians' privacy is being protected.\n\nCanadians want clear rules, they want strong limits, and they want real oversight and meaningful accountability.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715137","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr Speaker, I totally agree with my colleague that this is a very sensitive subject, certainly to Canadians who care about their safety and at the same time care about the protection of their privacy.\n\n As I mentioned in my speech, there are some parts of the bill that are very useful and would move us forward in protecting our safety. However, at the same time, it is the duty of the House to very","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["739d7c6d5710639a332ad81bb1c7ab71cc08548bc0467b15876c79670ae48ef6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d712ad33246828917b297f826bc8f9ee112733c6796a0ac95e9f0b6ce0f0e672"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-364fe5122ce1c495bf11ba57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715138,"date":"2026-04-13T22:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are facing a problem, which is a lack of confidence in the government to protect their privacy and their constitutional rights. \n\nTime and again we have seen the Liberal government abuse its power. I hope that in committee, we can have meaningful debate and careful scrutiny of the proposed bill and, again, just like when we talked about Bill C-8, be able to work with our Bloc colleagues and also come to some kind of agreement or consensus that we could improve this bill, so that we can rebuild the trust of the Canadian people in our government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715138","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are facing a problem, which is a lack of confidence in the government to protect their privacy and their constitutional rights. \n\nTime and again we have seen the Liberal government abuse its power. I hope that in committee, we can have meaningful debate and careful scrutiny of the proposed bill and, again, just like when we talked about Bill C-8, be able to work with our Blo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f097328f6670464b279ead32096aae8f1b79297fe4dd6c9ee4c5b39b28d7675a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-238d9e671d4bca15894dbfbc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715139,"date":"2026-04-13T22:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I really appreciate the comments made by my colleague. It is really a tough debate, but it is worthwhile because we are here to work for Canadians and to safeguard their safety and privacy.\n\nI am sure that when we debate this in committee, we will do our best to work together so that we can achieve the common goal, which is the betterment of our community and the safety of Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715139","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I really appreciate the comments made by my colleague. It is really a tough debate, but it is worthwhile because we are here to work for Canadians and to safeguard their safety and privacy.\n\nI am sure that when we debate this in committee, we will do our best to work together so that we can achieve the common goal, which is the betterment of our community and the safety of Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4b4863951a706ff6eee3c9dc9e97a61b098c8c0c8bef03e84ea3123a71dbbe5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1d253ca0c57d2932e857921","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715130,"date":"2026-04-14T19:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a year ago, a tragedy in Vancouver turned a joyful Lapu-Lapu festival into sorrow. As we approach this anniversary, the grief and trauma remain. For many families, the path to healing continues. \n\nEven in the midst of that pain, we saw the strength of a community coming together, a community with compassion, resilience and strength. Neighbours lifted up one another, strangers became family and Canadians across the country stood in solidarity. Last Sunday, I attended a community fundraiser supporting those still on the road to recovery. It was a reminder that as time passes, our support must not. \n\nAs we honour those we lost, we stand with those still healing, together.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715130","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a year ago, a tragedy in Vancouver turned a joyful Lapu-Lapu festival into sorrow. As we approach this anniversary, the grief and trauma remain. For many families, the path to healing continues. \n\nEven in the midst of that pain, we saw the strength of a community coming together, a community with compassion, resilience and strength. Neighbours lifted up one another, strangers became f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8046335f32b3016ea863d4312a6fd3e8e86cddbbd102824c40994228a331768"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bfe7c3f270c695c56a428a28864dca467651ce5fb08e42591263c3250ce7d57f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45a70f170fbcb459a57e30c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715131,"date":"2026-04-14T19:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government avoids the question, hiding behind appeals and technical definitions instead of stating a clear and substantive position. This is pattern. In court and in backroom agreements, the Liberals refuse to say whether they will stand up for Canadian homeowners. Canadians deserve certainty.\n\nWill the Prime Minister direct lawyers to argue that the private property rights of Canadian homeowners must come first, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715131","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government avoids the question, hiding behind appeals and technical definitions instead of stating a clear and substantive position. This is pattern. In court and in backroom agreements, the Liberals refuse to say whether they will stand up for Canadian homeowners. Canadians deserve certainty.\n\nWill the Prime Minister direct lawyers to argue that the private property right","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8cd24f002b50be25227679d2fc2624332d7bfffcc2f2c0834419c370d71c7246"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84d88cbb5d49b312bd41c680","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715132,"date":"2026-04-14T19:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, appealing the decision is not the question. The government still has not said whether it is arguing that Canadian homeowners' private property rights come first. I will keep asking this question until there is a clear answer.\n\nWill the Liberals make that position clear in court and in all future agreements, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715132","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, appealing the decision is not the question. The government still has not said whether it is arguing that Canadian homeowners' private property rights come first. I will keep asking this question until there is a clear answer.\n\nWill the Liberals make that position clear in court and in all future agreements, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0e7c19ce9bf63e52f48ac0f75878ab43005ad11f0db1c7426e2078885b9822d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a524ccef31874cbff5f216d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715129,"date":"2026-04-17T16:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the City of Richmond has written to the federal government repeatedly, most recently just two weeks ago, asking for a clear commitment to defend private property rights in the Cowichan land claim. Homeowners are worried. Investors are pulling out. People are asking if their homes are still secure, yet the Liberals have offered no clear answer.\n\n Why is the Liberal government ignoring Richmond city council and abandoning the people of Richmond?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715129","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the City of Richmond has written to the federal government repeatedly, most recently just two weeks ago, asking for a clear commitment to defend private property rights in the Cowichan land claim. Homeowners are worried. Investors are pulling out. People are asking if their homes are still secure, yet the Liberals have offered no clear answer.\n\n Why is the Liberal government ignoring ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f13ffc54fa2ea145756a0176e6c4a40b9937642549255d777162a534cb1692db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6fe7a5997f42fd88832e57984ac184ca06ef600c1610506e613486c385a43f5f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7581cb4a72f67a7c7802ff6c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301451,"date":"2026-04-21T15:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know that the justification given by the government is that there are bad apples among the private colleges. However, denying students who attend good private colleges for programs that could help them build their career in the future is denying them opportunities.\n\nDoes my dear colleague agree that this policy would harm our young people?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301451","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know that the justification given by the government is that there are bad apples among the private colleges. However, denying students who attend good private colleges for programs that could help them build their career in the future is denying them opportunities.\n\nDoes my dear colleague agree that this policy would harm our young people?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Private schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","label":"Private schools","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8af61a3636d524919ad1ac98b2c5d8a96dc55a340043403f8a62c7d082d9d8ee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f081a2648c52bf3936b66851","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127994,"date":"2026-04-21T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Ms. Read, thank you for your attendance. In your opening remarks, you talked about the five areas of your mandate: safety, security, efficiency, the environment and technological advances. Do you do self-assessments from time to time? If so, what measures do you use to measure your performance, and what has been your most recent assessment of your performance in these five areas? For example, was performance very good in one of them or very bad in another? What has been the assessment of these five areas?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127994","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Ms. Read, thank you for your attendance. In your opening remarks, you talked about the five areas of your mandate: safety, security, efficiency, the environment and technological advances. Do you do self-assessments from time to time? If so, what measures do you use to measure your performance, and what has been your most recent assessment of your performance in these five areas? For example, was ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","label":"Surveys","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c2970937a5930db1128c90c00b5e30f37b97ee00395271056f53d09585cf0a48"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f215e54b9ab06095931cbdbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127995,"date":"2026-04-21T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"In general terms, can you confirm that the mandate has largely been met?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127995","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In general terms, can you confirm that the mandate has largely been met?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0d019b0d58d34eefbeec57705239578efc707381f26f65c8f1f120cf1df8cef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-470fb7e1ac8e9e51bffbcaf7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127996,"date":"2026-04-21T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. You mentioned that your focus is on supply diversification. This is the committee concerning public safety and national security, and sometimes I think efficiency and security can be in conflict. We know that the CBSA has said that scanning of containers in and out of the country has been very limited. From your perspective at Transport Canada, do you think that's a very acceptable situation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127996","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. You mentioned that your focus is on supply diversification. This is the committee concerning public safety and national security, and sometimes I think efficiency and security can be in conflict. We know that the CBSA has said that scanning of containers in and out of the country has been very limited. From your perspective at Transport Canada, do you think that's a very acceptable situation","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec2f3cb19e024f47631210f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127997,"date":"2026-04-21T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"From your perspective, though.... Of course, the CBSA would have its point of view, but from Transport Canada's perspective, is the limited scanning of containers in and out of the country acceptable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127997","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"From your perspective, though.... Of course, the CBSA would have its point of view, but from Transport Canada's perspective, is the limited scanning of containers in and out of the country acceptable?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945702","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Packaging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"International transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","label":"International transport","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945702","label":"Packaging","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d52c95bec9734fcb5218f07082fff043e713b3247dc10510e1d0ad5ad0fdee67"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d2f4c333c86ffda1ed09fa5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127998,"date":"2026-04-21T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I hope that, for my next question, you won't defer it to another department. My colleague has mentioned that the time for clearance has been a problem at the port of Montreal. Again, do you have a standard for the port of Montreal for the clearance time? Do you have a standard, and if you do, what has been the performance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127998","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I hope that, for my next question, you won't defer it to another department. My colleague has mentioned that the time for clearance has been a problem at the port of Montreal. Again, do you have a standard for the port of Montreal for the clearance time? Do you have a standard, and if you do, what has been the performance?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b196ea185a42c85698301968222d723f3cc0efee410f3ca4a2fa70a315cf2756"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05407b0bbd269f49fd21f12b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1127999,"date":"2026-04-21T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Is there any data about the actual performance? What percentage would have to go for more than four days?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1127999","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is there any data about the actual performance? What percentage would have to go for more than four days?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","label":"Rates","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","label":"Data processing","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","label":"Life expectancy","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c0737d04fa5978b8f68e947f7425af291e7abfeaaf36e328d15dbeec0c7014a1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eab7931c032d0197bf69d3eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128000,"date":"2026-04-21T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"My colleagues have all pointed out that there's a problem with the time for clearance. Are you saying there's no problem?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128000","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My colleagues have all pointed out that there's a problem with the time for clearance. Are you saying there's no problem?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Demining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","label":"Demining","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1adde830159f469f39424306eb9399497181c37b3f2d6006af663bfdb6485f76"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2e772ebb181c2f30319055e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128001,"date":"2026-04-21T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Can I ask that you come back to us with more information in that respect?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128001","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can I ask that you come back to us with more information in that respect?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8dd06fcb702cc518a9ad9b09afb2590746ce0737b1dfdc7962026527104d87e9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25fc278c6a44c998951512cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128002,"date":"2026-04-21T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128002","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b870df2af2e1c53015a59da9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128003,"date":"2026-04-23T21:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. First of all, I want to thank Mr. Dubord for the presentation. I think Canadians would be alarmed if they knew what's going on at our ports. I have a few questions. I have in front of me a report completed by Mr. Peter German on the policing of the Delta port. The information in the report seems to be very serious. Based on your experience, do you think there has been any improvement since this report was completed in 2023?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128003","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. First of all, I want to thank Mr. Dubord for the presentation. I think Canadians would be alarmed if they knew what's going on at our ports. I have a few questions. I have in front of me a report completed by Mr. Peter German on the policing of the Delta port. The information in the report seems to be very serious. Based on your experience, do you think there has been any improvement si","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46d6f2064452c67c3602feccc4023020e946a621195c70ceb99c6321e3fadbef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d03e8f49f3b5d88a6e35f12","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128004,"date":"2026-04-23T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Did it get worse?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128004","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Did it get worse?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1331f6929edd147992b1208d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128005,"date":"2026-04-23T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Exactly. This is not something new. We know this has been going on for many years. My follow-up question is, why is that the situation? How come there has been no change or improvement in all these years? Is it purely a lack of resources? Is it because of compromising security for efficiency? Is it a lack of political will?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128005","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Exactly. This is not something new. We know this has been going on for many years. My follow-up question is, why is that the situation? How come there has been no change or improvement in all these years? Is it purely a lack of resources? Is it because of compromising security for efficiency? Is it a lack of political will?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ff13c6be17788884ecdb166","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128006,"date":"2026-04-23T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. This is a situation that has been going on for some time. Is there any way we can estimate the social cost we are paying as a community for this kind of situation? What are the economic losses, the costs of crime and other kinds of social costs we are paying because of this failure?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128006","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. This is a situation that has been going on for some time. Is there any way we can estimate the social cost we are paying as a community for this kind of situation? What are the economic losses, the costs of crime and other kinds of social costs we are paying because of this failure?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a6970817f76d3bb11ab69a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128007,"date":"2026-04-23T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"My other question is this: Now we are talking about the west coast, but are you aware of a difference between the east coast and the west coast, in terms of inspection structure, staffing models and integration with law enforcement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128007","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My other question is this: Now we are talking about the west coast, but are you aware of a difference between the east coast and the west coast, in terms of inspection structure, staffing models and integration with law enforcement?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f0132d2655d29a832edea3ae4994a9bd41d1d167074e37a39bd76bd303bfa2a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f60b72c7d98d73a9f01c1033","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128008,"date":"2026-04-23T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. My first question is for Mr. Polo. You mentioned a very interesting and inspiring point. If I heard you correctly, you mentioned in your opening remarks that some ports are operating at less than 50% of their capacity. You went on to say that it's not because of a lack of infrastructure; it's because of a structural problem. You mentioned a CBSA monopoly on clearance. Are you implying that there could be some alternatives, such as using private service providers for clearance, instead of relying on a CBSA monopoly?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128008","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. My first question is for Mr. Polo. You mentioned a very interesting and inspiring point. If I heard you correctly, you mentioned in your opening remarks that some ports are operating at less than 50% of their capacity. You went on to say that it's not because of a lack of infrastructure; it's because of a structural problem. You mentioned a CBSA monopoly on clearance. Are you implying t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8d4aa14979468fe17587bf0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128009,"date":"2026-04-23T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"In all your presentations, you have been asking for the same thing for quite some time: tailor-made and flexible services from the CBSA. What did the CBSA say to you? Why are they maintaining their current position? What's the justification for not catering to your request?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128009","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In all your presentations, you have been asking for the same thing for quite some time: tailor-made and flexible services from the CBSA. What did the CBSA say to you? Why are they maintaining their current position? What's the justification for not catering to your request?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035859","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Industrial waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035859","label":"Industrial waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["014bbf7f49e5db238734e502cb4efdf7dc07116f876b9b125078ade0b42f71f5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb9e80be06e8726fad8399d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128010,"date":"2026-04-23T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I'll go back to the first question. Have you seen any other models that work in the situation you described? Are there other jurisdictions using private operators to do the clearance and other kinds of inspections, and does it work for them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128010","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll go back to the first question. Have you seen any other models that work in the situation you described? Are there other jurisdictions using private operators to do the clearance and other kinds of inspections, and does it work for them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["923b1a990e1cc6e3520ffcd24760f9bdb29eadbf3a5ef638bd0e73cc1c7ba577"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0d1b5b3e2f5a22ba4fe8dfb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301450,"date":"2026-04-24T17:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals say that they defend private property rights, yet in the Cowichan case they chose not to argue extinguishment, which is how fee simple ownership has been historically defended. They weaken protections and then claim to defend them.\n\n Will the Liberals withdraw their directive and instruct their lawyers to defend private property rights to protect Canadians, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301450","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals say that they defend private property rights, yet in the Cowichan case they chose not to argue extinguishment, which is how fee simple ownership has been historically defended. They weaken protections and then claim to defend them.\n\n Will the Liberals withdraw their directive and instruct their lawyers to defend private property rights to protect Canadians, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fafd6a768704c86bcc15a4030be2016997564008fd2514174047798e72568ffd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d23ecb1daff8afbf1f18d5580f323260710be120a784a715daf09f51deb4493"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f941e99dd9b252ceb6fd2419","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128011,"date":"2026-04-30T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm going to share my time with MP Gill. Ministers, you've been trying to hide behind the excuse that you cannot comment on individual cases, but something went wrong. You know that the permit was being issued to that person. This is a shame, a failure and a mistake. Somebody has to take responsibility. Who has to take responsibility? Will somebody have to resign, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128011","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm going to share my time with MP Gill. Ministers, you've been trying to hide behind the excuse that you cannot comment on individual cases, but something went wrong. You know that the permit was being issued to that person. This is a shame, a failure and a mistake. Somebody has to take responsibility. Who has to take responsibility? Will somebody have to resign, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c4095a6d6b25c1ab62bad33","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128012,"date":"2026-04-30T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I will repeat my question. A mistake has been made. Will somebody be accountable? Will somebody have to resign, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128012","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I will repeat my question. A mistake has been made. Will somebody be accountable? Will somebody have to resign, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f56faf5fcc275a6c6567dd2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128013,"date":"2026-04-30T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"A mistake has been made and you said that you're accountable. What steps will you take to take on that responsibility?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128013","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"A mistake has been made and you said that you're accountable. What steps will you take to take on that responsibility?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","label":"Excise taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9bbac6c93b9bd7d299de52835c8bb01842eb50b834633fc9aba72baea2790a2a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5233723c69a32a6282dc593c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128014,"date":"2026-04-30T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm talking about you personally.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128014","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm talking about you personally.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-139e89374afa87444711f90e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960983,"date":"2026-05-06T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians watched a poorly staged performance last week when the Prime Minister responded to a simple question on private property rights from another Liberal MP. They could not even pretend to care. The fact remains that the Liberal government issued a litigation directive instructing federal lawyers to avoid protecting arguments for private property rights. That directive remains posted on the Liberal government's website today.\n\nIs this directive still government policy and if so, will the Prime Minister withdraw it, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960983","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians watched a poorly staged performance last week when the Prime Minister responded to a simple question on private property rights from another Liberal MP. They could not even pretend to care. The fact remains that the Liberal government issued a litigation directive instructing federal lawyers to avoid protecting arguments for private property rights. That directive remains po","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1dc90f42787decbe8b36b9cb0c63a74c6a1c241c10ee282244cf30cb7fc86029"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["503ee8de20197bd7345f6834da304bd1b454aba238039133ffe66c69e4cbf282"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52bd08069290a00b49ef7737","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960979,"date":"2026-05-07T17:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, for eight months, British Columbians have been left with silence: silence after a court ruling that raised serious questions about the certainty of private property rights in Canada; silence after repeated concerns from homeowners, businesses, municipalities and investors; silence after Richmond city council sent letters asking the government for clarity; and silence after Canadians asked the very simple question of whether the Liberal government still believes in defending the legal foundations of private property rights in Canada.\n\nAfter all that silence, when the Prime Minister finally addressed the issue in the House, Canadians did not get answers. They got talking points, attacks and accusations of fearmongering, but they still did not get clarity, so let us put some facts on the record.\n\nFirst, despite what the Prime Minister claimed in the House, the Liberal government did not immediately appeal the Cowichan ruling. It waited until the very last possible moment before filing its appeal, long after the Province of British Columbia and the City of Richmond did, which is a clear distinction in willingness to stand up for Canadians. If the Liberals truly believed the ruling created no uncertainty, why did it wait until the deadline had nearly expired?\n\nSecond, throughout this entire controversy, the government has offered no meaningful public explanation of the ruling and no substantive public statement on the implications for homeowners, businesses, municipalities, lenders or investors. Eight months passed before Canadians even heard a serious acknowledgement from the Prime Minister.\n\nThird, Richmond city council repeatedly attempted to engage with the Liberal government. It wrote letters seeking clarity on the implications of the Cowichan and Musqueam agreements and the border concerns surrounding land title certainty and federal litigation policy. These are not just fringe concerns. Homeowners cannot renew their mortgage. The concerns came from elected municipal leaders representing one of the most economically significant communities in British Columbia. What did they receive? It was silence. There was no meaningful engagement, no public reassurance and no detailed explanation.\n\nFourth, when Conservatives ask questions in committees and in the House, the government consistently provides vague and ambiguous answers. They hide behind legal technicalities. They avoid direct responses. They narrow every answer to procedural language instead of addressing the border issues Canadians were actually worried about: whether the government was weakening the legal foundations that underpin private ownership in Canada. That is not the level of clarity that business owners and investors must depend on.\n\nFinally, when the Prime Minister did speak, after months of pressure, he still refused to provide the one assurance Canadians were looking for. He would not clearly commit to withdrawing the 2019 directive's litigation guideline 14, which effectively sent its own lawyers into court with one hand tied behind their back. Let us be absolutely clear: The central issue in this litigation is that the federal government, through litigation guideline 14, instructed its lawyers to restrict their arguments regarding the supremacy and extinguishment effect of fee simple rights.\n\n This directive was issued in the middle of ongoing litigation and represented a clear change of course in the government's line of argument. Rather than fully defending the certainty and finality of private property rights, the government deliberately narrowed the arguments available to its own counsel, creating uncertainty with potentially far-reaching consequences for property owners across Canada. That directive remains publicly available on the Liberal government's own website today, so Canadians are still left asking what exactly the government's position is.\n\nConservatives have been accused of fearmongering for raising these concerns, but let us look at the real-world consequences of uncertainty. Markets react immediately. Investors react immediately. Lenders react immediately. Businesses react immediately.\n\nThe consequences are already being felt on the ground in British Columbia. Montrose Properties has publicly raised concerns about the uncertainty surrounding land title and investment confidence. The local golf course now sits in limbo, uncertain if it should continue to invest in growth or prepare to sell. Farmers who have worked their land for decades are now questioning how to manage long-term operations while watching property values decline and financing uncertainty increase.\n\nA local senior couple has reportedly been unable to sell their property in order to pursue a more secure retirement. Even a deal involving the sale of a local hotel that is not even located within the distributed area has collapsed because of the growing uncertainty surrounding land title and future risk.\n\nThese are not theoretical consequences. There are real people, real businesses and real livelihoods being impacted right now. Canadians are not asking for abstract legal debates. These are foundational questions about confidence in Canada's economy and its legal systems.\n\nThese issues matter deeply in my riding of Richmond Centre—Marpole. Richmond is not just another municipality. It is one of Canada's economic gateways to the Indo-Pacific. It is home to major transportation, infrastructure and international trade networks; logistics hubs; exporters; and entrepreneurs and families that have invested their life savings into homes and businesses. It is a place where immigrants have chosen to build a livelihood. That is why Richmond's city council raised concerns. That is why residents are paying attention. That is why businesses are watching carefully.\n\nThe Cowichan ruling has far-reaching consequences, yet the Liberal government is trying to water down its significance and mislead Canadians about its impact. The Liberals know they made a grave mistake when they gave their lawyers the restrictive instructions, and now they are trying to distance themselves from the consequences. They know that the impact of this ruling is real, yet instead of taking responsibility, they are attempting to whitewash the issue and accuse others of fearmongering.\n\nThis decision will have profound and lasting consequences not only for Richmond, not only for the Lower Mainland and not only for British Columbia but for all of Canada. The government's actions will be remembered as a shameful chapter in our country's history. Canadians deserve transparency. We deserve confidence. We deserve real answers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960979","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, for eight months, British Columbians have been left with silence: silence after a court ruling that raised serious questions about the certainty of private property rights in Canada; silence after repeated concerns from homeowners, businesses, municipalities and investors; silence after Richmond city council sent letters asking the government for clarity; and silence after Canadians a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a3b5887a11db643b6edd03fbfa48d7d33de050d41ca4315886e9f97223e11749"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65f8887382026b1cfd1ed69befd93ec6e5b1d4670ebd6f1b02527d4358e7dbf2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-48532ccf3157387ad90c337c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960980,"date":"2026-05-07T17:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, would my colleague on the other side not admit that the Liberal government did not appeal the ruling until the very last moment, long after the City of Richmond and the Province of British Columbia had done so? Would he not admit that the Liberals gave their lawyers the restrictive directive to tie their hands in court? Does he not admit that they have been silent for eight months and that, still, to this day, they have not given us any clarity?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960980","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, would my colleague on the other side not admit that the Liberal government did not appeal the ruling until the very last moment, long after the City of Richmond and the Province of British Columbia had done so? Would he not admit that the Liberals gave their lawyers the restrictive directive to tie their hands in court? Does he not admit that they have been silent for eight months and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f29ed3882ea4750458400f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960981,"date":"2026-05-07T18:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, first, this is an urgent matter in the sense that we have already felt the consequences on the ground. People in my riding and in the province of British Columbia are worried, and they are already being impacted by the consequences and uncertainty.\n\nIn addition, we have asked for an emergency debate before, which was not granted. This is not a matter on which we can keep waiting, and we have been asking the government to work with us on a solution.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960981","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, first, this is an urgent matter in the sense that we have already felt the consequences on the ground. People in my riding and in the province of British Columbia are worried, and they are already being impacted by the consequences and uncertainty.\n\nIn addition, we have asked for an emergency debate before, which was not granted. This is not a matter on which we can keep waiting, and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88d76ffb03a68c7475438efc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960982,"date":"2026-05-07T18:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is the question the Liberal government has to answer. The Liberals either have to admit they made a mistake in giving the directive, or they have to stand up and say they are still honouring that directive. Either way, Canadians are the losers.\n\nWith respect to the appeal, it is because the City of Richmond insisted right from the beginning on the fee simple argument that we are able to proceed in the appeal for that argument. I thank the City of Richmond for insisting on that argument. Shame on the government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960982","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is the question the Liberal government has to answer. The Liberals either have to admit they made a mistake in giving the directive, or they have to stand up and say they are still honouring that directive. Either way, Canadians are the losers.\n\nWith respect to the appeal, it is because the City of Richmond insisted right from the beginning on the fee simple argument that we are ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcd5099799a526620c2ded99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960977,"date":"2026-05-08T16:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, shoplifting is no longer a petty crime. It is becoming a growing crisis, affecting public safety, affordability and confidence in our justice system. \n\nAcross Canada, police have reported that shoplifting has increased by 66% over the past decade, with annual losses at nearly $10 billion. In Richmond, police recorded more than 1,700 shoplifting cases last year. In the first two months of this year, reports surged another 70%. Businesses are spending more on insurance and security instead of spending on growth. Retail workers face intimidation and unsafe conditions. Consumers are paying the price through higher costs.\n\nCanadians feel abandoned by a system where repeat offenders are arrested, released and soon back in the very same stores again. People are left asking how much worse this crisis must become before meaningful action is finally taken by the Liberal government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960977","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, shoplifting is no longer a petty crime. It is becoming a growing crisis, affecting public safety, affordability and confidence in our justice system. \n\nAcross Canada, police have reported that shoplifting has increased by 66% over the past decade, with annual losses at nearly $10 billion. In Richmond, police recorded more than 1,700 shoplifting cases last year. In the first two months","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["931dbec47f5275b0a047e373c602e2d8d1367576e2b7a99acb53a59fc04e2f81"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3ce75019f58659c956215109de3f26e73e3e6327f0b26f4b262ef79e104c76f9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-185a42b204dc45beffb6690b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960978,"date":"2026-05-08T16:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government says it disagrees with the Cowichan ruling, but Canadians still do not know what exactly the Liberals disagree with. Which part of the ruling are they appealing? On what legal basis does the government believe that private property ownership can coexist with aboriginal title? \n\nHomeowners, municipalities and business owners deserve clarity. Why are the Liberals refusing to give Canadians certainty?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960978","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government says it disagrees with the Cowichan ruling, but Canadians still do not know what exactly the Liberals disagree with. Which part of the ruling are they appealing? On what legal basis does the government believe that private property ownership can coexist with aboriginal title? \n\nHomeowners, municipalities and business owners deserve clarity. Why are the Liberals ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["729e98989e7524fd9f93fa88731b821f236b4d7998ad5ffd70a7d0caf422249b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b58eb71d76acf21d2b30a1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036351,"date":"2026-05-25T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are in denial. Canadians are demanding certainty, yet the Liberal government continues to leave homeowners, businesses, farmers and municipalities in limbo after the Cowichan decision. Conservatives have put forth a motion that would compel the government to replace litigation guideline 14, put private property first in the Cowichan case, secure fee simple property protection in future agreements and publish a plan to protect Canadians' land titles.\n\n Will the Liberal government finally stand with homeowners and vote for our Conservative motion to protect private property rights in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036351","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are in denial. Canadians are demanding certainty, yet the Liberal government continues to leave homeowners, businesses, farmers and municipalities in limbo after the Cowichan decision. Conservatives have put forth a motion that would compel the government to replace litigation guideline 14, put private property first in the Cowichan case, secure fee simple property protec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8b178f0a855373277284c18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036350,"date":"2026-05-26T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal housing minister accused Conservatives of fearmongering over the Cowichan ruling, but the impact is already real and immediate. According to expert reports in March, Richmond property value could fall by 40% because of uncertainty created by the government. Families, homeowners and businesses are worried, yet the Liberals remain in denial, denying the impact and denying that their litigation directive was a mistake.\n\nWhen will the government wake up and restore certainty for homeowners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036350","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal housing minister accused Conservatives of fearmongering over the Cowichan ruling, but the impact is already real and immediate. According to expert reports in March, Richmond property value could fall by 40% because of uncertainty created by the government. Families, homeowners and businesses are worried, yet the Liberals remain in denial, denying the impact and denying th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a8572921eb4986c9519907fa2032cf58d0c20d80b4040835aa93d8541a320a1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["89835a7142fc8a68363c32ff5e12bf73d06d76504a207473ada7bb7df4370642"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80670d2fc9ef7105f02ccb6a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036346,"date":"2026-05-28T16:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Liberal government must reject the CRTC's massive increase imposed on our online streaming platforms such as Netflix, Disney+, Amazon Prime Video and Apple TV, an increase sometimes referred to as the \"Netflix tax.\" \n\nThe government may try to frame this as a technical broadcasting adjustment, but Canadians know what it really means. It means higher costs and another blow to affordability at a time when families are already struggling. The government could not even contain itself from taxing at-home leisure. \n\nThe CRTC has now increased the required contribution from major streaming services from 5% to 15% of Canadian revenues, tripling the burden imposed on these companies. The 15% levy now places Canada among the most expensive countries in the world for streaming services to operate in. \n\nLet us be honest, business and Canadians do not operate alone or in a vacuum. When the Liberal government increases costs, those costs do not simply disappear. They erode the quality of leisure for hard-working Canadians. \n\nThe Liberal government will, of course, avoid answering a very simple economic question: Who ultimately pays for this massive increase in costs? There are only two possible outcomes. Either streaming platforms decide Canada is becoming too expensive and not worth investing in, or they pass the high costs directly on to Canadian consumers. In both cases, Canadians lose. \n\nIf productions move elsewhere, Canada loses jobs, investment and economic activity. This industry is highly mobile. Streaming companies can produce content almost anywhere in the world. Governments everywhere are competing aggressively to attract these productions, because they generate high-quality jobs and billions of dollars in economic activity. \n\nWhy is the government increasing costs at a time when Canada is already struggling to attract investment? Canada already has a growing reputation internationally for being expensive, over-regulated and increasingly difficult to do business in. We have already seen capital leaving sectors such as energy, manufacturing and resource development. This policy discourages investment in Canada and is particularly damaging for major film and television production hubs like Vancouver and Toronto. \n\nIf the government believes companies will simply pass the costs on to consumers, then let us call the policy what it really is, which is an indirect tax on Canadians. The Liberals may insist this is not technically a tax because the money does not flow directly into government revenue, but if government policy deliberately increases costs for companies and companies then raise prices for consumers, the effect on Canadians is exactly the same: Families pay more. Whether it appears on a tax form or on a monthly streaming bill, it is still more money coming out of the pockets of Canadians during a cost of living crisis. \n\nThe Liberals may argue that the increase per household is small, but Canadians are tired of being told every increase is small. A few dollars more for streaming, a few dollars more for groceries, a few dollars more for fuel and a few dollars more for utilities, and eventually, those small increases become a major burden for families already living paycheque to paycheque. The total amount involved is not small. \n\nReports indicate the new framework could extract hundreds of millions of additional dollars annually from the Canadian market, potentially approaching $600 million overall in contribution obligations. That is money Canadians could otherwise spend in the broader economy. That money could go toward groceries, restaurants, children's clothing, mortgage payments or supporting small businesses.\n\n Instead, the Liberals are squeezing more money out of consumers during a cost of living crisis.\n\nWhile the government talks about supporting industry, these platforms are already major contributors to the Canadian economy. Netflix alone has stated that, between 2021 and 2024, its activities generated approximately $6.5 billion in economic impact in Canada. These productions support thousands of jobs: camera operators, editors, visual effects artists, drivers, construction workers, caterers and countless small businesses connected to film production. \n\nThis is especially important for major urban centres, such as Vancouver and Toronto, where the screen production industry has become a major economic engine. Netflix recently opened Netflix Animation Studios in Vancouver, creating more than 450 jobs in the city and bringing significant investment into British Columbia.\n\nThis issue matters deeply to my riding of Richmond Centre—Marpole. Richmond and the broader Metro Vancouver region are directly connected to British Columbia's growing film and streaming industry. Many residents in my community work directly or indirectly in these sectors. In Richmond alone, filming activities take place almost every day of the year. When productions expand, jobs are created. When investments slow, local workers and businesses feel the consequences.\n\n Conservatives believe Canada should be a country that attracts investment, rewards innovation and creates jobs. However, once again, the Liberals are moving in the opposite direction. Every time a sector becomes successful, this government seeks another opportunity to impose higher costs and heavier regulations. At a time when Canada desperately needs economic growth, productivity and investor confidence, this government is making Canada less competitive. Canadians are the ones who will pay the price, through fewer jobs, less investment or higher monthly bills.\n\nThis increase is the wrong policy at the wrong time. Canadians deserve affordability. Canadians deserve economic opportunity. Canadians deserve a government that understands growth cannot come from squeezing more money out of consumers and businesses.\n\nConservatives will continue standing up for affordability, investment, jobs and common sense.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036346","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Liberal government must reject the CRTC's massive increase imposed on our online streaming platforms such as Netflix, Disney+, Amazon Prime Video and Apple TV, an increase sometimes referred to as the \"Netflix tax.\" \n\nThe government may try to frame this as a technical broadcasting adjustment, but Canadians know what it really means. It means higher costs and another blow to aff","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e91983b1974704e0cc093044e2b984a83c08990e4ed1fdef6e961a78d648bfa9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73b1429d330d1b36a2c6b7d94d85ffed381776337cd3dcae7117613a974c196f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af5a7fa44535abc5649d61fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036347,"date":"2026-05-28T17:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let us see who is sidestepping here.\n\nFrom 2021 up to now, we have seen numerous occasions where the government intervened with decisions made by the CRTC. Now the Liberals are trying to hide behind the argument that the CRTC is an arm's-length organization.\n\nLet us be clear. We are not talking about the CRTC's mandate here today. We are talking about affordability and the burden on the people with this increase in levy. \n\nLet me ask a simple question: Does the government agree that this increase would impose an additional burden on the people? Also, will the government support this additional burden on the people?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036347","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let us see who is sidestepping here.\n\nFrom 2021 up to now, we have seen numerous occasions where the government intervened with decisions made by the CRTC. Now the Liberals are trying to hide behind the argument that the CRTC is an arm's-length organization.\n\nLet us be clear. We are not talking about the CRTC's mandate here today. We are talking about affordability and the burden on t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eda174c47d1eebdd97930d5fa1b7697e423d236764e5e9a629897b48c2bd9643"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eca06e560e727a4b520d7a26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036348,"date":"2026-05-28T17:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think my city and his riding are in a similar situation. We have a growing film industry, and we are creating jobs and economic activities in our community, which is very beneficial to people. I think we have to keep this economic growth going.\n\nIf this kind of levy is imposed on companies creating jobs for our communities, I think it will hurt people. We have to safeguard and encourage the film industry, and not have it destroyed by this kind of additional cost for businesses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036348","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think my city and his riding are in a similar situation. We have a growing film industry, and we are creating jobs and economic activities in our community, which is very beneficial to people. I think we have to keep this economic growth going.\n\nIf this kind of levy is imposed on companies creating jobs for our communities, I think it will hurt people. We have to safeguard and encou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9ce3b12a3a515e44ec6cf3081de98165f27f38c2091d763eae0c2364259e654e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bcd030356e65096e467694d8513f6a38aca61f6092be42602d3c34fae7feaea2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4da6725aa6d26a887ceaad2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036349,"date":"2026-05-28T17:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with the comments that my Bloc colleague made earlier that the Liberals are a major threat to the cultural sector in Canada. Imposing that kind of levy with an increase is not going to make the cultural sector stronger.\n\nAlso, I believe we are focusing too much on Trump. We are talking about our own production and our own film industry in our country. Very often, Trump is being used as an excuse or as a defence, which again sidesteps the issue.\n\nWe have to encourage investments coming into our country for the cultural sector, so that those investments and their efficiency through competition will make Canada's culture be more widely broadcast, not by government intervention, but by the market economy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036349","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with the comments that my Bloc colleague made earlier that the Liberals are a major threat to the cultural sector in Canada. Imposing that kind of levy with an increase is not going to make the cultural sector stronger.\n\nAlso, I believe we are focusing too much on Trump. We are talking about our own production and our own film industry in our country. Very often, Trump is bein","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b3f922351bd7031465f1ac44443866892716f5fd4fabc190fb263351b14eafb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4cac2276f3f1585912e3776c98e1a2a1a0e705815340ce42443a3c1c032ffb9d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f566b67f3386d3c794540908","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128015,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Minister, I have some questions for you. They are simple questions, and I hope that I can get simple answers. As my first question, do you realize that shoplifting has become a national crisis?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128015","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Minister, I have some questions for you. They are simple questions, and I hope that I can get simple answers. As my first question, do you realize that shoplifting has become a national crisis?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6694266be348a005438bb13962ffbf0c29f0c1128924725e1c8c4728135cb3ab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1018c337d298be622cf2aa8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128016,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. As my second question, do you know the annual losses caused by shoplifting in the country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128016","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. As my second question, do you know the annual losses caused by shoplifting in the country?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e9603283b87b83b37e8d78fed213b12b1fa25385cb8e59cc59c65d777530b20"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-560e4059334142bd55e6b3b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128017,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"The answer is $9.2 billion. As question number three, do you know how much losses from shoplifting have increased from 2019 to 2025?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128017","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The answer is $9.2 billion. As question number three, do you know how much losses from shoplifting have increased from 2019 to 2025?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7172b34049e154237ec02b05ba99c34d14e0b66621aee1ef0e2adbb423d04bf3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e2cd3f9428ba66b13b63f38","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128018,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"They have doubled, from $5 billion to $9.2 billion. Do you know how much an average grocery store has to spend on preventive measures and security each year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128018","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"They have doubled, from $5 billion to $9.2 billion. Do you know how much an average grocery store has to spend on preventive measures and security each year?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["86296a7630666a9504b29e4776b78f6e0154e3de618b9c12f0a4de5353e6ad23"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13e9f0d993d4133eeaaaca05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128019,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"The answer is $5,000. On average, a grocery store has to spend $5,000 for preventive and security measures. Do you know the percentage increase in violence in reported shoplifting cases?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128019","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The answer is $5,000. On average, a grocery store has to spend $5,000 for preventive and security measures. Do you know the percentage increase in violence in reported shoplifting cases?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["09d1f3b3a38fec813ba342376504be731f21700317344b2c4bd4a12d3b69a82d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5768d530d79b789b7a5ee36c242511c47591df24e28948dd986021fafbbcbea4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbb7ac50f93b46cd013edea1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128020,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I can give the answer. The increase is 76%. Do you know the percentage of retailers who feel unsafe in their workplace?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128020","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I can give the answer. The increase is 76%. Do you know the percentage of retailers who feel unsafe in their workplace?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c902f837245e023baae9df8305e17e3d08ce303ce5a7b4933305a96f1a79528"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3cf3323b5e51e0ddc674fd8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128021,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"The answer is 47%. I will tell you why this is helpful at the end. Do you know that shoplifting is often related to drug use?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128021","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The answer is 47%. I will tell you why this is helpful at the end. Do you know that shoplifting is often related to drug use?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["20d447c74aa805a0ae837aa4005482968fd90f8b18f279879d898babe6e6fd3e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc5bd84f6f82bfb1a7312481","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128022,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Do you know that shoplifting is often related to drug use?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128022","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do you know that shoplifting is often related to drug use?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26c3b2228640280864a7c01fe27a1e8e08ad6321fe6d70dc2b81048b7763e55b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05077cee76ee0c7e83544d6a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128023,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay, that's great. Do you know that the same offenders are repeatedly arrested and released on the same day?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128023","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay, that's great. Do you know that the same offenders are repeatedly arrested and released on the same day?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["221382f45ef58aa28bb33b4a85874f54869f5a5bc0b0ad45e8e88ab023279439"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08926391e46b0066544c7541","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128024,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I have two more questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128024","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have two more questions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-149b754886cb339fd4c5704e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128025,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. Be patient.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128025","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Be patient.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b71d2eb97008b2608430d8c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128026,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I have two more questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128026","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have two more questions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce9aab6cf867171a4bb400fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128027,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Do you know the percentage of repeat offenders among those arrested for shoplifting?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128027","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do you know the percentage of repeat offenders among those arrested for shoplifting?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:344215","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Young offenders","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:344215","label":"Young offenders","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00b6421c2b96dfe47c7ca63c3c3bdc16f34bdc8b10775224a239ba12d7dfdbe7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1b6a71bc671b8ccaa76e1cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128028,"date":"2026-05-28T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"The answer is 18%. My final question is this: Do you have a national strategy to deal with this shoplifting crisis?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128028","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The answer is 18%. My final question is this: Do you have a national strategy to deal with this shoplifting crisis?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5be9db1c88c78ddce66cb4f23a5a4875697e581cb99c489af1719348c0cf1fa6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7b403ea32feed625b5e9de4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128029,"date":"2026-05-28T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I hope you can come up with an effective strategy to deal with this growing problem. It hurts everybody in the country. When there are losses in monetary terms, it affects affordability, because the loss for the business will just be passed on to the customers. Also, when we have such a large number of retailers telling us that they don't feel safe in their workplace, we should be concerned. I raised this question four weeks ago in the House. I made a statement. You are telling me that you are not aware of it. Perhaps it was not being paid attention to. I'm just a new MP, so maybe nobody cares about what I say. However, I would be surprised if you're telling me that you are not aware of the problem. I hope this is something you can bring back to your government and work on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128029","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I hope you can come up with an effective strategy to deal with this growing problem. It hurts everybody in the country. When there are losses in monetary terms, it affects affordability, because the loss for the business will just be passed on to the customers. Also, when we have such a large number of retailers telling us that they don't feel safe in their workplace, we should be concerned. I rai","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-587394e39ca832f67d8531f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128030,"date":"2026-05-28T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"It's organized retail crime.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128030","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's organized retail crime.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5707c83ae6ad6ce6178a740","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128031,"date":"2026-05-28T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I have questions for Mr. Larkin. Earlier on, when we talked about the MOU between China and Canada on policing co-operation, you mentioned three things. Number one, you said that it's general; number two, you said that this is similar to the previous MOUs; and number three, you mentioned addressing the fentanyl crisis. I find that to be very interesting because, from experience, we know that in the past years the previous MOU has not been effective in stopping the influx of fentanyl into Canada. If that's the case, why would we again sign an ineffective MOU and expect that it will bring a different result?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128031","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have questions for Mr. Larkin. Earlier on, when we talked about the MOU between China and Canada on policing co-operation, you mentioned three things. Number one, you said that it's general; number two, you said that this is similar to the previous MOUs; and number three, you mentioned addressing the fentanyl crisis. I find that to be very interesting because, from experience, we know that in th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bdb8c30954d1a6fd4796ca05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128032,"date":"2026-05-28T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"You mentioned a few more areas in addition to fentanyl. You mentioned foreign interference and other kinds of security concerns. Do you agree that, judging from past experience, the MOU has not been effective? You also used the word \"dialogue\". Are you saying that these MOUs are serving a purpose only on engagement and dialogue, and that there's nothing in the MOU or in the co-operation that could actually be effective in helping our country to become safer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128032","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You mentioned a few more areas in addition to fentanyl. You mentioned foreign interference and other kinds of security concerns. Do you agree that, judging from past experience, the MOU has not been effective? You also used the word \"dialogue\". Are you saying that these MOUs are serving a purpose only on engagement and dialogue, and that there's nothing in the MOU or in the co-operation that could","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6b485cf2e74dafd8a34c66a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128033,"date":"2026-05-28T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. Again, in order to make our country safer, what kinds of guarantees do we seek from our partners regarding implementation or what kinds of measures have to be put into place to make it work? I don't want people to have a false expectation based on a useless MOU. What kinds of guarantees are we seeking in order to make this kind of protection effective?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128033","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Again, in order to make our country safer, what kinds of guarantees do we seek from our partners regarding implementation or what kinds of measures have to be put into place to make it work? I don't want people to have a false expectation based on a useless MOU. What kinds of guarantees are we seeking in order to make this kind of protection effective?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bed0a9a65fce684b1fb6a8246d81653431436506f16e8660c1f74fbe5c201cbf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8366ccb9888d5d27175f1d8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128034,"date":"2026-05-28T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Why not take it one step further than the MOU?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128034","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Why not take it one step further than the MOU?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ffeb7fffcd9ed935c27db9d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128035,"date":"2026-05-28T23:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much. I don't know who can answer this question. There has been much discussion about how long and how the suppliers should maintain the information, but here's another aspect. Once the information gets out of the hands of the supplier and into the hands of the police, how are they going to deal with that information? For example, where and how and for how long are the police going to keep the information? Also, when will they destroy the information? There could be different scenarios. Number one, if the RCMP suspects that a person may have committed a crime and gets the information from the supplier and then at a later date discovers that this person is not really engaged in the criminal activities, when will they destroy that information about the person? Secondly, will the person be informed that their information was given to the RCMP, and will there be some verification that the information has been destroyed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128035","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I don't know who can answer this question. There has been much discussion about how long and how the suppliers should maintain the information, but here's another aspect. Once the information gets out of the hands of the supplier and into the hands of the police, how are they going to deal with that information? For example, where and how and for how long are the police going ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd929b217343f94b15b64f1b8520771cd57fba3f0220a8175616587b12b5b4b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0663baf4a3b9f6c54f6bd5145403d05ba3054b97297bc2f2e0e826b4e569c2d0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53ab2db4691655d4134349ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128036,"date":"2026-05-28T23:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"In that case, you're saying that the person who was investigated would be informed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128036","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In that case, you're saying that the person who was investigated would be informed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Internal audits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","label":"Internal audits","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","label":"Inspection","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1db5a333c7397421a86890e88f0abbcc60353d4bbd3209a73eaf25c0f8f7308c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc5de58e661bee7b83c90379","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128037,"date":"2026-05-28T23:45:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"This is not exactly the answer I wanted, but anyway, I will move on. In scenario two of the person who was being charged but eventually was found not guilty, again, what would happen to the information that had been collected through this process about him or her?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128037","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This is not exactly the answer I wanted, but anyway, I will move on. In scenario two of the person who was being charged but eventually was found not guilty, again, what would happen to the information that had been collected through this process about him or her?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ab271376e5acd3cfdcaaadf3fb7d288278060b32de6fc364f645a02bfdfca38"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af51b0bc8f01719b385bbe660f50b15b2132202a33620099673d539f08b51e71"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2cb54f5827eb98a140641cc1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128038,"date":"2026-05-28T23:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Good. Thank you. I have another related question. We are being told that this new arrangement of lawful access is needed because of investigations and other kinds of necessity. I get that, but on the other hand, how can we prevent these kinds of measures from being seen as necessary? At the end, they become measures of convenience because we're talking about two concepts: reasonable suspicion or reasonable grounds to believe. There's a difference there, and I would say the threshold for the first one, grounds to suspect, is lower, much lower than the grounds to believe. Where would one begin and end? I would suspect that there would be grey areas in between. In that kind of situation, how can we be sure that this will not become a measure of convenience for the police to abuse, if I can use that word, in order to obtain personal information?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128038","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Good. Thank you. I have another related question. We are being told that this new arrangement of lawful access is needed because of investigations and other kinds of necessity. I get that, but on the other hand, how can we prevent these kinds of measures from being seen as necessary? At the end, they become measures of convenience because we're talking about two concepts: reasonable suspicion or r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42ce52740929e87e9dd40b20","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036344,"date":"2026-05-29T16:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this morning, we learned that Canada is now the only G7 country in a recession. Our economy contracted both in the last quarter of 2025 and in the first quarter of 2026, which is two straight quarters of negative growth.\n\nThis happened because the Liberal Prime Minister raised industrial carbon taxes, kept antidevelopment laws in place and doubled Justin Trudeau's deficits. Every other G7 country faces the same tariffs and global challenges, yet none are in a recession. It is only Canada. The Prime Minister is now the only G7 leader to push his country into recession.\n\nThe Conservatives would cut taxes, repeal antidevelopment laws, control spending and restore growth and investment to Canada's economy. It is time for the Liberals to realize their policies have failed and to change course.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036344","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this morning, we learned that Canada is now the only G7 country in a recession. Our economy contracted both in the last quarter of 2025 and in the first quarter of 2026, which is two straight quarters of negative growth.\n\nThis happened because the Liberal Prime Minister raised industrial carbon taxes, kept antidevelopment laws in place and doubled Justin Trudeau's deficits. Every othe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2bf1c5dbcf60a9ed3812ce9e255c6ce89c28b6c1364395f9de033f3d43985f0e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["df56f47c5bb6f4f92e15555de7932e06f4c33fa6db57c5fcda6f4f57ec6105ba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-718c02f7adf828379bd19f46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128093,"date":"2026-06-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you. Because of my background in the higher education field, I am concerned about the declining ranking of Canadian universities internationally. That's why I have some questions on those issues. It has been explained that it is not because our universities are doing poorly. It's that our competitors are doing better and are faster than us at investing in research and development. Do you have any data on how our investment in university research compares to that of our competitors, such as South Korea, China, Singapore and Germany?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128093","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Because of my background in the higher education field, I am concerned about the declining ranking of Canadian universities internationally. That's why I have some questions on those issues. It has been explained that it is not because our universities are doing poorly. It's that our competitors are doing better and are faster than us at investing in research and development. Do you hav","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bad7f9a682336bcb6b3d4c6e83fbe7515c8cd493811f2af7e6eb18487a90f21c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e2afd75339eb13e5b5fdae151c67752833e3bd2edfe4eab2bbc690254f9ed30"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3cba9fabf6ec1c131a50b724","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128094,"date":"2026-06-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SRSR","text":"Do you agree that as a country we fall behind in terms of research and development in comparison to other countries?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128094","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you agree that as a country we fall behind in terms of research and development in comparison to other countries?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037245","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Studies abroad","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037245","label":"Studies abroad","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["247549303e26f774117ff38bb7dc522af354f24b344f1edae746af2545c3dc1f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ecb35a8e1a325d69794bcca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128095,"date":"2026-06-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SRSR","text":"According to my research, South Korea invests about 5% of its GDP in research and development, Germany invests 3.1%, China invests 2.6% and Singapore invests 2.1%. Canada invests only 1.7%, so we are actually behind other countries. Because of that, we have insufficient investment in research and development, and the fact is that, increasingly, our universities have had to rely on foreign sponsorship or investment in our research. The concern is that, in many cases, the benefits of the research will go to the foreign countries or the sponsors overseas. We are actually sponsoring our competitors because the benefits of the results would accelerate their research.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128095","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"According to my research, South Korea invests about 5% of its GDP in research and development, Germany invests 3.1%, China invests 2.6% and Singapore invests 2.1%. Canada invests only 1.7%, so we are actually behind other countries. Because of that, we have insufficient investment in research and development, and the fact is that, increasingly, our universities have had to rely on foreign sponsors","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9de914c719b7db4414e0a5bc99cd1deb4a86c433677b422ce06918cf33c7445c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["64ae14f2e6a5eb2913974a5ac4520d58025f7afc1c17f4025a1a7b6ef799406b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78ec397f09c71befdf8ddc31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128039,"date":"2026-06-04T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. Originally, I had questions that I wanted to ask later, but since some of my concerns have already been raised and discussed here, I have decided to ask some of these questions. One thing that I've been struggling with so far is how we delineate grounds to believe and grounds to suspect. How do we distinguish where it would begin and where it would stop? That has been my struggle all this time. Sergeant Gilkes, I'm grateful that you used concrete examples. That is what I need because I'm a concrete sequential learner. I need stories, facts and examples to help me understand. Early on you gave a very good example about somebody discovering that his bicycle had been stolen. You said all the descriptions were pointing to one person, and there were reasonable grounds to suspect and have the guy investigated. Let me give you one real case in Richmond, which happened many years ago, to see how the core suspect would fit into your description or classification. There is a resident in my riding, in my neighbourhood, actually. He was a gardener. He spent lots of time gardening. He had a beautiful garden. One day, he discovered that his garden had been destroyed, so he made a report to the police. He said, \"It is likely to be my neighbour, for the reason that he said he didn't like my garden. He hates me for gardening. I know this because each time I'm gardening, he comes to the fence and yells at me.\" He said that he didn't understand what the neighbour was talking about, but when he stopped, rose and went back to his house, the neighbour would be quiet. Not only that, he said that he received phone calls in the middle of the night. When he would pick up, somebody would yell in a very loud voice, in a different language that he didn't understand. Then he would hang up. In that kind of situation, how would you classify the neighbour living next door? Is there reasonable grounds to suspect or reasonable grounds to believe?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128039","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Originally, I had questions that I wanted to ask later, but since some of my concerns have already been raised and discussed here, I have decided to ask some of these questions. One thing that I've been struggling with so far is how we delineate grounds to believe and grounds to suspect. How do we distinguish where it would begin and where it would stop? That has been my struggle all th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Concrete","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","label":"Concrete","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["85725a63e8f4e015e46286ba9b8ff1df15312531458e59db9866793fe1207007"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7b133007dc489b3aea7a3f62287154701289a0dea3eaa3381b3ce5700fce1404"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67ad3fa1c99b88b164d2c367","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128040,"date":"2026-06-04T22:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm asking a simple question. In a case like that, from the perspective of the police or investigator, are there grounds to believe or grounds to suspect?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128040","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm asking a simple question. In a case like that, from the perspective of the police or investigator, are there grounds to believe or grounds to suspect?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b90e66aa20a5ab028bad9b49efef4580ba1d1e83464e213e2addb0711a96f80"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ad34572a55402ada4c3c5e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128041,"date":"2026-06-04T22:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Well, it's more confusing now. You seem to imply that this is subjective, depending on the interpretation of the investigator.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128041","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Well, it's more confusing now. You seem to imply that this is subjective, depending on the interpretation of the investigator.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf6e6afc29b1a4408ec9157b21bb3ab5183b8cd2178457516988ac9a879a9039"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-afc2fea62a5d0308f24c29c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128042,"date":"2026-06-04T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Again, I find this very interesting. When we are going to create a law or legislation, is it not our goal or our objective to try to eliminate the subjectivity of interpretation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128042","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Again, I find this very interesting. When we are going to create a law or legislation, is it not our goal or our objective to try to eliminate the subjectivity of interpretation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["948fbecc5d215b454bdcef0e6195be4cef4b565438ae1d7b5543cad2b7786d1c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9461beeca2afd2d1ce4ae0da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128043,"date":"2026-06-04T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"You just said that it is quite subjective. Now let me tell you what exactly happened and why I'm so worried that if we are not clear about the distinctions or the definitions, we can create problems. What actually happened was that this person's neighbour is a chiropractor, so when he saw his neighbour kneeling down to work on the ground, he was concerned. That's why he came to the fence and yelled at the person and said, \"Come on, get up. You know it hurts your back\", and things like that. When that person went back to the house, he was so happy, and later it was discovered that the phone call that this person received at night was an overseas call, an international call from another country, and because of a difference in the time zones, he received a call at night from a person who was mistaken and made a phone call to a wrong number from a time zone where it was daytime. All of these things could be reasonable. All these things could be misunderstood. That's why I'm so concerned about the—for lack of a better word—failure to make a clear definition. Now let me ask you about another concrete example. Again you receive a call or a complaint saying that something has happened, and the person gives you a description of five features of the suspect—five things. Then the police are able to locate a person that fits all five features. Are there grounds to believe or grounds to suspect that this person is involved?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128043","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You just said that it is quite subjective. Now let me tell you what exactly happened and why I'm so worried that if we are not clear about the distinctions or the definitions, we can create problems. What actually happened was that this person's neighbour is a chiropractor, so when he saw his neighbour kneeling down to work on the ground, he was concerned. That's why he came to the fence and yelle","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d2b3f1453319c488275dc4ec1fdb3dd962c810bcd9075b08a401458b096ec80"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85eb824c1f00bdb09438976d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128044,"date":"2026-06-04T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"In this case, what the government is trying to seek is the power to not involve the judge. You want the power to get information on that person faster and more easily and without any kind of check. Is that not the case? The judge is not involved in the example that I gave.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128044","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In this case, what the government is trying to seek is the power to not involve the judge. You want the power to get information on that person faster and more easily and without any kind of check. Is that not the case? The judge is not involved in the example that I gave.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-560f74c130e80c191518ffc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128045,"date":"2026-06-04T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Are you not trying to get lawful access to information on the people that you have reason to suspect?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128045","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Are you not trying to get lawful access to information on the people that you have reason to suspect?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e14bf291de2907c2682e0328dda3441564017c8c35fa5653d94dca4688c0668d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a18e57a02cdf619a437a103","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128046,"date":"2026-06-04T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Exactly, so the judge is not involved.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128046","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Exactly, so the judge is not involved.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7e388757bbc644f043408e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128047,"date":"2026-06-04T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"My question is actually this: How wide is the net you're going to open in the beginning?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128047","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"My question is actually this: How wide is the net you're going to open in the beginning?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Internet","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","label":"Fisheries technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","label":"Internet","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efb8f1d614fb86671bac52dfe0cb774b773f2a0c146a22a25aed351093606036"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76f5e95c377a9a55e19d2c0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128048,"date":"2026-06-04T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"This is what I'm trying to get at. I want to see how wide or narrow the net is going to be in the beginning of the process. I understand that when there's further investigation, there are more hurdles, so to speak, in the process, but what I am worried about is the beginning. To continue with my example, five of the person's features fit. Is that reasonable grounds to believe or suspect?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128048","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This is what I'm trying to get at. I want to see how wide or narrow the net is going to be in the beginning of the process. I understand that when there's further investigation, there are more hurdles, so to speak, in the process, but what I am worried about is the beginning. To continue with my example, five of the person's features fit. Is that reasonable grounds to believe or suspect?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42c2baf21b8566f8976b1eaed5dabe1c6b135abb4fa4fa2278fdd0290e40e2bf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-008bb5df1d6e44d6dc8cd81f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128049,"date":"2026-06-04T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Make it up: age, gender, colour, outfit and height.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128049","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Make it up: age, gender, colour, outfit and height.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","label":"Gender discrimination","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efef2c10f6aca73a0bcceb6c9f3093d283f06e5efb518a9a8d4c44bf96ef9713"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0348b0101fb5a7e5b6b5f9d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128050,"date":"2026-06-04T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay, let me go on. I'm using this example to try to understand. I would assume that if this person fits all five descriptions, it's reasonable to say that he is a suspect. There are reasonable grounds to believe that he was the guy. There are reasonable grounds to believe, but if it's down to four, down to three, down to two, down to one, then I would say that perhaps when it is down to one, he would be classified as reasonable to suspect. Five are enough to believe; one is enough to suspect. Would that be reasonable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128050","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay, let me go on. I'm using this example to try to understand. I would assume that if this person fits all five descriptions, it's reasonable to say that he is a suspect. There are reasonable grounds to believe that he was the guy. There are reasonable grounds to believe, but if it's down to four, down to three, down to two, down to one, then I would say that perhaps when it is down to one, he w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d6fa1b0274f38f0bb73a931","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128051,"date":"2026-06-04T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"This is not hypothetical. It could happen in real life. What I'm trying to ask is, how do you draw the line? It can open up a big net that can catch almost anybody with a limited feature that fits the description. How can we avoid that kind of situation from coming up? How can we avoid the situation of investigating somebody just based on the most basic, limited information?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128051","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This is not hypothetical. It could happen in real life. What I'm trying to ask is, how do you draw the line? It can open up a big net that can catch almost anybody with a limited feature that fits the description. How can we avoid that kind of situation from coming up? How can we avoid the situation of investigating somebody just based on the most basic, limited information?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ec10afd80ac0bfcb2a9f581","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128052,"date":"2026-06-04T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I just want to say that I share Madame DeBellefeuille's concern around whether or not you're going on a fishing expedition. I want to ask you another question. Again, my colleague MP Mantle asked a question about why we would use the word \"including\", which opens up the net again. Instead of using the word \"including\", why not use the words \"limited to\"? You want some concrete information—the name, the address, or a few things. Why don't you list those concrete things that you think you need and use the words \"limited to\", instead of including these things and opening up the net?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128052","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I just want to say that I share Madame DeBellefeuille's concern around whether or not you're going on a fishing expedition. I want to ask you another question. Again, my colleague MP Mantle asked a question about why we would use the word \"including\", which opens up the net again. Instead of using the word \"including\", why not use the words \"limited to\"? You want some concrete information—the name","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Concrete","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","label":"Concrete","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11e18cacc5de61bf83b074834128e97a7264421bb1a080e889e81b7b0008c584"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d4a72e5f8234e61688e5655","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128053,"date":"2026-06-04T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Okay. All along, I was under the impression that the information that you are seeking is just primary information, limited and categorized as insignificant—it's not a big deal to have that kind of information. If it is so insignificant, why would you need a law to compel the companies to give you this information? It's not voluntary; you compel them to do it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128053","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. All along, I was under the impression that the information that you are seeking is just primary information, limited and categorized as insignificant—it's not a big deal to have that kind of information. If it is so insignificant, why would you need a law to compel the companies to give you this information? It's not voluntary; you compel them to do it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a88b1b73632dea399f0773e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128054,"date":"2026-06-04T23:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Chair, I have no further questions for now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128054","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I have no further questions for now.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c67c5939ad90ac4fddbf86f0cbdee19cdb2b41f3412950b73c9a0ceac961f59b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a96ff2adacdda85bb30d0b7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084423,"date":"2026-06-05T16:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to recognize Airport Workers Day and to pay tribute to the thousands of dedicated workers who keep Canada's airports operating safely, efficiently and reliably every day.\n\nAs the member of Parliament for Richmond Centre—Marpole, home to the Vancouver International Airport, I see first-hand the vital roles played by these workers in connecting our communities, supporting our economy and strengthening Canada's links to the world. They are the engineers, ground crews, security personnel, cargo handlers, maintenance staff, emergency responders and logistics professionals whose hard work often takes place behind the scenes.\n\nLast year, YVR welcomed a record 26.9 million passengers and handled over 365,000 tonnes of goods. These achievements are a testimony to the professionalism, dedication and excellence of airport workers. On June 25, national Airport Workers Day, let us thank them and recognize their outstanding service and contributions across Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084423","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to recognize Airport Workers Day and to pay tribute to the thousands of dedicated workers who keep Canada's airports operating safely, efficiently and reliably every day.\n\nAs the member of Parliament for Richmond Centre—Marpole, home to the Vancouver International Airport, I see first-hand the vital roles played by these workers in connecting our communities, supporting","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","label":"Air transport industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","label":"Air transport industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9004f5a0c265e51766411fcc5d9c176411e3ae6de7ee85eb0d749b5d35ef0e13"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c5679245a514aa815cdd21c3beb9705afbabffbe5666b32126937eb34571c32"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-024c2204ea066c9af3d040df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086474,"date":"2026-06-09T19:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, 20 years ago, former prime minister Stephen Harper delivered in this House a historic apology and redress for the Chinese head tax. That was a defining moment in our country's reconciliation. It recognized a historic wrong and affirmed the great contributions of Chinese Canadians to Canada. From the railways that united our nation to the businesses, professions and communities that strengthen it today, Chinese Canadians have shaped our country's success for generations. \n\nToday, Chinese Canadians continue to excel in public service, entrepreneurship, academics and culture. That is why I have introduced Motion No. 32, which would designate June 22 as national Chinese Canadian contributions day and recognize June as Chinese Canadian contributions month.\n\n As we mark this important anniversary, let us honour the resilience, achievements and legacy of Chinese Canadians and ensure that their contributions continue to be recognized for generations to come.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086474","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, 20 years ago, former prime minister Stephen Harper delivered in this House a historic apology and redress for the Chinese head tax. That was a defining moment in our country's reconciliation. It recognized a historic wrong and affirmed the great contributions of Chinese Canadians to Canada. From the railways that united our nation to the businesses, professions and communities that st","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87ff56faf7944103fd26598306dcaf052a54aa186b2653667f1a49c4e1425680"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5b1259e53049d3e1ec17607","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128055,"date":"2026-06-09T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I will speak directly to the subamendment. I'm in support of the subamendment. However, before I go on, I have to share some of my observations, and I want to seek your guidance in the process. I think we are going in circles. I wonder whether we can move fast enough to produce a workable, acceptable and balanced piece of legislation for the sake of public safety. My feeling is that right now we have opinions from only one side. We are talking about trying to get a balance. I know this is what we are supposed to do. We have a piece of legislation in front of us. We have different views. We have people who are in favour. Some people who are in a different group might say, no, this is going too far. What I observe here is that even though our witnesses said they are not here to advocate for the passing of the legislation as is, actually they are, because they will be the users and consumers of this legislation if it passes. I can understand that from their perspective of what they should have, the more, the better in terms of authority, power and convenience. On the other hand, we have received lots of submissions from civil liberty groups and service providers, and they have a very different view. They have concerns. They have worries. They have also expressed some limitations of this bill if it is passed. What we have here today, as we had last week, is that whenever we raise a question, we get almost a rebuttal that this is not working, this is not the right thing or this is not the right approach. That is not what I would like to have. That's why I support the idea that we should at least have the Privacy Commissioner present to answer some of our questions. Yes, he made a presentation before, and he was mentioned by other people in their submissions, but that's different from having him present. New questions, new perspectives and new insights have been raised. We need to have a balance of opinions and need to have people here who can give us another perspective so that we can actually strike a balance.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128055","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I will speak directly to the subamendment. I'm in support of the subamendment. However, before I go on, I have to share some of my observations, and I want to seek your guidance in the process. I think we are going in circles. I wonder whether we can move fast enough to produce a workable, acceptable and balanced piece of legislation for the sake of public safety. My feeling ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["221d2a004ddb1217a83118f5e14e58e3cec402aff00d470c2c9e84552eca91ad"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1430d53c146a31020dcba58a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128056,"date":"2026-06-09T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"My suggestion is to be a bit more patient. I'm coming to you—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128056","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"My suggestion is to be a bit more patient. I'm coming to you—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","label":"Therapy","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["035f5fe83109498f351ca4e53ac5f63acc7b182f0108fcbbc34e78e35924dc02"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec72769deec29f98530ced88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128057,"date":"2026-06-09T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Let me tell you more about my background. I'm not a lawyer, so I'm not going to make long speeches. You don't have to worry about that. I'm a family therapist. I'm trained to listen to both sides. I'm used to it. That's where I'm coming from. That's why I made the statements I did earlier.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128057","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Let me tell you more about my background. I'm not a lawyer, so I'm not going to make long speeches. You don't have to worry about that. I'm a family therapist. I'm trained to listen to both sides. I'm used to it. That's where I'm coming from. That's why I made the statements I did earlier.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9074824eb08f011ef3575bdf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128058,"date":"2026-06-09T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Well, the more you interrupt me, the more I have to explain myself. Is that not the case?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128058","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Well, the more you interrupt me, the more I have to explain myself. Is that not the case?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02a1160aa9c9fa656f5bbbe2397151c972f99271ce400dd2f7d11cac7dfaac87"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ae4ca00921904b400dee3b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128059,"date":"2026-06-09T22:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"That's why I said at the beginning that I am in support of the subamendment. I said that last time. We need to have a clear definition of what we are seeking. This is also what civil liberties groups are asking for and what service providers are suggesting. I mentioned last time that we should limit and be clear about the information we are seeking and have a clear definition. With that, I have expressed my opinion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128059","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's why I said at the beginning that I am in support of the subamendment. I said that last time. We need to have a clear definition of what we are seeking. This is also what civil liberties groups are asking for and what service providers are suggesting. I mentioned last time that we should limit and be clear about the information we are seeking and have a clear definition. With that, I have ex","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f01d2c9a069220d377c1f697","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128060,"date":"2026-06-09T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. My colleague asked my first question regarding whether or not there's a channel for service providers to dispute or to not provide. You answered the question. Again, we are talking about keeping a balance here. I understand that law enforcers want more power and more convenience, but on the other hand, other groups, like civil liberty associations and service providers, have other concerns. I want to ask a question about the duty to inform. If a service provider provides the information requested and, after the investigation, law enforcement feels the guy is not a suspect, is there a duty for the service provider to inform the person involved, or a duty for the police to inform?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128060","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. My colleague asked my first question regarding whether or not there's a channel for service providers to dispute or to not provide. You answered the question. Again, we are talking about keeping a balance here. I understand that law enforcers want more power and more convenience, but on the other hand, other groups, like civil liberty associations and service providers, have other conce","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f8b5306ae814c842db46f587e40da275de5df9ae111311e7ef11d70fd75039ae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30650e0e554e680f967da659","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128061,"date":"2026-06-09T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Are you saying that if a person is not informed, he could be kept in the dark forever?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128061","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Are you saying that if a person is not informed, he could be kept in the dark forever?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["250f973fb74110cfcd5a63e127d62a398e26c102f8f280097600b8d8dec1568a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-808f5dfa99514b6bffcdd96b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128062,"date":"2026-06-09T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"When a company enters into a service agreement with a customer, what if there's a provision that says there's a duty to inform or get consent to release personal information as required? If there is such a service agreement between the company and the customer, it would put the company in a conflict, because you're compelling them to provide that information. Is that not the case?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128062","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"When a company enters into a service agreement with a customer, what if there's a provision that says there's a duty to inform or get consent to release personal information as required? If there is such a service agreement between the company and the customer, it would put the company in a conflict, because you're compelling them to provide that information. Is that not the case?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ab9e48612150cabd9656e0dc747bd82e8884f842b3ec7485c6dd070a2f319ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c10b50a4229fc5ab6ec442b2c06c73f1b5d80a0c674632524195adfd42e53cbb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66db37488f92fdb9b57faef8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128063,"date":"2026-06-09T22:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"If I understand you correctly, you seem to be implying that a company has the right to object to or withhold information, and there is no consequence for that company.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128063","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If I understand you correctly, you seem to be implying that a company has the right to object to or withhold information, and there is no consequence for that company.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["735b79296b360d897d5b0e2f67e855be333547f979f29995c75a724c2fe05c32"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-777cecca1581ba0404c177fd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128064,"date":"2026-06-09T22:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"In that case, would it not make your legislation useless? You keep telling us that it's because of urgency, the time and the need for a fast response that you need the information right now, immediately, before the guy is gone. Hypothetically, if a company chooses to delay by not responding, there may not be a consequence. What is the use of the legislation if you cannot compel? You want to ask for fast information, but if there's such leeway, if I can call it that, for a company to delay, what's the use?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128064","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In that case, would it not make your legislation useless? You keep telling us that it's because of urgency, the time and the need for a fast response that you need the information right now, immediately, before the guy is gone. Hypothetically, if a company chooses to delay by not responding, there may not be a consequence. What is the use of the legislation if you cannot compel? You want to ask fo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ccfe00ab12ea68696a77d29431a97b0b5e5e7ed18e7405d54cd3d0ccb0daab0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4929cb8398b1e3e119eec5c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128065,"date":"2026-06-09T22:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I have doubts about the effectiveness of the legislation as written. I have two more questions. In the case of a company that might be operating internationally, if there's a conflict of jurisdiction between countries and the company is bound by another jurisdiction not to release that kind of information, what will happen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128065","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have doubts about the effectiveness of the legislation as written. I have two more questions. In the case of a company that might be operating internationally, if there's a conflict of jurisdiction between countries and the company is bound by another jurisdiction not to release that kind of information, what will happen?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c65bdc1db576dd529d4dd2260443d693bd08496331522a2591ff6f851b011c56"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11dccb5c32354a7ef66270d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128066,"date":"2026-06-09T22:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"The last question I have I raised last time. There's temptation when you're given power: You have the tendency to use it more and more. What measures in the legislation or through other channels would forbid law enforcers from the overuse or abuse of that kind of authority?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128066","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The last question I have I raised last time. There's temptation when you're given power: You have the tendency to use it more and more. What measures in the legislation or through other channels would forbid law enforcers from the overuse or abuse of that kind of authority?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3ac8ec7160955c0de7452c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128067,"date":"2026-06-09T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"You reminded me of another question. Are you saying that you have no estimate for how many times this legislative power will be used? You have no idea how many times in the future this authority will be used.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128067","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You reminded me of another question. Are you saying that you have no estimate for how many times this legislative power will be used? You have no idea how many times in the future this authority will be used.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b31c537d56b2633d7c17c9192cad996ac8c416f6467bfacf9b40e217cd1c84a2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a52d99c4c38ba5a82807d6a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128068,"date":"2026-06-09T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Can anybody answer the question?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128068","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Can anybody answer the question?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08e094af6dc3ca89578a5c8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128069,"date":"2026-06-09T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Based on your previous experience in law enforcement, what would be your estimate? Can you say, \"From my experience, I can say that perhaps five times in the past, I could have applied these new measures in order to facilitate my investigation\"? Just give me some general idea; that's good enough. I'm not asking for statistics per se.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128069","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Based on your previous experience in law enforcement, what would be your estimate? Can you say, \"From my experience, I can say that perhaps five times in the past, I could have applied these new measures in order to facilitate my investigation\"? Just give me some general idea; that's good enough. I'm not asking for statistics per se.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67ecff6ab673fa325a15e8cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128070,"date":"2026-06-09T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I understand. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128070","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e96ac8be3c0de45cfe4ad4d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128071,"date":"2026-06-10T00:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Early on, I asked questions about the estimate of the number of times you will use this new measure if it's adopted. I also asked about the impact of not having this measure or tool in your hands in the past. I was told that there's no concrete information. However, I want to draw your attention to a piece of information, a report completed by the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians in 2025. The name of the report is \"Special Report on the Lawful Access to Communications by Security and Intelligence Organizations\". As I mentioned, this report is as recent as 2025. On page 54 of the report, there is some very interesting information. I would say it's relevant to what we are talking about. I will read it out for you. Note that by \"committee\" I mean the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians: The Committee did not see any clear, empirical data to substantiate claims by Canada's security and intelligence organizations that they face serious lawful access challenges because of rapidly evolving technology. CSIS and the RCMP do not systematically track how often they encounter various technological challenges in their national security investigations.... Further on, it reads: As a result, they do not know in quantifiable terms the degree of impact and overall significance of these challenges. Further down, it has: This is an important omission because as these organizations advise the government and attempt to convince Canadians—particularly those concerned about the potential erosion of their privacy—that new legislation and resources are required to keep pace with evolving technology.... I would ask for comments and feedback on that. Is there any response to that piece of information?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128071","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Early on, I asked questions about the estimate of the number of times you will use this new measure if it's adopted. I also asked about the impact of not having this measure or tool in your hands in the past. I was told that there's no concrete information. However, I want to draw your attention to a piece of information, a report completed by the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ccd5399da4a73398fa787b81b951feaf4e4e2bf6460e3c67e92813240263516e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["368590cd12f539e6b31ed179b1ad5ac2fe621d29ae81da5c8f36ad3f56bb5517"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ed4867c18514113d706c5e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128072,"date":"2026-06-10T00:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Are there any other comments?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128072","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Are there any other comments?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fbb45e89590f0dbce12f16c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128073,"date":"2026-06-10T00:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I just want to go back to the point I made earlier today. I'm trying—we all are—to find a balance, and that's why we have to listen to both sides. You come here to advocate for additional tools that you can use. I appreciate that. I understand that. On the other hand, we also have a duty to try to strike a balance to protect the privacy of Canadians. This report came to the conclusion that there's no substantial evidence to back up the claim that there's a serious lawful access challenge, so that's something we have to bear in mind. I'm not saying that you do not require further measures. However, going back to how we can strike a balance, as I said before, I think that with the loosely defined meaning of \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" and asking for the power to use it, the net is too wide and the risk is too big. Also, the temptation to abuse it is big. I still have some hesitation in supporting the draft as it is right now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128073","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I just want to go back to the point I made earlier today. I'm trying—we all are—to find a balance, and that's why we have to listen to both sides. You come here to advocate for additional tools that you can use. I appreciate that. I understand that. On the other hand, we also have a duty to try to strike a balance to protect the privacy of Canadians. This report came to the conclusion that there's","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["beedfa60915da770aa3bc3de58f945d59f93fc6f21c81ba34302dc4425a10f39"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["059748a42db39166fc0ad552d276820c1d0d93a8f76ae7d1c2cd038d68e548b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-756cb2fdfd843be5cbcc9885","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128074,"date":"2026-06-10T00:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"That's it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128074","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-38937ad0bed9b84c71996d2b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086471,"date":"2026-06-12T16:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, CTV reported that seniors in Richmond Centre—Marpole are sleeping in Tim Hortons because they cannot afford a place to live, while the Prime Minister spends nearly $1 million on luxury catering in his taxpayer-funded aircraft. Canada is the only G20 country in recession. Canadians cannot afford food, rent or housing. \n\nWhy does the Prime Minister refuse to accept the fact that his policies are failing Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086471","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, CTV reported that seniors in Richmond Centre—Marpole are sleeping in Tim Hortons because they cannot afford a place to live, while the Prime Minister spends nearly $1 million on luxury catering in his taxpayer-funded aircraft. Canada is the only G20 country in recession. Canadians cannot afford food, rent or housing. \n\nWhy does the Prime Minister refuse to accept the fact that his pol","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["77a17451902ceef8f775ea962a84bd14002023c2ab1e7decd4e9e837addff12e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d43d0100d15fbff84f49309259da5c303df89b86c87894865c4223c7ccd11e3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-239343b46ad76602391a6837","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086472,"date":"2026-06-12T16:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is seeing a growing homeless senior population. Emergency shelters are overflowing, and seniors are saying that they do not feel safe staying in them. After working their entire lives, seniors surviving on a pension should not be sleeping in restaurants or searching for a safe place to spend the night. Canadians deserve better than this Liberal-made affordability crisis. \n\nWill the Prime Minister reverse his costly policies that created this crisis, so Canadians can afford to live again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086472","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is seeing a growing homeless senior population. Emergency shelters are overflowing, and seniors are saying that they do not feel safe staying in them. After working their entire lives, seniors surviving on a pension should not be sleeping in restaurants or searching for a safe place to spend the night. Canadians deserve better than this Liberal-made affordability crisis. \n\nWill","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da0d11dfbfe2b04301b638cf4886c967eccf0950e7adf91fd302c1ce42464091"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48c08aa5988a2bc7a415b1ebfda13d138b3427277bf275b85c9d0885cabaab27"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fe07e4f83541c4ee98a3041","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086473,"date":"2026-06-12T17:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition signed by nearly 1,000 Canadians, mainly from my riding of Richmond Centre—Marpole, who are concerned about mental health and about suicide prevention in Canada.\n\nThe petitioners note that one in five Canadians experiences a mental health challenge each year, that many youth are affected and that suicide remains the second-leading cause of death among Canadians aged 15 to 34. They believe that people struggling with mental illness deserve treatment, support and a message of hope, not an option of death.\n\nTherefore, the petitioners call upon the House of Commons to support Bill C-218 to exclude mental illness from MAID, and to invest in critical resources in mental health services for Canadians.\n\n I thank the petitioners for bringing this important matter before Parliament.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086473","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition signed by nearly 1,000 Canadians, mainly from my riding of Richmond Centre—Marpole, who are concerned about mental health and about suicide prevention in Canada.\n\nThe petitioners note that one in five Canadians experiences a mental health challenge each year, that many youth are affected and that suicide remains the second-leading cause of death among Cana","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a91782cd95e25b50d22962fbf7a538518c6fb52c82be42eaca2910eea9e20009"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67a1fa3cc289217b58886448","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128075,"date":"2026-06-16T23:30:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. I have many questions, but I just want to ask one question for now, based on the answer given by Mr. Wong to MP Ramsay's question. It's a follow-up of the previous question. I get that there are numbers. You can talk about hundreds or thousands of cases in which investigations cannot be completed for many reasons. You gave the number, but I did not see the connections between the threshold for asking for information and the number of cases that could not be further investigated. There may be thousands of cases where you cannot complete the investigation, but the question is this: What percentage of those dead cases were caused because you did not have the reasonable grounds to suspect in order to get the information? I don't see the causation here. The numbers of cases could be great, but what is the actual percentage of cases that could not be investigated further due to the obstacle that you mentioned?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128075","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I have many questions, but I just want to ask one question for now, based on the answer given by Mr. Wong to MP Ramsay's question. It's a follow-up of the previous question. I get that there are numbers. You can talk about hundreds or thousands of cases in which investigations cannot be completed for many reasons. You gave the number, but I did not see the connections between the thresh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f72584a1fd5f478155beb33638417c9a23289e910fac630b8c7d6d1e6d72c6e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf38a844605859dc582d8c66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128076,"date":"2026-06-16T23:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Wong, I think you have opened up another can of worms. By what you just mentioned, you're saying that one can lead to the other and to many others. This is exactly why we are being cautious. You were just telling me that this is a way to open up the gate to investigate many more people who may or may not be associated.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128076","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Wong, I think you have opened up another can of worms. By what you just mentioned, you're saying that one can lead to the other and to many others. This is exactly why we are being cautious. You were just telling me that this is a way to open up the gate to investigate many more people who may or may not be associated.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac98e402f2f2063971c5b3a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128077,"date":"2026-06-16T23:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Again, the difference is in the threshold.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128077","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Again, the difference is in the threshold.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28f066b3f743468ebbab5a7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128078,"date":"2026-06-16T23:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Right. I want to ask another question because of time. Even if your logic is right and you can make that connection, saying that it's because of the high threshold that you cannot go on to further investigation, that doesn't mean it is a legislative problem. It could be a procedural problem where you cannot get the order, warrant or whatever you need to have to further investigate. It could be a lack of resources. It could be the work hours, or the judge may be on leave, on vacation. It could be many other reasons that you cannot get that kind of permission or authorization in time. That doesn't mean it's a problem in the law itself. It could be a problem in the administration. It could be a problem with procedure or a problem with resources. Why do you need to change the law and not review your procedures so that you can get the information through the legal means faster, in a timely manner, instead of making this big hole and opening up many cans of worms?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128078","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Right. I want to ask another question because of time. Even if your logic is right and you can make that connection, saying that it's because of the high threshold that you cannot go on to further investigation, that doesn't mean it is a legislative problem. It could be a procedural problem where you cannot get the order, warrant or whatever you need to have to further investigate. It could be a l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9509dcf915141844c0069ef40bd0ad707e652bc5b5cd7bf509b6bf431fd18225"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54ad13f3eda5ac3af2ebeafc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128079,"date":"2026-06-16T23:40:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"I will have questions further down the road.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128079","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I will have questions further down the road.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73d69cdc65c7cd79185978d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128080,"date":"2026-06-17T00:10:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Chair, before we go on, instead of relying on memory, shall we find out from the minutes what was submitted at the time? Otherwise, we are basing this on memory, which could be faulty. May I suggest that we pause and find this out from the minutes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128080","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, before we go on, instead of relying on memory, shall we find out from the minutes what was submitted at the time? Otherwise, we are basing this on memory, which could be faulty. May I suggest that we pause and find this out from the minutes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-983a981f1fb150b3ce185dde","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128081,"date":"2026-06-17T01:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Before I go on, I want to applaud Madame DeBellefeuille for her remarks. I think she is right that as representatives of the people, it's our duty to ask questions to make sure that we understand 100% what the bill before us would imply and to defend the constitutional right of Canadians to privacy. I also applaud her for pointing out that the Quebec Bar Association has made a very strong case opposing the changes. I would argue that.... It's something I don't understand. Why would the government dismiss those professional bodies' opinions and recommendations? Basically, that tells me the government does not take those comments seriously. The government feels that it knows best. The government feels that it can do whatever it can, and it is trying to get the most power it can have. My colleague Mr. Lawton has asked some of my questions about international comparison. In particular, I want to ask a question...because we're not talking about general thresholds. We're talking about lowering the thresholds from \"reasonable grounds to believe\" to \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" in ordinary criminal investigations in order to obtain subscriber information or comparable digital personal information. My question is this: Can the government identify the specific countries that you have studied, the comparisons that you have made and the conclusions that you have brought forward? You generally said that we have to do a comparison, but I hope that I can get more concrete information. In particular, I want you to address one question. I suppose that in those countries, as you mentioned—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128081","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Before I go on, I want to applaud Madame DeBellefeuille for her remarks. I think she is right that as representatives of the people, it's our duty to ask questions to make sure that we understand 100% what the bill before us would imply and to defend the constitutional right of Canadians to privacy. I also applaud her for pointing out that the Quebec Bar Association has made a very strong case opp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f7b35cc8e6d8a5f2b81cb0c9179d34b377d02dbcefbcbda6a15a167835ae5e2e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ae1ac7108586b2362419c8bdb429f6ef5fbd4fee8ac760f6702376deb14a9e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4856ba71102d2dd057084c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128082,"date":"2026-06-17T01:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to pick up from where I stopped. As I mentioned, I'm continuing the line of questions as posed by MP Lawton. There was talk about international comparisons and whether or not there are similar approaches to the threshold of obtaining permission. I said before the break that I would like to have more concrete examples instead of a general description saying that they were similar jurisdictions using similar thresholds and that, generally speaking, they're worse than us. Can I have more concrete examples of the countries and the kinds of regulations they may have? In particular, I want to ask this question: How have they dealt with privacy challenges in court? I suppose that in those countries, if there are similar thresholds to what we are proposing, there could have been constitutional challenges or court challenges. How have they dealt with those challenges?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128082","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to pick up from where I stopped. As I mentioned, I'm continuing the line of questions as posed by MP Lawton. There was talk about international comparisons and whether or not there are similar approaches to the threshold of obtaining permission. I said before the break that I would like to have more concrete examples instead of a general description saying that they we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Concrete","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","label":"Concrete","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6cdf4fe3656da171474a763f4a03fea3aad500e008fde82ecc2ddd0c348352b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-217896b341276404407cc30e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128083,"date":"2026-06-17T01:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Can anybody supply more information?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128083","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Can anybody supply more information?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ceb6cdbfa3984428b374eb8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128084,"date":"2026-06-17T02:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"In other words, we're breaking into new ground. We are doing the experiment, and we do not know what the end result is yet. Is it fair to say that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128084","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In other words, we're breaking into new ground. We are doing the experiment, and we do not know what the end result is yet. Is it fair to say that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016066","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Biomedical experiments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016066","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Biomedical experiments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016066","label":"Biomedical experiments","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3368c8e2068d309a4b9c8390d4964314a61ba2a71c2bc3cab338d10119b0bd58"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa85319f5c11cc105e89306d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128085,"date":"2026-06-17T02:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much. Now I want to turn from international to domestic. Spencer was just mentioned. I'm not a lawyer. I'm trying to educate myself by studying some of the cases. In my research, of course, the Spencer case came up, but I tend to feel that you and I may have come to different conclusions. In the Spencer case, as I found out, the police were investigating the sharing of child pornography over the Internet. The police obtained an IP address and then asked the service provider for the subscriber's name and address without a warrant. I think that was the case, right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128085","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Now I want to turn from international to domestic. Spencer was just mentioned. I'm not a lawyer. I'm trying to educate myself by studying some of the cases. In my research, of course, the Spencer case came up, but I tend to feel that you and I may have come to different conclusions. In the Spencer case, as I found out, the police were investigating the sharing of child pornogr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7cc3e36f9d0b5023da4ca039","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128086,"date":"2026-06-17T02:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Yes. I think, also, at the hearing, a key question was asked, which was this: Should a person have a reasonable expectation of privacy regarding subscriber information linking an IP address to their identity? I think the Supreme Court's ruling was yes, right? The Supreme Court felt there should be a reasonable expectation of privacy for subscriber information.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128086","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes. I think, also, at the hearing, a key question was asked, which was this: Should a person have a reasonable expectation of privacy regarding subscriber information linking an IP address to their identity? I think the Supreme Court's ruling was yes, right? The Supreme Court felt there should be a reasonable expectation of privacy for subscriber information.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cebab5c6b9712412072ebadfed3abb8ba248dcf1ce98c1118fbec4d94d1ffc8a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e3cff2162c30918fcd0e650a270d98f282748dfaddbe86c545380165475b9ecc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e6f4f6a360c75110d7646d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128087,"date":"2026-06-17T02:15:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Exactly. As you said, the court went on to say that the subscriber information is not really a person's name and address. When linked to an IP address, it views who was using the Internet connections and, therefore, provides the key to uncovering a person's online activities and so on. I think the court's ruling said that, instead of lowering the threshold, perhaps it's just the opposite: It should be better protected. The case established subscriber information and just the conditions of privacy protection. I think that's the first case. Then, of course, I found another case from 2024. I'm not sure if I'm pronouncing it correctly, but it's the Bykovets case. I think, again, you know about that case, and I think the court, 10 years after the Spencer case, went on to ask another question related to the new technology. The question asked was this: Is there a reasonable expectation of privacy in an IP address itself? Again, the Supreme Court's ruling was yes. The court also went on to say that modern Internet use leaves detailed digital traces. Once an IP address is linked to other information, it can reveal a lengthy, detailed picture of any individual's activities. Accordingly, the court mentioned that technological developments have greatly increased the amount of personal information that can be inferred from digital identifiers. Then, rather than reducing privacy protection because technology makes surveillance easier, the court held that constitutional protections must adapt to preserve meaningful privacy in the digital age. Putting all this together, my question is this: Now that the Supreme Court has made it clear that subscribers' information and IP addresses reveal far more than technical data.... It's not just phone-book information anymore—they can expose a detailed portrayal of a person's private life. If the court has recognized increasing privacy interests in digital information, what evidence do you have to conclude that reducing the legal threshold from \"reasonable grounds to believe\" to \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" is consistent with section 8 of the charter?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128087","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Exactly. As you said, the court went on to say that the subscriber information is not really a person's name and address. When linked to an IP address, it views who was using the Internet connections and, therefore, provides the key to uncovering a person's online activities and so on. I think the court's ruling said that, instead of lowering the threshold, perhaps it's just the opposite: It shoul","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["90943b8e29ca38bcfabe1b6eb48d8749f7decdf7822d038c96bd97db46d0736c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e5d8d8aa7aa916e961fd35494063fafacd8d3aa0c45ae0da2a6a15b37e1edb3c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0aad27819e27c509d9cc62b2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128088,"date":"2026-06-17T02:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Not quite. Even though you said that it's not lowering the threshold, in fact it is. You're making a distinction between reasonable grounds to suspect and reasonable grounds to believe. You have made that distinction. At the end, you're choosing the lower threshold, which is to suspect rather than to believe. Actually, you do lower the threshold. Are you saying that you don't expect there will be some constitutional challenge if this threshold is adopted?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128088","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Not quite. Even though you said that it's not lowering the threshold, in fact it is. You're making a distinction between reasonable grounds to suspect and reasonable grounds to believe. You have made that distinction. At the end, you're choosing the lower threshold, which is to suspect rather than to believe. Actually, you do lower the threshold. Are you saying that you don't expect there will be ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87a58b82e9006f806daccd319377450f2443e0ac05b6e1795bd74e792f30495e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99ca2ad8d736cca12b015d7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128089,"date":"2026-06-17T02:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Do you anticipate that this will be challenged in court?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128089","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you anticipate that this will be challenged in court?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3890a334c8691ac5130a4a20c5eaafae69157ea278903976fdc0d47538c4019f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2e41897cf1bc1e203f834d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128090,"date":"2026-06-17T02:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Assuming that in the future, this legislation is challenged in court, what will be the line of defence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128090","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Assuming that in the future, this legislation is challenged in court, what will be the line of defence?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a944653d2ec37bb8a213144815b65d272f6adb35b22188c85d2ed04ff366405"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-530ab23cccd7105f0a3e6151","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128091,"date":"2026-06-17T02:25:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you. Those are my questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128091","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Those are my questions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75b46f317db47907e5bd8ce9","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1148668,"date":"2026-06-17T16:22:18+00:00","title":"An Act to amend the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act and to make a related amendment to the Criminal Code","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"An Act to amend the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act and to make a related amendment to the Criminal Code","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-289","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-289","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1148668","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"An Act to amend the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act and to make a related amendment to the Criminal Code","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22daad58a76b1abe6715b7e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088311,"date":"2026-06-17T21:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C‐289, An Act to amend the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act and to make a related amendment to the Criminal Code.\n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, I rise to introduce my first private member's bill, the stopping supply to save lives act. I hope Canadians will come to know this as Emmy's legacy, in memory of Emmy Liu, a 14-year-old girl who lost her life to a fentanyl overdose in January 2025. Since her death, her mother has shown remarkable courage in advocating for stronger action against this deadly poison.\n\n Emmy had her whole life ahead of her. Instead, it was cut short because criminals sold her poison that had already killed tens of thousands of Canadians. In principle, those who profit from trafficking and producing large quantities of synthetic opioids should face serious consequences. Emmy's legacy can be more than a tragedy. It can be a call to strengthen penalties for the most serious drug offences and to protect Canadian families from experiencing the same loss.\n\n In honour of all of the lives lost, I ask all members of this House to support this legislation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088311","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C‐289, An Act to amend the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act and to make a related amendment to the Criminal Code.\n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, I rise to introduce my first private member's bill, the stopping supply to save lives act. I hope Canadians will come to know this as Emmy's legacy, in memory of Emmy Liu, a 14-year-old girl who lost her life to a fentanyl ov","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["56089a71774c64f96deab831bdc1d8c2aebab24001e16291714b8dd52e6cd242"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ef4abaada4b0fb59cf22d53ef1b8282441c0ea8f4def379f50c67d131001fd4a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c2c7576f37e2a9f598892cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088312,"date":"2026-06-18T01:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to express serious concerns with part 2 of Bill C‐22 and to oppose the motion in Government Business No. 13. Let me be clear from the outset: Conservatives believe that law enforcement must have modern tools to combat organized crime, fentanyl trafficking, child exploitation, terrorism and foreign interference in a digital age. These types of rampant criminality cannot go unattended.\n\nThat is why Conservatives have taken a constructive approach to Bill C‐22 and have indicated that we are prepared to support part 1 of the bill, subject to several changes, clarifications and amendments, even though we recognize that part 1 is not perfect. In fact, Conservatives have repeatedly proposed at committee that the bill should be split, allowing part 1 to proceed, while part 2 undergoes more thorough study and scrutiny.\n\n Part 2 would create an entirely new framework governing electronic service providers and compelled assistance. It is this portion of the legislation that has attracted substantial criticism from privacy experts, constitutional experts, technology companies and civil liberties organizations. If the government believes those concerns are unfounded, then it should welcome scrutiny, not shut it down.\n\nWhen legislation grants new surveillance powers, expands access to personal information and creates new obligations for communication providers, Parliament has a duty to scrutinize those powers carefully, deliberately and transparently. That duty becomes even more important when respected legal, privacy, constitutional and technology experts continue to warn that significant concerns remain unresolved. However, instead of allowing Parliament to complete that scrutiny, the Liberal government has brought forward the motion to force this legislation through before Parliament has properly completed its work. That is precisely backwards.\n\n When respected experts continue to identify unresolved concerns, Parliament's responsibility is to examine those concerns, not to declare that the discussion is over. Throughout committee consideration of Bill C‐22, witness after witness identified concerns regarding privacy protections, judicial oversight, transparency and the impact on personal and business communications.\n\n The Office of the Privacy Commissioner has stated that amendments remain necessary to strengthen privacy protections within the legislation. That alone should give Parliament pause before debate is cut short. The Privacy Commissioner was denied the opportunity to appear during clause-by-clause consideration, by Liberal members at the public safety and national security committee, despite being Canada's foremost independent authority on privacy rights.\n\nThe Canadian Bar Association has also raised concerns regarding the legislation. In its submission on Bill C‐22, it warned that certain provisions expand state powers while reducing traditional safeguards and questioned whether the government had adequately demonstrated the necessity and proportionality of some of the measures being proposed. Those concerns deserve answers before debate is terminated.\n\nThe Canadian Civil Liberties Association has seemingly warned that aspects of Bill C‐22 raise significant constitutional and civil liberties concerns. It has argued that broad surveillance powers require proportionally strong safeguards, oversight and accountability measures. That principle should not be controversial. Throughout Canadian history, Parliament has recognized that extraordinary powers must be accompanied by extraordinary safeguards. Canadians expect no less.\n\nResearchers from The Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto have also raised concerns regarding the scope and operation of certain powers contained in Bill C‐22. The Citizen Lab is internationally recognized as one of the world's leading research institutes on digital surveillance, cybersecurity and human rights. Its work has been cited by governments, courts, journalists and academics around the world. When researchers of that calibre identify concerns with surveillance legislation, Parliament should carefully examine those concerns rather than rush the bill through the legislative process.\n\nEven major technology companies and communications providers have expressed important concerns about the legislation. Their concerns are not about avoiding the law; they relate to whether legislation intended to improve public safety could inadvertently weaken cybersecurity, undermine encryption or create new vulnerabilities for law-abiding Canadians. Canadians deserve confidence that legislation intended to improve public safety would not inadvertently compromise digital security. This is where Government Business No. 13 becomes especially troubling.\n\nThe government is effectively asking Parliament to conclude that the debate is finished, but the debate is not finished. In fact, it has barely begun. The Minister of Public Safety has changed his position on part 2. He began by resisting amendments, but after hearing the extensive evidence provided by the opposition and expert witnesses on why part 2 required amendments, he agreed that changes were necessary. However, by shutting down further clause-by-clause debate before we have even begun considering part 2, the government would be using the motion to effectively prevent the very amendments that the minister himself has acknowledged are necessary.\n\nWith the proposed shutting down of further clause-by-clause debate, experts, industry and parliamentarians continue to raise concerns. The Liberal government is free to disagree with those concerns, but disagreement is not justification for shutting down parliamentary scrutiny. The purpose of Parliament is not to rubber-stamp legislation but to democratically challenge assumptions, test arguments, identify flaws and improve laws before they affect millions of Canadians. Government Business No. 13 would disregard democratic process and parliamentary responsibility.\n\nThe Liberal government argues that the legislation is urgently needed because Canada has fallen behind in modernizing lawful-access authorities. The Liberal government has a long history of asking for extraordinary powers in the name of urgency. Parliament's responsibility is to determine whether those powers are truly necessary, proportionate and accountable, before they are granted, not after they have already been exercised. This is where scrutiny matters the most.\n\nConservatives believe that Canadians deserve both security and freedom. Canadians can have effective law enforcement while safeguarding the constitutional rights that define our democracy. Public trust is essential, and it is strengthened when security measures are carefully designed, properly supervised and transparently justified. Public trust is weakened when governments appear eager to curtail debate before legitimate and constitutional concerns have been addressed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088312","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to express serious concerns with part 2 of Bill C‐22 and to oppose the motion in Government Business No. 13. Let me be clear from the outset: Conservatives believe that law enforcement must have modern tools to combat organized crime, fentanyl trafficking, child exploitation, terrorism and foreign interference in a digital age. These types of rampant criminality cannot ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fee50730b91434fc6d5628fa986df1657103745babef2dfab8a32899b5969dfd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["66f0fd3425c72f1ad510debf72aad4e8cd84d15d1d4b6075209389ed67f71f14"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da3c57002ff16da8d400a28b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088313,"date":"2026-06-18T01:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, with a bill that is so complex and complicated, we need time to understand it thoroughly and assess each portion of the bill so that we can address the concerns being raised and the questions being asked by the public and by professionals. I want to ask whether the member on the other side agrees that it is not democratic that we had not even had the chance to start debating clause-by-clause on part 2, and the government chose to shut down the discussion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088313","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, with a bill that is so complex and complicated, we need time to understand it thoroughly and assess each portion of the bill so that we can address the concerns being raised and the questions being asked by the public and by professionals. I want to ask whether the member on the other side agrees that it is not democratic that we had not even had the chance to start debating clause-","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ac54a0527ac07522225646c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088314,"date":"2026-06-18T01:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Chair, I have to point out that we cannot replace necessity with convenience. It may be convenient for the government to shut down debate in the name of urgency or in the name of saving time. As I mentioned, with a bill that is so complex and sometimes difficult to understand thoroughly, we need the time to do thorough work. It is necessary. It is not just for the sake of convenience that we shut it down.\n\nI also want to point out that someone made a very interesting observation, which was that the Conservatives, the Bloc, the NDP and the Green Party, all parties that are very different on the political spectrum, are united in opposing Bill C‐22. That is rare. With that kind of a situation, it is obvious that something is wrong. In this case, the Liberal government is wrong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088314","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I have to point out that we cannot replace necessity with convenience. It may be convenient for the government to shut down debate in the name of urgency or in the name of saving time. As I mentioned, with a bill that is so complex and sometimes difficult to understand thoroughly, we need the time to do thorough work. It is necessary. It is not just for the sake of convenience that we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04bcd5d4b326f1b3a5da5dbd938e249e2d7e35a01d3a431a0bd87cab8a4a9f2a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-478c0b9fb069c63e66ac33a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088315,"date":"2026-06-18T01:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Chak Au","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the government is known for its intention, its seeking of power and its expansion of its power. Therefore, I suppose that through shutting down this debate, the government wants to have more power, and it wants to do what it wants to do without really caring about the different views being expressed by the public and by professionals.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088315","member_id":"bc-mp-123608","member_name":"Chak Au","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the government is known for its intention, its seeking of power and its expansion of its power. Therefore, I suppose that through shutting down this debate, the government wants to have more power, and it wants to do what it wants to do without really caring about the different views being expressed by the public and by professionals.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7450cf9fdfc6fe0d021dd49cf5f379fb852668fc37d61fc20f38a2419afae745"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d7fd6bf17c982febb42874b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70516,"date":"2026-01-27T19:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Skeena—Bulkley Valley is ready to build. Conservatives worked with the government to pass Bill C-5 so that the Prime Minister could approve projects quickly while cutting red tape. However, after a year of speeches, no single project has been approved and no barriers have been removed.\n\nSkeena—Bulkley Valley is already contributing and is asking for a chance to invest, build and work. The Stewart World Port expansion, the Telkwa coal project, the Endako mine and Terrace industrial lands are real projects that mean real jobs, stronger businesses and stable futures for families in our regions.\n\nWhen we build and export, incomes rise and life becomes more affordable. That is why, today, we introduced a motion to pass a Canadian sovereignty act that would repeal federal measures that block and punish project development, would reward hard-working Canadians who build and invest, and would protect Canadian innovation and our economic sovereignty.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70516","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Skeena—Bulkley Valley is ready to build. Conservatives worked with the government to pass Bill C-5 so that the Prime Minister could approve projects quickly while cutting red tape. However, after a year of speeches, no single project has been approved and no barriers have been removed.\n\nSkeena—Bulkley Valley is already contributing and is asking for a chance to invest, build and work.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["25c901c5685f475d8a3085d99b61c1afedacfaac7aa5fd0c79d9f41f5bf03341"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["37507785ab2ab1b1a346089ed341e95701fee6bd877b6818d82560a01384bb28"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6d0a3907d7eadcb64b25757","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86081,"date":"2026-02-02T18:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague's speech was correct. As we know, the Conservatives are not putting up many speakers here, but we would like to get this issue resolved.\n\n As a new MP, I have heard all of the stories here about the victims, the testimony and what our citizens are going through, but the Liberals seem to want to debate the rights of offenders or how we should not debate the bill. All of us want to debate it to be fair to all Canadians.\n\nCan the member expand on exactly what the protecting victims act would do, and how we would get there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86081","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague's speech was correct. As we know, the Conservatives are not putting up many speakers here, but we would like to get this issue resolved.\n\n As a new MP, I have heard all of the stories here about the victims, the testimony and what our citizens are going through, but the Liberals seem to want to debate the rights of offenders or how we should not debate the bill. All of us","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca6ab25d8d40058de2d6015196a5d0ac905a3821a562e26fd00444b9a9dd8c55"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7df2284d7d3953dccf70832f2c8ed4bfa0c6ed15c0f14cbdb246fd08435df69f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd37c6c109eb5f3423a63ea8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86082,"date":"2026-02-02T20:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am presenting two petitions today.\n\nFirst, I rise again to present another petition on behalf of the residents of Skeena—Bulkley Valley, specifically law-abiding citizens who do not agree with the Liberals' failing confiscation plan of firearms. Provinces and police associations do not agree with it. Even the Parliamentary Budget Officer has estimated that the program will cost over $750 million of taxpayer money.\n\nThe petitioners of Skeena—Bulkley Valley want the government to stop going after law-abiding citizens and to go after criminals instead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86082","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am presenting two petitions today.\n\nFirst, I rise again to present another petition on behalf of the residents of Skeena—Bulkley Valley, specifically law-abiding citizens who do not agree with the Liberals' failing confiscation plan of firearms. Provinces and police associations do not agree with it. Even the Parliamentary Budget Officer has estimated that the program will cost over","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5c9a202c230758912a4dca666a8d2d8008b275e5b083536c3d41e5750ccc1d5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e473496a00904c3f61ba530f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86083,"date":"2026-02-02T20:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I rise to present on behalf of the residents of Skeena—Bulkley Valley is asking the House never to expand MAID to people suffering from mental illness. It is clear that the people of Skeena—Bulkley Valley believe that Canadians with mental illness should be met with supports, treatment and hope.\n\nMental illness is treatable, and recovery is possible. People who are suffering should be offered suicide prevention treatment, not assisted dying.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86083","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I rise to present on behalf of the residents of Skeena—Bulkley Valley is asking the House never to expand MAID to people suffering from mental illness. It is clear that the people of Skeena—Bulkley Valley believe that Canadians with mental illness should be met with supports, treatment and hope.\n\nMental illness is treatable, and recovery is possible. People who are","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1af3a0192e43f0cfabff69c0cf99279751f2e8848d0ef857999dceedc8bd55cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e02d48ee108b3571dfc2bb55890e17cbf9a1a410149b5e3f7be26236ec52b624"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b4c3b2670351585d4ead445","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86084,"date":"2026-02-02T23:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be dividing my time with the member for Moose Jaw—Lake Centre—Lanigan.\n\nWe are debating Bill C-19, the Canada groceries and essentials benefit act. Listening to the speeches all day today, the debates, I cannot help but ask, why this bill? It is mainly for two reasons: first, Canadians cannot afford to pay their bills and they cannot afford to buy groceries; and second, this was a promise made by the Liberal government to reduce grocery prices. \n\nThe name of this bill is a bit misleading because it does not affect grocery prices; this is actually a tax rebate. In fact, if we look at what is happening in Canada, the opposite is happening in terms of what the Liberal government promised around getting control of grocery inflation. In fact, the opposite is happening. Grocery costs have gone up and are still going up. Inflation did rise to 2.4% from 2.2%, but groceries rose to 5%. In that respect, Canada, in terms of inflation, especially groceries, is the best performing country because Canadians cannot afford groceries. This is crazy.\n\nI understand what it means not to be able to afford groceries. I was a councillor and a chief councillor for a small first nations band on the west coast of B.C, and it was one of my goals to make sure that people could afford groceries and pay their bills and build their own lives without government help. For members who do not know anything about the Indian Act, the Indian Act is basically built on government funding, and a lot of first nations leaders try to get away from that dependence.\n\nHowever, in this case here, Conservatives will be supporting Bill C-19 mainly to try to stop some of the pain Canadians are going through. An example of some of the pain Canadians are going through is that one in five Canadians have skipped paying bills to buy food in Canada. Some Canadians are skipping meals because they cannot afford them. They are making decisions on whether or not to keep the lights on or to feed their children or themselves. This is in Canada.\n\nWhen they are not celebrating food banks, the Liberals are actually celebrating this tax rebate. I am trying to get the logic of this down. They are celebrating the fact that they are imposing hidden taxes on Canadians, and they want Canadians to be grateful that they are going to give some of that money back. In my riding, $1,800 will not cover rent for one month. What these Liberals are celebrating today is $10 a month. They want Canadians to be grateful, yet they are not even fulfilling their election promise.\n\nThe Prime Minister himself said he should be judged by prices at the grocery store. This is not going to affect prices at the grocery store. It is a stopgap measure for one year. Those middle-income families, if they qualify, will maybe get a cheque, maybe. However, like everything else, there are qualifications.\n\nI have heard some of my colleagues here saying that we do not mind when Liberals steal Conservative ideas. In fact, the Liberals got elected on a Conservative platform: axe the tax, build pipelines and negotiate with Trump down in the United States. However, on all accounts, four or five of those promises could not be fulfilled by the Liberal government. I do not know why it could not fulfill those promises. Maybe it could not fulfill them, or maybe, by choice, it would not fulfill them.\n\nHere is another broken promise: They were saying they were going to address affordability at the grocery store. The question arises in the same context: Do the Liberals want to address grocery prices? Will they or, by choice, will they not?\n\n I have heard it said many times that two million people a month visit food banks in Canada and 700,000 of the people served are children. That is heartbreaking, especially when we consider that a portion of that population is middle-class income earners, people with jobs and mortgages, who 10 years ago did not have to worry about a tax rebate or skipping a bill. In today's day and age, when people skip a bill, there are consequences for them: a mortgage going into default or a car being taken away. It is happening because people have to make a decision on whether or not they should eat.\n\n What the Liberal government has not said is that out of the 40 million people living in Canada, there are 10 million people living with food insecurity, meaning that they are not sure where their next meal is going to come from. I cannot help but be surprised by that as a first nations leader, coming from an area where we actually resolved unemployment and resolved the economy by supporting LNG, mining and forestry.\n\nI came to the House of Commons and found out that all of Canada is in the same boat that we, as first nations, were in 20 years ago: just trying to pay the bills, find a job or be independent so we could chart our own future.\n\n In fact, Canada is going in the opposite direction. Now people are starting to get a good understanding of what it feels like to be a first nations person living in Canada, where there are no economic opportunities, where people cannot afford their bills and are dependent on government money. Canada is losing auto manufacturing and lumber jobs to the United States. Now we do not even have a plan to defend Canada's borders. If there were a plan, there would be no money for it because there is no economy.\n\nThe idea that the Liberals took as their own from the Conservatives was to build our national defences, build pipelines, axe the carbon tax and negotiate with the U.S.A. It is all going to hurt Canadians today and tomorrow, especially when we consider the massive deficit that the Liberal government has incurred is going to be paid for by our children and our children's children.\n\n I, like many other members, get asked what Conservatives would do. The Liberals got elected, but they could not implement the promises that they took from the Conservatives.\n\nWhat more could we do? We could get rid of the hidden taxes. The clean fuel regulations are going to add 7¢ a litre to fuel this year, which will rise to 17¢ per litre in 2030, and not just at the pumps but also for shipping goods and services. We should get rid of the industrial carbon tax, which adds cost to shipping, farming and groceries. The food packaging tax is adding costs at the grocer's level that are going to get passed on to consumers.\n\nBy the way, Canada in its wisdom has said it is going to lift the plastics ban for plastic straws and other goods to be shipped to the United States, which will make life affordable for people in the United States but not do the same for Canadians. Everything is going to the United States. Our government gave Stellantis auto manufacturing $220 million, and what did Stellantis do? It went to the United States and invested in its auto manufacturing sector.\n\n This is all talk and stopgap measures, while real people are suffering and trying to make decisions that affect not only their daily life but also their future. We cannot afford to keep going like this. The government should take a page from first nations leaders who say we should look ahead seven generations when making decisions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86084","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be dividing my time with the member for Moose Jaw—Lake Centre—Lanigan.\n\nWe are debating Bill C-19, the Canada groceries and essentials benefit act. Listening to the speeches all day today, the debates, I cannot help but ask, why this bill? It is mainly for two reasons: first, Canadians cannot afford to pay their bills and they cannot afford to buy groceries; and second, this wa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8d57de6c4d1a63aff714636e7a7c622ff2c0481e857de93e63cc36480e434e15"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c6e84508e15d9dee09ad6dc007b5e311f22edfa2b674e1043b9c35404150e14"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7eda9b937b8e2875590593a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86085,"date":"2026-02-02T23:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that was not a question. That was a bit of a ramble, but the member is always getting up and asking about what we are doing here, talking about things. It is because we were elected to come here to debate these issues. I made a commitment long ago to make sure that, if I was in opposition, I would hold the government to account. The member just got through saying that the bill will address grocery prices, but no, it will not. It is a tax rebate. The people who actually take advantage of that tax rebate, if they qualify, are going to have to decide how they use it: to pay the rent, the phone bill, the mortgage or the grocery bill. That is a tough decision.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86085","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that was not a question. That was a bit of a ramble, but the member is always getting up and asking about what we are doing here, talking about things. It is because we were elected to come here to debate these issues. I made a commitment long ago to make sure that, if I was in opposition, I would hold the government to account. The member just got through saying that the bill will ad","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b5117b789dcba2d22056daededb3d1ad3c901037cdd029c318d2564c194d58f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc042c4427eed1cf0909dbdf73d17daf4b1243f1d449715723861a58fc5dc832"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0102184ebc0641d83eaeede9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86086,"date":"2026-02-02T23:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I 100% agree. We should be looking at the capacity of vulnerable Canadians. In fact, that is what we have been doing in Skeena—Bulkley Valley for a number of years, and it does pay dividends in terms of independence. Those people are making good paycheques that actually contribute to the economy in Canada, which has been shrinking in the last 10 years in terms of oil, gas, forestry and mining. I do not think we have actually begun to see the real level of hurt that Canadians are going to see in the future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86086","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I 100% agree. We should be looking at the capacity of vulnerable Canadians. In fact, that is what we have been doing in Skeena—Bulkley Valley for a number of years, and it does pay dividends in terms of independence. Those people are making good paycheques that actually contribute to the economy in Canada, which has been shrinking in the last 10 years in terms of oil, gas, forestry an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0506e140cd2e013f08ca9fdaaafc090dbfa112418f1f902e4ee25bf64098339e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["405cf132be949a8a2c1e900acea2adcdf066b1ca303efd4f6cb93fb41c629ce1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-326745cee7bdf172e40609ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86087,"date":"2026-02-02T23:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is basically how a responsible government is supposed to look at the economy. Basically, capital is going to leave and jobs are going to leave. The brain drain is going to happen. In the case of agriculture, we are going to have to import more food, and the government is actually considering supporting the International Maritime Organization's shipping carbon tax. It is another hidden carbon tax that would not even go to Ottawa. It would go to some agency in New York or Geneva. \n\nBy the way, one of the things that I find ridiculous is the Liberals' questioning the hidden taxes when there are farmers on this side of the House who are saying that they can see the cost and it is going to have to be passed on to consumers. As such, these are not imaginary taxes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86087","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is basically how a responsible government is supposed to look at the economy. Basically, capital is going to leave and jobs are going to leave. The brain drain is going to happen. In the case of agriculture, we are going to have to import more food, and the government is actually considering supporting the International Maritime Organization's shipping carbon tax. It is another h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax avoidance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax avoidance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","label":"Tax avoidance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["983ff2f2062dc3f7f5e42e68bfc78a020a039510465388bb12097059d2ab081f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fbaa3e60ae3ef1d2074f765df09b533887f8d217b940b941127a2373caf40f56"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe37f758e201e11d96b95775","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86074,"date":"2026-02-05T16:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in listening to the debate, I heard two different speeches and two prerogatives over the last hour.\n\n It seems to me that the Bloc's motion is simply asking for an apology for expropriation that happened in 1969, in a formal manner, coming from the House and coming from the government. However, the government has not acknowledged the motion. All the government members are talking about is the high-speed rail. I get both sides. They both make sense.\n\nBringing us back to the motion, I can sympathize with the Bloc because as a first nations member, I, along with my people, experienced the exact trauma that their members have explained.\n\nCould the minister tell us if the government has any intention to actually acknowledge the motion that is on the floor today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86074","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in listening to the debate, I heard two different speeches and two prerogatives over the last hour.\n\n It seems to me that the Bloc's motion is simply asking for an apology for expropriation that happened in 1969, in a formal manner, coming from the House and coming from the government. However, the government has not acknowledged the motion. All the government members are talking abou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee97050656234441287d810eb7e6f4327393f6ac3b158d620866f0426ae5cddd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-adfa8531111c6058d6bd50c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86075,"date":"2026-02-05T18:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are having two debates here. The government is trying to sell high-speed rail, but nobody I have seen get up today opposes the idea of high-speed rail. I think our Bloc colleagues are suggesting that we do not repeat history. \n\nI will take a different approach. In terms of what happened to first nations, a lot of education had to happen before we could start to understand what we are trying to reconcile. I think what the Bloc is getting at is that we should educate Canadians on the dangers of expropriation, based on the past, so we do not repeat it in the future.\n\n Would my colleague from the Bloc agree with that statement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86075","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are having two debates here. The government is trying to sell high-speed rail, but nobody I have seen get up today opposes the idea of high-speed rail. I think our Bloc colleagues are suggesting that we do not repeat history. \n\nI will take a different approach. In terms of what happened to first nations, a lot of education had to happen before we could start to understand what we a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a68fa8776ae1d51d3a7f529ad36bafe001a912fe0c8faddb5ae4ddec4bbe262"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da9b2399b223a746f0e5b60c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86076,"date":"2026-02-05T18:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the motion is an apology to the residents of Mirabel for expropriation.\n\nI am using this opportunity for educational purposes. I did not know about this happening back in 1969. I get why the Bloc has put this motion on the table, so that we do not repeat the mistakes of the past. The government seems to be reluctant to support the motion.\n\nIn terms of expropriation, what is the member's understanding of where this takes place? Does it take place within the environmental assessment, or does it take place outside the environmental assessment that provides some type of pathway for high-speed rail?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86076","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the motion is an apology to the residents of Mirabel for expropriation.\n\nI am using this opportunity for educational purposes. I did not know about this happening back in 1969. I get why the Bloc has put this motion on the table, so that we do not repeat the mistakes of the past. The government seems to be reluctant to support the motion.\n\nIn terms of expropriation, what is the member","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f69e7bcb2b5e7b95d14a6358bee0b5dc5fb9c408f43c0810b1788deed9248471"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d2ae6dc447bb60fca72c00ccf1285c25cd5d75962ed7666153d9f48fbd758bb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e6b7e635d1e1f5df2d28168","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86077,"date":"2026-02-05T20:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, listening to the debate today, I hear two conversations: One is for an apology for past expropriations, and one is for the fast-tracking of a high-speed rail. To be honest, I did not know about these issues before today, but in doing some research, I am more interested in the process and the mechanics. \n\nCan my colleague across the way answer whether the same mechanics, in terms of expropriation and land acquisition, will apply to a pipeline being fast-tracked and built to the west coast of British Columbia?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86077","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, listening to the debate today, I hear two conversations: One is for an apology for past expropriations, and one is for the fast-tracking of a high-speed rail. To be honest, I did not know about these issues before today, but in doing some research, I am more interested in the process and the mechanics. \n\nCan my colleague across the way answer whether the same mechanics, in terms of ex","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["984eb9e3609b79a8ea4d59371fda7dae382561312c62ca9af3dcce72dc6d4d2e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a21fc0f3ae3f58b1afb208e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86078,"date":"2026-02-05T20:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this debate is really the Bloc asking for an apology for an expropriation of land that happened in 1969 and for the past not to be repeated, but I think we are coming across one of the fundamental problems that comes along with fast-tracking. Everybody understands the need to build our economy, build pipelines and build high-speed rail, but we have some fundamental human problems that come up when we talk about fast-tracking, which may override some fundamental issues.\n\nIf everybody understands the need to support—\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86078","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this debate is really the Bloc asking for an apology for an expropriation of land that happened in 1969 and for the past not to be repeated, but I think we are coming across one of the fundamental problems that comes along with fast-tracking. Everybody understands the need to build our economy, build pipelines and build high-speed rail, but we have some fundamental human problems that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f30e4e26b175c926706fd57c65d09fa41c5c7af3899fa69c8239f9ed97e7d8da"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["957128b02d683933d5fdddc8ca21d88cd2a06acf0343db91e4aebaf249b699b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45b6fb37121f2488df1f8bd1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86079,"date":"2026-02-05T20:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if everybody already sees the need to build up the economy, would an official apology from the government not actually be a big step in terms of clearing up the right-of-way for a high-speed rail?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86079","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if everybody already sees the need to build up the economy, would an official apology from the government not actually be a big step in terms of clearing up the right-of-way for a high-speed rail?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-94cd1dc2f61c8a33b7be3a0d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86080,"date":"2026-02-05T21:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, quite frankly, there are a lot of Canadians watching us who will be affected by this high-speed rail network and the right-of-way, which I heard is going to be 10 kilometres wide. For those watching at home who are wondering what is going on, we are talking about consultations and high-speed rail, yet the motion is simply asking for an apology to the people of Mirabel for the expropriation that happened in 1969.\n\nIs there any appetite for the government to respond to the motion on the floor today and what the Bloc is proposing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86080","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, quite frankly, there are a lot of Canadians watching us who will be affected by this high-speed rail network and the right-of-way, which I heard is going to be 10 kilometres wide. For those watching at home who are wondering what is going on, we are talking about consultations and high-speed rail, yet the motion is simply asking for an apology to the people of Mirabel for the expropri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ef169fd1f8c7aca511b91e902bd13868d3e70399fb3a58c77083b25544fc8de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5d47d4cb7e10540a6b53979062acd8cc5ad170ed21c69f194c935ab5eedc440c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4af75def16cc572e17f4d578","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299623,"date":"2026-02-09T17:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, back in my day, I was a treaty negotiator for my band. We did not sign a treaty, but I heard the same complaints for 20 years. Members of government and members of the Bloc talk about transparency, which has been alive and well in this place for the last 20 to 30 years. We have seen hundreds of reports go through this chamber on what the first nations are complaining about in terms of implementation. What we are talking about here is accountability. What is the use if the minister in charge will not make a decision or not interact with the first nation that signed one of the highest reconciliation agreements in Canada, which is protected by the Constitution?\n\nDo we need more transparency, or do we need more accountability in terms of Bill C-10?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299623","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, back in my day, I was a treaty negotiator for my band. We did not sign a treaty, but I heard the same complaints for 20 years. Members of government and members of the Bloc talk about transparency, which has been alive and well in this place for the last 20 to 30 years. We have seen hundreds of reports go through this chamber on what the first nations are complaining about in terms ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9aca26e980edebf7734d38ab3b932f96881f6e07a637638745daceaee447f0d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c51aef3cad7bb1f264475ffea01f1f50590ebcb0cb55ad1767e71e7b0f27ce4d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4fcc951594f0ab8fa41013f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299624,"date":"2026-02-09T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am listening to the debate. The government and our colleagues down the way want more oversight. Speaking as an aboriginal leader, especially regarding the Indian Act, I think there is already a ton of oversight. There are countless committees.\n\nThe insult here is that first nations have signed the highest agreement in the Canadian Constitution, yet they are being afforded a different type of disrespect. They are not getting the full partnership the treaty promised. What is outlined in every one of the chapters and provisions is what should be implemented as a partnership. Now we are talking about adding another oversight committee.\n\nCan my colleague talk about what it really means when we say, \"Let us hold the minister responsible for implementing a treaty\"?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299624","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am listening to the debate. The government and our colleagues down the way want more oversight. Speaking as an aboriginal leader, especially regarding the Indian Act, I think there is already a ton of oversight. There are countless committees.\n\nThe insult here is that first nations have signed the highest agreement in the Canadian Constitution, yet they are being afforded a differ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b3417c5f2956f8357ee7e1e32015acee289651249f1f5414b7689a818f15272"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a99379e8d34f0eb7134969c865ae431e0258bc2f84db210b2d214f2a7620da14"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40cf83e42a4a12a0d40c9bab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299625,"date":"2026-02-09T17:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank my colleague across the way for her experience with indigenous negotiations, land claims and treaty negotiations.\n\nI think the question on this side of the House is not about the purpose of the commissioner but about the reality of the minister's not being held responsible for not implementing a treaty. Everything in a treaty has provisions in terms of what the Crown should be doing to be an equal treaty partner. Even the bill we are talking about today says nothing that would compel the minister to honour a constitutionally protected, documented treaty.\n\nIs there any type of language that says that the government would actually uphold the honour of the Crown in terms of implementing treaties that have been in existence for the last 30 or 40 years?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299625","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank my colleague across the way for her experience with indigenous negotiations, land claims and treaty negotiations.\n\nI think the question on this side of the House is not about the purpose of the commissioner but about the reality of the minister's not being held responsible for not implementing a treaty. Everything in a treaty has provisions in terms of what the Crown should ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d35dc8d082ee7400acb1d9066554519be0ac5a9b99f56fc61b5cf8d2e2b042ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d302069e2c6ef6d4ae9acdd24d6cb62a8b7f7f5fb6a717e559d7e9b0b7d25db"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-01d73c14a11cef858618ebd3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299626,"date":"2026-02-09T18:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, in Canada, we already have one of the most senior and most powerful institutions. The Auditor General is already saying that Canada is failing at its treaty obligations. There are half a dozen oversight committees. There are aboriginal groups advocating for government to live up to its commitments under treaties. There are also the treaty provisions themselves that speak to accountability.\n\nWould the creation of a new commissioner compel the ministers and the government to live up to treaty obligations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299626","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, in Canada, we already have one of the most senior and most powerful institutions. The Auditor General is already saying that Canada is failing at its treaty obligations. There are half a dozen oversight committees. There are aboriginal groups advocating for government to live up to its commitments under treaties. There are also the treaty provisions themselves that speak to accounta","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["20223622bfea7cbee438132d5277005258ea7c589b31abeb2e55dee419b5c9d2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8cd8716f74e94b20552f9258868ddd5031ba67d542fd4c0158c5e906c9aa01c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f95cc32a648073da08108db0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299627,"date":"2026-02-09T20:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition on behalf of Skeena-Bulkley Valley.\n\nThe petition calls for the government to scrap the reckless expansion of MAID to those suffering with a mental illness as a sole underlying medical condition. They also state in this petition that this is wrong since the government has already failed to meet its promises to expand mental health supports.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299627","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition on behalf of Skeena-Bulkley Valley.\n\nThe petition calls for the government to scrap the reckless expansion of MAID to those suffering with a mental illness as a sole underlying medical condition. They also state in this petition that this is wrong since the government has already failed to meet its promises to expand mental health supports.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7dfc46e579c3200dfcd31e4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299628,"date":"2026-02-09T21:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this debate is centred around accountability in terms of the minister or the government not honouring or respecting treaties, yet it is already written into the provisions. One of the most powerful and most senior institutions the government has is the Auditor General, who says the government should respect treaties, but the government ignores that. There are oversight committees that have been talking about exactly what is contemplated in this bill, and the government ignores it.\n\nTo my colleague, I agree, but does this add or take away from the frustrations that first nations are experiencing in treaty bands today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299628","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this debate is centred around accountability in terms of the minister or the government not honouring or respecting treaties, yet it is already written into the provisions. One of the most powerful and most senior institutions the government has is the Auditor General, who says the government should respect treaties, but the government ignores that. There are oversight committees that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ef916de8ed7ef508250f3ead8b020132433c645676da4e7d7361013d2d46b5b6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18f561e45ad3bac1e2632837856c0e74e37d2e319a6870003748b741fec36cae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6007b86aaa907f49400749bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299629,"date":"2026-02-09T21:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, representatives from that side of the House, the government, claim that the Conservatives have no idea what we are really talking about, when what we are talking about is accountability.\n\n I was a chief councillor. I was a chairman of the treaty negotiations. I was actually part of First Nations Summit, an advocacy group based out of Vancouver of all chief negotiators. I know of the six oversight committees that are actually fighting for basic accountability. There is also the Auditor General, the highest, most powerful, basically non-political group in Canada, who has been telling the government that it has to respect treaties. The only group in the House that does not respect accountability for treaty implementation is the government. Would my colleague agree that basically there are enough provisions in the treaty, as well as organizations that are demanding accountability from the government—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299629","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, representatives from that side of the House, the government, claim that the Conservatives have no idea what we are really talking about, when what we are talking about is accountability.\n\n I was a chief councillor. I was a chairman of the treaty negotiations. I was actually part of First Nations Summit, an advocacy group based out of Vancouver of all chief negotiators. I know of the s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b91d6f7a1b2a839c3793129387e1753ebb01665abda0ef274e2004f4affbca8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3c523795fcd5e8f2a689e7285466a18ce878d9681cd64815bdd036dd0fc20de"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-91c68f34ce1c5c8cdd6f25cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299617,"date":"2026-02-12T22:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is tough to get back to House business given the events that happened in Tumbler Ridge on Tuesday. Canada is still trying to recover. We send our thoughts and prayers to the community, the people and the families of Tumbler Ridge. They are going to have a long journey of healing. My family is quite upset about this.\n\nToday, we are talking about electric vehicles and the rebate initiative from the federal government. Listening to the speeches, I keep hearing the conversation go back to how we are supporting Canadian auto worker, that the world is moving towards electric vehicles and how Canada intends to join that trend, but American EV automakers are actually writing off their losses, and the same thing is happening in China. Its domestic sales are collapsing. Canada is actually throwing a lifeline to America for EVs made in the United States with a rebate. There is only one car that could possibly qualify for the rebate that we are talking about; the rest of it is going to help an industry that is dying in the United States.\n\n The agreement the government signed with China is going to help an industry that is dying in China. It is an over-produced, over-subsidized vehicle. However, it does not end there. Tesla has revenues coming from carbon credits. Since 2017, without selling anything, it has raised over $10 billion in carbon credits from auto manufacturers that do not produce electric vehicles, including those in Canada. We will be sending $2.3 billion of rebates to help a failing industry in the United States, and our auto manufacturers, or what is left of them in Canada, that do not produce electric vehicles will have to buy carbon credits from an American company. How is this building Canada strong?\n\nWe hear all these talking points, but everything is actually geared toward the United States and helping its economy, helping it with its jobs and helping it re-establish its manufacturing sector. Canada not only is helping it with this rebate, but we also previously gave Stellantis hundreds of millions of dollars to produce jobs and vehicles in Canada. What did Stellantis do? It said, \"Thank you very much,\" left Canada and went to the United States. It is going to build a plant down there. Everything is geared toward the United States.\n\n There are the promises made by the Prime Minister. He promised that we are going to be the strongest performing country in the G7. No, we have a failing grade on that. He promised that we are going to be an energy superpower. No, we are not. He wanted to be judged by the price of groceries at the grocery store. No. \n\nOne of the most significant promises he made was to President Trump, and it was that he was going to invest $1 trillion Canadian into the United States economy. I think we are well on the road to seeing that promise fulfilled, even if it is in instalments, like a $2.3-billion rebate going to the electric vehicle manufacturers in the United States.\n\nBy the way, when the Prime Minister came back to Canada, he clarified that it would not be taxpayer dollars, but that it might be private investment dollars. Well, this tax rebate is coming from the government; it is coming from taxpayers. It is $2.3 billion, and that is on top of the $52 billion that the government committed to creating an electric vehicle supply chain in Canada for a vehicle that is produced in the United States.\n\nNow we are looking at 49,000 electric vehicles coming from China. We are helping lagging economies, but doing nothing to help our own economy and our own people, whether we are talking about jobs or affordability.\n\n I will say one thing, and I talked about this a lot in the B.C. legislature, but the electric vehicle mandate was unfair and unreasonable. Putting financial pressure on people to buy an electric vehicle, especially in ridings like mine, in Skeena—Bulkley Valley, where it is not practical for those who work in forestry or on farms. Perhaps I should say they used to work in forestry, because the industry is basically shutting down left, right and centre in B.C. An EV is not practical. Therefore, to put financial pressure on people who are already struggling with affordability, making sure they get punished if they buy a gas or diesel vehicle, is unfair.\n\n What has replaced this electric vehicle mandate? A tailpipe emissions mandate, which is going to accomplish the same thing as the EV mandate. It is going to put pressure on Canadians, especially those who cannot even think about purchasing an electric vehicle. This is not fair. Government should not be putting more hurdles and obstacles in front of Canadians, who cannot afford a home, cannot afford groceries and cannot afford to pay their utilities. \n\nThis is not what the Prime Minister promised, especially when I do not think the Canadian public understands where we are going with respect to investments. This is not just investing the $2.3 billion in rebates, which will go to the auto manufacturers in the United States. According to Natural Resources Canada, we will need around 450,000 public EV chargers, along with nearly 12 million in homes, by 2035 to accommodate the projected new EV car sales. \n\nWe talked a lot about this in B.C. The infrastructure we need in B.C., especially in the rural areas, is just not there. We are talking about a supply of electricity that B.C. does not have in the first place. Then there is the transmission line, which comes right into our neighbourhoods and into our homes, but it is just not there. It is going to cost billions more to provide the infrastructure for the EV mandates. Who is going to pay for that in the end? It will not be the government; it will be the consumers and the taxpayers.\n\n In fact, right now, I am getting complaints at my office about the new hydroelectricity bills that people got in the last couple of days. They are asking what is causing the jump, but I do not know. I know that the hydroelectricity cost for the dams in B.C. was a deferred cost. Just like with the unmanageable budget the Liberal government has put in place, at some point somebody is going to have to pay that bill. If they do not, there will be consequences to our sovereignty. There are many examples of what happens if a country cannot pay its bills.\n\n I know that to some people here, the idea of being fiscally responsible is a joke, but under the Indian Act, it was hammered into us, as chiefs in council, that we were not allowed to go into debt or have deficits, under punishment from the federal government. Those rules are still there today. \n\nWe can talk all we want about this brand new world of driving an electric vehicle—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299617","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is tough to get back to House business given the events that happened in Tumbler Ridge on Tuesday. Canada is still trying to recover. We send our thoughts and prayers to the community, the people and the families of Tumbler Ridge. They are going to have a long journey of healing. My family is quite upset about this.\n\nToday, we are talking about electric vehicles and the rebate init","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30198814578491e88953d9c613985f03e1fc620596159d85fabde4640a61e14a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["26f310a5adcfe1305f837cbf2a42148dbdaa846865fae3753e580b774afb206f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d51afd2c72087c7c49142754","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299618,"date":"2026-02-12T22:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I said that because the Liberal record already shows what failure looks like. The Liberals gave hundreds of millions of dollars to Stellantis to build a manufacturing plant here. They claimed they were going to get it back. They claimed there was a promise of jobs. What did Stellantis do? It took the money and ran down to the United States to build jobs and cars in the United States. \n\nWhat is so different here? How will this rebate actually produce jobs and improve the economy in Canada? It is all going to benefit the United States.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299618","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I said that because the Liberal record already shows what failure looks like. The Liberals gave hundreds of millions of dollars to Stellantis to build a manufacturing plant here. They claimed they were going to get it back. They claimed there was a promise of jobs. What did Stellantis do? It took the money and ran down to the United States to build jobs and cars in the United States. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4417902fdd7f54ea4b80a2aca81e97db0fb2908aa31e08833de271b0494da086"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["50f504838b535fad24b3fe3898495660ccf0788ee7cc91bef0615298d4f6134e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d525e3ff6539e3b2cdb2fdb0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299619,"date":"2026-02-12T22:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have nothing against affordable electric vehicles. I have nothing against affordable gas and diesel vehicles. I have nothing against them.\n\n My opposition has to do with how the rebate is essentially going to fix a dying economy in the United States, Ford and General Motors, while at the same time it will benefit Tesla, an American company that will benefit from more carbon credits.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299619","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have nothing against affordable electric vehicles. I have nothing against affordable gas and diesel vehicles. I have nothing against them.\n\n My opposition has to do with how the rebate is essentially going to fix a dying economy in the United States, Ford and General Motors, while at the same time it will benefit Tesla, an American company that will benefit from more carbon credits.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["14177bbcb1be6e02d2e9eca3fef9b07f97599fef19d5f18044842b43211cf60e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cca1dc2a9fa93ef8a7297d7ae6b519e6d865c12ebcddfa9f15c602640acc97ea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-493678ccf06dfb20e32b36ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299620,"date":"2026-02-12T22:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what I want to talk about, and what I try to talk about, is a made-in-Canada approach for Canadians. We have asked questions of the Canadian government about funding initiatives in Skeena—Bulkley Valley that would produce jobs and revenues for Canadians. We are talking about Telkwa Coal, which needs infrastructure. Terrace's industrial lands need infrastructure help. We are talking about the Stewart port, which needs infrastructure dollars. We have had no answers.\n\n We have the answers for a made-in-Canada approach. We do not need an approach that helps a dying electric vehicle industry in the United States. That is what this rebate is going to do. It is going to rescue the electric vehicle industry in the United States.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299620","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what I want to talk about, and what I try to talk about, is a made-in-Canada approach for Canadians. We have asked questions of the Canadian government about funding initiatives in Skeena—Bulkley Valley that would produce jobs and revenues for Canadians. We are talking about Telkwa Coal, which needs infrastructure. Terrace's industrial lands need infrastructure help. We are talking ab","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cfb67812daee458576ce610b3a7359a735270c36303cbe7493d4536c87d2feeb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80601d33688006965b2246c937091c8be10b820aaa97d19a3f511ca78799e541"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df611f7021ba4ce9b71d327d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299621,"date":"2026-02-12T22:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I do recognize that integration, but it is not only in the auto industry. We are intricately connected in all sorts of trade. That is why the CUSMA negotiations are so important, but the diversification we are talking about does not mean we should spend 2.3 billion of Canadian tax dollars to help a dying industry in the United States.\n\n Why are we not investing that into the industry in Canada to bring back the jobs that were lost just this past year under the Liberal government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299621","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I do recognize that integration, but it is not only in the auto industry. We are intricately connected in all sorts of trade. That is why the CUSMA negotiations are so important, but the diversification we are talking about does not mean we should spend 2.3 billion of Canadian tax dollars to help a dying industry in the United States.\n\n Why are we not investing that into the industry ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["16b630943c7acb80f8426070422ebbe633264ef8c6f2879d6210608ebf0a774b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4951abb671895f2b266d497a36981afd0023545073da9447d03b7baadce3f5cb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3272f1f3d763bc0d0839ce4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299622,"date":"2026-02-12T23:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that was an excellent description of this bill. It is not really talking about jurisdictions or provinces per se, but I want the member to talk about jurisdiction in terms of international borders, especially the United States. Some of the platforms the member talked about actually originate in the United States and are being advertised on YouTube, Facebook and Twitter. \n\nHas the government actually considered that, or is it going to wait for the bill to go to committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299622","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that was an excellent description of this bill. It is not really talking about jurisdictions or provinces per se, but I want the member to talk about jurisdiction in terms of international borders, especially the United States. Some of the platforms the member talked about actually originate in the United States and are being advertised on YouTube, Facebook and Twitter. \n\nHas the gove","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Websites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","label":"Websites","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dad88cf0cefb74b9afc78a158c1591a5fbcc2d6cb75cd665203ee82c089935c0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db46032bbe7bcd15ffe3d1a633f5640d52d65789b053d775ff3de6762f9d7cd8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f0755446982197a2719875c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715141,"date":"2026-04-14T19:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Cowichan ruling has created uncertainty for homeowners and first nations in B.C., calling into question whether private property rights are secure. Canadians are already struggling with affordability. They should not have to wonder whether or not they own their own homes. Cowichan themselves said that they did not seek to invalidate private property ownership.\n\nWill the Prime Minister direct his lawyers to thoroughly argue in court that the private property rights of Canadian homeowners must be a priority as well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715141","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Cowichan ruling has created uncertainty for homeowners and first nations in B.C., calling into question whether private property rights are secure. Canadians are already struggling with affordability. They should not have to wonder whether or not they own their own homes. Cowichan themselves said that they did not seek to invalidate private property ownership.\n\nWill the Prime Mini","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cae9e4b02a9dbc6af6930f894cf68ae85f512fe26286f9a5b7513a8b4c150596"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82af867e54ea8de84e4122d7d10f37275e11674b31d27d4aca997bf444f5b017"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ad6ca7ab7ba7c86a6912ecc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715142,"date":"2026-04-14T19:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this could have been avoided. The Liberal government's secret approach to agreements, such as the Musqueam rights recognition agreement, without transparency or clear protections for private property, has added to the anxiety private property owners are already experiencing. The consequences are uncertainty, stalled sales and the potential to derail previous reconciliation efforts.\n\nWill the Prime Minister commit today that no future agreements will be signed unless they explicitly protect and prioritize the private property rights of Canadian homeowners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715142","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this could have been avoided. The Liberal government's secret approach to agreements, such as the Musqueam rights recognition agreement, without transparency or clear protections for private property, has added to the anxiety private property owners are already experiencing. The consequences are uncertainty, stalled sales and the potential to derail previous reconciliation efforts.\n\nW","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["37db17b89382af8da7108e813483feac40a46e85eed56180e4acb51846f9448c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a150fa20326ff4744de8b90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128096,"date":"2026-04-16T16:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, witnesses, for your presence and your presentations. My question is for Mr. Tessier. Can you describe your role in the deal between the federal government and Northvolt for a $7-billion battery facility in Quebec?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128096","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, witnesses, for your presence and your presentations. My question is for Mr. Tessier. Can you describe your role in the deal between the federal government and Northvolt for a $7-billion battery facility in Quebec?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8791b1de509726f0589cf9b5e797ec12d8f055872dd345513ed27545dfe68f32"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca20fa4e8305ed4d92abb5b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128097,"date":"2026-04-16T16:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"I'm asking about your role.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128097","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm asking about your role.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d10526e4f66a854c3963f53b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128098,"date":"2026-04-16T16:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay, thank you. In September 2023, the government announced that it would provide $1.3 billion in a capital commitment toward the project and, not even a year later, Northvolt was declared insolvent. This was in September 2025, which ended this proposed gigafactory outside of Montreal. Did the government know that this was an unstable company to begin with and, if so, why did it invest this money?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128098","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay, thank you. In September 2023, the government announced that it would provide $1.3 billion in a capital commitment toward the project and, not even a year later, Northvolt was declared insolvent. This was in September 2025, which ended this proposed gigafactory outside of Montreal. Did the government know that this was an unstable company to begin with and, if so, why did it invest this money","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d61ad557c4d9cab60e689c44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128099,"date":"2026-04-16T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Excuse me. Before I lose a note, there was a mitigation assessment done. Were there any red flags to show that this might not be a good investment? Given that the assessment was done, was there anything there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128099","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Excuse me. Before I lose a note, there was a mitigation assessment done. Were there any red flags to show that this might not be a good investment? Given that the assessment was done, was there anything there?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb90075512be4575712cda1c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128100,"date":"2026-04-16T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Did the government look at this in terms of a healthy company? They were speculating that this would be a good economy, a good market and a good company, as opposed to looking at the financial stability or the viability of the company itself. Is it safe to say that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128100","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Did the government look at this in terms of a healthy company? They were speculating that this would be a good economy, a good market and a good company, as opposed to looking at the financial stability or the viability of the company itself. Is it safe to say that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3223ab9e1723d86ed8088df5c4c342c08c05709a0b630504bc11a5559276203b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-769bc371ad2d76cad87b6535","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128101,"date":"2026-04-16T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"I get all that. I'm just talking about the viability of the company itself. There was an assessment done that didn't talk about emerging markets or what's possible. Anybody can do that. We're really talking about the financial health and the viability of the company itself. The assessment didn't raise any flags in that respect.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128101","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I get all that. I'm just talking about the viability of the company itself. There was an assessment done that didn't talk about emerging markets or what's possible. Anybody can do that. We're really talking about the financial health and the viability of the company itself. The assessment didn't raise any flags in that respect.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a0f2ee256b1b544eab535ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128102,"date":"2026-04-16T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. In that same context, what was your role in the deal between the federal government and the $5-billion Stellantis-LG joint venture plant in Windsor?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128102","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. In that same context, what was your role in the deal between the federal government and the $5-billion Stellantis-LG joint venture plant in Windsor?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","label":"Foreign aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b44f8ea256c3efbab7f0aa7b93e731520ad25bf5b2f038d0202b07f9c6915785"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54042ecdafc2106e929f44ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128103,"date":"2026-04-16T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"It was very similar, in terms of.... Could you repeat your specific role in that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128103","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It was very similar, in terms of.... Could you repeat your specific role in that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cb3861632867a457d6f8bc9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128104,"date":"2026-04-16T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay. Given that the government promised to pay Stellantis up to $529 million, $268 million of which has already been paid out, what protections did you negotiate into this agreement? Even if it was just policy advisement, what protections were there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128104","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Given that the government promised to pay Stellantis up to $529 million, $268 million of which has already been paid out, what protections did you negotiate into this agreement? Even if it was just policy advisement, what protections were there?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["32587b8caf1c06d4737b2dcc34c029ef0a992ad00b2c49693c159b27d48147cc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0910c0d01b952cf12ead5ecc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128105,"date":"2026-04-16T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"To your recollection, did you advise any policies in terms of protecting this $5-billion commitment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128105","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"To your recollection, did you advise any policies in terms of protecting this $5-billion commitment?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7955315ae95dab5de8ede30523f964af7c00c3870f70b6883e9df9dc38b3db71"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-896c3b0470ce9232c01ff957","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128106,"date":"2026-04-16T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"However, there was some policy to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128106","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"However, there was some policy to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-521b961836d904637741b331","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128107,"date":"2026-04-16T17:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"It always jumps out at me that it's always urbanites telling everybody in rural Canada that it's okay and suitable for rural Canada to use EVs, but that's not what my constituents tell me. It's not really practical, or affordable for that matter. It's not even safe in some cases. We have to drive long distances just to get services. On the 40-kilometre rule in terms of range anxiety, I agree, but not when you have to drive 1,000 kilometres where there are no charging stations. It's not practical. Mr. Cauchi, you've answered this already with some of my colleagues' questions. What about Canadians in rural, remote and northern communities, like those in my riding of Skeena—Bulkley Valley, who don't have the option of switching to an EV? How does this new auto strategy ensure the affordability and availability of internal combustion engines for people in regions such as mine, who don't have practical access to EVs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128107","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It always jumps out at me that it's always urbanites telling everybody in rural Canada that it's okay and suitable for rural Canada to use EVs, but that's not what my constituents tell me. It's not really practical, or affordable for that matter. It's not even safe in some cases. We have to drive long distances just to get services. On the 40-kilometre rule in terms of range anxiety, I agree, but ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7ef0c7384fb44e17da8bdc6dbde36f31c4d2a45f75289643613f3e3d30d36e24"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2171747ca68ec8304f0e6929","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128108,"date":"2026-04-16T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"In the case of my constituents in rural Canada, we're concerned about the price of combustion vehicles, where the price of the combustion vehicles is pushed so high that my constituents have no choice but to buy a second-hand combustion vehicle. We still have that market. The range anxiety is real. To visit one of my communities, I have to drive 1,000 kilometres into the Yukon and then drive back down into the community. I've heard of people who, for some reason, have had their battery give out. In the wintertime, in the north, with -30° and -40° weather on an isolated highway, this becomes a safety risk. It is not just the affordability. How can I go back and tell my constituents that they'll be okay in terms of affordability, availability and safety, when we're talking about this new vehicle policy coming out of the federal government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128108","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the case of my constituents in rural Canada, we're concerned about the price of combustion vehicles, where the price of the combustion vehicles is pushed so high that my constituents have no choice but to buy a second-hand combustion vehicle. We still have that market. The range anxiety is real. To visit one of my communities, I have to drive 1,000 kilometres into the Yukon and then drive back ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","label":"Smoking","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8aa80cdc0f2dadee572b4295549ba3503e461ec76f37319fae6e7c1c8797fa24"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-657e0aa05692560c0df91dad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128109,"date":"2026-04-16T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Well, 2045 is way beyond.... My issue is affordability, safety and availability. That was my question. Madam Chair, I'd like to turn my remaining time over to my colleague.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128109","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Well, 2045 is way beyond.... My issue is affordability, safety and availability. That was my question. Madam Chair, I'd like to turn my remaining time over to my colleague.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f7ca9e1c9612473fb9a4e85465f4895ae9a8acb8892aa4978defdb35c9ae0cf6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95e5a8393f8f21f128b0e278","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715140,"date":"2026-04-16T22:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal member brought up AI in reference to our elections. Canada is so far behind in data centres and AI. It is becoming a bigger issue in the House of Commons. \n\nHow much more work does the member think we have to do, with the technologies already in place, in places like China, that are interfering with our elections?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715140","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal member brought up AI in reference to our elections. Canada is so far behind in data centres and AI. It is becoming a bigger issue in the House of Commons. \n\nHow much more work does the member think we have to do, with the technologies already in place, in places like China, that are interfering with our elections?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["68299b19e5ab9d3b3d36a09476eb6f3d8f5df8eabe1cd48a040eb77d9bdc6aae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-147b8da73b85387a152a9ee2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301460,"date":"2026-04-20T22:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, with respect to the Indian Act, I have a special concern when it comes to civil liberties and the freedoms and rights of Canadians. However, when we are talking about protecting civil liberties, the Liberal government says that is based on conspiracies when, really, all we are trying to do is protect the freedom of Canadians.\n\nCan my colleague give some examples of the Liberal government trying to promote the overreach of government, which nobody wants in this House or in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301460","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, with respect to the Indian Act, I have a special concern when it comes to civil liberties and the freedoms and rights of Canadians. However, when we are talking about protecting civil liberties, the Liberal government says that is based on conspiracies when, really, all we are trying to do is protect the freedom of Canadians.\n\nCan my colleague give some examples of the Liberal governm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3a3629fadcdfdf7e9f96aa362a4465d3cc63a7944a0f09d3a1cb9ae7fbf517cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29df9c8a70d9c312d82812954b170200d3926fd4261da2a16be1a9fd3958adb3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8daa0a886488e68093eebad1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301452,"date":"2026-04-21T17:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be dividing my time with the member for Kitchener Centre. \n\nI am very proud to get up on behalf of the people of Skeena—Bulkley Valley to speak to the motion, which is on the federal Canada student grant for full-time students. This brings me back to 20 years ago when my small first nation, the Haisla Nation, was trying to integrate our people into the economy, specifically into the workforce. Basically, what we are debating here is a motion about the federal government restricting student grants for public institutions and not-for-profit private institutions.\n\nWhile we are talking about this, I have to talk about the Kitimat Valley Institute, a private post-secondary institute in my riding, in the town of Kitimat, that was bankrupt. We could see the value in saving the Kitimat Valley Institute. As a small first nation band under the Indian Act, we had no money, but we could see its value because coming down the pike were forestry, LNG and mining jobs, so we did what we could to scratch together the dollars to purchase this private post-secondary institute and save it. Did we get any government help? No, we did not. It was the private sector that came to our rescue, the corporations. Those first few years were a struggle without government support, provincial or federal. \n\nOur people back then were facing the same situation that young people in Canada are facing right now. There is no opportunity or future for young people in Canada, so they are trying to leave. They are trying to go to the United States for a better opportunity to build a life. What was proposed at the Liberal convention just recently for these young people who want to leave is a $500,000 exit tax. If anybody wants to leave Canada for employment or to build a business outside of Canada, there could be an exit tax, which the Liberals debated at their convention. Not only are they stifling the economy so that young people cannot build a life, but they want to punish them with this proposed exit tax.\n\nThis is not the way to build Canada into the best performing country in the G7, let alone an energy superpower. To do either of those things we need a workforce, preferably a Canadian workforce that is trained and created in Canada, within our borders. Without that, we are basically supporting the economies of other countries, especially when we are talking about labour shortages in skilled and technical fields. \n\nNow, many students rely on those grants to afford their career programs, including first nations students. First nations have no real opportunity to engage with respect to what we are talking about here today. If the average aboriginal person who has never left and does not want to leave the reserve has to leave for training or employment, they will want to return to their community or their territory at some point. This is a real struggle. Not only are we telling that person to go out there and find their way in the outside world, but we are basically telling them that they are going to have to struggle with affordability issues under the Indian Act because they will not get 100% of the funding. For a first nation that does not have own-source revenue, it becomes a budgetary exercise and puts limits on what it can do with its younger generation. That is why we bought the Kitimat Valley Institute. We scratched together the dollars to accomplish that.\n\nThis proposal excludes the Kitimat Valley Institute, which my band operates on private land, by the way. We bought the land from the provincial government, kept it in fee-simple status and keep paying the taxes on it because we understand that the economy is a lot bigger than what we are thinking about.\n\nI do not think the government is truly thinking about all the aspects that go into a private post-secondary institution, which includes taxes and employment of instructors and custodians. Everybody who works at a facility contributes to the economy, locally, provincially and federally. However, it is the next generation of workers who are going to feel this crunch, because they cannot get the training in public institutions alone.\n\nFor first nations trying to be creative, trying to chart out their own futures for their young people based on the circumstances they have been given under the Indian Act, it is a tough slog. We cannot think about the idea of the chicken and egg when we are talking about economy versus education. I learned pretty quickly that everything we did for training, for education, actually returned to me in anger, because there was no economy in our region. There was a job expected after this training. At that point I understood that training and education go hand in hand with economic development. They have to, otherwise we have people leaving our community. We have a brain drain, and that is what is happening right now in Canada with our best and brightest, whether they go to a public institution or not, going to the United States. \n\nThis motion does not help. It punishes young people, it punishes Canadians, and why? Is it a budgetary question? If it is, just say it. However, if we want Canada to be running on all cylinders, we have to consider all the components that go into training, especially when we are talking about what we do as small first nations communities all across B.C. and Canada that want to contribute to the economy and want to get our people into the workforce. \n\nIf not for the Kitimat Valley Institute, KVI, we would not have the number of people entering the workforce to build LNG Canada. When we think about LNG Canada, there are 50,000 construction workers. I am sad to say that not all of those construction workers came from Canada. They came from all over the place. They came from the United States. They came from all across Canada, from different provinces. I see it as a specialized industry. I get it, but we do not build the Canadian workforce by limiting our options. \n\nCanada is in a really tough spot with the trade war from the United States and the trade talks coming up. I agree, we have to be independent as a country. We have to diversify our trade, and we have to rebuild our economy after 10 years of stifled policies, regulations and legislation. However, to omit a certain educational entity is wrong. It is not building our workforce. It is not building the future.\n\n If we are going to be the energy superpower in the same vein as LNG Canada, or maybe Chevron, which left Canada, a $30-billion investment, and if we want to rebuild this, we have to rebuild the people. We have to show them hope. This motion does not do it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301452","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be dividing my time with the member for Kitchener Centre. \n\nI am very proud to get up on behalf of the people of Skeena—Bulkley Valley to speak to the motion, which is on the federal Canada student grant for full-time students. This brings me back to 20 years ago when my small first nation, the Haisla Nation, was trying to integrate our people into the economy, specifically int","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0731186d1e08c639a466f8c977244790cb866db6cb83d6edc66457a99406a684"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["881fc780a25ca260487c829111f8e159fd40b145a023c2c317014cd9256aa02b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70603f09a1a189cfc14265b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301453,"date":"2026-04-21T17:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what is the point of this motion then, if not to restrict federal student grants and exclude for-profit institutions like my band has? Why should we have that? This member got up earlier. I heard him say that somehow we are playing a game. This is not gamesmanship. This is about rebuilding Canada. This is about rebuilding a future for young people.\n\n Why have this restriction, especially for a lot of first nations communities all across Canada, which are doing exactly the same thing as my community? This would actually discount all those first nations' efforts to not employ just their own people, like an institution like ours, and employ native and non-native alike. It has benefited everybody. It has made Canada stronger. I do not see the point of this motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301453","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what is the point of this motion then, if not to restrict federal student grants and exclude for-profit institutions like my band has? Why should we have that? This member got up earlier. I heard him say that somehow we are playing a game. This is not gamesmanship. This is about rebuilding Canada. This is about rebuilding a future for young people.\n\n Why have this restriction, especia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0fcb8cdde395f23af680aa585e29b8c54c333bc758a93550856a4f72f9c9794b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a912d3ee5a904f97d142e276df3d42ca751c3b0408aa224262d365b53265e4fc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebe03824b1ebbba799949d37","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301454,"date":"2026-04-21T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have a living example of that in my community, Haisla first nation. We could not get government support for our for-profit institution, Kitimat Valley Institute. We fixed it, not through government support, but through the corporations.\n\nI believe that this motion we are talking about is going to be discriminatory. Do colleagues know who it is going to affect the most? It will be those people with a low income. Who are the most low-income people in Canada? It is those people from first nations.\n\n I cannot accept this motion the way it is worded.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301454","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have a living example of that in my community, Haisla first nation. We could not get government support for our for-profit institution, Kitimat Valley Institute. We fixed it, not through government support, but through the corporations.\n\nI believe that this motion we are talking about is going to be discriminatory. Do colleagues know who it is going to affect the most? It will be t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42adf3d405d622eea946ff96e3cf40ab535ccec5c17c9583a5577870210899f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ee91f94106b6313feaa02fd3bc200ca05fa9893d67f0a5288530dd062cd8a84"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8827e4e81d0be6cb1a4c40db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301455,"date":"2026-04-21T17:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, without a doubt that is exactly what we learned pretty quickly when we purchased KVI. We opened that up to everybody, native and non-native alike, including first nations from other communities because we knew we could not fulfill the workforce for LNG Canada for 50,000 workers. With Chevron coming down, that was going to be another 40,000 workers.\n\nWe get the grand announcements. We get the rhetoric of building Canada strong, of being an energy superpower and all that. I do not believe any of it, but if we are going to try to get there, one of the key components is to build the workforce and make sure that the workforce, the majority of it, is Canadian.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301455","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, without a doubt that is exactly what we learned pretty quickly when we purchased KVI. We opened that up to everybody, native and non-native alike, including first nations from other communities because we knew we could not fulfill the workforce for LNG Canada for 50,000 workers. With Chevron coming down, that was going to be another 40,000 workers.\n\nWe get the grand announcements. We ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["419c52fa4fc95163cd7d2d9c612b2b57cc62655d7825931a636d4d7e09658665"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d98ed148896d70c520a545e5aa6e421d2ed6b49fb685fa811eb14ea663c6fdc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29fc5470020f9df30cfef852","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301456,"date":"2026-04-21T20:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved:\n\nThat Bill C-10 be amended by deleting the short title.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, before I get to my comments, I would like to draw members' attention to Cancer Awareness Month in honour of my younger sister, my mother and all those fighting this horrible disease; and the support teams who help out those who are trying to fight cancer.\n\nWe are talking today about the government trying to create a new position of treaty commissioner. The rationale is that somehow this would give accountability to the government's implementing and honouring the modern-day treaties that have been signed, mainly in B.C. They were negotiated in B.C. for the last 30 or 40 years. I have the honour of having one treaty in my riding, the Nisg̱a'a Treaty. The treaty is 20 years old and yet the people still cannot get the federal government to co-operate as a treaty partner as outlined in the treaty itself.\n\n I also have in my riding two first nations that are up for ratification, the Kitselas First Nation and Kitsumkalum. They are going through the ratification stage right now in B.C. However, they are going to face the same problems that Nisg̱a'a, Tsawwassen, Maa-nulth and other first nations are experiencing right now with modern-day treaties, in that they cannot get Canada to participate in a modern-day treaty in partnership with Canada.\n\nThe current Liberal government wants the world to think that if it creates a treaty commissioner there will be accountability and Canada would then get to the table and co-operate with these first nations that have signed modern-day treaties. However, what government members will forget to tell them is that this issue is 20 years old. It comes back annually. There have been endless reports, even to the point where the Government of Canada created a document called the \"Cabinet Directive on the Federal Approach to Modern Treaty Implementation\". It has headings: \"Roles and Responsibilities...Deputy Ministers' Oversight Committee...Modern Treaty Implementation Office [and] Evaluation of the Directive\". \n\nOn top of that is the expected rhetoric that the government will \"ensure that they are aware of, understand, and fulfill their departments' obligations pursuant to all modern treaties in effect.\" It sounds good, except it does not do it. The treaty itself is supposed to be a document that says Canada, B.C. and a first nation shall work together in key areas. A first nation gives up its asserted rights and title and comes into a constitutionally protected document agreement in good faith, in the spirit that the first nation that signs the treaty will walk beside Canada and B.C. and help build Canada together.\n\n The first nations are there. They want to implement and they want to build, not just for their own first nation but for Canada overall, but Canada is missing. In fact, the document, \"Cabinet Directive on the Federal Approach to Modern Treaty Implementation\", came from another document, \"Canada's Collaborative Modern Treaty Implementation Policy\". This has more headings than the first document I named. It goes on at length ad nauseam in terms of how Canada this year will commit to implementing the treaties that it signed with first nations. It has the regular rhetoric: \"Message from the Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations...Purpose...Context...Interpretation and application of this policy...Principles guiding the timely, effective and full implementation of modern treaties...Advancing objectives of modern treaties...[and] Direction to public servants\". \n\n That means that every single ministry under the federal government that is tasked with working with its counterparts in treaty first nations has been directed to do a job.\n\n There are headings on legislative, policy and program design considerations; monitoring, evaluation and review; and commitments to further work on essential components of the policy. Then there are the annexes. One is intergovernmental relationships, with the intergovernmental leaders' forum and the intergovernmental policy circle. The next is accountability and oversight.\n\nAll these documents and all these announcements that have come up year after year over the past 30 years are simply to state one thing: Canada is not living up to the obligations that it signed on to with the modern day treaties. Is it any wonder that the first nations will take anything that shows accountability to the first nations that have already signed them?\n\nThere are already mechanisms in the House that speak to the accountability. There are already entities outside the House that speak to the accountability that should be there but is not. There is the Auditor General's report on whether or not the government is living up to its commitments and obligations under the treaty. In B.C., we have the BC Treaty Commission, \"the keeper of the process\", as it is referred to.\n\nThere is also every single department under the federal government that is supposed to be held accountable and should be sending reports to the government and to cabinet on why they are or are not living up to these commitments. We have logged, cut down, a massive amount of forest to produce all the paperwork simply to say we want to work with first nations that have signed a treaty, that have given up their aboriginal rights and title.\n\nThe biggest example that comes to mind is the Nisg̱a'a, in my territory. They wanted to be respected as a treaty partner. They take pride in their treaty. Not only is it a form of independence they are still working on, but they also thought they would be walking side by side with the federal and provincial governments. That is not so, according to the Nisg̱a'a.\n\nOn Bill C-48, the tanker ban, the Nisg̱a'a urged the government that the moratorium, the tanker ban, must not be introduced before the implications for their nation and their treaty were well understood. More important, they said that the moratorium should not cover Nisg̱a'a treaty territory. The Nisg̱a'a, to be clear, were not supporting a tanker ban. They were not for it. They were not against it. They just felt that they were owed the duty of a higher level of consultation when Canada was proposing it. They did not get it.\n\nThis brings me back to the days of the B.C. legislature. I warned the B.C. legislature not to play games with aboriginal issues, whether we were talking about case law or UNDRIP, and now B.C. is chaos. I give the same warning to the House. We should not play games with aboriginal issues, or else the chaos and the confusion are going to get built on, in terms of what we are seeing in B.C. right now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301456","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"moved:\n\nThat Bill C-10 be amended by deleting the short title.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, before I get to my comments, I would like to draw members' attention to Cancer Awareness Month in honour of my younger sister, my mother and all those fighting this horrible disease; and the support teams who help out those who are trying to fight cancer.\n\nWe are talking today about the government trying to creat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c6d24b231c1cf8ebf04d090ee58854e50710a4cf4dbef292b6babab156de0cd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fd74e54523e1a85ab24739cf260514d1da8f3182bbc3165731cae8621a69c004"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b7e6dde278c447c48e56dd3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301457,"date":"2026-04-21T20:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, with all due respect, you are playing games with aboriginal issues. The Speaker is not, but through the Speaker to the member of the Liberal government, I say that you are playing games. You have 20 years of reports. There is Canada's collaborative modern treaty implementation policy that you have not implemented. Out of that, there is the cabinet directive on the federal approach to modern day treaty implementation that you have not implemented, so you are—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301457","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, with all due respect, you are playing games with aboriginal issues. The Speaker is not, but through the Speaker to the member of the Liberal government, I say that you are playing games. You have 20 years of reports. There is Canada's collaborative modern treaty implementation policy that you have not implemented. Out of that, there is the cabinet directive on the federal approach to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7f1eeb0ca3ff4e18b0f35752ba02f4d253b784747a8209b7e6c1cf19de1851a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e22e307c32f3898df4bb5ecc7a9fa8c4d4c68186327efb0727661c10cd5a4bf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-503aaf5947ace23c0d85c3db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301458,"date":"2026-04-21T20:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am not sure that there is any amendment that could be proposed that would actually breathe life into the agreements. The announcements are all there in black and white. They are detailed right down to the last letter. Creating another position to implement what the government should have been doing right from day one would just give first nations and the Canadian public a false sense of security, even of accomplishment for that matter.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301458","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am not sure that there is any amendment that could be proposed that would actually breathe life into the agreements. The announcements are all there in black and white. They are detailed right down to the last letter. Creating another position to implement what the government should have been doing right from day one would just give first nations and the Canadian public a false sens","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a10ef4b3c4365f926ea0239","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301459,"date":"2026-04-21T20:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, no, I do not think the Liberal government is sincere. Otherwise, why would we need a treaty commissioner, when it is already laid out in a number of agreements and announcements and the treaty itself says that it has to be partnering up on the clauses in each treaty? There were the games in the B.C. legislature as well. An ex-minister from the House was actually hired by the B.C. NDP to settle the pipeline blockade issue. We could not see the report, because the report was deemed an oral report, so we still do not know what the consequences of that were.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301459","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, no, I do not think the Liberal government is sincere. Otherwise, why would we need a treaty commissioner, when it is already laid out in a number of agreements and announcements and the treaty itself says that it has to be partnering up on the clauses in each treaty? There were the games in the B.C. legislature as well. An ex-minister from the House was actually hired by the B.C. NDP ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["013014690dcb7c4b1b442106d948f5a4ccf4cfcf44d58654821388acae2e0f27"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05c711fbd95957e34bae69c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128110,"date":"2026-04-21T21:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Mr. Keating, for coming here and being a witness. We're in a different area here. We're at a crossroads. It's been quite a while since I've actually talked about this in terms of global trade, economics and geopolitics. Canada has the ambition of becoming an energy superpower, but not really mentioning how. Right now, we're celebrating the fact that there will be more oil being sent to the United States in a pipeline. We sell them the majority of our oil already. Energy Newfoundland and Labrador said that the proposed oil and gas emissions cap would have a chilling effect on investment decisions. Could you elaborate on how industrial carbon pricing and measures like the emission caps are affecting the economic investment outlook and long-term viability of offshore energy production in Newfoundland and Labrador? Just for a little bit of context, I had the same issue in Kitimat, B.C., with a $40-billion LNG project, which is basically under the same umbrella and under the same conditions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128110","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Mr. Keating, for coming here and being a witness. We're in a different area here. We're at a crossroads. It's been quite a while since I've actually talked about this in terms of global trade, economics and geopolitics. Canada has the ambition of becoming an energy superpower, but not really mentioning how. Right now, we're celebrating the fact that there will be","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","label":"Oil spills","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9b7c1270e07326674b5c9d4c29fd863c70daa2e6897c5c59a2b3d4ccab6ee5a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc15bf78fa029eac9a81b195610988dc10fe533dd365e84f165dfe6686caf7fd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9cfd07c30a6aff020288fdff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128111,"date":"2026-04-21T21:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. I agree. In fact, what's happening in B.C. right now with LNG Canada is that the lead proponent, Shell, is actually looking for a buyer for three-quarters of its stake in LNG Canada, which is a $40-billion investment, the largest private investment in Canadian history. Mitsubishi is actually looking for buyers for its 15% stake. Both companies are saying it's to rebalance their risk profile, meaning Canada is too risky. There are a lot more jurisdictions that don't have these regulations and legislation in place, and they're going to do a lot better. I mean, look at Russia. They're selling more oil and more gas, as is Venezuela. It seems to me we're pricing ourselves out with these new geopolitics and new geo-energy politics that we're facing. In fact, phase two of LNG Canada is still up in the air. We're not sure if it's Canada or if it's B.C. actually holding back phase two in terms of emissions, or even carbon pricing for that matter. In the midst of all this, I assume that you have some type of approval process in place, maybe a preferred one. Does the Major Projects Office have anything to do with the projects happening in Labrador and Newfoundland?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128111","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I agree. In fact, what's happening in B.C. right now with LNG Canada is that the lead proponent, Shell, is actually looking for a buyer for three-quarters of its stake in LNG Canada, which is a $40-billion investment, the largest private investment in Canadian history. Mitsubishi is actually looking for buyers for its 15% stake. Both companies are saying it's to rebalance their risk pro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c52b4c8db0ad6c965a24803f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128112,"date":"2026-04-21T22:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Dr. Winter, thank you for your testimony. I do like the conversation we're having here, because we're trying to have a thoughtful discussion of consequences and trade-offs. I was an MLA in the B.C. legislature for a few years and was quite shocked when the Business Council of B.C. did an analysis of CleanBC's plan. A lot of mayors across B.C. were also shocked when the BCBC took the B.C. government's numbers and facts and basically compiled them to show that the cumulative economic loss to B.C. would be $109 billion to $132 billion, over 10 years. Are you aware of that analysis, and did you agree with the thought process that went into it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128112","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Dr. Winter, thank you for your testimony. I do like the conversation we're having here, because we're trying to have a thoughtful discussion of consequences and trade-offs. I was an MLA in the B.C. legislature for a few years and was quite shocked when the Business Council of B.C. did an analysis of CleanBC's plan. A lot of mayors across B.C. were also shocked when the BCBC","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b123089b6c662129f627818a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128113,"date":"2026-04-21T22:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Hold on a minute. If you haven't read it, I'll wait until you read it, and then maybe you can give me a thorough analysis of what you think of it. The B.C. government basically tried to downplay it, saying that the Business Council of B.C., the biggest business advocate in B.C., didn't know what they were talking about, even though the author took it from all the graphs and numbers and compiled it. He had to dig for it through all the government pages on the Internet. He had to dig for it, and that's what came out. They didn't deny it. Also, in that same report, the BCBC actually predicted that annual household income would decline by $11,000 annually. When we're talking about the consequences and trade-offs, I don't like to forget the human element. Have you done an analysis of all these policies, whether they be national or provincial, in terms of the impact on the household of the average Canadian individual?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128113","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Hold on a minute. If you haven't read it, I'll wait until you read it, and then maybe you can give me a thorough analysis of what you think of it. The B.C. government basically tried to downplay it, saying that the Business Council of B.C., the biggest business advocate in B.C., didn't know what they were talking about, even though the author took it from all the graphs and numbers and compiled it","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb537605a8e1cea51da94099bae58a92b8489d195f9bac8c96f886f0925b1193"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c49488d7094ce59083a40e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128114,"date":"2026-04-21T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Until I see something else, I'll go by the Business Council of B.C.'s analysis, which the B.C. government hasn't denied. In that context, when we're talking about the consequences and trade-offs—I'm looking at your bio, by the way—I've yet to come across anybody, in terms of the EV mandate, talking about the impact on the land and water. We're all geared towards the emissions, which is good, especially when we're talking about Canada's commitment to it, but nobody seems to talk about what this means to the land base. Whether we're talking about Canada or South Africa, or whether we're talking about different regions around the world that still use forced or slave labour or don't have worker standards or environmental standards.... Has your office actually looked into these consequences or trade-offs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128114","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Until I see something else, I'll go by the Business Council of B.C.'s analysis, which the B.C. government hasn't denied. In that context, when we're talking about the consequences and trade-offs—I'm looking at your bio, by the way—I've yet to come across anybody, in terms of the EV mandate, talking about the impact on the land and water. We're all geared towards the emissions, which is good, espec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["de63e30a32a84d0de4cbbd4018414e778e76e96f790a1d9526a1d3666161838d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54deec26cbe76d26843b8b70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128115,"date":"2026-04-21T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Have you done this internationally?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128115","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Have you done this internationally?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b04c4a41a38c59dc4c038e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128116,"date":"2026-04-21T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"We've heard reports of child labour in Africa, for instance. We've heard about the Uyghurs' treatment in China. This is relevant because the EV mandate has the Liberal government bringing in 49,000 electric vehicles from a country that's reported to have human rights issues. If we're going to have this thoughtful discussion on consequences and trade-offs, I think it has to include everything, including the supply chain. Would you agree with that comment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128116","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We've heard reports of child labour in Africa, for instance. We've heard about the Uyghurs' treatment in China. This is relevant because the EV mandate has the Liberal government bringing in 49,000 electric vehicles from a country that's reported to have human rights issues. If we're going to have this thoughtful discussion on consequences and trade-offs, I think it has to include everything, incl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66d95c51544eda3ebbe45ebd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728664,"date":"2026-04-30T15:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise to table our dissenting Conservative report, in both official languages. While the committee's report documents the failed Liberal emissions reduction plan, it then recommends more of the same. It calls for higher industrial carbon taxes or an oil and gas emissions cap that would drive investment, jobs and production out of Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728664","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise to table our dissenting Conservative report, in both official languages. While the committee's report documents the failed Liberal emissions reduction plan, it then recommends more of the same. It calls for higher industrial carbon taxes or an oil and gas emissions cap that would drive investment, jobs and production out of Canada.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8cf71880cb6a9f5ddcf99148ed5aab3dbd461eb45ce61b5ab13ca43a7d36b07f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5da9c66fa5739bc60101f642e91897d99b9f51d8ded7ee95c531d968f0b4a784"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e84338079c87d95288fc0b54","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728666,"date":"2026-04-30T21:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that speech covered a lot of area, I must admit. A number of the member's colleagues have gotten up and talked about how the Conservatives should get on board, work with them and just agree with the sovereign wealth fund, because it is good for the country. Actually, that is not how this model is set up. The Westminster model is set up with the official opposition, and normally we would go to committee, but committee has been stacked to the point now where we really cannot get debate without the government's votes stacked in its favour. On top of that, most of our committees are now going in camera, so we cannot even discuss what is being discussed in committees.\n\n Does the member have any opinions on how we can actually collaborate, outside of the committees, which have been hamstrung by the new appointments?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728666","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that speech covered a lot of area, I must admit. A number of the member's colleagues have gotten up and talked about how the Conservatives should get on board, work with them and just agree with the sovereign wealth fund, because it is good for the country. Actually, that is not how this model is set up. The Westminster model is set up with the official opposition, and normally we wou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7de206882056f83b3a6516cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128117,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. It seems that part of the mandate for Parks Canada is to expand and establish new protected areas and improve connectivity to contribute to Canada's 30% conservation target by 2030. I have experience in this area, as we did set aside lands for conservation back when I was chief in council for my small band, but it was a very unlevel playing field. We wanted to conserve land, of course, for sensitive areas, but money was an incentive, because we didn't have any. We didn't have any money, and there are a lot of first nations in Canada experiencing the same thing. That shouldn't be a glaring incentive, especially when we see that 30 by 30 is a permanent decision. You can't undo it and, kind of like us, you couldn't even get an exemption. In terms of the expansion of 30 by 30 and the expansion of Parks Canada, what are the measures to ensure it's a level playing field for first nations that don't have the resources otherwise?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128117","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. It seems that part of the mandate for Parks Canada is to expand and establish new protected areas and improve connectivity to contribute to Canada's 30% conservation target by 2030. I have experience in this area, as we did set aside lands for conservation back when I was chief in council for my small band, but it was a very unlevel playing field. We wanted to conserve land","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["39e93c812452db9deae947b2e339de1a74a7744471c51248c54cccea9e0845d4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b5af8d97def5cd5612ccc222e68e614154ae3909f5992e8680ae7497404feb4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9fc6d204fbbc4a5cd721b52c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128118,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Your answer will suffice.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128118","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Your answer will suffice.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d55385ba2e19ad20c90049c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128119,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Maybe I didn't make myself clear. I'm very familiar with the process. I want to know how you level the playing field without making money a primary incentive.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128119","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Maybe I didn't make myself clear. I'm very familiar with the process. I want to know how you level the playing field without making money a primary incentive.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721783","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Amateur sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721783","label":"Amateur sports","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["189bfc89fe3f289af9ded0beb54e27576f09a48ece1805db07618e2e7b238f06"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a75980d2cd209d9087ca9a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128120,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Maybe I can be more clear on my experience. I get the capacity funding, but what it was, really, was forwarding money to us for the long term to protect land, and it was in two pots. One was a finite pot for economic development, which we spent, and the other one was ongoing funding for environmental management from our office, but that actually sterilized the land forever. We tried to go back for exemptions, and we couldn't get them. We're effectively tying the hands of future indigenous leaders. To go back to my point, I thought it was very unfair to use that for a band that had.... Don't get me wrong. We have a lot of money now. We have forestry money and LNG money. That is not an issue for us now, but when we look back on some of those lands we protected, we can't undo it. In my eyes, what I'm seeing now is the same formula being used. That will tie the hands of future first nations leaders, who might not see the inventory of opportunity on the land base. I'm talking about energy, mining and forestry. The governments, the ENGOs and the non-profits came to us and promised us the moon on tourism opportunities, and none of them have materialized. In fact, they all left. They took the money they got from the federal government and the provincial government. They opened up big offices in San Francisco and Vancouver, and we got nothing. In fact, all we got from the provincial government was $15,000 a year to manage protected areas. That example is living right there, right now, under the coast opportunity funds in B.C. Is there any appetite from the government to ensure this process doesn't happen again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128120","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Maybe I can be more clear on my experience. I get the capacity funding, but what it was, really, was forwarding money to us for the long term to protect land, and it was in two pots. One was a finite pot for economic development, which we spent, and the other one was ongoing funding for environmental management from our office, but that actually sterilized the land forever. We tried to go back for","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["94c5ece826f584bd37a0806f6d270fdf60eedf652c334ffbdc7f766402a36512"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c7a35407a855b8657bb8e59fc0c911e12cd5aec1f77e46493663c9a156526d6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-880cd259d821c351a8f45075","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128121,"date":"2026-05-05T22:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Does that include the possibility to exempt or amend those protected areas in the future?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128121","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does that include the possibility to exempt or amend those protected areas in the future?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4a08fe57b7fba7dec19d9f6d831d0b324407f98c6d5260a7e0fccefbab6b65f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbbd6eb1ffef5afc6fe72131","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128122,"date":"2026-05-05T22:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. You can get back to me on this next question. The overlap issues in B.C. are a mess. It is absolute chaos. It has to do with the treaty negotiations that are going on. It has to do with DRIPA. It has to do with all sorts of different issues happening at the same time. In fact, first nations in B.C. are saying that they will block the highway to Prince Rupert if their overlap issues are not addressed within the B.C. treaty process. You can get back to the committee on this in writing, if you please. How will you ensure that this is an open, transparent process with all the first nations affected by overlap issues when you plan to expand 30 by 30 initiatives in B.C.? Madam Chair, I'm tabling a motion that I will move at a future meeting. With my remaining time, I'd like to read it into the record, as follows: That the Standing Committee on Environment and Sustainable Development undertake a study, pursuant to Standing Order 108(2), of at least two meetings, on the environmental and economic impacts of tire recycling and retreading in Canada, with particular attention to low-cost, single-use tire imports; examine their effects on domestic manufacturing, retreading, circular economy goals and waste diversion; consider implications for jobs, competitiveness and supply-chain resilience; and report its findings and recommendations to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128122","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. You can get back to me on this next question. The overlap issues in B.C. are a mess. It is absolute chaos. It has to do with the treaty negotiations that are going on. It has to do with DRIPA. It has to do with all sorts of different issues happening at the same time. In fact, first nations in B.C. are saying that they will block the highway to Prince Rupert if their overlap issues are ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["693c8d64e8e82545910fda03f886d6ec96e5d5283c0e7675a12a6840619b4296"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1f9844c3609d5c0751df7af3bed566fb888ea5dfafaa0a17a9c20ff3f68d783"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d27db0e2cadb8027cf52bf33","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960984,"date":"2026-05-06T19:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, despite the illusions and speeches, it is more cost, more carbon taxes and more of the same. In Skeena—Bulkley Valley, gas prices are up to two dollars a litre. The Liberals claim that gas prices are due to world oil prices being $100 a barrel, but in 2014, under the Conservative government, gas prices were around 45¢ cheaper, and the price of oil at the time was $100 a barrel.\n\nIt is Liberal policies that are hurting the hard-working people of northwest B.C. It is high Liberal taxes and our weak dollar, because of our weak economy. The loonie is down 20% compared to 2014. When we have a weak dollar, every internationally priced commodity, like energy and food, costs more. Why is our dollar weak? It is because Liberal policies blocking resource development are scaring away investment.\n\nThe Prime Minister should take our common-sense plan to remove all taxes on all gas all year, unblock our oil and gas production, and make Canada affordable and strong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960984","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, despite the illusions and speeches, it is more cost, more carbon taxes and more of the same. In Skeena—Bulkley Valley, gas prices are up to two dollars a litre. The Liberals claim that gas prices are due to world oil prices being $100 a barrel, but in 2014, under the Conservative government, gas prices were around 45¢ cheaper, and the price of oil at the time was $100 a barrel.\n\nIt is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["78f852d90d0b84a7395c5cd33f6ccb6047a6123a3bfc6de44cef0562e7315afb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["765fca9d481a5f93775e111bb8238ac406fc27b7224e523674785e415b44010e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c050eaa6f18f21aaaf3370d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960985,"date":"2026-05-06T19:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government directed its lawyers not to argue for property rights in the Cowichan case. The judge then ruled that private property was defective and invalid. Canada must pursue reconciliation with indigenous peoples, but these decisions are moving in the wrong direction. Canadians need the certainty that comes with knowing that their homes and property are theirs. \n\nWith appeals and other court cases coming, why is the Liberal Prime Minister telling his lawyers not to defend private property?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960985","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government directed its lawyers not to argue for property rights in the Cowichan case. The judge then ruled that private property was defective and invalid. Canada must pursue reconciliation with indigenous peoples, but these decisions are moving in the wrong direction. Canadians need the certainty that comes with knowing that their homes and property are theirs. \n\nWith ap","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9e5aa5364b2248e2a6dff85b063241e6a7fe583ed5f4f4a8b9aabb997b945d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5fe998cbb4f3d3d5a1f1b82242ae496e69ca63cecc77d94bce3d2fa943482d1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac4d7078f5fcabea90bdcf64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036352,"date":"2026-05-26T20:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government calls concerns about private property rights fearmongering, yet the Liberals, as the number one defendant, are appealing the Cowichan decision. The Liberal government is depending entirely on Montrose Properties, a private business, to defend private property on behalf of Canadians. On top of this, the Liberals voted against a Conservative motion that would protect private property rights. \n\nCanadian homeowners deserve certainty and clarity. Will the Liberal Prime Minister secure the private property rights of Canadians and provide economic certainty while creating respectful partnerships with first nations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036352","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government calls concerns about private property rights fearmongering, yet the Liberals, as the number one defendant, are appealing the Cowichan decision. The Liberal government is depending entirely on Montrose Properties, a private business, to defend private property on behalf of Canadians. On top of this, the Liberals voted against a Conservative motion that would prot","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1342f66d8536040cf7fa35354d794ff7b944afe4e793053b3b70aa8778f9e2eb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47f697e6d7956172807d8cff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128123,"date":"2026-05-26T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"We'll then go to Ms. Anstey. Ms. Fortin, when we're talking about consultation with first nations on the water initiative we're talking about here today, \"consultation\" is a term that's being thrown around very loosely nowadays, but it has two definitions. One is per section 35 of the Constitution and the pursuant jurisprudence. One is just a basic general notification: \"Hey, what's your opinion?\" What form of consultation and what definition are you going to use when you consult over 600 bands in Canada about water?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128123","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We'll then go to Ms. Anstey. Ms. Fortin, when we're talking about consultation with first nations on the water initiative we're talking about here today, \"consultation\" is a term that's being thrown around very loosely nowadays, but it has two definitions. One is per section 35 of the Constitution and the pursuant jurisprudence. One is just a basic general notification: \"Hey, what's your opinion?\"","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e681a9739683bcffc3373b95ec74a570cd4f5e150fc924138ecdb00d31ab4fcc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f4a48efaf856946e6be95213f87731d744500392b6a9f222e3f388a8b2a62c79"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c397a6caf18f03a0e35825e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128124,"date":"2026-05-26T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Is it a question that's being entertained right now, though? I don't want first nations to be misled in terms of a formal consultation accommodation process—as per the Haida court case of 2004—as opposed to something of just getting some type of comment from 600 bands, say, by email, fax or letter. That is not consultation as per section 35. If you can get back to me with an answer, that would be great, too.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128124","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is it a question that's being entertained right now, though? I don't want first nations to be misled in terms of a formal consultation accommodation process—as per the Haida court case of 2004—as opposed to something of just getting some type of comment from 600 bands, say, by email, fax or letter. That is not consultation as per section 35. If you can get back to me with an answer, that would be ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e14cd46626b644d8d958a9a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128125,"date":"2026-05-26T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128125","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe989e6315bf3d9f75c80e13","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128126,"date":"2026-05-26T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"This will be under the guise of the jurisprudence that actually supports section 35. Will it be that kind of consultation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128126","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This will be under the guise of the jurisprudence that actually supports section 35. Will it be that kind of consultation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aa0443e966d6c7c9acc5c6069231d69822ed7f22303cd9170397a862e4d3a21a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6bae42aaf1611ce07202b546","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128127,"date":"2026-05-26T22:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"That's right.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128127","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's right.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14355deb90be35cc204a108b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128128,"date":"2026-05-26T22:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"That would be great if we could actually define that, so first nations aren't misled. That would be great if you can provide the committee with an answer. I'll turn the time over to Mr. Bexte.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128128","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That would be great if we could actually define that, so first nations aren't misled. That would be great if you can provide the committee with an answer. I'll turn the time over to Mr. Bexte.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b0229cc93381d4c408557ff2f9c0c8c611ae3e689592cd62f06eb69ba9ab482"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-faacea488cbd6e7a2fe56f3a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036353,"date":"2026-05-26T23:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise on behalf of Skeena—Bulkley Valley, and more of an honour to go back over the 20 years of experience I have in project development.\n\nIn 2003, we really did not know what environmental assessment, permitting or aboriginal rights and title were. The Haida court case of 2004 still had not come out yet. By 2004-05, we had to piece it all together and try to understand it. We were living in a condemned residential school building that only had one computer and faxes, but we did it. To understand the process to achieve our objectives was the goal, because nothing else worked for us to get our people out of poverty and to get us out from the paternalistic Indian Act. We tried tourism, forestry and programs, but nothing worked, so we changed our strategy after a while and started engaging the economy. That is how Peace in the Forest, LNG and our deliberations on oil came about. It was all based on process, not on ideology or politics. What is the process in place here? How is the government going to ensure that it is going to engage first nations, as per section 35 of the Constitution?\n\nI see that the Prime Minister made an announcement in Vancouver a few days ago saying that it was non-negotiable to deal with aboriginal rights and title. Somehow, people clapped like he invented sliced bread. That has been in place since 2004. The processes that we developed, first nations along with the Crown, the communication processes to breathe life into the Haida court case of 2004, are well established. That ship has sailed.\n\n Now the question is whether the Liberal government is going to override all those processes and all that case law to fast-track a project, meaning a pipeline to the west coast of B.C. We have to remember where this came from. The Prime Minister sold himself as the person who could get control of Trump. That was it. Then, from then on, we started to hear all the doublespeak. Back then, the quote was, from the Prime Minister, \"We will win this trade war and build the strongest economy in the G7.\" He gave up on that. Then, he changed the narrative to \"Many of our former strengths, based on our close ties to America, have become weaknesses—weaknesses that we must correct.\" That has not gone over so well.\n\nThere was the slogan of \"elbows up\", but I guess Trump did not get the idea of what elbows up meant. Then the Prime Minister said, \"Canada...has the best trade deal with the United States. While it's different from what we had before, it is still better than that of any other country.\"\n\nI think that by now, Canadians understand that tariffs are here to stay. It does not matter if someone is a Republican or Democrat down in the United States, tariffs are here to stay. It got so bad for the Liberals that they hired a former Conservative leader to be part of the negotiation team to see if they could salvage something, but it is not looking so great.\n\nThe promise during the campaign was to invoke the Emergencies Act to get projects built, but that was scratched. Then, it was the Building Canada Act. When people come to me and ask what it is all about, I have to tell them that I do not know; I have no idea.\n\nI get process, but this is now such a scattered plan. We just heard the Liberals debating against tanker traffic. It is their MOU with Alberta, not ours. They have the gall to mention that there was no consultation on this bill. There was no consultation on the MOU or the co-operation agreement. Even with Pathways, they made the announcement of carbon sequestration and then they went over to the first nation and said, \"Okay, now we are going to consult with you,\" even though they had made the decision.\n\nIt was an afterthought. There was no respect for section 35 of the Constitution. Then the government brought in the doublespeak again. To save face, it was going to talk about consent. It had already made a deal to fast-track a project within one year, with shovels in the ground and all that stuff. Then the Prime Minister said that he would not do anything without consent, not only the consent of the first nations, which would have to be an elaborate plan, but also the consent of the Premier of British Columbia. The government was fighting against its own MOU. It was fighting against its own co-operation agreement. It was fighting against its own Building Canada Act.\n\nAll this mixed messaging is failing Canadians. The biggest announcement in the last year to diversify our oil exports was to revive Keystone to bring more oil to the United States. That is not even ironic. The idea was to get away from or at least diversify the markets away from America, not build up more dependence.\n\nWhen we are talking about the tanker ban itself, we have to know what it is. The ban prohibits oil tankers from stopping, unloading or loading in any port in a designated area. That is it because currently people are allowed to import or export, or even load or unload, 12,500 metric tons of crude oil or persistent oil products.\n\nThe Liberals talked about diesel spills on the west coast, which have been happening for the last 100 years. Tugboats go down. Seine boats go down. Gillnetters go down. It does not matter what one's background or ethnicity is. Everybody who owns a boat that sank has contributed to that diesel or gasoline spill. That is not new. In fact, the first nations that still depend on diesel for electricity have had spills at their docks. Now we are trying to eradicate that, of course, but it is going to take time.\n\nWe are talking about a voluntary exclusion zone, a buffer zone between tankers and much of B.C.'s coast extending further offshore. We saw the story of an oil tanker going up Hecate Strait between the mainland of B.C. and Haida Gwaii, but we did not get an explanation as to why. I thought it was because of the International Maritime Organization's laws, which Canada is a signatory to. We are talking about safety. There was a rumour saying that it is a shorter distance for an oil tanker to come up from Burnaby, B.C., to go up the strait and then head over to China. That is not much of a tanker ban. The risk is still there.\n\nThe Liberal government likes to talk about risk, but fails to mention all the tankers coming from Alaska to Washington State. What does Washington State do with that crude oil? It turns it into aviation jet fuel, gas and diesel, and we buy it from Washington State. We do not have a domestic energy policy. We are vulnerable. We saw the flooding that happened on the Coquihalla Highway in B.C. It got to a point where the Americans came to B.C.'s rescue. B.C. residents were rationed to 30 litres at a time for a fill-up at a gas station. What did Washington State do? It supplemented B.C.'s supply of gasoline and diesel by barging up more gas and diesel. At that time, the NDP premier mused about expanding the refinery capacity at Burnaby, trying to get away from this vulnerability that Canadians face. \n\nThere is also a penalty for violating this voluntary tanker moratorium. It can include fines of up to $5 million for each instance of non-compliance. It does not mention anything about Americans. It does not mention anything about the tankers coming from Burnaby.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Diesel fuel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036353","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise on behalf of Skeena—Bulkley Valley, and more of an honour to go back over the 20 years of experience I have in project development.\n\nIn 2003, we really did not know what environmental assessment, permitting or aboriginal rights and title were. The Haida court case of 2004 still had not come out yet. By 2004-05, we had to piece it all together and try to underst","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","label":"Diesel fuel"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Diesel fuel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","label":"Diesel fuel","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["16974f54d7b96fb994419e154cafd45d91cb742ccb335873600fbaab10f67d5b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Diesel fuel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1324e3a711d8c8d802233d8a5df646dadf1172b823bc05c4694ec6e688a9aec4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Diesel fuel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Diesel fuel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05b7824e7f6c2892f61c7e1a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128129,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. To the minister, the news so far is about major project development in terms of fast-tracking and even pre-approvals. However, in terms of the actual environmental certificate that will be issued for a major project, which agency will be issuing the certificate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128129","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. To the minister, the news so far is about major project development in terms of fast-tracking and even pre-approvals. However, in terms of the actual environmental certificate that will be issued for a major project, which agency will be issuing the certificate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth certificates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Birth certificates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","label":"Birth certificates","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["78baed7564dfe3e752d1f4ec211899bc709b145ca4eda5001d4fe47d6e142bfd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["34c34b91146107b15ffc4dc3700a197da39071e4e1f0169afbaf6760c58990f4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-976b073f3e138ec130626bd5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128130,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Let's be more specific, then. Say it's designated under the Major Projects Office for fast approval or pre-approval. Will the Major Projects Office issue the environmental certificate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128130","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Let's be more specific, then. Say it's designated under the Major Projects Office for fast approval or pre-approval. Will the Major Projects Office issue the environmental certificate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b383645d7649a2a7d70a3e62a6e4658258f0a32c2773a41884b197c817e64b18"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ce8b9b71a2f9e3368de5d06","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128131,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"The Canadian Impact Assessment Agency will issue this certificate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128131","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Canadian Impact Assessment Agency will issue this certificate.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth certificates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Birth certificates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083630","label":"Birth certificates","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["25ef1d28bab34eb7253e2b5894f2dbd1f1d8a56fbad80f8cbb2fa3724a8aee83"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff2dab9bf051a77f286fdcf8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128132,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Does that mean that it's not the environment minister?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128132","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does that mean that it's not the environment minister?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","label":"Environment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6b20badf508f58028be227eb8daf2529a32b7f5a72a47a58d721cfa32ce8adf1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de77cfdfed685d31b4fd16e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128133,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Will it have any tie-in to your ministry?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128133","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Will it have any tie-in to your ministry?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-849c4c67fc0a33740f19dd79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128134,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"In that respect then, your ministry will basically not be the lead in environmental assessments. You will provide assistance, and that will be it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128134","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In that respect then, your ministry will basically not be the lead in environmental assessments. You will provide assistance, and that will be it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4ee03089ddd863d83f38feeeb2e51a546b2eba854095c2dcaa2bb48e4987853"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34d16821b015049d89fa16c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128135,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"You will not issue the certificate to the building Canada....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128135","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You will not issue the certificate to the building Canada....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17c56039544d39db18c632d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128136,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"I understand that, but the Major Projects Office for pre-approval or fast approval will be the lead. It won't be your ministry that will issue the certificate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128136","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I understand that, but the Major Projects Office for pre-approval or fast approval will be the lead. It won't be your ministry that will issue the certificate.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["171d64ad963521f41be47b75b52309434ea52e60032168376139bb659076a4ea"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2cfd7f3c275677246fe0764c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128137,"date":"2026-05-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"No, I'm not talking about co-operation. I'm talking about the ministry's responsibilities. That's well laid out already in legislation and regulation, and everybody understands that currently it is the Canadian Impact Assessment Agency that takes the lead and issues a certificate, but right now, I'm seeing this turning into a three-headed beast. You talk about the Major Projects Office's being the designated agency to fast-track or pre-approve, but then there's a different ministry that will issue the certificate. My understanding now is that the Major Projects Office will take the lead, but they will use the resources that are currently there under the Canadian Impact Assessment Agency for the resources to assess a major project for fast approval.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128137","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"No, I'm not talking about co-operation. I'm talking about the ministry's responsibilities. That's well laid out already in legislation and regulation, and everybody understands that currently it is the Canadian Impact Assessment Agency that takes the lead and issues a certificate, but right now, I'm seeing this turning into a three-headed beast. You talk about the Major Projects Office's being the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01b97eb9cf7aa584a9934301c6df80c83bf6752a21dda80134903abbb500e1ac"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f2ce18ec7b697322cb649f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128138,"date":"2026-05-28T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'd like to start with Ms. Johnson, please. The minister was just here talking about the agreement that was signed in my riding, by the way, in Klemtu—or Kitasoo. The older name is Kitasoo. He was talking about a conservation land agreement. It's quite interesting. One of the provisions speaks about open-net fish farms. Kitasoo has had a fish farm for the better part of 30 years. In the context of this agreement, is the idea of the fish farms provision to continue the phase-out under Canada's plan to June 30, 2029, or is it to renegotiate fish farms in the context of Kitasoo's fish farms?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128138","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'd like to start with Ms. Johnson, please. The minister was just here talking about the agreement that was signed in my riding, by the way, in Klemtu—or Kitasoo. The older name is Kitasoo. He was talking about a conservation land agreement. It's quite interesting. One of the provisions speaks about open-net fish farms. Kitasoo has had a fish farm for the better part of 30 ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","label":"Fish farming"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","label":"Fish farming","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["325a60dcf9baf8184f3c7981bec506a6563bfbf503322e0a5ef660f00940619a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc0655a0fa1712551d38c4523b27683bcc0c19168c1a4c7131fcbddb6b41a832"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-122e397f907e2a6c4beb550f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128139,"date":"2026-05-28T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"The plan is to continue the phase-out to June 30, 2029.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128139","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The plan is to continue the phase-out to June 30, 2029.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["58c02f1c423d14e8dad895ea3f196254858e4fb6a3a2a7da908c95f8bbdd152c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c13b24463cd1af93345eb5f47e64d2c48365db44ed5b7b121f21317c44bde774"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b610e0f1bf466d99aed45cac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128140,"date":"2026-05-28T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"That's regarding the phase-out. Okay. In that respect and in that decision, consent wasn't a big term back then, but now it is. Will Canada be pursuing consent from Kitasoo to phase out fish farms by 2029?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128140","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's regarding the phase-out. Okay. In that respect and in that decision, consent wasn't a big term back then, but now it is. Will Canada be pursuing consent from Kitasoo to phase out fish farms by 2029?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","label":"Fisheries technology","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5d0563fd6c3c8dbd495536aa4353bddd7a8df375466aa021a033fdbb6c007733"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac65fd0d3855d7f6af63e39c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128141,"date":"2026-05-28T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Is this not a conversation for the agreement itself, the conservation agreement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128141","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Is this not a conversation for the agreement itself, the conservation agreement?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["34fd1f4611e83d77e87758ec215857ca00edac6c542edda7dc479284f7728f87"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-819c055f3504cc7be9947541","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128142,"date":"2026-05-28T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. I'm trying to understand the process in terms of fast-tracking or pre-approving a major project, especially a linear project that goes across provincial boundaries, and I didn't really get a good answer yet, even though this is the third kick at the can. Really, when we're talking about the fragmented process that we have now between the Major Projects Office and the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, we still don't understand how aboriginal rights and title interests get addressed on a one-year approval process under the Major Projects Office. Does that timeline coincide with the consultation and accommodation of aboriginal rights and title for those affected first nations along a pipeline, for example?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128142","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I'm trying to understand the process in terms of fast-tracking or pre-approving a major project, especially a linear project that goes across provincial boundaries, and I didn't really get a good answer yet, even though this is the third kick at the can. Really, when we're talking about the fragmented process that we have now between the Major Projects Office and the Impact Assessment A","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8253578eaed65fc98e05e82969251e46eaf6f028c890e93dac645fd11c7e3e9b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5cc9fc7cf5fd4c6968f5c93d141639c151827b9d6be2a945980128cd84c00ed9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93ab2263aaba07c3743742c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128143,"date":"2026-05-28T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"I get the process, and when I say \"third kick at the can\", I mean that I still haven't had an answer on the process. I'll leave that aside and try to decipher what the minister said, but in the context of aboriginal rights and title between the Major Projects Office, the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada and the new first nations hub they're proposing, will the timeline for consultation and accommodation of aboriginal rights and title coincide with a fast-track approval or a one-year approval term for approval of major projects?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128143","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I get the process, and when I say \"third kick at the can\", I mean that I still haven't had an answer on the process. I'll leave that aside and try to decipher what the minister said, but in the context of aboriginal rights and title between the Major Projects Office, the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada and the new first nations hub they're proposing, will the timeline for consultation and accom","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["04a84701b4c869bea4713e676eb9409b627c72778eb45aec82d4e00c37fd1554"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f0151eea237fc775cd9f5814b8aec27d4bef8cad7fda0609bf15ffcab47f636e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c2084ce51139609dacefd62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128144,"date":"2026-05-28T17:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Let me give you a scenario. There's a pre-approval of a project, but you haven't completed the consultation and accommodation. You don't have the consent yet. Does the pre-approval still stand even though you haven't completed the rights and title consultation and accommodation process?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128144","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Let me give you a scenario. There's a pre-approval of a project, but you haven't completed the consultation and accommodation. You don't have the consent yet. Does the pre-approval still stand even though you haven't completed the rights and title consultation and accommodation process?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child custody","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child custody","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","label":"Child custody","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["960c73f73d92a7697ce6ba8b15aa43416eb52f4bae64ed3eb5cefb1d57a6bc54"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a099ea43428f4c7865d29ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128145,"date":"2026-05-28T17:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Yes, but isn't that the chicken before the egg? You're talking about pre-approval, but you haven't completed the consultation and accommodation. You don't have consent. In that context as well—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128145","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes, but isn't that the chicken before the egg? You're talking about pre-approval, but you haven't completed the consultation and accommodation. You don't have consent. In that context as well—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poultry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036469","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Oats","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036469","label":"Oats","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","label":"Poultry","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6ee939ba72fd1ac34064576062bec5e285c6a8773a0ebae864d6660809cb62d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59cfa691628aa8e467130fa2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084430,"date":"2026-06-03T21:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the secretary of state for the description of the bill. I agree fully, and I have agreed fully for 20 years as an aboriginal leader, as an MLA and now as an MP. However, I do have a specific question about the Gladue principle. Would that principle survive, or would it get struck down with this bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084430","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the secretary of state for the description of the bill. I agree fully, and I have agreed fully for 20 years as an aboriginal leader, as an MLA and now as an MP. However, I do have a specific question about the Gladue principle. Would that principle survive, or would it get struck down with this bill?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ac8088c12d7f79d6674b3958a9eb05e4fff268993fa4171d59dbe49a2e958c1b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["488e8c5b80c8d0c43fe576c913f3895f52b0969299c11a9b19ef7c827c3d985c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-23d42a6e8eca00ef2bf08d2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084424,"date":"2026-06-04T22:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member's speech was passionate, and I agree. Coming from where I do, the north coast of British Columbia, I have experienced that most of my life.\n\nThe government wants to portray this side of the House as not being supportive of this type of bill or protecting vulnerable people. The Conservative member for York Centre moved an amendment, CPC-13, that was defeated by the Liberal government. It would have protected child pornography possession and access offences from charter challenges under section 7 and section 12 by enacting the notwithstanding clause, while also preventing these offences from benefiting from the bill's mandatory minimum safety valve.\n\nWhy did the government not protect victims in this equation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084424","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member's speech was passionate, and I agree. Coming from where I do, the north coast of British Columbia, I have experienced that most of my life.\n\nThe government wants to portray this side of the House as not being supportive of this type of bill or protecting vulnerable people. The Conservative member for York Centre moved an amendment, CPC-13, that was defeated by the Liberal g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["642a0bdbad94a8cab718db59f81ea62ea533e150cac07921cad328590d526008"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e0debe4c759b653d3dd94586d5b94c4416278e424b5e436334c0861c21f61f52"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aea1222712b9cfd6ba659d11","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084425,"date":"2026-06-04T22:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to get up on behalf of Skeena—Bulkley Valley to talk about Bill C-16, the protecting victims act.\n\nBefore I get into the substance of the bill itself, I want to explain the term \"safety valve\", because just about every speaker has spoken to this term. It is a mechanism that allows judges to give lesser sentences, as opposed to a strict mandatory minimum sentence. If we are going to give weaker sentences instead of imposing a strict mandatory minimum sentence for some of these crimes, then what is the point of using the term \"mandatory minimum sentence\", especially when we are talking about protecting women and vulnerable victims?\n\nEven when the government members themselves get up and debate, they admit that the bill is long overdue. In fact, when I was an MLA, we were talking about crimes and how there should be punishment. At the time, the NDP government actually blamed Ottawa for not amending or introducing more legislation. I agree. This is a long time coming.\n\nIt just so happens that a \"southern Alberta man faces criminal charges after police say they found more than half a million child sexual exploitation photos and videos in his possession.... More than 500,000 child sexual exploitation photos and videos were discovered, [making it] one of the largest collections the unit has ever encountered\".\n\nLike every other case that has been in the media in the last year or so, this just makes me sick. A lot of other leaders have said the same thing. It makes them sick. I know some premiers who have made some pretty inflammatory comments about what should be done with these kinds of people.\n\nIt is good that the legislation is up. Is it groundbreaking? Does it go to the full extent of protecting victims? We have to give credit to the Conservatives, who have been asking for the legislation for years. Finally, it is being recognized in Bill C-16, not just in terms of debate but also in terms of some of the content that we are talking about that is in Bill C-16. \n\nMaking the murder of an intimate partner first-degree actually came from the Conservative MP for Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. Expanding the offence prohibiting the non-consensual distribution of sexual deepfakes, digitally manipulated pictures or video using artificial intelligence, came from the Conservative MP for Calgary Nose Hill. Updating mandatory requirements for child exploitation material came from previous Conservative governments. We are pleased to see that the government took its lead from Conservative MPs.\n\nTo try to frame it now, politically, that Conservatives do not support this or that, somehow, we do not agree with protecting victims is misleading Canadians. That is not the truth. If anything, Conservatives have been leading the charge to actually punish offenders for years.\n\nIt is now here, but one of the best tools of this institution is committee work. I did not realize that until I got to Ottawa, because committees in the B.C. legislature are different.\n\nThe Liberal government stacked the committees to, basically, get its own way in terms of votes. Not only is it now a slim margin of votes so that the Liberal government can get everything it wants in a committee, but it actually stacked it even further so that there is no chance of any amendments proposed by any opposition parties. I am talking about the Bloc. I am talking about the Conservatives.\n\nThe committee is there for a purpose. It is to collaborate. It is to represent the interests and needs of Canadians, the interests and needs of the constituents we represent.\n\n The Liberal government is framing this as one of the most ambitious pieces of legislation that has come down the pike in a long time. That is not true. It could have been better. In terms of amendments regarding safety valves, there were six put forward by Conservatives that were all voted down by the Liberal committee members. There was one from the member for Brantford—Brant South—Six Nations that would have narrowed the mandatory minimum safety valves to only apply to offenders with no prior criminal record. There was one from the member for York Centre, another Conservative, that would have required courts to consider only offenders' actual circumstances, not hypothetical scenarios such as what the court is saying, when assessing the constitutionality of mandatory minimums. It was voted down by the Liberals. \n\nThere was another one from the member for Brantford—Brant South—Six Nations that would have excluded serious offences, including child sexual offences and major drug trafficking offences, from accessing the mandatory minimum safety valve. This means that we wanted the full extent of the law applied to these offenders, especially drug traffickers, sex traffickers and those having anything to do with violent crime. We should give them not a lesser penalty but the full mandatory sentence. We should keep the full mandatory sentence in play. If we really want to protect women, vulnerable victims and children, we should keep that mandatory sentence. If anyone wants to challenge it, they can challenge it in the courts. The Liberal government is so afraid of being challenged through the charter. If victims or Canadians cannot depend on us as lawmakers to stand up and fight for them, and they cannot depend on the courts, who are they going to depend on? There is nobody left. The Liberals should take on the challenge. The Supreme Court can use a challenge, especially when we are talking about a lesser, weaker sentence for some of the worst offenders in our society. It is getting worse. \n\nThere were six amendments put together for that safety valve, and each one was voted down. There were two amendments for victims' rights put together by my Conservative colleagues, and they were voted down by the Liberal committee members. One was put together by the member for Elgin—St. Thomas—London South that would have ensured victims of intimate partner violence and coercive control are notified without delay of release orders or recognizance. It was voted down. There was another one from the same member that would have required the Parole Board chairperson to disclose offender information without delay to the victims of intimate partner violence or coercive control offences. It was voted down. \n\nThe bill could have been stronger. We could have sent a strong message to the women and vulnerable victims in Canada, saying that we are going to fight for them. We are going to take on the Supreme Court, and if the Supreme Court rules against us, we will think of another fight. Each and every MP could have taken that pledge together, but we did not. The Liberal government backed down at committee through majority votes on each one of these amendments. \n\nThere were six other defeated amendments. The one put together by the member for York Centre would have protected against charter challenges to child pornography, possession and access offences under sections 7 and 12 by enacting the notwithstanding clause while also preventing these offences from benefiting from the bill's mandatory minimum safety valve. It was voted down. \n\nFour pages of amendments were voted down by the Liberal committee members. There were also amendments ruled out of scope, and each one of these amendments was just trying to further strengthen the bill so offenders could not get away. I know there are going to be lawyers arguing this and fighting for lesser sentences or no sentence at all. I know that.\n\n However, as legislators, we are the last stop. We are the last hope. Given that the Liberal government actually took recommendations from Conservatives and implemented them in this bill is commendable. To be truly ambitious, the Liberals should not have voted out the rest of the amendments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084425","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to get up on behalf of Skeena—Bulkley Valley to talk about Bill C-16, the protecting victims act.\n\nBefore I get into the substance of the bill itself, I want to explain the term \"safety valve\", because just about every speaker has spoken to this term. It is a mechanism that allows judges to give lesser sentences, as opposed to a strict mandatory minimum sentence. If we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["581162f41c05e06a0164d954d4a7c2a9db5ceadddff56a0d84d629a5d7b92319"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0c1f9cc335858c987255d4b744eebd0dd7cfafbedcee29dc2093df2d8b59b3b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9ebd9553b9a6998736d02f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084426,"date":"2026-06-04T22:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, that was not the point. The point is that we should actually impose a mandatory sentencing for these offenders. That is it. That is the starting point.\n\n We could have made the legislation so much stronger if we had actually taken more of the amendments that were proposed by my colleagues. Instead, we have watered it down.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084426","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, that was not the point. The point is that we should actually impose a mandatory sentencing for these offenders. That is it. That is the starting point.\n\n We could have made the legislation so much stronger if we had actually taken more of the amendments that were proposed by my colleagues. Instead, we have watered it down.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["48d5407b79d64b6b14bcc13ed69d7ca8c33221cdc2ce26e2ee4fae250e0d5043"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["45963cfd457c77a86a5cd26f8963ca921158d0d05a461968b52dac7cbf334462"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49c012a93225c095452cb900","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084427,"date":"2026-06-04T22:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it could have been stronger. There were even amendments talking about crimes committed with firearms. The Liberal government, through committee majority, voted them down as well.\n\n All I am saying is the amendments that were rejected could have made this bill so much stronger, including the amendments that dealt with firearms.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084427","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it could have been stronger. There were even amendments talking about crimes committed with firearms. The Liberal government, through committee majority, voted them down as well.\n\n All I am saying is the amendments that were rejected could have made this bill so much stronger, including the amendments that dealt with firearms.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3369f653cb2e4e256132488bf539a1dcd52af803213ec84e6ea2164df91181c7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c07b063e4d18486f80862d7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084428,"date":"2026-06-04T22:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the gun buyback or confiscation plan is actually going after law-abiding citizens who have PALS and get training. For those who have restricted firearms, the bar is even higher. They are not going to get safety valves. They are going to get a mandatory sentencing.\n\n Anything under this is going to get reduced sentences, and that is including firearms offences. The Conservatives have been saying that we have to start tightening the controls and the laws around firearms, especially connected to crimes, but not law-abiding citizens.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084428","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the gun buyback or confiscation plan is actually going after law-abiding citizens who have PALS and get training. For those who have restricted firearms, the bar is even higher. They are not going to get safety valves. They are going to get a mandatory sentencing.\n\n Anything under this is going to get reduced sentences, and that is including firearms offences. The Conservatives have b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["82fa354fd01d95bf6c5968e1ee3c07232434a055ca0e9ba8f2d7cc45bd0ac9be"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5df216b110aee0b88b6d60f43eaa74471d263272e31aae233c696d70cc5c555a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77d57d9455181420bf92dd8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084429,"date":"2026-06-04T22:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is a political decision. That is what it is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084429","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It is a political decision. That is what it is.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30f4deaa704342eaa03ffc60","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128146,"date":"2026-06-09T21:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Madam Chair, it's a motion on retrofitting for energy efficiency. When we're talking about it, we hear it from the government all the time that this is an existential crisis—climate change, the Paris accord—yet we have members who resigned from the net-zero committee coming to explain why they lost faith in the climate action plan in Canada. We hear it all the time that this is one of the single biggest issues facing Canadians, if not our global partners, when talking about clean energy, fossil fuels, you name it. What do we do? We waste time and muzzle our witnesses with a motion to look at heating efficiencies for houses. Some hon. members: Oh, oh! Ellis Ross: Is this really a big issue, as the government has been saying for the last how many years, or is this just an attempt to muzzle our witnesses, who are giving what we—as well as our colleagues down the way here—see as extremely important witness testimony?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128146","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Chair, it's a motion on retrofitting for energy efficiency. When we're talking about it, we hear it from the government all the time that this is an existential crisis—climate change, the Paris accord—yet we have members who resigned from the net-zero committee coming to explain why they lost faith in the climate action plan in Canada. We hear it all the time that this is one of the single b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69dbb189f09534b9c75e4b48","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086476,"date":"2026-06-10T23:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there are important life-saving drugs that Canadians might not be able to access in a timely manner. Some Canadians are suffering from serious conditions and cannot access proven life-saving drugs. We know the risks, and we know the science behind these drugs is sound. Those are not the problems. The problems facing Canadians trying to access life-saving drugs are too much paperwork and too much bureaucracy. That is why we are debating Bill C-265 today, so we can get life-saving drugs to Canadians who need them in a timely and efficient manner.\n\nThis is an act to amend the Food and Drugs Act. To be more clear, it is meant to provide a list of therapeutic products pre-approved for special access. \"Pre-approved\" is the key word. Pre-approved drugs cut down on time and bureaucracy. Canada already has a program designed for Canadians with serious or rare conditions when no other treatments exist. It is called the special access program. The problem is that there are no provisions for pre-approved drugs that are based on precedent. The special access program was meant to open a door to therapies already proven to be effective elsewhere. The intent was there, the intent was good, but the implementation failed.\n\nIn 2025 alone, over 11,000 requests were processed, but each request was treated as a new request. Repeated requests were treated as new requests, instead of a consistent and efficient system that recognized the suffering and complications that some Canadians were experiencing. These are drugs requested before by Canadian doctors, drugs approved by jurisdictions that we consider to be our peers and drugs with real-world data behind them, yet each application started from scratch. Not only do doctors have to go through this process time and time again, but the patients also have to apply time and time again.\n\nMy own brother, who suffers from a rare spinal disease, had to go through this for years. When his medications ran out, he would have to wait for his application to be approved so he could resume pain management. This left a gap. This left him to self-medicate with non-prescription drugs, which he hated to do, but he could not bear the pain, and I do not blame him. How many other people have considered this option? If the special access program was streamlined for well-established use cases, people like my brother would have less pain and definitely less stress, especially when the drug is referred to as \"life-saving\". The paperwork and bureaucracy do not produce or generate new data. They do not generate new knowledge, but they take up time. For patients with serious conditions, time is a valuable commodity.\n\nThere is no doubt that the Conservatives support this bill, but there are problems with it. My time is limited, so I will not go through them, but many of my colleagues have pointed out the problems with the bill. It is our wish that this bill go to committee.\n\nOne of the problems is that the bill, as presented, would open the door for dangerous drugs to make it onto the pre-approved list and would effectively create a loophole that would make it easy for people suffering from drug use to be prescribed methamphetamine as liquid caffeine. This is far from being hypothetical. Through the special access program, requests for drugs like LSD and MDMA have in fact been made.\n\nMembers may also recall that restrictions on the special access program existed to limit opioid diversion under the Harper government. In 2013, then health minister Rona Ambrose amended the program after learning that Health Canada had approved a request granting 21 patients with chronic addictions access to prescription heroin. However, the Trudeau Liberal government later lifted the restrictions that Conservatives had imposed on illegal and harmful substances, such as LSD, heroin and cocaine. Conservatives had put those restrictions in there for a reason. \n\n We look forward to seeing this go to committee for more amendments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086476","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there are important life-saving drugs that Canadians might not be able to access in a timely manner. Some Canadians are suffering from serious conditions and cannot access proven life-saving drugs. We know the risks, and we know the science behind these drugs is sound. Those are not the problems. The problems facing Canadians trying to access life-saving drugs are too much paperwork a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d42e00dc1039a72e4251131a89f6829856293a2d7ce204ad525a7cb1d4f13c40"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9b88d1a09a20e9e732340c48c70217da89f270a9bf7fa6acf1368e2f4fbe52d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b43e3fc0aaee63cb0f8f168","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128147,"date":"2026-06-11T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, witnesses, for your testimony. I am indigenous. I come from Kitamaat Village, B.C. I appreciate the comments saying that you'll look for indigenous knowledge, but to be clear, indigenous people use plastics just as much as non-indigenous people do. It's an affordability issue, and it's a safety issue when we're talking about food packaging. We've been struggling for answers to the same questions that you're posing today in terms of the marine environment, for example, for rivers and oceans. I do eat seafood four times a week still. In saying that and in talking about affordability and the safety of food packaging that plastics provide, this question is for Ms. Rochman. Should the federal government ban single-use plastics used in food packaging and in grocery stores?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128147","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, witnesses, for your testimony. I am indigenous. I come from Kitamaat Village, B.C. I appreciate the comments saying that you'll look for indigenous knowledge, but to be clear, indigenous people use plastics just as much as non-indigenous people do. It's an affordability issue, and it's a safety issue when we're talking about food packaging. We've been struggling ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Plastics industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","label":"Plastics industry","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0cff684a5d38a5e6778a2bcac1ff10047f00348cd60448e8c9e5089f347970eb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40054dfb095872a10b13ac702912f02b810dec75ee11a79e81a87b9bb4590109"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4125f03c863486ed785f6839","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128148,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"How about meat?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128148","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How about meat?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e712ad11f2f78bc04c62dc3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128149,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"I see. Has the federal government indicated any openness to a ban of single-use plastics in grocery stores?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128149","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I see. Has the federal government indicated any openness to a ban of single-use plastics in grocery stores?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Plastics industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","label":"Plastics industry","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c68c371d8f877568d5f1dc62307e0fe9d34fb1c95cc29fd3bf63b697ab46baaa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ddd631dc9696a3a76b47ad89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128150,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. Mr. Ross, I was intrigued by your comments about the content and how it's ending up in our environment. To my understanding, what you said is that we're all polluters, including every one of us who wears a suit. Each one of us has synthetic fibres that are working their way into our environment every time we wash our clothes. I have never heard that before. Canada is at least trying. They're trying, and I'll give you an example of synthetic fibres in tires. B.C. is trying to regulate this, and they're doing a pretty good job, but 15% of every tire makes it into our environment. It's regulated so that we know exactly what's in a tire and we know exactly what's getting into the environment. Unfortunately, that does not speak to other countries that use loopholes to get commercial tires into our market in B.C. We don't know what's in those tires coming from China, for example. As an option, what B.C. is considering is higher fees for British Columbians, who obey the rules, to cover the costs of these single-use tires coming in from China. Is there anything that Canada can do to help persuade the provinces not to import and other countries not to export products that don't abide by our environmental regulations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128150","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Ross, I was intrigued by your comments about the content and how it's ending up in our environment. To my understanding, what you said is that we're all polluters, including every one of us who wears a suit. Each one of us has synthetic fibres that are working their way into our environment every time we wash our clothes. I have never heard that before. Canada is at least trying. Th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","label":"Environment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037001","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rubber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037001","label":"Rubber industry","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","label":"Environment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6a1f84457965351b870bd7fd673995a94bc553fe2342213e6cea001a6746131f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["582b8a85887b3637ed26a437d43edc489380f84ef4399e1d147ce7f34c2afdff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e28da04e49192d494bee9573","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128151,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"How does the government square this? Canadians want to do good by the environment. They are recycling their tires. They are bringing them to approved facilities, and yet there's a huge amount of single-use tires coming from China that can't be recycled. We don't know what's in those tires. Basically, somehow they're not even being recycled. They're ending up in our landfills. Canadians have to foot the bill for this. I think this is important right now. The federal government is talking about a new trade agreement with China, and yet they haven't resolved the environmental impact of these single-use tires ending up in our Canadian environment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128151","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How does the government square this? Canadians want to do good by the environment. They are recycling their tires. They are bringing them to approved facilities, and yet there's a huge amount of single-use tires coming from China that can't be recycled. We don't know what's in those tires. Basically, somehow they're not even being recycled. They're ending up in our landfills. Canadians have to foo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03b3e97b90aaa84a88969399","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128152,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"In terms of a single-use product coming from China, that's a tire that can't be recycled. We don't know the content, and everybody's turning a blind eye to it. How do we address that as Canadians? How do we get the federal government and the provincial governments to actually take it seriously?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128152","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In terms of a single-use product coming from China, that's a tire that can't be recycled. We don't know the content, and everybody's turning a blind eye to it. How do we address that as Canadians? How do we get the federal government and the provincial governments to actually take it seriously?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c50151924e72aa23fcdce805","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128153,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Those products—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128153","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Those products—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00c534185e2d2b17046d34e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128154,"date":"2026-06-11T17:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, witnesses, for your testimony. Mr. Moffatt, you talked a bit about the economy. This committee has heard different testimony on a circular economy. Really, we have to expand on that, being a global economy, because we know the federal government has actually lifted part of its plastics ban so that Canadian businesses won't be impacted. They're allowed to export plastics to the United States, just to keep the economy and businesses going. In Prince Rupert, plastic pellets are exported to Asia, where they will make products with low environmental standards and low labour standards, and Canadians will buy back the finished product. That shows you how complicated this problem is. We're talking about further regulating this for recycled content, or content to begin with. Is it better for us to export plastic pellets to other countries that don't have the same standards as us, or is it better that we Canadians, with our high standards, do it ourselves?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128154","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, witnesses, for your testimony. Mr. Moffatt, you talked a bit about the economy. This committee has heard different testimony on a circular economy. Really, we have to expand on that, being a global economy, because we know the federal government has actually lifted part of its plastics ban so that Canadian businesses won't be impacted. They're allowed to export p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["37adb85c4fc26a83cab0875aff4764f57765179d7c37eb8730282fd2e7310f00"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8a42a3f84cccaa2bf3000b5462608fd8990f04df7b5c7da73bc3fe916dc718d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70bc45d95ef08d06f9321449","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128155,"date":"2026-06-11T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"We're talking about this global economy. On this side, we want results, especially in terms of the plastics that are making it into our environment. As an indigenous person, I've been battling this for 20 years in my local community. On the Stockholm Convention, which many countries have signed on to, including Canada, it seems that a lot of countries are not holding up their end of the bargain. In Southeast Asia, for example, the cumulative impact is 550 million tonnes of plastics making it into our environment—our marine environment, to boot—as opposed to Canada's average eight-million-tonne contribution to marine pollution. Canada is trying to do better, but it seems Canada and some other countries are alone in that respect, and we're actually allowing plastic products to be made elsewhere for Canadian use. We're not really enforcing the Stockholm convention on anybody. Is this fair to Canadians? Is it fair to Canadian businesses? Is there something Canada could be doing internationally to put more pressure on these other signatories to this convention to do better?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128155","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We're talking about this global economy. On this side, we want results, especially in terms of the plastics that are making it into our environment. As an indigenous person, I've been battling this for 20 years in my local community. On the Stockholm Convention, which many countries have signed on to, including Canada, it seems that a lot of countries are not holding up their end of the bargain. I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6e9b3bcf462006ecad52159eadfabd008cf57c58521331e9730d8211906879d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70cec0f0c1166c3050352539","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128156,"date":"2026-06-11T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"There's a lot of scrutiny being placed on imported products coming into Canada now, not just in terms of plastics, but in terms of origin, especially with the United States not wanting Canada to be a doorway into their market with products coming from different places that use substandard labour policies. Let's put it that way. In terms of products, like electric vehicles, coming from different countries, should it get down to the point that we're documenting and regulating the amount and kinds of plastics, and what amounts are in electric vehicles coming into Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128156","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There's a lot of scrutiny being placed on imported products coming into Canada now, not just in terms of plastics, but in terms of origin, especially with the United States not wanting Canada to be a doorway into their market with products coming from different places that use substandard labour policies. Let's put it that way. In terms of products, like electric vehicles, coming from different co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","label":"Imports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","label":"Imports","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc8fb827673cd66ea3979b09be27f0616bdeefc81254f43e4893922a3d8e2bbd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8584f2e3f03915a935457d6401d2d7c391cf356d7cc79b37be312a6d74221789"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05703bfff6f4a7b730dc8c3d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128157,"date":"2026-06-11T17:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"The reason I ask is that single-use tires are coming in from China. We have no idea what their content is. We know there are plastics in those tires—it's 24%, at least—and 15% of those commercial tires are making it into our environment. There are regulations around that in B.C., at least, but everybody's turning a blind eye to it. Nobody's really addressing this. In fact, the extra cost to regulate and manage this is going to fall to Canadians who are actually obeying the law. If we don't get a handle on exports and imports, this problem is not going to get addressed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128157","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The reason I ask is that single-use tires are coming in from China. We have no idea what their content is. We know there are plastics in those tires—it's 24%, at least—and 15% of those commercial tires are making it into our environment. There are regulations around that in B.C., at least, but everybody's turning a blind eye to it. Nobody's really addressing this. In fact, the extra cost to regula","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07c9241a2035786135c72d55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128158,"date":"2026-06-11T18:15:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Madam Chair, that was a very intriguing discussion over the two hours. There were things disclosed that I had no idea about. It opened my eyes in terms of how bad this problem is not just in Canada but also globally. I think we've pretty much debated the full extent of Canada's ban, the exemptions to the ban and the export of pellets to other countries to produce products, but we haven't really gotten a clear answer on Canada's global commitments, not just in terms of exports but also in terms of importing products from different countries around the world that don't have the same environmental standards. How will this be compliant or consistent with what Canada has been proposing, as well as with what Canadians want, overall? I'm in full favour of keeping this open until the minister can come to present.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128158","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Chair, that was a very intriguing discussion over the two hours. There were things disclosed that I had no idea about. It opened my eyes in terms of how bad this problem is not just in Canada but also globally. I think we've pretty much debated the full extent of Canada's ban, the exemptions to the ban and the export of pellets to other countries to produce products, but we haven't really go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c152d86d3bb4c24a619d0db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086475,"date":"2026-06-12T02:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member was knowledgeable in his comments and his speech on Bill C-9.\n\nI spoke to this bill. As an indigenous person, coming from the Indian Act and knowing that natives did not have rights until the last 50 years, I was shocked at this. The issue is the potential attack not only against faith leaders but also against the fundamental principle of freedom of all manners. I cannot understand why the House has not taken the charter seriously. We are actually playing politics with it.\n\nWith respect to the motion that my colleague has put on the floor, is there any chance the Liberal government will come to its senses and support it? If not, what are the options for us as Conservatives on behalf of Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086475","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member was knowledgeable in his comments and his speech on Bill C-9.\n\nI spoke to this bill. As an indigenous person, coming from the Indian Act and knowing that natives did not have rights until the last 50 years, I was shocked at this. The issue is the potential attack not only against faith leaders but also against the fundamental principle of freedom of all manners. I cannot un","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a5a555198f40af83dd7f083c878895da857d768eb13c0b62a1e2a297fe096051"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59630f6b14281b62eabc331c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128159,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"I'm 34.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128159","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm 34.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76c0af60e25d240851bb5871","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128160,"date":"2026-06-16T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you for your testimony, MP Weiler. I grew up on the West Coast, and I still live there today, so I'm well aware of the scourge of abandoned vessels sinking on the west coast of British Columbia. When I was a band councillor as well as a chief councillor, we tried to address this as well, and it ended up with us using our own resources to take abandoned vessels out of the water. We're well aware of the problem of buying a vessel for one dollar. Bill C-244 puts more responsibility—and I might say more liability—on the seller. The seller has to ensure that whoever he's selling this boat to has \"the ability, resources [and] intent to maintain, operate or dispose of the vessel in a manner that prevents it from becoming wrecked [or] abandoned\". This is the way I read that: If I sell the boat to my colleague here, who has never owned a boat—I don't even think he's seen the ocean—then I have to figure out if he has \"the ability, resources or intent to maintain, operate or dispose of the vessel\". I'm also assuming, on my part, that he has some kind of a document saying that the vessel is in good working condition and that my colleague has a résumé of items that he intends to do to operate this in an efficient manner. If not, the document has to stand up in the courts. Are we assuming that this document we're talking about has to be notarized? Does it have to be legalized in some manner to protect my liability and my responsibility? I don't want to be fined $5,000 when I know he has the resources and I know he has the ability to use YouTube. I know all that, but he still lets the boat sink. I don't want it to come back to me. What kind of a document do we need to ensure that I've done my due diligence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128160","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you for your testimony, MP Weiler. I grew up on the West Coast, and I still live there today, so I'm well aware of the scourge of abandoned vessels sinking on the west coast of British Columbia. When I was a band councillor as well as a chief councillor, we tried to address this as well, and it ended up with us using our own resources to take abandoned vessels out of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["defcb09ff4abfdb2b6399855a4330915dde8db7f81a30357c025d7ec5c83894b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d57e71620156c4dcef0333686f0c347c03aabffad96f77eb0e7434ee6db917e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a4d71c13558e3f23a67acee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128161,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"It has to be able to stand up in court, though.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128161","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It has to be able to stand up in court, though.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3cc890c31870805fa04256ce1bac06bb3c5f717a522c46275b1f49d3bdc3dd94"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72ff9f4e95852159081a85cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128162,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"I would still be fined, so then I would take it to court. I would still need a document from him that could stand up in court to say that I did my due diligence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128162","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would still be fined, so then I would take it to court. I would still need a document from him that could stand up in court to say that I did my due diligence.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","label":"Forgery","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e9ca4e0d7dbe075462d9c59a7a16d9da152ce4a09170716210b403042dd77966"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["436e4716817add380bed701ee0de866bb77ba7b98805c3d86b39025e5fe56705"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-176683b4d4ff8920ec5630da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128163,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"If I didn't verify that in some document, I'm breaking the law. It's prohibited for me to sell that vessel to Branden here without checking all these checkboxes. It's going to come back to the courts. In terms of enforcement, I assume that Transport Canada is going to enforce this, so will they be enforcing by looking at the documents? Marine assessment is not a problem. Marine survey is not a problem. They already exist. Will I have to submit to Transport Canada the résumé that Branden gave me to ensure that he's not a reckless boat owner?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128163","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If I didn't verify that in some document, I'm breaking the law. It's prohibited for me to sell that vessel to Branden here without checking all these checkboxes. It's going to come back to the courts. In terms of enforcement, I assume that Transport Canada is going to enforce this, so will they be enforcing by looking at the documents? Marine assessment is not a problem. Marine survey is not a pro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warranties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warranties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Warranties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207491","label":"Warranties","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b1f71eca8b6fa6cbc9a84858df7b42262f80b6a4c1ef1a6979afeac0cfee67cd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0da33b0ec3eb4c80edaf43f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128164,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"How will this apply on reserves? How will it be enforced on reserves?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128164","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How will this apply on reserves? How will it be enforced on reserves?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3cdc88671aa8509a0137531a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128165,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"No, it's not—not on reserve. There are a lot of laws that aren't enforced on reserve, whether provincial or federal. Most of the time, you ask permission to come onto reserve and enforce. Will the band council...? Band councils own boats and sell them as well. Will this need council buy-in, say, under the Indian Act?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128165","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, it's not—not on reserve. There are a lot of laws that aren't enforced on reserve, whether provincial or federal. Most of the time, you ask permission to come onto reserve and enforce. Will the band council...? Band councils own boats and sell them as well. Will this need council buy-in, say, under the Indian Act?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80a63a7c4556baaf032e2242","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128166,"date":"2026-06-16T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay, thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128166","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay, thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32d05262f4ad730e0c232f1b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128167,"date":"2026-06-16T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for your testimony. I pretty much exhausted my questions on this a few months ago when it was first introduced in the House. Being a boat owner, a boat seller and a boat buyer, I just didn't understand the legalities around this and the enforcement. We still don't have clarity on the question of how this is going to be enacted, especially on the west coast of British Columbia, where it's a really big problem. As a high-level question, how does this relate to a seller in the United States selling to somebody in Canada? Does this legislation apply to that seller in the United States in terms of pleasure boats? Can anybody answer? Bueller? Bueller? Some hon. members: Oh, oh! Ellis Ross: If you don't have that answer right now, that's great. You can get back to us later with some written answers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128167","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for your testimony. I pretty much exhausted my questions on this a few months ago when it was first introduced in the House. Being a boat owner, a boat seller and a boat buyer, I just didn't understand the legalities around this and the enforcement. We still don't have clarity on the question of how this is going to be enacted, especially on the w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32cab0e9fe7b0723725e3d51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128168,"date":"2026-06-16T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"If the seller is in the United States and that's where the purchase is made, and the boat comes to Canada and it sinks because the buyer wasn't able to maintain the boat, then does that liability stay with the buyer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128168","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If the seller is in the United States and that's where the purchase is made, and the boat comes to Canada and it sinks because the buyer wasn't able to maintain the boat, then does that liability stay with the buyer?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036775","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property and casualty insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036775","label":"Property and casualty insurance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ec95c68f4e07d815f63a9d7321f76ed98a334c022eb4e56bf8fbe753b9a9a82"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-023938ec26f5d81e4b80bec5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128169,"date":"2026-06-16T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Exactly, but you just said that, if the sale is made in the United States, then there are different rules.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128169","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Exactly, but you just said that, if the sale is made in the United States, then there are different rules.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47720","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Marketing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47720","label":"Marketing","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["12a1cc2bbce8c1eed88215db7aed2b87392c1ee0a1b6d2a1094c6f93ba81aeb6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77dda86f39f009fe501b8b59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128170,"date":"2026-06-16T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"If the sale is made in the States, and the buyer brings it to Canada and the boat sinks, you can't put the onus on the seller in the United States.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128170","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If the sale is made in the States, and the buyer brings it to Canada and the boat sinks, you can't put the onus on the seller in the United States.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","label":"Marine accidents","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","label":"Shipping","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["32644ffb9f227a44fa8d5f639ebd22280d1f6b899d09105a44f859783c80393a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-38857d7710e30ca80caca94a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128171,"date":"2026-06-16T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"I understand that, but the point of this bill is that the onus is on the seller. They say that you have to do the due diligence to ensure that the buyer is competent enough to maintain a boat. How will Canada do this at any level of government when they're selling surplus vessels to boat owners? How will they do it? Who will do it on behalf of Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128171","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand that, but the point of this bill is that the onus is on the seller. They say that you have to do the due diligence to ensure that the buyer is competent enough to maintain a boat. How will Canada do this at any level of government when they're selling surplus vessels to boat owners? How will they do it? Who will do it on behalf of Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69b8c0a9fb2c2297ec4bdc83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128172,"date":"2026-06-16T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"As well as the competence of the potential owner, the buyer, to ensure that that new owner is competent or not reckless in owning a boat or maintaining a boat.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128172","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"As well as the competence of the potential owner, the buyer, to ensure that that new owner is competent or not reckless in owning a boat or maintaining a boat.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b07694a26a5f40e0d80902650792fc819c4bb58fdaee81c08bdf9f0d6ce737a1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a2139f07c641c6b2c63090f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128173,"date":"2026-06-16T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. Currently, it's really tough to enforce these types of legislation regulations on reserve. Has that been considered in terms of this legislation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128173","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Currently, it's really tough to enforce these types of legislation regulations on reserve. Has that been considered in terms of this legislation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb951cc8a175b9f2c925a4b0a2f86dd40f300f7385fe4d2daf32982e00a3d744"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11a33637ba5d04687132879e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128174,"date":"2026-06-16T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"ENVI","text":"I'll turn the rest of my time over to MP Arnold.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128174","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll turn the rest of my time over to MP Arnold.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-138183f0182493c8c4d91ede","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088316,"date":"2026-06-17T19:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when Canadians think of Skeena—Bulkley Valley, they think of LNG and the port of Prince Rupert. These projects are important, but they are only part of the story.\n\nOur region is home to tremendous economic potential, from the port of Stewart to the industrial lands being developed around Kitselas and Terrace and emerging opportunities in mineral processing and refining in communities like Houston. Resource development is also creating new opportunities across the northwest, with projects such as the reopening of coal operations near Telkwa, helping to support jobs and local economies.\n\nThe people of Skeena—Bulkley Valley are ready to build, invest and grow. What we need is recognition and support from the government, not more barriers or delays. Our region has the resources, the workforce and the determination to help drive Canada's economic future. If we unleash the full potential of communities across the northwest, we can get Canada building again, growing again and back on track.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088316","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when Canadians think of Skeena—Bulkley Valley, they think of LNG and the port of Prince Rupert. These projects are important, but they are only part of the story.\n\nOur region is home to tremendous economic potential, from the port of Stewart to the industrial lands being developed around Kitselas and Terrace and emerging opportunities in mineral processing and refining in communities ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","label":"Resource development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","label":"Resource development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62e3f15a66a564046485853c95d38591b87a08a812ab5f8f2e995fd16bb9fa70"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8fde8768f534f69272941d44d90bbe3075076f1c9db2e8649ea3b0319f7fe681"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f71e8e84d1edbd8fc8e3012","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088317,"date":"2026-06-18T00:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member for that very passionate speech. As opposition members, we propose to improve these types of bills with amendments. The Liberals characterize these amendments at committee stage as obstructions, yet all we are trying to do is make the bills better.\n\nCould the member tell us if there are amendments that can be implemented to achieve the objectives while still protecting privacy and civil rights?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088317","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member for that very passionate speech. As opposition members, we propose to improve these types of bills with amendments. The Liberals characterize these amendments at committee stage as obstructions, yet all we are trying to do is make the bills better.\n\nCould the member tell us if there are amendments that can be implemented to achieve the objectives while still prote","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec564bd8fc3d85358fe4433b519c2272ea27c7b1eef8d51dcb117ab41cd64c71"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f57274b0809507d8b83943b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088318,"date":"2026-06-18T01:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member gave a knowledgeable speech in terms of democracy and the way this place is supposed to work. In fact, when I came here, the Liberal government had a minority government, and things were working. It was getting comments from all the MPs in this place, and there was compromise and amendments in committee. Now that the Liberals have a majority, they stacked their majority and now they do not allow debate on any amendments from any party. By my numbers, there are 174 Liberal members who want to force this bill through, but there are 169 MPs from every party who want to fix part 2. \n\nDoes the member see the fault in this? Can she see how this is wrong and how it is working against the democratic system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088318","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member gave a knowledgeable speech in terms of democracy and the way this place is supposed to work. In fact, when I came here, the Liberal government had a minority government, and things were working. It was getting comments from all the MPs in this place, and there was compromise and amendments in committee. Now that the Liberals have a majority, they stacked their majority a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fd84563c881f5d490d8a654f7352f40383a02d357d3b9adf6f603276c8c2966a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf80ffa1a8658eaba3f85901","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088319,"date":"2026-06-18T02:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ellis Ross","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is basically democracy that translates from the House to committee. The Conservatives, the Bloc and the NDP all agree with part 1 of this bill. There is no question about that. It is 9:30 at night, and after this, the committee will sit again. It will be one more attempt for MPs in the House to protect civil liberties and privacy.\n\nDoes the member think the Liberal government will listen to the debate and actually consider the amendments put together by all the members of the House outside of the Liberal majority government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088319","member_id":"bc-mp-123622","member_name":"Ellis Ross","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is basically democracy that translates from the House to committee. The Conservatives, the Bloc and the NDP all agree with part 1 of this bill. There is no question about that. It is 9:30 at night, and after this, the committee will sit again. It will be one more attempt for MPs in the House to protect civil liberties and privacy.\n\nDoes the member think the Liberal government will ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c369562fcd4763930212bd177a0bd1e309f2b469f9e8a624b48761ce6b8e2d76"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5829d2598197ad856559635","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70524,"date":"2026-01-29T16:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians in my riding have never been prouder to be Canadians.\n\nWe are more willing than ever to work together to make our country stronger. We care about one another, help one another and look out for one another. These are Canadian values.\n\nThat is why earlier this week, the Prime Minister announced the new Canada groceries and essentials benefit. This new benefit will provide meaningful support to more than 12 million Canadians with low and modest incomes.\n\nAs long as we stand up for our country and refuse to weaken ourselves from within through division and quarrels, we remain unbreakable. Unity is not just about kilometres of territory; it is a shared vision for our future.\n\nWe stand in solidarity with the world in defence of human rights and sovereignty, and we draw a clear red line when it comes to protecting our country. Let us pull together, work together and collaborate together for the good of Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70524","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians in my riding have never been prouder to be Canadians.\n\nWe are more willing than ever to work together to make our country stronger. We care about one another, help one another and look out for one another. These are Canadian values.\n\nThat is why earlier this week, the Prime Minister announced the new Canada groceries and essentials benefit. This new benefit will provide mean","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["665ac9c3b3fd44cc842f3712bbc7735ef674ca01ab9c3611993fb2d4a4277f4b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3d7fed51224d7944237b16f1be47265d56af4031ebb93710a50330311c5bcfb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2792871bd2e803b552b11413","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86088,"date":"2026-02-06T16:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to recognize the newly formed Surrey & White Rock Board of Trade, created through the merger of the Surrey Board of Trade and the South Surrey & White Rock Chamber of Commerce. It is now one of the largest and most influential business organizations in Canada. \n\nI also want to congratulate Joslyn Young, the CEO. Her leadership comes at a pivotal moment as this rapidly growing region continues to play a major role in B.C.'s economic future.\n\n They are a vital advocate for small businesses and the tourism sector, industries that create jobs, support families and showcase our communities to the world. By working collaboratively with the government, these organizations help ensure local entrepreneurs have the certainty, support and opportunities they need to grow and succeed. Today, I encourage all members to stay closely connected with their local chambers and boards of trade.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86088","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to recognize the newly formed Surrey & White Rock Board of Trade, created through the merger of the Surrey Board of Trade and the South Surrey & White Rock Chamber of Commerce. It is now one of the largest and most influential business organizations in Canada. \n\nI also want to congratulate Joslyn Young, the CEO. Her leadership comes at a pivotal moment as this rapidly g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2fb2f234039c175ef231a10c892bbb7abd36ec56a2dc56713741b37cd9605d5a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4dbdd66a260ab1b1a23228a0d6bed307fded012714cd03f530532d6e0532bd08"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b40cd47a86e86f5c4f2c384","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86089,"date":"2026-02-06T19:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am pleased to speak to Bill S-210, an act respecting Ukrainian heritage month. By adopting this bill, Parliament would designate September as Ukrainian heritage month across Canada, offering Canadians a chance each year to reflect upon and celebrate the significant contributions of the Ukrainian community to our shared history, culture and identity.\n\nI am pleased to inform the House that the government supports the bill. In doing so, let me start by saying that Canada's story cannot be told without the story of Ukrainian Canadians. From the first arrivals in September 1891 to the vibrant diaspora that exists today, Ukrainian Canadians have shaped this country in fundamental ways. They came to Canada seeking opportunity, freedom and stability. In turn, they helped build our country, opened businesses, enriched our cultural landscape and contributed to our democratic institutions.\n\nCanada is now home to over 1.5 million people of Ukrainian descent. They live and work in every province and territory. They are leaders in government, the arts, academia, agriculture, sports and the armed forces. They have brought with them a rich cultural heritage of food, music, dance, language, folklore and faith traditions that have become woven into the fabric of Canada itself. We only need to look across the country to see their legacy: thriving community centres, churches, cultural associations, annual festivals that draw thousands of Canadians of all backgrounds and academic contributions that have deepened our understanding of Ukrainian history, language and literature. \n\nIn agriculture, Ukrainian Canadians played an essential role in developing Canada's prairie provinces into the breadbasket of the nation. In our armed forces, they served with distinction in both world wars and continue to do so today. Designating Ukrainian heritage month would give all Canadians an annual opportunity to reflect on these contributions and to learn about the resilience, perseverance and achievements of this community.\n\nDeclaring September as Ukrainian heritage month would also serve as an invaluable educational opportunity. It would encourage schools, libraries, museums, cultural organizations and community groups to host programs and events that deepen our understanding of Ukrainian history, language, art and traditions. It will inspire young Canadians of all backgrounds to learn about the Holodomor, the struggle for Ukrainian independence, the legacy of immigration and the contemporary challenges facing Ukraine. As we educate, we fortify our national character. We inspire empathy, understanding and unity, values that are essential to the health of any democracy.\n\nThis recognition also reflects our broader commitments under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Canadian Multiculturalism Act. Section 27 of the charter reminds us that preserving and enhancing our multicultural heritage is a fundamental principle of Canadian democracy. The Canadian Multiculturalism Act calls upon us to recognize communities who share common origins and historic contributions to our society and to ensure that all Canadians can participate fully in our economic, social, cultural and political life. \n\nFormal recognition of September as Ukrainian heritage month would give meaning to these principles. This designation is also consistent with our government's broader priorities, building a country where everyone feels a sense of belonging and strengthening social cohesion. Multiculturalism is not just a policy. It is a unifying symbol of Canadian identity and a source of national pride. \n\nWhy should Ukrainian heritage month be in September? It is because the month of September is particularly special. It commemorates the arrival of the first Ukrainian immigrants in September 1891, and it is a time when communities across Canada already gather to celebrate Ukrainian culture and heritage. By designating September as Ukrainian heritage month, Parliament would be aligning with existing provincial designations in Manitoba and Ontario, further strengthening the recognition across the country. \n\n Support for Bill S-210 is expected to be broad and positive beyond the Ukrainian community in Canada. Similar heritage month bills, including those for Italian, Lebanese, Jewish, Sikh, Hindu, Tamil, German and Latin American communities, have passed with widespread approval in the House. Cultural recognition initiatives like these acknowledge the fundamental contributions of immigrant communities to Canada and provide an opportunity for all Canadians to learn about and celebrate our inclusive society. Such recognitions also resonate deeply with Canadians because they reflect who we are, which is a country of many cultures, histories and traditions united in a common identity.\n\n Declaring September as Ukrainian heritage month is not a symbolic pat on the back; it is a powerful statement of Canadian identity and global leadership. It tells the world that Canada stands with Ukraine, Canada honours its Ukrainian citizens, Canada remembers its history and Canada will never waver in its defence of freedom.\n\n I urge all members to support this bill and join Canadians in celebrating Ukrainian heritage month each September. In doing so, we will not only honour the legacy of Ukrainian Canadians but also strengthen the bonds that unite us all as Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86089","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am pleased to speak to Bill S-210, an act respecting Ukrainian heritage month. By adopting this bill, Parliament would designate September as Ukrainian heritage month across Canada, offering Canadians a chance each year to reflect upon and celebrate the significant contributions of the Ukrainian community to our shared history, culture and identity.\n\nI am pleased to inform the Hou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["91edb2b7792e5f6c628eb76e0d500012c7f76d28339c24c354be5090f9645f1a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["49bd173ca6e25e1ad45ac9b03cb7a61d3690d3a42ff9cd70fe5f18ca4a722cf9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-339bdfb9a2b3ec890cb86b3e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310837,"date":"2026-02-25T19:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in Canadian communities, Coldest Night of the Year 2026, to support the hurting, hungry and homeless, is on the final stretch of its annual campaign. On Saturday, I will be walking alongside community members in support of Sources, an organization that has been providing help, encouragement and hope to people who are experiencing hurt, hunger and homelessness.\n\nFor me, this walk is about showing up. It is about reminding people that they are not invisible and that their community cares. I have been honoured to be the top fundraiser for two years and the leading fundraiser in the region for six years, thanks to the generosity and dedication of my teammates and donors.\n\nI encourage all colleagues in the House to take part in the Coldest Night of the Year. It is free to join. Simply register to walk, start a team, or donate to my team. This weekend, send a simple but powerful message: in Canada, we care about each other.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310837","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in Canadian communities, Coldest Night of the Year 2026, to support the hurting, hungry and homeless, is on the final stretch of its annual campaign. On Saturday, I will be walking alongside community members in support of Sources, an organization that has been providing help, encouragement and hope to people who are experiencing hurt, hunger and homelessness.\n\nFor me, this walk is ab","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["50bdbe56cf2b82d5a02e9bf11e9be35adcd312f083e8fa0ecaddb5eccc68d8d5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1e35dc10e048616c4f1d2e094c46d9057f2a2d307396ca056cda22f708ca2b23"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-485504b0b1d1e77f6f908be0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310836,"date":"2026-02-26T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, fisheries management decisions must be rooted in science for the long-term economic prosperity of coastal communities. Our government will continue to make evidence-based decisions through meaningful consultations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310836","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, fisheries management decisions must be rooted in science for the long-term economic prosperity of coastal communities. Our government will continue to make evidence-based decisions through meaningful consultations.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","label":"Aquatic ecosystems","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0b5ec1816a081cc54675c49dc54c9a0daa3f0aa0b3c3601c62ade9c062535d5c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ce92faa0750005003d7b570","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310835,"date":"2026-02-27T17:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, small craft harbours are fixtures of coastal communities and our economy. That is exactly why our government is investing hundreds of millions of dollars into our small craft harbours. We are building the infrastructure that allows our harvesters to do their jobs and support their families and their communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310835","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, small craft harbours are fixtures of coastal communities and our economy. That is exactly why our government is investing hundreds of millions of dollars into our small craft harbours. We are building the infrastructure that allows our harvesters to do their jobs and support their families and their communities.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083628","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coastal waters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083628","label":"Coastal waters","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02c7d3cc7d4a3d5e26de8f294fd8e02a528b6ca71c5cdd12a6d427b3116bb8a5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b1504e84f98c1f09b13dede","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350214,"date":"2026-03-09T23:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on March 8, our Prime Minister convened the incident response group with ministers and senior officials to discuss the ongoing hostilities in Iran and the Middle East and continued vigilance to ensure the safety and security of all Canadians. \n\nBased on Canada's recent discussions with leaders in the region and the G7, could the minister update the House on the efforts to de-escalate the situation and could she assure Canadians that Canada will not engage in the military actions in Iran?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350214","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on March 8, our Prime Minister convened the incident response group with ministers and senior officials to discuss the ongoing hostilities in Iran and the Middle East and continued vigilance to ensure the safety and security of all Canadians. \n\nBased on Canada's recent discussions with leaders in the region and the G7, could the minister update the House on the efforts to de-escalate ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27e6266d80446460fd6fe514","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350213,"date":"2026-03-12T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, last Sunday I was joined by the Surrey police and fire departments to deliver a speech and to cheer on everyone at the Polar Plunge for Special Olympics BC. The Polar Plunge is about the belief that everyone deserves a place to belong. This year marks the 10th anniversary of the Polar Plunge for Special Olympics BC, which has raised more than $2 million to support athletes.\n\n In August, Alberta hosts the Special Olympics Canada Summer Games. As a father of a child with a disability, I have seen first-hand how sport builds confidence, friendships and joy. It opens doors for athletes, families and entire communities. Through Special Olympics, people are defined not by their challenges but by their courage, their determination and their incredible abilities.\n\nPeople who took the plunge this year should remember that they did not just brave the cold but also helped to create a more inclusive world where every athlete is celebrated.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350213","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, last Sunday I was joined by the Surrey police and fire departments to deliver a speech and to cheer on everyone at the Polar Plunge for Special Olympics BC. The Polar Plunge is about the belief that everyone deserves a place to belong. This year marks the 10th anniversary of the Polar Plunge for Special Olympics BC, which has raised more than $2 million to support athletes.\n\n In Augus","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c52fe630f3afd33d4af1fd9f72526709e7854e3d9a49b6964b72d730c4e18a4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["986d1f2131324ca647c0df464daedca6af513701b5851102c3b912741f8d35ec"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21c13e10277230852757896f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390272,"date":"2026-03-26T19:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I recently met with the Cuban ambassador, who described the situation in his country as very dire and noted a need for solar power generators. Last week, a total collapse of the electrical grid occurred, leaving all 10 million people without electricity. This was also the case for critical infrastructure, including hospitals. People are left without basic necessities.\n\n Cuba's lack of oil has been catastrophic. At a time of uncertainty and struggle, Canada is stepping up to support people in need. Our government has recently delivered $8 million in humanitarian assistance to help deliver vital support. Canada does not support any country's attempt to take over another sovereign nation. Canada continues its commitment to constructive engagement with Cuba, grounded in respect for international law, for sovereignty and for freedom of people to choose their way of life.\n\n Canada will continue to focus on the well-being of the Cuban people and uphold the values—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390272","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I recently met with the Cuban ambassador, who described the situation in his country as very dire and noted a need for solar power generators. Last week, a total collapse of the electrical grid occurred, leaving all 10 million people without electricity. This was also the case for critical infrastructure, including hospitals. People are left without basic necessities.\n\n Cuba's lack of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Solar energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","label":"Solar energy","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e75c8388be1b12ea0095efcafed0d4e3f24626673d4027aa9d7168064876750"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56e76be2a33774446349d377546bf598db5ff388bc1e8837906decd96826136d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-affd4a0d077f0d60ac17ada7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128175,"date":"2026-04-15T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thanks so much. Thanks to the witnesses. Further to the question that was put forward by Mr. Small, sometimes when people are waiting for a decision, they wonder when this decision is going to come. In hindsight, have the decisions made been the correct decisions, from your perspective?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128175","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thanks so much. Thanks to the witnesses. Further to the question that was put forward by Mr. Small, sometimes when people are waiting for a decision, they wonder when this decision is going to come. In hindsight, have the decisions made been the correct decisions, from your perspective?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1eea96c54fccfad0c7413fe8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128176,"date":"2026-04-15T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay, thank you. Speaking of the mass marking, our government just announced the move to increase this. How will this impact sport and recreational fishing and the tourism sector in B.C., from your perspective?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128176","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay, thank you. Speaking of the mass marking, our government just announced the move to increase this. How will this impact sport and recreational fishing and the tourism sector in B.C., from your perspective?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2dad18e98fa1a91782a863726f72c042f31a6ecf3e491ce83b0db1c419f008f6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2db02d832076907ada25e18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128177,"date":"2026-04-15T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"From your perspective, are there factors that are not being looked at when decisions are made but that should be incorporated into some of the decision-making processes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128177","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"From your perspective, are there factors that are not being looked at when decisions are made but that should be incorporated into some of the decision-making processes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5d2d7efe561d224d9cb830892fab91f4318ac1d14c88eb285d4f728dd59dd36a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95c63677b4401f2ebff138fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128178,"date":"2026-04-15T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you so much. Thanks to the witnesses. There is a lot of information coming our way from the three of you. It's been really educational to hear all of this. Mr. Brown, I think you mentioned this, as did Mr. Bird: We're looking at a $1.3-billion to $1.4-billion industry. You also stated that the fish industry is becoming less viable and that we need a more balanced approach to making the decisions, ensuring that the industry survives. I think all of us would agree that we want to make sure the industry survives. Can you talk about what kind of a more balanced approach you would like to see?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128178","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you so much. Thanks to the witnesses. There is a lot of information coming our way from the three of you. It's been really educational to hear all of this. Mr. Brown, I think you mentioned this, as did Mr. Bird: We're looking at a $1.3-billion to $1.4-billion industry. You also stated that the fish industry is becoming less viable and that we need a more balanced approach to making the decis","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f062d5158ff91325615f4ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128179,"date":"2026-04-15T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Zeman, you talked about the late opening of the salmon run. What do you think the consequences of the late opening would be to the stock, last year especially?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128179","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Zeman, you talked about the late opening of the salmon run. What do you think the consequences of the late opening would be to the stock, last year especially?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037228","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Stock markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037228","label":"Stock markets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1ec6432d5807c376544027799d36d5914a75a83102d066572108b3ba87ce258"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b751b1264b9d407dc46d212d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128180,"date":"2026-04-15T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. Mr. Kelly, you talked about how there have been some seasons closed prematurely. I'm wondering if you can talk a bit about how often that has happened. What are the consequences of it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128180","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Kelly, you talked about how there have been some seasons closed prematurely. I'm wondering if you can talk a bit about how often that has happened. What are the consequences of it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0eabba015666e8309493a98c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128181,"date":"2026-04-15T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. To go back to Mr. Brown, how do we ensure public access to fisheries while still prioritizing conservation for declining stocks?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128181","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. To go back to Mr. Brown, how do we ensure public access to fisheries while still prioritizing conservation for declining stocks?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","label":"Resources conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","label":"Resources conservation","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d1185c461b8457bef5127bc9393713e54a2874e83fc0dc29b5d0a230485b7b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b48c89ea27b7991c10a0a7baa4ee56ba5cc20b869d6c866cb00487d96326e5ef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54e4c84e753a23c62fe5f375","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715143,"date":"2026-04-16T19:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, tomorrow marks the 44th anniversary of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The charter stands as one of the strongest pillars of human rights protection, guaranteeing our fundamental freedoms and protecting the rights of all Canadians. The charter is a profoundly Canadian document. Its impact goes beyond our borders, inspiring and providing expertise to nations around the world, allowing Canada to lead by example.\n\nI would also like to recognize prime ministers Trudeau and Chrétien for their roles in achieving this landmark in Canadian history and for carrying this legacy forward by advancing equal rights, including the legalization of same-sex marriage, ensuring that the promise of the charter applies to all Canadians. \n\nWe believe that the charter works because it truly represents us, the Canadian people, and it stands the test of time. Let us recommit to these principles, ensuring that the charter continues to serve Canadians for generations to come.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715143","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, tomorrow marks the 44th anniversary of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The charter stands as one of the strongest pillars of human rights protection, guaranteeing our fundamental freedoms and protecting the rights of all Canadians. The charter is a profoundly Canadian document. Its impact goes beyond our borders, inspiring and providing expertise to nations around the wor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","label":"Charters"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","label":"Charters","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ce3328f479726c912165ba7124ff513b0134fb3cd7d99beca13126944358dd30"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a7ba3b4a12eb7d7699450c3909e75d6c85b97db34f13b850a9a50bf3db33e69e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09518a4c952358ae33bfacea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715144,"date":"2026-04-16T23:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from my home province who also sits with me on the fisheries committee. It is a pleasure to be here to discuss the policy that he is looking for some clarity on. It is great to have another opportunity to set the record straight on the Pacific salmon allocation policy.\n\nWild Pacific salmon are a keystone species on the west coast. As the member likely knows, the minister was recently in B.C. to announce close to $413 million in new funding for the Pacific salmon strategy initiative. This funding will be critical to continue our government's work to rebuild wild salmon. It will strengthen science and monitoring, enable essential habitat restoration, modernize salmon fisheries and expand collaboration with partners.\n\nWhile in B.C., our government also announced a next step in strengthening the long-term conservation and rebuilding of wild Pacific salmon with the expansion of mass marking of all DFO hatchery-origin chinook salmon in southern British Columbia. Expanded mass marking enhances our understanding of science, providing a clearer picture of wild salmon populations and the performance of our hatcheries. When it comes to the management of wild salmon, it starts with healthy salmon stock.\n\nThe 1999 Pacific salmon allocation policy outlines principles that guide the allocation of Pacific salmon catch among first nations, commercial and recreational fisheries. The policy does not define specific allocations for individual fisheries. Following the B.C. Supreme Court's 2018 Ahousaht decision, our government committed to review and update the policy in collaboration with first nations and stakeholders. DFO has been clear from the outset that the renewed policy will continue to prioritize conservation, followed by aboriginal and treaty fishing rights, including the five nations court-affirmed right to sell fish.\n\nThe salmon allocation policy review will not extinguish any sector's access to Pacific salmon. Pacific salmon will remain a shared public resource managed by the Government of Canada on behalf of all Canadians under the Minister of Fisheries authorities in the Fisheries Act and its regulations.\n\nSince 2019, DFO has undertaken an extensive, multi-year engagement process with first nations, the recreational and the commercial fishing sectors. The recent eight-week open, public and extended consultation on the discussion paper, developed with partners and stakeholders, provided an opportunity for DFO to share input gathered to date and to seek input from first nations, and commercial and recreational harvesters, as well as all other stakeholders.\n\nDiscussion papers exist to engage directly with interested parties to get their feedback and considerations. They are not prescriptive. They are a tool for feedback. All viewpoints provided by first nations and stakeholders will be considered in the salmon allocation policy review. No decisions have yet been made. The salmon allocation policy review is still under way and work continues through the formal salmon allocation policy multi-party working group, which provides representatives from first nations, the—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715144","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from my home province who also sits with me on the fisheries committee. It is a pleasure to be here to discuss the policy that he is looking for some clarity on. It is great to have another opportunity to set the record straight on the Pacific salmon allocation policy.\n\nWild Pacific salmon are a keystone species on the west coast. As the member likely knows, the m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c6b4add349a91de0d653c1bfa47e82f007aadd04f076cdd5349e49361003e021"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["272fd55192788612b1b1c7154e49f5d1460f865a2c7c6fc737d3267cc010310e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-428fd769b45a9db1abba01b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715145,"date":"2026-04-16T23:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let me be clear. A revised salmon allocation policy will not take away any sector's access to the resource. The policy is being reviewed, and the decisions have not been made to date. Anyone who suggests otherwise is wrong and only dividing Canadians. \n\nPacific salmon will remain a shared public resource managed by the Government of Canada on behalf of all Canadians under the Minister of Fisheries' authorities in the Fisheries Act and its regulations. There have been extensive public consultations on the policy. Working group tables continue, which include representatives from first nations, the commercial sector, and sport and recreational groups.\n\n The updated policy will continue to prioritize conservation, and it will continue to recognize the constitutional priority of indigenous fishing rights. All Canadians will be respected.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715145","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let me be clear. A revised salmon allocation policy will not take away any sector's access to the resource. The policy is being reviewed, and the decisions have not been made to date. Anyone who suggests otherwise is wrong and only dividing Canadians. \n\nPacific salmon will remain a shared public resource managed by the Government of Canada on behalf of all Canadians under the Minister","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be1c4ba0d68eb61fa61e50fbb78bb31a9ecc45f15e2670a32cc2c69b9f2fd9f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f544cfbc2d8edaa893f32e93c835c6466ec427fdf43f2b9476b06fe6ef1f2f0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e0247f064068263ce3d8ba0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128182,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. We collect a wealth of information from all of you. Hearing your stories, Ms. Collier, I get the sense that the industry must be a difficult lifestyle for you. Obviously, we hope to make it a little easier. You talked about how in 2022 the date was given so late and at such short notice. I think you said you had less than 12 hours' notice and you had converted your fishing boat to go to another licence that you have. How far apart are the two licences for the fishing areas you were talking about, and how long is the travel time between the two?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128182","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. We collect a wealth of information from all of you. Hearing your stories, Ms. Collier, I get the sense that the industry must be a difficult lifestyle for you. Obviously, we hope to make it a little easier. You talked about how in 2022 the date was given so late and at such short notice. I think you said you had less than 12 hours' notice and you h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","label":"Fishing permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","label":"Fishing permits","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["20bc19b25c2aa9eae6b2ecd8b69df07dc61c3d335d4d57411484d8ab5b4c9844"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bdb8c059c86b0dab7136e6f62cf30654ff6a07937b243f3739fb853622ebc6ea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035302","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f86905db9a68e11e09ab1957","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128183,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Were you able to change the gear over that year? How did that affect your catch?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128183","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Were you able to change the gear over that year? How did that affect your catch?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["204a18d1c3d8c056a0d012704e68f161cca1392a71656343af1970f5fed685ce"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2d94981f0d1fba26edbf822","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128184,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"That had quite an impact on you, for sure. You also talked about fisheries requiring in-season decision-making. Can you expand on that? Could some decisions be made a little sooner so that they aren't as last minute from your perspective?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128184","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That had quite an impact on you, for sure. You also talked about fisheries requiring in-season decision-making. Can you expand on that? Could some decisions be made a little sooner so that they aren't as last minute from your perspective?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3689900f7fdd03ebbd37aadb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128185,"date":"2026-04-20T16:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"You alluded to 2019. Prior to that year, were decisions made earlier than you've seen since then?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128185","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You alluded to 2019. Prior to that year, were decisions made earlier than you've seen since then?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88066f65596de5c40328278543f64455e4d9bf04b75f417c713953400b60658d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c19373edc5cf9b63e08ce54d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128186,"date":"2026-04-20T16:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Do you think that climate change has had an impact on how these decisions are being made?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128186","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you think that climate change has had an impact on how these decisions are being made?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee1cfd6dfa7e5fc5fc47a7318037ddbc94b9a489f3b19716ec5324aab21d9c3a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f720bdaf3d31f0a4e7367ba6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128187,"date":"2026-04-20T16:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"I think you said your family has been fishing for 40 years. How many people do you employ in your business?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128187","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I think you said your family has been fishing for 40 years. How many people do you employ in your business?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","label":"Fish farming","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c8ee8b28e5194211289a3916c94ce1e4e9b36d1e9720f710581d819dd74384f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18c504b3d52f213a52762c21","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128188,"date":"2026-04-20T16:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you for those comments. Mr. Desbois, I don't really understand the icebreaking myself, not being an east coast person. You said that the icebreaking needs better planning. How do you see that happening? Could you expand on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128188","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for those comments. Mr. Desbois, I don't really understand the icebreaking myself, not being an east coast person. You said that the icebreaking needs better planning. How do you see that happening? Could you expand on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083653","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Ice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083653","label":"Ice","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9fbb1066e36d1b0dc610f8caf82620aa42b7094f3eede5cd5b07e595ee6f40ce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d33543a620aedace6ac51833363ea373c90c5c6366f7de47bb4d0f376daca4f6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c473859b0692d5d5a389b5c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128189,"date":"2026-04-20T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thanks so much. Thanks to the witnesses for being here. Mr. Griswold, in your speaking notes that you submitted to us, you say that in 2025 \"it became known that the 2025 run size far exceeded the preseason forecast\". When was the forecast prediction made known? Also, can you talk a bit about how the forecast is created and when it became known that the actual run was different?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128189","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thanks so much. Thanks to the witnesses for being here. Mr. Griswold, in your speaking notes that you submitted to us, you say that in 2025 \"it became known that the 2025 run size far exceeded the preseason forecast\". When was the forecast prediction made known? Also, can you talk a bit about how the forecast is created and when it became known that the actual run was different?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f534d2fc0bc7052a21ed40bf3781ef3f1ab0b62a935ee24d6702375cee626910"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a83e96eb73cc690a11061661897d3230f43c79b4ecde13ae3636bec7ffc5e0d8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b450effbe7f3fc56b93e9206","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128190,"date":"2026-04-20T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. Mr. Summers, will the announcement about mass markings that you alluded to, and PSSI, be helpful to the recreational fishers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128190","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Summers, will the announcement about mass markings that you alluded to, and PSSI, be helpful to the recreational fishers?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","label":"Aquaculture","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["32e247891e8f485cce4191e57fa63ae2aa3930769a5f005b968ac89cfc121919"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12bf3dd5de536a6ffff7d925","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128191,"date":"2026-04-20T17:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Summers, you did talk about fishing being the economic driver in the small west coast communities. Obviously we want to ensure that the fisheries and the small family businesses carry on. Have you seen a decline in the industry, or are you only forecasting that there will be a decline? How can we prevent a decline from happening?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128191","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Summers, you did talk about fishing being the economic driver in the small west coast communities. Obviously we want to ensure that the fisheries and the small family businesses carry on. Have you seen a decline in the industry, or are you only forecasting that there will be a decline? How can we prevent a decline from happening?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["70a4ffa6f01d01bdd1d0d00eaa1ec3e57bfe93bc53e60743abb05b4ce47f1811"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f4bb88be4ea15d0abd48f8089e9f10fac8d648c109f36fd7a22287798067bfe8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53689d5b2411c00121ec030f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128192,"date":"2026-04-20T17:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Chu, you talked about the killer whales; we all want to make sure that we keep the population going. How does this affect your industry? Do the current policies around the killer whales, from your perspective, need to be revised?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128192","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Chu, you talked about the killer whales; we all want to make sure that we keep the population going. How does this affect your industry? Do the current policies around the killer whales, from your perspective, need to be revised?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","label":"Whales","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c97581ac7c8a638f47c13a6088a80007c81b94ad6b2f7465e6e0d5c8da1a669"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df535b130881690fda5b9835","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128193,"date":"2026-04-22T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would just echo what Mr. Morrissey said. I'm wondering whether Mr. Small could let us know which specific parts of the report he has any concerns with. He talked about a report that wasn't printed, but we have a copy of the report right here. I'm just wondering what areas specifically he has any concerns with.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128193","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would just echo what Mr. Morrissey said. I'm wondering whether Mr. Small could let us know which specific parts of the report he has any concerns with. He talked about a report that wasn't printed, but we have a copy of the report right here. I'm just wondering what areas specifically he has any concerns with.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["874cf9e48c28a542fdc7b6487b00056353b6e864ce0a3bd4ec72ca4e928b1d3f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34c4931d2bddf1fc70cfe28a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128194,"date":"2026-04-22T22:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. The member is seeking to undermine years of formal consultations and concrete work on aquaculture and wild salmon to call for documents related to a report that has been neither finalized nor published. This directly undermines nation-to-nation consultations with first nations and undermines consultations with the industry. I'd like to read some comments here: In November 2009, the Governor General in Council issued Order in Council 2009-1860, establishing this Commission of Inquiry into the Decline of Sockeye Salmon in the Fraser River and appointing...Bruce Cohen, sole Commissioner under Part 1 of the Inquiries Act. The report of this Inquiry consists of three volumes. I describe the Terms of Reference of this Commission in Volume 1, Chapter 1, and set them out in full in Appendix A to each volume of this report. In Volume 1, the Sockeye Fishery, I set out the background information necessary for the reader to understand the complexity and breadth of the Fraser River sockeye salmon fishery. The chapters in Volume 1 cover several topics: an overview of the Commission's mandate; a description of the life cycle of the Fraser River sockeye salmon; an overview of the legal framework governing the Fraser River sockeye fishery; an overview of the organizational structure of the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO); a description of the management of the Fraser River sockeye fishery; a description of the management of the Fraser River sockeye habitat; a description of DFO's enforcement activities related to the fishery and fish habitat; an overview of the management of salmon farms—an activity that may affect Fraser River sockeye; an overview of fish health management related to wild and cultured fish; a discussion of DFO's Wild Salmon Policy; and a case history of the Cultus Lake sockeye salmon. Some subject matter is repeated among the chapters and volumes. Often, to describe aspects of how the fishery is managed...it is necessary to describe the technical and scientific information upon which management decisions are based. That scientific evidence may be repeated in Volume 2 in discussing the causes of the decline. In Volume 2, Causes of the Decline, I focus on that section of the Terms of Reference (section C(I))—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128194","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. The member is seeking to undermine years of formal consultations and concrete work on aquaculture and wild salmon to call for documents related to a report that has been neither finalized nor published. This directly undermines nation-to-nation consultations with first nations and undermines consultations with the industry. I'd like to read some comments here: In November 200","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0b0b54c87a70605dea8945458c401fc9ef2def3cbba7de4ede1050ed051d019c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["673af59599c3f555dcd89f143e4792ad66c2f51ef501134b850f73395ddcd5c1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2632fb7d16731711c77e7051","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128195,"date":"2026-04-22T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Chair. I will continue: —directing me to investigate and make independent findings of fact regarding the causes of the decline of Fraser River sockeye. I summarize the public submissions I received regarding the causes of the decline, other investigations into the decline, as well as the scientific reports prepared for the Commission exploring the different possible causes of the decline. I also discuss the testimony of numerous witnesses, many of whom were qualified as experts in their fields. Volume 2 includes a summary of the findings of fact I make regarding the possible causes of the decline of the Fraser River sockeye salmon. Volume 3 contains my recommendations based on my review of the evidence and my findings set out in volumes 1 and 2. I also discuss Bill C-38, an act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on March 29, 2012 and other measures, which was introduced on April 26, 2012, after this Inquiry's evidentiary hearings had concluded, and which received royal assent on June 29, 2012. Bill C-38 amends the Fisheries Act and enacts a new Canadian Environmental Assessment Act, 2012. I summarize the provisions most relevant to the works of this Inquiry, record the views of the participants, and comment on the possible implications of Bill C-38 for Fraser River sockeye salmon and my recommendations respecting them. Volume 3 also provides an executive summary of this Report and a description of the Commission process. Each volume includes appendices related to that volume. All three volumes contain the Terms of Reference, a glossary, and a list of abbreviations and acronyms. I refer to many views and opinions submitted by members of the public and participants in this Inquiry, to the testimony of witnesses, and to the documents and reports put before me. The issues dealt with in this Inquiry were the source of differing points of view. In many cases, the issues were matters of significant concern to the speakers or authors. In my effort to convey the intensity of these perspectives, I have quoted submissions and evidence that may strike the reader as incorrect, and perhaps extreme. It's important for the reader to understand that I have been clear in the Report where I have made findings. The recitations of evidence and submissions are not findings. The reader should not interpret the reproduction or summary of evidence or submissions as my endorsement of any particular view. Throughout this Report, I've tried to provide the reader with—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128195","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. I will continue: —directing me to investigate and make independent findings of fact regarding the causes of the decline of Fraser River sockeye. I summarize the public submissions I received regarding the causes of the decline, other investigations into the decline, as well as the scientific reports prepared for the Commission exploring the different possible causes of the declin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Authors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","label":"Authors","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["669b357dfd1eef7f296761f3ff3c556d3cc93936d8a4815be08dac11f0b99e35"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a4b065574b6ab55a4fbd8b8eae75079814538369ea543d67143a4d2e3a25d484"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9adc3ff0dc8e1c969f218864","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128196,"date":"2026-04-22T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. I quote: \"Throughout this report— Some hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128196","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I quote: \"Throughout this report— Some hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Authors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","label":"Children's literature","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","label":"Historical research","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","label":"Authors","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f621eaf4879c751d5a260db2609a94dff7ee4e506eebfc944e6bda7cf8a4c3c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc67ab93f9f30956fde088b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128197,"date":"2026-04-22T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"I'll continue: Throughout this Report, I have tried to provide the reader with references to the sources of information I relied on by including a list of endnotes following each chapter. The sources are primarily documentary evidence...and the testimony of witnesses.... I also refer to public submissions, which will be archived on our website.... Occasionally, I refer to legislation and judicial decisions, as well as policy and practice reports prepared by Commission staff. In exceptional cases where the evidence was insufficient to explain something, such as an aspect of DFO's organizational structure, I refer to websites. Although they are up to date as of June 30, 2012, it must be kept in mind that websites change over time or become unavailable. This Report is accompanied by a DVD that includes the transcripts from the hearings along with exhibits, technical reports, legislation, case law, and policy and practice reports relevant to this Report. The DVD also includes my rulings on issues that arose during the hearings, the participants' submissions, and the Interim Report and Final Report. Detailed maps included in the Report are also on the DVD and can be enlarged when viewed electronically. Where it might be useful, I have tried to provide the page numbers of the transcripts and exhibits that I rely on. For most documents—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128197","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll continue: Throughout this Report, I have tried to provide the reader with references to the sources of information I relied on by including a list of endnotes following each chapter. The sources are primarily documentary evidence...and the testimony of witnesses.... I also refer to public submissions, which will be archived on our website.... Occasionally, I refer to legislation and judicial ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Websites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","label":"Websites","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c08ae9d9fd865ef4313952094de99cfcd45cf4c5ba82e8dbf9e9f64770133107"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b62c0a9d9e7f05ae19a5e6ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128198,"date":"2026-04-22T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"I'll continue: For most documents, the page number corresponds to the original pagination. If the original document was unpaginated but pagination was applied through the process of its disclosure to the Commission...or by virtue of its being a PDF file, I have provided the corresponding page number. Now I'll go to chapter 1: The sockeye salmon of British Columbia's Fraser River are iconic in Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal communities. They have sustained numerous Aboriginal communities and have been at the centre of Aboriginal traditions in this province for millennia. As well, Fraser River sockeye are an important resource in the province's economy, and a key component of its freshwater and marine ecosystems. Thirty years ago, the Government of Canada established a wide-ranging inquiry to examine all Pacific coast fisheries, including Fraser River sockeye salmon.* Since then, the landscape has changed dramatically. Warming marine and river temperatures and changing snowpack-melting patterns have added to other stressors affecting the health and productivity of Fraser River sockeye salmon. The Supreme Court of Canada and lower courts have made pronouncements on Aboriginal fishing entitlements under the Canadian Constitution, and on other aspects of fisheries management. Management of the Fraser River sockeye fishery has become more complex given competing claims by First Nations and stakeholders, changing policies and practices, and dozens of investigations and reports containing hundreds of recommendations. Fisheries managers and fish biologists have identified a decline in Fraser River sockeye abundance and productivity since the early 1990s. In terms of abundance, Figure 1.1.1 illustrates that decline and places it in a broader historical context.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128198","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll continue: For most documents, the page number corresponds to the original pagination. If the original document was unpaginated but pagination was applied through the process of its disclosure to the Commission...or by virtue of its being a PDF file, I have provided the corresponding page number. Now I'll go to chapter 1: The sockeye salmon of British Columbia's Fraser River are iconic in Abor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","label":"Indigenous culture","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["62ebd9a6036312bb39cf933c19c79b43aff7e571374ce72b7d206bab08251529"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9c4ec81b1769fda495fba788a7d359f21cfeb0c14b7d60668d32358f27607e2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32970c5aca469fb168443f4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128199,"date":"2026-04-22T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"I believe this is very relevant to the motion. I'll continue: In terms of productivity, a think tank of scientists organized by Simon Fraser University and the Pacific Fisheries Resource Conservation Council expressed the decline by comparing the number of adults returning to spawn...to the number of spawning adults four years previously.... If the number of recruits is lower than the parental numbers, the stock would appear to be in decline. Between the early 1990s and 2009, there was a steady and profound decline, to the point where the number of recruits per spawner was well below the replacement level. The steady decline of this resource over the past several decades has put enormous pressure on Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal communities that depend on the sockeye salmon, whether for Aboriginal food, social, and ceremonial purposes, recreational pursuits, or livelihood. In 2009, a record low number of sockeye salmon returning to the Fraser River led to the closure of the fishery for the third consecutive year, despite favourable pre-season estimates of the number of sockeye salmon expected to return. However...there was a dramatic improvement in both abundance and productivity in 2010 and, to a lesser extent, in 2011. In November 2009, the Governor General in Council issued Order in Council 2009-1860 establishing this Commission of Inquiry and appointing me as sole Commissioner under Part 1 of the Inquiries Act to investigate this decline of sockeye salmon in the Fraser River. The same Order in Council set the Commission's Terms of Reference. The Order in Council with complete Terms of Reference appears as Appendix A. In brief, the Terms of Reference direct me (A) to conduct the Inquiry without seeking to find fault on the part of any individual, community or organization, and with the overall aim of respecting conservation of the sockeye salmon stock and encouraging broad cooperation among stakeholders, (B) to consider the policies and practices of the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (the \"Department\") with respect to the sockeye salmon fishery in the Fraser River – including the Department's scientific advice, its fisheries policies and programs, its risk management strategies, its allocation of Departmental resources and its fisheries management practices and procedures, including monitoring, counting of stocks, forecasting and enforcement, (C) to investigate and make independent findings of fact regarding (I) the causes for the decline of Fraser River sockeye salmon including, but not limited to, the impact of environmental changes along the Fraser River, marine environmental conditions, aquaculture, predators, diseases, water temperature and other factors that may have affected the ability of sockeye salmon to reach traditional spawning grounds or reach the ocean, and (II) the current state of Fraser River sockeye salmon stocks and the long term projections for those stocks, and (D) to develop recommendations for improving the future sustainability of the sockeye salmon fishery in the Fraser River including, as required, any changes to the policies, practices and procedures of the Department in relation to the management of the Fraser River sockeye salmon fishery[.] Although there have been several dozen examinations, investigations, and reports on various aspects of the Pacific fishery during the past three decades, this Commission's mandate is broader than the mandates of previous examinations. It calls for a consideration of all aspects of the policies and practices of the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO* in relation to the management of the Fraser River sockeye salmon fishery and an investigation – not limited to any one year's return – of the biological, ecological/environmental, and other causes of its decline. It is also the first Commission of Inquiry established under the authority of the Inquiries Act dealing with the Fraser River sockeye fishery since the 1982 Pearse Commission on Pacific Fisheries Policy. Several aspects of the Commission's mandate warrant preliminary comment. One of the provisions of the Terms of Reference unique to this Inquiry was the direction \"to conduct the Inquiry without seeking to find fault on the part of any individual, community or organization.\" Rather, I was mandated to encourage broad co-operation among stakeholders. I am pleased to report that throughout the Inquiry's proceedings, counsel for the various participants, while vigorously advancing their clients' interests, acted with a high degree of professionalism in adopting a collaborative and co-operative approach. This enabled the Commission to gather information and evidence upon which to build a better and clearer understanding about the past declines to place the Commission in a position to recommend the necessary steps and solutions for ensuring the future sustainability of the Fraser River sockeye salmon fishery. Early in my mandate, an application was made to interpret the direction \"to conduct the Inquiry without seeking to find fault ...\" In my ruling, I found that those words clearly directed me to conduct the Inquiry without focusing on assigning fault to any individual, community, or organization, and to encourage co-operation among the stakeholders. However, I also found that the direction did not preclude me from making any particular findings. In the event that the evidence led me to the conclusion that any individual, community, or organization had engaged in conduct that directly or indirectly was a factor causing or contributing to the decline of Fraser River sockeye salmon, or in conduct that was the basis for recommendations to change policies, practices, or procedures in relation to management of the fishery, the direction did not limit the scope of the findings or recommendations that I was able to make. The Terms of Reference direct me to investigate and make independent findings of fact regarding the causes of the decline of Fraser River sockeye salmon. Various biological and ecological issues are enumerated, but the words \"including, but not limited to\" invite me to consider other possible causes as well. The manner in which Fraser River sockeye stocks have been managed during the period of the decline is an important matter that warrants examination, for several reasons. First, the preamble to the Terms of Reference acknowledges that the decline \"has been attributed to the interplay of a wide range of factors, including environmental changes along the Fraser River, marine environmental conditions and fisheries management.\" Second, the Terms of Reference specifically direct me to consider the policies and practices of DFO with respect to the sockeye salmon fishery in the Fraser River, including: the department's scientific advice; its fisheries policies and programs; its risk management strategies; its allocation of departmental resources; and its fisheries management practices—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128199","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I believe this is very relevant to the motion. I'll continue: In terms of productivity, a think tank of scientists organized by Simon Fraser University and the Pacific Fisheries Resource Conservation Council expressed the decline by comparing the number of adults returning to spawn...to the number of spawning adults four years previously.... If the number of recruits is lower than the parental num","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["216b3b58364a9ca46d599451d0f2393c0cdd5cc3c1fe7e544ccdda011910b612"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4962385e75f2b835b0b9317875ab872908535de340a012fd75d033c953c3a24a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dcb474291948a25b63c73922","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128200,"date":"2026-04-22T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll continue: its risk management strategies; its allocation of departmental resources; and its fisheries management practices and procedures, including monitoring, counting of stocks, forecasting, and enforcement. The only matter on which I am invited to make recommendations to the Government of Canada relates to improving the future sustainability of the sockeye salmon fishery in the Fraser River. I must interpret that directive in a manner consistent with the other paragraphs of the Terms of Reference, which direct me to consider DFO's policies and practices with respect to the Fraser River sockeye fishery and to make independent findings of fact regarding the causes of the decline of the Fraser River sockeye stocks. The scope of my recommendations for improving the future sustainability of the Fraser River sockeye fishery will be informed by the breadth of my fact-finding mandate, and by the context in which that mandate was created—the decline of Fraser River sockeye stocks since the early 1990s. It is that decline that the Government of Canada seeks to reverse by instituting measures to improve the future sustainability of the Fraser River sockeye fishery. I am invited to make recommendations to that end. The Terms of Reference specifically invite me to recommend changes to DFO's policies, practices, and procedures in relation to the management of the Fraser River sockeye salmon fishery. However, the word \"including\" leaves open the possibility of making recommendations on other matters as well. Although the Terms of Reference are silent on the matter of Aboriginal rights and title, this Commission of Inquiry respectfully acknowledges the special relationship that many First Nations have with Fraser River sockeye salmon. They have fished these waters for sustenance for millennia and, through their traditions, ceremonies, and traditional ecological knowledge, bring a unique perspective to bear on this Inquiry's work. Aboriginal people also possess a unique legal status in relation to Fraser River sockeye, based on section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982, which states \"[t]he existing aboriginal and treaty rights of the aboriginal peoples of Canada are hereby recognized and affirmed.\" For example, in 1990 the Supreme Court of Canada recognized for the first time...an Aboriginal right to fish for food, social, and ceremonial purposes, and stated that such a right would be treated with priority, subject only to conservation. In addition, several historical and modern treaties negotiated between the Crown and First Nations refer to Aboriginal access and participation in fisheries, and therefore must be considered as part of the legal framework underlying the management of Fraser River sockeye. Aboriginal and treaty rights are discussed in more detail in Chapter 3, Legal framework. In order to develop an evidentiary basis for making the findings of fact and recommendations mandated by the Terms of Reference, this Commission acquired information from a variety of sources. Taking direction from the Terms of Reference, I published an Interim Report in October 2010, setting out my views on any previous examinations, investigations, or reports deemed relevant to the Inquiry, and on Canada's responses to them. Previous reports were an important source of information. Over the past three decades, there have been dozens of reports on the Pacific fisheries, primarily focusing on DFO's management of the fisheries and its activities respecting harvesting, protection of habitat, protection of wild salmon stocks, and aquaculture. Some, such as Dr. Peter Pearse's 1982 report, were sweeping in nature, examining the condition, management, and utilization of all Pacific coast fisheries. Others, such as the Honourable Bryan Williams' 2005 report, which examined only the 2004 Fraser River sockeye salmon return, focused on a single event. In my October 2010 Interim Report, entitled Fraser River Sockeye Salmon: Past Declines. Future Sustainability?, I discussed 26 of those reports, and summarized the recommendations contained in them and the federal government's initial responses to them. Under the Commission's Terms of Reference, I may consider the findings of these previous reports, as I consider appropriate and relevant, and give them any weight, including accepting them as conclusive. In my Interim Report, I also discussed the input received by the Commission in response to its June 2010 discussion paper, which outlined the salmon management and technical and scientific issues the Commission intended to investigate, as well as our public forums in 10 coastal and Fraser River communities and our 14 site visits in 12 British Columbia communities. A more detailed description of the Commission's activities before and after the release of the Interim Report can be found in Volume 3, Chapter 5, Commission process. Throughout the Inquiry, members of the public were invited to express their views on issues related to the Commission's mandate by mail, by making a public submission on the Commission's website, or by commenting on another person's submission. The Commission received approximately 900 submissions, which are referred to throughout this Report. The Commission undertook a scientific research program, directed by our in-house fisheries research consultant, to investigate possible causes of the decline of Fraser River sockeye. Terms of reference were developed for a series of technical reports, which were contracted out to technical researchers knowledgeable in the respective fields on which they reported. In total, the researchers produced 15 technical reports. Under the Commission's Rules for Procedure and Practice...I may consider these technical reports in making my findings of fact and recommendations. The technical reports are discussed in Volume 2 of this Report; executive summaries are included as Appendix B to Volume 2; and each report is reproduced in full in the DVD accompanying this Report. In April 2010, I made 21 grants of standing for participation in the Commission. Many of these grants of standing were shared among applicants who originally applied individually. In total, 53 individuals, groups, and organizations were included in these grants of standing. Between October 2010 and September 2011, I conducted the evidentiary hearings, which were open to the media and public. Most of the hearings were held at the Federal Court in downtown Vancouver, BC. Hearings were reopened in December 2011 to consider emerging evidence on infectious salmon anemia (ISA) virus. Each witness testified under oath or affirmation, either alone or as a member of a panel. Each was questioned by Commission counsel and cross-examined by participants or participants' counsel. Witnesses included DFO senior management and employees, officials from the Province of British Columbia and local governments, independent scientists, conservationists, representatives of the aquaculture industry, and representatives of the commercial, sport, and Aboriginal fisheries. The authors of the Commission's technical reports were also questioned and cross-examined on their reports. The Commission held 133 days of evidentiary hearings, during which 179 witnesses testified, 2,145 documents were filed as exhibits, and 14,166 pages of transcript were generated. Exhibits and transcripts were posted on the Commission's website, giving the media and public full access to our proceedings. All hearing transcripts and the exhibits referred to in this Report are included in the accompanying DVD. Commission counsel also prepared 21 policy and practice reports on a wide range of legal topics and on numerous salmon management policies and practices. These reports were circulated to all participants in advance of evidentiary hearings on the corresponding topics, and were also filed as exhibits. They are part of the DVD included with this Report. Under the Commission's Rules for Procedure and Practice, I may consider these reports and the documents they reference in making my findings of fact and recommendations. At the conclusion of the evidentiary hearings, I received extensive written and oral final submissions from participants respecting the matters into which I have been directed to inquire, including recommendations for improving the future sustainability of the Fraser River sockeye salmon fishery. In April and May 2012, I invited participants to provide supplementary submissions, if they wished, on how their submissions were affected by proposed changes to a number of pieces of legislation relevant to the work of the Commission contained in Bill C-38.... All the sources of information and evidence discussed above have formed the basis of this Report, including my findings of fact and recommendations. My Terms of Reference direct me to develop recommendations for improving the sustainability of the Fraser River sockeye fishery. I interpret this as direction to consider the Fraser River sockeye fishery as a whole. However, this fishery is multifaceted and comprises three distinct harvest sectors: the Aboriginal communal fishery, the general commercial fishery, and the recreational fishery. Here, I provide a brief introduction to each of these harvest sectors; they are discussed in greater detail throughout my Report. Aboriginal communities have been fishing Fraser River sockeye for all of living memory. While British Columbia is home to a diverse population of Aboriginal cultures, I heard that many groups share a sense of cultural identity deeply rooted in the salmon fishery. This identity includes a profound respect for salmon, which are sometimes viewed as relatives or kin as opposed to simply as fish. Respect for salmon is passed down from Aboriginal elders to younger generations and is instilled in the laws of Aboriginal nations. Several witnesses told me that Aboriginal participation in the Fraser sockeye fishery is a vital means to preserve Aboriginal cultural practices and traditions. For example, Councillor June Quipp of the Cheam Indian Band told me that the salmon fishery is a part of her community's \"spirit,\" and Chief Fred Sampson of the Siska Indian Band told me that his community's cultural, physical, and spiritual well-being are all dependent on the salmon fishery. Aboriginal communal fishing licences authorize fishing for food, social, and ceremonial purposes. In respect of fishing for these purposes, Aboriginal groups enjoy a priority of access to Fraser River sockeye, subject to conservation. An hon. member: I have a point of order. Ernie Klassen: In addition, some Aboriginal communal fishing licences may authorize fishing—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128200","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll continue: its risk management strategies; its allocation of departmental resources; and its fisheries management practices and procedures, including monitoring, counting of stocks, forecasting, and enforcement. The only matter on which I am invited to make recommendations to the Government of Canada relates to improving the future sustainability of the sockeye salmon fis","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","label":"Fisheries technology","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1730fad72bf6998588995328564f5aa9ccc3a58ddbb916fd208eebe59cf5cdee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a95bea9e09e2fde8027e580b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301462,"date":"2026-04-23T23:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, perhaps I can clarify something for my colleague across the floor. The private member's bill referenced by the member was reckless and would have threatened the livelihoods of harvesters, plant workers and their families, and communities right across Atlantic Canada. Do not just take it from me. Both the FFAW and ASP shared their concern with the member's scheme. For those listening at home in the member's own province, the inshore fleet, the offshore fleet, processors and ENGOs were all against his proposal and have all stated it was a bill to change science and not to fish seven days a week. He ignored science, consultation and the thousands of people, including those in his own province, who depend on the fishery. \n\nTo hear from the people, the Minister of Fisheries launched the food fisheries survey, to which more than 9,500 people responded. It was the highest level of participation ever for a DFO survey. That is real consultation. Tomorrow, the minister will be meeting with recreational fishers, the province, the FFAW and ASP to hear their thoughts on the future of the food fishery. We want to get this right. Our government recently published the food fishery \"What We Heard Report\", and I recommend the member read it to see what Newfoundlanders and Labradorians want to see in the food fishery. \n\nThe member opposite proposed an entirely new monitoring system just for recreational fishers and would have forced Newfoundlanders and Labradorians to record their catch. How did the member want to offset those new administrative and red-tape costs? It was fees on the fishers themselves. That is not true representation. He proposed to have the government cover \"the administrative costs of the monitoring system by fees and penalties that are required to be paid under the Fisheries Act\". That would have meant licence fees and nobody wants those. \n\nThe member proposed a new system that would have told Newfoundlanders and Labradorians that they cannot catch cod like they have for their entire lives and it would have only made the fishery worse. Our government understands that the food fishery is culturally important. The member opposite talks about affordability, but he would have put a Conservative tax on those who fish to feed themselves and their families, as they have done for generations. This past year, the food fishery in Newfoundland and Labrador had no licence requirement, no licence fee and no reporting requirement. The idea was was just to follow the rules, be safe and fish for food. \n\nUnder the member's Conservative tax on food system, food fishers in Newfoundland and Labrador would have been forced to have a mandatory licence, pay a fee to cover additional new red tape and report every fish they caught through a new system that would also cost them money to use. \n\nWhile our new government is providing tax relief to millions of Canadians and working to build a stronger economy, the member has been playing short-sighted political games that threaten the economy for everyone in Atlantic Canada and would have made Newfoundlanders and Labradorians pay for the food fishery. \n\nOur government is working on behalf of all Canadians to truly make life more affordable for everyone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301462","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, perhaps I can clarify something for my colleague across the floor. The private member's bill referenced by the member was reckless and would have threatened the livelihoods of harvesters, plant workers and their families, and communities right across Atlantic Canada. Do not just take it from me. Both the FFAW and ASP shared their concern with the member's scheme. For those listening a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a2c11f0e9bb3bc1b436df7f17ddd926bac4516d16e3ca01c8d1b564d50004e5b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2188d2e80ddf173e378860a118fe433a6ed0c8fdaf1aefcdbec4c651ca5d19bd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56d4d8c8132ec66b1f7e2bb2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301463,"date":"2026-04-23T23:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it sounds like the member is forgetting what his bill actually called for. It is a tax on food for people in his province. It did not say anything about fishing seven days a week, but it did call for new red tape and licence fees on food fishers. That is not what Newfoundlanders and Labradorians want. He did not consult or listen to fishers. He put forward a proposal that threatened the entire commercial fishing industry in Atlantic Canada. That is tens of thousands of jobs and billions of dollars. \n\nThe Minister of Fisheries did a full survey to hear from the people in the province on what they want to see in the food fishery. Over 9,500 people completed the survey. Our government knows how much people in his province care about the food fishery. The member should read the \"What We Heard Report\" we recently published to see what real consultation looks like. He will find that his proposals for more red tape and licence fees are not popular with food fishers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301463","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it sounds like the member is forgetting what his bill actually called for. It is a tax on food for people in his province. It did not say anything about fishing seven days a week, but it did call for new red tape and licence fees on food fishers. That is not what Newfoundlanders and Labradorians want. He did not consult or listen to fishers. He put forward a proposal that threatened t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63abd87b5d998bb93ef70182563d30a96440253c90c3a13e4e664d5ff926b625"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad0788f5073ffd83c39d8095ffa9d97bfbf155e91779a710d2191a52553aa294"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52a46a9d0c85a4457ad154a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301461,"date":"2026-04-24T16:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, earlier this week, Ottawa was proud to host the 33rd Canadian Legislative Conference of the International Association of Fire Fighters. This annual gathering brings firefighters from across the country together to engage with parliamentarians and to raise awareness about federal issues that affect both their profession and the communities they serve.\n\nRepresentatives from the White Rock and Surrey fire departments raised issues directly affecting their members, including increasing the memorial grant program and strengthening protections for communities against lithium battery fires. These courageous first responders put their lives on the line every day to protect our residents and respond to emergencies. They are also deeply committed to their communities, raising funds for local charities, supporting families in need and giving back through countless volunteer initiatives.\n\nI thank our firefighters for their courage, their compassion and their unwavering service to our communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301461","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, earlier this week, Ottawa was proud to host the 33rd Canadian Legislative Conference of the International Association of Fire Fighters. This annual gathering brings firefighters from across the country together to engage with parliamentarians and to raise awareness about federal issues that affect both their profession and the communities they serve.\n\nRepresentatives from the White Ro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["26bed90bae35c3199c656a4d9251208eb3c1a3de618d934b289ec4aef4969fdd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff41e7f655bae70ce46c5423110f666ccac270fea1c18a2865a32a324a684bc2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c211c23ec02ce443ff3acd43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728671,"date":"2026-04-30T19:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Doug Tennant has dedicated more than 35 years to advancing inclusion for people with developmental disabilities as a parent, volunteer and CEO of Uniti.\n\nDoug has worked alongside self-advocate leaders to help ensure they have the same rights and opportunities as all Canadians. Doug helped lead innovative housing initiatives, creating communities that provide quality housing for all, including people with disabilities. His leadership has strengthened partnerships in the non-profit, business and public sectors. Doug has served as a board member of Uniti, the Surrey Board of Trade and the BC CEO Network. He was a founder of the Canadian Business Disability Inclusion Network. He uses his influence to challenge bigotry through initiatives such as We Belong Surrey.\n\nAs he retires, Doug plans to continue volunteering to advance inclusion and affordable housing, hopeful that his work helps shape policy, inspire leaders and build more welcoming communities. I wish Doug a happy retirement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728671","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Doug Tennant has dedicated more than 35 years to advancing inclusion for people with developmental disabilities as a parent, volunteer and CEO of Uniti.\n\nDoug has worked alongside self-advocate leaders to help ensure they have the same rights and opportunities as all Canadians. Doug helped lead innovative housing initiatives, creating communities that provide quality housing for all, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f01e17a1170ebb7d44bc7c4c0105ece7ad6de4e9e8a50f5fd44e0fc0755baa83"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66f87452eff467a6d7303313cdaf62f98ec796670471bfb46144ee83a00afaee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fb354a5682c7550cde037f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728667,"date":"2026-05-01T16:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, last week the minister was pleased to publish the \"What We Heard\" report from the food fishery survey. This was the largest survey done by DFO, with over 9,500 participants. We want to thank everyone who responded to the survey in order to allow us to work better for the people of the member across the aisle's statement.\n\nOur government knows how important the food fishery is in the province of Newfoundland and Labrador. We need to get this—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728667","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, last week the minister was pleased to publish the \"What We Heard\" report from the food fishery survey. This was the largest survey done by DFO, with over 9,500 participants. We want to thank everyone who responded to the survey in order to allow us to work better for the people of the member across the aisle's statement.\n\nOur government knows how important the food fishery is in the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","label":"Surveys"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","label":"Surveys","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["560c54b7bc8f4671835c8b644ebc331029b18be9e652a6fe0db3a3e494a4cf2b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd860447e4b3f77d510839ef5c971e893a21aa9165c5b96ebe5db235b07d6bad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b39e205c413e21e37669026","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128201,"date":"2026-05-04T16:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to all the witnesses for being present here with us today. Mr. Davis, there was, as you know, a lot of talk around fishers in 2025 and the overabundance of a return, which was unprecedented from my understanding. You talked about organizations that were involved in the decision-making process, in-season especially, and I'm wondering what factors are considered when making those decisions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128201","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to all the witnesses for being present here with us today. Mr. Davis, there was, as you know, a lot of talk around fishers in 2025 and the overabundance of a return, which was unprecedented from my understanding. You talked about organizations that were involved in the decision-making process, in-season especially, and I'm wondering what factors are considered whe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4564389f293eaccb82c64cc6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128202,"date":"2026-05-04T16:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"I have a second question that's not really related to that but related to the salmon run of the Fraser River. I have a lot of colleagues who have raised the issue of dredging. Does that have an impact on the opening and closing of the season?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128202","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a second question that's not really related to that but related to the salmon run of the Fraser River. I have a lot of colleagues who have raised the issue of dredging. Does that have an impact on the opening and closing of the season?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8fddcf29081ae6f3b4a2e618","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128203,"date":"2026-05-04T16:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. Mr. Vigneault, our government recently announced a move to increase mass marking for hatchery-raised salmon. This has been a major ask from the recreational fishery in B.C. How will this impact sport and recreational fishing, as well as the opening season and the tourism sector in B.C.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128203","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Vigneault, our government recently announced a move to increase mass marking for hatchery-raised salmon. This has been a major ask from the recreational fishery in B.C. How will this impact sport and recreational fishing, as well as the opening season and the tourism sector in B.C.?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["269fb3963b701f2a09f9dd134ce1433de2e352db19f64a2fed49d5d273080755"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f3e2db2f1ec2ab508876bae6d992619a7155d9f6d791a810282a1db5513a439"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f847dd5e4fca8dfc47e05ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960992,"date":"2026-05-04T19:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in 2011, along British Columbia's Highway of Tears, a remote stretch of Highway 16 where far too many indigenous women and girls have gone missing or been murdered, Paul and Raven Lacerte were moved to action. They are the father and daughter co-founders of the Moose Hide Campaign. It is an indigenous-led movement grounded in love, ceremony and accountability, calling on people of all backgrounds to take a stand against gender-based and domestic violence. \n\nWearing a moose hide pin is more than a symbol. It represents a personal commitment to honour, respect and protect women and children in our homes, workplaces and communities. It is about building safer communities where everyone is responsible to speak up and support one another.\n\nOn Thursday, May 14, Moose Hide Campaign Day, I am asking all Canadians to renew that pledge and, most important, to take meaningful action because ending violence is a responsibility we all share every single day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960992","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in 2011, along British Columbia's Highway of Tears, a remote stretch of Highway 16 where far too many indigenous women and girls have gone missing or been murdered, Paul and Raven Lacerte were moved to action. They are the father and daughter co-founders of the Moose Hide Campaign. It is an indigenous-led movement grounded in love, ceremony and accountability, calling on people of all","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b98748637700622e78e55d58c4769ff7343d50c0266f4063f0a7e87c7274d6ed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["552a87f3ee8d354016e58858120c91d1ca65094891e092650928802da50b1066"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7d96fc3ab1a5283019e5e8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128204,"date":"2026-05-06T23:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"I'll make a quick comment. I don't see why the witnesses can't be asked questions about the north, the west and the east coasts. Nobody is stopping anybody from talking about the west coast or the north coast. This isn't about reconciliation. We can talk about the entire country, as long as it relates to the subject matter that is identified as the study.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128204","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll make a quick comment. I don't see why the witnesses can't be asked questions about the north, the west and the east coasts. Nobody is stopping anybody from talking about the west coast or the north coast. This isn't about reconciliation. We can talk about the entire country, as long as it relates to the subject matter that is identified as the study.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebed25520eaf781ff5d99680","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960987,"date":"2026-05-07T17:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to use my time today to speak about the recent agreements that Canada signed with the Musqueam nation. These agreements build on the Constitution Act, 1982, the direction provided by the courts over the last several decades and efforts of indigenous groups over many years to have their rights recognized and upheld by the Crown. To understand these agreements, it is helpful to begin with the Constitution.\n\nSection 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982 states that \"The existing aboriginal and treaty rights of the aboriginal peoples of Canada are hereby recognized and affirmed.\" It reflects Parliament's recognition that indigenous nations will become partners in Confederation based on fair and just reconciliation between indigenous peoples and the Crown. Existing aboriginal and treaty rights include rights defined under historical or modern treaties and the asserted aboriginal rights and title of indigenous nations with claims to land that remain unresolved.\n\n Indigenous nations have rights and title within their territory that are recognized and affirmed by section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982. Section 35 recognizes what first nations have always known, that they have aboriginal rights. However, acknowledging aboriginal rights is not the same as defining those rights. General recognition that a first nation has aboriginal title acknowledges a legal and historical fact. That recognition also creates an important and respectful starting point for the negotiation of agreements to address their claims. General recognition of aboriginal rights, including title, is often included in agreements negotiated between governments and indigenous nations, including both treaties and incremental non-treaty agreements.\n\n Agreements such as the Musqueam Rights Recognition Agreement contain general recognition and do not create a legal interest in any specific lands. Specific recognition of aboriginal title means that an indigenous group has aboriginal title to specific lands, including a legal ownership interest based on their historical use and occupation of those lands. This type of recognition can happen either as part of an agreement negotiated between governments and indigenous nations or as a result of a court decision in an aboriginal title case such as in the Cowichan and Tsilhqot'in cases. Quite simply, this agreement does not create aboriginal rights for Musqueam. It does not define the nature or scope of their aboriginal rights. It simply acknowledges that Musqueam have aboriginal rights including aboriginal title somewhere, not throughout, within their entire traditional territory. Most important, it sets out a process for discussion about how and where those rights might be implemented in the future. To use the analogy of a tool box, general recognition of aboriginal rights through the Musqueam Rights Recognition Agreement is like agreeing that a tool box exists. What it does not do is decide how the tools will be used or which tools will be needed. Those are questions that will be worked through later, together, through discussion and negotiation.\n\n Moreover, the Musqueam Rights Recognition Agreement does not impact third party interests, including private property. It does not impact the rights of other first nations. It does not impact or alter the jurisdiction of federal, provincial or local governments. No decision-making powers about lands, waters or resources are transferred through these agreements. The Musqueam agreement does not mention private property because private property was never on the negotiating table in the first place. There has been a lot of commentary regarding these agreements. Canadians place great value on private property and also recognize the importance of advancing reconciliation with indigenous people.\n\n Given the importance of advancing reconciliation with first nations and the need for clarity as Canada strengthens its economy, it is critical that we are clear about what these agreements are and what they are not. To that end, I would emphasize that private property is firmly under the jurisdiction of provincial governments. It cannot be negotiated away from provinces or Canadians without their consent and it is not something the federal government can alter through this type of agreement. The Government of Canada respects both existing private property interests and constitutionally protected indigenous rights within the federal government's areas of responsibility. The Musqueam people have clearly stated that they have no intention of pursuing private property through this agreement.\n\n If I may quote Musqueam chief Wayne Sparrow, he said, \"Our approach to traditional unceded territory is one of partnership and relationship with our neighbours, not trying to take away our neighbours' private property.\"\n\nTreaties and other agreements, such as the one with Musqueam, allow government to advance reconciliation and address indigenous rights and title through dialogue and co-operation while protecting private property and providing certainty for all Canadians. The Musqueam Rights Recognition Agreement provides a path forward to address Musqueam's rights and title collaboratively and avoid the uncertainty and high costs of pursuing litigation in the courts.\n\nCanada has consistently stated that the best way to resolve outstanding claims is to work together in partnership through co-operative negotiations and respectful dialogue, not through litigation. The litigation of land claims often involves unpredictable outcomes and significant costs for provincial, territorial and federal governments, and Canadians. Negotiated agreements provide an alternative that supports clarity and stability around the exercise of aboriginal rights.\n\nAgreements like the Musqueam agreement are about creating certainty and predictability, predictability for investors, for major projects, for private landowners, for indigenous groups and for all Canadians. By negotiating agreements such as this one, Canada is taking a responsible approach to resolving outstanding claims, including through its work with Musqueam. In so doing, we are able to advance the resolution of long-standing disputes about land and rights in ways that respect the rights of indigenous peoples, uphold existing private property rights and reflect the best interests of all Canadians.\n\nThis approach supports a stronger and more unified Canada, where private property and indigenous rights are respected together.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960987","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to use my time today to speak about the recent agreements that Canada signed with the Musqueam nation. These agreements build on the Constitution Act, 1982, the direction provided by the courts over the last several decades and efforts of indigenous groups over many years to have their rights recognized and upheld by the Crown. To understand these agreements, it is helpfu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8f2680a396a9984de5d6e3064ddc0b7965e7982e1befa554d09ae49e6abc8678"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8903004241527595849f248f05001823db4fdf5af2d4392d56d3aa8b30bd116d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39f4cdfd60f9c4cc5ebc0e75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960988,"date":"2026-05-07T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this motion misrepresents both the law and the government's position. It suggests that Canadians could lose their homes because of agreements with indigenous partners, and that is simply not true. Our government has been clear. We support protecting private property rights and we are actively defending them through the courts. At the same time, we will not support a partisan process that supports and spreads fear and misinformation about reconciliation and indigenous partnerships.\n\nOur government has been clear that reconciliation is the way in which we want to move forward on these.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960988","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this motion misrepresents both the law and the government's position. It suggests that Canadians could lose their homes because of agreements with indigenous partners, and that is simply not true. Our government has been clear. We support protecting private property rights and we are actively defending them through the courts. At the same time, we will not support a partisan process t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b52914614d39a74f54c18b00b30acbe845dd4ab62a544c11f3273195e1e2e859"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc587fa2cff82d20f9854b4b0b1b25308160c4321ecb707e2ee6e45ec32283bd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e2bfe4fd2c79b2bdbf66b53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960989,"date":"2026-05-07T17:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, protecting the certainty and integrity of private property rights remains a fundamental priority for our government. That is precisely why we advance all viable legal arguments to protect private property. We do not agree with the B.C. Supreme Court's ruling, which is why the government appealed it back in September. Our government is fully committed to ensuring stability, certainty and confidence for Canadians who own property while we advance reconciliation.\n\nThis matter is before the courts, where it should properly be addressed, not reduced to partisan rhetoric in this chamber.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960989","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, protecting the certainty and integrity of private property rights remains a fundamental priority for our government. That is precisely why we advance all viable legal arguments to protect private property. We do not agree with the B.C. Supreme Court's ruling, which is why the government appealed it back in September. Our government is fully committed to ensuring stability, certainty a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e082cc61df02f9d359bdd5c2b477525558c9ddeab03e857f8c6f98327f814fa3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19dee2dca1e78ba6d3628814641bf1e6294a616794975f79faa9b5d2edcca000"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c05daad66042d6f5897aae4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960990,"date":"2026-05-07T17:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, preserving the certainty and stability of private property is of utmost importance. This is why we will advance all viable legal arguments to protect private property. We believed then and we continue to believe now that those potentially affected by a decision of this magnitude deserve to be informed and heard. This is why, as far back as 2017, Canada argued before the court that private landowners should be notified of the litigation. This is why we have supported an application that would allow Montrose, a private property owner in the area, to present evidence that was not before—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960990","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, preserving the certainty and stability of private property is of utmost importance. This is why we will advance all viable legal arguments to protect private property. We believed then and we continue to believe now that those potentially affected by a decision of this magnitude deserve to be informed and heard. This is why, as far back as 2017, Canada argued before the court that pri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d708662fd33881f4747af866879471afd773b38a87f97d604894309b17b014a1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8c52a212416f448464a1c458d5b2a2c48b75108acfa848b475a00b579b0dc16"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28d0c26c4a706c51e5f588ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960991,"date":"2026-05-07T17:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is also important to be very clear about the Musqueam agreements. These agreements do not impact private property. The agreements recognize the Musqueam's constitutionally protected aboriginal rights in the specific areas of stewardship and marine emergency management while creating a practical framework for collaboration between Canada and the first nations. These agreements respect the rights of indigenous peoples—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960991","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is also important to be very clear about the Musqueam agreements. These agreements do not impact private property. The agreements recognize the Musqueam's constitutionally protected aboriginal rights in the specific areas of stewardship and marine emergency management while creating a practical framework for collaboration between Canada and the first nations. These agreements respe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c84132acefd2b88ed5d8c06652e20a2106e19412c03486ecd2b06f680f8dcb9b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a773a1a358d648df0a556a605646a9208349f4d16c0ffe5fb735497757b1bbd9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5613581014410b201504c330","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960986,"date":"2026-05-08T16:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in Canada, educators are working to ensure that our schools are places where all students feel safe, respected and able to learn.\n\n Organizations, such as the ARC Foundation, support this effort through initiatives like SOGI 123, which provides educators with age-appropriate tools and resources to foster inclusive and respectful school environments. This helps schools strengthen policies, promote kindness and ensure that students, regardless of background, identity or experience, can thrive.\n\nResearch has shown that inclusive school environments can reduce social exclusion, bullying and discrimination, which benefits not only 2SLGBTQIA+ youth but also all other students in feeling safe and supported. It is important to ensure that our schools reflect both inclusion and trust, which allows society to learn and accept the diverse world around them. Every young person in Canada deserves dignity, respect and the opportunity to reach their full potential.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960986","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in Canada, educators are working to ensure that our schools are places where all students feel safe, respected and able to learn.\n\n Organizations, such as the ARC Foundation, support this effort through initiatives like SOGI 123, which provides educators with age-appropriate tools and resources to foster inclusive and respectful school environments. This helps schools strengthen polic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["317d7147c216db7707bd0013c7157a28760a92d1c4656c2c105f10f3ec86d4f2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0581f7161501a7cc878edfdaafb7e3abc895e0704c144fd7ea4b7643ea973fcd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1754c3436989038919afd93f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036356,"date":"2026-05-26T18:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, for over 100 years, Alex House in my riding of South Surrey—White Rock has been dedicated to empowering people to build and nurture a strong, connected community by offering programs and services that support individuals and families at every stage of life, from early childhood education and youth programs to seniors' services, wellness initiatives and community outreach. \n\nThis year also marks the 50th anniversary of Alex Fest, a celebration held on Semiahmoo First Nation land bringing together families, local artists and neighbours from across the Semiahmoo peninsula to share in creativity, learning and community spirit.\n\nI would like to thank the board, staff and volunteers for their continued commitment and recognize Penny Bradley for her outstanding leadership. At the heart of Alex House is a simple truth. Its mission would not be possible without the hard work and dedication of volunteers.\n\n I congratulate Alex House on these important milestones.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036356","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, for over 100 years, Alex House in my riding of South Surrey—White Rock has been dedicated to empowering people to build and nurture a strong, connected community by offering programs and services that support individuals and families at every stage of life, from early childhood education and youth programs to seniors' services, wellness initiatives and community outreach. \n\nThis year ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b21a5827596be91dcd0ffcf727f1c2b9f73848ee6398e48d6cce0d2457bbc390"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["625fe4f6cdcb9710fa1a97dc23f418fea82224512e978fbe1678cd9966302df2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fcd0851ce031fba33e9bf15","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036354,"date":"2026-05-28T00:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I welcome the opportunity to address the issues raised by my colleague, the hon. member for Courtenay—Alberni. \n\nFisheries and Oceans Canada is aware that many fish harvesters on the west coast are facing economic challenges. That is why, in February, the Minister of Fisheries announced two new objectives to guide the licensing reform work happening under the west coast commercial fisheries modernization initiative. These objectives are to support working harvesters so they have more control over their fishing activities and keep a greater share of the benefits from their fishing effort, and to modernize the licensing regime to support harvesters in pursuing their business objectives and adapting to change.\n\n Work is already under way. The government is engaging on fishery-specific policy options to achieve these objectives, starting with the crab and prawn fisheries. As part of this effort, DFO is gathering perspectives on the feasibility and implications of various policy options, such as made-in-B.C. versions of owner-operator and fleet separation requirements, and other ideas raised by participants and harvesters. DFO will also launch a survey of licence and quota holdings and leasing agreements to ensure that policies are informed by robust and current data.\n\nThe government understands the challenges that harvesters are facing, but those who rely on the fishery have told us that a cookie-cutter approach will not suffice. Careful consideration will be given to different ways that fisheries have evolved in British Columbia compared to on the east coast, when contemplating owner-operator type requirements or other policy ideas that can support active harvesters and the flow of benefits to local communities.\n\nThe government knows how important it is for Canada's fisheries resources to stay in the hands of Canadians. That is why we completed a beneficial ownership survey in 2022 to learn more about foreign participation in Canadian fisheries. While the results told us that 98% of respondents reported being Canadian-owned, we are conducting further research and analysis to deepen our understanding about who actually is benefiting from Canada's west coast fisheries.\n\n DFO believes in transparency of fisheries data and is actively working to improve data transparency for the benefit of active harvesters, new fishery participants and all Canadians. We have published interactive socio-economic data dashboards for fishery participants to learn more about the economics of their fisheries, and we are collecting more socio-economic data. We have also taken steps to make public data sets more accessible by publishing a web-based portal to facilitate access to publicly available licences and quota information.\n\nThe Government of Canada remains committed to supporting the economic health and prosperity of coastal communities that rely on fishery resources. We know that fishing activities are an important cultural and economic feature of many coastal communities in B.C. The government will not take a one-size-fits-all approach.\n\nThe west coast commercial fisheries modernization initiative will provide important opportunities for first nations and fishery participants to shape the future of licensing policy, ensuring that any policy changes are practical, effective, and suited and tailored to the west coast context, not a replica of the east coast.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036354","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I welcome the opportunity to address the issues raised by my colleague, the hon. member for Courtenay—Alberni. \n\nFisheries and Oceans Canada is aware that many fish harvesters on the west coast are facing economic challenges. That is why, in February, the Minister of Fisheries announced two new objectives to guide the licensing reform work happening under the west coast commercial f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ff7f2e9ea7ec7fae8cf35b65d6da3d5864b063f139fb4b3f0049bdc93bd3ec79"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48aa78b68f5136e724816c2bd6619c7a882e21fdc2b117576feb06e01b47cbc9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-063b5cbca0897bc2213bb490","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036355,"date":"2026-05-28T00:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Government of Canada is committed to supporting and strengthening the economies of our coastal communities.\n\nFishing is an important part of many coastal communities on the west coast. This government is taking steps to actively work with first nations, harvesters, licence holders and processors to explore potential solutions that reflect the unique realities of the west coast. \n\nThe Minister of Fisheries recently announced two new objectives guiding work to modernize west coast fisheries. The first is supporting harvesters to have more control over their fishing activities, to keep a greater share of the benefits from fishing. The second is modernizing licensing to support harvesters in pursuing their business objectives. This government will work closely with west coast fishery participants on options for how to achieve these objectives and address the concerns of fish harvesters.\n\nFisheries on the east and west coasts have evolved very differently. We cannot have a one-size-fits-all approach. This is why this government is working with those involved to develop solutions—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036355","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Government of Canada is committed to supporting and strengthening the economies of our coastal communities.\n\nFishing is an important part of many coastal communities on the west coast. This government is taking steps to actively work with first nations, harvesters, licence holders and processors to explore potential solutions that reflect the unique realities of the west coast. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0374598c30466205c35078d9f804aed51d4224fd6510745b1e3b338f2893acdf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b6fa4908572f95c7440d0fd31f3d85493eba462014d9bb0bf40eadcd18b4612d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-418a8b4c3107c63dd4d65b5b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128205,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thanks to all the witnesses for appearing here today. Ms. Paul, the Fisheries Act requires the minister to consider impacts on indigenous rights when making fisheries decisions. Can you give an example of when indigenous observation is different from DFO science? How should these differences then be reconciled?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128205","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thanks to all the witnesses for appearing here today. Ms. Paul, the Fisheries Act requires the minister to consider impacts on indigenous rights when making fisheries decisions. Can you give an example of when indigenous observation is different from DFO science? How should these differences then be reconciled?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bcd9ffa14534e1778b6f067","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128206,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"That's correct—versus DFO's decision-making. Is there a difference of opinion, and how is that reconciled?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128206","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's correct—versus DFO's decision-making. Is there a difference of opinion, and how is that reconciled?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034615","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conciliation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034615","label":"Conciliation","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["886654d09894f93248f56c1658ea3c78d965b1f3c0a4d1450c5ca00af634197d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3065c3111bd7e2aad692847a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128207,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you very much. My next question is for—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128207","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. My next question is for—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a427fd8283dc87d60c64073","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128208,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"It's okay. I'll move to another question for Mr. McLinton or Mr. Dovey. You talked about the prawn decision coming quite late. I couldn't remember if you said when the committee met. The decision was made mid-May, and I'm wondering if you can talk a bit about the delay and why there was about a two-month delay from the time the committee met until the decision was made.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128208","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's okay. I'll move to another question for Mr. McLinton or Mr. Dovey. You talked about the prawn decision coming quite late. I couldn't remember if you said when the committee met. The decision was made mid-May, and I'm wondering if you can talk a bit about the delay and why there was about a two-month delay from the time the committee met until the decision was made.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35a19267ff98208e4c47a399","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128209,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128209","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e67ae15c556fa135364be56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084431,"date":"2026-06-03T19:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this week we celebrate National AccessAbility Week, which began in 1988. Inspired by Rick Hansen's Man in Motion World Tour, this week honours the contributions of Canadians with disabilities and reminds us that we can always build a more inclusive and accessible society. This year's Canadian theme is \"Building a Strong, Accessible Canada.\"\n\n More than eight million Canadians face barriers in everyday life. Many of these obstacles are built into our homes and workplaces. As the father of a son with a disability, and a friend of Rick Hansen and of Canada's first chief accessibility officer, Stephanie Cadieux, I have seen first-hand the importance of designing our communities equitably.\n\n This week, we celebrate the progress we have made so far and acknowledge the work of advocates whose leadership continues to break down barriers and inspire positive change. Together, we can continue building communities where everyone can participate and thrive. Let us create a fair and welcoming society for everyone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084431","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this week we celebrate National AccessAbility Week, which began in 1988. Inspired by Rick Hansen's Man in Motion World Tour, this week honours the contributions of Canadians with disabilities and reminds us that we can always build a more inclusive and accessible society. This year's Canadian theme is \"Building a Strong, Accessible Canada.\"\n\n More than eight million Canadians face bar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f45970efe8adc1e875865199e2a5d4cc1257a95ea4c0d3ab219d184b5c6bee1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cdebc3886e91f2803306216aa17fd80a92c0dbb95c17908b4995c9ac3011f068"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d43f78c1cdc23a875fcd1e47","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128210,"date":"2026-06-03T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"FOPO","text":"I'll just expand on that. The department has submitted all relevant information from the requests with regard to what this study was all about. No more information that was requested and was relevant is to be submitted to the committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128210","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll just expand on that. The department has submitted all relevant information from the requests with regard to what this study was all about. No more information that was requested and was relevant is to be submitted to the committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee7047c430e208268147eefa3c2a79e93bf733af80362e0854025098e23da77d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b0c855c16648347b608c3f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086477,"date":"2026-06-08T19:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ernie Klassen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as we celebrate Pride season across Canada, we are reminded that the rights and freedoms many enjoy today should never be taken for granted. Around the world, identifying as 2SLGBTQIA+ remains illegal in 65 countries, and in 12 jurisdictions, individuals still face the death penalty simply for being who they are.\n\nI would like to recognize the work of the Canadian Pride Caucus, which is well known for its work here at home, but it is also playing an increasingly important international role. Through engagement with foreign parliamentarians, human rights defenders, diplomatic missions and civil society organizations, the caucus helps advance Canada's commitment to dignity, inclusion and protection of human rights on the global scale.\n\nI invite all colleagues from all parties to join us tomorrow at noon on Parliament Hill for the Pride flag raising. Let us come together to celebrate Pride season and reaffirm Canada's commitment to equality, inclusion and protecting human rights for all. I wish everyone a happy Pride.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086477","member_id":"bc-mp-123625","member_name":"Ernie Klassen","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as we celebrate Pride season across Canada, we are reminded that the rights and freedoms many enjoy today should never be taken for granted. Around the world, identifying as 2SLGBTQIA+ remains illegal in 65 countries, and in 12 jurisdictions, individuals still face the death penalty simply for being who they are.\n\nI would like to recognize the work of the Canadian Pride Caucus, which ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dbcbd8c6242b47af2c490ae2e63301ab6cdd54f3b5b60deee66f2e2bb7b6aa7c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e533cb2cf38de284e1fbf66197c29a55b334192dc3d96e50444fe619e4073d0c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41677f83139372a2177626a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76204,"date":"2026-01-27T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for Terrebonne for her question.\n\nOur government and the Government of Quebec have signed a Build Canada Homes agreement to accelerate housing construction and ensure that Quebec's priorities are met. What is more, under the agreement on the Canada housing infrastructure fund, nearly $1 billion will be used to modernize the infrastructure needed to develop new housing in Quebec.\n\nIt is time to live. It is time to build together.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76204","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for Terrebonne for her question.\n\nOur government and the Government of Quebec have signed a Build Canada Homes agreement to accelerate housing construction and ensure that Quebec's priorities are met. What is more, under the agreement on the Canada housing infrastructure fund, nearly $1 billion will be used to modernize the infrastructure needed to develop new housi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8bd82ee0aa9478637a693c3d6686a4c6a7891ed44bf999cc8126c73b29f0cc76"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3627a88e158448cb4dc39ddea9c8f7d9a21ad623af83da11e871a78ff44a07d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c80fc2924e6c281c08dba55e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76205,"date":"2026-01-28T19:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the good news is that our government has brought forward the first-time homebuyers' GST break, which is up to $50,000 off their first home purchase for young Canadians. This is a new measure. It was stalled in the fall session by the opposition, unfortunately.\n\nWe are ready to bring this forward. We are ready to deliver affordability for young Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76205","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the good news is that our government has brought forward the first-time homebuyers' GST break, which is up to $50,000 off their first home purchase for young Canadians. This is a new measure. It was stalled in the fall session by the opposition, unfortunately.\n\nWe are ready to bring this forward. We are ready to deliver affordability for young Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a380ce61bff47f39be33ca5b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76206,"date":"2026-01-28T19:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it starts with first-time homebuyers and not obstructing bills that will deliver relief and affordability for young Canadians. That is number one.\n\nNumber two, we have record annual construction in Calgary, in Montreal, in Edmonton and in Ottawa. We have housing starts that were solid last year, the fifth-best year in Canadian history.\n\nWe will continue to build on that work with Build Canada Homes, which we expect the opposition's support on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76206","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it starts with first-time homebuyers and not obstructing bills that will deliver relief and affordability for young Canadians. That is number one.\n\nNumber two, we have record annual construction in Calgary, in Montreal, in Edmonton and in Ottawa. We have housing starts that were solid last year, the fifth-best year in Canadian history.\n\nWe will continue to build on that work with Buil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e154e56d176a3cd3975138b418610641fc6c9a3899e073dff128b2a17fb347cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f18fee22a5768876af4ecee98a41d89a85d63b8ee87f698cc72f8bc2df0f6e22"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-92a0f39bfd1d84605e8af98a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76207,"date":"2026-01-28T19:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the good news is that we have Build Canada Homes starting up, a one-stop shop for affordable housing, delivering housing for young Canadians in particular.\n\nThe opposition can support affordable housing. It has never done it before, but it can start now. It can start helping this government deliver affordability, whether that is new homes through Build Canada Homes or bringing down rents, which we have seen drop across Canada for 30 straight months.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76207","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the good news is that we have Build Canada Homes starting up, a one-stop shop for affordable housing, delivering housing for young Canadians in particular.\n\nThe opposition can support affordable housing. It has never done it before, but it can start now. It can start helping this government deliver affordability, whether that is new homes through Build Canada Homes or bringing down re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c070de9853b3afc2c5422d761512e36350d5ca0c3444810e46bb44695ee891a7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d538cc46c32de342fa1e97e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76208,"date":"2026-01-29T16:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will say that members on this side, the young Canadians who represent their ridings here in the House, certainly speak to me about their priorities. They are here taking action to deliver for their fellow young Canadians.\n\nWe have the first-time homebuyer tax break coming through, which will deliver up to $50,000 to young Canadians for their first home purchase.\n\nWe are seeing positive trends across the country now, with rents declining over the last 12 months. That is good for young Canadians. We are delivering a groceries and essentials benefit. Young Canadians will benefit from that as well.\n\nThis side of the House is delivering for young Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76208","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will say that members on this side, the young Canadians who represent their ridings here in the House, certainly speak to me about their priorities. They are here taking action to deliver for their fellow young Canadians.\n\nWe have the first-time homebuyer tax break coming through, which will deliver up to $50,000 to young Canadians for their first home purchase.\n\nWe are seeing posit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logistics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","label":"Logistics","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b67841bd9b705409a4afc53f26ce249b92129216de0f07d9c1663296c0dfc639"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f110c592ce43769aa81c4cdd2ad990dd8de1659a65f90e9912c94e514ccadc6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ab15cde2dcd96cb9ae5476a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76209,"date":"2026-01-29T16:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, instead of slagging generations, the Conservatives should make generational investments with this side of the House.\n\nWe are focused on delivering for young Canadians. The members on the other side of the House delayed, all through the fall and into the winter, the first-time homebuyer tax break. On this side of the House, we have been pushing to do this. The Conservatives also did not vote for the first home savings account.\n\nThese are tangible efforts we are making to support young Canadians, and they are being opposed by the Conservatives.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76209","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, instead of slagging generations, the Conservatives should make generational investments with this side of the House.\n\nWe are focused on delivering for young Canadians. The members on the other side of the House delayed, all through the fall and into the winter, the first-time homebuyer tax break. On this side of the House, we have been pushing to do this. The Conservatives also did no","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2451b0558f2212d6b51a31f3b72c03d1092820030442a47329dae8be22f6c6b8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a04b1f311591eb7218884d0fc969e640bfb05724e60bff8aaea8314619231ec"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3672580f2909a3d7fa423271","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76210,"date":"2026-01-29T16:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would invite that member to speak with folks on the ground in his home province of Manitoba.\n\nWe are working with the Government of Manitoba to deliver affordable housing for young Canadians in Manitoba. These are unprecedented investments, through build Canada homes, on federal land. We are working with Canada Lands Company to make sure we are building and that we are giving jobs to young Canadians to build this country strong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76210","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would invite that member to speak with folks on the ground in his home province of Manitoba.\n\nWe are working with the Government of Manitoba to deliver affordable housing for young Canadians in Manitoba. These are unprecedented investments, through build Canada homes, on federal land. We are working with Canada Lands Company to make sure we are building and that we are giving jobs t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6dda6b81d64f1388900910d6cb382bd656eb03454e10752da0f067f6e2c6c725"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cbb668ca093c28f202316abd56c659e7bbe1f31e4992d74a9bd948b51eab1beb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2818b4c3b5afef3195b293fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86097,"date":"2026-02-02T19:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for his commitment to delivering for Canadians.\n\nIn just 100 days, Build Canada Homes has hit the ground running, delivering real—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86097","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for his commitment to delivering for Canadians.\n\nIn just 100 days, Build Canada Homes has hit the ground running, delivering real—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","label":"Construction materials","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a341c754052d36434e8e3e67f94c9c64594ae26fc942cf78e840b4acdc64a80b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dde53df34364b921ce8399af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86098,"date":"2026-02-02T19:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"First and foremost, Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank the member for his commitment to delivering for Canadians. \n\nIn just 100 days, Build Canada Homes has hit the ground running, delivering real results in dealing with Canada's housing crisis. We have signed major agreements with provinces, territories and cities. We have advanced six major federal land projects. We have lined up thousands of affordable homes, with tens of thousands more coming. Shovels will be in the ground this year. \n\nIn Nova Scotia alone, we are working with the province to deliver 1,430 homes faster, smarter and more affordably.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86098","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"First and foremost, Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank the member for his commitment to delivering for Canadians. \n\nIn just 100 days, Build Canada Homes has hit the ground running, delivering real results in dealing with Canada's housing crisis. We have signed major agreements with provinces, territories and cities. We have advanced six major federal land projects. We have lined up thousands of af","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","label":"Soil conservation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4315ff4b68f1863edb18e00745844f88ff67bb7184391217cb490f83296f2ddc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d02c477b663af48012f51138ec5fa81e4c4da888be3fd58d57b0f2669cf5e7b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3cdd5b20626f850b8298942b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86099,"date":"2026-02-02T19:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite should study the facts. The price of housing across the country is coming down. Average rents are coming down. Mortgage rates have come down.\n\nOur plan is working to deliver on affordability. We saw solid housing starts in this last year. We are focused on delivering that affordability with all types of housing across the country, in partnership with communities, provinces, territories and indigenous nations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86099","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite should study the facts. The price of housing across the country is coming down. Average rents are coming down. Mortgage rates have come down.\n\nOur plan is working to deliver on affordability. We saw solid housing starts in this last year. We are focused on delivering that affordability with all types of housing across the country, in partnership with communities, p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73a3cf40dfc10ffa26818ec0c0ad34b7656e20a10d7d57e85bcf939ec266c86b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e7ea077e61341fd81ac42d4b693049b833a025df062afa56dd4a1fe1e9f6677"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5216190cd8b7425a6ff94351","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86100,"date":"2026-02-02T19:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this government is committed to the most aggressive investment in affordable housing in Canadian history. That starts with the first-time homebuyers' tax break of $50,000. The members opposite stalled it all through last year. We are bringing that forward and delivering it for young Canadians.\n\nWe have $13 billion in this budget to deliver for Build Canada Homes, making sure we are building co-op housing and affordable rental housing, with $1 billion for supportive transitional housing to help solve the homelessness crisis.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86100","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this government is committed to the most aggressive investment in affordable housing in Canadian history. That starts with the first-time homebuyers' tax break of $50,000. The members opposite stalled it all through last year. We are bringing that forward and delivering it for young Canadians.\n\nWe have $13 billion in this budget to deliver for Build Canada Homes, making sure we are bu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aefad010edf28659f51bc578f47e9bb947388e3b749d0bec1f495633775267f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9ee929e977b8f3c9f71dcb420d48e4b149fe1250ff6aff9eabc3c109c474dad0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5209b3b6585905549fccdae1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86101,"date":"2026-02-02T20:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is puzzling to hear the Conservatives saying anything about affordable housing when they have never done anything historically to support it. We have a $13-billion Build Canada Homes agency coming through and taking action, delivering with provinces, territories and cities across the country. Last week, we announced 750 homes for Nunavut, which has the biggest housing challenge in the country. We are delivering those affordable homes this year. The Conservatives need to step up to the plate, because we are knocking it out of the park on housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86101","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is puzzling to hear the Conservatives saying anything about affordable housing when they have never done anything historically to support it. We have a $13-billion Build Canada Homes agency coming through and taking action, delivering with provinces, territories and cities across the country. Last week, we announced 750 homes for Nunavut, which has the biggest housing challenge in ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c369ac29f323cc96ded9308aeaf2296b24bb9f6fa2d9ed0a7738c6b5c56a72b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["05cd542914cc9b11c451d92cac2e779910e8c03e5fc90d7c2d22d4cf529f39d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34432c0cf9b7290cad989969","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86096,"date":"2026-02-03T20:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for her concern about the challenges for co-op housing. Co-op housing is a key priority within Build Canada Homes. We will ensure that a significant portion of the Build Canada Homes funding will be targeted for stabilizing and investing in new co-op housing.\n\nAs someone who has co-op housing in my riding, the most in B.C., I obviously want to make sure my constituents and those in the member's constituency and in co-ops across the country feel the strong support of the government. We are focused on delivering for co-ops.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86096","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for her concern about the challenges for co-op housing. Co-op housing is a key priority within Build Canada Homes. We will ensure that a significant portion of the Build Canada Homes funding will be targeted for stabilizing and investing in new co-op housing.\n\nAs someone who has co-op housing in my riding, the most in B.C., I obviously want to make sure my constitue","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d94d1e226998a6f33498fa15f90c436bbd0487db3a343a35a79edf0877625a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1eb404c311abac47b8f9c9a49914e9a40a15d980c97096c5e106a2afc14b725a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3919529532263701cc0bb1e","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":316482,"date":"2026-02-05T10:03:01+00:00","title":"An Act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"An Act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-20","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-20","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316482","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"An Act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bf94c1843315bc8565093b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86090,"date":"2026-02-05T15:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-20, An Act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86090","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-20, An Act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f790559af2072714a03e43d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86091,"date":"2026-02-05T19:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a good day to be asking that question.\n\nWe introduced the build Canada homes act this morning, precisely to make sure that young Canadians have access to affordable housing going forward. We have dedicated $13 billion in the budget. We need the support of members of the House to pass that budget to invest in young Canadians. We do not need obstruction on the build Canada homes act, which would make sure we have a lean-meat agency to deliver that funding to young Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86091","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a good day to be asking that question.\n\nWe introduced the build Canada homes act this morning, precisely to make sure that young Canadians have access to affordable housing going forward. We have dedicated $13 billion in the budget. We need the support of members of the House to pass that budget to invest in young Canadians. We do not need obstruction on the build Canada homes a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f7c0cfefbcb10fdd4fa5002335f73128469f8162a536b1d77704ffc8183176e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1e40a3ad729d6da1e7e1f4341b65186050902141cff2be347b99475dbb85a0cc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-493748552c1e3f478f227316","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86092,"date":"2026-02-05T19:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am concerned that the member opposite does not care about renters. In my city, half the population rents housing, and we certainly do not discriminate against people who choose to buy or those who choose to rent. Many Canadians do not have a choice; that is why we have to make affordable housing options possible for all Canadians to make sure they have a safe home.\n\n We do not need any delays in the House to the budget or to the build Canada homes act. We need to deliver affordable housing for Canadians. I hope the member will support us with our bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86092","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am concerned that the member opposite does not care about renters. In my city, half the population rents housing, and we certainly do not discriminate against people who choose to buy or those who choose to rent. Many Canadians do not have a choice; that is why we have to make affordable housing options possible for all Canadians to make sure they have a safe home.\n\n We do not need ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["016350bc591d78912712f55f7d35188b4a7cfbc409ea45d6b8aecb0b30c6c7d2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eb8f8bdd5a216530b229fc6ca24c7e3d0a0a7f44f164beaadc979c6d5c5c0e24"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa316c6b702b10454d3fe520","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86093,"date":"2026-02-05T19:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is critical that we build housing in the GTA that is affordable. We want to get the industry back building affordable housing for Canadians, certainly in the GTA but also across the country. We are seeing good housing starts in many cities across the country, but we are just getting started with affordability.\n\nWe need to deliver, with members around the House, on the build Canada homes act, with no obstruction. Let us get to building.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86093","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is critical that we build housing in the GTA that is affordable. We want to get the industry back building affordable housing for Canadians, certainly in the GTA but also across the country. We are seeing good housing starts in many cities across the country, but we are just getting started with affordability.\n\nWe need to deliver, with members around the House, on the build Canada ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b0b3a5c73e46c62fcefd38feed18e9e543cac2efc185bb9602c03381b1cff0ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b169a11bc06193fa6fa866e58325114dd0d1c649b9212f663319cc2f37b54b34"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-74732cb3ae2326d743f40a46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86094,"date":"2026-02-05T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for the question and her great work.\n\nWe have got right to work with Build Canada Homes. Since the launch, we have been signing major partnerships with provinces and cities. We have six major development sites on federal lands. We are delivering over 7,500 homes, with tens of thousands more in the pipeline right now, with the Build Canada Homes act that was introduced this morning, which we expect the support of this House on.\n\nWe are establishing a lean, efficient agency that is 100% focused on delivering affordable housing for Canadians. We ask for the support of all members in the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86094","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for the question and her great work.\n\nWe have got right to work with Build Canada Homes. Since the launch, we have been signing major partnerships with provinces and cities. We have six major development sites on federal lands. We are delivering over 7,500 homes, with tens of thousands more in the pipeline right now, with the Build Canada Homes act that was introduc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1975b23256f2bcf547d12e35ba95b4a40a3ad5ad50bcc0c9fa9d9dc2bf4aa5a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c1e37bea4a8068bc2a951136e6bd553fd3f5aa02d2b4f6bd798e3121c23f8e7c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-700cc1123f48e63a8cf38c7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86095,"date":"2026-02-05T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am very excited to share that the Government of Canada, the Government of Nunavut and Nunavut Tunngavik Incorporated reached an agreement to deliver up to 750 homes in the territory. Build Canada Homes will lead this work using innovative factory-built components to get homes ready faster.\n\nWe are prioritizing Canadian materials. We are supporting Inuit-owned businesses and creating lots of job and training opportunities. This partnership will make a real difference on the ground. \n\nI thank the member for her leadership in helping to bring more homes to Nunavut, much-needed affordable homes. I encourage all—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86095","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am very excited to share that the Government of Canada, the Government of Nunavut and Nunavut Tunngavik Incorporated reached an agreement to deliver up to 750 homes in the territory. Build Canada Homes will lead this work using innovative factory-built components to get homes ready faster.\n\nWe are prioritizing Canadian materials. We are supporting Inuit-owned businesses and creating","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","label":"Indigenous businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","label":"Indigenous businesses","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3bd8fe23c36cdab2f10c90686c3f0ee04f9ae6eede68521261d8efbd3b8f8004"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aed3a56d5017bf1c84ddf8fdbfbc8242860d34f3f82241dfd46c7b0b978bc538"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96eef2c99d1b19d23531f195","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299630,"date":"2026-02-09T19:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have a plan to attack affordability across this country; it starts with housing, but it certainly extends to tax breaks, as we saw in recent weeks with respect to groceries. There was also a tax break for 22 million Canadians last year.\n\nWe are delivering on affordability. We are focused on a first-time homebuyers' tax break of up to $50,000 and on building affordable homes for young Canadians at an unprecedented scale.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299630","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have a plan to attack affordability across this country; it starts with housing, but it certainly extends to tax breaks, as we saw in recent weeks with respect to groceries. There was also a tax break for 22 million Canadians last year.\n\nWe are delivering on affordability. We are focused on a first-time homebuyers' tax break of up to $50,000 and on building affordable homes for you","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["57bc2e9f9f1c5ddfe6e8f77e99a9538ab71afb5123214240da0b371de68d97f8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["51b8371e23d6064bab510e4fd5a1a3398d7deaca92017607d0c784c44b96991d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-422e93d238684e2077177ffc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299631,"date":"2026-02-09T19:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for his question.\n\nThe Quebec tramway has an investment of $1.44 billion from the federal government, and we continue to invest significantly in public transit across the country through the Canada public transit fund, as well as the build communities strong fund, where there is tens of billions of dollars available to allocate towards transit if the House supports the budget. Quebec, other provinces and cities will have access to the build communities strong fund with the support of the House to fund major transit projects.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299631","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for his question.\n\nThe Quebec tramway has an investment of $1.44 billion from the federal government, and we continue to invest significantly in public transit across the country through the Canada public transit fund, as well as the build communities strong fund, where there is tens of billions of dollars available to allocate towards transit if the House supports ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ded7e6e38ba61637b7bb37dbbe2958dec303b8070a28e53a04cc60ab0450b530"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f36fdee88dff93f4953e12ae3cd48f4a3e2af100e7c72d0e54f6f3005ffa9f06"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9949e4d4ab143f1e1860e78","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316463,"date":"2026-02-23T17:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that Bill C-20, An Act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes, be read the second time and referred to a committee.\n\n He said: Madam Speaker, the Build Canada Homes act would establish Canada as an affordable housing builder. The Build Canada Homes act is landmark legislation that would establish Build Canada Homes as a Crown corporation with a mandate to deliver affordable housing at scale. The work Build Canada Homes would do is essential to the federal government's ability to build the affordable homes Canadians need and would initiate a new phase of transformative growth in Canada's economy. \n\nThe legislation would provide Build Canada Homes with operational independence and flexibility. As a Crown corporation, Build Canada Homes would have the powers, functions and new tools it needs to deliver on its mandate. Equipped with these new tools, it would be able to act nimbly as a developer, financier, convenor and innovation driver in the housing sector. As I said, with this legislation Build Canada Homes would become a Crown corporation focused on building affordable housing in communities right across the country. This is important, essential and meaningful work, and it would tackle something even bigger than just the crisis that is facing our housing sector, because investing in building the affordable housing that Canada needs would in turn help grow our country's economy and strengthen our industries.\n\n We know that housing is not simply about having a roof over one's head. The stability that a home provides builds the foundation for mental and physical health, for community involvement and for personal success. Everyone in Canada deserves a safe home, a place where stability takes root so opportunity can blossom.\n\nI will put the housing crisis in context.\n\nEven though some progress has been made, many Canadians still struggle to find affordable housing. The pandemic complicated things by disrupting the supply chain, and tensions with the United States have added further challenges.\n\nThis pressure is being felt across the country, in big cities and small communities alike. Canadians are experiencing rising prices, a lack of supply, and greater inequality. That is why our new government is working to make housing more affordable, to offer more options and to help every Canadian have a place to call home. \n\nBudget 2025 includes generational investments of $25 billion over five years for housing. This strategic investment will build homes and create lasting prosperity, empowering Canadians to get ahead.\n\n Solving Canada's housing crisis requires immediate action to build homes that meet Canadians' needs: homes they can afford, built as soon as possible. That is why, in September 2025, our government launched Build Canada Homes as a special operating agency within the Department of Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada, with an initial investment of $13 billion. Build Canada Homes is part of a broader set of measures by our government to accelerate housing construction, restore housing affordability and reduce homelessness.\n\nAs a lean, purpose-built entity, Build Canada Homes would leverage public lands, deploy flexible financial tools and promote modern methods of construction, like factory-built housing components. These new approaches would allow us to accelerate construction timelines, improve productivity and support a more productive homebuilding sector.\n\n Build Canada Homes would fund multi-year agreements, providing increased certainty for housing providers, builders and manufacturers. In the immediate term, Build Canada Homes is prioritizing shovel-ready projects. Over time, Build Canada Homes would shift to funding large-scale, portfolio-based projects, delivering measurable impacts to Canada's supply of affordable housing, which brings us here today.\n\nThis legislation would provide Build Canada Homes with the tools and authorities of a Crown corporation to deploy capital at scale, partner in greater capacity and make investments in new and more productive approaches to housing construction. This is how we would expedite the delivery of more affordable homes on public lands and in communities across Canada. \n\nAs a special operating agency, Build Canada Homes has already launched the initial phase of work to build thousands of homes on federal lands in six communities across Canada, and we are getting shovels in the ground this year on those projects. In Ottawa, we would build approximately 1,100 homes just 20 minutes from the downtown core. We would deploy the same rapid approach across the country, in Dartmouth, Edmonton, Longueuil, Toronto and Winnipeg, to get homes built for Canadians as quickly as possible on these lands.\n\nThe bill authorizes the transfer of just over $1.5 billion from the Canada Lands Company to Build Canada Homes, once the agency is established, to ensure that this capital is ready to unlock construction on these sites. This is just the beginning. The Build Canada Homes act represents a major step forward in strengthening the federal government's ability to respond to Canada's housing crisis.\n\nThis legislation makes it clear that Build Canada Homes would be Canada's affordable housing builder going forward. As such, as a Crown corporation, Build Canada Homes' mandate would be to build affordable housing across Canada while modernizing the homebuilding sector.\n\nBy focusing on modern construction methods like prefabricated housing and the use of lumber, Build Canada Homes will stimulate a homebuilding industry that is more innovative, resilient and productive. Off-site construction will extend the construction season year-round, creating a steady supply of factory-produced housing components and quality year-round jobs. Over time, this will speed up project delivery, reduce costs and improve sustainability.\n\nWith manufactured panels and prefabricated components produced off-site, construction teams can work faster while minimizing waste, noise and required labour.\n\nWith the trade tensions hitting our industries such as steel and softwood, we have to be our own best customer. Mass timber, as an example, has tremendous potential for supporting greater densification. Mass-timber designs, especially those incorporating prefabrication and modular components, can accelerate the construction of multi-unit residential structures. The wood construction also provides natural insulation that reduces heat loss, increasing energy efficiency.\n\n The carbon capture by mass timber can also be significant, especially in taller wood buildings. When used as a substitute for or complement to concrete and steel, mass timber delivers significant climate benefits, cutting embodied emissions in buildings by as much as 25%.\n\nCanada has the third-most extensive forested area on earth. If we manage our forests sustainably, our country has a significant supply of timber available to meet the growing demand for building with wood and mass timber. Greater demand can strengthen Canada's softwood lumber industry while helping to reduce reliance on our southern neighbour and reducing the climate pollution caused by the embodied carbon and building materials.\n\n I want to talk about core partnerships next. Build Canada Homes has already formed key partnerships with provinces, territories, indigenous partners and local governments. Notably, we are forging commitments to ensure that supportive and transitional housing is matched with the wraparound services residents need.\n\nFor example, these partnerships would support the creation of 30 supportive and transitional homes announced in Nova Scotia and 54 at Dunn House phase 2 in the member for Taiaiako'n—Parkdale—High Park's riding in Toronto, with further negotiations under way to ensure critical services to the most vulnerable Canadians. Just last week, we announced a partnership with the B.C. government in Victoria to build 700 supportive and transitional homes, setting a new bar for the scale of the supportive and transitional homes that are needed to tackle homelessness.\n\nBuild Canada Homes is also committed to building indigenous partnerships that further self-determination and contribute meaningfully to meeting the needs of indigenous communities. Through Build Canada Homes, the governments of Canada, Nunavut and Nunavut Tunngavik Incorporated reached an agreement in principle to support the development of 750 homes for non-market housing in Nunavut. These homes will be designed and delivered in collaboration with Inuit, for Inuit.\n\n The Build Canada Homes act would establish a Crown corporation with a legislative mandate to engage with partners and deliver on projects that meet the needs of the communities they serve. As with Inuit, we look forward to strong partnerships with first nations and with Métis as well. The act would unlock the tools for Build Canada Homes to forge these new strategic relationships that would drive coordinated action and establish modern development models that could scale affordable housing like never before. This is how we move from the incremental progress we have seen in recent years to transformative progress.\n\n By changing how Canada builds, Build Canada Homes would be delivering speed, scale and innovation. Communities across Canada are ready to work with us. Since releasing our investment policy framework and launching our national submission portal in late November, we have seen very strong interest nationwide. Proposals have come in from every province and territory. Many are under review, and hundreds more are in progress right now, building a robust pipeline of projects ready to break ground this year. These partnerships are central to Build Canada Homes' strategy to grow community housing and ensure long-term affordability. We will do this while growing our economy and making it more resilient and stronger.\n\n Build Canada Homes would implement the Government of Canada's buy Canadian policy by prioritizing projects that use Canadian materials, strengthen our domestic supply chains and create good jobs. From softwood lumber in B.C. and New Brunswick to steel in Ontario and aluminum in Quebec, homebuilding connects Canadian materials to Canadian jobs. This is exactly why the government's approach to buy Canadian is exactly what it is about: becoming our own best customer.\n\nIt is also about shockproofing our economy. Buying and building domestically strengthens Canadian industries, supports Canadian workers and creates a stronger and more dynamic economy. The buy Canadian policy announced in December 2025 fundamentally changes how the federal government purchases goods and services. It prioritizes Canadian suppliers and requires the use of Canadian-produced steel, aluminum and wood in large federal projects so the dollars we invest drive demand here at home, strengthen our supply chains and support our workers and communities. That is how we move from reliance to resilience in a world where trade uncertainty is real.\n\nThis bill is about more than just building more housing. It focuses on something even more important. It is a key element of how we are retooling Canada's economy. When we invest in Canada, we are not just creating jobs. We are also strengthening domestic supply chains, reducing our dependence on foreign markets and ensuring that Canada remains competitive in a global economy where instability in international trade has become the new normal.\n\n For workers, this would mean increasing economic security and opportunity. For businesses, it would mean demand and predictability. For our country, it would be another step in a nation-building strategy that invests in Canadian industries and communities. We are prioritizing Canadian content in major procurements, building with Canadian materials and partnering across the country to strengthen our supply chains and keep people working.\n\nBuild Canada Homes would finance and build housing, which would drive demand for Canadian lumber and steel, encourage innovation in the construction sector and make investments that directly support Canadian workers and businesses. It is a model for how we build homes, infrastructure and prosperity using Canadian materials, creating jobs today and laying down the foundation for long-term economic growth.\n\nAs for measurable results, since its launch, Build Canada Homes has moved quickly to get housing projects off the ground. I identified public lands that are being converted into housing right now. We have partnered with local governments to cut red tape, waive fees and fast-track approvals as well. This means up to 3,000 new homes right here in Ottawa and up to 1,430 homes in Nova Scotia, and recently we signed a partnership with Quebec to accelerate approvals and identify even more housing projects in the province. In total, nine Build Canada Homes deals are now in place and are expected to deliver nearly 9,000 new homes. There are many more projects coming in the months ahead. With private, public and government partners all showing up, we are ready to build.\n\nThere is lots more work to do, but the progress we have seen in just a few short months gives me confidence that we are moving in the right direction. Build Canada Homes has already demonstrated what is possible when we combine speed, innovation and collaboration to get homes built for Canadians. With the passage of the Build Canada Homes act, we would have the flexibility, autonomy and accountability we need to deliver more affordable homes. We would have the tools and authorities of a Crown corporation to scale our progress even further, move faster, partner more effectively and deliver more affordable homes on federal lands and in communities across the country. This is a pivotal step that would transform our early momentum into long-term capacity.\n\nThat is exactly what the Build Canada Homes act is designed to deliver. The act is a major milestone in the government's plan to build more homes faster and help ensure that every Canadian has an affordable place to live. It is about building more homes now, but it is also about reshaping the future for Canadians, making sure the next generation can make choices about the communities they want to live in. It is about giving families stability and supporting Canadian manufacturers and supply chains to grow Canada's economy strong. It is about creating new careers and giving communities the tools to grow sustainably.\n\nIn conclusion, with this legislation, we are marking a new chapter in Canada's history. We are transforming the housing system with intent. We are building the right partnerships and innovative financing models by design. We are shaping Canada's future to create communities that are stronger, fairer and leave no one behind. Much like the Major Projects Office, Build Canada Homes would enable nation-building housing projects that would help make our country's economy the fastest-growing in the G7. We are investing in Canadian workers, Canadian jobs and Canadian industries.\n\nThe Build Canada Homes act is a milestone step that would strengthen Canada's self-reliance and resilience. It would empower Canadians with more opportunities to get ahead and build the life they want, where they want, in a home they can afford.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316463","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"moved that Bill C-20, An Act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes, be read the second time and referred to a committee.\n\n He said: Madam Speaker, the Build Canada Homes act would establish Canada as an affordable housing builder. The Build Canada Homes act is landmark legislation that would establish Build Canada Homes as a Crown corporation with a mandate to deliver affordable housi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["547a0efd68a1736a16faa7492f5c1891ca6084d58c5c7033f4ae9d6bf4cae3d1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28e46738b6152fc923295b3c7ad879ade1aee16fc136154c76bddc5c39dcc3e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e7c7fdc34b152ffecaf8c3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316464,"date":"2026-02-23T17:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member for his concerns. First and foremost, to speak to the challenge that young Canadians face with housing, that is clearly a focus of Build Canada Homes: to ensure we are building affordable homes for the next generation. Many of us who sit in the House have children or grandchildren and have great concerns about the escalation of homebuilding costs and the price of housing across Canada.\n\n We have seen the focus of the investments over the last few years into housing and affordable housing starting to bear fruit as the market pressures are easing. We have seen prices come down for several quarters in a row. We have seen rents come down. That does not mean we slow down. In fact, it means we need to step up efforts. The Build Canada Homes act is all about stepping up those efforts to build more affordable housing and to make sure housing is suitable for the next generation, including student housing and housing for young people who are looking for their first homes. It is complementary to the tax break for first-time homebuyers that the House is bringing forward.\n\nWe need to have a number of tools. Build Canada Homes is streamlining the process of moving affordable housing forward for Canada with a lean and nimble agency that will deliver that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316464","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member for his concerns. First and foremost, to speak to the challenge that young Canadians face with housing, that is clearly a focus of Build Canada Homes: to ensure we are building affordable homes for the next generation. Many of us who sit in the House have children or grandchildren and have great concerns about the escalation of homebuilding costs and the price of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f6fa7467f44f119008d68bdc332067db69ec3d1d8402698fd47534133961260d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9368d40c4ed9f586721ae85daf6a6de00ce14da1402a0cba0f3654505f736ed2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47e8cdff9f1d6d441503b527","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316465,"date":"2026-02-23T17:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member for her concern for those most vulnerable. The importance of supportive and transitional housing cannot be understated. It is a best practice, as part of a housing-first initiative, to make sure that people who are at risk of homelessness or are currently homeless have an opportunity to get into housing that has wraparound health and social supports so they can find stability in their lives and then transition to other housing opportunities successfully. \n\nWe have seen great examples of this. I mentioned that Dunn House, in the member for Taiaiako'n—Parkdale—High Park's riding, is really a social medicine example that is proving to save taxpayer dollars. We had people who were spending a lot of time in hospitals and emergency rooms or in jail within the justice system. The cost of all that has been reduced. Those people are rebuilding their lives with great success. We have seen that success in B.C. with the supportive housing I was involved with when I was the mayor of Vancouver.\n\n It is a best practice. We have a billion dollars dedicated toward that. We are looking for the operating funding from the provinces and territories to go forward and build thousands of supportive transitional homes. We will need that support from the leadership at the provincial level in particular. We have had early examples of that in Nova Scotia, Ontario and B.C. We need to scale that up. It is a big part of our work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316465","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member for her concern for those most vulnerable. The importance of supportive and transitional housing cannot be understated. It is a best practice, as part of a housing-first initiative, to make sure that people who are at risk of homelessness or are currently homeless have an opportunity to get into housing that has wraparound health and social supports so they can fi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["86a6d1c1b1ad03810f5cbe0c953e24251b1351d74e9297e6e5e79354290738a0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9f2a303007d63075d757df4629c5c1c73faf6997950ba2a89a63493510037e3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30d4038b40f4e5d750e2c13f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316466,"date":"2026-02-23T17:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I spoke briefly to the impact we have already had in terms of reducing approval times, red tape and the costs related to both of those with the City of Ottawa. We have an agreement in place with the City of Ottawa to build about 3,000 homes. The homes will be expedited through the city's system and that is a good example of how Build Canada Homes, by bringing new tools to the table, which this act would enable, has the opportunity to leverage that acceleration with city governments, which are responsible for those approvals and for reducing those costs.\n\nThere will be other approaches with infrastructure investments that reduce development cost charges, which we will be bringing forward in the weeks and months ahead. With Build Canada Homes in particular, we have that leverage point. What will be really critical for us going forward is also having the tools to crank up the supply of more affordable housing. We can invest, at Build Canada Homes, in affordable housing projects that leverage a range of deeper affordability right to the middle market, like housing for young people that is lower rent. There are opportunities for attainable home ownership as well.\n\nWe look forward, at Build Canada Homes, to being able to focus on scaling those opportunities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316466","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I spoke briefly to the impact we have already had in terms of reducing approval times, red tape and the costs related to both of those with the City of Ottawa. We have an agreement in place with the City of Ottawa to build about 3,000 homes. The homes will be expedited through the city's system and that is a good example of how Build Canada Homes, by bringing new tools to the table,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1b83eebaf93a828fc33bf2cc8f903dc147e7d93d508e2810591a6bdac8e03610"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["783d000a3e86a4fbdadb2d91dfa9e836c555bf171a0067c256c55b627f4f1996"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8fcaa710191c13dfd49c4206","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316467,"date":"2026-02-23T17:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to thank the member for her question.\n\nWe are focused on communities of all shapes and sizes. That is part of Build Canada Homes. The act would enable this new, lean, efficient agency to deliver both large-scale projects with larger communities and cities, and smaller projects in smaller and rural communities. We anticipate it being a measure of the impact within the community. In a small community, a small project would have a significant impact. We need to be able to fund and advance those projects in all sizes of communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316467","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to thank the member for her question.\n\nWe are focused on communities of all shapes and sizes. That is part of Build Canada Homes. The act would enable this new, lean, efficient agency to deliver both large-scale projects with larger communities and cities, and smaller projects in smaller and rural communities. We anticipate it being a measure of the impact within the communit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0bab6524e2dd6f0c639c5434235d8d5414b65aa0301d131fcd52ec6aee2eacb2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-073615a65d62206124c86d17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316468,"date":"2026-02-23T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have very exciting news in B.C. The Build Canada Homes partnership is set to deliver 1,100 new affordable homes. Many of these priority projects are set to break ground this year, including 700 supportive and transitional homes for people who need them the most.\n\nI hope that the members opposite will support the Build Canada Homes legislation rather than obstructing and preventing Canadians from getting access to affordable housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316468","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have very exciting news in B.C. The Build Canada Homes partnership is set to deliver 1,100 new affordable homes. Many of these priority projects are set to break ground this year, including 700 supportive and transitional homes for people who need them the most.\n\nI hope that the members opposite will support the Build Canada Homes legislation rather than obstructing and preventing ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d95d2356fbeba117275bee3eff585b8389a8d18531538046c73c17aaf26e46e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["867cdb5fc0406e23bf19f2546bb0952cf4b8109a2d7e8c2c3fb2584ea031e4e5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2a7674efdc6e37fcd983c72","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310842,"date":"2026-02-24T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the government is focused on making housing more affordable across the board, starting with our first-time homebuyers getting a tax break. Build Canada Homes has almost 9,000 homes now in development in cities across the country. Supportive housing was announced last week in B.C., with 700 homes for those who are at risk of homelessness. \n\nWe are delivering. We need support from the opposition on the Build Canada Homes act to go further.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310842","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the government is focused on making housing more affordable across the board, starting with our first-time homebuyers getting a tax break. Build Canada Homes has almost 9,000 homes now in development in cities across the country. Supportive housing was announced last week in B.C., with 700 homes for those who are at risk of homelessness. \n\nWe are delivering. We need support from the o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da2522b4d3c97283897f0fa3a2620bef55ebf4786642a941144d0e05872482c5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7b8482a0c0038c51ba9239a7f0338b153698ec1dd9c5f23de8dcc5e82793a1e7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1728e3b7bf6e29b5e5b07a80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":311355,"date":"2026-02-24T20:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is what Build Canada Homes is all about. We have a plan to deliver. We are delivering, and the experts are weighing in on this. The Canadian Housing and Renewal Association said it clearly: Build Canada Homes is \"an important step toward addressing the housing crisis—building homes at speed and scale, ensuring affordability, and listening to the community housing sector.\" We have an opportunity to deliver for Canadians. The whole House should stand in unison to support the Build Canada Homes act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:311355","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is what Build Canada Homes is all about. We have a plan to deliver. We are delivering, and the experts are weighing in on this. The Canadian Housing and Renewal Association said it clearly: Build Canada Homes is \"an important step toward addressing the housing crisis—building homes at speed and scale, ensuring affordability, and listening to the community housing sector.\" We have","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["97638b65cf61918a4b1684989d3e21f6e428a3f06495caa1156c0e130b744f8f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea57c6bb6cc386a6dea3f50b1d4236c74c34d0508ad69f5471fe9f408e1ceb2d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9940947a3836db5381ba926","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310838,"date":"2026-02-25T19:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the good news is that we have the build communities strong fund, which includes public transit. This is a $51-billion infrastructure fund that the House has the opportunity to support in the budget implementation act. It is $51 billion, and a significant percentage of that applies to public transit. \n\nWe are in talks with the Government of Quebec to pursue the opportunity for public transit investment. We hope to conclude those negotiations and be able to make ongoing investments in public transit across Quebec, as we have across the country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310838","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the good news is that we have the build communities strong fund, which includes public transit. This is a $51-billion infrastructure fund that the House has the opportunity to support in the budget implementation act. It is $51 billion, and a significant percentage of that applies to public transit. \n\nWe are in talks with the Government of Quebec to pursue the opportunity for public t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["af35ca1824d043f9b86a796b93a90609f69152e1797f4fe002d3f6c00fa26019"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a77a4751e6c1cea4c5c7bad439c8ba84e6a185cb88c10c0b9aa7d32fa0422c03"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc51a13b7df56ee24465a1e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310839,"date":"2026-02-25T19:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are ready to pursue public transit investment with the Government of Quebec. We are at the table. We are negotiating. We welcome the opportunity to invest. There are significant dollars available in the build communities strong fund. When the BIA is passed, we will be able to move that funding through, on top of the $25 billion that is available in the Canada public transit fund. Add all that up and there is a significant increase to the public transit funding that is available, and there is more flexibility for provinces and territories and cities to pursue.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310839","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are ready to pursue public transit investment with the Government of Quebec. We are at the table. We are negotiating. We welcome the opportunity to invest. There are significant dollars available in the build communities strong fund. When the BIA is passed, we will be able to move that funding through, on top of the $25 billion that is available in the Canada public transit fund. A","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["774b1a3370966f95d558fed92d918ec3fbd7a6e27afa6117894d01ddae9996db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58e364e70f21f142a350323eeb45eba0da36b079c275dcedefeddbba74c5f95e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3be8b85e5cdca86c043cb67","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310840,"date":"2026-02-25T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the good news is that there is a tax break coming for first-time homebuyers. I thank members of the House for standing up for our young people. We are now seeing prices starting to come down, rents coming down and home prices coming down. We see that in the new CMHC housing affordability index report that came out this morning.\n\n The trend is in the right direction, but we have to double down. We have to focus on delivering Build Canada Homes' $13 billion for affordable housing. We have to make sure that the entire House is committed to bringing down the price of housing for young Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310840","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the good news is that there is a tax break coming for first-time homebuyers. I thank members of the House for standing up for our young people. We are now seeing prices starting to come down, rents coming down and home prices coming down. We see that in the new CMHC housing affordability index report that came out this morning.\n\n The trend is in the right direction, but we have to dou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dee74938f66f0b434810bd9742129176027352081ca2e2057c02267fdd6857d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0028eacf7a62bd22e8cc1155a93ce8105296f966aee901b2e8529a0b79eb9620"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c77edcdef9944eebefe93af5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":310841,"date":"2026-02-25T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our next steps are critical. The next step that the member can take is supporting the Build Canada Homes act to make sure that the government has every tool available to invest in affordable housing. We have $13 billion labelled for non-market housing. That will leverage tens of thousands of units of affordable housing, from rental to affordable home ownership. \n\nWe need everybody on board with this. This is not a time to take potshots and not a time to fall back on the failed record of the Conservatives on housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:310841","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our next steps are critical. The next step that the member can take is supporting the Build Canada Homes act to make sure that the government has every tool available to invest in affordable housing. We have $13 billion labelled for non-market housing. That will leverage tens of thousands of units of affordable housing, from rental to affordable home ownership. \n\nWe need everybody on ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["049496a70b72d594a1bcbb9d5000572b8b0ef4fbfd7c9297bae22a0a8d277d2f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f551e509a085f8d043e71350ca63bbc6a82b0aa811cebea090909dfdb0e82ed3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d74415cc11b675d25d34db66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350220,"date":"2026-03-10T20:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the project is about clean energy. It is about local jobs and economic growth. It was approved through the independent process at the Canada Infrastructure Bank, led by non-partisan officials.\n\nEven the Progressive Conservative government of Nova Scotia is backing the project and supporting it, and it is easy to see why. It is creating clean energy. It is creating good jobs for Nova Scotians and strengthening the local community. It is a great project.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350220","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the project is about clean energy. It is about local jobs and economic growth. It was approved through the independent process at the Canada Infrastructure Bank, led by non-partisan officials.\n\nEven the Progressive Conservative government of Nova Scotia is backing the project and supporting it, and it is easy to see why. It is creating clean energy. It is creating good jobs for Nova S","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bcd1938ff12406a9b2392eb6fff039904e671b1b30ce378144feb39732620003"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a2cb8cc44571311c6ac80f94c662dbc82eaaf134f4a944f4f7b2dfca56cc0b9d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cc2104ec5ed20e8bf967140","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350221,"date":"2026-03-10T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Nova Scotians need action, and they need clean energy, not political games from the Conservatives here. They have the support of the Progressive Conservative government in Nova Scotia to advance this project and fund it. Officials at the Infrastructure Bank have supported the project. These are good jobs, energy reliability and choice for Nova Scotians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350221","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Nova Scotians need action, and they need clean energy, not political games from the Conservatives here. They have the support of the Progressive Conservative government in Nova Scotia to advance this project and fund it. Officials at the Infrastructure Bank have supported the project. These are good jobs, energy reliability and choice for Nova Scotians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["160f8d357e97fb4820f1725cefda972366944af53f7b54fa6155173f8c620e68"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77b02630492afbbd7e011182","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350219,"date":"2026-03-11T20:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Drummondville project is an important milestone in affordable housing for seniors, with 100 units now open. This new building reflects our efforts to make housing more accessible. It represents tangible progress in meeting the needs of the region's seniors.\n\nI encourage my colleagues to support the Build Canada Homes legislation so that we have more tools.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350219","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Drummondville project is an important milestone in affordable housing for seniors, with 100 units now open. This new building reflects our efforts to make housing more accessible. It represents tangible progress in meeting the needs of the region's seniors.\n\nI encourage my colleagues to support the Build Canada Homes legislation so that we have more tools.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b10fd4764ae040e1c90c20add878e3ec043b45131391fdd0d02c3c2e5b11809d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0804489b3f6eff382bc0bd266a72f954ce2bad1711ce6015678c5d4b2f27f955"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4bf42bddb7b2daa5f607a246","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350215,"date":"2026-03-12T19:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have some good news in that CMHC report, which shows that average rents across the country are coming down. We are making progress. We are seeing the price of housing come down as well, and mortgage rates are also down, so we are seeing trends in the right direction that achieve affordability, which every member of the House seems to want to deliver on. We could deliver even more for Canadians by passing the Build Canada Homes act in the House and getting $13 billion to set up Canada's affordable housing agency permanently.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350215","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have some good news in that CMHC report, which shows that average rents across the country are coming down. We are making progress. We are seeing the price of housing come down as well, and mortgage rates are also down, so we are seeing trends in the right direction that achieve affordability, which every member of the House seems to want to deliver on. We could deliver even more f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["652669684fe4505ec1a4bdefcb97438634ade5a70322d9ccad04de675c1f8bbb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["27fee4bdc59b16b045e7c7557ac8e28f3e83b0687a325c0da7cb4386f06dc77b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3be91df4190b739f4c0c610e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350216,"date":"2026-03-12T19:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for pointing that out, because we are cutting taxes for first-time homebuyers by up to $50,000, for young Canadians to be able to buy their first home. We are reducing the amount of red tape across the country. The housing accelerator fund is delivering for 241 cities across the country. We are seeing permitting and approvals move faster. We are delivering infrastructure investments to bring down development charges so fees for homebuilding go down. We are delivering on all these points. We need to take it to the next level with the members opposite.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350216","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for pointing that out, because we are cutting taxes for first-time homebuyers by up to $50,000, for young Canadians to be able to buy their first home. We are reducing the amount of red tape across the country. The housing accelerator fund is delivering for 241 cities across the country. We are seeing permitting and approvals move faster. We are delivering infrastru","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["95d4f926055600498d53f00b38f33d9883905262b0407ffc291f3d948c3f506a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["809eea628c316a14fb5fb4c6d349c52b179a7550c758b7436f9cab22e144cbde"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7fee3ce1daea4ea7db93e91","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350217,"date":"2026-03-12T19:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is no surprise that Canadians are challenged with buying a home right now, when there is a war in the Middle East. There is no surprise.\n\n In the first 100 days of Build Canada Homes, we have secured agreements with Nova Scotia, with B.C and with Nunavut. We are delivering thousands of homes. We are up to 9,000 homes that are being delivered through Build Canada Homes for Canadians, and we are just getting started. If we pass the Build Canada Homes act in the House in the days ahead, we can supercharge the construction of affordable housing, and that is what Canadians need.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350217","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is no surprise that Canadians are challenged with buying a home right now, when there is a war in the Middle East. There is no surprise.\n\n In the first 100 days of Build Canada Homes, we have secured agreements with Nova Scotia, with B.C and with Nunavut. We are delivering thousands of homes. We are up to 9,000 homes that are being delivered through Build Canada Homes for Canadians","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8611d5c6c8d0fc4dc29833993a7063b0dd967c1464ff63b21668c6403d62cf48"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f41cff1b649ec3d437351e099023bc658842d633b27629f79f779ee4487bafd3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e47ea5bcbc46a78f08bdeaca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":350218,"date":"2026-03-12T19:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the good news is that we had a very strong year last year for housing starts across Canada, one of the best in our history. Almost 260,000 homes were started. We need to keep that continuing. Sales are challenged right now. The economy is challenged.\n\nThis side of the House is focused on delivering for Canada on affordability, boosting our economy, creating jobs and cutting the costs and the challenges Canadians have. That starts first and foremost with our housing. We are going to deliver that with Build Canada Homes. I invite the members opposite to support the act moving forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:350218","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the good news is that we had a very strong year last year for housing starts across Canada, one of the best in our history. Almost 260,000 homes were started. We need to keep that continuing. Sales are challenged right now. The economy is challenged.\n\nThis side of the House is focused on delivering for Canada on affordability, boosting our economy, creating jobs and cutting the costs ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dadf1ee17b0df16634418327e79e16d435a86c982837a687542f31d2537ec3e5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e3ff514bef8c3527bbbe2cddc57da471aaf00ed73323a3fd5affcbce43dcdd4f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ac340a31753714aed39c934","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390275,"date":"2026-03-24T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are obviously very concerned about those who are homeless right now or utilizing the programs we put in place: Reaching Home and the unsheltered homelessness and encampments initiative. The unsheltered homelessness and encampments initiative was a two-year program. We have communicated very clearly the transition over to Reaching Home, which will continue for several more years. \n\nWe want to make sure we are providing the services. We are putting $1 billion into supportive and transitional housing as well and working with provinces to make sure we can support people who need that housing the most.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390275","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are obviously very concerned about those who are homeless right now or utilizing the programs we put in place: Reaching Home and the unsheltered homelessness and encampments initiative. The unsheltered homelessness and encampments initiative was a two-year program. We have communicated very clearly the transition over to Reaching Home, which will continue for several more years. \n\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d2e5891646ed00103dc37a6fa4a712b589dbaec5228f4da26c2828c49cfc420"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ffe310c153f8c547810262ef71129bb8611b941f7a3b9fdaa700b42decbb5592"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4476a5a4c9d2750f44e1f44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390274,"date":"2026-03-25T20:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for his question. We have some good news for New Brunswick. Through Build Canada Homes, we are working with partners to build 1,200 affordable housing units, with the potential to increase this number to 1,500 housing units. These projects are ready to move forward quickly, and nearly half of these units will use modern building methods to speed up construction.\n\nTogether with our partners, we are building more homes for all Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390274","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for his question. We have some good news for New Brunswick. Through Build Canada Homes, we are working with partners to build 1,200 affordable housing units, with the potential to increase this number to 1,500 housing units. These projects are ready to move forward quickly, and nearly half of these units will use modern building methods to speed up construction.\n\nTo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9edc7163b9265025df01f00caeac39c5fa02c4dd623e922a8577c7f92b9c19f2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8307eed1e00eda6b2aa9f2e13b34ad974d26179e3ebec683a0487a4fa2bc4c2a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83a6078246b5ce17db77d970","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390273,"date":"2026-03-26T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, indeed today is a very good day for housing in Canada. We are working with all provinces and territories, along with our homebuilding partners, to make housing more affordable and to deliver for Canadians. The funding from the housing supply bill would keep our projects moving, protect Canadian workers and support construction. This is for the months and years ahead.\n\nWe are investing in affordability in our housing and in the Canadians whom we need to support right now. There is a lot more work to do, but today is a great day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390273","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, indeed today is a very good day for housing in Canada. We are working with all provinces and territories, along with our homebuilding partners, to make housing more affordable and to deliver for Canadians. The funding from the housing supply bill would keep our projects moving, protect Canadian workers and support construction. This is for the months and years ahead.\n\nWe are investing","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["47acb6032dd435a49aed1b837b8201231ff109b30fc749005e3db56e8e5fc3b0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e1d547cec9b18165d001a8c53b914c77a212b49eab9d066048d9ca031f952595"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03f6cda1187af593bac85614","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715151,"date":"2026-04-13T19:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it was wonderful to be in Brampton last week with the Prime Minister to announce the funding for a new community centre, the Embleton community centre and park, in Brampton. It is a $64-million investment for a 175,000-square foot community centre. It is exactly the kind of project that we promised Canadians we would deliver. This is one of 13 initial projects for the build community strong fund.\n\nThere is much more to come in the weeks ahead. It is time to build.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715151","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it was wonderful to be in Brampton last week with the Prime Minister to announce the funding for a new community centre, the Embleton community centre and park, in Brampton. It is a $64-million investment for a 175,000-square foot community centre. It is exactly the kind of project that we promised Canadians we would deliver. This is one of 13 initial projects for the build community ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5a9b093f1341d085789741acf0b4ab4c8e7d3aef86e6e869e88a6393f8145ca2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["307166ad68b4c4fdf46692e18b16b06d984425a7b6ff76c79b8c007c24cadf38"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2065e0aba889699764010853","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715152,"date":"2026-04-13T19:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this government supports the rights of private property owners and this government is 100% committed to reconciliation.\n\nCanadians want the clarity that this appeal will provide. They do not want the fear and misinformation that these Conservatives are pushing out in an attempt to divide Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715152","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this government supports the rights of private property owners and this government is 100% committed to reconciliation.\n\nCanadians want the clarity that this appeal will provide. They do not want the fear and misinformation that these Conservatives are pushing out in an attempt to divide Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["219dab26e2abc88209dde53049a8581cc1a0e50a8c33ca37b48eab64a160646e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6340c8a97e446b929433eab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715153,"date":"2026-04-13T20:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity for the member opposite to let me highlight the work that is going into the Canada public transit fund and the zero emission transit fund.\n\nWe have opportunities to invest in zero emission transportation: battery electric buses. Technology is improving by the month. There are battery electric buses operating in many cities across Canada. Edmonton is currently the city with the lead. Edmonton, as some members opposite will know, is fairly far north in Canada, and those buses are running well. There is evidence around the world that battery electric buses will deliver good transportation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715153","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity for the member opposite to let me highlight the work that is going into the Canada public transit fund and the zero emission transit fund.\n\nWe have opportunities to invest in zero emission transportation: battery electric buses. Technology is improving by the month. There are battery electric buses operating in many cities across Canada. Edmonton is curren","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","label":"Sustainable transportation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","label":"Sustainable transportation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["27815bc6da96a13f90b8666628222c754c3b357405698a9431dea894043eda75"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["94c52b3b357365a017e9dc2549d96c5d2fe45118b260ed3360750e578e4b16a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f067908c9ba34a273a106526","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715149,"date":"2026-04-14T19:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear. This band of Conservatives is what is sowing dissent and anxiety in Canada. The government is being crystal clear. We support—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715149","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear. This band of Conservatives is what is sowing dissent and anxiety in Canada. The government is being crystal clear. We support—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b57edfd28caa48ccd559aba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715150,"date":"2026-04-14T19:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will reinforce the concerns this side of the House has about the anxiety and fearmongering the Conservatives are pushing on this issue. \n\nThis is a very serious issue. The government supports the appeal. The government supports the rights of private property owners. The government supports reconciliation. We will pursue the course of action of appealing the superior court decision in B.C. We will see justice and clarity on this. \n\nWe do not need the politics being played by the Conservatives to make this worse for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715150","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will reinforce the concerns this side of the House has about the anxiety and fearmongering the Conservatives are pushing on this issue. \n\nThis is a very serious issue. The government supports the appeal. The government supports the rights of private property owners. The government supports reconciliation. We will pursue the course of action of appealing the superior court decision i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da505fddea1d72402497b1d411b47923d39495c3627225c2f097c52fcc319957"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d093e9354942f89472d3d8a6becf0fc291a20e876f21d5ad36e607cad8f7b0d9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbbb4c2b9418d29df945bf69","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128257,"date":"2026-04-15T21:30:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee members, for the invitation to appear today to discuss the Canada Infrastructure Bank loan for the Mersey River Wind Project. I'm honoured to be here with Deputy Minister Paul Halucha. Before I delve into this great project that will have such positive economic and social impacts for Nova Scotians, I want to make it clear that the Canada Infrastructure Bank is an independent Crown corporation that works at arm's length from government in its day-to-day operations and makes its own investment decisions. These decisions are guided by rigorous due diligence, sound commercial discipline and a focus on delivering real benefits for Canadians. As you are aware, in February of this year the Canada Infrastructure Bank announced a $206.4-million investment to support the development of the Mersey River wind project in beautiful Milton, Nova Scotia. In addition to this loan, Natural Resources Canada's smart renewables and electrification pathways program is providing up to $25 million in funding, while the Province of Nova Scotia is contributing both financially and through in-kind support valued at nearly $700,000. This project reflects close co-operation between all levels of government and federal and provincial partners, including the Progressive Conservative government of Nova Scotia, working together to advance clean energy development and create economic opportunities for local communities. The project will provide more options for Nova Scotians, as well as bringing competition to the province's energy market. This is one of the larger wind energy investments that's supported by the Canada Infrastructure Bank, and it is a story that Nova Scotians can be very proud of. It is a sustainable clean-power project that aims to provide affordable, reliable and grid-stabilizing energy to the province. When we talk about building strong communities, this is what we're talking about. The Mersey River wind farm is expected to supply nearly 150 megawatts of zero-emissions electricity, capable of powering more than 50,000 homes while catalyzing over $500 million in private investment in the region. It represents the first renewable-to-retail licence in Nova Scotia. It will allow Nova Scotians to buy renewable electricity directly from the developer, giving them a choice. The Mersey River wind farm is expected to avoid approximately 220,000 tonnes of carbon emissions per year. This is the equivalent of about 1.5% of Nova Scotia's total carbon output in 2022. The project will also help reduce the financial strain on ratepayers as the province transitions to clean electricity. As part of the broader focus on clean renewable energy across the country, and as we seek to mitigate the increasing impacts of climate change, the project is eligible for the clean technology investment tax credit for up to 30% of capital costs. The Mersey River wind farm has reached financial close. Construction will take place in two phases, with the first phase expected to be completed next year, in 2027. More than 200 workers are expected to be employed at the peak of construction activities, supporting local economic activity in the region. The Canada Infrastructure Bank's involvement is enabling a faster build-out of the project at a lower cost to ratepayers, consistent with Nova Scotia's commitment of achieving 80% of clean power generation via renewable energy by 2030. As minister, I will always be supportive of meaningful investments that create local jobs, build local infrastructure and promote energy independence, particularly in these challenging times. I will take the last bit of time to walk through the structure of the Canada Infrastructure Bank, for the benefit of the committee. The Canada Infrastructure Bank is governed by an independent board of directors, which is responsible for overseeing the bank's strategic direction and improving these investments. This structure is designed to balance independence in investment decision-making with appropriate public oversight and transparency. The bank publishes information about its investments and performance on its website and through its annual reports. Finally, I will reiterate that this is exactly the kind of project that Nova Scotians need and that Canadians need. It's one that delivers clean energy, creates good jobs and drives sustainable economic growth. It's about building a stronger, more affordable and more resilient future for communities across the province. Thank you. I look forward to answering the members' questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128257","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee members, for the invitation to appear today to discuss the Canada Infrastructure Bank loan for the Mersey River Wind Project. I'm honoured to be here with Deputy Minister Paul Halucha. Before I delve into this great project that will have such positive economic and social impacts for Nova Scotians, I want to make it clear that the Canada Infrastructure Ba","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9897e6fbd4372332aaa87c64b0666bb0c6f43d724e0a68d9edb28b88b061c86"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["400563e37092993c183ca490a0b6bb9472221430fdc6efd0ee36324726ae0d15"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecc051e5c91eb9b6e8df2dd3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128258,"date":"2026-04-15T21:30:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Through the chair, first and foremost, the purpose of the Canada Infrastructure Bank is to attract private investment, capital to be invested in Canadian infrastructure. The bank has been very successful at doing that. This is about the 108th deal that has been secured by the Canada Infrastructure Bank. We're talking now about tens of billions of dollars that are being invested in Canadian infrastructure by the private sector through transactions such as this. This is a loan to private sector proponents, and the terms of that are legally protected.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128258","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Through the chair, first and foremost, the purpose of the Canada Infrastructure Bank is to attract private investment, capital to be invested in Canadian infrastructure. The bank has been very successful at doing that. This is about the 108th deal that has been secured by the Canada Infrastructure Bank. We're talking now about tens of billions of dollars that are being invested in Canadian infrast","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6a790d960bfef3151e834c3144133c23992796605f268a7f33f781737a1304b0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8115f3af5d33d085ae246ac6f93b1366b281257bcfd1610b04ed04a98371f3c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df7e4926c2b4fd26c768e72e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128259,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"We here in this room, we who are elected.... Although I have that responsibility of oversight with the Canada Infrastructure Bank, I have nothing to do with the deals that it makes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128259","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We here in this room, we who are elected.... Although I have that responsibility of oversight with the Canada Infrastructure Bank, I have nothing to do with the deals that it makes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d94475dae85c8447e5d4f77d5cd98253705de55333e0cf5c8f21ae393ea7574"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6597da489750436c9ba350c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128260,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Those are subject to legal requirements around confidentiality with the terms.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128260","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Those are subject to legal requirements around confidentiality with the terms.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fd2dc6a8ebbf26e52339d2bdd6c2cb0e02e3e3e25ef9719a3d99c7a8efe5b4f6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca0789a5e6c937052499fbd6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128261,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Through the chair, I do not know the specific terms of this deal. They are confidential between the bank and the project proponent. I understand, through the CEO, that these are competitive market rates in terms of interest on the loan. These are loans that are repaid.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128261","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Through the chair, I do not know the specific terms of this deal. They are confidential between the bank and the project proponent. I understand, through the CEO, that these are competitive market rates in terms of interest on the loan. These are loans that are repaid.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3612f1aa2f7a8bc2db7dca43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128262,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I do not have any insight into what those rates are.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128262","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I do not have any insight into what those rates are.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102600","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102600","label":"Birth rate","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","label":"Interest rates","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05e47d92e11575acfd2b06358d28a2c05c499406164f475882e4d343e7be6408"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06e297378775dd9c3de6a774","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128263,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"At this stage, I'm not here to talk about what competitive market rates are.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128263","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"At this stage, I'm not here to talk about what competitive market rates are.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035183","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exchange rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035183","label":"Exchange rates","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c603c53cb8fae6575ddf52610ee94c62f1c3a10fc8fc58e6563e7c4884bac626"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-088c519e3c705567b3aa2c15","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128264,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"My understanding is that this committee was informed by the CEO of the Canada Infrastructure Bank that this loan was done at competitive market rates.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128264","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My understanding is that this committee was informed by the CEO of the Canada Infrastructure Bank that this loan was done at competitive market rates.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021238","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021238","label":"Business loans","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d0e5894d4ca11979ada9e5a584b98cabc2973ce25c987f8e79d334c32a3e5ac"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a736474a5460b43e97777043","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128265,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"The bank's confidential loan agreements are not my business. I'm responsible for oversight of the Canada Infrastructure Bank.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128265","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The bank's confidential loan agreements are not my business. I'm responsible for oversight of the Canada Infrastructure Bank.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0dc864b6b16407cb264eb4f9d0dab5604d05f78317573ba45516dec979fc3eb3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa0c4839eb9dbea06c580da2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128266,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"It's not the committee's business either.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128266","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's not the committee's business either.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1dbffb19985564f1fafbe5e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128267,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"As minister, I have oversight of the Canada Infrastructure Bank. The Canada Infrastructure Bank is attracting private capital through loan agreements, for the Mersey River wind farm in particular in this case. Those agreements are subject to legal requirements on confidentiality. They report to us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128267","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As minister, I have oversight of the Canada Infrastructure Bank. The Canada Infrastructure Bank is attracting private capital through loan agreements, for the Mersey River wind farm in particular in this case. Those agreements are subject to legal requirements on confidentiality. They report to us.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["08b94d98deb4efa712fcb6821b424ea18d9a16e8608209db1bdac4fb381514d1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66194a2689965cec45d4f913d3384a0830dac9e3dc76786e9111f281e686a0c4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40f7a5afe1a77bbd4b9f796c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128268,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Through the chair, I'm not clear what the member is pursuing here. She wants the confidential details of loan agreements that the Canada Infrastructure Bank is making, potentially jeopardizing investment from the private sector into Canadian infrastructure. That seems to be where she's going with this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128268","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Through the chair, I'm not clear what the member is pursuing here. She wants the confidential details of loan agreements that the Canada Infrastructure Bank is making, potentially jeopardizing investment from the private sector into Canadian infrastructure. That seems to be where she's going with this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-edc057749f7fd5c708172947","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128269,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"First and foremost, this project is supported by the Conservative Government of Nova Scotia, so in terms of any partisan assertions, that's completely false. This project stands on its own feet with its own merits. It's creating jobs. It's creating clean power. It's investment from the private sector into Nova Scotia and into a clean grid project.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128269","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"First and foremost, this project is supported by the Conservative Government of Nova Scotia, so in terms of any partisan assertions, that's completely false. This project stands on its own feet with its own merits. It's creating jobs. It's creating clean power. It's investment from the private sector into Nova Scotia and into a clean grid project.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-586049c1a3c479aae8672776","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128270,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I was aware of this project probably a week before the announcement that happened in Mersey River, which I was very fortunate to go to. A member present here hosted us in her riding for the announcement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128270","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I was aware of this project probably a week before the announcement that happened in Mersey River, which I was very fortunate to go to. A member present here hosted us in her riding for the announcement.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Demining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","label":"Demining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","label":"Disaster relief","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","label":"Tourism facilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3fd98619c079fc96b7f1047926e3256c21b69173689399971b94760116b9cfb9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0766ae78edbd46c0157d8fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128271,"date":"2026-04-15T21:40:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I had no knowledge of the deal terms or any of the specifics. That is between the Infrastructure Bank and the proponent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128271","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I had no knowledge of the deal terms or any of the specifics. That is between the Infrastructure Bank and the proponent.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3896fc8ad571142ccbf3e0cf2a3e2adf7f8f6598eacdd98580cd9411a50b6eaf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-677b139869f2fd3a3adabc5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128272,"date":"2026-04-15T21:45:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Certainly the Canada Infrastructure Bank will play a key role in scaling up the infrastructure we need now across Canada to have the fastest-growing economy in the G7, to create the jobs that we need now, and to make sure it's done in a way that delivers results for Canadians. In this case, in Nova Scotia, we're going to see job creation and a clean, renewable energy project coming onto the grid. The Nova Scotia government, which as I just mentioned is a Progressive Conservative government, is very keen on this project. They are very strong supporters of it and want to see more projects like this. The Infrastructure Bank is really a central player in attracting private capital to invest in our infrastructure and to create these jobs. To date, the CIB has committed just over $18 billion of capital that is ultimately taxpayer-funded, and it has attracted over $25 billion of private capital into infrastructure. That's now almost $55 billion of capital value in those projects. There are 108 projects to date, and obviously there is rigorous scrutiny on all 108 of those projects. They report annually through the annual report, but there's also lots of information available online. It's providing a great service to Canadians in terms of making capital available in a country with big infrastructure needs and a shortage of capital. We need more private capital in the mix. We don't want to rely on only our taxpayers to fund everything here. In this case, because the terms are competitive and because the commercial rigour is paramount, we're seeing successful deals and great delivery on infrastructure across Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128272","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Certainly the Canada Infrastructure Bank will play a key role in scaling up the infrastructure we need now across Canada to have the fastest-growing economy in the G7, to create the jobs that we need now, and to make sure it's done in a way that delivers results for Canadians. In this case, in Nova Scotia, we're going to see job creation and a clean, renewable energy project coming onto the grid. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["36ea7b835462aff1356bedff23bca2491212058d59b8adcf23e04b228ff47b31"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["874ec2b5ead071ad75ffa2de2e5ff0a7fb0ad6b8c1f52e30c86d024eafe64157"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a31486f520517c2b2600d9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128273,"date":"2026-04-15T21:45:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"There are now 15 public transit projects supported by the Infrastructure Bank, which speaks to the importance of not only public transit but also, as the member stated, the connection and overlap with developing more housing and growing our economy. We're seeing a significant number of projects coming forward that combine infrastructure, trade and transportation, and public transit, in the case of Toronto. There are several examples of that. Regarding additional private capital being brought to the table, historically Canada relied on public capital from taxpayers to fund these projects. In this case, the innovation of having an infrastructure bank that has the tools of public financing and can also draw in capital finance is a huge benefit for many of these projects, which deliver more than just the economic outcome. They deliver real value in terms of community building. As the member stated, building communities where public transit is needed or where housing-enabling infrastructure is needed requires investment. The Canada Infrastructure Bank is doing a great job of those triple-word-score investments that have wins across the board for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128273","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There are now 15 public transit projects supported by the Infrastructure Bank, which speaks to the importance of not only public transit but also, as the member stated, the connection and overlap with developing more housing and growing our economy. We're seeing a significant number of projects coming forward that combine infrastructure, trade and transportation, and public transit, in the case of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["522bb23a63866d1941e1d4d8371e28af9ebae447d8d8c8faf1efac9b280328c8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04b60abb6b744ed770c6b9ffca1dcbe29434d2d5ae3cb579191c57e7cafeb915"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49c88070243fa997d46e6945","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128274,"date":"2026-04-15T21:50:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"We see projects supported by the Infrastructure Bank right across the country. There are over 40 projects in the west, where I come from. Ontario now has 34 projects. Quebec has 11 projects. Atlantic Canada has 15 projects. Mersey River Wind is number 15. There are half a dozen projects in the north. Projects are spread very equitably across the country, which is very important for Canada. We have to make sure we're building in all the regions. Over 300,000 jobs have been created through these projects. That's very significant job creation, and that's also a key element of this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128274","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We see projects supported by the Infrastructure Bank right across the country. There are over 40 projects in the west, where I come from. Ontario now has 34 projects. Quebec has 11 projects. Atlantic Canada has 15 projects. Mersey River Wind is number 15. There are half a dozen projects in the north. Projects are spread very equitably across the country, which is very important for Canada. We have","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75dbb82eb04689c9fc21e599e4e29041328efb6e0563975669454ee3e3048c68"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f1cc3b6cd6d5c9dc2ab3ba891af5363cf56b61fd693f3806e55ea159b4a75d92"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e1d6d38ba607654db483973","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128275,"date":"2026-04-15T21:50:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I thank the member for the question. I don't know any of the people involved that the member is mentioning. I do know that—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128275","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thank the member for the question. I don't know any of the people involved that the member is mentioning. I do know that—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54c8de1ffc4b16ed56f3d2cb3e22237c32d055f63f753579929c382dd7775903"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-656d5faed58c016e2809268a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128276,"date":"2026-04-15T21:50:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"No, I do not know the individuals involved behind the scenes with the proponent. I know that the Canada Infrastructure Bank does its due diligence and works with credible partners. There's an exhaustive process—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128276","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, I do not know the individuals involved behind the scenes with the proponent. I know that the Canada Infrastructure Bank does its due diligence and works with credible partners. There's an exhaustive process—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88098000259b3d556d0df4f419ddc1b7b8367310b31d26ea3b6a91eae5a85d92"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6f45a6e8ea3a1a96f14aa31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128277,"date":"2026-04-15T21:50:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"The Infrastructure Bank conducts its business with credible business people. They do the work and the due diligence that are necessary.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128277","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Infrastructure Bank conducts its business with credible business people. They do the work and the due diligence that are necessary.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b3eef35b98f5007c46096915e984a3cbb4f2fd846e19c1d40db3e45178c28f9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71c8fa3dcf2119232a9864f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128278,"date":"2026-04-15T21:50:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I think there's a field of relationships. Certainly regionally, lots of members have many relationships with business people or politicians, community representatives—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128278","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I think there's a field of relationships. Certainly regionally, lots of members have many relationships with business people or politicians, community representatives—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc1d56e32042410a3965b06975fe33b32390e2452791c8d6971567344826f218"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0e91069eb024c904f9dc53eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128279,"date":"2026-04-15T21:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Again, lots of project proponents meet with local members of Parliament. They are obviously present in their ridings. It's normal for members of Parliament to be consulted and informed about projects that proponents are bringing forward of all different types. Housing, infrastructure and public transit, in the realms that I am responsible for right now, are—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128279","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Again, lots of project proponents meet with local members of Parliament. They are obviously present in their ridings. It's normal for members of Parliament to be consulted and informed about projects that proponents are bringing forward of all different types. Housing, infrastructure and public transit, in the realms that I am responsible for right now, are—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e207f1465dab60583def9832","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128280,"date":"2026-04-15T21:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"In order to attract support for a project—I speak of this going back to my time serving at the local level on the west coast—it's important to do engagement and outreach in the community. Elected officials in the community are important to meet with in order to build those connections and make sure they understand the projects being brought forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128280","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In order to attract support for a project—I speak of this going back to my time serving at the local level on the west coast—it's important to do engagement and outreach in the community. Elected officials in the community are important to meet with in order to build those connections and make sure they understand the projects being brought forward.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b7318f479005f0c3b08cef510e42f560af1774020ae405b02abe2b8fded818a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["467c48e474a950c4d7f39cfa7b4949f1eefb49047a0bf2ba95a8d0bc4c8bbdb2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25d1717aa55fd2c7df127930","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128281,"date":"2026-04-15T21:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I do not make investment decisions related to the Canada Infrastructure Bank. It operates independently from the federal government in its day-to-day operations and its investment decisions. I was present at the announcement because this is an important project for Canada and its critical infrastructure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128281","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I do not make investment decisions related to the Canada Infrastructure Bank. It operates independently from the federal government in its day-to-day operations and its investment decisions. I was present at the announcement because this is an important project for Canada and its critical infrastructure.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d2f0386ae03b3b25d21bf51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128282,"date":"2026-04-15T21:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"To the member, through the chair, I have full confidence in the Canada Infrastructure Bank. They do their work, they do their due diligence and they negotiate the terms. In this case, it's a loan to a private investor to invest in energy infrastructure for Nova Scotia. It was supported by the Conservative government in Nova Scotia, so I don't think there is anything partisan about this. I think it's a very important infrastructure deal. It was negotiated on good terms with a private proponent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128282","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"To the member, through the chair, I have full confidence in the Canada Infrastructure Bank. They do their work, they do their due diligence and they negotiate the terms. In this case, it's a loan to a private investor to invest in energy infrastructure for Nova Scotia. It was supported by the Conservative government in Nova Scotia, so I don't think there is anything partisan about this. I think it","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b2facbf8fa598dcdce18cbf4838c4679356206373f4efeff8fc34ccbce21bc8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0bbc2ad7b0b5f3f960f0056e1581b2a51550f573e716246a282bcca9242ee304"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69e8da870c29b964c188c4d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128283,"date":"2026-04-15T21:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"The Government of Canada provides the capital for the Infrastructure Bank—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128283","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Government of Canada provides the capital for the Infrastructure Bank—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036381","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036381","label":"National Capital","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ca4fc69976d798910a4539b31fcec26ce5bec66271eb35c1609d68f9b40a954"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b5770f2cc6eb3ef488b96ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128284,"date":"2026-04-15T21:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I'll again clarify that the purpose of the Canada Infrastructure Bank is to attract private capital—businesses that can invest in Canadian infrastructure and build Canadian infrastructure for the benefit of Canadians. We serve for the benefit of Canadians. These are businesses that can make investments to benefit Canadians. Those investments do rely on commercial sensitivity. In many cases, those agreements have legal requirements for confidentiality around the specific terms of the agreements.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128284","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll again clarify that the purpose of the Canada Infrastructure Bank is to attract private capital—businesses that can invest in Canadian infrastructure and build Canadian infrastructure for the benefit of Canadians. We serve for the benefit of Canadians. These are businesses that can make investments to benefit Canadians. Those investments do rely on commercial sensitivity. In many cases, those ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ee7a0d4e17d6203d7bf65bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128285,"date":"2026-04-15T22:00:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I'm not aware of all my office's or staff's activities day to day. I am aware of the members' infrastructure and housing requests going back to last year, when this session of Parliament began. I got letters and lists from probably most members of Parliament.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128285","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm not aware of all my office's or staff's activities day to day. I am aware of the members' infrastructure and housing requests going back to last year, when this session of Parliament began. I got letters and lists from probably most members of Parliament.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba32f84b287ddb183aa13a95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128286,"date":"2026-04-15T22:00:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"That's correct. I don't have knowledge about that. My staff are contacting MPs every day. I have desks. I have advisers from every region of Canada who are constantly in touch with members of Parliament. I don't track that by the day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128286","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's correct. I don't have knowledge about that. My staff are contacting MPs every day. I have desks. I have advisers from every region of Canada who are constantly in touch with members of Parliament. I don't track that by the day.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ec6e4a15ff0faa3555a7944fa83fd8e2c403785cb9c48f4db1e22ab40990e49"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa7da4d73fad4530c71f820f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128287,"date":"2026-04-15T22:00:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I disagree, and I think at this point we're talking about the work of the Canada Infrastructure Bank, which certainly has done many of its projects in regions...irrespective of who the member of Parliament is. It has delivered those across the country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128287","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I disagree, and I think at this point we're talking about the work of the Canada Infrastructure Bank, which certainly has done many of its projects in regions...irrespective of who the member of Parliament is. It has delivered those across the country.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e75d38bdb7acc3b41a79fdb9b5a82a2c639e01f1eb8fc6ff3b44650a33f1ce79"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba6917b312f2f93d4c66656d0d8b490bc4d52cdc90d286553ca460cdf8922a9d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6734fa3bcd796683f168b1fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128288,"date":"2026-04-15T22:05:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I was very happy to see this announcement come forward. I've been really impressed with the array of projects that the Canada Infrastructure Bank funds. Clean power has been a significant part of that for the CIB, particularly working with first nations, with indigenous people, to basically give them energy security in the north with renewable projects. That is good for those communities. It's resilience. What I see with this project is a much larger version of that for Nova Scotia. Nova Scotia, as you state, has real challenges with power. The clean power supply is not there. The other piece that I think is really compelling is that this is a first stage in a much bigger build-out of renewable electricity on the Atlantic coast of Canada. Nova Scotia has enormous wind resources, both offshore and onshore. This is an onshore project. There are enormous resources in Newfoundland—onshore as well. These are world-class wind resources that Canada is currently not reaping any benefit from. Nova Scotia is leading the way here with an exemplary project, leveraging private capital and creating energy choice for Nova Scotians, as well as building those initial building blocks to have a much larger clean grid in Atlantic Canada, which I think will benefit many more Canadians than just the Nova Scotians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128288","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I was very happy to see this announcement come forward. I've been really impressed with the array of projects that the Canada Infrastructure Bank funds. Clean power has been a significant part of that for the CIB, particularly working with first nations, with indigenous people, to basically give them energy security in the north with renewable projects. That is good for those communities. It's res","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["133910a0b8c987e62aab4f68afd00d907f5fcc35a7af3f55e7eea5757712f096"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ae16c6e76705d9526aceda9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128289,"date":"2026-04-15T22:05:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Through the chair, if you look at the array of 108 different projects across the country, there are great outcomes for Canadians far and wide. I think significant private investment has been leveraged from that. These are loans, so they are being paid back. I think there's been some language used by some members that [ Inaudible—Editor ]","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128289","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Through the chair, if you look at the array of 108 different projects across the country, there are great outcomes for Canadians far and wide. I think significant private investment has been leveraged from that. These are loans, so they are being paid back. I think there's been some language used by some members that [ Inaudible—Editor ]","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f90dfc4073116de95d3df7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128290,"date":"2026-04-15T22:05:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Through the chair, it's quite the opposite. I think there is a great track record by the Infrastructure Bank of investing in very compelling and viable projects across Canada. The bank is bringing funding back in. The loans that have been made are solid. The capital is being repaid, which is the whole purpose of the Infrastructure Bank to begin with, to provide capital that could be repaid as judged by the bank based on its projects.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128290","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Through the chair, it's quite the opposite. I think there is a great track record by the Infrastructure Bank of investing in very compelling and viable projects across Canada. The bank is bringing funding back in. The loans that have been made are solid. The capital is being repaid, which is the whole purpose of the Infrastructure Bank to begin with, to provide capital that could be repaid as judg","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5892fcecc03b646c79a2f639","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128291,"date":"2026-04-15T22:05:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"The terms are legally protected by confidentiality between the parties, and that's the Infrastructure Bank and the proponents of these projects. They have language in their agreements that protects the commercial viability around the loan, and we need to respect that if we're going to attract further capital.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128291","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The terms are legally protected by confidentiality between the parties, and that's the Infrastructure Bank and the proponents of these projects. They have language in their agreements that protects the commercial viability around the loan, and we need to respect that if we're going to attract further capital.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3cb64737780f9c46a373741b53ca9634777dd2d8d5691cfd2dce43fc91f2772a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f45f511eedb7ea5834a97fe75bc483e62772746add77c2bf1069df745af8cc04"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71204d571fc6ffd0d419b2e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128292,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I did not know anything about that when I attended the announcement. That information has come up since that time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128292","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I did not know anything about that when I attended the announcement. That information has come up since that time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee2355fa954abc42b7517153","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128293,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I'm not sure when I heard there were assertions around that. I don't remember. It was some weeks ago, I think around the business of this committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128293","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm not sure when I heard there were assertions around that. I don't remember. It was some weeks ago, I think around the business of this committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58c568d803ea3ef2277f706cbc1bc477e9d1b593fe0216de6cd5d564fb062d94"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64adc8fb1ce94d4432c38002","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128294,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"The Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner is charged with ensuring that all of the work that we do here in the Government of Canada is subject to their rigorous scrutiny.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128294","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner is charged with ensuring that all of the work that we do here in the Government of Canada is subject to their rigorous scrutiny.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9fe82025601dead3d58fb849fe8709849e40b5943b2187326143c809f646399c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8abc79eed11e6e9c82c3daebd68f0a4dc8de8450afa2649fa44612c9538ec8d2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d4b4ad0b58e9a19c9e22e56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128295,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I personally did...? Sorry, can you repeat the question?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128295","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I personally did...? Sorry, can you repeat the question?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e02dada797965424b93a7bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128296,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"The company has a loan with the Canada Infrastructure Bank. I do not engage in the terms of the loans.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128296","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The company has a loan with the Canada Infrastructure Bank. I do not engage in the terms of the loans.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021238","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021238","label":"Business loans","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["78f602a63ce7a3b6499ab24cb3503150c980e2efa0fe8fb1a565cb1332e4012b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc1b5689f872262df20474c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128297,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"On the investments that are made, that's the business of the Infrastructure Bank and its board.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128297","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"On the investments that are made, that's the business of the Infrastructure Bank and its board.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7870db12e41252c6f86d546e3f9ddc1b616cffd56f8122c0b261afb7beebb07d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f14fd292dc22f148142f2114","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128298,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"If you're using that line of reasoning, this was for the Progressive Conservative Government of Nova Scotia to benefit from. I did not ask questions or ask for more scrutiny as to why a Conservative government is getting a deal with the Infrastructure Bank. My sense in looking at this is that there are no partisan issues that are relevant here. The commercial terms of the loan are negotiated by the bank, and they will deliver a successful outcome for Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128298","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If you're using that line of reasoning, this was for the Progressive Conservative Government of Nova Scotia to benefit from. I did not ask questions or ask for more scrutiny as to why a Conservative government is getting a deal with the Infrastructure Bank. My sense in looking at this is that there are no partisan issues that are relevant here. The commercial terms of the loan are negotiated by th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b282f8ef0d49ede1cc6cdcf5e00a201197f9f11a494fce2c6921950de6f2215a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e8a8ce8eefc8bd692f461123341cd4290dec8f7ed6603f028afcd0014d99716"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-feca8cd8fa1ac0aed79a5ef7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128299,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"The Infrastructure Bank has financed this project in part. It's up to the proponents of the project, the project partners, to do the procurement. Those decisions rest with the project partners. We certainly encourage buy Canada. I have done that directly with the Infrastructure Bank in my role with oversight. We now have a cross-government commitment to buy Canada, but this project was ahead of the curve, before that policy of the government came in. In terms of buy Canada, that's a recommendation we're making to all of the Crown corporations: that they do everything they can to buy Canada. Ultimately, those decisions are made by the project partners.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128299","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Infrastructure Bank has financed this project in part. It's up to the proponents of the project, the project partners, to do the procurement. Those decisions rest with the project partners. We certainly encourage buy Canada. I have done that directly with the Infrastructure Bank in my role with oversight. We now have a cross-government commitment to buy Canada, but this project was ahead of th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe688468f701e4a88ed847b62a396b23d05d76793f135b12d3448ffc7d091dfa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95b1d5e0f80e7f807ffe022572ed45cb463148ce55c6377364e1881b36a23186"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c2c2cfcfc8bdc8d53e092a83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128300,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"My department does not do that review or consideration. As I said, the project partners do their procurement—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128300","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My department does not do that review or consideration. As I said, the project partners do their procurement—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["595f89ab277555a8b79ca8a757ac64e04b7778ef8cca2a7167a375890e5f175f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35f61752f54f6d678f90c7a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128301,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"—and the Infrastructure Bank makes a decision on the financing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128301","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"—and the Infrastructure Bank makes a decision on the financing.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d157f8211595c2f6a4f276ccaba65505c1c50d9b6805827d47120568ad2bc0d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3bfafdfcbbbdb85d7e5bb7c17ac19a9cdc9b8d398229e5c121c9d55a3bb3cae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-abf77450013d6a99f9615328","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128302,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Two hundred and fifty jobs in Nova Scotia, in the southern part of the province, are critical. I heard that when I was at the member's riding. The mayor, who was there, was very happy to see a project of this scale, the jobs that it will create and the opportunities that it creates in the local community. The Progressive Conservative government in Nova Scotia is a strong supporter of this and took legislative action to enable the grid to be diversified beyond Nova Scotia Power, so that a project like this could feed in renewable electricity. They expect that will scale up with other projects around the province. Irrespective of which ridings, I think we're going to see a lot more activity there. As I mentioned, the Canada Infrastructure Bank also supported the Nova Scotia-New Brunswick intertie, connecting the grids of those two provinces to enable some of this renewable electricity to move out of Nova Scotia and into New Brunswick and towards points to the west and potentially the south. I think there's great commercial opportunity in that. Building all of this infrastructure means a significant number of jobs, which is a good thing—jobs that are building clean infrastructure. That's literally taking pollution out of Nova Scotia and replacing it with clean electricity. A more resilient grid, more local production, cleaning up the environment and improving the climate mean a lot of wins are being delivered. I heard a lot of excitement around the jobs when I was there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128302","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Two hundred and fifty jobs in Nova Scotia, in the southern part of the province, are critical. I heard that when I was at the member's riding. The mayor, who was there, was very happy to see a project of this scale, the jobs that it will create and the opportunities that it creates in the local community. The Progressive Conservative government in Nova Scotia is a strong supporter of this and took","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b2ddca08c4b3372d107fedfc2170c178fd01c2d0144dfa98738c2813f6451219"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["866f561854f7f2f602c4df8cd9ce4242d086eb877151bd218f56181e3d765c8e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97c09a8236a0eed36a1aebff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128303,"date":"2026-04-15T22:20:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"The salary for the CEO is set by cabinet through the Governor in Council.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128303","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The salary for the CEO is set by cabinet through the Governor in Council.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a50974adaa0be0cdcde28c788365176c7e19cee6ed1b0c7c0e4b33dee37af5c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e2b69854a53613366483e75194c458afef5efbffed035fe6b4e0ce027d73b1f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d8e941b94cdfcfcd769181d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128304,"date":"2026-04-15T22:20:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"The CEO's salary right now is.... Give me a second, here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128304","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The CEO's salary right now is.... Give me a second, here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18f645e36a0f27586704ac07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128305,"date":"2026-04-15T22:20:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"No. I think there is clear oversight of the work that the CEO is doing through the board. Their reviews do come up for my review as well, but in Mr. Cory's case, he has delivered exceptionally well over 100 projects across the country, with almost $20 billion of infrastructure, and he has attracted $25 billion in private investment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128305","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No. I think there is clear oversight of the work that the CEO is doing through the board. Their reviews do come up for my review as well, but in Mr. Cory's case, he has delivered exceptionally well over 100 projects across the country, with almost $20 billion of infrastructure, and he has attracted $25 billion in private investment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2eb26992e0451961fc7dc340","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128306,"date":"2026-04-15T22:20:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I'm not sure what the question was, but I judge this based on the merits of the project, which are outstanding in this case. Whether it's job creation, whether it's a clean grid, attracting private investment—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128306","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm not sure what the question was, but I judge this based on the merits of the project, which are outstanding in this case. Whether it's job creation, whether it's a clean grid, attracting private investment—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41e84d3cea3e59178a36cd72f57bddd43eaca3ef77f0188d73178dee5380f55c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ff8f1c645677d6f819e3d9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128307,"date":"2026-04-15T22:20:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"—or building infrastructure in Canada, those are the purposes here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128307","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"—or building infrastructure in Canada, those are the purposes here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd8fbb3b6383a96f781f361a2bd483cf1a39ac63a1fd9d366655114aff74431c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d93894d09b8cd2173f9a9a7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128308,"date":"2026-04-15T22:20:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"Many of these projects that are financed by the Canada Infrastructure Bank are challenged to proceed without private capital involved. They are large, complex projects, and attracting private capital is a critical piece of the puzzle in enabling us to advance, particularly in these times when investment is slowed and when we see the housing market slowed down in some parts of Canada because of uncertainty. I think it's really important that the mix of public and private capital right now restores confidence and gets projects built. That's what we need right now. We need job creation, and we need projects to advance and deliver for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128308","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Many of these projects that are financed by the Canada Infrastructure Bank are challenged to proceed without private capital involved. They are large, complex projects, and attracting private capital is a critical piece of the puzzle in enabling us to advance, particularly in these times when investment is slowed and when we see the housing market slowed down in some parts of Canada because of unc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b6edaae0f2a49b9498c2f09","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128309,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"My understanding is that there was nothing directly with the Infrastructure Bank or with the department.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128309","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My understanding is that there was nothing directly with the Infrastructure Bank or with the department.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a237852316f06033dc70980731123a0d4d36be0607fbec429eaacd9b9fc1ba2d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3b86cf973b159dd47089942","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128310,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"No, I'm not aware of any outreach or contact from any of the related entities right now, so I'm not sure what you're asking for. Can you clarify that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128310","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, I'm not aware of any outreach or contact from any of the related entities right now, so I'm not sure what you're asking for. Can you clarify that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65fec487d737efb285b99e63b9a2a78229ddb2871a32665379e0224ea9459310"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b63ffce020342399f5002a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128311,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"TRAN","text":"I don't know why there is a conflict of interest related to that. My office reaches out to MPs all over the country on a regular basis.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128311","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I don't know why there is a conflict of interest related to that. My office reaches out to MPs all over the country on a regular basis.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56e03c7082235a59d239f5e48c9ab33b83dafe9217b7ae6efc5654ffa6f261f8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec5415d12f5748bd80040c4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715146,"date":"2026-04-17T16:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are at the negotiating table; we are in discussions with Quebec. We are committed to working with our provincial counterparts to ensure that our communities are connected by robust and reliable public transport and active transport services.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715146","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are at the negotiating table; we are in discussions with Quebec. We are committed to working with our provincial counterparts to ensure that our communities are connected by robust and reliable public transport and active transport services.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["58f96b454d943a8934b789721f0646bbd9645573537267855e811fab5eb6b542"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56c78f04946740dc248094ada1e2983919be3fad4d2c5102e95313f42fc18b99"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2bc43849d8bea207fcea9ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715147,"date":"2026-04-17T16:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are tackling Canada's housing challenges with urgency and innovation. Build Canada Homes is already showing what is possible when we work in strong partnership with provinces, territories, local governments and community builders. We have agreements in place with many provinces. We have over 10,000 homes under way.\n\nWhat we can do now is pass the Build Canada Homes act in the House. I would urge all members, in these busy four weeks ahead, to support its swift passage so we can scale up, build Canada homes and build more affordable housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715147","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are tackling Canada's housing challenges with urgency and innovation. Build Canada Homes is already showing what is possible when we work in strong partnership with provinces, territories, local governments and community builders. We have agreements in place with many provinces. We have over 10,000 homes under way.\n\nWhat we can do now is pass the Build Canada Homes act in the House","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["48fbab4b40e2682b868e919694a289602049dd236c3279bb55572178f4f34a7c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33975a6c7240728009b1878f6531ea3312cb005273f576216288b205bc9749d5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64d33652845fb7c944c909fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715148,"date":"2026-04-17T16:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are doing a lot of work right now in B.C. to lift up people, particularly young people, with the break on new home purchases for first-time homebuyers, a GST break of up to $50,000. There is also a housing supply bonus going out to the provinces and territories to help reduce the cost of housing, which is the number one driver with affordability.\n\nWhen we look at the cost of housing, we see that we have more work to do with Build Canada Homes and many other initiatives on housing. We are delivering those in earnest.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715148","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are doing a lot of work right now in B.C. to lift up people, particularly young people, with the break on new home purchases for first-time homebuyers, a GST break of up to $50,000. There is also a housing supply bonus going out to the provinces and territories to help reduce the cost of housing, which is the number one driver with affordability.\n\nWhen we look at the cost of housin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c0024650502c7ca3167433919076865efff4302f9552157d8ef0f70cc9e39c41"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["948eed95da2eba3f5444fae8feb25617282fd0e91e3e1a099ce89ac9a803b207"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3a7e2859756a6bedd37c5c8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301466,"date":"2026-04-20T19:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have good news. Housing starts are up almost 10% across Canada year to date, so we are seeing progress in terms of housing starts. We are seeing rents decrease. We are seeing mortgages reduced. We are seeing home prices reduced. Affordability is improving for housing across Canada. It is not just a short-term change that we have to grapple with, with the uncertainty we face.\n\n Build Canada Homes is a dedicated affordable housing agency here in Canada to build for generations to come. We expect members opposite to support the bill through Parliament.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301466","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have good news. Housing starts are up almost 10% across Canada year to date, so we are seeing progress in terms of housing starts. We are seeing rents decrease. We are seeing mortgages reduced. We are seeing home prices reduced. Affordability is improving for housing across Canada. It is not just a short-term change that we have to grapple with, with the uncertainty we face.\n\n Buil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1b8bb9d77d42f8bc5113c7f0fde600017da0791a65682ecd5c69baa6960f0ee4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d93d5623e22c5a240f37fa69998175415d5014843ef9f2a33f39abdf17e4906c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-911045f41548b0a6ba72a0f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301467,"date":"2026-04-20T19:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the results speak for themselves. Affordability for housing has been improving over the last several years. The actions taken by the government are having an immediate effect. We are seeing rents come down. We are seeing home prices come down. We are seeing housing supply increase. We do have immediate-term measures to boost housing supply with provinces and territories. We are working with cities and with indigenous communities to build housing: supportive and transitional housing for people who are homeless, missing middle housing, and student housing. Across the board, we are investing.\n\nWe expect all members of the House to support affordable housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301467","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the results speak for themselves. Affordability for housing has been improving over the last several years. The actions taken by the government are having an immediate effect. We are seeing rents come down. We are seeing home prices come down. We are seeing housing supply increase. We do have immediate-term measures to boost housing supply with provinces and territories. We are workin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c5f0cfd7a7e236160b95cc7defa619996fb1cbfed3f90bbae0cf46bca1985e66"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8d985f4a8e3612752332009d46eaf9f8e32385515c70e79f34d76fb54e63ad48"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2662f19b1d4ea4d20925b64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301468,"date":"2026-04-20T20:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our government is leading a national effort to solve the housing crisis by working with cities and towns across Canada to get more housing built.\n\nIn reducing red tape, the housing accelerator fund has been very successful working with 241 communities across the country. Those communities made commitments. This government holds everyone accountable to their commitments. The integrity of those agreements is important. We are seeing great results, and Red Deer is one of the cities that is delivering housing supply. That is our goal—\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301468","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our government is leading a national effort to solve the housing crisis by working with cities and towns across Canada to get more housing built.\n\nIn reducing red tape, the housing accelerator fund has been very successful working with 241 communities across the country. Those communities made commitments. This government holds everyone accountable to their commitments. The integrity ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec3dc80f89e010e5b5d391b5698f766538ec5c54860d87099a70684a36439be5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["140dedc01275e47e0b0aa601fcd242df7bcbeef1f606b25de5f027f47d202fbf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8f87a0fb27cecd3f87a7da4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301464,"date":"2026-04-23T19:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is exciting news this morning here in Ottawa. I was proud to be at a construction site with the Prime Minister and the mayor to announce those eight shovel-ready projects. There will be over 1,100 homes. Over 90% of those are affordable homes by the Build Canada Homes' standard. This is great news. We are building at scale. We are prioritizing projects on the ground. We are building these deep partnerships, in this case at the City of Ottawa, and looking forward to continuing to build that good work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301464","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is exciting news this morning here in Ottawa. I was proud to be at a construction site with the Prime Minister and the mayor to announce those eight shovel-ready projects. There will be over 1,100 homes. Over 90% of those are affordable homes by the Build Canada Homes' standard. This is great news. We are building at scale. We are prioritizing projects on the ground. We are buil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ec2c91f147c8dcbc7d51aab684781813b673711a7cec67e06bf64981ac50742"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97146afa35cc06b7043736e73d9fb2811f9f9b7f561cd60baf72216ec1b7c73a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be18433e4a9f74bda8f320b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301465,"date":"2026-04-23T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for her concerns about public transit.\n\n The good news is that we have expanded the opportunities for funding on public transit, not only from the Canada public transit fund, which is the first permanent dedicated public transit fund in Canadian history, but also from the build communities strong fund, which is $51 billion of funding for infrastructure in communities across Canada, all of which is eligible for public transit funding.\n\nWe have grown the pot for public transit much larger. We intend to be investing aggressively, working with communities to deliver that public transit.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301465","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for her concerns about public transit.\n\n The good news is that we have expanded the opportunities for funding on public transit, not only from the Canada public transit fund, which is the first permanent dedicated public transit fund in Canadian history, but also from the build communities strong fund, which is $51 billion of funding for infrastructure in communitie","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bf208940ac256394c22b591f0a97a5d50b5e7119cc4bc36375bfcd51a3d2e704"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b60dad7dc62807db26dda50688b0a83fcfa6e545d3630968cb94555d16804af9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e48c79aef308c79db0c16c57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728680,"date":"2026-04-28T19:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I congratulate the member for University—Rosedale. Yes, we are very happy to see housing starts up 10% year to year and to see construction activity above the 10-year average, as well as seeing average rents come down for 18 consecutive months. We are seeing movement in the right direction. There is a lot more work to do.\n\nBuild Canada Homes is delivering on more social, supportive and community housing, working with non-profits, co-ops and builders across the country. We are seeing progress, and we are just getting started.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728680","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I congratulate the member for University—Rosedale. Yes, we are very happy to see housing starts up 10% year to year and to see construction activity above the 10-year average, as well as seeing average rents come down for 18 consecutive months. We are seeing movement in the right direction. There is a lot more work to do.\n\nBuild Canada Homes is delivering on more social, supportive an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca7c16ab04c4610db75b41d4adf531e39e42b7c58ed9d2ebd9fa913c20928bf4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["700233d5f585e689b3c86f0c5b1ed1c11cb3248967a265596db85de3c9bfdec3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72c48e693f9c6f09910bbd3d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728678,"date":"2026-04-29T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, while the Conservatives may be mired in the last decade or two of failure, this government is focused on the future and delivering today. \n\nThis spring update has an incredible opportunity for young Canadians. Up to 100,000 Canadians will have access to training and support to build the affordable homes and community infrastructure that this country needs to build Canada strong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728678","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, while the Conservatives may be mired in the last decade or two of failure, this government is focused on the future and delivering today. \n\nThis spring update has an incredible opportunity for young Canadians. Up to 100,000 Canadians will have access to training and support to build the affordable homes and community infrastructure that this country needs to build Canada strong.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["74dd5b25f3563a4b68580f55210bfc644413054f682a04b6b71cc5808625bdd8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe9b4df4fe558ba61bf00222","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728679,"date":"2026-04-29T19:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, once again, Conservatives are attacking former mayors like they attack current mayors. They have no respect. For leaders of our cities and towns, leaders of our provinces and territories, leaders of our indigenous communities, they have zero respect. In my first seven years as a mayor in Vancouver, how much support did we get from the Harper Conservative government? Zero. \n\nThis government is focused on partnering with cities, towns and indigenous communities and delivering the affordable housing we need.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728679","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, once again, Conservatives are attacking former mayors like they attack current mayors. They have no respect. For leaders of our cities and towns, leaders of our provinces and territories, leaders of our indigenous communities, they have zero respect. In my first seven years as a mayor in Vancouver, how much support did we get from the Harper Conservative government? Zero. \n\nThis gover","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d1ec3fd99f50772a53cca4329ead002a4896aabd8bed71e7d8bb1704b6ac244"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f686ae0e53cbc1dd3314f128e8062423670a0fd00fc09ba154c646dd6f5c041"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-231f8e8f508fcd0a3398c5d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728675,"date":"2026-04-30T19:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our spring economic update is making very smart investments and making life more affordable for Canadians. The opposition does not seem to ever want to talk about affordable housing and the success that we are having, bringing rents down for 18 months in a row.\n\nIn this update, we can see up to 100,000 Canadian workers who are going to help build affordable housing for decades to come. We are going to make sure life is more affordable, especially for young Canadians looking for that first-time homebuyers' tax break and the ability to have a career building homes for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728675","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our spring economic update is making very smart investments and making life more affordable for Canadians. The opposition does not seem to ever want to talk about affordable housing and the success that we are having, bringing rents down for 18 months in a row.\n\nIn this update, we can see up to 100,000 Canadian workers who are going to help build affordable housing for decades to come","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c27226307519a443944b551a6af774b8af7e04b284c12351bd91fab33dcc7353"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c1f5cf4fb899e96ff2969d7ed3e2ea5d9c07ce9ce62a2929a18d1107310ee0af"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0499ccac3678c36989d2bcb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960993,"date":"2026-05-07T19:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I had the honour of being at the BCIT, the B.C. Institute of Technology, earlier this week to talk about 100,000 jobs for young Canadians to build homes and infrastructure. The members opposite have an opportunity to support the spring economic update, which would dedicate $6 billion to training young Canadians to be part of our economy and to build the affordable housing that we need to house young Canadians. It is a great opportunity for us to build Canada strong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960993","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I had the honour of being at the BCIT, the B.C. Institute of Technology, earlier this week to talk about 100,000 jobs for young Canadians to build homes and infrastructure. The members opposite have an opportunity to support the spring economic update, which would dedicate $6 billion to training young Canadians to be part of our economy and to build the affordable housing that we need","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b63e731f87e2daedd7ddabd9d96f0a2cdcaea8cde4d828094af960e697c5eb02"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-127efe258629adb76cc233e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036357,"date":"2026-05-25T19:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is shameful to continue to hear members of the opposition fearmongering about private property rights. We, on this side of the House, stand for private property rights. We stand for reconciliation. We have appealed the case alongside the B.C. government, the government of the City of Richmond and first nations. We will continue to be there for private property owners and to work for reconciliation. The fearmongering has to stop.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036357","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is shameful to continue to hear members of the opposition fearmongering about private property rights. We, on this side of the House, stand for private property rights. We stand for reconciliation. We have appealed the case alongside the B.C. government, the government of the City of Richmond and first nations. We will continue to be there for private property owners and to work fo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b73ce5da5aeacb16490d6f78b1c98a0374cde4c7fa0200e9054ce4cf26dc5fd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d2813459645c70f51e01e3e172c94a8631703b931bc10aed146e4957f9a53b5d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6cfb3c9202daeb5e7bc35bc0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128211,"date":"2026-05-25T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee members, for the invitation to speak here today about the 2026-27 main estimates for the Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada portfolio. I am happy to be here to provide an overview and to cover the progress we've been making in building complete, connected and resilient communities. That is our mission. I'm joined today, as the chair mentioned, by Paul Halucha, our deputy minister, and Michelle Baron, our assistant deputy minister and CFO. I'll dive right in to talking about HICC, Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada, its partners and how we work closely together to invest in the critical infrastructure that makes a real difference in communities big and small. Together, we take action to build stronger communities, with good neighbourhoods and the homes that people can afford. For the 2026‐27 main estimates, HICC is seeking just over $17 billion in funding, representing a net increase of $9,076 compared to the previous year's main estimates. This increase for 2026‐27 is primarily influenced by the continued delivery of the investing in Canada infrastructure program and the Canada public transit fund. These two programs are providing long-term, stable federal investments that build connected communities, support economic growth and create good jobs. While the Canada public transit fund, CPTF, and the investing in Canada infrastructure program, ICIP, continue to advance, it's also important that we look ahead and highlight the progress we are making to support community infrastructure, invest in major projects and improve housing affordability. Through the new $51-billion build communities strong fund, the department is making generational investments that will modernize Canada's infrastructure and will unlock housing supply and support economic growth. This includes funding for housing-enabling infrastructure, health infrastructure and infrastructure at colleges and universities. We are moving quickly. In March, we announced the Canada-Ontario partnership to build, which will reduce development charges and increase housing affordability. Just last week, I announced a comprehensive agreement to deliver approximately—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128211","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee members, for the invitation to speak here today about the 2026-27 main estimates for the Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada portfolio. I am happy to be here to provide an overview and to cover the progress we've been making in building complete, connected and resilient communities. That is our mission. I'm joined today, as the chair mentioned, by Paul","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["376f65212848a572de7e1a3c3311d331a1af4934578f7a0dd37b295f9a4c8795"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2dab3ad1f2a6c26aeb2a33986eff78f4b57b591c61e6fd112ac17b641f3120a9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12db723ecbf9cd72a5913d4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128212,"date":"2026-05-25T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thanks, Mr. Chair. I'll dive back in and recount an announcement, made last week with Yukon, that will deliver approximately $350 million in housing and infrastructure investments under the build communities strong fund and with Build Canada Homes, in partnership with the Yukon territorial government. We're making good progress, but there's certainly lots more to come. HICC is also taking a leadership role to support the most vulnerable Canadians through Reaching Home, the veteran homelessness program and the unsheltered homelessness and encampments initiative. Our government is providing targeted funding to support the reduction and prevention of homelessness. In September 2025, Build Canada Homes was created to build more homes across our country and to build more affordable homes faster. Since its launch, Build Canada Homes has moved quickly to get housing projects off the ground. It has already advanced six direct-build projects in Dartmouth, Longueuil, Ottawa, Toronto, Winnipeg and Edmonton, with commitments to get shovels in the ground this year. In addition, there are now six major partnerships already secured with provincial and community partners. We're just getting rolling. There's a lot more to come. CMHC and the Canada Infrastructure Bank are important partners that will continue to play a vital role in building Canada strong. Looking forward, CMHC will focus on its core role as Canada's primary market-oriented housing finance institution, emphasizing its responsibilities for mortgage loan insurance, securitization and rental construction financing to support housing supply. There's been big uptake of the apartment construction loan program, which is building record levels of rental housing across the country. The Canada Infrastructure Bank will continue to play a central role in advancing our infrastructure agenda as it accelerates investments in high-impact projects that align with national priorities. The main estimates before you today will support the housing, infrastructure and communities portfolio in delivering on our ambitious commitments to Canadians—commitments that help grow our economy, and support Canadian workers, jobs and industries. All members of this committee know that, in this critical moment in our country's history, now is the time to invest in ourselves, to strengthen ourselves and to build ourselves up. We are taking action to increase housing affordability and to build generational infrastructure and strong communities today and into the future. Thank you, and I look forward to answering any questions you may have.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128212","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thanks, Mr. Chair. I'll dive back in and recount an announcement, made last week with Yukon, that will deliver approximately $350 million in housing and infrastructure investments under the build communities strong fund and with Build Canada Homes, in partnership with the Yukon territorial government. We're making good progress, but there's certainly lots more to come. HICC is also taking a leader","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0980820bf297a1179ecb7e26e79cf41cec1a80ac4c15a86c1244b675d4b5c705"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["971a2fa0d38c6894c275bd1cc8a8e808cd581a36143865dc2ec21b4c50eac2b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-294b8d78b9ed9e39f1afd085","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128213,"date":"2026-05-25T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Through the chair, the allocation to Build Canada Homes in budget 2025 was $13 billion, and a small fraction of that has been invested in the start-up and administration of Build Canada Homes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128213","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Through the chair, the allocation to Build Canada Homes in budget 2025 was $13 billion, and a small fraction of that has been invested in the start-up and administration of Build Canada Homes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05f066c278e797e638b0bd11e915b111d9a845db1a9cab3061077e55ec299384"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f67a91e7230f94868425b428","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128214,"date":"2026-05-25T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"I don't have it at hand. I could ask my deputy minister if he has those figures.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128214","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I don't have it at hand. I could ask my deputy minister if he has those figures.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["115a76413aeed8cdd26cffb382eb1433b48c9c14526fac55441f11910e97313e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0732b7f674ed90277ba427f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128215,"date":"2026-05-25T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Yes, that's correct.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128215","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes, that's correct.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28c4d2bd9e387b7d64f7a57c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128216,"date":"2026-05-25T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"As the deputy minister mentioned, there have been some smaller administrative costs with respect to restructuring, but the whole purpose is around efficiency. Build Canada Homes is the agency for affordable housing in Canada. The affordable housing activity, the housing activity in Canada Lands Company and the affordable housing activity in CMHC are all being consolidated in one agency that can focus and specialize in these; therefore, the responsibilities of CMHC and CLC are reduced.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128216","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As the deputy minister mentioned, there have been some smaller administrative costs with respect to restructuring, but the whole purpose is around efficiency. Build Canada Homes is the agency for affordable housing in Canada. The affordable housing activity, the housing activity in Canada Lands Company and the affordable housing activity in CMHC are all being consolidated in one agency that can fo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ee773606e7e464eef5e62aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128217,"date":"2026-05-25T21:05:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Well, there are a few factors in terms of giving a GST break. The market challenges in Toronto and Vancouver have been very significant, with pre-sales evaporating and many of the builders having real challenges—their equity stuck in projects and homes that were not selling. The market is clearly affected by global uncertainty right now. People are choosing, particularly in those markets, not to buy homes, and new homes in particular. We started with the first-time homebuyer break on GST. That didn't move the needle enough to make a difference with the supply that was sitting on the market in Vancouver and Toronto in particular. At that point, we went to the next level of offering a time-limited reduction in GST. In Ontario's case, they offered their provincial sales tax, so the HST is reduced across the board.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128217","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, there are a few factors in terms of giving a GST break. The market challenges in Toronto and Vancouver have been very significant, with pre-sales evaporating and many of the builders having real challenges—their equity stuck in projects and homes that were not selling. The market is clearly affected by global uncertainty right now. People are choosing, particularly in those markets, not to b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083623","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Sales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083623","label":"Sales","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f33321b9a909da73da730e37c9204859c16e5cffa1ef02c2768ffaeebe592a01"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af8c34f5f7ed5a8a8cbcb22d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128218,"date":"2026-05-25T21:05:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Before Parliament is a housing supply act that is offering funding to all provinces to apply toward increasing housing supply. Some provinces will choose different routes to use that funding. Ontario is choosing to go forward with that HST reduction. We are working with the Province of B.C. right now on a number of fronts, including reducing the development charges as part of the infrastructure funding with the build communities strong fund. They have access to housing supply funding as well. It is hoped that there will be a reduction in taxes for homebuyers in B.C. as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128218","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Before Parliament is a housing supply act that is offering funding to all provinces to apply toward increasing housing supply. Some provinces will choose different routes to use that funding. Ontario is choosing to go forward with that HST reduction. We are working with the Province of B.C. right now on a number of fronts, including reducing the development charges as part of the infrastructure fu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f88378dd2965e0d8a8a333ae57bdf7b76d73d23162d12fc26e99a78f54bfdfd5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5694e473d3dd63dfad32b1abf5d1f9f3d55c2ef6e9e88a1a8cfa86c51532ce6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dcccf09aab31aec4532cc163","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128219,"date":"2026-05-25T21:05:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you for your question. I'm going to answer in English. First and foremost, we have dedicated $1 billion of the $13 billion in budget 2025 for Build Canada Homes to supportive and transitional housing. That is the most tried and tested approach to tackling homelessness. We have a couple of thousand homes now in development with Build Canada Homes that will be supportive and transitional housing. We have an agreement on that front already between the Province of Quebec and Build Canada Homes to build hundreds of supportive and transitional homes in Quebec. I expect many more are coming, particularly focused in Montreal and Quebec City, where the mayors have been very vocal about the challenge and the need to invest in supportive and transitional housing. We have Reaching Home. That is the overall program in the national housing strategy that delivers support for people who are homeless or at risk of homelessness. Nearly 112,000 Canadians have found stable housing through Reaching Home in the last few years. Prevention services have supported over 200,000 Canadians, and we need to keep that work going. Reaching Home is coming to the conclusion of its work in 2028. We are going into an engagement this summer to talk about how we continue with Reaching Home. The unsheltered homelessness and encampments initiative was funded for an additional year, so it won't expire at the end of March. We've continued that, and we're working with the Government of Quebec to make sure that it will continue for two years with their partnership. We're looking at really scaling up the work, because homelessness has gotten worse. It continues to be a real challenge right across the country. We need to continue scaling up our work, investing in the housing that solves the challenge and making sure that the provinces are doing their part in funding the health supports and wraparound supports with supportive housing that are essential to enable people to be stable. We need to make sure that the cities are doing their part too. All of the partners need to come to the table, and we certainly know we have a big responsibility with that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128219","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for your question. I'm going to answer in English. First and foremost, we have dedicated $1 billion of the $13 billion in budget 2025 for Build Canada Homes to supportive and transitional housing. That is the most tried and tested approach to tackling homelessness. We have a couple of thousand homes now in development with Build Canada Homes that will be supportive and transitional housi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["91397eb316c9b14582cd813ad088400de0d5a4ea6122946fcee255c58b6d3c9c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cfeb32974669100177f3b29c61b9f75334c5d35ed4d5c796f2033e888a80d0e2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0998478b342e95d442e35426","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128220,"date":"2026-05-25T21:10:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you for your question. We are seeing homelessness counts continue to go up in some communities. We're also seeing some levelling off, finally, after many years of growth in the point-in-time counts. We are seeing that the growth is reduced, but it continues to be an unacceptable problem that we have to solve. There's a lot of data being gathered with point-in-time counts, and there's a fantastic complement of people working to solve homelessness across Canada right now. Many volunteers are working on this. That's why all levels of government need to double down on investing in and supporting the community of people who are looking into homelessness. The Reaching Home program is essential to our work going forward in making sure that we're doing our part as the Government of Canada. Again, I'll speak to the importance of supportive and transitional housing. We need to make sure that we're building the homes that actually solve homelessness. Until we build a supply of housing that works for people who are at risk of living rough or are living rough, we won't have anywhere for them to go outside of shelters. It's important to have the whole continuum but, in particular, to invest in long-term solutions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128220","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for your question. We are seeing homelessness counts continue to go up in some communities. We're also seeing some levelling off, finally, after many years of growth in the point-in-time counts. We are seeing that the growth is reduced, but it continues to be an unacceptable problem that we have to solve. There's a lot of data being gathered with point-in-time counts, and there's a fanta","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0dccb4543d829353f416338b2b3393ab855be2ff513cf235d54665f981c1c2b6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9e3d8a393cb01750e044f176b8f9cd0f32419860bd42a33e34ad44c9fc5e2378"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0faf6f595ab04cc9de79b846","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128221,"date":"2026-05-25T21:15:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you for your question. With renewal of Reaching Home, it will be important for organizations to see that longer-term commitment. The challenge we have right now is that the national housing strategy is in its final stage. Reaching Home is part of that, and there is concern from some organizations about what happens going forward. As long as I'm minister, I want to see that investment continue and increase in order to tackle homelessness. The problem continues to be very challenging across the country. We'd be interested in hearing from your communities to know exactly what support is needed to make more progress. I'd be happy to hear from you on the organizations, specifically, and the communities that need the support. That's something we can continue to work on together. It has to be tackled on the ground in every community. I certainly know that from my background as a mayor. The support needs to come from a federal level. However, with regard to how best to solve it on the ground within communities, we need that local knowledge and leadership as well. I look forward to hearing from you on how we can best work with your communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128221","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for your question. With renewal of Reaching Home, it will be important for organizations to see that longer-term commitment. The challenge we have right now is that the national housing strategy is in its final stage. Reaching Home is part of that, and there is concern from some organizations about what happens going forward. As long as I'm minister, I want to see that investment continu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["498a566e44c50c262d95241c9d1226d7c4dc7da1a703c250462bb56866e550fb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56dfda79c617315afea4d855f61a7ac4e2eb9166590e5a7a7ee3e9b494025ea4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d57a6e9f764518ed93411e4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128222,"date":"2026-05-25T21:15:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you for your question. There are several different streams here. Build Canada Homes is the new affordable housing agency. We do have an agreement with Quebec right now, through Build Canada Homes, that will soon be followed by a second phase. I'm anticipating that there will be several thousand affordable homes delivered through Build Canada Homes in the deeply affordable category. For supportive and transitional housing, we have about 500 of those homes coming initially, in the short term. I expect several thousand more homes to be delivered in Quebec as affordable housing through Build Canada Homes as well. Those won't be completed this year, but those are in the works now, in partnership with Quebec. We always work with Quebec, as Quebec is the lead. We make the funding available, and Quebec can direct the funding to the organizations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128222","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for your question. There are several different streams here. Build Canada Homes is the new affordable housing agency. We do have an agreement with Quebec right now, through Build Canada Homes, that will soon be followed by a second phase. I'm anticipating that there will be several thousand affordable homes delivered through Build Canada Homes in the deeply affordable category. For suppo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["82354d8e8f003ee51066251b540600190f8403280f945eea12a95c640a12208f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["279afc3699d470899e43faa982b3cbe1747cc64b6efd2b1079041f62c216b430"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0961e45f9e7d41595da37e99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128223,"date":"2026-05-25T21:15:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"We are seeing average rents declining across the country, which comes as a big relief after many years of rents escalating—decades, in fact. In the last two years, we've seen average rents decline across Canada. They are still too high, so building that affordable rental supply is critical right now. I didn't mention in my last response that the CMHC is also funding an apartment construction loan program for rental housing. I anticipate with Quebec that there will be thousands of rental homes financed through the CMHC in the period ahead. The combination of non-market, deeply affordable housing from Build Canada Homes—that's all rental housing—and the rental housing through the CMHC is a big boost in new supply to help keep driving those rents down. We have to continue increasing the supply to make sure that the rents continue to go down.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128223","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We are seeing average rents declining across the country, which comes as a big relief after many years of rents escalating—decades, in fact. In the last two years, we've seen average rents decline across Canada. They are still too high, so building that affordable rental supply is critical right now. I didn't mention in my last response that the CMHC is also funding an apartment construction loan ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae64b312772f7de29dafeac8b63a1ee4a52e34e4f616502100a9e06bd5a37c9e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-991b1394af432b65d63fd089","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128224,"date":"2026-05-25T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"We're seeing enormous interest in Build Canada Homes from the private sector and community builders. I mentioned that we have six agreements with provinces, territories and the City of Ottawa to build thousands of homes. We're at well over 10,000 homes that have been announced and are in the process of being built.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128224","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We're seeing enormous interest in Build Canada Homes from the private sector and community builders. I mentioned that we have six agreements with provinces, territories and the City of Ottawa to build thousands of homes. We're at well over 10,000 homes that have been announced and are in the process of being built.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["79d5fdba4d6c6c94e75a2df1215b753f72f4585765922e4614f8f0b1d8c350a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1d9e1f3b0f0f90a0a619699d1050691ed4656153fcf0075aa2f746e1600d7984"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e022aa4075139245aaf4734a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128225,"date":"2026-05-25T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"The last update I had, earlier this month, was that over 1,000 submissions have come in to Build Canada Homes. They are in the process of working through those, getting back to project proponents and working with them to figure out the details and how financing can help get those projects built. There's huge interest. There's a lot more interest than there is capital that's available in budget 2025.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128225","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The last update I had, earlier this month, was that over 1,000 submissions have come in to Build Canada Homes. They are in the process of working through those, getting back to project proponents and working with them to figure out the details and how financing can help get those projects built. There's huge interest. There's a lot more interest than there is capital that's available in budget 202","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-acc3811d2f109b147df581f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128226,"date":"2026-05-25T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"As I said, over 10,000 have been approved. I think over 12,000 approved was my last update, some days ago. We're climbing up that approval ladder very quickly now. About half the provinces and territories are part of the initial phases of approvals.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128226","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As I said, over 10,000 have been approved. I think over 12,000 approved was my last update, some days ago. We're climbing up that approval ladder very quickly now. About half the provinces and territories are part of the initial phases of approvals.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72484c021694e6e1d15ad0b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128227,"date":"2026-05-25T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"There's no hard and fast time, but the whole purpose is to have certainty for builders as soon as possible. There is now a real push to make sure that there's direct communication with all the proponents that have brought proposals forward to give them an initial sense of what else is needed or what's missing from their package. To be fair, this is a new model, having proposals coming forward to Build Canada Homes. Some do not have modern methods of construction involved. Some do not have enough affordability built into them or they're not shovel-ready. Those are three factors that Build Canada Homes is very focused on: getting building as soon as possible, more affordably and with modern methods of construction. There's a back-and-forth between Build Canada Homes and proponents that's really accelerating right now as the organization builds up.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128227","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There's no hard and fast time, but the whole purpose is to have certainty for builders as soon as possible. There is now a real push to make sure that there's direct communication with all the proponents that have brought proposals forward to give them an initial sense of what else is needed or what's missing from their package. To be fair, this is a new model, having proposals coming forward to B","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f545ab6a086b7e7d8e6415203d8ac42c63535b5ff3c39b0291a33fa8b64b573a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["129c4755d41d5dd72d1f363b7ff9b7218d2a102453f05ea9fc2a5e02dac0854c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e3d5daa93f0c0d1f597f680","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128228,"date":"2026-05-25T21:20:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"I appreciate the question. There's a wide range of modern methods. Build Canada Homes is not being prescriptive about that. There's a full range, from entire modular homes—volumetric modular that is manufactured in a factory—right to panel construction. Panel construction makes up the majority of modern methods right now. Those are wall panels and floor panels manufactured in a factory, flat-packed on a truck, shipped to site and assembled with a crane. I would say that is the predominant model of modern methods. There are also kitchen and bath pods that are completed in a factory and then dropped, with a crane, into a building or a home. Many different components can be manufactured off-site and more rapidly assembled on-site to make the build more efficient—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128228","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate the question. There's a wide range of modern methods. Build Canada Homes is not being prescriptive about that. There's a full range, from entire modular homes—volumetric modular that is manufactured in a factory—right to panel construction. Panel construction makes up the majority of modern methods right now. Those are wall panels and floor panels manufactured in a factory, flat-packe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","label":"Industrial buildings","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["195270dcd7ae071464998f14df6d198e8deb46ce14dd71a2f294f3155bb21ca9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e1efb1ff908b4be84590cbe63d5a6c3257791b9f4da4e51604d5e77d3ce42e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-443c71d2dea581e1d330788b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128229,"date":"2026-05-25T21:25:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"I agree with you there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128229","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I agree with you there.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5314f661a8101eff97ebfb5d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128230,"date":"2026-05-25T21:25:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thanks for the question. We've embarked on deploying the capital allocated in budget 2025, the $13 billion, as effectively and productively as humanly possible. Without knowing exactly what industry would bring forward, what the private sector would bring forward, and what the provinces and cities—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128230","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thanks for the question. We've embarked on deploying the capital allocated in budget 2025, the $13 billion, as effectively and productively as humanly possible. Without knowing exactly what industry would bring forward, what the private sector would bring forward, and what the provinces and cities—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e0f11de2dfe7a42a54b0bff5c428b97e2dd091cbff601c4c077269a6ec1e237"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aead7410aea9ada68676c975","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128231,"date":"2026-05-25T21:25:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"We're measuring as we go. Over this first year, we'll have a really good sense of how much it's costing per square foot and per unit of housing. We'll have a better sense of how much capital we've leveraged from the private sector. From that point, we can start setting targets for what our expectations are, going forward, based on the investment we're seeing from other levels of government and the private sector.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128231","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We're measuring as we go. Over this first year, we'll have a really good sense of how much it's costing per square foot and per unit of housing. We'll have a better sense of how much capital we've leveraged from the private sector. From that point, we can start setting targets for what our expectations are, going forward, based on the investment we're seeing from other levels of government and the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7097929dddf773e810933da0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128232,"date":"2026-05-25T21:25:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you for your question. For infrastructure, there are two pieces of news. We were able to achieve a memorandum of understanding with the Government of Quebec to guide our collaboration on housing and infrastructure. We have a collaboration table with the two governments working together to fund affordable housing projects and making sure we're aligned with our priorities. There is good coordination among the government, the local governments and all the community partners. Infrastructure and housing run together, as you know. As a former mayor, I know you don't build the housing without the infrastructure. Recognizing that we needed to speed up on the infrastructure side, we announced the signing of the agreement for the Canada housing infrastructure fund—$1 billion that the federal government will invest in Quebec to modernize and build essential housing infrastructure to scale up the work on housing projects. That's the housing infrastructure fund. The next generation is the build communities strong fund. We are in very good negotiations with Quebec right now and hoping to share good news very soon. That will lay the groundwork for more infrastructure funding connected to housing. At the same time, we're doing housing and infrastructure agreements and looking forward to the extension of these new agreements with the build communities strong fund and Build Canada Homes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128232","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for your question. For infrastructure, there are two pieces of news. We were able to achieve a memorandum of understanding with the Government of Quebec to guide our collaboration on housing and infrastructure. We have a collaboration table with the two governments working together to fund affordable housing projects and making sure we're aligned with our priorities. There is good coordi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["678f27644d234168766409ee968de8554a8051d5dcc2c3ac3c49cb28b1ac0d14"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e5830eebabba5e710159b7d3f7584d2ab43ed64ee677a6f04c2701ee4f04b592"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1f1a01b38f681699d4e2e1b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128233,"date":"2026-05-25T21:30:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you for your question. The apartment construction loan program is through CMHC, the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation. It is a loan program for rental housing, specifically. It's very successful across the country, with, effectively, tens of billions of dollars invested in rental housing. As you said, it's been helpful in driving average rents down—having all this new rental housing built. We did not build enough rental housing for a generation or more. I can get you an update on the stats. I don't know, Paul, if you have any updated stats on what the ACLP is delivering right now in Quebec. We can follow up with that information so you can know this specifically for your riding and province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128233","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for your question. The apartment construction loan program is through CMHC, the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation. It is a loan program for rental housing, specifically. It's very successful across the country, with, effectively, tens of billions of dollars invested in rental housing. As you said, it's been helpful in driving average rents down—having all this new rental housing bu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da540269ce557b6e3f9ed4b466ae8bf03bffbee4eb3dcf1e9bd3379ab70f724b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1bfd56518ab046c4b55f9e08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128234,"date":"2026-05-25T21:30:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you for your question. We now have agreements in place with Quebec, as I just mentioned, on housing infrastructure funding that flows through Quebec and with Build Canada Homes. In both cases, we work collaboratively with Quebec. The funding is transferred very directly. Basically, the collaboration table works together to decide on the projects to invest in. We, as the federal government, can bring forward our suggestions based on what we hear from mayors and local governments. It's the same thing with Quebec. They bring forward projects based on what they're hearing from local governments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128234","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for your question. We now have agreements in place with Quebec, as I just mentioned, on housing infrastructure funding that flows through Quebec and with Build Canada Homes. In both cases, we work collaboratively with Quebec. The funding is transferred very directly. Basically, the collaboration table works together to decide on the projects to invest in. We, as the federal government, c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0b02a4bafee5737b9a5fd4a3ec741fea01ec1f676c29b83e32a8fe03bef97b90"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["281a800683b21ce73ae6a0558ef90d9f355f04f4c8256f96eac0e60446b8e695"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c7ef7ddfa19b786870ad8ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128235,"date":"2026-05-25T21:30:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you for your question. We have a huge focus on community housing through Build Canada Homes. Right now, I think, the majority of the proposals coming through to Build Canada Homes are from community builders. There's been an enormous increase in the capacity of community builders across the country. We are certainly seeing that in Quebec. When I was in Quebec a few weeks ago, announcing projects from the agreement with Quebec, several of those projects locally were going to be delivered by community builders. Several were also targeted for vulnerable populations and seniors. It is definitely at the core of the work that Build Canada Homes is doing. There's alignment between Canada and Quebec on making sure that we focus on that deeper affordability and the most vulnerable people we can support with housing projects. In many cases, these projects have been delayed. Maybe in the past there was too much risk, but Build Canada Homes is focusing on delivering those.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128235","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for your question. We have a huge focus on community housing through Build Canada Homes. Right now, I think, the majority of the proposals coming through to Build Canada Homes are from community builders. There's been an enormous increase in the capacity of community builders across the country. We are certainly seeing that in Quebec. When I was in Quebec a few weeks ago, announcing proj","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b45f48b15727ab0736c379c9fdb2af6231fe12344786dba4bb8a009c03f7c719"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["00b9ce087459360264213f164ab7107412dc7f9a49ad5c3af35d617591bfcf38"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17644fc93bafd00445c697e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128236,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Through the chair, first and foremost, I do believe that housing is a human right, and here in Canada, private property has been protected for generations. This topic has come up a lot in recent months.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128236","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Through the chair, first and foremost, I do believe that housing is a human right, and here in Canada, private property has been protected for generations. This topic has come up a lot in recent months.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87170","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Epidemics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87170","label":"Epidemics","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb4b3bacf56b1ae574731ac1f572ff44ce9af3d1a565901b4f0b506062351636"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["38e39ed4f092216c68b5d688e3c89788a65674670c7383039dade87cb1dc4cd2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-778fe4615a35bdf69cc0e9b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128237,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"I think we've seen no challenge to private property as a result of aboriginal rights and title to date, and there's been a lot of fearmongering lately that is saying there is a problem—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128237","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I think we've seen no challenge to private property as a result of aboriginal rights and title to date, and there's been a lot of fearmongering lately that is saying there is a problem—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["995ae751268fe67fa276e12a17ef66a9706145e8299ed41b6e9c5d9522ff974f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["725d0a4c1f8acf5ad0e085bc17d244451601a76854b34ff01f912a20e0148da3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8017dd2244296d312289a96","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128238,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"They have coexisted to date here in Canada without issue in recent generations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128238","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"They have coexisted to date here in Canada without issue in recent generations.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083649","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Non-Status Indians","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083649","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Non-Status Indians","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083649","label":"Non-Status Indians","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a4bfc1af3587383270b6d0fb5745d38d24c0859b02a34406e92626d2dec7bca8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f841e3752257ed6715889e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128239,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Through the chair, I am not appealing the Cowichan decision personally. The Government of Canada is appealing, alongside the Province of B.C., the City of Richmond and several first nations—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128239","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Through the chair, I am not appealing the Cowichan decision personally. The Government of Canada is appealing, alongside the Province of B.C., the City of Richmond and several first nations—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["315f7ea1b35ad4a0fc67237d5d1be910050998fd2e1153e04852b09db71148ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e73cf5ae258881ceec2ed096","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128240,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"—because of the decision that was made.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128240","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"—because of the decision that was made.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c03d483079b58429e610437","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128241,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Through the chair, to be very clear, I'm here to talk about the budget estimates for the housing, infrastructure and communities department—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128241","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Through the chair, to be very clear, I'm here to talk about the budget estimates for the housing, infrastructure and communities department—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce26e5acddba6317311292a2f2c2e57bd3c6a44b1bed519ddbf74a9da3223db8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e844a0d8b0486921d79431e9c9880505ed09a6ef3232b4f1f4d27e865116fa69"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-337b5c870fdb1354143b3c5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128242,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"—and you're talking about a legal question, which should be addressed to the Minister of Justice , first and foremost, as Canada's authority on this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128242","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"—and you're talking about a legal question, which should be addressed to the Minister of Justice , first and foremost, as Canada's authority on this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d2cc66ba2c868b9fdb222cf408669ed66e24ece16da996f180419c772dcd22b0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f030647f5c11d5df5cf11d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128243,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Through the chair, I think the uncertainty is being whipped up by some of the members around this committee table and their party—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128243","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Through the chair, I think the uncertainty is being whipped up by some of the members around this committee table and their party—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5a815dc03486622531f187d63067c47e802cc40bbe257ec1d0066ccc25526cc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a71f62ab83b3b3814cb58f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128244,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"I think it is unjustified, given that there has been no conflict to date with respect to private property created by agreements with indigenous nations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128244","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I think it is unjustified, given that there has been no conflict to date with respect to private property created by agreements with indigenous nations.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2afa50e65c82c0a269c84985c45395f13ef364aa683b0ebbd1d26aa7793399ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2582508d647cf3887af3bc96","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128245,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Again, through the chair, I am not appealing the Cowichan decision—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128245","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Again, through the chair, I am not appealing the Cowichan decision—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4fa6075fe00115b286022cef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128246,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"The Government of Canada is appealing. You can ask the Minister of Justice if you want the rationale. It is well documented in the courts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128246","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Government of Canada is appealing. You can ask the Minister of Justice if you want the rationale. It is well documented in the courts.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["861da9a24fa184e47a65d12f8b724c7dd76a669f28db96441436a25da18376ac"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e2ba151560a536357eb633c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128247,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Through the chair, we're here to talk about budget estimates for my Department of Housing and Infrastructure—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128247","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Through the chair, we're here to talk about budget estimates for my Department of Housing and Infrastructure—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f51b263fc275d4115cd1bdfbd454a9c591997107078ff137f8e8b0cb99923a15"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-302c80fdf3a171f999e154d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128248,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"—and I think what is beneficial for all Canadians is clarity on the decision that was made by the B.C. Supreme Court. That is what is being sought in terms of the appeal—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128248","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"—and I think what is beneficial for all Canadians is clarity on the decision that was made by the B.C. Supreme Court. That is what is being sought in terms of the appeal—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7fb9eab160111b732e3b8b465d646e17d4b2fef426343bb55f8d471abc1629c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f65dbc58abb68bcd3dc304c34deba31858b87337add1a30add986ece1191a7c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d8c8021747eabbe550e1ca4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128249,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"—rather than misinformation and fearmongering, which is very—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128249","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"—rather than misinformation and fearmongering, which is very—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9d69a1b1d8a4d8e1d3836dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128250,"date":"2026-05-25T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"It's my understanding that the Musqueam agreement has nothing to do with rights and title, and it certainly has nothing to do with housing and infrastructure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128250","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's my understanding that the Musqueam agreement has nothing to do with rights and title, and it certainly has nothing to do with housing and infrastructure.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b26586971dcf3cbd26cdc610473bb6401dab7c151850c23076950442583d7bef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b13072216e2f6ea544a29fd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128251,"date":"2026-05-25T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"As stated by the Minister of Justice , the reason the Government of Canada is appealing is to get clarity with respect to the B.C. Supreme Court ruling. The government disagrees with the ruling. I will say that many of us disagree with the uncertainty being whipped up by the member and some of his colleagues, who are trying to turn this into a very difficult situation, when we need clarity from the courts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128251","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As stated by the Minister of Justice , the reason the Government of Canada is appealing is to get clarity with respect to the B.C. Supreme Court ruling. The government disagrees with the ruling. I will say that many of us disagree with the uncertainty being whipped up by the member and some of his colleagues, who are trying to turn this into a very difficult situation, when we need clarity from th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75b0e2639b56345d38dfff42523cd05a6b19cc57b109f6f7e5c5d60d041c4150"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f033cb9ea26d58c0814f696962fc85495daa8d1bda6d4261085af70744adb81e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47602ab189a59ed499b2ce67","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128252,"date":"2026-05-25T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Which issue? On homelessness specifically, Reaching Home is our primary activity around tackling and preventing homelessness. Reaching Home has a number of different elements. The unsheltered homelessness and encampments initiative is a component that has been renewed for this year. It is focused on solutions related to encampments and getting people into shelters and housing. Reaching Home has a number of prevention-related supports, and 200,000 people have been supported by Reaching Home so that they don't become homeless. This program has housed 110,000-plus people. This works through organizations at the community level. It works with the provinces, territories and cities in an integrated way. Ultimately, community organizations are delivering support for those trying to find housing or those needing support on the street, literally. Outreach workers are supported by this, in many cases, in different communities. The solution side—and I spoke to this earlier—is about supportive and transitional housing. We have an initial $1 billion at Build Canada Homes. As part of this work, we have several thousand homes being built in communities across the country, and we want to see many more. We are relying on the provinces to step up with the health funding and the wraparound supports needed to stabilize people in supportive and transitional housing. This is a piece we do in partnership with the provinces. We're pushing hard for more of those partnerships to get more housing built as soon as possible and to get people living in it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128252","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Which issue? On homelessness specifically, Reaching Home is our primary activity around tackling and preventing homelessness. Reaching Home has a number of different elements. The unsheltered homelessness and encampments initiative is a component that has been renewed for this year. It is focused on solutions related to encampments and getting people into shelters and housing. Reaching Home has a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2601b458a5ffd5bb19d5ebb1f45252856620c8cdd7eb76d40f7410b97876eaa0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e86f9b90eb247f9999cba1ff2b741db5071ca375c21790d0112f8bf1ea12568e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e598d4dbe8db95939c68b85d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128253,"date":"2026-05-25T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"As the national housing strategy approaches its closure, we're talking about its renewal this summer. We want to be ahead of the curve to make sure everyone working on delivering housing solutions and supporting work on homelessness.... We want to make sure we send a signal early about how these programs are continuing and how they're scaling up, wherever we are able to do that. We will be meeting with all partners involved—basically, the levels of government and the community organizations working on the ground—to deliver that support. This is for Reaching Home in particular, but it is also for the other programs that are part of the national housing strategy. We want to make sure we're learning from the past decade, almost, of work. We're making the best decisions going forward and taking into account the current challenges in the housing market. Things have changed over the years. At the centre of this, now, we have Build Canada Homes as an agency dedicated to affordable housing and working with community builders and the private sector to build affordable housing. The other components of the national housing strategy can wrap around that to make sure we have a comprehensive approach to making housing more affordable.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128253","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As the national housing strategy approaches its closure, we're talking about its renewal this summer. We want to be ahead of the curve to make sure everyone working on delivering housing solutions and supporting work on homelessness.... We want to make sure we send a signal early about how these programs are continuing and how they're scaling up, wherever we are able to do that. We will be meeting","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63d6ee3454dfc18c41a0564854d05637d0dfc3f9bdc2e228cd4d8cdf9bb48af0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b2031449066e47b59855824ae14bda530612a759846767081e17c3673ccbda1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0aad39a44c0b401ded2edd9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128254,"date":"2026-05-25T21:45:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you for the question. The Canada Infrastructure Bank has clean power as one of its key elements for investment. There are now 27 clean power projects that have been funded by the Canada Infrastructure Bank out of 108 projects total. Over $18 billion has been invested by the Canada Infrastructure Bank. The total capital value of those projects is almost $55 billion. They have attracted significant private and institutional capital. Over $25 billion in private and institutional capital has been leveraged by that public investment, which is paid back. The Canada Infrastructure Bank is delivering many projects. Most of those are still under construction. About 10% are now complete, after the past few years of financing and construction, but we're seeing projects start to be completed. Many more are coming, as the transition to clean electricity, in particular, is booming.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128254","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for the question. The Canada Infrastructure Bank has clean power as one of its key elements for investment. There are now 27 clean power projects that have been funded by the Canada Infrastructure Bank out of 108 projects total. Over $18 billion has been invested by the Canada Infrastructure Bank. The total capital value of those projects is almost $55 billion. They have attracted signif","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c41a38c48ee11c290af216b06953e2a88a0f0232b49bd2c0036579acc89a0afc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24332808e8cf1b0016ad61edc55cf1c97a6a110d01aa01f0d20e90bb264f9665"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13006d516bcb36f3f79ae83d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128255,"date":"2026-05-25T21:45:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"The unsheltered homelessness and encampments initiative was a two-year program that ended in March. The government has now extended it for another year, so there is more funding available to the groups doing the work on the ground. We've seen really good results from the work done by those groups, bringing stability and helping people find housing. As I mentioned, we have to continue to build the housing that works for people coming off the street or out of encampments. Shelters are not always the best solution, so transitional and supportive housing is a key investment. There is more funding available for the year ahead, through the UHEI.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128255","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The unsheltered homelessness and encampments initiative was a two-year program that ended in March. The government has now extended it for another year, so there is more funding available to the groups doing the work on the ground. We've seen really good results from the work done by those groups, bringing stability and helping people find housing. As I mentioned, we have to continue to build the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6286d52c40c2b85eaae754b3eef575290eaeb5a4e508aee366d230fe2916f142"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b10621fd8684cc327b8d6f68f06f1c1c72d3f2dd0e8d04dcf49aef80635526d8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2119e7ad1975f0a1f1164296","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128256,"date":"2026-05-25T21:45:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"HUMA","text":"You can follow up with me for more info.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128256","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You can follow up with me for more info.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7771e5a41de27f9183d0a96cfc0b48492d255068867230541a4ca72ea61bcaf3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0136411c2c3d220fd8a1d994","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084432,"date":"2026-06-03T19:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is important that we recognize the critical investments we are making in Canada's economy right now to help these same people the opposition mentions. Yesterday, we announced investments in Quebec in infrastructure, including $2.5 billion in community centres, infrastructure to build more housing and to scale up our affordable housing across the country, $1 billion to be invested to upgrade our hospitals and emergency rooms, and over $6 billion to invest in public transit to help people get around affordably and to create the jobs that make this country prosperous.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084432","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is important that we recognize the critical investments we are making in Canada's economy right now to help these same people the opposition mentions. Yesterday, we announced investments in Quebec in infrastructure, including $2.5 billion in community centres, infrastructure to build more housing and to scale up our affordable housing across the country, $1 billion to be invested t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["df9c659b3a8787c5dad7d65521f75a640ede5b0d339d2b3790dc3cc327c8a287"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3573d46fa704d6f15508adbccdde20a6fc4ed9bf002ffb9fef6cb6fd459dd7c1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c63363abf4a33d43311542fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084433,"date":"2026-06-03T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for the question.\n\nYesterday, with the Government of Quebec, we announced more than $10 billion for infrastructure and public transit. This is one of the biggest investments in the history of Quebec. We are supporting the infrastructure needed for housing construction, health care infrastructure, and public transportation projects. Now is the time to build.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084433","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for the question.\n\nYesterday, with the Government of Quebec, we announced more than $10 billion for infrastructure and public transit. This is one of the biggest investments in the history of Quebec. We are supporting the infrastructure needed for housing construction, health care infrastructure, and public transportation projects. Now is the time to build.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["02c8fa23c57844cbe258059f4be08321c802df22ddd5666f21a7d79bb3000cfa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["670882f04ab06b57c8944cee2def2d53d08b397b3646f631f198f9465298e4b5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-38665fbf5efe0f345348e29f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086507,"date":"2026-06-08T19:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are seeing rents come down across Canada right now. We are seeing 20 straight months of rents declining, which is a positive trend. We are investing in the affordable housing that Canada needs to make sure that Canadians can afford housing. We are investing in discounts and rebates with the groceries and essentials benefit, benefits for children and food programs, across the board.\n\nThis side of the House votes for affordability. That side of the House votes against it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086507","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are seeing rents come down across Canada right now. We are seeing 20 straight months of rents declining, which is a positive trend. We are investing in the affordable housing that Canada needs to make sure that Canadians can afford housing. We are investing in discounts and rebates with the groceries and essentials benefit, benefits for children and food programs, across the board.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["77848ccb5016bd47a148140b5c23b01cf567a5a220cd540575d6168b0c78af04"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7bdccf19ba54dce9c9b79d9c3bc84ac5272775a5c1f59e60aa2abd943bc38f9b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e7cbbc27713e36efd8699d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086508,"date":"2026-06-08T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are making unprecedented investments in Canada's community infrastructure: $51 billion in the build communities strong fund, which is going into our communities for community centres, for housing-enabling infrastructure and for public transit. These are unprecedented investments to make Canada more affordable and to get jobs on the ground across Canada for our young people, with 100,000 new tradespeople who will be trained, supported by this House again. The other side of the House does not support any of this action. They are just negative. They should get with the program.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086508","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are making unprecedented investments in Canada's community infrastructure: $51 billion in the build communities strong fund, which is going into our communities for community centres, for housing-enabling infrastructure and for public transit. These are unprecedented investments to make Canada more affordable and to get jobs on the ground across Canada for our young people, with 10","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5bd27f95a91feb3595da42ea2fd844523b941bc84c106f24bd96b6dffe1e6552"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c865662e8c72d224dbf6dba905f5025d021e26b630fdf91cdb8d57cab06891ca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68dccb2c3898dcffe75e0e4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086489,"date":"2026-06-09T16:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved: \n\nThat in relation to Bill C-20, an act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes, not more than five further hours shall be allotted to the consideration at the third reading stage of the said bill; and\n\n That, at the expiry of the five hours provided for consideration at the third reading stage of the said bill, any proceedings before the House shall be interrupted, if required for the purpose of this order, and in turn every question necessary for the disposal of the said stage of the bill then under consideration shall be put forthwith and successively without further debate or amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086489","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"moved: \n\nThat in relation to Bill C-20, an act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes, not more than five further hours shall be allotted to the consideration at the third reading stage of the said bill; and\n\n That, at the expiry of the five hours provided for consideration at the third reading stage of the said bill, any proceedings before the House shall be interrupted, if required f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89b26c9f5b5db070af6573ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086490,"date":"2026-06-09T16:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, first and foremost, we are in a housing crisis in Canada.\n\n Affordability is a challenge for too many Canadians: finding an affordable place to live, finding a place to live at all for those who are at risk or are homeless currently. We need to take action here. This is a dedicated agency for affordable housing, for non-market housing, the supply of which is short in Canada compared to our peer countries in Europe, where there is several times more non-market housing. We need an agency that is dedicated to that.\n\n We are in a crisis. That is why it is urgent that we have this agency created as a Crown corporation with the powers and accountability that enables, ensuring that we are taking action and delivering results as the Government of Canada, partnering with provinces, territories, cities and indigenous governments, and ensuring that we are delivering the affordable housing Canada needs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086490","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, first and foremost, we are in a housing crisis in Canada.\n\n Affordability is a challenge for too many Canadians: finding an affordable place to live, finding a place to live at all for those who are at risk or are homeless currently. We need to take action here. This is a dedicated agency for affordable housing, for non-market housing, the supply of which is short in Canada compared t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ace1c45d6cc31bd74790184f6916c70f7bea7d45b0a9870e079ed509673516c5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3c08d9221a1122bbb4ff9e21b8d4006ede756bcc383b9de8b972d46cf605d5db"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ac373b0569bc366bb4c75fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086491,"date":"2026-06-09T16:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, in the spring economic update there was a signal of the opportunity to work on the national model codes, the building codes for Canada, with the National Research Council, which is under the Minister of Industry. We have big opportunities across the country to ensure that building codes are more harmonized with provinces, territories and, in some cases, cities that control their own codes. We certainly have an opportunity to have a clearer set of standards around manufactured building components and to make sure that we have those standards accepted across the country, so manufacturers of wall panels, floor panels and modular homes can have an opportunity to have those products certified and accepted across the country. We see that as an important next step that is certainly related to the work we are doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086491","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, in the spring economic update there was a signal of the opportunity to work on the national model codes, the building codes for Canada, with the National Research Council, which is under the Minister of Industry. We have big opportunities across the country to ensure that building codes are more harmonized with provinces, territories and, in some cases, cities that control their own","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30271013de201f53ca9f0d39fcef17d28a6e7a7e66fc7ebff4238b336b1ce09f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d46e5660bfc4416301729254cc8419a8fd4ae775cfff7803dcd8a7d22600851"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e57f24a03955250a0fdf176b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086492,"date":"2026-06-09T16:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the housing crisis has been decades in the making. It goes back to the federal government not taking enough action to build affordable housing and non-market housing. It goes back at least to the nineties, and arguably before that. Governments of all stripes take responsibility; governments at all levels or orders across Canada as well. Certainly, there are challenges at the local level. I served at the local level. There are challenges in approving enough, approving fast enough and approving a balanced mix with non-market. Non-market housing needs the support of provincial and federal governments. There has to be investment in that. Build Canada Homes is an excellent vehicle to fast-track, and attract private capital to, non-market housing and the affordable housing spectrum.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086492","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the housing crisis has been decades in the making. It goes back to the federal government not taking enough action to build affordable housing and non-market housing. It goes back at least to the nineties, and arguably before that. Governments of all stripes take responsibility; governments at all levels or orders across Canada as well. Certainly, there are challenges at the local l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["88c3c6f5bfff9161e8a838a483c63aeb161d35592305aa109d4a3ac1eae86e1c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b6f85b6ecb04ce85d0e37ceaef6a0516b8bde65fc2f2bcee11ba0f79a446b7ef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e9e6adae859c6868af1d51c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086493,"date":"2026-06-09T16:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, costs do vary significantly across the country, certainly in the member opposite's riding and in the territories. The good news is that we have agreements now with Quebec to build, with Build Canada Homes, hundreds and hundreds of homes throughout Quebec in partnership with Quebec. As well, there are examples in Nunavut: 750 homes with the territorial Government of Nunavut and with Nunavut Tunngavik Inc., the housing corporation in Nunavut that is Inuit-controlled.\n\nWe have opportunities to build with provinces and territories where the cost is significantly higher. This affords an opportunity also to empower the manufacturing industry and get components of housing or volumetric housing to those remote territories and provinces. We see manufacturers now starting to set up in many parts of Canada to bring more efficiency to the farther regions out and bring those costs down as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086493","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, costs do vary significantly across the country, certainly in the member opposite's riding and in the territories. The good news is that we have agreements now with Quebec to build, with Build Canada Homes, hundreds and hundreds of homes throughout Quebec in partnership with Quebec. As well, there are examples in Nunavut: 750 homes with the territorial Government of Nunavut and with ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebb7fe408688484a3ad7af943178a6e2239d63f2c01ca401945ba1a944eba785"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a16615d831a78136a80bbba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086494,"date":"2026-06-09T16:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, to the point of collaboration, we have seen fantastic uptake from provinces and territories. I mentioned Quebec moments ago and Nunavut. We have a partnership with B.C. to build 1,100 new affordable homes and 700 of those are supportive and transitional homes for those who are homeless or at risk of homelessness. Both Nova Scotia and New Brunswick are in partnership with Build Canada Homes for more than 1,000 homes.\n\nRight out of the gate, we have agreements with provinces and territories; Yukon and Nunavut are examples, as are Ontario and Quebec. We have opportunities to build in every province and territory right now, and existing agreements are in place. That speaks to that collaboration. I think we are seeing the interest and the uptake. It is not only from different levels of government, like the City of Ottawa, but also from the private sector.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086494","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, to the point of collaboration, we have seen fantastic uptake from provinces and territories. I mentioned Quebec moments ago and Nunavut. We have a partnership with B.C. to build 1,100 new affordable homes and 700 of those are supportive and transitional homes for those who are homeless or at risk of homelessness. Both Nova Scotia and New Brunswick are in partnership with Build Canad","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b32b44169e672f149b83db2dae39f21261e990aa3c933fa63b7f903b73c3add4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09315ce06099a9c8b93bbd3137fb3ff6164b3370305e5195378ce4792ebdedab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2571f1a3dcff8fed151f6f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086495,"date":"2026-06-09T16:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I would ask the member to walk across the floor. I would be happy for him to come over and talk. We are here in Ottawa all the time. If he wants to be more bureaucratic and send emails, there is that, but I am here. I am here to talk about this. We are here to get housing built. That is the goal. I have certainly been approached and had conversations with many members on both sides of the House. I am certainly willing to focus on getting housing built in all the communities across Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086495","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I would ask the member to walk across the floor. I would be happy for him to come over and talk. We are here in Ottawa all the time. If he wants to be more bureaucratic and send emails, there is that, but I am here. I am here to talk about this. We are here to get housing built. That is the goal. I have certainly been approached and had conversations with many members on both sides ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be9b8a1e86fe8cf05b44a8fd9d4c8f03cefc6967f29f7778aa8d9fac3f61e4d2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b684bdda3200c21952759f1deac05243fa338c07d92e1c26f8a859b3a1cf6a98"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3334a6dd80cd5c00bb205779","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086496,"date":"2026-06-09T16:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, there are challenging costs related to shipping anything to remote regions of Canada, and that is factored into the cost. Build Canada Homes has to factor that in when it is putting together these partnerships with provinces and territories, or with community builders in various regions around the country.\n\nThe benefit of shipping manufactured components or volumetric homes is that is all that is being shipped: We are not shipping extra materials that are cut off and then turned into waste. Construction waste is the number one source of waste in solid waste landfills. We need to reduce the amount of waste in the industry, and we can do that with shipping. We have to factor in that cost. Ideally, we need to employ as many local people as we can for the assembly or installation of these homes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086496","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, there are challenging costs related to shipping anything to remote regions of Canada, and that is factored into the cost. Build Canada Homes has to factor that in when it is putting together these partnerships with provinces and territories, or with community builders in various regions around the country.\n\nThe benefit of shipping manufactured components or volumetric homes is that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a2c74b52ce798447103c4daeb4e4d2755328bf40925798da344078052d35f08"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5526ff750efad168334f5792b8eec8991427ae974a5d0645b426261275a341a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-51a169f00fa291a0818c7c8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086497,"date":"2026-06-09T16:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member for his leadership in New Brunswick.\n\nThe province of New Brunswick certainly has been an early adopter of manufacturing and modern methods of construction. There are many companies now set up in New Brunswick producing homes or components of homes.\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086497","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member for his leadership in New Brunswick.\n\nThe province of New Brunswick certainly has been an early adopter of manufacturing and modern methods of construction. There are many companies now set up in New Brunswick producing homes or components of homes.\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1b90933c34ce84eb0aecb0a25f3bd066b323c55102e7e8fb35d6e9a715cace4e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b087734dd6a9cf8c07523c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086498,"date":"2026-06-09T16:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, we see great leadership from New Brunswick, not only with respect to the 1,500 homes that are now in the works, between Build Canada Homes and New Brunswick, but also on the manufacturing side. It is one of the leading provinces in manufacturing homes and components of buildings and homes. That is where we see the future.\n\n Certainly, New Brunswick can produce for other Atlantic provinces as well, and ship within the region, but we are seeing that opportunity with manufacturing emerging in many other parts of the country. We are also seeing opportunities, like with New Brunswick's model, where there are a lot of smaller projects in rural communities in New Brunswick that are being coordinated by New Brunswick as a province, the housing minister and his team. That is a fantastic model for getting a lot of different types of projects, small, medium and large, built across the province. We hope to see that in many other provinces and territories.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086498","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, we see great leadership from New Brunswick, not only with respect to the 1,500 homes that are now in the works, between Build Canada Homes and New Brunswick, but also on the manufacturing side. It is one of the leading provinces in manufacturing homes and components of buildings and homes. That is where we see the future.\n\n Certainly, New Brunswick can produce for other Atlantic pro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ebab647ebaed269269105734c1328f82f8a0cb9db2abf27802715936532c6ad"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-128f9c4dc6dd2a9ab747dcc2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086499,"date":"2026-06-09T16:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, as the member said, we are not building affordable homes fast enough. That is why we need to have Build Canada Homes as a Crown corporation, with all of the tools, financial instruments and accountability to make sure we can build faster from the federal side. We need to have these partnerships in place. We need to make it easier for the private sector to build. We need to make sure it is faster for the cities, provinces, territories and indigenous governments to get housing built. We need to be an enabler or a catalyst. We certainly rely primarily on the private sector to do the actual construction and building. All levels of government need to be coordinated to make sure it is easier and faster to get affordable housing built.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086499","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, as the member said, we are not building affordable homes fast enough. That is why we need to have Build Canada Homes as a Crown corporation, with all of the tools, financial instruments and accountability to make sure we can build faster from the federal side. We need to have these partnerships in place. We need to make it easier for the private sector to build. We need to make sure","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e6cd2bf917610eb49c3c88f13659ac52dd3075047bb4b456796c664358070bb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["06783039d9c90c474dba17d1cdf36b12f05b521b9087e86d52768a718728f92d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b1d11f8ca4c0c128aaaf5814","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086500,"date":"2026-06-09T16:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member opposite for his questions and his concerns. Build Canada Homes will be the federal government agency to deliver affordable housing. CMHC will focus on market housing. There will be two agencies right now, CMHC on the market side and Build Canada Homes on the non-market side, that will be focused on housing. \n\nThe Canada Lands Company, which has been involved in housing development for the federal government, is effectively folding into Build Canada Homes with the portfolio of federal lands where affordable housing can be built. That is one component. It is basically that we are going to two agencies. One is affordable housing-focused, non-market, and the second, CMHC, continues to provide support for market housing, the apartment construction loan program, the MLI select program and the research that the member opposite is discussing, which is valuable across the board for the whole housing continuum.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086500","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member opposite for his questions and his concerns. Build Canada Homes will be the federal government agency to deliver affordable housing. CMHC will focus on market housing. There will be two agencies right now, CMHC on the market side and Build Canada Homes on the non-market side, that will be focused on housing. \n\nThe Canada Lands Company, which has been involved in h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5e4105b984daae5ff83d465bb5e31af4287c45713b370dd3e420ee10aab4c129"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d52051084688f8a079a63c06444b91ab636d383054055dd0b72cdda83aa8182f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1526884c20c29dd2344441d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086501,"date":"2026-06-09T16:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, we have seen enormous uptake among the non-profit or community housing builders. I think a majority of the proposals coming into Build Canada Homes are from the community building sector and non-profits partnering with the private sector, which will do a lot of the construction and building. Those homes will be effectively operated by the non-profit sector, because they are affordable homes. \n\nIn particular, I want to speak to the great uptake we have seen with transitional and supportive housing. The most important solution right now for homelessness is making sure people have access to a home that has the wraparound supports. We have a couple of thousand homes now in the works in partnership across the country for that supportive housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086501","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, we have seen enormous uptake among the non-profit or community housing builders. I think a majority of the proposals coming into Build Canada Homes are from the community building sector and non-profits partnering with the private sector, which will do a lot of the construction and building. Those homes will be effectively operated by the non-profit sector, because they are affordab","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5090e486edec199a61915fd2573aa3d6d01c5d64b233ee91fd04cdbe9b81b98b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8153f0c55f821076fd1f6fdc69cd0fdfe136b0777a3ab80e06ce2f17afca6150"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b725eb60e63cb179d3987b27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086502,"date":"2026-06-09T16:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, CMHC, will continue to focus on the market side of the housing continuum, and that is from rental housing to the mortgage insurance products it has provided for generations. It can specialize in that, and Build Canada Homes can specialize in affordable housing. We think it is important to have this separation between the two. They are very different lines of business, with very different partnerships that get put together with the provinces, territories and cities on the affordable housing side. \n\nThe example of Quebec's partnership illustrates the opportunity that provinces and territories see in partnering with Build Canada Homes to get the homes delivered, and get them delivered with affordability at the core.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086502","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, CMHC, will continue to focus on the market side of the housing continuum, and that is from rental housing to the mortgage insurance products it has provided for generations. It can specialize in that, and Build Canada Homes can specialize in affordable housing. We think it is important to have this separation between the two. They are ver","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fcb9fa22d9ff92d63956e8ef5249a1a5a8ea4d5023781725f1708719852b881b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["274a488d48bc41eb294845d42b78b31743b4984d7bf384a50768934e8943783d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25c2ff398d60e31c3078fd2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086503,"date":"2026-06-09T16:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the target is to build as much affordable housing as possible with the capital that is being provided here by the Government of Canada. There is an array of partnerships and collaborations now. There are different levels of affordability, as the member knows as a former mayor. There are projects that have deeply affordable supportive and transitional housing. Those require more investment from government, more support in terms of an equity investment to achieve that level of affordability. There is a mix of affordable rentals in many projects as well.\n\nAs for setting random large targets to shoot for, we want to see the maximum amount of housing delivered. We want to see as much affordability as possible. That is the core goal for Build Canada Homes. We want to also leverage opportunity across affordable rental housing and co-op housing. We want to see a whole range of housing in the middle market, the so-called missing middle, delivered alongside that. It is a range of different types of projects, with different affordability, but we want to see all of that maximized for the benefit of Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086503","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the target is to build as much affordable housing as possible with the capital that is being provided here by the Government of Canada. There is an array of partnerships and collaborations now. There are different levels of affordability, as the member knows as a former mayor. There are projects that have deeply affordable supportive and transitional housing. Those require more inve","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca891ad7f14fd5e4522a6df2302c87886b56f8f37a0ec9da19dcc253e6e38c77"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2a1c331b41bc38fbe5e3f1505e6c490d815858ae9022c5ad9d8fe7c4f2e99c57"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0f783f89d718d68b17eb858","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086504,"date":"2026-06-09T16:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate the member's concern around softwood. We see enormous opportunity with Build Canada Homes to focus on building with Canadian wood. That would benefit our industries from B.C. to Quebec and New Brunswick, provinces that rely heavily on softwood and forestry. We have real opportunities to scale up the value-added industry and make sure we are protecting jobs with softwood here in Canada. Buy Canadian is a key element with Build Canada Homes. That has gone into the investment criteria. We are seeing proposals come in that would use Canadian wood to build. We want to see, in the manufacturing sector, mass timber and value-added products built with Canadian wood. \n\nThat is our focus with Build Canada Homes, making sure we do everything we can to use Canadian materials, to strengthen Canadian homebuilding and manufacturing, right into the forest industry. I am working in collaboration with the Minister of Industry and the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources to make sure we are maximizing that opportunity and supporting that industry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086504","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate the member's concern around softwood. We see enormous opportunity with Build Canada Homes to focus on building with Canadian wood. That would benefit our industries from B.C. to Quebec and New Brunswick, provinces that rely heavily on softwood and forestry. We have real opportunities to scale up the value-added industry and make sure we are protecting jobs with softwood","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Woodworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","label":"Woodworking industry","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d12540bcf305a6b8810017dd52f1507a778804bc857a189bc1db207cf672b27b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["933be245537334a4801dd7c62c4413bd24118332f43ebdd3823550aae8b16402"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3ad9c82c0ec6f24656905d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086505,"date":"2026-06-09T16:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member for her leadership on behalf of New Brunswick. \n\nLike the members of Parliament from New Brunswick, we are very encouraging of Build Canada Homes and New Brunswick partnering to maximize the opportunity to build affordable housing across New Brunswick. The Government of New Brunswick has been a leader, as the member said, in being one of the first provinces to step forward. As I mentioned earlier, with the opportunity to build in communities of all shapes and sizes, the province has put together projects across New Brunswick. It is bringing that portfolio forward and will help manage the delivery of that housing, which is fantastic. It makes it much more streamlined for Build Canada Homes to be able to invest, knowing that the province is overseeing that portfolio, and many communities are being served at the same time. \n\nI give a big thanks to New Brunswick for leading the way on that and to the members for supporting that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086505","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank the member for her leadership on behalf of New Brunswick. \n\nLike the members of Parliament from New Brunswick, we are very encouraging of Build Canada Homes and New Brunswick partnering to maximize the opportunity to build affordable housing across New Brunswick. The Government of New Brunswick has been a leader, as the member said, in being one of the first provinces to ste","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["450b5bdbf1edab265c2948f5eed6489360f1c774a2707742fc26ff31a881764e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c288101e45722558db3b79e58a8952412cc854cf90f30df4fc625da296a30c6b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d7898d85e8eb67f230c0e8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086506,"date":"2026-06-09T16:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, certainly, indigenous housing is a really important component of what Build Canada Homes is delivering and will continue to deliver. The floor for investment in indigenous housing in Build Canada Homes is 10% of the capital there for affordable housing. There are many proposals coming in from indigenous home builders.\n\n We look forward to seeing Build Canada Homes supporting projects. There is a huge opportunity. We saw this in the Nunavut and Yukon territories, where the majority of the population is indigenous. That housing will obviously be delivered by the territorial governments, but it will benefit indigenous residents. We are going to see a lot of proposals and partnerships with first nations and Inuit and Métis people as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086506","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, certainly, indigenous housing is a really important component of what Build Canada Homes is delivering and will continue to deliver. The floor for investment in indigenous housing in Build Canada Homes is 10% of the capital there for affordable housing. There are many proposals coming in from indigenous home builders.\n\n We look forward to seeing Build Canada Homes supporting project","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["557fadcb99f1088a3a31e755202a18ada8f48952af15274794679d77e9d73da4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c59b5ffbf1655e3fc5bb294f49c66baab0780582b1ef51d05b776fad4c99c571"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62213f3e8ea30ce7e2fe2f33","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086487,"date":"2026-06-10T19:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as a British Columbian like the member opposite, I will say that people in B.C. are optimistic about our future, like we are on this side of the House. We see major projects coming to B.C. that are going to boost our economy in B.C. We see rents coming down. We see affordability coming back to the table. We see benefits to British Columbians that the other side of the House has opposed every step of the way, whether to our youth or to our young workers. We are interested in taking action right across the country to support Canadians, grow the economy and deliver affordability, not being stuck in the mud.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086487","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as a British Columbian like the member opposite, I will say that people in B.C. are optimistic about our future, like we are on this side of the House. We see major projects coming to B.C. that are going to boost our economy in B.C. We see rents coming down. We see affordability coming back to the table. We see benefits to British Columbians that the other side of the House has oppose","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["935c01e39c793fa87159856fadc001c8fe80f6bd9f1f85560f700b17015a7935"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52b5bfa53cf7696cbfa8316ae6ad1b78d2b88687173f1db9091aee9d839cf1ae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e0f5f075acd195b01f42a5d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086488,"date":"2026-06-10T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, thanks to Build Canada Homes, we are putting in place new tools to accelerate housing construction, leverage public land and support innovative constructive methods.\n\nToday, the House has the opportunity to support the bill on Build Canada Homes, and I encourage all members to vote in favour of this important measure to help us build more affordable housing in communities across Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086488","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, thanks to Build Canada Homes, we are putting in place new tools to accelerate housing construction, leverage public land and support innovative constructive methods.\n\nToday, the House has the opportunity to support the bill on Build Canada Homes, and I encourage all members to vote in favour of this important measure to help us build more affordable housing in communities across Canad","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["05cc85cac8200b19b8a65b522d03b6f1a1671004558edd232966204218c1780e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eeb1a2ef9c28837d9a8428b0815c3bdf27d2d42b56b64ff8e52aaed60a45b1c2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4cf3aa4d6ecf1e19f828e75f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086478,"date":"2026-06-11T15:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved:\n\n That, notwithstanding any standing order or usual practice of the House, Bill C-26, An Act to authorize certain payments to be made out of the Consolidated Revenue Fund for the purpose of improving housing supply, be disposed of as follows:\n\n(a) the bill be ordered for consideration at the second reading stage immediately after the adoption of this order;\n\n(b) when the House begins debate at the second reading stage of the bill, one member of each recognized party, a member of the New Democratic Party, and the member of the Green Party, may each speak at the said stage for not more than 20 minutes, followed by 10 minutes for questions and comments, provided that members may be permitted to split their time with another member; \n\n(c) at the conclusion of the time provided for the debate at the second reading stage or when no member wishes to speak, whichever is earlier, all questions necessary to dispose of the second reading stage of the bill shall be put without further debate or amendment; \n\n(d) if the bill is adopted at the second reading stage, it shall be deemed referred to a committee of the whole, deemed considered in committee of the whole, deemed reported without amendment, deemed concurred in at report stage, and deemed read a third time and passed; and\n\n(e) during consideration of the bill,\n\n(i) after 8:30 p.m., no quorum calls, dilatory motions or requests for unanimous consent shall be received by the Chair,\n\n(ii) the House shall not adjourn, except pursuant to a motion moved by a minister of the Crown, \n\n(iii) no motion to adjourn the debate may be moved except by a minister of the Crown.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, I rise to open the debate on Government Business No. 11 and to highlight the importance of Bill C-26, an act to authorize certain payments to be made out of the consolidated revenue fund for the purpose of improving housing supply.\n\nThe motion would allow for the quick passage of Bill C-26, putting our government in a position to make payments to the provinces and territories, up to a total of $1.7 billion, to support efforts that improve the housing supply across Canada. It is a targeted measure designed to get funding quickly to the provinces and territories for measures that get homes built, including reducing development fees or levies on new home construction and making incremental investments in provincial and territorial programming already in place to spur housing developments.\n\nFar too many Canadians are struggling to find an affordable place to live. I believe every member of the House agrees that Canada is in a housing crisis. Solving that crisis requires a multitude of different tools and it requires immediate action. We need to bring down the costs, cut red tape, improve productivity and build more quickly. To meet the current and future housing needs of Canadians, we need to ensure that housing supply can keep pace with demand and that homes can be delivered at prices that are affordable for Canadians.\n\nI want to speak to the urgency of the motion and the need to move quickly on the motion and the legislation. We need to move quickly to solve Canada's housing challenges by bringing down the costs, as I said, cutting red tape and building homes at a faster pace.\n\nBill C-26 has been designed to unlock housing supply across the country. The legislation would deliver a $1.7-billion federal investment to the provinces and territories to support measures that increase housing supply. These funds could, for example, help lower development fees or levies on new home construction, which are particularly significant in my home province of B.C. and in Ontario. They can also strengthen existing provincial and territorial programs that are already focused on building more homes through targeted, incremental investments.\n\nIn addition, the federal investment can provide support for provincial and territorial efforts to streamline regulations and boost productivity across the home construction sector. Ontario's recent announcement of an HST rebate on new homes is a key example of how these transfers would improve supply.\n\nAs part of tax relief efforts, the Ontario government, thanks to federal support tied to the bill, plans to rebate the full 13% harmonized sales tax in Ontario on new homes valued up to a million dollars, which would save buyers up to $130,000 on a new home at that $1-million price.\n\nIt is clear that strong partnerships with the provinces, territories and local governments are essential to building more homes and improving housing affordability for Canadians. Proceeding swiftly with Bill C-26 through this motion would get get these funds to the provinces, and all of the work could continue across the country at pace.\n\nLast week, I spoke at the annual conference of the Federation of Canadian Municipalities, where I shared my own experience as a mayor. I remember asking the federal government for the investments and support my community needed. I remember the years spent trying to get Stephen Harper's Conservative government to recognize this growing problem. I remember their many refusals to even sit at the table, let alone collaborate on finding and implementing solutions.\n\nToday, things are different. Canada has a new government that is resolutely committed to taking action. Thanks to our government's investments, we are supporting the community infrastructure that people depend on every day, from community centres and recreational facilities to parks and cultural spaces. This includes new builds, expansions, renovations, retrofits, climate adaptations and project replacements.\n\nSimply put, it is impossible to build housing without the road and water infrastructure needed to support it. Rather than let our municipal partners shoulder these responsibilities alone or pass on the cost of this infrastructure to homebuyers, we are making essential investments through the Canada housing infrastructure fund and now through our historic new build communities strong fund.\n\nThe result of these investments is real projects that will improve people's lives. Last April, we announced $25.9 million for water infrastructure in Regina, Saskatoon and Moose Jaw, enabling the construction of more than 29,000 homes. Last December, we announced $8.6 million for Charlottetown, P.E.I., to build the infrastructure needed to build up to 525 housing units. Just over a week ago, we announced our comprehensive partnership with the Government of Quebec on community, health and transportation infrastructure. Historic action is being taken to build stronger communities, with good neighbourhoods and homes people can afford.\n\nThese investments are complemented further by the important work of Build Canada Homes. Since launching in September, Build Canada Homes has already advanced six direct-build projects in Dartmouth, Longueuil, Ottawa, Toronto, Winnipeg and Edmonton, and secured six major partnerships with the City of Ottawa and the provinces of Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Quebec and B.C., and a tripartite agreement with the Nunavut Housing Corporation and Nunavut Tunngavik Inc.\n\n As a dedicated agency with a mandate to build affordable housing, Build Canada Homes is already doing important work to move thousands of new homes forward. We announced 1,100 new homes, including 700 supportive and transitional homes, to be built within the next 12 months, in B.C. just this last February. Build Canada Homes will build up to 750 homes across Nunavut in partnership with the Government of Nunavut and Nunavut Tunngavik Inc. Through the partnership with New Brunswick, we will accelerate the delivery of up to 1,200 shovel‐ready affordable homes, with the potential to scale up to 1,500 new homes in New Brunswick. A few weeks ago, we brought together both the build communities strong fund and Build Canada Homes by delivering approximately $350 million in housing and infrastructure investments in the Yukon.\n\n These are just a few examples of the partnerships and progress Build Canada Homes has accomplished in less than a year.\n\n Yesterday, this House passed Bill C‐20, the Build Canada Homes act, at third reading, taking us one step closer to turning Build Canada Homes into a Crown corporation, with even more tools to get more homes built. Whether it is through the build communities strong fund, Build Canada Homes or any of our other programs, now is the time to work together. Now is the time for all levels of government to get to the table and identify our priorities so that we can get building.\n\n We are in uncertain times, but when we work together, we can give ourselves more than anyone can take away. That is why our government is taking action on these different fronts across the housing spectrum, reducing barriers, investing in housing-enabled infrastructure and catalyzing a more productive homebuilding sector. Bill C‐26 is an important tool within this broader effort.\n\n The reality is that housing needs differ from region to region, and our response must be just as nuanced and targeted. The barriers faced in a fast-growing urban centre, like my home city of Vancouver, are very different from those in smaller or more remote communities. What Vancouver needs versus what Iqaluit, Chicoutimi or rural Canada needs generally differs significantly. Bill C‐26 reflects this reality by giving the provinces and territories the flexibility to find solutions that are best suited to the regional challenges that may impede housing supply and would best meet the housing needs of those jurisdictions. By empowering the provinces and territories to direct funding where it can be most impactful in addressing the housing supply barriers, we can help ensure that these federal investments align with the on-the-ground realities. This federal funding would be transferred to provinces and territories with the understanding that it will be used exclusively for measures that increase housing supply.\n\n For instance, this could include but is not limited to reducing development fees or levies on new home construction. The funding could be used on new home construction. The funding could also be used to make incremental investments in provincial or territorial programming already in place to spur housing developments. Ontario's HST announcement on March 25 of this year is an example of how these transfers could help home supply in Ontario.\n\n The key element here is partnership, which is also central to our broader housing approach. Strong collaboration among all levels of government, with indigenous partners and with non-profit organizations and private industry is needed to address the housing challenges that we face across Canada. Provinces and territories are well placed to determine how federal support can augment their provincial and territorial efforts to unlock additional supply across different regions, and Bill C‐26 would help enable that effort.\n\nWe are already seeing the effectiveness of partnerships. On March 23, the Prime Minister announced a partnership with Ontario to reduce development charges and support new housing supply, demonstrating how that collaboration can directly lower costs and accelerate building. As I outlined earlier, the federal government is also working with provinces, territories and indigenous partners to deliver more homes, affordable homes, through Build Canada Homes and the build communities strong fund.\n\n These examples show what is possible when the Government of Canada works together with provinces, territories, local governments, indigenous groups and other key partners. Bill C‐26's approach complements the broader work that is already under way to increase housing supply across Canada. We are bringing partners together, aligning these efforts and ensuring that every dollar contributes to faster, more effective housing delivery.\n\nThis bill is tailor-made to meet those needs, but I also want to take a moment to talk about other important programs.\n\n As I noted, our government is taking action to support building across the housing spectrum. The work of Build Canada Homes to scale up the supply of affordable housing nationwide is in full swing now. Other measures like targeted tax relief, such as removing the 5% GST on new purpose‐built rental construction, are lowering upfront costs and helping move projects forward.\n\n Programs like the apartment construction loan program and the CMHC mortgage loan insurance products, MLI select being a great example, help builders secure financing. These programs are very significant across Canada. They are more on the market side of housing, but they are certainly enabling historic levels of rental housing to be built right across the country.\n\nThe apartment construction loan program is making needed capital available to make more apartment projects financially viable and get shovels in the ground. That is the key piece, particularly in these uncertain times. Recently, in the spring economic update, we announced that we would be kicking this program into even higher gear, accelerating over $7 billion in low‐cost financing to speed up rental home construction even further.\n\n The housing accelerator fund is also a program that helps unlock supply, reducing barriers, reducing red tape and speeding up approvals at the local level. We have 241 housing accelerator fund agreements that were signed with local governments, and they are delivering tens of thousands of homes on pace that would not have been seen otherwise.\n\n To conclude, right now there is momentum like never before to deliver on the housing issue, but we cannot do it alone. Our success relies on working together to tackle the housing crisis from every angle and deliver results for Canadians. By enabling targeted, flexible funding and reinforcing collaboration across provinces and territories, Bill C‐26 would help to ensure that we are not just investing more but investing smarter, together. This is how we will deliver the homes that Canadians need. This is how we will create more prosperous, resilient communities. This is how we will build Canada strong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086478","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"moved:\n\n That, notwithstanding any standing order or usual practice of the House, Bill C-26, An Act to authorize certain payments to be made out of the Consolidated Revenue Fund for the purpose of improving housing supply, be disposed of as follows:\n\n(a) the bill be ordered for consideration at the second reading stage immediately after the adoption of this order;\n\n(b) when the House begins debate","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["500cb951d3bb1c90434d9850f093013c0f5fc9fc6bc4601f9dcd2d419e2944a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc321aee7b2d34f5bc4216f36c55a920a56eaf469905502ebc61935bc3cc5504"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f33508e0ded490e6e778b30","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086479,"date":"2026-06-11T16:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I said in my remarks, we are in an affordable housing crisis across Canada. Canadians expect us to take action and deliver in every way possible.\n\nFor the last two days, Conservatives have been moving motions to shut down this House early and to send us home for the summer, with hours of work left to do and hours of debate left on important legislation like this that would deliver affordable housing for Canadians. If the Conservatives are interested in a longer process, more time for debate and circuitous routes that take forever to deliver for Canadians, that will not be supported by this side of the House.\n\n We want to see action taken. We want to see partnerships advanced with provinces and territories, and investment in new affordable housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086479","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I said in my remarks, we are in an affordable housing crisis across Canada. Canadians expect us to take action and deliver in every way possible.\n\nFor the last two days, Conservatives have been moving motions to shut down this House early and to send us home for the summer, with hours of work left to do and hours of debate left on important legislation like this that would deliver ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f288b0a747690e519f34208a4d25601943c446d702174f9dfef13af8afc4a7c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea92cbfbf099ef804bbf6b19476d4d70655314b1489288ed81ec34b501a333d5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0a40c573a365f2598dbaf69","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086480,"date":"2026-06-11T16:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have been very transparent in all of our housing funding allocations and our partnerships. In particular with Quebec, we have an unprecedented partnership on housing through Build Canada Homes. We are contributing funding from the federal level in partnership and at a collaboration table with Quebec to get affordable housing built, including supportive and transitional housing, which is a big priority for many communities and for the province of Quebec, to help solve homelessness. This would be an additional investment that could be made to provinces and territories, obviously including Quebec, to get them funding to take next levels of action.\n\nAs I mentioned, there are many tools that we need to bring forward. This is one that needs to be expedited.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086480","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have been very transparent in all of our housing funding allocations and our partnerships. In particular with Quebec, we have an unprecedented partnership on housing through Build Canada Homes. We are contributing funding from the federal level in partnership and at a collaboration table with Quebec to get affordable housing built, including supportive and transitional housing, whi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c83480ab3363b6aefccf7c13b409f6160cbae6548c84bd93e2b6191235003897"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7eeddd5ff93c08ce4dd181f0cc8f60e48116afa0821f3965fa712f59a1ddb4f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ba6f71556ab5c5ad5d36209","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086481,"date":"2026-06-11T16:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, having served for a decade at the local government level in both the city of Vancouver and the metro Vancouver regional government, I am obviously very familiar with the challenges faced not only on the housing front, but also in the relationships with the provinces and territories and the federal government. Historically, it has been very difficult for cities to work with other levels of government. That is why we are in the predicament we are in with housing.\n\n Cities have a critical role to play, but in years past, certainly in my years as mayor, there was not direct support. A program like the housing accelerator fund did not exist, nor were there transfers or investments that enabled the cities to take action and build, nor were there adequate programs through the provinces and territories. In this case, we are working with all of these partners, collaborating and investing at historic levels, and we want to make sure that collaboration creates affordable housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086481","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, having served for a decade at the local government level in both the city of Vancouver and the metro Vancouver regional government, I am obviously very familiar with the challenges faced not only on the housing front, but also in the relationships with the provinces and territories and the federal government. Historically, it has been very difficult for cities to work with other level","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fbd952900b382e73ab82561c411b34b812a9b255f86c8396c45dbaebb234fbe2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6aa04ba15e7cd40200de4aaa2baae094573b4c58584c4976d2e18c85fbff09e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7d40a7f65cb2aa918736d08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086482,"date":"2026-06-11T16:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I was surprised to see the member and members on the other side of the House oppose the Build Canada Homes act at third reading yesterday. This is an agency that will be 100% focused on delivering affordable housing in Canada. We have never had that before.\n\nWith respect to the rationale, as the housing minister, I will be responsible for the Crown corporation, as I am for the special operating agency currently. The special operating agency has very limited tools to do financing and land acquisition and to expedite bringing on human resources to get more housing built. The Crown corporation structure will get more housing built in the long run, and that is the goal overall. It is accountable to Parliament through the minister, so I see it as a very significant advancement for getting affordable housing built.\n\n In this case, with Bill C-26, funding would also go to provinces and territories to enable and expedite the—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086482","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I was surprised to see the member and members on the other side of the House oppose the Build Canada Homes act at third reading yesterday. This is an agency that will be 100% focused on delivering affordable housing in Canada. We have never had that before.\n\nWith respect to the rationale, as the housing minister, I will be responsible for the Crown corporation, as I am for the special","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036797","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036797","label":"Public architecture","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75e556b3fe94eee9abcf91b35093795a9e3d1114f9b67b30aed5add453fc0679"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6d06d80f7d0c8656d30de3f1e510e468b95182001dbdf0ed528e3dcfdad9363e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7872aa9c9892fdd3baad2b44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086483,"date":"2026-06-11T16:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I just want to clarify to the member opposite that the Parliamentary Budget Officer's report related to Build Canada Homes was very much focused on Build Canada Homes, not on all of the tools that government has to get housing built, most of which reside within the national housing strategy and related programs. Build Canada Homes is at far beyond the number stated, with probably triple that right now in the pipeline for the construction of affordable housing.\n\nThere are many other programs. This initiative with Bill C-26 would get additional funding to provinces and territories and would expedite it to make sure they will have more tools and more opportunities, as Ontario has done, as an example, to bring down its HST and make it more affordable for homebuyers to buy homes of up to $1 million. It is helping Canadians get into their first homes. For first-time homebuyers, it is another opportunity.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086483","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I just want to clarify to the member opposite that the Parliamentary Budget Officer's report related to Build Canada Homes was very much focused on Build Canada Homes, not on all of the tools that government has to get housing built, most of which reside within the national housing strategy and related programs. Build Canada Homes is at far beyond the number stated, with probably trip","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["615e1e4fccf31ecfff5186fa34f8d682e5f24c53c4f9565cf2f94daee3cba142"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["542b079ecbe8678420ca131720b971f33161fa47d4eb9c21139ad5f5e7f25583"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b78cbb4bc2ed29319f80d43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086484,"date":"2026-06-11T16:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for those concerns.\n\nWe have to get more supportive and transitional housing built, in particular for our most vulnerable Canadians. That is a big focus of Build Canada Homes. We want to see this funding expedite housing like that, and we need to not only do what Ontario is doing with the HST, but focus on the most affordable housing, first and foremost. We will be doing that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086484","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for those concerns.\n\nWe have to get more supportive and transitional housing built, in particular for our most vulnerable Canadians. That is a big focus of Build Canada Homes. We want to see this funding expedite housing like that, and we need to not only do what Ontario is doing with the HST, but focus on the most affordable housing, first and foremost. We will be ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fceaf2f1e849775d485bfc249e26fe6fcb07b3a9bde08a0f4e3a720aea18e1c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df478091a70743a999abeb2baea41c34e2248d8ae2f3e2a77809b09b8f9ba732"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54f67df6a0a7645a849a5766","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086485,"date":"2026-06-11T19:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to reassure the members that the Canada Infrastructure Bank and the infrastructure investments we make as a country follow the Canada Labour Code.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086485","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to reassure the members that the Canada Infrastructure Bank and the infrastructure investments we make as a country follow the Canada Labour Code.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","label":"Labour code"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","label":"Labour code","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a5e0991c56f7bd0f3838b8733acdb36aa2080dfc9b079f5de4a524c9161b2725"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e72a173e260104eaac96febb91a676ecb9e77db2f3af76c088f68311b4b446cb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64f67d8a61843a3f2ff6e4c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086486,"date":"2026-06-11T20:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for Peterborough for her great work in the community.\n\nYesterday was a great day for affordable housing. Despite the opposition of members opposite, who are against affordable housing, the government passed the Build Canada Homes act here in the House. This brings us one step closer to getting affordable housing built.\n\nBuild Canada Homes will become a Crown corporation with the support of the Senate. We are looking forward to working with our senators to secure the bill's final passage and get Build Canada Homes up and running and delivering affordable—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086486","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for Peterborough for her great work in the community.\n\nYesterday was a great day for affordable housing. Despite the opposition of members opposite, who are against affordable housing, the government passed the Build Canada Homes act here in the House. This brings us one step closer to getting affordable housing built.\n\nBuild Canada Homes will become a Crown corpora","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Urban planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","label":"Urban planning","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["76de84ee32a56c8c7193b5ed511520b03e472c17d4a22744d1856649a98d9e18"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["36c553c27e01f43758c4ae7c22ea46cdd92fc4976a5d3ee78eb2b521236f02c5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce32e21d383151391350ad1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088320,"date":"2026-06-16T21:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in relation to the consideration of Government Business No. 11, I move:\n\nThat debate be not further adjourned.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088320","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in relation to the consideration of Government Business No. 11, I move:\n\nThat debate be not further adjourned.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ff57e4c0852e853470161fd6a32851ff2958d42a760b9a9c36eee5ba1ddb5ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-374360ba2e14bcef3be824b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088321,"date":"2026-06-16T21:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, just to be clear, this debate is about the housing supply act before the House, which is about $1.7 billion that would be distributed among the provinces and territories to boost housing supply.\n\nWe already have an uptake on this with the province of Ontario. It was announced a few months ago. Ontario, thanks to the federal support that is tied to the bill, would be rebating the full 13% of the harmonized sales tax, the HST, on new homes up to $1 million. Buyers of those new homes up to $1 million could save up to $130,000. When we combine that with the initiative around reducing development charges, which is 30% to 50% with municipalities in Ontario and is administered by the province of Ontario, it is an additional up to $70,000.\n\nAll this is in response to the crisis that Ontario, particularly the GTA, has had with the housing market. There is oversupply in the housing market and other challenges, such as uncertainty in the market, buyers not buying and builders not being able to move on projects. This is about getting the housing market going across the country, particularly in Ontario and B.C.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088321","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, just to be clear, this debate is about the housing supply act before the House, which is about $1.7 billion that would be distributed among the provinces and territories to boost housing supply.\n\nWe already have an uptake on this with the province of Ontario. It was announced a few months ago. Ontario, thanks to the federal support that is tied to the bill, would be rebating the full ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75ecf545955f891ad93a1b86557d129acdce69a9022a2bea1728f62285ddafbb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e0abfdca12545b0114ed59b745a479fd203cf1012f0f1218b3e8abf6832342e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8680bdd8271ae1b4bcaf42ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088322,"date":"2026-06-16T22:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we absolutely cannot forget about the important housing needs in smaller communities. Rural Canada faces many of the same challenges in terms of affordability and housing supply. Particularly in the north, housing supply is a huge challenge.\n\nBuild Canada Homes is an agency focused on making sure the supply side is boosted, but in this case, the funding would be going to the provinces and territories. Ontario has given us the first example of what can be done. It is choosing to use its funding to effectively eliminate the HST for homebuyers throughout Ontario. It would benefit homebuyers and home builders, by extension, across all of Ontario, from urban to rural. Obviously that is a much-needed break on the HST for the homebuyers. That would be provided for in Ontario because of the housing supply bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088322","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we absolutely cannot forget about the important housing needs in smaller communities. Rural Canada faces many of the same challenges in terms of affordability and housing supply. Particularly in the north, housing supply is a huge challenge.\n\nBuild Canada Homes is an agency focused on making sure the supply side is boosted, but in this case, the funding would be going to the provinces","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["de1574b7ba5d3002f6a5638437340144a5e8b533068c9e8430c77459059507ea"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6fd5f5cba292e9bf481988c7d96b81ed5370b23aec8256c46fd0b00f1f13fd0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5335de8cd62a665e793f42c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088323,"date":"2026-06-16T22:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am stumped by the actions we just saw in the House from Conservatives, trying to adjourn the House for the day. They just voted to adjourn the House, but fortunately a majority of us are here to do the work and continue with the business of the House. We voted that adjournment motion down.\n\n We welcome the debate, in the case of this bill, to advance the work on housing supply. Housing is in a crisis across Canada, and we need to make sure affordability is paramount. The bill is about investing $1.7 billion in provinces and territories to boost their housing supply. It is a very simple, straightforward bill. There have been hours of debate on it. We can contrast that opportunity for members to speak to the bill with what happened yesterday in the House, when the Conservative member for Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford filibustered for hours, preventing many other members from being able to speak in the debate in the House. I know there are lots of games being played around adjournment and filibustering.\n\n The bill is about getting funding to the people on the ground in our country who need affordable housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088323","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am stumped by the actions we just saw in the House from Conservatives, trying to adjourn the House for the day. They just voted to adjourn the House, but fortunately a majority of us are here to do the work and continue with the business of the House. We voted that adjournment motion down.\n\n We welcome the debate, in the case of this bill, to advance the work on housing supply. Hous","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29bef14b0c91db4ed02abd34722ee21c8a107b8653e2616e3a30a87505c49ba2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ef619e9e7e9e71c83f3ffcf901711e88cf7b5c54c8c0083d83346f18f44bd10"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ebc904303c11b38e658d68d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088324,"date":"2026-06-16T22:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, with all due respect to our predecessors here in the House, there is about 40 years of history of the Government of Canada's neglecting to invest enough in affordable housing. That is what has created the housing crisis today. It has been built up over decades by governments of all stripes. There have been lots of challenges from the local, provincial and territorial levels in not expediting and not approving housing. The challenges have mounted over many years.\n\n The government has now been elected to take action. That is what advancing the bill is about: to make sure we are investing, working collaboratively with provinces and territories to get housing built and to get the housing market going again. I know that the opposition housing critic has been very vocal about supporting getting the housing market going. Ontario and B.C. are two of the provinces that are really challenged on housing supply and market. We need to get this money invested on the ground as quickly as possible.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088324","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, with all due respect to our predecessors here in the House, there is about 40 years of history of the Government of Canada's neglecting to invest enough in affordable housing. That is what has created the housing crisis today. It has been built up over decades by governments of all stripes. There have been lots of challenges from the local, provincial and territorial levels in not exp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a94d225ada24bde7bba487d03ed18ea61d71df7c7e77cef4e575ef3ecbbbb09e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["066d4306c0604b252a6ce4ccb9a37ede174175707fcbc4d1c8ffea334de98133"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa74a63a9d3a9f069831c511","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088325,"date":"2026-06-16T22:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-26 would be one tool in a large tool box that we need to activate to get the housing market turned around here in Canada, to get more affordable housing built, to make sure we have a healthy housing market and to make sure the homebuilding industry is innovating and advancing to make housing more affordable. This would be one tool in collaboration with the provinces and territories. It would be a direct investment, a transfer, and would give them the flexibility to apply it where needed.\n\nOntario is choosing to eliminate its HST for this year, which I think is having a very positive effect on the market in Ontario. Other provinces and territories would have different approaches depending on their markets, but we have many other tools from Build Canada Homes and reaching home, which is supporting homelessness efforts, to the housing accelerator fund, which works with communities and local governments to cut red tape and get housing built.\n\n We have a wide array of tools. We need to continue scaling up the work on those tools, scaling up the investment that is needed to ensure that we have enough affordable housing being built, and to make sure that as a House we are here supporting the efforts and collaboration with all levels of government and the private sector.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088325","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-26 would be one tool in a large tool box that we need to activate to get the housing market turned around here in Canada, to get more affordable housing built, to make sure we have a healthy housing market and to make sure the homebuilding industry is innovating and advancing to make housing more affordable. This would be one tool in collaboration with the provinces and territo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2d8943fccdf9cec41be36af12490b0775a45e432aaddeeb23f5f0eb9c7cc82a6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6bcb6d2ec843a091a7e7da4cf8969dc2aeb82437777c31575b9ce84e07c5a37e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7aff023a0d67c18b9f9ab415","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088326,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if the members of the opposition are so insistent on debate time, why did they just vote to adjourn the House in the middle of the day on a Tuesday? It does not add up.\n\nThe bill is all about focusing on delivering results for the housing market, particularly in the member opposite's province, where I live too, B.C. The housing market in metro Vancouver is extremely challenged right now. The Province of B.C. would have the opportunity to deploy this funding to get the province's market going. That is an example. I think we have seen that already happen with Ontario as the first mover taking action to eliminate its HST.\n\nWe need to get this funding out to communities. That is the priority. It is a very simple and straightforward bill about collaborating, investing in our provinces and territories and making sure that housing is built across Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088326","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if the members of the opposition are so insistent on debate time, why did they just vote to adjourn the House in the middle of the day on a Tuesday? It does not add up.\n\nThe bill is all about focusing on delivering results for the housing market, particularly in the member opposite's province, where I live too, B.C. The housing market in metro Vancouver is extremely challenged right n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["61e2db2d8a6e878769a26087a7ac664c24a3bce59eeb3b97a93117a63d76aca8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce2ef90328c547f2504de3ec4574ae9bca1bc53b5421ba85cfebca738d9d515f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad7b782c802ba9ed6e1c2faf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088327,"date":"2026-06-16T22:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think we need to look at what is happening in the member opposite's province. Ontario has been first out of the gate, accepting this funding and deploying it to eliminate the HST, for which members opposite have been calling for months, to take action. I think both sides of the House agree we need to take action to get the housing market going in Ontario and B.C., where it has been stalled. This has done that in Ontario. Ontario is a good example of making a good choice to eliminate the HST for this year and prime the pump on its housing market. That is an example of what we want to see across the country.\n\nWe would not be prescriptive with provinces and territories. We would be responsive to the needs across the country. We want to be sure that Ontario and B.C. markets are addressed, as they are in a state of relative crisis, but we want to have flexibility with this too. It is a very simple next step and a statement of collaboration with provinces and territories that we would entrust them to do the right thing and take action to deliver on housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088327","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think we need to look at what is happening in the member opposite's province. Ontario has been first out of the gate, accepting this funding and deploying it to eliminate the HST, for which members opposite have been calling for months, to take action. I think both sides of the House agree we need to take action to get the housing market going in Ontario and B.C., where it has been ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f00c05fc2279c3166b2c592ba69ada7e3e6640e4cea25b7e4c055cb8548616fe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0af4291b6bd065bb1fd911c2ecb249b418dddecac6dd5ea45c1de2d76b1bd63"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5b8b18b0b4cb4658946c965","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088328,"date":"2026-06-16T22:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the investment in housing for first nations on reserve is something the Minister of Indigenous Services is responsible for. She currently has an indigenous housing process going to build a strategy, which I will be happy to collaborate with her on. There is indigenous housing funding as well in Build Canada Homes that is focused on urban, rural and northern indigenous housing, which is about a $4‐billion envelope. There are a number of different opportunities for indigenous housing.\n\nWith this housing supply bill, we are talking about $1.7 billion to the provinces and territories, giving them the discretion to deploy that funding as needed. Some may choose to work with indigenous populations to invest that money on housing. That is their choice.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088328","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the investment in housing for first nations on reserve is something the Minister of Indigenous Services is responsible for. She currently has an indigenous housing process going to build a strategy, which I will be happy to collaborate with her on. There is indigenous housing funding as well in Build Canada Homes that is focused on urban, rural and northern indigenous housing, which i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7a2bf60836873e2e4db7ea3bd3683a06a9503e4bc5dd3215408b0802074cf082"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7cdd3df11958e7cbaa6e68bd652b164e26ab71d91aa610c27165b8b357d1a34c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21e1aa0fd8fa9c1c1f411217","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088329,"date":"2026-06-16T22:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, first and foremost, on process, I have spoken to the urgency and simplicity of this bill in entrusting provinces and territories with taking action and deploying this funding to get housing supply scaled up in their jurisdictions. As we have seen with Ontario eliminating the HST, we already have a good example of what can be done.\n\nI think the collaboration piece is really critical here. We do rely upon provinces and territories. A member opposite had a question about building codes. There are attempts to harmonize on or to have a smoother flow for the supply chains for homebuilding materials, Canadian materials in particular, and for labour, workers and expertise across the country. We want the provinces and territories working on team Canada to get more housing built.\n\nI think it is really critical that, right now, we are investing across the board to facilitate more housing getting built and more interchange between provinces and territories to get that done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088329","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, first and foremost, on process, I have spoken to the urgency and simplicity of this bill in entrusting provinces and territories with taking action and deploying this funding to get housing supply scaled up in their jurisdictions. As we have seen with Ontario eliminating the HST, we already have a good example of what can be done.\n\nI think the collaboration piece is really critical he","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a709d33b22242e3caaa70e4b660f7195d88ca32701d7875c7fa666e90792bc5d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a85f6021ea986e1bdfeb621a015dc4fb7d059eeae204d4bae48796c4e4752663"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fe02847c693630366385b64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088330,"date":"2026-06-16T22:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite well knows that I have appeared before HUMA a number of times to talk about the initiatives we have, as a government, to get affordable housing going, to get Build Canada Homes up and running as a Crown corporation so that it can drive the pace in getting affordable housing built. I have been at HUMA. I have been at other committees as well to make sure we are doing everything we can to advance the work on affordable housing. I will certainly be in front of HUMA again many more times as the housing minister.\n\nWhat we are talking about with this bill is advancing it so we can accelerate, so we can invest in the provinces and territories to get housing supply boosted across Canada right now. It is very simple and straightforward. Members opposite may not want to support investing in provinces and territories. They may not want to invest $1.7 billion in scaling up housing supply. This is an opportunity to say yes to that, and I encourage the members—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088330","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite well knows that I have appeared before HUMA a number of times to talk about the initiatives we have, as a government, to get affordable housing going, to get Build Canada Homes up and running as a Crown corporation so that it can drive the pace in getting affordable housing built. I have been at HUMA. I have been at other committees as well to make sure we are doin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6c97c9781c987f399376b6dc6480fa045cdddeff324b4072b4adc88e4d665c79"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5d9191f56885aa122378a826fdac64dc3c311cd618b215633023a979cecd471"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06130c52917fc6ab2048a634","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088331,"date":"2026-06-16T22:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, again, I am a bit surprised to hear this commentary from the members opposite. We are in a housing crisis. We need to move urgently to solve this, to fix this. We need to work with our provinces and territories to do that. We rely on their leadership as well. \n\nIt is a simple question: Does she support investing $1.7 billion, boosting housing supply with provinces and territories? The members opposite may not agree. It is a very simple next step to increase the federal government's investment in housing. This is what is before us right now. I encourage the members to support this so we can get this out as soon as possible and get housing built.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088331","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, again, I am a bit surprised to hear this commentary from the members opposite. We are in a housing crisis. We need to move urgently to solve this, to fix this. We need to work with our provinces and territories to do that. We rely on their leadership as well. \n\nIt is a simple question: Does she support investing $1.7 billion, boosting housing supply with provinces and territories? The","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d36224daea43907225b65d73f7d7c7693bb08b3dbd69600dd6b35e05a495ecf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["96ee9b314b322ee2c085f4612faf6179e5b7ebbbe3c566d8954b40917ed180bd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4092b737f9883941e2dc5168","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088332,"date":"2026-06-16T22:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, well, I have a very simple question for the members opposite: Do they support working with the Government of Ontario to eliminate the HST for one year on new homes up to $1 million? \n\nThis is exactly what Ontario is doing with the funding related to this housing supply bill. This is exactly what it is doing. It has committed the funding. If the members opposite support giving Ontarians a break on buying a new home up to $1 million, with $130,000 off $1 million, that is what the bill is all about. This is what Ontario is doing. If the Conservatives vote against the bill, they are voting against giving people in Ontario a break on buying a new home and giving home builders in Ontario an opportunity to get more active and make sure they are driving up supply in Ontario. That is what this is about.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088332","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, well, I have a very simple question for the members opposite: Do they support working with the Government of Ontario to eliminate the HST for one year on new homes up to $1 million? \n\nThis is exactly what Ontario is doing with the funding related to this housing supply bill. This is exactly what it is doing. It has committed the funding. If the members opposite support giving Ontarian","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dfe5a58cac2389f56e90d8dafe5ab729fd8b256206f69f67431708c0f86d1b5a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a41e034584eebc5285398b4b3882d98b0e265351eeea55d56b804632b91240d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b74f0e778b8acc25573fc4a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088333,"date":"2026-06-16T22:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with the member. The importance of getting this done is urgent. Really, the example in Ontario is what we are working with. It shows the difference this can make on the ground for the housing market, homebuyers and home builders in Ontario, who need to get going on building more supply. \n\nThat is the result we are seeing already in Ontario. We met with developers over the last few weeks. The Prime Minister and I were told that we are seeing a 60% to 70% increase in sales volume here in Ottawa, and that is because of the Ontario HST elimination this year. Therefore, we are seeing a direct benefit of the Ontario partnership here. \n\nI expect we will see this with provinces and territories across the country as this funding is approved and deployed. This is about collaboration and a partnership of trust. It is about getting the money to the communities and the people, ultimately, so they can buy homes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088333","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with the member. The importance of getting this done is urgent. Really, the example in Ontario is what we are working with. It shows the difference this can make on the ground for the housing market, homebuyers and home builders in Ontario, who need to get going on building more supply. \n\nThat is the result we are seeing already in Ontario. We met with developers over the last","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c34aefe49f65b682fde2aedf2663328d2d7a8cb95a5c3a66f7754e87495553cd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["026987d0a794f05745f8f1f87d58d399076826f3a39467fa32aa97466abc0528"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5d8cd53d8dac6678d3f7972","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088334,"date":"2026-06-16T22:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would say to the member opposite that we need to look at the Ontario example of how this funding is being used. The Ontario government has chosen to deploy it for eliminating the HST for this year to get its housing market going. Getting that housing market going by giving people a discount effectively on a new home is advancing the market. It is getting home builders back to building, because they know the market is coming back alive. \n\nI have heard from the members opposite that this has been a crisis, particularly in the GTA, that is related to the housing market. This is how the Ontario government, in partnership with us and resourced by this housing supply bill, is getting that market going and getting homebuyers into homes more affordably. \n\nWe want to see that happen across the country. I know the provinces and territories have different approaches depending on their markets and their housing contexts. I am looking forward to seeing this deployed in B.C., in my home province, because the metro Vancouver market has very similar challenges to those of the GTA, and I want to see that change. We are receiving a lot of pressure from home builders who are concerned about the markets being flat. That is not surprising given the uncertainty in the world. This is a way to help jump-start and accelerate the markets and get more homes built.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088334","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would say to the member opposite that we need to look at the Ontario example of how this funding is being used. The Ontario government has chosen to deploy it for eliminating the HST for this year to get its housing market going. Getting that housing market going by giving people a discount effectively on a new home is advancing the market. It is getting home builders back to buildi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business start-ups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","label":"Business start-ups","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01778e7e0cc5bcca938e99f483756caa125197a3e85f914dc83730ff499bd57c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2ae21031185479fa457125db580dceac0a63d3d7b620dafa24252ce8522d157b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1499c9c989df3f074437381","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1088335,"date":"2026-06-17T02:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gregor Robertson","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that Bill C-26, An Act to authorize certain payments to be made out of the Consolidated Revenue Fund for the purpose of improving housing supply, be read the second time and referred to a committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1088335","member_id":"bc-mp-123644","member_name":"Gregor Robertson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"moved that Bill C-26, An Act to authorize certain payments to be made out of the Consolidated Revenue Fund for the purpose of improving housing supply, be read the second time and referred to a committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c04733b7f00b0f13670678f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86105,"date":"2026-02-02T23:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know some people think one should not do this after February 1, but I would like to wish you a happy new year, because it is the first time I have been able to engage with you.\n\nThe purpose of Canada's industrial carbon pricing system is straightforward and fair. Large producers should take responsibility for the pollution they produce. That is the principle at the heart of the policy and one that Canadians understand instinctively. When pollution has real costs for our health, our environment, our economy and our future, those costs should not be absorbed by families, taxpayers or future generations. Instead, it seems that the opposition has not taken the time to understand the substance of our environmental policies. \n\nWhat I do know is, within billions, the $57 billion in decarbonization relating to industrial carbon pricing infrastructure. \n\nThe industrial carbon pricing system is not a tax designated to punish industry. It is a performance-based system that applies only to Canada's largest emitters and is carefully calibrated to maintain competitiveness while driving cleaner growth. Facilities are charged only on emissions above a set standard, which rewards companies that operate more efficiently and invest in cleaner technologies. Those that innovate pay less; those that pollute more are expected to pay more. \n\nThis approach is essential for Canada's economic future. Global markets are moving quickly toward low-carbon production. Major trading partners are introducing carbon border measures and clean procurement standards. Countries that fail to reduce industrial emissions will face growing trade barriers and investment risks. Industrial carbon pricing helps ensure Canadian products remain competitive in a world that increasingly values low-emissions production. \n\nThe system also provides flexibility. Facilities can reduce emissions directly, improve efficiency, switch fuels, generate credits or purchase credits from others that outperform their targets. This market-based design keeps costs down and allows businesses to choose the most cost-effective path forward, rather than imposing rigid rules or blanket changes. \n\nIt is also important to be clear about what this policy does and does not do. It does not apply to families at the checkout counter, it does not apply to farms, and it is not the driver of rising grocery prices. Food inflation has been shaped by global energy shocks, supply chain disruptions, climate-related crop losses and international market volatility, pressures that are being felt well beyond our country's borders. \n\nAbandoning the polluter pays principle would not make Canada more competitive; it would make us less prepared. It would leave Canadian industries exposed to future trade penalties and undermine the investments already under way to modernize our economy. Our approach ensures that heavy industry does its fair share, innovation is rewarded, and Canada remains a strong, credible trading partner in a rapidly changing global economy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86105","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know some people think one should not do this after February 1, but I would like to wish you a happy new year, because it is the first time I have been able to engage with you.\n\nThe purpose of Canada's industrial carbon pricing system is straightforward and fair. Large producers should take responsibility for the pollution they produce. That is the principle at the heart of the poli","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["275ed76a701b70b2ad7fc3456ecace8ef2705c177b028e2feb58ac3281871fb2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff9acced4086a56e7d629ab6d6cb6db9cf8e13bca43513ee72f6c7f902461597"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2df6168670c7f253d45ef782","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86106,"date":"2026-02-02T23:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, industrial carbon pricing is about fairness and economic responsibility. When pollution imposes real costs, those costs should be borne by the largest emitters, not by families and not by farmers. The system is designed to protect industrial competitiveness, reward efficiency and align Canada with global clean market rules. Scrapping it would not lower grocery prices or strengthen industry; it would weaken Canada's position at a time when clean production is becoming a condition for access to global markets.\n\n Our focus is clear. It remains on a strong economy, fair rules and long-term competitiveness.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86106","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, industrial carbon pricing is about fairness and economic responsibility. When pollution imposes real costs, those costs should be borne by the largest emitters, not by families and not by farmers. The system is designed to protect industrial competitiveness, reward efficiency and align Canada with global clean market rules. Scrapping it would not lower grocery prices or strengthen ind","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["70fcf9d3fdbc13fd04faec113fabb027acc00fdaa6d81b89fc5e8fb16b1d34c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["171f4d724e19acd4a3af2efce3637e11def82ab2687787ee29615ebcb7954fea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08906d0fd52f9d2bfc453f1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86104,"date":"2026-02-03T19:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today with a heavy heart but in celebration of one of my matriarchs. Barbara \"Mary\" Charles passed away at the age of 96 last year.\n\nBetter known to thousands as Aunty Mary, she grew up as a Tsleil-Waututh member, went to a Catholic day school for much of her youth and at 17 married into Musqueam. She had 13 children and became the leader of her family, but also a leader in Musqueam as a councillor for over 40 years and engaged in the Sparrow case that proved our right to fish for food, social and ceremonial purposes.\n\nAfter her time as a councillor, she became a cultural ambassador for Musqueam, welcoming dignitaries, royalty, celebrities and even politicians. In fact, the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure once called her his rock. \n\nAs we move forward, I want to raise my hands to my aunt and end this speech for everyone in the House the way she would end it, by saying, \"May your days be filled with joy. May your successes be frequent. May you find peace and comfort, and may your hearts always know how special you all are.\"\n\nHay čxw q̓ə.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86104","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today with a heavy heart but in celebration of one of my matriarchs. Barbara \"Mary\" Charles passed away at the age of 96 last year.\n\nBetter known to thousands as Aunty Mary, she grew up as a Tsleil-Waututh member, went to a Catholic day school for much of her youth and at 17 married into Musqueam. She had 13 children and became the leader of her family, but also a leader in Mus","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00708e5b0f705aa5d401a10f2542825db4e65f1e9697a76c328ecf40e44271f8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9ccb46881e4c64a938ea195","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86102,"date":"2026-02-06T17:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, as a father of two young children, aged 15 and 17, I know how important it is to ensure that we think about the health and safety of our children and youth. We will work hard in ensuring that they are not in any danger moving forward.\n\nThat is what we will continue to do on this side of the House, and I really look forward to working with both sides of the House to ensure the safety of our young children moving forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86102","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, as a father of two young children, aged 15 and 17, I know how important it is to ensure that we think about the health and safety of our children and youth. We will work hard in ensuring that they are not in any danger moving forward.\n\nThat is what we will continue to do on this side of the House, and I really look forward to working with both sides of the House to ensure the safety","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01d6d770653c83807f6b7b1feabb9057c54770ef749a601a358e08d648d77267"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f31ddbf3d42a46a5e304761","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86103,"date":"2026-02-06T17:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I welcome the member's question. I will work with him after question period to find a solution with the member.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86103","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I welcome the member's question. I will work with him after question period to find a solution with the member.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce90b06645b6d7d7aa90639c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299633,"date":"2026-02-12T23:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I just want to make sure we make it clear that the member is presenting a picture of the industrial carbon pricing system that simply does not reflect how it works or to whom it applies. There is no carbon tax on food, and farmers are not subject to the industrial carbon price. That is a fact. Independent modelling backs this up.\n\n An analysis from the Canadian Climate Institute and Navius Research shows that the economic effect on industrial carbon pricing on consumption will be extremely small, less than one-tenth of one per cent by 2030. Industrial carbon pricing has essentially no impact on the agricultural sector. The same analysis projects that the cumulative GDP impact on the agricultural sector would be 0.08% by 2030. Farmers do not directly pay the industrial carbon tax, and there are almost no costs passed to consumers.\n\n The system in question applies only to large industrial emitters: the steel, cement, oil and gas, mining and other heavy industries. It was designed so the biggest polluters, not smaller operations like Canadian farmers, are the ones carrying the costs. The intent is straightforward: Cut emissions from major industrial facilities while protecting competitiveness and keeping jobs here in Canada.\n\nUnder the federal system, industries have several compliance options. They can make their operations more efficient, including by adopting new technologies; they can generate or buy credits from cleaner performers; or they can pay the carbon price. This is not a one-size-fits-all levy; it is a flexible framework that rewards innovation, drives investment and minimizes cost impacts across the economy.\n\nWhen Canadians see higher grocery bills, the main drivers are global: disrupted shipping routes, climate-related crop impacts, and the cascading effects of Russia's illegal invasion of Ukraine on fertilizer and energy markets. These are the same pressures facing consumers in Europe, in the United States and around the world.\n\nOur government has taken concrete steps to support producers, and it continues targeted support through the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act. We continue to work with farmers and not against them. The idea that scrapping the industrial carbon pricing would suddenly make fruit from the Okanagan cheaper is simply not rooted in evidence. Eliminating climate policy will not reverse climate-related crop losses. It will not stabilize global supply chains, and it will not protect Canadian industries from carbon border measures being implemented by our trading partners.\n\nClimate action and economic strength go hand in hand. We will continue to deliver on both. That is what this side of the House promises.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299633","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I just want to make sure we make it clear that the member is presenting a picture of the industrial carbon pricing system that simply does not reflect how it works or to whom it applies. There is no carbon tax on food, and farmers are not subject to the industrial carbon price. That is a fact. Independent modelling backs this up.\n\n An analysis from the Canadian Climate Institute and N","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035950","label":"International markets","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e9b0af7b8b1114dff5338d5a601bf3342f891edd2f5c211d373c6c53645396dc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["34b90634202c2cf3d4171c61288dcfa91fba9bdcffc4754038766752cd2b24d8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa4d09a1cd88bbe41971ae9d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299634,"date":"2026-02-13T00:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will repeat this because it matters: Farmers do not pay the industrial carbon price, and groceries are not subject to the carbon price. Industrial carbon pricing focuses only on major emitters and gives them practical options to reduce pollution at the lowest possible cost, while it also drives investment in clean technology in Canada.\n\n If the opposition succeeded in dismantling these tools, it would not lower food prices. It would increase pollution, reduce investor certainty and place Canadian industries at a competitive disadvantage as other countries move toward cleaner production.\n\nOur government will stay focused on affordability, economic resilience and a cleaner future for Canadian workers and families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299634","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will repeat this because it matters: Farmers do not pay the industrial carbon price, and groceries are not subject to the carbon price. Industrial carbon pricing focuses only on major emitters and gives them practical options to reduce pollution at the lowest possible cost, while it also drives investment in clean technology in Canada.\n\n If the opposition succeeded in dismantling th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","label":"Pollution prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035328","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035328","label":"Food processing","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","label":"Pollution prevention","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28b758d0a5b42b1057c1fe72ade79112498b284799e42eecd479a6daa0debb38"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73fa14f263ebb94c9e7a637dedce42e9e767256f2ef6d566b1fa6fa53bf2d30a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b7838fe9aa3a1ea8373c7b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299632,"date":"2026-02-13T16:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from British Columbia for the question. I am so proud to stand on this side of the House as we build Canada strong from coast to coast to coast. Building Canada's housing is very important not only in cities and provinces but in first nations communities. I live in a first nations community with a housing list of over 500 people. These people want to come home to their communities. That is why I am so proud of this new policy. It is why I know my children are going to be able to live where they please with their families for future generations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299632","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from British Columbia for the question. I am so proud to stand on this side of the House as we build Canada strong from coast to coast to coast. Building Canada's housing is very important not only in cities and provinces but in first nations communities. I live in a first nations community with a housing list of over 500 people. These people want to come home to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0854bbea8103e004a25a9250244f344f094d5b09402776336463309ba254777b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d6ce380a0295f6169ef0f2e3f1d66f52b81b691f49bd0e17e0036b70653a0b0a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33a4244d4592fced4ed1de80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":311357,"date":"2026-02-25T00:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise to engage with my dear colleague from Saanich—Gulf Islands.\n\nThe government does and will always take climate change commitments very seriously. In 2015, Canada, alongside 194 other countries, adopted the Paris Agreement under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. The agreement sets a global goal to limit warming, strengthen resilience and align financial flows with low emissions and climate-resilient development. In addition, almost every country in the world, including Canada, has committed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and preparing for the impacts that climate change presents.\n\n Our government recognizes that climate action is both a moral responsibility and an economic necessity. Budget 2025 sets Canada on a path to meet our legally binding commitments, while building a strong, resilient economy. This includes cutting greenhouse gas emissions and addressing the impacts of climate change. Our climate competitiveness strategy in budget 2025 drives these outcomes while building a resilient economy. As the Prime Minister has stated, this budget puts us on a path for real results for climate, for nature and for reconciliation with indigenous peoples. We respect our Paris commitments, and we are determined to achieve them.\n\n Industrial carbon pricing is central to Canada's climate strategy. It is designed not only to reduce emissions but also to unlock investment in clean technologies, support Canadian industries and maintain our competitiveness in global markets. By putting a price on pollution for large industrial polluters, we drive decarbonization, support innovation and create good jobs, while keeping energy and goods affordable.\n\n Strong industrial carbon markets also help Canada maintain trade relationships with partners like Europe and the U.K., ensuring that our exports meet the growing global demand for low-carbon products.\n\nWe are also investing in adaptation. The national adaptation strategy, supported by the Government of Canada adaptation action plan, lays out more than 70 actions to protect communities, improve health outcomes, safeguard nature and support a resilient economy. Since 2015, Canada has invested over $6.6 billion in adaptation, including new funding in budget 2025 for community infrastructure and youth-focused initiatives.\n\n The Government of Canada has a fundamental commitment to reconciliation and respects indigenous peoples as equal partners in the country we are building together. If I did not believe that, I would not be standing on this side of the House. The government supports the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and invests in indigenous-led climate solutions. Since 2020, over $2 billion has been committed to indigenous climate action, including funds for clean energy, energy efficiency and resiliency. Indigenous knowledge and leadership are critical to achieving meaningful, long-term and long-lasting change.\n\nThe Government of Canada is fully committed to delivering on its climate obligations, supporting adaptation, advancing nature protection and working with indigenous peoples across this country to ensure a sustainable, resilient and prosperous Canada for all.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:311357","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise to engage with my dear colleague from Saanich—Gulf Islands.\n\nThe government does and will always take climate change commitments very seriously. In 2015, Canada, alongside 194 other countries, adopted the Paris Agreement under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. The agreement sets a global goal to limit warming, strengthen resilie","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["85fb294eb5b557e5daf119bd5b01e7c9ad3fd3b802b5557a0ac33393e83fe00a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c12b9da08de3faac7b2ad1db2a4320273749a8941a5b73ded5c51b0a4370e1d4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06f57f6b709591a820d843ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":311358,"date":"2026-02-25T00:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I just want to address the fact that Canada's climate strategy is about more than meeting commitments; it is also about building a safer, stronger and more prosperous country. By putting a price on pollution, investing in clean energy and supporting indigenous-led solutions, we are reducing emissions while creating jobs and economic opportunity.\n\nOur national adaptation strategy and action plan help communities prepare for climate risks, protect biodiversity and build resilience. Canada remains fully engaged internationally, reporting under the Paris Agreement and working with partners to ensure that our climate actions are effective. We are committed to measurable results for climate, for nature and for reconciliation. That is not only for today, but that also is for many generations to come.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:311358","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I just want to address the fact that Canada's climate strategy is about more than meeting commitments; it is also about building a safer, stronger and more prosperous country. By putting a price on pollution, investing in clean energy and supporting indigenous-led solutions, we are reducing emissions while creating jobs and economic opportunity.\n\nOur national adaptation strategy and a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea994a7fa2d426f9c990533a37a7c6f05a082447e5a0c99f7eaf2b58a6ab4749"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["886679882fa05324796ebbee5c695d1f6e8d9d4b058881fb623640f867791c74"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4ddfb89516581b559d4f3e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":311356,"date":"2026-02-27T16:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, before I came to this side of the House, I was so excited when the national school food program was put forward. I grew up in a first nations community among many kids who lived below the poverty line. When I go down to my community centre, I watch kids go into our community centre. They get breakfast, they get lunch and they go to school with a full belly.\n\nWhen I graduated from high school, I was one of very few who graduated from high school. Now we are seeing kids graduate in record numbers in my community. I have no doubt that it is because of the nutritious breakfasts and lunches they get.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:311356","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, before I came to this side of the House, I was so excited when the national school food program was put forward. I grew up in a first nations community among many kids who lived below the poverty line. When I go down to my community centre, I watch kids go into our community centre. They get breakfast, they get lunch and they go to school with a full belly.\n\nWhen I graduated from high","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","label":"Functional foods","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["02bbb0b95975dba74813ee8e6ddbf9ca7ae227f2b1b6466bae3d4148d0057ddd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9244c318dc565b83dc7790478d88b7bbbaea9ef5e29f44463a7af75dd4c5dab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c8f6e6f8e280c68a653e9b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390276,"date":"2026-03-23T19:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today with a heavy heart to pay tribute to a man I was lucky enough to get to know over the last 10 years. David Barnett of my riding of Vancouver Quadra passed away on February 5 at the age of 53, after a courageous battle with a rare and aggressive form of cancer. \n\nDave was executive vice-president of the Dayhu Group of Companies, working alongside his brother Jonathan to build on their family's 70-year legacy in real estate.\n\nHowever, what I will remember him for and what he may be best remembered for is founding the Music Heals Charitable Foundation with his wife Sara Ferguson. Together, they helped fund music therapy programs across British Columbia and Canada with over $5 million.\n\n David's life was far too short, but his impact was undoubtedly profound. He was known for his kindness, his generosity and his warmth.\n\n I offer my heartfelt condolences to his wife Sara; their children Asher, Cassidy and Zoe; and his parents Shirley and Peter. May his memory be for a blessing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390276","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today with a heavy heart to pay tribute to a man I was lucky enough to get to know over the last 10 years. David Barnett of my riding of Vancouver Quadra passed away on February 5 at the age of 53, after a courageous battle with a rare and aggressive form of cancer. \n\nDave was executive vice-president of the Dayhu Group of Companies, working alongside his brother Jonathan to bu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0f38cfe502cfa434c92bcd2fd388ac39788af41470ef386f4b246a9520169f2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5307fb99dacb9d71acd34bf5a6d6c5a1bceede260130316402323c313d2d408"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b91f38d47e73587c6e51b9c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390277,"date":"2026-03-24T00:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, with regard to the particular matter raised by my colleague, it would not be appropriate for a minister or parliamentary secretary to indicate an opinion on criminality. This is a matter for law enforcement and the courts to determine. However, it is important to acknowledge the member's concerns.\n\nCanada's new government takes financial crimes seriously. This is why our government has introduced the first-ever national anti-fraud strategy through budget 2025. We have committed more resources to the RCMP, to a new Canadian financial crimes agency and to stronger FINTRAC authorities in order to better prevent and respond to financial wrongdoing accusations. The new financial crimes agency will bring together the required expertise to investigate crimes such as money laundering, online fraud and financial scams, and recover criminals' illicit proceeds.\n\nFor some prior context on the matter at hand, the government announced a contribution through the strategic innovation fund with Lion Electric in March 2021, of which $31 million has been disbursed according to the public accounts of Canada audit. This loan was paid out as a partially repayable contribution to Lion Electric, which the government continues to monitor as Justice Canada and the court-appointed trustees evaluate the next steps.\n\nIn this new global era, we know that unjustified U.S. tariffs have impacted our industries. These we cannot control but we can control our responses. We can work with the industries to strengthen the Canadian economy. The company has unfortunately faced a number of financial challenges, which resulted in the company seeking creditor protection in late 2024 and ultimately being sold to a group of Quebec-based investors in 2025.\n\nAs we continue to modernize our response to the changing global landscape and work closely with our cross-government partners, we will continue to ensure that Canadian taxpayers get responsible governance and responsible use of taxpayers' dollars, to create a stronger, more resilient Canadian economy.\n\nIt is absolutely vital, in this time of global uncertainty, that Canada remains focused on economic development, protecting and creating jobs, and attracting talent, both home and abroad, as well as investments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390277","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, with regard to the particular matter raised by my colleague, it would not be appropriate for a minister or parliamentary secretary to indicate an opinion on criminality. This is a matter for law enforcement and the courts to determine. However, it is important to acknowledge the member's concerns.\n\nCanada's new government takes financial crimes seriously. This is why our government ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a56de4c426d3b6fa79137fe7ca16600b7ff901369e7efc9d90c8cfaae3757bae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3896b78b0ba347fef3b05f1e337917692e532177fe292552a25d6b492dcb2d95"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80766938f418ea19ea5d1646","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390511,"date":"2026-03-24T00:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let me be absolutely clear. We will not tolerate financial wrongdoing. \n\nBudget 2025 introduced new, strengthened measures to ensure stronger financial oversight and improved detection and prevention of financial crimes across Canada. We are committed to ensuring that our industries are not only protected from this current global environment, but strengthened and able to adapt to changing conditions. We will continue to ensure that public funds are safeguarded and used responsibly, while acting decisively to support responsible innovation efforts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390511","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let me be absolutely clear. We will not tolerate financial wrongdoing. \n\nBudget 2025 introduced new, strengthened measures to ensure stronger financial oversight and improved detection and prevention of financial crimes across Canada. We are committed to ensuring that our industries are not only protected from this current global environment, but strengthened and able to adapt to chan","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76b1088cedf0da729473fc3622c46c5047bc98dbbaff4f71a72ab817144a6211"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be55e1e879e2ac0f7bf4d42ddf32b247af371b1893d6276fada874e4aaa55aae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ca2de962409120c29b267ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390512,"date":"2026-03-24T00:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let me be clear that I and this government take food affordability concerns seriously. We know that families across the country are feeling the pressure of higher grocery bills. That is why earlier this year we introduced the Canada grocery and essentials benefit, previously the GST credit. This new benefit will boost payments to Canadians by 25% for five years plus a one-time 50% increase, delivering up to $1,890 to families nationwide. This is significant money to help with rising costs, including for families in my own community of the Musqueam First Nation. \n\nTo understand the cost of rising food prices, it is important that we have an honest conversation about what is actually driving prices and what our policies are designed to do. Food prices in Canada—\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nWade Grant: Mr. Speaker, I have two young kids, so it is okay. I have dealt with people yelling at me when I am trying to do my job.\n\n Food prices in Canada, as in many countries, have been influenced by a range of global factors. Supply chain disruptions, geopolitical instability, extreme weather and rising production costs have always played a role in putting pressure on food systems worldwide. These are challenges that farmers and producers are facing not just here in Canada, but across the globe.\n\n With respect to Canada's climate policies, it is important to clarify the facts. Canada's industrial carbon pricing system applies to large industrial emitters. It is designed to encourage efficiency and cleaner production while protecting the competitiveness of Canadian industries that operate in global markets. It does not apply to individual Canadians or to farms, and it is structured specifically to avoid driving investment or jobs out of this country. This approach ensures that Canadian industries remain competitive as more and more international markets place a premium on low-carbon production. Rolling back these policies would not lower grocery bills, but would introduce uncertainty for business owners and risk, leaving Canadian exporters at higher exposure to carbon border measures, which key trading partners are already putting in place.\n\n The same principle applies to the clean fuel regulations. These regulations set performance standards for fuel suppliers and provide multiple flexible options for compliance, including blending low-carbon fuels or investing in cleaner production. They do not mandate a specific price increase at the pump, and the actual impact depends on how suppliers choose to comply. Independent analysis indicates that the overall impact on fuel prices is expected to remain modest. Suggestions that we cancel the clean fuel regulations are misguided. They have supported billions of dollars of investments in clean fuel projects while supporting sustainable jobs across Canada.\n\n In short, climate action and affordability are not competing goals. Well-designed climate policies are supporting innovation and investment in Canada's energy sector while reducing emissions that contribute to climate change. That matters because climate change itself is already affecting food production through droughts, floods and other extreme weather events that disrupt harvests and supply chains. Climate action and economic resilience go hand in hand. Our approach is to support farmers and producers, strengthen competition and ensure that Canada's economy remains strong and competitive in the changing global market while also protecting the environment and public health for future generations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390512","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let me be clear that I and this government take food affordability concerns seriously. We know that families across the country are feeling the pressure of higher grocery bills. That is why earlier this year we introduced the Canada grocery and essentials benefit, previously the GST credit. This new benefit will boost payments to Canadians by 25% for five years plus a one-time 50% inc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eaaca52c36b94cac1156aa50223795368636806358a661b6c8d2ddee5c287ff5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5680ec1f7c4029d4718b494ad4c04838a2f5da3403e155b62f9ad794312251fa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6474528ec8b87c361494394a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390513,"date":"2026-03-24T00:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the government will not take steps that weaken Canada's competitiveness or create uncertainty for industries that support good jobs in this country.\n\n Industrial carbon pricing and the clean fuel regulations are carefully designed policies that reduce emissions while protecting Canadian competitiveness and encouraging innovation. They provide flexibility for businesses, maintain investment confidence and position Canadian producers to succeed in global markets that increasingly reward cleaner production. Rather than dismantling policies that support long-term economic resilience, the government will continue to work with provinces, industry, farmers and indigenous partners to strengthen affordability, support economic growth and ensure Canada remains competitive in the transition to a low-carbon economy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390513","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the government will not take steps that weaken Canada's competitiveness or create uncertainty for industries that support good jobs in this country.\n\n Industrial carbon pricing and the clean fuel regulations are carefully designed policies that reduce emissions while protecting Canadian competitiveness and encouraging innovation. They provide flexibility for businesses, maintain inves","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["93370be08e96cb24ebb3fe7158244622d5ddbb6c59830e0aae3b99f05f543223"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f6b4a150ae4213fbe46ef146db183e014da4c0b4a8518c44eae0e073db3c8761"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-987b076c21ea3b868dc8aa8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390514,"date":"2026-03-24T00:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to start off by saying that I was a basketball player growing up in high school, but I guess I am a hockey player tonight, and this is my hat trick. Here we go.\n\n The global economy is more than a year into a profound rupture, with economic security, industrial policy and geopolitical competition increasingly shaping economic, financial and supply chain decisions. On top of that, heightened geopolitical tensions, including the recent events in the Middle East that disrupted global energy markets and shipping routes, have further underscored the fragility of global supply chains and are now contributing to elevated uncertainty.\n\nHowever, there is some good news for the Canadian economy. Business sentiment in Canada has improved, and firms are diversifying suppliers and markets. Canada leads the G7 in inward foreign direct investment per capita, and businesses plan to increase their capital spending in 2026. Reflecting on this adaptability, the International Monetary Fund expects Canada to post the second-fastest growth in the G7 over 2026 and 2027. \n\nHowever, we know that the high cost of living is an issue for far too many Canadian families. This is why the government is taking action to put more money in people's pockets. It is the right thing to do, and we want more Canadians to be able to support their families, build financial stability and contribute to our country's long-term national prosperity.\n\n Last summer, we introduced a middle-class tax cut that will save two-income families up to $840 in 2026 and is expected to deliver over $27 billion in tax savings to Canadians over five years. We have also limited the goods and services tax for first-time homebuyers on new homes at or under $1 million, and reduced the GST for first-time homebuyers on new homes between $1 million and $1.5 million. This will save first-time homebuyers up to $50,000, allowing more young Canadians to enter the housing market and spurring the construction of new homes across the country. We launched Build Canada Homes, which will leverage public lands, attract private capital and support modern manufacturers to help build the affordable homes that Canadians need at scale.\n\nWe also tabled budget 2025, \"Canada Strong\", which, as my hon. colleagues know, contains several targeted measures aimed at reducing costs for households, improving consumer protections and addressing housing affordability. For example, budget 2025 proposes to make the national school food program permanent. This program helps up to 400,000 children each year to receive meals every day and is saving participating families with two children an average of $800 per year on groceries.\n\n The budget also proposes to start automatically delivering federal benefits to low-income Canadians. The Canada Revenue Agency will ensure that they receive the federal benefits to which they are entitled, including those they may not even be aware of. That includes the Canada groceries and essentials benefit and the Canada child benefit. These amounts will go up in the coming years, because the benefits are indexed to inflation to ensure that they keep pace with the cost of living.\n\n Budget 2025 also renewed the Canada Strong pass for next summer so that younger families can discover Canada at lower costs. I know many in my community will benefit from that as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390514","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to start off by saying that I was a basketball player growing up in high school, but I guess I am a hockey player tonight, and this is my hat trick. Here we go.\n\n The global economy is more than a year into a profound rupture, with economic security, industrial policy and geopolitical competition increasingly shaping economic, financial and supply chain decisions. On top ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6c72321a4cd08bb46fac3c9514ffb8d22f1a6d86306178cfd2c05c37c9faca0f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1fca5cbf3e0d75b2aa899abc180885792505a7ca7b0efe73cb50fac3bcc7524a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-902a79c9f9e9271c2cbe0d99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":390515,"date":"2026-03-24T00:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have seen that the Canada school food program has worked in my own community, where I see smiling happy kids every morning going off to school, coming home with full bellies and actually excelling in school for the first time in their lives. That is something that we need to be proud of.\n\n At a time when global supply chain disruptions are driving up prices, the government is focused on bringing down costs, supercharging homebuilding and sustaining the important programs that support Canadians. We will continue pushing for a more resilient, affordable economy for everyone, while ensuring that Canada is resilient and not dependent on any single economic power.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:390515","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have seen that the Canada school food program has worked in my own community, where I see smiling happy kids every morning going off to school, coming home with full bellies and actually excelling in school for the first time in their lives. That is something that we need to be proud of.\n\n At a time when global supply chain disruptions are driving up prices, the government is focuse","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2753392bc498d4a9edefc9513a62cf5caab2a223786639e996aea5faa000c1fc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e17a1374d0c5b474c0cf45f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715156,"date":"2026-04-13T23:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for Cloverdale—Langley City, which is a beautiful riding not too far from my home, for the question. \n\nThe Government of Canada is focused on making housing more affordable and buying a home more attainable for Canadians. Through budget 2025, we are making generational investments of $25 billion over five years for housing and $115 billion over five years for infrastructure. These strategic investments will build major infrastructure and homes and create lasting prosperity, empowering Canadians to get ahead. This is also why the Prime Minister launched Build Canada Homes in September 2025. \n\nBuild Canada Homes is a completely different way to build affordable housing for Canadians. This new federal agency will catalyze a productive housing industry, something that sets it apart from anything done previously. Build Canada Homes will not act alone. It will work in close partnership with developers, manufacturers, provinces, territories, municipalities and indigenous partners to get housing financed and built. Our goal is to make it faster and easier for builders to get big projects off the ground and deliver homes for Canadians right across the country.\n\n Young families and first-time homebuyers deserve the same opportunities to own a home that our parents did. That is why we are taking action to provide Canadians with immediate relief through targeted tax measures. We are cutting the GST on new homes at or under $1 million for first-time homebuyers, delivering savings of up to $50,000. We are also lowering the GST on new homes between $1 million and $1.5 million. These initiatives will help more Canadians buy their homes. \n\nAs well, we are helping first-time homebuyers through the tax-free home savings account, which helps Canadians to save for their first home. We are building on the success of programs delivered through the national housing strategy, like the $4.4-billion housing accelerator fund, which incentivizes municipalities to reduce barriers to building. We are investing in the purpose-built rental supply through the apartment construction loan program. We are also taking action to help the community housing sector to acquire at-risk rental apartment buildings, ensuring they remain affordable over the long term, with the launch of the Canada rental protection fund. \n\nIt is unacceptable for anybody in Canada to go without safe, affordable and inclusive housing, and that is why the federal government is committed to solving the housing crisis and taking a leadership role on housing. The Government of Canada is removing barriers to construction, reducing risk for home builders and making significant investments in non-market housing. We are working closely with builders, investors, indigenous partners and all levels of government to implement innovative solutions to get the job done. Together with our partners, the Government of Canada is leading transformative change in Canada's housing sector.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715156","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for Cloverdale—Langley City, which is a beautiful riding not too far from my home, for the question. \n\nThe Government of Canada is focused on making housing more affordable and buying a home more attainable for Canadians. Through budget 2025, we are making generational investments of $25 billion over five years for housing and $115 billion over five years for infr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f14509a1183bd7cbaad7d90c2befb50627bb3a2dc82ed67584c01e16391066fb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["32cdeb588ce7383304595b7eb800997c8ac97dd51613e029529e1a1e9675e973"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63a51acc269abfa1e41616ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715157,"date":"2026-04-13T23:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Government of Canada is committed to solving the housing crisis, and we are working together with all of our partners to use every tool available to get the job done. \n\nThe affordable housing fund, the housing accelerator fund and the apartment construction loan program are just some of the key programs that are helping Canadians. Build Canada Homes will also partner across the housing ecosystem to drive the development of affordable housing and support a mix of income needs. It will catalyze modern methods of construction as part of a national effort to increase housing construction, restore affordability and reduce homelessness.\n\n The federal government is back in the business of building homes for Canadians. We are taking bold action to build a housing market that works for everyone and to create lasting, meaningful change across this country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715157","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Government of Canada is committed to solving the housing crisis, and we are working together with all of our partners to use every tool available to get the job done. \n\nThe affordable housing fund, the housing accelerator fund and the apartment construction loan program are just some of the key programs that are helping Canadians. Build Canada Homes will also partner across the ho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["05eded2c70d03087f0c9476a3ae3a7d7a9c5c1f8606eaf1b6c32a75913f96789"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca71d644735e55de33dc52520e68f478d2756fe4b740669d443e6da4a3c37425"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-784edf42686772b816bf1cc2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715158,"date":"2026-04-13T23:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know my friend from York—Durham was recently in my province of British Columbia, so I hope that he had some hospitality from my friends there. \n\nTo answer the member's question, this government knows that people across the country need affordable housing, and we are taking action. Through budget 2025, we are making generational investments of $25 billion over five years for housing and $115 billion over five years for infrastructure. These strategic investments will build major infrastructure in homes and create lasting prosperity, empowering Canadians to get ahead. \n\nThis is also why the Prime Minister launched Build Canada Homes in September 2025. Build Canada Homes is a completely different way to build affordable housing for Canadians. This new federal agency will catalyze a more productive housing industry, something that sets it apart from anything done previously. On February 5, Bill C-20, an act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes, was tabled in Parliament. This legislation, if passed, would establish Build Canada Homes as a Crown corporation. \n\nI want to clear up some misconceptions. The hon. member for York—Durham said the $13 billion for Build Canada Homes will only result in 5,200 homes. That is not the case. Those homes represent the first investments announced by Build Canada Homes and are just the start. Build Canada Homes has a mandate to move quickly, and these homes are a demonstration of what can be done in a short amount of time. Build Canada Homes will create more affordable housing by using flexible financial tools and by leveraging public land. It will also attract funding from other governments, non-profits and the private sector. The scaling power of these investments should not be underestimated. This will allow Build Canada Homes to support thousands more affordable and market-rate units. \n\nIn the immediate term, Build Canada Homes will prioritize shovel-ready projects, building that can start within 12 months, to accelerate delivery while building capacity for long-term scale. Over time, the intention of Build Canada Homes is to focus on funding larger-scale and portfolio-based projects. These projects will deliver measurable impacts to Canada's supply of affordable housing. \n\nBuild Canada Homes will not act alone. It will work in close partnership with developers, manufacturers, provinces, territories and municipalities, as well as indigenous partners, to get housing financed and built. Our goal is to make it faster and easier for builders to get big projects off the ground and deliver homes for Canadians across the country. Build Canada Homes will partner across the housing ecosystem to drive the development of affordable housing, supporting a mix of income needs. It will catalyze modern methods of construction as part of a national effort to increase housing construction, restore affordability and reduce homelessness. \n\nThe Government of Canada is changing the way that housing is built across our country and improving affordability for Canadians with Build Canada Homes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715158","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know my friend from York—Durham was recently in my province of British Columbia, so I hope that he had some hospitality from my friends there. \n\nTo answer the member's question, this government knows that people across the country need affordable housing, and we are taking action. Through budget 2025, we are making generational investments of $25 billion over five years for housing ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["25eb678c7df366034c94f441beda342383a099d3653260601cfafdfa2cc90709"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d0ab7ae169ae1e54355adb911f5c94bac3940c652b10118f169881c1c9b776ed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a999715712cdcbe816913a82","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715159,"date":"2026-04-13T23:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will do my best to answer the question.\n\nThe Government of Canada is always focused on housing affordability for Canadians. The number of homes Build Canada Homes will support is much greater than the estimate contained in the Parliamentary Budget Officer's report, when funding from partners is taken into account. Build Canada Homes is about building partnerships. The Parliamentary Budget Officer's report does not account for Build Canada Homes' role of crowding in funding from other governments, non-profits, industry and investors. This is a key component of the agency's ability to increase the supply of affordable housing.\n\nBy leveraging public lands, deploying flexible financial tools and acting as a catalyst for modern methods of construction, Build Canada Homes is driving a more productive and innovative homebuilding sector. Alongside our partners, the Government of Canada is getting shovels in the ground, projects under way and homes built.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715159","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will do my best to answer the question.\n\nThe Government of Canada is always focused on housing affordability for Canadians. The number of homes Build Canada Homes will support is much greater than the estimate contained in the Parliamentary Budget Officer's report, when funding from partners is taken into account. Build Canada Homes is about building partnerships. The Parliamentary ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6f70ad6f063bcfea4f74713ed1fa2959192dd123d1525dcdb9eb97a175633100"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["29055ad276dfc79af881a230ca6d8e9afb931e8e338b08c4e711ba67b9adfd71"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a32b63b95f31b40012a93b9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715154,"date":"2026-04-16T00:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know my colleague from Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford proudly represents many of my extended family in the Sumas and Sts'ailes first nations, and I raise my hands to him for that, but I have to disagree with how he is painting the industrial carbon pricing.\n\nWe have said before that there is no carbon tax on food and farmers, and farmers are not subject to the industrial carbon price. Independent modelling from the Canadian Climate Institute and Navius Research shows the impact of industrial carbon pricing on agriculture is less than one-tenth of 1% by 2030. Why? It is because farmers are not the ones paying it. Industrial carbon pricing applies only to large industrial emitters: steel, cement, mining, oil and gas. Under the output-based system, facilities can cut emissions, buy credits or adopt cleaner technologies. It is a flexible and efficient framework that reduces emissions at the lowest cost while protecting business and competitiveness. \n\nGlobal pressures, not federal climate policy, are driving food inflation. Disrupted shipping routes, climate-related crop losses and the impacts of international conflicts on fertilizer and energy markets are the same challenges faced around the world. That is why yesterday the government temporarily suspended the federal fuel excise tax on gasoline and diesel across Canada. Starting April 20, this measure will provide immediate relief to Canadians, reducing prices at the pump by approximately 10¢ per litre on gasoline and four cents per litre on diesel. It lowers costs for businesses and truckers across key sectors while we continue to build long-term energy security. This is in addition to our new Canada groceries and essentials benefit announced earlier this year, which will help more than 12 million low- and modest-income earners afford day-to-day essentials.\n\n We are also investing heavily in adaptation. Since 2015, more than $6.6 billion has supported community resilience, with new funding in budget 2025. Indigenous leadership is essential to this work and supported by over $2 billion in indigenous-led climate initiatives since 2020. Climate action is economic action. Our policies protect families, support workers and position Canada for long-term prosperity.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715154","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know my colleague from Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford proudly represents many of my extended family in the Sumas and Sts'ailes first nations, and I raise my hands to him for that, but I have to disagree with how he is painting the industrial carbon pricing.\n\nWe have said before that there is no carbon tax on food and farmers, and farmers are not subject to the industrial carbon price. I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035041","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Emission control technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035041","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Emission control technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035041","label":"Emission control technology","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4c6f34b4f770414ec00fc3f990e5e71016cfb41fd6142d22f135dfc34d7d1a74"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2cfe59967f2056d9619736dd8c947673f89c220e507eb902598e83bcd6f26eed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f3420a3ed747ab7c415fe4c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715155,"date":"2026-04-16T00:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, yes, I do recognize what the hon. member has stated. I have talked with many of my family members in that area about that very topic.\n\nI will repeat this because it matters. Farmers do not pay the industrial carbon price, and groceries are not subject to any carbon tax. Our government eliminated the consumer fuel charge back in 2025. Industrial carbon pricing applies only to major emitters and gives them practical, low-cost options to reduce pollution. Eliminating these tools would not lower food prices. It would increase pollution, undermine investor certainty and weaken Canada's competitiveness as the global market shifts to cleaner production. There is no food packaging tax, and independent analysis shows food inflation has been driven by global disruptions, not climate policy. \n\nCanadians deserve solutions grounded in evidence, and that is exactly what this government will be delivering.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715155","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, yes, I do recognize what the hon. member has stated. I have talked with many of my family members in that area about that very topic.\n\nI will repeat this because it matters. Farmers do not pay the industrial carbon price, and groceries are not subject to any carbon tax. Our government eliminated the consumer fuel charge back in 2025. Industrial carbon pricing applies only to major emi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e7f2ed1a4f30e103d1593a81ba7fd677ceea7ca5768256445b58c4e4b25aac7a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bdd394383580c73b64ffa37a90303e20e5a8e53e51c0f214fb6e1725369cafb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-298268b45aecea2fef6328ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128312,"date":"2026-04-16T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. It's always great when an Olympic medal-winning person is in the witness chair. I follow my Olympic history, and I was watching, Ms. van der Kamp. Mr. Cauchi, transportation remains one of the largest sources of greenhouse gas emissions in Canada. It is also a major driver of local air pollution in our communities. As outlined in the government's automotive strategy, we are moving away from prescriptive sales mandates and instead strengthening greenhouse gas emissions standards, which were described by the department as some of the strongest tools we have right now to support emissions reductions while giving industry flexibility. These standards are designed not only to reduce emissions but also to cut the pollution that is breathed in every day by Canadians, especially children, seniors, and people who live near busy roads. From ECCC's perspective, why is the light-duty vehicle sector such a critical focus for emissions reduction, and how do strengthened vehicle GHG standards contribute to both climate goals and improving air quality and public health across Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128312","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. It's always great when an Olympic medal-winning person is in the witness chair. I follow my Olympic history, and I was watching, Ms. van der Kamp. Mr. Cauchi, transportation remains one of the largest sources of greenhouse gas emissions in Canada. It is also a major driver of local air pollution in our communities. As outlined in the government's","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","label":"Pollution prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","label":"Pollution prevention","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7983406ec717961d860e693972699e75d795bc273cebbdff078750507a16a391"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8f10256ac2ff46781ecbc420315d45b9dfd034d3a524d3188303cedb5993295b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee21287590f4f6e2a1c2ba3b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128313,"date":"2026-04-16T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Mr. Cauchi, we've often heard the term \"range anxiety\". Opponents often argue that electric vehicles are impractical outside of major urban centres, despite growing evidence to the contrary. What data or analysis does ECCC rely on to assess the real-world viability of electric vehicles across different regions, including northern and colder climates, and long-distance travel corridors in our country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128313","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Cauchi, we've often heard the term \"range anxiety\". Opponents often argue that electric vehicles are impractical outside of major urban centres, despite growing evidence to the contrary. What data or analysis does ECCC rely on to assess the real-world viability of electric vehicles across different regions, including northern and colder climates, and long-distance travel corridors in our count","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f03fdbe2cc934421da8c88bd7ecfecd101918e48944ac690ac11b123b721ef3d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-afc05f649e1cce34651132cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301473,"date":"2026-04-20T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we, of course, acknowledge and take seriously the concerns raised by indigenous communities in the regions around tailings ponds where safety risks happen. Pollution from oil sands tailings is a serious issue that affects Canada's waters, ecosystems and the well-being of communities.\n\nOur government is committed to protecting the health of communities, as well as Canada's waters, fish and ecosystems, today and for generations to come. This is why we are working closely with the Crown-indigenous working group along with the affected communities, first nations, provinces and industry to develop a long-term, science-based solution, and we look forward to their recommendations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301473","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we, of course, acknowledge and take seriously the concerns raised by indigenous communities in the regions around tailings ponds where safety risks happen. Pollution from oil sands tailings is a serious issue that affects Canada's waters, ecosystems and the well-being of communities.\n\nOur government is committed to protecting the health of communities, as well as Canada's waters, fish","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["79adafedc3bb25fa98fb42821f738c9d637c9402aefab531495db5866f1eb588"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9934c5c9ffeb34db3a03e1e38981f12e3067cd261ec1caa6669c66decc3120f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3dfe36eedc19ae2a1782bd85","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128314,"date":"2026-04-21T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. It's a pleasure to see you again, Ms. Brouillette. I want to touch on the letter that the Climate Action Network jointly signed to the Prime Minister earlier this year, in March. The industrial carbon pricing is \"widely agreed to be the most efficient road to industrial decarbonization\". Can you explain to the committee what is meant by \"efficient\"?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128314","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. It's a pleasure to see you again, Ms. Brouillette. I want to touch on the letter that the Climate Action Network jointly signed to the Prime Minister earlier this year, in March. The industrial carbon pricing is \"widely agreed to be the most efficient road to industrial decarbonization\". Can you explain to the committee w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-600c703bd0025aff5b630c55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128315,"date":"2026-04-21T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"There's a concern we often hear that pricing industrial emissions in Canada pushes production and investment to countries where there's no carbon price without actually reducing global emissions. Can you walk the committee through why a well-designed output-based system like OBPS addresses that concern?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128315","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There's a concern we often hear that pricing industrial emissions in Canada pushes production and investment to countries where there's no carbon price without actually reducing global emissions. Can you walk the committee through why a well-designed output-based system like OBPS addresses that concern?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7da100087dc16a01a0cb1244fa5013a7f490a0cd7d24a813038193b95c2c16d4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08f0ee45bbcce583190905b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128316,"date":"2026-04-21T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"How does industrial carbon pricing support investment certainty for clean energy and decarbonization projects in the country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128316","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How does industrial carbon pricing support investment certainty for clean energy and decarbonization projects in the country?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6de211778ce6c9cc9d71243a3bd39473b09a63e761e4875bc98203e252307076"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-788471468c3801cc569366ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128317,"date":"2026-04-21T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Can you speak further to what it would cost the industry and Canada's competitive position if we didn't have industrial carbon pricing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128317","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can you speak further to what it would cost the industry and Canada's competitive position if we didn't have industrial carbon pricing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba54450e798ca854fae2e47b5829d3e330c0c2bcb440af3fe175cd013d808719"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0177439a036e83b64cb19cf8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128318,"date":"2026-04-21T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"I'll go back to the OBPS then. How does the way the OBPS is structured help keep production here while still creating an incentive to reduce emissions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128318","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll go back to the OBPS then. How does the way the OBPS is structured help keep production here while still creating an incentive to reduce emissions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["692fe8df0cd254523dbb92ea664aa2c35bdd72dded5e881bf6016c6ba2e20aae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2dd00bdeb2d6592f11b7e019","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128319,"date":"2026-04-21T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128319","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e69b639c653857a12c2831f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128320,"date":"2026-04-21T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you to the witnesses. I'll start with you, Dr. Winter. I want to talk about this context: The EU's carbon border adjustment mechanism is now fully entering its definitive phase, where Canadian exporters in sectors like steel and aluminum face potential border carbon charges. Is there a credible argument that having a robust, well-enforced OBPS actually protects those industries from double exposure, and is a strong domestic carbon price an asset rather than a liability in that trading environment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128320","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to the witnesses. I'll start with you, Dr. Winter. I want to talk about this context: The EU's carbon border adjustment mechanism is now fully entering its definitive phase, where Canadian exporters in sectors like steel and aluminum face potential border carbon charges. Is there a credible argument that having a robust, well-enforced OBPS actually protects those industries from double e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036871","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway installations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036871","label":"Railway installations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02bc0b22a42df18ac4ac0e904e204a059d87d564cb1169860fadd301b8b603ed"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac7e4a6a9223b40dc70729b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128321,"date":"2026-04-21T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. Mr. Auer, as I understand it, cement is a hard-to-abate sector. The chemistry of making the cement itself accounts for the majority of emissions, meaning efficiency improvements and fuel switching can only take you so far. There, CCUS is ultimately a valuable tool. In that context, how essential is a stable, long-term carbon price trajectory paired with the existence of investment tax credits?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128321","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Auer, as I understand it, cement is a hard-to-abate sector. The chemistry of making the cement itself accounts for the majority of emissions, meaning efficiency improvements and fuel switching can only take you so far. There, CCUS is ultimately a valuable tool. In that context, how essential is a stable, long-term carbon price trajectory paired with the existence of investment tax c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50d785ab2e4452a2340f5e18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128322,"date":"2026-04-21T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"To follow up, would uncertainty regarding carbon pricing—if industrial carbon pricing were not on the table—be a major barrier to the achievement of a net-zero cement sector?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128322","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"To follow up, would uncertainty regarding carbon pricing—if industrial carbon pricing were not on the table—be a major barrier to the achievement of a net-zero cement sector?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf31e96a7d63495879d36f96d61fdd57c4feda8fab71185444e40013626d89dd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e921fd07cb1bfeab74d27027","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128323,"date":"2026-04-21T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"I'll go back to you, Dr. Winter. The Canadian Climate Institute found that approximately $4.3 billion in annual clean energy investment is linked directly to the existence of industrial carbon pricing systems. Does your own research support the view that pricing certainty is what enables companies to make the business case for large clean-energy technology capital expenditures?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128323","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll go back to you, Dr. Winter. The Canadian Climate Institute found that approximately $4.3 billion in annual clean energy investment is linked directly to the existence of industrial carbon pricing systems. Does your own research support the view that pricing certainty is what enables companies to make the business case for large clean-energy technology capital expenditures?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0e4afd3fc0539fd9ba25aba82cf1f3669e2572157558af9392f07767eae30a86"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c6371d56dce3625e33247db1e679b6b632e0d26ef974abbe7eb79724890da0e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b726df3911b44ffc0b6d864","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128324,"date":"2026-04-21T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Conversely, what does the economic literature suggest happens to that investment if the price signal becomes uncertain or is removed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128324","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Conversely, what does the economic literature suggest happens to that investment if the price signal becomes uncertain or is removed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","label":"Literature","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35766dbb98f48be5efb3a93a5d8ff2e1887fc21ee5e568febaef9eda45a4595b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-465def152c5fd0bf402a0185","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128325,"date":"2026-04-21T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Quickly, what sectors of the Canadian economy stand to benefit the most from a strong, stable industrial carbon price over the next decade?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128325","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Quickly, what sectors of the Canadian economy stand to benefit the most from a strong, stable industrial carbon price over the next decade?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["447e03e6bf9a32a9d5a8dd4ce8c85c20b32e27ab22a376819c2e069ac352c3e7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e529b49d370c268132eb064","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128326,"date":"2026-04-21T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128326","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69754e44b1423e7f54ae8e14","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301470,"date":"2026-04-22T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this will undoubtedly be the hardest minute in my time as an MP, where I honour my father, who passed away on March 29 this year. He was born Howard Hong to a Musqueam matriarch and Hong Tim Hing, a Chinese immigrant. He grew up without a father; his father died when he was 10. My dad was the greatest father that my five siblings and I could ever have. \n\nHe was Dad to many other people because of his large shoulders that we all stand upon. He built bridges between communities and between cultures, and he became a bridge himself, a person who would bring people together. He told me to come here to the House of Commons and to shake the hands of each and every person here because we are all working together. That is the Canada he wanted for his children and his grandchildren. \n\nToday I have a little secret: My name is Howard Wade Grant. He named me after him. If I could say something to him today, I would say that the love that I shared with him, the love that we shared, is so much better because I got to share his name.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301470","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this will undoubtedly be the hardest minute in my time as an MP, where I honour my father, who passed away on March 29 this year. He was born Howard Hong to a Musqueam matriarch and Hong Tim Hing, a Chinese immigrant. He grew up without a father; his father died when he was 10. My dad was the greatest father that my five siblings and I could ever have. \n\nHe was Dad to many other peopl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf3b98365277301f845a985ea7366ec0cca0c467bcb0de30a78c8dc53dbe1478"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0937c6cb785ed11763241d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301471,"date":"2026-04-23T00:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise and reply to my friend from York—Durham.\n\n Yes, we know that too many Canadians are struggling to find homes they can afford. That is why the government is taking action on multiple fronts to increase the rate of home construction, restore affordability and reduce homelessness, not through a single program but with a comprehensive approach that brings every partner to the table. \n\nOn February 5, the government tabled legislation to establish Build Canada Homes as a Crown corporation to scale up the supply of affordable homes for lower- and middle-income Canadians. Build Canada Homes will partner across the housing ecosystem, deploying flexible financing tools, leveraging public lands and using modern methods of construction to build more affordable homes for Canadians. It will help build homes more quickly, more efficiently and at scale. \n\nAcross this country, the Government of Canada is working with provinces, territories and municipalities to remove local barriers that slow new supply. We are helping to support faster, more predictable approvals and aligning rules so that good projects can get built.\n\n We have introduced targeted tax measures that make purpose-built rental projects more financially viable, because renters need more options that they can afford. The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation programs, such as the apartment construction loan program and mortgage loan insurance, are helping builders access the financing necessary to move projects from concept to construction. This continues the progress made by the national housing strategy. \n\nTo date, over 741,000 households have been reduced or eliminated from housing needs. More than 195,000 new housing units were created or committed. That progress matters, because solving the housing crisis requires steady, sustained effort over time. For young Canadians working toward their first home, federal supports, such as the first home savings account, will allow them to save up to $40,000 tax-free. This is done with contributions that reduce their taxable income and withdrawals that are entirely tax-free when they buy their first home. \n\nTo lower the upfront cost of buying a new home for young Canadians, we introduced the first-time homebuyers' GST rebate to allow first-time homebuyers to save up to $50,000 on a new home. The government is eliminating the goods and services tax on new homes up to $1 million and reducing the same GST on new homes between $1 million and $1.5 million for first-time homebuyers.\n\n We are also working to reduce the cost of home building. The first of these partnerships was announced on March 30 with the Government of Ontario. It will help lower development charges and reduce taxes and fees for a home in Ontario up to $200,000. We look forward to working with other partners to reach similar agreements. \n\nThe Government of Canada is taking action so all Canadians have access to an affordable place to live.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301471","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise and reply to my friend from York—Durham.\n\n Yes, we know that too many Canadians are struggling to find homes they can afford. That is why the government is taking action on multiple fronts to increase the rate of home construction, restore affordability and reduce homelessness, not through a single program but with a comprehensive approach that brings e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94966f22f2c4adb66375a1911116322a7bd7238be94311b68efc72e6dd294a7e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6e46a50b7994fbe459b8c6c03ed2bf984959192068f743b92b289f4d2d5e56f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-601713c9dc1a5187d8501397","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301472,"date":"2026-04-23T00:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to start by saying that the federal government is empowering Canadians to get ahead, through budget 2025. Build Canada Homes and a range of housing measures are part of our national effort to increase housing construction, restore affordability and reduce homelessness. Budget 2025 is making generational investments of $25 billion over five years for housing, and $115 billion over five years for infrastructure. These strategic investments will create lasting prosperity by building homes and major infrastructure projects. Together with our partners across government and the housing industry, we are building homes, creating jobs and growing our economy.\n\nThe Government of Canada is strengthening its capacity to address Canada's housing crisis, improving housing supply and accelerating innovation in homebuilding. We are taking action to lower housing costs for Canadians so everyone has a place to call home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301472","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to start by saying that the federal government is empowering Canadians to get ahead, through budget 2025. Build Canada Homes and a range of housing measures are part of our national effort to increase housing construction, restore affordability and reduce homelessness. Budget 2025 is making generational investments of $25 billion over five years for housing, and $115 billion ov","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["77a1428d2ca2418cfe52289ef2f7020cfc69d59ec688e41c4abf5ad569cb6fb0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["18c3f6455f64d41b9a5afcec3f55e8f9553499bc9a18eb3f846ecae6d79eaf04"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43379724b5417e0798a3f28b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128327,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much. Thank you to the witnesses for providing testimony. Mr. Clark, in your testimony, you talked about New Economy Canada bringing together labour, business and indigenous leaders, as they focus on Canada's economic transition. You also talked about the importance of a clear, strong and predictable industrial carbon price. Could you elaborate further on what a clear, strong and predictable carbon price would actually do for their investment decisions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128327","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Thank you to the witnesses for providing testimony. Mr. Clark, in your testimony, you talked about New Economy Canada bringing together labour, business and indigenous leaders, as they focus on Canada's economic transition. You also talked about the importance of a clear, strong and predictable industrial carbon price. Could you elaborate further on what a clear, strong and pr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["830a61efae243325c2062a3ddac7b4f026959f3dd7c5f3fe32d2b10426ef4da9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-574e682d7c59b014e27ce0b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128328,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. When investors are deciding whether to build a clean steel facility or a net-zero cement plant in Canada versus another jurisdiction, what factors matter most and where does industrial carbon pricing fit into that calculation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128328","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. When investors are deciding whether to build a clean steel facility or a net-zero cement plant in Canada versus another jurisdiction, what factors matter most and where does industrial carbon pricing fit into that calculation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","label":"Steel","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7823943439dd7f4dd4a27eed808726e422fad9be8888208e6773dfc1a6bdecf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e881bfd2b81c78cb04b1edbc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128329,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"If pricing industrial pollution sends a market signal to industry that invests in clean technologies, they'll cut their emissions. It also sends a signal to innovators to develop those technologies. What would a strengthened system mean for clean technology investment in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128329","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If pricing industrial pollution sends a market signal to industry that invests in clean technologies, they'll cut their emissions. It also sends a signal to innovators to develop those technologies. What would a strengthened system mean for clean technology investment in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbdf50ed38abdb14a223c9e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128330,"date":"2026-04-23T17:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Let me shift a little bit, Mr. Clark. Some of our trading partners in the EU, the U.K. and now maybe even others are introducing border carbon adjustments of their own. For Canadian companies looking to export to those markets, what is the commercial significance of Canada's maintaining a credible, internationally recognized industrial carbon price?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128330","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Let me shift a little bit, Mr. Clark. Some of our trading partners in the EU, the U.K. and now maybe even others are introducing border carbon adjustments of their own. For Canadian companies looking to export to those markets, what is the commercial significance of Canada's maintaining a credible, internationally recognized industrial carbon price?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-001b0996f4b9c28d0e9c135e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128331,"date":"2026-04-23T17:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"If Canada were to weaken or eliminate its industrial carbon price, what would that signal to the major industrial investors and clean economy companies that New Economy Canada works with?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128331","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If Canada were to weaken or eliminate its industrial carbon price, what would that signal to the major industrial investors and clean economy companies that New Economy Canada works with?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad3b2cc3e2f99d0de8c66314223b955b61f68da8c059b56ea4bc5247a8857c1e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-983ab02575e318222a95b5a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":301469,"date":"2026-04-24T17:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for looking out for my relatives from the Cowichan tribes. I know they are probably very furious about what is happening. We will work with them and work with others to ensure that no illegal dumping occurs on their property. We will make sure that it stops as soon as possible.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:301469","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for looking out for my relatives from the Cowichan tribes. I know they are probably very furious about what is happening. We will work with them and work with others to ensure that no illegal dumping occurs on their property. We will make sure that it stops as soon as possible.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ee7bb876d30c50e719dd42ec5bb85a441287540d68a99d829c139465b7b352a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61e854d879c3e7c5e0ec1295a00ffeb21285b8a98d535e66aad04c06330f63f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-744ff1070f7f1db4cf870e35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728702,"date":"2026-04-28T18:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my dear friend's tremendous speech. I know that he is a proud Nova Scotian. I know he is a proud Canadian. Like me, he probably grew up thinking about going to space and always dreaming of being an astronaut. Unfortunately, things changed for me, but we do now have this bill on the floor.\n\n I want to talk a bit about the member's beautiful riding. I have never been there, but I know I will be there one day. He talked about the investment that this could bring to his riding. He talked about his constituents. He is a proud indigenous member as well. What can investments like this in his riding provide for indigenous communities and indigenous people in his riding?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728702","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my dear friend's tremendous speech. I know that he is a proud Nova Scotian. I know he is a proud Canadian. Like me, he probably grew up thinking about going to space and always dreaming of being an astronaut. Unfortunately, things changed for me, but we do now have this bill on the floor.\n\n I want to talk a bit about the member's beautiful riding. I have never been there,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1f0a0b7294064de16837069818075266e604a97265c61dad044c5f6bc4fb9c0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04120eb11a199eb21a44d224","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728682,"date":"2026-05-01T17:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to say that Canada continues to be a global climate leader, and we are making our voice heard on the world stage. In fact, just last week, at the G7, the Minister of the Environment, Climate Change presented our ambitious new nature strategy. \n\nIn the spring economic statement, we renewed Canada's international climate finance to support sustainable solutions across the world, especially in vulnerable places. As the Prime Minister has said in the House of Commons, we will respect our Paris commitments for climate change, and we are determined to achieve them.\n\nOur government will continue to take decisive climate action and engage in global conversations and action supporting a stronger, cleaner and safer world.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728682","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to say that Canada continues to be a global climate leader, and we are making our voice heard on the world stage. In fact, just last week, at the G7, the Minister of the Environment, Climate Change presented our ambitious new nature strategy. \n\nIn the spring economic statement, we renewed Canada's international climate finance to support sustainable solutions across the world","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2563d5c413d3bd4ad60168356a6dbbfc793727b4e32c9661b54b042d0aeff0f7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b537b747d1676264dab9b876fcc7458731ea7ab5c7c481d5d9ccdb24ad76ba8d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed594f25524c9a00800014f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728698,"date":"2026-05-01T19:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, before I start, I want to thank my colleague from Kitchener Centre for standing up and having the tremendous strength she had today to share her story. Far too often in my 47 years, I have had to say goodbye to many family members way too early. They never were able to climb the mountain that she was able to climb, but I am able to share her story now to say that people can climb that mountain and be in this hallowed hall one day. I thank the member again.\n\nI am thankful for this opportunity to speak to the private member's bill, Bill C-240, the offender rehabilitation act. This bill proposes amendments to the Criminal Code, the Corrections and Conditional Release Act, CCRA, and the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act. More specifically, the proposed amendments would allow a court to prescribe measures that an offender must undertake during their sentence, such as participation in treatment or employment programs; require that such measures be incorporated into an offender's correctional plan and that progress be considered by the Parole Board of Canada, PBC, when making sentencing decisions; and treat large-scale fentanyl trafficking as an aggravating sentencing factor. \n\nOur primary responsibility as a government is to keep all Canadians safe. This responsibility requires us to carefully review legislation, assess its implications and ensure that it upholds the values that Canadians expect of us. We support the principles of Bill C-240 and recognize that it requires further study at the committee stage to address certain challenges present in its current form. We look forward to working together to rectify these issues and ensure the safety of all Canadians.\n\nWith this in mind, I will use my time to talk about how Correctional Service Canada, CSC, helps people in custody achieve their substance use goals, as well as how parole works in Canada.\n\nSubstance use is a complex health issue that requires a balanced approach focused on prevention, treatment and harm reduction. Through its national drugs and substances strategy, CSC takes a health-centred approach to substance abuse, recognizing that addressing problematic use is essential to rehabilitation and public safety. CSC provides screening, evidence-based treatment and peer-supported recovery services. This includes substance use treatment delivered by health care professionals, such as opioid agonist treatment for individuals with opioid use disorder.\n\nCSC also implements harm reduction measures to reduce the risk of overdose and the spread of infectious diseases while supporting access to care. CSC further supports recovery through peer-based programs, which use lived experience to promote engagement, recovery and successful reintegration into the community.\n\nThe majority of offenders are serving fixed-length sentences. This means that they will eventually be released back into the community once their sentence ends.\n\nLet me, for a moment, explain how parole works in Canada.\n\nParole contributes to public safety by helping offenders reintegrate into society as law-abiding citizens through a gradual, controlled and supported release with conditions. Parole decisions are made by the Parole Board of Canada, an independent administrative tribunal that operates at arm's length from government and is free from outside influence.\n\nThe process can take place through an in-office file review or a face-to-face hearing with the offender and their parole officer. When hearings are held in person, observers may request to attend remotely. Board members consider all relevant and available information in assessing an offender's risk to reoffend. Decisions are based on a thorough risk assessment of all relevant and available information, which includes information from police, courts, Crown attorneys, mental health professionals, correctional authorities, private agencies, indigenous communities and victims of crime.\n\nWe must not forget that an offender on parole is not completely free. They continue to be monitored and supported by a parole officer from Correctional Service Canada. The Parole Board of Canada may revoke an offender's release not only if they breach their conditions, but also if their risk is assessed as having become unacceptable.\n\nI want to reassure all Canadians that public safety is the primary consideration in all conditional release decisions.\n\nI would also like to share some information about recidivism. Over the last 10 years, 93% of offenders granted day or full parole by the Parole Board of Canada have not committed a new offence while on parole and 99% of offenders have not committed a new violent offence while on parole.\n\nI would also like to emphasize that victims have a role to play in the parole process as well. They may register to receive information from the Parole Board of Canada and Correctional Service Canada. Victims may also provide information to Correctional Service Canada and/or to the Parole Board of Canada at any time throughout the offender's sentence, for consideration when making decisions related to the offender's security level, evaluations or the offender's programming needs and overall risk to re-offend. This includes by board members when deciding whether the offender should be released and the conditions they impose.\n\nVictims can choose to provide a victim statement describing the impact the crime continues to have on them, express their views about the possible conditional release of the offender and ask Correctional Service Canada to consider their area of residence when making a release plan. Victims can also request special conditions for the Parole Board to consider, for example, preventing the offender from communicating with them or their family and from going to any specified place. Further, victims may attend the offender's parole hearing as observers and can read their written statement to board members, outlining the continuing impact the offence has had on them, as well as any risk or safety concerns the offender may pose.\n\nThe national office for victims, through Public Safety Canada, provides an essential resource for victims of federal offenders. It is committed to empowering victims of federal offenders through information. Victims of crime can use this information to understand how authorities determine eligibility dates for different types of release. Through the Canadian Victims Bill of Rights, the Government of Canada also provides the following rights to victims of crime: the right to information, the right to protection, the right to participation and the right to seek restitution. Under the Corrections and Conditional Release Act, victims of crime can receive information on progress made by inmates towards meeting the objectives of their correctional plan.\n\nThe government will always take the protection of these rights seriously. We will continue to ensure the safety of all Canadians. As we support sending the bill to committee, we hope to further the progress, efforts and values I discussed today by strengthening this piece of legislation and ensuring a safer Canada for all Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728698","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, before I start, I want to thank my colleague from Kitchener Centre for standing up and having the tremendous strength she had today to share her story. Far too often in my 47 years, I have had to say goodbye to many family members way too early. They never were able to climb the mountain that she was able to climb, but I am able to share her story now to say that people can climb th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04fdf337bcbc8e43c4af82bf22d93c88459119ae4868278caf06d361739f2495"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5da49ecef62d1428add31c6d052e7ceee14526eefbbe30e228d53b148cbb9822"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbfc597646bc144f8b4ba6ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128332,"date":"2026-05-05T22:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses who have come forward today. I really appreciate it. As you know, I'm from Vancouver, the third-largest metro area in Canada. I believe it was Mr. Fanjoy who asked a question about urban national parks—something we're keenly aware of. You mentioned that six have been put forward already. How does that work? Are there any others coming forward, or was there a limit set on which parks could be available?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128332","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses who have come forward today. I really appreciate it. As you know, I'm from Vancouver, the third-largest metro area in Canada. I believe it was Mr. Fanjoy who asked a question about urban national parks—something we're keenly aware of. You mentioned that six have been put forward already. How does that work? Are there any others coming forward, or ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8e207662e56f473fddafbd5fd30cb96a3ab6b2b6c905ed2b04229c4f0986e1c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da1034c7d41f2c4a7f6ccaf8a0de0d532863354ab4c762688d4a87642a98c82d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf55fe3616c516dad4a93a90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128333,"date":"2026-05-05T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Great. I want to talk a bit about national historic sites. There's a national historic site near my community for one of our ancient village sites. I was proud to be able to attend the designation of the Tk'emlúps Indian residential school as a national historic site. I know that they are designated as that, but how are we protecting them? I know that they're not protected in a way that.... People can still go and develop on the midden, where we live. What sort of criteria are put in place there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historic sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128333","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Great. I want to talk a bit about national historic sites. There's a national historic site near my community for one of our ancient village sites. I was proud to be able to attend the designation of the Tk'emlúps Indian residential school as a national historic site. I know that they are designated as that, but how are we protecting them? I know that they're not protected in a way that.... People","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","label":"Historic sites"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036784","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Protected species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historic sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","label":"Historic sites","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036784","label":"Protected species","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00428073d9563b59964e50594b2a1c17c0d28f2b6c3741d0877af7e813deda5b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historic sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["647558189f4d88137e1711d817857a2f26fe4cedb0b348f661ad9f030e02b823"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historic sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24c8578743a570b78f4addaf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128334,"date":"2026-05-05T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Going back to the establishment of parks, you talked about local indigenous communities being a part of that. How much work is going into bringing in indigenous knowledge and other things to ensure that the traditional historic overseeing of these beautiful pieces of land is properly a part of that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128334","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Going back to the establishment of parks, you talked about local indigenous communities being a part of that. How much work is going into bringing in indigenous knowledge and other things to ensure that the traditional historic overseeing of these beautiful pieces of land is properly a part of that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1bf92f88a4cca4dddb881fbf1dfb074e44e458e9078e6525cb765fe7035738c8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e8ab0ec934c6ba26bd72bbc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128335,"date":"2026-05-05T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"I'll cede my minute, Madam Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128335","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll cede my minute, Madam Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60b067660b677db797b4be0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128336,"date":"2026-05-07T16:15:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. You look good in that chair, I have to say. Thank you to all of the witnesses and those online as well for being here. I'll start with you, Mr. DeMarco. Your report, \"Flood Hazard Mapping\", includes a number of constructive recommendations. Can you confirm that departments have accepted these recommendations and are already taking steps towards implementing them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128336","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. You look good in that chair, I have to say. Thank you to all of the witnesses and those online as well for being here. I'll start with you, Mr. DeMarco. Your report, \"Flood Hazard Mapping\", includes a number of constructive recommendations. Can you confirm that departments have accepted these recommendations and are already taking steps towards implementing them?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d856786d258edfe878231ea2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128337,"date":"2026-05-07T16:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay. I forgot to mention I'll be sharing my time with Monsieur St-Pierre. I'll move on to my next question. Budget 2025 commits $25 billion to housing and $115 billion to infrastructure across Canada. In your view, does your report establish that accurate, accessible and climate-informed flood hazard maps are a prerequisite for ensuring those investments are sited and built responsibly?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128337","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. I forgot to mention I'll be sharing my time with Monsieur St-Pierre. I'll move on to my next question. Budget 2025 commits $25 billion to housing and $115 billion to infrastructure across Canada. In your view, does your report establish that accurate, accessible and climate-informed flood hazard maps are a prerequisite for ensuring those investments are sited and built responsibly?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0aff8665b2ffeb8972a768e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128338,"date":"2026-05-07T16:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"I want to turn to the \"Avian Influenza\" report. This may be a question more for the witnesses from CFIA. The audit found that CFIA successfully completed stamping-out procedures at all 47 sampled sites, issued movement controls within one day in 94% of cases and paid $360 million in compensation. In your view, does that operational record reflect that Canada's overall response to avian influenza was managed effectively on the ground?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Influenza","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128338","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to turn to the \"Avian Influenza\" report. This may be a question more for the witnesses from CFIA. The audit found that CFIA successfully completed stamping-out procedures at all 47 sampled sites, issued movement controls within one day in 94% of cases and paid $360 million in compensation. In your view, does that operational record reflect that Canada's overall response to avian influenza w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","label":"Influenza"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Influenza","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","label":"Influenza","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2dad7b0fb630004d7771b82e99e3f8d8565058f4f26e7c7a4c38c28f9866943b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Influenza","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1de2af4130de29216147186f4fe84e08d95c7a2c18c11e49f1ecf40138ea168d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Influenza","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0073046ee723dbd17f64d9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128339,"date":"2026-05-07T16:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. I'll turn it over to Mr. St-Pierre.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128339","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I'll turn it over to Mr. St-Pierre.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d84ebb40637a85cd335b89f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128340,"date":"2026-05-07T17:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I'll be sharing my time once again with Mr. St-Pierre. My first question is on the avian influenza report, and it is for Ms. Robinson. Your department accepted recommendations that have implementation timelines in October, November and December 2026. Regarding PHAC's vaccine procurement and distribution tracking processes, can you speak to what has already changed, since the audit period closed, to meet those recommendations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128340","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I'll be sharing my time once again with Mr. St-Pierre. My first question is on the avian influenza report, and it is for Ms. Robinson. Your department accepted recommendations that have implementation timelines in October, November and December 2026. Regarding PHAC's vaccine procurement and distribution tracking processes, can you speak to what has already changed, si","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11b4590b39ed7211e3343545","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128341,"date":"2026-05-07T17:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. Mr. St-Pierre.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128341","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. St-Pierre.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54b875b5cba4b735fbf0c6b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960994,"date":"2026-05-07T18:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have memories of being in high school in the early 1990s when the B.C. treaty process was opened up because of the many title cases that my colleague has talked about. Fellow students asked, \"Are you coming for our house? Are you coming for our land?\" We had to have leadership come say absolutely not, we will never do that; we want to work in co-operation and we want to live in harmony with each and every person who lives in and around our territory.\n\nThe hon. parliamentary secretary has been involved in first nations politics for a very long time across this country. Has he ever once heard a first nations person, a chief or anybody, say they want private property rights?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960994","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have memories of being in high school in the early 1990s when the B.C. treaty process was opened up because of the many title cases that my colleague has talked about. Fellow students asked, \"Are you coming for our house? Are you coming for our land?\" We had to have leadership come say absolutely not, we will never do that; we want to work in co-operation and we want to live in harm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501323","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501323","label":"Adolescence","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["babd0559d93ea615eca02812d63cd39f90ded81fbddba54d74185fda2506e419"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0aff24140cffff19a4bc78d5eeaea340cea3e4d69b6f1f2563e0735b200c8a02"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6bb04351229e7b75f5d1190c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960995,"date":"2026-05-07T18:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know that my colleague, the member for Richmond East—Steveston, has been very involved with the issue. He is very concerned as well, because he does take this very seriously with his residents and his constituents. I have seen him working on the ground, not only with them but also with the parties appealing the decision along with the federal government. There is the municipality. There are other first nations. There is the province of British Columbia. There is a unified approach to make sure the decision is appealed.\n\nI want to ask the member what he has been hearing from the other parties, so we know they are all working together to ensure that it is appealed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960995","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know that my colleague, the member for Richmond East—Steveston, has been very involved with the issue. He is very concerned as well, because he does take this very seriously with his residents and his constituents. I have seen him working on the ground, not only with them but also with the parties appealing the decision along with the federal government. There is the municipality. T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5592263951997e8669eccc8c5ef2aa56a67e1505c709c1029257c47c55d39f94"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8f61b8904f9c291589386a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":960996,"date":"2026-05-07T18:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have much respect for my colleague from the Nanaimo territory. \n\nShe mentioned that the government failed to negotiate a treaty with the Cowichan Tribes. However, the Stz'uminus tribe, which is part of the Cowichan Tribes, dropped out of the treaty process in 2014, and who was in government at the time, in 2014?\n\nWe try to negotiate on this side. We go to court. These sorts of things happen. Then the Conservatives criticize the negotiations on a government-to-government level. What are we supposed to do? What is their solution, to negotiate with first nations or to go to court, because they are saying that both do not work?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:960996","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have much respect for my colleague from the Nanaimo territory. \n\nShe mentioned that the government failed to negotiate a treaty with the Cowichan Tribes. However, the Stz'uminus tribe, which is part of the Cowichan Tribes, dropped out of the treaty process in 2014, and who was in government at the time, in 2014?\n\nWe try to negotiate on this side. We go to court. These sorts of thing","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c030e8c51e6f1996867e7eb1ced4e32197fcb75a4333a0a350d7da5315eb3166"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61b4ef85579cd155b59a4fb9b106f9b6937a8c0050c38ce0c73f2467b01d1817"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2f866361ab61972901542e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036360,"date":"2026-05-25T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we cannot build Canada strong and clean if we are not working together. That is why we are thinking differently, strategically, to deliver real results for Canadians. We have introduced new methane regulations and $90 billion in clean investment tax credits. We brought Alberta to the table for the first time, making sure that we move together for the future, and I was so proud to be in Klemtu this weekend, where we worked with six first nations and the Province of British Columbia to protect 6,500 square kilometres of marine conservation for future generations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036360","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we cannot build Canada strong and clean if we are not working together. That is why we are thinking differently, strategically, to deliver real results for Canadians. We have introduced new methane regulations and $90 billion in clean investment tax credits. We brought Alberta to the table for the first time, making sure that we move together for the future, and I was so proud to be i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","label":"Indigenous reserves","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd6024720ed6da32c48f7749ad8faa6b8d963bae81f82d113829eddc124cda80"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c52f04c302c691ddd723c189311148e34d06fa995f6457d314f9a7f26a6999ff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df46367a770335fc0c91ee9d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128342,"date":"2026-05-26T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll be sharing my time with Mr. Watchorn. Mademoiselle Auguste, it's very good to see you. I know how passionate you are about this bill. I know the first thing you texted me afterwards was that you wanted to get this bill through as fast as possible, and I really raise my hands in thanks for your having so much passion. I would like to go back to Mr. Pomeroy, if I may, and talk about the flooding. It doesn't respect borders. The Ottawa River, for example, runs between Ontario and Quebec. With the absence of a coordinated national forecasting framework, what does that mean in practice for communities that sit within shared or interprovincial boundaries?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128342","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll be sharing my time with Mr. Watchorn. Mademoiselle Auguste, it's very good to see you. I know how passionate you are about this bill. I know the first thing you texted me afterwards was that you wanted to get this bill through as fast as possible, and I really raise my hands in thanks for your having so much passion. I would like to go back to Mr. Pomeroy, if I may, an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-695bd70e0aef08bc3cf16898","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128343,"date":"2026-05-26T21:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"That's a good point. I'm from British Columbia, where large flooding along the Sumas Prairie spreads across to Washington state, so I really respect that answer. You also spoke about engagement and coordination with indigenous communities. I was at a very remote indigenous community very recently. What can you tell us about indigenous knowledge and how that can help strengthen a national approach to flood and drought forecasting?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128343","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's a good point. I'm from British Columbia, where large flooding along the Sumas Prairie spreads across to Washington state, so I really respect that answer. You also spoke about engagement and coordination with indigenous communities. I was at a very remote indigenous community very recently. What can you tell us about indigenous knowledge and how that can help strengthen a national approach ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46b067fadae13be4864eac96232043e8ac991bdc572955a96348b80ed5751cf3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-358419906668f3fc558ecfeb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128344,"date":"2026-05-26T21:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Mr. Watchorn.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128344","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Watchorn.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1d819a1c66171ed2cf95b84","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128345,"date":"2026-05-26T22:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thanks, Mr. Watchorn. Once again, thanks for acknowledging my 32nd birthday. I really appreciate that. I know I only have a short time, Ms. Fortin. I live in British Columbia. I'm in a metropolitan area, but there are large swaths of B.C. that are rural and remote towns, and first nations as well. We know that indigenous communities are becoming increasingly essential to environmental policy. Can you speak to how the department is increasingly approaching indigenous engagement and co-development in its current work?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128345","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thanks, Mr. Watchorn. Once again, thanks for acknowledging my 32nd birthday. I really appreciate that. I know I only have a short time, Ms. Fortin. I live in British Columbia. I'm in a metropolitan area, but there are large swaths of B.C. that are rural and remote towns, and first nations as well. We know that indigenous communities are becoming increasingly essential to environmental policy. Can ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c1b4817ab221561deed96dbf283542c5b65cba191cdeccf0929ce4057952c86"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-641298a7d11b6015e148ca61","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128346,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"I would like to follow up. I know I don't have much time, but you're talking about the nature strategy. Could you explain how this is going to advance our 30 by 30 commitments and how it's going to benefit future generations as well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128346","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to follow up. I know I don't have much time, but you're talking about the nature strategy. Could you explain how this is going to advance our 30 by 30 commitments and how it's going to benefit future generations as well?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b9de634a92f5fe7bf23300639ac83af2283d80436dbdb83b58ffb4f5d10b1851"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ee098df048bced1cc83ed90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128347,"date":"2026-05-28T17:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you Mr. Watchorn, and thank you all for being here. Mr. Campbell, we heard earlier about the signing of a national marine conservation area reserve agreement last week between the federal government, the Government of British Columbia and the Kitasoo Xai'xais, Nuxalk, Heiltsuk, Gitxaała, Gitga'at and Wuikinuxv nations. I saw the great turnout there. Could you elaborate on the potential of this model? There's no one-size-fits-all model, but would this model include agreements with indigenous peoples based on mutual collaboration moving forward?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128347","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you Mr. Watchorn, and thank you all for being here. Mr. Campbell, we heard earlier about the signing of a national marine conservation area reserve agreement last week between the federal government, the Government of British Columbia and the Kitasoo Xai'xais, Nuxalk, Heiltsuk, Gitxaała, Gitga'at and Wuikinuxv nations. I saw the great turnout there. Could you elaborate on the potential of th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd4f5ac1b034606448cac969","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128348,"date":"2026-05-28T18:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Madam Chair, we have important witnesses here today, and we have a number of members who would like to continue asking their questions, as we did extend this meeting for three minutes each. This motion is not the subject of this meeting today, and I think we should continue our scheduled business. Therefore, I move to adjourn this debate. (Motion agreed to)","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128348","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Chair, we have important witnesses here today, and we have a number of members who would like to continue asking their questions, as we did extend this meeting for three minutes each. This motion is not the subject of this meeting today, and I think we should continue our scheduled business. Therefore, I move to adjourn this debate. (Motion agreed to)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["badb2a402db4d23e8769086a61e0f2c06f496f776c0ac637bf24d40e779147c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-773940b62e953d319b5f7bf4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128349,"date":"2026-05-28T18:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Mr. Fisher, on World Water Day earlier this year, the minister announced that we're going to launch Canada's national water security strategy. This is a significant milestone. Could you speak to what the strategy will mean for Canadians and how the Canada Water Agency intends to work with provinces, territories and indigenous partners to develop it in relation to the full diversity of water challenges across the country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128349","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Fisher, on World Water Day earlier this year, the minister announced that we're going to launch Canada's national water security strategy. This is a significant milestone. Could you speak to what the strategy will mean for Canadians and how the Canada Water Agency intends to work with provinces, territories and indigenous partners to develop it in relation to the full diversity of water challe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4cfec4cc8ada24e822ba4a91b418aa79b54b96f648961bde986ed2cbe9470f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d94c2a4d4ad153f5195d91964a3870fdf7fec0fa7dffe98856f5403f82f9573c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7927c650d01038f15dd82a2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128350,"date":"2026-05-28T18:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much, Ms. Johnson, with another COP approaching later this year, Canada has an important role to play in advancing multilateral climate ambition. Can you speak to how ECCC is positioning Canada to be a climate leader on the world stage?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128350","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Ms. Johnson, with another COP approaching later this year, Canada has an important role to play in advancing multilateral climate ambition. Can you speak to how ECCC is positioning Canada to be a climate leader on the world stage?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7a5f9236088ee501e313ea072200c2ac0e63223ed4da654b70b22957d3294049"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5ebcc8334a9168bac0688c3f62688087a731ccb2c446e30d2d7b10b577c2927c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccaecff0dedbc852c7a07666","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128351,"date":"2026-06-04T16:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"I would like to move my amendment to clause 3. I have a couple of amendments in there, but the first one is to paragraph 3(3)(b), which begins with \"an assessment of the need for modelling that\". My amendment would strike out \"would identify properties and infrastructure at risk from floods\" and replace that with: would support flood and drought forecasting To the beginning of paragraph (d), it would add: measures that the Government of Canada may take in response to the assessments referred to in paragraphs (a) to (c), including That would be followed by \"the preparation of a proposal\" and so on. There's also a correction at the end, where it says, \"and system based on the federal-provincial distributed model of the National Hydrological Service.\" Instead, the last two words should be \"Hydrometric Program.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128351","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like to move my amendment to clause 3. I have a couple of amendments in there, but the first one is to paragraph 3(3)(b), which begins with \"an assessment of the need for modelling that\". My amendment would strike out \"would identify properties and infrastructure at risk from floods\" and replace that with: would support flood and drought forecasting To the beginning of paragraph (d), it wo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-969ea836008c592cbe9eb227","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128352,"date":"2026-06-04T16:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"As currently written, paragraph 3(3)(b) would mean the strategy would have to include an assessment of the need for modelling that would identify properties and infrastructure at risk for floods. This amendment would change the provision to instead require the strategy to include assessment of the need for modelling more generally that could support effective flood and drought forecasting. This is better aligned with the proposed bill, which intends to enhance coordination.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128352","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"As currently written, paragraph 3(3)(b) would mean the strategy would have to include an assessment of the need for modelling that would identify properties and infrastructure at risk for floods. This amendment would change the provision to instead require the strategy to include assessment of the need for modelling more generally that could support effective flood and drought forecasting. This is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50bb4f936c38375934620e57001955ec5466feb68048f72c5a1e37b7bc3dd09f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75d379e6b9190ff50286b099","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128353,"date":"2026-06-04T16:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Do I believe it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128353","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do I believe it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e9631dce4ddc2af52fd7956","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128354,"date":"2026-06-04T16:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Monitoring water levels is always important for predictions of flood forecasting and whatnot, including in my area of Vancouver Quadra, at the mouth of Fraser River, where we've seen the fluctuation in the water levels not only on the Fraser River but in the tributaries surrounding there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128354","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Monitoring water levels is always important for predictions of flood forecasting and whatnot, including in my area of Vancouver Quadra, at the mouth of Fraser River, where we've seen the fluctuation in the water levels not only on the Fraser River but in the tributaries surrounding there.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a62e7f71013d495e54965079ed19d823553bd8bbe1e1b60f2824cf815860aa5d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f663865ed8adaf8fe9c8e7e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128355,"date":"2026-06-04T16:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"For me, I think that saying that and making sure that we follow up on that is something that we will continue to do. I believe that we will make concerted efforts to do that, for sure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128355","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"For me, I think that saying that and making sure that we follow up on that is something that we will continue to do. I believe that we will make concerted efforts to do that, for sure.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-280469701d880841ea461f53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128356,"date":"2026-06-04T16:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"I don't want to be prescriptive always. I think there's always an opening for interpretation, so that's why I feel this is the strongest way to move forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128356","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I don't want to be prescriptive always. I think there's always an opening for interpretation, so that's why I feel this is the strongest way to move forward.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a96f2db2281f3107f9503cf3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128357,"date":"2026-06-04T16:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"I think that the purpose of the bill is to provide the most latitude possible for the development of a strategy moving forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128357","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think that the purpose of the bill is to provide the most latitude possible for the development of a strategy moving forward.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1f3b428ee45e00b58e96dac3cd2c3afb556a233d7e7019c39980190f0cab4ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-983ea99a18f509ef8d7ffbad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128358,"date":"2026-06-11T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. I'll start with you, Mr. Thurlow. It's been clear that the plastics manufacturers are not in agreement with the government trying to ban their products. This is quite clear. Is there any aspect of the government's approach to plastic and plastic waste that you can support?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Plastics industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128358","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. I'll start with you, Mr. Thurlow. It's been clear that the plastics manufacturers are not in agreement with the government trying to ban their products. This is quite clear. Is there any aspect of the government's approach to plastic and plastic waste that you can support?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","label":"Plastics industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Plastics industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","label":"Plastics industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d9b16622dca61f49e50a4abef2c490b8ae8288b60d7ae67074d7f306855589e8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Plastics industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e3affe687373d1a66da22075599eb5314a70ec3646cbe06738878fe647d8d69"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Plastics industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ddc0be163050e72a50d7a722","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128359,"date":"2026-06-11T17:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"The part of the act that was used to designate plastics as toxic is the basis for Canada's chemicals management plan. Are you able to explain to the committee the process by which a chemical substance is assessed and managed and the steps that the CMP undertakes to ensure that there is targeted risk management?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128359","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The part of the act that was used to designate plastics as toxic is the basis for Canada's chemicals management plan. Are you able to explain to the committee the process by which a chemical substance is assessed and managed and the steps that the CMP undertakes to ensure that there is targeted risk management?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Plastics industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","label":"Plastics industry","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["660235f9c8779f56e8c8e35b68922844c4582b32928f40bf43ff9921ecec3c80"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6d5341320790bf0898c4aa431e384232d8c73faf0172516dd38c2c76e673ab55"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd23bc8919af6eb6a86a66bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128360,"date":"2026-06-11T17:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. Dr. Ross, like my colleague Mr. Ross, I'm an indigenous person from the coast of B.C. I'm actually on the south coast of the mouth of the Fraser River and from the Musqueam first nation. I've spent many, many years on the water fishing with my family. My brother is still a commercial fisher. I've been on the water, and I've noticed the increase in plastics as they flow down the river and out into the Salish Sea. I know that some of them have come from many, many, many miles away because of the branding on these plastics and whatnot. Are you able to help the committee understand what body of evidence actually shows how single-use plastics move through a marine ecosystem once they enter it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128360","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Dr. Ross, like my colleague Mr. Ross, I'm an indigenous person from the coast of B.C. I'm actually on the south coast of the mouth of the Fraser River and from the Musqueam first nation. I've spent many, many years on the water fishing with my family. My brother is still a commercial fisher. I've been on the water, and I've noticed the increase in plastics as they flow down the river an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Plastics industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47620","label":"Plastics industry","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b426f24e41ba399688a4aacb39f26e97711e9f8dd1fc0d77209f3c2c61029b37"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0aacd1677b5ab217379cd045","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128361,"date":"2026-06-11T17:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128361","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37eee28eb12b5bea8b4c37e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086509,"date":"2026-06-12T16:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we cannot build a clean Canada if we are not working together. We are thinking differently and strategically to deliver results for Canadians. We have introduced new methane regulations. We have brought Alberta to the table. We have actually brought Canada's largest-emitting province to the table. We will soon also be launching our clean electricity strategy to double our grid in the next number of years. It is something we have promised Canadians. We are going to give this to Canadians today, tomorrow and for future generations, and that is why I am proud to stand on this side of the aisle.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086509","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we cannot build a clean Canada if we are not working together. We are thinking differently and strategically to deliver results for Canadians. We have introduced new methane regulations. We have brought Alberta to the table. We have actually brought Canada's largest-emitting province to the table. We will soon also be launching our clean electricity strategy to double our grid in the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6b9376b6cdf5f37a2270e6af3f991e9640f10b265a8ad82643c79e1af719c195"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a6244d0048bc702f4cbb614b58c9eba00f109b3c68fda7004cebddf32a56ed81"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d76bf26e297276aa2c959ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086510,"date":"2026-06-12T16:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Wade Grant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on top of what I just said, we have also released the nature strategy. We are going to be protecting 30% of Canada's lands and waters by 2030. In fact, about two weeks ago, I went to Klemtu on the coast of British Columbia, where I was standing with the Minister of the Environment and Climate Change. We announced with seven first nations in the province of British Columbia a plan to protect over 6,700 square kilometres of coast. That is equivalent to 1.5 times the size of Banff National Park and larger than Prince Edward Island.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086510","member_id":"bc-mp-123653","member_name":"Wade Grant","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on top of what I just said, we have also released the nature strategy. We are going to be protecting 30% of Canada's lands and waters by 2030. In fact, about two weeks ago, I went to Klemtu on the coast of British Columbia, where I was standing with the Minister of the Environment and Climate Change. We announced with seven first nations in the province of British Columbia a plan to p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["906e78ccc96a7ea0c382c759a015b1d992ec17855cc0dc8c41ad3d0a70b12423"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1242f97c6700b83b9097396ef0e894f4ab47a82d27a7eb26cb39d0ce2615cac3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6fe30fe9f997b34e2bf841d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86107,"date":"2026-02-03T20:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is a bit like living through an episode of The Twilight Zone to hear the opposition talk about carbon pricing in this country.\n\nBeing from British Columbia, I know that the first consumer price on carbon in North America was introduced in British Columbia in 2007 by a right-of-centre government that some members of the opposition benches supported at the time. There is no historical memory opposite of the reality of climate change and climate policy in this country. There is nary an honest word that the opposition has to share on this topic. For a new member of the House such as myself, it is deeply disillusioning.\n\nI wonder whether my hon. colleague from Kingston and the Islands would elaborate on the government's approach to combatting climate change.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86107","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is a bit like living through an episode of The Twilight Zone to hear the opposition talk about carbon pricing in this country.\n\nBeing from British Columbia, I know that the first consumer price on carbon in North America was introduced in British Columbia in 2007 by a right-of-centre government that some members of the opposition benches supported at the time. There is no histori","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b9368fb52d88863b6ee2f06de5ac7d06b97c5d7eda7ef1c21ba0254e084195e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8405a28fb51ad9ffeea57612993a5a190c2e70f8a766091b107930bb9bfec339"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96fd2118f31b1e369a819310","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86108,"date":"2026-02-03T21:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I think we should all in this chamber sympathize because our Conservative colleagues are having a bad week. The polling clearly shows Canadians are rallying behind the leadership of the Prime Minister. The polling clearly shows most Canadians do not have confidence in the Leader of the Opposition. To add insult to injury, just today the last Conservative to serve as prime minister was in the House, reminding our colleagues opposite of that vanishing sensation of winning an election.\n\n My sympathies are with them, but I think it is intolerable to hear our Conservative colleagues working so hard to divide Canadians. As we heard just a few minutes ago, they are dividing rural Canada from urban Canada as though many of our ridings do not straddle both, as though the members in this chamber do not have an obligation to represent all of our constituents and as though urban MPs do not know and love rural Canada.\n\nMy question for my hon. colleague from Winnipeg is whether he would agree that the reason Canadians are supporting the Prime Minister at this time is that he is deeply committed to bringing Canadians together, as he did when he announced last year that the consumer price on carbon would be removed because it was divisive. It was divisive because Conservatives had been attacking it relentlessly for years.\n\n The Prime Minister wants to bring Canadians together. Does my colleague agree?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86108","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I think we should all in this chamber sympathize because our Conservative colleagues are having a bad week. The polling clearly shows Canadians are rallying behind the leadership of the Prime Minister. The polling clearly shows most Canadians do not have confidence in the Leader of the Opposition. To add insult to injury, just today the last Conservative to serve as prime minister w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49d53b65c11a3fd072bae6b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86109,"date":"2026-02-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is again disappointing to hear that the leading strategy of the opposition party is nothing less than pitting Canadians against each other, trying to convince rural Canadians and Canadians from across the prairie provinces that the government does not care about them. The insistence by opposition members that only they speak for real Canadians is one of the core divisive pieces of our politics. It is shameful. The members should, in fact, apologize to the House. They should apologize to my hon. colleague.\n\n I will ask my colleague from St. Paul's whether she would like to elaborate on the way in which affordability challenges related to food are an issue that many Canadians face, Canadians in cities and Canadians in rural Canada, and how the government is addressing those needs while bringing the country together.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86109","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is again disappointing to hear that the leading strategy of the opposition party is nothing less than pitting Canadians against each other, trying to convince rural Canadians and Canadians from across the prairie provinces that the government does not care about them. The insistence by opposition members that only they speak for real Canadians is one of the core divisive pieces o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7725ba3ef9d5a34fe2243f5d41c1624732896cf20eb333c51f9a7c80b36fad1d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e5d1d000001fb8a935853aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86110,"date":"2026-02-03T22:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. colleague for Cumberland—Colchester for the touching and personal remarks she shared with all of us in the chamber today. \n\nI also represent a riding that has a significant number of Canadian Armed Forces and Department of National Defence properties. While the hon. member opposite's point is taken that many members, I am sure, do have an idea of what we might do in our ridings with some of those properties, I would suggest that the merit of my colleague's motion is to have a systematic review of all of those properties across Canada so that, instead of an ad hoc process where individual MPs are putting forward their own favourite projects, we might actually have a more broad, wide-reaching and systematic assessment of the properties that the federal government could use to better effect for Canadians, and in this case, for veterans. Would my colleague care to comment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86110","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. colleague for Cumberland—Colchester for the touching and personal remarks she shared with all of us in the chamber today. \n\nI also represent a riding that has a significant number of Canadian Armed Forces and Department of National Defence properties. While the hon. member opposite's point is taken that many members, I am sure, do have an idea of what we might do in ou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e03c90e0eace8e73527822fe20f61cab7ccf6fd845e9b80e469468b596d9b87"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc13ecf1faaf5625f40fa563","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299638,"date":"2026-02-10T21:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I understand what a challenge the extortion crisis is in my colleague's community, and I understand the passion that he brings to this issue speaking on behalf of his community members today.\n\nMy colleagues on this side of the aisle, especially those of us from British Columbia, have spoken extensively about the extortion crisis. We understand what a challenge this is in many communities across the country. That is why we have spoken with the Premier of British Columbia, cabinet ministers from British Columbia, mayors from municipalities affected most directly in the Lower Mainland, law enforcement officials and chiefs of police. The messages we have received from all those different levels of government and all those different stakeholders are very consistent. We have been told that law enforcement needs more tools, more resources, more cross-border and inter-jurisdictional coordination, and for the House to pass Bill C-2 and Bill C-14.\n\nWill the member agree with just about every other public official on this issue?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299638","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I understand what a challenge the extortion crisis is in my colleague's community, and I understand the passion that he brings to this issue speaking on behalf of his community members today.\n\nMy colleagues on this side of the aisle, especially those of us from British Columbia, have spoken extensively about the extortion crisis. We understand what a challenge this is in many communit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e4bab99519eb6d7d701dff446f43981bd5697503867adaf8dc0b30b270817b7c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f951bd9e3f306da313580ff118398edf966a913c36126597799629c14d3b8373"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-588925414adc4b18a9d90d40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299635,"date":"2026-02-13T17:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today I am pleased to speak as the member of Parliament for Victoria in support of the clean coasts act, put forward by my colleague, the hon. member for West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country.\n\nThose of us who live in and represent coastal communities know that the ocean is our lifeline but also our responsibility.\n\nEven before being elected to the House, I heard from people in my community daily about the negative effects of derelict vessels in our waterways. After every storm, we see more and more vessels that have fallen into disrepair and been abandoned by irresponsible owners for others to deal with. These so-called \"dead boats\" do not just serve as an eyesore for our community; they pose serious safety and environmental risks, often with no one around to be held accountable. There is not one perfect solution to this issue, but I commend my colleague for putting forward Bill C-244, which would take important steps in the right direction.\n\nThe bill would target the irresponsible transfer of vessel ownership. In Victoria, I hear of these instances far too often. An owner sells a rotting hull for a dollar, sometimes less, to somebody who they know cannot maintain it, effectively washing their hands of the environmental liability of responsibly disposing of that vessel. By prohibiting the transfer of vessels to those who lack the resources or the intent to actually maintain them, we would help stop the cycle of abandoned and wrecked vessels before they end up on our beaches and in our marinas. We would be demanding accountability at the point of sale, not just when the taxpayer is forced to foot the bill for a clean-up or removal of a derelict vessel, and not simply relying on the goodwill of local organizations and hard-working volunteers.\n\nI would like to take this opportunity to recognize the often thankless work by organizations in my riding, such as the Cadboro Bay Dead Boats Society, the Royal Victoria Yacht Club, the Veins of Life Watershed Society, and the Dead Boats Disposal Society, as well as others who have given their time and energy to address this issue, often taking on personal costs and liability. I would also like to thank the Canadian Coast Guard's western region and Transport Canada for their role in environmental response but acknowledge that they do not have the capacity or the mandate to single-handedly shoulder this burden.\n\nAs always, we also wish to express our thanks and our appreciation to the Lekwungen-speaking peoples of southern—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299635","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today I am pleased to speak as the member of Parliament for Victoria in support of the clean coasts act, put forward by my colleague, the hon. member for West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country.\n\nThose of us who live in and represent coastal communities know that the ocean is our lifeline but also our responsibility.\n\nEven before being elected to the House, I heard from peopl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","label":"Marine accidents","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a5dfbe6759a09a2beda6054afcf6ad46f39c798f228dd52b08a3d5db84e3aadb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["07c8b80512afbf3a1d8bbfba0be848dab1e2f16552f8316f844d2c67b95a9f7a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b0fdbb7373388f2b247791a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299636,"date":"2026-02-13T18:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as always, we also wish to express our thanks and our appreciation to the Lekwungen-speaking peoples of southern Vancouver Island, the Songhees, Esquimalt and W̱SÁNEĆ nations, whose stewardship and care for these lands and waters since time immemorial set a high bar for our communities and our governments to uphold today—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299636","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as always, we also wish to express our thanks and our appreciation to the Lekwungen-speaking peoples of southern Vancouver Island, the Songhees, Esquimalt and W̱SÁNEĆ nations, whose stewardship and care for these lands and waters since time immemorial set a high bar for our communities and our governments to uphold today—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["adf3e055689e30bddfe1b9459340a691e4e1f4c8c37f662021254219ae88a9b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f354cd4b860c961c807afe1c206fb1d05597685015f18099db54335c149042a0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00b1065a6a76e438854360bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299637,"date":"2026-02-13T18:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to continue. \n\nI want to start again by expressing the thanks and appreciation that everybody in my community has to the Lekwungen-speaking peoples of southern Vancouver Island, the Songhees, Esquimalt and W̱SÁNEĆ nations, whose stewardship of and care for the lands and waters that we live on today since time immemorial sets a high bar for our governments and communities to achieve today. \n\nThe bill before us proposes important amendments to the Canadian Environmental Protection Act to ensure that no person or ship can \"allow the disposal\" of substances in our waters. This is about proactive stewardship. It ensures that negligence is no longer a legal defence for polluting our marine ecosystems.\n\nThe Salish Sea, which surrounds my region and my riding, is an intricate ecosystem, home to species such as the southern resident killer whale and the chinook salmon. These species are put at risk when pollutants are introduced in our waterways, and we have a duty to act.\n\nThe clean coasts act is a common-sense, preventative measure. It would protect our blue economy, save millions in future salvage costs and honour our commitment to maintaining the health, beauty and accessibility of the B.C. coast and all of Canada's coasts for everyone. \n\nI sincerely thank my colleague the hon. member for West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country for bringing this bill forward, and I urge all members of the House to support this important piece of legislation to keep our coasts clean, to keep owners accountable and to keep our oceans thriving.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299637","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to continue. \n\nI want to start again by expressing the thanks and appreciation that everybody in my community has to the Lekwungen-speaking peoples of southern Vancouver Island, the Songhees, Esquimalt and W̱SÁNEĆ nations, whose stewardship of and care for the lands and waters that we live on today since time immemorial sets a high bar for our governments ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","label":"Water pollution"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","label":"Water pollution","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["427747ce33e740d8945746dedfc1cb8fcdffe79012d5c127140e98f7ac3dfcbf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9790585c7f731aa00e3fa3aeb93ab66798c94a42a9faa764af2fbb639b7fae99"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb979d0377fcc20fe3d15029","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128362,"date":"2026-04-16T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning, colleagues, and thank you to our witnesses for being here today. Given some of the recent events occurring in the world, we understand what a difficult time it is for manufacturers, but also for Canadian consumers, whether that's the spike in oil prices due to the crisis in the Strait of Hormuz caused by the United States and Iran, or whether it's the trade war that's been thrust on us by the United States. I'd rather focus my questions on some of the domestic aspects and the domestic benefits that flow from higher rates of EV adoption. In my riding of Victoria, for example, transportation-related emissions account for around 50% of air pollution in our entire region, and some communities in Canada have even higher rates. Health Canada estimates that traffic-related air pollution contributes to around 1,200 premature deaths annually across the country. Mr. Cauchi, I'll start with you. I'm wondering if we could discuss what the health benefits are for Canadians of these newly strengthened GHG standards. How will Canadians benefit in terms of their long-term health outcomes and reduce the strain on our public health care system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128362","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning, colleagues, and thank you to our witnesses for being here today. Given some of the recent events occurring in the world, we understand what a difficult time it is for manufacturers, but also for Canadian consumers, whether that's the spike in oil prices due to the crisis in the Strait of Hormuz caused by the United States and Iran, or whether it's the trade wa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1e75724f44ee448c158beed6739f8a76bc105fc6bebd6b0c3b1d2673b14aaf56"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dbaed1067ea934c561132885355c8ba91b2776f3b690f8bc8dfcb8aa3b7d5a3f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e3f20caea876e25d42bab23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128363,"date":"2026-04-16T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that. In a similar vein that is certainly public health and safety related, I think one of the perhaps less discussed aspects of EV adoption has to do with increased safety for all road users given the lighter mass of electric vehicles as battery technology has become more sophisticated. We've seen not only more energy-efficient EVs entering the market, but also lighter vehicles, which then might have corresponding benefits for road safety and all road users. Is that something that you could also comment on, Mr. Cauchi?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128363","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that. In a similar vein that is certainly public health and safety related, I think one of the perhaps less discussed aspects of EV adoption has to do with increased safety for all road users given the lighter mass of electric vehicles as battery technology has become more sophisticated. We've seen not only more energy-efficient EVs entering the market, but also lighter vehicles, whi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3efbc82a71cb64d9ae1c50b38004dc293bb620c2c8c1ac263af1c840fc82d5a8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0a8afe4f22e37c844ed2e24ab8c69e57e2a0fece3af45602c964eeb362ecb4f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-060f701ea755d14f65317e64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128364,"date":"2026-04-16T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Fair enough. Switching gears slightly, I'll direct my next question to Ms. van der Kamp. If any of the other witnesses would like to respond as well, they should please feel free to do so afterwards. I'd like to drill in on what the estimated cost savings are for the average Canadian household, given the increased cost of fuel and given the market price of EVs now. Can you give us a sense of what the long-term economic benefits to households would be of switching to an EV and saving for themselves those high costs of fuel that we're seeing at the pumps?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128364","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Fair enough. Switching gears slightly, I'll direct my next question to Ms. van der Kamp. If any of the other witnesses would like to respond as well, they should please feel free to do so afterwards. I'd like to drill in on what the estimated cost savings are for the average Canadian household, given the increased cost of fuel and given the market price of EVs now. Can you give us a sense of what ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1043df44a6822df34136deab17619152e71dc357bcf47038787939d91e970532"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["146cff316a47f6c2d15c1ec399ab28d48439a85887ed72d8e4773a7f997b62c3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-540c8c6f780254b6e5f61f6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128365,"date":"2026-04-16T16:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Right now the price of gas in Victoria is around $2.15, so that $1.50 sounds pretty good. Ms. van der Kamp, you also discussed the difference between dense urban, more suburban, remote and in some cases rural regions. Do you have any sense of what the different cost savings would be for Canadians living in those types of communities? Will remote drivers who obviously have much longer distances to cover gain more savings from EV adoption as a result of their longer commutes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128365","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Right now the price of gas in Victoria is around $2.15, so that $1.50 sounds pretty good. Ms. van der Kamp, you also discussed the difference between dense urban, more suburban, remote and in some cases rural regions. Do you have any sense of what the different cost savings would be for Canadians living in those types of communities? Will remote drivers who obviously have much longer distances to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6eb10c139054af8633445abc8c0d145250c17e97cf17d38f1334e5c3a9f05f87"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-92776b298bf504edd5a83a90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128366,"date":"2026-04-16T16:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. Thanks, Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128366","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Thanks, Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb9813f5d961bcf7a137a20f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128367,"date":"2026-04-16T17:15:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to our witnesses for sticking around. I'm going to pick up exactly where my colleague left off. As we're aware, the Prime Minister and the government have recently negotiated tariff relief with China, which allows for a certain number of Chinese-made EVs to enter the Canadian market. I'd just like to give you the opportunity to elaborate on the details of that, specifically with the focus on making lower-cost EVs available to Canadians. Monsieur Tessier, can you speak to how many there will be and what the anticipated price point of those new EVs in the Canadian market will be?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128367","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to our witnesses for sticking around. I'm going to pick up exactly where my colleague left off. As we're aware, the Prime Minister and the government have recently negotiated tariff relief with China, which allows for a certain number of Chinese-made EVs to enter the Canadian market. I'd just like to give you the opportunity to elaborate on the details of that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["572740345687131b12e510b7b50625da7cf811b94a73e88a71112d30c51a3577"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["643050402cd3b992dd19efe36ce48bf67ae5f6551ce2b03f1580e76aa3a60132"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3d69d474e25efe41ebeabbb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128368,"date":"2026-04-16T17:15:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"As 50% of the EVs have been permitted under the recent agreement, do you have any reason to think there might be more EVs made available in the future, which would increase the availability of lower-cost EVs for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128368","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As 50% of the EVs have been permitted under the recent agreement, do you have any reason to think there might be more EVs made available in the future, which would increase the availability of lower-cost EVs for Canadians?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c8ac44c0773228f6184596724563ca50fe313d3037f4d20f1484e24ead7f894"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-409fc6566fe2787fad534381","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128369,"date":"2026-04-16T17:15:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay. Thank you. We heard today and in previous meetings concerns from our colleagues about affordability, about whether or not EVs are essentially a luxury good that won't be available to everyday Canadians, to middle-class families. We know this isn't true. We know that much of the rest of the world is already transitioning towards EVs. We know that more than half of the vehicles sold in the world last year were electric vehicles, so we know that incorrect information has been circulating around this issue. I'm wondering whether any of you could speak to what the government might be able to do to communicate this information more clearly to Canadians about the savings associated with transitioning towards EVs. Is there a strategy in place to communicate how much the annual household savings might be, as we previously discussed, Ms. van der Kamp, or the increasing affordability of the EVs entering the Canadian market? Can we get this information to Canadians to help dispel some of the half-truths that are out there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128369","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you. We heard today and in previous meetings concerns from our colleagues about affordability, about whether or not EVs are essentially a luxury good that won't be available to everyday Canadians, to middle-class families. We know this isn't true. We know that much of the rest of the world is already transitioning towards EVs. We know that more than half of the vehicles sold in the wor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["45890db8f29227bc7816bd83ed738e0e07fb85e07762fea6ae21bc6593a434b2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["294a58d971d4b78723fbfbaaa01b49925d32945df581374ca983351e03cb4e86"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cacccb858b90c1262b2d6abc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128370,"date":"2026-04-16T17:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that. It's great to hear that this is something that falls under your responsibilities at NRCan. Would that information and communication campaign also include some of the information you shared earlier, in terms of the availability of charging stations, making people aware that, in most instances, they actually live in communities that are served by this kind of infrastructure? Similarly, that would be information useful for Canadians to have access to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128370","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that. It's great to hear that this is something that falls under your responsibilities at NRCan. Would that information and communication campaign also include some of the information you shared earlier, in terms of the availability of charging stations, making people aware that, in most instances, they actually live in communities that are served by this kind of infrastructure? Simi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd631c6f78e5b17dd766ea66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128371,"date":"2026-04-16T17:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay. Thank you. I'll go back to Monsieur Tessier. The question around what failing to transition towards a cleaner economy and a cleaner industrial sector means for Canada's international competitiveness is a large one that touches on many different issues. However, it's certainly relevant here as well. We've heard suggestions that Canada shouldn't or cannot get out of alignment with the United States. However, given the current circumstances in the United States, I would hope that it's an aberration that the U.S. government is not currently supportive of this transition and that it's going to be a very difficult position for the United States to maintain going into the future. Can you speak briefly about what the risks to Canada are of not transitioning our own economy towards cleaner energy and lower emissions at a time when that is what the overwhelming majority of the rest of the world is attempting to do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128371","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you. I'll go back to Monsieur Tessier. The question around what failing to transition towards a cleaner economy and a cleaner industrial sector means for Canada's international competitiveness is a large one that touches on many different issues. However, it's certainly relevant here as well. We've heard suggestions that Canada shouldn't or cannot get out of alignment with the United S","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a82327b1cd91bbfebc5dfc4d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128372,"date":"2026-04-16T17:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Before asking my question, I would like to set the record straight because the model of Norway has come up several times in our meeting today, and the reason for that, of course, is that Norway leads the world in EV adoption. Ninety-seven per cent of vehicles sold in that country last year are electric vehicles. One of our colleagues suggested that it was a fallacy to compare Norway to Canada for a variety of reasons. I'd like the record to show that that is not correct. The average December temperature in the community of Tromsø, very, very far north in Norway, I assure you, is 0°C. The average December temperature in Prince Rupert, British Columbia, is 5°C. The average winter temperature in Karasjok, in north Norway, is -16°C. The average temperature in Smithers, British Columbia, is -11°C. Both those communities are in Mr. Ross's riding. The point is that there is, in fact, no geographic nor climatological reasons that something that works in Norway would not work in northern Canada, and the fallacy is that our colleagues continue to insist otherwise. I understand that the comparison to Norway is not favourable to our Albertan friends because it throws into contrast the way that resource wealth has been managed differently in those two polities. Let's try to stick to the facts, please. May I ask our witnesses if there's any reason to believe that cold temperatures or remote northern distances are an insurmountable obstacle towards EV adoption in northern and remote communities in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128372","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Before asking my question, I would like to set the record straight because the model of Norway has come up several times in our meeting today, and the reason for that, of course, is that Norway leads the world in EV adoption. Ninety-seven per cent of vehicles sold in that country last year are electric vehicles. One of our colleagues suggested that it was a fallacy to compa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083611","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Snow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083611","label":"Snow","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09036020fa538a9a9808c176129f581dd961a0bae75484bb5b4664ca275b0af9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-788d4b17353b15bd16eb10be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128373,"date":"2026-04-16T18:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Excuse me. Madam Chair, I think it's difficult to hear the witness. Our colleagues are not showing suitable respect to the witnesses in front of our committee today. I'd ask if we could have a few more seconds for the witness to complete his answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128373","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Excuse me. Madam Chair, I think it's difficult to hear the witness. Our colleagues are not showing suitable respect to the witnesses in front of our committee today. I'd ask if we could have a few more seconds for the witness to complete his answer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["990c526671d68ae617f9de635f77ebe396e71c83c166713c7116cef305505df7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f81179a1cbfcd88f9aaa0902","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128374,"date":"2026-04-16T18:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"I appreciate the response. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128374","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I appreciate the response. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-682a2a836ad34e49f89a1553","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":715160,"date":"2026-04-16T19:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, wild Pacific salmon are a part of who we are for everyone who calls British Columbia or Yukon home. Climate change and habitat loss are already putting additional pressure on this threatened species. We have a responsibility to help this species rebuild.\n\nCan the Minister of Fisheries tell us what this government is doing to help protect wild salmon populations for everyone in British Columbia and along the west coast?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715160","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, wild Pacific salmon are a part of who we are for everyone who calls British Columbia or Yukon home. Climate change and habitat loss are already putting additional pressure on this threatened species. We have a responsibility to help this species rebuild.\n\nCan the Minister of Fisheries tell us what this government is doing to help protect wild salmon populations for everyone in British","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["108b718948e275f278ce611a59d8e70d5c36935a62ffd09e700671adcfab3929"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["67859978ef8f0d4049259cd78c7c55206f8a98f1a615bc485b9fe8373d3bd513"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49afcdc350bf287dbb8eb5d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128375,"date":"2026-04-21T21:20:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon, colleagues. Thank you to the witnesses for joining us today. My first question is for Madame Brouillette. Thank you very much for your testimony. I very much appreciated how you spoke to the fact that the design of Canada's industrial carbon price is often misunderstood and sometimes perhaps wilfully misrepresented. I'm wondering if we could delve into one aspect of how output-based pricing operates in terms of providing funds back to the provinces of origin in order to fund decarbonization and green efforts. Could you speak to how important a funding stream that provides to municipalities and provinces, as far as funding necessary investments in green and sustainable infrastructure is concerned?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128375","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon, colleagues. Thank you to the witnesses for joining us today. My first question is for Madame Brouillette. Thank you very much for your testimony. I very much appreciated how you spoke to the fact that the design of Canada's industrial carbon price is often misunderstood and sometimes perhaps wilfully misrepresented. I'm wondering if we could delve into one a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ffa3ed5646e9e08e5452125","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128376,"date":"2026-04-21T21:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that. Would it be fair to say that this is an important source of funding for those provinces and territories where the federal backstop does apply—that this is a valuable, necessary source of revenue for communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128376","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that. Would it be fair to say that this is an important source of funding for those provinces and territories where the federal backstop does apply—that this is a valuable, necessary source of revenue for communities?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5f143a7aef4eef7b52af4ff99aa70bb3f135a1c18467831dd1ec2a6051045a71"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9527f01bc7bcf08646dcc4d9e899732286891c8ff6101c384059fe7549ddeed4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60a35b6f9530e675c911a6d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128377,"date":"2026-04-21T21:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay. Thank you for that. I want to turn to the global level—you spoke to this in your comments as well, Madame Brouillette—in terms of what the potential implications for Canada are of missing the global market transition toward cleaner energy and lower emissions. In your view, is there another policy lever available to the federal government that could achieve the same scale of emissions reductions as output-based pricing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128377","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you for that. I want to turn to the global level—you spoke to this in your comments as well, Madame Brouillette—in terms of what the potential implications for Canada are of missing the global market transition toward cleaner energy and lower emissions. In your view, is there another policy lever available to the federal government that could achieve the same scale of emissions reducti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["df67473b564346df359a86637fddd1e4b15b961ce8160e559d945192662fe031"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ba4cb85deb5dec7a1e192088ccd42a13e0c4ce8c7d3e8640333f33ab87e83a5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e168e8546888b33105c749a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128378,"date":"2026-04-21T21:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"I appreciate your pointing out that there are multiple tools and policies that the government has in effect to try to address Canada's emissions. Perhaps to reframe the question, do you think it would be a strategic risk for Canada, in terms of achieving both our economic and environmental goals, to move away from a national industrial carbon pricing system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128378","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I appreciate your pointing out that there are multiple tools and policies that the government has in effect to try to address Canada's emissions. Perhaps to reframe the question, do you think it would be a strategic risk for Canada, in terms of achieving both our economic and environmental goals, to move away from a national industrial carbon pricing system?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["385f75342b6fa23bff6aeb0464d644b05b516ead8c8e5e83ca35361a3bfecc81"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01bb1b40e953ed72de733bfd9c857cea4b0960e7f54c75a3b24063411af1d281"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ce9a8679e168aa1e995d659","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128379,"date":"2026-04-21T21:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"What would be the risks to Canada or Canadian investments of not keeping this policy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128379","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What would be the risks to Canada or Canadian investments of not keeping this policy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a57fa036a9a6d66f69deddc388c9c4efa0bea9f5f56383aaa2cba7ab84af392b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3f9f10feeb79afc97e4951e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128380,"date":"2026-04-23T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning to the witnesses—although it's a challenging morning at committee when we hear witnesses offering testimony that, unfortunately, seems deeply at odds with the facts. I would suggest that it is highly misleading, as well, as we move forward with our work and try to prepare a fact-based and evidence-based analysis of the incredibly important issue of industrial carbon pricing in this country. I know some of our colleagues opposite are concerned about the pending changes to the composition of our committees, with more government members likely to be added. I'm glad you have some witnesses here who can effectively serve as additional CPC members, in terms of the quality and tenor of their testimony this morning. I would like to ask our witnesses from the International Institute for Sustainable Development whether or not they could speak to the claims that have been made regarding the impacts of the industrial carbon price in Canada on small businesses and on Canada's international competitiveness. Mr. Cosbey or Mr. Haig, would either of you be able to take a crack at that question?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128380","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning to the witnesses—although it's a challenging morning at committee when we hear witnesses offering testimony that, unfortunately, seems deeply at odds with the facts. I would suggest that it is highly misleading, as well, as we move forward with our work and try to prepare a fact-based and evidence-based analysis of the incredibly important issue of industrial c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a95a69cb8b7f22c01f0f1e34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128381,"date":"2026-04-23T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that response. Maybe I'll start with you, Mr. Cosbey, as I continue into my second question. Can you situate Canada and our carbon-pricing regime for us, relative to other comparable industrialized economies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128381","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that response. Maybe I'll start with you, Mr. Cosbey, as I continue into my second question. Can you situate Canada and our carbon-pricing regime for us, relative to other comparable industrialized economies?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Domestic markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034884","label":"Domestic markets","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5a70203a5dd341f6e5991c98f862d3b9a007db3783468ecfc9c5fa7775b381da"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce43c265ab00123508278b1bc959896b5ed6cc45ef8bcd3943ab5327d272312e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a38f45aa21f0ffe60197c78","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128382,"date":"2026-04-23T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that. I'll turn to Dr. Purdon this morning. Good morning. Thank you for joining us. Could I start with the same question for you, sir? Can you situate Canada's industrial carbon price in the context of comparable industrial economies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128382","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that. I'll turn to Dr. Purdon this morning. Good morning. Thank you for joining us. Could I start with the same question for you, sir? Can you situate Canada's industrial carbon price in the context of comparable industrial economies?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["504d913ebd37c5c0d45a1defa9bd1d6211ae18a63f23c3c4905bff044e7bb9e1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-16a13086b3d60f265856a84e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128383,"date":"2026-04-23T16:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that, Dr. Purdon. Mr. Cosbey and Mr. Haig, could you speak, please, to what you see as the risks to Canada's international competitiveness of removing or further diluting our current policies to reduce emissions and address climate change? How would that affect Canada strategically, in comparison to our trading partners and allies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128383","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that, Dr. Purdon. Mr. Cosbey and Mr. Haig, could you speak, please, to what you see as the risks to Canada's international competitiveness of removing or further diluting our current policies to reduce emissions and address climate change? How would that affect Canada strategically, in comparison to our trading partners and allies?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["91b02407752b8087e2b883ff2db50fed42b5ab7cf1cbae14350d18012b1dbc1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f583260cbb8742dab6aa3b8def4a128f6fd2a2aee62cb6aa80226f9b07980fc6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a051de30d3849ad6ac6fbbc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128384,"date":"2026-04-23T17:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon to our witnesses. Thank you for joining us today. I would like to direct my first questions to Professor McKitrick. Professor, you identified yourself as having a Ph.D. in economics from the University of British Columbia. Could you please clarify if any of your academic training at either the graduate or the undergraduate level was in a field outside of economics?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128384","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon to our witnesses. Thank you for joining us today. I would like to direct my first questions to Professor McKitrick. Professor, you identified yourself as having a Ph.D. in economics from the University of British Columbia. Could you please clarify if any of your academic training at either the graduate or the undergraduate level was in a field outside of econ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97e760da5bab4871cf0f4caba6d25bd5b9b566e59950df6a6dd4a3188c74e08c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9648db705102caa8e1020e4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128385,"date":"2026-04-23T17:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"You're certainly a well-qualified, formally trained economist. You are perhaps well known in certain circles for your views that are outside the realm of economics and in the realm of climate science. Could you clarify, for the committee, your training in the physical or natural sciences that informs our understanding of human impacts on the global biosphere and climate system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128385","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You're certainly a well-qualified, formally trained economist. You are perhaps well known in certain circles for your views that are outside the realm of economics and in the realm of climate science. Could you clarify, for the committee, your training in the physical or natural sciences that informs our understanding of human impacts on the global biosphere and climate system?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["542e3fd96daf0d7f2145029c3b59d4aedadcb1d7ec1cd5249ea2ad404313b275"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8977ffb3757e0eae85e887707075c614f3cbcb98986a0cccba3a86fd502dca4d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-064459a51743e19f0f472aac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128386,"date":"2026-04-23T17:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that clarification. One of your well-known, recent outputs was the review of climate policy in the United States, which was conducted for the U.S. Department of Energy. Could you elaborate on some of the criticisms of that study? Are you aware of concerns with the report's findings, which have been provided publicly or released in various forms by other climate and natural scientists?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128386","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that clarification. One of your well-known, recent outputs was the review of climate policy in the United States, which was conducted for the U.S. Department of Energy. Could you elaborate on some of the criticisms of that study? Are you aware of concerns with the report's findings, which have been provided publicly or released in various forms by other climate and natural scientists","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7ca6b534ad4c54d64b46c518be62ba6742ce161229476d93fe29ad0885182948"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f34b60eee89646b82bc7fa6c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128387,"date":"2026-04-23T17:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that clarification. It's good to hear that the authors are prepared to address at least some of the 114 public criticisms of the scientific content of that report. Professor McKitrick, you testified before this committee, 21 years ago this month, on a loosely related topic—climate change policy. In that testimony, you stated that climate change has \"positive...impacts\" for Canada, particularly with respect to the forestry and agricultural sectors. I'm wondering if the experience and evidence of the last 21 years have changed your views on either of those sectors and how they've been impacted by climate change.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128387","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that clarification. It's good to hear that the authors are prepared to address at least some of the 114 public criticisms of the scientific content of that report. Professor McKitrick, you testified before this committee, 21 years ago this month, on a loosely related topic—climate change policy. In that testimony, you stated that climate change has \"positive...impacts\" for Canada, pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["24b4744abf749d59290a1e1c7d732a3baf201a739b9954080deef09fcc334770"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fe27d28f33e97492b4f0cc4744b9738fbf0f28cb2b52cbc54c05a6fd654e85c1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6620205382ba93bcad2aa9fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128388,"date":"2026-04-23T17:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"There are competing perspectives of the impacts of climate change on agriculture production, and many of those perspectives are borne out by evidence we have of sustained drought conditions in this country. As of the fall of 2025, in fact, 85% of Canada's agricultural lands were under drought conditions. I think that suggests there may be a more focused lens that we might bring to the question of how agriculture will be negatively impacted by the aggregate impacts of climate change, not just by the increases in the average global temperature. With respect to the questions around the impacts of climate change on the forestry sector.... This has had great impacts and been of concern in my home province. In five to 10 seconds, would you be able to comment on how you see the forestry sector benefiting from increased global temperatures?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drought","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128388","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There are competing perspectives of the impacts of climate change on agriculture production, and many of those perspectives are borne out by evidence we have of sustained drought conditions in this country. As of the fall of 2025, in fact, 85% of Canada's agricultural lands were under drought conditions. I think that suggests there may be a more focused lens that we might bring to the question of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","label":"Drought"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drought","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","label":"Drought","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5b998835f7a8715ada4a64eae392fd98e84b117d6f8b1e0f5be25efb45da15d4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drought","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1b468202d4fc0cd8dc764630691ca54a4bf5b1c38f9b2b93c5e408af567daf41"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drought","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drought","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f730ae202b16cf6c580a04da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128422,"date":"2026-05-05T17:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Mr. Chair, I have a point of order. Sorry, but I wanted to clarify the relevance of the questioning to the committee's topic of discussion today. We're talking about Bill S-2 —","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128422","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I have a point of order. Sorry, but I wanted to clarify the relevance of the questioning to the committee's topic of discussion today. We're talking about Bill S-2 —","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efbe2e848326277819ae432c740b3ed8feba792e170cf11576ff563c7f0a132c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7919a2463186fa641ca83f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128423,"date":"2026-05-05T17:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"It's about the gun buyback program, Mr. Zimmer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128423","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's about the gun buyback program, Mr. Zimmer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd80680a07e3f08385fa9833","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128424,"date":"2026-05-05T18:00:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you very much, Chair. Good afternoon, colleagues. Thank you to the witnesses for being here today. I really appreciate their testimony this afternoon and that of the previous witnesses. I think it really underscores the layers of complexity that surround questions of indigenous rights, status and identity in Canada. We have these layers of constitutional, political and judicial structures that seem fairly abstract in many ways. Then we hear personal stories about how these 50,000-foot concepts have affected people's lives in very fundamental ways. One of our previous witnesses made reference to the Garden River First Nation in northern Ontario, which is a place my family has connections with. My grandmother, who was non-indigenous, had two sisters who both married first nations men. They gained status for themselves and their children as a result of that. We can see how, within a single family tree, you can have non-indigenous people, status Indians and non-status indigenous people. It's within all that complexity that we need to try to make good decisions in order to address the injustices and discrimination of the past. This leads me to my question. I'll direct this first to Mrs. Price. Thank you very much for joining us today. In previous testimony to the Senate, you emphasized that \"any amendments to the Indian Act [must be] consistent with the indigenous and human rights affirmed by the UN Declaration and meet the requirement of Free, Prior and Informed Consent.\" I'm wondering if we could explore that a bit—the contradiction that enters in because of the fact that the Indian Act was not, of course, a piece of legislation indigenous peoples consented to. It was imposed on them and affected their family structures and rights in such fundamental ways. How can we reconcile this different set of principles—needing to address the discrimination that still exists in the Indian Act, and the gender-based discrimination against women from first nations families in particular, while meeting the UN declaration's standard of free, prior and informed consent for any changes to the act that would affect the rights of indigenous peoples?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128424","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Chair. Good afternoon, colleagues. Thank you to the witnesses for being here today. I really appreciate their testimony this afternoon and that of the previous witnesses. I think it really underscores the layers of complexity that surround questions of indigenous rights, status and identity in Canada. We have these layers of constitutional, political and judicial structures th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b2f6d6582a9511986624bb3e86850ca4f6347599ad557814248edaac5f716a0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bcc201a7eba49ea2a7a8aae9196bd2680042df07f6228d5ade62aa71bf360143"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26b0a9b8434630e70d77cf30","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128425,"date":"2026-05-05T18:05:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"If I could jump in on that on that point, Mrs. Price, please, just to narrow in—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128425","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If I could jump in on that on that point, Mrs. Price, please, just to narrow in—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b9c816fe93e7a88f47ad700","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128389,"date":"2026-05-05T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, colleagues. Hello, everyone. Thank you for being with us, Ms. Provost. My question for you, Madam Secretary, has to do with how the government is going about the process of identifying new lands in order to meet the 30 by 30 target. In particular, is it often the case that rural, remote and northern parts of the country have more land available to conserve? What measures are contained in this strategy to try to conserve land closer to urban areas, where more Canadians would be able to access it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128389","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, colleagues. Hello, everyone. Thank you for being with us, Ms. Provost. My question for you, Madam Secretary, has to do with how the government is going about the process of identifying new lands in order to meet the 30 by 30 target. In particular, is it often the case that rural, remote and northern parts of the country have more land available to conserve? What measures are contained i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["926357cb88032e13b99f32b6f04479208f5006165bf5c0f34ecd017c88e0001f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-46933a181a03cb03acac2deb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128390,"date":"2026-05-05T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon, colleagues. Good afternoon to our witnesses. Thank you so much for being here. I'll direct my question to Mr. Campbell. Potentially, this is also for Mr. Millar. Given your role, you'd be well suited to answer. We heard from one of our colleagues about the fires in Jasper. I'm a representative of a British Columbia riding, and as we approach a wildfire season after a year with a low snowpack and other concerns about water availability, wildland firefighting is very much on the mind at this time. The plan discussed under the nature strategy takes seriously the need to invest in wildland firefighting, especially in western Canada, which is acutely vulnerable for reasons I've already touched on. We recognize that climate change is a major driver of our worsening fire season. Fires are burning hotter and longer and are stretching farther than ever before, endangering many communities. Can you speak to the kinds of investments being made in services through Parks Canada to help address wildfire risk through a mitigation perspective or to help with response through a firefighting perspective?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128390","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon, colleagues. Good afternoon to our witnesses. Thank you so much for being here. I'll direct my question to Mr. Campbell. Potentially, this is also for Mr. Millar. Given your role, you'd be well suited to answer. We heard from one of our colleagues about the fires in Jasper. I'm a representative of a British Columbia riding, and as we approach a wildfire seaso","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","label":"Forest fires"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","label":"Forest fires","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fcd4106e1f9f62ee2923558c6c630207da751153daa0a71e307819d36650fd88"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["428f45d9274de460d6e83af19aee38b4b7c04de51db4126af34bf4ffba3c1b64"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-634f37b4c15cc7e5c16ec9ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128426,"date":"2026-05-07T14:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Good morning, colleagues, and good morning to our witnesses. Thank you all for being with us today. This issue is so challenging for the committee. We've heard testimony from witnesses—first nations leaders, chiefs and members of different nations, including today, of course—who are very clear and very strong in their support for the amendments contained in Bill S-2 . They insist that the discrimination contained in the Indian Act has to end. It's incompatible with Canadian values, and it's an infringement upon the rights and dignity of first nations and indigenous people, particularly women. We've also heard from representatives and leaders of other first nations and indigenous communities who say that while the discrimination in the Indian Act must end, they do not support these specific amendments because they view the idea that the government would change the Indian Act in a way that creates new members of those nations without the consent of those nations as an infringement on the Crown's duty to consult. The work of this committee and the government is to find the best way forward between these two critical imperatives and these two principles, each of which is fundamental, but in this case, they are actually in some tension. There's the question around ending discrimination, and there's the question around the Crown's obligation to consult with indigenous peoples precisely in the way that it has not done historically and obviously did not do in the case of the Indian Act. In that context, my first question is for the national chief. Thank you for being with us today, Chief. You have advocated frequently for the need for first nations to have control over their own membership and their own citizenship. I'm wondering if you can elaborate on why self-government and control over membership are so fundamental to first nations, in your view.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128426","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Good morning, colleagues, and good morning to our witnesses. Thank you all for being with us today. This issue is so challenging for the committee. We've heard testimony from witnesses—first nations leaders, chiefs and members of different nations, including today, of course—who are very clear and very strong in their support for the amendments contained in Bill S-2 . They insist that the discrimi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6be8a8e97a604eaa3101391612f7368d4ab436018ac94bddee280d083323b0d7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["012c33c62b70abed3d9c64a2d82006b1caa7e6106dea7ff95bdc05436cee042b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2cad0185265567c6d9c5182","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128427,"date":"2026-05-07T14:45:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you for that answer, Chief. Both in that response and in your opening statement, you made mention of co-development and the need for first nations and the federal government to co-develop policies that will affect first nations and indigenous peoples going forward. In that context, I will turn to Chief Smoke. Thank you for being with us today, Chief. I understand that you have had experiences in your role in working with the federal government on these consultative processes. Could you speak to that experience? From your perspective, what have the outcomes of that been for you and for your nation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128427","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for that answer, Chief. Both in that response and in your opening statement, you made mention of co-development and the need for first nations and the federal government to co-develop policies that will affect first nations and indigenous peoples going forward. In that context, I will turn to Chief Smoke. Thank you for being with us today, Chief. I understand that you have had experience","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8906adf6b08bd945d89693ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128391,"date":"2026-05-07T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you and good morning, colleagues. Good morning, witnesses. Thank you for being with us. I'd like to start with two brief questions for Mr. DeMarco. Thank you for being here, Commissioner. Just in the interest of time, could you keep your answers brief? A yes or no is fine unless you have more information that you'd like to add. Given the scale of the federal government's assets—roughly in the neighbourhood of 100 billion dollars' worth of public assets—and the increasing severity and frequency of climate-related extreme weather events and other kinds of impacts, would you agree that investing in climate adaptation and climate-resilient infrastructure is a necessity for the federal government to be a responsible steward of those public assets?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128391","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you and good morning, colleagues. Good morning, witnesses. Thank you for being with us. I'd like to start with two brief questions for Mr. DeMarco. Thank you for being here, Commissioner. Just in the interest of time, could you keep your answers brief? A yes or no is fine unless you have more information that you'd like to add. Given the scale of the federal government's assets—roughly in th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f0f08a750692877d08fc207","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128392,"date":"2026-05-07T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. In the same vein, then, would you also agree that recognizing the reality of climate change and the scientific basis underpinning our understanding of climate change, including the role of human activities in making climate change happen faster and more aggressively, is also necessary for the government to fulfill its obligations to safeguard the public assets in its care?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128392","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. In the same vein, then, would you also agree that recognizing the reality of climate change and the scientific basis underpinning our understanding of climate change, including the role of human activities in making climate change happen faster and more aggressively, is also necessary for the government to fulfill its obligations to safeguard the public assets in its care?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc4e683d9883ec307b8bd329ab2c891cde2415020be06523ad41f10fc0b583ef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1be62c2347f0fc9ca3ba584d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128393,"date":"2026-05-07T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"That's excellent. Thank you for that, sir. My next question is for Ms. Wood from DFO. Thank you for joining us online. I'm very excited, of course, with the government's recent announcement of the investment of approximately $1 billion in small craft harbours across the country. This is something that will benefit many communities that are reliant upon access to the water and the harbour infrastructure that supports local jobs, livelihoods, culture and identity, including in my province of British Columbia. Could you please elaborate on what specific innovations or measures are being taken to ensure those upgrades in small craft harbour infrastructure will be more resilient in the face of extreme weather events and other climate impacts?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128393","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's excellent. Thank you for that, sir. My next question is for Ms. Wood from DFO. Thank you for joining us online. I'm very excited, of course, with the government's recent announcement of the investment of approximately $1 billion in small craft harbours across the country. This is something that will benefit many communities that are reliant upon access to the water and the harbour infrastru","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f426a549dde16b03dc69ce3e1d485ce605d956881341fc742d96ba00be6c959a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5607a3b6298ff652f37c4ab400ccdf9eb077386a85263c8f7caf775d1c6a534"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c25bbf64af7a4ca69d380b0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128394,"date":"2026-05-07T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128394","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7313a85bc5266c419bfb64f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128395,"date":"2026-05-07T17:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much. Hello again, colleagues. Thanks to all of our witnesses. My question is for Dr. Furness. Thank you for joining us today to discuss some of the report's conclusions around avian flu and the government's response. I wonder if you could give us a high-level synopsis of what the best practices are that help to ensure that a single reported case of avian flu doesn't turn into a wider outbreak or a national crisis.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Influenza","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128395","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Hello again, colleagues. Thanks to all of our witnesses. My question is for Dr. Furness. Thank you for joining us today to discuss some of the report's conclusions around avian flu and the government's response. I wonder if you could give us a high-level synopsis of what the best practices are that help to ensure that a single reported case of avian flu doesn't turn into a wid","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","label":"Influenza"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Influenza","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035433","label":"Furs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","label":"Influenza","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a5b7a7a8ff950253022ed7a18458b873d8575832c0a59ffb31a9c550c2a6c9c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Influenza","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["13999200fecba11086e6a6e5476e4889e040421c24318f3ed51cd0345b08654b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Influenza","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Influenza","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:234024","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-969f758aedf0bb65f0404d8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128396,"date":"2026-05-07T17:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much. I have only a few seconds left. Could you also speak to whether it is considered best practice to secure vaccine supplies early, even when the eventual severity of the outbreak is not yet known?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128396","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I have only a few seconds left. Could you also speak to whether it is considered best practice to secure vaccine supplies early, even when the eventual severity of the outbreak is not yet known?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04de756d9b2966ff87bcacde567475589cb9e216907396dc8b56972bbd319637"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f388d85c8c402560f04909a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128397,"date":"2026-05-07T17:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"My time is up, but thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128397","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My time is up, but thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa7b5db5182d475a11e0cf7c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128398,"date":"2026-05-07T17:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much for your indulgence, Mr. Chair. The question was simply whether it is considered a best practice to secure vaccine supplies early, even if the eventual severity of an outbreak is not yet known.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128398","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much for your indulgence, Mr. Chair. The question was simply whether it is considered a best practice to secure vaccine supplies early, even if the eventual severity of an outbreak is not yet known.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d003cf1e01f5dd282277cb6b7f2e695c65c994f38cc7d3685bf72aa5733b2585"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b495a5b1029fd027122c1fefe848641700ae15a6c75ee6386af6a7884709ace5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a24b0a0fe60e00b0307934ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128399,"date":"2026-05-07T17:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you to the hon. member for Carleton. Thank you, once again, to all our witnesses for indulging us in this extra long meeting today. I do not believe we have anybody from the Department of National Defence. If we do, perhaps the director general could come forward. Thank you very much for joining us. I appreciate it. One of the pieces that jumped out at me from the commissioner's report was about the large share of federal assets that are the responsibility of the Department of National Defence, which really underscores the necessity for DND to take climate resilience and adaptation seriously for its infrastructure and other assets. Could you speak to the future planning, perhaps, at DND in terms of the kinds of actions that will be taken to ultimately ensure the effectiveness and operational readiness of those assets going forward?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128399","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you to the hon. member for Carleton. Thank you, once again, to all our witnesses for indulging us in this extra long meeting today. I do not believe we have anybody from the Department of National Defence. If we do, perhaps the director general could come forward. Thank you very much for joining us. I appreciate it. One of the pieces that jumped out at me from the commissioner's report was a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e0b34a32ceea5f9f186f83b61066552173a73f131ad16ed9f23e4e7fecf09b8c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3460cccf46606018c97e3fcbaa00a1ed685a2a59ecab17c21a23fb23c5769589"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da96dd33a82f0c50cce6a6f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128400,"date":"2026-05-07T17:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much for that answer, Ms. Evans. In the final minute remaining, could you maybe expand on the greatest climate-related risks that DND assets and operations face at this time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128400","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much for that answer, Ms. Evans. In the final minute remaining, could you maybe expand on the greatest climate-related risks that DND assets and operations face at this time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60c2e4c4dd9de82902e76333974378cf20df19be5b242616e391308489ae3c7e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-977619555f639ec139084e65","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128401,"date":"2026-05-07T17:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much, and thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128401","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, and thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e14d2f2e9e855ffa350953ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128402,"date":"2026-05-26T21:40:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Good afternoon, colleagues. Good afternoon, Ms. Auguste. Thank you for being here today. Thank you for bringing forward this private member's bill, which speaks to a topic of the utmost importance to many of our communities. As the member of Parliament for Victoria my community, unfortunately, is periodically afflicted by both drought and flooding, so these are experiences with which we are intimately familiar. In fact, in 2021, our province of British Columbia was afflicted by a series of extreme weather events that had devastating impacts right across BC. The extreme flooding in that year not only cut off my region of greater Victoria from the rest of Vancouver Island, but it was actually severe enough that it cut off the city of Metro Vancouver and the port of Vancouver from the rest of Canada. The economic and social impacts as well as the physical damage of these kinds of events are difficult to overstate, so planning appropriately really does seem to be an item of the greatest urgency for this country and this government. That being said, could you elaborate on how a national strategy, as outlined in your private member's bill, would help governments, the provinces and other agencies to proactively protect infrastructure in the face of extreme weather events such as flooding?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128402","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Good afternoon, colleagues. Good afternoon, Ms. Auguste. Thank you for being here today. Thank you for bringing forward this private member's bill, which speaks to a topic of the utmost importance to many of our communities. As the member of Parliament for Victoria my community, unfortunately, is periodically afflicted by both drought and flooding, so these are experiences with which we are intima","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","label":"Floods"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","label":"Floods","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cee218f138fb56bd1248a7e1efb5c0c1ce09dad9458ccc1648dfd7c135694ac9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9abb69c5a850a58b5be72ffe45c3f7d414eea83f82173ea9c9590aa167d83ae0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89777c4f6b01e9ed6764711f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128403,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll be sharing my time with the honourable gentleman from Bay of Quinte. Good afternoon, witnesses. Thank you so much for joining us. I'm not entirely sure whom to direct this to, but potentially it's Mr. Vu. If somebody else is better suited, please feel free to direct the question to them. I'm wondering if you could explain, for the benefit of the committee, how it is that the federal government currently tracks key infrastructure across the country for vulnerability to extreme weather events such as flooding, drought or wildfires. Is there currently a system that identifies particularly vulnerable infrastructure? What does that process look like?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128403","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll be sharing my time with the honourable gentleman from Bay of Quinte. Good afternoon, witnesses. Thank you so much for joining us. I'm not entirely sure whom to direct this to, but potentially it's Mr. Vu. If somebody else is better suited, please feel free to direct the question to them. I'm wondering if you could explain, for the benefit of the committee, how it is th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["caf506b2f971b57ea0be57eb9755211fb06b5eab0cf4279a795b59177bbd3fd0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b461f1c887e1d261e10c4dbad558e716a48b545f76a758de0d19c60141d380ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4ae79e630729c4ef8740a4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128404,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"In your view, then, if there were a system that made it easier to compare data from different provinces and territories and across jurisdictions around, obviously, flood and drought risk, would that data facilitate measures to ensure the safety of critical infrastructure around the country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128404","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In your view, then, if there were a system that made it easier to compare data from different provinces and territories and across jurisdictions around, obviously, flood and drought risk, would that data facilitate measures to ensure the safety of critical infrastructure around the country?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drought","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","label":"Data processing","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","label":"Drought","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f8a046b25d45ef6f14841da4ecf80406d2a3813521353680ef1617433c100c1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07de487fa1bc9a89ddc0ba03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128405,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. In my remaining time, I'll quickly move to Ms. El Bied. Thank you for being here. One of the risks that we're obviously facing in British Columbia, as well as in other parts of the country, is extreme wildfires. Could you speak to how better mapping and data around drought might more effectively inform your team on wildfire risks?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128405","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. In my remaining time, I'll quickly move to Ms. El Bied. Thank you for being here. One of the risks that we're obviously facing in British Columbia, as well as in other parts of the country, is extreme wildfires. Could you speak to how better mapping and data around drought might more effectively inform your team on wildfire risks?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-138e49de0b660f5e6703e583","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128406,"date":"2026-05-26T22:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much. I'll pass along my time now, Madam Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128406","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I'll pass along my time now, Madam Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6df7b76ef459022c2ad340af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128407,"date":"2026-05-28T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning, colleagues. Thank you for joining us today, Minister. It's a pleasure to have you with us, though I am sorry that our meeting today has started with questions from our Conservative colleagues opposite who are, to put it mildly, factually challenged and more or less pretend that the province of British Columbia doesn't exist and hasn't benefited from enormous investments in the resource sector over the last 10 years. As you're well aware, Canadians across the country supported the public acquisition and construction of a $35-billion pipeline to support the Alberta energy sector. We've seen the largest private sector investment in Canadian history in LNG Canada, which is now moving towards phase two. Frankly, the members opposite shouldn't need any reminding from me about the LNG that B.C. has been developing over the last decade. It's frustrating to have this be the context of your meeting, when it's very clear that British Columbia has helped lead the country in the last 10 years in terms of building out our natural resource and energy sectors. Having said all that, it's also true that the government is clearly committed to helping to preserve and conserve our incredible natural environment in British Columbia. Recently, members of your team representing the Government of Canada, along with the Government of British Columbia and Coastal First Nations, announced a historic milestone to establish a national marine conservation area reserve on the B.C. coast. This is an incredibly exciting announcement as we move towards our 30 by 30 targets for conservation in this country. I wonder if you could please speak to how this new agreement and the conservation area will help to protect Pacific salmon and help to support our coastal economies and coastal ecologies going forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128407","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning, colleagues. Thank you for joining us today, Minister. It's a pleasure to have you with us, though I am sorry that our meeting today has started with questions from our Conservative colleagues opposite who are, to put it mildly, factually challenged and more or less pretend that the province of British Columbia doesn't exist and hasn't benefited from enormous i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0d2a43ceca26833c5ef304ee08630fe7aaa3753b8bdd25b439317456f26734e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d31cbb741d579e2d76ce1e3b707fd0155e5221bab769cb67b295574b389c0f10"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a503c8f14f02f0547f460fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128408,"date":"2026-05-28T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Minister.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128408","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Minister.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6664b7f8a6c2519708ac9b8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128409,"date":"2026-05-28T17:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much, colleague. Good afternoon to our witnesses. Thank you for joining us today. My question is for Mr. Campbell and Parks Canada. As you are aware, my home riding of Victoria is one of the great destinations in this country, receiving more than one million visitors a year to explore the best of our region. That includes a number of national parks and national historic sites as well. I'm wondering if Parks Canada has data from last year about the effect of the Canada Strong pass in terms of attendance at those kinds of sites and parks, not necessarily specific to Victoria—though that would be welcome—but more broadly. What impact did that program have on attendance for Parks Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128409","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, colleague. Good afternoon to our witnesses. Thank you for joining us today. My question is for Mr. Campbell and Parks Canada. As you are aware, my home riding of Victoria is one of the great destinations in this country, receiving more than one million visitors a year to explore the best of our region. That includes a number of national parks and national historic sites as wel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2404571cddaa724ac2bd75b7f6c7f150a6e9264d07d641982f1590207580d17a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e64e3e05ad1f190d97d40ae22531a4100c5eafe44bb05232208e33c2ac914ca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9f593745622f214cadc760f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128410,"date":"2026-05-28T17:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Absolutely. We see those effects in our region every day. Relatedly, in the context of the government's 30 by 30 conservation targets, national parks and national urban parks play an important role in increasing access for Canadians to natural spaces and conservation areas. I'm wondering if you could speak to the process of establishing those new national urban parks and, in particular, the way Parks Canada interacts with indigenous nations and communities, whose territories may be implicated in those projects.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128410","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Absolutely. We see those effects in our region every day. Relatedly, in the context of the government's 30 by 30 conservation targets, national parks and national urban parks play an important role in increasing access for Canadians to natural spaces and conservation areas. I'm wondering if you could speak to the process of establishing those new national urban parks and, in particular, the way Pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b29d808bffbf9a814ccef9795da7ee9f71ced5a521b228a5345db08d0a009b22"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6d0576c7fb0a80e81a85e8445459039134233b05ee018a352ea0c0e41152fd8c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1092e9e13994825b127abf6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128411,"date":"2026-05-28T17:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128411","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe5f502b49225189016bc0aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128428,"date":"2026-06-04T13:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you, Chair. Good morning, colleagues, and thank you to our witnesses for being here today. My question is also for Mr. Murdoch-Flowers. Thank you for joining us, sir. As you may be aware, earlier this year the Prime Minister announced an investment of $1 billion in the Arctic infrastructure fund to help build and expand the most important transportation infrastructure in the northern part of our country. I'm wondering if you could speak to how you think that money could best be allocated in the north to help address the supply chain challenges and cost of living issues there, particularly related to food affordability, as you've spoken to this morning. What could that money do to help reduce the cost of food for people in Iqaluit and other northern communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128428","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Good morning, colleagues, and thank you to our witnesses for being here today. My question is also for Mr. Murdoch-Flowers. Thank you for joining us, sir. As you may be aware, earlier this year the Prime Minister announced an investment of $1 billion in the Arctic infrastructure fund to help build and expand the most important transportation infrastructure in the northern part of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15b61924f165a915986a0f82","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128429,"date":"2026-06-04T15:00:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you very much, Chair. Thank you for being here, Mr. Vivian. I'd like to pick up on the theme of infrastructure that you've been touching on. It's really fascinating to hear about your long experience living and working in the north. I'm sure that in that time you've seen a lot of change. We know that the level of public interest in the north has varied over time. We know that the level of governmental interest in the north has varied over time. We know that the north has often found itself at the intersection of large global or macro forces, whether those are geopolitics, global economic trends or, for example, the impacts of global warming and global climate change, which have such a profound impact on northern communities and northern infrastructure. I would expect that in the context of your particular field of geology and mining, where there's so much change happening in terms of the landscape of the north—the physical soils, the permafrost thaw, etc.—you are aware that the government is focused on investing in northern infrastructure, but the focus is very much on dual-benefit or multi-use infrastructure that will help meet the needs of the Department of National Defence, the Canadian Armed Forces and northern communities, which of course have been significantly underinvested in with regard to critical infrastructure over many decades. I'm wondering if you could share your perspective on what would be the best types of investments for dual-benefit, dual-use infrastructure in the north that in your view would help serve not only the needs of local communities but also the needs of industry, the needs of geoscientists such as yourself and—if you're able to add this—the needs of the defence community in northern Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128429","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Chair. Thank you for being here, Mr. Vivian. I'd like to pick up on the theme of infrastructure that you've been touching on. It's really fascinating to hear about your long experience living and working in the north. I'm sure that in that time you've seen a lot of change. We know that the level of public interest in the north has varied over time. We know that the level of go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2b30010fc8c420fec9365159c504f1b7c44b747f66c9d07427cfd4ce8510a7cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94af957023fca1cb5fc2d4a6fed10bf7eb14c949b359c90cf89048104822bb6b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8a4f8a2e6ea871a63546ac1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128430,"date":"2026-06-04T15:05:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"That anticipates my next question, which is about inviting you to reflect on how the federal government might best spend the $1 billion that's been allocated for the Arctic infrastructure fund to support lowering costs and increasing affordability for northerners. It sounds like your answer might be investing in road infrastructure, but I'll give you an opportunity to elaborate, if you'd like.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128430","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That anticipates my next question, which is about inviting you to reflect on how the federal government might best spend the $1 billion that's been allocated for the Arctic infrastructure fund to support lowering costs and increasing affordability for northerners. It sounds like your answer might be investing in road infrastructure, but I'll give you an opportunity to elaborate, if you'd like.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","label":"Arctic"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","label":"Arctic","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3db5a4211a6dfb414cd6105004bbf87c9dba6388695c52026d5e8775941c4d0c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["99782fb25ea4da3266a0800a5abe502f18c4512676b4c8a179860829df0027df"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15b27435556c7d0edf8e7e72","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128431,"date":"2026-06-04T15:05:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Drawing on your experience as a professional geologist, somebody who I imagine has spent a great deal of time working on the land, working in communities and working on different kinds of sites, I'm wondering if you could speak to how climate impacts—and I am thinking specifically of permafrost thaw, although there may be other relevant impacts—have driven the cost of these infrastructure projects up. We know they've increased the cost for industry in the development of new mine projects, but likewise, they will increase the cost for government to invest in infrastructure like roads. Can you reflect on that in our final 20 seconds, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128431","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Drawing on your experience as a professional geologist, somebody who I imagine has spent a great deal of time working on the land, working in communities and working on different kinds of sites, I'm wondering if you could speak to how climate impacts—and I am thinking specifically of permafrost thaw, although there may be other relevant impacts—have driven the cost of these infrastructure projects","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c16f20b8ee6185a07ed31501","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128412,"date":"2026-06-04T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to the officials for sharing some time with us this morning. To clarify some of the intent behind my colleagues' questions, I'm wondering if you could specify in quite simple terms whether you would agree that the amendments proposed today would allow the government to develop a more comprehensive strategy for flood prevention and drought prevention.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128412","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to the officials for sharing some time with us this morning. To clarify some of the intent behind my colleagues' questions, I'm wondering if you could specify in quite simple terms whether you would agree that the amendments proposed today would allow the government to develop a more comprehensive strategy for flood prevention and drought prevention.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drought","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","label":"Drought","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9a132a0f19d0889fbbdda2a47a0014fa759503ba259dcdf767cfc99e850755b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61803fa1c66b9dcf609b1962","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128413,"date":"2026-06-04T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. Does this amendment, in your view, give officials like you better tools to do what this legislation is asking you to do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128413","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Does this amendment, in your view, give officials like you better tools to do what this legislation is asking you to do?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05f7cb6470d298d3dba90fc821273744c4ef360269b10c774d8552ce12aaa8c6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e07b7888225e70af9e03f702","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128414,"date":"2026-06-04T16:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128414","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da990273c0f050f1d5491d55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084434,"date":"2026-06-04T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, across British Columbia, workers and communities know how important the forestry sector is to our economy. As Canada's forest ministers met this week in Langford on southern Vancouver Island—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084434","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, across British Columbia, workers and communities know how important the forestry sector is to our economy. As Canada's forest ministers met this week in Langford on southern Vancouver Island—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["299b1a2dacfa11410c33c70ef174f6cb8f29f55060e5182d35beebf3e1e9e836"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e35bb98b5920d43a309d23760fc7acd75d90c44e44f02cf4095dc373f8d285d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6bb07b5eba4337b3d4c200b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084435,"date":"2026-06-04T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, across British Columbia, workers and communities know how important the forestry sector is to our economy. As Canada's forest ministers met this week in Langford on beautiful Vancouver Island to discuss the future of forestry, workers face unjustified U.S. softwood lumber tariffs and conditions that will require us to make our forestry sector more competitive.\n\nCan the Minister of Industry update the House on how our government is working with provinces and territories to strengthen the sector and support forestry workers from coast to coast to coast?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084435","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, across British Columbia, workers and communities know how important the forestry sector is to our economy. As Canada's forest ministers met this week in Langford on beautiful Vancouver Island to discuss the future of forestry, workers face unjustified U.S. softwood lumber tariffs and conditions that will require us to make our forestry sector more competitive.\n\nCan the Minister of Ind","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a67e7b86e873bc07068f796dc64a0bd5997f59462029d8fdca10e3b4a60e548"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9da315cad35d5b6c1ec79d2b5eeb05f671749e5b0ac8953bf4eeb05cfd61e015"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e37df400473c7d23f3a2ad2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128432,"date":"2026-06-11T15:00:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Good morning, Chair. Thank you. Good morning, colleagues. Thank you to our witnesses for being here today. My first question is for Minister Alty. It is in a similar vein to that of my colleague opposite a moment ago. As you're aware, in British Columbia, there have been very active discussions about questions pertaining to aboriginal title. I'm hoping, Minister, that you can speak to the recently signed agreement between Canada and the Musqueam Indian Band. As you're aware, this agreement strengthens the Musqueam's role in fisheries stewardship and marine emergency management on the British Columbia coast. This agreement represents a major step toward reconciliation and the implementation of the Musqueam's aboriginal rights under section 35 of the Constitution. However, we have heard, unfortunately, a great deal of either confusing information or, in some cases, misinformation in British Columbia. I'm hoping you can explain for the committee, Minister, and perhaps for Canadians watching, what the Musqueam agreement achieves and, equally, what it does not mean. How does this agreement reflect and entrench the rights of the Musqueam, while maintaining the rights of Canadians under the Constitution as well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128432","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Good morning, Chair. Thank you. Good morning, colleagues. Thank you to our witnesses for being here today. My first question is for Minister Alty. It is in a similar vein to that of my colleague opposite a moment ago. As you're aware, in British Columbia, there have been very active discussions about questions pertaining to aboriginal title. I'm hoping, Minister, that you can speak to the recently","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4d1b6433333fbaeb02b999908e4d5a02596a8e14d69fd82aedc2eb6710d4b2cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e232011a6c4cec67ca7e48530da03a98324b3b9719e5af52de195abe13cd79cb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d3a236c4c191a2515dc45aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128433,"date":"2026-06-11T15:00:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you very much, Minister. I appreciate that response. I'll quickly turn to Minister Chartrand. Thank you for being here with us. Prior to being elected last year, in my previous career, I was an academic focused on questions of Arctic security and defence, so your portfolio is very near and dear to my heart. It's something I've taken a great interest in for many years. I'm wondering if you could please elaborate, Minister, on how you see the government's Arctic defence spending commitments as being integrated with the interests and needs of communities. Specifically, what are the best opportunities for the government to make defence investments that will best support northerners in all the other aspects of their life as well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128433","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Minister. I appreciate that response. I'll quickly turn to Minister Chartrand. Thank you for being here with us. Prior to being elected last year, in my previous career, I was an academic focused on questions of Arctic security and defence, so your portfolio is very near and dear to my heart. It's something I've taken a great interest in for many years. I'm wondering if you co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","label":"Arctic"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","label":"Arctic","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d7386c3a0badd51c0c761e6b2b4e94e5407d4695fff8cfa45a01341a809b52b6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab1c4304d9947f93fe32f964323bf672423ec71e1292c03e5ab7a4566d74cf0e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6943a95c2152550f707434e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128434,"date":"2026-06-11T15:05:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you very much, Minister. I appreciate that response. Mr. Chair, I'll share the remainder of my time with the honourable member for St. Boniface—St. Vital.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128434","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Minister. I appreciate that response. Mr. Chair, I'll share the remainder of my time with the honourable member for St. Boniface—St. Vital.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5d930500aabfda5b69bf17dc338cc7e7fd0c746a4ff76aab54d4c45790930b50"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a9f408122e2710e45e3b64c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128415,"date":"2026-06-11T16:25:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair, and good morning, colleagues. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today. My first question is for Dr. Ross. Thank you for joining us today, sir. Thank you for your contributions to the study of our ecosystems and water systems in southern British Columbia, in particular, a highly relevant experience that informs our discussion and our study today. I'd like to drill into this question of the economic impacts of plastics as we were just hearing. We're often presented with the argument about the negative environmental impacts of regulating plastics in various ways. However, from a differing perspective, and as a representative of a coastal community that has millions of visitors come every single year, we see the way in which plastic pollution on our coastline and in our waters is actually an economic threat to one of our core industries in the visitor economy. I would suggest that's true not just on Vancouver Island but everywhere that we have beautiful coastlines in this country, whether that's elsewhere on the B.C. coast, whether that's in Gros Morne National Park in Newfoundland, whether that's the Bow River in Alberta, or indeed on the shores of Lake Ontario. In that context, Dr. Ross, could you speak to the volume of plastic pollution that we have in our waterways? Would you have any comments you could offer about the economic harms that plastic pollution causes to our local and regional economies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128415","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair, and good morning, colleagues. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us today. My first question is for Dr. Ross. Thank you for joining us today, sir. Thank you for your contributions to the study of our ecosystems and water systems in southern British Columbia, in particular, a highly relevant experience that informs our discussion and our study today. I'd like to drill in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3ff1324ba1e05711559f0f7e520039ba81f4039383f41910b8ac8dee97f510a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["af1b5866d7da15e3ab9aa09026ac0e4c0c45cc95c38a6e53d0b0de361149d1cb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb1b81b6984c32f0b4bd2bc9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128416,"date":"2026-06-11T16:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that answer, Dr. Ross. You anticipated my next question. I'd like to drill down on the connection between land and the rivers, seas and oceans that surround us and marine life. As you're aware, for our community here in Victoria, our urban and rural watersheds are directly tied to the health of the Salish Sea and, as you mentioned, the southern resident orcas and the salmon populations that inhabit those waters. They are inseparable from our way of life and many aspects of culture and identity on the B.C. coast. In that context, could you please explain how plastic pollution from inland watersheds is compounding the challenges facing these species in critical marine habitats? Specifically, what targeted interventions at the watershed level would yield the greatest benefit for cleaner oceans and waters for all of us?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128416","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for that answer, Dr. Ross. You anticipated my next question. I'd like to drill down on the connection between land and the rivers, seas and oceans that surround us and marine life. As you're aware, for our community here in Victoria, our urban and rural watersheds are directly tied to the health of the Salish Sea and, as you mentioned, the southern resident orcas and the salmon populatio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b487d4c22b48cda7fd9396a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128435,"date":"2026-06-16T16:55:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. I'll go to you, Ms. Chamberlain. In British Columbia, around other recent modern land claim or treaty negotiations, or other self-government agreements, we've unfortunately seen efforts to misinform and confuse members of the public about what the implications of those agreements would entail. In many instances, efforts to purposefully generate that concern have focused on questions around private property ownership. I'm wondering if you could speak to whether or not you've had similar challenges in this negotiation—people being concerned about the impacts on private property—and what kinds of communications the government has put out to address and allay those concerns as not being warranted in this case.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128435","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. I'll go to you, Ms. Chamberlain. In British Columbia, around other recent modern land claim or treaty negotiations, or other self-government agreements, we've unfortunately seen efforts to misinform and confuse members of the public about what the implications of those agreements would entail. In many instances, efforts to purposefully ge","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["510a90b64b504093bade362b1c75561d252aa40c838133f21be374478eddad93"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a51fcc39bd7e8c5016315561b8ffd76482efe8474583ea72047ac3ec700d4afc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-545605f6c8495263e0276792","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128436,"date":"2026-06-16T16:55:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128436","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bb19c2da0c0ce7a6e448d4e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128417,"date":"2026-06-16T20:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Good afternoon, colleagues. Good afternoon, MP Weiler. Thank you so much for bringing forward this private member's bill and for giving us the opportunity to talk about an issue that I know is of great concern to residents in your part of the country, which is close to my part of the country, and our coastal communities, where this issue is a surprisingly topical one in many instances. It's probably the first issue, in fact, that I was approached on after last year's election and that people demanded our government take action on. I appreciate your stepping in to help address that need. I think it's particularly important, as our colleague opposite mentioned a moment ago in his remarks, to bring attention to this issue for our colleagues who may not live in coastal communities, who may not live in marine-adjacent ridings such as ours and may not be familiar with the many aspects and challenges associated with dead and derelict boats being, in many cases, abandoned. One thing that leaps out at me about this issue is that people see it through many distinct lenses. We have, obviously, an environmental perspective in terms of contamination in the waters and on the shoreline and impacts on animal populations. We also have implications in terms of local economies, tourism and destination-based economies like ours. These vessels are something of an eyesore. There are also impacts on public finances—because, at the end of the day, the cost to remove these derelict vessels falls on the public purse—as well as for safety and other reasons. There are numerous different ways in which we can interrogate this issue. With that in mind, would you be able to expand for our colleagues, who may not be as familiar with the knock-on impacts of these vessels in our communities, on how Bill C-244 will work to reduce the instances of new boats being added to this problem?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128417","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Good afternoon, colleagues. Good afternoon, MP Weiler. Thank you so much for bringing forward this private member's bill and for giving us the opportunity to talk about an issue that I know is of great concern to residents in your part of the country, which is close to my part of the country, and our coastal communities, where this issue is a surprisingly topical ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec049d83dfa0a0a9ffc5f69d57657f5ed4fbff6907300e19485ecd76bb400eff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22d69ecb48e853c5a4cf63430d51250b0006a4a4fd53b9e44d94ffb9d65d717d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b821c75c4d22118e3cc38fd3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128418,"date":"2026-06-16T20:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you for that response. I want to pick up on one piece of what you just said. I feel that, in many communities where this isn't as relevant an issue, there isn't an appreciation of the costs and the quite specific technical expertise that could be required to remove these boats from our shores and communities once they've been abandoned. Certainly, in Victoria, I have people quite frequently ask me about where the responsibility for dead and derelict boats falls. Who's responsible for paying for their removal? Is it the Coast Guard? Is it the municipality? Is it me personally? Should I dive into the water and pull them out with my bare hands? I'm wondering if you could speak to the challenges related to resources and jurisdiction that arise around this issue, because I know there's quite a bit of complexity here. At the end of the day, if the cost of removing these vessels falls to the federal government, there's a considerable cost to pay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128418","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for that response. I want to pick up on one piece of what you just said. I feel that, in many communities where this isn't as relevant an issue, there isn't an appreciation of the costs and the quite specific technical expertise that could be required to remove these boats from our shores and communities once they've been abandoned. Certainly, in Victoria, I have people quite frequently ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f92da67ccff5b46fcc4fc48ff4912b2b617b53369783776dc280b7facdfdcd8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9bc1619076c1710abbe591df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128419,"date":"2026-06-16T20:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. In our last 30 seconds or so, let me ask you this: The bill would make it an offence to transfer a vessel if the owner is \"reckless as to whether\" the buyer has \"the ability, resources or intent to maintain\" it. Can you speak to what message you feel your bill sends to boat owners in Canada who view selling their boat for a dollar to anybody who comes along as an appropriate disposal strategy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128419","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. In our last 30 seconds or so, let me ask you this: The bill would make it an offence to transfer a vessel if the owner is \"reckless as to whether\" the buyer has \"the ability, resources or intent to maintain\" it. Can you speak to what message you feel your bill sends to boat owners in Canada who view selling their boat for a dollar to anybody who comes along as an appropriate disposal st","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","label":"Hazardous materials transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b17a9ed1a48f8c67cda5bef16bd635627c9dfca716ab7009974d81db3905e40"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab2c91c53e76bbcb075d0b9d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128420,"date":"2026-06-16T20:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128420","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecbb82fb2c0af5aad5268735","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1128421,"date":"2026-06-16T22:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Will Greaves","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Good afternoon to all our witnesses. Thank you for being here. I'd like to go back to some of the fundamentals around the issue that we're trying to tackle, broadly speaking, through this legislation, which my colleague from West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country has brought forward with this private member's bill. In a situation in which there is a boat that's been abandoned, a vessel that's derelict or dangerous, there is at the root, I would suggest, a lack of accountability. Who's to be held responsible for an object that poses some kind of risk to the public or is otherwise a blight in our communities? In most instances, where a vessel has been abandoned, the simple reality is that it's difficult to identify an owner, so the boat becomes the problem of the nearest marina, community, first nation or neighbourhood. For instance, in my community in Victoria, we're very lucky to have groups such as the Cadboro Bay Dead Boats Society, which is a group of volunteers who make it their work to identify vessels that have been abandoned or have washed up on our beaches, to try to get the relevant municipal and federal agencies involved. In some cases they take it upon themselves to do the cleanup directly. In this instance, the accountability or responsibility for the vessel is being taken on by people who are not actually responsible for its presence in the first place. In that context, speaking of the obligation and responsibility to clean up the boats, can you maybe speak to it? I would direct this to the officials from Transport Canada: Could you speak to how Bill C-244 could help to enforce or strengthen the legal accountability for vessel owners to clean up their own vessels before they fall into a state of severe disrepair that can then threaten our environment and human health?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1128421","member_id":"bc-mp-123665","member_name":"Will Greaves","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Good afternoon to all our witnesses. Thank you for being here. I'd like to go back to some of the fundamentals around the issue that we're trying to tackle, broadly speaking, through this legislation, which my colleague from West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country has brought forward with this private member's bill. In a situation in which there is a boat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["879ec18f5daedf904d77d9738a5429fe1825dd7fb612a689f3263c9d2b4b9886"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5618c2210cd4de1806bda726f2fabae7af228b1c54427cd98230a5c98a668fd9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2587a76fd1f506824e316106","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76212,"date":"2026-01-27T22:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that Bill C-226, An Act to establish a national framework to improve food price transparency, be read the second time and referred to a committee.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, I proudly rise today for the second reading of my private member's bill, Bill C-226, an act to establish a national framework to improve food price transparency. The bill responds directly to what Canadians in every region of the country have been telling us, that grocery prices are too expensive and the pricing is too confusing.\n\nCanadians are doing everything they can to stretch their budgets. Families deserve clearer and more consistent information when making everyday purchasing decisions. Our government should ensure that the prices people see on the shelves are fair and transparent. Bill C-226 would call upon the collective efforts of federal, provincial and territorial governments. In response to this crisis, the Minister of Industry would consult with provincial and territorial counterparts responsible for consumers' affairs.\n\nThe bill recognizes that improving food price transparency is not the responsibility of a single entity. It requires partnership. This is the exact kind of collaboration that Canadians deserve on issues that affect their daily lives. This is what Canadians voted for.\n\nAs set out in subclause 3(2) of the bill, the framework must include measures to establish a national standard for unit pricing, ensuring accuracy, usability and accessibility across the country. It would also mandate greater transparency around price increases, adjustments and fluctuations. This would help consumers to better understand changes to the cost of essential foods over time. Furthermore, it would promote public education, so that Canadians are informed on unit pricing and how they can better compare products to determine value.\n\nThe foundation of Bill C-226 is the promotion of fairness. The bill would strengthen transparency and build consumers' confidence during a crisis that unreasonably impacts families, students, newcomers and seniors on fixed incomes.\n\nThe practice of unit pricing remains voluntary, and it is applied inconsistently from one province or territory to the next, affecting all Canadians. When meeting with my constituents, I regularly hear from families, seniors, newcomers and young people who face this reality. Rising grocery costs require more deliberate planning and careful budgeting for each trip to the grocery store. When unit pricing is applied inconsistently, consumers face increased pressure to compare products quickly and ineffectively. As Canadians struggle to make ends meet, this uncertainty places increased pressure on limited household budgets.\n\nQuebec is currently the only province where unit pricing is mandated by law, and Quebeckers benefit from clear, universal unit price transparency everywhere in that province.\n\nMeanwhile, in other jurisdictions, Canadians face the inconsistencies of a system reliant on retailers' discretion. This is a system that works for some but leaves many without the benefit of a blanket approach that looks after all Canadians.\n\nThe inconvenience of this disparity is fundamentally unfair. Canadians, regardless of where they live, deserve the same level of clarity when purchasing essential goods. The House can make this a reality by taking this crucial first step.\n\nI have spoken with many stakeholders, including my constituents, post-secondary institutions and organizations that support individuals and communities struggling with unaffordable grocery pricing.\n\nMembers of the Consumers Council of Canada have emphasized that a national unit pricing framework would provide consumers with accurate, uniform and accessible labelling for every product. Clear, standardized unit pricing would ensure that Canadians are not left to calculate costs based on inconsistent store practices to determine the true value of their groceries.\n\nI have also heard directly from post-secondary students of all backgrounds who are facing significant hardship. The student rights and responsibilities office at Kwantlen Polytechnic University shared that many students are making dramatic sacrifices to their living standards to afford basic groceries. This includes sharing one- or two-bedroom suites with many roommates and cutting necessary expenses, such as heating or medication, to ensure that they can eat. Young Canadians deserve the opportunity to buy affordable, nutritious and culturally appropriate meals in the face of food insecurity. Basic needs should never be compromised.\n\nWhile Bill C-226 is not a complete solution, it is a meaningful and practical step toward ensuring that Canadians have the tools they need to navigate an increasingly unaffordable grocery landscape. By ensuring universal unit price transparency, we empower consumers, promote fairness and ease the burden of the overarching issue of overpriced groceries.\n\nPassing this bill would be a concrete step toward addressing food insecurity and unaffordability. Unit price transparency would provide Canadians with the clarity to shop based on products that provide the best value. It would help families maximize their grocery dollars, support those on fixed income, and ensure newcomers and low-income Canadians are not disadvantaged by inconsistent or complex price displays.\n\nThe bill's transparency requirement would address price increases and fluctuation by fostering greater accountability and giving Canadians the opportunity to make informed decisions. Unit price transparency will not solve food insecurity on its own, but it is a practical first step that would ease a key component of affordability for all Canadians. As Canadians struggle to make ends meet, the bill offers fairness and transparency to all Canadians so they can make more informed decisions.\n\nOur country deserves a grocery system that is fair, transparent and works for all its people. Bill C-226 would deliver on this by providing Canadians with the tools they need to make informed choices.\n\nI urge all members of the House to vote for this bill and help Canadians take back control of the grocery stores.\n\nBill C-226. Second reading","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76212","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"moved that Bill C-226, An Act to establish a national framework to improve food price transparency, be read the second time and referred to a committee.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, I proudly rise today for the second reading of my private member's bill, Bill C-226, an act to establish a national framework to improve food price transparency. The bill responds directly to what Canadians in every region o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["de9a5bb480bb25b8accf927344e51a9e448ead0d643fdc31cb21c84f4de65487"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a5b695256f0bd0cbc7b358ff51aad4c305879c33f5e46f4bb22bc132515fa55b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c8a1adb40fbac46b3dec179","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76213,"date":"2026-01-27T22:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the taxes the member is talking about do not exist. There is zero effect from carbon taxes, and there are many studies that have justified that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76213","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the taxes the member is talking about do not exist. There is zero effect from carbon taxes, and there are many studies that have justified that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2921e8f2f295aca3950a0a3eba6318a9a0ecb81f5af971f1a00408fadaab0cc8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1eec7da556c06d97125ee2dd711f48d064e87d4a4a85162184390bb3cdca04d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53318ec7441df4634e4e17e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76214,"date":"2026-01-27T22:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I congratulate the member as a Quebec member because Quebec is currently the only province that has this transparency. I am trying to tell Canadians that, if it can be done in Quebec, it should be done for all Canadians.\n\nI am absolutely open to help fellow Canadians wherever we can so they can live a reasonable life by paying reasonable prices for food products.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76214","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I congratulate the member as a Quebec member because Quebec is currently the only province that has this transparency. I am trying to tell Canadians that, if it can be done in Quebec, it should be done for all Canadians.\n\nI am absolutely open to help fellow Canadians wherever we can so they can live a reasonable life by paying reasonable prices for food products.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3a24c1fd959965fb357cf0006a05f19c71a293454d1ebe0ad14bbf6ef0e33535"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a04cc327e33623af1df0d13","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76215,"date":"2026-01-27T22:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-226 would make it so that every time someone goes to a grocery store, beside the pricing, the label would show what quantity someone is paying for, like grams or kilos. The consumer could then compare different products and stores to make sure they are getting the best price available. Right now, that is not happening anywhere besides Quebec.\n\nDuring the crisis two or three years ago, one of the worst things that happened was that food prices stayed the same but the packages shrunk. Consumers were paying a lot more money for less product. This bill would force retailers to show what the price is per gram or per kilo, and then Canadians could compare prices online with different retailers and with different manufacturers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76215","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-226 would make it so that every time someone goes to a grocery store, beside the pricing, the label would show what quantity someone is paying for, like grams or kilos. The consumer could then compare different products and stores to make sure they are getting the best price available. Right now, that is not happening anywhere besides Quebec.\n\nDuring the crisis two or three yea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0fd819e0d2a22d1a8ce0387b6e62aa9947237c3d54449e0d605ded15f17dbbbb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b5c43bc107dfc542d335462dc10c63b9f5beb82492a7ca7f33f01a919a048cba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0448a0047a2a96e04d79c2c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76216,"date":"2026-01-28T19:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, communities across Canada want to feel safe in their neighbourhoods and confident their government is taking action to prevent crime, especially given the rise in extortion in B.C.'s Lower Mainland.\n\nCan the minister update the House on measures the government is taking to counter extortion, support law enforcement and ensure our communities feel safe?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76216","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, communities across Canada want to feel safe in their neighbourhoods and confident their government is taking action to prevent crime, especially given the rise in extortion in B.C.'s Lower Mainland.\n\nCan the minister update the House on measures the government is taking to counter extortion, support law enforcement and ensure our communities feel safe?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad0759a965e536cfd0f487108a28b7354a4638b18136a4ebacc4d2c464014593"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["877e0082da4ac18a70d8380ffabf51fa1a92aa59cae6e1e540d554b9d01fc56c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39eb8a591b663823b9a64145","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77095,"date":"2026-02-04T19:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to draw attention to a serious issue in Fleetwood—Port Kells. With the number of extortion cases on the rise, I met with constituents who shared their concerns about extortion and intimidation in Surrey. No one should live in fear for their safety or their livelihood. These acts undermine trust, threaten community well-being and place strain on those who are trying to build a better life.\n\n I want my constituents to know that their voices have been heard. Addressing extortion requires strong co-operation between government and community leaders. I will continue working to support community safety and ensure that those responsible are held accountable.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77095","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to draw attention to a serious issue in Fleetwood—Port Kells. With the number of extortion cases on the rise, I met with constituents who shared their concerns about extortion and intimidation in Surrey. No one should live in fear for their safety or their livelihood. These acts undermine trust, threaten community well-being and place strain on those who are trying to build a b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bbd0a0bfcad28fcc5b314cc2c629367320b6c7f151d3566dc9c4270a7ba8d439"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f9f9b6a580ba48d928f5167fd93b14c161d861bb21e1226e0688b2e04acdc635"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a3c9b6f1358e174b54dc191","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86170,"date":"2026-02-12T19:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are all heartbroken by the horrific attack at Tumbler Ridge Secondary School.\n\nNo parent should ever have to experience the loss of a child. I want to join members of the House in sharing my grief for the nine lives lost in Tumbler Ridge on Tuesday, and to pray for the quick recovery of the injured survivors. I also want to thank the first responders for their professionalism, which doubtlessly saved many lives.\n\n As the people of Tumbler Ridge feel the weight of their heavy loss, I want them to know that the House and this nation stand with them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86170","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are all heartbroken by the horrific attack at Tumbler Ridge Secondary School.\n\nNo parent should ever have to experience the loss of a child. I want to join members of the House in sharing my grief for the nine lives lost in Tumbler Ridge on Tuesday, and to pray for the quick recovery of the injured survivors. I also want to thank the first responders for their professionalism, whic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75262aec92d5beea5b6d01ec7c427dec1082fc1ede050cc448a0dac93cde34fe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6875c653d80b33e4f36cd0f81738c134ff6336986df7900222ee61e0289f193"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cd0ebde0c7e7bee26d85d8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331786,"date":"2026-03-11T19:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as we celebrate International Women's Day this week, we take time to recognize the many contributions that women make in our communities, workplaces and families. Across Canada, women are leaders, caregivers, business owners, teachers and volunteers who help build a stronger and more compassionate country.\n\n Let us be reminded to continue working toward equality and opportunity for all women and girls across Canada and around the world. When women have access to opportunity and stability, entire communities thrive. Let us continue working toward a more equal and prosperous future for all.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331786","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as we celebrate International Women's Day this week, we take time to recognize the many contributions that women make in our communities, workplaces and families. Across Canada, women are leaders, caregivers, business owners, teachers and volunteers who help build a stronger and more compassionate country.\n\n Let us be reminded to continue working toward equality and opportunity for al","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","label":"Gender equality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","label":"Gender equality","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3a8d04adab6df8861e6e1634b2a999b611a8ce820ac645f437382655a4e087e3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b27b491e7fecb5b6f6eb9d97c2fd03f060a1de62f00d2e3099bd9b41408d2a0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b6e173af3b016003147c832","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372348,"date":"2026-03-24T19:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, across Canada, people from many cultures and backgrounds come together to contribute to a shared society. The safety, opportunity and sense of belonging found here are what have led many people to choose Canada as their home.\n\nThis week, as we mark the International Day for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, we reflect on the importance of protecting these values. Respect, social cohesion and a strong spirit of living together are what allow our communities to grow and flourish. By encouraging these principles, we ensure that Canada remains a place where diversity is welcome and where everyone has the opportunity to succeed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372348","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, across Canada, people from many cultures and backgrounds come together to contribute to a shared society. The safety, opportunity and sense of belonging found here are what have led many people to choose Canada as their home.\n\nThis week, as we mark the International Day for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, we reflect on the importance of protecting these values. Respect, soci","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab7b6d2b9a22d622a149e96454442a17250d104291ca1d553206e8b95119ae02"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47987feaa55fe4cd4b26ed6a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101107,"date":"2026-04-16T21:25:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you for coming. Is the cooling-off period the same for the premier of the province versus a parliamentary secretary after they have completed their jobs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101107","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for coming. Is the cooling-off period the same for the premier of the province versus a parliamentary secretary after they have completed their jobs?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cefa97ea6c48b2cae0512567ea3a48b346c069588c80e5b43ba2f650515438f1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d26d4080b037844e2565f97620c136bc993d9de80506af8960ee871161472c5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80a2197db5c9d881d5aa2e9b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101108,"date":"2026-04-16T21:25:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"The other thing you discussed was people hired as lobbyists having to declare what remuneration they will get. Could you elaborate on that one?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101108","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The other thing you discussed was people hired as lobbyists having to declare what remuneration they will get. Could you elaborate on that one?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0068be25143d58477237d963dd37341c0e4920cb72d9d8b8f2f4c7517534ea00"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-94266b661b64ec956148b43a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101109,"date":"2026-04-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"This question is for Elsa. The Canadian Lobbying Act is seen as being one of the best in the world, but since we are considering a statutory review of the legislation, what key elements or best practices would you recommend we consider?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101109","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This question is for Elsa. The Canadian Lobbying Act is seen as being one of the best in the world, but since we are considering a statutory review of the legislation, what key elements or best practices would you recommend we consider?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9330e4edb843751aed4ef0c128634d2cc38b4b686cd57ddd536f61e5d20e9f62"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2493d65eb7e227076f577b98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101110,"date":"2026-04-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"In your 2020 report, you recommended additional compliance measures that could be available to the Commissioner of Lobbying in Quebec. Do other countries, such as the United Kingdom, France, Australia or New Zealand, have similar tools? If so, what types of measures do they use?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101110","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In your 2020 report, you recommended additional compliance measures that could be available to the Commissioner of Lobbying in Quebec. Do other countries, such as the United Kingdom, France, Australia or New Zealand, have similar tools? If so, what types of measures do they use?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9361372851a1f998d5a874d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101111,"date":"2026-04-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"British Columbia is considered to have some of the best legislation in the world. Can you compare that to Canadian legislation, both at the federal level and in Quebec?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101111","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"British Columbia is considered to have some of the best legislation in the world. Can you compare that to Canadian legislation, both at the federal level and in Quebec?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dbba0105b0dfd12ae999a82341ac6d3159a286d4dffe4251d6dabfa12090bd6f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f0ddcf6f01dad97dd9e0c8ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101112,"date":"2026-04-17T15:30:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Cooper. Is it common when there's an ethics screen that it has to be announced publicly? Mr. Cooper keeps bringing up that this is a mandatory thing. I think as long as the Ethics Commissioner is aware of it and a member presides by that ruling, that's the most relevant thing. The other thing I am having difficulty with, similar to Mr. Sari, is when we keep saying that the minister got caught. There is no such information that was public to say that the minister was caught. The minister voluntarily went to the Ethics Commissioner, stated the facts and moved on. This discussion is not going anywhere. Mr. Chair, I'm going to move that we adjourn this meeting.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101112","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Cooper. Is it common when there's an ethics screen that it has to be announced publicly? Mr. Cooper keeps bringing up that this is a mandatory thing. I think as long as the Ethics Commissioner is aware of it and a member presides by that ruling, that's the most relevant thing. The other thing I am having difficulty with, similar to Mr. Sari, is when we keep say","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f29a6196f4534704851fc4b3a2b9d34cb3dce920663a82c24342409ef718f2e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7dc7bfe82c63ee4914cd5b362e9754322569620269ce1ba39a90bf699b6bb885"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-370bc756f84757416bd757dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289563,"date":"2026-04-20T16:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise once again in support of Bill C-226, an act to establish a national framework to improve food price transparency.\n\n Let me begin by acknowledging that our government has already taken important steps to support Canadians through a challenging period of global inflation and rising food costs, from strengthening competition in the grocery sector to supporting households directly. We recognize that affordability remains one of the most pressing concerns for Canadians today. These are important steps. They show that our government is taking concrete steps to better understand pricing practices and ensure that markets remain fair and competitive.\n\n However, we also recognize that more can and should be done. Bill C-226 builds on these efforts in a constructive and collaborative way. It does not seek to replace existing measures, nor does it place undue burden on provinces, territories or retailers. Instead, it proposes a practical framework that complements current initiatives by focusing on one key principle: transparency. Canadians want to make informed choices, yet too often they are faced with unclear or inconsistent pricing practices. Without standardized unit pricing, such as the cost per gram or per litre, it becomes unnecessarily difficult to compare products and determine their true value.\n\n It is important to note that this bill aims to foster a shared approach to clarity and consistency across the country in partnership with provinces and territories, without infringing on their jurisdictions or authorities. It is also important to emphasize that this legislation is measured and realistic. It does not claim to solve all aspects of food affordability; rather, it represents a thoughtful step forward that empowers consumers without imposing heavy-handed regulations.\n\n At a time when Canadians are carefully managing their household budgets, even small improvements in transparency can make a meaningful difference. When people can easily compare prices, they are better equipped to stretch their dollars and make choices that suit their needs.\n\n This bill is also about trust. Transparency strengthens confidence in the marketplace. It reassures Canadians that the system is fair, that information is accessible and that they are not at a disadvantage when making everyday purchases. This is a balanced proposal. It aligns with the work our government is already doing, and it reflects our commitment to supporting Canadians in a practical, responsible way.\n\n I invite all members of the House to view Bill C-226 in that spirit, as a collaborative, responsible measure that would complement existing efforts and help Canadians navigate the realities of today's economy. Let us continue working together to improve affordability, strengthen transparency and ensure that our grocery system works for all Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289563","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise once again in support of Bill C-226, an act to establish a national framework to improve food price transparency.\n\n Let me begin by acknowledging that our government has already taken important steps to support Canadians through a challenging period of global inflation and rising food costs, from strengthening competition in the grocery sector to supporting househ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab4a7701ece18d63cc2c1864c9bc7c8791d9866b751478005b49dae78ec36b6e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e7dadb70f14a04bef2328727a2207180a0ffa3961bb3846dbada19ec13c76b39"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fbc6607e7c02c926346235a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289564,"date":"2026-04-20T16:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to see a recorded vote.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289564","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to see a recorded vote.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["112f55a0d0c8bb725cc211a11f231397e561615975a6478f326a2d167a213cbc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35a94ade445f4e03eaa419eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289565,"date":"2026-04-20T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to note that my private member's bill, Bill C-226, an act to improve food price transparency, will be voted on in the House on Wednesday.\n\nAt a time when families are facing high grocery costs, Canadians deserve clear information to make informed choices. Too often, unclear pricing makes it difficult to compare products and find the best value. The bill proposes a practical, balanced federal framework focused on transparency while respecting provincial jurisdiction. It does not claim to solve all aspects of food affordability. Rather, it represents a thoughtful step forward.\n\nI urge all members of the House to support my bill, Bill C-226, on Wednesday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289565","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to note that my private member's bill, Bill C-226, an act to improve food price transparency, will be voted on in the House on Wednesday.\n\nAt a time when families are facing high grocery costs, Canadians deserve clear information to make informed choices. Too often, unclear pricing makes it difficult to compare products and find the best value. The bill proposes a practic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54ed2d27d90ef8b4750689e9fe1a084015c8232116bf06b1ff13aef5d69ce4cf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9de751de6eaa19cd4d13276","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101113,"date":"2026-04-23T21:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Mr. Jordan and Mr. Hurley. Mr. Jordan, in your opening statement, you were talking about recommendation number 11, but then due to the shortage of time, you had to let it go. I would like to hear your viewpoint on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101113","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Jordan and Mr. Hurley. Mr. Jordan, in your opening statement, you were talking about recommendation number 11, but then due to the shortage of time, you had to let it go. I would like to hear your viewpoint on that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff1a13cbabee4640e09b6da7d3e8f897d76cf059e4fd688631fd6282cca65ca5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15b1241c911308929edcf226","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101114,"date":"2026-04-23T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"In the commissioner's recommendation number five, they would like to change the registration to a 10-day period, compared to the current two months. Do you have views on that issue? Do you think it's effective?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101114","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the commissioner's recommendation number five, they would like to change the registration to a 10-day period, compared to the current two months. Do you have views on that issue? Do you think it's effective?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d10c151bfe46af80ffc0e4c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101115,"date":"2026-04-23T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Mr. Hurley, the commissioner has recommended clarifying that board members, partners and sole proprietors count as employees of their organizations for registration purposes. Does your association see this as a helpful clarification? Are there other areas of uncertainty that should be cleaned up at the same time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101115","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Hurley, the commissioner has recommended clarifying that board members, partners and sole proprietors count as employees of their organizations for registration purposes. Does your association see this as a helpful clarification? Are there other areas of uncertainty that should be cleaned up at the same time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c728f4960fb11cf17684f22b2430458eecfe87dcd5bdd205c8c6ab763a80fbe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d59d84e371db97e6466bde0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101116,"date":"2026-04-23T22:20:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to the two commissioners. One of the recommendations the federal Commissioner of Lobbying is proposing is immunity from civil and criminal proceedings for herself and for her office. I understand that some of the other federal agencies that are reporting to Parliament already have that. Commissioner Motherwell, could you give us your viewpoint on that, and could you elaborate on how that would affect your office?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101116","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to the two commissioners. One of the recommendations the federal Commissioner of Lobbying is proposing is immunity from civil and criminal proceedings for herself and for her office. I understand that some of the other federal agencies that are reporting to Parliament already have that. Commissioner Motherwell, could you give us your viewpoint on that, and could","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-511567c180dd886426b52553","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101117,"date":"2026-04-23T22:20:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Maybe Commissioner Bélanger could speak to that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101117","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Maybe Commissioner Bélanger could speak to that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c516873fb664e340badbf761","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101118,"date":"2026-04-23T22:20:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Yes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101118","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9bae28745a9223017a5c45fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101119,"date":"2026-04-23T22:20:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you. The next question is for Commissioner Motherwell. How does the referral process to the appropriate authority work under your legislation? Can you provide an example of a referral that was recently made by your office?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101119","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. The next question is for Commissioner Motherwell. How does the referral process to the appropriate authority work under your legislation? Can you provide an example of a referral that was recently made by your office?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69ded69ffb5540fe6b1a36d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101120,"date":"2026-04-23T22:20:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Can you elaborate on the cooling-off period set out in your respective legislation and on whether any exception exists that would reduce or eliminate that period?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101120","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can you elaborate on the cooling-off period set out in your respective legislation and on whether any exception exists that would reduce or eliminate that period?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental emergencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","label":"Environmental emergencies","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","label":"Smoking prevention","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","label":"Moratorium","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50e2c68c63e8b642e5b2e917eab960ffe4a75f3f585ab9f80f4db80d44785a83"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d058365e1560c71e621ffc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101121,"date":"2026-04-23T23:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Mr. Chair, we've been at the ETHI committee for the last 10 months. It seems to me that my friends on the opposite side only have one agenda, and that is a fishing expedition for something we know is not there. The other thing is that our country is going through some very difficult times, and it seems to me that the members on the opposite side just want to make sure that they derail the government agenda of building a strong Canada. In the last eight to 10 months, we have heard constantly that Canadians don't have faith in our government and the Prime Minister . I just wanted to remind everyone that a year ago, we had an election where the people of Canada elected the Prime Minister, which says they have trust and faith in him. They had two choices. One was the Leader of the Opposition , who couldn't hold his own seat. Canadians elected a Prime Minister they believed was the right person at the right time to lead the country in a difficult time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101121","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, we've been at the ETHI committee for the last 10 months. It seems to me that my friends on the opposite side only have one agenda, and that is a fishing expedition for something we know is not there. The other thing is that our country is going through some very difficult times, and it seems to me that the members on the opposite side just want to make sure that they derail the governme","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["014c48cb8f5e3548dcc4df9f6dd670708117930f71fbfdd3740e87f018469e6f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b9df043cd655cf50e4e5f42","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101122,"date":"2026-04-23T23:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"We've heard a lot of testimony from a lot of experts who said that the best system in the world to look after ethics is in Canada. This was not only heard from Canadians. We also heard witnesses from overseas who said that Canadian ethics are the best in the world. However, we still continue ignoring those things. We also heard from Ms. Turnbull, who said that you cannot create ethics laws based on one person. However, it seems to me that my friends opposite have only one person in mind: the Prime Minister of Canada . It's sad that we are working under these circumstances. I want to find out what we are trying to address here. Regarding the proposal Mr. Barrett put out, most of the information is already there, and it's very effectively done. All the systems are in place and functioning as intended. The Ethics Commissioner has confirmed that the Prime Minister 's conflict of interest screen is an effective preventive tool. Its purpose is to stop conflicts before they arise. By all accounts, it is doing what its purpose is. We also heard directly that the Prime Minister, before he became Prime Minister, put everything in a blind trust. Those blind trusts are not something the Prime Minister started. They've been going on for years. Every Prime Minister, whether they were Conservative or Liberal, has used them effectively. Therefore, we already have the required transparency in place. What is being proposed today is further monthly reporting on external and internal records—broad categories of communication—along with detailed travel information. My colleague Ms. Lapointe went through the places the Prime Minister has gone to, and the purposes for that. His travel has been very successful. If you look, we have the best economy, and it is doing what it is supposed to be doing. We have created more jobs than our friends in the United States are telling us. They lost 6,000 jobs, whereas we gained 80,000 jobs in Canada. That is from the work the Prime Minister is doing, and it's working. We also heard from the Ethics Commissioner that the essential safeguards are there. This is to ensure that the Prime Minister is not aware of the screening applied until decisions are finalized and made public. The protection exists to preserve the integrity and independence of that process. There is also a practical side to this. Public servants are already meeting the current reporting requirements. Adding a much more frequent and detailed reporting structure would require a significant amount of time and resources, which quite inevitably means less capacity for other important work that concerns the role of this committee. We have before us important studies and responsibilities, including work related to the Lobbying Act and other reports, that require careful attention. These are issues that have a direct impact on Canadians and their lives, issues on which our efforts can make a meaningful difference. Transparency is essential, and accountability matters. At the same time, it is worth considering whether increasing the volume and frequency of reporting necessarily leads to better oversight, especially when systems have already been validated and reporting is already under way. The question becomes this: How do we ensure that we maintain strong accountability while also being mindful of the effectiveness, proportionality and priorities that matter most to Canadians in these times? I'm going to talk about conflict of interest— A voice: [ Inaudible—Editor ] Gurbux Saini: Actually, I have a point of order, Mr. Chair. If Mr. Davidson has any question, he needs to allow the other people respectful dignity, and I don't see that. Last week, the same thing happened. I would expect that he would let people continue doing what they're doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101122","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We've heard a lot of testimony from a lot of experts who said that the best system in the world to look after ethics is in Canada. This was not only heard from Canadians. We also heard witnesses from overseas who said that Canadian ethics are the best in the world. However, we still continue ignoring those things. We also heard from Ms. Turnbull, who said that you cannot create ethics laws based o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ff5b6981ae6d07361a29d826a34440c14a29491423a290f41d3e2b7d872506a2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5030ec25c22161eaa4ec7dfd14c37e660b3e7b7d6ea26bcefa692e757537dde"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d54c57e903d0bcc667cf4684","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101123,"date":"2026-04-23T23:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Professor Lori Turnbull made a critical distinction between soft and hard approaches to ethics regulation, arguing that the concept of an apparent conflict of interest belongs in a code of conduct, not in legislation. She told the committee: Enforcing that into a law is a different thing. I think the appearance of conflict of interest is problematic. It can cause a trust problem with the public. There's a reason to enumerate that in a code. Enumerating it into a law starts to create problems in terms of back and forth around whether there's really an appearance. How do you get into the legalities of that? If you're going to start fining people in terms of administrative monetary penalties, that's messy to me.... This is legislation, not an aspiration, and the consequences of getting it wrong are severe. Scott Thurlow pointed to the fundamental difficulty of proving the appearance of conflict objectively and warned that including apparent conflicts of interest in the act would \"create more problems than it solves.\" Michael Wernick, with a decade of experience at the highest level in the public service, cautioned against the concept as well, stating he doesn't think we can describe potential issues of perceived conflicts in the future in a way that can be supported, including in principle, and believes extending the act to include apparent conflicts would make it harder to apply. On the general application rule and the recommendation of narrowing the exclusion for a decision of general application, particularly as it applies to prime ministers and the parliamentary secretaries, this recommendation, if implemented, could render senior members of the executive unable to govern. On the blind trust, let's start with the fact that the federal Ethics Commissioner has confirmed that the Prime Minister is in full compliance, with assets in a blind trust, no communication with the trustee and a rigorous conflict of interest screen operating exactly as it should. The two administrators of the screen, who are the most senior civil servants, Michael Sabia and Marc-André Blanchard, are not minor figures. These are two of the most senior and experienced people in Canadian public life. Mr. Blanchard described the system as \"one of the most comprehensive and rigorous\" he has seen in his entire career. Mr. Sabia said it is \"every bit as rigorous as any screen [he has] in the private sector, pretty much ever.\" The commissioner himself confirmed to the committee that the screen is working well, and then there are the provincial commissioners. Ontario's integrity commissioner, Cathryn Motherwell, was unequivocal. She has described the blind trust as an essential tool and told this committee she has not seen evidence, in her experience thus far, that indicate that trusts do not work. We had Quebec's ethics commissioner. She had the same opinion. She has been working in her jurisdiction and suggests that blind trusts do...and noted that additional compliance measures can be added if we need them. If that isn't enough, the Federal Court of Appeal, the highest court in this land, has confirmed that the conflict of interest screen is a lawful and reasonable exercise of the commissioner's authority. This is a settled law. Let's be honest about what's happening here. The opposition had before it the federal Ethics Commissioner, two sitting provincial commissioners, the Federal Court of Appeal decision and two of the most respected administrators in the country all pointing to the same thing: The system we have is very rigorous. Our friends on the opposition continue to ignore all of those facts. Professor Lori Turnbull drew a very clear distinction, saying apparent conflicts of interest belong in a code of conduct, not in legislation. Her words were direct: \"Enumerating it into a law starts to create problems in terms of back and forth around whether there's really an appearance.\" Michael Wernick, the former clerk of the Privy Council, cautioned that perceived conflicts cannot be described in legislation \"with a lot of clarity.\" Scott Thurlow warned that this would \"create more problems than it solves.\" Perhaps the most telling story came from Guy Giorno, the former chief of staff to former prime minister Stephen Harper, who supported the idea in principle. He conceded that extending the act to an apparent conflict would make it \"harder to apply\". Then there's the practical reality that Professor Andrew Stark put squarely on the table. An ethics commissioner could find themselves compelled to rule on allegations effected by political opponents on social media in a parliamentary system built on adversarial debate. This is not a hypothetical issue. This is a certainty that my friends continue to push for. We believe this recommendation would put vague and highly subjective legal standards into federal legislation, and the unintended consequences of getting that wrong are serious. Let's be clear about what the general application exemption actually is. It's not a loophole. It's a foundational feature of ethics legislation that exists in virtually every regime across Canada. The federal Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner's own legal counsel confirmed this to the committee directly. Scott Thurlow pulled apart the practical, consequential penalty when he asked, \"if we don't have a general application rule, will parliamentarians ever be able to vote on anything? Where do we draw the line with something in front of Parliament that is important for the country to keep going?\" He went further, pointing to trade agreements like CUSMA, the federal budget and the countless other matters on which a parliamentarian's past experience will enlighten and have bearing. Professor Andrew Stark acknowledged that the Prime Minister , in that way, would simply be unable to govern effectively. Michael Wernick recommended against expanding the concept of private interests in this direction, noting that many policies, including the federal budget, have implications that touch virtually everyone. What the opposition is proposing is so narrow that this rule, specifically for the most senior decision-makers in the country—the Prime Minister and the cabinet—would not strengthen accountability. It would create an unworkable regime at the exact level of the government where effective decision-making matters the most. We, with my friends on the opposite side, talked about tax havens. Let's start with what Canada's leading tax law scholar, Professor Allison Christians, told the committee. The chair of law at McGill University was categorical when she said, \"A tax haven is not a technical term,\" and \"Every country could be accused of being a tax haven\". She doesn't recognize that term and she couldn't use it for us. A lot of Canadian taxes are even lower than those in the U.S., and Canada could be considered a tax haven. Are we telling the world that investing in Canada is wrong because Canada is a tax haven? This is the philosophy my opponents are trying to spread. Scott Thurlow was very blunt when he said, \"I don't like the term 'tax haven'. I think there is a pejorative aspect to it.\" When Andres Knobel of the Tax Justice Network acknowledged that declaring a jurisdiction as a tax haven is often politically driven and inconsistently applied—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101123","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Professor Lori Turnbull made a critical distinction between soft and hard approaches to ethics regulation, arguing that the concept of an apparent conflict of interest belongs in a code of conduct, not in legislation. She told the committee: Enforcing that into a law is a different thing. I think the appearance of conflict of interest is problematic. It can cause a trust problem with the public. T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5f29dfdd5bdea1ddf3d6c6bc1a3dcb84b68b868f52a99dfdacc14af9f0b0424"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ab47f7a38b4ddf1675bedfe8262f5bdb90d0893a14739ee55b9f7d3d7875c1b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa1ceb59c3007ae829d346ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101124,"date":"2026-04-23T23:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Mr. Chair, for the last eight or 10 months, I have heard nothing more from my opponents than talking about tax havens and everything they can justify to muddy the waters and to bring injustice to our honourable Prime Minister . I find it difficult. When other people have opinions, they don't want to listen to those arguments. They have spent the whole last 10 months talking about it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101124","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, for the last eight or 10 months, I have heard nothing more from my opponents than talking about tax havens and everything they can justify to muddy the waters and to bring injustice to our honourable Prime Minister . I find it difficult. When other people have opinions, they don't want to listen to those arguments. They have spent the whole last 10 months talking about it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e109f16cf164896d0f83dd9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101125,"date":"2026-04-23T23:10:00+00:00","title":"ETHI","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"ETHI","text":"Thank you. The Prime Minister is travelling around the world bringing a lot of strength, a lot of business and a lot of jobs to this country. That is evident. World leaders and world economists are telling us that it is proven that his travel, which you guys wanted to restrict—or wanted to know what was going on—is a very beneficial thing to the government. He continues to serve this country, to make sure that Canadians have jobs, to make sure that Canada continues to be a country that we can be proud of and live in, and that we can continue to be part of an exciting nation. With that, my friend, I'm going to bring my comments to a close, but I would like to put my name on the list of speakers as we go.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ETHI/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101125","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. The Prime Minister is travelling around the world bringing a lot of strength, a lot of business and a lot of jobs to this country. That is evident. World leaders and world economists are telling us that it is proven that his travel, which you guys wanted to restrict—or wanted to know what was going on—is a very beneficial thing to the government. He continues to serve this country, to m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f4db3699784ccf251236829e66a448e63951a63cd9d6c2cdf49f98736911fa7a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ae7dbe22708b940d28610aa7504eb5ab20b21862eb97190237fba6e1220b819"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b632d3d3ab0868dcd857ada6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101149,"date":"2026-04-30T21:20:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. Being a British Columbian MP, I want to ask Mr. Pivnick a question about the northwest transmission line, which has been proposed as one of the major projects. It will be going to the area where we have a lot of critical minerals. Could I hear your viewpoint on how, besides creating a lot of jobs, it will help what we're trying to accomplish in this process?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101149","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. Being a British Columbian MP, I want to ask Mr. Pivnick a question about the northwest transmission line, which has been proposed as one of the major projects. It will be going to the area where we have a lot of critical minerals. Could I hear your viewpoint on how, besides creating a lot of jobs, it will help what we're trying to accomplish in thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9c7039db42a8727d11f73be7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101150,"date":"2026-04-30T21:20:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"The Government of Canada has announced one office, the Major Projects Office, to take care of the major infrastructure projects. Do you see that as a major step rather than having the provincial governments and several different groups trying to approve those projects?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101150","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Government of Canada has announced one office, the Major Projects Office, to take care of the major infrastructure projects. Do you see that as a major step rather than having the provincial governments and several different groups trying to approve those projects?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036514","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Office automation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036514","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Office automation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036514","label":"Office automation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3126516903ff1b35b6765ac4830743c3e6f56bacec7df19908da3ded816ed09e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0110f2202a8275c0751d2006","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101151,"date":"2026-04-30T21:20:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"In a recent trip to India, we made some decisions on nuclear energy technology to be sold to India. Do you think that will help the world clean up the coal that has been talked about as one of the difficulties we are facing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101151","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In a recent trip to India, we made some decisions on nuclear energy technology to be sold to India. Do you think that will help the world clean up the coal that has been talked about as one of the difficulties we are facing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","label":"Nuclear technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","label":"Nuclear technology","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","label":"Coal","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f53d7bcefd5335a93209be5e7fe3b6f51e2ff99fe3aa53ff9d313fd1c889362"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee456ae33119928f52e465f4031c129489c8cb8d02ea2eda5fad55533604c3d7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c01671eab8ca4d30a7c6b57d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101152,"date":"2026-04-30T21:20:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"I think that the Canada greener homes affordability program is being implemented by some provinces, but it's not something that is available across Canada. How can the federal government help so that this is made available throughout Canada and so that every province is able to take part in it? Either one of you can answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101152","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I think that the Canada greener homes affordability program is being implemented by some provinces, but it's not something that is available across Canada. How can the federal government help so that this is made available throughout Canada and so that every province is able to take part in it? Either one of you can answer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036438","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nonrenewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036438","label":"Nonrenewable resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18075388613e31b5b1bc5210f3ed76e3fb9d40d619afc44764fac7a616461072"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9dc0bfd3edfc1077f99227bd80b46bc0b8953fb74ed1b1dae6933e4319c08c5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b8db3d7b371da7128ae19ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101153,"date":"2026-05-05T16:35:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"I want to talk to you, Mrs. Payne, about the forestry sector. I know there are problems in that industry, but the provincial government also has a lot to do with it. The federal government can provide some subsidies, but when it comes to the levies that the government charges on harvesting the timber.... Can you elaborate on your viewpoint on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101153","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to talk to you, Mrs. Payne, about the forestry sector. I know there are problems in that industry, but the provincial government also has a lot to do with it. The federal government can provide some subsidies, but when it comes to the levies that the government charges on harvesting the timber.... Can you elaborate on your viewpoint on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a56cb3e40a7166bd382b280c418967fb99592704c92ed9a4321aa15c7c8ecdf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95e66c289eb5031a186217595dcf8cb25d1ac99ea52a03a773fc2747e00251b0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21f704c5b3481364a98ab100","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101154,"date":"2026-05-05T16:35:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Currently, we have 10 provincial governments, three territorial governments and a federal government. Is it not practical that we should have a minister of forests who can look after all of Canadian forestry? This is one of the biggest problems: The three levels of government are not working hand in hand. It's making it very difficult. The second thing I wanted to ask you about is your viewpoint on the tariffs the U.S. has levied. This has been going on for the last 25 or 30 years. We go to court. We win those cases. America lobbies. They're so strong. We get some money back, and they're back into it. Can you give us your viewpoint on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101154","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Currently, we have 10 provincial governments, three territorial governments and a federal government. Is it not practical that we should have a minister of forests who can look after all of Canadian forestry? This is one of the biggest problems: The three levels of government are not working hand in hand. It's making it very difficult. The second thing I wanted to ask you about is your viewpoint o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c47f48b3a204fee77843cce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101126,"date":"2026-05-25T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you to the witnesses. CIBC economists in 2026 say that the price of housing is too high for buyers but too low for the construction industry to make any profit. What can the federal government do to balance this, Mr. Brooks?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101126","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you to the witnesses. CIBC economists in 2026 say that the price of housing is too high for buyers but too low for the construction industry to make any profit. What can the federal government do to balance this, Mr. Brooks?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d41e34a471e8b05cb0b09a348624973fb396b5c9c4cc9fc2f605a7e165249d81"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5abe5d2bf072b71b2a15921","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101127,"date":"2026-05-25T22:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you. Mr. Jones, I live in Surrey, and I hear a lot of people talking about the foreign buyer tax being removed, the stress test being removed, and longer amortization. Can you give your viewpoint on those three issues? What impact would there be if government removed those three barriers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101127","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Jones, I live in Surrey, and I hear a lot of people talking about the foreign buyer tax being removed, the stress test being removed, and longer amortization. Can you give your viewpoint on those three issues? What impact would there be if government removed those three barriers?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a948d79b23244276e5c9df5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101128,"date":"2026-05-25T22:45:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you. Housing starts play a major role in the economy because they create high-paying jobs. They also create a lot of revenue for the government in taxes. What can we do to make sure that the economy stays strong and we still have those factors in play? I'll ask Mr. Baird his opinion on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101128","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Housing starts play a major role in the economy because they create high-paying jobs. They also create a lot of revenue for the government in taxes. What can we do to make sure that the economy stays strong and we still have those factors in play? I'll ask Mr. Baird his opinion on that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5bffc11c7cef6da4bd074edbbb35b3386c94b9ed7b471436e14400af8a6a8e0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3bbb269a493abc9488f8d993b3b8f4d24988f17e4a364f911a5c335a2bc5c51a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e20e1af0178f9869d735a0d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101155,"date":"2026-05-26T16:40:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Mr. Chair, I'm having difficulty with interpretation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101155","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I'm having difficulty with interpretation.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a2abce7af7344de16bac997","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101156,"date":"2026-05-26T16:55:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you, witnesses, for being here. We are talking about doubling the capacity of the grid by 2050. How many jobs is that going to create? Do we have any idea?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101156","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, witnesses, for being here. We are talking about doubling the capacity of the grid by 2050. How many jobs is that going to create? Do we have any idea?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bf757cdc181d069078f421c7866b4d717169efcf817312d0704b2d5f731c99de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f727d4d3766afa3dcc43a11f46f594366525262fe9a9793e012bba456855234e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53e9b9f7826448330692bda0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101157,"date":"2026-05-26T16:55:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"In the recent announcement about the major projects, there's a northwest grid proposed for British Columbia that is going to link British Columbia with the Northwest Territories. Is that the type of development we should be seeing across Canada to help reduce all the barriers we have?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101157","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In the recent announcement about the major projects, there's a northwest grid proposed for British Columbia that is going to link British Columbia with the Northwest Territories. Is that the type of development we should be seeing across Canada to help reduce all the barriers we have?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cff4e35e60652b106c6de9c6c607872c837bfe95d3bda727ae9478dcef89951a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0606a408f26aaf59b37033d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101158,"date":"2026-05-26T16:55:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you. Mr. Christie, in your opening remarks, you said that we are issuing about 170 international permits. Is that only in the U.S., or do we have other countries that are also participating in that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101158","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Christie, in your opening remarks, you said that we are issuing about 170 international permits. Is that only in the U.S., or do we have other countries that are also participating in that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a6a14b7192eb115a2035327194c178867308ba286db819d620f710bc78c9ead7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be01153f1287627e78fde789f53d35023521e91219e517103e0f9eb9f2e1055c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9611b026eea50b3de90fe4b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101159,"date":"2026-05-26T16:55:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you. Mr. Leyburne, can you detail the electricity projects being advanced by the federal government to make Canada more energy secure in both clean and conventional energy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101159","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Leyburne, can you detail the electricity projects being advanced by the federal government to make Canada more energy secure in both clean and conventional energy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98e618c9df2ce5809334b2ad6ee451b2e5f5905edd4938a5913a4b23913012d4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a0b5b6f9731fbd8c7fd8a32","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101160,"date":"2026-05-26T16:55:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101160","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b285b1a33e64b7b4c52d517","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101129,"date":"2026-05-28T13:45:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Good morning, Minister and members of the team. It's great to have you here. Minister, the spring economic update included measures to modernize the disability tax credit. How will these changes make it easier for Canadians with disabilities to access the benefits they are entitled to?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101129","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Good morning, Minister and members of the team. It's great to have you here. Minister, the spring economic update included measures to modernize the disability tax credit. How will these changes make it easier for Canadians with disabilities to access the benefits they are entitled to?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9db72f4b4fbe68e462d0b3f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101130,"date":"2026-05-28T13:45:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Minister, we know that you have been working very hard to find solutions for workers who have been impacted by tariffs. What has your department done to make sure workers are supported in these challenging times?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101130","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Minister, we know that you have been working very hard to find solutions for workers who have been impacted by tariffs. What has your department done to make sure workers are supported in these challenging times?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["422fc901b289b12ddbc10fc73eb361784b19fd73779ec8f8860af597e34bb210"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44f564591eef39db5fb9c307","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101131,"date":"2026-05-28T13:50:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Minister, the government has taken action to strengthen workers' rights, including with anti-scab legislation and support for union training. How do these measures support a fair workplace and strong labour relations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101131","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Minister, the government has taken action to strengthen workers' rights, including with anti-scab legislation and support for union training. How do these measures support a fair workplace and strong labour relations?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["385072f9951e800549b01ff3366b64c201da1813acc784b1ffcbb62bd2ba348c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28a5ac6403929fd142b56a642ca88dae058fa9e84e537bee94893240f79ef58b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-488eeb5b7cb02f89c5fb5cb1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018233,"date":"2026-05-28T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this summer, organizations across Fleetwood—Port Kells are creating valuable opportunities for young people through the Canada summer jobs program. Through this program, we were able to connect and fund 221 youth jobs in my riding, representing a total of 59,320 hours of valuable work experience to prepare for future careers while supporting important community organizations. \n\nThis year, more than 45 organizations in Fleetwood—Port Kells are participating, including non-profits, sports groups, and cultural and religious organizations. I would like to thank all the organizations that applied and that continue to invest in young Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018233","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this summer, organizations across Fleetwood—Port Kells are creating valuable opportunities for young people through the Canada summer jobs program. Through this program, we were able to connect and fund 221 youth jobs in my riding, representing a total of 59,320 hours of valuable work experience to prepare for future careers while supporting important community organizations. \n\nThis y","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75eace066fc736e6c252cac12fe1b4f4426040da6525629d17c859c3f5f0b951"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ede85e72dc3b03c881b1a585da93597b25ac16f8a98cd74e990919cdd697b2a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d02dcc621ebf89d80d0b5f68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101161,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you. Thank you to all the witnesses. My question is for Mr. Brossard. Can you share your views on the one project, one review agreement that the federal government has signed with the provinces? How can such an agreement benefit energy and electricity projects?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101161","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Thank you to all the witnesses. My question is for Mr. Brossard. Can you share your views on the one project, one review agreement that the federal government has signed with the provinces? How can such an agreement benefit energy and electricity projects?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33e0280da6167649620b59ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101162,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Mr. Cheliak, how can developing natural gas infrastructure support the growth of LNG export projects?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101162","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Cheliak, how can developing natural gas infrastructure support the growth of LNG export projects?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d3eab21e01bd37cc0ed0aa7a092150369581251de30d4ebc7191488ae280793"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ae9e9fbac1affd09add3934","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101163,"date":"2026-05-28T21:10:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"My next question is for Travis. How can the Government of Canada support indigenous equity and leadership in energy projects? How can such efforts benefit northern indigenous communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101163","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My next question is for Travis. How can the Government of Canada support indigenous equity and leadership in energy projects? How can such efforts benefit northern indigenous communities?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82a3080678ee38af7587220590666addea5775cf59a4a5f4dfe390ce3ae6803f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f52580e9344d325488caec1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101164,"date":"2026-05-28T21:15:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Mr. Cheliak, I lived in the small community of Williams Lake for a lot of years. If you go 10 or 15 miles outside the community, there are a lot of indigenous communities. I can think of at least 15. There's no natural gas in their homes. Why is that such a complicated issue?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101164","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Cheliak, I lived in the small community of Williams Lake for a lot of years. If you go 10 or 15 miles outside the community, there are a lot of indigenous communities. I can think of at least 15. There's no natural gas in their homes. Why is that such a complicated issue?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b72782cf5ab014e3a4da5e0dfe8fead498fbcb8a4b8a7f208fc84ad90096c94"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d40911052280725a46007674","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101132,"date":"2026-06-01T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to all the witnesses. It's very heartbreaking to hear the stories, especially living in the country that we live in. It's sad that it happens. My question is for you, Mr. Lethby. You said a lot of the people are coming as youth. Is it family breakdown? Is it a cultural issue? What are the issues? What is forcing these kids to be in these situations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101132","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to all the witnesses. It's very heartbreaking to hear the stories, especially living in the country that we live in. It's sad that it happens. My question is for you, Mr. Lethby. You said a lot of the people are coming as youth. Is it family breakdown? Is it a cultural issue? What are the issues? What is forcing these kids to be in these situations?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b9fe5c280571c868c590fa6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101133,"date":"2026-06-01T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you. My next question is for Mr. Donais. Looking at the data, it shows that a high proportion of homeless youths are from LGB communities. In keeping with your experience, what are some of the unique challenges facing this population?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101133","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. My next question is for Mr. Donais. Looking at the data, it shows that a high proportion of homeless youths are from LGB communities. In keeping with your experience, what are some of the unique challenges facing this population?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2275a95050c9cea84c7a3f70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101134,"date":"2026-06-01T21:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Do any of the other panellists have any experience in this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101134","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do any of the other panellists have any experience in this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7911c5484f007cf652fe65651745db189f6fc0793e7f11ba2912006213661c04"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d573f0a0952ec03504357c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101135,"date":"2026-06-01T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you. If the committee were going to make some recommendations, what would be the three things you would want this committee to take to the Government of Canada and say, \"We need to help these people, and this is how we can go forward\"? Go ahead, Mr. Lethby.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101135","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. If the committee were going to make some recommendations, what would be the three things you would want this committee to take to the Government of Canada and say, \"We need to help these people, and this is how we can go forward\"? Go ahead, Mr. Lethby.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52126ed7700b5f680e877e5f86b7af5ae9e97db4bd1f9d16753908459f70bf1d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac39f535cba154ce2a662c8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101136,"date":"2026-06-01T21:40:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101136","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45deb9698c3962fb6619a353","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101165,"date":"2026-06-02T17:40:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. On the question that my colleague, Roman Baber, put about importing electricity from the U.S., I thought we were exporting more through Quebec and Ontario. Could you tell me, on a net basis, if we are importers or exporters of energy from the U.S.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101165","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. On the question that my colleague, Roman Baber, put about importing electricity from the U.S., I thought we were exporting more through Quebec and Ontario. Could you tell me, on a net basis, if we are importers or exporters of energy from the U.S.?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","label":"Imports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","label":"Imports","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4130bcc577728fbb96565949e671a4090c3d780676fbf0147e5ab03afc195127"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["720573a27c96253a82892582007ea22b6ee75781518065f6272bfd79a772bb00"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-981142ea796cb3d0427753e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101166,"date":"2026-06-02T17:40:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Yes, it's for you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101166","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, it's for you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-625d52e523c3b91a3540c6c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101167,"date":"2026-06-02T17:40:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Mr. Calzado, currently, under major projects, there is a transmission line, the northwest transmission line, which is going to link British Columbia and Alberta. Could those types of interties and interprovincial transmission lines strengthen Canada's renewal energy development?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101167","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Calzado, currently, under major projects, there is a transmission line, the northwest transmission line, which is going to link British Columbia and Alberta. Could those types of interties and interprovincial transmission lines strengthen Canada's renewal energy development?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","label":"Railway networks","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1561bd9aa1a9c14b497183c875fe32d051bbee1ed6e7aa39087bd45dbc2f41dc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f1b9670a150cfd557fe571e3559b62c6d8c333160596b44819bd4ef7c75bc4e6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25c283ddb8ab349acbbfe9f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101168,"date":"2026-06-02T17:40:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Do you view the clean technology investment tax credit as helpful for the development of renewable energy? Also, do you support this expansion to high-voltage interprovincial lines?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101168","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you view the clean technology investment tax credit as helpful for the development of renewable energy? Also, do you support this expansion to high-voltage interprovincial lines?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035974","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035974","label":"Interprovincial transport","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7720159b83de1aa676a7bcddf6c684a0330f34e591e384d0226d881e1d45e720"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd5d2856d2f5ee95899393c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101169,"date":"2026-06-02T17:40:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Can you describe the economics of the renewable energy opportunity in Canada and Quebec?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101169","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Can you describe the economics of the renewable energy opportunity in Canada and Quebec?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["728adcf64cff22fd0fc3f0d8649ae6c3e7a79e8fa9056b1a49a33eb8e0a92064"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d8e9b664c150031f3e06ea8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036820,"date":"2026-06-02T19:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize Kaur Collective Foundation, a national organization advancing South Asian women's health equity and collective care.\n\n Founded and led by Jessie Kaur Lehail, Kaur Collective Foundation works at the intersection of women's health, culture and power. It leads health equity research and projects that improve access to culturally safe care for South Asian women. Kaur Collective Foundation also pushes government and institutions to see intimate partner violence, human trafficking and food security labour through a cultural lens.\n\n I ask all members to join me in thanking the Kaur Collective Foundation for its vital work supporting South Asian women.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036820","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize Kaur Collective Foundation, a national organization advancing South Asian women's health equity and collective care.\n\n Founded and led by Jessie Kaur Lehail, Kaur Collective Foundation works at the intersection of women's health, culture and power. It leads health equity research and projects that improve access to culturally safe care for South Asian women. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e23fe8b61cbe7a7ab79680f026e06c2629e58ec76a823382a06f29ac2a269c0e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-704b941b2285313873f6b6d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101137,"date":"2026-06-08T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you to the witnesses. In your opening remarks, you talked about the housing accelerator fund, which was started by the federal government. Later on, a couple of months ago, the federal and provincial governments did a deal in Ontario, trying to accomplish the same thing. What is the difference between those two? Which is the most effective of the two systems?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101137","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you to the witnesses. In your opening remarks, you talked about the housing accelerator fund, which was started by the federal government. Later on, a couple of months ago, the federal and provincial governments did a deal in Ontario, trying to accomplish the same thing. What is the difference between those two? Which is the most effective of the two systems?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69b3eaab81f4670f5bcc1de5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101138,"date":"2026-06-08T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you. In the economic statement that was done a month ago, there was $6 billion put in to train and hire Red Seal workers. What kind of impact do you think that's going to have in the long term? Do you think that's the right program?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101138","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. In the economic statement that was done a month ago, there was $6 billion put in to train and hire Red Seal workers. What kind of impact do you think that's going to have in the long term? Do you think that's the right program?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036862","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail companies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036862","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rail companies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036862","label":"Rail companies","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["07454a01a0f5d99ab1e0c2305bd85f732e08953aae463b356ceda1bbd42a75a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dbab45bb91fc8c02f000ad24c44749fa8b3521ccf9a8cdddd73ae83ea704ca13"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ee9106d96bee380114b12d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101139,"date":"2026-06-08T22:10:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Cost development charges are a big thing. I represent one of the ridings in Vancouver, so I hear that every unit costs $80,000 to $90,000 in development charges. Similar stories are happening in Toronto. Is there a permanent solution, whether it's the federal government or the provincial government? Who should be looking after all of that infrastructure? I see that this has continued to be a bigger and bigger problem over the last 40 or 50 years.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101139","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Cost development charges are a big thing. I represent one of the ridings in Vancouver, so I hear that every unit costs $80,000 to $90,000 in development charges. Similar stories are happening in Toronto. Is there a permanent solution, whether it's the federal government or the provincial government? Who should be looking after all of that infrastructure? I see that this has continued to be a bigge","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e2d6763ec31f838344d9200","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101140,"date":"2026-06-08T22:15:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Okay—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101140","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30e8ceb6124834925717f88e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101141,"date":"2026-06-08T22:15:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Three seconds...? I'm good, thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101141","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Three seconds...? I'm good, thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c575bae3269d4a33239aa4f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084700,"date":"2026-06-10T02:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague opposite talks about the notwithstanding clause. Your government has said publicly that it would use the notwithstanding clause to take away the rights of Canadians, whether it is religious freedom or any others. This is why your party voted in favour of Bill C‐21, which would take rights away from Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084700","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague opposite talks about the notwithstanding clause. Your government has said publicly that it would use the notwithstanding clause to take away the rights of Canadians, whether it is religious freedom or any others. This is why your party voted in favour of Bill C‐21, which would take rights away from Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2342b1187d027c94b23828bba699915e841d62b15f146c12584f596eb6d9fc01"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3368f6f150b03d7ebeb32981","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101142,"date":"2026-06-11T15:15:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you, witnesses, for your time. I want to talk about something different. In listening to both of you, the three things that I see as the biggest problems are the amount of time permitting at the city level takes, the development cost charges, which are compounding at $80,000 or $90,000 per unit, and the financing of these projects. In the mid-1970s, the interest rate was 10%, 12% or 13% for years and years. Why are those issues a problem? Do we need to find a different way of doing development cost charges so municipalities are not burdened with this? I just want to see a solution where housing affordability becomes a reality.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101142","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, witnesses, for your time. I want to talk about something different. In listening to both of you, the three things that I see as the biggest problems are the amount of time permitting at the city level takes, the development cost charges, which are compounding at $80,000 or $90,000 per unit, and the financing of these projects. In the mid-1970s, the interest rate was 10%, 12% or 13% for ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45c6ca17d584b386e1122c2d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101143,"date":"2026-06-11T15:15:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Mr. Irwin, should development cost charges be the responsibility of municipal governments or should the federal and provincial governments be the ones building infrastructure?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101143","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Irwin, should development cost charges be the responsibility of municipal governments or should the federal and provincial governments be the ones building infrastructure?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c35d87e3c5814e903279696e2c598252c2cffd5c11824d8e9947da4ca1520dc9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f48a556e304bcbe94c21f4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101144,"date":"2026-06-11T15:20:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"I represent one of the ridings in British Columbia, and the permitting process in the City of Surrey takes up to a year from the beginning until they're ready. On top of that, you have $80,000 to $90,000 per unit on the development. How can we survive?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101144","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I represent one of the ridings in British Columbia, and the permitting process in the City of Surrey takes up to a year from the beginning until they're ready. On top of that, you have $80,000 to $90,000 per unit on the development. How can we survive?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9fe01054c36386d88bcff8651cdcf3e2a585404f42815756634da03a85862531"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["24fcb21406a739d802f4648dfbd6c24a4b97f1a94ca566abdfdaf0f335a631a6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a05ddec13bb56d8033c738a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101170,"date":"2026-06-11T23:00:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you to both of the witnesses. Madame von der Porten, one thing that I am very glad of is that you're representing 200 first nations communities, with chiefs and hereditary chiefs. It's a very great thing to see that there's collaboration and everybody's working together. Can you explain to the committee the importance of indigenous partnership and leadership for promoting energy security in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101170","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you to both of the witnesses. Madame von der Porten, one thing that I am very glad of is that you're representing 200 first nations communities, with chiefs and hereditary chiefs. It's a very great thing to see that there's collaboration and everybody's working together. Can you explain to the committee the importance of indigenous partnership and leadership for promoting energy security in ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["509e3630309d213f72d7c20908cff0d5a8dc4ddb6558b6d7cde9d7a43bb63483"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b362e0545e52e86377886114","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101171,"date":"2026-06-11T23:05:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"My next question is for Ms. Exner-Pirot. Can you explain the importance of the one project, one review agreement to streamlining project permitting?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101171","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"My next question is for Ms. Exner-Pirot. Can you explain the importance of the one project, one review agreement to streamlining project permitting?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d22974d098448ef81d8e0c3b0eaeb78972e08bb4b9b67ee28d8e3fee67db859a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83e1a806fdb5f6c4b1efa0bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101172,"date":"2026-06-11T23:05:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"The next question is for Dr. von der Porten. Do you support the indigenous loan guarantee program? Is it a helpful tool to promote indigenous equity in major projects?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101172","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The next question is for Dr. von der Porten. Do you support the indigenous loan guarantee program? Is it a helpful tool to promote indigenous equity in major projects?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9857c62fa57d66274dd5ffc4dec423701b2467cef8d088397c0722b58bbb82b8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a98f2c5a6ce3e796106697ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101173,"date":"2026-06-11T23:05:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you. Mr. Chair, how much time do I have?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101173","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Chair, how much time do I have?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4209df72874af63409f2b94","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101174,"date":"2026-06-11T23:05:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Dr. von der Porten, how can LNG development strengthen Canada's energy security and global energy security?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101174","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Dr. von der Porten, how can LNG development strengthen Canada's energy security and global energy security?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb1b1d78b8edb2fd169c9d1863cc590af7f72fbab33eae022e2231e9e3de6408"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-643b86daff90b4cf674803f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101175,"date":"2026-06-16T18:00:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you to the witnesses. I also want to commend Minister Hodgson for allowing this process to take place at a very critical time. Ken, I live in British Columbia. I come from Williams Lake, in the neighbourhood of 100 Mile House. At one time, those communities were 80% dependent on forestry. Now half of that business has gone. The biggest problem was with the U.S. market. We think we have a problem right now, over the last two years, but the forest community has been fighting those problems for the last 30 years. We challenge them and we win in court, but a few years later, the U.S. goes back into it. What can we do? I don't think we can really get away from U.S. markets 100%. The U.S. will continue to be a major part of our economy. Yes, we can build in Canada, but we don't have enough capacity to use the forests that we have in Canada. I'd like to hear from Ken and the other gentleman their views on those issues.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101175","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you to the witnesses. I also want to commend Minister Hodgson for allowing this process to take place at a very critical time. Ken, I live in British Columbia. I come from Williams Lake, in the neighbourhood of 100 Mile House. At one time, those communities were 80% dependent on forestry. Now half of that business has gone. The biggest problem was with the U.S. market. We think we have a pro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b44e9bb8f453decedc7d367c024a959615b3209c100bafc98c749d0a8070a483"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["989e64d1f14b3cbabcb8ea9321a0d7ee2c6c37dae743ade99dd7ef3a5b985c0c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-668cc2105b4586be556f9bcd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101176,"date":"2026-06-16T18:05:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"RNNR","text":"My second question is this. I think, maybe for political reasons, we have ignored the forest industry, because it employs 200,000 people today, plus those who are in other industries that depend on it. We have 9% of the world's forests in Canada, but we don't have a ministry at the federal level that says we need to be managing this forest in such a way. New Brunswick is a prime example. Why can't we have a ministry at the federal level that says, \"We need to follow these regulations. This is what's going to make it competitive, and that's what needs to be done\"? I'd like to hear from you on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101176","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"My second question is this. I think, maybe for political reasons, we have ignored the forest industry, because it employs 200,000 people today, plus those who are in other industries that depend on it. We have 9% of the world's forests in Canada, but we don't have a ministry at the federal level that says we need to be managing this forest in such a way. New Brunswick is a prime example. Why can't","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["96568836010e9757b8864cd7cf0c8c99b07c830e0e5a8292f09f307c1c4179c8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5b01d7d93ed90fec5b6a155368534e52d8e9a1dfad06c08c289e93b21a17663"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e56a7fcd6a1ca3763fdad7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101145,"date":"2026-06-18T14:00:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the witnesses for the great work you do for all Canadians. My question is for Krystyna. We are here to come up with a strategy to improve the system. What part of it is working that we need to maintain and strengthen? What homelessness initiatives are having a positive impact right now, and why do you think they are succeeding?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101145","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all the witnesses for the great work you do for all Canadians. My question is for Krystyna. We are here to come up with a strategy to improve the system. What part of it is working that we need to maintain and strengthen? What homelessness initiatives are having a positive impact right now, and why do you think they are succeeding?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8e535e6b2e6128148a4837b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101146,"date":"2026-06-18T14:05:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Mr. Gladstone, in your statement, you said 3,000 homes are needed by 2031. Are we talking about one specific region of the country, or is this for the entire nation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101146","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Gladstone, in your statement, you said 3,000 homes are needed by 2031. Are we talking about one specific region of the country, or is this for the entire nation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d7a0d4020b370117c92cfd4d6891a83fcbf5d79115ed7e05272641d8bbb6a11"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e150b90334c34f3cf415452","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101147,"date":"2026-06-18T14:05:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you. My next question is for Ms. Savage. We know addiction can play a huge role in individuals becoming homeless and having difficulty accessing things like shelter or transitional housing. Can you share some of your experience in this negative cycle?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101147","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. My next question is for Ms. Savage. We know addiction can play a huge role in individuals becoming homeless and having difficulty accessing things like shelter or transitional housing. Can you share some of your experience in this negative cycle?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ef2300c9f3c084d42ffc711","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101148,"date":"2026-06-18T14:05:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Gurbux Saini","venue":"HUMA","text":"We know addiction can play a huge role in an individual becoming homeless and having difficulty accessing things like shelter or transitional housing. Can you share some of your experience in this negative cycle?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101148","member_id":"bc-mp-1422","member_name":"Gurbux Saini","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We know addiction can play a huge role in an individual becoming homeless and having difficulty accessing things like shelter or transitional housing. Can you share some of your experience in this negative cycle?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed37d77d90439dca2d127497f7bab5089799b545552f77f6be18c7595a7b7dd7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42722004fd7b1d0cecbe8a3a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86172,"date":"2026-02-10T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, cardiovascular disease, CVD, remains one of the greatest health challenges facing Canadians today. Currently, one in 12 adults, 2.6 million people, lives with CVD. Nine in 10 Canadians over age 20 have at least one risk factor. More than 750,000 Canadians live with heart failure, and a million live with atrial fibrillation. Nine out of 10 over age 20 are at risk.\n\n CVD is one of the main causes of hospitalization and loss of productivity, costing the health care system over $21 billion a year. Early detection in high-risk populations can prevent and delay disease, reduce the cost of treatment, improve quality of life and save millions of lives.\n\n The Canadian Cardiovascular Society and the University of Ottawa Heart Institute have partnered with our Speaker to offer heart risk assessments in West Block today until 4 p.m. I encourage members to go. The life we save may be our own.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86172","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, cardiovascular disease, CVD, remains one of the greatest health challenges facing Canadians today. Currently, one in 12 adults, 2.6 million people, lives with CVD. Nine in 10 Canadians over age 20 have at least one risk factor. More than 750,000 Canadians live with heart failure, and a million live with atrial fibrillation. Nine out of 10 over age 20 are at risk.\n\n CVD is one of the m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","label":"Cardiovascular diseases"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","label":"Chronic diseases"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","label":"Cardiovascular diseases","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","label":"Chronic diseases","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["278d92db098c6a085516e125167a6f2f478f1ea153a4b5759f3ac48490f70560"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cad7e8556a7316856162ddeed81d1c9c538f32783e86c5dece49b9898590e9a0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1cd4fe9ecde03f46049e8e26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86171,"date":"2026-02-12T19:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to offer comfort to the families who lost their loved ones so tragically, so cruelly and so suddenly in Tumbler Ridge, B.C., but I am at a loss for words. They have all been said. \n\nWhat can I say to ease the pain of a parent who will never again see or hug their child, watch them grow or share with them the ordinary joys and sorrows of daily life? As a mother, my heart breaks for those years lost forever. What can I say to heal the wounds of a community that once lived in trust and may now be guarded? What can I say to the families who keep vigil by the bedside of the injured, hoping and praying, or to the traumatized children for whom school was once a place to play, learn and feel safe? \n\nWords have become trite. Thoughts and prayers are not enough.\n\nWe in the House can honour the lives lost in Tumbler Ridge. We can ensure that this tragedy will never happen again to other families, other children and other communities. We have the tools and the power to make that pledge. We must now find the courage.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86171","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to offer comfort to the families who lost their loved ones so tragically, so cruelly and so suddenly in Tumbler Ridge, B.C., but I am at a loss for words. They have all been said. \n\nWhat can I say to ease the pain of a parent who will never again see or hug their child, watch them grow or share with them the ordinary joys and sorrows of daily life? As a mother, my heart breaks ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dfd20c1f41294141aac65837d8e8f749ecd9f2290a293471d0c15fe3c93270a5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53db00a3ad4118bcefa0d80d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303333,"date":"2026-02-26T19:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as we enter the fifth year of Russia's invasion of sovereign Ukraine, I want to bring attention to the ongoing abduction of Ukrainian children. Over 35,000 Ukrainian children have been abducted since the start of the war, stolen from their families through manipulation, coercion and violence, and relocated to Russia for ideological re-education, military training and abuse. Only 2,000 have been repatriated.\n\nThe United Nations demands their immediate and unconditional return. This forcible abduction of children to de-Ukrainize them is a grave violation of international law. The Geneva Convention is clear on this issue. No child should have their identity erased. \n\nRussia is now bartering a child for the return of each Russian prisoner of war. This is a disgusting violation of the rights of the child. Canada must continue to lead on this issue. Ukraine's war is our war. Ukraine's children are our children.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303333","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as we enter the fifth year of Russia's invasion of sovereign Ukraine, I want to bring attention to the ongoing abduction of Ukrainian children. Over 35,000 Ukrainian children have been abducted since the start of the war, stolen from their families through manipulation, coercion and violence, and relocated to Russia for ideological re-education, military training and abuse. Only 2,000","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["903d64171f009541e44d06f52a886e2851cca9bc73f50f013b68f8a1fad41225"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04c2d8da4725516f20fd7c27a94aae09edf225c5518782bad409d1d6d11b5240"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dca497cfad6df8268bcd1908","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372349,"date":"2026-03-25T21:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have the honour to present, in both official languages, the third report of the Standing Committee on Health.\n\nThe report concerns Bill C-234, an act respecting the establishment and award of a living donor recognition medal. The committee studied the bill and has decided to report the bill back to the House with amendments.\n\nI also have the honour to present in both official languages the fourth report of the Standing Committee on Health entitled \"Supplementary Estimates (C), 2025-26: Vote 5c under Canadian Institutes of Health Research, Vote 10c under Department of Health, Votes 1c and 10c under Public Health Agency of Canada\".","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372349","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have the honour to present, in both official languages, the third report of the Standing Committee on Health.\n\nThe report concerns Bill C-234, an act respecting the establishment and award of a living donor recognition medal. The committee studied the bill and has decided to report the bill back to the House with amendments.\n\nI also have the honour to present in both official langua","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dfd9312019a801c18bc0311b4eb84024a86d6d5f02de7f75746eba0ffa2cb7c9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a37825bd1ff30b4997d5d27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101181,"date":"2026-04-15T22:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"HESA","text":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 27 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. We recognize that we meet on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe peoples. Today's meeting is taking place in a personal format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Before we continue, I will remind you about all the instructions with regard to your phones, earpieces, interpretation, etc. Don't speak until the chair recognizes you, etc., and put up your hand if you want to speak. This meeting is requested pursuant to Standing Order 106(4) to discuss the March 12, 2026, production of document motion. So we are meeting to respond to Standing Order 106(4). Before proceeding, I want to quickly inform members that on March 10, the clerk circulated a budget of $7,250 for the meeting with the Canadian Centre on Substance Use and Addiction; and a budget of $14,500 for the study of Bill C-224 , an act to amend the Food and Drugs Act. Will the committee adopt those budgets? Some hon. members: Agreed. The Chair: Thank you very much. I now want to open the floor to members to discuss the order of today, which is the Standing Order 106(4) motion requesting documents. Are there any hands up for members to speak to this? Dan.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101181","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 27 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. We recognize that we meet on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe peoples. Today's meeting is taking place in a personal format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Before we continue, I will remind you about all the instructions with regard to your phones, earpieces, interpre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1534df8a150f4e3363ea34b555cf67a826ba66923cad3906e21384c9e0e6e185"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21390ef478ce21173739ce8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101182,"date":"2026-04-16T20:45:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"HESA","text":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 28 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. We recognize that we meet on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe peoples. Today's meeting is taking place, as you can see, in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. I want to do some housekeeping and remind everyone of the following points. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, please click on the microphone icon to activate your mic. Please mute yourself when you're not speaking. Otherwise, we will get ancillary noise. At the bottom of your screen, you can select the appropriate channel for interpretation. It's a little round globe icon. You can pick whatever language you want. All comments should be addressed through the chair. For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand and the clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best we can. We appreciate your patience and understanding in this regard. Pursuant to Standing Order 108(2) and the motion adopted on Tuesday, January 27, the committee shall commence its study on the Canadian Centre on Substance Use and Addiction. I would like to welcome our witnesses. They are Dr. Alexander Caudarella, chief executive officer; Neil Arao, board member, who is here by video conference; Scott Elliott, board member, by video conference; Susan Russell-Csanyi, board member, by video conference; and Dr. Louis Hugo Francescutti, board member, by video conference. We also have one of our committee members, MP Parm Bains, who is here by video conference. This is how it's going to work. I will give every person five minutes to speak. At one minute before your time is up, I'm literally going to give you a shout-out and say \"one minute\" and then \"thirty seconds\", so you can wrap up. If you cannot finish your presentation in that time, you have an opportunity during the question and answer session to elaborate on anything you felt you didn't get to say the first time around. Yes, go ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101182","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 28 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. We recognize that we meet on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe peoples. Today's meeting is taking place, as you can see, in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. I want to do some housekeeping and remind everyone of the following points. Please wait until I r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71284e01dc73451c7222ce789eabddb56462e7f09550bf2bab14966da959f131"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3d0382d66449ddfdbc616fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289566,"date":"2026-04-21T19:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am proud to welcome to the gallery physicians from across Canada, part of the Canadian Medical Association—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289566","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am proud to welcome to the gallery physicians from across Canada, part of the Canadian Medical Association—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0f1a2fcaa79456c6b41dc9e44c399c2f036a53401753161bdb39b7679e3a4c42"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["78b85effa191dca63307d703b7c4cee8f328c071ac670dbf79179856d4ab676c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d0a34e9d318212e194b09cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289567,"date":"2026-04-21T19:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, physicians from across Canada are here today as part of the Canadian Medical Association's Hill day.\n\n My colleagues are here to deliver this message on behalf of their patients: medicare is in trouble, and we must fix it. I spent years as a physician, standing with patients in times of sorrow, joy, pain, birth and death. It was a privilege and an honour. I saw what happens when a system stretched past its limits is held together only by the dedication of those who deliver care. Our doctors know what is needed to build a more efficient, effective and equitable system. \n\nLet us meet with them and listen to them. Let us end the toxic spread of health disinformation that erodes public trust and risks lives. Let us ensure access to care by all Canadians, especially the vulnerable and the stigmatized.\n\n I ask colleagues to salute doctors across the country, who show up each day for their patients against all odds to deliver the care they need when they need it, regardless of where they live or their ability to pay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289567","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, physicians from across Canada are here today as part of the Canadian Medical Association's Hill day.\n\n My colleagues are here to deliver this message on behalf of their patients: medicare is in trouble, and we must fix it. I spent years as a physician, standing with patients in times of sorrow, joy, pain, birth and death. It was a privilege and an honour. I saw what happens when a sys","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fac286e8f80c811ce291902f6a81a2606ee1b1981071d0d95e88874f32d7a4e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["19734d8cc292b89c3b8f621f8ede4bab710b59c08b95b897642013ae70fa4b05"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3067ab6b3beb68bf485d3842","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101183,"date":"2026-04-21T20:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"HESA","text":"Welcome to meeting number 29 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. We recognize that we meet on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. I want to remind participants of the following points: Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, please note that there will be a little globe at the bottom of your screen, and it is for interpretation. You can pick which language you want. Please mute your mic when you're not speaking. This is a reminder that all comments should be made through the chair. For members in the room, of course, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. The clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best we can. We appreciate your patience and understanding. I also want to mention something I heard from the interpreters: Your phones should not be used for any video or audio recording, because it bothers their ears. That is just for those who may think that they want to do so in future. Pursuant to Standing Order 108(2) and the motion adopted on Wednesday, April 15, 2026, the committee will begin its briefing session on PrescribeIT. Before proceeding, I'd like to inform members that yesterday the clerk circulated a proposed budget of $1,500 for the meeting we are having today. It seems that it was the pleasure of the committee to adopt that. Is it? Some hon. members: Agreed. The Chair: We have a three-hour meeting today. We're going to begin with our first hour from 3:30 p.m. to 4:30 p.m., but before we do that, I want to tell the committee that we have a bit of a conundrum. Every time we have a request from the committee to get material, any kind of material whatsoever that's not from a department—it could be from the private sector, individuals or whatever—the committee has to translate it. It's costly to the committee. We are asking for a lot of stuff, and it's going to cost us a lot. I wanted to ask you to think about this when you are making motions to request information. Thank you very much. I will begin with a witness from Telus Health today, who is going to be present virtually. Do you have a question, Mr. Blanchette-Joncas?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101183","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Welcome to meeting number 29 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. We recognize that we meet on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. I want to remind participants of the following points: Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by vide","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae0182d574bcdf242c002653e64cac6fda8072583460088d5b7b60e08136c387"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7744d8f5e6f282e53a26fa83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101184,"date":"2026-04-23T20:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"HESA","text":"I now call the meeting to order. Good morning, everyone. Welcome to meeting number 30 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. We meet on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. Today's meeting is taking place in a non-hybrid format for a change. I want remind participants of the following points. Wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating, please mute your mic so we don't have interference. On the console in front of you, you will see that there is English and French, so you know what to do there. All comments should be addressed through the chair. For members in the room, you know the drill: If you want to speak, put up your hand. The clerk and I will try to figure out whose hand was up first, and we will go ahead with it in that order. Pursuant to Standing Order 108(2) and the motion adopted by the committee on Tuesday, September 23, 2025, the committee will commence its study of Canada's pharmaceutical sovereignty. I want to welcome the witnesses who are here to speak to that. From Diabetes Canada, we have Glenn Thibeault, executive director, government affairs, advocacy and policy. From HealthPRO Canada, we have Christine Donaldson, president and chief executive officer. From VaxSynergy, we have Denis Leclerc, director and full professor at CHU de Québec, Université Laval. Each of you will have five minutes. I will shout out \"a minute\" when you have a minute left, and then \"30 seconds\" to give you a chance to wrap up. If you cannot finish what you've said, you will be able to expand on it during the question and answer session, so do not panic. We will begin with Monsieur Thibeault for five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101184","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I now call the meeting to order. Good morning, everyone. Welcome to meeting number 30 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. We meet on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. Today's meeting is taking place in a non-hybrid format for a change. I want remind participants of the following points. Wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those particip","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c57838dd90c05f2c317d3d7c956bbf6ce4b1aee60b2e5fca7608c79727809a62"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6238435ff3857b7624240dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101177,"date":"2026-05-04T16:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"FOPO","text":"Good morning, everyone. What a terrible way to start as chair. I want to apologize profusely to all of you for being late. My cab was supposed to arrive; it didn't arrive. We called and called and had to get another one. Here I am, but I really do apologize for this. Thank you very much. Thank you for electing me. I hope I will be worthy of filling Mr. Weiler's shoes. I have known him for such a long time. He's an excellent MP, and I know he was an excellent chair because I sat in the last meeting and watched how he chaired. I want to congratulate this committee on being a committee that is respectful and collegial and that wants to get the things done that it wants to get done, which are to make sure that fisheries on both coasts work well and that your reports mean something. Thank you again. I hope I can do justice to this committee. Mr. Arnold.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101177","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Good morning, everyone. What a terrible way to start as chair. I want to apologize profusely to all of you for being late. My cab was supposed to arrive; it didn't arrive. We called and called and had to get another one. Here I am, but I really do apologize for this. Thank you very much. Thank you for electing me. I hope I will be worthy of filling Mr. Weiler's shoes. I have known him for such a l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09805230e99f55caaf00a1d642f8fa483ddf3b3ca7d6393aae8a92e77f5110a8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f06b461206ef4a498b287b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751810,"date":"2026-05-04T20:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, pursuant to Standing Order 34(1), I have the honour to present to the House, in both official languages, the following reports. \n\nThey are the Canadian Delegation to the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe Parliamentary Assembly, 21st Autumn Meeting in Yerevan, Armenia, from November 18 to 20, 2023, and the Canadian Delegation to the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe Parliamentary Assembly, 23rd Autumn Meeting in Istanbul, Turkey, from November 17 to 19, 2025.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751810","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, pursuant to Standing Order 34(1), I have the honour to present to the House, in both official languages, the following reports. \n\nThey are the Canadian Delegation to the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe Parliamentary Assembly, 21st Autumn Meeting in Yerevan, Armenia, from November 18 to 20, 2023, and the Canadian Delegation to the Organization for Security and Co-o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["404fcf63cc24a79a3f7fd3c8808d2f8a31d4f451a522cfe0f367357f9e93d12c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21d1deae6ec56061ba2b5b307e846f59fcb9b3f556a844a224e591fe8658e93b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ff63d323c2fdc1912b7fd68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101178,"date":"2026-05-06T22:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"FOPO","text":"We'll resume the meeting. Mr. Deschênes, you have the floor.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101178","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We'll resume the meeting. Mr. Deschênes, you have the floor.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ca390459ffc0e0814fc980d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101179,"date":"2026-06-03T21:05:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"FOPO","text":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 41 of the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I want to start by acknowledging that we are gathered on the ancestral and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. Pursuant to Standing Order 108 and the motion adopted on Wednesday, April 22, 2026, the committee is meeting to begin its study on the publication of a report on four wind energy areas in the offshore of Nova Scotia. This meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Pursuant to routine motions, I would like to advise committee members that all virtual witnesses today have successfully completed their testing. I would like to remind participants of the following points. Before speaking, please wait until I recognize you by name. For those on video conference, please click on the microphone icon to ensure you are able to get interpretation. Unmute yourself when you are not speaking. At the bottom of your screen, you will see a globe-looking icon. It will tell you the appropriate channel for interpretation: floor, English or French. I want to remind witnesses that committee members will ask you questions in French or English. If you need interpretation, I'd ask you to put on your earpieces right now. All comments should be made through the chair. Members, if you wish to speak in the room, put up your hands. The clerk and I will try to manipulate what we think is the right order of things. I want to remove the word \"manipulate\". I would now like to welcome our witnesses. From the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, we have Bernard Vigneault, director general, ecosystem science directorate; Wendy Williams, regional director, aquatic ecosystems, Maritimes region, by video conference; and Luke Gaulton, director, oceans and aquaculture management, Maritimes region, also by video conference. I will start with the five-minute opening statement by whichever one of you is doing it, please. I will give you a one-minute and then 30-second literal shout-out, so you know your time is up and can adjust your speaking notes accordingly. Mr. Vigneault, if you are speaking, you have five minutes, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101179","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 41 of the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I want to start by acknowledging that we are gathered on the ancestral and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. Pursuant to Standing Order 108 and the motion adopted on Wednesday, April 22, 2026, the committee is meeting to begin its study on the publication of a report on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Audiovisual equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","label":"Audiovisual equipment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61a302b8cfa33ae48eabade7e8726f36271cef64772ced52f78d0548937519b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["114cc7588f5bbdf0837e841842dea2d23ad3bfe58dedc3bf14de9174fbf44699"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c0ba0fac5e9d0615f4ca7cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084701,"date":"2026-06-09T19:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I stand today to champion the Dr. Peter Centre, an organization in my riding that integrates housing, health care, nutrition, therapeutic and cultural programs to serve the underserved and the vulnerable. The centre's integrated model has demonstrated positive and measurable results among its clients for decades. I have personally witnessed its impact: Reduced dependence on emergency departments, improved health status and fewer overdoses equal a decrease in health care costs in the long run. However, most important is the hope that the clients get from this program and the sense of belonging and integration into the community.\n\n The Dr. Peter Centre has begun to extend this program across Canada. The vulnerable and underserved need our help and support to achieve these outcomes: positive health and social and economic well-being. After all, is this not what we all came here to do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084701","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I stand today to champion the Dr. Peter Centre, an organization in my riding that integrates housing, health care, nutrition, therapeutic and cultural programs to serve the underserved and the vulnerable. The centre's integrated model has demonstrated positive and measurable results among its clients for decades. I have personally witnessed its impact: Reduced dependence on emergency ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63c8e07df0d416f5728057008a554cbce5d0d7a7f337cdbbbe0d1ae24a3beeb4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c0ef4e1a6331a750d99837e3b114017378c587b3e4e6dacf83b8b2c07b5da7d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6462b781ddcdb9cb88b5286d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101180,"date":"2026-06-10T22:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Hedy Fry","venue":"FOPO","text":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 43 of the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I would like to begin by acknowledging that we are gathered on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. Pursuant to Standing Order 108, the committee is meeting to begin its study of Atlantic salmon populations. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Pursuant to our routine motions, I want to advise committee members that all witnesses appearing virtually today have successfully conducted the required testing. I want to remind participants of the following housekeeping points: Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those on video conference, if you click on the little microphone at the bottom of your screen, you will be able to listen in the language of your choice. Witnesses, I would like to remind you that committee members may ask questions in either English or French, so please put on your earpieces now so that you can be ready for that. All comments should be addressed through the chair. Members in the room, if you want to speak, put your hand up, and we will recognize you. I want to welcome our witnesses. From Kingsclear First Nation, we have Chief Justice Gruben, Councillor Patrick Polchies and Chad Solomon. From Fédération québécoise pour le saumon atlantique, we have Normand Fiset, president, and Myriam Bergeron, executive director. We also have Paul White, an angler, by video conference. Witnesses, you have five minutes for your group; you don't get five minutes each. The spokesperson for your group can start. We're clocking you. I will literally give you a shout-out when you have one minute left so that you can wrap up. If you don't get to finish your full presentation, you have to wrap up, and then you can expand on it during the question and answer period. We will start with the witnesses' opening statements of five minutes, and we'll start with Chief Gruben.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101180","member_id":"bc-mp-1589","member_name":"Hedy Fry","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 43 of the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans. I would like to begin by acknowledging that we are gathered on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. Pursuant to Standing Order 108, the committee is meeting to begin its study of Atlantic salmon populations. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6943c8bd3dc84ed71ea0d24506f54a2fbb14baf80da8e8d819e851b2be2d5f4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e13aa18b178865eb7a7d8710","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70495,"date":"2026-01-26T17:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I wonder if the hon. member has had conversations with the Minister of Justice.\n\nThere are sections of Bill C-16 that Greens will support, but there are other sections that we would like amended. Does the hon. member have a sense from the government as to whether amendments will be entertained and if we could move swiftly on the parts we all agree on, such as proper sentencing, and move quickly against intimate partner violence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70495","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I wonder if the hon. member has had conversations with the Minister of Justice.\n\nThere are sections of Bill C-16 that Greens will support, but there are other sections that we would like amended. Does the hon. member have a sense from the government as to whether amendments will be entertained and if we could move swiftly on the parts we all agree on, such as proper sentencing, and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f56b42e1de87df6dced8613ea7973c4915e31debb59d856e5ca1e720a3dcd3b2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["05df1ed21d9e98db7b700fe3d9321dd216850de52e905bd9e725a902b4ccc2c4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14b9d6b343425cf0127c28b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70496,"date":"2026-01-26T18:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am very concerned as well. I am glad to see Bill C-16 debated in this place after having been introduced in December. I think we need to move more quickly on legislation. We have not had a very full legislative package since the election. This is one bill I feel very strongly about.\n\nI want to say a name out loud here. She is one of the more recent victims of alleged intimate partner violence. Her former husband is awaiting trial. I want to say the name of Laura Gover, who died not long ago in Saanich. She was a mom. She was much loved in the community and a victim, we believe, of intimate partner violence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70496","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am very concerned as well. I am glad to see Bill C-16 debated in this place after having been introduced in December. I think we need to move more quickly on legislation. We have not had a very full legislative package since the election. This is one bill I feel very strongly about.\n\nI want to say a name out loud here. She is one of the more recent victims of alleged intimate part","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["708a7b5ceac9e1732d6244319f20cec4e8ff258e242c61c24d6f7c763de599d1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["742d8b01729d06fc6cccacff95fd589cc9e2f9a5419d4f1708772d7a4ce9bc73"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7473a2f3d7d39d615cbf8151","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70497,"date":"2026-01-26T20:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a real honour to rise to present this petition, which was originally presented by the former member for Kitchener Centre, Mike Morrice, and brought forward by one of his constituents in the disability community. The disability community, as many members of the House will know because it is an issue that I think is completely non-partisan, wants to see people with disabilities in this country raised out of poverty.\n\nThe petitioners point out that since the COVID pandemic, many services for people with disabilities have been offered online. These are more financially feasible, and certainly more affordable, accessible and flexible, yet the tax code has not caught up with this. They ask the Minister of Finance and National Revenue to revise the existing criteria for tax exemption for support services for people with disabilities such that their support services provided virtually would receive the same tax treatment as such services provided in person. Right now, essentially, people with disabilities in this country face a disadvantage in seeking more available, affordable and accessible services because they are online.\n\nIt is an honour to present this petition, and the petitioners look forward to the government's response.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70497","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a real honour to rise to present this petition, which was originally presented by the former member for Kitchener Centre, Mike Morrice, and brought forward by one of his constituents in the disability community. The disability community, as many members of the House will know because it is an issue that I think is completely non-partisan, wants to see people with disabilities in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a4e4d466ac3889b81c90b3c7d665e0f0d87c0eaec2318bb49528dba8fe3d0ce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1547b9db657dbde5fa5f2b4f171dc1b15767c81534155f858b67590e5a78a99"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45ff86fad4ebf7da85fff97e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70499,"date":"2026-01-26T21:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as we debate Bill C-16 and turn to mandatory minimums, I am concerned. As someone who stood in the House repeatedly to oppose the mandatory minimums brought in during the Harper administration in, at that time, Bill C-10, I remember going through the academic articles and the reviews by experts in criminal law. One of the things they found throughout the United States, where mandatory minimums were used widely, was that it did not deter criminal activity. It actually overcrowded jails. It was not working to deter criminal activity.\n\nDoes the member know if, in doing this, it is in response to a rallying cry that is more partisan-based or whether it is evidence-based?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70499","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as we debate Bill C-16 and turn to mandatory minimums, I am concerned. As someone who stood in the House repeatedly to oppose the mandatory minimums brought in during the Harper administration in, at that time, Bill C-10, I remember going through the academic articles and the reviews by experts in criminal law. One of the things they found throughout the United States, where mandatory","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["601f752f30b3d340ac3c6db535298d1311f4c37f696f1587c02ef7f03bb50bdb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["019d3ea79ff649893d1634d2b8b2b70d4819faadc865efcd311d7312849578f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2411361c0463ccff99ad945","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70500,"date":"2026-01-27T15:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present this petition, which deals with the issue of the threat of nuclear war.\n\nThe petitioners point out that the nuclear arms control architecture has all but disintegrated with the termination of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action with Iran and the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty and Treaty on Open Skies between the United States and Russia, and that the New START Treaty negotiations are, at this point, not inspiring hope for a good conclusion.\n\nThe petitioners further go on to remind us that the House of Commons and the Senate approved a motion unanimously back in 2010 to encourage Canada to engage in negotiations for the Nuclear Weapons Convention and deploy a major worldwide Canadian diplomatic initiative in support of nuclear disarmament.\n\nAs well, petitioners remind us that in 2018, the House of Commons Standing Committee on National Defence made an all-party recommendation that Canada play a leadership role in NATO in encouraging work toward a world free of nuclear weapons.\n\nTherefore, the petitioners ask the Government of Canada to make nuclear disarmament a foreign policy national defence priority and to engage with and accede to the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43115","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70500","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present this petition, which deals with the issue of the threat of nuclear war.\n\nThe petitioners point out that the nuclear arms control architecture has all but disintegrated with the termination of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action with Iran and the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty and Treaty on Open Skies between the United States and Russia, and tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","label":"Arms control"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43115","label":"Nuclear weapons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43115","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43115","label":"Nuclear weapons","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","label":"Arms control","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a789ab6f47579aad6591d3e6ae4b19343604a96c799b238f419bb93dad359eb9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43115","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6f135d2c6bcf8e8fc7b83654261f2bb67ee7e5069cfa6ff89bcf283f81326b0d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43115","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43115","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43115","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3977239f68eb636214288274","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70501,"date":"2026-01-27T15:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is good to see my hon. friend from Lakeland back in this place and well. We were deeply concerned when she was in hospital during the time of the budget debate. I apologize, Madam Speaker, but it had to be said.\n\nI also want to say that she will know we agree on more things than others might imagine. However, on the offshore tanker issue, where U.S. and offshore foreign tankers pass by Canada's waters and British Columbian waters, they pass on the outside, because that is the direct route from Alaska to Washington state. They do not come in through the inside passages that are covered by Bill C-48.\n\nI wonder if we can agree that we should probably stick to the facts of the geography and the waters where tankers move and where they do not.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70501","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is good to see my hon. friend from Lakeland back in this place and well. We were deeply concerned when she was in hospital during the time of the budget debate. I apologize, Madam Speaker, but it had to be said.\n\nI also want to say that she will know we agree on more things than others might imagine. However, on the offshore tanker issue, where U.S. and offshore foreign tankers p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","label":"Waterways"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"International transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","label":"International transport","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","label":"Waterways","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["975782f7344bfbe379bf4e2012a03e50872adcdccffca8fd9fe746c7f45f731a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ccb2522bdd302a4dd542821bb9ed2f670e2fd8ed98c81b6db9c40c13965914ca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c43a90ae90ddaa9aa25c3690","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70502,"date":"2026-01-27T18:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I note that we are debating something today on supply that is titled as something for economic sovereignty.\n\nI am concerned about the growing movement toward separatism within Alberta. I am wondering if the member, as an Alberta MP, has noted whether the leader of the official opposition, as a fellow Alberta MP, has chosen a lane. What can we all do, as members of Parliament who have sworn an oath in this place, to defend our country, to be loyal to Canada and to provide an alternative and an effective way of ensuring that any Alberta vote is not contaminated with foreign interference?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70502","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I note that we are debating something today on supply that is titled as something for economic sovereignty.\n\nI am concerned about the growing movement toward separatism within Alberta. I am wondering if the member, as an Alberta MP, has noted whether the leader of the official opposition, as a fellow Alberta MP, has chosen a lane. What can we all do, as members of Parliament who have ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3bb239a8cb8edb814cd0c9acdfef52c7e58e0bc0d756a1112a7cc4eeb4ac65ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d73cb4e70d4ed2e4de083626","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70503,"date":"2026-01-27T18:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, just to clarify my comments, I was not relying on the Prime Minister's verbal comments. They are still found on page 348 of the federal budget, as they did not use disappearing ink. It actually does say that there will not be investment tax credits available for enhanced oil recovery, and that was contradicted 10 days later in the MOU with Alberta.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70503","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, just to clarify my comments, I was not relying on the Prime Minister's verbal comments. They are still found on page 348 of the federal budget, as they did not use disappearing ink. It actually does say that there will not be investment tax credits available for enhanced oil recovery, and that was contradicted 10 days later in the MOU with Alberta.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c9e6592fc3ac5b038bb80c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70504,"date":"2026-01-27T21:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the history of environmental assessments in this country is one in which we had a predictable, comprehensive environmental review of projects in federal jurisdictions from about the mid-seventies until 2012, when Stephen Harper repealed the Environmental Assessment Act that had been put in place under Brian Mulroney. Since then, we have had a very discretionary projects-based review.\n\nI voted against Bill C-69 because, although the Alberta premier at the time called it the anti-pipeline act, I said it could just as easily be called the pro-pipeline act as it uses such heavy reliance on ministerial discretion as opposed to what we used to have, which was criteria-based and predictable. If federal monies, federal lands or federal permits were to be used, we would do an assessment. I think we still have problems in this area.\n\nI see the member for West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country is prepared to respond.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70504","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the history of environmental assessments in this country is one in which we had a predictable, comprehensive environmental review of projects in federal jurisdictions from about the mid-seventies until 2012, when Stephen Harper repealed the Environmental Assessment Act that had been put in place under Brian Mulroney. Since then, we have had a very discretionary projects-based review","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac129b71adee4cd7ae7c7352833be51912f20e6b58624c8a2e62b95ad5f57b22"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9f2b5282f50126926d03ded","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70505,"date":"2026-01-28T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, with massive cuts being made to our civil service, how can the government justify threats to public health and safety as outlined today by the Public Service Alliance of Canada? Specifically in my community, we are very concerned because across a number of departments, believe it or not, workers involved in marine emergency responses to oil spills have all been laid off.\n\nHow does the government justify this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70505","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, with massive cuts being made to our civil service, how can the government justify threats to public health and safety as outlined today by the Public Service Alliance of Canada? Specifically in my community, we are very concerned because across a number of departments, believe it or not, workers involved in marine emergency responses to oil spills have all been laid off.\n\nHow does the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","label":"Oil spills","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2111c4360347396db5bdeeec16a5867fba5db5ea8e142bf0eca6cdd5c59da8b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7980441e2c6a5bb170d2ebe1d77a12a01d6802d91bb61449a07360d900f26fc0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b958e01bdde2baa6f27758e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70506,"date":"2026-01-28T20:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to present a petition of deep concern to many constituents. As Canadians from coast to coast know, we have a housing crisis.\n\nThe petitioners call on the Government of Canada to expedite and focus on immediate help for people who cannot afford to get a roof over their head, particularly by getting rid of real estate investment trusts and corporate ownership of housing units as investment properties. They also call on the government to focus on more support for co-op housing and other forms of more accessible shared housing arrangements.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70506","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to present a petition of deep concern to many constituents. As Canadians from coast to coast know, we have a housing crisis.\n\nThe petitioners call on the Government of Canada to expedite and focus on immediate help for people who cannot afford to get a roof over their head, particularly by getting rid of real estate investment trusts and corporate ownership of housing u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ddb64a4d2867db42a90850b823db531909d8a62ab07d05c448af31ded4b53ff7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fe13f49f102b24234c45d19bf5b4915abc109b6a7d92c0b5107768415f28fb2e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50dd2f34dca26ef65fb89786","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70507,"date":"2026-01-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to begin, of course, by acknowledging we are on the traditional territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people.\n\nI did have a question for the minister that I was unable to ask, but perhaps I can work it into my speech.\n\nI am sure many of the people watching today's debate in the Canadian House of Commons will be from Indonesia, interested in what Canadian parliamentarians think about their country and this trade agreement. Therefore, I want to start by expressing deep condolences to the people of Indonesia who, just last weekend, experienced an extreme weather event, likely due to climate change. The extreme rainfall event caused landslides. At this point, those landslides in West Java have killed at least 20 people, and there are dozens still missing. We are aware of the difficult time being faced right now by local governments and communities, including naval officials who are still stuck due to the landslides. It is a horrific event.\n\nThat brings me to the question I was going to ask the minister. I think I will start by prefacing my speech with this question. We have before us a bill that would appear to be an opportunity for the House of Commons to either agree and ratify a treaty or not. As a matter of law, this treaty likely was considered by both Canada and Indonesia to have come into force when the Prime Minister and the leadership in Indonesia signed the agreement back in September 2025. I think this is somewhat pro forma, which is troubling.\n\nIn Canada, which a lot of Canadians would not know, each government, each executive, the Prime Minister and cabinet, has a choice. They can choose to bring a treaty to Parliament for a debate and a vote, or it can be passed solely in cabinet by Governor in Council. In this case, the comprehensive economic partnership agreement between Canada and Indonesia was signed before it ever came to Parliament. We are now debating and considering an act to implement the comprehensive economic partnership agreement. It is kind of a hybrid here.\n\nIn the past, we have had many treaties where a prime minister has decided it is so important that we are going to debate it on the floor of the House of Commons and let Parliament vote on it. Let me contrast two with which I am very familiar. One was the time former prime minister Jean Chrétien felt that it was really important for Canada's Parliament, as a whole, to debate and vote on the Kyoto protocol back in 1997, the first of many legally binding climate negotiations that were concluded. Another example was when former prime minister Stephen Harper decided the Canadian Parliament did not need to debate or vote on a very dangerous agreement, which, in the end, was concluded by only a vote in cabinet, by an order in council.\n\nThat relates to what I am going to continue to speak about here today. It was the Canada-China Foreign Investment Protection and Promotion Agreement, or FIPA, which never was debated in Parliament but was only carried through the Governor in Council. It allows for, to this day, secret hearings if the People's Republic of China objects to any change in a regulation or rule by a local government, provincial government or whatever. We can then be sued for whatever amount by the politburo of the People's Republic of China because so many of their enterprises are state-owned. In any case, the FIPA with China never came before Parliament.\n\nEach federal government has the option of concluding any treaty with a foreign power either through cabinet alone or through bringing it to Parliament for a vote. In this case, I am afraid that this is probably already a legally binding treaty with Indonesia before we discussed it here, and this is the implementation act to bring it forward.\n\nIt is very much the case that the Green Party agrees with the goals of the current government, that we need trade diversification. However, we would prefer far more effort to ensure that those agreements we make are with strong democracies that share our values. I can now quote her in this place because she is no longer a member, but former deputy prime minister Chrystia Freeland put it this way: \"Democracies should depend on democracies, not dictators.\" Even in times when we need more trade agreements, more trade diversification and less reliance on the United States, no question, we should look at, excuse the expression, whom we are climbing into bed with on these issues.\n\nI am concerned about the fact that while it is true Indonesia is a democracy, it may be a democracy in name only. According to the Economist Intelligence Unit, it has, for years, marked Indonesia down as a flawed democracy. There are many issues, such as were already raised by my friend and colleague from the Bloc Québécois, around human rights within Indonesia and with the fraying of that relationship within a real democracy where the people really decide what the policies are and really control their government. There are many democracies around the world where people may think that may not be the case. In any case, Indonesia still, on paper, is a democracy.\n\nHowever, when we look at this agreement, and I do want to focus on one specific area and one specific company, we have had a lot of trade with Indonesia already. I question whether it has been to our benefit and whether we should not have reviewed some of these trade arrangements more closely. I speak, of course, of the fact, which is astonishing for most Canadians, that the largest of our pulp and paper enterprises across Canada is a company that is basically controlled in Indonesia. It is called Paper Excellence. It started by buying Northern Pulp in Pictou County, Nova Scotia, and over the years, it then absorbed Domtar, Resolute and Catalyst. It controls a vast amount of Canadian forest, and it runs pulp and paper mills across Canada.\n\nBy this agreement, we would now be giving the same thing I mentioned earlier in the foreign investment promotion and protection agreement, which would mean that the Government of Indonesia can complain and go to arbitration if we change our rules or laws and it affects their investments. This is a very strange situation.\n\nThe Standing Committee on Natural Resources subpoenaed the leadership of Paper Excellence to come before the committee to explain what it was doing with our pulp and paper industry and with our vast area of forest that it now controls. The entire corporation is controlled by one Indonesian billionaire, Mr. Wijaya, who refused to come before the committee and sent some representatives. The company, on paper, is registered in Vancouver, but again, there is no transparency. It is not listed on any stock exchange. It is the sole property of one individual billionaire.\n\nBy this agreement, which I think is already signed and in law, we have now given investment protection and the ability to go to an investor-state dispute resolution to complain if a Canadian province decides that it was a mistake to let an Indonesian multinational buy up Domtar, Resolute, Catalyst or Northern Pulp and now wishes to protect our forests, protect our forest workers and put in place more protections. I did hear the minister's answer that this agreement does maintain that we are going to seek sustainable development, promote the environment and promote fair labour standards, but we are dealing with a country where those things are rather unknown. It is not clear to me how, in passing Bill C-18, we will get to where we want to go.\n\nIn terms of the promised new day and how much this is going to deliver for Canadians, the estimate is that this will increase Canada's GDP by 2040 by 0.012%. Again, we do want to diversify trade, but we do want to be careful.\n\nI look forward to the bill going to committee at second reading, where we can pursue some of these questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pulp and paper industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70507","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to begin, of course, by acknowledging we are on the traditional territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people.\n\nI did have a question for the minister that I was unable to ask, but perhaps I can work it into my speech.\n\nI am sure many of the people watching today's debate in the Canadian House of Commons will be from Indonesia, interested in what Canadian parliamentarians thin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","label":"Pulp and paper industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pulp and paper industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","label":"Pulp and paper industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["11972289a74674aa3f37aa33f32ad226013f22e4cf908dccb5ead10edda8f7b3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pulp and paper industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["74ad8dffaf66ad6f2113563d7bc543ddc2767914c930333e236623496f02c2ad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pulp and paper industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pulp and paper industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c0ab49a661f26aef4e83550","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70510,"date":"2026-01-28T21:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, yes, I am deeply concerned if we jettison human rights in an effort to get trade deals. There is a price we pay. I do think we need strengthened diplomatic relationships with the People's Republic of China, but I do not forget what happened to the two Michaels, and I do not forget where we stand for the Uyghurs, other human rights, the people of Tibet and more.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70510","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, yes, I am deeply concerned if we jettison human rights in an effort to get trade deals. There is a price we pay. I do think we need strengthened diplomatic relationships with the People's Republic of China, but I do not forget what happened to the two Michaels, and I do not forget where we stand for the Uyghurs, other human rights, the people of Tibet and more.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31b80c5418d659406ea35840a50c4b1e0adfcc4ab94dec10c025d6c0ae3d1968"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3742c3d8a6cf361680ce09bc39f4c8eb63bd95e4e21339f73ba0346ca1c3882"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e51aee4cbf08999a5dae8e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70511,"date":"2026-01-28T21:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, we favour trade, particularly fair trade, rooted in Canadian values that prioritizes Canadian-owned businesses and enterprises, and a Canada-first policy that helps get our products first sold across interprovincial barriers and exported to the world. We need to link arms with other democracies that defend human rights.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70511","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, we favour trade, particularly fair trade, rooted in Canadian values that prioritizes Canadian-owned businesses and enterprises, and a Canada-first policy that helps get our products first sold across interprovincial barriers and exported to the world. We need to link arms with other democracies that defend human rights.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e0191ab8856ae9f2825d60dd4585c881921277de34b80003032011939f71c511"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c0e5c3395ec6f7fbe4d7c2d64d61565b0a72ebb45b21b2839d02d99bf0ba6bc3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9da1d2037e8466a3ad882f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70512,"date":"2026-01-28T21:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I completely agree with my esteemed colleague. We are a people who have ignored the child labour situation around the world. The position of Canadian ombudsperson for responsible enterprise, which ensures worker protection and children's rights in global manufacturing and trade, is still vacant today. We need to do more.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70512","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I completely agree with my esteemed colleague. We are a people who have ignored the child labour situation around the world. The position of Canadian ombudsperson for responsible enterprise, which ensures worker protection and children's rights in global manufacturing and trade, is still vacant today. We need to do more.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5cff13faa8d13772af149b1b44ed776729905df6fcaa8089bee713aad1056c29"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-745983086ec3ac1d4ccd52a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70513,"date":"2026-01-28T22:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. friend from Wellington—Halton Hills-North mentioned Bill C-4. It passed this place quickly. I am very concerned about part 4 of Bill C-4, which would change the Elections Act to eliminate any privacy protections for Canadians. I wonder if he has any thoughts on whether we can still stop it in the Senate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70513","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. friend from Wellington—Halton Hills-North mentioned Bill C-4. It passed this place quickly. I am very concerned about part 4 of Bill C-4, which would change the Elections Act to eliminate any privacy protections for Canadians. I wonder if he has any thoughts on whether we can still stop it in the Senate.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d9d758edc7d23e41a172a304ca5319cf7861d26bfd138ac0165523c7947df06b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebbe19d2cb33f075fdebff3520ae0655a004439b0e7681a96d310fd4ae13f0b3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-079ae787bce7410dd4689162","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70514,"date":"2026-01-29T17:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to present a petition on behalf of many residents of Saanich—Gulf Islands and beyond Saanich—Gulf Islands. They are concerned that while the Government of Canada has recognized that we are in a climate crisis, and though Canadians continue to support and call for climate action, Canada is continuing to spend, the petitioners note, at least $4.8 billion a year in subsidies to the fossil fuel industry, including loans and tax credits. They note that the oil and gas industry continues to make record profits, while Canadians continue to struggle with the rising cost of living.\n\nSummarizing the rest of the concerns of the petition, petitioners ask that the Government of Canada end all such subsidies to fossil fuels; invest in clean and renewable energy and infrastructure, including an improved and modernized cross-province electricity grid, while respecting the rights of indigenous peoples through UNDRIP; and impose a windfall tax on excess profits of the oil and gas industry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70514","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to present a petition on behalf of many residents of Saanich—Gulf Islands and beyond Saanich—Gulf Islands. They are concerned that while the Government of Canada has recognized that we are in a climate crisis, and though Canadians continue to support and call for climate action, Canada is continuing to spend, the petitioners note, at least $4.8 billion a year in subsidi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["438d5c40522a31d6c36fd534c32429b7e2b32b0e6370086adc9d205fcb5db42b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["493445ea0d1e3024de4e4a0bfd40483d8f5634506cb54869766e3fc5596d65b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af50b8362c0b3b7ba923f258","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70515,"date":"2026-01-29T17:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, my colleague raised the case, and I raised it earlier in the debate on Bill C-16 because it is so fresh in our minds: Laura Gover was murdered on January 5. It is a very recent case. We operate under the principle of innocent until proven guilty, but her former partner is under arrest and charged with the murder. It certainly appears to be a case of intimate partner violence, in fact a murder, that took the life of Laura Gover, a much-loved mother and educator.\n\nI want to thank the member for Cowichan—Malahat—Langford for raising this case. I part company with him at that point just to ask whether he has looked at the vast literature and research that show that mandatory minimum penalties do not work. They do not deter crime. They do not deter violent crime. There are many places we need to work, and Bill C-16 would deal with some of them in terms of fighting coercive control and doing more in a preventative fashion.\n\nI just ask my friends across the way, including those on the government benches who brought forward the legislation, to look at the evidence before assuming mandatory minimum penalties work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70515","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, my colleague raised the case, and I raised it earlier in the debate on Bill C-16 because it is so fresh in our minds: Laura Gover was murdered on January 5. It is a very recent case. We operate under the principle of innocent until proven guilty, but her former partner is under arrest and charged with the murder. It certainly appears to be a case of intimate partner violence, in fac","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["338a2294a0f04bbdc0b49df7e2f3b284a8fe712bc0addafc450e6ec7f94909ae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc74929812c5ccd2caec954b9c61cc16ec14aa154bfbba0ecade4bd11342b387"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa83d3cb234e1d8049750658","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77128,"date":"2026-02-02T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I do not think I will get a chance to speak to Bill C-16. I was initially concerned that the government had created a weakening and was going back to mandatory minimums.\n\nIf one does research on mandatory minimums, one finds that far from being effective at reducing crime rates, they are completely ineffective. We find that mandatory minimums increase disproportionate treatment within prisons. It is one of the reasons the Truth and Reconciliation Commission recommended we get rid of them. If we look at every report from the Department of Justice or the Parliamentary Centre, they find that mandatory minimums do not work, so I am worried about Bill C-16.\n\nI am going to close here and ask if the hon. member has looked at the research that says mandatory minimums are simply ineffective.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77128","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I do not think I will get a chance to speak to Bill C-16. I was initially concerned that the government had created a weakening and was going back to mandatory minimums.\n\nIf one does research on mandatory minimums, one finds that far from being effective at reducing crime rates, they are completely ineffective. We find that mandatory minimums increase disproportionate treatment within","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad3267866eea71ab656ad9878d3d37d0b26c144bd59bd19aaba2a7356ca28bbc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-198f1c0f2e5a19f851a28a02","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77129,"date":"2026-02-02T18:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I wonder if the government has recalculated the deficit numbers. We are now in favour of Bill C-19 and a GST rebate for consumers, but I am also aware that page 348 of the budget has been reversed and now enhanced oil recovery is eligible for investment tax credits.\n\nGiven the additional ways that we are spending the public purse, or not collecting, what is the new deficit number compared to the $78 billion it was on November 4 of last year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77129","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I wonder if the government has recalculated the deficit numbers. We are now in favour of Bill C-19 and a GST rebate for consumers, but I am also aware that page 348 of the budget has been reversed and now enhanced oil recovery is eligible for investment tax credits.\n\nGiven the additional ways that we are spending the public purse, or not collecting, what is the new deficit number comp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8f0c4a0d4c6f7d35f77a4dc355c1c32da31d619eee8522ee0ab38c6baa2f70e8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5e52f49fd3b631a5c56d3afb64258e4e40dd77bb4b5575b644d66e485cfa002b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03f47df0208f3a9be4039113","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77131,"date":"2026-02-02T20:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, petitioners from Saanich—Gulf Islands and elsewhere are calling on the government and Parliament to take note of the scientific warnings of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report. There are particular warnings related to what happens if we overshoot the 1.5°C global average temperature increase as against what the temperature was before the beginning of the Industrial Revolution.\n\nPetitioners point out that we are currently on track to significantly overshoot our 2030 Paris Agreement target. Not only could this result in health effects that are considered environmental effects, but as the petitioners are physicians, they are also calling on us to take note of the World Health Organization's warning that \"climate change is the greatest threat to global health in the 21st century.\"\n\nThe petitioners therefore call on Parliament to work, across all departments and every portfolio of federal and provincial parties, toward the elimination of emissions and the preservation of a healthy environment. They call for a nationwide carbon pricing scheme and the rapid transition toward green energy and net-zero infrastructure across Canada.\n\nThe petitioners signed themselves as the Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment and physician mothers of Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77131","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, petitioners from Saanich—Gulf Islands and elsewhere are calling on the government and Parliament to take note of the scientific warnings of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report. There are particular warnings related to what happens if we overshoot the 1.5°C global average temperature increase as against what the temperature was before the beginning of the Industrial Re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","label":"Global warming"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","label":"Global warming","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["907d3858bdc49b7c60462e672a75d08d6bc4ed0884daa5f2da917f5484f836b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5a5acc724c0996bfbf07b9e86d70f7e154c6b627e7c5a3b4657169a07a3304fe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54ebdbba6232626e52d1028f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77124,"date":"2026-02-03T16:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is one part of this motion that I could agree with, which is point (b): that we need to boost competition. When we look at why food prices in Canada are higher, it has to do with the big, giant grocery stores having a much larger concentration of ownership in our market. I grew up in Atlantic Canada, where I belonged to a co-op. The co-op grocery stores across Canada continue to have lower food prices than the big giants: the Loblaws, the Sobeys, the Metros, so on and so forth.\n\n I want to ask the hon. parliamentary secretary if we could seize this moment to develop a real analysis of our food systems in order to bring down prices and increase nutritional value? Could we not also look at local food and stopping food waste so that people know how to cook and use food well and economically?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77124","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is one part of this motion that I could agree with, which is point (b): that we need to boost competition. When we look at why food prices in Canada are higher, it has to do with the big, giant grocery stores having a much larger concentration of ownership in our market. I grew up in Atlantic Canada, where I belonged to a co-op. The co-op grocery stores across Canada continue to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d1341463149428df1c5bfbd7eefdcdcbdb75d56c98c25ff45e80fe35d60ccd52"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b440888ac44dc004974f974266adf4f7dd35071ce3972d6bd43201a539e15546"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc0c10d6ebb3fa1cbebe3e23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77125,"date":"2026-02-03T20:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. It is an honour to raise this point of order when the Right Hon. Stephen Harper is in the House.\n\nI remember the level of decorum we had in those days, and I rise only because Standing Orders 14 to 16 were repeatedly violated on all sides of the House today. When Mr. Harper was prime minister, he was never once interrupted by heckling, as I recall. I hope we can go back to that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77125","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. It is an honour to raise this point of order when the Right Hon. Stephen Harper is in the House.\n\nI remember the level of decorum we had in those days, and I rise only because Standing Orders 14 to 16 were repeatedly violated on all sides of the House today. When Mr. Harper was prime minister, he was never once interrupted by heckling, as I recall. I hope w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41d80416b2e5658873be8949e021b2102cb9ea34a352690e6b32d936e64e5ca9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb43a8fe9620664f956ad33f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77126,"date":"2026-02-03T23:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight at Adjournment Proceedings to pursue a question I asked the Minister of Finance back on December 4, 2025, about what was committed in the budget. \n\nAt page 348 in the budget, it very clearly states that a component of carbon capture, utilization and storage, known as \"enhanced oil recovery\", would not qualify for investment tax credits. \n\nFor those who are watching and do not know what \"enhanced oil recovery\" is, it is basically using the fig leaf that we are somehow pulling carbon out of the atmosphere, keeping it stored and avoiding its global warming effect, which is somehow good for the climate. However, what they are really doing is using the pressure and the impact of shooting carbon dioxide under the surface to areas where the industry has not been able to access the oil that is still there. Therefore, enhanced oil recovery is not about carbon capture and storage; it is about increasing oil production. \n\nBack when the budget was being drafted and before it was tabled on November 4, a clear case was made to the government not to add a new fossil fuel subsidy and to make it very clear. It is still there. The government did not use disappearing ink. It still says, at page 348 in the English version of the budget, that enhanced oil recovery is not eligible for investment tax credits.\n\n The reason I asked the question of the Minister of Finance back on December 4, which was ironically exactly a month after the tabling of the budget, was due to the memorandum of understanding that had been executed with the Government of Alberta on November 27, which, amazingly, said exactly the opposite of the commitment made in the budget. I made the point in my question that some might call it a flip-flop, but a flip-flop is a sandal. This is a betrayal, because in the agreement with Danielle Smith of Alberta, the Government of Canada committed to provide exactly the subsidy it said it would not provide on page 348 of the budget. \n\nMy question was a financial question. We already had quite a stunning bottom-line number in this budget for the extent of the deficit, a $78-billion deficit, but when we throw more money at subsidies, what we do is increase our deficit because we add to what the government is spending more than to what it receives.\n\nThe Green Party has a very good record on the subject of deficits and trying to strike balance. Of all the parties in the last federal election, we submitted more proposals to the Parliamentary Budget Officer for review than any other party. We provided, chapter and verse, how the government could bring in more revenue and pay down the deficit faster without austerity, without cuts, without depriving our social safety net of the resources it needs to expand and to provide for the needs of Canadians. \n\nThese studies are still on the Parliamentary Budget Officer's website, should anyone want to check out how much money we would have raised with a financial transaction tax, how much money we would raise with a wealth tax, or how much we could get if we put Canada first and stopped allowing the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board to take Canada pension plan money and invest it in other countries. \n\n I did not get an answer that day. The Minister of the Environment rose, but she did not give me an answer. \n\nTherefore, what is the deficit now that the Liberals have betrayed the promise on enhanced oil recovery?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77126","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight at Adjournment Proceedings to pursue a question I asked the Minister of Finance back on December 4, 2025, about what was committed in the budget. \n\nAt page 348 in the budget, it very clearly states that a component of carbon capture, utilization and storage, known as \"enhanced oil recovery\", would not qualify for investment tax credits. \n\nFor those who are watching and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","label":"Oil spills","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56d7ed0ee643351004fb93c3a4af5f010dd9cb60687983a0b5c10a2d8ef82c87"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a2a3d9d3f8e9519523b9f3cf544cb3b0a82ffcf5f4ad7ebf8f795595decdc2d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d575c8ff8bdd859550ff1dac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77127,"date":"2026-02-03T23:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that was four minutes without an answer. I asked what the deficit is now because the government has increased throwing money at big oil. I did not get an answer.\n\n I was told a number of things that are not true, including that, somehow, the memorandum of understanding with Alberta has something to do with diversifying trade in Canada. With a barrel of West Texas Intermediate selling at less than $60 a barrel, and they cannot make money out of bitumen in northern Alberta unless it is selling for $80 a barrel, there is not a market for bitumen. There is certainly not going to be carbon captured through the Pathways project because the only thing that carbon capture and storage has ever been proven to capture is government money all around the world.\n\n We have to be serious about what we want to be if we are going to be a serious economy and look at a new world order. Step one is to put Canada first. We need to stop taking Canada pension plan money to spend it in other countries, start putting Canada first and put in strategic reserves for our natural resources.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77127","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that was four minutes without an answer. I asked what the deficit is now because the government has increased throwing money at big oil. I did not get an answer.\n\n I was told a number of things that are not true, including that, somehow, the memorandum of understanding with Alberta has something to do with diversifying trade in Canada. With a barrel of West Texas Intermediate selling ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["117a57bd7279b4f4b8f467c2b14d10b94a9b736c5ba6dffa7f081b00d786c5b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5b574cc5630d11833523b5f48c75df5651d6a3b40777447c519805e82982a3ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65cfe4c79269fcf17ee99502","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77119,"date":"2026-02-04T21:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the petitioners wish to draw the attention of the House to findings from international conservation organizations that point out that when we have marine protected areas, and Canada has committed to having 30% protected, there is a positive effect. The petition describes this as a positive spillover effect, where neighbouring fishing areas have larger populations of fish, larger sizes of individual fish and better catches.\n\nPetitioners are calling on the House to look at what Fisheries and Oceans can do to protect our fisheries, grow our fisheries through marine conservation areas and ensure the marine protected areas are expanded.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77119","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the petitioners wish to draw the attention of the House to findings from international conservation organizations that point out that when we have marine protected areas, and Canada has committed to having 30% protected, there is a positive effect. The petition describes this as a positive spillover effect, where neighbouring fishing areas have larger populations of fish, larger sizes","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["239c56cd41ed088f21b20e923ca557030ef95e94548cf294f2f1231a74044153"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7b48662f1b794e72dac31cd95a6bb7fb5e63acef9afc31cc161929b50daf013d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-beed8c26088ebfcf66f6e465","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77118,"date":"2026-02-05T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as International Development Week comes to a close, I know I and many of my colleagues in this place have met with dozens of frontline workers from development organizations who are reeling from a broken promise. During the election, the Liberals promised and the Prime Minister said that we would \"not cut foreign aid\" or development assistance, but the budget showed a cut of $2.7 billion.\n\nWe used to be known in the world. Lester B. Pearson, when he was prime minister, set the global target for development assistance, yet here we are, falling through the cracks and not delivering.\n\nWill the minister commit to reviving the Pearson target?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-80/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77118","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as International Development Week comes to a close, I know I and many of my colleagues in this place have met with dozens of frontline workers from development organizations who are reeling from a broken promise. During the election, the Liberals promised and the Prime Minister said that we would \"not cut foreign aid\" or development assistance, but the budget showed a cut of $2.7 bill","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110795","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"World heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110795","label":"World heritage","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bb6785a23581153d0d8b110651721cabd230ac0f81a25ae3d938d00f9369e2a7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e6ad2707a8dbac7e1fbb147dee3f3bed332bcfaceaf857cdfd5d56e77fa8f48"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c54ba4bfbdcbf851accbbc46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77106,"date":"2026-02-06T17:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is a great honour for me to rise today. It is a very difficult moment for me, but I want to pay tribute to my dear friend, Kirsty Duncan.\n\nI do not think I have ever been in the House when we have had a round of speeches for a former colleague when the flag over the Peace Tower is at half-mast. Maybe we have, but it is an unusual moment. Today is the day that Kirsty's family is having a small ceremony. Her funeral is today, and as she would want, because she was so modest about all her accomplishments, it is a small, family event. However, the flag on the Peace Tower is at half-mast, as it should be. As so many of her friends and family who have posted notices have said, we are shattered, and our hearts are broken, as I think her husband Sven said, \"into a million pieces.\"\n\nWe think about politics and MPs who have served together, and it happened that Kirsty was elected in 2008, and I was elected in 2011. Through the grace of whatever House of Commons angels there are, I was seated right next to her. I was one seat behind her, and she was on the banquette. We were in the far corner next to the translators' booth in Centre Block; over in that corner now, here in West Block, it was me in the back row, Kirsty right in front of me and Justin Trudeau there. We would have lots of conversations.\n\n The thing that is even more remarkable is that Kirsty and I had been friends for 15 years before either of us entered politics. I knew Kirsty initially through her work at Environment Canada. An odd coincidence was that for a brief period of time, my daughter was in child care in the same building where Kirsty worked. I was inspired by the member for Calgary Nose Hill and went back through some old text messages from Kirsty. I should not have done that before trying to talk. Kirsty always referred to my daughter, Cate, as \"your wee bairn.\" She would always say to me, through our lives, \"How is your wee bairn?\" I just looked back through some text messages where I had sent her pictures of my wee bairn with her wee bairn, of my daughter and granddaughter, and Kirsty had responded as one would expect: \"Oh, your beautiful wee bairn.\"\n\n I want to reflect, as many members have. I want to give thanks for the heartfelt speech by the hon. member for Calgary Nose Hill, who already touched on some of the things I was going to say about Kirsty's work and her authorship of the book about the hunt for the 1918 flu virus. An extraordinary degree of intellectual curiosity led Kirsty, alone or almost alone among scientists, to wonder, now that we are experiencing climate change and some corpses in various places are thawing, if we could find a victim of the Spanish flu who had been completely frozen but from whom now, because of global warming, we could perhaps access tissue. We could perhaps find out more about the origins of the Spanish flu. It has been referenced, but it was an extraordinary effort of will to launch a global expedition to Spitsbergen, Norway, to get the help of the Norwegian government, to engage other scientists and to say this could matter. It was really a medical detective story that she led.\n\nShe accomplished so very much. I want to canvass what her family put in the obituary, the number of things they felt she would want to be remembered for and that she was passionate about: dance, music, art, sport, science and research and, of course, politics, as well as humanitarian causes that were also courageously championed by her husband, Sven.\n\nAgain, thanks to the member for Calgary Nose Hill for paying tribute to the extent that Kirsty's work on young women in sport who were victimized and sexually harassed was not swept under the carpet.\n\nAll of that makes for a person about whom someone could not say, even in summary fashion, what they gave the world.\n\n Of course, she had an enormous joy for life, an exuberant embracing of life, and even with health challenges, she never felt sorry for herself. My God, what a hero she was. For the spirit of life, if there was ever someone for whom we could sing this at their funeral, and in my heart I am thinking of this, it would be her: \"I am the Lord of the Dance, said he.\" She had that spirit of dance, and Kirsty had pride, joy and love for her little students. Even as an MP, she kept teaching students in Highland dance, and it meant the world to her.\n\nI am quite incoherent and overwhelmed, but I wrote to a few of her scientist colleagues because I thought it would be good in this place to have the words of scientists who worked with her.\n\nI am first going to share what was said by one of Canada's leading scientists, Dr. Gordon McBean. He wrote:\n\nKirsty Duncan was an outstanding scientist who dealt with health and environmental issues including climate change. I first met Dr. Duncan in the 1990s when she was teaching climate change at University of Windsor and I was the Assistant Deputy Minister of the atmosphere-climate part of Environment Canada. I was very impressed by her scientific knowledge and leadership....\n\n I was so pleased when she was elected in 2008 as she provided—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77106","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is a great honour for me to rise today. It is a very difficult moment for me, but I want to pay tribute to my dear friend, Kirsty Duncan.\n\nI do not think I have ever been in the House when we have had a round of speeches for a former colleague when the flag over the Peace Tower is at half-mast. Maybe we have, but it is an unusual moment. Today is the day that Kirsty's family is h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","label":"Whistleblower protection","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ad48ed89d98a508a5307f591f29d79bea4a52381cf5bed900a1e42c552275ed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["daeb56c02e4027513712dcc8e28a8e0ecc95342b7425d912b9310366b191b192"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8043eb58ee4f06389379486c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77107,"date":"2026-02-06T17:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I seek unanimous consent to finish up my speech as quickly as I can. I am very sorry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77107","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I seek unanimous consent to finish up my speech as quickly as I can. I am very sorry.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fb42a5787199f0535a9a72a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77109,"date":"2026-02-06T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank my colleagues.\n\nI am going to close with words from another one of Kirsty's scientist colleagues, Dr. Ian Burton, who said:\n\nIt has been an honour to work in association with Kirsty Duncan through the University of Toronto and IPCC.... With her work and training in Medical Geography she made outstanding contributions to the award of the Nobel Prize to the IPCC.\n\nHer premature demise is an irreplaceable loss to the ongoing struggle against...ignorance.\n\nI will close with these words in Gaelic. I do not know how to speak Gaelic in the past tense, so I can say it only in the present tense: Kirsty, tha gaol agam ort. I love you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77109","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank my colleagues.\n\nI am going to close with words from another one of Kirsty's scientist colleagues, Dr. Ian Burton, who said:\n\nIt has been an honour to work in association with Kirsty Duncan through the University of Toronto and IPCC.... With her work and training in Medical Geography she made outstanding contributions to the award of the Nobel Prize to the IPCC.\n\nHer prematur","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b77fcb9912a112017a546c125162dc2fba05abdea153b2be52c6b64ef52b8591"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7bddaeaa157d07264a0bce1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77110,"date":"2026-02-06T17:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am presenting a petition on behalf of petitioners, who requested that it be presented today, February 6, in honour of the life and work of Ghaffar Khan, who is a close friend of Mahatma Gandhi and a champion political and spiritual leader known for his non-violent opposition and lifelong pacifism in the search to end colonial rule in India.\n\nThe petitioners summarize by saying that the husband of a Canadian citizen was deported, and they plead with Parliament to ask the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship to reunite Canadian citizen Sophia Papp with her husband, Zain Haq, who was deported for non-violent protest and civil disobedience for defending old-growth forests and for climate activism.\n\nI should mention that this was an e-petition signed by more than 4,000 people who have come to know and love this brilliant young man from Pakistan, who is a Canadian in all but citizenship. He is married to Vancouver resident Sophia Papp, who at this moment, with her entire family, is in Pakistan with her husband.\n\nThe petitioners plead for Parliament and for the minister to take immediate action to reunite Sophia Papp with her husband, Zain Haq, through his admission to Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77110","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am presenting a petition on behalf of petitioners, who requested that it be presented today, February 6, in honour of the life and work of Ghaffar Khan, who is a close friend of Mahatma Gandhi and a champion political and spiritual leader known for his non-violent opposition and lifelong pacifism in the search to end colonial rule in India.\n\nThe petitioners summarize by saying tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","label":"Indigenous youth","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["228c04fc6f31f4892eda210a158007ce425485b97575fd3cdffb0271922dc6e6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e436573e9dc42cbe50129d2f829060982c7170ab80dfab03e9d3a0d9673d8d18"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-955ec895de810dffb775e61e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77111,"date":"2026-02-06T18:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, this is the first time I have had today to rise to speak to the Standing Orders. If I can, before asking a question of the hon. member for Lanark—Frontenac, I want to associate myself with some of the comments made by the member for Calgary Crowfoot.\n\nI strongly agree with his argument that five standing members should be able to ensure a recorded vote and that passing bills on division gives an extreme level of power and authority to a small group of parties in this place, only the recognized parties. It reduces the rights of not just me as the member of Parliament for Saanich—Gulf Islands, but of my constituents, who do not necessarily know where we stand on the issues when we move so quickly. I thought the member for Calgary Crowfoot made very cogent arguments, and I also appreciated his suggestion that we look at the U.K. Parliament and the idea that an MP who is speaking can yield the floor to another MP of their own party.\n\nI want to associate myself very strongly with the comments just now from the member for Lanark—Frontenac and support his concerns. For anyone watching this who does not know the member for Lanark—Frontenac, they will not find a finer person of greater integrity. What he went through with the Tay Valley Township council is appalling, and I want to thank him for always being upright, honest and so well informed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77111","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, this is the first time I have had today to rise to speak to the Standing Orders. If I can, before asking a question of the hon. member for Lanark—Frontenac, I want to associate myself with some of the comments made by the member for Calgary Crowfoot.\n\nI strongly agree with his argument that five standing members should be able to ensure a recorded vote and that passing bills on divi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["86f08e205f698907fce2f392b4616d0b8e24e293e72d685d81c5afcce3f63de4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd6968b9114ecb7125fed04b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77117,"date":"2026-02-06T18:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am passionate about the Standing Orders. We do not get nearly enough time to speak about them. As the Green Party member, I do not have an opportunity to participate in PROC to pursue these essential changes.\n\nI want to make a point to the hon. parliamentary secretary. I think things would work better in this place if we were to actually observe the rules we currently have. For instance, members are not supposed to read written speeches. We could shorten the time on debates if the only members who could speak would be, as in the Parliament in the U.K., able to speak without notes. \n\nI also think we would improve our rules a great deal and have better decorum in the House if party whips were not able to have more power over the Speaker. That is not a rule. The rule is that only the Speaker recognizes individual members of Parliament, but the practice has been, just as the practice has been to allow written speeches, against our rules, which gives party whips more power over decorum than the Speaker.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77117","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am passionate about the Standing Orders. We do not get nearly enough time to speak about them. As the Green Party member, I do not have an opportunity to participate in PROC to pursue these essential changes.\n\nI want to make a point to the hon. parliamentary secretary. I think things would work better in this place if we were to actually observe the rules we currently have. For in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b152fd2278b8a5a000b5e026c4674ef187c374fd367ba3cec3668ee31e6e075b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bbacbe6aebbe7d31699b62ee9fb9c4ad553843a34c5fd4e05ef0d75feee2051b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87313d606a480c8ec0533501","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86187,"date":"2026-02-09T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, members of this place who are in unrecognized parties get a 35-second opportunity once a week. I take members at their word.\n\nI wonder if it would not be appropriate, as we do for each other all the time, to ask for unanimous consent for the member for Nunavut to ask her question again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86187","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, members of this place who are in unrecognized parties get a 35-second opportunity once a week. I take members at their word.\n\nI wonder if it would not be appropriate, as we do for each other all the time, to ask for unanimous consent for the member for Nunavut to ask her question again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["33c8173c70b3411c6aa9eacb77bd3353f052e35ade6a9ed417ab8c3d7e6fc945"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f7addf1679abe5e55a688d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86188,"date":"2026-02-09T20:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today on behalf of constituents in Saanich—Gulf Islands who are concerned with irresponsible practices from industry and large multinational corporations that have led to the destruction and denigration of much of Canada's waterways and wetlands. They are also concerned for the sustainability of our groundwater.\n\nThey are calling on the House of Commons to update Canada's water laws and ensure that no industry or corporation's profit line can take priority over the health of our waterways. They want to ensure that there are specialists and experts guiding the Parliament of Canada to protect our water.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:211985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Groundwater","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86188","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today on behalf of constituents in Saanich—Gulf Islands who are concerned with irresponsible practices from industry and large multinational corporations that have led to the destruction and denigration of much of Canada's waterways and wetlands. They are also concerned for the sustainability of our groundwater.\n\nThey are calling on the House of Commons to upda","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:211985","label":"Groundwater"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:211985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Groundwater","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:211985","label":"Groundwater","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cccf3af09cb3977aa9a78ac3254a06f5206a5b2026f50eef98800f74823faf9e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:211985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Groundwater","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0e212d2de94f2c8b6c8bfbed6a72736d5c3d1be5cf0bcc05a9226d1dec9ec6ae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:211985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Groundwater","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:211985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Groundwater","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:211985","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf46b1170e510cdc35bf9f33","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86189,"date":"2026-02-09T21:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the late show has never come so early.\n\nI am rising tonight to raise an issue that I initially put before the House on December 9, 2025. I am rather proud of the fact that I seem to have been the first member of Parliament to have put this on the public record. Hopefully people noticed, and yes, there is a growing coalition who wants to raise awareness of the issue I first raised here on December 9. It is division 5 within the omnibus budget bill, Bill C-15, which, at over 600 pages, takes a while to read, get through and study.\n\nI want to categorically put it on the record right now that I see no sign that the Conservatives are filibustering Bill C-15, the omnibus budget bill. It takes a while to study a budget implementation act of over 600 pages. I also believe that since the bill was put up for first reading on November 18, there is no sign of delay since the House, by unanimous consent with my objection, adjourned a day early on December 11. We have only been back a little while, and 600 pages plus changing 20 different laws takes some time.\n\nI maintain, as I did on December 9, that the most egregious section of the bill is the one that says that a minister can, on personal discretion, deciding it is in the public interest, exempt the application of any Canadian law, except the Criminal Code, from application within their area of jurisdiction and that they will make this public not immediately, not soon, but according to the act, as soon as it is feasible, with no time limit on that.\n\nSince the time that people have become alarmed about this, there has been testimony before committee. Because, as we just did, we passed Bill C-15 on division at second reading, we did not have a recorded vote, which is why I have not been able to state on the record that I cannot possibly vote for the budget implementation act as currently drafted with the sections found in division 5.\n\nSince then, because it did pass on division at second reading, it has gone to the finance committee and other committees for study. I found it interesting, in going over the witnesses put forward, the ways in which the Liberals are trying to justify this extraordinary power grab by individual ministers to exempt any entity from the operation of any Canadian law except for the Criminal Code.\n\nThe defence of this provision first started with the response by the hon. Parliamentary Secretary to Minister of Finance, who answered and said that because \"Canada has world-class innovators and entrepreneurs,\" we need to build the strongest economy and \"we are reducing red tape\", because division 5 of Bill C-15 is to amend the Red Tape Reduction Act. The hon. parliamentary secretary continued, \"As part of this process, we are reducing red tape to broaden the use of something called regulatory sandboxes to help foster and spur research...and innovation.\"\n\nSince that time, the concept of regulatory sandboxes has been expanded upon by the witnesses from the Treasury Board before the committee. The witnesses put forward that there were \"misconceptions in the public domain\", and they wanted to explain all that because what they said to the committee was that regulatory sandboxes are a \"well-established governmental tool\" to allow the testing of innovative products.\n\nWhere does this well-established governmental tool come from and where is it defined? Even after going back to amend the Red Tape Reduction Act, Bill C-15 does not include any definition of \"regulatory sandbox\"—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86189","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the late show has never come so early.\n\nI am rising tonight to raise an issue that I initially put before the House on December 9, 2025. I am rather proud of the fact that I seem to have been the first member of Parliament to have put this on the public record. Hopefully people noticed, and yes, there is a growing coalition who wants to raise awareness of the issue I first raised here","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["586ac2efcc4bd7eaed1f77764dfeaf68ea194ce6dbb2ddc1cd947c034669f73b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a37e1d04e655bf04dca9e535700e8a85bc212a837f16dc1d2c3efdb32de94eee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73f8eb320ce09237a1d83b97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86190,"date":"2026-02-09T21:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will try to watch the clock carefully, because I cannot possibly take apart even the so-called conditions that are found in proposed paragraphs 12(3)(a) through 12(3)(e) at page 301 of the bill. They are highly discretionary.\n\nThe bill would do no such thing as create guardrails; it may create small children waving by the side of the road. It is not a piece of legislation that is well drafted, nor are any of these terms defined, including \"public interest\" and \"regulatory sandbox\". The minister would be allowed to work within their own discretion. Furthermore, the transparency could be as much as a year after the exemption has been granted saying that a federal law does not have to be obeyed.\n\n I would prefer better drafting. I urge the government to amend Bill C-15. If it means what the government has its Treasury Board Secretariat say in committee, it ought to have drafted it to say so.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86190","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will try to watch the clock carefully, because I cannot possibly take apart even the so-called conditions that are found in proposed paragraphs 12(3)(a) through 12(3)(e) at page 301 of the bill. They are highly discretionary.\n\nThe bill would do no such thing as create guardrails; it may create small children waving by the side of the road. It is not a piece of legislation that is we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9aeedf85f4ccc72b6d5047a4541bd4810b07be0e9bef055d4b5cceac763b8910"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f2a13d15fa2620944acfb97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86184,"date":"2026-02-10T16:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I would like to ask a question of the hon. parliamentary secretary, and she is an honourable member.\n\n I am opposed to Bill C-2, and I understand that she put it forward again in the House today as though there has been some delay on the part of opposition members. I want to ask her if she can explain the quite unusual procedure where Bill C-2, the so-called strong borders act, was put forth in June after more than 300 groups from civil society formed a coalition to stop it, groups from migrant workers' rights organizations to civil liberties unions, the United Church of Canada and so on. Then the government brought in a vastly similar bill, Bill C-12, and now we are asked about Bill C-2, which has not even gone through second reading.\n\n The government controls when bills are put forward for votes. Opposition members do not do so, and I will not vote for Bill C-2 as it currently stands. I am wondering how they can bring forward Bill C-2 since vast portions of it, verbatim, have already been passed in Bill C-12, and it would violate our rules to bring forward the same motions twice in one session.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86184","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I would like to ask a question of the hon. parliamentary secretary, and she is an honourable member.\n\n I am opposed to Bill C-2, and I understand that she put it forward again in the House today as though there has been some delay on the part of opposition members. I want to ask her if she can explain the quite unusual procedure where Bill C-2, the so-called strong borders act, was ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e70921be9b2d870c638657c11a68ccad9f0aa5f00a9c0a02f3c4f94a6b7863b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["12f3105f0336d39f94b69b5d66ea8d6fc5f256255bdd68e05d2cc958a33fda0e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e35451effe58b0bd3b6f28cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86185,"date":"2026-02-10T18:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. friend from Winnipeg North will know that I am pretty fair-minded. If the Conservatives are filibustering, I would love to join him in denouncing that, but I do not see any sign of the Conservatives' filibustering, particularly on Bill C-2, which came forward for first reading on June 5. The Liberals then put it up for debate on June 18, September 16 and September 17, and we have not seen it since, largely because huge portions of it were put into Bill C-12. I do not see any signs of the Conservatives' stopping Bill C-12, since it went through on December 11 by unanimous consent. I asked to be registered as in opposition.\n\nIn fairness, could my hon. colleague point out any episode that I could not find online, in the committee hearings or in the House of filibustering by the Conservatives on Bill C-2?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86185","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. friend from Winnipeg North will know that I am pretty fair-minded. If the Conservatives are filibustering, I would love to join him in denouncing that, but I do not see any sign of the Conservatives' filibustering, particularly on Bill C-2, which came forward for first reading on June 5. The Liberals then put it up for debate on June 18, September 16 and September 17, and we h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e5693db145019ada7a060570dcc4b2dc4b8dc1753847db1789b9447cb544763"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17224f2f2cac7fc15c5bf2a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86186,"date":"2026-02-10T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.\n\nDuring the course of debate today, numerous times, numerous Liberal members made reference to Bill C-2, which was named the strong borders act when it was introduced in June. The trouble, and I will try to be succinct, is that Bill C-2 cannot be put forward for a vote. It is in violation at this moment. It would only be acceptable for it to sit on a shelf covered in dust until the government removes all the sections that have already been carried in C-12 and are identical to those still in Bill C-2. This would encompass, in Bill C-2, parts 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12. This is because the rule in this place, known traditionally as the same question rule, prohibits any government or any member from bringing forward legislation that is substantially the same.\n\nIn this case, we know Bill C-2 came forward in June. I thought, when I saw Bill C-12, that the government would remove Bill C-2 from the Order Paper. I was informed later by the minister responsible that the intention was to reintroduce Bill C-2 with only those sections that related to warrantless access, as the rest of Bill C-2 had been put into Bill C-12.\n\nAs such, I would like to direct the Speaker to House of Commons Procedure and Practice, fourth edition, 2025, in which he will find on this particular issue of concern, the same question, that a bill adopted \"cannot be revived in the same session.\"\n\nMr. Speaker, I would ask you to please consider the matter and direct the government to immediately remove Bill C-2 from the Order Paper until such time as it can reintroduce it with only those sections that have not yet been adopted, the warrantless access sections.\n\n I also draw the Speaker's attention to the fact that the Secretary of State for Combatting Crime called for Bill C-2 to be passed. That violates the same question rule. \n\nEven worse is the part the Speaker will find in Hansard. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons asked for unanimous consent to pass Bill C-2 immediately. Fortunately, I said no. Otherwise, the government would have found itself in error and contravening all our rules. Should the member have happened to achieve unanimous consent, the government would have violated the same question rule.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86186","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.\n\nDuring the course of debate today, numerous times, numerous Liberal members made reference to Bill C-2, which was named the strong borders act when it was introduced in June. The trouble, and I will try to be succinct, is that Bill C-2 cannot be put forward for a vote. It is in violation at this moment. It would only be acceptable for it to sit on a shelf ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1b69d9f2b4cf7f2a4de5dc456da32a20d71554e8c3d25e3acf8a2f0e3e2e2d7b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-052dbec35a44b2c729be0b2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86183,"date":"2026-02-11T19:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the Prime Minister from the bottom of my heart for his thoughtful words. They were truly touching.\n\nI also thank the Leader of the Opposition for sharing thoughts that are very difficult to say out loud.\n\nIt is hard for any one of us as parents to imagine what the community of Tumbler Ridge is going through.\n\nI would also like to thank the leader of the Bloc Québécois for saying something very important, namely that we stand together and are united at this time. I would also like to thank him for mentioning the tragedy that is unfolding today in the Anishinabe nation. Meegwetch.\n\nI would also like to thank the leader of the New Democratic Party, who, like me, is a member of Parliament from British Columbia.\n\nThere are no words. Politicians will try to find words. I will try not to.\n\n I want to send my love to our dear friend, the member of Parliament for Prince George—Peace River—Northern Rockies. This is the kind of thing none of us want to have happen in Canada, but it happened, and in a place like Tumbler Ridge, which is so small. Everyone knows everyone, and I know that the member of Parliament knows everyone. It is a time that our hearts are broken. \n\nWe are not just a nation, we are a proud nation. We are also a family.\n\nWe love each other.\n\nToday, our hearts are broken.\n\nI think of Matthew 5:4, \"Blessed are those who mourn, for they shall be comforted\", but that comfort may feel far, far away right now if you are in Tumbler Ridge. Know wherever you are that we are praying for the injured, for the 12-year-old little girl fighting for her life in hospital. We will be with you this day, yes, and whether we are believers or not, we are all one in the human family and we hold you all close. If there is ever any opportunity for us, as individual members of Parliament, to do anything to alleviate the pain, the suffering and the grief of the people of Tumbler Ridge, we are with you today.\n\nWe always will be.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-84/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-84/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86183","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the Prime Minister from the bottom of my heart for his thoughtful words. They were truly touching.\n\nI also thank the Leader of the Opposition for sharing thoughts that are very difficult to say out loud.\n\nIt is hard for any one of us as parents to imagine what the community of Tumbler Ridge is going through.\n\nI would also like to thank the leader of the Bloc Québécois ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4de9d22cc008a5a568e7028ddb77e6f6b12478fb4037372b06c35159042c3bd3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af077097f5cdaacb6672f561","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86180,"date":"2026-02-12T15:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise to present a petition on behalf of the constituents of Saanich—Gulf Islands. They have raised this concern with me in person as well as in this petition. They call the attention of the House to the ongoing joint ecological, social and economic crises, sometimes referred to as a \"polycrisis\", and they ask that the Government of Canada extend leadership in that area to recognize how many system boundaries are being exceeded. In other words, the ecological ability of the caring capacity of the planet for human activity is being exceeded through massive human consumption, industrial symptoms and, particularly, the climate crisis.\n\nThey call on the government to provide national leadership on environment and sustainability, education, and the importance of leaning on indigenous knowledge and wisdom. They call on the House and ask the government to support educators, communicators and community leaders, who are trying to raise awareness and action for a sustainable future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86180","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise to present a petition on behalf of the constituents of Saanich—Gulf Islands. They have raised this concern with me in person as well as in this petition. They call the attention of the House to the ongoing joint ecological, social and economic crises, sometimes referred to as a \"polycrisis\", and they ask that the Government of Canada extend leadership in that are","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ff061905d1d620f236aade99f8b4488527e6219e3f88a5daa4b022ebff97fdb7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9a134c1ba65d987c800167e24116d291230dc83a6f2247484a7c87a57dd1d8a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-892b3efd3145b5d95b04276a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86181,"date":"2026-02-12T18:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciated my hon. friend from Kingston and the Islands' call for Canada to be in the forefront. \n\nWe are too late to be in the forefront, but like the hon. member for Kingston and the Islands, I drive a plug-in, a hybrid. For those who talk about range anxiety and not having enough charging stations, this is a good step. \n\nA hybrid is not as expensive as a full electric, and I can use the three-prong plug in friends' garages when I park while I am visiting. I rent, and the landlord agreed to let me plug it in there. It has an adapter. It is very versatile. I agree with the hon. member: I do not have servicing problems or battery issues either.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86181","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciated my hon. friend from Kingston and the Islands' call for Canada to be in the forefront. \n\nWe are too late to be in the forefront, but like the hon. member for Kingston and the Islands, I drive a plug-in, a hybrid. For those who talk about range anxiety and not having enough charging stations, this is a good step. \n\nA hybrid is not as expensive as a full electric, and I can","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1ec97c094eb4f06e4b326a66314c24107b90f38c2ab13dc9c523ee5577af937"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca05d3d092dc9c35f883d2fce2d4d7f719b034df7a942437ecfc6ba056840e5d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24bd0408ae4a4e80abaa84e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86182,"date":"2026-02-12T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we know foreign interference is a threat to Canadian democracy. It was confirmed by the Hogue commission, and we have taken steps, at the federal level for federal elections, to deal with the threat of foreign interference.\n\n Is there anything being done and what is being done now to consider the threat of foreign interference to provincial referenda that could break up this country, when we know people in the White House are encouraging separatism? What are we doing to prepare?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86182","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we know foreign interference is a threat to Canadian democracy. It was confirmed by the Hogue commission, and we have taken steps, at the federal level for federal elections, to deal with the threat of foreign interference.\n\n Is there anything being done and what is being done now to consider the threat of foreign interference to provincial referenda that could break up this country, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40bffa413bcf67363e28f635afbd38f036d1e84b5cea70f7b10da7c1715cbde5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce9fade2a51ea88016a5896b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86178,"date":"2026-02-13T15:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"seconded by the member for Nunavut, moved:\n\nMotion No. 2\n\nThat Bill C-14 be amended by deleting Clause 43.\n\nMotion No. 3\n\nThat Bill C-14, in Clause 58, be amended by replacing lines 32 and 33 on page 28 with the following:\n\n\"Criminal Code, as enacted by sections 8, 9, 11, 37 and 40, apply only with respect to an offence\"\n\nMotion No. 4\n\nThat Bill C-14 be amended by deleting Clause 70.\n\nMotion No. 5\n\nThat Bill C-14 be amended by deleting Clause 71.\n\nMotion No. 6\n\nThat Bill C-14 be amended by deleting Clause 72.\n\nMotion No. 7\n\nThat Bill C-14 be amended by deleting Clause 76.\n\nMotion No. 8\n\nThat Bill C-14 be amended by deleting Clause 77.\n\nMotion No. 9\n\nThat Bill C-14, in Clause 78, be amended by replacing line 26 on page 36 with the following:\n\n\"Act, as enacted by sections 60 to 62, 68, 73\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86178","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"seconded by the member for Nunavut, moved:\n\nMotion No. 2\n\nThat Bill C-14 be amended by deleting Clause 43.\n\nMotion No. 3\n\nThat Bill C-14, in Clause 58, be amended by replacing lines 32 and 33 on page 28 with the following:\n\n\"Criminal Code, as enacted by sections 8, 9, 11, 37 and 40, apply only with respect to an offence\"\n\nMotion No. 4\n\nThat Bill C-14 be amended by deleting Clause 70.\n\nMotion No. 5","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["80ab071dc35870591c0f8634b4243c4e17a00ecd7610b8ff70f58e60a97f48da"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9bd84fce4c0d3f8e31406572fecf548b397bfd528847c2b264670ce2cdf17f97"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7707b06080d900d9b3be06e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86179,"date":"2026-02-13T15:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"She said: Mr. Speaker, at the moment, all I would like to say in terms of debate is that I am grateful to have the [Technical difficulty—Editor] submitted, and I look forward to voting on them, but I will be unable to participate in debate at the moment due to circumstances [Technical difficulty—Editor].","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86179","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"She said: Mr. Speaker, at the moment, all I would like to say in terms of debate is that I am grateful to have the [Technical difficulty—Editor] submitted, and I look forward to voting on them, but I will be unable to participate in debate at the moment due to circumstances [Technical difficulty—Editor].","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-394e1b7b69b63935e44eb7dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":314868,"date":"2026-02-23T20:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Greens agree with the application of the results of the last vote to this vote, with Greens voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314868","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Greens agree with the application of the results of the last vote to this vote, with Greens voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["08e5eab6392034da3d095c61d492fe7cfdaeaf82ebdee1c6c8f7b5627cc5e4bb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bd764314829229ddfb2ffd8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303357,"date":"2026-02-24T15:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition today on behalf of residents from within Saanich—Gulf Islands and, increasingly, from across the country, I should add, who are concerned with the state of Canada's waterways and watersheds. \n\nPetitioners recognize that riding alongside the climate crisis comes a water crisis. They call on the Government of Canada and the House of Commons to update Canada's water laws to ensure that no industry or corporation would take precedence over the health of Canada's waterways and watersheds. Of course, our water is essential for human health. They call for Canada's water laws to be updated with the guidance of professionals and specialists in the field of water conservation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303357","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition today on behalf of residents from within Saanich—Gulf Islands and, increasingly, from across the country, I should add, who are concerned with the state of Canada's waterways and watersheds. \n\nPetitioners recognize that riding alongside the climate crisis comes a water crisis. They call on the Government of Canada and the House of Commons to update Canada'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental emergencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","label":"Environmental emergencies","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b382eecdf543789062b343293f18fd203f48b6132c9beafcbb7ad3eecef357c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e398dd9425aef0f1591b3bb6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303358,"date":"2026-02-24T15:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I wonder if my hon. friend from Calgary Nose Hill, as a proud Albertan, has thoughts on the premier's recent proposal around immigration as a referendum for Albertans since it touches on today's question. I am baffled by the fact that she is encouraging more people to move to Alberta, with Alberta complaining the federal Liberals are not doing enough to get immigrants to Alberta. If she has thoughts on this as a proud Canadian and Albertan, I would be grateful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303358","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I wonder if my hon. friend from Calgary Nose Hill, as a proud Albertan, has thoughts on the premier's recent proposal around immigration as a referendum for Albertans since it touches on today's question. I am baffled by the fact that she is encouraging more people to move to Alberta, with Alberta complaining the federal Liberals are not doing enough to get immigrants to Alberta. If","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dbcbf7072888af54f44714039ffdf7e58c0c3cf9a193a15fa8d121729209443a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aee514024d3d2219fc10ae0350166007ff96420ca882cdcae4a606a4299086d0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13cf89d2406940d1f9ab6398","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303359,"date":"2026-02-24T16:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am pleased to hear the parliamentary secretary say he will stand up and call out whenever refugees are made scapegoats.\n\nWhy did he not stand up and call out Bill C-12? Right now, the senators are trying, with sober second thought, to take out the anti-refugee components of that bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303359","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am pleased to hear the parliamentary secretary say he will stand up and call out whenever refugees are made scapegoats.\n\nWhy did he not stand up and call out Bill C-12? Right now, the senators are trying, with sober second thought, to take out the anti-refugee components of that bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-36c069977213faa92e91d15e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303360,"date":"2026-02-24T17:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am grateful for the opportunity to put a question directly to the hon. leader of the official opposition. As an Albertan who, I know, is also a proud Canadian, would he let Canadians know where he will stand if there is a referendum on Alberta separation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303360","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am grateful for the opportunity to put a question directly to the hon. leader of the official opposition. As an Albertan who, I know, is also a proud Canadian, would he let Canadians know where he will stand if there is a referendum on Alberta separation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["424e94e508b73a0638ca2c0695ce99ec813570b98fe6f081784b26efecc7efeb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8264b09087a97f10698dc6a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303361,"date":"2026-02-24T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in an open letter to the world from an island, an ordinary woman denounces a crime that the world refuses to see.\n\nShe writes, \"My name is like millions of others\", Ikay Romay. \"I am an ordinary Cuban woman—a daughter, a sister [and] I write this with a broken heart and trembling hands. What my people [are experiencing] today is not a crisis.\" It is a crime. \"It is slow, calculated murder.... And the world looks the other way.\"\n\nLet us look at Cuba, at what the United States is doing to it, and ask ourselves, \"Which side of history do I want to be on?\"\n\nThis is a crime. I ask that we share her message. Children and babies are dying in incubators because of blockades. People are dying for lack of medication. I ask that we do not look the other way. Thousands of people sharing her message will make a difference.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303361","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in an open letter to the world from an island, an ordinary woman denounces a crime that the world refuses to see.\n\nShe writes, \"My name is like millions of others\", Ikay Romay. \"I am an ordinary Cuban woman—a daughter, a sister [and] I write this with a broken heart and trembling hands. What my people [are experiencing] today is not a crisis.\" It is a crime. \"It is slow, calculated mu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1692cabb39551203e5e9f8c51c8aa6974d86263fc0f7f757fa134c5797feb74d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5df750f55db4188d59eedee3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303362,"date":"2026-02-24T20:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today, it is almost impossible to imagine and believe that, for the past four years, there has been a war in Ukraine that is the result of the brutality of one country, one man: Mr. Putin and his pointless and cruel war.\n\n We are united in this country. We are united in this Parliament. I want to thank every one of my colleagues who spoke, including the hon. Minister of Defence, my friend and colleague from Selkirk—Interlake—Eastman, the member for Lac-Saint-Jean and the member for Rosemont—La Petite-Patrie.\n\nI completely agree that we stand with Ukraine. We stand with the people of Ukraine. It is unacceptable that our world is being torn apart by a war that was impossible to imagine five years ago.\n\n When we think of the naïveté that we had, the wonderful thought of the political theorist Fukuyama, it seemed so clear that we had The End of History, as he wrote in 1992, that the political and ideological evolution of nations led inevitably to a time of the rule of law, to liberal democracies that lived within a set of rules that were predictable.\n\n A land war in Europe?\n\nIt was impossible to imagine. It could not be true.\n\nWhen Putin invaded Ukraine, we saw the signs. We saw it was coming, but it still seemed far too impossible to believe. I will never forget February 24, 2022. For the first time, I put on yellow and blue ribbons, and I thought that I would put them on every day until this awful war was over.\n\n Now, Putin thought he could end it in three weeks. I thought the world, the community of nations, would stand with Ukraine so clearly that it would not be long before this was over. The sense of the courage of President Zelenskyy, I thought, was the variable that Putin did not count on. He thought that not that many Ukrainians would stand up and defend their country. He thought, as did the United States at that time, that when they said, \"Do not worry, Mr. Zelenskyy, we are sending a plane for you,\" and he said, \"I need ammunition; I don't need a ride,\" that was the surprise: a genuine hero of his country, someone actually elected, someone who had been a comic on television. He was the unexpected variable of courage that was so unusual in our times, when leadership is in name only.\n\n President Zelenskyy addressed us here for the first time almost four years ago, on a TV screen. I so wished for the day that he could come back, when there was peace in Ukraine and we could celebrate him as the leader who survived a dreadful and unjust war. We still pray for that.\n\n We know that Putin miscalculated. He thought he could end a war in three weeks, but he miscalculated the corruption of his own military, the lack of consideration for what it would mean to the world, and the solidarity of Europe. Today, on the fourth anniversary, the President of the European Union is there in Ukraine. Today, in the United Nations, a resolution was carried whereby 107 nations said, \"We stand with Ukraine. We stand with peace.\"\n\n Today, President Zelenskyy spoke of Putin and of his lifetime political career of destruction, of hatred, of war. He actually said, of Putin, \"He is war itself.\" He said that to stand with him is to stand with unending war.\n\nI cannot help but feel, as I always have since we first started debating in this place what we would do for Ukraine, that we have not done enough. In some ways we cannot do enough. We have NATO. We have the United Nations. We have massive efforts.\n\nI am grateful, as my colleagues have said, that the Government of Canada has consistently stood with Ukraine. I am grateful we have welcomed Ukrainian refugees to Canada. However, more should be done with sanctions. We need to cripple the Russian economy. We need to do more. We need to seize the assets of oligarchs and see that they are liquidated and that those funds go to the Ukrainian people and the Ukrainian government.\n\n War cannot be the solution to war. More bombs do not bring peace. As other members of Parliament have said today, peace will come at a negotiating table. It is extremely important and fundamental that Mr. Putin understand that Canada, every single last one of us, stands with Ukraine, which means Russia has made itself a pariah. When the government changes, perhaps we can welcome it again into the community of nations, but there was no Russian flag at the Olympics. There will not be a Russian flag where civilized people gather, because we recognize what President Zelenskyy has said: Putin is \"war itself\". \n\nNow, as we stand here on the fourth anniversary of the beginning of that impossible war, we must make peace possible. \n\nWe must choose peace. We must work tirelessly and do what we can to ensure that there is peace around the world, particularly for the children of Ukraine and for the people of Ukraine.\n\nFor all those who have suffered and died at the hands of Russian forces, and, yes, I grieve with the Russian mothers too as they have an impossible leader who has taken them to heartbreak and disaster, peace cannot just be a dream. We have to make it real. We have to rescue the Ukrainian children who were kidnapped from their families. We have to reunite those families. We have to pour into Ukraine the help it needs so desperately. \n\nWith those words, I join all colleagues here in saying, slava Ukraini, peace and victory to Ukraine.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303362","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today, it is almost impossible to imagine and believe that, for the past four years, there has been a war in Ukraine that is the result of the brutality of one country, one man: Mr. Putin and his pointless and cruel war.\n\n We are united in this country. We are united in this Parliament. I want to thank every one of my colleagues who spoke, including the hon. Minister of Defence, my fr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52ec947f843cc191ac4a5ad05c7a5c5b7790b17daba43b39795880d1512c10c5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62996ac6443b14926191ccd12a5e4fe8d1dbe945c5ad410285e34ca49c22eb0e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25ed81027c5ac75980a744db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303363,"date":"2026-02-25T00:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise in the House tonight, in Adjournment Proceedings, to pursue a question I asked on a memorable date, November 17, 2025. It was a day on which we were going to vote later in the day on the budget itself. \n\nMy question pertained to the budget. It was for the Prime Minister. In that instance, I asked him if he would agree that there was a deficiency in the budget, in that our legally binding Paris Agreement commitments were not mentioned and that we had not yet seen what was described as a nature strategy: Canada's commitments under COP15 of the biodiversity convention, otherwise known as the Kunming-Montreal agreement.\n\n It was a very strong answer, but there have been some inconsistencies. The Prime Minister did respond, and it is important to repeat it for the purpose of the Hansard. \n\nHe stated:\n\nI can confirm to the House that we will respect our Paris commitments for climate change, and we are determined to achieve them. I can confirm with the House that consistent with our Kunming-Montreal commitments, the nature strategy will be released in the coming weeks.\n\nThe Prime Minister also mentioned that it was important that we be \"on the path for real results for climate, for nature and for reconciliation.\"\n\nMy question at this hour is this. Now that we are looking at the answer that was received, and since then the changes that have been made in government planning, we are still, according to all reports, not on track to meet our Paris Agreement targets. We can measure things in weeks, but certainly \"the coming weeks\" suggested that we would see the nature strategy relatively quickly. This was November 17. We are now almost four months later and have not yet seen the nature strategy. \n\nI certainly hope that someone representing the Prime Minister here this evening can update the House on when we are on getting the nature strategy brought forward. It is critical if we are going to meet the commitments that are due by 2030, it now being 2026, that we see action, that we see commitments and that we see funding.\n\n It is also important to mention, and I look for any kind of an update on climate commitments, that the budget that was tabled that day and that we voted on shortly after this exchange in question period included, at page 348, a clear commitment that what are called enhanced oil recovery measures would not qualify for investment tax credits. However, some days later, not that long thereafter, a commitment was made to the Government of Alberta in an MOU that such investments to increase oil production would in fact qualify for further subsidies to encourage further oil production. This was contrary to the exact wording of the budget we had voted on that day, which said \"Eligible uses include\" and then listed some, but not enhanced oil recovery. \n\nThat left us in this place, and across Canada I might add, with some significant questions about where we are as a nation. What can we make of the commitment of November 17 that we will act to avoid exceeding a 2°C global average temperature increase and will take steps to ensure that the nature strategy and our commitments globally are observed?\n\n I note at this hour, as my time is running out on putting forward my argument in this late show proceeding, that time is also running out for the climate. We are dealing with atmospheric changes that are irreversible and can be self-accelerating without quick action.\n\n I look forward to this debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303363","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise in the House tonight, in Adjournment Proceedings, to pursue a question I asked on a memorable date, November 17, 2025. It was a day on which we were going to vote later in the day on the budget itself. \n\nMy question pertained to the budget. It was for the Prime Minister. In that instance, I asked him if he would agree that there was a deficiency in the budget, in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d1ceb0c47e3fc91d51c3481472ed80310000659774724a1a459d46b784bd58e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d8b25a00f21e51d46d6f91f7a10c64b05561fef8106cd8517e680b6bbd35f35c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1500b847918ec0667da9652","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303364,"date":"2026-02-25T00:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, surely my hon. colleague is aware that recent studies, including by the government-appointed experts in the Canadian Climate Institute, have shown that Canada is not on track to meet any of our targets. That includes that Canada is not on track to meet the climate targets put in place by former prime minister Stephen Harper and that Canada is nowhere near the targets under former prime minister Justin Trudeau that we are supposed to be meeting, because we have, as the Climate Institute report pointed out, weakened more actions than we have strengthened.\n\nIt is a foregone conclusion that without much more robust actions to reduce emissions, we are going to risk hitting tipping points in the atmosphere that put us on a path to unstoppable, self-accelerating climate change that threatens future generations and human civilization itself.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303364","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, surely my hon. colleague is aware that recent studies, including by the government-appointed experts in the Canadian Climate Institute, have shown that Canada is not on track to meet any of our targets. That includes that Canada is not on track to meet the climate targets put in place by former prime minister Stephen Harper and that Canada is nowhere near the targets under former prim","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","label":"Atmospheric emissions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","label":"Atmospheric emissions","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0d40f714e82346bf33deba92efbdc203d83c945c0781aa422c7535b61001eabd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a50b7c417a0c9cfe39f2152d5670254de19c0c482ce87ce8a6adabf244244dc8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e82ebdc1500228e828bfa4d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303346,"date":"2026-02-25T21:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on behalf of many constituents, I rise to present a petition expressing their deep concern that Canada is off track to meet its targets under the Paris Agreement. These are not political targets but are based in the science, which demands that for the security of humankind, all life on the planet, our children and our grandchildren, we hold the global average temperature increase to no more than 2°C.\n\nI will not read the petition, but many steps need to be taken that constitute bold climate action. The petitioners ask for the government to act swiftly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303346","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on behalf of many constituents, I rise to present a petition expressing their deep concern that Canada is off track to meet its targets under the Paris Agreement. These are not political targets but are based in the science, which demands that for the security of humankind, all life on the planet, our children and our grandchildren, we hold the global average temperature increase to n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2daf8f9493fa1f1bc605bd26618108068f47c3442340f77f4f44df4600bb3bb4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e63b7af5c67593d8707c29d2ccee88f909d3d4c7e65cb7fca137ab1edd99e6d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3587ff3277af7b1a9d24c18a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303347,"date":"2026-02-25T23:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I usually begin a speech by saying it is an honour or a pleasure to stand to speak to the bill before us, but I am so deeply appalled and offended by what has been going on in this place since June that I have a hard time speaking without the rage making my voice tremble.\n\nBill C-15, the omnibus budget bill, is offensive at every level. It is very much an omnibus bill. A budget implementation bill is supposed to implement a budget and not contain surprises, things that were not in the budget and were not even mentioned. However, we are presented with them here and it is all supposed to be fast-tracked. It was fast-tracked by a UC motion, and it was done on Friday the 13th when I was unable to object to the fast-tracking of this bill. I do not regret going to Tumbler Ridge. It was important to be there together with the other party leaders, but I deeply regret that the governing party chose that moment to put forward a unanimous consent motion to fast-track the review of this bill at report stage and third reading.\n\nIt is, as we have heard and as Canadians have heard, a bill of over 600 pages. I remember the omnibus budget bill of spring 2012, Bill C-38. I was appalled when Stephen Harper tried to push it through and did in fact push it through. It took longer to debate, in fairness, but it was over 400 pages. The omnibus budget implementation act of spring 2012 was over 400 pages. Here we have the omnibus budget bill to budget 2025-26 and it is over 600 pages, with much of it, as I said, unanticipated. It touches on more than 20 different laws, bills as diverse as anything we have heard of. It deals with the fast-tracked expropriation of lands next to Alto high-speed rail. I support high-speed rail, but I think we needed more time to study this in the House.\n\nWe have changes made here to the Canadian Environmental Protection Act. My attempts to put forward amendments to that in the finance committee were summarily defeated, but we never properly discussed them. The public has not heard as much as a peep about the things in this budget implementation act, Bill C-15, which would change things for the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, weakening environmental protections, particularly around a practice that has been under way since 1988. The act has been around for a long time.\n\nTo change it to say we want equivalency with the provinces so that we do not duplicate is a good thing, but it needs to be reviewed now and then. This bill says, no, we are never going to review it. That is it. There is no sunset on that. Equivalency goes forward. A lot of environmental law experts would have liked to testify to that. They would have liked to testify at the environment committee about that, but no amendments occurred to the changes to the Canadian Environmental Protection Act that are included in Bill C-15.\n\nIt is egregious, as we have heard from other speakers here tonight, and I should remember the names of the members who spoke so eloquently to the changes that are being made to veterans' rights. I know the member for Vancouver Kingsway mentioned it. We have here in this bill retroactive changes to avoid legislative changes to help our veterans in long-term care have access to the reimbursements to which they are entirely entitled. We are doing a quickie on that one. \n\nBefore they can turn around, members will find that this bill also includes a number of time machines. We never had time to talk about it in this place, but Bill C-4, which is currently before the Senate, in part 4, changes privacy rights under the Elections Act. That is a doozy, by the way. We never got to debate that in this place. The bill will enter into force when the Senate is finished with it, and it will enter into force 26 years ago, because it enters into force in the year 2000. Things are being done in this place that should scandalize the members of the House, because they are profoundly anti-democratic. They represent power grabs. \n\nBill C-5, which was rushed through in June, of course, was the first time any prime minister in Canada has ever used the King Henry VIII clause to say that if something in the bill breaks other laws we have already passed, that is okay. I was not prepared for this to show up when I was reading this monstrous bill and to find in division 5, well over 500 pages in, that Bill C-15 put forward the notion that, unlike in Bill C-5 where the cabinet as a whole could break other laws, an individual minister, at his or her discretion, in areas within his or her jurisdiction, could exempt any entity from the application of any law except the Criminal Code.\n\nI want to thank the hon. member for Newmarket—Aurora, who put forward the amendments in committee that would make this less bad, but in case anyone's wondering, spoiler alert, I am not going to vote for this. It is less bad, but it is still pretty awful. I cannot vote for a bill that would say that any minister can exempt an entity from acts except for a listed few, even though the ones listed are good. \n\nOn this notion of regulatory sandboxes, as far as I'm concerned and despite the fact that committee members were told in finance committee by Treasury Board officials that regulatory sandboxes are normal and routine and that we should all be used to them by now, I cannot support it. They come from the U.K., the Tory government and the Bank of England, where regulatory sandboxes were initiated in order to innovate financial instruments, services and products and were exempted from laws to be able to innovate and experiment.\n\nI do not mind it so much, although innovation in financial instruments is what led to the collapse of the housing market in the U.S. by bundling together worthless mortgage papers and calling it a product, but it is more dangerous when they are playing with our health and environment.\n\nWe do not have any way of really regulating what is going on, even with the admirable work of the member for Newmarket—Aurora. The hon. member for Vancouver Kingsway referred to it as a \"backroom deal\". No doubt that is what happened. It makes this slightly less awful. It would mean that before a minister exempts an entity from the application of a law, there must be a 30-day public consultation period. Unlike the original version of this act that said that the minister will make it public as soon as it is \"feasible\" but with no timeline on that, thanks to amendments in committee it is now within 30 days that it must be made public. However, that does not allow me to vote for this bill.\n\nThe hon. member for Vancouver Kingsway also pointed out, and I will certainly vote for those amendments, that this bill would do away with the digital services tax. While that was not as much of a surprise, given the budget, as other things, and I think regulatory sandboxes were never foreshadowed, certainly in the election campaign, we were told it was \"elbows up\". It was subsequent to that, but before the budget, that our elbows dropped when Donald Trump said that he did not like the fact that Canadians were bringing in a digital services tax.\n\nWe were doing that in concert with colleagues through the European Union. We need to get a hold of these digital giants that are ripping off our private information for their own profit. We need to have a way of holding them to account. They are eroding our democracy and attacking our public media and newspapers.\n\nI remember a prominent Liberal and respected former minister in this place, the hon. Lloyd Axworthy, who called it \"bootlicking\" when Trump said that he did not like the digital services tax and the Prime Minister said that we will get rid of it really quickly. I am too nice to say that, but I can quote Lloyd Axworthy saying it.\n\nI find it deeply worrying that we now have to pass an omnibus budget bill in quick fashion, because it has to be done by later tonight. We all know that is the plan. It is going to be whizzed through, because they whizzed through that process in the unanimous consent motion of February 13.\n\nI find this bill deeply offensive. There would be changes to CEPA without proper analysis and study and changes to the digital services tax without us even debating in this place the fact that we are repealing a law that we passed to bring it into effect. We would lose the oversight under the Red Tape Reduction Act. One would have never expected us to bring in the right for any individual minister to exempt an entity from a law, which still remains in place in this bill but with more safeguards and somewhat more transparency.\n\n When I consider all the things that comprise this giant, over 600-page bill, I am offended. I will vote no, and I urge my fellow members to make it less bad by supporting the amendments from the hon. member for Vancouver Kingsway.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303347","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I usually begin a speech by saying it is an honour or a pleasure to stand to speak to the bill before us, but I am so deeply appalled and offended by what has been going on in this place since June that I have a hard time speaking without the rage making my voice tremble.\n\nBill C-15, the omnibus budget bill, is offensive at every level. It is very much an omnibus bill. A budget implem","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4640b4da43490358d8aa9af484cb0f10d7cb0fef88fbd3ce91a1745ce7f5ee7f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ade573c17a4f26c21088f213334a981d43ca3ed381982fac0ce9bb62a9a4b4c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-249234dcaf49b4d5e6631f0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303348,"date":"2026-02-25T23:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would say this quickly to my hon. colleague from Winnipeg North. As he knows, I am the only opposition party member who voted for the budget itself. I largely did that because the budget, on page 348, committed that the eligible uses for investment tax credits would not include \"enhanced oil recovery\". It was 10 days after I voted for the budget that the memorandum of understanding with Alberta said to forget that thing written in the budget. I know it is not in disappearing ink as I still see it here in the budget, but the reverse has been promised to Danielle Smith of Alberta.\n\n I support that we friendshore. I support what the former deputy leader Chrystia Freeland said, which is that democracies need democracies, not dictators. Therefore, it bothers me if our international trading partners are Saudi Arabia—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303348","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would say this quickly to my hon. colleague from Winnipeg North. As he knows, I am the only opposition party member who voted for the budget itself. I largely did that because the budget, on page 348, committed that the eligible uses for investment tax credits would not include \"enhanced oil recovery\". It was 10 days after I voted for the budget that the memorandum of understanding ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d43c5930b74eab1cbb70894255965a2d14a257e2f50010b2a8c8669d828403c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a2f2b1684b160a275ea34df8d78d2d314bd23956df36651245956ccd2e689f2c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b1774e2cebe1fdc448aafb8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303349,"date":"2026-02-25T23:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as has also been pointed out by another colleague from the member's bench, some of the high-speed rail will impact sensitive areas. The problem with building everything fast is this.\n\nI can say it in French. I asked a Bloc Québécois colleague what the French word for \"bulldozer\" is. It is the same word.\n\nWe are seeing a lot of bulldozing over process, procedure, democracy and ecosystems. It goes hand in hand.\n\nI think there are some problems with this omnibus bill.\n\nI agree with my colleague that we should study it. We want rail across Canada, but we need to know what we are getting into.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303349","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as has also been pointed out by another colleague from the member's bench, some of the high-speed rail will impact sensitive areas. The problem with building everything fast is this.\n\nI can say it in French. I asked a Bloc Québécois colleague what the French word for \"bulldozer\" is. It is the same word.\n\nWe are seeing a lot of bulldozing over process, procedure, democracy and ecosyste","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8c9c57e12f5fd0898c17aafd7d456fd228134a2020c481a6fa512b83dbaa9626"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["85a8ca98186a917566859d2ae9f4499ca87e537372c6e882e9e6402756c1bdd7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9daa52b8f33294495b67f0a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303350,"date":"2026-02-25T23:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I completely agree with my esteemed colleague from the Bloc Québécois. It is clear. The proof is there. We have no indication that the current government will uphold environmental laws protecting endangered species.\n\n It is clear from Bill C-5 and Bill C-15 that those things do not matter. The only thing that matters is the bulldozers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303350","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I completely agree with my esteemed colleague from the Bloc Québécois. It is clear. The proof is there. We have no indication that the current government will uphold environmental laws protecting endangered species.\n\n It is clear from Bill C-5 and Bill C-15 that those things do not matter. The only thing that matters is the bulldozers.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-16fa452ff660cef6e042b490","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303351,"date":"2026-02-26T00:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting against the motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303351","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting against the motion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9d481f293bf8a37a8bd0076bc0128ee5a120676bb44889eca9d10f946806866"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a214f20a1072ed14c2ccb3d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303352,"date":"2026-02-26T00:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am sorry. My eyesight is giving me some difficulties. For the last motion, I would like to vote in favour.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303352","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am sorry. My eyesight is giving me some difficulties. For the last motion, I would like to vote in favour.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f7d86cadf6488c2724c287fef85de8bd1b7a8a3924333e74e53c52d560e3f7cb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de2def5440fd1ecd0f2661b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303353,"date":"2026-02-26T01:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting against the motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303353","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting against the motion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9d481f293bf8a37a8bd0076bc0128ee5a120676bb44889eca9d10f946806866"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b50110c6a24b4541014ec4d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303354,"date":"2026-02-26T01:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I agree to applying the vote, voting yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303354","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I agree to applying the vote, voting yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba9decb47d8753457863938f7547fef95e81904a37029b3eac7d831f3e9b97f3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-581058b7a345bcf6e6352c6f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303355,"date":"2026-02-26T01:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting in favour.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303355","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting in favour.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df9dd4af40cd45c824292cb831e505c0fc64d4c64fbe3553ea030972709c2ae7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c32fb60767a06cf135c3d36","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303356,"date":"2026-02-26T01:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote. We will be voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303356","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote. We will be voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71d8f64e079199a455571955519b18f97240ed5bd25cfc347f991037b12a5a39"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eac0b41fe7e748bd95f89be6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303343,"date":"2026-02-26T15:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise on behalf of the constituents of Saanich—Gulf Islands to present a petition through which constituents in Saanich—Gulf Islands are looking to see the government pursue the promise of protected marine areas. It has been such a long time, as it has been decades, since it was first proposed that there be a protected marine area next to the Gulf Islands National Park. It was so long ago that Jacques Cousteau endorsed the idea.\n\nIn any case, there are 11 classifications for marine protected areas, and depending on how they are classified, a different department would oversee the marine protected area. Petitioners are pointing out that, when areas are closed off to fishing, there is a net benefit to fisheries throughout the region. Areas where there is a no-fishing rule allow fisheries to recover and be more plentiful in the areas surrounding the protected area. \n\nThe petitioners call on the government and DFO to work with relevant government branches to simplify the communication and ensure that marine protected areas are put in place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303343","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise on behalf of the constituents of Saanich—Gulf Islands to present a petition through which constituents in Saanich—Gulf Islands are looking to see the government pursue the promise of protected marine areas. It has been such a long time, as it has been decades, since it was first proposed that there be a protected marine area next to the Gulf Islands National Pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["839c8b3900c9e17e8feb2af555f9298cf40b47aa3c1603f0f6134e6647b01336"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c534d61c3bfaf91134a84cf6183ba494e452138aa347d7311adfe02d6b3b1a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a3de8f53026a0bdd55fd53f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303344,"date":"2026-02-26T16:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I would like to ask my colleague from Mirabel a question.\n\nThe member for Winnipeg North said that we have had plenty of time to study this omnibus bill, which is over 600 pages long. However, first reading was on November 18, and then we had the Christmas break. We did not have time to properly study all the sections and each very complicated provision, particularly those concerning high-speed rail.\n\nDoes my colleague share my view that we have not had enough time to properly study this bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303344","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I would like to ask my colleague from Mirabel a question.\n\nThe member for Winnipeg North said that we have had plenty of time to study this omnibus bill, which is over 600 pages long. However, first reading was on November 18, and then we had the Christmas break. We did not have time to properly study all the sections and each very complicated provision, particularly those concernin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb8ef3cfaa68e7afdf431175777075d481093b4dcf194d6bd74f171493817518"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0842a07ae1bb6fdd404bc433","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303345,"date":"2026-02-26T17:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would just like to make sure this is on the record, because the hon. member for Winnipeg North said clearly that everyone in the House was in favour of the process we are taking now because the motion received unanimous consent. The people who put it forward at that moment knew full well that I would object but that I was travelling with the Prime Minister to Tumbler Ridge. That is a choice I am very honoured to have made, and I am grateful to the Prime Minister for making it possible for all opposition party members to be on that flight. I did not know it would be to my disadvantage in saying no to the process we are now going through regarding the omnibus budget bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303345","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would just like to make sure this is on the record, because the hon. member for Winnipeg North said clearly that everyone in the House was in favour of the process we are taking now because the motion received unanimous consent. The people who put it forward at that moment knew full well that I would object but that I was travelling with the Prime Minister to Tumbler Ridge. That is ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a546f1c570e7b8529ae9119603ef2d73f51ee1e706913c9c93e58678607be56"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30218dcbf0950239ce0f097aa66958ef97ba6eb35d3a1ab7431c5668ab118324"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bb63ecf38125a980b78836f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303341,"date":"2026-02-27T15:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this legislation certainly needs the amendments of the Senate. Bill S-2 must include dealing with the first-generation cut-off. \n\nI want to ask the hon. member if she heard an answer when she asked the minister if the government was prepared to support the Senate amendments so this bill could be passed expeditiously. I am still not certain, and I ask the hon. member for Nunavut.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303341","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this legislation certainly needs the amendments of the Senate. Bill S-2 must include dealing with the first-generation cut-off. \n\nI want to ask the hon. member if she heard an answer when she asked the minister if the government was prepared to support the Senate amendments so this bill could be passed expeditiously. I am still not certain, and I ask the hon. member for Nunavut.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d29550b5b3c9baa9e120d6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":303342,"date":"2026-02-27T17:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my question is to the hon. Minister of Housing. \n\nBritish Columbian MPs were stunned when the provincial government killed the B.C. community housing fund. We now have projects that are ready to roll. The land has been purchased, the zoning is completed and the permits are in place for senior, low-income housing and veterans housing on Galiano Island, on Mayne Island, in Saanich and across British Columbia.\n\n Will the federal government step up to create a defined program for shovel-ready projects to make sure that the housing gets built for the people who need it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:303342","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my question is to the hon. Minister of Housing. \n\nBritish Columbian MPs were stunned when the provincial government killed the B.C. community housing fund. We now have projects that are ready to roll. The land has been purchased, the zoning is completed and the permits are in place for senior, low-income housing and veterans housing on Galiano Island, on Mayne Island, in Saanich and a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7dc1f97ea94adbfc46b49d399cff4544aa9166a55a5b292449e7ee52effa0779"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66cdcabbca22c48bd93f74a6090ca1a71bafd03003406f5c40a0d8eb4601d2ee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86ee9603edb010c498ff7894","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331831,"date":"2026-03-09T18:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank my colleague from Drummond for his speech.\n\nI have a lot of concerns about Bill C-9, but that is not what we are talking about today. I do not like the idea of putting so much importance on using motions like these to study a bill quickly.\n\nI have a problem with the part of Bill C-9 that makes it possible to break the law during a demonstration for being too close to a building. A demonstrator might not realize that there is not enough space between the demonstration and the building.\n\nWhat does the member think about this problematic aspect of Bill C-9?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331831","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank my colleague from Drummond for his speech.\n\nI have a lot of concerns about Bill C-9, but that is not what we are talking about today. I do not like the idea of putting so much importance on using motions like these to study a bill quickly.\n\nI have a problem with the part of Bill C-9 that makes it possible to break the law during a demonstration for being too close to a build","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e24384cb675e54d10821ea9aef4394f877e27b93d53d250e039aab46676943a2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed1be776a9801ca5b7f34246132288dc2da4748c0ba5cc2643ea38a74f404f96"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a9416ecc3ecbdf88fc183b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331832,"date":"2026-03-09T18:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, as I come to my feet today on this legislation and on the programming motion, it just has to be said that we are shaken to our core and, as Greens, horrified by the acts of violence directed at synagogues just within the last day or two in Toronto. \n\nWe are debating legislation and wondering if it would make things better, and I do not know, because I agree with the civil liberties reviews of the legislation, saying that the definitions around motivated crimes against places of worship are so indistinct that they could end up criminalizing legal protest. I ask the hon. member to please reconsider the nature of the government's attempt over and over again to bulldoze things through this place without adequate study.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331832","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, as I come to my feet today on this legislation and on the programming motion, it just has to be said that we are shaken to our core and, as Greens, horrified by the acts of violence directed at synagogues just within the last day or two in Toronto. \n\nWe are debating legislation and wondering if it would make things better, and I do not know, because I agree with the civil liberties ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb453432a9f86c022dbd06a6459af2d9c079f3a9543f415921693f653f68dfdc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9c2784680b81797c4068eb57eb6bf2af3ad201b8d2a8b8aaa7d13b2917e323e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd0e5f221edb2ad3fdc214d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331833,"date":"2026-03-09T20:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on February 28, the United States and Israel launched illegal attacks against Iran.\n\nLloyd Axworthy, former foreign minister of this country, wrote in the Toronto Star that day, \"Canada once rejected America's aggressive, unlawful foreign policy. Today [the Prime Minister] embraced it\". He went on to say, \"Under the [United Nations] Charter, cross-border uses of force are prohibited except in two narrow cases\". He points out that Operation Epic Fury applies to neither.\n\nI will ask today, will the Prime Minister belatedly—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331833","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on February 28, the United States and Israel launched illegal attacks against Iran.\n\nLloyd Axworthy, former foreign minister of this country, wrote in the Toronto Star that day, \"Canada once rejected America's aggressive, unlawful foreign policy. Today [the Prime Minister] embraced it\". He went on to say, \"Under the [United Nations] Charter, cross-border uses of force are prohibited e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["39240dd031d2570caa8dd6a52092b7126f18ac22d86eefb73535247c7f8d804f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a4cfecf39eca7eec888ab5dcefb9ba523b334621cf32174b3f25f4260fdfa053"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eba4991ed42197b4f699972e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331834,"date":"2026-03-09T20:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is an issue of deep concern for the people of Saanich—Gulf Islands and across Canada. Every MP in this place knows of this scandal, that people living with disabilities in this country are far more likely to be living in poverty. We voted and worked in this place to get the Canadian disability benefit through. However, at this point it is not lifting people out of poverty. Therefore, the petitioners are asking the House to look at the reality that the financial pressures from rising costs are disproportionately falling on these same people with disabilities across Canada. Any disability and emergency supports they receive end up occasionally being clawed back and are not treated as benefits they can keep. \n\nThe petitioners are very specifically relying on all of these facts and calling on the government to fix the Canadian disability benefit, alleviate the financial pressures and ensure that every person with disabilities across Canada receiving any disability support receive a one-time emergency support of $5,000 tax-free that is not means-tested and cannot be clawed back by any order of government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331834","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is an issue of deep concern for the people of Saanich—Gulf Islands and across Canada. Every MP in this place knows of this scandal, that people living with disabilities in this country are far more likely to be living in poverty. We voted and worked in this place to get the Canadian disability benefit through. However, at this point it is not lifting people out of poverty. Theref","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5ebea7650026ac4de388edff86175b5b951c08a3ce7a744820eff94f794bdcdf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["918a0674774b25f05c46433990d0fd922e9146e5ecb4b5be8a2492fc2e36e6fa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2cc3b7d145a57f4cc0f24bdb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331835,"date":"2026-03-09T20:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I look at the creation of Build Canada Homes, I am particularly interested in the fact that the government moved fast and used something rarely used, called a special operating agency, which is under Treasury Board rules.\n\nI wonder if the lack of transparency involved in that troubles the member for Thornhill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331835","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I look at the creation of Build Canada Homes, I am particularly interested in the fact that the government moved fast and used something rarely used, called a special operating agency, which is under Treasury Board rules.\n\nI wonder if the lack of transparency involved in that troubles the member for Thornhill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c51dd48e96fac7c6d490bd709df77f8b222c70729b66267b432d6ef8a1341eb9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["496f707e69efd97c6a2fe9a2e97afc9ec2fca0beb6f2ae7dc8c518575d9801d8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-785755ba497c898c7d7a270b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331836,"date":"2026-03-09T23:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I asked earlier to another hon. colleague on the Conservative benches if there was not an improvement in seeing if, now that we have Bill C-20's approach, we actually are no longer describing Build Canada Homes as a special operating agency and there may be more transparency—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331836","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I asked earlier to another hon. colleague on the Conservative benches if there was not an improvement in seeing if, now that we have Bill C-20's approach, we actually are no longer describing Build Canada Homes as a special operating agency and there may be more transparency—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7dca23f143a3c1f296c61f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331837,"date":"2026-03-09T23:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a former senior commander of the Canadian Forces, retired Major-General Denis Thompson, has said on the record that he thinks it is \"highly likely\" that Canadian exchange officers in the region knew in advance.\n\nDoes the minister have any comment on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331837","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a former senior commander of the Canadian Forces, retired Major-General Denis Thompson, has said on the record that he thinks it is \"highly likely\" that Canadian exchange officers in the region knew in advance.\n\nDoes the minister have any comment on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79cf9f870cacc6fe626d3bf5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331838,"date":"2026-03-10T00:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I addressed this question earlier to the official opposition with some trepidation because it is information I have from friends within the Vancouver area who are also, like me, associated with the Anglican Church and are very concerned that some members of the Iranian national guard may be obtaining a baptismal certificate to hide their real background and intentions in this country. I second the member's call that we absolutely look for any members of the Iranian national guard who are masquerading as real refugees. I want to ask him if he has heard similar concerns.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331838","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I addressed this question earlier to the official opposition with some trepidation because it is information I have from friends within the Vancouver area who are also, like me, associated with the Anglican Church and are very concerned that some members of the Iranian national guard may be obtaining a baptismal certificate to hide their real background and intentions in this country.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf57eb629ed3dda850a5452c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331839,"date":"2026-03-10T00:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague, the Bloc Québécois leader, for his speech.\n\nNow, I want to quote the President of the United States, who said, \"When crazy people have nuclear weapons, bad things happen.\"\n\nDoes my colleague think, as I do, that the President is looking in the mirror?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331839","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague, the Bloc Québécois leader, for his speech.\n\nNow, I want to quote the President of the United States, who said, \"When crazy people have nuclear weapons, bad things happen.\"\n\nDoes my colleague think, as I do, that the President is looking in the mirror?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e45d0b18d7b9d2580d4deb5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331840,"date":"2026-03-10T01:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, a regime change in Iran may be sought by many, but it would not necessarily lead to peace and prosperity for the people of Iran if it were to come through an armed conflict.\n\n I recall, as the member will as well because he was with that government working with John Baird, when on June 14, 2011, I was the only member of Parliament to vote against Canada bombing Libya. I asked John Baird at the time about the people who we recognized as a legitimate government of Libya, which included people from al Qaeda. He famously said that, although we may not know the people we were supporting, we could be assured of one thing, which was that they could not be as bad as Gadhafi. \n\nThe reality now is that we have a failed state in Libya. It exported a lot of arms to conflicts and terrorism around the world. Can we reflect on how we can bring about a regime change so that there is peace and stability?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331840","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, a regime change in Iran may be sought by many, but it would not necessarily lead to peace and prosperity for the people of Iran if it were to come through an armed conflict.\n\n I recall, as the member will as well because he was with that government working with John Baird, when on June 14, 2011, I was the only member of Parliament to vote against Canada bombing Libya. I asked John Baird","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["228be844693e840b5befbc3d4d0e6d2c9f71f4c5c38c5042e2a38b21100fa0f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["17bae7a273af99bbd73b865a3aa09046f9923216e90299ac04dce5e540f9e172"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f861d0bb6440e0e481d823b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331841,"date":"2026-03-10T01:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I thank my dear colleague for giving me the opportunity to participate in this evening's incredibly important debate.\n\nSince the morning of February 28, from coast to coast to coast, Canadians have been scared. Canadians are praying for peace, wondering if the world is unravelling even faster than before. We have wondered, since Putin invaded Ukraine four years ago, if the world is capable of pulling together for peace.\n\nMy goal tonight is to try to find some common threads, because what this must not be is purely a partisan debate. It is far too easy to point out that the Prime Minister made a mistake on February 28 in being too quick to issue a declaration that we supported the bombing. It is obvious now, and it should have been obvious that day to the Prime Minister, that this is a violation of international law. We must stand with international law.\n\nHowever, we are Canadians, first and foremost. Around this room and through all parts of Canada, I am sure what we most want is for our country to do the right thing, and that might mean that we have to put partisanship to the side.\n\nI think we can set aside partisan differences. The question we must debate is this: What can we do now?\n\nWe know the Minister of Foreign Affairs said clearly that we need to move to de-escalation. She is not alone in that. I want to quote the Secretary-General of the United Nations, at the emergency debates of the Security Council. Of course, we know that around the table of that Security Council are some of the prime actors in avoiding peace in this conflict. \n\nStill, Secretary-General António Guterres said, \"Military action carries the risk of igniting a chain of events that no one can control in the most volatile region of the world.\" He said, \"the world [needs] a way out now\", and that way is \"de-escalation and an immediate cessation of hostilities.\"\n\nHow can Canada help? Can we help?\n\n We do need to stop saying there is no international law. There is such a thing as international law. It's the United Nations Charter. It is critical that Canada continually defends the fact that there is a United Nations Charter. We are wrong when we decide it is difficult, awkward or embarrassing to point out when the United States violates the international rule of law by, for instance, seizing the President of Venezuela. It is hard to point these things out, but when we have a U.S. President who, right now, 60% of Canadians see as a threat, we really do need to insist on the United Nations Charter being observed and respected. Otherwise, who will stand up for us if someday we need to remind people that the United Nations Charter defends Canada's sovereignty?\n\n We need to defend the sovereignty of even those nations in which we want to see regime change as quickly as possible. No one will disagree, I do not think, that the Iranian regime is a despicable and brutal regime that oppresses, suppresses and kills its own people. However, that does not mean that the United States and Israel had any legal grounds to bomb Tehran. That was reckless and dangerous, and we will continue to see the consequences, maybe into generations.\n\n We need to now seize the chance, somehow, against the odds, while we are still respected in the world, for Canada to play the kind of role we played long ago, but not that long ago. I am thinking of Hon. Lloyd Axworthy. He was our foreign minister from 1996 to 2000, and he played a key role in getting the landmine treaty. He is calling on the government to respect international law, to speak out and to ensure that we are on the right side of history.\n\n For this, it means that those of us in this room tonight accept our responsibility, not just as partisans but as human beings on a planet in peril, and put aside the obvious fun of making political points and giving partisan jabs. There has not been a single person speaking tonight with whom I would not agree with most of what they said. Not every word, but most of what everybody has said in this room tonight is about how we protect all of the world from an escalating conflict whose ultimate consequences could be beyond the disaster that we dare not speak its name.\n\nWith that, I conclude.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331841","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I thank my dear colleague for giving me the opportunity to participate in this evening's incredibly important debate.\n\nSince the morning of February 28, from coast to coast to coast, Canadians have been scared. Canadians are praying for peace, wondering if the world is unravelling even faster than before. We have wondered, since Putin invaded Ukraine four years ago, if the world is capa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8bb6bcfde5ce50b22a77cde431d967dbc6ea7b4be01c0da233e7ab7dd8d5d58e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19ad74925838151b6b63ebc6618b594e5f3228feef89acb6f25c26530da6b18d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9bf5061bee7483ddf1ea592","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331842,"date":"2026-03-10T01:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, it is not possible to rewrite the United Nations Charter from a desk in this place. It is the case that sovereign nation-states are recognized for their sovereignty as nation-states.\n\n I will agree with the hon. member. I, myself, dislike the Iranian regime, but the sovereignty of that nation does not rest in its people, unfortunately, any more than the sovereignty of any nation can be determined by public opinion polls.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331842","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, it is not possible to rewrite the United Nations Charter from a desk in this place. It is the case that sovereign nation-states are recognized for their sovereignty as nation-states.\n\n I will agree with the hon. member. I, myself, dislike the Iranian regime, but the sovereignty of that nation does not rest in its people, unfortunately, any more than the sovereignty of any nation can be ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["835c89ee097ebc5e9026ba7049efadc7cc2549a9a6699dcbd38487562ba7358c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba5277e90ea7041442e2dfbd9db2ca9a79af0be0a731caff8229f56fa161eaea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5e685b6eefdd9fa2aa428d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331843,"date":"2026-03-10T01:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Chair, I agree with my colleague 100%. The Government of Canada must not support illegal wars.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331843","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I agree with my colleague 100%. The Government of Canada must not support illegal wars.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05fd4eb5d28286eaf4f5d9c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331844,"date":"2026-03-10T01:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Chair, the member for Mount Royal knows that is absolutely not the position Greens would take. We do believe that there can be multilateral diplomatic efforts, and we have always supported that the people of Iran deserve to be protected.\n\nUnfortunately, the responsibility to protect doctrine was wrecked when Canada went along with bombing Libya until Libya became a failed state and we destroyed the opportunity to use responsibility to protect. It is a nascent notion in international law. We must defend it, and we should be able to use it, but only within the constraints of those things that are legal.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331844","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Chair, the member for Mount Royal knows that is absolutely not the position Greens would take. We do believe that there can be multilateral diplomatic efforts, and we have always supported that the people of Iran deserve to be protected.\n\nUnfortunately, the responsibility to protect doctrine was wrecked when Canada went along with bombing Libya until Libya became a failed state and we destro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2019d8ce6841b381bbae3acdef8e7dae5ebeda2ed9d6e937ea60ffd0f3f8fb59"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-acf4569e93b24706b4bfb704","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331845,"date":"2026-03-10T01:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Chair, the United Nations Charter is not a legal technicality. If we did not have it, this world would be in a great deal more trouble.\n\n However, I do agree with the hon. member. We should not turn away. We should never have turned away. We should not have allowed what happened in Syria to happen, with the butcher al-Assad killing his people. We turned away because it was difficult, but a community of nations working together can take action, and we need to revive the doctrine of the responsibility to protect.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331845","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Chair, the United Nations Charter is not a legal technicality. If we did not have it, this world would be in a great deal more trouble.\n\n However, I do agree with the hon. member. We should not turn away. We should never have turned away. We should not have allowed what happened in Syria to happen, with the butcher al-Assad killing his people. We turned away because it was difficult, but a c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a22173f3e5f952764203e11e915c0a9866e6ab42a1fb41cd50b5cf520c22432e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3aa6007355d1b3a3e918fa9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331846,"date":"2026-03-10T02:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Chair, I could not agree more with the hon. member for Thornhill that it would be a great day to see the end of this regime. My problem is that the lessons of history tell us that when wars have started for regime change, they often fail to achieve regime change and worse leadership is put in place by the same kinds of thugs we were hoping to get rid of the first time. \n\nI ask the hon. member if she sees a pathway to the people of Iran being able to choose their own leadership in a situation of conflict that is escalating out of control.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331846","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I could not agree more with the hon. member for Thornhill that it would be a great day to see the end of this regime. My problem is that the lessons of history tell us that when wars have started for regime change, they often fail to achieve regime change and worse leadership is put in place by the same kinds of thugs we were hoping to get rid of the first time. \n\nI ask the hon. membe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e08a60979b548d550f93dfb21525dacb2135741d53d67837cb82fa42f56cc080"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["687911066d2461c7ecc44f5ce43c1a6979995226dac564c39f68958f36db1c70"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d179e73c5c53c0ef93600488","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331847,"date":"2026-03-10T02:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I wonder if the hon. parliamentary secretary can agree with me that there are times when we land on the same place, like with the need to get rid of former Iranian Guard members who make Iranian Canadians and others in the diaspora feel afraid. We have to deal with that, but can we also agree that a lot of Iranian dissidents who hate this regime also object to the bombing by the United States and Israel?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331847","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I wonder if the hon. parliamentary secretary can agree with me that there are times when we land on the same place, like with the need to get rid of former Iranian Guard members who make Iranian Canadians and others in the diaspora feel afraid. We have to deal with that, but can we also agree that a lot of Iranian dissidents who hate this regime also object to the bombing by the United ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0cae6f7192dc9e90579c294","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331848,"date":"2026-03-10T03:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I made many of those points as well when I spoke earlier this evening, because it is clear that this is an illegal war, but we are put with a false choice that if we do not oppose an illegal war, we are somehow just giving in and abandoning the brave people of Iran who are fighting against a brutal regime.\n\nDoes the hon. leader of the NDP not believe we can do both: work hard to protect and stand in solidarity with the brave people of Iran, and denounce an illegal and reckless war undertaken by the United States and Israel?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331848","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I made many of those points as well when I spoke earlier this evening, because it is clear that this is an illegal war, but we are put with a false choice that if we do not oppose an illegal war, we are somehow just giving in and abandoning the brave people of Iran who are fighting against a brutal regime.\n\nDoes the hon. leader of the NDP not believe we can do both: work hard to protect","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c32758a3de2144b2ada9bd017f877baa78c263915966476b921caede5ce0978a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4de9dedcb47c12c01a04ae9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331827,"date":"2026-03-10T15:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to present a petition about an issue my constituents are concerned about, but the issue is actually on the other side of the country and relates to a proposed project that will affect the Tantramar marsh that is on the Chignecto Isthmus. For those who are not familiar with the Chignecto Isthmus, it is the very low-lying land mass that connects the rest of Nova Scotia to the mainland of Canada. It is under extreme threat from climate change.\n\n Since the 1980s, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change identified that this area was particularly vulnerable to sea level rise. In other words, we could lose Nova Scotia's connection by land to the rest of Canada, which would have a multi-billion-dollar impact for sure.\n\n The petitioners note that there is currently a project that is moving toward federal approval for the Centre Village, New Brunswick, gas plant under the company's name, Proenergy, the RIGS project. Given the significance of this area, in terms of both its biodiversity and its critical importance to Nova Scotia and all of Canada, the petitioners are calling for a full independent environmental and climate impact assessment under the Impact Assessment Act, and for the designation of the Chignecto Isthmus, including the Tantramar marsh, as a federally protected area. They are also looking for enforcement of all the laws that protect the biodiversity and the ecosystems of this area.\n\nMembers will remember Bill Casey, who used to be the member of Parliament for that area. He raised this issue frequently as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331827","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to present a petition about an issue my constituents are concerned about, but the issue is actually on the other side of the country and relates to a proposed project that will affect the Tantramar marsh that is on the Chignecto Isthmus. For those who are not familiar with the Chignecto Isthmus, it is the very low-lying land mass that connects the rest of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ff663d4943d972a404dafb367d8c1bf7ea0c328d83aa26d12624c3235cdb1f8a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dcf294928cd515c625b577704397747f75c305a48399edcc99dc7b95ac37eeb5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-612e19b9fb3562f842bb38b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331828,"date":"2026-03-10T15:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to address the hon. minister on the matter before us right now, which is shutting down debate on Bill C-9, rather than the details within Bill C-9. I think the bill needs much more debate and discussion, which is why I hope the government will withdraw the attempt at closure on Bill C-9 before we have had an opportunity to discuss it properly.\n\nI know the minister will say it was stuck at clause-by-clause. In this case, I will absolutely agree that the Conservatives were obstructing in the committee on Bill C-9. They have been so routinely accused of filibustering and obstructing when they have not that I feel it is worthwhile pointing out, in this one instance, that there has been an attempt to slow down Bill C-9.\n\nI find much of the bill objectionable. Certainly, the International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group, in its brief to the minister, has pointed out how the intimidation and disruption sections are overly broad and create a really large risk of discretionary enforcement by police that will leave people who are engaged in lawful exercise of their democratic rights and free speech on the wrong side of a law that is vague and discretionary.\n\nI urge the minister to please reconsider and withdraw the motion under debate at the moment so we can have a full discussion and debate, which is what Parliament is for.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331828","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to address the hon. minister on the matter before us right now, which is shutting down debate on Bill C-9, rather than the details within Bill C-9. I think the bill needs much more debate and discussion, which is why I hope the government will withdraw the attempt at closure on Bill C-9 before we have had an opportunity to discuss it properly.\n\nI know the minister will say it w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66b1d660b3abc07bcabb0723babf43da3b410d34576b4815c9e83a0635eaef84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e7df48f2afdd1538d9a924cd86bd5f285afb943af45d0551612d9c2600b7d9cd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-646eb6f3a2641e39c7e8ff66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331829,"date":"2026-03-10T18:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am struggling with Bill C-9 because I think the definitions are so vague and there is so much discretion that the bill may not survive court challenges later.\n\nDoes the hon. member not think it would be better to take the time here to debate it and get the bill right than to see it defeated in the court later?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331829","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am struggling with Bill C-9 because I think the definitions are so vague and there is so much discretion that the bill may not survive court challenges later.\n\nDoes the hon. member not think it would be better to take the time here to debate it and get the bill right than to see it defeated in the court later?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd30bf100a78689c4eb1875b5796bc1b8ffe4e633b470f47494ad9d99a861b27"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f98e8fbaa7efa7073b10189a41483c75ce08563bdb221404a32a3b58042dc9b0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0269efba02a40299d7b5b7ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331830,"date":"2026-03-10T21:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I just want a chance to ask the hon. member if he is aware that it is not just the Conservatives who do not like the bill. The Greens will vote against it as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331830","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I just want a chance to ask the hon. member if he is aware that it is not just the Conservatives who do not like the bill. The Greens will vote against it as well.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba7441d07422d53229527e6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331824,"date":"2026-03-11T21:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, of course, most Canadians know AtkinsRéalis by its original name of SNC-Lavalin. It is the now disgraced company that is so corrupt it cannot do business anywhere in the world after bribing Gadhafi's family to get a contract. We also know that AtkinsRéalis got the deal of deals when Harper sold it all of AECL for $17 million. Now, using the name of Canadian Nuclear Laboratories, it masquerades as having real technology for small modular reactors that do not exist anywhere.\n\n Can the parliamentary secretary possibly justify why we are throwing billions of dollars into this without a single day of debate in this place about nuclear technology?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331824","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, of course, most Canadians know AtkinsRéalis by its original name of SNC-Lavalin. It is the now disgraced company that is so corrupt it cannot do business anywhere in the world after bribing Gadhafi's family to get a contract. We also know that AtkinsRéalis got the deal of deals when Harper sold it all of AECL for $17 million. Now, using the name of Canadian Nuclear Laboratories, it ma","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","label":"Nuclear technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","label":"Nuclear technology","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ef2909a6de34c2bee9d98ded229977b34d7f6fca851f227fc864877970647e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["763d0390a00799c4055d116bb3ba064b2020d39fbae58eb2e8a2f1e13e7578f0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106294","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40475a31fe7eb1adc2c4855b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331825,"date":"2026-03-11T22:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a question for my colleague from Saint‐Hyacinthe—Bagot—Acton. As he knows, I am very concerned about trade agreements that include investor-state dispute settlement mechanisms.\n\nThat gives rights to foreign companies, like the Indonesian company Paper Excellence for example, which bought the vast majority of pulp and paper companies across Canada, particularly in Quebec with Resolute.\n\nUnder this agreement, Paper Excellence would have the right to sue the government if the government implements environmental protection measures or measures to protect unions and workers. Does my colleague agree?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331825","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a question for my colleague from Saint‐Hyacinthe—Bagot—Acton. As he knows, I am very concerned about trade agreements that include investor-state dispute settlement mechanisms.\n\nThat gives rights to foreign companies, like the Indonesian company Paper Excellence for example, which bought the vast majority of pulp and paper companies across Canada, particularly in Quebec with Re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e4fa48238ac54a09cdc14e70df752286062350842bbcbb55d064280ecedda730"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d726b8a8d91546a98fe08e209efc874096517c46e31f20b3c7a7d54aa2f8a01"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89cb285c49b10ce27cecfa75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331826,"date":"2026-03-11T22:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the question I asked earlier to the Bloc Québécois, to my friend from Saint-Hyacinthe—Bagot—Acton, was specifically about an Indonesian company that has bought up most of Canada's pulp and paper mills. It is called Paper Excellence. This agreement, and its investor-state agreements, will limit our ability to regulate to protect our forests and those jobs. Does the hon. member not agree?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331826","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the question I asked earlier to the Bloc Québécois, to my friend from Saint-Hyacinthe—Bagot—Acton, was specifically about an Indonesian company that has bought up most of Canada's pulp and paper mills. It is called Paper Excellence. This agreement, and its investor-state agreements, will limit our ability to regulate to protect our forests and those jobs. Does the hon. member not agre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15a3f326fe53dc9f16627496a1c314be4017df82d8215da46c34add24fe04365"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca4de7835c4cb754fa29d60839492b1b67f35046934468aac33c8bc6a73395a0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25d9ad5a1bab4995b51f5644","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331815,"date":"2026-03-12T15:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise on behalf of constituents of Saanich—Gulf Islands on an issue that remains one that I know many members of this place would agree is a national crisis, and that is that we continue to see far too many deaths from opioids, by what are essentially fentanyl poisonings. \n\nI want to particularly pay tribute to one of my constituents, Leslie McBain, who lost her son in that crisis and is one of the founders of an extraordinary group of bereaved parents called Moms Stop the Harm. The petitioners are asking the government to consider that it is ineffective to treat those suffering from drug abuse as criminals. They are people in need of medical assistance and mental health supports to help deal with addiction. In other words, incarceration and treating this as a criminal matter has been ineffective, and rehabilitation through treatment programs is urgently needed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331815","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise on behalf of constituents of Saanich—Gulf Islands on an issue that remains one that I know many members of this place would agree is a national crisis, and that is that we continue to see far too many deaths from opioids, by what are essentially fentanyl poisonings. \n\nI want to particularly pay tribute to one of my constituents, Leslie McBain, who lost her son ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["883ac6c88ac59f024ae536dd6dc048586829aa31e16811aa48ed39413059c03b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1d28d320c9dcaae81410529604b10fa4bd3821eb97acaf735f4d204fb58ed798"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2855c1de3380ecdc75adc377","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331816,"date":"2026-03-12T15:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am so disappointed that the government is not willing to consider sober second thought, having put forward such a scandalous abuse of omnibus budget bills as is found in Bill C-4.\n\nWhat we have in Bill C-4, which is titled the affordability act, are many measures that are mostly about affordability, but magically, there is this bizarre inclusion of amendments to the Canada Elections Act.\n\nPart 4 of this bill contains amendments to the Canada Elections Act. What does the Canada Elections Act have to do with the cost of living?\n\nIt is not just bizarre that we find in part 4 of Bill C-4, which is the affordability act, unaccountably, changes to the Canada Elections Act. The content of those changes is, and I will use the word again, scandalous. Canadians will be scandalized, and it is unfortunate that the way of going in this Parliament has been for things to be passed so quickly that people do not even know what they have passed.\n\nPart 4 of Bill C-4 is all about one thing: removing any thought that there is any requirement on the part of any federal political party in this country to protect the personal private information of Canadians. The bill is a bit of overkill, one might say. At one point in part 4 of Bill C-4, it says that any of the provisions for protection of privacy are \"deemed never to have come into force and is repealed.\" \n\nIf they were deemed never to have come into force, I suppose it is a bit of overkill to also make sure they are repealed, but it gets worse. The bill then says that part 4 of Bill C-4 will come into force in the year 2000. \n\nI remember the day this bill was tabled in June. I took around the hard copy of Bill C-4 to various friends on the side of the House of the Liberal Party and said, \"Look at this. Why does this bill have to come into force in the year 2000?\" People would say that it must be a typo, and I would say, \"No, that is not a typo, my friend. That is a time machine.\"\n\nI have never seen before in this place that a bill in the future tense would come into force 26 years ago.\n\nThere is nothing extraordinary about the fact that there are things I have never seen before.\n\nI am not the only one who has never seen this.\n\nHowever, for the moment, this is a part of the bill that strikes me as odd.\n\nThe Senate looked at it and asked why, buried in the affordability act, there were amendments to the Elections Act. It is all well and good that, in the preamble the Speaker just read, the government says it is sending this back to the Senate and that they have no business in this, letting them slap them on the wrist for thinking they can presume to tell anybody in this place about the Elections Act, but the government had this coming and was well overdue to start looking at sections of omnibus bills. I think it is scandalous that we did not.\n\nI know a lot of senators were disturbed by Bill C-12. They looked at Bill C-12 in committee, and they said that it had not been properly studied and that it would abuse the rights of refugees, but they held back. They thought that the government would not want to accept their amendments, so they did not make amendments, but they did put on the record that a subcommittee was concerned. \n\nIt would have been tough for the Senate to make amendments because the pressure was on them to not make amendments. In fact, the leader of the government in the Senate went so far as to misstate to other senators that Bill C-4 had been carried unanimously in this place.\n\nI noticed they were careful in the preamble we just heard to refer to unanimous support from recognized parties. The Liberals, the Conservatives and the Bloc were happy to carry this unanimously, but my objections were recorded on the record, even in the so-called unanimous consent motion. It says, \"that the opposition of the member for Saanich—Gulf Islands be noted\". \n\nWhy do I dig in my heels? Why do I say hurrah for the senators who put forward some common-sense amendments? What is wrong with the government that it will not accept the Senate amendments?\n\nIf one has not looked at the Senate amendments, standing by what I have said, it is extraordinary that the Government of Canada would say it is bringing into effect a bill that would take effect 26 years ago. What kind of offence has the Liberal Party committed in the last 26 years that would require a time machine to say that laws that we might have had to protect the personal information of Canadians did not ever exist, were never carried and, on top of that, took effect in the year 2000?\n\n The Senate amendment just says that three years from when Bill C-4 takes effect, three years from now, the government must come up with a way of protecting the personal and private information of Canadians held by federal political parties.\n\nThis was not that long ago, so I will cite the source, but there was an iPolitics news story from March 3 of this year where the leader of the government in the House, and of course I will not say his name but we know it, said, after citing that he was the former national director of the Liberal Party, \"I can assure you that, for our part, and I assume all parties follow the same basic standard, we essentially comply with PIPEDA\", referring to the acronym for the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act.\n\nThere is currently a court case in British Columbia because the privacy commissioner for British Columbia has said that this is a matter of law. Provincial political parties in British Columbia have to abide by the protection of privacy information for Canadians.\n\nWe know that there was a study before the ethics committee back in 2018. The study was entitled \"Breach of Personal Information Involving Cambridge Analytica and Facebook\".\n\nThat particular case study should make us, as parliamentarians, and as people who believe in democracy, deeply concerned that the personal and private information of Canadians can be misused in the hands of those who develop systems, such as Cambridge Analytica did, to target, use algorithms, distort and deliver information that is misinformation directed to particular people who are likely to believe, as they are pre-inclined and predisposed to believe, that misinformation. In that case, in that study, the committee pointed to the need of protecting the personal information of Canadians held by federal political parties. \n\nI will not disagree with the government for one minute, but it would be far better to not bury in an omnibus bill on affordability the taking away of rights regarding the personal and private information of Canadians held by federal political parties. It would be far better to be open about it and say that they are going to amend the Canada Elections Act and talk about the personal and private information of Canadians.\n\nI think the government should be ashamed. Every Liberal, and every floor crosser who has joined this gang, should be ashamed of being associated with a piece of subterfuge as vile as saying that this is an act on affordability, to not look over there at part 4, that it has nothing to do with us, that it is something they are doing about privacy information and they are making sure that it took effect 26 years ago.\n\nIf they had nothing to be ashamed of, why would they not bring forward a bill that, on its own, is about updating the Canada Elections Act and that clearly asks Canadians what they want us to do with their personal and private information, those of us who are federal political parties? Certainly, the Green Party tries very hard to abide by all the personal and private information protections, as though the law already applied to us clearly, and we will continue to do so.\n\nThis is an abomination. This is a very reasonable amendment from the Senate that, three years from now, once the bill is passed, we would have a better plan of action. The government's motion today said it is planning to bring forward something soon. Will that be sooner than three years from now?\n\nHow can the government possibly object to an amendment from the Senate that says to get its act in order within the next three years? We should, in this place, absolutely refuse to accept the government's advice to reject Senate amendments. If there ever was a time for sober second thought, it is now. This is embarrassing. Are all recognized parties, the Conservatives, the Liberals and the Bloc, okay with passing a law that turns the clock back 26 years? Come on. This is embarrassing. I ask members to please accept the Senate amendments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331816","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am so disappointed that the government is not willing to consider sober second thought, having put forward such a scandalous abuse of omnibus budget bills as is found in Bill C-4.\n\nWhat we have in Bill C-4, which is titled the affordability act, are many measures that are mostly about affordability, but magically, there is this bizarre inclusion of amendments to the Canada Elections","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ef730f38a2842e6dda9bc5cbbbf5eb7353cebe7a61691f5ac5c0984043dd0d7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e23391ab0f63a604dba8fcc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331817,"date":"2026-03-12T17:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to truly thank my colleague for his speech on investor-state dispute settlement. I actually think that things are worse than how he described them in his speech. My colleague said that large transnational corporations currently have the right to take part in agreements, but it is worse than that. They currently have more rights than Canada does in such agreements.\n\nCould my colleague comment on the fact that trade agreements do not always have to include an investor-state dispute settlement mechanism?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331817","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to truly thank my colleague for his speech on investor-state dispute settlement. I actually think that things are worse than how he described them in his speech. My colleague said that large transnational corporations currently have the right to take part in agreements, but it is worse than that. They currently have more rights than Canada does in such agreements.\n\nCould ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b47ed142e1a322bea1c7290dfdbb1ead9f62e2d7dd6f389fb333e67c1667233"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9b91d1df7e3669de3f704fd366a0f91f92bf329e71312491abb5404a6ac72c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f5eb51049059c60afb897d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331818,"date":"2026-03-12T20:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague from Edmonton Manning for raising the issue I have also been working on for years on behalf of British pensioners within Saanich—Gulf Islands.\n\nThere have been many years and many missed opportunities to try to negotiate with the British government on how it indexes the pension for Canadian expats. It does not make sense, and as the member rightly pointed out, it is a cost to the Canadian economy. It is also a needless worry to wonderful people. I am sure that each member in their own riding has had people come see them about this unfairness.\n\nI carried with me a stack of petitions to try to hand directly to Boris Johnson when I went to a COP in Glasgow, and I had the help of my hon. colleague. I will not say his riding name because it will take too long, but we tried really hard to hand it directly to the Prime Minister of the U.K. so we could say that this is so unfair.\n\nWhat do we do now? This agreement is in front of us. What can we all do collectively to push the government to get a proper deal with the U.K. government to defend our pensioners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331818","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague from Edmonton Manning for raising the issue I have also been working on for years on behalf of British pensioners within Saanich—Gulf Islands.\n\nThere have been many years and many missed opportunities to try to negotiate with the British government on how it indexes the pension for Canadian expats. It does not make sense, and as the member rightly po","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["39db73509f9b06bd019d774877e35bc61fedcf2910498d9466377c7dbfad6a02"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e82ead28e5b9a030e62fb75397522c3ce18a261f70f7d543e7c7f8b56f8b6012"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b7f12d8de34c6b22a717baf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331819,"date":"2026-03-12T20:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the hon. parliamentary secretary for splitting his time with me.\n\nThis is an alphabet soup, as people have mentioned. It is sometimes hard to see why the U.K. is suddenly joining the CPTPP and why we are discussing it today, but there are overlays and previous trade agreements. Perhaps something of a narrative might work to quickly review how we got to where we are today, and then I can highlight the concerns the Green Party has about it.\n\nThe trans-Pacific partnership agreement started quite a long time ago. As others have mentioned, there is a long list of countries that were initially involved, all of course in the Pacific region. There is Singapore, Malaysia and Japan, but then there are ones we do not necessarily expect, such as Peru as well as Canada and New Zealand. Of course, one of the instigators of the original trans-Pacific partnership agreement was the United States. However, back in President Trump's first term in 2017, he pulled the U.S. out of the trans-Pacific partnership. \n\nGoing back to Canada's trade relationships with the U.K., this is obviously not the first or even the most important of Canada's trade agreements with the U.K. Again, this goes back to trade agreements that countries enter into, and then when somebody pulls out, the pieces have to sort of reassemble. \n\nLooking back at Canada's first trade agreement with the U.K., it was when the U.K. was part of the European Union, before the very tragic events that led to Brexit. For the U.K., and indeed the European Union, it was dreadful, with the skullduggery, the use of algorithms and social media, Cambridge Analytica and the sort. \n\nThere is a tremendous documentary for people who want to see how vulnerable our democracies are to the misuse of social media and those kinds of campaigns. It is called Brexit: The Uncivil War. I am not going to give a whole film review, but it does star Benedict Cumberbatch, in case anyone wants to look it up on Netflix. Members can watch it, and for parliamentarians or someone who runs for elected office, it may leave them feeling quite shaken about how vulnerable we are to misinformation and how the British public was misled into pulling out of not just a very good trade agreement but a governance agreement within the European Union that had a lot of benefit for the U.K., and that also had benefit for the European Union when the U.K. was in it.\n\nCanada's first trade deal with the U.K., back to this particular piece, was the Canada-European Union Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement, which was negotiated between Canada and the EU. Of course, part of the EU at that time was the U.K. Therefore, we had a lot of pre-existing negotiations and conversations, and then there was the TPP, which was negotiated without the U.K. but with the U.S.\n\nWhat are the differences between these two agreements? Do they entirely overlap since we already negotiated them? We went back once the U.K. left the European Union, and Canada renegotiated the bits we needed so that Canada would continue to have a trade deal with the U.K. once the U.K. left the European Union. That got done. We have an existing trade agreement with the U.K., which is still called the comprehensive economic and trade agreement, but between Canada and the U.K. It is largely based on the previous agreement that was done with the European Union. Now we have the TPP and the CPTPP, which is without the United States but with the U.K. \n\nWhy do I go through all this other than to remind people of the threads they may have heard before? It is because there are differences between these agreements, and one is less advantageous to Canada and Canada's environment than the other. Both the CPTPP, which we are debating today, and the comprehensive economic and trade agreement, the CETA, include things called investor-state dispute settlement mechanisms. \n\nThe hon. member for Saint-Hyacinthe—Bagot—Acton has been the most engaged on this subject as we continue to debate it. I certainly agree with him and have always supported any efforts Canada can make to get out of such lopsided agreements, which inevitably, invariably and always give superior rights to foreign corporations investing in Canada or operating in Canada. Even if they do not invest, they can open up a post office box somewhere and be considered an investor. \n\nPrivate sector corporations are bestowed with rights under investor-state dispute resolution mechanisms and agreements, the very first of which, by the way, we are now out of, which was chapter 11 of NAFTA, which ironically did not survive into the new negotiations when it became CUSMA. I am very glad chapter 11 of NAFTA is no more, but it was a prototype. Here is what it did. It said that if what a government does to a foreign corporation can be considered tantamount to expropriation, then that foreign corporation can sue the country in which it is operating. We have had S.D. Myers sue Canada. We had Ethyl Corporation of Richmond, Virginia, sue Canada.\n\n Canada tends to lose on these challenges. Not only does Canada lose, but in general, the larger economic power wins. It is not always the corporation that wins, but if a U.S. corporation sues a government and the U.S. corporation is a giant, the U.S. corporation will win. If a Canadian corporation sues the U.S, the Canadian corporation will lose. There is a pattern. The larger economic power tends to win. The arbitrators are drawn from a rank of four. They are operating, $500 an hour, $1,000 an hour, lawyer kinds of people. The investor-state dispute resolution mechanisms, as has been established through numerous global studies, tend to favour the larger economic power.\n\nIt was a shocker when it first happened. This means that decisions and laws passed democratically by governments, whether at the provincial or federal level, could be overturned by secret tribunals run by for-profit secret lawyers who make a case and argue that something was done that cost the corporation money. They do not even have to allege that it was done with animus or that it was discriminatory towards that country or nation or corporation, just that it cost them money. For example changing the regulations to protect the environment or changing the regulations to protect workers, if it costs them money, the Government of Canada is going to pay out and pay a company from the U.S, which has happened to Canada an unfortunate number of times.\n\nAs we negotiate and discuss this agreement today, the CPTPP, it includes investor-state dispute resolution mechanisms that are of an order that is slightly less fair and slightly less transparent than similar agreements that were negotiated with the European Union under the CETA. Between the two, they both have investor-state dispute resolution mechanisms, but the one we are debating today, to which we are adding the U.K. and which means U.K. corporations will be able to sue Canada under the CPTPP, just as we are now allowing Peruvian or, more likely, Canadian companies to sue Peru if we are mining in their country and do not like the laws to which we are being subjected, will have less transparency than if we were working under the CETA. This is because there were enough elements that the European Union refused to pass the CETA as long as these investor-state dispute resolution measures were included.\n\nI do not have much time left to wrap up my speech so I will end by saying that it is too late at this point to renegotiate and remove the investor-state dispute settlement mechanism.\n\nHowever, it is time to shine a light on them and decide that henceforth Canada should get out of agreements that allow foreign corporations to have more power to sue the Canadian government, a province, a first nation or a municipality, for that matter. These agreements are corrosive to democracy. It is time to shine a light on them and start carving them out. It has now become routine with trade deals to throw in investor-state dispute resolutions. They are noxious.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331819","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the hon. parliamentary secretary for splitting his time with me.\n\nThis is an alphabet soup, as people have mentioned. It is sometimes hard to see why the U.K. is suddenly joining the CPTPP and why we are discussing it today, but there are overlays and previous trade agreements. Perhaps something of a narrative might work to quickly review how we got to where we are tod","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1227858838cab9691f0a11796529629666d98e97bfc3596be42db1d5f87656f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f1434fcfa4733a2f5856594d87e0049f050dd63a76a30f1c680a5010d32669a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11d872703638a62d7d3fa4fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331820,"date":"2026-03-12T20:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I can tell the hon. colleague from York—Durham that, for an absolute fact, there is absolutely nothing illegal about things the Canadian government has done for which we have ended up having to shell out money.\n\nAs for being secret, I recommend that the member have a look at the Canada investment promotion and protection agreement with the People's Republic of China, which must remain entirely secret throughout the entire tribunal. The results may be made public by Canada at the end, but the fact of a challenge by the People's Republic of China against the Canadian government is secret and must remain secret. We are bound to it for 35 years without ever having had a vote in the House, because it was approved by Stephen Harper's cabinet.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331820","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I can tell the hon. colleague from York—Durham that, for an absolute fact, there is absolutely nothing illegal about things the Canadian government has done for which we have ended up having to shell out money.\n\nAs for being secret, I recommend that the member have a look at the Canada investment promotion and protection agreement with the People's Republic of China, which must remain","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["04c2423d13ade7fd5f644ed3ddeb634051f736b66d6030d06086157ae96d7a09"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["def9ae0de316667af4b511e4c6b8de3583ba5fa901f7f13929dc5de6704fa63a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4537432eef6ab5e0c51cf1d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331821,"date":"2026-03-12T20:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I wholeheartedly agree with my colleague, because the problem is that the major parties here, in this Parliament, despite their many political differences, all share the same high regard for big multinational companies, big oil and big pharma.\n\nBig oil and big banks get the respect of Liberals and Conservatives always, regardless of who is leading the parties, which is at the base of giving them superior rights to Canadian corporations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331821","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I wholeheartedly agree with my colleague, because the problem is that the major parties here, in this Parliament, despite their many political differences, all share the same high regard for big multinational companies, big oil and big pharma.\n\nBig oil and big banks get the respect of Liberals and Conservatives always, regardless of who is leading the parties, which is at the base of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bfc2c59e6550039c2a36d5d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331822,"date":"2026-03-12T20:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as with all our policies, the member can find it online. We support trade that is respectful of environmental protections, indigenous rights and labour rights, in other words, fair trade.\n\n In fact, for the record, we voted for the Canada-Ukraine trade deal when every single Conservative voted against it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331822","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as with all our policies, the member can find it online. We support trade that is respectful of environmental protections, indigenous rights and labour rights, in other words, fair trade.\n\n In fact, for the record, we voted for the Canada-Ukraine trade deal when every single Conservative voted against it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Internet","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","label":"Internet","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69cb49fb6ea4fe005046dd50649fdc68c56480abda60faf634bc591c05b99e60"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7cb8ebc85f0e0e1bf69bf1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331823,"date":"2026-03-12T21:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will just quickly dispute the notion that we have brought more money into protest groups than Canada paid out. Canada paid out $8 million for a perfectly legal decision rendered by the federal Minister of Environment, John Baird at the time, and the Progressive Conservative provincial Minister of Environment for Nova Scotia. Bilcon of Delaware got away with murder and took our money.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331823","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will just quickly dispute the notion that we have brought more money into protest groups than Canada paid out. Canada paid out $8 million for a perfectly legal decision rendered by the federal Minister of Environment, John Baird at the time, and the Progressive Conservative provincial Minister of Environment for Nova Scotia. Bilcon of Delaware got away with murder and took our money","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b686a7e889341e8b68d4e332a879dfc593d85a23194968388b5a08171a57be2f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cc53b78f1ad45d8e84f4c21","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":331814,"date":"2026-03-13T17:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present a petition virtually today.\n\nThe petitioners expressed deep concern for the historic wrongs and injustices done to indigenous peoples by settler culture Canadians over the experience of colonization. To summarize, they specifically call on the government to follow through on the many long-overdue promises to implement the calls to action from the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the calls for justice from the missing and murdered indigenous women and girls commission, and to follow closely our commitments under the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. It is a timely petition.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:331814","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present a petition virtually today.\n\nThe petitioners expressed deep concern for the historic wrongs and injustices done to indigenous peoples by settler culture Canadians over the experience of colonization. To summarize, they specifically call on the government to follow through on the many long-overdue promises to implement the calls to action from the Truth and R","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ef243b875b8dcfc851e7f53653336e7df3b3e253df2b340c4c58e057e758a07f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["14e08cb7118c1ddb30ad00f6b784fd46118b9a6e58e6459f1fbdc8ee19b18995"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7036389ba456c7024dbef74","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372789,"date":"2026-03-23T18:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-9, the anti-hate bill. I will start by saying that I hate the bill. I do not know if that is a good thing or a bad thing. Actually, I try not to hold hatred in my heart for any person, but I think when one sees really bad legislation, it is okay to hate it. This is really bad legislation because it has provoked a debate that pits people who should totally agree against each other. All of us in this place, whether Liberals, Conservatives, Bloc members or New Democrats, want to see an end to hatred in this country. We all see every day the dramatic increase in acts of hatred and anti-Semitism, particularly Islamophobia. It is racism. It is despicable. We stand against it, but Bill C-9 has gotten in the way in a way that ties us in knots and is making it more difficult to use the tools we already have, such as section 319 of the Criminal Code.\n\nI will back up and say that I looked for the most recent statement, because there have been some amendments. I appreciate the amendment that says we would need the approval of an Attorney General to prosecute under this act, but that would not remedy the many faults of the bill. I looked for the most recent press release from the Canadian Civil Liberties Association to make sure its views had not changed as a result of recent amendments. It says this very clearly, and I am going to quote from their most recent release:\n\nAntisemitism, Islamophobia, and racism are on the rise. Communities across this country are worried, and they deserve protection. But Bill C-9 doesn't solve this complex issue. Instead, it hands the government a blunt instrument that history tells us will be turned against the very people it's supposed to help.\n\n Let me speak to what this is talking about. I oppose Bill C-9. Yes, I am a practising Christian, and yes, I believe that the sacred texts of the Quran, the Torah or Bible are religious texts. They are not hate speech, but that is not my big problem with this bill, because I think it is very unlikely, no matter what anyone might say for partisan reasons, that anybody in the Liberal Party wants to prosecute a preacher. That is nonsense. What we are dealing with here, though, is a bill that is so unnecessary that it would create new risks, through vagueness and discretion. These could create real problems that would end up before the courts and get in the way of making sure we have the proper tools to prosecute hate crimes with the laws we already have.\n\nWhy do we have Bill C-9? Normally a bill of this weirdness would come because the courts had said something and the government felt compelled. \n\nExcuse me, Mr. Speaker. I have to adjust. The corner I am in is really difficult. I am sorry. I did not mean to complain about the furniture in the middle of a speech.\n\nNormally something like this that appears to be redundant, discretionary and confusing would come about because the Supreme Court has said something criticizing an existing law so that the Department of Justice tries to clarify the law with yet another law on the same subject. However, this is the opposite. The Supreme Court of Canada has already, in numerous decisions, dealt with the big problem that we have. When we are defining hate, when we say hate speech is a crime and when we say there is an identifiable group against whom this speech is directed, we might have this problem, something the courts identify and numerous people identify: What about the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, what about our right to free speech, what about our right to worship as we choose and what about the right of freedom of assembly?\n\nI am now referring to section 319 of the Criminal Code against acts of hate. Do these criminal acts of hate conflict with the Charter of Rights and Freedoms? Thankfully, in the Keegstra case, in a couple of places, the Supreme Court of Canada has dealt with this. Law enforcement, lawyers and judges across the country have a pathway to know that they can prosecute hate crimes under the Criminal Code and not defy the charter. The Supreme Court of Canada has ruled on this, and its rulings are clear. Unfortunately, Bill C-9 is not clear. Bill C-9 would create a whole new discretionary web of things that may or may not be criminal.\n\nI just want to refer briefly to a personal experience I had awhile ago. It was back in 2006. I was not in Parliament. I attended a rally to decry what was then happening. Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose. Israel was bombing Lebanon in an attempt to hit Hezbollah, and Hezbollah was bombing in Israel. I was at a peace rally in Toronto. I was on the back of a flatbed truck. I remember that Judy Rebick was standing with me. I denounced Hezbollah for shooting rockets into Israel. I also denounced the use of rockets from Israel that were hitting civilian targets in Lebanon.\n\nAfter the rally, it came to my attention through social media that someone had gotten a photograph of me; I had not known about a Hezbollah flag behind me. I would not have recognized the Hezbollah flag if I had fallen into it, but as it was, it was behind me. I did not know it was there. It was clearly a hate symbol. However, not knowing it was there, I equally would not have known, standing there on the back of a flatbed truck, how close I was to a place of worship, a day care centre or a cemetery. I would have had no idea.\n\nWhen I first read Bill C-9, I thought it was definitely going to impede freedom of assembly and rightful protest. It was going to be very confusing. How will law enforcement deal with a gathering in which a group of people spill onto a side street and do not realize that they might be impeding access to a church they did not know was there? As a lawyer, a civil libertarian and more than an occasional protester, I look at this bill with alarm. It is going to create a lot of confusion and potentially wrongful arrests.\n\nIt has been referenced by some of my hon. colleagues on the Conservative benches that not only does every major religious group in this country express concerns about Bill C-9, but so do the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and the Black Legal Action Centre. I particularly noted the brief to the committee from the International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group, which includes groups from around the world expressing concern. We are seeing intrusions on civil liberties; they referenced particularly what we are seeing in the United States, with the U.S. administration's immigration and enforcement group, known as ICE, trampling on civil liberties. It is saying that a person was about to do something, that a person had hate in their heart or whatever. The International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group told our parliamentary committee that Canada must be very careful. We should not create offences that can be misunderstood. We should not make openings to have an overreach by law enforcement.\n\nWe are seeing, in many countries around the world, overreach by law enforcement. They are anticipating something that I hope we never see in Canada. Although I will say that the so-called industrial resource community group of the RCMP in British Columbia, which is cracking down on non-violent civil disobedience to protect old-growth forests, has frequently violated the charter. I look to them as a worrying example.\n\nBill C-9 would not solve problems of hate crimes, and it would not give law enforcement new tools. Not only that, but it would create a morass. I am absolutely certain that if this law passes as is, it would waste police resources, waste court time and tie people up in knots in wrongful prosecutions for things that were never hate crimes at all.\n\nWith that, I will vote against the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372789","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-9, the anti-hate bill. I will start by saying that I hate the bill. I do not know if that is a good thing or a bad thing. Actually, I try not to hold hatred in my heart for any person, but I think when one sees really bad legislation, it is okay to hate it. This is really bad legislation because it has provoked a debate that pits people who should total","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e22120078af48c8cb22aa6008f25b8e6f0032c1b956337b10f6e2b986b51eefb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3bc90f7f909b3adacf638f39896dc98c93f8f2ec3c2df90f82ca97ab8e5e207a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e6ebefd26c66f1e397c6a60e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372790,"date":"2026-03-23T18:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am not in receipt of Conservative fundraising emails, but I will say this: At this point in the history of our Parliament, we need to come together more and not seek reasons to divide. While I decry the use of partisan clickbait, I also decry notions about anyone in this country, regardless of their political party, faith or lack of faith. I am a practising Christian, but I praise all those atheists because, by God, they are great citizens too. We need to come together, and we need to defeat this bill and use section 319 to stop hate crimes, not—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372790","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am not in receipt of Conservative fundraising emails, but I will say this: At this point in the history of our Parliament, we need to come together more and not seek reasons to divide. While I decry the use of partisan clickbait, I also decry notions about anyone in this country, regardless of their political party, faith or lack of faith. I am a practising Christian, but I praise a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-502656b9d6c0e6130532dcc2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372791,"date":"2026-03-23T18:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate where my hon. colleague is coming from, but no. As a fierce opposition party leader and someone who has deep concerns about the direction of the current government, I would say that it does not have an anti-faith group approach, absolutely not. The Prime Minister is a practising Catholic. I compared notes with him about what we have both given up for Lent. \n\nLet us stop thinking that anyone has anything against faith-based groups and work to defend every Canadian's ability, to the best of our ability, to live out their place in this life, for whatever purposes they see in this life. Let us do so for the good of all and stop finding reasons to divide us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372791","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate where my hon. colleague is coming from, but no. As a fierce opposition party leader and someone who has deep concerns about the direction of the current government, I would say that it does not have an anti-faith group approach, absolutely not. The Prime Minister is a practising Catholic. I compared notes with him about what we have both given up for Lent. \n\nLet us stop t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d03cc1770644188c775331d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372792,"date":"2026-03-23T18:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the hon. member for Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong and I did have a personal conversation recently, in which she told me that people thought she should be in jail for that. For any speech, obviously, that would be appalling, and I hope the comments she related to me were meant not in earnest, but offhand, and that the members who might have said that deeply regret it, because it is offensive. \n\nAs to the prayer breakfast and dinner, I will be there tonight, and I imagine a lot of us will be doing both.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372792","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the hon. member for Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong and I did have a personal conversation recently, in which she told me that people thought she should be in jail for that. For any speech, obviously, that would be appalling, and I hope the comments she related to me were meant not in earnest, but offhand, and that the members who might have said that deeply regret it, because it is offensi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e22237ac6bb1efdded89032ea07d493c105bd44056a3664c782d22a5a3424e78"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8fe1afddeaff95ba41465c58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372793,"date":"2026-03-23T18:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have made it clear to the parliamentary secretary before that it would already be a hate crime to direct hatred and acts of hatred toward individuals or an identifiable group, whether they are practising a faith or are identifiable through other means. \n\nThe legislation is poorly drafted, and I think the government members will rue the day they force it through.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372793","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have made it clear to the parliamentary secretary before that it would already be a hate crime to direct hatred and acts of hatred toward individuals or an identifiable group, whether they are practising a faith or are identifiable through other means. \n\nThe legislation is poorly drafted, and I think the government members will rue the day they force it through.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87a7f637a6d9cf9c97e92b8a88b7f2cca6935787d440fca7c9fdd69371f9faec"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41fe7875b06567d249cb2599","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372794,"date":"2026-03-23T20:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise on behalf of the many residents of Saanich—Gulf Islands who raise the issue again of the climate crisis.\n\nIn this context, the petitioners ask the House of Commons to recognize that the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has recognized how much the climate crisis accentuates and increases the societal divides globally, with the global south bearing much of the cost and the burden of climate events, and the urgent need for action to try to avoid more than 100 million people being pushed into poverty as a result of the industrialized world, including Canada's failure to act to pursue our Paris Agreement targets.\n\nThe petitioners call for Canada to increase our climate finance commitments towards the global south, providing more funding for adaptation and for projects that also advance a particularly targeted group within Canada and globally: Women are particularly impacted by the climate crisis.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372794","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise on behalf of the many residents of Saanich—Gulf Islands who raise the issue again of the climate crisis.\n\nIn this context, the petitioners ask the House of Commons to recognize that the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has recognized how much the climate crisis accentuates and increases the societal divides globally, with the global south bearing much ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d95776d002c884ac8367b4b151b291bcb2d29ea3492d37ff5c96d72340b5476e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62b58ca273edd9ae9fc0b71a6ca77999279d4d935f9fa24f8a05a2a2d6b61493"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bab7ee826a30aedbec1c63c8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372795,"date":"2026-03-23T21:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will actually say this as a practising Christian. When they quote one part of the Bible, particularly Leviticus, where they go back and say, \"It is not good to commit adultery, but it is okay if it is your slave girl,\" there are some sections pulled out by themselves that one would not regard as inspirational or as the word of God. Let me just get that out of the way. \n\nThe point of Bill C-9, which the hon. member for Bow River put so well and which I believe is the core of the problem, is the uncertainty it would create. That is why I am voting against it. We need certainty. If we are going to fight hate crimes, the Criminal Code already provides us with the tools.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372795","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will actually say this as a practising Christian. When they quote one part of the Bible, particularly Leviticus, where they go back and say, \"It is not good to commit adultery, but it is okay if it is your slave girl,\" there are some sections pulled out by themselves that one would not regard as inspirational or as the word of God. Let me just get that out of the way. \n\nThe point of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","label":"Waterways","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["477d07d66d3128b0abdf41e43cc8bb9dbc3c365d4b4c53ef46358a501f3228de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0cdbc85285d8db8e25beaacd6bcb382cc55c601d465ca3536cabfd27788a9f11"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14712e873bd7274c5eb4d4e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372796,"date":"2026-03-23T21:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, very briefly, I do not think I have seen this before, so perhaps the hon. parliamentary secretary, at some point later in debate, or the Speaker can answer the question I have.\n\n Is it at all normal that we would have a point of order to review amendments after committee work has closed on Bill C-8 to ask if it is within scope? Those questions are usually taken up at the moment when the amendments are brought forward. The clerk of the committee and the chair of the committee judge whether the amendment proposed is within scope.\n\nI know retroactivity seems to be a big thing these days, and we just passed Bill C-4, which came into effect 26 years ago, but I question the validity of this point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372796","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, very briefly, I do not think I have seen this before, so perhaps the hon. parliamentary secretary, at some point later in debate, or the Speaker can answer the question I have.\n\n Is it at all normal that we would have a point of order to review amendments after committee work has closed on Bill C-8 to ask if it is within scope? Those questions are usually taken up at the moment when t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4611e7c8f39bf85ede61b84ebd7f060499aebc569c7252f4ddf12907256742e1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd7881027d3f493920d0a6e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372366,"date":"2026-03-24T15:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise and present a petition on behalf of concerned constituents. They are concerned because, as we all know here, the poverty rates among people in the disabled community in Canada are shamefully high.\n\n The petitioners point out that after COVID, a lot of services that are essential for people in the disabled community are provided virtually, but the tax system has not caught up to this reality, so disabled Canadians are taxed on services that are a medical necessity. Prior to COVID, had they gone in person to receive them, they would have been tax-free.\n\nThe petitioners are asking the Minister of Finance to revise the criteria, review the real-life situation of Canadians living with disabilities and establish a new standard for tax exemptions to enable organizations to offer tax-free virtual support services and programs. It is a matter of essential justice.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372366","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise and present a petition on behalf of concerned constituents. They are concerned because, as we all know here, the poverty rates among people in the disabled community in Canada are shamefully high.\n\n The petitioners point out that after COVID, a lot of services that are essential for people in the disabled community are provided virtually, but the tax system has","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9f152ab90d734b83fdded82ac56d5db1ab4a5affb3aeee4c140c9fff1582e7e8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2ff7d05b20b9b8c4f98bf9b4fc86737957652f714da24f69e6f0c046c57ecc60"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09d09403aa50ec5ab6805e98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372367,"date":"2026-03-24T18:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will not in the next 60 seconds be able to do justice to the accomplishments of Dr. David Suzuki.\n\n Scientist, geneticist, broadcaster, author, educator and activist, David Suzuki has been a recipient of the highest citizen award in this country, the Companion of the Order of Canada. He has received awards from universities around the world too numerous to mention; awards from Japan, Australia, throughout Europe and from UNESCO and the United Nations; and the so-called alternative Nobel Prize, the Right Livelihood Award.\n\nAs host of The Nature of Things for decades, he educated generations of Canadians, making and increasing our awareness that nature itself is a miracle.\n\nHe has been, in his personal life, a devoted husband, father, grandfather and now great-grandfather.\n\n David Suzuki is much loved by millions of Canadians, and for good reason.\n\nHis 90th birthday is today, and I wish him a happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372367","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will not in the next 60 seconds be able to do justice to the accomplishments of Dr. David Suzuki.\n\n Scientist, geneticist, broadcaster, author, educator and activist, David Suzuki has been a recipient of the highest citizen award in this country, the Companion of the Order of Canada. He has received awards from universities around the world too numerous to mention; awards from Japan","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf0c3a54e33f75aabb9e0697","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372368,"date":"2026-03-24T20:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will not be voting for the motion before us today, but I do agree with the hon. member that we need to find ways to ensure that Canadian industries are put first and that we focus on Canada. I would like to ask the hon. member if he has looked at the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board. Of the $80 billion in our pension plan investments, there is no consideration at all for investing in Canada. There is no priority for Canadian investments. In fact, most of those investments go to other countries, particularly the United States.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372368","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will not be voting for the motion before us today, but I do agree with the hon. member that we need to find ways to ensure that Canadian industries are put first and that we focus on Canada. I would like to ask the hon. member if he has looked at the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board. Of the $80 billion in our pension plan investments, there is no consideration at all for investi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bcdbeda71b913ad52de541e30247666c9e3ecf227058ae5cb917cbb2d5226fa9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e5c9e988e028e3670d6b7292bd27dd9ea8a766c77e07ca283eb2235ff3f31f40"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-363313cc9a87182a8a9d7aea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372788,"date":"2026-03-24T21:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in the course of the debate today, there have been a number of good points made by members on all sides, honestly, but one of the things that continue to trouble me is that we are not actually putting Canada first in our investments. \n\nI wonder if the hon. parliamentary secretary would consider raising within his caucus that it is time to reform the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board Act so that our pension funds are invested in Canada and not as they are now, which is more in the United States than here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372788","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in the course of the debate today, there have been a number of good points made by members on all sides, honestly, but one of the things that continue to trouble me is that we are not actually putting Canada first in our investments. \n\nI wonder if the hon. parliamentary secretary would consider raising within his caucus that it is time to reform the Canada Pension Plan Investment Boar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3b094c2977ae1abb47221cfc25f04c9567d71481fa12064e48bc9bf84cb5e642"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d98158ffe0cb2cd81b1415269d73bdde70e5317c53b92bb07b116cb734ab93c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d017b3b0e20800f36067293","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372363,"date":"2026-03-26T16:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, members of my constituency of Saanich—Gulf Islands, as well as many adjacent areas, are very concerned about the fate of the southern resident killer whale, an extremely endangered species. These petitioners point out that once the whales swim to their other areas of occupation here and there, they are in Washington state. Washington state has far better protections for southern resident killer whales and other whales than we do in Canada. \n\nThe petitioners call on the Minister of Transport to implement mandatory vessel distance regulations to keep recreational and commercial vessels at least 1,000 metres away from the highly endangered southern resident killer whales. This is what they do in Washington state. This is one instance in which we should do something they do south of the border. \n\nIt is an honour to present this petition.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372363","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, members of my constituency of Saanich—Gulf Islands, as well as many adjacent areas, are very concerned about the fate of the southern resident killer whale, an extremely endangered species. These petitioners point out that once the whales swim to their other areas of occupation here and there, they are in Washington state. Washington state has far better protections for southern resid","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","label":"Aquatic wildlife"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","label":"Aquatic wildlife","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a68653944c673a3986388346f6522352bef81e1f5dcd0e6cf493436cd1ec4e32"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73d8a2b952b3c64d319ad2113c3886b67c7348fc38d0c2b6960b83d1581d285e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8ab6aef819a9dd6a0e79bb9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372364,"date":"2026-03-26T20:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I have a question for my colleague from Beauharnois—Salaberry—Soulanges—Huntingdon. I am a member of the House, but I am not a member of a committee.\n\nI want to add a few words to support the position of my colleague and friend from the Bloc Québécois, because it is not just the majority of the committee members who accepted the amendments. There are also two other parties in the House whose members cannot vote in committee. The NDP member for Vancouver East and myself, from the Green Party, also agree with the changes that were made by the committee following clause-by-clause consideration but that were ruled out of order by the Speaker of the House. I simply want to add that I think the majority, plus two other members, agree that the bill should be improved.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372364","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I have a question for my colleague from Beauharnois—Salaberry—Soulanges—Huntingdon. I am a member of the House, but I am not a member of a committee.\n\nI want to add a few words to support the position of my colleague and friend from the Bloc Québécois, because it is not just the majority of the committee members who accepted the amendments. There are also two other parties in the Ho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","label":"Minorities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6469e6c1e7767f6f2014439db07613d3b7004f68e0c2cdf21a4aae81def939e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1671f7dbba8ab7eca08f62f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":372365,"date":"2026-03-26T20:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is an honour for me to speak to Bill C-8 this afternoon.\n\nI have a few comments regarding the substance of the bill, but in light of the previous speeches, I think I can clarify the situation regarding unrecognized parties, although it is a bit complicated.\n\nThe reality of it is that we do not have to change our rules, but I share with my other colleagues that we have the right, as members of Parliament in parties with fewer than 12 MPs, under our standing rules and procedures of Parliament to stand in this place at report stage and present and debate substantive amendments. That is as a right, not as a favour on unanimous consent. That right we have at report stage is one that exists in our rules.\n\nWhy it does not happen goes back to a long story, and I do not want to lose my time to discuss Bill C-8 by explaining this. Back when Stephen Harper was the prime minister, the governing party objected to my efforts to try to protect environmental legislation in an omnibus budget bill in the spring of 2012. I presented amendments on the floor of the House at report stage. Long story short, the Prime Minister's Office of the day decided it was too much trouble to change the rules to deprive members of Parliament in a situation such as my own, which is now a situation the NDP finds itself in. Not long ago in the past, the Bloc Québécois was in the same situation.\n\nRather than change the rules, they came up with a simple expedient: Tell every committee to pass an identical motion to say members of Parliament serving in a party of fewer than 12 MPs or as independents would be given a short timeline of 24 hours' notice to present amendments at committee which are deemed to have been tabled. This was because, as non-committee members, we do not have the right to argue for our amendments, except during a one-minute period. We also do not have the right to withdraw our amendments, but the deemed presentation of our amendments occurs.\n\nI have spent days in committees at clause-by-clause, waiting hours for the one chance I have to present one amendment and argue for it for a minute.\n\nThis is all to say that this process, in the case of Bill C-8, gave me a front-row seat to really good, strong attempts by Conservative members of Parliament, by the Bloc Québécois, by one NDP member in the same situation I am in and by a number of Green Party amendments that were put forward to try to improve the act. It is worth noting at this point that it represents four of the five parties that serve in this Parliament, working together to try to improve the legislation, with the governing party members opposing.\n\nEven though we got through committee a number of strong amendments, at the end of the day, here in this chamber, an ex post facto change was made to the rulings that the majority of the committee members who had a vote, and, if we had had a vote, the other members of Parliament who were sitting at the table and presenting amendments, would have concurred in.\n\nIt is a strange road that leads me to every single committee on almost every piece of legislation when it gets to clause-by-clause to try to improve the legislation. As a right, I should not have to run from committee to committee. I should be able to make my amendments at report stage in one room, rather than sometimes simultaneously running from committee to committee.\n\nI raise this because members of committee now routinely pass a motion sent down to them from on high. They do not question it or realize that what they are doing is reducing my rights as a member of Parliament. I have more rights if they do not pass that motion in committee, but it is now a mindless procedure. They never call me beforehand to ask how it would affect my rights or if they should pass it or not.\n\nUnfortunately, this is the situation facing members of parties with fewer than 12 seats. We are only allowed to present amendments at report stage, here in the House.\n\nThe House is now considering Bill C-8 at third reading. Bill C-8, which we are debating in the House this afternoon, is virtually identical to Bill C-26, but it includes certain improvements that were made to that bill, which could not be passed because the House was prorogued.\n\nWe know that Bill C-26 was the first attempt to have a cybersecurity framework for this country to protect Canadians and be prepared for the numerous ways in which we need a proper framework for cybersecurity. Bill C-8 is an improvement over Bill C-26. There is more transparency. Improvements have been made, and there is more clarity around the question of what is essential infrastructure for Canadians in this area. \n\nBill C-8 is an omnibus bill that would create an entirely new act, the critical cyber-systems protection act, and amend many other acts. As much as we can stand here and say it is an improvement, it is also an improvement because at least some of the amendments that were made in clause-by-clause in committee, amendments primarily from the Conservative Party members of committee, improved the legislation and did more to protect privacy for Canadians. However, still, despite some improvements that we welcome, I will be voting against Bill C-8 because there are still too many loopholes and too many flaws. \n\nI am quite certain of the bill's passage, and we do need legislation in this area, but not this. We are not ready yet. I very much hope that the Senate of Canada, in exercising sober second thought, will look at the debates here today and consider the briefs that were presented to the public safety committee from the Canadian Civil Liberties Union; the Citizen Lab, which is part of the Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy; OpenMedia; and a number of other concerned technical expert groups that, while looking at cybersecurity, think that this bill still has flaws that would create constitutional weaknesses and fail to properly protect encryption and the security of private information.\n\n The concerns fall into a couple of broad categories. Again, when the Senate of Canada looks at this, I would ask it to please consider if the legislation is good enough to pass the tests. Cybersecurity is an interesting area, where Canada, in passing legislation, has an eye on what the U.K. threshold tests looks like for protection of personal information before our products can be used within the U.K. Certainly a number of experts have looked at this and think that Bill C-8 does not get us across the threshold for what privacy protections are required in other countries. \n\nIn general, despite improvements in transparency, the reality is that this law, Bill C-8, like other laws passed recently, would give individual ministers too much power. We do not have the requirement for warrants. There is not enough judicial oversight. We still have a situation where many of these orders can be made without the public knowing. The notion is that the minister alone would decide whether they can order a telecommunications company to pull access to their system or an individual Canadian, who will not necessarily know this is happening and not have an opportunity to speak to it. \n\nThe ongoing question is not only that this bill has loopholes, but it weakens existing protections that exist under other laws. Those points have been made well. I was going to particularly point to the brief of OpenMedia on Bill C-8, which points out, \"A bad loophole you pass in this legislation does not just weaken the law; it will prove far more important than the law's intended purpose.\" There are serious loopholes that must be fixed, and they have not been fixed. I certainly hope that the Senate will look at the Bloc Québécois amendment, which would make sure there is mandatory review of how this law is working within a confined and defined period of time. \n\nIn conclusion, it is clear that this bill is imperfect. No member of Parliament believes that the bill has been improved enough to make it perfect now.\n\nWe cannot let the perfect be the enemy of the good. Let us hope that the Senate fixes the flaws, that the bill comes back to us and that the government accepts those fixes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:372365","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is an honour for me to speak to Bill C-8 this afternoon.\n\nI have a few comments regarding the substance of the bill, but in light of the previous speeches, I think I can clarify the situation regarding unrecognized parties, although it is a bit complicated.\n\nThe reality of it is that we do not have to change our rules, but I share with my other colleagues that we have the right, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0ca12baf45976df71b39dbe638efb8e267f739e6fa1caf918ab5493bd075ace7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa8ae977a27e13ce8f87403f1a4743a00f2c0aecc4921f9ca91b6fb9456c2d14"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-639e020d8fe3f7048fd12aa5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418261,"date":"2026-04-13T17:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this bill regarding lawful access certainly includes many improvements. I would like to see more, but I will speak to that later.\n\n It occurs to me today, and I am sure the Minister of Justice has this on his mind, that in five days we mark six years since the largest mass killings in Canada, in Portapique, Nova Scotia. In the resulting inquiry, the Mass Casualty Commission report called for many critical measures to be pursued. When the Minister of Justice says we are going to hire 1,000 new RCMP officers, what springs to my mind is that they would all be inadequately trained, according to the Mass Casualty Commission. The commission called for an overhaul of the way that RCMP officers are trained. We are talking about a preventable tragedy.\n\nWill the government implement the report from the Mass Casualty Commission?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418261","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this bill regarding lawful access certainly includes many improvements. I would like to see more, but I will speak to that later.\n\n It occurs to me today, and I am sure the Minister of Justice has this on his mind, that in five days we mark six years since the largest mass killings in Canada, in Portapique, Nova Scotia. In the resulting inquiry, the Mass Casualty Commission report cal","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5ab03bd46f9e0ae21d3d0a8b5c04aa7f593df5ced257c9c2fc3458cb8383824"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ac2c6617149b17dcf95232bd496b1caddc1a93141ad9f1799ca603f34b69323"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8c4109e3c455bf6cd3ff777","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418262,"date":"2026-04-13T17:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there are many issues on which the member and I do not agree, but I think we do agree that there has never been anything like this not only in this Parliament but in any Parliament of Canada. A single bill, originally Bill C-2, the strong borders act, was so universally panned and attacked by so many civil society groups, a coalition of more than 300, that the bill then had to morph from Bill C-2 to Bill C-12 and now, to try to get to warrantless access, to Bill C-22. There has never been a course of legislation like this.\n\n I would ask my hon. colleague, with whom I agreed on many of his attempts to improve the bill in committee, does he think we are getting closer? We have at least gotten rid of the original provisions that post office employees could open the mail without a warrant. The member for Winnipeg North may be the only member in this place who laments Bill C-2—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418262","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there are many issues on which the member and I do not agree, but I think we do agree that there has never been anything like this not only in this Parliament but in any Parliament of Canada. A single bill, originally Bill C-2, the strong borders act, was so universally panned and attacked by so many civil society groups, a coalition of more than 300, that the bill then had to morph f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a21924edba369c2e4e457296b63145f159824a9a1a72a919e3836297f723a8db"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63037f104d0cc0eaaaa55657","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418260,"date":"2026-04-14T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my question goes to the heart of the issue: Does the government respect science?\n\n We are hearing cuts announced across Environment and Climate Change in terms of its research efforts, and in Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada and its critical research. Hundreds of scientists around the world have expressed alarm at killing an entire segment of our scientific capacity for insect taxonomy.\n\nHas the Prime Minister ever consulted his chief science adviser about these cuts before the pink slips go out?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418260","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my question goes to the heart of the issue: Does the government respect science?\n\n We are hearing cuts announced across Environment and Climate Change in terms of its research efforts, and in Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada and its critical research. Hundreds of scientists around the world have expressed alarm at killing an entire segment of our scientific capacity for insect taxonom","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722099","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Living organisms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722099","label":"Living organisms","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94ca177da8ca6313efbd3b288a30bf739aa74dc2af94a04a030dd61a98f69f6a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a4318f2992112cf7e2b2659f288d63a2bef2dbdc0fe07d615a2aa9a19df148ab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de8169f9a4ad2e98291c3040","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418259,"date":"2026-04-15T21:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is a petition that I am so honoured to present. I am always honoured to present petitions from my constituents, but this is e-petition 6955, with an extraordinarily high number of supporters. In fact, just under 24,000 people signed this. The first signatories on the petition are all scientists from around the world. \n\nIn short, the petition notes that currently, under Canadian law, animals are treated as property and not considered sentient beings, but under increasing efforts internationally from scientists around the world, there is a very strong consensus that animals are sentient beings, not mere property. The petitioners, as I said, just under 24,000 of them, are calling on the government to pass legislation to recognize animals as sentient beings and not mere property.\n\nI present this petition and hope that the government will attend to this matter and respond appropriately.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418259","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is a petition that I am so honoured to present. I am always honoured to present petitions from my constituents, but this is e-petition 6955, with an extraordinarily high number of supporters. In fact, just under 24,000 people signed this. The first signatories on the petition are all scientists from around the world. \n\nIn short, the petition notes that currently, under Canadian l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["56264f5493472f8e0e04cdb18c1fe34e4e180618a5745035d58565bec92343a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["417d918486ef4ec4b590199d943be72634332fe49a4109fa1b70601e3dce5c61"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-590d0e307667657eecba6585","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418254,"date":"2026-04-16T15:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as pre-arranged through the desk for virtual petition presentation, I am presenting e-petition—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418254","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as pre-arranged through the desk for virtual petition presentation, I am presenting e-petition—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e670d9149e67d8313d6aff85","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418255,"date":"2026-04-16T15:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I ask the hon. minister a very direct question and thank him for improvements made in the amendments in Bill C-25 to the Elections Act.\n\nI wonder if the minister could give the House a quick rundown on the sections of former Bill C-65, which had been through committee, was being studied and had elements that are not included in this act. I wonder if he could explain why the government chose not to include improvements to the Elections Act from slightly more than a year ago that are now not included, such as removing obstacles for the collection of signatures for candidates.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418255","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I ask the hon. minister a very direct question and thank him for improvements made in the amendments in Bill C-25 to the Elections Act.\n\nI wonder if the minister could give the House a quick rundown on the sections of former Bill C-65, which had been through committee, was being studied and had elements that are not included in this act. I wonder if he could explain why the government","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a35644f508bec4fc07b6a9f303dfdf5755e05b075ef24e9917c844c7dcb45dd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6aed0e529f98a029ed82093e6331dfb4c0365ab34b660294c72deec5889cfbb8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73536ff55aae59390a62b694","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418256,"date":"2026-04-16T16:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, since the official opposition has had good success in obtaining amendments by working with the government, I wonder if the hon. member for St. Albert—Sturgeon River will be willing to pursue changes to the Elections Act that were in former Bill C-65, which died on the Order Paper when the House prorogued on January 6 of last year. Might he be willing to get amendments over the line in committee to address the issue of the difficulty presented to candidates in collecting signatures, as was addressed in Bill C-65?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418256","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, since the official opposition has had good success in obtaining amendments by working with the government, I wonder if the hon. member for St. Albert—Sturgeon River will be willing to pursue changes to the Elections Act that were in former Bill C-65, which died on the Order Paper when the House prorogued on January 6 of last year. Might he be willing to get amendments over the line in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8b084064c8a5c5ab30b0efba08d1d0ee2e83bac0d5f1faaad376d2df27a2650"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f4320ccde748450e13a2e18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418257,"date":"2026-04-16T17:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I certainly do support the member's key point that we should have, by now, acted to create the foreign registry for agents who interfere in Canadian democracy. However, knowing him to be an open-minded and fair-minded member, I would ask him if he would reconsider his opposition to the per-vote subsidy for fair financing, recognizing that it was one of the recommendations in the report from Madam Justice Hogue that in order to counter foreign interference, we should revisit the use of a vote subsidy directed by the citizens casting their ballot and giving a very small amount per year to the party of their choice.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418257","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I certainly do support the member's key point that we should have, by now, acted to create the foreign registry for agents who interfere in Canadian democracy. However, knowing him to be an open-minded and fair-minded member, I would ask him if he would reconsider his opposition to the per-vote subsidy for fair financing, recognizing that it was one of the recommendations in the repor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc2dd696676463f71d0a28a80f42b6fe0ca1ff47f484b92cf0279efccbedcac4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e251a768f4a579a2144141566221c2933b04b7e01ff5b6f8035f588814c23e1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a50ff0e14882f7ff1e9ec98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418258,"date":"2026-04-16T18:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, one recommendation from Madam Justice Hogue that is not in Bill C-25 to confront foreign interference but that I would love to see in Bill C-25, was to restore the political finance reforms that were introduced originally by a former prime minister, the Right Honourable Jean Chrétien.\n\n Does my friend from Davenport agree that the bill would be strengthened if we were to bring back the per-vote subsidy that also encouraged voters to vote for the party of their choice even in ridings that were regarded as safe for another party?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418258","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, one recommendation from Madam Justice Hogue that is not in Bill C-25 to confront foreign interference but that I would love to see in Bill C-25, was to restore the political finance reforms that were introduced originally by a former prime minister, the Right Honourable Jean Chrétien.\n\n Does my friend from Davenport agree that the bill would be strengthened if we were to bring back th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42fdba6771f380fbde6f16b1716054c684df9dce7a2d3109911379ecc07c94cf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b6132df294d07452f89259e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418246,"date":"2026-04-17T15:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know this may offend people. There are people who think there are too many lawyers in politics, but I do not think there are enough of us. I want to thank the hon. member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith, whose legal background showed through in the way she put together that critique of Bill C-22.\n\nI am also very concerned about changing \"reasonable grounds to believe\" to \"reasonable grounds to suspect\". I would like the member to expand on whether she found any previous example of that kind of threshold being used. I cannot find a previous example of \"reasonable grounds to suspect\".","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418246","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know this may offend people. There are people who think there are too many lawyers in politics, but I do not think there are enough of us. I want to thank the hon. member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith, whose legal background showed through in the way she put together that critique of Bill C-22.\n\nI am also very concerned about changing \"reasonable grounds to believe\" to \"reasonable grounds t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-19fdcc0c5c28f428071667d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418247,"date":"2026-04-17T17:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present a petition on behalf of concerned residents of Saanich—Gulf Islands. The southern resident killer whale is, as all my constituents are deeply concerned about it, one of those issues that unifies people within all of British Columbia, particularly the coastal Coast Salish territories. \n\nThe southern resident killer whale is an extremely endangered species. It is increasingly endangered, as petitioners point out, by additional ship traffic. Every additional Aframax oil tanker from the Trans Mountain pipeline, every additional expansion from the harbour authority in Vancouver—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418247","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present a petition on behalf of concerned residents of Saanich—Gulf Islands. The southern resident killer whale is, as all my constituents are deeply concerned about it, one of those issues that unifies people within all of British Columbia, particularly the coastal Coast Salish territories. \n\nThe southern resident killer whale is an extremely endangered species. It","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","label":"Whales"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","label":"Whales","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["badbe975858daa32743c94c37151065369ec1e5b57eb2b0a6bdb0d565c9e0ce7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b086eacc9bf9fcc97421ff59f85244c269fe3d34b45c0900d30f15144649cf7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Whales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47641","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17d5a9087e32477f7a22e200","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418248,"date":"2026-04-17T17:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we had the problem yesterday. I went to IT, and they verified that this one does work and is appropriate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418248","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we had the problem yesterday. I went to IT, and they verified that this one does work and is appropriate.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a76e4c631309451abce11b37a56f701867574af5b4b86fe3a26ff6a24869758c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26557b0c1a23b66da85a6e2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418249,"date":"2026-04-17T17:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will put on the record my request that we do in the House what we do in committee, which is to let the IT people check ahead of time so this does not happen, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418249","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will put on the record my request that we do in the House what we do in committee, which is to let the IT people check ahead of time so this does not happen, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b5cfea727537fbde75a66f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418250,"date":"2026-04-17T17:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour for me to speak virtually, since a situation came up that prevented me from participating in person. Those are the rules of the House.\n\nI am grateful for the chance to speak to Bill C-22. I do not have lengthy parliamentarian experience compared to other members, but I have been a member of Parliament for nearly 15 years, and I have never seen anything like what the government has done in the area of the legislation that we now have before us. It initially came to us in June as Bill C-2, and in that bill there were provisions for access and warrantless access that were combined with \"strong borders\" provisions, as they were then called.\n\n I just want to draw attention to the process of the legislation, because it is highly unusual. Again, obviously there are people who have more experience. The member for Vancouver Centre, for example, has served far longer than I have, but I have never seen anything like this, for what it is worth. We started with Bill C-2, which was not withdrawn. It remained there, and then it was largely replaced, although it was not withdrawn, by Bill C-12. Now we have Bill C-22, picking up on elements of what was unacceptable in Bill C-2.\n\nI have heard the Prime Minister in press comments talk about the ways the new Liberal majority plans to change our committee composition. Somehow there is a lot of showboating going on, the Prime Minister said, a lot of grandstanding, but honestly, the process of studying legislation has some precedents and parliamentary tradition that really do matter. One is to give a bill proper study. This is interrupted by the innovation of the government in never admitting it has made a mistake or in not amending a bill that is on the Order Paper but rather replacing it with a series of repeated starts and stops.\n\nI am sure the hon. member for Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, whose humour I enjoyed earlier, might make a comment on this. It is bizarre and certainly unusual. We started with Bill C-2, and then we had Bill C-12, which continued the anti-refugee rights provisions that were in Bill C-2. Now we have moved to Bill C-22, on access, and the bill of course is dealing with access to information that is important for law enforcement.\n\nThis is an unusual process, to put it mildly. Today I want to focus on what is in Bill C-22 and on the reasons that I certainly hope the government will go to a more normal parliamentary procedure, which would be to amend Bill C-22 to achieve the kind of consensus that would allow me, as a Green Party member of Parliament, to vote for it. I cannot vote for it as it is now on the Order Paper.\n\n Again, let me step back and say, as I have said in the House before, on the record, that Bill C-22 represents improvements over the portions that were originally put forward in Bill C-2. The original access legislation would have allowed, for instance, postal workers to open our mail, and it would have allowed access to subscriber information from telecommunications companies without notice to the user.\n\nHowever, while there has been much improvement in requiring warrants, the warrants would still be required to meet a threshold that the hon member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith referred to earlier in debate today. It is a completely unprecedented threshold for a warrant to obtain information and access to information: \"reasonable grounds to suspect\". We find that language in proposed subsection 487.0142(2).\n\n\"Reasonable grounds to believe\" is a well-understood concept. There is much jurisprudence on what is required to have reasonable grounds to believe. There is zero jurisprudence on what it means to have reasonable grounds to suspect. It is a lower threshold. It does not make sense to put legal terms in that have no foundation in law. It would undoubtedly create confusion in how the legislation would be used by law enforcement.\n\nI note that the Liberals have changed the definition of who would be able to access, from police officer to public officer, which would mean that the same terminology could apply to a CSIS agent or a police officer. The judge issuing a warrant, under many of these sections, would merely have to determine if there are reasonable grounds to suspect. Again, there is no background in law for this.\n\nWhen I say \"jurisprudence\", to break that down to common sense, that just means we can go back and look up legal decisions where courts have struggled with what a word means, so the court dealing with the matter before it has somewhere to go to see what the previous judges said. The court can see the record of court cases on this matter so it knows what it is looking for. In this case, with the use of novel terminology, \"reasonable grounds to suspect\", people do not know what they are looking for. A judge would have to deal with the issue for the first time, and I think we could say, at a minimum, that this is unwise in drafting.\n\nWhere does this leave us now with Bill C-22? There are many improvements, particularly in part one, but there are some concerns with part two, as has been noted by numerous commentators, from the Canadian Civil Liberties Association to a group called OpenMedia. By the way, I pay a lot of attention to OpenMedia, because it is a very impressive organization as a small non-government organization that worries about Internet access and public policy. It also happens to be headed by an executive director who is one of my constituents. I thank Matt Hatfield from Salt Spring Island for his diligence in working with an organization that represents the concerns of thousands of Canadians.\n\nHowever, the concerns we have with Bill C-22 continue. The concerns are largely in the one area, and I asked the hon. Minister for Public Safety to entertain amendments on this matter, amendments to understand that if what the bill would require is surveillance capacity from Internet providers, it would mean they would have to permanently insert spyware into the platforms that Canadians use.\n\nThis would create access to information about Canadians that would be accessible not only by Canadian public officers and by Canadian intelligence officers, such as from CSIS, but could also potentially be open to surveillance, and that data could be accessed, by foreign governments, including the United States government. A number of Canadians would have concerns about having their personal Internet information accessed by foreign governments. I think that is an unintentional consequence of the way the bill is drafted that needs to be repaired. We do not want surveillance built into the permanent collection of data, which would be required under the terms of the act as it is currently drafted.\n\nI want to make it clear that I would be very pleased to vote for the legislation. I will be preparing amendments and taking them before committee. Although, under the bizarre terms in which I operate on committees, I am not allowed to vote on my own amendments, I hope that other members of the House and members of the committee will show support, and I hope the Minister for Public Safety will improve the bill to bring it to a state where people can vote for it and get it over the finish line.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418250","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour for me to speak virtually, since a situation came up that prevented me from participating in person. Those are the rules of the House.\n\nI am grateful for the chance to speak to Bill C-22. I do not have lengthy parliamentarian experience compared to other members, but I have been a member of Parliament for nearly 15 years, and I have never seen anything like what the go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","label":"Warrants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","label":"Warrants","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7625b4a17e212bd3bfe9b90a5df00f1a00a4d61cb659ed35cf5a7f4bfe5c2e3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e612a5e0a522ce3e894c4ac615628629e0730be9f6393bf3159bd5196e738b58"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7a781dae3e246fa346f1905","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418251,"date":"2026-04-17T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think it is the first time my hon. colleague the member for London—Fanshawe and I have had an exchange. I did hear his speech as well. I agree with his concern. For smaller service providers, this could indeed be a burden, so I will just say that I agree.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418251","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think it is the first time my hon. colleague the member for London—Fanshawe and I have had an exchange. I did hear his speech as well. I agree with his concern. For smaller service providers, this could indeed be a burden, so I will just say that I agree.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1df44ed10a30fa45566fb7562b2b3e178bacef69ebecf2056633205f10624e01"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bdd7ffc6b131af18a63d995c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418252,"date":"2026-04-17T17:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be proposing amendments, particularly with respect to part 2. The best thing would be to remove part 2 as a whole, but in anticipation of the committee's work, I will be preparing amendments to that part.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418252","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be proposing amendments, particularly with respect to part 2. The best thing would be to remove part 2 as a whole, but in anticipation of the committee's work, I will be preparing amendments to that part.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-876816c123f0ab373bcf23af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418253,"date":"2026-04-17T17:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a good record. In 15 years, I have never heckled in this place, but I had a very strong temptation to respond and to encourage the member for Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, to inject levity, and say, \"Hello, hello, hello\" back to him when he made the Grand Canyon comment, which may go down in the annals of parliamentary history as a good way of not breaking our rule of not pointing out who may or may not be present in the Chamber.\n\nThe member asked what kind of failure I thought Bill C-2 was. It was a catastrophic failure. It was a bill I never saw over the course of the summer. It was tabled in June. Over the course of last summer, I think 400 different organizations from various points of view, from refugee rights and civil liberties to how to control the Internet and rights to privacy, had a breadth of pulling together a massive coalition to oppose the bill.\n\nOn that ground alone, perhaps the Liberal government should be congratulated for never before having launched a bill so bad that 400 civil society groups banded together to stop it. The government, while stopping Bill C-2, never admitted it had made a mistake, again, by using a novel method of ignoring the opposition, except to table in September 2025 Bill C-12 and then to table Bill C-22. They all dealt with largely the same subject matter.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418253","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a good record. In 15 years, I have never heckled in this place, but I had a very strong temptation to respond and to encourage the member for Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, to inject levity, and say, \"Hello, hello, hello\" back to him when he made the Grand Canyon comment, which may go down in the annals of parliamentary history as a good way of not breaking our rule of not pointing ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["607f7f31eb7f88273b923038fafe405bd5e38846bd14193790813efe29d7604b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d8031f17b7b4e04f5284712f14c6bca8d3e2ad8809248494b02a29caa2940b3a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9ec745f68eef37e197abcd1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289799,"date":"2026-04-20T17:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am very concerned about aspects of Bill C-22, things that continue to include unacceptable elements from Bill C-2. \n\nI could not agree more with the hon. member for Oshawa that the hon. member for Winnipeg North has assumed that people are filibustering when we are merely insisting that the legislation be acceptable. Bill C-22 is an improvement, but could the hon. member for Humber River—Black Creek let us know if the government will be open to amending it to deal with the problems in part 2 of the bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289799","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am very concerned about aspects of Bill C-22, things that continue to include unacceptable elements from Bill C-2. \n\nI could not agree more with the hon. member for Oshawa that the hon. member for Winnipeg North has assumed that people are filibustering when we are merely insisting that the legislation be acceptable. Bill C-22 is an improvement, but could the hon. member for Humber ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-174d7bbe310ec150f24797a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289800,"date":"2026-04-20T17:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to put a comment on the record. The Green Party of Canada is 100% in agreement with the summary of what has happened with this bill that was just given by the hon. member for Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289800","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to put a comment on the record. The Green Party of Canada is 100% in agreement with the summary of what has happened with this bill that was just given by the hon. member for Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b74c5b52c25e43876258f7f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289801,"date":"2026-04-20T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, last Thursday in question period, in response to a question from the member for Edmonton Strathcona, the Minister of Energy completely dismissed any concern about the recent nearly one million-litre leak from the pipeline of Imperial Oil on Cold Lake First Nations territory, on top of frequent spills and leaks by Imperial from its tailings ponds and elsewhere.\n\nWith Earth Day on Wednesday, I wonder if, as the Speaker says, the hon. minister might want to take it from the top and give a response that at least pretends to be concerned about the environment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289801","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, last Thursday in question period, in response to a question from the member for Edmonton Strathcona, the Minister of Energy completely dismissed any concern about the recent nearly one million-litre leak from the pipeline of Imperial Oil on Cold Lake First Nations territory, on top of frequent spills and leaks by Imperial from its tailings ponds and elsewhere.\n\nWith Earth Day on Wedne","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","label":"Oil spills"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","label":"Oil spills","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["086e1d8c9d78114ccc25454d716b7239295b4872d81db7fadd1acc788469adbf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ff6e89d5ddcee2e1e3716cdec991f1e0aa7e740641c9715b3c80622ab77c99d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59284744b2ad879ce26b12a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289802,"date":"2026-04-20T20:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to present a petition. It is an e-petition that was put together and supported by 587 people looking at the issue of expansion of fossil fuel infrastructure.\n\nThe petitioners point out that any expansion of fossil fuel infrastructure runs contrary to climate action and the necessity of holding the global average temperature increase to below 1.5°C, if possible. The petitioners point out that projects, and specifically the carbon sequestration project called the Pathways Alliance project, are unlikely to work to hold greenhouse gases out of the atmosphere. The petitioners also point out that even if it did work, it would be insufficient to undo the environmental damage of continued fossil fuel expansion.\n\n Therefore, the petitioners call on the government to stop any subsidies to the Pathways Alliance project and to do what is practical and meaningful, which is to reduce greenhouse gases, not expand them while pretending that carbon capture and storage will nullify the damage that expansion will inevitably produce.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289802","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to present a petition. It is an e-petition that was put together and supported by 587 people looking at the issue of expansion of fossil fuel infrastructure.\n\nThe petitioners point out that any expansion of fossil fuel infrastructure runs contrary to climate action and the necessity of holding the global average temperature increase to below 1.5°C, if pos","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","label":"Greenhouse gases"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","label":"Greenhouse gases","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["361e6d6cc42d7647fe899330cd42de962ce6b81e4616b075bc36ffc009e6c55c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["43774fca79618496ef398172fc6641515b86adce20b1f57a007ce0336455e27c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28011e1ac4b02324bd143c63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289796,"date":"2026-04-21T15:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons.\n\nPerhaps he misspoke. It was unfair to suggest that the Conservative Party is against the nominee proposed by the government benches to be the new Parliamentary Budget Officer. It is certainly not uncommon for the opposition to bring forward debate on concurrence in a committee report. It may be annoying. It may mean that I do not get to present a petition for another couple of hours. However, it is hardly an attack on the person who is being put forward. I just wanted to make that point.\n\n Perhaps the hon. member for Winnipeg North would like to correct the accusation that the Conservatives are against this particular person.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289796","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons.\n\nPerhaps he misspoke. It was unfair to suggest that the Conservative Party is against the nominee proposed by the government benches to be the new Parliamentary Budget Officer. It is certainly not uncommon for the opposition to bring forward debate on concurrence in a committee repo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dec65a478035ef9f81919916c8e34f2f282085644728fd74b811f2a6eba9df0c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67a502144b6d840e6f820add","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289797,"date":"2026-04-21T23:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am raising a question tonight in Adjournment Proceedings that I first raised on February 5 at the end of our annual International Development Week. I raised a question in great sadness because the Liberal Party platform in the last election committed to something that mattered. It committed to not cut development assistance. That stood in stark contrast to the Conservative Party commitment to cut development assistance. It was one of those issues on which voters could make a pivotal choice. Sometimes, it seemed like they were saying the same thing: Liberals were saying they were going to get rid of the consumer carbon price and Conservatives were saying they were going to get rid of the consumer carbon price.\n\nHowever, on the issue of development assistance, there was a clear choice to be made because the Liberals said, very clearly, that they would not cut development assistance. This matters, particularly in the world today, where shocking things have happened south of the border. Under the Trump administration, two critical decisions were made that imperil millions and millions of the world's poorest. One was the decision to cut all ties and cut funding. The U.S. was the biggest funder of the World Health Organization, the organization that helps with immunizations against polio, malaria and TB. A lot of us in Parliament and across Canada are Rotarians. We worked with the program to end polio that was supported by Canadians from coast to coast to coast. When Trump cut funding to the World Health Organization, the U.S. cut funding to one of the biggest partners working around the world with Rotarians to end the scourge of polio. At the same time, pretty much, Elon Musk and his DOGE machine, along with his fake but real chainsaw, cut USAID, which was one of the world's biggest donor organizations, from a government state donor to the poorest of the poor.\n\nAgain, Canada's role in this is important. We have shown, if not leadership in terms of dollars, leadership in exhorting others to do it. Our former prime minister Lester B. Pearson chaired a UN agency and set a target for industrialized countries, suggesting that if wealthy donor countries would only put 0.7% of our GDP into official development assistance, we could end poverty. The closest we ever got to that target was back in 1992 when the prime minister was Brian Mulroney. At the Rio Earth Summit, Canada had 0.48%.\n\n Now, tragically, the Liberals have broken that promise. We were never as close as we were under Mulroney, but we have dropped quite a bit. Breaking their promise, the Liberals, under our current Prime Minister, cut $2.8 billion from development assistance. At a time when the world looks to us to step up and help repair the damage done by the hole created by the U.S. stepping away from the poorest of the poor, we are doing the same and stepping away instead of stepping up.\n\n In a moment of sadness on February 5, I posed the question and pointed out to the minister that this is the first time in 50 years that Canada has not had a full cabinet minister responsible for development assistance. Rather, we have a secretary of state who I know means well, but a secretary of state for development assistance is not the same thing as having a cabinet minister at the table.\n\n I hope to pursue this matter.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289797","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am raising a question tonight in Adjournment Proceedings that I first raised on February 5 at the end of our annual International Development Week. I raised a question in great sadness because the Liberal Party platform in the last election committed to something that mattered. It committed to not cut development assistance. That stood in stark contrast to the Conservative Party com","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a01c0d3e8c60d1b30020b558ebf41824b951c920a3a8babaecc53dce5c083f13"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0875387af1a3cf6c121f80a7fd8c61c2395770e3ed0ef1726003772f90f28283"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76e124f982fe86bb5b486f9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289798,"date":"2026-04-21T23:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, oh, I wish that was all true. I thank the hon. parliamentary secretary for saying we are committed, but if we are committed, why have we cut when the Liberal budget promised it would not be cut? This is at a time when the world is screaming out that there are increased humanitarian pressures. There are humanitarian pressures in Gaza, in Darfur, in Ukraine and all around the world, and if anyone looks to Canada for help, we have cut development assistance by $2.7 billion this year.\n\nWe cannot talk out of both sides of our mouth forever. It catches up with us. We must do more. Canadians care about the poorest of the poor. We know that in the climate crisis, there will be more environmental refugees, more people turning up on our shores, looking for help and looking for assistance. The U.S. has turned insular, turned more selfish than ever. Canada needs to look outward. We need to be more generous than ever.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289798","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, oh, I wish that was all true. I thank the hon. parliamentary secretary for saying we are committed, but if we are committed, why have we cut when the Liberal budget promised it would not be cut? This is at a time when the world is screaming out that there are increased humanitarian pressures. There are humanitarian pressures in Gaza, in Darfur, in Ukraine and all around the world, and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","label":"Humanitarian crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","label":"Humanitarian crisis","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["10767285df84d015b5cc84de71a6845f8e33c9841baa03f5c50ccdd7ed14b860"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cdef91a514d61e17b084a68cf2dfe743f9c9606e4bd0c98ebcba9d9fc03917f6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d55db982d2ce340f643b6fd9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289795,"date":"2026-04-22T21:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to join virtually today, and again, as other members have done, I wish everyone a happy Earth Day.\n\nThe petition I am raising today is not a happy story. However, it is all too typical. There are a lot of examples of Canadian mining companies operating particularly in Latin America, where there are allegations of human rights and environmental abuses.\n\nIn this case, petitioners wish to raise and bring to the attention of the House the situation for indigenous people of Guatemala, the Xinka people, who have been for many years opposing the Escobal mine, which is an operation of the Pan American Silver company registered in Vancouver.\n\nCurrently the position of the Canadian ombudsperson for responsible enterprise is vacant, so petitioners are looking to the House of Commons and to the Canadian government to take action. The Escobal mine has been opposed by the Xinka people. The story is long and complex, so I will summarize. It has involved the murder of local indigenous people who oppose the mine. The courts in Guatemala stopped the company from operating until consultations could take place, but now, over the objections of the Xinka people, the mining operation wishes to proceed.\n\nThe petitioners point out that Canada is a signatory to the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and that Canadian mining companies must not violate indigenous people's rights to free, prior and informed consent. They call on Canadian authorities to direct Canadian consular officials to protect the Xinka defenders and to fully implement \"Voices at Risk: Canada's Guidelines on Supporting Human Rights Defenders\" to protect their safety and to preserve the rights of the people of Guatemala and the natural environment there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289795","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to join virtually today, and again, as other members have done, I wish everyone a happy Earth Day.\n\nThe petition I am raising today is not a happy story. However, it is all too typical. There are a lot of examples of Canadian mining companies operating particularly in Latin America, where there are allegations of human rights and environmental abuses.\n\nIn this case, pe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2dcd3f2ab74520c442c1c28e9d8e8a9c2e90db54ce1c8b98cab7709518c72cf6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bdfc4d041e381fb33bbed250e0cd83cfc892c918406436f90b9abd558395067c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ab0245ee2cbe585e9fdb227","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289794,"date":"2026-04-23T20:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this gives us a chance to look at something again. The recognized party status rules were created by law in 1963 to do one thing only, which was to provide funding to parties that have at least 12 members of Parliament in the House. That law said nothing about changing the rights that each member of Parliament has vis-à-vis each other.\n\nAs the leader of the Green Party of Canada with a seat for Saanich—Gulf Islands, I should in theory have equal rights to those of every other member of the House, because the 1963 rule did not say, and no rule has ever said, that members of Parliament from parties with fewer than 12 MPs cannot sit on committees. I verified this quite recently with the clerk to make sure. As the clerk described it, it is a practice of long standing, not a rule.\n\nWhy has the government decided it is okay to provide funding to the NDP members but not to ensure that those very fine members sit on committees?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289794","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this gives us a chance to look at something again. The recognized party status rules were created by law in 1963 to do one thing only, which was to provide funding to parties that have at least 12 members of Parliament in the House. That law said nothing about changing the rights that each member of Parliament has vis-à-vis each other.\n\nAs the leader of the Green Party of Canada with ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b7016f753077caebc83c024fd3b1c3fc3758a17c623464f6fa696597a32f8e46"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93c8244cbbf54ca8aada1fcd913d74fdb85e8a17f4e086010eca6c4041f3a53d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b3524a4233fec1b3c9da758","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289604,"date":"2026-04-24T15:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, does it not occur to my friend from Vaudreuil that it is time to revisit what Jean Chrétien put forward as the most advanced financing laws in Canada, and there have been other points made by other members, to encourage Canadians to vote and to give people a reason to vote, even if they are in a so-called safe riding for a party they do not favour, and restore the per vote support?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289604","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, does it not occur to my friend from Vaudreuil that it is time to revisit what Jean Chrétien put forward as the most advanced financing laws in Canada, and there have been other points made by other members, to encourage Canadians to vote and to give people a reason to vote, even if they are in a so-called safe riding for a party they do not favour, and restore the per vote support?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d98245ad6502745d57215fb677fbd0b7020818815f5ee05bd0e60421d78bfa1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e18bee1ff8c351ebca45cb0fcda4e7802efb9568bbfe820490b0078f5a62cd31"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d337d99852d1303746403985","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289605,"date":"2026-04-24T17:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am presenting virtually today a petition from very concerned residents and people who have been exposed through their military service to toxic contamination from phenoxy herbicides. This dates back to an era even before Agent Orange was used in Vietnam. Various formulations were tested in the vicinity of Camp Gagetown in New Brunswick.\n\nThe petitioners point out that the previous health studies were inadequate and had enormous gaps. They are asking the House and the government to please initiate a public, independent inquiry into the health impacts, on veterans and on neighbouring communities, of the testing of phenoxy herbicides and their widespread use in the vicinity of Camp Gagetown, including the subsequent toxic contamination, as well as the health effects for people who were in the vicinity.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48754","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Herbicides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289605","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am presenting virtually today a petition from very concerned residents and people who have been exposed through their military service to toxic contamination from phenoxy herbicides. This dates back to an era even before Agent Orange was used in Vietnam. Various formulations were tested in the vicinity of Camp Gagetown in New Brunswick.\n\nThe petitioners point out that the previous h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48754","label":"Herbicides"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48754","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Herbicides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48754","label":"Herbicides","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["64ced8d7536457b6f57b33efe880cd7ab72833fbe2c4eaf450f36854f7adcb12"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48754","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Herbicides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b31bb10da5a5da7748d698a9dfc243146f62e4bec7fce38c4273ae715b4e724c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48754","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Herbicides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48754","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9be9a61fa944695376bc693","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289606,"date":"2026-04-24T18:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am sorry. I had to get my headset back on. I know I am late to say that I would like to give a speech on Bill C-25.\n\nIf it is not too late, before debate collapses—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289606","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am sorry. I had to get my headset back on. I know I am late to say that I would like to give a speech on Bill C-25.\n\nIf it is not too late, before debate collapses—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc4bf233809ba05a142cc5a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":289793,"date":"2026-04-24T18:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am sorry, it is because I had surgery on Tuesday.\n\nI am very disappointed not to be able—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:289793","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am sorry, it is because I had surgery on Tuesday.\n\nI am very disappointed not to be able—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9bb2006dfecf8b64d44e823c3266f69ecca572bfce08358b077a03735a779eb9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["426c31a302ed58db24c9326208f470985a85c1c81d6ce8bbe8a0f31879990f60"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5221dbca2574ee39af01b4f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722313,"date":"2026-04-27T17:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I do not know to whom to direct the concern, but my desk has been moved and I cannot rise in my place in this space due to the post and the chairs. I do not know what to do about this. Perhaps there can be some accommodation organized by House officers. I do not know.\n\n I am sorry. I wish to speak, but this is the first time I have tried to rise in my new seat, and it is not really possible.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722313","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I do not know to whom to direct the concern, but my desk has been moved and I cannot rise in my place in this space due to the post and the chairs. I do not know what to do about this. Perhaps there can be some accommodation organized by House officers. I do not know.\n\n I am sorry. I wish to speak, but this is the first time I have tried to rise in my new seat, and it is not really po","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9ae2bf9d48c79137a9b2967d802008ce08f8aebf802c4b032042be03127e721"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2f8c854137d14943f04e159","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722321,"date":"2026-04-27T17:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am speaking now from a spot that has a chair with no arms, which means I can stand up and address the hon. government House leader.\n\n The purpose of this debate is to bring closure on the debate on Motion No. 9. I hope I will have a chance to speak more substantively to Motion No. 9 later this day.\n\nOn an unprecedented matter and doing something unusual, which is taking the matter of changing House committees from their normal process to a motion debated in the House that will be carried by what we now know is a majority of Liberal members, would the hon. government House leader explain why it is urgent that we close down debate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722321","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am speaking now from a spot that has a chair with no arms, which means I can stand up and address the hon. government House leader.\n\n The purpose of this debate is to bring closure on the debate on Motion No. 9. I hope I will have a chance to speak more substantively to Motion No. 9 later this day.\n\nOn an unprecedented matter and doing something unusual, which is taking the matter o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb3b9a85f0fc75a48893c166","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722326,"date":"2026-04-27T18:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the hon. member for St. Catharines says that it has been fundamental to parliamentary democracy. I wonder if he would agree with me that the process of parliamentary democracy in this place is continually, regardless of who is in power, to reduce the rights and powers of smaller parties in favour of their own rights and powers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722326","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the hon. member for St. Catharines says that it has been fundamental to parliamentary democracy. I wonder if he would agree with me that the process of parliamentary democracy in this place is continually, regardless of who is in power, to reduce the rights and powers of smaller parties in favour of their own rights and powers.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e42f6957de1cc211c4121df9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722328,"date":"2026-04-27T20:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is the first time I have heard publicly that the member was specifically courted and that there was an attempt to recruit her to cross the floor. I wonder if she could expand on that and confirm whether it is true. It is the first time I have heard it, and it is indeed shocking because we have been assured by the government benches that they never tried to recruit anyone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722328","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is the first time I have heard publicly that the member was specifically courted and that there was an attempt to recruit her to cross the floor. I wonder if she could expand on that and confirm whether it is true. It is the first time I have heard it, and it is indeed shocking because we have been assured by the government benches that they never tried to recruit anyone.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3f44e26dd1962d787183407","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722330,"date":"2026-04-27T21:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from Saint‐Jean for her excellent speech. I completely agree with her. She raised some points and shared new figures. Well, they were new to me, at least. The member showed that the committees are not an obstacle to progress here in the House. I thank her for that.\n\nWas there anything else my colleague wanted to add?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722330","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from Saint‐Jean for her excellent speech. I completely agree with her. She raised some points and shared new figures. Well, they were new to me, at least. The member showed that the committees are not an obstacle to progress here in the House. I thank her for that.\n\nWas there anything else my colleague wanted to add?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f0ecaa904a7107b28ecf1444f8ffdc4da9beccd86aabf10e83a9655a70d590a5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d8fbb234b3ee84b0ae92be4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722333,"date":"2026-04-27T21:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to have the opportunity to speak today. It is always an honour to rise in the House. I am speaking today as part of the debate on a key issue, specifically government Motion No. 9. The purpose of this motion is to introduce changes that could be described as innovative. These are unprecedented changes aimed at altering the composition of committees.\n\n We know what the topic is before us. It is certainly unprecedented because the situation is unprecedented. We have never had in this place a change after an election where the composition of committees is to be changed because, according to the government, there are now more Liberal MPs than there were after the election. There is no question regarding the numbers: the result is that we have moved from a minority Parliament to a majority Parliament.\n\n It gives me an opportunity to get to some of the basics that we very rarely get to talk about in this place, which is assumptions that are made about the nature of committees and the rights of individual members. Unquestioned, in the way this motion is put forward, is the notion I wrote to the Prime Minister about, after the election. I said, \"Please do not forget to include, when they are considering committee makeup, the very respected and experienced parliamentarians who happen at the moment to be in an unrecognized party.\" I was speaking not of myself and the Green Party, but of, at that point, seven New Democratic Party MPs who were experienced, thoughtful parliamentarians who all had good experience on committees.\n\n We knew we had a lot of new MPs. We have seen problems where committees can become overtaken by an effort to filibuster, but it is not always the case. Certainly, experienced MPs with committee experience are worth consideration to put on committees. That certainly is not immediately the issue at hand with the numbers and rejigging the numbers to ensure that there is a Liberal majority of members on those committees. I am unfortunately in a position where I cannot say what the Prime Minister thought about my proposal because, although I put a lot of thought and effort into that letter, I did not get so much as a courtesy reply, \"We have received your letter and we will get back to you at some point when we have absolutely nothing better to do and can consider it.\"\n\nI went through the research to confirm what I understood to be the case, which is the status of every member of Parliament. I put it the other day to the hon. government House leader, who agreed with me. \"Oh yes indeed, all members are equal in this place. Oh yes indeed, we all have equal rights,\" said the hon. leader of the government in the House. Obviously, yes, that is our fiction, but our reality is somewhat different. I had more rights in this place when I was first elected in May 2011 than I have today.\n\n As is always the case, larger and more powerful parties spend a great deal of effort to reduce the rights of smaller parties. Smaller parties and opposition parties spend a lot of effort trying to scupper what a larger party wants to do when it is in government. It is kind of an endless cycle and it is not really in the interest of democracy. It is also not what happens in other Westminster parliamentary systems around the world.\n\n I am going to spend a bit of time now going back through the recognized party rules. What does it mean to be a member of a recognized party? What are their rights in that situation? I double-checked with our Clerk before I wrote the letter to the Prime Minister, to say, \"Am I right? Is it the case?\" I just wanted to double-check that nothing has changed in our rules. In 1963, Parliament passed a law that created the concept of a recognized party. Without any self-interest, the members of the larger parties decided larger parties should by right have money in order to support their work in Parliament. Because larger parties have so much more work than smaller parties, goes the fiction, they need public funds to do the work of MPs in Parliament. That is the recognized party law from 1963. It has been unchanged. It says that if they have 12 members, they get money. That is all it says. It does not say anywhere that if the party has fewer than 12 members, they do not get as many questions in question period. It does not say anywhere that if they have fewer than 12 members, they have no right to be a full member of any standing committee.\n\nI double-checked with the clerk. I suggested to the clerk, and I hope the clerk does not mind me recounting the conversation, as I do not think it was terribly private, that this constitutes a really bad habit, this practice of saying that the member for Saanich—Gulf Islands cannot sit on any committee and would get one question once a week at the end of question period, etc. That is not part of the recognized party law. That is a bad habit. The clerk put it into more parliamentary language: It is a practice of long standing. In other words, I did not have it wrong. There is no law or rule that says members of Parliament from whatever size party cannot be full members of a standing committee. It offends no rule. It offends no law. It just ignores a practice of long standing. However, it adheres far more closely to our beautiful fiction that all members of Parliament are equal to every other member of Parliament and that the Prime Minister is merely primus inter pares, first among equals.\n\n We know that when the recognized party rule was created, it created two tiers of MPs. One is those from larger, recognized parties. For citizens who may be watching this discussion, the minute we get 12 members of Parliament, we get about $1 million in extra resources from the parliamentary budget to support our parliamentary work. We have had cases, and I will not mention them, where parties have used the money they get for parliamentary work quite inappropriately, and I would say illegally, for partisan purposes. However, that is a separate question. The money is the only thing the 1963 recognized party law is about. Rights to participate in committees are not a part of that, nor are rights in question period, etc. \n\nThen we go to this: How far and wide is this practice in Westminster parliamentary democracy? How much did this Canadian idea of recognized parties catch on? The answer is, not at all, not anywhere. We are the only Westminster parliamentary democracy that ever created the idea that there are two tiers, that larger party MPs or their parties get money—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722333","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to have the opportunity to speak today. It is always an honour to rise in the House. I am speaking today as part of the debate on a key issue, specifically government Motion No. 9. The purpose of this motion is to introduce changes that could be described as innovative. These are unprecedented changes aimed at altering the composition of committees.\n\n We know what the top","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a017b7dce5dcf938e8ea2c4144cac721052af65e8f2a86c901414de06625585"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc96cbe4ddf9d0e74dd0288c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722335,"date":"2026-04-27T21:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what I am putting forward is entirely on point with respect to the motion we have before us. The assumption that underlies what the government is doing with this motion is that it was beyond even consideration that there should be seats on the committee for members of the New Democratic Party or the Green Party or any members who happen to sit in this place as independents. There is no rule against it. I think most members of Parliament, if I gave a pop quiz, would be surprised to hear that we are the only Westminster parliamentary democracy that uses this concept of a recognized party at all. \n\n Beyond that, when we look at the results after an election, if we are looking at proportionality, which is at the essence of the government's position in Motion No. 9 because it now has a majority of representation in this place, we want committees to actually reflect the way people voted, with the number of seats at committee reflecting the number of votes obtained in an election, to reflect the democracy of this House into each committee. I think it would have been worthwhile, although I note that it was not considered by the Liberal benches, to consider that proportionality would include the approximately or somewhat under 8% of Canadians who did not vote for any of the recognized parties. That would be some representation on committees, which the Liberals could still have considered when putting forward Motion No. 9, and I think they should have considered it.\n\nAs I said, I wrote the Prime Minister about the composition of committees at the very beginning of his mandate to suggest that we want committees to work and that experienced parliamentarians from any party should be considered for full membership because it offends no rule at all, and it reflects more of the principles on which we believe this place to be founded in a Westminster parliamentary democracy.\n\nWe are all equal, and each and every one of us has the same rights, the same powers and the same tools to find solutions for Canadians.\n\n When I speak to the motion, it actually is important and directly on point to point out that the recognized party law has been misunderstood for many decades now, and it would be a good time, when we are in this unprecedented transition, to go back to what our House of Commons stands for. That is the reason that it is not an offence under parliamentary rules for someone elected as a Conservative to decide to go sit with the Liberal Party, any more than it was for a Liberal member of Parliament from Paul Martin's immediately deceased cabinet. David Emerson comes to mind. He was elected as a Liberal, and when former prime minister Stephen Harper swore in his new cabinet, there were jaws dropping all over the place as the limos pulled up in front of Rideau Hall and famous Liberal David Emerson got out to be sworn in as a member of Stephen Harper's cabinet.\n\n This is a perpetual problem in Parliament. It is really awkward, because most people have short memories and forget they are living in a glass house. When someone lives in a glass house, it is not a good idea to throw stones. We can say many things about floor crossing, but it is not against our rules, and it is certainly not a surprise, depending on who has just gained the person who crossed the floor. I lost a dear friend. She is still a friend, but I lost a friend when the member for Fredericton, elected as a Green, went and sat with the Liberals. I never said a single mean or nasty thing about her. Her reasons were her own.\n\n Under our system of Westminster parliamentary democracy, we do not put forward candidates to act as cardboard cutouts, as proxy representatives of the leader who cannot be present everywhere, with a recorder button that we can push to hear the voice on some kind of cassette tape. I am using a very old-fashioned reference. I am sure that, with all the social media and AI that we have, we could get a hologram leader of a party to travel around with every candidate and actually seem to be speaking to their constituents. However, the point is that we run as individuals. We are elected in our ridings by our constituents, and the only place we can find a job description for what we are supposed to do as members of Parliament, because there is not a very handy job description, is in our Constitution. All it says is that members of Parliament represent constituencies.\n\nBack to Motion No. 9, what we are doing here is not a big surprise, but I do think there have been cogent arguments made by a number of opposition members as to why this is not a good idea and would create a precedent that the Liberals today may regret having put in place for a future occasion. I found particularly compelling the argument from the member for Saint-Jean.\n\nThe member for Saint-Jean contributed additional data to today's debate. She did some research and presented evidence showing that committees do not have a strong track record when it comes to creating barriers.\n\nThe member for Saint-Jean pointed out with evidence that in the last number of years, parliamentary committees have not been blocking government legislation. Sometimes it has actually been Liberals in control of Parliament who have filibustered their own legislation. In fact, right before the last election, we had a long period of time when the whole House of Commons was caught up in a Conservative motion on a matter of privilege before committee. All of us who were serving at that time will remember it as sort of a long and painful version of Groundhog Day, where every day we debated the same thing, and every time the Conservatives amended their own motion, they reset the clock and every Conservative member could speak to the same thing again and again. Therefore, the filibustering of one's own motion is not unheard of. Filibustering in committee, even for one's own bill, is not unheard of. \n\nCommittees need to function well, and for them to function well, there needs to be a basis of trust and respect in this place. Since I was first elected, I have seen it deteriorate. One thing that deteriorates trust and respect in this place is when members of Parliament are bulldozed by the party with more power. I have experienced, just for the record, more bulldozing since the April 28 general election in this place as a member of Parliament for the Green Party. I feel sort of more physical pain from the bulldozing that took place to get through Bill C-5 very quickly, with full Conservative Party support, no obstruction and no interfering with the Liberal government's agenda. Things were moving with a lot of co-operation, except for those of us who objected, and those of us who are not in recognized parties, as I said, have fewer rights today than I had when I was elected in 2011, because I can no longer stand with four other members of Parliament and insist on a recorded vote, which I was able to do from 2011 until the COVID outbreak. \n\nI know that the debate is going to come to an end very shortly. I do not want to use my full time allotted, because I think my points have been made pretty clearly at this point. I would ask, and I hope, that when we look at this again, PROC will be engaged to study committee membership. I hope we will actually have a proper study and discussion of why we have misinterpreted the recognized party rules to such an extent that there are two tiers. It does get very Orwellian. All MPs are equal, but some are more equal than others. \n\nWith that, I urge this place to defeat the motion before us and attempt, if we possibly can, not to build this place on \"might makes right\" or \"numbers rule all\", but get to a place where we have real conversations and real study and respect democracy and the people who sent us here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722335","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what I am putting forward is entirely on point with respect to the motion we have before us. The assumption that underlies what the government is doing with this motion is that it was beyond even consideration that there should be seats on the committee for members of the New Democratic Party or the Green Party or any members who happen to sit in this place as independents. There is n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Self employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037077","label":"Self employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e70063eb988acdfdc75d008f4bb6665006add2d6a02e535e901a535891fb3a64"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75f37c4bd7dd0559b04715ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722340,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague from Winnipeg North will recall that nowhere in my speech did I draw attention to any difficulties myself, as three of my private member's bills have become law. I think that exceeds the batting average for most. What I am pointing out is that members of committees should have been considered from more than just the three recognized parties. With only three recognized parties, power has shifted even more into a centralized role. \n\nI agree that this motion does not change my rights, but it does give me an opportunity to point out that the recognized party rules are misinterpreted and misunderstood, and I am not an independent member. I am a member here on behalf of the Green Party of Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722340","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague from Winnipeg North will recall that nowhere in my speech did I draw attention to any difficulties myself, as three of my private member's bills have become law. I think that exceeds the batting average for most. What I am pointing out is that members of committees should have been considered from more than just the three recognized parties. With only three recognize","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","label":"Green products","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b36741078630ea48a6760d3a33a05e514be2d2c9af7423de506885c3f10062e7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-46e5d33460617056d859428e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722342,"date":"2026-04-27T22:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the purpose of every government I have witnessed is to accumulate more power for itself and generally more power for its prime minister. This is not the way of healthy democracies.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722342","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the purpose of every government I have witnessed is to accumulate more power for itself and generally more power for its prime minister. This is not the way of healthy democracies.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["660ed36937e5b4915774eeb147fb1385a7ad57bf7d77147832cd33a5d371e19a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-898ccc1ab6cce73bddcc057d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722346,"date":"2026-04-27T22:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my esteemed Bloc Québécois colleague. I think he is right. To answer his question, I think that the current government is on the wrong track. The government has done away with programs aimed at addressing the climate crisis. It has passed bills that violate the rights of refugees, for example.\n\nThe government has lost sight of several priorities. I used to think that the Liberal Party shared these priorities, but not anymore.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722346","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my esteemed Bloc Québécois colleague. I think he is right. To answer his question, I think that the current government is on the wrong track. The government has done away with programs aimed at addressing the climate crisis. It has passed bills that violate the rights of refugees, for example.\n\nThe government has lost sight of several priorities. I used to think that the Liber","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7738c52b319fd98bd7993f03cf38be475a0cd7c7b97267e650fbec19a0a5dbe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-073db5014fde05b2dd51f424","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722348,"date":"2026-04-27T22:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is true. It is almost the anniversary of the election and there are several members for whom this is their first year in the House. I very much regret that they have not had the experience I had. I worked for the Progressive Conservative government. I was not a party member, but I worked for Mr. Mulroney's majority government. There was more democracy back then. There was more commitment to the environment and to human rights.\n\nI am disappointed. We must establish systems that work for humanity and for the planet. We must not give in to the current power of a government that has a Prime Minister who is very popular, but not very democratic.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722348","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is true. It is almost the anniversary of the election and there are several members for whom this is their first year in the House. I very much regret that they have not had the experience I had. I worked for the Progressive Conservative government. I was not a party member, but I worked for Mr. Mulroney's majority government. There was more democracy back then. There was more comm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf82f3197d97e4c1f5297ffaa92a23770a12970873fefedef4af969f56182a1e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f62bfe5821553668d5e9ce24","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722349,"date":"2026-04-27T22:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, here is my advice. If they want to make a difference for their grandchildren, then the members need to immediately reject the opinion of their party whip. They need to show moral courage for the sake of our grandchildren and our county. To make a difference, it is vital that every member is able to exercise their rights in the name of democracy, not merely for the sake of the leader's power.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722349","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, here is my advice. If they want to make a difference for their grandchildren, then the members need to immediately reject the opinion of their party whip. They need to show moral courage for the sake of our grandchildren and our county. To make a difference, it is vital that every member is able to exercise their rights in the name of democracy, not merely for the sake of the leader's","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c44824e78960a86070bc0d7e3122505e080160477f6c8a5ef99081b8713e7ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf4cb968e28c65cc8ecfa0bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722354,"date":"2026-04-27T22:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as far as we know, there has never been an effort to recruit MPs to shift from a minority government situation to a majority. As I mentioned, it is not unusual to see members cross the floor. Again, there is nothing particularly against our principles, but I think it does tend to, increasingly out there in the hustings, feel a bit fishy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722354","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as far as we know, there has never been an effort to recruit MPs to shift from a minority government situation to a majority. As I mentioned, it is not unusual to see members cross the floor. Again, there is nothing particularly against our principles, but I think it does tend to, increasingly out there in the hustings, feel a bit fishy.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1fcfd0829009e40995691fda8e1aa47aeadc33bce68a79ffa90d86392d2c46d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b7aef8fe1576bc7c401ca8b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722296,"date":"2026-04-28T23:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my friend from Vancouver Kingsway, the parliamentary leader for the New Democratic Party. I agreed with every single thing he said, right up until when he said the NDP was the only party in this place to stand up for universal pharmacare. We will continue to agree with him that the current Liberal government has abandoned it by not concluding agreements with every province. We are the only country that has universal public health care but does not have complete coverage for prescription drugs.\n\nI would like to ask the hon. member if he would like to expand on and explain how universal pharmacare would bring down health care costs across Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722296","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my friend from Vancouver Kingsway, the parliamentary leader for the New Democratic Party. I agreed with every single thing he said, right up until when he said the NDP was the only party in this place to stand up for universal pharmacare. We will continue to agree with him that the current Liberal government has abandoned it by not concluding agreements with every prov","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036424","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nonprescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036424","label":"Nonprescription drugs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca362da16d9bf754268c09bf0171402a88ab735b989cc392bee5ca0307085447"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f38a0a45383df7d88fbb67fa881aa35151c9f7602169c8b345be841a487d3274"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8b954f228f4522ee1a46023","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722299,"date":"2026-04-28T23:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise at this later hour, having had some hours pass since the Minister of Finance tabled the spring economic update.\n\nIt is always an honour to rise in the House as leader of the Green Party of Canada. It is a great honour for me. \n\nI did not have high expectations or much hope for the 2026 spring economic update—it is not a budget—but still, I am disappointed. No explanation was provided concerning the measures we were expecting. The government promised to provide details on measures it had already announced. They are not in this update.\n\nI want to explain the things that are most important to the Green Party, including the challenges facing Canada right now. It is clear that the Prime Minister and the Liberal majority government are facing major challenges related to global events beyond their control.\n\nIt is very clear, and I do not want to suggest that the situation would be easy if I were in the Prime Minister's chair. It would not be easy for any government to deal with the fact that our greatest ally and trading partner, our neighbour to the south, is no longer a reliable ally, which is a gross understatement.\n\nWe are not just dealing with our regional relationships, as neighbours here on Turtle Island, between the United States and Canada. We are dealing with much more than that. What Donald Trump represents to the world is the source of geopolitical instability. \n\nThe United States and Israel together launched a war on Iran. I agree with my colleague from the New Democrat Party, and it needs to be acknowledged every time we talk about the impacts of the war in Iran, that it is an illegal war. It did not have even the minimal justifications under international law of necessity for a war. It is a war of choice. It was reckless.\n\nMuch of the spring economic statement talks about the economic uncertainty created by what is now happening, the disruption of the war against Iran and how it spread with Israel's attacks on Lebanon and Iran's retaliation against numerous gulf states. There is no question that there are challenges for any finance department or any central bank anywhere in the world in trying to project and predict what the world holds, what the economy is going to be like even six months from now, much less on a usual budgetary horizon of budgeting out and forecasting four years' worth of spending.\n\nStill, despite those challenges, I am surprised at this spring economic statement's overall tone. It is remarkably sanguine, as if we do know what is ahead and can confidently predict that the government has done a great job already.\n\nFor instance, there are numerous graphs and charts throughout this spring economic statement that present a picture that is not real. Even in examining the pictures that are in the budget and looking at the graphs, there are claims that we have done a great job of expanding markets outside of the United States for our fossil fuel exports. It is suggested in graphs and bar charts. To the casual observer, it might seem that we had made a major difference in how much of our fossil fuel exports do not go to the United States anymore. Those bar charts are misleading. They say there has been a big increase in non-U.S. exports. Yeah, from 3% to 10%, and when we present percentages in bar charts, we can make that look like a lot, but the reality is still the same. About 90% of our fossil fuel exports go to the United States.\n\nIt is the same thing for exports of our other products. Our economies are still very interlocked. We are mutually dependent on each other's exports and imports. We do want trade diversification; Greens do as well. Again, the tone of the spring economic update is remarkably sanguine.\n\nThere is a comment on page 27 that suggests that longer-term oil price expectations are now more firmly anchored. I am baffled by that. Certainly, global energy economists do not share that sense of assurance that we now have more firmly anchored oil price expectations. On the contrary, around the world, energy economists are saying that it is extremely volatile, that it does not seem to be settling down and that there is no way we would possibly know that. Given that, the appropriate things to do are not necessarily where the government is heading.\n\nThere is much discussion in the spring economic update of how the Middle East uncertainty, the illegal war against Iran launched by the United States and Israel, is going to affect Canada's future. In reading the spring economic update, it is as though the most we can say about it is that it has been some kind of blip and that we can almost say we are going to be past it soon. That is completely contradicted by the opinion of experts.\n\nI am saddened by the fact that there is no mention in the spring economic update of the conclusion of one of the world's leading energy economists and experts, the executive director of the International Energy Agency, Fatih Birol. He has said very clearly that the oil crisis triggered by the Iran war has changed the fossil fuel industry for ever.\n\nWhat the International Energy Agency is saying is that the days of fossil fuels are now very limited and it is not just by the climate crisis. We should have said the days of fossil fuels are limited some time ago, the days are drawing to a close. Former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau did say that at one point, that we know that we are moving away from fossil fuels.\n\nHowever, this is interesting. We are at a tipping point in terms of climate science and we are at risk. Global scientists are saying we are at a significant risk of hitting a tipping point. There is a whole system called the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation, AMOC. The Gulf Stream is part of it. It is basically a vast conveyor belt of ocean currents in the Atlantic Ocean. We are at the point where global scientists are saying we are perilously close to where it becomes inevitable that the AMOC is going to stall or collapse. This is not just startling or alarming, it is terrifying.\n\nThe scientists who have done this work say they now see that the chances are not less than 5% as previously thought, but are approaching fifty-fifty. That is a global tipping point in climate science, which should be moving us off fossil fuels quite rapidly and toward tree planting and anything we can do to avoid, as the lead scientist on this report said, the collapse of the AMOC. We must avoid its collapse \"at all costs\" because the impact of this would be a rapid climatic shift that is planetary and would soon become inevitable and unstoppable.\n\nThat is a tipping point in global climate science, but here, we have the head of the International Energy Agency saying we have basically hit a tipping point due to geopolitical instability, and that economies around the world are not going to want fossil fuels because of the instability and because they are inevitably and inextricably tied to wars and instability.\n\nThis spring economic update is tone-deaf to even the possibility that Canada's future economic stability is not tied to boosting fossil fuels. We have new subsidies for LNG and new announcements for pipelines, and there is practically a hallelujah chorus for this, but not from the Green Party.\n\nWe are looking at what it means for Canada's economy, not just our survival, as if our survival as a human civilization is a small thing, to hard-wire itself to fossil fuels when we know what we know about the transition that is happening globally based on price alone. Price point alone is moving investment dollars away from fossil fuels and rapidly to renewable energy, to solar, wind and geothermal, but particularly solar because solar electricity is now cheaper than coal. \n\nIt is astonishing that in the spring economic statement, renewable energy is not mentioned or increased. There is no commitment to expand it. We do have a commitment here that we have been waiting for, for some time. The November 4, 2025, budget, said, at page 19, that one of the great building Canada strong kinds of projects would be \"building clean power grids for a sustainable future\". We have been waiting for announcements for a green electricity grid for some time. The Prime Minister has hinted at it at various points at press conferences. He said we would see this commitment to a green electricity grid strategy very soon. \n\nIn this spring economic statement, it is mentioned, all right, that something we are looking at is building \"a stronger grid\" for Canada, but what we get is not a commitment to fund it, build it or put it on the major projects list. What we get is that very soon we will see a discussion paper. That is not just underwhelming; it is appallingly negligent. We need to do more than have a discussion paper about a key piece of infrastructure that has been promised over and over again without details, and now, after all of that, what we get in today's spring economic update is the promise of a discussion paper to be released soon. The ways in which this disappoints are quite numerous, and I know I have enough speaking time to get to some of them, but not all of them. \n\nLet us look again at what was one of the big-ticket items announced yesterday. Before we got the spring economic statement, we were told that Canada is unveiling a new Canadian sovereign wealth fund. It sounds wonderful. It sounds very patriotic. It sounds like a new idea. Of course, it immediately brought to light and raised comparisons with Norway's sovereign wealth fund. We were told that there would be details in the spring economic statement of how this was going to work. The Prime Minister said yesterday that the sovereign wealth fund was also going to give individual Canadians a chance to invest, and that was going to be part of this. The sovereign wealth fund would allow individual Canadians to be part of putting together the investment dollars that we need for a sovereign wealth fund. \n\nFirst of all, let us compare it to Norway. Norway's sovereign wealth fund was built on taxation of oil revenues. Ironically, it was the Norwegian experts who came to Alberta who understood the rules of Peter Lougheed, who was a visionary, for developing the oil sands: \"act like an owner\" and \"don't live on oil rents but set them to the side\". The sovereign wealth fund has allowed individual Norwegians to have millions of dollars of assets in a sovereign wealth fund built on North Sea oil. Ironically, that Norwegian sovereign wealth fund was developed based on what Peter Lougheed was doing in Alberta, which was then cancelled by Ralph Klein. It is interesting how leaders of the same party can follow such radically different approaches. In any case, Norway's sovereign wealth fund was built on oil taxation with revenues for the benefit of all. \n\nWhat is the Canada Strong fund going to be? We do not know yet. We do know that it is not based on revenues from taxation of oil wealth. It is, rather, the opposite. It is based on borrowing $25 billion, again public borrowing and debt, to call it a sovereign wealth fund. We do not have any details in today's document. The spring economic statement has no details on how this is going to work.\n\nWe do know that we have created a new entity once again. It is very common in the current government for all kinds of new offices to open, and the Canada Strong fund now would have a Canada Strong fund transition office. The Canada Strong fund transition office, once established, and of course it does not exist now, would consult widely and then tell us how the Canada Strong fund would work.\n\nIf it is not ready to be announced, the Liberals could wait until they had answers before announcing things, but that is just me. I would like to know the details about something that is basically the top-line headline for the spring economic update: that we have a new, first time ever, Canadian sovereign wealth fund.\n\nJust as advice to the government, I will say that it might be useful to figure out how to do this, because the Green Party already did the research. We asked the Parliamentary Budget Office to figure out how we could have funding for Canadians and for our own resources, and create it based on the concept of Canada savings bonds. We called them \"saving Canada bonds\", and we had the Parliamentary Budget Office cost this out for us.\n\nIf we have strategic reserves of our resources, to avoid having them shipped to the U.S. and tariffed or whatever, we could, for instance, buy up all of Canada's potash at the price that potash producers want to receive, at market prices, and we could store it. We actually had the Parliamentary Budget Office include reasonable estimates for what it would cost to store the potash until we wanted to sell it to someone. There would be a guaranteed return on investment to individual Canadians of 5%.\n\nTherefore, I recommend to the Minister of Finance that he have a look. I have already mentioned this to the Prime Minister. On the Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer's website is the research that was done, because once the PBO does research for a political party, it does not belong just to the political party for which it did the research. It is publicly available information. The government could find out how to generate $50 billion in revenue from wealth taxes or how to use financial transaction taxes at basically 20¢ for every $100 in stock market transactions, and how that would create new sources of government revenue to afford the things we need.\n\n We need to address rapidly what is happening with youth unemployment. We need to address what is happening in the affordability crisis. Yes, we should have excess profit taxes on the grocery chains and, yes, excess profit taxes on oil and gas companies and wealth taxes on the very wealthiest people, not affecting most Canadians. These are things we could do. By asking the Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer to cost them out, we have proven they can be done.\n\n Actually, it is striking to me that the Green Party, with our rather abysmal lack of resources compared to the Government of Canada's resources, did a better job pointing out how we could protect our economy, protect our natural resources, avoid Trump's tariffs and have better economic sovereignty than the Government of Canada has done to date. Members can please check if they do not believe me. We actually brought the deficit down more as a party than did any other party, not by cutting, but by generating new revenue for the Government of Canada.\n\n The government claims that there is revenue. It is a shocking claim in the spring economic update that there is more revenue by expanding a subsidy. This goes back to one of the main reasons that the former minister of the environment resigned over last year's budget. At page 348 of the November 2025 budget there was a commitment that investment tax credits would apply for carbon capture, utilization and storage \"but not [for] enhanced oil recovery\".\n\nIn this spring economic update, we finally find out, because it was very clear that the commitment made to Danielle Smith in the November 27 MOU with Alberta very specifically said that there would be investment tax credits available for enhanced oil recovery. This is a little tricky, and I will try to get through it quickly. We had to ask a lot of questions in our off-the-record lock-up with the Department of Finance Canada officials, because I just found it too perplexing for words to hear that now the Liberals were going to admit that, as of today, there will be investment tax credits available for enhanced oil recovery.\n\nAstonishingly, at page 64, it says that this will, \"increase federal revenues by $395 million over four years\". I had to press. I asked how increasing a subsidy to the oil and gas industry would increase federal revenue. The government had to admit that It might be considered misleading because it does not actually increase government revenue. What it does is decrease some government spending as against the system of November 2025, the carbon capture, utilization and storage piece. The Government of Canada was supporting keeping carbon in the ground, which meant it was paying to help the oil and gas industry store carbon. When it does not store as much, because with enhanced oil recovery it takes it out of the ground, it increases the profits of the oil industry by allowing that oil to come out of the ground and be sold and burned. I kept pressing on how that would increase federal revenues, as the spring economic update claims at page 64. Finally, it was admitted that it was not exactly that it increases the revenue, but decreases the spending, as the federal government no longer has to provide as much money to the oil industry for the purpose of keeping carbon in the ground. It just creates more profits for the oil industry and somewhat reduces the spending of the federal government. It is not new revenue. \n\nThere is so much here that I found difficult to absorb and hard to accept, particularly the government's vision on artificial intelligence. I have to say, from yesterday's protests of young people on the lawns of Parliament, that they are concerned about the impacts of artificial intelligence and screen time on their mental health and well-being. Here we have the government's vision, \"Artificial Intelligence for All\". That is just plain tone-deaf. We need legislation that regulates online harms from this development. We are not going to be able to stop AI, but the idea that we are going to have a homegrown AI industry that creates lots of jobs for Canadians is hooey. However, it is a big part, apparently, of the vision of the government for the future of Canada's economy.\n\nI will close by saying this. There are opportunities for Canada, even in this world of geopolitical instability. There are opportunities for us to stand up for human rights, to stand up for other democracies, to only trade with other democracies that respect human rights and to be a beacon of hope and sanity in this world. However, to decide, as though we are still living in the 1950s, that our future lies in fossil fuels, and that economic growth and growing the GDP is enough to make Canada a more prosperous country with greater societal well-being, is simply wrong. It does not lead us there. History has taught us that. What makes Canada's economy strong is economic sovereignty. What gives us resilience is to not be dependent on the United States to the degree we are, but to broaden our links and link arms with democracies that respect human rights and climate action. That is not too late to achieve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722299","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise at this later hour, having had some hours pass since the Minister of Finance tabled the spring economic update.\n\nIt is always an honour to rise in the House as leader of the Green Party of Canada. It is a great honour for me. \n\nI did not have high expectations or much hope for the 2026 spring economic update—it is not a budget—but still, I am disappointed. No e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c70898825c05df664deafb6c8cb165cdd01ce9452e367014b7781d1d41abdde7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8676f7b28d13517907c4a4ff92d61219ada4f40e05c45e47e1aa189f241206fc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa15720902b61a378fdfce08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722311,"date":"2026-04-28T23:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I totally agree with my hon. colleague from Edmonton Strathcona that this is also worrying. It appears that the government thinks there is enough of a surplus in the Canada pension plan that it is okay to reduce contributions. We need to know that there is not going to be a reduction in the benefits to which senior Canadians are entitled, and we need to know that it is not seen as a business tax.\n\nAlso, there is one quick thing, if I may. The Canada Pension Plan Investment Board Act is one of the pieces of legislation that should be amended. There is $80 billion in the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board. It has access to $80 billion, and most of it is invested in the United States. All it looks at is the return on investment, not thinking of Canada first in regard to where we invest our Canada pension plan dollars. It is shocking.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722311","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I totally agree with my hon. colleague from Edmonton Strathcona that this is also worrying. It appears that the government thinks there is enough of a surplus in the Canada pension plan that it is okay to reduce contributions. We need to know that there is not going to be a reduction in the benefits to which senior Canadians are entitled, and we need to know that it is not seen as a b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["78d8e9298d8b8292c886244eef740cb17c48434f5b4d52ccc1d221a4b2968182"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c726b4c18322640cf5721431d49cd8febd08753fb84755dfc732d2459ee11da"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc84ac6cff8fd67f7f19a89e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722295,"date":"2026-04-29T20:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present a petition on behalf of concerned residents of Saanich—Gulf Islands and others. The petitioners note that what we have learned from the empirical evidence is that for people who suffer from mental health issues and substance abuse, incarcerating them is not effective in alleviating the burden to society, the individual or their family.\n\nTherefore, the petitioners call upon the government to cease incarceration of people who suffer from drug abuse and to rehabilitate them back into society through treatment programs, as is done in Portugal.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722295","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present a petition on behalf of concerned residents of Saanich—Gulf Islands and others. The petitioners note that what we have learned from the empirical evidence is that for people who suffer from mental health issues and substance abuse, incarcerating them is not effective in alleviating the burden to society, the individual or their family.\n\nTherefore, the petiti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d2a5c19c0a6394de704241ca171e42743c0e2ae9f6a006c86871a1fd8ffe476"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f9d5c854ca0f962f81e7b84","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101389,"date":"2026-04-29T21:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"No, you don't, actually, Mr. Chair. If I may, I have a point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101389","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, you don't, actually, Mr. Chair. If I may, I have a point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24e4797b3cb98696e443316391b693df04915bec46fae34db1086e7463a564e3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c4119ef15974c1a175e0fb4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101390,"date":"2026-04-29T21:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"No, I don't, Mr. Chair. I want to explain the terms on which Ms. Gazan and I are here, because it seems that other members may be unfamiliar with them. I'll ask for your consent to do it now, or I'll do it when my first amendment comes up. It's up to you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101390","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, I don't, Mr. Chair. I want to explain the terms on which Ms. Gazan and I are here, because it seems that other members may be unfamiliar with them. I'll ask for your consent to do it now, or I'll do it when my first amendment comes up. It's up to you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86e54ae08f204d8d6d703723","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101391,"date":"2026-04-29T21:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"Mr. Chair—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101391","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Chair—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-644ab0ebe32d031a25630cff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101392,"date":"2026-04-29T21:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"I'm sorry. I'd like to remind the chair—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101392","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm sorry. I'd like to remind the chair—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de2092cfedbdf95453ce2ef8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101393,"date":"2026-04-29T21:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101393","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c72e5f1d48c2cb31dab447e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101394,"date":"2026-04-29T21:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"Mr. Chair, you know that personally I show you grace and respect, but the motion of June 17 was not routine. I'd like to put on the record that if it were not for the committee's choosing to pass that motion of its own volition, Ms. Gazan and I would have, as members of parties that are not \"recognized\", the right to bring forward substantive amendments at report stage. This motion was a device to avoid our rights, initially instigated by the Prime Minister's Office when Stephen Harper was in power, and it has since been carried into every committee. As a result, we are more or less required, if we want to put forward amendments, to come to committee. It's not our choice. It's rather coercive, but the motion has been carried, and that's why I object to the notion that Ms. Gazan needed anyone's permission to speak. We are here because the motion that was carried on June 17 in this committee says that if we want to present an amendment, this is the fashion in which we must do it. Our motions are deemed moved. We are, under the motion, permitted to speak to our amendments—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101394","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, you know that personally I show you grace and respect, but the motion of June 17 was not routine. I'd like to put on the record that if it were not for the committee's choosing to pass that motion of its own volition, Ms. Gazan and I would have, as members of parties that are not \"recognized\", the right to bring forward substantive amendments at report stage. This motion was a device to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a791b2ad47ee6c8bf9493e2da1e944196f14b8ce464ba093834eadf07de9a23"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a843638a801cfc7058140c8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101395,"date":"2026-04-29T21:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"You don't have a choice. That's your motion. It carried.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101395","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You don't have a choice. That's your motion. It carried.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2e23725a689ad33faae299a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101396,"date":"2026-04-29T21:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I go to a lot of trouble to prepare amendments for committees, and I just want it on the record that this is not my choice. I'd have had more rights if you hadn't passed the motion. I'll now move to my amendment. As the committee knows, many representatives from groups that represent seniors, the elders of this country—Dementia Justice Canada, Elder Abuse Prevention Ontario, the Canadian Network for the Prevention of Elder Abuse and others—have seen in this bill, Bill C-16 , which I support because it is important to end coercive control over intimate partners.... There's also an issue of coercive control over seniors who are relatives. In that context, all of my amendments speak to the same issue: extending the prevention of coercive control over intimate partners to include, throughout the legislation, those who are seniors, those who are family members and those who experience coercive control through other methods. PV-1 is very simple. This is the simplest style of motion. You're right that PV-4 is longer and more complete in its attempt. It is to add \"or relative\" after \"intimate partner\". As you see, it would replace line 15 on page 2.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101396","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I go to a lot of trouble to prepare amendments for committees, and I just want it on the record that this is not my choice. I'd have had more rights if you hadn't passed the motion. I'll now move to my amendment. As the committee knows, many representatives from groups that represent seniors, the elders of this country—Dementia Justice Canada, Elder Abuse Prevention Ontario, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","label":"Elder abuse"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","label":"Elder abuse","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ffb369d4dabd9dee4d7657395c23a3eae61440e7e27c0b420ef36ff4cf233af9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["85016aeec99f1cd2c923e16ff70a56ad7ded1cd2aa149ac653e26953e88e8260"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0e5329ac7c77acfc226b9b70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101397,"date":"2026-04-29T22:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I hope this lightens the mood and makes your heart glad. If—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101397","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I hope this lightens the mood and makes your heart glad. If—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","label":"Automobile safety equipment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["85f70e014a3e1f1a6b074e6fda5228636c677183357fd794bca85b589c939b2f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e575faff929eef2ebfb41804","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101398,"date":"2026-04-29T22:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"I'm in an awkward position here, so I'm going to look to you for guidance. Now that Mr. Housefather has again drawn my attention to G-35, I've been considering it before showing up here today. I am encouraged to see the government effort, as Mr. Housefather has put it, to study it and consider. I know I have a lot of amendments, 11 amendments, to one point only. Under the terms of the motion passed by this committee—not to belabour the point—I have no rights here to suggest that I'd like to withdraw my amendments, knowing that G-35 may actually solve the problem and mean that the voices of so many wonderful groups, like the seniors organizations, the Canadian Network for the Prevention of Elder Abuse and so on, have been heard. If I had the right, I would now say that I would like to withdraw my amendments to save the committee time, because I can confidently expect—I think, but I don't assume—that all my amendments will be defeated. There's no point in taking the committee's time for that, now that I'm particularly encouraged by G-35. Mr. Chair, they are deemed moved. I'm not allowed to do anything about them at this stage.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101398","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm in an awkward position here, so I'm going to look to you for guidance. Now that Mr. Housefather has again drawn my attention to G-35, I've been considering it before showing up here today. I am encouraged to see the government effort, as Mr. Housefather has put it, to study it and consider. I know I have a lot of amendments, 11 amendments, to one point only. Under the terms of the motion passe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a6cebf087c54b3c4463bc83daed15e01cb14829ec6c445b5837b7baf06a2c00c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e876c25920c039bbea58e3a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101399,"date":"2026-04-29T22:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"JUST","text":"That's correct. I request that the committee consider withdrawing all of my amendments. They all speak to the same point.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-27/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101399","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's correct. I request that the committee consider withdrawing all of my amendments. They all speak to the same point.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae9defe7bbb38f6fcf3dfc459c779b978f1ad1bfc68b652be380ef6702f95510"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57e94cacac0d3688510788ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722273,"date":"2026-04-30T18:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my dear colleague from Mount Royal, the parliamentary secretary, for sharing his time with me. I hope he will not regret it after hearing my speech because there are several things in the opposition motion that I agree with. This might be the first time I find myself in this situation. \n\nI usually do not find myself agreeing so very much with opposition day motions from the official opposition. I am watchful, and I really am very careful, of how long it takes to study, be fair and consider what has been put before us. I will try to make a number of points that relate to the multiple paragraphs in the opposition day motion. \n\nI will start with one of the government's announcements and my experience as a parliamentarian and as a Canadian citizen.\n\nA big announcement was made on April 27, the day before \"Canada Strong for All: Spring Economic Update 2026\" was tabled. The Prime Minister announced that we would soon have all the information regarding a new sovereign wealth fund, the Canada Strong fund.\n\nWe were given the big announcement on April 27. There was a press conference. I do not think I got it wrong when the government announced this and that we would get all the details on April 28, the next day.\n\nWe would know the details of how this sovereign wealth fund would work and how Canadians could participate in it as individuals.\n\n We were told the fund would create opportunities for Canadians to make investments and to participate in our sovereign wealth fund. We just had to wait a day for the details. When we get to the details, and this is what I find astonishing, because this seems to happen a lot, on page 56 of the spring economic update, what we are told is that yes, and it is very exciting, we were going to have a \"broadly accessible [fund for] Canadians from coast to coast to coast\" that was \"easy and simple to purchase, hold, and transact\". It was to be the Canada Strong fund, our sovereign wealth fund, but how were we going to find out about it? \n\nThe update says, \"The government will establish a dedicated Canada Strong Fund Transition Office.\" It will, once set up, \"lead a targeted engagement with market participants and regulators, and rapidly finalise the Fund. Further details will be provided in the coming months.\" I am just quoting from the statement. I do not want to be unfair with them, but it is absurd. They cannot say they are going to borrow $25 billion to create a sovereign wealth fund, which is going to have all these great attributes, but first they have to create a transition office.\n\nIt did not need to be like this. We have really good models from Canada for how a sovereign wealth fund can be created. I will take us back in a time machine to a place where good ideas emerged. In 1976 Alberta, Peter Lougheed created a sovereign wealth fund for the province of Alberta. Norway actually sent experts from Norway to Alberta to learn from Alberta about how it was creating a sovereign wealth fund. Norway's sovereign wealth fund is now worth over $2 trillion U.S.\n\nNorway created the sovereign wealth fund based on the principles established by the late and, I think we would all would agree, great Canadian Peter Lougheed, who in establishing the oil sands and investing in them, said we have to look at this resource and have some rules. \n\nOne of Peter Lougheed's first rules was to think like an owner. Another thing he decided was that we do not want to live off the oil rents. We do not want the revenues from oil wealth to go into spending by government. He wanted to set it aside as what we might call a rainy day fund.\n\nAlberta created what was then called the Alberta heritage savings trust, and it was funded largely by resource revenue, which went into the fund and accumulated. It accumulated the wealth. \n\nNorway followed that example. These are the attributes of Norway's fund. I take the points from my hon. colleague from Lakeland, who was just speaking and pointing out the differences between Norway and Canada, and they are taken as read.\n\nLet us look at what Norway established based on what Peter Lougheed put forward. Number one is that it was run by an independent board. No government could touch the principal, and withdrawals were kept by law, so no subsequent politician could do what actually happened in Alberta when Ralph Klein became the premier and took over from Peter Lougheed. I will not editorialize on the differences between Ralph Klein and Peter Lougheed, but I think everybody knows.\n\n Norway's sovereign wealth fund was created as a sovereign wealth fund. What we have in Canada may be a sovereign wealth fund, but we are starting out with borrowing $25 billion to get it started. I do not see any suggestion here that anyone other than Canadians could invest. \n\nWould anyone invest? We do not know what it is. It is definitely a pig in a poke, but on top of that, we are told to wait while a transition office, for which we are paying a couple million dollars a year, decides to consult to figure out what it is. I think we should start with what we know works, which is to tax oil wealth and separate that.\n\nThe Province of Alberta did set it up and did run it. That was in its jurisdiction. The only way the federal government can do it at this point, and I am not proposing this on the floor of the House, but let us be clear that we could do it, is if we were to nationalize that sector and said that we would set aside that wealth for future generations. That is not going to happen. I know my hon. colleague here is laughing, and I am sure they are not laughing at me, but with me. \n\nThe point of what I am saying here is that, in Canada at this point, we have missed the boat on deciding to create a sovereign wealth fund based on resource revenue, unless the government puts in place what many of us, the NDP and the Greens, have been calling for for some time, which is a tax on the excess profits that big oil is experiencing, particularly as prices go through the roof due to war and not due to their careful management as managers of the resource. The prices skyrocketed when Netanyahu and Trump began bombing Iran. As the spring economic statement pointed out, this drives up the price of oil and increases profits for the private sector. We should be applying an excess profits tax on those who are basically war profiteering in the sector.\n\n Let me look at another aspect of the very thoughtful motion from the opposition. I do want to thank them. Under their sixth point, the Conservatives are pointing out something that I have been railing about in this place for some time. There is over $1 trillion in pension fund money in Canada. If we are looking for sovereign wealth, there is over $1 trillion in pension fund money that has been invested outside of Canada. How does that happen? \n\nLet us just roll back a little on that. The Canada Pension Plan Investment Board Act was carried through Parliament by our former prime minister, and I think we all respect him enormously, the Right Hon. Jean Chrétien. He is still active in public life, and he created the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board Act with the idea of an independent Canada Pension Plan Investment Board to decide how to take Canada's pension money and make it work for us. The investment board is not necessarily even made up of Canadians, unfortunately and tragically. \n\nI urge all my colleagues to think about this. Let us open up the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board Act, because it requires that the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board consider only one criterion when investing our pension plan dollars, which is a return on investment. If we look at the Quebec investment board process, in Quebec they are required to consider, and it does not sound like a big threshold, the well-being of Quebec in the interest of the Quebec. This is missing for the federal monies. Our act for where our pension plan dollars go does not mention the good of Canada, and most of the money that has been invested has gone to the United States, not Canada. It has gone outside of Canada to other investments.\n\nOne of them stuns me, and I think it should shake us to our core when we look at what just happened in Tumbler Ridge. The Canada Pension Plan Investment Board decided it was a good investment, with good return on investment, to invest in OpenAI and Grok, the developers of deepfake AI. By the way, a member of that investment board is now our ambassador to the United States, Mark Wiseman. Two hundred million dollars of our pension plan money went into that because the board thought it was going to make money.\n\nThere is no ethical screen on where our money goes. Obviously there is no climate screen on where our money goes. There is not even a question of whether it is in the interest of Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722273","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my dear colleague from Mount Royal, the parliamentary secretary, for sharing his time with me. I hope he will not regret it after hearing my speech because there are several things in the opposition motion that I agree with. This might be the first time I find myself in this situation. \n\nI usually do not find myself agreeing so very much with opposition day motions fro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9803651a335f2b07155e59a2413ed306e8eccf45c9078d0ec2dbcc0a845b5dd6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0b4b8d802f41c846574a6d064cf58f3f60241f291f383d66bb77d4ce59cd5034"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40dab84d6b49cced5ccfd820","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722275,"date":"2026-04-30T18:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I absolutely agree. As my hon. colleague from the Bloc Québécois mentioned earlier in debate, this looks a lot like the Infrastructure Bank. Government money is put into it. It is supposed to be a bank. It is supposed to sound great.\n\nAt this point, particularly since we have no details, we are debating something that is amorphous. We know what happened with the Infrastructure Bank, and it does look much the same, as my friend from Yellowhead has said.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722275","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I absolutely agree. As my hon. colleague from the Bloc Québécois mentioned earlier in debate, this looks a lot like the Infrastructure Bank. Government money is put into it. It is supposed to be a bank. It is supposed to sound great.\n\nAt this point, particularly since we have no details, we are debating something that is amorphous. We know what happened with the Infrastructure Bank, a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7ca7f963984e0aeb0dc04bf111da698ab71932e180cd92e0af7157849aa93abe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c31f1ba5df9e7062f673eba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722284,"date":"2026-04-30T18:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the economic update document includes the following sentence: \"Introducing Canada's own sovereign wealth fund—the new Canada Strong Fund\". That is all. There is no explanation, no rationale. There is not a single reason why we should have confidence in the idea of a Canada Strong fund.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722284","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the economic update document includes the following sentence: \"Introducing Canada's own sovereign wealth fund—the new Canada Strong Fund\". That is all. There is no explanation, no rationale. There is not a single reason why we should have confidence in the idea of a Canada Strong fund.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56467046137f5ff98379ca44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722287,"date":"2026-04-30T18:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I like to share information, and I appreciate that my colleague has noted that I do the work before I speak.\n\n I would have loved to have discussed what we knew about the sovereign wealth fund and how it is going to be set up, but all we know is that the Liberals are creating yet another office to consider and consult. If we had information, my speech could have focused on that information.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722287","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I like to share information, and I appreciate that my colleague has noted that I do the work before I speak.\n\n I would have loved to have discussed what we knew about the sovereign wealth fund and how it is going to be set up, but all we know is that the Liberals are creating yet another office to consider and consult. If we had information, my speech could have focused on that inform","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88b84cb07d23300add35a0e616f6f7114dc268c2081f46645f97c595bc8542ac"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4944abfbb9ba4e08a3dd592a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722289,"date":"2026-04-30T20:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise because of the member for Kings—Hants's response to a question from the member for Repentigny.\n\n I would like the member for Kings—Hants to reflect on whether it was appropriate to, basically, attack the member for Repentigny for continually raising the climate crisis, which is galloping now to a point where we are facing the risk of tipping points and a fifty-fifty risk of the collapse of the entire circulatory system, which includes the Gulf Stream, with devastating impacts for Nova Scotia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722289","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise because of the member for Kings—Hants's response to a question from the member for Repentigny.\n\n I would like the member for Kings—Hants to reflect on whether it was appropriate to, basically, attack the member for Repentigny for continually raising the climate crisis, which is galloping now to a point where we are facing the risk of tipping points and a fifty-fifty risk of the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc17d16e4293bd1fa5d0210a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722290,"date":"2026-04-30T22:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank my dear colleague, the member for Bourassa.\n\nI am also proud to give my support to his important private member's bill. My question is, does the member have the government's support for this bill to be accepted and become law in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722290","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank my dear colleague, the member for Bourassa.\n\nI am also proud to give my support to his important private member's bill. My question is, does the member have the government's support for this bill to be accepted and become law in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b880191599d99c7c051a36f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722291,"date":"2026-04-30T23:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am rising today to pursue a question I asked in question period on February 27. It was right after the British Columbia government came out with its budget. I have to say that I think every British Columbia member of Parliament was shocked. The B.C. NDP government cancelled a very important program: the community housing fund. The reason I raise this in the context of our federal Parliament is that obviously the Canadian government is making many commitments to build many Canadian homes. Housing starts are up. This is discussed, of course, in the spring economic update.\n\nMy concern, though, which was not properly addressed in question period, is that, yes, the federal government is providing funding to the B.C. government, but we have a real opportunity here that I hope the federal Minister of Housing will seize. The last statistic I can find since I asked the question, after the B.C. community housing fund was cancelled, is that the commitment from the federal government, out of the funds approved through Bill C-15, the budget implementation act's commitment of $15 billion to the Build Canada Homes agency, was that $170 million was to go to B.C. This is the latest statistic I can find of what is committed from the federal government to the B.C. government. To be clear, that is the total, which includes all kinds of housing: market housing, social housing, co-op housing and so on.\n\nThe opportunity here for the federal government is huge. There are hundreds of thousands of dollars that municipalities, local communities and non-profit associations have already spent in getting ready to build great housing. They have bought the land. They have hired the architects. They have cleared the studies. They have done the zoning. They are ready to roll, and suddenly, the B.C. government's decision to pull out of the funding has left thousands of potential homes for British Columbians in peril. There are big question marks now over many projects.\n\n My plea to the government in pursuing this question tonight in Adjournment Proceedings is this: Set some clear requirements. Parties have the land. They are ready to roll. They have done their zoning. They have their permits. The plans are ready. It is just a question of a top-up from the federal government, specifically designed for non-profit housing in British Columbia. As I mentioned before in my question when I asked it in February, there are projects on Galiano Island and Mayne Island, and also in Saanich. The Prince George council member Cori Ramsay, who is the president of the Union of BC Municipalities, is saying the same thing. So many of these wonderful projects are going to fall through the cracks. We are ready to go.\n\nWe are looking for the federal government to commit to creating a special funding program, designed for B.C. in this moment and designed to capture those projects that are ready to roll, shovel-ready, but that may fall through the cracks and never get built unless the Minister of Housing, who is a British Columbian, can step up and design a project that gets the money flowing to build these homes for British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722291","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am rising today to pursue a question I asked in question period on February 27. It was right after the British Columbia government came out with its budget. I have to say that I think every British Columbia member of Parliament was shocked. The B.C. NDP government cancelled a very important program: the community housing fund. The reason I raise this in the context of our federal ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ec8e69d135a18dd44c67745d2eeb6ad930797d2d0fe5c1fbd73cb15822b16565"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc788f6c0fef75887820069906534c3da37045598606bd2929632960476cf059"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f206e3e76cb43f83bed3d40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722293,"date":"2026-04-30T23:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am so sorry. That was my first interaction with the newly elected member for Ajax. I congratulate her on her appointment as the parliamentary secretary.\n\n My question in question period, and again tonight, was very specific. There is an opportunity that may disappear, specific to British Columbia and specific to projects that are ready to go. It is an opportunity for the federal government to pick up on a bespoke program, limited in time and designed to capture those projects in B.C. that are ready to roll but may fall through the cracks. While I support the national vision that the hon. parliamentary secretary just described, it does not speak at all, I am sad to say, to the issue I raised at the end of February: the opportunity that is here right now to get non-profit housing built really fast by picking up on the opportunities of ready-to-roll projects that may fall through the cracks before the federal government gets around to trying to rescue them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722293","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am so sorry. That was my first interaction with the newly elected member for Ajax. I congratulate her on her appointment as the parliamentary secretary.\n\n My question in question period, and again tonight, was very specific. There is an opportunity that may disappear, specific to British Columbia and specific to projects that are ready to go. It is an opportunity for the federal g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fd41f5fcc539068ea5032e3c8a8894f67a225e9656a365d42a76d0c542bf5f0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["337742d6d0fc3b0dcdbc0a5f71a89a24c2f6be2e23f6bc9d8f6866577fcb6d44"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a676b9d9e284b5b8a3353dc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722246,"date":"2026-05-01T15:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to specifically drill into what we can expect in an omnibus budget bill in relation to the Pest Control Products Act. The parliamentary secretary referenced that earlier. Will that section of the bill be carved out so that potential health threats through reducing the regulatory process of registering new pesticides, which I am assuming this may be about, will go to the health committee and not just the finance committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722246","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to specifically drill into what we can expect in an omnibus budget bill in relation to the Pest Control Products Act. The parliamentary secretary referenced that earlier. Will that section of the bill be carved out so that potential health threats through reducing the regulatory process of registering new pesticides, which I am assuming this may be about, will go to the healt","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["51dd8e40d15efa03007d4871c0ec92edf5cb7f90ae455075d19e3481dd3a2b35"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05e691ce1ea1b12d6848a533c53389ec3f7606426c3c634a69a7c682f97f7694"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0aed0502decf8fd90106d32b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722256,"date":"2026-05-01T17:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, alarm bells are ringing of imminent global collapse of key climate systems, but the alarms are being drowned out by the cheering of Liberals and Conservatives for new and more climate-killing projects. Key experts say that there is a fifty-fifty chance of the collapse of the massive and complex Atlantic Ocean current system with devastating and catastrophic results. \n\nWhen will the government stop shutting off the alarms and try to act before we pass the tipping points?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722256","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, alarm bells are ringing of imminent global collapse of key climate systems, but the alarms are being drowned out by the cheering of Liberals and Conservatives for new and more climate-killing projects. Key experts say that there is a fifty-fifty chance of the collapse of the massive and complex Atlantic Ocean current system with devastating and catastrophic results. \n\nWhen will the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037058","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Seas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037058","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Seas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather warnings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037058","label":"Seas","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50395","label":"Weather warnings","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5bfc5653553307f1509aa5c80457ca336c71754af3515a2660459413047c080c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7eef0c8461104e2c35681743d865d17ea3c7f40250a026bf2da398664c86010f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f12aeeaf7f608dd5dd1ba31b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":722263,"date":"2026-05-01T17:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is nice to see you in the chair, Mr. Speaker. I am presenting a petition that I cannot say I am happy to present. I was hoping this issue would have been resolved. I know I am not to speak to my own opinion.\n\nTo summarize, Canadians are outraged that live horses continue to be exported for slaughter for sushi in Japan. The slaughter and the movement of wild horses by air are in cruel and inhumane conditions. These petitioners ask the government to please amend the Health of Animals Regulations to ban the export of live horses and to do so as quickly as possible.\n\nI will not quote Jann Arden because it is not parliamentary language.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48410","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Horses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Slaughtering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722263","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is nice to see you in the chair, Mr. Speaker. I am presenting a petition that I cannot say I am happy to present. I was hoping this issue would have been resolved. I know I am not to speak to my own opinion.\n\nTo summarize, Canadians are outraged that live horses continue to be exported for slaughter for sushi in Japan. The slaughter and the movement of wild horses by air are in cruel and inhuma","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48410","label":"Horses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","label":"Slaughtering"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48410","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Horses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Slaughtering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","label":"Slaughtering","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48410","label":"Horses","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a678c6c6faf7d69148014148c6fcaebb7e79d56e4ca6396a1adc0894142a4ae2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48410","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Horses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Slaughtering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["842594abcb1c53d06b29692654c00ced45cf96a72dad4f968f47de4fb999dfc7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48410","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Horses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Slaughtering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48410","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00c9d8963b1f2af5b5494a1e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751839,"date":"2026-05-04T17:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as we are now debating not Bill C-11 itself but time allocation, I would like to remind my hon. friend the Minister of National Defence and cast his mind back to when the Liberals were the third party in the House and the Harper Conservatives used time allocation over and over again. In those days, those of us back in this corner would say frequently that we did not need time allocation, that we should properly debate and that the routine use of time allocation is anti-democratic. I hold to that view no matter who is holding the reins of power. \n\nIt is anti-democratic to shut down debate early. This is why I will be voting no to time allocation. I do support pursuing Madam Justice Arbour's recommendations, but I do not like being bulldozed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751839","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as we are now debating not Bill C-11 itself but time allocation, I would like to remind my hon. friend the Minister of National Defence and cast his mind back to when the Liberals were the third party in the House and the Harper Conservatives used time allocation over and over again. In those days, those of us back in this corner would say frequently that we did not need time allocati","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["355bdc3b5e71b66fc238ac86e9aadc58e09abf4db84c37a32cb31db43ff2cc35"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a488dedd3b27da06077c0cc3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751840,"date":"2026-05-04T20:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition on behalf of my constituents who are deeply concerned about abuses of human rights and environmental protections. This petition deals with the activities of a Vancouver-based mining company, Pan American Silver Corp, with respect to a silver mine called the Escobal mine in Guatemala. The Guatemalan courts interceded and instructed the mine to stop operations and adequately consult the Xinka indigenous peoples of the area. After the people said no, the mine has continued operations. \n\nThe petitioners are affronted. They ask the Government of Canada to take action. We have a vacant seat for the so-called Canadian ombudsperson for responsible enterprise. The petitioners ask Canadian consular officials to protect Xinka land defenders, and fully implement the report \"Voices at Risk: Canada's Guidelines on Supporting Human Rights Defenders\" and the principles of UNDRIP.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751840","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition on behalf of my constituents who are deeply concerned about abuses of human rights and environmental protections. This petition deals with the activities of a Vancouver-based mining company, Pan American Silver Corp, with respect to a silver mine called the Escobal mine in Guatemala. The Guatemalan courts interceded and instructed the mine to stop operatio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Demining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034809","label":"Demining","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e4f58d1c385d55caa5cfde082da5bc1378fbba4689797b31f73373f6fefc5e85"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["727f46c14b6a6189a1425d28f682aaccff21c077157da1276893f69fcdae7002"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7810fadbee66cb88e0903e14","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751829,"date":"2026-05-05T16:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my esteemed colleague, the hon. leader of the Bloc Québécois.\n\nMy question is simple. There is only one product everywhere in Canada that is protected in a strategic reserve: maple syrup, of course. In my opinion, it might be a good idea to have a strategic reserve for our forestry products or for the others we share. I would like to hear the Bloc Québécois's policies on the idea of having strategic reserves for our natural resources here in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751829","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my esteemed colleague, the hon. leader of the Bloc Québécois.\n\nMy question is simple. There is only one product everywhere in Canada that is protected in a strategic reserve: maple syrup, of course. In my opinion, it might be a good idea to have a strategic reserve for our forestry products or for the others we share. I would like to hear the Bloc Québécois's policies on the i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","label":"Maple products"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","label":"Maple products","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e3bd64a7c95e811fab6162d405eb202fabae82bb6b1e998f2d1aec2e304f5365"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18bde874de851bb7c4d48915a6a9effaf04c99b559cbba81f1412ba1a7efbbdd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c18cf6b1233a48ef9b1caa3e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751830,"date":"2026-05-05T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, almost seven years ago, June 3, 2019, the inquiry into missing and murdered indigenous women, girls and two-spirited plus people was given to the government. \n\nOf the 231 individual calls for justice, can the Prime Minister update us as to how many have been fulfilled?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751830","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, almost seven years ago, June 3, 2019, the inquiry into missing and murdered indigenous women, girls and two-spirited plus people was given to the government. \n\nOf the 231 individual calls for justice, can the Prime Minister update us as to how many have been fulfilled?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["205025c64f47d41457ac52f06d14a237a446ba43d37ce256d652a9dccb9aa9de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f8a39b752a04783ed10cc31a00f6de051eeac22561a4f4eb2abdc4eb6f188fdf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d01a8f9cbf67a152886fbf58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751832,"date":"2026-05-05T20:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting against the motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751832","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting against the motion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9d481f293bf8a37a8bd0076bc0128ee5a120676bb44889eca9d10f946806866"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5de7c8c3ee9310adad4c488","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751833,"date":"2026-05-05T20:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the votes and will also be voting in the negative.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751833","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the votes and will also be voting in the negative.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e6e3fd00645f53f9999872696d9c6e987ac13ca67b93a8a1237e6eb24ffa70b3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f49e63936d7fb1dde4df127","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751834,"date":"2026-05-05T20:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I agree to apply the vote, with Greens voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751834","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I agree to apply the vote, with Greens voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb63c4fc2f983fc4fd8c2dec787a94a85daa044dd5598b09f4d0d5c3576fe6c2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75e6a7f5f8541c88e2dee337","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751835,"date":"2026-05-05T20:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party also agrees to apply the result of the previous vote to this vote and will vote in favour of the motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751835","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party also agrees to apply the result of the previous vote to this vote and will vote in favour of the motion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0fad609cf9392204d1ba5e4a0e27b2bebc82a638549b384161e5732c376dfaa3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e08f1a7d5120fdedac224a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751836,"date":"2026-05-05T20:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Greens agree to apply the vote and vote no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751836","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Greens agree to apply the vote and vote no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88d898b0191e5b195cf32e6d34e613b9ea84e68cb84f1ab8bc93cac36016d759"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34e1fc7d07679e06bc61205f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751837,"date":"2026-05-05T20:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the results of the last vote to this vote and will be voting yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751837","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the results of the last vote to this vote and will be voting yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["389e7da1b57dd6164a00683c66a1159798348f131ef2a58342c47c06a24af857"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-82db55f6741cb3722e956202","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751838,"date":"2026-05-05T20:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751838","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1fa032ad9896605a588033508d0e197dbc399765e92f587e36ffbbcea8231d3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7ef305c77e3c7148778990b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101374,"date":"2026-05-05T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. This is another sharing moment between the Green Party and the Bloc Québécois. Welcome, Ms. Provost. I'll ask one question very clearly so I don't trespass too much on this generosity. When the nature strategy on how we would get to 30 by 30 was first unveiled—that was two years ago, in June 2024—a key part was the nature accountability act. As we all know, Bill C-73 died on the Order Paper. I wonder if the minister can update us on when we might see the nature accountability act reintroduced in Parliament.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101374","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. This is another sharing moment between the Green Party and the Bloc Québécois. Welcome, Ms. Provost. I'll ask one question very clearly so I don't trespass too much on this generosity. When the nature strategy on how we would get to 30 by 30 was first unveiled—that was two years ago, in June 2024—a key part was the nature accountability act. As we all know, Bill C-73 died on the Order P","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbae3ed3c6c36bd60b876ed3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751826,"date":"2026-05-06T20:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the issue in the petition I am presenting today was initially raised in one of my town hall meetings some months ago. As some may know, Saanich—Gulf Islands happens to be a riding that has a particularly high percentage of senior residents. The petitioners from Saanich—Gulf Islands are very concerned and raise an issue that I think is Canada-wide, which is that the headlights for automobiles have changed dramatically over the years. The LED lights, with their current intensity in many automobiles, are a hazard, particularly for older drivers, as it is hard for them to see where they are going. This is because of the lack of street lighting and the halogen vehicle headlights, which are extremely bright.\n\nThe petitioners, therefore, ask the House of Commons to review and update federal motor vehicle safety standards related to headlight brightness. They ask for a report to be commissioned and independent research on the impact on road safety as a result of these high-intensity lights. They also ask to strengthen testing, compliance and enforcement to ensure that headlights do not produce excessive glare under normal operating conditions. The petitioners ask that the federal government work with provinces, territories, road safety experts and vehicle manufacturers to address this safety threat.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751826","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the issue in the petition I am presenting today was initially raised in one of my town hall meetings some months ago. As some may know, Saanich—Gulf Islands happens to be a riding that has a particularly high percentage of senior residents. The petitioners from Saanich—Gulf Islands are very concerned and raise an issue that I think is Canada-wide, which is that the headlights for auto","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a1788d4b28c25f01ce94771b8e1e654f54b2ac9e83195f4f3399bfcf427b71d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7c17cb92064ffc2e317c4371bf7b8b2c7d9699d004dff4cc0a1542c2c9eb5725"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3ce73765d759556d70c172d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751827,"date":"2026-05-06T21:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we frequently hear said in this place that the previous government under Stephen Harper was ready to move ahead with northern gateway and that it was the Liberals who struck it down. However, I am certain many people forgot, but I did not forget, that the Conservative platform in 2011 was specifically against exporting bitumen to Asia. Specifically, Stephen Harper's platform said that we should not ship Canadian fossil fuels to refineries in countries that have weaker environmental standards than we did. The Conservatives were explicitly against pipelines across British Columbia to export to Asia. As for northern gateway, it was struck down by the Federal Court of Appeal, and due to actions by the previous government, not the Liberals.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751827","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we frequently hear said in this place that the previous government under Stephen Harper was ready to move ahead with northern gateway and that it was the Liberals who struck it down. However, I am certain many people forgot, but I did not forget, that the Conservative platform in 2011 was specifically against exporting bitumen to Asia. Specifically, Stephen Harper's platform said that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["65e302125fab4f2a1595c7901027101b4fe66cada8415e90993528e89445d306"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["900d0413b4d7cf7a465831f83ed876363131a128a36262b79da6d41c611a0fdc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec59e78a557b1a19180ed26a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751828,"date":"2026-05-06T22:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I must start with congratulating the new member for University—Rosedale. I have long admired her advocacy for our public health care system when going down to Washington.\n\nThis may be a bit of a tough question. Does she agree with the Canadian Medical Association that the climate crisis is the single biggest public health threat of the 21st century? Can she help us get it back on track, with her government at the moment going slow?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751828","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I must start with congratulating the new member for University—Rosedale. I have long admired her advocacy for our public health care system when going down to Washington.\n\nThis may be a bit of a tough question. Does she agree with the Canadian Medical Association that the climate crisis is the single biggest public health threat of the 21st century? Can she help us get it back on trac","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e4db194e1375a553785c502e12a9767a65bbd1e7ec8149491567ba92ce423d59"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ba76434f8d153db4fbfcd0a003b80d38f41ced6256741b7526a06e059017ffff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf9d5bb6dc1ffb747bb9edf0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101400,"date":"2026-05-07T16:35:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"PROC","text":"Mr. Chair, may I ask for unanimous consent at this moment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101400","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, may I ask for unanimous consent at this moment?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72aa9c40e234737aba56eccac594b0dda733f4981483d2131d8f665bb858e25c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6c789792b0817839fbf28d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101401,"date":"2026-05-07T16:35:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"PROC","text":"I'd like 30 seconds to pose a question to Monsieur Perrault. I think it would be a yes or no. It's up to my colleagues, of course.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101401","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like 30 seconds to pose a question to Monsieur Perrault. I think it would be a yes or no. It's up to my colleagues, of course.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207037","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Permafrost","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207037","label":"Permafrost","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d6cdf997360cdfdcbe2fddbc48bd45862400940d46c93ed0ff16858ce24b5a6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33ee87f61edce3ff03f3d747","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101402,"date":"2026-05-07T16:40:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all my colleagues. Very briefly, Mr. Perrault, I think I've understood your testimony to be that you stand by the recommendations of the 2022 report from your office, many of which were included in Bill C-65 , which died on the Order Paper. My question is this: Do you think Bill C-25 would be stronger if it still included the sections from Bill C-65 that have been dropped?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101402","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all my colleagues. Very briefly, Mr. Perrault, I think I've understood your testimony to be that you stand by the recommendations of the 2022 report from your office, many of which were included in Bill C-65 , which died on the Order Paper. My question is this: Do you think Bill C-25 would be stronger if it still included the sections from Bill C-65 that have bee","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f636cd5da7a9a6f3a41e0255967304c45594124d53ab0845d0060d308a56a0b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84fbb93f824ac708db166d78","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751819,"date":"2026-05-07T21:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I really do want to thank my hon. colleague from Winnipeg Centre, and I am grateful to her for splitting her time with me. \n\nIn this day's debate, I do not want to attribute motivations and reasons for why we are doing it or to say which side is right or wrong, but the problem is that it is posing a question as if it is a live issue that needs to be addressed. That is largely due to misunderstandings and misinformation, so let me try to explain, because I am a British Columbia MP.\n\nAnother British Columbia MP said that the proof of the fact that the court decision has created real problems is that we are getting calls in our constituency office. I can say that, yes, I am getting calls in my constituency office and getting constituents emailing me. I take it as my responsibility to dig into what the court said and share with my constituents and reassure them that there is no threat to their fee simple ownership of their place. There is no threat to ownership of land by settler culture British Columbians at all from the Cowichan decision. \n\nI want to go back to what it is about and what the court did. This is a declaration of the British Columbia Supreme Court. By the way, I think the Prime Minister was wrong to stand in this place and commit to appealing, and I think the British Columbia premier should be ashamed of his running away from DRIPA and of his decision to demonize this decision as if it puts anything into a state of confusion at all. I am more upset with the premier of B.C., because he is a lawyer, so he should know better. The Prime Minister is not, and the Leader of the Opposition is not. \n\nI dig into these things because I think it is my job. I will never forget one of my favourite professors at law school. He used to thwack a cane across the desk right in front of us, like something out of The Paper Chase on TV, and he would say, \"Develop the habit of thoroughness\", so I have dug in. I have learned more about what this is about, and I want to share it with people because I think it will help take away the notion that in any generalized way the Cowichan decision has anything to say about fee simple property rights in Canada. \n\nWhat the court said was that British Columbia, the British Columbia government, has a duty to negotiate in good faith with the Cowichan, now that the facts are clear, \"in a manner consistent with the honour of the Crown.\" We use the term \"honour of the Crown\" quite loosely. There is a minister responsible for Crown-indigenous relations. It is not some anachronism that we still talk about the Crown; it is at the essence of indigenous nations' relationships with the country of Canada. It is something that happened before there was a country of Canada: the Crown, and the Crown's relationship with nations that were here before we got here. \n\nIn this case, what happened? It is an interesting story, and I hope other colleagues here will realize how specific this was to a specific historical injustice, not a generalized one. What happened here to the honour of the Crown? The first governor of British Columbia, appointed by the Crown, Governor James Douglas, was a very interesting person and a person of real integrity. I will not digress too much about James Douglas, but he was, interestingly enough, Black, and he married an indigenous woman when he came to B.C. His mother was Black and his father was Scottish. He was our first governor of British Columbia, and he set a moral tone that was fascinating. \n\nWith eight engineers at his side, not armed ones, he stood down a whole bunch of armed folks coming up from the U.S. I know we sometimes think about this now and hope it never happens, but he stood down a whole bunch of armed folks from the U.S. who, in the mid-1800s, were coming up to B.C. in the gold rush. They were armed to the teeth. They said they wanted to kill Indians and they wanted to get our gold. How the heck he did this, I do not know, but it is a great story. With eight engineers, Sir James Douglas stood them down and said to them, \"You're entering British Empire now. Put your guns over there and queue up over here to buy your licence if you want to go pan for gold on the Fraser River.\" This is astonishing. \n\nGovernor James Douglas also negotiated with the indigenous nations, particularly in the region I am honoured to represent here, the Saanich nation. There were a lot of individual nations that entered into negotiated agreements with the Crown through Sir James Douglas. They are called the Douglas treaties, and they are really fair and largely ignored over the generations.\n\nThis particular court decision is about one specific village site on Lulu Island that had been occupied for a very long time. By the way, the court case we are talking about is over 800 pages long, and much of it is about this story: What happened? What was the double-cross? Was there a double-cross?\n\nTo go back, Sir James Douglas, in 1853 and again in 1859, assured the Cowichan people that this particular village site on Lulu Island, called Tl'uqtinus, which had been heavily populated and was an important village site, would always be Cowichan lands. They set it aside in reserve. That is what Sir James Douglas did. He was an honourable man. \n\nUnfortunately, a little later in our history, along comes Colonel Richard Moody, who was given the job of land commissioner for the province of B.C. The Cowichan had a specific commitment from the governor, \"This is where you can stay. This is reserve land for you. We're basically taking everything else, but this is reserve land for you\", but then, about 10 years later, along comes Colonel Richard Moody as land commissioner and buys the land for himself as a land speculator. He dishonours the honour of the Crown. As the court described it, he \"surreptitiously\" purchased the land for himself to make himself rich while violating a commitment of the Crown to the people of the Cowichan nation.\n\n Now, time goes on, but the Cowichan people do not forget that this is actually their land. They had a commitment from the Crown, from Sir James Douglas, and the skullduggery of Colonel Richard Moody cannot dishonour the Crown, so the Cowichan never gave up. They launched a court case in 1911, saying, \"This is our land.\" The chief of the Cowichan, in 1913, travelled to London, England, and met with King Edward VII to say, \"This is our land. Can you please repair this injustice that's been done to us?\" Well, as we can see, time marches on, and they are still trying to get a resolution to this. The gold rush of 1858 was, again, what triggered Colonel Richard Moody's double-cross. As I said, Sir James Douglas stood them down. \n\nI find the history of British Columbia fascinating, but this case is not about any kind of generalized discussion of indigenous land title versus fee simple title. Not at all. Not ever. This is about a very specific injustice to a very specific nation over very specific land that was always theirs. That is what the court said. Then the court said that, because the land now is basically Crown land, the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority, and the B.C. government has no legal right to extinguish title, that is the honour of the Crown to these peoples. \n\nMy friend Adam Olsen, who was once the Green Party member of the B.C. legislature representing me, and who is a member of the Tsartlip First Nation, in response to this Cowichan decision tried to emphasize, \"When First Nations win, the rest of society does not lose.\" I would like my hon. colleagues in this place to think about how significant it is for us all that what may knit us together, our sovereignty as a nation, is better protected by the honour of the Crown and its relationship with indigenous nations than almost anything else if we are dealing with a U.S. President who thinks we could be the 51st state. Lots of luck. Section 35 of our Constitution says indigenous lands are inherently held and are indigenous title.\n\n It is very important, and some of us in this place have gone to law school, like the hon. member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith, so I know she knows this stuff, that we cannot conflate indigenous title with fee simple title. Crown land is in a different kind of category, and in that sense, indigenous title is more akin to that. As my hon. colleague from Winnipeg said, we have the Haida decision, and there is the Delgamuukw decision, but really the Tsilhqot'in decision of the Supreme Court of Canada made it really clear. Fee simple title is held specifically and personally and can be bought and sold. Indigenous title, as the court said in the Tsilhqot'in decision, is collective and intergenerational. \n\nTo all concerned, let us please not allow people to believe something that is not true. This Cowichan decision does not threaten fee simple land or property rights. Let us wait for the courts to conclude, and let us stay calm.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751819","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I really do want to thank my hon. colleague from Winnipeg Centre, and I am grateful to her for splitting her time with me. \n\nIn this day's debate, I do not want to attribute motivations and reasons for why we are doing it or to say which side is right or wrong, but the problem is that it is posing a question as if it is a live issue that needs to be addressed. That is largely due to m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["32b6840463a1ea62a164e94fc72f43bb805ed9f6ee94f113a373fa8d88008b23"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1c8d343896e76596a47a37d73c9012f988342ef7269a9c075cec69394370df00"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c4f1277be45905cee12744b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751820,"date":"2026-05-07T21:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it has already been quoted by my hon. colleague from Winnipeg Centre that the court confirmed that the Cowichan nation did not seek to invalidate or render ineffective fee simple lands. It is true there are some fee simple lands within the area that used to be the village. It is primarily federal land, it is City of Richmond land, and it is the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority. However, the declaration by the court does not affect one iota the fee simple property rights of those people. \n\nThe burden is on the Province of British Columbia, which for 100 years ignored its duty to properly negotiate this dispute and to pay attention to the rights of the Cowichan nation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751820","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it has already been quoted by my hon. colleague from Winnipeg Centre that the court confirmed that the Cowichan nation did not seek to invalidate or render ineffective fee simple lands. It is true there are some fee simple lands within the area that used to be the village. It is primarily federal land, it is City of Richmond land, and it is the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority. However","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035543","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grasslands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035543","label":"Grasslands","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b044ec8a171ce944fc47d8c875588b94928725568bf21953c3fd15160fc1a559"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c4131bb2b340a4d8e7a3f8efe14d2d6f305699d3e62965438ffc87ae500206a4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b77bb0a7e1d3594a8f38d36c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751821,"date":"2026-05-07T21:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know a lot of my Conservative friends are wondering about the expropriations built into Bill C-15 for Alto. That is basing it on what kind of title rights we have in this country. Nobody's title rights in fee simple are absolute vis-à-vis our own government, but they are absolute vis-à-vis potential indigenous title, which has not in any way been put forward. \n\nAs my hon. colleague from Winnipeg Centre says, there has been no case ever where indigenous title has resulted in fee simple title rights being lost for settler culture Canadians. Fee simple rights are only taken when a government expropriates for something big, like the Mirabel airport or what have you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751821","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know a lot of my Conservative friends are wondering about the expropriations built into Bill C-15 for Alto. That is basing it on what kind of title rights we have in this country. Nobody's title rights in fee simple are absolute vis-à-vis our own government, but they are absolute vis-à-vis potential indigenous title, which has not in any way been put forward. \n\nAs my hon. colleague ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40eb57097f3bb806db58d23c32b31eef509c31ff0b7e798d5e2c0e43b670a8e5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f703d83470726aeb2c4e5cbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751822,"date":"2026-05-07T21:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague from Repentigny. It is a bit difficult because various issues are being conflated. From this confusion, untruths may grow.\n\nWe are in a situation where, for natural resource projects, we need to establish honest and thorough consultation mechanisms before the projects are implemented. At the same time, the decision from the B.C. Supreme Court in the Cowichan case has no impact on issues like major natural resource projects.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751822","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague from Repentigny. It is a bit difficult because various issues are being conflated. From this confusion, untruths may grow.\n\nWe are in a situation where, for natural resource projects, we need to establish honest and thorough consultation mechanisms before the projects are implemented. At the same time, the decision from the B.C. Supreme Court in the C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f830fe905f70a785687a4a678d6acc879cbff0a103a98cb6fedcf0696bb11763"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b72f22d35c197aa1db30959","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751823,"date":"2026-05-07T21:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a shame that Richard Moody was a thief. It is a shame the Government of British Columbia did not long ago negotiate in good faith with the Cowichan. It is a shame the Government of Canada did not long ago negotiate with the Cowichan.\n\nWith this degree of shame, we must not let the honour of the Crown be dishonoured now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751823","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a shame that Richard Moody was a thief. It is a shame the Government of British Columbia did not long ago negotiate in good faith with the Cowichan. It is a shame the Government of Canada did not long ago negotiate with the Cowichan.\n\nWith this degree of shame, we must not let the honour of the Crown be dishonoured now.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["53a5f1dcd388d21ab168a80215d73876af6c7a82c5dde20dfc789314628a30f5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-712f04bc654e24010fecebc6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751824,"date":"2026-05-07T23:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I congratulate my friend from Simcoe North. Those who started watching at late show will not know what just happened. In any case, that was a good moment.\n\n I am speaking tonight to a question that I asked in question period on January 28, related to what the government had announced as intended cuts to the civil service. I was particularly concerned because within my riding of Saanich—Gulf Islands and elsewhere on Vancouver Island we were getting news that people involved in the critical work of emergency response in the case of oil spills were already receiving their pink slips. They were being told that they were to be removed from their position. It appeared to be everyone in that department. On the same day, the Public Service Alliance of Canada held its own press conference to say that it was informed that about 8,000 workers of the federal civil service were to be terminated.\n\n Since the time I asked the question, it is now confirmed that about 800 of those people are from Parks Canada. Today, I heard from concerned constituents that an interpreter position within Gulf Islands National Park Reserve is being terminated, an essential connection for the visiting public on Saturna Island. The list goes on, including many workers within Environment and Climate Change Canada, particularly those who do critical work in understanding and tracking what we are doing to respond to climate change, which is less by the day so there is less to track. However, there is no question that we are seeing significant cuts to the civil service.\n\n We are seeing some reduction in an area where I am very concerned. We could see cuts in federal spending, which is in the billions of dollars, on outside consultants. We have civil service workers with expertise and if they are put in the role of delivery, they are a lot less expensive than asking Deloitte or McKinsey or other billion-dollar management consultants all around the world that have been getting too much of the public purse in Canada to do the work that we should be doing internally with our own public sector workers. I saw a recent statement that the Government of Canada, in budget 2026, was going to cut by 20% the amount it is spending. That still, by my calculation, leaves us spending about $4 billion on outside consultants, which are for-profit agencies from outside Canada for the most part. \n\nWhat are we cutting here? Again, there are cuts in science, agricultural research stations across Canada and the oceans protection plan, which appears to no longer exist. We are looking at significant cuts across the board. As I said, the Public Service Alliance of Canada representatives are estimating 8,000 workers.\n\nThe answer I got on January 28 was from the minister himself, which is somewhat unusual. The President of the Treasury Board did stand to answer my question and did say that there were going to be cuts through voluntary measures. However, I rather think, as ever, that when a government is putting through significant cuts that affect the services that Canadians want, it does tend to downplay it and say that it will do it by attrition, that it will find some people it could give a buyout package to and encourage them to leave now, knowing that their job is hanging by a thread anyway.\n\nI never did get a clear answer to my specific concern about the workers who are supposed to be ready, although we know that, if ever there were ever a spill of diluted bitumen, we do not have the technology to clean it up. I hope that tonight we can get a clear answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751824","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I congratulate my friend from Simcoe North. Those who started watching at late show will not know what just happened. In any case, that was a good moment.\n\n I am speaking tonight to a question that I asked in question period on January 28, related to what the government had announced as intended cuts to the civil service. I was particularly concerned because within my riding of Saanic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28766b6f6d0e351331c3bb68f4f68330e828ddbfe6edfb2df58aa39eb45c915e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b45c23a49724ad60a85fb878cb719131219c18dfa469bf3f87c3a22a60e6ed8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a3babea71d7e2b6d376e60a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751825,"date":"2026-05-07T23:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, forgive me if I am not impressed with the government's attempt to run balanced budgets when we now have a $66.9-billion deficit. We also know that where there are funds that could be accessed through reasonable shifts in taxation, such as a wealth tax, those opportunities are being avoided. So too is a financial transaction tax that would affect no one but multi-billionaires. \n\nWe also see a boost in subsidies to fossil fuels, and there is a real cost in the climate impacts that will happen across Canada, not to mention specifically the one I keep trying to find an answer for: cuts to the workers who should be ready in the case of oil spill emergencies. In fact, we do not have people to maintain the vessels that were purchased for oil spill emergencies, in what I would call the greenwashing of saying, \"We are prepared,\" and with no oceans protection plan.\n\nWhere are we now for the impacts of the build Canada strong major projects?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751825","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, forgive me if I am not impressed with the government's attempt to run balanced budgets when we now have a $66.9-billion deficit. We also know that where there are funds that could be accessed through reasonable shifts in taxation, such as a wealth tax, those opportunities are being avoided. So too is a financial transaction tax that would affect no one but multi-billionaires. \n\nWe als","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["81b016d30d638c0e35227f125cbc4e3bcc8581826899078fc33e40aed339c55e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9040cf74a514522368265d404894585d0f86640689407e58f7402f79e28e8c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37a6ae4bbb72c4e85a53beee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751817,"date":"2026-05-08T16:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Mother's Day was not invented by Hallmark Cards. In the late 1800s,there was an annual mother's day for peace. It was started by mothers and women who were sick of seeing the ravages of war after the Civil War and the Franco-Prussian War. They started an annual day to call for an end to war. \n\nIn 2026, let us think of the mothers of Ukraine, whose children are being stolen by Putin to erase their culture. Let us think of the mothers of Palestine, whose grief is unending. Let us think of our indigenous mothers, whose daughters are still missing and murdered. Let us think of the mothers of Russia, whose children are being stolen by Putin for an illegal war. \n\nThis Mother's Day, whether it is for mothers in Israel or in Sudan, we know that Mother's Day is all about love, but let us take a moment and let Mother's Day be a cry for peace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751817","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Mother's Day was not invented by Hallmark Cards. In the late 1800s,there was an annual mother's day for peace. It was started by mothers and women who were sick of seeing the ravages of war after the Civil War and the Franco-Prussian War. They started an annual day to call for an end to war. \n\nIn 2026, let us think of the mothers of Ukraine, whose children are being stolen by Putin to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["331c76892453d1fd97443f8b5035fcc7ccb7f123d51e50a38e42fdc9f7411a1c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-751dcf1e32e36baf2cc505c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":751818,"date":"2026-05-08T17:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, petitioners have asked me to present a petition around the export of thermal coal. We note that if Bill C-33 had not died on the Order Paper on January 6 last year, that bill would have banned the export of thermal coal as the government had previously committed to do.\n\nPetitioners point out to the government that it has the mechanisms now. By listing thermal coal as a toxic product, it could immediately ban the export of thermal coal through CEPA. They also note that we export thermal coal through the port of Vancouver, first importing it from the United States. U.S. ports no longer allow the export of thermal coal, so we ship it for them.\n\nPetitioners ask that the government take action to regulate the mining, use and export and import of thermal coal, in accordance with our international commitments to reduce greenhouse gases.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751818","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, petitioners have asked me to present a petition around the export of thermal coal. We note that if Bill C-33 had not died on the Order Paper on January 6 last year, that bill would have banned the export of thermal coal as the government had previously committed to do.\n\nPetitioners point out to the government that it has the mechanisms now. By listing thermal coal as a toxic product, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","label":"Coal"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","label":"Coal","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab6cc0f9137a7f4ba34101a87faa3059790a99c3fdab2e5cfb3b5353222b9990"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7459160ae51410eba47656160e9b7da03021fee65b5859c161275d3c6a2ca0a8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e567a1e072a5d56cf7ca8c2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018493,"date":"2026-05-25T17:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there are parts of every omnibus bill that need to be studied, but when there are omnibus bills, they rarely are. I was the only member of Parliament to vote against part 1 of Bill C-5 last June. Why? It was because the Canadian Cancer Society reached me and asked me to please oppose reducing measures that would make it easier for toxic chemicals that are carcinogens to cross provincial borders. \n\nI am very similarly concerned that this bill, in division 8, would increase carcinogens in our foods and in our environment because of changes being proposed to the Pest Control Products Act on the scanty evidence, or I would say the assumption without evidence, that somehow food would be cheaper if we made it easier for corporate profits to accrue in the chemical industry. \n\nI ask the hon. Minister of Finance to please reconsider the amendments to the Pest Control Products Act. There are parts of this bill I would vote for, but please, to the Minister of Finance, do not reduce our health protections pretending it would bring down food prices.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018493","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there are parts of every omnibus bill that need to be studied, but when there are omnibus bills, they rarely are. I was the only member of Parliament to vote against part 1 of Bill C-5 last June. Why? It was because the Canadian Cancer Society reached me and asked me to please oppose reducing measures that would make it easier for toxic chemicals that are carcinogens to cross provinci","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69f343a0f3ad864dc3ff798ce5ce6800040516c8b529d5d37a2f30010484ebbe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43198a20c9d69b1ed75cfc69d8005d612b3a4ecf9c6d959201faab8e33f466f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b7ef6e4a2dd88f7ef59df0d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018495,"date":"2026-05-25T20:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting against.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018495","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting against.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["78abab8f9b92c2a446a4a058e3638a40bac406eacd72bad832a5d3891e77124a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-306aabe9784c669e5bb28dfb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018510,"date":"2026-05-25T20:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting in favour.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018510","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and will be voting in favour.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df9dd4af40cd45c824292cb831e505c0fc64d4c64fbe3553ea030972709c2ae7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba27ab0a660bac32e607dad3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018512,"date":"2026-05-25T20:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present two petitions today, the first of which is an e-petition that received over 1,000 signatures from Canadians across the country, and particularly from my riding of Saanich—Gulf Islands.\n\n It is a civil society-based effort, launching as well this week in Victoria, with support from many nations around the world. The petitioners hope that Canada will take the lead in seeking the ratification of an international peace charter.\n\n The petitioners note that global conflict is increasing and geopolitical instability threatens lives and livelihoods, and of course peaceful coexistence all around the world. In pursuit of an international peace charter, the petitioners have developed a strong campaign calling for self-determination, finding truth and countering disinformation, and promoting human dignity, diversity, justice and accountability.\n\nI am honoured to present this petition today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018512","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present two petitions today, the first of which is an e-petition that received over 1,000 signatures from Canadians across the country, and particularly from my riding of Saanich—Gulf Islands.\n\n It is a civil society-based effort, launching as well this week in Victoria, with support from many nations around the world. The petitioners hope that Canada will take the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7213a0888b73012e411368bc428117f78cd90212dc8d744b1fcdb5db3a0417c1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b9ca6d543829892eed63ae807be36ed42718b9ab316ac1d25466be118d36a7ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-981e5e925fd35b05c1202f6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018515,"date":"2026-05-25T20:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition comes from constituents concerned with the status of animals in this country. Under law, they are seen only as property, without recognizing that they are sentient beings, living beings, with the ability to feel pain, fear, comfort and other experiences.\n\n The petitioners cite the support of the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association in saying that animal sentience should be formally recognized in Canadian law. The e-petition, which was signed by many Canadians, asks that the Government of Canada take this consideration.\n\n We have tried before in this House to have legislation to cease treating animals as property. The petitioners hope that we will take this up again and consider legislation to recognize the nature of animals as sentient beings.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018515","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition comes from constituents concerned with the status of animals in this country. Under law, they are seen only as property, without recognizing that they are sentient beings, living beings, with the ability to feel pain, fear, comfort and other experiences.\n\n The petitioners cite the support of the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association in saying that animal sentienc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d4f82e3b61b3b402a63ffc934d6bb0373ddf8cfd09db9d4ed63b0dab7914128"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b5e64fff86c718638190c6918a185fe6f46308e17da8261c5a1d2d905b89dc01"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31009fdd462c5c21391b1381","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018519,"date":"2026-05-25T21:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in Bill C-30, there is not much climate commitment at all. We now know, concerning the MOU with the province of Alberta, that whereas the November 27 MOU said Canada and Alberta are committed to net zero by 2050, the May 15 MOU said they are committed to tangible progress toward net zero by 2050.\n\nHas the Prime Minister now completely withdrawn from our legally binding commitments to reductions by 2035? Are we now retracting the commitment, which was already too late, to the year 2050?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018519","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in Bill C-30, there is not much climate commitment at all. We now know, concerning the MOU with the province of Alberta, that whereas the November 27 MOU said Canada and Alberta are committed to net zero by 2050, the May 15 MOU said they are committed to tangible progress toward net zero by 2050.\n\nHas the Prime Minister now completely withdrawn from our legally binding commitments to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84a5b15cc5615ed152d7a277","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018523,"date":"2026-05-25T22:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to agree with my colleague. The sovereign wealth funds of other countries, particularly Norway's, were designed on Peter Lougheed's plan, which was to take oil revenue out of government rents and using it as a set-aside for a rainy day, which is not what the Liberals' fund proposes to do.\n\n I wonder if my hon. colleague has any comments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018523","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to agree with my colleague. The sovereign wealth funds of other countries, particularly Norway's, were designed on Peter Lougheed's plan, which was to take oil revenue out of government rents and using it as a set-aside for a rainy day, which is not what the Liberals' fund proposes to do.\n\n I wonder if my hon. colleague has any comments.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c88df0b297718ec96af058473c18076834363405a52e9ccdfbf5812d80b660b5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b387e7ebc633eae7e5a97181","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018410,"date":"2026-05-26T16:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the minister for his speech.\n\nMy question is about the temporary suspension of the federal fuel excise tax and the fact that, under former prime minister Stephen Harper, that tax was used exclusively to fund urban transit.\n\nIf this fuel excise tax is suspended, what revenue will go to urban public transit?\n\nThat is the responsibility of another level of government, local government, which depends on this tax for urban transit.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018410","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the minister for his speech.\n\nMy question is about the temporary suspension of the federal fuel excise tax and the fact that, under former prime minister Stephen Harper, that tax was used exclusively to fund urban transit.\n\nIf this fuel excise tax is suspended, what revenue will go to urban public transit?\n\nThat is the responsibility of another level of government, loc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","label":"Excise taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","label":"Excise taxes","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["224564c8969862e13c2044512480aab9aa9aa7ab0f3cb274fcf149edf0ba11ca"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e8e81ad6c97149aed12d6797697817ee9b32f671a103f191f68d5171692ec04"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-473d98980da5defda1443ee4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018412,"date":"2026-05-26T20:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and says, \"no goddamn way\".\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018412","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote and says, \"no goddamn way\".\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75fb92b739ed4cfa9d7d25d6b72d2be7f79eb4606e26a72c97d9be6d86929f2d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1b52fad45fc9f838c4c3bcc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018416,"date":"2026-05-26T20:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I apologize for the wording but not the sentiment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018416","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I apologize for the wording but not the sentiment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d61e842c24b6043f702ba26b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018420,"date":"2026-05-26T20:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a point of order that I hope the hon. member who has the floor at the moment, will appreciate. There is far too much noise entering the chamber for me to give respectful attention to the hon. member from Kings—Hants.\n\n I do not know if you could hear it from where you are, Mr. Speaker, and it is beginning to come down to a dull roar, but it was really difficult to hear the hon. member for Kings—Hants.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018420","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a point of order that I hope the hon. member who has the floor at the moment, will appreciate. There is far too much noise entering the chamber for me to give respectful attention to the hon. member from Kings—Hants.\n\n I do not know if you could hear it from where you are, Mr. Speaker, and it is beginning to come down to a dull roar, but it was really difficult to hear the hon. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea120aa7b2e8e55e71b73e3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018422,"date":"2026-05-26T21:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to have the opportunity to rise in debate today on the opposition day motion, and I have the great honour of splitting my time with the terrific MP for Vancouver Kingsway.\n\n I want to start by saying that this is a thoughtful motion. I will be voting against it, but I do think it is important to have Canadians use this moment as a teachable moment. There is no question that the price of fossil fuels, particularly gasoline, throughout North America and around the world, has felt the shock created by Donald Trump's and Benjamin Netanyahu's illegally bombing Iran. It had an immediate effect on gas prices around the world. Yes, it is worth Canadians asking, given that has had a global impact, how come gas prices are higher in Canada. As such, I want to dig into that a bit.\n\n I want to state right off the top, and we often fail to say this, even as Greens, but we need to say it, that the cheapest way to move people around in vehicles and the cheapest way to power those vehicles is to move 100% off fossil fuels. I want to say very quickly, before friends anywhere get angry with me, that this is not a useful choice if it is not there for them.\n\n Let me give a contrast. In Germany, pensioners can hang solar panels off their balconies in urban places, and they have the capacity to safely plug their home appliances into the solar panel, just as friends of mine in the Cobble Hill area in British Columbia have solar panels on their roof and plug their car into their house. This means that the source of energy is abundant, renewable and essentially free once everything is in place. \n\nThese are larger discussions to have, but the question that I want to focus on now is the one before us from the Conservative Party: Why is there a price differential, even with the international volatility caused by war and mistakes? To say they were mistakes is to be charitable toward the U.S. White House. To say they were monstrously reckless decisions is more accurate.\n\nWhy is there this price differential? To get into this, I have to drill down a bit, no pun intended. When the Green Party issued our climate policy in 2019, called \"Mission: Possible\", we made the commitment, which I think very few Canadians ever heard of, that we should, as we ramp down on our dependence on fossil fuels in Canada, only use Canadian fossil fuels in this country and absolutely bring imports from other countries to zero.\n\n There is a logic to this, but let us look at the current situation. One of the reasons that fossil fuel prices are higher for Canadians who want to put gas in the tank is that, of the fossil fuels we produce in this country, about 75% of them are exported, and the bulk of that by far, 75% of what we export, or about 60% of total, is exported unprocessed raw. I became more aware of this back in 2016. I was an intervenor in the National Energy Board review of what was then the Kinder Morgan pipeline project, and the largest union representing workers in the oil sands, Unifor, was also intervening against the pipeline project.\n\n Why would the largest union in the oil sands be against the pipeline project? They pointed out the obvious. The pipeline was then idiotically bought and built by Canada at a cost of $36 billion of public funds. However, the pipeline project was then and is now, as it operates, transporting something that is a solid, low-value form of fossil fuel called bitumen, which is diluted with enough fossil fuel condensates that it can flow through a pipeline. Unprocessed raw gets shipped out of Canada to go to refineries in other countries to be upgraded to synthetic crude, and from there it goes to refineries elsewhere.\n\nFocusing on our refinery capacity, in the 1970s, Canada had about 40 refineries. One of the things that the Unifor brief pointed out to the National Energy Board is that we have lost a huge amount of our refinery capacity. It is now down to, in 2026, about 14 to 16 refineries, depending on how one counts. That is down from 40 refineries.\n\nOur capacity to take a domestic product, refine it and use it here has been substantially structurally reduced. Unifor told the National Energy Board that it did not want an export pipeline built because it felt it would inevitably lead to the closure of refineries in the Lower Mainland of B.C. This is because the product that those refineries might want to refine was moving offshore before there was any value added, as is the case whenever we ship out raw materials. We do this a lot in Canada with shippers, hewers of wood and drawers of water. Because we ship out raw logs, the sawmills in Canada cannot operate at full capacity. We ship out raw bitumen, and people could have had jobs in refineries if we had kept up the capacity in our refineries and if we had built upgraders to go with the refineries so that Canadian bitumen could be used in Canadian gas tanks without being shipped out of the country first.\n\nThis is a big problem. This affects the price of gas in Canada. We are the fifth largest producer of fossil fuels in the world. We export most of it by far, and we import product from other countries. That is quite astonishing. Why do we do that? Well, I think it is still the mindset of hewers of wood and drawers of water, and because we are failing to listen to smart folks in the refinery business and in the workforces who have been looking at why we do not want to have value added to our refining capacity and be able to say that what we are using in our tanks, as long as we are still using the internal combustion engine, comes from Canada, because this is a Canadian product.\n\nIt does make it more expensive, as we can imagine, to ship it out of the port in Burnaby, ship it overseas, and, in some cases, down to refineries in Washington state, only for British Columbians to buy it back from refineries in Washington state. Despite the fact that we have been told some fairy tales over the years, like if we had a pipeline from British Columbia to eastern Canada or from Alberta to New Brunswick, the Irving refinery in New Brunswick could process that and it would be good and we could we use it domestically, the reality is that the Irving refinery is still the only refinery in Canada that imports Saudi oil. The Irving refinery does not have an upgrader to take solid bitumen, turn it into synthetic crude and then refine it.\n\nThese are some of the basic structural impediments to Canada getting maximum workforce benefit and maximum domestic economic benefit. We could get more benefit and more jobs in Canada while reducing our overall production of fossil fuels, which we primarily export to the United States. It is still, on the order, about 90% of our exports that go to the United States. \n\nOne little curious point people might find amusing as a factoid, but that is rather despairing, is the idea that there was some great benefit coming to Canada by getting our bitumen to tidewater. In fact, a great deal of what gets shipped out of the port of Burnaby towards China, because it is still a solid thing, is a lot like tar. A lot of what we ship to China gets used to pave roads because it is a lot like tar. If we wanted to have a domestic industry that would improve our productivity measurements as an economy, we would not be shipping out raw product. Every time we increase the relative proportion of value-added product before shipping it out of the country, we improve our overall economic indicators.\n\nTo that, I will only add that I am concerned about getting rid of the excise tax on our fuel, which we are doing with the spring economic statement, Bill C-30. Stephen Harper's made the wise decision that the excise gas tax would be forever dedicated to public transit in urban areas. The Liberals have now ditched that plan and are giving a short-term, and I think insufficient, tax break to Canadians because it ends on Labour Day. \n\nFor all of that, the one sure thing is that nothing is going to hurt our economy like the climate crisis, which is barrelling towards us. Nothing is going to damage our economy as much as the government is currently doing by slashing carbon and climate control programs in order to boost what it thinks will turn into economic growth.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018422","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to have the opportunity to rise in debate today on the opposition day motion, and I have the great honour of splitting my time with the terrific MP for Vancouver Kingsway.\n\n I want to start by saying that this is a thoughtful motion. I will be voting against it, but I do think it is important to have Canadians use this moment as a teachable moment. There is no question","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","label":"Shipping"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","label":"Shipping","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["50b276e835f1d9259d1c4637d74782547b5e2082036b478a76304e3e67ffb7a4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1733c8052309d30abaad7b6a62a3128b933303264b2b4aaeddec242e7c39e21"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e4d95021ab65db3eb3009c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018428,"date":"2026-05-26T21:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, to the second part of the question, there is no hesitation on my part, because we have, for years, been calling for improving our refinery capacity in Canada. There was a Canadian entrepreneur in British Columbia who wanted to do that to reduce the risk of bitumen on our coastlines. However, let me just point out that eastern Canada has something called Hibernia. The mobile oil platforms there produce a much higher-value crude than bitumen, and it is all shipped to the States.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018428","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, to the second part of the question, there is no hesitation on my part, because we have, for years, been calling for improving our refinery capacity in Canada. There was a Canadian entrepreneur in British Columbia who wanted to do that to reduce the risk of bitumen on our coastlines. However, let me just point out that eastern Canada has something called Hibernia. The mobile oil platfo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Alternative fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","label":"Alternative fuels","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69988a666e2a3d15ac4c93871a607080f5c68b3a4b360e44ffe155f100d7ffe2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c19eb2cb7429b69b7afd96d5e25d92e651ea033a32ca60ca3ea2ce0c158356f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d167e59b28a638773b71c506","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018432,"date":"2026-05-26T21:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is clear that the Liberals' policies lack common sense. There is this belief that it is a good idea to cut and eliminate almost every policy aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions. At the same time, the government is saying yes to electric vehicles. However, at the last minute, the government changes its plans and ends up saying that it does not want them at all. In the end, the government says they may want some. The government also eliminated energy efficiency programs for homes in Canada. It makes no sense.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018432","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is clear that the Liberals' policies lack common sense. There is this belief that it is a good idea to cut and eliminate almost every policy aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions. At the same time, the government is saying yes to electric vehicles. However, at the last minute, the government changes its plans and ends up saying that it does not want them at all. In the end, th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["393efb7528a875f23f4eebda27866c9e57ee12c72adc7afaa4e6011c730629d7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e517fa7de8f8204680b81dde634521423efb906d4565087bbd9109584d7b323f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42a9b2d89f4e488d956dccbf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018449,"date":"2026-05-26T21:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I do think it is important to remember that, while it is rare that on any climate issue one would invoke Stephen Harper's legacy, the current government's climate policies are so bad that they do bring to mind things that Stephen Harper did better, such as deciding that the gas tax should be permanent and should be used to fund urban transit. I think there is a bit of bait and switch when they say they are going to relieve this tax.\n\nI think what the Liberals are doing is fuelling, no pun intended, the wrong message, as if the narrative is correct that somehow it is the extra taxes from government that are making gas more expensive. It is a factor, but a much larger factor is that we have structured our economy and our use of fossil fuels around shipping out low-value exports and not creating the jobs here.\n\nPart of the Green Party policy, just to make it clear for my friends across the way, is to pick a date on which we will transition off fossil fuels and only use Canadian fossil fuels till that date.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018449","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I do think it is important to remember that, while it is rare that on any climate issue one would invoke Stephen Harper's legacy, the current government's climate policies are so bad that they do bring to mind things that Stephen Harper did better, such as deciding that the gas tax should be permanent and should be used to fund urban transit. I think there is a bit of bait and switch ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e01db2192680f5509b6fe836c82e896fcac79a1b2fde76b2ea15f403c6432bcc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e2583386daadb6757412d3b4cef9da02dbc57215ccea3b6748cc7793ddc3c3d0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de6ac6c1af5415924b3e2ef5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018462,"date":"2026-05-27T03:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I wish the hon. minister a good evening. I will watch my time closely and try to give him adequate time to respond because I hope to have a conversation more than a grilling. \n\nI note that the hon. minister referred frequently to the International Energy Agency as authoritative. I wonder if he noted that last month the executive director, Fatih Birol, said that based on the global experience of the U.S. and Israeli attack on Iran and the geopolitical instability around fossil fuels, the days of fossil fuels are numbered, that the world is shifting more quickly to renewables and electrifying, and that there would be a steep decline in any demand for oil in the future.\n\n I wonder if the various investments that are described as subsidies and investment tax credits in budget 2025 and in the spring economic update have been subjected to a risk assessment of what the Prime Minister once referred to as what happens when we have unburnable carbon and there is no market for it. \n\nHave we seen in the finance department a real assessment of the risks of assuming that investing in fossil fuels is a good bet for this country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018462","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I wish the hon. minister a good evening. I will watch my time closely and try to give him adequate time to respond because I hope to have a conversation more than a grilling. \n\nI note that the hon. minister referred frequently to the International Energy Agency as authoritative. I wonder if he noted that last month the executive director, Fatih Birol, said that based on the global exper","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["058a3e17d87449d0f4fea960fe23e3936595b77274fd104e8f810171a6e5fa94"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["96b8481967ff035076f20f4f24817c5e1b029e6b02e8e1422755758b52ec9d06"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0e45642eb7fd2284bde630b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018463,"date":"2026-05-27T03:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I thank the minister for his very kind comments.\n\nI want to turn to a perennial challenge for Canada's economy and ask where the minister sees his government's efforts to deal with the productivity crisis going. We are not making any headway since back when David Dodge first declared that we had a crisis in productivity. This is my analysis, and I could be dead wrong on this. Certainly in countries and sectors that are dominated by oligopolies, we have a problem where there is a relatively small number of firms dominating an entire sector.\n\n It is pretty well known that Canada's telecommunications sector, banking sector and the large grocery store chains lack the kind of competitiveness that would lead to better productivity. However, a multifactorial issue for productivity occurs when we export a relatively large proportion as raw material without value added.\n\n I wonder if the minister has any thoughts on how Canada can improve productivity or can point to any measures in the existing financial documents of the last year that actually would make a difference in improving our productivity.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018463","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I thank the minister for his very kind comments.\n\nI want to turn to a perennial challenge for Canada's economy and ask where the minister sees his government's efforts to deal with the productivity crisis going. We are not making any headway since back when David Dodge first declared that we had a crisis in productivity. This is my analysis, and I could be dead wrong on this. Certainly ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["abba5223378890067b8e9665e2b8697ef1c00246409c931aad8cb63024bfaa6e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f6a25f25c32a5ba152bf18bcdb46d82b61170e4433374ce5f841bdadea2fa531"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-671f4cadfaf29913ffce6de8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018465,"date":"2026-05-27T03:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I ask the hon. minister if he would not agree with me that we have seen a steady stream of efforts to get Canadians corporations to invest in themselves and reinvest in R and D, and it is a string of failures, as David Dodge pointed out. The tools that we have tried just have not worked, and then people tend to turn on the corporate sector, which it does not appreciate. They say that the sector is not investing in itself and it is its fault.\n\nI am just hoping that we can learn lessons from the past and decide that it is time to ensure that we actually use Canadian workers in Canada to further process our raw materials and not ship them out raw. Might the government be thinking of putting in some measures that would encourage that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018465","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I ask the hon. minister if he would not agree with me that we have seen a steady stream of efforts to get Canadians corporations to invest in themselves and reinvest in R and D, and it is a string of failures, as David Dodge pointed out. The tools that we have tried just have not worked, and then people tend to turn on the corporate sector, which it does not appreciate. They say that th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca8face012f7cebb01d07746e4bcdccb6de0ec39106ad5562dcef9d554b51b63"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c3b51009ce78bc6a3b8f4339d020dab7b25386bb411980c5f5175039dd667368"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-395bc74ac616a92e2d117c67","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018477,"date":"2026-05-27T03:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, we are here borrowing $25 billion to start a sovereign wealth fund, but we have $793 billion in assets in the Canada pension plan, managed by the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board. Most of those investments go to the United States. The vast majority of them go to countries other than Canada. We have had some—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018477","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, we are here borrowing $25 billion to start a sovereign wealth fund, but we have $793 billion in assets in the Canada pension plan, managed by the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board. Most of those investments go to the United States. The vast majority of them go to countries other than Canada. We have had some—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b7f447e6edf4017364706580f9d2f8c0de773a3ea4d3cca132fccf3484df9557"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a4f4e3f40b3c7d038f95910bd66da0319f9e36902fe10311d56a2e8fee4db8d7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41a7eb81d232553313b33fab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018394,"date":"2026-05-27T20:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, later this afternoon we will hear the hon. member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie address the House one last time.\n\nI thank him. I salute him. He is a man of integrity and courage.\n\nMy question is for the Minister of the Environment. Will she find the courage to fight for climate? Will she find the courage to fight for our future?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018394","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, later this afternoon we will hear the hon. member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie address the House one last time.\n\nI thank him. I salute him. He is a man of integrity and courage.\n\nMy question is for the Minister of the Environment. Will she find the courage to fight for climate? Will she find the courage to fight for our future?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["74e53e10e2f51eb792fece63c2f09b1058d64db135238c8d7e6e26759e198598"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e68a7de2abed4cc67657b5e0a6b6b54f7d079987f790fb7cf2347371cac2a1f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb48516a5cc3ff04f120b5d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018400,"date":"2026-05-27T21:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Greens agree to apply the vote, thank the good lord, and vote yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018400","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Greens agree to apply the vote, thank the good lord, and vote yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a10f7ef0157f190c79fedcc8cb9346b5f33afd3212fdabbb32278411edc43cf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a88b51273d9f071601344e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018402,"date":"2026-05-27T21:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am presenting an e-petition that has the signatures of just under 5,000 Canadians, raising an issue that seems pretty much a no-brainer.\n\nThe death benefit from the Canadian pension plan has been frozen at the same level since 1998, at $2,500. Obviously, the cost of living and the cost of a funeral, the cost of dying, in this country have more than doubled since 1998.\n\nSince many Canadians outlive their savings, the petitioners are asking the House of Commons to consider that the CPP top-up death benefit really applies only to people who have never received CPP. The number of people who are suffering and who are living below the poverty line calls us to consider this: that the House of Commons and the government increase the CPP death benefit.\n\nPetitioners have calculated the inflation-adjusted 2025 value of where the benefit was in 1998, so they are calling on the government to increase the CPP death benefit to $6,400 and to provide tax deductions and credits for families for funeral expenses and other final expenses, to help all Canadian families afford a dignified funeral and burial for their loved ones.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Survivor benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018402","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am presenting an e-petition that has the signatures of just under 5,000 Canadians, raising an issue that seems pretty much a no-brainer.\n\nThe death benefit from the Canadian pension plan has been frozen at the same level since 1998, at $2,500. Obviously, the cost of living and the cost of a funeral, the cost of dying, in this country have more than doubled since 1998.\n\nSince many Ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","label":"Survivor benefits"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Survivor benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","label":"Survivor benefits","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8022e134625a2177e0361a720c2d2e657366ebdfb9e7f12494f339364c366782"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Survivor benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2571cfac5a5e19c29669c8a41791846b4e7beff7c87fde8a1fafc0e53b923a2e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Survivor benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0807fde13e06ac675db91932","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018409,"date":"2026-05-27T21:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank our colleague and dear friend, the member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie.\n\nI just want to say that it is an honour to work with him here. We have been friends for a long time, of course. It was an honour to work together as MPs in the House. It is a great honour for me. It is true that I will miss him here in Parliament, but I know that we will continue to work together.\n\n I do not know in what fashion, I do not know how, but I know that courage should be respected regardless of views. What we are dealing with is a crisis, but it is heartbreaking in this moment.\n\n I would like to thank the residents of Laurier—Sainte-Marie for their wisdom in electing him as their MP.\n\nThe only question I would have would be to give the member one more chance to tell us, of all the extraordinary things he has accomplished in his service to this place, what achievement he is most proud of or would want us to remember.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018409","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank our colleague and dear friend, the member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie.\n\nI just want to say that it is an honour to work with him here. We have been friends for a long time, of course. It was an honour to work together as MPs in the House. It is a great honour for me. It is true that I will miss him here in Parliament, but I know that we will continue to work togethe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f517e66a88a21f29088ae17bec3a7f7b372c5a346bfefd3f86c867b7dea70e11"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f703f48a7539be443fef2e1d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101403,"date":"2026-05-28T16:05:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I need to put on the record that, on every occasion, I appear under the format of motions that are identical and that are passed by every committee immediately following every election. They were originally designed by the Prime Minister's office under Stephen Harper to deprive me of rights I would otherwise have to present substantive amendments at report stage. I apologize for taking a moment to explain that I'm here under rules the committee passed that make a mockery of the notion that the committee is the master of its own process, since miraculously identical motions were passed at the same time by all committees simultaneously, depriving me of rights that I have. In this case, Mr. Chair, the amendments I'm bringing forward are exactly what was in Bill C-65 , which died on the Order Paper on January 6, 2025. At one point, at least, the government approved the suggestions being made through Elections Canada. In testimony before this committee in relation to Bill C-25 , I put a question to the Chief Electoral Officer about the recommendations that were previously made, and about the support of Elections Canada for changes that were previously made. I'm not a witness, so I won't say what specific impact it had on my party in the last election, but Bill C-65 and its changes died on the Order Paper. Amendment PV-1 is very straightforward. It's saying that we support the increased integrity measures found in Bill C-25 , but we don't want these measures to raise barriers to entry for candidates running as independents, candidates in smaller parties or candidates in small, remote communities. The amendment speaks for itself. It's very straightforward. In effect, it says that it should be 75 signatures on the nomination papers. With all the other rules in place, and with a witness present, it would be 75 electors from that electoral district. Again, given that this was in previous legislation, I hope committee members will see fit to accept the amendment. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101403","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I need to put on the record that, on every occasion, I appear under the format of motions that are identical and that are passed by every committee immediately following every election. They were originally designed by the Prime Minister's office under Stephen Harper to deprive me of rights I would otherwise have to present substantive amendments at report stage. I apologize ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["caa7b5181035296dea4148cf22dffe51ba755d0bfb6a9d344944c03c3fb9c738"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f25657f2b26c9a9fe763abbf6931301e54304bf6256c2eb05a7a93a10a69e3ee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7ef3a43ac9aeef06b4a16c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101404,"date":"2026-05-28T16:10:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"PROC","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is, again, consistent with what was in Bill C-65 . We want to improve the fairness and administrative efficiency by making the nomination window larger than it is in the current bill. Just to reflect again.... Under the terms of the motion that was put forward, I can't enter into debate, so under those terms, I wasn't allowed to enter into discussion as to why it can be more difficult to collect 100 signatures in 2026 than it was in 1990. What we discovered is that electors are extremely reticent and skeptical as to why they should provide information to a stranger on the street in ways that, in 2025 and 2026, aren't the same as in 2019. There's a large degree of resistance to providing personal information. You have to explain to someone on the street why you want their name and that it's not a scam. There's a lot more resistance and hostility in our current climate. It was to the point that volunteers were refusing to go back out, because they'd been harassed on the street for asking for information. It matters, particularly in a snap election, to be able to collect the signatures. With this amendment—which, again, was in the framework of Bill C-65 —we want to create the opportunity to start earlier, because collecting the signatures takes longer than it used to. You can run into a rainy day. We had electoral officers refusing signatures because they were smeared by the rain when they were brought to the electoral officer, having been collected on the street. People's electoral boundaries have changed, so sometimes they don't recognize the name across the top of the sheet. All this is to say that this amendment, PV-2, is solely to ensure that you start collecting your nomination papers...that they can allow them to be filed from the first day of the pre-election period instead of only in the writ period. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101404","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is, again, consistent with what was in Bill C-65 . We want to improve the fairness and administrative efficiency by making the nomination window larger than it is in the current bill. Just to reflect again.... Under the terms of the motion that was put forward, I can't enter into debate, so under those terms, I wasn't allowed to enter into discussion as to why it can be ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["edcac8d029a7266c60764b0345613b28c3c1e466f20c39a16e00d3c3cd4e813d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b2bbc9dd1d51a46c664d729a0a6d968503a8e9ba37b772a9fdd346eac084f82f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63987284a8f1d7790dc269a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101405,"date":"2026-05-28T16:20:00+00:00","title":"PROC","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"PROC","text":"Again, just to clarify what the amendment is about, yes, you can collect ahead, but to make sure that the signature is accepted, you have to be able to file it. The Chief Electoral Officer has to be able to look at it. The amendment is to that issue. I appreciate the clarification that was just brought forward by Blaine. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PROC/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101405","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Again, just to clarify what the amendment is about, yes, you can collect ahead, but to make sure that the signature is accepted, you have to be able to file it. The Chief Electoral Officer has to be able to look at it. The amendment is to that issue. I appreciate the clarification that was just brought forward by Blaine. Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebeead6be8d39e544118da05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018306,"date":"2026-05-28T17:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague is a relatively new member of the House.\n\nI want to congratulate my colleague on her French. I think she has improved considerably. That is something I had to work on as well. My goal is still to become truly bilingual.\n\nOnline streaming, as the member said, is a relatively new concept. Those of us who are older, and I will put myself in that category, did not grow up with the concept. We would not have known what anyone was talking about. We had television, and the big innovation when I was a kid was that we could get it in colour.\n\nI want to ask this again. What I am wondering, given that the changes are so rapid, is this: What does the member believe is the most important thing we can do to ensure that the big online streaming platforms hire more Canadian talent, hire more Canadian actors and pay them at scale instead of lesser wages while they bring in U.S. stars to sprinkle the programming?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018306","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague is a relatively new member of the House.\n\nI want to congratulate my colleague on her French. I think she has improved considerably. That is something I had to work on as well. My goal is still to become truly bilingual.\n\nOnline streaming, as the member said, is a relatively new concept. Those of us who are older, and I will put myself in that category, did not grow u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","label":"Television","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d5fdfa14256fc034d034c4223b5b2e40078ab32be1931463967d7569948aa29"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ef5a302c799c5ce6c8f5a175808bc281c05d0b0f77827f1f4914e3ac390ad4a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba640d2c88b79141e1adba89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018310,"date":"2026-05-28T18:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I also agree with what my colleague said about today's motion.\n\nIt is a mystery to me. I do not understand why anyone would oppose this tax, which is already enshrined in Canadian law, when big foreign companies like Netflix and others do not pay taxes in Canada. At the same time, they are making over $2 billion or $3 billion in profit—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018310","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I also agree with what my colleague said about today's motion.\n\nIt is a mystery to me. I do not understand why anyone would oppose this tax, which is already enshrined in Canadian law, when big foreign companies like Netflix and others do not pay taxes in Canada. At the same time, they are making over $2 billion or $3 billion in profit—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4bc8576b7a9bd525458a98b8bf4f9a25a7e688ab2955155e2c88477742325c3a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b39311bd38d1baf5eb9eb6804f7c57eaa54b691e10c8736691b11fe4423dd79"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d47f5f8d50ff7d346ecf0015","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018315,"date":"2026-05-28T23:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to pursue a question I initially asked on February 12 of this year, and it is one about which, regardless of party, I think most people in this House are concerned. \n\nThe question I asked related to knowing the concern we have in this place of foreign interference in elections and, particularly, the experience we have had on many issues that were brought to light by Madam Justice Hogue. I raised the issue of what would happen if there were efforts, potentially from the United States and other countries, to manipulate a potential Alberta referendum. The response I got from the hon. minister was not out of sympathy with the issue I raised. Of course, there is not a complete answer for any of us at this point. \n\nWe know that Elections Alberta would be in charge of any potential referendum. Since I asked the question on February 12, we now know that the Alberta premier has said she is going to put forward a question about a question, which is murky, confusing and opening up a can of worms. I think a lot of us are holding our breath and hoping she will not do the same thing that David Cameron did when he fatefully and idiotically appeased a small group of his own caucus by deciding to hold a referendum on the U.K. leaving the European Union, and did so absolutely confident that it could not possibly carry because the public opinion showed the vast majority of the people of England and Wales liked being part of the EU. That was before we heard names like Cambridge Analytica and found out how effectively algorithms and data mining could be used to convince people.\n\nThere is an extremely good film that explains all this in Hollywood fashion, but it is rooted in facts and very well done. It is called Brexit: The Uncivil War with Benedict Cumberbatch. It is absolutely terrifying to watch because it reminds us of what we watched in real time as Britain was divided and people believed absolute nonsense because they were convinced it was the truth. \n\nWe now have a situation where we know for a fact that David Parker, one of the leaders of the Centurion Project, is behind a major data breach. Alberta voter information was put up on public websites. Our former colleague in this place and former premier of Alberta, Jason Kenney, is very concerned, and for very good reason. This information included a lot of private information put up in public places. As I mentioned, David Parker is one of the leaders of the separatist movement in Alberta. Would he be concerned, I ask, about advice from Elections Alberta on how to conduct himself? He is not going to be concerned. He has already described Elections Alberta as an \"evil\" institution. This is extraordinary.\n\nThe privacy breaches that have occurred in Alberta should make everyone very concerned. We have heard from a Canadian leading expert in national security, Wesley Wark, whose name is known to all of us. From 2005 to 2009, he was a two-term adviser to the prime minister on national security. He has expressed significant concern about what could happen in an Alberta referendum and how we can ensure there is not foreign interference and also domestic interference, such as happened in Brexit. \n\nWhat will the government do to be prepared and hold this country together?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018315","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to pursue a question I initially asked on February 12 of this year, and it is one about which, regardless of party, I think most people in this House are concerned. \n\nThe question I asked related to knowing the concern we have in this place of foreign interference in elections and, particularly, the experience we have had on many issues that were brought to light by Mad","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9ab11dd2dfc7851bfc087566106b1d8e41d42f029a8a47a859e572d2fc34070f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d42341a04d6aa1ae2b70333f6433031cf68f9b625bb89a189019740fb49e4817"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdcc7e947d4f5e6b581d6b7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018344,"date":"2026-05-28T23:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in the minute I have left, first of all, I want to thank to the hon. representative of the government here in the House. This was very helpful.\n\n I think we need to, as Canadians, as settler culture people, understand how profoundly fortunate we are that indigenous rights and rights holders are protected under section 35 of the Constitution. With the honour of the Crown being at stake, the treaties achieved by the treaty peoples of Alberta with the Crown and the indigenous nations of Alberta with the Crown are probably our best way to hold the country together. \n\nThe federal government should be in court every step of the way, joining with the Mikisew Cree and others in ensuring an injunction against the very idea that lands that were committed to indigenous peoples before the province of Alberta existed are protected, and treaty rights protect us all and protect Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018344","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in the minute I have left, first of all, I want to thank to the hon. representative of the government here in the House. This was very helpful.\n\n I think we need to, as Canadians, as settler culture people, understand how profoundly fortunate we are that indigenous rights and rights holders are protected under section 35 of the Constitution. With the honour of the Crown being at stake","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dbe6ef9851bc9fc6d539566e6f0728426e948e7cd0c5c49f434858bb6471c90d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6ef99b9d061b015538e5afa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018347,"date":"2026-05-29T03:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I will be sharing my time with the hon. member for Vancouver East.\n\nI want to say that moments of tonight's discussions have been encouraging. After the horrors of the passage of Bill C-12 and international condemnation that it attacks refugee rights, it was so refreshing that some of the points I was going to make were made by the hon. member for Pierrefonds—Dollard on the long delays in getting people out of Gaza and out of the horrible situations found in Sudan. Also, it was wonderful to hear the words one wants to hear of compassion from a Canadian from the hon. member for Spadina—Harbourfront.\n\nMy question to the minister is the following. Is the department considering that it is long since time to recognize that the United States is no longer a safe third country after ICE has arrested over 900 children who have been held for more than 20 days?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018347","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I will be sharing my time with the hon. member for Vancouver East.\n\nI want to say that moments of tonight's discussions have been encouraging. After the horrors of the passage of Bill C-12 and international condemnation that it attacks refugee rights, it was so refreshing that some of the points I was going to make were made by the hon. member for Pierrefonds—Dollard on the long delays ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4af9956e972f763d6524230b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018349,"date":"2026-05-29T03:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I consider myself at least bicoastal, having spent much of my life on Cape Breton Island. I also went to Dalhousie law school, so I am at least partially Haligonian.\n\nI hear a lot of concerns from my constituents. My constituency office is pretty much overwhelmed with people who need help as they are caught up in the long delays of trying to get processed by IRCC. It is not uncommon for security assessments to take several years, and we know that a lot of the international partnering agencies that work with IRCC create tremendous bottlenecks.\n\nWhat is the department planning to do to expedite the process and to find a better balance between security and compassion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018349","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I consider myself at least bicoastal, having spent much of my life on Cape Breton Island. I also went to Dalhousie law school, so I am at least partially Haligonian.\n\nI hear a lot of concerns from my constituents. My constituency office is pretty much overwhelmed with people who need help as they are caught up in the long delays of trying to get processed by IRCC. It is not uncommon for","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["038a15f5577f42b2fecf96177e3df06a7087377163d7ef5f57165b3fb0f9136e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e92de7f0b033d430249fa546143da907cd7924f12ea6474eac06f3082835269"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ee59b605eefd8b16b78df05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018351,"date":"2026-05-29T03:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, we know that we want to attract, as the minister has mentioned tonight, skilled and talented people, new Canadians who bring the talents and skills we need, but this is not just a compassion exercise. This is also a steep competition. It was recently pointed out in Policy Options magazine, just last month, that Canada risks discovering too late that the real consequences of a burdensome and cumbersome process are not just delayed applications but losing eligible and desirable people, who go elsewhere.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018351","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, we know that we want to attract, as the minister has mentioned tonight, skilled and talented people, new Canadians who bring the talents and skills we need, but this is not just a compassion exercise. This is also a steep competition. It was recently pointed out in Policy Options magazine, just last month, that Canada risks discovering too late that the real consequences of a burdensome","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd841114160b25795dea4ff6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018368,"date":"2026-05-29T03:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, another big concern for my constituents is the home care worker program. The home care worker immigration pilot, as the minister knows, was opened in March 2025 and closed soon thereafter. We understand from her department that it has been paused. When will it restart?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018368","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, another big concern for my constituents is the home care worker program. The home care worker immigration pilot, as the minister knows, was opened in March 2025 and closed soon thereafter. We understand from her department that it has been paused. When will it restart?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9a5fb81ace5bbe80de2c83b852ed60ece047013699b77e31749d9f31354a9e9f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["51331f243447f32805a4df33cc84b4c6f77a5eb663cd015fea9a1d9b9a5e70bf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb463e6e58fc303513ed7fec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018375,"date":"2026-05-29T03:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, it should not be so difficult when people are living in Canada as permanent residents and want to bring their parents here on a TRV to visit their grandchildren. Why is that so bottlenecked?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018375","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, it should not be so difficult when people are living in Canada as permanent residents and want to bring their parents here on a TRV to visit their grandchildren. Why is that so bottlenecked?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8dd9cbaf7ed127ad0686ca5ffeb3b890a71a225c54921ba45bc9a3aa900f35f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["12f034d167449665b4dbe66e6fe5aa44f83771f140dba14341b7132b1c92cc8f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3a0fe90775686e623aa5179","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018385,"date":"2026-05-29T03:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, does the minister believe there is a lack of financial resources to her department? Is it a lack of people power that makes this a grinding misery for so many people who either are here and wanting their permanent residency or are overseas and wanting to come here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018385","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, does the minister believe there is a lack of financial resources to her department? Is it a lack of people power that makes this a grinding misery for so many people who either are here and wanting their permanent residency or are overseas and wanting to come here?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a619982d881fb62d76166d7ff8ba662dd04ad7ed11e081e48ad67e9644460100"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5260129a61a5f504b6bcaabf38b6c92ec3f5782c0d400b3e3eacd4c293ecf2e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8368c65c3dd77cf649f6b980","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018388,"date":"2026-05-29T03:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, as the minister hears from every corner of the House, there is deep concern that her department is not delivering for the safety and security of Canadians, but my concern is far more that we are not delivering on our own reputation for being compassionate and humanitarian people.\n\nWill the minister agree that much more needs to be done, and is there a timeline and a strategy to deliver on these concerns?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018388","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, as the minister hears from every corner of the House, there is deep concern that her department is not delivering for the safety and security of Canadians, but my concern is far more that we are not delivering on our own reputation for being compassionate and humanitarian people.\n\nWill the minister agree that much more needs to be done, and is there a timeline and a strategy to deliver ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3208cea484a7d199b88fb0d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018392,"date":"2026-05-29T03:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, with all due respect, it is not adequate. If the main estimates discussion tonight ends up being a cry for help, that this is not adequate, that should be taken to the cabinet table. It is not adequate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018392","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, with all due respect, it is not adequate. If the main estimates discussion tonight ends up being a cry for help, that this is not adequate, that should be taken to the cabinet table. It is not adequate.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87324a951168639a4d55fa2d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018288,"date":"2026-05-29T15:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I really enjoyed my colleague's speech.\n\nMy question is about the last part of his speech, when he talked about the difference between a minority and a majority Parliament, from a democracy standpoint.\n\nSome citizens, some Quebeckers, do believe that it is better if the government has a majority. Why is a minority government better for democracy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018288","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I really enjoyed my colleague's speech.\n\nMy question is about the last part of his speech, when he talked about the difference between a minority and a majority Parliament, from a democracy standpoint.\n\nSome citizens, some Quebeckers, do believe that it is better if the government has a majority. Why is a minority government better for democracy?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c739f42bc7ed94891aa9ea20eb867149dc4f40072aea0d4441883d4f66d92b96"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-322397bc08921a7bc20ae99d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018300,"date":"2026-05-29T15:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague for Edmonton Strathcona, not just for today's speech but for absolutely everything. I do not always get to put a question to her, and she is stalwart on so many issues that it would take my time in a question just to list them.\n\nMy question is this: Is the member also struggling, as I am, to understand why we have now received a 331-page, part 2 budget bill, Bill C-31, and what within it has attracted her attention other than the macro-level issues she addressed in her speech?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018300","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague for Edmonton Strathcona, not just for today's speech but for absolutely everything. I do not always get to put a question to her, and she is stalwart on so many issues that it would take my time in a question just to list them.\n\nMy question is this: Is the member also struggling, as I am, to understand why we have now received a 331-page, part 2 budge","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ae2f636b83f5002a537071e3abc1974914fbefec6db4a945407193f87287a6f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af60f096696f53ac2cc2ad0e764fca0359996741b7ff1d101a64160120ff7b9d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40deabd1e0ec1a597884ff9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1018302,"date":"2026-05-29T17:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a true honour, as always, to stand in this place, particularly with the petition I am presenting today, which concerns one of my constituents. I know I am just to present the petition, so with a tiny bit of latitude I would like to say that Robert Bateman's birthday was last week. He is one of Canada's most extraordinary wildlife artists.\n\n The petitioners from Saanich—Gulf Islands are asking that the government speak to the National Gallery of Canada. Obviously, the National Gallery is independently run, and the petitioners know this, but they point out the shocking reality that even though its mandate is to showcase artists who contribute significantly to Canadian culture and identity, Mr. Robert Bateman's work has never been exhibited there. Therefore, the petitioners call on the government to urge the National Gallery of Canada to redress this and hold an exhibition for Canadians on the lifetime work of Robert Bateman.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Artists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018302","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a true honour, as always, to stand in this place, particularly with the petition I am presenting today, which concerns one of my constituents. I know I am just to present the petition, so with a tiny bit of latitude I would like to say that Robert Bateman's birthday was last week. He is one of Canada's most extraordinary wildlife artists.\n\n The petitioners from Saanich—Gulf Isla","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","label":"Artists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Artists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","label":"Artists","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","label":"Wildlife","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c84d7ea4a4dfbebfef931a75208f23028d06529d6526241126bd233273bbcea7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Artists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90e6d16c38a50dcb5200958987f393a880e6dceef7e480699beac82dad89ba2a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Artists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6622cae999b42facf5d257fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036869,"date":"2026-06-01T20:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in the petition I am honoured to present today, petitioners note that the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has pointed out that the impacts of climate change disproportionately hit those portions of the world that have contributed least to the problem in the global south. Particularly, the petitioners point out that the damage that will be done will also reverberate to Canada and that climate impacts through extreme weather events and loss of food production will contribute to 100 million more people living in poverty globally by 2030.\n\n The petitioners ask that the Government of Canada ensure that the limited amount of global finances should be expanded so that we can do more as an industrialized country that has contributed to the problem. They ask that the Government of Canada focus on adaptation measures, at least equally with other measures, to reduce emissions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036869","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in the petition I am honoured to present today, petitioners note that the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has pointed out that the impacts of climate change disproportionately hit those portions of the world that have contributed least to the problem in the global south. Particularly, the petitioners point out that the damage that will be done will also reverberate to Canada","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f58dfb4bca6453a09757e3ef57f4a824c47f30b9d71d60270f3aeaa71338b4ef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6fe942cb938162b1c37f4070f6aa0a9ed0ac87b3441a037b750b63aa1feaa08e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccc7976cd0bf783040d42b71","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036870,"date":"2026-06-01T22:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my esteemed colleague from South Shore—St. Margarets for sharing her time with me.\n\nUnfortunately, I disagree with her last comment that we have time to debate the bill now. Given the gag order, enough time to debate the bill is exactly what we do not have.\n\n I want to speak to what is happening here. I am going to throw in Bill C-30, because I was not allowed to speak to it. We rushed through it so fast that I did not get a speech at second reading. For Bill C-30 and Bill C-31, back-to-back omnibus budget bills, both had a reduction of debate. Due to the newly minted majority Liberal government, we were not given the normal amount of time to have debate before moving to the vote at second reading.\n\nI am sure the Speaker recognizes how often I have raised this concern in the House. It has accelerated. It is becoming de rigueur. It is almost with every single bill that we are told we have had enough time to talk about it and we move on. \n\nThere are many things that one would focus on with respect to two omnibus bills. What I want to focus on in the time I have is with respect to the one we are debating today, Bill C-31, which is 331 pages long. I lugged it around with me all weekend. There is only one part of it that I want to raise now, but there would be more. When we get to committee perhaps I will get an opportunity to say a word or two.\n\nThese are budget implementation acts. Bill C-30 has now passed second reading and Bill C-31 is what we are debating now. One would think there would be a very strong connection to the budget. That is what the point is; these are implementation of the budget. In Bill C-30 and Bill C-31, I want to talk about the significant changes to the Pest Control Products Act. We remember that the 2025 budget was all about build Canada strong. There is one line about the Pest Control Products Act, which is now the subject of changes in Bill C-30 and Bill C-31. \n\nHere is one line from budget 2025, which states, \"the government proposes to amend legislation to remove cyclical pesticide re-evaluations to enable modern, risk-based oversight.\"\n\nAccording to Prevent Cancer Now and Ecojustice, one of the country's leading environmental law groups, this is not about modern risk-based oversight, but about reducing the regulation of pesticides, reducing environment and health and safety controls that can actually affect human health, as well as the environment, in ways that I found completely shocking. \n\nBecause the debate on Bill C-30 was shut down after three hours, there was not time for every member or even every party to make a speech. I did manage to ask the parliamentary secretary for finance when it was first tabled how it was that there were these provisions to so weaken pesticide oversight and pesticide reviews. I asked if it would be possible to have a section of the bill, division 8, go to a committee on health or the environment to be studied. The hon. parliamentary secretary said he would look into it, but I have heard nothing further and, as far as we know, this is going to the finance committee, not a health and safety committee. \n\nI have not had an opportunity to speak to this in the House, and it does relate to Bill C-31, because it is more of the same.\n\n Bill C-30 says, which is astonishing, that if a minister decides that a pest control product is so dangerous it cannot be used, that usually is the end of the matter. This refers to a pesticide, and this covers herbicides, insecticides, rodenticides and all manner of products that are intended to kill living things, insecticides and herbicides being the most common.\n\nHowever, now, because of Bill C-30, which as I said was pushed through second reading after three hours of debate, the cabinet can override the Minister of Health or the Minister of Environment if they consider it \"necessary to do so to protect national economic security, regional economic security, or national food security.\" \n\nGoing back to the original budget, we see that they have thrown in this justification here and there. Sometimes, it is referenced as having to make these measures because they want to move to, as I mentioned before, modern oversight. In other places, it is referenced as though we can bring down the cost of groceries if we use more pesticides. There is no evidence for this whatsoever.\n\nHaving worked on pesticides in this country as an environmental lawyer, and before that as an activist, I have worked on pesticide issues in this country since 1975. In any case, no government has ever attempted something as reckless as what Bill C-30 would do in saying that the decision of the minister responsible, when a substance is too dangerous to be used, could be overturned by cabinet, at cabinet's discretion, if it seems that it affects, astonishingly, \"national economic security, regional economic security or national food security\". \n\nThese are the kinds of cuts to regulations that Margaret Thatcher engaged in that led to mad cow disease. We do not cut corners on health and safety. We do not cut corners on pesticide regulation for national economic concerns, overriding a minister of environment or a minister of health. It is quite surprising.\n\nI was unable to speak to Bill C-30 at second reading debate, and now we have come to Bill C-31. I have to say I was astonished, in reading the 331 pages of Bill C-31, to find that it too takes aim at the Pest Control Products Act. This time it is found in division 13 in changes to the Pest Control Products Act to reduce the mandatory review every 15 years to look at a substance and, if the situation has changed, to have an evaluation. They are routine, but the bill we have before us today would change the review, and this gets murky. As someone who practised law, I know that one of the things we hate to see in new legislation is a change to the definitions because, by the time most legislation has gone around for a couple of years, and this legislation has been around for decades, the meaning of the words is clear, so there is not a lot of room for uncertainty and not knowing what we are dealing with.\n\nIn this legislation, we suddenly have the discretionary initiating of an assessment and then, if the minister is convinced that, on the basis of the assessment, the health and safety and the environmental risks of a registered pest control product have increased significantly, then the minister may have a re-evaluation, but the minister may also decide at any time to stop the re-evaluation. \n\nTherefore, there would be no certainty and, certainly from a public health point of view and from an environmental point of view, this would fundamentally weaken the regime within which we use chemicals and products that are, by definition, intended to be toxic. They are intended to kill things. It is not an accident. That is their purpose. Therefore, the notion that we would no longer have cyclical re-evaluations undermines science. That is the bottom line. Ecojustice, one of Canada's pre-eminent environmental law groups, finds that this must be amended, that we must maintain cyclical re-evaluations and uphold science-based decision-making.\n\nEarlier today, one of the members here presented a really important petition, and I am wondering if these things are not connected. Is there a pro-pesticide bias emerging from the current government that connects with cuts at the Swift Current agriculture research station in Swift Current, Saskatchewan? It was the country's pre-eminent research hub for many years in organic agriculture. Does the current government dislike the idea of organic agriculture? Does it want to promote pesticide-based agriculture?\n\n Again, here we are. This bill has had, as far as I can count, about one and a half days of debate. In its first day of debate, most of the debate time was taken up by the farewell speech of the hon. member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie. The time is up, but we have to let Canadians know that this is unacceptable.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036870","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my esteemed colleague from South Shore—St. Margarets for sharing her time with me.\n\nUnfortunately, I disagree with her last comment that we have time to debate the bill now. Given the gag order, enough time to debate the bill is exactly what we do not have.\n\n I want to speak to what is happening here. I am going to throw in Bill C-30, because I was not allowed to speak to it. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["414d01b9f436d3fd4cbc4bf6d4df112fd5435789e61b71dd276ce56046959033"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c7fe15ef1e68f343a8a7943c6bf3163c30691b13fbf60101147996d1d2b9a65"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bedd914205d2bf029705c585","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036872,"date":"2026-06-01T22:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will not concede it because it is not true. The reality is that the Conservatives have been more than obliging in helping the government pass lots of legislation, including Bill C-5, and including things I found astonishing. \n\nThe reality is that now, with the new Liberal majority, we are seeing time allocation when it is not needed and pushing things through before they are properly studied. In the end, and I offer this from my heart as a warning to the majority Liberals, this will come back to bite them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036872","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will not concede it because it is not true. The reality is that the Conservatives have been more than obliging in helping the government pass lots of legislation, including Bill C-5, and including things I found astonishing. \n\nThe reality is that now, with the new Liberal majority, we are seeing time allocation when it is not needed and pushing things through before they are properl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e66e343f38aaa4eaa8870d80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036873,"date":"2026-06-01T22:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I did vote for it, and I stand here as the only member of the opposition who voted for the Liberal budget, because not only was I given oral promises, but the commitment against putting forward investment tax credits for enhanced oil recovery was also in black and white and printed in the budget. That was reversed within 10 days of that vote, so yes, I would have voted against the budget had I known the Liberals did not intend to keep words that were printed in the budget. \n\nThat is quite something. It is a new record. Some governments forget what they said they were going to put in a budget, and two or three years later they have not done it, but I have never seen a promise in a budget reversed. Neither had the hon. member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie, which is why he is going to be leaving this place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036873","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I did vote for it, and I stand here as the only member of the opposition who voted for the Liberal budget, because not only was I given oral promises, but the commitment against putting forward investment tax credits for enhanced oil recovery was also in black and white and printed in the budget. That was reversed within 10 days of that vote, so yes, I would have voted against the bud","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da58534ff1b05fd6babebb230bace8ad457acac4fb34626ff9bd7efb59eb085d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8759761e7bac9fcabd6376fbeca3dc59bc7c42eca932f3d3e801b1d100f747cf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-476713e50a594a282a88ee13","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036874,"date":"2026-06-01T22:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I completely agree with my Bloc Québécois colleague.\n\nIt is clear that this is, unfortunately, a real tragedy. I am very disappointed. It is now clear that, with the current policies, the Government of Canada can no longer meet the Paris Agreement targets. That will have a huge impact on Canada's security and the economy, as well as worldwide.\n\nWe have a great challenge ahead of us and the Government of Canada and the Prime Minister have decided that they are not interested in the future. I do not understand how it is possible for someone who understands the crisis to make these decisions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036874","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I completely agree with my Bloc Québécois colleague.\n\nIt is clear that this is, unfortunately, a real tragedy. I am very disappointed. It is now clear that, with the current policies, the Government of Canada can no longer meet the Paris Agreement targets. That will have a huge impact on Canada's security and the economy, as well as worldwide.\n\nWe have a great challenge ahead of us an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c2a5f24160cd45ebb2563960a84b25b7eedc054bc4577e66b22f009fbbb5d6d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b5eed58e84571c06b4b76e84fa1bb3ba1c1740e81a4914f57dca97cad4712f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f6a23ba78e4af0750b909e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036875,"date":"2026-06-01T22:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in 10 seconds, all I can say is that it makes no sense. I do not understand it. Someone needs to ask the Prime Minister why he is making these decisions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036875","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in 10 seconds, all I can say is that it makes no sense. I do not understand it. Someone needs to ask the Prime Minister why he is making these decisions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e903ba232f8b6e674f38e7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036861,"date":"2026-06-02T16:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, my question concerns the Bloc Québécois's economic approach. It is clear that the Liberals, the former Conservatives and the current Conservative Party all think alike when it comes to the economy. It is always about economic growth, but without regard for the well-being of everyone.\n\nWhat do my colleague from Mirabel and the Bloc Québécois think of the circular economy or Kate Raworth's book Doughnut Economics: Seven Ways to Think Like a 21st-Century Economist? Could my colleague explain what the Bloc Québécois's approach to envisioning a different economy entails?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036861","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, my question concerns the Bloc Québécois's economic approach. It is clear that the Liberals, the former Conservatives and the current Conservative Party all think alike when it comes to the economy. It is always about economic growth, but without regard for the well-being of everyone.\n\nWhat do my colleague from Mirabel and the Bloc Québécois think of the circular economy or Kate Rawo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab3ba8ae879b6ee1f0f494055bcf9bf1fb110899f0dca21ae7c1a888daa811b2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1a91e5d5f40dfeadfdb9138a7418f9216c935892b9fc71a2d4fb1b5e44c95f5e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d6d1ccb8ed0c300ad322503","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036863,"date":"2026-06-02T20:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, to the point of order raised by the hon. member and the question of privilege raised by the hon. member for Vancouver East, having been in those discussions on the main estimates, and I know I do not need to reacquaint you, Mr. Speaker, I note the serious nature of those committee of the whole sessions. I am very troubled by what the hon. member for Vancouver East has detailed in what she has documented, and I hope this matter will be investigated thoroughly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036863","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, to the point of order raised by the hon. member and the question of privilege raised by the hon. member for Vancouver East, having been in those discussions on the main estimates, and I know I do not need to reacquaint you, Mr. Speaker, I note the serious nature of those committee of the whole sessions. I am very troubled by what the hon. member for Vancouver East has detailed in what","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e215efee563aad32be39919e7eb425cc3bb4f254d14e0241d68c5656bc029878"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96e59b891ccf1295b16207da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036865,"date":"2026-06-02T22:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, to my hon. colleague from North Vancouver—Capilano, it is bittersweet to see him leave this place. The only sweet part is knowing that he will be representing Canada so well as our ambassador to the European Union, a jurisdiction that has not forgotten climate change. \n\nEarlier today, I was meeting with a colleague from the German Greens who serves as a member of the European Parliament. She was describing to me what it was like to work in Brussels and Strasbourg, back and forth, and she thought it was a long trip. I explained what it was like to be a British Columbia member of Parliament in this place. She is from Hanover. The hon. member may run into her someday.\n\nMy hon. colleague and friend from North Vancouver—Capilano and I have become friends. I do not think we started out that way, but it was one of my favourite moments in any committee meeting when our hon. colleague gave me his time at the beginning of the environment committee. It was a choice moment, and it does not happen very often, but he did not really need a briefing book either way. I will just say that. He is one of the ministers in this place who are not in need of someone telling them what the facts are or telling them what to say. It would be unnecessary.\n\n In reviewing all the years that he has served in this place, primarily under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau as Minister of Fisheries, Minister of Environment and Climate Change and Minister of Energy and Natural Resources, anyone here will know that we hardly ever crossed paths: in other words, pretty constantly. There is the work that the hon. member did on fisheries, as my hon. friend from Vancouver Kingsway has pointed out, the work to ban single-use plastics to get them out of our oceans, the work, as has been mentioned, for wild salmon, the work on carbon pricing and the work to move to a post-carbon economy. \n\nThese lessons and the hard fights that he had must not be lost, so I will say, from the bottom of my heart, \"thank you\", and I will say that perhaps his child Max might say that when the member gets to Brussels, he should change Canada's position to make ecocide a crime under the International Criminal Court provisions. That is just something to take away. No one asked me to say that.\n\nAdditionally, I would say to the hon. member for North Vancouver—Capilano as he leaves here that we are always in the right to remember one of the greatest Canadian parliamentarians ever, Tommy Douglas. The fact that the hon. member was able to be brought into cabinet to represent Saskatchewan, while a Vancouver MP, is one of those things that we know will define him as a great Canadian to represent Canada to the EU.\n\nI ask him to remember other lines that I recall from William Blake's Jerusalem, which I also love. It is not \"my sword sleep in my hand\" or about this green land, but remember how William Blake described industry: the \"dark Satanic Mills\".\n\nTo the hon. member, continue the good work. We look forward to seeing him at home in Canada, and in the meantime I hope to be able to come now and then to Brussels. I thank him so much for his service. There are not enough words to thank him.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036865","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, to my hon. colleague from North Vancouver—Capilano, it is bittersweet to see him leave this place. The only sweet part is knowing that he will be representing Canada so well as our ambassador to the European Union, a jurisdiction that has not forgotten climate change. \n\nEarlier today, I was meeting with a colleague from the German Greens who serves as a member of the European Parliame","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b021cad55fc4534e4fbc72d95656c225e2e2cb5107f8b3b306214d16363a7bbc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c81d3c1c18a9fbe20ff0e2e3edd11938be9a44e9285bcdf978d5a13423cb0626"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5cfaa992ba35e0f5898672f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036866,"date":"2026-06-02T23:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am rising at the hour of adjournment, or as we colloquially call it around here, the late show, to pursue a question I asked the Prime Minister but to which the response came from the hon. Minister of Foreign Affairs.\n\nThe question I asked was on March 9 and was in relation to the events of February 28, when, illegally, the government of Israel and the government of the United States authorized attacks, strikes, on Iran. In my question to the hon. minister, I quoted our former minister of foreign affairs, the Hon. Lloyd Axworthy, who actually wrote to the Toronto Star to say, \"Canada once rejected America's aggressive, unlawful foreign policy. Today [the Prime Minister] embraced it.\" He went on to say, again quoting Lloyd Axworthy, \"Under the [United Nations] Charter, cross-border uses of force are prohibited except in two narrow cases\". He then pointed out that Operation Epic Fury, as the White House called it, applies to neither.\n\n I wanted to ask the Prime Minister at the time whether he would belatedly condemn what the U.S. and Israel did in attacking Iran. The response from the Minister of Foreign Affairs, just to summarize, was that while we support Iran's never obtaining nuclear weapons, this support is not a blank cheque. Canada reaffirms that international law binds all parties. The U.S. and Israel must respect the rules of international engagement. In other words, this stopped and fell short of a condemnation of our allies' ignoring international law. That is in fact what we did. The condemnation should have been from Canada's government immediately.\n\n I want to include in my brief remarks tonight while pursuing this question something that I rarely do. I would like to thank a member of the opposition benches, a newly elected member of Parliament from the riding that abuts mine, shall we say, my neighbour, the hon. Liberal member for Victoria, who was, prior to entering politics, associate professor of international law at the University of Victoria. He was unequivocal in issuing a written statement that Canada's response fell short.\n\nI will quote the hon. member for Victoria as he was quoted in the Times Colonist: \"Canada cannot endorse the unilateral and illegal acts of military force\". He went on to call for \"a consistent Canadian standard, one that applies the laws of war and the principle of protecting civilians, whether the actors are allies or adversaries.\"\n\n The difficulty we have is that Canada should have been quick to condemn in the first Trump administration. I think we actually did that when the Trump administration tore up the agreement that had been reached with Iran, which was working. Of course the goal is to make sure Iran never has nuclear weapons. The Government of Iran is ruthless, ignores human rights, is abusive and also exports terrorism. Nobody questions that, but ignoring international law is a grave error. In the case of the original U.S.-Iran deal, it was working. It was \"Trust but verify\". The international atomic energy experts were getting access to all the research facilities.\n\nAs the time passes, I wonder what the government is saying about the United Nations charter and international law. Is it only when it is convenient?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036866","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am rising at the hour of adjournment, or as we colloquially call it around here, the late show, to pursue a question I asked the Prime Minister but to which the response came from the hon. Minister of Foreign Affairs.\n\nThe question I asked was on March 9 and was in relation to the events of February 28, when, illegally, the government of Israel and the government of the United State","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0c68bac354cb8e9da5df4b89d7e1b0bc20daa8b017ac04578425fe0cfc050ddc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71dfac6f0652f2799da50683831a4a5722a878cfb53619e7368b8f6975800385"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-afc42dd6ecadd1315856eb68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036868,"date":"2026-06-02T23:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I really appreciate my hon. friend, the parliamentary secretary, for giving such a thoughtful answer. He is quite correct that I did not get out the last words, which were, will the Prime Minister belatedly condemn these actions? \n\nThe actions have continued, as the parliamentary secretary indicated, from that horrible attack of February 28. We have now had the spreading of conflict in multiple directions. There are sanctions against Hezbollah and sanctions against Iran, but when are we going to talk about sanctions against Netanyahu and Israel for persistently violating international law? \n\nAgain, what can we do? I know it is complicated by Trump's attacks on Canada in terms of our commerce and trade, but the reality is that there are several great destabilizers around the world right now. There is Trump, there is Netanyahu, and there is Putin. How can Canada amplify our diplomatic efforts and consider sanctions against these bad actors?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036868","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I really appreciate my hon. friend, the parliamentary secretary, for giving such a thoughtful answer. He is quite correct that I did not get out the last words, which were, will the Prime Minister belatedly condemn these actions? \n\nThe actions have continued, as the parliamentary secretary indicated, from that horrible attack of February 28. We have now had the spreading of conflict i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63b2dff889112b33bf749a19f1374c60ef0c0f7b7d5e568834e1cfc856136855"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ef348d4349b0a1194fb82fa988061a6146381b018d9b9a9459d9d33ea48b3da"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b59232990a68b07dc603abdc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036855,"date":"2026-06-03T20:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Greens agree to apply the vote and will be voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036855","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Greens agree to apply the vote and will be voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cffbd3e335139abc3cd0ecb83063853341838a874259e2d3d3e00c317437f6d6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a535c41104f37d4141d20fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036856,"date":"2026-06-03T20:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote, and will be voting in favour.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036856","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote, and will be voting in favour.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f552ea846e5e90230be4425034a4ccad2df79887cbfde1bc009e4910599bda3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f38be1c556226a620e046e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036857,"date":"2026-06-03T20:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote, and we are voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036857","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote, and we are voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7630ff01e67387d625f0772b38383215a2323568f83ad8db3dc47fc455bcf2df"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76c1cad3928e0e9cad5d230a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036858,"date":"2026-06-03T21:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today being June 3, we have hit the seventh anniversary of the tabling of the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls inquiry.\n\nThe petitioners call the attention of Parliament to the ongoing harm toward indigenous peoples and communities, through both historical and ongoing colonization and genocide. The petitioners point out that the legal and social change needed to address the high rates of violence against indigenous women and girls was pointed out in the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls inquiry, and there are over 231 calls for justice.\n\nThe petitioners point out that the federal government is jointly or directly accountable for 76 of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's calls to action, but has only acted on 13 to date. Of the 231 calls for justice in the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls, there have only been, at this point, three dealt with according to the last data.\n\nThe petitioners call on the government to fully adopt and implement the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and to prioritize funding and policies that advance Canada's process for reconciliation and justice.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036858","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today being June 3, we have hit the seventh anniversary of the tabling of the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls inquiry.\n\nThe petitioners call the attention of Parliament to the ongoing harm toward indigenous peoples and communities, through both historical and ongoing colonization and genocide. The petitioners point out that the legal and social change needed to address","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c85f8bc265eca1c5ebec6b9056f9ccced5377253ce585fe3f6b4a3d50777bfe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["784cdbb31cc254b2824c021fbeeee830abf0545523c09e87d748db295baa078c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bfb8db746cebdc04bcd952ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036845,"date":"2026-06-04T16:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the hon. Minister of Justice will know that I have never seen a debate closure motion that I liked. I think time allocation is overused.\n\nI support Bill C‐16, although I regret that my amendments to extend coercive control to protect seniors from elder abuse were not accepted in this round. Perhaps I can use this opportunity to ask him, since the bill now contains a periodic review, if the justice department would not see fit to bring in a bill against elder abuse, specifically dealing with the coercive control of seniors by those who are close to them or make the pretense of being close to them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036845","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the hon. Minister of Justice will know that I have never seen a debate closure motion that I liked. I think time allocation is overused.\n\nI support Bill C‐16, although I regret that my amendments to extend coercive control to protect seniors from elder abuse were not accepted in this round. Perhaps I can use this opportunity to ask him, since the bill now contains a periodic review,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","label":"Elder abuse"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","label":"Elder abuse","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca698745eed318566a1e6daee48cd0a939386877360c2e162e523eab56209ee2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c2f674a4508dedb170f6c5972a5ab5ea9c37eef53b272eb56ccaadb3d530b476"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32a9d897ce20e8119ed1400f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036847,"date":"2026-06-04T18:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am very pleased to have a chance to take the floor to ask a question of my colleague from Milton East—Halton Hills South.\n\n I am distressed. I certainly agree with all the sentiments. We need to make sure that we are acting to protect people from the crimes that we have talked about, including intimate partner violence. However, we are falling back on rhetoric in the absence of evidence when we start echoing the notion that mandatory minimum sentences are somehow great at preventing crime, because there is no evidence for that at all. Empirical studies from all around the world, particularly from the U.S., where they were used a lot in Texas, prove conclusively that they do not deter crime. What deters crime is the risk of being caught, not longer sentences.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036847","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am very pleased to have a chance to take the floor to ask a question of my colleague from Milton East—Halton Hills South.\n\n I am distressed. I certainly agree with all the sentiments. We need to make sure that we are acting to protect people from the crimes that we have talked about, including intimate partner violence. However, we are falling back on rhetoric in the absence of evid","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4fcaac7af986a830cabd4773342998177c00494f3cb801659c06032638092fdb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1f1e839b63d5c61dc2eca0335fcd0c48fb277ea09a7213bdaf5a3b04be4824c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be3c3d96d986926ae23b2f80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036848,"date":"2026-06-04T20:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I wonder how the slogan \"AI for all\" lands in Tumbler Ridge—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036848","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I wonder how the slogan \"AI for all\" lands in Tumbler Ridge—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71e457e4d0e49d756c8b45fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036851,"date":"2026-06-04T20:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, children's lives could have been saved if we had better protection. \n\nI am wondering, despite the benefits of AI, why does this strategy land with more promotion than protection? When will the Prime Minister and the government consider the advice of Pope Leo XIV that AI needs to be \"disarmed\"?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036851","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, children's lives could have been saved if we had better protection. \n\nI am wondering, despite the benefits of AI, why does this strategy land with more promotion than protection? When will the Prime Minister and the government consider the advice of Pope Leo XIV that AI needs to be \"disarmed\"?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c94365c55010526f3174eb6f9c08954d2b3b0aae76be9c8396a9dc0d4137b0b1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2045c1895607f498abb070b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036852,"date":"2026-06-04T20:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I started to put my question forward when I heard my riding addressed. I have been informed by colleagues that I stood up and began to address the question without having the microphone on.\n\nI know the hon. parliamentary secretary has answered, but may I repeat the first part of my question?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036852","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I started to put my question forward when I heard my riding addressed. I have been informed by colleagues that I stood up and began to address the question without having the microphone on.\n\nI know the hon. parliamentary secretary has answered, but may I repeat the first part of my question?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e01b93be338a0f3a215559ec085d920fa3134205564bafaf29c1748ddf3d2a7a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30acdc3e540a05806914259f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036853,"date":"2026-06-04T20:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the first part of my question was this: I wonder how the slogan \"artificial intelligence for all\" lands in Tumbler Ridge, where seven families are now in court seeking redress for the loss of their children, who were not adequately protected. When will we see protection?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036853","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the first part of my question was this: I wonder how the slogan \"artificial intelligence for all\" lands in Tumbler Ridge, where seven families are now in court seeking redress for the loss of their children, who were not adequately protected. When will we see protection?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a20b9d4d7d0685fab795335874e17272e3276e9f797411afdddd67547be3f1d2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b685a4c72b759d8e173af835","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036833,"date":"2026-06-05T15:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I have no objection to Bill C-16, but this is only the first step. Now there is a Crown corporation.\n\n A Crown corporation is better than having a special operating agency, which is where Build Canada Homes started out.\n\nHowever, I do have some concerns regarding the minister's accountability and responsibility. The more independent the organization is, the less responsibility he bears. When it comes to the important issue of housing, accountability is crucial.\n\n The accountability question is the one that bothers me. We are seeing a lot of new Crown corporations created.\n\nWill the ministerial lines of accountability be as strong?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036833","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I have no objection to Bill C-16, but this is only the first step. Now there is a Crown corporation.\n\n A Crown corporation is better than having a special operating agency, which is where Build Canada Homes started out.\n\nHowever, I do have some concerns regarding the minister's accountability and responsibility. The more independent the organization is, the less responsibility he be","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mergers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036263","label":"Mergers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fd7132d8e57f772dfba7ce952daaed0ab78d7fe9c1f4c1b231b678fe9d2cacb7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["525f5e6d42ee3c737d2b59a8396b1ada9d81b379bf8d4b0faef3b6db55b9166b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3cb0b1b2fbd975474064288","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036834,"date":"2026-06-05T15:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, there was so much I agreed with in the speech the member gave. She referred to the fact that we should look at homes as homes and not as investments. If I am not quoting her accurately, I am sure she can correct me.\n\nThe concept that Greens also bring to this is that we are building homes and communities. We are not just building homes for market purposes. We need to meet the needs of communities and help people actually have a life with dignity.\n\nI wonder if the member has any comments on the approach between a Crown corporation, bricks and mortar, and what we can do to make people's lives better.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036834","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, there was so much I agreed with in the speech the member gave. She referred to the fact that we should look at homes as homes and not as investments. If I am not quoting her accurately, I am sure she can correct me.\n\nThe concept that Greens also bring to this is that we are building homes and communities. We are not just building homes for market purposes. We need to meet the needs ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bdcdab3a0488fe1699528b9995012fa3181818a392ab65dad1c78f939dc2f401"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89691dc1f2d81cceed109b55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036835,"date":"2026-06-05T15:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I find it discouraging, as I am sure many members do, when the debates get overly partisan. I did not find the hon. member for Pitt Meadows—Maple Ridge to be particularly partisan in his comments.\n\nAlso, in a weird show of solidarity with a former member, I would like to point out that poor Bev Oda has been vilified for years for something that was not her fault. It is her fault that she is addicted to smoking, and her staff put her in a non-smoking hotel. She asked to be moved, and she never bothered to check that, where she was moving to, it was impossible to order breakfast without getting a $16 glass of orange juice. There are many things about which Bev Oda and I disagreed, but I served at the same time as her, and we did share a love of dogs, so I will just put that out there.\n\nMy concern with this bill, and I will agree with my hon. friend from Pitt Meadows, is the proposed creation of new bureaucracies on bureaucracies. I will address this when I get a chance in my speech, but it does not mean that the Build Canada Homes idea is a bad idea. \n\nHow do we get more efficient delivery, from a speech and money and a commitment to actually getting Canadians homes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036835","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I find it discouraging, as I am sure many members do, when the debates get overly partisan. I did not find the hon. member for Pitt Meadows—Maple Ridge to be particularly partisan in his comments.\n\nAlso, in a weird show of solidarity with a former member, I would like to point out that poor Bev Oda has been vilified for years for something that was not her fault. It is her fault tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","label":"Smoking","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2925284b0b31fd495948f945574363dd078685b98445698070f64238f49f0c37"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1af7e68550006bd6dc16cae0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036836,"date":"2026-06-05T17:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise in this place to present a petition on behalf of many constituents and other people. This petition has over 800 signatories. The petitioners are concerned, as are so many Canadians, about the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. I will summarize the petition.\n\nThe petitioners call on the Government of Canada to increase support for civilians, particularly the thousands of children suffering from acute malnutrition, and for the loss of civilian infrastructure that has been destroyed, and they call for an end to the obstacles to delivering humanitarian aid.\n\n The petitioners call on the House of Commons to pressure our government to apply diplomatic and economic pressure to urge an immediate lifting of the blockade and to ensure the swift and unimpeded delivery of assistance to the people of Gaza.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036836","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise in this place to present a petition on behalf of many constituents and other people. This petition has over 800 signatories. The petitioners are concerned, as are so many Canadians, about the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. I will summarize the petition.\n\nThe petitioners call on the Government of Canada to increase support for civilians, particularly the thousands","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","label":"Humanitarian crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","label":"Humanitarian crisis","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["779e89a15c50e28b2a11bf181d913a2418dc7f8f440b859735430cbf116fd4d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fdbf932f27645de04bb95eedf978285f2dee847dcdc989e988d65dfe0b1c2c1d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-658233af40ebad1a23c789d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036837,"date":"2026-06-05T18:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the hon. member for Vancouver East anticipated my question, because I was just asking where the accountability measures are in the bill. I wonder if she has noticed, as I have, that the responsible minister is not actually listed. The bill just says they may be \"designated by the Governor in Council\". Where is the accountability?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036837","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the hon. member for Vancouver East anticipated my question, because I was just asking where the accountability measures are in the bill. I wonder if she has noticed, as I have, that the responsible minister is not actually listed. The bill just says they may be \"designated by the Governor in Council\". Where is the accountability?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e5d1a546bb5ac91355589e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036838,"date":"2026-06-05T18:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I confess that I have been struggling as to whether I vote for or against the bill.\n\nOf course, building homes for Canadians is a great goal. I would vote for that. I kept trying to figure out why it is that I am having trouble figuring out whether I would vote for it or against it. I guess it is because, when I really study the bill and think it through, it does absolutely nothing, even if fully implemented. That is troubling.\n\nI am just going to get to the bare bones. To Canadians who may be watching, what does Bill C-20 do? It is called an act respecting the establishment of Build Canada Homes. That is a familiar-sounding announcement because it was made on September 14, 2025, when the government created Build Canada Homes as a special operating agency.\n\nThat is something it has done a couple of times since the new government came in. Special operating agencies operate under the Treasury Board in an opaque environment where nothing is particularly visible or transparent or included in legislation. We already created Build Canada Homes on September 14 of last year. We are creating Build Canada Homes but not as a special operating agency. The bill deals with that. It would now be a Crown corporation. The bill would set up a Crown corporation. That is what it would do. It does not talk about the housing crisis. It does not give tools to address the housing crisis. It sets no targets. It has no timelines. It does not talk about the housing crisis. The purpose is:\n\n...to promote, support and develop the supply of affordable housing in Canada and to promote innovative and efficient building techniques in the housing construction sector in Canada.\n\nThe rest of the bill is devoted to how many people are on the board of directors, what it can borrow and what it can lend. My favourite part of the bill, which, again, is a bill about setting up a corporation, is that this new corporation, Build Canada Homes, can actually take money from the federal government and give it to the federal government. It is lacking, shall we say, in ambition.\n\nThe bill misses the point. If it is going to take us through the process of passing legislation in this place, it ought to have accountability. As the member for Vancouver East just pointed out, there is no minister of housing named in the bill as responsible. The minister shall be appointed by someone in the Privy Council at any given time, who will say, of the people around the cabinet table, this week it will be Joe. That is the kind of accountability we have here. That worries me.\n\nWe also have the fundamental reality that since the end of the Second World War, since 1945, we have had the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, CMHC. Was there something wrong with CMHC? It has been massively cut. It is not being scrapped. We will still have CMHC. The Minister of Housing is responsible for CMHC. That is an entity we understand. Are there endless delays? Are there things that should be done better at CMHC? Yes, but for a government that wants to, as we always hear from the Prime Minister, move fast, why not use, fit for purpose, the institution we have already? It has in it fewer people who know what they are doing, but it still has a goal and a principle and a practice that understands that housing is a human right.\n\nWe have two kinds of housing crises in Canada right now. I want to make sure that this is explicit in the rest of my remarks. We have a crisis of affordability in market housing. People earning good incomes cannot afford a good home. A lot of that is due to industry speculation, things like real estate investment trusts, corporations owning housing and making money out of speculation. That hurts, and so does the supply of housing not being adequate to our population.\n\nThe first housing crisis, I will underscore, is a market housing supply problem for affordable housing in rental and ownership. The second housing crisis we have is acute, cruel, grinding homelessness and it is on the rise. What do we do about that?\n\nI want to share an inspiring example. I was so honoured to tour a little place called 12 Neighbours outside Fredericton. It was a few years ago now. I met Marcel LeBrun of Fredericton, a young man. He would maybe not think he is so young now. He is a multi-millionaire because of his own entrepreneurial instincts and because he got involved in an Internet company he built up and then sold. At a sermon in a Baptist church one day, he was called upon to do more.\n\n He made a big donation to a local homelessness group. Then he thought that was not quite enough and the homelessness problem was growing in Fredericton. Long story short, this is what Marcel LeBrun decided to do. He realized that one of the critical obstacles for building affordable homes and social, non-market housing was the cost of land, so he bought a bunch of land. Then he said, \"I'm going to build 99 tiny homes on this land, 240-square-foot homes. This will give a person dignity, a home of their own. They can lock the door. It will be their home.\"\n\nHe applied to CMHC for funding. He was prepared to pay one-third of the cost of this project out of his own pocket. He was putting $12 million of his own money into it. CMHC told him it would take about two weeks to process. He built 35 homes before he heard from CMHC that his project was approved, because it took CMHC about a year and a half. He got it done. Not only did he get it done, but then he saw that these problems were acute. We cannot take someone who has been homeless, living in a tent or in an encampment in the woods, put them in their own home, and magically everything is good for them, because they lack community and they lack social skills. They are still wondering how they are going to make a living.\n\nHe created a whole network of social enterprise around the housing development he built himself, for the people in his community, things like a local restaurant that people could come to, where the people who lived in his tiny homes could learn how to work in that restaurant. There is a trade shop, so people can learn how to use a Skilsaw. What Marcel LeBrun has done goes on and on. With supports for mental health and addiction, he did not just build homes. He built a community with love, care and compassion. That can be done in every community if we mandate CMHC to see if it can follow the model of what Marcel LeBrun did on his own to create sustainable long-term housing with strong mental health supports and built-in dignity and community. That is what we should be building.\n\nThis Build Canada Homes bill is not about building homes. I am not being mean about it. If colleagues read it, they will see that the Build Canada Homes act is about setting up a Crown corporation, full stop. Build Canada Homes, Bill C-20, is about replacing a special operating agency set up last year with a Crown corporation this year. There are no goals, no timelines, no accountability, no listening to the briefs that the government got from the Assembly of First Nations about engaging indigenous people and no listening to the brief that it got from the Federation of Canadian Municipalities, where the rubber really hits the road at the municipal housing level. That is where people have to figure out what we are going to do.\n\n The government is not listening to the co-operatives in this country. The Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada gave a great brief to the committee that studied this bill. Since the bill does not include timelines or goals, I think that, if we were to actually put meaning into this bill, the clerk of the committee would have said it was outside the scope of the bill, because the scope of the bill is to set up a Crown corporation. After that, well, I wish the current Minister of Housing a great deal of luck. I hope he becomes the designated minister. Maybe he can make something out of this, but this does nothing more than set up a Crown corporation.\n\nWe need to do so much more. There will be money thrown at this Crown corporation, for sure. There will be chief executive officers and board members and it will function as a Crown corporation, but will it do more than what Marcel LeBrun did for the people of Fredericton?\n\nThe first social housing ever built in this country was in the early part of the 1900s, after the Halifax explosion, when that devastating collision in Halifax Harbour wiped out homes for thousands of people and the government had to build housing for people. The government did it, and did it fast. Nobody froze that winter. Everybody was gotten into housing fast.\n\n We need to act like this is an emergency, because it is an emergency. Women my age in my riding are living in their cars. This is driving me to distraction. Why can we not find the housing, build the housing? There are so many delays. They are unintentional in many cases, but they show a lack of political will, which has to come from the top down. Yes, there are multiple levels of government involved, but the federal government, in Build Canada Homes, should set the standard and set some goals.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036838","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I confess that I have been struggling as to whether I vote for or against the bill.\n\nOf course, building homes for Canadians is a great goal. I would vote for that. I kept trying to figure out why it is that I am having trouble figuring out whether I would vote for it or against it. I guess it is because, when I really study the bill and think it through, it does absolutely nothing,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8ad8bdfeed7fea484303e93539d4bb5c54a2375c9460863c1245bed1c99aeb2c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b6f8cac59ef8c3e9ccc4fcb4332dbad0d0d1eb764e262d4423597fd0757b7a85"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1e2dde040c3a0c34fa62c71","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036839,"date":"2026-06-05T18:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I know I cannot ask the member a question in response, but if he could show me the sections of the bill that talk about partnership, collaboration, working together and the things he just posed to me in the question, I would be fascinated to know where they are, because it is not that long a bill and they are not in here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036839","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I know I cannot ask the member a question in response, but if he could show me the sections of the bill that talk about partnership, collaboration, working together and the things he just posed to me in the question, I would be fascinated to know where they are, because it is not that long a bill and they are not in here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1814e2499d6e7eb72f9b51a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036840,"date":"2026-06-05T18:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, for my friend from Edmonton Manning, I want to be clear. The act would not do anything. I am not saying the government will not do anything. The act is kind of pointless, because the Liberals created a special operating agency. I would agree that there is a titch more transparency when we shift from an agency operating under the Treasury Board to a Crown corporation, but not much. \n\nI would demand that the government act and respond to the housing crisis with non-market housing and market housing. The bill does not do it by itself. It does not do anything.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036840","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, for my friend from Edmonton Manning, I want to be clear. The act would not do anything. I am not saying the government will not do anything. The act is kind of pointless, because the Liberals created a special operating agency. I would agree that there is a titch more transparency when we shift from an agency operating under the Treasury Board to a Crown corporation, but not much. \n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["68daeca07098c47c7ce1ad61079cd877d2b865c327c44788378c332a5e371028"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["17c98b82a62c1ede5447fd1a58b9914dfdab7edc0c6e153077a0212f43e36204"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4f819e402718a9c25e2090a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036841,"date":"2026-06-05T18:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, without intending to sound snarky or partisan, I guess the point of establishing yet another Crown corporation is to have an excuse for another set of press releases.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036841","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, without intending to sound snarky or partisan, I guess the point of establishing yet another Crown corporation is to have an excuse for another set of press releases.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d7819f99c5c2a3ddd3bcd0db969c5ca7fecdfe64f057a2bdf77a50dace9746b4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96aa0847147b1249ff775155","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036843,"date":"2026-06-05T18:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I would say to my hon. colleague from Nanaimo—Ladysmith that I cannot speculate. I have known this minister a long time, so forgive me for trespassing into my personal history. I am terribly fond of him. I do not think it is the minister. I think it is the government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036843","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I would say to my hon. colleague from Nanaimo—Ladysmith that I cannot speculate. I have known this minister a long time, so forgive me for trespassing into my personal history. I am terribly fond of him. I do not think it is the minister. I think it is the government.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11b53e4774f506edd3b128b2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101385,"date":"2026-06-09T03:00:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"FINA","text":"They are 30-minute bells, aren't they?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101385","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"They are 30-minute bells, aren't they?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c61273673d66063be0149af4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084717,"date":"2026-06-09T04:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote, with Greens voting in favour.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084717","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the vote, with Greens voting in favour.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c0263080b360895c78dd9b2c9594c7bfed4f52a88475c9ecfa6a600ab39c68e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-025c3c8ddddc162af5428394","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084716,"date":"2026-06-09T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, division 8 of Bill C-30, with only three hours of debate in this place before time allocation, represents the single largest rollback of health and environmental protection in the regulation of pesticides in the history of this country. \n\nI ask the government, I ask the Prime Minister, where did the pressure come from for this rollback? I am reliably informed that even industry did not ask for it. Why is the government doing this to our environment and our health?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084716","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, division 8 of Bill C-30, with only three hours of debate in this place before time allocation, represents the single largest rollback of health and environmental protection in the regulation of pesticides in the history of this country. \n\nI ask the government, I ask the Prime Minister, where did the pressure come from for this rollback? I am reliably informed that even industry did no","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3249f5ac64a933f8af4aa21dfbf9a18174317a75a285aeefab64617406d2fc2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["238261094fc19635b9721ca3bef0f0ca01ffe15907c5b42a697a5d50107778cc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff7e791d1cf9e6a2d1c7ba91","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101375,"date":"2026-06-09T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"I want to start by making sure that anyone watching this publicly knows that I'm only able to ask these questions because the Conservative party decided to give me six minutes, for which I thank them. First of all—because I know you both—I want to extend to you my thanks for your hard work on the climate issue for so many years. I want to thank Dr. Donner for standing for scientific integrity, and I want to thank both of you for a really tough decision. I know it cost you personally and emotionally more than you're able to share before a committee. I want to put my question to Dr. Donner. I'm also informed that the Prime Minister has never once met with his prime ministerial science adviser, Dr. Mona Nemer. Do you sense that this government understands the importance of science writ large? You spoke of scientific integrity. Do you have any comments on that matter? How much does this new government understand the importance of science?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101375","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I want to start by making sure that anyone watching this publicly knows that I'm only able to ask these questions because the Conservative party decided to give me six minutes, for which I thank them. First of all—because I know you both—I want to extend to you my thanks for your hard work on the climate issue for so many years. I want to thank Dr. Donner for standing for scientific integrity, and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a8ee32cd37f3580a449fb33b316a9d752d20987b3c1e774fcbb82083a47e84b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["09902031b6210c7d63d0ede8f230f08b1d34fdc209964b846af73dae51720a94"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03a54530fd815ff74c42fb08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101376,"date":"2026-06-09T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"I have a further question for Dr. Donner. I'm deeply troubled by the most recent research that's come out on what's now estimated to be a fifty-fifty risk of the collapse of the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation system—which has to be the worst name for anything scary in the history of time. Could you just talk directly to Canadians about what's at stake if we don't move quickly? We're talking about science here. How would you explain to the average person that fifty-fifty risk of collapse of the Gulf Stream and the circulatory systems by mid-century?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101376","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a further question for Dr. Donner. I'm deeply troubled by the most recent research that's come out on what's now estimated to be a fifty-fifty risk of the collapse of the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation system—which has to be the worst name for anything scary in the history of time. Could you just talk directly to Canadians about what's at stake if we don't move quickly? We're t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c409a57a11d17b94d0c02b7b2bc5d03da0e90d3dd3845a23455f331711fc1ba9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8009a6950c630e73280842f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101377,"date":"2026-06-09T21:15:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. To Catherine Abreu, if you could give advice to this government right now, what advice would you give if they were open to listening? I think I have less than a minute for your answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101377","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. To Catherine Abreu, if you could give advice to this government right now, what advice would you give if they were open to listening? I think I have less than a minute for your answer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["170eb642a3ed0af451472cc34154ef9e75e8c0740ec532919b2a62681d8fa5fb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eca825dfff58fe4eced9db88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101378,"date":"2026-06-09T21:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"Just to be clear, do I split five minutes with Mr. Johns?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101378","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just to be clear, do I split five minutes with Mr. Johns?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96a2c500631a76581d73952a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101379,"date":"2026-06-09T21:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. I thank you again, Ms. Abreu, for your very clear statements. I want to go back to some of the key points: that Canada is not doing as good a job as the Trump administration and that the climate accountability act is being ignored. Given what you've experienced, do you think there's any point in keeping the climate accountability act, or should we just let it be repealed so Canadians know the truth?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101379","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I thank you again, Ms. Abreu, for your very clear statements. I want to go back to some of the key points: that Canada is not doing as good a job as the Trump administration and that the climate accountability act is being ignored. Given what you've experienced, do you think there's any point in keeping the climate accountability act, or should we just let it be repealed so Canadians kn","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["af710d5006c871b460f42da93de8155cfd3f548ca5d09157caaef819a23bbc64"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ab024eecdea6e526a9b44f34a250faf679d0b134d71577f426931c164f6753a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5bb3c5284e1de2fa4bb895c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101380,"date":"2026-06-09T21:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"Ms. Abreu, as you said, there is a global energy revolution happening. Dr. Donner said the same thing. Canada is not part of it. Are we in a very small group of countries that are still defending and willing to subsidize fossil fuels? Are we putting ourselves outside of what is now an increasingly global norm, in your view?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101380","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Ms. Abreu, as you said, there is a global energy revolution happening. Dr. Donner said the same thing. Canada is not part of it. Are we in a very small group of countries that are still defending and willing to subsidize fossil fuels? Are we putting ourselves outside of what is now an increasingly global norm, in your view?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e7375b43c77e4469bb678a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101386,"date":"2026-06-10T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"FINA","text":"Madam Chair, is there any chance I can make a comment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101386","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Chair, is there any chance I can make a comment?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a9f784a79e7a4e42806e2a9d2de6cf5fa15faa25c63ba2b053c0d5db0f4a3a3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe2b5a7b3bbf99b4ebea029a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101387,"date":"2026-06-10T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"FINA","text":"I'm not a member of this committee. I'm here because of a motion the committee passed when it began its work after the election. I deeply regret that the motion was made because I could make my amendments on the floor of the House, otherwise, at report stage. My only point here is that since my friend Ryan Turnbull is making a point for people watching, I'd like people watching to know that I've been here most of those hours, with amendments to try to protect health and the environment from division 8 of Bill C-30 . That's all I have to say.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-46/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101387","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm not a member of this committee. I'm here because of a motion the committee passed when it began its work after the election. I deeply regret that the motion was made because I could make my amendments on the floor of the House, otherwise, at report stage. My only point here is that since my friend Ryan Turnbull is making a point for people watching, I'd like people watching to know that I've b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fcb409a1c6623d526805336a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084713,"date":"2026-06-11T16:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am struggling with Bill C-20. I voted against it last evening. I am looking at Bill C-26. I am hoping the hon. Minister of Housing can explain to me why the good work done since September by Build Canada Homes, as a special operating agency, seems disconnected from the new Crown corporation. For Bill C-20, we do not even know who the responsible minister would be, because that hat could change based on what cabinet decides at any given time.\n\n Can the hon. minister explain to me why we have put so much effort into transferring a special operating agency into a Crown corporation, with nothing new in Bill C-20 and work already under way?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084713","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am struggling with Bill C-20. I voted against it last evening. I am looking at Bill C-26. I am hoping the hon. Minister of Housing can explain to me why the good work done since September by Build Canada Homes, as a special operating agency, seems disconnected from the new Crown corporation. For Bill C-20, we do not even know who the responsible minister would be, because that hat c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad22caa06499c5929264f406b13b33d130888ac4946bedd0777baed04d730ee8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e320c229ca900df5563b3ce3cde203d5aefac4ad48d9884a3919c078f2aad27c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be074bcd078f6c4bd656c03a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101381,"date":"2026-06-11T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Dr. Ross, obviously a lot of us got involved in trying to get rid of single-use plastics because we saw it choking the life out of wildlife, but I'm really quite concerned about microplastics entering the human body and the health effects of that. You mentioned landfills. Could you briefly touch on microplastics in human health and what you're finding in landfills? For instance, is there any sign of the forever chemicals, the PFAS?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101381","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Dr. Ross, obviously a lot of us got involved in trying to get rid of single-use plastics because we saw it choking the life out of wildlife, but I'm really quite concerned about microplastics entering the human body and the health effects of that. You mentioned landfills. Could you briefly touch on microplastics in human health and what you're finding in landfills? For inst","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fa7ad1ba9c56b567e3eaff392cc8df70c2e28230c32e1996983c6e75564d0135"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["429c99a1c659f788a7f29dca9d1efc7c10ad0ee1e2ed94f325af472fc011abb9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f53de8d6be0453a86f3cc403","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101382,"date":"2026-06-11T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"It was about PFAS.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101382","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It was about PFAS.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc8ca40c443e131d54cea09b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101383,"date":"2026-06-11T17:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"I'm going to put my questions to Ms. Wirsig, and I really wish I had time for everybody. I want to try to drill down on what's been raised about food waste and how we'd have more food waste if we didn't have single-use plastics and food contamination affecting our health. I quickly looked it up. North America, with lots of access to plastics for food, wastes between 95 and 115 kilograms of food per capita, whereas places that don't use plastic, sub-Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia, waste far less food, six to 11 kilograms a year. From your point of view, Ms. Wirsig, is there a plausible case that we need plastics to avoid food waste?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101383","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm going to put my questions to Ms. Wirsig, and I really wish I had time for everybody. I want to try to drill down on what's been raised about food waste and how we'd have more food waste if we didn't have single-use plastics and food contamination affecting our health. I quickly looked it up. North America, with lots of access to plastics for food, wastes between 95 and 115 kilograms of food pe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9570b5c59592d7360160abcd6b3829f7fc7476dffeaf80993f80f27bb00b388"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd728f954413fd411cbc32cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101384,"date":"2026-06-11T18:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"ENVI","text":"I can't pose the second part. Thank you, Madam Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101384","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I can't pose the second part. Thank you, Madam Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7e765d23dc7c7566de10f26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084714,"date":"2026-06-12T02:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pursuing a question I first asked on April 14. I have been concerned for some time that the new Liberal government has less respect for science than previous governments had. We recently mourned the death of our colleague Dr. Kirsty Duncan. In all the eulogies, people remembered her as the first minister of science in Canada. We may note, and I hate to say this, that she will be the last minister of science in Canada, because there is not one now.\n\n The gravitas, the importance, of scientific briefings and scientific advice from core government departments that are science-based is sorely lacking. This is reflected in the cuts to Environment and Climate Change and to Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, to basic scientific research. Whole branches of science are being shut down in this country.\n\n A scientific expert, an anthropologist and taxonomist, contacted me because the whole national collection of insects in the Diptera order has been shut down. There are no scientists to pick up this work. They have all been laid off. An international petition was launched; 495 scientists from 47 different countries are raising the alarm about Canada's dropping the ball. It may seem to people that it is obscure to keep track of what species of insect we have in our collection, but it can cause enormous economic damage when we lose the brainpower to know which insect is which. If it is an exotic species that does not belong in a particular forest, we need to know about it soon, and we need to take action.\n\nThere are cuts across the board. An open letter was sent just today to the Prime Minister's office, from 425 scientists from many jurisdictions, including internationally, concerned that the cuts to the ocean protection plan mean that we simply will not be able to understand and protect our marine environment.\n\n These are serious matters, and I asked the Prime Minister, in April, if he had ever consulted his chief science adviser about these cuts. The hon. parliamentary secretary made a good go of it, saying that, in general, people appreciated the advice of Dr. Mona Nemer, the Prime Minister's chief science adviser. However, since I asked the question, I have had it verified that the Prime Minister has not once sat down to meet with his chief science adviser. This is deeply worrying.\n\n Changes are being proposed, such as in the massive discussion documents issued May 8, that would have profound impacts, endangering endangered species. Also, we are losing the precautionary principle. If we look, buried in the omnibus budget bill, Bill C-30, we find the single biggest assault on bringing evidence and science to bear on the dangers of pesticides to human health and the environment. However, buried in an omnibus bill, it will be studied only by the finance committee, which had no time to hear from witnesses really concerned about this issue.\n\n With that, I ask the government again, will it please rethink, stop and be concerned? The precautionary principle has been recognized by the Supreme Court of Canada as fundamental to our legal jurisprudence. In this country, we do not want to find ourselves once again with decision-based evidence-making. We need to look at the science and do our research first, before we decide we have to build whatever fast and not be concerned with what the scientists are warning us will occur if we fail to think first, plan well and then build.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210561","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Insects","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084714","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pursuing a question I first asked on April 14. I have been concerned for some time that the new Liberal government has less respect for science than previous governments had. We recently mourned the death of our colleague Dr. Kirsty Duncan. In all the eulogies, people remembered her as the first minister of science in Canada. We may note, and I hate to say this, that she will be ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210561","label":"Insects"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210561","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Insects","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210561","label":"Insects","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fa91dfcbdf4911eb014747b35873363857d71d16750cca386a7896c3e0c9be0f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210561","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Insects","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["343f58f32c41132487f171375d870c7ac19b8b86e4b5582d5e2f58b8518263ea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210561","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Insects","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210561","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Insects","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210561","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0a6d21dc629d08a7d34e7f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084715,"date":"2026-06-12T02:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. friend, and he is a friend, the parliamentary secretary. Let me give him an example right now that is not hypothetical.\n\n None of the wonderful press releases he has mentioned has done a single thing to allow the Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada to have a budget sufficient enough to hold the meetings it is required to hold by law. It is supposed to assess and monitor species at risk along a continuum from threatened to critically endangered, but these top-notch scientists have to meet to do that. The committee did not have a budget to meet, so it has gone from two meetings required a year down to one, and it is not going to have enough time to plow through the backlog of species that need attention, need recovery plans and need habitat attention.\n\n At the same time that the Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada cannot meet, we see a discussion paper that says maybe it is okay to lose the southern resident killer whales. It is not acceptable.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084715","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. friend, and he is a friend, the parliamentary secretary. Let me give him an example right now that is not hypothetical.\n\n None of the wonderful press releases he has mentioned has done a single thing to allow the Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada to have a budget sufficient enough to hold the meetings it is required to hold by law. It is supposed","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["731bfb590d8df5ef8b1bddc8e37521bc5adc31779508ed768a9aca8377923962"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2baa71635355b367fef90d88d31e56018ba8bdf0c59e812d59378bc549af16bf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83ef5e4fd46637647ae27d79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084711,"date":"2026-06-12T17:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present petition e-6791, signed by 1,084 people. I imagine that most of them are from the disability community.\n\nThe petition is heart-wrenching to read. I know I cannot read it aloud but must summarize it. It is about the number of Canadians with disabilities who are living in deep poverty. The petitioners say that disabled people have lost hope that anyone cares. Many are turning to MAID because they cannot afford to live, and they are asking why they are not supported to live but have easy supports to die. Many disabled people have fallen off the financial cliff.\n\n The petition goes on, but the bottom line is that the citizens and residents of Canada who have signed the petition call on the government to show disabled people that it will fix the pressures from the rising costs of everyday life and to give every disabled person across Canada and people on disability supports a tax-free emergency support of $5,000 that is not means-tested and cannot be clawed back.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084711","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present petition e-6791, signed by 1,084 people. I imagine that most of them are from the disability community.\n\nThe petition is heart-wrenching to read. I know I cannot read it aloud but must summarize it. It is about the number of Canadians with disabilities who are living in deep poverty. The petitioners say that disabled people have lost hope that anyone cares. Many are ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0abe8882f3e7e8c4c47394c7845062e69d68004b8aaa9910b64afdda3d24cbdd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aef8d351f5025bd2cf3da3c118cd3f835953a56d9a88db2a28195476a5f8bbc2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79b38c5fd02104d9725a07c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084712,"date":"2026-06-12T17:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when the hon. Minister of Justice says we have a very small window to push through legislation, that is entirely due to the government's decision to adjourn two days early. I wish the government had come to me and asked how I would feel about staying later this summer to properly study bills and not push through the destruction of pesticide regulations in an omnibus budget bill. \n\nI know it is not the minister's problem, but we are being pushed to the last minute and told we could not debate something as important as the Senate amendments to Bill C‐14. I opposed Bill C‐14. It was never passed unanimously, contrary to what the Liberal deputy House leader said. It was on division because members like me, who are not in a recognized party, cannot even stand up and scream \"no\" when they decide to vote on division.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084712","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when the hon. Minister of Justice says we have a very small window to push through legislation, that is entirely due to the government's decision to adjourn two days early. I wish the government had come to me and asked how I would feel about staying later this summer to properly study bills and not push through the destruction of pesticide regulations in an omnibus budget bill. \n\nI k","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d178b4baf845725404d7a03659209a8bb3ad49c9cf902b664f0b5d3c62d77c5d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26287bc9db11799394f62670","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086919,"date":"2026-06-15T17:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I suppose I will echo the comments of my friend from the Conservative benches, the member for Edmonton West, a moment ago.\n\n The programming motions, the time allocations, are becoming routine. They used to be rare exceptions. I am honoured to have been serving here for the last 15 years, so saying something as simple as \"I have never seen anything like it\" might mean something. \n\nThe spring economic statement did not, in any way, foretell what would be in Bill C-30. A budget implementation bill is supposed to be about implementing what one reads in the economic statement. This one did not make anything of it. There is one line where we were going to include that regulatory agencies get to consider food security and food prices. It did not say that we plan to deregulate pesticides so that we can use them when they are too dangerous. \n\nI am wondering if the hon. member would explain why it is that we do not have adequate time to study bills in this place under the new administration.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086919","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I suppose I will echo the comments of my friend from the Conservative benches, the member for Edmonton West, a moment ago.\n\n The programming motions, the time allocations, are becoming routine. They used to be rare exceptions. I am honoured to have been serving here for the last 15 years, so saying something as simple as \"I have never seen anything like it\" might mean something. \n\nT","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["744e120e3093f46bed4f1dffc18e6f3fdfdb409fdaa6c1381072511fc87752a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0acf4d0b4021bec2e8f1dbc2478976e1f899342f5189efa3ea6fb6532c515331"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6818696a33c8fb54638f936","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086920,"date":"2026-06-15T17:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, over the course of this debate, I have heard a number of things said that need to be referenced. As my hon. friend from Fort McMurray—Cold Lake pointed out, we have actually had one hour, or maybe a bit more by now, for the programming motion we are debating right now, and now we have closure on that programming motion, which is all about speeding things up.\n\nThe hon. member says that the government was elected and \"we were elected\". I remember the member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie pointing out that climate change was mentioned 28 times in what the government was elected to do. Pipelines were not mentioned once. I will remind the hon. member that, in the spring economic statement, there is no reference at all to deciding that, if a pesticide is considered too dangerous for use, that decision can be overturned for economic reasons. That is now buried in an omnibus budget bill that only got studied at the finance committee and, even there, very briefly. That is not due to the Conservative filibuster, but to the priority of the whole committee in what witnesses got called.\n\nTherefore, I beg of the government to not push this through without taking the time necessary, to not push through those buried bits in the omnibus budget bill without any real discussion or debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086920","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, over the course of this debate, I have heard a number of things said that need to be referenced. As my hon. friend from Fort McMurray—Cold Lake pointed out, we have actually had one hour, or maybe a bit more by now, for the programming motion we are debating right now, and now we have closure on that programming motion, which is all about speeding things up.\n\nThe hon. member says th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df0cf716739c174e0d6c099ad0a58538a3e5d4f56958073765cbd47b5a79cd01"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33894a915e07a64fd627b563","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086921,"date":"2026-06-15T18:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to thank my friend, the member for Mirabel, for pointing out in his speech that I was also present at the Standing Committee on Finance during the 30 hours when the committee was effectively deadlocked. It is not the fault of the committee members.\n\nDoes my colleague agree that the root of the problem is that we are seized with an omnibus budget bill containing a hidden clause that applies to an entirely separate matter, namely pesticides?\n\nThat is why we are angry now about the idea of another closure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086921","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to thank my friend, the member for Mirabel, for pointing out in his speech that I was also present at the Standing Committee on Finance during the 30 hours when the committee was effectively deadlocked. It is not the fault of the committee members.\n\nDoes my colleague agree that the root of the problem is that we are seized with an omnibus budget bill containing a hidden claus","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0b516910f2e1ab275c0a076c2a6728ab8060c5fa40a37f2bb0b3eeceddab96c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e2bc895eaa64aafd003cb730d5d2e49306c0d98a0e5671a22e19b7a5ea030074"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c715e98fdcf0b6b68d19159","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086922,"date":"2026-06-15T21:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague from Saskatoon West made the point that there was ample time. I just went back to double-check. First reading on Bill C‐30 was on April 29, and then time allocation, after three hours of debate, was moved a whole month later, basically, on May 25. \n\nDoes the member recall, because I am trying to recall, what happened with Bill C‐30 between first reading and when the government decided to bring in time allocation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086922","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague from Saskatoon West made the point that there was ample time. I just went back to double-check. First reading on Bill C‐30 was on April 29, and then time allocation, after three hours of debate, was moved a whole month later, basically, on May 25. \n\nDoes the member recall, because I am trying to recall, what happened with Bill C‐30 between first reading and when the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc78b49c9c940766491a1613","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086923,"date":"2026-06-15T22:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is often that I find myself here wondering if this place has turned into something not quite like a sports arena, in the style of the Trump White House, with its caged sport for the celebration of 250 years of independence, which is a topic that is not necessarily connected to this at all, but, for sporting spectacles, this place sometimes resembles nothing more than target practice for teams that live in glass houses. It is difficult to watch. I know that I must have a glass house somewhere, but with the Green Party never having been in power, we have less of a record to attack.\n\nI do vividly recall when the Harper administration started using, as a matter of course, very long omnibus budget bills, which the Liberals of the day decried as burying too much in one bill, not properly reflecting or advancing the initial version of the budget and being done routinely.\n\nWe then had, of course, the Harper administration bringing in repetitive motions for time allocation. I remember the first time I had started noticing that it had become quite routine. I went back, looked it up and found out that, over a period of 40 years, which is not that far back in our history, it had happened about 10 times. I started adding them up and keeping track, and it became hundreds of times.\n\nOf course, when in opposition, the Liberals pledged that they would never bring in omnibus budget bills containing many different measures in one piece of legislation and that they certainly would not use time allocation to shorten the time we have available to do those things. Again, both of the large parties live in, I must say, very large and well-equipped glass homes, but they are still throwing rocks at the same glass houses in which they live.\n\nThey have both moved to omnibus budget bills once in power. The Liberals have done it, first under former prime minister Trudeau and now under the current Prime Minister. They also have continued to use time allocation. \n\nMy own plea comes from my own little perch on parliamentary procedure. I know that it is against the rules of this place to have a member stand to deliver a written speech. If we followed that rule, I believe House leaders would be able to come to an agreement more quickly about how many speakers it would take to get a bill through the House.\n\nListening to debate on the motion so far, I am reminded that, as the parliamentary secretary says to us all, we have to use time allocation or we cannot get this passed. To which I say, again, this is a glass house. It is like a child who has killed both of their parents pleading for mercy because they are an orphan.\n\nWhy are we under time pressure? It is because the government of the day decided that we could shorten the amount of time we are sitting in June. Let us eliminate two days and create more pressure, meaning that it has to be passed now. Why is there no discussion about sitting longer? Why is there no discussion about what happened between when Bill C‐30 was first tabled on April 29 and when we next got back to it?\n\nAfter three hours of debate, the government moved time allocation on Bill C‐30. It is not a massive omnibus budget bill, but it is omnibus enough that I certainly had no indication that I was going to come across division 8, which has the most regressive pieces of the deregulation of pesticide legislation that I have seen.\n\nBelieve it or not, as I know I look like a mere slip of a girl, someone who has just barely left law school, I have been working on pesticide issues for 51 years. This is the worst piece of deregulation I have ever seen, and it is inside an omnibus budget bill.\n\n I would be happy to support many of the provisions in the spring economic statement. There are some I would not. That is the nature of an omnibus bill. There are many things affecting many different bills, done all in one vote and all in one go. This time it is with the added factor that we do not have a lot of time.\n\nWho controls the timing? The government controls the timing. Who controls what bills come forward for debate, for Government Orders, for orders of the day? The government side does that.\n\nMy hon. friends on the finance committee, I must say, performed the most extraordinary filibuster I have ever seen, in terms of creativity. I sat through all of it because I kept hoping against hope that we would maybe get to clause-by-clause and that my amendments could be discussed and debated.\n\nHowever, again, the pattern of the House of Commons since forever has been that the parties in opposition will use whatever tools they have at their disposal. It was decades ago that the Conservatives left the bells ringing for days. It takes a while, but the government regroups and finds a new way to get around that particular effort to put a spanner in the works. This is not uncommon, but what is uncommon is the use of programming motions, and I say this to my hon. colleagues on the Liberal benches.\n\nThe first extremely offensive programming motion, in my experience as a member of Parliament since 2011, was what happened in June last year with the programming motion on Bill C-5, which saw us take the most extraordinary seizure of power and expansion to the power of the executive cabinet in a bill, Bill C-5, which included provisions I never thought I would see in Canada, and say that, if in passing this law we break other laws we have already passed, that is okay. This is based on a historical and never-used-in-Canada archival bit of trivia. It was Henry VIII who came up with that. If in passing this law, we break other laws we have passed before, that is okay. This extraordinary abuse of power was in Bill C-5, building Canada strong and reducing interprovincial trade barriers in part 1, which went through this place. I will never forget it because I still feel like I was caught under a bulldozer going right over me. It was Monday, June 16, when the programming motion took effect, and second reading took place with limited debate to pass it to committee.\n\nBy the way, on the Monday, June 16, we did not even have a committee in place yet to deal with the bill. On Tuesday, June 17 at 3:30 p.m., the committee was put in place, one committee for all these provisions. Then the committee could start hearing witnesses in the afternoon. By Wednesday at noon, all amendments were due and so on until we got through report stage and third reading, both on Friday, June 20. Then we were adjourned for the summer, and we were told it was a monstrous hurry that we have a Major Projects Office. It was very important to able to see projects come through this process, which is why we could not, as I pleaded at the time, stay longer through the summer, discuss this bill, debate this bill, to see whether this extreme sweeping accumulation of powers by the executive was in any way justified. They said we were in a hurry, except it has been a whole year now, and the bill has not been used once to name a project through Bill C-5.\n\nAgain, here we are on Motion No. 12 on Bill C-30. I am thankful for the way the unanimous consent motion was structured. I will have a chance to speak at third reading on Bill C-30 on the specifics of the part I most decry. I still hope against hope that the finance committee tomorrow will see fit to accept the amendments I have put forward and deemed to be moved. I have been, as I said, patiently waiting while admiring the artistry of the Conservative filibuster. I must say I have had more fun watching paint dry. It is always more interesting. On the other hand, it was artful. Although I do not agree with why the Conservatives were filibustering, I do sometimes, as a person who is observing glass houses more than living in them, enjoy the karma of the whole thing.\n\nI will vote against Motion No. 12 because it is offensive to democracy to have programming motions that say we must move fast, that we must not debate, that we must not consider. I find over and over again that there has been nothing like the current government for moving fast, and there has been nothing like the current government for treating Parliament with a kind of casual contempt. As a Canadian and someone who deeply believes in Westminster parliamentary democracy, I personally find it offensive. I may be the only one, but I think Canadians want to see this place respected and want to know that every bill has been properly studied. For one, I would be prepared to say that if properly studying bills means we cut into the summer and we are in Ottawa longer to do it, that is the right thing to do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086923","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is often that I find myself here wondering if this place has turned into something not quite like a sports arena, in the style of the Trump White House, with its caged sport for the celebration of 250 years of independence, which is a topic that is not necessarily connected to this at all, but, for sporting spectacles, this place sometimes resembles nothing more than target practic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8562994f98084b2b63d2ac3143273ec8d439d76f450acd99b421491901b7b6e3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe65cdb3a53fe634c7886767","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086924,"date":"2026-06-15T22:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is deeply offensive. The point of Parliament is to actually have respectful debate and discussion and make sure bills are adequately studied before they are passed. The track record of programming motions on Bill C-5 and this one on Bill C-30 sets extremely dangerous precedence. \n\nParliament is not a mere waste of time for a CEO in a hurry. Parliament is essential to Westminster parliamentary democracy, and we are here to represent our constituents. Regardless of party, views need to be heard. Again, if we all could work together better, it would be by not allowing prepared written speeches.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086924","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is deeply offensive. The point of Parliament is to actually have respectful debate and discussion and make sure bills are adequately studied before they are passed. The track record of programming motions on Bill C-5 and this one on Bill C-30 sets extremely dangerous precedence. \n\nParliament is not a mere waste of time for a CEO in a hurry. Parliament is essential to Westminster pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13bc29ff942eaf07b61d289b2c7275f08e63866d936b9f344d919c8b01826503"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b442ce869687a434c42b7d88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086925,"date":"2026-06-15T22:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I completely agree with my Bloc Québécois colleague.\n\nIt is true that, over the past year, we have lost policies aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The government has gone in a completely different directions from what the Liberal Party's platform proposed a year ago. We now have a government whose goal is to increase greenhouse gas emissions.\n\nWith these policies, it is absolutely impossible to meet the targets we are legally bound by under the Paris Agreement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086925","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I completely agree with my Bloc Québécois colleague.\n\nIt is true that, over the past year, we have lost policies aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The government has gone in a completely different directions from what the Liberal Party's platform proposed a year ago. We now have a government whose goal is to increase greenhouse gas emissions.\n\nWith these policies, it is abso","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","label":"Global warming"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","label":"Global warming","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22cd44bc6c922c56eca57b9a903e2514b27486eddcdd7e091ec326e4a87c6408"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c5788ea696c02a0b0e2d4e69fba689b4a5ec1ae4ee5a03dffa0d598547cbfd9c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6c0c95c0e87e7e3e233356d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086926,"date":"2026-06-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am glad the hon. member for Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas respects my experience in this place because I started, our very first days together, sitting in that corner, trying to acquaint him with standing orders about heckling. I do believe that when I say \"move fast\", what I mean is ignoring the requirements of democracy that bills be adequately considered before they are passed. I will remind him, as the hon. former minister of the environment has reminded other Liberals, that climate change was mentioned 28 times in the platform of the hon. member and pipelines were not mentioned once.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086926","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am glad the hon. member for Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas respects my experience in this place because I started, our very first days together, sitting in that corner, trying to acquaint him with standing orders about heckling. I do believe that when I say \"move fast\", what I mean is ignoring the requirements of democracy that bills be adequately considered before they are passed. I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["016e531a617f26fbb3f80f5948e109fde8e9430580bc546ac7297c0886673749"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["16a0e51dfef9b3273b28a8912a2edea58028ea22b36a51cfa0a53159804d587b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e03ecef7f7d7416ab27ff907","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086927,"date":"2026-06-16T00:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I need to preface this before I thank the hon. member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith, in case anyone has forgotten how unlikely it is that I am deeply grateful to her for her work, her diligence and her ability to analyze legislation. It still breaks my heart to hear \"The hon. member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith\" and not have it be Green Party member Paul Manly.\n\nI have to pay tribute to this member. Every word she just said was excellent. We should be listening. Her words, \"vote first and understand later\", should be put up in neon lights as the defining words of this session.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086927","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I need to preface this before I thank the hon. member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith, in case anyone has forgotten how unlikely it is that I am deeply grateful to her for her work, her diligence and her ability to analyze legislation. It still breaks my heart to hear \"The hon. member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith\" and not have it be Green Party member Paul Manly.\n\nI have to pay tribute to this member.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a357b91d192f9d0efd46d27ac3ee6a40f63ca2c3c3cd14778391174138c0afc0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b673d19194f0648ae79d28cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086928,"date":"2026-06-16T02:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, no matter how well-intentioned the bill may be, I do not think I have ever received so many angry and concerned calls, letters and emails from constituents about a bill. I do oppose the legislation, but I would appreciate adequate time to be able to explain the reasons I agree with those from the civil liberties community who believe the bill would create more litigation and more charter violations through the provisions that are unclear about when someone happens to be on the street and does not know that around the corner there is a day care centre or a synagogue, but they are expressing their charter rights to be able to participate. \n\nI cannot support time allocation on this. I know everybody is in a hurry, but rather than push us to bulldoze things through, why not consider keeping—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!\n\nElizabeth May: Mr. Speaker, I am sorry, but we are debating time allocation. I feel like I am being heckled and cannot express myself properly. \n\nIf we are interested in having proper time to debate bills, why does the government want to use time allocation as opposed to allowing us to sit until Friday, which was the original schedule?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086928","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, no matter how well-intentioned the bill may be, I do not think I have ever received so many angry and concerned calls, letters and emails from constituents about a bill. I do oppose the legislation, but I would appreciate adequate time to be able to explain the reasons I agree with those from the civil liberties community who believe the bill would create more litigation and more char","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eca7b4a20d1c2ed76a83a69d3c603b7e5ae7c9632e90004d9d02d9de899a68ea"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["afe951573c8164977bc4bcb2f0bf0a3748cad6edd330ac021c39b5d8aeb6ef61"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9e628f9fbe36c23b7bdfb29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101388,"date":"2026-06-16T14:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I want to start by thanking all members of this committee for allowing me to speak now. In the normal course of things, without the programming motion, my amendments would come up in order. My first amendment occurs at clause 52. I have eight amendments. They speak specifically and only to division 8 of Bill C-30 . Division 8 relates to pesticides. I would like to start by thanking my colleagues from the Bloc Québécois, the member of Parliament for Mirabel, Mr. Garon , and the member of Parliament for Rimouski—La Matapédia , who raised the same issues and concerns in the House. I'm very grateful for their help, and also, as we sit around this table, to Jas, to everybody and obviously to Ryan and to you, Madam Chair, for the opportunity for me to have time to speak to my concerns outside the normal programming motion. Given that this bill, Bill C-30 , is the implementation bill for the spring economic statement and that the only part of the spring economic statement that relates to division 8 are these simple lines on page 96: \"Announces the government's intention to amend the Canadian Food Inspection Agency Act and the Pest Control Products Act to include consideration of food security and cost of food\". I would submit, Madam Chair, that if we'd had enough time in the House at the very beginning of this bill, we should have moved to have this entire division 8 removed as being far beyond the scope of what was set out and what we are now implementing. I recognize that most of Bill C-30 does aim to implement specific financial measures, such as excise tax changes, CPP measures and so on, and would directly implement what was in the spring economic statement, but I submit to you and to all members of this committee, as you may notice very quickly, that this is a last-minute Hail Mary pass begging my colleagues to accept my amendment so that this wrong is not done. I think the government will live to regret the inclusion of something as significant and regressive as division 8 in an omnibus budget bill if they insist on continuing down this course of a massive change in pesticide regulation placing economic considerations above human health and environmental risks. There were no independent witnesses before committee, because it moved very quickly. I'm not accusing anyone on the committee, but I'm speaking now on behalf of the Association pour la santé publique du Québec and its Quebec victims of pesticides initiative. I'm also speaking on behalf of the following organizations. This includes Breast Cancer Action Quebec, the Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment, the Canadian Biotechnology Action Network, the Canadian Environmental Law Association, the Canadian Partnership for Children's Health and Environment, Children's Health Defense Canada, Council of Canadians Edmonton Chapter, the David Suzuki Foundation, Earth Education League, Ecojustice, Environmental Defence, Équiterre, Evidence for Democracy, Fondation Rivières, Friends of the Earth Canada, National Farmers Union, Nature Canada, Pesticide Free Edmonton, Prevent Cancer Now, Quebec Environmental Law Centre, Safe Food Matters, the Saskatchewan Network for Alternatives to Pesticides, Vigilance OGM and West Coast Environmental Law. Who am I to say that I can speak for these people? I do so because they submitted briefs, but their words were not heard before the finance committee. I submit again the review of Bill C-30 and division 8 in the chamber itself, where we had this bill tabled on April 29. After three hours of debate, the time allocation motion came down on May 25. I don't think anyone feeling confident in their own personal integrity could say that this section, division 8, had anything like adequate time before the House before it went on division to a second reading at this table. I'm so grateful for this chance. I've written some of you to say that my background.... I know I'm only 72 years old, but for 51 years I've worked on pesticide issues. I was briefly the chair—it was for a couple of years, but when you're 72, it's brief—of the environmental law subsection for the Canadian Bar Association, and I personally handled a number of pesticide cases in my career before politics. Briefly, to the committee then, I'll explain why this is a substantial change and why it should be resisted. Then, I'll describe my amendments as briefly as I can. In 1969, the Pest Control Products Act was passed in this country. It gave the regulation of pesticides—pesticides being a category that includes insecticides, fungicides, rodenticides and herbicides—to Agriculture Canada, pretty much exclusively. The now defunct pest management regulatory agency had to accept advice and sometimes vetoes from the health department. I won't go through step by step the different changes that occurred. The most significant change that occurred was when then Liberal leader Jean Chrétien put in the Liberal platform in 1993 that the Pest Control Products Act would be moved from Agriculture Canada and moved to Health Canada. That was done in 1995 with a lot of credit to someone who visited the chamber recently, former member of Parliament, former minister of the environment for Quebec, Mr. Clifford Lincoln. For me, he's a real hero. Clifford Lincoln was the Liberal MP who made the change that was in the Liberal red book to say that the Pest Management Regulatory Agency reports to the Minister of Health, and that human health would take a more prominent role in the review of pesticides. Another significant event, which I mention only because I think division 8 of Bill C-30 will run into trouble in court, is that in 2001 the Supreme Court of Canada ruled in the Hudson, Quebec, case that the precautionary principle under which the little municipality of Hudson banned the use of cosmetic pesticides on lawns.... That was upheld by the Supreme Court of Canada because the Supreme Court said that the precautionary principle was now fundamental to federal pesticide regulation and Canadian law in general. The precautionary principle can be summed up as \"look both ways before you cross the street.\" Again, briefly I'll just say that we often hear from whoever's in charge of pesticides at the time, regardless of party, and they all have the same talking point that says that Canada has the most rigorous pest-management regime in the world. That's just nonsense. To this day, Richard Nixon's FIFRA—the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act—is stronger and better constructed than Canadian pesticide regulation. Here's a case in point. If I can find any reason that this has come forward, in the guise of something to do with food costs and food security, it's the episode that occurred last year when the Pest Management Regulatory Agency, for the period of one month only, said it would not be okay to use liquid strychnine on farm fields in Alberta and Saskatchewan to deal with ground squirrels, also known as gophers. It was one month but the industry appealed and PMRA granted them the appeal with careful conditions because, as you can imagine, liquid strychnine is rather dangerous to be used in any uncontrolled environment. In any case, it seems that this may have given impetus to this quite wrong-headed idea that the federal cabinet should, as is described here in division 8 of Bill C-30 , allow the federal cabinet to overturn a decision by a minister. This is proposed subsection 28.1(1). It says, \"because the Minister does not consider that the environmental risks of the pest control product are acceptable,\" the Governor in Council may, by order, amend the registration \"if the Governor in Council considers it necessary to do so to protect national economic security, regional economic security, or national food security.\" Again, there are many things wrong with this, including that the timelines provided would allow extensions that would mean that something like liquid strychnine in an emergency consideration could be used for up to nine years before being reviewed. Whoever drafted this section of Bill C-30 wasn't considering the implications for human health or the environment, or even the economy at all. Some of the evidence we would have heard, had we had witnesses here, is that in terms of the European Union, Canadians need to diversify markets. Our farmers don't need their products to be rejected because of excessive pesticide use, but lentils from Canada have been rejected from a number of EU countries because we allow more glyphosate, trade name Roundup, than the EU will allow. We've had crops rejected at the border. We don't need this. We need to work in harmony with allies, particularly within the European Union, to make sure that Canadian food exports don't face rejection at the border. In any case, the groups I've mentioned have told me that as much as my amendments may improve things, they actually think that even if all of my amendments were accepted, it would be far preferable to delete division 8 altogether. Nevertheless, I do want to thank the environmental law group, Ecojustice, for their assistance, and my team. I particularly thank Steve Parkinson, who is a very hard worker. He worked until two in the morning to make sure we could get these in by the deadline created by the motion that allows me to be here at all. I know the clock is ticking. My first amendment speaks to the fact that Bill C-30 doesn't define.... In saying the cabinet can overturn a minister, it uses terms like \"national economic security\" and \"national food security\" without defining them and without providing any requirement for evidence, research or any kind of independent panel to review what the cabinet is doing. This appears to be a permission to overturn a decision that is reasoned and based on evidence with one that is purely political discretion. I won't go through these in great detail because I know that time is ticking. I'm so grateful to the Bloc and the Conservatives for all of this time. If anyone is watching this, I would not be able to do this without the Conservative Party members here—each and every one of them—the Bloc member here at the table and all of the Liberals here at the table. Thank you. I can't thank you enough for at least allowing me to present these. I really hope you'll find it in your hearts to carry at least some of them. I should mention that my colleague and friend, Steven Guilbeault , has a number of amendments here that speak to the issue of transparency. Those amendments, if accepted, will not deal with the problem created—the real offence to the precautionary principle—which is the notion that this government cares more about human health and the environment than it does about brief economic pressures from lobbyists. My first amendment attempts to define \"national economic security\" to include \"long-term sustainability\" and not create unacceptable risks to human health and the environment. I won't go through each definition, but the first amendment is to create definitions around terms that are used to justify overturning a decision by saying that a pesticide is too dangerous to be used by the agency in charge. The second amendment adds that cabinet can only overturn a decision of a minister if the minister agrees that the risks to human health from the use of that product are not non-negotiable. You can't change the decision if the minister has decided that, really, the human health risks are unacceptable. My third amendment says that cabinet must not make an order to overturn the decision if the minister responsible has \"determined that the health risks or the combined environmental risks and health risks are not acceptable\". The second consideration is that \"the pest control product does not have sufficient value for the control of an infestation\". Another thing that must be considered in decisions like this, which isn't mentioned in Bill C-30 , is whether reasonable alternatives are available. Is there another way to handle this emergency that requires...? For instance, to go back to the prairie gophers, is another reasonable alternative available? Rather ironically, the reason the prairie gophers have become so much more prevalent and destructive is what is described in all of the government documents as \"abnormally dry conditions\". In other words, it's the climate crisis and persistent drought. My fourth amendment is that emergency orders specifically must not have extensions. It would limit the emergency order to one year and no extensions. Currently, as I mentioned briefly earlier, the three-year duration in the bill is extendable by another three years, followed by a phase-out period, so the prolonged use of a product that has been determined by the minister responsible as unacceptable could be allowed, by cabinet override, to continue for up to nine years. The fifth amendment I have removed—pardon me for returning to it—because we replaced it with another one, with consent of the clerk. I'll just go to to the sixth amendment, which is replacing lines 7 and 8 on page 31. It is to change so that the minister must not allow the product to be used if it is unsafe. Without this amendment, public confidence will be undermined and regulatory decisions will have no effect. I can't really pick one—they come as a package—but if someone on the Liberal benches felt that there was one thing that might make this less appalling, it would be this one. It's amendment PV‐7. I'll read it to you. That Bill C‐30 , in clause 57, be amended by adding after line 2 on page 32 the following: \"(2.1) Despite subsections (1) and (2), the Governor in Council must not make an order under this section if (a) the Minister has determined that the health risks or the combined environmental risks and health risks are unacceptable; (b) the pest control product does not have sufficient value for the protection of national economic security, regional economic security or national food security; or (c) reasonable alternatives are available.\" I have more amendments, but I will plead with my friends across the way. In the 51 years I've worked on pesticides in this country, this is the single most regressive proposal I've ever seen. Stephen Harper's government never touched toxic chemicals. I will say that the Harper administration did massive damage to environmental impact assessment law and the Fisheries Act, but those were repaired subsequently. Nobody of any government of any political stripe, in my experience, has ever proposed anything as appalling as this. I beg my colleagues around the table. I know that I've had the great generosity of time. I'm deeply grateful. There are trade implications. Our products could be rejected over and over again. Even looking just at the economics of this, whoever drafted this didn't look at the facts. They didn't look at the economics. They certainly didn't look at the environmental risks, and they didn't consider that pesticides.... The Canadian Cancer Society has been clear for years that pesticides carry risks, depending on the pesticide. What kind of economic argument is used? I recall this one, because I was in the Mulroney government as an adviser, and I was the lawyer for Friends of the Earth in the alachlor case. The moment that Monsanto's economic argument for why their carcinogenic herbicide, alachlor, must not be banned.... The agriculture minister at the time was prepared to accept this argument. Monsanto and Agriculture Canada said that it would be unfair to ban alachlor because its next closest competitor also caused cancer. It took Jake Epp, as former minister of health, saying that he'd have to stand up in the House of Commons after the Minister of Agriculture licensed this project and, if asked, say that this herbicide, alachlor, causes cancer. The economic arguments at the time were seen to override Jake Epp's argument. Fortunately, the cabinet didn't buy it. I don't see any criteria in Bill C-30 that would prevent a known carcinogen to continue to be used in dangerous and certainly risky circumstances, with no economic case having to be made. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, my colleagues. Again, I'm pleading with you, particularly the Liberal and Conservative members in this place. I know the Bloc Québécois is supporting my position, and I'm deeply grateful. If we had NDP members at the table...but of course, they're not a recognized party. I'm grateful that I, as a representative of an unrecognized party, was given this latitude. Thank you again, Madam Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-48/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-48/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101388","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I want to start by thanking all members of this committee for allowing me to speak now. In the normal course of things, without the programming motion, my amendments would come up in order. My first amendment occurs at clause 52. I have eight amendments. They speak specifically and only to division 8 of Bill C-30 . Division 8 relates to pesticides. I would like to start by ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2ffad17d55c65bb0b32388646ac15c64f7307018e07489d86d24d112987ccec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cce10915a92bea495e722330395865bb279ef19d2b3c848e483626d4d3006c05"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88a7aa93c2ea52c85ea4400d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086914,"date":"2026-06-16T15:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for Saskatoon—University for presenting his private member's bill. I will certainly support it.\n\nI wonder if there is unanimous consent so that I could present a private member's bill at this moment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086914","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for Saskatoon—University for presenting his private member's bill. I will certainly support it.\n\nI wonder if there is unanimous consent so that I could present a private member's bill at this moment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-926d15992e867a97bd4ce754","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086915,"date":"2026-06-16T16:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I heard the hon. member mention frequently that there was an election in which we elected a Prime Minister. I know this may seem pedantic, but we do not elect prime ministers in this country. Under Westminster parliamentary democracy, each member in this place is equal to every other member. Every constituent has the choice to elect their member of Parliament. If their member of Parliament happens to be the leader of a party, and that party has the most seats in the House or can hold the confidence of the House, that person becomes prime minister, with no particular constitutional authority. We certainly do not directly elect them as is done in the United States.\n\n I know it may seem pedantic, but we did not elect the current Prime Minister; we elected our own MPs. Only the people in Nepean elected the Prime Minister. Beyond that, we did not elect a CEO. We did not elect a dictator. We elected a Parliament. Parliament needs to do its work. I find time allocation and programming motions offensive to those principles. \n\nI wonder if the parliamentary secretary wants to comment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086915","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I heard the hon. member mention frequently that there was an election in which we elected a Prime Minister. I know this may seem pedantic, but we do not elect prime ministers in this country. Under Westminster parliamentary democracy, each member in this place is equal to every other member. Every constituent has the choice to elect their member of Parliament. If their member of Par","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d18c9ed41546d76edac972529e5751997f415247b81f31b3483255e381f08bc8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["12d28a92f4b27713fab426e50a81cefab706dab6ac05740793d13e8195d61947"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2230abb1f9f4089cd9093dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086916,"date":"2026-06-16T18:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this debate is difficult because the Liberals have put forward that there is no justification for being against Bill C‐9. I have a lot of difficulty with that, particularly from a civil liberties point of view, especially in its describing of the idea of there being certain places and certain symbols.\n\nHowever, we are grappling with the same problem we have been grappling with for a long time. I think the cosmic jury may still be out as to whether Homo sapiens were a good idea. We seem to be willing to take up arms against each other, hate each other and do foul things to each other. It just brings to mind what Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. said: \"Morality cannot be legislated, but behavior can be regulated. Judicial decrees may not change the heart, but they can restrain the heartless.\"\n\nI am torn about the bill in many ways, but I cannot vote for it, and I wish that there were more ways through which we could find common cause against hatred.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086916","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this debate is difficult because the Liberals have put forward that there is no justification for being against Bill C‐9. I have a lot of difficulty with that, particularly from a civil liberties point of view, especially in its describing of the idea of there being certain places and certain symbols.\n\nHowever, we are grappling with the same problem we have been grappling with for a l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ebc0ed80dd1ec25bf393d8ec46bd06f3c20cab580e9631561e26628a2060e20"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["129434fd4c602a5cad4330082c469cc0c7fa0a0fce22801547d5daa6a395c4df"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9dc69644a8e25d32e5c0a3d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086917,"date":"2026-06-16T20:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise. Today is a sad day because our dear colleague, the member for Saint-Hyacinthe—Bagot—Acton, has made this decision, which was already well known before he gave his last speech.\n\nHowever, it is important for me to thank him for his friendship, for his very hard work on the important issues facing Canada—I hope he forgives me for saying so—as well as the issues facing Quebec. I wish him all the best in the future, and I hope he will continue to think about the rest of Canada, because we need the values that are embodied every day by the Bloc Québécois.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086917","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise. Today is a sad day because our dear colleague, the member for Saint-Hyacinthe—Bagot—Acton, has made this decision, which was already well known before he gave his last speech.\n\nHowever, it is important for me to thank him for his friendship, for his very hard work on the important issues facing Canada—I hope he forgives me for saying so—as well as the issues f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-519320db6163c6613a0fe0f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101406,"date":"2026-06-17T00:20:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"SECU","text":"Mr. Chair, your English is nothing but perfect.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101406","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, your English is nothing but perfect.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a540ffdc8c77c3e7a5033f77","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086918,"date":"2026-06-17T02:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, very briefly, I completely agree with the member for Beauharnois—Salaberry—Soulanges—Huntingdon.\n\nI would like to make it as clear as I can.\n\nI agree with the Bloc Québécois member on her point of order. The things that are happening in Parliament right now really are anti-democratic.\n\n I want to put on the record my support for the point of order by the hon. member for Beauharnois—Salaberry—Soulanges—Huntingdon. \n\nAs is so often the case, she is right. I am so very grateful to her.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086918","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, very briefly, I completely agree with the member for Beauharnois—Salaberry—Soulanges—Huntingdon.\n\nI would like to make it as clear as I can.\n\nI agree with the Bloc Québécois member on her point of order. The things that are happening in Parliament right now really are anti-democratic.\n\n I want to put on the record my support for the point of order by the hon. member for Beauharnois—Sa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d18e19d0c8021084c77c9522","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101407,"date":"2026-06-17T03:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"SECU","text":"I do have an amendment. That's why I'm here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101407","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I do have an amendment. That's why I'm here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e73beee95b869a8c8b4b97d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101408,"date":"2026-06-17T03:00:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"SECU","text":"I'm not allowed to speak, but I agree with you. Some hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101408","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm not allowed to speak, but I agree with you. Some hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d696c2caf9aeed3b0da6d92","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1148670,"date":"2026-06-17T16:26:31+00:00","title":"An Act to amend the Department of Industry Act (small businesses)","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"An Act to amend the Department of Industry Act (small businesses)","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-291","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-291","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1148670","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"An Act to amend the Department of Industry Act (small businesses)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac3831331c27c3cde465abeb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086898,"date":"2026-06-17T21:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":", seconded by the member for Courtenay—Alberni, moved for leave to introduce Bill C-291, An Act to amend the Department of Industry Act (small businesses).\n\nShe said: Mr. Speaker, I am very honoured today to introduce a private member's bill that seeks to amend the Department of Industry Act with regard to the promotion of small businesses.\n\nI want to thank my dear friend, the hon. member for Courtenay—Alberni, for seconding this bill.\n\n I think most members here agree that small businesses are the backbone of Canada's economy. They employ the most people. In every one of our communities and across Canada, they are responsible for more than half of the economic activity.\n\nI presented this bill before, but it failed to get past second reading. Let me give some context. I first heard about what gets called the \"think small first\" bill from friends of mine who are in the Green parties in the European Union and the European Parliament. It was adopted in the European Parliament in 2008. The basic principle is that before any law passes a Parliament, there is screening to see whether there will be unintended consequences of a piece of legislation or regulation that are negative for small businesses. It is an advanced review that looks through a lens to see whether a law is going to create more unnecessary hurdles for small businesses to succeed.\n\n It calls on the government and the Minister of Industry to protect and promote the role of small businesses within the Canadian economy. I certainly hope all of my colleagues here will see this bill passed unanimously, because small businesses matter.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086898","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":", seconded by the member for Courtenay—Alberni, moved for leave to introduce Bill C-291, An Act to amend the Department of Industry Act (small businesses).\n\nShe said: Mr. Speaker, I am very honoured today to introduce a private member's bill that seeks to amend the Department of Industry Act with regard to the promotion of small businesses.\n\nI want to thank my dear friend, the hon. member for Cour","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["12c22361e248ed1f2ff274ef5e741b78569fc11e4c42584cfed7399b262450ff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f4a08bf5df09361c4c28714313c92e1ba35bb53c741431e26a023294eb8b2001"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ca72f312b47174ae07a488e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086899,"date":"2026-06-17T21:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank a local grassroots activist for proportional representation who has asked me to present a number of these petitions on the subject of our current first-past-the-post voting system. I want to thank Shelagh Levey for collecting so many signatures. Her petition calls for an immediate adoption of a fair voting system, such as what is in place in most democracies around the world, before the next election.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086899","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank a local grassroots activist for proportional representation who has asked me to present a number of these petitions on the subject of our current first-past-the-post voting system. I want to thank Shelagh Levey for collecting so many signatures. Her petition calls for an immediate adoption of a fair voting system, such as what is in place in most democracies around the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["41f66529f28761440f9fa1f453c3dac3275972c273b0a6fb01e47e1097fecf40"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6c8278154f8436dc2b07052abea6cb12b5bcfa04f06fab8cdf3390e72077766e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33af1dc02d72d4c9efe837ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086900,"date":"2026-06-17T21:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition is an e-petition signed by nearly 2,000 Canadians calling on the government, particularly the Pest Management Regulatory Agency, to conduct a thorough review of the use of anticoagulant rodenticides, as well as neurotoxic rodenticides, the damage to the environment and the threats to pets and health.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036997","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rodenticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086900","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition is an e-petition signed by nearly 2,000 Canadians calling on the government, particularly the Pest Management Regulatory Agency, to conduct a thorough review of the use of anticoagulant rodenticides, as well as neurotoxic rodenticides, the damage to the environment and the threats to pets and health.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036997","label":"Rodenticides"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036997","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rodenticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036997","label":"Rodenticides","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["276c2d3c1208dd3f47f3448fc2c3d2c02f652216499e76d337c12bfd80968503"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036997","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rodenticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9293a1985cde3a3f05ca7abbdbfd7302352246a52d6e6a59142e48768b929170"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036997","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rodenticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036997","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rodenticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036997","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4389f29c49c7de0e4ec04d4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086901,"date":"2026-06-17T22:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the hon. member for Yorkton—Melville gave her farewell address. I would just get on the record how much I am going to miss her. I want to thank her for her service to our prayer breakfast group when she was chair, and just say, best of luck in everything and all my love.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086901","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the hon. member for Yorkton—Melville gave her farewell address. I would just get on the record how much I am going to miss her. I want to thank her for her service to our prayer breakfast group when she was chair, and just say, best of luck in everything and all my love.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7774ecd017fc76da0fb30746","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086902,"date":"2026-06-18T00:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I thank my esteemed Bloc Québécois colleague for the hard work that she did at the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security. I also had the opportunity to attend the meetings of that committee, but as an observer. I watched her work, and I completely agree with what she said this evening.\n\nIt is really strange to be rushing through such an important bill. Why does my colleague think that the government is forcing us to put such a rush on this bill that we could not even hear from witnesses?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086902","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I thank my esteemed Bloc Québécois colleague for the hard work that she did at the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security. I also had the opportunity to attend the meetings of that committee, but as an observer. I watched her work, and I completely agree with what she said this evening.\n\nIt is really strange to be rushing through such an important bill. Why does m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["74093a8a188e63cb468a0b9eec43cd64c306406d6e19758aee7757d1e8fdee8b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90d19fab8a066ba121f98e669771424f6b612b6199597a58a113b003fe164f73"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f51e1f889f92a47f614eef87","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086903,"date":"2026-06-18T01:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am in the same position as the member for Vancouver East in having a deep concern about this bill. This has not come up in the debate, but just to clarify, even though we have the fiction that committees are the masters of their own process, every PMO since Stephen Harper's has insisted that members of Parliament from parties that do not have 12 members are given 24 hours' notice to come up with amendments and then their amendments are deemed to have been moved, but we are not allowed to speak to the bill much, question witnesses ever or even vote on our own amendments. We are in the same boat, but we have both observed what has been going on at the public safety committee. Rather than repeat everything the member just said, I will say that I observed the same things.\n\nAs a member who has been here for the last 10 years, has she ever seen anything like starting with Bill C‐2, going to Bill C‐12 and then going to Bill C‐22 and, at every stage, ignoring the concerns about the overreach?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086903","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am in the same position as the member for Vancouver East in having a deep concern about this bill. This has not come up in the debate, but just to clarify, even though we have the fiction that committees are the masters of their own process, every PMO since Stephen Harper's has insisted that members of Parliament from parties that do not have 12 members are given 24 hours' notice ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0a72232828f8d7dc24dbca26856861ed9ead02b974c1c13c55182949ebc001c8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a6097f06a65539b64aec5addc47b8e805ac163d7ac4801f842f1f5cf25a229ed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32e5ac5ff172a2e5d024e2b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086904,"date":"2026-06-18T01:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am rising at this hour to speak to the programming motion on Bill C‐22.\n\nI have heard the speeches of a number of colleagues in this place with whom I agree, particularly my colleagues from the Bloc Québécois and the New Democratic Party.\n\nAs I explained earlier, in an answer to an earlier discussion with the hon. member for Vancouver East, the position we were in was not as members of the committee but as members of Parliament with the right to participate in the development of amendments. As we were not full members of the committee, our participation in the public safety committee, and when I speak of \"we\", I mean the member for Vancouver East and me, was more limited than that of members who are full members of the committee.\n\nI have been very concerned, from the very beginning, which was June 2025's tabling of Bill C‐2, the so-called strong borders act, there was an astonishing, broad, deep coalition of groups, over 300, that came together to oppose the bill on many grounds relating to human rights, as well as to privacy and overreach. Again, I just want to preface my discussion of Bill C‐22 by placing it, for citizens watching this, in the context of how we moved away from Bill C‐2, the strong borders act, which was strongly opposed, in June 2025. I do not think I have ever seen quite a diverse coalition. Certainly there are some bills that invite a lot of organizations to get involved and individual citizens to get involved. There was a breadth and a depth here that was certainly unusual.\n\nThe government realized it was in trouble. There was so much opposition to Bill C‐2. When we came back in the fall, I thought to myself that the bill, over the course of the summer, had been dumped and replaced as we now had Bill C‐12. It is not a completely different bill. It is largely the same chunks of language that were in the strong borders act, Bill C‐2, taking out the parts that were an overreach into privacy, for instance, the sections originally in Bill C‐2 that said that postal workers could open the mail and such things. There were a number of examples that got dropped.\n\nThe thing that is unusual about this, and I know it is complicated and I know the hour is late, but why would a government introduce a bill, which is widely panned, and then bring in a different bill, as opposed to amending the bill it already had on the Order Paper? I have not seen this before. It then brought in Bill C-12, which had most of what was in the strong borders act, and left Bill C-2 on the Order Paper while continuing to force through Bill C-12.\n\nTime will tell when Bill C-12 will be challenged in the courts globally because it violates our charter commitments to the protection of refugee rights. I speak of that in terms of the global convention on refugees. It may also offend the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, but I am speaking globally. It pulled that protection out from under people who had expectations. They had expectations of being in Canada but did not know their access to claiming refugee rights would be taken away so abruptly.\n\nIn any case, this has been bizarre. We had Bill C-2 staying on the Order Paper, and we had Bill C-12, which was largely language from Bill C-2, being pushed through.\n\nThe whole time we were thinking that at least we had avoided the surveillance concerns, the privacy concerns and the overreach concerns that were evident in the original Bill C‐2, the strong borders act, but come March 12, 2026, we had the bill that is before us tonight, Bill C‐22. Again, it is the government's, at this point, third run at crafting a bill that deals with lawful access.\n\nI will give them this: Bill C‐12 actually avoided the lawful access sections and just focused on the portions that affected refugee rights. That one still grieves me, the fact that we had Bill C‐12 pushed through to final stages on a unanimous consent motion in this place last June. I really still regret it very much that it was pushed through. This is a phrase we will hear from the opposition members tonight, and we have it heard it often: pushed through, rushed through.\n\n This is not hyperbole from opposition members. I am an experienced member of Parliament. I have been here 15 years, and I am honoured to have been so, but to my hon. colleagues in the government party on the other benches, it has been a shock to see how often we see these things. When mistakes are identified, previous governments have been more willing to say, \"Ah, we have a mistake and we are going to have to rethink this. This is a mistake, and we are going to amend the bill. We are going to say where we made the mistake and how we are going to change it.\" The government is quite unusual in not admitting mistakes, but it will bring in a different bill that does some of the same things. In this case, it is taking its third run at it. \n\nThis lawful access regime has many improvements over the lawful access regime of Bill C-2. There is no question and no doubt. There have been significant changes, and I think every group that was in the original coalition opposing Bill C-2 has said that Bill C-22 is much better. We have fewer problems with it, but there are still very serious problems, which is why it is lamentable that we were not able to have the kind of conversation one would have with a government that was more comfortable in its skin to say that it made a mistake with Bill C-2. Such a government would say, \"We pushed too hard, too far, too fast. Now we are going to listen to people. As we craft a lawful access regime, we are going to really listen and we are not going to assume we have it right because we are right, or because we have the majority, so we are right.\" This has been very difficult to observe. \n\nCertainly, in committee, I have to say that I was surprised. I was taken aback when a reasonable request to have before the public safety committee the Privacy Commissioner, who had raised concerns, was rejected. We had a lot of witnesses there who represented government agencies and law enforcement to provide technical background. I try to be as non-partisan as possible, but I could not see any problem with getting the expertise of the Privacy Commissioner in the room as members were discussing and debating the impact of Bill C-22 and whether some amendments should work and how they should work, but the idea that the Privacy Commissioner should be in the room was rejected. I could not see, in any world, where that would not have been seen as helpful, but it was rejected.\n\nI had some amendments before the committee. We will get to them later this evening. I do not think it is anything but a foregone conclusion that the motion before us is going to pass, but I lament that we have seen the government, and it is a pattern, moving very fast and passing legislation despite significant concerns from significant quarters. \n\nA significant number of respected law professors and experts in privacy law and constitutional law wrote, as recently as last month, to most of the cabinet to express their deep concerns about Bill C-22. I think it is important to say that people are not just partisan here. Certainly law professors are not, and they acknowledge that they see the improvement over Bill C-2 in a number of areas. I will read from the letter, which was signed by 20 or 30 law professors from across Canada, and it is dated May 4, so anyone who is looking for it can find it. It reads:\n\nWe write as lawyers and law professors who teach and practice in the areas of privacy law and constitutional rights....\n\nI will skip ahead to their conclusion, which reads:\n\n...provisions of the bill as currently drafted raise serious constitutional concerns and fail to strike a reasonable balance between the legitimate needs of law enforcement and the privacy rights of Canadians. \n\nAgain, these are not the voices of people who have been misinformed through social media. These are people of depth, knowledge and experience, and they are very concerned.\n\nOne of Canada's premier policy wonk magazines is Policy Options, and I do not speak of it pejoratively here. Policy Options is not something one would pick up in the supermarket, such as \"inquiring minds want to know\". Policy Options is serious. \n\n There was an article just yesterday by Professor Cynthia Khoo, who is a professor at University of Toronto and a senior fellow at The Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto. She is an expert in both technology and privacy areas. Her conclusion was that \"Ottawa should reject any data-sharing arrangement that allows U.S. law enforcement to access Canadians' personal information\". This is based on recent research within The Citizen Lab that the regime for surveillance being established by Bill C-22 could provide easy access for, for instance, U.S. homeland security to the private information of Canadians.\n\nI know the government benches have heard, and do not want to hear anything more, from Professor Michael Geist, who is, again, a prominent critic of Bill C-22, starting with his opposition to Bill C-2. He pointed out that what he sees being spread by the government benches could be described as misinformation, mischaracterization, overly broad definitions and a failure to be precise in areas where one really has to be precise.\n\nI am just going to quote from a blog he posted recently: \"The political pressure against Bill C-22 has been steadily mounting, with the opposition parties,\" as we can see, all the opposition parties in this place, \"tech companies, and privacy experts, all increasingly\" concerned about the need to amend this bill, increasingly concerned that all the government seems to have in response to the criticisms are, in his words, \"misleading or inaccurate claims with little in the way of an actual defence\" based on the facts. His conclusion is that \"the government's disregard for facts and privacy is fast becoming Bill C-22's legacy.\"\n\nNow, the criticisms come, again, from a broad sweep of legal, privacy and tech experts. They are not all the same. I practised law, and technology is not my area. I would not put myself out there as an expert in technology, though I read deeply. I am concerned about constitutional rights and privacy as a former practising lawyer, but it would seem to me that anyone with a background in the various areas that are touched by Bill C-22 would want to take the time to get it right. \n\nThere have been things claimed, like that all our Five Eyes partners have legislation just like Bill C-22. That has been debunked by numerous experts. We have been told that it was wrong to take a long time in committee. Obviously, as my hon. colleague on the other side the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Finance knows well, we had a very lengthy filibuster on Bill C-30 in the finance committee. I sat through those evenings waiting for the chance to speak to my amendments. \n\nAs I mentioned earlier, motions are passed by committees as if they are normal, and they are not normal at all, but the longer they are used, I guess, the more that future committees will just assume, as every committee did after this last election, that it is just normal to take away the rights of the smaller parties so that the larger parties do not have to fuss with them at report stage. That is the case. If it were not for the motions that were passed by committees, without thinking about them, taking away the rights of smaller parties, I would have the right to put forward amendments at report stage. I do not have that right at report stage only because I have been given this so-called opportunity to work really, really hard to bring forward amendments that give me the ability to sit in a room and not speak for days at a time, hoping for the chance to speak to the one or two amendments that I had brought forward.\n\n I want to thank my hon. colleague from Vancouver East, from the New Democratic Party, because she is in the same boat and she brought forward many more amendments to Bill C-22 than I brought forward on Bill C-22. I think I was too busy trying to write amendments on Bill C-30.\n\nIn any case, what we have here is not just an imperfect bill but a potentially dangerous bill. We are now down to the final moments. The clock is ticking, and the words of experts from across Canada are being shut out because the government has determined it will move forward with Bill C-22. That is why we have a programming motion, to make sure that we do not have any further debate on the amendments that have been put forward by members of the Conservative Party, the Bloc Québécois, the Greens and the New Democrats. We are in a hurry.\n\nAgain, I have to push back and ask why. What is the hurry? What is the rush? As a reminder, the first attempt the government made to bring forward lawful access was in the very outrageously overreaching Bill C‐2 a year ago. A year has passed. One would have hoped that year would have been used well by allowing a real discussion and continually striving to have the best possible surveillance architecture to protect privacy, to give law enforcement what it needs, without tests of access that are so low, the reasonable grounds to suspect, which we do not think the courts will find to have been an adequate ground to seize personal information.\n\nWe are hearing concerns, again, from tech companies, constitutional and privacy law experts, those who work in the field and others, like OpenMedia. I am honoured to claim that the executive director of OpenMedia happens to be one of my constituents, so I also speak on behalf of my constituents when I stand here at this hour. We are hearing concerns, yet those voices seem to have just gotten annoying to the members of the government. They do not seem to be concerned, despite all the work and the full year that has gone by, that we could get this right.\n\nAgain, we hear that we have run out of time. Well, we have not. I do not think any of us are going to expire in any particular moment. We could meet next week. We could get together again and have more time for witnesses to actually discuss without a clock ticking, for witnesses and experts to share with the members of the committee in a respectful way how we can improve this.\n\nI saw that the hon. member for Barrie South—Innisfil mentioned it earlier, but we are seeing news across the news wires that the Minister of Public Safety is about to make a step. Who knows, but certainly it was not the National Enquirer saying this. It was at least the CBC, saying that the Government of Canada is prepared to fundamentally change one aspect of this, which is not having to hold Canadians' private data for a year but maybe bringing that down to six months. Is that going to be presented? I do not know. \n\nWe will be going into committee after the programming motion is passed. There will be an opportunity for new amendments to be tabled, but not, of course, from me or the member for Vancouver East, because we had a deadline some time ago, and we either had to bring it in by that deadline or could not bring in something new.\n\nThere may still be that opportunity to improve the bill. I certainly hope so, because what we have in front of us may violate our own Charter of Rights and Freedoms, open up personal data, surveillance data, and do serious damage. If, good heavens, the Citizen Lab research is right and Canadians' private data would be available to the U.S. homeland security folks in large tranches, none of us are going to feel particularly happy about that.\n\nOur government should be making sure that our privacy is protected. It is an inherent right that we have. I would like to say it is a right in the same way first nations have the right to clean drinking water, although we have now been informed that they do not have the right to that but only the hope of a gradual or eventual \"realization\" of a right. That term is just so extraordinary. Well, we have a right to privacy, and I do not want to hear that it is dialed back to a gradual realization of a right. We have a right to privacy. We can reasonably expect it of our government to ensure that our private data is not left in an architecture of surveillance that allows it to be accessed by foreign governments, any foreign government.\n\nThe Citizen Lab research that was just published in Policy Options yesterday talks about U.S. homeland security as an example, but I do not want my government asking tech companies to save, store and access private data about Canadians that is then available to foreign governments. We have certainly learned a lot about foreign interference, and we are waiting for the foreign interference registry to actually be established since we passed that law some time ago.\n\nAt this late hour, and I know I'm out of time—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086904","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am rising at this hour to speak to the programming motion on Bill C‐22.\n\nI have heard the speeches of a number of colleagues in this place with whom I agree, particularly my colleagues from the Bloc Québécois and the New Democratic Party.\n\nAs I explained earlier, in an answer to an earlier discussion with the hon. member for Vancouver East, the position we were in was not as membe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["679dcc7a8eade4b8c44e7c57e7ea0980e00312416fe76175c6a57f33067f780b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d67497ed19a1cbc94ddda580718ed0638c1057fa595ba8f7a15f8e334f477255"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56c84621691fdc3fb95b756f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086905,"date":"2026-06-18T01:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I understand the member's frustration, but I do not accept that that is an excuse for the programming motions. Again, in 15 years in this place, I have never seen anything like putting a bulldozer on steroids in the way that programming motions are being used, and it is offensive. Again, I know there is frustration. Inevitably, between a majority government and an opposition, tools like filibusters will be used, but the point is that we do not have to be in a rush to get out tomorrow or the day after or next week. We could take our time and make sure we get this bill right rather than have it thrown out by the court later.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086905","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I understand the member's frustration, but I do not accept that that is an excuse for the programming motions. Again, in 15 years in this place, I have never seen anything like putting a bulldozer on steroids in the way that programming motions are being used, and it is offensive. Again, I know there is frustration. Inevitably, between a majority government and an opposition, tools ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","label":"Equipment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["561f617f8f02f8e23dcc30dbda7fd1c14ffa7345bb9ed737c16282d051d6da91"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a233b861b260c1374297c8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086906,"date":"2026-06-18T01:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, from my point of view, as leader of the Green Party, I did not think it was working terribly well in the minority Parliament because the Conservatives supported every egregious Liberal bill like Bill C-5. I still feel the pain of the bulldozer across my back when I think of Monday, June 16, 2025. I do not forget, because June 18 was a Wednesday, and I went to Marc Garneau's funeral in Montreal. I then went back online to try to fight off the changes in Bill C-5, and by Friday, Bill C-5 was done. That was offensive to democracy. This is offensive to democracy. We can make Parliament work better, yes we can, but that is not an excuse for bulldozing through bills that need work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086906","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, from my point of view, as leader of the Green Party, I did not think it was working terribly well in the minority Parliament because the Conservatives supported every egregious Liberal bill like Bill C-5. I still feel the pain of the bulldozer across my back when I think of Monday, June 16, 2025. I do not forget, because June 18 was a Wednesday, and I went to Marc Garneau's funeral ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a44ae5d6780a97837d9186f2089698f306182f696e3be66d7a438f32c9e222be"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4b6644e7e93eaacec6e80bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086907,"date":"2026-06-18T02:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as my colleague for Drummond said, I have been a member of this place for 15 years. What an honour it is to represent the communities of Saanich—Gulf Islands and Sencoten- and Lekwungen-speaking indigenous peoples.\n\nThe fact that I represent a very small party always causes problems, but right now things are worse for me than ever before. Mr. Harper's majority government from 2011 to 2015 was an awful time for me. Now, however, too much is being done too fast. Right now, I do not get a sense that the current government respects Parliament or Canada's institutions. \n\nIn my opinion, it may be because of our Prime Minister's experience. He is a brilliant man who is respected around the world for his experience in the banking sector, but not for his experience in Parliament at our level, because he does not have one day of experience in Parliament. That is what frightens me. He has things to learn. As brilliant as he is, however, he does not understand that he has things to learn.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086907","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as my colleague for Drummond said, I have been a member of this place for 15 years. What an honour it is to represent the communities of Saanich—Gulf Islands and Sencoten- and Lekwungen-speaking indigenous peoples.\n\nThe fact that I represent a very small party always causes problems, but right now things are worse for me than ever before. Mr. Harper's majority government from 2011 to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","label":"Indigenous culture","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","label":"Social problems","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["724b706fd2855542c2f44062a531c61f1218735036a5e069f517bcac47fb3872"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a41ba116350c8b17fe2ba938","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086908,"date":"2026-06-18T02:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I can offer my opinion. I think it is just a fact that they were told to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086908","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I can offer my opinion. I think it is just a fact that they were told to.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-794889a7399712953bb58d2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086909,"date":"2026-06-18T02:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, as the hon. parliamentary secretary knows, I believe that if we followed the rules of this place, we could far more easily come to consensus around how long each bill should have at second reading before going to committee and so on.\n\n The rules of this place say we cannot read a written speech. Knowing that a member cannot deliver a speech unless they have the knowledge in their head to stand up and speak would winnow down the number of members that a House leader uses to negotiate with the other parties. \"We have 100 people ready to speak.\" Really? Without written notes? I do not think so.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086909","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, as the hon. parliamentary secretary knows, I believe that if we followed the rules of this place, we could far more easily come to consensus around how long each bill should have at second reading before going to committee and so on.\n\n The rules of this place say we cannot read a written speech. Knowing that a member cannot deliver a speech unless they have the knowledge in their he","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72f3e67367635438c9f966e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086910,"date":"2026-06-18T03:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the result of the previous vote to this vote and will vote no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086910","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Green Party agrees to apply the result of the previous vote to this vote and will vote no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cce24af864119e89fe80ad095b110b1b4f9b075fbe3eb5fc54db01469418508e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdcaf60a8c056d99d36051f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086911,"date":"2026-06-18T03:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is indeed nice that we have seen the clock at midnight. I cannot break the legal fiction, while we are all here together, but it is time for Adjournment Proceedings. \n\nI am raising a question I initially raised April 20, two days before Earth Day. I had, on a previous occasion, witnessed an exchange between the hon. member for Edmonton Strathcona and the Minister of Energy, in which he was dismissive of the concerns of the most recent oil spill from Imperial Oil on the Cold Lake First Nations territory. \n\nI asked on that occasion if there might be an interest on the part of the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources in amending his answer to reflect deep concern for the fact that it is not just one oil spill or one leaking tailings ponds in northern Alberta in the area of the oil sands, it is multiple. \n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!\n\nElizabeth May: Mr. Speaker, I am having trouble hearing myself.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086911","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is indeed nice that we have seen the clock at midnight. I cannot break the legal fiction, while we are all here together, but it is time for Adjournment Proceedings. \n\nI am raising a question I initially raised April 20, two days before Earth Day. I had, on a previous occasion, witnessed an exchange between the hon. member for Edmonton Strathcona and the Minister of Energy, in whic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b8a84273f98e4391aed0300ec3084137f9cd6989fe7695fb73f4408bd4781477"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["871805db4baf59da9d90f11a21ed70fc7f88762614084c4697f795060cfe023b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6507ac20f1c1610faafd1db7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086912,"date":"2026-06-18T03:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the difficulty we have and the reason I raised this issue again is that I did ask in the House, on April 20, for a better answer.\n\nThe hon. Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Environment attempted to answer at that point, saying that the government was concerned and was \"working closely with the Crown-indigenous working group along with the affected communities\", and that it would find \"a long-term, science-based solution\".\n\nThe difficulty I have with that answer is that it has been more than a decade since one of the most prominent scientists in Canada, the late Dr. David Schindler appeared before the fisheries committee in this place and testified that his research had found the component parts, chemical contaminants that could have come only from the tailings ponds, not from any natural source in the environment, of contamination that violated the Fisheries Act, yet the government had taken no action. Dr. Schindler made it very clear to the fisheries committee that there had already been extensive contamination of the Athabasca River from what are called tailings ponds.\n\nThe difficulty is not so much that Imperial Oil is experiencing leaks. It is that the containment system is a failure. It is basically a sieve. What Imperial Oil did in the past, when it initially did not tell the community that it had what it could see was a breach of containment, was pump the water out of the areas where there was extensive recent contamination, and then pump it back into the same container, which was a sieve and was leaking.\n\nYears before, I had participated in environmental assessment hearings where this particular oil sands mine was approved to go ahead, with conditions to make sure that the river, the treaty rights, the rights holders in the area, and the indigenous people were actually protected. Their health, the environment where they live and the fish they eat needed to be protected. Dr. David Schindler warned the environment committee of this in public testimony more than a decade before these recent, continuing leaks and breaches.\n\nIt would be easier for me to accept that the government, either the current government or previous governments, is concerned about the multiple breaches of the treaty rights of the rights holders throughout the area of the oil sands development, if it ever had been in the past. It would be easier to believe that something was going to happen, if it had ever happened in the past.\n\nI put it again to the government: When will it show concern for the environment in this area and the continual breaches and leaks?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086912","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the difficulty we have and the reason I raised this issue again is that I did ask in the House, on April 20, for a better answer.\n\nThe hon. Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Environment attempted to answer at that point, saying that the government was concerned and was \"working closely with the Crown-indigenous working group along with the affected communities\", and that it w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","label":"Oil spills"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","label":"Oil spills","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52812aa67d6f2195a33634e4a984b5b7b8bdef43190264d3933b02cc409bcd3d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bda7d9966a4e27e03d8afca832a02bf757d811f9dd9e33ff9ebf96424be62ca3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d19f9d6bbedac1a46a47536","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086913,"date":"2026-06-18T03:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the difficulty I have with this, again, is that we have had working groups and consultation groups, and if we ask the first nation peoples of Cold Lake, as well as those around the Cold Lake operations and the Kearl mine, there have been repeated breaches of their rights and contamination of their waterways, yet Imperial Oil last year, in 2025, had a profit of $3.5 billion. It seems that perhaps we have a disconnect between where the wealth of the area is going, which is not to sustain people's livelihood or assist in protecting the environment, and the treaty rights of the peoples of the region.\n\n I would ask again that when the government considers reconciliation, it would consider honouring the promises made in the treaties we have.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086913","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the difficulty I have with this, again, is that we have had working groups and consultation groups, and if we ask the first nation peoples of Cold Lake, as well as those around the Cold Lake operations and the Kearl mine, there have been repeated breaches of their rights and contamination of their waterways, yet Imperial Oil last year, in 2025, had a profit of $3.5 billion. It seems t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ff032f26b296c28d8b29b77e642b15aea2303e279928d6c6d090bade45aabc2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2fbddc1b13f8b4d8800126c16f6f65ee0333013e3e9060d2b719f54d0a82f8ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b241af40424ed2311beafacf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1101409,"date":"2026-06-18T04:05:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"SECU","text":"I want to thank the honourable member so much. It has been 13 years since the bizarre motion was created by Mr. Harper's PMO that members of parties that are smaller than 12 would be allowed amendments to be deemed moved, but they could only speak when the amendment came up. Had I not been allowed to say a word, this would have been the first time that I've done the work, come to a committee and not been able to say a word, so I'm grateful for that. I was just reflecting on the fact that today is June 17. I remember what I was doing last year on June 18 in the dying hours of the evening, because during the morning of June 18, I had attended the funeral for the late honourable Marc Garneau in Montreal, then spent until midnight when the bâillon came down trying to present amendments to the committee on Bill C-5 before there was no longer any time to debate them. I will say that I didn't put in nearly as many amendments as Jenny Kwan and the NDP did and certainly not as many as my colleague from the Bloc Québécois did, but all of our amendments were intended to reflect concerns we heard from experts and from our constituents. My amendments—if there's any chance without debate as you look through them tonight, as you come up to them one after another—some of them have conflicts or are very similar to efforts put forward by other members of the Bloc Québécois and the NDP. One of our amendments is PV‐2. In fact, there is a reason why we use the letters \"PV\" to refer to the Green Party. If we put it down in English, it would look like a government amendment, G-something. I'm going to jump right in to talk about PV‐2. It is directly supported by the intelligence commissioner. Oversight cannot be meaningful if the reviewer does not have access to the full evidentiary record. As for my first amendment, I ask you to please consider it, although it is somewhat similar to some of the other amendments, but it's really important that orders made under this act be time limited and subject to meaningful, ongoing review. We can't have extraordinary powers that continue by default. I won't have time. I know you gave me a few moments, and we're going to have the end of debate in I don't know how many minutes, but I'm grateful for this chance to say a few words. This process of programming motions is offensive at any time. I've always objected to them, but I hope this committee—and maybe the chair will help me—will take it back to the powers that be. It really isn't right to say that our rights, which I would have but for the motion that was passed by this committee and every other committee without thinking about it after every election.... I would otherwise have the right under our rules to bring forward substantive amendments at report stage, so I would beg of members here who have seen what it's like to be a member of Parliament sitting at the table hoping for a chance to say a word.... I appreciate the Conservative member's thoughtfulness in asking if I'd like to say something before saying I will vote against this bill. I'm terribly, terribly sad that the concerns of so many people were dismissed so casually. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1101409","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I want to thank the honourable member so much. It has been 13 years since the bizarre motion was created by Mr. Harper's PMO that members of parties that are smaller than 12 would be allowed amendments to be deemed moved, but they could only speak when the amendment came up. Had I not been allowed to say a word, this would have been the first time that I've done the work, come to a committee and n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Solar energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","label":"Solar energy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d9269fe2b3c483b2e7643b474e0d4f8f4df5c1608f7fbc63e6680eca94a9313"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc0d1ada32e333d874ab9841","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086888,"date":"2026-06-18T15:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will briefly summarize my three petitions.\n\nConstituents and others have asked that this petition be tabled here and that the government take action on an issue that we rarely hear about, which is the looming threat of the commercial farming of cephalopods. These are octopus and squid. Commercial industrial farming operations in other countries are threatening to come into Canada.\n\n The petitioners ask that large-scale aquatic farms of cephalopods be banned in Canada, that we take action to ban the importation of farmed cephalopod products and that we prohibit the breeding and raising of these sentient beings within farms in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086888","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will briefly summarize my three petitions.\n\nConstituents and others have asked that this petition be tabled here and that the government take action on an issue that we rarely hear about, which is the looming threat of the commercial farming of cephalopods. These are octopus and squid. Commercial industrial farming operations in other countries are threatening to come into Canada.\n\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f6e9744d48873138d53bc9b741030ab02ce1ac0f3b9eeea0189235a956a44601"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0982e453e0b40af57b920046","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086889,"date":"2026-06-18T15:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I am presenting is an e-petition with over 1,181 signatures.\n\nThe petitioners call on the government, in the effort to make Canada an energy superpower, to support renewable energy at least as much as it supports fossil fuels. They call on the government to commit to protect our biosphere while becoming an energy superpower and, in order to do that, ensure that renewable generation receives at least dollar for dollar the same kinds of subsidies that flow toward fossil fuels.\n\n The petitioners ask Parliament and the government to provide a legislative foundation that will provide financial support for renewable energy at least as much as fossil fuels and ban, by legislation, coal-fired electricity generation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086889","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I am presenting is an e-petition with over 1,181 signatures.\n\nThe petitioners call on the government, in the effort to make Canada an energy superpower, to support renewable energy at least as much as it supports fossil fuels. They call on the government to commit to protect our biosphere while becoming an energy superpower and, in order to do that, ensure that ren","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","label":"Renewable resources"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","label":"Renewable resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d63ca7253f794a885fbe1e9f3d0df247c0a6edc99c74264423290e7ebaf59a63"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e468b031513bbfdffa071da93461ebe949f5d6ad008792ebfab14fe413dfba5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e6715aa94117e2218a5f6cd8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086890,"date":"2026-06-18T15:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is my final petition. It is a shame, in 2026, that this needs to be said. The petitioners are calling for the government to declare the overdose crisis in Canada a public health emergency, to call for action related to opioid deaths, recognize that this is a public health emergency and take steps based on the advice of experts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086890","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is my final petition. It is a shame, in 2026, that this needs to be said. The petitioners are calling for the government to declare the overdose crisis in Canada a public health emergency, to call for action related to opioid deaths, recognize that this is a public health emergency and take steps based on the advice of experts.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f47e67f896640d4adaa434bc79c86db8852c8bf7c3eb7132e55bb673527e45c0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25c1797d5502fe2cb1f5bb0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086891,"date":"2026-06-18T15:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the hon. parliamentary secretary is a friend, so when I say a friend, it is not just rhetoric, but I am disappointed. When Bill C-30 was first tabled, I asked the hon. parliamentary secretary for finance if it would not be wise to remove division 8 from an omnibus budget bill, so that the pesticide provisions would not just be studied by the finance committee, but go to the appropriate committee of environment or health. At the time, he said he would get back to me. I do not blame him that he did not have time and, certainly, I know those decisions are not necessarily made by the parliamentary secretary for finance at all.\n\nHowever, does he now not regret, having heard how significant the concerns are from across this country that this bill was not properly studied, that division 8 received no expert review at all?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086891","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the hon. parliamentary secretary is a friend, so when I say a friend, it is not just rhetoric, but I am disappointed. When Bill C-30 was first tabled, I asked the hon. parliamentary secretary for finance if it would not be wise to remove division 8 from an omnibus budget bill, so that the pesticide provisions would not just be studied by the finance committee, but go to the appropriat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cccf334931fc4292dadd9f807d4efd476b35b27f6b1cb6b262d3db0e047925d7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbe9b9a5a24b0df384196674","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086892,"date":"2026-06-18T16:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am really impressed, hearing the member for Elmwood—Transcona talking about his personal background.\n\nI have been impressed when travelling in Winnipeg, with the co-op work and housing and building using prison labour by Shaun Loney. I wonder if the hon. member, as someone experienced in the trades, thinks that holds promise for getting tradespeople into a field where we have a lot of skills gaps right now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086892","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am really impressed, hearing the member for Elmwood—Transcona talking about his personal background.\n\nI have been impressed when travelling in Winnipeg, with the co-op work and housing and building using prison labour by Shaun Loney. I wonder if the hon. member, as someone experienced in the trades, thinks that holds promise for getting tradespeople into a field where we have a lot ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ead7f22a490b1a681ed0cb2d54c6508bee2c53581f6c185b4cfa95a9864df45"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55b5732b9cdd45fd9bec380e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086893,"date":"2026-06-18T16:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I misspoke. The term \"prison labour\" has connotations that I did not intend. The projects I mentioned in homebuilding in Winnipeg involve people who have been convicted of crimes, have served their sentences and then avoid recidivism by building homes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086893","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I misspoke. The term \"prison labour\" has connotations that I did not intend. The projects I mentioned in homebuilding in Winnipeg involve people who have been convicted of crimes, have served their sentences and then avoid recidivism by building homes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56cfd54be16a82274141ade13a0587a0f2babf04e6d54edc991aa82a80bf7de5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-759b4967a00395aa2420f34a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086894,"date":"2026-06-18T16:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I particularly appreciated my colleague's comments regarding division 8 of Bill C-30. He addressed the issue of pesticides and said that reducing health and environmental protections in the agricultural sector is very serious. I just want to ask him if he has any further comments to add.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086894","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I particularly appreciated my colleague's comments regarding division 8 of Bill C-30. He addressed the issue of pesticides and said that reducing health and environmental protections in the agricultural sector is very serious. I just want to ask him if he has any further comments to add.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3a9ea484aedaafa6a21840c0463ff42c7f6be244329bc5a411e6d71c1492caa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1951b20e999fa7e49a880de91abbb5ca8f8148ef3181e43496174c177f799de2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0db11b0a6062c34c57b58390","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086895,"date":"2026-06-18T16:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on a point of order, I would like it placed on the record very firmly that the Green Party does not support Bill C-22. We understand it is going to be passed on division. We want our position on the record.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086895","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on a point of order, I would like it placed on the record very firmly that the Green Party does not support Bill C-22. We understand it is going to be passed on division. We want our position on the record.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97ef1d3af46d8628171292d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086896,"date":"2026-06-18T17:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the hon. member for Vancouver East for an extremely important review of the gaps between the spring economic statement and the reality for Canadians. I just wonder if she would like to expand on any of the points she has made, because they were excellent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086896","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the hon. member for Vancouver East for an extremely important review of the gaps between the spring economic statement and the reality for Canadians. I just wonder if she would like to expand on any of the points she has made, because they were excellent.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["59a250779184b29634cb3756fb3538eaed5c2fc411a5fb2b6150c3fb06f6c994"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b1c04f78bd80c5eff4a62b2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1086897,"date":"2026-06-18T18:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elizabeth May","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think that my colleagues have thanked everyone already. I hope that no one was left out. I would like to send everyone my best wishes for the summer. May they all take good care of themselves and stay united for Canada.\n\nWe will be back in September. Let us stand united across party lines. This country is a country that has more in common than in difference. What makes this country the best place in the world to live in is that we take care of each other and love our neighbours. No matter what may be going on around us, know that we are blessed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1086897","member_id":"bc-mp-2897","member_name":"Elizabeth May","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think that my colleagues have thanked everyone already. I hope that no one was left out. I would like to send everyone my best wishes for the summer. May they all take good care of themselves and stay united for Canada.\n\nWe will be back in September. Let us stand united across party lines. This country is a country that has more in common than in difference. What makes this country ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de0ba55dcd1bc53a6bae58a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76879,"date":"2026-01-27T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, small businesses in the Lower Mainland of British Columbia and across Canada are being targeted by organized extortion. Businesses are receiving threats. Families are afraid, and communities are under real pressure from criminal groups that use fear and violence. This is happening in our neighbourhoods and on our streets, and it requires urgent action from Parliament.\n\nOur government has introduced important public safety legislation, including Bill C-2, Bill C-12 and Bill C-14, to give law enforcement stronger tools to fight organized crime, strengthen Canada's bail system and toughen sentences for serious and violent crimes.\n\nI call on the Conservatives to stop delaying and allow these bills to pass quickly, so law enforcement can confront organized extortion and better protect Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76879","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, small businesses in the Lower Mainland of British Columbia and across Canada are being targeted by organized extortion. Businesses are receiving threats. Families are afraid, and communities are under real pressure from criminal groups that use fear and violence. This is happening in our neighbourhoods and on our streets, and it requires urgent action from Parliament.\n\nOur government ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["369042079d75d276ef99d54ba722ea25e69ab24738792474a9e823c037aba320"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7bb452316a3dd2b67eda4aebbc4411fe082741039858d55bdddfeec530c30b9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-999b9d3a369d2260ac00100e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":92942,"date":"2026-02-10T16:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, extortion has been a key issue in British Columbia. I have been on this file almost every day, talking to the secretary of state, the Minister of Public Safety or even the Prime Minister. \n\nThe Conservatives are playing games when it comes to dealing with extortion. I would ask the hon. secretary of state what the Conservatives can do immediately to deal with this situation instead of making it a political football?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92942","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, extortion has been a key issue in British Columbia. I have been on this file almost every day, talking to the secretary of state, the Minister of Public Safety or even the Prime Minister. \n\nThe Conservatives are playing games when it comes to dealing with extortion. I would ask the hon. secretary of state what the Conservatives can do immediately to deal with this situation instead ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5990a18a3a1fe16dd825c9efa76b2ce31c9916cbf4cac99623e5b37f1373d856"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-598dc867424dbbcee5d19719","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":92943,"date":"2026-02-10T17:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in his speech, the hon. member mentioned foreign interference. In fact I am very familiar with the issue because I brought in a motion in the previous Parliament to deal with foreign interference. In fact our government brought in Bill C-70 to deal with those situations as well.\n\n I would like the hon. member to tell the House what kind of foreign interference he is hearing about on the ground, and what his leader is doing to curb that situation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92943","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in his speech, the hon. member mentioned foreign interference. In fact I am very familiar with the issue because I brought in a motion in the previous Parliament to deal with foreign interference. In fact our government brought in Bill C-70 to deal with those situations as well.\n\n I would like the hon. member to tell the House what kind of foreign interference he is hearing about on t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65db8c56ddd81588abddab26f504368baf7d98009ac2421fb9ed0da6191b61f2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e6942813af2e09b74d0f30f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":92944,"date":"2026-02-10T17:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with my colleague, the hon. member for Surrey Centre.\n\nLet me begin clearly: Extortion is a serious crime. It terrorizes families, threatens small business owners and undermines confidence in public safety. In Surrey and across British Columbia, I have met with constituents who are living in fear. They deserve real solutions, not political theatre.\n\n The Conservative motion claims to be about fighting extortion, but it relies on misinformation and proposals that would weaken, not strengthen, our justice system.\n\nIn British Columbia, the federal government has provided significant resources to combat extortion. We have committed $4 million to strengthen the B.C. extortion task force through the regional integrated drug enforcement team. In addition, the federal government and the Province of B.C. have jointly provided $1 million to support victims of extortion. The federal RCMP will deploy up to an additional 20 RCMP officers, along with helicopter resources, to support on-the-ground enforcement efforts in Surrey. Further funding is being delivered through the federal gun and gang violence action fund to disrupt gun and gang violence linked to extortion networks.\n\nWe have also taken decisive action by listing the Bishnoi gang as a terrorist organization. The RCMP and the CBSA are actively supporting investigations, laying charges and, where appropriate, also pursuing removal orders against foreign nationals who are inadmissible due to criminality or to non-compliance with Canadian law.\n\nOnce passed, Bill C-12, the strengthening Canada's immigration system and borders act, would modernize immigration enforcement and crack down on transnational organized crime, including extortion networks, making it harder for violent offenders to exploit procedural delays.\n\n Now let us address the Conservative proposals directly. They are claiming that non-citizens convicted of serious crimes can make refugee claims to avoid consequences. That is simply false. Claiming asylum does not and will not prevent criminals from being punished to the fullest extent of the law. Criminal matters take precedence over immigration matters. When CBSA believes a claimant is inadmissible on the grounds of serious criminality, their claim is put on hold while their criminal case proceeds. If they are found inadmissible, their asylum claim is terminated, their lawful status ends, and they face removal.\n\nForeign nationals already subject to a removal order cannot make a refugee claim. In cases of serious inadmissibility, those individuals are permanently barred from re-entering Canada.\n\nCBSA is aggressively pursuing the removal of criminals attempting to misuse the asylum system. Where credibility issues arise, CBSA prioritizes those files, presents evidence to the Immigration and Refugee Board and seeks dismissal or admissibility hearings leading to deportation.\n\nUnder the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, a claim is already ineligible if the person is inadmissible for serious criminality or has been convicted in or outside Canada of an offence punishable by at least 10 years. Adopting the Conservative proposal would not close a loophole; it would create new administrative layers and invite litigation.\n\nParagraph (b) of the motion would bar asylum claims for those with active criminal proceedings. That, too, has already been addressed. CBSA officers may suspend eligibility reviews when a claimant is charged with a serious offence. Once the criminal case is resolved, the officer resumes the assessment and may deem the person ineligible. Canada's system already prevents asylum claims from advancing when serious charges are pending.\n\n In paragraph (c), the Conservatives call for an end to so-called leniency to avoid deportation. What they are really proposing is to prohibit judges from considering immigration consequences at sentencing. Judges may consider immigration consequences to ensure that a sentence remains fit and proportionate, but never to reduce a sentence below what is appropriate. There is no evidence that the courts are improperly lowering sentences to avoid deportation. Any rare adjustments are reviewable on appeal and often reflect the joint positions of the Crown and defence. Eliminating judicial discretion would weaken, not strengthen, the justice system.\n\n The Conservatives are also demanding the repeal of Bill C-5 and Bill C-75. Canadians elected this government with a mandate to strengthen public safety and modernize the justice system, and we are delivering. We have tabled more than six major public safety and criminal justice bills designed to crack down on violent and repeat offenders. Conservatives have delayed them, while premiers, police chiefs and municipalities have called for their urgent passage.\n\n Bill C-75 did not weaken bail. It strengthened protections for victims of intimate partner violence by defining \"intimate partner\" to include former partners, creating a reverse onus for repeat offenders and requiring courts to consider prior convictions. Bill C-14 would go even further by clarifying that restraint does not mean automatic release, yet the Conservatives have blocked it. I have seen that in the House. The other day, speaker after speaker from the Conservatives did nothing but block Bill C-14, which would strengthen the bail act.\n\nBill C-5 did not allow house arrest for serious extortion. Conditional sentences are unavailable when sentences exceed two years or offenders pose a public safety threat. Mandatory jail time remains for extortion involving firearms or criminal organizations, which are exactly the cases that Canadians are most concerned about.\n\n Our current legislation agenda targets extortion directly and effectively. Bill C-14 would create a new reverse onus for violent extortion, require consecutive sentences for related crimes like arson, prohibit weapons at bail and strengthen geographic restrictions. Together with Bill C-2, Bill C-8, Bill C-9 and Bill C-12, these reforms would strengthen border enforcement, cybersecurity, hate crime laws and immigration integrity. These are evidence-based measures supported by law enforcement and municipalities across Canada.\n\n Extortion is not a street-level crime; it is driven by organized networks and money laundering. That is why the response must be comprehensive. Fighting extortion requires evidence-based policy and firm endorsement, not false promises, and it requires a justice system that is tough on crime while still upholding the rule of law.\n\n The Conservative approach is to blame immigration and repeal laws. Our approach is to dismantle criminal networks, strengthen enforcement, protect victims and uphold the rule of law. Victims of extortion want results, not slogans. This motion would divide communities, undermine due process and distract from real solutions.\n\n For those reasons, I will oppose this motion and support the serious, targeted reforms needed to keep Canadians safe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92944","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with my colleague, the hon. member for Surrey Centre.\n\nLet me begin clearly: Extortion is a serious crime. It terrorizes families, threatens small business owners and undermines confidence in public safety. In Surrey and across British Columbia, I have met with constituents who are living in fear. They deserve real solutions, not political theatre.\n\n The Cons","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d13604291eb45e78513f0f49a0266e5503a876b448a303d7e4b070e926cd632d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d20a6e9ad9f8e92b5b24a51a15698827ba2a929122af9765eb12f451bbed9b9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2611d85eac7f9381ecc17f8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":92945,"date":"2026-02-10T17:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is quite evident that Bill C-2, which would give lawful access to police forces, Bill C-12, which deals with asylum seekers, and Bill C-14, which deals with bail reforms, are the bills that police chiefs, premiers and the public want. There is only one party, the Conservative Party, that is blocking those bills and not letting them pass.\n\n The Conservatives are the ones who are putting Canadians at risk every day. That is what I am hearing on the ground, and I am here to fix that problem.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92945","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is quite evident that Bill C-2, which would give lawful access to police forces, Bill C-12, which deals with asylum seekers, and Bill C-14, which deals with bail reforms, are the bills that police chiefs, premiers and the public want. There is only one party, the Conservative Party, that is blocking those bills and not letting them pass.\n\n The Conservatives are the ones who are put","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["162586ca36bc828ef50cdb290d488dd4baad0f9224377b63319fd1045215cb51"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["986ace6bd13b4c67226ea5461606196335b7659de1a6261ca24985a149d1b1c9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4964a6177d71304fe20a4996","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":92946,"date":"2026-02-10T17:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, any person who claims to be a citizen, either by descent or by naturalization, has to go through criminal and security checks. That is what I personally believe and what this Parliament believes, and that legislation is in place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92946","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, any person who claims to be a citizen, either by descent or by naturalization, has to go through criminal and security checks. That is what I personally believe and what this Parliament believes, and that legislation is in place.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1fd5ebf419a1b63a399eb66bd75b9b7737b5b095d453c06c0926c6b5b64463d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["12f4e4c852c6b6ab5d91c60dfafe123b30a69154935a61857ef7fbc99ef7e07c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c7e7626e884358b347dc8a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":92947,"date":"2026-02-10T17:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, recently, members might have noticed that some of the criminals who are trying to commit crimes are seeking asylum. When we see Bill C-12, which has already gone through the House, pass through the Senate and get royal assent, they will not be eligible to claim asylum, effective June 2025.\n\n What I am hearing on the ground is that the people who are caught should not be free. They should be kept behind bars. If the Conservatives and the opposition parties support Bill C-14, once it passes, those criminals will stay behind bars and not be out and free.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92947","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, recently, members might have noticed that some of the criminals who are trying to commit crimes are seeking asylum. When we see Bill C-12, which has already gone through the House, pass through the Senate and get royal assent, they will not be eligible to claim asylum, effective June 2025.\n\n What I am hearing on the ground is that the people who are caught should not be free. They sho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["30a9d7fe3aa2c2617a54b439df1c1de2cf4c23caeb6eb0b72665b1cffacb860e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e2abaa233f048372abab94fbffa66bf90c5f3b71d17bc8dc98d6541549fce0db"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-091eb7ad3c810c477530311e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":92948,"date":"2026-02-10T17:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in fact, if we look at this motion, it is nothing but politics. It has no solutions. The only solution is the immediate action we need on the ground to catch those criminals.\n\n I want to tell the hon. member that I brought up that the CFSEU-BC should be deployed in British Columbia. The Prime Minister, the Minister of Public Safety, the Secretary of State for Combatting Crime and the B.C. Liberal caucus supported me in that. The only person who did not support that is the Leader of the Opposition. The member should go and tell his leader to support me on that issue.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92948","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in fact, if we look at this motion, it is nothing but politics. It has no solutions. The only solution is the immediate action we need on the ground to catch those criminals.\n\n I want to tell the hon. member that I brought up that the CFSEU-BC should be deployed in British Columbia. The Prime Minister, the Minister of Public Safety, the Secretary of State for Combatting Crime and the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb3f343c0a3bd08241545494b5d5d22a8c4fc433d7fee185499bda9bab83d70e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["17cd83c54564c30963460a4ba67490f521407a2b62db75159180840097593cfe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af122b02b02d766b85f504bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304881,"date":"2026-02-24T17:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with not only a good friend of mine, but in fact a great friend of the Sikh community, the hon. member for Winnipeg North. \n\nThe interim federal health program, or IFHP, is a temporary program. It supports people who do not yet have provincial or territorial health coverage. It is also an important tool to protect the health and safety of Canadians while supporting vulnerable people who are seeking Canada's protection. \n\nLet me address the claims behind the motion before us. \n\nThe first is on the growth in costs. Yes, costs under the IFHP have increased, but we must be honest about why. The cost of this program depends mainly on two things: how many asylum claims are made, and how long it takes to make final decisions. \n\nWhen claim volumes are high and processing times are long, costs rise. The good news is that under our government, asylum claims were down by about one-third last year. This will reduce pressure on the IFHP. Through Bill C-12 and other measures, we are closing loopholes at the border, tightening visa rules and discouraging misuse of the asylum system. These actions reduce future surges and shorten delays. That is how we control costs responsibly.\n\n Second, the opposition relies heavily on the projections from the Parliamentary Budget Officer. We respect the work of the PBO, but this report presents an incomplete picture. It does not account for the recent changes to the IFHP announced in budget 2025, the expected impact of Bill C-12 on claim volumes and processing time, and the possibility of further future adjustments. It also assumes that the government will do nothing more, which is simply not true. When opposition members claim that the program will cost far more in the future, they are relying on projections that ignore reforms already under way.\n\n Third is the claim that asylum claimants receive better care than Canadians. The IFHP provides basic and temporary coverage while claims are processed by the Immigration and Refugee Board. Essential care, such as visits to a doctor or a hospital, will continue to be fully covered. This protects public health and avoids higher costs later. For supplementary benefits, such as some vision care and medications, we are making measured changes. Starting in May, there will be a $4 copayment for filling or refilling a prescription and a 30% copayment for other supplementary services. These changes were announced in budget 2025. They are expected to save hundreds of millions of dollars each year. They also align the IFHP with other publicly funded programs, including those for people on social assistance. At this time, essential care remains fully covered. We will monitor the impact closely to protect public health and meet our legal and humanitarian obligations. \n\nFourth, the motion claims that asylum claims are preventing Canadians from getting health care. There is no evidence for this. It is difficult to measure exactly how much pressure asylum claimants place on the health care system, and rejected claimants are only one portion of the IFHP users.\n\nMy two daughters are physicians who are proudly serving Canadians, and I can say that Canada's health care challenges mainly come from a shortage of doctors and nurses, an aging population and long-standing system pressures. Blaming asylum seekers will not fix wait times. It will not train nurses, and it will not build hospitals. That is why our government is investing in health care for Canadians. \n\nMore than six million Canadians are now eligible for the Canadian dental care plan, which is saving families hundreds of dollars a year. With budget 2025, we are investing $5 billion in health care infrastructure. We are all well aware that this is the first time leadership has been shown by a federal government to intervene in this particular program. Through pharmacare, mental health investments and co-operation with provinces and territories, we are strengthening health care based on medical need, not the ability to pay.\n\nLet me turn to the proposals in the motion. Part A calls for reviewing benefits to find savings. We already agree with this principle. That is why we introduced copayments for supplementary benefits. These changes will save hundreds of millions of dollars each year. We can remain open to further examination, but the motion ignores what has already been done.\n\n Part B calls for limiting rejected claimants to emergency life-saving care only. This sounds simple, but it is not. Some people cannot be removed for humanitarian reasons. Limiting them to emergency-only care would create a contradiction. We would be saying we cannot send them back but also denying them basic primary care. This also risks pushing people into hospital emergency rooms instead of to family doctors. That increases costs and pressure on the health care system. We can show limited openness to reviewing how long coverage lasts, but the Conservative proposal would likely create higher costs and worse outcomes.\n\n Part C calls for more transparency. Our government is already transparent. We have provided information to Parliament. We asked the PBO to examine the program. We answered Order Paper questions. The number of people covered and cost are already public. A new formal reporting law is therefore unnecessary.\n\n Part D calls for immediate removal of non-citizens convicted of serious crimes. In Canada, criminal law comes first. People must face justice and serve their sentences before removal. If we change this rule, we would remove a real punishment for serious crime. People could commit crimes and simply be sent home.\n\n Recently I had a discussion with one of the top young criminal defence lawyers, Gagan Nahal, who is also running for a city council position. I wish him the best. In fact, he agreed with me that they should be punished and serve sentences before they are sent back to their home country. The motion would weaken deterrence and threaten public safety as well.\n\n I also want to speak about politics and accountability. The Conservatives say this motion is about accountability in health care spending, but if they truly care about accountability in the health care system, they would support my private member's bill, Bill C-239, which proposes to strengthen accountability under the Canada Health Act. The Conservatives cannot say they want accountability on one hand and then block an accountability bill on the other.\n\nThis shows the motion is not really about fixing health care; it is about playing politics with vulnerable people. The IFHP is not only about compassion. It is about public health and smart spending. Many asylum claimants will eventually become protected persons, permanent residents and possibly citizens. If we deny basic health care now, we will likely pay much higher costs later through the emergency care system. The government is acting responsibly by reducing asylum claim volumes, speeding up decisions, introducing copayments and investing in health care for Canadians. While the Conservatives debate what services to cut, we are focused on health care based on medical needs and fairness.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304881","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with not only a good friend of mine, but in fact a great friend of the Sikh community, the hon. member for Winnipeg North. \n\nThe interim federal health program, or IFHP, is a temporary program. It supports people who do not yet have provincial or territorial health coverage. It is also an important tool to protect the health and safety of Canadians while supp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6913204e04d3498a1b3ac12e485e34f0aa34bcf7ca5bd033aefaf9db7156ec56"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b1f8e5722e8708ce03f72367f8a0d08fdf2b1f4c0344528afd4087c148951b52"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d4f4db51270699e8936e498","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304882,"date":"2026-02-24T17:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a tremendous amount of respect for the hon. member. He is very compassionate and a very good friend of the Sikh community.\n\nAs I mentioned earlier, there are accountability issues with health care. That is why I brought in Bill C-239, which proposes to strengthen accountability under the Canada Health Act. I would request that the hon. member for Cariboo—Prince George and his leader support that bill, so we can provide the accountability that Canadians, particularly British Columbians, need.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304882","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a tremendous amount of respect for the hon. member. He is very compassionate and a very good friend of the Sikh community.\n\nAs I mentioned earlier, there are accountability issues with health care. That is why I brought in Bill C-239, which proposes to strengthen accountability under the Canada Health Act. I would request that the hon. member for Cariboo—Prince George and his l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56a720c76f26714c7771d9877211271a327d7c1034a5052a946037483ec3c797"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ec1a0daa231b7a5a0898b9d07f984ab35a0286253f7a4c5554049cba98a78b39"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b64d0f410a55e7d29d5a8eed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304883,"date":"2026-02-24T17:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on this particular question, I agree with the member.\n\n When there was a non-controlled border location where people were moving into Quebec and piling up those claims, we, as a federal government, were fully committed to making sure that we were able to provide the resources that the Government of Quebec and Quebeckers needed to deal with those situations. I personally support him on this idea.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304883","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on this particular question, I agree with the member.\n\n When there was a non-controlled border location where people were moving into Quebec and piling up those claims, we, as a federal government, were fully committed to making sure that we were able to provide the resources that the Government of Quebec and Quebeckers needed to deal with those situations. I personally support him on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","label":"Border crossing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","label":"Border crossing","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d147f34cdcee82b1f0a5c2ad384874909bce3dbf96fb3b6bafa44463e5b0900"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c526de3b07723556c433f7bb39e04440b73ec829350f2ee154b4388a95dad8b0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Border crossing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083636","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-36da07def7f0d4f6b4866078","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304884,"date":"2026-02-24T17:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, first of all, I want to thank the hon. member for Winnipeg North for being the seconder to Bill C-239, and for his support and inspiration to me as I brought this forward.\n\nI am hearing a lot of resentment from the opposition, particularly the Conservative Party. Conservatives think they believe in accountability, but they do not. In fact, if they really believed in accountability in health care and wanted to improve health care for Canadians, they would support Bill C-239. It is a very basic bill that would open up the Canada Health Act and introduce a sixth pillar, for provincial governments to be responsible so that Canadians' dollars are well spent on Canadians for their health care and for their well-being.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304884","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, first of all, I want to thank the hon. member for Winnipeg North for being the seconder to Bill C-239, and for his support and inspiration to me as I brought this forward.\n\nI am hearing a lot of resentment from the opposition, particularly the Conservative Party. Conservatives think they believe in accountability, but they do not. In fact, if they really believed in accountability in ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3fe43170de148a906c002081a6c8b7004dcffb73d52dba089c3cf4ea12302715"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0537e86447734c77e95f1ac89d1e039430f011fdcda66e4385ba9e2ca40cd6c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9153277af8a59db29b548ebf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304880,"date":"2026-02-25T19:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as we celebrate Black History Month, I rise to recognize the important contributions of Black Canadians and the work of the Black Business Association of BC. Surrey is home to the largest black population in our province.\n\nBlack entrepreneurs are creating jobs, driving innovation and strengthening our economy, even as many face systemic barriers. Led by co-founders Nerissa Allen and Clavia Alleyne, the Black Business Association of BC is addressing these challenges. Through programs that support market access, regulatory compliance and international trade, they help businesses grow and compete globally.\n\nBy investing in equity and inclusion, we invest in Canada's future and build a stronger, more inclusive Canada.\n\nToday is Pink Shirt Day. Let us stand against bullying and stand together in kindness.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304880","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as we celebrate Black History Month, I rise to recognize the important contributions of Black Canadians and the work of the Black Business Association of BC. Surrey is home to the largest black population in our province.\n\nBlack entrepreneurs are creating jobs, driving innovation and strengthening our economy, even as many face systemic barriers. Led by co-founders Nerissa Allen and C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4648cdecf13a0cbd36adf3bc9ea755e4181e664037fe2e56cd895e07deb4b1de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01d0e51d505eb7dd4e0e311996a37ed7964db250f7e3a50998fe911eea5bd2e3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b0916ce8f6581e8f6428fd4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":375987,"date":"2026-03-25T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize the important work of the Tradesman Association of British Columbia, a non-profit organization dedicated to supporting the skilled trades and strengthening our construction industry. Through education, safety training and professional development, the association helps tradespeople build successful careers while promoting high standards of workmanship and safety.\n\nOn March 28 and 29, the association will host its 10th annual construction expo in Surrey, welcoming thousands of visitors with free public admission. Led by president and founder Mr. Raman Sharma, this expo connects industry professionals with families and homeowners, showcases innovation and green building and supports local businesses. I commend Mr. Sharma and the Tradesman Association of BC for its leadership.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:375987","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize the important work of the Tradesman Association of British Columbia, a non-profit organization dedicated to supporting the skilled trades and strengthening our construction industry. Through education, safety training and professional development, the association helps tradespeople build successful careers while promoting high standards of workmanship and saf","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72ec93a6f236e6ac50ee6c52e178de04d1191d46d2fa8a6e85e602f12460586f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b09e07848a30f84a6aa65a6f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":418998,"date":"2026-04-13T19:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.\n\nThis month marks the seventh anniversary of Sikh Heritage Month, which allows us to celebrate and educate future generations about the contributions Sikh Canadians continue to make across our country. Vaisakhi, the founding of Khalsa, is being honoured today on Parliament Hill.\n\n On April 18, Khalsa Day and Vaisakhi will be celebrated in Surrey Newton, where the annual Nagar Kirtan will attract over half a million people. This celebration reflects the Sikh commitment to equality, selfless service and unity. I thank the organizers of the Surrey Nagar Kirtan and Sikh Canadians across our nation, who, over the past century, have helped build Canada into the country it is today.\n\nJo Bole So Nihal. Sat Sri Akal.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:418998","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.\n\nThis month marks the seventh anniversary of Sikh Heritage Month, which allows us to celebrate and educate future generations about the contributions Sikh Canadians continue to make across our country. Vaisakhi, the founding of Khalsa, is being honoured today on Parliament Hill.\n\n On April 18, Khalsa Day and Vaisakhi will be celebrated in S","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["95154f44fe881fcf60ae010cbb5799fe3be182b26de1607d3d5d43bdd9f2907d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8478eafb35a9cd47470f6e5bc0aeb5132845334dcfb7fa5297f366b9bd6a5318"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78fe88425df90974af56330e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102456,"date":"2026-04-28T17:05:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"HESA","text":"Good afternoon, everyone. Mr. Mazier, thank you for nominating me, and thank you to all the honourable members for putting your trust in me and electing me as chair of this committee. I have previously chaired committees on both sides of the aisle. People have come to me and made suggestions. I have taken them very seriously. My way of working as chair—and you can ask Tom Kmiec , Brad Redekopp and all the people I've worked with previously—is to be fair but very firm when I need to be firm. If you have any suggestions, you can come to me and tell me, and I will improve, because I'm also a human being. When it comes to the health committee, health is non-partisan. Some of you are medical professionals or your spouses are medical professionals. I'm fortunate that both my daughters are physicians. One is a neonatologist and the other a family physician. As I have a business background, any time they come to me, they say, \"Dad, health care is not politics. Health care is not business. It is a service.\" In this committee, we are all here to serve Canadians, and that's the way we should move forward. Thank you again, Mr. Mazier. Now I will call the meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 31 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. We recognize that we meet on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Before we continue, I would ask all in-person participants to consult the guidelines written on the cards on the table. These measures are in place to help prevent audio and feedback incidents and to protect the health and safety of all participants, including the interpreters. You will also notice a QR code on the card, which links to a short awareness video. I would like to remind participants of the following points. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic, and please mute yourself when you are not speaking. At the bottom of your screen, you can select the appropriate channel for interpretation: floor, English or French. As a reminder, all comments should be addressed through the chair. For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. For members on Zoom, please use the \"raise hand\" function. The clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best we can, and we appreciate your patience and understanding in this regard. This meeting was requested pursuant to Standing Order 106(4). The committee is meeting to discuss the committee's investigation of the PrescribeIT program. I will now open the floor to members. I have Mr. Mazier and then Madame Konanz. Mr. Mazier, the floor is yours.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102456","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Good afternoon, everyone. Mr. Mazier, thank you for nominating me, and thank you to all the honourable members for putting your trust in me and electing me as chair of this committee. I have previously chaired committees on both sides of the aisle. People have come to me and made suggestions. I have taken them very seriously. My way of working as chair—and you can ask Tom Kmiec , Brad Redekopp and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54cb3bb8fde03878e10fea681483492bba97e52dddf49425055d0b431499a9b6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ffb2434c075a86a26bbe9c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102457,"date":"2026-04-30T20:40:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"HESA","text":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 30 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. I would like to remind participants of the following points. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic, and please mute yourself when you are not speaking. I remind you that all comments should be addressed through the chair. For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. For members on Zoom, please use the \"raise hand\" function. The clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best as we can. You can also look at the card that is on the table. One thing that I want honourable members to pay attention to here is that crosstalk is not acceptable. That's for the health of the interpreters and so that members get the time they deserve—both sides, not one side. When we have witnesses, sometimes what happens is that a witness goes on a bit too long. If an honourable member wants to stop a witness, they should please raise their hand, and I will stop the clock so we will not take time from the member. We'll let the witness finish, and then we will come back to the honourable member. I hope that is good for everyone. It makes sense. I have done that in the past.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102457","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 30 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. I would like to remind participants of the following points. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15cfe158cfcd33b105edfd7182c66e21396c0f0b261a1f165662f1bafd8c55f5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f54b20d690b5b198d8f1771","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102458,"date":"2026-05-05T20:50:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"HESA","text":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 33 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. As a reminder, all comments should be addressed through the chair. For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. The clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best we can, and we appreciate your patience and understanding in this regard. To the witnesses, I want you to keep an eye on the honourable member who has the floor. As soon as that honourable member raises a hand, I would like you to stop. I don't want any crosstalk, in the best interest of the health of our interpreters. Pursuant to Standing Order 108(2) and the motion adopted on Tuesday, April 15, the committee shall resume its briefing session on PrescribeIT. We will be meeting for a full two hours. I would like to welcome our witnesses. On behalf of the committee members, I would like to welcome, from Canada Health Infoway, Dr. Vaughan, board chair, and Ms. Tania Ensor, strategic adviser; and from Telus Health, Mohamed El-Demerdash, president. Welcome. Each organization will have five minutes for its opening statement. With that, I will start with Dr. Vaughan. You have the floor for five minutes. Please go ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102458","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 33 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. As a reminder, all comments should be addressed through the chair. For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. The clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best we can, and we appreciate your pati","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5b6b493dfa69c9cc7053af9dd2c0c90f9519848c1bba0516ab63a3029b34a747"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a1dbf07c00f1e5dea06ed6b69d75c85cae7a4c4d40f32b74c828a094aaf0921"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d93218cd8a16caf5ef7e63c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102459,"date":"2026-05-07T20:30:00+00:00","title":"HESA","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"HESA","text":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 34 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, please click on the microphone icon to activate your microphone, and please mute yourself when you are not speaking. At the bottom of your screen, you can select the appropriate channel for interpretation: floor audio, English or French. As a reminder, all comments should be addressed through the chair. For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. For members on Zoom, please use the \"raise hand\" function. The clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best we can. We appreciate your patience and understanding in this regard. On behalf of the committee members, I would love to welcome Kristina Tesser Derksen to the committee, and Aslam Rana as well, and earlier, I forgot Jake, who has joined us. Pursuant to Standing Order 108(2) and the motion adopted by the committee on Tuesday, September 23, 2025, the committee shall resume its study of Canada's pharmaceutical sovereignty. On behalf of the committee members, I would like to welcome our witnesses. From the Best Medicines Coalition, we have Kim Steele, who has joined us by video conference. Welcome, Ms. Steele. From the Canadian Health Food Association, we have the vice-president, government relations and regulatory affairs, Ms. Sonia Parmar. Ms. Parmar, welcome. From GPIM, we have the general manager, Stéphane Lévesque. Mr. Lévesque, welcome to the committee. Now I'm going to give the floor to the witnesses in the sequence that I introduced them in. We will give Ms. Steele five minutes, if you're ready, Ms. Steele.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HESA/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102459","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I call this meeting to order. Welcome to meeting number 34 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health. Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, please click on the microphone icon to activate your microphone, and please mute yourself when you","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Audiovisual equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","label":"Audiovisual equipment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b1c51a16753ad6daccc1b1d93ebdd33eeba23fb9407f08d602b6a44bf4fb227"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75afcaca6cf920d380ec9723","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1020444,"date":"2026-05-26T19:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as we celebrated Africa Day yesterday, I would like to recognize the impactful work of Beyond Hoops Africa under the leadership of James Kamau. Rooted in Surrey's African diaspora, this organization represents the power of community-driven development across borders. \n\nThrough initiatives in Kenya, it is expanding access to clean water, building sports facilities and promoting environmental stewardship. Equally important, it is creating meaningful opportunities for Canadians to engage in global citizenship and support sustainable change. Its work reflects the very best of collaboration, compassion and leadership, strengthening ties between Canada and Africa while empowering youth and communities toward a brighter future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020444","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as we celebrated Africa Day yesterday, I would like to recognize the impactful work of Beyond Hoops Africa under the leadership of James Kamau. Rooted in Surrey's African diaspora, this organization represents the power of community-driven development across borders. \n\nThrough initiatives in Kenya, it is expanding access to clean water, building sports facilities and promoting environ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7e76e81eefaf3715f800d28635810914c760f055e0cdd3557cbf6b316f6c1bc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22f32cf43ebd4b3a94f9a67eab9b9ac062997bbd58178a7cacdf519d4c89b07e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-285aac110a19be0622676b22","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1020434,"date":"2026-05-28T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, demand for LNG is growing, and Canada is the cleanest supplier to help meet the demand. During the last election, we committed to making Canada an energy superpower, and we are delivering on that promise. Less than a year ago, LNG Canada delivered its first exports to Asia, and we are already expanding further.\n\nCan the minister update the House on the efforts to expand Canadian LNG exports?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020434","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, demand for LNG is growing, and Canada is the cleanest supplier to help meet the demand. During the last election, we committed to making Canada an energy superpower, and we are delivering on that promise. Less than a year ago, LNG Canada delivered its first exports to Asia, and we are already expanding further.\n\nCan the minister update the House on the efforts to expand Canadian LNG e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["97fb92002b0bfc79c714becb68f5d14d8b9b34636d77d8c90348f1ce183c4b50"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac426f7c311034c539e8ae17c624f4f68d3217a4326eebccccb40353bb0b73f3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b591fd59ce40c126f049920d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037188,"date":"2026-06-03T20:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Conservatives have spent the last week talking down Canada's economy, industries and workers. Meanwhile, our government is making historic investments to grow the economy and strengthen Canada's future, from tens of billions of dollars in infrastructure to reaching NATO's 2% target, and $6 billion for the skilled trades.\n\nCan the minister tell Canadians how these investments are helping us respond to economic headwinds and build a more resilient and prosperous economy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037188","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Conservatives have spent the last week talking down Canada's economy, industries and workers. Meanwhile, our government is making historic investments to grow the economy and strengthen Canada's future, from tens of billions of dollars in infrastructure to reaching NATO's 2% target, and $6 billion for the skilled trades.\n\nCan the minister tell Canadians how these investments are h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f99d538a9c3543bda1d44e47c31b398496bef9f51b12b6262df86e8f9938e75b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d51f1a46bc96fa77d94d669f39ac270443b1d64b1145b3ce3342df376c273cd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95137ce995497e98ea7e11ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102455,"date":"2026-06-04T17:05:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"FINA","text":"Madam Chair, I seek unanimous consent to carry on with this meeting while the bells are ringing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102455","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I seek unanimous consent to carry on with this meeting while the bells are ringing.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97ede2e042c99d470f727c897ddba095f92b976aa7ce83537f4aa5310a2421e8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8645818ebf84bd6582c808b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1084985,"date":"2026-06-11T19:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to recognize Dr. Arun Garg for his lifetime of leadership, service and dedication to improving public health in British Columbia. For more than 50 years, including several decades with Fraser Health, Dr. Garg has advanced culturally informed health care. He has championed prevention, healthy living and community-based care, while bridging traditional knowledge with modern medicine.\n\nAs the founder of Canada India Network Society and a leader of the South Asian Health Institute, Dr. Garg has brought together physicians, researchers and community leaders to improve culturally informed care and healthier living. Dr. Garg's vision, humility and commitment to teamwork have created a legacy for generations to come.\n\nPlease join me in thanking Dr. Arun Garg for his amazing service to our communities and to Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1084985","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to recognize Dr. Arun Garg for his lifetime of leadership, service and dedication to improving public health in British Columbia. For more than 50 years, including several decades with Fraser Health, Dr. Garg has advanced culturally informed health care. He has championed prevention, healthy living and community-based care, while bridging traditional knowledge with modern medic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["431078e7a8214aaa689b5dab8ee097c7cadf3c23b8dc3ef28361c0fe321612b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2bdbdac9cb8ef55a7b8debf759e328f87a9f1677936ebfc57366d1647494a3ad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5cdd8f7db233f67d74f0301","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087167,"date":"2026-06-16T19:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sukh Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour the life and legacy of Rajpaul Singh Dhillon, known as Paul Dhillon, an award-winning journalist, screenwriter, producer and film director whose contributions enriched Canada's cultural landscape and amplified the voices of diverse communities. Through his work, he shared stories that fostered understanding, celebrated heritage and connected people across generations. His dedication to journalism, storytelling and the arts reflected a commitment to truth, creativity and community.\n\nI extend my sincere condolences to his spouse, Harsimrat, and his two children, Muskaan and Ishaan, as well as to all those whose lives he touched.\n\nMay his memory and enduring legacy continue to inspire future generations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087167","member_id":"bc-mp-31098","member_name":"Sukh Dhaliwal","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour the life and legacy of Rajpaul Singh Dhillon, known as Paul Dhillon, an award-winning journalist, screenwriter, producer and film director whose contributions enriched Canada's cultural landscape and amplified the voices of diverse communities. Through his work, he shared stories that fostered understanding, celebrated heritage and connected people across genera","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3d57bec8e000a0be0e0542e9f6468987d43cee99d68974d36a0a75cf780e8d6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f19189aed1c29c8d9603b76","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76527,"date":"2026-01-28T22:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives stand for free trade agreements. Under Harper we had a couple of dozen free trade agreements.\n\nAn hon. member: No.\n\nMarc Dalton: Mr. Speaker, there were a lot.\n\nThe fact is that all these countries, like Indonesia, Vietnam, Malaysia and Taiwan, are very concerned and building up their forces in response to the militarization and threats from China.\n\nThe member talked a bit about China, obviously, but we are concerned that the Liberals are continuing in step with what Trudeau said, that he admired the basic dictatorship of China.\n\nI wonder if the member could make some comments about the Prime Minister talking to the—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76527","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives stand for free trade agreements. Under Harper we had a couple of dozen free trade agreements.\n\nAn hon. member: No.\n\nMarc Dalton: Mr. Speaker, there were a lot.\n\nThe fact is that all these countries, like Indonesia, Vietnam, Malaysia and Taiwan, are very concerned and building up their forces in response to the militarization and threats from China.\n\nThe member talked a b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f54b81ac8a7977c18e43795206eff5e67631167244a7420d51a024bab5945cce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4108685ed6e40cc5e53cd9d1528271035d9d0d7e880ae31524495944e2010049"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bb82f014e557cbd8e7cf727c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76528,"date":"2026-01-29T16:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are paying the price for Liberal economic failure one grocery bill at a time. A friend of mine showed me a flyer last week in which the same meat package was twice the price, with one-third less. Canada has the highest food inflation in the G7. Families are paying $1,000 more this year. Food banks are overwhelmed.\n\nWhy do the Liberals refuse to admit that their industrial carbon tax and reckless deficit spending are driving food prices through the roof and pushing families to the brink?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76528","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are paying the price for Liberal economic failure one grocery bill at a time. A friend of mine showed me a flyer last week in which the same meat package was twice the price, with one-third less. Canada has the highest food inflation in the G7. Families are paying $1,000 more this year. Food banks are overwhelmed.\n\nWhy do the Liberals refuse to admit that their industrial ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","label":"Meat"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","label":"Meat","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76b0ab262593de3e023bfa20a23e7df7980fd0ae823b0097eda1d05be796208a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["80d7731c0db4a2ae48dfbb59f2f0169fc10ae6a527223b3c7bc49c1e99a89a2c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2493ca8cb289ab4be7d25b5a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76529,"date":"2026-01-29T17:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am pleased to present a petition from 11,500 Canadians who are asking that the Liberal government no longer proceed with Bill C-9 but enforce existing laws to protect Canadians. Among other things, they say Bill C-9 lowers the legal standard for hatred with a vague definition, which is confusing and unmeasurable, threatening freedom of speech and expression; that it removes important safeguards, such as requiring Attorney General approval for hate speech charges; and finally, that it will undermine constitutional rights to freedoms of religion, conscience, thought, belief, opinion and expression, and the freedom of press and other mediums of communication.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76529","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am pleased to present a petition from 11,500 Canadians who are asking that the Liberal government no longer proceed with Bill C-9 but enforce existing laws to protect Canadians. Among other things, they say Bill C-9 lowers the legal standard for hatred with a vague definition, which is confusing and unmeasurable, threatening freedom of speech and expression; that it removes import","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd34d180c969cbdd0ab0500c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77390,"date":"2026-02-02T17:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to speak to Bill C-16. It is an important bill, and it is quite disturbing to hear the Liberal parliamentary secretary saying we are filibustering. We are putting up four speakers, a one-hour debate, and he is saying we are trying to push back. We are doing our job. We are here to say where things are good and where there needs to be improvement. That is our job. The Liberals would just prefer that we do not do our job on behalf of Canada. I just wanted to begin with that.\n\nWe believe that job one for the federal government is public safety and security. Historically, Canada has been known as a peaceful and safe place to live. As a matter of fact, in the 1867 Constitution Act, the words are \"Peace, Order, and good Government\". That is what Canadians should expect from the federal government: peace, for public safety; order, for rule of law; and good government, as in competent.\n\nCanada has been known for a number of symbols internationally. The one that is probably most famous is the maple leaf. It is on our flags, everywhere. The second one that would probably be most known internationally would be the RCMP with his red serge, or her red serge, and possibly on one of the horses.\n\nI remember the first time I visited Ottawa. This was in 1973. I came on a school trip from Chibougamau, Quebec. I was very impressed with the buildings and the city. I never dreamed of one day being able to represent the Canadian people as a member of Parliament, specifically the residents of Pitt Meadows—Maple Ridge and Mission, whom I thank for having re-elected me for a third term. I remember in 1973, when I was here, actually getting a coin, a 25¢ coin, and it was the centennial of the formation of the RCMP, which was originally the North-West Mounted Police.\n\nThe reason I bring this up is that the North-West Mounted Police, which later became the RCMP, came and brought order in the west of Canada. There was one fort that members may be aware of, Fort Whoop-Up, where whisky traders from the United States were making a mockery of justice in that part of Canada, so the NWMP was establishing order.\n\nCanada has been known as a peaceful place and a safe place, but this has changed dramatically under the Liberals. I have many interesting conversations with Uber drivers, including late last night. I got in, and the fellow was an immigrant; he told me he was from Brazil. I asked him why he moved here. He said he moved here about nine years ago. He said a big thing for him was safety and security; that was the first thing. I said, \"Oh, really?\" However, he said things have changed, things are changing here in Canada. He says he sees the crime going up, people going to stores, grabbing things, and the police do not seem to be doing anything.\n\nIt was very disappointing to hear this. Canadians are not just making this up. They are not misinformed. Let us look at Statistics Canada since 2015. I choose 2015 because that is the year the Liberals came into power. Human trafficking is up 80%. Sexual assault is up 74%. Violent crime is up more than 50%. I can roll off mathematical percentages, but those stats represent thousands, hundreds of thousands, of victims in our country.\n\nAs a member of Parliament from British Columbia, I see violent crime is, again, up 50% to 85,000 incidences. Sexual assaults are up 97% to 4,396 incidences. Extortion is up 482%, almost 500%, or 2,885 cases in one year. This is under the Liberals. Government makes a difference. Brenda Locke, the mayor of Surrey, asked the government to invoke the Emergencies Act because the police are overwhelmed. People are fleeing the country. There are killings. We had never heard of this sort of thing beforehand. What is going on?\n\n In B.C., again, sexual violations against children are up 294% since the Liberals have been in power, to 2,581 cases. Luring children on a computer has gone up 18 times, to 1,406 incidents. Distributing child pornography is up 776%. This is insane. These are Statistics Canada's numbers. People are afraid on transit, in their neighbourhoods, in their homes and the downtown core. Crime did not rise on its own. It rose because of deliberate Liberal choices and legislation. The deliberate Liberal laws have undermined public safety. \n\nWhat sort of things have they done to undermine it? They say we have Bill C-16, and they are all about safety, order and criminal justice. Well, they have a track record. Under catch-and-release bail, they let criminals go under the least onerous conditions. One-third of homicides in Canada are committed by criminals out on bail. The partner of Bailey McCourt from Kelowna was charged with domestic violence and released on bail. He found the young mother of two in a parking lot and killed her in cold blood two hours later. We have talked about this at different times. The Conservatives brought forward Bailey's law. There are stories across Canada. I talked to the grandmother, who lives in my riding. She told me that she was with Bailey when she took her first breath and she was with her when she took the last breath of life. She is grieving. \n\nThe Liberals also deliberately repealed mandatory minimum sentences. They have claimed that mandatory minimums violate the charter, and the Supreme Court upheld it. There are over 100 mandatory minimums, and they are constitutional. There are weak consequences for violent offenders. There have been 50,000 apprehensions of 40 people in Vancouver in one year. It is a cycle. Police ask me: What is the use? That is under the Liberals' watch. They cannot just wave around Bill C-16 and tell Canadians that everything is good now. They have the wrong criminal justice priorities. \n\nThere is the gun buyback program. Conservatives believe in keeping Canadians safe from criminals, and the Liberals believe in keeping turkeys safe from hunters. One frontline police officer wrote me and said, \"As a police officer, I don't get to voice my opinion publicly. I was hired to enforce the law, not comment on politics.\" He felt compelled to email me. He said the Liberal firearm buyback program is a political distraction, a waste of resources and a danger to public safety. Those were his comments as a frontline professional. Meanwhile, those smuggling guns, repeat offenders and violent criminals walk free. That is not public safety; that is optics. \n\nNow the Liberals wonder why Canadians have lost trust. Bill C-16 needs to be judged in this context. It does not exist in a vacuum. There is every sign of the Liberals calling a snap election, including comments by the member who said Conservatives are filibustering. They are trying to develop a line. They have their trump card, their ace card. It is like they are battering a door in an arena with a flag, getting people riled up. The thing is, though, that they realize they have some vulnerabilities, and one of their biggest vulnerabilities is that they know Canadians are very concerned about public safety. \n\nConservatives support some of the language, some of the things the bill has brought forward, because they are actually Conservative. However, the Liberals have a poison pill. If I had another 20 minutes, I could show how they could very well make things a lot worse for Canadians with this bill. It needs to be changed and to be split. I hope the Liberals will take our advice. We are going to pass Bill C-16 on to committee stage. I very much hope they will take the Conservative recommendations to split the bill and debate our meaningful amendments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77390","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to speak to Bill C-16. It is an important bill, and it is quite disturbing to hear the Liberal parliamentary secretary saying we are filibustering. We are putting up four speakers, a one-hour debate, and he is saying we are trying to push back. We are doing our job. We are here to say where things are good and where there needs to be improvement. That is our job. The Libe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["574b1b32a52e10a0d26768038aae4d066d849a6573c0d5b6788fe5a89da8965e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["35fbf758fac5e6735aae06309e49e07dd2dd7e7a6fd2e09ee44f1f7cafe099b0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37cad3c25e8985db01a37e1b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77391,"date":"2026-02-02T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, like everything the Liberals do, this is about optics and about words. When we dig into it, we see that it is fake, like we are seeing with a lot of their projects. They have said that something is going to happen, but nothing is happening. The Conservatives are very concerned about this.\n\nIt is not about the language being used, because we agree with many of the concerns being brought forward. The language sounds great until we get deeper into the bill and read what is said, buried in the provisions. There is a provision that would allow judges to ignore mandatory minimums if they decide that the sentence would be cruel and unusual. That may sound compassionate, but it is not. It would invite endless litigation and a steady erosion of sentencing law.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77391","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, like everything the Liberals do, this is about optics and about words. When we dig into it, we see that it is fake, like we are seeing with a lot of their projects. They have said that something is going to happen, but nothing is happening. The Conservatives are very concerned about this.\n\nIt is not about the language being used, because we agree with many of the concerns being brough","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5676d17d732e469164a46a408ca06aa4f6f897d04c6284264ecdd773416a44f2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-564bd44be85bfba05b2684e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77392,"date":"2026-02-02T17:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with my colleague from the Bloc Québécois.\n\nThis demonstrates the importance of the economy and how the federal government manages the economy. It has been completely flat for the past ten years under the Liberals. We do not have the resources to do what we should be doing and to invest more, perhaps, in health, security, transportation and all that.\n\nWhat are they doing? They are running ever-larger deficits and the debt is growing. This is terrible for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77392","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with my colleague from the Bloc Québécois.\n\nThis demonstrates the importance of the economy and how the federal government manages the economy. It has been completely flat for the past ten years under the Liberals. We do not have the resources to do what we should be doing and to invest more, perhaps, in health, security, transportation and all that.\n\nWhat are they doing? They","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036438","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nonrenewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036438","label":"Nonrenewable resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["90f761315a0b47e59d64ef1f09dc3cfd892da7049c1c89f76a680926e2ea39ff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be8f6d1552851a9ae4d1bea9b548095d0d6f7dbd5d69702bc894e7da3730edd3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9c5455e6c4ce45808c5c80b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77393,"date":"2026-02-02T17:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a good point from my colleague. We warned the Liberals during the debate on Bill C-5 that repealing mandatory minimums would increase crime and undermine trust, but we were mocked by them four years ago.\n\nSince then, crime is up and fear is up, and Bill C-16 would not correct the course; it would accelerate it. There are some changes, but the bill could be a lot better if the Liberals would take some of our amendments and apply them, and Canadians would be better off because of that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77393","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a good point from my colleague. We warned the Liberals during the debate on Bill C-5 that repealing mandatory minimums would increase crime and undermine trust, but we were mocked by them four years ago.\n\nSince then, crime is up and fear is up, and Bill C-16 would not correct the course; it would accelerate it. There are some changes, but the bill could be a lot better if the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0b83eae30640c864e54f4bf43e2072a31df0a63d412d8193abe3572d3b5932d9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["50d8919c2fe02ea8e037dd455cb2cdc570797baf3402546ae24f0322d0c1cec8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72dc656579a475e0669afca7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77384,"date":"2026-02-04T21:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to present a petition from a number of constituents who are very concerned about the escalating attacks, kidnappings and killings affecting Christians and other communities in parts of Nigeria. These incidents have had devastating humanitarian consequences, including mass displacement of life, destruction of property and places of worship, and an acute insecurity for vulnerable populations.\n\nThe petitioners seek urgent and coordinated international action to protect civilians, uphold human rights and support peaceful coexistence in Nigeria.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77384","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to present a petition from a number of constituents who are very concerned about the escalating attacks, kidnappings and killings affecting Christians and other communities in parts of Nigeria. These incidents have had devastating humanitarian consequences, including mass displacement of life, destruction of property and places of worship, and an acute insecurity for vuln","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ef3a92bca0c9a6b167264633ba4a5c391680f6350abdd2284b52f0efc5c9491"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["27fa90bd0c33b891d57462cb11b8581613371861f5ac70a38c8f81a55c318e85"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5ac41bd1f300e5011b7d6c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77385,"date":"2026-02-04T21:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I also present a petition on behalf of 211 constituents who are concerned about Canada Post's announcement of the elimination of door-to-door service and postal services, which would impact seniors and rural parts of my constituency.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77385","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I also present a petition on behalf of 211 constituents who are concerned about Canada Post's announcement of the elimination of door-to-door service and postal services, which would impact seniors and rural parts of my constituency.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01dc5ad436fb0fa155e8374c1fbf81cae639ec3065148eace9fef6dd2dca5917"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-844409298cb4c2564ceb7966","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304913,"date":"2026-02-26T19:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after 11 years of the Liberal government, the cost of living crisis is crushing young Canadians and seniors alike. \n\nAn RBC poll shows that 64% of millennials are anxious about their future, and 57% have nothing left at month's end. Four in 10 fear that they will never escape their debts. TransUnion Canada reports that household debts have surged to a record $2.6 trillion, driven largely by mortgages as families take on staggering debt just to keep a roof overhead. \n\nToday, the Financial Post reported that only 41% believe they will have enough to retire, with most worried they will not have enough savings to live securely. \n\nSeniors in the communities in my riding are asking how they are supposed to survive with the ever-escalating costs of groceries and everything else. \n\nWhen will the Liberals rein in their inflationary deficits, lower costs and restore an economy where Canadians can finally get ahead?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304913","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after 11 years of the Liberal government, the cost of living crisis is crushing young Canadians and seniors alike. \n\nAn RBC poll shows that 64% of millennials are anxious about their future, and 57% have nothing left at month's end. Four in 10 fear that they will never escape their debts. TransUnion Canada reports that household debts have surged to a record $2.6 trillion, driven larg","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f9a2899ba595a661ba4e9eb4d2875909648f8dc2ddcdf299b9308cfd64d3f65f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4cd02fbc7339e64082cc966b5fae6a69d6de6086d50131b819b773d5cec2922"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d1222a48d33d94f4f82e974","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332112,"date":"2026-03-10T15:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the minister waxes eloquent about the bill and this motion, saying it is the best thing since sliced bread, that there is nothing to worry about and to trust in him. It reminds me of some words of a certain reptile in the The Jungle Book named Kaa, I believe. The minister says, \"Just trust in us. Do not listen to all these religious organizations, all these churches, synagogues and mosques. Just trust in us.\" Well, we do not trust in them at all. They have a track record.\n\nDoes the minister not recognize that there is such a contradiction between them saying they are promoting the protection of religious communities and, at the same time, removing the defence of religious expression, which was put in by Pierre Elliott Trudeau with Bill C-3, the original hate propaganda bill. Does the minister not recognize the concerns of hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of Canadians across Canada, and recognize that we do not trust in them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332112","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the minister waxes eloquent about the bill and this motion, saying it is the best thing since sliced bread, that there is nothing to worry about and to trust in him. It reminds me of some words of a certain reptile in the The Jungle Book named Kaa, I believe. The minister says, \"Just trust in us. Do not listen to all these religious organizations, all these churches, synagogues and mo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b2fc6426bb74f547a25c4926dfb938c6f53cc0d0f41fe560ffbbe8f5d377117"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9baa4ba20e4dca2f81809513","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332113,"date":"2026-03-10T18:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals seem to be quite blind to the impact their legislation would have on freedom of belief, expression and religion. Can the member share whether she agrees that it is not so much blindness but that they really do not care about these rights and would prefer censorship rather than Canadians' having different perspectives, for whatever agenda or ideology they are propagating?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332113","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals seem to be quite blind to the impact their legislation would have on freedom of belief, expression and religion. Can the member share whether she agrees that it is not so much blindness but that they really do not care about these rights and would prefer censorship rather than Canadians' having different perspectives, for whatever agenda or ideology they are propagating?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1d1476060bafd08c6b64450f3c5c0de1728c8c4540994c778ec3300defe7d30"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fee3eac1515c135b78e982ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332114,"date":"2026-03-10T18:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, yesterday, coming from the airport, I had the cab driver tell me, unsolicited, that he wanted Israel wiped off the map, and I have to assume Jews also.\n\nWhat we are seeing in Canada is an 800% increase in hate speech. This craziness has happened under the Liberal watch in every respect. An Iranian dissident I knew was killed in Vancouver last month. This is going on.\n\nThe Liberals have not been enforcing the laws that are there, so they come up with this bill that censors religious speech. I wonder if the member could speak to the fact that the Conservatives wanted to split the bill to keep the crime pieces in and move out the censorship aspect.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332114","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, yesterday, coming from the airport, I had the cab driver tell me, unsolicited, that he wanted Israel wiped off the map, and I have to assume Jews also.\n\nWhat we are seeing in Canada is an 800% increase in hate speech. This craziness has happened under the Liberal watch in every respect. An Iranian dissident I knew was killed in Vancouver last month. This is going on.\n\nThe Liberals hav","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd7fbc5cac0ddfcc434afeb439b53832a07fcf632feb81bed548afcc29e2d034"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f37fba8d055119ad8875f71c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332111,"date":"2026-03-11T19:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, conflict in the Middle East is not new, but never have we seen it spill onto the streets of Canada in the way it has under the Liberal government. By politicizing foreign conflicts and pushing a soft-on-crime agenda, the Liberals have left Jewish and Iranian Canadians feeling unsafe in their own communities. Last week alone, three synagogues in the greater Toronto area were shot at. Canadians have heard enough of the condemnations and the endless empty words. Words are not enough.\n\nThe truth is that terrorists operate on our streets while the laws already on the books go unenforced. Now, an Iranian dissident in Vancouver, someone I knew personally, has gone missing, and police fear he was killed, yet successive Liberal immigration and public safety ministers have failed to stop hundreds of known, active IRGC agents from living here. Why will the government not deport them now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332111","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, conflict in the Middle East is not new, but never have we seen it spill onto the streets of Canada in the way it has under the Liberal government. By politicizing foreign conflicts and pushing a soft-on-crime agenda, the Liberals have left Jewish and Iranian Canadians feeling unsafe in their own communities. Last week alone, three synagogues in the greater Toronto area were shot at. C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ede91ad8c83781dbf528e4e2b8f2ffdc1389b8a1dc1747b7a9f51dc43f6c48f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa5464974674a148f4053d8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":376926,"date":"2026-03-24T16:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, over the past 10 years of Liberal governance, the number of vehicles produced has declined from 2.3 million to 1.2 million. Exports have dropped significantly in the past year.\n\nCan the Bloc Québécois member comment on those numbers? Does he know how far the number of cars in Quebec has fallen over the past 10 years and what impact that has had? Can he comment on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:376926","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, over the past 10 years of Liberal governance, the number of vehicles produced has declined from 2.3 million to 1.2 million. Exports have dropped significantly in the past year.\n\nCan the Bloc Québécois member comment on those numbers? Does he know how far the number of cars in Quebec has fallen over the past 10 years and what impact that has had? Can he comment on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2cf115ba1d3948dc61e2ee374726678da3e0556ada4a536a0193a381f40da777"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dcc0e54681c343dfb0735e5a590fd0be91b39f0b46884c580b4c9c61a2936521"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61d7091be75e0a8e5762f3bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":376927,"date":"2026-03-24T16:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Sainte‐Thérèse was once home to an auto manufacturing facility, and even though Quebec no longer manufactures cars, it remains a very important industry in that province. Parts and engines are still manufactured there, for example. Thousands of workers are employed in that industry.\n\nCan the Bloc Québécois comment on the impact that the Liberal's policy is having on Quebec and on this staggering decline of more than a million cars? Although vehicles are not fully assembled in Quebec, this does have an impact on parts manufacturing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:376927","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Sainte‐Thérèse was once home to an auto manufacturing facility, and even though Quebec no longer manufactures cars, it remains a very important industry in that province. Parts and engines are still manufactured there, for example. Thousands of workers are employed in that industry.\n\nCan the Bloc Québécois comment on the impact that the Liberal's policy is having on Quebec and on this","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a4128ca4955af398047522ab4432e986b94f85d539824db6035fa812c06fb71"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d2baa07fd711c7e7163664dd18e7fd6f95baae3351bc22491f81820d7fdcab2c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee4686071214b295673c74a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419420,"date":"2026-04-13T16:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker I spoke with Bailey's grandmother, who lives in my riding, who heartbrokenly told me that she was with Bailey the day she was born, for her first breath, and was with her when she took her last breath.\n\n I just wonder if the member could tell us how we as legislators can justify not strengthening protections for victims through measures like Bailey's law to ensure that dangerous offenders are not given opportunities to reoffend and to murder an intimate partner.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419420","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker I spoke with Bailey's grandmother, who lives in my riding, who heartbrokenly told me that she was with Bailey the day she was born, for her first breath, and was with her when she took her last breath.\n\n I just wonder if the member could tell us how we as legislators can justify not strengthening protections for victims through measures like Bailey's law to ensure that dangerous offend","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48e2a094485e8f26fc8e9b34a25d2ef5026dd13d4d9bd6db00fcf8b3ca2edc7c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cef581b63724f6cca2eef2cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419419,"date":"2026-04-14T19:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are under immense economic strain, and now the Liberal government has jeopardized the very foundation of home ownership. The Cowichan decision and secret Musqueam agreement have cast a dark shadow over private property rights. By failing to defend fee simple ownership in court and dropping key legal arguments, the government has sparked fear and financial chaos. Appraisers are warning that affected property values could plunge 40%. Financing is drying up and projects are already being cancelled. This is a massive failure of leadership. \n\nConservatives are calling on the Prime Minister to reinstate a strong legal defence of private property, ensure all agreements unmistakably protect ownership, deliver a clear plan within 30 days and immediately convene a parliamentary committee.\n\nCanadians deserve certainty and security, not empty words. The government must protect Canadian homes and restore confidence now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419419","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are under immense economic strain, and now the Liberal government has jeopardized the very foundation of home ownership. The Cowichan decision and secret Musqueam agreement have cast a dark shadow over private property rights. By failing to defend fee simple ownership in court and dropping key legal arguments, the government has sparked fear and financial chaos. Appraisers a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f42e8a35b1012cecf0465b663ab07b7b7db3f65eb0560e22201abff458955547"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ac8ef786b60d89fe74a125cba05bd47ca70a2ba31d03b628a8298424161d8da"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-014b4ad5d30cbaa658b08922","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419416,"date":"2026-04-16T15:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have three petitions to present on behalf of my constituents from Pitt Meadows—Maple Ridge and Mission.\n\n The first one regards Bill C-218. The petitioners state that Canadians with mental illness should be provided with treatment and support. They state that mental illness is complex and includes suicidal thoughts as a symptom. The lives of Canadians with mental illness will be at risk when they are eligible for medical assistance in dying on the basis of mental illness alone, especially when treatment and support are not readily available.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419416","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have three petitions to present on behalf of my constituents from Pitt Meadows—Maple Ridge and Mission.\n\n The first one regards Bill C-218. The petitioners state that Canadians with mental illness should be provided with treatment and support. They state that mental illness is complex and includes suicidal thoughts as a symptom. The lives of Canadians with mental illness will be at ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","label":"Suicide"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","label":"Suicide","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c24e577c99757659b99130833d468cba51ef96c42b8470ab2404ba0ecfe5aff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0e50e9379339624c908872d7f20c7b3bd622a423ae06b27f95b5e2c349023e44"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e2c9359c1ec72a22acc161fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419417,"date":"2026-04-16T15:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I am presenting is in regard to Bill C-9.\n\nThe petitioners state they are concerned that the Liberal and Bloc amendments to Bill C-9 could be used to criminalize passages from the Bible, the Koran, the Torah and other sacred texts. The petitioners state that the government has no place in religious texts or teachings of any faith community, and that freedom of expression and religion are fundamental rights that must be preserved.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419417","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I am presenting is in regard to Bill C-9.\n\nThe petitioners state they are concerned that the Liberal and Bloc amendments to Bill C-9 could be used to criminalize passages from the Bible, the Koran, the Torah and other sacred texts. The petitioners state that the government has no place in religious texts or teachings of any faith community, and that freedom of expr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33e070d9f689bb9361792a711db52203d1a3b7f0fd34e3bbb817cd9d23777fe9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eadd4aa789d9e38311810314052f383925e1defd79dfcc2c5054928bf6a439af"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a97bf24cbb5cbe3a928b6aca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419418,"date":"2026-04-16T15:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the last petition regards post office closures, the axing of long-treasured postal services, particularly for those in remote and Indigenous communities, and the impact upon seniors. The petitioners are calling on the government to revisit its cutbacks on these important services.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419418","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the last petition regards post office closures, the axing of long-treasured postal services, particularly for those in remote and Indigenous communities, and the impact upon seniors. The petitioners are calling on the government to revisit its cutbacks on these important services.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19dd57fcea33023c79877fd3e52e2b4cc54035317271a114da5786686e262abb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97f2dac4174a98eabdd0c5cf0a53f2d6c3429b2d59fbcb959073612d9f7a9d52"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4cde56b56011c6709f4c8fbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102879,"date":"2026-04-21T22:30:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"I just want to say that the president had several years to learn a few words to communicate or to read in French. He was familiar with the laws and the importance of having a good command of the French language. He knew all that. I think that's an important point, but I also understand what my colleague is saying.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102879","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I just want to say that the president had several years to learn a few words to communicate or to read in French. He was familiar with the laws and the importance of having a good command of the French language. He knew all that. I think that's an important point, but I also understand what my colleague is saying.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15d8997f545625e5009d14f32306defb1b725b97c18d4f232908480e7a2b3ed8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10126ec3c20b77ddc4f8e651","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102877,"date":"2026-04-23T16:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. Thank you to the witnesses for joining us today. I had a conversation last week with somebody who had sent in an email. I gave him a call. He was very shaken. He was actually breaking down in the conversation. He was talking about the challenges that he and others are facing with the cost of living and other challenges. He was talking about the current government and how its policies are impacting everyday Canadians. He challenged me. He said, \"Marc, you need to get your voice out there and speak to this, because it's hurting us. These policies are hurting us.\" We can live in our ivory towers, and we get our government paycheques, but everyday people who are relying on jobs, working hard and not just receiving from the government, are struggling. I'd like to direct this question to Ms. Swift. The industrial carbon tax is an extra cost. The Liberals have argued with us saying that the carbon tax, among many other things, but let's talk specifically about the industrial carbon tax, does not impact food costs, that it doesn't impact the cost of living. However, people in British Columbia, where I live and where things have been stagnating for the past decade under this Liberal government and under the NDP government, have been struggling. I see that. Can you make some comments, please, just on this one issue of the industrial carbon tax and its impact on the cost of living and food? Then we can expand a little more.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102877","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Thank you to the witnesses for joining us today. I had a conversation last week with somebody who had sent in an email. I gave him a call. He was very shaken. He was actually breaking down in the conversation. He was talking about the challenges that he and others are facing with the cost of living and other challenges. He was talking about the current government and how its policies ar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df241f4d760fa103597136308c9a0b026ecda121ab4bff9a29f4e788b8e0490a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["58236636b060d0ab7fb37633351b8d4b3178b0188b24ce93c1cd5466ff348b52"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67e0ddef5ce2a79babdb1b9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102878,"date":"2026-04-23T16:55:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you very much. I visit businesses and industries across British Columbia, including on Vancouver Island. They are in forestry, fishing and manufacturing. We're seeing mills closing down. We're seeing thousands of people losing their jobs. We've seen that happen in my community of Maple Ridge. The largest mill, Hammond mill, closed down a number of years ago. We're talking to these people, the owners who have moved their businesses elsewhere. As you mentioned, they'll keep a shell in British Columbia, or in Canada, but they're moving out because it's a much better investment. Can you speak a bit more to how, among other things—I know you mentioned regulations—the industrial carbon tax is impacting our competitiveness and the job market?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102878","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I visit businesses and industries across British Columbia, including on Vancouver Island. They are in forestry, fishing and manufacturing. We're seeing mills closing down. We're seeing thousands of people losing their jobs. We've seen that happen in my community of Maple Ridge. The largest mill, Hammond mill, closed down a number of years ago. We're talking to these people, th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["36e6c2024308bed9d672aefea04d893aabeae5c723777341c38e7423fdc44971"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d6990f02f83847d7e1efd904163331d0e5474db178340580b312d7987204105"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-367d564137042edf323ef5cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723100,"date":"2026-04-30T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a national disgrace that 80% of Canadians now say that food is their fastest-rising expense, and one in three are forced to borrow money just to eat. The Liberal government continues merrily on its way with its costly spending, forcing parents to make difficult choices at the grocery store. History shows that, as nations prosper, people eat better, but under the Liberals, Canadians are cutting back on meat and essential nutrition.\n\n When will the Prime Minister end his costly credit card budgeting, so all Canadians can afford to eat properly?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723100","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a national disgrace that 80% of Canadians now say that food is their fastest-rising expense, and one in three are forced to borrow money just to eat. The Liberal government continues merrily on its way with its costly spending, forcing parents to make difficult choices at the grocery store. History shows that, as nations prosper, people eat better, but under the Liberals, Canadi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","label":"Nutrition"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","label":"Nutrition","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e85c0b949360302f244dc33651c0e8e67403af8974606d5709d49b48707d631"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca0971122bc4fe68201612d915d77ae67c385403f851ba63490596a6319e6fe0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-561acc010b9c3884e47dd8c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102923,"date":"2026-05-04T16:05:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. Thank you to the witnesses for sharing their experiences with us. Ms. MacIsaac, my story is similar to yours. My father was in the Royal Canadian Air Force. He was from Alberta, and I too am Métis. We're probably related because my family is also from around Lac Ste. Anne and the area north of there. It's nice to meet you. My father spent 36 years in the armed forces. He joined during the Korean War. I'm a veteran as well. I was a reservist for a while. We always knew we were indigenous, but we didn't talk about it much. Before he died, I asked my father why he hadn't been more open about the fact that he was Métis, and he said that it wouldn't have helped him at all. That was the situation. Back then, people's attitudes towards indigenous people were much more negative. I'm happy to see that things are changing. That's very important. I am a citizen of Métis Nation British Columbia, and I have family in Alberta. I'm also a francophone. My mother is francophone, and she encouraged me to learn French. As a teenager, I resisted, but I made the effort to learn later in life. That brings me to my question. Have you seen significant changes? I believe you said you've been in the Canadian Armed Forces, or CAF, for 25 years.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102923","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Thank you to the witnesses for sharing their experiences with us. Ms. MacIsaac, my story is similar to yours. My father was in the Royal Canadian Air Force. He was from Alberta, and I too am Métis. We're probably related because my family is also from around Lac Ste. Anne and the area north of there. It's nice to meet you. My father spent 36 years in the armed forces. He joine","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["443dc374752f45f4c246903de947d27af885bc74dbd46cf3700f1909c944bdad"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06f4ead1af7d1170f931fa8ad9948104ff0cbdc23d5c576bd64303459bf0f9d0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4278d048caa5dec3511a5749","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102924,"date":"2026-05-04T16:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"NDDN","text":"That can't be. In the military world, have you seen the attitude towards indigenous, first nations, Métis or francophone people change? Has it always been the same, or has there been a change?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102924","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That can't be. In the military world, have you seen the attitude towards indigenous, first nations, Métis or francophone people change? Has it always been the same, or has there been a change?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c353716ef9e0b894989bccdb55d8ccc756bb32f874ed482b26c41c29463fcf12"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ec0173d9b9d2b9d814e5535","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102925,"date":"2026-05-04T16:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. Thank you to both of you for your service. I'm wondering, Madam Eisan, about the Canadian Rangers program. How many are there? I don't have the numbers. What component is indigenous? Are we seeing a transition of those who are involved in the rangers in the Northwest Territories moving into the regular forces? Has that been beneficial?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102925","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Thank you to both of you for your service. I'm wondering, Madam Eisan, about the Canadian Rangers program. How many are there? I don't have the numbers. What component is indigenous? Are we seeing a transition of those who are involved in the rangers in the Northwest Territories moving into the regular forces? Has that been beneficial?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-092ff7a8b47027b72e8a1cc1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102926,"date":"2026-05-04T16:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's good to hear. I mean it wasn't good that it wasn't recognized, but that there's a change that the reservists' time is counting, and it certainly should be applying to this also. I see we have come to the end, but I'll just put a question out there. The last time, the committee heard that indigenous enrolment was far below target and that officials have clear statistics on indigenous representation at the general and flag officers senior leadership level. From your perspective, what should DND and CAF be focusing on? You may want to weave that into one of your responses. If you have a quick response, go ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102926","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's good to hear. I mean it wasn't good that it wasn't recognized, but that there's a change that the reservists' time is counting, and it certainly should be applying to this also. I see we have come to the end, but I'll just put a question out there. The last time, the committee heard that indigenous enrolment was far below target and that officials have clear statistics on indigenous represe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83e6dc5d69a60a6f9830a4ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102927,"date":"2026-05-04T16:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102927","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83bd67157a84b1cfb6ec343b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752120,"date":"2026-05-04T22:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this debate is an important one. I was reflecting, as I was preparing my comments, on the new Liberal majority. I thank the members of Parliament who double-crossed the voters who elected them one year ago. We are in a situation now where the Liberals have their cherished majority government.\n\nI was thinking of this new age, and I had a flashback of when I was in grade 3 and living on a small military base in north Vancouver Island called Holberg. I was a proud member of Gary's Singing Worms. There was a song we sang. You are probably too young to remember it, Mr. Speaker. It was called The Age of Aquarius. It was a hit in the Broadway production Hair. Some of us have been losing our hair in the meantime.\n\nI will not sing the song. Some members might know the words, but I will refresh everyone's memory. It came out in 1969, the \"flower power\" era of love and peace. Some of the words are as follows:\n\nThis is the dawning of the Age of AquariusAge of AquariusAquariusAquariusHarmony and understandingSympathy and trust aboundingNo more falsehoods or derisionGolden living dreams of visions\n\nI have some words that could very well have been penned by the Liberal Prime Minister. They have the same tune:\n\nThis is the dawning of the Age of Majority,Our Majority, Liberal MajorityHarmony? We can stop pretendingQuestions asked will be met with no bendingMore secrecy and more derisionOne-Party rule with tunnel vision\n\nCommittees bring recommendationsWe Liberals will ignore consultationsNo more listening or debateJust whipped votes, no need to waitLovely Majority, Liberal Majority\n\nI am surprised that my Liberal colleagues are not clapping at that.\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nMarc Dalton: Mr. Speaker, we have moved into a new realm of secrecy and of control. The Liberal member is sighing, as if it were not true, but he knows it is true.\n\nWhat was the first thing the Liberals did when they got their majority last week? They moved several committees in camera, into secrecy, and shut down debate on things that are uncomfortable for them. Even the Liberal media organ, the CBC, now that the Liberals are established, is perplexed and critical of this move and says this is sending the wrong message.\n\nWe are seeing the same attitude in the Liberals' imposing closure on debate on this important bill. They have shown their true colours toward victims of sexual harassment in the military with how they have pushed through and are pushing through Bill C-11 without the amendments that were passed at committee. That is very unfortunate. It really boils down to control and secrecy, and we will talk a bit more about that.\n\nThis debate should not be about procedure. It must not be about politics. It must be about the survivors. It must be about veterans and serving members of the Canadian Armed Forces who came before the Standing Committee on National Defence and did something extraordinarily brave. They relived some of the most painful moments of their lives, publicly and on record, because they believed that Parliament was finally prepared to listen.\n\nLet us imagine someone's testifying about one of the worst experiences of their life and then having the government refuse to listen to their voice. They testified about sexual assault. They testified about betrayal by institutions they trusted. They testified about being silenced. Above all, they testified about choice: the right to choose which justice, military or civilian, would be most effective and where they could see justice served.\n\n Therefore, I ask the House this: Why is the government now moving to shut down debate on Bill C-11 before those concerns are fully and honestly addressed? The government tells Canadians that the bill is about supporting victims and restoring trust. If that is true, why are the ministers afraid of scrutiny? Why impose time allocation on legislation that would directly affect survivors of military sexual trauma?\n\nIf the government is confident that the bill reflects what survivors want and need, then let Parliament test that. Let the arguments be heard. Let victims know that their voices matter, not just at committee but also here in the House, where laws are made.\n\nThis is about choice. People asked for a system that treats them with dignity, not suspicion. At committee, we listened. Conservatives worked constructively across party lines, with colleagues from the Bloc and the NDP, to improve Bill C-11. Together we brought forward amendments rooted directly in witness testimony, especially the nearly universal request that the victims of military sexual assault be able to choose which justice system they report to. That is what collaboration looks like. That is what respect for survivors looks like.\n\n However, that stands in stark contrast to the Liberal government's approach. For months, the bill has sat idle. The government did not act. It did not engage meaningfully with victims. Then, only after securing a political procedural advantage, the government moved to rush the bill through and undo the very amendments survivors had fought for.\n\nThis is not leadership. This is political expediency. I can understand why the Liberals are this way, because they have gotten in a lot of trouble around the issue of sexual harassment in the military. I think of Harjit Sajjan. He was censured publicly at the House of Commons in 2021 around the issue of the cover-up of sexual harassment. This is a shame.\n\nWhat are the Liberals doing? There is an expression for that.\n\nThe more things change, the more they stay the same.\n\nThe more it changes, the more it is the same. It is the same old, same old. Actually, it is not the same old, same old. It is getting worse. The Liberals would now give the minister the power to intervene and have his way. This would be superseding justice. That is not good, because it is political expedience and political cover-up. This is not what Canadians need, and it is not what the members of the armed forces need. It is a shame.\n\nInstead of increasing the independence of military prosecutors, defence counsel and the provost marshal, the minister would ensure that these roles would remain under political and institutional control. This would do nothing to prevent sexual misconduct. It would deepen the mistrust.\n\nThere is an expression by former British prime minister William Gladstone in which he said, \"Justice delayed is justice denied.\" Gladstone was a prime minister of the U.K. at the time of the Confederation of Canada, the 1860s. It basically says that if legal remedy comes too late, it means that people are getting no justice at all. That is what is happening. The Liberals would be putting the cases into the civilian courts, but the courts are already clogged up.\n\nI was at a home show in Maple Ridge over the weekend and talked to hundreds of people, including police officers and people in justice. They were telling me that people are being arrested and the prosecutors are not moving the cases forward because the courts are jammed full. It is taking so long that they are releasing people. This is what the Liberals' solution is: just to put the matter through into a jammed-up system where they can bury it and protect themselves. This is about self-protection and self-preservation. Shame on them.\n\n Let us get a bill that really reflects what has been brought forward by the witnesses, to protect and help our armed forces and those who have suffered sexual assault.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752120","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this debate is an important one. I was reflecting, as I was preparing my comments, on the new Liberal majority. I thank the members of Parliament who double-crossed the voters who elected them one year ago. We are in a situation now where the Liberals have their cherished majority government.\n\nI was thinking of this new age, and I had a flashback of when I was in grade 3 and living on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7f3df3b09ae4e505c8383fca28f7388f7dc99203a5612f386d7badcbe620a8e8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["716497305e265100bbcb8f0b3d7dafbf45581e590da896ca800c24423bd83fa7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2bb7f5d60e0a930ab0a934b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752122,"date":"2026-05-04T22:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we support choice for the victims in where they can see the quickest route to justice. Right now the civilian system is really clogged up. What we believe in is choice, not just for victims in Canada but also internationally in the military.\n\nYou made reference to the report. You mentioned a few times Madam Arbour—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752122","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we support choice for the victims in where they can see the quickest route to justice. Right now the civilian system is really clogged up. What we believe in is choice, not just for victims in Canada but also internationally in the military.\n\nYou made reference to the report. You mentioned a few times Madam Arbour—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed79bc4748e090841a115dce7f15483f66824e18c36c006070a05a409b6f53dd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-456a24ecd659b0c5ab2db8e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752123,"date":"2026-05-04T22:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a rookie error, but I am not a rookie.\n\nMadam Arbour was asked to come to committee to testify. She did not come to committee. We wanted her to respond to the reports, to witnesses and to other reports that have also been done, the Deschamps report and the Fish report. She would not respond.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752123","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a rookie error, but I am not a rookie.\n\nMadam Arbour was asked to come to committee to testify. She did not come to committee. We wanted her to respond to the reports, to witnesses and to other reports that have also been done, the Deschamps report and the Fish report. She would not respond.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-497341b84d96c53f543f869a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752124,"date":"2026-05-04T22:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member is absolutely right. What the Liberals are doing in such a serious matter is appalling. To protect their own interests, they are putting their politics ahead of the pain of victims and respect for justice. What they are doing is really terrible.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752124","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member is absolutely right. What the Liberals are doing in such a serious matter is appalling. To protect their own interests, they are putting their politics ahead of the pain of victims and respect for justice. What they are doing is really terrible.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10a4217b8e86d46c5a615e2b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752126,"date":"2026-05-04T22:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it was meant as provocation. They put the floor crossers right next to the Prime Minister. We see the people who have crossed the floor. It seems as though the Liberals are showing off their trophies. The floor crossers have no shame, just like the Liberals.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752126","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it was meant as provocation. They put the floor crossers right next to the Prime Minister. We see the people who have crossed the floor. It seems as though the Liberals are showing off their trophies. The floor crossers have no shame, just like the Liberals.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bde627583e58d2074d05b6cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102880,"date":"2026-05-05T20:55:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Does that mean you're going to vote with us in harmony? Voices: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102880","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does that mean you're going to vote with us in harmony? Voices: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["08c55f0dc51d864c8ac6b180911474911b013b97818a1ee3033e883b860d78f1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f756f14d819f5f2123245300","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102881,"date":"2026-05-05T21:15:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Can we give the witnesses more time since we're losing time due to technical reasons?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102881","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Can we give the witnesses more time since we're losing time due to technical reasons?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hearing disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","label":"Hearing disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67dc4b10f55eae04e47a6124688004beb3f36d71812c486a1da42aace7408bc0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-092ebd14c85e22bb900bb259","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102882,"date":"2026-05-05T21:40:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Ms. Boyer, thank you for being here. It's always a pleasure to see you. I will continue along the same lines as my colleagues. As a member of Parliament from British Columbia, I would like to know if there are any regions in that province with a strong francophone presence where these regulations will apply.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102882","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Ms. Boyer, thank you for being here. It's always a pleasure to see you. I will continue along the same lines as my colleagues. As a member of Parliament from British Columbia, I would like to know if there are any regions in that province with a strong francophone presence where these regulations will apply.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["175a06016add299de421e7a62f6df0f0dadbbebf1cc16b2a196b9fedcdf6d3ae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02d2365d48d8d1e7f78ddd49","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102883,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"You mentioned western Canada, specifically Manitoba, Alberta and Saskatchewan, where there are two regions with strong francophone presence, such as Beausejour, Saint-Boniface and the Bonnyville area. How will you determine whether the regulations apply in Edmonton and Bonnyville, for example?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102883","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You mentioned western Canada, specifically Manitoba, Alberta and Saskatchewan, where there are two regions with strong francophone presence, such as Beausejour, Saint-Boniface and the Bonnyville area. How will you determine whether the regulations apply in Edmonton and Bonnyville, for example?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43fbda528b1927a3675b44242f0285c41f11fa886e5c58bd3f3f2d9dee3d5b3a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98b022d07d651045999bc720","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102884,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"I'm sure the campus will be ready to do that. Minister Miller talked about \"significant upfront costs\". Can you elaborate on what \"significant\" is? What are the regulations? Have you projected what some of the costs would be for different sizes of companies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102884","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sure the campus will be ready to do that. Minister Miller talked about \"significant upfront costs\". Can you elaborate on what \"significant\" is? What are the regulations? Have you projected what some of the costs would be for different sizes of companies?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7744b7118db1fa4a75eae217d3bd1ca752027fe754dc942e9969b4ea7a5e6a90"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1af6bc0f9718f62fae4c0ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102885,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"My question isn't so much about the government costs. It's more about the costs for the businesses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102885","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My question isn't so much about the government costs. It's more about the costs for the businesses.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["851dd45648b7b8ac5138c38a3d559fee5c31052e9cb27adc425552a3881c324d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31e90ffd3f521469e3b21df0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102886,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"If you could have this submitted to the committee, that would be interesting.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102886","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If you could have this submitted to the committee, that would be interesting.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79bbd0e704052acfb945afc6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102887,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Okay. For companies that have 25 employees in Quebec and, say, 1,000 outside, these laws apply to the entire company. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102887","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. For companies that have 25 employees in Quebec and, say, 1,000 outside, these laws apply to the entire company. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26d49ff5de1ee4fca276b1528ae784e41cd1e7265526a4eca800b81e3db7d353"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9effef5e220c65d5852768df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102888,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"No, it's not if they're based.... If they have a unit in Quebec, even of just 25 employees, does it apply to their entire operation across the country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102888","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"No, it's not if they're based.... If they have a unit in Quebec, even of just 25 employees, does it apply to their entire operation across the country?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["495999b8773581bb88e5a86518300a0d1d57714aab0baa682e088c6cf3a9525b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dcad6725f4410de71efccb30","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102889,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Will this make some companies a little more hesitant to expand into Quebec if it's just a small office, because it would apply everywhere else? Do you see that as an issue?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102889","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Will this make some companies a little more hesitant to expand into Quebec if it's just a small office, because it would apply everywhere else? Do you see that as an issue?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d05ca0b8e4e6f078798d9f6266ed6e4788cf1adb1085fa6f525cc823a1145ac"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b09484ea5ba3f1176d65c24","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102890,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"If a company is in a region with a strong francophone presence, the regulations would apply if it has 100 employees. Do you think there might be people who would oppose the idea of hiring a French-speaking person that would impose these responsibilities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102890","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If a company is in a region with a strong francophone presence, the regulations would apply if it has 100 employees. Do you think there might be people who would oppose the idea of hiring a French-speaking person that would impose these responsibilities?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["39ea15ebb10e148c6fba92b12aed15f7d074fd3a9d194a5d77236b01e7f033e4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2ef0aa0c4c1fc04d60c0e7c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102891,"date":"2026-05-05T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102891","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08e6e90e1081b644cbd146f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752117,"date":"2026-05-07T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbians bought their homes, paid their mortgages and followed the law, but because the Liberal government directed its lawyers not to argue for property rights in the Cowichan case, the judge did not protect private property.\n\nIn 2019, the Liberal government issued a directive called litigation guideline number 14, which discourages federal lawyers from defending property rights in court. The Liberal Prime Minister has kept that guideline in place. In fact, it is still on the government's website today.\n\nWhy do the Liberals continue to tell lawyers not to defend homeowners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752117","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbians bought their homes, paid their mortgages and followed the law, but because the Liberal government directed its lawyers not to argue for property rights in the Cowichan case, the judge did not protect private property.\n\nIn 2019, the Liberal government issued a directive called litigation guideline number 14, which discourages federal lawyers from defending property r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a022fb9170161473dda43b2c953d87fc83a4c506664a05ff5a2b2faec720d64d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fb5e6fff55c0fc9b87fa8a96252dde65c724d12213472f238334fc1962d72aa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0174913957e1b86cb042daed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752118,"date":"2026-05-07T22:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are talking today about a very important issue that is impacting all British Columbians and has implications for all Canadians: property rights.\n\n In the 2021 census, two-thirds, about 66.8%, of British Columbian households owned their own home, and it was about the same throughout the country. One-third were renters, and a good many of those renters wanted to eventually own. It has become increasingly difficult during the past decade under the Liberals due to the cost of housing, rising inflation and less and less disposable income to pay for things like groceries, gas and taxes, let alone a down payment on a home.\n\nPeople work hard to pay down their mortgages. It can take decades. I remember one worker I spoke to not that long ago telling me that he was working seven days a week, and very long days, just to keep a roof over his family's head and to keep their home. \"It is nothing fancy\", he told me. He said that he could not give his body a break.\n\n I think of myself when I was a new teacher buying a condo, working long hours, extra hours, for money to go towards the mortgage. I think of seniors who have spent a lifetime paying down their mortgage and want to use their house as a nest egg to provide financial resources and security for their retirement and pass it on to their children and grandchildren. I do not like saying this, but this is being undermined today. \n\nIn British Columbia, we sometimes have small earthquakes, we have not had a large for probably over 100 years, but I have felt them. There are tremors, foreshocks and aftershocks. The foreshocks around the world sometimes indicate that a big one is coming and should not be ignored. However, with private property rights, there are some shocks happening. The Liberals can just ignore them and say that nothing is happening. \"It is the same old, same old\" is what we hear from them, but there is something dangerous looming, and it is already here.\n\nPrivate property rights are often considered one of the foundational elements of a free and stable economy. It is important, because it impacts people's economic freedom, their personal security and investment. For generations, Canadians have understood a basic principle: If they lawfully purchase a home, if they hold title to their property, if they invest their life savings into a piece of land, and not just their life savings, but their sweat and work, then the law protects that ownership. It is certainly not a privilege. It is one of the cornerstones of democratic society. It is what allows families to build a future. It allows farmers to invest in their land. It allows businesses to create jobs and communities to grow. \n\nWhere there is uncertainty in property rights, confidence erodes, investment dries up, families hesitate and communities stagnate. This is a big concern.\n\nI had a booth at a home show over the past weekend for several days and talked to hundreds of people. The topic of property rights came up over and over again, unsolicited. It is not just what the Liberals call \"fearmongering\". It is what people are feeling in the community. It is not some bad dream they are having. It is reality. There are things happening, and the Liberals have been asleep at the switch, which is an old expression. The Liberals are more than asleep. Their incompetence is a key reason that we find ourselves in the mess we are in.\n\nLast August, the Cowichan Tribes v. Canada decision of the B.C. Supreme Court threatened the private property rights of landowners in British Columbia and potentially in other provinces. In one act, the judge deemed the aboriginal title had prior and senior rights over fee simple home ownership, like over 800 acres in Richmond worth a billion dollars. It is setting a precedent that other judgments can be made on. That is the concern. That is a big concern. It sets a precedent that can expand. It is already serious enough. This ruling has shaken the foundations of British Columbia's economy and sparked fear among landowners province-wide.\n\nAs Conservatives, we are bringing this up. We are hearing what communities, like Richmond, and the owners are saying. I have met with farmers who have spent generations on their land, clearing, working and spending money. This is all being threatened and the Liberals pooh-pooh us. They say we are just barking up a tree. We are not barking up a tree. This is serious and they need to take it seriously. They cannot just say it is in the court's hands, that we need to forget about it and just go back to sleep. We are not going to. We are going to fight for this. We are going to fight for landowners. We are going to fight for homeowners. We are going to fight for our communities. We are going to try to wake up the Liberals because they have gotten us into this situation.\n\nBritish Columbians bought their homes, paid their mortgages and followed the law, but because the Liberal government directed its lawyers not to argue for property rights in the Cowichan case, the judge did not protect private property. The government will say it is there and it is fighting for it, but it did not actually intervene. It said it would appeal on the very last day. The government said it had better do that as it might not be very good for it electorally. That is what it is thinking of. It is all electoral; it is all speech.\n\nUnder the Prime Minister's leadership, the federal government continues to maintain the same legal directive adopted in 2019: litigation guideline 14. That directive led Ottawa to abandon the argument in defence of fee simple title in British Columbia, including in the Cowichan case. It is still on the government's website today, unless it was taken out this morning, to not encourage the government lawyers to stand up for fee simple property.\n\nThe Liberals say we are fearmongering. That is not true. They are trying to minimize a very serious situation that British Columbians find themselves in. They say we are being racist. It is not true. Conservatives believe in reconciliation with indigenous people. It is essential. It is a moral obligation, a constitutional responsibility and an opportunity to build a stronger Canada founded on mutual respect and shared prosperity. Reconciliation cannot succeed if it is built on ambiguity, secrecy and legal confusion.\n\nWhat does this all mean? What is going on here for private property owners? What does it mean for municipalities? What does it mean for future land claims and development projects? British Columbia has been an important engine in Confederation and in the economy, but it is not the same. We are struggling here economically and developmentally. When business owners are afraid of expanding, that has an impact on jobs. The lack of jobs impacts taxes and revenues, which impacts health care and everything else.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752118","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are talking today about a very important issue that is impacting all British Columbians and has implications for all Canadians: property rights.\n\n In the 2021 census, two-thirds, about 66.8%, of British Columbian households owned their own home, and it was about the same throughout the country. One-third were renters, and a good many of those renters wanted to eventually own. It ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e8a9d8d2bf5ddd70508820cbca148e33abe05e82e06758130969173611592275"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9142483266dbd492833bd29f6c7e16bdf0e5bada0fb960028806f1dbbce677b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-247e72f826c4f13c6399b4c8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752119,"date":"2026-05-07T22:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are ignoring what is happening. Do they think that the business owners and the homeowners are just making things up, saying that they cannot renew their mortgages or that business owners cannot get loans? That is in the law. It is happening. It is the uncertainty. It is what is not in the treaties and the agreements, so it is causing problems. It is causing problems within the Lower Mainland and it is causing problems in other first nations. It is a mess and they can put that on the Liberals.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752119","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are ignoring what is happening. Do they think that the business owners and the homeowners are just making things up, saying that they cannot renew their mortgages or that business owners cannot get loans? That is in the law. It is happening. It is the uncertainty. It is what is not in the treaties and the agreements, so it is causing problems. It is causing problems withi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c484787c0bc23767ace8d8d47454012e374b2406460cac46cc233344740fdabc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0bcbe48510a088229740b6b1cb693147ed8661c9358b574c41d9e2ee93d22a3f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-244dbd1e10cf89bad1c2a93c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102892,"date":"2026-05-26T21:00:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Mr. Chair, is the vote on adjourning the debate on this motion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102892","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, is the vote on adjourning the debate on this motion?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["380c489e0a7df214d1e499cbe70328c400000b4416772ba59f0e16eb820b836e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f0f76592ff1952dd6d76f13","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102893,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"My thanks to the witnesses. The Assemblée de la francophonie de l'Ontario represents 800,000 people. That's a lot of people. It's really a big deal. I agree that the current proposal masks the concentrations. That's important. As we have heard, for example, Toronto has 200,000 francophones and francophiles. Do you expect any resistance if the way of applying the regulations is adjusted?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102893","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My thanks to the witnesses. The Assemblée de la francophonie de l'Ontario represents 800,000 people. That's a lot of people. It's really a big deal. I agree that the current proposal masks the concentrations. That's important. As we have heard, for example, Toronto has 200,000 francophones and francophiles. Do you expect any resistance if the way of applying the regulations is adjusted?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["653c568cc1eea72025879151b29f3996ea9c5f153a3b2deb48b599dc7994cf68"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f8ca5a017d3fc9fe38c4f944867454544f7069cb9fbb1ce8818d5e90cc5b33b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3962e2a1461854bc5a001935","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102894,"date":"2026-05-26T22:20:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you very much. I am now going to turn to the representatives from the Canadian Bankers Association. You talked about technology. Phone apps and websites are all well and good, but what are your thoughts for the future? It's fine to talk about where you are, but you have to know where you are going. I am referring to artificial intelligence because it is really going to change communications in five or ten years. What do you see as the impact of artificial intelligence in your sector? That question also goes to those representing the Assemblée de la francophonie de l'Ontario.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102894","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I am now going to turn to the representatives from the Canadian Bankers Association. You talked about technology. Phone apps and websites are all well and good, but what are your thoughts for the future? It's fine to talk about where you are, but you have to know where you are going. I am referring to artificial intelligence because it is really going to change communications ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["87d449190b6da881dc47bc0d6bdd9e49092150074f682e67452d6b1d1e065715"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a51d81c9226251910aebf4c793092d05376041ac30d1242705d5cf2e004369c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-294f7748c704e783b79b0339","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102895,"date":"2026-05-26T22:25:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"We have 15 seconds left.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102895","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We have 15 seconds left.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8cd6b4d4ea40855848e12dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102896,"date":"2026-05-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you. Mr. Chiasson, let me thank you personally and your organization, the Fédération acadienne de la Nouvelle‐Écosse, for the struggle, the battle, you are leading and for the success you are having. It's a major challenge and we can see the progress. Can you talk a little about immigration and its impact on the francophone community? Do you have any figures on it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102896","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Chiasson, let me thank you personally and your organization, the Fédération acadienne de la Nouvelle‐Écosse, for the struggle, the battle, you are leading and for the success you are having. It's a major challenge and we can see the progress. Can you talk a little about immigration and its impact on the francophone community? Do you have any figures on it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8e8844fa8214fcf53e4f653","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102897,"date":"2026-05-28T21:20:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you very much. I am going to give the rest of my time to my colleague, Joël Godin.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102897","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I am going to give the rest of my time to my colleague, Joël Godin.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d907b2be4188fa5155f28dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102898,"date":"2026-05-28T22:00:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you. I would like to thank the witnesses. Ms. Chayer, your company's presentation was very positive. That's nice, but I haven't heard any complaints. Normally, when business representatives come to meet with us, they have suggestions to make. Are you completely satisfied with the draft regulations, and are you giving us carte blanche? If you have any suggestions, now is the time to make them, because we will be making recommendations after our study is complete. Do you have any recommendations to make, or are you applauding what we've done?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102898","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I would like to thank the witnesses. Ms. Chayer, your company's presentation was very positive. That's nice, but I haven't heard any complaints. Normally, when business representatives come to meet with us, they have suggestions to make. Are you completely satisfied with the draft regulations, and are you giving us carte blanche? If you have any suggestions, now is the time to make them","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["928f94950dbc7f98a344aa5f4aedeb994f019b04b20714c1a33f1ab484bb9733"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9af2687013ac6105283427f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102899,"date":"2026-05-28T22:00:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"I didn't hear them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102899","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I didn't hear them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f5ec18b0ff5bea2e049a3686","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102900,"date":"2026-05-28T22:00:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Making recommendations is also part of the process we are currently engaged in. So, if you have any to make, please send them to us in writing. We're also talking about other very specific locations in the west where there is a strong francophone presence. I'm thinking of the Bonnie Doon area, which is part of Edmonton, and Beausejour, I believe. So, these are larger centres, like Edmonton in Alberta, or in Manitoba. So, it could be much more than what you have now. Are you ready to hire? Is hiring people a big challenge? Do you currently have the number of fluent French speakers that you need? Tell us a little about recruitment. I used to be a high school teacher. Do you have booths in French-language schools or immersion schools to encourage twelfth-grade students to consider working for you? Is that something you do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102900","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Making recommendations is also part of the process we are currently engaged in. So, if you have any to make, please send them to us in writing. We're also talking about other very specific locations in the west where there is a strong francophone presence. I'm thinking of the Bonnie Doon area, which is part of Edmonton, and Beausejour, I believe. So, these are larger centres, like Edmonton in Albe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["71ec2dfb06ab08c66b170f56ebdbd7105fc1c61008de2e7643ef9386ead35466"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["698f78749110adca566a65c059ee7fbfe65473bd6f1be1bc88eb1b46d1053b35"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6bbff0295d1afc8d475e2a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102928,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. Thank you to all of our panellists for being here. This is an important topic. Prior to asking a few questions here, I want to make a couple of comments. I'm quite encouraged, and I'd say enthusiastic, about the direction for building our defence capacity. Having been raised in a military family and having been in the military myself, I think it is really important to be developing our capabilities here in Canada for jobs and for technology. I'm enthusiastic about that, but I also want to share a concern. That concern is that we've seen how funding can so often be led into the mismanagement of funds. I'm not pointing to you right now, but I will mention that we have seen, for example, how the dollars have rolled out with the environmental funds, the green slush fund and all of these different commitments. It's been really good sometimes for Liberal insiders, friends and companies, but it hasn't been great for the taxpayers of Canada. We've seen that also with the COVID contracts for the ArriveCAN app and for the ventilators. We've seen all sorts of money thrown out, hand over fist, with very poor results. That's the concern I have. I'm not pointing any fingers here, but I will also say that the announcement of a $200-million spaceport and the contract for 10 years for land that was already leased is very concerning to me, to taxpayers and to this side right here. This is the flashing red light, as much as I want it to just go forward. Mr. Elzein, you mentioned building a real business that is not dependent on grants. There can be accountability issues, and it can get pretty sloppy, but it's important. You also mentioned having defence contracts that are not based just on Canadian defence, because that's boom or bust. We've always seen that, whether it's shipbuilding or whatever else. That's important. I just had that comment. Ms. Hébert, Mr. Pyun, can you talk about the impact of U.S. tariffs on the auto sector, especially in Ontario? Are you also feeling an impact in your sector?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102928","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Thank you to all of our panellists for being here. This is an important topic. Prior to asking a few questions here, I want to make a couple of comments. I'm quite encouraged, and I'd say enthusiastic, about the direction for building our defence capacity. Having been raised in a military family and having been in the military myself, I think it is really important to be devel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","label":"Military training","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3824e4961fa418aed745db0666bf63c73afe52e10e8ce97fc626e5a36c29012c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41dd9d211bfe086149cca373201ddd76167bd6b93085cadbc7b0ba3285038290"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00b3b07800835a1c37ea358b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102929,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"NDDN","text":"If you don't mind, just because my time is going.... Just continue with the question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102929","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If you don't mind, just because my time is going.... Just continue with the question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["647261520e9e41e00ec50db50f211dce4faf3c326b8be295db48ee28052094e3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9bda92a1bc741c4996549ebe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102930,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm going to have to interrupt. I hope you don't mind. The question here is this: Does any entity in your ownership or core supply chain trace to a foreign state-owned enterprise or non-like-minded government? I'll be clear: With China, there's a concern. It's important to have trade relationships, but with technology.... Do you see that? Maybe I can quickly get a yes or no. Go ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102930","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm going to have to interrupt. I hope you don't mind. The question here is this: Does any entity in your ownership or core supply chain trace to a foreign state-owned enterprise or non-like-minded government? I'll be clear: With China, there's a concern. It's important to have trade relationships, but with technology.... Do you see that? Maybe I can quickly get a yes or no. Go ahead.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4177f3f6a1a6242549a34386","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102931,"date":"2026-06-01T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"NDDN","text":"Those are good things. It looks like my time is probably up. Is that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102931","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Those are good things. It looks like my time is probably up. Is that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef3e8b074aee8be213c7eb3f3368be4735d8c5ac5c8693eadf67d99ecb9484f1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22550a03246dc74922e0a006","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102901,"date":"2026-06-02T20:55:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Ms. Burke, congratulations on your appointment as commissioner. It's nice to see you. Almost every witness we've heard from, except maybe WestJet, is a little disappointed with what's happening with the proposed regulations. It's not what they imagined. Even you, you started by saying these proposed regulations don't meet the needs. Do we need to start over on these proposed regulations? Do you think what we've done so far is useless or useful?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102901","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Ms. Burke, congratulations on your appointment as commissioner. It's nice to see you. Almost every witness we've heard from, except maybe WestJet, is a little disappointed with what's happening with the proposed regulations. It's not what they imagined. Even you, you started by saying these proposed regulations don't meet the needs. Do we need to start over on these proposed regulations? Do you th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eb1b475db45b78bf721deda8b7ee3e8a6d01c7dc72af7c5eb6ca14091812391f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e28a82a74dc94868bc37037496c85a43f4da27f612f7148f1da58d850b349733"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae162073222353738b08e70a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102902,"date":"2026-06-02T20:55:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"I'm a member from British Columbia, and I just received an email from the Fédération des francophones de la Colombie-Britannique. It says our province would be completely abandoned by the method suggested in the proposed regulations for the federal government to determine if a region has a strong francophone presence, affecting, among other things, the offer of banking services, despite the growth of our community, and going against the modernization of the act, which was to emphasize the protection of French. The federation isn't happy, because it doesn't affect the francophone community. We also received comments from Toronto, where francophones are under-represented. It's the same thing in Vancouver. Could you comment further on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102902","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm a member from British Columbia, and I just received an email from the Fédération des francophones de la Colombie-Britannique. It says our province would be completely abandoned by the method suggested in the proposed regulations for the federal government to determine if a region has a strong francophone presence, affecting, among other things, the offer of banking services, despite the growth","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["846c32662434c65ba32336c757da1371f24a6a741edee418f63df0290054f6e4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b5766d2b006ee5bfce47f4bdadc2a11d5fbad84e51c415e8199ebf4f0a217334"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc38ddb1e682cfca6ff6cb79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102903,"date":"2026-06-02T21:00:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"There's always some tension: We have to encourage and support the francophone community without over-regulating. It's a question of balance. Different size companies have different abilities to accommodate francophone clients and employees. How will your office treat companies of different sizes? Will you be stronger or tougher on the large ones or on the small ones? Will you recognize the different capacities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102903","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There's always some tension: We have to encourage and support the francophone community without over-regulating. It's a question of balance. Different size companies have different abilities to accommodate francophone clients and employees. How will your office treat companies of different sizes? Will you be stronger or tougher on the large ones or on the small ones? Will you recognize the differe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["410fe07c971392ec5c9cbb47c723132112b94e79435ae4a1c90307f5032b37b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c97f08c2b627185f19801edfa4383f8b5d86788511ba29b305a9d6a70a718815"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e7e0d612c9acaeec433602e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102904,"date":"2026-06-02T21:00:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"You can take time away from the Liberals, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102904","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You can take time away from the Liberals, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a25af45fb1ac44ee861559d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102905,"date":"2026-06-04T21:40:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you very much. Thank you to the witnesses for joining us. Ms. Chouinard, it's always a pleasure to see you. I remember the first time I heard you at committee was during the COVID‐19 pandemic. You had some very clear suggestions and recommendations for us. We're pleased to have you and the Société de la francophonie manitobaine appear today. If you, or perhaps your child, had a magic wand you could use across the country, especially outside Quebec—I'm an MP from British Columbia—what designated regions would you add?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102905","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Thank you to the witnesses for joining us. Ms. Chouinard, it's always a pleasure to see you. I remember the first time I heard you at committee was during the COVID‐19 pandemic. You had some very clear suggestions and recommendations for us. We're pleased to have you and the Société de la francophonie manitobaine appear today. If you, or perhaps your child, had a magic wand yo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7976d96976e2316c1404be23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102906,"date":"2026-06-04T21:40:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Yes, that's what we've heard from other provinces as well, but not from Manitoba. We've already heard testimony from Nova Scotia, and I've received correspondence from people in British Columbia who are a bit disappointed because they don't see how this legislation will help them. They're somewhat discouraged. You said that it's a bit arbitrary to place more emphasis on concentration rather than vitality. Could you expand on that a bit, particularly with respect to vitality?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102906","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, that's what we've heard from other provinces as well, but not from Manitoba. We've already heard testimony from Nova Scotia, and I've received correspondence from people in British Columbia who are a bit disappointed because they don't see how this legislation will help them. They're somewhat discouraged. You said that it's a bit arbitrary to place more emphasis on concentration rather than v","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bac05046b2db678514aa53ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102907,"date":"2026-06-04T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Mr. Bentley, you said that you think these regulations will have a real and significant impact. Could you elaborate on that a little bit? Are there major shortcomings now? You also said that Manitoba is very supportive of francophone communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102907","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Bentley, you said that you think these regulations will have a real and significant impact. Could you elaborate on that a little bit? Are there major shortcomings now? You also said that Manitoba is very supportive of francophone communities.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ee87ffecea06370e40f0bd0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102908,"date":"2026-06-04T21:45:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102908","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-729b5b1545bc82cae6529a47","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037207,"date":"2026-06-05T15:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I was an MLA in British Columbia in the years coinciding with when the Conservatives were in power under former prime minister Stephen Harper. Those were the years when Canada, and more specifically B.C., was moving forward. Projects were getting built under a free enterprise provincial and federal government.\n\n In my riding, there is the Golden Ears Bridge, the Pitt River Bridge, the Port Mann Bridge and the expansion of the Trans-Canada Highway. The highway that used to go between Vancouver and Squamish was called the highway of death because of all the fatalities there. That was expanded. There is Kicking Horse Pass. The Olympics happened. There is the Canada Line, the convention centre and a new stadium, new hospitals and new schools. All throughout British Columbia there was tremendous progress, and I know that this was the same throughout the country.\n\nThe New York Times, during that period, said that Canada had the richest middle class in the world. We had a dollar at par with the American dollar. I would talk to Americans and others visiting Canada and visiting Victoria, where I often was for my government work. They were amazed by the prosperity they saw in British Columbia and in Canada.\n\nLet us keep in mind that between 2007 and mid-2009, the world underwent the great global recession. It was the most severe economic and financial meltdown since the Great Depression in the late twenties and the thirties, impacting housing significantly. Canada weathered this storm very well, and we were number one in growth. Between 2006 and 2015, under Stephen Harper, there were two million housing starts in Canada, while the population growth was about 3.2 million. Using household sizes, those starts were enough to accommodate more people than the population during that period. Canada fared the best in the G7. We were a prosperous nation going from strength to strength.\n\nFast-forward to 2026. After 11 long years under the Liberal government and under two Liberal prime ministers, we have gone from boom to gloom and from first to worst. There has been economic stagnation and decline under the Liberals. In three of the last four quarters, we have shrunk. We are in a recession. We are the only country in the G20 with an economy that is shrinking.\n\nThe G20 includes nations such as Argentina, which was an economic basket case not so long ago; Australia; Brazil; China; France; Germany; India; Indonesia; Italy; Japan; Mexico, whose number one trading partner is the U.S., as it is for Canada; Russia; Saudi Arabia; South Africa; South Korea; Turkey; the United Kingdom and the United States. I know that the Liberals would like to blame the U.S. for all the problems Canada faces, but all these countries are impacted by U.S. tariffs, and some are in war zones.\n\nHowever, credit must be given where credit is deserved. The Liberals excel, get an A, for building bureaucracy, increasing red tape and doling out money to friends, family and themselves. Since I was elected to the House of Commons in 2019, it has been one scandal after another. We get numb after a while.\n\n The Conservatives had their scandals also. One lady, a cabinet minister, resigned for having a $16 glass of orange juice.\n\n The Prime Minister promised to double housing construction to half a million homes a year and to move at speeds we have not seen in generations. How has that turned out? More than one year in, the result is the exact opposite: fewer permits, fewer starts, and a housing crisis that keeps getting worse. For example, Toronto has experienced a major housing construction downturn, a crash. Starts are down more than 50% in the last three years. New condo sales in the GTA collapsed to 1,599 units in 2025, the lowest annual total in 35 years and 91% less than the 10-year average.\n\nHowever, this must be kept in context. Canada's population has increased by 2.5 million people in the last three years alone, under the Liberals' chaotic handling of immigration. Construction should be skyrocketing, not plummeting. The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation says that we need to build 480,000 homes a year for the next decade. We are expected to build only half of that this year and only 212,000 units by 2028. Meanwhile, 131,000 Canadians who used to work in construction are unemployed as of April, and half of home builders and contractors are reporting layoffs in the first quarter of this year.\n\n Maybe there is a strategy under this political madness. Maybe the intention is to make things so bad that when there is a change, and I think there was some positive news with the numbers today, the Liberals will blow the trumpets, bang on the drums and say how they have turned things around, how marvellous things have become. However, this is a fail. It is not a new day. It is not a new government. It is the same old, same old.\n\n Instead of a plan to build homes, the Liberals would deliver a fourth housing bureaucracy. Far from building at generational speeds, they have taken a year to introduce legislation that still builds no homes. Even when homes start getting built, the Parliamentary Budget Officer found, Build Canada Homes would add just 5,000 homes per year, 1% of what the Liberals promised. We can do the math on how much is being invested right there and what that equates to as far as cost per unit. It is more bureaucracy, more red tape and more cost.\n\n I recently held a round table with builders and developers. They are asking for less government in the homebuilding process, not more. Ever-increasing regulations are killing the market and driving up construction costs. Federal, provincial and municipal regulations and taxes are all adding costs, not just for the builder but also for the home purchaser. If we are to make housing affordable for Canadians, we need to cut the cost of building and to build more, faster.\n\nBill C‐20 would not build, and it would not cut costs for builders. What would it do? It would build a fourth government bureaucracy. That is an F, for \"fail\". I was a teacher. We can see the stats here very clearly.\n\n Canadians used to be able to buy their first home in their twenties or early thirties. Realtors in Vancouver tell me that it is now an anomaly for new homebuyers to purchase a place without getting significant financial help from their family. This is building a sharp divide in Canadian society between the haves and the have-nots. This is not good. It is becoming dependent upon generational wealth rather than on someone's being able to make it on their own, even with a supposedly great salary.\n\n Conservatives have a plan: Cut the GST on all new homes under $1.3 million, saving families up to $65,000 and unleashing new building; tie federal infrastructure dollars to homebuilding, with municipalities having to permit at least 15% more homebuilding each year to get things done; cut development charges by 50%, because the number one cost of construction is all the regulations and permitting; and end the capital gains tax on reinvestments in new housing in Canada and unlock billions of dollars of investment in the country's homebuilding sector.\n\n Canadians should be able to earn a strong paycheque in a thriving economy to buy an affordable home. It used to be this way, and it can be this way again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037207","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I was an MLA in British Columbia in the years coinciding with when the Conservatives were in power under former prime minister Stephen Harper. Those were the years when Canada, and more specifically B.C., was moving forward. Projects were getting built under a free enterprise provincial and federal government.\n\n In my riding, there is the Golden Ears Bridge, the Pitt River Bridge, t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["135357052c298ce7864790954cf646df3ad54424209f6ce35767df97207a5f10"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8e7459095077a5a7c51164825629d75073852443afb714bd271fb90adf91e5a0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1fbe471268dd7782486e492a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037208,"date":"2026-06-05T15:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to apologize for the fact that I will probably be too nice in my remarks to the Liberal member. This is madness, and it actually proves the point that the Liberals might see a slight change and then blow the horn about how wonderful they are. It has been a disaster, and now they are saying that immigration is down, but it is down from historic highs. The Liberals tweak it down just a little and say how great they are doing. \n\nThey have made a total mess of things. Under the Conservatives, we built two and a half million homes during a time of population increase that was less than the increase over the past few years. I hold onto that F for failure for the Liberals.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037208","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to apologize for the fact that I will probably be too nice in my remarks to the Liberal member. This is madness, and it actually proves the point that the Liberals might see a slight change and then blow the horn about how wonderful they are. It has been a disaster, and now they are saying that immigration is down, but it is down from historic highs. The Liberals tweak it dow","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["db81dc4d2243e23c7a82b1c8d1d538f9a7c03b2b859e25cbfaf0c86d3491d158"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["768152ed83fe8546b0e4487965a882f7fd0f87aef636eb2edff30f2390bf9cde"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb3a8bbf87bb7d7cda77d854","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037209,"date":"2026-06-05T15:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, how we do it is we move building more into the private sector, as opposed to keeping it in government hands and government bureaucracies, where it gives jobs to friendly insiders and goes nowhere. That is the problem. The government has just been building bureaucracy. It has become a disaster for Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037209","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, how we do it is we move building more into the private sector, as opposed to keeping it in government hands and government bureaucracies, where it gives jobs to friendly insiders and goes nowhere. That is the problem. The government has just been building bureaucracy. It has become a disaster for Canada.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3fecec4256ebb00382cf6c53ece972c922f39870ee8cad48c837f2fa7901d215"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e9ebb61d6645fc1ac1412891e091be9cafd2a5f505ff0e97d9d6a39d0a4739e3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-852304b8fdaf80115aeb7fde","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037210,"date":"2026-06-05T15:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I did not hear my colleague's question. If he is wondering if there is a role for private companies, the answer is yes. It is important.\n\nCanada needs to be unleashed. This is what is happening. Companies, individuals, Canadians are being held back, and they need to be unleashed from all these regulations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037210","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I did not hear my colleague's question. If he is wondering if there is a role for private companies, the answer is yes. It is important.\n\nCanada needs to be unleashed. This is what is happening. Companies, individuals, Canadians are being held back, and they need to be unleashed from all these regulations.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15fcc81cc64a368608c84944777b20a377da3029a1c7ca96435689cc3fefe4b3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["774a8ece7d02a487dfeeddba3398199cb7745fb19076f8e00415cf821b88c4bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4249da8bee6ad730dabbe03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037211,"date":"2026-06-05T16:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, last year Canadians thought they were electing someone with exceptional economic skills who could strengthen our economy and quickly negotiate a deal with the United States. Well, it is becoming increasingly evident that we have been duped.\n\nUnder the Liberals, Canada has the only recession in the G20. We have now suffered economic decline in three of the last four quarters. The Parliamentary Budget Officer paints a grim picture, saying there is only a 1% chance the Liberals will meet their own fiscal targets. As for businesses, they are retreating from investment amid soaring uncertainty. The Liberals claim to be cutting costs, but they plan to hike personnel expenses from $69 billion to $86 billion by 2031. Then there is the $72 billion in deficit borrowing this year alone. This is not just numbers; it is diminished paycheques, fewer jobs and strained households.\n\n Canadians deserve better than a Liberal government that has lost its way.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037211","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, last year Canadians thought they were electing someone with exceptional economic skills who could strengthen our economy and quickly negotiate a deal with the United States. Well, it is becoming increasingly evident that we have been duped.\n\nUnder the Liberals, Canada has the only recession in the G20. We have now suffered economic decline in three of the last four quarters. The Par","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["03eabccdd4dcacce733b5143c1590ade942b6fa1e63a1e21b49377cfd549f2d6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4e2997c5e55e0725836b7459515ddc4bb39b69454559f33aab5a02140299bfa9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29a3a5101a0014e65b74d85e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037212,"date":"2026-06-05T17:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, to capsulize Bill C-20, I would say it is more bureaucracy, it is more regulation and it is more cost to the taxpayer, but it is great for Liberal insiders and friends. We are probably going to find out more and more as time goes on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037212","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, to capsulize Bill C-20, I would say it is more bureaucracy, it is more regulation and it is more cost to the taxpayer, but it is great for Liberal insiders and friends. We are probably going to find out more and more as time goes on.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["081247cbd0f518bbcdb118b6abcb35472cbc2e68483c1dde84576da2a1a863e3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f7549ef67b76fd0f1f65136953666588788e2f34bd127858128c5c3f22ee535b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-886aec091c25e30448a56662","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102909,"date":"2026-06-09T21:00:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you very much, Ms. Lachance and Ms. Laurin, for being with us today. My family is from Alberta. I think that half of the people north of Edmonton are related to me. My mother is a Beaudoin and she comes from a family of 18 children. How will this affect northern Alberta towns like Fahler, Girouxville and McLennan? This region of the province has a rich francophone history. Can you tell us a bit about this region?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102909","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Ms. Lachance and Ms. Laurin, for being with us today. My family is from Alberta. I think that half of the people north of Edmonton are related to me. My mother is a Beaudoin and she comes from a family of 18 children. How will this affect northern Alberta towns like Fahler, Girouxville and McLennan? This region of the province has a rich francophone history. Can you tell us a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Decentralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","label":"Decentralization","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91371ef0621b9b3d02c5466798e0c09a47de7ad32c1592d3725bd4e7be734914"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ddf88aa7ff9525ecb61852a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102910,"date":"2026-06-09T21:05:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"That's great. Do you think that the legislation, in its current form, will, in fact, bring about changes for Alberta's francophone community, once the rules are in effect and enforced?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102910","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's great. Do you think that the legislation, in its current form, will, in fact, bring about changes for Alberta's francophone community, once the rules are in effect and enforced?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d680163fc95c232709b034ffe42163e2bdb381a60d7405535055e8cfdc41eb1b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ea9f01b30c03d21e931bfe0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102911,"date":"2026-06-09T21:05:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"You talked a bit about the importance of not going backwards. Can you talk a bit more about the importance of not removing a designation that's already there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102911","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You talked a bit about the importance of not going backwards. Can you talk a bit more about the importance of not removing a designation that's already there?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f4051863f4634230b728397e4146d46564543c092b98c7f82899c353aba6a9c0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d667bbdd8d3c8d041dc3090","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102912,"date":"2026-06-09T21:05:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"I'm not entirely clear about the designation. Are we talking about the area around Bonnie Doon and Campus Saint‐Jean? Is that region designated as a francophone community? Can you tell us a bit more about that and the expansion to the entire capital city?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102912","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm not entirely clear about the designation. Are we talking about the area around Bonnie Doon and Campus Saint‐Jean? Is that region designated as a francophone community? Can you tell us a bit more about that and the expansion to the entire capital city?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fda0fba1dd18a7c8b74c26f42953e1db158d29261111e7abb748c34f33e4d80c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02ecc65261821355f321c6fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102913,"date":"2026-06-09T21:05:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you very much. Ms. Lachance, we heard from representatives of the Fédération des francophones de la Colombie-Britannique and other organizations. They're not very happy with the regulations, because it doesn't seem that it applies to francophone communities in their region. I'm a member from British Columbia, but we've heard the same thing from people in Nova Scotia and other regions. You seem to be more positive. It may be because there is a small region where it will apply. Is that the case?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102913","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Ms. Lachance, we heard from representatives of the Fédération des francophones de la Colombie-Britannique and other organizations. They're not very happy with the regulations, because it doesn't seem that it applies to francophone communities in their region. I'm a member from British Columbia, but we've heard the same thing from people in Nova Scotia and other regions. You se","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eeb8715e1fa550a7356f6dcfcd95032637742d4074e988850726618320d02d53"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b88f74e58732d278bfde1a0707f4f938ff96ccc81a93e159bba2af333ee85932"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c96bf22b7af36774c0f3bb0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102914,"date":"2026-06-09T21:05:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"In your opinion, will businesses in the region react positively or negatively to these changes? What do you think?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102914","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In your opinion, will businesses in the region react positively or negatively to these changes? What do you think?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["830a1169b5ee6a7d00fa8a2ac1f4043f3eb2bf5036aede9583f47bf5eefc0934"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bca1287ddb1678410135160b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102915,"date":"2026-06-09T21:05:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you for the work you are doing. It's encouraging to hear that the francophonie is making progress in Alberta. How many francophones and francophiles are there in Calgary and Edmonton? The two are not exactly the same. The number of francophones in both cities is roughly the same in both cities, but these services won't be available in Calgary.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102915","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for the work you are doing. It's encouraging to hear that the francophonie is making progress in Alberta. How many francophones and francophiles are there in Calgary and Edmonton? The two are not exactly the same. The number of francophones in both cities is roughly the same in both cities, but these services won't be available in Calgary.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6425247a0756d8840d7089ee7456557ebc848b7c2bac855b5c4e3cad9dea8b02"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6722b60c0dc290f82ae5799","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102916,"date":"2026-06-09T21:05:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you, Ms. Lachance.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102916","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Ms. Lachance.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7164b005ab3009f36552ef9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102917,"date":"2026-06-09T22:15:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Thank you for joining us today and for sharing your thoughts. TALQ recommends adding an explicit non-derogation statement confirming that nothing in the regulation reduces existing access to service in English where it's already provided. Can you give more information regarding this recommendation? I know you've talked a bit about it already, but you're saying you don't want it taken away.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102917","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for joining us today and for sharing your thoughts. TALQ recommends adding an explicit non-derogation statement confirming that nothing in the regulation reduces existing access to service in English where it's already provided. Can you give more information regarding this recommendation? I know you've talked a bit about it already, but you're saying you don't want it taken away.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ac3bebc3a8e44da919d45bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102918,"date":"2026-06-09T22:20:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Can you elaborate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102918","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Can you elaborate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa67e700f981bcb672a35e22","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102919,"date":"2026-06-09T22:20:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Okay. TALQ recommends that small and medium-sized enterprises under federal jurisdiction receive compliance support before any punitive measures are taken. What do you mean by compliance support? What federal agencies could offer that program? Finally, does the Government of Quebec offer such programs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102919","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. TALQ recommends that small and medium-sized enterprises under federal jurisdiction receive compliance support before any punitive measures are taken. What do you mean by compliance support? What federal agencies could offer that program? Finally, does the Government of Quebec offer such programs?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a9c9645a403e61bbbe672e786658212660db752965e888b2733662735eaf011"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd72a9ef2861bb9cdf048a47","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102920,"date":"2026-06-09T22:20:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Choose whatever you want to answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102920","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Choose whatever you want to answer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa67ec71cb694a4d4b88e8fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102921,"date":"2026-06-09T22:20:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"From your perspective, you see a lot more regulations, regulatory burden and costs related to this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102921","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"From your perspective, you see a lot more regulations, regulatory burden and costs related to this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88032d888e9571fcaf01a84894163e44208c83db7603f3dc0df03bdb451e678c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17a902bed60f2feadd447893","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1102922,"date":"2026-06-09T22:20:00+00:00","title":"LANG","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"LANG","text":"Please send in what we could do better on that from your perspective.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/LANG/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1102922","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Please send in what we could do better on that from your perspective.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4f182c58922973e5409b5d885743c6ab21576612b5a45ef7f06784a6d28fed03"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-708a434338626e51fc598af0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085018,"date":"2026-06-10T19:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after a decade of Liberal inflation and economic mismanagement, Canadians are the ones who are paying the price. A new United Way survey found that 60% of them are anxious about their finances and 40% are losing sleep trying to make ends meet. More than two million Canadians relied on food banks every month last year, and in Maple Ridge, food bank use has doubled in the past five years.\n\nHow much worse must it get before the Liberal Prime Minister reverses the costly policies driving Canadians into hardship?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085018","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after a decade of Liberal inflation and economic mismanagement, Canadians are the ones who are paying the price. A new United Way survey found that 60% of them are anxious about their finances and 40% are losing sleep trying to make ends meet. More than two million Canadians relied on food banks every month last year, and in Maple Ridge, food bank use has doubled in the past five year","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","label":"Nutrition","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f28a4881a4aa136f4c756993a63defc55a5ae5752b1a2aefe59db4ee1ea6e1e6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0cfc1c06c004a8a85730af31ebbd62dfdfd1a967b1a87cec50faafbdf8b2fe41"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cedb1ab4d6f0b0f818672daa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085014,"date":"2026-06-11T19:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour the life of an extraordinary British Columbian philanthropist and community builder, Mel Zajac, who passed away at the age of 98.\n\n I had the privilege of knowing Mel and visited Zajac Ranch in Mission on several occasions, including just last month. It is an amazing place, and it is constantly improving.\n\nWhat always struck me was that, right to the very end, Mel remained passionately committed to helping youth with disabilities. After the heartbreaking loss of two sons, Mel transformed personal tragedy into a remarkable legacy of hope. His vision gave life to Zajac Ranch, which is a fully accessible camp where children and young adults with complex medical conditions can experience joy, friendship, confidence and the sense of belonging that every child needs. Over the decades, thousands have been touched by Mel and Wendy's belief that barriers should never prevent a child from thriving.\n\n Mel Zajac leaves behind a legacy of philanthropy and compassion. On behalf of the House, I extend my deepest condolences to Wendy, his family and the entire Zajac community.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085014","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour the life of an extraordinary British Columbian philanthropist and community builder, Mel Zajac, who passed away at the age of 98.\n\n I had the privilege of knowing Mel and visited Zajac Ranch in Mission on several occasions, including just last month. It is an amazing place, and it is constantly improving.\n\nWhat always struck me was that, right to the very end, M","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0d394fad117057e1ad7265261d321c8411fa30bc8f791952d333c2a77677d382"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cef83830d78ee91fd5d3b1a104edcab004224a6d79a97cf37b07895126d8426a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d2d4c22f898dc8170a811a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085015,"date":"2026-06-11T22:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives are a bit disappointed that the Liberals voted against some of our amendments. I think that will affect how we will vote.\n\nI would like to know what the Bloc Québécois member thinks of some of these amendments, particularly those aimed at strengthening the security of ballot boxes, as well as the measures designed to close loopholes that allow third parties to advertise on behalf of one party or another.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085015","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives are a bit disappointed that the Liberals voted against some of our amendments. I think that will affect how we will vote.\n\nI would like to know what the Bloc Québécois member thinks of some of these amendments, particularly those aimed at strengthening the security of ballot boxes, as well as the measures designed to close loopholes that allow third parties to advertise ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["357e351401e552a518ac165c0cb17bd97da162cdb66d81d75fc29c5451249a5f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c87fe92203f06a974c7920f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085016,"date":"2026-06-11T23:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to speak to Bill C-267, an act to establish a national framework to promote the durability of electronic products and essential home appliances. The legislation proposes a federal framework to improve product durability, repairability and transparency for consumers. It sounds really good.\n\n Everyone has stories about appliances and their longevity, or the lack thereof. I bought a second-hand freezer 35 years ago. It is still humming away in our basement. It needs some defrosting. It has almost become a member of the family. I do not know how many more years it has, but it will probably outlive us. There is also my microwave. It is 23 years old today. It celebrated its birthday. About 10 years ago, it had a little problem. It started sparking. My wife, whom I have been pretty impressed with, has come up with some fixes for our dryer and our microwave, and we did a little patch. Guess what? They are still working after all these years.\n\nThose are some good stories about appliances, but not all appliances in our household have happy stories. Take our stove. It did not have a knob, like they used to. I guess some of them still do, but the one we had did not. It had a plastic top. Anyway, one of the little plastic pieces behind broke. It was about 50¢ for the piece, so I thought it would be no problem to get this little repair job done. I thought it was going to keep up with my freezer, but it apparently needed a whole new control panel. They did not make the replacement for that little piece, and a new control panel would have cost almost the same as buying a new a stove. That was a frustrating and expensive experience. Toasters nowadays seem to be just as useless, compared to half a century ago. The list goes on and on.\n\nThere is a history of planned obsolescence. Have members ever heard about the Phoebus cartel? I had never heard about the Phoebus cartel before I did the preparation for this speech. It was made up of the world's major light bulb manufacturers. In 1924, we had Osram, which I had never heard of, and Philips, which I have heard of, as well as GE and others. These companies secretly agreed to cap bulb lifespans at about 1,000 hours. They were at about 2,500 hours at that time. They fined members whose bulbs lasted too long. They saw, rightly, that having bulbs that never went out was not good for business.\n\nThere is a light bulb in my riding. It was part of the member for Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford's riding until the last election. It is in the Ruskin Dam. That light bulb is almost 100 years old. It has not gone out in 100 years. That is amazing. If we had light bulbs like that, we could almost put them in our will.\n\n Planned obsolescence is not new. In the 1920s, GM introduced the annual model year. Alfred Sloan pioneered dynamic obsolescence. He restyled the cars every year so that the previous year looked aged. This is what happened to the Model T. That sank it for Ford and the Model T. It was about fashion.\n\nWe see present-day obsolescence in software updates, incompatible chargers, glued-in batteries and printer cartridges with kill chips. This is frustrating. I would agree that the industry can do better. We can get products that last. Canadians would welcome this. I just ordered a fourth shaver a couple days ago from Amazon. They used to last a decade or more. This is what we are seeing.\n\nWe need to dig a little deeper into this bill. What would it actually do? It would force the minister to make a bureaucracy. It would force the minister to make a national framework. Liberals love the words \"national framework\". The framework must address the minimum useful life and labelling, the repair via accessible parts, tools and information, replacement part availability periods, technical documentation, software support duration, consumer education and the responsibilities of manufacturers, importers and distributors. It is a massive bureaucratic undertaking. I can see the Liberals being gleeful about this bureaucracy.\n\n Frameworks are nebulous and vaporous. What does it mean to have a national framework? It means 50 full-time bureaucrats talking and talking. Maybe it is 500 or 5,000. I do not know. The minister must confer with the provinces on possible future legislation, industry obligations, inspections and penalties every 18 months and must report to Parliament. There would be report after report, more bureaucracy and more expense to the taxpayer.\n\n We have seen this playing out over and over again. We were recently discussing Build Canada Homes, which is a fourth bureaucracy. The Liberals have a terrible record. My staff tell me how hard it is becoming to deal with the Canada Revenue Agency, immigration and the government. It is getting slower and slower. It is hard.\n\nWe need to also consider the prices for appliances that were stable and have been declining for many years. It is true that refrigerators, washers and dryers were simpler and easier to repair, and parts were more robust and less dependent on electronics. They were also heavier, with more metal components. Now, electronic control boards, sensors, touch screens and smart features introduce more failure points. Manufacturers are also feeling the pressure to keep prices competitive, which leads to lighter construction and lower-cost components. Before we run headlong into bureaucracy and regulations, we need to also recognize that modern appliances use much less electricity and water. That is a significant cost savings. They have more features and conveniences, and they meet stricter environmental standards. The trade-off has been lower purchase prices and better efficiency versus durability and ease of repair.\n\nThis is another issue to keep in mind. Canada is a small market, compared to Europe and the United States. As it was mentioned previously by my colleague from British Columbia, most of the manufacturing is done in other countries. That is a problem, because they are not going to bend for Canada. Basically, what will end up happening is there will be a reduction in the number of products for Canadians. This will certainly increase costs for Canadian consumers, who the Liberals are saying they are trying to help. At the same time, the Internet has made it easier than ever for consumers to see how long things last, based on honest reviews. They may be honest. We may have to pick through them.\n\nThe Conservatives are opposing this bill. Why? It is because it moves away from previous Conservative-supported right-to-repair measures. Bill C-294, which we supported, would have made it easier for Canadian businesses and innovators to create products that work with existing technologies, giving consumers more choice and encouraging competition. It was a common-sense measure that would have supported innovation, helped grow our economy and benefited Canadians without taking away copyright protections.\n\n This bill, despite its title, does not display common sense. This bill would present risks around federal intrusion into areas of provincial jurisdiction. The Liberals do not have a problem with that. It would introduce the potential for increased regulatory burden on businesses. The Liberals do not have a problem with that, either. It would risk consumer choice by reducing lower-cost product options and discouraging manufacturers from offering certain products in the Canadian market. It sounds like a great idea, but there are a lot of problems and pitfalls in this bill.\n\nThe Conservatives will be voting against it, and I encourage the government to go back to the table and follow the Conservatives' plan.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085016","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to speak to Bill C-267, an act to establish a national framework to promote the durability of electronic products and essential home appliances. The legislation proposes a federal framework to improve product durability, repairability and transparency for consumers. It sounds really good.\n\n Everyone has stories about appliances and their longevity, or the lack thereof. I ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","label":"Household equipment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","label":"Household equipment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["260ae59c8ad8c0d1f90bf883f3582ec4910550ac6476941cde5676ac43ecb115"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a19fc6ac49253a7fda05049985e55d850da34340f43c7ec12746c6183e11f93"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d084de58ffec98498fcbd40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085017,"date":"2026-06-12T01:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for his passionate speech and for his very clearly thought-out presentation and understanding of the bill. I certainly hope that the Liberals will follow through with his amendment.\n\nMy wife and I received a call a couple of days ago from a relative of the pastor of the church I have been going to for about 25 years. She was very upset about this bill. I wanted to soothe her, so I told her, \"I do not believe they are going to be taking people in the next few days or few weeks and bringing them to prison.\" I was just trying to calm her down. At the same time, I said, \"This is leading somewhere. We do not know where it is going to go. It is going to be interpreted.\"\n\nI wonder if the member could tell us how this would impact the human rights courts—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085017","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for his passionate speech and for his very clearly thought-out presentation and understanding of the bill. I certainly hope that the Liberals will follow through with his amendment.\n\nMy wife and I received a call a couple of days ago from a relative of the pastor of the church I have been going to for about 25 years. She was very upset about this bill. I wan","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:202314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Lead","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:202314","label":"Lead","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["372cbe42bfad2d1ed015d6d7bb6b90db1acd918e097734fdf1fa7be5fb7f6e28"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-532a14ed865118ba111539ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085012,"date":"2026-06-12T15:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I see that the member for Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong has certainly been drinking the Liberal Kool‐Aid, with her jargon, \"build Canada strong\" and \"investment\".\n\nOne important industry she did not really refer to is the automobile industry and how it has dropped from over 2.5 million units to, now, under one million. There has been a free fall there. That is one sector. There is also EV manufacturing. I think of the different companies. Honda's $15‐billion EV and battery complex has been scrapped. Northvolt has been cut. It has been a free fall.\n\nI wonder if the member would agree with me that these Liberal investments have actually been very dubious and unfruitful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085012","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I see that the member for Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong has certainly been drinking the Liberal Kool‐Aid, with her jargon, \"build Canada strong\" and \"investment\".\n\nOne important industry she did not really refer to is the automobile industry and how it has dropped from over 2.5 million units to, now, under one million. There has been a free fall there. That is one sector. There is also EV","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9484983f9c90672f790f09bb4f97df5ec32370ff9e03fb9e6df76133cc84624e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dd0329c60464f8eccdaf1e0f015aac8fbd6824af86c4fcdce68bfd7a384c0b20"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-19d4bea215a64fbf4d4bed37","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085013,"date":"2026-06-12T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Marc Dalton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, crime has gone out of control under the Liberals with violent crime, extortion and those out on bail. They make it seem as if they are the bearers of truth and justice and getting things done when they are the reason we are in the situation we are now.\n\nThey are closing down debate. We have a role to play. I am sure the Liberals would prefer there not be an opposition. We have a responsibility to bring forward amendments as the opposition on behalf of Canadians, because almost all the time the Liberals get it wrong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085013","member_id":"bc-mp-35909","member_name":"Marc Dalton","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, crime has gone out of control under the Liberals with violent crime, extortion and those out on bail. They make it seem as if they are the bearers of truth and justice and getting things done when they are the reason we are in the situation we are now.\n\nThey are closing down debate. We have a role to play. I am sure the Liberals would prefer there not be an opposition. We have a respo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6f22b0e6c7f9c3cedae3fb0349e93c432f5e6cdb345e6dad47d555f517533371"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["854431ac8e07ed8bc20dc3b28b8376452a34e8f5c033e1efd6d0f25a2a0d2a6b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9fad5b68ee7332bafc186bf9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77468,"date":"2026-02-04T21:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank the member for Beauport—Limoilou for sharing his time with me. \n\nIt is my pleasure to take part in this debate today on Bill C-19, the Canada groceries and essentials benefits act. As we all know, advanced economies around the world are facing complex economic challenges, and Canada is no different. Rising protectionism in the form of tariffs, supply chain disruptions and climate change are all posing significant challenges to the Canadian economy, and Canadians are feeling the impact in their daily lives. \n\nIn response, our new government is moving Canada's economy from reliance to resilience, but we understand that some of the biggest long-term payoffs in this transformation will take time to be felt. To ensure Canadians have the support they need right now, we have introduced a series of new measures to limit pressures on costs, including making groceries and other essentials more affordable. \n\nThe bill I am here to talk about today will help more than 12 million low- and modest-income Canadians afford day-to-day essentials. The support will be indexed to inflation and builds on the goods and services tax credit to provide $11.7 billion in additional financial assistance over six years. To help address affordability challenges, the benefit will provide a one-time top-up payment equal to a 50% increase in the annual 2025-26 value of the GST credit. This support will be paid out as early as possible this spring. It will deliver $3.1 billion in immediate assistance to individuals and families who are already getting the GST credit. \n\nThere is more. In addition, the value of the Canada groceries and essentials benefit will increase by 25% for five years starting in July 2026. This expansion will deliver another $8.6 billion in support over the 2026-27 to 2030-31 period and will ensure the benefit goes to 500,000 new individuals and families. Taken together, these measures will provide up to an additional $402 to a single individual without children, $527 to a couple and $805 to a couple with two children. At these levels, our government will be offsetting grocery cost increases beyond the overall inflation rate since the pandemic. \n\nLet me provide a couple of examples of what this assistance would look like. A single senior with $25,000 in net income would receive a one-time top-up of $267 plus a longer-term increase of $136 for the 2026-27 benefit year, for a total increase of $402. In total, this senior would receive $950 for the 2026-27 benefit year, including the top-up. A couple with two children with $40,000 in net income would receive a one-time top-up of $533 plus an increase of $272 for the 2026-27 benefit year, for a total increase of $805. In total, they would receive $1,890 for the 2026-27 benefit year, including the top-up. \n\nAfter the one-time payment is made in the spring of 2026, eligible families and individuals will receive the enriched regular payments under the Canada groceries and essentials benefit as of July 2026. The benefit payments will arrive quarterly to ensure families can use the funds to help with their day-to-day expenses. To simplify this benefit for Canadians, recipients will not need to apply for the additional payments, but will be required to file their 2024 tax return to be able to receive the top-up. Recipients will need to file their 2025 tax return to receive the increased Canada groceries and essentials benefit payments as of July 2026. \n\nAs we know, this benefit is one example of the many ways we are supporting Canadians during these unprecedented times. It will be in addition to existing benefits, such as the Canada child benefit, the Canada disability benefit and the guaranteed income supplement, which are already providing relief to millions of Canadians. \n\nThe government is committed to limiting pressure on everyday costs for Canadians. Budget 2025 outlined how we will spend less on government operations and cut waste so we can invest more in growing our economy and protecting essential programs and initiatives that make life more affordable. There are programs and initiatives like the national school food program, which we are making permanent so that it can continue providing meals for up to 400,000 children every year. We are renewing the Canada Strong pass to help families and young people travel and explore Canada for less, and we are launching automated federal benefits that will reach up to 5.5 million low-income Canadians for the 2028 tax year.\n\n Bill C-19 also builds on measures we have introduced to lower costs for Canadians and protect essential programs like cutting taxes for 22 million middle-class Canadians, eliminating the GST for first-time homebuyers on new homes under $1 million, lowering the GST for first-time homebuyers on new homes between $1 million and $1.5 million, and cancelling the federal consumer carbon tax.\n\nAffordability measures, especially those related to food, require immediate support for Canadians. As previously mentioned, it is estimated that 12.6 million individuals and families would benefit from the new Canada groceries and essentials benefit, representing a material support to Canadians who need it the most while the government's plan to build the strongest economy in the G7 takes effect.\n\nThe government is focused on building a stronger economy to create more career opportunities and higher wages. In parallel, we are limiting cost pressures to make life more affordable. That is how we will empower more Canadians with greater certainty, security and prosperity, now and into the future.\n\nI urge all hon. members to pass Bill C-19 without delay, so that we can ensure Canadians get this much-needed relief as soon as possible.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77468","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank the member for Beauport—Limoilou for sharing his time with me. \n\nIt is my pleasure to take part in this debate today on Bill C-19, the Canada groceries and essentials benefits act. As we all know, advanced economies around the world are facing complex economic challenges, and Canada is no different. Rising protectionism in the form of tariffs, supply chain disrup","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7a180c1d47bf3d28280e5b21ba132fcf5a74fa8f08cbf887fc68b91e94370fa7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a92e3b18ba86661c1b804dc66fddfed679588e8d9cc52b3454eafbb3d3363abc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2dafde198a322ed3b1bba99b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77469,"date":"2026-02-04T21:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would not agree with the causes of the high price for food that the hon. member mentioned. It is more realistic to understand that the high prices for food at this time are due more to tariffs, climate change and things like that. This program is not intended to be a magic bullet that will solve all the problems. This is a program that will help people to weather the storm while our other major undertakings take root and prosper.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77469","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would not agree with the causes of the high price for food that the hon. member mentioned. It is more realistic to understand that the high prices for food at this time are due more to tariffs, climate change and things like that. This program is not intended to be a magic bullet that will solve all the problems. This is a program that will help people to weather the storm while our","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037232","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Storms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037232","label":"Storms","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd492c6e5eed546f31cc3f64997489b565ae14105db1f3135198392531819553"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fedeebe1d0345487f44ced71e063c1fc9fa505ce4474a5dbac77f9cb2b5775f1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c9f1f248be3a27986cc041a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77470,"date":"2026-02-04T21:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will refer to my predecessor, who answered the question about whether payments are monthly or quarterly. It is a practical matter of getting things out in an efficient and effective manner.\n\n In terms of the overall budget that we presented before Christmas, it still has to be passed. It still has to go through all the steps it needs to go through. This is faster. This will allow us to deal with some of the intermediate problems that we are going to face over the coming months in a much quicker way.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77470","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will refer to my predecessor, who answered the question about whether payments are monthly or quarterly. It is a practical matter of getting things out in an efficient and effective manner.\n\n In terms of the overall budget that we presented before Christmas, it still has to be passed. It still has to go through all the steps it needs to go through. This is faster. This will allow us","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2bac4e02a60748e5d1b187a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77471,"date":"2026-02-04T21:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I believe that my constituents are very happy with the results that we are producing. I have heard very solid and promising comments from people. They are very excited to see the outcome of the budget when it happens, and certainly, in the interim, to see measures like this take effect.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77471","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I believe that my constituents are very happy with the results that we are producing. I have heard very solid and promising comments from people. They are very excited to see the outcome of the budget when it happens, and certainly, in the interim, to see measures like this take effect.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5a83fe006d8b34619817f163225fd0e463af4e3f3a0fb7d985acf8813508716a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b7851cf1e79e09c53c87c0d5da607011e91e74844bc0e0400b2f382a78cd81a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e68f1c5dfe2dde1c1bff100c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77472,"date":"2026-02-04T21:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would say that we are always open to collaboration with the opposition benches. We are looking for solutions for Canadians and moving things forward in a coherent and efficient manner.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77472","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would say that we are always open to collaboration with the opposition benches. We are looking for solutions for Canadians and moving things forward in a coherent and efficient manner.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0756608404ad32594d8732d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":93005,"date":"2026-02-09T19:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Iranian Canadians' hearts ache every day. It is the silence after an email that never delivers, the fear when a loved one cannot be reached and the worry that a simple act of courage will be met with violence. In our communities across B.C.'s Lower Mainland, many are living this reality right now, as they have relatives and friends in Iran facing repression, detention and worse. To them, I want to say clearly, I hear them and they are not alone.\n\nWe mourn those who have been lost, including the victims of flight PS752, and we stand with families still seeking truth, justice and accountability. I will keep listening to Iranian Canadians, and I will keep pressing the Government of Canada to work with partners to defend human rights and protect our communities here from intimidation and foreign interference.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:93005","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Iranian Canadians' hearts ache every day. It is the silence after an email that never delivers, the fear when a loved one cannot be reached and the worry that a simple act of courage will be met with violence. In our communities across B.C.'s Lower Mainland, many are living this reality right now, as they have relatives and friends in Iran facing repression, detention and worse. To th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","label":"Social problems","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1dbb89eb80a7dac0656be0f15b52ad0917597cc0314e0198e531c78516f2621"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05e5d7cb08580cec59fa4048","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":93006,"date":"2026-02-09T20:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let me start by acknowledging that Canada's Parliament is located on the unceded, unsurrendered territory of the Anishinabe Algonquin people, whose presence here reaches back to time immemorial.\n\nI am honoured to rise in the House today to speak in support of Bill C-10, an act respecting the commissioner for modern treaty implementation. This legislation represents a vital step forward, one that would strengthen accountability, enhance transparency and build trust with modern treaty partners across the country. It would also reinforce our shared commitment to reconciliation and to ensuring that Canada keeps its promises.\n\nFor too long, there has been a gap between the commitments made in modern treaties and the reality of their implementation. This bill would take a significant step toward closing that gap. By establishing an independent agent of Parliament, the commissioner for modern treaty implementation, Canada would ensure that progress on modern treaty obligations is transparent, measurable and accountable. This is not a symbolic gesture. It is a concrete, practical reform that would support real progress in implementing the rights and relationships enshrined in modern treaties.\n\nOur government has made significant policy changes that enable us to conclude treaty negotiations faster and more effectively. As a result, Liberal governments over the past decade have signed or initialled five modern treaties, including, most recently, with the Manitoba Métis Federation in 2024. Right now, Canada's new government is nearing the initialling of six new modern treaties, and we will continue to advance this important work alongside indigenous partners. This bill and the commissioner it would create would build trust, enhance transparency and deliver the results that modern treaty partners have been advocating for. When it comes to modern treaties, we intend to listen to indigenous partners.\n\nThe commissioner would provide independent oversight of federal activities related to modern treaty implementation, ensuring that progress is visible and its shortcomings are addressed transparently. Through regular reporting and public accountability, Canadians and modern treaty partners alike would have a clear picture of how Canada is meeting its obligations. Accountability is at the heart of this legislation.\n\nThe commissioner would join a distinguished group of agents of Parliament, officers who safeguard the principles of our democracy, like the Auditor General, who ensures public funds are used effectively; the Privacy Commissioner, who protects Canadians' personal information; the Information Commissioner, who upholds the right to know; and the Commissioner of Official Languages, who defends linguistic rights across federal institutions. Each plays a vital role in strengthening public trust, yet until now, there has been no independent oversight to ensure that Canada fulfills its constitutional obligations under modern treaties. That is the gap this legislation would fill.\n\nThe commissioner would have full and direct access to the information required to evaluate federal performance, a level of independence on par with other oversight officers such as the Auditor General and Privacy Commissioner. This is the benchmark of openness and accountability, essential to maintaining public confidence and ensuring credible, evidence-based oversight. Transparency is not about blame. It is about clarity, openness and shared progress.\n\nWhen modern treaty partners, Parliament and Canadians can see how modern treaty implementation is progressing, trust grows. Imagine a future where all Canadians can access clear information on where treaty commitments are being fulfilled and where more work is needed. That is what this bill would deliver.\n\nTransparency empowers communities, strengthens governance and builds the foundation for a better relationship between Canada and indigenous peoples. Transparency and trust make good governance stronger. They turn promises into measurable progress and ensure that reconciliation is grounded in evidence and results.\n\nReconciliation takes shape through the everyday work of implementing commitments, resolving gaps and fostering trust. This legislation would move reconciliation from aspiration to administration, ensuring that the work of partnership is measured and maintained. Modern treaties are at the core of this journey. They affirm indigenous rights and outline shared responsibilities for the future.\n\n However, treaties are only as strong as their implementation. The bill would ensure that implementation will be guided by independent oversight, clear reporting and mutual accountability. By embedding transparency and accountability into our systems, we are advancing reconciliation not just with words but with action.\n\nThe commissioner's work would complement Canada's commitments under the Truth and Reconciliation Commission calls to action and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act. These frameworks remind us that oversight and accountability are not obstacles to reconciliation; they are its foundation.\n\nWhat is great about the legislation is that it was co-developed with modern treaty partners. Over 130 indigenous governments and organizations were engaged in shaping this proposal, ensuring the design reflects their experience and priorities. That process has already built trust, and that trust will continue once the commissioner begins their work.\n\nAs the Tli?cho Government stated, \"The Commissioner for Modern Treaty has been decades in the making. This is an exciting moment that our hard work together has paid off, and this important mechanism for accountability and oversight will be established.\"\n\nThrough ongoing engagement and dialogue, the commissioner would ensure that the perspectives of modern treaty partners are reflected in the reviews and recommendations. This is how partnership becomes policy and how reconciliation becomes reality.\n\nModern treaties are much more than legal instruments. They are blueprints for opportunity. They provide a framework for governance, education, infrastructure and economic development. When implemented effectively, they enable indigenous governments to plan long-term, attract investment and create jobs. By improving implementation and accountability, the bill would strengthen those outcomes, not only for indigenous peoples but for all Canadians.\n\nModern treaties contribute to stronger local economies, better infrastructure and sustainable growth. When indigenous communities thrive, Canada thrives. As an agent of Parliament, the commissioner would report directly to Parliament, ensuring independence from political influence. These reports would highlight successes, identify challenges and recommend systemic improvements to ensure better outcomes. This accountability mechanism would serve both Parliament and modern treaty partners, providing transparent information and supporting continuous progress.\n\nAccountability is not about perfection. It is about persistence, learning and the courage to adapt. It shows modern treaty partners that Canada is prepared to hold itself to the same standard of responsibility it asks of others.\n\nThe bill is about accountability, trust and reconciliation in action. It ensures that Canada fulfills not only the letter of its modern treaty obligations but also the spirit, grounded in partnership, respect and shared responsibility. The commissioner for modern treaty implementation would bring independent oversight, greater transparency and meaningful accountability. This is not a cost but a tool that would prevent disputes, strengthen relationships and deliver lasting results.\n\nWe have made progress, but we know there is more to do. Let us seize upon this opportunity to make reconciliation real, not only with words but with measurable results. The bill strengthens the institutions that uphold reconciliation, not by rewriting the past but by ensuring accountability for the future. By supporting the act, we affirm that transparency and trust are the cornerstones of our shared journey forward. Meegwetch. Qujannamiik. Marsi.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:93006","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let me start by acknowledging that Canada's Parliament is located on the unceded, unsurrendered territory of the Anishinabe Algonquin people, whose presence here reaches back to time immemorial.\n\nI am honoured to rise in the House today to speak in support of Bill C-10, an act respecting the commissioner for modern treaty implementation. This legislation represents a vital step forwar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["422eb931718fd55d2d78ddf3260c423fa01dac42987ce5583dc2a68d0b14327f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b58ddec5da2e3bf27c4ce245851c7a985771ae150f28eaaf8e38b753e45a0007"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fbd854af1873439b734e0d27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":93007,"date":"2026-02-09T20:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, while it is true that existing committees can undertake studies of this kind, many committees do a lot of work on many different things.\n\n What is important about this approach is that it is a focus mechanism that is deeply integrated in our relationship with indigenous people and would allow this new agent of Parliament to focus very directly, on an ongoing basis, on matters that are of concern to indigenous partners.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:93007","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, while it is true that existing committees can undertake studies of this kind, many committees do a lot of work on many different things.\n\n What is important about this approach is that it is a focus mechanism that is deeply integrated in our relationship with indigenous people and would allow this new agent of Parliament to focus very directly, on an ongoing basis, on matters that are","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e53573efe6f3faa3224882dc6fd88a522583e207fba9bffacf27d751da4cfd3d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["254bdf35c3ea017f07d7225acd88183fcd78e2c4acab3db5ec780ced00dcf8cb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-265fca3e04e48505eafceeb4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":93008,"date":"2026-02-09T20:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my colleague's support for the bill. \n\nIn terms of what we call it, that is really up to the legislation. I have no objection to his suggestion, but I would suggest that once it, hopefully, passes second reading, this is something that could be addressed in committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:93008","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my colleague's support for the bill. \n\nIn terms of what we call it, that is really up to the legislation. I have no objection to his suggestion, but I would suggest that once it, hopefully, passes second reading, this is something that could be addressed in committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d87ba78a3e2554344d3903935bae45e6cee12bc35885c8dd77d47af1babc716e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23b16ee5bf9ce3982ee65daf5eab20ea13ae29cfa27e98748cf35af7639f6c67"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b16b8fcc073b40f579c1a533","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":93009,"date":"2026-02-09T20:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a list here of dozens of indigenous partners that were consulted. In my speech, I mentioned there were 130 organizations and indigenous governments that were consulted. \n\nThis position of an independent agent of Parliament has been requested by indigenous partners and peoples for at least 20 years. It is critical in being able to focus on the deficiencies in the processes and to make sure that we achieve effective progress going forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:93009","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a list here of dozens of indigenous partners that were consulted. In my speech, I mentioned there were 130 organizations and indigenous governments that were consulted. \n\nThis position of an independent agent of Parliament has been requested by indigenous partners and peoples for at least 20 years. It is critical in being able to focus on the deficiencies in the processes and t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ba121df90eed728e0df258f2525ce443fdef1970e93ad22f437805a45871b67b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7976800491749eead8c7e6799c79ed1de56fbe89dbd76b6c86c0a13339c488d4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd1e60c00a3289796593568d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":93010,"date":"2026-02-09T20:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I certainly agree with my hon. colleague about how important this bill is for all of us, each and every person in this country who benefits from a long-time establishment on former indigenous lands, unceded and unreconciled. We all have a stake in the outcome, and we all have something to offer going forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:93010","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I certainly agree with my hon. colleague about how important this bill is for all of us, each and every person in this country who benefits from a long-time establishment on former indigenous lands, unceded and unreconciled. We all have a stake in the outcome, and we all have something to offer going forward.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82b62889e05dba3146f04c17ceb75dbd2b0a4ac8a5a938b317ab839620cd5885"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7760ec0017f7ce9872216ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":96203,"date":"2026-02-09T21:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member mentioned that Parliament's remit is not only legislation but also holding government to account. He mentioned many times the Auditor General. I would remind the member that the role of this new commissioner is exactly in parallel with that of the Auditor General. Its job is to inform Parliament, to make Parliament more able to hold ministers to account and to hold government to account.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96203","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member mentioned that Parliament's remit is not only legislation but also holding government to account. He mentioned many times the Auditor General. I would remind the member that the role of this new commissioner is exactly in parallel with that of the Auditor General. Its job is to inform Parliament, to make Parliament more able to hold ministers to account and to hold governme","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["259e78f8b306e3e9a1412da063aef1b43d16653e54f252976668e0e26bdffa84"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c3f40cf50fe8417781248b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":96204,"date":"2026-02-09T21:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member is concerned that there is no enforcement capability in this agency, while at the same time he is bewailing what he considers the creation of a bureaucracy. I would suggest that if enforcement were incorporated, that would mandate an enormous bureaucracy.\n\n In truth, there would be no bureaucracy around the position. This is all about using the bureaucracy of the House of Commons to hold the government to account. The role of the agency would be to be a tool of Parliament so Parliament can be kept informed on an ongoing, live basis of situations that need action and so the House can hold the government to account.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96204","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member is concerned that there is no enforcement capability in this agency, while at the same time he is bewailing what he considers the creation of a bureaucracy. I would suggest that if enforcement were incorporated, that would mandate an enormous bureaucracy.\n\n In truth, there would be no bureaucracy around the position. This is all about using the bureaucracy of the House of C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4838ba3d0cdc3d73b28288a4ddba3cc985c5249ce9e3d6a103557d6779e5d992"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-baddc8581d0234381335593c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":93004,"date":"2026-02-12T19:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Tuesday's tragic events at Tumbler Ridge Secondary School have left a community devastated. My heart is with the families grieving unimaginable loss. I am wishing love and strength to the people who were injured and to the students, staff and residents who are now trying to process what happened. No community should have to experience this kind of violence.\n\n I want to acknowledge the courage and professionalism of all first responders, educators and local officials who acted swiftly to protect others and to respond in a moment of crisis.\n\n On behalf of Coquitlam—Port Coquitlam, I extend our deepest condolences to everyone affected. We stand with the people of Tumbler Ridge, all British Columbians and indeed all Canadians at this heartbreaking time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:93004","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Tuesday's tragic events at Tumbler Ridge Secondary School have left a community devastated. My heart is with the families grieving unimaginable loss. I am wishing love and strength to the people who were injured and to the students, staff and residents who are now trying to process what happened. No community should have to experience this kind of violence.\n\n I want to acknowledge the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7c80518cb93d339b2812addcd7ec162941a81154f8ddbc21271b78f6b893a4cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8c5f30d8756329af507e4f5d689de3bf6005da3dc6ed241ac16ade5b765024c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fdf62cfa6b6dafaae440d12e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103670,"date":"2026-04-13T17:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you, Chair. I'm going to start with Ms. Hogan. You mentioned that you studied three bases. Could you tell me what the three bases are?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103670","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. I'm going to start with Ms. Hogan. You mentioned that you studied three bases. Could you tell me what the three bases are?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fertilizers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fertilizers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70289","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Nuclear power plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43107","label":"Fertilizers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","label":"Indigenous reserves","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70289","label":"Nuclear power plants","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b8577a4e834a8318f7898233193cfdc5f574f5de261fb583f10c06f3be984435"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1197a660d87e9322b0ac4bb1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103671,"date":"2026-04-13T17:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Would you say your data from these bases is fairly representative of the situation at large?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103671","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Would you say your data from these bases is fairly representative of the situation at large?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","label":"Data processing","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cfe7595df679cf01083fe1f88f2a1ac5cbfca6c661555c35e4f028bd4126f5de"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d579b40c4c0397f7f490e5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103672,"date":"2026-04-13T17:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Okay. Thanks. I also note that this study was done from, I think, March 2024 to April 2025. That's a year ago. Do we have any idea of how things may have changed, improved or gotten worse?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103672","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Thanks. I also note that this study was done from, I think, March 2024 to April 2025. That's a year ago. Do we have any idea of how things may have changed, improved or gotten worse?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011992","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Biodegradation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011992","label":"Biodegradation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df7ff16df3f2b8a6c1bee9a63409d95e4266dbd1621a241b62034b81f2996b0c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86000cbdaa5ca0e13bc1d778","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103673,"date":"2026-04-13T17:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you. Ms. Fox, when people are assigned to a new base, is it the general expectation that they will find accommodations in the general market around them, or is it the expectation that they will find something on base?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103673","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Ms. Fox, when people are assigned to a new base, is it the general expectation that they will find accommodations in the general market around them, or is it the expectation that they will find something on base?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","label":"Incentives","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["80a059473d97a709a4244e772eefa2a6713097cbf2a8348ad0dc4456dee6c469"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f26c15ddc2c4cf3136df192265b6070db67dc5bab0ea40a427ec2749fec9fcdf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e305634628c3450d11936121","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103674,"date":"2026-04-13T17:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"For a place like Esquimalt, you have Victoria, Sidney and that whole area. You have a large area of market-based availability for residences. For someplace like Yellowknife, it's quite different. How does this affect your decisions and the planning for residences?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103674","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"For a place like Esquimalt, you have Victoria, Sidney and that whole area. You have a large area of market-based availability for residences. For someplace like Yellowknife, it's quite different. How does this affect your decisions and the planning for residences?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb77ccd0342377bed2f4a82ba1da1e83f12a0d27b7a41867e3157c71523d0fa3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5545df6e60c003e6e708cdf83f986bd7fc70570788ed370347d8e2756021569b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebc74803a53113aef938d6b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103675,"date":"2026-04-13T17:05:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I don't know if it was you, but someone mentioned 189 units in Yellowknife. This sounds like a lot for Yellowknife, but we have to get to 10,000 units eventually. We'll never get there if we do 200 here and 200 there. How do we do this? Who is responsible? Whom do we hold accountable for meeting this requirement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103675","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I don't know if it was you, but someone mentioned 189 units in Yellowknife. This sounds like a lot for Yellowknife, but we have to get to 10,000 units eventually. We'll never get there if we do 200 here and 200 there. How do we do this? Who is responsible? Whom do we hold accountable for meeting this requirement?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d4ce49696edca6c1755f6ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103676,"date":"2026-04-13T17:05:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Whom do we hold accountable for making sure this is done?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103676","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Whom do we hold accountable for making sure this is done?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","label":"Whistleblower protection","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b0d4f4560995397cdb317a1c8af35ce842115a4c418b73a2bd6bc0a40e683022"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a908c6beae80466bfb5a87ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103677,"date":"2026-04-13T18:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I'm going to carry on. I talked earlier about accountability and who's responsible. I think the answer was that DND is responsible, but that's a little too blurry for my taste. I think, for the housing, that the Canadian Forces Housing Agency is the one responsible for that. As you are the chief executive officer, I think we need to be able to hold you accountable. Would you say that's correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103677","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm going to carry on. I talked earlier about accountability and who's responsible. I think the answer was that DND is responsible, but that's a little too blurry for my taste. I think, for the housing, that the Canadian Forces Housing Agency is the one responsible for that. As you are the chief executive officer, I think we need to be able to hold you accountable. Would you say that's correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e0e7ce7dff1bd2fc23ac8394d70e8ca332bb25770b1f158645f015286b910e2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d08eb26a3a519beb2e2acb88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103678,"date":"2026-04-13T18:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I understand. Do you need any further clarification of the mandate? Is the mandate sufficiently clear for the Canadian Forces Housing Agency?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103678","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I understand. Do you need any further clarification of the mandate? Is the mandate sufficiently clear for the Canadian Forces Housing Agency?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Military law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752121","label":"Military law","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bba1e3f03ad1e6b665c37ac9212f9eef8580baa7e1e0b5b26eef4c531704564"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa434308ecce1cde1d403aae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103679,"date":"2026-04-13T18:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Is there anything more you need from the government, from us, to help you meet this mandate?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103679","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is there anything more you need from the government, from us, to help you meet this mandate?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ff159e41cb9abe2a40f6acd47bd4a2018868c80ebd6f3e76d78684d0b48de07"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7deb19af7c6d95bdc7d3e44f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103680,"date":"2026-04-13T18:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"One thing we heard earlier was that, of 35 housing units, 32 needed major repairs that weren't done. Is this a problem of a lack of resources, a lack of people to do it? There's also a consideration of many inspections that weren't done. Do you need more resources? Do you need more money to do this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103680","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"One thing we heard earlier was that, of 35 housing units, 32 needed major repairs that weren't done. Is this a problem of a lack of resources, a lack of people to do it? There's also a consideration of many inspections that weren't done. Do you need more resources? Do you need more money to do this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-375363d601a08c9e0c597e07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103681,"date":"2026-04-13T18:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"In the last two minutes, I'll see if anyone needs to give any summarizing remarks. Ms. Fox, would you like to wrap anything up?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103681","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the last two minutes, I'll see if anyone needs to give any summarizing remarks. Ms. Fox, would you like to wrap anything up?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66262a9b26895c103d24b9bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103682,"date":"2026-04-13T18:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Are there any other remarks? No. I guess that's it for me, then. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103682","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are there any other remarks? No. I guess that's it for me, then. Thank you, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-010fd813f76f3f4704d0072b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103683,"date":"2026-04-15T22:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. You mentioned that the bank cannot go insolvent. When you spend more than you bring in, does that mean you borrow money from the receiver general? Is that what I heard?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103683","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. You mentioned that the bank cannot go insolvent. When you spend more than you bring in, does that mean you borrow money from the receiver general? Is that what I heard?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d21f4effd52db69fa0151d9382a94f5155e81590588ea817f24ffbcdf6224eaf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b05551b46a7bf7b8007a90f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103684,"date":"2026-04-15T22:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"You are in a unique position, obviously. I'm interested to hear this: If you spend more than you earn but are not borrowing money, how do you close that gap in the interim?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103684","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You are in a unique position, obviously. I'm interested to hear this: If you spend more than you earn but are not borrowing money, how do you close that gap in the interim?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5149f9b56db62474b87fd74b2d71a6c8a29095833cba07391da5d5989678eba4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2868432f1b0def6284bf6276","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103685,"date":"2026-04-15T22:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I guess what I'm hearing—and I'm not sure I'm hearing correctly—is that these losses or gains are just bookkeeping entries. There's no money transfer involved whatsoever.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103685","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I guess what I'm hearing—and I'm not sure I'm hearing correctly—is that these losses or gains are just bookkeeping entries. There's no money transfer involved whatsoever.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a83aa1800d948b297a6d92d37db9b60a4d8b48714c43a02124cc330fd52d49db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["493d631bdf1fa55a960e79e0a6d735bbecf763d692f68e6660b2004fa030cea4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d04bbafbb01531698db643e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103686,"date":"2026-04-15T22:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I'm trying to put this in the context of my credit card. It doesn't work. Some hon. members: Oh, oh! Ron McKinnon: I want to segue now. The Prime Minister is making a distinction between capital spending and operational spending. How is that going to affect the public accounts?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103686","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm trying to put this in the context of my credit card. It doesn't work. Some hon. members: Oh, oh! Ron McKinnon: I want to segue now. The Prime Minister is making a distinction between capital spending and operational spending. How is that going to affect the public accounts?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33177851c04d1b7df1774814","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103687,"date":"2026-04-15T22:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I'm not sure if you can comment on this. I'm not sure if it fits. Can you comment on the relationship between government fiscal policies and monetary policies? I guess the bank is supposed to control inflation somewhat by adjusting interest rates and so forth. That's monetary policy. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103687","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm not sure if you can comment on this. I'm not sure if it fits. Can you comment on the relationship between government fiscal policies and monetary policies? I guess the bank is supposed to control inflation somewhat by adjusting interest rates and so forth. That's monetary policy. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21b693107ac460c9b1067e16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103688,"date":"2026-04-15T22:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Are you able to speak to monetary policy at this point?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103688","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are you able to speak to monetary policy at this point?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b323991054b064302d684d98f5d8bb247892f0614b456841700be5080262ccf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-034fffd43d6533a58b75b645","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103689,"date":"2026-04-15T22:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103689","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24be3041f624ef266bbd24c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103690,"date":"2026-04-15T23:10:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I support the motion in general, but I think 30 days.... We have no idea what the governor's schedule is. I would support inviting him and trying to find a time that works for him, but let's get rid of the 30 days from the motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103690","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I support the motion in general, but I think 30 days.... We have no idea what the governor's schedule is. I would support inviting him and trying to find a time that works for him, but let's get rid of the 30 days from the motion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-763b92760d4909a4ebfbdbf2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103691,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you all for being here. I appreciate it. What I think I'm hearing is that the lack of instruction resources is a major limitation. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103691","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you all for being here. I appreciate it. What I think I'm hearing is that the lack of instruction resources is a major limitation. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6038abf32994bfc6b2ade45617242de6fe7677af7ec66b8d9ff4e2c59a8e5284"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85c4978693b8f409440a16d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103692,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"If we had more instruction resources, would that alone help us to increase our rates of growth?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103692","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If we had more instruction resources, would that alone help us to increase our rates of growth?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","label":"Rates","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c909ab54581b6ff568ae235ecfd83aefa52b91cc050ff06343fb992a2556355a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc60cc6f40f95d2cba381d93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103693,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Let's focus a little bit more on instruction resources. What can we do to improve and increase those? Is this a problem with retention? Are we having trouble retaining the personnel who conduct these instruction exercises?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103693","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Let's focus a little bit more on instruction resources. What can we do to improve and increase those? Is this a problem with retention? Are we having trouble retaining the personnel who conduct these instruction exercises?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fba7a4acbbf016e52be3be05a3dbb0ba6454bae40c97b9fd32f2f50240d755e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8aa952287862c71c579a1e2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103694,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"You're saying that there are incentives in place now to encourage instructors to be instructors and to remain in the forces. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103694","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You're saying that there are incentives in place now to encourage instructors to be instructors and to remain in the forces. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","label":"Incentives","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e93f9a19b2ce15aba89517320b37971cd329eb12a649890b3698ea71788005e9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9040ddb7e6ad64227953bd4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103695,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"What do you mean by \"training line?\" I don't understand that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103695","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What do you mean by \"training line?\" I don't understand that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e040fe4ad670d63266c182312e86b47181c8c4b89e3c7b98c3006569d6cd88b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af2ab6258cf51f3b4c361f7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103696,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"With more training lines, we're training more people on a concurrent basis. Is that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103696","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"With more training lines, we're training more people on a concurrent basis. Is that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5d63de4f92639b6104cc351b6cc0a6159633dfbcff4d5f1e02d16da7ac0c46b8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39748b1a02fcf45173c6baa7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103697,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I want to go back to retention. Are we having problems with qualified instructors dropping out of the forces?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103697","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to go back to retention. Are we having problems with qualified instructors dropping out of the forces?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","label":"Military training","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e5780e6d4b94c8db36d724fdf13af0faaf939bdcfa1a478246c791b867d42f9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98418080c88c0b491476b3eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103698,"date":"2026-04-20T16:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Are there any particular gaps in our ability to instruct, or any particular professions or roles that need to be better staffed in order to do that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103698","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are there any particular gaps in our ability to instruct, or any particular professions or roles that need to be better staffed in order to do that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a211857cecaf3664ed8a29754738ece4c61f540cded96d0cf8d43ef0db65e9fb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55ba5a72f21c9dcba690d2fd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103699,"date":"2026-04-20T16:45:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"That's great. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103699","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's great. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-294cf30a74b1c26287d9b57e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103700,"date":"2026-04-22T21:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you, Chair. We welcome the Auditor General's report. Thank you. It's very favourable. It indicates that the intents of the program have been largely met, and certainly, strengthening the integrity of the system is a top priority. One of the things I believe I heard from Mr. Gallivan's testimony was the difference in opinion relating to the amount of fraud cases that have been investigated. Is there a difference between how the Auditor General categorizes these and how the IRCC categorizes them? If you'd each like to respond to that, I'd appreciate it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103700","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. We welcome the Auditor General's report. Thank you. It's very favourable. It indicates that the intents of the program have been largely met, and certainly, strengthening the integrity of the system is a top priority. One of the things I believe I heard from Mr. Gallivan's testimony was the difference in opinion relating to the amount of fraud cases that have been investigated. I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da59f732a0010d56004724ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103701,"date":"2026-04-22T21:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"It sounds like the investigation of potential fraud has been very adequately and satisfactorily addressed. Do you believe that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103701","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It sounds like the investigation of potential fraud has been very adequately and satisfactorily addressed. Do you believe that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Internal audits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","label":"Internal audits","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1676475bfc8c2d9d4f33f3983140f00a4a614cac6712cf2d99d716f74b163deb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b7b03302c34c82a4c7c8fd6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103702,"date":"2026-04-22T21:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"That brings me to a more general question, Mr. Gallivan. What is your department's response to the feedback shared by the Auditor General, and what steps will your department be taking going forward to address these concerns?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103702","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That brings me to a more general question, Mr. Gallivan. What is your department's response to the feedback shared by the Auditor General, and what steps will your department be taking going forward to address these concerns?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Internal audits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","label":"Internal audits","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ccab97f9aaca705106010132ccafdf7109c531f7b597885c6bf78157e85ea078"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d3e169a06fe598e7933bb55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103703,"date":"2026-04-22T21:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I have a few seconds left. I'm interested in the numbers, which have fallen substantially in terms of approvals, but I understand the applications have fallen substantially as well and that the educational institutions have not been recruiting as vigorously. Do you have any comment on that or explanation for that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103703","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a few seconds left. I'm interested in the numbers, which have fallen substantially in terms of approvals, but I understand the applications have fallen substantially as well and that the educational institutions have not been recruiting as vigorously. Do you have any comment on that or explanation for that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ae63942736adcc7c75c7769216e3af70891d192a6038b69c2af1cb9433ac120"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34c9c4333c53ef9e7ebbbc17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103704,"date":"2026-04-22T21:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103704","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e0ed897263986ba69a964f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103705,"date":"2026-04-22T22:10:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I think it's a very interesting motion. It's something I could get behind, but I have some issues. One concern I have is about the independence of the Auditor General . We cannot be seen to be directing her to do anything. I have no problem making a request of her to take action. I would move to amend this motion in a paragraph that says, \"and the committee further write to the Auditor General to undertake\". I think it would be clearer if we change that \"undertake\" to \"request\". Second, at the end, it says, \"and the committee report this request to the House\". I would move to drop that line .","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103705","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I think it's a very interesting motion. It's something I could get behind, but I have some issues. One concern I have is about the independence of the Auditor General . We cannot be seen to be directing her to do anything. I have no problem making a request of her to take action. I would move to amend this motion in a paragraph that says, \"and the committee further write to the Auditor General to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7de88091bbba492405c3a169","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103706,"date":"2026-04-22T22:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I have a problem with \"undertake\".","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103706","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a problem with \"undertake\".","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af9a63aae493c2b5892cdff4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103707,"date":"2026-04-22T22:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I'll accept that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103707","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll accept that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ae3b6c5cdadfb715265eff2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103708,"date":"2026-04-22T22:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I was just going to say that I don't think the Auditor General needs something to catch her attention on this. I agree with my colleagues.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103708","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I was just going to say that I don't think the Auditor General needs something to catch her attention on this. I agree with my colleagues.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Internal audits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","label":"Internal audits","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1b50b95bbfa48ed54e0f979a42dc054989f7a7109d74d7b68c37df65886d6d2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84aefd7a51c9c7ec0d8d506a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103709,"date":"2026-04-22T23:45:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"If it's okay, I'd like to cede my time to Mr. Osborne.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103709","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If it's okay, I'd like to cede my time to Mr. Osborne.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083643","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Time zones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083643","label":"Time zones","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75b3b898d27bc808cee9d8798d1540417b29619f8b032ef3da551760a7aa3a1b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d4d5bb372db0c554f2fe9f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103710,"date":"2026-04-22T23:45:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I'll—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103710","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-232c1afa0ae55656e137f2e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103711,"date":"2026-04-22T23:45:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"No, that's okay. First of all, our colleague is here because Professor Derksen wasn't, not because it indicates any ulterior motive of the government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103711","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, that's okay. First of all, our colleague is here because Professor Derksen wasn't, not because it indicates any ulterior motive of the government.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4130119cc93d6b0d576c7dbb9069b4db3a8a92181d79c9c7df3b0257c146edea"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad34f2dcd149517a8c20368f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103712,"date":"2026-04-22T23:45:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Mr. Lemire mentioned that we want to toe the line and keep costs in order and so forth, and we don't want to waste taxpayer money. That's exactly the point of what we're trying to negotiate with Mr. Lemire. We're trying to keep the number of documents to a manageable level and to a time frame that is reasonable and responsible. In that respect, I'd like to submit an amendment. In the second paragraph of this motion in English, I'd like to change the word \"management\" where it says \"relating to the management of the Modernization of Benefit Payments\", to say, \"estimates and costs\". That would be my amendment at this point.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103712","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Lemire mentioned that we want to toe the line and keep costs in order and so forth, and we don't want to waste taxpayer money. That's exactly the point of what we're trying to negotiate with Mr. Lemire. We're trying to keep the number of documents to a manageable level and to a time frame that is reasonable and responsible. In that respect, I'd like to submit an amendment. In the second paragr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c1e93123d2b59e22d1ef909","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103713,"date":"2026-04-22T23:50:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I just want to emphasize that the point here is to keep this to a manageable request and a doable thing. Mr. Lemire mentioned his concern about wasting taxpayer money. If we issue a request for these documents—a massive data dump—it could cost millions of dollars. It could take weeks and weeks. I want to keep this reasonable and manageable. This is, as Mr. Osborne mentioned, a good-faith attempt to do so.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103713","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I just want to emphasize that the point here is to keep this to a manageable request and a doable thing. Mr. Lemire mentioned his concern about wasting taxpayer money. If we issue a request for these documents—a massive data dump—it could cost millions of dollars. It could take weeks and weeks. I want to keep this reasonable and manageable. This is, as Mr. Osborne mentioned, a good-faith attempt t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3e9979bfcb3bd1821e32a87cb7b346204199f93033aaabcb3f88669c1cc45da"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4c69066e7af759e21609f97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103714,"date":"2026-04-22T23:55:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Drilling down into what exactly \"estimates and costs\" entail is very technical. I don't think we want to get into the level of defining legal terms and so forth, but it's much more specific than \"management\". \"Management\", broadly speaking, is a very general saying. Can we focus this on estimates and costs, as we go forward? If that's not the kind of information Mr. Lemire wants, we can modify it later on. For now, keep this request reasonable. Keep it manageable and doable, because we certainly want to get the information that it needs before this committee. I think that's an appropriate change at this time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103714","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Drilling down into what exactly \"estimates and costs\" entail is very technical. I don't think we want to get into the level of defining legal terms and so forth, but it's much more specific than \"management\". \"Management\", broadly speaking, is a very general saying. Can we focus this on estimates and costs, as we go forward? If that's not the kind of information Mr. Lemire wants, we can modify it ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f2fb66e63e658b98ffede2f54482e5d430a42a2b9fa48b9113dab01509e4c2f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8299527b586d983d35c2c73a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103715,"date":"2026-04-27T16:15:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I want to talk about these four barriers that were identified. I'm wondering if something can be done to empower first nations groups to have more effect on whether these things are followed through on. At this point, it looks like these are impediments on the government side at Indigenous Services and so forth. What about the other side of the equation? Can the groups themselves be empowered, and in what way could we do that? Either one of you can go ahead. Whoever has the best answer can go first.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103715","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to talk about these four barriers that were identified. I'm wondering if something can be done to empower first nations groups to have more effect on whether these things are followed through on. At this point, it looks like these are impediments on the government side at Indigenous Services and so forth. What about the other side of the equation? Can the groups themselves be empowered, and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["798c8c6efa8add9b784fb14cb53f6da040af2cb842c353f38e2a496047556ecf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-92af8f0b21f08769ba2ddb97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103716,"date":"2026-04-27T16:20:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Do we have to give them new tools to do this? If so, what kinds of tools would you suggest we bring to the table?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103716","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do we have to give them new tools to do this? If so, what kinds of tools would you suggest we bring to the table?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034716","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crafts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034716","label":"Crafts","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","label":"Assistive technologies","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["151f8ace660383a6a0e3bbdd455a3f13b3c039e5704a2dae2125b6b4ded98e5b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b574a682cbeb0c4d12a8264a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103717,"date":"2026-04-27T16:20:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Indigenous Services would have a perspective on this as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103717","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Indigenous Services would have a perspective on this as well.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5b6952741d77934073bee9c728f0e8c77d9d81176b0b37ec76d4d2474ec988e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21b9e41c9c6512ff605f84a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103718,"date":"2026-04-27T16:20:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Is there any area or region that is doing this significantly better than the rest? We'll start with that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103718","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is there any area or region that is doing this significantly better than the rest? We'll start with that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["32e4184ba3c9837e4361d28661f253c898887909fb377d4a3cf490ea80fe9dc8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2ecee4a4c1c02372604f207","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103719,"date":"2026-04-27T17:20:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm going to go back to empowerment. In all of these programs, we have billions of dollars from this large, overall organization. We have to get them out to where they belong. The people involved on the ground don't necessarily have the feedback to say that they're not getting it. I know that we who are not in indigenous communities count on our cities, towns and provincial and territorial governments to do this. Is there any way that we can build in some mechanisms to give people on the ground more feedback and opportunity to say that this is not working or this needs to be working better?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103719","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm going to go back to empowerment. In all of these programs, we have billions of dollars from this large, overall organization. We have to get them out to where they belong. The people involved on the ground don't necessarily have the feedback to say that they're not getting it. I know that we who are not in indigenous communities count on our cities, towns and provincial a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00904e49abdff7ac5beb8918","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103720,"date":"2026-04-27T17:25:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I think these are very good points. This is top-down stuff. I'm more interested at this point in hearing about bottom-up mechanisms. For example, if I have problems in my city—they're not clearing the roads—I phone my city councillor. I don't wait until some big organization comes back and says.... What I'm looking for is some opportunity to empower the people on the ground to feed back into the system where things are not working or where things could be working better.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103720","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I think these are very good points. This is top-down stuff. I'm more interested at this point in hearing about bottom-up mechanisms. For example, if I have problems in my city—they're not clearing the roads—I phone my city councillor. I don't wait until some big organization comes back and says.... What I'm looking for is some opportunity to empower the people on the ground to feed back into the s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bae39499d3b71027165ca9c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103721,"date":"2026-04-27T17:25:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Is it just for five minutes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103721","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is it just for five minutes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-261b4cb1320357c0d43d83b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103722,"date":"2026-04-27T20:45:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"When we left off, I believe we were debating this amendment to change \"management\" to \"estimates and costs\". We didn't vote on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103722","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"When we left off, I believe we were debating this amendment to change \"management\" to \"estimates and costs\". We didn't vote on that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0680405023141e90dc191ba17597a78804d514cad164fb685ba727ef4cae9390"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b1280a9a8205c3dc12c79ec4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103723,"date":"2026-04-27T20:45:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Did it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103723","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Did it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-543b584d7705d9298acba7a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103724,"date":"2026-04-27T20:45:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Okay. That's fair enough.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103724","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. That's fair enough.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f9a102a725d93d2ed87d153","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103725,"date":"2026-04-27T20:45:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Personally, I'm ready to vote on that. We have other things to carry on with. I just wanted to tidy up where we were.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103725","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Personally, I'm ready to vote on that. We have other things to carry on with. I just wanted to tidy up where we were.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["33270d465caaeda6cdb243e0b220f80b56c1de58dd2bd7405fda12e439712f70"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-217ac9065e825de2cce624c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103726,"date":"2026-04-27T21:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I was going to say to Mr. Lemire that, yes, there have been discussions and there are all kinds of ideas and suggestions. It's a point of form that when we are in an amendment, we need to finish the amendment and then we can move on to bigger and better things.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103726","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I was going to say to Mr. Lemire that, yes, there have been discussions and there are all kinds of ideas and suggestions. It's a point of form that when we are in an amendment, we need to finish the amendment and then we can move on to bigger and better things.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ddf18ed2696506bc64fe5e0b178bfe749250d264319306fa983231d6c340820"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26a5c5b39c38bfa17fc7cfe1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103727,"date":"2026-04-27T21:05:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Mr. Lemire is worried about what we are trying to hide. We're not trying to hide anything. We want to do a real study. We do studies in all of our committees all throughout Parliament. We do them all the time. We bring witnesses in. We ask them questions, and we get them to provide us information that they can offer. That's exactly what we want to do. The notion of getting this massive dump of documents, even though we have agreed to narrow it down somewhat.... It's still a massive dump. To think that we're going to take this massive number of documents and suddenly discover magic solutions to this problem is not realistic. From my perspective, we're trying to make this not into a backward study. We want to call the witnesses forward, drill down into the issues that were identified before, conceivably invite the Auditor General to do a further study to follow up, and absolutely find out what went wrong here. I'm an IT guy from way back. I spent probably 30 or 40 years doing IT. Things happen when writing code. Things change. We're not going to get some magic document dump that's going to tell us what went wrong. I think we have to look at the matter systemically, and we have to do that from a coherent perspective, looking at the salient witnesses that we can bring forward to do the study. I'm fully prepared and fully interested in doing a study to drill down and find out what went wrong. I just think that getting this mass of documents ahead of time is, without having an opportunity to narrow the scope according to the witnesses and find out what the problems might be, extraordinarily problematic. I certainly will support this amendment. If this amendment is not going to pass, and one hopes it does, we will basically go back and start to work on the original motion to see if we can make it more effective and more useful. Anyway, my perspective is that we absolutely want to do this study. We want to find out what went wrong, and there is absolutely nothing we're seeking to hide here. We just want to undertake a process that's most likely to give us answers that are meaningful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103727","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Lemire is worried about what we are trying to hide. We're not trying to hide anything. We want to do a real study. We do studies in all of our committees all throughout Parliament. We do them all the time. We bring witnesses in. We ask them questions, and we get them to provide us information that they can offer. That's exactly what we want to do. The notion of getting this massive dump of doc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2774d1224d24b24cf132d6e14a008d56f4779f699123a99f454c8679a25f57a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eb17b2c37e78e53e89b83cf61bd1e422c1fc6341bf02022a2116f3c6fd013efd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea69523671712e1af9f78431","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103728,"date":"2026-04-27T21:15:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I'm going to be bold and move another amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103728","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm going to be bold and move another amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c3e933590759ed75949ea4241408c80a6118b6474f504425895e467f719c634"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a20586181db564a5abc14c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103729,"date":"2026-04-27T21:15:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I really like the idea of doing a study. Of course, we're not going to find out what's going on unless we do a study. The big problem with the document request is that we can talk about the kinds of documents, and if you say it fast it doesn't sound like much, but we're talking about 10 years' worth of documents and—who knows—hundreds or maybe thousands of people involved. I would like to focus on doing a study, so I'm going to move that in this motion, at least in the English version, the second paragraph be dropped entirely, and that in the third paragraph, which starts, \"That the Committee hold the first meeting on this study one week after receiving the documents\", that phrase be removed. That's my amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103729","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I really like the idea of doing a study. Of course, we're not going to find out what's going on unless we do a study. The big problem with the document request is that we can talk about the kinds of documents, and if you say it fast it doesn't sound like much, but we're talking about 10 years' worth of documents and—who knows—hundreds or maybe thousands of people involved. I would like to focus on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93bb11e7c9b4bd6ae3122d38","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103730,"date":"2026-04-27T21:15:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"It's to delete paragraph two and delete the first portion of the following paragraph, which says, \"That the Committee hold the first meeting on this study one week after receiving the documents\", and start that paragraph with the words \"That senior officials\". That commits us, as a committee, if we're doing a study on this matter.... I don't know what the schedule is for this committee going forward, but I know the chair is fully aware of the kind of business that lies before us, and I trust the chair to be able to allocate some time for us as we go forward. Once we get into and do a study and we talk to the officials and the people who were involved in doing this design and development, and we drill down into where the problems happened, at that point we'll be in a much better position to do a focused request for documents that are going to actually make sense to us. Anyway, that's my amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103730","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's to delete paragraph two and delete the first portion of the following paragraph, which says, \"That the Committee hold the first meeting on this study one week after receiving the documents\", and start that paragraph with the words \"That senior officials\". That commits us, as a committee, if we're doing a study on this matter.... I don't know what the schedule is for this committee going forwa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8003064c551d002f39dcd74f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103731,"date":"2026-04-27T21:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I agree that it's a positive step. I think it helps us to narrow the focus to the documents we're looking for. The more we can do to keep things focused and keep things to reasonable volumes of documents, the better. That's really all I have to say about that. I think it's a good amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103731","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I agree that it's a positive step. I think it helps us to narrow the focus to the documents we're looking for. The more we can do to keep things focused and keep things to reasonable volumes of documents, the better. That's really all I have to say about that. I think it's a good amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5a993ac10718ddff1d80d77","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103732,"date":"2026-04-27T21:45:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I just want to comment that I'd be happy to see what I could do to get this document forwarded to Monsieur Lemire. As a member of the House of Commons, I need more clarification on what it is. If you're reading about it on the Internet or something, it's probably fairly publicly available. We could probably find that, get it translated and make it available. I don't know if you could subamend this to do that, but I would certainly be willing to commit to seeing if we can get this document for you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103732","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I just want to comment that I'd be happy to see what I could do to get this document forwarded to Monsieur Lemire. As a member of the House of Commons, I need more clarification on what it is. If you're reading about it on the Internet or something, it's probably fairly publicly available. We could probably find that, get it translated and make it available. I don't know if you could subamend this","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04b4de592e0a44a69fa3596c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103733,"date":"2026-04-27T21:50:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"It's a subamendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103733","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's a subamendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ac791a04f4c456b89892fa0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103734,"date":"2026-04-27T21:50:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I'm just wondering if we could get this clarified in writing before we carry on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103734","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm just wondering if we could get this clarified in writing before we carry on?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034615","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conciliation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034615","label":"Conciliation","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64d6e4511435c3f6ac9e8707f800f136e7944ff8264750fca17e6aff295a2137"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e96018c9085871080bab3e99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103735,"date":"2026-04-27T21:50:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"There are two places for \"Prime Minister's Office\". Is that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103735","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There are two places for \"Prime Minister's Office\". Is that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04b2306391b83f96a9528b37e2b46017a4dc3c2fd890649f61f8c5ae566ad6a8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d496cdf640733b3440a3bba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103736,"date":"2026-04-27T22:25:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"The previous government....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103736","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The previous government....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6494c0b5ba2c59657942d175","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103737,"date":"2026-04-27T22:25:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I'll talk COBOL.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103737","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll talk COBOL.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5347ddd555650bc1a78281a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103738,"date":"2026-04-27T23:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I just want to build on what Ms. Khalid said, as well as what Ms. Yip said. First, the fact that HUMA is looking at exactly this same document production request is a problem for me. We don't need both committees doing this or asking for this. It makes me question the motives for doing this. However, in any case, as Ms. Khalid mentioned—and we're trying to narrow down the scope to focus it—as originally asked for, we're looking at, arguably, millions of documents. We want to have these millions of documents—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103738","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I just want to build on what Ms. Khalid said, as well as what Ms. Yip said. First, the fact that HUMA is looking at exactly this same document production request is a problem for me. We don't need both committees doing this or asking for this. It makes me question the motives for doing this. However, in any case, as Ms. Khalid mentioned—and we're trying to narrow down the scope to focus it—as orig","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8ed1ebe78bdfe2535fd6a2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103739,"date":"2026-04-27T23:00:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"That's fair enough. I'll go back to my older problem later. I would emphasize what Ms. Tesser Derksen said—that there's really no need to incorporate this into the motion. It's publicly available. We can bring it in and introduce it any time we like. I'll leave it there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103739","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's fair enough. I'll go back to my older problem later. I would emphasize what Ms. Tesser Derksen said—that there's really no need to incorporate this into the motion. It's publicly available. We can bring it in and introduce it any time we like. I'll leave it there.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a6be50990e8fe2f9477e206","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103740,"date":"2026-04-27T23:40:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Mr. Chair—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103740","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Chair—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf1f6749259e031ff495594d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103741,"date":"2026-04-27T23:50:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Yes, I'm going to do that, but I do want to quibble about a couple of things. Many people have said that Canadians didn't elect a majority government or whatever. I would like to point out that in Canada, we don't elect governments. We elect individual representatives. We form a government depending on the numbers of members elected from each party. That's how we form governments. We do not elect them. If members wish to change their viewpoints or they lose confidence in their leadership and they wish to change parties, that's totally correct and appropriate. In regard to Mr. Lemire's amendment, I also want to mention that I started out thinking, \"Yeah, I'll support that,\" but I've been listening to innuendo and slander from Mr. Lemire about our concern over trying to keep the document retrieval reasonable and useful. He suggests that it indicates some sort of conspiracy to hide information. I have no idea what kind of information would be out there for this. I certainly know that this document retrieval is a major undertaking, absolutely, but it also relates to a major undertaking in this system's redevelopment. I've been in the business long enough to know that it's a horrendous job. Lots of things go wrong in the process. I'd be delighted to talk to officials about it and have them drill down to find out what we can do better next time, but frankly, even if we solve all the problems of last time, it won't make any difference the next time, because technology is changing. The systems are moving on. We have different database systems. We have all kinds of things that are different. We're always going to be pushing the limits of the technology, and I think the notion that we're going to do this massive study with this mass of documents and then miraculously come to an answer that's going to solve our problems going forward is absurd. At this point, I'm inclined to not support Mr. Lemire's amendment because, frankly, the document is available. We can get that. Ms. Tesser Derksen has obviously referred to it quite extensively, and it's not a secret document. It's available, so we don't have to incorporate that into the motion. Anyway, I don't know what my colleagues are feeling about that particular choice, but at this point, I'm inclined to not support Mr. Lemire's amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103741","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, I'm going to do that, but I do want to quibble about a couple of things. Many people have said that Canadians didn't elect a majority government or whatever. I would like to point out that in Canada, we don't elect governments. We elect individual representatives. We form a government depending on the numbers of members elected from each party. That's how we form governments. We do not elect ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a11ffc02e9a1e8c2b9df72ecd38398f02e79802426f2d52e355c43744b525922"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fecbf4d7680b2c9a43b561d60a00655b00914000638579468a826db9718ac6e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6012167412fa9515b963ab49","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103742,"date":"2026-04-27T23:55:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"That's a start date, not an end date.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103742","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's a start date, not an end date.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69d147fb161c94a15678a2b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103743,"date":"2026-04-27T23:55:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103743","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4df79946eeb78b1b65f3022","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103744,"date":"2026-04-28T00:10:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"This is an important amendment. One of the things we've been talking about all evening and as long as we've been talking about this whole motion is the sheer number of documents. I've been told, certainly, that we're looking at millions of documents, and it could be an immense cost to translate them, redact them and so on, so this really narrows it down. It takes it from a 10-year period to a two-year period. It cuts it down to probably 20% of the documents, to start with. This is a really important thing. If we can get through all those documents, we should be able to come up with some good questions to ask the various officials when we do the study. The whole point of this is not the documents. The point of this is to do the study, at the end of the day, so we can drill down into what happened and when, and figure out what went wrong, how we can fix it and, frankly, how we can avoid it going forward. I want to emphasize that cutting this back to two years would be really helpful to deliver meaningful outputs and meaningful results from this motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103744","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This is an important amendment. One of the things we've been talking about all evening and as long as we've been talking about this whole motion is the sheer number of documents. I've been told, certainly, that we're looking at millions of documents, and it could be an immense cost to translate them, redact them and so on, so this really narrows it down. It takes it from a 10-year period to a two-","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["44846b8971487e79f539d81391ff6751bc60f338aa74020247ad8b8738a28b71"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a384de0f57214b340a723642","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103745,"date":"2026-04-28T00:20:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I really like those words—\"unlimited temporal window\". That's amazing. Voices: Oh, oh! Ron McKinnon: Again, I really want to emphasize that certainly my concern with this whole motion, right from the get-go, has been the sheer volume of documents and the horrendous task of gathering them. Having public servants out there putting them together and getting them translated and redacted as necessary would be hugely expensive and so forth. Certainly, this is a significant step forward. I want to emphasize that. It cuts down the time. It makes the unlimited temporal window a very limited temporal window, and I'm very supportive of that. I think it's a good idea. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103745","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I really like those words—\"unlimited temporal window\". That's amazing. Voices: Oh, oh! Ron McKinnon: Again, I really want to emphasize that certainly my concern with this whole motion, right from the get-go, has been the sheer volume of documents and the horrendous task of gathering them. Having public servants out there putting them together and getting them translated and redacted as necessary w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc982d2a0c7e7e4b9bcf3487","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103746,"date":"2026-04-28T00:25:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Okay. I'm not quite sure what I was going to say, but I think Mr. Osborne had a point.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103746","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. I'm not quite sure what I was going to say, but I think Mr. Osborne had a point.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-683a43407a0744443dff1c6c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103747,"date":"2026-04-28T00:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I also want to express my taking great exception to this innuendo, actually the slander, that somehow this means we're trying to hide something, that we, the government, are in fact trying to hide anything. To start with, we're not the government. We're members of the governing party, but we don't know what's going on behind the covers. We don't know what's going on in all of those offices all over the place. Right from the get-go, I have said—and I think we've all said—that the main focus of our concerns, our arguments and our efforts is to make this into a study that is reasonable and can be done in a cost-effective and effective way. We'll get documents that we can actually read, we can actually use and we can use in a beneficial way to advance that study. Not to mention, as mentioned before, it's a whole backward way of doing a study. Generally, in all the committees in Parliament, we call witnesses and we hear from witnesses. They give us information about more information we might need, and we can use that information to call for additional documents. That's the normal way things go. To go and get some massive document dump from way back when with very little regard to its import in any particular case, and then, on the basis of that, try to put together a study is, in my mind, ludicrous, because there are going to be far too many documents to get anything meaningful out of them. To wade through all of those documents and come up with a really clear picture of what's going on is going to take months. Once we're done this amendment, we need to have another look at when we do our study once we get the documents.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103747","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I also want to express my taking great exception to this innuendo, actually the slander, that somehow this means we're trying to hide something, that we, the government, are in fact trying to hide anything. To start with, we're not the government. We're members of the governing party, but we don't know what's going on behind the covers. We don't know what's going on in all of those offices all ove","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["871b4003463e5b9562656129186ea1d795a33533d77fe1403598d785e036eb44"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd27368158c161c730395c06626a411c2bd391743ae1ed6835aa20706e79d9e4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9309b5ba833b64c8f99e3274","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103748,"date":"2026-04-28T00:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you, Chair. I just wanted to respond to Mr. Kuruc. He's very concerned that we've been talking for three hours. I would just as soon not have been here talking for three hours myself, but right from the get-go, as I've mentioned before, we were trying to keep this number of documents to a manageable level so that we could actually manage these documents and read them. Frankly, as I've mentioned a couple of times, it's a backwards way of doing a study. We normally bring witnesses in here, we talk to them, we ask them questions and they give us information that we can use to drill into those documents and get the meaningful documents so we don't have to wade through millions and millions of documents and have the millions of documents converted, translated, redacted and whatnot. Right from the get-go, when we started tonight, this is what I said. We want to get this down. If we could have done that right from the get-go, we would be able to get this study under way with a reasonable number of document requests and a manageable outcome. I certainly take exception to Mr. Kuruc's concerns. I also will take further exception to the notion that Canadians did not choose a minority government. Canadians elected individual representatives. They elected 343 representatives and different ridings elected people from different parties. There is no decision that was made by anybody out there who said, \"I'm going to vote for a minority\" or \"I'm going to vote for a majority.\" It's a bizarre way of looking at things to say that they voted for a majority or they didn't. In terms of the floor crossers, I think I've worked with all of these people for very many years. They're all very conscientious and dedicated individuals. I think that they took a look at the world and where it is and where it's going and decided that this particular party was a better place to stand to move forward on the kinds of things they wanted to achieve. I don't think there's anything detrimental to say about them for that. I understand that people from their original parties might be unhappy about that, I fully understand that. Nevertheless, I don't think there's any basis to impugn their integrity or their characters for what has to be an insanely difficult decision to make. You move out of one social structure in a riding with all of your EDA people and the people you've been working with for years, and suddenly you're in a new one. It's not an easy thing. I think we have to give respect to the people who have made those tough choices and absolutely make sure we respect them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103748","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. I just wanted to respond to Mr. Kuruc. He's very concerned that we've been talking for three hours. I would just as soon not have been here talking for three hours myself, but right from the get-go, as I've mentioned before, we were trying to keep this number of documents to a manageable level so that we could actually manage these documents and read them. Frankly, as I've mentio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d764dc21a1c97ae36a9fadcb66baed208f9df6300d8228fc6065b57081aff63"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e5ee97537770c58b08e0dbb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103749,"date":"2026-04-29T21:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Chair, we don't see the guests on the screen.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103749","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Chair, we don't see the guests on the screen.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","label":"Television","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a84292ff945bdaabf26490ae0b6d41c11b8ccd84a969a9224113b7d41cf24dca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31edfeccc9b765efabb4e18a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103750,"date":"2026-04-29T22:25:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"If I start to flail, I'll pass it on to somebody.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103750","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If I start to flail, I'll pass it on to somebody.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be836dfa2b8f6733235246f50824c9bcfe3c44e5e2b0408f7bb0df7dadd9329d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17e2c34b4cb448f123095cda","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103751,"date":"2026-04-29T22:25:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I too want to talk about BC Ferries. BC Ferries is a provincial Crown corporation. It is independent. It certainly doesn't answer to the federal government, but many of us were disappointed that they were taking their ferry contracts to China. However, I talked to Seaspan, which is a major shipbuilder in our community. They're currently in the throes of building two joint supply ships for the navy and, I think, one or two icebreakers for the Coast Guard. They have no capacity to build it, and I think there were some issues with the RFP—timeline issues and so forth. No Canadian firms actually bid on this contract, so I think that, apart from the potential problems with the RFP process, it didn't take anything away from Canadian firms. I'm wondering if the Canada Infrastructure Bank has any ability to incorporate in its loan mechanism, in its process for approving loans, a process whereby we can encourage to buy Canadian, where we can encourage projects, even if they're executed outside of the country, to utilize Canadian products. Is there any mechanism in the Canada Infrastructure Bank that would support that sort of undertaking?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103751","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I too want to talk about BC Ferries. BC Ferries is a provincial Crown corporation. It is independent. It certainly doesn't answer to the federal government, but many of us were disappointed that they were taking their ferry contracts to China. However, I talked to Seaspan, which is a major shipbuilder in our community. They're currently in the throes of building two joint supply ships for the navy","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1c66a4a57da2cc2d0c50ee6d54026e87872891a03b5591e8b64d4c927b20efed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8404bf44a96263b7222a0759100f95c085520275b10703489da3d29db8222f85"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-467ea61cf4d07a2c11be6f00","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103752,"date":"2026-04-29T22:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you. Mr. Kuruc and Ms. Kusie earlier on indicated concerns about the spending that you do and whether it's bringing good value to Canada. I want to emphasize that really—and I'd like you to speak again on this—you're not spending money. You're loaning money. The money you disburse to these projects is going to come back to us with interest, presumably. Similarly, Mr. Kuruc indicated that you've completed x number of projects. I don't think it's your job to complete any projects. Your job is to invest properly in proponents. They will be completing the projects, not you. You just have to make sure that the money you loan is going to come back. Would you care to comment on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103752","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Mr. Kuruc and Ms. Kusie earlier on indicated concerns about the spending that you do and whether it's bringing good value to Canada. I want to emphasize that really—and I'd like you to speak again on this—you're not spending money. You're loaning money. The money you disburse to these projects is going to come back to us with interest, presumably. Similarly, Mr. Kuruc indicated that you","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f1b798a7353742220abc62d67f308152044f86da9d7ca0cb825c478d179f889"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f26762df0e4ca5a1e775232d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103753,"date":"2026-04-29T22:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you. I'm going to switch to your corporate plan. What are the key differences between your 2024-25 corporate plan and your 2026-27 corporate plan?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103753","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I'm going to switch to your corporate plan. What are the key differences between your 2024-25 corporate plan and your 2026-27 corporate plan?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f759e1663c65893c768a6016b97ac5f97bad2da6485f0b06a212f5d8d75ad757"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ab21852276448fb83942c14","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103754,"date":"2026-04-29T22:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Okay, I think that's my time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103754","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay, I think that's my time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f5491e571c010aed6e4db08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723299,"date":"2026-04-30T19:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, next week, residents of Port Coquitlam will celebrate one of our community's most beloved traditions, May Days. Now in its 103rd year, this long-standing celebration of spring brings together neighbours, families and visitors for festivities that reflect the very best of community spirit.\n\nFrom the opening ceremonies this Sunday to the Rotary May Day Parade the following Saturday, May 9, May Days is a reminder of the strong volunteerism and local pride that define our community. I encourage everyone to take part and to enjoy the live music, delicious food and many family-friendly activities that make May Days so special. I encourage everyone to join in celebrating what makes Port Coquitlam such a vibrant place to call home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723299","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, next week, residents of Port Coquitlam will celebrate one of our community's most beloved traditions, May Days. Now in its 103rd year, this long-standing celebration of spring brings together neighbours, families and visitors for festivities that reflect the very best of community spirit.\n\nFrom the opening ceremonies this Sunday to the Rotary May Day Parade the following Saturday, May","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["548af72709e0b96bb3d817f71ea8ea50aec2a1f4bd0fc8a7ed181ec30905808c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47611d92419f5dc3b166ef2664c11aad39cdaed99b24a37947302081c3cd324a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57bf591324e6fa336e453c01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103755,"date":"2026-05-06T22:25:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you, Chair. Ms. Bogden, you mentioned that we have 17 bargaining agents and 28 collective bargaining groups, I believe, which represent a hugely complex pay environment. I'm wondering, to start with, as an ex-IT guy, why we think that one large, one-size-fits-all system will solve this problem, rather than, say, 28 smaller, individualized, customized systems. Why is that the right answer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103755","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Ms. Bogden, you mentioned that we have 17 bargaining agents and 28 collective bargaining groups, I believe, which represent a hugely complex pay environment. I'm wondering, to start with, as an ex-IT guy, why we think that one large, one-size-fits-all system will solve this problem, rather than, say, 28 smaller, individualized, customized systems. Why is that the right answer?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","label":"Environment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e85f8cb306b3bb324a12a09c519d5de0da442d1fc68b9d4199351b86734a7fd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["83309e8976e9ed089dadb439162a1892795c9115351fd8d3bb58397ceb6078ab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98e769880c4e117936d07ae9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103756,"date":"2026-05-06T22:30:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"The AG's report mentions that the progress in simplifying and standardizing pay rules has been limited, and this has been under way since the first rollout of Phoenix in 2012 at Miramichi. That's almost 15 years now. Why do we think we're going to have better success going forward in that simplification so we can actually encompass this requisite simplicity within Dayforce?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103756","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The AG's report mentions that the progress in simplifying and standardizing pay rules has been limited, and this has been under way since the first rollout of Phoenix in 2012 at Miramichi. That's almost 15 years now. Why do we think we're going to have better success going forward in that simplification so we can actually encompass this requisite simplicity within Dayforce?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e4b527c3f346162e923e77d2c141152633096cf7d5733953b108a07940c6547d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a51f7e04e061f62f6e56a3e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103757,"date":"2026-05-06T23:25:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I was fundamentally going to agree with you as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103757","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I was fundamentally going to agree with you as well.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc4db44eb71144b059705359","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103758,"date":"2026-05-06T23:25:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"This motion is what's before us right now. We need to debate or vote on it. If there's any other motion we want to deal with, we can do it at that time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103758","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This motion is what's before us right now. We need to debate or vote on it. If there's any other motion we want to deal with, we can do it at that time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5396b2deceba23791991447b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752388,"date":"2026-05-07T19:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I wish to inform the House that on Friday, April 24, I was arrested by the Coquitlam RCMP. The crime was drinking too much coffee while on House duty. I pleaded guilty. I was cuffed for a cure.\n\nCuffed for a Cure is the lighter side of Cops for Cancer. The harder side is the cycling. Each year, officers across Canada cycle hundreds of kilometres raising funds for life-saving childhood cancer research and supporting families facing the unimaginable. Their commitment reflects the very best of our community: compassion, resilience and a deep sense of service. \n\nI encourage all Canadians to support Cops for Cancer and to help ensure that no child faces cancer alone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752388","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I wish to inform the House that on Friday, April 24, I was arrested by the Coquitlam RCMP. The crime was drinking too much coffee while on House duty. I pleaded guilty. I was cuffed for a cure.\n\nCuffed for a Cure is the lighter side of Cops for Cancer. The harder side is the cycling. Each year, officers across Canada cycle hundreds of kilometres raising funds for life-saving childhood","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a6ace2a2795c48951faeaaf8a9f56a744189060101de1b433d228838d4afe88e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb313a5f3e8c641ffdaf78aed902ceda9064f4a7630796af8b400aefd01c2c7c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ed8672dcd609b00838d41b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103759,"date":"2026-06-01T16:15:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you all for being here today. I appreciate your contributions and your input. I want to talk about different ethnic communities. My riding has probably the second-largest Persian community in at least British Columbia but maybe even in Canada. I was wondering what funding might be available to support the Persian community in our area. Also, considering there's a great deal of anxiety regarding what's going on in Iran today, do you have a role to play in helping them get through that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103759","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you all for being here today. I appreciate your contributions and your input. I want to talk about different ethnic communities. My riding has probably the second-largest Persian community in at least British Columbia but maybe even in Canada. I was wondering what funding might be available to support the Persian community in our area. Also, considering there's a great ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["355fd24cc9f334ae38a9979128aca283847f8bf2125c4af8d3f317b82eb5f263"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["405632c97d13333b39a1d64cdc6d2d2c253ef27d08f8be73414ea0f7fbb2425d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aacdb8a0f4061929a7bef3e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103760,"date":"2026-06-01T16:15:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Frankly, I hadn't thought about the racism aspect of it. I appreciate that that's important. I was thinking more in terms of positive things to support Persian culture and the recognition of their history and their contributions to world history and so forth. I think you spoke to that to some degree in terms of multiculturalism. Is there any more that you can add to that? How can we support them in a positive way to embrace their Persian culture in our society?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103760","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Frankly, I hadn't thought about the racism aspect of it. I appreciate that that's important. I was thinking more in terms of positive things to support Persian culture and the recognition of their history and their contributions to world history and so forth. I think you spoke to that to some degree in terms of multiculturalism. Is there any more that you can add to that? How can we support them i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4df1b2bfc0fcea5d3ee22d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103761,"date":"2026-06-01T16:15:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"I'll segue to Mr. Deltell's line of questions regarding indigenous languages, but not his precise question. We have the Kwikwetlem First Nation in my riding. It has the hən̓q̓əmin̓əm̓ language, and as with all indigenous languages, we have a concern about it dying out. Can you give us more information about what we can do to support our indigenous community in advancing and enhancing their native language skills?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103761","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll segue to Mr. Deltell's line of questions regarding indigenous languages, but not his precise question. We have the Kwikwetlem First Nation in my riding. It has the hən̓q̓əmin̓əm̓ language, and as with all indigenous languages, we have a concern about it dying out. Can you give us more information about what we can do to support our indigenous community in advancing and enhancing their native ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2f2cafb1c4e5b27b03aab5757c6292107774b6773cc03531eff45b84dfd92d69"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a5a77f6c18d2e921d14e818da9255b3113e408d27725e95571e430f8eb2d97a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78c68107426b1d0dc3bafd55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103762,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you for being here. I'm not going to approach this with any kind of economic sophistication. I'm a computer programmer. In your deck, you indicated that one of the liabilities the bank has is banknotes in circulation. I'm wondering how cryptocurrency factors in there. Do you guys have a role in cryptocurrency? Do you supply cryptocurrency? What are the consequences more broadly in having cryptocurrencies out there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103762","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. Thank you for being here. I'm not going to approach this with any kind of economic sophistication. I'm a computer programmer. In your deck, you indicated that one of the liabilities the bank has is banknotes in circulation. I'm wondering how cryptocurrency factors in there. Do you guys have a role in cryptocurrency? Do you supply cryptocurrency? What are the consequences more bro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3f26e9b9f47f779c2eca1b8105f52603f376c2008c90ac7d6f9187163b76fc0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7de93e4e0a178a4a37e0b140","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103763,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"It's kind of a niche element in the economy at this point. Is that what you're saying?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103763","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's kind of a niche element in the economy at this point. Is that what you're saying?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["410ca0653401192114bda89e0136c408a7379ee0b9a4556e41377ba81ef3f6b8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2ee3826851e40beaba45b19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103764,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Carrying on with this, as we hopefully do more business with Europe, for example, how does the value of the euro versus the value of the U.S. dollar affect our economic decisions and our economic welfare?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103764","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Carrying on with this, as we hopefully do more business with Europe, for example, how does the value of the euro versus the value of the U.S. dollar affect our economic decisions and our economic welfare?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1329204671cef3baf3288f208e1cae02ef74446af22ce74ef2a4755e4b1e376"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ee2de223533f7b68754cad16115bd3774c2d070446cfdcc09a88a25cd5f40e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-895c21db9e562f15b840f534","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103765,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Just to belabour this, as to banknotes in circulation, people don't use banknotes so much anymore. I don't think I've paid a bill with a Terry Fox bill recently. Everything is electronic. Does that affect the banknotes in circulation and the liabilities of the bank?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103765","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just to belabour this, as to banknotes in circulation, people don't use banknotes so much anymore. I don't think I've paid a bill with a Terry Fox bill recently. Everything is electronic. Does that affect the banknotes in circulation and the liabilities of the bank?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-198b502a08d7e66272164ce7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103766,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Do you have any projection of where this is going in terms of currency in circulation and the relationship with cryptocurrencies and so forth?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103766","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you have any projection of where this is going in terms of currency in circulation and the relationship with cryptocurrencies and so forth?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035183","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exchange rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cryptography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034744","label":"Cryptography","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035183","label":"Exchange rates","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b922935d036b823476eeb5ac27ec1ac92fc644c0442ee2fd8b65c3ecf061b7b9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d1c5f47020a08640ac4f00d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103767,"date":"2026-06-01T17:35:00+00:00","title":"PACP","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"PACP","text":"Thank you very much. I think that's my time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/PACP/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103767","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I think that's my time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9e5a283ad6fa4b3062237d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087218,"date":"2026-06-16T19:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ron McKinnon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when Christine and I sent Katherine and Sarah off on school trips, we waved goodbye and could not wait to hear about their adventures when they returned home. That was the expectation for the parents of Minnekhada Middle School students in Port Coquitlam yesterday. Ten students and two adults on an end-of-year excursion to Cultus Lake Waterpark sustained serious electrical injuries. They were rushed to hospital by ground and air ambulance. They are now in stable condition.\n\nTo the kids, I say get better soon. They have an entire community pulling for them. To the parents, I say I cannot imagine the fear and anxiety in those moments. No parent expects a call like the one they received yesterday. I want to assure the parents, the children and all those impacted that the whole Tri-Cities community stands with them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087218","member_id":"bc-mp-59293","member_name":"Ron McKinnon","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when Christine and I sent Katherine and Sarah off on school trips, we waved goodbye and could not wait to hear about their adventures when they returned home. That was the expectation for the parents of Minnekhada Middle School students in Port Coquitlam yesterday. Ten students and two adults on an end-of-year excursion to Cultus Lake Waterpark sustained serious electrical injuries. T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed7c3ba90047dd5fd960811231ebce1d5a0c501a436b6bdaebf1817934f83ff0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c3b21194f51f17b89d4b691","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":96207,"date":"2026-02-10T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today in recognition of national Kindness Week and the 20th anniversary of Real Acts of Caring, founded by educator Harriette Chang. What began in 2005 as a simple idea led by young students has grown into a lasting movement rooted in Canadian values and a belief that kindness, practised with intention, can strengthen entire communities.\n\nToday, Real Acts of Caring has expanded beyond School District No. 43 and across B.C., Canada and the world. Each year, students and families take part through genuine acts of caring, supporting food banks, helping neighbours, sharing books and showing up for others without expecting anything in return.\n\nI invite everyone to take part in national Kindness Week and keep the spirit of caring alive.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96207","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today in recognition of national Kindness Week and the 20th anniversary of Real Acts of Caring, founded by educator Harriette Chang. What began in 2005 as a simple idea led by young students has grown into a lasting movement rooted in Canadian values and a belief that kindness, practised with intention, can strengthen entire communities.\n\nToday, Real Acts of Caring has expanded","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aae425748190983a4cd12b3c5355c5404faf3efa7e004502123b1ecc6f3390c6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-167471be148c7473f6ba839c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":96205,"date":"2026-02-12T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today as a British Columbian to express my deepest sympathy for the people of Tumbler Ridge. Innocent lives were lost in an unimaginable tragedy that has shaken a small and deeply connected community to its core.\n\nTo the families, friends, classmates, teachers and first responders, I say that they carry a heavy burden of grief that is almost impossible to bear. Nothing can replace the beautiful lives that were taken. They matter, and they will never be forgotten.\n\nIn this country, when tragedy strikes one community, it touches us all. Canadians do not turn away. We draw closer. We stand together. We support and love one another. That is who we are, and that is what it means to be Canadian.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96205","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today as a British Columbian to express my deepest sympathy for the people of Tumbler Ridge. Innocent lives were lost in an unimaginable tragedy that has shaken a small and deeply connected community to its core.\n\nTo the families, friends, classmates, teachers and first responders, I say that they carry a heavy burden of grief that is almost impossible to bear. Nothing can repl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca10631c271e11eee07f28bdb276595709bdd1f17343fe6ae4e527f7499a04d1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f62f31eb4622ea40af45cbbcea8d38a3dc91090432ec0a099bd5d4eb9d43eff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-496f630214c2960b4e79195f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103779,"date":"2026-04-14T17:15:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I have deep respect for everybody in the room today giving testimony. This is such an important topic. It's really an imperative of our time. In my riding of Port Moody—Coquitlam, our local news shuttered their doors just ahead of the 2025 election, about a month before. That created space for the, as Mr. Wood said, deluge of free, and as Mr. Harvey said, unverified and, in some cases, malicious content. It was really a feeding frenzy of all of that stuff ahead of the election. Here we are. In this time of news, when people are hungry for local, fact-based journalistic integrity, but the vacuum is being filled with everything else, what does journalistic integrity look like to you? How can Canadians spot it? I'd like to open the floor and hear from many of you, maybe beginning with Ms. Simard and Mr. Harvey, because you train journalists. Please, I'd like to hear from you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103779","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I have deep respect for everybody in the room today giving testimony. This is such an important topic. It's really an imperative of our time. In my riding of Port Moody—Coquitlam, our local news shuttered their doors just ahead of the 2025 election, about a month before. That created space for the, as Mr. Wood said, deluge of free, and as Mr. Harvey said, unverified and, in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ef32714d69567410e1caed0b795d3ca53c0b43e937abb8a3a18b5e47cf5b7123"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91aeaf9999d7b5854391cd132b767d3efac39ee1e35e61006dbe624101afbb15"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79585cafef364b7cbbe03791","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103780,"date":"2026-04-14T17:20:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Amazing. Thank you. To Ms. Spring, when you're reviewing applications for funding, are you looking at those applications through a journalism code of ethics? How does your screening process work?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103780","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Amazing. Thank you. To Ms. Spring, when you're reviewing applications for funding, are you looking at those applications through a journalism code of ethics? How does your screening process work?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4294b78da6ae7ee03977143b7281ff2d9d43ac583e374b479cc135e0a8ddab98"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ddb4c542ddd1941e221c88dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103781,"date":"2026-04-14T17:20:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"For Canadians listening today, what would you say are the pillars of the journalistic code of ethics, if you had to summarize it in five points?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103781","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"For Canadians listening today, what would you say are the pillars of the journalistic code of ethics, if you had to summarize it in five points?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Whistleblower protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037639","label":"Whistleblower protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c918ca8556906685c9be7c422ea72296b7953dfb10557dd44ac208acd3d41c69"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd68b15667c413dad082b1db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103782,"date":"2026-04-21T16:55:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you so much, Madam Chair. I'm delighted to hear testimony from so many extraordinary witnesses. Given that there is a member from my own community here today, I will focus my questions on Ms. Cena from Tri-Cities Community Television. I want to say thank you, as well, because Tri-Cities Community Television provides an extraordinary voice in the community. You inform and entertain us. As you said in your own words, Ms. Cena, your goal is to make sure the community is seen, heard and connected. You and the team do an incredible job. There is no question that community media like Tri-Cities Community Television plays a unique role in Canada's journalism and media landscape, telling meaningful local stories, training new voices and reflecting community life in ways that larger outlets often cannot. Ms. Cena, from your perspective, what do you see as the most important successes of community media in Canada over the past decade, and perhaps even more specifically of Tri-Cities Community Television?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103782","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you so much, Madam Chair. I'm delighted to hear testimony from so many extraordinary witnesses. Given that there is a member from my own community here today, I will focus my questions on Ms. Cena from Tri-Cities Community Television. I want to say thank you, as well, because Tri-Cities Community Television provides an extraordinary voice in the community. You inform and entertain us. As you","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","label":"Television"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","label":"Television","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5ce71c6ecfe2c4d7ec06b77e122a9875390ccf486fc73cf2abbe841af5453fef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76a290994d3872b9cacd2a22f39d865ebb66e48b8ddc72205bba6b8e7cbcba96"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad9dd6366d01ddacb27615b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103783,"date":"2026-04-21T16:55:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"That's amazing. Tri-Cities Community Television was founded in response to the decline of cable-based community TV and the withdrawal of private broadcasters from local production. Looking back, how do you think changes in technology, market forces and policy decisions have contributed to the current state of local journalism and community media in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103783","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's amazing. Tri-Cities Community Television was founded in response to the decline of cable-based community TV and the withdrawal of private broadcasters from local production. Looking back, how do you think changes in technology, market forces and policy decisions have contributed to the current state of local journalism and community media in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Broadcasting industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Broadcasting industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48748","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","label":"Broadcasting industry","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48748","label":"Computer networks","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e96afd549ddf856fd7161bd610d30a7c7a5ef566f4a5728b4db2e5063607a867"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2218356c2807750fc89c4557","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103784,"date":"2026-04-21T17:00:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"One of your suggestions was multi-year support so that you can, in fact, plan ahead. Local media is facing serious financial and capacity pressures, as you rightly pointed out. How does Tri-Cities Community Television experience the contrast between opportunity and vulnerability at a local level? What does that look like on a day-to-day and week-to-week basis?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103784","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"One of your suggestions was multi-year support so that you can, in fact, plan ahead. Local media is facing serious financial and capacity pressures, as you rightly pointed out. How does Tri-Cities Community Television experience the contrast between opportunity and vulnerability at a local level? What does that look like on a day-to-day and week-to-week basis?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e13e2c0483dd23e9b3014c81","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103785,"date":"2026-04-21T17:00:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103785","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8689898b44a41e93a00d337","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103786,"date":"2026-04-23T14:05:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you very much. I'm going to pose my first question to Mr. Frame. Mr. Frame, you mentioned that you represent 350 journalists. You mentioned, in the scenario of an emergency, that predominantly American news would be reported to the Canadian people. I would like you to imagine yourself in the seat of a parliamentarian for a moment. We know we need to pivot, in terms of supporting a vibrant, local, credible news network across the country, coast to coast to coast. What are some of the policies you would want to implement? What would be the priority with which you would roll these out? Maybe you could also speak to some of the international legislation that is happening right now, given the state of journalism.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103786","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I'm going to pose my first question to Mr. Frame. Mr. Frame, you mentioned that you represent 350 journalists. You mentioned, in the scenario of an emergency, that predominantly American news would be reported to the Canadian people. I would like you to imagine yourself in the seat of a parliamentarian for a moment. We know we need to pivot, in terms of supporting a vibrant, l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b44ffa4512c52a78b0f72c98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103787,"date":"2026-04-23T14:10:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"That's amazing. Very quickly, what is the hallmark of credible journalism versus non-credible journalism in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103787","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's amazing. Very quickly, what is the hallmark of credible journalism versus non-credible journalism in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8322594194c630832bd06680d51b06ccc972fc4922de7f0c92006040750f0b31"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e50f7ea4f4f1113a2c4fada","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103788,"date":"2026-04-23T14:15:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103788","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4a5cefcd33dc7ea1e111a34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103789,"date":"2026-04-28T16:50:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you. I'd like to begin by thanking every witness for appearing today. I'll focus my comments on Ms. Dickenson. You wrote to me last July, and I had the opportunity to meet with CPAC last fall. I was truly thankful for that. I want to say how much I truly value CPAC's service to all Canadians. It is, as you quoted from someone who had written to you, an \"indispensable service\" to Canadians and journalists across our country. CPAC gives Canadians a direct window into Parliament, into our committees, into public affairs and democratic debate in English and French, often with aging equipment that is nearly impossible to replace, which you can sometimes find on eBay, and it does that on a shoestring budget that last year was $15 million. I also want to acknowledge the people behind that work, the journalists, producers, camera crews, editors, technicians and staff who make it all possible. I was deeply saddened to hear the news last week about the layoffs. In a small organization, I know it is felt deeply. When CPAC has to reduce its workforce, in practical terms, what does that mean for the service Canadians receive?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103789","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I'd like to begin by thanking every witness for appearing today. I'll focus my comments on Ms. Dickenson. You wrote to me last July, and I had the opportunity to meet with CPAC last fall. I was truly thankful for that. I want to say how much I truly value CPAC's service to all Canadians. It is, as you quoted from someone who had written to you, an \"indispensable service\" to Canadians an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5069cd9c79c969a44ae52257247a3010e78b1362d2969613a4e098d6c8aff46c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6304f2a400ee0e5d53f2646af0590c6f23beb4b49e5019b3d6c78bbb438468fa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59211e58b4c4c80969f1ad5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103790,"date":"2026-04-28T16:55:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Let me ask you this: Imagine you're sitting in my seat and you're a policy-maker. What are some of the changes you would implement, and how would you prioritize them? Are there international best practices that you might look to in that process?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103790","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Let me ask you this: Imagine you're sitting in my seat and you're a policy-maker. What are some of the changes you would implement, and how would you prioritize them? Are there international best practices that you might look to in that process?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b5f123935e70c7193322448","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103791,"date":"2026-04-28T16:55:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103791","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3eb154389ecb2cbe1f250467","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103792,"date":"2026-05-05T17:10:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Welcome to our committee today. I thought I would begin by enticing you, Deputy Minister and your department, and hopefully Minister Miller, to take a little tour of my riding of Port Moody—Coquitlam, including Anmore and Belcarra, on the beautiful west coast of B.C. I'll begin by painting a picture of some of the organizations that contribute greatly to my neck of the woods. We have organizations such as the Port Moody Arts Centre, the Place des Arts and the station museum. We have active sports clubs, like the Coquitlam Express Junior A Hockey Club and the Port Moody Soccer Club. We have community media, like Tri-Cities Community TV and Freshet News. With a 46% immigration population, we have very active independent ethnic community TV producers, such as Parvaz media and KTV. I would be remiss if I didn't talk about the Festival du Bois, the much-loved festival put on by the Société francophone de Maillardville every year. These, and so many others, are bringing people together. It's all happening on the unceded territory of eight nations. These are the Kwikwetlem, Tsleil-Waututh, Musqueam, Squamish, Katzie, Kwantlen, Qayqayt and Stó꞉lō peoples. All of this culminates in an incredible project that horseshoes around the Burrard Inlet called the presence of ancestors. It's a collaboration of five house posts created by a Coast Salish artist, Tasha Faye Evans, other indigenous artists and the Port Moody Ecological Society. It really showcases my riding. It's an incredible place to visit any time of the year. With the new budget, how might these groups see themselves reflected?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103792","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Welcome to our committee today. I thought I would begin by enticing you, Deputy Minister and your department, and hopefully Minister Miller, to take a little tour of my riding of Port Moody—Coquitlam, including Anmore and Belcarra, on the beautiful west coast of B.C. I'll begin by painting a picture of some of the organizations that contribute greatly to my neck of the wood","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Broadcasting industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Broadcasting industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","label":"Broadcasting industry","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ecf81eaa5504bc5708d0f762ac82ed38497921dc16b3724360c09b6e80d42335"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b5cb9aa6e1417d2c03fc87205b3b7af4b51930eb027c3d240a0743d0a2f17543"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f47b86c2fa4aabbb99f85ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103793,"date":"2026-05-05T17:15:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"That's incredible. I think that responds very nicely to some smaller organizations. In the metro Vancouver area, which my riding is part of, there are also what we call the \"G-8\", the larger, well-established organizations: Ballet BC, Arts Umbrella, Arts Club, Bard on the Beach, the Vancouver Symphony Orchestra, the Vancouver Art Gallery, etc. There's also an emerging player: Ballet Vancouver. It is repatriating some of the top-performing Canadian ballet artists who are coming back from companies like the American Ballet Theatre. Some of them were trained in my riding. How can these bigger groups meet with your department? Are you accessible and open to meeting with them? What programs can they tap into?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103793","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's incredible. I think that responds very nicely to some smaller organizations. In the metro Vancouver area, which my riding is part of, there are also what we call the \"G-8\", the larger, well-established organizations: Ballet BC, Arts Umbrella, Arts Club, Bard on the Beach, the Vancouver Symphony Orchestra, the Vancouver Art Gallery, etc. There's also an emerging player: Ballet Vancouver. It ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","label":"Dance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","label":"Dance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e2591e9e5c34b6b154db682a6a9decd96fedcd8853ef2223a29d0f50648efb13"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91e7a17e53d8fe058b01c834f5040ec59758e6c129929cf4bfc7298260d0b994"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15f81f3a2463744a3a258ed8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103794,"date":"2026-05-05T17:15:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"That's music to my ears. Thank you so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103794","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That's music to my ears. Thank you so much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26084268f379014e7bb2d10a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752390,"date":"2026-05-05T19:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise in support of Bill C-16, because safety in Canada is not a privilege, but a fundamental right.\n\n Intimate partner violence isolates people in fear and in silence. It erodes dignity and weakens communities, and it calls on every single one of us to respond with clarity and resolve.\n\nWe are also seeing a rise in harassment, including online. Too many people are experiencing it, especially women.\n\n Each of us deserves to feel safe at home, at work and in public life. Bill C-16 would move us forward. It would reinforce something fundamental, which is that in Canada, safety, dignity and respect must be upheld for everyone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752390","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise in support of Bill C-16, because safety in Canada is not a privilege, but a fundamental right.\n\n Intimate partner violence isolates people in fear and in silence. It erodes dignity and weakens communities, and it calls on every single one of us to respond with clarity and resolve.\n\nWe are also seeing a rise in harassment, including online. Too many people are experiencing it, e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da8319bf9331f481d5e352a4f8549b6b793044f02ca6fe763f82d9a84bc8c89e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1bde8f8453bd3201dcc9caf1c4b7d148bdbedda62c0c67f72f8cf81423247c96"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83b3b0c2c937844c717990d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752389,"date":"2026-05-07T15:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, pursuant to Standing Order 34(1) I have the honour to present to the House, in both official languages, the following reports: the Canada-China Legislative Association 25th bilateral meeting, in Ottawa, Ontario, and Vancouver, British Columbia, from December 1 to 3, 2025; as well as the Canada-China Legislative Association co-chairs' annual visit to China, in Beijing, Hangzhou, Shanghai and Shenzhen, China, from March 16 to 20, 2026.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752389","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, pursuant to Standing Order 34(1) I have the honour to present to the House, in both official languages, the following reports: the Canada-China Legislative Association 25th bilateral meeting, in Ottawa, Ontario, and Vancouver, British Columbia, from December 1 to 3, 2025; as well as the Canada-China Legislative Association co-chairs' annual visit to China, in Beijing, Hangzhou, Shangh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9867d41440b8c9ca1944fbf8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103795,"date":"2026-05-28T14:25:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm going to centre my questions first on Ms. Benjamin. I'll give a bit of context. I'm a west coast MP, and I represent four of the 21 metro Vancouver municipalities—Anmore, Belcarra, Port Moody and Coquitlam. That's from smallest to largest. It's 800 people right up to nearly 170,000 people. It's four communities. Of those, Port Moody chose a moniker about 25 years ago. That moniker is \"City of the Arts\". Even back when I was a city councillor for 11 years, we were still trying to live up to that moniker. It was very important to our community. You talked about the cultural ecosystem and the necessary infrastructure. One of the things we would often do for smaller groups looking for performance space, which is also limited in the community.... There are really two main venues. One is in Port Moody, the Inlet Theatre, which has a capacity of about 190 seats, and there's a similar, slightly bigger venue in Coquitlam, the Evergreen Cultural Centre. In Port Moody, council would often grant fee waivers. How that really transpired was that a group could avoid the rental fee, but they would still need to satisfy the other costs, like the cost of the theatre technician. That might result in having to pay about $1,400 a day. That gets really expensive in smaller venues. With municipalities all over granting fee waivers, it still might not be enough to help these performing groups get their starts, so in your best estimate, what would you suggest? How can the federal government better support municipalities when there may be some existing infrastructure, albeit not enough? What do you imagine we can do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103795","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm going to centre my questions first on Ms. Benjamin. I'll give a bit of context. I'm a west coast MP, and I represent four of the 21 metro Vancouver municipalities—Anmore, Belcarra, Port Moody and Coquitlam. That's from smallest to largest. It's 800 people right up to nearly 170,000 people. It's four communities. Of those, Port Moody chose a moniker about 25 years ago. T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b0eff54ae3e4b7aa893f4d30a7215860e936d26596c7985304562d45895903f1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d3e3e0287d8924e01ca286001cd7d919b3fabf84e9a7c797f4c15559c5fb922"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb742272d51f6a7f56b4d443","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103768,"date":"2026-06-01T16:40:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to thank Master Corporals Forcier and Peddle, the veterans who are here in the gallery today, and all of the men and women who have served our country for their extraordinary service. My husband served 22 years, and he's a veteran, so I have a glimpse into this world. I know that there is nothing more powerful than the lived experience of a veteran and their transition. I want to focus my questions on three points. What is working? Where can we improve? What should the next contract look like? I'm going to begin my questioning. I'd like to get to all three of you, but I'd like to begin with Mr. Slingerland. Mr. Slingerland, I know that you've had this contract since this year, but from a rehabilitation perspective, what indications tell us that a veterans rehabilitation program is succeeding? What should Parliament be looking at beyond wait times and service volumes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103768","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to thank Master Corporals Forcier and Peddle, the veterans who are here in the gallery today, and all of the men and women who have served our country for their extraordinary service. My husband served 22 years, and he's a veteran, so I have a glimpse into this world. I know that there is nothing more powerful than the lived experience of a veteran and their transition","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["57c4e6d3911d34c13d4fa70fb10d9f06a3138ababc7a99af8cd16241a3d33d31"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cbf579839a1b9c41eebdcd31f69d2213a3174bdb6101cba7791a25f6d87add15"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c20e83f4b4014aeab4e9c50d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103769,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you. Master Corporal Forcier, you've had an extraordinary journey. You've shared that, and I want to recognize it. Where do you see the greatest opportunities for improvement? I know you've talked about the co-creation of the program in concert with veterans and the importance of the individual plans, but can you talk a bit more about what this might look like in practice?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103769","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Master Corporal Forcier, you've had an extraordinary journey. You've shared that, and I want to recognize it. Where do you see the greatest opportunities for improvement? I know you've talked about the co-creation of the program in concert with veterans and the importance of the individual plans, but can you talk a bit more about what this might look like in practice?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f240b179f55ff8a2038d972f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103770,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you very much. Mr. Peddle, very quickly—we have only about 30 seconds—trust is fragile and precious. What would be some of the building blocks that we could implement that would restore trust with veterans who are in this program?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103770","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Mr. Peddle, very quickly—we have only about 30 seconds—trust is fragile and precious. What would be some of the building blocks that we could implement that would restore trust with veterans who are in this program?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2735ed51391153adf23fe68fd007d132cd03a8a147edaba305f6ccd87b25871f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3e26080685c2398e8b141fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103771,"date":"2026-06-01T16:45:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103771","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71db8e5d9ab6fc9818e0469c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103796,"date":"2026-06-02T17:45:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Okay. Yikes.... In the cities and communities I represent—Coquitlam, Port Moody, Anmore and Belcarra—we have two theatres. Those are a 200-seat theatre in Port Moody and a 257-seat theatre in Coquitlam, the Evergreen Cultural Centre black box. Years ago, when I was still on city council, cities were doing these cultural mapping exercises. There are two that really stick out. One is Kelowna, and the other one is Coquitlam. In Coquitlam, they created an arts, culture and heritage strategic plan for 2015-30. It was everything from cultural mapping and community consultation to facilities planning and infrastructure assessment. It treated culture as an economic engine, growing a cultural ecosystem. Where can the intersection be between cities that know and that have worked so closely with the many arts groups that make up their communities...? How can the federal government intersect with communities to identify...? We know that programming isn't the biggest challenge; it's the space. That's one. I also really wanted to ask about the tax credit. How would it work in practice, and what would it look like? In the seconds left, who is the best person to answer? I want to leave you with this as well. You're all such incredible witnesses. Please send us written statements that can be used in testimony. This will help enrich our study. Each one of you has so much to contribute to this, and I don't want anything to be left behind. Grumms, take it away.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103796","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Yikes.... In the cities and communities I represent—Coquitlam, Port Moody, Anmore and Belcarra—we have two theatres. Those are a 200-seat theatre in Port Moody and a 257-seat theatre in Coquitlam, the Evergreen Cultural Centre black box. Years ago, when I was still on city council, cities were doing these cultural mapping exercises. There are two that really stick out. One is Kelowna, and th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","label":"Cultural development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","label":"Cultural development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["09f2ec6416260de64438da21537d682c1af347333c22262f78752beb96cc3d46"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1ab3bbc0a1f735258322d74a3084e950c6432cfd8179cc1598a916eec5f650f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-598fe77d0e9af78cb75397e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103797,"date":"2026-06-02T17:50:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"The spaces.... Jonathan, please go ahead. All of you....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103797","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The spaces.... Jonathan, please go ahead. All of you....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5802978e3890fa03a04b21b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103798,"date":"2026-06-02T17:50:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you. Please write in to us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103798","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Please write in to us.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eddfe67dbf393b2c09319788","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103772,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"Welcome, Captain Gibson. I'm so pleased to welcome you here. I thank both of our witnesses for their incredible service to our country. I think your background talked about your being at CFB Esquimalt in 2000. My husband was a base engineer in the early nineties at CFB Esquimalt. I don't know that your paths would have crossed, but I just wanted to share that as a bit of background and to recognize your 44 years of service. You received the Member of the Order of Military Merit medal from Michaëlle Jean, a Black woman governor general. That is really incredible and so very impressive. You talked about having a really good experience with Veterans Affairs, but it's a more recent experience, I would say. Can you talk about some of the parts that you feel have been working really well in that experience? Can you give a bit more detail? What was the transition like from your 44 years to moving through this process with VAC?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103772","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Welcome, Captain Gibson. I'm so pleased to welcome you here. I thank both of our witnesses for their incredible service to our country. I think your background talked about your being at CFB Esquimalt in 2000. My husband was a base engineer in the early nineties at CFB Esquimalt. I don't know that your paths would have crossed, but I just wanted to share that as a bit of background and to recogniz","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["29f941e90c30c4dd0378e3bb1c34afa54defda9f7cb9fd2cd58dbfd22f0a4119"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c411be9e58d256660df7438b32885772b35b754d4455b127d856f1941b5959e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db2ca26ceaf8ded1c271f029","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103773,"date":"2026-06-03T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"Ms. Gibson, you served for 44 years. What was the thing that kept you in?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103773","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Ms. Gibson, you served for 44 years. What was the thing that kept you in?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12f8de0e618d0fefe6a24196","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103774,"date":"2026-06-03T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103774","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab1860413a4674dda7538ead","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103775,"date":"2026-06-03T23:20:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"All right, here it goes. Sergeant, thank you very much for your incredible service. Ms. Gillis, Sergeant, you both make incredible witnesses. I'm not going to do that justice. I don't want to at all diminish your incredible experiences and your contribution. I'd like to know, Ms. Gillis, if you were to design the system from the ground up, what you would consider a very effective rehabilitation program. What would it look like?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103775","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"All right, here it goes. Sergeant, thank you very much for your incredible service. Ms. Gillis, Sergeant, you both make incredible witnesses. I'm not going to do that justice. I don't want to at all diminish your incredible experiences and your contribution. I'd like to know, Ms. Gillis, if you were to design the system from the ground up, what you would consider a very effective rehabilitation pr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e98b7fe3df4b33652a9dcfa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103776,"date":"2026-06-03T23:20:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"Is that whole medical workup the first piece? The training and supervision, but....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103776","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is that whole medical workup the first piece? The training and supervision, but....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eda9b1963396acb421553f9e3d0878d293d7166bfb021d25033dc79a56809e78"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fbe417a075921a62c6037024","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103777,"date":"2026-06-03T23:20:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"I know there will be time for written statements after, so please, if you could....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103777","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I know there will be time for written statements after, so please, if you could....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["492126c1dab72151b904cadf2463e9d914a0be09e83f411b34b550acec2f9b8b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ec046242521bc146fde0ff0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103778,"date":"2026-06-03T23:20:00+00:00","title":"ACVA","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"ACVA","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ACVA/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103778","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcf35846999f978cb72d184f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103799,"date":"2026-06-04T15:15:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103799","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d66d2e55087f9174c935a61","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103800,"date":"2026-06-04T15:15:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"My question is for Christy. I'm talking about Arts on the Avenue. I was a city councillor in Port Moody when Mayor Don Iveson was speaking at the Federation of Canadian Municipalities. He was talking about the transformation that was taking place in Edmonton. He talked about the tech hub that it was becoming and how it was attracting investment and revitalization, but when you were speaking, I thought, \"Wait a second, you were there first.\" You were actually creating the vibrancy. My very quick question is, how can arts organizations work with cities—which are often doing cultural mapping and strat plans around the arts—to access the build communities strong funds in terms of cultural precincts? Please, I have 35 seconds.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103800","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"My question is for Christy. I'm talking about Arts on the Avenue. I was a city councillor in Port Moody when Mayor Don Iveson was speaking at the Federation of Canadian Municipalities. He was talking about the transformation that was taking place in Edmonton. He talked about the tech hub that it was becoming and how it was attracting investment and revitalization, but when you were speaking, I tho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee4c09b8e70db66fdaf508c0a957f5a22b52d5b6a7e3ea2f2285f0bdc121508f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41b155b1502aecaace43e7d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103801,"date":"2026-06-04T15:15:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"I would invite every single witness—Tania, I had questions for you as well, but I know that we're out of time—to provide further written testimony, because I know there's much that you could have said and wanted to say. That would be amazing to enrich our study. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103801","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would invite every single witness—Tania, I had questions for you as well, but I know that we're out of time—to provide further written testimony, because I know there's much that you could have said and wanted to say. That would be amazing to enrich our study. Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","label":"Science education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","label":"Scholarships","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd1d84ba40821e1ac56fefd174b884f21de23deccdafbe47f5aa13e2debd19ab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-626c37dda9e5d534bde98a0c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103802,"date":"2026-06-09T17:55:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you to every person who's appearing here today. Mr. Beamish, in less than three years, Ballet Vancouver has made incredible strides in the development of B.C.'s performing arts sector and in the professional classical ballet space. You have been instrumental in repatriating top Canadian talent from other countries and from some companies, such as the American Ballet Theatre and San Francisco's ballet company, etc. How important is the repatriation and the retention of professional artists to our cultural sovereignty?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103802","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you to every person who's appearing here today. Mr. Beamish, in less than three years, Ballet Vancouver has made incredible strides in the development of B.C.'s performing arts sector and in the professional classical ballet space. You have been instrumental in repatriating top Canadian talent from other countries and from some companies, such as the American Ballet Theatre and San Francisco","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","label":"Dance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","label":"Dance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["98895015595f74800afa9b60f3b5c8030bcba507c3d38e8356e3e96b3276a43e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4095bb5c00c8326bcac04849e1ad9d0b9d7a5b19c4cda8bb324efabdf23563b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff8b861ebebc510373e40d93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103803,"date":"2026-06-09T17:55:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"How important is the critical cultural infrastructure to this piece of being able to actually retain and repatriate artists?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103803","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How important is the critical cultural infrastructure to this piece of being able to actually retain and repatriate artists?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Artists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","label":"Artists","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f842d72002eddc952d3494b835c4f3c97c5856b110bff09e4aeec2778c976a99"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e90d5d47075d013ffd98a871","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103804,"date":"2026-06-09T18:00:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"In your opening remarks, you said that individual donors were up 1,600%, and ticket sales were up 50%. You are experiencing exponential growth, and I know that your operating budget will need to quadruple in the next year. With that growth, how can the federal government better support that type of extenuating circumstance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103804","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In your opening remarks, you said that individual donors were up 1,600%, and ticket sales were up 50%. You are experiencing exponential growth, and I know that your operating budget will need to quadruple in the next year. With that growth, how can the federal government better support that type of extenuating circumstance?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b74e59036619898c3cf23a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1103805,"date":"2026-06-09T18:00:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"CHPC","text":"Thank you very much. In my 20 seconds remaining, I have a quick question for Ms. Juneau. I know that the build communities strong fund doesn't necessarily have a carve-out for cultural spaces. Can you speak just a bit to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1103805","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. In my 20 seconds remaining, I have a quick question for Ms. Juneau. I know that the build communities strong fund doesn't necessarily have a carve-out for cultural spaces. Can you speak just a bit to that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9afbd9bb795cf094d54b7de4fb5e9a3d7042ae16692c989a6971b8d08613f69d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e1217f79401de1c79c20db1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085074,"date":"2026-06-09T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Zoe Royer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, over the past three weeks in Port Moody—Coquitlam, I have been truly inspired by remarkable young people. I met students at the Youth Leadership Society of B.C.'s Model UN, the HanaTV youth press corps and the Steps Together Foundation public speaking contest, young people who were debating human rights and diplomacy, learning journalism and finding the courage to use their voices. I also had the honour of meeting members of the 754 Phoenix Squadron of the Royal Canadian Air Cadets and hearing the remarkable Port Moody Youth Symphony Orchestra.\n\n These opportunities do not happen by accident. They are built by founders, mentors, families and leaders in every field who pour their hearts into helping young people grow and lead. This gives me great hope for Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083648","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Orchestras","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085074","member_id":"bc-mp-59294","member_name":"Zoe Royer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, over the past three weeks in Port Moody—Coquitlam, I have been truly inspired by remarkable young people. I met students at the Youth Leadership Society of B.C.'s Model UN, the HanaTV youth press corps and the Steps Together Foundation public speaking contest, young people who were debating human rights and diplomacy, learning journalism and finding the courage to use their voices. I ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083648","label":"Orchestras"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083648","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Orchestras","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083648","label":"Orchestras","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a28c269abb94fb0261b73a48cbcedf3e00a7cff914342887cb4a403f5a5799b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083648","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Orchestras","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b03472280777f82586748fc4578308356f457eee33a9d2a1e05e9939d51a90f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083648","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Orchestras","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083648","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d4c277fec122e626adc65d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70490,"date":"2026-01-27T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats just returned from Rankin Inlet, where we witnessed the challenges facing Canadians in the north. We heard stories of 12, 15 or 17 people living in a two-bedroom home, of folks on housing waitlists for decades and of extreme food prices, from $15 onions to $28 orange juice. There is no hospital, not enough jobs and unreliable Internet.\n\nPeople are experiencing similar issues in communities across Canada. When is the government going to take real action to address them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70490","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats just returned from Rankin Inlet, where we witnessed the challenges facing Canadians in the north. We heard stories of 12, 15 or 17 people living in a two-bedroom home, of folks on housing waitlists for decades and of extreme food prices, from $15 onions to $28 orange juice. There is no hospital, not enough jobs and unreliable Internet.\n\nPeople are experiencing similar is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9c0cde89c48272649509af1f42f7e713fa80e4a14aed05ac3009d68baa5714cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["55b0cd19073120b678fc63578f45c1f82d380eed44b576693c5010c106349fbb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c26e59fac6cf06b7b21e3841","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70491,"date":"2026-01-28T21:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to request an emergency debate on the recent deeply concerning actions and statements by the Trump administration that have grave implications for the sovereignty and security of Canada.\n\nOn January 3, President Trump ordered American forces to disregard international law and core principles of national sovereignty by attacking Venezuela, a UN member state. This aggression was followed by President Trump's announcement of a Donroe doctrine, considering the entire western Hemisphere to be within the sole hegemonic control of the United States.\n\nOn January 18, President Trump expressed his intent to seize Greenland, a territory of Denmark, another UN member state and, importantly, a NATO member. He justified this aggression by referencing Greenland's Arctic proximity, mineral reserves and inadequate defence capacity.\n\nThese actions and words have direct application to Canada. They follow repeated and continuing threats made to Canada since Donald Trump became President. They are occurring on a daily basis right up to this moment. There is a wide consensus among observers, policy experts and stakeholders from across the political spectrum in Canada, from Jason Kenney to Bob Rae, that our country is vulnerable as a result.\n\nIt is vital that members of Parliament be afforded an opportunity to speak to these important and urgent matters, which profoundly affect our sovereignty, security and place in the world. I ask that this emergency debate be approved and conducted forthwith tonight.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70491","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to request an emergency debate on the recent deeply concerning actions and statements by the Trump administration that have grave implications for the sovereignty and security of Canada.\n\nOn January 3, President Trump ordered American forces to disregard international law and core principles of national sovereignty by attacking Venezuela, a UN member state. This aggress","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","label":"Arctic","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e63da4bbe562c17e7ad86b8ed8d30e93e98d0ae582210c477b2297f5f41aeab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b43cb6184004f934e53ecf50","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70492,"date":"2026-01-29T16:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is facing an unprecedented threat to our sovereignty from Donald Trump and his administration. This is the most serious external danger for our country in decades, but we also face challenges to Canada's unity from within. Actions and words that sow division, spread hatred and foment violence are scourges that undermine and damage society.\n\nThis week we marked International Holocaust Remembrance Day, a sombre commemoration of the genocide that took the lives of six million Jews and damaged the lives of millions more. Today is the national day of action against Islamophobia and remembrance of the Québec City mosque attack that killed and injured 25 Muslims at prayer. Together, these profound memorials remind us of the deadly effects of racism and the need to confront it, and defeat it, every day.\n\nNew Democrats will always stand with those fighting for the equality, dignity, safety and respect of all Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70492","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is facing an unprecedented threat to our sovereignty from Donald Trump and his administration. This is the most serious external danger for our country in decades, but we also face challenges to Canada's unity from within. Actions and words that sow division, spread hatred and foment violence are scourges that undermine and damage society.\n\nThis week we marked International Hol","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["207e528483d0765c5d38c31f0cadcb3529666b10ae2f6fe44739031b8f9bcb2c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9e19737b9f1df67a246a67b35ca12f6ac8014d558d07d41fa5fc42065dd643cf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d607bc1018babb326fcae6c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":96210,"date":"2026-02-10T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister recently urged the global community to stand up to superpower intimidation and called on middle powers to stand together to resist it. \n\nThe United States has imposed an illegal blockade on Cuba for decades, crippling its economy and causing mass suffering to the Cuban people. Now Donald Trump is cutting off fuel, risking a humanitarian disaster. \n\nWill the Prime Minister stay true to his words in Davos, uphold independent Canadian foreign policy and support Cuba in the face of aggressive U.S. imperialism?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96210","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister recently urged the global community to stand up to superpower intimidation and called on middle powers to stand together to resist it. \n\nThe United States has imposed an illegal blockade on Cuba for decades, crippling its economy and causing mass suffering to the Cuban people. Now Donald Trump is cutting off fuel, risking a humanitarian disaster. \n\nWill the Prime Mi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc31c20d4244ad249ff3426c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":96209,"date":"2026-02-11T19:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we solemnly gather today in the shadow of a heartbreaking tragedy that has shaken our country. \n\nOur nation is in mourning. \n\nYesterday in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia, nine innocent lives were senselessly taken and 25 people were injured in a horrific mass shooting. This violence unfolded at a school, a place meant to nurture and protect our children, deepening the shock and sorrow felt by all Canadians. \n\nLoved ones have been stolen, families have been shattered, and a small community will be changed forever. In a place where everyone knows one another, where neighbours are more like extended family, a loss like this reverberates through every home, every workplace and every gathering. \n\n To the families who are mourning: We grieve with you, we stand behind you and we hold you in our hearts. We know that no words can fill the void, but we hope that you feel the support of a nation that is behind you today, tomorrow and for all the challenging days ahead.\n\nWe remember all of the victims not as numbers in a headline but as human beings whose lives were rich and meaningful. The light they brought into this world and the potential they carried can never be replaced and will never be forgotten. \n\nTo the injured, we send our deepest thoughts of healing and strength. \n\nTo the students, friends and teachers who suffered this assault, we are there for you. \n\nWe express our profound gratitude to the educators who first faced this assault, the first responders who courageously rushed to the scene as it unfolded and to all the health care workers who are caring for the injured. Your humanity and professionalism in the face of trauma remind us of the quiet heroism you display in our communities every single day. \n\nWe thank the many people of Tumbler Ridge and across the region who have rushed to offer support for one another in this heartbreaking moment. In times like these, the strength of a community is truly revealed. \n\nIn the face of such senseless tragedy and pain, we feel anger, confusion and despair. We ask ourselves how such violence can happen in our communities in this country. These questions matter, and they deserve honest, thoughtful consideration. There will be a time to answer them, but that time is not today. \n\nToday is a day when we cherish the victims and care for their families. Today is a day when we collectively grieve, comfort and hold each other just a little more tightly. Today is a day when a nation comes together in solidarity and love.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-84/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-84/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96209","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we solemnly gather today in the shadow of a heartbreaking tragedy that has shaken our country. \n\nOur nation is in mourning. \n\nYesterday in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia, nine innocent lives were senselessly taken and 25 people were injured in a horrific mass shooting. This violence unfolded at a school, a place meant to nurture and protect our children, deepening the shock and sorro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5e19bb3611a9b5855c6788df6620641624dcfb091e214caaffae10b452fda423"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f6e6d1220f453fa841aec0374e6ea416520290ac25bbd1900d26b80067cacbc5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b79153d676fe408d96f38962","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304955,"date":"2026-02-25T21:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved:\n\nMotion No. 1\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 126.\n\nMotion No. 2\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 127.\n\nMotion No. 3\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 128.\n\nMotion No. 4\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 129.\n\nMotion No. 5\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 130.\n\nMotion No. 6\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 131.\n\nMotion No. 7\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 132.\n\nMotion No. 8\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 133.\n\nMotion No. 9\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 134.\n\nMotion No. 10\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 135.\n\nMotion No. 11\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 136.\n\nMotion No. 12\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 137.\n\nMotion No. 13\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 138.\n\nMotion No. 14\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 139.\n\nMotion No. 15\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 140.\n\nMotion No. 16\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 141.\n\nMotion No. 17\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 142.\n\nMotion No. 18\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 143.\n\nMotion No. 19\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 144.\n\nMotion No. 20\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 145.\n\nMotion No. 21\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 146.\n\nMotion No. 22\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 147.\n\nMotion No. 23\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 148.\n\nMotion No. 24\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 149.\n\nMotion No. 25\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 150.\n\nMotion No. 26\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 151.\n\nMotion No. 27\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 152.\n\nMotion No. 28\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 153.\n\nMotion No. 29\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 154.\n\nMotion No. 30\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 155.\n\nMotion No. 31\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 156.\n\nMotion No. 32\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 157.\n\nMotion No. 33\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 158.\n\nMotion No. 34\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 167.\n\nMotion No. 35\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 168.\n\nMotion No. 36\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 169.\n\nMotion No. 37\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 170.\n\nMotion No. 38\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 171.\n\nMotion No. 39\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 172.\n\nMotion No. 40\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 173.\n\nMotion No. 41\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 174.\n\nMotion No. 42\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 175.\n\nMotion No. 43\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 176.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304955","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"moved:\n\nMotion No. 1\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 126.\n\nMotion No. 2\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 127.\n\nMotion No. 3\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 128.\n\nMotion No. 4\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 129.\n\nMotion No. 5\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 130.\n\nMotion No. 6\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 131.\n\nMo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["44ec7e2b428d94671d7cf22197230a680f4de0d3a4bdadcd2025a66d40e63f74"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79fb8199904efb02f77b053f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304956,"date":"2026-02-25T21:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved:\n\nMotion No. 48\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 203.\n\nMotion No. 49\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 204.\n\nMotion No. 50\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 205.\n\nMotion No. 51\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 206.\n\nMotion No. 52\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 207.\n\nMotion No. 53\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 208.\n\nMotion No. 54\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 209.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304956","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"moved:\n\nMotion No. 48\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 203.\n\nMotion No. 49\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 204.\n\nMotion No. 50\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 205.\n\nMotion No. 51\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 206.\n\nMotion No. 52\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 207.\n\nMotion No. 53\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 20","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["584f48d932a84d7552e959c1efc42308a81f679e209fdcf118c14f73de9bccb0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-059fe7a0622ae627a449e6b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304957,"date":"2026-02-25T21:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved:\n\nMotion No. 78\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 373.\n\nMotion No. 79\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 374.\n\nMotion No. 80\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 375.\n\nMotion No. 81\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 597.\n\nMotion No. 82\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 598.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304957","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"moved:\n\nMotion No. 78\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 373.\n\nMotion No. 79\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 374.\n\nMotion No. 80\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 375.\n\nMotion No. 81\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 597.\n\nMotion No. 82\n\nThat Bill C-15 be amended by deleting Clause 598.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["204f25e5c964788f42445563c3c836a5a6d1010af7175db08e6418a8e36e4101"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50da5080d69d0d6f1dd4816c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304958,"date":"2026-02-25T21:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"He said: Mr. Speaker, Canadians are facing multiple overlapping crises, from difficulties finding affordable housing and buying groceries to feed their families, to a climate emergency that threatens our very planet. The budget was an opportunity to meet this moment. Unfortunately, in New Democrats' view, it has failed. In fact, it would actually reverse many measures the Liberals themselves told Canadians were essential just months ago. \n\nNew Democrats believe much more can and should be done to build a stronger, more prosperous and independent Canada that works for all Canadians. Accordingly, we proposed a number of amendments and changes to the budget to meet this objective. Today I will highlight those at report stage that relate to sections of the budget that we argue should be deleted. \n\nFirst, the Liberals' decision to repeal the digital services tax would hand a major victory to U.S. tech giants at the direct expense of Canadian taxpayers and an even greater victory to Donald Trump. When the Liberals announced this measure in budget 2021, they described it as essential \"to ensure that corporations in all sectors, including digital corporations, pay their fair share of tax on that money they earn by doing business in Canada.\" Those are not my words. They are the words of the Liberal government. When the Trump administration objected, the Liberals pledged to abandon this measure immediately. \n\nThe digital services tax was specifically designed to ensure that the largest U.S. tech giants, companies like those led by Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg, contribute fairly to the Canadian economy with the profits they make here from Canadians. The Parliamentary Budget Officer estimated it would raise $7.2 billion over five years, revenue that could have supported public services, infrastructure and programs Canadians need and rely on. Instead, the Liberals caved to Donald Trump, walked away from billions in revenue and gave up a tool meant to level the playing field for Canadian businesses, all without negotiating a single benefit for Canada in return. \n\nThe result is that the Liberals are rewarding the biggest foreign tech corporations while eliminating tens of thousands of family-sustaining jobs and slashing services that Canadians rely on. New Democrats say that is the wrong way to go. \n\nSecond, the budget would repeal the underused housing tax during a housing crisis, which is a truly baffling decision. When this measure was first introduced, the Liberals described it as \"a national, tax-based measure targeting the unproductive use of domestic housing that is owned by non-resident, non-Canadians\", arguing that it would ensure foreign owners who use Canada as a place to passively store wealth in housing \"pay their fair share\". Again, it was the Liberals who said that, yet in this budget, the Liberals today wish to eliminate this measure entirely. I guess the development industry has gotten to them. \n\nThe PBO estimates the underused housing tax would raise $693 million over five years. Repealing it means we would be walking away from hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue that could be used to support truly affordable non-market housing, municipal infrastructure or other public priorities. It would also remove an important policy lever designed to discourage vacant foreign-investor-held properties at a time when Canadians are struggling with some of the worst housing affordability challenges in our country's history. This would encourage premises to stay vacant when renters are desperately in need of spaces to call home. \n\nThird, while working-class Canadians are told by the government to make sacrifices, the government is proposing to repeal the luxury tax on private jets and yachts. The contrast could not be more glaring: austerity for working people, and tax breaks for those at the very top. It is also another total liberal backflip. In budget 2021, the Liberals argued that \"Those who can afford to buy luxury goods can afford to pay a bit more\", especially at a time when ordinary Canadians were making sacrifices to keep our economy afloat post-COVID. \n\nTo New Democrats, that logic still holds, yet the Liberals are now abandoning the luxury tax on private jets and yachts entirely. Their justification is that the luxury tax costs more to administer than it brings in, but their own 2025 budget contradicts this claim. Eliminating the tax would cost $135 million over five years in lost revenue. Walking away from this revenue is a political choice, one that benefits the wealthiest in Canada, while the Liberal government eliminates tens of thousands of family-sustaining jobs and slashes services Canadians rely on because it claims to have a revenue problem.\n\nWhat makes this decision even more troubling is that unions in the aviation and boating sectors have proposed practical solutions to address the potential industry impacts of this measure, not a full repeal of the luxury tax. Instead of listening to workers and refining the policy, though, the Liberals are listening to the ultrawealthy in this country and seeking to scrap it altogether. The result is a policy retreat that gives up hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue, abandons an important tax fairness measure aimed at the ultrawealthy and ignores the constructive proposals put forward by workers and their unions who were ready to help improve the system rather than dismantle it.\n\nFourth, Bill C-15 contains a serious threat to Canada's democratic foundations. Division 5 of part 5 contains clauses that would grant federal ministers sweeping Henry VIII-style powers to temporarily exempt any individual corporation, individual, partnership, association or organization from the application of almost every federal law and regulation. Although the Liberals made a deal to accept Conservative amendments at committee to add some limited guardrails to these provisions, the core issue remains. This legislation would give ministers the extraordinary power to exempt specific people and corporations from federal laws and regulations. These exemptions could override labour standards, health and safety rules, environmental protections, indigenous rights and more. Even with the limited guardrails, the scope of potential exemptions remains incredibly expansive.\n\nThis undermines the separation of powers by allowing the executive to override laws passed by this Parliament without full transparency or accountability. These clauses do not streamline regulation, as has been claimed. Rather, they erode the rule of law and create a two-tier system where laws passed by Parliament can be suspended arbitrarily. Legal experts and civil liberties advocates maintain that this is not true regulatory sandboxing, as is claimed. They argue that even with the deal cut with the Conservatives, this approach is too broad and is less transparent than existing sandbox frameworks in other jurisdictions.\n\nThe NDP maintains that these clauses cannot be fixed through backroom deals between the Liberals and Conservatives. Indeed, the government still has not publicly justified why such extraordinary powers are necessary. Measures of this magnitude should not be buried in a 600-page omnibus budget bill, which Liberals themselves, in opposition, said they would not bring in. Once in government, it is a different story. If the Liberals believe these powers are essential, they should introduce stand-alone legislation that can be fully studied and debated transparently. To protect democratic governance, the rule of law and Canada's constitutional order, division 5 of part 5 should be removed from Bill C-15 entirely.\n\nFifth, clauses 373 to 375 of Bill C-15 would retroactively redefine \"province\" to exclude the territories in the veterans health care regulations as it relates to accommodation and meals payment by veterans in long-term care. In short, this would allow Veterans Affairs Canada to legitimize its past overcharges to veterans and nullify ongoing litigation aimed at securing reimbursement for affected veterans. Canada's Veterans Ombud, retired Colonel Nishika Jardine, has written to the Minister of Veteran Affairs asking that these provisions be removed from the bill. In her words, \"using retroactive legislation to correct administrative errors is both inappropriate and unfair and undermines confidence in government decision-making\".\n\nShe continues:\n\nUltimately, it is clear to the Veteran community that Bill C-15 [changes] are meant solely to correct an error made by the Department and to deny [veterans] compensation for the overcharge. VAC already faces growing reputational backlash over the manner in which it communicates with Canada's Veterans, their families and Survivors. I fear this retroactivity measure, if enacted, will only increase the deep distrust....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304958","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"He said: Mr. Speaker, Canadians are facing multiple overlapping crises, from difficulties finding affordable housing and buying groceries to feed their families, to a climate emergency that threatens our very planet. The budget was an opportunity to meet this moment. Unfortunately, in New Democrats' view, it has failed. In fact, it would actually reverse many measures the Liberals themselves told ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fc7777c66dcd63c1b5b91bde0f0ae905dfa4bca28c3e2b3d6a4952857b270b0e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c376d4ba6028bc8cfce1c885593c3aeb9d9285926050aca774cae3d747c95a45"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5510ba597c5fac0f4e6cd16f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304959,"date":"2026-02-25T21:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am glad my hon. colleague brought up the last election. I do not recall the Liberals telling Canadians in the last election that if they were elected, they would cave to Donald Trump and remove the digital services tax. Frankly, the Liberals told Canadians they would have an elbows-up approach and take a firm stance with Donald Trump.\n\nI do not recall the Liberals telling Canadians that they would get rid of the underused housing tax, which is a measure that is starting to work in this country; house prices are starting to come down. I do not recall the Liberals telling Canadians that they were going to hurt veterans by overcharging them for long-term care. They did not say those things.\n\nThere is a fundamental question of credibility raised by my hon. colleague. When parties tell Canadians something during an election, Canadians expect them to be true to it when they are in government. The Liberals are failing that test.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304959","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am glad my hon. colleague brought up the last election. I do not recall the Liberals telling Canadians in the last election that if they were elected, they would cave to Donald Trump and remove the digital services tax. Frankly, the Liberals told Canadians they would have an elbows-up approach and take a firm stance with Donald Trump.\n\nI do not recall the Liberals telling Canadians ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["916f113d81008a42957a04e18b070497c7e4110e76e89c392878f085318d62d1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a60b8e88b8cef809fca07879f0ddd9aa3640eca7b38e972d3a48b504a5fc3936"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0abf090f49921ce445975038","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304960,"date":"2026-02-25T21:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. colleague for that excellent question. Much is raised by that question, including the proper approach to dealing with what we all agree is a difficult Donald Trump administration. Nevertheless, the Liberal government said it would stand up to the Trump administration, yet all we have seen is concession after concession, and we are getting nothing in return.\n\nIt raises the fundamental question of tax fairness. If we are not going to tax the largest, most profitable digital corporations in the world, U.S. tech giants that make hundreds of billions of dollars every year, then what message does that send to ordinary Canadians who the Prime Minister asked to tighten their belts? What message does it send to the 50,000 federal civil servants who are getting pink slips. and the tens of thousands more of their family members, because the government says it does not have enough money?\n\nIt sends the message that the government cares more about pleasing Donald Trump and pleasing U.S. tech giants than it does about fundamental fairness to Canadians in this country, and New Democrats—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304960","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. colleague for that excellent question. Much is raised by that question, including the proper approach to dealing with what we all agree is a difficult Donald Trump administration. Nevertheless, the Liberal government said it would stand up to the Trump administration, yet all we have seen is concession after concession, and we are getting nothing in return.\n\nIt raises ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c16087c3e396aa22c49a73526e3ad2268f8f53c17952c799ba375aa14078ddcb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c86d9da49a3574b60293c2ab21ffdcb11452e8c80341c373b4e9192c170d03d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9aef1546bfae1dfe030ad385","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304961,"date":"2026-02-25T21:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, no, I do not. The government has a revenue problem. Instead of cutting and slashing services that Canadians need at a time when we are facing crises, and I must respectfully say the Conservatives would slash even more, what we need to do is raise revenue in a fair and progressive manner.\n\nThat is why we should do things like tax yachts, private jets and U.S. tech giants, and make sure that the wealthiest pay a bit more. That is what the Liberals said was necessary before the last election, and it is something New Democrats believe in. We have a great country. We need to pay for the services Canadians—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304961","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, no, I do not. The government has a revenue problem. Instead of cutting and slashing services that Canadians need at a time when we are facing crises, and I must respectfully say the Conservatives would slash even more, what we need to do is raise revenue in a fair and progressive manner.\n\nThat is why we should do things like tax yachts, private jets and U.S. tech giants, and make sure","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7bb88bd86f85c4d408b1c2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332181,"date":"2026-03-10T03:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, there are moments in global affairs when the decisions of powerful nations echo beyond their borders, when the international order is tested, when rules meant to prevent mass violence are cast aside and when innocent people pay the ultimate price. We are living through such a moment now.\n\n On February 28, the United States and Israel launched coordinated air strikes against Iran. This was a patently unlawful act of aggression and the consequences were entirely foreseeable: Iranian retaliation across the region, the closure of the Strait of Hormuz and a rapidly escalating conflict with massive damage and the loss of innocent lives.\n\n It is a war being prosecuted with appalling brutality and disregard for international humanitarian law. Instead of protecting civilians, U.S. and Israeli forces are deliberately striking non-military sites and civilian infrastructure, a pattern disturbingly reminiscent of Israel's recent siege of Gaza. Targets hit thus far include a girls' elementary school, attacked by missiles once to kill the children and then again to kill the parents frantically looking for their kids; hospitals; desalination plants; oil refineries; and historic cultural sites. Densely populated cities are being carpet-bombed. The death toll is now in the thousands.\n\n These are war crimes. This disregard for civilian life is no accident. It is being openly celebrated by the Trump administration. On March 2, U.S. Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth declared the United States will not be following \"stupid rules of engagement\" or fighting \"politically correct wars\". Instead, he said that \"death and destruction\" were the prime objectives of the U.S. forces.\n\n What has been the Liberal government's response to this illegal, dangerous assault? It is a position that is unprincipled, contradictory and incoherent. In fact, it has changed almost daily. The Prime Minister's initial response offered a full-throated endorsement with no caveats, conditions or even a mention of international law. That is a telling and tragic omission.\n\n Under the UN Charter, force between states is prohibited, except in two prescribed circumstances: self-defence from an actual attack or authorization by the Security Council. These strikes met neither test. Trump administration officials admitted there was no intelligence suggesting Iran planned to attack the United States, and neither the U.S. nor Israel even attempted to bring a case before the Security Council, the only body under international law empowered to determine when the use of force is lawful. Put bluntly, this attack is clearly and completely illegal under international law.\n\n Moreover, the International Atomic Energy Agency has confirmed that their inspectors had found no evidence of a coordinated Iranian program to build nuclear weapons. On the contrary, at the very time the U.S. and Israel attacked, negotiations were ongoing, with mediator Oman saying that significant progress was being made and that Iran had made all the necessary concessions asked of it. This is against the backdrop of Donald Trump ripping up the previous nuclear agreement with Iran that had, by all accounts, been working, as well as the bombing of Iranian nuclear facilities and scientists by Israeli forces last June, which Trump said, at the time, conclusively took out Iran's nuclear weapons capacity.\n\nHowever, the Prime Minister chose to endorse this war. Only four days after doing so, he then admitted that the attack appears inconsistent with international law, but in the same breath declared he supports it, with regret. Then, when asked directly whether Canada might participate militarily, the Prime Minister refused to draw a firm line, saying only that \"One can never categorically rule out participation\".\n\n This is untenable. One cannot logically and ethically acknowledge that a war is illegal, but continue to support it and refuse to rule out participation in that very illegality. More disturbingly, the words and actions of the Prime Minister completely contradict the foreign policy doctrine he outlined at Davos just weeks ago. There, he told the world that Canada and other middle powers \"are not powerless\" and that we have \"the capacity to build a new order that encompasses our values, like respect for human rights...sovereignty and territorial integrity\".\n\n He said that we aim to be principled in our commitment to the prohibition of the use of force, except when consistent with the UN Charter. He claimed that middle powers must \"live the truth\" by \"acting consistently, applying the same standards to allies and rivals.\"\n\nCanada has rightly condemned Russia's invasion of Ukraine as illegal, but when the United States and Israel launched air strikes that equally violated international law, the Prime Minister offered his support. This is a stark betrayal of the Prime Minister's own words.\n\n In our view, Canada's security is always dependent on a rules-based order that constrains great powers. The moment we decide international law applies only to our adversaries, we undermine the very protections that shield countries like our own. This is not just my position as leader of the New Democratic Party. Former Liberal foreign affairs minister Lloyd Axworthy has been blunt in his critique of the Prime Minister's approach.\n\nMr. Axworthy said Canada is abandoning its historic commitment to preventing illegal aggression. He warns that the Prime Minister is becoming a \"complicit partner\" to Trump's ambitions, and he indicts the Prime Minister with endorsing Trump's new \"obsession with becoming an imperial power\", calling that the \"worst kind of situation for Canada.\"\n\nCanada ought not continue down this path. The time for ambiguity is over, and principled clarity is required now. That is why New Democrats are calling on the government to take three clear positions immediately: Condemn the war and explicitly recognize it violates the UN charter, categorically rule out any Canadian military participation and call for an immediate ceasefire and a return to multilateral diplomacy.\n\nI would like to address the key arguments raised by the Liberals and the Conservatives throughout this debate. The first is that Iran's regime is oppressive and dangerous. New Democrats are under no illusions about the Iranian regime or its brutal repression, nor do we dismiss concerns about nuclear proliferation, but an illegal war is not the answer. It can never be if we desire a world of order, security and justice. The real remedy is harder: diplomacy, engagement, arms control and rigorous inspections, which are tools that were working when this war was launched. \n\nFurthermore, we know from painful experience what follows U.S. regime change wars. Similar attacks on Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and Syria did not yield stability or democracy. On the contrary, these societies are now lawless and fragmented, economic basket cases run by the people we once labelled terrorists, with prolonged conflict, civilian suffering, mass displacement and regional chaos. Most fundamentally, the events unfolding in Iran today will not bring freedom to its people. They will bring catastrophe.\n\nSecond, we heard the argument that with tariffs already weaponized against our economy, Canada cannot risk further retaliation from Donald Trump. We must be honest about what that position demands, placing a price on Canada's independence, reputation and humanity. I remind the House that Canada's ability to chart our own foreign policy was not gifted to us. It was earned through immense national sacrifice, and it cannot be sacrificed on the altar of expediency or by bending to a bully.\n\nHowever, I think the best answer is to quote the Prime Minister again just weeks ago in Davos. He invoked Václav Havel's image of the greengrocer who placed a sign in his window to avoid trouble and signal compliance, and the Prime Minister proudly declared that Canada was \"taking the sign out of the window.\" He said that if we think we can go along to get along, to accommodate, to avoid trouble and to hope compliance will buy safety, it will not.\n\nWhat sign has the Prime Minister put in Canada's window by his recent statements and clear contradictions? It is a sign that says our values are conditional, our words lack integrity and our foreign policy is for sale. That is not the Canada New Democrats envision, and we believe it is not who Canadians want us to be.\n\nOn the gravest questions any government can face, such as whether to commit our country to war, whether to implicate Canadian forces in illegal violence, whether to abandon the principles we proclaim, Canadians deserve clarity, consistency and moral courage. That is what we owe the people we represent. That is what I and my New Democrat colleagues are here to demand tonight.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332181","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, there are moments in global affairs when the decisions of powerful nations echo beyond their borders, when the international order is tested, when rules meant to prevent mass violence are cast aside and when innocent people pay the ultimate price. We are living through such a moment now.\n\n On February 28, the United States and Israel launched coordinated air strikes against Iran. This w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f36fe255c6001e82a1cb994eec841fab140cbd995e7429f1b4f1bb4e4f1dfe76"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6eac1b3807ff4e7f71b18605e16e6d4c8620daa5a792d7e649f8b059e30b3f8b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e6105d0272237776386dcdb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332182,"date":"2026-03-10T03:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, the answer is yes. We do have an obligation to stand by the people of Iran, as we do for all oppressed people of the world. The real question that this debate engages tonight is how to do that. I know my hon. colleague is a lawyer. We cannot justify breaking the law because we think we have a good motive. I imagine Canadian society if we invoked that in our streets. If there was a family we did not like or we disagreed with, we could take it upon ourselves to violently attack them. To use such a ridiculous example shows how absolutely, utterly absurd this is on an international level. \n\nOnce again, I commend to my colleagues the examples in this House. Tell me an example in the Middle East where violence has resulted in freedom for the people, democracy in their government and better welfare for their society. Show me where. It did not happen in Libya, it did not happen in Iraq, it did not happen in Syria and it did not happen in Afghanistan. One cannot impose democracy from the outside by force. We need to stand with the Iranian people in a peaceful way and support them with diplomacy, with economic sanctions, with help and with nuclear proliferation processes that actually work. We are working.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332182","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, the answer is yes. We do have an obligation to stand by the people of Iran, as we do for all oppressed people of the world. The real question that this debate engages tonight is how to do that. I know my hon. colleague is a lawyer. We cannot justify breaking the law because we think we have a good motive. I imagine Canadian society if we invoked that in our streets. If there was a famil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3b12502514207e5d9357922aec6c7a4cfdc44bbbfe06993e7ae5f7039e25bff9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["08ebbb36a08fe5257d0823bcbbe4b67a2459e99101345c3f5bf3741d462203e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10f9a4eadb777281a902bc65","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332180,"date":"2026-03-10T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats' hearts also go out to all of the community in Tumbler Ridge.\n\nThe Prime Minister told the world in Davos that Canada will be \"[p]rincipled in our commitment to...the prohibition of the use of force except when consistent with the UN Charter\". The attack on Iran by the U.S. and Israel clearly violates the UN Charter, as the Prime Minister himself has admitted, yet he supports it.\n\nWill the Prime Minister explain to Canadians why he betrayed his commitment and now supports a war he knows is illegal?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332180","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats' hearts also go out to all of the community in Tumbler Ridge.\n\nThe Prime Minister told the world in Davos that Canada will be \"[p]rincipled in our commitment to...the prohibition of the use of force except when consistent with the UN Charter\". The attack on Iran by the U.S. and Israel clearly violates the UN Charter, as the Prime Minister himself has admitted, yet he sup","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["04ad47e43d1f9a7f443dc9d7f58c9fa80065d0b267a2f2e11ad2a9e15dba48d6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3c837fae094b44f4c9c269b74f4b346ba50c059d59047d8e200d47bc267acb3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-479ebb314f662a131471f0ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332178,"date":"2026-03-13T16:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise in the House today to honour the remarkable life of Mr. Kuldip Singh Thandi, a constituent who recently passed at the age of 80 after a courageous battle with cancer. \n\nA deeply respected leader, Mr. Thandi served the Khalsa Diwan Society gurdwara with unwavering dedication. He held the positions of president and treasurer, leading always with humility, integrity and commitment. \n\nMr. Thandi was an incredible organizer, a guiding force behind countless community initiatives and a pillar of strength for many families. His selfless service, deep wisdom and rare generosity touched innumerable lives. As he was recently described to me, Mr. Thandi was one in a million and a loyal friend whose kindness and compassion were felt by everyone who met him. His contributions to our community and country will never be forgotten. \n\nWe extend our heartfelt condolences to Mr. Thandi's family and loved ones. May Waheguru bless his soul with eternal peace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332178","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise in the House today to honour the remarkable life of Mr. Kuldip Singh Thandi, a constituent who recently passed at the age of 80 after a courageous battle with cancer. \n\nA deeply respected leader, Mr. Thandi served the Khalsa Diwan Society gurdwara with unwavering dedication. He held the positions of president and treasurer, leading always with humility, integrity and commitment","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72c2d68bd61dbeccffb5f51d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332179,"date":"2026-03-13T17:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in Davos, the Prime Minister declared that Canada will live the truth by acting consistently, applying the same standards to allies as to rivals.\n\nCanada has rightly condemned Russia's invasion of Ukraine as illegal, yet the Prime Minister is supporting the United States and Israel as they wage an equally illegal war on Iran. This double standard undermines Canada's credibility and erodes the rules-based order we depend on for our security.\n\n Why is the Prime Minister walking away from the principles he championed just weeks ago?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332179","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in Davos, the Prime Minister declared that Canada will live the truth by acting consistently, applying the same standards to allies as to rivals.\n\nCanada has rightly condemned Russia's invasion of Ukraine as illegal, yet the Prime Minister is supporting the United States and Israel as they wage an equally illegal war on Iran. This double standard undermines Canada's credibility and er","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8bf8bb478fe784c64cce012","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":376966,"date":"2026-03-25T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Donald Trump's attack on Iran is not only illegal and causing death and destruction but spreading economic chaos around the globe. Canadians are now seeing sky-high gas prices, and the cost of products from fertilizers to food are going to soar, bringing pain to every household. Economists predict that the world will face massive turmoil for years to come.\n\nWhat does the Prime Minister say to Canadians who are suffering serious financial harm as a result of the senseless war that he and the Conservatives supported?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:376966","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Donald Trump's attack on Iran is not only illegal and causing death and destruction but spreading economic chaos around the globe. Canadians are now seeing sky-high gas prices, and the cost of products from fertilizers to food are going to soar, bringing pain to every household. Economists predict that the world will face massive turmoil for years to come.\n\nWhat does the Prime Ministe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb658cf736c8883a3e51d66a61ec8723d7d9d2e8977255c1a43e811a6d2ff234"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-496fb096703941b0ac760456","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419764,"date":"2026-04-13T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to mark the beginning of an exciting new chapter for Canada's New Democrats and our nation. I would like to thank the Prime Minister, the leaders of all parties and every member of the House for their collegiality during my term as interim leader, an experience that reaffirmed for me the profound privilege of serving Canadians in the heart of our democracy.\n\n Recently in Winnipeg, thousands of New Democrats came together with purpose and unity to choose our new leader, Avi Lewis. Avi understands that this moment demands bold action. He knows Canadians are facing rising unemployment, soaring grocery bills and crushing housing costs. He will fight for good jobs with fair wages and give young people real hope for the future.\n\n The truth is that Canada's NDP is needed now more than ever. Under Avi Lewis's leadership, we will deliver the progressive vision our country needs and will fight for the progressive, positive change Canadians deserve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419764","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to mark the beginning of an exciting new chapter for Canada's New Democrats and our nation. I would like to thank the Prime Minister, the leaders of all parties and every member of the House for their collegiality during my term as interim leader, an experience that reaffirmed for me the profound privilege of serving Canadians in the heart of our democracy.\n\n Recently in ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-16f05792cd655dba4c115bc3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419762,"date":"2026-04-15T20:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, grocery giants are ripping off Canadians again. First, they colluded to fix bread prices. Now they are committing fraud through deceptive weight labels on meat. They are literally putting their fingers on the scales to overcharge shoppers. Instead of enforcing the law, the Liberals cut Canadian food inspectors, the only way to protect consumers. \n\nThe Prime Minister said he wanted to be judged on the cost of groceries. Will he take action to stop the food monopoly from cheating Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419762","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, grocery giants are ripping off Canadians again. First, they colluded to fix bread prices. Now they are committing fraud through deceptive weight labels on meat. They are literally putting their fingers on the scales to overcharge shoppers. Instead of enforcing the law, the Liberals cut Canadian food inspectors, the only way to protect consumers. \n\nThe Prime Minister said he wanted to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","label":"Meat"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","label":"Meat","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4ba41e78689bda6b03c82b633eacdcf18a8d22a3115066f3bde6cd8ed3cafd9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e97fdbff7de2fe3db73d4f9f38263e9b53612caa06b3440082f20ae57548ff66"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3aea49126d226d3a9e90c142","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419763,"date":"2026-04-15T20:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there have been discussions among the parties, and if you seek it I hope you will find unanimous consent for the following motion: That, in the opinion of the House, the government should ban surveillance pricing, where personal data is used by corporations to increase the prices consumers pay, both in store and on line.\n\nSome hon. members: No.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419763","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there have been discussions among the parties, and if you seek it I hope you will find unanimous consent for the following motion: That, in the opinion of the House, the government should ban surveillance pricing, where personal data is used by corporations to increase the prices consumers pay, both in store and on line.\n\nSome hon. members: No.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f201eac0986af8bf2a907735e4bdcd5be8a88ceec4b567cf5c97de52f6efd6ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["680018688fd0ebcfe3db1d4ac19e74943eadfa23de397c80aaf90ac083ff20fd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64399462eb601c675c6e04c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299932,"date":"2026-04-21T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are being crushed by the cost of living, and now gas prices are skyrocketing, but not everyone is suffering. Oil companies will rake in an extra $90 billion this year from Donald Trump's illegal war on Iran.\n\nWhat is the Liberal response? It is a tax cut that oil companies will simply pocket by raising prices.\n\nInstead of handing more money to oil giants, why does the government not cap gas prices, tax windfall profits and use those funds to give people real relief?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299932","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are being crushed by the cost of living, and now gas prices are skyrocketing, but not everyone is suffering. Oil companies will rake in an extra $90 billion this year from Donald Trump's illegal war on Iran.\n\nWhat is the Liberal response? It is a tax cut that oil companies will simply pocket by raising prices.\n\nInstead of handing more money to oil giants, why does the govern","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3ca8469a19744fca487b5a0ddd18c20b2e2581d03a9ecfc6cdfb85293b43a18"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ffc3e37d20c47f5957f8c418f8018ae4df143ff83cd6320197e9e9c0ab75453e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f1f8f3b3e97eed21e95758a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299931,"date":"2026-04-23T20:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in the last election, the Prime Minister promised to protect pharmacare and sign agreements with all provinces and territories as quickly as possible. Despite those clear commitments, his government has failed to sign a single agreement. This week, P.E.I.'s health minister revealed the Liberals' plan to scrap pharmacare entirely when current deals expire.\n\nWill the government provide funding in the spring economic update to protect pharmacare and expand it to all Canadians as they promised, or are Liberals breaking their commitment to public pharmacare?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299931","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in the last election, the Prime Minister promised to protect pharmacare and sign agreements with all provinces and territories as quickly as possible. Despite those clear commitments, his government has failed to sign a single agreement. This week, P.E.I.'s health minister revealed the Liberals' plan to scrap pharmacare entirely when current deals expire.\n\nWill the government provide ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b864c6ee1ec89c703c15deeea1da73383413813bb10a9fa998e12319d471d543"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["80d27ca6800aa8a4032f24126c3ffbc299eb9f99bf81ef7f23f373eab161b1d7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d702f4e371738f6c849fd9e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723301,"date":"2026-04-28T22:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to respond to the 2026 spring economic update on behalf of Canada's New Democrats and our new leader, Avi Lewis.\n\nAt the outset, I want to acknowledge that this update includes some positive measures that New Democrats agree with and some, indeed, that we have long advocated for, including supporting apprenticeships in the skilled trades, delivering the Canada groceries and essentials benefit, standing up the financial crimes agency to better go after white-collar criminals and funding youth athletic programs. \n\nNew Democrats will always work constructively with other parties and support measures that bring real benefits to working people in this country. However, taken as a whole, this update represents a missed opportunity to meet the moment, just as the budget in the fall did. In fact, there is almost nothing new in this update that has not already been announced. \n\nIn classic neo-liberal fashion, it naively assumes the private sector can be relied upon to solve all the challenges we face. It doubles down on trickle-down economics by using taxpayer dollars to fund corporate welfare, an approach that has consistently failed to deliver benefits to working people wherever and whenever it has been applied. It falls far short of responding to the reality that Canadians are living through, the everyday emergency of just trying to get by in a rigged economy. \n\nI want to underscore this: Across this country, people are being stretched to the breaking point. Young Canadians are being locked out of opportunity, unable to find stable work in the communities where they live. Half of Canadians are living paycheque to paycheque, one missed payment away from crisis. The cost of essentials, from groceries to rent, continues to soar and is pushing families deeper into anxiety and uncertainty. \n\nAt the same time, our public services are under persistent and growing strain, and our economy remains fundamentally tilted in favour of those at the very top. Beyond our borders, the world grows more unstable by the day. Donald Trump's trade war is a direct attack on Canadian workers and our industries. His illegal war on Iran has destabilized the global economy. Critically, the Prime Minister and the Liberal government chose to support that war despite its foreseeable economic consequences for Canadians. \n\nNew Democrats recognize these are not small challenges. They demand bold, decisive action. They demand a government willing to stand up for people instead of deferring to the powerful, yet what we have before us is an economic update that tinkers at the margins when what Canadians need is transformative change. \n\nModest relief is not enough when people are facing an affordability emergency, and make no mistake, this is an emergency. At kitchen tables across this country, Canadians are doing everything right. They are working hard. Some are juggling multiple jobs. Others are caring for children or aging parents. Many are sacrificing just to keep up. Despite all that effort, they continue to fall behind. Why is this? It is not because Canadians are not working hard enough. It is because the system is not working for them. \n\nTo understand why so many Canadians feel like they are falling behind, we have to confront a deeper truth. This is not just an affordability crisis; it is also an inequality crisis. In Canada today, the richest one per cent hold as much wealth as the bottom 80% combined. That is the worst degree of inequality in generations in this country. Even more striking is that Canada's richest 86 families hold as much wealth as the poorest 6.2 million Canadians. While wealth at the top explodes, everyone else is being squeezed. That is why working harder is no longer enough. That is why people feel that the system is rigged; in many ways, it is.\n\n Corporate profits are soaring. Billionaire wealth is growing by the tens of billions. There are almost double the number of billionaires in Canada today than there were 20 years ago, but wages are not keeping up, costs are rising and public services are being cut. This level of extreme inequality undermines social cohesion, weakens democracy and makes it harder to solve every other challenge we face, from housing to health care and climate change, as public priorities are displaced by private interests.\n\n However, in this economic update by the Liberal government, there is really no serious plan to address these issues. There is no effort to rebalance the system, and no willingness to ask those who have benefited the most to contribute more. It is no surprise that, for the economic projections the government relied on for this economic update, it consulted a group of some 12 economists, and every single one of them works for a bank or the corporate sector. Not a single labour economist was consulted on the path ahead for the government. \n\nWorking Canadians are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for an economy where hard work is rewarded, where opportunity is real and where prosperity is shared. Until we confront the growing concentration of wealth and power in this country, we will not solve the affordability crisis, because at its core, that crisis is not just about high prices. It is about who our economy is built for and who it is leaving behind.\n\n Let us talk about one of the clearest examples of that imbalance, one that came up just last week, which is predatory pricing. Canadians know that prices are too high. We just have to walk down a grocery aisle to know that. They see it every time they go to the grocery store, pay rent or fill up their gas tank. What they may not know is that companies are increasingly using invasive data practices, such as tracking personal information to charge different prices to different people, often exploiting the most vulnerable, those who do not have the mobility to actually chase lower prices. This is called \"surveillance pricing\". It means two Canadians can pay different prices for the exact same product simply because an algorithm decides that one of them can be charged more, and they can get away with it. That is not fair or transparent, and it should not be legal.\n\nThe New Democratic Party called on the government last week to ban surveillance pricing and to protect consumers from this kind of digital price gouging. However, in this economic update, there is nothing. There is no action, no protection. There is not even any acknowledgement of the problem. There is just full-throated support and cheerleading for more AI. Canadians deserve a marketplace that is fair, that is competitive and that is not one that exploits them in increasingly sophisticated ways. \n\nLet us turn to energy. Canadians are being crushed by the cost of living, and now gas prices are skyrocketing, but not everyone is suffering. Oil and gas companies are set to rake in an extra $90 billion in profits this year alone from Donald Trump's illegal war on Iran, which is an illegal war that the government supported. What was the government's response? It was a tax cut, which oil companies can simply pocket, and no doubt will pocket to some degree, by raising prices. \n\nThat is not relief. That is a gift to the oil and gas sector. It is also a band-aid, because that reduction in the excise tax will last only until Labour Day. We will come back to this point in September and find out if gas prices are lower in September, because every reputable economist that I have looked at tells us that we are looking at persistent high oil prices for the foreseeable future beyond Labour Day. Instead of more corporate welfare, we should put a windfall tax on oil and gas giants and invest that money in projects that benefit working Canadians.\n\n Through this update, the Liberal government announced plans to launch a sovereign wealth fund and the Canada Strong fund, and it cited Norway as an example. New Democrats have been calling for this approach for many years. Norway has a public oil company and invests the revenues in its sovereign wealth fund, which is now worth over $2 trillion. Norway put that money to work for the public benefit, including building a renewable economy and investing in high-quality public services.\n\nHowever, what this update is proposing is the mirror image of what Norway has done. Norway built a public oil company, something the Conservatives dismantled under Brian Mulroney, and it took a fair share of the oil profits for the public. However, instead of using private profits for the public benefit like Norway did, the Liberals are proposing to use public money for the private profit of wealthy investors. The public takes on the risks, but the private sector reaps the rewards.\n\nNew Democrats favour the concept of a sovereign wealth fund. We believe we have an opportunity to fund it properly for public benefit like the Norwegians did. It should start with an excess profits tax on the oil and gas sector. Now is a great time to do it, as Canadian oil companies stand to reap some $100 billion in excess profits this year alone. If we cannot start now, when can we start? However, there is nothing in this update to ask the most profitable corporations to contribute their fair share towards Canada's economic transformation.\n\nI would like to turn now to housing, because no discussion of affordability is complete without addressing the housing crisis. This is one of the clearest and most painful expressions of inequality that exist across our economy. Secure, decent, affordable housing is a foundational need for every Canadian. It anchors us in community, making participation in society and access to work, friends and family possible.\n\nHowever, young people are giving up on ever owning a home. Renters are facing relentless increases in housing and security. Seniors are struggling to remain in their community. Students are being priced out of the community they grew up in, are being forced into unsafe conditions or are having to live with roommates well into their thirties. This is a national crisis, and it demands a response on the scale of a crisis.\n\n In the last election, the Liberals made a clear promise. They said they would double Canada's rate of residential construction to reach 500,000 homes per year over the next decade, but a recent report from the Parliamentary Budget Officer found that the government has not even laid out a plan to achieve that goal. Maybe that was why the government was so quick to remove him.\n\nAccording to the same report, the government's flagship initiative, Build Canada Homes, will produce only about 26,000 homes by 2030. That is nowhere near what is required. That is not a legitimate response to a housing crisis. At the very moment when Canadians need a surge in housing construction, federal housing spending is projected to fall over the coming years. That is the opposite, I would suggest, of what this moment needs.\n\nFor decades, successive governments, Liberal and Conservative alike, have stepped back from building non-market housing, the only way we are going to deliver truly affordable housing. The result is clear. Canada now lags far behind peer countries in the supply of housing that is built for people, not for profit. New Democrats know that the market alone cannot fix this crisis. I think the Liberals and Conservatives refuse to acknowledge that.\n\n New Democrats say that we need sustained federal leadership and long-term investment to dramatically scale up non-market housing: co-ops, student housing, seniors' housing, supportive housing for people living with disabilities and housing for low-income Canadians. Housing is not just a commodity to be addressed by the market. It is a human right and a foundational need.\n\nHousing is the foundation of stable lives, strong communities, a fair economy and a healthy country. Investing in housing is also smart economic policy. It creates good jobs, supports local industries and builds the infrastructure our communities need in order to grow. Once again, this economic update fails to rise to that challenge.\n\n Health care is another area where the government is failing to meet the moment. Canadians are deeply proud of our public health care system. In fact, as we face threats from south of the border, from Mr. Trump, public health care is one of those strong national Canadian institutions that has helped bind us together and create Canadian pride in the face of that threat to our sovereignty. However, our health care system, as we all know, is under strain. It has been facing staff shortages, long wait times and growing privatization. Now instead of strengthening it, the Liberal government is stepping back.\n\n During the last election, the Prime Minister and, I would bet, every single person elected on the Liberal side of the House promised Canadians that they would protect and expand pharmacare. The Prime Minister committed to signing agreements for free contraception and diabetes medications with all outstanding provinces and territories, in his words, \"quickly and equitably\". Liberals insisted on calling it \"national pharmacare\" when New Democrats, of course, meant public pharmacare.\n\nAfter being in power a year, the Liberals have not signed one agreement with a single province or territory, leaving only B.C., Manitoba, P.E.I. and the Yukon territory with deals in place. That is not national. In fact, Newfoundland and Labrador's health minister just revealed that the federal government has now closed the door on negotiating a pharmacare program with their province. We hear the same thing from the Government of Nova Scotia. Even more troubling, we have also recently learned from P.E.I.'s health minister that the Liberal government will allow existing agreements to expire in 2029, dismantling pharmacare before it is even fully realized.\n\n This economic update does not even include pharmacare in its list of affordability measures alongside dental care and other programs like child care. This economic update claims that the government is protecting essential social programs, but that simply is not true. The Liberals committed to national pharmacare, which the NDP forced to be delivered publicly. Betraying that pledge is politically immoral. It is a democratic offence, and the Liberals ought to be ashamed of themselves.\n\n Speaking of what is politically immoral, this update provides no increase whatsoever to the Canadian dental care plan. As we all know, costs go up every year, and the CDCP is no different. Any government truly committed to the long-term viability of dental care would ensure that both the income threshold to qualify and the fee guide to properly compensate oral health professionals went up by at least the rate of inflation. The fact that the Liberals have ignored that completely, not adding a penny to the fee guide or to the income threshold, speaks volumes to their lack of commitment to this important public health initiative spearheaded by the NDP. \n\nWe all hear Liberals stand up in this place and in public claiming to take credit for dental care, when we all know the NDP forced them to bring it in. As Joe Biden said, \"don't tell me what you value, show me your budget, and I will tell you what you value.\" Nothing speaks louder about this Liberal government's lack of commitment to dental care than the fact that they are allowing it to wither on the line, not properly funding it, as soon as the New Democrats are not there to make them do it.\n\n If I might, there is also an issue of accuracy in budgeting and budget integrity raised by this update. This government is projecting a deficit difference of $11 billion from projections it made just five months ago. Despite a 2026 that is shaping up to be just as volatile, just as uncertain, just as affected by tariffs and Trump and increasingly affected by global disorder as 2025, this update claims Canada will face four smooth quarters of 2% growth. To compare that to last year, we experienced two quarters of growth and two of recession.\n\nIf I did not know any better, I would say that the government is pulling the old Paul Martin trick: overestimate, pad numbers and claim victory when they come in better. In fact, that would be amusing, if the real pain of an economy that is not serving working people was not so devastating. \n\nThis brings me to the broader question of nation building. At key moments in our history, Canada has chosen to build, to invest in public services and infrastructure that connects us, strengthens us and prepares us for the future. New Democrats say that today should be one of those moments. We face economic uncertainty, yes. We face external threats, yes. We face internal inequality and declining affordability. That is precisely when governments must step up, yet there is not nearly enough in this update for indigenous people, for real action on the climate crisis, to support our public servants, who deliver critical services for Canadians, or to invest in peace building and peacekeeping. Instead, the Liberal government has chosen to put its blind faith in the market to solve our current challenges.\n\nNew Democrats see a different path. We understand that our country faces deep structural problems that cannot be solved through the profit motive and the private sector alone. Ensuring that everyone has a roof over their head, a world-class education and high-quality health care can only be done by the government using collective power and exercising public enterprise. We need investments in non-market housing, clean energy, transportation and public services that create jobs and build resilience. We need to strengthen the east-west connections and reduce our dependence on an increasingly unreliable U.S. We need a vision for Canada that is bold, inclusive and forward-looking.\n\nThat is not what the economic update delivers. The pattern is clear. On affordability, the government falls short. On inequality, the government falls short. On housing, the government falls short. On jobs and public services, the government falls short. On health care, the government falls short. On the broader vision that Canadians need, it falls short.\n\nCanadians deserve better than slogans and self-congratulations. We heard the Conservatives practise nursery rhyme politics. Now we are hearing endless sloganeering from the finance minister. Slogans do not put food on the table, and slogans are not a substitute for strong public programs.\n\nCanadians deserve a government that understands the scale of the challenges they face and responds with the urgency those challenges demand. Canadians deserve fairness. They deserve security. They deserve hope.\n\nThe New Democratic Party put forward clear priorities for this economic update: ban surveillance pricing; implement a windfall profits tax on oil and gas giants; enforce the Canada Health Act against privatization; strengthen public health care, including pharmacare and dental care; and take real action on affordability. These are practical measures that would make a real difference in people's lives.\n\nThe government chose not to act in those ways. Instead, it has delivered an update that is out of step with the reality most Canadians are living. That is the central issue. While we debate in this chamber, Canadians are making impossible choices. They are skipping meals. They are delaying care. They are taking on debt just to survive.\n\n Canadians are not asking for miracles. They are asking for fairness. They are asking for leadership. They are asking for a government that is on their side.\n\nThis moment calls for courage. It calls for a willingness to challenge the status quo and to build an economy that finally works for everyone. This economic update, unfortunately, does not meet this moment. However, it is not too late to choose a different path, a path that puts people first, a path that builds a fairer, stronger and more resilient Canada. That is the path New Democrats will continue to fight for. It is the path we will work on collaboratively with the government, should it choose to pursue it, because Canadians deserve nothing less.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723301","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to respond to the 2026 spring economic update on behalf of Canada's New Democrats and our new leader, Avi Lewis.\n\nAt the outset, I want to acknowledge that this update includes some positive measures that New Democrats agree with and some, indeed, that we have long advocated for, including supporting apprenticeships in the skilled trades, delivering the Canada groceries a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e508a8d7282644f2bed1e8e5df43eaf7bee66341904aa84d7861a272ea3b2e12"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["643d0043a30984437cb8e94b1ce31de9d725db90420abcd4068e0042b050d098"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-216ba35801bddc0a79b6d814","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723302,"date":"2026-04-28T23:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague talks about what the NDP did last Parliament. I think we stand in this place, and in our communities, with great pride. With the caucus of 2025, we brought in dental care to nine million Canadians. In the House, the NDP brought pharmacare to over 10 million Canadians and established the first public delivery of diabetes and contraceptive medications. There are people today in this country who are walking into pharmacies and walking out with their diabetes meds, using only their health care card, because of what the NDP did in the House. The NDP also brought an anti-scab law to this place, finally protecting workers who risk violence on the picket line. \n\nI cannot point to a single accomplishment of the Conservatives. With their vaunted official opposition last Parliament, they cannot point to a single thing, not one, that they delivered for Canadians.\n\nWhat I will say concerning the support of the Liberals is that it was not the NDP that voted for the government's throne speech. That was the Conservatives. It was not the NDP that voted for Bill C-2 and Bill C-5 and helped the government pass major economic programs in the House. It was the Conservatives who voted with the Liberals. There is only one coalition that I see in the House, which is the far-right Conservative Party sitting to my right and the progressive conservative party I see across the aisle.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723302","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague talks about what the NDP did last Parliament. I think we stand in this place, and in our communities, with great pride. With the caucus of 2025, we brought in dental care to nine million Canadians. In the House, the NDP brought pharmacare to over 10 million Canadians and established the first public delivery of diabetes and contraceptive medications. There are people","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","label":"Oral health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","label":"Oral health","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b0571c308f1acde34b65c2f67f02f9627414bd5823be017808966b53216dea37"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["48cfb9cec14cab3879b0a7d2f8f7860e6bc3f143b6e7b763215e87dcd5e4ddb6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fa3b87d435dfcac0005ba6c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723307,"date":"2026-04-28T23:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this gives me an opportunity to thank my hon. colleague from Edmonton Strathcona, who has been such a powerful voice for equity and for defending things such as public health care, which is under great threat from the Conservatives in Alberta. We can actually see what would happen if the federal Conservatives were to ever get power in this place. We can see what they would do by looking to places like Alberta, where there is a constant attack on the public delivery of health care and a constant push for privatization, and we know where that ends. That means that people with means and wealthy people will always get the health care they want and the rest of people, those who cannot afford it, will suffer. This is what Conservative approaches to health care mean.\n\nHowever, what is more disturbing to me is the way the Liberal government, which is governing as a conservative party, has adopted, with slightly nicer language and perhaps less severe vocabulary, the same policies. Let us take pharmacare as an example. The government negotiated with us and signed a bill into law called the Pharmacare Act, which obligates the government to negotiate pharmacare agreements with every single province and territory in our Confederation.\n\nAgain, I will repeat that the Liberals insisted that we call it national pharmacare, but they have stalled at regional pharmacare. They refuse to sign anymore pharmacare agreements with any provinces and territories. All they had to do was put a few billion dollars into this budget, and they could have signed agreements with every remaining province and territory. They chose not to. They have put tens and tens of billions of dollars into military spending, so if they want to find the money, they can.\n\nPolitics is about choices. The Liberals had a choice to make. They could have honoured their word, honoured the Canada Pharmacare Act, honoured their 30-year commitment to public pharmacare and put some money in to make pharmacare a reality across this country, but they chose not to. That is why New Democrats are needed in this place. We are the only party that consistently stands up to protect, defend, sustain and expand public pharmacare, which we will do in the House until every Canadian can get the health care they need from head to toe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723307","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this gives me an opportunity to thank my hon. colleague from Edmonton Strathcona, who has been such a powerful voice for equity and for defending things such as public health care, which is under great threat from the Conservatives in Alberta. We can actually see what would happen if the federal Conservatives were to ever get power in this place. We can see what they would do by looki","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["abfe47b6bbd7549b1408b1881e7aa55267ad7b09f9e54a848d9879643e29e7a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fe449fb6e6cfde84aae77348e2acaab5b9e6e37691ce48c41870a7d416f131b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08b305f93eb8e20611f8c95c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723311,"date":"2026-04-28T23:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this gives me a chance to correct the record and to agree with my hon. colleague, the leader of the Green Party. Yes, the Green Party is a staunch advocate for public pharmacare. I want to thank her and her party for that principled position.\n\nPharmacare is not just a moral imperative. We New Democrats believe that every Canadian should be able to get the medicine they need when they need it, regardless of the size of their bank account. This is simply an extension of the fundamental principle of our medicare system, and it is also economically smart. Study after study, seven of them in a row, has found that if we bring in universal public pharmacare in this country, we will save anywhere from $4 billion to $14 billion a year and cover every single Canadian.\n\nIt is not just me saying that. It is what the House of Commons Standing Committee on Health found. It is what the Senate committee has found. It is what the committee that was struck by the government and Dr. Eric Hoskins found. Dr. Hoskins is the former Liberal health minister of Ontario. The committee found that by making sure every Canadian has their medication, we would keep Canadians healthier and save money. It has been estimated that it would save $500 to $600 per person per year. If someone has a catastrophic illness, it would be far more than that.\n\nApparently only the New Democrat and Green members of the House are people who would take the wealth of this country and build our Canadian health care system, expanding it so Canadians would get coverage not only for hospital and physician care but also for mental health care, eye care, ear care, pharmacare and dental care. We are going to keep fighting for that.\n\nHowever, the Liberals have done us a favour, through their fall budget and the spring economic update, by showing Canadians what they really believe in. When the Liberals do not have a minority government and other parliamentarians forcing them to do progressive things, they show us who they really are, and the government is showing us what it is. It is a right-wing, conservative government that does not believe in things like public health care.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723311","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this gives me a chance to correct the record and to agree with my hon. colleague, the leader of the Green Party. Yes, the Green Party is a staunch advocate for public pharmacare. I want to thank her and her party for that principled position.\n\nPharmacare is not just a moral imperative. We New Democrats believe that every Canadian should be able to get the medicine they need when they ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91e813f0c1a93a51635256f39bec786d2bfef1a4753bcd4a5678f7b7c8cdadd9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c567aed9a33a14656c25de6fe36f2f8da642f67c86bfc524bcfda01c42c16ff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dafacaacc68b3f8f9d02582f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752393,"date":"2026-05-05T20:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote, with New Democrats voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752393","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote, with New Democrats voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0496a87f3ad326f469397031986fb18efdac4dc4117b29f71b09ddeedf8c1535"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f28a455e70bda9c4b0e85651","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752394,"date":"2026-05-05T20:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote, with New Democrats voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752394","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote, with New Democrats voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0496a87f3ad326f469397031986fb18efdac4dc4117b29f71b09ddeedf8c1535"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a837a2739f737471dc83441e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752395,"date":"2026-05-05T20:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote, with New Democrats voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752395","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote, with New Democrats voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0496a87f3ad326f469397031986fb18efdac4dc4117b29f71b09ddeedf8c1535"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6344cfc3fe86d728346adeed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752396,"date":"2026-05-05T20:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the New Democrats agree to apply the vote from the previous vote, with New Democrats voting yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752396","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the New Democrats agree to apply the vote from the previous vote, with New Democrats voting yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9bd54cd0b07bab1134405bd18e614860a152e4a5962e5315d3335fbdd5a2da9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-148179dcd3d95f4f3d0dd35c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752397,"date":"2026-05-05T20:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote from the previous vote, with New Democrats voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752397","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote from the previous vote, with New Democrats voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61d512702ef4022411aa98ae8c0d2447fea5f399adc9447af5328a7990bbd767"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d12c06edcfe5293772bf7501","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752398,"date":"2026-05-05T20:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote, with New Democrats voting yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752398","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote, with New Democrats voting yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bbe2de41ea2abb3cf7612504ca11e157bb2403b081f0b96280716a5ac0308f65"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d6ee0385bf37542411bbb00","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752399,"date":"2026-05-05T20:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote, with New Democrats voting yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752399","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote, with New Democrats voting yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bbe2de41ea2abb3cf7612504ca11e157bb2403b081f0b96280716a5ac0308f65"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7cbfa6a3e618f78f6c254d68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752392,"date":"2026-05-06T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, legal experts just confirmed what New Democrats have been warning for months: Alberta's private health care law violates the Canada Health Act. Danielle Smith's two-tier scheme lets wealthy patients pay to jump the line, while everyone else waits longer. This breaks a core principle of public health care: access must be based on need, not ability to pay. Upholding this value is the federal government's job, but the Liberals have refused to do it.\n\nWhy is the Prime Minister doing nothing while Conservatives dismantle public health care?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752392","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, legal experts just confirmed what New Democrats have been warning for months: Alberta's private health care law violates the Canada Health Act. Danielle Smith's two-tier scheme lets wealthy patients pay to jump the line, while everyone else waits longer. This breaks a core principle of public health care: access must be based on need, not ability to pay. Upholding this value is the fe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["03b610eb7a5a773f9ea5aa0ed38371b8712d6843d4c3f00a04bbbf46992e96e5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6d3b4de1204f782b4bc502cacf7cd1b9f17bd064efbe10d827038f2e91ebacdd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3698b5c8fb2eb3c21f9542f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752391,"date":"2026-05-07T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals' privatization agenda is disturbing and dangerous. They are planning to sell off Canada's ports and airports, strategic assets that will end up in the hands of foreign buyers, compromising our security.\n\nWhen Heathrow was privatized in the U.K., it resulted in Saudi Arabia, Qatar and China controlling major stakes in that airport. Passengers paid more and services declined.\n\nWill the Prime Minister commit to keeping Canada's ports and airports in public hands, or will he sell our sovereignty to the highest bidder?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privatization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752391","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals' privatization agenda is disturbing and dangerous. They are planning to sell off Canada's ports and airports, strategic assets that will end up in the hands of foreign buyers, compromising our security.\n\nWhen Heathrow was privatized in the U.K., it resulted in Saudi Arabia, Qatar and China controlling major stakes in that airport. Passengers paid more and services decline","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","label":"Privatization"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privatization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","label":"Privatization","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["efd008ed8159293bc8a216d48bda6f9cd033b114fd845dd455f56914e7a55e6e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privatization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b2121575aaab9d42467ba4a356d1376d89811232f7bec4edcc87afe38e2188dc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privatization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1569a6f1cedb3ddbc9e7b1d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021030,"date":"2026-05-26T21:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to follow my hon. colleague from Saanich—Gulf Islands. I will be picking up some of the same themes she articulated so well. \n\nThere are a few things about this motion that I want to agree with and thank my Conservative colleagues for pointing out. First of all, across this country, people are being stretched to the breaking point, and this motion is predicated on that acknowledgement. The cost of essentials, from groceries to rent and energy, continues to soar. Half of Canadians are living paycheque to paycheque. That is a fact I mention often in this place because I think it is profound. I want to emphasize that. Half of Canadians are two paycheques away from economic disaster. One in four parents is cutting back on food or skipping meals to feed their children. This is in a G7 country that my colleagues on the Liberal side of the House call an energy superpower, where 25% of parents cannot get enough food to eat because they are worried about their children.\n\nI also agree very much that Canadians need immediate relief from this affordability crisis. I further agree that after 11 years of Liberal government, at a certain point, we have to ask ourselves who is responsible for the current situation and who is accountable for the policy decisions that have gotten us in this position. They did not just happen. It is not only a cause of external factors, but a result of 11 years of misguided policies and lack of action by the Liberal government on the very basic foundations of affordability, which have caused so many Canadians to be struggling today. \n\nHowever, I do think that the Conservatives are proposing an ineffective measure that amounts to a corporate giveaway, with no guarantee that any savings will actually reach consumers, which also sets back environmental progress even more than is already the case under the current Liberal government. \n\nConservatives want Canadians to believe that this is simply about taxes and regulation, but the evidence tells a different story. Gas prices are not set principally by tax levels or even basic supply and demand. They are shaped by global oil markets, financial speculation and the pricing power of a highly concentrated industry. The gasoline that Canadians buy today was refined weeks ago from oil produced months ago, often at much lower costs, yet prices at the pump can rise quickly in response to global events and market expectations, long before any real change in physical supply or production costs occurs. \n\nCanada produces far more oil than we consume. Three-quarters of our production is exported. Of the modest volumes imported into eastern Canada, almost none comes through the Persian Gulf. In other words, there is no energy supply shock in Canada. The cost of producing and refining gas has not changed at all in this country, yet Canadian consumers are being hammered at the pumps. That is because a significant driver of price movement is speculation in global oil markets. The truth is that traders respond to geopolitical developments and anticipated risks by bidding up prices based on expectations of disruption. These financial signals can move prices at the pump even when nothing at all has been changed in the real supply of fuel. \n\nThis is also why the Conservatives' call to simply get out of the way and further deregulate the sector would not stabilize prices. In fact, it would do the opposite. It would tie Canadians even more directly to volatile global markets, where speculation and shocks are immediately passed through to consumers, rather than strengthening any insulation from them. Tax cuts and deregulation will never solve this problem. If underlying market prices are being driven up by speculation and price gouging, removing taxes does not stop that dynamic. It simply reduces government revenue while leaving the same pricing system in place. Savings will not be passed on to consumers; rather, they will be absorbed into higher corporate profit margins.\n\nWhat I have just said is not just theory. We have already seen this approach fail to lower prices for Canadians in real time recently. The Liberal government temporarily suspended the fuel excise tax on April 20 at a cost of approximately $2.4 billion, claiming it would reduce gas prices by 10¢ per litre. Instead, prices have continued to increase while oil and gas giants continue to post record profits.\n\nWhen the suspension came into effect, the national average gas price was 169.1¢ per litre. Today, the national average price is $1.83 per litre. In Vancouver, where I live, a litre of gas is now routinely over two dollars. The result of the Liberals' removing the excise tax since April 20 is that, so far, prices have gone up. Not a single consumer in Canada has benefited from the Liberal move, and this was predicted by New Democrats at the very time this excise tax reduction was put in place. \n\nThis experience demonstrates a key point. When underlying market prices are driven by speculation and price gouging, tax cuts do not reliably translate into lower prices at the pump. That is one of the key flaws of the Conservative motion here today, which seeks to do that even more so. \n\nInstead, the benefit of the reduction in excise tax can be absorbed into higher margins in an already highly profitable sector. I have no doubt that oil companies have already absorbed at least a portion of that 10¢ excise tax reduction. Certainly, there was nothing in the Liberals' measure to stop them from doing that. As I have said already, the proof is in the pudding. Prices have gone up since the Liberals said their measure would take prices down. \n\nWhile Canadians struggle with affordability, oil and gas giants are positioned to capture massive windfall gains. We are going to see some $90 billion in profits for Canadian oil companies this year. They were slated to make $30 billion in profits this year but are now expecting an additional $60 billion in profits as a result of the U.S.-Israeli war on Iran. Yet, Conservatives want to hand these same corporations another tax break with no mechanism that is guaranteed to ensure that consumers benefit, and the Liberals consistently refuse to bring in a windfall profits tax on the oil and gas companies and use those funds to provide real relief to Canadians who desperately need it.\n\n There is no question that Canadians need relief. The real question is this: How do we make sure that relief reaches working people instead of padding corporate balance sheets? Rather than writing a blank cheque to oil giants, the government should look at measures to cap prices at the pump, crack down on profiteering and ensure that savings are actually passed on to consumers. \n\nOther countries, and Canada itself in past moments of crisis, have recognized this basic principle. When extraordinary windfall profits are generated by crisis-driven price spikes, the public has a right to recoup a fair share of those gains rather than allowing them to be fully privatized. They have a right to expect that their governments will protect them from what is called \"war profiteering\".\n\n We have done this before. During both world wars, the Canadian government used excess profit measures to ensure that wartime windfalls were redirected toward the public good and the national effort, not captured by private interests. More recently, during the COVID pandemic, the Liberal government itself imposed an excise profits tax on major banks, recognizing that extraordinary gains during a national crisis should not simply remain as private profit. New Democrats believe, respectfully, that the same principle applies today in the oil and gas sector.\n\n I will pause for a moment to say that the motion also calls on the government to permanently scrap the clean fuel standard. That standard requires primary fuel suppliers, refiners and importers to progressively reduce the life cycle carbon intensity of the gasoline and diesel they produce and sell. This measure aims to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 30 million tonnes annually by 2030. It encourages fuel providers to innovate, like blending lower-carbon biofuels like ethanol into their products; invest in renewable energy sources; or purchase credits from EV charging providers. This motion would set that back, and New Democrats cannot support that. \n\nFinally, Jack Layton is the person who got the Liberal government to devote one cent of the federal excise gas tax to municipalities, including to provide stable funding for public transit. \n\n New Democrats will continue to work for positive proposals like that, instead of measures that will not help consumers, will hurt the government's ability to innovate and will pad the profits of an oil and gas sector that is already enriching itself at the cost of Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021030","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to follow my hon. colleague from Saanich—Gulf Islands. I will be picking up some of the same themes she articulated so well. \n\nThere are a few things about this motion that I want to agree with and thank my Conservative colleagues for pointing out. First of all, across this country, people are being stretched to the breaking point, and this motion is predicated on that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["514c8a331f23d6dc99f21afc4c2d2966b68eba966ddb99ab7b5c7b4a0919a1ec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ba0d1b45e59a678a3f0faf1dbea3464a13344a6da0890d0a2181ee3510277728"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ddcf1d074ff2333b8671a43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021031,"date":"2026-05-26T22:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am so glad my friend gave me a chance to talk about the fantastic job that Premier Wab Kinew is doing in Manitoba. I was in Manitoba just last week, in the provincial legislature. I was attending the Canadian Labour Congress convention. The types of policies and measures that the Kinew government is bringing in, as a New Democrat government in Manitoba, would be very instructive for this government to follow, if it could. I am very proud of that government.\n\n I noticed my friend did not address the main thrust of my argument, which is that the Liberals brought in a measure on April 20 that they said would lower gas prices for Canadians. They took 10¢ off the price of a litre of gas in this country, telling Canadians that they would pay less at the pump. It was $1.69 a litre on April 20, and it is $1.81 today. It did not work. That is math, and my honourable colleague would do well to focus on the math.\n\nThe New Democrats are calling for measures that will actually help consumers, not hurt them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021031","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am so glad my friend gave me a chance to talk about the fantastic job that Premier Wab Kinew is doing in Manitoba. I was in Manitoba just last week, in the provincial legislature. I was attending the Canadian Labour Congress convention. The types of policies and measures that the Kinew government is bringing in, as a New Democrat government in Manitoba, would be very instructive for","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["636a498c3271e08b055957358ac8d7464848fc038298044879a273db64c6c0ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d4ca063e3dd419db4353286384d4a59d347051bc0622547ae717eb97ec777b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c689280692f11473d8fab397","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021033,"date":"2026-05-26T22:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats said at the time that the Liberal government had proposed this measure without any kind of cap or measure to prevent oil companies from taking a portion of that 10¢ and just hiking their price. The Liberals did nothing. Of course it had a predictable unfortunate result.\n\n New Democrats have been calling for real measures that would actually help Canadians at the pump. Bringing in a cap on prices at the pump in a time of crisis would actually help consumers. Bringing in a windfall profits tax on oil and gas companies, which are making $90 billion this year and are not suffering, and using that money to help Canadians by lowering their cost of living in a variety of ways would help.\n\nWhile I am at it, I will just conclude by saying to my hon. colleague, who talked about previous governments, that he would do well to study the government of C.D. Howe, a Liberal government during World War II that did bring in measures to stop corporations from making obscene profits by profiting off war and to protect consumers. He should take a look and read—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021033","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats said at the time that the Liberal government had proposed this measure without any kind of cap or measure to prevent oil companies from taking a portion of that 10¢ and just hiking their price. The Liberals did nothing. Of course it had a predictable unfortunate result.\n\n New Democrats have been calling for real measures that would actually help Canadians at the pump. Br","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["093f0aeba9f087e4e54a4dc04ebce95b506f48e7a1f9036c76b25891b143bf2b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a05dd51e8196136300d344d78d792bf90d4df0a465d1b5d3e9d19501378099e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e8444a1e7c27a9a0b9dbf71","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021034,"date":"2026-05-26T22:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with my hon. colleague that there will be corporate taxes generated on the additional corporate profits that are made. However, when we are talking about a windfall like this, an extra $60 billion of unanticipated revenue, a case can be made that an excess profits tax is appropriate, especially when that profit was not made because of extra investment by the oil and gas industry but because of geopolitical instability that has caused a spike in world prices. \n\nWhat we do agree on is that we need to give consumers relief in this country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021034","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I agree with my hon. colleague that there will be corporate taxes generated on the additional corporate profits that are made. However, when we are talking about a windfall like this, an extra $60 billion of unanticipated revenue, a case can be made that an excess profits tax is appropriate, especially when that profit was not made because of extra investment by the oil and gas indust","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fedcb994122479f6845982fc783895d641b013febed27c8ae2af7048b8196547"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["409b943a073b2476091c6a02ea2e156cacad14890a18f85d26faa5a16ed313d4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aebfc5bf1aa595372bb4ca68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021035,"date":"2026-05-27T03:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I will be splitting my time with the hon. member for Saanich—Gulf Islands.\n\nFederal civil servants working partly from home are being—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021035","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I will be splitting my time with the hon. member for Saanich—Gulf Islands.\n\nFederal civil servants working partly from home are being—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["355dcc50b8f94c79764fe500bc1b1b1029c2d73bd5cbcce0a0fd731dce2e592b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a40cfd731f029bf736ac3c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021036,"date":"2026-05-27T03:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, federal civil servants working partly from home are being forced to return full-time to an office, even where there is no place to put them. There is no compelling reason to work from an office. It will negatively affect their quality of life and productivity, and it will cost the government more money.\n\nWhy are Liberals pursuing a policy that is so irrational?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021036","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, federal civil servants working partly from home are being forced to return full-time to an office, even where there is no place to put them. There is no compelling reason to work from an office. It will negatively affect their quality of life and productivity, and it will cost the government more money.\n\nWhy are Liberals pursuing a policy that is so irrational?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3e8cbea6748be2d35159c143b5a9a25ec3f3882882bfae4f1f97754650b38582"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["868d0d643944661f314f1bf07a0edd9761d9b014bea8908056f09f4995ff2e56"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f7195f8629debe6d9c4126e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021038,"date":"2026-05-27T03:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, the government claimed that suspending the gas tax would save Canadians 10¢ a litre. When the suspension came into effect, the national average gas price was $1.69 a litre. Today, it is $1.83 a litre, and $2 a litre in Vancouver.\n\nDoes the minister believe that oil companies are pocketing at least some portion of the tax cut?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021038","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, the government claimed that suspending the gas tax would save Canadians 10¢ a litre. When the suspension came into effect, the national average gas price was $1.69 a litre. Today, it is $1.83 a litre, and $2 a litre in Vancouver.\n\nDoes the minister believe that oil companies are pocketing at least some portion of the tax cut?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe932d52939c9624355a36a2d81be22bae381cd8eee261f19e016711a6ee729f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["862ffa22a1afba54ff5553bfa535f6b8a5571dc46713fd3bd1d97664ea01f0ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc5b2523381d43ea6f760c01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021048,"date":"2026-05-27T03:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, oil companies are set to make some $90 billion in profits this year as a result of the attack on Iran.\n\nWhy will the government not tax those excess profits?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021048","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, oil companies are set to make some $90 billion in profits this year as a result of the attack on Iran.\n\nWhy will the government not tax those excess profits?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["571a1923be5268180b26f32578737a5709c7fa83ef943973bbbfbb24502e3b4c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05fb426703aa90c05ab9330e6f5758b89eb92060d6ee89083e6b9281e992103b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d48b281fbcf10e5d6fcb476","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021050,"date":"2026-05-27T03:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, Liberals are planning to sell off Canada's ports and airports. When the U.K. privatized Heathrow, costs skyrocketed and service declined. Today, the governments of Saudi Arabia, Qatar and China control major stakes in that airport.\n\nHas the government conducted a full national security review of the risks posed by foreign and state-linked entities acquiring ownership of Canada's strategic infrastructure?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021050","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, Liberals are planning to sell off Canada's ports and airports. When the U.K. privatized Heathrow, costs skyrocketed and service declined. Today, the governments of Saudi Arabia, Qatar and China control major stakes in that airport.\n\nHas the government conducted a full national security review of the risks posed by foreign and state-linked entities acquiring ownership of Canada's strateg","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b9107fca2e204b55664cb198da7d677d909ec8f5a4c95bfc0eeab2f7ff903f4f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["89f1c4ca8a4e84eadd0360f1b1220de101f8f4794e6fc005476eb6af86f3cfa1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62076783d9efb602c4a76d77","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021057,"date":"2026-05-27T03:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, does the minister expect that service quality will be improved by privatizing Canada's airports?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021057","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, does the minister expect that service quality will be improved by privatizing Canada's airports?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["486555d76089742eb2f3495ef964a2b0f99a5a2e38695f01460c415b361de357"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["978313cc04c55e7a87beb0bc125ac79bf6528e127bc2eeb1c3facff71e3b82dc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f35a7b6c019133bf82aefaa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021083,"date":"2026-05-27T03:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, does the minister expect that introducing a profit element will lead to lower airport fees in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021083","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, does the minister expect that introducing a profit element will lead to lower airport fees in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc392ef513888e2bd6a538273076ec383c6f7668cd5b9f7d7e5fdc116878643f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1240907e8b4f438918477b8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021085,"date":"2026-05-27T03:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, the Prime Minister made a campaign promise to protect pharmacare and sign agreements with all outstanding provinces and territories, yet the government has refused to sign any new agreements or allocate funding to cover all Canadians.\n\nCan the minister explain to the millions of people who cannot afford their medication why this promise has been broken?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021085","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, the Prime Minister made a campaign promise to protect pharmacare and sign agreements with all outstanding provinces and territories, yet the government has refused to sign any new agreements or allocate funding to cover all Canadians.\n\nCan the minister explain to the millions of people who cannot afford their medication why this promise has been broken?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98a2af07063301d042a9b7a124df4881cae13a64af0b7e67ac106a09a8758d48"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6bcb360e89fcaa0652e2f2e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021096,"date":"2026-05-27T03:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, can the minister confirm if the Liberals are planning to eliminate pharmacare entirely when the current agreements expire in 2029?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021096","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, can the minister confirm if the Liberals are planning to eliminate pharmacare entirely when the current agreements expire in 2029?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-518d20724d22b6cda6ed872e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021107,"date":"2026-05-27T03:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, in the last election the Liberals pledged to double Canada's rate of residential construction to 500,000 homes per year over the next decade, but according to the Parliamentary Budget Officer, the government will produce only 26,000 homes by 2030 through its flagship Build Canada Homes. \n\nCan the Minister explain this massive gap between what was promised and what is being delivered with respect to affordable housing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021107","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, in the last election the Liberals pledged to double Canada's rate of residential construction to 500,000 homes per year over the next decade, but according to the Parliamentary Budget Officer, the government will produce only 26,000 homes by 2030 through its flagship Build Canada Homes. \n\nCan the Minister explain this massive gap between what was promised and what is being delivered wit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d8e9b2b743595f22fef39e85c8ac6acd9ed14ffe6534029e8fff5bec424e4546"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["05dead2c9a456117ac308efd1eaed00cb871968245e99d4233ac90504c74c20a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e50529a969cae28311759501","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021115,"date":"2026-05-27T03:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, the government plans to spend 5% of Canada's GDP on defence by 2035. That is a greater share of our economy than the U.S. currently spends on its military. The PBO estimates that meeting this target will require $159 billion a year in core defence spending. \n\nHow does the government intend to pay for this dramatic increase?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021115","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, the government plans to spend 5% of Canada's GDP on defence by 2035. That is a greater share of our economy than the U.S. currently spends on its military. The PBO estimates that meeting this target will require $159 billion a year in core defence spending. \n\nHow does the government intend to pay for this dramatic increase?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5b3e3db261482ba226ad3e6647d8e66a13381ba856f60e350bbe2570d53bf16c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f67534622d410acfdf97a552575162c5ecec2059fa07c1d6a072a40f47f87bac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-121302b2e2aeda37eccd4e8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021126,"date":"2026-05-27T03:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, the government is slashing $60 billion across federal departments and programs. With over $2 billion in cuts to indigenous programs alone, what impact will these reductions have on communities already facing significant infrastructure and service gaps?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021126","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, the government is slashing $60 billion across federal departments and programs. With over $2 billion in cuts to indigenous programs alone, what impact will these reductions have on communities already facing significant infrastructure and service gaps?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c2d44e9ab2080e6d1bc6b7e4001b78bf332ca97043e0e12bfe86b9d6b7818404"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3c79a9fa0c35407778c5ce6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021132,"date":"2026-05-27T03:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, why are the Liberals allowing companies to use surveillance pricing to harvest Canadians' personal data in order to charge them higher prices, instead of banning this new form of price gouging in an affordability crisis?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021132","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, why are the Liberals allowing companies to use surveillance pricing to harvest Canadians' personal data in order to charge them higher prices, instead of banning this new form of price gouging in an affordability crisis?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1031690e9ba42cd109a2d8f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021029,"date":"2026-05-27T23:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, there is not a whole lot I can get in at this point with three minutes, but I will say that I am proud to rise as the labour critic for the NDP and to speak to the bill.\n\n Prior to being elected, I spent 16 years working as the director of legal resources for the Teamsters Local No. 31. In that time period, I did not just walk picket lines, as my hon. colleague, the parliamentary secretary to the government House leader, said, but I negotiated collective agreements, I made applications to the labour board, I defended the right to strike, I prosecuted unfair labour practices and I did essential services designations. There was probably not a section of the Canada Labour Code that I did not deal with in those 16 years. This is not a theoretical exercise to me or to the millions of workers in this country. It affects their lives. \n\nHere is what I know from that experience: One, collective bargaining is the foundation of union rights in this country. Two, the right of a worker to withdraw their services is a charter-protected strike.\n\n I am surprised to see the Liberals so easily violate charter rights, because they themselves claim proudly that they are the party of the charter. As the party of the charter, eight times in the past two years, they have violated the charter rights as described by the Supreme Court of Canada. That is not an NDP position, but the highest court in the land that said that workers have the right to withdraw their services as a core expression of their right to free assembly and association. Eight times this government has ended that right by sending an email.\n\n Now, my hon. colleague, the parliamentary secretary to the government House leader, is saying that NDP governments, in the past, have brought in back-to-work legislation. That is the democratic way to do it, after many days of labour action, and then back-to-work legislation is debated in the House. However, that is not what this government has done. The Liberals ended eight strikes by an email. When did they do it? It was 12 hours after the flight attendants at Air Canada went off the job, and 10 hours after the rail workers at CN and CP rail went off the job. They did not even wait a day for these workers to express their charter rights before they were violated. The only power labour has is the power to withdraw their services. That is it. If we interfere with that right, we interfere with the very foundation of collective bargaining. \n\nCollective bargaining is a success in Canada, and 99% of collective agreements are resolved without a strike or lockout. They are resolved at the bargaining table. I have heard repeatedly from the government, and all members of the House, that the best agreements are agreements reached at the bargaining table. Do members know why they are reached at the bargaining table? It is because unions and employers have a tool—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021029","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, there is not a whole lot I can get in at this point with three minutes, but I will say that I am proud to rise as the labour critic for the NDP and to speak to the bill.\n\n Prior to being elected, I spent 16 years working as the director of legal resources for the Teamsters Local No. 31. In that time period, I did not just walk picket lines, as my hon. colleague, the parliamentary se","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e3e3cbc65b3c23ea6e9164eb2b2c493e8413d3046bdb5e53f0a0ec2c611c0450"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e76f245e36230fc3e31ad2cb18bcf7a46ab00d078dc67dd10da0c803bbe15d31"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28d03a402692af03bf55d079","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1148657,"date":"2026-06-02T10:03:42+00:00","title":"An Act to amend the Parliament of Canada Act","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"An Act to amend the Parliament of Canada Act","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-278","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-278","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1148657","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"An Act to amend the Parliament of Canada Act","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","label":"Warrants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b9139e58c9c344efec5cebc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037332,"date":"2026-06-02T15:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C‐278, An Act to amend the Parliament of Canada Act.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, I rise to introduce legislation to address floor crossing, with thanks to the hon. member for Vancouver East for seconding.\n\nIt is elementary that, in a democracy, elections are the primary opportunity for voters to express their democratic choice. When parliamentarians cross the floor to join a different party from the one they were elected with, they unilaterally alter the will of their electors. The corrosive effects in our democracy are profound: Voters lose trust in elections, the prospect that MPs have been enticed by backroom deals emerges, and the idea that only government members get resources for their constituencies brings pork barrel politics to the table.\n\nRecently, the very balance of power in the House was changed, not by voters at the ballot box but by political operatives in back rooms. While that may not be illegal, it is undeniably undemocratic.\n\nThe bill would not ban floor crossing nor the ability to sit as an independent member. The latter is a valid protection against party oppression and to preserve matters of conscience. The bill would simply require those members who wish to join another party's caucus to seek the approval of their constituents through a by‐election. If an MP who wishes to join another party believes they have valid reasons for doing so, they should have no problem putting that choice to the test of their voters, where it should be.\n\nI urge all members to support this important measure to protect the democratic rights of Canadian voters.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037332","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C‐278, An Act to amend the Parliament of Canada Act.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, I rise to introduce legislation to address floor crossing, with thanks to the hon. member for Vancouver East for seconding.\n\nIt is elementary that, in a democracy, elections are the primary opportunity for voters to express their democratic choice. When parliamentarians cross the floor to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71d26011eff29f524158647cd64896492c7cb37644f065e8ccdf5cb98bc9acd6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9278dce22a419a5ac97a52e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037334,"date":"2026-06-02T15:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have two petitions to present today. The first is from the good people of Vancouver Kingsway.\n\n Over 600 residents signed a petition pointing out that the military strikes on Iran have caused significant civilian casualties and widespread destruction of civilian infrastructure, including hospitals, schools, water systems and heritage sites. They point out that the war threatens irreversible harm to the civilian population, including children, women and political prisoners, and poses grave risks to regional stability.\n\nThe petitioners want the House to know that Iran's future must be determined by Iranians themselves, free from both foreign military intervention and domestic repression. They are calling on the Canadian government to urgently advocate for an immediate ceasefire and an end to all military strikes on Iranian territory, and to use Canada's influence to facilitate a durable regional peace through multilateral engagement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037334","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have two petitions to present today. The first is from the good people of Vancouver Kingsway.\n\n Over 600 residents signed a petition pointing out that the military strikes on Iran have caused significant civilian casualties and widespread destruction of civilian infrastructure, including hospitals, schools, water systems and heritage sites. They point out that the war threatens irre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["808e256fdc9500e30ecb21a1af37dbfad07c9627ede44c03f4a1cff465d02522"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e18a4254e1d82d1c58f4e0201b3ffeb895c4342b3fb42ebb07cf726760e1f84"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62d19e0d34f67d8e754b80fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037335,"date":"2026-06-02T15:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition is signed by over 30,000 Canadians who point out that the Canadian Charter of Rights exists to protect individuals and minority communities from discriminatory laws.\n\n The petitioners are concerned about recent legislation enacted by the Government of Alberta and the Government of Saskatchewan that, in their view, restricts the rights, dignity and safety of transgender and gender-diverse people, particularly children and youth, including access to gender-affirming and medically appropriate health care.\n\n The petitioners note that the provincial governments have invoked the notwithstanding clause to shield that legislation from judicial review, thus preventing charter challenges. The petitioners call on the House to urge the government to exercise its disallowance power under section 90 of the Constitution Act to better protect the rights of transgender and gender‐diverse people in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037335","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition is signed by over 30,000 Canadians who point out that the Canadian Charter of Rights exists to protect individuals and minority communities from discriminatory laws.\n\n The petitioners are concerned about recent legislation enacted by the Government of Alberta and the Government of Saskatchewan that, in their view, restricts the rights, dignity and safety of transge","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","label":"Transgender people"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","label":"Transgender people","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["86798d53ff2b0178ad0223eb23f9a57b0be15eeab9e09cd17eb7457a1d22ca9e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c9becb76a37ed509d328f0c772090620f7b581948c14900727baab4a99bca927"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ea0a95cdef985968af2b788","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037336,"date":"2026-06-02T22:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a genuine privilege to pay tribute to the hon. member for North Vancouver—Capilano on behalf of Canada's New Democrats and to wish him well in his upcoming post as Canada's ambassador to the European Union. I was told I had a minute and a half to say what needed to be said. I find myself with a little bit more time, so I am going to use that time because there is much that can be said about this member.\n\nHe has always brought intelligence, collegiality and dedication to service to this place. As a cabinet minister with several critical portfolios, he has made significant contributions to our nation. His voracious reading, attention to detail and commitment to hard work are now the stuff of legend. He centred much of his efforts on preparing Canada for a sustainable future. We know that through his efforts, we have made profound progress on salmon conservation and plastic pollution. In fact, the largest investment in Canadian history in salmon preservation was done because of his efforts.\n\nThe House, in its wisdom, has already anticipated my next line, which is that I applaud him for his vision and passion in this regard.\n\nAs B.C. members of Parliament, I can say for us that we deeply appreciate the positive impact he has had, in particular, on our province and our coasts. I think the very best that can be said about any elected representative is that they made a difference. Well, the hon. member has certainly done that here in spades. We wish him all the best in his new duties, filling a critical role that will benefit greatly from his skills and talents. I know that he will make a difference in Brussels and do Canada proud.\n\nAs he does so, I urge him to hearken back to his early days as a Saskatchewan Young New Democrat, an excellent pedigree, and in times of doubt or difficulty, never hesitate to ask, what would Tommy Douglas have done?\n\nI thank the member for his service, and we wish him all the best.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037336","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a genuine privilege to pay tribute to the hon. member for North Vancouver—Capilano on behalf of Canada's New Democrats and to wish him well in his upcoming post as Canada's ambassador to the European Union. I was told I had a minute and a half to say what needed to be said. I find myself with a little bit more time, so I am going to use that time because there is much that can b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66f051571965da86c49b74c81b160621dc922d7ad8a56596273c26984d19039f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd76868cf2a43f854df62534f1c143bf17c0b026c40351a58f9132e59bc21ecd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-490db5524a29f78c8ed9ef07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037329,"date":"2026-06-03T20:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote from the previous vote, with New Democrats voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037329","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote from the previous vote, with New Democrats voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61d512702ef4022411aa98ae8c0d2447fea5f399adc9447af5328a7990bbd767"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0aa8c168c6bb1c506fe6fe7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037330,"date":"2026-06-03T20:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote with New Democrat members voting yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037330","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote with New Democrat members voting yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f74b844e8d144dc29534bbeef53795f41c7cff0b3ba8af55c905c26839284fd2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12711033d851799c388a173d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037331,"date":"2026-06-03T20:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote from the previous vote, with New Democrat members voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037331","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree to apply the vote from the previous vote, with New Democrat members voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fff3b874e2ffc5f699666471280c5cb14ce3698b67e80125ff31ecffe4e9d68e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac7a0081d2432d41493668df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037328,"date":"2026-06-04T20:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the government's AI strategy is leaving Canadians dangerously exposed. While this technology can produce benefits, it urgently needs effective regulation and strong guardrails. We know AI is driving mass surveillance, facilitating fraud and threatening jobs. It uses huge amounts of water and energy, and children are being targeted. These are real threats, yet the Liberals sprinted through a shallow consultation and are mouthing the lines of tech billionaires.\n\nWhy is the government rushing a reckless AI strategy without ensuring real protections for Canadians—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037328","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the government's AI strategy is leaving Canadians dangerously exposed. While this technology can produce benefits, it urgently needs effective regulation and strong guardrails. We know AI is driving mass surveillance, facilitating fraud and threatening jobs. It uses huge amounts of water and energy, and children are being targeted. These are real threats, yet the Liberals sprinted thr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33ad10bc97767da36c56cbef7bb1f512f42e8c429c9583d437e4077ed2eccd56"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["143a989b56e6642545429f79ca992df303866ab3ba554565c89682f7faf52ce4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ee141dd9d1f45d9e676fdcb","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1148663,"date":"2026-06-08T16:14:35+00:00","title":"An Act to amend the Canada Labour Code (replacement workers)","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"An Act to amend the Canada Labour Code (replacement workers)","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-284","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-284","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1148663","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"An Act to amend the Canada Labour Code (replacement workers)","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","label":"Labour code"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d32c70c8895930e6087b82ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085077,"date":"2026-06-08T21:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-284, An Act to amend the Canada Labour Code (replacement workers).\n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, I rise today to introduce legislation to close a loophole in the Canada Labour Code that allows employers to use outside managers as replacement workers during strikes and lockouts. I thank the member for Courtenay—Alberni for seconding the bill.\n\nIn the last Parliament, the NDP secured long overdue federal anti-scab legislation to restore fairness to collective bargaining and to protect workers' rights. However, those rights are undermined when employers can bring in managers from other locations to perform the work of striking or locked-out employees, tilting the balance and prolonging disputes. We saw this during a recent Rogers strike in Abbotsford, British Columbia, where United Steelworkers technicians spent more than four months on the picket line while outside managers performed their work as scabs. No worker should have their right to strike undermined in this way.\n\nThe bill would close that loophole and protect free and fair collective bargaining for Canadian workers. I urge all members to support it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085077","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-284, An Act to amend the Canada Labour Code (replacement workers).\n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, I rise today to introduce legislation to close a loophole in the Canada Labour Code that allows employers to use outside managers as replacement workers during strikes and lockouts. I thank the member for Courtenay—Alberni for seconding the bill.\n\nIn the last Parliament, t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28a325cc0fef272371cd677eb739b1375d74c1814d894f7827217f85864fbfea"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc152556ec211d22da0f8a206cf03744bf5b3098092e06ef7c43c68e96c97b03"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a8db56a60667d4bedab6ee3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085078,"date":"2026-06-09T01:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the hon. member from Milton East—Halton Hills South.\n\nI think we all know that fraud in Canada is a growing problem. Stories are now appearing in the media virtually every week. Data from the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre shows that Canadians lost $638 million to fraud in 2024. Reported losses to the CAFC since 2021 have now surpassed $2 billion. The rate of frauds being reported remains low, with an estimated only 5% to 10% being reported, so the problem is understated and in the billions of dollars.\n\nWe know that fraudsters generally target the most vulnerable people among us, such as seniors, new Canadians and young people. Bank fraud in particular is a significant concern in Canada, yet investigations by financial institutions often end with banks' blaming the very customers who trusted them with protecting their money. This raises the issue of the proper responsibility of banks to their depositors and the role of the federal government in regulating or not regulating them properly.\n\n I would like to share with the House some real examples that have been brought to my attention recently by constituents in Vancouver Kingsway. For case number one, I will read from the letter I received: \n\n\"In early September, my dad, a 67 year old retiree called me in a panic. He had just realized he had been scammed out of his entire life savings and more. He was involved in what we believe was a 'pig butchering' scam. He was told he was investing in cryptocurrency—he had a wallet which showed incredibly high returns. When he went to withdrawal, he was hit with yet another fee of $90,000 USD to do so. His 'partner' who was to be paying the fees to share in the investment suddenly said she didn't have anymore money. This is when he realized.\n\n\"...Going through the details of the scam ended up showing that my dad didn't purchase crypto in a typical way. He was directed to the bank to wire money to several different locations. Locally here in Vancouver, then to New York and then finally to Vietnam.\n\n\"My dad opened a new account at BMO in April 2025 and thus the transactions begun. Every 10-14 days my dad went to the same branch on Mainland Street in Yaletown and sent anywhere from $100,000-$300,000 USD to accounts based in Vietnam under the guise of 'purchasing auto parts.' Every single time he wire transferred the money, the same branch manager signed off on it. No questions asked. By the end of August he had drained most of his RRSPs, remortgaged his home, took out personal loans, and borrowed from family and friends. l'm dumbfounded by the fact that the branch manager at this location never noticed the red flags: a brand new customer, a senior retiree, purchasing nearly $2 million dollars in auto parts from a personal bank account.\n\n\"I filed a complaint against BMO.... They refuse to answer if my dad was ever reported to FINTRAC. They replied that he signed off on the wire transfers that stated if he was being coached into cryptocurrency he shouldn't go through with it—none of the wire transfers use that type of language. Further, BMO states that they have a policy in place for prevention of fraud with seniors—obviously this policy wasn't followed in this instance. There has been zero accountability for what happened from BMO. They have said they will not return or refund any of the money and that this was completely my dad's own doing.\n\n\"My dad died of a sudden fatal collapse on January 5th, 2026. Months of stress and uncertainty, embarrassment and emotional toll had taken place. He had nothing. Forced to sell his condo to pay off some of his debt but seemingly about to be homeless.\n\n\"Fraud is abundant. We read about it all the time. I simply don't understand how the bank could see such large sums of money to be transferred with no regard. And at this point, they simply do not care....\n\n\"But I do want something good to come out of his death—more people need to hear stories like this for real change to happen....\n\n\"The lack of responsibility by BMO has changed the course of my life. My dad will not get to watch [my or my sisters'] families grow up. He will never financially contribute towards us. We are now left with the bill of his death and bankrupting his estate. lt's a devastating end.\"\n\nExample number two is Mrs. L, a 79-year-old senior who was the victim of a devastating financial fraud that resulted in the loss of a significant portion of her retirement life savings. Fraudsters impersonated law enforcement and coerced her into selling her retirement investments in her registered retirement accounts and wiring the money abroad to them from local RBC and TD branches. She lost some $400,000 in her life savings. To add insult to injury, she now faces a significant tax liability from the CRA due to this, despite already having suffered a complete financial loss of much of her retirement savings. Because she withdrew RSP savings, which were then stolen, she now has to pay taxes on these monies, even though they have been lost to her.\n\nThe NDP recently moved seven amendments to Bill C-15, the budget 2025 implementation act, no. 1, aimed at strengthening protections for Canadians targeted by bank-related fraud. Unfortunately, Liberals and Conservatives combined to defeat them, and we see nothing addressing this in these estimates. Our amendments would have required banks to reimburse customers who fall victim to consumer-targeted fraud, unless they have been grossly negligent in relation to that fraud. Banks would have also been required to report anonymized consumer-targeted fraud data, so we could get a better understanding of the scope of this problem. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada would have been required to conduct regular unannounced audits of banks' anti-fraud practices and policies, publish detailed fraud statistics and make its annual fraud report public, so that we could make sure that banks are actually following through on the policies they claim to have. The amendments also sought to make decisions of the Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments binding.\n\n These measures were recommended by advocacy organizations, including Option consommateurs and Democracy Watch, which argued that without mandatory audits, transparency, and accountability mechanisms, existing anti-fraud rules would remain ineffective.\n\nThe United Kingdom recently brought in new rules requiring that a consumer who is a victim of a fraud known as an APP scam, which is a scam wherein the scammer convinces the victim to make a payment, must be reimbursed, unless there is gross negligence on their part. In Quebec, the Consumer Protection Act was recently amended to impose reimbursement obligations on financial institutions in cases of fraud involving a consumer's bank account.\n\nI want to quote Democracy Watch, which noted this:\n\nIt is not enough to just require the banks to have policies and procedures in place. The Bank Act was changed in 2018 to add...two provisions requiring banks to have policies, procedures and training to ensure the financial interests of their customers are protected...but the FCAC was not required in those provisions to audit the banks to ensure they comply with those provisions and, as a result, the FCAC has done nothing to ensure they actually comply....\n\nThe new anti-bank account fraud measures will also have little effect unless the FCAC is required to conduct regular, unannounced audits and to prosecute and penalize violations...\n\nOption consommateurs noted this:\n\nWe believe that an approach that holds banks more accountable will not only allow thousands of Canadians who are victims of fraud to be able to recover their money, but it will also decrease the occurrence of such fraud. By placing greater responsibility on banks, the legislative framework will incentivize these businesses to deploy the appropriate measures to prevent their losses.\n\nThe example of the United Kingdom is a clear illustration of this. According to the Payment Systems Regulator, following the entry into force of the new consumer protection framework, the number of claims for...fraud decreased by approximately 15% between October 2024 and June 2025, compared to the same period [the year before].\n\nWith the advent of AI and growing technology, the prospects of fraud growing in this country are chilling. Imagine a senior answering the phone and hearing the computer-generated voice of their bank manager or their grandchild, who is asking them to wire money somewhere. This is the kind of technology that exists now, yet we are operating on outdated legislation. Although the government did put a financial crimes agency in the budget, which is a good step forward, it can and should do much more to help protect Canadians from fraud in this country. New Democrats will certainly work together to help make that happen.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085078","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the hon. member from Milton East—Halton Hills South.\n\nI think we all know that fraud in Canada is a growing problem. Stories are now appearing in the media virtually every week. Data from the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre shows that Canadians lost $638 million to fraud in 2024. Reported losses to the CAFC since 2021 have now surpassed $2 billion. The rate","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1bf75879801811735dd1cc5444e9a14b1e6b1c3e8d81a010336e8327f4d04622"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3944e92c4b3d63463aaa59fb784529fa3e2a48d4432f47b67797d0231bdb9429"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5fdfeb472ee1113efc30b03e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085079,"date":"2026-06-09T01:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague is right. The problem is staggering. If the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre said that Canadians lost $638 million to fraud in 2024, and only 5% to 10% is being reported, we are talking about $6 billion to $12 billion a year being lost to fraud in this country. \n\nI know we cannot stop it entirely, but what we can and should be doing is taking measures. The government should really look at the amendments the NDP put forward, because we can place more responsibility on banks, which are financial experts, to watch for the red flags and maybe ask questions so that when vulnerable people are going to banks and being defrauded, at least that is addressed in some meaningful manner.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085079","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague is right. The problem is staggering. If the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre said that Canadians lost $638 million to fraud in 2024, and only 5% to 10% is being reported, we are talking about $6 billion to $12 billion a year being lost to fraud in this country. \n\nI know we cannot stop it entirely, but what we can and should be doing is taking measures. The government shoul","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5fbbfb1b376017bac1be7188036fd0db1002639b4e6fe28eb45c076a2635f68d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["979e445bef63fd48181bbc24e3a08e791a9fe21dc6a79bde1ae139fb13eb5f39"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e30e542c847cbeb3c5ac14f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085080,"date":"2026-06-09T01:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yes, Mr. Speaker, this is going to take a multi-jurisdictional approach. The member is quite right that the provinces have a role to play, but the federal government regulates banks and the banking sector. \n\nOne of my children has a disability, and every January or February I make a contribution to her RDSP. When I do that, because I have made only one contribution a year, I have to answer about 20 minutes of questions to assess my level of investor knowledge, and yet I just read out examples of a senior walking into a bank who just opened an account and is wiring hundreds of thousands of dollars to Vietnam, and they get one question asked of them. \n\nI think that banks can and should be doing much more to flag these problems, and perhaps we can at least help some of these seniors who are being defrauded out of their life savings.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085080","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, Mr. Speaker, this is going to take a multi-jurisdictional approach. The member is quite right that the provinces have a role to play, but the federal government regulates banks and the banking sector. \n\nOne of my children has a disability, and every January or February I make a contribution to her RDSP. When I do that, because I have made only one contribution a year, I have to answer about 2","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8335c19e78165f112c31edc2016c7094658910ea70c24e8ac4755cca498cdad1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21c9ef60b0fc6b0e182d8a24574b9d20fc3412309c360550e685145e824cbf3d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ea2d29debd66f2e6f4777fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085081,"date":"2026-06-09T01:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, first of all, my heart goes out to those employees, and I agree with my hon. colleague that the SME sector is critical to Canada's growth. What I would say is that Quebec is leading the country in advocating changes to the way banks are held responsible for these fraud situations, so I think we should study the Quebec example and apply those very valid mechanisms at the federal level as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085081","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, first of all, my heart goes out to those employees, and I agree with my hon. colleague that the SME sector is critical to Canada's growth. What I would say is that Quebec is leading the country in advocating changes to the way banks are held responsible for these fraud situations, so I think we should study the Quebec example and apply those very valid mechanisms at the federal level ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06f0c59ad2144d29a71284d4eb70032b92a5f4076162d0b2ab3dce5c03ca4374"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2d996a368c45ad1961caa34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085082,"date":"2026-06-09T04:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP agrees to apply the vote, with the NDP voting in favour.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085082","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP agrees to apply the vote, with the NDP voting in favour.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58b0dcfac1f32053a7654c98cb19c05983b0084d2cf73829974d9c2227823375"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b26d93daf838ff6e11c9fea0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085075,"date":"2026-06-12T15:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to mark Philippine Independence Day and to celebrate Filipino Heritage Month across Canada.\n\nI was honoured to join many friends in the Filipino Canadian community for the annual flag raising ceremony at Filipino Plaza in the heart of Vancouver Kingsway. It was a proud celebration of bayanihan, representing unity, co-operation and selfless aid. I give many thanks to the United Filipino Canadian Associations in British Columbia for organizing this fabulous event.\n\nMore than one million Filipino Canadians call Canada home, and their contributions strengthen our nation economically, culturally, politically and socially. In every vocation and profession from health care to education, skilled trades, business and public service, Filipino Canadians play an essential role in building our country. Their generosity, resilience, faith and love of life enrich our society and inspire us all.\n\nI thank the Filipino Canadian community for everything they contribute to our world.\n\nMaligayang Araw ng Kalayaan. Mabuhay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085075","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to mark Philippine Independence Day and to celebrate Filipino Heritage Month across Canada.\n\nI was honoured to join many friends in the Filipino Canadian community for the annual flag raising ceremony at Filipino Plaza in the heart of Vancouver Kingsway. It was a proud celebration of bayanihan, representing unity, co-operation and selfless aid. I give many thanks to the U","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["51b5161b4945f043925fc3e543f8537bfa29791193829f10afc01194873928af"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["274fa16646126179357a7b2284e3cd7b41a77e732b911112664f53f73f24f754"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77850f9422c15f915e5c2ec4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085076,"date":"2026-06-12T17:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats have been advocating for a Filipino cultural centre in metro Vancouver for many years. Our persistence resulted in the federal budget committing to fund this much-needed community resource. After the Lapu-Lapu tragedy, this centre is needed now more than ever. The Filipino Canadian community contributes so much to our country. It deserves a place to call home. \n\nWhen will the government honour its promise and deliver the funds necessary to make the Filipino cultural centre a reality?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085076","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats have been advocating for a Filipino cultural centre in metro Vancouver for many years. Our persistence resulted in the federal budget committing to fund this much-needed community resource. After the Lapu-Lapu tragedy, this centre is needed now more than ever. The Filipino Canadian community contributes so much to our country. It deserves a place to call home. \n\nWhen wil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6cade0d5eb807964d963a43a7d3ce5908960efcd5eab510481e44a77a47d034"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0455396c2247a06114715f7699a64d41d64affca3c5cba29816c38aa6ea598f4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-915314653c3930cc23dec54d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087219,"date":"2026-06-16T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Don Davies","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats have raised the alarm on surveillance pricing, an invasive and unfair scheme that gouges Canadians. We called on the Liberals to follow the Manitoba NDP government, which moved swiftly to ban this insidious practice. Instead, the government tabled legislation that not only fails to address this issue, but does not even mention it. I guess AI for everyone really means everyone is a target.\n\n Why are the Liberals refusing to protect Canadians from abusive technology that invades their privacy and enables discriminatory pricing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087219","member_id":"bc-mp-59325","member_name":"Don Davies","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats have raised the alarm on surveillance pricing, an invasive and unfair scheme that gouges Canadians. We called on the Liberals to follow the Manitoba NDP government, which moved swiftly to ban this insidious practice. Instead, the government tabled legislation that not only fails to address this issue, but does not even mention it. I guess AI for everyone really means eve","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9b16359d65d38d8c0e75e4053c9759019acb3bc20eddd24003f80dac038ff11f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4fdf7c7573ab825753338b7ca91f63dcceec259a92eaffb41fc62cd874b4447"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d963f7b100837e817121819","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77496,"date":"2026-02-04T19:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the finance minister promised three years ago that he had a plan to lower food prices. How is that working out? Since then, the cost of groceries has skyrocketed, with the price of lettuce up 40%, coffee up over 30% and the price of beef up over 25%. The recycled plan for a temporary rebate will not reduce the cost of a single item of food. \n\n Their plan has failed, so why do the Liberals not support our food affordability plan to axe the industrial carbon tax, cut the fuel standards tax and boost competition in grocery stores to lower food prices for all Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77496","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the finance minister promised three years ago that he had a plan to lower food prices. How is that working out? Since then, the cost of groceries has skyrocketed, with the price of lettuce up 40%, coffee up over 30% and the price of beef up over 25%. The recycled plan for a temporary rebate will not reduce the cost of a single item of food. \n\n Their plan has failed, so why do the Libe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lettuce","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036117","label":"Lettuce","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c6b0e0996b60654d35da7873ea98162aa6b63b9419a290033db18a88362c6ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ecbde09da708b6e9c07f18b34221c96378c0db097fc9e84af4e43410038c946d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b61c9999a80c56fea6b8468e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77497,"date":"2026-02-04T19:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, most Canadians will get no benefit from this recycled plan. A small number will get about $10 a week, but that will not make a dent in the over $340 a week a family of four has to spend to buy groceries. The finance minister promised he would bring down grocery prices three years ago. He failed then, and he is failing again. \n\nThe Liberals' plan is not working, so why do they not vote for our food affordability plan to cut the industrial carbon tax, axe the fuel standards tax and finally lower grocery prices for all Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77497","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, most Canadians will get no benefit from this recycled plan. A small number will get about $10 a week, but that will not make a dent in the over $340 a week a family of four has to spend to buy groceries. The finance minister promised he would bring down grocery prices three years ago. He failed then, and he is failing again. \n\nThe Liberals' plan is not working, so why do they not vote","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["36969ec6ecdf53185c4e825a4631e86f004b8489ccc4ed42d2a2323eca011802"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e9a5af6bbc1b654328495a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":96244,"date":"2026-02-10T19:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, these Liberals keep telling Canadians that they have never had it so good. Not only has food inflation doubled since the Prime Minister took office; it is now twice as high in Canada as it is in the United States. It is driving over two million people a month to food banks. I guess they should just \"move on\" from that. \n\nNow we learn that more and more Canadians have been forced into bankruptcy and bankruptcy proposals. In my province of British Columbia, they are up over 10% in the last year alone. When will the government stop pushing people to the brink and cut the taxes and red tape that are pushing Canadians into bankruptcy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96244","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, these Liberals keep telling Canadians that they have never had it so good. Not only has food inflation doubled since the Prime Minister took office; it is now twice as high in Canada as it is in the United States. It is driving over two million people a month to food banks. I guess they should just \"move on\" from that. \n\nNow we learn that more and more Canadians have been forced into ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["92d619b26743f25e31ebac48ba6dc2e113168bf4048fd2a2e27684a8e954c621"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c2bb77c00b5da643e2b3b2e979f97458afa600b4baf68b8598d0ad68252d4b75"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f68efa015db139c47b141c1e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":96245,"date":"2026-02-10T19:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal plan is not working. Over two million Canadians a month are using the food bank. The cost of groceries has skyrocketed to over $340 a week for a family of four. The small minority of Canadians who get that recycled rebate he was talking about will only get $10 a week, which is not going to keep their creditors at bay. \n\nNow bankruptcies and bankruptcy proposals are at their highest levels since the global financial crisis, so when will the Liberals finally cut taxes and red tape and stop pushing record numbers of Canadians into bankruptcy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96245","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal plan is not working. Over two million Canadians a month are using the food bank. The cost of groceries has skyrocketed to over $340 a week for a family of four. The small minority of Canadians who get that recycled rebate he was talking about will only get $10 a week, which is not going to keep their creditors at bay. \n\nNow bankruptcies and bankruptcy proposals are at thei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","label":"Bankruptcies"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","label":"Bankruptcies","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6b93363fa96f3e053eb82283aa2c25bd023245f19266b005f5595c0a85b046bb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a60cbd46c3d393acc6ce1e29f84ea4168995319708fd2e96dc99ba40592f001c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1114c115921c6c1dfd782be5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332223,"date":"2026-03-10T19:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are struggling to make ends meet. Record food bank usage, personal bankruptcy rates and an increasing number of Canadians borrowing money to buy food are proof of that. While there are some things that are outside of our control, there are things that the government does control, like its new fuel tax, which is already raising the price of gas by seven cents a litre and is set to climb up to 17¢ a litre, raising the cost of everything that Canadians buy. \n\nWhen will the Liberals finally take responsibility for their reckless policies and stop making life more expensive for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332223","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are struggling to make ends meet. Record food bank usage, personal bankruptcy rates and an increasing number of Canadians borrowing money to buy food are proof of that. While there are some things that are outside of our control, there are things that the government does control, like its new fuel tax, which is already raising the price of gas by seven cents a litre and is s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8d1c13f2c3b86f0c2b95230d510b610d56cca45ab0d801c7d9b9d0e541d88eb1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3033e7b597266d23f267ea6c6544ae152d81cfbe3f5715368deccf02cf654e0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f1378cc665ec530b669cf59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332224,"date":"2026-03-10T19:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, every country in the G7 is facing external pressures, but this government stands alone in having created the worst food price inflation and the only shrinking economy in the G7. Instead of making life more affordable, the Liberals are making it worse with their higher fuel and carbon taxes, which are raising the costs for farmers, fishers and truckers, driving up the cost of everything for cash-strapped Canadians. \n\nWhy do the Liberals not finally focus on what they can control and get rid of these harmful policies that are punishing Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332224","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, every country in the G7 is facing external pressures, but this government stands alone in having created the worst food price inflation and the only shrinking economy in the G7. Instead of making life more affordable, the Liberals are making it worse with their higher fuel and carbon taxes, which are raising the costs for farmers, fishers and truckers, driving up the cost of everythin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f61e80798ca3085f84a1ce5bba21fd4ce63a5073d313c80972151527171820c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0d4d6bad602c68709a5ffe531d7ae0c39c23af00c6f53eff4d16bf4e02c4f25a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8038795b9582d51c8f18a0ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":377413,"date":"2026-03-25T19:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, while the Liberals do not control what happens abroad, they do control their policies here at home. Instead of working to bring costs down, the Liberal Prime Minister is not only going ahead with his industrial carbon tax, but has introduced a fuel standard tax, which adds 7¢ a litre to the already high cost of gas and will eventually rise to 17¢ per litre. It is more of the same Liberal taxes from the same Liberal government.\n\n When will the Liberal government give Canadians a break and get rid of these Liberal gas taxes that are making life more expensive for Canadian families?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:377413","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, while the Liberals do not control what happens abroad, they do control their policies here at home. Instead of working to bring costs down, the Liberal Prime Minister is not only going ahead with his industrial carbon tax, but has introduced a fuel standard tax, which adds 7¢ a litre to the already high cost of gas and will eventually rise to 17¢ per litre. It is more of the same Libe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["120153e73bff658408281f7e9b0a021ea81eb60a10761f025a3077f6edc27255"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97c00d2f0db056ae136a890fafb9545a3dfc800f0a9f8946201d106c5e7aabf5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25ed6a74900cb15af50e3100","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":377415,"date":"2026-03-25T19:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are paying more because of Liberal policies here at home. All G7 countries are dealing with similar external factors, but it is only the Liberal government that has caused us to have the worst food inflation and the only shrinking economy in the G7. The price of gas is 20% higher here than it is in the U.S., and Liberal fuel and carbon taxes are making it even worse.\n\n When will the Liberal government stop passing the buck, take responsibility for its policies and finally cut Liberal taxes to make life more affordable for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:377415","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are paying more because of Liberal policies here at home. All G7 countries are dealing with similar external factors, but it is only the Liberal government that has caused us to have the worst food inflation and the only shrinking economy in the G7. The price of gas is 20% higher here than it is in the U.S., and Liberal fuel and carbon taxes are making it even worse.\n\n When ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["93574adb2b6ba5f0b31d462c4a2c0c3e5c3b61a6fdef288bc28dafa77a0a08a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a54201dda9c6548f8252f741ade0abdde15f9718454b2bacdbba179a6fb8e841"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-611b2b77a867c09fdf02bdea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419776,"date":"2026-04-15T21:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am here to present two petitions on behalf of my constituents.\n\nThe first is from constituents who are calling on the government to lead an international investigation into the Iranian regime's brutal crackdown on activists. Thousands have been killed. Tens of thousands have been arbitrarily arrested. The regime has used torture and sexual violence as a tool of repression.\n\nThe petitioners are calling for the use of Magnitsky sanctions against Iranian officials and the use of all diplomatic channels to demand the immediate release of Narges Mohammadi and the staying of all pending execution orders for political prisoners.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419776","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am here to present two petitions on behalf of my constituents.\n\nThe first is from constituents who are calling on the government to lead an international investigation into the Iranian regime's brutal crackdown on activists. Thousands have been killed. Tens of thousands have been arbitrarily arrested. The regime has used torture and sexual violence as a tool of repression.\n\nThe peti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5062f3c8ec78bb88008e8c4422d379535463f0860caa60cc34906ae697719ebc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6fe52aa15b43acbb99bd0da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419777,"date":"2026-04-15T21:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition is on behalf of British Columbians who are deeply concerned about proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia. Changing this common property principle risks turning a shared public resource into an exclusive privilege, reducing access for many Canadians and undermining confidence in fisheries management.\n\nThese B.C. residents are calling on the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans to leave the current salmon allocation policy alone and uphold the cultural rights and traditions of all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419777","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition is on behalf of British Columbians who are deeply concerned about proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia. Changing this common property principle risks turning a shared public resource into an exclusive privilege, reducing access for many Canadians and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61007d54e562d28a18a4dcd33221176eea9dcd03f740ca958b07b583dab511b5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53cd8687afde55591945ae2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419774,"date":"2026-04-16T19:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after a decade of Liberal governments, Canadians are at a breaking point. Here are the sobering statistics. Nearly a third of Canadians say they do not earn enough to cover their bills. Nearly four out of 10 are worried about losing their job. Three out of five say they are working harder, but not getting ahead. Just yesterday, the Liberal government voted against affordability for Canadians yet again. \n\nWhy will the Liberals not provide Canadians with real relief by adopting our Conservative plan to cut all federal taxes on gas and food?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419774","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after a decade of Liberal governments, Canadians are at a breaking point. Here are the sobering statistics. Nearly a third of Canadians say they do not earn enough to cover their bills. Nearly four out of 10 are worried about losing their job. Three out of five say they are working harder, but not getting ahead. Just yesterday, the Liberal government voted against affordability for Ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b7594bb201132dcccf407468fe59b0174d77dda44cbfb15b5e5d49ea47bca522"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01a665f20d916ec94a5fffed23cf075f2d33e3828f7309c076808d68f60a98fd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d99df32c4f2bc80a885f8bcf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419775,"date":"2026-04-16T19:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, while Conservatives offer real relief, the Liberals are offering pennies at the pump. Their plan cuts only a third of the taxes they collect on fuel for a third of the year. These tiny tax cuts will be burned up immediately as gas stations are switching over to more expensive summer fuel blends. Liberal taxes are so out of control that one out of five young Canadians say they will need to go into debt just to pay their tax bill.\n\n Why will the Liberals not provide Canadians with real relief instead of half measures and adopt our Conservative plan to cut all taxes on fuel for the rest of the year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419775","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, while Conservatives offer real relief, the Liberals are offering pennies at the pump. Their plan cuts only a third of the taxes they collect on fuel for a third of the year. These tiny tax cuts will be burned up immediately as gas stations are switching over to more expensive summer fuel blends. Liberal taxes are so out of control that one out of five young Canadians say they will nee","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c497bae473bc70f2b9ad0b874ea035579a100ac7be04273bbd457299ffbd565c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3cc33cdad1be5d7430d7530fdb1bc5d1ed962876cb43da67fed93783bf3269c3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0c5508a5c45e67d1f3c850c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723458,"date":"2026-04-29T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, these same old costly Liberals have continued their decade of credit card budgeting: more costs, more debt, more taxes, more of the same. In fact, the costly Liberal Prime Minister is now doubling the Trudeau deficit. He is literally doubling down on the failures of the past, failures that have delivered the worst housing, worst food inflation and worst economic growth in the G7.\n\nWhen will the Liberal Prime Minister end his costly credit card budgeting so Canadians can afford to put food on the table and keep a roof over their head?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723458","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, these same old costly Liberals have continued their decade of credit card budgeting: more costs, more debt, more taxes, more of the same. In fact, the costly Liberal Prime Minister is now doubling the Trudeau deficit. He is literally doubling down on the failures of the past, failures that have delivered the worst housing, worst food inflation and worst economic growth in the G7.\n\nWhe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad5ca71bb07b1a1f85a9732a6faaa01850fcb03e4cee0c500d6c42e2554fe8e5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["170e76d5dbdcbede9c79baabae74fb7f42da133fb8c97f381aebecd9aefd911c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d20a02a1aa03665dd1f97c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723461,"date":"2026-04-29T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I understand why that minister would not want to talk about the past, given his horrendous record on housing in the city of Vancouver. It is the same old story with these same old Liberals. Even Liberal-friendly columnists like Andrew Coyne have finally taken notice, saying, \"Canada's New Government is no more interested in arresting our economic decline than Canada's Old Government\". Canadians are maxed out. They cannot afford the same reckless Liberal policies of the last decade.\n\nWhy have the Liberals doubled Justin Trudeau's deficit, doubled down on costly credit card budgeting and forced Canadians to pay more for gas, groceries and housing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723461","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I understand why that minister would not want to talk about the past, given his horrendous record on housing in the city of Vancouver. It is the same old story with these same old Liberals. Even Liberal-friendly columnists like Andrew Coyne have finally taken notice, saying, \"Canada's New Government is no more interested in arresting our economic decline than Canada's Old Government\".","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fbdb0e90c62ebe1ba3660b80df4630b0cdb85b934b0b15f905af05902d176a55"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c35f98a865f240ace8f10611","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723456,"date":"2026-04-30T19:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the same old Liberals have continued their decade of credit card budgets. Not only has this costly Liberal Prime Minister embraced the same borrow-and-spend policies of Justin Trudeau, he has doubled down, doubling the deficit. \n\nThese failed policies have left Canadians with the worst housing costs, worst economic growth and worst inflation in the G7. The costs to Canadians are enormous. Interest charges on the national debt this year will reach $60 billion and in five years will be $90 billion. That works out to $3,400 in interest costs for every Canadian family this year. That money goes to bankers and bondholders instead of doctors and nurses. Interest payments on our debt are now the fastest-growing item in the Liberal budget. \n\nThe Liberals are mortgaging the future, selfishly racking up the credit card and leaving the bill for our kids and grandkids. Enough is enough. It is time to restore fiscal responsibility and put an end to these reckless Liberal credit card budgets.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723456","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the same old Liberals have continued their decade of credit card budgets. Not only has this costly Liberal Prime Minister embraced the same borrow-and-spend policies of Justin Trudeau, he has doubled down, doubling the deficit. \n\nThese failed policies have left Canadians with the worst housing costs, worst economic growth and worst inflation in the G7. The costs to Canadians are enorm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","label":"Interest rates","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["74261531586af9503d8751ef5621030ba23d18b6ae2bc7c91bb7b622079b0493"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["667cbbe9b040f10b293a92f2cddfee37e07b059a8806970bfe3c6f5d56d288cb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e46201e9b69e8b4cf338cd48","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752416,"date":"2026-05-06T20:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbians bought their homes, paid their mortgages and played by the rules, but due to the Cowichan decision, they now face uncertainty as to whether their private property will be protected going forward. Instead of arguing in favour of those rights in the Cowichan case, this Liberal government told federal lawyers not to defend those rights through litigation directive number 14, a directive that is still active to this day.\n\nHow can British Columbians believe that this Liberal Prime Minister will stand up for their private property rights when his government guidelines are telling his lawyers to stand down?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752416","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbians bought their homes, paid their mortgages and played by the rules, but due to the Cowichan decision, they now face uncertainty as to whether their private property will be protected going forward. Instead of arguing in favour of those rights in the Cowichan case, this Liberal government told federal lawyers not to defend those rights through litigation directive numb","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["78e6084418205c0a23a4d58ddc7d88e383922d61232263f85dc2b42da815eaf7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa910709c670396d46ee831b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021400,"date":"2026-05-28T19:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister is off to New York for what even the CBC calls a straight-up networking trip. Perhaps he will meet with his friends at Brookfield Asset Management there. Like so many other investors, they fled Bay Street for Wall Street, with Main Street in Canada paying the price.\n\nOver the last Liberal decade, more than $1 trillion in investment has left Canada. That means lost jobs and lost wages for Canadian workers. The Prime Minister himself holds 91% of his personal investments in the United States. \n\nIs he in New York for Canadians, or is he just there to check up on his own portfolio?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021400","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister is off to New York for what even the CBC calls a straight-up networking trip. Perhaps he will meet with his friends at Brookfield Asset Management there. Like so many other investors, they fled Bay Street for Wall Street, with Main Street in Canada paying the price.\n\nOver the last Liberal decade, more than $1 trillion in investment has left Canada. That means lost j","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28bb3d9b17c5387b32dff5ac929b5c7c0c9a058856aac9b9a4405159fabd5433"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ee1344895dfe2204da62712","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021411,"date":"2026-05-28T19:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, speaking of $20 billion, that is how much money has left Canada in the last four quarters under this Prime Minister. After more than a decade of Liberal taxes, red tape and uncertainty, investors, including the Prime Minister, continue to take their money elsewhere. Despite Liberal re-announcements, major projects remain trapped in years of delays while Canadian workers lose those jobs.\n\nWhen will the Prime Minister take real action to cut red tape and repeal these anti-development laws that are continuing to bring about an investment exodus?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021411","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, speaking of $20 billion, that is how much money has left Canada in the last four quarters under this Prime Minister. After more than a decade of Liberal taxes, red tape and uncertainty, investors, including the Prime Minister, continue to take their money elsewhere. Despite Liberal re-announcements, major projects remain trapped in years of delays while Canadian workers lose those job","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1ed4380332c71c88f02ca0037fdbee5c50106bc64fff9d96f69e396fedc935e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d4caea5d35f53311f449945","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085109,"date":"2026-06-10T19:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mark Strahl","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after more than a decade of reckless Liberal spending, borrowing and economic mismanagement, more and more Canadians are suffering. Under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country in a recession, and the devastating results can no longer be ignored. Today the United Way report has painted a grim picture of the impact on Canadians: Sixty per cent now feel anxiety about their personal finances, 38% struggle with food insecurity, 40% are losing sleep over how they will stretch their paycheque to pay their bills, and 34% know someone close to them who is experiencing poverty, which is up five percentage points.\n\nGlobal factors did not cause this. Liberal inflationary spending, red tape and antidevelopment laws did. With millions of people going hungry, stressed about their finances and fearful for their future, it is high time the Liberal government reversed its disastrous economic policies so we can finally begin to restore hope for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085109","member_id":"bc-mp-71986","member_name":"Mark Strahl","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after more than a decade of reckless Liberal spending, borrowing and economic mismanagement, more and more Canadians are suffering. Under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country in a recession, and the devastating results can no longer be ignored. Today the United Way report has painted a grim picture of the impact on Canadians: Sixty per cent now feel anxiety about","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["06b68bfd3acb66440e88dfd202dc1b6c8ba2c2d04119c20e4332b44ecf43a31a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6bc70fa6feb325887acfe51ddaeb5a02f5b44ab4c9a62c83a05313f9be62ab5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72fafade03d14a194d128869","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77498,"date":"2026-02-03T19:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on February 4, Ismaili Muslims across Canada and around the world will celebrate Imamat Day, marking one year since His Highness Prince Rahim Aga Khan became the 50th hereditary imam of the Ismaili Muslims.\n\n In that time, Mawlana Hazar Imam has worked tirelessly to build bridges between nations, to advance the fight against climate change, to support community resilience and to improve the quality of life of those living in the most difficult of circumstances. For Ismailis, he has reminded us of the importance of being active, engaged, ethical citizens and that living our values of kindness, compassion and service to all is an act of faith. For us all, Hazar Imam has shown us the importance of faith, of maintaining balance in our lives, of taking the time to care for family and community and, above all, of living our physical lives with purpose and intention. These values reflect the best of what unites us as Canadians.\n\n I invite all members of the House to join me in wishing His Highness and Ismailis across Canada, Khushali Mubarak.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77498","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on February 4, Ismaili Muslims across Canada and around the world will celebrate Imamat Day, marking one year since His Highness Prince Rahim Aga Khan became the 50th hereditary imam of the Ismaili Muslims.\n\n In that time, Mawlana Hazar Imam has worked tirelessly to build bridges between nations, to advance the fight against climate change, to support community resilience and to impro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0c547bb301cace3bd82eb7da2becb54008af1bbe6e03e9a6841b6315ec8d541a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7fcb2f82ba316c25fd09aba2c039eb91d0d1ceef2ba9d2acfbf259464b98c9f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-82a317dbbfe69e70e054bfec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":96246,"date":"2026-02-09T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, building a strong economy is not just about looking at any single sector. It is about looking at all sectors. It is about making sure we are investing in the economy of the future today, making sure we are investing in technology, making sure we are investing in artificial intelligence, and making sure we are creating the jobs of the future in industries where Canadians can lead.\n\nAs we work to support our manufacturing sector, we are also making sure that in health sciences, life sciences, biotech, technology, e-commerce, digital, AI and quantum, Canada will continue to lead and create the jobs of the future today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96246","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, building a strong economy is not just about looking at any single sector. It is about looking at all sectors. It is about making sure we are investing in the economy of the future today, making sure we are investing in technology, making sure we are investing in artificial intelligence, and making sure we are creating the jobs of the future in industries where Canadians can lead.\n\nAs ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["582419a353b1de5728d850878f2b3d39b5e419fff04b0b0da7130d5110e3b157"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eaccb7397281e56883d19bdd2c3d7cdab916c409e55c634a9ca15f75d3745714"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af767798ec8b144553c59ce1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332225,"date":"2026-03-13T15:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to begin not with a policy argument but with something more fundamental, a question that I think most Canadians are grappling with right now: Can the next generation afford to live in the communities they grew up? For too many Canadians, and certainly this is the case in my riding of Vancouver Granville, the answer is no. I think it is worth sitting with that for a moment before we get into the mechanics of the legislation.\n\nThe mechanics matter only if we are honest about the scale of what we are trying to solve. We are not dealing with a temporary market fluctuation. We are dealing with a structural deficit in housing supply that has compounded over decades in communities large and small in every province and every territory. The cost of inaction shows up in families doubling up in homes that were not designed for it, in workers who cannot live near the jobs they are being asked to fill, because they cannot afford to, and in young people who have quietly stopped imagining home ownership as something that belongs to them. This bill is one part of the government's response to that reality.\n\nBill C-20, the Build Canada Homes act, proposes to transition Build Canada Homes from a special operating agency within Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada into a Crown corporation. I want to take a moment to explain why the distinction matters, because I think it is easy to hear \"Crown corporation\" and think of it as a bureaucratic technicality or a boondoggle, but it is anything but.\n\nA special operating agency, however well resourced and however well intentioned, operates within the constraints of its parent department. It cannot independently hold assets, it cannot take on the kind of financial risk that is required to build complex or large-scale housing developments, and it cannot move with the speed and flexibility that a housing crisis of this magnitude demands. A Crown corporation, on the other hand, can do all those things while remaining fully accountable to Parliament and to Canadians.\n\nWhat the legislation would do in practical terms is give Build Canada Homes the legal and operational independence to deploy $13 billion in additional capitalization to hold and to develop public lands; to enter into complex financial arrangements with provinces, municipalities, non-profits and indigenous housing providers; and to do so without the structural friction that has, quite frankly, slowed federal housing delivery in the past, regardless of who has been in power.\n\nThe legislation would authorize the integration of the Canada Lands Company, which would bring with it significant land holdings and deep development expertise, under the Build Canada Homes umbrella. It would enable non-profits, church groups and other organizations to bring their land to bear in helping to solve the housing crisis in the country. That matters. Federal land is one of the most underleveraged assets we have in addressing the housing supply gap, and the legislation would begin to change that.\n\nThe arguments that one could make against the bill are predictable, and they deserve a substantive response. We will hear and have already heard that this would be yet another federal bureaucracy, that the government would be inserting itself where it does not belong and that builders build homes, not bureaucrats. I would say with the greatest of respect that this framing misunderstands what Build Canada Homes is designed to do.\n\nBuild Canada Homes would not be competing with the private sector. It is not designed to replace builders, developers or market mechanisms that have an important role to play in housing supply. It is designed to go where the market on its own has demonstrated it will not go: deeply affordable housing, non-market housing, supportive and transitional housing, housing for indigenous communities and housing in places and for populations where the financial returns do not attract the scale of private capital that other markets do. This is not government overreach. It is government doing what only government can do.\n\nI want to point out something concrete, because I think this debate benefits from moving from principle to evidence. Last month, Build Canada Homes and my province, the province of British Columbia, announced a partnership that I think illustrates exactly what this model is capable of. Through that agreement, Build Canada Homes committed $170 billion in capital, which in turn unlocked $640 million in provincial investment through BC Housing.\n\nTogether, that partnership will deliver over 700 shovel-ready and supportive transitional homes, with construction beginning in the next 12 months, alongside at least 400 affordable rental homes using B.C.'s DASH program, Digitally Accelerated Standardized Housing, which uses prefab Canadian components to reduce costs and construction timelines simultaneously. It is one federal investment and multiple times its value in leveraged provincial dollars. It is over 1,000 homes built using innovative Canadian construction methods on a timeline that would not have been achievable under the old model.\n\nThis is the logic of the legislation made real, and it is not an isolated example. Since its launch in September, Build Canada Homes has already secured partnerships and agreements with the City of Ottawa and with the provinces of Nova Scotia and Quebec, and a tripartite agreement with Nunavut and Nunavut Tunngavik Incorporated. All of these represent, together with the B.C. agreement, more than 8,600 new homes already.\n\nSince I was elected, I have made a commitment to my constituents that I would do everything possible to bring affordable and rental housing to our riding. Since then, we have delivered more than 10,000 units of affordable and rental housing in Vancouver Granville. However, that is not enough. That is why this work with Build Canada Homes is essential.\n\nI want to say a word about affordability and accountability because I know it will be raised, and accountability should be raised. Accountability is not a distraction from the urgency of the housing crisis; it is what makes sustained, long-term delivery possible. Build Canada Homes, as a Crown corporation, would operate with a board of directors and a Governor in Council-appointed leadership. It would be subject to the FAA. It would report to Parliament. The minister would retain authority to issue directives.\n\nThese are not weak accountability mechanisms. They are quite the opposite. They are the standard framework that has governed effective Crown corporations in this country for generations. The question is not whether there will be accountability but whether we are willing to give this institution the independence it needs to actually deliver. The legislation seeks to balance that in the right manner.\n\nI think about what the bill would achieve when we look down the line 10, 15 or 20 years. What would it make possible in that time frame? We know, because history has shown us, that the most consequential investments governments make are rarely the ones that produce immediate visible returns. This is not just about between now and the next election but about security and stability for generations of Canadians.\n\n The infrastructure that was built by previous generations, the institutions established over decades, and the long-term bets on innovation and capacity that have compounded over time are what define whether a country is building toward something or simply managing its present. Housing affordability is one of those long-term bets. Turning Build Canada Homes into a durable, well-capitalized, operationally independent institution is not a quick fix; it is a foundation that if built well will be delivering homes for Canadians long after the politics of this moment have moved on.\n\nI believe, and on this side of the House we believe, that is worth doing, and I think it is worth doing urgently. The evidence of the last six months, the partnerships, the projects, the capital deployed, the communities engaged from British Columbia to Nunavut and to Nova Scotia, suggest that we have in Build Canada Homes an institution that is ready to rise to that responsibility. \n\nWhen I think about what we have already accomplished in my own riding, whether it is the Soroptimist project, which is women-led housing for women and women-led families; whether it is the Ashley Mar project, which turned a small number of co-op units into hundreds of co-op units alongside rental; or whether it is the Sen̓áḵw project in the north end of my riding, each and every one of these projects, supported by the federal government, has enabled different types of housing to take shape. It has helped to address the missing middle challenges. It has helped to address what workers need in order to be close to their jobs.\n\nHowever, we need more. We need to be able to move quickly, and I think every single member of the House recognizes that CMHC has not been able to deliver this on its own. That is why Build Canada Homes, given the space, the authorities, the capacity and the independence to be able to act, would do what we all need it to do.\n\nIt would unlock private capital, unlock the investors who are going to be able to partner with government, and unlock lands held by the federal government. It would enable all manner of groups and organizations that have land, but do not have the means to be able to develop it, to work with the federal government and to look at a portfolio approach across this country to develop housing where we need it most, in the communities that are in desperate need of this.\n\nThe legislation would transform positively the lives of Canadians, young Canadians and the people most in need. It would also make sure our communities are resilient, our cities are strong and rural Canada has what it deserves: the type of housing where we are going to see an increasing and growing need. I encourage every member of the House to support Bill C-20. I know that by moving forward on the legislation and by giving Build Canada Homes the space and the mandate it deserves, we would see the results that Canadians deserve from all of us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332225","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to begin not with a policy argument but with something more fundamental, a question that I think most Canadians are grappling with right now: Can the next generation afford to live in the communities they grew up? For too many Canadians, and certainly this is the case in my riding of Vancouver Granville, the answer is no. I think it is worth sitting with that for a moment befor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e01a393ce75371e147f08eaddc4ba65cdf176ca8565bce63327340dad31059cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5ba0c6d246bd42fe068e8fe114a90ae41870ee5ffbf23ad182d72c4e7f491f6c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dceace18f8aa64a1dc22e5dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332226,"date":"2026-03-13T15:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a very good question because it illustrates some of the information that I think people should have access to. \n\nAs each department has gone through and looked at their land inventories, that is one step in the process. There is also a process by which Build Canada Homes will ask pointed questions when inventories do not look like they line up with reality. I will give a good example of this. As we all know, there are Canada Post facilities across this country, some of which have been designated and some of which have not. There is going to be a process that the folks at Build Canada Homes will be certain to undertake to ensure that, where there is an opportunity to access those lands, they will.\n\n In my own riding, there are several pieces of land that the federal government owns that are now going to be part of the portfolio approach, including the Heather Lands, which is going to be an important development. \n\nIf we all look at those opportunities together, we will be able to achieve success.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332226","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a very good question because it illustrates some of the information that I think people should have access to. \n\nAs each department has gone through and looked at their land inventories, that is one step in the process. There is also a process by which Build Canada Homes will ask pointed questions when inventories do not look like they line up with reality. I will give a good ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8fdf7e26229c00ac88dae951ba2c488d863d36d4543c1c998691d001678e2f33"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd86cf35defe797ab531c698","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332227,"date":"2026-03-13T15:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in my opinion, this agreement between Quebec and Canada to work together within the Build Canada Homes framework should reassure my colleague that the Quebec government is committed to protecting the rights of Quebec and Quebeckers.\n\nWe can draw on Quebec's experience and capabilities to assure Quebeckers that the federal government's involvement in this matter will benefit Quebec. In fact, we can leverage all of Quebec's and the Quebec government's experience, authority, and capabilities to ensure that Quebeckers—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332227","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in my opinion, this agreement between Quebec and Canada to work together within the Build Canada Homes framework should reassure my colleague that the Quebec government is committed to protecting the rights of Quebec and Quebeckers.\n\nWe can draw on Quebec's experience and capabilities to assure Quebeckers that the federal government's involvement in this matter will benefit Quebec. In","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["59c8a9a46974e26f3c725f123bb97ea68e278b0d3004a3fd5aec8e2e69cc5821"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e88841bcb462b926622dab9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332228,"date":"2026-03-13T15:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. colleague for the amazing work that she does in that community.\n\n The example she presented is a perfect example of how community-led initiatives give government the priorities that it should be using. When we look at the types of projects that communities need, we see that communities know best what they need. By being able to work through the Build Canada Homes process, they will be able to put those projects at the fore as their priorities.\n\n This is one perfect example of that, and the more of this that we can do, the more communities will see that government partnering with them can deliver the types of results that they deserve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332228","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. colleague for the amazing work that she does in that community.\n\n The example she presented is a perfect example of how community-led initiatives give government the priorities that it should be using. When we look at the types of projects that communities need, we see that communities know best what they need. By being able to work through the Build Canada Homes proce","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c55e19a0d1cfac71e98a19dffaba06798a3dbd98d02aff2b79b26221dc2738d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe992f5587e88942cf595365","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":377416,"date":"2026-03-24T19:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, tomorrow Canadians will welcome His Highness Prince Rahim Aga Khan, the 50th hereditary imam of the Ismaili Muslims, to Canada. It is his first visit to Canada since his ascension to the imamate. \n\nCanada and the Ismaili imamate have a decades-long history of partnership and co-operation, built on shared values and a commitment to improving the quality of life of people around the world. This relationship transcends politics and reflects the best of Canada in action in some of the most challenging places across the globe. This visit by His Highness will serve to reaffirm that commitment and to find new ways to work together in a complex world, supporting development through economic progress, collaborating to address global issues like climate change and food security and building a stronger, more pluralistic Canada.\n\nFor Ismailis, this visit holds special significance as it will be an opportunity for thousands of people in our community to meet with our imam and to recommit ourselves to our values of kindness, compassion, spiritual search and working to build stronger societies in which everyone can belong. \n\nOn this important historic occasion, I know that all members in the House will join me in welcoming His Highness the Aga Khan to Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:377416","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, tomorrow Canadians will welcome His Highness Prince Rahim Aga Khan, the 50th hereditary imam of the Ismaili Muslims, to Canada. It is his first visit to Canada since his ascension to the imamate. \n\nCanada and the Ismaili imamate have a decades-long history of partnership and co-operation, built on shared values and a commitment to improving the quality of life of people around the wor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6029758e5b7434e8d56662742a12ae23522bd1a31f4e30b5033f4008d125f852"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a9a238a453f742ff00a310c32e80dd90828b410a26c15a941c3a73ffabd49a5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99a256cef76d84df856afac2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419783,"date":"2026-04-14T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our government has made it clear, first by appealing the decision and then by making clear statements that we not only stand for property rights but also defend them. \n\nThe concern here is that the opposition is not interested in the answer. What its members are interested in is fearmongering, spreading misinformation, driving mistrust in the market and creating economic uncertainty. That is what they are about. We are about making sure we are protecting property rights, building a strong economy and pursuing reconciliation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419783","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our government has made it clear, first by appealing the decision and then by making clear statements that we not only stand for property rights but also defend them. \n\nThe concern here is that the opposition is not interested in the answer. What its members are interested in is fearmongering, spreading misinformation, driving mistrust in the market and creating economic uncertainty. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47720","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Marketing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47720","label":"Marketing","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["37e372e59c2eda1a4187fc96f3c5989aaf5009a95828112066597d8b23cf016d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-104ba0a17600a6267d4d74fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419779,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for Hull—Aylmer.\n\nI am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill C-22, an act respecting lawful access.\n\nI want to start by asking two questions that I think Canadians are rightly asking.\n\nThe first is this: Are we meeting the moment when it comes to investigating crimes in a digital world? The tools that criminals use today, including encrypted communications, cryptocurrency and transnational digital networks, did not exist five years ago the way that they do now and certainly not at the scale at which they exist now. The crimes have not changed. Child exploitation is real and still exists in our world. Organized crime has not changed, and fentanyl trafficking is still there. What has changed, however, is how these crimes are carried out and the degree to which our existing investigative tools simply cannot keep pace.\n\nThe second question is just as important: Are we doing this in a way that protects the privacy of Canadians? If the answer to the first question comes at the expense of the second, then we have not done our job.\n\nBill C-22 seeks to answer both questions.\n\nI think it is important to walk through what the legislation would do because there has been a lot of confusion and misinformation about what is being proposed. Bill C-22 has two parts that would work together. Part 1 would modernize legal authorities that law enforcement and CSIS need to investigate crimes in a digital environment. Part 2, the supporting authorized access to information act, would establish the technical requirements for electronic service providers, companies like our major telcos, to be able to comply with existing court-authorized processes. I want to emphasize the word \"existing\". The bill would not create new surveillance powers, new intercept authorities or back doors into any one system. It would make the court-authorized processes that we already have, warrants and production orders, which are tools that have always required judicial oversight, functional in a world that has moved online.\n\nRight now, if a judge were to issue a production order for evidence held by a service provider, there is no regulatory framework in Canada that requires the provider to have the technical capability to comply. I would ask us all to think about that for a moment. A judge can authorize access to evidence, but the system to carry that out may not exist. That is the gap this bill seeks to close.\n\nFolks may ask, \"Why now?\" The answer is simple: The gap between criminal capability and law enforcement capability is widening, not narrowing. Two Supreme Court decisions, R. v. Spencer and R. v. Bykovets, have brought important clarity to the legal landscape around digital investigations. In Spencer, the court confirmed that police need a warrant to obtain basic subscriber information. In Bykovets, the court extended that principle to IP addresses. These rulings affirmed something important: Canadians have a reasonable expectation of privacy in their digital lives. This bill would respect that.\n\nThose decisions also made clear how outdated our existing legislative framework really is. The law as it stands was not built to function in a world where, rightly, judicial authorization is required at these stages. Without the proper tools to operate within that reality efficiently, investigations are slowing at precisely the moments when timeliness matters the most.\n\nHere is a practical reality. When police are investigating a serious crime, such as a child exploitation case, an extortion ring or an active threat, and have a court-authorized production order in hand, they still need to know which service provider holds the relevant data. Under the current framework, they cannot even ask that question. They cannot confirm whether a provider services a particular IP address, not the subscriber's identity, just whether the provider has any connection to that address at all. If they serve the order on the wrong provider, they have to start all over again. Meanwhile, evidence degrades, trails go cold and, in some cases, kids remain at risk.\n\nThat is the gap I am talking about. It is not hypothetical; it is playing out in investigations across the country, and it is costing us time that we simply do not have.\n\nWe are the only Five Eyes country and the only G7 member without a modernized lawful access framework. What that means practically is that Canadian law enforcement has had to rely on international partners to do what we should have been able to do ourselves. That is simply not a sustainable position for a country that takes both public safety and sovereignty seriously.\n\nWe also need to have the conversation about whatever concerns exist about privacy.\n\nI would ask members to look carefully at how this bill is structured, because I think that when we do, we see something that should give Canadians confidence. The principle at the heart of this bill is proportionality. The level of oversight is calibrated to the level of intrusion. The more information one is seeking and the more it touches the privacy of an individual, the higher the bar that has to be cleared. Most Canadians, I believe, would agree with that instinct.\n\nLet us walk through what that might look like in practice. At the most basic level, there is confirmation of service demand, which is a threshold question. It asks, does this particular provider service this IP address or phone number, yes or no? There are no subscriber details, no content, no further information. This simply tells investigators whether they are knocking on the door of the right service provider. Because it reveals so little, it does not require a warrant. We are not learning anything about a person. We are learning whether a company has a connection to an identifier.\n\nThe next step is the subscriber information production order. Now we are asking for something that starts to identify a person, such as a name, an address, a phone number or an email address. This is more intrusive, so, appropriately, it requires the consent or the authorization of a justice or a judge. However, it is still narrower than a general production order, because we are not seeking content or communications, just the basic identifiers that allow an investigation to proceed. Then, when an investigator needs access to the content of communication or more detailed data, the full weight of the existing production order and warrant process applies, such as judicial authorization and full oversight. These are the same protections that have always existed under Canadian law.\n\nEach step up in what the police ask for comes with a corresponding step up in the scrutiny that is applied. The oversight is proportionate to the invasiveness. I would suggest that this is not just good policy. It is in line with what the courts have told us about privacy and privacy interests in a digital context. The courts have said that these things engage privacy. This bill seeks to address the instructions of the court. It builds a system where the protections match the intrusions.\n\nI want to speak briefly to the safeguards, because they reflect something important about how this bill came together. Earlier proposals around lawful access raised legitimate questions. The government's members heard those concerns. We went back and refined our approach. The definition of subscriber information was narrowed to basic identifiers. Ministerial orders under part 2 are now subject to approval by the intelligence commissioner. Data retention requirements are limited to metadata only and for a maximum of one year, and the bill explicitly excludes content, web browsing history and social media activity.\n\nThese are not small refinements. They are the product of careful work to get the balance right. The bill also includes mandatory public reporting in a parliamentary review three years after royal assent. I think we have an obligation to build that kind of transparency into any legislation that touches on investigative power, and this bill does exactly that.\n\nI would like to end with what matters to me as a dad, what should matter to all of us, because what matters is at stake. The crimes that depend most heavily on digital infrastructure, such as child exploitation, extortion, human trafficking and money laundering, are precisely the crimes where law enforcement currently lack the tools to investigate effectively.\n\nThe Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police has called for the modernization of our lawful access regime. The Canadian Centre for Child Protection has supported the advancement of this bill. The National Police Federation has recognized that this legislation is a long-overdue modernization that protects the rights of Canadians while keeping them safe. When law enforcement and child protection organizations are telling us the same thing, we have a responsibility to act, not recklessly, but deliberately, and with the kind of care that this bill reflects. Responsible governance means modernizing our tools while respecting the rights of Canadians, not one at the expense of the other, but both together.\n\nBill C-22 gives law enforcement the investigative tools that they need to combat serious crimes, while ensuring that the privacy of Canadians is protected through judicial oversight, proportioned authorities and robust accountability. It is built within the charter. It responds to the jurisprudence of the Supreme Court, and it closes a gap that has left Canada behind every one of its Five Eyes allies and G7 partners. This is how we keep Canadians safe, not by standing still while the world moves forward, but by keeping pace with the threats and the values that define us.\n\nI urge all members to support this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419779","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for Hull—Aylmer.\n\nI am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill C-22, an act respecting lawful access.\n\nI want to start by asking two questions that I think Canadians are rightly asking.\n\nThe first is this: Are we meeting the moment when it comes to investigating crimes in a digital world? The tools that criminals use today, including encrypted ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db21e4aaf12a8412ac2c7ff131d1e53e28b03757397878085bb16b8626b08260"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["720d1154b81972e5cf9d802af30f2dcadbd3cae80db3b917010a5f1111c2e80b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d54126f12518153a349c6ea3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419780,"date":"2026-04-15T22:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for the work he has put in, and for his advocacy on behalf of his citizens and, of course, all Canadians when it comes to matters of public safety.\n\nThe reality is that this bill works precisely within the limitations of the law. It works within the instructions of the court and ensures that the rights of Canadians are protected. That includes their privacy rights. It includes ensuring that the appropriate information is or is not disclosed within the bounds of what is acceptable in this country. \n\n I would argue that one of the challenges we will always have in dealing with legislation like this is the question of whether seeking perfection is preventing us from getting done what is necessary and right in this moment. I believe this bill addresses those concerns and the concerns of my friend across. He should feel confident, as should Canadians, in this response from the government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419780","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for the work he has put in, and for his advocacy on behalf of his citizens and, of course, all Canadians when it comes to matters of public safety.\n\nThe reality is that this bill works precisely within the limitations of the law. It works within the instructions of the court and ensures that the rights of Canadians are protected. That includes their privac","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9debaa502e1add2f1b6537ec941c31580ad556f8bc6ccea697546e881aed090c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-994d3705e6e595497d7031ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419781,"date":"2026-04-15T22:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the law is clear in that regard. We need to create an environment where service providers must work with and help law enforcement in a way that respects the law. \n\nAs the member opposite knows, it is important to make sure these definitions are clear and correct. This bill does that. It makes sure that the folks who are in the positions to provide that information, the service providers, know exactly what their responsibilities are and, within the constructs, are able to do the work and have the capacity to do what is required to address the needs of local police.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419781","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the law is clear in that regard. We need to create an environment where service providers must work with and help law enforcement in a way that respects the law. \n\nAs the member opposite knows, it is important to make sure these definitions are clear and correct. This bill does that. It makes sure that the folks who are in the positions to provide that information, the service provide","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a3611d3e13edb62c88ad3e236146cec535b27044bc142c7298531d912e8bb71"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6eae04dc7e57873969df86e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419782,"date":"2026-04-15T22:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I said in my speech, this bill represents exactly that. It reflects the changing reality that we are currently facing. This bill is designed to protect rights while providing responsible support to law enforcement in a digital environment that has become very complex. It reflects both the desire and the need to take significant yet responsible action for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419782","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I said in my speech, this bill represents exactly that. It reflects the changing reality that we are currently facing. This bill is designed to protect rights while providing responsible support to law enforcement in a digital environment that has become very complex. It reflects both the desire and the need to take significant yet responsible action for Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d901886c412f59613ff68bbdf3e33f25eb5533d3aff06224abe70fdf94f3187"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a685719bd9b0b5ace837c5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104395,"date":"2026-04-16T16:20:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to both our witnesses for being here. Perhaps I can begin with you, Ambassador. One thing that I think is an important framing for all of us is that the Prime Minister described this moment in China-Canada relations as a \"turning point\". From your experience as the ambassador in Beijing, how significant is this reset? What doors does it open that have been closed? What safeguards and guardrails do you see are in place now to help make sure this relationship is one that respects the way in which Canada works to see the world right now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104395","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to both our witnesses for being here. Perhaps I can begin with you, Ambassador. One thing that I think is an important framing for all of us is that the Prime Minister described this moment in China-Canada relations as a \"turning point\". From your experience as the ambassador in Beijing, how significant is this reset? What doors does it open that have been closed?","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92b40f31cd463e912076d2c6399abcb8b856927f721a47f02fa52869665c1bd1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04fe9f7dd588de769405bd35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104396,"date":"2026-04-16T16:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Ambassador, if I could, I'll turn to the issue of the EV sector. One thing we've come to accept is that, thanks to the way the U.S. has taken decisions, there's been a massive impact on the auto industry in this country. Auto production, as my friends from Ontario would know, has gone from three million vehicles in 2000 to just shy of 1.3 million in 2025. What are the ways to attract Chinese EV joint ventures? You're hearing some of the comments out of Magna and others. How is that going to potentially help employment and manufacturing in this country? How does it help bolster our manufacturing sector at a time when the reliability of the United States as a partner is diminished and may or may not return to the level it used to be?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104396","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Ambassador, if I could, I'll turn to the issue of the EV sector. One thing we've come to accept is that, thanks to the way the U.S. has taken decisions, there's been a massive impact on the auto industry in this country. Auto production, as my friends from Ontario would know, has gone from three million vehicles in 2000 to just shy of 1.3 million in 2025. What are the ways to attract Chinese EV jo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7fe28077877a275ab9934203b4a87722ab2186605b43ba4d19c521ad8f75b37a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cf7555d74c868f1fb158c716f727ac456d8295cac6e304a348af1accd4d9887c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f84e0cfec582a5002a2e920","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104397,"date":"2026-04-16T16:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Can we take this a step further? We know Canada has the resources needed to compete in the EV market. We have ample access to zero-emission electricity. We have access to critical minerals. How do we turn those natural advantages into assets for negotiating with Chinese automakers when it comes time to look at building in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104397","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can we take this a step further? We know Canada has the resources needed to compete in the EV market. We have ample access to zero-emission electricity. We have access to critical minerals. How do we turn those natural advantages into assets for negotiating with Chinese automakers when it comes time to look at building in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b10589a7bf0cf0160f0f1a0a12bc8bf2062a9bd5ac77d705e144bb177ec12880"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd7e8049ada7d751e0960e66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104398,"date":"2026-04-16T16:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Mr. Kovrig, it's good to see you again. Just to pick up where my colleague left off, you've been remarkably clear that despite what you personally endured, countries need to find ways to move forward and figure out where their relationships need to go. Given that framing, what would a well-designed reset with China look like in the context of where we are today, in the context of the reality that Canada is facing with the United States, where increasingly we are seeing that cleave continues to grow and not come closer? Is there a version of a China-Canada engagement on EVs that you would be able to support, I suppose?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104398","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Kovrig, it's good to see you again. Just to pick up where my colleague left off, you've been remarkably clear that despite what you personally endured, countries need to find ways to move forward and figure out where their relationships need to go. Given that framing, what would a well-designed reset with China look like in the context of where we are today, in the context of the reality that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13d69ae3bc6d3e4dfc17a789741903a4f063572492db12f42bbf0c1565d5a383"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cbf184ee47c347690afbdd63bea50cac114d16dd76699353d21f7222d0826f02"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-deb0ebf9f4b54dd9beae75bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104399,"date":"2026-04-16T16:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"If you were to dig into that and you were to look at these sectors where there are opportunities.... You've discussed some of those—for example, agriculture. There are opportunities around EVs, critical minerals, and so on and so forth. In the context of the safeguards around Chinese EVs, Canada has effectively gone to where Europe has gone in terms of the safeguards and in terms of the issues relating to data protection. Would that not then align with exactly what you said in respect of working with like-minded countries to ensure that when we are trading, even though conversations may be bilateral, that the context is multilateral and the context is then predicated on what others with like-minded values and like-minded circumstances have actually either done or are doing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104399","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If you were to dig into that and you were to look at these sectors where there are opportunities.... You've discussed some of those—for example, agriculture. There are opportunities around EVs, critical minerals, and so on and so forth. In the context of the safeguards around Chinese EVs, Canada has effectively gone to where Europe has gone in terms of the safeguards and in terms of the issues rel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2453b1f444afda0469b16fbb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104400,"date":"2026-04-16T17:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"On that basis, going back to EVs because that is the topic of this study.... We could have a much longer conversation about geopolitics and the other challenges we face, but if we come back to this question of EVs and talk about like-minded countries, I don't think there's anybody in this room from any side who isn't clear about the desire of certain Chinese auto manufacturers and others in that ecosystem to ensure that they have global dominance. This is what we have seen with what the Americans tried to do with their auto sector in years past, and so forth. Having spent time in Europe, I was shocked to see the number of BYDs on the road and the excitement with which people in those countries are using their Chinese EVs. How has Europe managed this issue in terms of their own manufacturing and their own auto sectors? They seem to have found a balance, or they appear to have found a balance.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104400","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"On that basis, going back to EVs because that is the topic of this study.... We could have a much longer conversation about geopolitics and the other challenges we face, but if we come back to this question of EVs and talk about like-minded countries, I don't think there's anybody in this room from any side who isn't clear about the desire of certain Chinese auto manufacturers and others in that e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb44c79be103fd49d4a8000173fdb24b67b3d2ec7f0f193b70d2f8a59b81c881"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-986e467ff6a1fdb343343a27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419778,"date":"2026-04-17T16:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear about a few things. First of all, our government has been opposed to the B.C. Supreme Court decision, which is why we are appealing that decision. However, let us also understand a few other things. Not a single negotiation, not a single agreement with a first nation since the 1970s has resulted in a single Canadian losing any of their private property.\n\nThe Conservatives are fearmongering, they are spreading misinformation and they are causing disruption in the economy of British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419778","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear about a few things. First of all, our government has been opposed to the B.C. Supreme Court decision, which is why we are appealing that decision. However, let us also understand a few other things. Not a single negotiation, not a single agreement with a first nation since the 1970s has resulted in a single Canadian losing any of their private property.\n\nThe Conservati","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1d8832ba86b5cef5d2a36f1969311c708cb3da71ff0c61367740e4b87b88bdfd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6105474d1abc948bc65eb0d0a11d385647b89f0178fdff3e552e2ef989454ac5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccc2740bb3d1a77af6134a11","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104401,"date":"2026-04-20T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you to our witnesses for being here. You know, I remember a time when my Conservative colleagues across the way were cheering when Stephen Harper oversaw and in fact stood with glee as Huawei signed an agreement to provide telecommunications integrated services in Canada. I remember when the Harper government signed a customs agreement in 2014. I don't hear those concerns. In fact, I also remember the 31-year FIPA deal that the Harper government signed in 2014, so it's interesting to see my friends opposite now all upset that we are trying to do the best we can to help create opportunities for Canadian workers. Mr. Kingston, it's good to see you again, as always. How many jobs has the auto sector lost since Trump started imposing tariffs on Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104401","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to our witnesses for being here. You know, I remember a time when my Conservative colleagues across the way were cheering when Stephen Harper oversaw and in fact stood with glee as Huawei signed an agreement to provide telecommunications integrated services in Canada. I remember when the Harper government signed a customs agreement in 2014. I don't hear those concerns. In fact, I also re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a1639d49e6416d0eb320c5c60cd0f2a2b08c6ec4569ea1ff93a58c7f4d145647"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f92306e8b78361ec56fe153f9c65e7f7c1001af299520be0c3ce6c562d4a6172"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76aa56a161eb7e4a5a504fd3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104402,"date":"2026-04-20T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"How many would you say that is?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104402","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How many would you say that is?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-536352e6641331bb90ad02f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104403,"date":"2026-04-20T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104403","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab0be8099321492dfef597ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104404,"date":"2026-04-20T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"It's down 5%. How much investment has been made by U.S. automakers in Canada in the last two years?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104404","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's down 5%. How much investment has been made by U.S. automakers in Canada in the last two years?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd83e093a7e2bc6b9717c5ab89f20ad014d5dc92f56d3f204be23cf89b23dbc0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0bdc3e3926c3108794dd8464","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104405,"date":"2026-04-20T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104405","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b8e6824cdccfe3f25516f3b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104406,"date":"2026-04-20T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Ford is a member of your organization. Is that right?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104406","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Ford is a member of your organization. Is that right?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c203691bf6ef98b8a66fed2a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104407,"date":"2026-04-20T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Are you concerned about their partnership with Changan?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104407","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are you concerned about their partnership with Changan?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b02fede598d0cd0b4fd4863","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104408,"date":"2026-04-20T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Are you concerned about their JV with Changan in China?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104408","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are you concerned about their JV with Changan in China?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["70a35180932bb463dd2a0c139a34336e20075ffd276d83b9287c0691aeaee0bd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50c7d8c2b9375abc9090981e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104409,"date":"2026-04-20T21:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Yes, their partnership with Changan, or the GM partnership with SAIC or the Stellantis-Leapmotor partnership.... Do you have the same concerns about the fact that your members are entering into JVs with the very same types of manufacturers that we are concerned about bringing to Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104409","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, their partnership with Changan, or the GM partnership with SAIC or the Stellantis-Leapmotor partnership.... Do you have the same concerns about the fact that your members are entering into JVs with the very same types of manufacturers that we are concerned about bringing to Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","label":"Interprovincial relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8981b4cd9687e5697c185a096a4f5bfd71929fcecdbbf882474e67cf7563af10"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e79ccc658c3dd2614122e672","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104410,"date":"2026-04-20T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Mr. Kingston, there are conditions, and you know there are conditions. In fact, there are conditions around a whole variety of different parts of this, including around ensuring that the same types of security frameworks that were put in place by the Europeans are put in place in Canada. There are agreements to procure Canadian goods. How do we think about the auto sector in this country if we are entirely dependent on U.S. manufacturers alone? Should we not be looking at the world and bringing people here to manufacture, as an opportunity for Canada and Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104410","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Kingston, there are conditions, and you know there are conditions. In fact, there are conditions around a whole variety of different parts of this, including around ensuring that the same types of security frameworks that were put in place by the Europeans are put in place in Canada. There are agreements to procure Canadian goods. How do we think about the auto sector in this country if we are","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4aba6fc991958019f42cc161","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104411,"date":"2026-04-20T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"You've heard Trump say he doesn't want the U.S. to buy cars made in Canada. You've already heard this directly from the President of the United States. Should we not be looking at options for Canadian auto workers and Canadian supply chains?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104411","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You've heard Trump say he doesn't want the U.S. to buy cars made in Canada. You've already heard this directly from the President of the United States. Should we not be looking at options for Canadian auto workers and Canadian supply chains?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd69625d2291f7b30fe2ee08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104412,"date":"2026-04-20T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"The question I would ask you, then, is this: How do you negotiate in good faith with a U.S. administration that keeps changing the rules of the game on Canada? You represent the auto sector, auto manufacturers in this country. How do you negotiate in an environment where, day to day, the rules change, if you don't also look at ways to bring investment and to create opportunities for Canada and Canadians at the same time as increasing affordability for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104412","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The question I would ask you, then, is this: How do you negotiate in good faith with a U.S. administration that keeps changing the rules of the game on Canada? You represent the auto sector, auto manufacturers in this country. How do you negotiate in an environment where, day to day, the rules change, if you don't also look at ways to bring investment and to create opportunities for Canada and Can","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ffbf5ef62efd3fae34f2dbd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104413,"date":"2026-04-20T21:15:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Let's just be clear on one thing. You mentioned that there were no security requirements. Every car that comes in has to meet Canadian standards of security. Bill C-8 and PIPEDA both give us those tools. Do they not?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104413","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Let's just be clear on one thing. You mentioned that there were no security requirements. Every car that comes in has to meet Canadian standards of security. Bill C-8 and PIPEDA both give us those tools. Do they not?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6b42748e6fb7c83ecf7b6dd82e9b4d5eba595579d43077ed68c90020316082ed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a6e5ebe35ae394ebb121aeaa76227dc54bcc02b8ef48bd126f9346d59f04b35"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4768bb75c1742ca82b8eabf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104414,"date":"2026-04-23T16:20:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I want to thank all the witnesses for being here. I want to begin by saying that I have, for a very long time, like others from all parties, been deeply concerned about workers' rights—not selectively. I think issues that many have raised in China and other parts of the world are real concerns that we should be mindful of in the agreements that we strike and in the way that we position conversations that we have. I'm sorry, Professor McCuaig-Johnston, for the challenges that you are now dealing with. I want to bring us back to the conversation that we are having here about domestic issues related to Chinese EVs and their sale in Canada. I also want to talk a little bit about the broader question of data, because you and a couple of other witnesses have mentioned data, the ability of cars to be taken over, and so on and so forth. We've heard from Mr. Shipley about the issues related to cars being taken over and these challenges. Professor McCuaig-Johnston, are you concerned about Polestar 2s that were sold in Canada prior to 2025?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104414","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to thank all the witnesses for being here. I want to begin by saying that I have, for a very long time, like others from all parties, been deeply concerned about workers' rights—not selectively. I think issues that many have raised in China and other parts of the world are real concerns that we should be mindful of in the agreements that we strike and in the way that we position conversatio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9c7b4a9a316ad06f51c5e451471002b7c21def397fc061750c2436542c4ac10b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["299c2a3e657ec24b0535f99ae99be50b5914f8f9a145ca8d43b6acd94d9b4967"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e075b258e864e12dd0d73961","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104415,"date":"2026-04-23T16:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"The Polestar 2s were manufactured in China and were sold in Canada prior to the 100% tariffs and then were no longer sold in Canada as part of the agreement or the JV with Voler and those cars. Should we be concerned about cars that were manufactured prior to 2025 as well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104415","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Polestar 2s were manufactured in China and were sold in Canada prior to the 100% tariffs and then were no longer sold in Canada as part of the agreement or the JV with Voler and those cars. Should we be concerned about cars that were manufactured prior to 2025 as well?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","label":"Maple products","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8df8d083dffee6cfe256ba98076992eb2e33fcdb3250247911ada1d806ed0466"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a49d21d6db34c2c10d92fa9962c984f7dcf005aa56be687380c4c1c96ac396b8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63eb9994589085a3a1f36526","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104416,"date":"2026-04-23T16:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Digging into the question of data, given the complexity of Canada's relationship with the U.S. right now, given the ownership structure of Tesla and given Elon Musk's relationships, for example, with the U.S. government and with U.S. government decisions in respect to data that is stored in the U.S., should Canadians be equally concerned about information that their Tesla might be gathering that will then be living on U.S. servers that the U.S. government could access, if it so chooses, under the CLOUD Act?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104416","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Digging into the question of data, given the complexity of Canada's relationship with the U.S. right now, given the ownership structure of Tesla and given Elon Musk's relationships, for example, with the U.S. government and with U.S. government decisions in respect to data that is stored in the U.S., should Canadians be equally concerned about information that their Tesla might be gathering that w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d723819c8f9bf7981f8e22ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104417,"date":"2026-04-23T16:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I'm talking about the ones that are already in Canada. That Tesla data is stored on U.S. servers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104417","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm talking about the ones that are already in Canada. That Tesla data is stored on U.S. servers.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["531fdc756c6e1c0a74156a796b4008a01b8b92abacdfcd88e7db8995cce86b99"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0502a7745688f63dc8246312","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104418,"date":"2026-04-23T16:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Obviously, requirements under PIPEDA apply to any vehicles, any software and any data that is collected and stored in Canada. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104418","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Obviously, requirements under PIPEDA apply to any vehicles, any software and any data that is collected and stored in Canada. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Alternative fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Software","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718410","label":"Software","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","label":"Alternative fuels","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48ba16af6de0b1d083285dc24e0093665dacaab88351b7e14ff4adcbcfe8fea2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7da9af9926b562601d18a476","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104419,"date":"2026-04-23T16:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"PIPEDA applies to all transactions being done in Canada, whether it's data collected or so on and so forth. That, to my understanding, applies to any EVs, theoretically Chinese and others, that come to Canada. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104419","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"PIPEDA applies to all transactions being done in Canada, whether it's data collected or so on and so forth. That, to my understanding, applies to any EVs, theoretically Chinese and others, that come to Canada. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transborder data flow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037238","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Streams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","label":"Data processing","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037238","label":"Streams","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","label":"Transborder data flow","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d150fd1cedf1bb6f8a2bb8e63882b6b0eaa14c7f77a62a68c2e0f60ee0bbf9c5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3433a96163d490d0fe151358","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104420,"date":"2026-04-23T16:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Okay. The agreement, if it does.... I think this is one of the things that we need to dissect a bit, because I want to make sure, like you, that Canadians are kept safe. There are several separate issues. One is, of course, the issue related to labour and China. There's the issue related to making sure we're protecting jobs in this country and the issues related to how Canadian data is stored. I want to make sure that in these conversations, all of which are important, we're not conflating one with the other and vice versa. Sometimes we have a tendency in short spurts of questions to try to conflate one with the other. For me, there are really three batches of things that we need to interrogate. One is obviously the issues related to labour in this country and in China. There's the issue of jobs in this country versus the export of jobs to others. The third, then, is the issue of data. When it comes to the privacy protections of Canadians, this is something that has come up in previous conversations. There's been an acknowledgement that privacy laws in this country should apply and do apply to any vehicles that are imported. I would observe and I would consider that under the agreement we have to bring in the 49,000 Chinese EVs, this applies to them as well. We should all, I think, take a moment to figure that out, because I think it does then address that particular piece of the conversation. When we go to the issue of jobs in this country—I would pose this to you, Professor McCuaig-Johnston and then to Mr. Shipley—the reality is that vehicles made in this country have components that have come, fortunately or otherwise, from different places, whether it's the U.S. or it's China, and so on and so forth, and those components go into Canadian-made vehicles. Canadian-made auto jobs right now are not growing. Is there an opportunity for us to work with Chinese manufacturers to create jobs in this country? Do you think that's something that as a government we should be looking at?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104420","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. The agreement, if it does.... I think this is one of the things that we need to dissect a bit, because I want to make sure, like you, that Canadians are kept safe. There are several separate issues. One is, of course, the issue related to labour and China. There's the issue related to making sure we're protecting jobs in this country and the issues related to how Canadian data is stored. I w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca2afd69f67d2773c85aab7d231a17faf9f7caaf4e73373a90af33e816332427"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9b57697ac2aa84913288621d8c45485fdcbc92fd108df9a6d848e822da4ec5f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c3a2203539f2dadd7600b4a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104421,"date":"2026-04-23T16:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I'd like my three minutes. I want to make sure I don't lose my three minutes. I still have—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104421","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like my three minutes. I want to make sure I don't lose my three minutes. I still have—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035305","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fitness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035305","label":"Fitness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","label":"Safety education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["17855b634fa25b308ca540ddf2e6258bfc40301ce1fbb2d8523a6bc8989ddb7b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65716e134b9a07c9a33736ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104422,"date":"2026-04-23T16:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I was going to offer a suggestion. If Professor McCuaig-Johnston is still here, why don't we take a minute during the break to try to resolve this amongst ourselves and see how best to do it? I want to make sure we hear from the other witnesses. I recognize that my colleague might want more time with the professor, but I suspect that we're probably better to solve it in a natural conversation rather than try to do it like this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104422","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I was going to offer a suggestion. If Professor McCuaig-Johnston is still here, why don't we take a minute during the break to try to resolve this amongst ourselves and see how best to do it? I want to make sure we hear from the other witnesses. I recognize that my colleague might want more time with the professor, but I suspect that we're probably better to solve it in a natural conversation rath","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21e8006b9cd9d7152b78669d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104423,"date":"2026-04-23T17:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"It feels so long ago, but I just want to go back to where we were. I want to go back to this conversation about data, Professor McCuaig-Johnston and Mr. Shipley, and about the concerns Canadians should have about data storage writ large. We've talked about EVs. Professor, should we be concerned about other smart devices in our homes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104423","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It feels so long ago, but I just want to go back to where we were. I want to go back to this conversation about data, Professor McCuaig-Johnston and Mr. Shipley, and about the concerns Canadians should have about data storage writ large. We've talked about EVs. Professor, should we be concerned about other smart devices in our homes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be492543d2d1e9cf8f944bcf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104424,"date":"2026-04-23T17:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Wouldn't you be concerned about a device in your home that's capturing video 24-7?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104424","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Wouldn't you be concerned about a device in your home that's capturing video 24-7?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cefb02026fb9bdd88e0788424ec20db800ff7f4af0038c9f3e3f8755ca83b1aa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76cb1c6b9badf25c946ab9dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104425,"date":"2026-04-23T17:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"You would have been concerned, then, about the deal that Prime Minister Harper signed between Huawei and Telus, which he presided over. You would have been concerned about that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104425","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You would have been concerned, then, about the deal that Prime Minister Harper signed between Huawei and Telus, which he presided over. You would have been concerned about that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af9638d125d5cac3de17c877c13808d85375b55b238871aca95b6c255562bc47"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6da1f5d369c6c1ae97559c4f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104426,"date":"2026-04-23T17:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"You went to that effort to make sure you did not have Chinese equipment as part of your home surveillance devices. Should Canadians, then, not be concerned about those types of things as well? Whether it's a scale or the Amazon Fire TV Stick my colleague opposite tried to give to the member of Parliament, which you were concerned about earlier, these are all devices made in China that are in our homes, collecting data all the time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104426","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You went to that effort to make sure you did not have Chinese equipment as part of your home surveillance devices. Should Canadians, then, not be concerned about those types of things as well? Whether it's a scale or the Amazon Fire TV Stick my colleague opposite tried to give to the member of Parliament, which you were concerned about earlier, these are all devices made in China that are in our h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-801a82d73245891cd8e5bd58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104427,"date":"2026-04-23T17:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"That's all vehicles. To be fair, my vehicle not made in China also downloads that information from my phone, but that can happen on the cloud all the time. Does it not?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104427","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's all vehicles. To be fair, my vehicle not made in China also downloads that information from my phone, but that can happen on the cloud all the time. Does it not?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["553216d6de018406ad3cd35b947548db8f64d993b102f2e2a56864597d907d36"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f55bea779c24ad0697ecaf0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104428,"date":"2026-04-23T17:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"The U.S. CLOUD Act gives the U.S. government certain provisions, protections and access to data that is held on U.S. servers. That includes data of Canadian citizens, which is captured on all manner of devices, including, for example, certain devices that may be made in China but which are owned by U.S. companies and powered by U.S. businesses. Does that not also concern you?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104428","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The U.S. CLOUD Act gives the U.S. government certain provisions, protections and access to data that is held on U.S. servers. That includes data of Canadian citizens, which is captured on all manner of devices, including, for example, certain devices that may be made in China but which are owned by U.S. companies and powered by U.S. businesses. Does that not also concern you?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034613","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034613","label":"Computers","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5aaaef52af6ef536175e0466e68e2b8e20974861c347a6ed11a0673b35e76eff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64ea1af5b3cba5185d62d0249d543fee8495b482fb7a6eb247c615a5eeab40ff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1ebae6d04c61df62c5cd9a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104429,"date":"2026-04-23T17:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"This is where I'm confused. You're concerned about EVs but not about the devices we have in our homes that our kids are exposed to every single day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104429","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This is where I'm confused. You're concerned about EVs but not about the devices we have in our homes that our kids are exposed to every single day.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","label":"Household equipment","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9cbb65aa4f5de3f2916cfe59de275cbe1def99cca46505bf05438bc168e02575"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ae59f2688d1bdb61149959b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104430,"date":"2026-04-23T17:50:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"We have, theoretically, seven minutes left. In that time, we need to be able to do scheduling, I presume. We have a question from Maxime that needs to be addressed. How do we propose to do all of this in seven minutes? What can we reasonably do in seven minutes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104430","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We have, theoretically, seven minutes left. In that time, we need to be able to do scheduling, I presume. We have a question from Maxime that needs to be addressed. How do we propose to do all of this in seven minutes? What can we reasonably do in seven minutes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3a6399c63d86383db0188d8c896bf68c860c2adc911dd3c50db92551cd6dc74c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d60e4a4fcbf4b652a3a83fb5a0c464130fca0437a002fde69b84650229fc6b3c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f9cbd554830a04b50d2721f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104431,"date":"2026-04-23T17:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"As we come to an end, I wanted to raise something that came up earlier in the committee. Thus far, I think we have managed to work in a reasonably collegial, collaborative format. A couple of members have expressed some concern over some reasonably unparliamentary language that was used, in particular a comment that was made about somebody who may or may not consider switching teams, which folks were pretty offended by. Among us, I wonder if there's a way we could try to— An hon. member: [ Inaudible—Editor ] Taleeb Noormohamed: I don't think it was very much on the record. That's part of the challenge.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104431","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As we come to an end, I wanted to raise something that came up earlier in the committee. Thus far, I think we have managed to work in a reasonably collegial, collaborative format. A couple of members have expressed some concern over some reasonably unparliamentary language that was used, in particular a comment that was made about somebody who may or may not consider switching teams, which folks w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af9ca300639f6abbb0c94694","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104432,"date":"2026-04-23T18:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Madam Chair, from a scheduling standpoint, we have the last meeting on EVs coming up. The meeting after that is going to be presumably the draft reports. God willing, we get through all of the draft reports in that meeting, inshallah. If not, then off we go to the next one. Assuming we do, then we have break weeks. We would have two meetings on this study, and then would we go to the science advisers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104432","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Chair, from a scheduling standpoint, we have the last meeting on EVs coming up. The meeting after that is going to be presumably the draft reports. God willing, we get through all of the draft reports in that meeting, inshallah. If not, then off we go to the next one. Assuming we do, then we have break weeks. We would have two meetings on this study, and then would we go to the science advis","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8a3d613aec9bf66d2dafff4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104433,"date":"2026-04-23T18:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"My point is that it seems once we finish with the advisers, we have two more meetings left on the upcoming study and then we're pretty much done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104433","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My point is that it seems once we finish with the advisers, we have two more meetings left on the upcoming study and then we're pretty much done.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9072fcb11cc82a28ab369307b2d098a2b3dd5f3627dd9a92c3f2d0dbe565cec"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4aea91a3b7a542ac039e7fa1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104434,"date":"2026-04-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I thank the witnesses for coming. Ms. Goldfeder, can you tell me how many GM employees have lost their jobs over the last two years?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104434","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I thank the witnesses for coming. Ms. Goldfeder, can you tell me how many GM employees have lost their jobs over the last two years?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47600","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Genetically modified organisms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47600","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Genetically modified organisms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47600","label":"Genetically modified organisms","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f9ee8ce7b6db16cb9b510e88398a261d5faff714b7cce02f4bae931cf7a07e8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3a6d66a210670e47a7137bbb5ed897cb02ec1809461dc949ce2f39b4cd058bff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10a3c363eb6422f87734f81e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104435,"date":"2026-04-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"What is the reason for the indefinite layoff?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104435","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What is the reason for the indefinite layoff?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4537ad8276b5b853d4753d5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104436,"date":"2026-04-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I'm asking about employees across the company in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104436","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm asking about employees across the company in Canada.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d1b3a256578286bc5cfc92d64991fb82b181c427abb5ec758f571461a5c943b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-579e306c76ab6be5f416087f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104437,"date":"2026-04-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"That's not what I asked you. I asked you how many GM employees have lost their jobs in Canada over the last couple of years.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104437","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's not what I asked you. I asked you how many GM employees have lost their jobs in Canada over the last couple of years.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a547cf8cea0850ec898418d408132d1d187cbbeecac5ce2cf4336174f370a9fe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97d39d70acbcc2031921cdfa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104438,"date":"2026-04-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Why was that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104438","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Why was that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b3f9d64efae2c30cfac1ae7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104439,"date":"2026-04-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"You've seen no impact at all as a result of the U.S. tariffs. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104439","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You've seen no impact at all as a result of the U.S. tariffs. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7f59217df42d4e8f6ab7fac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104440,"date":"2026-04-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"That's interesting. Okay. If you've seen no impact at all because of the U.S. tariffs, then why are so many others expressing their concerns?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104440","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's interesting. Okay. If you've seen no impact at all because of the U.S. tariffs, then why are so many others expressing their concerns?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea1d94778537394a32637219003131788469b76631dab0b1e0cb419f03a7eaae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["965722cfd968c3af627c39f091c7bd31db818b3d8416b35b4e08d7279bd46a9c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7be2fb1be3eccb5e433d1dc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104441,"date":"2026-04-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Okay. You didn't answer my question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104441","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. You didn't answer my question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3405c43b08e86588745a3cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104442,"date":"2026-04-27T21:55:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"What are your concerns?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104442","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What are your concerns?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-525721ab36cdb32bda107ba7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104443,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"When you hear Donald Trump say he doesn't want Americans to buy cars made in Canada, what does that mean to you?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104443","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"When you hear Donald Trump say he doesn't want Americans to buy cars made in Canada, what does that mean to you?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86c51a101f62847d7bd822e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104444,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"How nuanced is it when the President of the United States says that he doesn't want Canadians to be making cars?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104444","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How nuanced is it when the President of the United States says that he doesn't want Canadians to be making cars?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b798cd2ce134775f14549517098d2a514c0457c3685cf84d44352a396008995"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-403cfe552d5d3444afa7a61e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104445,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"He said that publicly, so are we not to take him at his word?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104445","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"He said that publicly, so are we not to take him at his word?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e320d919f224beb1de4e8f61","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104446,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you for that. I would observe that we've had some interesting conversations in this committee over the last little while on some of the challenges and risks that have come forward. One of the things I don't think we have spent a lot of time on is the positive impact of having EVs and EV infrastructure in this country and what it means for the future, so on that basis, I'd like to table a motion. I move: That the committee conduct a study of no less than three meetings on positive examples of EV infrastructure implementation with specific references to lessons learned from Quebec and British Columbia. We'll be circulating that motion in both official languages. It is obviously relevant and tied to this study, because I think it's important for us to make sure we are bringing this into the conversation. I'd like to move that motion now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104446","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for that. I would observe that we've had some interesting conversations in this committee over the last little while on some of the challenges and risks that have come forward. One of the things I don't think we have spent a lot of time on is the positive impact of having EVs and EV infrastructure in this country and what it means for the future, so on that basis, I'd like to table a mot","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b04d62b41100ac5526a5f35b1a187a129b39c64c20d77d9749f9dc94adb39c1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b669659b6eb198658e42a950","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104447,"date":"2026-04-27T22:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Yes, I will, in both official languages. I can also read the motion in French: Que le Comité réalise une étude d'au moins trois réunions sur des exemples positifs de mise en œuvre d'infrastructures pour véhicules électriques, en faisant spécifiquement référence aux leçons tirées du Québec et de la Colombie-Britannique.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104447","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, I will, in both official languages. I can also read the motion in French: Que le Comité réalise une étude d'au moins trois réunions sur des exemples positifs de mise en œuvre d'infrastructures pour véhicules électriques, en faisant spécifiquement référence aux leçons tirées du Québec et de la Colombie-Britannique.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44242","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Earthquakes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44242","label":"Earthquakes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6cb01355450a0622d108f308bd07adcb130431c76af32e3af759f54c0bf25cd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["581ba06978d22b3c929180bc54ebd43e7d6f76c56d0bc40183c7f067b89bc227"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52f7fc432b2dcd493cb5de0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104448,"date":"2026-04-27T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. One of the things that has been top of mind as we've gone through this study is that there's an ongoing sense that as we talk about the presence of Chinese EVs in the market, this has somehow become conflated with the idea that all EVs are bad. There have been ongoing comments about how if we're not making ICE vehicles, somehow we have fallen off. In the comments from one of our witnesses today about electric delivery vehicles, the implication was that EVs somehow don't fit into our ecosystem. One of the things I would like us to consider, which is part of the reason for this study, is that not only have a lot of good things come from having EVs in our communities and on our streets but the impact of the infrastructure that's being built around them has been really helpful. If you look at B.C., it has quietly become one of the most important case studies in clean transportation policy, and the lessons are quite impressive. When I was growing up, nobody knew what the heck an EV was. A decade ago, there was a single charger in Nanaimo on Vancouver Island. In all of B.C., there was one EV charger. An hon. member: [ Inaudible—Editor ] Taleeb Noormohamed: My colleague opposite thinks that this is somehow a filibuster, but I just want to make a couple of important points before I cede my time to others. It's really important for us not to conflate the things that we have been talking about here. There are 5,000 public chargers in British Columbia right now, while in Vancouver, there's one gas station downtown. What you're seeing now is that approximately 22% of vehicle sales in B.C. are, in fact, zero-emission vehicles. This is having a huge environmental impact at scale. The second piece is that this has not just been publicly funded but also privately funded. The private investment in new infrastructure has been hugely valuable. We're seeing that you can now travel throughout the province of B.C. using your EV, and it is as effective as using an internal combustion engine vehicle. It has showed us that public-private partnership works. For all of the things that we've been talking about in this study where we have had concerns, the presence of EVs and EV infrastructure has actually helped and has become a big part of many of those solutions and has addressed many of those concerns. In the case of B.C., the government set the framework, the utilities built the backbone and the private sector has filled the gaps. When we talk about a study like this, I want to point out simply that we are at a tipping point right now where political narratives around where cars are coming from are becoming conflated with the idea that we somehow shouldn't have EVs on the road. I've heard this insinuation from a number of witnesses and a number of folks. An hon. member: [ Inaudible—Editor ] Taleeb Noormohamed: I'm sorry. My colleague opposite keeps interrupting me. What I was trying to say is that we've heard from folks that somehow there is something wrong with the idea that we should be pursuing an aggressive EV strategy in this country. We've heard from previous witnesses that 49,000 vehicles aren't going to make a difference. What will make a difference is making sure that EVs in this country have the charging infrastructure that they require and that we're building that alongside other clean infrastructure, which has been happening. It has, frankly, created jobs. It has created partnerships with indigenous communities. It has been a substantial contributor to British Columbia. I suspect there are examples from Quebec and other provinces where this has worked. I think it's important for us at this committee, when we're taking on topics like this, to build in the space to look at what has worked, so that if we're going to be talking about the impact of EVs writ large, whether they're imported or they are built in this country, we also understand what it takes to put them on the roads. This is an important study in that regard. As we at this committee are charged with making sure we're looking at this in the context of science, we need to actually do that. You start to think about what powers a charge versus what powers a gas station and what powers some of these vehicles. It's really important for us to remember that, in British Columbia at least, it's powered by clean water quite literally falling through turbines. These are the types of things that often get lost in this conversation and have been lost in this conversation. It behooves us all.... I'm sure my colleagues would agree, especially those across the way who may not admit to it but do drive EVs and would be keen to have a conversation about why this is important. Frankly, the other thing that I think is important coming out of these examples—and I will stop after this—is why certain provinces embraced EV infrastructure and the building of EV infrastructure to the benefit of consumers, to the benefit of ratepayers and to the benefit of taxpayers who tend to save a large amount of money buying EVs versus internal combustion engine vehicles. What's worked in B.C. and Quebec? What could other provinces learn from those examples? My hope is that the study is a productive one, where we can have meaningful conversations, bring in witnesses from those provinces and perhaps bring witnesses from jurisdictions where it hasn't gone as well because they haven't been able to—or had the means to—put in the resources to do that. These are the types of narratives that I think are important, because they provide a perspective that often gets lost in some of the super partisan, super political debate. I think this is a space where we can have that conversation. I will say this for B.C. In many cases, building EV infrastructure was a direct response to the increase in the cost of internal combustion engine vehicles and the cost of operating those vehicles. It's turned into an economic winner. It's turned into something that has been incredibly useful for the province and for those of us who live in that province. The ease, the speed and the cost-efficiency of driving EVs is a direct result of the infrastructure that's been built. With that, Madam Chair, I hope we'll be able to get positive support for this motion, and I hope we'll be able to have a meaningful conversation with our colleagues across, even those who think that, somehow, advocating for this motion was a filibuster. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104448","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. One of the things that has been top of mind as we've gone through this study is that there's an ongoing sense that as we talk about the presence of Chinese EVs in the market, this has somehow become conflated with the idea that all EVs are bad. There have been ongoing comments about how if we're not making ICE vehicles, somehow we have fallen off. In the comments from one o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa6ec05ec36bb294c6ba9312db49e9b534709efb37e7bb4bd35959a5da1a3eab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f34fc22d8a36bb290c5581457fd58b306025a36a011ace90ee60208b98b0bf63"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52dbe61928b4985e69b55065","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104449,"date":"2026-04-27T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"If we gave additional questions, would the witnesses be willing to give us written responses?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104449","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If we gave additional questions, would the witnesses be willing to give us written responses?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["425137ff7cd85d5aa80fca6deef1e80f6b08624ed94f7f91e9a27315e9e1035c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3348bccdaaffb292251beaee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104450,"date":"2026-04-27T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I mean, I'd prefer a written response if the time is....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104450","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I mean, I'd prefer a written response if the time is....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083643","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Time zones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083643","label":"Time zones","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0fb116d777abc0e4fe00d3dc5e2a364ae35d83dd115f40059563718bb2438528"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6c3d11ff07f887a5828cc90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104451,"date":"2026-04-27T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. I just wanted to make sure my friend got the clip he needs before I called my point of order. I just want to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104451","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. I just wanted to make sure my friend got the clip he needs before I called my point of order. I just want to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ceb4f0a6e55ae0866ff21927617230fd83dc00c7a1532f6774634f8b5df7467"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f02bf2a47e66434b957abfd9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104452,"date":"2026-04-27T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"We are now on the motion, so—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104452","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We are now on the motion, so—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf27f98c17be9035ac5fb53e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104453,"date":"2026-04-27T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I'm failing to understand how this is relevant to the motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104453","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm failing to understand how this is relevant to the motion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","label":"Arms control","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["099d3073bf38514dcaa6d3406229052d814f66db4dda9b7f0397b7ab232af626"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6837fea76fdbfe37f9a75c9b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104454,"date":"2026-04-27T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I think it's a good amendment. I would certainly be pleased to support it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104454","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I think it's a good amendment. I would certainly be pleased to support it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4864a23db9809299972bda12","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104455,"date":"2026-04-27T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Madam Chair, I want to suggest two things. First, I think we're all happy to debate the motion and have discussion on it. I suggest that we suspend to discuss it amongst ourselves. Second, perhaps we could suspend the meeting and pick this up on Thursday when we have the proper time to be able to engage in that conversation. I do think this is a good conversation to have. I think we all have questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104455","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I want to suggest two things. First, I think we're all happy to debate the motion and have discussion on it. I suggest that we suspend to discuss it amongst ourselves. Second, perhaps we could suspend the meeting and pick this up on Thursday when we have the proper time to be able to engage in that conversation. I do think this is a good conversation to have. I think we all have quest","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69073e56bccb5acdf3d8b2b3d05c78c8b73dd7aa549de9a849a3792dc903b3de"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e094b70006ba04fe8fa20209","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104456,"date":"2026-04-27T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"That's end of day on Thursday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104456","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's end of day on Thursday.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37db82702eeb55ee4a093bdb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104457,"date":"2026-04-27T22:50:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. What Mr. Blanchette-Joncas is saying is entirely out of order. Basically it violates the decorum of the committee and attacks the chair. There's a limit to this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104457","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. What Mr. Blanchette-Joncas is saying is entirely out of order. Basically it violates the decorum of the committee and attacks the chair. There's a limit to this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87e710b5a589192f43ccbfd9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723462,"date":"2026-04-29T19:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbia and Vancouver's Greek community lost a giant earlier this month with the passing of Andreas Arsoniadis.\n\nThose of us who grew up in Vancouver remember Andreas not for his incredible skill with numbers or his entrepreneurial spirit but as the guy who was responsible for feeding us some of the most incredible food: Greek food, pizzas and the most generous portions one could ever imagine. He always greeted us with a big smile and welcomed us into his restaurant like we were coming home. For decade upon decade, he made sure that each and every one of us felt like we belonged when we walked into Andreas Restaurant.\n\nHe leaves a massive hole in the heart of the Greek community, of which he was a pioneer and a builder, and a massive hole in the hearts of his loved ones, including sisters Marikoula and Parthena; his children, George, Dimitrios and Kaity; his grandchildren, Mati, Anna, Mia, Amalia, Andreas and Adriana; his first great-grandchild; and so many people in our community who celebrated his life in Van Gran's St. George's Greek Orthodox Cathedral on April 15.\n\nWe will all miss him dearly. May he rest in peace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723462","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbia and Vancouver's Greek community lost a giant earlier this month with the passing of Andreas Arsoniadis.\n\nThose of us who grew up in Vancouver remember Andreas not for his incredible skill with numbers or his entrepreneurial spirit but as the guy who was responsible for feeding us some of the most incredible food: Greek food, pizzas and the most generous portions one c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b15c67951047abed8e3fd31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104458,"date":"2026-05-04T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"On a point of order, Madam Chair, at what time did we start and how much time do we have?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104458","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"On a point of order, Madam Chair, at what time did we start and how much time do we have?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083676","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical societies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083676","label":"Historical societies","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1f6d5aca05d80d38e5192a519b426719882d04f917f90e0c6af019318af4994"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b90cc1591428ca0ac7d34550","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104459,"date":"2026-05-04T21:20:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thanks.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104459","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thanks.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85c110c8e61fe3c5474c8b1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104460,"date":"2026-05-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to my colleague. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. Karn, it's good to see you here. It's good to see a homegrown Vancouver Granville company here doing amazing work in the space that you're in. I want to thank you for all the work that you're doing, the jobs you're creating and the innovative research and the innovative businesses that you are now leading. One thing I wanted to touch on has to do with how, in your case, Terramera's soil health and carbon sequestration technology could contribute to northern and Arctic food sovereignty as a defence-relevant objective. Obviously, one of the things that we've been talking a lot about is how we can enhance co-operation with indigenous and northern communities, as well as the private sector, to address evolving threats to the north to build climate-resilient, dual-use or multi-purpose infrastructure, particularly around this area. Anything you could share with us in that regard would be great.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104460","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to my colleague. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. Karn, it's good to see you here. It's good to see a homegrown Vancouver Granville company here doing amazing work in the space that you're in. I want to thank you for all the work that you're doing, the jobs you're creating and the innovative research and the innovative businesses that you are now lea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33b5cf063eaf7f88feca6bd6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104461,"date":"2026-05-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Some are going to say that this is really about improving food productivity and not necessarily about defence and dual use. How do you bridge that gap for folks who will say that this should be bucketed over here, rather than part of a dual-use opportunity for Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104461","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Some are going to say that this is really about improving food productivity and not necessarily about defence and dual use. How do you bridge that gap for folks who will say that this should be bucketed over here, rather than part of a dual-use opportunity for Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","label":"Functional foods","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8cbbc7a75ff0f369a2c5f3bf0a3511a5da4e4943206f1bcd93ce536a486d3cb7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-01bd5a26304f5bf7dc1c0da8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104462,"date":"2026-05-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"This takes me to the whole question of agritech risk. Obviously, your platform involves manipulating biological active ingredients at scale. Biotechnology as military applications sometimes complicates the dual-use dilemma, because the same infrastructure, the same tools and the same knowledge used to develop beneficial products can be used for harmful purposes. What governance frameworks do you use? How does Canada's current dual-use oversight regime adequately address risks in the space of agritech?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104462","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This takes me to the whole question of agritech risk. Obviously, your platform involves manipulating biological active ingredients at scale. Biotechnology as military applications sometimes complicates the dual-use dilemma, because the same infrastructure, the same tools and the same knowledge used to develop beneficial products can be used for harmful purposes. What governance frameworks do you u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Biotechnology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Biotechnology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","label":"Biotechnology","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a6100e150849196e32291ec3f116c66870477522afcbe33ec0bd92682b6d381"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-699a088eb7e278b75c7bcc29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104463,"date":"2026-05-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. It's great to see all of you here. In particular, it's good to see Industrio, another Vancouver Granville company here. It's great to see you virtually. I might start with you, because you are at the nexus of a lot of things that are going on in our world right now and, in particular, some of the challenges and opportunities the space you're in is dealing with. I might start by asking you to talk a bit about your competition and what it's like in your current space. The military landscape right now is increasingly dominated by a lot of the neoprimes, like Palantir and others, that are investing in their own R and D and their own market-finished projects. They work with military customers. What does a company like Industrio need from the government to be competitive in that market without being absorbed or displaced by better capitalized American players at a time when sovereignty is super important?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104463","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. It's great to see all of you here. In particular, it's good to see Industrio, another Vancouver Granville company here. It's great to see you virtually. I might start with you, because you are at the nexus of a lot of things that are going on in our world right now and, in particular, some of the challenges and opportunities the space you're in i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bd31b4974cebdb5ea36ce9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104464,"date":"2026-05-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"You pointed out the DIS. The strategy's explicit about how AI, secure cloud, integrated command and control and high assurance communications are sovereign capabilities that Canada has to own and control. You spent three years building Signal for exactly these environments. In your view, what does it mean practically for Canada to own and control an AI platform? How does the current procurement framework reward sovereign-by-design builders like you? Where do you see the opportunity for you and for companies like yours in that strategy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104464","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You pointed out the DIS. The strategy's explicit about how AI, secure cloud, integrated command and control and high assurance communications are sovereign capabilities that Canada has to own and control. You spent three years building Signal for exactly these environments. In your view, what does it mean practically for Canada to own and control an AI platform? How does the current procurement fr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-410aa260c61ff2486ae7d1e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104465,"date":"2026-05-04T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Let's dig into that in the time we have left. Any analysis right now of Canada's defence industrial strategy would say digital sovereignty is no longer a policy debate, but a readiness imperative. If that's the case, the choices we're making today in procurement and likely architecture as well are going to have an impact. They're going to shape Canada's operational resilience for a very long time. When you deploy Signal in a government environment, one of the questions that I think it is important for everyone to hear is, what concrete guarantees of data residency and model control can a Canadian SME like yours provide, which a hyperscaler that's perhaps U.S.-based could not?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104465","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Let's dig into that in the time we have left. Any analysis right now of Canada's defence industrial strategy would say digital sovereignty is no longer a policy debate, but a readiness imperative. If that's the case, the choices we're making today in procurement and likely architecture as well are going to have an impact. They're going to shape Canada's operational resilience for a very long time.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c8a063002c7a36fd35c5541","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104466,"date":"2026-05-04T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"What you're saying is we should be taking intelligent, managed risk and betting on Canadian companies.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104466","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What you're saying is we should be taking intelligent, managed risk and betting on Canadian companies.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance companies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083677","label":"Insurance companies","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","label":"Gambling","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b99e7e8fa75256bfd7684a7958da0ac399a5ea3fc3815b8652f7366dbe405e6e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-345adbf2c61966aa0c701124","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104467,"date":"2026-05-04T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104467","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a776e178d7b9249926de3a46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104468,"date":"2026-05-04T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. If we're going to have this conversation, it's important that we state what the facts are. Mr. Ho is misrepresenting what actually occurred. I wasn't at the meeting, but from what I watched, this is a misrepresentation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104468","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. If we're going to have this conversation, it's important that we state what the facts are. Mr. Ho is misrepresenting what actually occurred. I wasn't at the meeting, but from what I watched, this is a misrepresentation.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a3587ffbc18dfc6ff669862","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104469,"date":"2026-05-04T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"The Harper government cut the space program every year—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104469","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Harper government cut the space program every year—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed40882bda11ce004fc2059788defe192b07eb0b0aacf969ff4de0657c65e4bf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efa1adb8a238a2b44c644ba5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104470,"date":"2026-05-04T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Why did the Harper government cut space funding every opportunity they got?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104470","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Why did the Harper government cut space funding every opportunity they got?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["81556b862aec11994dbfc99fc4935c54aa911bd364fcab19d3c60ffb7f01fb6b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9b6875a772fcdb29bf938e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104471,"date":"2026-05-04T22:40:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Why is he filibustering? It's on a motion—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104471","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Why is he filibustering? It's on a motion—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a863e89c1731c55f3bb3938","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752423,"date":"2026-05-06T19:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this May, Canadians mark Asian Heritage Month, and someone who comes from a city like Vancouver, as I do, does not have to look far to understand why that matters.\n\nThere is no one Asian story in Canada; there are tens of thousands. They are written in many languages, carried through many faiths, shaped by many histories and lived through families that crossed oceans, built lives from nothing, endured exclusion and still chose to give this country their labour, their hope and their children's future. Those of us who grew up in Vancouver know this story well. We know it in the restaurants that feed us, the businesses that raise up our neighbourhoods, the music and festivals that fill our streets, the athletes who carry our pride and the volunteers who show up for community day after day.\n\nAsian Canadians did not simply arrive in Canada. They have helped build it. They have established communities, preserved culture and built bonds across differences. This month we honour that legacy and this commitment, not as a footnote to Canadian history but as a critical story in that history and in Canada's future.\n\nI invite all members of the—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752423","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this May, Canadians mark Asian Heritage Month, and someone who comes from a city like Vancouver, as I do, does not have to look far to understand why that matters.\n\nThere is no one Asian story in Canada; there are tens of thousands. They are written in many languages, carried through many faiths, shaped by many histories and lived through families that crossed oceans, built lives from","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Restaurants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131383","label":"Restaurants","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["10f0e9b70a3f7b55768ed78a73d24427674b6dae09147674fabafdd86276a0bf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3477ae6524b157f9583a013","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752424,"date":"2026-05-06T20:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear about what the facts are. The fact is that the Prime Minister has stood and said very clearly that our government is going to protect private property rights.\n\nLet us be clear about the facts. We have said that we are appealing the decision, which we are.\n\nLet us also be clear that the fearmongering and misinformation coming from the other side of the House is causing uncertainty in British Columbia, not what the facts on the ground say. The facts on the ground say that we are defending private property rights. The opposition is trying to drive uncertainty and is driving problems in the housing market in British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752424","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear about what the facts are. The fact is that the Prime Minister has stood and said very clearly that our government is going to protect private property rights.\n\nLet us be clear about the facts. We have said that we are appealing the decision, which we are.\n\nLet us also be clear that the fearmongering and misinformation coming from the other side of the House is causing ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18264a60c07f53449effe62a86976805efc87ce0267e8e9c4e352e5b33f1eadf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc02d23ffc0a8c1a7a23e6de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104472,"date":"2026-05-07T16:20:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. Would time not have been taken off, given you had already started the next round? You started the first round of questioning, and there is no such thing as a point of information. Technically, the time should have been running.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104472","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. Would time not have been taken off, given you had already started the next round? You started the first round of questioning, and there is no such thing as a point of information. Technically, the time should have been running.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa72e3e81750b7374a965305","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104473,"date":"2026-05-07T16:20:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"In that case, I have a further question for you. Perhaps we could also clarify for the viewing public that the ministers who were named by my friend opposite were not part of the request in the original motion. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104473","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In that case, I have a further question for you. Perhaps we could also clarify for the viewing public that the ministers who were named by my friend opposite were not part of the request in the original motion. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04d4dc83d1ee0b7e67ffe5b6dbb4117fdca12e2ee5470267cfa3d064fbc1ce44"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c30ee88f0fcaafb050ba59a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104474,"date":"2026-05-07T16:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"For avoidance of doubt, as is process, a number of witnesses were requested by the committee, some ministers, some CEOs and others. No one is compelled to attend unless a motion calls for them to attend. Is that correct? I want to be sure, because what I don't want is a bunch of misleading clips to say that ministers deliberately didn't come to committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104474","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"For avoidance of doubt, as is process, a number of witnesses were requested by the committee, some ministers, some CEOs and others. No one is compelled to attend unless a motion calls for them to attend. Is that correct? I want to be sure, because what I don't want is a bunch of misleading clips to say that ministers deliberately didn't come to committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a46cdb4f0eb9d43d5b5000d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104475,"date":"2026-05-07T16:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104475","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee5df9a9a45b1c435a919147","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104476,"date":"2026-05-07T16:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I think it's really important that if we're going to have conversations in this committee, we don't brand non-partisan public servants as \"Liberal bureaucrats\". We are now crossing a ton of lines.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104476","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I think it's really important that if we're going to have conversations in this committee, we don't brand non-partisan public servants as \"Liberal bureaucrats\". We are now crossing a ton of lines.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e556585b2230ae32b1db1fb7f993ece7726c24f88c72b09a5a4e7736827d0539"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f4a08521b1be8fbc706089b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104477,"date":"2026-05-07T16:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104477","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-246dfdadafb81ecaf0d9eca8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104478,"date":"2026-05-07T16:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Your time stops every time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104478","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Your time stops every time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f8c792c0da9ebc19500e8c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104479,"date":"2026-05-07T16:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"The member opposite stated or implied inaccurate—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104479","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The member opposite stated or implied inaccurate—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29ef2166d326bce8388319d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104480,"date":"2026-05-07T16:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Madam Chair, if we're going to talk about the mandate of the committee, I'll note there was an implied comment there. There was a very clear assertion of what this committee does. In fact, the mandate of this committee is absolutely not what the member opposite has said. We need to be very clear when we are referring to matters of content with respect to the specific nature and mandate of the committee. They should actually be clear, not misleading, so that when we are posing questions and doing studies, they are, in fact, within the scope of the committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104480","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Chair, if we're going to talk about the mandate of the committee, I'll note there was an implied comment there. There was a very clear assertion of what this committee does. In fact, the mandate of this committee is absolutely not what the member opposite has said. We need to be very clear when we are referring to matters of content with respect to the specific nature and mandate of the comm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e1297b68156eb19072933d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104481,"date":"2026-05-07T16:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"On a point of order, Madam Chair, we have less than 20 minutes left in this round. We have witnesses who are waiting. If this is going to go on, perhaps we can do the courteous thing and ask the witnesses to leave and invite them back to a different meeting. It's disrespectful to them. It's clear that Mr. Ho has a number of things he thinks are important that he would like to share with us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104481","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"On a point of order, Madam Chair, we have less than 20 minutes left in this round. We have witnesses who are waiting. If this is going to go on, perhaps we can do the courteous thing and ask the witnesses to leave and invite them back to a different meeting. It's disrespectful to them. It's clear that Mr. Ho has a number of things he thinks are important that he would like to share with us.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bae24cb603c523cfc2f129a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104482,"date":"2026-05-07T16:40:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Science....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104482","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Science....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6099a663df44f0de2480d52b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104483,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Madam Chair, I have a point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104483","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I have a point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f69182a8ff64c5994f7b1a44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104484,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Under the Simms protocol in the PROC report from the 42nd Parliament, I would like to use my prerogative to intervene and ask questions while the member has the floor. This doesn't require Mr. Ho to cede the floor, but it does give me right to speak and, indeed, address some of the points that he has made.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104484","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Under the Simms protocol in the PROC report from the 42nd Parliament, I would like to use my prerogative to intervene and ask questions while the member has the floor. This doesn't require Mr. Ho to cede the floor, but it does give me right to speak and, indeed, address some of the points that he has made.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f6c62dd152810e1bd9bc41c9fdd36328209d6870bb4cf78005ed8272bd2a5ac9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bdefc2ade0726a86c84919ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104485,"date":"2026-05-07T16:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"We can look it up.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104485","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We can look it up.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a60bf2b58e4a4786dfe4001f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752417,"date":"2026-05-07T17:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I noted that in the member opposite's comments, he expressed that somehow these Musqueam agreements were secret. If he would like, I am more than happy to share with him the links online, where they are available to the public.\n\n He also spoke about the need for true reconciliation, which he alleges his party believes in. Does that strategy of true reconciliation include condemning the comments of the member for North Island—Powell River, who said indigenous people \"asked for\" residential schools and there was no indigenous genocide?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752417","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I noted that in the member opposite's comments, he expressed that somehow these Musqueam agreements were secret. If he would like, I am more than happy to share with him the links online, where they are available to the public.\n\n He also spoke about the need for true reconciliation, which he alleges his party believes in. Does that strategy of true reconciliation include condemning th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["493de32297c98199957064e44beafeaad3fa18e560377463cb51b6e74c820273"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aff9b392e6b0e04f7ede91db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752418,"date":"2026-05-07T17:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for South Surrey—White Rock.\n\nI rise this afternoon to speak about a court decision that has caused real worry in my province and to speak directly to the Canadians, particularly British Columbians, who have been watching this debate and wondering what it means for them and for their homes. Let us begin with the facts, because the facts have been in short supply in the debate by members opposite.\n\nThe fact is that the government has fundamentally disagreed with, and continues to disagree with, the British Columbia Supreme Court's decision in Cowichan. The fact is that we appealed that decision on September 8 of last year. The fact is that the Prime Minister of Canada has stood in this House and stated clearly to all who would listen that private property rights are fundamental, that this government will protect them and that federal agreements, including agreements about aboriginal title, have always protected and will always protect private property.\n\n These are the facts. They are on the record. They are not in dispute, except by those who find facts inconvenient to the story that they would prefer to tell, a story that leads to mistrust, anti-indigenous racism and, perhaps most importantly, instability in British Columbia's economy.\n\nI want to speak directly to the homeowner in Richmond who read a headline and felt their stomach drop. I want to speak to the family in my riding of Vancouver Granville who have spent 20 years paying down a mortgage and are now wondering whether the ground beneath their home is as solid as they believed it to be. I want to speak to the small business owner who has been asking their bank for financing and getting questions they have never been asked before. These concerns are legitimate. A home is the largest investment most Canadians will ever make. When a court raises questions about the relationship between aboriginal title and fee simple ownership, people are right to ask for clarity. They deserve a serious answer, not a slogan or a sound bite, so allow me, if you would, Mr. Chair, to give them one.\n\n Three principles guide this government's response to the Cowichan decision. First, we believe in the security of private property. Canadians who hold title to their homes and their land must be able to rely on that title. This should not be a partisan position. It is the foundation on which families plan their future, on which businesses make investments and on which our economy functions.\n\n Second, we believe in the principles of reconciliation. Reconciliation is not a slogan, and it is not an obstacle to be managed. It is a constitutional and moral obligation that this country has been working through for generations, and we continue that work patiently, lawfully and in good faith.\n\n Third, we believe in building shared prosperity for homeowners, for workers, for businesses and for indigenous communities who have for too long been excluded from the economic life of this country. These are not competing goods. They are connected goods. \n\nI want to be honest with the House and with the Canadians watching. The legal questions raised in the Cowichan decision are genuinely complex, and the clarity that Canadians deserve is going to come from where it should come from in our system: from the courts on appeal, with all viable arguments tested and all parties heard. That process is under way. It will take time, and none of us should stand in this place and pretend otherwise, because Canadians deserve, as I said before, a serious answer, not a slogan. They deserve facts, not fearmongering.\n\n The Conservative motion before the House asks Canadians to choose between the first principle and the second. It asks them to believe that property rights and reconciliation cannot exist in harmony. This is false and has always been false, and the people advancing that false choice know it is false.\n\n Let me say something very clearly. The legal questions we are working through in Cowichan are not questions that indigenous peoples created. They are the product of decisions made by the Crown over generations in a province where most of the land was never covered by treaty. The Crown made those decisions, the Crown bears responsibility to resolve them, and no responsible government should allow any ordinary homeowner to be made afraid, or indigenous peoples to be scapegoated, while that work is carried out.\n\nHere is what is being missed in the noise: Almost every party to this litigation has gone to the Court of Appeal. The Government of Canada is appealing. The Province of British Columbia is appealing. The City of Richmond is appealing. Musqueam is appealing. Chief Wayne Sparrow has spoken publicly about Musqueam's deep concern with the decision that declared aboriginal title in what they assert is their own traditional territory. Tsawwassen First Nation is appealing alongside Musqueam on similar grounds. The Cowichan themselves are appealing on different grounds.\n\n This is not the picture of settled judgment. This is the picture of a decision that has satisfied almost no one, that produced a clarity that almost no one was looking for and that is now being worked through by our courts exactly as our system is designed to handle it.\n\nThis is also not the story of homeowners on one side and indigenous peoples on the other. It is the story of a serious country with a serious legal system doing serious work. This includes first nations that are using that very system to seek the clarity that each and every one of us needs and deserves. It is the story that members opposite are refusing to tell because it does not serve a political agenda. The cost of that political agenda and of this misinformation is real and is being paid right now in my home province of British Columbia.\n\nJust yesterday, the Business Council of British Columbia released a survey of its members. About 74% of respondents are decreasing investment plans in B.C., one in three are reducing hiring, 41% report harder access to external financing, and 80% of those same business leaders say they continue to support reconciliation as an important goal.\n\nWhy are they reducing those investments? They are reducing those investments because of misinformation and uncertainty that is being spurred on by people who would like to use the Cowichan decision as a political cudgel. In this House, in this Parliament, we must ensure that does not continue, for the security of the economy in British Columbia and for preservation of the principle of true reconciliation.\n\nThe people who are supporting reconciliation are very clear. This is a business community that is pro-reconciliation and is exhausted by uncertainty. They are not asking us to choose. They are asking us to lead. The damage is not abstract. Homes are not being built. Jobs are not being created. There are workers waiting for projects that have been paused while financing is renegotiated. There are businesses across B.C. that are delaying decisions; holding back on investment; watching the noise around this case created by politicians, not by the courts; and concluding that the cost of moving forward is too uncertain to bear. That is what irresponsibility looks like in practice, and it is being done deliberately for the political gain of the party opposite.\n\nThe seriousness of this moment is not lost on the political leadership of British Columbia. The Premier of B.C. has spoken at length about the impact of legal uncertainty on his province. Mayors have spoken. The City of Richmond is in court. There is broad cross-partisan recognition in B.C., not from one party and not from one ideology but from across the political spectrum of my province, that resolving this matters and that the work cannot wait. The only people who seem to disagree are the Conservative members opposite, who have decided that uncertainty and a parliamentary committee are more useful to them than actual resolution of the problem.\n\nThe Conservatives know exactly what they are doing. They know that the Cowichan decision is under appeal. They know that the Government of Canada, the Province of B.C., the City of Richmond, Musqueam and Tsawwassen First Nation have all gone to the Court of Appeal precisely because the legal questions need to be resolved. They know that the Prime Minister has committed, clearly and repeatedly, that this government will defend private property rights.\n\nThey know the historical record across this country is that modern treaties and negotiated agreements have always protected private property. Not one Canadian has lost their private property as a result of a negotiated agreement. They know this, and they are choosing every day to tell their constituents the opposite because fear is more politically useful than the truth. It is not leadership but a calculation, and the people paying for that calculation are the homeowners they claim to defend.\n\nI want to close with a story about what is possible when we get this right. This Friday in my riding of Vancouver Granville, I will be at the blessing ceremony of the opening of Sen̓áḵw. Sen̓áḵw sits in Squamish territory at the foot of the Burrard bridge, where it has always been, in the land, in the stories and in the people. What is new is what is being built there: 6,000 rental homes in a city that is desperately in need of them.\n\nThis is true reconciliation, where rents to 30% below market are being provided by the Squamish Nation in partnership with the Government of Canada. The Squamish Nation is moving toward economic independence and helping Vancouver provide the housing it needs. Property rights will be respected, indigenous rights will be honoured, homes will be built, and jobs will be created. For the Squamish Nation, there will be prosperity, and for the city that I represent, 6,000 families will be able to call Sen̓áḵw home. That is reconciliation, that is prosperity, and that is what is possible when we refuse the false choice being put upon us by the opposition. That is happening in real time in my riding.\n\nTo the homeowners in my riding and across B.C. who have been worried, the government has appealed the Cowichan decision. We are advancing every legally viable argument to defend the security of fee simple. We have been clear, from the Prime Minister on down, that protecting private property is fundamental to who we are as a country, and we will always stand for that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752418","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for South Surrey—White Rock.\n\nI rise this afternoon to speak about a court decision that has caused real worry in my province and to speak directly to the Canadians, particularly British Columbians, who have been watching this debate and wondering what it means for them and for their homes. Let us begin with the facts, because the facts have b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["11858549a58b6529ec890a94a0c24923109bf70a93d2c9d4132b5893dbcca42a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e27bc9ea2cdde21aacb074eb69d81d984580f9902cfcb6b0ea34548dd09f527f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba730377947a9ac711c483ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752419,"date":"2026-05-07T17:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member opposite for yet again, like his colleagues, making light of what is a very serious situation for folks in Vancouver and across British Columbia.\n\nThere are people who listen to the debates in this Parliament and expect serious discussion and serious debate. What they hear is misinformation, which leads to market uncertainty. Market uncertainty leads to builders not wanting to build affordable homes and to jobs not being created.\n\nThe Conservatives should be ashamed of themselves. They should be asking themselves what they will tell their constituents when they ask if the government is going to stand for property rights or not when the answer is yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752419","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member opposite for yet again, like his colleagues, making light of what is a very serious situation for folks in Vancouver and across British Columbia.\n\nThere are people who listen to the debates in this Parliament and expect serious discussion and serious debate. What they hear is misinformation, which leads to market uncertainty. Market uncertainty leads to builders not","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a06232c898ad4b7b6d4d7f29909736776ed0a9260dc19d3945128a9ff6e93044"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-094202bfd3f5f7fcff170cca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752420,"date":"2026-05-07T17:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think the simple answer is no. I would invite members opposite to read beyond the first line of the directive because they would see there is substantial depth there. They should choose to look at the facts. I know my hon. friend here, who is a lawyer, has read the entirety of the decision and would understand why we have to read the whole thing, not just the headlines.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752420","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think the simple answer is no. I would invite members opposite to read beyond the first line of the directive because they would see there is substantial depth there. They should choose to look at the facts. I know my hon. friend here, who is a lawyer, has read the entirety of the decision and would understand why we have to read the whole thing, not just the headlines.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8368f6cfcc5c7849078d0e01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752421,"date":"2026-05-07T17:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am so pleased the member opposite chose to hang his entire argument on the word \"viable\". The whole premise of our legal system is based on viable argument, on the fact that we make arguments that can stand up in court and that we win or lose decisions on the basis of the quality of our arguments and our understanding of the law.\n\nI would invite the member opposite to look at the agreements with Musqueam that he claims were done in secret to understand the Cowichan decision and the basis of the appeals. What he would see is a government that is vigorously defending private property rights and doing the work that is required to run this through the systems designed by our Constitution, which are the courts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752421","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am so pleased the member opposite chose to hang his entire argument on the word \"viable\". The whole premise of our legal system is based on viable argument, on the fact that we make arguments that can stand up in court and that we win or lose decisions on the basis of the quality of our arguments and our understanding of the law.\n\nI would invite the member opposite to look at the ag","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e59e0e7519aee5b8705521847a6f691f2c9c834f55d3b9cace753a7eb41d4606"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f00a9b4524d2d860eac6cbd575a8115c164523b93c9e0767a936310614dcc7c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbea582c0bb950275cf4d766","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752422,"date":"2026-05-07T17:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is sad that we have to rise in the House to even address this issue. I suppose when we are dealing with an opposition party whose leader once said that indigenous people needed a better work ethic, not support, this is what we get.\n\nThere are members across the way who have made comments that have disparaged indigenous people, directly and indirectly. Their arguments about this case, which are being litigated with absolutely no basis in judgment, are causing people to look at indigenous people as the cause of a problem, to blame them and cast dispersions upon them, when in fact what we need to be doing is working through this toward reconciliation in a way that creates prosperity but also ensures private property is protected.\n\nIf the Conservatives focused their attention on that, perhaps we would have committees in which we felt like we could work together, which is what the Conservatives simply have no interest in doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752422","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is sad that we have to rise in the House to even address this issue. I suppose when we are dealing with an opposition party whose leader once said that indigenous people needed a better work ethic, not support, this is what we get.\n\nThere are members across the way who have made comments that have disparaged indigenous people, directly and indirectly. Their arguments about this cas","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0f21fd29b507265c7f42732c2de796dfe54aa8f4439cfe4bcfd2ab0fe94fef01"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["668563b82ad44453668d8e758508fab811f7ff2974af493b337a962a272265d6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2a2b4184c62f473e9dc09b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104486,"date":"2026-05-07T17:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I would agree with my friend opposite. We would have gladly supported this motion—we didn't need the YouTube video—and we're happy to get to a vote.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104486","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would agree with my friend opposite. We would have gladly supported this motion—we didn't need the YouTube video—and we're happy to get to a vote.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e4134e6c9080a044d3bf3647a021b4e72403d10c801b52c172de4701ebab04a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-858695b35b82815661dc8854","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021420,"date":"2026-05-25T19:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, earlier this month, I attended the blessing ceremony of Sen̓áḵw, a housing development in my riding of Vancouver Granville. When complete, Sen̓áḵw will bring more than 6,000 rental homes to Vancouver open to everyone, including much-needed affordable and below-market housing units for families, workers and newcomers alike.\n\nHowever, Sen̓áḵw is more than a housing project. It is a homecoming. More than a century after Squamish families were forcibly removed from their ancestral village, the Squamish nation gathered once again on their land. They gathered with elders. They gathered in language, in song, in ceremony and in strength.\n\nI was honoured to be a witness to that ceremony, that blessing, as the first tower prepares to welcome families into 333 new homes. It is high-quality housing. It is affordable housing on prime land in Vancouver. Above all else, it is reconciliation in action.\n\nSen̓áḵw reminds us that when we work with first nations, when first nations lead and we partner, we do more than build homes. We build trust, we restore belonging and we build the future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021420","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, earlier this month, I attended the blessing ceremony of Sen̓áḵw, a housing development in my riding of Vancouver Granville. When complete, Sen̓áḵw will bring more than 6,000 rental homes to Vancouver open to everyone, including much-needed affordable and below-market housing units for families, workers and newcomers alike.\n\nHowever, Sen̓áḵw is more than a housing project. It is a home","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ee4bbea4ed175b5aa2db5f87f842d5e0a6095c678292bd71a178dd878f47b997"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65d1cf71d2b80090f766fbeb2803440b25d36d7d4c1700f1bfafcff60438e0bf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4643a9257c28740fd2650cae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021421,"date":"2026-05-25T19:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, yet again, it is either misinformation or disinformation coming from the Conservatives. Either way, Canadians need to understand the facts. \n\nThe facts are that the government is appealing the Cowichan decision in the courts today and that the government has stood up for the rights of private property owners. It is also important that Canadians understand that not a single Canadian has ever lost any private property in any agreement with an indigenous community. Conservatives are spreading misinformation, risking substantial economic growth in British Columbia and putting at risk true reconciliation and economic growth.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021421","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, yet again, it is either misinformation or disinformation coming from the Conservatives. Either way, Canadians need to understand the facts. \n\nThe facts are that the government is appealing the Cowichan decision in the courts today and that the government has stood up for the rights of private property owners. It is also important that Canadians understand that not a single Canadian ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bcda9de9c8725bee8c0d94fd90f5ded68c0092bb24ebe8db2f517e67d6f60368"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba848a36c043810a9f05ec63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104487,"date":"2026-05-25T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you very much. Maybe I can begin with Ms. Campbell. The conversations that have been going on today range from how you select astronauts, all the way through to some of the more relevant questions that people might want answered. I'm curious. When you see a group of parliamentarians like this, what are some of the things that we should be focusing on, in terms of the conversation that we should be having in respect of where the Canadian Space Agency—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104487","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Maybe I can begin with Ms. Campbell. The conversations that have been going on today range from how you select astronauts, all the way through to some of the more relevant questions that people might want answered. I'm curious. When you see a group of parliamentarians like this, what are some of the things that we should be focusing on, in terms of the conversation that we sho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space station","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037195","label":"Space station","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c5bccf86ee70af18c94a48336e20711560c88a6391abe2c8c11cbb1b4012fe3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b590cade4c91d5db22969402","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104488,"date":"2026-05-25T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I'm sorry, Madam Chair. Mr. Ho appears to think that interrupting is the best way to conduct himself.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104488","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry, Madam Chair. Mr. Ho appears to think that interrupting is the best way to conduct himself.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22c992e3794314291ca2d491","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104489,"date":"2026-05-25T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you. Instead of waging DEI battles, let's actually have a conversation about what matters. One of the things that I think Canadians would be interested in knowing, when you think about the future of the space program for this country—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104489","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Instead of waging DEI battles, let's actually have a conversation about what matters. One of the things that I think Canadians would be interested in knowing, when you think about the future of the space program for this country—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1013163","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Biological warfare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1013163","label":"Biological warfare","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["68a266e5cd72aec05ca1b29ddbdf5d9ff2c40c6d77b4c3cfcf7849840c619e86"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f78c21e463a7624f5a5852a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104490,"date":"2026-05-25T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I'm going to get my time back, though. Is that right, Madam Chair?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104490","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm going to get my time back, though. Is that right, Madam Chair?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c85f130ba35d8b0b877852209409fe0948bff5b8551725807f2956139f06b39"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fba0e0e922af435f71f2c03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104491,"date":"2026-05-25T22:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you. Again, the opposition would like to wage DEI battles. I'd be curious to talk to you about the future of the space program in this country, and I think Canadians would like to know. Obviously, the Prime Minister has laid out a fairly ambitious agenda for where he would like Canada to be going. There's a defence industrial strategy now in place. The reality is that there are a variety of different factors that now come into play. What is the one thing that you would like parliamentarians to be focusing on as we think about the future of the Canadian Space Agency? In particular, what should we be thinking about with respect to space and Canada's role in space programming and true engagement in terms of how we think about growth and how we think about exploration?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104491","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Again, the opposition would like to wage DEI battles. I'd be curious to talk to you about the future of the space program in this country, and I think Canadians would like to know. Obviously, the Prime Minister has laid out a fairly ambitious agenda for where he would like Canada to be going. There's a defence industrial strategy now in place. The reality is that there are a variety of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a58ec9bae40d350b3b49a7aefbf3763f14196b2dbe6fd240721822f2ae56f451"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["06233ce13f7ebb2f0349c2b9a5b09c4e1a6b69557d4ef887e65f6eeaa7832efa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45dabdb018d82f19363d1cc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104492,"date":"2026-05-25T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you. Madam Chair, how much time do I have left?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104492","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. Madam Chair, how much time do I have left?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46633b4daaf31e037fcb1faae98b358a8595f34e8cc82a92c77ada8118717483"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aebb4e191b64850cdc53c4d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104493,"date":"2026-05-25T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I did have a number of other questions I wanted to ask you, but regrettably I actually have to move a motion, so I'm now going to do that. I want to thank you for the insightful response to that question. I want to move a motion that was put on notice earlier, and the motion reads: That, notwithstanding the motion adopted on February 12, 2026 on the disclosure of documents related to the AI Strategy, and given that the estimate provided by ISED Officials for the cost of production of these materials ranges from $1,192,493.59 to $1,327,208.59, and given that all AI Strategy Task Force reports and more than 11,000 submissions from the public have been proactively disclosed, the committee rescind the order for the production of documents adopted on February 12, 2026. I need to move that motion now, obviously, and recognize that all the materials that were requested in that study are now available, and they're available online to anybody who wants them. It renders the direction of the committee moot, so I would put that on the floor now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104493","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I did have a number of other questions I wanted to ask you, but regrettably I actually have to move a motion, so I'm now going to do that. I want to thank you for the insightful response to that question. I want to move a motion that was put on notice earlier, and the motion reads: That, notwithstanding the motion adopted on February 12, 2026 on the disclosure of documents related to the AI Strate","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e2f386014f5e17a6bc2fc42dfc4fd55629b862f4c1289f723563adb1b0c5cb8b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b89f87c50045dbee596b3c75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104494,"date":"2026-05-25T22:10:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I do want to set the record straight on a couple of things, because my friend opposite.... I call him \"my friend\" because I do think of him in that way. I've had this conversation on several occasions. He also has met with individuals in the minister 's office, who explained to him the frustration that we have also had in getting information from the department in respect of the breakdown. Notwithstanding the above, we know exactly what the cost range is. More importantly, Madam Chair, what we also know is that the information the committee sought to find is now available publicly: 11,000 different submissions. I'm not entirely certain why there would be feigned outrage for information that is now available in the public domain. If folks are having a difficult time finding it, I will be glad to ensure that anybody who wants it has access to it. The reality here is that there was over a million dollars in costs to find, for this committee, stuff that is actually available in the form that it was previously submitted. To repackage it so that it addresses whatever it is that the opposition wants at a cost of $1.2 million or $1.3 million seems to be a bit of a waste of taxpayer dollars. Given that they speak about being the so-called party of fiscal prudence, I think they would be the ones who would be aghast that the government would be asked to spend money to package something in the way they want it packaged. The information is available. It's available to them. I would be glad to share it again with my colleagues if they would like it, but the idea that we would somehow be wasting money—and now time—to discuss this seems absolutely bananas.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104494","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I do want to set the record straight on a couple of things, because my friend opposite.... I call him \"my friend\" because I do think of him in that way. I've had this conversation on several occasions. He also has met with individuals in the minister 's office, who explained to him the frustration that we have also had in getting information from the department in respect o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8236fd9061855d838fd8db9b5fd06d556042e6f1b067ed6c3c9b5c8bbccccb02"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ab4b7b3a1432456e2711255426887c69e17668636a7225041a8b3806d9e7d13"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10c0762afd29655fcffc8220","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104495,"date":"2026-05-25T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. Given that this is clearly now getting into a lively debate, perhaps we might release our witnesses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104495","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. Given that this is clearly now getting into a lively debate, perhaps we might release our witnesses.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["37c841d64a7871bd2b41f18f0a4484c142607e2dec3a270c89280458a2e83b0c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d24d86dbfbabf78cd074f84","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104496,"date":"2026-05-25T22:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Awesome. I love it. Let's talk about space.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104496","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Awesome. I love it. Let's talk about space.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-468be1d75a548a132664bbad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021414,"date":"2026-05-26T22:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise this afternoon to speak to Bill C-264, and I will say at the outset what the central problem with this bill is. It is a one-line proposition dressed up as serious policy. It is a slogan in legislative form. It asks this Parliament to do something that the legislative record, the scientific record, the consultation record and the conservation record of this country have all decided against repeatedly over 50 years under prime ministers of every party. Perhaps we should take a walk down memory lane and look at history.\n\n In 1972, the House passed a resolution declaring that \"the movement of oil by tanker along the coast of British Columbia...is inimical to Canadian interests\". It said \"inimical\". That was the language of this Parliament in 1972.\n\n In 1985, a Conservative prime minister named Brian Mulroney established a voluntary tanker exclusion zone along the north coast of British Columbia. It was a Tory prime minister, a Tory cabinet and a Tory decision, and a good one at that.\n\n In 1988, that exclusion zone was formalized through coordination between the Canadian Coast Guard, the United States Coast Guard and the Reagan administration. A Conservative government and a Republican government worked together to protect the environment, imagine that. Now a Conservative opposition in Ottawa is working to undo exactly that.\n\nLet us think back to 1989. The Exxon Valdez ran aground in Prince William Sound. Thousands of kilometres of coastline were contaminated. A herring fishery collapsed and is still not yet fully recovered. Marine ecosystems were damaged in ways that are still being studied today. That disaster reinforced what Canadian governments had already concluded: The risk on that coast is unique, and the consequences of failure are too great. Members from British Columbia, particularly, are concerned about this. While I appreciate the concern for the environment from our members from Alberta, this is a particular problem that affects British Columbia, but it should affect the sensibility of all Canadians. \n\nFor 34 years, this voluntary moratorium held, through four Conservative prime ministers and four Liberal prime ministers. None of them moved to repeal it, and none of them tried.\n\n In 2017, our government introduced Bill C-48, the Oil Tanker Moratorium Act, to give that 34-year consensus the force of statute. It passed the House with support from members of four of five parties represented. That is the history, and that is what this slogan, or this bill, proposes to overturn.\n\n The members opposite are not making a science-based case for repeal. They are not bringing forward new evidence about the risk on the north coast. They are not presenting a new technology or a new spill response capacity that changes that calculus. They are not pointing to a change in the vulnerability of that coast. They are bringing forward a one-line bill, with no consultation, no indigenous engagement and no environmental review, that asks Parliament to undo half a century of careful policy because it might look good in a social media clip.\n\n I want to make a point that I think the members opposite have not fully thought through, and I say this in the spirit of genuine concern for the credibility of debate in this institution. If the members opposite truly believe that a pipeline to the north coast of British Columbia is the future of Canadian energy, passage of this bill would be the worst possible way to pursue that future. The moment that this bill comes to a vote, it would galvanize every coastal first nation, every B.C. municipality, every environmental organization, every one of us who is concerned about the environment and every legal team in the country who has spent decades preparing for exactly this fight. It would guarantee injunctions. It would guarantee litigation. It would guarantee gridlock. \n\nIf I were being cynical about it, I might encourage members opposite to proceed and encourage us to vote for it, to tie that up in the courts. Passing this bill would be the single most effective way to ensure that no pipeline ever gets built to the north coast of British Columbia, because the legal and political response that this bill on its own would trigger would be exactly that. That is not how to build big things in this country. That is how to make sure they never get built, and the proof of that is the years of Conservative government when not a single pipeline was built and no progress was made in protecting the environment, all at once. It was quite remarkable.\n\nLet us talk about the substantive case for why this moratorium should stand. First is the nature of the coast itself. The waters from the northern tip of Vancouver Island to the Alaska border are some of the most biologically productive seas on the planet, habitat for over 25 species of marine animals and spawning grounds for salmon runs that sustain ecosystems. This is not any ordinary coastline.\n\nThe second is the nature of that risk. Crude oil tankers are vessels carrying volumes of persistent oil that, in the event of a failure, cannot be cleaned up. A herring fishery collapsed after the Exxon Valdez, and as I said earlier, it has still not recovered. The Nathan E. Stewart tug ran aground near Bella Bella in 2016. There was a diesel spill, and the Heiltsuk Nation is still measuring the consequences of that a decade later.\n\n The third is the obligation to coastal first nations, something that seems like an inconvenience to members opposite. The Coastal First Nations alliance has made its position clear, repeatedly, for decades. They are rights holders whose constitutional position is at the centre of it. Those nations have spoken loud and clear, and I would encourage members opposite to speak to them directly to hear their voices.\n\n The fourth pillar is, of course, the alternatives. There is already a pipeline to tidewater in this country, TMX. Expanded and operational, it is moving Canadian energy to global markets through the port of Vancouver, where the safety architecture, the spill response capacity, the marine traffic management and the indigenous consultation frameworks are all built around that infrastructure. Canadian energy has access to the Pacific. It has access to the markets that it needs to be going to, and we are working hard to ensure that, in the cleanest, greenest way possible, we continue to make that possible under the right conditions. It does not need access at the cost of a coastline that this Parliament, 50 years ago, declared inimical to Canadian interests to put at risk.\n\nUnless every single box is checked and all of the criteria are met to the satisfaction of all parties involved, there is no reason for a new pipeline to go through the north coast. If the science has changed, if science tells us something different and if indigenous consultations tell us something different, then we should all be having that conversation, but a one-line bill that proposes to change history just because it would look good is not how serious governments should make decisions.\n\nThis is a government that believes in evidence. It is a government that believes in science. This is a government that believes in building a strong economy and protecting a healthy future for our environment. We believe these are not opposites. Quite the opposite, in fact, we believe they are part of the same future. \n\nWe have demonstrated that. We have ensured Trans Mountain's viability. We signed a Canada-Alberta memorandum of understanding, which put a $130-per-tonne price floor under industrial carbon pricing in Alberta. We have secured an agreement in principle for a 75% reduction in methane emissions from Alberta's oil and gas sector by 2035. We have launched a joint electricity working group with Alberta to build a net-zero grid by 2050, including transmission interties that will finally allow British Columbia to export clean hydroelectric power eastward.\n\n Let us also look at the facts. From 2014 to 2025, bitumen production in this country grew by 63%. Alberta's royalties from 2021 to 2025 totalled $58 billion, nearly four times what they were in the previous seven years combined. At the same time as this happened, under a Liberal government, we were also able to preserve and protect 6,700 square kilometres on the north coast of British Columbia, larger than the size of P.E.I., in a nature reserve.\n\n That is how intelligent, managed, evidence-based energy policy works. It looks like signing an MOU. It looks like pricing carbon, cutting methane, respecting indigenous rights and our natural environment, and protecting our coast. It looks like building big things and protecting what no amount of private sector intervention can replace. What it does not look like is a one-line bill repealing 50 years of conservation policy because it polls well in a fundraising email for Conservatives. We owe Canadians better than that. We owe the next generation better than that. My son is in the lobby watching this speech today. I owe him better than that. We all do. We owe the coastal communities of British Columbia better than that. The case for repeal has not been made.\n\n I will be voting against Bill C-264. I urge every member of the House who has a conscience, who cares about the coastline of British Columbia and who cares about our environmental future and about building a prosperous economy to do the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021414","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise this afternoon to speak to Bill C-264, and I will say at the outset what the central problem with this bill is. It is a one-line proposition dressed up as serious policy. It is a slogan in legislative form. It asks this Parliament to do something that the legislative record, the scientific record, the consultation record and the conservation record of this country have all deci","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","label":"Moratorium"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","label":"Moratorium","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["912689a71823b6130f372b5584d62159e6a0edaf122eab9fcfffb7663dae5659"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97509740d795c9349f20f5a569df96381a999e18525862e4c07792bee48172f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb80a6a9079e314b846eaaa1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104497,"date":"2026-06-01T21:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. I know my colleagues have been trying to finalize the answer to this. Ms. Hadwen, in one minute or less, can you please finish your answer on how you're working with the academic community to ensure they're ready for security requirements? I have very limited time, so if you can keep the answer brief that would be great.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104497","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. I know my colleagues have been trying to finalize the answer to this. Ms. Hadwen, in one minute or less, can you please finish your answer on how you're working with the academic community to ensure they're ready for security requirements? I have very limited time, so if you can keep the answer brief that would be great.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b103fd30dbc433f4abbf76e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104498,"date":"2026-06-01T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you very much. One of the things we hear a lot about when we talk to Canadian innovators and Canadian companies is that they want the Government of Canada and Canada's military to be their customer. Sometimes it is more challenging to become a customer of the Government of Canada or Canada's armed forces than it is to be the customer of other governments or other armed forces. What are some of the things we should be thinking about at this moment in time, when Canada is working on, and the Prime Minister is very clear on, making sure that we have our own independence, that we look at sovereignty as something that is essential, not optional? What are some of the things we need to be doing from a policy standpoint to ensure that those directions and that directive, and that sense of purpose for Canadian innovators being able to sell into Canada, the Canadian government...? And, of course, our armed forces is front of mind.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104498","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. One of the things we hear a lot about when we talk to Canadian innovators and Canadian companies is that they want the Government of Canada and Canada's military to be their customer. Sometimes it is more challenging to become a customer of the Government of Canada or Canada's armed forces than it is to be the customer of other governments or other armed forces. What are some ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3eef759447588d4ae9bce065638cafdc06d6898939369e59eae1e6c21ef4acf5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b5e0e1a9255b1edaed87aab18f40bd0ff9352c448ece81a27c659787f3cffbec"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6884986a1dc825d9b6619fb5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104499,"date":"2026-06-01T21:30:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"If we then go to the question of how BOREALIS can take this on intentionally, one of the concerns, obviously, is that these small and medium-sized businesses grow in Canada a little bit, they get customers elsewhere, and they recognize or they realize that perhaps they're not going to be able to continue their growth plan here. Of course, that's one thing we want to change, and obviously decisions that we're making are going to help inform that. What else should we be doing, and what are some of the things that you have seen, particularly through the work that BOREALIS is doing as it gets organized, in ensuring that those SMEs can become larger global players based in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104499","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If we then go to the question of how BOREALIS can take this on intentionally, one of the concerns, obviously, is that these small and medium-sized businesses grow in Canada a little bit, they get customers elsewhere, and they recognize or they realize that perhaps they're not going to be able to continue their growth plan here. Of course, that's one thing we want to change, and obviously decisions","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-500ca9d34c4ae4ec3a9c3610","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037348,"date":"2026-06-02T17:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for Madawaska—Restigouche.\n\nI would like to begin where this motion does not. I will not begin with the numbers, but with the people this motion is supposed to be about. Somewhere, today, there is a parent at a kitchen table, running the math on a mortgage renewal for a second time because the first answer could not possibly be right. There is a young person in the same house who did everything they were asked to and is now looking at the cost of a home and wondering whether this country still has room for them. I am not going to tell either of them that these things are better than they feel. They are actually not, and we all know that. That worry is real, and it deserves a serious response, which is exactly what this motion is not, so this is where I part ways with the member who put this motion forward.\n\nThe Conservative Party offers that family a story that all of this is the fault of one or two people, conjured in a single year, and that the cure, which the member just spoke about, is to simply tear things down. It is a tidy story. It asks nothing hard of the party that is telling it. It is a bid for power and a social media clip dressed up as an answer, but it is wrong. It is wrong about how we got here, and it is emptiest precisely where it ought to be the fullest, which is on what they would actually do instead. The members opposite are just about everything they are not and have no ideas about what we should be doing.\n\nLet us give that family an honest answer. The pressure did not arrive all at once. It built slowly over decades, through what successive governments of all stripes and at all levels chose to do and, far more often, chose to put off. There were too few homes built year after year, infrastructure was deferred and deferred again and productivity was left adrift while other countries pulled ahead. The one I know best is that, for decades, we let it become too hard to build big things in this country. Governments left the walls standing between our provinces so that it stayed easier to trade with another country than to trade with one another.\n\n None of it was inevitable. It was the accumulated cost of choosing not to act. The bill for everything that was waiting came up at the very moment the global economy was being torn up and rewritten. There are tariffs at levels not seen in generations and supply chains are fracturing under conflict in Europe and the Middle East. The Prime Minister has called this what it is: a rupture, not a transition.\n\nI did not come to this chamber as a political staffer. I did not grow up in politics. I came from building companies and creating actual jobs. I know what it takes to start something, to make payroll and to scale a business past the point that it is fragile.\n\n I know the patterns the members opposite never name. In this country, we generate world‐class research. We build competitive firms and then, sometimes, we watch the industrial scale, the intellectual property, the jobs and the talent migrate somewhere else. This pattern is not a law of nature, but a result of choices. This is a government that has finally made the other choice. It has chosen to back our champions, keep our IP here, keep jobs here, build talent here and let Canadian companies scale without having to leave Canada to do it ever again.\n\nWe have made it easier to build big things again with the Major Projects Office so that nation-building projects stop dying in the queue. Ground has already broken on projects, like the port expansion in Montreal, which will move Canadian goods to the world for decades, and there are four major projects in my own province of British Columbia. The One Canadian Economy Act tears down the internal trade walls I just described. We have a productivity superdeduction so that businesses can write off investment right away and have a reason to make it here. We have a plan to unlock $1 trillion in investment over the next five years. We have $6 billion and 100,000 new skilled trades workers through team Canada strong so that we have the hands to build what we approve. We have Build Canada Homes, which is not another task force, but an actual builder with more than 7,500 homes already under way in this country.\n\nHere is how I know it is working. It is showing up in my own province. Anglo Teck is choosing Canada as its headquarters, bringing blue- and white-collar jobs to British Columbia. Torys is opening up a new office in Vancouver. Lululemon is keeping its headquarters in British Columbia. These are companies that could plant their flag anywhere on earth, and they are choosing here because they see what British Columbia and Canada have to offer. They are betting on our prosperity. They would not place that bet on a country in decline.\n\nThe Conservatives are gleeful about the fact that there are challenges in this country. They propose no solutions and they continue to tear down, but what the rest of the world is seeing, through foreign direct investment, companies moving their headquarters here, talent coming to this country and researchers coming to this country, is that this is the place to build a future. That is because we have a Prime Minister and a government that are focused on that, know what it takes to build big things and are prepared to do the heavy lifting to get it done.\n\n The wider proof is real. Wages have outpaced inflation every single month this government has been in office. Foreign investment, as I said, is flowing to us faster now than it is to any of our closest peers. It is at an 18‐year high. Canada has now surpassed the United States as the most attractive market in the world for infrastructure investment. Our economy is now projected to grow the second fastest in the G7 this year and next. To me, this is not the portrait of a country in retreat, but a country that has decided to build again.\n\nThe member opposite asked the government to \"immediately...reverse all the economic policies\" that got us here. I would ask him to be honest about what that actually means. Does it mean reversing the Major Projects Office? Does it mean eliminating the superdeduction that rewards firms for investing in this country? Does it mean eliminating the work to tear down the walls between our provinces or the $6 billion for 100,000 new tradespeople?\n\n While he is at it, let him tell that family at the kitchen table which of their savings he means to take back. Is it the national school food program, which his own party has called \"garbage\"? Is it the child care that his party leader calls a \"slush fund\", which has benefited people in his own riding? Is it the dental care that seniors in his communities are currently benefiting from? Are those the programs he would choose to roll back?\n\nTo the Conservatives, the help that gets a family through the month is a line item that they sneer at. It is something to be looked down upon. To us, it is precisely the point. It is lifting families up so that they can build success. We cannot rip out the scaffolding and claw back what families are counting on and call that a plan to build.\n\nI understand the impatience. After this many years and decades of building too little, Canadians have every right to be impatient, but impatience is not a reason to stop building and tear out the scaffolding. It is a reason to build faster. A family having a tough time does not need a politician to name their fear back to them, only louder. They have lived that fear. They do not need it performed as political theatre. The young person wondering if there is room for their future in this country does not need another performance of outrage from the members opposite, which has, sadly, become the only thing they seem to know how to do. Young people need us to build something worthy of their trust, and that is what our government has chosen to do.\n\nIn times of crisis and in times of difficulty, Canadians expect us to come together and build big things. They expect us to put aside pettiness and all of the things we cannot do to focus on the things we can and should do. They expect us to show up with solutions.\n\nAll of us who have kids know that when we have difficult conversations with them, a temper tantrum is not the way to a solution. Resolution comes through doing things together and showing by example. The Conservatives would have us believe that by ripping up the paper, tossing our toys and walking away, we are somehow going to build a stronger economy. That is not how economies are built. They are built by people who are prepared to invest in this country, which we are seeing now in record numbers. We are seeing that through workers who are prepared to be retrained today for the jobs of the future. That is what we are seeing. It comes with governments that are prepared to match the ambition Canadians have with what they need, which are the resources and the support to be able to get to those places.\n\nDanielle Smith talked about how working with this Prime Minister is a joy. David Eby talked about how working with this government is a joy. I am really curious to know how provincial governments, from Wab Kinew's and David Eby's to Doug Ford's and Danielle Smith's, look at this government and say this is a government they can work with, yet the Conservatives sit there and wonder why their poll numbers keep going down and Canadians refuse to return them to office. It is because premiers of all parties have recognized that this is a government that is prepared to work hard for Canadians, build things for Canadians and invest in the type of economy that Canadians want to see built in this country for a future their kids can look at and be proud of.\n\nYes, we all know that times are tough. When times are tough, we work together. We are providing solutions to people to give them the supports they need to get through this period. We are showing them a path to a brighter future with the dollars, supports, commitments and, most importantly, the compassion and hope to be able to deliver on big things. We are doing that. We are backing it up by having the provinces and the private sector working with us.\n\n I encourage the Conservatives to stop the slogans and get to work for Canadians with us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037348","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for Madawaska—Restigouche.\n\nI would like to begin where this motion does not. I will not begin with the numbers, but with the people this motion is supposed to be about. Somewhere, today, there is a parent at a kitchen table, running the math on a mortgage renewal for a second time because the first answer could not possibly be right. There is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fc02ed1174d3a8959fe9abe300f37a2cc4f9c55725e88cd94c864de2496ee93"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30020a22c3a2e0a1c0587c08ae80b17ea655d6380aed0888f12bc1ee6d1047e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae76d57e0e50029399dc9be8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037350,"date":"2026-06-02T17:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am not sure exactly what the question was. It sounded yet again like a litany of complaints and no new ideas, which is exactly what the opposition is devoid of.\n\n Perhaps I could tell them something they might be hopeful about. In my province of British Columbia, there are now four projects at the Major Projects Office. I understand that the Government of Alberta is looking forward to putting forward a proposition to be able to get energy resources to tidewater. It seems that the provinces, the country and the private sector are working together to ensure that we are building things.\n\nI understand the impatience on the other side. After all, the bill was passed less than a year ago. However, they somehow expect mines to spring out of the ground, mills to be built overnight and pipelines to randomly show up. People who have actually built things know that is not how things get done in this country, and it is not how we build real, resilient infrastructure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037350","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am not sure exactly what the question was. It sounded yet again like a litany of complaints and no new ideas, which is exactly what the opposition is devoid of.\n\n Perhaps I could tell them something they might be hopeful about. In my province of British Columbia, there are now four projects at the Major Projects Office. I understand that the Government of Alberta is looking forward ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5f026e6b7dd94cb42bb0e4b17c31a89483b0b6d91d09a94b390cbb133e03d190"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1fca0c30815dc595e7ac64a902c02d1a81d97ea9299af8dd5f3d4511bcc9dc9b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55c778027dc3e79bfadfe629","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037351,"date":"2026-06-02T17:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if we look at the number of trade agreements we now have with countries around the world, we can see that countries are seeking to invest in Canada. Whether they are countries in the Middle East or Europe, or our partners in the EU, more and more countries are looking at Canada with confidence as the place to invest. Why? It is because there is a government they can trust and rely on. There are Canadian workers who have talent and are the best in the world. We have research and researchers in this country coming up with the ideas of the future today.\n\n They see the convergence of those three things as a recipe for success and a place where they can place a bet, and they know our word means something.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037351","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if we look at the number of trade agreements we now have with countries around the world, we can see that countries are seeking to invest in Canada. Whether they are countries in the Middle East or Europe, or our partners in the EU, more and more countries are looking at Canada with confidence as the place to invest. Why? It is because there is a government they can trust and rely on.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5adf8abddc42f3b498d88c3d9e53cb9a0543d47ae176cdea4b037768e372c55"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["548cd62e9f120a2b3bca2b9550515fb6408a48e3bc77c7bf33bb66f3d1bde70e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e133a4fb0f94b495765f4fa2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037352,"date":"2026-06-02T17:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in English, we say we should be able to walk and chew gum at the same time.\n\nWe believe we need to work toward resolving the issue of U.S. tariffs. That is what we are doing. At the same time, we believe it is important to diversify our trade with other countries. That is why we have succeeded in establishing agreements with other countries for Canadian products, thereby creating opportunities for Canada to diversify—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037352","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in English, we say we should be able to walk and chew gum at the same time.\n\nWe believe we need to work toward resolving the issue of U.S. tariffs. That is what we are doing. At the same time, we believe it is important to diversify our trade with other countries. That is why we have succeeded in establishing agreements with other countries for Canadian products, thereby creating oppo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c5f7b8b16f36f5bbcc870f8f8d5f295cb25ec89d170367cf37313d5318ec055"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["968df15830e8f319514d3a7bc0471977b7e1c043b7520ddefab8618956050d7a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6526c0c34cdd0156a743f7bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104500,"date":"2026-06-08T21:40:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104500","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ff7c241f90790833f7ed66c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104501,"date":"2026-06-08T21:40:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"The witness is here in her capacity as the chief science adviser. Her opinion on any matter, as an individual, is actually not relevant to her mandate. I would be interested to see if Mr. Ho could reframe the question, if he so wishes, to be within her mandate as the chief science adviser.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104501","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The witness is here in her capacity as the chief science adviser. Her opinion on any matter, as an individual, is actually not relevant to her mandate. I would be interested to see if Mr. Ho could reframe the question, if he so wishes, to be within her mandate as the chief science adviser.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f098155e074595d1f0f40bb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104502,"date":"2026-06-08T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you so much. Thank you for being here, Dr. Nemer. It's a pleasure to see you again. I'm sorry that you have to endure some of the absurdities of this committee, but it's good to have you again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104502","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you so much. Thank you for being here, Dr. Nemer. It's a pleasure to see you again. I'm sorry that you have to endure some of the absurdities of this committee, but it's good to have you again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b81892b9710a5431f13f71aceac38d723ef3b6a55a80ec98e814371f6f024b1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f805e788e63e7ad5b493d393","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104503,"date":"2026-06-08T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"It's my time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104503","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's my time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-652853eb68093db74fce5e31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104504,"date":"2026-06-08T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you. While I didn't reference anyone in particular, if the shoe fits, as they say.... I'd like to begin by asking you a few questions quickly, sort of rapid-fire. There was this conversation about demographic targets. In your experience, in your current or past roles, have you ever heard of somebody hired as a scientist who did a lesser job because they were a person of colour or a woman?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104504","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. While I didn't reference anyone in particular, if the shoe fits, as they say.... I'd like to begin by asking you a few questions quickly, sort of rapid-fire. There was this conversation about demographic targets. In your experience, in your current or past roles, have you ever heard of somebody hired as a scientist who did a lesser job because they were a person of colour or a woman?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ce82eab1514946398035872","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104505,"date":"2026-06-08T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"We put $1.7 billion to recruit 1,000 of the top researchers in the world to come to Canada. Is it your view that the criteria currently in place will allow Canada to attract the best and the brightest in the world, regardless of issues...as they seem to be put across?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104505","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We put $1.7 billion to recruit 1,000 of the top researchers in the world to come to Canada. Is it your view that the criteria currently in place will allow Canada to attract the best and the brightest in the world, regardless of issues...as they seem to be put across?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["171b5ebe2d5085f84df386d5f53463781225d549fb231c8836fbf294143f6361"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec5c117b219b577182746ffde1c84b73303fe14a6014b43738cebf96735c53eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cea82c892e954bf3f11ef4a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104506,"date":"2026-06-08T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I would like my time back.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104506","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I would like my time back.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8429fd251db612ec5d3f97f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104507,"date":"2026-06-08T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"The question was this. We put $1.7 billion on the table to hire the top researchers. Do you see any issues with the criteria that are currently in place to help us attract the best and the brightest scientists in the world?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104507","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The question was this. We put $1.7 billion on the table to hire the top researchers. Do you see any issues with the criteria that are currently in place to help us attract the best and the brightest scientists in the world?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","label":"Science education","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8829adccf11c15b2216776d917f45e9b093d483bdd94e42f086a5d40ce9ce91"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["08bc1e11b5a580ff1eeec836b425b26591303752a353b6a117b9a40d6273e6c1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d40cfcb8c3d5f629e5af6494","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104508,"date":"2026-06-08T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"You and I both, and certainly those of us who believe in science, also feel that way. You will recall the 2013 muzzling of scientists under the Harper government. How long did it take scientists and government to recover from that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104508","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You and I both, and certainly those of us who believe in science, also feel that way. You will recall the 2013 muzzling of scientists under the Harper government. How long did it take scientists and government to recover from that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7925be2e69c5bcebe5a3eb4370c638923708d2ba4b1bc305f4bacefb04e06b7b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc4307882b4dee813a57f2b32756d62371f9da802c509dc21dbc26fd3cadf931"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5fdb155be344a35007bdd8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104509,"date":"2026-06-08T21:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"That's perfect. That sounds great. Obviously, one of the things that we had seen in previous governments was a cut to science and research. What does that do in terms of the recruitment of talent when there is a concern that the stable funding will not be available? How important is it to have the stable funding that we've articulated now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104509","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's perfect. That sounds great. Obviously, one of the things that we had seen in previous governments was a cut to science and research. What does that do in terms of the recruitment of talent when there is a concern that the stable funding will not be available? How important is it to have the stable funding that we've articulated now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4f640a41029dbaa60ede734","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104510,"date":"2026-06-08T21:50:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"That's perfect. You're a scientist. You're the chief science adviser of this country. You have helped to run research at a university. What are the damaging—and I shouldn't say damaging, because I don't want to prejudice the answer—implications when politicians start to question science and start to question the credibility of science for political gain?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104510","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's perfect. You're a scientist. You're the chief science adviser of this country. You have helped to run research at a university. What are the damaging—and I shouldn't say damaging, because I don't want to prejudice the answer—implications when politicians start to question science and start to question the credibility of science for political gain?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Laboratories","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","label":"Laboratories","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fa1a1a75b6baf3e86def845d5a39325fe175ecbc514364b67033177aabc8ff6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c84097cf6c4794ad2e861fa1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104511,"date":"2026-06-08T21:50:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I want to thank you for being here. You should rest assured that, on this side, we will always support science and scientists. While the clip factory opposite will do what it does, we're going to keep working hard to ensure that scientists and the top researchers can come to this country and feel that they are safe and secure to do the important research they need to do. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104511","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I want to thank you for being here. You should rest assured that, on this side, we will always support science and scientists. While the clip factory opposite will do what it does, we're going to keep working hard to ensure that scientists and the top researchers can come to this country and feel that they are safe and secure to do the important research they need to do. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","label":"Science education","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5b179632fde8a178916263e9065a0da878651a9b732d258a81cd554e419f764"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e4751bb4f00121fcc077bda3141100a60e28f37097ae06de8c728679140b23d4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56a8b49df65b9b647ae4afaf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104512,"date":"2026-06-08T22:20:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104512","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf03aa0f97fb50a274c0e106","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104513,"date":"2026-06-08T22:20:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Is this within the scope of the chief science adviser?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104513","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is this within the scope of the chief science adviser?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","label":"Science education","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0058a70e487c134278a678424e07896a768a06c2c7fc380afdc6b46ea2856c2b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22cfa84a394cdfcff76fb398","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104514,"date":"2026-06-08T22:25:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"It's a great question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104514","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's a great question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-133719f6602ba597230e5623","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104515,"date":"2026-06-08T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you so much. It's nice to be able to ask you a few more questions. I want to go back to the conversation we were having about previous cuts and the challenges those have posed. Programs like the polar environment atmospheric research lab and the Experimental Lakes Area had their funding cut by the previous Conservative government. What has the restoration of these long-term programs meant for Canada's ability to track and respond to climate change?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104515","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you so much. It's nice to be able to ask you a few more questions. I want to go back to the conversation we were having about previous cuts and the challenges those have posed. Programs like the polar environment atmospheric research lab and the Experimental Lakes Area had their funding cut by the previous Conservative government. What has the restoration of these long-term programs meant fo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8e14f754b52458143bd6306","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104516,"date":"2026-06-08T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I'm so pleased you said that, and I'd like to spend a bit of time on it. You've been in this role now for a little while. Before that, as we know, you led research at a major university. Can you speak to the existential threat to scientists and science in the face of misinformation and what I would call \"armchair quarterbacking\" on social media? What does that mean for research, researchers and, perhaps more importantly, public acceptance of scientific fact?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104516","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm so pleased you said that, and I'd like to spend a bit of time on it. You've been in this role now for a little while. Before that, as we know, you led research at a major university. Can you speak to the existential threat to scientists and science in the face of misinformation and what I would call \"armchair quarterbacking\" on social media? What does that mean for research, researchers and, p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["157599ce40247e402f3507fb64ea3912fe768e0c57f248f7d20414a21405dcb1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2f1e2ac24a4edbcf76aa5071520c3fe0d7eae78cf626ba66991eb7ae735a379b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb789158e79c4032ee3884e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104517,"date":"2026-06-08T23:00:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I want to double-click a bit on this now, and then I want to layer on the misinformation around equity of hiring. As you rightly pointed out, there is no difference in quality when Canadians are well represented in research. You've made it very clear that there's never been a degradation in the quality of the research, the quality of the academics or academia and what the outcomes of that research are. What is the added impact, positive or negative, when people believe that somehow science is being degraded or the quality of the work is being done more poorly, when we look to expand the number of folks in the research realm?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104517","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I want to double-click a bit on this now, and then I want to layer on the misinformation around equity of hiring. As you rightly pointed out, there is no difference in quality when Canadians are well represented in research. You've made it very clear that there's never been a degradation in the quality of the research, the quality of the academics or academia and what the outcomes of that research","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a3261c01441db6d0d2a9500954e8e2896069598fd05840f435eeaf2823fa7bc7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48f1dc2b4c1c32969c42da8672abab46a8ec686512a545293ebf6252b0d6c8c4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be402595af3aa24b8235d703","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104518,"date":"2026-06-08T23:05:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Just to be clear, it's without any impact on the quality of the research.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104518","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Just to be clear, it's without any impact on the quality of the research.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f8617670bcf3f2325b21f4e0dd496454917f87613075fcf89f63fedae84bcc8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2dbd5147529e2fb7d34a14a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085110,"date":"2026-06-08T23:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we all know we are living through one of the most dangerous and divided moments the world has seen in generations. We all know the pressure that is coming toward Canadians is not coming from just one direction, but all directions at once. We know our closest ally and trading partner has imposed tariffs at levels we have not seen in living memory. Wars are being fought in Europe and the Middle East. Supply chains that took decades to build are being fractured in real time. All of this is unfolding against a technological transformation that is defining what work and our economy will look like a decade from now and, indeed, in less than a decade from now.\n\n This is not a normal moment, and most Canadians know it. They feel it at the grocery till and at mortgage renewal. A young person feels it doing the math on a first home. We all understand that. We all understand the concerns and the risks, and we all understand that it is our job to figure out how to make it better.\n\nNo honest account of how we got here points to a single villain or a single year. This has taken decades, across governments of every stripe in a country where it has become simply too hard to build, too hard to get major projects off the ground, too hard to keep our best talent, research and companies from leaving to go elsewhere and too hard to turn ideas into industry. These are not partisan accusations. They are an inheritance for every single one of us in the chamber from decades and decades of action.\n\nThe question before the House is not whether the moment is hard. We all know it is. The question is what a serious government does about it. What this government has chosen to do is focus relentlessly on what is within our control. We have established a Major Projects Office to make sure that we can get nation-building projects built and that they do not die in a queue. We passed the One Canadian Economy Act to make sure that we tear down the internal trade walls that made it absurdly easier to trade with another country than with the next province over. Our productivity superdeduction gives businesses a reason to invest here and now. Build Canada Homes is already building thousands of homes. Through team Canada strong, we are putting $6 billion behind 100,000 new skilled trade workers, because we cannot build what we approve without the hands to build it.\n\n Here is the part that the members opposite will never mention, because it is not convenient: We are doing this with people, not against them. Premiers of every political stripe, Liberal, Conservative and New Democrat, and even Danielle Smith have found that this government is a partner with whom they can actually work. That is what governing in a time of crisis actually looks like. We put down the partisan cudgel, we pick up the tools and we work together.\n\nThis brings me to the motion from the Leader of the Opposition that is before us today, because it was definitely not written in that spirit. It is not an offer to build. It is not an offer to think about how we might work together. It is not even an honest account of where we are. It is, yet again, performative theatre.\n\n I want to take a moment to focus on a single word that is at the centre of it. The motion does not say \"a difficult quarter\". It does not say \"a slowdown\". It reaches, in the very first line, for the biggest word available: \"recession\".\n\n There is a body that all of us have recognized, whose entire job is to decide whether that word applies. It is the C.D. Howe Institute's business cycle council. Trusted by Conservatives and Liberals alike, it is the organization that has effectively been trusted as the organization that determines whether we are, in fact, in a recession, and it has not said that. It is not a Liberal organization. It is not a Liberal press release or a Conservative press release that gets to decide this. It is the council that called the 2008 financial crisis and the council that called the COVID downturn. When the real thing arrives, that council is the one that names it, not politicians.\n\nThree days ago, the council looked at exactly the same data the Leader of the Opposition is brandishing, and it refused to use his word. It found the decline so slight, at a fraction of a single per cent, that it does not even come close to any recession it has ever declared, and it warned in very clear terms that it is precisely this kind of label placed upon it by politicians and stapled onto numbers like these that causes further problems, because it is designed to sound official and frightening.\n\nThe country's own referees, the people who called the 2008 recession and the COVID downturn, looked at this and would not go there. The Leader of the Opposition decided that it is his job to go and write a bigger word than theirs into a motion. Let us ask the question that the motion was built to stop anyone from asking: Why?\n\nWhy would the Leader of the Opposition reach past the experts, as is custom for him, for the most frightening word he could find? Why does he need a slowdown to be a catastrophe? Why is it valuable for him to cast fear into the hearts of Canadians, who are already facing challenging times, which we all acknowledge? It is because, for him, the catastrophe becomes a permission slip.\n\n A slowdown asks the government to steady the ship and keep building, but a catastrophe is the only thing that could ever justify what this motion actually demands, which is to reverse the policies. We should say what is clearly hiding inside that intention. Reversing the policies means taking away the dental care that seniors are using right now. Taking away child care means telling the parents at Butterfly Kisses, a child care centre in his own riding that has brought fees down for working families, that those working families will no longer be able to access the subsidies that make it possible for children in his riding to access affordable child care. Reversing the policies means taking away the national school food program that feeds children before they sit down to learn.\n\n Whether they are in Carleton or Battle River—Crowfoot, Canadians are asking for the same things. They are asking for dental care, child care and certainty and stability in the government. They are looking for leadership that not only tells them that things will be all right, but shows them a path and takes the action to do so by building consensus.\n\n The Leader of the Opposition wants rubble he can stand in. That is what reversing the policies means once we start performing the word \"recession\" in pantomime or theatre in this place and start reading the fine print. They cannot rip the floor out from underneath people over a fraction of 1%. They can only do it if they first convince the country, as they are seeking to do, that the house is on fire.\n\nThe Leader of the Opposition needs catastrophe. He needs the fire, but not because the data supports it. He does not. He needs it because without it, there is no excuse for what he is selling Canadians. Without it, there is little reason for toxic leadership from his side. That is the real divide in this chamber, and it could not be starker. One side is working to convince Canadians, alongside premiers, Conservatives, Liberals and New Democrats that it is time to work together and build things, and another side is saying the building we are trying to build together is condemned so that no one objects when they start tearing down the walls.\n\nOn this side, we are going to keep building. That building is showing up in results where people live and in what they will experience.\n\nIn B.C., which is my home province, the merger that created Anglo Teck has planted a new global mining champion headquarters in Vancouver, with thousands of Canadian jobs and billions of dollars in investment secured here at home. That is talent and capital choosing Canada at the very moment when the members opposite insist that Canada is collapsing.\n\nThe OECD, which is by no means a Liberal agency, projects that this country will grow the second-fastest in the G7 this year and next—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085110","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we all know we are living through one of the most dangerous and divided moments the world has seen in generations. We all know the pressure that is coming toward Canadians is not coming from just one direction, but all directions at once. We know our closest ally and trading partner has imposed tariffs at levels we have not seen in living memory. Wars are being fought in Europe and th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic sanctions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","label":"Oral health","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","label":"Economic sanctions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fd57ee108d05bda6b8515473be13161e26080889d7796eb1b5c48db0eb6b3b0f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80d4b848d2f2588a0e51397e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104519,"date":"2026-06-11T16:40:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I thank the witnesses for being here. Mr. Yurichuk, I am from British Columbia, so I'm not going to hold against you the fact that you won a Grey Cup with the Argos, but it does allow me to ask you one important question. What's the total value of federal government contracts that you've had at Wuxly?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104519","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I thank the witnesses for being here. Mr. Yurichuk, I am from British Columbia, so I'm not going to hold against you the fact that you won a Grey Cup with the Argos, but it does allow me to ask you one important question. What's the total value of federal government contracts that you've had at Wuxly?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf6023d387bb1549621c2cff4320c57435e64b4839d595df2a32a4caf724a602"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a83ecda4592b959cfa937196e35c8ab6d15aa0e58b6a4fb90dda4a3deaf83889"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fa6deacd63d108a0bba486f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104520,"date":"2026-06-11T16:40:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"What proportion of your total business would that make up?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104520","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What proportion of your total business would that make up?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["138a2c643b41ad8fa62fdd9c61b45d9d697e05813d1a0a7fc289bbc30944149a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02422c5ebbf31ca3ae5f99a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104521,"date":"2026-06-11T16:40:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Is it fair to say that you are seeing a substantial benefit because of the Canadian government's procuring from you?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104521","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is it fair to say that you are seeing a substantial benefit because of the Canadian government's procuring from you?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26ff80ba3915079af896ea6dba72d14942ca68d94777d9e9d211750bc1a598fc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4eff2aa5c411f0fca3c202c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104522,"date":"2026-06-11T16:40:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"You've been critical of some components of the government's approach. As we look toward buying more Canadian and ensuring not only that Canadian suppliers have the best products, which we clearly do, but also that the means by which to acquire them is in place, I think we would all agree that these things don't happen overnight. Over the course of how long have you seen your trajectory of government business grow?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104522","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You've been critical of some components of the government's approach. As we look toward buying more Canadian and ensuring not only that Canadian suppliers have the best products, which we clearly do, but also that the means by which to acquire them is in place, I think we would all agree that these things don't happen overnight. Over the course of how long have you seen your trajectory of governme","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3e56845a90ac7f91675ec6f62e8920ac4565c366f903f8ccbc2f2ed8cc7f18d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57053f974e48f368e668ea26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104523,"date":"2026-06-11T16:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"Walk me through this. I hear this, and I want to make sure that you are selling more to Canada and doing more. You just said that 60% to 70% of your business is done with the Canadian government—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104523","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Walk me through this. I hear this, and I want to make sure that you are selling more to Canada and doing more. You just said that 60% to 70% of your business is done with the Canadian government—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","label":"Maple products","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","label":"Indigenous businesses","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d7558fb9198a87db97e8fdd1dca5bdf6bc91b30165ca2c3d1e594c16133f901"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24b7ac8efef85e5bb3ddda04","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104524,"date":"2026-06-11T16:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"—but you say you're selling more abroad. Walk me through that logic.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104524","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"—but you say you're selling more abroad. Walk me through that logic.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33f6f3cae96e6989c39179ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104525,"date":"2026-06-11T16:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"That's important. It would be great, as we expand the amount that we're acquiring and as we expand the spending—and it's on truly unprecedented levels—to ensure that we're doing that. You know that buying Canadian is a priority, so companies like yours that have the experience, I would imagine, would be part of that conversation, but I don't want to understate the point that the Government of Canada has been part of your business, and we're glad that you're doing that. It's important for all of us, but it's also important for us to make sure we're giving the feedback that helps to do those things, which I hope these conversations do. I'll turn to you, Mr. Perry. One thing that is important for all of us is that those of us who have had to build companies did that outside this country and raised capital outside this country. Historically, it's been harder for Canadian companies to acquire and raise capital in this country and to build their businesses here. I would submit that this has happened regardless of political party. There has been, over the course of the last number of decades, in fact, this view that in order to be successful, you have to go outside. I think for the first time in our history we've reached a moment at which Canadians are saying, \"Actually, do you know what? Being Canadian and investing in Canada matter.\" This should matter, and it should be what drives us. You and the companies you are affiliated with are dealing with investors. How do we unlock, particularly in dual use—in which there's a huge opportunity right now—the investor psychology to say that investing in Canada first and investing in Canadian companies and in Canadian start-ups right now is what matters so that those companies are in a position for government to be their first and best customer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104525","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's important. It would be great, as we expand the amount that we're acquiring and as we expand the spending—and it's on truly unprecedented levels—to ensure that we're doing that. You know that buying Canadian is a priority, so companies like yours that have the experience, I would imagine, would be part of that conversation, but I don't want to understate the point that the Government of Cana","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15ccb8a3dc9243ce9dee5fac7741dbb12139701209294cfa9e0cc8dfbd93da4e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f5ae08d85fec9069d2f43798ab3e82e71d4a9367ef42f13bb757fde58121024"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d49e00b62ba34e6e02db5d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104526,"date":"2026-06-11T17:45:00+00:00","title":"SRSR","speaker":"Taleeb Noormohamed","venue":"SRSR","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. Could we stop the clock? I couldn't hear the answer fully. Could you ask the witness to repeat the answer, please? I couldn't hear it properly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SRSR/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104526","member_id":"bc-mp-72023","member_name":"Taleeb Noormohamed","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. Could we stop the clock? I couldn't hear the answer fully. Could you ask the witness to repeat the answer, please? I couldn't hear it properly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf1f418354cb1f21ef1023efadfbe5d6da17ae980fd1cbc4206ac00e20e79293"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7032ace5a3c41dce11371aac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70473,"date":"2026-01-27T16:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate being in the chamber to hear the speech from the hon. member from Manitoba. She has done an excellent job at the industry committee.\n\nIn her speech, the member touched upon the need to have more Canadian innovation, particularly Canadian patents that are held in Canada. I know of several entrepreneurs who have told me that it can be years for the patents office, which has one job, to approve patents that can be used here in Canada. Entrepreneurs said that many of them will go to the United States instead, not because they do not want to have the IP here in Canada but because they get protections immediately because the United States has a faster process.\n\nDoes the member believe that the minister responsible should make this her job, in order to fix that one job the patent office has, which is to approve patents that are worthy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76844","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Patents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70473","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate being in the chamber to hear the speech from the hon. member from Manitoba. She has done an excellent job at the industry committee.\n\nIn her speech, the member touched upon the need to have more Canadian innovation, particularly Canadian patents that are held in Canada. I know of several entrepreneurs who have told me that it can be years for the patents office, which h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76844","label":"Patents"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76844","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Patents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76844","label":"Patents","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fd2ce98f35a693bab23ae37f50a0ba0f9216f68094c137bd513c2d08c62a4d91"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76844","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Patents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e64ea6603f6bfe24177319db00a7ff1e7efef93f5755199c737b7bc7c75c720"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76844","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Patents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76844","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d61f7743e868a61510c57356","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70474,"date":"2026-01-29T17:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister often says that we should focus on what we can control. Well, I agree. His government controls the industrial carbon tax and the fuel standard regulations that have driven our food inflation to double that of the U.S.\n\nA family of four now pays $17,600 a year, while two million Canadians line up at food banks, so which is it? Is the government driving up fuel costs to inflate the price of fertilizer and other farm inputs to satisfy its radical targets, or does the Prime Minister not see that taxing the tractor and then taxing the trucker ultimately means less food on Canadians' dinner tables?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70474","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister often says that we should focus on what we can control. Well, I agree. His government controls the industrial carbon tax and the fuel standard regulations that have driven our food inflation to double that of the U.S.\n\nA family of four now pays $17,600 a year, while two million Canadians line up at food banks, so which is it? Is the government driving up fuel costs ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["abca176ea2ea36dc12382f47af63ec44aa55412ffc20b19ad0fae676455124d7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9b37dfbea6d9f0ec706ce7f0cdeac8ea3c8da76f1326d746485871d6e3516d62"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a91e74c27da0ad9d66496699","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70475,"date":"2026-01-29T17:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister often speaks about the levers they can pull. He keeps slamming one called permanent grocery price hikes. His fuel tax fixation adds seven cents today and will rocket to 17¢ a litre, an outright hunger hike hitting every part of our food supply chain.\n\nWhen will the Liberal government finally show some common sense and pull the lever that pauses this food cost explosion, or is it simply intent on letting more Canadians go hungry to protect its radical ideology?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70475","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister often speaks about the levers they can pull. He keeps slamming one called permanent grocery price hikes. His fuel tax fixation adds seven cents today and will rocket to 17¢ a litre, an outright hunger hike hitting every part of our food supply chain.\n\nWhen will the Liberal government finally show some common sense and pull the lever that pauses this food cost explos","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["803dfd48caa0ac65be8f8f17563a15a2fc4aa7e78eecb81bd37daf241cb12a96"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56f2eac84fcb52f7647e2a55a369d7b279f7eda29aea9ea36876808a5ecdbeac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2dc8fbac375abfb24782bf6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77499,"date":"2026-02-03T20:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.\n\nThe Secretary of State for Sport referenced the \"temporary\" member for Battle River—Crowfoot. It is in the Standing Orders that we are supposed to use either the title of the leader of the official opposition or the name of the riding. To add any adverbs or adjectives undermines the decorum in this place, and as someone who is part of the government, he should know better.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77499","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.\n\nThe Secretary of State for Sport referenced the \"temporary\" member for Battle River—Crowfoot. It is in the Standing Orders that we are supposed to use either the title of the leader of the official opposition or the name of the riding. To add any adverbs or adjectives undermines the decorum in this place, and as someone who is part of the government, he sh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["accbcc55d1f7a1df04a096445c00d535068ea0a59430020c7c9d0475cbae833a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce29870eb8630b9bc4d3c94b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":97218,"date":"2026-02-10T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after 10 years of Liberal government, food inflation is double what it was when the Prime Minister took office and double that of the United States. Food bank use has more than doubled, and now bankruptcies are up, the highest they have been since the financial crisis, clocking in at a shocking 10.6% in British Columbia.\n\n Will the government admit that its taxes and deficits are driving Canadians into food banks and into bankruptcy, or will it just claim that everything is fine, proving that it is totally out of touch with reality?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97218","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after 10 years of Liberal government, food inflation is double what it was when the Prime Minister took office and double that of the United States. Food bank use has more than doubled, and now bankruptcies are up, the highest they have been since the financial crisis, clocking in at a shocking 10.6% in British Columbia.\n\n Will the government admit that its taxes and deficits are driv","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","label":"Bankruptcies"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","label":"Bankruptcies","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1c2a330a72dc3edbcc8abfa2dc87adba761c22743dca995acbb3d48304efe416"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["350f1f06beba05fe0dc6e230382055a7bc816d9360cb33d4cfe18306ecc2628e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-045b9747e184f94f3b9afbfe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":314925,"date":"2026-02-23T22:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Cassidy deVeer and Krista Paine from the Central Okanagan Canadian Home Builder's Association expressed many of the same concerns to me when they visited about the national building code and increased costs. I give the member that point.\n\nIn the bill, it talks about developing land and constructing housing in Canada. That is better than what the Canada Infrastructure Bank has done with funding Chinese vessels outside of Canada. It is nice to see that the Liberals have actually put some limitations in the bill. \n\nAs I read through the entire bill, there is no designation to say that it must use Canadian products, such as wood. I would simply ask if this member believes the government has made a mistake. It says it is going to use Canadian wood, but that is not in the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314925","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Cassidy deVeer and Krista Paine from the Central Okanagan Canadian Home Builder's Association expressed many of the same concerns to me when they visited about the national building code and increased costs. I give the member that point.\n\nIn the bill, it talks about developing land and constructing housing in Canada. That is better than what the Canada Infrastructure Bank has done wit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","label":"Forestry technology","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c8ebed586860b7baf11cb1c9a010c9b94d21e61b0282b6a44c351127a04ed5a5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-200f6aa69135632da7ed9f69","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304986,"date":"2026-02-25T23:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to rise on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna, in the beautiful interior of British Columbia.\n\nBill C-15 is an omnibus piece of legislation, and the Liberals, in their various forms of government, like in the Trudeau era and now followed by the new Prime Minister, have staked out that the omnibus is a perfectly legitimate piece of legislation. They throw essentially everything, including the kitchen sink, in there. What happens when we throw in the kitchen sink? It means we cannot keep our hands clean anymore.\n\n One of the problems that we have in this particular bill is around the high-speed rail network act. The government is making an effort to get in front of an announcement and say, \"Look at us. Look at all the great things we are doing.\" We will have a project with very scant details that was first announced by the previous prime minister and then re-announced by the government and cited as part of the building Canada legislation, Bill C-5. By the way, the Liberals still have not gotten around to designating it formally under the act, as is required by law.\n\nThis is a process whereby the Liberals simply say, \"Look at us. Look at how great it is,\" and then throw the implementation, not just to the bureaucracy, but in particular to Alto, a Crown corporation with a private component that goes with it. Essentially, when it comes to the designation of a line, the government has had a very short process for communities that would see this line, if it is ever finally created, divide their towns and their streets and, as we have heard from the previous member, affect their ability to access things like health care. These are important conversations that are not to be taken lightly.\n\n In fact, property rights are something that Conservatives believe in and stand for. We believe there should be a firm rule of law when it comes to how property rights are standardized, and obviously it is not common law solely. There is the Expropriation Act, but that is a long-standing act that decides how government should best proceed to work with property owners to have certainty, to treat them with respect and to actually give them an independent process to use to contest when expropriation happens. However, the government, in its attempt to be the hero, would simply throw all of the messiness to Alto by essentially, with Bill C-15, abridging those property rights and the normal, usual process that would be followed through the Expropriation Act.\n\nWhen the minister came to committee, I asked him specifically. I said that he would give this power to Alto and essentially freeze people's property. He said that no, it was not like that, but one can imagine being a farmer who is just about to sell. They are near the end of their long career and want to be able to sell at a firm price, and suddenly they are told they cannot make improvements and their land is essentially frozen. As such, if they were about to sell their farm lot to their neighbour, whom they have known for many years, and suddenly the neighbour says they have zero ability to predict whether they will be able to use the land in the fashion that they planned for their model, this would simply drive the value of that property down. Who would blame that neighbour, and who would blame someone else for wanting to come in?\n\nIt is so draconian, what the government is calling for, that they could actually say no to new improvements. While someone is going through this process, they would be given very short notice. They would be told that they could not make improvements to their property, and they would be trying to attempt a sale. I said to the minister and committee that this is not fair, but the minister simply said this would all be ironed out through that process.\n\n I should even take a step back. We challenged the minister to look at an accelerated CTA review that would not just allow the project to proceed with timeliness but also provide a process whereby communities could formally submit their thoughts. Instead, Alto is running a consultation process, and it is not the same as an independent tribunal, such as the CTA, that can review all the evidence and make a determination as to where the line should go. \n\nSpeaking of where the line should go, there are going to be cases where properties will have a crossing, and there will be many properties that will not. As we heard from previous members, for a property owner to suddenly find that the most direct path they have taken for 20 years to get to the hospital will be closed, and that there will be no overpass that will allow them quick access, has a tremendous effect on people who need to make life decisions, such as being close to health care. \n\nIt also means routes are going to be slowed down, so an ambulance ride that would take 10 to 15 minutes might take over an hour now. These are things that are going to be decided by Alto, not by a tribunal that hears the evidence and that says what is reasonable given the stated goal of the project and given the community's very valid concerns. \n\nInstead, Bill C-15 would just wipe all of that out. We offered the minister that, and the minister, just like with all these things, gave a tin ear. He would essentially be giving the keys to the castle to Alto and letting those communities fall into the moat. It is simply the worst way to run a procurement. \n\nAre there some reasonable amendments that have been brought up at report stage? I am happy to say that there are. The idea is that if a property owner is frozen and maybe they have a barn or hen house that burns down or a water or flood event happens, they should be able to restore that property. \n\nThat is a simple courtesy to the people who are there, but I will also say that I have some tremendous concerns, because we always talk about the front end of expropriation and the frozen process, but there is also the back end. In every single procurement that the federal government goes through, and the Bloc Québécois member for Mirabel reminded us of this in the House, the federal government does not always do as it says it will.\n\nIn fact, it can happen that the government will expropriate or freeze someone's land but then never use it, and there is nothing in Bill C-15 that would protect people from these things. We have a process set up by the government that would essentially allow it to play the hero and Alto to play the villain. We have now a situation whereby Alto essentially has been given the run of the road and could literally run over communities, go over traditional roads and infrastructure, and divide communities without even having to say it will fix it and build an overpass. There would be no process for that. Alto would get to decide. There would be no independent tribunal that could be appealed to. \n\nThere is that, and again, freezing someone's assets on short notice is totally waiving many of the protections found in the Expropriation Act. When the government says it wants to be exempt from long-standing law so that it can give the insiders of Alto the ultimate authority, I think that the government has overreached. Conservatives will not support that type of process.\n\n Therefore, we will be looking to support reasonable amendments that start to take into account and to pull some of that power back to the property owners, because these property owners are worried. They are concerned, and so far, these consultation processes are consultation in name only. They are not meaningful, and they are not assuring the communities. As the member for Northumberland—Clarke stated previously, information is what gives people certainty. Unfortunately, through this particular bill, Bill C-15, the government has put no onus on Alto to do that. \n\nAgain, Conservatives support those affected property owners. We feel that the government has not looked out for their interests, but if the Liberals do not, the Conservatives will.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304986","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to rise on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna, in the beautiful interior of British Columbia.\n\nBill C-15 is an omnibus piece of legislation, and the Liberals, in their various forms of government, like in the Trudeau era and now followed by the new Prime Minister, have staked out that the omnibus is a perfectly legitimate piece of legislatio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c73f723972511d4858621a9d93c88f061f83a8ba5b09bd2b45c31f81040934a7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f663aea5b05745d6b759e1e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304987,"date":"2026-02-25T23:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what was said about Alto's authority is absolutely false.\n\n It is anything but absolute. The government holds all the cards. It decides if there should be consultation. There is nothing in here that actually requires the government to do what we originally asked of the minister, to have an accelerated CTA process whereby communities could be heard and an independent tribunal could come down and weigh in on where the public interest is and where the private interest is, to make it so that it is fair.\n\n For the member to say that is fearmongering, no, that is called making a suggestion. That is called a win-win. Unfortunately, by taking the side of Alto and ultimately all of the authority that has been given—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304987","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what was said about Alto's authority is absolutely false.\n\n It is anything but absolute. The government holds all the cards. It decides if there should be consultation. There is nothing in here that actually requires the government to do what we originally asked of the minister, to have an accelerated CTA process whereby communities could be heard and an independent tribunal could com","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3dd9afd0e6fa25be6537d891041006bc6a1c21abee9b053156099f83bfc34f0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-46b98e84ee2547445e7c0b8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304988,"date":"2026-02-25T23:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I said, it is absolutely important and imperative for Parliament to decide whether the best way to proceed is with Alto and whether Alto is the best regulatory body. It is a company, not a tribunal. Using an independent body such as the Canadian Transportation Agency would give a great deal of certainty to the communities affected and to property owners who are very concerned at this time.\n\nI am grateful to the Bloc Québécois and other members for working to improve this, because the Minister of Transport does not agree with us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304988","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I said, it is absolutely important and imperative for Parliament to decide whether the best way to proceed is with Alto and whether Alto is the best regulatory body. It is a company, not a tribunal. Using an independent body such as the Canadian Transportation Agency would give a great deal of certainty to the communities affected and to property owners who are very concerned at th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd22b8d5d6d0d52c182b24b6fb31db8250b801a9ea8c3142d0a11595f8284eb5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fcdd13125474f4f06fc2658a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":304989,"date":"2026-02-25T23:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think we can all ask the question of what we would do with $1 million, but I need to take a moment to think about $90 billion in one project, in one particular area. We could fix up the Trans-Canada Highway. We could establish northern Arctic ports. We could establish much more productive ports that would actually carry out some of the things the government says it is all about, increasing and diversifying our trade. We could spend $90 billion in a lot of different ways.\n\nI think the House needs to consider where we should be putting our money.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:304989","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think we can all ask the question of what we would do with $1 million, but I need to take a moment to think about $90 billion in one project, in one particular area. We could fix up the Trans-Canada Highway. We could establish northern Arctic ports. We could establish much more productive ports that would actually carry out some of the things the government says it is all about, inc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3d5f0b26f7516d01d15fa47f34a9142ad384e8b95402e16c4a6a5e0594d5ac14"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eaa981a0ce141bef8cbd349aef16b58cd4107bba1843333275321946a3572967"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65cc54aea86a7e2802301b9d","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1148641,"date":"2026-03-09T15:11:55+00:00","title":"An Act to amend the Canada Post Corporation Act","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"An Act to amend the Canada Post Corporation Act","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-262","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-262","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1148641","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"An Act to amend the Canada Post Corporation Act","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0e30d942e79c685688acc7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332235,"date":"2026-03-09T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-262, An Act to amend the Canada Post Corporation Act.\n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, today I rise to introduce a bill, seconded by the member of Parliament for Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, that brings long overdue modernization and national consistency to how Canadians can buy and ship Canadian wine, beer and spirits across provincial borders. \n\nAs the Prime Minister often reminds us, we should focus on what we can control, and Parliament can control this. Canada should be our own best customer, not a place where our producers face some of their toughest barriers. Right now, it is still easier for a B.C. winery to ship to Texas than to Toronto. That makes no sense for consumers, small producers or a modern Canadian economy. This bill creates a simple national framework for direct-to-consumer shipping. It ensures that Canada Post provides consistent interprovincial service and allows trusted carriers that follow the same standards to compete and offer Canadians more choice and better service. It replaces a patchwork system of outdated provincial rules with a single predictable coast-to-coast system. \n\nThis matters for small wineries, craft breweries and distilleries that want to reach customers across the country. It matters for Canadians who want access to the best of every region. It matters for Parliament, because this is something positive, practical and long overdue. \n\nI hope we can move past the prohibition era and the interprovincial trade barriers that still dog our country by working together across all parties to modernize a system Canadians have waited for for far too long. I would gladly work with all parties on accelerating this private member's bill or have the Minister of Finance include this framework in his next budget implementation act. If Parliament can pass this bill, then we can finally free the grapes and raise our spirits to a glorious pan-Canadian toast from coast to coast to coast.\n\n Let us free the beer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332235","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-262, An Act to amend the Canada Post Corporation Act.\n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, today I rise to introduce a bill, seconded by the member of Parliament for Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, that brings long overdue modernization and national consistency to how Canadians can buy and ship Canadian wine, beer and spirits across provincial borders. \n\nAs the Pri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","label":"Wine industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","label":"Wine industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f97125b4ad5edea4c4d300064070939201bf540bca77b57c6eb0d9fe1c4872e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d7b7452fe47995d7796bbb848e5d53e784005b174b43b851a05df5e3b2a3cf19"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a112749e45a4035638ec8ab6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332229,"date":"2026-03-10T19:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister says Canada should strive to be our own best customer. Well, Conservatives could not agree more, and that is why we want a one Canadian economy where a craft brewer in the Maritimes, a distiller in Ontario or a vintner in the Okanagan can sell to any adult Canadian anywhere in this country. However, the Prime Minister's Canada Day deadline of last year to fix this has come and gone, leaving beer, wine and spirits stuck behind trade barriers.\n\n Will the government finally live up to its own rhetoric, support our common-sense Conservative bill and allow Canadians to finally be our own best customer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332229","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister says Canada should strive to be our own best customer. Well, Conservatives could not agree more, and that is why we want a one Canadian economy where a craft brewer in the Maritimes, a distiller in Ontario or a vintner in the Okanagan can sell to any adult Canadian anywhere in this country. However, the Prime Minister's Canada Day deadline of last year to fix this h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","label":"Beverage industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","label":"Beverage industry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b99239e2e232c84ad208d89696681718c0e7511bc358b3312f9002a36adce7d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2838fdc435cb1492b751ecf61b2a9de3107a3c2941492cd28892671037d26dfa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b01ca6b36b5976f1140b9f4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332230,"date":"2026-03-10T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, producers in my riding find it easier to ship a bottle of wine to London, England, than to London, Ontario. Trade walls are blocking the growth of producers across this great country. The Prime Minister tells Canadians that we need to focus on the things we can control. Parliament has control over Canada Post and interprovincial shipping.\n\n I invite the Liberals to steal this idea. They could do so today. Will the Prime Minister focus on what we can control, steal my bill, finally tear down these walls for all Canadian consumers and producers, and free the beer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332230","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, producers in my riding find it easier to ship a bottle of wine to London, England, than to London, Ontario. Trade walls are blocking the growth of producers across this great country. The Prime Minister tells Canadians that we need to focus on the things we can control. Parliament has control over Canada Post and interprovincial shipping.\n\n I invite the Liberals to steal this idea. Th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","label":"Wine industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","label":"Wine industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["09e7bf991dd1c0eb0d9912200c55ea05706b2f4db18b230de6cafc508b3b7f08"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["12c2f1f06ce41fba83ff6ff4c5de93da2eaddc819060e1dd0e1e28e73dd785cb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wine industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45513","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e38cb75ff9050fb8d6909f06","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332231,"date":"2026-03-10T20:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is certainly an honour to rise and speak on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. I am also pleased to inform the House that I will be sharing my time with the hon. member for Calgary Midnapore.\n\nI have been fortunate to have spent enough time in this place to have sat on both sides of the House, which I consider a great honour. Over my time in this place, I have witnessed a great many bills come and go. Some of them make it to royal assent and others do not, for a variety of different reasons. Sometimes there will be consensus on a bill, when a majority of members of this place support a bill to move forward. However, more often than not, there will be disagreement. \n\nUsually, that disagreement might be based on ideology. However, from time to time there are also bills that come forward that are so controversial that they may draw serious concerns from all sides of the political spectrum. Bill C-9 is one of those bills.\n\nAs we were reminded yesterday in this place, in the speech from the member for Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, Bill C-9 has raised serious concerns from the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, the Canadian Constitution Foundation, the Rabbinical Council of Toronto, the National Council of Canadian Muslims, the United Church of Canada, the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops, the Primate of the Anglican Church of Canada, the Evangelical Fellowship of Canada and Egale Canada. I am sure all members would agree that this is a very diverse set of different organizations. That one single bill could unite so many of these different groups and organizations to raise very serious concerns should be an alarm bell for every member of this place, and even more so as some of these groups and organizations are intended to be better protected by the bill.\n\n They are also sending a strong message to all of us, and members do not have to take my word for it. I am certain that every member in this place has similar concerns shared to them by their constituents. In fact, if there is one thing I can say, it is that of all those I have heard from in emails or phone calls, or with whom I've met in person, not one single person has ever said, \"Bill C-9 gets it right. Please support it and pass it.\" Not one single person in my riding has said that to me. The only place I hear that is from Liberal MPs in this place, and that is really saying something. When some of the groups this bill seeks to protect say there are serious problems with the bill itself, I submit that we should all be listening.\n\n However, the Liberals have now decided that they do not want to do that. They have decided that these groups and individuals do not deserve to be heard. We all know that is wrong, yet here we are again. I say \"again\" because, of course, that is how things would often work under the former Liberal government. With the help of the NDP, the Liberals would ignore the concerns of everyday Canadians and say, \"Trust us,\" and, \"We know what is best for you,\" while they imposed one-size-fits-all, Ottawa-enforced solutions. We know how that approach worked out for the former Liberal prime minister and the former NDP leader, but this is not meant to be a history lesson. This is a bill that the Liberals like to tell us is from the new Liberal government, even though it is beginning to act and sound, quite frankly, a lot like the previous Liberal government.\n\nLet us pause for a moment here. It is not a secret that we already have existing laws that can deal with hate and that are completely and totally ignored right now. There are laws that are in force. When those groups, and lately it is often Jewish Canadians, look to government for leadership, they are not getting answers, accountability or action. Instead, they are getting Bill C-9, which is a classic way for the government to attempt to say, \"We are doing something, and this is what we are doing.\" It is a process, but there is nothing concrete.\n\n As we all know, one of the most controversial parts of Bill C-9 is the proposal to remove the religious exemption clause. I think we can all agree on that. However, exemptions for \"a legitimate purpose\", such as an educational, artistic or journalistic purpose, would not be captured by this offence.\n\nIn other words, there is a recognition in this proposed legislation for exemptions, just no longer for religious reasons, despite charter protections to the contrary. I know Liberals will say, \"That is not who we mean to target by targeting the religious exemption for elimination.\" For the purpose of this debate, suppose we were to give those Liberals the benefit of the doubt. The problem is that what the Liberals intend to happen in this proposed bill may not be what would end up happening once it becomes law.\n\n When the Liberals changed the Criminal Code in provisions around bail, I am certain they did not intend those changes to result in a massive increase in serious crimes, yet that is precisely what occurred, as prolific offenders get the benefit of the doubt and are back on the street again on bail instead of being in jail. The principle of restraint is a principle that has created a big problem. We in the official opposition did warn the Liberals about changing that. We all know what happened. They simply discounted and ignored, arrogantly saying, \"Everything you are saying is wrong and we are right,\" a typical Liberal response in regard to these kinds of concerns.\n\n In many ways, we are here again, like it is Groundhog Day, where it is not just the official opposition Conservatives who are warning the Liberals about this bill. It is a huge group of different organizations, all saying the same thing, because the Liberals continue to refuse to listen. They continue to push this into law, and then it is out of our hands as members of Parliament. Once that happens, it is in our communities and, again, it could be weaponized against the very people it is said to protect. More often than not, we are seeing that enforcement and public safety have become increasingly selective based on what group yells the loudest. That is not to mention judicial activism, where some rulings are raising serious concerns.\n\n This is our current environment when it comes to enforcement, prosecution and sentencing. This is creating more division and, I would submit, a less tolerant attitude among many Canadians. Targeting faith, even though the stated intent is not to do so, would carry serious consequences and repercussions. Keep in mind that it is the very groups and organizations this bill is supposed to be trying to protect that are sounding the alarm bell on this. Why would we not want to listen?\n\nIn conclusion, while I would agree that the intent here is not nefarious but meant to be well-meaning, I submit that we need to take a step back and listen to those who are raising concerns. We need to address those concerns in a meaningful way. We cannot risk getting this bill wrong solely due to Liberal arrogance. We do not need more polarization, more weaponization or more divisiveness, all the things this bill could create more of if we do not get it right.\n\nI met with a local pastoral association in my area of West Kelowna. The members of the association felt particularly targeted by this good-faith exemption being drawn out just for religious worship. They said, \"It says 'academic', so a professor could say the same thing from the same holy book and receive a good-faith exemption. Someone could put on a play or put the same scripture on a painting and receive the exemption, but those people who are in a church in front of people of faith in pews, rather than students at a local university, could not.\" They feel targeted.\n\n That is precisely why I will be voting against this bill, as every single constituent I have heard from has asked me to do. I would encourage the members of the government to listen to the concerns of their constituents as well and do likewise. I would like to sincerely thank everyone who has listened today and taken my comments into account. I hope that those comments track with their own experience and that they will have a similar response to my own.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332231","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is certainly an honour to rise and speak on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. I am also pleased to inform the House that I will be sharing my time with the hon. member for Calgary Midnapore.\n\nI have been fortunate to have spent enough time in this place to have sat on both sides of the House, which I consider a great honour. Over my time in this place, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0f6e4b86603cceea62ccf982d3c432aebef36f03dddf562899af41613c8ddbec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9a02eeb96fc278b5db689bf25e04c3a53e7919c92a60f2ebd1162d99893ed462"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa9ef90de4b1444e09569776","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332232,"date":"2026-03-10T20:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate what the member has to say, and I am sure my mom probably sent him friendship cookies to get him to say things like that publicly. I cannot see many other Liberal members saying that about me. The respect is mutual. \n\nWhat I would simply say is that I have fundamental differences on Bill C-9. For example, the current law has it so that the Attorney General of Canada must give approval. That sets a very high bar. Unfortunately, as I said, there is divisiveness. In my province of British Columbia, there have been many divisive statements said by different ministers from the provincial government. We have seen where a former minister, a Jewish woman, was basically cast out of that caucus and cabinet for her viewpoints. Bringing it down to the attorney general level at the provincial level takes away a valuable safeguard. That is one of the principal reasons.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332232","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate what the member has to say, and I am sure my mom probably sent him friendship cookies to get him to say things like that publicly. I cannot see many other Liberal members saying that about me. The respect is mutual. \n\nWhat I would simply say is that I have fundamental differences on Bill C-9. For example, the current law has it so that the Attorney General of Canada must ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6bcf9ebf0103ecc006cd26376923a09ac456e20cae9ed609f09d9b1367543079"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41b6ce233405765ddec61fb6a3e3ecfda3e14c148bc904804f2ffd4b4f6b6295"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d081993533f757d63e618d6c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332233,"date":"2026-03-10T20:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that member spent almost his full career in law enforcement. He knows how critically important it is for law and order to be expressed with clear rules and clear enforcement. As I have said, we have existing rules around violence and incitement. What we need is less talk from politicians and more backing of our police forces so they can make those charges, present the evidence and have the Crown prosecutors prosecute those who have threatened Canadians. Those who have harmed others need to be seen to be held accountable. \n\nRight now, we have so much division because no one feels like anyone is in charge. We need to have law and order, and we need to have enforcement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332233","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that member spent almost his full career in law enforcement. He knows how critically important it is for law and order to be expressed with clear rules and clear enforcement. As I have said, we have existing rules around violence and incitement. What we need is less talk from politicians and more backing of our police forces so they can make those charges, present the evidence and hav","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efac2ed3d4731fa17801e8d43a962113d1caf246c1f1b961c9327d221d23469e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea1696f377e55f0db2d643d3917043630d57d61f82a1e02c778ebc5ae838ab4d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1f54c19d5b99377942802d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332234,"date":"2026-03-10T20:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a serious issue and a serious question, one that I will answer. \n\nFirst of all, I believe that ultimately the changes promoted by the Bloc and the government that remove the good-faith clause when it comes to religious worship will inevitably be challenged in a court under the charter. I believe it will go from lower to higher courts, all the way to the Supreme Court. The challenge is that we will have an individual who has to go through the weight, burden and stress of defending their charter rights all the way through the system only to find out that this law was not well thought out and is not charter-compliant.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332234","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a serious issue and a serious question, one that I will answer. \n\nFirst of all, I believe that ultimately the changes promoted by the Bloc and the government that remove the good-faith clause when it comes to religious worship will inevitably be challenged in a court under the charter. I believe it will go from lower to higher courts, all the way to the Supreme Court. The challe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0a9a079cde415fd023a8c2dbb0a014563a4c77524979b26866bbbe10a847246d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0da0e150e505f7963bcdcd46e962783e959c4f1e7eb67b5614911206ad71fd41"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-458b50aeb0229e64c1a578ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":377418,"date":"2026-03-23T16:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a great honour to rise in the chamber and to speak on behalf of my constituents, the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. Crime is one of the most serious concerns facing my riding today, with Kelowna also represented by a Liberal member, sadly becoming ground zero for the consequences of failed Liberal bail policies.\n\nBefore I speak directly to the jail not bail act, I think it is important to remind the House how we got to this place. In 2018, for purely ideological reasons, the former Trudeau Liberal government passed Bill C-75, amending the Criminal Code and fundamentally reshaping Canada's bail system. Although there were several changes, the guiding principle was very clear: Release should be the default position at the earliest opportunity and on the least onerous conditions possible. In that decision lies the heart of what Canadians now recognize as a catch-and-release justice system.\n\nThe results have been devastating. Between 2015 and 2022, violent crimes increased dramatically. The number of murders rose, gang-related homicides surged and violent gun crime more than doubled. These are not abstract statistics I speak of. They represent real victims, real families and real communities, our communities, paying the price. It became so serious that every provincial premier, regardless of their political stripe, jointly wrote to the federal government, demanding bail reform. That alone should have been a wake-up call to the seriousness of the problem, yet here we are in 2026 still debating how to clean up a mess that was created eight years ago by the former Liberal majority government.\n\nLast week in Kelowna, a prolific career criminal, someone who had 67 criminal convictions, was once again released on bail. Can any member of the House guess what happened next? We all know the answer: This individual was released back into the very community he has repeatedly victimized, despite an extensive record that clearly demonstrated a pattern of reoffending. The situation became so serious that the RCMP took the unprecedented step of issuing a public warning upon his release. This is not normal. This is not normal policing. This is what happens when law enforcement is forced to manage risk created by bad legislation.\n\nOut of respect for families affected by violent crime, I will not be retelling individual stories in this debate. We all have these stories. We all know the damage that has been done to our communities over and over, and the real damage to families and their lives.\n\nI do want to just take a moment to acknowledge the terrific work of my colleague the member for Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola and the families, particularly in Kelowna, whose advocacy has given rise to what we now know as Bailey's law. This brings me to the legislation before us today.\n\nBefore I go further, I should say that I thank the member for Oxford for his leadership on this issue and for bringing forward the jail not bail legislation, which squarely puts public safety back at the centre of bail decision. I thank the member for his contributions. I thank him for the time he spends away from his family, educating Canadians on the problems created by the previous government, and for the solutions being proposed by him as a member of Parliament, a Conservative member who believes strongly that this country and our streets can be safe again.\n\nThe legislation reflects the concerns being raised in our communities by police and by provincial leaders across the country, and it puts forward a clear, principled alternative to the status quo. Canadians have heard a lot about government attempts to fix bail laws, including Bill C-14. While some amendments are welcome and have been pushed by our caucus as supportable, I want to acknowledge that on this bill, we have tried to work in good faith with the government. Despite Bill C-14's solutions, the fundamental problem remains untouched, and that is the principle of restraint. It still exists.\n\nThe principle, enshrined by the Liberal majority in 2017, continues to prioritize release over detention, even for repeat and violent offenders. It is the philosophical core of catch-and-release, and it is precisely why incremental changes since that time, whether they be Bill C-48 in the previous Parliament or Bill C-14 in the current Parliament, will not fix the problem. That is why the jail not bail act is necessary. Unlike Liberal half measures, the jail not bail act would confront the problem head-on.\n\nFirst, it would repeal and replace the Liberal principle of restraint, making public safety the primary consideration in bail decisions, not an afterthought and not one factor among many but the guiding principle that judges must take into consideration.\n\nSecond, it would introduce a new major offences category, applying reverse onus bail to the most serious crimes: firearms offences, sexual assault, kidnapping, human trafficking, home invasion, robbery, extortion, arson and serious assaults. These are crimes where the burden should rest squarely on the accused to justify their release.\n\nThird, the jail not bail act would strengthen bail decisions by requiring judges to consider the accused's full criminal history, not just the offence that is immediately before the court. It would also prevent individuals convicted of a major offence within the last 10 years who are already out on bail and who are charged again from being released yet again. Importantly, it would toughen the legal standard itself, replacing the vague threshold of substantial likelihood with a more realistic and protective test of what is reasonably foreseeable.\n\nThe bill would also close loopholes by prohibiting anyone with an indictable conviction from acting as a guarantor. Someone who has done a crime should not be able to be a guarantor for another. This would require meaningful enforcement of guarantor responsibilities. The bill would also require non-residents to surrender passports where appropriate.\n\nThese are not radical ideas. They are common-sense protections that put victims and our communities ahead of repeat offenders.\n\nRecently I met with the City of Kelowna, along with the member for Oxford and the member for Brantford—Brant South—Six Nations, to discuss this issue. Representatives presented documents in which their executive summary stated very clearly that federal bail reforms have prioritized release over detention, even for chronic offenders. Their conclusion was clear: Kelowna supports presumptive detention and stricter bail conditions for chronic offenders.\n\nI want to say that I stand with the City of Kelowna on these points, and I believe that most Canadians do. In fact, we held a town hall to discuss how we can stop crime in our neighbourhoods. We visited community leaders like those from the Uptown Rutland Business Association. We walked the streets with them to hear their concerns about criminality and public disorder. It became abundantly clear at our town hall that citizens in places like Kelowna and throughout the Central Okanagan are fed up. They want to know that when police charge and when people are prosecuted, people are held accountable and not simply released, only to harm families and communities again and again.\n\nThe jail not bail act would answer that question by doing what the government has refused to do: put public safety first, clearly, consistently and without apology backing up our RCMP officers, who work so hard to stop the crime, only to have those individuals released, while they are stuck with the paperwork and are arguing for more resources to deal with them.\n\nI want to conclude by acknowledging the many members on all sides of the House who care about justice and public safety. I respect the work that the member for Oxford has done on the legislation, and I ask that all hon. members support the jail not bail act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:377418","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a great honour to rise in the chamber and to speak on behalf of my constituents, the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. Crime is one of the most serious concerns facing my riding today, with Kelowna also represented by a Liberal member, sadly becoming ground zero for the consequences of failed Liberal bail policies.\n\nBefore I speak directly to the jail not b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["65847f9b80a66c1bbe38b572884c3f5646813fbb498197a2a3555f68a56c5901"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7f66ca928e8a8ac14f8d46add875961a59c9da3bb79b155f3351173b49b7905e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0410725ed69d7f863082b0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":377417,"date":"2026-03-26T19:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a great honour to share with the House that on December 23, 1926, the Peachland Royal Canadian Legion Branch 69 was presented with its charter. I am proud to note that this original charter, issued by the British Empire Service League, still hangs on the wall of that legion to this very day.\n\n The Peachland Legion was established in the aftermath of the First World War by returning soldiers, marking an incredibly proud moment for the small community of Peachland, British Columbia. For nearly a century, the legion has supported veterans who have served in the Second World War, Korea, Rwanda, Somalia, Bosnia, the Gulf War, Afghanistan and more recent theatres where our men and women answered the call to serve. May we all stand in support of our veterans, who have sacrificed so much for our great country.\n\nFor 100 years, the Peachland Legion has withstood the test of time, and I am confident it will stand steadfast for generations to come. I invite the House to join me in celebrating the 100th anniversary of the Peachland Royal Canadian Legion Branch 69.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:377417","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a great honour to share with the House that on December 23, 1926, the Peachland Royal Canadian Legion Branch 69 was presented with its charter. I am proud to note that this original charter, issued by the British Empire Service League, still hangs on the wall of that legion to this very day.\n\n The Peachland Legion was established in the aftermath of the First World War by return","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","label":"Charters"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","label":"Charters","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7065d5d16c664c9d27d4c8a71f4cf65053b1f030a994f7c3a9a49b8d43d0cb7a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d836b3e72bb099d4478d09d7f0c5b6e24260aadac978f2a5c0b363ccc371344"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034436","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bda6d9f0d7cfd73ce9af244c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104542,"date":"2026-04-13T16:15:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all our witnesses for coming today and sharing their expertise with our committee. I'll start with you, Mr. Harvey. I know that your association has partnered with other industry groups in talking about the need for regulatory reform writ large. Right now with Bill C-5 , even with the powers that have been given to the Prime Minister and his government, they have not made use of Bill C-5 to really get things going. They've opened up a new office, but they have not actually gotten anything designated under schedule 1. Do you believe the tool should be utilized more? What would you like to see? Hundreds of other projects that could advance your industry—bridges, tunnels and culverts—need to be done, but right now the regulatory side, from my understanding, holds a lot of that up.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104542","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to all our witnesses for coming today and sharing their expertise with our committee. I'll start with you, Mr. Harvey. I know that your association has partnered with other industry groups in talking about the need for regulatory reform writ large. Right now with Bill C-5 , even with the powers that have been given to the Prime Minister and his government, they have","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47b37380a0a838ad6bc7a6c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104543,"date":"2026-04-13T16:15:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"Do you think there needs to be more of a writ-large approach to regulatory reform and not just necessarily favoured projects that in certain parts of the country could be influenced by politics or by connections?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104543","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you think there needs to be more of a writ-large approach to regulatory reform and not just necessarily favoured projects that in certain parts of the country could be influenced by politics or by connections?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["342ccac10b44bc85b1b43e0df322dd1236ee6a93d1c7bddef881ca180ad686ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56c570624d5da9acc661ec06","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104544,"date":"2026-04-13T16:20:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"Speaking about little projects, there's the trade corridors funding. A lot of railroads have received support from the government over recent years for digitalization. I'm sure that's been very successful on their part, but my understanding is that the ports don't connect with that information, so you essentially have ports that are not part and parcel of an information-sharing regime. Is that your experience?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104544","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Speaking about little projects, there's the trade corridors funding. A lot of railroads have received support from the government over recent years for digitalization. I'm sure that's been very successful on their part, but my understanding is that the ports don't connect with that information, so you essentially have ports that are not part and parcel of an information-sharing regime. Is that you","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10557bb50bce489bdab243de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104545,"date":"2026-04-13T16:20:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"There seemed to be a bit of a governance issue with the CN Second Narrows Rail Bridge in British Columbia when it was closed for about four days in February. You mentioned that some priorities should be raised. The fact is that this stopped shipments of our energy to international markets at a time when that's something the government wants. One small piece of infrastructure caused a close to $40-billion pipeline, which was bought by the government, to come to a standstill. Do you believe there needs to be a more strategic coming together of parties—Transport Canada, the port of Vancouver, CN and others—to try to make sure that these priorities are mapped out ahead of time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104545","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There seemed to be a bit of a governance issue with the CN Second Narrows Rail Bridge in British Columbia when it was closed for about four days in February. You mentioned that some priorities should be raised. The fact is that this stopped shipments of our energy to international markets at a time when that's something the government wants. One small piece of infrastructure caused a close to $40-","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","label":"Railway networks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","label":"Railway networks","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["889690dd906f2459e01885f27ec86e3e5a34e6842eedaab533d6aaf8f957adcf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8ce62839ae095be04ff8f122ea3e0902d7d386468481c918e5d0b8d60ab925a4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c2bb39749cc1c2b2ec0543f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104546,"date":"2026-04-13T17:50:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to say thank you to both of our witnesses for being here today. I would like to start with Picton Terminals. Sir, let me start by saying that offering to pay for the CBSA not only is a sign of faith that your port can handle the business, but also signals the seriousness of this to the government and that it is absolutely necessary. The government has talked about hiring 1,000 CBSA agents. I imagine you would wish for a few of them to be allocated to Picton. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104546","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to say thank you to both of our witnesses for being here today. I would like to start with Picton Terminals. Sir, let me start by saying that offering to pay for the CBSA not only is a sign of faith that your port can handle the business, but also signals the seriousness of this to the government and that it is absolutely necessary. The government has talked about hiri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9879027f485b98dbf658e6cf770e535262a75f27d8ed4fc6d2fd78043a5266d8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6eeb1d8ef64adc17e5636ac2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104547,"date":"2026-04-13T17:50:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"In terms of your port development, I'm sure you have a capital plan. Do you have a plan for the expansion of the port that you're considering, or right now is it just renewing the infrastructure?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104547","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In terms of your port development, I'm sure you have a capital plan. Do you have a plan for the expansion of the port that you're considering, or right now is it just renewing the infrastructure?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["264375b688f8a19863792df5ccf596d0fdd909e14b0d457a382b98a291bb9ff1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b1bb083335285f4ee8adfa04c344097ac33a54cec79a1fc10c1d8d5ca77c7b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6b38d9e6e7ee1204ed7788e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104548,"date":"2026-04-13T17:50:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"How can you best do that? Is there a privatized capital plan, or are you looking for partnerships in government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104548","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"How can you best do that? Is there a privatized capital plan, or are you looking for partnerships in government?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privatization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","label":"Privatization","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e02397fa40f6c8dd5207a433d07ab2aaba52b385278d6fd76fda7c5e8ee5508a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fbdbf738ba4e1b80f654a42f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104549,"date":"2026-04-13T17:50:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"Thank you, sir. I want to impress upon the government members who are here today that when someone is asking for the government to just do its job so they can expand their operations to the benefit of the region, that's a great candidate to start with. Mr. Chair, I have given notice of a motion that I was hoping we could quickly slip in with regard to B'nai Brith and their request to appear. I want to make sure with the clerk that it's eligible. I sent it in on Friday, on the 10th, so it should be eligible. Yes, okay. I was just making sure. I move: That, in relation to the motion adopted by the committee on December 11, 2025, the committee invite representatives from B'nai Brith to testify as part of the committee's study on the challenges facing Canadian airports. I hope this is a common-sense thing. They're actually the ones who wrote to us originally, saying this was an important thing, so we should consider having them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104549","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, sir. I want to impress upon the government members who are here today that when someone is asking for the government to just do its job so they can expand their operations to the benefit of the region, that's a great candidate to start with. Mr. Chair, I have given notice of a motion that I was hoping we could quickly slip in with regard to B'nai Brith and their request to appear. I wan","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bbb1c1ce40038f2e42a911b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104550,"date":"2026-04-13T17:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"I'm looking for unanimous consent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104550","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm looking for unanimous consent.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d5aca850b6059316f7727ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104551,"date":"2026-04-13T17:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"Mr. Chair—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104551","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Chair—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e0de5ec3725e8a66bb0eca5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104552,"date":"2026-04-13T17:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"I sent the text of the motion to the clerk.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104552","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I sent the text of the motion to the clerk.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d87336b59afc126b96c001f123153b08410085802e624d855d2091e5e18d1416"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce0d5528a58f2776dba7dc53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104553,"date":"2026-04-13T17:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"I figured this would be a simple one. If members need more time, I guess that's what we'll do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104553","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I figured this would be a simple one. If members need more time, I guess that's what we'll do.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35e921a9d904e3572526348b40ace4fd222d432f0d204c4cbc109d19cd9e8aa3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-180b6e23b12315a658bb543b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104554,"date":"2026-04-13T17:55:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104554","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd09cedc2fe5f465d330072b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419789,"date":"2026-04-14T21:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. I would like to inform you that I will be sharing my time with the hon. member for Lethbridge.\n\nToday's debate is an important one because it goes directly to the affordability crisis Canadians are living through. Often in this place, along with much of the media, we tend to focus on things we most disagree on. Today I will start with what I hope we can agree on: Canadians are struggling with the rising cost of living. They want practical solutions that lower costs now.\n\nThat brings me to fuel prices. In recent weeks, Canadians have seen sharp increases in the price of gasoline and diesel. Families felt it immediately, and so did farmers, truckers, tradespeople, small businesses and anyone who depends on transportation. Some will say that global events are to blame, and that may be true, but Canadians do not elect us to describe the problem and then do nothing. They elect us to find solutions.\n\nThis is why the Conservative official opposition has led the debate on gas prices and affordability. We are not shrugging our shoulders while Canadians struggle, nor have we simply named the problem, but we have proposed solutions.\n\nWhat we are seeing, again and again, is that when Conservatives put forward solutions that work, reality catches up and the government is forced to change course. There is also a pattern Canadians can see clearly, which is the government consistently taking on only a fraction of the solution. On affordability, the Prime Minister removed the consumer carbon tax, but kept the industrial carbon tax and so-called clean fuel regulations, policies that continue to raise costs across the economy. On housing, instead of removing the GST completely to build supply, the government offered narrow measures that can increase demand without fixing the supply problem. On getting big projects built, the government asked for and received the support of the Conservatives to pass Bill C-5, but instead of designating and then streamlining these projects to get past the red tape, it has yet to designate a single project as a national interest project, as was named under the legislation.\n\nAll of these are half measures that may create some headlines but limit the real-world impact to Canadians.\n\nThat takes us to today's motion. The problem is clear: When costs surge due to higher fuel costs, the cost of everything rises, and when government adds layers of taxes and policy-driven costs on top of that surge, it makes a bad situation worse.\n\nNow we have a new development. The Prime Minister announced that the federal government will temporarily suspend the federal fuel excise tax on gasoline and diesel starting next week and lasting through the summer, but only to 10¢ a litre. That confirms what Conservatives have been saying all along: Taxes at the pump matter and Canadians need relief.\n\nLet me be clear: Canadians deserve relief. If the government finally takes a step in that direction, I think we should acknowledge it, but we will also point out what it has left on the table.\n\nIf someone were to ask my constituents a simple question, would they rather have a plan that delivers about 25¢ a litre of relief for the rest of this year or a plan that delivers about 10¢ a litre for a few months, especially when higher prices mean that Ottawa collects more GST and corporate tax revenue, most Canadians would know the answer right away. They would prefer our plan.\n\nThe question today before the House is whether we will do what Canadians need, not partially, temporarily or halfway, but with a plan that lowers costs across the economy and protects Canadians from price shocks beyond their control. Suspending only a small part of the tax temporarily while leaving these other federal charges and regulations in place is not a full solution.\n\nThe Conservative official opposition proposes that we can and should do the following: Suspend all federal fuel excise tax and GST on gas and diesel and permanently eliminate the so-called clean fuel standard and the industrial carbon tax. If we take these steps, we could deliver meaningful and immediate relief at the pumps and reduce inflationary pressure throughout the supply chain.\n\nWhy does fuel matter so much? Virtually everything in our Canadian economy moves by commercial trucking at some point in the delivery chain: goods, groceries, building supplies and services. If it moves, it usually moves on a truck. When fuel costs rise, shipping costs rise, and when shipping costs rise, the price of what Canadians buy rises. That is how inflation gets embedded in day-to-day life.\n\nIt is not just trucking. Aviation, marine shipping and rail depend on fuel, as well as mines, forestry operations, major construction sites and heavy-duty equipment. Fuel is the major input cost across our entire economy. If we are serious about finding solutions to affordability, we cannot treat fuel costs as a small or isolated issue. Fuel costs drive the cost of living.\n\n I want to return to a point we often hear from the Prime Minister, that we should focus on the things that we can control here in Canada, not the things that we cannot. On that principle, I will agree. We cannot control global conflicts, international choke points or the decisions of other countries, but we can control federal taxes and policies that increase the costs here at home. So the question is simple. If the government now agrees that suspending the federal excise tax helps Canadians, why not also suspend the GST on gas and diesel? Why not remove policies that permanently drive up costs for Canadian industries and consumers? Why not do everything we can to control and to protect Canadians from what we cannot control? That is what this motion is about.\n\n It is also about recognizing when governments delay action, consequences are real and often permanent. Let me share a real example. At the end of 2025, the community of Crofton, British Columbia was devastated by the news that Domtar would permanently close the pulp mill in that community, costing about 350 well-paying jobs. It was a tragedy for those workers, their families and their community. Now, I am not going to claim that the closure was entirely the fault of government. It was not. However, did the government do everything it could have done to help prevent it? Well, the answer is no.\n\n What is telling is what happened next. Following this closure, the B.C. NDP government announced it would ease industrial carbon pricing for pulp mills going forward. Now, why did it do that? It was because it took a closure and job losses for government to recognize an economic reality. If costs are piled onto a sector that is not competing internationally, costs that competitors may not be paying, that sector can be made less competitive and there can be accelerated closures and job losses. For the people of Crofton, that response was too little, too late.\n\nThat is exactly the risk when governments choose half measures and delay. They wait for harm to happen and then they say, \"Oops, we had better fix that.\" This House has a chance to act early, to choose solutions now, not apologies later. That is where the Conservative official opposition's role is clear, not just to name the problem but, whenever possible, to propose a solution.\n\nThe government often tells Canadians it is focused on affordability, competitiveness and resilience. Those are fine words, but words do not lower a grocery bill or fill a fuel tank. If this government is serious, it can prove it today, not with slogans but with a vote. It could vote for measures that actually reduce costs. This should not be that complicated. Canadians want relief that is real, measurable and immediate. They want us to find solutions. They want us to reduce costs that government controls, especially when families are being squeezed.\n\n A temporary suspension of one tax is a start, but Canadians deserve a full plan, a plan like ours. That is what the official opposition is proposing. This is our chance to show Canadians we hear them. This is a chance to put solutions ahead of excuses. This is our chance to vote for affordability. All we have to do is vote in favour of this motion. It is really that simple.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419789","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. I would like to inform you that I will be sharing my time with the hon. member for Lethbridge.\n\nToday's debate is an important one because it goes directly to the affordability crisis Canadians are living through. Often in this place, along with much of the media, we tend to focus on things we most ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["323e42121794f9dccc23bef903851759398fdea7823e8c68963587641706d701"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae6a8d969e816ce17cf4cf91d833a8c85885fb820b5ea564b043aaa911ed1b3f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f9e4209c04aba4f1802a148","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419790,"date":"2026-04-14T21:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let us start off with the so-called clean fuel standard. The previous minister of the environment, Catherine McKenna, under the Trudeau majority, originally started this. They actually said we should have one set of regulations to monitor solid, liquid and gaseous forms of energy. They wanted one ring to rule them all, one regulation to rule them all, and it became so burdensome and complicated that the government ended up shunting half of that framework away in favour of what we have now. \n\nRather than working with industry on a technical solution that would see good things happen in this country, like, for example, the use of Canadian biofuels and those kinds of things, instead, it encouraged more importation from the Americans that is still being used today to fill it with some of the clean mandates that the government does. They are not only complicated and just pie in the sky, they actually make it where we are dependent on the Americans at a time we should be helping ourselves.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419790","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let us start off with the so-called clean fuel standard. The previous minister of the environment, Catherine McKenna, under the Trudeau majority, originally started this. They actually said we should have one set of regulations to monitor solid, liquid and gaseous forms of energy. They wanted one ring to rule them all, one regulation to rule them all, and it became so burdensome and c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["35daac56aca332df4182a4cdb4adccd7c033e7c2c4f93a77a45effde04dacbce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67888a27804f85929d3c3fb66ebaafedfd00a495215777b84af34b593b00fe0b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d87b1def631a7789e72e8a27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419791,"date":"2026-04-14T21:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am going to offer my friend a very good piece of advice. He should not soak in anything that I say. There are many other speakers in this place he should marinate in. \n\nI will say this. At the end of the day, the government has an opportunity put before it. Time and time again, when Conservatives put forward great policies that are not only good for Canada but electorally popular, the government then implements a small part of them, and Canadians suffer because of that. We have fewer houses because of its plan and higher costs because of its industrial carbon tax. I hope that, in this case, Liberals can agree with Conservatives that affordability should be the main thing. They have an opportunity today to support a better solution.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419791","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am going to offer my friend a very good piece of advice. He should not soak in anything that I say. There are many other speakers in this place he should marinate in. \n\nI will say this. At the end of the day, the government has an opportunity put before it. Time and time again, when Conservatives put forward great policies that are not only good for Canada but electorally popular, t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036438","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nonrenewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036438","label":"Nonrenewable resources","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce4e9022aabc6feb1a3ecb90137515e6e00170db24e8cb0e024d66a7299766a4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13f9ebd7f87678077aa8eb88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419792,"date":"2026-04-14T22:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member should know that supply chains take a while to react to certain things. The Trump administration stripped out a number of bipartisan policies that were put in place under a large budget measure a few years ago. It essentially took the carrots away for biofuel manufacturing that scaled up so massively. This is one of the reasons Canada continues to import a lot of its biofuels from outside the country: to be able to fill the so-called clean fuel standards that are here today. These guys have not done so much, as the Americans have taken away those carrots.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419792","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member should know that supply chains take a while to react to certain things. The Trump administration stripped out a number of bipartisan policies that were put in place under a large budget measure a few years ago. It essentially took the carrots away for biofuel manufacturing that scaled up so massively. This is one of the reasons Canada continues to import a lot of its biofue","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","label":"Imports"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logistics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Carrots","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034404","label":"Carrots","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","label":"Imports","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","label":"Logistics","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a8abc71a8dcdd52aea36f94411ab83393e48ec28a1399eb2d32c4f801abadbb3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0601a3d91558ab03eb9c8df5749ee327d60613f6555d2a0e974aee340b876cb4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Imports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43062","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9d5473c940ad5bc58200be7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104555,"date":"2026-04-15T23:25:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"It's not just the interpreters who are struggling, Mr. Chair. With the non-answers we're getting, Orwell is spinning in his grave. Thank you. Some hon. members : Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104555","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's not just the interpreters who are struggling, Mr. Chair. With the non-answers we're getting, Orwell is spinning in his grave. Thank you. Some hon. members : Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083651","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083651","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Language minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Deafness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","label":"Deafness","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083651","label":"Language minorities","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2dc2961638ababe251783b5a9b9b50aed7f8234a29454648c82d9988637f615b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eebd96d6eed7a585cfe7f94e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104556,"date":"2026-04-15T23:30:00+00:00","title":"TRAN","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"TRAN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to remind everyone that B'nai Brith is really interested in participating. I really hope that Liberal members can maybe caucus a bit and see if they are willing to do that. I think they asked us to do the study on cybersecurity in Canada's airports, and I would hope that their requests would be welcomed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/TRAN/meeting-29/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104556","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to remind everyone that B'nai Brith is really interested in participating. I really hope that Liberal members can maybe caucus a bit and see if they are willing to do that. I think they asked us to do the study on cybersecurity in Canada's airports, and I would hope that their requests would be welcomed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0edc3d4be92a4658fdee972","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419788,"date":"2026-04-16T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, while we are just talking about corrections, I just want to thank the Secretary of State for Canada Revenue Agency and Financial Institutions for delineating the difference between Connor McGregor and Connor McDavid. I will say, to his credit, that he is more right than when people, Canadians, phone into the CRA and ask questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419788","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, while we are just talking about corrections, I just want to thank the Secretary of State for Canada Revenue Agency and Financial Institutions for delineating the difference between Connor McGregor and Connor McDavid. I will say, to his credit, that he is more right than when people, Canadians, phone into the CRA and ask questions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2cdee58d3d1fd34733577a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419784,"date":"2026-04-17T17:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in this place on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna.\n\nA part of me wants to say that we really should not be here, again, having this debate today. It is not just because it is a Friday and not because the debate is unimportant. It is. On the contrary, it is absolutely essential.\n\nSometimes, in the House, we are our own worst enemy. I say that candidly because this is not the first time Parliament has debated efforts to modernize lawful access legislation. More than 14 years ago, when I sat on the government side of the House, I supported similar initiatives. Before that, the previous Liberal government under Paul Martin attempted and also failed to move this work forward. Each time Parliament fails to act, the cost is not political. The cost is borne by Canadians.\n\nThe world has changed how Canadians live, communicate, bank, work and raise families. That has all moved online, rapidly and permanently, but our laws have not kept pace with that reality. That is why it is important to be clear about what this debate is and what it is not. We are not here to debate legislation that allows law enforcement to spy on innocent, law-abiding Canadians without oversight. That is not what Bill C-22 proposes. The core issue before us is how Parliament protects Canadians in an increasingly digital country while respecting the rights and freedoms that define us. Public safety is the most obvious concern. Canadians are being targeted every day by online fraud, identity theft, extortion and exploitation. Seniors have lost life savings. Families have had their identities stolen. Children have been coerced and harmed in ways made possible by anonymity and speed online.\n\nThis issue also goes far beyond individual victims. Canada is not only rich in natural resources. We are rich in research, intellectual property, innovation and data. Where is that value increasingly stored and accessed? It is increasingly stored and accessed online. Essential services, banking, health records, commerce and even the operation of the Parliament now depend on digital infrastructure. This is not ideology. It is reality.\n\nAs Canadians move online, our ability to protect them has fallen behind. I often explain it in this way. In the physical world, if there is a hit-and-run accident and a licence plate number is recorded, police can lawfully use that information to identify the registered owner and begin an investigation. That does not give access to private conversations. It simply provides a lawful starting point. Online, even when establishing those basic facts, it can take much longer, while the harm continues.\n\nBill C-22 is an attempt, imperfect, as all legislation ultimately is, to modernize investigative tools while maintaining judicial oversight. However, I want to pause a moment and address concerns that Canadians have directly raised with me, including constituents who oppose the bill. Some fear that Bill C-22 could require digital service providers to embed surveillance capabilities that may weaken security. Others are concerned about the retention of metadata involving people who are not under investigation. Still others worry that future governments could expand the scope of this law through regulation without sufficient parliamentary scrutiny and oversight.\n\nI understand this mistrust. Too many Canadians feel that governments no longer listen. I did not enter politics to reinforce that cynicism. I entered public life because I believe that trust in our institutions must be earned, and it is only earned through accountability, something that I hope Liberal members of the House also believe in.\n\nAs a Conservative, I believe in limited government, in checks and balances, and in a government that thinks of Canadians, not for them. That is why it matters to be very clear about what Bill C-22 does and does not do. It does not authorize warrantless access to private communication. It does not eliminate judicial oversight. It does not give government the power to read the content of Canadians' messages without court approval. Much like wiretap authorities that Canadians have accepted for decades, police must make their case to a judge, meet defined legal thresholds and operate within strict limits. That is not unchecked power. That is the rule of law.\n\nLet me ground this debate in the real experiences Canadians are facing. In my former riding, police investigated a case where a woman was shaken down by scammers claiming to be the Canada Revenue Agency and demanding payment in bitcoin. The officers in Merritt knew a crime had been committed, but they could not quickly determine whether the perpetrators were even in the country. Pursuing charges would have required significant time and resources, resources that many small-town RCMP detachments simply do not have.\n\nIn West Kelowna, a retired professional was convinced to install remote access applications on her phone and private computer, unknowingly giving criminals full control over her financial life. She lost more than $100,000. Even more disturbing, she was told that contacting the police or even her member of Parliament would place her in violation of national security laws. Fear and deception did the rest.\n\nPerhaps the most disturbing are the countless cases supported by organizations like the Kelowna Child and Youth Advocacy Centre, where children who have already suffered abuse endure further trauma while authorities work urgently to identify, locate and stop the spread of child sexual exploitation materials.\n\nIn each of these cases, time matters. Delay magnifies the harm.\n\nRCMP officers in the Central Okanagan are already carrying the highest caseloads in British Columbia. They are not asking for unchecked authority, they are asking for lawful, court-supervised tools that would allow them to establish basic facts quickly and protect victims sooner.\n\nThat brings me back to the role of Parliament. I want to address a broader point about how Parliament must legislate in the digital age, because this bill is not unique in facing these challenges. Technology evolves faster than legislation ever can. That creates real tension between clarity and flexibility, and between certainty and adaptability.\n\n Canadians are right to be cautious when laws rely on regulations and technical definitions that may change over time. That caution is healthy in a free society. As Conservatives, we have always believed the answer to that tension is not blind trust in government but strong parliamentary oversight. It is Parliament, not the executive, that must define limits, ask hard questions and ensure delegated authorities are narrow, justified, proportionate and, above all else, accountable.\n\n That responsibility does not end at second reading. It continues at committee, through expert testimony, proposed amendments and rigorous scrutiny of how these powers would operate in the real world. It also continues after passage, through ongoing review and accountability.\n\n Canadians should expect nothing less. Protecting privacy and protecting public safety are not competing ideals. They are complementary responsibilities. When the law is outdated, vague or unclear, both privacy and safety suffer. Criminal networks exploit legal uncertainty far more effectively than law-abiding citizens ever could.\n\n Our task as legislators is to ensure the law is precise, restrained and grounded in constitutional principles, while still effective enough to protect the people it is meant to serve. Avoiding that challenge altogether is not neutral. It leaves victims exposed, strains already overburdened police services and erodes confidence in the rule of law. That is the biggest challenge we have. When people believe that the justice system is simply catch-and-release, or that if they phone, like the woman in Merritt, and are simply told they do not have the resources, people lose faith in our institutions. That must change, and not just with Bill C-22. We need to see stronger sanctions. We need to see jail, not bail. We need to re-earn the confidence of Canadians who are so disconcerted over the state of our system.\n\nThat is why we need to ask the tough questions at committee, get into the weeds and fully understand and weigh the tradeoffs between public safety, privacy and individual liberty. Addressing these concerns transparently is not a flaw in this process; it is Parliament doing its job.\n\nThe question before us is whether Parliament will once again allow inaction to become the default or whether we will act carefully, responsibly and within appropriate limits. Our future is undeniably online. If we are serious about protecting Canadians in the future, we must be willing to modernize our laws while respecting people's rights and values.\n\nI believe we can do that. I believe Parliament is capable of getting it right.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419784","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in this place on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna.\n\nA part of me wants to say that we really should not be here, again, having this debate today. It is not just because it is a Friday and not because the debate is unimportant. It is. On the contrary, it is absolutely essential.\n\nSometimes, in the House, we are our own worst e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","label":"Computer crime","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b52f44e5b7a2b4afe88893dcc388c71fe60587889bd0f6129bb436914f3720d6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["efc6f390a91ff6bd3a095872b57c48bb2f199a2e3ac88e0684fcb8c6d0c155ff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Computer crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43443","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d848de547e282052c146e352","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419785,"date":"2026-04-17T17:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the member for Hull—Aylmer's comments. As members of the House of Commons, it is important that we communicate issues clearly and accurately, especially online. There is also an opportunity to make amendments to improve the bill, depending on the nature of the bill, which could be a private member's bill or a government bill. In this case, we are talking about a government bill.\n\nI hope that, if the member participates in the committee study, he will take a closer look at part 2, especially the techniques, equipment and system proposed in the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419785","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the member for Hull—Aylmer's comments. As members of the House of Commons, it is important that we communicate issues clearly and accurately, especially online. There is also an opportunity to make amendments to improve the bill, depending on the nature of the bill, which could be a private member's bill or a government bill. In this case, we are talking about a governmen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Internet","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","label":"Internet","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","label":"Communications","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d8ba2cd96a078f72c211a18ac90443fee4e2a273b56e69d8552193a0082379d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6b82e70d1edd0ca2f0be6bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419786,"date":"2026-04-17T18:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is essential for the opposition to be able to fulfill the role entrusted to it by Canadians. It is particularly important to demand evidence and ask the government to share its reasoning and thought process, especially that of the minister responsible. It is also important for the opposition to press the government to make improvements and to consider our amendments for the benefit of all Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419786","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is essential for the opposition to be able to fulfill the role entrusted to it by Canadians. It is particularly important to demand evidence and ask the government to share its reasoning and thought process, especially that of the minister responsible. It is also important for the opposition to press the government to make improvements and to consider our amendments for the benefit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ae8d5404abdd87ec25ebe25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419787,"date":"2026-04-17T18:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am going to speak about Internet service providers, ISPs, in general. Obviously, there are going to be some distinctions between other large Internet companies other than ISPs, but I think that for the most part, that is what we are going to be talking about in committee.\n\nSimply, right now it is the Wild West. Some ISPs are retaining data for longer than a year and some are doing it for zero days because there is no particular requirement on them. First of all is having a requirement: We need to decide as parliamentarians what is reasonable. We can look at other jurisdictions to see what they have, but we do need to have rules in place so that we can have the rule of law in this space.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419787","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am going to speak about Internet service providers, ISPs, in general. Obviously, there are going to be some distinctions between other large Internet companies other than ISPs, but I think that for the most part, that is what we are going to be talking about in committee.\n\nSimply, right now it is the Wild West. Some ISPs are retaining data for longer than a year and some are doing i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Computer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","label":"Computer services","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","label":"Wildlife","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c2a3a73643c69e6de61b945968e1b40e87e2c20d29893f7ac3d1e75f2099c16"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b26b267112a048eecd458fa8b361aa87477f5459be29d61ba5dbd0c5af8a6d49"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-764100458dfee453400c6b2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299963,"date":"2026-04-21T19:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, while there is much we may debate in the House, today I want to begin with what unites us, which is standing with Canadians affected by cancer. April is Daffodil Month, a time for us to show support for Canadians living with cancer, their families and caregivers.\n\nAs the co-chair of the all-party parliamentary cancer caucus, I want to thank the Canadian Cancer Society for its leadership and non-partisan support.\n\nI also recognize my co-chair, the member for Vaudreuil, and Senator Andrew Cardozo, as well as the patient advocates, researchers and volunteers who make this work possible.\n\nDaffodil Month also reminds us why access to innovation matters. Clinical trials are often a last resort, and they can be a lifeline. As journalist Don Martin recently shared, a clinical trial can quite literally mean the difference between life and death, yet too many Canadians still face unnecessary delays. That is why the Canadian Cancer Society has set a big achievable goal: no more than 75 days from a clinical trial registration to enrolling patients. This means more trials, more innovations and more lives saved here in Canada. This is a goal we can achieve together. \n\nLet us support the work of the Canadian Cancer Society and give those facing a cancer diagnosis hope.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299963","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, while there is much we may debate in the House, today I want to begin with what unites us, which is standing with Canadians affected by cancer. April is Daffodil Month, a time for us to show support for Canadians living with cancer, their families and caregivers.\n\nAs the co-chair of the all-party parliamentary cancer caucus, I want to thank the Canadian Cancer Society for its leadersh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d633540b2fea5b2e2f2c74c219c2600cd40c251180be1cf2887321494ffd8ee3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c28bca6c0534022e1c1cc17bf2d8f40e47e03726d59341ee1fe7c83a141eeeb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca1ce735d7d147445b076cb5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299961,"date":"2026-04-23T19:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when someone leases a new vehicle, they get a new vehicle, but when the Liberals leased a spaceport, all they got for $200 million was a gravel parking lot. I am sure it had nothing to do with the fact that it is in a Liberal riding or that the justice minister's former staffer was the lobbyist for the project or that former Liberal premiers are on the company's advisory board. Clearly, there are no Liberal insiders getting rich at all.\n\nCanadians have only one question: Why are so many Liberal insiders getting so rich off taxpayers on this boondoggle of a lease?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299961","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when someone leases a new vehicle, they get a new vehicle, but when the Liberals leased a spaceport, all they got for $200 million was a gravel parking lot. I am sure it had nothing to do with the fact that it is in a Liberal riding or that the justice minister's former staffer was the lobbyist for the project or that former Liberal premiers are on the company's advisory board. Clearl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e65aab857312b3950d33ade5e5878cbae73bd8d9e2f54f7a8184c9b6a4613159"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f44798cf0b0be8d22651bd686d66ebdc75466e86e55197635bea0a157ae6dac3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67044caaac45897454bd1d7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299962,"date":"2026-04-23T19:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, get the minister some rocket fuel. The Liberals are experts at paying a lot for nothing. They have turned a gravel pit into a money pit.\n\nA former Liberal MP got $237 million for ventilators that went straight into the scrap heap. A Nova Scotia wind farm, tightly connected to former Liberal MPs, got a $206-million loan. Liberal insiders are making bank, while too many Canadians are at the food bank.\n\nWhen will a satellite be launched from our $200-million parking lot?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299962","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, get the minister some rocket fuel. The Liberals are experts at paying a lot for nothing. They have turned a gravel pit into a money pit.\n\nA former Liberal MP got $237 million for ventilators that went straight into the scrap heap. A Nova Scotia wind farm, tightly connected to former Liberal MPs, got a $206-million loan. Liberal insiders are making bank, while too many Canadians are at","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Satellites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wind energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","label":"Wind energy","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","label":"Satellites","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ee207ed23b065b1654e533fb5f3605c52af9ff6a772921a458aca44fa34296c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f9672e1133f9b8df851adfb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299959,"date":"2026-04-24T15:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I certainly appreciate the hon. member's presence. I hope he is doing well.\n\nWhat I would say is simply that the Chief Electoral Officer, years ago, went to the PROC committee and asked the government to do something about the ballot issue of having the longest ballot committee causing such consternation in repeated by-election after by-election, and even in the last election.\n\nDoes the hon. member regret how his government let Canadian voters down by waiting so long to introduce the simple amendment to the bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299959","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I certainly appreciate the hon. member's presence. I hope he is doing well.\n\nWhat I would say is simply that the Chief Electoral Officer, years ago, went to the PROC committee and asked the government to do something about the ballot issue of having the longest ballot committee causing such consternation in repeated by-election after by-election, and even in the last election.\n\nDoes t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3f7169bd9b5dc7e78d8452ca118975d202b99c4899466e018668318886c85652"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2191103199dc0e0ccf2bbed76eeaa8f60f0693319ef7aed7e8752a4d57769742"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0fe70c4f90c8ebb5b5ffe2d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299960,"date":"2026-04-24T15:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in the earlier reply to my question, the member said that Canadians elected a prime minister. I think that is a misnomer that we need to correct. Canadians elect MPs.\n\nIn fact, last night on a panel, Althia Raj said, \"This Prime Minister definitely has an authoritarian streak. We've seen this with all types of legislation. I was struck after the by-election when he referred to his MPs in English as his 'deputies'. At first he was saying that. I thought it was just an error in translation; he means 'députés', and then he was just saying it in English. But then he keeps repeating it, so I'm starting to wonder if he actually thinks members of Parliament are his deputies to do his bidding in the House of Commons, which is not their job.\"\n\nDoes the member believe he is the deputy to the Prime Minister, or does he serve his riding?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299960","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in the earlier reply to my question, the member said that Canadians elected a prime minister. I think that is a misnomer that we need to correct. Canadians elect MPs.\n\nIn fact, last night on a panel, Althia Raj said, \"This Prime Minister definitely has an authoritarian streak. We've seen this with all types of legislation. I was struck after the by-election when he referred to his MPs","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66c834db810b3630c8a3664b17c905b97dde3d3a4cbfb7b3acef132544e3e6ce"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-588d437b6537a05b266f7771","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723477,"date":"2026-04-28T15:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Conservatives agree that Canada has a proud history in space and that we have great talent and great opportunities in space. However, we have to set aside the past and future in terms of our idealism because what the minister was speaking about was sovereignty. We must be real. We must look at the bill as it is, right here and right now.\n\n In the bill, the minister has not even defined what launch and relaunch are. The minister has not introduced a bill that would protect our sovereignty. There is no national security screening of payloads. A firm from another country could use any rocket launch as an ability to put a dual-use satellite into orbit, undermining our sovereignty, particularly when satellites are looking at the north. I would like the minister to address these subjects.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Satellites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723477","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Conservatives agree that Canada has a proud history in space and that we have great talent and great opportunities in space. However, we have to set aside the past and future in terms of our idealism because what the minister was speaking about was sovereignty. We must be real. We must look at the bill as it is, right here and right now.\n\n In the bill, the minister has not even ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","label":"Satellites"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Satellites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","label":"Satellites","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7cd1f5f2336566b10e7ff6a7fa23a058d046fa6ca8095724a355867391f1c0a4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Satellites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0285bedd7fe4d4c180d9f9c4fbb1ff13e8ed69352b90b8fa2d35b8df9209a3f5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Satellites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2151fc22fe901ad67647b54d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723479,"date":"2026-04-28T15:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the minister needs to talk about exactly why he has chosen the bill to give himself so much power. He would be approving permits and re-entries, launches, etc. The list goes on. Indemnification is essentially where the taxpayer offers insurance to private operators for indemnifying their launches. The way the bill is written, the minister could give special treatment to one firm and a different set of rules for another. \n\nHow can the minister look at this Parliament in the eye and say that he is trying to attract capital with such an opaque system that would be so arbitrary in how it will be applied? If we want to do well in space, we need to have the rule of law, not the rule of one minister, where he can pick and choose winners and losers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723479","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the minister needs to talk about exactly why he has chosen the bill to give himself so much power. He would be approving permits and re-entries, launches, etc. The list goes on. Indemnification is essentially where the taxpayer offers insurance to private operators for indemnifying their launches. The way the bill is written, the minister could give special treatment to one firm and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance companies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083677","label":"Insurance companies","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a7e94fc7581f5fe577bbebbf121408ffd96f314debb6c2038ea4a23e462be7c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["569bd23d796a861fc1540dcc45c0a4ac2247cfc0d85a35fff941ba5cb25b0fac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9100220efb49f1e81bd1c6f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723488,"date":"2026-04-28T15:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise in this place to participate in debate, particularly when the official opposition has the opportunity to apply serious scrutiny to legislation that asks Parliament to hand broad authority away from itself and to the executive.\n\nBill C-28 deals with space launch and re-entry. It is not ideological. Most Canadians support the idea of Canada having a domestic space capability. They understand its importance to innovation, economic growth and, increasingly, national security. I support that goal as well, but ambition does not excuse poor design. Supporting the objective does not mean giving the government a blank cheque, especially in a sector that involves public safety, national security and potentially significant taxpayer exposure.\n\n We are entering a period of rapid growth in space-based activity. Satellite deployment, re-entry technologies and launch infrastructure are expanding quickly. Canada does not want to be left behind, and it should not be. The government argues that Bill C-28 is needed because Canada lacks a clear legislative framework for space launch and re-entry. That is true. These activities have been managed through aviation law and ad hoc decisions. That approach is no longer adequate.\n\nWhat is troubling is that Bill C-28 would not replace uncertainty with a clear law. It would replace it with discretion. Rather than having Parliament define rules, the bill asks Parliament to approve a framework and trust that the real decisions would be made later through regulation and ministerial judgment. The hardest questions are deferred. The risks are obscured. Parliamentary control is weakened.\n\nWhen one reads this bill carefully, the pattern is unmistakable. Launch permits, re-entry approvals, site certification, emergency stop powers, land use restrictions, financial responsibility requirements, exemptions from those requirements and the indemnification of private operators would all be placed within the discretion of the Minister of Transport. This is where the bill starts to drift from concerning to almost surreal. This entire regime assumes that the minister would personally oversee permits, exemptions, indemnification decisions, emergency stop orders, land use restrictions and national security judgments in one of the most complex and high-risk emerging sectors of the economy.\n\n That might sound reassuring until we remember that as of this moment, Canada does not even have a full-time Minister of Transport. We are being asked to believe that a part-time minister already juggling multiple portfolios would somehow have the time, the capacity and the sustained focus to personally weigh launch permits, re-entry approvals, liability thresholds, indemnification decisions and national security considerations, sometimes under time pressure, sometimes under political pressure, while taxpayers carry the downside risk.\n\nThis is not a governance model. This is wishful thinking dressed up as legislation, which leads to a very practical question that the government has not answered and cannot avoid. When this industry scales up, and the government insists that it will, who exactly is supposed to manage all of this? Who is reviewing each permit? Who is assessing each re-entry? Who is recalibrating liability exposure? Who is deciding whether an operator qualifies for indemnification and when it does not? Under this bill, almost all the responsibility would flow upward to one political office, not to an independent regulator, not to a transparent statutory process, but to the discretion of the minister.\n\n Good policy depends on systems, not personalities. Bill C-28 gives us neither. Nowhere in this design flaw is that more serious than in the indemnification and liability provisions of the bill. Bill C-28 would remove space launch and re-entry activities, which, by the way, are not even defined in the act. It would take those activities from a normal aviation insurance framework and replace them with a new concept called \"financial responsibility\". Parliament would not be told what those minimum levels would be. They obviously would be left to regulation, to be answered by the minister and his officials at their discretion.\n\nThe bill then goes much further. It would allow the minister to reduce or waive those requirements and to indemnify private operators against third party liability, entirely at ministerial discretion. Let us be clear about exactly what that means. Indemnification is not a technical detail. It is government-backed insurance. It transfers risk from private companies onto taxpayers.\n\nIf one operator is indemnified and another is not, the indemnified operator enjoys a powerful competitive advantage. Its risk profile drops, its financing costs fall, and its tolerance for failure increases. Its competitor, facing full commercial exposure, is placed at a structural disadvantage. Nothing in this bill would require indemnification to be offered on equal terms. Nothing would require similar risks to receive similar treatment. Nothing would require advanced disclosure to Parliament. Nothing would require public reporting afterward. This is not flexibility. That is state‐authorized market distortion. \n\nThe political consequences of that structure are enormous. We already have a company operating in this space that has demonstrated financial instability and operational uncertainty. Under Bill C‐28, the same company could benefit enormously if indemnification is loosened or be severely harmed if that protection is tightened or withdrawn. In either case, the impact would be dramatic, but the decision would not be governed by rules set by Parliament. It would be by the politics of the day. If indemnification is loosened, taxpayers could be exposed to substantial and unquantified liability without ever knowing or realizing it. If it is withdrawn, a company could become commercially unviable almost overnight. In both cases, the consequences would be profound, yet the decision would occur behind closed doors. \n\nTaxpayers would not know what risks they were carrying. Parliament would not know what exposure it had approved. Only the minister would know. This is not transparency and accountability, and it is not responsible governance in a strategic sector involving public safety, national security and public money. When indemnification decisions are left entirely to ministerial discretion, they inevitably become political decisions. They are influenced by timing, urgency, pressure and optics. None of those is a substitute for law.\n\nThis bill would effectively ask Parliament to assume that every minister under every political circumstance would exercise his or her power perfectly. History suggests otherwise. Laws exist precisely because judgment is imperfect and politics change. Taxpayers should never bear catastrophic risk as the result of decisions they cannot see, cannot measure and cannot challenge. \n\nThe weakness in this bill extends beyond indemnification. The government speaks often about sovereignty and security when promoting Bill C‐28, yet the legislation fails to embed basic national security safeguards in statute. There would be no statutory requirement for foreign ownership or control screening of launch operators or payloads. There would be no requirement for beneficial ownership transparency. There would be no statutory test for payload mission profiles or end use. There would be no mandatory integration of intelligence or national security assessments into the approval process. Instead, these issues would be left to regulation or the discretion of the minister in the public interest. \n\nI have served on the Standing Joint Committee for the Scrutiny of Regulations, and we have seen, time after time, what happens when the use of the term \"public interest\" is exercised without any details from Parliament as to what is in the public interest in this narrow set of circumstances. What happens is uncertainty. What would happen under this bill? That uncertainty would be either a yes or a no from the minister, with no explanation given other than a denial. The minister could say, \"It is not in the public interest to give you this permit. I'm revoking it.\" We could ask what the public interest is, but the minister would not have any responsibility to say what it is. \n\nUsually, in the Aeronautics Act, someone would go to an administrative tribunal that has a specialty in this, but guess what. The minister has exempted this act from that tribunal's auspices. Essentially, a company would have a window, based on weather conditions, to get a payload through the atmosphere. Suddenly, it would have to go to court to challenge a decision, which would inevitably cost the taxpayer money because the justice department now would have to say what is in the public interest, but it is not defined by law. This is a recipe for uncertainty, and for the minister to say it would give certainty to a market that has yet to exist is a big warning sign flashing. I want to say, \"Ottawa, we have a problem here.\" \n\nThe result here is a convergence of risk that includes broad executive power, opaque indemnification authority, reduced independent review, large financial commitments and no hard-wired national security screening. This, like space, is a vacuum, a vacuum of accountability. The reasons the minister could give to deny a permit would be as black as space. We would not be able to see transparently why it was denied. This is a problem, considering that there is so much to be said about the Liberal government's penchant for insiders. \n\nWe know of the MLS launch. We know of the public record, which has been widely distributed, about it not being a going concern, then 158 conversations with the PMO and different ministers later and, wow, suddenly there is a $200-million lease for a property that was previously leased from the Province of Nova Scotia for $13,500 a year. It is now $55,000 a day. \n\nAgain, opaque processes, uncertainty and the discretion of one individual are not a recipe for the rule of law. It is a recipe for inside activity. I have said a lot about these things because I am concerned and because I am a proud Canadian. I believe in innovation. I believe in progress. I believe we have Canadian know-how, and we have proven it, time and time again, but this is not a bill for our times. This is a bill for insiders. \n\nLet me be very clear. I have not been speaking about Canadian space launch capacity. This is an argument against governing it badly. Canada needs domestic launch and re-entry infrastructure. I am sure we can all agree on that. We also need clear, predictable and competitive rules, or else we are only going to track businesses that we will end up identifying, and we will not innovate because there will not be a sphere of competition that drives innovation, reduces costs and sees new ways and approaches come forward. This is because, under this act, there would not be the incentive to do so. \n\nIt would be more incentive to get a better lobbyist than to get a better rocket. That is not the rocket fuel this industry needs or wants. We need taxpayers protected from unknowable exposure. We need national security safeguards that are automatic and non-negotiable. Once a satellite is in orbit and it does not use Canadian spectrum, the government has no responsibility or power over that satellite. That satellite, as I said, could be at the behest of a state actor and, let us be mindful, the People's Republic of China does require its companies, under its national security laws, to comply with whatever they are asked of by the authoritarian government in Beijing. The Russians also have an interest in the north and its surveillance of the north. \n\nThese are questions that the official opposition members are asking for some accountability on and some better answers. With what I heard today from the minister in his responses to me on national security and indemnification, it is clear that he has either not done the work or is silent on purpose. \n\nWe need Parliament, not a minister, setting the rules for this space. We do not need legislation that privatizes reward, nationalizes risk and leaves Canadians in the dark. Space policy, I would argue, is too important, too expensive and too sensitive to be governed this way. Again, capital flows to stability. \n\nThe minister is right that Canada has some wonderful attributes. We are a country that is politically stable. We have, most of the time, the rule of law, but if a large company were looking to make a strategic investment in Canada and seize this regime, and unless they have an inside track with a lobbyist who has the ability to get them what they want, I question that this is the right approach.\n\nIf the government is serious about our sovereignty, it should be serious about accountability. If it is serious about security, it should put it right into the statute, right into Bill C-28. If it is serious about market activity, it should stop designing laws that reward discretion over discipline. Parliament should not approve a framework that asks Canadians to trust what they cannot see.\n\nI would like to say that it is always a pleasure to be here and to debate these important topics on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. I urge my colleagues to take the time to look into Bill C-28 to see with their own eyes not only what is there, which is the fact that almost all of the power would be given to one person, but also the large gaps in the bill that this Parliament could and should address.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723488","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise in this place to participate in debate, particularly when the official opposition has the opportunity to apply serious scrutiny to legislation that asks Parliament to hand broad authority away from itself and to the executive.\n\nBill C-28 deals with space launch and re-entry. It is not ideological. Most Canadians support the idea of Canada having a dom","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4b3cf57f95e8fa4ab827120fd3ff9b7562c0ac160b05df24481a49c184d31dce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["33590d336ada0d7af3c4750dd74882c10a3a4b053f2d2a42a4c1d9d6dc4edb60"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f712573323b0e694f2bc26e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723492,"date":"2026-04-28T15:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Conservative Party of Canada believes in Canadians and their know-how.\n\n We have a strong record, from Diefenbaker and the Alouette I, the first Canadian satellite to be launched. Brian Mulroney created the space act, which is the framework for much of the Canadian missions where we partnered with other countries, to the great success of Canadarm, among other projects. It was Stephen Harper, in 2014, who created a space sovereignty framework that this government, in this new legislation, seems to be ignoring completely.\n\nWhen we talk about sovereignty, it is non-negotiable, yet under this particular bill, it is discretionary.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723492","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Conservative Party of Canada believes in Canadians and their know-how.\n\n We have a strong record, from Diefenbaker and the Alouette I, the first Canadian satellite to be launched. Brian Mulroney created the space act, which is the framework for much of the Canadian missions where we partnered with other countries, to the great success of Canadarm, among other projects. It was St","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ee3d6bcb72aa0e20f5b7ed24f65fe87df4ee10d880c39f014fb51b8b868412c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["498001b9eff651df398cb0f0a87b88b893f2b2d95c0d93025bc9a8b87aee74b2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f20f50782ec73b108ed6501","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723495,"date":"2026-04-28T15:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I certainly appreciate this member's intervention here today because it highlights that the government has a penchant for giving itself ultimate discretion at the expense of someone else.\n\n There is no greater sign of this than the government's actually removing access to a tribunal. Tribunals are there for administrative fairness. Let me give an example. If a space firm that is operating legally in Canada is not favoured by the government for whatever reason, maybe they used the wrong lobbyist, had an application come in with a tight time window, or has a spelling or technical error that could easily be rectified, the minister could simply say, \"Sorry\". That launch would then be scuttled at great cost to that individual company.\n\n Being able to go to a tribunal to be able to rectify these things gives people confidence that they can move forward. If they have to take the government to court over something as simple as an error on a permit, that is ridiculous.\n\n One might ask why the government would want it this way. That is what we are asking. Why would the government be giving itself unfettered discretion unless it had a plan to do something with that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723495","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I certainly appreciate this member's intervention here today because it highlights that the government has a penchant for giving itself ultimate discretion at the expense of someone else.\n\n There is no greater sign of this than the government's actually removing access to a tribunal. Tribunals are there for administrative fairness. Let me give an example. If a space firm that is ope","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mergers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036263","label":"Mergers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a11dc4d0883b881a11ad8c372b3801e2964f05a30e848b56901c9dcbfb80b9a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ea7d58f5bc64523213197ed81eaeaf913067103afcc3b4bae07ca64dfa360a8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88b0586a4b8568ceff174eab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723498,"date":"2026-04-28T15:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is important for us to acknowledge what the minister himself said. He said that the world will want what Canada could have here. Well, the world is a lot of people, and some of them do not align with our values or our goals as a nation, so it makes sense that, if there is a gap where there is no screening over who owns what technology and what that technology is used for, that could be circumvented.\n\nRight now, which countries lead the world in rockets? We have the United States, Russia and China, all of whom would have some sort of interest in our north. Again, Canadian rockets are the fundamental part to making this sovereignty happen. We need a legislative framework, sure, but we also need to have Canadian rockets, or else this launch pad would just be a launch pad for other nations' rockets and, without the proper screening, for payloads that are for their objectives, not ours.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723498","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is important for us to acknowledge what the minister himself said. He said that the world will want what Canada could have here. Well, the world is a lot of people, and some of them do not align with our values or our goals as a nation, so it makes sense that, if there is a gap where there is no screening over who owns what technology and what that technology is used for, that co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b30c31658e3f746b90a50e2375d033c783104e50b1f339a623187a2fd0f1d860"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8384fa2f5217136bffe23fdd20eb8dcd2426dba8ca2fdf01de5ce2556d4f4a21"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8276dfa29cfcda841036a1e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723501,"date":"2026-04-28T15:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, this is how far down the government has gone, that the members are referring to a launch pad. In a competitive market that is well-regulated, there could be multiple launch pads, but we have only one. We have only one because the government has given a $200-million lease over 10 years, $55,000 a day, to a company that had a lease for the same property from the Province of Nova Scotia for $13,500 a year. In its own corporate notes, it states that this company was not a going concern, which means to the average person that it would be going out of business. Then, miraculously, the company got this lease after lobbying, and suddenly we are all supposed to pin our hopes on it.\n\nThe gentleman across the way mentioned a company in his riding. We are very supportive of that, but I will remind the member that, first, a properly functioning market would have probably more than one spaceport. Second, we would probably see individual money being brought in, which could create that. Last, those satellites do not miraculously sprout wings and fly off into the stratosphere from the space pad. They need rockets. \n\nHow can we support our industry, and how can we encourage industries to come here? Right now, if this thing were put to test right away, it would be other countries' rockets.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723501","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, this is how far down the government has gone, that the members are referring to a launch pad. In a competitive market that is well-regulated, there could be multiple launch pads, but we have only one. We have only one because the government has given a $200-million lease over 10 years, $55,000 a day, to a company that had a lease for the same property from the Province of Nova Scoti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","label":"Personal income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","label":"Personal finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2573e8d31315b3314baaa4eb9734afcf3f74835a27449706a194b2dff49f366b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4befecc75abeed2c4ceedef1d5413dcb74de0642a8a823ecec717b376fb9e588"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5da28ca87b0d62e4a3085463","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723504,"date":"2026-04-28T15:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am going to paraphrase the New York Times saying that democracy dies under darkness. When we have darkness and opaque processes, and the discretion of one particular minister who has market-distorting—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723504","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am going to paraphrase the New York Times saying that democracy dies under darkness. When we have darkness and opaque processes, and the discretion of one particular minister who has market-distorting—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-514707e2ab4395817c4dcf88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723506,"date":"2026-04-28T15:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, one might say the question is whether the speaker is working properly.\n\nI would simply say that if we have a competitive market with a proper regulatory structure, good things will happen, but right now, insiders and those who would exploit our national security gaps put us at risk.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723506","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, one might say the question is whether the speaker is working properly.\n\nI would simply say that if we have a competitive market with a proper regulatory structure, good things will happen, but right now, insiders and those who would exploit our national security gaps put us at risk.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65906bf4d2131b84d86037eaa462f3c0ef1c61c3c4fcd9ea6d3946bcc8d18985"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a69b672fcae7d964fe2f0c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723516,"date":"2026-04-28T16:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member for Winnipeg North mentioned his admiration for what the U.K. has done, in terms of its space program. In fact, the outer space program act of 1986 established very clearly under the U.K. model that the licensing authority must be satisfied that an activity will not impact national security. There is no statutory duty to consult DND or CSIS in Bill C-28 and no defined national security clearance. This completely contrasts with what the U.K. has.\n\nDoes this member realize that there is a real existing gap that puts us at risk, compared to our G7 partners?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723516","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member for Winnipeg North mentioned his admiration for what the U.K. has done, in terms of its space program. In fact, the outer space program act of 1986 established very clearly under the U.K. model that the licensing authority must be satisfied that an activity will not impact national security. There is no statutory duty to consult DND or CSIS in Bill C-28 and no defined nat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","label":"Licensing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","label":"Licensing","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["56eaecdfa39db082c3e48b8c10ebd394b8f85ba65126c0e8366b5155f15586e0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e4d789bbc10ac04f8129c37d4f042899cfc43f1641db3c378dd533b6a784fc9f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce8ccf4eae60930a91960820","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723519,"date":"2026-04-28T17:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member is an industrious member of the transport committee. I learn more each time I speak with him.\n\nEarlier today, the Minister of Transport told me in response to a question that the people at the Canadian Space Agency would help him make sure that payloads have national security screening. There would be no statutory duty to consult DND or CSIS. The Canadian Space Agency is not a security or intelligence body. It has no statutory mandate to conduct national security investigations. It has expertise but zero authority.\n\nIs the member concerned that the minister would depend on an agency to do something it is not meant to do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723519","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member is an industrious member of the transport committee. I learn more each time I speak with him.\n\nEarlier today, the Minister of Transport told me in response to a question that the people at the Canadian Space Agency would help him make sure that payloads have national security screening. There would be no statutory duty to consult DND or CSIS. The Canadian Space Agency is no","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["956f75e9dad2bd4c2cd04f4d76f7a4ab21d620ed3ca8a876520b60d1e1bdb150"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fadd0c89b483c37a272ddc15ce1d73d722b70fde16da08416162823a8ec2fc4e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8038a414cfbef9c5121f5996","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723523,"date":"2026-04-28T17:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the parliamentary secretary may or may not be aware, but the Minister of Transport, when I questioned him today about the glaring gaps in national security screening, said not to worry because we have the Canadian Space Agency. Well, the Canadian Space Agency has no national security mandate. In fact, the bill itself, Bill C-28, is completely silent on CSIS or any other national security review.\n\nIf the Canadian Space Agency has expertise, maybe on a technological basis, but no authority when it comes to national security, who is in charge of making sure that our system is not going to be compromised? We can look at the United Kingdom and the United States: They have clear national security to make sure there are not dual-use technologies that can be applied against their people. There is nothing in this bill on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723523","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the parliamentary secretary may or may not be aware, but the Minister of Transport, when I questioned him today about the glaring gaps in national security screening, said not to worry because we have the Canadian Space Agency. Well, the Canadian Space Agency has no national security mandate. In fact, the bill itself, Bill C-28, is completely silent on CSIS or any other national secur","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","label":"Space technology","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["635140cf9bcbb283e5f943ffc2b2044985596e60b375c74044cb75752e610cab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["189023267ab44778d7169a5344f1efa95d5382534c7b0319923363aeb5b473f7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4568020e2e2222e29af99c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723527,"date":"2026-04-28T17:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we do not have translation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723527","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we do not have translation.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a09717d9472cc867d38bda8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723531,"date":"2026-04-28T18:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the government has said multiple times that this would align Canada with other G7 countries, like the U.K. and the United States. \n\nThe legislation in the U.K., the Outer Space Act 1986, literally says that the licensing authority must be satisfied that an activity will not impede national security. In the United States, Congress decided that the giving of indemnification to participants in the space industry should be decided by Congress and not by the administration itself. Why would this legislation do neither?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723531","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the government has said multiple times that this would align Canada with other G7 countries, like the U.K. and the United States. \n\nThe legislation in the U.K., the Outer Space Act 1986, literally says that the licensing authority must be satisfied that an activity will not impede national security. In the United States, Congress decided that the giving of indemnification to participa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fa7f83d53833c8b4aa2f0df5088c7f77e5409ec1d0c561b14f58dec85a84d14"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79de99f5d47a8c3a139f4662","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723537,"date":"2026-04-28T18:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I certainly appreciate the member's big contribution on this topic today, particularly about the uneasy relationship the government has with MLS. It seems crazy to me that something that is rented for $13,500 per year is effectively receiving $55,000 a day from the Government of Canada. Bear in mind that this property is owned by the Province of Nova Scotia.\n\nThere are other key elements in this bill that would allow the minister to use total discretion in who he can give permits to and under what terms. Does the member feel that this will benefit insiders, well-connected Liberals and lobbyists?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723537","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I certainly appreciate the member's big contribution on this topic today, particularly about the uneasy relationship the government has with MLS. It seems crazy to me that something that is rented for $13,500 per year is effectively receiving $55,000 a day from the Government of Canada. Bear in mind that this property is owned by the Province of Nova Scotia.\n\nThere are other key eleme","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["768aa39a7d43b54c503d655613c246c2e540406ba802267e62f7e8a33684a1cd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-adf36f08fc899e731ea6631e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723541,"date":"2026-04-28T18:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member mentioned Marc Garneau. I think this is important, because many of us in the House knew him. In addition to his successful career in the navy, he ended up leading the Canadian Space Agency. Later on he became a Liberal member of Parliament and eventually a minister. I remember Mr. Garneau very well. When I first came to the House, we may have had our political differences, but I have always believed him to be a hero, and I do believe we need to honour our veterans and honour public service. I thank the member opposite for mentioning the service of Marc Garneau.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723541","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member mentioned Marc Garneau. I think this is important, because many of us in the House knew him. In addition to his successful career in the navy, he ended up leading the Canadian Space Agency. Later on he became a Liberal member of Parliament and eventually a minister. I remember Mr. Garneau very well. When I first came to the House, we may have had our political differences, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["172fbaaa61bb11cec3fb082c4d0d0d1beea6632ac701d78545d5e6595ef701dd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02ed4e87dc2d960b845607d7dc77af176e0f18f98750c16a22557a4cf3144fd5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1f195f1ced38eb5b78b4f00","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723543,"date":"2026-04-28T18:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when I questioned the minister earlier this morning about the gaps in the bill when it comes to national security, he said not to worry and that we would be working with the Canadian Space Agency. However, the Canadian Space Agency does not do national security or intelligence, nor does it have a mandate to do so. CSIS is not included in the bill, and neither is the RCMP. Does the member believe that there needs to be a solid reprisal or a change to the bill to address this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723543","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when I questioned the minister earlier this morning about the gaps in the bill when it comes to national security, he said not to worry and that we would be working with the Canadian Space Agency. However, the Canadian Space Agency does not do national security or intelligence, nor does it have a mandate to do so. CSIS is not included in the bill, and neither is the RCMP. Does the mem","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5b7f6cb70744c5abe8196f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723544,"date":"2026-04-28T20:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I homed in particularly on the fact that the member has mentioned the administrative, arbitrary nature of the minister's power. First of all, it would all be concentrated in the minister. He would actually be taking it away from the transportation tribunal that usually handles these things. Again, there is very little specificity as to what is in the public interest. The minister could literally give one indemnification rate to one market participant, and another to a different performer, totally distorting the market.\n\nCould the member please comment a bit about who would benefit from a regime that is so opaque and arbitrary?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723544","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I homed in particularly on the fact that the member has mentioned the administrative, arbitrary nature of the minister's power. First of all, it would all be concentrated in the minister. He would actually be taking it away from the transportation tribunal that usually handles these things. Again, there is very little specificity as to what is in the public interest. The minister coul","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["954365143a7426b487810fca9c42e835fbd0326e38053078e6cd176aa08affb8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a2fbfd32357a43aa676cb6f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723553,"date":"2026-04-28T20:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think that the member has raised, in his comments today, a very good example. If the oil and gas sector was regulated the way that the Minister of Transport is suggesting Bill C-28 should be regulated, it would be all-powerful and it would be for arbitrary reasons.\n\nI think industry participants would say it would not be fair if certain companies were insured and certain companies were not insured, and if certain companies could get a permit to start drilling and certain ones could not. That is an opaque system. It would not be tolerated in any investment-oriented enterprise like oil and gas.\n\nCould the member talk a bit more about how MLS lobbied the PMO and ministers over 150 times and somehow acquired this lease where it is getting $55,000 a day from the federal government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723553","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think that the member has raised, in his comments today, a very good example. If the oil and gas sector was regulated the way that the Minister of Transport is suggesting Bill C-28 should be regulated, it would be all-powerful and it would be for arbitrary reasons.\n\nI think industry participants would say it would not be fair if certain companies were insured and certain companies w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance companies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083677","label":"Insurance companies","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4062dfeda109ee08a80869ee06d49cb4f144652677f64ae0bcf6a01ae28ca2b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b7095ed3e0b202194ba397277c25df43da8b78974f517138bf97a5f8fdbe580"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0dcb0f1772abea8519a898f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723475,"date":"2026-04-29T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians were promised change after a decade of a costly Liberal government under Justin Trudeau. Yesterday, they did not get change; they got more of the same. The Liberals are asking every Canadian household to shoulder roughly $3,400 of new debt from a Prime Minister who said he would be different. This costly credit card budget delivers more debt, more costs and more taxes, and it is doubling the deficit while life gets more expensive.\n\nWhich promise was false, the promise of change, or the claim that doubling the deficit would somehow make Canadians better off?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723475","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians were promised change after a decade of a costly Liberal government under Justin Trudeau. Yesterday, they did not get change; they got more of the same. The Liberals are asking every Canadian household to shoulder roughly $3,400 of new debt from a Prime Minister who said he would be different. This costly credit card budget delivers more debt, more costs and more taxes, and i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["019cc9f51fe2b27d18c46bc62d8d17c2c7b0eb05e9ce7677dfad87f9209a68ff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["36706ad8e4b85b0c9b762ac0affd61ad5cb5b0d72f29dedd4e97057d34c237ac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4248217382157ff8ffe22189","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":723476,"date":"2026-04-29T19:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the only thing the government delivers is more recycled talking points. Even The Globe and Mail says that, in this upside-down Liberal world, a spending increase of $26.8 billion is not a spending cut. For every $100 in new revenue, the government spends 97% of it. \n\nWill the government admit this costly credit card budget proves nothing has changed, or are Canadians now supposed to believe that doubling the deficit is fiscal responsibility?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723476","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the only thing the government delivers is more recycled talking points. Even The Globe and Mail says that, in this upside-down Liberal world, a spending increase of $26.8 billion is not a spending cut. For every $100 in new revenue, the government spends 97% of it. \n\nWill the government admit this costly credit card budget proves nothing has changed, or are Canadians now supposed to b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b152b8d961b811afe624fb52dce5566758c60249d49c08fc34aac0b18e8c88e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0902552d4ff18d6cfbf108a3c3c42efc9d565dc812d735bbb6a85a746893cba2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-16c71bf278b423a7260f2538","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752434,"date":"2026-05-04T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the minister of employment, in response to the member for Calgary East, was clearly reading off notes that had a member's picture on both sides, clearly making it a prop and making it very easy to be seen on the screen.\n\nThis is something that I think you need to take a look at, Mr. Speaker. It is obviously a planned practice by the government, by that minister, to again present, as she made her comments, an example that had a clear photo on it. That is a prop. It does not follow the traditions of this place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752434","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the minister of employment, in response to the member for Calgary East, was clearly reading off notes that had a member's picture on both sides, clearly making it a prop and making it very easy to be seen on the screen.\n\nThis is something that I think you need to take a look at, Mr. Speaker. It is obviously a planned practice by the government, by that minister, to again present, as s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0577a4f0f9c1300d04bd5cf9be2dce2d5ed39df4005f8be53d5318c679fb23e8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03704f1fd2584df6dce4319f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752425,"date":"2026-05-07T17:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in this place to speak on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. \n\nI have the honour of sharing my time with the hon. member for Richmond Centre—Marpole. \n\nThis past week, Canadians, particularly British Columbians, received deeply troubling news. A new survey from the Business Council of British Columbia found that nearly three-quarters of businesses plan to reduce investment and one-third plan to reduce hiring because of the growing uncertainty around property rights and land title in this country. This uncertainty is not theoretical. It is very real. It affects homeowners, employers, municipalities and investors who believed that, in Canada, fee simple ownership meant certainty.\n\nSince the Cowichan ruling, I have received calls, and I was a bit shocked because Westbank First Nation is in the heart of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna and sits side by side with the City of West Kelowna. I have had people who live in Westbank First Nation ask me questions about their property and whether their investments are safe. This is not surprising because today's debate is really about a simple question that people in my riding are asking: Will the House of Commons stand up for Canadians who followed the rules and invested their life savings, or will it allow uncertainty and inaction to undermine private property rights in Canada? \n\nBusiness leaders are clear about what is driving this concern. It is the increased costs, the delay, the complexity and the unpredictability caused by this court ruling, as well policy reversals and an ever-changing legal landscape. As a result, investment is being shelved, jobs are at risk and confidence is eroding. \n\nWhat we already know is alarming. Fee simple titles held by the city of Richmond, the federal government and the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority are now potentially invalid or ineffective due to this ruling. What we do not know yet is what the full impact will be on private landowners, people who worked hard, followed every rule, paid their taxes and put their entire life savings into their homes and businesses. They are worried, and rightly so. \n\nWhen these concerns are raised, members opposite respond by accusing critics of fearmongering or spreading misinformation. This is what Liberals tend to do when they do not have a substantive answer to serious questions, because these are serious questions. \n\nTo those making those accusations, I would offer this: It was the Liberal government that adopted litigation directive number 14. That directive restricted the arguments Crown lawyers could make in court to defend fee simple property rights. That is not rhetoric. That is documented policy. Litigation directive number 14 is not fearmongering. It is a fact. It is an inconvenient fact for the Prime Minister and his government, one it has refused to explain still being on the books and that is instructing lawyers within its employ. The Prime Minister has been asked repeatedly why his government has continued with this directive, and he has continued to avoid giving a clear answer. \n\nWhy did the Liberal Prime Minister refuse to stand up for property rights when it mattered? That remains unanswered, but what we do know now is that, after the damage has been done, the Prime Minister says he disagrees with this court decision. He now says that private property rights are fundamental and that his government will defend them. I am happy to say that the Prime Minister will have that opportunity with this motion. This opposition day motion gives the Prime Minister a chance to match his words with action, something that is increasingly difficult for the Prime Minister. Will he vote to defend private property rights, or will he vote against them once again? \n\nThis motion proposes practical, substantive and achievable steps to help restore certainty and confidence. First, it calls on the government to put private property first in the Cowichan case by clearly arguing that fee simple ownership has priority. I have heard the term \"viable arguments\", but that does not necessarily mean they are making every argument. Second, the motion specifically calls for litigation directive number 14 to be replaced with a clear requirement that the federal government aggressively defend property rights in all litigation. \n\nThird, the motion requires that no agreement be concluded without explicit protection of fee simple property rights in all future negotiations with first nations, so everyone understands and has some certainty, something failed to have been done under this government and its predecessor. Fourth, it demands a concrete plan from the Prime Minister within 30 days, complete with timelines, to protect Canadians affected by the Cowichan decision and the Musqueam agreement. Finally, it establishes a special parliamentary committee to examine every legal, constitutional and political tool available to protect private property rights in Canada.\n\n These are not radical proposals, and they are not ideological. They are responsible. They only become controversial if one does not believe that private property rights are fundamental to our system, both our system of capitalism in this country and our Westminster system. We have always honoured these things, and the lack of certainty that we see today is causing real harm. It is freezing investment, encouraging litigation and forcing Canadians into a legal limbo with no clear path forward. This is despite the Prime Minister and all his Liberal members of Parliament, or as I have heard it described in the Toronto Star, his deputies, describing everything that the Conservatives say as not being true. \n\nIt should not be this way. Behind closed doors, negotiations are occurring with public tax dollars on the line, while affected Canadians are left without consultation, clarity or protection. Lawyers disagree and experts disagree. Lawsuits are multiplying, and the government is failing to protect the interests of some of the very people it claims to serve.\n\n British Columbia already faces enough challenges. One can look at softwood lumber, American tariffs and an NDP provincial government, which appears to have no idea of what it is doing. We do not need to add property rights chaos to that list, but I guess it already has been. We have to make sure that we pull that off the list. This motion is a way to do that.\n\nThe Prime Minister often says that we should focus on what we can control. Today, with this motion, the House can control something. We can restore certainty, and we can defend property rights. We can stand up for Canadians who, by every account, have done everything right. That is why I will be voting in favour of this motion. The Prime Minister, himself, has said, \"private property rights are fundamental\". Today we will see if his words mean anything.\n\nI urge all hon. members to support this motion and send a clear message that, in Canada, private property rights matter. We hear the concerns raised by British Columbians. We know we have the means to address them. We are dedicated in service to ensuring that their rights and concerns are addressed, not in some far‐off land at some yet-to-be-determined time, but here and now, in this Parliament, in this country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752425","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in this place to speak on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. \n\nI have the honour of sharing my time with the hon. member for Richmond Centre—Marpole. \n\nThis past week, Canadians, particularly British Columbians, received deeply troubling news. A new survey from the Business Council of British Columbia found that nearly three-q","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["511b1803cfd9e674f6b6214a1cc1112b0c864b0468f0661fcc524ea816f96fcf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c05692108543932b6009f7878240a47f5d6c435d75d41fa928b63857cc830399"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d085b0467e7887d53a01a936","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752426,"date":"2026-05-07T17:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I said, Liberal members continue to throw out any concerns as misinformation. What is not misinformation is that in 2019, the Liberals adopted litigation guideline number 14, telling federal lawyers to avoid defending property rights. That directive is still enforced today despite multiple calls by Conservative members for the Prime Minister to show Canadians that he means what he says. He has yet to take us up on that offer.\n\nWe have Liberals saying that it is all misinformation, but it is on the government website. If it is misinformation, is the government now the biggest misleader on this particular case? If we read the website, that is what it says. The member cannot say otherwise because it is the truth.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752426","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I said, Liberal members continue to throw out any concerns as misinformation. What is not misinformation is that in 2019, the Liberals adopted litigation guideline number 14, telling federal lawyers to avoid defending property rights. That directive is still enforced today despite multiple calls by Conservative members for the Prime Minister to show Canadians that he means what he ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c39b3d2b04719c5c12755c938054ac96619cab3f17382b4709f14cb1e1ce6f25"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a628a82dabfdb5894a73d4d5e85bfa847f976e3b3d41af2fd85f63edb2665407"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa858fa2a51fcd4db3ee88d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752427,"date":"2026-05-07T17:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if members read any newspaper in British Columbia, they are going to read about the mayor of Richmond, who has broadly raised this issue while the province and federal government said nothing. They made clear representation on private property rights.\n\nAll we are asking in this motion today, and of Liberal members, is to start listening to British Columbians and those they have elected who have been raising this alarm. They have had lots of time. The fact that they are now sending out members from British Columbia who are just reading talking points, basically giving the same line without concrete action, says to me that they are prepared to vote against this, because they truly do not protect the private property rights of British Columbians or anyone else.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752427","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if members read any newspaper in British Columbia, they are going to read about the mayor of Richmond, who has broadly raised this issue while the province and federal government said nothing. They made clear representation on private property rights.\n\nAll we are asking in this motion today, and of Liberal members, is to start listening to British Columbians and those they have electe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb99eb40cbd3418d5a868ecfbd7d9d42e37c0b04f052096078293862700d10c7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbceb3bcd668c6f456bb5f3a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752428,"date":"2026-05-07T17:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have Liberal members rise to talk about this all being part of reconciliation, but a judge in New Brunswick had a very different interpretation. In fact, when there was talk in a court case in New Brunswick about extinguishment and how it related to private property rights, the judge identified that the one way to dial reconciliation back in a negative direction would be to put the private property rights of the people who I mentioned at risk, those homeowners and business owners who have done everything that has been asked of them under the law. It causes frictions between first nations in British Columbia and Canada and the interests of homeowners and business owners, and now the government is making it all worse.\n\nWe need to work together to get back to a situation where everyone is comfortable with those relations moving forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752428","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have Liberal members rise to talk about this all being part of reconciliation, but a judge in New Brunswick had a very different interpretation. In fact, when there was talk in a court case in New Brunswick about extinguishment and how it related to private property rights, the judge identified that the one way to dial reconciliation back in a negative direction would be to put the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5d9fcccc7d35444f98ee8dc6533ec3422f57f1b39cfb126c0b7c2f01fb1d57ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ac70fa5c28b49591411afb0440f8bee392ab87ddb44549085cda7ea7588e8f0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d5c616ad38d9e9e9a899f8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752429,"date":"2026-05-07T20:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbia land title certainty is foundational. Families buy homes, secure mortgages and plan their futures on the strength of our land registry. Today, homeowners in Richmond are being told that certainty no longer exists because of the Cowichan decision. That ruling followed a federal choice. The Liberal government instructed its lawyers not to defend private property rights in court. In 2019, the Liberals adopted litigation guideline number 14, telling federal lawyers to avoid defending property rights. That directive is still in force today.\n\nWhy is the Prime Minister choosing Liberal ideology over British Columbian homeowners by continuing to tell federal lawyers not to defend their private property rights?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752429","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, British Columbia land title certainty is foundational. Families buy homes, secure mortgages and plan their futures on the strength of our land registry. Today, homeowners in Richmond are being told that certainty no longer exists because of the Cowichan decision. That ruling followed a federal choice. The Liberal government instructed its lawyers not to defend private property rights ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc207e3b9674be8d81eff4709db4a96c0eb9e684b56f754bd394d85926904569"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9067610696787acd96777a784773957339066b20079b220951fcb2145c20c27a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-010ace83cb62b40924857b7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752430,"date":"2026-05-07T20:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, many British Columbians are afraid and they do not have certainty right now. In 2019, the Liberals adopted litigation guideline number 14 telling federal lawyers to avoid defending property rights. That directive is still in force today. \n\nThe Prime Minister likes to talk about things that we can control and focusing on them. Would the leader of the official opposition maybe tell the Prime Minister what is under our control here in Parliament and what the leader of the official opposition tends to do about it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752430","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, many British Columbians are afraid and they do not have certainty right now. In 2019, the Liberals adopted litigation guideline number 14 telling federal lawyers to avoid defending property rights. That directive is still in force today. \n\nThe Prime Minister likes to talk about things that we can control and focusing on them. Would the leader of the official opposition maybe tell the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["26f578b6cb49a68f6045e2548468a8683f87f5e6fc1eae0cdd7576b54ca7004c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a61673bffca73ada49cc5953b31ca4656977ea0f07f0973fe48dda77e6ec3891"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f13ed6599b1c34dd6418a61","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752431,"date":"2026-05-07T22:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, all throughout today's debate, Liberals continue to say that it is Conservatives who are being divisive and creating misinformation, among even worse items.\n\n Now, the mayor of Richmond, Malcolm Brodie, wrote in a letter from the city to all the landowners who were affected that the \"City of Richmond was the only party at trial arguing that the Crown grants of fee simple necessarily extinguished Aboriginal title. The federal and provincial Crowns were each labouring under litigation directives that constrained their ability to argue extinguishment\".\n\n Does the member believe that the mayor of Richmond, Malcolm Brodie, is offering misinformation and being divisive, or is he simply calling out both the federal and provincial governments for their failures to make arguments to protect B.C.'s private property owners' rights?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752431","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, all throughout today's debate, Liberals continue to say that it is Conservatives who are being divisive and creating misinformation, among even worse items.\n\n Now, the mayor of Richmond, Malcolm Brodie, wrote in a letter from the city to all the landowners who were affected that the \"City of Richmond was the only party at trial arguing that the Crown grants of fee simple necessarily e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0b00933df99dffab01a2f43502d24e7d8993fa54e1162b41eb7853b7496503cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0bf2391faaea4463e49101282c6d37e70752ea583fb82c81ce07366bdce2beb2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bdb2ab6cef7a393043ed55b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1033675,"date":"2026-05-25T20:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a Pearson ramp worker said, \"I walk right out through the terminal doors.... Nobody checks you\", and \"We joke that you could walk out carrying a cruise missile\". That is from a W5 investigation exposing organized crime using travellers' baggage to traffic drugs through Pearson airport, a scheme that has been happening for a very long time.\n\nGiven the transport minister's silence on this brazen security failure, Canadians want to know, with the FIFA games set to start in weeks and over a billion dollars committed to security, if the Liberals are not taking this seriously now, why are Canadians to believe they ever will with our security?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033675","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a Pearson ramp worker said, \"I walk right out through the terminal doors.... Nobody checks you\", and \"We joke that you could walk out carrying a cruise missile\". That is from a W5 investigation exposing organized crime using travellers' baggage to traffic drugs through Pearson airport, a scheme that has been happening for a very long time.\n\nGiven the transport minister's silence on th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["87872a76c532356bfbcb2e70dd618e3b6394ea20c18943f3930f44b5bc336ace"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7460d94d7494bf13e581d0bca07cba9e36ecffe84b53d6646f894d662dbe3d0a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73266ff4f8402493667d8073","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021426,"date":"2026-05-26T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when Canadians go through airport security, they submit to invasive screening. Medical implants are flagged. Personal items are confiscated. They are even emptying their baby bottles, yet a worker at Pearson says someone could bring a cruise missile through without detection. \n\nCanadians have already been detained abroad because of security failures here at home. Will the part-time Minister of Transport admit that these failures put Canadians at risk and apologize to those whose lives and reputations have already been harmed by his inaction?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021426","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when Canadians go through airport security, they submit to invasive screening. Medical implants are flagged. Personal items are confiscated. They are even emptying their baby bottles, yet a worker at Pearson says someone could bring a cruise missile through without detection. \n\nCanadians have already been detained abroad because of security failures here at home. Will the part-time Mi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c492ff9163ed309e55b40c0586d2c0ee17ffec8e63d6055f92f3d0eebfaa0fc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e98b1cfd2999ae0ea6adea90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021431,"date":"2026-05-26T19:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, who is minding business at Pearson right now? That answer of 1,000 members someday is not going to work. If these gaps exist at Pearson, our largest airport, why would Canadians believe they do not exist somewhere else?\n\n Will the Liberal government commit, yes or no, to conducting the same security audits at every major airport in Canada and tabling those findings here in Parliament for all Canadians to see? If they will not, is it because this part-time Minister of Transport has no idea how bad it is, or does he just have no idea of what to do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021431","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, who is minding business at Pearson right now? That answer of 1,000 members someday is not going to work. If these gaps exist at Pearson, our largest airport, why would Canadians believe they do not exist somewhere else?\n\n Will the Liberal government commit, yes or no, to conducting the same security audits at every major airport in Canada and tabling those findings here in Parliament ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3115c867ddbe00f6184e1956e5841aae4550ca3f457b89e4074025cc74b44c8e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["33afb68a3d9a84e071ee57e287088cab9c85bbe5c85504c44ae140316c9d71d5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28ed60376eb7a97e6e44c7ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021432,"date":"2026-05-26T20:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, during question period, you suggested that I should be using the proper title of a minister or a member.\n\nIn my comments, if you review the tapes, I did quite rightly refer to the Minister of Transport. I understand you did not like, or maybe the Liberals did not like, the term \"part-time\", but had I said the \"effervescent\" Minister of Transport, that would have been an adjective, the same as I would say a \"part-time\" Minister of Transport.\n\nIf you do not find that this is correct, could you please inform me as to whether or not I should be referring to the \"sometimes\" House leaders—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021432","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, during question period, you suggested that I should be using the proper title of a minister or a member.\n\nIn my comments, if you review the tapes, I did quite rightly refer to the Minister of Transport. I understand you did not like, or maybe the Liberals did not like, the term \"part-time\", but had I said the \"effervescent\" Minister of Transport, that would have been an adjective, the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73d7dafe3743ef69ec4d30d7bbfe0708aeb3f35daf6957c45f9bdc5e9d0e5aff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08bb92234ee490bff39599f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021433,"date":"2026-05-27T01:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, the government is already spending money on land acquisition for the Alto project while public consultations are still active. Why are taxpayers paying for the real estate before consultations are even finished and before the final route is even locked in?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021433","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, the government is already spending money on land acquisition for the Alto project while public consultations are still active. Why are taxpayers paying for the real estate before consultations are even finished and before the final route is even locked in?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real property services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","label":"Resource development","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083678","label":"Real property services","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f6fe16463b2544c991ee56d3f6c4b09efe3865b1b7bcef767f6255032a7d2acd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00f5d60445f27868a221b48ba511f96182eb0bf83e84e8872ce20c70f3c64a90"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da2a360c0edf06e4e87bc56e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021434,"date":"2026-05-27T01:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I realize the minister has been here for a couple of hours, but he has not answered very many questions, if any. I am hopeful he will answer this one.\n\nInternal documents outline a strategy for massive station area land assembly stretching up to two kilometres around a station, explicitly based on the Hong Kong \"rail plus property\" real estate model. Since his bill, Bill C-15, fails to include land abandonment or buyback provisions, if the route changes in an Ottawa neighbourhood like Eastway Gardens, who keeps the excess land and development profits? Is it the government, Alto or the private consortium?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021434","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I realize the minister has been here for a couple of hours, but he has not answered very many questions, if any. I am hopeful he will answer this one.\n\nInternal documents outline a strategy for massive station area land assembly stretching up to two kilometres around a station, explicitly based on the Hong Kong \"rail plus property\" real estate model. Since his bill, Bill C-15, fails to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-787a1bb14a14a5f2dfed4851","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021435,"date":"2026-05-27T01:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, can the minister provide a total land acquisition cost today or confirm that the Department of Finance does not really have a final number because it is busy appraising entire urban neighbourhoods for real estate portfolios?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021435","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, can the minister provide a total land acquisition cost today or confirm that the Department of Finance does not really have a final number because it is busy appraising entire urban neighbourhoods for real estate portfolios?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d1045002ba20b918a85361ca83ae7f4a1247267876f43ae5b33bbadbad7bada"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5012fb72a6ff522283b213de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1033671,"date":"2026-05-27T01:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I am not looking for a generational answer. I am just looking for an answer.\n\n Under this public-private partnership, do taxpayers carry 100% of the expropriation and route change risk while the private consortium carries zero per cent of that risk? I would like just a simple yes or no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033671","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I am not looking for a generational answer. I am just looking for an answer.\n\n Under this public-private partnership, do taxpayers carry 100% of the expropriation and route change risk while the private consortium carries zero per cent of that risk? I would like just a simple yes or no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ac44aed132c7ce1a3d92f3572bf96bddfbe26c241a94e4d073799341401369ae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb8ec49f7d0238da212eb69f03f6e26a78bff23a480576148cc25695cf9ebfc2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-faba081e045d308643560816","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1033672,"date":"2026-05-27T01:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I thought I asked the minister a good question.\n\nI guess the minister has a different impression of what answers mean to someone else.\n\nIf the public takes all the financial gambles on surplus land assembly, and the private sector takes all the development guarantees, what risk is actually private in this partnership? Maybe the minister can answer that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033672","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I thought I asked the minister a good question.\n\nI guess the minister has a different impression of what answers mean to someone else.\n\nIf the public takes all the financial gambles on surplus land assembly, and the private sector takes all the development guarantees, what risk is actually private in this partnership? Maybe the minister can answer that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["098b53168d48b526d99c4a873b6228bd888afeafe341094115ed3b655f39c291"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8e81f80b8dbfa3102c60862","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1033673,"date":"2026-05-27T01:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, maybe the minister is less touchy about this, so I will turn to airport policy.\n\nThe government is expanding its information-gathering powers under division 6 of Bill C-30 to include every single airport authority in Canada. What are our national airports worth today, and has a full valuation been provided to Parliament, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033673","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, maybe the minister is less touchy about this, so I will turn to airport policy.\n\nThe government is expanding its information-gathering powers under division 6 of Bill C-30 to include every single airport authority in Canada. What are our national airports worth today, and has a full valuation been provided to Parliament, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bccbd0ac6646537a58b7e773b63301aecf1b5b7615abfa84846feced1b7387e4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c410d1536302d9f186b2c2ae7995db3e2b0098c4be039fd9469dc8c9f99648c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-337a5fb1f824fce407f4399b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1033674,"date":"2026-05-27T01:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, since the proceeds of these alternative ownership models are earmarked to be stripped away from local operators and siphoned to the Canada Strong fund, how will our airports maintain their infrastructure when they are being left unintentionally undercapitalized while travellers are hit with massive fee hikes just to satisfy a private investor's ROI?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033674","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, since the proceeds of these alternative ownership models are earmarked to be stripped away from local operators and siphoned to the Canada Strong fund, how will our airports maintain their infrastructure when they are being left unintentionally undercapitalized while travellers are hit with massive fee hikes just to satisfy a private investor's ROI?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"International transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","label":"International transport","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","label":"Tourism facilities","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d14f0f4694f6ab939b896e6539a5cef9a510f6ed1d00c4f324ac564302d258d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["07e03387b5bbda6860bec7a1e256612baf202c23a2c14ce037aa725854fe2e71"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e860d2751c6b72a85641d92a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1021423,"date":"2026-05-29T18:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith for standing up in this House on the very important topic of air passenger protection regulations and the government's absolute mess of it. \n\nThe member mentioned that we are in a recession and the economy is contracting. What is not contracting? It is the backlog of the CTA. It has around 97,000, perhaps even 100,000 cases in backlog. That means people are waiting three years to have someone hear their case. Instead of the government fixing the system and simplifying the rules, it provided $75 million over three years to make the CTA process faster, and by this particular provision in the bill that she mentions, it shows that it has been a complete disaster. \n\nCould the member please let us know if she thinks that this is the best use of her constituents' money in this bill and by the government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1021423","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith for standing up in this House on the very important topic of air passenger protection regulations and the government's absolute mess of it. \n\nThe member mentioned that we are in a recession and the economy is contracting. What is not contracting? It is the backlog of the CTA. It has around 97,000, perhaps even 100,000 cases in backlog. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["78c7a71ec03f36a7e602052223b768e66cb836f5fb31bb27d2bf377ab2bdce24"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-625fefe95746a50ef97c217e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037355,"date":"2026-06-02T21:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to note the departure of the hon. member for North Vancouver—Capilano, who will be leaving this place to serve Canada abroad in a new capacity. \n\nThe member and I have spent a good deal of time on opposite sides of some very important debates, such as on net-zero legislation, the 2 billion trees initiative and broader Conservative concerns about the government's environmental approach. Those disagreements were real. I stand by them, just as I am sure the hon. member does. While most of those exchanges were during his time as the minister of the environment and minister of natural resources, I also want to thank him for his service as the minister of fisheries. I know he cared very much in that role about salmon policy, and it is always welcome, as I have said many times, to have another British Columbian voice in Ottawa, particularly one in a position of authority. \n\nIn fact, when it comes to the debates we had, I suspect we may both continue to believe we were on the right side of those debates. Perhaps the only fair way we can resolve that is to compare notes in the years ahead, say, in 2030, and maybe again in 2050, when the results of those policies are clear. \n\nWhat is worth noting is that even through those disagreements, we never lost the ability to have a conversation. Whether it was in the House, at committee, at the parliamentary gym or even when we found ourselves seated next to each other on a long flight, there was always professionalism and mutual respect. \n\nAs a fellow British Columbian, I can attest to the travel demands that come with representing a riding on the west coast. It is not always an easy schedule. I recall mentioning to the member at the gym that perhaps in his new role, he might finally find himself ahead of events happening in Ottawa rather than living life feeling three hours behind. \n\nI recall one moment during COVID at committee when I yielded my time, and of course, members would know that the opposition never has tricks for ministers when they show up at committee. When I yielded my time to the member for Saanich—Gulf Islands to question the minister on his net-zero bill, in that instant, a minister's staffer sprung, or I should say flung, into action, diving onto the desk, pulling one book out and somehow switching it with a completely different book. It was a small moment, but it allowed the minister to switch the answers fitting the perspective of a Conservative to that of a Green member of Parliament. \n\nIt may have been a small moment, but it reflected not only the preparation but also the strength of the people we count on. Moments like this remind us that none of us do this work alone. We often rely on dedicated staff who work behind the scenes, often under pressure, to help us perform our duties as elected officials as ably as possible. They may not often be recognized, but they should be, and we should thank them not just today but, I believe, every day. \n\nThere comes a time when many who serve here look for new ways to continue contributing. Canadians have been well served by former parliamentarians at the federal and provincial levels who have stepped into roles abroad. It was Prime Minister Harper who began appointing experienced political leaders such as Gary Doer, followed by Gordon Campbell. Prime Minister Trudeau continued this practice, with Stéphane Dion and John Horgan of British Columbia. \n\nThese individuals said yes to continuing to serve and to putting their years of insight and experience to work for Canada in a new way. I suspect having a prime minister make that personal call helps in one's decision-making. I would just point out before I finish that there are many experienced parliamentarians who have since left active political life whose insight and perspective could likewise be drawn upon. \n\nOn that basis, I wish the hon. member for North Vancouver—Capilano well. While I have said we have disagreed, I respect his willingness to serve and have no doubt he will continue to do so in his next role.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037355","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to note the departure of the hon. member for North Vancouver—Capilano, who will be leaving this place to serve Canada abroad in a new capacity. \n\nThe member and I have spent a good deal of time on opposite sides of some very important debates, such as on net-zero legislation, the 2 billion trees initiative and broader Conservative concerns about the government's environme","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0285377614dfbe9c6b689e154ce5f7fe989826a599f5b4622baf5e6bc3b62952"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5750b4d94c8833a1d68bee015dfe064e935ee72e0f4bba8013b96f9de9201fbb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65bc397d5faccb06c628b31c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104529,"date":"2026-06-04T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Minister, deputy minister and officials, for making yourselves available to discuss this important piece of legislation. Minister, this casts a wide net across all airports. What should airports be concerned about in terms of the new requirements?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104529","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Minister, deputy minister and officials, for making yourselves available to discuss this important piece of legislation. Minister, this casts a wide net across all airports. What should airports be concerned about in terms of the new requirements?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9c1741b16a424851a1a7c02f578dc6981280b73b585eeba6027a4fa7cea5aafe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["202adb82b03bd1de5a7ce9b2ad4cb40ada113473be6e8badfe687acdec43dd13"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0bf21cedb591ffb020b34bdf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104530,"date":"2026-06-04T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"FINA","text":"If you are seeking voluntary information, why are you legislating it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104530","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If you are seeking voluntary information, why are you legislating it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["631ef148f72158972d8fa0a2891528ad1ccbc542f659c5cea223921115a430a7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-806cdf97d30a01f9e9fc504f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104531,"date":"2026-06-04T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"FINA","text":"First of all, Minister, your department is a bit of a mess right now when it comes to aviation. We saw, in the W5 exposé on Pearson, what's happened. There is a sudden requirement for small airports such as those at Castlegar or Comox to comply and send you information. Are you actually going to be looking at these things, or is this about something else? Is it about the valorization of certain airports, and you're using this catch-all mechanism to basically require information from the major airports so that you can, so-called, asset recycle them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104531","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"First of all, Minister, your department is a bit of a mess right now when it comes to aviation. We saw, in the W5 exposé on Pearson, what's happened. There is a sudden requirement for small airports such as those at Castlegar or Comox to comply and send you information. Are you actually going to be looking at these things, or is this about something else? Is it about the valorization of certain ai","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33d94a373cda51725c45a2bb6d2bd2c38418c3f6102ff63ffe2da16ff85718ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7969a9828a71883041446da20aaac53fd44b21845230f2b89b40dcea3cabe1ca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-befcbb5a5372d90efc417b2b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104532,"date":"2026-06-04T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"FINA","text":"Again, you cast a net on all airports. Are you asking for all airports to comply or not?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104532","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Again, you cast a net on all airports. Are you asking for all airports to comply or not?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","label":"Fisheries technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a5c8815a0ce6e4163c876c740a76bdc9952b4320e8cdb343e782326275b7317"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c4fd5f03682f6c1a86666ae9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104533,"date":"2026-06-04T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"FINA","text":"Speaking of data, are you going to be seeking information around airport improvement fees and their debt levels? Right now, it seems to me, Minister, that it's awfully strange that you're more interested in looking at the valorization of these assets for other means, rather than fixing the problems in Canadian airports, such as CBSA computer shortages and NavCan labour shortages. Also, we have the issue of airport baggage screening and non-passenger screening requirements, which are your direct responsibility, Minister.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104533","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Speaking of data, are you going to be seeking information around airport improvement fees and their debt levels? Right now, it seems to me, Minister, that it's awfully strange that you're more interested in looking at the valorization of these assets for other means, rather than fixing the problems in Canadian airports, such as CBSA computer shortages and NavCan labour shortages. Also, we have the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f8fe24695aff794f05436019b67d5615043e5f4e92837e83f0e96112c723631b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5798ea46b07a345571100b1bb7a9a304e9ef1e3331910926b382505076af5499"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b4379b4bb36273b3bc26fa3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104534,"date":"2026-06-04T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"FINA","text":"Let's start with that. What are you doing right now in regard to Pearson's screening requirements? It's Transport Canada that has the lead on that. How is it that people right now are being detained, arrested and then caught up in CBSA's system forevermore for something they didn't do? It is your responsibility to make sure bad people can't get those jobs and then stay in those jobs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104534","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Let's start with that. What are you doing right now in regard to Pearson's screening requirements? It's Transport Canada that has the lead on that. How is it that people right now are being detained, arrested and then caught up in CBSA's system forevermore for something they didn't do? It is your responsibility to make sure bad people can't get those jobs and then stay in those jobs.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-baaf77077ffe27ffe84bff92","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104535,"date":"2026-06-04T16:35:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"FINA","text":"Minister, this is the first time you've publicly spoken about this. You are the minister responsible. What one concrete measure have you done beyond talking to your officials and saying that you can do everything at the same time? As far as I can see, Minister, you are a part-time transport minister and a full-time House leader.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104535","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Minister, this is the first time you've publicly spoken about this. You are the minister responsible. What one concrete measure have you done beyond talking to your officials and saying that you can do everything at the same time? As far as I can see, Minister, you are a part-time transport minister and a full-time House leader.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d4d91f840232aef22bb5f72","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104536,"date":"2026-06-04T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"FINA","text":"Minister, I'd like you to actually.... This is serious. Be serious.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104536","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Minister, I'd like you to actually.... This is serious. Be serious.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-681a12f6bab89b4cd670c059","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104537,"date":"2026-06-04T16:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"FINA","text":"Give one concrete measure, please, Minister, beyond talking to your officials.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104537","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Give one concrete measure, please, Minister, beyond talking to your officials.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Concrete","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","label":"Concrete","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ac9e810d9c30cac5e4793c1076c2001263a8352f36297462df213ffd37bb1b7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e893bdca348de2b47bd20df0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1037354,"date":"2026-06-04T19:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is the only G20 country that is in a recession. Shirley is a senior from my riding who lives alone in Summerland. She tells me that she does not drink, smoke or gamble. Her only luxury is a swim pass to the local public pool. Every time I speak to her, her tone is increasingly dire. Shirley and her friends do not see anything getting better, and they believe that the Liberals have forgotten seniors. Another recycled rebate is not going to fix it.\n\nCan the minister tell Shirley whether the reason she cannot pay her grocery bills is that we are in a recession, or is it just that it is a technical recession?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037354","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is the only G20 country that is in a recession. Shirley is a senior from my riding who lives alone in Summerland. She tells me that she does not drink, smoke or gamble. Her only luxury is a swim pass to the local public pool. Every time I speak to her, her tone is increasingly dire. Shirley and her friends do not see anything getting better, and they believe that the Liberals h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac56e8cfbda51031a6374ea8856e1b56921e44e35258ad44bd804264492ee603"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9e2509b5bda9298f60dc37706f91b23b4655cd1229b2a2e6b7b506a3be0db9d2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6df29694c06adb492cc4925b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085116,"date":"2026-06-09T00:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Province of Nova Scotia leases the Maritime Launch Services land for approximately $13,500 per year, yet through the federal agreement that we are going to be debating tonight, Maritime Launch Services receives $55,000 a day. That is a 400,000% increase. \n\nDoes the member think that is really, truly good value for money?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085116","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Province of Nova Scotia leases the Maritime Launch Services land for approximately $13,500 per year, yet through the federal agreement that we are going to be debating tonight, Maritime Launch Services receives $55,000 a day. That is a 400,000% increase. \n\nDoes the member think that is really, truly good value for money?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7e7bde8838cc4ac3db77408","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085117,"date":"2026-06-09T00:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time today with the hon. member for Leeds—Grenville—Thousand Islands—Rideau Lakes.\n\n I want to begin where we should always begin, with judgment. Archibald Lampman, a Canadian poet who worked right here in Ottawa, once wrote, \"The pulse of the great machine goes on forever, dead and blind, and no voice or sound of human will disturbs its deep and ceaseless grind.\"\n\n The reason I share this is because Canadians are watching the decision about Maritime Launch Services in such bewilderment. They are asking if this is an actual attempt at Canadian space sovereignty or something else altogether. Many who have looked into this decision closely have questions. The more they look and the more they research, the more this looks like a decision that was hastily made and that just happens to support well-connected Liberal insiders and lobbyists surrounding Maritime Launch Services.\n\n The Liberal members will stand in this House and argue this $200-million expenditure is a necessary investment to secure Canada's place in a global space economy. They will justify this spending, just as Liberals always justify deficit spending, to grow the economy, meet the moment, invest in our future and protect our sovereignty. We have heard it all before, over and over again, with the superclusters, the SDTC green slush fund, planting billions of trees and subsidizing EV battery plants. I could go on and on. Liberals will always find new ways to burn tax dollars on projects that benefit Liberal friends and insiders, but these projects always fizzle out and leave nothing but debt and unanswered questions behind.\n\n Let us look at the so-called space sovereignty spending, the $20 million in this allocation. If this was truly a national investment, we would, of course, be building a national asset. As an example, when Norway decided it needed its own sovereign launch capacity, it acted with the discipline of a sovereign state. It built its own infrastructure, it owns the land, it owns the pad and it owns the capability. It has an asset directly under its control. Who owns NASA? The people of the United States through the U.S. government.\n\n Who will own Maritime Launch Services, the spaceport that we are talking about? This is where it gets a tad murky. At the present time, online information suggests that 26% of the ownership is held by individuals, close to 12% is listed as institutional owners and the remaining balance of 60% is unknown. This is for a national asset, something that the Liberals tell us is necessary for our space sovereignty. In other words, the Liberals are doing the exact opposite of what other democratic countries are doing when it comes to protecting and creating space sovereignty. This means we are not building a true national asset.\n\n Instead, we are building a private company's balance sheet. We are paying $200 million for the privilege of using a facility we do not own, under terms that strip away our sovereign leverage and hand it to a private entity. That is the difference between acquiring an asset and assuming an obligation. They are not the same thing. Make no mistake, this is giving away public tax dollars to create private equity, a scheme that a Brookfield investor would no doubt approve of. The government claims this is about growing the economy, yet the math reveals a different reality.\n\n This is not a market player; it is a public dependency. When 97% of a company's revenue is derived from a single taxpayer-funded contract, that is not a commercial enterprise. That is a ward of the state. We are told that this is a burgeoning spaceport, yet look at the reality at Spaceport Nova Scotia this week. We are being asked to cheer for suborbital test flights that generate zero revenue and serve only as public relations demonstrations for a foreign firm. In this case, we have a launch happening very soon with T-Minus Engineering testing their technology on our soil. Who is T-Minus Engineering? It is a privately held Dutch company.\n\n The government's position relies on the claim that we are buying capability, but are we really? How can this Liberal government claim to be buying capability when the regulatory framework to govern that very capability does not even yet exist? Now, the Minister of Transport had admitted in this House that we needed Bill C-28, the Canadian space launch act, to establish a proper framework.\n\n Meanwhile, the Liberals are bypassing the legislative process, stretching the outdated Aeronautics Act to fit rocket science and pushing the machine forward without the very safety, environmental and financial guards they admit are necessary. Let me just say this again. Two foreign-owned, Dutch Barracuda rockets will be tested suborbitally, and they are paying no revenue to Maritime Launch Services. Through public disclosure, we can see that this is, again, a company 90% of whose revenue is from one single contract with the Government of Canada. The government claims this arrangement protects the national interest, but it is also ignoring that with these tests it is putting on right now and the launch pad, the Government of Canada bears the ultimate legal and financial liability.\n\nAs proposed within Bill C-28, the minister gets to pick what private operators are indemnified and what public taxpayers will pay in case of a catastrophic accident or spill over the ocean. Those things do happen. This would fall on the Government of Canada. Again, if these rockets fail, cause damage or contaminate our water, the responsibility does not reside with the public firm, which is the Dutch company I was mentioning, nor with MLS itself, but with the Canadian taxpayer. We are socializing the risk of catastrophic failure while privatizing the potential gain for shareholders and lobbyists.\n\nLet me address now the financial absurdity at the heart of this deal. The provincial government lets this land for roughly $13,500 per year, yet, through this federal agreement, Maritime Launch Services receives $55,000 every single day of the year. This is not an investment. This is an excessive, indefensible transfer of wealth. While the public carries the liability, the corporate structure shows all the hallmarks of a venture designed to enrich the insiders rather than to launch satellites. We have seen massive share dilution, with hundreds of millions of shares issued while insiders reduce their own exposure.\n\nThe Liberals have been totally silent about this. This is not how a healthy, productive market behaves. This is an inversion of market principles, where the government is using public money to insulate a company from the rigours of competition, or from the risks that come from the business itself. The government's position is that we must pay this price to play this game. My position is that we are paying a premium so private corporations like MLS can play the game.\n\nSome might ask why Conservatives are not ambitious enough, why we are not for the type of investment this represents for our space sovereignty. Well, ambition is not the issue here. We all want a robust Canadian space sector, but ambition without discipline is a policy of failure. By the government's own test, the capability is not demonstrated. The value is not realized. Ownership is absent, and the risk is entirely public. This is not an investment. This is an obligation with downside exposure. Canadians are paying up front, bearing the risk and carrying the liability for a capability that does not yet exist. We are being asked to trust the great machine as it grinds onward, indifferent to the taxpayer.\n\nAs Conservatives, we refuse to participate in this gamble with other people's money. For these reasons, we cannot support this allocation. Again, I would just remind the government that this is not a case of problem and solution, where the problem is a lack of space sovereignty and the solution is MLS. This solution has been imposed on the Canadian taxpayer. Conservatives will not support it, and we will fight against a government that puts its own needs and those of insiders before our sovereign ability to advance this field in a proper fashion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085117","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time today with the hon. member for Leeds—Grenville—Thousand Islands—Rideau Lakes.\n\n I want to begin where we should always begin, with judgment. Archibald Lampman, a Canadian poet who worked right here in Ottawa, once wrote, \"The pulse of the great machine goes on forever, dead and blind, and no voice or sound of human will disturbs its deep and ceaseless grind.\"","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a96a4a6d7d77d5adc430dff47aa75b2b8fd292eeb38fac950f417583b0dbafc1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["193df5f77d0555a22067c1bf4eb8b19c2ac995ca3fde6a1d4699e07a6dad6637"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6aa0e902a9c0387388a8fcea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085118,"date":"2026-06-09T00:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are debating $20 million, one of 20 years' worth of payments that are going to a private company for an asset that we would never own. As I mentioned, in Norway, when they wanted to create sovereign space capacity, for approximately $30 million, they did it themselves. Here, we would be giving $200 million. I would ask the member opposite what $200 million could do in this economy. There are so many other priorities that would be better suited from here, but perhaps, if the Department of National Defence needs this capacity, it should own the asset, operate the asset and get the benefits to Canadians, not to MLS.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085118","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are debating $20 million, one of 20 years' worth of payments that are going to a private company for an asset that we would never own. As I mentioned, in Norway, when they wanted to create sovereign space capacity, for approximately $30 million, they did it themselves. Here, we would be giving $200 million. I would ask the member opposite what $200 million could do in this economy.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["de5eeed6da105c80e9aceb97a6e49e34cb1a73f3445f562ae5a022e9e7d75b5f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c04a0adbd6f8242628ecfd845cba1e5c255234338094a4a59b121c08ac1e4c83"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49dfad24e81573f74d9db3db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085119,"date":"2026-06-09T00:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are here to talk about $20 million that would be allocated from the Department of National Defence and given to a private company. As much as I appreciate the member's concern for seniors, the fact is that if we as an opposition, whether the Bloc Québécois, the NDP, the Greens or the Conservatives, simply talk about anything other than what the government is actually doing, it is taking our money and giving it to a private interest. There are already signs of huge profits being taken for a company that, a year ago, disclosed to its investors that it was not a going concern, meaning it was close to bankruptcy. I recognize that under the Liberals, not only are seniors close to bankruptcy but MLS was too. Where did the government choose to put its money in bailing out MLS versus seniors? That is what we are here to talk about, and that is what I will be talking about here tonight.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085119","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are here to talk about $20 million that would be allocated from the Department of National Defence and given to a private company. As much as I appreciate the member's concern for seniors, the fact is that if we as an opposition, whether the Bloc Québécois, the NDP, the Greens or the Conservatives, simply talk about anything other than what the government is actually doing, it is t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["638b97bdfbaf23355982b667e8ce826e770cb3672b20896bda78b62b0a3d0a43"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0340501076e586cc722d0313923ccca10db3ea009d74dad7757b207c5d1d9ff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee410ad8a0d5d986dd50e009","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085120,"date":"2026-06-09T00:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I understand what the member is saying. The government has gone completely radio silent when it comes to transparency on this. It is claiming that MLS answers a problem it has not properly defined. As I said, in Norway they spent about $40 million to create their own infrastructure, which the people own. The Liberals would be giving $200 million of taxpayer money, financed by bondholders. We deserve answers. Maybe the member might want to go to the national defence committee and ask for a production order in relation to this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085120","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I understand what the member is saying. The government has gone completely radio silent when it comes to transparency on this. It is claiming that MLS answers a problem it has not properly defined. As I said, in Norway they spent about $40 million to create their own infrastructure, which the people own. The Liberals would be giving $200 million of taxpayer money, financed by bondhold","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af3f392527c5957021f39ed3884e48724213bc1aed8ac50293d781a0f652507e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e5481f5c66a2906c25d7111f5e2d4417283a09cfdb0de32c9b037d546fe60bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-389f1804d8acb853ec5fc954","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085121,"date":"2026-06-09T01:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for bringing this debate to the floor. It is a deplorable situation where people are exploited, particularly in their golden years, out of everything they have made and hope to pass on to their children. I appreciate the member doing that. \n\nOne of the challenges is that bank officials do not necessarily understand, and when someone comes in who seems to have full use of their faculties, they are loath to either start asking questions or even stop a transaction. Provincial governments can make a big difference. Right now, if someone loses the ability to make good judgments for themselves, oftentimes a court order has to be received by family members who are concerned. Basically, it is like a light switch, saying that someone who had autonomy to make their own decisions is no longer able to do that. \n\nI know the member has Mr. David Eby's number on speed dial. Is he prepared to talk to the province about changing the provincial laws so they are not like a light switch?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085121","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for bringing this debate to the floor. It is a deplorable situation where people are exploited, particularly in their golden years, out of everything they have made and hope to pass on to their children. I appreciate the member doing that. \n\nOne of the challenges is that bank officials do not necessarily understand, and when someone comes in who seems to have full u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","label":"Social problems"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","label":"Human trafficking","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","label":"Social problems","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","label":"Family law","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e9b5ab4f9fd792d8194eec79385fa446bf4294114c43a10e643ad5fc284e82c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8816206e851ce4f57a091355244c1f490288beb9ec414cc2885d1b830b312860"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a2bc949d6c7c2484f931e2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085122,"date":"2026-06-09T01:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when the Liberals talk about the Maritime Launch Services lease they say it is an investment, that somehow it is giving us space sovereignty within Canada. \n\nWhen Norway sought to create its own spaceport, it partnered with the private sector. However, for approximately $60 million of today's Canadian dollars it was able to own 90% of the asset and partner with a private sector proponent. \n\nWhat we are saying here is that the $200 million going to an asset that we will never own, and for which 60% of the shares are unaccounted for as we do not know who owns them, is a big mistake. It is not a solution, but a bad deal for taxpayers. \n\nWhat does the member have to say with respect to that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085122","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when the Liberals talk about the Maritime Launch Services lease they say it is an investment, that somehow it is giving us space sovereignty within Canada. \n\nWhen Norway sought to create its own spaceport, it partnered with the private sector. However, for approximately $60 million of today's Canadian dollars it was able to own 90% of the asset and partner with a private sector propon","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shares","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037106","label":"Shares","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2eadb8f7b785a0c2fa9efcda8f11d7b3275b8401d7db3157eb581e66935ab2b1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca5a5c6c04753076cbbdbadab805e2de864dba033d4936f62857d107b527e175"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-046ac6c6cff1656805a22fff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085123,"date":"2026-06-09T02:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. The member opposite is not being relevant, neither he personally nor with respect to anything in particular regarding the motion. I would ask that he come to order and maybe talk about Maritime Launch Services, the lease, and the Department of National Defence—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085123","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. The member opposite is not being relevant, neither he personally nor with respect to anything in particular regarding the motion. I would ask that he come to order and maybe talk about Maritime Launch Services, the lease, and the Department of National Defence—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035583","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine installations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035583","label":"Marine installations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a4fcbfec011db414a2ad5f89f627f6d8543edd1802967e0117d0bd587688db4d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0aee567c23aef0bed360e216","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104527,"date":"2026-06-09T17:55:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"CHPC","text":"I have a point of order. I may be new to the committee, but I'm certainly not new to parliamentary time. The member had, as you said, about three and a half minutes. It's his time and he can use it to ask questions of the witnesses or he could ask questions of the room. I understand that members can be disappointed and they'll want to share some of their feelings with their colleagues. I don't think you can just take away a member's time simply because you disagree with what he has to say.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104527","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order. I may be new to the committee, but I'm certainly not new to parliamentary time. The member had, as you said, about three and a half minutes. It's his time and he can use it to ask questions of the witnesses or he could ask questions of the room. I understand that members can be disappointed and they'll want to share some of their feelings with their colleagues. I don't thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-192beccedb8c895103aa9105","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104528,"date":"2026-06-09T17:55:00+00:00","title":"CHPC","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"CHPC","text":"Could you rule on whether or not a member's time is a member's time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CHPC/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104528","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could you rule on whether or not a member's time is a member's time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083643","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Time zones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083643","label":"Time zones","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["722682f1aa4aa5d1d5f046b5faa9b13044262f084620ada5b8c3a59e3e05dc5e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-946c95f1f3b42d6d0f805478","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085114,"date":"2026-06-09T20:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will just take a moment of time. I am not bringing this up for any other reason than that I am concerned about this place and one of your rulings. I have seen on a number of occasions now that you have cancelled one of the leader of the official opposition's questions because he did not put a question in it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085114","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will just take a moment of time. I am not bringing this up for any other reason than that I am concerned about this place and one of your rulings. I have seen on a number of occasions now that you have cancelled one of the leader of the official opposition's questions because he did not put a question in it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-683b1423e1f1aa91aab77ee0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085115,"date":"2026-06-09T20:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I care about this place, and I hope you do too and that you can listen to what I have to say. If you are going to be cutting someone off because they did not put an inflection at the end of a question or they did not deliver a question properly, if you do that to the leader of the official opposition, it could happen to any of us in this place on the opposition side.\n\nWhen previous Speakers have not chosen to regulate the quality of answers from the Prime Minister and the government, why—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085115","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I care about this place, and I hope you do too and that you can listen to what I have to say. If you are going to be cutting someone off because they did not put an inflection at the end of a question or they did not deliver a question properly, if you do that to the leader of the official opposition, it could happen to any of us in this place on the opposition side.\n\nWhen previous Sp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-958d3fad775430a83e38935c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085112,"date":"2026-06-11T16:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the minister covered a lot of ground, but ultimately Bill C‐26 is a sham of a process. Why? It is because the minister and the government already have the ability to come to provincial agreements. He could go to the NDP government in our home province of British Columbia and do a deal, and then go to the Minister of Finance and have it funded through the estimates process.\n\n To be wasting time in this chamber is, in my belief, more to address the minister's shortfalls when it comes to being seen as politically competent and when it comes to supplying housing, a priority that was made out in the last election.\n\nWill the minister not just admit today that Bill C‐26 is a fig leaf for his government's lack of action and a waste of the time of this House?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085112","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the minister covered a lot of ground, but ultimately Bill C‐26 is a sham of a process. Why? It is because the minister and the government already have the ability to come to provincial agreements. He could go to the NDP government in our home province of British Columbia and do a deal, and then go to the Minister of Finance and have it funded through the estimates process.\n\n To be was","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b8da5f1e249c90c099e7c22786cde1c21d7d35f629cf260249070baf66c2dad9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69ed1397d2ac2dc3a1825a60","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085113,"date":"2026-06-11T22:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. It is also a pleasure to be speaking today about Bill C-267, an act to establish a national framework to promote the durability of electronic products and essential home appliances.\n\nIn a former Parliament, I served as the critic for the environment for the Conservatives. One of the big criticisms I had of Liberal policies was about the Liberals' promise, in one of their platform pledges, that they would make all home appliances Energy Star. One might think that Energy Star sounds like a very good thing. If everyone had Energy Star appliances in their homes, they would have access to the lowest electrical usage machines available in Canada or in North America for laundry, dishwashing and all things.\n\n However, many people do not know that, first of all, Energy Star is an American designation that essentially says that to be Energy Star, a product has to be among the top 25% most energy-conserving products out there. Someone might ask what is wrong with that. The first thing it does is it raises prices, because energy-reducing technology costs more. It usually uses advanced technology and chips, which also costs more.\n\nEssentially, if a person is a private citizen of low income, like a pensioner, is someone who is starting out or is a single mother, and suddenly their dryer, washer or dishwasher blows out and they have to go to the local store, they would only get access to a quarter of the inventory out there, with the most expensive products only. This would push people into used ones, and perhaps that is not a bad thing, but only wealthy Canadians would probably be able to afford to buy new.\n\n Now fast-forward to this bill. I will quote the preamble: \n\nWhereas Canadian households bear significant costs when they have to replace electronic products and essential home appliances prematurely;\n\n Whereas consumers increasingly depend on electronic products and essential home appliances in their everyday lives;\n\n Whereas product durability and repairability help protect consumers, reduce household expenses and boost the competitiveness of a responsible economy;\n\n Whereas transparency about the useful life of products and the support available for them fosters a fairer and more competitive market;\n\n And whereas Parliament considers it desirable to establish a national framework for products marketed in Canada in order to promote minimum standards of durability and repairability;\n\nThese are all noble things, and I am happy to see the Liberal Party, or at least one member, recognize that we should all be focused on affordability. This exactly opposite to their approach in previous iterations. The Trudeau government was trying to raise standards to make things more costly. Now this particular member is doing a U-turn.\n\nWhere have we seen this before? It is in other environmental areas, such as the carbon tax. Many of the people who are currently sitting in the Liberal Party used to say that Conservatives should support a carbon tax, which would save Canada, lower our emissions, stop forest fires, and everything else. During the 2021 election, a minister of the Crown said to me that I had a \"moral failing\" for failing to support their increased emissions targets, which were going from 40% to 45%.\n\nBecause I would not support that increased goal, they said I had a moral failure, yet now the same Liberal Party members of Parliament have done a U-turn, and so much so that even the former Quebec lieutenant has said that he does not feel that he can be effective in that caucus anymore and has simply said, \"I'm out.\" It is very interesting to see these changes, and I am sure that some members opposite would understand why some of us feel like we have political whiplash because of the quick changes.\n\nIt is really important for us to point out a couple of things. First of all, this particular bill tries to push manufacturers on the aspect of durability. One thing we have to bear in mind is that none of these manufacturers are here in Canada. We are very integrated north-south. In the North American market, almost all of the manufacturers for washers, dryers, refrigerators, freezers and dishwashers are in the United States. Obviously, some come from places like Korea and whatnot, but the fact of the matter is that this particular bill is trying to push manufacturers to do things differently when they are not here in Canada. Therefore, there is, first of all, that disconnect in the approach that is taken. \n\nThe second thing I would say is that the Liberals always seem to believe they have an outsized influence on these things. If a manufacturer is in the United States, who are they making their products for? They are not making Energy Star products specifically and marketing only them. They are selling to a wide variety of people.\n\nOne of the biggest challenges here is that if we are asking to make things more durable, industry will say this makes them more expensive. How does that work? Well, if something is more durable, perhaps it requires more steel. If something is more durable, perhaps it uses less plastic. To make something more durable, perhaps it has to use a more expensive alternative refrigeration system. Again, these are important questions to be asking, because, essentially, asking for something to be more durable and wanting it to be cheaper are contradictory concepts.\n\n This is being placed in a far-removed conversation, because they are not Canadian manufacturers and the manufacturers do not consider Canada to be their primary target. In fact, we benefit here in Canada by having access to other markets because the economies of scale in places like the United States give us cheaper products. If we were to suddenly say to them that they have to do these things, when they are not our manufacturers and are not manufacturing things with the Canadian market in mind, that conversation would not go anywhere.\n\nThis bill states this in the \"National framework\" component:\n\nThe Minister must, in consultation with the representatives of the provincial governments responsible for consumer protection\n\nThis is an interesting part, because provinces can, if they choose, set a level playing field when it comes to things like warranties. Warranties are consumer protections, so it makes sense that there would be some discussion here, but would a foreign manufacturer listen to Prince Edward Island? I do not know. I do not think that would be the case, because, while I respect the members who come from Prince Edward Island, it has a small population.\n\nIt is one of those curious aspects of our Constitution, to wax eloquently about our Constitution for a moment, that at the founding of our country, we gave authority to deal with these large manufacturers to the provinces. The provinces can enforce basic standards of contract, which include things like warranties. However, the federal government would be expected here to create, through the Minister of Industry, a framework that would affect things all across the country and a group of companies that are not Canadian.\n\n I am opposed to this particular bill, but I do look forward to hearing the arguments of other members on it today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085113","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the good people of Okanagan Lake West—South Kelowna. It is also a pleasure to be speaking today about Bill C-267, an act to establish a national framework to promote the durability of electronic products and essential home appliances.\n\nIn a former Parliament, I served as the critic for the environment for the Conservatives. One of the big c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","label":"Household equipment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036228","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Materials technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","label":"Household equipment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036228","label":"Materials technology","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["676bdec07cb571be7d110545bd848b81377ff767eeda1e12d85487848a02b8e1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1785132c8322739e469b6cf4bb75efd4e54bd86ae872f4c2b1408418175cde1c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a41ca36dc9ebfa29df8fe814","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085111,"date":"2026-06-12T21:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Westbank First Nation is one of the indigenous communities in my riding. It obviously has its own governance agreement.\n\nWould the member enlighten us and say what he believes is a good message for people, not just in the Okanagan but right across B.C.? What would they like to hear from the Conservative Party right now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085111","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Westbank First Nation is one of the indigenous communities in my riding. It obviously has its own governance agreement.\n\nWould the member enlighten us and say what he believes is a good message for people, not just in the Okanagan but right across B.C.? What would they like to hear from the Conservative Party right now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8e4ba5d9de7b9e2d4263a6c2a274f8807964ab5469cc544578dbaf15198102a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7994b1dd04a8dddbd0255ce844a3344ac6f73310370b71a9987dbfcbe53bd87"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bdd58b2610c3e2c7e802fe85","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087232,"date":"2026-06-18T15:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise on behalf of petitioners who have asked that the government recognize the very real pain that is being inflicted upon Falun Gong practitioners by the repressive government in Beijing. Recent events include a bomb and shooting threats targeting Shen Yun, a classical Chinese dance and music performance presented globally by the Falun Gong community that showcases traditional China before Communism and exposes these atrocities.\n\n The petitioners publicly call on the Chinese regime to end its persecution of Falun Gong and to end transnational repression abroad.\n\nI would like to thank the petitioners who were key to this: Mike and his friend Kelloway. I would certainly be open to meeting with the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Transport, either in his office or in my study, to further discuss the petition.\n\n I wish everyone a good summer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087232","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise on behalf of petitioners who have asked that the government recognize the very real pain that is being inflicted upon Falun Gong practitioners by the repressive government in Beijing. Recent events include a bomb and shooting threats targeting Shen Yun, a classical Chinese dance and music performance presented globally by the Falun Gong community that showcases tr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1437fbce3e3066f99d3d33c5ed09d86672262d92f201c769197e8d2e4f185c58"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f44ef0f23c659fce9da6d6a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087233,"date":"2026-06-18T19:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dan Albas","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, for whatever reason, the Prime Minister has told us affordability is the best it has been in decades. Perhaps if he spent less time in Europe, he might be aware that we now have full-time workers living in RVs and trailers. Families who do not have the benefit of luxury, million-dollar inflight catering are spending over 120% of their income on food and rent alone. Some Canadians, who are not Liberal friends or insiders and do not receive luxury Liberal appointments, have even turned to crowdfunding to make ends meet. In my riding, the Central Okanagan Food Bank is now serving 12,000 people. That is a 20% increase.\n\nDespite record deficit spending after he promised Canadians he would spend less, the Prime Minister is the only G7 leader to take his country into a recession. Make no mistake. The Liberals' inflationary spending and antidevelopment policies created this recession and cost of living crisis. These are Liberal choices. Only the Conservatives will end wasteful spending, cut bureaucracy, restore accountability and replace Liberal excess with results.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087233","member_id":"bc-mp-72029","member_name":"Dan Albas","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, for whatever reason, the Prime Minister has told us affordability is the best it has been in decades. Perhaps if he spent less time in Europe, he might be aware that we now have full-time workers living in RVs and trailers. Families who do not have the benefit of luxury, million-dollar inflight catering are spending over 120% of their income on food and rent alone. Some Canadians, who","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dbf97d1bcb99cc3ab6d403b116ef5d518a1d9b4f79d485f466e9073887745d92"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["10aa430137d6904276e7fb6a7aec69ee0869018a54f94f13e76065b185c8167f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-abeb0aaaaa8b4ddd252bd742","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70377,"date":"2026-01-27T19:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we voted for Bill C-5 so the Prime Minister could approve projects quickly, but nothing has changed. I was in Yellowknife last week. Diamond mines used to be 20% of NWT's GDP. Only two mines are left, and one will close in March. In the last 10 years, 1,600 resource-related jobs have been lost, but our Canadian sovereignty act would repeal federal blocks and penalties to development and reward the territories, provinces, businesses and workers who build and invest right here in Canada.\n\nWhen we export and build more, incomes go up and life becomes more affordable. Will the Prime Minister support it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70377","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we voted for Bill C-5 so the Prime Minister could approve projects quickly, but nothing has changed. I was in Yellowknife last week. Diamond mines used to be 20% of NWT's GDP. Only two mines are left, and one will close in March. In the last 10 years, 1,600 resource-related jobs have been lost, but our Canadian sovereignty act would repeal federal blocks and penalties to development a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ebeffe8ce5dab9ee4bc1309c3a35b32b9618b8ae3cfcba1ef96019523d560200"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1b525439c96d919fa1c57d47025587191f11b79528d4746a3d82465a37e9386"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-209b04312cb0f5bad3126102","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70378,"date":"2026-01-27T22:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Canadian sovereignty act is meant to get our economy going, but I listen to the Liberals, and we have listened to them for the last 10 years. They basically destroyed our economy. One would think they would support this particular act and our bill. I was surprised to hear their opposition to it, as I am sure the member is.\n\nOur motion is supposed to repeal federal blocks and penalties to development and reward territories, provinces, businesses and workers who invest in Canada. For clarity, is Canadian sovereignty meant to help our economy or hurt it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70378","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Canadian sovereignty act is meant to get our economy going, but I listen to the Liberals, and we have listened to them for the last 10 years. They basically destroyed our economy. One would think they would support this particular act and our bill. I was surprised to hear their opposition to it, as I am sure the member is.\n\nOur motion is supposed to repeal federal blocks and penal","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["21832f994c7ff03bfddaafe7b0bc491b8ba5f9fba1cb188fb5115cb365a04d7f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97a7096a5dfd4fc8b205c88c0f67490429f2b67fc85f0922aab73b353b346b78"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-91d7d15a0e86d827111e10c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77500,"date":"2026-02-02T18:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in the last election, the Prime Minister ran on being the more responsible economic adviser type, saying he would do a much better job with our economy and would spend more wisely than his predecessor. Justin Trudeau was going to add $154 billion to our debt over the next five years. The current Prime Minister is adding $321 billion to our debt over the next five years, and this new program is going to add another $12.4 billion to that debt.\n\n Can the member speak to those people who voted for the Prime Minister expecting a more responsible Prime Minister? Is he indeed more responsible?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77500","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in the last election, the Prime Minister ran on being the more responsible economic adviser type, saying he would do a much better job with our economy and would spend more wisely than his predecessor. Justin Trudeau was going to add $154 billion to our debt over the next five years. The current Prime Minister is adding $321 billion to our debt over the next five years, and this new p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c56c3026d3b3381f9b422fa7fdf0dee438c5eeaa2c0bc8c6013222fbe42910c7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d4108b40198bbda6b4947f3f86aa75aba4f63c937aef00bd5bc1c83886cf1f0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9351d003a047e346f0104ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332237,"date":"2026-03-09T20:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I present a petition that comes from many Christians across the country who are concerned about the effects of Bill C-9 and that its effects could criminalize passages of the Bible. \n\nPetitioners say that the state has no place in the religious texts or teachings of any faith community and that freedom of expression and freedom of religion are fundamental rights that must be preserved. Therefore, the petitioners call on the Liberal Government of Canada to protect religious freedom, uphold the right to read and to share sacred texts, and prevent government overreach into matters of faith.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332237","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I present a petition that comes from many Christians across the country who are concerned about the effects of Bill C-9 and that its effects could criminalize passages of the Bible. \n\nPetitioners say that the state has no place in the religious texts or teachings of any faith community and that freedom of expression and freedom of religion are fundamental rights that must be preserved","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6f4d054c23d428df1eded0123b58b40c83f83ac44cec3479fed02fd805a38b3d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c8768e1a88fb891d52e4884e11bdaeb8084ce849debb7a53ef5426b0cf6990c7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1901b5df76b0a83fc5fa4573","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":332236,"date":"2026-03-10T20:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, to the Tumbler Ridge families of Zoey, Tiki, Abel, Ezekiel, Kylie, Shannda, Emmett and Jennifer, we say that we continue to grieve with them.\n\nI thank our leader, the Prime Minister and all the federal leaders for making the trip to Tumbler Ridge to support us. I thank all members who have reached out over these last four weeks to give kind notes to me in some semblance of trying to pass on their peace to me.\n\nI thank the people around the world who have been praying for the Tumbler Ridge community, who have been praying for Maya and other victims and who have been praying for me. Jesus has been the light to me in this darkness, as he has been to so many of the victims' families in this tragedy.\n\nTumbler Ridge families, though, are now are asking what can be done so this never happens again, so I ask the Prime Minister this: Will he commit today to a full public inquiry into the Tumbler Ridge tragedy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:332236","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, to the Tumbler Ridge families of Zoey, Tiki, Abel, Ezekiel, Kylie, Shannda, Emmett and Jennifer, we say that we continue to grieve with them.\n\nI thank our leader, the Prime Minister and all the federal leaders for making the trip to Tumbler Ridge to support us. I thank all members who have reached out over these last four weeks to give kind notes to me in some semblance of trying to p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c6e70474f189b5b85da1dc33b4291e4f7b33766b2f9898a9e2ffbc5497e11ad"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0214a5e150eb2f9160486370","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":377419,"date":"2026-03-23T21:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know a lot of Christian groups. I am a Christian myself, and Christians across the country are concerned about this overreach, as the member just said. We have seen recent examples of government overreach as recently as four years ago, when the government invoked the Emergencies Act. I do not believe we can trust the current government with respect to restraining its authority, especially when a sitting minister says that biblical texts could possibly be implicated in this legislation.\n\n I just would ask the member a simple question. We have the Bible here in its entirety for a reason. We believe in it. Does the member believe the Bible in its entirety or the interpretation by the current minister for Canadian heritage?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:377419","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know a lot of Christian groups. I am a Christian myself, and Christians across the country are concerned about this overreach, as the member just said. We have seen recent examples of government overreach as recently as four years ago, when the government invoked the Emergencies Act. I do not believe we can trust the current government with respect to restraining its authority, espe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da3aff94a33f1979b34e2dcda8da7040669e6399800b13b20c4a23902b329af7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c2244db81046e8fd092c3f183310e7de66338b71414c497071106dd507b9ee8b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6881e0dd40037970541c1dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":377420,"date":"2026-03-23T22:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague did a great job of highlighting the Christian heritage of Parliament in Canada and the dominion from sea to sea and the many references that are in this place. \n\nI have been hearing from Christians across the country who know me, Christians in my own church, about the threats of Bill C-9 to freedom of religion and freedom of speech. \n\nWhat is the consensus in Canada around Bill C-9? Is it a threat to freedom of speech and freedom of religion in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:377420","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague did a great job of highlighting the Christian heritage of Parliament in Canada and the dominion from sea to sea and the many references that are in this place. \n\nI have been hearing from Christians across the country who know me, Christians in my own church, about the threats of Bill C-9 to freedom of religion and freedom of speech. \n\nWhat is the consensus in Canada aroun","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b8e9722ec0f91ebea80e78ffc08331771f77b2908e94cabce92d8434a43dbf1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0c202708d0e5a2bccc3532b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419797,"date":"2026-04-13T19:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, last week a Christian family of eight was killed in Nigeria. Two weeks ago, on Palm Sunday, an attack on a mostly Christian Nigerian town left 28 dead. Since 2009, Boko Haram and others have waged a brutal campaign attacking Christians in Nigeria. Millions have been displaced, villages destroyed, churches burned and entire families murdered. \n\nReports indicate that over 7,000 Christians were massacred in 2025 alone. Three churches on average are being destroyed every day, with over 18,000 churches destroyed since 2009. These attacks are not just political disputes; they are violent attacks against innocent people just because they are Christians. Canada must speak out and stand up for the persecuted Christians and push the international community to act. Freedom of worship and freedom of conscience are core Canadian values that we cannot ignore. \n\nTo our brothers and sisters in Nigeria, we have not forgotten about them. Stay strong and keep the faith.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419797","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, last week a Christian family of eight was killed in Nigeria. Two weeks ago, on Palm Sunday, an attack on a mostly Christian Nigerian town left 28 dead. Since 2009, Boko Haram and others have waged a brutal campaign attacking Christians in Nigeria. Millions have been displaced, villages destroyed, churches burned and entire families murdered. \n\nReports indicate that over 7,000 Christia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eb66eeea4cf3f61c50e6dee02080a29fc6a6434c7973479c33fea179e997d83c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6e3eb9fab39e92f7f21430e01e157305a3caa81a760458d990a2ae9dccc5f982"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-159a3782e59983c92a5bcd8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419795,"date":"2026-04-14T20:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague who brought up the pipeline. As it was planned initially many years ago, the cost was substantially lower. I believe the cost at the time was $4.9 billion, when the private sector was going to get that pipeline to tidewater. I just want the member to answer a simple question. I can answer it for him if he wishes. It was supposed to be $4.9 billion. It ended up costing quite a bit more than that.\n\n Does the member actually know what the final price tag was? It was closer to $30 billion or $40 billion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419795","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague who brought up the pipeline. As it was planned initially many years ago, the cost was substantially lower. I believe the cost at the time was $4.9 billion, when the private sector was going to get that pipeline to tidewater. I just want the member to answer a simple question. I can answer it for him if he wishes. It was supposed to be $4.9 billion. It ende","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6d9bb0c487f5ab17798af142baf914b3e28eb8b3beebc733250cd6126f0b39af"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb16de8e74276e3943592693ef4af87ddb3cf6ea4feb4403547eb6b641a8e2a6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77e8f7c706ea162e97155d79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419796,"date":"2026-04-14T23:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank all those watching out there in Canada. I am glad to have them watching us tonight.\n\nReally, Motion M-15 is about the Liberal commitment to the 30 by 30 agenda, the ever-growing commitment, as it grows to 50 by 50, which is half of our land mass and waters in Canada. There is also the commitment to funding the groups that promote this agenda. This agenda threatens public access to large tracts of land and waterways that have previously been utilized for hunting, fishing and resource development. This motion would ensure more loss of public access.\n\nDespite the Liberals trying to give us the impression that this is about conservation, it is really about protection. For the audience out there, I asked a group just last week at UVIC what the difference is between protection and conservation. Conservation is the principle that we will conserve things so we can use them. An example would be some people I know very well, our salmon fishermen and fisherwomen, who go on weekends to clean up garbage along the river and the streams, all to promote those salmon spawning again. That is, again, conservation so it can be used.\n\nProtection is completely different. This group is proposing to support more protection, and it is really building fences around areas in the country and really preventing accessing from what used to be public land. I am going to quote the member for Skeena—Bulkley Valley, who spoke on this earlier. He said that this debate is not simply about conservation policy. It is about who makes decisions over Canada's land, resources and economic future, whether those decisions are made here in Canada by elected representatives accountable to Canadians or whether they are increasingly shaped by international frameworks and targets negotiated outside this country's democratic institutions.\n\nI will speak first-hand because I have a couple of personal examples. It all really started around PNCIMA, which is the Pacific north coast integrated management area, where I was first exposed to MPAs, as they are called. Where it really hit home for me was the caribou closures that happened in my riding. It started with a meeting with the mayor and council in Chetwynd. They said that they were worried that, if these caribou closures really took hold, we would lose mills and we would possibly lose coal mines in the area. They were very concerned about what this closure would do to access to resources.\n\nWell, the closures came to fruition, despite community outcry and many community meetings saying this would be devastating for coal development, snowmobiling, hiking in the backwoods, skiing, etc. The government, despite all our recommendations, proceeded to go forward with this closure policy. We have since lost two mills in Chetwynd. We have lost access to snowmobiling in the Rocky Mountains, where people from Chetwynd go to recreate and people in the Peace region go to recreate. We saw this land closure do exactly as we had predicted with the loss of public access to previously accessible lands and waters.\n\nAnother example is the bluffs of Pender, which are off Victoria. We met people who fish in Victoria and they have little boat businesses. This contributes about $1.3 billion to the provincial GDP. In this one really key area just outside of Victoria where people fish, the closure was proposed for the protection of the southern resident killer whales. Well, the southern resident killer whales are only in that particular area for five to seven days per year, yet they are going to close down the entire area for the entire year. These closures have not gotten smaller, even though the southern resident killer whale population and the other killer whale populations have done very well and are very healthy. The MPAs, or the marine protected areas, keep expanding all because of this 30 by 30 and 50 by 50 agenda.\n\nI will speak to another example that just happened recently, and this is under the current Prime Minister's watch. It is a closure that is happening and has been implemented in Northwest Territories. I will just read the article, and this is an American article. Again, another highlight for us in this particular issue is that it is not just Canadians talking about these protections. It has actually had a lot of foreign influence, which has really shut down access to those public lands. The headline reads, \"Pew and Partners Celebrate Unprecedented Indigenous-Led...\".\n\nIt is not really indigenous-led. It was an initiative led by these other groups, and they got eventual buy-in from indigenous groups. I will read from the article again. It states:\n\nPew and Partners Celebrate Unprecedented Indigenous-Led Initiative to Protect Northwest Territories\n\nWASHINGTON—.... The agreement, initially funded through an investment of CAD$375 million (approximately USD$270 million) in public and private financing....\n\n The initiative will protect [not conserve] a vast area of intact forests, rugged mountain chains, and wetlands, lakes, and rivers, resulting in a significant contribution to Canada's pledge to protect 30% of its lands and waters by 2030. \n\nAgain, protection is putting a big fence around a large area of potentially resource-rich territory in the Northwest Territories. The article continues:\n\nPrivate donors will match the government on a 1-to-4 basis, contributing CAD$75 million over a 10-year period.\n\nGuess where that money is coming from? The article says it is coming from the Pew foundation, so the international donors, of which there are not many, include the Pew Charitable Trust.\n\n Here we have this foreign influence that really threatens access to the public not only to fish and hunt but also to mine. We know we are already struggling to have mining in Northwest Territories. The last mine is about to close at the end of 2026, and here we have another impediment to future development.\n\n I will just read this in terms of scale. When we say the scale of 30% and 50% and those kinds of things, what does that actually mean? This is a quote from an article in The Canadian Press about the size of 25 by 25 and then what 30 by 30 will mean in a tangible way. It states:\n\nTo hit \"25 by 25,\" Canada must further protect more than 1.2 million square kilometres of land, or approximately the size of Manitoba and Saskatchewan added together [a massive amount of territory]. To get to 30 per cent is to add, on top of that, land almost equivalent in size to Alberta.\n\nIt is massive. It continues:\n\nThe federal government would need to protect another 638,000 square kilometres of marine territory and coastlines by 2025, or an area almost three times the size of the Gulf of St. Lawrence. By 2030, another area the size of the gulf would need to be added.\n\nTherefore, here we are, influenced by foreign non-governmental environmental organizations about closing key areas that we could formerly access publicly to fish, hunt and develop our resources, all shut down by these groups.\n\nI met Crawford Patkotak. He is an Alaskan Inuit leader and he spoke to us about this very issue. Listen to his approach to these radical environmental groups:\n\nEnvironmental groups, animal rights groups, these are the same organizations that come into our communities and try to split us all apart, split all the corporations, the tribes, the governments because they have an agenda [it is called the \"30 by 30\" agenda] and if they had their agenda we wouldn't be able to hunt today. If they had their agenda, we wouldn't be able to develop the oil we have in the ground. That would cripple us economically.\n\nHe said that they told these groups to get lost. I would say that is an example of an indigenous leader who knows exactly the benefit of having access to be able to fish, hunt and develop their resources.\n\nTherefore, Motion No. 15, while well-intentioned perhaps, would really set the stage to have a lot more closures and protections in Canada, and 30 by 30 is already causing Canadians to lose access to our beloved fishing, hunting, areas of recreation and other examples I have laid out tonight. That, I simply cannot support.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419796","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank all those watching out there in Canada. I am glad to have them watching us tonight.\n\nReally, Motion M-15 is about the Liberal commitment to the 30 by 30 agenda, the ever-growing commitment, as it grows to 50 by 50, which is half of our land mass and waters in Canada. There is also the commitment to funding the groups that promote this agenda. This agenda threatens public acces","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a4f4a6781831cf454d024c8ba58d3c79a93a5fe950fc213f7de46359e2a9269"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["65dc6b25b268dd6e8a851bf4b5e1359d2a20e279d67f91fd643c4a4afb009417"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39687dcbc358670f40ba64d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419793,"date":"2026-04-15T19:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after 11 years of Liberals, affordability is getting worse for northerners, despite what they tell us. I quote from their own recent nutrition north report: In the Northwest Territories, 60.7% of Inuit are food-insecure. In Nunavut, 76% of Inuit experience food insecurity.\n\nWill Liberals vote for our Conservative motion to remove all federal taxes on gas and diesel, so that Canadians can save 25¢ a litre for the rest of the year, or will they keep voting for half measures?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419793","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after 11 years of Liberals, affordability is getting worse for northerners, despite what they tell us. I quote from their own recent nutrition north report: In the Northwest Territories, 60.7% of Inuit are food-insecure. In Nunavut, 76% of Inuit experience food insecurity.\n\nWill Liberals vote for our Conservative motion to remove all federal taxes on gas and diesel, so that Canadians ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","label":"Nutrition","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01a63c9502605728c3687eb6c1c9deb46e32829bb01d70f4c0121fd17e7bcd01"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0b66f991ff90e4cc1278bb2e401439be812bc3e3b8681a5d0dd85c052bc571da"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a8cb5060719cf5c5dd12229","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":419794,"date":"2026-04-15T21:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a petition on behalf of all British Columbians who love to fish for salmon and who are also deeply concerned about the proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia.\n\nChanging this common property principle risks turning a shared public resource into an exclusive privilege, reducing access for many Canadians and undermining confidence in fisheries management. Petitioners note that it would be devastating to our tourism economy and the millions of dollars that flow into conservation efforts. Constituents are calling on the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans to leave the current salmon allocation policy alone and uphold the cultural rights and traditions of all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:419794","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a petition on behalf of all British Columbians who love to fish for salmon and who are also deeply concerned about the proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia.\n\nChanging this common property principle risks turning a shared public resource into an exclusive pri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["95f0b1f11db3592bcf0cd03f89179b9944624e75269635ccac6f7b1c31e4f2a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d01a77d91b507bdaf4837a33a0e597b510c59f1b4a650463828feef25585f100"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06dbf7d2616f8aeb1095bfdb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299966,"date":"2026-04-21T20:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on the Wet'suwet'en issue, many Canadians were captivated by what was happening in their territory, where a pipeline was being blocked, a project was being blocked. I met Hereditary Chief Theresa Tait-Day. She came to me and said, \"Bob, 80% of us in the Wet'suwet'en really support this project.\" Elected chiefs and hereditary chiefs supported it, and there was a small group of hereditary chiefs who were opposed to the project. Guess which group the minister at the time from the Liberal government was sent out to negotiate with. It was only with the people who were in opposition to the project.\n\nWe talk about \"in good faith\". Does the member for Skeena—Bulkley Valley think the Liberals really do want to work in good faith with first nations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299966","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on the Wet'suwet'en issue, many Canadians were captivated by what was happening in their territory, where a pipeline was being blocked, a project was being blocked. I met Hereditary Chief Theresa Tait-Day. She came to me and said, \"Bob, 80% of us in the Wet'suwet'en really support this project.\" Elected chiefs and hereditary chiefs supported it, and there was a small group of heredita","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["485e1a00636c1db42e80522bde20b3c24b876562477687ccf43b0ffdf3d910b7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2cf59158263623adb65ec2ec70e6673944161851e2585c02ae33f91322032c3f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1d28c088bce4e3ad3311fb9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299967,"date":"2026-04-21T22:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when the member was part of the NDP, we had spoken. She has not really been the strongest supporter of natural resource projects in the north, specifically Nunavut. However, we know how natural resource jobs are incredibly important to residents of Nunavut. We are seeing some of these mines develop; it is a great thing for Nunavummiut and youth. \n\nDoes the member believe that adding a commissioner will actually enable more natural resource development and more jobs? Does she think it is going to be a positive for the economy of Nunavut?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299967","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when the member was part of the NDP, we had spoken. She has not really been the strongest supporter of natural resource projects in the north, specifically Nunavut. However, we know how natural resource jobs are incredibly important to residents of Nunavut. We are seeing some of these mines develop; it is a great thing for Nunavummiut and youth. \n\nDoes the member believe that adding a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","label":"Indigenous youth","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f666a65442d8c96801b809b118b6deaf3d4f248867fab9f9fc1652d5d6c571f7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["51e7129b7bbc1679cbb93451c445e08366df55c02b65fefce2db264dc52611e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efcc898ca4e471d4a28d16d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299965,"date":"2026-04-22T20:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister promised he would negotiate a win on trade by last summer, but from his recent video, he seems to be throwing in the towel. The Council of Forest Industries said that last year softwood tariffs had tripled, to 45%, since 2022; 15,000 forestry jobs have been lost; and since 2023, 21 more mills have closed. \n\nI ask the Prime Minister how many thousands of B.C. forestry workers need to lose their jobs before he keeps his promise to negotiate a win?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299965","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister promised he would negotiate a win on trade by last summer, but from his recent video, he seems to be throwing in the towel. The Council of Forest Industries said that last year softwood tariffs had tripled, to 45%, since 2022; 15,000 forestry jobs have been lost; and since 2023, 21 more mills have closed. \n\nI ask the Prime Minister how many thousands of B.C. forestr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c8476b6c8d7591896fbe7e560461edde09607f3d6200381dc157e9e3f84a92e6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["419a08c15a0823e925e3c3850eced551106dbb7a6045a03ba032e133b3e00d69"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-913ef4185938a22b48f16388","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":299964,"date":"2026-04-23T16:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. For the record, the member who made that statement is actually from the Bloc Québécois. That is for correction purposes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:299964","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. For the record, the member who made that statement is actually from the Bloc Québécois. That is for correction purposes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bb0f42576c2a485e8947d75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752436,"date":"2026-05-04T19:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, despite his promises, the Liberal Prime Minister is all about more costs, more carbon taxes and more of the same. He said last May, \"Canadians will hold us to account by their experience at the grocery store\". Everyone knows that when fuel prices go up, food costs go up. Mike Beaulieu of The North West Company said that a jug of milk now costs two to five dollars more because of higher fuel prices.\n\nWhy is fuel so expensive? It is because of high Liberal taxes, including the newly renamed carbon tax. Will the Liberals scrap all gas taxes all year, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752436","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, despite his promises, the Liberal Prime Minister is all about more costs, more carbon taxes and more of the same. He said last May, \"Canadians will hold us to account by their experience at the grocery store\". Everyone knows that when fuel prices go up, food costs go up. Mike Beaulieu of The North West Company said that a jug of milk now costs two to five dollars more because of highe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","label":"Dairy products","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1cafbe0029fb26b124be6a88e04211c9a2d495521f5e23854add89a4409b1914"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f1c82e61b590e069c605626687d6d9741477e6da90249a11f2b1c8cae67b8637"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c45721bc60ce6c632035f096","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752437,"date":"2026-05-04T19:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, those empty words will not fill empty stomachs. The Liberals tell us that gas prices are up because world oil prices are at $100 a barrel. Do members know when oil was also at $100 a barrel? It was in 2014, under our Conservative government. The price at the pump then was $1.38 per litre, not $1.99 for gas or $2.29 for diesel, as it is today in Fort St. John.\n\n Will the Liberal Prime Minister stop the illusion and scrap all gas taxes all year so Canadians can afford to live again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-116/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752437","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, those empty words will not fill empty stomachs. The Liberals tell us that gas prices are up because world oil prices are at $100 a barrel. Do members know when oil was also at $100 a barrel? It was in 2014, under our Conservative government. The price at the pump then was $1.38 per litre, not $1.99 for gas or $2.29 for diesel, as it is today in Fort St. John.\n\n Will the Liberal Prime ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["87f351e1408e6a38c495dcdb41b11860ecc22fbe97e18faf50b818b6a6d9644b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["06e39569b4b0f421b79980c3a591b3c72b6166b8007b52d1ce0ae5604e3357ba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e773b26808cb4c76883bc606","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104557,"date":"2026-05-05T17:30:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My questions will be for Carey Price. Good day, Carey. As a fellow British Columbian, let me say we're proud of your achievements and what you've done over your lifetime already. It's good to talk to you today. The Minister of Indigenous Services , appearing before the Senate committee on Bill S-2 , said, \"I am committed to finding proper solutions for First Nations, but it must be done in collaboration to address the second‐generation cut-off\". The second-generation cut off refers to First Nations who were never given legal status, because two generations – their parents and grandparents – intermarried with people without legal status. It ends legal status — the official recognition of a person as a First Nation rights holder, who has access to community rights and treaty rights such as hunting [and] fishing.... Carey, do you still hunt?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104557","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My questions will be for Carey Price. Good day, Carey. As a fellow British Columbian, let me say we're proud of your achievements and what you've done over your lifetime already. It's good to talk to you today. The Minister of Indigenous Services , appearing before the Senate committee on Bill S-2 , said, \"I am committed to finding proper solutions for First Nations, but it m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ed49912e8881305daf7d5e960ecc445fc20c519b1d75bf8be904706e8a426623"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eb4374d2d2999372e9a61398362a375f808de0665bab6149e161ea05174a5110"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-488d6155b094cb4bb17a6aa7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104558,"date":"2026-05-05T17:30:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"What does hunting mean to you, your family and your heritage?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104558","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What does hunting mean to you, your family and your heritage?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hunting (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hunting (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","label":"Hunting (Sport)","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","label":"Natural heritage","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28a3f580fc2350d20e5bce8a84c3ab89614f7e8ac291f1e5e636fc606d9ce62e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5876ebb599566013d1d9983","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104559,"date":"2026-05-05T17:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"You've been very outspoken against the government's gun confiscation program. As it potentially infringes on indigenous rights as well, could you comment on your feelings about the current government's and Mark Carney 's gun confiscation program?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104559","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You've been very outspoken against the government's gun confiscation program. As it potentially infringes on indigenous rights as well, could you comment on your feelings about the current government's and Mark Carney 's gun confiscation program?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","label":"Smoking prevention","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["046ae78135f24ce02187db48bb069553434b8a467a3cebedcf0a3128cd275d5c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-837f0a8cb04ead85e882d373","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104560,"date":"2026-05-05T17:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"This is the last question from me. If targeting gun crime and criminals and dealing with the violence on the streets is the goal like the government is saying, what can the government do better to target criminals who are getting their hands on illegal guns instead of targeting law-abiding firearms owners like yourself?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104560","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This is the last question from me. If targeting gun crime and criminals and dealing with the violence on the streets is the goal like the government is saying, what can the government do better to target criminals who are getting their hands on illegal guns instead of targeting law-abiding firearms owners like yourself?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dfb52c8a23b2a8d16ea03b5546a570c156bef88f0134714f421a9e2124a1aa8b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["51d700399aebcf20af8370b8016a0d671c3038268fffa6c35639050ac9043b52"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6bc2cbd7eafe6dcc7943bbff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104561,"date":"2026-05-05T17:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"It's about indigenous rights, and that's what's—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104561","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's about indigenous rights, and that's what's—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a80a7413b355fc3d2759dc0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104562,"date":"2026-05-05T17:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I just asked the question. Carey, if you don't mind answering the question, that'd be great.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104562","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just asked the question. Carey, if you don't mind answering the question, that'd be great.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e1ca07b3d19c7bebba33fcf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104563,"date":"2026-05-05T17:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thanks, Carey. I'll pass on the rest of my time to my colleague Billy Morin.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104563","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thanks, Carey. I'll pass on the rest of my time to my colleague Billy Morin.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-deafaa4f12e65d6bb6e19eac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104564,"date":"2026-05-07T15:10:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I'm bringing back the topic of the affordability study. I wanted to know where that was at, because I know it was agreed to in a previous committee meeting. I've since had a few conversations, and it sounds like it is going to move ahead. Maybe you could clarify, Chair, where that's going.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104564","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm bringing back the topic of the affordability study. I wanted to know where that was at, because I know it was agreed to in a previous committee meeting. I've since had a few conversations, and it sounds like it is going to move ahead. Maybe you could clarify, Chair, where that's going.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1909179146081ee04e7fcf5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104565,"date":"2026-05-07T15:10:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I just want to know when we're going to proceed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104565","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just want to know when we're going to proceed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3982d66ad9309224d3bae7babcc2fdfc4fc1f17587b09895257a632af41b3311"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a54d9a415f97792a3ebe2a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104566,"date":"2026-05-07T15:10:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"We would like to move forward on it right away. I'd like to discuss it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104566","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We would like to move forward on it right away. I'd like to discuss it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97948c23732c158581c517aa35257aefbca7afc5b6acd1a1c44000c659201520"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69ac7153458662ebc4b217df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104567,"date":"2026-05-07T15:20:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you again for the consideration. I appreciate it—and Brendan too. As part of this, we were also discussing being in the community. It's really important. Brendan and Lori would probably relate to the costs. It's one thing to say it in Ottawa, but it's another thing to see the sticker shock when you walk into a grocery store up in Iqaluit or wherever, so I would propose that we travel as well, whether we go to one place or two. If it's two, my perfect scenario would be to see Inuvik, on the western side of the Arctic, and to see, on the eastern side, at least Iqaluit. They're relatively easy to get to on an airplane. Any of the other remote communities are even better to visit, but they're much more difficult to get to. That's what I would propose, but I'll leave it up to you to let us know what's possible. Part of the planning should be to do some of the planning work before, even pre-summer, because some of that work should be done sooner rather than later.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104567","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you again for the consideration. I appreciate it—and Brendan too. As part of this, we were also discussing being in the community. It's really important. Brendan and Lori would probably relate to the costs. It's one thing to say it in Ottawa, but it's another thing to see the sticker shock when you walk into a grocery store up in Iqaluit or wherever, so I would propose that we travel as well","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3d52a07ca0be52256a946fec341ecae3a3c6ec69bfcf284727e75d6b1a74eddf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b5b52e333fad754258561d1f82f77b04d6b79a6a20f3a4b0a127458ebba7a20d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b0735231bd05f9cb9198ec2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752435,"date":"2026-05-07T17:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a headline from Business in Vancouver reads, \"Councillor says $100M project denied loan over Cowichan case, bank says not a factor\". The article goes on to say, \"A Richmond, B.C., councillor says a company based in the city has been refused financing for what she says is a $100 million project because of uncertainty over their site due to the Cowichan Tribes aboriginal title ruling.\"\n\nWe are hearing conflicting things. We hear the government say it is no big deal here and other people are saying it is no big deal there, but that is what is happening and that is the reality on the ground.\n\nDespite the empty words from the Prime Minister and the minister, to the member from Vancouver Island, what are the genuine fears you are hearing about from members in your own community on the ground?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752435","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a headline from Business in Vancouver reads, \"Councillor says $100M project denied loan over Cowichan case, bank says not a factor\". The article goes on to say, \"A Richmond, B.C., councillor says a company based in the city has been refused financing for what she says is a $100 million project because of uncertainty over their site due to the Cowichan Tribes aboriginal title ruling.\"\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23477cd36ad131aebb0ab1d4a156c6d4acd615d6974af05bdedb7f556eaefbcf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f87d101fa1fc07524caa94a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1033676,"date":"2026-05-25T16:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate this opportunity to speak on this bill that my colleague brought to the House a while ago. My colleague from Cariboo—Prince George has been stalwart in support of first responders in the Prince George community in northeastern B.C.\n\n I know the member meets with firefighters from Prince George, as I do. We hear their stories, the first-hand accounts of firefighters who signed up to fight fires but are now dealing with overdoses. That is the vast majority of what they are doing. Sadly, some of the stuff that comes along with that response to the drug side of our community is violence against them. It is really sad. It is a shame that these people who sign up to protect us and keep us safe are having to deal with violence.\n\n Maybe I will start off by saying that most Canadians expect this House to protect our first responders. For me, there are really a couple of aspects to this that I think about. It is one thing for our first responders to be assaulted while they are trying to help us. First of all, they sign up for their entire lives. They put years into university and all that training basically to serve their fellow men by providing health care. My daughter wants to be a doctor. She is studying to do that as we speak. My to-be daughter-in-law, my son's fiancée, is studying to be a nurse in the Philippines as we speak. I know this comes out of a servant heart. They really want to help their fellow Canadians, their fellow persons. The sad part is that when they do that, when they get into serving and taking care of us, that is when violence is committed against them.\n\n The expectation of most Canadians, as I was saying before, is that it is one thing for them to be assaulted, but it is another thing for us to not do anything about it. We are in opposition, and the government is across the way. Canadians are looking at us and saying the Liberal government, the former prime minister Justin Trudeau and the current Prime Minister, are responsible for protecting these first responders. They had the opportunity in the last Parliament to do it, and for some reason, they sort of shoved it to the corner of the desk.\n\n I saw my colleague from Cariboo—Prince George working tirelessly, putting hours and hours into this, and our first responders sitting in the gallery waiting for this to be passed, all to just be ignored. Again, what Canadians are expecting of us, and what first responders are watching for, is what they have been asking for, what this member has been working on. They have been coming to him and saying they need help, that they need help to really deal with the gap in legislation where this violence is being allowed to continue.\n\nWhat is worse is that these people have sacrificed everything to serve us, and the government is looking the other way. That is just not cool on our watch. \n\nI am just going to read the preamble to the bill. People hear about different bills, and they hear the titles. This is what the preamble to Bill S-233 says: \n\nWhereas there are an increasing number of incidents involving violence against persons who provide health services and first responders; Whereas assaults on persons who provide health services and first responders have both a physical and a psychological impact; And whereas persons who provide health services and first responders, who care for and protect others, deserve to feel protected and valued by the justice system;\n\nI think the most important line in the whole bill is that last line. They deserve to feel protected and valued by the justice system. That tells me that right now it is maybe a question sometimes. They are being assaulted. They are doing their duty as a doctor, nurse, ambulance worker, police officer or firefighter, and they are being assaulted in different ways. It is mentioned in the preamble too. It is not just the physical aspect of it but the psychological aspect of that kind of assault too. Again, when that assault goes on unabated, they probably start to question whether or not they are valued by this government.\n\n Again, I applaud my colleague from Cariboo—Prince George for doing this.\n\nAs the member of Parliament for Tumbler Ridge, I cannot say enough about the first responders and the police officers who responded. Many of the stories of how they really stepped up and helped have not even come out yet. There is the police officer who was first on scene who lifted an injured girl off the floor and brought her to the hospital to give her care. She is alive today because that first responder acted.\n\nThe story is known by most people in Tumbler Ridge, but Maya is alive today because a first responder listened to a bit of advice from her classmate Addison, who I chatted with just last week. There was, of course, all the tragedy that had happened in the school. The police came, and Addison pointed out that Maya's finger had moved. He said, \"Her finger just moved.\" Part of the reason Maya is still alive today is that the police officer responded, picked her up and took her to be cared for. \n\nTo me, that is an amazing story, but it is a first responder's story. Here was somebody who had just signed up to be an RCMP officer in a very beautiful town, the normally peaceful town of Tumbler Ridge, and in the moment that we needed him, he stepped up. Maya is alive today because of it.\n\nI will expand on that story a bit. Many people have been watching Maya's story, how she keeps improving, on social media. She has a long way to go, but I will take the time today to send our appreciation to the nurses and doctors in British Columbia who have taken Maya under their wing and are providing her with first world service. It is just incredible. \n\nMaya is still in B.C. There have been a lot of stories saying that she was going to go elsewhere, but she is in British Columbia now. She is still recovering, more on the long-term side. I cannot say enough about the immediate service that she got from the police officers and from the nurses and doctors, both in Tumbler Ridge and then at BC Children's Hospital in Vancouver.\n\n It goes without saying that these services are here. Sometimes, that is what it is, is it not? We just expect the services to be there, and we do not always appreciate the men and women who work in those services enough. This bill is meant to recognize that service. It would be a good shot in the arm to say to responders that, even though someone may not be assaulted physically or psychologically, we would recognize what they do for us in our communities. Maybe it would be the morale boost they need. Members can imagine the issues we are seeing with some first responders. Even going back to Tumbler Ridge, the long-term effects of responding to that kind of a tragedy are profound.\n\nI have another story. Even a person involved in the funeral aspects is dealing with the trauma of the situations. I remember talking to Kaylee, one of the morticians up there. I said, \"Well, I guess you are used to this.\" She said, \"Nobody is used to this.\" It is just a tough situation all along, even for the folks who deal with this on a regular basis.\n\nI wanted to have the chance to speak today, first of all, to support my colleague and what he is trying to do. I also want to say to our men and women, whether they are a firefighter, those who work in an ambulance every day, a doctor, a nurse or an RCMP officer, and I am sure I am forgetting somebody, that whoever they are, we appreciate them and we care about them. That is what Bill S-233 is about. It is to make them feel protected and valued by the justice system, just like we do on this side of the House. My hope is that the government will decide to proceed and that we will get this bill passed as soon as we can. \n\nI thank all those who listened today and, again, I give special appreciation to my colleague from Cariboo—Prince George. It is a great bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033676","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate this opportunity to speak on this bill that my colleague brought to the House a while ago. My colleague from Cariboo—Prince George has been stalwart in support of first responders in the Prince George community in northeastern B.C.\n\n I know the member meets with firefighters from Prince George, as I do. We hear their stories, the first-hand accounts of firefighters who si","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0927017c1ad96b5d8c93d3b42deba47a885942dc98cce1e5d6574acd2e0ad563"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c33c07987caa7d20466e255c9f2ae5644069e0fc53e7b3ed4a0137bcc114942b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-662c612094ba0f4fe8964ac4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104568,"date":"2026-06-04T13:15:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you for coming, witnesses, on this affordability study. Affordability is something you live with every day, and I appreciate the difficulty, even for you personally, of buying groceries in a place like Iqaluit and even further north. Look at a bag of groceries. It's already expensive in northern B.C., where I live. It's surprising how expensive it has become, but for you it's often probably double or triple that. Affordability, simply put, is the financial ability of individuals or households to pay for essential goods and services such as housing, health care and food without experiencing financial hardship or compromising their ability to meet other basic needs. Joseph, is food affordable in Nunavut?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104568","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for coming, witnesses, on this affordability study. Affordability is something you live with every day, and I appreciate the difficulty, even for you personally, of buying groceries in a place like Iqaluit and even further north. Look at a bag of groceries. It's already expensive in northern B.C., where I live. It's surprising how expensive it has become, but for you it's often probably ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca40fc47ad0191ba6b790785eb4dc5a41ed65d33201bded991c1b490d72e9106"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80165a162abf3197e85d1b35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104569,"date":"2026-06-04T13:15:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Well, there you go. Voices: Oh, oh! Bob Zimmer: I have some other documents. The Prime Minister said last election, as quoted by Brian Lilley on September 16, 2025, \"Canadians will hold us to account by their experience at the grocery store, when they are paying their electricity bill, when they or their children are looking for a place to live.\" That is what Carney said, and it goes to exactly the definition of affordability. By that measure, has the Prime Minister been successful thus far?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104569","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Well, there you go. Voices: Oh, oh! Bob Zimmer: I have some other documents. The Prime Minister said last election, as quoted by Brian Lilley on September 16, 2025, \"Canadians will hold us to account by their experience at the grocery store, when they are paying their electricity bill, when they or their children are looking for a place to live.\" That is what Carney said, and it goes to exactly th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Commonwealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Commonwealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","label":"Commonwealth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ace0aced1d255935a3ebb4f00c9e9b9770ca6969862586c5d2f6f1b1ab127f7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6c9d8db97d26ef1eb764149","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104570,"date":"2026-06-04T13:30:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I want to thank you for the work you do. You provide meals for those in need of food in your own community, where it's not cheap to do that. I appreciate your time and effort and your volunteers. Before I forget to say it, I just want to say thank you for your efforts. You talked about previous governments. Nutrition north was an effort by our previous government to combat high food prices. It started off with good intentions, and it's done some good work. It's lowered the prices of some necessities, like milk and bread, and other foods at the grocery store, but it hasn't been perfect, for sure, and there are still some out-of-control prices in the north. I have a document here, \"Evaluation of the Nutrition North Canada Horizontal Initiative\", from December 2025. It says, \"For example, in 2022, in Nunavut, 76% of Inuit experienced food insecurity.\" Are you seeing a disparity between Inuit who are from Nunavut and those who come in who work in Iqaluit? Are you seeing a disparity in that sort of affordability? Is it hitting Nunavummiut more than visitors to the community?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104570","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I want to thank you for the work you do. You provide meals for those in need of food in your own community, where it's not cheap to do that. I appreciate your time and effort and your volunteers. Before I forget to say it, I just want to say thank you for your efforts. You talked about previous governments. Nutrition north was an effort by our previous government to combat high food prices. It sta","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92298","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Inuit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inuit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92298","label":"Inuit","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab57d469686638ac8df1ad6dbb19219d33ac691e9cac85f43849c87188ceea84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95aab0cbf6baa31ae5c624585c407b2514f5e17d3b2ed7adc34879a9aff08d40"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba5cc51544336123cbbf8c86","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104571,"date":"2026-06-04T13:30:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I appreciate what you said. You mentioned incomes earlier in your statement. I was up in the Baffinland iron mines earlier this spring when it was very cold but beautiful. We talked to many young workers there who are Nunavummiut. They said they really liked their jobs. That gave them not only the ability to earn incomes, but also the ability to go back home and eat a traditional diet. They could afford skidoos. They could afford side-by-sides. They also had the time to do it. They had two weeks on and two weeks off. They had a solid two weeks to get their harvest and provide for their families. They had houses they could afford. To me, that was a good answer to the affordability challenge question. What is your answer to bringing incomes up and the economy up in Nunavut so that affordability becomes a lot easier of a question to answer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104571","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I appreciate what you said. You mentioned incomes earlier in your statement. I was up in the Baffinland iron mines earlier this spring when it was very cold but beautiful. We talked to many young workers there who are Nunavummiut. They said they really liked their jobs. That gave them not only the ability to earn incomes, but also the ability to go back home and eat a traditional diet. They could ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe3c42136302ad253135d737572c0164485c6397848f2ae3e75548ae400a3bf2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2fcaf98af735734b055b40a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104572,"date":"2026-06-04T14:20:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Gary, for appearing at committee. It would have been nice to have you down here in Ottawa, but I know that's quite a trek. Gary, we're having an affordability study today. I mentioned the definition of affordability before, but I'll say it again, because why is a miner at an affordability study in Ottawa? Affordability is the financial ability of individuals or households to pay for essential goods and services, such as housing, health care and food, without experiencing financial hardship or compromising their ability to meet other basic needs. I have an article here from May 6. It's from the Yellowknifer: \"NWT's GDP continues to contract, largely driven by declining resource extraction\". It says: According to Statistics Canada, the NWT was the only jurisdiction to experience a decline in gross domestic product (GDP) for 2025. Statistics Canada says the NWT had the weakest economic performance in 2025, falling by two per cent.... Gary, how is the Northwest Territories doing economically?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gross domestic product","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104572","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Gary, for appearing at committee. It would have been nice to have you down here in Ottawa, but I know that's quite a trek. Gary, we're having an affordability study today. I mentioned the definition of affordability before, but I'll say it again, because why is a miner at an affordability study in Ottawa? Affordability is the financial ability of individuals or hou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","label":"Gross domestic product"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gross domestic product","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","label":"Gross domestic product","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["096aad429fdffb277160e6daef74c37e7cdfac3e23ee08d3fdb1085a1ab28397"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gross domestic product","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["980048bf31cbb9d733cb0f2be5736f6d0b6980f5d2b4f71023807c82c79b6e6a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gross domestic product","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gross domestic product","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48729","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54077d7a98e6047de968c213","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104573,"date":"2026-06-04T14:20:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"That's all about exploration, Gary, isn't it? That's often a measure that most people who aren't miners don't understand. Exploration has the advanced team for actual mining to take place, and we know that Canada is one of the most difficult jurisdictions around the world in which to mine. It takes 19 years from start to finish—from when a mine starts to when it actually starts producing a resource and can profit. I'll go on. It was strange to me, Gary, knowing the economic situation, that one of the first announcements the Prime Minister made was that he was going to turn 30% of the Northwest Territories into a park. That was an initiative from environmentalist groups, some of which are from foreign countries. They are contributing $75 million. That's the seed money from environmental groups. One is the Pew foundation, from the U.S. This was a combined effort, with $300 million coming from the Canadian taxpayer. This is my next question: If the economy is doing so poorly, do you think it's a good idea for the Prime Minister to announce that he is turning 30% of the Northwest Territories into a park?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104573","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's all about exploration, Gary, isn't it? That's often a measure that most people who aren't miners don't understand. Exploration has the advanced team for actual mining to take place, and we know that Canada is one of the most difficult jurisdictions around the world in which to mine. It takes 19 years from start to finish—from when a mine starts to when it actually starts producing a resourc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b8708ab09a79687b8cc7904517a3307f9c8f07cde3fdd3ecd9d52c831bf04703"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b65cfc17e12566f32c76a46dcd0977c7a355f729b9fc4e0abe32b40fa1424d5b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e648d86cf71356cbbd8a989","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104574,"date":"2026-06-04T14:20:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Gary, what's IOGC?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104574","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Gary, what's IOGC?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c4d865eabdfb4603a16c57dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104575,"date":"2026-06-04T14:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Could you maybe clarify something for this room? I talked to some of the leaders there, and they were under the understanding that they could still develop resources once an area is put under protection. Once a territory or a park is put under these protections, taking the 30% as an example, can resources be developed in that area?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104575","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could you maybe clarify something for this room? I talked to some of the leaders there, and they were under the understanding that they could still develop resources once an area is put under protection. Once a territory or a park is put under these protections, taking the 30% as an example, can resources be developed in that area?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1d08473a19a26efe8994ccd820cb21866a79f543216133a6357079d95851f10d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["21716daa91667f50f2fc79b1ce4b1e3bf956ac7d72a0c29c6371f1435d1977d6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-01e72bb3df48a2e7859b193b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104576,"date":"2026-06-04T14:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"For context, how many mines are still going to be operational by the end of this year in the NWT?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104576","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"For context, how many mines are still going to be operational by the end of this year in the NWT?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","label":"Industrial buildings","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e6266eaf9ce622dae670a07bd6a15d055d82455ef9a22940f9fd4edf0a42eca1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-282f4977db4fab3e6b9b80da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104577,"date":"2026-06-04T14:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"From what once was recognized as a diamond hub, really, around the world, we're down to zero operational mines in the Northwest Territories.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104577","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"From what once was recognized as a diamond hub, really, around the world, we're down to zero operational mines in the Northwest Territories.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036074","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Landmines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036074","label":"Landmines","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","label":"Coal","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d429eb3c096abc20523a7f65f846cd2c387a1dc94bc0d10b1a08032eb67674eb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-74a3866c2fb20e2f2cf62738","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104578,"date":"2026-06-04T15:05:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you, Chair. I appreciate the opportunity. Gary, again, thank you for coming. For context for the viewers, in terms of region size, we were talking about protecting 30% of the Northwest Territories. That might seem insignificant to somebody who is not living there, but the Northwest Territories is the third-largest region in the country, at 1.346 million square kilometres, so 30% of NWT is very significant in geographical size. I want to go back to something you said before. Exploration has been on the decline in NWT since 2007, and you said this isn't a new problem and that the Northwest Territories has a bad reputation. Why is exploration in such sharp decline in the Northwest Territories, Gary?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104578","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. I appreciate the opportunity. Gary, again, thank you for coming. For context for the viewers, in terms of region size, we were talking about protecting 30% of the Northwest Territories. That might seem insignificant to somebody who is not living there, but the Northwest Territories is the third-largest region in the country, at 1.346 million square kilometres, so 30% of NWT is ve","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7bd96f6d246814562549f4fb27302b1ecb66277c9c22cbe65afb58136d97a350"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b51de7dcb8d337169c893e49","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104579,"date":"2026-06-04T15:10:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I appreciate what the Prime Minister had to say last election. He said he was going to develop our economy \"at speeds we haven't seen in generations\". It's one thing to be hopeful that that actually happens, and I'm sure you would agree. It's one thing to say that, but for that to happen is a completely different thing. I will ask this as a last five-second question. Do you see that happening in the next couple of years?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104579","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I appreciate what the Prime Minister had to say last election. He said he was going to develop our economy \"at speeds we haven't seen in generations\". It's one thing to be hopeful that that actually happens, and I'm sure you would agree. It's one thing to say that, but for that to happen is a completely different thing. I will ask this as a last five-second question. Do you see that happening in t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6817c960b114a98a4155641","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104580,"date":"2026-06-04T15:10:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Could you repeat the last 30 seconds? There was a glitch in the video. Just repeat your last two sentences.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104580","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could you repeat the last 30 seconds? There was a glitch in the video. Just repeat your last two sentences.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c85577ba4803695189967376","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085127,"date":"2026-06-08T17:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I just want to bring up to the member across the way that his government has been in power for the last 11 years, and the Northwest Territories should be one of the powerful cylinders in our economic engine, but it is seriously misfiring. The Northwest Territories was in a recession in six of the years since the Liberals formed government: 2016, 2019, 2020, 2022, 2024 and 2025, after job-killing Liberal policies were enacted by the previous prime minister and the current Prime Minister. The current Prime Minister does not seem to be wanting to fix it either. He just turned 30% of the Northwest Territories into a park.\n\nMy question for the member is this: Is the Northwest Territories in recession, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085127","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I just want to bring up to the member across the way that his government has been in power for the last 11 years, and the Northwest Territories should be one of the powerful cylinders in our economic engine, but it is seriously misfiring. The Northwest Territories was in a recession in six of the years since the Liberals formed government: 2016, 2019, 2020, 2022, 2024 and 2025, afte","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fedd91a186c6abef7350c6f33df6cc0a13e97a4f406dc4a10a513f83d11dbcee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c5dcfb9e346ca7b5cc1d37d81eef657e3e64e25844955ce8bb45c7844d291093"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02238abd02587dc187faf530","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085128,"date":"2026-06-08T17:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of order. The question was about the Northwest Territories—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085128","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of order. The question was about the Northwest Territories—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-716907522c4ec3cdb156a17a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104581,"date":"2026-06-11T13:50:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"It's his time; it's not her time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104581","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's his time; it's not her time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d84886da152be3603baf5008","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104582,"date":"2026-06-11T14:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My first question is for Minister Chartrand. The Prime Minister said last year, \"Canadians will hold us to account by their experience at the grocery store, when they are paying their electricity bill, when they or their children are looking for a place to live\". Northerners took him at his word, and so did they take his predecessor at his word. Last week, at this committee, Joseph Murdoch-Flowers, executive director of the Qajuqturvik Community Food Centre in Iqaluit, testified that yearly meal counts have grown from \"58,000 in 2022 to almost 91,000\" in 2025, a 57% increase in three years. As of June 3, 2026, the centre had already served over 37,000 meals. That's this year. According to Statistics Canada, 58.1% of people in Nunavut live in food-insecure households, the highest rate in the country and more than double the national average. In Nunavut, a jar of jam costs $35, a jar of pickles costs $66 and a six-pack of applesauce costs $58. Minister, your government has been in power for 11 years, and hunger in Nunavut is worsening. When is life going to finally get more affordable for northerners, as Prime Minister Mark Carney promised?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104582","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. My first question is for Minister Chartrand. The Prime Minister said last year, \"Canadians will hold us to account by their experience at the grocery store, when they are paying their electricity bill, when they or their children are looking for a place to live\". Northerners took him at his word, and so did they take his predecessor at his word. Last week, at this committee, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4045fe272c52bf7f936d540","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104583,"date":"2026-06-11T14:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"With respect, Minister, your government has been in government for 11 years.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104583","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"With respect, Minister, your government has been in government for 11 years.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8bf087bbef7d955dc2fb62734ae9442a0a62e49b466051dd090d964fe1e06748"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6194209413b33d29ad18033f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104584,"date":"2026-06-11T14:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"It's my time, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104584","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's my time, Mr. Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d006519a828d7c427e742d63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104585,"date":"2026-06-11T14:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"No, she's already not answered the question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104585","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, she's already not answered the question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f8818a9fe6ec958ac8b92dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104586,"date":"2026-06-11T14:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you, but the respect goes both ways, and it's my question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104586","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, but the respect goes both ways, and it's my question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","label":"Gender equality","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["530995ec88e1e8646eed2817c54d3fa476d29eb176da96b85da4115263987a46"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd17d14d8d07c7b3f7079b98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104587,"date":"2026-06-11T14:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Minister, you've been in government for 11 years—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104587","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Minister, you've been in government for 11 years—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-750dc25d879e766352a950c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104588,"date":"2026-06-11T14:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Minister.... I have a point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104588","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Minister.... I have a point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab6d3e8def4d78cb6b11b971","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104589,"date":"2026-06-11T14:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"This isn't her time; it's mine. I know she doesn't want to answer, because there is not really a good answer for northerners.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104589","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"This isn't her time; it's mine. I know she doesn't want to answer, because there is not really a good answer for northerners.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1696799f917de7a936f686c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104590,"date":"2026-06-11T14:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I'm trying.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104590","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm trying.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7982dde094dfce8ca49da4cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104591,"date":"2026-06-11T14:35:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Minister, your government's been in power for 11 years, and things have gotten worse, based on promises of the previous prime minister and the current Prime Minister . More promises make people feel better, but they don't fill their stomachs. I know that northerners are expecting the Prime Minister to fulfill his promise, and I hope that's forthcoming. Minister Alty, according to Statistics Canada, the Northwest Territories' crime severity index, which weighs crimes by seriousness, rose to 526.9 in 2024. That's up 35% from 389 in 2019. It is the highest crime severity index of any province or territory in the country. The Auditor General reported in March 2026 that the Northwest Territories RCMP division carried a vacancy rate of 22.9%, which is the highest in the country. One in four policing positions in the Northwest Territories is empty. In the same supplementary estimates (A) that we are examining today, the federal government is spending $203 million to confiscate the firearms of law-abiding Canadian firearms owners, who rely on these firearms to feed their families or for protection in the backcountry. Minister, do you personally think it is a good use of police officers, police resources and $200 million to go after law-abiding firearms owners' firearms?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104591","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Minister, your government's been in power for 11 years, and things have gotten worse, based on promises of the previous prime minister and the current Prime Minister . More promises make people feel better, but they don't fill their stomachs. I know that northerners are expecting the Prime Minister to fulfill his promise, and I hope that's forthcoming. Minister Alty, according to Statistics Canada","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6d3d31fc582471fa5935b65e280a823e092feab232dc144c7fffc06bc91ce5d5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5f5032decaec2ca6f5383bd1aae899bc96efc9215f21a41b97908f0b11796aec"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b97326ae887f470a30ff2a76","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104592,"date":"2026-06-11T14:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Minister, with respect.... Maybe I'll ask you this personally, because you're from Yellowknife. You see people who hunt and go into the backcountry—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104592","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Minister, with respect.... Maybe I'll ask you this personally, because you're from Yellowknife. You see people who hunt and go into the backcountry—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hunting (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hunting (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historic sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","label":"Historic sites","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","label":"Hunting (Sport)","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35b29fad730b6970d3b80b63fce79abffc45a1eff334cc0708d456c09c7d3807"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a12aef295440eb8ca663810b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104593,"date":"2026-06-11T14:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"They are, actually. There are hunting rifles being banned. Your predecessor Michael McLeod, after one of these committee meetings, came to me and said, \"I know.\" He said that they're banning some of the hunting rifles they hunt bison with in the Northwest Territories. Your colleague previously voted against this legislation. I'm just asking this for the people of the Northwest Territories: Are you willing to do the same? Are you going to stand up for law-abiding firearms owners in the Northwest Territories?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104593","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"They are, actually. There are hunting rifles being banned. Your predecessor Michael McLeod, after one of these committee meetings, came to me and said, \"I know.\" He said that they're banning some of the hunting rifles they hunt bison with in the Northwest Territories. Your colleague previously voted against this legislation. I'm just asking this for the people of the Northwest Territories: Are you","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14f1da73c28e993a67d4175a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104594,"date":"2026-06-11T14:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I'm asking you personally.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104594","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm asking you personally.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eef5b51677b1972c86ccef80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104595,"date":"2026-06-11T14:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"She's not answering the question, though.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104595","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"She's not answering the question, though.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a96504f1000006e631c1c6fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104596,"date":"2026-06-11T14:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"You're not. I asked you personally.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104596","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You're not. I asked you personally.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-959c66ddb0056a3155b2cf4d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104597,"date":"2026-06-11T14:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Okay. Personally, you're not going to stand up for your constituents, as your predecessor Michael McLeod did. He voted against this legislation. Even Brendan Hanley, who's sitting with us today, voted against this legislation. It basically targets law-abiding firearms owners. Are you going to stand up for your constituents and oppose this gun confiscation program, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104597","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Personally, you're not going to stand up for your constituents, as your predecessor Michael McLeod did. He voted against this legislation. Even Brendan Hanley, who's sitting with us today, voted against this legislation. It basically targets law-abiding firearms owners. Are you going to stand up for your constituents and oppose this gun confiscation program, yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c12ca39d1fafb6931103913","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104598,"date":"2026-06-11T14:40:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I'll take that as a no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104598","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll take that as a no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f03a38db417fe80e75c6f2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104599,"date":"2026-06-11T14:55:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I have two quick questions, and then I'll pass it over to my colleague Jamie Schmale. Minister Alty, I have a quick question. On the Giant Mine remediation project, are you currently benefiting or have you personally benefited from the project?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104599","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have two quick questions, and then I'll pass it over to my colleague Jamie Schmale. Minister Alty, I have a quick question. On the Giant Mine remediation project, are you currently benefiting or have you personally benefited from the project?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43588ee79d71a9d5d99233e72674193b28f32240242bb51f629d42ec305fa60e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1cb0f3b6efe99d17ffdad7e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104600,"date":"2026-06-11T14:55:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you. Minister Chartrand, the Giant Mine remediation project has grown from a once-budgeted $467 million to $4.4 billion. Of that, $200 million has been paid to consultants. Of the training paid for by the project, fewer than 50% of the people getting training dollars are actually working on the project. It's so bad that this committee voted to have the Auditor General audit the entire project. What are you doing, Minister, to get the project back on track?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104600","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Minister Chartrand, the Giant Mine remediation project has grown from a once-budgeted $467 million to $4.4 billion. Of that, $200 million has been paid to consultants. Of the training paid for by the project, fewer than 50% of the people getting training dollars are actually working on the project. It's so bad that this committee voted to have the Auditor General audit the entire projec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-109ca9ea6c59cf1eac20cfe1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104601,"date":"2026-06-11T14:55:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you, Minister. That's my time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104601","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Minister. That's my time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0e804c613f87aac848ea433","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085124,"date":"2026-06-11T19:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that was another non-answer.\n\nJoseph Murdoch-Flowers, executive director of the Qajuqturvik Community Food Centre in Iqaluit, said this week that the centre has seen its daily meal count go from around 58,000 in 2022 to almost 91,000 last year. It has served 37,000 meals so far this year in a town of 7,500 people. The Liberals have been in power for 11 years, yet 58% of people in Nunavut live in food-insecure households.\n\nAfter 11 years, does the Prime Minister really think Nunavut has never had it so good?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085124","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that was another non-answer.\n\nJoseph Murdoch-Flowers, executive director of the Qajuqturvik Community Food Centre in Iqaluit, said this week that the centre has seen its daily meal count go from around 58,000 in 2022 to almost 91,000 last year. It has served 37,000 meals so far this year in a town of 7,500 people. The Liberals have been in power for 11 years, yet 58% of people in Nuna","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cd7d5780f0a88db4a83d92f668ea194ee2f3cd1471addf1ee6821b22db541869"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88f4e7de065af532028ac7436bae556509c31f0fa2741f7d040e89caa4d34a6a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b383b7dc55d68491a40ea042","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085125,"date":"2026-06-12T00:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know third party advertising and the involvement of foreign governments in our elections is a big problem. It reared its head back in 2015. I am sure the member remembers back in the day. This is a headline from 2017: \"Controversial Leadnow active in B.C. politics, Vancouver city affairs\". We originally sort of brought the evidence forward that this was occurring. The article refers to \"claims filed last week with Elections Canada—and reported this week by the Calgary Herald—that foreign money 'spawned' Leadnow and helped fund an elaborate campaign to oust the ruling Conservative Party.\"\n\n I would ask the member to speak to this issue. It is a big deal, and we even see our colleague across the way from Toronto affected by shenanigans in elections. Maybe the member can just speak to what happened back in 2015.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085125","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know third party advertising and the involvement of foreign governments in our elections is a big problem. It reared its head back in 2015. I am sure the member remembers back in the day. This is a headline from 2017: \"Controversial Leadnow active in B.C. politics, Vancouver city affairs\". We originally sort of brought the evidence forward that this was occurring. The article refers","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca9dff6c7135f95781785524ec077cc8edbefa51dc641795e98c55f3fb01a9f7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9e9c25d4c809ccaf7f7d29a5e3051319efafefa8a8d75b36ad9b47ef7c9b42b3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1ca70eb86dad2709ac92455","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085126,"date":"2026-06-12T01:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his great work across this country on Bill C-9. Maybe there are some well-intentioned Liberals across the way, but we made these same arguments around medical assistance in dying. We said that there was going to be pressure on seniors to end their life and that MAID was going to be pushed on people who are affected by mental health issues, and that is exactly what has been happening.\n\nIf Bill C-9 really becomes the law of the land, where does the member see this going? How could it actually affect pastors and preachers at Christian churches across Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085126","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his great work across this country on Bill C-9. Maybe there are some well-intentioned Liberals across the way, but we made these same arguments around medical assistance in dying. We said that there was going to be pressure on seniors to end their life and that MAID was going to be pushed on people who are affected by mental health issues, and that is exactly ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1069d8d962785186c02a1042ebc1d4b7a8ad6b6d3d52c35d51ea3e5702149615"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2649cc56c4b95be2b5c40607f534e5749d009af3b3aa691b27e2c9dba101f4d6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30083bcdd2d1c0a4046c4c86","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104602,"date":"2026-06-16T16:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, President Hodgson and Paul Tan for appearing at committee today. You're probably aware of an announcement that was recently made. There has been a recent 30 by 30 announcement in the Northwest Territories that essentially puts a fence around 30% of the Northwest Territories. Perhaps it sounds good turning 30% of Northwest Territories into a park if you live in Vancouver or Toronto, but as you know, the economy is struggling in the Northwest Territories. The last mine that's still operational is about to close at the end of 2026 and, really, economic development in the Northwest Territories has stalled. We have heard from many first nations in this very committee that economic reconciliation is key to indigenous communities flourishing, whether it's in B.C., the Northwest Territories or anywhere. Are you seeking this agreement to close down the area to resource development or to help open it up for development?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104602","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, President Hodgson and Paul Tan for appearing at committee today. You're probably aware of an announcement that was recently made. There has been a recent 30 by 30 announcement in the Northwest Territories that essentially puts a fence around 30% of the Northwest Territories. Perhaps it sounds good turning 30% of Northwest Territories into a park if you live in Vanc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17a4486e83a71ea20b7b13d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104603,"date":"2026-06-16T16:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"President Hodgson, can you speak to that? I heard you say earlier that generating economic opportunities was part of your goal. Maybe you can explain to the committee what some of your hopes and dreams are for your community, economic development-wise, if this agreement is put in place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104603","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"President Hodgson, can you speak to that? I heard you say earlier that generating economic opportunities was part of your goal. Maybe you can explain to the committee what some of your hopes and dreams are for your community, economic development-wise, if this agreement is put in place.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d2d649a2fe8b5ebce21e9a5e843f5405b8e35db94deef976f65cebf14dd9fb0e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50e3bef4fae3455a17ee809f77644f3537d062f0907fb3945471bba99c773eea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a6f8b7bad4d98902a54fa02","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104604,"date":"2026-06-16T16:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"It just so happens that this committee is doing an affordability study in the north about food affordability, housing and other things. Key to affordability is having economic development or jobs that come around, so even if that food is a bit more expensive—as we know it is in the territories, especially the further you get out of Yellowknife—at least you have an opportunity to have a wage that helps pay for that extra cost of milk and other foods. Maybe you can explain how much previous economic development has meant to the community in the past, and even speak to some of those opportunities. You spoke in a general sense, but are companies lining up to talk to you about how, once this agreement is signed, they're ready to go on the other side? Affordability and jobs are key, but maybe there are some key industries that are knocking at your door, even now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104604","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It just so happens that this committee is doing an affordability study in the north about food affordability, housing and other things. Key to affordability is having economic development or jobs that come around, so even if that food is a bit more expensive—as we know it is in the territories, especially the further you get out of Yellowknife—at least you have an opportunity to have a wage that h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["16aa4bf27250d1d2e79c6077175518139f1b4d8ac430f4b042329d59f55fd61e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["440b4120152b3a56a216a927f8631873db1aa148ecb64d4a267979a9bbabd0ca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e810311c47ede1f74ac18c95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104605,"date":"2026-06-16T16:50:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"No, they answered my question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104605","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, they answered my question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bdfeb5671b4bfe600ce32142","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104606,"date":"2026-06-16T17:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you all for coming. I know it's a long journey to get to Ottawa. The flights to Ottawa are a bit better from Iqaluit, but if you're any farther north or in Cambridge Bay, it's very much a long day. Again, thanks for coming today. My questions will be for Brian Tattuinee. Brian, you live in the north. I know you have a good job with the sealift, and you also work for the co-op—the food provider in the north. I've shopped at the local grocery store there, and I see how expensive it is. That's even in Iqaluit, where it's relatively inexpensive. As you get further north, it gets far more expensive, as you know. You have a young family. How many kids do you have?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104606","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you all for coming. I know it's a long journey to get to Ottawa. The flights to Ottawa are a bit better from Iqaluit, but if you're any farther north or in Cambridge Bay, it's very much a long day. Again, thanks for coming today. My questions will be for Brian Tattuinee. Brian, you live in the north. I know you have a good job with the sealift, and you also work for the co-op—the food provid","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00580d35c545ab67bc6a1e01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104607,"date":"2026-06-16T17:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"You and your wife have good jobs. What is it like to buy groceries in Iqaluit?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104607","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You and your wife have good jobs. What is it like to buy groceries in Iqaluit?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035320","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035320","label":"Food inspection","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62814c312fd580de62891dad943f95a1acd262c7c6468d4a521bd97f215f3f01"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbacf9c96b1af531572c913c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104608,"date":"2026-06-16T17:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"That's for a family of four, and I'm assuming you're not buying fancy things when you're buying groceries. Give us some examples of some food that Canadians would buy—milk and some of those examples. What has stood out to you? You've been here too once in a while, in Montreal. What are some foods that really stand out to you as being exceptionally expensive in Iqaluit?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104608","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's for a family of four, and I'm assuming you're not buying fancy things when you're buying groceries. Give us some examples of some food that Canadians would buy—milk and some of those examples. What has stood out to you? You've been here too once in a while, in Montreal. What are some foods that really stand out to you as being exceptionally expensive in Iqaluit?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","label":"Functional foods","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e979e53844d081fac05acedfca82826bfe40c82166c4bc470aac9df99f42b0d7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a142bf4c365b8e547bac3b56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104609,"date":"2026-06-16T17:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Is it safe to say food prices have gone up in the last couple of years and haven't gone down?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104609","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is it safe to say food prices have gone up in the last couple of years and haven't gone down?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e894fc22f189dadcd7b06b797d9ff81d6dd3ebe2623956769e3ae1644b54bc2a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-427d25f6bd32ce838a6ebc18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104610,"date":"2026-06-16T17:25:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"According to Statistics Canada, 58.1% of people in Nunavut live in food insecure households, many of whom are your neighbours and people I've met. Kevin stands out to me. It's a very difficult situation. It's the highest rate in the country and more than double the national average. You didn't say this, but I'm going to. The Prime Minister said last year, \"Canadians will hold us to account by their experience at the grocery store, when they are paying their electricity bill, when they or their children are looking for a place to live.\" People might say, \"Look, food has always been expensive in the north\", but northerners took him at his word when he said he would be measured by the price of groceries, and it hasn't gone down; it has gone up. For me, that comes back to the second part of affordability, which is having the ability to buy food. It's one thing to have expensive food, but if you have a good job—and you and your wife have good jobs—you can afford a house and you can afford food. Even though it's expensive, it's affordable, technically. You spend a lot of time at a key piece of infrastructure, which you mentioned: the port of Iqaluit. It's a key part in building a vibrant economy in Nunavut. Could you explain the difference that the port of Iqaluit has made, maybe as a sealift business but even to making food cost less or making it more affordable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104610","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"According to Statistics Canada, 58.1% of people in Nunavut live in food insecure households, many of whom are your neighbours and people I've met. Kevin stands out to me. It's a very difficult situation. It's the highest rate in the country and more than double the national average. You didn't say this, but I'm going to. The Prime Minister said last year, \"Canadians will hold us to account by thei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["54b13c7897e7616fd1b9e1ff056fd7909790f14e38e888c2dd6c3228aa22b8c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bdabe811e0c31d94dbfdd16a13126d751f0bef119bc456ef9892234ebfee1a0d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39dde3527100a02e9ed2bdc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104611,"date":"2026-06-16T17:30:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thanks, Brian.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104611","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thanks, Brian.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4f9468e9af89668b90ae7b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104612,"date":"2026-06-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have some very brief questions for you, Brian. First, how much does a house cost in Iqaluit?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104612","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have some very brief questions for you, Brian. First, how much does a house cost in Iqaluit?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102600","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102600","label":"Birth rate","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ecda2e52205ea7536df0633a04f75eb077b2ff5f5cfe93b690b3690983a6ba4f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b445ad90e55e986b2bdc831","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104613,"date":"2026-06-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"You're not talking about a fancy house. This is pretty basic. I've seen your house. It's a nice house, but it's still fairly basic. To replace that house now, it would be close to $1 million.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104613","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You're not talking about a fancy house. This is pretty basic. I've seen your house. It's a nice house, but it's still fairly basic. To replace that house now, it would be close to $1 million.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","label":"Household equipment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9c2a2e94df7d9cdb4328780b8a5a394076dd7fe0c4c1cd449c97e80010550fcf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26923a245742244df959d6e5e08a06961325d3262acb6030f9e2a543076a7a38"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-473160566762faeac760afdb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104614,"date":"2026-06-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"That's if you can even find one to buy if you have $1 million to buy it with. It's a very challenged market for inventory.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104614","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's if you can even find one to buy if you have $1 million to buy it with. It's a very challenged market for inventory.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c35535e510a6f5e66a1af19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104615,"date":"2026-06-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I have a last quick question. I know this is tough to summarize, but maybe in 30 seconds, Brian, you could tell us your story. You have a really amazing story about how your family was almost couch surfing at one point. There was a pivotal change around housing that changed the direction, really, of the lives of your family. Could you explain it as best you can?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104615","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a last quick question. I know this is tough to summarize, but maybe in 30 seconds, Brian, you could tell us your story. You have a really amazing story about how your family was almost couch surfing at one point. There was a pivotal change around housing that changed the direction, really, of the lives of your family. Could you explain it as best you can?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da170a8430346fcf22f587f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104616,"date":"2026-06-16T17:45:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"I'll finish with this, because I know your story. Your dad became a tradesman and your mom is now an elected MLA. Congratulations to your mom. She was elected early this year. It really changed the whole outlook, even as a professional, and opportunities jobs-wise. It really was such a life-changing experience. I'll pass the rest of my time to Jamie Schmale. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104616","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll finish with this, because I know your story. Your dad became a tradesman and your mom is now an elected MLA. Congratulations to your mom. She was elected early this year. It really changed the whole outlook, even as a professional, and opportunities jobs-wise. It really was such a life-changing experience. I'll pass the rest of my time to Jamie Schmale. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3df02297c0e257581ab80a5c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104617,"date":"2026-06-16T18:00:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"Mr. Chair, can I just interrupt?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104617","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, can I just interrupt?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93305b075bdd1156a0311835","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1104618,"date":"2026-06-16T18:00:00+00:00","title":"INAN","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"INAN","text":"It's just for 20 seconds. I just want to thank all the witnesses for coming today. Brian and Inuaraq, I know it's very intimidating to sit in the hot seat, but you did a great job. Thanks, Merlyn. Albert Netser sends his best. He says you're pretty good, so you're good in his stead. Thank you, Chair, for having them today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/INAN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1104618","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's just for 20 seconds. I just want to thank all the witnesses for coming today. Brian and Inuaraq, I know it's very intimidating to sit in the hot seat, but you did a great job. Thanks, Merlyn. Albert Netser sends his best. He says you're pretty good, so you're good in his stead. Thank you, Chair, for having them today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b9ca27885e38a5fc0f7d2e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087234,"date":"2026-06-16T19:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bob Zimmer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as we can hear from my Quebec colleagues, obviously that was not a good answer to the member's question. \n\nLiberal government documents confirm that nearly 18% of the firearms being confiscated by the Liberal gun grab are .22-calibre rifles, often used to hunt gophers or to shoot pop cans. \n\nWhy are Liberals wasting hundreds of millions of dollars on .22s, or \"plinkers\", instead of millions of dollars on police officers to lock up violent criminals?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087234","member_id":"bc-mp-72035","member_name":"Bob Zimmer","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as we can hear from my Quebec colleagues, obviously that was not a good answer to the member's question. \n\nLiberal government documents confirm that nearly 18% of the firearms being confiscated by the Liberal gun grab are .22-calibre rifles, often used to hunt gophers or to shoot pop cans. \n\nWhy are Liberals wasting hundreds of millions of dollars on .22s, or \"plinkers\", instead of mi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ae619eff3e230bec61f828f0bfce3f316d2fd936350a9a84641d3a82621e0509"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e1738183e37f72e0a8741564adb3a1a29c3a217397aba4f0f9d4e1d780143eb6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-797b199259c4bfc6b6f9e020","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76925,"date":"2026-01-29T19:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I only have five minutes, but I am not going to take a lot of it.\n\nI will start by saying thanks. I want to thank all of my colleagues who contributed, not just today but in the first hour. To all of my colleagues who have been working on this for several years, either at the HUMA committee or in various ways, it is hard for me to explain why it has perhaps taken this long to get to this place. However, I am going to do everything I can to make sure this bill gets across the line.\n\nI especially want to thank the members who presented their own personal, individual stories. The fact that we have members in this House who could have benefited from this bill, who are willing to be vulnerable, get up and tell their stories, tells us how impactful this is for the more than 1,600 families this affects across Canada. I would like to thank them next.\n\nFor those families who have had this happen, I thank them for sharing their stories, which are not easy to tell. Those families told their stories not for their own personal benefit but for the benefit of the next family that may benefit from this particular legislation. For that, I say a real heartfelt thank you.\n\nI want to thank the Minister of Jobs and Families, the Minister of Finance and all of their staff who have helped work through various iterations of this bill and who will continue to work as we go through, hopefully, to the committee process and on to what I hope is third reading and royal assent.\n\nOf course, I want to thank the critics, both the old critic and the new critic in the Bloc and the critics in all the parties, for their communication and their work on this so far.\n\nFor the 1,600 families that would benefit from it, this bill would provide a simple and elegant fix. A Bloc member rose in the first hour and asked if this was a good measure, saying that it seems to have universal support but that they were concerned about the royal recommendation. They asked me if we had the royal recommendation. I answered honestly that I did not have it and needed everybody's help to try to get it.\n\nI am happy to update the House and say that I believe we have found a path to get a royal recommendation. However, it will require co-operation at committee, and we have to tie up a few loose ends. The required amendments are straightforward. They do not change the purpose of the bill; they simply ensure sound legislative execution. We will work diligently to make sure that is successful. The last thing we want to do is have another bill go all the way through and then not actually help those 1,600 families.\n\nI believe there is broad agreement in the House to move this quickly to HUMA. I do not think it will take long to study it. We could have it back in the House and actually, probably, have the bill wrapped up by February. We have the evidence and the stories. We have the solution right in front of us.\n\nFor the benefit of all Canadians and those future families who, in the most unfortunate of circumstances, might face this kind of tragedy, let us get this done. Let us use this moment to help those future families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76925","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I only have five minutes, but I am not going to take a lot of it.\n\nI will start by saying thanks. I want to thank all of my colleagues who contributed, not just today but in the first hour. To all of my colleagues who have been working on this for several years, either at the HUMA committee or in various ways, it is hard for me to explain why it has perhaps taken this long to get to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["effe7c396caffd8ebc45532e3c0d14b75aaae3ce30685b09d6617d202ba9ac48"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a81272a65ff075ada981308","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76926,"date":"2026-01-29T19:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I would like to wish you and everyone a good weekend, and I would like to request a recorded vote.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76926","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I would like to wish you and everyone a good weekend, and I would like to request a recorded vote.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc15fa15b5ccbe80b6b664c4807eaf217e7945aa01220db7a608ff2a5ba3c490"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c846cce4e82aee608c89ff3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109579,"date":"2026-04-16T16:05:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"HUMA","text":"I appreciate the ability to comment at a high level. I appreciate the work of everyone at the committee, from all sides and all party members, and I appreciate the complexity that has been brought upon all of us because of the unprecedented way that this is going through, as described by the chair when we started. At a high level, the way that I think about these amendments is that they fall into three categories: technical, timing and money. Technical are things.... Despite the wonderful drafting abilities of our wonderful Library of Parliament, it is impossible when you first start into this process—before the department has had its ability and the justice department has had its ability to look deeply into it—to understand exactly what it will affect and what unintended consequences there might be. Those are the technical amendments. Hence, we get a situation where the amendments can be larger than a one-page, double-sided bill. The second is to do with timing. We wanted to make sure that the department was given a specified time to be able to execute this as it goes through. This ensures that it's going to be within a six-month timing. I'm hoping that it's going to be faster, but if we do this today, we get it done before Christmas. The third is specifically to do with money and the requirements of the royal recommendation and to make sure that what is financially encapsulated in this bill falls inside what was already proposed in the annex of budget 2025. That gets us the royal recommendation. That gets this passed. That gets it to the Senate and, hopefully, gets it done before Christmas. From a high level, that's what we're doing today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109579","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I appreciate the ability to comment at a high level. I appreciate the work of everyone at the committee, from all sides and all party members, and I appreciate the complexity that has been brought upon all of us because of the unprecedented way that this is going through, as described by the chair when we started. At a high level, the way that I think about these amendments is that they fall into ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["de99ac6e78293367902d2f104b46f84466c807d63f4f89ca425587ab860be78d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-637eef82160f9ac3417da0ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109580,"date":"2026-04-16T16:15:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"HUMA","text":"No, it was not.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109580","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, it was not.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eed8a383471a4ded792f9189","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109581,"date":"2026-04-16T16:15:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"HUMA","text":"Thank you for the opportunity. I'm going to take this opportunity to speak to clauses 4 and 5. I've had conversations with all sides, and I understand the frustration experienced by all sides based on the lateness of the emergence of the amendments and the clauses thus affected. I would also defer to any of the professionals sitting next to me, who are all technical people, if they want to get into more details. In my understanding, both clauses 4 and 5 are redundant, and an additional flag was raised that, because death of a child would be incorporated into the definition and stillbirth is not affected by what we're doing here today, by incorporating that into the specific definition, you would actually be putting those rights at risk. Because it's unnecessary and would have an unintended consequence, I'm hoping both clause 4 and clause 5 will be removed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109581","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for the opportunity. I'm going to take this opportunity to speak to clauses 4 and 5. I've had conversations with all sides, and I understand the frustration experienced by all sides based on the lateness of the emergence of the amendments and the clauses thus affected. I would also defer to any of the professionals sitting next to me, who are all technical people, if they want to get int","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3cc039de54a6d74f9a97a077","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109582,"date":"2026-04-16T16:35:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"HUMA","text":"I super appreciate all levels of mom guilt, and I want to assure you that this is a feature and not a bug. There were discussions about this potentially taking longer, and I want to constrain that to a maximum of six months. I hope it can be completed much faster than that. I would also like to assure you that I've already approached a sponsor in the Senate. They were previously a pediatrician and are very invested in this. We've gone to all the different parties. I'm hoping we can get this through very quickly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109582","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I super appreciate all levels of mom guilt, and I want to assure you that this is a feature and not a bug. There were discussions about this potentially taking longer, and I want to constrain that to a maximum of six months. I hope it can be completed much faster than that. I would also like to assure you that I've already approached a sponsor in the Senate. They were previously a pediatrician and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f96bd7bcb7de04cbe76c7ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109583,"date":"2026-04-16T16:45:00+00:00","title":"HUMA","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"HUMA","text":"I'd just like to give a big thank you to everyone, including my colleague Mr. Richards. To everyone, this would not proceed in this very unprecedented way without a certain level of trust. I think that trust is here because of how important the issue is that we're discussing. You know, we're facing a lot of difficult things in this country. We all go back during the election and represent our relative parties, but at the end of the day, we're all on team Canada, and this was a team Canada thing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/HUMA/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109583","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd just like to give a big thank you to everyone, including my colleague Mr. Richards. To everyone, this would not proceed in this very unprecedented way without a certain level of trust. I think that trust is here because of how important the issue is that we're discussing. You know, we're facing a lot of difficult things in this country. We all go back during the election and represent our rela","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50d9ac0a7de03ff2680a8566","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034941,"date":"2026-05-29T18:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as we all know, our friend does not get enough time to talk in the chamber, so I have arranged for a literal \"choose your own adventure\" question, remarking both on his speech and also on his previous answers.\n\n On affordability, I know for a fact how much dental care, child care and the national school food program have helped constituents in my riding of Burnaby North—Seymour. On defence, the member talked about how we went from less than 1% in the Harper days to more than 2%, but he did not talk about how the economy has grown, so it sounds like we doubled the spending, but we more than doubled it. With regard to the Conservatives' saying that we are antidevelopment, we are actually at a stage where there is record bitumen production in Alberta, record royalties and record corporate profit.\n\nOn any of those three areas that the member would like to talk about, I would like to hear his ideas.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47808","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Royalties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034941","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as we all know, our friend does not get enough time to talk in the chamber, so I have arranged for a literal \"choose your own adventure\" question, remarking both on his speech and also on his previous answers.\n\n On affordability, I know for a fact how much dental care, child care and the national school food program have helped constituents in my riding of Burnaby North—Seymour. On de","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47808","label":"Royalties"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47808","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Royalties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","label":"Oral health","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47808","label":"Royalties","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["62b491a181a9144ec6f28d523c566dfd32d80c735f5937a27a36431bd8812346"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47808","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Royalties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a7f93e625f6dfd17efbb74cc4652f08bbaf2a3518b34e7332548f070c7ff6d5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47808","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Royalties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47808","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df8fa9c097e963743c2099f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034943,"date":"2026-05-29T18:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today with a profound sense of gratitude and purpose as we debate Bill C-222, otherwise known as Evan's law, at report stage.\n\nThis is a bit of a historic moment. Just two days ago, we officially secured a royal recommendation for the legislation. This marks only the fourth time in Canadian history that a private member's bill has received a royal recommendation and the first time it has ever been obtained through this specific legislative path. We were, in fact, joking about this just before the debate started.\n\nBefore we discuss the mechanics of the bill and the amendments before us today, we must remember why we are here. Legislation often deals in the cold realities of budgets, bureaucracy and statutory language, but Evan's law is fundamentally about compassion. It is about how our government treats Canadian families in some of their darkest moments.\n\nFor me, this is deeply personal. As I shared during second reading, my wife and I came incredibly close to losing one of our daughters during a difficult birth. Those 20 days we spent in the NICU gave us a glimpse of the heartbreak that is experienced by many families. In fact, we are still friends with many of the families we met in the NICU during that experience.\n\nSadly, for approximately 1,600 families in Canada every year, there is no happy ending. They leave the hospital without their child, and they return home to a government system that inadvertently adds to their unimaginable pain. Under the current rules of the Employment Insurance Act, if a child passes away while a parent is on leave, the parent legally ceases to qualify for parental benefits in that very moment.\n\nMembers can consider what this means in practice. In the midst of planning a funeral and grieving a profound loss, a parent is expected to contact Service Canada immediately. If they do not, they are subject to a financial liability that the Canada Revenue Agency will later claw back. Parents can switch to EI sickness benefits, which offer similar financial support, but to do so, they have to contact Service Canada every two weeks and prove that they are still grieving, to rejustify their need for support.\n\nImagine forcing grieving parents to repeatedly explain their tragedy to strangers every 14 days. It is a cruel and unnecessary administrative burden placed on people who are barely holding it together. In fact, we do not need to imagine this because we heard these stories during the committee appearances at HUMA.\n\nI have always believed that Bill C-222 sells itself. It is straightforward and compassionate, and it provides an elegant solution to a glaring bureaucratic failure.\n\nEvan's mom is a constituent of Burlington. As the two former ministers of Service Canada, the member for Burlington and I were well-versed in what was operationally possible within the department. We were careful to maximize the benefit for grieving families while simultaneously reducing administrative and incremental costs. It is one of those rare cases in government where we can do the right thing while reducing unnecessary red tape.\n\nFrom the beginning, we have had strong and early support from the Minister of Finance and ESDC. When we presented the framework to the Prime Minister last spring, it was very well received. During second reading, the debate was incredibly compelling and the bill was unanimously supported by the House. When the bill proceeded to the HUMA committee, the testimony we heard was extraordinarily moving. Many MPs commented that it was some of the most heart-wrenching testimony they had ever heard during a legislative debate.\n\nI want to give immense credit to our committee colleagues from all parties. When I first introduced the bill, I was honest that I was going to need help to secure a royal recommendation. I was honest that it was going to be difficult. The committee worked brilliantly and strategically to keep the bill strictly within its original scope so that it could survive the legislative process, paving the exact procedural runway needed for the Prime Minister and cabinet to officially support it with the royal recommendation that we have before us today.\n\nThat brings us to the amendments being introduced at this stage. As I promised in the House, I committed to working co-operatively to tie up the technical loose ends to properly execute this within the EI framework. The government amendments before us today do exactly that. \n\nRather than abruptly cutting off support, the newly amended framework would explicitly ensure that parental benefits can continue to be paid for the entire eligibility period, whether that is the 40-week standard or the 69-week extended window. It clarifies that these benefits remain payable even when the eligibility period has been extended for special circumstances such as hospitalization. Crucially, these amendments introduce a vital safety net. If a child tragically passes away near the very end of a parent's leave, when they have limited remaining entitlement, the amendments grant up to five additional weeks of benefits per eligible parent. This would ensure equitable support for all families, regardless of when a tragedy occurs.\n\n Furthermore, we are making corresponding amendments to the Canada Labour Code. We are extending job-protected bereavement leave to 17 weeks. This ensures parents will have the protected time off they need to access these EI benefits and provides additional flexibility for mothers whose maternity leave overlaps with their bereavement. \n\nMost importantly, we are addressing the cruel administrative burdens. The amendments introduce a regulatory authority allowing the Canada Employment Insurance Commission to establish a compassionate, simplified notification process, such as a basic attestation. This avoids forcing parents into biweekly reporting, while ensuring and protecting program integrity.\n\nI also want to address the fiscal reality of the bill head-on. While some costing estimates looked at payouts in isolation, they failed to account for the fact that many of these parents would otherwise switch to EI sickness benefits, which pay out a similar amount. Therefore, on a net basis, the measures are somewhat cost neutral. In fact, there are savings because the CRA will no longer need to chase down grieving parents for clawbacks. As well, by stopping Service Canada offices from having to process biweekly sickness reports, we are reducing administrative waste. We are saving the government money while delivering infinitely better services to Canadians.\n\nThis is a prime example of Parliament working exactly as it should, prioritizing compassion, focusing on practical solutions and working across the aisle to get the details right. My hope now is that we can move quickly through the House and through the Senate. It is my expectation that we will get this bill implemented before Christmas of this year. Once that happens, any parent who faces the unimaginable loss of losing a child while on parental leave will no longer face additional administrative cost pressures from our government. Instead, they will be given the time, space and support they need to heal.\n\nWednesday was a historic day, but we will not stop pushing until affected parents are directly benefiting from Evan's law. Let us pass this bill. Let us show Canadians that their Parliament can be efficient, smart, and above all, kind and compassionate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034943","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today with a profound sense of gratitude and purpose as we debate Bill C-222, otherwise known as Evan's law, at report stage.\n\nThis is a bit of a historic moment. Just two days ago, we officially secured a royal recommendation for the legislation. This marks only the fourth time in Canadian history that a private member's bill has received a royal recommendation and the first t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","label":"Workplace violence","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3bdb1816225a5f1a2ed934bd8a5b3da648fc8285da0138ea78eef40ce87978c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c50ead9c7277b441819b50f127b914dc418d6d776f4c160059d78b745d815394"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba85f0112a4d036d8f440e66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109574,"date":"2026-06-02T18:00:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"CIIT","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thanks to all the committee members. I'm a guest here. It's my first time at the trade committee, but I did do some briefings on all the work you've been doing on this subject in particular. I appreciate all the work that you guys have been up to. It's also nice to see how many familiar faces are around the table, quite by coincidence. Thanks to the witnesses. On your B.C.-based and family-based business, Mr. Zanatta, I really enjoyed reading up about the company. I hope committee members will forgive me for taking a more B.C.-specific track. Specifically, I'd like to talk to the chamber. This was raised briefly. British Columbia is the home of the digital supercluster for a reason. We're a hub not just for artificial intelligence, but for software, cloud compute—you mentioned quantum—cybersecurity, fintech, gaming, entertainment and digital services. If we think about the industries that have advanced the most since the last time we were taking on CUSMA, I would say that these industries, and particularly artificial intelligence, are probably the lead candidates. You mentioned the committee on cybersecurity as a potential opportunity. Could you take us through the opportunities for Canadian companies in this ecosystem and the potential threats, and what we should be taking into account that we might not have been thinking about 12 months ago, never mind five years ago or 10 years ago?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109574","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thanks to all the committee members. I'm a guest here. It's my first time at the trade committee, but I did do some briefings on all the work you've been doing on this subject in particular. I appreciate all the work that you guys have been up to. It's also nice to see how many familiar faces are around the table, quite by coincidence. Thanks to the witnesses. On your B.C.-ba","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["703c3eb7f0a0f15e759f1ab9c53ec0f6dac0834fc92afceef068ed4f1cb15d44"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9eaaebbb96b6bad8abba67505c82dff34d27c748114a284fd1e01923cfc32cbf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9cdb7fedf7b969f92cde9d0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109575,"date":"2026-06-02T18:05:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"CIIT","text":"Strengths, threats or opportunities....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109575","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Strengths, threats or opportunities....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a0a152c66722ff24d33fd60","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109576,"date":"2026-06-02T18:05:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"CIIT","text":"If I could guide you just a bit, it's not just thinking about AI and the technologies that enable that. There are specific attributes to digital goods and services in terms of market access and how those goods are delivered that allow for a certain scale and a certain level of competition. Is there anything that is specific to that industry with regard to that, where we might think differently than we would shipping a car across borders, etc.? Is there anything that we should be thinking about at this committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109576","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If I could guide you just a bit, it's not just thinking about AI and the technologies that enable that. There are specific attributes to digital goods and services in terms of market access and how those goods are delivered that allow for a certain scale and a certain level of competition. Is there anything that is specific to that industry with regard to that, where we might think differently tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04aaf1c3d9f823a48ba0438c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109577,"date":"2026-06-02T18:05:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"CIIT","text":"I'm the last person to ask questions and the chair is giving me the signal. I have seven seconds, but if I had another three minutes, I'd be asking you about biotech as well. Maybe that's for the next meeting. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109577","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm the last person to ask questions and the chair is giving me the signal. I have seven seconds, but if I had another three minutes, I'd be asking you about biotech as well. Maybe that's for the next meeting. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Biotechnology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Biotechnology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016066","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Biomedical experiments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016066","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Biomedical experiments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016066","label":"Biomedical experiments","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","label":"Biotechnology","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cbc297ae76cde966b5463b6700185efea007b665145521b417db47c74054dfb1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e635a8bea99d2378d1bc071","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109578,"date":"2026-06-02T18:05:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"CIIT","text":"Well, it's not quick. I would be getting into the details of the biotech ecosystem, and I don't think we could do it in less than a minute.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109578","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Well, it's not quick. I would be getting into the details of the biotech ecosystem, and I don't think we could do it in less than a minute.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017302","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Bioenergy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017302","label":"Bioenergy","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c513d73d6e4b6227dca2064bbfebc331284789e0fbbb0681c1a575259b3c983c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-91a4e675577ab96dfc67933c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083755,"date":"2026-06-02T22:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Terry Beech","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member for North Vancouver—Capilano will be deeply and profoundly missed in this House, on the North Shore, in B.C. and across Canada. We were nominated as neighbours within weeks of each other, and for more than 12 years, I have had the pleasure of watching his impact on our community and our country. The only solace I have is that Europe, the world and Canada get to continue to benefit from His Excellency's new position. \n\nHe did not do this alone. He is notorious for surrounding himself with the best people, and I thought he might want to take this opportunity to acknowledge some of the great Canadians with whom he has had the opportunity to work over the years.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083755","member_id":"bc-mp-89236","member_name":"Terry Beech","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member for North Vancouver—Capilano will be deeply and profoundly missed in this House, on the North Shore, in B.C. and across Canada. We were nominated as neighbours within weeks of each other, and for more than 12 years, I have had the pleasure of watching his impact on our community and our country. The only solace I have is that Europe, the world and Canada get to continue to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6381002d6ac38a9400dad77dee0d4606575ab45419328c26ba919817cec4a8a4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0870ded97b8a8b349063aced","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77897,"date":"2026-02-03T19:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives are united for hope. After 10 years of Liberal failure, Canadians are struggling just to get by. Groceries cost more, housing is out of reach, energy bills are up and crime is out of control. The Canadian promise that if someone works hard and plays by the rules they can get ahead has been broken. Conservatives are united to restore that promise. \n\nWhile the Liberals offer slogans and photo ops, Canadians are demanding real results, but the Prime Minister's rhetoric does not match reality. Food inflation is higher than ever, housing is out of reach, dozens of mills have closed across British Columbia and no new resource projects have been approved or built. \n\nConservatives are focused on delivering real solutions. We will lower taxes, fight inflation, cut red tape, build more homes and produce more Canadian energy, so we can stand on our own two feet. We are united for hope. We are focused on results, and we are ready to make life more affordable for the millions of Canadians who work hard and deserve better than what this guy is promising.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77897","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Conservatives are united for hope. After 10 years of Liberal failure, Canadians are struggling just to get by. Groceries cost more, housing is out of reach, energy bills are up and crime is out of control. The Canadian promise that if someone works hard and plays by the rules they can get ahead has been broken. Conservatives are united to restore that promise. \n\nWhile the Liberals off","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52e6e37084a60deb7ff746f9b53d79909e0e11026e9482edff3d4dea462ceebc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["944749b6a59aa13075d3e7f39eec163bd37b1555378998b377999f7a22800ff1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f2e32786232e3abb3e6b685","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77893,"date":"2026-02-04T21:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is interesting. The Liberals always stand up and say that Conservatives are obstructing. I will remind our colleagues, as they heckle me, that the House does not belong to them. It belongs to the constituents of the 343 members of Parliament, those who voted us in to be their voices in the House. Regardless of what they want to say, we will ask the questions that we need to. We will do the due diligence. \n\nI am hearing on the ground in Cariboo—Prince George that this benefit would essentially be just a coupon. The cost of groceries has gone through the roof. The Liberals are blind to this fact as they live in whatever fairy tale land they live in, but it is impacting our constituents immeasurably.\n\nWhat are some of the things that my hon. colleague's constituents are saying on the doorsteps when she is back in her riding of Haldimand—Norfolk?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77893","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is interesting. The Liberals always stand up and say that Conservatives are obstructing. I will remind our colleagues, as they heckle me, that the House does not belong to them. It belongs to the constituents of the 343 members of Parliament, those who voted us in to be their voices in the House. Regardless of what they want to say, we will ask the questions that we need to. We wil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b2c7f05c5a10f0d5a6b8c760c3e2bebe4c698bcb31d86c5da1a6aeada67b059d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15d57696e48a0ae4b77d97b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77894,"date":"2026-02-04T23:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that Bill S-233, An Act to amend the Criminal Code (assault against persons who provide health services and first responders), be read the second time and referred to a committee.\n\n He said: Madam Speaker, before we get going, my granddaughter is at home watching as we speak. If you will indulge me, I would love to say hello to my granddaughter, Ren, and to tell her that I love her and will see her soon. I know she is watching. At five years old, she is already watching CPAC.\n\nI stand before my colleagues frustrated. I am frustrated that we are here, once again, talking about an issue that is non-partisan.\n\n I rise today to speak on behalf of the hundreds of thousands of brave men and women who protect and serve our communities each and every day. They run into burning buildings. They run towards gunfire. They heal our broken bones. They hold our hands as we take our final breath. They are our silent sentinels: nurses, health care workers, firefighters, paramedics, EMTs and correctional officers.\n\nThese are the Canadians who hold our country together. When we dial 911, they pick up. They respond with no questions asked, yet for at least the decade that I have been here on the Hill, they have been asking for a single thing. It is that we protect them, just as they protect us. They put their safety, their comfort and their lives on the line each and every day when they go to work, and they do so knowing and expecting that they are going to face rising incidents of violence, assault and harassment. That is not part of their job description, and it is unacceptable. Nowhere in their job description does it say that they should sign on to a life of violence, abuse and harassment.\n\nIf colleagues can sense the frustration and the emotion in my voice, it is because I have sat with nurses. I have sat with paramedics who have had their lives threatened. I have sat with the families of first responders who have been killed on the job. All they are asking for is a simple thing, that we stand with them.\n\nIf some of this speech sounds familiar, it is because we have all been here before. My bill, Bill C-321, passed at all stages in the last Parliament. We studied it again because Bill C-321 was born out of a study from the first session of the 42nd Parliament, \"Violence Facing Health Care Workers in Canada\". All parliamentarians came together to say, with recommendations, that this bill, which was Bill C-321 in the previous Parliament and is now Bill S-233, should be passed, that we should be doing something and standing up for those who stand for us.\n\n I get frustrated. The message I got, which originally asked me to please refer to this document and put forth a piece of legislation, hangs heavy on my shoulders. It was a message from a paramedic who had responded to a call at a residence. The family of the victim proceeded to throw the paramedic down a set of stairs, break her ankles and beat her to the point where she gave up. If that sounds shocking to members, it is but one of, if not hundreds, thousands of messages and stories that I have heard over the last five years of pushing for this bill. \n\nWe have nurses who are running a campaign called \"Code Black and Blue\". The nurses launched a campaign against violence in the workplace. That was last fall. The Canadian Federation of Nurses Unions said that it cannot stand for this any longer. During its lobby days over the last decade, the International Association of Fire Fighters' number one ask was to do something against the rising acts of violence against them. Last Parliament, this bill passed at all stages, but what happened? Parliament was prorogued, so it fell off the Order Paper. This could be law today.\n\nWhen passed, Bill S-233, or Bill C-321, would act as a strong deterrent, a powerful deterrent, to those who would seek to commit violence against our frontline heroes. It would signal to first responders and health care workers that their Parliament values them, that we as leaders in our country value them, that we are looking out for them and that the justice system will protect them.\n\nNow, as it stands, a high percentage of those incidents go unreported because they know that they will not be followed through on. What would Bill S-233 do? It would amend the Criminal Code concerning assaults against persons who provide health services and first responders. It would amend the Criminal Code to make an offence against a health care professional or a first responder an aggravating factor upon sentencing.\n\nThere is always a time for partisanship in the House, but over my tenure, I have proven, I think, that when it comes to mental health, when it comes to standing up for those who stand up for us and who protect us, I will work collegially across party lines to get something done. I did that with Bill C-321. The NDP brought forth amendments. The Bloc brought forth amendments, and so did the Liberals. We agreed to them. That is why Bill C-321 passed.\n\nWhen we got back after the last election, Senator Housakos in the other House and his Liberal colleagues, Liberal senators or the independent senators, the former prime minister Justin Trudeau-appointed senators, got together and out of the ashes, they rose and supported Bill S-233 because they knew how important it was that we as a House send this message, that we as a House stand with those who put their lives on the line every day.\n\nI had hope, when it passed unanimously last fall, that we would be able to do something swiftly here in the House. I had hope because I believed in all of us, in the power of the 343 members of Parliament who were here. I believed the Liberals when they said that they wanted to work together to get things done for Canadians. However, every step of the way for the last three or four months, I have been disappointed. As a matter of fact, I have had somebody on the other side in leadership tell me that they guess we are just going to have to wait.\n\nMy friend, Paul Hills, a paramedic from Saskatoon, dedicated the last decade to trying to get something like this bill passed. I cannot tell members how heartbroken and disappointed he was when he worked across party lines to try to get something done, and then was told it was not going to get done.\n\nWe could have passed Bill S-233 in the waning days just before Christmas break, and it would be law today. The nurses, firefighters and paramedics, those who put their uniforms on every day in protection of all of us, would have that protection and would know that we stand with them, but no. Once again, partisan politics takes place. I have begged and I have pleaded. If any members in the House have watched question period before, I am almost down on both knees talking with the government House leader, pleading with him over this.\n\n I understand that there is precedence and so on, but the bill has been agreed upon and has been studied. We are going on six years. Ten years it has been asked for.\n\nWhen we talk about violence against our first responders and health care professionals, we are talking about real people in real communities: our families, my family. My youngest daughter is a psychiatric nurse. I get choked up talking about it because of the stories I hear.\n\nThere is no protection. They go to work every day simply trying to help others, yet they are increasingly being met with fists, knives, threats and abuse in return. Last fall a nurse in British Columbia was punched and kicked, knocked unconscious, simply trying to take somebody's blood pressure. In Ontario a nurse was attacked with a knife and a machete.\n\nAcross Canada the incidents of violence against frontline workers have surged. Nurses report being punched, kicked, spat on and threatened. Paramedics are assaulted while they are trying to save lives. Firefighters are attacked at emergency scenes. Correctional officers face daily threats, and institutions are already stretched beyond capacity. I do not even want to get into the nightmare they work in, because it is staggering. I would never want to do that. I think I can handle myself, but I would never want to work in that situation.\n\nIn many hospitals across the country, nurses will tell us that violence is now considered part of the job. That is shameful. Imagine if we had to deal with that each and every day. Would we come to work if we knew we were going to get punched, spat on or kicked, or have our life threatened? In emergency departments, staff are trained not only in trauma care but also in how to de-escalate physical threats. Paramedics now routinely wait for police backup before responding to calls that once would have been considered routine.\n\nFirefighters cannot not respond to dangerous situations. Regardless of what is presented before them, they have to respond, yet there is nothing backing them up, nothing that is protecting them in the eyes of the law if they are beat up, kicked, punched and so on. They are told very often that it is part of the job and to just move on. This is not normal, and it should not be accepted as normal, yet there are games that are going on in the House.\n\nI think if I can leave the House with any request for members, it is to please work with their party, with their side. I do not care if it has my name on it. I do not care if it has a Conservative name on it. I really do not. My request is for us to stand together and pass the bill.\n\nNo Canadian should go to work wondering whether they will come home safe at the end of their shift. No nurse should have to fear being attacked while caring for a patient. No paramedics should be assaulted while providing life-saving treatment. No firefighters should be threatened while responding to an emergency. No correctional officers should be injured simply for doing their job, yet that is exactly what is happening each and every day.\n\nThis is why Bill S-233 is so important and matters. The legislation, if passed, would send a clear and unambiguous message that when someone assaults a person who is providing health care or emergency services, that offence will be treated with the seriousness it deserves.\n\nWith the last bit of time I have left with the bill, I will remind the House why we are here: our nurses, our paramedics, our firefighters, our first responders. They lay it on the line every day for us. They get up every morning knowing they are going to experience life-changing events, but no one is there to stand up for them.\n\nI urge all members to please take it upon themselves to get Bill S-233 passed at all stages. We can work together on this. Lives depend on it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77894","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"moved that Bill S-233, An Act to amend the Criminal Code (assault against persons who provide health services and first responders), be read the second time and referred to a committee.\n\n He said: Madam Speaker, before we get going, my granddaughter is at home watching as we speak. If you will indulge me, I would love to say hello to my granddaughter, Ren, and to tell her that I love her and will ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","label":"Workplace violence"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","label":"Workplace violence","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["26e09a032616525773a4aa1814d86eeca7b66e53e08b76df546923de44bab799"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73fe949440688b07ff29890a45d088ff95d70dd3d729914a0f9629bcf80df53d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86962","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3796b674e0d3f1243b472a9f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77895,"date":"2026-02-04T23:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, as a matter of fact, we worked with the ministers of public safety and justice at that time on Bill C-3. In their own words, they said that Bill C-321 was complementary to Bill C-3, because Bill C-3 did not go far enough. The two bills, between them, covered exactly what we needed to do.\n\nIt is not a single line; it is a stand-alone paragraph when it comes to assaults. Bill C-3 did not go far enough, but Bill C-321 took it to the next level, which is why we took amendments from the Liberals, the NDP and the Bloc to get Bill C-321 passed. At that time, the minister of justice and the minister of public safety and security were in support of Bill C-321.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77895","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, as a matter of fact, we worked with the ministers of public safety and justice at that time on Bill C-3. In their own words, they said that Bill C-321 was complementary to Bill C-3, because Bill C-3 did not go far enough. The two bills, between them, covered exactly what we needed to do.\n\nIt is not a single line; it is a stand-alone paragraph when it comes to assaults. Bill C-3 did ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebb41dedcab9a2c3c0dd7414fa432a37816e5d3465f456a8aabb2b38f2ca27f1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2cfa83674bb84b550baeac2fc29a528202d46fd31513047001bcbde78edb4810"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a61f3df8d79a1262f7a5a805","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77896,"date":"2026-02-04T23:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, why do we need to do this? It is because each and every day, nurses, doctors, paramedics and firefighters put their uniform on and go to work, but trust me when I say that there will be lives lost. Somebody will lose their life; it could be a nurse, or it could be a paramedic in the back of an ambulance. The challenge we have right now is that there is not enough meat in the Criminal Code to ensure that the attacker gets charged at the highest level and that the full weight of the law is behind the victims.\n\n Bill S-233 targets a specific part of the Criminal Code that deals with assaults. It does not talk about 25 duties and functions; it is specific to health care workers and first responders over the course of doing their job. It is about an aggravating circumstance for assault against persons who provide health services and against first responders.\n\nThe bill needs to be passed now. Every day we delay is another life of a paramedic, a first responder or a nurse in jeopardy. We need to put teeth behind the Criminal Code and be able to stand with them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77896","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, why do we need to do this? It is because each and every day, nurses, doctors, paramedics and firefighters put their uniform on and go to work, but trust me when I say that there will be lives lost. Somebody will lose their life; it could be a nurse, or it could be a paramedic in the back of an ambulance. The challenge we have right now is that there is not enough meat in the Crimina","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["71e781a8a3f5c035f20023f089d1e8c61d5a61cdb89faf18d03e0bef85845273"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9a8de204d58e01b8a49b9d4d077866b1eafbe20288bb67d00c4bc3a35b8f2054"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78ea5d287f0c03cb3d3b0b56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287734,"date":"2026-02-10T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on November 25, 2021, a lone gunman circled the Vanderhoof RCMP detachment, spraying dozens of rounds into the particle board walls, narrowly missing the RCMP members working inside. They thought they were going to die that day. It is a miracle no one was killed. \n\nThe Liberal government promised it would stand with these members. It promised it would partner with the province and the District of Vanderhoof to build a new detachment, but five years later, the memories are still raw. The bullet holes remain, serving as a constant reminder of that horrific day. \n\nThe province is on board, and the District of Vanderhoof is on board, but the government is missing in action. Why is that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287734","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on November 25, 2021, a lone gunman circled the Vanderhoof RCMP detachment, spraying dozens of rounds into the particle board walls, narrowly missing the RCMP members working inside. They thought they were going to die that day. It is a miracle no one was killed. \n\nThe Liberal government promised it would stand with these members. It promised it would partner with the province and the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f17490523ca7f3781e3016592300330ce1ca44ad0a49e1cbf117ac99e549af5f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95b17f681bec81f3f4122753e6d8cf2cde3cde3a51207086f7117d175852a70e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-999f4b960d12b70032f7b71c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287733,"date":"2026-02-12T19:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this past Tuesday, innocence was lost. Not expecting the unimaginable horrific events that would take place that day, parents packed lunches and sent their children to school. Precious lives were taken, and many other people were injured in an act of devastating, brutal and senseless violence.\n\n Long after the political statements are made, the flags are raised and the cameras are gone, this day must forever be etched in our hearts and minds because the families in Tumbler Ridge are forever changed. They are now facing the unimaginable grief of silent classrooms, of empty seats around the dinner table, and of parents replaying the last goodbye and wishing they had held on to their child just a little bit longer or told them they loved them. The sorrow we feel is almost too heavy to bear.\n\n On behalf of the families in my riding of Cariboo—Prince George, many of whom, like mine, have friends and relatives in Tumbler Ridge, I extend our deepest condolences. To the students whose sense of safety has forever been shaken and lives forever changed, we are here for them. To the teachers whose courage and selflessness saved lives, to the first responders who ran towards danger to protect others, and to the nurses and other health care workers who treated the wounded, I say that they are truly heroes and that we owe them a debt of gratitude forever.\n\nIt is on us as a nation to wrap the community of Tumbler Ridge in our collective arms, to lift it up, to hold it in our hearts and to never forget.\n\nI say to my colleagues to hold their loved ones a little tighter today and never miss an opportunity to tell them they love them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287733","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this past Tuesday, innocence was lost. Not expecting the unimaginable horrific events that would take place that day, parents packed lunches and sent their children to school. Precious lives were taken, and many other people were injured in an act of devastating, brutal and senseless violence.\n\n Long after the political statements are made, the flags are raised and the cameras are gon","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["08853d5d622857024f179bf7688ae100ee6f89c562082a3b183ca6a8d0ff2c97"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d2137bcf9a0cec1a398fbb43fb3da23547cc05845bb35ec217bfc576b2c7991b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-accaa4a7754de40cf400c6af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306817,"date":"2026-02-24T15:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today with a petition signed by the residents of my riding and many British Columbians.\n\nSalmon is a critical resource for not only our province of British Columbia and our region, but also our first nations and non-first nations. The petition is signed by citizens and permanent residents of Canada who are calling upon the Government of Canada to keep the common property resource principle in the revised salmon allocation policy so that salmon remain a publicly managed resource, federal stewardship stays transparent and conservation-focused, and no single group is given exclusive control over access.\n\nIt is important to note that we must have fish for today, fish for tomorrow and fish for the future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306817","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today with a petition signed by the residents of my riding and many British Columbians.\n\nSalmon is a critical resource for not only our province of British Columbia and our region, but also our first nations and non-first nations. The petition is signed by citizens and permanent residents of Canada who are calling upon the Government of Canada to keep the common property resour","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","label":"Fish"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","label":"Fish","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b09140fd3b7688511782de66aa893f1c631fbf1fb08275484b0ff0fa55b4f91"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b555836487c467aa15df03d8c8b061402f177b17087d6a98af2705da90a559ae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fb4d0d318e5b9737a2c1a7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306818,"date":"2026-02-24T15:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, nowhere is this felt more impactfully than in our rural and remote communities. Over six million Canadians are without doctors. In our province of British Columbia, we have emergency room closures. We have OB/GYN teams that are absolutely abandoning our communities, and pregnant women are forced to go great distances to get help. \n\nAlmost $1 billion has been spent on illegal immigrants and such. That money could be spent to do incredible work in our rural and remote communities, as well as on my file of recovery centres for those facing mental health issues and addictions. Could our colleague comment on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306818","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, nowhere is this felt more impactfully than in our rural and remote communities. Over six million Canadians are without doctors. In our province of British Columbia, we have emergency room closures. We have OB/GYN teams that are absolutely abandoning our communities, and pregnant women are forced to go great distances to get help. \n\nAlmost $1 billion has been spent on illegal immigra","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["97852af5459a78716b9ac8aa5b7545abe1bef41a2b16cedd071db512a910eddf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fed5f3bb6792e3a34a0b19fbfce5ce9eff2ffd0a88ce4e5c9b8869019d000fe7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8d48c5171158f79186c164c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306819,"date":"2026-02-24T15:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of order.\n\nI would like to indicate, under Standing Order 43(2)(a), that the allotted speaking times of the Conservative caucus will henceforth be divided in two.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306819","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of order.\n\nI would like to indicate, under Standing Order 43(2)(a), that the allotted speaking times of the Conservative caucus will henceforth be divided in two.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9edb7dc0e02199909b62093c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306820,"date":"2026-02-24T15:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, our hon. colleague knows that he is to address his comments not to the gallery but through the Speaker. He continues to answer questions, and it goes back and forth. I am just saying that he should get back on track and direct his comments through the Speaker, not directly to the gallery.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306820","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, our hon. colleague knows that he is to address his comments not to the gallery but through the Speaker. He continues to answer questions, and it goes back and forth. I am just saying that he should get back on track and direct his comments through the Speaker, not directly to the gallery.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e668096be1d28d4bc771dbda","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306821,"date":"2026-02-24T16:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, there is a lot to unpack there. We can feel the passion from our colleague across the way. I do not think anyone is dreaming in la-la land, as our colleague across the way projected this morning.\n\nLet us look at what the motion of the text says. It merely states that the cost of the interim federal health program has more than quadrupled, from $211 million to $896 million, in the last four years. It is projected to rise to $1.5 billion. We currently have non-Canadians who are receiving treatment when Canadians who have paid into it all their lives are not receiving it.\n\nIn my province, there are wait times up to 18 months. As I mentioned earlier on, we have emergency room closures. We have pregnant women who are having to travel up to four to eight hours to see specialists because we do not have doctors who are available for them in rural, remote communities. Our health care system is broken. I think we can all agree on that. What we are asking is that the House call on the government to review federal health benefits provided to asylum claimants in order to find savings for taxpayers. The Liberals like to bring up the guy to the south whenever they want to strike fear into and divide Canadians. All we are saying through this motion is that a calmer, measured approach needs to be taken to fix our health care system, and our motion clearly states that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306821","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, there is a lot to unpack there. We can feel the passion from our colleague across the way. I do not think anyone is dreaming in la-la land, as our colleague across the way projected this morning.\n\nLet us look at what the motion of the text says. It merely states that the cost of the interim federal health program has more than quadrupled, from $211 million to $896 million, in the la","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd324b11c4ef8c0645df303549932c12927771e8a413bd5b61ce06f8e56af758"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["792ae419995d17aadf08dc45dba64b0745ccb0b6dd8662d5283c357e15ff5316"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0f35c0ee54ae3c34ee4144a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306822,"date":"2026-02-24T17:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have known our colleague for a long time, and I have a lot of respect for him. I expect him to do better. I expect him to not participate in the dog whistle politics that we are seeing from others down the way here.\n\n To sum it up, the motion simply says our health care system is broken. A considerable amount of money is being spent, yet we have Canadians who are without doctors. The hon. colleague and I live in the same province, and I know there are British Columbians who cannot get in to see a doctor in his own riding.\n\nWhat we are saying through this motion is that a sober second thought has to be given to our health care system. Would the hon. member not agree with that sentiment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306822","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have known our colleague for a long time, and I have a lot of respect for him. I expect him to do better. I expect him to not participate in the dog whistle politics that we are seeing from others down the way here.\n\n To sum it up, the motion simply says our health care system is broken. A considerable amount of money is being spent, yet we have Canadians who are without doctors. Th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012796","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Bioethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012796","label":"Bioethics","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["751d7de3172626579a6f73cd1a65da3bb19c808ff47c87b19b1ff5d23a674f1a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b5a5f6d65617b8dd5a7f9c86440a1dbcf4931b4338ba318ca257c3a43d7f9e0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9406a25314bf5ea77c6176e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306824,"date":"2026-02-24T17:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, an incredible point was just made, and for the first time today in all this debate. Those who are suffering are the immigrant communities, whether it is the six million Canadians who are without doctors or the incredible crime rates and extortion rates being perpetuated in our immigrant communities.\n\nI would like to ask our hon. colleague for the stories he has heard and why it is so important that we stand up for some of the most vulnerable communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306824","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, an incredible point was just made, and for the first time today in all this debate. Those who are suffering are the immigrant communities, whether it is the six million Canadians who are without doctors or the incredible crime rates and extortion rates being perpetuated in our immigrant communities.\n\nI would like to ask our hon. colleague for the stories he has heard and why it is so ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f6ca03401258837c260a664583d87bee88062ac0c8b83157b5b6d616996ef477"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5face2f238d6f3cc37969d1d6fa6095766c5b5329d7dbf241ee8e8d8e98e9673"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34c3f6c00494c8a011bbcdde","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306825,"date":"2026-02-24T18:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we are here today because over six million Canadians are without a doctor. Our health care system is broken, and I will add that the Liberals broke the system. It is those in our rural and remote and indigenous communities who are facing this. Do they know that between indigenous women and non-indigenous women in Canada, indigenous women are twice as likely to die from pregnancy-related deaths? Communities in British Columbia are missing OB/GYNs. They do not have access to them. Rural and remote communities are facing this. \n\nOur motion today is saying that the government needs to give it sober second thought and to rethink health care in our country. Will the member not agree that this needs to be done?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306825","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we are here today because over six million Canadians are without a doctor. Our health care system is broken, and I will add that the Liberals broke the system. It is those in our rural and remote and indigenous communities who are facing this. Do they know that between indigenous women and non-indigenous women in Canada, indigenous women are twice as likely to die from pregnancy-relat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0b45d63bea1b0339aa043a677abaaac89489f4e474515f487091d71ea3410a13"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8dc4e95feea549cb1b77e4a386bae0af4461c1e383f1040c54e01d9024528842"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d213b5ef001ae8e1e5713dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306826,"date":"2026-02-24T21:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know that my hon. colleague has done incredible work on the health committee. In our province of British Columbia, and I know our colleague is experiencing this in her region as well, we are seeing maternity wards that are closed down. We are seeing emergency rooms that are closed down because we do not have enough doctors. The assertions from the other side are that we are anti-immigrant on this side, which is completely egregious to even say. What we are against are known fraudulent immigrant cases, applicants who are jumping in front of veterans, jumping in front of everyday Canadians, jumping in front of approved asylum seekers and getting the health care treatment that the rest of those groups cannot get.\n\n I want to ask my hon. colleague if she is hearing any more information and stories in her own riding that she could share.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306826","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know that my hon. colleague has done incredible work on the health committee. In our province of British Columbia, and I know our colleague is experiencing this in her region as well, we are seeing maternity wards that are closed down. We are seeing emergency rooms that are closed down because we do not have enough doctors. The assertions from the other side are that we are anti-imm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["62b93a5511cd60948eb01e6fd5f19f4d541ad957994f89a3255bb35a196c522d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a64c58e1b2d288c10af121af18d712a5089170e863cb860d225904c9f44f883"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43e447482dcf95e5b02aaa57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034954,"date":"2026-05-25T16:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to first thank our colleagues from all sides who spoke to Bill S-233.\n\n I specifically want to thank two members. I thank the member for Barrie South—Innisfil for his service. What many people may not know is that he served as a firefighter for, I believe, 22 years. He served our communities. He knows first-hand the challenges firefighters face. \n\nI also want to thank our colleague for Prince George—Peace River—Northern Rockies—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!\n\nTodd Doherty: Mr. Speaker, perhaps I should wait until government members can settle down and listen.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034954","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to first thank our colleagues from all sides who spoke to Bill S-233.\n\n I specifically want to thank two members. I thank the member for Barrie South—Innisfil for his service. What many people may not know is that he served as a firefighter for, I believe, 22 years. He served our communities. He knows first-hand the challenges firefighters face. \n\nI also want to thank our colle","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a3d5cd7979d23cb4751f45e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034955,"date":"2026-05-25T16:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is indicative of what we faced with this bill, which is the disrespect for the hundreds of thousands of first responders, nurses and health care workers—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034955","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is indicative of what we faced with this bill, which is the disrespect for the hundreds of thousands of first responders, nurses and health care workers—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e641af66c49bf3fb065f3180","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034956,"date":"2026-05-25T16:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I started off by saying I wanted to thank our colleagues who have all spoken on the bill, specifically the member for Barrie South—Innisfil, for his service, and the member for Prince George—Peace River—Northern Rockies. Through a tremendously hard time in our nation, his leadership on the ground within his community of Tumbler Ridge has been really remarkable. He has been there for the families. He has been there for the community. He has been there for the nation. I thank him.\n\nWhy are we here? Why are we here if we cannot stand up for those who actually stand up for us and fight for us? We are here for the 500,000 nurses in our country, the 40,000 paramedics, the 100,000 firefighters, the 25,000 correctional officers and the hundreds of thousands of first responders who put on their uniforms every day, not knowing what they are going to endure in their service to our country, to members' families or to mine. They are all asking for one thing, to pass Bill S-233, to put protections in place so that they know that if they face violence when they respond to an incident, we have their backs.\n\nFor 10 years, the IAFF has been asking for this. It has been their number one lobby ask. For seven years, we have been fighting to get a piece of legislation through.\n\nI am embarrassed that we are here at this point. We had a bill that passed unanimously in the House and that passed in the other House but, because of the dissolution of Parliament, it did not become law. I want to thank Senator Housakos and Senator Yussuff. Senators from both sides came together last fall, saw the importance of the bill and passed it on all sides in the Senate.\n\nI want to thank my friend Paul Hills, from the Saskatoon Paramedics Association and the IAFF, who has tirelessly worked to get a piece of legislation through, a piece of legislation that would protect his colleagues in the hospitals and on the front lines as first responders. They face unbelievable acts of violence.\n\nThe bill has already been studied twice. It is born of the 2019 HESA report, entitled \"Violence Facing Health Care Workers in Canada\". It was studied in the last Parliament at both levels, the Senate and the House. Amendments were made that are reflected in the bill that we have today, Bill S-233.\n\nIt is so frustrating for me that we are here at this point. Last fall, the gallery was full of firefighters and health care workers. We thought that we had support from the House to pass this. Before I stood to ask for it, I was told it was not going to happen. I literally stood in front of the House leader, who is in the House right now and I begged and said that I do not care who asks. It could be from their side, our side or anybody's side. I do not care who asks for unanimous consent. All I care about is that the bill passes and that we can tell the firefighters, the first responders and the nurses that we have their backs. That is what we owe to the hundreds of thousands of first responders.\n\n I will just end with this. I carry a coin with me. It says that heroes are human, service before self and to never give up. I firmly believe and hope that when this comes to a vote in two days, all members will support the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034956","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I started off by saying I wanted to thank our colleagues who have all spoken on the bill, specifically the member for Barrie South—Innisfil, for his service, and the member for Prince George—Peace River—Northern Rockies. Through a tremendously hard time in our nation, his leadership on the ground within his community of Tumbler Ridge has been really remarkable. He has been there for t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["47cf89b463ab2ea6a2891cee1f2033e1628ec5fb3de29995504d48188a55b3af"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2013f4973905382a4a303a751345d82e7d990365b8aa8b1088d6391d25492f57"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-079cb2352734154e7f1cf0dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034957,"date":"2026-05-25T17:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to stand and ask for a UC, but I would request a recorded division.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034957","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to stand and ask for a UC, but I would request a recorded division.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bbc2f252f9f5842dafd247d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034951,"date":"2026-05-26T18:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on that point of order, Conservatives would support, maybe, during that amendment, the government's changing it for the rest of the year. This is a novel idea. That is why we are here today. While the government is amending the proposal, why does it not just waive the taxes for the rest of the year and support this motion?\n\nI have sat here and listened to the debate, and I apologize to all the people who are struggling to stay awake, not only here in the gallery but also at home watching, the 12 or 13 people who are watching on TV. This is so frustrating because the government says, \"Surprise. Do not worry; we are here to help.\" Then, of course, the real world sets in for those of us who live in rural and remote areas and know that everything the government has done, well, maybe not everything but most things it has tried to do, in the last 11 years has made life more difficult, especially for people who live in rural and remote areas.\n\nToday in my riding of Cariboo—Prince George, a family pulls up to a pump to get gas. When they see the numbers ticking away, they start doing the math in their head. They wonder what they are going to forego. They cannot go to the grocery store anymore and buy just 100 dollars' worth of groceries. How far will that go? A hundred dollars does not buy even one bag of groceries, especially in rural and remote areas.\n\nMy riding is over 90,000 square kilometres. We do not have the benefit of jumping on an O-Train or other rapid transit to get groceries or go to medical services. In my riding, the one thing my constituents know is distance. We have to drive if we want to get groceries, sometimes for long hours. In my riding, it sometimes takes 12 hours for me to drive to a single meeting. Can members imagine someone trying to get medical services for their pregnant wife or a sick child? They have to make painful and hard decisions as to what they are going to do.\n\nI remember when we had this debate in the last Parliament. When I was fighting for forestry and asking what I should tell the forestry worker who is now out of work, there was the audacity of the other side, saying to tell them to move and find another job. We do not have that luxury in rural and remote areas. My riding is resource-based and agriculture-based. Everything we produce in our riding is dependent on fuel and the cost of it. Who pays that price ultimately? It is my constituents. It is the consumer.\n\nThe government wants to stand up and say that it is giving a rebate and that, guess what, in June there is going to be a little bit more money in Canadians' pockets. However, while they are giving that money with one hand, they are taking it away with the other hand. The Liberals have made life so unaffordable.\n\nThe chief government whip said that he did not say this, but everybody heard him say it, or something like it: He will not vote for a motion that benefits the unbelievably rich.\n\nHere is the reality of what we are asking for in this motion. Let me remind the people who are in the gallery and others who are listening. The motion says:\n\nThat, given that,\n\n(i) gas prices are 13% higher in Canada than in the United States, equating to 22 cents more on average per litre,\n\n(ii) gas now costs 50 cents more per litre today than when global oil prices were at the same level in 2014,\n\n(iii) the Minister of Finance and National Revenue told Canadians on May 19, \"We have already acted\",\n\n(iv) Canadian families are still paying more to live due to a decade of Liberal credit card budgets, waste and mismanagement,\n\nthe House call on the government to offer Canadians immediate relief by ending all federal taxes on gas and diesel for the rest of the year, including the GST, and permanently scrap the Clean Fuel Standard.\n\n If they were really for Canadians, they would just scrap it. It is a common-sense motion. However, they will not. They say that Conservatives are bad and that the government has done a lot for Canadians already. Man, the government is so out of touch. This is my first time back in a number of weeks, due to a surgery, and I cannot say how maddening this is. In my recovery, I sat screaming at the TV because we hear the Liberal gobbledygook every day. They spew it.\n\n What is funny is the hypocrisy of it all. When they had Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, they were all for the carbon tax, but now they have seen the error of their ways. Now all the people on the other side have found a new messiah whom they are following. It is just maddening.\n\n The Liberals are so out of touch. Many of them, not all, have constituencies they can drive across in literally minutes. They have the benefit of rapid transit, such as the O-Train or SkyTrain or other rapid transit, but this is not true for those of us in rural and remote areas, where the Liberals' policies are absolutely punishing us.\n\nDo not even get me started on their \"jail, not bail\" and their catch-and-release policies. That is coming a bit later.\n\n In rural and remote areas, we are facing the wrath of Liberal policies, and the Liberals just do not get it. It is so frustrating. I believe there are good people on all sides of the House, even though I am getting scorned and mean-mugged right now by somebody on the other side who is staring at me. I do not care. He can laugh all he wants. He is laughing at the hardship of Canadians, and that is disgusting. Canadians should be angry and frustrated at this.\n\nRight now, my staff are probably pulling their hair out because they created a beautiful speech for me, but as members can see, I have not opened even one page, because I am so infuriated by what the Liberals are saying and doing.\n\n The reality is this: After 11 years, a decade, of Liberal mismanagement, the Liberals say they are going to do one thing, but then they do another thing. They apologize and say they will do better. Today their hon. colleague stood up and said, \"Oops, we made a mistake in rushing\", and they probably forced closure on it. In rushing the bill through, they made a mistake and want to amend the bill. Here is a simple amendment: When they are opening the bill back up, just eliminate the tax for the rest of the year.\n\nAn hon. member: Get 'er done.\n\nTodd Doherty: Get 'er done.\n\nMr. Speaker, it would benefit so many Canadians. I would stand up, and I think other colleagues would stand up, if the Liberals voted in favour of our motion, and applaud them. In the spirit of good faith and good nature, why does the government not do that?\n\n I know what the Liberals are going to say: \"We cannot trust the Conservatives, those dirty Conservatives.\" This is what they are going to say, but it is not true. There is one side that has been fighting for Canadians, and it is us on this side. It is frustrating that the Liberals stand up time and again and spew these talking points that somebody, short pants in the back room, has come up with. The colleagues across the way stand up and bring forth this stuff, and it is just maddening. It is just untrue.\n\n The Liberals' policies have hurt Canadians, especially people such as those in my riding of Cariboo—Prince George, over 90,000 square kilometres where we do not have the benefit of O-Trains, the SkyTrain or other rapid transit. We actually have to drive for critical services. The Liberals have targeted rural and remote areas. They have actually forced rural and remote against urban in their policies, and that is unfair. They should support our motion, and I hope they will.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034951","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on that point of order, Conservatives would support, maybe, during that amendment, the government's changing it for the rest of the year. This is a novel idea. That is why we are here today. While the government is amending the proposal, why does it not just waive the taxes for the rest of the year and support this motion?\n\nI have sat here and listened to the debate, and I apologize t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8cccbb8c99ac279963f52f48702c4416f322cf13abc531b26f6dddff544787f5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50b62e5765cc065a6d7fd7de33075fbf9ce9d73c5bd7cd409058419e2db8894e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31a9deeb35227abc95d7be97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034952,"date":"2026-05-26T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in the fall of 2024, a senior in Prince George returned home to find his house being ransacked and robbed. When he tried to stop the perpetrators, they ran over him, dragged him down the road and left him for dead. They were caught later that day and released just hours later. The victim's family has just been informed that the charges against the perpetrators have been dropped. They left him for dead, and they got off scot-free. \n\nWhen will the Liberal Prime Minister finally put victims before criminals?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034952","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in the fall of 2024, a senior in Prince George returned home to find his house being ransacked and robbed. When he tried to stop the perpetrators, they ran over him, dragged him down the road and left him for dead. They were caught later that day and released just hours later. The victim's family has just been informed that the charges against the perpetrators have been dropped. They ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d2e8ad5e4fe467350ae18d4228b8ef62e1defbf3541bd7fd68e668d364039e9a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["89d724aee63c47a8285572d19cd6f3c6d48b4b2b78fb04019310e1ecc8742b21"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-812f2dbaf6a4d54d1a602f1d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034953,"date":"2026-05-26T19:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the victim was run over, dragged down a road and left for dead, and the perpetrators are off scot-free. The victim now lives in fear that they are going to finish the job. He suffered broken ribs, flail chest and brain damage. He needed facial reconstruction surgery, and the perpetrators are free to do this again.\n\nUnder the Liberals, criminals face zero accountability. Canadians are fed up, and that is the government's legacy. \n\nWill the Prime Minister stand up today to commit to calling this senior, who is afraid for his life, and explain to him and his family why the perpetrators are off scot-free?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034953","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the victim was run over, dragged down a road and left for dead, and the perpetrators are off scot-free. The victim now lives in fear that they are going to finish the job. He suffered broken ribs, flail chest and brain damage. He needed facial reconstruction surgery, and the perpetrators are free to do this again.\n\nUnder the Liberals, criminals face zero accountability. Canadians are ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["666c3ff3f43810bdb1b89b179ac567a049ab04822a36111b6d171e18f672a99f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c7587965f56d0db3476ebde3f7df5e484ab39c0139403cbeaa8851fc3bcafeb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d437b07cb4de2738024232bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034944,"date":"2026-05-29T16:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this morning Canadians received deeply troubling news. According to the latest StatsCan data, Canada is now in a recession, with two consecutive quarters of negative growth. That makes Canada the only G7 country in a recession. In a global environment where all G7 nations are facing similar challenges, tariffs, war and global uncertainty, Canada alone has fallen into a recession. \n\nHow did we get here? It is because of the 11 years of Liberal policy choices that continue to stifle investment, block productivity and undermine confidence in our economy, choices like hiking the industrial carbon tax, maintaining antidevelopment legislation that discourages major projects and having a deficit that is double the size of Justin Trudeau's. \n\nCanada deserves better than a Liberal recession. We need a change, one that restores competitiveness, creates jobs, unleashes resource development, supports investment and puts affordability first, because Canadians deserve results, not more Liberal excuses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034944","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this morning Canadians received deeply troubling news. According to the latest StatsCan data, Canada is now in a recession, with two consecutive quarters of negative growth. That makes Canada the only G7 country in a recession. In a global environment where all G7 nations are facing similar challenges, tariffs, war and global uncertainty, Canada alone has fallen into a recession. \n\nHo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c1462659226ef930509d8f085432249afe5d57063d30f98fea2f906a3644988c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d9d411c6a467b37f1ab96b13b986115defed39bb54a3a84c087a97f7fc734da3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-114e6eeace060b65e4770cb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034946,"date":"2026-05-29T17:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, residents of Williams Lake are once again sounding the alarm about rising crime, street disorder, open drug use and repeat violent offenders terrorizing local businesses and families. Williams Lake city council is holding an emergency public safety meeting after RCMP reported more than 1,400 calls connected to the downtown core already this year.\n\nThe Prime Minister promised Canadians safer communities, but after 11 years, people in Williams Lake feel less safe walking down the street, less safe opening their businesses and less safe raising their kids.\n\n Will the Prime Minister stand in the House today and finally admit that his soft-on-crime policies have failed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034946","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, residents of Williams Lake are once again sounding the alarm about rising crime, street disorder, open drug use and repeat violent offenders terrorizing local businesses and families. Williams Lake city council is holding an emergency public safety meeting after RCMP reported more than 1,400 calls connected to the downtown core already this year.\n\nThe Prime Minister promised Canadians","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["778b444d8bdd29d44b1ecb3a2401e8b68093ca18e51454cef3f878efacb968ce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b53a1898dcb62bb7a3b68467ab5c5c939028138a5064b0fc7d0de7003086b618"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39b958c3ef2a1bcd0e800eb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034947,"date":"2026-05-29T17:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I do not know what fantasy world my colleague is living in, but there are bad people doing bad things to good people, and Canadians are fed up with it.\n\nI spoke this week about a constituent who was run over, dragged down the street and left for dead. The perpetrators got off scot-free. Williams Lake city council is actually considering sending all the criminals to another jurisdiction because of soft-on-crime policies. This is real.\n\nWhen will the Prime Minister admit that his catch-and-release experiment has failed to keep repeat offenders off the streets?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034947","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I do not know what fantasy world my colleague is living in, but there are bad people doing bad things to good people, and Canadians are fed up with it.\n\nI spoke this week about a constituent who was run over, dragged down the street and left for dead. The perpetrators got off scot-free. Williams Lake city council is actually considering sending all the criminals to another jurisdictio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-779f70078aadb8bcf106a4c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083759,"date":"2026-06-01T16:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to speak to Bill C-240, an act to amend the Criminal Code, to make related amendments to the Corrections and Conditional Release Act and to amend the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, more simply known as the offender rehabilitation act. It is hard to say this early on a Monday morning.\n\nI am struggling with what to do for the next 10 minutes. Do I read the prepared speech that my staff worked tirelessly to put together and did a great job of, or do I talk about our colleague and the importance of the bill she has brought forward?\n\n This bill is important. It looks specifically at three areas. One is in-custody treatment and rehabilitation programs.\n\n Another is earned release. The offenders, those who are in jail, would have to demonstrate that they are actually taking the measures they need to, with the responsibility on them, so that they earn their release. They would not, as my colleague mentioned earlier, just be waiting out the clock.\n\n The final area is harsher sentences for fentanyl traffickers. Very plainly, I truly believe that if somebody is producing fentanyl and selling it on the streets, the harshest penalties we have should be levied against these people. This is because, very simply, they are killing Canadians. Over 50,000 Canadians have died through our opioid crisis since 2016, and we do not have an answer.\n\nI talked about a senior constituent in my riding who was run over. He returned home to find his house being ransacked and robbed by a group of people who were addicted. They were looking to find ways to get that next fix. When he tried to stop them, they ran him over. They dragged him down a rural road and left him for dead. They were caught later that same day and released within hours. Just this past week, we were informed that the charges had been dropped.\n\n We are failing Canadians. We are not making communities safer.\n\n I want to talk about our colleague from Kitchener Centre. This is not an issue that attracts headlines. It is not sexy to talk about accountability, rehabilitation, public safety, addiction and criminal justice all at the same time. However, people who are in the gallery and the 12 or 13 people who are watching online or on TV should know the incredible story of our colleague. I met her just weeks after the last election, when she was a newly elected MP. She asked to meet with me. She wanted to talk to me about what she wanted to do during her time here in Parliament.\n\nWe have a unique platform to be able to really make a difference, regardless of whether we are in government or on the opposition side. We have worked for the last 11 years to try to make a difference to the mental health of Canadians, whether it was through our Bill C-211, making Canada the first country in the world to adopt a piece of legislation to combat post-traumatic stress disorder, or in launching 988, making Canada a country that now has a three-digit suicide hotline 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. Those are things that we did on this side of the House to try to make a difference.\n\nThe member for Kitchener Centre's story is incredible. Here is a member of Parliament who at one time was struggling with addiction herself and lived homeless on the streets for a number of years. She pulled herself out of addiction, put herself through school and is now a sitting member of Parliament, representing the very place where she was homeless.\n\nWhat an incredible story that is. It should be celebrated. What she wants to do in her time here is leave a legacy of change to help those who mirror her life as a youth, addicted and on the streets. It is incredible.\n\nThe reality is that our current justice system is not producing the results Canadians deserve. Across the country, communities are dealing with the consequences of repeat offenders, addiction-fuelled crime and an overdose crisis that continues to take lives each and every day. Canadians are frustrated because they see individuals cycling repeatedly through the justice system without change. They see offenders arrested, released, rearrested, released again and often returning to the same destructive behaviours the very same day. At the same time, they see families devastated by addiction and communities struggling with the consequences of fentanyl trafficking and organized criminal activity. \n\nI was talking about our colleague. The strength and courage it took for her to share her story is incredible. I have probably cried more times than I would like to count here in Parliament as we recounted our own stories or talked about other colleagues. I have also shared that my family has been impacted by the overdose crisis. My brother-in-law died by overdose. My brother is gripped with addiction and lives on the streets. We just cannot seem to get him off the streets. We have struggled since the nineties. We say a cat has nine lives. I do not know how many lives my brother has. He has had so many overdoses, he has been in and out of the jail system and he was shot with a double-barrelled shotgun recently, and he still survives. The grip of that addiction still pulls him back onto the streets.\n\nWhen people are arrested and go into the jail system, there is not a lot of incentive for them to get better. As a matter of fact, they probably become better criminals and just bide their time until they get out. They can get the drugs in prison, as well, but through Bill C-240, it would become mandatory that those who are incarcerated and addicted take the measures and take on the responsibility necessary to get themselves better. That is why Bill C-240 is so important.\n\nRegarding in-custody treatment, we talk about how there are not enough beds in our country to get people well. We should be investing in recovery, not investing in perpetuating people's addictions, which is what we have been doing over the last 10 years. We need in-custody treatment. That could include addiction treatment. It could include educational programs. It could include jobs training and skills development.\n\nI spent an awful lot of time talking about our colleague, but I honestly do not think we have shared her story enough. She works every day, representing her constituents of Kitchener Centre, being a better MP, being a better representative and ensuring that she leaves a legacy of change. I am so honoured to count her as one of our colleagues. I am proud of her, as everyone can tell.\n\nBill C-240 looks at three distinct areas in this piece of legislation. One is in-custody treatment and rehabilitation programs. Another is earned release, so the responsibility would be on the incarcerated person to demonstrate that they deserve parole. They would not just get it. The last is harsher sentences for fentanyl traffickers, because if we do not start doing something about our opioid crisis, we will continue going down the same path we are on, and more Canadians will die.\n\nI support Bill C-240 and humbly ask that our colleagues do as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083759","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to speak to Bill C-240, an act to amend the Criminal Code, to make related amendments to the Corrections and Conditional Release Act and to amend the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, more simply known as the offender rehabilitation act. It is hard to say this early on a Monday morning.\n\nI am struggling with what to do for the next 10 minutes. Do I rea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["54d82d258af3ac4175e696697566ecc210eee84bc55183582a4e5388c313a1b8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["54d318c3b41d8df5e95311102c3f9f9042668bf68ad97dcad07c3c70022b4c6b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-079ea707deefb0acfb9a7e47","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083756,"date":"2026-06-05T16:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is my favourite season of the year, rodeo season, in Prince George, Quesnel, Vanderhoof, and in my hometown, the greatest show on dirt, the Williams Lake Stampede.\n\nThe dust is rising, the countdown's on, And before you know it, rodeo season will be gone.From near and far for 98 years,They've packed the stands for the sweat and the tears.The Williams Lake Stampede is second to none,The roping, the riding, the legendary fun.Where the cowboys ride, and cowgirls fly, And city folks learn about dust in the eye.The Williams Lake Stampede is more than a show—It's community, tradition, and full-blown rodeo!To the volunteers, competitors, handlers, and sponsors too,We tip our hats for all you do.If I've said it once I'll say it again,You son of a gun,We're the best there's ever been!It's the bulls and the blood, it's the dust and the mudIt's the roar of a Sunday crowdIt's the boots, the chaps, and the cowboy hats And they call the thing rodeo.Yee-haw!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083756","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is my favourite season of the year, rodeo season, in Prince George, Quesnel, Vanderhoof, and in my hometown, the greatest show on dirt, the Williams Lake Stampede.\n\nThe dust is rising, the countdown's on, And before you know it, rodeo season will be gone.From near and far for 98 years,They've packed the stands for the sweat and the tears.The Williams Lake Stampede is second to no","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3802eeeb6401e5f575f77c82","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083757,"date":"2026-06-05T16:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, every Liberal campaign is on the Prime Minister being the man with the plan and an economic genius. However, under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country to fall into a recession. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has now confirmed that there is less than a 1% chance the government will meet its own fiscal anchor. \n\nAfter an economic decline in three of the last four quarters, he cannot even tell us whether we are in a recession or a technical recession, so I will ask again: Which one is it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083757","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, every Liberal campaign is on the Prime Minister being the man with the plan and an economic genius. However, under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country to fall into a recession. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has now confirmed that there is less than a 1% chance the government will meet its own fiscal anchor. \n\nAfter an economic decline in three of the last f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["02c826ee2331f0f28211e8c67878cc573f804fd9f0111c2f0f1b7993720e6aae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["547c59ef29a8ab73859b8efc2fa47b34aafbbbb3bddd3bbd0dd2cf5605456166"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e563adf12b0a62a27aedf82c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083758,"date":"2026-06-05T16:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, as a British Columbian, the member knows that more British Columbians are out of work because of the Liberal government. The Parliamentary Budget Officer is sounding the alarm, saying businesses are postponing expansion plans and investing elsewhere. Under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country to fall into a recession and Canadians are paying the price. \n\nIf it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it probably is a duck. I will give the Prime Minister one more chance. If he is the economic genius he says he is, will he stand and tell us whether we are in a technical recession or a recession?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083758","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, as a British Columbian, the member knows that more British Columbians are out of work because of the Liberal government. The Parliamentary Budget Officer is sounding the alarm, saying businesses are postponing expansion plans and investing elsewhere. Under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canada is the only G20 country to fall into a recession and Canadians are paying the price. \n\nIf it ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","label":"Birds","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","label":"Wildlife","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3bdbbd47cb2c8c66bcc0d539e6c7e59f2864147c7e6e2bdef7a83c661f4fc4e2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-38d2fb589a922f2597ddac48","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085678,"date":"2026-06-12T15:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Motion No. 12, a motion that would dramatically curtail Parliament's ability to properly scrutinize Bill C-30, the Liberal budget implementation act. \n\nThe government says it wants to move quickly, but Canadians want us to move carefully. When Liberals ask Parliament to fast-track another budget bill and limit scrutiny, Canadians have every right to ask a simple question: What has the last decade of Liberal economic management delivered for ordinary families? When I return home to Prince George, Vanderhoof, Quesnel, Williams Lake, 100 Mile House and the communities throughout Cariboo—Prince George, I do not hear people saying that life is more affordable than it was 10 years ago. I hear quite the opposite. I hear from young families that have given up the hope of home ownership. I hear from seniors who never imagined that they would have to worry about affording groceries after a lifetime of work. I hear from small business owners struggling with rising costs and shrinking margins. I hear from forestry workers worried about whether their mill will still be operating next year. I hear from the hundreds, if not thousands, of forestry workers who are now out of work because of mill closures that happened under the Liberal government.\n\n The simple fact is that after 11 years of Liberal management, Canadians are not better off. Our communities are being punished. Rural and remote communities, specifically, are being punished with the catch-and-release policies. It is getting harder and harder for Canadians to make ends meet. I stand in this House, day in and day out, and I champion those in my riding and across Canada who are facing hardship and who are facing mental health crises and addiction crises that have not been seen in generations. Since 2016, more Canadians have died from overdose than in World War II. It is hard to sit and listen, whether I was at home in recovery or here in the House, to the talking points from the other side. \n\nWe have a former Conservative colleague, now on the other side, who just gave a speech for 10 or 15 minutes with the Liberal talking points. It is a sad day for me, because I was elected with her. I have a lot of respect for her, but now we see her kind of changing her tune and spewing the very things that we fought against. \n\nThe truth of the matter is that over 2.5 million Canadians are using food banks every month. More and more Canadians are a paycheque away from insolvency or bankruptcy. It is getting harder and harder for Canadians to make ends meet or to live that Canadian dream. It is hard to sit and watch and listen to the talking points being spewed. I have said it before, and I will say it again. I am not quite sure of the world that some of my colleagues live in. It is hard. In British Columbia, we have had over 35 mills close in the last 10 years, many of those in my riding of Cariboo—Prince George. Those are high-paying, generational jobs. Many of those mills have been operating for a number of years, with generations of a single family working in the same mill because it is a great job. They were the number one employer in most of our communities. When those mills close, there is not another major industry coming behind them.\n\n What the Liberal government has created over the last 10 years is not an environment where we are open for business. It is an environment where investors really, truly question whether they want to invest in our country and where we have major producers looking elsewhere to relocate their businesses. That is the reality we live in. We talk about the last election, and the Liberals say this is a new government with a man with a plan. The Prime Minister was elected as being the man with the plan. He comes with a pretty impressive résumé, I will say that. However, everywhere he has gone, he has left a wake of economic devastation.\n\nWe are the only G7 country and the only G20 country that is currently in a recession. Now, people will say, \"What is the G7?\" We always talk about these acronyms. It is a packed gallery here on a Friday, and I know that the viewership goes up when they hear that the member for Cariboo—Prince George is speaking, every time, so the bandwidth is just crazy right now. People are definitely going to be smarter at the end of this speech. There are no two questions about that. \n\nWe talk about the group of seven, the G7. Let me just tell those at home what this means, in case anyone is confused about it. The G7 is a coalition of countries that share core values: pluralism, liberal democracy and free market capitalism. They meet annually to coordinate global economic policy. Members include Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom and the United States. We are the only G7 country in that list that is technically in a recession. We cannot figure out whether it is a technical recession or whether we are actually in a recession. As I have said before, if it walks like a duck and it quacks like a duck, it probably is a duck. If we are technically in a recession, we are in a recession.\n\nWe talk about Canada being the only G20 country that is in a recession. What is the G20? Well, it is the same as the G7 countries, plus Argentina, Australia, Brazil, China, India, Indonesia, Mexico, Russia, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, South Korea and Turkey. Canada, once again, is the only country out of that mix that is in a recession.\n\n The Liberals will stand up and say that their plan is working. Was their plan for us to fail? It is not working. They can be tone-deaf. They can be ignorant of the facts. However, the facts are these: More businesses are fleeing our country; more jobs are fleeing our country, regardless of whether they say the job numbers are up or not; and more Canadians are lining up at food banks. That is the truth. There is no misinformation or disinformation or whatever they want to say. It is reality. Food banks all across our country are saying that they are in dire need because more and more Canadians are accessing their services.\n\nWe talk with those on the ground. In Prince George, the food banks and community organizations are facing demand levels that would have been unimaginable a decade ago. The Salvation Army in Prince George reported unprecedented demand and significant increase in food bank usage, with many clients citing the rising cost of food, rent, utilities and fuel as the reason they needed help. Think about that. People who have worked their entire lives, people who never thought they would need assistance, people who did everything society asked of them, today are lining up for food hampers because the cost of living has risen faster than their paycheques.\n\n Nationally, food bank visits have reached nearly 2.5 million in a single month, the highest number ever recorded in Canadian history. Food bank usage has doubled since 2019. Many of those seeking assistance are actually employed Canadians who simply cannot keep up with the rising costs. What does that say about the state of the country, when people working full-time jobs cannot afford groceries? What does it say when families are skipping meals so that their children can eat? I know it is happening all across our country. We see the number of encampments of RVs that people are being forced to move into. They cannot afford a home and they cannot afford rent, so they are moving into these rest areas in RVs, or tents in some cases.\n\n That is the reality. It is not misinformation; it is not disinformation. I ask any of those who are paying attention today to take a look around their neighbourhood and take a look around their community. Does it look the same as it did 10 years ago, or is their community, like mine and many others, riddled with crime and addiction? It is absolutely heartbreaking. There are people on the streets in a state of overdose or in some form of addiction or mental health crisis, and it has almost become the norm. People just walk by it, when normally they would want to stop and help. Many times I do not know whether a person is alive. It is unbelievable.\n\n What does it say when a food bank has become a permanent part of household budgeting? This is not the Canada that previous generations built. Housing tells a similar story. For generations, home ownership represented the Canadian dream. People worked hard, saved their money and eventually bought a home. Today, many young Canadians have stopped believing that this dream is achievable. Many young Canadians have had to move back home into their parents' basement. People worked hard, saved their money and eventually bought a home. Now they cannot. Now they do not see that dream as possible.\n\n I recently spoke with a young couple in Prince George. Both have great jobs. Both are responsible. Both have done everything right, yet they feel like they are running on a treadmill. Every month they save money, but every month housing costs seem to rise even faster. The down payment they need keeps moving further and further away. They are not asking for a handout. They are just asking for a chance. They are asking for the same opportunity their parents and grandparents had. Unfortunately, after 10 years of costly Liberal policies, that opportunity is becoming increasingly difficult to find.\n\n I touched a little on the forestry sector earlier. Few regions understand the consequences of economic mismanagement better than northern British Columbia. Where I come from, forestry is so much more than just an industry. It is families. It is communities. It is minor league hockey team sponsorships. It is swim team sponsorships. It is high school sponsorships. When forestry dollars are earned, forestry dollars are spent in the communities they are earned in, and when those businesses go out and those jobs are lost, those dollars are no longer in those communities.\n\nOur region has absolutely been decimated. I rose in the House last fall to talk about 100 Mile House, a community in my riding that lost its last mill, which represented half of its municipal tax base. When a forestry job is lost, it is not just that job. If their spouse is a teacher or a nurse, those jobs are lost when they leave our communities. When they leave our region, they are not coming back, because there is nothing there for them.\n\n Entire towns are built around the jobs that forestry provides. Over the past 10 years, forestry communities have faced uncertainty, curtailments, shutdowns and job losses. In late 2025 alone, temporary closures and curtailments affected hundreds of workers in Prince George, Vanderhoof, Quesnel, Williams Lake, 100 Mile House and all areas in between. Those are all communities in my riding.\n\n In the last 10 years, we have seen thousands of job losses. Our forestry industry, once a cornerstone industry in our country, has been all but decimated by this government. It has honestly been 10 years of mismanagement. I do not think there is anybody on that side who can say that they have handled the forestry file correctly. When the Liberals took office in 2015, there was a one-year grace period on the softwood lumber agreement that our former Conservative government had negotiated. The Conservatives put to bed one of the longest-standing trade disagreements with our U.S. counterparts and negotiated a one-year grace period, knowing that 2015 represented an election year.\n\nThe former Conservative government got that agreement, literally, if anyone is a sports fanatic like I am, to the one‐yard mark. The next government, whichever that was, just needed to get it into the end zone. It was there for the taking. I stood in the House for my maiden speech. I reminded the new government at that time of the importance of this. I said, \"If this is not secured in the one year, in the grace period that you have, we are going to face the downfall of an industry. Now is the time.\" We were told at the time that there was a new‐found bromance between the incoming, new Prime Minister and the U.S. administration at that time, and that they had it handled. \"Don't worry about it. We've got it handled.\"\n\nTen years later, we are seeing a cornerstone industry in our country absolutely decimated. There were job losses in the tens of thousands, not just in my province of British Columbia, where softwood was the number one export at one time. Over 65% of our softwood lumber exports went to the U.S., and the industry was decimated. Now we have a president in the United States who is saying that they do not need anything from Canada, as things have gone sideways.\n\nWhen the Liberals say that their plan is working, it is so frustrating. I guess their plan was total economic destruction, Every time a shift is lost, a family feels it. Every time a mill closes, local businesses feel it. Every time a forestry job disappears, a community loses part of its economic foundation, yet the government comes to this House and says we should spend less time examining legislation that will affect the economy. That is exactly ass‐backwards. After 10 years of rising costs and economic uncertainty, Parliament should be asking more questions, not fewer. We should be demanding more accountability, not less. We should be examining every dollar of spending, every new program and every economic proposal with greater scrutiny than ever before.\n\nThe owners of small businesses in Williams Lake review every invoice before they sign it. The ranch near 100 Mile House reviews expenses before making a major purchase. A family in Quesnel studies its household budget before taking on new debt, yet somehow the federal government believes Parliament should spend less time reviewing legislation that affects billions and billions of taxpayer dollars. It makes no sense.\n\nNow the Liberals say they want to work collaboratively. They say they are working for the people, and they invite collaboration from all sides. However, we have seen quite the opposite. Once they got their false majority, committees were shut down and filibustered. We see more and more time allocation motions, such as the one that we are debating today. There is no collaboration. They say they need to rush this through, and they talk about the obstructionist Conservatives and opposition. The government has a majority. It controls the legislative calendar. The government controls when bills are introduced. The government controls its priorities. After creating the timetable, it now wants Parliament to surrender its responsibility to scrutinize the details. That is not accountability, that is not transparency and that is not good government.\n\nWhen I go home to Cariboo—Prince George, nobody tells me, \"Todd, stop asking questions.\" Nobody says that we should vote faster. What they tell me is that groceries cost too much, housing costs too much, fuel costs too much and life costs too much. They want someone in Ottawa to ask hard questions on their behalf. That is why this motion is so troubling. After 10 years of Liberal economic management, Canadians have earned the right to expect more scrutiny, not less.\n\nIf the government's economic plan is sound, it should survive debate and hard questions. If its spending priorities are justified, they should survive a committee review. If its legislation is well crafted, it should survive amendment and examination. Accountability should never be viewed as an inconvenience. It is the very reason Parliament exists.\n\nAt its core, this debate is about accountability. It is about whether Parliament will continue to fulfill its constitutional responsibility to examine legislation, challenge government spending and ensure that Canadians receive value for the billions and billions of dollars being taken from their pockets. Let me remind those in this House and those listening that the money being spent is not the government's money. It is taxpayer dollars. Unfortunately, this motion moves us in the opposite direction. The Liberal government is once again asking Parliament to surrender its ability to carefully examine legislation. It is asking members to accept less debate and less committee scrutiny, to accept fewer opportunities for amendments and to identify mistakes before they become law. That should concern every member of this House, regardless of political affiliation. \n\nLet me remind this House and those listening, and I say this often in my speeches, this House is not ours. This House belongs to Canadians, those who elected us to be here to speak on their behalf, represent them, scrutinize the government and provide support where necessary, but to challenge the government. This House is not the government's House. It belongs to those in the gallery and those watching from all across our country. Committees exist for a reason. Debate exists for a reason. Committees are where legislation receives detailed examination. They are where experts testify. They are where stakeholders identify unintended consequences of poor legislation. They are where parliamentarians from all parties can propose amendments and improvements to legislation.\n\nThe government now proposes to impose an artificial deadline on the finance committee study of Bill C‐30, and if the committee members have not completed their work by a predetermined hour, all remaining amendments would simply be deemed moved and voted upon without further debate. Let us think about that for a moment. Regardless of how many clauses or amendments remain, regardless of how many concerns experts or stakeholders have raised, regardless of how many concerns Canadians have raised, regardless of whether parliamentarians have had the opportunity to fully disclose and discuss those proposals, the Liberal government wants the process to stop and votes to begin, essentially silencing the Canadians and stakeholders who elected us to be here. This is not the thoughtful law‐making that Canadians expect from their Parliament.\n\nBill C‐30 is not a minor piece of legislation. Like many budget implementation acts before it, it contains numerous measures affecting Canadians, businesses, taxpayers and communities across the country. When legislation is broad in scope, scrutiny becomes more important, not less. The larger the bill, the greater the need for committee review. The more spending involved, the more questions are needed. The more power that is granted to the government or the ministers to make decisions without scrutiny, the more oversight should occur. Instead, the government is proposing exactly the opposite.\n\nCanadians are being told that Parliament should simply hurry up and approve legislation. That is not how a responsible government works. Parliament should not just act as a rubber stamp. Members of Parliament are not spectators. We are sent here to ask questions, challenge assumptions and ensure taxpayer dollars are spent wisely. When governments become impatient with accountability, Canadians should start paying attention, because accountability is not an inconvenience. It is the very foundation of parliamentary democracy. \n\nCanadians are already struggling. Families are struggling with affordability, businesses are struggling with uncertainty and communities across northern and rural Canada are struggling with economic pressures, labour shortages and declining opportunities. \n\n People want to know how their government intends to spend their money. They want to know whether programs are effective and they want to know whether commitments made in Ottawa will actually deliver results on the ground. \n\nCommittee study helps answer those questions. This motion would limit those opportunities. \n\nThe government argues that legislation must move quickly. However, whose fault is it when Parliament is presented with a massive omnibus piece of legislation requiring extensive examination? Whose fault is it when complex measures are bundled together? Whose fault is it when committees are given insufficient time to hear witnesses and review evidence? Whose fault is it when Canadians are not heard? \n\nThe answer is obvious. Governments control their legislative agenda and control the timing of legislation. Governments determine when bills are introduced. Time and again, Liberal governments create their own scheduling problems and then use those problems as justification for limiting parliamentary scrutiny. \n\nThat pattern has become all too familiar. Whenever questions become uncomfortable, debate is shortened. Whenever scrutiny becomes inconvenient, deadlines are imposed. Whenever opposition members attempt to improve legislation, procedural tools are used to limit discussion. \n\nCanadians deserve better. \n\nThere is another important principle at stake. Good legislation benefits from criticism. Strong legislation survives scrutiny. Effective legislation is improved by debate. Governments should welcome examination if they are confident in their proposals. Instead, this motion suggests that the government sees scrutiny as an obstacle rather than a safeguard. That is troubling. \n\nEvery member of the House has seen examples of legislation that required amendment after flaws were discovered. Every member has seen examples where witness testimony highlighted concerns that government had overlooked. Every member has seen examples where committee work improved legislation. That work becomes more difficult when Parliament is placed under a procedural guillotine. \n\nRepresenting northern British Columbia has taught me an important lesson. People do not expect perfection from the government and do not expect transparency. However, they do expect accountability and they do expect their elected representative to ask tough questions before billions of taxpayer dollars are committed. \n\nWhether someone lives in Prince George, Quesnel, Williams Lake, Vanderhoof, Lone Butte, 100 Mile House, Horsefly, Likely or any other community I represent, they understand a simple principle: When someone asks for more money, people deserve to know how it will be spent. The same principle should apply here. The government should welcome scrutiny. It should welcome questions. It should welcome accountability. Instead, government Motion No. 12 seeks to reduce all three. \n\nThe House should be very cautious whenever a government asks Parliament to do less of its most important work. Debate matters, committee study matters, amendments matter and accountability matters. Parliament exists to examine legislation on behalf of Canadians, not merely to accelerate government timelines. \n\nFor those reasons, I cannot support this motion. I believe Canadians deserve a Parliament that scrutinizes legislation thoroughly, examines spending carefully and holds government accountable every step of the way. That is our responsibility, it is our duty and it is exactly what we should continue doing. \n\nAfter 10 years of deficits, rising debt and an affordability crisis, the Liberal government's answer is less accountability, less scrutiny, weaker communities and weaker democracy. Canadians should be asking themselves a very simple question: If this budget is so good, why is the government so afraid of letting Parliament fully examine it? \n\nTherefore, I move, seconded by the member for Langley Township—Fraser Heights:\n\n That the motion be amended: \n\n(a) in paragraph (a),\n\n(i) by replacing the word \"completing\", in subparagraph (i), with the word \"continuing\", and\n\n(ii) by deleting subparagraphs (ii) and (iv); and\n\n(b) by deleting paragraphs (b) to (f).","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085678","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Motion No. 12, a motion that would dramatically curtail Parliament's ability to properly scrutinize Bill C-30, the Liberal budget implementation act. \n\nThe government says it wants to move quickly, but Canadians want us to move carefully. When Liberals ask Parliament to fast-track another budget bill and limit scrutiny, Canadians have every right to ask a simp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ffa24fbe15cf1398c5b5ceb5b285546fc21c52f3a6825721094f0ed4ed55427d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5e852ca93050c772b6f027e3110b49295d8c8db66f4768c8534de554ed0e8172"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6194a08d26a54e012d8166f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085679,"date":"2026-06-12T15:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is a lot to unpack there. Our oil and gas and mining sectors are truly important sectors for our country. Some great announcements have been made, but I highlighted that over 35 mills have closed unnecessarily in the province of British Columbia, and tens of thousands of British Columbians are out of work. There are not tens of thousands of jobs they can move to.\n\nThe fact of the matter is that over two and a half million Canadians are accessing food banks. It is not getting easier or better for Canadians. It is getting harder under the Liberal government, which should wake up and see that its plan is not working, because Canadians are not better off with it at the wheel.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085679","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is a lot to unpack there. Our oil and gas and mining sectors are truly important sectors for our country. Some great announcements have been made, but I highlighted that over 35 mills have closed unnecessarily in the province of British Columbia, and tens of thousands of British Columbians are out of work. There are not tens of thousands of jobs they can move to.\n\nThe fact of th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7cde5bf8f61a0e619b38f9f88e3f23054ec8b9ebf674037b4c91c4c84ac3829c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fda2f92583a3618b4c2e16475331e41dfdf220e8bbded40bf454c60bec4795b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-084bf82285ba45764e04f2e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087611,"date":"2026-06-15T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, $38 million spent, 1,000 deliberately set fires in just four years and businesses closing and leaving town are the true devastating costs of Liberal catch-and-release and mental health policies in the city of Prince George. Prolific offenders are arrested and released the very same day. Homelessness, addiction and crime have turned our communities into war zones. That is the reality, and that is the Liberal government's legacy. \n\nMembers of the Prince George city council are here in Ottawa today. Will the Prime Minister accept their invite to come to Prince George to tell our business owners directly to their faces why he believes they should give his catch-and-release policies another chance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087611","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, $38 million spent, 1,000 deliberately set fires in just four years and businesses closing and leaving town are the true devastating costs of Liberal catch-and-release and mental health policies in the city of Prince George. Prolific offenders are arrested and released the very same day. Homelessness, addiction and crime have turned our communities into war zones. That is the reality, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31cccec4577509ba9c49dbd59fa7c9696fca0d5aa2eaaa25d56e99f3d156522a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["96a03e85d25b5d8c1563b9a55e0bff1ea15416a485c27cda5d6884cbb5d62c1e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20396d56734ecd2f84883c57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087609,"date":"2026-06-17T21:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to present a petition signed by the residents of Prince George and hand delivered by members of city council, who are all deeply concerned about repeat offending, court delays and the growing impact of property crime in our community. The petitioners point out that downtown Prince George businesses continue to face theft, vandalism, broken windows, arson and ongoing public safety concerns, while a small number of prolific offenders are responsible for a disproportionate amount of crime.\n\n The petitioners call on the government to strengthen bail provisions for repeat offenders, appoint more judges and prosecutors, increase resources for Crown counsel to reduce court delays and provide additional funding for correctional facilities, rehabilitation programs and release planning. I am pleased to table this petition on behalf of my constituents.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087609","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to present a petition signed by the residents of Prince George and hand delivered by members of city council, who are all deeply concerned about repeat offending, court delays and the growing impact of property crime in our community. The petitioners point out that downtown Prince George businesses continue to face theft, vandalism, broken windows, arson and ongoing publ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034546","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034546","label":"Commercial buildings","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d84ec2efa3cb30a0841fb2668bbfaad79c0a2065866d15c4ceca72b218fa56e0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["571603f7890778fc6a821db83999661001cead607d001d314ef1f419742b20ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a3e91661fa71ddc1b09a551","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087610,"date":"2026-06-17T22:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Todd Doherty","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to extend my thanks to the hon. member, as my colleagues have done.\n\n I was elected with my friend in 2015. As many know, we go through highs and lows in this job. She has always been resolute in her faith. She is a strong supporter of her colleagues. She was always someone who, if we were going through a hard time or if she found out that we or a loved one was struggling, was quick to tell us that she would pray for us. I do not know about you, Mr. Speaker, but when somebody reaches out to tell me that they are praying for me, it is deeply personal and means a whole lot. \n\nTherefore, from me and my family to my colleague, I wish her success and thank her for the years she spent with us here in this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087610","member_id":"bc-mp-89249","member_name":"Todd Doherty","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to extend my thanks to the hon. member, as my colleagues have done.\n\n I was elected with my friend in 2015. As many know, we go through highs and lows in this job. She has always been resolute in her faith. She is a strong supporter of her colleagues. She was always someone who, if we were going through a hard time or if she found out that we or a loved one was struggling, was ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d97f9901de4568fa5c1955b8f76b2d3d60b05594a8c49a14d9a08a6cbe797684"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a38820e5fd9a2c0e6a74045","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77898,"date":"2026-02-03T19:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are telling us that soaring grocery bills are caused by external factors, as if the cost of living is going up everywhere. It is not. We have higher food costs than almost anywhere else in the G7. Meanwhile, the government piles on carbon taxes and red tape that make it more expensive to grow, transport and sell food. Let us be honest. These handouts are an admission of failure and a small band-aid for large, self-inflicted wounds. \n\nWhen will the government stop blaming others and start scrapping the policies that are driving food inflation at the checkout?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77898","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are telling us that soaring grocery bills are caused by external factors, as if the cost of living is going up everywhere. It is not. We have higher food costs than almost anywhere else in the G7. Meanwhile, the government piles on carbon taxes and red tape that make it more expensive to grow, transport and sell food. Let us be honest. These handouts are an admission of f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["414b3810d4f810b0bb2016b3443611ce8381cc1c8025a0e5a9686861b9efe019"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5427622520c7ac6f16433480b0b4640307fae04d518a669c2fa8e440648df70a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-717a95d9f8b516f72ec852a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77899,"date":"2026-02-03T22:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am sure the member is aware that the Department of National Defence is expanding rapidly right now and that the unused properties are generally World War II heritage leftovers.\n\nWhat would the member say about the coming expansion and how that may conflict with her bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77899","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am sure the member is aware that the Department of National Defence is expanding rapidly right now and that the unused properties are generally World War II heritage leftovers.\n\nWhat would the member say about the coming expansion and how that may conflict with her bill?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ee79ef1bc428033d65688528143ce91839e81ac3c584860dea8f67b6f4de4fe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66c3187a481f1a37d7740ed3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287735,"date":"2026-02-10T17:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are trying to build a narrative of obstructionism by saying we are obstructing their efforts to combat the problems that they themselves have created over the last 11 years. The irony here is that they are actually opposing a bill that would fix some of the problems they have created, which they claim they want to fix.\n\n My question for the member is why.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287735","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are trying to build a narrative of obstructionism by saying we are obstructing their efforts to combat the problems that they themselves have created over the last 11 years. The irony here is that they are actually opposing a bill that would fix some of the problems they have created, which they claim they want to fix.\n\n My question for the member is why.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a74d3a4e6b81ca1140dc0321","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287736,"date":"2026-02-10T21:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are trying to build a narrative that the Conservatives are obstructing them at every turn, despite the irony of actually doing this on a bill that we are presenting. I watched the Liberals obstruct it. Every single speech has the word \"obstructionism\" in it. I think even a new word was created today, \"obstructionality\", by one of the speakers.\n\n I am wondering if the member, who talked about how terrible it is to work with the Conservatives, has any views on the actual bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287736","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are trying to build a narrative that the Conservatives are obstructing them at every turn, despite the irony of actually doing this on a bill that we are presenting. I watched the Liberals obstruct it. Every single speech has the word \"obstructionism\" in it. I think even a new word was created today, \"obstructionality\", by one of the speakers.\n\n I am wondering if the memb","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e3a1e7b47b3656e456f6684","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":335999,"date":"2026-03-10T15:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition on behalf of the hundreds of thousands of Canadians who would like to see Bill C-9 withdrawn.\n\n Given the atrocious record of this Liberal government in overstepping its bounds, given the Emergency Act and freezing bank accounts, these Canadians are asking what exactly is preventing this government from expanding its powers under the bill, just to squash dissent. Therefore, the petitioners are calling on the Liberal government to withdraw Bill C-9.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:335999","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition on behalf of the hundreds of thousands of Canadians who would like to see Bill C-9 withdrawn.\n\n Given the atrocious record of this Liberal government in overstepping its bounds, given the Emergency Act and freezing bank accounts, these Canadians are asking what exactly is preventing this government from expanding its powers under the bill, just to sq","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22a2c428ab6f593efe78ff0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336000,"date":"2026-03-10T15:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, given the Liberal track record of flagrantly misusing government power, and I cite the misuse of the Emergencies Act, the freezing of citizen bank accounts, the intrusion on provincial jurisdiction numerous times, the arbitrary firearm confiscation by executive order and the elements of the Impact Assessment Act that were ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court of Canada, if the government can punish speech it considers hateful now, what is stopping it from silencing any dissent tomorrow?\n\nFurthermore, if the government can do that, what about future governments? Are they going to be able to silence dissent simply by ruling it hateful?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336000","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, given the Liberal track record of flagrantly misusing government power, and I cite the misuse of the Emergencies Act, the freezing of citizen bank accounts, the intrusion on provincial jurisdiction numerous times, the arbitrary firearm confiscation by executive order and the elements of the Impact Assessment Act that were ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court of Canada, if the g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f6509a061648796b3b2d71be498f18558e858717b3c6101e1543abc1359acc4e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f891be2dc3edd6f25174e77dd05fc1b98d7e0fb1671ed0e2ade5d587520d4a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0eb3defb52740cb2dc691e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336001,"date":"2026-03-10T17:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, recently a Canadian journalist was fined three-quarters of a million dollars for observing that there are only two genders. The reason I mention this is that it is an example of how well-meant but subjective ideas can slide sideways into something that is completely against free speech. \n\nCould my colleague elaborate on why it is so important that any changes to the system fully respect the freedoms guaranteed under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, particularly the freedom of religion, and what safeguards she believes should be included to ensure those rights remain protected?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336001","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, recently a Canadian journalist was fined three-quarters of a million dollars for observing that there are only two genders. The reason I mention this is that it is an example of how well-meant but subjective ideas can slide sideways into something that is completely against free speech. \n\nCould my colleague elaborate on why it is so important that any changes to the system fully res","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9c0d88549733e471476021a0e803b91c4158e96109f6dbeb53e262033dd5664f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["afe16e6cde8c9ead42300b0b7dda9f01c9e87bd1ce83411c4b91774c51fecaff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7044c820f7bbeee6fd470fa2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336002,"date":"2026-03-10T21:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, not one person has emailed me or contacted me to ask me to support this bill. In fact, I have more Liberal members emailing me asking me to cross the floor than to support this bill. On the other hand, many have phoned me to oppose it. This does not sound like a bill anybody wants. The member across the aisle claims that this is all a plot by the Conservative Party to raise funds. He has a point, because it is a great fundraiser. I actually have people phoning me to say they will donate if I can stop this bill. If it is a fundraising tool, it is a pretty good one. I cannot stop it. Only the Liberals can stop it. The Liberals keep telling us this bill is harmless, yet they also claim it is crucial.\n\nI am wondering if the member could speak a little about this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336002","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, not one person has emailed me or contacted me to ask me to support this bill. In fact, I have more Liberal members emailing me asking me to cross the floor than to support this bill. On the other hand, many have phoned me to oppose it. This does not sound like a bill anybody wants. The member across the aisle claims that this is all a plot by the Conservative Party to raise funds. He ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93f45ddcab418ca357562f46eacae8250abb6d49ebb688c9408106a77f8e4bb7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["833bf313183bb7a4ec542a9a92a2e09189ed33492fac51e6939f8894e1229087"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05e755a553b4bfed1b1fc6e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":335998,"date":"2026-03-13T17:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we face a situation similar to the one we faced after the Second World War, with millions of people looking for homes. The solution then was quite different and quite a bit more effective. By 1947, Canada was building 80,000, 90,000 or as many as 100,000 homes per year. Not one Crown corporation was involved, though I should say there was only one, CMHC, and that was explicitly for veterans. How was it done? The private sector did it by responding to demand at the time, and the government helped by getting out of the way.\n\nI wonder if the member could explain to the Liberals how that possibly happened without a giant bureaucracy to do it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:335998","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we face a situation similar to the one we faced after the Second World War, with millions of people looking for homes. The solution then was quite different and quite a bit more effective. By 1947, Canada was building 80,000, 90,000 or as many as 100,000 homes per year. Not one Crown corporation was involved, though I should say there was only one, CMHC, and that was explicitly for ve","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["290f7f345e6a439f4e65b2a39fe067fef1d6fab65c49c190503a61aa8816eda2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4f6fa307ceb43ee3ef77725ee812ea40b2aa16127a8ca87862ba5b4fdefa0eb1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b61fa090f9569daa88d31c8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384246,"date":"2026-03-23T21:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on a point of order, the member across the aisle said there were anti-LGBQ things in the speech. I did not hear any such thing at all. I would like him to retract that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384246","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on a point of order, the member across the aisle said there were anti-LGBQ things in the speech. I did not hear any such thing at all. I would like him to retract that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33f51f97820802979880a142","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384247,"date":"2026-03-23T21:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to begin by saying that I believe in a free, democratic Canada. I believe in a country where people can speak their minds, practise their faith and engage in open debate without fear of punishment from their government. That is why I am deeply concerned about Bill C-9. \n\nI recently held a town hall in my city, with the help of my colleague from Elgin—St. Thomas—London South. Usually, these town halls see maybe 50 or 100 people. That evening, over 600 people from my riding and others showed up. These are not fringe voices. Many were religious thought leaders from established Christian and other denominations, some were officials from other levels of government and all were thoughtful, engaged citizens deeply concerned about what they see as an assault on civil liberties. That level of concern should make all of us pause. \n\nThis is not about defending hate. Hate should be condemned. Where it crosses into violence or incitement, we already have those laws, and we need to enforce them instead of making more of them. This bill would expand government power over speech, and whenever government takes more power in this area, we know it is not coming back. Intent matters, and I do not doubt for a second that the framers of this bill had good intentions. The original bill contained provisions that many of us would support, but at committee, the Liberal Party accepted a Bloc amendment to remove the religious exemption. That is a hard no from this side of the House, and I believe from many other Canadians. \n\nThe Charter of Rights and Freedoms does not treat religion as an afterthought or something to be bargained away in committee. Freedom of religion is listed among our fundamental freedoms because that freedom to hold beliefs, to express them and to live them out is foundational to human dignity. For decades, Canadian law has reflected this through a religious exemption in hate speech provisions. That exemption ensures Canadians can cite scripture, preach, teach, debate and discuss matters of faith, even when those teachings are controversial, without fear of criminal prosecution. Bill C-9 would remove that protection. \n\nReligious expression is a charter-protected freedom. Let us think about what that means. Expressing a traditional religious teaching, something that has been part of faith for generations, could now be interpreted as criminal, depending on how someone else perceives it. The old adage that the road to hell is paved with good intentions is not just a saying. It is on full display here. The government may mean no harm and the next government may mean no harm, but we do not know the future and what future governments may plan. What we do know is that if Bill C-9 passes, future governments will have the tools they need to legally repress Canadians by simply redefining \"hate\" to mean whatever they say. That does not mean they necessarily will, but it was not that long ago that the Liberal government accused anti-government protesters of hate and invoked the Emergencies Act. It is not a long walk to imagine future misuse of that term. \n\nThis brings us to another major issue: the definition of \"hate\" in this bill. The bill describes \"hate\" as detestation or vilification, stronger than dislike or disdain, but what does that actually mean? Who decides what qualifies as detestation? Who determines when strong disagreement becomes criminal speech? It is not voters or Parliament. It is unelected officials, police, prosecutors and courts making subjective judgments about tone, intent and interpretation. That should concern all of us, every single Canadian. Once the state begins policing subjective thresholds in speech, it creates uncertainty, and uncertainty leads to a chilling effect. People begin to self-censor. They avoid difficult conversations, they stay silent rather than risk investigation or complaint, and that silence weakens democracy. If the exemption is removed, many clergy, imams, rabbis, elders and faith leaders will feel compelled to self-censor, not because they promote hatred but because the line between controversial and criminal becomes very blurred. \n\nThink of everyday faith community life: sermons, youth programs, marriage preparation classes, theological debates and small group discussions. In all of these settings, people discuss difficult moral questions. Without the exemption, these conversations could be misinterpreted or taken out of context, leading to complaints or investigation. A law that intimidates people out of participating in their own faith tradition is not protecting freedom but chilling it.\n\nAnother troubling aspect of this bill is how it would be enforced. It would rely heavily on a complaint-based system. That means investigations could be triggered not by clear violations, but by complaints, by perception. In today's world, especially online, context is easily lost and disagreement is constant. Do we really want a system where a social media post can lead to police knocking on our door? Do we want a country where people fear that what they said months ago in the heat of an argument could suddenly bring police to their door?\n\n I do not like the \"frog in the pot\" analogy because it tends to smack of conspiracy theory. This analogy, as we know, says that if we put a frog in a pot of cold water and turn on the heat the frog will not notice the water getting warmer until it is boiling and it is way too late. However, many Canadians feel that negative change is happening gradually, bit by bit. They see rising crime, economic strain and increasing government reach into everyday life. They see their firearms being confiscated and the Emergencies Act misused. They see bank accounts frozen and their jobs disappearing. If they manage to succeed, they are demonized and called greedy. Now they feel that their deepest beliefs may be taken away. Their concern is real and should not be simply dismissed. \n\nPerhaps the most serious issue is the precedent that it sets, that the state can determine which religious beliefs are acceptable and which are criminally suspect. A government should never be in the business of judging which scripture passages are allowed or which doctrines may be taught. I thought western society was over that in the 16th century. Once that door is reopened, it becomes easier for future governments to go further. Today's controversial belief may become tomorrow's punishable offence. It is one thing to uphold the separation of church and state, but it is another to allow the state to define \"acceptable church\". \n\nWe all want a country that is safe, respectable and just, but safety cannot come at the cost of freedom. The issue is not whether we oppose hate; we all do. Bill C-9 introduces ambiguity where we need clarity. It removes protections where we need safeguards. It shifts power away from Canadians toward institutions that are not directly accountable to them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384247","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to begin by saying that I believe in a free, democratic Canada. I believe in a country where people can speak their minds, practise their faith and engage in open debate without fear of punishment from their government. That is why I am deeply concerned about Bill C-9. \n\nI recently held a town hall in my city, with the help of my colleague from Elgin—St. Thomas—London South. Us","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Municipal buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","label":"Municipal buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3f541a292c889f11906d6212fb70139a8a083509ca99886c034542043bda58c4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1fe9439a8e973a22861d7167aa152cc89597b3ec6cc5c5671926c8e2de287f9f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b071810baa518f394eed1564","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384248,"date":"2026-03-23T21:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I think the Conservatives have been very clear about this. We are opposed to the removal of the religious exemption, which was never a campaign promise made by the Liberals at any point. At no point in the campaign were we told they were going to remove religious exemptions from Canadians.\n\n The laws already exist. I cannot think of an offence that this particular bill covers that is not already covered in the Criminal Code.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384248","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I think the Conservatives have been very clear about this. We are opposed to the removal of the religious exemption, which was never a campaign promise made by the Liberals at any point. At no point in the campaign were we told they were going to remove religious exemptions from Canadians.\n\n The laws already exist. I cannot think of an offence that this particular bill covers that is not already c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8066d302749d868c370866b559c2c9077ebd02c29a387454484bdc3e39498119"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["39479ae6924abfee0557a7d6b2d5a26739944fbbb2ad7ad4658d587f8a280259"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8f82b36d8ca94f5d2eca3e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384249,"date":"2026-03-23T22:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when somebody uses religion as a pretext to commit a crime, they go to jail. They would go to jail now, before the bill is passed. We do not need the bill to make them go to jail. There is no precedent for doing this at all. I reject the question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384249","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when somebody uses religion as a pretext to commit a crime, they go to jail. They would go to jail now, before the bill is passed. We do not need the bill to make them go to jail. There is no precedent for doing this at all. I reject the question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d39c17fa2ba545f31eea48caed705be533b9455b05cbc6e363fd057dcd0648f4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab15fdd15cc2801bf725c05b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384250,"date":"2026-03-23T22:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have been called a religious maniac and all the usual terms that come from across the floor many times, despite the fact that I think I have gone to church three or four times in the last 10 years and always on Christmas eve. I am not a religious maniac.\n\n I am very concerned about the curbs on free speech that the bill contains. It is crucial to democracy that we hear all opinions. We cannot form opinions without hearing all of those opinions. Sometimes they are controversial. Sometimes they are not controversial. Personally, I am against all forms of censorship, because I feel that society itself polices this very well. I find free speech to be an absolutely crucial element to democracy. We cannot have democracy unless we have a reasonable amount of free speech.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384250","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have been called a religious maniac and all the usual terms that come from across the floor many times, despite the fact that I think I have gone to church three or four times in the last 10 years and always on Christmas eve. I am not a religious maniac.\n\n I am very concerned about the curbs on free speech that the bill contains. It is crucial to democracy that we hear all opinions.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["779f1d66f721ce44598f3a19488c490edd0e3bcede25033749af73edd60b4574"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d3afb2eebdd2a431fb4f326eca5dcea038f2a35861ddc628e55a44193a1d500"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-262ed1bd82977f10ba1dcdd1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425345,"date":"2026-04-13T19:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize Henry Ly for his leadership in the Father's Knowledge Circle, a weekly meeting run by the North Okanagan Friendship Center Society in Vernon, British Columbia. The circle creates a respectful, supportive space for fathers to come together and share knowledge and stories. Speaking at the knowledge circle took me back 20 years, to the day I suddenly found myself a single father with my three young kids, living in a motel room. Things worked out for me, but for far too many men the extra stress can be deadly.\n\n Single fatherhood is a growing demographic in our society, and the challenges and lack of support can be overwhelming. Nearly a million Canadian men suffer from major depression annually, and 75% of all suicides in Canada are men. Volunteer support programs like this save lives. Thanks to leaders like Henry Ly and programs like Father's Knowledge Circle, dads have a place to turn and a community that says to them that they are not alone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425345","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize Henry Ly for his leadership in the Father's Knowledge Circle, a weekly meeting run by the North Okanagan Friendship Center Society in Vernon, British Columbia. The circle creates a respectful, supportive space for fathers to come together and share knowledge and stories. Speaking at the knowledge circle took me back 20 years, to the day I suddenly found mysel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","label":"Single parent families"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","label":"Single parent families","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["64b22c5206581b9b925e42091e21c74f4e6da162ac6124f1cc661994e653081a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7443b92cb23cb64d602975ff8df2c0390f86ae357f037824bcc8a91bf883b084"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15178633f6cde38b597c8872","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425344,"date":"2026-04-15T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the minister is telling us half the story about the pay raises. What he is forgetting is that overseas, reductions of over $1,500 a month are being taken back from living allowances. These are real families putting their lives on the line abroad who were given just six days' notice and are now scrambling to adjust.\n\nThe Liberal government increases pay only to claw it back. The headlines all scream about increased military pay, but why are so many frontline soldiers deployed overseas actually being forced to take a pay cut?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425344","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the minister is telling us half the story about the pay raises. What he is forgetting is that overseas, reductions of over $1,500 a month are being taken back from living allowances. These are real families putting their lives on the line abroad who were given just six days' notice and are now scrambling to adjust.\n\nThe Liberal government increases pay only to claw it back. The headli","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","label":"Foreign aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0cf5c6ca54933edc6166cfe03dcf920d6e30505db5e3059e71af1a4353862a09"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0fa140ba5fca81d7467596fe3fb8deb0b923a2ceecd75e84e55a0f7e4d33f482"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3985f0504ee0e26361d72746","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109584,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thanks, Chair. Thank you for appearing today. I've heard the same rumours as my colleague about training problems with language and the inability to speak either official language. Is the language training offered before or after recruitment? I don't think we heard a straight yes or no on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109584","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thanks, Chair. Thank you for appearing today. I've heard the same rumours as my colleague about training problems with language and the inability to speak either official language. Is the language training offered before or after recruitment? I don't think we heard a straight yes or no on that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73dd8ffee3b7b459b847a5f14d489b303cf84fbf999b381a2708bf78a940899f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56c38297f6afc17891e871c774d9e68d39b5c39725464d808f26950877f949de"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-395018e1acfbc7e7cccae9a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109585,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"If I may, do you do medical testing before recruitment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109585","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If I may, do you do medical testing before recruitment?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c9ccb3b41b87f73b3b782dfd2db398329d25e71a5b8b49322c97019251c8f27"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5fdc45f8fd3e8409c8cbf5a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109586,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do you do psychological testing before recruitment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109586","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you do psychological testing before recruitment?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cbe61acd676e7104f13a7b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109587,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"However, you don't do language testing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109587","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"However, you don't do language testing.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-adc325a0845a2419195f0abd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109588,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Are there plans right now to test language beforehand?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109588","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are there plans right now to test language beforehand?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80c73c3c02682bb79cee7bff87e077df66d16a3279b3a240e01644927a0f392f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e5fde1d8c2005012983db6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109589,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Is there something being planned to do that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109589","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Is there something being planned to do that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-990ae04fa355ccb912c110d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109590,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"You have—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109590","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You have—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b2867a1768848261c2c608d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109591,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I see. Okay. What level of language proficiency is required?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109591","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I see. Okay. What level of language proficiency is required?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-506ff1b6bf1ae6f0796eb850","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109592,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"What level of proficiency is required? I can operate in Hindi, but that doesn't mean I speak Hindi.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109592","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What level of proficiency is required? I can operate in Hindi, but that doesn't mean I speak Hindi.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083649","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Non-Status Indians","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083649","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Non-Status Indians","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083649","label":"Non-Status Indians","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f3c2393b5a6420d3eb9aa8b005fededa2d6032171447366b86944f0f9298dae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-406e599d41e4ac1bebe9a7a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109593,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. You said that security risks are rooted out before operational status. Between recruitment and operational status, it can sometimes be years. I know of one second lieutenant who was a second lieutenant for 10 years beforehand. It wasn't me, incidentally. Voices: Oh, oh! Scott Anderson: In the meantime, they received the lion's share of the training, and they received an automatic weapon and ammunition for it. I'm talking about the land army. Is this ideal? Is this the ideal way to test security?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109593","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. You said that security risks are rooted out before operational status. Between recruitment and operational status, it can sometimes be years. I know of one second lieutenant who was a second lieutenant for 10 years beforehand. It wasn't me, incidentally. Voices: Oh, oh! Scott Anderson: In the meantime, they received the lion's share of the training, and they received an automatic weapon and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fd922a948f811cefbef124e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109594,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. What specific efforts are being made to recruit indigenous personnel?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109594","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. What specific efforts are being made to recruit indigenous personnel?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92a6e9452be5bc58425c74ff02a373931504373a7b0542b89bba3b9e63d0da7c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6689ae9a66021888102b93d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109595,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Are indigenous personnel involved in this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109595","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are indigenous personnel involved in this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68d8c5c441f44d638a411469","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109596,"date":"2026-04-15T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay, that's excellent. Is the military actively seeking out immigrants for dual-use skills like medicine or engineering and things that are more advanced?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109596","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay, that's excellent. Is the military actively seeking out immigrants for dual-use skills like medicine or engineering and things that are more advanced?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","label":"Medicine","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","label":"Military training","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","label":"Engineering","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c99d2c37cb191f40dfa8d5e56122cffaf7656559ddab68416b3901d72fa84dde"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0f162acf60067ffaa138509","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109597,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you so much. I'll turn the rest of my time, if I have any, over to James.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109597","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you so much. I'll turn the rest of my time, if I have any, over to James.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50abba6b4b95e1b271736fe4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109598,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I was just trying to be a Liberal.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109598","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I was just trying to be a Liberal.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc66ded652a91c8d7561212c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109599,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"No.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109599","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dea295651c8eb73b9bdc2d31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109600,"date":"2026-04-15T23:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"For the benefit of Canadians—I know the military loves acronyms—can you tell us what \"CBRN\" is? You used the acronym before.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109600","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"For the benefit of Canadians—I know the military loves acronyms—can you tell us what \"CBRN\" is? You used the acronym before.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083604","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Civil aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083604","label":"Civil aviation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71ea57c8917201d8f70f94a237759ca6688e61c2869496291827ff70997e9941"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-150895e0276f84ae72553446","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109601,"date":"2026-04-15T23:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. Lieutenant-General, you mentioned a screening process. I remember that my screening process in the officer stream was a discussion with the major, who basically had a conversation with me and, at the end of it, asked if I was able to kill somebody. To me, that's not an adequate screening process. This was only in 2009, I think. Is there a more enhanced screening process now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109601","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Lieutenant-General, you mentioned a screening process. I remember that my screening process in the officer stream was a discussion with the major, who basically had a conversation with me and, at the end of it, asked if I was able to kill somebody. To me, that's not an adequate screening process. This was only in 2009, I think. Is there a more enhanced screening process now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["342013ee4e18a3f541fbd8a6e683895388c89366449dc7b61a260079240a95af"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-46c0db58e9f77de7f9150eb8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109602,"date":"2026-04-15T23:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm sorry to interrupt. That was one part of the question. There is another part of the question. I've been around warfare a bit, and I know that it attracts some people whose legal status is questionable. A lot of those people may be applying here. Does IRCC pass on to you or alert you that there's a lack of paperwork on their end? In the refugee stream, that's often the case.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109602","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm sorry to interrupt. That was one part of the question. There is another part of the question. I've been around warfare a bit, and I know that it attracts some people whose legal status is questionable. A lot of those people may be applying here. Does IRCC pass on to you or alert you that there's a lack of paperwork on their end? In the refugee stream, that's often the case.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-014e1c26efbf799b9df40f8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109603,"date":"2026-04-15T23:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. I'm going to pass the rest of my time over to my colleague Jeff Kibble.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-30/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109603","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I'm going to pass the rest of my time over to my colleague Jeff Kibble.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77acad5d572553ce84a52df3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425341,"date":"2026-04-17T15:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Liberal catch-and-release policies have actually caused this crime. Before Trudeau came along 10 years ago, we did not have a crime wave; now we do. We also did not have Bill C-22. The difference here is actually the catch-and-release problems, the catch-and-release policies we are suffering under.\n\nWould it not make more sense to stop shooting down Conservative bills, anti-crime bills, and leave the privacy of Canadians alone?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425341","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Liberal catch-and-release policies have actually caused this crime. Before Trudeau came along 10 years ago, we did not have a crime wave; now we do. We also did not have Bill C-22. The difference here is actually the catch-and-release problems, the catch-and-release policies we are suffering under.\n\nWould it not make more sense to stop shooting down Conservative bills, anti-crime bill","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b41cf88d09342a2a8ba1aaa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425342,"date":"2026-04-17T15:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard much from the Liberals about how we are obstructing their bills and whatnot, even though they are filibustering their own bills in committee. Usually that means that they are trying to create a narrative that we are obstructing.\n\nDo you feel that we are obstructing or debating this bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425342","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have heard much from the Liberals about how we are obstructing their bills and whatnot, even though they are filibustering their own bills in committee. Usually that means that they are trying to create a narrative that we are obstructing.\n\nDo you feel that we are obstructing or debating this bill?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42280b54902227f9c1b2e9ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425343,"date":"2026-04-17T17:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I notice the Liberals are tending to characterize this as obstructionism. We are here in Parliament to do a job, and that job is to question the other side and improve any bill that comes through committee.\n\n I wonder if my hon. colleague could speak to whether he thinks Conservatives are obstructing or improving this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425343","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I notice the Liberals are tending to characterize this as obstructionism. We are here in Parliament to do a job, and that job is to question the other side and improve any bill that comes through committee.\n\n I wonder if my hon. colleague could speak to whether he thinks Conservatives are obstructing or improving this bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["49594b17242d02ba73492e5c75b6c090856271c45672d2ebc408776f9338d8e3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e43fc2bd358cd6ee9fc3597d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109604,"date":"2026-04-20T17:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. I want to start by recognizing some people in my riding who fought in the war. We have a reserve OKIB, Okanagan Indian Band, and they have a proud history of fighting in wars. William Smith was a tank gunner who was killed in France in 1944. Gunner Robert Sheffield, 19, died in the war. Flight sergeant Leslie Sparkes of the Royal Canadian Air Force died in 1942. Edward James Tronson went to war with four of his brothers, who all came home. Unfortunately, their mother, Louisa Tronson, died before any of them got home. I wanted to mention that. I want to set the stage for the next question. It's an interesting one. The modern battlefield in a symmetrical war is something we're seeing right now in Ukraine. There are two tactical scenarios for communication. One is the frontline cities. For instance, Kramatorsk is about 15 kilometres from the Russians. There is surveillance from satellites or high-level drones. There is medium-level and low-level surveillance. There are electronic listening devices and electronic scrambling devices. The GPS is foiled. Every time we try to use it there, it tries to direct us into the river. Listening devices are everywhere, and there is AI and advanced signals intelligence. At the zero line, which is a little closer to the Russians, in Kupiansk, electronic comms are simply shut down. There's nothing there. This brings up a question I had about the code talkers from World War II. It seems odd in this highly technological environment to talk about something that was in World War II, but in the immediate tactical battlefield when communications have to be done, what about something like the code talkers? You would think that in a modern battlefield, you would just whip out your cellphone and use a translator device. Can any of the academics here tell me how many indigenous languages are actually on translation devices? I've looked around, and I cannot find anything there at all. We have 80,000 Cree speakers in Canada. We have 40,000 Inuktitut speakers. In a modern symmetrical battlefield where electronic devices don't work—and this is a serious question—is this a possibility? Is this something that should be explored?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791165","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Battlefields","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109604","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I want to start by recognizing some people in my riding who fought in the war. We have a reserve OKIB, Okanagan Indian Band, and they have a proud history of fighting in wars. William Smith was a tank gunner who was killed in France in 1944. Gunner Robert Sheffield, 19, died in the war. Flight sergeant Leslie Sparkes of the Royal Canadian Air Force died in 1942. Edward James T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791165","label":"Battlefields"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","label":"Military communications"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","label":"Electronic equipment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791165","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Battlefields","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","label":"Electronic equipment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","label":"Military communications","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791165","label":"Battlefields","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2bcb54cacc5f9ad3d3c86d7fa9770b754dbc74c62f007667b2dcdde740b7841c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791165","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Battlefields","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c67622c78204721a6663bcddcd953ef775d45d77d29f099ded2cacf1c2b6252"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791165","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Battlefields","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791165","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Battlefields","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791165","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0802f009bc38f268c39d22c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109605,"date":"2026-04-20T17:05:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Speaking of the leverage that you just mentioned, how would that translate into...? We've heard a lot about casual racism and a sense of racism within the forces. How would that translate into an almost special forces cachet that would actually attract indigenous folks to the CAF?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109605","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Speaking of the leverage that you just mentioned, how would that translate into...? We've heard a lot about casual racism and a sense of racism within the forces. How would that translate into an almost special forces cachet that would actually attract indigenous folks to the CAF?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2e30ffd7b8d346153890760","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300677,"date":"2026-04-20T21:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am wondering if my colleague across the aisle could explain whether he believes Bill C-22 is better than Bill C-2, given that Bill C-2 wanted to limit the use of cash for Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300677","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am wondering if my colleague across the aisle could explain whether he believes Bill C-22 is better than Bill C-2, given that Bill C-2 wanted to limit the use of cash for Canadians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea51d20cdb3b29663fcbd3bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300678,"date":"2026-04-20T21:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from Davenport mentioned that this is a better bill than before. In fact, this is the third attempt the Liberals have made to introduce a bill that is similar to this, each one a little less intrusive than the last one. My concern, if we let the bill go to committee, is around whether the Liberals would actually respect the amendments we make in it, because I have just come out of a committee with Bill C-11 where we had made some very important amendments to the bill, and on Friday the Liberal Minister of National Defence simply attempted to strip all the amendments away.\n\n I wonder if the Liberals intend to actually respect the amendments we make in committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300678","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from Davenport mentioned that this is a better bill than before. In fact, this is the third attempt the Liberals have made to introduce a bill that is similar to this, each one a little less intrusive than the last one. My concern, if we let the bill go to committee, is around whether the Liberals would actually respect the amendments we make in it, because I have just co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-91d6c6717cb87568fd0a8fc6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300679,"date":"2026-04-20T21:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from Riding Mountain. I originally hail from Manitoba as well. One thing I can say about it is it is cold and flat and has many mosquitoes. I love it too. \n\n We live in a technological society that is so advanced most of us here do not understand some of the capabilities that are out there, and I do not pretend to know what technologies are employed by criminals around here. On the one hand, we have pure anarchy when we address governance and on the other, we have severe authoritarianism. As my colleague mentioned, there have been several bills and several attempts to do this. I wonder if he thinks this bill comes closest to striking a proper balance between severe authoritarianism on the one hand and pure anarchy on the other.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300679","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague from Riding Mountain. I originally hail from Manitoba as well. One thing I can say about it is it is cold and flat and has many mosquitoes. I love it too. \n\n We live in a technological society that is so advanced most of us here do not understand some of the capabilities that are out there, and I do not pretend to know what technologies are employed by criminals a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210561","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Insects","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","label":"Mountains","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210561","label":"Insects","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80191ad12e44e50a8ab47151faa8f63793ca50454aca8db23124c64408c2933a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b51ed40c8ec6d48034b3af67","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300680,"date":"2026-04-20T22:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the parliamentary secretary said, quite rightly, that 15 years ago we did not have this problem, and that is absolutely true. Technology has advanced since then. He also said that his new government is laser-focused on crime. I would like to point out that the government is not a new government. It is 11 years old. While technology has advanced, criminality has galloped forward. \n\nI am wondering if the parliamentary secretary would like to explain why, in 11 years, when technology has advanced at a certain pace, crime has galloped ahead at a much faster pace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300680","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the parliamentary secretary said, quite rightly, that 15 years ago we did not have this problem, and that is absolutely true. Technology has advanced since then. He also said that his new government is laser-focused on crime. I would like to point out that the government is not a new government. It is 11 years old. While technology has advanced, criminality has galloped forward. \n\nI a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["965ba7b25ffb6002dc68eed325e77f793c6abf0a3f4dca750c59fba68b7d4a6c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f999f36b23a6e1f4d69aef5b12671f540ae06e9fda84fcc3ed691c376ea3b1a9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d117c5da7024669efcf3ff77","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300681,"date":"2026-04-20T22:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-22 is like so many other bills that show good promise and strong potential to be shaped into good policy in committee. It is right here in second reading that the problems with Bill C-22 are initially identified, and that is what my colleagues on this side of the chamber have been doing: probing, asking questions and identifying weak spots that could be eliminated or good points that could be strengthened. If after this debate the House agrees, Bill C-22 would go to committee stage where it would be debate and have amendments introduced, and then the amendments would be voted on.\n\nCommittees are an exceptional tool in which all parties can take a mediocre bill and shape it into good policy, or they can take a good bill and make it even better. We conduct witness interviews, and we incorporate the concerns of everyone until we have a bill that works for all parties, and by extension, for all Canadians. Unfortunately, this is what the Liberals have recently taken to calling obstruction, but it is not. This is how our Canadian parliamentary democracy is supposed to work. I want to address this manufactured Liberal claim of obstruction, because with the compliant media out there, if I do not tell Canadians in the House, they are not going to find out.\n\nContrary to the narrative of obstruction the Liberals are trying to create, we Conservatives truly did hope that the Prime Minister would steal another of our platform promises and build the so-called energy corridor he promised. We believed him when he said he would make Canada an energy superpower. We hoped he would move quickly and decisively to get our clean Canadian energy to an energy-starved world. That is why we Conservatives voted for Bill C-5 early in the Prime Minister's tenure, and with it gave him more power than any previous prime minister has ever had to achieve those goals.\n\n The Prime Minister has more jurisdictional power than Prime Minister John A. Macdonald had when he built thousands of miles of continental railway through some of the most inhospitable terrain imaginable. The Prime Minister has technologies that would leave Macdonald in shock. We can do in a day what it took a year to do in Macdonald's day.\n\nThe Prime Minister can look down in real time from 100 kilometres above and see right into the earth with lidar. He can view the route. He can model a pipeline. He can even watch it in real time as it is built from the comfort of his airplane seat. He could have a pipeline built in two years if he wanted to, yet a year after Bill C-5, he does not even have a pipeline started. He does not have a plan to build one. He does not have a route, not even a gleam in a surveyor's eye. What would a rational person think about this?\n\nThe Prime Minister promised grand projects of great national importance. He promised a deal with the Americans by this time last year. He promised to move at speeds not seen in generations to unleash our Canadian economy. However, he has not landed in Canada long enough to move anything. Instead of an energy corridor, we have silence. Instead of housing, we have an enormously expensive bureaucracy and empty props that are taken down as soon as the photo op is over. Instead of a continental railway from coast to coast, we have a $90-billion boondoggle between two eastern cities that will likely never get built, and even that is mired in scandal and controversy before the land snatch even begins.\n\nUnfortunately, our Prime Minister is usually absent from Ottawa, flitting about the world here and there in no particular direction, at enormous taxpayer expense and with a catering budget that would make Emperor Nero blush, all apparently to avoid hard questions in question period, since nothing much has been produced except an undergrad international relations term paper at Davos.\n\nThe reason I bring this up is that there is a problem, and I am troubled by it. If we send Bill C-22 to committee by voting for the legislation, how can we be confident the Liberals will respect the committee process and not try to do an end run around Canadians? Can we be sure that our efforts in committee will be respected by the Liberals? What is supposed to happen is all-party input, all-party witnesses, all-party debate and amendments put forward and voted on, and ultimately the result is a bill modified by the people of Canada through the process of representative democracy. That is what is supposed to happen. It is not what is actually happening, and I want to talk for a minute about what is happening.\n\nI want to talk about a troubling tactic the Liberals are using to subvert that process. I am fearful that what happened to Bill C-11 is going to happen to Bill C-22. I am a member of the national defence committee. We recently studied Bill C-11, a bill whose central purpose is to transfer sexual assault cases from the military to the civilian justice system. I assumed, probably like most of us here, that after listening to the horror stories in the media, this would be a rubber stamp, and we would simply transfer the authority to the civilian system. However, all of us at committee were surprised.\n\n We listened to the defence and the prosecution teams from the military argue that the studies the bill was responding to were a decade old and no longer applied to the current military culture. They argued that they had both the capability and the capacity to address the cases, and that the culture within the CAF had radically changed in those 10 years. \n\nWe listened to the civilian police, who told us that, although they had the capability, they no longer had the capacity to absorb yet more work, especially in locations with military bases close by. \n\nThen we listened to victim after victim of sexual assault in the military. It was really the victims who surprised me and I think most of us at committee, the people I thought would have the strongest desire to move out of the military justice system. I thought perhaps one or two might say they would like to have a choice, but it turned out that just about every single witness we talked to wanted a choice between the military justice system and the civilian system.\n\n After numerous victims spoke, it became obvious that the bill needed to be modified, so, with the support of the Bloc member on the committee, we co-operated to amend an outdated Liberal motion into one that every stakeholder, from victim to investigator, wanted. We gave the victims a choice. So far, so good. We took a bill that was okay and made it into a good bill. Late this Friday afternoon, the Minister of National Defence, in defiance of civilian and military lawyers, civilian and military police, and even the victims themselves, came into the House and tabled Bill C-11 at report stage. \n\nHe is trying to strip our amendments from the bill. Why are the Liberals doing this? We had a decent bill that we turned into a much better bill. There seems to be no explanation for it at all. Why would the Liberals defy both the military and civilian justice systems and the victims? \n\nThere is a reason. The Prime Minister has not, will not and cannot fulfill his campaign promises. The cracks in our economy have become chasms, and he needs an election before Canadians feel the full brunt of his purposeful inaction. He knows Canadians are going to start to notice the growing divide between these grandiose announcements and the cold, grey reality of their pocketbooks, so he needs a majority government, and fast. He trolled the opposition benches and, yes, sure enough, an artificial majority did manage to slither across the aisle, but the Prime Minister is afraid that his majority will unravel, since he now has both far right and far left members in his caucus. He has called this a big tent, but it has become more like a circus tent, so he needs an election. \n\nHowever, the Prime Minister does not want to be blamed for calling an election, so the Liberals are banging on about obstruction to make it look like the normal processes of Parliament are somehow wrong. If he employs tactics like this now that he has a majority government, he knows it is to create the kinds of division within Parliament that he can point to and claim are obstruction. Bill C-22 may have the potential to be a good bill, if it makes it past second reading and goes to committee. My fear is that it will meet the fate of Bill C-11, be subjected to the scrutiny of experts, be modified into a much clearer, better bill, and then have all the positive changes stripped out once it hits report stage. This is obstruction, to be sure, but not by Conservatives.\n\n Conservatives are doing what we are supposed to be doing for the benefit of Canadians. The Prime Minister and the Liberal Party, on the other hand, are acting on behalf of the Liberal Party. They are attempting to fabricate another election that no one wants by trying to make it look like it is not their fault. This is not order and good government, but devious arrogance by the Liberals. Canadians had better brace themselves.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300681","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-22 is like so many other bills that show good promise and strong potential to be shaped into good policy in committee. It is right here in second reading that the problems with Bill C-22 are initially identified, and that is what my colleagues on this side of the chamber have been doing: probing, asking questions and identifying weak spots that could be eliminated or good point","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["83a73ed5c0af0f0835ff2c648daf2e52576b0647a1f0239257db68a7a5b5c132"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c01c2876b067e4104a3d8c4c5951acd8deeaa3a5682e4ebf1981891628a6d9d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9dc34e4b43b41f538e51680","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300682,"date":"2026-04-20T22:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there was not a question there. There was a statement, so I am going to make a statement. Potentialities are not the same thing as actualities. We have MOUs worth whatever amount of money. What we actually have is very little. I could talk about the great mineral exploration we are going to be doing on Saturn, but that does not mean we are going to have it today, tomorrow or ever. I am just talking about it.\n\nThat is my statement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300682","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there was not a question there. There was a statement, so I am going to make a statement. Potentialities are not the same thing as actualities. We have MOUs worth whatever amount of money. What we actually have is very little. I could talk about the great mineral exploration we are going to be doing on Saturn, but that does not mean we are going to have it today, tomorrow or ever. I a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e1de4e98701a1a364f0e2270d89da401d61525299fed9c7b30c39670097106a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-545271e0aee30e94377686a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300683,"date":"2026-04-20T22:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I do not think we should trust the Liberals at all. We just heard that over 10 years, crime has galloped ahead, and it is being blamed on technology creep. Crime has galloped. Technology has moved. The reason for that is fairly obvious: The Liberals are now playing catch-up to a decade of ignoring crime and hoping that it would go away. Now they are dealing with the actuality. They are scrambling to do it and somehow yelling and screaming that they need to do it quickly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300683","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I do not think we should trust the Liberals at all. We just heard that over 10 years, crime has galloped ahead, and it is being blamed on technology creep. Crime has galloped. Technology has moved. The reason for that is fairly obvious: The Liberals are now playing catch-up to a decade of ignoring crime and hoping that it would go away. Now they are dealing with the actuality. They ar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["10d95b58d800a0ffd2ee4f8c4d958b0aef05cdac30033880887cada0fcee5038"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d6eb985eb048fdac583022ef4337a84791289b4f304b3eee62f8413f645b6fc1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4dad1fd9a6559ad1ab196b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300684,"date":"2026-04-20T22:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I see a great deal of potential in the bill. I have been talking to people overseas as well. There is absolutely no recourse in our laws, and I certainly think we need that, but we have to draw a balance between, on one hand, the anarchy of pure freedom, and on the other hand, really heavy-handed authoritarianism. I think the bill has the potential to hit the middle ground there, but it must go to committee and have all-party input. I hope that the Liberals abide by that, and I hope that they honour the process of Parliament.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300684","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I see a great deal of potential in the bill. I have been talking to people overseas as well. There is absolutely no recourse in our laws, and I certainly think we need that, but we have to draw a balance between, on one hand, the anarchy of pure freedom, and on the other hand, really heavy-handed authoritarianism. I think the bill has the potential to hit the middle ground there, but ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9215eac51479b18c3b4fa86bb111e3dd9bf5b84f00b63685f3184a08141878c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd3f27eea30516bbeef27358","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109606,"date":"2026-04-22T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much to all of the witnesses who came today. General Maisonneuve, I want to play the devil's advocate a bit here. Professor Chouinard said that French should begin in BMQ, and/or BMOQ, I assume. BMQ is really a culture change. It's taking young adults who have spent a couple of decades in the civilian world and turning them into soldiers. I'm wondering if, in your view, BMQ is the best place to start language training, adding that task to the culture shock that they're enduring.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109606","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much to all of the witnesses who came today. General Maisonneuve, I want to play the devil's advocate a bit here. Professor Chouinard said that French should begin in BMQ, and/or BMOQ, I assume. BMQ is really a culture change. It's taking young adults who have spent a couple of decades in the civilian world and turning them into soldiers. I'm wondering if, in your view, BMQ is the b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d125efe24ab7513b231bb07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109607,"date":"2026-04-22T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. That was the same requirement they had in grad school at the University of Manitoba. You had to be bilingual, at least nominally. In your view, at what point during the rank progression should the officer stream, first of all, and the non-commissioned stream, second of all, begin to learn French?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109607","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. That was the same requirement they had in grad school at the University of Manitoba. You had to be bilingual, at least nominally. In your view, at what point during the rank progression should the officer stream, first of all, and the non-commissioned stream, second of all, begin to learn French?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72a4e94ddb9ec5b44e08ded3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109608,"date":"2026-04-22T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"My question is really about at what point in the training. Is it early in the qualifications after BMQ? At what point do you suggest that you begin to force people to learn languages?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109608","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My question is really about at what point in the training. Is it early in the qualifications after BMQ? At what point do you suggest that you begin to force people to learn languages?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77c554809316627c0f0c6ee4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109609,"date":"2026-04-22T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. Professor Chouinard, I should ask you, is that what you meant?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109609","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Professor Chouinard, I should ask you, is that what you meant?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18c170bf52392300ea762735b744aab8bcddc5c5570ffd29db6f592d9cb982cf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26af41a50b66a49b3172f2d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109610,"date":"2026-04-22T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Major Sauvé, do you agree with the assessment as to when both non-commissioned and officer streams should begin training?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109610","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Major Sauvé, do you agree with the assessment as to when both non-commissioned and officer streams should begin training?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037238","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Streams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037238","label":"Streams","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["570a786239a39fbc9fed9fe5d4c9b0c037dea6f95e0cca5b1de760ec5ec1675c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0abb8466677ed3c9e9b4086b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109611,"date":"2026-04-22T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109611","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-195d190cf3f748b6dbf07b90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109612,"date":"2026-04-22T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. General, I have another question for you. During the Afghan deployment, about a quarter of the people who went over were actually reserves, including junior and senior officers. What's your prescription for the reserves, given that in a kinetic situation they are quite likely to supplement and be integrated into the force structure that's being projected.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109612","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. General, I have another question for you. During the Afghan deployment, about a quarter of the people who went over were actually reserves, including junior and senior officers. What's your prescription for the reserves, given that in a kinetic situation they are quite likely to supplement and be integrated into the force structure that's being projected.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","label":"Indigenous reserves","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","label":"Military training","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c8c03e0543031119f403a0bd76411be7b0c991a8ae3f3c7a95a8797fa5a3715"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efbb8e3fa4f90dd0bfcfb40b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109613,"date":"2026-04-22T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much, sir. I'm going to pass the rest of my time to my colleague, Jeff Kibble.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-32/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109613","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much, sir. I'm going to pass the rest of my time to my colleague, Jeff Kibble.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e20a9810400faf74f7f699e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300671,"date":"2026-04-23T17:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, first, I would suggest that my colleagues not use \"chain of command\" until they understand what it means. People are removed from the chain of command today and put into the JAG system, or at least they were prior to this.\n\n I want to quote Dr. Karen Breeck, who is a former officer in the Canadian Armed Forces and is also a medical doctor. She testified that the military of 2025 has changed. She said:\n\nToday the chain of command has extensive awareness and training. The sexual misconduct support and resource centre is fully operational. Victims' rights legislation is in force. Independent legal and victim supports exist.... What evidence still shows that [the civilian system] remains the best way forward?\n\nI wonder if my colleague could comment on one of the victims who said much the same thing as—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300671","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, first, I would suggest that my colleagues not use \"chain of command\" until they understand what it means. People are removed from the chain of command today and put into the JAG system, or at least they were prior to this.\n\n I want to quote Dr. Karen Breeck, who is a former officer in the Canadian Armed Forces and is also a medical doctor. She testified that the military of 2025 has c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9056b2ae544939d36cab60d5c15a5f53a9c5cda819a689e0c31a4e4f51452c39"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41fd85e999e81e8787d8b7bf8de6a40538c61639383f5c1939e7133506ce28a6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-461d3670318522c93d6a9e82","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300672,"date":"2026-04-23T17:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-11, when it first came to the national defence committee, was meant to transfer sexual assault cases from the military to the civilian justice system. It was not supposed to be a controversial bill. It arose because of the need to address sexual assault in the military. All of us in the House have, I believe, deep down, the best interests of Canadians at heart.\n\nAs a former officer, the bill matters to me. All of us in the room value the strength and dedication of our troops, but not one of us wants to see greater physical strength turned against our own. I have another personal reason for taking the bill seriously. I have a daughter who recently earned a university degree and a civilian pilot's license. She has recently applied to the Canadian Armed Forces to fly as a pilot in defence of our country. \n\nThose of us in the House who are fathers of daughters will understand all too well the deep rage that wells up at the mere thought of someone doing harm to our daughters. I want to assure the House that I take the bill very seriously indeed, and that I really mean what I am about to say. Those of us who have sons should be aware that, because of the higher number of men serving, 40% of sexual assault cases involve male victims.\n\nLike all of us, I had heard over the years horror stories involving sexual predation in the military, and I assumed, after having listened to the media, that this bill would be a sort of rubber stamp because everyone would want it. I assumed that victims of sexual predation in the military would want to stay far away from anybody in uniform. I assumed the victims would believe they would get a better shake in an inherently less structured and more liberal civilian justice system. I thought the victims would associate the military with the crime and understandably believe that, if their case were to be tried in the military, somehow the chain of command could influence the outcome, even though it has nothing to do with actual chain of command.\n\nThe Liberals told us that the victims of criminal sexual assault would be too traumatized to choose between a civilian investigation and a military investigation. It was best, according to the Liberals, if the state chose for them. This sounded a little bit like the old TV show Father Knows Best.\n\nWhen we first started this investigation, I had no reason to believe that the victims would want anything to do with the military system, so I let it go. I think there are all sorts of other problems with the bill that we could fix with other amendments, and I am sure my colleagues will address those, but I want to talk specifically about the importance of choice.\n\nLike I said, I had assumed that no one would object to moving the crime into the civilian system. I was shocked. I was surprised at the responses of the academics, the military and the civilian police, and I was truly shocked at the response of the victims.\n\nWe talked to academics. One professor pointed out that the conviction rate for sexual offences was not very high in the military justice system. Another academic, former JAG officer Rory Fowler, responded that, if the object were a high rate of conviction, perhaps Canada should emulate the North Korean justice system. He said that, quite likely, the reason for a low rate of conviction was an excellent defence team available in the military and referenced a recent high-profile case in which a JAG lawyer, Major Francesca Ferguson, supplied quality defence for a private who was falsely accused, right up to the Supreme Court.\n\nRory Fowler argued that the culture in the military has changed radically over the years. Back in the 1990s and earlier in this century, high-profile cases of sexual predation drew national attention to a real problem with sexual assault and the way it was handled in the military justice system. As a result, the government reacted and ordered high-level independent reviews of the military's handling of sexual assault in the military. The Deschamps report came out 11 years ago and the Fish and Arbour reports followed it. They all had ideas for change. The Arbour report had 48 recommendations, including steering victims toward the civilian justice system.\n\nThe problems in the military had not just kicked off a few reports, like most government studies do. They also kicked off a significant institutional culture change within the military. The senior leaders in the CAF did not just treat the Arbour and Fish reports as annoyances that had to be suffered through; they treated them as a new mission. \n\nBy late last year, the CAF had actioned all 48 of the Arbour report recommendations and were still actively engaged in culture change. Culture change is much faster in a top-down chain of command. When the organization is built around instant obedience, instant cultural change can happen very quickly when it comes from the top in a sincere effort.\n\n Next, we listened to the defence and prosecution teams from the military. They argued that the studies the bill was responding to were out of date or no longer applied to current military culture. They said that they had both the know-how and the professionalism to handle the job. In fact, they said they were surprised to learn that the Liberals intended to remove jurisdiction because the CAF had made sweeping changes and spent enormous effort reforming the system. They also said the culture of the CAF had changed. We have two bodies of experts who are saying that the culture has changed.\n\n Then we listened to the civilian police who told us that, although they had the capability, they no longer had the capacity to absorb yet more work, especially in locations with military bases close by. One such police chief told us that the witnesses might be scattered in redeployments to other jurisdictions in Canada or internationally. She said a case in those circumstances would be almost impossible for her department to investigate.\n\n Then we listened to the victims of sexual assault in the military. These brave soldiers rose above the crimes that were done to them and were brave enough to testify in front of the nation in hopes that what had happened to them would not happen to others. Their testimony shocked me. These are the very people I thought would have the strongest desire to stay out of the military system, but the vast majority insisted that they wanted a choice. For various reasons, they wanted a choice.\n\n After numerous victims spoke, it became obvious that the victims wanted choice, so we co-operated with the Bloc member on the committee to amend an outdated Liberal motion into one that every stakeholder, from victim to investigator, wanted. Our amendments gave the victims choice. Dr. Karen Breeck, a former medical officer in the CAF and a victim of sexual assault, put it to us succinctly:\n\n First, the military of 2025 [has changed]. Today the chain of command has extensive awareness and training. The sexual misconduct support and resource centre is fully operational. Victims' rights legislation is in force. Independent legal and victim supports exist. What evidence still shows that [the civilian system] remains the best way forward? \n\nSo far so good, but late Friday afternoon, the Minister of National Defence tabled Bill C-11 at report stage. Instead of our amended bill, and in defiance of civilian lawyers, military lawyers, civilian police, military police and even the victims themselves, what came into the House had been stripped of all our amendments. Why? It is because the artificial Liberal majority can now just stiff our soldiers and download the problem onto lower levels of government. The Liberals are not doing it to help our soldiers. They are doing it to push the problem off the federal plate, and then they will just not have to worry about it anymore.\n\n I appeal to my fellow veterans and to the MPs on the other side of the aisle to listen carefully to what one of our own veterans had to say about this. The veteran said that this bill, if it were stripped of all the amendments that were asked for by victims, cannot claim to be putting people first and that the bill, without the amendments, is not about making life easier for uniformed members but about making life easier for politicians. That is a very different thing and it is, frankly, dishonourable.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300672","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-11, when it first came to the national defence committee, was meant to transfer sexual assault cases from the military to the civilian justice system. It was not supposed to be a controversial bill. It arose because of the need to address sexual assault in the military. All of us in the House have, I believe, deep down, the best interests of Canadians at heart.\n\nAs a former off","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a30b18e3c21bed88a04d3cf694efe3ad4113f6ebab0599878f2bba0f2a20e27"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["faea84f8bbe1ba955402785ece0fb20b54346da4a1dc53fc85faa9e3f3b04060"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b979d81a5e7b0362acc8192c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300673,"date":"2026-04-23T17:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member, a veteran himself, knows very well that, in the military, with a top-down chain of command, culture can change very fast, because it is an order-based society.\n\n The Arbour report is several years old, and the culture did not stop to wait for the Arbour report. Right away, the military started the culture change, and you know that very well. You know that if you go back—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300673","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member, a veteran himself, knows very well that, in the military, with a top-down chain of command, culture can change very fast, because it is an order-based society.\n\n The Arbour report is several years old, and the culture did not stop to wait for the Arbour report. Right away, the military started the culture change, and you know that very well. You know that if you go back—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c7c59592a28fa6a8f02b9a9b97c9fc47e0b4d5ead34579935685b63c6b4f3651"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f7f5eb932c20fc626435adc2658a08cee4c12943692089883c096b4a086f06e5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ff075aae3608a9d9117b7ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300674,"date":"2026-04-23T17:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I apologize. However, if the member is acquainted with the military today, he knows very well that the culture has radically changed in a very short period of time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300674","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I apologize. However, if the member is acquainted with the military today, he knows very well that the culture has radically changed in a very short period of time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","label":"Military training","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["185ab6897d4c07c431fa80f70f08e6bfc8f464db005f03b3adddceb67098f7e9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9bc1f3036f9b3fb8838589ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300675,"date":"2026-04-23T17:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have put to us that we should remove choice because victims are going to be too traumatized after an assault to actually make a choice. This reminds me of the 19th-century idea that women became hysterical and really had to be directed and taught by men, because when they became hysterical, they were not capable of making good choices. I find that this is paternalistic and insulting to the women who are victims. Frankly, the Liberals are simply throwing out the Arbour report as if it concretizes their point, but it does not. It tends to push people toward the civilian system, but it does not make it mandatory.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300675","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have put to us that we should remove choice because victims are going to be too traumatized after an assault to actually make a choice. This reminds me of the 19th-century idea that women became hysterical and really had to be directed and taught by men, because when they became hysterical, they were not capable of making good choices. I find that this is paternalistic an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","label":"Gender discrimination","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e6f3fcf4afc9504a5b342ee78ed8a62a205aa198a529641b5b18556cf7fa6fff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6e00815412da6cebd87d5167239cf58eb0a76ebe4a5c5eb890538a8179bb5df5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac23aa5384de08d92cd16369","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300676,"date":"2026-04-23T17:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this bill, in its original intent, and that is the reason the amendments were stripped off, is simply to help the government, because the government has to deal with these problems when they arise. If the Liberals get it off their plate and dump it into the municipal police force or into the civilian provincial courts, they will not have to deal with it anymore and it will now be somebody else's problem. \n\nI just do not see how the Liberals can keep a straight face and keep saying \"Arbour\" over and over again as if it means something. It does not. The victims want choice.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300676","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this bill, in its original intent, and that is the reason the amendments were stripped off, is simply to help the government, because the government has to deal with these problems when they arise. If the Liberals get it off their plate and dump it into the municipal police force or into the civilian provincial courts, they will not have to deal with it anymore and it will now be some","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["68b36353aef7ccd990853a696dc2a3a2db2109a421aadc123e08b98df4f3a8bb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9472634a1c72596245274ca0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300669,"date":"2026-04-24T15:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Winston Churchill famously remarked that democracy is the worst form of government except for all the others. The parliamentary system is not a perfect system. It is only as good as the actors in it. When 93% of the electorate votes for the party and not for the candidate, and only 7% vote for the candidate, that is a distortion of democracy in the way parliamentary democracy is set up.\n\n The member mentioned reinstating the $1,000, because the same problem applies to the people in the long ballot. They are doing this. I was wondering if the member could talk about the $1,000 reinstatement—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300669","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Winston Churchill famously remarked that democracy is the worst form of government except for all the others. The parliamentary system is not a perfect system. It is only as good as the actors in it. When 93% of the electorate votes for the party and not for the candidate, and only 7% vote for the candidate, that is a distortion of democracy in the way parliamentary democracy is set u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["06a65dccffbd209fc249fc650384f329eb0e2fd73249ead2629b290f9f2b3a54"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["db21f8d25e9b74ddd0f5b1d34a795f518d1adc6375a5eb6f4abfd1f76e20896f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7e2effea8445f7e95bfa308","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300670,"date":"2026-04-24T17:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, parliamentary democracy is a loose framework and is only as good as the actors in it. If the actors use good ethics, then it works well. For example, when 93% of the electorate votes for the party customarily rather than for the candidate and when a floor crossing happens in a case like that, we can see intent of parliamentary democracy.\n\nI wonder if my colleague could expand on whether she considers the long ballot to be similarly detrimental to democracy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300670","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, parliamentary democracy is a loose framework and is only as good as the actors in it. If the actors use good ethics, then it works well. For example, when 93% of the electorate votes for the party customarily rather than for the candidate and when a floor crossing happens in a case like that, we can see intent of parliamentary democracy.\n\nI wonder if my colleague could expand on wheth","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18ff2bb01574ba92d812e348eb2b31a69bd482ab8494d2c22fbc60c6001f539a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2117c8277400012fbbd3c0279f4c9e2bb699709ff9dbd25e3b79c9c4e3738a75"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a49d0c489a51acb8a3c77541","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109614,"date":"2026-04-27T16:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. Thank you very much for appearing, Mr. Guzman, and the same goes to the folks you brought with you. Many of us have taken a pay cut to work here, and I understand you took a pay cut as well. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109614","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Thank you very much for appearing, Mr. Guzman, and the same goes to the folks you brought with you. Many of us have taken a pay cut to work here, and I understand you took a pay cut as well. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["267f55c8eb8644ebc620ce18be8e3291f282554b6f0c96e755ad096490663fe0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc7c08ff0df2d5f262c20e4c64c77b4041b1450c121f7b6cf731fb44c8db1448"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd3922d8acbc4d98a05dd68f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109615,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. Have you heard of the dollar-a-year men?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109615","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. Have you heard of the dollar-a-year men?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","label":"Gold","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7232c4dba03a77703d7c3918ffdeb863da9add520689f5b2592b88f0cac1b1f5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71a319804cdf08cf2b3aecff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109616,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"What were they?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109616","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What were they?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a13fd6d562db76d4c3151667","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109617,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"They were paid a dollar a year.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109617","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"They were paid a dollar a year.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc3f5b4b00ae6081bf369903","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109618,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"When you expressed your desire to help, did you offer to be paid nothing to do this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109618","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"When you expressed your desire to help, did you offer to be paid nothing to do this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unpaid work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036415","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Non-repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036415","label":"Non-repayable contributions","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","label":"Unpaid work","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["03eceb850080f3c7d11a0e617e015a94956f0bcf170c72522a8ec375bab296b2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4442b8aec98a47eba4b471df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109619,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"You didn't. You said it's beyond your pay grade. Your pay grade is the highest in the government at the moment, I believe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109619","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You didn't. You said it's beyond your pay grade. Your pay grade is the highest in the government at the moment, I believe.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3cf06b61da42c923b67e7c697846e0f8972fda2211a50671ec950128198d78f8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb3f9ecaf0c0213cf061d68d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109620,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I don't think there's much that's above your pay grade, then. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109620","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I don't think there's much that's above your pay grade, then. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00f582dcaeb7d9bbbaf129fcf79be37f659ecbad34868641b5f05d41b1e56988"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b13858c7f4d7f19dfdf1a230","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109621,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes, it is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109621","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, it is.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6d6aeb7867a23ba6dadd95e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109622,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Exactly. Okay. The media reports that you plan to hire up to 400 people and you're poaching predominantly from three departments: Public Services, Innovation and DND, of course. If you fail to deliver on a project, is any portion of your salary going to be cut?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Poaching","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109622","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Exactly. Okay. The media reports that you plan to hire up to 400 people and you're poaching predominantly from three departments: Public Services, Innovation and DND, of course. If you fail to deliver on a project, is any portion of your salary going to be cut?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","label":"Poaching"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Poaching","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","label":"Poaching","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7482e7ad18192485869efe830f6261d810f2bbe785d3dee57dd43924f268f311"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Poaching","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f85da3073573bdb4ace78dd8e7050fc580b59ba09f22729893a3696b0ec5757"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Poaching","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-705796040c81633d8aa18163","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109623,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"In other words, is it set up like the private sector where you have bonuses, incentives and so on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109623","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In other words, is it set up like the private sector where you have bonuses, incentives and so on?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca2be0d132356ca306ddb22d25fe5ceef2102049df14b945842a8fa4eb817c60"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78338ad6c5d884c952f1e5e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109624,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"There is, so you will fail to get that if there is a failure. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109624","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There is, so you will fail to get that if there is a failure. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["533afcfaa491b7e2bebb56b271373be13bdcec1a37c15e8a1dc4c54ca18b2bca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f53405e1f0b6ed9b52e4189","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109625,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"In whose hands...?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109625","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In whose hands...?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-884307a9b633f29062c6f536","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109626,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. How do you respond to the concern...? Never mind, you already answered that. That's fine.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109626","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. How do you respond to the concern...? Never mind, you already answered that. That's fine.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-602156e4961020dc56b789e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109627,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"You mentioned that you sped up the procurement of the rifles that we just did. In fact, that was started between 2009 and 2015 by the Harper government. That is when that project was done. It seemed to hit a dead spot for 10 years, and then, in 2024, responding to \"we absolutely have to do that,\" it was picked. It seems to me that you came along and picked that off the top and are claiming credit for doing it, when, in fact, it's been in operation for over two decades. Can you explain that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109627","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You mentioned that you sped up the procurement of the rifles that we just did. In fact, that was started between 2009 and 2015 by the Harper government. That is when that project was done. It seemed to hit a dead spot for 10 years, and then, in 2024, responding to \"we absolutely have to do that,\" it was picked. It seems to me that you came along and picked that off the top and are claiming credit ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eea69b2948228d99c455c14e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109628,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Actually, it's been two decades.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109628","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Actually, it's been two decades.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d06c27c9e2fcea7ec834c7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109629,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"With respect, if I may, this has been going on for two decades, not 12 years. In fact, it was ready for delivery when you were appointed. I will put to you that there is not much that has been sped up in this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109629","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"With respect, if I may, this has been going on for two decades, not 12 years. In fact, it was ready for delivery when you were appointed. I will put to you that there is not much that has been sped up in this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e0d54a8035969c3f87afc27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109630,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. With regard to Canadian sovereignty and weapons procurement, in our submarines, the combat systems, weaponry and communications—the three primary operational aspects—are all American. We're shooting their MK-48 torpedos in mods four and seven. What steps are we taking to replace this? We can get all the fancy Canadian hardware in the world, but if we have nothing to shoot from it.... What are we doing to switch over our armaments?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109630","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. With regard to Canadian sovereignty and weapons procurement, in our submarines, the combat systems, weaponry and communications—the three primary operational aspects—are all American. We're shooting their MK-48 torpedos in mods four and seven. What steps are we taking to replace this? We can get all the fancy Canadian hardware in the world, but if we have nothing to shoot from it.... What ar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fca09370ed330c0184c1a9c5fac514fa0e84d3b06ade88210c3cb82845af355a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6fd0825151de1f0e74dfcc9f4d103133771348b9bf2a42903e583ac8e74f67d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d1923c614fdcb4145731052","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109631,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"It's your job to fix that, sir.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109631","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's your job to fix that, sir.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2dd9cd175ffecb74a924b37c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109632,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Are we doing that, though, now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109632","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are we doing that, though, now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25c5d0c78c7c73574c53b955","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109633,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Sir, I only have five minutes, so I really have to try to make this count. What are we doing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109633","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Sir, I only have five minutes, so I really have to try to make this count. What are we doing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6d6d606deb33a5f2ff8645d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109634,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Specifically with weapons systems, what are we doing now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109634","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Specifically with weapons systems, what are we doing now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18da0b4420be6fcf8b139c409679a85b3005c70d2f1dee2549a1efb6a07e6266"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e34d7158beaf9bb50f0ae129","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109635,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"We are not operationally pushing to create a Canadian industry in arms right now. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109635","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We are not operationally pushing to create a Canadian industry in arms right now. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d953f6f2123bd36de3feacf06f88f8b0adcc692ad4e2e706a173963239fcc141"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2cb564feccadb6302c4add8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109636,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Are you involved in the F-35 purchase at all?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109636","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Are you involved in the F-35 purchase at all?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5648dd9869cd3249f30c968a9b609791a8023bad77458fa7a8b59c334291c74e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06b5a58fc132185434ea383f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109637,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Stephen Fuhr has said that it's not his file, and you're saying that it's not your file. I'm not sure whose file it is, but it's certainly sitting there. The strategy is full of forums, councils and industry days. In terms of actual procurement timelines, do you have timelines set up right now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109637","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Stephen Fuhr has said that it's not his file, and you're saying that it's not your file. I'm not sure whose file it is, but it's certainly sitting there. The strategy is full of forums, councils and industry days. In terms of actual procurement timelines, do you have timelines set up right now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c86cc7441f0e347b9e31b78f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109638,"date":"2026-04-27T16:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"In terms of producing something....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109638","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In terms of producing something....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-063f2f400ef1c024bcdb3c82","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109639,"date":"2026-04-27T16:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"You have timelines—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109639","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You have timelines—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-adbb06df0b6b42d8a8a4f117","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109640,"date":"2026-04-27T17:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. Mr. Guzman, my colleague asked you a question, and I didn't really catch the answer. Is the U.S. a trusted ally? You talked around the question. You didn't answer the question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109640","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Mr. Guzman, my colleague asked you a question, and I didn't really catch the answer. Is the U.S. a trusted ally? You talked around the question. You didn't answer the question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1c4a49cecf5fc63d0ac4dd5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109641,"date":"2026-04-27T17:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm aware of what we do with the U.S. I'm asking a question. It's a matter of opinion, but it's a matter of opinion that directs our future behaviour.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109641","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm aware of what we do with the U.S. I'm asking a question. It's a matter of opinion, but it's a matter of opinion that directs our future behaviour.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["999963979241c9bc19638085f4db3c634e6a6c0bf1e3fa5aa3a7e35377625708"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9177ccd97a78b6bb377b407","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109642,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"In your opinion, is the U.S. a trusted ally?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109642","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In your opinion, is the U.S. a trusted ally?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e078f28ba05eeb1024be7ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109643,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm asking your opinion, and that's what makes it relevant right now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109643","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm asking your opinion, and that's what makes it relevant right now.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f18fcb6bf4b24fa876155ec19d9f2e0f7174dce831941e08577637fb6aa2921"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e1b7ee61f83a089c37b0156","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109644,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Are they a trusted ally?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109644","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Are they a trusted ally?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c191d479f354da1f582cd88e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109645,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I understand that. With regard to sovereign capabilities, you mentioned that with a submarine, it didn't slow it down. My understanding is that the two bids that were accepted were submitted on March 2. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109645","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I understand that. With regard to sovereign capabilities, you mentioned that with a submarine, it didn't slow it down. My understanding is that the two bids that were accepted were submitted on March 2. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44256","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Submarines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44256","label":"Submarines","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2742392ad0968266f52e28987bda9f028b128a9a6da4edf9b60abaca9af1abcd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-94cf7eb22c07a03eefdc036b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109646,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"In April, we added a new requirement. You said that didn't add time to it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109646","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In April, we added a new requirement. You said that didn't add time to it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5815a9bad398384218c8a3ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109647,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"You added a requirement to it, which actually extended the time. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109647","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You added a requirement to it, which actually extended the time. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05a42187e9823c09423cfbde","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109648,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Would it have been two weeks of doing nothing, then, otherwise?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109648","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Would it have been two weeks of doing nothing, then, otherwise?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa17e3b815012c157ff5a19e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109649,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's fair enough. Do you have any government experience, Mr. Guzman?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109649","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's fair enough. Do you have any government experience, Mr. Guzman?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31d6ff54b91d82473768aed1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109650,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes, but have you worked in government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109650","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, but have you worked in government?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-74a745d8ea91e8a3f7a2c4ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109651,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I've noticed that, a lot of the time, you're spreading these questions out because you don't know the answers to them. I understand that in a leadership capacity, it's what you do. You don't have experience in meshing.... You come with private experience, which is distinctly different from government process.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109651","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I've noticed that, a lot of the time, you're spreading these questions out because you don't know the answers to them. I understand that in a leadership capacity, it's what you do. You don't have experience in meshing.... You come with private experience, which is distinctly different from government process.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c4c87c622c46fb1898ea583","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109652,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. What metric do you use to find a balance between sovereignty and cost?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109652","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. What metric do you use to find a balance between sovereignty and cost?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3d3df3138a447a625d69aae516e3a2d2d3fa14c130504621be3da537d7326d3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1790e2bffd7da2b768f003b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109653,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes. You want to have Canadian content, which will add a cost, in most cases.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109653","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes. You want to have Canadian content, which will add a cost, in most cases.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86956","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Sponsorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86956","label":"Sponsorship","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23d0bc3c67e8e9bc05e749674556692e4e4f4d3a793d302cccd0e685a62be270"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a3a10d85b2a6a17f21625c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109654,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do you use a metric, though?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109654","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Do you use a metric, though?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-910428f5b29285360e5165d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109655,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"You have a grid.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109655","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You have a grid.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61d10f42dab5fa73d9edd27b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109656,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Is the $100-million threshold arbitrary, or is there something behind it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109656","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Is the $100-million threshold arbitrary, or is there something behind it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70542","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Minimum wage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70542","label":"Minimum wage","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7faeb35a42b4e5a66999cb997e3a1983894dd35ce0b956f14e410bfb6c0df49a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf283bfd235d52c6a2a54a0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109657,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"You're planning to buy Canadian. How are you planning to stop foreign countries from gaming the system by claiming to be Canadian?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109657","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You're planning to buy Canadian. How are you planning to stop foreign countries from gaming the system by claiming to be Canadian?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036587","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Panamerican games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036587","label":"Panamerican games","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3e617ada175a489451921745802b5d059331d87273c8ed55124a768ad7a48ce"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57ac5b4b6d5d7f51959b8b68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109658,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"We're talking about us, though. How are you going to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109658","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We're talking about us, though. How are you going to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66e88751ba7bd08d52fa92f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109659,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's regardless of whether they're foreign-owned.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109659","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"That's regardless of whether they're foreign-owned.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7560fab81eb5db0ff3984a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109660,"date":"2026-04-27T17:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. You're being paid at a premium to fix procurement. What are your top three measurable outcomes for this year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-33/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109660","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. You're being paid at a premium to fix procurement. What are your top three measurable outcomes for this year?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","label":"Life expectancy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["33799f2e2990d4bd15f6e40716c5f38da9e565ac85dff6c05b5909974846a6fb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c67882863894558ee0c75b85","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725120,"date":"2026-04-27T18:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite has put a new face on what happened. In fact, the government has been trolling our benches, and some did slither over.\n\nThe House is not reflective of Canadians' wishes. About 93% of the vote goes to the party now, by custom, and about 7% goes to the individual. By law, yes, we are elected as individuals.\n\nThe Liberal Party's explanation is that it is \"a big tent\", but I would say it is more like a circus tent.\n\n I wonder if the member agrees with the views of his party's newest acquisition on vaccines and the convoy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725120","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member opposite has put a new face on what happened. In fact, the government has been trolling our benches, and some did slither over.\n\nThe House is not reflective of Canadians' wishes. About 93% of the vote goes to the party now, by custom, and about 7% goes to the individual. By law, yes, we are elected as individuals.\n\nThe Liberal Party's explanation is that it is \"a big tent\",","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8569e7438953a38f4cfcbcc031e6abbd0a92d6d2d72d758f3f70bdec5c27fe44"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a14e051516dda1fce424eea0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109661,"date":"2026-04-29T22:05:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. I'm afraid that I have to use English. My French is non-existent, and the only alternative is Spanish, which would probably make a mess for all of us here. Mr. Villandré, you mentioned that munitions were in the ground there. They told you that it was a low risk in the area they did, and you ran into munitions. Did they give you any timeline for when these munitions become inert in the ground?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109661","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I'm afraid that I have to use English. My French is non-existent, and the only alternative is Spanish, which would probably make a mess for all of us here. Mr. Villandré, you mentioned that munitions were in the ground there. They told you that it was a low risk in the area they did, and you ran into munitions. Did they give you any timeline for when these munitions become ine","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","label":"Military technology","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f8d0e790707177204dd6963e7969608d67460ba092258aedf3e325df51576c12"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6afb82f7b77c04ba3a1b63ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109662,"date":"2026-04-29T22:05:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Were you told any size for the munitions and whether they were small munitions or large munitions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109662","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Were you told any size for the munitions and whether they were small munitions or large munitions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47488","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Chemical weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47488","label":"Chemical weapons","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e2ed2f722cca2a4891851ab3d9b2a9406f7464faa214a5bb68bca007567b61b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80960bc051e0398964748ec0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109663,"date":"2026-04-29T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Of course. In effect, you were given no technical information whatsoever about the site.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109663","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Of course. In effect, you were given no technical information whatsoever about the site.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d06bdfcbdba95ffcf3bbe38f84240e1a4e0502108cc369186eb0befa2e99b3b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66888ac99a92258658fc2a3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109664,"date":"2026-04-29T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Thank you very much. I'm sorry. There's a bit of a lag in translation, so if I wait a minute, it's because I'm listening to that. Ms. Perreault, you mentioned a figure of $35 million. I'm trying to clarify that in my mind. I'm not clear what that was associated with.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109664","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you very much. I'm sorry. There's a bit of a lag in translation, so if I wait a minute, it's because I'm listening to that. Ms. Perreault, you mentioned a figure of $35 million. I'm trying to clarify that in my mind. I'm not clear what that was associated with.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ab6a38c1293090a7f217a51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109665,"date":"2026-04-29T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. The federal government paid for that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109665","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. The federal government paid for that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87b4d7c53440f5f5766abccf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109666,"date":"2026-04-29T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Did the military admit that they are the source of the contamination? Was that ever at any point an issue?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109666","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Did the military admit that they are the source of the contamination? Was that ever at any point an issue?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015021","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Biological weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59927","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military police","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59927","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Military police","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015021","label":"Biological weapons","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","label":"Pollution","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59927","label":"Military police","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["557dbd3e8171ea7e0e92706ddabb94a5a28f1ec3684c57f34bd8fc449501bd6b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe950894d5165b15daf52f01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109667,"date":"2026-04-29T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes, it does. Thank you very much. I want to clarify something else. You mentioned that the property values have not lowered. They've recouped, in any event. Does that mean the effects on the water table are gone now? Have they remediated themselves through time, or do they still need remediation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109667","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, it does. Thank you very much. I want to clarify something else. You mentioned that the property values have not lowered. They've recouped, in any event. Does that mean the effects on the water table are gone now? Have they remediated themselves through time, or do they still need remediation?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a400cfbc2df5b83e64056cbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109668,"date":"2026-04-29T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-34/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109668","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5cac33d15a701c09960efc0c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725111,"date":"2026-04-30T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, with regard to Norway's sovereign wealth fund, I decided to do the same thing as the Prime Minister, because he is a wise person. I decided that what I would do is take the bulk of the money out of my credit card, put it in my savings account and call it \"Scott's retirement fund\". Then I went to my accountant, who said that I would never retire. I was wondering if the member could explain to me why that is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725111","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, with regard to Norway's sovereign wealth fund, I decided to do the same thing as the Prime Minister, because he is a wise person. I decided that what I would do is take the bulk of the money out of my credit card, put it in my savings account and call it \"Scott's retirement fund\". Then I went to my accountant, who said that I would never retire. I was wondering if the member could exp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","label":"Personal finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","label":"Personal finance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b8b6d3dfa04ac5f744314edeb288d23238441647d4b9b9450a42f153bf893564"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d2431d018f84db76dcc710f64ba0b63b76ff812752259738abe0789920a9abf2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93273227769edc2cea23bce7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725117,"date":"2026-04-30T18:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, with regard to the sovereign wealth fund, I recently asked my colleague the same question. The other day, my neighbour showed me his bank account, and it was enormous. I thought, \"This is a secret\", so I maxed out my credit cards and put the money in my savings account. For some reason, when I went to my accountant, he said I will never retire.\n\nI am wondering if the member can explain to me the difference between my neighbour's bank account, in which he saved money over time, and my savings account that I just put money into. Can you explain the difference between those two?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725117","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, with regard to the sovereign wealth fund, I recently asked my colleague the same question. The other day, my neighbour showed me his bank account, and it was enormous. I thought, \"This is a secret\", so I maxed out my credit cards and put the money in my savings account. For some reason, when I went to my accountant, he said I will never retire.\n\nI am wondering if the member can explai","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["536d7a97c52894eb642922f8cc3759961fbad66555560eae28a278617e580aba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8624ea548268ab8731df72f51c26c2df7bc06ecd96c7eb5fcf51c4e4a6b16ace"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f5d803e4155a5764c7d4a663","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109669,"date":"2026-05-27T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. All my future questions will be through you. Mr. Ziadé, I love the acronym of your association, ACDC, by the way. I got in a lot of trouble associated with that acronym in my younger days. Voices: Oh, oh! Scott Anderson: Academic after academic and expert after expert who have come before these committees have all mentioned either \"grey zone\" warfare or prekinetic warfare. Some of them have said that we're in a situation similar to 1913 or 1939, before each of the two world wars. All of them have used the term \"war\" to describe the situation we're in right now. What that means to me is that there is a great deal of haste in rearming our forces right now. Given the apparent urgency of rearming, and especially if we want to rearm with deterrence rather than with war fighting in mind, would you support our buying off the shelf initially to rearm for operational needs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109669","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. All my future questions will be through you. Mr. Ziadé, I love the acronym of your association, ACDC, by the way. I got in a lot of trouble associated with that acronym in my younger days. Voices: Oh, oh! Scott Anderson: Academic after academic and expert after expert who have come before these committees have all mentioned either \"grey zone\" warfare or prekinetic w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036297","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036297","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036297","label":"Military engineering","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c98e6ae400429eb19e3aefac06aca90f5cf2ebb90e3a833fca30a608e54fcfb5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e071819c8c3531de01224d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109670,"date":"2026-05-27T22:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"If you don't mind—I only have five minutes here—I'd like to ask the same question of Mr. Mueller.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109670","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If you don't mind—I only have five minutes here—I'd like to ask the same question of Mr. Mueller.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dab7ab68e66061109f815585","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109671,"date":"2026-05-27T22:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"What I'm getting at, though, is that there seem to be two separate problems, and we're conflating the two of them in this discussion: rearming our forces and making them Canadian-owned. There are two different things. We need haste in rearming right now. We may have that capability in the longer term, but in the short term, we do not have it. It took over 30 years to develop the F-35. If we start from a perfect situation right now, we're looking at 30 years—2055—before we actually have this thing. We don't have that time, or at least the academics we've talked to say we don't have that time. We're faced with two separate problems. Would you say that we have two problems that we're conflating?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109671","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What I'm getting at, though, is that there seem to be two separate problems, and we're conflating the two of them in this discussion: rearming our forces and making them Canadian-owned. There are two different things. We need haste in rearming right now. We may have that capability in the longer term, but in the short term, we do not have it. It took over 30 years to develop the F-35. If we start ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d7a4c4da5edfb2ce2130d448255175f0055ee405b2a0e76521ffe17c16b97997"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fb0d4790f6434188b33915b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109672,"date":"2026-05-27T22:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Ms. Lussier, would you agree with that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109672","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Ms. Lussier, would you agree with that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20c6bca906fff801d38b33ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109673,"date":"2026-05-27T22:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109673","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you so much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88f0deaa8cde9ffa16988164","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109674,"date":"2026-05-27T22:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. I'll start again with Mr. Ziadé. There was a recent SAHA trade show in Istanbul. Canadians, specifically under the DIA, sent a trade delegation. The purpose of being there was to sell Canadian goods overseas, something that we should have done decades ago, in my opinion. The government should have been behind this. However, we got there, and I think that, much to their surprise, the Canadian delegation found that they had a mixed message. They are trying to get foreign governments to buy into our industry and buy our wares, but at the same time, they are announcing that we're going to keep 80% of our supply chain Canadian. It's a mixed message: \"Please buy our stuff, but we're not going to buy your stuff.\" In your opinion, how should we reconcile that message, and what should we be saying at these overseas trade shows?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109674","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much. I'll start again with Mr. Ziadé. There was a recent SAHA trade show in Istanbul. Canadians, specifically under the DIA, sent a trade delegation. The purpose of being there was to sell Canadian goods overseas, something that we should have done decades ago, in my opinion. The government should have been behind this. However, we got there, and I think that, much to their surpris","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["306f7077f13252375baaf7da1bb78da117eb8807a89edca41bf4787c326c9944"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86d14c56a2db79e49e995bcb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109675,"date":"2026-05-27T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"They're not mutually exclusive...?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109675","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"They're not mutually exclusive...?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b23842c92848b0fc8b5e3fb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109676,"date":"2026-05-27T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Mr. Mueller, could you answer the same question?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109676","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Mr. Mueller, could you answer the same question?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a8239d5ffe02994af321484","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109677,"date":"2026-05-27T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"What kind of message are we sending, though, if we're saying that we want them to buy our stuff, but we're not going to buy their stuff?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109677","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What kind of message are we sending, though, if we're saying that we want them to buy our stuff, but we're not going to buy their stuff?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67c77bcf7b3c85446289b956840ce30519506a5a4bc798f0342eb9056b225ba8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-444367e209036cb89f865940","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109678,"date":"2026-05-27T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Ms. Lussier, would you agree with that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109678","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Ms. Lussier, would you agree with that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73a8c7356a9f0f0a12e090fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109679,"date":"2026-05-27T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Let me return to this. We're doing these things. As you said, we're talking about messaging. We're messaging to companies. The companies aren't the only ones getting the message, though. Foreign governments are getting the message, our domestic voters are getting the message and so on and so forth. Are we taking steps that are long-term and structural right now that will deter the next administration next door to us from trying to repair some of the trade relations that have been disrupted? Are we creating long-term structural destruction to address what might be a short-term problem?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109679","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. Let me return to this. We're doing these things. As you said, we're talking about messaging. We're messaging to companies. The companies aren't the only ones getting the message, though. Foreign governments are getting the message, our domestic voters are getting the message and so on and so forth. Are we taking steps that are long-term and structural right now that will deter the next admin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-039202057f898b221a7385b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109680,"date":"2026-05-27T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"The government is not the aerospace industry, though. That's the trouble.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109680","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The government is not the aerospace industry, though. That's the trouble.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aerospace industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57704","label":"Aerospace industry","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee9e90688101cea60fdac684502233488f6d274c672cc48049026679fb62f314"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37a46fbdfb3f317f547afeb6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109681,"date":"2026-05-27T22:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I hope our government is listening to that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109681","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I hope our government is listening to that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-511b1f7382ee316186f8b7c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034958,"date":"2026-05-28T21:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I was trying to think of great artists in history, such Shakespeare, Michelangelo, Cicero and Plato. Some of them had private benefactors, but none of them, to my knowledge, had government support behind them. I cannot think of any artist that had government support—\n\nSome hon members: Oh, oh!\n\nScott Anderson: Mr. Speaker, on the other hand, I cannot think of any artist who did have government support and who is great. I cannot think of a great Soviet artist.\n\n I wonder if my colleague could tell us this: Is it because the Liberals hate Canadian culture?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Artists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034958","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I was trying to think of great artists in history, such Shakespeare, Michelangelo, Cicero and Plato. Some of them had private benefactors, but none of them, to my knowledge, had government support behind them. I cannot think of any artist that had government support—\n\nSome hon members: Oh, oh!\n\nScott Anderson: Mr. Speaker, on the other hand, I cannot think of any artist who did have g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","label":"Artists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Artists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","label":"Artists","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["37896f4a87edd2916792b7126eb52f9451d168bc4e083a3dd18abba4d0884b2a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Artists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["86cdae00332d6c02509046ec2f33fdd175a22bfd4b530ed082a08d9f9aa83011"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Artists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42850","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-566439b1656e8a60f9582ab8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109682,"date":"2026-06-01T16:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. The pace of adaptation in Ukraine is.... We can see it's entirely different. Symmetrical warfare has changed radically over the last two years. I don't see anything in the defence industrial strategy to keep up with or to maintain that nimbleness. We are always building for the last war. It's an adage that's true. Clearly, it's been true up to now. Our procurement strategy right now is quite hidebound. We want to change that. I'll start with you, Mr. Pyun. What is there that's built into the industrial strategy? Is there any proactive nimbleness built into your R and D?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109682","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. The pace of adaptation in Ukraine is.... We can see it's entirely different. Symmetrical warfare has changed radically over the last two years. I don't see anything in the defence industrial strategy to keep up with or to maintain that nimbleness. We are always building for the last war. It's an adage that's true. Clearly, it's been true up to now. Our procurement strategy rig","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a37b892141b7e85f2e6ff7cb9abc1af74cafaa38789806a35854458878ff5edb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5d72ac94c87dfc8d2f2b030b4ebba242ba81a9cd7cbc44c21e9496494c1a917"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0da703e8a3f89ba0e6b2a8ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109683,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do you find that the DIS addresses this problem?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109683","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you find that the DIS addresses this problem?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bff7299b846a7c881339a347","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109684,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Is there anything in the DIS—I haven't seen it—that envisions a crossover with the CAF and the things we're learning in Ukraine right now in order to direct the development?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109684","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is there anything in the DIS—I haven't seen it—that envisions a crossover with the CAF and the things we're learning in Ukraine right now in order to direct the development?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","label":"Intercity transport","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31ea02225e436012e2ff14bd8b1590094c50e265609a6e4a4c88891a55f42271"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f14d7e825a37d96d3394b49","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109685,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"One of the things that's brought up is the aspirational 70% Canadian content. I listened to Secretary Fuhr recently at a trade conference, where he used 80% as an aspirational. How realistic is it, at the current time, to have 70% Canadian content in our procurement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109685","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"One of the things that's brought up is the aspirational 70% Canadian content. I listened to Secretary Fuhr recently at a trade conference, where he used 80% as an aspirational. How realistic is it, at the current time, to have 70% Canadian content in our procurement?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3b0fdbd3f3dbbcf16ea3c94","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109686,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Well, we're watching and I'm asking a question—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109686","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Well, we're watching and I'm asking a question—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b956e1e3af7385c0d6c31be1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109687,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"It's aspirational 70% Canadian content.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109687","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's aspirational 70% Canadian content.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ebd1c15d34ade1c5385dfbd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109688,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109688","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-620ae2b4af65e62de34f07c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109689,"date":"2026-06-01T16:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"It's possible, but right now is it realistic? What is the rough percentage right now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109689","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's possible, but right now is it realistic? What is the rough percentage right now?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["223f45a5a4075a8c838c0301e3fccdf77eafd3421b39c145baf2cc8e4ba00532"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9c9e2e4ffea6db6d87365754","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109690,"date":"2026-06-01T17:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Sure it is in industrial capacity, but given the nimbleness to be able to switch, the previous question I asked was about being able to match the technologies of the future today because we pretty much have to do that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-38/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109690","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Sure it is in industrial capacity, but given the nimbleness to be able to switch, the previous question I asked was about being able to match the technologies of the future today because we pretty much have to do that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b85d0ca5f4f92eeb78a72f6bd5aac206975829be9632343e96111b5fc2c9a8c0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c7b124d61baee9e11ceb4d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109691,"date":"2026-06-03T21:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I believe the witness is speaking over the question, not the other way around.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109691","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I believe the witness is speaking over the question, not the other way around.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0005c833324386f349c0332d78fa38f4495ea8c1d85a1d70a2ac3a0127967f53"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27d550b247ca5768b300a545","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109692,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. All the questions will be through you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Fuhr, you have mentioned several times, and I've heard this repeatedly, that the DIA is going to be a one-stop shop. I wonder if you can supply us with a phone number for that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109692","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. All the questions will be through you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Fuhr, you have mentioned several times, and I've heard this repeatedly, that the DIA is going to be a one-stop shop. I wonder if you can supply us with a phone number for that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad043dc3c556561eb56d057b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109693,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"No, it's not your phone number, but the phone number for the DIA.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109693","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, it's not your phone number, but the phone number for the DIA.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88233","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Telehealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88233","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telehealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88233","label":"Telehealth","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d869e6c827ae79bbddc8fec34c4830a468e922c1110a7196048230515676d88"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-392ce8e8be2490c2914a736e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109694,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay, that's good. How many contracts have been signed with Canadian companies so far?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109694","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay, that's good. How many contracts have been signed with Canadian companies so far?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["437b4f2f68261e3bceba3b02a5ff868773d1f815318187124cb4d0b7d6edb543"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c544a3fde51695e76d4b425f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109695,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Give me a number.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109695","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Give me a number.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35df79f80cb92f5d80fd4ea2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109696,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I don't want to waste five minutes listing off these companies. Just give me a number. Is there no number?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109696","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I don't want to waste five minutes listing off these companies. Just give me a number. Is there no number?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efe44c6973fc6b92c9e547e4b2a743832cdf0c0b527abaeebb789eef0b3c4177"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1258fe6c7f8712750d01b934","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109697,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. How many foreign contracts have been signed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109697","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. How many foreign contracts have been signed?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7afe2e77771ea447596257b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109698,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"It's about the same for Canadian and foreign companies. Okay. Under division 16, the minister can access up to $1 billion dollars and, with that money, purchase equity in private companies and hire and fire boards of companies. Essentially, if you wanted to, or if the minister wanted to, they could simply buy a bunch of companies and call it procurement and Canadian-source it. You mentioned that this is standard procedure and it will be reported back to Parliament and everything. In fact, it doesn't have to be reported back. Can you name a single comparable federal procurement authority that allows that sort of expenditure without any accountability whatsoever and without the duty to report back to Parliament?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109698","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's about the same for Canadian and foreign companies. Okay. Under division 16, the minister can access up to $1 billion dollars and, with that money, purchase equity in private companies and hire and fire boards of companies. Essentially, if you wanted to, or if the minister wanted to, they could simply buy a bunch of companies and call it procurement and Canadian-source it. You mentioned that t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15002392a0276279b609ea03c38992aace36517b67a483bdd1f0857bc655273c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48aa4cf688cd90ec8f8aad3e521cc9ef2688fa829b2ab57336b2b55a8849dac7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ebbccb26a12ffeed09a8b7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109699,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I agree.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109699","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I agree.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56bfa68a814c2cdb671900d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109700,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Actually, it was very hard to get you here, sir.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109700","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Actually, it was very hard to get you here, sir.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ab772fc81e9f3a20e0099b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109701,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"We asked several times.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109701","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We asked several times.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f0b4025df313aee9f1346151","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109702,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Clause 32 allows the minister to exclude a company from the procurement on national security grounds without providing.... Can you name another body in the Canadian government that allows simply excluding companies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109702","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Clause 32 allows the minister to exclude a company from the procurement on national security grounds without providing.... Can you name another body in the Canadian government that allows simply excluding companies?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["323b6879b4ae7f4c7c8c5a52867af24ba08b73c8882a534c8801f730a376270b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea301e8c08df16dc320b54fdc658fa200768b2b8aa8dc84abe3a4a14079cf82d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-785e0d2c68c95012fd789c0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109703,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"No, sir. I'm asking you a question, and you're not answering.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109703","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, sir. I'm asking you a question, and you're not answering.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-063e460602d0df5a3c100bce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109704,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"What are they?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109704","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What are they?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5bdd8676582432e2b30dcceb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109705,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Exactly. That goes to the first question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109705","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Exactly. That goes to the first question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5468054db9404273a0bb6e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109706,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Go ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109706","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Go ahead.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e54f2723079b2b3d92a9f6ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109707,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's exactly what's going on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109707","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's exactly what's going on.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-adbe781a1ebe0399c83601ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109708,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm going to move on to the next question. The government frequently speaks about leveraging pension funds and private capital to support defence, and you mentioned integrating industry a few minutes ago. What roles do organizations like Brookfield and other institutional investors anticipate having in projects that are administered through the DIA?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109708","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm going to move on to the next question. The government frequently speaks about leveraging pension funds and private capital to support defence, and you mentioned integrating industry a few minutes ago. What roles do organizations like Brookfield and other institutional investors anticipate having in projects that are administered through the DIA?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26337289749729aea7fe7a5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109709,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"You're the one who's allowing it to happen, sir.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109709","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You're the one who's allowing it to happen, sir.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["823a76d9619472f40e25b4818da8458edade4eac5d92f1a9fa33ff9d923e80ba"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b439c87e5335c50ec7bc06e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109710,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"No, it hasn't happened. I'm asking you what safeguards are there. What sort of involvement.... Do you have a plan to go forward?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109710","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, it hasn't happened. I'm asking you what safeguards are there. What sort of involvement.... Do you have a plan to go forward?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-394cc2521c20d49d138fd135","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109711,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"There's no metric to govern this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109711","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There's no metric to govern this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d92343a43e52b421699f68e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109712,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"It's not your file.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109712","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's not your file.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6f5bdd1191d4e05f9a94cae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109713,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"The bill creates 13 separate exceptions to competitive procurement. Can you identify a single major defence procurement failure in Canada that occurred because they didn't have access to enough sole-source exemptions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109713","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The bill creates 13 separate exceptions to competitive procurement. Can you identify a single major defence procurement failure in Canada that occurred because they didn't have access to enough sole-source exemptions?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb1c0030d3ef6af6a23fe026466ad197d4a1cf44f9d8e1cce741c62bd325bf89"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efef39e92a348ce6f28f653e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109714,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's not their mission, though.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109714","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's not their mission, though.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a15c6a7f6535b88655eb640","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109715,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. I don't think that's how it went. The bill gives the minister authority to acquire shares in corporations and influence corporate government. Under what circumstances does the government believe it should become an owner of private defence companies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109715","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. I don't think that's how it went. The bill gives the minister authority to acquire shares in corporations and influence corporate government. Under what circumstances does the government believe it should become an owner of private defence companies?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91d29c1e7764f21919898e343e3775aed5216c2ea5b7e512d179c5a2e90bc8b2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05378fa22127205064e6cec3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109716,"date":"2026-06-03T23:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you. Can anybody tell me how many scientists work at BOREALIS full-time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109716","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Can anybody tell me how many scientists work at BOREALIS full-time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017769","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Boreal ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017769","label":"Boreal ecosystems","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff5cab702ceb2401286acffa7de6bab4414a39a8627da8dd10c7d552f8d756c1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d93beb29c136d80de504051","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109717,"date":"2026-06-03T23:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. Can you answer the same question for DRDC?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109717","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. Can you answer the same question for DRDC?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e981b35b4a42bf8ad50932a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109718,"date":"2026-06-03T23:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Is that 1,600 scientists?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109718","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is that 1,600 scientists?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ef705ae702cc755e07c6ac59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109719,"date":"2026-06-03T23:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Can you tell me how many bureaucrats work at BOREALIS—non-scientists?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109719","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Can you tell me how many bureaucrats work at BOREALIS—non-scientists?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18fed749351a00793c9735873afedd1467974d782ef49f4f3ec886c53a3b34f8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05a9e042b3759232beff7a2a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109720,"date":"2026-06-03T23:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Okay. Is it the same for DRDC?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109720","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Is it the same for DRDC?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1ef962b55a80c30d7f12b10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109721,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. When evaluating major procurements—this question would be for Mr. Robitaille—what weighting is assigned to military capability, cost, delivery schedule, industrial benefits, Canadian content and so on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109721","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. When evaluating major procurements—this question would be for Mr. Robitaille—what weighting is assigned to military capability, cost, delivery schedule, industrial benefits, Canadian content and so on?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","label":"Military technology","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cd08ff420c970a3a07870c9aa6fa022870745c8c1fa777799916a34e07484a47"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0de1b63fc420139a2050997cfc4cbc52ba13201b18d5c1b8fbe5d787f2165b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc26f04324499b2bc75ae475","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109722,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"In this case, would it reside with the minister or the CEO?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109722","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In this case, would it reside with the minister or the CEO?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f55bc2e7eaf880767f81ccd8c49e2c1d250bf35bdab54138b0844579b57dd94"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4616229addf0f9b4d17b9a7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109723,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Who makes the decision? Who establishes the metric you're going to use on each procurement problem?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109723","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Who makes the decision? Who establishes the metric you're going to use on each procurement problem?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3095dcf42a7c876d37bbe0a6dcfab7c94980f9781be0c1f65ed25a27a65cf805"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30976109f388f29104aaca55","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109724,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I want to clear up something here. The minister, the CEO or somebody in that department has the ability to use $1 billion dollars without reporting to Parliament before it's spent. Is that correct? Is there any mechanism in the DIS that forces the minister to report prior to spending money?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109724","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I want to clear up something here. The minister, the CEO or somebody in that department has the ability to use $1 billion dollars without reporting to Parliament before it's spent. Is that correct? Is there any mechanism in the DIS that forces the minister to report prior to spending money?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["caf517ddda1c2dc83e5cdaf1cd55c68f772138c077da8a39b10049cabf16c806"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09c7eb7f71a04aacd1970b72ae9fe3a8bd02c32213e5091ce6bb33cd829fab29"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2655bceb27f4372398c7b9e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109725,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"No, sir, I'm talking about this one here. I'm asking, is there a mechanism in the DIS and in the legislation that forces the minister to report prior to spending money?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109725","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, sir, I'm talking about this one here. I'm asking, is there a mechanism in the DIS and in the legislation that forces the minister to report prior to spending money?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b650dc9c41680174a128c88a236e744b885c8b05b713e63c3d9a163e8719152c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4487f4e52eafa3664ddd54da077ee228fdb4e53ed99727a8f4c058bbeef29dd2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63d134fee616732a3a69f5eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109726,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"Is that a yes or a no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109726","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is that a yes or a no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c599187614f3f4d7544813f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109727,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"All right, but I don't actually have an answer. I still don't know if the minister has to report that before spending money.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109727","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"All right, but I don't actually have an answer. I still don't know if the minister has to report that before spending money.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f0a54b8698836c6c1ce70d1dd93669a4e2daee1cb3fd00755514d15c59af92e3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62cd1ac4158eb921b0fd13ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109728,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"In that case, there is no metric set up for these things. There's no metric that can be slid around it. There's just a lot of collaboration.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109728","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In that case, there is no metric set up for these things. There's no metric that can be slid around it. There's just a lot of collaboration.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67f1476bbb7cedb0b0aa784a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109729,"date":"2026-06-03T23:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm going to turn the rest of my time over to my colleague.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109729","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm going to turn the rest of my time over to my colleague.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["529bdbb6679c362c62b2fcac634e551f133c3168684d4689d05547f30614477a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7f6f08206ffcccf9cc06e90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083760,"date":"2026-06-04T21:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague spoke about the poison pill. First of all, mandatory sentences, obviously, as my other colleague pointed out much earlier, do in fact stop crime because it is very hard to commit a crime when in jail. \n\nAs far as the poison pill goes, when I raised my kids and told them to clean their rooms, I did not say at the end of it, \"Unless you don't feel like it.\" This, I believe, is what is happening with this bill: If we do not feel like it, we do not have to obey the law. I would like my colleague to expand on that, if she would.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083760","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague spoke about the poison pill. First of all, mandatory sentences, obviously, as my other colleague pointed out much earlier, do in fact stop crime because it is very hard to commit a crime when in jail. \n\nAs far as the poison pill goes, when I raised my kids and told them to clean their rooms, I did not say at the end of it, \"Unless you don't feel like it.\" This, I believe,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["39e27db6bc0d0f12b6e6fc11a8af05a8dd96cc8436bdb63fd39dbe6ceda43991"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["37fd9ab1a9076bcbb9b5c4d735ed19e16490e0464047612714a26048b60efd58"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37b6b899dcca11b7c39c242d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087612,"date":"2026-06-18T01:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, this is one of the deepest debates in Canadian politics, between the rights and freedoms of citizens on one hand and the powers of government on the other hand. I wonder if my colleague could speculate on why the Liberals want to shut down debate like this, so pre-emptively.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087612","member_id":"bc-mp-89259","member_name":"Scott Anderson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, this is one of the deepest debates in Canadian politics, between the rights and freedoms of citizens on one hand and the powers of government on the other hand. I wonder if my colleague could speculate on why the Liberals want to shut down debate like this, so pre-emptively.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24a32d2597ab66f666b1c93f1b3bdccccedfdecc8f5f5e9e934f0633530ccac8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab5e9ceb7ee382f8f0c9113b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76196,"date":"2026-01-28T20:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am honoured today to present petition e-6795, which is sponsored by Chloe Dubois from Ocean Legacy Foundation. The petition has been signed by 659 Canadians who are deeply concerned about ghost gear: abandoned, lost or discarded fishing gear that is among the deadliest sources of plastic pollution. They are concerned that the Liberal government killed this very important program.\n\nPetitioners note that ghost gear kills fish, marine animals and species like wild salmon, seabirds and turtles; damages habitats; and creates microplastics and even hazards for navigation and active harvesters, which hurts coastal communities, our way of life and our economy.\n\nThey point out that the dedicated funding for retrieval, prevention, repair and recycling works, creating skilled jobs and partnerships with indigenous communities, small businesses, coastal people, fishers, harbour authorities and recyclers, especially in rural and remote areas.\n\nPetitioners are calling for the government to reinstate and expand a permanent multi-year ghost gear fund with streams for rapid retrieval response, prevention and innovation, including gear marking and tracking; whalesafe and ropeless pilots; end-of-life management, repair and recycling; community capacity; and indigenous guardian programs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76196","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am honoured today to present petition e-6795, which is sponsored by Chloe Dubois from Ocean Legacy Foundation. The petition has been signed by 659 Canadians who are deeply concerned about ghost gear: abandoned, lost or discarded fishing gear that is among the deadliest sources of plastic pollution. They are concerned that the Liberal government killed this very important program.\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","label":"Water pollution","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["79397512faba324ab00daa6f2b75b488fa2412c42db68ac04f5120939a1c755e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e239b7f2de31b67ac810e0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76197,"date":"2026-01-28T23:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on October 3, I asked the Minister of Agriculture if he would abandon the government's proposed regulatory changes to the plant breeders' rights in favour of supporting the rights of farmers who save and re-use their seed. The parliamentary secretary rose and responded that consultations have happened, which completely dodged the question. Less than a week later, on October 9, I rose in the House to present a petition signed by more than 6,000 Canadians who want the same answer to the same unanswered question.\n\nAmending the Plant Breeders' Rights Act, as the government has proposed to do, would be, as I said in October, harmful and reckless. It would force farmers to purchase seed annually, and it would drive up production costs, restrict access to new varieties and undermine the ability of farmers to adapt to climate change. It would undermine the age-old practice of farmers' using farm-safe seed, forcing them to buy seeds or pay royalties year after year.\n\nThat is what the CFIA's proposed regulatory changes would do to the people who grow Canada's fruit, vegetable, ornamental and hybrid varieties.\n\nI am rising again tonight on the issue because in the government's response to my e-petition 6778, which was signed by more than 6,000 Canadians, it missed the mark and left the farm community perplexed about whom the government is actually trying to help with its changes. It is certainly not the hard-working farmers who produce our food.\n\nThe National Farmers Union has been banging the alarm bell on this issue, and I want to thank its members for their tireless advocacy and for keeping this important issue at the forefront. Earlier this month they wrote to the agriculture minister expressing their disappointment with the government's response to the e-petition and, once again, urging the government to abandon its proposed amendments to the plant breeders' rights regulations removing farmer privilege to certain crops.\n\nThat letter from the National Farmers Union was co-signed by many other major agricultural stakeholder groups from across Canada, including the Atlantic Canadian Organic Regional Network, the Canada Organic Trade Association, the Canadian Organic Growers, the Canadian Biotechnology Action Network, the Ecological Farmers Association of Ontario, FarmFolk CityFolk, Friends of the Earth Canada, Growers of Organic Food Yukon, Manitoba Organics, Organic Alberta, SaskOrganics, SeedChange and Young Agrarians.\n\nThe co-signatories on the letter feel the government's response to this issue was inadequate and is not reflective of a government that purports to take farmers' concerns seriously. They note that the government failed to provide a thoughtful response that properly acknowledged the validity of the points made in the e-petition, including forcing farmers to buy seed and/or propagating material annually, which would increase production costs, allow plant breeders to raise prices, prevent access to new varieties that are not available commercially, and prevent farmers from adapting their crops to changing climatic conditions on their farms.\n\nThey also state that removing farmers' privilege for new fruit, vegetable and ornamental varieties would unfairly encroach upon farmers' age-old practice of using farm-saved seed. The CFIA wants private investment in plant breeding to become more profitable by taking more revenue from farmers. Canada should provide more support to our public plant breeding system, which benefits farmers and the public. Farmers' privilege is key to food security and Canada's sovereignty. Ensuring that farmers can reproduce crops on their own farms, even if supply chain or climate impacts restrict the supply of propagating material, is critical.\n\nI should note that this letter was sent to the whole of cabinet, including the Prime Minister. In all sincerity I say that I have a copy of that letter with me this evening if the government needs a copy.\n\nI hope the parliamentary secretary is prepared to address these concerns in a more fulsome way than was done during question period in October. I stand alongside these incredible organizations in calling on the government to abandon the proposed regulatory amendments, protect farmers and support farmers' rights through this real action, not empty words. I look forward to the response.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76197","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on October 3, I asked the Minister of Agriculture if he would abandon the government's proposed regulatory changes to the plant breeders' rights in favour of supporting the rights of farmers who save and re-use their seed. The parliamentary secretary rose and responded that consultations have happened, which completely dodged the question. Less than a week later, on October 9, I rose ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3aa50ca9c2907e29f079aacc6bae4a4afcd9dd688569f0a5b44ae0fb6370508d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70a032a5583e26fc111f5bc9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76198,"date":"2026-01-29T00:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to reiterate that I stand alongside these incredible organizations, which I talked about earlier, representing small farmers. They are calling on the government to abandon these proposed regulatory amendments, to protect farmers and to support farmers' rights through real action and not empty words. From what I just heard, I do not feel the government is going to do that, but it needs to come clean, explain its rationale and listen to the impact this is going to have on these farmers.\n\nThe ask of the stakeholders, who represent hundreds of thousands of farmers who grow our food, is simple: Will the government show, through concrete action and not empty words, that it respects a farmer's right to the age-old practice of collecting and saving their own farm seed, and abandon these harmful regulatory changes?\n\nThere are different sizes of farms. There are different farmers' needs, but these organizations represent a lot of farmers. They are being ignored, and I hope that the government will come clean on what it is proposing to do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76198","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to reiterate that I stand alongside these incredible organizations, which I talked about earlier, representing small farmers. They are calling on the government to abandon these proposed regulatory amendments, to protect farmers and to support farmers' rights through real action and not empty words. From what I just heard, I do not feel the government is going to do that, but i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["697b1c4add3fe5e63960b02abc88dd2e0596ce11078c32649d67bef22939689f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2acff550a042fe316d2c0b03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76199,"date":"2026-01-29T17:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am raising this issue again because in two months, core federal support for friendship centres will run out.\n\nIn Rankin Inlet, Nunavut, I saw how the Pulaarvik Kablu Friendship Centre delivers life-saving mental health, addictions and on-the-land programs. In my riding, the Port Alberni and Wachiay friendship centres are lifelines, providing food, housing, safety, culture and belonging. Indigenous populations are growing, friendship centres are beyond capacity, and budget 2025 offered nothing. This is not reconciliation. This is abandonment.\n\nWhen will the government commit to renewing this funding with long-term, secure and stable support?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76199","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am raising this issue again because in two months, core federal support for friendship centres will run out.\n\nIn Rankin Inlet, Nunavut, I saw how the Pulaarvik Kablu Friendship Centre delivers life-saving mental health, addictions and on-the-land programs. In my riding, the Port Alberni and Wachiay friendship centres are lifelines, providing food, housing, safety, culture and belong","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5816fb96a92003bdbd5798e7c2285a213c0a3693fb28e511074e2dfda522ea1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5d7243b03e5d8b4028d7b621b1b65862cdc8be6908b3fad11e64d1579ca84994"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-311b2b43c1e1932480879d18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76200,"date":"2026-01-29T17:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to present petition e-6751, sponsored by John Mayba from Port Alberni and signed by over 1,500 Canadians who are deeply concerned about the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza and Canada's obligations under international law. The petition highlights that under the Geneva Convention and Canada's own Official Development Assistance Accountability Act, Canada is required to uphold international humanitarian law and ensure that aid is delivered in a neutral, impartial and independent manner.\n\nThe petitioners call on the House to clearly reject the current model of militarized aid delivery in Palestine and to demand the full restoration of access for UN agencies and established humanitarian organizations, including UNRWA and the World Food Program. They urge Canada to insist on safe and immediate entry for Canadian and international humanitarian and medical workers. They further ask that Canadian funding be withheld from any mechanism that does not respect humanitarian principles and that all Canadian aid to Gaza be delivered exclusively through internationally recognized humanitarian channels. Again, this petition reflects the voices of 1,500 Canadians who want our country to stand firmly for human life, international law and the protection of civilians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76200","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to present petition e-6751, sponsored by John Mayba from Port Alberni and signed by over 1,500 Canadians who are deeply concerned about the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza and Canada's obligations under international law. The petition highlights that under the Geneva Convention and Canada's own Official Development Assistance Accountability Act, Canada is required to u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6a82f6765cb2ce917d131a6604ea6d4b20d513502faab82c242b116021a75104"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc330f6f9729c7e39f3c4d8308a2d7395ab6d3735a23030019b6fff59c2ec49a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f75eff6a6b61636a3795fea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77910,"date":"2026-02-02T18:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree with any supports to help people with the cost of living, but one thing we have never heard from the Liberals and will never hear from Conservatives is about the runaway, out-of-control corporate greed. We are seeing big grocery stores post record profits. There is no mechanism so that the big grocery stores do not increase prices the day before this benefit comes into play. All the Liberals need to do is charge an excess profit tax on big grocery stores.\n\nIs there a threshold for the Liberals on the out-of-control corporate greed that is now becoming normalized?\n\nWe see Loblaws with $2 billion in profits last year alone. The minister says that there is nothing we can do here in Canada. Well, there is: an excess profit tax.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77910","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats agree with any supports to help people with the cost of living, but one thing we have never heard from the Liberals and will never hear from Conservatives is about the runaway, out-of-control corporate greed. We are seeing big grocery stores post record profits. There is no mechanism so that the big grocery stores do not increase prices the day before this benefit comes ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["39e410bb5e4dda0bb5e738a3b05afc0b1d43bdc37a9214bd12e877d3b9075f8d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b1b0fbf696d3878ef12eebcd2e2c68883d77e387736f406fd4b4bab9e3b37f3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9efe6054f4ce4e2fef66cf51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77911,"date":"2026-02-02T20:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour today to table petition e-6823, which is sponsored by Jim Abram from Quadra Island and is signed by over 699 Canadians.\n\nPetitioners call upon the Government of Canada to partner with the private sector in collaboration with potential first nations partners to retrofit a portion of Canada's retired CC-130H Hercules fleet to turn them into large air tankers for wildfire suppression.\n\nSecond, they call on the government to deploy these aircraft under a national wildfire response shared with provinces and territories, and, where appropriate, international humanitarian and emergency missions, and to consider the Canadian Interagency Forest Fire Centre for managing deployment under a transparent cost-sharing framework with initial operating capability by the 2027 wildfire season.\n\nThird, petitioners call on the government to prioritize this made-in-Canada solution, leveraging Canadian engineering and protecting lives, communities and the environment. They cite that wildfires Canada-wide have increasing intensity and cost, demanding bold, timely action.\n\n I want to thank Jim Abram and the 699 Canadians who signed the petition.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77911","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour today to table petition e-6823, which is sponsored by Jim Abram from Quadra Island and is signed by over 699 Canadians.\n\nPetitioners call upon the Government of Canada to partner with the private sector in collaboration with potential first nations partners to retrofit a portion of Canada's retired CC-130H Hercules fleet to turn them into large air tankers for wildfire","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["07917f4b82a4844f9052cac25a969c7e4666c992c35df509bab81c0ed93712d5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5be53c299bcadf79cafc5a42755cc290ceebf579383d056c090ded3b77a827b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ed90601af6e4364eeb3279a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77902,"date":"2026-02-03T15:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise today to table a petition on behalf of Canadians deeply concerned about the worsening mental health and substance use crisis across our country, a crisis that has only been exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic.\n\nPetitioners note that too many Canadians are unable to access timely mental health or substance use supports. They point out that when care is not available in the community, people are left to rely on overcrowded hospital emergency rooms or primary care providers. Untreated or inadequately treated mental illness carries enormous social and economic costs.\n\nThe petitioners therefore call on the Government of Canada to take urgent action by legislating parity between physical and mental health in Canada's universal public health care system; ensuring timely access to evidence-based, culturally appropriate and publicly funded mental health and substance use services beyond hospital and physician settings; and, finally, establishing the Canada mental health transfer to sustainably fund these services, including an initial investment of $4.5 billion to the provinces and territories.\n\nPetitioners are clear: Canadians deserve a health care system where mental health is treated with the same urgency, priority and respect as physical health.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77902","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise today to table a petition on behalf of Canadians deeply concerned about the worsening mental health and substance use crisis across our country, a crisis that has only been exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic.\n\nPetitioners note that too many Canadians are unable to access timely mental health or substance use supports. They point out that when care is not availa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["639c22705962e1b27b7449b14b4a4cb904977e3d1538b85175e479559057f040"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a7ba22f18ea0bf87e7792a4ebbcc2ffc8507a82ed89f65650f73ab7731425f9b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30ec1f5f14959304bf9643d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77903,"date":"2026-02-03T15:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague talked about grocery store prices doubling. Well, guess what else doubled: margins from the big grocery stores. They are posting record profits. My colleague talked about the Liberals' bringing the big grocery stores together to have a conversation, but nothing has happened. This requires government intervention and an excess profit tax.\n\n Does my colleague agree that there needs to be a threshold, that the big corporations profiteering on the backs of everyday people need to be reined in, and that an excess profit tax would do just that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77903","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague talked about grocery store prices doubling. Well, guess what else doubled: margins from the big grocery stores. They are posting record profits. My colleague talked about the Liberals' bringing the big grocery stores together to have a conversation, but nothing has happened. This requires government intervention and an excess profit tax.\n\n Does my colleague agree that the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a5f66eb48b6fee8aa193ae0f759c9cd71195ae1745194cc4622411a15efe3f8e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a055afdaa8f0428c4c8a1c71b2eb1232f810ae81b2994f6cb3147915c9ebbbc4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40a917b37d1c3bd3506f1fa3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77904,"date":"2026-02-03T15:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we all want small, medium and large businesses to win. We all want that, but when the only winners, when it comes to groceries and food prices, are the big corporations, and the only losers are everyday people across this country, something has to be done. The member highlighted and claimed that Canada has the highest grocery prices in the G7. Guess what else we have? We have the lowest corporate taxes in the G7. Big grocery stores are posting record profits. \n\nDoes my colleague not agree that there needs to be a threshold when it comes to profiteering by big grocery stores? This is a time when we need to work collectively on solutions. \n\nShe is right that the government says it brought the big grocery stores together to work on dealing with the inflationary costs happening on food, but nothing has happened. The Liberals got nothing done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77904","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we all want small, medium and large businesses to win. We all want that, but when the only winners, when it comes to groceries and food prices, are the big corporations, and the only losers are everyday people across this country, something has to be done. The member highlighted and claimed that Canada has the highest grocery prices in the G7. Guess what else we have? We have the lowe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97eab51c66a5f2ee4c9f7748139b74f9b0621b69ff06aab42df320d00463f4fe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c26995bedf82893ea8c6cfa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77905,"date":"2026-02-03T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I ask all members to join me today in expressing solidarity with the Nuu-chah-nulth people of Tseshaht First Nation after two incidents of racist vandalism at the \"Every Child Matters\" orange bridge in Port Alberni in just one week. Swastikas and hateful slurs defaced this important site of remembrance. \n\nThis was not random vandalism. It was an attack on survivors, on indigenous families, on Jewish communities and on the truth of what happened at the Alberni Indian Residential School. For generations, indigenous children were taken across this bridge from their families. Painting it orange was an act of remembrance, education and reconciliation.\n\nHate will not erase the truth. I thank the many volunteers who repainted the bridge and showed our community's resolve. We must condemn racism wherever it rears its ugly head in Canada, support education and the hard work of reconciliation, and stand with survivors today and always.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77905","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I ask all members to join me today in expressing solidarity with the Nuu-chah-nulth people of Tseshaht First Nation after two incidents of racist vandalism at the \"Every Child Matters\" orange bridge in Port Alberni in just one week. Swastikas and hateful slurs defaced this important site of remembrance. \n\nThis was not random vandalism. It was an attack on survivors, on indigenous fami","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","label":"Vandalism"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","label":"Vandalism","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb74befce409336d8a3f5f04403788c90213ce1c85be92427288e2a8382086bc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f4be2e9f34865becb0ec9bf770ee37828ad0b62d97e8aeb2662415a34b02abad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab4f197e4f0029671ba277ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77906,"date":"2026-02-03T20:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, when the previous Liberal government brought together the top executives of the big grocery chains that have been price gouging Canadians since the pandemic, they showed up with no plan. The grocery executives offered nothing but pictures of their weekly sale flyers and were held to no accountable commitments. The meeting was all for show, and while the government pat itself on the back, it walked away with nothing to show for it and no relief for Canadians.\n\nRegarding Bill C-19, helping people matters, but without an excess profit tax, families pay twice: once at the store and again through taxes.\n\nDoes my colleague not agree that it is time for an excess profit tax to make those who are profiteering off people pay their fair share?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77906","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, when the previous Liberal government brought together the top executives of the big grocery chains that have been price gouging Canadians since the pandemic, they showed up with no plan. The grocery executives offered nothing but pictures of their weekly sale flyers and were held to no accountable commitments. The meeting was all for show, and while the government pat itself on the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["44c0603c161ffd5c051126c5af7e51bc2367fef76c763fdfe53a83d9d3b17b15"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bcf780703fa81790ce8b86d987f7bea036b03968044d4cf33392504f15c1ce83"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b78ad36413c21003db116732","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77907,"date":"2026-02-03T23:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am glad that this motion has come forward to inspire the conversation around the veterans in our country.\n\nFirst, I will highlight that clearly everyone in the House, and all Canadians, agree that no veteran should be living on the streets of this country. Any man or woman who served this country should be prioritized when it comes to housing. They should not be left out on the streets. \n\nHowever, we do have concerns around this motion. We know that this is a real problem. Veterans are overrepresented when it comes to homelessness and homeless people on the streets of our great nation, but so are indigenous peoples. We have been flagging this. I have raised this in the House many times: Any government buildings or any government lands that are to be used for housing, something that we have supported and we do support, should be prioritized for Canada's military veterans, RCMP veterans and, of course, indigenous peoples, who, again, are overrepresented in terms of homelessness in this country, the first peoples of these lands.\n\n We have seen the breakdown many times when veterans groups, organizations or legions try to access funds to build veterans housing. Constantly, what we find out, and we can see where it has happened in Ontario, is that when a group wants to get housing going, even when a municipality comes forward saying it has land, the provincial government says that veterans are a responsibility of the federal Government of Canada. Often the federal government does not provide the funding that is needed, so they fall between the cracks.\n\n Even when local governments or local organizations want to spearhead a project to make sure there are no veterans in their community or anywhere in Canada without a place to live, often the gaps collide. There is an opportunity right now for the federal government to show leadership.\n\n One thing about this motion is that it is non-binding. What we heard from my Conservative colleague, which I wholly support, is that we are talking about doing a study in six months' time on a non-binding motion. This could be in the fall economic statement. In fact, the Prime Minister could announce a policy this week that could absolutely cement that all government lands and buildings to be used for housing are to prioritize Canada's men and women who have served in the military or the RCMP and indigenous peoples, on whose lands they are. \n\nHowever, the Liberals will not do this. Instead, we have a motion that is going to drag this out. Honestly, it is a motion that, as much as we are frustrated with, we will support at second reading to get the conversation going. However, it is absolutely unnecessary. In fact, this should be an urgent priority of the government. It should be looking at ways to support those groups and organizations and fast-tracking shovel-ready projects, those that are ready right now to be implemented. We have cities, provinces and territories that want to support Canada's military and RCMP veterans and indigenous peoples on federal lands, but they require the federal government to come to the table and actually be the leader when it comes to pulling it together.\n\nAgain, we recognize this is a real problem, and we need a pan-Canadian approach to this. However, we do not need to wait for a study when we know there are government lands and buildings that could be used immediately. We have non-profits with shovel-ready projects. We need data, as my colleague talked about earlier. There is no credible data to identify how many of Canada's military and RCMP veterans are homeless. We need to ensure that there are strong transition supports for those who are in an absolute crisis. We need this to be coordinated across the government. All levels of government should be working collectively to address this problem. We need housing-first supports. \n\nIt is critical that we get to a place of prevention. When a military or RCMP veteran is homeless, we cannot wait for them to be in crisis. This should be a priority of government. If someone who is serving, right through to their release, is in trouble, if they do not have housing lined up or if they do not have safe, secure supports when they are released, we need to ensure that at least they have, as a bare minimum, a place to live.\n\nThe government has had a decade to address this problem, and the Liberals bring forward a motion to talk about it and do a study in six months, which it does not require. This can be enacted now. We would expect a lot more from the leadership of the government. All parliamentarians would expect more.\n\nI hope that the mover of this motion actually goes to the Prime Minister and the cabinet and says that the least we could do for Canada's veterans is make sure that none of them are homeless. This could be done expediently, and it has to be done expediently, because we cannot lose veterans. When a veteran is homeless and they are not getting the adequate supports they need, we know what can happen. \n\nThis is disrespectful to Canada's veterans, the people who put their lives on the line for our safety and our security and have served our country. To the mover, I hope that this is in the fall economic statement, or even better, that the government fast-tracks this process and gets moving on making sure that no veteran is left homeless in this country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77907","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am glad that this motion has come forward to inspire the conversation around the veterans in our country.\n\nFirst, I will highlight that clearly everyone in the House, and all Canadians, agree that no veteran should be living on the streets of this country. Any man or woman who served this country should be prioritized when it comes to housing. They should not be left out on the stre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3ae9bbdfa31de82e99764497ce037374ffffb9b472c7c4056540d161e25d2a24"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c1479eb3c6513ad7829730c006dccb00d5556bec79dad72c0705c5b8c6a7ed8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a5efe6c820c79250fb36a7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77908,"date":"2026-02-03T23:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to speak to the closure of the Crofton mill on Vancouver Island and what it exposes about the state of Canada's forest sector and the Liberal government's failure to act when forestry workers need help most. \n\nToday, February 3, the first round of layoffs at Crofton takes effect. Workers are emptying lockers and families are losing paycheques. Mortgages, rent and grocery bills do not pause while the government deliberates. Communities are being told to wait. I am raising this tonight because Geoff Dawe, the president of Public and Private Workers of Canada, contacted me directly. His concern was simple and alarming. Workers losing their good-paying union jobs cannot access the federal supports that they were promised and deserve. Crofton is not in my riding, but when hundreds of Vancouver Island workers are thrown out of work overnight, riding boundaries mean nothing. It demands a national response. \n\nI reached out immediately to three federal departments about removing barriers to workers' support, barriers that simply should never have existed in the first place. I acknowledge those ministers and officials who responded, but let me be clear: Workers should not need an MP running interference just to get help when mills close. \n\nI also want to recognize British Columbia's Minister of Forests, Ravi Parmar, who is working around the clock, North Cowichan Mayor Rob Douglas and Duncan Mayor Michelle Staples, who are doing everything they can on the ground, despite the absence of a serious, coordinated federal response. When governments fail to intervene during a sectoral crisis, the outcome is predictable: economic shock, mental health crisis, population loss and entire communities shaken to the core. This moment is a real-time stress test for employment insurance, labour market development funding, softwood lumber relief and federal-provincial coordination. Right now, the system is failing that test. \n\nLet me explain. The government announced $1.2 billion for the forest sector. Workers quickly discovered that only $50 million of that is actually for them. That is less than 5%, not for income replacement, not for retraining and not for communities trying to survive closures. The $50 million for tens of thousands of workers is not support; it is neglect. In British Columbia alone, nearly 50,000 direct forestry jobs are at risk. These are mill workers, fallers, truck drivers, equipment operators, indigenous workers and workers in single-industry towns. \n\nForestry has sustained generations of families in my home province. British Columbia produces roughly 45% of Canada's softwood lumber exports, yet under the $450-million labour market adjustment envelope, British Columbia receives only about $70 million, while Ontario receives roughly $230 million. That is indefensible. It is not proportional and it abandons forestry communities in British Columbia. \n\nWhen the auto sector faces crisis, Ottawa intervenes. When steel faces unfair trade action, Ottawa steps in, and rightly so. Forestry workers are asking, though, why they are treated as expendable. What is missing is a new, dedicated round of forestry relief, including softwood lumber supports, that reflects the scale of this crisis and treats British Columbia fairly. Many affected workers are between 55 and 64 years old, too old for retraining and too young for retirement. Employment insurance replaces just 60% of income, and severance clawbacks block access to support entirely. \n\nWorkers are not asking for charity; they are simply asking for action. They are asking for employment insurance replacement to be raised to at least 80% and for EI duration to be extended to 104 weeks. They are asking for no waiting periods and no severance clawbacks. They are asking for bridge-to-retirement supports for workers aged 55 to 64. They are asking for guaranteed apprenticeship completion and long-term mental health supports. They are asking for mobility assistance where local jobs do not exist. \n\nCrofton is the test. Layoffs are happening today, and the excuses will not pay the rent. Delay is not neutral; it is harm. The government must act, and it must act now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77908","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight to speak to the closure of the Crofton mill on Vancouver Island and what it exposes about the state of Canada's forest sector and the Liberal government's failure to act when forestry workers need help most. \n\nToday, February 3, the first round of layoffs at Crofton takes effect. Workers are emptying lockers and families are losing paycheques. Mortgages, rent and grocer","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d0f94e52e3acd1af7825f68da3a9aca7852bcbd976e1f0060ba945dea4cc3a9e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c6d08551c276349bda898b799bdbb38ffd24992149ad33243458863cae168bba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c75ca09c732c89d7eb6a586","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77909,"date":"2026-02-03T23:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, feelings are not enough. The layoffs are happening today. I am urging the government not to abandon the families and workers at Crofton. Forestry workers do not need more reassurance; they need action. If the government is serious about preventing further job losses and supporting workers who have already lost their jobs, it must deliver real, sector-specific relief now, including softwood lumber relief funds that are proportional to British Columbia's role in this industry and comparable to what auto and steel received.\n\nThis means stabilizing existing mills, securing fibre supply, resolving the softwood lumber dispute with the United States and diversifying markets through a team Canada approach with provinces, labour and industry. Workers are losing their jobs today, and support must be timely and fair. Many have paid into employment insurance for decades. EI at 60% is not enough. Waiting periods delay income at the very moment families are losing paycheques, and severance clawbacks punish workers for benefits they have earned.\n\nWill the government act now? Will it help the workers and families of Crofton, B.C., right now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77909","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, feelings are not enough. The layoffs are happening today. I am urging the government not to abandon the families and workers at Crofton. Forestry workers do not need more reassurance; they need action. If the government is serious about preventing further job losses and supporting workers who have already lost their jobs, it must deliver real, sector-specific relief now, including sof","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","label":"Employment insurance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","label":"Employment insurance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b9e7cd68531e9f0f865b434219984c0d3fdfdf6adb9d8ae00319eb8a08c1d044"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e7adab2c77e972a0df70b2c368a00b382d574682e5dfa5993b64b25e69c7ead3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47845","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44c9f124245379aed948cb4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77900,"date":"2026-02-04T21:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise to present a petition from Canadians who are calling for urgent federal leadership on brain injury awareness, prevention and treatment.\n\nThe petitioners note that brain injuries can occur in many ways, from accidents to illness and strokes, and often result in serious physical, cognitive, emotional and behavioural effects. They further point out that brain injuries are frequently linked with other challenges, including substance use and homelessness, creating additional barriers for those affected. It is estimated that 1.6 million Canadians are living with a brain injury today, yet there is still no federal coordinated national response.\n\nThe petitioners therefore call upon the Government of Canada to develop a national brain injury strategy to improve awareness and prevention and to ensure better access to treatment, rehabilitation and recovery supports for Canadians living with the impacts of brain injury.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77900","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise to present a petition from Canadians who are calling for urgent federal leadership on brain injury awareness, prevention and treatment.\n\nThe petitioners note that brain injuries can occur in many ways, from accidents to illness and strokes, and often result in serious physical, cognitive, emotional and behavioural effects. They further point out that brain inju","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["893359f9fee7056a5281adf966c503b478d3e6763b1a5d9390e1c39bf4405ea2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["67b179fba79d28d2f2fa23ee3a53bc658e36fdb3f6fe696ce20561cf56e603a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d1d4638814b4d172ec8aee0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77901,"date":"2026-02-04T22:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, when we are talking about food costs, we have to look at the corporate profits. I know big grocery stores are making big profits. \n\nWhere I live, in coastal British Columbia, when it comes to fish and independent fish harvesters, a lot of the quota licences are held by a handful of fishers. We call them slipper skippers or armchair fishers because they hold the licences and then lease them out to fishers, who do not actually make very much money. As well, the consumer ends up paying more money.\n\nDoes my colleague agree that this model needs to be changed, that anybody out fishing should be making the profit and that this would lower prices for consumers at the end of the day?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-79/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77901","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, when we are talking about food costs, we have to look at the corporate profits. I know big grocery stores are making big profits. \n\nWhere I live, in coastal British Columbia, when it comes to fish and independent fish harvesters, a lot of the quota licences are held by a handful of fishers. We call them slipper skippers or armchair fishers because they hold the licences and then lea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d92abd13752f62b6e136b58f2817e1ca63115aaca5e5783737ad1ff3f7cae194"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f74d1954caf2379842482642d35c98bd8891cc0f9f754876a2de2a043a428d7d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07462e824608d6e2156c8d28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287748,"date":"2026-02-09T20:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. This is not to discredit my esteemed colleague on her petition, but she did mention a member of the House. Maybe it is best if she highlights the member's riding instead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287748","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. This is not to discredit my esteemed colleague on her petition, but she did mention a member of the House. Maybe it is best if she highlights the member's riding instead.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6dfdce633f19c65ea260eaee14fb219f012ab5fd6b0f749b36fb7ea56c8b411"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac10937272fa90d58adb64a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287749,"date":"2026-02-09T20:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour today to table a petition on behalf of Vancouver Islanders and British Columbians. They highlight that wealth inequality in Canada is rising, with more Canadians struggling to afford the basics of life while corporate profits continue to break records. They highlight that austerity measures very often exasperate inequality. The federal government is planning austerity measures including a massive cut of $25 billion to the publicly funded jobs and programs that Canadians rely upon, and the federal government has and plans on further cutting taxes on the wealthy. They also highlight that climate change is worsening, causing Canadians to project $25 billion in losses each year, and a wealth tax could, as per the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, generate more than $32 billion in the first year alone.\n\nPetitioners call on the House of Commons to reconsider the sweeping cuts to Canadian jobs and services and, lastly, to propose a bill to fund good-paying jobs, public services and the transition to a sustainable economy by making corporations and the wealthiest Canadians pay their fair share.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287749","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour today to table a petition on behalf of Vancouver Islanders and British Columbians. They highlight that wealth inequality in Canada is rising, with more Canadians struggling to afford the basics of life while corporate profits continue to break records. They highlight that austerity measures very often exasperate inequality. The federal government is planning austerity ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","label":"Inequality"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","label":"Inequality","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b944339f2eeb93a144bbabddcd9b28bc6cb0651d960c4af9eeca40dae8468a6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["591f0beff86af967ecddfc3a5b3a5f85cf95c9244c3bed591594afab2fb7b4de"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27f2fbd156d8252162f7c756","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287750,"date":"2026-02-09T21:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have to disagree about the importance of the implementation of this commissioner to hold government to account. Often, treaties have been signed and those agreements have not been implemented. It has been uneven, inconsistent and ignored. We heard that this morning from Chief John Jack from Huu-ay-aht First Nations and Chief Wilfred Cootes from Uchucklesaht. They are calling for the commissioner to hold the government to account to ensure that when treaties are signed, they are actually implemented.\n\nWhy are the Conservatives going against the calls to action by indigenous peoples in this country who want to work nation to nation to support their people and build a better, healthier Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287750","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have to disagree about the importance of the implementation of this commissioner to hold government to account. Often, treaties have been signed and those agreements have not been implemented. It has been uneven, inconsistent and ignored. We heard that this morning from Chief John Jack from Huu-ay-aht First Nations and Chief Wilfred Cootes from Uchucklesaht. They are calling for the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["659e56f03e1c1b053c9daeeac74ce87c2059ebcb70b7d7bc0944979ba77007e8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9af26cf2f5ff7690d92d5eef48f5bcdf84ba1b0c3fdc66e4bbcc8fa607144681"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbcd2d66069daa758cfd8494","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287751,"date":"2026-02-09T21:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we heard again this morning about the uneven, inconsistent and sometimes ignored implementation of the treaty process. We have heard from the nations wanting this treaty commissioner to absolutely ensure that treaty implementation happens. Now, we hear Conservatives say, \"Well, that is a waste of money.\" However, what is costly is not implementing a treaty because, when treaties are implemented, it creates jobs. Those nations want to participate in the economy. They want to move forward.\n\n We hear also from the Conservatives all the time that the government should have done more. Absolutely, the government should do more, but so should the official opposition. Will the Conservatives admit that they need to ask more questions when it comes to indigenous issues in this place, as the official opposition?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287751","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we heard again this morning about the uneven, inconsistent and sometimes ignored implementation of the treaty process. We have heard from the nations wanting this treaty commissioner to absolutely ensure that treaty implementation happens. Now, we hear Conservatives say, \"Well, that is a waste of money.\" However, what is costly is not implementing a treaty because, when treaties are i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["99b0be3e8e83bde681bc46603ceeb1cff4fc521083282e43625217ace694f6e0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["524f4e92db0ad8eca23f6a843012fc50c25350fb8d067c8845c6ea088f57b7e6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b1fae4c60374e253d770310e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287744,"date":"2026-02-10T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Alberta's Bill 11 is American-style two-tier medicine. It allows doctors to bill privately while also billing the public system, and it allows private insurance for medically necessary care. This breaks the promise of Canadian medicare, creating one system for the wealthy and one where the rest of us are left waiting even longer. \n\nThe minister said she would look into it, but it has been two months and we have heard nothing. Will she stop stalling, enforce the Canada Health Act and protect Canada's universal health care system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287744","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Alberta's Bill 11 is American-style two-tier medicine. It allows doctors to bill privately while also billing the public system, and it allows private insurance for medically necessary care. This breaks the promise of Canadian medicare, creating one system for the wealthy and one where the rest of us are left waiting even longer. \n\nThe minister said she would look into it, but it has ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["381f7b17fc59a351b9153af13d5f3011b7e0e3965fe4b7109e1d2a2d50e56e8b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d8392c8d36fdb48f09092a09ddfc3103df9c36c4634e4ea3edc25d66ffb0b4f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25e5cbd04a2d2423aff956ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287745,"date":"2026-02-10T21:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is a highly partisan motion, and the response was highly partisan as well. As New Democrats, we recognize, and I think everybody in the House recognizes, that there is a rise in extortion, that there is a rise in organized crime, that everybody has a right to feel safe in this country and that we need to do more. The Conservatives continue to make assertions that mandatory minimums and longer sentencing would actually curb this, but if we look to the States, there is a sevenfold incarceration rate from taking that very approach.\n\n What we want is evidence-based policy. I would like to hear from my colleague about solutions. When we look at solutions, what we hear about is targeted enforcement against organized crime, which is effective public safety, as well as timely courts and prevention, not rhetoric that undermines charter rights and stigmatizes newcomers. I hope my colleague can talk about solutions, because clearly they must step forward and do more. I am sure my colleague agrees that the government needs to do more.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287745","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is a highly partisan motion, and the response was highly partisan as well. As New Democrats, we recognize, and I think everybody in the House recognizes, that there is a rise in extortion, that there is a rise in organized crime, that everybody has a right to feel safe in this country and that we need to do more. The Conservatives continue to make assertions that mandatory minimu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cf41900cc7194be0c3d972bdc2da134443f9a0df317cc35bb508f57844efeb11"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7500ac69f38af500bb96ced9c1bf94aeb0c337dc395e38c8e51f56c3cc4efd14"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9bf52b9a433b8c75b879c7c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287746,"date":"2026-02-10T22:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, tonight I am here on behalf of Pacific salmon. The Pacific salmon strategy initiative, the main federal program supporting wild salmon restoration, habitat protection, science and rebuilding on the west coast, sunsets at the end of March. It was not renewed in the budget, and there is still no confirmation of renewal. This puts the single-largest federal investment in wild salmon recovery at risk. \n\nFirst nations, hatcheries and community restoration groups cannot plan projects or keep workers on the ground without certainty. Habitat restoration is not something we can turn on and off; salmon recovery takes years of steady work. Time is of the essence. If the government is serious about protecting wild salmon and supporting coastal economies, it must renew the Pacific salmon strategy initiative now. \n\nOn the west coast, wild salmon are not an abstract policy issue. They are food security, culture, ecosystem health, local livelihoods and local economies. Organizations like the Redd Fish Restoration Society, working with Nuu-chah-nulth nations, have spent decades restoring watersheds, rebuilding salmon habitat and training local workers. This is reconciliation in action. \n\nWe also know, from programs like the watershed security fund, that restoration works. Dozens of projects have been supported, hundreds of jobs created and millions leveraged in community investment. Demand far exceeds available funding. Communities are lining up to do the work. If something works, we scale it up. We do not pull the rug out from underneath the people rebuilding wild salmon and protecting watersheds. \n\nThere is also a separate policy discussion under way about the salmon allocation policy. That review is long overdue and tied to court decisions and conservation realities. There has also been a lot of fear stirred up around the salmon allocation policy review. People are being told they will lose their right to fish, that salmon will stop being a public resource or that the Constitution is being rewritten. None of that is true. No one is being shut out of the water. Recreational fishing is not being eliminated. Families will still be able to fish. \n\nSome Conservatives have chosen to stir fear instead of engaging honestly with the law, the science and the reality facing wild salmon. At the same time, the Liberal government has failed to clearly explain what this review is and what it is not, which is allowing misinformation to spread. What is actually happening is long overdue. Courts have ruled that indigenous fishing rights must be meaningfully accommodated. Outdated policy from 1999 has failed to reflect that reality, and at the same time, many wild salmon stocks are still in decline. \n\nConservation and rebuilding must come first, because without healthy wild salmon, there is no fishery for anyone. What is most troubling is the double standard we are hearing from some Conservatives. They show up at rallies and town halls and tell fishers one story, and then they come back to Ottawa, sit at the fisheries and oceans committee with the minister and her officials for two hours and do not raise these concerns at all. They have not once raised the sunsetting of the Pacific salmon strategy initiative, the most critical salmon funding we have, nor the concerns they claim to have heard about the salmon allocation policy, either at committee or here in the House of Commons. \n\nAs New Democrats, we are clear about where we stand. Our positions are evidence-based and expert-led. We stand for conservation first because without wild salmon, there is no fishery. We stand for rebuilding salmon so there is a future for all fishers, good jobs in coastal communities and strong local economies. We stand for respecting the law on indigenous rights, and we stand for stable, long-term funding so restoration does not collapse every few years. \n\nThe government must now move quickly on these decisions related to both the Pacific salmon strategy initiative and the salmon allocation policy review. Organizations, communities and businesses need transparency and certainty. Delays create real costs on the ground. Coastal communities are running out of time, and the government must act now. Time is of the essence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287746","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, tonight I am here on behalf of Pacific salmon. The Pacific salmon strategy initiative, the main federal program supporting wild salmon restoration, habitat protection, science and rebuilding on the west coast, sunsets at the end of March. It was not renewed in the budget, and there is still no confirmation of renewal. This puts the single-largest federal investment in wild salmon re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c7611bf082bd367cbe63dd4d784421473a696835d5d619d35f3a4871d37aa9b0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["27c146103c200a933dda4be2d071c52f4aa8c8c5c92650b4a278fa59ccbf49e7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-46e62b2568ca3d33635bc906","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287747,"date":"2026-02-10T22:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate my colleague talking about the record amount of funding invested in wild salmon and its success. I have a lot of respect for him, but now is not the time to take our foot off the gas. The answer tonight does not give coastal communities what they need, which is certainty. The Pacific salmon strategy initiative is set to expire in just over a month, and we still do not have a clear commitment on its renewal. That puts restoration work, good jobs and real progress on wild salmon recovery at risk. First nations, hatcheries and community restoration groups cannot plan without stable long-term funding. Habitat restoration is not something we turn on and off. Time is of the essence.\n\nThere is also a separate review under way of the salmon allocation policy. People deserve honest communication about what that review is and what it is not. No one is losing their right to fish. Recreation fishing is not being eliminated, but conservation and rebuilding must come first. Without healthy salmon, there is no fishery for anyone. Coastal communities are waiting.\n\nThe Liberal government needs to move quickly, provide transparency and commit now to renewing wild salmon restoration funding.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287747","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate my colleague talking about the record amount of funding invested in wild salmon and its success. I have a lot of respect for him, but now is not the time to take our foot off the gas. The answer tonight does not give coastal communities what they need, which is certainty. The Pacific salmon strategy initiative is set to expire in just over a month, and we still do not h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","label":"Fish"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","label":"Fish","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["48f6a83a9c32965eba013b9c4ceed948effb73385e90196732402458bddda223"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98840cb2193bdf76ef5f5028041bc737b00d86f10080350087f897b68bcc6258"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b29a04175327d32dcba58663","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287740,"date":"2026-02-12T15:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition today from Canadians and Vancouver Islanders who are deeply concerned about ghost gear, which is abandoned, lost or discarded fishing gear. It is among the deadliest sources of plastic pollution. \n\nThese petitioners note that ghost gear kills fish; impacts wild Pacific salmon, marine mammals, seabirds and turtles; damages habitats; creates microplastics; and even hazards navigation and active harvesters, hurting coastal economies. They point out the dedicated funding for retrieval, prevention, repair and recycling works creates skilled jobs in partnership with indigenous communities, small businesses, fishers, harbour authorities and recyclers, especially in rural and remote regions. \n\nThe petitioners are calling for the reinstatement and expansion of the permanent and multi-year ghost gear fund, which was cut by the Liberal government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287740","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition today from Canadians and Vancouver Islanders who are deeply concerned about ghost gear, which is abandoned, lost or discarded fishing gear. It is among the deadliest sources of plastic pollution. \n\nThese petitioners note that ghost gear kills fish; impacts wild Pacific salmon, marine mammals, seabirds and turtles; damages habitats; creates microplastics; a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:255569","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Contaminated sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:255569","label":"Contaminated sites","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","label":"Aquatic animals","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["786c924e585db95088557199c468132fe0b3fbd84ba553b84d238a5e228909b2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b2f953dea1c7a5fac127afc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287741,"date":"2026-02-12T15:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, we hear Conservatives talk about how Canada is too big and the transition is too bold, but we can look to Norway, where it is cold, where they travel long distances, and they have had huge success, so geography should not be an excuse. What we need is the Conservatives to support a Canadian auto strategy that protects workers, supports tackling climate change and builds vehicles here at home.\n\nWhy are they not getting on board? We know workers support actually building, and these investments are critical to the auto industry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287741","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, we hear Conservatives talk about how Canada is too big and the transition is too bold, but we can look to Norway, where it is cold, where they travel long distances, and they have had huge success, so geography should not be an excuse. What we need is the Conservatives to support a Canadian auto strategy that protects workers, supports tackling climate change and builds vehicles her","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-764e3f553b20af2ee52a692c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287742,"date":"2026-02-12T16:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, we have seen the impact that Donald Trump's tariffs have had on auto and forestry. We are seeing layoffs at CAMI. We have seen jobs lost in communities on Vancouver Island, whether it be in Crofton or Chemainus, temporary or permanent. The government has been slow in getting income supports and relief out to workers. \n\nWhen will the government scale up income supports for those workers who have either been displaced or lost their jobs permanently, fix the EI delays and deliver benefits to these workers?\n\nFor forestry, for example, there was a $1.2-billion package. Only $50 million of that is earmarked for workers. Hopefully we can get an answer from the Liberal government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287742","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, we have seen the impact that Donald Trump's tariffs have had on auto and forestry. We are seeing layoffs at CAMI. We have seen jobs lost in communities on Vancouver Island, whether it be in Crofton or Chemainus, temporary or permanent. The government has been slow in getting income supports and relief out to workers. \n\nWhen will the government scale up income supports for those work","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ecf4021fc2facc4f1af14c1ac7612babfe1f92fb33af0db9bac15b15fbed210e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7b905e20317d2ea4d00e45a1014bdf6936455687da9536fddd1b5715e7b83b18"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98f37e9579888f8917c0cbc7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287743,"date":"2026-02-12T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is in a mental health crisis and young people are being hit hardest, yet counselling, therapy and treatment still depend on workplace benefits or the ability to pay in a two-tier system. The PBO confirmed that bringing mental health care under the Canada Health Act and achieving parity with physical health care through Bill C-201 would cost just 1.5% of total public health spending. \n\nWill the minister act now and bring mental health care under the Canada Health Act, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287743","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is in a mental health crisis and young people are being hit hardest, yet counselling, therapy and treatment still depend on workplace benefits or the ability to pay in a two-tier system. The PBO confirmed that bringing mental health care under the Canada Health Act and achieving parity with physical health care through Bill C-201 would cost just 1.5% of total public health spen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41e6b984ee0b1cc7da4d2c3f612fb6fdc4438b6704d1cbf2de2112ac982873ec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8c81cee466b0d393d4fd26ed0e66976518a24b05481765328c40a4ebecc874b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0117f8be230d57ba1504f800","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287737,"date":"2026-02-13T17:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister says he is committed to pharmacare, but today only three provinces and one territory are covered. That is about 17% of all Canadians. A commitment to pharmacare should mean access for Canadians no matter where they live. Right now, access to medicine depends on one's postal code. It is not nation building when we give only certain provinces and territories access to medicine.\n\nWill the Prime Minister commit today to expanding pharmacare to every province and territory that wants in so Canadians are not treated differently based on where they live?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287737","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister says he is committed to pharmacare, but today only three provinces and one territory are covered. That is about 17% of all Canadians. A commitment to pharmacare should mean access for Canadians no matter where they live. Right now, access to medicine depends on one's postal code. It is not nation building when we give only certain provinces and territories access to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ddf727a2ae3de9ed0e21cbe203ff95bca59d38ad3025a38b342ebd684452869c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd9a7dcf41397bcb9b69b7234093c1acfb93efa621699750764c2635d9bb6c2e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dcb62e6fd6ad68229630ac9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287738,"date":"2026-02-13T17:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to table a certified petition on behalf of residents from Port Alberni on Vancouver Island who are calling on the federal government to fund more shore power at the Port Alberni loading docks. \n\nThe petitioners describe living with the relentless noise and air pollution caused by ships running diesel generators while they are berthed, sometimes continuously day and night for weeks at a time. They say this is not a minor inconvenience. It affects sleep, health and quality of life for families living near the port. They cite that shore power is a proven solution. It allows ships to plug into the local electrical grid, eliminating the need for diesel generation while berthed. The petitioners also point out that shore power reduces emissions, lowers noise pollution, delivers long-term fuel savings and is already in place in ports around the world, including the port of Vancouver. \n\nThese petitioners are calling on the federal government to prioritize community health and environmental protection by funding shore power infrastructure at the Port Alberni loading docks.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287738","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to table a certified petition on behalf of residents from Port Alberni on Vancouver Island who are calling on the federal government to fund more shore power at the Port Alberni loading docks. \n\nThe petitioners describe living with the relentless noise and air pollution caused by ships running diesel generators while they are berthed, sometimes continuously day and night ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3d84567af51d0bc86086a24f6806188e5f401654223f7de45a0c386fd231eefa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91404cb039dd538ac0c620118b6ee1a7f871dd0b29de658fb99de5e386b5ab4a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a89112e25e4991f4d27904e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287739,"date":"2026-02-13T18:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to speak to Bill C-244. It is a bill that delivers real accountability and takes a proactive approach to preventing marine pollution and abandoned vessels. \n\nI would first like to thank my colleague, the member for West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country, for bringing this bill forward, which shows great leadership.\n\n The first thing the bill does is amend the Canadian Environmental Protection Act to make it clear that when pollution ends up in our oceans, the owner or operator of the polluting vessel is responsible, even when that pollution results from negligence, poor maintenance or foreseeable failure, not only when the intent can be proven. \n\nSecond, it amends the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act to stop vessel owners from off-loading end-of-life boats onto people they know do not have the means to maintain or safely dispose of them. It closes a loophole that allows responsibility to be transferred on paper while the pollution risk remains in the water.\n\n These two changes are practical. They respond directly to what coastal communities live with every day. From the perspective of a coastal riding, where I live, the problem this bill addresses is not occasional; it is structural. Our system too often intervenes only after damage has already been done. We mobilize the Coast Guard once fuel is already in the water. We rely on volunteers, especially indigenous guardian programs, once debris is already on our coast. We scramble for funding once a vessel has already sunk. That approach costs more, harms ecosystems and downloads the responsibility onto communities that did not cause the problem.\n\nBill C-244 moves us toward a prevention-first approach. It strengthens accountability when pollution results from negligence, poor maintenance or foreseeable failure, not only when intent can be proven. Anyone who works around these harbours knows that some of the most damaging pollution comes from aging vessels or deferred maintenance and weak oversight. The ecological harm is the same whether a spill is deliberate or caused by neglect, so if we want to change behaviour, we have to change incentives. \n\nClear liability rules encourage better maintenance, safety planning and proper end-of-life management. When the costs of failure are real, prevention becomes cheaper than cleanup. \n\nThe bill also addresses a pattern that coastal communities see repeatedly, which is responsibility being passed along until no one is left holding it. Vessels nearing the end of their useful life are transferred, deteriorate and eventually sink. The community that then inherits that problem has to deal with the navigational hazard and the cleanup bill. That is not just an individual failure but a huge policy failure that the bill will address. \n\nIt is also important to be honest about why some of these transfers happen. Many vessel owners want to avoid the costs of the proper deconstruction of the vessel or the recycling of a boat at the end of its life rather than pay for responsible disposal. Some of them off-load these vessels cheaply or literally for free onto vulnerable or desperate people. A lot of people take these vessels just for housing. I have seen this first-hand in Tofino, where I lived for almost 25 years. With limited affordable housing, people ended up, and still live, on aging vessels tied to makeshift moorages. Those vessels are often not seaworthy, and the people living on them often do not have the resources to maintain or even safely dispose of them. The result is predictable. The vessel deteriorates, pollution increases, and when it finally sinks, the costs fall onto the community.\n\n The bill helps close the loophole that allows responsibility to be pushed onto the most vulnerable. This is not about blaming people who are struggling to find housing; it is about ensuring that those who profit from vessels and control their disposal cannot avoid and evade responsibility by passing the problem down the line to someone who really has no realistic ability to manage those risks. \n\nMarine pollution is also an economic issue. It undermines fisheries, tourism and working waterfronts. Clean waters are the foundation of coastal communities. Every abandoned vessel that sinks in a harbour imposes costs on local governments, first nations and taxpayers. Strong rules are not anti-economic but pro-community and pro-future. We know how sacred wild Pacific salmon is. The bill would protect it as well.\n\nFor these reasons, the NDP supports this bill at second reading. It improves accountability and strengthens prevention, which are things for which we have been calling for a long time, and it moves us in the right direction.\n\nThe bill also highlights how much further the federal government still needs to go. Even with the stronger liability rules, as the Transportation Safety Board has rightly pointed out in the past, Canada still has no coordinated response system for dealing with shipping container spills and marine debris incidents. We have seen the consequences of that over and again, and I would like to see it addressed.\n\n Containers were lost from the Hanjin Seattle in 2016. More than 100 containers fell from the Zim Kingston just a few years ago. More recently, a large barge off Bella Bella nearly went down with a full load. Each time, first nations and coastal communities were left to respond. Volunteers cleaned debris from beaches, and local governments and indigenous guardians dealt with the long-term impacts to ecosystems, fisheries and local economies. The lack of a coordinated response leaves our coast exposed incident after incident.\n\n The Zim Kingston spill also exposed a deeper accountability gap that is similar to concerns outlined in the bill. Under current rules, the owner of the Zim Kingston can be held liable for damages and cleanup costs for only up to six years from the date of the incident, but the debris from that spill continues to wash up on our shores and will for decades. Microplastics and polystyrene fragments will persist in the marine environment long after that liability clock runs out.\n\nPollution does not end when a legal timeline expires. Communities and ecosystems live with the consequences long after corporate liability has ended; this is why relying on after-the-fact liability alone is not enough. We need preparedness, prevention and a standing response system that is ready before the next spill happens, not improvised afterward.\n\nCoastal and indigenous communities keep telling Ottawa the same thing: They are tired of holding the bag when debris hits their shores. A coordinated response system backed by industry through mechanisms like an ecosystem service fee on cargo units and on ships would ensure that the costs of protecting our coasts are not downloaded onto communities and volunteers alone.\n\nAny coordinated marine pollution response would be incomplete without reinstating the ghost gear fund. It was one of the most important conservation initiatives in Canadian history, tackling up to 800,000 tonnes annually of abandoned, lost or discarded fishing gear that is among the deadliest sources of plastic pollution. I think of the Ocean Legacy foundation, the Coastal Restoration Society in my riding, the Surfrider Foundation Pacific Rim, and many other groups that did that work. The bill before us might strengthen legal liability standards against marine pollution, but a multi-year, permanent ghost gear fund focused on prevention and rapid response remains essential to keeping our coast clean.\n\nThis brings me to another piece of the prevention puzzle that Bill C-244 points towards but would not fully solve: What happens to vessels at the end of their life? If we are serious about stopping abandoned and derelict vessels from becoming pollution hazards, Canada needs a responsible ship recycling system here at home. Too many Canadian vessels are sold off, exported to jurisdictions with weaker standards, or left to deteriorate in our waters until they become hazardous waste. That is environmental negligence and economic leakage. We lose the jobs and the materials, and communities inherit the pollution.\n\nCanadian vessels should be recycled here in Canada to high environmental and labour standards. That requires domestic ship recycling infrastructure, clear federal guidelines, and investment in facilities and training so vessels can be dismantled safely and responsibly. This is not only an environmental necessity; it is also an economic opportunity to create good, local jobs in coastal communities while preventing pollution before it happens.\n\n In Port Alberni, in my riding, the ship recycling leadership group that I have been working on has brought together local governments, labour, environmental organizations, industry, and indigenous partners to develop a model for responsible ship recycling. A core guiding principle of that group is that ship recycling must be grounded in indigenous leadership, decision-making authority and consent. Responsible ship recycling cannot be imposed on communities, and it must be done with indigenous nations as true partners with leadership at the table, real decision-making authority and free, prior and informed consent. This is the standard Canada should be embedding in any national ship recycling framework. \n\nBill C-244 would strengthen accountability when vessels are abandoned or cause pollution. That is necessary. However, if we want to stop the problem at its source, we must also build the end-of-life solutions that make responsible disposal the easy, affordable way for vessel owners.\n\nParliament should support Bill C-244. It would close loopholes and strengthen prevention, but the government must act on container spills and marine debris, implement the Transportation Safety Board's recommendations and invest in Canadian ship recycling capacity with strong federal standards. If we fail to do the full job, we will keep paying more to clean up pollution after the fact instead of preventing it at the source. Coastal communities deserve better than that.\n\nAgain, I want to thank my colleague the MP for West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country for bringing this bill forward. I look forward to working with him on these additional concerns and solutions, from marine debris and container spills to building responsible ship recycling capacity here in Canada. New Democrats will be supporting this bill and will continue to push the government to do the full job of protecting our coasts, our communities and the waters we depend on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-86/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287739","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to speak to Bill C-244. It is a bill that delivers real accountability and takes a proactive approach to preventing marine pollution and abandoned vessels. \n\nI would first like to thank my colleague, the member for West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country, for bringing this bill forward, which shows great leadership.\n\n The first thing the bill doe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d026dc495099b1fa31a87d59039c5f06cd67baf919f04b7356ec5cb499b44a04"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69032b6b5483b7ba38765a43b1b0a3cad5206ccd52e259f90d2b3e2fcf22d0d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-23ada61063bc8851ee0aa8e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":314998,"date":"2026-02-23T20:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we keep asking the Liberal government when pharmacare will expand, and we cannot get a straight answer from the Minister of Health. \n\nBritish Columbia's pharmacare agreement starts next week, because New Democrats pushed for it and because the B.C. NDP moved quickly. Families in other provinces are still waiting because the Liberal government is not negotiating. This means access to life-saving medicine depends on someone's postal code.\n\nWhen will the Minister of Health finally start negotiating so Canadians can access life-saving medicine no matter where they live?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314998","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we keep asking the Liberal government when pharmacare will expand, and we cannot get a straight answer from the Minister of Health. \n\nBritish Columbia's pharmacare agreement starts next week, because New Democrats pushed for it and because the B.C. NDP moved quickly. Families in other provinces are still waiting because the Liberal government is not negotiating. This means access to l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["292e03007cc409dd21f2682b78c53b25c9bc37c0ffaccf4d3f94bb57f17bd6a7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fa44936fda430788199d20d957f2528f6000b06db86a9037bef169969e29ac4f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8edf2ae1328f9c366e1e8dc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":314999,"date":"2026-02-23T20:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition on behalf of residents from Tofino, Ucluelet, Port Alberni and the Oceanside region in my riding of Courtenay—Alberni who are deeply concerned about the shortage of community recreation facilities in our region and across Canada.\n\n Petitioners stress that recreation centres are vital spaces for people of all ages to gather, stay healthy and build strong communities. They note that recreation promotes physical and mental health, supports rehabilitation, reduces antisocial behaviours and lowers long-term health and social costs. Facilities also help retain families, seniors and youth in rural areas while driving economic and volunteer activity. These petitioners point out that the federal government has previously partnered with British Columbia through the investing in Canada infrastructure program's community, culture and recreation infrastructure stream and call for its renewal and expansion.\n\nPetitioners urge the federal government to ensure rural and coastal communities have equitable access to the recreation infrastructure needed for a healthy and sustainable community and country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314999","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition on behalf of residents from Tofino, Ucluelet, Port Alberni and the Oceanside region in my riding of Courtenay—Alberni who are deeply concerned about the shortage of community recreation facilities in our region and across Canada.\n\n Petitioners stress that recreation centres are vital spaces for people of all ages to gather, stay healthy and build st","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d9932e5f25bb41bdd387b2dc07bea2f389b3cc5403ee90a00ffa0859aae7b245"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62f4a8d65542ad8c20d7a54463cec781d183d89ab9b7fe204b682f73880fc06e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2bf4b5c07d99beb0067451fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315000,"date":"2026-02-23T20:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, nowhere in the world has the free market solved an affordable housing crisis.\n\n Let us look at the Netherlands, with 34% non-market housing; Denmark, 21%; Britain, 16%; and France, 17%. Here in Canada, we are now at 3.4% non-market housing. Nothing in this bill sets targets on non-market housing. My colleague had a good idea around removing the GST on housing. Instead, why do we not take that GST, invest it back into the communities where homes were sold and use it for building non-market housing?\n\n We know we need a mix of market and non-market housing. They go hand in hand. Do the Conservatives support any form of non-market housing? Do they understand its critical importance for the most vulnerable, for people who are trying to make ends meet, especially housing that is geared to income?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315000","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, nowhere in the world has the free market solved an affordable housing crisis.\n\n Let us look at the Netherlands, with 34% non-market housing; Denmark, 21%; Britain, 16%; and France, 17%. Here in Canada, we are now at 3.4% non-market housing. Nothing in this bill sets targets on non-market housing. My colleague had a good idea around removing the GST on housing. Instead, why do we not t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Urban planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","label":"Urban planning","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["372fe45222d205994033248ae9ba9d5c81de27dc8706c2d329af715b877a4709"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["82ebef95ed77eb6ab5a2e214b565c9f6adf1298baa1fdc8085c08f7a0bd549f9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95bdfa469925aaabe7edd558","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306830,"date":"2026-02-24T15:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition signed by Canadian military and RCMP veterans who are calling on the Government of Canada to eliminate the so-called marriage after 60 clause, a discriminatory provision of the Canadian Forces Superannuation Act that denies survivor pension benefits to spouses and partners of military and RCMP veterans who marry after the age of 60.\n\n This outdated policy punishes these veterans for finding love and companionship later in life and forces some to choose between financial security and their partners' future well-being. These veterans have served our country with honour, and they and their loved ones deserve to be treated with fairness and dignity. I am proud today to present this petition and to stand with the petitioners in supporting their call for the government to eliminate this unjust clause and ensure that surviving spouses and partners receive the pension benefits they deserve and should be entitled to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306830","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition signed by Canadian military and RCMP veterans who are calling on the Government of Canada to eliminate the so-called marriage after 60 clause, a discriminatory provision of the Canadian Forces Superannuation Act that denies survivor pension benefits to spouses and partners of military and RCMP veterans who marry after the age of 60.\n\n This outdated p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036809","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036809","label":"Public pensions","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9cf8b0381ce1932a2b93eec308baf4b4050b6b270b5ec4651b8f46e4020a390f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4bcb515622081c27d64e142775eef088cbc7d092fefee1770ffe15c3576e3eb2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7963b1e5764481b51ab4e071","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306831,"date":"2026-02-24T15:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, in this place, there is a responsibility to provide background in evidence when a member starts making claims that a whole province would be—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306831","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, in this place, there is a responsibility to provide background in evidence when a member starts making claims that a whole province would be—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66fd61209fd516079db40a843dc45c93aec0034b3f83c828a7299ce49b32c88e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1fda0bd3e72488ef3056f041","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306832,"date":"2026-02-24T20:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, our health care system is already stretched, yet the Liberal government piles on needless paperwork.\n\nThe College of Family Physicians warns that the disability tax credit form is worsening the strain on family doctors and limiting access to the Canada disability benefit. Instead of fixing the problem, budget 2025 sets aside $10 million to help people navigate a broken system. Provinces already determine disability eligibility.\n\nWhy will the minister not just accept provincial approvals for the disability tax credit and cut red tape so family doctors can focus on patient care and so people with disabilities can actually access their benefits?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306832","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, our health care system is already stretched, yet the Liberal government piles on needless paperwork.\n\nThe College of Family Physicians warns that the disability tax credit form is worsening the strain on family doctors and limiting access to the Canada disability benefit. Instead of fixing the problem, budget 2025 sets aside $10 million to help people navigate a broken system. Provinc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f45b5c083a8cdd922b62c43975409aa5189064d08205a73139ca9f193e1efbfa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["277f337eceaaee3ec535cf4f7ecadb8287d341256b1e3e6ac6275dee33cd5f8c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4400c234df047e0447423c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306833,"date":"2026-02-24T22:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, here we are today, on the fourth anniversary of the war that Russia implemented on Ukraine, and what did we hear from a Conservative? A Conservative got up and stated that \"the program for bogus refugee claimants\" costs the same as the transfer to the whole province of Saskatchewan at $1.6 billion a year. Basically, the member is insinuating that every single immigrant and every single refugee has a bogus claim. \n\nMaybe the Conservatives are trying to hide the fact that, up until yesterday, they had only asked four questions of the health minister. They could do better.\n\nDoes my colleague agree that these refugees and immigrants pay taxes, that they work in our health care system and that this exercise here today is shameful?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306833","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, here we are today, on the fourth anniversary of the war that Russia implemented on Ukraine, and what did we hear from a Conservative? A Conservative got up and stated that \"the program for bogus refugee claimants\" costs the same as the transfer to the whole province of Saskatchewan at $1.6 billion a year. Basically, the member is insinuating that every single immigrant and every singl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["529da6ac1e4b84b075d09689d7ea2f7b039c257f1fa913a0c748a1a047c11225"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c04d6317e4f881321228a765","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306829,"date":"2026-02-25T21:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured today to table a petition on behalf of residents from Port Alberni, Parksville, Qualicum and Courtenay in my riding who are concerned about rising inequality, austerity and the erosion of public services. These petitioners note that while corporate profits continue to reach record highs, more Canadians are struggling to afford the basics of life. They warn that austerity measures, particularly the government's planned $25-billion reduction to publicly funded jobs and services, would only deepen inequality and undermine the programs that Canadians, especially seniors and people living with disabilities, rely on and are entitled to.\n\n This petition also highlights that climate change is already costing Canadians billions of dollars each year and that a fair tax on extreme wealth would generate significant revenue to fund good-paying jobs, public services and a just transition to a sustainable economy.\n\n Last, these petitioners are calling on the House to reconsider sweeping cuts to jobs and services and to bring forward legislation that would ensure that corporations and the wealthiest of Canadians pay their fair share.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306829","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured today to table a petition on behalf of residents from Port Alberni, Parksville, Qualicum and Courtenay in my riding who are concerned about rising inequality, austerity and the erosion of public services. These petitioners note that while corporate profits continue to reach record highs, more Canadians are struggling to afford the basics of life. They warn that austerity","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ca71e24a56df243da1ca2da5ca6e6abc452ba489bc93cddf7b8c9c4b0deaabe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5760a18e272084101123877be52dc51e640cfba690b22b5864ee74f7e455fa1f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29db65f37fef1af1e071c5c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306827,"date":"2026-02-26T15:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to table a petition from Canadians on Vancouver Island, from Victoria and Courtenay to Port Alberni and Parksville. They are all calling on the federal government to take leadership on brain injury awareness, prevention and treatment.\n\nThe petitioners note that brain injuries can occur in many ways, from accidents and sporting events to illnesses, strokes and overdoses, and they often result in serious physical, cognitive, emotional and behavioural effects. They would like to see better coordination between the provinces and the federal government on this issue.\n\nThe petitioners further point out that brain injuries are frequently linked to other challenges, including substance use and homelessness, and they create additional barriers for those affected. It is estimated that there are 1.6 million Canadians who are living with a brain injury today, yet there is no coordinated national response.\n\nThe petitioners call on the government to support my bill, Bill C-206, to develop a national strategy on brain injuries; to improve education, awareness and prevention; to ensure better access to treatment and rehabilitation; and to have better coordination and recovery supports for Canadians living with the impacts of brain injuries.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306827","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to table a petition from Canadians on Vancouver Island, from Victoria and Courtenay to Port Alberni and Parksville. They are all calling on the federal government to take leadership on brain injury awareness, prevention and treatment.\n\nThe petitioners note that brain injuries can occur in many ways, from accidents and sporting events to illnesses, strokes and overdoses, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5afcf45e8a0635f0ee80d0468ba25333620b21aeda8cf1b8e20a129824a5c620"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4ab01ccf5006a1a16a23304","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306828,"date":"2026-02-26T15:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the bureau of pensions advocates is about to lose half of its workforce. The Liberal government is sunsetting a program that is meant to address wait times for Canada's RCMP and military veterans. This is important for veterans who are appealing benefits that have been denied. In fact, the bureau has had an 89% success rate for cases that have been heard improving benefits. \n\nGreg Harlow, the president of the Association of Justice Counsel, the union representing the lawyers employed by the federal government, said, \"Veterans are going to get hurt\" by this. The NDP put forward a motion to reverse these cuts, which was defeated by the Liberal government just yesterday.\n\nCan my colleague speak about the duty and the honour we have to support Canada's RCMP and military veterans?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-90/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306828","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the bureau of pensions advocates is about to lose half of its workforce. The Liberal government is sunsetting a program that is meant to address wait times for Canada's RCMP and military veterans. This is important for veterans who are appealing benefits that have been denied. In fact, the bureau has had an 89% success rate for cases that have been heard improving benefits. \n\nGreg H","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15dfeb76dd0b735c7bdb49157f898d82b5dc422718e362723429aefd0f60b555"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["baa772dc61535d3ddc0cc1345d2127a2ef910ff3390c30dd2a3e362b2560614d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-463114a5c3a670f551e48c1e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336012,"date":"2026-03-09T20:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition that was collected by the National Union of Public and General Employees.\n\nThe petition first highlights that wildland and forest firefighters across Canada perform life-threatening public safety duties, including wildfire suppression and evacuation. They protect communities, ecosystems, property and critical infrastructure during increasingly severe wildfire seasons. The petitioners also highlight that climate change has led to longer, hotter and more destructive wildfire seasons, placing wildland and forest firefighters at a growing risk to their physical and mental health. However, they routinely deploy across provinces and territories, and internationally, to provide emergency response. Despite performing the same dangerous work as other firefighters, wildland and forest firefighters are excluded from the firefighter category in the national occupational classification, which is a misclassification that limits their access to recognition, benefits and protections available to other firefighters and public safety workers.\n\nThe petitioners therefore call on the government to immediately correct the miscalculation of wildland and forest firefighters in the national occupational classification by recognizing them as firefighters. They also ask the government to remove any and all federal barriers that prevent wildland and forest firefighters from being recognized as the firefighters and public safety workers that they are.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336012","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition that was collected by the National Union of Public and General Employees.\n\nThe petition first highlights that wildland and forest firefighters across Canada perform life-threatening public safety duties, including wildfire suppression and evacuation. They protect communities, ecosystems, property and critical infrastructure during increasingly sever","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","label":"Forest fires"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","label":"Forest fires","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7633678bba1f2a171a99a02200ded193e97e334a4fd5f52ed0d69f43ea2bdb2f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["efdc46bff5277ec167f8ac5f407eea01cde64de68da5515a51eec7324c270c63"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b5c51cca59d75d3e828cad2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336009,"date":"2026-03-11T20:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise to present a petition from Canadians committed to advancing peace and human rights, especially given the conflict right now in the Middle East. The petitioners note that Canada pledged itself to these principles with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948. They highlight that justice, equality and freedom are essential to preventing conflict while a lack of respect for these rights fuels violence worldwide.\n\n The petitioners further stress that Canada has lost vital civilian-led capacity for research, education and training in peace operations with the closure of the Pearson Peacekeeping Centre. They cite also that the current spending obligations and commitments by the federal government on NATO and military spending should prioritize peacekeeping. Therefore, they call upon the Government of Canada to establish and fund a new centre of excellence for peace and justice to support conflict resolution, diplomacy and peacebuilding for Canadians and the international community.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336009","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise to present a petition from Canadians committed to advancing peace and human rights, especially given the conflict right now in the Middle East. The petitioners note that Canada pledged itself to these principles with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948. They highlight that justice, equality and freedom are essential to preventing conflict while a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e8cd2b52d4cc1ff3fd367505a9c1e7bdf649a9bed347356d12ee057c5139ed12"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5ae2167004a9ad4078efada52a73a3820416832f8e121f1ef55f069e91335d13"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f5bd3c95f6277d3824efc4a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336010,"date":"2026-03-11T23:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am here again tonight to once again remind the House and, of course, the Liberal government about a massive gap in our emergency preparedness framework: the lack of a standing federal plan to prevent, prepare for and actively respond to marine debris spills.\n\nTo begin, I want to recognize some of the environmental champions who have been calling attention to the urgency of this issue: Lilly Woodbury from Surfrider Pacific Rim; Karla Robison, who helped deal with the tsunami fallout from the Japanese earthquake at Fukushima; Josh Charleson and Josh Temple, both from Coastal Restoration Society; and organizations like Ocean Legacy and Living Oceans. These people and groups have been doing the work on the ground in coastal communities. They have been raising the alarm for years, but the government still has not addressed the gaps. It is time the Liberal government listened and actually took action.\n\nIn 2016, the Hanjin Seattle lost 35 shipping containers just off the coast of Tofino, spreading millions of pieces of damaging styrofoam and plastic across the beaches. In 2021, even worse, the ZIM Kingston lost 109 shipping containers in a spill just south of Ucluelet, in the Strait of Juan de Fuca off Victoria, dumping toxic chemicals, toys, household appliances and other plastic items off our coast. Those are going to appear and resurface for the next 100 years and beyond. Last November, near Bella Bella, a freighter carrying a full load took on water. If not for the quick response of the Heiltsuk nation, it might have caused a devastating marine spill with reverberating effects on the environment and nearby communities.\n\n Each time, it was not the federal government taking the first response and leading the cleanup. It was municipalities, volunteers and, again, often first nations and indigenous communities. While the work they do is incredible, they can only respond rather than act to prevent the worst effects of marine debris spills, straining limited resources in this process.\n\nThat is why, in 2022, the fisheries and oceans committee called for the government to step up with regulations against expanded polystyrene foam in packaging, a stronger polluter pays liability model and a coordinated cleanup plan involving all stakeholders, especially first nations. That is also why the Transportation Safety Board reported in 2024 that Canada is not properly prepared for marine emergencies, including marine debris spills, and advised that a well-resourced response plan will protect marine ecosystems and save lives.\n\nThat is exactly why I am here. It has been over a year since that report came out and four years since the committee report, and there has been nothing from the government. Transport Canada committed to act on these recommendations, yet in all that time, there has been no concrete action, no improved liability framework and no standing response plan. It has been pure inaction, plain and simple.\n\nHowever, there is a clear path forward here. Canada has standing oil spill response teams at the dock, ready to move. I want to thank them for their deeply valuable work. With new equipment, training and capacity, these crews could actually step in and also respond to marine cargo spills as well, giving much-needed support to existing cleanup efforts. A small ecosystem service fee could be applied to each container coming to port, which could help fund critical response capacity while keeping the financial onus on transnational shipping corporations that are doing business, not on everyday Canadians. A polluter pays model, as with oil spills, could apply here.\n\nAgain I will remind the government that the time to act is now. We learned on Monday that cargo volumes at the Port of Vancouver rose to a record high of 170 million tonnes in 2025. More traffic, alongside increasingly dangerous navigating conditions due to climate change, mean that spills will only become more common and more devastating without a real plan.\n\nLet us not ask coastal communities to wait for the next disaster. I ask the House to please pass my bill to establish a national strategy on shipping container spills, build out rapid response capacity with an ecosystem service fee, and take proactive steps to protect our coasts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336010","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am here again tonight to once again remind the House and, of course, the Liberal government about a massive gap in our emergency preparedness framework: the lack of a standing federal plan to prevent, prepare for and actively respond to marine debris spills.\n\nTo begin, I want to recognize some of the environmental champions who have been calling attention to the urgency of this issu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","label":"Oil spills","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b34fb749144271edcd30acf9bd4327755f68d21ca4275a609624295291490486"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6572a6b526415c5bfbdd4ab7f4b04bc72d0e96d425ec77bdc7fddedf4b3d3c66"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad0fa848bbd1dafc5e328e56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336011,"date":"2026-03-11T23:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we can ask coastal communities how the Liberals' regimes are playing out. If a spill were to happen today, nothing has changed. It would be municipalities, conservation groups and first nations caught holding the bag. Promises and statements like that do not protect coastal communities. The Transportation Safety Board said that Canada is not properly prepared for marine emergencies, including marine debris spills.\n\nThe owners of the ZIM Kingston are only on the hook for six years under the current regime the member talked about. A hundred shipping containers landing on the bottom of the ocean are going to take a lot longer than six years to surface.\n\nWe are calling for the government to actually act, follow up on its own transportation board recommendations, listen to the recommendations and introduce a coordinated response plan that includes coastal communities, with an ecosystem service fee so industry actually pays for it and cleans up our coast when there is a spill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336011","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we can ask coastal communities how the Liberals' regimes are playing out. If a spill were to happen today, nothing has changed. It would be municipalities, conservation groups and first nations caught holding the bag. Promises and statements like that do not protect coastal communities. The Transportation Safety Board said that Canada is not properly prepared for marine emergencies, i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","label":"Marine accidents"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","label":"Marine accidents","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6283a22295216771b0e4cb311bd3edd1576f73ed6b50934179df9a73ac42910e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a676410399cd685074dd16fa978d35263e9f195c6a5fb90b38989c1137207cfe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1dfd45761d1dbee97dbb2546","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336003,"date":"2026-03-12T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, because the Liberal fisheries minister has failed to explain the Pacific salmon allocation policy review, misinformation is spreading across the west coast. Recreational fishing is essential to many Vancouver Island communities, which are uncertain about their future, and that confusion is fuelling division and racism.\n\nThis review was directed by the courts to update an outdated policy with conservation first, recognition of constitutionally protected indigenous fishing rights and fairness for everyone on the water.\n\nExplaining what this review actually means is the minister's job. When will she show leadership and set the record straight?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336003","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, because the Liberal fisheries minister has failed to explain the Pacific salmon allocation policy review, misinformation is spreading across the west coast. Recreational fishing is essential to many Vancouver Island communities, which are uncertain about their future, and that confusion is fuelling division and racism.\n\nThis review was directed by the courts to update an outdated poli","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7c46c888c241e9c71e3715a82cb5dc44786e49b5e2f821296593a8d95fc05887"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30c404f8e4f29b2811ca8f8f068e8f1a179841abae3c1b1b05443792fcb2e59e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ff2cca4b738a52bef54b0a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336004,"date":"2026-03-12T21:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we would be hard-pressed to find another member of Parliament that advocates more for the livestock and agriculture industry than that member. I wanted to state that here. Agriculture is not a partisan issue, and this member has been a champion of that.\n\nI want to say how important the conversation around the indexing of British pensions here in Canada is when we have any discussion on trade.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336004","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we would be hard-pressed to find another member of Parliament that advocates more for the livestock and agriculture industry than that member. I wanted to state that here. Agriculture is not a partisan issue, and this member has been a champion of that.\n\nI want to say how important the conversation around the indexing of British pensions here in Canada is when we have any discussion o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6dbca3ec0b9b38e38f2284e4635bfdcc7bca0550474e23db12d9b3cbe7165bfa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3193ba94270f09ed64702ec5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336005,"date":"2026-03-12T22:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to speak to Bill C-13, legislation that would implement the protocol on the accession of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland to the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership. At its core, the bill would update Canadian legislation so the United Kingdom can formally join the CPTPP trade agreement so Canada can meet its obligations under that accession protocol.\n\nI will begin by acknowledging the broader context in which this legislation is being debated.\n\nCanada's economy is deeply tied to international trade, as members are well aware. Millions of jobs in this country depend on exports and on our ability to access global markets. Over the past several years, we have been reminded about how fragile global supply chains can be and how risky it can be for Canada to rely too heavily on a single trading partner. We acknowledge, as New Democrats, that diversifying our trade relationships matters, that strengthening economic co-operation with democratic allies matters, and that building resilient, rules-based trading systems is in Canada's long-term interest.\n\nThe United Kingdom is an important partner in that effort. It is a G7 country, one of the world's largest economies and a nation with which Canada shares deep historical ties, cultural connections and long-standing diplomatic relationships. Expanding trade opportunities between Canada and the United Kingdom has the potential to support Canadian exporters, encourage investment and reinforce the global rules-based trading system at a time when that system is facing increasing pressure. It is for those reasons that there is value in strengthening our economic partnership with the United Kingdom.\n\nHowever, supporting trade diversification does not mean giving the government a blank cheque. Parliament has a responsibility to ensure that trade agreements serve Canadians fairly, protect our public interests and deliver real benefits for workers, farmers and communities across this country. On that front, Bill C-13 raises several important concerns that must be addressed.\n\nThe first concern is transparency. Under the Government of Canada's policy on tabling treaties in Parliament, when the government introduces implementing legislation for a new free trade agreement, it is required to table an economic impact assessment outlining the projected costs and benefits of the agreement. This policy exists for a simple reason, which is that members of Parliament cannot make informed decisions about trade agreements without understanding their economic implications.\n\nThe requirement was introduced after repeated calls for greater transparency in trade negotiations. In fact, in 2020, the government committed to strengthening parliamentary oversight of trade agreements by ensuring that economic impact assessments would accompany implementing legislation. However, in the case of Bill C-13, no economic impact assessment has been tabled. This undermines accountability and weakens the ability of the House to properly scrutinize the agreement before us.\n\nThe second concern we have relates to the ongoing barriers faced by Canadian agricultural producers in accessing the United Kingdom market. For years, and we heard this in the House today repeatedly, Canadian beef and pork producers have raised concerns about the United Kingdom's sanitary and phytosanitary regulations. These rules relate to food safety and to animal and plant health, but in practice, they function as non-tariff barriers that prevent Canadian products from entering the U.K. market.\n\nDespite years of discussions, consultations and negotiations, these barriers remain largely unchanged. This needs to be fixed. The result is a trading relationship that is far from reciprocal. In fact, the numbers tell a very clear story: There were no Canadian beef exports to the United Kingdom in 2024 and none in 2025. At the same time, imports of U.K. beef into Canada have increased significantly. They rose from $16.6 million in 2023 to $42.5 million in 2024, representing an increase of more than 150% in a single year. This is not the outcome Canadian producers were promised when the negotiations began.\n\n Organizations representing Canada's agricultural sector, including the Canadian Cattle Association, the Canadian Pork Council and the Canadian Meat Council, have all raised serious concerns about the lack of meaningful market access. They need to be consulted.\n\nCanadian farmers and ranchers operate under some of the highest food safety standards in the world. They produce high-quality products that are competitive in markets around the globe, and they deserve fair and reciprocal access to markets, especially when Canada is opening its own market to imports. Without meaningful access to the U.K. market, the benefits of this agreement will remain limited for many Canadian producers.\n\nThe third concern relates to investor-state dispute settlement provisions, commonly known as ISDS. These provisions allow foreign investors to challenge government policies through international arbitration if they believe those policies harm their investments. Under NAFTA, Canada faced numerous ISDS claims from foreign investors. More than 60% of the cases filed against Canada under NAFTA were linked to environmental or natural resource measures. That is deeply concerning.\n\nThese experiences raise serious questions about the impact of ISDS provisions on the government's ability to regulate in the public interest. That is one of the reasons Canada removed the ISDS from the renegotiated Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement, CUSMA.\n\nIn the case of Bill C-13, the government has not secured a side letter with the United Kingdom to exclude ISDS provisions between our two countries. This is particularly puzzling because the United Kingdom has already signed such side letters with Australia and New Zealand in their agreements. Canada could have negotiated the same arrangement, and we hope it will. Instead, these provisions remain in place.\n\nA coalition of civil society organizations, labour unions and academics from both Canada and the United Kingdom has called on the government to remove ISDS protections from this agreement. We are hoping that the government will act. If Canada has already recognized these risks in other agreements, then it is reasonable to expect the government to address them here as well.\n\nWe have heard a lot today that there is another issue connected to Canada's relationship with the United Kingdom that deserves attention in this debate. It is a decades-long issue of fairness that affects tens of thousands of seniors living here in Canada. I am referring to the problem of frozen British pensions. At the outset, I want to thank Ian Andexser from Nanaimo, the chair of the Canadian Alliance of British Pensioners, for his leadership on this issue, as well as all those who are members of that organization.\n\nMore than 100,000 British pensioners live in Canada and receive a state pension from the United Kingdom. Those pensions are frozen at the rate the pensioners first received when they retired or when they moved abroad. For over 70 years, unlike British pensioners living in the United States, Israel, Turkey, the Philippines, the European Union or several other countries, British pensioners here in Canada do not receive annual cost of living increases. This is unfair.\n\nCanada itself does not treat pensioners this way when they move overseas. Whether a Canadian retiree lives in Vancouver, in London, or in Sydney, Australia, their CPP benefits continue to increase with inflation. The U.K.'s policy stands in stark contrast to that. The consequences are very real for many seniors. As inflation rises and living costs increase, the purchasing power of frozen pensions declines year after year.\n\nSome seniors are struggling to afford basic necessities such as food, heating and medication. I think about Anne Puckridge, a 100-year-old veteran, who is receiving literally less than half of her pension because she chose to retire in Canada. While pensioners in the U.K. receive 176 pounds a week, the freeze means she is getting only 72 pounds a week. Like Anne, many were unaware of this policy before they moved to Canada. We know that a third of women who are over the age of 65 in this country are living in poverty.\n\nPeople like Anne who spent decades contributing to the U.K. pension system, believing their retirement income would follow them wherever they chose to live, which it should have, have instead discovered too late that their pension would never increase. Because these pensions remain frozen, many seniors eventually rely on Canadian income support programs, including the guaranteed income supplement. In effect, Canadian taxpayers end up helping to fill the gap created by the U.K. government's policy. Estimates suggest this situation costs Canada hundreds of millions of dollars a year.\n\nSuccessive Canadian governments have raised this issue with the United Kingdom repeatedly, and each time the U.K. has declined. That raises an important question: If Canada is strengthening trade relations with the United Kingdom and deepening our economic partnership through agreements like this one, why is this long-standing injustice not being addressed as part of those negotiations? Trade negotiations are moments of leverage. They provide opportunities to resolve long-standing disputes and secure fair outcomes exactly like this one, yet once again the government appears to have failed to use that leverage.\n\nBill C-13 represents an important step in Canada's trade relationship with the United Kingdom. Trade diversification matters. Building stronger partnerships with trusted allies matters. Strengthening the global trading system matters, but Parliament must ensure these agreements are fair, transparent and in the public interest. \n\nThis means providing the economic analysis needed for informed decision-making. It means ensuring Canadian producers receive meaningful access to international markets. It means protecting democratic policy-making by addressing problematic investor-state dispute resolution settlement provisions, and it means standing up for fairness for the tens of thousands of seniors in Canada affected by the U.K.'s frozen pension policy. \n\nTrade agreements should reflect more than economic opportunity. They should reflect fairness, reciprocity and respect for the people whose lives are shaped by these policies.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336005","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to speak to Bill C-13, legislation that would implement the protocol on the accession of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland to the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership. At its core, the bill would update Canadian legislation so the United Kingdom can formally join the CPTPP trade agreement so Canada c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f2e4160cdd264a455de9aa32f0a1a38eb35b3ad33536dbd961f448a64d283bef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["05be8c1551eb47519060daf080da49cde3016b865a849abe074c727ea9cb234b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e3846388336f0b5cc903581","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336006,"date":"2026-03-12T22:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I outlined at the beginning, we of course support trade, and we put conditions on how we support trade. It cannot be a blank cheque from the government. We also believe in reciprocity. We outlined, regarding the pork producers and the beef producers, that it is not reciprocal. These countries are getting access to our market, but we are not getting the same access to their markets. That is unfair. That actually has to be addressed when we negotiate. Of course, there are issues outside of this that we need to have at the table, like the British pension issue that I talked about. These issues all need to be part of the conversation, but we need to make sure it is fair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336006","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I outlined at the beginning, we of course support trade, and we put conditions on how we support trade. It cannot be a blank cheque from the government. We also believe in reciprocity. We outlined, regarding the pork producers and the beef producers, that it is not reciprocal. These countries are getting access to our market, but we are not getting the same access to their markets.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c60d30a6cb3b4e8c10ef343e6e54784695608114dd363fccfe6e5af702f8c6ae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb54f8d469b3329e90fa53764fc5330f9e6486c0fd158d15cf90a376faa380fc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b5e3f43547050c168000f48","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336007,"date":"2026-03-12T22:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from the Bloc raises a really important point. It is something I hopefully addressed, for the most part, in my speech, but he is absolutely right. This exposes Canada when it comes to the environment and when it comes to sovereignty here at home. We were able to get those ISDS, or investor-state dispute settlement, provisions removed from CUSMA. It should be something we could also negotiate in this agreement. I do not understand why the government is not putting that in as part of this agreement. I am glad to see the Bloc and the New Democrats advocating for this, so that this is dealt with and there is a responsible way forward when it comes to Bill C-13.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336007","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague from the Bloc raises a really important point. It is something I hopefully addressed, for the most part, in my speech, but he is absolutely right. This exposes Canada when it comes to the environment and when it comes to sovereignty here at home. We were able to get those ISDS, or investor-state dispute settlement, provisions removed from CUSMA. It should be something we ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","label":"Environment","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fffee6a5b36d65b50519d5b1f707459580b07e09f961eeae2cdf38dbc704d26"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b663bdce494b149cfe0e58da191ccd4e8a648ec071f7a27f8cfecba5cec52481"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e14f075a8d15219ef5833d9d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336008,"date":"2026-03-12T22:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, like I said earlier, U.K. pensioners living in the United States, Israel, Turkey, the Philippines and the European Union are actually not penalized like this. Their pensions are not frozen. They are indexed, just like our pensions are for Canadians who are retiring abroad. However, for some reason, Canada has not been able to get an agreement with the U.K. The Prime Minister supposedly has this great relationship with the U.K. He should be able to negotiate this unfairness and this unjust policy by the U.K. government. \n\nLike I said earlier, a third of Canadian women over the age of 65 are living in poverty. This is absolutely a critical step to addressing that and this injustice. I hope that the government will take it seriously. This is an opportune moment, when it comes to a trade agreement, to address irritants like this that are impacting the lives of British citizens who are living here in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336008","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, like I said earlier, U.K. pensioners living in the United States, Israel, Turkey, the Philippines and the European Union are actually not penalized like this. Their pensions are not frozen. They are indexed, just like our pensions are for Canadians who are retiring abroad. However, for some reason, Canada has not been able to get an agreement with the U.K. The Prime Minister supposedl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ecd18a00e3622cade0f2c8bed82a5c24df4dccb764848c3cc83d8c2d8e8338d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["81fc053d636756a752c58d80a7228fa3b6cb2fb9f24c30ef7fd2a1fdb3cb630f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44fb94a3ca54d4acacfa7d84","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384253,"date":"2026-03-23T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, public health experts across Canada are clear that supervised consumption sites save lives and connect people to treatment, recovery and support, and yet, in Ontario, the Conservative government is cutting supervised consumption sites. In Alberta, the Conservative government is closing Calgary's only such service, despite the fact that thousands of overdoses have been reversed there without a single recorded death.\n\n Frontline workers, physicians and public health researchers warn that shutting these services would not end substance use. Instead, they warn it would increase overdose deaths, push drug use further into public spaces and place greater strain on already overburdened emergency services, hospitals and law enforcement.\n\n At a time when families and communities are grieving profound loss, Canadians expect leadership from the federal government grounded in evidence, compassion and public health. We have to strengthen the full continuum of care, not weaken it. Lives depend on it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384253","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, public health experts across Canada are clear that supervised consumption sites save lives and connect people to treatment, recovery and support, and yet, in Ontario, the Conservative government is cutting supervised consumption sites. In Alberta, the Conservative government is closing Calgary's only such service, despite the fact that thousands of overdoses have been reversed there w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b777874590740a289e72a03c2274e7d453e649a3aade5c9f90b83dec40e07511"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f886a54062af44edcaf1462b6946c46b34878c54b229e4d60e33976225b30c7a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5116c4538bb662203b5ecebb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384254,"date":"2026-03-23T20:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour today to table a petition on behalf of Vancouver Islanders who are deeply upset and concerned about the cutting of the world-class ghost gear fund. They cite that ghost gear is abandoned, lost or discarded fishing gear that is among the deadliest sources of plastic pollution.\n\nThe petitioners note that ghost gear kills fish, marine mammals, seabirds and turtles; damages habitats; and creates microplastics and even hazards for navigation and active harvesters, hurting coastal economies. They point out that dedicated funding for retrieval, prevention, repair and recycling works, creating skilled jobs and partnerships with indigenous communities, small businesses, fishers, harbour authorities and recyclers, especially in rural and remote regions.\n\nPetitioners are asking for the ghost gear fund, which helps protect coastal communities and our oceans, to be reinstated.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384254","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour today to table a petition on behalf of Vancouver Islanders who are deeply upset and concerned about the cutting of the world-class ghost gear fund. They cite that ghost gear is abandoned, lost or discarded fishing gear that is among the deadliest sources of plastic pollution.\n\nThe petitioners note that ghost gear kills fish, marine mammals, seabirds and turtles; damage","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64a029fe3190933774f1e38c1154eabedd84a5388651d0c109cd072db1f1f034"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f21ed3fd5dc08f37bf525c8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384252,"date":"2026-03-24T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the illegal war waged by Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu in the Middle East is inflicting devastating consequences on civilians, especially children. The humanitarian and environmental tolls are immense, and the economic fallout is global. It is driving up gas and fertilizer prices, disrupting critical supplies, like helium used in MRIs, and threatening pharmaceutical supply chains. Canadians who are already struggling with the cost of living will feel these impacts.\n\nWill the Prime Minister ensure that Canada is not complicit with our arms exports in the killings of civilians and take a clear stance against this horrific war?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384252","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the illegal war waged by Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu in the Middle East is inflicting devastating consequences on civilians, especially children. The humanitarian and environmental tolls are immense, and the economic fallout is global. It is driving up gas and fertilizer prices, disrupting critical supplies, like helium used in MRIs, and threatening pharmaceutical supply chain","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","label":"Humanitarian crisis"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","label":"Humanitarian crisis","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0286c9894f82af233fe11e92dd7e643fd261605bda771202c2ee820262a7deda"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7886b7894356696b541b0b03cd61e3f1831126941e5287409766b85a6e58288f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c11f594bfbd5e08468f872c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384251,"date":"2026-03-26T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, seniors in my riding are being told they no longer qualify for the Canadian dental care plan because they supposedly have access to private insurance, even when that so-called access is only theoretical, unaffordable or based on plans they opted out of decades ago. Some have already had treatment approved and completed and are now being told they may have to pay the money back.\n\n Why is the government clawing back dental care from seniors who followed the rules and simply cannot afford private dental care coverage?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384251","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, seniors in my riding are being told they no longer qualify for the Canadian dental care plan because they supposedly have access to private insurance, even when that so-called access is only theoretical, unaffordable or based on plans they opted out of decades ago. Some have already had treatment approved and completed and are now being told they may have to pay the money back.\n\n Why ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","label":"Dental insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","label":"Dental insurance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73f065d413a301342dfcb748ae835cff3e85332319d14d1901264334fd111545"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eb2abe12dfa20c8a61191a7b73831a5e5292736c8273f074ff0bc3f2dfbebc16"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26081044ce6dff89ba7e9dc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425354,"date":"2026-04-13T20:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a petition on behalf of constituents of my riding of Courtenay—Alberni. They are citing that there are 165,000 new cases of brain injuries annually in Canada; that health and community service providers require more education regarding the intersection of brain injury, mental health and addiction; that the risk of suicide increases by 400% for a survivor of brain injury; that brain injury survivors face a 200% increase in risk of struggling with addictions after sustaining a brain injury; and that, despite the federal government's committing $11 million over 10 years to improve community support and mental health and addiction services, none are specifically targeted to brain injury.\n\n The petitioners are calling upon the government to support my bill, Bill C-206, to develop a national strategy to support and improve brain injury awareness, prevention and treatment, as well as the rehabilitation and recovery of persons living with brain injury. Preferably, the petitioners would like this brain injury strategy implemented in the spring economic statement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-101/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425354","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a petition on behalf of constituents of my riding of Courtenay—Alberni. They are citing that there are 165,000 new cases of brain injuries annually in Canada; that health and community service providers require more education regarding the intersection of brain injury, mental health and addiction; that the risk of suicide increases by 400% for a survivor of brain injury; ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09ad08a89eb08aa3fe08f8613f6d5eb6dc76031fdc01f938eebf3a42378f3bfa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fcdb8fc107a39a2d472e0a2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425346,"date":"2026-04-14T15:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour today to table this petition on behalf of petitioners who are part of the peace train movement. They highlight that for lasting peace, military deterrence must take place within the context of long-term solutions identified through research and analysis. \n\nThey also note that, within its NATO funding commitment, Canada can and should establish a national centre dedicated to peacebuilding and should contribute much more funding, training, equipment and personnel to UN peacekeeping, and that Canada's pre-eminent free institutions dedicated to peacebuilding have been terminated, including the Pearson Peacekeeping Centre and the Canadian Institute for Peace and Human Security. They point to a national defence report that recommends that the Government of Canada re-establish the Pearson Peacekeeping Centre with a mandate that includes, but is not limited to, conflict research, conflict prevention, mediation and civilian protection.\n\n Lastly, they recommend that the Canadian Peacekeeping Veterans Association also advocate for the re-establishment of the former peacekeeping centre. \n\nThe petitioners' call to action is to establish and fund, as a fundamental part of Canada's increasing commitment to defence and security, an independent Canadian centre for peace dedicated to peacekeeping and global security through research, education, policy and training in conflict resolution, diplomacy and peace operations for Canadian civilians, police and military personnel, and the international community.\n\n As members can imagine, this is a timely petition given the global conflict that we are enduring right now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425346","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour today to table this petition on behalf of petitioners who are part of the peace train movement. They highlight that for lasting peace, military deterrence must take place within the context of long-term solutions identified through research and analysis. \n\nThey also note that, within its NATO funding commitment, Canada can and should establish a national centre dedicat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["266b9e17a75c46b82abf1d4828b56fe54c8cbf82950c0c906f4de7f30d091776"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0b4e2c1db7d6f555489dd53d45a1273ecab0cb1a00b87ce656a616f73eae5a94"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61f71b0f5fce34af17a77c34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425347,"date":"2026-04-14T15:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I just hosted four town halls in my riding on the cost of living and affordability, and I brought this very idea that the Conservatives are proposing to the people at those town halls. Nearly unanimously, people there wanted the taxes removed temporarily to provide relief. However, it was also unanimous that the people at those town halls wanted the big oil and gas companies, which are posting record profits, to pick up the tab. Attendees agreed that the relief needs to happen, but it should not be at the expense of investments in roads, infrastructure and health.\n\nWhen will the Conservative and Liberal coalition for corporate welfare end? What is the threshold on corporate profits for big oil and gas before the Conservatives and Liberals will ask them to pay a little bit more when they win so they can take the pressure off everyday Canadians and pay their fair share for once?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425347","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I just hosted four town halls in my riding on the cost of living and affordability, and I brought this very idea that the Conservatives are proposing to the people at those town halls. Nearly unanimously, people there wanted the taxes removed temporarily to provide relief. However, it was also unanimous that the people at those town halls wanted the big oil and gas companies, which ar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c24de00ad065101cda7347aa3df87d3e8fa6f36f431e59cc89c1fea022e30dff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["40c74bdeb40df5576cf11feb6bf1b151ac23e2f6aff9c01fad05cd2a6f182559"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8fa5cae5414f400749660f19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425348,"date":"2026-04-14T15:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Statistics Canada highlighted yesterday that inequality is skyrocketing even more, with the bottom 40% only holding 3% of the wealth and the top 20% holding two-thirds of the wealth. This is at a time when the big banks have posted $70 billion in profits. For the top big five oil companies, it is almost $25 billion. The top five grocery stores have gone from $2.4 billion in profits to $6.3 billion. \n\nAt what point, or at what level, would there be a threshold between the Conservatives and Liberals where they will charge an excess profit tax on the big corporations or a wealth tax on individuals so they are moving forward with tackling inequality in this country? This measure alone would not do that. It would actually push the deficits, and the investments in infrastructure and health that would help those people, down the road.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425348","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Statistics Canada highlighted yesterday that inequality is skyrocketing even more, with the bottom 40% only holding 3% of the wealth and the top 20% holding two-thirds of the wealth. This is at a time when the big banks have posted $70 billion in profits. For the top big five oil companies, it is almost $25 billion. The top five grocery stores have gone from $2.4 billion in profits to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["284777b77fa9cf724b7728ef2b3f8a5d1457726081dbd3518277e19908e92181"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4186a3e46086d76f1eb7a9b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425349,"date":"2026-04-14T18:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it feels like Groundhog Day showing up here. We come here and hear the Liberals adopting Conservative policies, such as removing the carbon tax. The Conservatives said the sky was falling because of the carbon tax. Now it is the gas tax, or austerity, or the first-time homebuyer tax that my colleague talked about. That has not made housing more affordable.\n\nWhat we see constantly with Liberals and Conservatives is that they are standing up for corporate greed and the corporate machine. Big oil, for example, is posting record profits right now. \n\nWhat is the amount of record profits that big oil can charge before the Liberals or Conservatives will start implementing an excess profit tax so it pays its fair share?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425349","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it feels like Groundhog Day showing up here. We come here and hear the Liberals adopting Conservative policies, such as removing the carbon tax. The Conservatives said the sky was falling because of the carbon tax. Now it is the gas tax, or austerity, or the first-time homebuyer tax that my colleague talked about. That has not made housing more affordable.\n\nWhat we see constantly with","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","label":"Atmospheric emissions","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0af8a3e6a1ad300d8b0527525390df0738cc9e8f74d07d176aa6a35f7309daf5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d6d20d238fe9ea3246d75ed3837132ce0937e630a99cb34f510c845157ee3bb3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f097a7e4f364750b3fee3ecb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425350,"date":"2026-04-14T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, two months ago the Minister of Health stood in the House and called herself \"the guardian of the Canada Health Act\", yet after months of delay, she has failed to act while Danielle Smith expands American-style \"pay for access\" diagnostics and two-tiered care. Canadians cannot afford more stalling while our universal health care system is undermined.\n\nIf the minister is truly the guardian, why is she taking so long to enforce the law and stop the erosion of our public health care system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425350","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, two months ago the Minister of Health stood in the House and called herself \"the guardian of the Canada Health Act\", yet after months of delay, she has failed to act while Danielle Smith expands American-style \"pay for access\" diagnostics and two-tiered care. Canadians cannot afford more stalling while our universal health care system is undermined.\n\nIf the minister is truly the guard","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f162daacc88c5d93fd6b0e20e911182e58702465bbb192ebf2defbba7aede535"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3751685c84a09979d38aff31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425351,"date":"2026-04-14T21:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it was not that long ago that the leader of the official opposition was running on a campaign around axe the tax. He talked about how the sky was falling because of the carbon tax. What happened when the carbon tax was removed? Gas prices dropped for maybe a day or two then started increasing. What we have seen is gas prices skyrocketing. What is also skyrocketing is profits for big oil and gas. \n\nToday, the Liberals adopted another Conservative policy. They removed the carbon tax. Now they have removed the fuel excise tax. If the big oil and gas companies continue to have skyrocketing profits and the price of fuel goes up despite the fact that they are removing this tax, will they finally implement an excess profit tax on big oil and gas?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425351","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it was not that long ago that the leader of the official opposition was running on a campaign around axe the tax. He talked about how the sky was falling because of the carbon tax. What happened when the carbon tax was removed? Gas prices dropped for maybe a day or two then started increasing. What we have seen is gas prices skyrocketing. What is also skyrocketing is profits for big o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4be8d870479e10379cdff498d21f304cd0337981d9a5ae730caa831586ada170"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["af112463aba16bb87714b022d66b302e3dedbce19856cee028ddad8c66544f55"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdc9370ca91151b385568c6f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425352,"date":"2026-04-14T23:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am again here late at night to offer the government common-sense solutions. We hear every day that our health care system is stretched thin. Across the 34 communities in my riding of Courtenay—Alberni, too many people are already struggling to find a family doctor. We should be reducing pressure on the system, not adding to it, yet the federal disability tax credit process continues to do exactly that.\n\nFamily doctors are spending hours on Government of Canada paperwork when they could instead be seeing their patients. The College of Family Physicians of Canada has been clear. In 2022, roughly 250,000 disability tax credit forms consumed about 250,000 hours of physician time, which is the equivalent of one million lost patient visits. That is one million appointments that could have gone to giving Canadians the care they need. \n\nThere is also another side to this problem. Across the country, many people who already qualify for disability supports in their province or territory cannot access the disability tax credit, not because they are ineligible but because they cannot find a doctor to complete the form. No doctor means no form, and no form means no access. As a result, people are being shut out of both the disability tax credit and the disability benefit that depends on getting the disability tax credit. The benefit they are trying to get is modest, about $200 a month, but it can make a huge difference in the life of someone who is living on disability. It can be the difference between getting by and falling even further behind. Instead of removing barriers, the government is maintaining them.\n\nWe are also learning from public servants at the Canada Revenue Agency who deal with the burdensome and duplicative process I identified that they are repeating the work that provinces and territories have already done. While a growing backlog of applications leaves Canadians waiting, this is not just inefficient but deeply frustrating for the staff, doctors and health care workers who are trying to help the people navigate the system to get this done. \n\nI have been raising this issue for years. Tonight I am responding to a question I asked again in December, and this question still has not improved the situation. Budget 2025 sets aside $10 million so applicants can pay a $150 fee to navigate the same broken process. Instead of fixing the system, the Liberal government is asking people to pay to get through it. It is just not okay. This is not a solution. \n\nCanadians deserve to know why these barriers remain. When eligible people cannot access supports, it raises serious ethical questions about whether the complexity is being used to limit access and make life harder rather than to improve outcomes. That is why I introduced Bill C-211, which would make it easier for people with disabilities to access the benefits they are entitled to while reducing the paperwork burden on health care workers. \n\nRight now, Canadians are forced to prove the same disability over and over again across different levels of government. My bill would streamline the process so that when a disability is recognized by a province or territory, it would automatically be recognized federally. This is a practical and common-sense fix. It would reduce barriers, improve access to benefits and free up doctors to focus on patient care. It would also ensure that people are not excluded simply because they cannot access a physician to complete their paperwork. \n\nCanadians deserve a system that works. New Democrats will continue to put forward practical solutions that relieve pressure on our health care system, respect health care workers and ensure that supports reach the very people who need them the most. It is time to fix the disability tax credit process once and for all.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425352","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am again here late at night to offer the government common-sense solutions. We hear every day that our health care system is stretched thin. Across the 34 communities in my riding of Courtenay—Alberni, too many people are already struggling to find a family doctor. We should be reducing pressure on the system, not adding to it, yet the federal disability tax credit process continues","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da1cfb3f4ceb52855d9b6e1a7e3b5cc42f8b4d685d48888b88a2f788f67a8060"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b621fad8204593fa6d89b816b3537a621da01d41a71f552c7506a8c871f0e21d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d31f3fb9e454048e86bc141","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425353,"date":"2026-04-14T23:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, even though this is federal, clearly the Liberal government does not see this as its issue. During COVID, governments moved quickly. We cut red tape, trusted existing systems and delivered support when Canadians needed it most. We need that same urgency now. \n\nToday, doctors are losing valuable time to paperwork instead of seeing patients. People who qualify for the disability tax credit and the Canada disability benefit cannot access the supports they need because they cannot find a doctor to complete the form. Meanwhile, public servants are stuck managing a duplicative process and growing backlogs. When resources are scarce, every hour matters and every barrier matters. \n\nProvinces already assess eligibility. The government needs to recognize that and act: Stop the duplication, free up doctors, support people and let public servants do their job. Why will the Liberal government not act now and take this issue seriously?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425353","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, even though this is federal, clearly the Liberal government does not see this as its issue. During COVID, governments moved quickly. We cut red tape, trusted existing systems and delivered support when Canadians needed it most. We need that same urgency now. \n\nToday, doctors are losing valuable time to paperwork instead of seeing patients. People who qualify for the disability tax cre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8e15bea4eeecd0625f90cba1c14287e943754cf41185e7c0f566c16f31a707c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd9427cda4b3e147f503f7f233a4f296785031fbd7f21af943d413562ab3375c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd0e2c0eb8a541b402cc4739","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300686,"date":"2026-04-21T22:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for Cumberland—Colchester for bringing this motion forward and for raising this important issue about how we support veterans. \n\nThis motion proposes a study on how unused federal lands and buildings could support veterans, including with housing and community services. We support studying these ideas, but let us be clear: This is a non-binding motion. It asks only for a study. Veterans do not live in studies. Already many of them are facing insecurity now, and we already know enough to act. \n\nIf this motion passes and the government operations committee undertakes this study, it must hear directly from veterans about their lived experiences, including the veterans ombud, retired colonel Nishika Jardine, who has been working tirelessly to advance the concerns and urgent needs of veterans. This includes mental health supports for veterans and their families, suicide prevention, rehabilitation and other critical services in addition to housing. \n\n I also want to thank the Legions in my riding, across Vancouver Island and across this country and the local non-profit housing organizations that support people experiencing homelessness, including many that support military and RCMP veterans and their families. In the Comox Valley alone, 16 veterans have been identified as homeless, representing about 12% of the total homeless population. This should never happen in a country like Canada. The Government of Canada pledged a sacred obligation to support veterans and their families. This is to ensure care, compassion and respect. This is often, as members know, referred to as the \"social covenant\". However, the motion before us would not deliver that.\n\n We can see what works. In Esquimalt, the Veterans House, formerly known as Cockrell House, has been helping veterans transition out of homelessness with safe, stable and on-site supports. I also want to acknowledge Angus Stanfield from the Royal Canadian Legion for getting that off the ground. The model works. It provides dignity, stability and community. However, it totally relies on donations and volunteers, which is why it is not scaled up.\n\nCertainly, we need to implement and use government lands to ensure that all veterans have a safe place to live. We cannot be relying on non-profits to do what the government clearly has a responsibility to do. At a time of a housing crisis, these lands should be used to house people, especially those most affected, including veterans and their families, and of course, indigenous peoples. No veteran and no veteran's family should ever be without a home in this country. \n\nWe have heard directly from veterans about what this failure looks like in practice. From Comox Valley, retired sergeant William Webb, who served in the 1st Regiment of the Royal Canadian Horse Artillery, told a parliamentary committee in 2019 that after nearly 20 years of service, he cycled through nine case managers and ultimately became homeless. He said, \"Case managers are not aware of what to do when a veteran, like me, is soon to be homeless and then becomes homeless.\" If the system does not know what to do when a veteran becomes homeless, then the system is not working. \n\nWe need to be honest about how we got here. In 1992, the government pulled out of housing. We know this can be fixed. There are plenty of opportunities, but let us face it: The opportunity is now. Keep public land public, build housing, fund it properly and prioritize veterans and their families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300686","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for Cumberland—Colchester for bringing this motion forward and for raising this important issue about how we support veterans. \n\nThis motion proposes a study on how unused federal lands and buildings could support veterans, including with housing and community services. We support studying these ideas, but let us be clear: This is a non-binding motion. It ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["182385be8f4299ab80f856e131432243ea1f419320c8cce44d6b0a719e45c0f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6a0755f50817a48bcb18d8d37aaec503f10b64b34a01e88542b68860387d39ea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7be96deec3e19ba9d8125738","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300687,"date":"2026-04-21T23:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight on behalf of those who have been cut out of the conversation on the Liberals' pipeline MOU with Alberta Premier, Danielle Smith, and the Canadian taxpayers who are continually on the hook for big oil subsidies. It is time for their voices to be heard. The MOU fails to respect first nations' emphatic stance against a new pipeline to the north coast; fails to respect the crucial principle of free, prior and informed consent; and fails to respect the B.C. government's clear stance that the oil tanker moratorium must stay in place.\n\n However, there is another group this MOU fails to respect, which is Canadian taxpayers. The federal government already subsidizes fossil fuels to the tune of $30 billion, and with no proponent lined up, this new pipeline could be yet another taxpayer-funded, subsidized boondoggle. \n\nWe have seen this film before with the Trans Mountain expansion. In two separate investigations, the Parliamentary Budget Officer found TMX to be a net loss. Since the government purchased the pipeline in 2018, its costs have ballooned from $7.4 billion to $34 billion.\n\n In the long term, subsidizing fossil fuel export infrastructure is a losing game and a bad investment. In a climate-safe scenario, around 70% of new LNG projects would never recover their costs due to low demand and a structural oversupply. Carbon Tracker projects that, in the long term, the financial risks of new Canadian oil and gas projects are double their potential rewards, and while taxpayers lose out, big oil is reaping the rewards. \n\nThe top five Canadian oil companies made over $25 billion in profits just last year and will make $90 billion in windfall profits from the war on Iran. Big oil is already raking in profits off a pipeline they wanted but refused to buy, and now they want another one. While the Liberals and Conservatives will not even ask big oil to support relief for everyday people through a windfall profits tax, the government is instead subsidizing them further with a gas tax cut that big oil should be covering.\n\n Between this MOU and the over $1.8 billion in subsidies for mainly foreign-owned LNG projects, the government appears ready to repeat the same mistake it made with TMX. \n\nThese giveaways to polluters also hurt our health and the health of future generations. We remember the hundreds who died in the 2021 heat dome in British Columbia. We have seen the devastating effects of wildfire smoke, including the tragic death of nine-year-old Carter Vigh. Health Canada points out that these are not distant risks. These are happening now.\n\nThere are also growing legal issues. Cases before the courts argue that government failure on climate action violates Canadian charter rights to life, liberty and security of the person. A case in Ontario supported by Ecojustice reached all the way to the superior court before the provincial government gutted its environmental regulations to evade legal scrutiny.\n\n Internationally, an ICJ advisory opinion finds:\n\nThe failure of a state to take appropriate action to protect the climate system from [greenhouse gas] emissions, including through fossil fuel production, fossil fuel consumption, the granting of fossil fuel exploration licenses, or the provision of fossil fuel fuel subsidies, may constitute an internationally wrongful act....\n\n It is absurd to ask Canadian taxpayers to subsidize big oil and then go back to ask them to finance their own climate crisis, but that is exactly what the Liberals are doing here. Canadians deserve clarity. Is the government going to commit to a pipeline and tanker project that ignores indigenous consent, deepens the climate crisis and exposes Canadians to financial and legal risk, or will it respect rights, protect communities and invest in a sustainable future by cancelling this backroom deal?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300687","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise tonight on behalf of those who have been cut out of the conversation on the Liberals' pipeline MOU with Alberta Premier, Danielle Smith, and the Canadian taxpayers who are continually on the hook for big oil subsidies. It is time for their voices to be heard. The MOU fails to respect first nations' emphatic stance against a new pipeline to the north coast; fails to respect the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b2e55d92b8466913ac12d5ded9bc2e7507c9b40d032093c576be889f11bd948a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ce35972c1b39d9eb45bf5f64b02139a798bfc0014527e8b063aacc6d5699e2d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-075afff18eba71ae2a8273fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300688,"date":"2026-04-21T23:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals may try to dismiss these concerns, but Canadians can see what is happening. The government is still funding big oil, with over $30 billion in taxpayer money and subsidies, while refusing to be transparent about the real cost.\n\nWe have already seen the consequences. Projects like the Trans Mountain expansion have shown that public financing of fossil fuel infrastructure can leave Canadians carrying the risk, while private interests take the reward, while new oil and gas development risks millions more carbon-related deaths and while charter rights concerns pile up for an ever-shrinking market. These oil and gas subsidies make no economic sense, force Canadians to pay for their own climate catastrophe and could violate international law.\n\nIn budget 2025, the government is proposing a so-called strategic financing framework to coordinate funding across Crown corporations and agencies. At a time when families are facing rising costs and communities are dealing with the impacts of climate change, Canadians deserve to know exactly what that means. Does it mean more public money flowing to oil and gas? Does it mean more risk being shifted onto taxpayers? Will the government come clean about how much more it plans to give to big polluters, and why?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300688","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals may try to dismiss these concerns, but Canadians can see what is happening. The government is still funding big oil, with over $30 billion in taxpayer money and subsidies, while refusing to be transparent about the real cost.\n\nWe have already seen the consequences. Projects like the Trans Mountain expansion have shown that public financing of fossil fuel infrastructure ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6940e5835c946f9f8dc0a23c87a5b676a49f2dcb60705218149e964b9f438dbf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d769cd6ba1b1db2be8493639453b07d5aabdfee6edf7db60ded2d947f7d162db"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e4f7516e66fdc82635584ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300685,"date":"2026-04-24T17:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present this petition on behalf of farmers across this country who have signed this petition.\n\nThey cite that, in January, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada announced plans to cut 665 positions, primarily scientific, technical and support staff carrying out agricultural research, and close seven research facilities. They cite that the affected positions and facilities are essential to Canadian agriculture, representing an irreplaceable investment in facilities, equipment and highly educated personnel; an irreplaceable knowledge base; essential infrastructure for public plant breeding needed to address critical production challenges to provide ongoing success for farmers and our agricultural economy; and a strategic asset to safeguard Canadians' ability to feed ourselves.\n\nThey call on the government to reverse these planned cuts of 665 Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada staff and the closure of the organic and regenerative research program at Swift Current and of the Lacombe, Guelph, Quebec City, Indian Head, Scott, Portage la Prairie and Nappan research facilities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300685","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to present this petition on behalf of farmers across this country who have signed this petition.\n\nThey cite that, in January, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada announced plans to cut 665 positions, primarily scientific, technical and support staff carrying out agricultural research, and close seven research facilities. They cite that the affected positions and facilitie","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea326240830dbe28e2b061cbb6ab28b9b3d0c761df395890ef442218b8953f11"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9331092f3885b09904c402e0573ca88a209e0035bbc10fed251eb642f3dd8f8e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c4a5b3953b9881da9dcbba0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725153,"date":"2026-04-27T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on the west coast, commercial fish harvesters, the people actually doing the fishing, are being pushed out. Corporate concentration and growing foreign ownership of licences and quota are driving up costs and draining wealth out of coastal communities. We do not even know who owns much of this quota because there is no public registry. Meanwhile, on the east coast, an owner-operator model protects independent fish harvesters and keeps the value in local communities. It is like we are living in two different countries. \n\nWhen will the Liberals fix this and bring in a west coast owner-operator model, increase transparency and stop foreign and corporate ownership of our fisheries?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725153","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on the west coast, commercial fish harvesters, the people actually doing the fishing, are being pushed out. Corporate concentration and growing foreign ownership of licences and quota are driving up costs and draining wealth out of coastal communities. We do not even know who owns much of this quota because there is no public registry. Meanwhile, on the east coast, an owner-operator m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquaculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47540","label":"Aquaculture","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd28fe36d22a39e0ff7a10cd5e077664fc9c06b828c1b0500ca4b8d48950c9bd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2b2e182bdd3203b09c4bee3cec8535db6079eda755153b228898a34d70cd677b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3e3be25a42d2bba9316805e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725157,"date":"2026-04-27T20:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to table a petition on behalf of my constituents. \n\nThe petitioners highlight that the threat of wildfires, floods, and other natural disasters is on the rise as a result of climate change; that mass casualty events, including the 2018 Fredericton shooting and the Lac-Mégantic rail disaster, leave scars on their communities for years afterward; that evacuations, property loss, grief and uncertainty resulting from emergencies have shown to have lasting impacts on mental health and can exasperate mental illness; that, in November 2025, a grizzly attack on a school field near Bella Coola in British Columbia severely injured students and a staff member, leaving students and families in the wider Nuxalk community coping with ongoing trauma, which highlights the need for accessible mental health supports in remote communities; that Australia, New Zealand and the United States have introduced federal frameworks for addressing mental health following large-scale emergencies; and that the federal government is involved in emergency management, often in collaboration with provincial, territorial and indigenous governments.\n\n The petitioners call on the federal government to support Motion No. 20 and work with provinces and territories, indigenous peoples, labour unions and other stakeholders to develop and implement a national strategy for addressing the mental health impacts of emergencies, including those arising from natural disasters and mass casualty events.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725157","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to table a petition on behalf of my constituents. \n\nThe petitioners highlight that the threat of wildfires, floods, and other natural disasters is on the rise as a result of climate change; that mass casualty events, including the 2018 Fredericton shooting and the Lac-Mégantic rail disaster, leave scars on their communities for years afterward; that evacuations, property","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","label":"Disaster relief","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b2288e565d5f90ba6ee77e751f9d922c2ee4254324a4ccbdcda64af235ea5ec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da32aae1d3f84529f85aa313868448248ba7ca17f092652ad3b39bb0fde5dcbd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e70733d2da2186cec93544ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725141,"date":"2026-04-28T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister cannot go on TV one day and claim that pharmacare is a nation-building program for all Canadians, and the next day allow entire provinces to be excluded.\n\n Newfoundland and Labrador's health minister says that the federal government has closed the door on negotiations. Right now, where one lives determines whether one can access essential medications. People are being left out altogether. That is not a national program. It is patchwork. \n\nWhy is this government abandoning Newfoundland and Labrador and so many other provinces and territories while claiming that pharmacare is for all Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725141","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister cannot go on TV one day and claim that pharmacare is a nation-building program for all Canadians, and the next day allow entire provinces to be excluded.\n\n Newfoundland and Labrador's health minister says that the federal government has closed the door on negotiations. Right now, where one lives determines whether one can access essential medications. People are bei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0043a1c102ab2f49a4b567686b496fea4abb05ce7bc8cd888312daff7b9c6744"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77423ff21787ce187dcdfe47","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725145,"date":"2026-04-28T22:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we know that people living with disabilities who qualify get $200 for the Canada disability benefit. That is very meagre and the Liberals offered nothing in terms of an increase, despite the high rates of inflation. \n\nAlso, we talked to the Liberals and brought forward ideas about improving the disability tax credit form to honour people who are living with disabilities in their province or territory so they would automatically qualify. What do the Liberals do? They tinker with the form and say it is good enough, but it is costing 250,000 doctor-hours a year and one million patient visits just to fill out that form. That red tape alone is a reason to honour people living with disabilities in their province or territory.\n\nDoes the leader of the official opposition support our proposal that if people are on disability in their province or territory, they should automatically qualify? Do the Conservatives support increasing the Canada disability benefit for those living with disabilities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725145","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we know that people living with disabilities who qualify get $200 for the Canada disability benefit. That is very meagre and the Liberals offered nothing in terms of an increase, despite the high rates of inflation. \n\nAlso, we talked to the Liberals and brought forward ideas about improving the disability tax credit form to honour people who are living with disabilities in their provi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fa3d54cd9e839a1a1ffe95166ce8027cada60f806d809ced80277e58832677de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9defa70a9d05a44a7154375a1b1ff97cfa0e6d5d6a37183b21ebfc162d87475f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57ebbbd7c4bde290ac680027","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725129,"date":"2026-04-29T20:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government's decision to end the Canadian Corps of Commissionaires' preferential contracting threatens jobs for veterans who rely on it for stable work after service, while potentially shifting contracts to for-profit firms. For decades, Commissionaires has supported their transition from serving our nation in the Canadian Armed Forces or the RCMP with dignity. \n\nWhy is the Minister of Veterans Affairs moving ahead without any consultation with the commissionaires, and will she instead reverse these arbitrary procurement changes before veterans pay the price?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725129","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government's decision to end the Canadian Corps of Commissionaires' preferential contracting threatens jobs for veterans who rely on it for stable work after service, while potentially shifting contracts to for-profit firms. For decades, Commissionaires has supported their transition from serving our nation in the Canadian Armed Forces or the RCMP with dignity. \n\nWhy is th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d2167800c6fba5690c9d4d065c1ce704dbad53308aacad3f5c1ec1945142f6a8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9aff86e8bdcb414890c478ef44080cada17034bd53ae4fe061f586a43ab19ee6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-572f7861a05a6b3276eb079e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725131,"date":"2026-04-29T20:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition on behalf of constituents on Vancouver Island.\n\nPetitioners are highlighting that Canada is experiencing a mental health and substance use crisis that was exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. They highlight that too many Canadians are unable to access mental health or substance use supports in a timely manner, that the lack of access to community-based mental health and substance use services increases demands on hospital emergency rooms and primary care providers, and that untreated and inadequately treated mental illness carries significant social and economic costs.\n\nPetitioners are calling on the government to support Bill C-201 and legislate parity between physical and mental health in Canada's universal public health care system to ensure timely access to evidence-based, culturally appropriate and publicly funded mental health and substance use services beyond hospital and physician settings.\n\nThird, petitioners are calling on the government to establish the Canada mental health transfer that the Liberals promised to sustainably fund the provision of mental health and substance use services, and to immediately disburse an initial investment of $4.5 billion for mental health care and substance use services to the provinces and territories.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725131","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition on behalf of constituents on Vancouver Island.\n\nPetitioners are highlighting that Canada is experiencing a mental health and substance use crisis that was exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. They highlight that too many Canadians are unable to access mental health or substance use supports in a timely manner, that the lack of access to community-b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1cbc7a06685ea02fa18ceaa8abfde7c38aeeb9c875b3cf86bfc8c540e2e7bc6d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["744ab3fbb541c7980a355ed322f59960bd14b516c137411fdb550f09d0ffd2af"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf665ba4c120b75b1ff5df62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725137,"date":"2026-04-29T23:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, just like last week, and just like the week before, I am here tonight to drag the government in here to hold it to account and to ensure that it protects and enhances our public health care system and follows through with its promises. I will just serve notice that I will be dragging the government back in here again next week if it does not take some action.\n\nNo one in Canada, not our kids, parents or grandparents, should have to worry about the cost of medication they need to stay healthy, but that is exactly what is happening today. Canadians were promised the beginning of a national pharmacare program. We actually voted on it. They were promised a single-payer system that serves people, not a patchwork system that leaves millions behind.\n\n The promise was that we were going to start with universal free access to diabetes medicine and birth control. It was highly celebrated by the Liberals. Right now, only three provinces and one territory are covered. That is about 17% of Canadians. More than four out of five Canadians cannot access the federal pharmacare plan today. This means access to life-saving diabetes medicine or birth control coverage depends on where someone lives. It depends on their postal code.\n\nWhile I hate to do this, I must mention that this inaction comes while many Liberal MPs are bragging about a national pharmacare program that their own constituents cannot even access. In Newfoundland and Labrador, for example, the provincial health minister said that the federal Liberal government has closed the door on negotiations. Meanwhile, the Liberal MP for Labrador defends pharmacare as putting money back in Canadians' pockets. On Prince Edward Island, the federal government has moved slowly, and its provincial health minister says that the federal government has told them that pharmacare funds will expire in 2029 and will not be renewed.\n\nMeanwhile, the member for Cardigan claimed that pharmacare is a key program for all Canadians. Nova Scotia is ready to negotiate, but it is still waiting for an invitation. Meanwhile, the member for Cumberland—Colchester described pharmacare as an essential service that Liberals will continue to protect. Their premier says he cannot even get a meeting to negotiate a deal. \n\nThese provinces want in. They are ready to work, but they are being shut out while these Liberals pat themselves on the back. That is not nation building. The Prime Minister was just on CBC two days ago touting his commitment to pharmacare. Even today in question period, he rightly criticised the Conservatives for voting against pharmacare, but only three provinces and one territory actually have an agreement.\n\nYesterday we saw that, in the spring economic update, the word pharmacare is mentioned only once. It signals that the Liberals are walking away from their commitment to the national pharmacare plan they ran on during the last election. This has real consequences. People are skipping prescriptions. They are cutting pills in half. They are choosing between paying rent and filling a prescription. In a country as wealthy as Canada, this should never happen. This is not what Canadians were promised, like I said in the last election.\n\nNew Democrats in the House and across Canada are fighting to ensure Canadians can access the medicine they need while the Liberals continue to delay and side with powerful industry interests. In B.C., pharmacare coverage began on March 1 because the B.C. NDP government pushed for it and the provincial health minister Josie Osborne acted quickly. She signed a deal. Families in B.C. are getting that relief, but families in the rest of the country are still waiting. They are waiting because the federal government is refusing to negotiate. \n\nA truly national pharmacare program would guarantee the security Canadians need at a time of economic uncertainty. If the Liberals fail to meet their commitment, they are going to have to explain to Canadians why they are breaking yet another promise.\n\nThe question is simple: Will the government reopen negotiations with provinces like Newfoundland and Labrador and Nova Scotia? Will it commit to expanding pharmacare to every province and territory that wants in, or will it continue down this path where access depends on one's postal code or where one lives? Canadians deserve better than this patchwork.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725137","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, just like last week, and just like the week before, I am here tonight to drag the government in here to hold it to account and to ensure that it protects and enhances our public health care system and follows through with its promises. I will just serve notice that I will be dragging the government back in here again next week if it does not take some action.\n\nNo one in Canada, not ou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fbb19236b0cc48b28bd2fad6620019daf8f7f59ac63dd45c45cf406aeff0d61e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8442ac14173574c4a530cd2b1c0e56b5e3e48b6248da661ee00cc79dc2911154"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14163c2d6673867a7346d2f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725140,"date":"2026-04-29T23:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for coming. I know it is inconvenient, but I will continue to drag her and her government here to debate this issue, because what we heard does not match the reality that Canadians are facing.\n\nIt is great to hear that British Columbians are getting access to pharmacare. The government says pharmacare is moving ahead, but only four out of five Canadians are accessing it. That is not progress; that is exclusion.\n\nThe Liberals say it takes time, but provinces like Newfoundland and Labrador and Nova Scotia are ready now, and the federal government is refusing to negotiate. We just heard the parliamentary secretary say it is too expensive, but pharmacare actually saves money for families and for provinces. The real cost is forcing Canadians to go without the medicine they need.\n\nLet us be clear. Mentioning pharmacare once in a major economic update is not a plan. It is a signal that the government is walking away from its promise, and it is not nation building. Canadians were told that this would be a national program, not a patchwork or something determined by postal code. No one in this country should have to choose between paying rent and filling a prescription.\n\nThe question remains. When will the government stop delaying, start negotiating and deliver pharmacare for all Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725140","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for coming. I know it is inconvenient, but I will continue to drag her and her government here to debate this issue, because what we heard does not match the reality that Canadians are facing.\n\nIt is great to hear that British Columbians are getting access to pharmacare. The government says pharmacare is moving ahead, but only four out of five Canadians are ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bebd547fcd5f8bff4f771a73bd5d418222aecc6a66347ac143812c153abf2070"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e661a7b60d215795abf13032fa40de2ac04e79dc1147d410718f2b5fffeee72c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dcb19bf370a17973828040e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725124,"date":"2026-04-30T17:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we hear the Prime Minister and my colleague compare the sovereign wealth fund to the Norwegian fund. The Norwegian sovereign wealth fund is independent, and it is only for public good. It is not used for political interests or what the Liberals call nation-building projects, which could end up funnelling money to Danielle Smith's dream pipeline through the north coast, billions of dollars for a pipeline that the private sector does not even have support for, never mind support from coastal first nations that are opposed to it. \n\nDoes my colleague agree that the sovereign wealth fund should be independent and only for public good, not for supporting private projects that are not economically viable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-114/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725124","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we hear the Prime Minister and my colleague compare the sovereign wealth fund to the Norwegian fund. The Norwegian sovereign wealth fund is independent, and it is only for public good. It is not used for political interests or what the Liberals call nation-building projects, which could end up funnelling money to Danielle Smith's dream pipeline through the north coast, billions of dol","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a99c4f82084e4f43e0e3006c36e17d13b2e96dde63112abc10ace646ba45e492"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3b834899782c247404771fdecf7746acd7d4e72c60eb3d856adfe4a92c12040"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c8f16f676399952276e29c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791116,"date":"2026-05-05T18:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my Bloc colleague for putting this very important motion forward today.\n\n Maybe my colleague could speak about how this government has completely forgotten forestry workers and the forestry sector, and how unfair it has been, in terms of government support for sectors that are struggling due to the harm and damage that Donald Trump's tariffs are causing Canadian workers in industry sectors, and forestry workers in particular.\n\nWe heard from the premier of British Columbia just yesterday. He spoke about how the forestry workers in B.C. have not been fairly treated compared to other sectors. We believe that those other sectors should be supported. I also know many forestry workers in Quebec are suffering.\n\nI hope my colleague can share her perspective.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791116","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my Bloc colleague for putting this very important motion forward today.\n\n Maybe my colleague could speak about how this government has completely forgotten forestry workers and the forestry sector, and how unfair it has been, in terms of government support for sectors that are struggling due to the harm and damage that Donald Trump's tariffs are causing Canadian ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1421ae4c649452656c5eeaf0ab1d97328a0c0f5df3c05688706186bfdb48fd48"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b98fc610e58b79fbb2ed653c6d8b26cf95af85853cd888fbf591891d72959673"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1eb175b632d49b8b9cf244e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791117,"date":"2026-05-05T18:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour Eva Hilborn, who is in her 100th year and whose life has been defined by service and an unwavering commitment to nurturing a love of learning in children. Born on a Manitoba farm in 1926, Eva began teaching at just 17 years old and went on to shape generations of students across British Columbia. In Port Alberni, she helped build early childhood education programs from the ground up, understanding that a strong start in life begins with books, curiosity and confidence.\n\nKnown to first nations families as \"the book lady\", Eva has spent decades putting books into the hands of children and supporting education for young women. Her legacy will live in every child inspired to read and dream. \n\nI thank Eva for the lasting impact she has made on generations of children and for a century of inspiring leadership and generosity of spirit.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791117","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour Eva Hilborn, who is in her 100th year and whose life has been defined by service and an unwavering commitment to nurturing a love of learning in children. Born on a Manitoba farm in 1926, Eva began teaching at just 17 years old and went on to shape generations of students across British Columbia. In Port Alberni, she helped build early childhood education progra","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","label":"Children's literature"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","label":"Preschool education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","label":"Children's literature","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","label":"Preschool education","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e54d3d6a31920034beee3958fb594d2c68a99ed1467a52a136c974b785b9c22a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c4e2f01da301527bceba76908b2edf47a1ae7b11e5f2becf26ca71937484416"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bce716fab248e4ecd84ccb52","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791118,"date":"2026-05-05T23:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to be here tonight. I would first like to begin by extending my congratulations to Louise Arbour on her appointment today to serve as Canada's next governor general. She is a human rights champion, and she has had a remarkable career. She will, no doubt, continue to serve our country well in this new role.\n\nWith that, I would like to turn the topic of debate this evening to Alberta's Bill 11 and the Canada Health Act.\n\nIn the last election, the Prime Minister promised Canadians that a Liberal government would protect our values and way of life. The Liberal platform highlighted our public health care system as an example of Canadians' belief in the common good and a key difference between Canada and the U.S. The Liberal platform pledged to defend the Canada Health Act and told Canadians, \"It's time to return to the foundational values upon which our national health care was developed: free of charge, fair, universal, and accessible.\"\n\nToday, those values are under threat, but instead of fighting for what matters to Canadians, the federal government is looking the other way. This morning, an independent legal opinion was published that confirmed what many have been saying for months. Alberta's Bill 11 violates both the letter and the spirit of the Canada Health Act. The legal opinion, commissioned by the Canadian Health Coalition, explains that allowing people to pay privately for faster access to medically necessary care creates unequal access based on one's ability to pay. \n\nIn plain terms, Bill 11 would create an American-style, two-tier health care system. It is time for the minister to make clear that the government will keep its promise to Canadians and defend the Canada Health Act. The minister has called herself \"the guardian of the Canada Health Act\", but since December, she has failed to act on this threat to our public health care system.\n\nToday, the Canada Health Coalition held a press conference with health and legal experts, calling for the minister to act, to take a clear position against Bill 11 and to speak about the threats the bill poses for all Canadians.\n\nJason MacLean, chair of the Canadian Health Coalition, spoke about how the crisis in our health care system, fuelled by Conservative premiers, is seen as a business opportunity by major insurance companies. That should concern every Canadian who believes that health care is a right. \n\nDr. Melanie Bechard, the chair of Canadian Doctors for Medicare and a pediatric emergency physician at the Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario, also spoke today in Ottawa. She spoke about how allowing dual practice will impact wait times, stating, \"If we are...prioritizing...patients who can pay privately, that means that the majority of patients who rely on the public system will have to wait longer.\"\n\nLet us be clear. Canadians deserve quicker access to the health care they need, but a two-tier health care system is not a solution to long wait times.\n\nChris Gallaway, the executive director of Friends of Medicare in Alberta, also spoke in Ottawa today and called on the minister to take action to stop Bill 11. He said bluntly, \"no more delays. No more stalling. No more talking about looking at regulations and implementation. We need you to do your job and show leadership\".\n\nIf the federal government fails to enforce the Canada Health Act now, it sends a clear message far beyond Alberta. It tells provinces that the rules can be bent. It tells private interests that our public system is open for profits. Canadians did not build Medicare so that it could be quietly replaced with a system where wealth determines who gets treated first. If the federal government does not act now, it risks opening the door to further privatization across the country.\n\nI will ask this again: Will the minister stop stalling, enforce the Canada Health Act and stand up for a health care system that serves everyone equally?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791118","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to be here tonight. I would first like to begin by extending my congratulations to Louise Arbour on her appointment today to serve as Canada's next governor general. She is a human rights champion, and she has had a remarkable career. She will, no doubt, continue to serve our country well in this new role.\n\nWith that, I would like to turn the topic of debate this eveni","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5b6fea5b95b32171e1688b60fd33853441268fd1139555c184e7d7c5496b25b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ebdb3d1d3df8cdd00677e82d53b5c4bcdae000a3820cc2a3ff71b73124ebca8c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-11c776a21059b52c7015664f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791119,"date":"2026-05-06T00:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, here we are. We are the last people here again. It has been four weeks in a row that I have dragged the government in here because it has not done its job to fulfill its promises when it comes to protecting our public health care system or to enhancing our system. In fact, it has failed to even protect it from the threats it is facing. This is no slight to the parliamentary secretary of industry, but it is shameful that the Minister of Health or her parliamentary secretary could not show up for this very important debate tonight. It is very disappointing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791119","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, here we are. We are the last people here again. It has been four weeks in a row that I have dragged the government in here because it has not done its job to fulfill its promises when it comes to protecting our public health care system or to enhancing our system. In fact, it has failed to even protect it from the threats it is facing. This is no slight to the parliamentary secretary ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4015c25c0af157b997b86a5fd1bc071f50551335d2af881573cba9b378759d1c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecbf1ea90f1099debf6daca4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791120,"date":"2026-05-06T00:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate that.\n\nChris Gallaway was here today. He is from Friends of Medicare from Alberta. He highlighted that the minister, who has claimed over and over again in questions from me and from my colleague, the member for Edmonton Strathcona, that she is the guardian of the Health Care Act, has not told Canadians what she thinks about the act, what her plan is, and what regulations would suit her needs and what ones would not. She has not communicated publicly on this issue, which would really help us know what her thinking is, how we can move forward on regulations and what is happening. She has not shared that as our federal health minister.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-117/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791120","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate that.\n\nChris Gallaway was here today. He is from Friends of Medicare from Alberta. He highlighted that the minister, who has claimed over and over again in questions from me and from my colleague, the member for Edmonton Strathcona, that she is the guardian of the Health Care Act, has not told Canadians what she thinks about the act, what her plan is, and what regulations","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce7a25bef68af507d9d93295","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791112,"date":"2026-05-06T20:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table this petition today signed by many independent fish harvesters on Vancouver Island and coastal British Columbia who are concerned about the concentration of foreign ownership of fishing quota. Only in British Columbia is this allowed. \n\nThe petitioners highlight that DFO's mandate includes promoting the stability and economic viability of fishing operations; that Canadian owner-operator fish harvesters are increasingly displaced by foreign acquisition of Canada's commercial fishing licences and quotas; that Canada does not currently have any limitation on foreign ownership of commercial fishing licences and quotas in the Pacific region; that Canada does not record or track citizenship within transactions of fishing licences and quotas; and that the absence of restrictions on foreign ownership on commercial fishing licences and quotas damages the economic viability of Canadian-owned fishing operations, harvesters and their families, and coastal communities. \n\nThe foreign ownership of commercial fishing access compromises domestic food security and is directly linked to economic losses of domestic fish processing and processing jobs here in Canada. They are calling on the Government of Canada to immediately ban any further transfer of Canadian commercial fishing licences and quotas to foreign ownership or foreign beneficial interest.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791112","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table this petition today signed by many independent fish harvesters on Vancouver Island and coastal British Columbia who are concerned about the concentration of foreign ownership of fishing quota. Only in British Columbia is this allowed. \n\nThe petitioners highlight that DFO's mandate includes promoting the stability and economic viability of fishing operations; t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4cbc39887e23a8768e16dec5ff80176747034329bbc37d5de404c0652a78a52b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3afbc776fc38f2119103ca6dae5a50f22d41a4694388827fccc16540c934570e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8a5b537bd8066546ae1a2f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791113,"date":"2026-05-06T21:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the question from my Liberal colleague in terms of the $6-billion plan to recruit and train 100,000 new Red Seal workers. \n\nHowever, the Liberal government cut international student study permits by more than 40% and restricted postgraduate work permits without consulting higher-learning institutions that rely on those students. The consequences have been hard-hitting on Vancouver Island. Nearly 30 programs have been cut between North Island College and Vancouver Island University, including a dental assistant program that has trained workers for 50 years.\n\nThe Prime Minister says that Canada must deliver major nation-building projects. How will the government build the workforce Canada needs while its policies shut down the very important programs that are needed to train those workers, especially in rural Canada, in places like Port Alberni?\n\nMaybe my colleague can speak about how that impact is hurting her riding and people who want to study and participate in the workforce in her community.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791113","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the question from my Liberal colleague in terms of the $6-billion plan to recruit and train 100,000 new Red Seal workers. \n\nHowever, the Liberal government cut international student study permits by more than 40% and restricted postgraduate work permits without consulting higher-learning institutions that rely on those students. The consequences have been hard-hitting on ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9774beb9bc0ec4c08191e8f0e0383f37c7901049297df8b4032c7d6de4bf1b08"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["169c53a71da0155475204dc4b706c7df29ab8d09a0665d3da5f2cf9ba7071cb7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a366527da92dd2e0a10f7dd0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791114,"date":"2026-05-06T22:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have known my colleague for a long time. I have a lot of respect for him. \n\nThe spring economic update states that the government is \"assessing opportunities to unlock the...value of airports in support of investments in Canada's long-term growth, including through alternative models of ownership.\" The Liberal government is looking at privatizing airports. This is not something that even Conservatives would do. \n\nRod Sims, the former chair of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, highlighted that \"the travelling public loses big time, over time\" when they tried this experiment.\n\nWill my colleague stand in the House and tell the Canadian public that they will not privatize Canada's airports?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791114","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have known my colleague for a long time. I have a lot of respect for him. \n\nThe spring economic update states that the government is \"assessing opportunities to unlock the...value of airports in support of investments in Canada's long-term growth, including through alternative models of ownership.\" The Liberal government is looking at privatizing airports. This is not something that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2983c9b44ad5b7964d2a95af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791115,"date":"2026-05-06T22:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, first I want to congratulate my colleague on her election. She has been a strong proponent of a universal public pharmacare plan. She has long advocated and argued that a national single-payer pharmacare program would actually save money, but now she represents a riding in a province that does not have a pharmacare deal.\n\nCan New Democrats, the people of Ontario and the people of her riding count on her to be a champion, to force her government to get to the table with Ontario and deliver on the promise of a national pharmacare plan so those people in Ontario can actually get access to it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791115","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, first I want to congratulate my colleague on her election. She has been a strong proponent of a universal public pharmacare plan. She has long advocated and argued that a national single-payer pharmacare program would actually save money, but now she represents a riding in a province that does not have a pharmacare deal.\n\nCan New Democrats, the people of Ontario and the people of her ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1cffbcaa11f2e339c9afab4e315740a4d5044d24e974c2505679c7f34bfe394d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c52825fa5ce7318d60e3d81ec2cc5900184633e491ac70503b0acde5f3863cf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-defb29e48df95ecca7d4add7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791111,"date":"2026-05-07T15:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition drafted by Graham Riches from Parksville in my riding. He calls on the government to fulfill international commitments to treat food as a human right. He draws the attention of the House of Commons to the fact that the right to adequate food is a fundamental human right recognized in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, ratified by Canada in 1976. Under the ICESCR, Canada has a legal obligation to ensure physical economic access to sufficient, safe, nutritious and culturally appropriate food for all.\n\n The petitioners highlight that the United Nations has affirmed that food insecurity is primarily the result of inadequate income and social protection, not food shortages, yet over 10 million people in Canada experience some form of household food insecurity, and the reliance on food banks continues to rise. Canada has neither entrenched the right to food in domestic law nor established clear legal duties for monitoring or remedies to fulfill this obligation. \n\nThe petitioners call on the Government of Canada to recognize the right to adequate food as a justifiable human right in Canadian law consistent with the ICESCR; invite the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food to conduct an official visit to Canada and report to Parliament; develop, in consultation with indigenous peoples, provinces, territories, civil society and people with lived experience, a federal right to food framework act that establishes government duties, measurable targets, monitoring remedies; and lastly, align federal poverty reduction, income security, food and health policies with Canada's international human rights obligations, including the ICESCR and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791111","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition drafted by Graham Riches from Parksville in my riding. He calls on the government to fulfill international commitments to treat food as a human right. He draws the attention of the House of Commons to the fact that the right to adequate food is a fundamental human right recognized in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and in the International","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["92c4ee7f6df685b7b926770f04da9afd73234f57d8734909ed0b2fe481adcbc9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["18f7bff772ecac90d07f5baec2e60d94431750aa4442f113889f606fdff9e31b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49a961bd95d2069fa42cf759","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791109,"date":"2026-05-08T17:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, 2025 was the second-worst wildfire season in Canadian history, and Canadians are bracing for another devastating summer. Despite the growing climate crisis, Canada is missing its climate targets and running out of time. While more than 50 countries gathered in Colombia to discuss the transition away from fossil fuels, the Liberals did not even send a minister. Instead they came home with a plan to fast-track more fossil fuel extraction.\n\nAt a time when communities are burning and families are being displaced, why is the Liberal government doubling down on fossil fuel extraction?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791109","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, 2025 was the second-worst wildfire season in Canadian history, and Canadians are bracing for another devastating summer. Despite the growing climate crisis, Canada is missing its climate targets and running out of time. While more than 50 countries gathered in Colombia to discuss the transition away from fossil fuels, the Liberals did not even send a minister. Instead they came home w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2ca794885193f6201c80abde7a7058af86aeedd27971ac7f501177dac4316d93"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dcd5df4835119e640575339440bffa49862dfef1c3a107c667bb144ffda479f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32b6e926308c75a1377b04b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791110,"date":"2026-05-08T17:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition on behalf of constituents in my riding who are concerned about the lack of ability to get aid into Gaza.\n\nPetitioners highlight that under common article 1 of the Geneva Conventions, Canada is actually required to respect international humanitarian law. Under article 59 of the fourth Geneva Convention, Israel, as an occupying power, must allow and facilitate humanitarian aid by impartial organizations.\n\nThey highlight that, under Canada's own international assistance accountability act, Canada is required, with regard to foreign aid, to uphold human rights and international legal standards. Israel's policies and actions violate all those obligations.\n\nPetitioners are calling for the restoration of full access for UN agencies and established humanitarian NGOs, including UNRWA and the World Food Programme, and they insist on safe and immediate entry for Canadian health care workers and other international humanitarian personnel to Palestine. Last, they are asking for it be ensured that all Canadian aid to Gaza is delivered through internationally recognized humanitarian channels.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791110","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition on behalf of constituents in my riding who are concerned about the lack of ability to get aid into Gaza.\n\nPetitioners highlight that under common article 1 of the Geneva Conventions, Canada is actually required to respect international humanitarian law. Under article 59 of the fourth Geneva Convention, Israel, as an occupying power, must allow and f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["afc9f4606817fa76d98442c825990a0490dd4d4d4ce05a5ddf0280e86f0b0c59"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8cef598ab27b95f5c1c39d0b89c45f2096dc8491fbf5c7ddd28017d51b0bca2e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c96d0fca703723795e1b88b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034964,"date":"2026-05-26T20:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP agrees to apply the vote, voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034964","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP agrees to apply the vote, voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["991a0fd067afd775160f34d33f25284659901663b76991ebf4b5a334c8f1e3f1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-563ae68a554cb709ced788f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034959,"date":"2026-05-27T21:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats also agree to apply the vote, and we enthusiastically support the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034959","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, New Democrats also agree to apply the vote, and we enthusiastically support the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56da97c33d7548258184ebef3a24c55dff20918dad592ee9484217ebf09830d3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff86f44c833cb57e5323b3f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034960,"date":"2026-05-27T21:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour and privilege to table this petition on behalf of people living in Port Alberni, in my riding. They highlight and want to draw the House of Commons' attention to these facts: that wealth inequality in Canada is rising, with more Canadians struggling to afford the basics of life while corporate profits continue to break records; that austerity measures often exacerbate inequality; that the federal government is implementing austerity measures, including a massive cut of $25 billion to publicly funded jobs and programs that Canadians rely on; that the federal government has cut and plans on further cutting taxes on the wealthy; and that climate change is worsening, causing Canadians a projected $25 billion in losses each year. \n\nThe petitioners highlight that a wealth tax could, as per the Centre for Policy Alternatives, generate more than $32 billion in its first year alone. They are calling on the government to reverse the sweeping cuts to Canadian jobs and services and to put forward a bill to fund good-paying jobs, public services and the transition to a sustainable economy by making corporations and the wealthiest Canadians pay their fair share.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034960","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour and privilege to table this petition on behalf of people living in Port Alberni, in my riding. They highlight and want to draw the House of Commons' attention to these facts: that wealth inequality in Canada is rising, with more Canadians struggling to afford the basics of life while corporate profits continue to break records; that austerity measures often exacerbate ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["61dbe5a8e60024f7f0f3e1ec826c3fdbc76751056fd218df5e778c6cb60a7bb6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c2daa80cf64613dbddd7f03da0e6d891f5a4b1bdd199bdeaac7f979911e1246a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6205aaf77ec3517f4ba7b216","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034961,"date":"2026-05-27T21:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this resignation should be of serious concern to all Canadians. It is a huge wake-up call, hopefully for everybody. What our colleague is doing today takes incredible courage. It takes courage to stand up for climate science and environmental protection for future generations when powerful interests inside government are pushing in the opposite direction.\n\n As New Democrats, we have had the opportunity to work across the aisle with our colleague when he was a former minister on a number of important issues, including climate accountability, biodiversity protection and building a fair transition for workers and communities. We may not have always agreed, but he understood that the climate crisis demands action, not delay. The people of Laurier—Sainte-Marie were represented by someone who consistently fought to put the climate crisis and environmental protection on the national agenda. Now the government is weakening emissions caps, backing away from environmental protection and putting fossil fuel expansion ahead of climate leadership while Canadians face devastating fires, floods and extreme weather.\n\nWe as New Democrats want to thank the member for his courage and his public service. We want to wish him well and encourage him to keep fighting for climate justice and for the future of our planet. We look forward to continuing to work with him to tackle the climate crisis.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034961","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this resignation should be of serious concern to all Canadians. It is a huge wake-up call, hopefully for everybody. What our colleague is doing today takes incredible courage. It takes courage to stand up for climate science and environmental protection for future generations when powerful interests inside government are pushing in the opposite direction.\n\n As New Democrats, we have h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4f9f698f5f5b3b953d1c1a1397884389685da01224df89fe76ead7ed60b289bf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82e179f1ee89f3717f113aea70bac5b21dab7f26eac8fb458a8c1c6faaa82326"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72f03fab531674cbf5ae6586","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034962,"date":"2026-05-27T23:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, tonight's debate is about fisheries policy on the west coast, but it is also about something bigger. It is about whether coastal communities on Vancouver Island and across British Columbia are treated with the same fairness and respect as other parts of the country.\n\nOn the west coast, commercial fish harvesters, the people actually doing the fishing, are being pushed out. Corporate concentration and growing foreign ownership of licences and quota are driving up costs and draining wealth out of coastal communities. We actually do not even know who owns much of the quota because there is still no public registry. Meanwhile, on the east coast, an owner-operator model protects independent fish harvesters and keeps the value in local communities.\n\nEight years ago, the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans made unanimous recommendations to bring those same protections to the west coast, yet eight years later, there still has not been any meaningful action. That delay has real consequences. Every year, more access, control and wealth leave the hands of independent fish harvesters and coastal communities. It is a huge economic leakage.\n\nThis is not a new problem. The solutions have already been identified, but what has been missing is the Liberal government's willingness to act.\n\nFor many Vancouver Islanders, this is part of a larger problem. We often hear about western alienation. It is real and few large populations in Canada understand that feeling better than Vancouver Islanders, not because we want to leave Canada. Vancouver Islanders believe that Canada is stronger together, but people begin to feel alienated when they are ignored, under-represented and treated unfairly for decades.\n\nA perfect example is our ferry system, which is a huge cost barrier to getting our seafood products to market. As coastal peoples, we understand that ferries are not a luxury. They are essential highways that connect communities to the rest of Canada, which is why we deserve strong federal ferry support. According to the Library of Parliament, last year, BC Ferries received approximately $1.63 in federal support per passenger, while federally supported east coast ferry systems received approximately $291 per passenger, roughly 178 times more support than BC Ferries received. Marine Atlantic received 300 times more support.\n\nThis is not about taking away support from Atlantic Canadians. Their ferry systems are essential national infrastructure. The issue is that Vancouver Islanders are asking why essential marine highways on the west coast are not treated with the same level of federal importance. The federal government keeps pointing to constitutional agreements signed more than 80 years ago and funding formulas created nearly 50 years ago, when Vancouver Island had about 450,000 residents.\n\nThe government now points to temporary pandemic relief and repayable Infrastructure Bank loans as proof that the system is fair, but emergency COVID funding was temporary. Atlantic ferry systems also receive pandemic support. Loans still have to be repaid by British Columbians through fares and borrowing costs. That is not the same as ongoing federal operational support.\n\nToday, Vancouver Island is approaching one million people and BC Ferries carries more than 22 million passengers annually. These are essential marine highways connecting workers, seniors, families, students, truckers and businesses, including those in the blue economy and our supply chains.\n\nPremier Eby made the point clearly. The federal government should not reward provinces that threaten separation while ignoring regions that continue working constructively within the federation. Unlike some provinces, Vancouver Islanders are not threatening to separate from Canada because they are frustrated by this unfairness, but people are asking why consecutive Liberal and Conservative governments have continued treating us like an afterthought.\n\nIt does not stop there. Nearly one million people live on Vancouver Island, yet not a single senator clearly rooted on Vancouver Island has been appointed in more than 55 years. Meanwhile, New Brunswick, with a comparable population, has 10 Senate seats. Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland and Labrador together have fewer people than Vancouver Island, yet they also hold 10 seats. That means no Vancouver Island senator on the Senate fisheries committee.\n\nThis is what being ignored looks like. Vancouver Islanders are not asking for special treatment. We are asking for fairness: fair ferry funding, fair representation and fair fisheries policies that protect coastal communities. As Vancouver Islanders, we love this country. We believe in Canada, but we know this country is—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034962","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, tonight's debate is about fisheries policy on the west coast, but it is also about something bigger. It is about whether coastal communities on Vancouver Island and across British Columbia are treated with the same fairness and respect as other parts of the country.\n\nOn the west coast, commercial fish harvesters, the people actually doing the fishing, are being pushed out. Corporate","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cd1f6da032ca39a28446d0799a948ec7888c32ce214ef464d3d5f7f5d039ab91"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1e54105c1aa5cbea699da4daf6802ec4bd1f3fea37703c8543fe74cb2c71d2bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6fe45761d7f0a96999577c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034963,"date":"2026-05-28T00:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the speech I just gave was about a growing feeling on Vancouver Island and across the west coast that our communities are too often treated like an afterthought. Talking about a survey that was done four years ago, or a new survey that the Liberals are going to do eight years after the fisheries and oceans report, just says it all. The frustration could not be more clear.\n\nAnother example is what happened last year on the Fraser River. Nearly 10 million sockeye returned, one of the strongest runs in decades, yet independent fish harvesters, including indigenous commercial harvesters, were effectively shut out while families struggled to keep their boats and businesses afloat.\n\nNobody is arguing against conservation. Weak stocks need to be protected, and treaty obligations with the United States through the Pacific Salmon Commission must be respected, but when Canada's own commercial fleet is denied fair access during years of proven abundance, it undermines confidence in the system.\n\nI want to know today from the parliamentary secretary what concrete changes the government will make before the 2026 Fraser sockeye season to ensure that this never happens again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034963","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the speech I just gave was about a growing feeling on Vancouver Island and across the west coast that our communities are too often treated like an afterthought. Talking about a survey that was done four years ago, or a new survey that the Liberals are going to do eight years after the fisheries and oceans report, just says it all. The frustration could not be more clear.\n\nAnother e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","label":"Surveys","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7abc6e5750ac6485120b4539c09c6517d08a569f3ef28ea25c311e61f64cffc5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60ab7ea66176697a0ff14b17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083774,"date":"2026-06-01T20:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table this petition today, which is signed by residents of Parksville, British Columbia, and created by Jasmine Tomczyk of Parksville.\n\nThe petitioners highlight that healthy soil, clean water and biodiversity are essential to food security, climate resilience, national sovereignty and the long-term sustainability of Canadian agriculture; that regenerative and agro-ecological farming practices can rebuild soil health, increase biodiversity, recharge aquifers, reduce erosion, capture carbon and prevent pollution from entering rivers, lakes and oceans; that regenerative food systems strengthen farmer livelihoods, support community well-being, enhance climate resilience and improve individual and public health; and that many farmers want to adopt regenerative practices but face financial, technical and transitional barriers without adequate public support. \n\nTherefore, the petitioners are calling on the Government of Canada to develop and fund a national regenerative agriculture strategy that prioritizes soil health, biodiversity, water protection and climate resilience; that provides long-term funding, incentives and technical assistance to support farmers transitioning to regenerative and agro-ecological practices; that integrates soil health, water protection and biodiversity outcomes into federal agricultural programs and climate policy; that expands farmer-led research, extension services and knowledge sharing on the regenerative practices suited to diverse regions of Canada; that strengthens policies to reduce soil erosion, pesticide use, agricultural runoff, nutrient pollution and plastic waste affecting freshwater and marine ecosystems; and that supports resilient and democratic local and regional food systems that improve food security, rural economies and community well-being.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083774","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table this petition today, which is signed by residents of Parksville, British Columbia, and created by Jasmine Tomczyk of Parksville.\n\nThe petitioners highlight that healthy soil, clean water and biodiversity are essential to food security, climate resilience, national sovereignty and the long-term sustainability of Canadian agriculture; that regenerative and agro-","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","label":"Soil conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","label":"Soil conservation","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4cd012705f6799ea98442007b120224f0a7873a00cff6f8ac1b6ae9f41afccd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["785a09de0c0963af4d5430ff4f85fe382c926ce831631c39b98b59b41f1c95a9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-628e6a3eb7ed0cef8afd1a80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083767,"date":"2026-06-02T15:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to table a petition signed by many people across Vancouver Island and across Canada.\n\nThe petitioners highlight that approximately 165,000 new cases of brain injury are happening annually in Canada and that health and community service providers require more education regarding the intersection of brain injury, mental health and addiction.\n\n The petitioners also highlight that survivors and families are often left to navigate fragmented systems, with little to no support, leading to further deterioration in health, housing and economic stability. They have been calling for this to be in the budget, and they are hoping it will in the budget this fall.\n\n The petitioners also support Bill C‐206, my bill to develop a national strategy to support and improve brain injury awareness, prevention and treatment, as well as the rehabilitation and recovery of persons living with brain injury.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083767","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to table a petition signed by many people across Vancouver Island and across Canada.\n\nThe petitioners highlight that approximately 165,000 new cases of brain injury are happening annually in Canada and that health and community service providers require more education regarding the intersection of brain injury, mental health and addiction.\n\n The petitioners also highligh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a849946fe98084bf9b994f619772fa3d6528ff2e5308578b6fc429a344c9d4d7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-267261bb2a8160fabe7f7925","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083768,"date":"2026-06-02T18:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member talked about AI, which I want to talk about. We know that Canadians right now are facing rising costs and economic uncertainty. Financial fraud is even becoming a greater threat, and it is not being talked enough about today. Organized crime is using AI-generated scams for deepfakes, spoof calls and fake investment schemes to target people already under financial pressure.\n\nA record amount of fraud is impacting seniors in my riding who are losing their life savings. Families are being defrauded, and victims are often left to recover on their own. Protecting Canadians requires urgent government intervention: blocking scam calls, holding financial institutions and digital platforms accountable, ensuring that victims have access to support and recovery services, and growing the scale and urgency of this problem at a time when every dollar counts. When will the Liberals finally combat fraud using the measures they have, as a key tool in protecting Canadians' financial security and economic well-being?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083768","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member talked about AI, which I want to talk about. We know that Canadians right now are facing rising costs and economic uncertainty. Financial fraud is even becoming a greater threat, and it is not being talked enough about today. Organized crime is using AI-generated scams for deepfakes, spoof calls and fake investment schemes to target people already under financial pressure.\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b6cd61f5d18853acc7faeb6a55115312dd15e33bc37a79433bc71d17850a706e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["928b9f970c403a6e940f455d28903eb39e498b2c90c786e5c61ab2897d084d23"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90520805492ff15c809f48ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083769,"date":"2026-06-02T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, ferries are essential highways for coastal communities. Of course we support strong federal funding for ferry services in Atlantic Canada. However, BC Ferries receives only $1.63 per passenger in federal operational support, compared to about $291 per passenger in Atlantic Canada. Temporary relief measures and repayable loans for B.C. cannot replace fair, long-term federal operational support.\n\n When will the Liberal government finally modernize these outdated agreements and provide fair support for British Columbia and BC Ferries?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083769","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, ferries are essential highways for coastal communities. Of course we support strong federal funding for ferry services in Atlantic Canada. However, BC Ferries receives only $1.63 per passenger in federal operational support, compared to about $291 per passenger in Atlantic Canada. Temporary relief measures and repayable loans for B.C. cannot replace fair, long-term federal operational","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2be71b5301cf98734f58561834c4e87fc39235a385f5845eb949c5199212b45e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bb08a8777e233e01daf9e3be652d4dc489aabec81725e5beff2c8490a528a52c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-672f54de953ee49f1aadc9ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083770,"date":"2026-06-02T21:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am glad my colleague talked about food banks, because Food Banks Canada is here on the Hill today.\n\nFood Banks Canada made it clear, and actually warned us, that our employment insurance system no longer reflects the reality of work in Canada. This is impacting people. More Canadians are working multiple part-time jobs, contract positions and gig work. Yet, they are paying into a system that often denies them support when they need it most. It highlighted that while food bank use continues to reach record levels and families struggle with the rising cost of living, millions of workers are being left behind by an outdated EI system designed for a workplace that no longer exists.\n\n Do the Conservatives and my colleague agree with Food Banks Canada in their call for comprehensive EI reform so that gig workers, part-time workers and precarious workers can actually access the benefits that they pay for?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083770","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am glad my colleague talked about food banks, because Food Banks Canada is here on the Hill today.\n\nFood Banks Canada made it clear, and actually warned us, that our employment insurance system no longer reflects the reality of work in Canada. This is impacting people. More Canadians are working multiple part-time jobs, contract positions and gig work. Yet, they are paying into a sy","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc22f736a393fc5230c058ec257b253e30f395f9e9e1ce0bbecafd5ea3658656"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fbc6f6163100c5b4a59930ec0e485da1b89f3068f99b7af3bf55a028ce4d3275"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ead170fd235fceb6d1ed417","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083771,"date":"2026-06-02T21:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a lot of respect for my colleague the member for Calgary Centre, despite our differences. I also have respect for my colleague the member for Calgary Confederation, who on May 27, 2025, in the House said, \"We will ensure the future sustainability of programs that have already saved families thousands of dollars a year. This includes child care and pharmacare.\"\n\nI am going to talk about pharmacare, because right now in Alberta there is not a pharmacare plan, something we fought really hard for as New Democrats. Does my colleague think that people in Alberta's not having diabetes medicine or birth control is the responsibility, or blame, of his premier, Danielle Smith, or is it the Prime Minister's fault?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083771","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a lot of respect for my colleague the member for Calgary Centre, despite our differences. I also have respect for my colleague the member for Calgary Confederation, who on May 27, 2025, in the House said, \"We will ensure the future sustainability of programs that have already saved families thousands of dollars a year. This includes child care and pharmacare.\"\n\nI am going to ta","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ba16d46e3257845322d2aab620c9dee2a80d2a5213a4951c0c79cf54fda2cf4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b56bc944a6493467afed16f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083772,"date":"2026-06-02T23:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Canadian dental care plan is one of the most significant expansions of public health care in a generation. For too long, millions of Canadians went without dental care because they could not afford it. They delayed treatment, lived with pain and watched manageable dental problems become serious health issues because the cost was out of reach.\n\nThe New Democrats fought to make this program a reality because access to health care should never depend on the size of a person's paycheque, pension cheque or bank account. Today, millions of Canadians have access to dental care because of the Canadian dental care plan. This is a success worth protecting. It is why I rise tonight to raise a serious and growing concern.\n\nMy office has been contacted by Canadians who have applied in good faith, were approved, received care and renewed their coverage as instructed. Many believed everything was in order, only to receive letters saying their eligibility was now under review or they may no longer qualify. Many affected are retirees, former union members, veterans and pensioners who made decisions about dental coverage through their unions or employers years ago, sometimes decades, based on the rules that existed at the time. Some were told that if they opted out of their dental coverage, they could never rejoin.\n\nWhen the Canadian dental care plan became available, they applied honestly because they believed they did not have access to dental coverage. The government reviewed their applications and approved them. Now they are being told that information on a T4 or T4A tax slip suggests they may have had access after all.\n\n Susan from Errington believed she qualified because she had opted out of her pension dental plan before December 11, 2023, and could not re-enroll. She has documentation supporting her position but no clear timeline for a decision.\n\nIan from Parksville left his former employer decades ago. He declined dental coverage because the premiums were nearly equal to the pension benefits he receives. He was told he could never rejoin. Now he fears being asked to repay benefits he received in good faith.\n\nAllan from Coombs, a retired veteran, opted out of dental coverage in the 1990s because he could not afford the premiums. He was told he could not rejoin. Now he is caught in an eligibility review because rules appear to be changing decades later.\n\nJoyce from Lasqueti Island had not seen a dentist in eight years because she could not afford private coverage. The plan finally gave her access to care. Now she worries that coverage may be taken away.\n\nThese constituents are not alone. We know people across Canada do not know whether they will lose their coverage, whether they can renew, whether documents have been received or whether they will be asked to repay benefits already approved by the Liberal government. Many cannot even speak directly to the officials reviewing their cases. They are directed from one department to another with no clear timeline for a decision. Even members of Parliament have limited ability to obtain updates. This is not simply a question of paperwork. It is a question of access to health care.\n\nWill the government maintain coverage and protect renewal eligibility while reviews are under way? Will it establish clear service guidelines and standards, provide applicants and MPs with a dedicated point of contact, and ensure that Canadians who acted honestly and in good faith are not denied dental care because of gaps between government systems and the reality of their circumstances?\n\nThe Canadian dental care plan is improving lives. We must not allow bureaucracy, confusion and administrative barriers to undermine that promise.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083772","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Canadian dental care plan is one of the most significant expansions of public health care in a generation. For too long, millions of Canadians went without dental care because they could not afford it. They delayed treatment, lived with pain and watched manageable dental problems become serious health issues because the cost was out of reach.\n\nThe New Democrats fought to make this","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","label":"Dental insurance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","label":"Dental insurance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d16953a321dd065d43a6774c60bc4e46b68de82f93a0c3f410b3d7982d8bffa6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["852017b1b75f7f729d604d03042da2bfcd0a2d993708692ff73a23d9f12542e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a00ef7787ec781c721968771","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083773,"date":"2026-06-02T23:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I truly hope the Liberals will address these issues. \n\nI have another emerging issue that I want to raise. \n\nMy office has been inundated with calls from seniors, retirees, veterans and pensioners who are confused, anxious and afraid of losing the Canadian dental care plan coverage because of yesterday's June 1 renewal deadline. Many applied honestly, were approved and received care but are now being told their eligibility is under review. Others missed the deadline because of unclear communication, delayed notices or confusion and now must reapply, risking a gap in coverage. \n\nThe government needs to understand the anxiety that this has caused. Requiring renewal creates unnecessary barriers, especially for seniors and vulnerable people navigating government systems.\n\n The renewal deadline must be extended. No Canadian should lose dental coverage because of administrative confusion. The government must provide clarity and ensure no one is left without the care they depend on.\n\nWill the government fix this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083773","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I truly hope the Liberals will address these issues. \n\nI have another emerging issue that I want to raise. \n\nMy office has been inundated with calls from seniors, retirees, veterans and pensioners who are confused, anxious and afraid of losing the Canadian dental care plan coverage because of yesterday's June 1 renewal deadline. Many applied honestly, were approved and received care b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","label":"Dental insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","label":"Dental insurance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d4f3a89ff9a742a0c90095fa14d08cebedfb7cc7c904a7a97a3dc9b21aa89a56"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11ba73860197412c7774acd12369c5d100ce73a7d2c42d05ca861748220935c7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e667de0fb2aabac7e2d28df","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1148659,"date":"2026-06-03T15:49:41+00:00","title":"An Act to enact the Mental Health, Addictions and Substance Use Services Act and to make consequential amendments to the Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"An Act to enact the Mental Health, Addictions and Substance Use Services Act and to make consequential amendments to the Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-280","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-280","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1148659","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"An Act to enact the Mental Health, Addictions and Substance Use Services Act and to make consequential amendments to the Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c4aa2b538e4c81d428bdbcb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083765,"date":"2026-06-03T20:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-280, An Act to enact the Mental Health, Addictions and Substance Use Services Act and to make consequential amendments to the Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act.\n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to table this bill, which aims to create parity between physical and mental health in our public health care system. The mental health parity act proposes a framework for the federal government to partner with provinces and territories to provide public coverage for community-based mental health, addictions and substance use services. The goal of this bill is to make mental health services accessible to all Canadians through our public health care system. This bill would incorporate the principles of the Canada Health Act: public administration, comprehensiveness, universality, portability and accessibility. It would also incorporate provisions to promote public accountability and to reduce regional disparities in coverage.\n\nI want to thank the Canadian Alliance on Mental Illness and Mental Health, the Canadian Mental Health Association and all those who spent years advocating for mental health parity. I also want to thank my colleague, who has been a champion for mental health, the member of Parliament for Edmonton Strathcona, for seconding this bill. I hope all members will support this bill as a step towards building a stronger, healthier Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083765","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-280, An Act to enact the Mental Health, Addictions and Substance Use Services Act and to make consequential amendments to the Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act.\n\n He said: Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to table this bill, which aims to create parity between physical and mental health in our public health care system. The mental health parit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ea846cb1cdeaa3de3b2fd5e53b0c978d5ee907b16d1cc9e37e65ba37203920c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["87724c93e0669045d7b2a0b7eaff2951f95cc0b0a30a9a1642319195e7d17aea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d4d281da4d8cff569b1f1cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083766,"date":"2026-06-03T20:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table this petition, which was signed by residents of my riding just this last weekend. They highlight that ferries are essential marine highways that connect coastal communities, workers, families, businesses and supply chains to the rest of Canada. Vancouver Island is approaching one million residents and BC Ferries carries more than 22 million passengers annually.\n\nAccording to an analysis by the Library of Parliament, BC Ferries received approximately $1.63 in federal operational support per passenger in 2024-25, compared to $291 for federally supported east coast ferry systems. Canadians in Atlantic Canada and British Columbia deserve strong federal ferry support because these services are part of essential national transportation infrastructure.\n\nThe petitioners also highlight that current federal ferry funding agreements rely on outdated constitutional arrangements and formulas created decades ago when Vancouver Island had roughly half its current population. Vancouver Island and coastal communities should not have to become separate provinces in order to receive fair ferry funding from the federal government. It is no longer sustainable to operate one of the world's largest ferry systems without stable, long-term federal operational support.\n\nThe petitioners cite that they want the government to modernize federal ferry funding policies and provide fair, stable, long-term federal operational support for BC Ferries as essential national transportation infrastructure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083766","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table this petition, which was signed by residents of my riding just this last weekend. They highlight that ferries are essential marine highways that connect coastal communities, workers, families, businesses and supply chains to the rest of Canada. Vancouver Island is approaching one million residents and BC Ferries carries more than 22 million passengers annually","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","label":"Waterways","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc8d3d47dcd7b49d6a6c974d4d7621fd972a203eca265338eb59114644f1058b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e83550eae0960c5451e4b0177794bb290e9a7a2bb7aa1a1f3b253edb4aab511"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-554a6ef40c1d6b13c2af2204","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083763,"date":"2026-06-04T16:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, we all want to prevent discrimination and violence in this country, but fast-tracking and shutting down debate is not going to help improve this legislation. We have a lot of important questions. We do not want to wait until there are complaints, tribunals or criminal sanctions after the fact. We want to talk about what we are going to do to prevent it.\n\nWe have not heard from the minister or the government on how they are going to invest in anti-bullying in schools; in mental health supports for vulnerable youth; in housing and homelessness, which is something that we have heard is clearly important on this; in community-based violence protection; in support for victims of hate incidents and discrimination; and in training in federally regulated workplaces, which is under the purview of the federal government and the minister, before complaints happen. \n\nWe have a lot of questions that have not been addressed by the government. Can the minister explain when the funding is going to come in on prevention, instead of it happening after the fact?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083763","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, we all want to prevent discrimination and violence in this country, but fast-tracking and shutting down debate is not going to help improve this legislation. We have a lot of important questions. We do not want to wait until there are complaints, tribunals or criminal sanctions after the fact. We want to talk about what we are going to do to prevent it.\n\nWe have not heard from the m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c88d610bd8b0ed5cc2b0167b1c337e8cf155f4e9f2f5ccc85407d18f99b137c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["652ee40f6d82fc3348c4837cb571e6d7eb80b7f30d6e5e8a02fdd5c986adfcdc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-808cdf4ec3db9234952cde80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083764,"date":"2026-06-04T22:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to work with my colleague on many climate-related issues.\n\nEarlier, I raised some concerns to the justice minister on responding to those who have been victims of discrimination and violence. Certainly, we understand the important work around dealing with complaints and the criminal sanctions piece, but there is still nothing when it comes to funding and when it comes to prevention around discrimination and violence, especially for vulnerable youth. I tabled a bill yesterday calling for parity for mental and physical health so that people get services when they need them.\n\nDoes my colleague agree that the government should be supporting legislation to have parity for mental and physical health? This would be so that mental health is an insured benefit and people, especially youth, could get the supports they need when they need them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083764","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to work with my colleague on many climate-related issues.\n\nEarlier, I raised some concerns to the justice minister on responding to those who have been victims of discrimination and violence. Certainly, we understand the important work around dealing with complaints and the criminal sanctions piece, but there is still nothing when it comes to funding and when it comes to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c2e8a0af2641afb70e338b0b5991b7d166bc7aabe79ac739b1448b91f20593bf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bfa6a4ff2b1499fe067cba9d9e8f6308da5aaabd2d2e462a07b481b51ca5e27f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee40b183707cb904a97717e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083761,"date":"2026-06-05T17:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, five years ago, the Liberals promised to ban flavoured vaping products that appeal to youth. Health Canada drafted the regulations years ago, and evidence from Canada, Quebec and the Netherlands shows that flavour bans can reduce youth vaping without increasing smoking rates, yet shelves remain stocked with bubble gum-flavoured, cotton candy-flavoured, berry-flavoured, mango-flavoured and watermelon-flavoured products designed to attract young people and increase the risk of nicotine addiction.\n\n The evidence is clear and the regulations are ready. Who is blocking these regulations, and when will the Liberal government finally ban these youth-targeted flavoured vaping products?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083761","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, five years ago, the Liberals promised to ban flavoured vaping products that appeal to youth. Health Canada drafted the regulations years ago, and evidence from Canada, Quebec and the Netherlands shows that flavour bans can reduce youth vaping without increasing smoking rates, yet shelves remain stocked with bubble gum-flavoured, cotton candy-flavoured, berry-flavoured, mango-flavour","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1004110caeab90caaeda45e4e41aec08222ae6fd71b64d3ebd5c47388b05b22d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6194d14d74791600140c1228","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083762,"date":"2026-06-05T17:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am presenting a petition on behalf of residents of my riding. They highlight that Israel's policies and actions violate the obligations set out under the Geneva Convention, which it is required to respect; that Canada is required to respect international humanitarian law; and that Israel, as an occupying power, must allow and facilitate humanitarian aid by impartial organizations.\n\n The petitioners clearly ask that Canada publicly and unequivocally reject the militarized aid model currently used in Palestine; demand the full restoration of access for UN agencies and established humanitarian aid, including UNRWA and the World Food Programme; insist on safe and immediate entry for Canadian health care workers and other international humanitarian personnel to Palestine; withhold Canadian funding from any entity or model that does not comply with these principles of neutrality, impartiality, independence and humanity; and ensure that all Canadian aid to Gaza be delivered through internationally recognized humanitarian channels.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083762","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am presenting a petition on behalf of residents of my riding. They highlight that Israel's policies and actions violate the obligations set out under the Geneva Convention, which it is required to respect; that Canada is required to respect international humanitarian law; and that Israel, as an occupying power, must allow and facilitate humanitarian aid by impartial organizations.\n\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["79a44014c060216b8b62bff7ca75c28f599329a3dc75cab34e55f56cbbf03e02"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-235d0fd325add4e2088ada16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085689,"date":"2026-06-08T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Alberta is considering several routes for a new diluted bitumen pipeline and export terminals through northern British Columbia, yet the Nisga'a Nation says that neither Alberta nor the federal Liberal government has discussed any oil pipeline proposal with the Nisga'a government. Reconciliation cannot mean making decisions first and talking to first nations later.\n\nWill the government commit today to meaningful consultation, accommodation and free, prior and informed consent of affected first nations, and to upholding the north coast oil tanker ban?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-131/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085689","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Alberta is considering several routes for a new diluted bitumen pipeline and export terminals through northern British Columbia, yet the Nisga'a Nation says that neither Alberta nor the federal Liberal government has discussed any oil pipeline proposal with the Nisga'a government. Reconciliation cannot mean making decisions first and talking to first nations later.\n\nWill the governmen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c0e39181d4be9ffe6dc6b8b5bf6b622238bd415835e92519bca7e0cfe1a0d01f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eb7478fba94bfe27314db9d46663dbbdedae65739f2e6afcd99da74617517a24"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da30f2f721604ba2291f2f2d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085683,"date":"2026-06-09T18:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour and a privilege to be able to say a couple of kind words about my good friend from Beaches—East York. \n\nI will start by saying that it is disappointing. In the last few weeks, this is the third progressive member of Parliament from the government caucus who is leaving this place, especially at a time when we need progressive politics.\n\n I cannot think of another member of Parliament in the history of this country who has fought and worked more to end animal cruelty and stand up for animal rights. It has been a privilege to watch him work, and we all know we have to carry that work forward. We will take his crusade with us.\n\nMy colleague from Calgary Nose Hill talked about courage, and I really want to emphasize that. He stood with the NDP well before the supply and confidence agreement on pharmacare. I am disappointed that he does not get to see it exercised in his home province. I hope the government will take that to heart. He stood with my bill, Bill C-216, on a health-based approach to tackle the toxic drug crisis. He was an outlier in his caucus and he stood with us to make sure that we had a plan to respond to the toxic drug crisis. I want to thank him for his support.\n\nI want to highlight one thing, which is his job as a minister. He took it to heart when we asked for support for a pool upgrade in my riding. He understood the need for seniors to have a safe place to exercise and how it was community medicine. He constantly texted me, emailed me, phoned me and checked on the project. He worked so diligently. I was so taken aback by his persistence to try to get something done. It resulted in the single largest federal government investment in mid-Vancouver Island for a recreation facility. My community is grateful.\n\nI hope he will visit my community so that we can celebrate the incredible work he put into our project. I want to thank him for his work and courage, and I look forward to seeing what he does next.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085683","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour and a privilege to be able to say a couple of kind words about my good friend from Beaches—East York. \n\nI will start by saying that it is disappointing. In the last few weeks, this is the third progressive member of Parliament from the government caucus who is leaving this place, especially at a time when we need progressive politics.\n\n I cannot think of another member","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ed5e1329ad2254e45f957bbfee19bc7c801f2c1b4f17abf34f95fc4b8c4072f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["763647f53cb00a456c473c5f136149c67c303fc2300f55e5c913f43e0358ad19"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4066e99b0ebe9ea2c8bafea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109730,"date":"2026-06-09T21:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. Thank you so much for your testimonies, Ms. Abreu and Dr. Donner, and for your courage in standing up for climate action. Canada won the Fossil of the Day Award in 2025 at COP30. Do you think Canada will win again this year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109730","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Thank you so much for your testimonies, Ms. Abreu and Dr. Donner, and for your courage in standing up for climate action. Canada won the Fossil of the Day Award in 2025 at COP30. Do you think Canada will win again this year?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9c7e4091b7275e71a94e3fbb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109731,"date":"2026-06-09T21:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"ENVI","text":"You talked about our international partners leading with a low-carbon agenda. We see that the European Union has its carbon border adjustment mechanism. We were told that if we removed carbon pricing, we would pay the price there. We've heard the Liberals talk about this prosperity agenda, and the Prime Minister comes in and calls this a prosperity agenda. Given the wildfires we've seen in the last five years—kids being told they can't go outside—and the damage to the environment, can you speak to what that prosperity agenda looks like and its impact on our economy due to our walking back on climate action?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109731","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You talked about our international partners leading with a low-carbon agenda. We see that the European Union has its carbon border adjustment mechanism. We were told that if we removed carbon pricing, we would pay the price there. We've heard the Liberals talk about this prosperity agenda, and the Prime Minister comes in and calls this a prosperity agenda. Given the wildfires we've seen in the las","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["abc620c1101ec58336593397dadd3617fa091f127eedfa1bf12c21b9f6fcaea4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6fec281cb1b2fcc018e9cbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109732,"date":"2026-06-09T21:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thanks. Ms. Abreu, you stated that the net-zero advisory body wasn't informed of policy decisions under way, and that you weren't asked to provide advice on those decisions. Can you identify the most significant decisions that the advisory body was excluded from?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109732","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thanks. Ms. Abreu, you stated that the net-zero advisory body wasn't informed of policy decisions under way, and that you weren't asked to provide advice on those decisions. Can you identify the most significant decisions that the advisory body was excluded from?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58f8630dc2278b170203c2a46bac04c945c7a6735c41ea6583f4d645d5480a0c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-178f6e2c75d476c44de33a24","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109733,"date":"2026-06-09T21:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"ENVI","text":"How much time do I have?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109733","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How much time do I have?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d9eb2e1c412131800a79c65","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109734,"date":"2026-06-09T21:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. Ms. Abreu, the Prime Minister was elected just over a year ago. He was elected as a climate champion. He served as the UN special envoy on climate action, leading global net-zero initiatives. This was his pedigree. Do you believe that he is betraying what he got elected on, his pedigree and the work that he had been doing prior to becoming Prime Minister ?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109734","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. Ms. Abreu, the Prime Minister was elected just over a year ago. He was elected as a climate champion. He served as the UN special envoy on climate action, leading global net-zero initiatives. This was his pedigree. Do you believe that he is betraying what he got elected on, his pedigree and the work that he had been doing prior to becoming Prime Minister ?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c2f8bfd8015464ba95984b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085684,"date":"2026-06-09T22:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague made some good points. The number one project in my riding for Build Canada Homes is a project to serve some individuals with intellectual disabilities. We know that many people with intellectual disabilities are served by L'Arche Canada, L'Arche Comox Valley in my riding. I am sure it is L'Arche in Regina—Lewvan.\n\nRight now, Build Canada Homes is holding the project up. It is saying that it does not meet the criteria for supportive and transitional needs. How can people with intellectual disabilities not meet the criteria for transitional needs? This is a project that is supported by L'Arche Canada. Build Canada Homes is saying that it cannot do anything right now. The minister's office says it cannot talk to Build Canada Homes and cannot get involved. These people have nowhere to go right now. They are the most vulnerable people in our society. They count on us.\n\nMaybe my colleague can speak about how this is such a disaster right now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085684","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague made some good points. The number one project in my riding for Build Canada Homes is a project to serve some individuals with intellectual disabilities. We know that many people with intellectual disabilities are served by L'Arche Canada, L'Arche Comox Valley in my riding. I am sure it is L'Arche in Regina—Lewvan.\n\nRight now, Build Canada Homes is holding the project up. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2fddc717f0c9a0513099030940df5f4d1166841ce1a0529d818849aa8fb79a61"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a671853b3fcaaf0056acc97eb71615d670c5c78ba0f563950cb6b88130c699ac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f9f38c8e4c862dfef9a1bc7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085685,"date":"2026-06-10T04:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak to this bill. Before I get started, I want to give a shout-out to Laurel Collins, the former MP for Victoria, who, as you might recall, was a champion in tackling gender-based violence and laid the groundwork for today. \n\nIf Bill C-16 is about protecting women and children, we need to get it right. We need to listen to the experts, and many of them, including women's organizations, survivor groups and legal advocates, have repeatedly called for greater investments in prevention, housing, income security and violence protection programs, yet we have seen Liberals and Conservatives continually vote against amendments that we put forward, especially from the member for Winnipeg Centre. \n\nMaybe my colleague can speak about why the Conservatives voted against those amendments instead of focusing on stopping violence before it happens, because that is a critical component.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085685","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak to this bill. Before I get started, I want to give a shout-out to Laurel Collins, the former MP for Victoria, who, as you might recall, was a champion in tackling gender-based violence and laid the groundwork for today. \n\nIf Bill C-16 is about protecting women and children, we need to get it right. We need to listen to the experts, and many of the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["625a0ad417d65f847657e171f49f3f9cc008c824c36fa4fd0ad14fa77b55514b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55ffc7ffce745b2ac67a0058","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085686,"date":"2026-06-10T04:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a tremendous amount of respect for my colleague. The main concern that we have been having as New Democrats is that we see the Liberals right now, and they are cutting critical programs that are essential for prevention. They are also letting programs expire. Maybe my colleague can explain how the government expects to reduce violence against women and victims of intimate partner violence when they are cutting the very programs that are critical for prevention. We have heard from the experts time and time again that not only do they need to be maintained, but the investment needs to be increased significantly. It is essential to this conversation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085686","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a tremendous amount of respect for my colleague. The main concern that we have been having as New Democrats is that we see the Liberals right now, and they are cutting critical programs that are essential for prevention. They are also letting programs expire. Maybe my colleague can explain how the government expects to reduce violence against women and victims of intimate partn","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc3bce99efcf3359fa7a8f97d1d064432853176103e7db4e01a923d74957d6f5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd3eeafed2f91729af67e32798060149a20d7cf9001cabbd7cd775de8a417b9f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ceb1cbf97eaa987860442b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085687,"date":"2026-06-10T05:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, here I am again, tonight, at the hour of 12:14 a.m.\n\nFair ferry funding is a critical issue to Vancouver Islanders and to coastal British Columbians. It is such a serious issue that it cannot go unanswered. I am sure that the Liberals were hoping I would not show up tonight, but here I am. I am here because ferry affordability, economic competitiveness and transportation equity matter to the nearly one million people who call Vancouver Island home and to the coastal communities that depend on BC Ferries every day.\n\nFor many of my constituents, BC Ferries is not just a convenience; it is a necessity. It is a critical transportation link connecting people to work, health care, education, family and economic opportunity. The Liberal government recognizes ferries as essential transportation infrastructure in Atlantic Canada, but it continues to treat British Columbia differently.\n\nLast July, the Prime Minister announced a 50% reduction in fares on federally supported ferry routes in Atlantic Canada. That decision recognized an important reality. Ferry affordability matters because ferry transportation is essential infrastructure when we have the longest coastline in the world. I agree with that funding.\n\nThe question is why the same principle does not apply to British Columbia. The people of B.C. pay the same federal taxes as Canadians living in Atlantic Canada, yet when it comes to ferry funding, we receive dramatically different levels of support.\n\nBC Ferries is one of the largest ferry systems in the world. It operates 25 routes, serves approximately 1,600 kilometres of coastline, maintains 47 terminals, operates a fleet of 37 vessels and carries more than 22 million passengers a year. According to the Library of Parliament, federal operational funding accounts for approximately 3% of BC Ferries' operating revenues. By comparison, federal funding covers approximately 43% of operating costs for federally supported ferry services in Atlantic Canada.\n\nThis disparity is also evident on a per capita basis. British Columbians receive approximately five to six dollars per person in federal operational ferry support, while Atlantic Canadians receive approximately $125 per person. These numbers reveal a significant imbalance in how the federal government supports essential transportation infrastructure across the country.\n\nLet me be clear. This is not an argument against supporting Atlantic Canada. I support those investments. This is an argument for fairness. B.C. is currently in the midst of a ferry fare review. It is around their services. BC Ferries has warned that without additional funding, customers could face fare increases of more than 30% over the coming years. Reductions in services could also happen, or both. At a time when Canadians are struggling with the cost of living, that prospect should concern every member in the House, especially coastal MPs from B.C.\n\nThe current funding framework is rooted in historical arrangements developed decades ago, when Vancouver Island had roughly half its current population. Today, Vancouver Island is approaching a million residents and is comparable to the size of New Zealand's South Island. It is home to a major regional economy that depends on reliable and affordable ferry transportation.\n\nIf the current model no longer reflects the realities of modern Canada, then it is time for a review and a modification to fix this agreement. Vancouver Islanders and coastal people in B.C. should not have to become a province to qualify for fair federal support for essential transportation infrastructure from the federal government. If ferry affordability matters in Atlantic Canada, it should matter in British Columbia.\n\nI am calling for a real response tonight from the federal government. We need to see action for coastal British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085687","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, here I am again, tonight, at the hour of 12:14 a.m.\n\nFair ferry funding is a critical issue to Vancouver Islanders and to coastal British Columbians. It is such a serious issue that it cannot go unanswered. I am sure that the Liberals were hoping I would not show up tonight, but here I am. I am here because ferry affordability, economic competitiveness and transportation equity matter","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["26c300bfd163ce69bce9c8afa5fe3979e4e021c0fe4ed913b514233d2b307cc6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7181640d999bddc862746fc09818bb4c81cc5572dc71e6e35684d4b6ae81b095"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09c22050f699feb55afabbbb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085688,"date":"2026-06-10T05:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I first want to thank my colleague for staying up late tonight to show up for this important debate.\n\nI am going to correct a couple of things. First of all, the pandemic relief that the federal government provided to BC Ferries was also provided to the east coast. It was equal in terms of per capita. Second, the loans that the member cited are repayable loans. Even with the loan interest at $26 million a year and the $38 million, when we look at loan savings per year over 25 years, that does not even come close to the hundreds of millions of dollars that the federal government subsidizes on the east coast.\n\n There are approximately 350,000 passengers on the east coast and 22 million at BC Ferries, yet the federal government gives hundreds of millions of dollars to Atlantic Canada, which we support, but they shortchange British Columbians. It has been far too long since the government has reviewed the essential ferry funding for British Columbians. It is time for the government to fix it.\n\n The population of Vancouver Island is more than the population of New Brunswick, more than that of Newfoundland and Labrador and P.E.I. together, and almost the same as that of Nova Scotia. This is long overdue. I am here at 12.22 a.m. not because I think this is fair. It is unfair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085688","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I first want to thank my colleague for staying up late tonight to show up for this important debate.\n\nI am going to correct a couple of things. First of all, the pandemic relief that the federal government provided to BC Ferries was also provided to the east coast. It was equal in terms of per capita. Second, the loans that the member cited are repayable loans. Even with the loan inte","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2ca16ea6f417595921f9a80beddee418448f332aa5afec857706cfcb4ce05a07"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["93819508bba4800bcec8b0bd674c6bfac4a034aeb7aff77e3a37778a8a6d695c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0e277663fd1e49a5fbc8419f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085682,"date":"2026-06-11T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada's national shipbuilding strategy focuses on building and maintaining vessels, but there is no plan for responsibly retiring them. More than 900 derelict and end-of-life vessels sit off B.C.'s coast, threatening the marine environment. While aging navy and Coast Guard vessels approach retirement, Canada lacks the capacity to safely recycle them here at home.\n\nWill the Prime Minister finally commit to investing in dry dock infrastructure, in world-class ship recycling facilities and in regulations, and make ship recycling a core component of the national shipbuilding strategy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037108","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Shipbuilding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085682","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada's national shipbuilding strategy focuses on building and maintaining vessels, but there is no plan for responsibly retiring them. More than 900 derelict and end-of-life vessels sit off B.C.'s coast, threatening the marine environment. While aging navy and Coast Guard vessels approach retirement, Canada lacks the capacity to safely recycle them here at home.\n\nWill the Prime Mini","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037108","label":"Shipbuilding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037108","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Shipbuilding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037108","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shipbuilding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037635","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wharfs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037108","label":"Shipbuilding","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037635","label":"Wharfs","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2216a9a7ead3f5de88634185c6ad20e3a7780f5f0bbf1302caf78a52f85d6eb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037108","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Shipbuilding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037108","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shipbuilding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b43abf0b1d7ab853be1e4fc61bc3cd989348b455270beff3537b1138c395eeca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037108","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Shipbuilding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037108","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shipbuilding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037108","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7f1eca5a6a5295e14d90ce0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085680,"date":"2026-06-12T17:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour today to table a petition on behalf of constituents from my riding. It is signed by members of the Tseshaht and Hupačasath nations in Nuu-chah-nulth territory. They highlight that an essential part of reconciliation is addressing the harms first nations have experienced, including the devastating loss of language and culture; that there is a growing number of indigenous language learners, but the number of remaining fluent speakers is falling; that the changes to federal funding for indigenous language programming, especially in British Columbia, have put the preservation and revitalization of first nation languages and cultural heritage at risk; and that there is an urgent need to invest in indigenous language revitalization before it is too late. \n\nThe petitioners are calling on the government to ensure that there is fair, adequate, long-term funding to protect indigenous languages and for indigenous language programming.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085680","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour today to table a petition on behalf of constituents from my riding. It is signed by members of the Tseshaht and Hupačasath nations in Nuu-chah-nulth territory. They highlight that an essential part of reconciliation is addressing the harms first nations have experienced, including the devastating loss of language and culture; that there is a growing number of indigenou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e3164df0a98603e141d6559d3abe4888eba5659d4edc0a2169242c7b9455d8d2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d412773ddab73a068ddc9101d706fb9f5d87bbeaf83b33323b82d7b67db5222"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-481971472afd6ad045362714","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085681,"date":"2026-06-12T17:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"First, Mr. Speaker, no one is arguing the importance of this bill. However, there are Senate amendments that are very good and that we support. The government rejected them. Now it is proposing closure instead of having proper debate on the bill. We want to get it right. I think that is important. I think we all want to work together in the House to make sure we have the best legislation and in moving it forward quickly. At the same time, this is not the right tool for us to have the proper debate, which has not been held in the House. Closure is not the right tool.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-135/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085681","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"First, Mr. Speaker, no one is arguing the importance of this bill. However, there are Senate amendments that are very good and that we support. The government rejected them. Now it is proposing closure instead of having proper debate on the bill. We want to get it right. I think that is important. I think we all want to work together in the House to make sure we have the best legislation and in mo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d03669aa704192d40c45f11","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087619,"date":"2026-06-15T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, June is Brain Injury Awareness Month, a time to recognize survivors, families, caregivers and first responders whose lives are forever changed by brain injury. \n\nIn Courtenay—Alberni, Amelia Hayden, a retired RCMP officer, knows this impact deeply. She was on duty the day Constable Gerry Breeze was injured, and she remained a source of support to his family throughout his recovery and after his passing. Their story reminds us why Canada needs a national brain injury strategy. It is why I introduced Bill C-206. \n\nIn the last Parliament, former MP Alistair MacGregor's bill passed unanimously at every stage to report stage but died because of prorogation. The call to action is non-partisan, and on Wednesday, June 17, as Canadians take part in a national pause for brain injury, we hope all parties will support a call for a national brain injury strategy in this fall's budget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087619","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, June is Brain Injury Awareness Month, a time to recognize survivors, families, caregivers and first responders whose lives are forever changed by brain injury. \n\nIn Courtenay—Alberni, Amelia Hayden, a retired RCMP officer, knows this impact deeply. She was on duty the day Constable Gerry Breeze was injured, and she remained a source of support to his family throughout his recovery and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb2d6a9657f0b6bd471949e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087620,"date":"2026-06-15T21:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as my colleague well knows, in Atlantic Canada, they receive about $125 per person in ongoing ferry subsidies for operating costs. In British Columbia, it is about $6 per person. In fact, BC Ferries receives only 3% of overall expenditures in funding from the federal government for operating costs, versus Atlantic Canada's 43%.\n\nMy colleague will cite that the Liberals provided funding for COVID relief, which they did for Atlantic Canada, too, or loans that have to be repaid by ferry users that accumulate to about $26 million in savings over 25 years. It is nothing compared to the hundreds of millions of dollars in subsidies to Atlantic Canada.\n\n Does my colleague believe the current agreements are outdated and need to be modernized? He talked about increases in fuel. BC Ferries, just last week, added a 5% surcharge because of fuel.\n\n Is my colleague going to stand up for our coastal communities today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087620","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as my colleague well knows, in Atlantic Canada, they receive about $125 per person in ongoing ferry subsidies for operating costs. In British Columbia, it is about $6 per person. In fact, BC Ferries receives only 3% of overall expenditures in funding from the federal government for operating costs, versus Atlantic Canada's 43%.\n\nMy colleague will cite that the Liberals provided fundin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["825764a219685d5d423c51efbf8e553c33132111470a4241b1699670b891261e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["030bba23f0c5f320a54ff9fbc691ca659e2a9997acb80caec93622dd249661d4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39657646803cd17fd1ec558d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087621,"date":"2026-06-15T23:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I asked a Liberal colleague earlier today about ferry funding. I was explaining that the federal government contributes 43% of operating costs for Atlantic ferries. In British Columbia, they contribute 3%. The government contributes $6 per capita to the average British Columbian for operating costs for ferries, but on the east coast, it is $125. The Liberals say it is because of constitutional agreements and because those ferries are travelling province to province.\n\n Does my colleague think that Vancouver Island and coastal B.C. need to become a province just to get funding when it comes to operational costs for ferries?\n\n Living in a coastal community, ferries are essential transportation. I stood in the House, and I heard a Liberal parliamentary secretary agree that it is essential transportation. This is about fairness. People on Vancouver Island pay the same amount in taxes as people in Atlantic Canada. We do not even have a senator on Vancouver Island. We have not had one in 55 years. They have 10 senators in New Brunswick. They have six in Nova Scotia. They have 10 between P.E.I. and Newfoundland. P.E.I. and Newfoundland do not even have the same population as Vancouver Island. Neither does New Brunswick. In Nova Scotia, it is the same.\n\n We are not asking to reopen the Constitution. We are just asking the government to do something that is fair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-136/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087621","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I asked a Liberal colleague earlier today about ferry funding. I was explaining that the federal government contributes 43% of operating costs for Atlantic ferries. In British Columbia, they contribute 3%. The government contributes $6 per capita to the average British Columbian for operating costs for ferries, but on the east coast, it is $125. The Liberals say it is because of const","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8d50858a16d93b273e47db820b86f89014c7e28a3fd50b134e4aad9704f8d783"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ed5ce75365d5fc93c629535f800532575a55697438a6949273f896aa02b901ca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f04a650743770c18aab96855","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109735,"date":"2026-06-16T17:50:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"RNNR","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to thank the parliamentary secretary, Mr. Hogan, for giving me this time and this opportunity. I was at the all-party forestry caucus this morning, and it was great to see all of us working collectively. This shouldn't be a partisan issue, but there are some things that need to happen and some issues that can be rectified. We heard from the Forest Products Association of Canada. They talked about, obviously, the uncertainty that the U.S. tariffs and trade disputes are causing on the forest sector, but they did highlight that Canada should be putting more emphasis on creating domestic demand for Canadian wood products rather than relying so heavily on export markets. I shared a story about IGV Housing in my riding. They're a company that we're so proud of. They had PacifiCan funding. They're ready to go, but they're running into the problem that CMHC can't finance off-site modular housing, but Build Canada Homes says you have to have modular housing. This is the same minister . The minister could direct CMHC to fix their financing allowability, but they haven't, and this is holding up projects that could use Canadian wood. I'm going to go, obviously, to my fellow British Columbian, Mr. Kalesnikoff, so he can speak about how some of these gaps and barriers need to be addressed immediately and can help create jobs in our communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109735","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to thank the parliamentary secretary, Mr. Hogan, for giving me this time and this opportunity. I was at the all-party forestry caucus this morning, and it was great to see all of us working collectively. This shouldn't be a partisan issue, but there are some things that need to happen and some issues that can be rectified. We heard from the Forest Products Association ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be9f92de3e575c91fc9560550dd0daca5d016cc0858154a82582f9da5cb6f091"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["de9ae6cbe8ae2588fa360d6c65a805b00140167a5ee597119d5a90f3b6a9e53e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68bb6e849a20b9cacd623f24","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109736,"date":"2026-06-16T17:50:00+00:00","title":"RNNR","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"RNNR","text":"I think you're touching on how important it is that we use Canadian wood for all infrastructure. The forest sector action plan requires federal partnerships in key areas, as you know, to implement the strategy. We've heard from stakeholders that we need to scale up regional forest manufacturing hubs and integrated value chains; to accelerate investment in modernization, innovation and value-added production; to reduce, obviously, regulatory friction and align policy frameworks with provinces; and to support workforce transition and community resilience. I'm thinking about the workers in Crofton and the need for a bridge to retirement. I'll go back to you, Mr. Kalesnikoff, given that you're from my home province. Do you want to touch on some of those issues? You have about a minute left. I want to give you my time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/RNNR/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109736","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think you're touching on how important it is that we use Canadian wood for all infrastructure. The forest sector action plan requires federal partnerships in key areas, as you know, to implement the strategy. We've heard from stakeholders that we need to scale up regional forest manufacturing hubs and integrated value chains; to accelerate investment in modernization, innovation and value-added ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3750b3def3adf44bfcaf6b02deb07b3d5c3c8e1e55e2b389414fadb6524d99d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4f91a17a04df78423be067caad75e0e7e59dc38e825db68d2923e9151fcfc8ea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d1ce6f6efb4406bd6a83d46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087616,"date":"2026-06-17T21:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank all my colleagues for allowing that to happen.\n\nToday is Brain Injury Awareness Day. It is an honour to table this petition on behalf of the families impacted by 165,000 new cases annually of brain injury in our country. They highlight that brain injury survivors face a 200% increased risk of struggling with addictions after sustaining a brain injury. Despite the federal government committing $11 billion over 10 years to improve community support in mental health and addiction services, none have been specifically targeted to brain injury.\n\nThe petitioners call on the government to support Bill C‐206, develop a national strategy to support and improve brain injury awareness prevention and treatment and the rehabilitation and recovery of persons living with a brain injury.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087616","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank all my colleagues for allowing that to happen.\n\nToday is Brain Injury Awareness Day. It is an honour to table this petition on behalf of the families impacted by 165,000 new cases annually of brain injury in our country. They highlight that brain injury survivors face a 200% increased risk of struggling with addictions after sustaining a brain injury. Despite the feder","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c0876f7ac2e6c1eb4f3e30edfc2bc19c9b62272778a841754a46a9ae13135731"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7235d5fb76be88b9863bce1e6021997d2078ed4690c0d259bfc8dbf4c04451f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d7ef165da51544be8defd41","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087617,"date":"2026-06-17T21:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table this petition to modernize federal ferry funding policies and provide fair, stable, long-term federal operational support for BC Ferries as essential national transportation infrastructure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087617","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table this petition to modernize federal ferry funding policies and provide fair, stable, long-term federal operational support for BC Ferries as essential national transportation infrastructure.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["254cb3d9e9785028bfdf55c0c06c7d2e70887b0d314b02356be156bc1aba9735"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a20127f2eeb7606b952529c6ddcb12607b81669bfd3f03cf348682e10bfffe01"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fc891aed0a1d0b63ed33582","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087618,"date":"2026-06-17T21:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition to reverse the planned cuts of the 665 AAFC staff and the closure of the organic and regenerative research program units.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087618","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to table a petition to reverse the planned cuts of the 665 AAFC staff and the closure of the organic and regenerative research program units.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb7a8b5cbc3ab5c69f228a2a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087613,"date":"2026-06-18T16:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we recall that the United Nations special rapporteur warned that Canada's temporary foreign worker program can create conditions resembling modern-day slavery. Last month, the San Group, a company operating in Port Alberni, was fined $429,000 and banned for two years for serious violations involving migrant workers. \n\nMy office met with those workers, and they were terrified. They feared losing their jobs, their status and the money they had borrowed to come to Canada. It was NGOs, the Salvation Army's Michael Ramsay and Kim Tran, a local Vietnamese interpreter, who stepped up and helped out because the federal government was not there to support these migrant workers who were trying to get help. A two-year ban certainly is not enough. Exploited workers deserve timely support, open permits and a pathway to permanency. \n\nDoes my colleague agree that this program needs to be fixed and that there needs to be funding to support workers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087613","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we recall that the United Nations special rapporteur warned that Canada's temporary foreign worker program can create conditions resembling modern-day slavery. Last month, the San Group, a company operating in Port Alberni, was fined $429,000 and banned for two years for serious violations involving migrant workers. \n\nMy office met with those workers, and they were terrified. They fea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75108900c19d858bc33eba77ca9aea21198cd241a9e5a8a36218e00efd0e805a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad37d9b98864131ca17e22ef5ecd215f3096c0292f4f0418f7b8ad5d07a6d7dd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f98847c11f32d3223905082","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087614,"date":"2026-06-18T17:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I highlighted earlier, a Port Alberni company was fined $429,000 for its violation in its treatment of migrant workers, and it was given a two-year ban. Clearly, two years is not enough. The company operates other companies, and the rumour is that it actually has temporary foreign workers working for them as well. It took local people to help them out, because the government failed to be there. There is no funding in Bill C-30 to create more funding to support workers whose rights are violated.\n\n I would like to hear the member's opinion, first, about the program itself and, second, about the importance of ensuring that when workers' rights are violated, they get the support they need.\n\nMany people have filed complaints about employers who are abusing the program. There has been no follow-up and no feedback. Temporary foreign workers are often hired without the labour market opinion having been done in the right way. Workers who are looking for work are not getting hired. We hear in my riding about abuses of workers by employers, but there is no follow-up. There is nothing. When workers are in trouble, they are not supported. When people complain about workers being violated, they do not get support, and the workers they are concerned about do not get the help they need.\n\nI wonder if my colleague can speak about the changes that are needed in the program.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087614","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I highlighted earlier, a Port Alberni company was fined $429,000 for its violation in its treatment of migrant workers, and it was given a two-year ban. Clearly, two years is not enough. The company operates other companies, and the rumour is that it actually has temporary foreign workers working for them as well. It took local people to help them out, because the government failed","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d01af48d7b4d5bdc4ee7ba0843efc325edbae2b9a50b9c8296581f63343d405"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["62d77e1a7eab99eb9aa1179794fd751f1fa0067204ccad3954d2cc2e5cc582e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9af6f27328b0b9ad7b414dae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087615,"date":"2026-06-18T17:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gord Johns","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to bring us back to a part of the conversation in which my colleague talked about the government's removing regulations on dangerous pesticides. Just last week, the Prime Minister announced his food security strategy, and the Liberals are removing important regulations that protect Canadians regarding pesticides. At the same time, the government is cutting public agricultural research capacity at Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. These cuts would close research facilities, eliminate scientists and technicians, and end programs like the organic and regenerative agriculture research program.\n\nI would like to hear from my colleague about whether, when food security and food sovereignty matter more than ever, my colleague sees the importance of the government's pausing its changes on these regulations, pausing these cuts and actually working with farmers to protect Canada's public agricultural research system?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087615","member_id":"bc-mp-89263","member_name":"Gord Johns","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to bring us back to a part of the conversation in which my colleague talked about the government's removing regulations on dangerous pesticides. Just last week, the Prime Minister announced his food security strategy, and the Liberals are removing important regulations that protect Canadians regarding pesticides. At the same time, the government is cutting public agricultural r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6eb11b7e2d295a88422d989afec94fdd70ea87b59c40a32f0a1b5de9221a805f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["849ed4a761e73e9dc3795e77847350c6d8cfcfb716822f1f54bedb5afdd408e5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43230ddcb9a598decc128fe8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306834,"date":"2026-02-25T20:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for South Shore—St. Margarets for her advocacy for Nova Scotia's manufacturers, such as Hawboldt Industries. Companies like this prove that advanced defence manufacturing is thriving in rural Canada.\n\n Our defence industrial strategy makes procurement a driver of growth. In Atlantic Canada, the sector supports 10,000 good-paying jobs. Through a defence investment agency, at least 70% of our defence spending will focus on generating jobs and investments here at home. That makes work in communities like Chester and allows faster delivery for equipment to the Canadian Armed Forces.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306834","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member for South Shore—St. Margarets for her advocacy for Nova Scotia's manufacturers, such as Hawboldt Industries. Companies like this prove that advanced defence manufacturing is thriving in rural Canada.\n\n Our defence industrial strategy makes procurement a driver of growth. In Atlantic Canada, the sector supports 10,000 good-paying jobs. Through a defence inves","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","label":"Industrial buildings","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","label":"Military technology","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["813303e31fb5c4d046a52643a120c58f1a3ccf68dc13ea4d37d84ff278644c08"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b5416e6867873d669ba13039fbfb1243e8a1e4fb87c9a3af07e21bc7cb82f0f0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ad176bb8d88c51e1d4f476d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384255,"date":"2026-03-23T23:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved that the bill, as amended, be concurred in at report stage.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384255","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"moved that the bill, as amended, be concurred in at report stage.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad6bc321948ca480d24f1c2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725160,"date":"2026-05-01T17:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, unfortunately, an agreement could not be reached under the provisions of Standing Order 78(1) or 78(2) with respect to the report stage and third reading stage of Bill C-11, an act to amend the National Defence Act and other acts. \n\nUnder the provisions of Standing Order 78(3), I give notice that a minister of the Crown will propose at the next sitting a motion to allot a specific number of days or hours for the consideration and disposal of the proceedings at the respective stages of said bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-115/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725160","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, unfortunately, an agreement could not be reached under the provisions of Standing Order 78(1) or 78(2) with respect to the report stage and third reading stage of Bill C-11, an act to amend the National Defence Act and other acts. \n\nUnder the provisions of Standing Order 78(3), I give notice that a minister of the Crown will propose at the next sitting a motion to allot a specific num","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da952b18675ea0bc2f7b1254","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034965,"date":"2026-05-25T22:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to designate Thursday, May 28, as an opposition day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034965","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to designate Thursday, May 28, as an opposition day.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1981144fd164df0746962d11","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109737,"date":"2026-06-03T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Good morning, everyone. I am very pleased to be here today. I would like to begin by acknowledging that we are gathered on the traditional and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. The defence industrial strategy is built on a simple idea: Defence and economic security are mutually reinforcing. The geopolitical assumptions that have shaped Canada's defence and industrial policies for decades no longer hold. By strengthening the operational readiness of the Canadian Armed Forces, we can also strengthen Canadian industry, support innovation, create good jobs and build greater resilience here at home. To achieve these objectives, the defence industrial strategy introduced a new build-partner-buy framework. Through the Defence Investment Agency, we are applying this framework by building in Canada where practical, partnering with trusted allies where collaboration strengthens capability and industrial participation, and acquiring proven systems when speed and operational requirements demand it. Let me begin with operational readiness, the first area examined by your committee. The Canadian Armed Forces requires modern equipment delivered at the speed of relevance. The capabilities identified in \"Our North, Strong and Free\" remain critical to Canada's security, but the pace of technological and geopolitical change has increased the importance of delivering them sooner. Over the past year, we've accelerated the delivery of a number of key capabilities for the Canadian Armed Forces. For instance, we've accelerated the Canadian modular assault rifle program by approximately two years. We've accelerated Canada's submarine replacement program and, most recently, advanced Canada's airborne early warning and control capability, a key enabler for both NORAD and NATO operations. Together, these initiatives are helping ensure that the Canadian Armed Forces receive the capabilities they need faster while strengthening Canada's ability to sustain and evolve these capabilities over time. Canada's defence industry is another key area examined by your committee. The strategy aims to increase the share of defence acquisitions awarded to Canadian firms to 70% over the next decade while increasing defence exports by 50%. This is already being reflected in the DIA procurements we've done. The Canadian modular assault rifle program is built here in Canada and supported by an approximately 80% Canadian supply chain, and Colt is already supporting allied demand, including exports to Denmark. Canadian-built Bombardier Global 6500 aircraft provide airlift capability here in Canada as well. This supports domestic aerospace manufacturing, engineering and sustainment. The Canadian patrol submarine project is placing significant emphasis on Canadian in-service support and supply chain participation. Innovation is also central to the defence industrial strategy. The selection of Saab as a preferred supplier to provide airborne early warning and control is a strong example of this. It delivers significant Canadian industrial participation from the outset while allowing Canada to participate in spiral development of those systems over time. This also creates an opportunity for Canada to develop and export a finished AEWC capability to allied partner nations, a key defence industrial strategy objective of increasing Canadian defence exports. By bringing more of the missionization and systems integration work back to Canada, the project supports high-value jobs and sovereign expertise here at home. This approach helps ensure interoperability with allies while creating long-term opportunities for Canadian innovation, expertise and industrial participation. The final area identified in this study is the creation of jobs here in Canada. The defence industrial strategy is expected to generate up to 125,000 new jobs across Canada, and we're already seeing evidence of that impact through the growing production capacity, investment and hiring across Canada's defence and aerospace sectors. As an example, I was told by Colt Canada that they were going to have to double their employee workforce to meet the demand of the Canadian order, plus the Denmark order, and I'm sure there are more coming for that great company in southern Ontario. Mr. Chair, the defence industrial strategy is not simply about buying equipment. It's about providing capability for the Canadian Armed Forces while building out capacity for Canada. Through the build-partner-buy framework, we are strengthening readiness, supporting Canadian industry and encouraging innovation while creating jobs here at home in Canada. Thank you. I look forward to your questions. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109737","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Good morning, everyone. I am very pleased to be here today. I would like to begin by acknowledging that we are gathered on the traditional and unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people. The defence industrial strategy is built on a simple idea: Defence and economic security are mutually reinforcing. The geopolitical assumptions that have shaped Canada's d","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad98bee509d25d157ae299f2ebd8e9dda45a73cdf10a411b34a34c8311dbc8de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["adccb4bb6523aea6f0cfd527df4cec4aee23e70358b455fb60e763c5d0587965"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f42cc2c1981734b814063199","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109738,"date":"2026-06-03T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I will answer your question, but we're here to talk about the defence industrial strategy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109738","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I will answer your question, but we're here to talk about the defence industrial strategy.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47488","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Chemical weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47488","label":"Chemical weapons","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["636011a0584f885ba6c797aa58889854a769927cdf470f04c2a25fad5524ddf5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04051f3791616c2360c7ca0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109739,"date":"2026-06-03T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I did bring it up. Right now, the DIA is negotiating with Saab as a preferred supplier. We're in the pretty early stages of this procurement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109739","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I did bring it up. Right now, the DIA is negotiating with Saab as a preferred supplier. We're in the pretty early stages of this procurement.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e94560e54529026e1e331f42ca020b866a421995e5ff931fcd2c03ead5541fcd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["864d93cb1346b1902c71ebfb0e979d8196040bcee772dc2d79f1e4ac0557350e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80218dc54c8e625e54f261d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109740,"date":"2026-06-03T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We're negotiating with Saab as a preferred supplier.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109740","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We're negotiating with Saab as a preferred supplier.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a7dfeee7f587c3501544cf8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109741,"date":"2026-06-03T21:35:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We are in pretty early stages, Mr. Bezan. We just announced it at CANSEC, as you know.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109741","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We are in pretty early stages, Mr. Bezan. We just announced it at CANSEC, as you know.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Innu","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Innu","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035901","label":"Innu","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["882f3415676a0d7fc40de733e68330b838b427768daeb2fdbaabb041e2787a42"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-088c62f35a6803b2c073c927","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109742,"date":"2026-06-03T21:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We're ahead of it. If you look at \"Our North, Strong and Free\", there are timelines and capabilities in it. That's a couple of years old. A lot has changed in two years. The entire planet is different from how it was two years ago. That was a policy update to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109742","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We're ahead of it. If you look at \"Our North, Strong and Free\", there are timelines and capabilities in it. That's a couple of years old. A lot has changed in two years. The entire planet is different from how it was two years ago. That was a policy update to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Planetariums","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036678","label":"Planetariums","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d115e3a6accac5c852cff69c2f99c6b8b307009d714b60476b9b1fecb0f9e3ed"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab49b6f0c6078c95a00308a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109743,"date":"2026-06-03T21:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We had a defence policy from 2017, and then we had an update. These things happen from time to time. I'm saying that since the last update we had two years ago, \"Our North, Strong and Free\", significant changes have occurred. We're pulling lots of capability forward. Subs are another good example of that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109743","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We had a defence policy from 2017, and then we had an update. These things happen from time to time. I'm saying that since the last update we had two years ago, \"Our North, Strong and Free\", significant changes have occurred. We're pulling lots of capability forward. Subs are another good example of that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","label":"Global warming","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["57af9464f8bab1727ade187ac55092e4e30a0eb145de5fff56c139578adc23ac"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70a1f1593e4090fb4506b850","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109744,"date":"2026-06-03T21:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I think this came up in committee the last time I was here. It's no secret; the defence department writes the requirements for the things that they need. We have a build-partner-buy strategy that we're applying to that, so that's what's happening.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109744","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think this came up in committee the last time I was here. It's no secret; the defence department writes the requirements for the things that they need. We have a build-partner-buy strategy that we're applying to that, so that's what's happening.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db7e518b652a9bffa15afb05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109745,"date":"2026-06-03T21:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I don't think so at all. Sole source has always been a way any government—including yours, which tried to sole source the F-35, ironically.... It's always existed there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109745","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I don't think so at all. Sole source has always been a way any government—including yours, which tried to sole source the F-35, ironically.... It's always existed there.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c58cd90d7be60b513c8c55ca1749fd6da5fb3a8158c2b629c25e5fbd0770b70"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3043bdac2eb3e6cc4446c36d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109746,"date":"2026-06-03T21:40:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"If you look at the four ways you can sole source something under the existing rules—until this passes—there's some pretty broad subjectivity on the ways that you can do things. All this does is add clarity to that. The Government of Canada, whether it be Conservative or Liberal, in the past and in the future, has always had the ability to sole source. There's some more clarity in the bill. That's my opinion. If they decide to do it for whatever reasons, they have to justify it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109746","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If you look at the four ways you can sole source something under the existing rules—until this passes—there's some pretty broad subjectivity on the ways that you can do things. All this does is add clarity to that. The Government of Canada, whether it be Conservative or Liberal, in the past and in the future, has always had the ability to sole source. There's some more clarity in the bill. That's ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c24ef882b90285786172e01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109747,"date":"2026-06-03T21:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Now it sounds like we want to have a committee meeting on Bill C-31 , division 16, because we're really in the weeds here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109747","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Now it sounds like we want to have a committee meeting on Bill C-31 , division 16, because we're really in the weeds here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weeds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037627","label":"Weeds","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e2997068a172b2c97bbc9b7c27a9fc94264c8f7e9069ce00630b22433742e99"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-abd4152344406d6e40bfd874","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109748,"date":"2026-06-03T21:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I think what you're drilling at here, Mr. Bezan, is accountability, and I agree with you. Let me say that, as for any other department that exists now, all the accountability still exists. There's Parliament. There is this committee. There's the Auditor General, and there's a PBO. None of that stuff goes away. All we've done is create an agency to manage one of the biggest complaints about military procurement—as your committee identified back in November 2024—which is that it's too slow. It cannot deliver on time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109748","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think what you're drilling at here, Mr. Bezan, is accountability, and I agree with you. Let me say that, as for any other department that exists now, all the accountability still exists. There's Parliament. There is this committee. There's the Auditor General, and there's a PBO. None of that stuff goes away. All we've done is create an agency to manage one of the biggest complaints about militar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a66bf9b3dead5e01a15dab46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109749,"date":"2026-06-03T21:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Here's another revelation: The national security exemption has existed and exists now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109749","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Here's another revelation: The national security exemption has existed and exists now.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35d34e030f4513a595d5dbc514fe0151f3f785bd81a5862270da1f7a1b03467e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa276fd83091fc5c45b9a2c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109750,"date":"2026-06-03T21:45:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"If we look at what's going on in the world right now, we've seen a number of conflicts that we thought would end quickly but that just didn't. There are no signs of them ending quickly. Certainly one of them is for sure in that state. What I think we all could admit and agree to is that we need to persist. We have to be able to persist in conflicts, should we get ourselves into one. I hope that doesn't happen, but we have to be prepared to defend our sovereignty. Supply chain resilience is a big part of that persistence. You can have integrated supply chain resilience with partners. You can have much better personal, sovereign supply chain resilience. Canada has amazing capacity and capability, probably much more than we've ever appreciated before. We want to engage in that supply chain resilience, not only to help us be more resilient and less reliant on others, but to create well-paying jobs and careers for Canadians. Whether it's shipbuilding or aerospace.... Those are big ones, but the small and medium-sized enterprises in this country are unbelievable. There is a ton that they have to offer. We need to ensure that we get them into our supply chains where we can. This document, the defence industrial strategy, really is a road map to do it. Some of the initiatives are shared. For example, DISHs and BOREALIS are defence department initiatives, but they're still helpful. Build-partner-buy, from the DIA perspective, is how we can help bring these other companies in as we move forward. This document, which is the first of its kind—I think we've talked about this before, maybe even in the House—is the road map to help. There is absolutely no way we're going to meet the KPIs in this document without bringing SMEs into the conversation. It's more than the conversation; it's bringing them into the process. It has to happen. They represent 93% of our companies in this space and 40% of the workforce. They are critical to making sure that we do this big economic pivot and give our great defence and security companies a chance to participate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109750","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If we look at what's going on in the world right now, we've seen a number of conflicts that we thought would end quickly but that just didn't. There are no signs of them ending quickly. Certainly one of them is for sure in that state. What I think we all could admit and agree to is that we need to persist. We have to be able to persist in conflicts, should we get ourselves into one. I hope that do","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a11e7e76dcf431106248a7431dc5b03e09e67cb9d0f0e8034dbcf4bad3ef0f93"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["761d8d6decd1f7002692b1b6cddb5fc8f93aa5d1a0ae3e9a498fc3c785dc9f64"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3924af562487aa695e738c50","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109751,"date":"2026-06-03T21:50:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes, I can. With the document specifically, there are, I believe, 10 sovereign capabilities listed. That's a pretty good indicator of where Canada plans to build capacity. I used to be a small business owner myself in this space, and I would be looking at where Canada plans to do more in the 10 areas that are identified in the DIS. However, as I was saying just a few minutes ago to your colleague, the defence policy and the defence investment plan are also very important documents to signal to industry where we're going. If they want to [ Inaudible—Editor ] investing in themselves and/or get involved, the three documents—the defence policy, which in this case is an update, because that's what we're working with now; \"Our North, Strong and Free\", the defence plan; and then the defence industrial strategy—are very good indicators. Plus, I would say this: We have really done a lot of work with being available to industry. I take a ton of meetings, and it's not just me. All our colleagues take a ton of meetings with industry, to make sure they know what's going on. That will not stop. That will continue to make sure that small to medium-sized businesses know what's going on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109751","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, I can. With the document specifically, there are, I believe, 10 sovereign capabilities listed. That's a pretty good indicator of where Canada plans to build capacity. I used to be a small business owner myself in this space, and I would be looking at where Canada plans to do more in the 10 areas that are identified in the DIS. However, as I was saying just a few minutes ago to your colleague,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aef0e6ff1822d0bed10a18f4799d878cbfa8e54fa884276a02ffed0b448ffd6a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea41e4c114b745e11bdb3ba82f427cf71c48a559fb70f624d6cdcdbe8c8e80d0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-299561a87cfd4cd26e91ceb9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109752,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Thank you very much. We are all very aware. Steel, aluminum, auto and softwood are the ones we hear about over and over in the House because it's true that those sectoral tariffs are very damaging to our economy. On defence procurement, where we can.... I'll use both steel and aluminum as examples. Steel is a good example. We're building armoured vehicles here. We're building ships here. We need a very specific type of steel for that, and we're trying to get some of our big steel producers to pivot. It's the same with aircraft aluminum. We have De Havilland. We have Bombardier. We have some big aircraft manufacturers here. We're trying to see whether there's an opportunity for them to source some of their material from Canada. Again, the aluminum they need may not be exactly what's being produced. The bigger opportunity is the buy Canada strategy, which is all the building that we're going to do across the country—and it's significant. The Government of Canada will be buying Canadian materials: steel, aluminum and lumber. That's probably the quickest relief you'll see for the aluminum sector. There may be others. I know the government's also looking for other markets for our aluminum. I think the U.S. will come to terms with the fact that they need us for aluminum. I hope that happens sooner rather than later.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109752","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much. We are all very aware. Steel, aluminum, auto and softwood are the ones we hear about over and over in the House because it's true that those sectoral tariffs are very damaging to our economy. On defence procurement, where we can.... I'll use both steel and aluminum as examples. Steel is a good example. We're building armoured vehicles here. We're building ships here. We need a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","label":"Steel"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035853","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Industrial technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035853","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035853","label":"Industrial technology","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","label":"Steel","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0fd2d22c0777212f3b6f1372241e25bb9d78fad7880cf22de37b9acad623ff96"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6757ce70ccbe128c8eb7dbc9fdbdb8e2696baacfeef22d11e7989f90c5937d1a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8078df779f78c86f85d4fd53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109753,"date":"2026-06-03T21:55:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I understand what you're saying, but let me add a couple of things. This is like it is with our need for steel for armoured vehicles or icebreaking ships when we don't necessarily have that type of steel here. This is analogous to what you're describing. We have aluminum, but it's not the type we can use, so we send it someplace else. In the second hour, there will be somebody here from ISED. The reason I bring that up is that there's something called the strategic investment fund. This fund of money is to help companies pivot. If what was working before these tariffs came in is not working now, and we need to change the way they do things so they can compete and get into procurement in Canada, this is not my department. However, this type of money does exist out there to help companies specifically do these types of things so that we can keep everybody working here in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109753","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand what you're saying, but let me add a couple of things. This is like it is with our need for steel for armoured vehicles or icebreaking ships when we don't necessarily have that type of steel here. This is analogous to what you're describing. We have aluminum, but it's not the type we can use, so we send it someplace else. In the second hour, there will be somebody here from ISED. The ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dfb15e0315109f587f49d5eb4161c4597ed3609cb174d04ed749f2eca5b0e88f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a53e6f5e4878a2931930543","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109754,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We're picking up our pace here at home with regard to how we procure things in Canada. As you know, we've signed up to SAFE, which is another NATO initiative. The good news about SAFE is that not only is Canada the only non-EU country that's involved in this—other than the EU ones that are in it—but it gives us access of up to 80% of procurement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109754","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We're picking up our pace here at home with regard to how we procure things in Canada. As you know, we've signed up to SAFE, which is another NATO initiative. The good news about SAFE is that not only is Canada the only non-EU country that's involved in this—other than the EU ones that are in it—but it gives us access of up to 80% of procurement.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","label":"Green products","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6574af28021ecbdae45ff3d7550ad2650a01ce2dd483f086fe3b292b2fc7d3ef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c55d85f639549defe0430ef8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109755,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Right now, as you may know—I'm sure you've looked at the DIA's website—we have eight procurements. We will be getting all the procurements. We don't have them yet, so we're working with the procurements that we have. As you heard from the people who were here—I watched a committee meeting on Monday—I would argue that we're moving quickly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109755","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Right now, as you may know—I'm sure you've looked at the DIA's website—we have eight procurements. We will be getting all the procurements. We don't have them yet, so we're working with the procurements that we have. As you heard from the people who were here—I watched a committee meeting on Monday—I would argue that we're moving quickly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75e8fdfdde4d7850467ad6a0df885b354c1891f8113a9b2ec7b259864254ecb9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7754f6d37f0b4393728f508","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109756,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"In this document, you'll see BOREALIS and DISHs. Those are probably the pathways that you're talking about. Those are DND initiatives. The other problem is that we're too slow. Before, slow meant \"late and expensive\". Now it means \"late, expensive and irrelevant\". There are a host of things in this document. Not all of them are DIA initiatives. I would say DISHs and BOREALIS are very good examples of how we're going to bring technology.... We're going to have to do all sorts of things. We're going to have to make sure that we have an evolving supply chain, because technology is changing so quickly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109756","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In this document, you'll see BOREALIS and DISHs. Those are probably the pathways that you're talking about. Those are DND initiatives. The other problem is that we're too slow. Before, slow meant \"late and expensive\". Now it means \"late, expensive and irrelevant\". There are a host of things in this document. Not all of them are DIA initiatives. I would say DISHs and BOREALIS are very good examples","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49344ed9fae931d2b1d2668b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109757,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We buy things off the shelf, and we spiral develop them. We get them quickly—the ones that exist. We make sure that they have extra power, cooling and space so that we can spiral develop them moving forward. As an alternative, we could do it the old way, which is to buy something, reiterate it a million times, \"Canadianize\" it and wait 10 years to get it. We're not doing that anymore.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109757","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We buy things off the shelf, and we spiral develop them. We get them quickly—the ones that exist. We make sure that they have extra power, cooling and space so that we can spiral develop them moving forward. As an alternative, we could do it the old way, which is to buy something, reiterate it a million times, \"Canadianize\" it and wait 10 years to get it. We're not doing that anymore.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c60af49fb29bfd2dd1133d70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109758,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's one way we can de-risk it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109758","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's one way we can de-risk it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bfd97a472702542bda9ea59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109759,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Do you want to jump in, Mr. Robitaille?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109759","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you want to jump in, Mr. Robitaille?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93d4f5011e217a006655ffee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109760,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Strategic partnerships are a good example of that. We have a strategic partnership with CAE for future fighter lead-in training. We have a strategic partnership with MDA Telesat. The whole point of getting involved with companies early on is to let the experts of these companies help us figure out how to go quickly, not make mistakes and not waste money. Those are two good examples of that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109760","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Strategic partnerships are a good example of that. We have a strategic partnership with CAE for future fighter lead-in training. We have a strategic partnership with MDA Telesat. The whole point of getting involved with companies early on is to let the experts of these companies help us figure out how to go quickly, not make mistakes and not waste money. Those are two good examples of that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["492cfc1f075779e9c8847d7c72877563c17247299ff9ace80fecc3bc3122eda6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35570b063a0378473acd8029","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109761,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Right now, that's with natural resources. Today, we're a special operating agency inside PSPC. We will be a stand-alone agency, as we all know, but critical minerals aren't on our plate yet. I suspect they will be, but they are not there now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109761","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Right now, that's with natural resources. Today, we're a special operating agency inside PSPC. We will be a stand-alone agency, as we all know, but critical minerals aren't on our plate yet. I suspect they will be, but they are not there now.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0a7fbe5db5dea5a37c61e6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109762,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Our 2% was sanctioned by NATO—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109762","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Our 2% was sanctioned by NATO—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-693964310b9dca0230816527","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109763,"date":"2026-06-03T22:00:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm saying that because there were some people who said that we just self-declared at 2%. I've seen it, but that's not true. We met our 2% obligation. NATO agrees with our accounting and what we've done. As for your question, going from 2% to 5%, I would have to turn to the official to find out exactly what's going on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109763","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm saying that because there were some people who said that we just self-declared at 2%. I've seen it, but that's not true. We met our 2% obligation. NATO agrees with our accounting and what we've done. As for your question, going from 2% to 5%, I would have to turn to the official to find out exactly what's going on.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88770b57a78b3249b774e8fc8156def9c690de51c8cf7bf60da9b89f429574ef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f2cf2a9685e2bb509c48446","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109764,"date":"2026-06-03T22:05:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We're engaging with the industry to find out what capability exists in Canada, first and foremost, and there's a lot of it—AI, robotics and quantum. Canada's a leader in all of those spaces—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109764","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We're engaging with the industry to find out what capability exists in Canada, first and foremost, and there's a lot of it—AI, robotics and quantum. Canada's a leader in all of those spaces—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210830","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Robotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aviation industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:210830","label":"Robotics","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","label":"Aviation industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c621c4720d1b8f7b9f1d6f890b644fa4701a257447955818f44c342a34c834c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53562904c32409cfe83d4f66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109765,"date":"2026-06-03T22:05:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"It's the Department of National Defence that writes the requirements—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109765","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's the Department of National Defence that writes the requirements—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d24d43c9cb30e34310802f9a47bbd2a0ef96dc2d69ce61d8c78a0ead93a405b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4439262f552739c8c51d67c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109766,"date":"2026-06-03T22:05:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We work with them. They identify what they need. We go through something called options analysis, which we'll be involved in to make sure that the build-partner-buy strategy is applied. At the end of the day, the requirements exist at the Department of National Defence, so what you're describing is exactly what they're up to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109766","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We work with them. They identify what they need. We go through something called options analysis, which we'll be involved in to make sure that the build-partner-buy strategy is applied. At the end of the day, the requirements exist at the Department of National Defence, so what you're describing is exactly what they're up to.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47720","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Marketing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47720","label":"Marketing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6a45a29c90867bb0032ec650c24332416793a0d15c23b015b019810d013c862"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8665d7a94bcf2230d8492f67","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109767,"date":"2026-06-03T22:05:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes. Thank you for the question. As I said earlier, it's critical for us to do this, not only for our economy but for our resilience. If we want supply chain resilience in Canada to support our Canadian Armed Forces, we need to make sure all these small companies, especially like the ones you described, are known about and can participate. If I were to go through this document, I would point out a couple of things. It removes a lot of barriers, and I speak from experience, because I used to operate in this space. One of the barriers was communication with the government. These SMEs have no chance or the resources to figure out who to talk to. Big primes even struggle with this. The communication with the government is at an all-time high. I know this because I deal with them all the time, and there was some pretty positive feedback from the group of folks you had here on Monday. I watched the committee meeting, and they were pretty happy with the way things were. Therefore, communication is key, and that happens right at the beginning. Fiscal supports for SMEs in particular are challenging. You just couldn't get money from anywhere, unless you were going to a venture capital place and are prepared to pay 12%, 13% or 15%. They can't do that all the time. There are a whole bunch of initiatives in financing that have come about. They're identified in there. I think BDC got a total of about $6 billion. The regional development agencies got about $350 million. The NRC got some money. Financing for these small to medium-sized companies is a lot more prevalent than it was before. Regarding security clearances, I'm not sure if powder coating would necessarily be in that space, but it is an issue. These small businesses that want to work in this space need to have security clearances, and then they need to have a place to work, because you can't have these conversations at the local Starbucks. All of these things have been addressed. Moreover, another thing we've just taken on, or have done since we've been running, is introducing small companies to big primes. I took 25 companies with me to South Korea. I took 15 to Germany and Norway when I went—there were fewer on that trip because it was just before Christmas. These companies that are working on submarines, or even AEWC, will have billions of dollars in ITB obligations to Canada. They could buy 100 million dollars' worth of rubber boots, but we don't necessarily want that. We want to direct this fiscal resource to where Canada wants the money to go, and we can incentivize this through a points system to make sure that the money coming back is going to the places that actually matter to our supply chain—and we'll certainly do that. One other thing, really quickly—because not a lot of people are talking about this, but it's going to happen—is that all the ISED stuff, all the ITB policy, will be transferred to the DIA when this agency is stood up as a department. Now, what does that do? You will truly have one-stop shopping for defence procurement. The DIA—Doug Guzman and his team—will do the negotiation and the total business case for the procurement. All the SMEs will have essentially one phone number to call, and we can do what we can to help. If we have the authority to help, great. If it's something we don't have the authority to do or we can't help them with, we can help find out what to do. I'll give you one quick example. We will never have the authority or the ability to grant export permits. That's a Global Affairs function, but it's important and matters to us because I have a KPI to increase defence exports by 50%. Small businesses go through the process. They go to GAC, but guess what. We can also help advocate for them from inside to make sure nothing gets lost in the process—because there are tons of files and lots of things are happening—and we can get these companies export permits, as an example. One-stop shopping is what everybody in this room who was on that committee in 2024 wanted. They also wanted a single point of accountability. That was a supplementary opinion or position of the Conservatives on top of the number of recommendations the committee had, which everybody agreed to, and this is exactly what we're building. I'm quite excited about it. You've got great feedback from the companies that were here. That's not our talking about it or tapping our own backs. The companies are quite happy with this. Can we do more? Can we go faster? I think we can, and we'll be able to do more when we build ourselves up in our final form.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109767","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes. Thank you for the question. As I said earlier, it's critical for us to do this, not only for our economy but for our resilience. If we want supply chain resilience in Canada to support our Canadian Armed Forces, we need to make sure all these small companies, especially like the ones you described, are known about and can participate. If I were to go through this document, I would point out a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b4d3ac97d9f679d9056874d44f1972be58f9bf73ca57d92017c88dea469ac9c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a5b7ef53d0bfc433ecff89f250246910f46400b6667fcfca9ddf1724b2fa8cd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e2083eb257840edaf8ff4db7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109768,"date":"2026-06-03T22:10:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"To close the loop on your aluminum, I'm very sensitive to that. I totally understand what you're saying, and I'll be pleased when we have the official from ISED here to see if there is some path to helping rejig the aluminum situation so that it's more viable, given our current situation with the tariffs. With regard to the broader picture, there is literally billions of dollars going into bases, and Bagotville is one of those bases. A lot of new infrastructure is being built and provided for new aircraft. There's new housing, and there's water and sewer. There's billions of dollars' worth of construction. My assumption—I don't know this right now—is that much of the labour will come from that region, which is going to be very helpful to the people who live there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109768","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"To close the loop on your aluminum, I'm very sensitive to that. I totally understand what you're saying, and I'll be pleased when we have the official from ISED here to see if there is some path to helping rejig the aluminum situation so that it's more viable, given our current situation with the tariffs. With regard to the broader picture, there is literally billions of dollars going into bases, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f5aaf3dff771b276f55ae3eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109769,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Very quickly, the answer is yes. It's called the buy Canadian policy, and it's going to be enforced. It's already being enforced, and this is for the exact reason we just talked about. We will be looking for materials and labour, and it's going to be enforced for the reasons you cited.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109769","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Very quickly, the answer is yes. It's called the buy Canadian policy, and it's going to be enforced. It's already being enforced, and this is for the exact reason we just talked about. We will be looking for materials and labour, and it's going to be enforced for the reasons you cited.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed0e086ea46679fee6eeaff3cdb2c8b8ae357c5c1ef34c4cc3ecf04477804c58"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66fbf24416faac2e74b2656a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109770,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I think I gave you my phone number the other day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109770","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think I gave you my phone number the other day.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88233","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Telehealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88233","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telehealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88233","label":"Telehealth","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff0244d1fae58a5c0dfe1a230fc04e588eede4e2ac0cc502fe2d04c624a69100"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63d0bede16700c643f2fc56c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109771,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm sure we can provide you a phone number that you can call.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109771","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm sure we can provide you a phone number that you can call.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["918197501da74156d3031a752c089bea5d6e95b961058d06da6be18e65ea7356"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd3101d2628e06b119e00bee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109772,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We have one with Telesat and MDA.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109772","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We have one with Telesat and MDA.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8dc7b4317371db85600c97c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109773,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I have to list them. There's Telesat and MDA, Colt Canada, Bombardier—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109773","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have to list them. There's Telesat and MDA, Colt Canada, Bombardier—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b61892cae7be5fe1d0e67618","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109774,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"There are about half a dozen.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109774","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There are about half a dozen.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42497c30ea36b6c2ee3829d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109775,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I don't know. A voice: It's about the same number.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109775","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I don't know. A voice: It's about the same number.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e486370aa8f067840c4e6c84","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109776,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"You've put some things together that make no sense.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109776","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You've put some things together that make no sense.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f4798ed78e9772ec8fb86cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109777,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We are completely accountable. I listed a whole bunch: Parliament, committees, the PBO, the House of Commons, the Auditor General. We are accountable to all those things. You can haul us in here any time you want. Nothing's changed there. To your other question—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109777","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We are completely accountable. I listed a whole bunch: Parliament, committees, the PBO, the House of Commons, the Auditor General. We are accountable to all those things. You can haul us in here any time you want. Nothing's changed there. To your other question—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c180e8155c79296b53d9589949fd771c1e62fcaf0f2bc83f501d9ffccc1779db"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89e2a62169baec8accb9dc07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109778,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Actually, it wasn't. You asked me, and I came.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109778","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Actually, it wasn't. You asked me, and I came.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08987c484735ad66f3bbb7ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109779,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"No, you asked me, and I came. That's what happened.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109779","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No, you asked me, and I came. That's what happened.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c559bfe6e4ea019e8d7196d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109780,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"You're fabricating a bunch of things that you pulled out of the document.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109780","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You're fabricating a bunch of things that you pulled out of the document.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945702","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Packaging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034716","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crafts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034716","label":"Crafts","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945702","label":"Packaging","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5dd52e2b181c68c073b8fe6137914d31f1277872a6da5c33ede624da273b45c5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4442d33293a0baa9dd6b546c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109781,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I don't have an answer for you, but I will say that there are new financial tools in division 16—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109781","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I don't have an answer for you, but I will say that there are new financial tools in division 16—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44401","label":"Personal finance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4d41573f58f46231755ba08b283d4bf873413ac196b81b0213deba24e255178"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1abebcc14ab7278efa53583a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109782,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"There are equity positions. There are loans. There are loan guarantees—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109782","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There are equity positions. There are loans. There are loan guarantees—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1db4f5eadd5ad734347b4d26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109783,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"If you give me a second, I'll answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109783","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If you give me a second, I'll answer.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fa2ff428e7118e4e10b38f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109784,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"There are a number of countries that have similar things. I believe the Brits and the U.S. do, and the NATO DIANA has a couple of things that are set up this way. I know what you're driving at. You're trying to drive at that we're going to have this unlimited amount of money that we run around doing whatever we want with.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109784","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There are a number of countries that have similar things. I believe the Brits and the U.S. do, and the NATO DIANA has a couple of things that are set up this way. I know what you're driving at. You're trying to drive at that we're going to have this unlimited amount of money that we run around doing whatever we want with.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d2bbb5bfd510a37c7ca61a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109785,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's the way you're interpreting it, but that's not necessarily what's happening, Scott.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109785","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's the way you're interpreting it, but that's not necessarily what's happening, Scott.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-625fdbc7ef22f2d7ec8c354e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109786,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I think you'd have to talk to them. How would I even know that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109786","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think you'd have to talk to them. How would I even know that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62dcbabe1cb95f1911f217df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109787,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"It hasn't happened, Scott.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109787","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It hasn't happened, Scott.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-979ab4d33e4048015179280c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109788,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"We're going to look at, on a case-by-case basis, the opportunities that lie in front of the government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109788","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We're going to look at, on a case-by-case basis, the opportunities that lie in front of the government.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4f91611dd5ec130e77b4e32a54f1e1df610b39b67a99e5e151f32df6e3ada3e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a088dee714c07f20bef52af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109789,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"First of all, it's the public service that does this. It's not me personally. The public service will look at the—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109789","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"First of all, it's the public service that does this. It's not me personally. The public service will look at the—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3a586c0e7db17fce9dfefe5d202de290d0221603d9db3b5ba05223b59283f095"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b5d1024ef0f80770ba824a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109790,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"It's my file, Scott.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109790","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It's my file, Scott.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2900a367f29e9bcc16fb18b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109791,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"What I said to Mr. Bezan before was that the Government of Canada has always had the ability to sole source. It has always had the ability to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109791","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"What I said to Mr. Bezan before was that the Government of Canada has always had the ability to sole source. It has always had the ability to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb9add03b8a5946f78f2955c2c05ca72242e1f4419e570563b0cf22d16a7ac17"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0877dce4a9099d142014a16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109792,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"—use a national security exemption. Probably the biggest example of a mess-up on a sole source was the F-35 that the previous Harper government tried to do. In fact, they were held in contempt of Parliament for trying to do it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109792","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"—use a national security exemption. Probably the biggest example of a mess-up on a sole source was the F-35 that the previous Harper government tried to do. In fact, they were held in contempt of Parliament for trying to do it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["039cc0a760b66bb7b0f059d656a2a95c4fbd9f966355d61679488850c07537d2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c513850f57c91c65863ce93b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109793,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I think that you would have to ask the CEO of the investment agency when that becomes an issue. I can't speculate on what may or may not happen in the future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109793","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think that you would have to ask the CEO of the investment agency when that becomes an issue. I can't speculate on what may or may not happen in the future.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privatization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","label":"Privatization","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ad1a504b59c0b3aafb5bfafcb59f9ed80614cdbcf3727a017e1f0d8ec6523ae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-203b7edfe2e6ec6e26c48c24","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109794,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Communication is a big one. I've talked to many companies that didn't know where to go, didn't know who to talk to and were burned out with trying to deal with the machine, as they referred to it, so they missed out on opportunities. If someone is interested in defence procurement and they put any kind of effort into it, they're going to get someone in our department who will help them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109794","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Communication is a big one. I've talked to many companies that didn't know where to go, didn't know who to talk to and were burned out with trying to deal with the machine, as they referred to it, so they missed out on opportunities. If someone is interested in defence procurement and they put any kind of effort into it, they're going to get someone in our department who will help them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["14079813090015202d76c27e06f8f571b4f59fb10ca27f93036819cd59fb403d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f2eb5b311067eaf2c90000fe80befcb56793055b134c834f3a99ef3f81313f4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-165e37f9b29750c92b6099d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109795,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"There are a number of programs out there to help workers that are unrelated to this that the Government of Canada is doing and that we've been talking about. Companies basically will invest in themselves and get out over their skis if they know what's coming. You skate to where the puck's going. If you don't do that, you're going to be playing catch-up all the time. As I mentioned before, sovereign capability is in this document, specifically the defence investment plan and the defence policy. Those documents exist and are out there, and they give companies some certainty, an idea about where the Government of Canada will be investing. Certainty is what's helpful for business; uncertainty is not. We're saying that we're going to be serious about build-partner-buy. That's us, the DIA. Then there's the buy Canada policy, which is a PSPC policy. Between those two things, there's certainty built in. To go back to where the puck's going, with those three documents I just talked about, industry can start to see where we're headed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109795","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There are a number of programs out there to help workers that are unrelated to this that the Government of Canada is doing and that we've been talking about. Companies basically will invest in themselves and get out over their skis if they know what's coming. You skate to where the puck's going. If you don't do that, you're going to be playing catch-up all the time. As I mentioned before, sovereig","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["152b294115eb9f8b20fabde901537a3dd9ee02324f49c89f0c75af2b9e1aede8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-298cadd9dfe9686eb9b5e140","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109796,"date":"2026-06-03T22:20:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I think a good example of that would be the strategic partnership. It's having companies come in early and manage more of the process. Let them figure out who would be best. Typically primes would do this anyway, but it would be bringing in companies early in the process. It might be MDA or Telesat, or in the case of fighter lead-in training, it would be CAE. They can figure out the most effective way for teaming. They actually manage much more of the process, because they're closer to the issue than the government is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109796","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think a good example of that would be the strategic partnership. It's having companies come in early and manage more of the process. Let them figure out who would be best. Typically primes would do this anyway, but it would be bringing in companies early in the process. It might be MDA or Telesat, or in the case of fighter lead-in training, it would be CAE. They can figure out the most effective","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac59f5b76c22a0ffa96f6eb9dc876637c3ca837afd82535002712a8858b05d29"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a3234803ee43ccb17708277","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109797,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'll check to see if there is a phone number. There certainly is an email address, and if there's a phone number, I will pass it on to the committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109797","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll check to see if there is a phone number. There certainly is an email address, and if there's a phone number, I will pass it on to the committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd87caf544ebcc352e2909cc542a710703288cced3584a0007707e82d21287fd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54dafee256c35b9b5be0e083","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109798,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'm not too hard to get hold of.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109798","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'm not too hard to get hold of.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28903f02c9289d387710cee7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109799,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"They're mutually reinforcing. We can do both. Here's a great example. We just bought HIMARS from the U.S. In this particular case, for that procurement, that was the quickest way to get the kit the military needed. We just went and did it. It's tough to answer that question, because every single circumstance is different.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109799","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"They're mutually reinforcing. We can do both. Here's a great example. We just bought HIMARS from the U.S. In this particular case, for that procurement, that was the quickest way to get the kit the military needed. We just went and did it. It's tough to answer that question, because every single circumstance is different.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","label":"Military technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","label":"Military technology","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5fcfa35d438621d5c2abc156053848b6240ba51e5eb4f45500757ae0d0c79241"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["894d697a65ee4b378b3a554fafa6f05c9f206cfcb7a34e7d002bac852b53d3ad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a3cbf9f7a357a603f22ad35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109800,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"That's certainly something we could talk about. HIMARS is pretty mature. This is going back to another committee appearance that I had. Many—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109800","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's certainly something we could talk about. HIMARS is pretty mature. This is going back to another committee appearance that I had. Many—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f76f978d2afe29c6b4cf9ab315d7b9fc190a826b51331c31e37e73e20e6a2431"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-863213d820cf62c54676ab75","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109801,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Ammo in general is an issue. Whether it's for HIMARS, 155 millimetre, small arms or 120 millimetre, all of that's an issue. That's something Canada is very serious about getting into, not only for our own war stocks but to help out our neighbours—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109801","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Ammo in general is an issue. Whether it's for HIMARS, 155 millimetre, small arms or 120 millimetre, all of that's an issue. That's something Canada is very serious about getting into, not only for our own war stocks but to help out our neighbours—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","label":"International finance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","label":"Space technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","label":"Arms control","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dfe6ae8202c976a2729f27bf9a886d362b5efc2d29e78379cb1ae510363b4f76"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc987e2965505b25868251a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109802,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I think you hit the nail on the head. With rockets now, it seemed like that was old technology as we went to different higher-end systems, but we can't throw million-dollar missiles at $20,000 drones. That is not a sustainable position to be in. I think the Brits have a laser-guided rocket. It's a fairly effective way to do it. I tend to agree with you, in that Magellan used to build a CRV7 for Canada. They still have that capability in cold storage. I'm going to be raising that with my colleagues to see if there's a need for us to get back into that business.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109802","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I think you hit the nail on the head. With rockets now, it seemed like that was old technology as we went to different higher-end systems, but we can't throw million-dollar missiles at $20,000 drones. That is not a sustainable position to be in. I think the Brits have a laser-guided rocket. It's a fairly effective way to do it. I tend to agree with you, in that Magellan used to build a CRV7 for Ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:291774","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Explosives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:291774","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Explosives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:291774","label":"Explosives","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f808ace8cc3cf3dacfd86eb9aef317079158c2c3838df9eaea4799830da850aa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67b9441085e755ef6364ce94","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109803,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes. Those are Canadian ones that we wrote off—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109803","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes. Those are Canadian ones that we wrote off—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Maple products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036186","label":"Maple products","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","label":"Literature","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef046293544913d1bf7023ac93c4fbb566b35f714152480e2b0c266a0a246f39"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41da34bc848e57db70cc9932","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109804,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"Yes, they were, 100%.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109804","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes, they were, 100%.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9702bc9cbbeac8cdd7f9a4f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109805,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I used to chair this committee as well. I think everyone's been generous, but if you want me to come back on this—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109805","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I used to chair this committee as well. I think everyone's been generous, but if you want me to come back on this—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1643e69fc0eaa91b2fea763fb0c1fb863ae19509f94873fef27a6de0c3d217f8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c2f98844abc9fd2d83e81632","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109806,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I want to answer questions on the subject for which I was called to the committee, which is the DIS. If you want to have me back, I'm happy to come back.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109806","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I want to answer questions on the subject for which I was called to the committee, which is the DIS. If you want to have me back, I'm happy to come back.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64440a85904125eb84ddf09118925a32f02f5bad44e17e994f15f9b7192a1484"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-893c2959df8453e107bddb03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109807,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"No—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109807","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6558a3bb5d9662e592e5d9b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109808,"date":"2026-06-03T22:25:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I'll say this more broadly. I've said it before, and I'll say it again: The department now and the department in the future will always be held to account by the same net mechanisms that exist now for any other department. If Parliament, committees, the Auditor General or the PBO has an issue or if they are worried about something, they can haul in whoever it is in the future—me, or whoever that might be—to talk about what they think has gone sideways.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109808","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll say this more broadly. I've said it before, and I'll say it again: The department now and the department in the future will always be held to account by the same net mechanisms that exist now for any other department. If Parliament, committees, the Auditor General or the PBO has an issue or if they are worried about something, they can haul in whoever it is in the future—me, or whoever that m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["70853075c26352b2390abc54ff67856412d7d367f42ab17310b2405b00ca2088"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-792adf6cf2e8bddce569954f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109809,"date":"2026-06-03T22:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"I did review the committees before I showed up for the study, and I wasn't surprised. What I heard on Monday was very much what I'm hearing across.... Those are very much Quebec or eastern companies, but I've heard it all over the country. I've heard it in Atlantic Canada. I've heard it in the Prairies. I've heard it in the north. I've heard it out in British Columbia. What we've done so far is remarkably better than what we had. There's no question about it. You could measure it in any way you want, and you would hear the same thing. It is much better, and it will continue to get better. There's one thing I want to mention. You mentioned the L3. When we talked about supporting Canadian companies, we ran around and said \"Canadian companies\", and that's true, but what we mean is economic benefit to Canada. Foreign direct investment in Canada is probably at a 22- to 23-year high, which is great, and this is what we want, but we talk about economic benefit to Canada. L3, Lockheed Martin, Boeing—those are examples of companies that have thousands of workers here in Canada. As long as they continue to invest in Canada, that's what we want. Whether it's a born and bred Canadian company or it's a foreign company that is driving economic growth in Canada, we're open to all of it. To circle back to your question, everybody that I'm hearing from is quite happy with the direction we're headed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109809","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I did review the committees before I showed up for the study, and I wasn't surprised. What I heard on Monday was very much what I'm hearing across.... Those are very much Quebec or eastern companies, but I've heard it all over the country. I've heard it in Atlantic Canada. I've heard it in the Prairies. I've heard it in the north. I've heard it out in British Columbia. What we've done so far is re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["faed7672837ca51d1f3b2f7c0a41b4ddffde90fc10a573b88f6dd3991fe96f77"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56a4ecf55faadc1ebbf689213988ad1cf274a35331672ddc839d19162642d527"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e29f39dec5fe7a714f44b890","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109810,"date":"2026-06-03T22:30:00+00:00","title":"NDDN","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"NDDN","text":"There are a couple of KPIs in the document. We're moving towards 70% acquisitions in Canada and 50% exports. I think there's a 240% increase in revenue for small to medium-sized businesses. There's a bunch of them in there. There's a 10-year window to get there. At the rate we're moving, I'm confident that we're going to get there. That's the important part. I was really glad to see that you got such positive feedback. We're working super hard to make sure this works, because it really matters right now. We need to find other things for Canadians to do—careers. Our auto industry is getting hammered. Softwood is getting hammered. Steel and aluminum have massive pressure. Whatever we can do to help...it's not just defence but the Major Projects Office, buy Canadian and Build Canada Homes. These are all pillars of how we're going to keep this economy running, and defence is going to do its fair share.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/NDDN/meeting-39/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109810","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There are a couple of KPIs in the document. We're moving towards 70% acquisitions in Canada and 50% exports. I think there's a 240% increase in revenue for small to medium-sized businesses. There's a bunch of them in there. There's a 10-year window to get there. At the rate we're moving, I'm confident that we're going to get there. That's the important part. I was really glad to see that you got s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ed3746c901d485f1c78f6c2220ab812e94319f739c5e09cdee9c55ec84381b1a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["217722d13ad47ca31e74b09cea0d8a746b707353981f8cb688a67af294ba3db8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e893555adedf70526629dc7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083775,"date":"2026-06-05T16:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, that member knows very well that the foundations of the Canadian economy remain strong. I will give a couple of good examples of that.\n\n Foreign direct investment is at a 23–year high. Interest rates remain low. Inflation remains at the Bank of Canada window. Manufacturing numbers are up. Even productivity in Canada is trending in the right direction. Hot off the press: unemployment is down, job creation is up and 20,000 people in my riding will get the groceries and essentials benefit today. We could not be happier.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083775","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, that member knows very well that the foundations of the Canadian economy remain strong. I will give a couple of good examples of that.\n\n Foreign direct investment is at a 23–year high. Interest rates remain low. Inflation remains at the Bank of Canada window. Manufacturing numbers are up. Even productivity in Canada is trending in the right direction. Hot off the press: unemployment","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","label":"International finance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7229691d2df476eaf879dc03d0c47e1b976793ed4ee84b6baf5a7331a85c42c9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e0e1a7b3611ca3756bace9ed823a0da7eaad0cb4f84348f70ccd82dc621e8aaa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b71c81a7eaee754b0da5e761","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083776,"date":"2026-06-05T16:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephen Fuhr","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I miss that member. I am happy to see him again. \n\nAs he knows, the foundations of our economy remain strong. I will repeat them. Foreign direct investment is at a 23-year high. Interest rates remain low. Inflation remains in the Bank of Canada window. Manufacturing numbers are up. Productivity, which has been the boat anchor around our economy for years, is trending in the right direction. Hot off the press is that unemployment is going down. The economy just posted 88,000 jobs. \n\nToday, in his riding, as in mine and everybody's in this room, Canadians are getting the groceries and essentials benefit.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083776","member_id":"bc-mp-89279","member_name":"Stephen Fuhr","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I miss that member. I am happy to see him again. \n\nAs he knows, the foundations of our economy remain strong. I will repeat them. Foreign direct investment is at a 23-year high. Interest rates remain low. Inflation remains in the Bank of Canada window. Manufacturing numbers are up. Productivity, which has been the boat anchor around our economy for years, is trending in the right di","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e6dc18dea4e2a69adb2bea3052c6c80c75897fa09ed37bb7d5aa8a6caa1ae171"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2f0712aa4497fa32ebe370b79a0ee7a19b973ac2991cf590000fdd31b454b80a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e13d8d1dd23ed3ef30d054b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70379,"date":"2026-01-26T19:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, extortion cases are exploding and it is a full-on crisis. In Surrey alone, police are responding to more than one case a day. Families and small businesses are terrified, truckers are feeling the heat and people feel abandoned by Justice Canada. After years of Liberal promises, the results speak for themselves. Crime is up and criminals walk free. Bill C-5 and Bill C-75 strip mandatory minimums and entrench catch-and-release policies.\n\nWhen will the government work in good faith with the Conservatives to eliminate mandatory minimums for extortionists and repeal the catch-and-release laws that are hurting our country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70379","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, extortion cases are exploding and it is a full-on crisis. In Surrey alone, police are responding to more than one case a day. Families and small businesses are terrified, truckers are feeling the heat and people feel abandoned by Justice Canada. After years of Liberal promises, the results speak for themselves. Crime is up and criminals walk free. Bill C-5 and Bill C-75 strip mandator","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f390b01d6f0f1045201b167eaefb6da84568896875e0124b64fa5a4cfc8c243"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9629ec9db71a3f4ed02447d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70380,"date":"2026-01-26T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise on behalf of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford to table two petitions.\n\nThe first is in memory of Mr. Darshan Sahsi. Daylight shootings, murders and violence underscore a broader public safety crisis in the Fraser Valley and Lower Mainland. Residents are calling on the Government of Canada to reinforce the process of public reporting so Canadians can clearly see how federal, provincial and local governments are working together to prevent further increases in violent and organized crime.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70380","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise on behalf of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford to table two petitions.\n\nThe first is in memory of Mr. Darshan Sahsi. Daylight shootings, murders and violence underscore a broader public safety crisis in the Fraser Valley and Lower Mainland. Residents are calling on the Government of Canada to reinforce the process of public reporting so Canadians can clearly see how federal, pro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1e396c77ad640ac73ec0ff81336ce5c1934da7becfb038bfaf9347d8550dd0da"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0c09e7a01e112a0c5dbbaca5f73be99c7c0d8baed8ffc0a96e945cdcba9e4476"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c60d33bbd6254481faf7afbc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70381,"date":"2026-01-26T20:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I present today is calling for an alternate location to a supportive housing project planned for Martens Street across from the Abbotsford Traditional School. Throughout the process, there has been a lack of transparency, public input and considerations of alternate locations, nor has a disclosure of plans been provided by BC Housing. The petitioners are calling on the Government of Canada to cease all funding to BC Housing until it finds a more appropriate location, not beside a school.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-73/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70381","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I present today is calling for an alternate location to a supportive housing project planned for Martens Street across from the Abbotsford Traditional School. Throughout the process, there has been a lack of transparency, public input and considerations of alternate locations, nor has a disclosure of plans been provided by BC Housing. The petitioners are calling on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["acbb604c7a215c3340178d5b37c313444427ec6f9d6e40463e39046572df51f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ee37f3fed160fb88f4808ca0fbeae22b6b611a17b2eaaa3c7abeaf44410ba80"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c10c065450a49552058c15c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70382,"date":"2026-01-27T15:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present petition e-6753, which was signed by 7,175 Canadians who want the GST and HST removed from massage therapy services.\n\nRegistered massage therapy is recognized as a medical service by health care professionals, and registered massage therapists are licensed and regulated like other health professionals but still not exempt from GST and HST under the Excise Tax Act.\n\nFailure to remove the GST creates double standards and inequity in the professions regulated by the colleges. It may also contribute to financial barriers for some patients.\n\nThese Canadians are calling on the Government of Canada to add registered massage therapy to the GST and HST exemption within the Excise Tax Act and remove the GST and HST from registered massage therapy services in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70382","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present petition e-6753, which was signed by 7,175 Canadians who want the GST and HST removed from massage therapy services.\n\nRegistered massage therapy is recognized as a medical service by health care professionals, and registered massage therapists are licensed and regulated like other health professionals but still not exempt from GST and HST under the Excise Tax A","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","label":"Therapy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","label":"Therapy","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c855575863479d0a9e9faba6711d42cc2761bad097bd7cd548cb825d49317c6e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c385866c1e830a18cdc4e253b5347ca9434b6184de3114567c13a23506884790"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6adb66a65cdbe484d9051610","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70383,"date":"2026-01-27T20:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member opposite, the parliamentary secretary, said that the Conservatives do not talk about climate change. A government scientist said that the disaster that happened in my riding in December was related to climate change.\n\nI have been in the House for many years, beating my head against the table, asking the government for a response in order to protect the breadbasket of British Columbia, the critical supply chains that run through my riding, the second-largest airport, and a border crossing. All I have received from the government is crickets with respect to an area that is completed related to Canada's ability to export to foreign markets.\n\nWhen will the government take seriously the issues affecting the Sumas Prairie, Abbotsford and the flood infrastructure needed to protect Canadian exports and Canadian agriculture, and provide some semblance of security for the farmers and the people who call this place home?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70383","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member opposite, the parliamentary secretary, said that the Conservatives do not talk about climate change. A government scientist said that the disaster that happened in my riding in December was related to climate change.\n\nI have been in the House for many years, beating my head against the table, asking the government for a response in order to protect the breadbasket of Brit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d7310ae95dd9383d5110e66bc217b7e8f758e0708661659e18f14fab8d0c56bf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9895c717095298d728806dd0a1ca9e8166f63845fdb4f0e8e01f4c4087ee2887"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d8a9c7cafcdced67e1d40e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70384,"date":"2026-01-28T20:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, on behalf of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford, I would like to present a petition about Bill C-9. The Liberal-Bloc amendment to Bill C-9, passed at the justice committee, would remove the good-faith religious defence clause from the Criminal Code of Canada. Bill C-9 would allow the state to prosecute people who express deeply held religious beliefs the government finds offensive.\n\nTherefore the petitioners are asking the Government of Canada to withdraw Bill C-9, protect religious freedom, uphold the right to read and share sacred texts, and prevent government intrusion into faith.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70384","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, on behalf of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford, I would like to present a petition about Bill C-9. The Liberal-Bloc amendment to Bill C-9, passed at the justice committee, would remove the good-faith religious defence clause from the Criminal Code of Canada. Bill C-9 would allow the state to prosecute people who express deeply held religious beliefs the government finds offensive.\n\nTherefo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["86c4956ea096ca59df9440d9bfcc9aa61d87057de2430c0ec5f0bc455cfc8505"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["589ce3de4a077fdd30399fa569e76d7d0fc9584e66115d690cf9f441d6567aff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5855ae83e5ff104e9db49ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70385,"date":"2026-01-28T20:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of residents of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are deeply concerned about the proposed expansion of medical assistance in dying to individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness.\n\nMy constituents fear that expanding MAID in this way risks normalizing suicide as a response to mental illness. They believe that Canada should instead prioritize and strengthen mental health supports.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70385","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of residents of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are deeply concerned about the proposed expansion of medical assistance in dying to individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness.\n\nMy constituents fear that expanding MAID in this way risks normalizing suicide as a response to mental illness. They believe ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7323106b1b23869d328d6f1761ba8e3ee5be5166e21cbab8173ffd5ab4c55f83"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["27462a5609f42733f18d406a397261ab0a7a38d62cdd07496d3451868bfa9d78"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb1fc4ce8b938f71019a44c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70386,"date":"2026-01-28T20:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the third petition I would like to present today is about GST and HST in the context of physical education, specifically dance education, which provides significant physical, mental and emotional health benefits, including improved fitness, self-confidence and resilience, contributing to the overall well-being of Canadians.\n\nThe petitioning Canadians are calling on the Government of Canada to remove GST from instructional dance classes that meet formal educational criteria and align with the existing GST exemption for music instruction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70386","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the third petition I would like to present today is about GST and HST in the context of physical education, specifically dance education, which provides significant physical, mental and emotional health benefits, including improved fitness, self-confidence and resilience, contributing to the overall well-being of Canadians.\n\nThe petitioning Canadians are calling on the Government of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb2231ddd3d2194522528a64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":70403,"date":"2026-01-28T20:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the last petition I would like to present today is on behalf of citizens of Abbotsford, in honour of Darshan Sahsi, who lost his life a few months ago. These residents are calling upon the Government of Canada to reinforce the process of public reporting so Canadians can clearly see how federal, provincial and local governments are working together to prevent further increases in violent and organized crime.\n\nIt is always a pleasure to rise and to present petitions constructively.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-75/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70403","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the last petition I would like to present today is on behalf of citizens of Abbotsford, in honour of Darshan Sahsi, who lost his life a few months ago. These residents are calling upon the Government of Canada to reinforce the process of public reporting so Canadians can clearly see how federal, provincial and local governments are working together to prevent further increases in vi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7eeb2f0abadd914f6c40a86091dbd9dd3c6f551d93f08cf2436f10e84994c134"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33a9409bec7add5e8a8b42f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287760,"date":"2026-02-09T16:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today in good faith and in the spirit of collaboration to get things done, to move Canada forward, and I believe that Bill C-230 can help us do that. Bill C-230 is an act to amend the Financial Administration Act and to make consequential amendments to other acts by establishing a public registry of large debts and obligations that have been waived, written off or forgiven.\n\nAt its heart, this bill is about tax fairness, transparency and respect for the small businesses that form the backbone of our economy. Across Canada, small business owners open their doors every morning knowing that success is never guaranteed. They manage payroll, remit taxes and comply with complex regulatory requirements, often at significant risk. They do so because they believe in our country and believe in a system that is fair, predictable and applied equally. Bill C-230 is about reinforcing that core belief for businesses in Canada.\n\nThe bill would require the President of the Treasury Board to establish and maintain a public, online, searchable registry to disclose information about large debts or obligations, those valued at $1 million or more, owed to the Crown by corporations, trust companies or partnerships where those debts have been waived, written off or forgiven. The registry would include the name of the entity, the amount forgiven, the period to which it relates and the statutory authority under which the debt arose. This is not an exercise in blame or punishment. It is an exercise in accountability.\n\nWhen small businesses fall behind on their tax obligations, the consequences are immediate and visible. Payment plans are negotiated, interest accrues, and enforcement measures are well understood. What has been far less visible, however, is when very large corporate debts, sometimes involving millions of dollars, are forgiven by the federal government. Even when such decisions are justified, the lack of transparency creates a perception of unequal treatment. Bill C-230 would address that gap directly.\n\nBy making large-scale debt forgiveness transparent, it would reassure small businesses that there is no separate, hidden system for the biggest players in the economy. It would send a clear message that extraordinary relief must be accompanied by extraordinary accountability.\n\nImportantly, the bill is carefully designed. It would apply only to large entities and only above a significant monetary threshold. It would not expose personal information, nor would it interfere with legitimate tax administration. The bill would also include targeted, consequential amendments to existing tax and excise statutes to ensure that confidential information may be disclosed solely for the purpose of maintaining the registry. In other words, the disclosure is limited, lawful and purposeful.\n\nFor small businesses, fairness is not about preferential treatment. It is about knowing that everyone plays by the same rules. When a local retailer struggles to meet remittance deadlines while reading headlines about massive corporate writeoffs, confidence in the system erodes. When that same small business owner gets a call from a CRA agent because they are short by a couple of hundred dollars on their last submission in their CRA online account, it sticks with them. Transparency would restore a sense of confidence in Canada.\n\nThis bill would also strengthen fiscal discipline. Public disclosure encourages careful decision-making, ensures that debt forgiven is properly documented and allows Parliament and Canadians to better understand how public funds are managed. Sunlight, as the saying goes, is the best disinfectant. Bill C-230 would not raise taxes. It would not create new penalties. It would simply affirm a basic principle that small businesses already live by every day: Accountability matters.\n\nBy supporting this bill, we stand with the entrepreneurs who keep our communities vibrant, who employ our neighbours and who trust their government will treat them fairly. Bill C-230 tells them that when it comes to tax obligations and debt forgiveness, transparency applies to everyone, especially when the sums involved are large.\n\nFor these reasons, I urge all members of this House to consider supporting Bill C-230 to provide a degree of accountability and confidence in our taxation system.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287760","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today in good faith and in the spirit of collaboration to get things done, to move Canada forward, and I believe that Bill C-230 can help us do that. Bill C-230 is an act to amend the Financial Administration Act and to make consequential amendments to other acts by establishing a public registry of large debts and obligations that have been waived, written off or forgiven.\n\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d3a8a5d3b94cee5f8f6d93327c74d21d354d7b784fffd04fbbb307a2bbb9923"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cae0bef9ceb90a33400430d10c76a0eac146143e7cc82567d5929ef21501e9ef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f3a8a8ff458ea90c41b70482","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287761,"date":"2026-02-09T19:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, small businesses are paying the price for the Prime Minister's economic inaction. In January, 52,000 private sector jobs were lost and $39 billion in investment fled to the United States. Canadian businesses are delaying expansion and workers are losing their livelihoods. The Prime Minister promised the fastest-growing economy in the G7, but growth is flat and not a single anti-development or major regulation has been removed by this government.\n\nWhen will the Prime Minister empower the private sector to build at a scale necessary to protect Canada's economy in the face of American threats?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287761","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, small businesses are paying the price for the Prime Minister's economic inaction. In January, 52,000 private sector jobs were lost and $39 billion in investment fled to the United States. Canadian businesses are delaying expansion and workers are losing their livelihoods. The Prime Minister promised the fastest-growing economy in the G7, but growth is flat and not a single anti-develo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7ae5fbbc143f21321c2b44e21c3aa2e4e0da7801160c8b8a1e363a13b886afe2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e184e5c0071fb8db5b07471850ada68b48688426c99df9b1e211cd06bbb083aa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e2a0ad3eb88a7cf3eddd44b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287762,"date":"2026-02-09T20:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to table a petition on behalf of constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are seeking certainty for funding for the salmon enhancement program beyond the current budget end of March 31. The salmon enhancement program is a great educational tool in the province of B.C. that teaches biology and the salmon cycle to many youth. This program is administered by the Pacific Streamkeepers Federation to provide training to volunteers who protect the aquatic health, habitat status and stock assessments within their communities. They therefore call upon the Government of Canada to reconsider how the $544 million of cuts to DFO are administered, so as not to affect program spending specifically.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287762","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to table a petition on behalf of constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are seeking certainty for funding for the salmon enhancement program beyond the current budget end of March 31. The salmon enhancement program is a great educational tool in the province of B.C. that teaches biology and the salmon cycle to many youth. This program is administered by the Pacifi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a5939597b494e661258cb3860ccc0b6836a715ebe771579b47ed069fed37a53c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5524f3619a18c69581975435f4f6bde75936df7f65d83b340dea2d95feee24f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09788aa1739e668fba5faa51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287763,"date":"2026-02-09T20:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what can Parliament not do that is contained in Bill C-10? My concern with the bill is that it is simply an admonishment that Parliament has not been doing its job holding the executive accountable already.\n\nWhat is to stop the existing standing committee from issuing a report or conducting an audit? Parliament already has these powers. Why do we need another officer of Parliament to do the job of parliamentarians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287763","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what can Parliament not do that is contained in Bill C-10? My concern with the bill is that it is simply an admonishment that Parliament has not been doing its job holding the executive accountable already.\n\nWhat is to stop the existing standing committee from issuing a report or conducting an audit? Parliament already has these powers. Why do we need another officer of Parliament to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0cba75bcc14ffe5b4111de2a0e8b2400bffb42ed9ce699943e160b2e90fbd623"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b690049a95265edd7e32c619","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287764,"date":"2026-02-09T20:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in reference to the debate that just took place, I do not believe the Liberal government has passed very many treaties in the last decade. It is almost as though the Liberals are slapping themselves on the wrist for not doing their job.\n\n Today, I rise to oppose Bill C-10, an act respecting the commissioner for modern treaty implementation. The stated aim of the bill is better accountability in modern treaty implementation. It sounds attractive, but what this bill would really do is create another officer of Parliament and another office, expanding oversight without enforcement, duplication without delivery and bureaucracy without results.\n\n At the heart of this debate is a constitutional first principle. Signing and enacting treaties is the duty of the Crown, of the executive, and not of Parliament. Our core functions in the House are to debate, scrutinize and approve spending, as well as to hold the executive to account. Creating an officer of Parliament to hover over executive treaty work veers away from our legislative remit and blurs lines of responsibility. \n\nThe bill's machinery of appointment, mandate, review, audit and tabling would recast a fundamentally executive obligation as a parliamentary oversight project, which is a category error. Parliament should enforce accountability through votes, questions, committee scrutiny and the public accounts process, not by inventing new officers to monitor what ministers should already execute. The honour of the Crown is upheld by action, not by multiplying overseers.\n\n Modern treaties are not obscure documents. They are transparent, publicly accountable instruments that reconcile aboriginal rights and title with Crown title and give certainty to all parties. They are accessible. Nothing is redacted and they acknowledge one country, one set of laws and management plans designed to benefit everyone. \n\nMy colleague, the MP for Skeena—Bulkley Valley, has noted that modern treaties provide the most transparent and accountable form of reconciliation. Nobody is put at a disadvantage and the final agreements can be accessed and read by anyone. The member from the Haisla Nation would know better than most people in this chamber.\n\n The bill would hand the commissioner discretion to set priorities, conduct reviews and performance audits, issue findings and recommendations, and table final reports in Parliament. It would require coordination with the Auditor General to avoid duplication and provide access to information and immunity provisions, yet nowhere does the bill compel ministers or departments to act when they fail to meet treaty obligations. It would be monitoring without muscle.\n\n For years, the Auditor General has produced reports detailing implementation delays and fragmented responsibilities. The problem has never been insufficient reporting. The problem has been a lack of ministerial responsibility and follow-through. Adding a new office and more reports would not build a single home, deliver clean water or move one project to completion. Accountability requires consequences, not another commissioner.\n\n If we want real progress, we must return to fundamental ministerial responsibility. We should mandate clarity and require the Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations to embed modern treaty implementation milestones in departmental mandates and Treasury Board frameworks, so obligations would not be optional, but operational. We should have routine reporting to Parliament. The minister could proactively report to Parliament during Routine Proceedings, tabling quarterly treaty implementation statements, including what has been met, what has been delayed and how each delay would be fixed, with specific dates and supporting documents. This is how Parliament is supposed to exercise its core function of scrutinizing performance and spending in public.\n\n We can act on audits. When the Auditor General flags failures, the minister should table an action plan, perhaps in 60 days, and committees should hold accountability hearings until commitments are met. There should be consequences for non-performance, tying senior official performance pay to treaty milestones and, where chronic delays persist, changing leadership. Accountability must be felt inside departments, not outsourced to a new office. \n\nMy colleague from the Haisla Nation emphasized that overlap issues among first nations should be worked out between the affected nations and not left to the courts or government to impose solutions. This is real partnership that respects indigenous leadership to resolve boundaries through negotiation rather than litigation. \n\nHe notes that we need to call out the current government for not living up to its obligations to treaty bands that negotiated in good faith and sets out two practical Conservative solutions. Number one is that the government needs to do its job to respect and implement treaties. Number two is that, if a treaty band has an issue with government, it should go to MPs to help its representatives amplify its voice. It should come to Ottawa to hold us accountable for what we are here to do. \n\nThese principles align with a ministerial responsibility model. They empower the parties to solve overlaps, require the minister to remove federal roadblocks, and ensure Parliament has the performance lens to see whether the minister has, in fact, delivered.\n\nMembers can consider the bill's architecture. The commissioner's appointment and tenure mandate is framed around assessing consistency with Crown honour and broad objectives, discretion over reviews and audits, reports tabled by Speakers and referred to committees, annual and special reports, parliamentary reviews within 10 years, independent reviews every five to seven years and consequential amendments adding the office to key statutes. All of this is oversight machinery, but there are no enforcement levers to compel execution of obligations already within our laws.\n\nWe are proliferating process instead of guaranteeing performance. We are not fixing diffusion over responsibility across departments; we are adding a new layer above it. By making an officer of Parliament central to executive treaty functions, we would be subtly shifting accountability away from ministers and towards an umpire whose principal tool would be a report. That is not how we deliver reconciliation.\n\n Canadians are facing real affordability pressures. The answers cannot be to grow administrative overhead while frontline outcomes stall. Dollars should flow to delivery, not duplication. If we need transparency, we can use existing parliamentary tools such as committee mandates, Order Paper questions, supply votes, public accounts and Auditor General follow-ups, so performance and spending are scrutinized where they belong.\n\nThe preamble to Bill C-10 invokes UNDRIP, modern treaties as living documents and the honour of the Crown. Those are important aspirations, but they are realized only when governments do what they have promised, on time and in full, not when we create a new office to monitor yet another delay.\n\n Modern treaties do deliver certainty for indigenous governments, neighbouring communities, investors and private property owners who need predictable rules. This is reconciliation by results, grounded in the rule of law.\n\nConservatives, of course, support modern treaties and indigenous communities seeking to move beyond the paternalistic Indian Act. We will oppose Bill C-10 because it confuses monitoring for delivery. Conservatives will insist on ministerial responsibility, acting on audits and the respect of a practical approach, one that leads to real results.\n\nThe honour of the Crown is not measured by the number of commissioners we appoint; it is measured by promises kept. Modern treaties deserve execution, not another report. For these reasons, I will vote against this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287764","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in reference to the debate that just took place, I do not believe the Liberal government has passed very many treaties in the last decade. It is almost as though the Liberals are slapping themselves on the wrist for not doing their job.\n\n Today, I rise to oppose Bill C-10, an act respecting the commissioner for modern treaty implementation. The stated aim of the bill is better account","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["42d24d0645c7d90e4398032e781f0c053b0e63669b7a73d37f80a60bb744ef72"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3cea897cf95977035b0e8ba99b58d9c7b6a24da61fb82ca13a992308b58e1d38"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30b0bede75aa7a6938cb95ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287765,"date":"2026-02-09T21:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will note, as I did in my speech, that there are many reports from the Auditor General outlining the issues we have had with implementing treaty rights for indigenous peoples of Canada. They have never been followed through on.\n\nThe argument I was making throughout my speech is that we do not actually enforce the mandate of the executive of the Crown to fulfill treaty obligations. I do not believe another officer of Parliament would lead us to better objectives.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287765","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will note, as I did in my speech, that there are many reports from the Auditor General outlining the issues we have had with implementing treaty rights for indigenous peoples of Canada. They have never been followed through on.\n\nThe argument I was making throughout my speech is that we do not actually enforce the mandate of the executive of the Crown to fulfill treaty obligations. I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b0e803996721ebd0b8d51b8e3ffdb0a15db57c5284cf12801967ad42f434c0c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["af1ca12a5294fb648ce67f8b15d1e707e99e76a1297d99c2baf1104d3a12ee86"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7472d9319ce86891bc130934","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287766,"date":"2026-02-09T21:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what lies behind my opposition to this is that we, as individual members of Parliament, have so much more power than I think almost any of us even attempt to exercise. If this bill is successful, all the powers outlined in Bill C-10 for the actions of the commissioner, the officer of Parliament, would be for what we as members of Parliament already can do. \n\nIf we care about seeing treaties operationalize, and in the context of British Columbia this is so important right now, first and foremost we have to devote ourselves as MPS to holding the minister accountable. We can do that through the tools we have already. It is up to us, the elected people. We should not dismiss our responsibilities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287766","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what lies behind my opposition to this is that we, as individual members of Parliament, have so much more power than I think almost any of us even attempt to exercise. If this bill is successful, all the powers outlined in Bill C-10 for the actions of the commissioner, the officer of Parliament, would be for what we as members of Parliament already can do. \n\nIf we care about seeing tr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f803dfdb8f898c41763cdf3f01afd7da5c7d193ad3bce6b6014302efe8c86903"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b19ece4ea4afc977e7c66562","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287767,"date":"2026-02-09T21:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I wish I were standing here today and the Minister of Indigenous Services was before Parliament saying that they had signed multiple treaties that were going to empower young indigenous Canadians to start businesses, have access to their resources and have better certainty for home ownership. However, we are not there, and we have not seen any of that in the last decade. That is unfortunate. \n\nI do not believe in establishing another officer of Parliament because it will lead to more red tape. Again, in the last 10 years, there have been no treaties signed. Why not? Where has the minister been? The minister has not done their job.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287767","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I wish I were standing here today and the Minister of Indigenous Services was before Parliament saying that they had signed multiple treaties that were going to empower young indigenous Canadians to start businesses, have access to their resources and have better certainty for home ownership. However, we are not there, and we have not seen any of that in the last decade. That is unfor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3fc312fd615efc6dd224e253d1c9172910abc4f1a40ea5eb00ddc8bf5353cbf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2738f5229b75a8821165e848045e5f3f1673cc0b06336a466715065382227edd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1fb735e4542521cbe8472026","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287768,"date":"2026-02-09T21:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I oppose the establishment of another officer of Parliament because it would degrade the work we should be doing as members of Parliament and would not take concrete action to hold the minister accountable for their responsibilities to sign treaties. There is no consequence for not signing treaties in this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287768","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I oppose the establishment of another officer of Parliament because it would degrade the work we should be doing as members of Parliament and would not take concrete action to hold the minister accountable for their responsibilities to sign treaties. There is no consequence for not signing treaties in this bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac764260a3a4b4a4857774b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287752,"date":"2026-02-10T15:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise on behalf of the residents of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford regarding the gun confiscation program, which will cost Canadian taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars. They feel it unfairly targets law-abiding, responsible and licensed gun owners, while doing nothing to address public safety and rising crime rates.\n\n The Parliamentary Budget Officer estimates that the cost to compensate firearms owners alone will exceed $750 million. Even the public safety minister has serious doubts as to the effectiveness of the program, as do police jurisdictions across Canada.\n\nThe petitioning residents call upon the Government of Canada to immediately rescind the program and prioritize public safety with real change such as bail reform.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287752","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise on behalf of the residents of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford regarding the gun confiscation program, which will cost Canadian taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars. They feel it unfairly targets law-abiding, responsible and licensed gun owners, while doing nothing to address public safety and rising crime rates.\n\n The Parliamentary Budget Officer estimates that the cost t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["51a04b3ff7ccd36cff17c16f008cde50709748351952173685cc1df9eca7bb3d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a6e7c6867a21cd33922ab45","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287753,"date":"2026-02-10T19:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is facing a surge in violent extortion that is shaking communities across the country. Families and small business owners in my own community are living with a level of fear they have never known before.\n\nExtortion has risen by 330% since the Liberals were elected. In British Columbia it has climbed more than 480%. In B.C., 14 accused extortionists have paused removal by claiming refugee status, exposing the blatant abuse of our asylum system.\n\nCanadians deserve to feel safe in their home, on their streets and in their place of work. We owe it to them to strengthen protections and to ensure that violent offenders face meaningful consequences. This is why our Conservative motion demands that the government close loopholes exploited by serious offenders, repeal Bill C-5 and Bill C-75, end repeat offender cycles and ensure that violent criminals cannot use the system to delay or avoid removal from Canada. We also refuse to let the Liberals play politics with the safety and security of Canadians any longer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287753","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada is facing a surge in violent extortion that is shaking communities across the country. Families and small business owners in my own community are living with a level of fear they have never known before.\n\nExtortion has risen by 330% since the Liberals were elected. In British Columbia it has climbed more than 480%. In B.C., 14 accused extortionists have paused removal by claimi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f3efd50562100848a6087716864060df51e850598effcda839c25ed335dc3573"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e403b2150fce09f5646e7785b07d4a60234e6bede6ffdd40014c2cf262e5f6ac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6220a630602ef683f7f9b36","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287754,"date":"2026-02-10T20:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is a lot of hot air in the chamber this afternoon. We have not heard the member for St. Catharines lose his mind for quite some time. I am actually quite disturbed by what I heard and how much anger and confusion he seems to have as an individual member. I can see why the Liberals have not let him speak for quite a while. That was just an egregious example of what a member of Parliament should not be doing—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287754","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is a lot of hot air in the chamber this afternoon. We have not heard the member for St. Catharines lose his mind for quite some time. I am actually quite disturbed by what I heard and how much anger and confusion he seems to have as an individual member. I can see why the Liberals have not let him speak for quite a while. That was just an egregious example of what a member of Pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","label":"Weather","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0384e190c0fae523e923e6acab05916e74c3e92453fa6546b170c7f251e3ecfa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d842e2bec318f935d44db7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287755,"date":"2026-02-10T20:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, obviously the member for St. Catharines is very disturbed. Maybe he needs a cup of coffee. I am surprised the Liberals let him speak today. Normally, it is only the member for Winnipeg North. I feel bad for him. In respect—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287755","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, obviously the member for St. Catharines is very disturbed. Maybe he needs a cup of coffee. I am surprised the Liberals let him speak today. Normally, it is only the member for Winnipeg North. I feel bad for him. In respect—\n\nSome hon. members: Oh, oh!","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62f57fd18e9ed58fab97f62c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287756,"date":"2026-02-10T20:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in response to the member for Richmond East—Steveston, who spoke earlier, I would just like to clarify some comments on Bill C-16 that I heard in the House. Bill C-16 would not change the offence of extortion itself and would not create any new mandatory minimum sentences for extortion. It would add extortion as an explicit aggravating factor. It would not redefine extortion. It would not increase the maximum penalty for extortion. It would not add a new mandatory minimum for extortion, and it would not create any new stand-alone offences for extortion either. I just wanted to clarify those points for the House of Commons before I began.\n\nThe reason we are here today with another opposition day motion is that the Liberals told us we needed to have one today. They allotted one of our supply days early on because they would rather push forward their new agenda, to say we are delaying things in the House of Commons, before the Prime Minister likely calls a spring election. That is what is taking place today. The government controls the House calendar. We heard the rhetoric from the member for St. Catharines, with his anger and confusion, but we are only here today because the Liberals did not want to talk about their own bills, full stop.\n\nI rise in support of what we are talking about today. The safety of our communities is the first duty of a free and just society. Unfortunately, the Liberals forgot that for 10 years. The foremost responsibility of any government is to protect law-abiding citizens. Across British Columbia, and across Canada, that responsibility is being tested with increasing urgency. Recent data and public warnings point to a troubling rise in organized extortion and related criminal activity, while the response required to confront this threat has too often been delayed. For too long, policies that weaken consequences for serious crime and blur the integrity of our immigration system have eroded public confidence in safety and justice.\n\nAfter nearly a decade, Canadians are asking a fundamental question: Why do criminals feel more confident, while communities feel more vulnerable? From small business owners and construction workers to truck drivers and young families, ordinary Canadians are facing intimidation that disrupts their livelihoods and undermines stability. In places like Abbotsford, threatening extortion letters have unsettled entire neighbourhoods and placed growing strain on local police. These are the lived realities of Canadians who seek nothing more than to work, raise their families and live in peace.\n\nSince the Liberals took office nearly 10 years ago, violent crime has increased by 54% and extortion is up 330%. This is not a marginal increase. This is a systemic failure. Again, the member for St. Catharines talked about decreasing crime. Well, guess what. The cities of Surrey and Abbotsford in British Columbia, just in the last year, have had to create many special task forces to deal with the problem at hand here today. The reason is that the Liberal government failed to act, full stop.\n\nLess than a month ago, police investigated an extortion-related shooting that damaged a local business and nearby vehicles. This was part of a series that included 34 reported threats, 21 victims and seven shots-fired calls in just 19 days. Law-abiding Canadians must be able to trust that crime will be met with firm and proportionate consequences. Instead, serious crime is too often met with delay, leniency and the absence of real consequences.\n\nMore than a year ago, I sponsored legislation in the House through Bill C-381, the protection against extortion act. This legislation would have delivered real jail time for serious offences, stronger penalties for organized crime involvement and a clear denunciation of extortion as a violent and coercive crime. The government, the Liberals, voted against it.\n\nToday, police in British Columbia report that they are overwhelmed, arresting the same offenders again and again. Communities are left to deal with the fallout. Business owners are left to fend for themselves. Victims are left asking whether the justice system in fact works for them. This is the direct result of Liberal catch-and-release laws, weak sentencing and revolving-door bail policies that are enabling repeat offenders to return to the streets, placing families, workers and businesses at risk.\n\nOur motion today also addresses the government's refusal to repeal Bill C-5 and Bill C-75, laws that have weakened consequences for serious and repeat offenders. We mention those laws again because their consequences will even touch on the legislation in this chamber and the impact of what the Liberals say it is going to do.\n\nBill C-5 removed mandatory prison sentences for serious firearm-related crimes, including extortion involving a weapon. Bill C-75 entrenched a principle of restraint in bail decisions that too often results in repeat violent offenders being released back into the community while awaiting trial. It is not every day that every single premier in the country stands against an action by a standing government. They did on that law. They did it because what the government did was so egregious that every premier, New Democrat, Liberal and Conservative, agreed that the government had failed badly and eroded any sense of justice in this nation.\n\n In British Columbia, police have raised new concerns about transnational crime networks, some involving individuals with no legal right to remain in Canada. Allowing extortionists to hide behind asylum claims undermines public confidence and endangers communities, including immigrant communities, who are often targeted first.\n\n Conservatives believe deeply in protecting genuine refugees, those fleeing persecution and violence, but when violent criminals can claim refugee status to delay deportation, something has to change. That is why last November, Conservatives proposed an amendment to Bill C-12 that would have updated the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act to bar asylum claims from being made by those who had been convicted of serious crimes in Canada. The Liberals rejected it, and nothing has changed.\n\nThis motion reflects exactly what Conservatives have promised Canadians: to bar non-citizens convicted of serious crimes from making refugee claims, bar non-citizens facing serious criminal proceedings from making refugee claims, end leniency that allows criminals to avoid deportation, and repeal Bill C-5 and Bill C-75 so repeat extortionists stay in jail. These measures are fair, lawful and absolutely necessary. They would protect victims, newcomers and communities alike, and they would restore a sense of justice in our country.\n\n The issue before us is not complicated. It comes down to a simple question: Will Parliament stand with victims or with the loopholes that protect criminals? The choice before the House is clear.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287756","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in response to the member for Richmond East—Steveston, who spoke earlier, I would just like to clarify some comments on Bill C-16 that I heard in the House. Bill C-16 would not change the offence of extortion itself and would not create any new mandatory minimum sentences for extortion. It would add extortion as an explicit aggravating factor. It would not redefine extortion. It would","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["37113a019d5107a713c9cbe73eb141cb03603723e13aa5a3398fa746a386421d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0c9d2d6c9f6c630d9805d3ee16d311110cdb02ca01d71e5cfbfe2b495912290c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64e19d650cafc265253620e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287757,"date":"2026-02-10T20:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we have already had the debate in this chamber between Bill C-2 and Bill C-12 in good faith. The Liberals' attempt to bring up another issue that was not related to their election platform in the amendments they made in Bill C-9 disrupted a lot of good work that we could have done collaboratively on behalf of Canadians. Instead, when it was right before Christmas, in December, the Liberals chose not to work with us and to put a wrench in the notion of what freedom of religion means in Canada, when we could have been debating these issues in more detail.\n\nWhat police also need and what they have been calling for are additional resources and for the Liberals to make sure there are no judicial vacancies.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287757","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we have already had the debate in this chamber between Bill C-2 and Bill C-12 in good faith. The Liberals' attempt to bring up another issue that was not related to their election platform in the amendments they made in Bill C-9 disrupted a lot of good work that we could have done collaboratively on behalf of Canadians. Instead, when it was right before Christmas, in December, the Lib","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e3b7ffd1099863fe548242717842450a2685b10e29b4f08ec5593de975a13a7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a5fca5d7c6a52b3bf14946425a39134a49338392d1d146fc0ca62d71e1551e9c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f0789b978ca39aab57e2dca3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287758,"date":"2026-02-10T20:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when our institutions work as they should, people feel safer, victims know where to turn, investigations can move forward, and communities can stand strong in the face of intimidation and violence. Unfortunately, due to the changes Liberals have made over the last 10 years, that is not the case in Canada right now. We know what we need to do. The motion before us today is a step in the right direction. We want the Liberal government to work collaboratively with us and to stop putting its politics ahead of public safety in Canada. We need better from the government. It is not doing a good enough job to protect Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287758","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when our institutions work as they should, people feel safer, victims know where to turn, investigations can move forward, and communities can stand strong in the face of intimidation and violence. Unfortunately, due to the changes Liberals have made over the last 10 years, that is not the case in Canada right now. We know what we need to do. The motion before us today is a step in th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ec2ec301a8a2328b34651e96ce643adfd2241a40c8732ea730d69e3d2d1c549"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-acc977de0de0485723b38071","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287759,"date":"2026-02-10T20:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, all I have to say in response to the member for Winnipeg North is that it is time for the Liberals to stop playing politics with the lives and security of Canadians. I will offer him the opportunity to clarify his earlier statements on Bill C-16 and how he misled Canadians with his false statements on what is included in that legislation. I will take no lessons from the member. \n\nAgain, the Liberals need to work constructively with Conservatives, to vote for bills and laws and support motions that are going to put the safety and security of Canadians first. We have not seen that from the government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287759","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, all I have to say in response to the member for Winnipeg North is that it is time for the Liberals to stop playing politics with the lives and security of Canadians. I will offer him the opportunity to clarify his earlier statements on Bill C-16 and how he misled Canadians with his false statements on what is included in that legislation. I will take no lessons from the member. \n\nAgai","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c65406d541d8d2515eab66084f70b204008426929ac53457718c83d55f105e0b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed511037608c57f96b5f1744","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315001,"date":"2026-02-23T17:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, my question is very simple. Why would the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure think it responsible to develop a new government agency, with the use of taxpayer dollars, without set targets and timelines to outline to Canadians how many homes would actually be built?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315001","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, my question is very simple. Why would the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure think it responsible to develop a new government agency, with the use of taxpayer dollars, without set targets and timelines to outline to Canadians how many homes would actually be built?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9cb5066c79608eae51bc09946740fed22aa694d8fa67648a02512512630e1988"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-acf7fa28254e9d879cd84b23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315002,"date":"2026-02-23T20:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table a petition on behalf of constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are deeply concerned about the proposed expansion of medical assistance in dying to individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness. My constituents fear that expanding MAID in this way risks normalizing suicide as a response to mental illness. They believe instead that Canada should prioritize and strengthen mental health supports for those who are suffering. They therefore call on the government to support Bill C-218 and halt the expansion of MAID to those with a mental illness.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315002","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table a petition on behalf of constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are deeply concerned about the proposed expansion of medical assistance in dying to individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness. My constituents fear that expanding MAID in this way risks normalizing suicide as a response to mental illness. They believe instead that Canada should","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3607ba18b5affd0e0efd0cd59798ea8bbfc4584681499d57b1f7bf8b42b9bffa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["551c07ea1f3444aeea367e57ac93f4c8e4335a4c5e6d14e7b8cc531b040d9955"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e3542b7441a17cdcd6f5896","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":315003,"date":"2026-02-23T23:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always amusing listening to the speeches by the member for St. Catharines.\n\nIn 2015, in the Niagara Region, the average cost of a home was about $270,000. Today, it is about $600,000. The same experts that the member referenced, and I will acknowledge they are experts and do a lot of great work in our community, also endorsed the plan in 2015 that was supposed to make housing affordable across Canada. The reality is that after 10 years of Liberal government, every viable metric on housing has only gotten worse. \n\nWhy should we give the Liberals any more confidence to address this crisis, which has hurt hundreds of thousands of young people and destroyed what their concept of Canada was because of the Liberals' bad policies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-87/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:315003","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always amusing listening to the speeches by the member for St. Catharines.\n\nIn 2015, in the Niagara Region, the average cost of a home was about $270,000. Today, it is about $600,000. The same experts that the member referenced, and I will acknowledge they are experts and do a lot of great work in our community, also endorsed the plan in 2015 that was supposed to make housing af","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5edd08fd146f1259c1cf53778b9bfdac8d6e10fdd694ba0a98e797264c8a64c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6210ab9407553c25f0598fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306836,"date":"2026-02-24T15:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a petition on behalf of constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are deeply concerned about proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy, which would decimate recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia.\n\nRecreational fishers fully recognize conservation and first nations' constitutionally protected food, social, ceremonial and commercial fisheries. For generations, salmon have been managed by the government as a common property resource held in trust for the benefit of all Canadians. Changing this common property principle risks turning a shared public resource into an exclusive privilege that would reduce access for many Canadians and undermine confidence in fisheries management. Petitioners note that it would be devastating to our tourism economy and the millions of dollars that flow into conservation efforts. Constituents are calling on the Minister of Fisheries to leave current salmon allocation policies alone and uphold the cultural rights and traditions of all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306836","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a petition on behalf of constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are deeply concerned about proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy, which would decimate recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia.\n\nRecreational fishers fully recognize conservation and first nations' constitutionally protected food, social, ceremonial and co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["732de796fdff2dc0353aa6dc6523aa3770061ba92effbd7b092a9b6b1e796ef3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0785c43b95b608203827668cc20598895b31dd9049064c9c9a2d7f82a3ff394c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ed413d7cd1df08d6c95bd77","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306835,"date":"2026-02-25T19:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have created an immigration crisis that is straining housing, health care and jobs. As of January, non-permanent residents outnumbered unemployed Canadians, and the Liberals are expanding immigration streams that push our young people further away from employment.\n\n Six million Canadians cannot find a family doctor, but taxpayers are now spending $1 billion per year to cover the health care costs of refugee claimants, and the government has no clear plan for the nearly three million temporary residents whose permits are expiring this year.\n\n Canadians deserve a competent immigration minister. The immigration minister's own caucus is not confident in her ability to handle these out-of-control problems.\n\n It is time for decisive action. Only with strong leadership can we protect Canadians, prioritize jobs for our youth and secure a sustainable future for our country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306835","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have created an immigration crisis that is straining housing, health care and jobs. As of January, non-permanent residents outnumbered unemployed Canadians, and the Liberals are expanding immigration streams that push our young people further away from employment.\n\n Six million Canadians cannot find a family doctor, but taxpayers are now spending $1 billion per year to co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9350f6e108fcf85dc94f1565f1540d7422f743d02f3c9a3b93198be3639b2f1b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["714d199a07878f705065cf2c0fef475cbe639e003735a539f8870fe2411bcaaf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-566295d03a10b8ce9252dee7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336024,"date":"2026-03-09T20:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, petitioners in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford are concerned about the recreational fishery, specifically related to coho and chinook. They are imploring the Minister of Fisheries to listen to both Conservatives and Liberals, scrap her policy proposal and maintain recreational access for all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336024","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, petitioners in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford are concerned about the recreational fishery, specifically related to coho and chinook. They are imploring the Minister of Fisheries to listen to both Conservatives and Liberals, scrap her policy proposal and maintain recreational access for all British Columbians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1d883db117f18dec30aa02e6432cf1ae7932d4d5769b5041456adbb3ff28a52d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c2edc374f776d6a5d27b148628285c64f20074829d8be075dbb5d3ea624678f7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1fc1a0be18bfe344948ff052","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336020,"date":"2026-03-10T15:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, petitioners in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford are concerned about Bill C-9, which would amend the Criminal Code to address hate propaganda and hate crimes. The Liberals are proposing an amendment to remove the religious exemption from the Criminal Code that protects good faith expressions of beliefs based on religious texts.\n\n Therefore, the petitioners and permanent residents of Canada call upon the Government of Canada to reject any amendment to Bill C-9 that would remove the religious exemption from Canada's hate speech provisions, to protect Canada's constitutional rights to freedom of religion and expression and ensure that legislation does not criminalize good faith, religious discourse or teaching.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336020","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, petitioners in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford are concerned about Bill C-9, which would amend the Criminal Code to address hate propaganda and hate crimes. The Liberals are proposing an amendment to remove the religious exemption from the Criminal Code that protects good faith expressions of beliefs based on religious texts.\n\n Therefore, the petitioners and permanent residents of Canada c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35644f201e99318a9beb47d58f6874ca4860d1137cf3e5275635fc27f347231a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d14074aefecdd40cb6d225a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336021,"date":"2026-03-10T15:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like the minister to acknowledge today that by including the removal of the religious defence clause, his actions have actually sown more fear and division in Canadian society. This was a bill on which there was broad consensus when it was first brought forward. With the inclusion of the removal of the religious defence clause, he has diminished public support for the position he is taking.\n\nWill he acknowledge that this amendment will cause more division and fear among religious communities, especially in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford, which is one of the most faith-based ridings in all of Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336021","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like the minister to acknowledge today that by including the removal of the religious defence clause, his actions have actually sown more fear and division in Canadian society. This was a bill on which there was broad consensus when it was first brought forward. With the inclusion of the removal of the religious defence clause, he has diminished public support for the position","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8f1d70e4c50ccf0d7a3447cab6017578979284506a2a133987318c4311bc23cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8c16602fbf27ce7c6d6470aa0070fe4aa9336c86242551211eee6ae3b7c3ce1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7a3500d9db169ddec137d7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336022,"date":"2026-03-10T19:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, despite the Prime Minister's promising to eliminate all federal barriers to interprovincial trade by Canada Day 2025, that promise has proven to be an illusion. In many cases, it is still easier for British Columbian distilleries to sell their products to Washington state than to Nova Scotia.\n\n Can the Prime Minister provide a specific date when it will be easier for British Columbian distillers to sell in Canada versus in the United States?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336022","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, despite the Prime Minister's promising to eliminate all federal barriers to interprovincial trade by Canada Day 2025, that promise has proven to be an illusion. In many cases, it is still easier for British Columbian distilleries to sell their products to Washington state than to Nova Scotia.\n\n Can the Prime Minister provide a specific date when it will be easier for British Columbian","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b34e5dc21a70feedbdf00d95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336023,"date":"2026-03-10T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the problem is that the Liberal government misled Canadians when it made the promise that interprovincial trade barriers would actually be eliminated in Canada by 2025. The CBC reported in January that interprovincial trade is still like a 9% tariff on the Canadian economy, accounting for $210 billion of lost goods.\n\n I will ask the question again. Can the Prime Minister provide a specific date, not just when alcohol will be free to trade but when all services and goods will be free to trade in Canada among provinces to build our country up?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336023","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the problem is that the Liberal government misled Canadians when it made the promise that interprovincial trade barriers would actually be eliminated in Canada by 2025. The CBC reported in January that interprovincial trade is still like a 9% tariff on the Canadian economy, accounting for $210 billion of lost goods.\n\n I will ask the question again. Can the Prime Minister provide a spe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8045425c2a1bc010b65c4a3247f183bd75c49222da1b3cb8a7a16b109fb7684b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a3edab6c4fc86076644a650bb51504ec72c80d0012cb36bce8aae5e8f2b92bb8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2eea90d700287396b2ec026b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336018,"date":"2026-03-11T20:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to table a petition today on behalf of the Mission Self Advocacy Group. Its members state that Canadians with disabilities face disproportionately high rates of poverty, and existing federal income supports, including the Canada disability benefit at $200 per month, are insufficient to meet basic living costs. Individuals with permanent and lifelong disabilities such as cerebral palsy are required to repeatedly reapply for benefits, creating unnecessary administrative burdens, delays and stress with little or no public benefit. Reducing unnecessary administrative barriers would improve accessibility, efficiency and fairness, while ensuring federal programs serve their intended purpose.\n\nTherefore, the signatories of this petition call upon the Government of Canada to increase the Canada disability benefit to $500 per month, to implement a one-time application process for individuals with permanent disabilities and to significantly reduce administrative and paperwork requirements associated with the Canada disability benefit so that essential supports are accessible, dignified and effective for Canadian citizens and permanent residents.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336018","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to table a petition today on behalf of the Mission Self Advocacy Group. Its members state that Canadians with disabilities face disproportionately high rates of poverty, and existing federal income supports, including the Canada disability benefit at $200 per month, are insufficient to meet basic living costs. Individuals with permanent and lifelong disabilities such as ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["800803b6b95dc2a8c2864c592641f89ebd86d0ecc1f629b5b7d7ccc5143d0ec4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8750ab7b2a0b176dd130f4f0c39429e4b8b0524e1bd88f762175e07c72870c8a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-468ca5ac36f1cb09236939f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336019,"date":"2026-03-11T20:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of the streamkeepers on the Miami River in Harrison Hot Springs. Streamkeepers throughout the province of British Columbia are committed volunteers who deserve certainty for funding and support from the salmon enhancement program beyond the current budget end of March 31, 2026. The salmon enhancement program collaborates with the Pacific Streamkeepers Federation on training that ensures that community volunteers are able to protect and improve aquatic health, habitat status, land use and stock assessment within their communities. \n\nTherefore, the petitioners are calling upon the Government of Canada to not cut program funding for the salmon enhancement programs across British Columbia, which educate thousands of young people on salmon habitat and life cycles.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336019","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of the streamkeepers on the Miami River in Harrison Hot Springs. Streamkeepers throughout the province of British Columbia are committed volunteers who deserve certainty for funding and support from the salmon enhancement program beyond the current budget end of March 31, 2026. The salmon enhancement program collaborates w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a0d604769718404e08182a2354d7b7f0b1c222c4503702c97a140393200a1267"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06b7f4cf80195e3eecf0021c8a2ca10026791f1f602f07c6076cdc847e0e096e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcacf260eac5744309cfc938","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336013,"date":"2026-03-12T16:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I listened intently to the member for Winnipeg North speak about the Canadian pork industry. I think he raises some valid points, but unfortunately he left out the real and pressing issues that Canada has with the United Kingdom as they relate to non-tariff and trade irritants specifically for the exportation of pork.\n\nThe Library of Parliament outlines that Britain exported 5.6 million dollars' worth of pork to Canada in 2023, 9.1 million dollars' worth in 2024, and 3.6 million dollars' worth in the first half of 2025. Meanwhile, Canada exported no pork to the U.K. in 2023, 75,000 dollars' worth in 2024 and only 122,000 dollars' worth in 2025.\n\n The Canadian Pork Council outlines that the reasons it cannot export to the U.K. are trichinosis testing and animal production and processing rules that prevent the great pork producers in the member's riding and across the province of Manitoba from doing so.\n\nWhy did the Prime Minister not use this opportunity to remove those trade irritants and include them in Bill C-13 so Canadian pork producers in Manitoba could sell more product on the international market?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336013","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I listened intently to the member for Winnipeg North speak about the Canadian pork industry. I think he raises some valid points, but unfortunately he left out the real and pressing issues that Canada has with the United Kingdom as they relate to non-tariff and trade irritants specifically for the exportation of pork.\n\nThe Library of Parliament outlines that Britain exported 5.6 mil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722814","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722814","label":"Animal inspection","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["471e751687f7299d96b9d6921dab9e9c58c8e43c5880e0e128041e5116be4e17"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8957a19c4d657efcbd4893b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336014,"date":"2026-03-12T16:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to build on my colleague's excellent speech. The Prime Minister has spent a great deal of time travelling abroad, signing memorandums of understanding and participating in high-profile international events. While international engagement certainly plays an important role in advancing Canada's interests, it cannot come at the expense of the pressing priorities we face here at home. Canadians are looking for leadership that is grounded, focused, and attentive to the challenges facing families, workers and entrepreneurs across this country, but right now they are not seeing it.\n\n Our trade agenda is only as strong as our domestic economy. The reality is simple: No agreement abroad will fix Canada's outdated tax system. No foreign handshake or high-level summit will modernize our regulatory structures. None of these trips will improve the service delivery of our public institutions, increase the personnel of our military or update our privacy and intellectual property laws to reflect a rapidly changing global environment. These are the tasks that require committed national leadership, leadership that begins here, not on the international conference circuit.\n\n On October 22, 2025, the Prime Minister announced in Ottawa an ambitious goal: to double Canada's non-U.S. exports over the next decade. Conservatives take that objective seriously. We worked constructively with the government and granted the Liberals unprecedented authorities under Bill C-5, the One Canadian Economy Act, to empower the government to pursue those ambitions. We believe that if the government were prepared to act boldly, we could collectively position Canada for long-term economic strength, but a year has passed, and the patience of Canadian entrepreneurs is wearing thin.\n\n Consider the economic picture before us. Over the last decade under the Liberals, approximately $500 billion in foreign capital has left Canada. This is not an abstract figure. It represents lost opportunity, lost productivity and lost confidence in Canada's economic direction. Investment that could have helped build industries, create jobs and support innovation has instead gone elsewhere, to countries like Ireland, where the Prime Minister has citizenship. Ireland has robust foreign direct investment through a modern taxation system.\n\nAt the same time, according to the Business Development Bank of Canada, Canada today has 100,000 fewer entrepreneurs than we did 10 years ago, even though our population has grown by 10 million. This is a staggering shift. It means fewer new businesses, fewer new ideas and fewer pathways for economic growth. For a country built on ambition, creativity and enterprise, this decline should ring alarm bells for every policy-maker in Ottawa, but is not being talked about.\n\n Canada's economic challenges will not be solved through symbolism abroad or even by Bill C-13, but through practical action here at home. Therefore, if the Prime Minister is truly committed to strengthening Canada's economy, here is what I believe he must do right now.\n\n First, we need to reform Canada's tax system. We need a system that rewards effort, investment and innovation rather than penalizes them. Entrepreneurs must see Canada as a place where risk-taking is supported and where success is not met with punitive tax burdens. That means revisiting profit-sharing models, capital gains rules and the taxation environment for start-ups so talented Canadians can build their ideas into thriving enterprises that scale up in Canada.\n\nSecond, the Prime Minister should work with the Conservatives to repeal anti-energy laws that have contributed to pushing investment out of this country. He knows these policies are not working. They have created uncertainty, discouraged development and weakened one of Canada's greatest competitive advantages. It is time to scrap them, not go over them and leave them in place, in order to reverse the capital outflow we are seeing. Yesterday I was pleased to support a private member's bill from the member for Calgary Signal Hill to do exactly that by removing the moratorium on oil tankers in British Columbia.\n\nThird, we must move away from the government's habit of picking economic winners and losers. The Minister of Finance's experiment with large production subsidies for automakers has not delivered the results Canadians expected. We were promised a thriving auto industry less than two years ago in the House. This example should stand for all Canadians that big subsidies to big corporations do not result in better jobs for Canadian workers and families.\n\nFourth, we need to reform service delivery within the public service. The public service has grown exponentially, but we are not seeing the necessary results. We have to do that work.\n\nFifth, the government must outline and commit to essential infrastructure upgrades. The ports in British Columbia are wonderful. We love them. However, they are not performing at their capacity. We lack the strategic infrastructure investments across Canada to move people and goods in a way that is commensurate with a G7 economy. We have to grow up and get that work done.\n\nThe sixth thing is very important. The Prime Minister should dedicate as much time to engaging with first nations leaders here at home as he does with world leaders abroad. Why do I say that? The Supreme Court of Canada has made many rulings in the last number of years outlining the rights and titles of first nations. For economic reconciliation at large to take place, we have to look at new models of engaging with our first nations.\n\nI believe in a Canada where first nations people on reserve are all millionaires, have more economic potential and economic drive than the average Canadian and are pushing new projects in rural Canada that are lifting up Canada's economy and contributing to our GDP in ways we never thought imaginable. The Prime Minister has a social license to do that right now, but he prefers to go on international trips than to engage with Canadians here at home.\n\nOn that point, seventh is that in B.C. we are facing some real and significant challenges on private property and fee simple land. B.C. is the gateway to doubling our exports abroad. If the Prime Minister does not take seriously the concerns of everyday British Columbians on ensuring that fee simple land and private property are essential to Canada's economy, people will continue to move their money outside British Columbia. We will not see the strategic mineral reserves developed nor exports grow; we will see the opposite. He has to be on top of this file. We cannot live in a society where private property is not protected, but this is the number one issue coming up in B.C. right now.\n\nFinally, we must improve Canada's intellectual property laws and privacy laws. We are outdated, not modern, and it is hurting our entrepreneurs. We have to do better. The Minister of Industry needs to bring forward the requisite legislation to improve things like open banking, to ensure that children are protected on the Internet, and to ensure that we are giving our tech companies the biggest bang for their buck if they decide to stay in Canada.\n\nDespite the challenges we face, Canada's potential is extraordinary. We are blessed with abundant resources like no other nation on earth is, but we are squandering a critical period in time when we could be doing so much more. By refocusing on the fundamentals, prioritizing economic growth at home and making the structural reforms to our economy that we can do only in the chamber, we can restore some confidence in Canada's economy, bring 100,000 entrepreneurs back into Canadian society and reverse the outflow of foreign direct investment. None of these trade deals will matter if we do not get our economic house in order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336014","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to build on my colleague's excellent speech. The Prime Minister has spent a great deal of time travelling abroad, signing memorandums of understanding and participating in high-profile international events. While international engagement certainly plays an important role in advancing Canada's interests, it cannot come at the expense of the pressing priorities we face here at ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73d20e7f822255c64b34e4fc2542ee3b5487ad740aefabf9438f6a157f138f69"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["608e700bb6a5f4681614f4f8546fd28a8a93d9df23129ec7dc44491f08e0e696"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3e1de91ac2465eaa45c7ed1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336015,"date":"2026-03-12T16:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member for Québec Centre's question was a great one. In fact, I think he is a great member of Parliament. I wish he were still in cabinet, because I believe he could make some real reforms for the public service that are not taking place under the Treasury Board Secretariat right now.\n\nI will address the member's point. What I was outlining in my speech is that we are not focusing on the economic fundamentals here in Canada. We can sign whatever MOU or strategic partnership we want, but if we do not reform our taxation system and if we do not get our rules on energy development modernized, all that work abroad means nothing. If we do not have our economic house in order, we are failing as a nation. That is why I am encouraging the Prime Minister today to stay at home and to work on the economic fundamentals. He should not try to be a puppeteer but should roll up his sleeves and operationalize everything Canadians want right now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336015","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member for Québec Centre's question was a great one. In fact, I think he is a great member of Parliament. I wish he were still in cabinet, because I believe he could make some real reforms for the public service that are not taking place under the Treasury Board Secretariat right now.\n\nI will address the member's point. What I was outlining in my speech is that we are not focusi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cba471b05496c032a5589a4c3c98313054c7eebb008969eb1f4194d7a8221c18"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["83239dc11b3f3d02b47ae8133f2b6964cd15cde2ecc4d5fea67bf2c3653131a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85242dd8c3c0738644764bea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336016,"date":"2026-03-12T16:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member from the Bloc asked an excellent question about Taiwan. Indeed, Canada has a long history and a growing economic relationship with Taiwan. I think that is where we need a strategic partnership by recognizing its sovereignty in standing up to Chinese ambition, which may lead to a global conflict in the next 20 years. We need to be on the side of Taiwan, not on the side of Communist China as it relates to that sovereign country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336016","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member from the Bloc asked an excellent question about Taiwan. Indeed, Canada has a long history and a growing economic relationship with Taiwan. I think that is where we need a strategic partnership by recognizing its sovereignty in standing up to Chinese ambition, which may lead to a global conflict in the next 20 years. We need to be on the side of Taiwan, not on the side of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["14414f9b582465a25c47d3c15f6d9a52a228e056316b373eb271ce33317fa6e4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b8489339dc457f18bd4d21b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336017,"date":"2026-03-12T16:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, one of the great honours I have in being a member of Parliament is that I get to meet with incredible entrepreneurs across Canada. They have heard the words of the Prime Minister and have been hopeful, but that hope is running thin. It is time to act. It is time to see shovels in the ground. It is time to use the advantages that we have been gifted in this country to our economic success.\n\nFor example, if we built a pipeline in northern British Columbia, that one project would exceed the total worth of all our trade with China today. How could we not take that opportunity right now? How are we not moving on that like those other countries in Europe have when action was required?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-95/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336017","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, one of the great honours I have in being a member of Parliament is that I get to meet with incredible entrepreneurs across Canada. They have heard the words of the Prime Minister and have been hopeful, but that hope is running thin. It is time to act. It is time to see shovels in the ground. It is time to use the advantages that we have been gifted in this country to our economic su","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036616","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036616","label":"Soil","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3385793b58c87cf7ddc3fe4063f4b25fba32a3bbe5e378ad49fba4d6e1dd3ccc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a873fe3ac29a7e8cbe69e735","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384338,"date":"2026-03-23T20:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on behalf of constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford to table several petitions, for the very last time, on the Liberal-Bloc amendment to Bill C-9, which would remove the good-faith religious exemption from the Criminal Code of Canada. This could criminalize clergy, educators or individuals for expressing sincerely held religious beliefs or for quoting sacred texts.\n\nTherefore, the petitioners call upon the Government of Canada to reject any amendment to Bill C-9 that would remove the good-faith exemption from Canada's hate speech provisions, and to protect Canada's constitutional right to freedom of religion and freedom of expression.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384338","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on behalf of constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford to table several petitions, for the very last time, on the Liberal-Bloc amendment to Bill C-9, which would remove the good-faith religious exemption from the Criminal Code of Canada. This could criminalize clergy, educators or individuals for expressing sincerely held religious beliefs or for quoting sacred texts.\n\nT","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["17635938cebcc9601892844c168cc1bc5742316ead97cd1cd573dc8b9ae81b4a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["58fa12cf6edbd4b52f359c3aa80ac93c5679e00fc3e57d17b8b05e6ca283ef38"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4ecb687dfbf9b1c0d0ea26e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384339,"date":"2026-03-23T20:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, before I begin my formal remarks, just over a week ago, an old folks' home in my riding, the Chartwell residence on 7th Avenue in Mission that is located right beside the church, burned to the ground. It was my church, St. Joseph's, that organized help for all of those displaced seniors. It was community members, the Mission Gurdwara and other faith groups that came forward and helped all those displaced residents. I want to thank all of them for standing up for what community means and helping people when they are in trouble. I want to thank all those individuals for their hard work and giving me hope for Canadian society.\n\nThose same people in my parish who woke up in the middle of the night to help those displaced from their burning residence are the same people who are concerned about Bill C-9. I rise today thinking about the people I represent: the families in faith communities who expect Parliament to defend their freedoms and not erode them. \n\nBill C-9 raises serious questions about whether the government is in fact still prepared to do that. Removing the good-faith exemption from the Criminal Code was completely unnecessary. It was not what the Liberals said they were going to do. It is not what the Liberals campaigned upon. It only happened because of a political circumstance. \n\nRemoving the good-faith exemption from the Criminal Code, as I said, was completely unnecessary. The provision ensured that individuals cannot be convicted of wilful promotion of hatred if they are expressing in good faith an opinion on a religious subject or a belief based on a religious text. \n\nThese safeguards were not incidental. They were deliberately included in Canada's Criminal Code to ensure that laws remained consistent with the charter. There has been a sharp increase in hate crimes and violence in Canada. Mosques have been shot up, businesses have been vandalized, churches across our country have been burned and Jewish Canadians are facing a lot of hatred right now, which is completely unacceptable. \n\nHowever, we have not reached this point due to a lack of legislation. Many parts of this bill, whether they are banning hate symbols or protecting access to places of worship, are already covered under current law. Rather, the refusal to enforce our existing laws has created a sense of security for those who actually seek to promote hate, to sow fear and to create violence in Canadian society. The answer is not to weaken fundamental freedoms for the vast majority of Canadians who just want to go about their everyday life and go to their church or synagogue or mosque on a weekend and worship. \n\nThis is why the Conservatives today are proposing to restore the good-faith exemption to listen to the hundreds of thousands of Canadians who have overwhelmed Parliament with their fear of what the government is doing. Canadians of all faiths are raising legitimate concerns about the impact this decision would have. \n\nThe Muslim Public Affairs Council emphasized the \"[d]isproportionate impacts on minority communities whose scriptures are more frequently politicized or scrutinized\". The Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops highlighted that it \"risks creating uncertainty for faith communities, clergy, educators, and others who may fear that the expression of traditional moral or doctrinal teachings could be misrepresented as hate speech\".\n\nOver the course of this debate, the government has framed these concerns as unfounded. However, comments from the Minister of Identity at the justice committee a few months ago suggesting that parts of religious texts themselves could be considered hateful and open to prosecution should give every member of the House pause, because once the state begins to interpret belief as potential criminality, we are heading down a very different path in this nation. \n\nFaith groups in Canada are not asking for the right to spread hate. They are asking if they will still be free to speak openly about what they believe. What unites us in this country is an understanding that in a free country, people must be able to speak about their beliefs, even when others disagree, without fear of criminal prosecution. \n\nOne of the most troubling consequences of the amendment is the uncertainty and division it would create in our justice system and across our country. The proposed Liberal amendment claiming Bill C-9 would not infringe on freedom of expression or religious freedom offers no robust protection for charter rights. That uncertainty fosters a climate where Canadians feel they must walk on eggshells rather than engage openly and respectfully in a robust civil society. Even the Supreme Court of Canada acknowledged that protections like this are essential to keeping our laws balanced and constitutional. Removing this safeguard introduces legal ambiguity and increases the risk of constitutional challenge. It also places a greater interpretive burden on courts and prosecutors without clear statutory guidance.\n\nAs confirmed by the Minister of Justice, these rules would also extend to digital spaces. This would significantly broaden the scope of enforcement. Without the good-faith exemption, individuals expressing religious or political views online may face increased legal uncertainty and greater exposure to investigation or prosecution. This reinforces the need for clear statutory safeguards, not their removal. Canadians are left wondering not just what they can say in a place of worship but what they can post, share or discuss online in good faith. That level of uncertainty is not healthy in a democracy and is contrary to the way Canadians have lived.\n\nThe government could have achieved every goal they set out originally in Bill C-9 without the amendment. Conservatives offered to split the bill into two parts to swiftly pass uncontentious sections of the legislation. This approach was rejected. I hosted a town hall on this issue with my colleagues, the member for Abbotsford—South Langley and the member for Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, who spoke earlier, and we heard a clear and consistent sentiment.\n\nOver the past decade, Canadians feel that the government has increasingly tried to dictate how they live and what they should believe. Canadians expected a different approach under the Prime Minister from Nepean. However, my constituents raised that, within the last year, they were afraid not only of their freedom of expression but of churches and synagogues and all religious institutions even maintaining charitable status under CRA laws. Combined with the introduction of online censorship measures, the government is continuing restrictive policies that we thought it was supposed to have rejected. Liberals did not campaign on this.\n\nIn my riding, I have one of the largest Sikh populations in Canada. Abbotsford is home to one of the first Gur Sikh temples in Canada. It is a national historic site. We are all very proud of that. Constituents have come forward to me and asked what they are going to do with their kirpan now. If a prosecutor reads in their holy book about the role of a kirpan and a sword and sees them wearing it, how will they be impacted? How will they be impacted as a member of the Sikh faith?\n\nAs other members of the Conservative caucus have raised, what will happen if someone, like the Minister of Canadian Identity and Culture, decides to prosecute someone for an interpretation of an Old Testament text?\n\nThe government was elected with a mandate to strengthen the economy yet, as The Globe and Mail reported yesterday, Canada's GDP growth has been flat for the past three quarters and remains below the G7 average. We also face an affordability crisis. Instead of working collaboratively on measures that everyone in the House could agree upon, the Liberals decided to side with the Bloc Québécois on something that is so divisive and so fearful for the average Canadian. I do not get it. This was not part of the government's mandate.\n\nConservatives are not even proposing to dismantle Bill C-9. We simply want to maintain the Criminal Code exemption that already exists and was never part of any political discussion during the last campaign until the Liberals felt that they were not going to get what they wanted and made a deal with the Bloc Québécois. Every member of the House agrees that hatred, violence and intimidation have no place in Canada. Those who target individuals or communities, whether in person or online, must be held accountable under the law. The good-faith exemption has served as an important safeguard, ensuring that Canada's hate speech laws target real harm without capturing sincere expression or leaving religious texts up to interpretation from bodies outside of those religions.\n\nAt a time when Canadians are already so divided, we should not be advancing measures that deepen uncertainty or cause people to second-guess their ability to speak openly about their beliefs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384339","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, before I begin my formal remarks, just over a week ago, an old folks' home in my riding, the Chartwell residence on 7th Avenue in Mission that is located right beside the church, burned to the ground. It was my church, St. Joseph's, that organized help for all of those displaced seniors. It was community members, the Mission Gurdwara and other faith groups that came forward and helped","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["79ebf709c277a5a0f61c37005c2f0a4982bb805b71ed9c53a75b2fab7c705e98"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a25f19a87632ab30e856746c908df51b9b3163ed1b789daee5a040244c6acdf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80c110a4aeaf83995ad2a3a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384515,"date":"2026-03-23T20:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member has used that example in good faith, and that is one single interpretation.\n\nThe justice committee has heard from hundreds, if not thousands, of people and organizations that feel that the government is going down the wrong path and that it has steered away from what it intended to do in the legislation originally to get it passed in a way that they wanted and in the time frame that they wanted, with the Bloc Québécois. As a result of that, they have sowed division and fear such that I have never seen in Canadian society before.\n\nWhy? For what reason, might I ask, did they do this? It is for political expediency.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384515","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member has used that example in good faith, and that is one single interpretation.\n\nThe justice committee has heard from hundreds, if not thousands, of people and organizations that feel that the government is going down the wrong path and that it has steered away from what it intended to do in the legislation originally to get it passed in a way that they wanted and in the time f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab387a54d748bb1d42b8308080e49c58b7772531f33e4b259f12b48d03a35511"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2a8005d04d290c8a9423101","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384516,"date":"2026-03-23T20:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will say it has been great getting to know the member from Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj, and playing hockey and building bridges amongst the political parties. In good faith, I really have enjoyed getting to know him. However, we do fundamentally disagree on approaches to secularism in Canada.\n\n I will note as well that my constituents are very concerned about the context of Bill C-9 and Bill 21 from the Quebec National Assembly going before the Supreme Court. My constituents, if they were to move to Quebec and ask to work as a school teacher, would not be permitted to wear a kirpan. That is not acceptable in my version of Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384516","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will say it has been great getting to know the member from Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj, and playing hockey and building bridges amongst the political parties. In good faith, I really have enjoyed getting to know him. However, we do fundamentally disagree on approaches to secularism in Canada.\n\n I will note as well that my constituents are very concerned about the cont","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7b1269ffd4e7223651df94ab83958ca6199d8d719acc335751c623d8f5c26e17"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe48ed37473e94e2ac5ba45a43c49e6195a459c82744c27f46c07588b5a5c0cc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fcf72306019c413288648b1e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384517,"date":"2026-03-23T20:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think it is an insult to the hundreds of thousands of Canadians who are concerned right now.\n\n The script reads like a movie. The Minister of Canadian Identity makes these comments before he is in cabinet. He erupts, people get angry all across Canada, and then the Prime Minister appoints him to cabinet. Then the Liberals make an agreement to amend Bill C-9.\n\n Canadians are right to be concerned about the sneaky approach of the government as it relates to religious freedoms. The Liberals have been arguing throughout this debate that it would not make any difference if the provision were taken out of the Criminal Code. Then why do it in the first place?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384517","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think it is an insult to the hundreds of thousands of Canadians who are concerned right now.\n\n The script reads like a movie. The Minister of Canadian Identity makes these comments before he is in cabinet. He erupts, people get angry all across Canada, and then the Prime Minister appoints him to cabinet. Then the Liberals make an agreement to amend Bill C-9.\n\n Canadians are right to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f92a40931bda050508414e79847795848bab7fc54336ec2318385e8c6e45637a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f9d7febf41a0b74320e0a00","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384261,"date":"2026-03-24T15:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a petition on behalf of constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are deeply concerned about proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia.\n\nRecreational fishers fully recognize conservation in first nations' constitutionally protected food, social, ceremonial and commercial fisheries. For generations, salmon have been managed by the government as a common property resource, held in trust for the benefit of all. Changing this common property principle risks turning a shared public resource into an exclusive privilege, reducing access for many Canadians and undermining confidence in fisheries management. Petitioners note that this would be devastating to our tourism economy and the billions of dollars that flow into conservation efforts.\n\nTherefore, petitioners are calling on the Minister of Fisheries to leave the current salmon allocation policy alone and uphold the cultural rights and traditions of all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384261","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a petition on behalf of constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are deeply concerned about proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy that would decimate regular recreational fishing opportunities for coho and chinook in British Columbia.\n\nRecreational fishers fully recognize conservation in first nations' constitutionally protected food, social, ceremonial a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["debcdfb071d4744f5074e3e37022378b97b91bc625452899585b51227b8718a1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce687e77f45c214e2793559f747d3be665685006c5d214b6500d7dc2c8bbb597"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1704b40b537ca0d1e8148a2b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384337,"date":"2026-03-24T19:02:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, last week we had another serious flood warning in the Fraser Valley. Today I plead with the government to listen to the concerns of our region, a key national economic corridor.\n\n On November 24, 2021, in the House, I was promised that the Liberal government would be a partner in rebuilding Abbotsford for a stronger future. We are still waiting for action. The government has signalled that the $51-billion build communities strong fund will help my community recover, but what my riding is looking for is an assurance that this funding will be allocated accordingly.\n\n I implore the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure to ensure that we are not forgotten. Every major railway runs through our area. The local airport is critical for national defence. Highway 1 is the key arterial road in British Columbia. The TransMountain pipeline runs through the flood zone.\n\n The time for talk is over. We need action from the federal government. It needs to fulfill its promises.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384337","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, last week we had another serious flood warning in the Fraser Valley. Today I plead with the government to listen to the concerns of our region, a key national economic corridor.\n\n On November 24, 2021, in the House, I was promised that the Liberal government would be a partner in rebuilding Abbotsford for a stronger future. We are still waiting for action. The government has signalled","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ed2ff91fdadbc1891df04eac3892beeff11342a6884bce08fa4cf3a62ee8f79"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ec56a616b1f8250d296304b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384259,"date":"2026-03-25T19:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister promised Canadians the strongest economy in the G7. Instead, Canada now has the only shrinking economy and the second-highest unemployment. We have lost over 100,000 jobs since January of this year, and many of our small businesses are going to the United States. Other countries are dealing with the same problems and the same global pressures.\n\nWill the Prime Minister admit his policies are failing Canadians and outline why our economy is the worst in the G7?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384259","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister promised Canadians the strongest economy in the G7. Instead, Canada now has the only shrinking economy and the second-highest unemployment. We have lost over 100,000 jobs since January of this year, and many of our small businesses are going to the United States. Other countries are dealing with the same problems and the same global pressures.\n\nWill the Prime Minist","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e0e7ba5bf17a9d7689588de7535c2ee1d3ee35869d7b9c885138a0ef00d05205"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2184b3d0d5eb126a8ee1ebd1117f975d04f14c61f2929eea6f7c14096c294274"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6826f5f6b887863a362a96ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384260,"date":"2026-03-25T19:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I do not think the gravity of the situation is hitting the government appropriately. In the last two decades, Canada has lost 100,000 entrepreneurs, but our population has gone up by 10 million people. Since 2019, there has been a 19% increase in business exits, with only a 5% increase in new businesses. Nothing the government is doing is helping our entrepreneurs, our job creators.\n\nWhen will the government reverse its horrible economic policies and get out of the way so businesses can thrive?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384260","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I do not think the gravity of the situation is hitting the government appropriately. In the last two decades, Canada has lost 100,000 entrepreneurs, but our population has gone up by 10 million people. Since 2019, there has been a 19% increase in business exits, with only a 5% increase in new businesses. Nothing the government is doing is helping our entrepreneurs, our job creators.\n\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3f89055ad61fdd22855aa576f483fa4dfc09155ed3be257d68256a07a8f0644"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cae334b98a6c35237d75ccf2d375676ee9bd60b86c9a65c9374f8e91bbca7f75"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc10beaaf074ad6fefc81858","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384256,"date":"2026-03-26T16:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, one of the first issues I raised in Parliament six and a half years ago was about the outdated technology system for the employment insurance, CPP and EI model through Employment and Social Development Canada. Unfortunately, the Government of Canada continues to face these horrible situations because the Treasury Board guidelines for technology employees specifically have not been modernized. \n\nThe Government of Canada relies so heavily on outsourced consultants because the pay scales do not allow for the Government of Canada to hire the experts. What it ends up doing is going to those experts, who charge them over $1,000 and sometimes $2,000 a day to do the work, instead of changing the Treasury Board guidelines and allowing those people to come into the public service. \n\nWould the member for Shefford agree that if the Government of Canada wants to stop running into all these scandals, all this mismanagement, it would update the guidelines for the Treasury Board Secretariat to hire the best and the brightest in Ottawa to do the necessary technology upgrades the Government of Canada needs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384256","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, one of the first issues I raised in Parliament six and a half years ago was about the outdated technology system for the employment insurance, CPP and EI model through Employment and Social Development Canada. Unfortunately, the Government of Canada continues to face these horrible situations because the Treasury Board guidelines for technology employees specifically have not been m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aaad8c2ca21e9d41d06afcebaa5f61c2a8a29c8be71f52fb2cebd53c9416a25e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["39866c51ec00ec88f3edc1d58e6bc3d48a6af4ca687f52254e5fa715e8d3103c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77478d0161bce4d8a3a58fa1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384257,"date":"2026-03-26T16:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a petition on behalf of the residents of Abbotsford and the Fraser Valley, who are highly vulnerable to flooding due to low-lying geography adjacent to the Fraser River and tributaries. Recent severe flood events have caused widespread damage to homes, businesses, agricultural lands and critical infrastructure in the region. Flooding disrupts critical supply chains and trade routes, impacting not only local but also regional and national economies. The existing flood protection infrastructure, including dykes, levees and the drainage system, is aging and inadequate to withstand current and future flood risks.\n\n Therefore, the undersigned citizens and permanent residents of Canada call upon the Government of Canada not to ignore Abbotsford any longer and to invest in the critical infrastructure needed to protect this key economic corridor for the entirety of Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384257","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am tabling a petition on behalf of the residents of Abbotsford and the Fraser Valley, who are highly vulnerable to flooding due to low-lying geography adjacent to the Fraser River and tributaries. Recent severe flood events have caused widespread damage to homes, businesses, agricultural lands and critical infrastructure in the region. Flooding disrupts critical supply chains and tr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["593ccaeb62ba09da9555b2ebe6960fcb1c15d992c4f41fd9f5a1b2827b0b78f3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35ffebc1e06da0ee47531d44c0c41aa9212ca7479512c4f1b64813456ffd8d69"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3844b533287631cf10eddc1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384258,"date":"2026-03-26T16:46:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, since 2009, Boko Haram, ISIS West Africa and armed Fulani militia have carried out sustained attacks against Christian communities in Nigeria, causing mass killings and widespread destruction of churches and villages. Despite the scale and duration of this violence, there have been no meaningful prosecutions, and international rights organizations report persistent failures by Nigerian authorities to prevent attacks or hold perpetrators accountable.\n\nThe petitioners are calling upon the government of Canada to recognize the targeted killings of Christians in Nigeria, hold those responsible accountable and work with international partners to protect Christian communities and support humanitarian aid, safe return of displaced persons and asylum for those fleeing persecution.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384258","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, since 2009, Boko Haram, ISIS West Africa and armed Fulani militia have carried out sustained attacks against Christian communities in Nigeria, causing mass killings and widespread destruction of churches and villages. Despite the scale and duration of this violence, there have been no meaningful prosecutions, and international rights organizations report persistent failures by Nigeria","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dd40b2c912e442acd596aae13774a514b5b9774943016b63714a68a4bb641581"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2cab77b2ac4e7639ae6908f8477ad0b90ea81c395a01a751470c90ec1fe44413"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b63ceb816aa76ee8c447953","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425423,"date":"2026-04-14T15:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have multiple petitions to present today. \n\nThe petitioners in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford recognize that the total cost of regulation to Canadian businesses has reached $51.5 billion, with $17.9 billion of that for red tape alone. Small businesses have spent an average of 735 hours per year complying with regulatory requirements that provide little or no public benefit. Small businesses pay over five times more per employee than large firms to comply with regulation, making unnecessary red tape a major barrier to growth and a drag on Canada's productivity and competitiveness. \n\nThe petitioners therefore call upon the Government of Canada to immediately review and eliminate redundant regulations and overlapping requirements that disproportionately harm small businesses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425423","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have multiple petitions to present today. \n\nThe petitioners in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford recognize that the total cost of regulation to Canadian businesses has reached $51.5 billion, with $17.9 billion of that for red tape alone. Small businesses have spent an average of 735 hours per year complying with regulatory requirements that provide little or no public benefit. Small busine","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e77b0e4eb12ff62a9526379d0a9f04a887c6c82c3a3e441a865962f3869e110"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e77dc7449bb765d86c65da394848c23b637e6e2abf4be1636832cd3d2b738405"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f87025e258edca704143408","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425424,"date":"2026-04-14T15:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of residents of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are raising concerns about individuals linked to the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, a listed terrorist organization in Canada. The petitioners warn that such actors threaten national security and may be operating within Canada. They also note that sanctions and the closure of Canada's embassy in Iran have delayed immigration applications and prolonged family separation. They call upon the Government of Canada to enforce its designation of the IRGC by investigating and removing affiliated individuals where warranted, freezing linked assets and expediting immigration processes for affected Iranian nationals while supporting the Iranian people and protecting democratic values.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425424","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of residents of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford who are raising concerns about individuals linked to the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, a listed terrorist organization in Canada. The petitioners warn that such actors threaten national security and may be operating within Canada. They also note that sanctions and the closure","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["139662b2dc0d00b45913e4b017c2a79451f3d520525ed9e702f495b18bf63aa6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa6880c5d40ade896189bce5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425425,"date":"2026-04-14T19:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, what I am seeing today from the government is a government pursuing a policy of confusion that has the whole province of British Columbia upset. Earlier today in question period, the Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations said that the government will pursue all legal options.\n\nCan the minister clarify for British Columbians whether that includes an argument to protect the private property rights of the British Columbians impacted by the Cowichan decision, yes or no? I would like a straight answer, in good faith.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425425","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, what I am seeing today from the government is a government pursuing a policy of confusion that has the whole province of British Columbia upset. Earlier today in question period, the Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations said that the government will pursue all legal options.\n\nCan the minister clarify for British Columbians whether that includes an argument to protect the private pro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7e2cc19e413926b916d4d2f467d9c55a2a89ac3a3e89f6469fd5a7cede4b735"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d619386686fab4674d15e40cf1eb5b74c1c76dff12812e70b58579fabddedc6f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04fd1c2d150268abf5ee24ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425417,"date":"2026-04-15T21:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, petitioners in my riding note that the federal government recently gave $64 million to a new recreation centre in Brampton, $20 million for the Somali Centre in Toronto, $15 million for a Montreal North athletic centre, $7 million for an aquatic centre in Qualicum Beach and $6 million for a new aquatic centre in New Brunswick.\n\nPetitioners from the Wolverines field hockey club are wondering why residents of the Fraser Valley are not getting their adequate share of recreational dollars for the same types of facilities they see in other communities across this country. Therefore, they call upon the federal government to be fair and equitable with taxpayer dollars and give some money to the Fraser Valley as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425417","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, petitioners in my riding note that the federal government recently gave $64 million to a new recreation centre in Brampton, $20 million for the Somali Centre in Toronto, $15 million for a Montreal North athletic centre, $7 million for an aquatic centre in Qualicum Beach and $6 million for a new aquatic centre in New Brunswick.\n\nPetitioners from the Wolverines field hockey club are won","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4c9be0291a5fc0937808d2123a58ad78e2405208ea9967ef4103bc66fac4f429"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["769964b7dab049db8e35250f65c1eeab80a41e2fdbeb7e71910a5ddbd4da27b5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6fe4f16800a1982856c49edd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425418,"date":"2026-04-15T21:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of the recreational fishing community in British Columbia. They are very concerned about access to coho and chinook.\n\nThey note that the federal government did not consult with them in advance of its proposed changes, and they are pleading, in good faith, with the Minister of Fisheries to maintain access for all British Columbians to practise their cultural right to fish, as British Columbians have always done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425418","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of the recreational fishing community in British Columbia. They are very concerned about access to coho and chinook.\n\nThey note that the federal government did not consult with them in advance of its proposed changes, and they are pleading, in good faith, with the Minister of Fisheries to maintain access for all British Co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d1ab11739a486d8759653e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425419,"date":"2026-04-15T23:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-22 is the federal government's attempt to finally establish a Canadian lawful access regime after years of inaction. There is no doubt that law enforcement and national security agencies face real challenges in the digital world. Criminals involved in organized crime, child exploitation and human trafficking increasingly use encrypted services, burner phones and foreign-based platforms to hide their identities and evade justice. Conservatives have long recognized the need to give police the tools required to pursue criminals effectively. \n\nHowever, while Bill C-22 addresses some genuine operational gaps, it also raises serious concerns about civil liberties, proportionality and ministerial overreach. As drafted, the bill risks trading Canadians' privacy and constitutional protections for administrative convenience while failing to meaningfully address the most urgent public safety issues facing the country. \n\nMy first point is that faster access comes at the cost of lower thresholds. At the heart of Bill C-22 is a deliberate shift toward faster and easier access to digital information. The bill introduces new confirmation of service demands, production orders for subscriber information and clarified emergency seizure powers, many of which operate on the low standard of \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" rather than \"reasonable grounds to believe\". Subscriber information under this bill is defined broadly, including names, addresses, email accounts, device identifiers and service history. In the modern context, this information can reveal detailed personal profiles and social connections. Lowering the evidentiary threshold for accessing this data risks normalizing surveillance at early investigative stages without sufficient justification or safeguards. While judicial oversight technically remains in place for most tools, the cumulative effect is a system where access is easier, quicker and more routine, even when the intrusion into privacy could be significant.\n\nMy second point is about the expansion of warrantless and voluntary disclosure powers. Bill C-22 codifies and expands the ability of police and public officers to obtain information without warrants in exigent circumstances. While true emergencies justify flexibility, the bill's language does risk stretching \"impracticability\" beyond genuine urgency and into administrative expediency. \n\nEven more concerning is the bill's broad reliance on voluntary disclosure. Telecommunications companies and other service providers are explicitly encouraged to hand over information voluntarily, including unsolicited information or data required under foreign law, with full immunity from civil or criminal liability. This effectively creates, or could create, a parallel system of access outside traditional judiciary scrutiny. Canadians should not have their personal information transferred to the state simply because a company decides it is expedient or risk-free to comply in certain circumstances.\n\n My third concern is that secrecy and delayed notice could weaken accountability. Bill C-22 entrenches secrecy as a core feature of lawful access. Non-disclosure orders can prevent service providers from revealing that they have been compelled to co-operate. In some cases, notice to affected individuals may be delayed for up to three years, with possible extensions. This erosion of transparency undermines meaningful accountability. Canadians whose data is accessed may never know it happened, making charter challenges or judicial remedies largely theoretical. Oversight that occurs only after the fact and primarily within government institutions cannot substitute for timely notice and real recourse.\n\nMy fourth point is about ministerial powers and burdens on service providers. Part 2 of the bill, the supporting authorized access to information act, introduces a new regulatory regime imposing obligations on electronic service providers. The government may designate core providers, such as a cellphone company, and require them to build and maintain technical surveillance capabilities, retain metadata for up to one year, and assist in testing access systems, all at their own expense. While the bill claims to prohibit mandatory back doors and systematic vulnerabilities, the scope of ministerial discretion remains extremely broad. Individualized ministerial orders are confidential, shielded from public scrutiny, and only reviewed for reasonableness by the intelligence commissioner. This framework risks imposing compliance costs, stifling innovation and concentrating powers in the hands of our executive.\n\nMy fifth point is that the bill fails to address Canada's real public safety crisis. Perhaps most troubling is what Bill C-22 would not do: It would do nothing to address catch-and-release bail, sentencing leniency or the lack of mandatory prison time for fentanyl traffickers and violent gang members. Canadians continue to face rising violent crime, organized theft and drug trafficking, problems driven not by lack of data but by judicial and policy failures. The government's focus on digital access powers, while ignoring these other key aspects of our criminal justice system, reflects, in some cases, a few misplaced priorities.\n\n Bill C-22 contains elements that Conservatives can support in principle and that I will be voting in favour of, particularly the goal of modernizing investigative tools, but as drafted, the bill would overreach in ways that could threaten civil liberties, weaken transparency and expand ministerial power, while failing to deliver real improvements to public safety in certain cases.\n\n In a digital era, when metadata can be as revealing as content itself, the bill's cumulative effect risks putting Canada on a path to where lawful access becomes pervasive access. A more balanced approach would have raised access thresholds, narrowed voluntary disclosure, strengthened notice obligations and subjected the most privacy-intrusive powers to stricter, not looser, judicial control. For these reasons, I believe Conservatives should support the bill at second reading in order to send it to committee, but only with a clear expectation that amendments are required.\n\n Any lawful access regime must strike a proper balance, equipping police to stop criminals while firmly protecting the rights and freedoms of law-abiding Canadians. I believe we can get there, and this is a step in the right direction, especially as it relates to vulnerable children and victims of human trafficking.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425419","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-22 is the federal government's attempt to finally establish a Canadian lawful access regime after years of inaction. There is no doubt that law enforcement and national security agencies face real challenges in the digital world. Criminals involved in organized crime, child exploitation and human trafficking increasingly use encrypted services, burner phones and foreign-based p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["959c2157a35b7b46b3f0f2243eae893ba9a235f38809355de86fa0fbbd0730c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["449ef7d0d56bf756f9eb6483da7c9d640b27700ac3d76d11032ec6fe28d0f8c4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-954f73fee836f9bc16732d9e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425420,"date":"2026-04-15T23:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think the most concerning thing is the requirement for blanket metadata retention. Under the bill, service providers could be forced to store vast quantities of Canadians' digital footprints for up to a year, regardless of suspicion and regardless of wrongdoing. I know in some cases that metadata can be utilized for nefarious purposes, and we need to make sure that the proper protocols are in place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425420","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think the most concerning thing is the requirement for blanket metadata retention. Under the bill, service providers could be forced to store vast quantities of Canadians' digital footprints for up to a year, regardless of suspicion and regardless of wrongdoing. I know in some cases that metadata can be utilized for nefarious purposes, and we need to make sure that the proper protoc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["291b3e8012a72cf8c35c4299c4c3af600fed3923434e1e41afc56730292f85af"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13a2c6caee81d65fef95f857a3f504499f13cad1a99dd20db48b6bf73f414088"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9f32efba8baff01de38c78f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425421,"date":"2026-04-16T00:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in December, I asked the Minister of Jobs and Families why the Prime Minister was increasing industrial carbon taxes during a cost of living crisis. These costs do not stay with large emitters, but are passed down the supply chains, raising the price of groceries and transportation, and stunting economic growth. Lower fuel costs would reduce the price of shipping, building materials and essentials, making life more affordable for Canadians who are already pinching their pennies. \n\nThat is why this week the government listened to the Conservatives. However, its plan only delivers a third of the relief Conservatives propose for a third of the year. Eliminating federal taxes would also ease pressures for small businesses operating on already thin margins. The industrial carbon tax disproportionately targets energy-intensive sectors that small businesses rely on, such as fuels for shipping and electricity for day-to-day operations. According to the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, nearly two-thirds of small businesses report that they are absorbing additional fuel costs. A third have increased their prices as a result.\n\n Taxes and regulatory burden remain among the top pressures facing small businesses in Canada today. We are already seeing the consequences. Business closures are up 19% since 2019. Small business employment dropped by 34,000 jobs in March alone. Employment declined across every region in the country. Fifty-five per cent of small businesses would not recommend starting a business in Canada's environment today. \n\nWhile the government has temporarily suspended the federal excise tax on gas and diesel this week, it has doubled down on the clean fuel standards and the industrial carbon tax, which is set to increase to $170 per tonne by 2030. It is subjecting our economy and Canadians to a death by a thousand cuts. Even the Parliamentary Budget Officer has noted that Canada's emissions reductions will have a limited impact globally, yet Canadian businesses are bearing disproportionately high costs. Temporary relief does nothing to offset permanent structural cost increases, causing our economy to hemorrhage jobs and investments and not address the affordability crisis. \n\nThe situation, unfortunately, is projected to get worse. A study by the Fraser Institute estimates that increasing the industrial carbon price to $170 per tonne by 2030 will lead to a 1.3% reduction in our GDP nationally, reduce average incomes by $1,160 per worker and cost Canada 50,000 jobs. The report is clear. Reduced returns on investment will lead to cancelled or delayed business expansion, less capital investment and ultimately lower long-term living standards for Canadians.\n\n Over the last decade, Canada has already lost 1,000 entrepreneurs, while our population has gone up by 10 million people. When Canadian firms face higher input costs due to carbon pricing, investment flows elsewhere. The Business Council of Canada has warned that investment is increasingly being redirected to the U.S. due to more competitive policy frameworks. For small businesses, that means fewer contracts, fewer supply chains, less growth and fewer jobs. I have been contacted by businesses from B.C. and across Canada that cannot afford to keep their doors open due to mounting financial pressures that are not just international in nature but from Canada as well. The Hub recently reported that Canadians are opening more businesses in the U.S. than at home because we have no regulatory framework to protect entrepreneurs. \n\nThe government's policies have made it impossible to meet its own economic objectives. Why is it making it harder to do business in Canada? Will it finally scrap these policies before more jobs and investment leave our great country?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425421","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in December, I asked the Minister of Jobs and Families why the Prime Minister was increasing industrial carbon taxes during a cost of living crisis. These costs do not stay with large emitters, but are passed down the supply chains, raising the price of groceries and transportation, and stunting economic growth. Lower fuel costs would reduce the price of shipping, building materials a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6ee46fe8b5f87dc30410df4329ef855056fb9d030c9997f40524e9ae2d23beaf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fe8a79cd2562462c41ff20fa4def21e23a57e60a197784d3aae099596ff50afa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b639dab562b27429adb324e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425422,"date":"2026-04-16T00:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I really do enjoy debating with the member for Vancouver Quadra every single time.\n\nI will point out, in disagreement, that the suspension of the fuel excise tax proves the argument I was making, that increased regulations and carbon taxes in Canada do impact our cost of living, and that is why, indeed, the government listened to the Conservatives, in good faith and constructive parliamentary debate, and decided to remove it until Labour Day. \n\nThe member also mentioned climate change adaptation in his remarks, and I am glad he did, because he knows as well as I do that my constituents in Semá:th first nation, across Sumas Prairie and across the eastern Fraser Valley really are looking for leadership from the Government of Canada. When we come forward with a flood mitigation plan, it will require federal leadership to build the requisite climate-resilient infrastructure to prevent the next flood. The member knows as well as I do that Sumas Lake used to be a lake. Now it is farmland, but we need to fix that area for future agriculture.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-103/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425422","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I really do enjoy debating with the member for Vancouver Quadra every single time.\n\nI will point out, in disagreement, that the suspension of the fuel excise tax proves the argument I was making, that increased regulations and carbon taxes in Canada do impact our cost of living, and that is why, indeed, the government listened to the Conservatives, in good faith and constructive parli","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9eea053110f48466e26fa0f5d8a6160bf5ff2a87e77dd111f5e00e8f0e3e9f8a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9126b5684df7d1b42e7bf405953155b2d6c41a76615a0ad7b0e1183c64342134"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dcfdd5c845f5f5002c2e051a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425355,"date":"2026-04-16T15:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition from Canadians concerned about the closure of the organic and regenerative research program at the Swift Current Research and Development Centre.\n\nThe petitioners note that this was the only dedicated organic research initiative within Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. It supported critical long-term work on soil health, crop rotation, pest management and scientific best practices writ large. They warn that its closure risks weakening Canada's agricultural research capacity and long-term competitiveness.\n\nThe petitioners therefore call upon the Government of Canada to stop its attack on agricultural science, reinstate the program and strengthen public research in organic and regenerative agriculture, which is an economic boost to the country of Canada and small businesses in every province and territory.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425355","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition from Canadians concerned about the closure of the organic and regenerative research program at the Swift Current Research and Development Centre.\n\nThe petitioners note that this was the only dedicated organic research initiative within Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. It supported critical long-term work on soil health, crop rotation, pest managemen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","label":"Soil quality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","label":"Soil quality","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","label":"Agricultural technology","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5a5ef1c38ff01a9e261c0abcda793b3b6af662dc62050c51665d90c20b0877f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0b7ad3efaf30a2b7b95787db3249f3d778afc3033f0462c46294dff11a498498"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71402062f4acb9c70192f47f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425356,"date":"2026-04-16T15:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on a point of order, I would like unanimous consent to table one more petition.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425356","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on a point of order, I would like unanimous consent to table one more petition.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c8d9e164311e19eb5c44a43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425357,"date":"2026-04-16T15:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition on behalf of small business owners, including convenience store owners, to remove restrictions on the sale of nicotine pouches. Members of Parliament across all political parties love nicotine pouches. They use them every day, but they can only buy them at Shoppers Drug Mart. Why is Shoppers Drug Mart getting an exclusive monopoly for the sale of nicotine pouches?\n\nThe petitioners call on the Minister of Health to remove the restriction of the sale of nicotine pouches only to pharmacies, and allow convenience stores to sell them once again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425357","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition on behalf of small business owners, including convenience store owners, to remove restrictions on the sale of nicotine pouches. Members of Parliament across all political parties love nicotine pouches. They use them every day, but they can only buy them at Shoppers Drug Mart. Why is Shoppers Drug Mart getting an exclusive monopoly for the sale of nic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99353","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tobacco industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99353","label":"Tobacco industry","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c0fbe16e7b2ef6358f6a076584dc2d1adf9aa97e0974df80cb7696845634103"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4f716f3f978cb84870f6ff9be79e7153f5a4859aab20b24208d14632ea4973f1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e776bd89fbd4b7f40e3da86e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425358,"date":"2026-04-16T17:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in my time today, I want to talk about two specific issues. One is foreign interference in the context of the Hogue commission, and the second is my own experience in the 2015 election and my previous nomination contest at the time.\n\nLet us start with the Hogue commission. What did the Hogue commission say about foreign interference? It concluded that foreign states are actively attempting to interfere in Canada's democratic institutions and electoral processes. The threat is persistent and evolving, with the main state actors identified as China, India, Russia, Iran and Pakistan. The commission noted that their tactics include covert influence, disinformation, cyber activity, intimidation and the use of proxies within Canada.\n\nThe Hogue commission outlined that the 2019 and 2021 elections were not undermined, but that there was foreign influence. The commissioner found no evidence of widespread or systematic manipulation. At most, though it is still very significant, a small number of ridings may have been impacted, but that impact could not be determined with certainty; in other words, the ability of the government to determine our security apparatuses did not have the tools. There was no evidence that members of Parliament were elected because of foreign state support.\n\nThe commission found that there were no parliamentarians influenced by foreign agents. While there were some concerning and naive interactions with foreign actors, the evidence did not support allegations of systemic betrayal or treason in the context of those elections. \n\nThe commissioner outlined that the greatest threat from foreign actors is disinformation and misinformation, especially online. Those things cause the most serious, long-term threat to Canadian democracy. Social media, foreign-language platforms and AI-enabled tools are increasingly used to amplify division, discourage participation and undermine trust. Even when election outcomes are unchanged, disinformation damages confidence in democracy, which is in itself a strategic objective of hostile state actors.\n\nThe commission found that diaspora communities in Canada are disproportionately harmed. A central finding of the Hogue commission was on the human impact of foreign interference. Diaspora communities are the primary targets. Many experience transnational repression, including threats, intimidation, surveillance of family abroad and coercion. Indeed, I believe the member for Wellington—Halton Hills North had his family impacted by these very problems. These activities, in many cases, chill political participation in Canada and undermine self-expression and trust in Canadian institutions.\n\nWhile government responses have improved, we have been too slow and opaque as a nation to address many of our shortcomings. Our government is slow to react to intelligence. There is poor coordination, and there are unclear responsibilities. There have been failures in intelligence flow to decision-makers, and there is insufficient transparency and public communication about the real threats that Canada faces.\n\nOur intelligence is fragile and has limits. Much of the information about foreign interference comes from unverified or partial intelligence. Intelligence must be handled carefully to avoid unfair conclusions about individuals. The intelligence-to-evidence problem makes prosecutions difficult and requires non-criminal disruption tools.\n\nForeign interference, the commission notes, has already harmed our democracy by undermining trust. It has been successful in weakening public confidence in the outcomes of our elections.\n\nThe commissioner also noted that we need a whole-of-society response. We need greater transparency in public education, digital and media literacy, stronger coordination across government, engagement with civil society, and targeted action against disinformation and transnational repression.\n\nThe bottom line from the Hogue commission is that foreign interference is a real and serious threat. Although our democracy has proven resilient, we have seen some gaps and some damage because our government has not moved fast enough.\n\nI will say that the Conservatives will be supporting Bill C-25 at second reading to go to committee so we can make improvements to our democracy. I am glad to see this type of collaboration in the House of Commons.\n\nWhat would Bill C-25 do? It would extend foreign interference protections year-round. It would close channels for foreign and opaque political financing, such as cryptocurrencies, money orders and prepaid cards. It would tighten third party financing rules so that only Canadian citizens' or permanent residents' funds could be used for regulated partisan activities. It would prohibit using foreign money, property or services to influence elections in Canada. While there are still a few more loopholes we want to address at committee, this is a step in the right direction.\n\n Bill C-25 would protect nomination and leadership contests from interference. It would ban deceptive AI deepfakes tied to elections. It would criminalize false information meant to disrupt voting. It would strengthen enforcement penalties. There would be increases to administrative monetary penalties, up to $100,000 for organizations. I think we might even consider going higher on some of those penalties if in fact our intelligence community found that foreign actors were using funds in a nefarious manner. It would improve party data protection obligations and boost foreign information threat detection capacity for our government.\n\nThis is all very important. However, I will note as well that in the last Parliament, we had Bill C-70, which was a response to the troubling findings of the Hogue commission. Still, today, despite many repeated promises, the Government of Canada has not enacted a foreign registry. Many of the things in Bill C-25 cannot be operationalized, cannot be used to their full effect, until the government fulfills its responsibility on legislation that received royal assent over a year ago. The threats to democracy are real, that has been concluded in Canada, but we have not seen the requisite action from the government to move at a speed that undermines the real problems Canadians are facing.\n\nA foreign registry would protect democratic debate in Canada. It would address that grey zone between influence and interference. It would deter covert and deceptive behaviour. It would strengthen trust in our institutions without stigmatizing communities. It would give parliamentarians and officials a basic due diligence tool. It would align Canada with all of our Five Eyes allies, who already have a similar policy in place. It would reinforce the principle that sovereignty includes the information space and that how we conduct ourselves as MPs and engage with foreign agents or foreign governments matters in the context of protecting Canadian sovereignty. \n\nI mention all of this in the context of a former member of Parliament, Han Dong. While the Hogue commission outlined that intelligence officials in Canada indicated that PRC officials likely attempted to influence the 2019 Liberal nomination contest in Don Valley North, there were limits to our intelligence, so the Hogue commission and the Government of Canada could not definitively determine whether those foreign students actually voted and whether or not coercion in fact occurred. I argue here today that if we had enacted the tools in Bill C-70, and if we enact the tools in Bill C-25, the findings of the Hogue commission would have been different regarding Han Dong. I think the findings would have been much worse for Mr. Dong.\n\nI served on the HUMA committee with Mr. Dong in 2020, and it is on the parliamentary record that he spoke more about the need to have better processes and policies in place for foreign students than about any other subject matter when he got to the standing committee in the first place. How can we not, in this House, recognize that Mr. Dong was in fact influenced by those foreign students, or by the PRC officials who brought those foreign students to his nomination? I know that is a bit controversial, but the record stands for itself. Mr. Dong was here to advocate for foreign students from China, not to stand up for his constituents. I believe he was influenced, and I have no problem saying that in this chamber.\n\nWhat I would love the government to do is to move swiftly with Bill C-25. The Liberals have the backing of the Conservatives. Let us tie together some of those third party financing obligations that serve Canadian sovereignty. Let us prevent another situation like that nefarious nomination in 2019. Let us give our law enforcement the tools it needs to protect Canadian sovereignty, and let us improve the processes in this place so there are clear lines of intelligence between our officials and our security apparatus. That does not exist today, but between Bill C-70, with the work the government needs to do today to enact a foreign registry, and the tools in Bill C-25, I believe we are moving in the right direction.\n\nI am going to change subjects here because I would be remiss if I did not take an opportunity during a review of the Canada Elections Act to talk about the very real challenges I faced in 2015. I raise this because in 2015, tons of foreign students participated in my nomination. The most common form of identification was an Indian passport. People would go to the table to vote, and they would write a Canadian address and use an Indian passport. It was horrible. It undermined the confidence of people who had signed up in good faith as Canadian citizens to participate in our electoral process.\n\nI will note that the Conservative Party was following all the rules and that after Liv Grewal technically \"won\" the nomination in 2015, the Conservative Party used the Canada Elections Act, existing measures and its own investigative powers as a political entity in Canada to remove that candidate because of what took place at that nomination. Liv Grewal's father, Gurmant Grewal, a former Conservative member of Parliament, had signed up non-Canadians to participate in that nomination.\n\n The principal problem that happened in 2015 still exists. Under a Canadian ID issued by a province, we do not know whether someone is a Canadian citizen or a permanent resident or a foreign student. Our identification does not outline that key fact. I know this has happened in all parties. It is not a partisan issue. This is a nomination issue with Elections Canada. It happens in every political party. Even under the many good and positive improvements the Conservative Party has made within the context of the Canada Elections Act, when people go to vote, one cannot determine their citizenship. One cannot determine whether someone is simply a permanent resident or a foreign student. That is a wide gap for abuse in our system.\n\n I will note that at the Conservative convention, we tried to pass a resolution to change this. Unfortunately, it did not pass, because many Conservative members made the rightful point that sometimes a permanent resident's first access to Canadian democracy is that vote in a nomination contest. In many parts of the country, for the Liberal Party, the Bloc Québécois and the Conservatives, the nomination itself is the determining factor in who will be the representative in Ottawa. We have to change the law. We have to eliminate the ability of non-Canadian citizens to choose our elected representatives in nomination contests.\n\n The system is not perfect, but I believe that if Bill C-25 took this necessary step, we would avoid some of the abuse I have seen in my own political party, and that has absolutely taken place in every other political party in Canada. The gaps and the outcomes are too large and too enticing for people not to do it. Frankly, it is not even against the law right now, so why would they not do it? I believe that nomination contests to choose candidates should only be for Canadian citizens. That is not the position of my party. That is the position of Brad Vis, but I feel very strongly about that position.\n\nIn 2015, going back to my nomination, I spent a year going around to farms and to gurdwaras. I put myself out there like I had never done before in my life, and I lost. To the Conservative Party's credit, our former lawyer, Arthur Hamilton, recognized there was a problem. Liv Grewal was disqualified. Ironically, the Conservative Party then asked Mike de Jong to run. Mike de Jong was the finance minister for British Columbia at the time. Mike de Jong rejected the invitation from the Conservative Party to be appointed as a candidate, and I was subsequently appointed, three weeks into the writ. I lost that election by 1,000 votes.\n\nWhen I went back and did a poll-by-poll analysis, the neighbourhoods with the highest concentration of Conservative memberships were getting about 10% Conservative support on the day of the election. Every election since then, I go to Homestead Crescent. In 2015, I got 10% there. In 2019, I got about 30% and it has gone up every election. We cannot deny the fact that there were nefarious political actions that were not just. I know for a fact that people who signed up for the Conservative Party absolutely voted Liberal. I know for a fact that there were many people assigned addresses in West Abbotsford who were not Canadian citizens. That skewed our political data, because we did not have the tools to verify citizenship, as I mentioned earlier.\n\nOne of the best ways to improve the integrity of our elections, for all Canadians and for all political parties, is to limit nomination contests solely to Canadians. It is not perfect, but in a country as diverse as ours, with so many foreign pressures and so many diaspora communities that may be influenced by non-state actors in Canada, we have to take that necessary step to protect the integrity of our local races.\n\nI love our democracy. I like the fact that even in challenging times, we can come together and we can agree on improvements in Bill C-25 that would benefit all political parties. That is the right way to go. I hope that all members of Parliament on the procedure and House affairs committee review nomination contests. I know Elections Canada has made a similar recommendation based on stories it has heard from across Canada.\n\nI hope, in good faith, that this bill is amended to include a provision that does not allow for non-Canadians to vote in candidate selections and nominations across Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425358","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in my time today, I want to talk about two specific issues. One is foreign interference in the context of the Hogue commission, and the second is my own experience in the 2015 election and my previous nomination contest at the time.\n\nLet us start with the Hogue commission. What did the Hogue commission say about foreign interference? It concluded that foreign states are actively attem","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e770a69adc39cd4e8c2690af99d0aa9b79f9a6ec5a0160bd739a7b0cb0442209"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75fa154759ebfdaa1b9c87e492cc783417bf27bdf8ad3b11668df8a89d81fe9a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f761e155a4dec0567c051826","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425359,"date":"2026-04-16T17:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will note that Kenny Chiu, a former member of Parliament for Richmond, was the member for one of those ridings in question. Kenny Chiu was originally born in Hong Kong. The PRC targeted Richmond as a result of his statements about the human rights activists in Hong Kong at that time. That is a fact. That was outlined by the Hogue commission as well.\n\n We have the case of Joe Tay and a former member of the Liberal caucus who talked about a bounty on Joe Tay's head in advance of the 2025 election. That individual is no longer in the House of Commons as a result of that.\n\nThose are two very clear examples where the PRC used its influence through organizations like the United Front.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425359","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will note that Kenny Chiu, a former member of Parliament for Richmond, was the member for one of those ridings in question. Kenny Chiu was originally born in Hong Kong. The PRC targeted Richmond as a result of his statements about the human rights activists in Hong Kong at that time. That is a fact. That was outlined by the Hogue commission as well.\n\n We have the case of Joe Tay and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4b26fc28b068e3d9d3f4a249273af512b69eb8c3c2380fcc15497ff960055f0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79f9459d2f364c018336395d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425360,"date":"2026-04-16T17:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a great question. However, I do not agree that the public should be subsidizing political parties through a per-vote subsidy. My reason in opposition to that is that we already have very robust Elections Canada returns, which are in fact subsidies already. \n\nI believe our political parties are best served when grassroots members are willing to put forward their own dollars, with the receipt of a generous tax credit, to show that they really believe in what a political party stands for. It takes effort and it takes engagement on the part of all of us in here and all of the candidates who run in every election to gain public support in a way that is often the hardest: getting people to give us money. However, I think it makes our democracy more accountable when there is no broad-based political subsidy. I believe we are best served when we, as individuals, and our political parties have to fight and justify our roles to the Canadian public.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425360","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a great question. However, I do not agree that the public should be subsidizing political parties through a per-vote subsidy. My reason in opposition to that is that we already have very robust Elections Canada returns, which are in fact subsidies already. \n\nI believe our political parties are best served when grassroots members are willing to put forward their own dollars, wi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c94f0fb7f140a67226d60a3cdc4a2fabce6cad64e233f08453a18cb9f0ee0c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3092c23ddfbed642810c55f4545771e844803db49e36d03e7cb22b2260529be7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebabb90cb71b15eb01356e41","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425361,"date":"2026-04-16T17:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a great question. In preparation for my speech, I thought about it, but the fact is that in 2015 we could not verify one way or the other. Many of those people might have been permanent residents without a Canadian passport and using their Indian passport. That is a fact, and that absolutely happened. \n\nHowever, I think what Elections Canada and this place would need to do, if permanent residents were to continue to participate, is update the licensing requirements at the provincial and territorial level to outline one's status in Canada. That is an easy fix to the issue I am addressing, to outline if one is a permanent resident, a Canadian citizen or here on another type of visa. That is indeed one way we could address my very real concern.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425361","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a great question. In preparation for my speech, I thought about it, but the fact is that in 2015 we could not verify one way or the other. Many of those people might have been permanent residents without a Canadian passport and using their Indian passport. That is a fact, and that absolutely happened. \n\nHowever, I think what Elections Canada and this place would need to do, if","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083605","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Passports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083605","label":"Passports","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","label":"Visas","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e88453b784f2a4af90d00a9fdffc194b8b77acb02072a5639e1cb88f214fbe93"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a2ecb8c68d7a07259f9cdb276274b477106ce5e31d347206100d5c069f753792"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083674","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35b79c352cb86aa42a460720","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425362,"date":"2026-04-16T17:40:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, indeed, the Hogue commission does outline that. Again, my personal belief is that democracy is best served when we have to be accountable to the people. The best way to be accountable to Canadian citizens is to convince them that we are good enough that they can open up their chequebook, especially in this time of an affordability crisis, to say, \"I believe in you, and I'm going to give you my hard-earned money, because I think you can make a difference in our democracy.\" There is no more powerful tool of accountability than one's ability to fundraise one's election and to subsequently win with the support of the grassroots members of our respective communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425362","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, indeed, the Hogue commission does outline that. Again, my personal belief is that democracy is best served when we have to be accountable to the people. The best way to be accountable to Canadian citizens is to convince them that we are good enough that they can open up their chequebook, especially in this time of an affordability crisis, to say, \"I believe in you, and I'm going to gi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d054a6ee03dd386f31b6f9a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425363,"date":"2026-04-16T17:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will acknowledge that Canada does need to improve its relationship with China, but we need to be clear-eyed and realistic about it. Like my colleague from Yorkton—Melville, I was concerned when the government recently signed a new security agreement with the People's Republic of China, even though we have not enacted our foreign registry yet. There would have been much less apprehension about any such type of agreement had the government already fulfilled its duty on Bill C-70, as it said it was going to do over a year ago today.\n\nAgain, I encourage the government members to push their minister of democratic institutions to take the steps he said he was going to take and enact the registry today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425363","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will acknowledge that Canada does need to improve its relationship with China, but we need to be clear-eyed and realistic about it. Like my colleague from Yorkton—Melville, I was concerned when the government recently signed a new security agreement with the People's Republic of China, even though we have not enacted our foreign registry yet. There would have been much less apprehen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["572934869b48b5a222bb3efee68a36249d96733a88667b5e0e1bc654af52b5aa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["689f85d13c1056cbbea40afb30943373210ecb7fb3d6a4946f73fb7b7f0a2d4c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81652322a207afdf3c601e7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425364,"date":"2026-04-16T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, while I find floor crossing to be a reprehensible action, I do not believe that this power should be taken away from individual MPs. Call me a Conservative, but I believe that, at the end of the day, we are all accountable to the people who elected us. I know that there are varying positions on this in every political party. Ultimately, I believe in accountability to the people who elected me to stand as Brad Vis, as the member for Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford, in the chamber to represent them and to use my due judgment to make decisions on their behalf.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425364","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, while I find floor crossing to be a reprehensible action, I do not believe that this power should be taken away from individual MPs. Call me a Conservative, but I believe that, at the end of the day, we are all accountable to the people who elected us. I know that there are varying positions on this in every political party. Ultimately, I believe in accountability to the people who el","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b111f4f68080018a206ad17b2f95021d24d5f7dc45fdcf9431e21ee442c2a904"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fecb9120cc6cc76a8fc295f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425365,"date":"2026-04-16T19:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Canadian Federation of Independent Business released a damning report, saying that Canada is now in an \"entrepreneurial drought\", with more businesses closing than opening for six straight quarters. More than half of small business owners \"would not recommend starting a business\" in this country, and there are now 100,000 fewer entrepreneurs than we had 20 years ago. Most damning is that 73% of survey respondents indicated a lack of confidence in this Liberal government.\n\nWhat is the Prime Minister's response to the alarming decline of entrepreneurship in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425365","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Canadian Federation of Independent Business released a damning report, saying that Canada is now in an \"entrepreneurial drought\", with more businesses closing than opening for six straight quarters. More than half of small business owners \"would not recommend starting a business\" in this country, and there are now 100,000 fewer entrepreneurs than we had 20 years ago. Most damning ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drought","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","label":"Drought","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ce8abaed9641eaf3bb4ab0abbd3b8f9e4663a17c7a29c7787ddb3fab6ff3761"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["29b60a4e43a487fb38e9f63bdfb190203738101e8976dcb55ae358a98b333b0c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b07b94e0f24cf05ad0bd93e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425415,"date":"2026-04-16T19:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, whatever the government is doing, it is not working, and a myriad of programs will not replace the structural forms necessary to improve the entrepreneurial climate in Canada.\n\nSmall businesses indeed are being squeezed from every direction by this government, with higher payroll taxes, rising costs and endless regulations. This government is doing nothing to stop that.\n\nHow many more businesses have to shut their doors before the Prime Minister reverses some of these horrible economic policies and lets Canadian entrepreneurs succeed once again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425415","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, whatever the government is doing, it is not working, and a myriad of programs will not replace the structural forms necessary to improve the entrepreneurial climate in Canada.\n\nSmall businesses indeed are being squeezed from every direction by this government, with higher payroll taxes, rising costs and endless regulations. This government is doing nothing to stop that.\n\nHow many more","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5db5ca3e2331762c37f6569b395567d735e0571dfdd4261b1ec8855732020835"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["36c04ebad34b7f1949a7550c6e1379eb9aa5e86fe453a9c2dad9eecf8ba30e57"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f2b9479226d0fbe099f204e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425416,"date":"2026-04-16T22:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to ask the member for his thoughts in more detail about why the government has failed to enact the foreign registry. The government outlined during debates in the last Parliament that it was an important and necessary tool. It was partly in response to the Hogue commission, yet here we are. On three or four occasions, the government changed the timeline. Why is it being so slow to act on something that is so important? \n\nI also mention this in the context of the new security agreement the government just signed with China. How can we, as parliamentarians, be confident in the approach taken with a foreign government that the Hogue commission outlined as the greatest threat to Canadian democracy and with the new security agreement, when the government has not not enacted the foreign registry to date?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425416","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to ask the member for his thoughts in more detail about why the government has failed to enact the foreign registry. The government outlined during debates in the last Parliament that it was an important and necessary tool. It was partly in response to the Hogue commission, yet here we are. On three or four occasions, the government changed the timeline. Why is it being s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7c917cd4a996eb935da60e140fc74eb9ba2a98e52342cc8c1c33f6950f822052"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["442b680a74606818e44c10a31a7c042b4bf86ed50806a5da1ee3689065d17d94"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-897b709c92059782da27b393","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725183,"date":"2026-04-27T20:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to present several petitions today on behalf of British Columbians and my constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford regarding the salmon allocation policy. Petitioners note that the proposed changes by the government, which could compromise recreational access to coho and chinook, could undermine cultural sensitivities and the long-standing traditions of British Columbians who just want to fish with their families and eat healthy wild salmon.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725183","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to present several petitions today on behalf of British Columbians and my constituents in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford regarding the salmon allocation policy. Petitioners note that the proposed changes by the government, which could compromise recreational access to coho and chinook, could undermine cultural sensitivities and the long-standing traditions of British Columbia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["684e4cb8cf2fdd3da008d47f95fa6213a9d6bd339a72e2c57625d6a92b0135a2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5eea7d6cd6c2b76c5783b58f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725169,"date":"2026-04-28T15:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise to present three petitions.\n\nThe first petition is from the Mission Self Advocacy Group. Petitioners are calling upon the Government of Canada to significantly reduce administrative and paperwork requirements regarding the Canada dental benefit. They want the program to be more accessible and effective for low- and modest-income Canadians and those who have difficulty filling out the enormous amount of paperwork associated with the program.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725169","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today I rise to present three petitions.\n\nThe first petition is from the Mission Self Advocacy Group. Petitioners are calling upon the Government of Canada to significantly reduce administrative and paperwork requirements regarding the Canada dental benefit. They want the program to be more accessible and effective for low- and modest-income Canadians and those who have difficulty fil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f7ed1a2213a5bf393e8fe90ec240d78c3fcc4527f76460b96fcee867805a25a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4037220b697e931b1d01c57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725172,"date":"2026-04-28T15:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present on behalf of my constituents is regarding Bill C-218 and MAID. My constituents are deeply concerned about the proposed expansion of medical assistance in dying to individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness.\n\nPetitioners are calling upon the Government of Canada to support Bill C-218 and halt the expansion of MAID for people with only mental illness as their underlying condition.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725172","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present on behalf of my constituents is regarding Bill C-218 and MAID. My constituents are deeply concerned about the proposed expansion of medical assistance in dying to individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness.\n\nPetitioners are calling upon the Government of Canada to support Bill C-218 and halt the expansion of MAID for peo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Survivor benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","label":"Survivor benefits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4a11be471ce9dbd1925fa321705466ed612550948a61f0068e4fa352c05ad58"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f03e4de298ba9bc077a818cfac290d42c00dbb1bc1d31b69464c7c5f755793c7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da7fc58be02b1e682a7c7b74","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725180,"date":"2026-04-28T15:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the third petition I would like to present is on behalf of the Miami River Streamkeepers. They are calling for sustained funding for conservation efforts at the local level to support British Columbia's iconic salmon species.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725180","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the third petition I would like to present is on behalf of the Miami River Streamkeepers. They are calling for sustained funding for conservation efforts at the local level to support British Columbia's iconic salmon species.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","label":"Resources conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","label":"Resources conservation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30804fbb817ee2235cdb1014be1075272edd4cc7768c635660f56d4deedff142"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["04ffc24c4821f328f4428ad8923afbe7f112a75d09ce2aeebc2bf6ac1365f78b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9115f566c354fc6a0905628","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725164,"date":"2026-04-29T19:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians hoped for relief, but this spring economic statement delivers more of the same. The costly credit card budget means more debt, more costs, more spending and more taxes. Nothing has changed. After years of reckless Liberal policies, families are stretched thin and small businesses continue to struggle. \n\nThe CFIB said this update leaves \"small and medium-sized firms stuck in the same old mix of red tape and high taxes\".\n\n A year ago, the government promised major infrastructure to drive growth. It has failed to deliver, and there is still no credible plan to make its promises a reality. Instead, it has doubled Trudeau's deficit so life is more expensive for Canadians, and no major infrastructure projects are being approved.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725164","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians hoped for relief, but this spring economic statement delivers more of the same. The costly credit card budget means more debt, more costs, more spending and more taxes. Nothing has changed. After years of reckless Liberal policies, families are stretched thin and small businesses continue to struggle. \n\nThe CFIB said this update leaves \"small and medium-sized firms stuck in ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2eb503b105273a5c784fc1264e2208d72f4ebef1be358ff796acd3a1d36d8af7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["38d55c9b561b52f1ac2a4784d3d0034e67d0acfcf94d1477272c59615e5e14e4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d1c3cbbac2418c246bb90d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725168,"date":"2026-04-29T20:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise again today on behalf of residents of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford and surrounding constituencies who are concerned about the future of the recreational fishing industry in British Columbia.\n\nThroughout our history as a province, we have seen salmon as a common property resource, managed in good faith by the Government of Canada. Proposed changes by Fisheries and Oceans Canada to deprioritize recreational access to coho and chinook salmon would damage our recreational industry, which supports businesses and the cultural way of life of all British Columbians who simply want to access our rivers and take part in something all British Columbians have always done: fish to feed their family.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-113/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725168","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise again today on behalf of residents of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford and surrounding constituencies who are concerned about the future of the recreational fishing industry in British Columbia.\n\nThroughout our history as a province, we have seen salmon as a common property resource, managed in good faith by the Government of Canada. Proposed changes by Fisheries and Oceans Canada to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","label":"Fish farming","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4304103a548ccf7b3f2a4957bb4bed6bed84a403a058d20504a56132f4413fc1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ad242dd9a311d706dd32f6e7dbd7c132739d75c683b0dada8d1579b935f842d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7c4b3bf34750c9a6a0e02f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034970,"date":"2026-05-25T19:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are failing to defend Canada's system of private property rights and indefeasible title while sowing confusion and fear among homeowners about whether their land is secure. With the Cowichan decision and the Musqueam agreement raising serious and valid concerns, British Columbians are wondering whether their private property rights will be defended at all, especially after the government constrained its arguments on extinguishment.\n\nWill the Liberal government fix its litigation and negotiation policies and commit to protecting Canadians' property rights by supporting our Conservative motion today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034970","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are failing to defend Canada's system of private property rights and indefeasible title while sowing confusion and fear among homeowners about whether their land is secure. With the Cowichan decision and the Musqueam agreement raising serious and valid concerns, British Columbians are wondering whether their private property rights will be defended at all, especially afte","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b6b5f02cd6ac706e83f4cbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109811,"date":"2026-05-26T23:40:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"FINA","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. My questions will be directed to Mr. Tierney today. Congratulations on your new role with the federation. I represent Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford. In 2021, we experienced one of the most costly natural disasters in Canada. My riding was also burned to the ground in the Fraser Canyon region. Just last year, we had another major catastrophic flood. The Sumas Prairie region of the Fraser Valley has an international airport, and the new national firefighting fleet is being constructed there. We have hydro transmission lines. We have the Enbridge pipeline that was just approved for expansion by the government. We have 37% of all oil going to United States through the Trans Mountain pipeline, and it goes right through the flood zone. The pipeline looked like a toothpick because all the land got washed away around it during the floods. We have an international border crossing. We have a major arterial road connecting the Fraser Valley with Vancouver and the rest of the province. We also have a southern rail line, which is a rail line to the United States, in addition to CN and CP just a few kilometres away in Matsqui Prairie. We are the breadbasket of British Columbia and produce a large majority of the vegetables, fruits, poultry and dairy that are consumed in British Columbia. What advice would you have for Abbotsford, which has not received any additional infrastructure dollars from the federal government to protect national supply chains, the sovereignty of our country and the well-being of millions of people who are connected with these critical infrastructure points?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109811","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. My questions will be directed to Mr. Tierney today. Congratulations on your new role with the federation. I represent Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford. In 2021, we experienced one of the most costly natural disasters in Canada. My riding was also burned to the ground in the Fraser Canyon region. Just last year, we had another major catastrophic flood. The Sumas Prairie region of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","label":"Floods"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","label":"Floods","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7938860f7967bc35091fd4974124fce3af09e164ba0f7ae69ed2cc9402b5c1cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7c18eed2fcba8e2c7c5d20ab712e1f31b04d3ec397b978eda6b703496bda545a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0e8305982b73c1a0bee76fb5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109812,"date":"2026-05-26T23:45:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"FINA","text":"You mentioned the build communities strong fund. I know $6 billion has been allocated out of the $50 billion, over a 10-year period. Would the Federation of Canadian Municipalities be supportive of Abbotsford receiving a portion of that fund to protect this national corridor, the supply chains and the billions of dollars in taxpayer money that is generated from this key area in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109812","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You mentioned the build communities strong fund. I know $6 billion has been allocated out of the $50 billion, over a 10-year period. Would the Federation of Canadian Municipalities be supportive of Abbotsford receiving a portion of that fund to protect this national corridor, the supply chains and the billions of dollars in taxpayer money that is generated from this key area in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc279796f50c6edd061c2c0d4bd3974b357a42f968fb2b5edd0fa5985b30ed00"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15477ce929e25de16197982d543b1e17875864b960ca7696029e26a0d0927e98"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cd599fa2f20e138c8d4e41c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109813,"date":"2026-05-26T23:45:00+00:00","title":"FINA","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"FINA","text":"You mentioned that it was a defining moment. I invite you to Abbotsford. We'd be happy to have you. It's a defining moment for our community. The Fraser Valley is a region that is not really well understood by Ottawa. We're very far away, but when the port of metro Vancouver was cut off from the rest of Canada, that opened up some appreciation for how important we are and how the port of metro Vancouver is connected to all this vital infrastructure as well. Thank you for your time today. I look forward to seeing you. That's my time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FINA/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109813","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"You mentioned that it was a defining moment. I invite you to Abbotsford. We'd be happy to have you. It's a defining moment for our community. The Fraser Valley is a region that is not really well understood by Ottawa. We're very far away, but when the port of metro Vancouver was cut off from the rest of Canada, that opened up some appreciation for how important we are and how the port of metro Van","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-92594b3b864c03b4b98fb078","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034966,"date":"2026-05-27T21:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have several petitions to present today.\n\n The first one is regarding the alarming increase in repeat violent offenders being released on bail. The petitioners have witnessed a sharp increase in car theft, gang violence and drug-related deaths. In fact, one constituent warned me about a car theft at my house just this week. Violent crimes have increased by 50%. Violent gun crime has surged by 116%. In 2022, 256 Canadians were tragically killed by people out on bail, thanks to Liberal catch-and-release policies under Bill C-75. \n\nThe petitioners are calling on the Minister of Justice, urgently, to reform Canada's bail laws and restore safety on our streets.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034966","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have several petitions to present today.\n\n The first one is regarding the alarming increase in repeat violent offenders being released on bail. The petitioners have witnessed a sharp increase in car theft, gang violence and drug-related deaths. In fact, one constituent warned me about a car theft at my house just this week. Violent crimes have increased by 50%. Violent gun crime has","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","label":"Gangs","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1c6eab2c479337c2c6c4f961290c584eb2a39017c3926cf4a48a2ca0434a0c65"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bf7ae97548ffca49854c9d2da9571ca67ea44e6373689ef89d1d030b0d949f1e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5005dcdfadffcf5314491115","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034968,"date":"2026-05-27T21:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is regarding the ongoing challenges British Columbians are facing regarding recreational access to coho and chinook in British Columbia.\n\n Constituents are calling in good faith on the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans to leave the current salmon allocation policy alone and to uphold the cultural rights and traditions of all British Columbians to access fish, especially on the Fraser River.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034968","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is regarding the ongoing challenges British Columbians are facing regarding recreational access to coho and chinook in British Columbia.\n\n Constituents are calling in good faith on the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans to leave the current salmon allocation policy alone and to uphold the cultural rights and traditions of all British Col","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["226c105c4bff41dfec4da4d912229274f8f2586ab771b1ec639acd817d45707b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d647739ce2b5bd1fb55f4b9b6e9e59e52f938b112c4c6809fcd955b87b29bd80"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-948ed3aa71b6ca9baafdd432","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034969,"date":"2026-05-27T21:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the final petition I would like to present today is on behalf of Canadian organic growers who are concerned about the closure of the organic and regenerative research program at the Swift Current Research and Development Centre. \n\nPetitioners note that this was the only dedicated organic research initiative within Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. Therefore, they call on the government to reinstate the program and strengthen public research in organic and regenerative agriculture within Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada to align with the government's own goals of increasing agricultural exports abroad.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034969","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the final petition I would like to present today is on behalf of Canadian organic growers who are concerned about the closure of the organic and regenerative research program at the Swift Current Research and Development Centre. \n\nPetitioners note that this was the only dedicated organic research initiative within Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. Therefore, they call on the governmen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["252942dd85b29887a740d16fbffffdc2fdb3131917c6feb87817123795435510"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f20068f44fcf803bde0976340bc8782700ad791603b87215a9badf23ef92d54"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9220976cf03b2f060b58397a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083785,"date":"2026-06-01T20:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, today I am pleased to table several petitions.\n\nNotably, on the salmon allocation policy in British Columbia, British Columbians are fearful that the Minister of Fisheries is going to take their cultural rights away through amending the Pacific salmon allocation policy and removing recreational access for coho and chinook salmon specifically. Therefore, petitioners are calling on the Minister of Fisheries to leave the current salmon allocation policy alone and uphold the cultural rights of all British Columbians to this common property resource.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083785","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, today I am pleased to table several petitions.\n\nNotably, on the salmon allocation policy in British Columbia, British Columbians are fearful that the Minister of Fisheries is going to take their cultural rights away through amending the Pacific salmon allocation policy and removing recreational access for coho and chinook salmon specifically. Therefore, petitioners are calling on the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["808d2cbf9a3d5ea4ab20a00921de0106fc1a93d472e032b4059bbb14be10bf82"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31a38f2f31391cea4c6c2fae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083786,"date":"2026-06-01T20:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of concerned Canadians who are worried about the state of human trafficking in Canada.\n\nHuman trafficking continues to rise, and too many people are being victimized as a result of our weak laws on this subject. Therefore, petitioners are calling upon the Government of Canada to strengthen the Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act to address these shortcomings and put an end to human trafficking in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083786","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of concerned Canadians who are worried about the state of human trafficking in Canada.\n\nHuman trafficking continues to rise, and too many people are being victimized as a result of our weak laws on this subject. Therefore, petitioners are calling upon the Government of Canada to strengthen the Protection of Communities and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","label":"Human trafficking"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime against humanity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime against humanity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034722","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime against humanity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034722","label":"Crime against humanity","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","label":"Human trafficking","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e8f013f4193e800b5317591a45ab4efee9ae5c65c9e08cb566ee7ee8cdb531c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["edc6d0576b18315cf6407ebac51604bb11e01d7f32347e8f44467e020ecebc0c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32eb42234ebd67e4cfc6fcc3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083787,"date":"2026-06-01T20:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, finally, the third petition I would like to present today is on behalf of Canadian organic growers. They are specifically concerned about the policies of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada and the closing of the research program at the Swift Current Research and Development Centre. If the Government of Canada truly wants to double its exports abroad, attacking the organic agricultural sector will not get it there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083787","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, finally, the third petition I would like to present today is on behalf of Canadian organic growers. They are specifically concerned about the policies of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada and the closing of the research program at the Swift Current Research and Development Centre. If the Government of Canada truly wants to double its exports abroad, attacking the organic agricultural s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a7e70c61a104cdc5dd3ff1d81420430968fa00feb5cd6a8a4648321d08b6ec98"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c679082594449c7e0e1a7c6481c5da532142a0bc14d9c7264aa57029dc22c1d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-659a7336f4a6208390fe3416","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083788,"date":"2026-06-01T21:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, recently, there were 112,300 job losses in the first three months of this year alone, with 485,000 more Canadians unemployed since the member for Nepean became the Prime Minister. What is the economic impact of a Prime Minister who does not take our job losses seriously in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083788","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, recently, there were 112,300 job losses in the first three months of this year alone, with 485,000 more Canadians unemployed since the member for Nepean became the Prime Minister. What is the economic impact of a Prime Minister who does not take our job losses seriously in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["20aba05c0c880f25d7ac291917ab4560d99437d98f191352939a079ecf22e70b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e2e420d25c4e093a33d16b02fbca9aa36e6e1b2dce4900ae6df3658e81edec87"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54bb73a0610c0be524aeec15","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083789,"date":"2026-06-01T21:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, before I begin, I want to say that I will be sharing my time with the member for Mirabel.\n\nBefore I begin, BC School Sports hosted the high schools' rugby championships in Abbotsford last week. There were thousands of young boys and girls from across the province who competed in sevens and 15s. Our very own in Abbotsford, the Yale Lions senior girls rugby team, won the provincial championships, and the Robert Bateman Timberwolves senior boys team came in second in the province. The WJ Mouat girls, the Yale boys, and the Abbotsford senior boys all did phenomenally well.\n\n We are blessed to have the infrastructure to host such an event in Abbotsford. It truly does lift up the profile of our local economy, and the ability to host major sporting events creates lasting memories for so many young athletes. As the member of Parliament for Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford, I give special congratulations to all the phenomenal athletes on the Yale girls team in particular. They ran an amazing game of running rugby and totally dominated their opposition. It was just a joy to watch.\n\nMy plug is to the Secretary of State for Sport, who has $700 million to hand out to sporting organizations. On a per capita basis, Abbotsford produces more Olympic athletes in the sport of rugby and more national team players than any other community in this country. I hope to see some of those infrastructure dollars there to improve our aging recreational infrastructure.\n\n Now to Bill C-31, a Canadian Venture Capital and Private Equity Association report found that in the first quarter of 2026, Canadian venture capital investing dropped to its lowest level in nearly a decade. Venture capital investment fell nearly 77% quarter over quarter. For every dollar of foreign direct investment coming into Canada, two dollars have left, the largest capital exodus in Canadian history.\n\n Since the Liberals came to power, Canada has lost $1 trillion of investment, largely into the arms of our American friends. It is very unusual for Canadian businesses to go through this significant a period of negative growth as we are experiencing right now.\n\nAs we reflect on Bill C-31, why not take some actions to protect small businesses? I believe small businesses have largely been ignored by this government. Many business organizations across Canada are calling for some changes to the tax code, like the small business deduction threshold, which has been set at $500,000 since 2009. The threshold has not kept pace with inflation, rising input costs or higher interest rates. This creates a cliff effect, where growing businesses are pushed into a higher tax bracket, discouraging investment and expansion.\n\n Business organizations have requested that the government increase the small business deduction threshold to $700,000 and index it to the CPI year after year. This would allow our truly small businesses in Canada to take advantage of the 9% tax rate and really make a difference in our economy. Let us support our small businesses.\n\n Second, another thing the government could have done in the last year, which would have made a huge difference in the lives of our entrepreneurs, is that it could have addressed the small business GST threshold. This was created in 1991, and it is currently set at $30,000. It was originally designed to limit GST collection to large businesses. Over two decades later, the threshold value has been eroded by inflation, and more businesses are now required to register, collect and remit GST than originally intended.\n\n I believe the government, in the last year, could have changed its policy and increased the threshold to $60,000 to reduce red tape for truly small businesses, the ones where people go to work every day and pay lots of taxes in Canada. Including these measures in Bill C-31, along with other GST/HST adjustments, would have provided SMEs with real financial relief, yet nothing has changed in the last year.\n\nThe Liberals are still looking for big headline wins, while forgetting that most people in our private sector do in fact work for small firms. They are forgetting about small businesses that do not have lawyers who can apply for complex programs. They just do not have the time to do this, because they are actually running a business. Let me give an example: the tariff rebate programs.\n\nAt a time when Canadian small businesses have faced real economic pressure because of American tariffs, the government has not come forward with meaningful support to help them. It promised that the tariff revenues would be reinvested to help the sectors hit the hardest, but that promise has simply not been met. The regional tariff response initiative was supposed to be the vehicle for that support. Instead it has become a case study in poor execution.\n\nThe Secretary of State for Small Business has consistently framed the program as accessible and supportive, but in reality it has created more red tape, cutting out local small businesses. In January this year, the National Post reported that 80% of businesses were not even aware that this program existed, and only 8% said they intended to apply. In British Columbia, seven out of 10 businesses were not even eligible for the program itself, despite paying those tariffs. CFIB president, Dan Kelly, called the regional tariff response initiative totally useless.\n\nThe challenges facing small businesses are not unique. I heard many of the concerns from business leaders across the Fraser Valley earlier this month at the Fraser Valley Economic Summit 2026 in Abbotsford, when more than 200 leaders from business, local government, indigenous communities, educational institutions and industry came together to discuss the future of our regional economy. Throughout the summit, speakers and participants spoke about the need for transportation corridors, trade-enabling infrastructure, industrial land, workforce development, housing and energy systems. They asked how Canada can improve productivity if businesses cannot access those infrastructure dollars.\n\nThe Fraser Valley is one of Canada's most important economic regions. The region is expected to grow by nearly 47% by 2050, bringing new opportunities for investment, job creation and agricultural exports in particular. Realizing that potential will require governments to focus on the practical conditions that allow communities to grow and succeed. We see this reflected across multiple sectors of the economy, including financial services.\n\nCanada benefits from having some of the largest and most stable banks in the world. However, there remains a significant gap between the country's largest financial institutions and smaller local providers. A local example is Tru Cooperative Bank, formerly First West Credit Union, which began its federal continuance process in 2018 but did not receive final approval until 2026.\n\nIf Canada wants greater competition in financial services, we need to create the conditions for strong, Canadian-owned, mid-sized institutions to grow and to compete nationally. This is in line with the policies of every political party in Canada: free trade between our provinces, more economic exchange between Canadians. It took eight years to get federal approval for one of the most established cooperatives in British Columbia. That is not acceptable. If Canada wants greater competition in financial services, it needs to look at reducing red tape and prioritizing the private enterprises that are willing to take the risk and put up the capital to expand and offer better services to Canada.\n\nWe could say the same thing about open banking right now as well, and the same policies apply to infrastructure. The government announced, in the budget last year, the build communities strong fund as a major investment in those fields. The program does allocate $6 billion directly for regionally significant projects, including climate adaptation and flood protection infrastructure.\n\nI implore the House of Commons not to forget Abbotsford and the Fraser Valley when they think of the allocation of that money. In my riding in the Fraser Valley, the Trans Mountain pipeline sends 37% of its oil across the flood zone into the United States. That is billions of dollars into the coffers every single year to the Government of Canada.\n\nThe recent Enbridge pipeline expansion goes right through the flood zone as well. We have a major border crossing, we have an international airport, and we have a Southern Railway line that brings billions of dollars of Canadian goods into America every year, benefiting our country, yet since the floods in 2021, we have not received any infrastructure dollars to protect one of the most important economic regions in all of Canada. Again, I ask the government to not forget about the Fraser Valley. The government needs it to accomplish its goals. Canada needs our region to build up better.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083789","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, before I begin, I want to say that I will be sharing my time with the member for Mirabel.\n\nBefore I begin, BC School Sports hosted the high schools' rugby championships in Abbotsford last week. There were thousands of young boys and girls from across the province who competed in sevens and 15s. Our very own in Abbotsford, the Yale Lions senior girls rugby team, won the provincial ch","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7137d342b51e481a6a676bb77e619f69ee85573c1551d1a316173bc30153eaa1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61837da58d15cd4b37f676536d087d19a1d561eb7118f817700c065d12fe32fb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cba2dd1688e65b1fd304f53d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083790,"date":"2026-06-01T21:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, indeed, the Conservatives voted in favour of removing all federal regulations on interprovincial trade, but the fact of the matter is that the Prime Minister promised there would be free trade amongst the provinces in Canada. What we needed in that moment was federal leadership, for the Prime Minister to say to the provinces and territories that if they do not remove their barriers in professional services, financial services and transportation, there will be consequences.\n\nThe Prime Minister was not willing to expend the necessary political capital to remove the provincially related barriers to interprovincial trade in Canada. That is a failure of his leadership, and a promise broken that he made.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59492","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Free trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083790","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, indeed, the Conservatives voted in favour of removing all federal regulations on interprovincial trade, but the fact of the matter is that the Prime Minister promised there would be free trade amongst the provinces in Canada. What we needed in that moment was federal leadership, for the Prime Minister to say to the provinces and territories that if they do not remove their barriers ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59492","label":"Free trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59492","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Free trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59492","label":"Free trade","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5abc2eb820b8573d15342244bbdd31d7e0c72a1328c60d90db6a817cd7c38056"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59492","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Free trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d491299e6b1626beb7627ef139a0ce74c710815154214a0f77a0a9af6e0c2c78"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59492","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Free trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59492","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Free trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59492","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b07a3b36c8b8223c97c0138","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083791,"date":"2026-06-01T21:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member for Mirabel needs to ask his constituents why it is easier for a small and medium-sized enterprise in his province to trade with the northeast United States. Why is it easier for a Quebec company to do business with America than with a company in British Columbia?\n\nI believe in a federation where it is easier to do trade among Canadian provinces first, before doing it with a foreign country. If the Bloc Québécois continues taking that position, it is going to minimize its economic impact and the ability of its province's enterprises to grow accordingly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083791","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member for Mirabel needs to ask his constituents why it is easier for a small and medium-sized enterprise in his province to trade with the northeast United States. Why is it easier for a Quebec company to do business with America than with a company in British Columbia?\n\nI believe in a federation where it is easier to do trade among Canadian provinces first, before doing it wit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6f964cc4e602559748a5ded5f2901786b1b1440e0208291d449bf9153078e4a7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["37aa133d0bfae270134c9e36397a29afa34ec658cef2de7dc8ab1e9af537b6c9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-596259b2ff4264da7f226a2b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083792,"date":"2026-06-01T21:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I would say that my constituents are very apprehensive right now. They have heard a lot of mixed messages from the Prime Minister. On one hand, he says that we are at economic war with the United States and will take heavy-handed language here in Canada. The next day, he goes down to America and says we need to \"make America great again.\" They really do not know what to make of the rhetoric. What all the businesses in my region talk about is maintaining our market access to their American partners.\n\nCanadians across this country have long-established business relationships with their American customers and partners. We need to secure that while also looking at opportunities abroad. That is a good thing, but make no mistake; we cannot replace the American relationship, and the Prime Minister needs to be clear on that point, because it is causing concern by the many Canadian businesses that are reliant on their American partners. We have to maintain that market access first and foremost, which is going to require more political leadership and the government's being transparent about what type of deals it is cutting with the American administration and whether that serves Canada's interests well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083792","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I would say that my constituents are very apprehensive right now. They have heard a lot of mixed messages from the Prime Minister. On one hand, he says that we are at economic war with the United States and will take heavy-handed language here in Canada. The next day, he goes down to America and says we need to \"make America great again.\" They really do not know what to make of the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment abroad","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035045","label":"Employment abroad","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["664bce5d5e40fe74f2f5aaaa644c9647984d899c69c2a438a10c5fa8259069ae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2afa775ca01cf8a568eabdf8a1f198c2cbc46d8a2069b17227e02dc92c8074fd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f32be0301cbd4f093491e1d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083783,"date":"2026-06-02T20:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in March, the government increased the temporary foreign worker program from 10% to 15% for thousands of work sites in remote and rural communities across Canada. At the same time, Canada lost 112,000 jobs in that same period of time and the youth unemployment rate was at 14.3%. \n\nThrough my Order Paper question yesterday, we learned that the program for temporary foreign workers cost $1.6 billion with a net loss of $509 million. What will the government say to the hundreds of thousands of unemployed youth in this country when they are increasing the number of temporary foreign workers this year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083783","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in March, the government increased the temporary foreign worker program from 10% to 15% for thousands of work sites in remote and rural communities across Canada. At the same time, Canada lost 112,000 jobs in that same period of time and the youth unemployment rate was at 14.3%. \n\nThrough my Order Paper question yesterday, we learned that the program for temporary foreign workers cost","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","label":"Foreign aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e77fd5df1480371dec46a6bc777c99b0c1ec49f5828804d81c4bec1f895f3c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["370c457b89a8a6dd19af6889f363b1853b7d3fb2b940a9c6a72f07216ab38518"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7e3ae4a649f0ed28ae9a368","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083784,"date":"2026-06-02T22:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, before I begin, I just want to say that the speech by my colleague, the member for Calgary Heritage, was so wonderful and well informed. My words tonight will not meet that threshold.\n\n What I am here to talk about is shawarma. My first introduction to Arab culture was at Mr. Falafel. It is on 10th Avenue near my old university, the University of British Columbia. I was a poor student, and I probably had enough money to eat out once a week. When I went there and got that big, juicy shawarma sandwich, it was a highlight of my week. I still love eating it. In fact I went back just a few weeks ago to visit some entrepreneurs at UBC, and I stopped by Mr. Falafel. They have been in business for 26 years now. I love that restaurant. It speaks to what many Arabs do when they come to Canada: They start small businesses. They, disproportionately, start small businesses, and they make a positive impact in Canada's economy.\n\n Another shawarma place I have been frequenting since my university days is Shawarma King. It is right up the road on Bank Street. In fact, my buddy Mo has been serving me shawarma there since about 2008, when I moved to Ottawa to do my master's degree at Carleton University. I eat there probably once a week, even to this day. It is nice going to Shawarma King, a long-established shawarma joint in Ottawa, after a long day on Parliament Hill, to talk to my buddy Mo. The food is just incredible: the eggplant, the cauliflower, the mixed beef and chicken, the tahini sauce on top and the tabbouleh salad. I love this food. I think it is the greatest food in the world.\n\n Another place is Falafel King on Denman Street in Vancouver. It serves the best carrot soup I have had in my entire life. Whenever I go to English Bay, I have to stop by Falafel King and get the carrot soup. They also put a lot of tahini on their chicken, and I can never go wrong with that dish. It is honestly one of the best meals, and it brings me joy every time I get to eat it.\n\n There is another place, a new one, and it is a good one. I went to Ajax on a small business tour a few months ago, and I went to Aleppo Kebab. The owner is a Syrian refugee. He used to have a shawarma joint in Syria that served all the tourists who would go to the Roman ruins. Unfortunately, due to all the conflict in that country, he had to come to Canada, but like many people who come from Syria and other Arab countries, he did not sit around getting welfare; he started a business. The shawarma barbecue I got at Aleppo Kebab in Ajax is the best Middle Eastern barbecue I have had in my entire life. It makes sense, as the owner's family has been doing this for generations, and he is a really good businessman.\n\n I love Middle Eastern food. I am giving these examples because they are real and people can relate to them, but they also speak to the broader impact that shawarma restaurants have had for small business in Canada. Another great example of Middle Eastern food has come from some families I have helped in my job. An Iraqi family has given me Iraqi dolma. It is wrapped in a leaf, and it is just mouth-wateringly delicious. They put some rice and lamb in a compressed pot with tomatoes and all sorts of spices. I cannot find better food than what there is in the Middle East. It just blows my mind, and it warms my heart every single time.\n\nThe bill we are discussing today is about recognizing Arab contributions to Canadian society. Arab Canadians have had an outweighted impact in terms of food. Shawarma is the greatest food in the world, and I think it is the best form of fast food in the world. Every chance I get to eat it, I am going to continue doing so. I thank all the shawarma restaurants across Canada for keeping me fit and in better shape, not going for a burger or something less helpful, because their food is just so amazing.\n\nWhen I speak to many of the new immigrants from countries in the Middle East, they do not want to stop at shawarma restaurants. Their frustration with Canada relates to skills recognition. The reason some of these entrepreneurs are so good with their restaurants is that, in their home countries, they were running engineering firms. They were doctors at regional hospitals. They were orthopaedic surgeons. Canada must and can do a better job of admitting people and allowing for their previous work experience to be recognized in Canada. \n\nThe common story that has been shared in the House of Commons thousands of times is that of a cab driver or shawarma restaurant owner who had this great career abroad. They came to Canada on the points system, not necessarily as a refugee, but as soon as they got here, they found it almost impossible to practise the profession that got them here in the very first place. \n\nThe Liberal government has made commitments to improve skills recognition. I hope to see those promises fulfilled. I think that is a good thing for Canada and a good thing for our economy. Provincial governments across the board have done so as well.\n\n If we take anything from the legislation before us here today, it is that very point: We will not see the full potential of Arab citizens in Canada if we do not modernize our immigration system and our skills recognition to allow people to flourish in the way we want every new Canadian to flourish in our country.\n\nI am thankful for the time to speak today. It was wonderful to talk about amazing shawarma in the House of Commons.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083784","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, before I begin, I just want to say that the speech by my colleague, the member for Calgary Heritage, was so wonderful and well informed. My words tonight will not meet that threshold.\n\n What I am here to talk about is shawarma. My first introduction to Arab culture was at Mr. Falafel. It is on 10th Avenue near my old university, the University of British Columbia. I was a poor student","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["21f6c5bc46584c2ff84fd66eff266aa8f620efaabeed96b1b02ebce5748e2861"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d744bc05da5ece7c0c1abf8a2a8ecf84428e582dee7d1ed350c46c21b5776af"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-600cee95f214d7aec5628573","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083777,"date":"2026-06-03T21:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on behalf of British Columbian recreational anglers who are concerned about proposed changes to recreational access for coho and chinook salmon, specifically along the Fraser River, in a revised policy by the Government of Canada.\n\nPetitioners call upon the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans to maintain current access for recreational fishers; to not prioritize commercial access for these two species, as is the case for other salmon species, to maintain the recreational fishing economy; and to allow all British Columbians to practice their cultural traditions of harvesting safe, beautiful food that feeds their families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083777","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on behalf of British Columbian recreational anglers who are concerned about proposed changes to recreational access for coho and chinook salmon, specifically along the Fraser River, in a revised policy by the Government of Canada.\n\nPetitioners call upon the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans to maintain current access for recreational fishers; to not prioritize commercial a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e1fb7f0e2ed09bd70a7339821d02b3628da637a93ab3cae50667dfaf674d32d7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3199ab22e052cd53b914482ba373c6b31e94c85a44792c012e9d24aa1c769a44"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99ce573bbd419572ca888970","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083778,"date":"2026-06-03T22:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, during the amendment stage, the Conservative Party put forward CPC‐13. It would have protected child pornography possession and access offences from charter challenges under sections 7 and 12 by enacting the notwithstanding clause while also preventing these offences from benefiting from the bill's mandatory minimum safety valve. \n\nDoes the Bloc Québécois believe that the government has done enough to prosecute individuals who look at child pornography in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43805","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Pornography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083778","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, during the amendment stage, the Conservative Party put forward CPC‐13. It would have protected child pornography possession and access offences from charter challenges under sections 7 and 12 by enacting the notwithstanding clause while also preventing these offences from benefiting from the bill's mandatory minimum safety valve. \n\nDoes the Bloc Québécois believe that the government h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43805","label":"Pornography"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43805","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Pornography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43805","label":"Pornography","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1e29a7f04de346ae063fdcaed50a8bd0d9e548400c6e75ec8668c6e24025eb5b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43805","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Pornography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cedaf642fb32254c4bf8391321e53cc6e462eb6268f4176afcd80794fa56666a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43805","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Pornography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43805","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dcbe500a7e02f7ddffecc0ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083779,"date":"2026-06-03T22:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, at the amendment stage, Conservatives put forward CPC-13, which would have protected child pornography possession and access offences from charter challenges under sections 7 and 12 by enacting a notwithstanding clause, while also preventing those offences from benefiting from the bill's mandatory minimum safety valve.\n\nI know the member to be an hon. member. I still cannot get around the fact that the Liberals would not support these Conservative amendments, which would have protected the most vulnerable in our society and ensured a level of justice for victims of child pornography. I still cannot get my head around the fact that the government will not support these measures.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083779","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, at the amendment stage, Conservatives put forward CPC-13, which would have protected child pornography possession and access offences from charter challenges under sections 7 and 12 by enacting a notwithstanding clause, while also preventing those offences from benefiting from the bill's mandatory minimum safety valve.\n\nI know the member to be an hon. member. I still cannot get around","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd1f352c720587167ee977b233bb9f5ebbcd8eddf3973a52f05a1cc24a22f46d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d53f32fd7628e0f7e072fab4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083780,"date":"2026-06-03T23:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, right now in Canada, clawbacks for old age security commence at $95,000, but individuals aged 65 to 74 earning up to $152,000 and those over 75 earning up to $157,000 can still receive old age security. While I understand the intent of the legislation before us today and what the member is referring to, does she not understand that the costs for old age security would exceed $100 billion within the next five years? How are my children going to pay for this monumental expense?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083780","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, right now in Canada, clawbacks for old age security commence at $95,000, but individuals aged 65 to 74 earning up to $152,000 and those over 75 earning up to $157,000 can still receive old age security. While I understand the intent of the legislation before us today and what the member is referring to, does she not understand that the costs for old age security would exceed $100 bill","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c3d02b9c9eec25f5fbb1bb46b2b521d2d5cfc294fbe2e8085fa26fdea6974baf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ffb4e3e35efec07d373c5540a6a55426df306f74dc28b3ec02da7bacb374b1a9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fba36a0533a3ab28a227f52","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083781,"date":"2026-06-04T00:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, a few weeks ago, I asked the Prime Minister a simple question: Will the Liberal government defend the private property rights of British Columbians in response to the Cowichan decision, yes or no? The member for Vancouver Fraserview—South Burnaby said that Conservatives, myself included, were fearmongering. However, British Columbians were not imagining what was happening. Real people and real businesses are already feeling the consequences of the Cowichan decision. Real estate deals have been abandoned. The provincial government has had to backstop mortgages, and investment is draining out of British Columbia. A survey from the Business Council of British Columbia found that almost 74% of B.C. businesses plan to decrease investment due to uncertainty over DRIPA, which is the provincial equivalent of the federal UNDRIP legislation; 73% said it is harder to access external financing; and one in three respondents said they are reducing hiring plans.\n\nThe CEO of Wesbild Holdings said to Global News, \"If you asked us today whether we're going to invest in land in B.C., the answer is no.\" In March, the Vancouver Sun reported that property values in Richmond could decrease by up to 40%. For many families, that means their home, their biggest asset, is suddenly at risk. This is not theoretical. Business owners and homeowners are facing the consequences of the government's refusal or denial to prioritize and protect fee simple titles.\n\nLast week, the government could have made a commitment to defend private property and remove previous instructions to its lawyers. Instead, it left British Columbia in further uncertainty, sending a signal that Canada is becoming a riskier place to invest. Thankfully, the Supreme Court refused to hear the New Brunswick Wolastoqey Nation case.\n\nConservatives will continue to push the government to pursue a policy and a legal position that protects private property rights for all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083781","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, a few weeks ago, I asked the Prime Minister a simple question: Will the Liberal government defend the private property rights of British Columbians in response to the Cowichan decision, yes or no? The member for Vancouver Fraserview—South Burnaby said that Conservatives, myself included, were fearmongering. However, British Columbians were not imagining what was happening. Real people","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["673f1d563273740d8bf0f60488fb0135ece51b0de471ece2c5b361924b6b278a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["332c24848ab018b97706448c81142a94775cb2156400db21146f5104d327daa5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f5b993511f51efe209e39fe1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083782,"date":"2026-06-04T00:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for his response this evening. I am glad he raised the Montrose application.\n\nWhat is problematic is that when the court case commenced, it was only the City of Richmond and not the Government of Canada that explicitly made arguments in favour of fee simple land. Part of the uncertainty today is because the Government of Canada did not make those arguments or use the language that even the parliamentary secretary is using this evening in favour of property rights.\n\n My hope for British Columbia is that the Government of Canada revises its legal arguments with the opportunity from the Montrose application and stands firmly in favour of private property rights to move Canada's economy forward and improve exports out of British Columbia, which are in question as a result of this case.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083782","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for his response this evening. I am glad he raised the Montrose application.\n\nWhat is problematic is that when the court case commenced, it was only the City of Richmond and not the Government of Canada that explicitly made arguments in favour of fee simple land. Part of the uncertainty today is because the Government of Canada did not make those arguments or use th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ac429545dc5b59a92a5446111a98d4f57b94d1b1034230875ac848712a01107"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-557f26db74b64a935b78d969","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085694,"date":"2026-06-09T19:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on this side of the House of Commons, we believe in the incredible potential of Canadian youth, yet the Bank of Canada says the surge in temporary foreign workers is driving down wages and making it harder for young Canadians to find jobs. The youth unemployment rate sits at over 14%.\n\n While Conservatives would prioritize jobs for Canadian youth, the Liberals are still flooding the labour market with temporary foreign workers when young Canadians cannot find work. Why?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085694","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on this side of the House of Commons, we believe in the incredible potential of Canadian youth, yet the Bank of Canada says the surge in temporary foreign workers is driving down wages and making it harder for young Canadians to find jobs. The youth unemployment rate sits at over 14%.\n\n While Conservatives would prioritize jobs for Canadian youth, the Liberals are still flooding the l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a0812ee22efcd52d5489a62d001c88cede4936bd79f8c324c59dcef5b6e15c1b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c2f83d031025cba4ff08395ff849b10640b20a965fba986bdb2006ab3ea56f60"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29f6a3c02ebae1770419a0ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085695,"date":"2026-06-09T19:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, young Canadians do appreciate the Canada summer jobs, but it does not omit the fact that this government let in over 170,000 foreign workers in the last four quarters. These programs were meant to be temporary, but under this government, they have become permanent and unchecked. The Globe and Mail calls it an \"enduring problem\" created by Ottawa's overreliance on foreign workers.\n\n Why has this government let the temporary foreign worker program spiral out of control, and when will it finally rein it in?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085695","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, young Canadians do appreciate the Canada summer jobs, but it does not omit the fact that this government let in over 170,000 foreign workers in the last four quarters. These programs were meant to be temporary, but under this government, they have become permanent and unchecked. The Globe and Mail calls it an \"enduring problem\" created by Ottawa's overreliance on foreign workers.\n\n Wh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e9165f26d38d40f05a51c5147412b23fb4b69f6dd36f18a0d9d59f134ee1ff53"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a10ad4a9df8ae66fd643e364","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085690,"date":"2026-06-11T16:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, before I begin my formal remarks, I want to outline that the City of Abbotsford is launching its consultations this June on the Sumas River watershed flood mitigation plan. Earlier this month, the cities of Princeton, Merritt, Hope, Chilliwack and Abbotsford launched the west coast corridor resiliency partnership.\n\nExcuse my skepticism today, but with the bill before us, Bill C‐26, and the corresponding programming motion, we would essentially be granting, without any parliamentary oversight, $1.7 billion to the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure to fund certain projects at their discretion without any parliamentary oversight. That is what we are debating today. I would encourage the minister to consider Abbotsford and the 2021 floods we had. When a minister takes action like this, I know that we can do the same for a region of British Columbia that is essential for the government to meet its own export and infrastructure goals.\n\nBill C‐26 is two paragraphs long. It basically would grant the minister unfettered spending abilities with $1.7 billion. Forgive my skepticism, but I do not want to authorize and will not support another dollar of taxpayer money's going to a government that has so resoundingly failed on the housing platform, starting in 2016, so with my time today, I am going to share a few remarks about fiscal accountability. I am going to outline some of the most egregious examples of how the government has mismanaged money. I am going to talk about flood infrastructure in the Fraser Valley. If the government can take quick action like this, why can it not take quick action on a project of national interest with clear accountability metrics?\n\nThen I am going to go over the national housing strategy the Liberals launched in 2016, the National Housing Strategy Act, what they said at the time about these bills and what they hoped to accomplish. I look forward to reviewing federal program spending on housing affordability dating back to 2019 with the Parliamentary Budget Officer. I will have some other comments tying all those points together. Finally, I might even bring a motion forward to amend the programming motion before us today.\n\nLet us start with fiscal accountability. I want to start by speaking about a cornerstone of our democratic system, parliamentary accountability, specifically how it operates in the context of federal spending legislation in Canada. At its heart, parliamentary accountability ensures that the government, which exercises the power to tax and spend, remains answerable to the elected representatives of the people of the House. That duty goes to the very heart of our parliamentary system and why we are here.\n\nThe power of the purse is one of the oldest and most fundamental principles of Westminster democracy. It was hard fought over for centuries, from the struggles between Parliament and the Crown in the United Kingdom to the evolution of responsible government here in Canada. The principle is simple: Governments may propose spending, but only Parliament can authorize it, and that authorization must be informed, transparent and accountable. This is not a ceremonial role. It is not a rubber stamp. It is a safeguard on behalf of taxpayers.\n\nAt first glance, the bill appears straightforward. It would authorize $1.7 billion in payments to provinces and territories to address housing supply, but as parliamentarians, our responsibility does not end with the stated intent of a bill or the comments from one of the ministers responsible, during his remarks in the House. Our duty is to examine how public money is authorized, how it is spent and whether it is subject to meaningful oversight.\n\nIn Canada, this principle is embedded in our Constitution and operationalized through the financial procedures of Parliament. The House of Commons plays a central role in reviewing and approving federal expenditures. Standing committees examine departmental estimates and call ministers and officials to testify and justify their spending plans in detail, at least in an ideal world.\n\nHowever, accountability does not end once funds are approved. In fact, it continues through the fiscal cycle. Mechanisms such as the Public Accounts of Canada and reports from the Auditor General provide retrospective oversight, enabling Parliament to assess whether funds were spent as intended and whether value for money was achieved. The Standing Committee on Public Accounts then reviews these findings, further reinforcing accountability.\n\nDespite this robust framework, obvious challenges remain. One persistent concern is the complexity and timing of financial documents. Parliamentarians are often tasked with reviewing information within a limited time frame and with limited information. This task constrains effective scrutiny and at times shifts the balance of power to the executive branch from the legislative branch. We have seen the consequences of that in recent years, and it is only heightened now through the fabricated majority of the Prime Minister.\n\nThe current government has overseen a significant expansion in federal spending, accompanied by rising deficits and growing public debt. While some of that spending occurred during extraordinary circumstances, the pattern has continued well beyond those moments. Nowhere is that more evident than in housing. The government has announced and re‐announced billions of dollars in housing initiatives over the past decade.\n\nDespite these commitments, housing affordability has deteriorated. The cost of buying a home has risen dramatically, rents have increased and supply has not kept pace with demand. If Parliament had been provided with clear metrics, stronger oversight tools and more transparent reporting, we might better understand where these programs fell short. Instead we are left with repeated announcements, escalating costs and performative motions such as the one before us today on more money.\n\nA culture of accountability must be maintained and strengthened in the House. This is not solely about rules and procedures; it is also about a shared commitment to transparency, responsibility and respect for Parliament's role. Parliamentary accountability in federal spending is not an abstract concept. It is a living practice that underpins public trust in our institutions, which is diminishing. Each vote on estimates, each committee hearing and each audit contributes to ensuring that all Canadians have trust in the process, which right now they do not.\n\nIn 2017, the government unveiled Canada's national housing strategy. The initial investment was $40 billion over 10 years to tackle homelessness and housing supply through redesigned and expanded federal programs. At the time, former minister of fisheries, and member, Bernadette Jordan said that through these investments, \"we will reduce chronic homelessness by 50%.\" In 2017, the estimated number of chronically homeless shelter users was 28,900, according to Statistics Canada. In 2024, that number rose to an estimated 36,058 people experiencing chronic homelessness. The government made a promise to learn from the past, act with foresight and deliver real solutions, but nearly a decade later, the results tell a different story.\n\nIn October, the Parliamentary Budget Officer reported that an average home costs 34% more than what an average-income household can afford. CMHC's latest outlook projects that homebuilding could drop by as much as 18.1% over the next three years and forecasts that housing starts will be 55% below CMHC's own target to restore affordability. The federal housing advocate, and this is wild, reported that it would take more than 1,000 years to restore housing affordability under the current plan.\n\nThis is a systemic failure. One of the clearest constraints that do not get enough attention in the House is infrastructure. While the minister did outline a few projects about improving infrastructure for housing supply, the scale of the problem is much greater than the one-off announcements he has made. More than 11% of Canada's water infrastructure and waste-water infrastructure is in poor condition, with an estimated more than $100 billion in upgrades needed, according to Statistics Canada. Mike Moffatt, founding director of the Missing Middle Initiative, said, \"communities simply don't open land for development at all because they know infrastructure cannot support it.\"\n\nWhile Canadians are told more housing is coming, the foundation required to build it is missing. Either it is outdated, or current systems and approaches cannot accommodate it. The government cannot deliver housing, partly because it cannot deliver infrastructure. Its track record proves it cannot manage large-scale investments at all.\n\nLet us look at some examples. In the last Parliament, Conservatives were upheld in a Speaker's ruling on Sustainable Development Technology Canada. The member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie held a beneficial interest in Cycle Capital, a Quebec-based venture capital firm that received tens of millions of dollars in SDTC grants without any checks and balances. A recording of a senior civil servant slammed the outright incompetence of the Trudeau government, which had inappropriately given 123 million dollars' worth of contracts to companies such as Cycle Capital. It was so bad, so egregious, that the former speaker, the member for Hull—Aylmer, essentially shut parliamentary procedures down for almost a year.\n\nThe Auditor General found the SDTC fund did not follow conflict of interest policies in 90 cases. It spent nearly $76 million on projects connected to Liberal friends and appointees to run SDTC. It spent $59 million on projects that were not allowed to have been awarded any money. It spent $12 million on projects that were both in a conflict of interest and ineligible for funding. In one instance, Trudeau's hand-picked SDTC chair, Annette Verschuren, syphoned off $217,000 to her own company.\n\nThe Liberal government has a history of very poor decision-making. Other members of the House and members of the public have described it as corruption. The former speaker shut down Parliament for almost a year because the government at the time refused to comply with basic financial transparency and then tried to make the superfluous argument that it was a charter violation for the Conservatives to refer this information to the RCMP. What did the Liberals do? They prorogued Parliament, and Justin Trudeau is no longer prime minister.\n\nThe second example is the Canada Infrastructure Bank. With great fanfare, in 2017, the CIB was given $35 billion in federal financing intended to attract private sector investment into infrastructure. The government plan indicated that the Canada Infrastructure Bank would be responsible for delivering the capital over an 11-year period. Global News reported in 2021 that the CIB had committed over $4 billion for projects, but none involved funding from private investors, which was the original intent of the fund: public-private partnerships using federal dollars to scale private sector investment. It just was not happening. In July 2025, the PBO reported that the Infrastructure Bank was not on track to spend its sector-specific funding amounts by 2027-28. In other words, it was projecting complete failure.\n\nA third example is electric batteries. This one really grinds my gears. According to the Parliamentary Budget Officer's estimates, the total cost of government support for EV investments in Canada was earmarked at $52.5 billion between October 2020 and April 2024, including the strategic innovation fund and special production subsidies for Stellantis, Volkswagen, Honda and Northvolt. Despite funding commitments, many federally backed auto sector projects have been delayed or have fallen apart altogether. Stellantis shifted Jeep Compass production from Brampton, Ontario, to Illinois; Honda's $15-billion EV supply chain project in Alliston is delayed; Volkswagen has deferred its production schedule in St. Thomas; Northvolt is slower than expected in its rollout in Quebec; and General Motors' termination of BrightDrop EV van production has taken place in Ingersoll.\n\nTo make matters even worse, despite significant promises, hours of debate and promises from the government that it was going to create an EV ecosystem like nothing we have ever seen before in Canada, taking advantage of our critical minerals, the advanced manufacturing in Ontario, new opportunities for mining in the Ring of Fire and new export opportunities, all through these investments that were so necessary, the Prime Minister just recently handed 30% of our electric vehicle market to China without guardrails. This is the very country that he said, just a year ago in the election, was the greatest threat to Canadian democracy. What in the world is this?\n\nExample number four is ArriveCAN, which was originally budgeted at only $80,000 but ballooned to cost Canadians approximately $60 million. A year ago tomorrow, the Auditor General confirmed that GC Strategies, a dodgy IT firm that does not do IT work and is now under RCMP investigation for ArriveCAN, was awarded 106 contracts worth nearly $100 million under the Liberals. Despite the firm already receiving $64.5 million from the government, the Auditor General found that in 46% of cases, there was little or no evidence that work was actually performed. The Auditor General called the government bookkeeping for the project the worst she had ever seen. In an extraordinary, rare step, the contractor was formally censured in Parliament for its conduct, which is something almost never seen in federal procurement, underscoring just how serious and egregious these failures were.\n\nExample five, another one that hits close to home, because I represent a sizable indigenous population, is the indigenous procurement policy. In August 2024, Global News reported that through the procurement strategy for indigenous businesses, the government awarded billions of dollars in contracts earmarked for indigenous enterprises without always requiring bidders to prove they were first nations, Métis or Inuit. Contracts awarded to indigenous businesses skyrocketed from $100 million in 2018 to $1.6 billion, which is 6.3% of all eligible federal spending at the time. Thawennontie Thomas, co-founder of LaFlesche, a plastics manufacturing company near Montreal, \"said it's 'commonly known' among Indigenous executives that non-Indigenous businesses [were] taking advantage\" of the procurement policies.\n\nExample number six is a recent one, PrescribeIT. The Liberals spent nearly $300 million over a decade on prescribing software. The CEO of Canada Health Infoway was paid nearly $900,000 a year while the program failed across most of Canada. The agency has still not complied with a parliamentary request to provide unredacted documents on its PrescribeIT failure. Nearly $100 million went to Telus Health as the primary technology vendor, with unanswered questions about who owns the taxpayer-funded intellectual property. What a disgrace. We have just learned that the Minister of Health has now cancelled the program in disgrace despite repeated attempts for more transparency by Conservatives at the health committee, which were blocked by the Liberal members.\n\nExample number seven is COVID-19 loans and the Canada emergency business account program. This is a big one. A 2024 Auditor General report estimated that $3.5 billion went to ineligible businesses. The Department of Finance Canada and Global Affairs Canada, according to the Auditor General, did not provide effective oversight to ensure that the CEBA program was managed with due regard for value for money. Export Development Canada notes that the Auditor General failed to exercise basic controls in contract management, such as monitoring that the amounts paid aligned with the work performed. This meant that the value for money was compromised.\n\nExample number eight was a big one in the 2021 election, the WE Charity. It seems like ages ago. In June 2020, the WE Charity was chosen to administer the Canada student service grant, a $912-million program introduced by Justin Trudeau to provide financial relief for students during the COVID-19 pandemic. According to a report to Parliament's ethics committee, Trudeau family members were paid more than $217,000 for speaking engagements and reimbursed $210,000, which included flights and hotels—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085690","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, before I begin my formal remarks, I want to outline that the City of Abbotsford is launching its consultations this June on the Sumas River watershed flood mitigation plan. Earlier this month, the cities of Princeton, Merritt, Hope, Chilliwack and Abbotsford launched the west coast corridor resiliency partnership.\n\nExcuse my skepticism today, but with the bill before us, Bill C‐26, an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["de9db3f9948d3a5593a5484f75ec5dda9f546b6af07364485bedffedae0fcad8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["526fe49f77449da2504529cd55c81b316f7beebc921342f2414e6a4af7d0a229"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2769edf1205cb31658c18359","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085691,"date":"2026-06-11T16:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, these are only a few examples of how the government creates these big blocks of money without any accountability or transparency. What is the point of scrutiny when the Liberals are just going to turn a blind eye again and again to mismanagement? This is one of the most dangerous things Parliament can do: grant billions of dollars without any metrics of success, without any capacity to see how the money is being used. This is not the way our democracy or public accountability is supposed to work. When we hear promises of new spending, new funds, new programs and new announcements, I am required to ask, will it be any different this time?\n\n In my riding of Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford, these failures are not theoretical. They touch very close to home. In 2021, we experienced massive flooding that became one of the most expensive natural disasters in Canada. Later that year, Lytton, British Columbia, in my riding, was burned to the ground. No riding in Canada has ever faced devastation like Mission—Matsqui—Fraser Canyon did in 2021. \n\nThe CN Rail line was washed out throughout the province. The CP Rail line was washed out all across the province. The Trans-Canada Highway was washed out and flooded. The Duffey, which connects Whistler and Pemberton to Lillooet, was washed out. The Lougheed Highway was washed out. The Southern Railway line was washed out. The port of metro Vancouver was completely shut off from the rest of Canada. We had to bring in military assistance from Quebec because there was no equipment cache in British Columbia to deal with the devastation we faced. The Sumas Prairie was flooded, compromising B.C.'s food supply. Homes were lost. People died. Our infrastructure failed.\n\n I remember walking up to the Sir John A. Macdonald Building. It was at the time when the senator from Saskatchewan was kicked out of the Conservative caucus for a while, when Erin O'Toole was our leader, and some journalist asked me, \"What do you think about this?\" I had just come from a meeting with Bill Blair, now the high commissioner to the U.K. I said, \"I can't believe you're asking me this. British Columbia is cut off from the rest of Canada, the port of metro Vancouver can't move any goods, and you're asking me about a senator?\"\n\n B.C. is often overlooked in this chamber. It is not an understood place. Since 2021, I have stood in this chamber and in committees and pleaded with ministers of housing and infrastructure to help British Columbia, to help our farmers and to help the government achieve its own objectives of doubling exports to Asia-Pacific markets. None of that can happen unless the government pays attention to my riding.\n\nMost members in this chamber do not know that 37% of the oil from Trans Mountain goes through the Sumas transfer station in my community to the United States. Without that money, the Government of Canada would be bankrupt. Most members do not know that the Enbridge expansion and the Huntingdon transfer station are right in my riding. Canada cannot function without Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford. My riding has one of the highest farm gates in all of Canada, and we are a key producer of berries, poultry, dairy and vegetables, on less than 1% of the land in B.C. We are an agricultural powerhouse, and we are also the confluence of the Trans Mountain pipeline, the Enbridge pipeline, the Trans‐Canada Highway, all three major rail lines in Canada, a border crossing and an international airport where the government just announced it is going to build Canada's new firefighting fleet through one of the best companies in Canada, Conair.\n\nThere is so much happening in Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford and in the Fraser Valley that is essential to what the government needs to do to complete its objectives.\n\n I ask the government when the dollars that Justin Trudeau promised at the photo ops in Abbotsford, in 2021, will come to fruition. I saw the high commissioner at the airport last week. I said, \"Bill, I am still fighting.\" He said to keep fighting, because they did not fulfill their promises to Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford.\n\nMy number one duty in the House is to get that member who spoke before me to come clean and support my community, to support Canada, to support our export objectives and to support renewed interest in supply chains.\n\nThe Prime Minister went to New York and talked about looking to the future, about Canada's place in the global economy. We can agree that our future is not just a new trade agreement with the United States and Mexico. It is westbound, through British Columbia, because the next chapter of Canada's prosperity will be written in our relationships with the Asia‐Pacific markets, which are growing faster and demanding more food, more energy and a more reliable trading partner with expertise in engineering and services, with one of the most educated workforces in the entire world.\n\nWe cannot do any of that if we do not take the $3.83 billion in national economic activity through agriculture in my riding, the role of our international airport, the site of our firefighting fleet, the Enbridge pipeline, the Trans Mountain pipeline, our international border crossing, the major arterial roads that connect British Columbia with all of Canada, our rail lines to the south, our rail lines to the port, and the breadbasket of British Columbia in my riding.\n\nEvery container heading to Asia, every shipment of agricultural product and every export moving through our Pacific gateway depends on the strength and reliability of the supply chains in the Fraser Valley. If Canada wants to be a serious player in the Indo‐Pacific and if we want to seize the opportunities of growing global demand, we must ensure that our gateways work.\n\nI am going to repeat this time and time again. The government cannot accomplish its goal to double our exports abroad if it does not protect and maintain this critical infrastructure, not just on sunny days but in the face of floods, extreme weather and these growing infrastructure pressures.\n\nIt is worth noting that our competitors are not standing still. Other countries are investing heavily in trade routes and in climate‐resilient infrastructure. We are seeing it in Washington state, where they are going to start exporting more potash and other goods that Canada has, because we are not moving fast enough. Canada has to do the same.\n\nThe question before us is simple: Are we prepared to invest in the infrastructure that will define Canada's future, or are we willing to leave one of our most critical trade corridors vulnerable at the very moment the world is looking to Canada and the Pacific to provide some stability in light of global conflicts?\n\nThe Fraser Valley is not just about the past. It is about the future that the Prime Minister spoke about in his remarks in New York. It is about a future where Canada can feed global markets, power economies with responsibly developed energy and strengthen its place as a reliable trading nation. Everything the Prime Minister wants to do happens in the Fraser Valley.\n\nHowever, to my key point, none of this is possible without resilient infrastructure, without protected corridors, without a federal government willing to act with urgency and ambition in a way it has not done yet. Yes, let us build homes, but let us also build the foundation of a country that can compete, that can trade and that can lead. When we invest in the Fraser Valley, it is not just about investing in a region. We are investing in Canada's future on the world stage.\n\nThis is an odd bill. It was not in the budget, and it does not appear to be part of a coherent plan based on the information before the House today. It feels more like a last-minute talking point, so the Liberals can say that the Conservatives voted against housing, rather than a serious effort to address the legitimate things the minister is trying to solve. Canadians do want to see investment in housing and infrastructure, but they also want to see improved processes, because what I will outline in the coming hours will show that the Liberals have not done that to date.\n\nBefore I do that, I would be remiss if I did not cover, just to reiterate the point, some of the comments that my constituents made in a recent mailer about what happened to them in the flood. Sometimes in this House, we need to bring in that personal perspective. These people matter, and they pay a lot of taxes. Their voice needs to be heard. I am going to refer to them just by their initials to protect their confidentiality.\n\nJ. and T. wrote me and said the following: \"Our family was seriously impacted when the dikes of Sumas River blew out in 2021. This flooded the Sumas Prairie where we live on a five-acre hay farm. We lost everything in our home. We had to rebuild the entire inside of the house, from floor to ceiling, including all appliances, windows, doors, furniture, flooring and personal items. We lost three vehicles, tools and equipment for the farm. Federal help is needed to deal with international disaster with the floodwaters.\"\n\nThis is a funny one. P. in Abbotsford wrote, \"Instead of wasting time trying to get the Liberals to do something for the west coast, why not build a berm along the border? They can keep their water.\" That is fair.\n\nD.S. wrote, \"It appears to me the federal government is not taking the flooding issue seriously. Merritt, Princeton, Sumas Prairie, all their constituencies are not listened to by the Liberal government. Is it because they don't have their party's MPs in these ridings? Five hundred pages of reposting is not sufficient to approve funding for flood-stricken families? We pay equally into the tax system in Canada. Citizens should be first.\"\n\n C. in Abbotsford wrote, \"In 2021, our property flooded. We had a foot of water on the main floor of our house. We were displaced for six months from our home while we let it dry out. Gutted the main floor and renovated. We also have a barn, so animals, goats, horses and chickens, were relocated for a while. My husband has a landscaping business and his shop flooded, ruining equipment and storage areas. It has taken years to rebuild.\" \n\nC. from Abbotsford wrote, \"I was unable to get to my workplace during the floods. My church took the opportunity to help Ripples Estate with their restoration, and the devastation to their land was exceptional. In a documentary recap I filmed, one of the owners makes the comment that, 'We receive alert messages all the time on our iPhones. How is it possible that there is a failure to use this kind of method to warn about the potential weather impact of flooding?'\"\n\n R. from Abbotsford wrote, \"My wife with extreme Parkinson's and myself were evacuated for three weeks. We went to our son's in Calgary. I live in Sumas Prairie, where the dike broke. I helped move my neighbour as his barn flooded, as well as two homes past the bridge on Sumas River, which had to be replaced. My wife recently passed. This was an extremely difficult time. During the flood in 2025, I was stranded for three days, because all the roads around me were flooded. In this day and age, this problem must be resolved. Government, change. We need proper dyking in Sumas, Washington, and pump stations on Sumas River at Barrowtown.\"\n\nN. and L. wrote, \"Our family has lived on this property since 1957, which my father and mother moved to because of the high location of the property. They lived in a lower area when they migrated here in the 1930s. They went through the 1948 flood threat and realized the situation back then, so until November 2021, our family felt confident that we did not have to worry, but to our amazement the dyke on the Sumas River breached, and that was that. We suffered water flooding in our basement, costing us over $8,000 and time away from home. At that time, I was suffering from cancer, which was very difficult.\"\n\n D. from Abbotsford wrote, \"I used to live in Sumas Prairie in the flood zone, and the threat of flooding was a constant concern, so we moved to the Bradner area of Abbotsford, out of the flood zone. Our old house was badly damaged in 2021. The Canadian government must pressure the U.S. government to dredge out the Nooksack River to prevent flooding again. That is one of the only solutions, as I see it.\"\n\nR. from Abbotsford wrote, \"Both the 2021 and 2025 floods cut off use of Highway 1 to the interior for a month. I lost access to my cabin at Hope, and what about the promised infrastructure? How come it is not happening? Let's get it done. Let's get it right this time. We can't go on like this.\"\n\nO. from Abbotsford wrote, \"Yes, I saw many affected residents from the floods. We have to find a way to fix this from happening again by all means.\"\n\nE. from Abbotsford said, \"We need the federal government to work constructively on the Sumas River watershed coalition and to work with our American partners to fix this issue. Where is the federal leadership?\"\n\nB. in Mission wrote, \"I lived in Agassiz in 2021, near the fairgrounds. My crawlspace flooded. I had huge personal and material losses. I spent months sorting and paying for things that could not be saved.\"\n\nJ. in Mission wrote, \"Infrastructure needs to be built to stop this from happening again. We can't go on.\"\n\nT. in Abbotsford wrote, \"I don't live on the Sumas flood plain, but do live on the hill above it. My lower level floods on occasion when our storm drainage system can't handle the extra water, because it has nowhere to go when the plains flood. When the freeway is flooded, my daughter can't go to work in Chilliwack.\"\n\nR. in Abbotsford wrote, \"Thanks for pushing this, Brad. My friend's family's cattle were heavily impacted by the 2021 floods. There was incredible destruction and loss around Sumas Prairie.\" He mentions the cattle, and in fact one of the few things people from outside the region remember is the cows swimming in the water during the floods.\n\n G. and P. in Abbotsford wrote, \"In addition to being cut off from the rest of Canada by the flooding in 2021, our region had to rely on shipments being rerouted through the U.S., Washington state, and then back into B.C. Given the trade tensions with the U.S. and our country's resolve to become less dependent on the U.S., do we really want to find ourselves in that position again when the flooding reoccurs? Please get the flood mitigation assistance that was promised in November 2021.\"\n\nS. H. from Abbotsford wrote, \"We had to be evacuated in the middle of the night. We had to relocate our livestock. We missed work. Our property was damaged. The Trans-Canada Highway was flooded and closed. There was poor communication on road closures. We lost a lot of livestock due to the flood.\"\n\nS. in Abbotsford wrote, \"While my property was not flooded, my friends had just recovered from the previous flood disaster. To have two floods so close together stinks of neglect and disinterest for the people of the Fraser Valley.\"\n\nR. in Abbotsford wrote, \"The recent flood disrupted my work for most of a week. I head up construction for farmers, fresh mushrooms, these last 12 years. My work stopped because I had no access to gravel on Sumas Mountain. Three of my crew lost a week's worth of work, because all the roads were cut off.\"\n\nJ. in Abbotsford wrote, \"I don't live in the flood plain, but a percentage of our city does. It is terribly disruptive when the floods take place. I am only inconvenienced, but there are people in our city fighting for their homes, land and way of life. Do we have to have another fatality for Ottawa to notice? Thank you for your efforts.\"\n\nD. in Abbotsford wrote, \"Again, Brad, you're looking out for your people. Thank you. Not impacted by the flood except by higher prices and groceries and other necessities because freight was held up. The poor farmers affected have been most heartbreaking. We knew the prime minister at the time, Justin Trudeau, would not keep his promise to help. He gave hope in one hand and snatched it up with the other hand. Typical of him. Also, go very hard on SOGI in our schools. God continue to give you strength.\"\n\nM. in Abbotsford wrote, \"I haven't been affected personally, but my uncle was flooded in the 1975 flood. It has only gotten worse in the 1990s and in the 2020s. My dad had a friend who was a diking commissioner in the Nooksack in the nineties. He was hamstrung by bureaucracies there. It was an international problem that affects the local Americans as well. It missed federal government action on both sides of the border. The Nooksack needs dredging, and we need to improve our dikes. I agree. This problem can only be fixed if the federal government gets involved.\"\n\nP. from Abbotsford is a professor at the university, and she said they had to cancel exams and that the university was shut for a week because of the floods. She encourages the federal government to take leadership and dredge the Nooksack.\n\nK. from Mission wrote, \"I'm going to be 85 this spring. I have a caring heart. We've got to get this fixed. This is not acceptable.\" \n\nB. from Abbotsford wrote, \"I received your letter, 'Fix the Flooding Failure, Hold Ottawa Accountable', in the mail this week.\" This was a few months ago. \"You asked how the 2021 and most recent flooding have affected our lives. Well, the Sumas Prairie flood was truly an experience for us. After spending the evening of November 15, 2021, and well into the morning moving files from our office into the shop and into the house, we tried to save our daughter's art studio, furniture and artwork, our other daughter's piano studio, located by the back of our garage, and anything we could from the basement by moving it to the main floor. We never expected the water to rise as much as it did.\n\n\"We moved items and mopped up water for 26 hours straight. By 4:30 a.m. on November 16, we were completely exhausted and cold. We rested until 6:30 a.m., when we heard police telling us to evacuate. In that short time, the water had rushed in and was already four feet deep in the basement. We couldn't reach the breaker panel or turn off the water or gas. We had only minutes to leave. The water continued rising faster.\n\n\"We waded through dirty, freezing water to reach our truck on the road. The road had disappeared, and the surrounding area looked like we were in the middle of a lake. Water was entering the cab of the truck. We were very fortunate to get out when we did. Trying to drive when no road is visible and avoiding deep farm ditches was extremely challenging.\n\n\"We headed south along the mountain, driving through the mudslides and downed branches, and made our way to Chilliwack. With the flooding and landslides, it felt like we were in a movie.\n\n\"Cold and wet, we were instructed to register with emergency evacuation services in Chilliwack. Our two daughters had stayed at their grandparents the night before because they couldn't make it home once flooding began at Whatcom Road. My husband and I ended up in Chilliwack.\n\n\"Chilliwack became chaotic as people panicked to get gas and food. Gas stations ran out of fuel, and fights were starting because of the long, frantic lineups. We were able to get clothes and food at Superstore since we had left many essentials at home, but later the store closed as shelves were emptied.\n\n\"Sumas Prairie and Highway No. 1 were closed, as were Highway No. 1 East past the Agassiz exit and Highway 7 due to mudslides. Exhausted and considering sleeping in the back of the truck, we searched for a place to stay, but nothing was available. It was November, and daytime temperatures were around five degrees. Thankfully, my mum made some calls, and we ended up staying with a distant relative.\n\n\"On Thursday, November 19, we were finally able to head back to Abbotsford via Highway No. 7. It took three hours, but we still couldn't reach our house. Flooding was everywhere, even though the water had receded three feet.\n\n\"By Sunday, we were able to pull up to our home and assess the damage. Wearing boots, we entered the house and quickly packed what we could from the main and upper floors. The smell permeated everything. Clothing and bedding that could be washed were washed, but it took a lot to remove the odour. We lost all of our office equipment and furniture, the furniture and appliances in our basement and anything we had placed on our shelves, thinking the water wouldn't reach the ceiling.\n\n \"We lost all our RV, our chickens and both coops, the art studio, the piano studio and four vehicles. Our business trailers were flooded, and we worked with ICBC to have them repaired.\n\n\"Seeing the damage was tough, but we had to move forward and do the hard work to get back to normal. We gutted, dried out and repaired our shop. We bought new tools and threw out damaged equipment. Our construction company's head office had to be relocated off the property.\n\n\"With the help of family and friends, the cleanup began. We ended up with six and a half feet of water, contaminated water containing septic waste, manure, chemicals, oils and gas. Anything touched by it had to be thrown out. Our house needed to be rebuilt, so we lived elsewhere for two and a half years. \n\n\"We are still dealing with the aftermath. Damage to the outbuildings is yet to be repaired because our focus and finances had to go towards the house and shop. Our older farmhouse had water up to the main floorboards, and after sitting in water for almost a week, the mould and structural damage made rebuilding necessary.\n\n\"Unfortunately, we had no insurance coverage for overland flooding. Intact Insurance had sent us a letter a year earlier stating that due to failing infrastructure, they would no longer cover floods. I tried to get insurance elsewhere for this, but no one would offer it.\n\n \"The recent flooding only affected our backyard field and ditches.\" That's the one last year. \"The house was spared this time. My daughter and I were evacuated at 12:30 a.m. but returned in the morning before Vye Road flooded. Our daughter had recently undergone surgery and was still using a hospital bed, so staying elsewhere was impossible. My husband remained at the house. The stress was still there, knowing how easily it could happen again.\n\n\"One of our neighbours completely emptied their house, appliances and all, fearing a repeat of 2021. We monitored the water constantly to see how quickly the yard was filling. We were still able to reach Chilliwack via back roads but were cut off from Abbotsford due to closures at Vye Road, Whatcom Road and Whatcom Road to Highway No. 1 from our work.\n\n\"In 2021, when our dike filled, we realized most of the water that flooded our home came from that failure. This time, we watched the direction of the water from the Nooksack, which has flooded before and follows the same path towards Highway No. 1.\n\n\"As landowners in the Sumas Prairie, it is deeply concerning that so little has been addressed since 2021. Thank you for taking the time to read our story and share our concerns.\"\n\nC. from Abbotsford wrote, \"In 2021, we were greatly impacted by the flood. We lost many of our belongings and animals. We never received any relief funding or even dump fees waived because we were not put on alert. Our house was completely surrounded by water, but because it sits up high enough, we were able to stay. Not once did any first responders or law enforcement ever come to check on us. We continue to flood every winter, but the city refuses to help us in any way.\"\n\nR. and D. in Mission wrote, \"I can't access the Fraser River from the Barrowtown boat launch anymore due to the level of gravel flowing through the Vedder Canal. The Chilliwack Lake watershed was overlogged decades ago but perhaps has recovered by now. However, the canal needs to be dredged. It's got nothing to do with the so-called climate change, as some try to suggest.\"\n\nI could go on, but those testaments are clear. My constituents have not received the type of federal support they deserve. They have not received the type of flexibility that the government is showing in Bill C-26 and in this programming motion to accomplish its goals. It has not done anything for the Fraser Valley region, which is integral to maintaining Canada's supply chains in 2026.\n\nIn my next hour, I am going to look a little more closely at what the government has done on housing since it was elected. It starts with the national housing strategy, which came out in 2016 or 2017.\n\nThe member for Québec Centre wrote a message as the minister of families, children and social development. He stated:\n\nIt is my great honour and pleasure to present Canada's first ever National Housing Strategy (NHS), an ambitious $40-billion plan to help ensure that Canadians have access to housing that meets their needs and that they can afford.\n\nBringing this Strategy to life has been a priority for the Government of Canada for the past 18 months. We are making historic investments in housing—and planning for transformational change—because we understand the value of home. Safe, affordable housing is a launch-pad for better socio-economic outcomes for our citizens, a more inclusive society where everyone has the opportunity to be well and to succeed, a stronger economy and a cleaner environment.\n\nBut for too many Canadian families, a decent home is simply not affordable. Across Canada, 1.7 million people are in housing need, living in homes that are inadequate or unaffordable. Another 25,000 Canadians are chronically homeless. This needs to change.\n\nBuilding on investments announced in Budgets 2016 and 2017, [this strategy] signals a meaningful re-engagement by the federal government in housing. It is a key element of our Government's plan to help strengthen the middle class, promote growth for everyone, and lift more Canadians out of poverty.\n\nImportant learnings emerged from last year's Let's Talk Housing consultations, and our Strategy is stronger for it. Now the work of implementing these ideas begins.\n\nHe continued:\n\nWe have set clear goals for the [national housing strategy], including removing 530,000 Canadian families from housing need and reducing chronic homelessness by half over the next decade. We will track and report on our success, and adapt our approach as needed as the Strategy unfolds. Our primary focus will be on meeting the needs of vulnerable populations, such as women and children fleeing family violence, seniors, Indigenous peoples, people with disabilities, those dealing with mental health and addiction issues, veterans and young adults.\n\nThe release of the [national housing strategy] marks the beginning of a new era for housing in Canada. We have a Strategy that all Canadians can be proud of and support. I encourage you to become part of this nation-wide effort to ensure that all Canadians have the safe and affordable housing they need and deserve.\n\nI consider the member to be an honourable one, but I will note that every metric and group outlined in his introductory letter to the national housing strategy has failed, every single one. Not one thing has been done as they said it would be done when the plan was announced.\n\nThe first-ever national housing strategy went on:\n\nThe Government of Canada believes every Canadian deserves a safe and affordable home. Affordable housing is a cornerstone of inclusive communities.... Canada's first ever National Housing Strategy is a 10-year, $40-billion plan that will give more Canadians a place to call home.\n\nCanada's National Housing Strategy sets ambitious targets to ensure that unprecedented investments and new programming deliver results. This will include a 50% reduction in chronic homelessness, and as many as 530,000 households being taken out of housing need. The National Housing Strategy will result in up to 100,000 new housing units and 300,000 repaired or renewed housing units \n\nThrough new initiatives like the National Housing Co-Investment Fund and the Canada Community Housing Initiative, the National Housing Strategy will create a new generation of housing in Canada. \n\nNone of that has taken place.\n\nOur plan will promote diverse communities. It will build housing that is sustainable, accessible, mixed-income, and mixed-use. We will build housing that is fully integrated into the community—close to transit, close to work, and close to public services.\n\nExpanded and reformed federal homelessness programming, a new Canada Housing Benefit, and a rights-based approach to housing will ensure that the National Housing Strategy prioritizes the most vulnerable Canadians including women and children fleeing [from] violence....\n\n I will note that since this strategy was implemented, violence against women in Canada has more than doubled. Cases of sexual assault and intimate partner violence have skyrocketed under the government. The Liberals said housing would fix it. They were wrong. They misled Canada. They misled our entire nation.\n\nThe statement continues:\n\nThe National Housing Strategy is truly a national project, built by and for Canadians. The success of our plan requires collaboration from many partners. The National Housing Strategy invests in the provinces and territories, so all regions can achieve better and more affordable housing. It invests in municipalities, to empower communities to lead the fight against homelessness. It also creates new opportunities for the federal government to innovate through [community] partnerships....\n\n I could go on.\n\n Page 5 of the report is about \"A vision for housing in Canada\". It reads:\n\nCanadians have housing that meets their needs and they can afford.\n\nThat vision has failed.\n\nAffordable housing is a cornerstone of sustainable, inclusive communities and a Canadian economy where we can prosper and thrive.\n\n I agree with that. The government has done the opposite.\n\n The government notes in its strategy on page 5 that:\n\nHousing is more than just a roof over our heads\n\n It says:\n\nEvery Canadian deserves a safe and affordable home\n\n I agree. They have not done it.\n\nHousing investments must prioritize those most in need, including: women and children fleeing family violence; seniors; Indigenous peoples...\n\n I might read, later on, the Auditor General's report on the state of housing on first nations reserves. It is complete failure, again.\n\nHousing policy should be grounded in the principles of inclusion, participation, accountability, and non-discrimination\n\nI agree, but the government has completely failed on that, too.\n\nHousing programs should align with public investments in job creation, skills training, transit, early learning, healthcare, and cultural and recreational infrastructure\n\nI wish that were the case. It has not happened.\n\nHousing investments should support Canada's climate change agenda and commitment to accessible communities\n\n I agree, but with regard to the impacts of natural disasters and what the government scientists have said about climate change in Canada and in my riding, there was never that alignment or prioritization, as I have outlined in the last hour. That is another big fail.\n\nCommunities should be empowered to develop and implement local solutions to housing challenges\n\nI agree. I do not think it is happening, though.\n\nPage 6 of the strategy outlines some targets, including \"530,000 households removed from housing need\", \"385,000 community housing units protected and another 50,000 units created through an expansion of community housing\", a \"50% reduction in estimated number of chronically homeless shelter users\", \"300,000 existing housing units repaired and renewed\", \"100,000 new housing units created\" and \"300,000 households provided with affordability support through the Canada Housing Benefit\".\n\nI do not think they have succeeded in any of those metrics.\n\nOn page 7, it says the $40-billion initial investment, which has since doubled, will be a \"Once-in-a-Generation Joint Investment\". I find it sad that the government has spent so much money and has so little to show for what it said it wanted to do.\n\nIn chapter 1, the strategy outlines that:\n\nHousing Rights Are Human Rights\n\nCanadians deserve safe and affordable housing. That is why the federal government is taking these additional steps to progressively implement the right of every Canadian to access adequate housing. Our plan is grounded in the principles of inclusion, accountability, participation and non-discrimination....\n\nNone of that has taken place. The plan talks about new legislation, the National Housing Strategy Act, which I will get to in just a minute, and a new federal housing advocate. I will note, on a positive note, that at least the federal housing advocate has been willing to call out the government accordingly and hold it to account for some of its failures, like the 1,000-year statistic I gave earlier, which outlines that the plan is a complete failure.\n\nThe plan created a new national housing council, new initiatives, new public campaigns, new legislation and all sorts of new agencies and councils. None of it has made a difference. None of the metrics were met.\n\nChapter 2 talks about \"Federal Re-Engagement Through the National Housing Co-Investment Fund\". I do not know what to say. It talked about 60,000 new units and new shelter spaces. Poverty in Canada has grown at such an exponential rate under the government over the last 10 years that even where the government might have made an incremental improvement, the foundation of our economy, our socio-economic status and the erosion of civil society that we have witnessed over the last 10 years have eroded any good that any of these policies could have completed. While more money was pumped, fewer results were achieved.\n\n The plan talks about \"Making Federal Lands Available for Affordable Housing\". The government is still talking about that. It still has not done anything. I do not think it has made any measurable difference. The only success we have seen on that is when we removed all federal barriers and granted federal lands to indigenous people, to the outcry of many residents in Vancouver. We have seen massive new housing developments take place. It is only when the federal government is not involved that we see results.\n\nChapter 3 talks about \"Maintaining a Resilient Community Housing Sector\". I do not know what that means. I do not think it has made a difference.\n\n Chapter 4 talks about \"A New Canada Housing Benefit\" for low-income people. The government is removing that benefit now.\n\n Chapter 5 talks about \"Progress Through Partnership: Enhanced Support to Provinces and Territories\". Again, what progress have we seen? The report mentions the same statistics I read at the beginning, over and over again.\n\n Chapter 6 talks about \"Letting Communities Lead\". I do not know what that means.\n\n Chapter 7 is titled \"'Nothing About Us, Without Us'\". Housing starts for first nations have only eroded under the government.\n\n Chapter 8 talks about \"Evidence-Based Housing: Research, Data and Demonstrations\". They developed a research agenda around their own work. The research, as I will show, shows that the plan was an abysmal failure.\n\nChapter 9 is about \"Improving Homeownership Options for Canadians\". In some of the debates, I will talk about how, in conjunction with this plan, the government's solution for that was allowing the Government of Canada to co-invest in mortgages or have a portion of Canadians' mortgages. That plan failed drastically.\n\n Chapter 10 is about \"Gender-Based Analysis Plus\". I do not know what that means or what it has done to improve housing affordability in Canada. I hope it has made some improvements but I do not think it has.\n\nChapter 11 talks about the government's journey to reinvest in housing. Great.\n\n I could go on. There are more statistics, more failed investments, zero progress to date and a move in the complete opposite direction from the direction the strategy said it would go in.\n\nThe next document I will quickly take a look at is the National Housing Strategy Act. It was very big legislation for the government at the time.\n\nI will outline what it says in the preamble:\n\nWhereas housing is essential to the inherent dignity and well-being of the person and to building sustainable and inclusive communities as well as a strong national economy in which the people of Canada can prosper and thrive;\n\nWhereas access to affordable housing contributes to achieving beneficial social, economic, health and environmental outcomes;\n\nWhereas improved housing outcomes are best achieved through cooperation between governments and civil society as well as the meaningful involvement of local communities;\n\nWhereas national goals, timelines and initiatives relating to housing and homelessness are essential to improving the quality of life of the people of Canada, particularly persons in greatest need;\n\nWhereas a national housing strategy would support a common vision, key principles and a coordinated approach to achieving...housing outcomes;\n\nWhereas a national housing strategy would contribute to meeting the Sustainable Development Goals of the United Nations;\n\nAnd whereas a national housing strategy would support the progressive realization of the right to adequate housing as recognized in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, to which Canada is a party;\n\nImportantly, the legislation includes a housing policy declaration. In section 4, it reads:\n\nIt is declared to be the housing policy of the Government of Canada to\n\n(a) recognize that the right to adequate housing is a fundamental human right affirmed in international law;\n\n(b) recognize that housing is essential to the inherent dignity and well-being of the person and to building sustainable and inclusive communities;\n\n(c) support improved housing outcomes for the people of Canada; and\n\n(d) further the progressive realization of the right to adequate housing as recognized in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.\n\nIn section 5, under \"National Housing Strategy\", on page 3 of the bill, it states:\n\n5 (1) The Minister must develop and maintain a national housing strategy to further the housing policy, taking into account key principles of a human rights-based approach to housing.\n\nContent\n\n(2) The National Housing Strategy is to, among other things,\n\n(a) set out a long-term vision for housing in Canada that recognizes the importance of housing in achieving social, economic, health and environmental goals;\n\n(b) establish national goals relating to housing and homelessness and identify related priorities, initiatives, timelines and desired outcomes;\n\n(c) focus on improving housing outcomes for persons in greatest need; and\n\n(d) provide for participatory processes to ensure the ongoing inclusion and engagement of civil society, stakeholders, vulnerable groups and persons with lived experience of housing need, as well as those with lived experience of homelessness.\n\nThe act sets out a national housing council. It states:\n\n6 (1) A council, to be known as the National Housing Council, is established for the purpose of furthering the housing policy...by\n\n(a) providing advice to the Minister, on its own initiative or at the request of the Minister, including, among other things, on the effectiveness of the National Housing Strategy\n\nThis sounds familiar. Is it another bureaucratic body to do the job of the minister.\n\n It talks about the membership of the council, which I will not go into, as well as ex officio members and the appointment terms. This was a very common thing under Trudeau. Every legislation had a corresponding council.\n\nThe legislation created a federal housing advocate on page 6, with specific duties to do the following:\n\n(a) monitor the implementation of the housing policy and assess its impact on persons who are members of vulnerable groups, persons with lived experience of housing need and persons with lived experience of homelessness;\n\n(b) monitor progress in meeting the goals and timelines...\n\n(c) analyze and conduct research, as the Advocate sees fit, on systemic housing issues, including barriers...\n\n(d) initiate studies, as the Advocate sees fit, into economic, institutional or industry conditions...\n\n(e) consult with persons referred to in paragraph (a) and civil society organizations...\n\n(f) receive submissions with respect to systemic housing issues;\n\n(g) provide advice to the Minister;\n\n(h) submit a report to the Minister on the Advocate's findings...and;\n\n(i) participate in the work of the National Housing Council as an ex officio member.\n\n The act established a review panel, and it goes on and on about the review panel.\n\nIt talks about accountability on page 10, which states:\n\nThe Minister must respond to the annual report of the Federal Housing Advocate.\n\n I would be remiss as a member of Parliament to not note that we ask general questions on the state of housing in Canada every day, and we never get clear responses. We hear only that everything is okay and Canada has never had it so good. That is essentially the strategy.\n\nDuring the debates, because this was part of the budget bill in April 2019, many Liberals spoke highly about what they were doing. Jennifer O'Connell, the parliamentary secretary to the minister of finance at the time, talked about how the Liberal approach was going to help young Canadians who \"want the chance to work in a good career, buy a home and build a better future for themselves, their families and their communities.\" That was never realized.\n\nShe talked about their approach to housing, and stated:\n\nMany Canadians might feel that because of high house prices in some of Canada's largest cities, buying a home is increasingly out of reach. We know that young people especially are being priced out of some house and condo markets. Average home prices today are about eight times larger than the average full-time income of Canadians aged 25 to 34. That is markedly different from a few decades ago, when they were about four times larger.\n\n To address the difficulty that young families may be having in buying their first home, through Bill C‐97, budget 2019 proposes a new first‐time home buyer incentive. With this extra help in the shape of a shared equity mortgage through the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, Canadians can lower their monthly mortgage payments, making home ownership more affordable.\n\nI would note that the government scrapped that program pretty quickly. It was an abysmal failure.\n\n She continued:\n\nThrough budget 2019 and Bill C‐97, our government is also increasing the home buyers' plan withdrawal limit for the first time in a decade.\n\n I will admit that was a good policy, but none of the Liberals' measures improved affordability.\n\n Budget 2019 talked about job experience and employer-relevant skills. None of that panned out.\n\n This is interesting: The parliamentary secretary at the time talked about attracting more foreign students to Canada by promoting Canadian educational institutions as high-caliber places to study. One of the biggest and most negative impacts on housing affordability in Canada has been the immigration policies of the current government, where demand completely outstrips supply due to unfettered immigration targets. Just a few years ago, the members opposite praised the government for increasing those numbers. What a short-sighted policy idea that was.\n\n Maryam Monsef, in May 2019, talked about more funding in budget 2019:\n\n ...we took our commitment to housing even further. We are investing an additional $10 billion in the rental construction financing initiative, which will help people who rely on rental and social housing to find more housing opportunities. We have introduced the first-time homebuyer incentive, which will help more Canadians achieve the dream of owning a home.\n\nThanks to these and other investments, the national housing strategy is now a...$55-billion plan, and we are seeing the fruits of our commitment in new and renewed housing units across the country.\n\nNext year, the Canada housing benefit will come into effect. This is an additional $2,500 a year for low-income Canadians. It is a portable fund that will follow them wherever they choose to live to ensure they have greater access to affordable housing.\n\n She talked about the National Housing Strategy Act, which I just read from and which:\n\n...would create a national housing council supported by CMHC, which will act as a focal point for housing policy discussions on the national housing strategy and will advise the minister on how to improve housing outcomes. With [these] amendments, we are empowering the national housing council with even more freedom to support the federal housing advocate and to report on the findings to the minister responsible.\n\n She talked about being very proud of the housing investments and about upholding the rights of Canadians.\n\nThe member for Surrey Centre also spoke about the 2019 budget with respect to housing. He stated:\n\nBy listening to the needs of Canadians and encouraging dialogue, I am proud to say this government has continued its commitment to improving housing affordability in this country, and this is exemplified in budget 2019....\n\nThe government is...committed to working in partnership with the province and the municipality to ensure a tri-levelled affordable housing strategy for Surrey residents. In conjunction with British Columbia's affordable...plan and Surrey's affordable housing strategy, the government's new homeowner incentive is a proactive measure to ensure that a future in Surrey is possible for young people and families.\n\nHe stated in his speech:\n\nOur goal is to cut chronic homelessness in half, remove 530,000 families from housing need and invest in the construction of up to 100,000 new homes. However, our government knows that these changes cannot, unfortunately, take place overnight. This is why our government has introduced new measures in budget 2019 to help relieve the pressures on Canadians....\n\nWe will continue working hard to ensure that...middle-class Canadians [can afford a home, that] home ownership is not a pipe dream, but rather, an achievable goal.\n\nThe then parliamentary secretary to the Minister of International Development talked about this, saying:\n\nToday in Canada, especially where my constituents live in Brampton West, once affordable properties are now out of reach due to high demand. Therefore, in budget 2016 and in budget 2017, we established Canada's first-ever housing strategy that would invest $40 billion over 10 years to build and repair affordable housing units. This gives future homeowners greater options when looking at the housing market and makes housing accessible to more people than ever before.\n\n In budget 2019, we are taking another step to support first-time homebuyers, including new immigrant families in Brampton West. To help make home ownership more affordable for first-time homebuyers, budget 2019 introduces the first-time homebuyer incentive. This incentive would allow eligible first-time homebuyers, who have the minimum down payment of an insured mortgage, to finance a portion of their home purchase through a shared equity mortgage with the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation.\n\nLater in her speech, she says:\n\nIt is unfortunate that the provincial government in Ontario is impeding the flow of federal dollars to our municipalities. This has been having a tremendous effect in my community in Brampton.\n\nWe are working directly with our municipalities to ensure that essential projects move forward. I am proud to be part of a government that is working with municipalities on behalf of Canadians and delivering for them.\n\nBrampton will be receiving close to $50 million through this fund so that it can invest in services that Bramptonians rely on most, such as public transportation, recreation centres and our parks.\n\nI could go on. The member for Humber River—Black Creek, on June 4, 2019, said:\n\nWe are not just talking about the homeless. We are talking about seniors who cannot sell their houses because they have nowhere to go, and they are struggling as it is. There are a lot of people who are struggling and looking for housing. I hope that the way we are doing it, under our new national housing strategy, is going to help decrease the number of homeless people. More important, it is to help people find alternative forms of housing compared to what they currently have.\n\nThe member for Humber River—Black Creek went on to prop up the first-time homebuyers incentive. She said that it:\n\nwill certainly help a lot of young people in their mid-thirties who are having significant difficulty just getting into the housing market. Once they can get into the housing market and stay employed, they will have lots of opportunity to build equity in that house and then can later on move into a larger house as their family grows.\n\n The then parliamentary secretary to the minister of finance, a member from Quebec, talked about many measures in budget 2019 as well. About Bill C-97, he said:\n\nIn concrete terms, it will require the federal government to give priority to the housing needs of the most vulnerable Canadians.\n\nThe government will also be required to report back to Parliament on the progress made in implementing the strategy and in achieving the desired results with respect to housing. These targets, such as cutting homelessness in half in this country and building 100,000 new units, as well as repairing and renovating another 300,000, will make a real difference in the lives of many Canadians....\n\nI think it is time for the federal government to take responsibility for housing and make a bold, ambitious comeback. That is what the national housing strategy does.\n\n The Liberals' housing agenda, first articulated in 2017 through the national housing strategy, was framed as a historic and transformational shift in federal policy. The quotes I just outlined from the budget debate in 2019 reinforce that.\n\nThe former minister from the Quebec region presented the strategy as a long-overdue correction to decades of federal withdrawal, promising not only significant new investment, but a reorientation of housing policy toward affordable, equitable and measurable outcomes. Housing was to be treated as a human right. Vulnerable Canadians would be prioritized, and hundreds of thousands of households would be lifted out of housing need.\n\nThe rhetoric was expansive and ambitious, setting expectations for systemic change rather than incremental improvement. However, when these promises are compared to the current trajectory of housing policy, particularly as outlined in the 2025 report by the Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer, a significant gap emerges between what was promised and what is now being delivered.\n\nOne of the most striking divergences lies in the trajectory of federal spending. The national housing strategy was built on the premise of sustained, long-term federal investment. In 2017, the government emphasized that consistent funding over a decade would provide stability, enable planning and ultimately improve affordability outcomes, yet according to the PBO's 2025 analysis, federal housing spending is not being sustained. It is actually declining sharply. Planned spending falls from $9.8 billion in 2025-26 to just $4.3 billion by 2028-29. It is almost as if the government is afraid to admit the fact that its strategy was not working.\n\nThe implication is clear: Despite earlier commitments to long-term leadership, the federal role in housing is set to diminish precisely when demand for intervention still remains incredibly high. This decline in spending is closely tied to the exploration of key programs under the national housing strategy. This creates some structural problems. The policy architecture that supported the government's original affordability goals is being dismantled faster than a new policy can be approached. As a result, the overall footprint of federal housing policy is changing without direction.\n\nThe flagship initiative under budget 2025, Build Canada Homes, exemplifies this shift. Rather than providing immediate relief to households struggling without housing costs, it focuses on financing construction, developing assets and encouraging new housing supply over time. In principle, increasing housing supply is an essential component of any housing strategy. However, the effectiveness of the shift depends on both the scale and the timing of the resulting construction.\n\nOn both counts, the PBO's assessment raises concerns. The report estimates that Building Canada Homes will generate approximately 26,000 new housing units over a five‐year period. While this is not insignificant in absolute terms, it is modest relative to the scale of housing shortages. The PBO notes that this output would increase housing completions by only 2.1% and addresses just 3.7% of the projected housing gap. These figures underscore a key limitation: The program's contribution to overall supply is incremental rather than transformative.\n\nThe government has also stated an ambitious goal of doubling the pace of housing construction, yet the PBO explicitly states that no detailed plan has been provided to achieve these objectives. This disconnect between stated targets and concrete policy mechanisms weakens the credibility of the government's approach and raises questions about its capacity to deliver meaningful results. The limited scale of new supply is further compounded by issues related to affordability targeting. Of the 26,000 units expected to be created under Building Canada Homes, only about 13% are projected to be affordable for low-income households. This represents a relatively small contribution in the context where millions of Canadians face affordability challenges.\n\nMore concerning is the definition of affordability itself. The PBO highlights that some units classified as affordable under the program may have rents significantly higher than historical market benchmarks. For example, illustrative calculations suggest that rents deemed affordable for median-income households could be substantially higher than the national median market rent observed in previous years. This raises a critical concern: The policy risks conflating affordability with relative pricing metrics that does not reflect the lived reality of low- and moderate-income households. In effect, units may be labelled as affordable without being meaningfully accessible to those most in need.\n\nAnother important aspect of the current policy direction is the trade-off between short-term support and long-term investment. By shifting resources toward capital development, the government is prioritizing supply over immediate affordability, which warrants more discussion. However, this does create a timing mismatch. Housing construction takes years to complete, and its impact on prices and rents is gradual. In contrast, affordability challenges are immediate and acute for many households. Renters facing high costs today cannot wait for long-term supply responses necessarily to materialize.\n\nIt is something to consider. The reduction or expiration of direct supports, many have argued, leaves a gap in the policy framework. The PBO explicitly notes that the addition of new units will only partially offset the decline in overall affordability support.\n\nCompounding these issues are plan reductions in funding from the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, the federal agency responsible for administering many housing programs. The report identifies $2.4 billion in cuts to CMHC funding over several years. This raises concerns about the system's capacity to deliver effective housing support. Reductions in funding for programs, administration, financing tools and sector development can weaken the overall effectiveness of housing policy.\n\nTaken together, these trends point to a broader pattern, a contraction in federal housing policy combined with a reorientation toward long-term supply measures. That is not all bad, but the national housing strategy is still the official policy of the government on the books and should be taken in the context of these changed policy metrics.\n\nWhen viewed in the context of the government's original promises, the divergence becomes even more pronounced. In 2017, the Liberals committed to prioritizing vulnerable Canadians. These commitments implied not only increased spending but also a sustained focus on outcomes for those most affected by the housing crisis. By 2026, however, the policy framework appears to be moving away from these priorities.\n\nThis does not mean that all elements of the current approach are without merit. Investments in housing supply are necessary, and efforts to modernize construction methods or leverage public land can contribute to long-term improvements. However, the scale and design of these initiatives are critical. As the PBO analysis shows, the current measures are insufficient to address the magnitude of Canada's housing challenges. Ultimately, the gap between promise and reality reflects a deeper issue in policy design.\n\nI think that warrants us to look at some of the PBO reports that have been issued by the Parliamentary Budget Officer on federal program spending on housing affordability. The first one was on June 18, 2019.\n\nThe executive summary, on page 1, states:\n\nCanada's 2017 National Housing Strategy...provided new funding for housing affordability programs over its ten-year term from 2018-19 to 2027-28. Taking into account existing and subsequent commitments, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) plans to spend an average of $2.8 billion/year on assisted housing programs over the [ten years] of the NHS. This represents a $0.4 billion/year (15%) increase in nominal spending over the 10-year historical average. Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC) plans to spend $225 million/year on homelessness programs, which represents a $86 million/year (62%) increase in nominal spending over the five-year historical average. \n\nIn the overall allocation of funding between CMHC's core responsibilities, there is a $325 million/year (14%) reduction in funding for Assistance for Housing Needs programs intended to help low-income households compared with the 10-year historical average. Within the Assistance for Housing Need portfolio, there is a $167 million/year (12%) reduction in funding for transfers to the provinces and territories and a $175 million/year (30%) reduction in funding for federal community housing. These reductions are partially offset by $200 million/year in new spending on rent subsidies. The decline in funding for Assistance for Housing Needs programs is offset, in terms of aggregate spending, by a $664 million/year increase in funding for Financing for Housing programs which are not necessarily targeted to low-income households. \n\nIt is not clear that the National Housing Strategy will reduce the prevalence of housing need relative to 2017 levels. Overall, Canada's National Housing Strategy largely maintains current funding levels for current activities and slightly reduces targeted funding for households in core housing need. CMHC's assumptions regarding the impact of NHS outputs on housing need do not reflect the likely impact of those programs on the prevalence of housing need.\n\nFrom chapter 1, the introduction, under \"Purpose of Report\":\n\nThis report is intended to help parliamentarians understand federal spending on affordable housing and the results that spending is likely to achieve.\n\n[The] report is undertaken under the Parliamentary Budget Officers' mandate to prepare reports concerning the government's budget and estimates. It was also undertaken under the Parliamentary Budget Officer's mandate to estimate the financial cost of a proposal over which Parliament has jurisdiction upon requests from a parliamentarian. In this case, a Member of Parliament requested an estimate of the incremental [financing] costs arising from Canada's National Housing Strategy and the cost to achieve the targets of that strategy.\n\nThen, under \"Scope of Report\", it states:\n\nThe National Housing Strategy was announced in Budget 2017 and elaborated upon in a subsequent policy document.\n\nThis is something I have already read.\n\nIt was presented as an \"ambitious $40-billion plan to help ensure that Canadians have access to housing that meets their needs and that they can afford\" by making \"unprecedented investments\" in housing. The National Housing Strategy Act, found in clause 313 of the 2019 Budget Implementation Act...would require the government to maintain similar strategies and national goals.\n\nThe National Housing Strategy focuses on program expenditures by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) and Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC). CMHC administers most program expenditures relating to housing affordability, while ESDC provides transfers to communities and service providers to help address homelessness. The focus of this report is direct federal expenditures by these two organizations outlined in the Strategy.\n\nThis report does not include federal tax expenditures. Details regarding federal tax expenditures related to housing can be found in the Department of Finance's Report on Federal Tax Expenditures.\n\nExpenditures by Indigenous Services Canada and Crown Indigenous-Relations and Northern Affairs Canada are not covered in this report. Expenditures of Infrastructure Canada were not examined since it does not provide significant funding for housing\n\n Chapter 2 is called \"How Much Does Canada Spend on Housing Affordability?\" It states:\n\nFrom 2008-09 to 2017-18, CMHC spent [on] average...$2.4 billion/year on the activities now included in its \"Assisted Housing\" business segment. From 2018 to 2027-28, CMHC plans to spend $2.8 billion/year on these same activities.\n\n Under \"National Housing Strategy Breakdown\", the chapter continues:\n\nAs noted previously, the National Housing Strategy was marketed as a \"$40- billion plan\" or as a \"$40-billion federal investment\". In reality, the Strategy committed...$16.1 billion in new federal planned spending....\n\nAs shown in Figure 2-4—\n\nThis is on page 6 of the 2019 \"Federal Program Spending on Housing Affordability\" report by the Parliamentary Budget Officer.\n\n—the \"$40 billion\" headline commitment in the National Housing Strategy policy document includes...loans..., new loans..., existing planned spending...and required Provincial‐Territorial cost matching.... Together with the $16.1 billion in new planned spending, this exceeds the \"$40 billion\" headline commitment. A full breakdown is attached as Appendix A....\n\nCMHC's total planned spending from 2018‐19 to 2027‐28 is $27.9 billion.\n\nAs we will note in future reports, it has gone up significantly since then, but in the interest of time, and having so many of these reports to get to, I am going to jump ahead to some of the findings they found in 2019.\n\nUnder \"What will the [national housing strategy] achieve?\", the report states:\n\nThe primary outcome target of the National Housing Strategy is \"530,000 households removed from housing need\" or \"up to 50% reduction in the housing need of renters.\" However, it is not clear that the National Housing Strategy will reduce the prevalence of housing need relative to 2017 levels.\n\nAs shown above, the [national housing strategy] largely maintains current funding levels for current activities in nominal term and slightly reduces targeted funding for households in core housing need. Furthermore, CMHC's assumptions regarding the impact of [the national housing strategy] outputs on housing need [to] reflect the likely impact of those programs on the prevalence of housing need.\n\nThis is something the report aptly does.\n\nOn to the report \"Federal Program Spending on Housing Affordability in 2021\", this is a continuation of the review of the Parliamentary Budget Officer's assessment of the national housing strategy. It reads:\n\nThe Government of Canada's current plan to address housing affordability is the 2017 National Housing Strategy (NHS), which runs from 2018‐19 to 2027‐28. This plan is primarily administered by Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) and Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC). These department's planned spending under the National Housing Strategy is $3.7 billion each year.\n\nAs we have noted, it has gone up from $2.8 billion in the 2019 examination already.\n\nAverage planned spending is driven up by time-limited programs implemented in response to COVID‐19, like the Rapid Housing Initiative.\n\nOf the $3.7 billion per year in average planned spending, $221 million per year...is dedicated to indigenous housing in urban, rural and northern areas.\n\nSince [the] 2019 report...Canada's federal government has allocated $672 million per year in additional funding to address housing...and homelessness.\n\nThe report continues:\n\nFirst, despite the increase in overall spending, funding for CMHC's assistance for housing need programs intended to help low‐income households increased only by $192 million per year...in nominal terms, which represents a 15% decline in the real purchasing power of federal spending.\n\nSecond, a significant portion of the community housing supported under CMHC's bilateral agreements with provinces reached the end of their operating agreements. This caused a [42%] reduction in the number of low-income community housing units supported under bilateral agreements between 2015 and the baseline established by CMHC's new bilateral agreements.\n\nThese were outlined in the National Housing Strategy Act.\n\nThird, CMHC's capital contribution programs have faced implementation delays. Over the first three years of Canada's National Housing Strategy, CMHC spent less than half the funding allocated for two key initiatives, the National Housing Co-Investment Fund and Rental Construction Financing Initiative. As of 30 October 2020, CMHC had made financial commitments towards the creation of 4,270 units of affordable housing committing [on] average [a] maximum of 52% of median market rent under the National Housing Co-Investment Fund. CMHC had made financial commitments towards the creation of 7,960 units of affordable housing committing to charge an average maximum of 72% of 30% of median household income under the Rental Construction Financing Initiative....\n\nFinally, we project that in the absence of additional spending the number of households in housing need would have increased to approximately 1.8 million households with a $9.3 billion aggregate affordability gap by 2025‐26. Over the period of 2021 to 2025, incremental CMHC spending averages 16% of the projected affordability gap and about $63/month per household in housing need.\n\nI am going to go on to the 2024 report because I have not even gotten to my analysis yet, after I read all of these reports last night, and that is the most important part.\n\nIn 2024, the Parliamentary Budget Officer highlights:\n\nSpending on programs to address housing affordability averages $6.1 billion...over the term of Canada's 10‐year National Housing Strategy (NHS).\n\nThis is a massive increase, we will note, from the 2021 numbers.\n\nThis represents a 50% increase in the purchasing power of federal spending compared with the prior 10 years.\n\nAdditional [housing] program spending has been primarily allocated to the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporations' Financing for Housing programs, which received a $1.3 billion per annum increase in funding.\n\nTotal spending on housing affordability is estimated to be $17.5 billion annually, with 65% attributable to tax expenditures.\n\nAfter accounting for the impact of all relevant federal policies, [the Parliamentary Budget Officer projects] that 2.6 million households will be in housing need by 2027. This represents an increase of about 926,000 households in core housing need compared to the start of Canada's [national housing strategy] in 2017.\n\nAlready, in 2024, we saw that the strategy was not working.\n\nAn hon. member: Oh, oh!\n\nBrad Vis: I am getting there. Do not worry.\n\nMr. Speaker, the report goes on to say:\n\nThe overall target of Canada's NHS is to remove 530,000 households from housing need by 2027‐28. After accounting for the impact of all relevant federal policies and economic trends, we estimate that 2.4 million households are currently in core housing need and we project that, by 2027, 2.6 million households will be in core housing need. We project that by 2027, there will be about 926,000 more households in core housing need compared to the start of [the national housing strategy] in 2017. \n\n Let us go on to 2025. Then we are going to get to my speech. I have to do my research first.\n\nIn 2025, in \"Build Canada Homes and the Outlook for Housing Programs under Budget 2025\", the Parliamentary Budget Officer highlights that:\n\nFederal planned spending on housing programs is set to decline 56 per cent, from $9.8 billion in 2025‐26 to $4.3 billion in 2028‐29 due to the expiry of funding for existing programs and cuts set out in Budget 2025.\n\nWithin this spending plan, Budget 2025 prioritizes...the construction of new housing through a new federal agency called Build Canada Homes. Build Canada Homes plans to spend $7.3 billion over 2025‐26 to 2029‐30.\n\nHere is the cliffhanger:\n\nBuild Canada Homes should be expected to make a modest contribution toward housing supply and affordability within the broader context of a large decline in support for housing affordability.\n\nThe report continues:\n\nBuild Canada Homes is presented as part of the Government's efforts to double the pace of housing construction over the next decade. That said, the Government has not yet laid out an overall plan to achieve this goal.\n\nOuch.\n\n We anticipate that the contribution of Build Canada Homes will likely be modest and estimate that the program will add about 26,000 units over five years, representing a 2.1 per cent increase in housing completions relative to our baseline projection.\n\nBuild Canada Homes has sufficient funding to create approximately 13,000...units of housing affordable for low‐income households. However, this occurs within a context of declining spending and a shift away from immediate affordability supports such as the Canada Housing Benefit and support for existing social housing.\n\nLet us walk through this and break down all of this important information because that was a lot of data. It even got me sweating, it was so suspenseful.\n\n I want to walk through not just what the government promised on housing but what the evidence shows. This is now a question not only of policy performance but of whether the government is delivering on its own law, the national housing strategy, and ambition in policy.\n\nAs I have reiterated numerous times throughout my remarks this morning, the government promised to remove 530,000 households from housing need, cut housing need in half, create 100,000 new housing units, repair or renew 300,000 existing units, protect 385,000 community housing units and reduce chronic homelessness by 50%, a suite of commitments that the government presented as comprehensive, time‐bound and transformational under the national housing strategy in 2017. It committed to cutting housing need in half. These were not small commitments. They, in the government's own words, were meant to be transformational.\n\nHowever, the Parliamentary Budget Officer made very clear early on that outcomes were already falling far short. As early as the first major PBO assessments of the national housing strategy, the evidence showed that the scale of program impacts was insufficient relative to the need, as the member from Winnipeg will note in my disposition of the 2019 report. Even before recent population pressures and interest rate shocks, by 2021, only a few years into its implementation, the PBO was already warning that the net reduction in core housing need was modest and that federal interventions were not on track to meeting stated targets.\n\nIn other words, the warning signs were visible well before the current crisis we find ourselves in today. The strategy was underscaled from the outset, heavily relying on slow-moving capital programs and incapable of delivering the rapid affordability improvements the government promised. Rather than correcting course when this evidence emerged, the government largely stayed on the path, allowing a predictable gap between ambition and outcomes to widen year after year.\n\nThe net reduction in core housing need is limited relative to the scale of the problem. That is what the Parliamentary Budget Officer stated in the 2021 analysis report. This was the first clue that something fundamental was not working, because when a plan is described as transformative, but its outcomes are described as limited, there is already a gap between promise and performance.\n\nMy second point is on the National Housing Strategy Act and ambition in law. It is also important to situate this legal framework in the context of the scale of the federal investment that accompanied it.\n\nWhen the national housing strategy was launched, it was presented as a $40-billion plan. Over time, that figure was repeatedly increased and reframed as over $70 billion in federal commitments across grants, loans, financing tools and program spending. I believe that as of last night, it is over $80 billion in commitments.\n\nParliament was told that this level of investment, combined with a rights-based legislative framework, as I outlined in my review of the act, would fundamentally change housing outcomes in Canada. The act was therefore never intended to operate in isolation from funding. It was meant to discipline and guide very large public expenditures toward measurable outcomes. Indeed, all of the speeches I read from concerning Bill C-97 in the 2019 debates reinforced that very point.\n\nIn other words, the bargain was clear: unprecedented federal investment in exchange for clear goals, timelines, accountability and a focus on those in greatest need. That is why the failure to meet outcomes is so consequential. After years and years of record spending, program expansion and administrative growth, the evidence shows worsening housing needs rather than the progressive improvement the government labelled in its original housing strategy, as I outlined.\n\nThis context matters when evaluating the current policy choices before us and this programming motion today. Bill C-26 and budget 2025 do not emerge in a vacuum. They follow a decade of escalating financial commitments that have not delivered the promised results.\n\nWhen the government seeks additional funds through ad hoc legislation while simultaneously reducing support under the existing strategy, it is not because housing lacked funding in the past. It is because large-scale funding, absent structural reform and accountability, has not translated into affordability or adequate supply.\n\n Seen this way, the issue before Parliament is not whether more money should be spent, but whether spending is being governed by a framework that actually works. The National Housing Strategy Act was supposed to be that framework. The fact that the government is now bypassing it after committing tens of billions of dollars without achieving its objectives underscores the depth of the policy failure we are confronting.\n\nHowever, this is not just a policy story. As I outlined earlier today, in 2019, Parliament passed the National Housing Strategy Act, and that changed everything because it legally requires the government, in section 5, to set out national goals, timelines and desired outcomes, and \"focus on improving housing outcomes for persons in greatest need\". At its core, the act establishes not only a statement of principle, but a framework for action and accountability that is directly relevant to the government's current legislative choices, including Bill C-26.\n\n This is where the government's position becomes most revealing. The National Housing Strategy Act was designed to ensure that federal housing policy is guided by outcomes, not announcements: clear goals and timelines, a focus on those in greatest need and mechanisms to measure whether progress is actually being made. New spending under that framework is supposed to advance those objectives and be evaluated against them.\n\n Bill C-26 departs from that logic. Rather than strengthening or reforming the national housing strategy to correct its glaring shortcomings and complete failure, the government is proposing a parallel track, authorizing significant new payments for housing supply without anchoring that spending to the strategy's target or the act's obligations. There is no requirement in Bill C-26 to demonstrate how funds would reduce core housing need, no binding affordability thresholds and no alignment with the act's statutory focus on households in greatest need.\n\n In effect, the bill asks Parliament to approve new money while suspending the very accountability framework that the Liberal government put in place in 2019. That choice matters. If the strategy and the act were working, new resources would logically flow through them, reinforced by tighter targets and clearer accountability. Instead, Bill C-26 would bypass that framework altogether.\n\n This is not an accident. It reflects a tacit recognition that the existing approach cannot deliver outcomes it promised. However, rather than acknowledging that failure and proposing a redesigned strategy, the government is seeking flexibility without accountability, with more money now and fewer questions later. This approach risks repeating the same mistakes at greater cost.\n\n Untied spending may move dollars, but without discipline and without parliamentary accountability, it does not guarantee homes that are affordable, nor the intended objectives of the minister. Bill C-26 therefore represents not a course correction, but an institutional workaround, one that would allow the government to claim action on housing while avoiding a candid reckoning with why its flagship strategies have fallen apart.\n\n The National Housing Strategy Act establishes the right to adequate housing as a \"fundamental human right\". These are not suggestions. They are regulatory obligations, which means that we must evaluate this policy not just politically but legally. Is it improving outcomes? Is it prioritizing Canadians most in need who are going to their local food bank and working two jobs? Is it moving things forward, as the principle that the Liberals outlined of progressive realization requires? No. \n\nLet us turn to the data we reviewed in the 2019, 2021, 2024 and 2025 Parliamentary Budget Officer reports that I outlined earlier.\n\nThe Parliamentary Budget Officer told us that housing need rose to 2.6 million households in 2024, yet only 78,000 households have been removed from need in that same 2024 report. This is not a small gap. This is a complete collapse in deliverology. The Liberals used to love talking about deliverology. That is a shortfall of more than 450,000 households. Barely one in seven who were promised relief will actually receive it.\n\nCritically, the PBO concludes that housing need is expected to increase over the projected period despite program spending. It is very clear. Program spending is not working. What the government campaigned on in the last election is not working. This is perhaps the most damning finding in my entire analysis today, because it tells us that even after billions of dollars and years of programs, the system is not improving; it is deteriorating. Public, independent evidence makes clear that this deterioration is occurring despite the creation of a large federal housing bureaucracy and tens of billions of dollars in announced spending. \n\nThe Parliamentary Budget Officer is repeatedly showing us that while administrative structures, programs and reporting requirements have expanded, the measurable outcomes that matter, such as reductions in housing need, improved affordability and faster supply delivery, have not followed. In effect, the federal government has built a complex policy and administrative architecture, but that architecture has not translated into results on the ground. Rising housing need, declining affordability and missed targets demonstrate that process has outpaced performance and that the scale of bureaucracy and spending alone has not been sufficient to meet the Liberal government's stated objectives.\n\nLet us look at some of the mortgage delinquency rates that are on the rise.\n\nMortgage delinquencies have increased significantly after nearly a decade of Liberal housing policy. CMHC reported in May 2026 that the national 90‐plus day mortgage delinquency rate rose to 0.2% in quarter four of 2025, up from 0.21% a year earlier. According to a 2026 Equifax report, the rate of delinquencies in Ontario sat at about 0.3% in the first quarter of this year, a jump of 52% year over year. In B.C., the number jumped 36% to 0.25%.\n\nRebecca Oakes, vice‐president of advanced analytics at Equifax Canada, said, \"When we look kind of at the mortgage trend, it is just a really good indication of the severity of financial stress that's happening in a region.\" Ontario is experiencing record stress. The housing crisis is no longer even about affordability alone. It is becoming a mortgage payment crisis.\n\nEquifax reported that mortgage delinquencies were up 52% year over year in Ontario during quarter one of 2026. In Toronto, mortgage delinquency rates increased by approximately 58% year over year. Data from CMHC showed that around 0.21% of homeowners in Hamilton had not made a full mortgage payment in at least three months as of late 2025, representing a 425% increase in that city's mortgage delinquency rate from mid-2022.\n\nHomeowners are carrying larger and larger debts. When borrowers fall behind today, they are falling behind on much larger mortgages. The average delinquent mortgage balance reached approximately $355,000 in quarter one of 2026, a 13.2% increase from a year earlier. Total consumer debt reached $2.66 trillion nationally. Mortgage delinquencies are often the final stage of household financial distress. The Bank of Canada found that households heading towards mortgage delinquency typically increase credit card utilization roughly two years beforehand, begin missing consumer credit payments one or two years beforehand and experience rapidly worsening financial conditions in the six months leading up to mortgage delinquency.\n\n Canada needs more homes, but the 2025 National Building Code risks making homes more expensive to build. The Canadian Home Builders' Association argues that housing affordability and supply are already in crisis and that the code changes should be evidence-based, cost-effective and implementable at scale. The CHBA has criticized the 2025 codes for insufficient consideration of their cumulative cost impacts.\n\nThe costs are so significant that in a February 2026 open letter to the Prime Minister, the Canadian Home Builders' Association calls for an immediate pause to that regulatory approach. The CHBA has cited federal impact analysis showing that high-energy performance tiers could increase construction costs by more than $40,000 per home. In total, the CHBA estimates that the 2025 National Building Code could add up to $100,000 in costs to a new unit.\n\nEvery policy should be tested against one question: Will it build more homes? Governments should be focused on removing barriers to construction and increasing supply. The association has warned that many regulatory responses to housing and climate objectives ultimately increase costs and reduce housing production.\n\n Let me expand on my speech on budget 2025 regarding less support, not more. One might assume that worsening outcomes could be addressed simply by expanding funding, but the evidence shows that money alone is not the binding constraint. The problem is not a lack of announcements or headline dollars. It is that the underlying policy framework has failed to translate resources into results. Structural barriers, slow approvals and misaligned incentives such as those outlined by the Canadian Home Builders' Association outline that very fact.\n\nDelayed project delivery, weak targeting and an overreliance on long-term capital programs have meant that additional funding has not produced proportional investments in affordability or a reduction in housing need. However, the PBO shows something more important: Outcomes have continued to worsen, not because funding was insufficient but because the government's approach failed to address structural constraints that determine whether homes actually get built and become affordable.\n\nSpending's falling 56% is a signal that the government itself is implicitly acknowledging that simply layering additional funding onto the existing approach has not delivered results. Rather than openly reassessing the strategy and admitting that its core design has failed, the government appears to be quietly pulling back, reducing funding while maintaining the same policy framework. This halfway acknowledgement, though, stops short of the full consideration the evidence supports, which is that the approach itself, not just its funding level, has failed to meet its objectives.\n\n I encourage everyone to look at the highlights on page 1 of the Parliamentary Budget Officer's outlook for housing programs under budget 2025. Federal plan spending on housing programs, as I just noted, is set to decline 56%, a decline that reflects more than a fiscal choice. It follows years in which the government failed to meet the core objectives it set for itself under both the national housing strategy and the strategy act. Rather than acknowledging that its approach has delivered neither the promised reduction in housing need nor improvements in affordability, the government is scaling back federal supports while leaving the underlying strategy largely intact, effectively retreating from its own commitments without admitting its failure.\n\nLet us be clear. Housing need continues to rise in Canada. Targets are being missed, and spending is being cut. This is not an adjustment. It is a quiet retreat from objectives the government has failed to meet under both the national housing strategy and the National Housing Strategy Act, an implicit acknowledgement that the approach has not worked, without the candour to admit failure or undertake a genuine course correction.\n\nIf I had another couple of hours today, I would probably delve into some of the comments made by the Minister of Infrastructure and Housing on his new approach and the new bureaucracies the government is covering. I just do not have enough time to get through all that in the time I have today.\n\n I will talk about the supply strategy and Build Canada Homes for a bit. The government's response is to emphasize supply, to build more homes and to accelerate construction, but the PBO even offers a reality check where Conservatives and Liberals might agree on improving supply: \"[Build Canada Homes] should be expected to make a modest contribution towards housing supply and affordability.\"\n\nAs I asked earlier when I read that report, what does \"modest\" mean in practice? It would be about 26,000 units over five years, a scale of delivery that underscores the failure of the government's current approach. Put plainly, this represents roughly 5,000 units per year nationwide, at a time when Canada is adding hundreds of thousands of new residents annually and facing a huge housing gap measured in hundreds of thousands of units. Even the Parliamentary Budget Officer characterized this contribution as \"modest\", estimating it would increase housing completions by only about 2.1%, relative to baseline projections. That is not transformational. It is marginal change at best.\n\nWhen a strategy promises to cut housing need in half but delivers a supply that addresses only a tiny fraction of that projected shortfall, this amounts to an admission that the policy levers being used are inadequate. The result is predictable: Housing needs continue to rise, affordability deteriorates, and the government declares success while the underlying problems worsen. In effect, the federal approach substitutes announcement and program branding for outcomes, producing numbers that are too small, too slow and too poorly targeted to reverse the crisis. According to the government's own independent budget officer's assessment, this level of supply cannot meet its stated objectives, confirming that the current strategy, as designed and funded, is failing to deliver the results Canada was promised.\n\nLet us delve a bit more into a structural problem in policy design. The issue is not just scale. It is design. The strategy has shifted toward financing tools and long-term capital programs. That is not all bad, but the PBO warns that \"this occurs within a context of declining spending and a shift away from immediate affordability supports\". I mention that in the context, because so many more Canadians are on the verge of being homeless. Homeless numbers are actually rising, while the government said they would do the opposite.\n\n The government has failed to prioritize the people who are in greatest need. The National Housing Strategy Act requires a focus on those in greatest need, but the funding structure and approach tell a different story. Funding is being shifted from programs that provide current affordability supports toward capital contributions with benefits over many decades. I hope there are some improvements there.\n\n Let us talk about generational impact. The consequences for the government's policy failures on housing are not evenly distributed. Young Canadians are bearing the brunt. They face higher rents, delayed home ownership, delayed family formation, rising debt burdens and other postponed life decisions. Even when new units are built, the PBO cautions, the addition of these units would only partially offset the decline in overall affordability support, so even new supply is not solving the overall affordability crisis so many Canadians face today. It barely offsets worsening conditions.\n\nTo add to these pressures, there is rapid population growth. Demand has surged. Supply has not kept pace, and policy failed to adjust fast enough. Over the last number of years, there have been historically low vacancy rates, rising rents and increased competition for entry-level housing. This is not an isolated policy failure. It is a system-level imbalance. It is therefore deeply ironic that the government is now taking credit for signs of easing in rental markets in some cities where rents have stabilized or grown more slowly. This change is far more plausibly explained by a reduction in housing demand, not by a sudden success of federal housing policy.\n\n Over the past year, the federal government has tightened and reduced inflows of temporary residents, including international students and temporary foreign workers, as it celebrated in the 2019 budget implementation act. That shift has had an immediate and measurable effect on rental demand, particularly in urban markets that absorbed a large number of the new arrivals. Fewer new entrants competing for the same limited stock of rental housing naturally does ease upward pressure on rents. That is basic economics.\n\n However, this is not a victory on housing policy, supply or affordability. It does not reflect new homes coming online at scale, faster approvals, lower construction costs or a more functional housing system. It reflects demand-side slowdown caused by changes in immigration and temporary resident policy, not the success of the national housing strategy.\n\n Indeed, if the government's housing strategy were working as intended, rent moderation would be driven by increased supply, improved affordability outcomes and lower usage of the food bank, especially for low and moderate-income households, not by reduced population inflows. Claiming credit for lower rent growth under these circumstances risks confusing cause and effect. Slower rent increases caused by the arrival of fewer people does not mean housing has become more affordable. It means pressure has been temporarily relieved by constraining demand. This distinction matters.\n\n A housing system that relies on dampening demand rather than expanded supply is not resilient. It does nothing to address the underlying shortage. It does not improve access for Canadians already locked out of the housing market, and it offers no assurances that affordability will be sustained if demand rises again. Without structural reform, faster approval, lower non-construction costs and a regulatory environment that enables builders to deliver housing at scale, any short-term easing driven by reduced demand will prove fragile and reversible.\n\n In short, the recent moderation in rents is not evidence that the government's housing strategy is succeeding. It is evidence that the imbalance between supply and demand remains unresolved and that the system responds more quickly to changes in population flows than to years of federal spending and bureaucracy. That reality only reinforces the conclusion that the core problem lies not with the funding levels but with the policy framework that has failed to deliver sufficient housing supply.\n\nAt the same time, the government has not moved fast enough to improve the economic conditions required for private sector building. Developers have faced rising financing costs, regulatory delays, increased development charges and approval bottlenecks.\n\n In fact, I think it is worth reading the February 18, 2026, letter to the Prime Minister. It states:\n\nDear Prime Minister...\n\nThe Canadian Home Builders' Association (CHBA) continues to support building code development where it follows principles of clear and convincing policy analysis, where evidence-based decision-making happens in public meetings and where committees emphasize cost-effective (ideally cost-neutral) acceptable solutions that equally solve the climate and housing affordability crises in Canada. We estimate that the new 2025 code will add over $100,000 to the cost of a typical new home...this is completely untenable. To that end, we cannot support the 2025 model codes or their adoption and call for an immediate pause to redo them properly\n\nCHBA has become seriously concerned over the last few years with how Canada's new governance system for national codes and its updated code development process is neither transparent nor evidence-based anymore. These deficiencies are having a direct and negative impact on housing affordability, construction productivity, and the ability of industry stakeholders to contribute meaningfully to effective codes development and implementation while reaching your government's priorities of additional housing supply and more climate change effective construction.\n\nFurther to that, by not addressing housing affordability in the national model codes, even though most provinces and territories call it a priority, there may in fact not be harmonization—the very reason model codes exist in the first place—because provinces may rightly reviewed and accepted by the time they are published, which negates harmonization by instead increasing the likelihood of provincial variations or non-adoption. Lack of harmonization at the provincial (and municipal) level is a key barrier to industry productivity.\n\nA serious course correction is needed, and thus CHBA is urging the Government of Canada to immediately pause all changes to the National Model Construction Codes, as Australia has done with its code system. With that, and before seeking adoption of the 2025 National Construction Codes by the provinces, CHBA is calling on the government to improve the 2025 codes with the proper lenses of affordability, evidenced-based decision-making, and a view to regulations that will truly lead to the optimized outcomes that must be considered in today's world. The 2025 codes should be paused, revisited, and re-issued once these issues are addressed, so that provinces can and should actually adopt them, and harmonization can be achieved.\n\nHere are our key reasons for pausing all construction code changes and revisiting them with proper focus:\n\nReduced Productivity—The large amount of national priorities and the pace of developing the respective code changes leave insufficient time for proper review, simplification and resolution of outstanding constructability or affordability concerns by those who are most affected—the residential construction industry...and Canadians facing affordability challenges in trying to buy a home. The amount of new code requirements is overwhelming. Changes related to energy, greenhouse gas emissions, radon, and wind/seismic loads add significant costs and delays and will reduce the productivity of the sector, while in many cases not even delivering the right outcomes. Much better approaches to achieve these goals must be found through a revamping of the 2025 code, with timelines and solutions that support affordability.\n\nAffordability Ignored—There is no formal requirement or code objective to protect housing affordability...\n\nAgain, the government's approach is not aligned with its national housing strategy or the National Housing Strategy Act.\n\nThe letter continues:\n\n...not even a principle for committees developing the national codes. Economic concerns brought forward by the construction industry are being dismissed, and cumulative costs for all changes in the 2025 codes have not been calculated by those developing the code. Ultimately, it is Canadians bearing the brunt of the added cost of these changes. All changes should be properly revisited to look at their individual cost impacts, plus the cumulative cost impacts of the full suite of changes the 2025 code will require on each home. CHBA's initial analysis of a typical 2500 sq. ft. home estimates increased costs from the 2025 code changes to be $56,364 (see Appendix A ) without any energy efficiency compliance cost. If provinces continue to mandate the progressive energy targets from the 2020 codes from Tier 1 to Tier 5 this would double those costs, bringing full implementation of the 2020 energy targets and 2025 codes to an estimated cost of $113,930 for each home built within the next few years. CHBA's Housing Market Index shows material costs alone for that same house have gone up $100,000 from 2025. Canada's housing crisis cannot handle these kinds of increases. A much more reasonable approach is needed.\n\nReduced Transparency—Recent changes to the governance and committee structure have reduced transparency and sidelined industry voices.\n\nIt would be interesting to see how many members of the Canadian Home Builders' Association are on any of the councils the government created in its National Housing Strategy Act.\n\nThe letter continues:\n\nDecisions are increasingly made behind closed doors, with little rationale published or meaningful engagement with those most affected—Canada's residential construction sector. The residential construction sector...can no longer be the target of poorly thought-out policies and regulations that take away from building more supply. If all levels of government hope to achieve building 500,000 new homes per year, they need to treat the sector as a partner, and excessive and ill‐conceived regulation is a key barrier to be addressed jointly.\n\nThe more I read this, the more the concerns outlined by the Canadian Home Builders' Association contradict the community-building partnership clauses of the National Housing Strategy Act. How dare they?\n\nThe letter continues:\n\nHarmonization Failure—Without addressing affordability in national codes, which is a key priority for almost every province and territory, the national codes risk being not adopted, or being modified so much provincially that there isn't in fact harmonization. To that end, the federal government should change the national code publication process such that provinces and territories have time to review a draft code for a year so they can collectively agree to a set of changes they can then adopt as fully harmonized national code at the time the code is published. Without this change, provinces will continue making their own amendments, which prevents harmonization and risks low adoption of costly changes in the 2025 codes. We are urging the federal government to take action now to avoid further fragmentation across Canada.\n\nFragmented Interpretation—Local interpretation of building codes varies significantly from municipality to municipality—even across the same city sometimes, causing delays and extra costs for the industry. This barrier to more housing faster has not been recognized by governments. As the government continues to reduce inter-provincial trade barriers, it also needs to resolve the fragmented interpretation of building codes that not only vary from province to province but also municipality to municipality. To that end, CHBA recommends a National Code Interpretation Centre be established at the National Research Council to publish code interpretations—provinces can in turn reference those interpretations, making them binding, and helping to end the endless variations on code interpretations that are a major barrier to industry productivity.\n\nThe roadblocks confronting the residential construction industry, such as rising costs, reduced transparency, and fragmented code interpretation will inevitably hinder the government's pursuit of doubling housing starts, including affecting the government‐supported housing to be built under the Build Canada Homes initiative. Without urgent reform, these systemic issues will undermine all efforts to deliver housing Canadians can afford on the accelerated timelines needed.\n\nFacing very similar challenges, the government of Australia recently paused changes to its National Construction Code until 2029, following a report from its own Productivity Commission. The report found that frequent code changes were slowing housing delivery and increasing costs. The pause is intended to provide stability, reduce red tape, and help the industry focus on building more homes. The parallels between Australia's housing challenges and Canada's are extensive, making a similar move for Canada justified and essential.\n\nTo that end, Canada should follow Australia's lead and\n\nimmediately stop the adoption and implementation process of the 2025 National Construction Codes, and assess them, with a plan to only put forth for adopting cost-neutral changes for housing in Part 9 of the 2025 national codes...\n\npause all 2030 code development until critical reforms are made to the development approach, such as\n\nrestoring transparency, accountability, and meaningful stakeholder engagement within the codes system\n\n adding an ex-officio seat for CHBA and other broad sector stakeholders at all CBHCC meetings (including in-camera meetings) to properly inform the development from an industry perspective\n\nreinstating a coordination committee dedicated to NBC Part 9 (which deals directly with housing) rather than spreading it across 13 committees with nonresidential construction\n\nreducing the priorities for the 2030 code cycles, focusing only on essential, cost-neutral requirements\n\n making housing affordability a core principle in code development along with a robust structured process to assess and limit individual-change and cumulative costs for each future code edition\n\nestablish a National Building Code Interpretation Centre to achieve consistent local application of harmonized national construction codes, and work with the provinces to make published solutions binding.\n\nCanada must act quickly to avoid the same problems identified in Australia and ensure our codes system supports safe, affordable, and climate-resilient housing.\n\nCHBA remains committed to working with government towards a more effective and inclusive code development process. We would be happy to meet with you and your officials at your earliest convenience to continue this important conversation and inform immediate action.\n\nThat was written by Kevin Lee. That letter was cc'd to the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure, the minister of Innovation, Science and Economic Development, the Minister of Internal Trade and minister responsible for One Canadian Economy, and the president of the National Research Council of Canada.\n\nIt also bears mentioning, reflecting on earlier words in the House of Commons today, that the minister responsible, when demanding $1.7 billion, unchecked, from the federal government, could not have referenced this very important letter outlined to him about what he needed to do to address housing affordability in Canada. It is from the very people the government depends on to build homes in the first place.\n\nGetting back to my speech and the failure to enable private sector construction, it is not because builders refuse to build, but because conditions made projects unviable. This point has been repeatedly underscored by the Canadian home builders, and it aligns with the broader demand-side story now being mis-characterized as policy success. Builders have consistently warned that the primary barriers to increasing housing supply are not a lack of willingness or the capacity to build, but an accumulation of policy-driven costs, delays and uncertainty that makes projects financially impossible to proceed.\n\nAs Mr. Lee outlined in his remarks, just the regulatory additions from 2025 alone add over $100,000 to the cost of a 2,500-square-foot home in Canada. How is that a good thing? We have to also look at these building code requirements in the context of the rental market, which is now showing temporary easing during our reduced population inflows, but where we still need to see more rental construction.\n\nIn other words, recent moderation in rents does not signal that builders suddenly found projects viable. It signals that demand pressures ease when inflows of international students and temporary workers slow.\n\n Builders have been clear that absent faster approvals, lower non‐construction costs and predictable timelines, supply will not respond at scale. Approval timelines stretching into years amplify financing risk. Development charges and levies imposed up front erode feasibility. Repeated redesigns across jurisdictions, as Mr. Lee outlined through the Canadian Home Builders' Association, add cost without adding homes. When these factors combine, projects stall or are cancelled, even as governments point to headline spending or short‐term rent data.\n\nCanadian home builders have also cautioned that subsidies layered into this environment cannot compensate for structural barriers. Supply responds to certainty, speed and predictability, not to complex program criteria or untied transfers, as we see in Bill C‐26. Without reforms that fix approvals, fees and coordination across governments, additional spending risks flowing to a narrow set of projects or even, in some cases, sitting unused. The lesson from builders is consistent: Easing rents driven by lower demand is fragile and reversible; durable affordability requires making projects viable so homes actually get built.\n\nCanadian home builders have pointed to approval timelines that stretch for years, during which carrying costs accumulate and financing risks rise. Zoning constraints, repeated designs and overlapping municipal, provincial and federal requirements add time and cost without adding homes. Development charges, parkland levies and infrastructure fees, often imposed up front, can represent a significant share of total project costs, particularly for multi-unit and purpose-built rental housing. Builders have been clear that when these charges rise faster than sale prices or rents, projects simply do not proceed.\n\nIf we look back on the 2019, 2021, 2024 and 2025 housing construction policies outlined by the Parliamentary Budget Officer, we can also draw a correlation between rental construction financing and some of these constraints faced by home builders. While intended to reduce costs and provide affordability for homeowners or renters, those costs, in fact, are so great that government financing is outweighed by the regulatory requirements that have increased the cost of home production in the first place, so financing conditions have compounded these problems.\n\n Builders have also emphasized that higher interest rates and tighter lending conditions disproportionately affect construction projects with long approval timelines. When approvals take years, interest rate risks alone can erase already thin margins, especially for rental projects where revenues are capped for affordability expectations. In that environment, even projects that align with public policy goals are delayed or cancelled because they no longer pencil out. \n\nCritically, builders have also warned that federal programs layered on top of the system do little to address these fundamentals. Subsidies and incentives cannot compensate for regulatory systems that delay projects or for cost structures that exceed what the market can bear. As builders have repeatedly argued, supply responds to certainty, speed and predictability, not program criteria or slow-moving capital contributions. Without reforms that reduce approval timelines, lower non‐construction costs and align incentives across government, additional funding risks sitting unused or flowing to a limited number of projects rather than unlocking broad‐based supply.\n\nIn short, the evidence from those who actually build homes reinforces the conclusion reached by the Parliamentary Budget Officer. The housing shortfall is not the result of building reluctance or market failure; it is the result of policy choices that have made building housing increasingly difficult. Until those structural barriers are addressed, no amount of new spending, whether under the national housing strategy or through ad hoc measures, such as Bill C‐26, will deliver the scale of housing supply Canadians urgently need. We now have a law requiring better outcomes, a strategy promising transformation and data showing deterioration.\n\nThe PBO's conclusion remains: The impact of federal housing programs is limited relative to the scale of need. That is our reality.\n\nThis is not just a policy failure. It is a failure to meet commitments, targets and statutory obligations. When the government promises to help 530,000 households in need and delivers only 78,000 units, when it plays around with its own budgets for housing and then, through Bill C‐26, asks Parliament to authorize new, untied spending for housing supply without reconnecting that spending to the outcomes, targets and timelines it established itself, it bears further scrutiny in Parliament.\n\nBill C‐26 and the programming motion I am debating right now reveal what Bill C‐26 does not do. It authorizes billions of dollars in additional payments to provinces and territories, but it does so outside the architecture of the national housing strategy. There are no statutory outcome requirements, no ties to reductions in housing need, no clear affordability thresholds and no measurable targets aligned with the act's obligations to focus on those in greatest need. In effect, the government is asking for more money now, while simultaneously retreating from the very framework that was supposed to ensure that money produced results.\n\n This suggests a partial acknowledgement by the government that its existing approach is not working, but a willingness to go all the way in admitting failure is beyond any Liberal, in my opinion. Rather than reforming the strategy to fix its structural flaws or aligning new spending with the legal obligations Parliament enacted in 2019, the government appears to be sidestepping the problem. It is shifting away from the strategy through re-funding allocations while pursuing ad hoc spending through Bill C‐26 that is disconnected from its own commitments. This is not coherence; it is fragmentation.\n\n If the national housing strategy were working, there would be no need to bypass it. If the act's frameworks were delivering results, new spending would logically flow through it, reinforced by clear targets, timelines and accountability. Instead, we see the opposite: declining support under the strategy, combined with new spending requests that avoid its constraints. That combination strongly suggests the government knows that its current approach has failed but does not want to formally acknowledge that failure or undertake the difficult work to redesign what is necessary to help build affordable homes in Canada.\n\n The result that we have today, therefore, is the worst of both worlds. Canadians are told that housing remains a top priority, yet the strategy that was supposed to deliver results is being hollowed out. Parliament is asked to approve new funding, but without the guardrails that ensure effectiveness. The core problems, such as affordability, access to affordable homes for low-income households and the growing gap between need and supply, remain unaddressed. In short, Bill C‐26 does not represent a fix to a failing strategy. It represents a workaround. Workarounds are what governments turn to when they no longer believe their own plan can succeed. The conclusion is unavoidable: The strategy is not working, and Canadians are paying the price. \n\nIn conclusion, according to the Parliamentary Budget Officer, Canada now has approximately 2.4 million households in core housing need, and that figure is projected to rise to 2.6 million by 2027. That would mean nearly one million more households in core housing need than when the national housing strategy was launched in 2017. The very strategy that was supposed to make housing more affordable has coincided with a dramatic increase in the number of Canadians struggling to find suitable, affordable homes.\n\nThe Liberals have announced program after program, funding envelope after funding envelope, yet the results continue to move in the wrong direction. The PBO found that in 2023 Canada added approximately 460,000 new households while completing only 242,000 housing units. In other words, household growth vastly outpaced housing construction. The result is exactly what Canadians have experienced: rising prices, rising rents and fewer attainable housing options. \n\nThe same report estimates that Canada will require an additional 1.3 million housing units by 2030 above current projections simply to close the national housing gap. That means Canada would need, on average, roughly 436,000 completed housing units annually between 2024 and 2030, far beyond current construction levels. For renters, the situation is equally troubling. CMHC reported that affordability remains a major challenge. With turnover rents increasing by 23.5% in 2024, young Canadians, newcomers and working families are finding it increasingly difficult to secure housing they can afford. \n\nWhat is most concerning is not simply the scale of the crisis, but the Liberal government's record. Canadians have heard the promises before. They were promised that the national housing strategy would improve affordability. They were promised that billions of dollars in spending would deliver results, yet the Parliamentary Budget Officer has concluded that housing needs continue to grow despite increased federal spending. Even the government's flagship housing accelerator fund deserves scrutiny. The PBO noted that very little funding was spent in its first year and that many of the housing increases observed in participating jurisdictions may have been driven by initiatives already under way before agreements were signed. \n\nTrust is earned through results. After years of soaring home prices, rising rents, growing housing needs and repeated missed targets, Canadians have every reason to question whether the same government that helped this crisis can be trusted to solve it. Canadians do not need more announcements. Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford does not need more announcements. That is why, in the first hour of my remarks today, I related Bill C-26 to the flexibility the government was showing and the lack of action we have had in the Fraser Valley region.\n\n It bears repeating, before I conclude today, that my riding is the confluence of the Canadian Pacific Railway, the National Pacific Railway and the Southern Railway. We have a border crossing. The Government of Canada has chosen the Abbotsford International Airport and an amazing Canadian company, Conair, to build the national firefighting fleet for our entire country. Conair already hosts one of the largest fleets of any aircraft provider in the country. We are using De Havilland aircraft built in Canada to supply that fleet. We have the Trans Mountain pipeline and the Sumas transfer station, which transfers 37% of oil from the Trans Mountain pipeline to the United States. The Enbridge pipeline expansion and the Huntingdon transfer station that the government just approved are in my riding. We have the arterial road connecting British Columbia with the rest of Canada.\n\n As I outlined for over an hour in this speech, we have received no federal supports, no flexibility and no accountability from the previous prime minister, who said that he would help us. Even today, High Commissioner Bill Blair said to me the other day, \"Yes, we broke the promises we made to you.\" It is my responsibility to continue fighting for that and to continue saying in this House that the status quo is not okay, if the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure can come forward with Bill C-26, a two-paragraph bill, to say that he needs $1.7 billion in additional housing funding, after a fund of $80 billion over 10 years has already failed every metric pointed out in the 2019, 2021, 2024 and 2025 Parliamentary Budget Officer reports. \n\nWhy can the federal government not support Abbotsford? I invite the minister to come to my community in good faith. I have never politicized this issue, because it is about Canada first, about the Government of Canada meeting its export objectives. Those export objectives run through the Fraser Valley. Canada cannot build if the Fraser Valley is not protected. \n\nWe are also the breadbasket of British Columbia. We are the heartland of dairy farmers, blueberry farmers and immigrants who have built their livelihoods supplying Canada with fresh produce, fresh vegetables and the best agricultural products we can find anywhere in this province, and we need help. I plead with the government to help us.\n\n This June, we are launching the review process for the transboundary commission. The Minister of Emergency Management, in good faith, sent the parliamentary secretary to support it after I requested it. I will say that in good faith, and I invite the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure to come and hear what people have said and about the suffering we have gone through. Our only request is to help Canada build, help improve those exports and help Canada meet its objectives.\n\nWe are in British Columbia. I know many Laurentian elites in Ontario and Quebec see it as just this place where they go on vacation and ski, sail and golf in a single day, but it is more than that. It is the export opportunity to the Asia-Pacific region. It is the future of Canada's economic prosperity and it completely aligns with all of the trade objectives set by the Prime Minister, so again, I plead with the government—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085691","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, these are only a few examples of how the government creates these big blocks of money without any accountability or transparency. What is the point of scrutiny when the Liberals are just going to turn a blind eye again and again to mismanagement? This is one of the most dangerous things Parliament can do: grant billions of dollars without any metrics of success, without any capacity t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dd24393c88b4282cf7fa01669da4eb278902519b0487fc4776a25081832473a1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c180d2fe5bf7596160154d6783c6064d484a2d1655782901ecdaaa8f634b41f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f7a6eb1ce9ec3cee8b0d5b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085692,"date":"2026-06-11T18:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, in conclusion, I plead with the federal government in good faith. As I mentioned, I respect the Minister of Emergency Management, who has shown up in good faith so far. I ask that she comes to our consultation periods, held in conjunction with officials from the United States, to hear what we are proposing. I ask the Minister of Infrastructure to provide the same level of flexibility he provides for the bill to the infrastructure funding commitments we need in the Fraser Valley.\n\n Canada needs this. British Columbia needs this. The Prime Minister cannot complete his objectives in the Asia-Pacific region until the problems in my riding are fixed, so to that end, I move:\n\nThat the motion be amended by:\n\n (a) replacing paragraph (d) with the following: \"(d) if the bill is adopted at the second reading stage, it shall stand referred to the Standing Committee on Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with Disabilities.\"; and\n\n(b) deleting paragraph (e).\n\nI reference this, because I want to see amendments at the committee stage that would put in flexibility for the Minister of Infrastructure and Housing to apply some of this funding—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085692","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, in conclusion, I plead with the federal government in good faith. As I mentioned, I respect the Minister of Emergency Management, who has shown up in good faith so far. I ask that she comes to our consultation periods, held in conjunction with officials from the United States, to hear what we are proposing. I ask the Minister of Infrastructure to provide the same level of flexibilit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fdd170d12ef4e1745c297545649be5293fe044b9ab50fba556783904c1105f12"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f8f6bd3bdd42e414eb78ca4531082f6d818b81b4ae888aea236c59ff56bb765d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da71879918ae54ebd2897a50","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085693,"date":"2026-06-11T23:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to rise today on this legislation. Bill C-267 is an act to establish a national framework to promote the durability of electronic products and essential home appliances.\n\n At first glance, the bill may appear straightforward. Canadians want products that last longer, they want affordable repairs and they want to get the maximum value from the products they purchase. These are reasonable goals. However, this bill represents a significant departure from the practical, targeted approach that the Conservatives and the Liberals have previously supported when it comes to consumer choice and the right to repair without imposing broad, regulatory structures. In the last Parliament, there were two bills. We had Bill C-244, from Wilson Miao, and Bill C-294, from the member for Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley.\n\n Bill C-267, however, takes a different path. Instead of removing barriers and empowering consumers through targeted legislative changes, it proposes to create a broad national framework that would require federal intervention in product design, product durability, repairability standards, information disclosure requirements and supply chain considerations across numerous industries. The difference is significant. Bill C-294 sought to remove obstacles. Bill C-267 seeks to create a new regulatory framework.\n\n I cannot help but outline the significance this legislation would have in the context of electric vehicles, based on some of the debate that took place earlier today. Is the government really proposing to tell China how to regulate its battery production when we just conceded 30% of our market share? I do not think so. I think this bill would open up a world of unforeseen problems for Canadian manufacturers.\n\nThe bill would direct the federal government to develop a framework touching on numerous aspects of product durability and repairability. While supporters may view this as a simple exercise, businesses often experience such frameworks quite differently.\n\n Frameworks frequently become regulations, and regulations create reporting requirements. For years, Canadian manufacturers have contended with the surge of low-cost imports. Rather than alleviating this imbalance, existing tariff structures have exacerbated the strain on domestic firms. Many Canadian companies are now forced to absorb things like tariff costs or share them with customers, eroding their competitiveness and limiting access to key markets. At the same time, the slowdown in the housing market is reducing domestic demand, further tightening margins for Canadian producers. The result is a concerning trend of increased import penetration, declining domestic production and the early stages of business closures across the sector. Without intervention, any future growth in the industry will likely be driven by imports, rather than by Canadian manufacturing. This is especially concerning at a time when Canadian businesses are already facing significant economic pressures.\n\nManufacturers, distributors, retailers and small businesses are navigating inflationary pressures, labour shortages, supply chain challenges and increasing operating costs. Adding another layer of federal regulation might satisfy bureaucratic ambitions, but it would not help Canadian consumers or business competitiveness and, ultimately, I do not believe it would help the consumer. In fact, it would risk limiting consumer choice by reducing lower-cost product options and discouraging manufacturers from offering certain products to the Canadian market.\n\nThe Conservatives believe the government should focus on enabling competition and innovation, not expanding bureaucracy through yet another framework. Before imposing new obligations on businesses, Parliament should have clear evidence that those obligations would produce meaningful benefits that outweigh their costs. That evidence has not been demonstrated in the bill before us.\n\nPerhaps the greatest concern is the potential impact on consumer choice. Supporters of this bill argue that it would help consumers, which is the opposite of what I said. However, regulations often produce those unintended consequences.\n\nWhen governments impose additional requirements on products entering the marketplace, manufacturers face higher compliance costs. Some companies absorb those costs, others pass them on to the buyers, and some simply choose not to offer certain products in smaller markets. Canada is not the largest consumer market in the world. We represent a relatively small share of global demand. If regulatory requirements become too complex or too costly, some manufacturers may decide that offering particular products in Canada is no longer worthwhile. I can only imagine the number of attempts by manufacturers who might try to circumvent any new regulations in Canada as well.\n\n The result will be fewer choices for consumers, not more. The result could also be higher prices, particularly for low-cost products that many families rely upon. Canadians are already facing affordability challenges. Many families do not have the luxury of purchasing premium appliances or high-end electronics. They depend on affordable options that fit within their household budgets. If new regulatory requirements increase manufacturing, certification, distribution or compliance costs, those costs will inevitably be reflected in the price consumers pay at the checkout counter. Conservatives believe that consumers are best served by competition. Competition encourages innovation and quality. When consumers have choices, manufacturers must compete to earn their business.\n\n One of our primary concerns with this legislation is the risk of federal intrusion into areas of provincial jurisdiction as well. Consumer protection, property rights, repair services, commercial regulation and many aspects of marketplace oversight traditionally involve provincial responsibilities. Several provinces have already been examining right to repair measures and consumer protection frameworks that reflect their own economic circumstances and priorities. The federal government should be cautious before establishing a national framework that could duplicate, overlap or conflict with provincial authorities.\n\n Canadians are frustrated when governments create multiple layers of regulation that accomplish the same objective while increasing complexity and compliance costs. Unfortunately, Bill C‐267 risks doing exactly that. Rather than creating another federal framework and empowering our public service with more tools to look at certain products, we should focus on policies that encourage competition, support innovation and reduce barriers for businesses operating in Canada.\n\nFinally, I think we should draw some parallels when we see the public service trying to over-regulate in the Canadian context, and that would be with natural health products. Across Canada, we have natural health food stores practically on every main street. They are a staple of Canada's economy. Small business owners across Canada, for the last number of years, have been decrying the government's desire to intrude and impose new regulatory frameworks that would push their business out of Canada and into online markets. Effectively, with natural health products, the government's approach has essentially meant that businesses are saying they do not have a future in Canada anymore. People are still going to be able to buy the products they were offering locally, when they were paying taxes in Canada, but people will have to buy the products on Amazon from an American supplier, because that is still legal to do anyway.\n\nThe government needs to take another look at this legislation. It needs to find better ways of ensuring that the electronic products we use do not impact Canadians' health, and focus on those issues, but ultimately leave the choice to consumers as to whether they want to buy a certain product.\n\nInstead, this bill proposes a broad framework with uncertain implications for businesses, consumers, provincial jurisdictions and the marketplace as a whole. At a time when Canadians are concerned about affordability, Parliament should be cautious before advancing legislation that risks increasing costs and pushing business out of Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085693","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to rise today on this legislation. Bill C-267 is an act to establish a national framework to promote the durability of electronic products and essential home appliances.\n\n At first glance, the bill may appear straightforward. Canadians want products that last longer, they want affordable repairs and they want to get the maximum value from the products they purchase. T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3709c2d1cddd800504df11a9a52318e72457184e456071ffa5fa7e87e1a50212"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2940eb4df25895597b5959df455231a4a8f75cd4155c2043b54e662663acbfaa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3df3301cf5303d227426c225","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087627,"date":"2026-06-17T19:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour the life of Mel Zajac, a remarkable British Columbian whose compassion and generosity left an enduring imprint.\n\n Mel's life was marked by a profound tragedy that ultimately inspired a legacy of extraordinary philanthropy. In July 1986, he lost his son Mel Jr. in a tragic accident on the Chilliwack River. Just eight months later, his son Marty was killed in an avalanche near Blue River in the Cariboo.\n\n In their memory, Mel founded The Mel Jr. and Marty Zajac Foundation in 1987, dedicating himself to helping others. Through his work, including the creation of Zajac Ranch, he ensured that children of all abilities could experience the joy, inclusion and confidence that come from summer camp. Because of his vision, countless children and families, many of whom face major medical challenges, have been given opportunities that might otherwise have been out of reach.\n\n At the age of 98, we have lost a truly extraordinary Canadian. I extend my sincere condolences to the Zajac family and to all those who mourn Mel's passing while celebrating his remarkable legacy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087627","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honour the life of Mel Zajac, a remarkable British Columbian whose compassion and generosity left an enduring imprint.\n\n Mel's life was marked by a profound tragedy that ultimately inspired a legacy of extraordinary philanthropy. In July 1986, he lost his son Mel Jr. in a tragic accident on the Chilliwack River. Just eight months later, his son Marty was killed in an a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8abef64feebd74d4114aff3e60a72325a1600c07cef584a1b99af7e486887d69"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7328eca356c026f3334ed158ae641fb82b8f7fef79fa51215cff2efcdb10a165"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7426a20b6b0bf1b355ee0371","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087628,"date":"2026-06-17T19:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on this side of the House we are incredibly worried. Statistics Canada reported on May 29 that \"business capital investment fell 0.7% in the first quarter of 2026, the fifth consecutive quarterly decline\".\n\nAfter years of policies that have left small business owners struggling, will these Liberals reverse their policies so businesses can get ahead?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087628","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on this side of the House we are incredibly worried. Statistics Canada reported on May 29 that \"business capital investment fell 0.7% in the first quarter of 2026, the fifth consecutive quarterly decline\".\n\nAfter years of policies that have left small business owners struggling, will these Liberals reverse their policies so businesses can get ahead?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["52cb79f76ca029369355382fd63d15b0c3b1c07b8444750dfb1e2fbec353d7b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c58210ed20e2666089eb962dc7a7b9507b93ab4d89bd4802776f0f9a05455c4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-359d5d275c1e09d03de58dc6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087629,"date":"2026-06-17T19:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal member for Eglinton—Lawrence badgered the CFIB as to why his own government's policies were not reaching Canadian small businesses. The CFIB says three in four entrepreneurs do not feel supported by the government, and many would not start a business today.\n\nWhy will the government not lower costs and give small businesses a real chance to compete, so we do not continue losing capital to other countries?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087629","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal member for Eglinton—Lawrence badgered the CFIB as to why his own government's policies were not reaching Canadian small businesses. The CFIB says three in four entrepreneurs do not feel supported by the government, and many would not start a business today.\n\nWhy will the government not lower costs and give small businesses a real chance to compete, so we do not continue lo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["39aa0c9a1e0360109eea3396b1d46abb181363f203a6a912ae30324cbefd5936"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3bb0e08a6d63ede1f54177cb8ca7d2477cd8ff57407b84a78b88d862c721a7a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e357c0e8a0877c78482a959e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087630,"date":"2026-06-17T21:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to present my first petition on behalf of the petitioners in Mission who are concerned about the proposed telecommunications tower at 32935 Cameron Avenue. The petitioners call upon the Government of Canada to review the proposed location and work with the proponents and relevant authorities to identify alternative sites that better reflect community interests and appropriate land use.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087630","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would like to present my first petition on behalf of the petitioners in Mission who are concerned about the proposed telecommunications tower at 32935 Cameron Avenue. The petitioners call upon the Government of Canada to review the proposed location and work with the proponents and relevant authorities to identify alternative sites that better reflect community interests and appropr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98835b53c0c0b1e0add3dbc9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087631,"date":"2026-06-17T21:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of Canadians living with long COVID who are concerned that federal programs do not adequately meet their needs. The petitioners call upon the Government of Canada to launch a national inquiry into Canada's pandemic response and the long-term impacts of long COVID.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087631","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is on behalf of Canadians living with long COVID who are concerned that federal programs do not adequately meet their needs. The petitioners call upon the Government of Canada to launch a national inquiry into Canada's pandemic response and the long-term impacts of long COVID.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d39a1afc2bda2867ac886eefa226b740587c62ccce0ba57875f5b00a60dd690"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c8729fb423d5654ab1ef6d79074ad97e0727d40e852487557596285d68277bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49e911d5180a373c38f74625","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087632,"date":"2026-06-17T21:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the third petition I would like to present today is on behalf of veterans in the Fraser Valley. They note that the absence of an office in Abbotsford limits access for a large and growing veteran population, which can lead to delays in processing disability benefits. They call upon the Government of Canada to open a veterans office in the Fraser Valley.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087632","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the third petition I would like to present today is on behalf of veterans in the Fraser Valley. They note that the absence of an office in Abbotsford limits access for a large and growing veteran population, which can lead to delays in processing disability benefits. They call upon the Government of Canada to open a veterans office in the Fraser Valley.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["641a21822cad8867c502ecf5ff91ddf40d21fd203980955542fb889fcb23c4ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11173a806431465a79d0c2be0e3adbe30181da1db51ff9cdf3b24cce6b386572"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f78fa416c29c879a7382b64f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087622,"date":"2026-06-18T15:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have a number of petitions to present today.\n\n The first is petition e-7198, which has 5,746 signatures. It calls upon the Minister of Fisheries to not remove the recreational access to chinook and coho salmon in the allotment of salmon allocation.\n\nThe petitioners note that they want to respect the rights of first nations and the conservation policies of the government, but they would like to maintain common property resource access for recreational fishers as well. They also note that commercial interests do not supersede those recreational interests.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087622","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have a number of petitions to present today.\n\n The first is petition e-7198, which has 5,746 signatures. It calls upon the Minister of Fisheries to not remove the recreational access to chinook and coho salmon in the allotment of salmon allocation.\n\nThe petitioners note that they want to respect the rights of first nations and the conservation policies of the government, but they wo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["36108006503b8e355c442de5545aa8845334f45d2263aecfe07822573f7d0d3b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a6fe6899902d9ce6a8e29aa8d940affe4fd9ffa3ae31febad6eff26e9a9e502e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ff987efaa882d22e49364ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087623,"date":"2026-06-18T15:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is with regard to the elimination of the federal apprenticeship incentive.\n\nThe petitioners call upon the Government of Canada to reinstate the apprenticeship incentive grant for Red Seal trades, index it to inflation, link it to the successful completion of technical training and ensure timely, predictable payments to support apprentices during their training.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087623","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition I would like to present today is with regard to the elimination of the federal apprenticeship incentive.\n\nThe petitioners call upon the Government of Canada to reinstate the apprenticeship incentive grant for Red Seal trades, index it to inflation, link it to the successful completion of technical training and ensure timely, predictable payments to support apprenti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7bbef3b3e741d30cfacc5caddf196ee097ec16cfd086d5074048a3ee562deec9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["792e3fc90a376e6c8360c53be0207d08ed2a90a4279b0af280fdbeb9ee4077f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f221c863951d8f86d66975be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087624,"date":"2026-06-18T15:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the third petition I would like to present today is on nicotine pouches. This petition is being presented on behalf of small businesses, including convenience stores. The petitioners call upon the Minister of Health to remove the restrictions on the sale of nicotine pouches to only pharmacies in order to allow convenience stores to sell the product as well.\n\nThe petitioners also note that the actions of the government have led to an illegal online trade and that it would be better to tax the product in Canada, versus allowing American producers to reap the economic benefits.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087624","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the third petition I would like to present today is on nicotine pouches. This petition is being presented on behalf of small businesses, including convenience stores. The petitioners call upon the Minister of Health to remove the restrictions on the sale of nicotine pouches to only pharmacies in order to allow convenience stores to sell the product as well.\n\nThe petitioners also note ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","label":"Smoking","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91788a0257e3d57732f9973097085d5d492a3932a29aec47a655e00950bb4409"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56cf200ca2a83c884cf806f0a250baa3ae77f1d3f69551036ea815a1580c2aeb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d40315471a5347634fad0a0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087625,"date":"2026-06-18T15:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-30 contains proposed new provisions under the Privacy Act and the Canada Transportation Act to assess the full value of our publicly owned airports. Rumours in British Columbia dictate that part of the new security agreement with China would allow Chinese companies to buy airports in Canada.\n\nCan the member confirm or deny this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087625","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-30 contains proposed new provisions under the Privacy Act and the Canada Transportation Act to assess the full value of our publicly owned airports. Rumours in British Columbia dictate that part of the new security agreement with China would allow Chinese companies to buy airports in Canada.\n\nCan the member confirm or deny this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95dfce68dcd4b99f7d5d1a779890eb10e2d4d74d428569a7adea07aa00e7d68b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9408dabf6c99475bed3fda07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087626,"date":"2026-06-18T16:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brad Vis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, earlier today, I asked a Liberal member a very simple question: Could he confirm or deny the rumours in British Columbia that, under the new security partnership between Canada and China and the government's desire to sell federal airport assets, Chinese companies would be able to buy those assets? He could not answer that question.\n\n Does the Bloc Québécois agree that Chinese companies buying Canadian airports would pose security threats to Canada's security intelligence regime?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087626","member_id":"bc-mp-89289","member_name":"Brad Vis","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, earlier today, I asked a Liberal member a very simple question: Could he confirm or deny the rumours in British Columbia that, under the new security partnership between Canada and China and the government's desire to sell federal airport assets, Chinese companies would be able to buy those assets? He could not answer that question.\n\n Does the Bloc Québécois agree that Chinese compani","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["125c15d9d215dce17bd8d46a866654f0a85fa46e13771c34527d9f08bb7ded84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9045b11b69af182d4d5a0fc16bd15ed1421e60f40ba44d9ac205acf6643b5dbd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99f1c04ed34d4013ccc511fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76587,"date":"2026-01-27T21:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is a new riding name, but I have been through four elections to reach this place four different times now, and I thank the voters in Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies for sending me here again.\n\nI have a really simple question for the member opposite: What is it that he and his government have against releasing Canadian resources, and releasing Canadian people to develop those resources, to make Canada the country that we can be? Every piece of legislation that I have seen from the government over the past 10 years restricts Canadians from getting our resources to market, including Bill C-48, the tanker ban, and Bill C-69. All of these pieces of government legislation have restricted the opportunity, the wealth and the prosperity that Canadians could be enjoying, rather than having to rely on the food banks and school food programs that the government spouts as being the solution for everything, when people would rather be able to afford their own groceries.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76587","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is a new riding name, but I have been through four elections to reach this place four different times now, and I thank the voters in Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies for sending me here again.\n\nI have a really simple question for the member opposite: What is it that he and his government have against releasing Canadian resources, and releasing Canadian people to develop those res","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb542c2fb7a690004e332a2ddd06907d8dcc18cc93a47a44758ceab5719153d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a6298a93d6ff3572de26cad3fbe790753eef8ac188537774c7009ed874a8552"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a0b02ea757dae6e930bb890","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76588,"date":"2026-01-27T21:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member spoke about bringing electric vehicles into Canada in his speech. I spoke with a car dealer last week who told me that his manufacturers have told him that they are not going to pay the surcharge that will be put on non-EVs. They will just not send them to Canada once the quotas—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-74/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76588","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member spoke about bringing electric vehicles into Canada in his speech. I spoke with a car dealer last week who told me that his manufacturers have told him that they are not going to pay the surcharge that will be put on non-EVs. They will just not send them to Canada once the quotas—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c35295eab25d8d875128df45f364bd834ad52bc57bdea3cd77ee65c447e0503"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b10214d80d5552c923a44e90e407117fadc6f0891b3ab8b8133b42093343ac1f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e28db8794a5cbb93fd873f52","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76589,"date":"2026-01-29T16:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister said Canadians should judge him by the prices at the grocery store. Now, food prices are rising twice as fast since he took office. It will now take $17,000 to feed a family of four, $1,000 more than last year.\n\nA record 2.2 million Canadians are being forced to visit food banks in a single month, all because the Liberal industrial carbon tax is driving up costs for farm equipment, fertilizer and food processing. It is worse than the old carbon tax, with no rebate for Canadians. Even Liberals realize that families are struggling to put food on the table when basic grocery costs are rising 5% to 25% year over year.\n\nWhen will the government finally introduce legislation that will eliminate the industrial carbon tax, eliminate the fuel standard tax, boost competition at grocery chains and cut red tape for farmers?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76589","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister said Canadians should judge him by the prices at the grocery store. Now, food prices are rising twice as fast since he took office. It will now take $17,000 to feed a family of four, $1,000 more than last year.\n\nA record 2.2 million Canadians are being forced to visit food banks in a single month, all because the Liberal industrial carbon tax is driving up costs for","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73df710c61404df0a23815602c34153f425a0ea56ffd0ae192a209bbe4db6263"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["57782b15c2c4825294817cc475e6bdcfac1a88d2540bef641519429f43387864"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a27b23bcfc769a6682d4218","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":76590,"date":"2026-01-29T18:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am honoured today to rise as the representative for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies and speak to the government's Bill C-16, an act to amend certain acts in relation to criminal and correctional matters.\n\nAll of us have a solemn responsibility to provide representation and voice to those citizens who depend on us to do their bidding in Parliament. Canadians need us to see the challenges and dangers they face and to do our jobs to make necessary amendments to federal statutes in order to make life safer and more secure for Canadians.\n\nIt is no coincidence that we are here in Parliament. The word \"Parliament\" was derived from an 11th-century Old French word, parlement, which means \"discussion\" or \"discourse\", and from the French verb parler, which means \"to talk\". We spend a lot of time talking in this place because our forebears resolved to use words rather than swords and cannons to resolve disagreements, to establish consensus for common good and to deliver solutions for the citizens represented by every member of Parliament.\n\nYes, Parliament can be raucous and adversarial, but we can never let the friction and heat deter us from the duties we owe the people of Canada: our duty to represent our constituents, and our duty to engage in discussion and discourse in this place, not for the sake of merely speaking or engaging in verbal scrums but to contribute to progress for the people. Constructive discussion in Parliament can certainly lead to collaboration, and this can include the governing party adopting proposals from opposition members and including those proposals in government bills, as the government has done in Bill C-16.\n\nOn September 17, 2025, just last year, I tabled my private member's bill, Bill C-221, an act to amend the Corrections and Conditional Release Act, disclosure of information to victims. Currently, victims of crime can request that they be informed of the eligibility dates and review dates for the temporary absence, release or parole of the offender who victimized them. My bill, Bill C-221, proposes that when the victims are provided with such dates, they are also provided with an explanation of how the dates were determined. When Canadians are victimized by crime, they often carry psychological and emotional burdens for life. My private member's bill proposes common-sense, realistic measures aimed at reducing the stress victims experience in dealing with the parole and release processes of those who have victimized them.\n\nAfter six and a half years of Conservative efforts to pass these proposals into law, it is good to see that the government has finally acknowledged the merit and necessity of these proposals and included them in a government bill, Bill C-16. My bill, Bill C-221, follows three previous Conservative bills that carried the same proposal. Those bills were Bill C-466, sponsored by the Hon. Lisa Raitt in the 42nd Parliament, Bill S-219, sponsored by Senator Boisvenu in the 43rd Parliament, and Bill C-320, sponsored by Dr. Colin Carrie in the 44th Parliament.\n\nThe legislative proposals of our bills are now included in a government bill, Bill C-16. They were initially developed and advocated for by Ms. Lisa Freeman of Oshawa, Ontario. Ms. Freeman suffered a tragic loss when her father was brutally murdered. Then she endured years of dealing with Correctional Service Canada and the Parole Board while trying to keep track of the offender who murdered her father. Lisa Freeman's experience dealing with these government processes was painful and added to the burden she already carried.\n\nI thank Lisa Freeman for her determination and bravery in persevering through the pain and trauma of losing her father to fight for the measures that increase respect for victims of crime navigating government processes. I am pleased that the Liberal government has finally recognized this as an issue and has chosen to prioritize my private member's bill's proposals by including them in Bill C-16. This means that much-needed changes could happen sooner for Canadians. This is a good thing.\n\nVictims of crime and the people who advocate for them have stated for years that these measures are necessary, and I am glad the Conservative leadership has caused the government to finally adopt these proposals. What is important to me and to victims is that these measures get passed in order to ease the experience victims of crime have in dealing with corrections and parole processes.\n\nCanadians count on parliamentarians to make Parliament work, and until the government passes Bill C-16, I will continue to work to move my private member's bill toward completion, because these changes are worth pursuing through all avenues possible.\n\nBill C-16 is an omnibus bill, and I think some proposed measures are long overdue but other clauses of the bill require amendments to be strengthened to deliver results and relief for Canadians facing real dangers. Here are some hard facts on the dangers Canadians, including my constituents in Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, are facing: Since 2015, human trafficking has increased 84%, sexual assaults are up almost 76% and violent crime is up almost 55%.\n\nBill C-16 has incorporated other pieces of Conservative legislation that was drafted. Bill C-16 proposes to ban deepfakes of intimate partners, and this would help keep Canadians, especially women, safe from non-consensual intimate images being created and shared.\n\nConservatives are glad that in Bill C-16 the government has adopted the proposal of Bill C-216, which was sponsored by the Conservative member for Calgary Nose Hill. Bill C-16 also incorporates Bill C-216 provisions for establishing mandatory reporting of child sexual abuse material. This would help protect our children from despicable crimes and exploitation.\n\nIn Bill C-16, the government has also answered calls from my Conservative colleague, the member for Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, whose private member's bill proposed that murder of an intimate partner be automatically treated as first-degree murder. I am glad that the Liberal government has heard the calls of my hon. colleagues and incorporated these proposals in Bill C-16.\n\nThese parts of the government's Bill C-16 are long overdue and are relevant to Canadians today. However, other components of Bill C-16 miss the mark because they simply do not go far enough to be relevant to the problems Canadians face today. For instance, Bill C-16 proposes to allow judges to ignore literally every mandatory prison sentence in the Criminal Code, other than murder and treason.\n\nThe Liberals are trying to allow judges to ignore mandatory sentences for crimes such as aggravated sexual assault with a gun, human trafficking, multiple violence with firearms, extortion with a firearm, weapons trafficking, drive-by shootings and more.\n\nI call on the government to hear the voices of Canadians who are living with a 55% increase in violent crime and want peace and security restored in their communities. Bill C-16's proposed elimination of mandatory sentence requirements must be split and removed from the bill so that it may be thoroughly debated and allow the solid parts of Bill C-16 to proceed expeditiously for the safety of Canadians.\n\nI call on the government to listen once again to the voices of Canadians who oppose light sentences for serious and violent crimes, and split the bill so we can advance the solid parts and work on the elements that need to be reworked.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-76/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76590","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-01","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am honoured today to rise as the representative for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies and speak to the government's Bill C-16, an act to amend certain acts in relation to criminal and correctional matters.\n\nAll of us have a solemn responsibility to provide representation and voice to those citizens who depend on us to do their bidding in Parliament. Canadians need us to see the cha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5295e5c68bec405ab25008eebeee4bc07cd313df421237a98f0359b18050f17"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c35a00070d234555a2e1e2d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287871,"date":"2026-02-10T16:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member has been part of Liberal governments for 10 years that are responsible for the crime, chaos and corruption on our streets. I was just reading an article from this week saying that 53% of Canadians fear for their safety because of crime, 56% avoid a certain area in their communities and 71% have lost faith and have no confidence in the justice system, which the secretary of state is responsible for.\n\nAfter 10 years of being with the Liberal soft-on-crime agenda and in that government, how can we trust the secretary now, saying that she is going to do something different?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287871","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member has been part of Liberal governments for 10 years that are responsible for the crime, chaos and corruption on our streets. I was just reading an article from this week saying that 53% of Canadians fear for their safety because of crime, 56% avoid a certain area in their communities and 71% have lost faith and have no confidence in the justice system, which the secretary o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a017a5803dea06046a3676f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306837,"date":"2026-02-27T16:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Liberal policies have made child poverty worse. The child and family poverty report card shows child poverty rising for a third straight year. Nearly 30,000 more children are falling below the poverty line, and almost one in five children under age six is now living in poverty. The number of children in severely food-insecure households doubled between 2019 and 2023.\n\nWhen will the Liberal government stop making child poverty worse, start caring about family food affordability and create a working economy so Canadians can afford to live?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306837","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Liberal policies have made child poverty worse. The child and family poverty report card shows child poverty rising for a third straight year. Nearly 30,000 more children are falling below the poverty line, and almost one in five children under age six is now living in poverty. The number of children in severely food-insecure households doubled between 2019 and 2023.\n\nWhen will the Li","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c7a9ae991391a36d60ccd0a30ce37ec1905f9131ee304ecf4dbac848acbe2ab3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4cbac64ca126fb20c7580ba34418c8a2b5f592068c77f8a75325382a43dc98f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d7521bde56816e1524d3af9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306838,"date":"2026-02-27T18:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I wish to thank all members who spoke to the bill today and those who spoke during the first hour of second reading on November 18, 2025. Their contributions and support are sincerely appreciated, not just by me but by all victims of crime and those who have worked on this bill.\n\nWhen Canadians are victimized by crime, they often carry psychological and emotional burdens for life. This private member's bill proposes common-sense, realistic measures aimed at reducing the stress victims experience in dealing with the parole and release process of those who have victimized them. The legislation before us today deserves to be passed because it would deliver relief for victims of crime. It would lighten the burdens they carry by providing them explanations about how parole and release dates have been calculated in relation to the offenders who victimized them.\n\nDebates of this bill, and of a previous bill that proposed the same measures, have reflected how these measures are supported by victims of crime and those who support them and advocate for their rights. As I have articulated in previous debates, the proposals in this bill were brought to Parliament by Lisa Freeman of Oshawa, Ontario.\n\nMs. Freeman's personal experience of losing her father and spending years navigating Canada's corrections and parole systems in dealing with her father's killer were excruciating for her. When the burden of losing her father to a violent murderer was compounded by the frustration of dealing with government bureaucracies, Lisa resolved to advocate for legislative measures to alleviate the burdens and frustrations that victims of crime carry.\n\nI send my heartfelt thanks to Lisa Freeman. I thank Lisa for her courage, her determination and the hard work that has moved this legislation forward.\n\nThe proposals of this private member's bill have been introduced in four consecutive Parliaments, spanning six and a half years. I also thank those who have worked with Ms. Freeman in previous Parliaments to move those proposals forward. I would like to thank the Hon. Lisa Raitt, who tabled Bill C-466 in the 42nd Parliament; Senator Boisvenu, who tabled Bill S-219 in the 43rd Parliament; and Dr. Colin Carrie, who tabled Bill C-320 in the 44th Parliament. I thank them all for their efforts to improve Canadian law.\n\nIt is good to see that the government has formally acknowledged the merit and necessity of the bill's proposals and included them in the government's bill, Bill C-16. These measures supporting victims of crime need to be passed as soon as possible. Canadians count on parliamentarians to make Parliament work, and I invite all parliamentarians to join me in moving my private member's bill toward completion, because the outcome of Bill C-16 remains uncertain in a minority government and these changes are worth pursuing through all possible avenues.\n\nThese measures could have and should have been passed years ago, and they were very close to being passed just over a year ago. Clause 205 of the government's bill, Bill C-16, contains coordinating amendments that anticipate the possibility of my bill passing before Bill C-16 does. I appreciate the government acknowledging this possibility and drafting those coordinating amendments in the event that my bill passes before the government's bill does.\n\nNow is the time for us, as legislators, to do our part and pass these amendments to the Corrections and Conditional Release Act, the changes that Lisa Freeman and other victims of crime deserve. I ask all parliamentarians to support victims of crime across Canada by swiftly passing Bill C-221.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306838","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I wish to thank all members who spoke to the bill today and those who spoke during the first hour of second reading on November 18, 2025. Their contributions and support are sincerely appreciated, not just by me but by all victims of crime and those who have worked on this bill.\n\nWhen Canadians are victimized by crime, they often carry psychological and emotional burdens for life. Thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2253758ef37001123de5c46ef087b9b421a3674d78e121e2a3931b3d788714dd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bb98b2f6a236962dc03bad2a39e7583470b22cf14533f877bf84a522e61bf984"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5b1cecd52b28f8847c05018","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306839,"date":"2026-02-27T18:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I ask that the bill be passed with the support of all parties.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-91/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306839","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I ask that the bill be passed with the support of all parties.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["097966740d11671392dafcaf345d8fe4548b683118e3ccfed640071bef5bb204"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-663c37b9128a6f77b6809ac0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336025,"date":"2026-03-13T16:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the February \"no jobs\" report shows the Liberal policies are not working for Canadians.\n\nThere were 108,000 full-time jobs lost, the largest one-month decline in full-time employment since 2020. Youth unemployment shot up to 14%. We have the only shrinking economy in the G7, and now we have the second-highest unemployment. Canadians are not working because Liberal policies are not working.\n\n When will the Liberals accept Conservative proposals, including our youth jobs plan, and remove taxes and bureaucracies that are killing Canadian jobs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-96/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336025","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the February \"no jobs\" report shows the Liberal policies are not working for Canadians.\n\nThere were 108,000 full-time jobs lost, the largest one-month decline in full-time employment since 2020. Youth unemployment shot up to 14%. We have the only shrinking economy in the G7, and now we have the second-highest unemployment. Canadians are not working because Liberal policies are not wor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["580f25ad2d57b49eba6e506ea414f5e78d755b92933f1d28ce36de17c75b3f45"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fdebfe867314c308421e1a981a0e11bf7766930082fad1b97f4596f6211ac1ed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e17f3d19ab2c9641c0609ef0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384522,"date":"2026-03-23T22:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in this House as the elected representative for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, a part of this country that is known for its significant place and time in Canadian history. Craigellachie in the middle of the Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies is the place where in 1885 the last spike was driven on the Canadian Pacific Railway, uniting this country from coast to coast to coast. I mention this because it was a time when Canadians were united across this country because of a vision of a Conservative leader and a willing private sector. It was a time of great building and of great accomplishments, not a time of division.\n\nI want to put this question to all Canadians who are listening out there. What would be more concerning than a Liberal government promoting a bill that would remove the exemption that ensures that clergy of any faith would not be found guilty for quoting religious books like the Bible, the Torah or the Quran? What is more concerning is the Liberal government's introducing this programming motion that would limit the debate in this House and limit the ability for Canadians to have influence on how and what legislation gets passed that would continue and control their futures. The Liberals have abused their powers to limit debate, limiting word changes and limiting amendments. Even reading of amendments being voted on was not permitted at committee.\n\nThis has amounted to the Liberals' censoring debate of a censorship bill. They have used their parliamentary strong arm to shut down debate with respect to Bill C-9, shutting down our voices as members of this House representing the voices of millions of Canadians of faith who have sent letters and submitted countless petitions all against what the Liberals would do in Bill C-9 and calling on the government to reject Bill C-9.\n\n Prior to the amendments put forward by the Bloc and supported by the Liberals, clergy were exempted from being charged with hate speech for simply quoting texts in holy books. Changes in Bill C-9, such as the removal of the religious defence for wilfully promoting hate, would make it easier for people to be prosecuted for expressing sincerely held religious and political views, and would create ambiguity in a law where clarity is needed now more than ever. As Conservatives, we believe that hate is real and must be addressed, but it has festered under the current Liberal government.\n\n The divisions in Canada have never before reached the point where they are now, after 10 years and more of Liberal government and the divisive policies of the current government. Canada already has bans on hate symbols and for obstructing access to a house of worship, making parts of Bill C-9 redundant. In fact, Conservative members offered to split Bill C-9 into two parts to swiftly pass the uncontentious sections of the legislation, but the Liberals rejected this. They took the easy way out by teaming up with the Bloc to attack freedom of expression and religious freedom. This bill and this debate are not about whether faith leaders should be free to spread hate; no one should be allowed to do that. They are about how hate is defined and how the law is applied.\n\n On December 9, 2025, at the justice committee, the Liberals and the Bloc voted to remove Criminal Code paragraphs 319(3)(b) and paragraph 319(3.1)(b), which say that individuals cannot be prosecuted for wilful promotion of hatred if they are expressing \"in good faith....an argument or opinion on a religious subject or...based on a belief in a religious text\".\n\n This is the troublesome part of this version of Bill C-9, which the Liberals are now pushing through with their programming motion. Calls to incite hatred or violence, whether cloaked in religion or not, are already illegal and not subject to the religious defence that Bill C-9 now removes. Religious communities, including the Jewish community, Christians, Muslims, Sikhs, Hindus and Buddhists, hold a vast range of beliefs on religion, morality, sexuality, politics and culture. Though some may find these beliefs objectionable, old-fashioned or even hateful, a free country does not criminalize expression of sincere religious beliefs.\n\nWhat is also really troubling in the bill is that the former justice committee chair said in committee on October 31 that there was \"clear hatred\" in some books of the Bible and Torah, singling out Leviticus, Deuteronomy and Romans.\n\nThe minister said:\n\nClearly, there are situations in these texts where statements are hateful. They should not be used to invoke...or be a defence.\n\nHe said that prosecutors should be able to press charges. He meant pressing charges for someone quoting sacred text.\n\nThe Supreme Court has recognized the religious defence as necessary to keep Canada's hate speech laws constitutional, because of how crucial freedom of expression and freedom of religion are.\n\nThe Liberals have tried to restrict what people can say through numerous pieces of legislation, including the online harms act, Bill C-63 in the previous Parliament, which they have committed to reintroducing in this Parliament.\n\nWe have seen, for over 10 years, that they simply cannot be trusted to draft legislation that is in the best interests of Canadian freedoms. In fact, they are still not accepting the court ruling that they actually broke the law when they invoked the Emergencies Act.\n\nIf there is one thing I have learned in my 10-plus years in the House, it is that when the Liberals say to trust them, it is time to take a closer look at what they are saying. They have repeatedly shut down debate and even gone as far as shutting down Parliament when they were caught pushing ideological agendas that were not in the best interests of Canadians.\n\nI mentioned earlier the time when the country was united by a railway and a vision of leadership. Unfortunately, over the past 10 years, now going on 11, we are seeing a country that is divided by Liberal ideologies and a lack of hope for what the country could be.\n\nWe do see them picking up some of the best Conservative policies and platform ideas, but too often those policies and platform ideas are watered down to the point of irrelevance or blocked by existing Liberal laws. I can only caution Canadians, and especially the Liberal government, against trying to limit the freedoms of Canadians. That is what our veterans fought for, our freedoms in this country, and I urge all Canadians to do all we can to maintain the freedoms that we have here in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384522","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in this House as the elected representative for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, a part of this country that is known for its significant place and time in Canadian history. Craigellachie in the middle of the Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies is the place where in 1885 the last spike was driven on the Canadian Pacific Railway, uniting this country from c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["315194d18d17867821f8d4500e1d1721955d2aed733899be6098498aca2729f5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8eb0fa8cda6ed83dcb32cdef0034c002a8d9966459fb8030a70eadae7efeaa5a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fbbe9da3eaa7d96bbca6304","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384523,"date":"2026-03-23T23:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, just to clarify for anyone who has tuned in to the recent diatribe back and forth about conduct in the House, I do not believe any of it was directed at me because I had been conducting myself in a manner appropriate to the House. The Speaker's comments, I think, were directed at others.\n\nHowever, it has been so long since the member asked the question, I have forgotten the name of his riding. However, I would just like to remind him that he has forgotten to mention a few things while he was up and had an opportunity to speak. He did not mention the crime and chaos that has been unleashed on Canada's streets since the Liberals took power over 10 years ago. He did not mention the burning of churches. Over 100 churches have been burned, and the Liberals have been silent on that. He did not mention the shootings at synagogues that have happened over the past number of months. He did not mention the extortion that has taken place because Liberals have unleashed crime and hatred on the streets like we have never seen in Canadian history.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384523","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, just to clarify for anyone who has tuned in to the recent diatribe back and forth about conduct in the House, I do not believe any of it was directed at me because I had been conducting myself in a manner appropriate to the House. The Speaker's comments, I think, were directed at others.\n\nHowever, it has been so long since the member asked the question, I have forgotten the name of hi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0555c61b890e8035aa2f03b36cb963f01fefc6963bf0d8b9ac705dd420318bf6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ee531f49502cebad8a97580","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384524,"date":"2026-03-23T23:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the aspect of self-censorship or censorship is really paramount to some of the discussion we are having here.\n\nWe have seen how the Liberals are shutting down debate or censoring a censorship bill. I do not think there is anything that could be more troubling from a government that has always sought to have ultimate power by censoring the people. That, I believe, is what the government is truly seeking.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384524","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the aspect of self-censorship or censorship is really paramount to some of the discussion we are having here.\n\nWe have seen how the Liberals are shutting down debate or censoring a censorship bill. I do not think there is anything that could be more troubling from a government that has always sought to have ultimate power by censoring the people. That, I believe, is what the governmen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c156010783891812e3a528e3015987a504ecbdc88ca66f9aa7caf342270e702"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65d4f4d1c19fc88cf26b3f44a0e2c3dec0bbea751f4eb827c6492f2686599999"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a597cda9374198c0392f38a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384525,"date":"2026-03-23T23:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member for Winnipeg North did point out that there are many pieces of Bill C-9 that are positive. Conservatives offered to split this bill and deal with those components expeditiously, so they could have been passed long ago. It was this ultimate censorship that the government is invoking and then ending the debate on it and not allowing members who represent Canadians across the country to continue the debate so that the reality and truth could be told.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384525","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member for Winnipeg North did point out that there are many pieces of Bill C-9 that are positive. Conservatives offered to split this bill and deal with those components expeditiously, so they could have been passed long ago. It was this ultimate censorship that the government is invoking and then ending the debate on it and not allowing members who represent Canadians across the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["951fd99fb88e4933dff962a2f6298afbe94999e58e22fdb3f676a7f0bf109f2f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-376e6de29253794a26a6961f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384518,"date":"2026-03-26T16:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present multiple petitions.\n\nThe first petition is on behalf of Canadians who are deeply concerned about proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy, which would decimate public fishing opportunities for chinook and coho salmon in British Columbia. Changing the common property resource principle risks turning a shared public resource into an exclusive privilege, reducing access for many Canadians and undermining confidence in fisheries management. The petitioners note that it would be devastating to our tourism economy and the millions of dollars that flow into conservation efforts. \n\nThis petition calls upon the government to keep the common property resource principle in the revised salmon allocation policy so that salmon remain a publicly managed resource, federal stewardship stays transparent and conservation-focused, and no single group is given exclusive control over access.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384518","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present multiple petitions.\n\nThe first petition is on behalf of Canadians who are deeply concerned about proposed changes to the salmon allocation policy, which would decimate public fishing opportunities for chinook and coho salmon in British Columbia. Changing the common property resource principle risks turning a shared public resource into an exclusive privilege, r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e231dce33ff846e69be739e2f489cb45be494a72a65c118a5b10378e779bde6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5169c6172e731f6f6fb4867c48ffe0bd3dd44f43afc9cd87668c99d8bc4f04e7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-734134a711d8215875bb9f3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384519,"date":"2026-03-26T16:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the other five petitions I have today are from residents of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. They are concerned about Bill C-9, which was passed in this House but is still going through the Senate. \n\nThey call upon the government to reject any amendments to Bill C-9 that remove the religious exemption from Canada's hate speech provisions, protect Canadians' constitutional rights to freedom of religion and expression and ensure that legislation does not criminalize good faith religious discourse or teaching.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384519","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the other five petitions I have today are from residents of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. They are concerned about Bill C-9, which was passed in this House but is still going through the Senate. \n\nThey call upon the government to reject any amendments to Bill C-9 that remove the religious exemption from Canada's hate speech provisions, protect Canadians' constitutional rights to f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4b67106d46a10d64590d9a9508624822f7df59455c4eb042a8e49a08723c5604"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["175329e6dabe2f838f1eba2962ff7a7181ac5067f3a52a977d4eff10c5af1495"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5bec7743c0a2d7d5f0d8325","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384520,"date":"2026-03-26T20:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada's fisheries resources do belong to the people of Canada. The fisheries minister confirmed this last October when I asked her at the fisheries committee. However, the minister's department has recklessly published a proposal that would eliminate this principle, and Canadians are paying the price for the uncertainty it has caused.\n\nWas the minister's statement at committee more Liberal bait and switch, or will she reaffirm that Canada's fisheries resources belong to the people of Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384520","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada's fisheries resources do belong to the people of Canada. The fisheries minister confirmed this last October when I asked her at the fisheries committee. However, the minister's department has recklessly published a proposal that would eliminate this principle, and Canadians are paying the price for the uncertainty it has caused.\n\nWas the minister's statement at committee more L","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73f20595579c5a97ecb9b67fa57922ae188c1306c5a2d05d86c387ddc52e5275"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c4553b9566086d83bf0b86a5347b4b31b1283709077c6f5741e478caacc9e6d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72eb22e0b8ba391643bc527f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384521,"date":"2026-03-26T20:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it sounds like the minister is tired of hearing from Canadians, but Conservatives will not stop raising their voices on their behalf.\n\n We recognize that the salmon allocation policy must be aligned with the Ahousaht decision. No one is disputing that in the policy's review, but why is the minister's department floating the proposal to go far beyond, and proposing to sink over 9,000 jobs in B.C. by gutting the public fisheries' access to chinook and coho salmon?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384521","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it sounds like the minister is tired of hearing from Canadians, but Conservatives will not stop raising their voices on their behalf.\n\n We recognize that the salmon allocation policy must be aligned with the Ahousaht decision. No one is disputing that in the policy's review, but why is the minister's department floating the proposal to go far beyond, and proposing to sink over 9,000 j","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:222216","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Freshwater fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:222216","label":"Freshwater fish","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db4e37fe6c14b974a0cb69814a342243767fca2243bdcb07668ae64d4948ce89"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f63562153376390a03286989","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109837,"date":"2026-04-15T21:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to both witnesses for your testimony today. I want to start with Mr. Bird, please. In your experience as a fishing guide—you mentioned that you've done this for a number of years—how far ahead were clients booking vacation time from their workplace, and how far ahead were they typically planning trips?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109837","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to both witnesses for your testimony today. I want to start with Mr. Bird, please. In your experience as a fishing guide—you mentioned that you've done this for a number of years—how far ahead were clients booking vacation time from their workplace, and how far ahead were they typically planning trips?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a5722e9bc261f7c30bc54f2d34fe5f0ef1ec525b6368ebb676dfcd722ed3c2ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b335fb979de9ac84c191cb5b9359d942756703f9ba41957565faf8c35761c94"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aee04cf6b72baf75ca8b4301","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109838,"date":"2026-04-15T21:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"This covers the people who are purchasing these trips and so on. Moving to the people who are selling the trips or the gear that's required—a marina buying small boats to take clients out, making sure they have enough guides on staff or making sure that the tackle shops have the gear they need—how far in advance do they have to make those arrangements for staffing, equipment and sales items?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109838","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This covers the people who are purchasing these trips and so on. Moving to the people who are selling the trips or the gear that's required—a marina buying small boats to take clients out, making sure they have enough guides on staff or making sure that the tackle shops have the gear they need—how far in advance do they have to make those arrangements for staffing, equipment and sales items?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","label":"Equipment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","label":"Equipment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7ad05c5b9c5c95f43bab62683efbcc59e28a555592e157b1e9747e9e84688b80"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94857b763f41ef90aabbef12cb6e9cd3c88f1d5d66666cab9d25bdb32600709b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-857228be12d4ff796c564a6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109839,"date":"2026-04-15T21:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"What would be the impact if there wasn't some certainty that the seasons would run for times similar to those of the previous year or years?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109839","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What would be the impact if there wasn't some certainty that the seasons would run for times similar to those of the previous year or years?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29215143bc9003d78f18ea67939902954d609c52f66ecc76f9ae77b08f6d1a8e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-003ff470d170070ed36c6563","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109840,"date":"2026-04-15T21:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"What would clients do if there was another location with more certainty?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109840","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What would clients do if there was another location with more certainty?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035997","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Isolated communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035997","label":"Isolated communities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a020286660c524e4822509e86aec22992fc96105c39ba33da0203002a28eea5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af48a038ff72a7690051b996","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109841,"date":"2026-04-15T21:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Can you give me any information about your experience with what happened last year on the west coast? We had a superabundant return of sockeye salmon that was far over early expectations. Was there any additional opportunity issued, or were there delays in getting the opportunity available?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109841","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Can you give me any information about your experience with what happened last year on the west coast? We had a superabundant return of sockeye salmon that was far over early expectations. Was there any additional opportunity issued, or were there delays in getting the opportunity available?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-accfddd0529a9a6fd9a990f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109842,"date":"2026-04-15T21:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Has the Sport Fishing Institute of British Columbia estimated the economic opportunity that may have been lost?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109842","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Has the Sport Fishing Institute of British Columbia estimated the economic opportunity that may have been lost?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["17cfdb6d12dc235ca68dad4e3af2ab85bead3b31f7b66d57b0d43cf84e42c558"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ceb91a2a85bbaa147b939f8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109843,"date":"2026-04-15T21:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Has this been a trend of greater uncertainty over any length of time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109843","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Has this been a trend of greater uncertainty over any length of time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a6a75b326c4284858d5304f566368778755e567acbf39561d76bc568cec9c18"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b149c4d869fdad35d84c752c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109844,"date":"2026-04-15T21:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109844","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89e015bd0e49f300cfcd4b0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109845,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I thank all three witnesses for being here. It's an important study. I want to start out with Mr. Zeman, if I could. You talked about the impact on the sockeye fishery last year. I believe you said that only 5% of the catch was.... Was that 5% of the total allowable catch or was that 5% of the return of the run? A lot of people don't understand that there is an expected return and then there's an expected number that are allowed to be caught out of that, to allow the escape.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109845","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thank all three witnesses for being here. It's an important study. I want to start out with Mr. Zeman, if I could. You talked about the impact on the sockeye fishery last year. I believe you said that only 5% of the catch was.... Was that 5% of the total allowable catch or was that 5% of the return of the run? A lot of people don't understand that there is an expected return and then there's an ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fishing (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035298","label":"Fishing (Sport)","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["502497aa292e731616db7e2a72809e515bb68baaa35b48bc28b518fe21d22c71"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-091d5b603957970118469533","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109846,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"This is less than 1% of the entire return that came back. Thanks for clarifying that. This was my first piece about what impact the public fishery has. Have the recreational or public fisheries ever been the cause of a fish stock becoming at-risk, on the west coast or in Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109846","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This is less than 1% of the entire return that came back. Thanks for clarifying that. This was my first piece about what impact the public fishery has. Have the recreational or public fisheries ever been the cause of a fish stock becoming at-risk, on the west coast or in Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d510d868b1e61338fed08b3d803755f8e002d1008cedfc3ec824bb7ec0b8b29"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75d6f91940d69fab97656bf986760975d1e32c4b8dc7b16564ca66aa4b747c46"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e58dec2522878e8861053d03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109847,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"To your knowledge, no fish stocks have been put at risk through a public fishery.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109847","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"To your knowledge, no fish stocks have been put at risk through a public fishery.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3bfee7cda8012f32be989b4059fbe8e0cbe0a49cfc230b253d48ad58a3833c04"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc663d0bdf08cbacdc84f656","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109848,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay, but you've been at it for a while. Going back to the season openings last year, what organizations had input into the season openings, the potential expansion of the opportunity or the delays in the expansion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109848","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay, but you've been at it for a while. Going back to the season openings last year, what organizations had input into the season openings, the potential expansion of the opportunity or the delays in the expansion?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ed4719a664853c09e9bfb55f388b58028c6d50b2e14fc7f8e210b0188e9d685"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f3749951ede6cdca0193e66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109849,"date":"2026-04-15T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Brown, I believe it was you who said that there were concerns from the Pacific Salmon Commission last year regarding the sockeye fishery. Was it you who mentioned this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109849","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Brown, I believe it was you who said that there were concerns from the Pacific Salmon Commission last year regarding the sockeye fishery. Was it you who mentioned this?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66af3df214a6bb26f1f9be4cd13b1e949572e59b97630210cb8c9156714cabc8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-803a06e3d60f09a00f2c79d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109850,"date":"2026-04-15T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Was that Mr. Zeman? Can you elaborate on this? What were those concerns from the Pacific Salmon Commission?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109850","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Was that Mr. Zeman? Can you elaborate on this? What were those concerns from the Pacific Salmon Commission?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["85ce540d847101a954f634360fc2ba35c40a754b1edf23483df3c79a14a3df7e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9019e4b823158235ec57b6d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109851,"date":"2026-04-15T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Brown, you talked about stock assessments, how important they are and the delays or the lateness of them. Can you elaborate a little more on that? We've heard that some of these stock assessments are going to be eliminated through cuts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109851","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Brown, you talked about stock assessments, how important they are and the delays or the lateness of them. Can you elaborate a little more on that? We've heard that some of these stock assessments are going to be eliminated through cuts.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07f72ba4550e196f7029debc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109852,"date":"2026-04-15T22:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"It sounds as though the government is cutting off the cash flow that could be coming in from the public fisheries—the cash flow they need to do the stock assessments. They've cut the stock assessment, so you can't fish.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109852","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It sounds as though the government is cutting off the cash flow that could be coming in from the public fisheries—the cash flow they need to do the stock assessments. They've cut the stock assessment, so you can't fish.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035295","label":"Fisheries technology","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92b515f5220219720a47943d2c6f5a398aee33503d706582d96632abfebfb18d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b6e827dc240d98392e48dc6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109853,"date":"2026-04-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you for sharing your time. I have one question for each of the three of you. What would you recommend to the DFO when it comes to season openings? The crux of this report is making recommendations to the government to improve the process of getting seasons opened or being adaptable. We'll go to whoever would like to start and then go down the line.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109853","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for sharing your time. I have one question for each of the three of you. What would you recommend to the DFO when it comes to season openings? The crux of this report is making recommendations to the government to improve the process of getting seasons opened or being adaptable. We'll go to whoever would like to start and then go down the line.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebc6125687371715f29bea71","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109854,"date":"2026-04-15T22:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"The policy is there. It's just how it's being interpreted under different.... Is that by—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109854","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The policy is there. It's just how it's being interpreted under different.... Is that by—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb48fea53b0ee5c0dcef395924b767c2535ee53667235f996afa3f3703401e4d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-367244b853a2ea1b1f8f214b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109855,"date":"2026-04-15T23:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. I think that was....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109855","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I think that was....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3bb395530aed396c9a001508","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109856,"date":"2026-04-15T23:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I took Mr. Deschênes' time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109856","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I took Mr. Deschênes' time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97e7e79868c29303268e5de5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109857,"date":"2026-04-15T23:00:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay. I'll pass the remaining four minutes on to Mr. Small.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-31/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109857","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. I'll pass the remaining four minutes on to Mr. Small.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f5dcb3ed2e515666b6087d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":426112,"date":"2026-04-16T23:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in this House as the elected representative for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, and as the associate shadow minister for fisheries for His Majesty's official loyal opposition.\n\n I am here today to debate the response to the question I posed to the Minister of Fisheries on March 26, 2026, when I asked if she would reaffirm a principle that is foundational to the management and control of Canada's fisheries: the principle that fisheries resources belong to the people of Canada. The minister replied, \"Pacific salmon will remain a shared public resource managed by the federal government.\" The minister also stated, \"A revised salmon allocation policy will not take away [anyone's] access to the resource.\"\n\n Despite the minister's response, many Canadians remain very concerned, because it is unclear whether Canadians would continue to be able to depend on the shared public resource principle in order to access just an opportunity to fish for salmon. Canadians remain concerned because the minister's answer did not provide any specifics detailing how the Government of Canada would continue to manage Pacific salmon for all Canadians as a shared public resource. The minister did not state how much access Canadians would have to the shared public resource of Pacific salmon.\n\n In responding, the minister also stated that suggesting that the government would not uphold the shared public resource principle was wrong and divisive. It is ironic that the minister would issue this indictment, when it was her department that published a discussion paper that contained a proposal for the shared public resource principle to be removed from the government's salmon allocation policy. Documents produced and made public by her own government have caused concerns among Canadians. They do not know how the salmon would be managed and by whom, and what organizations would influence or control the management of wild Pacific salmon.\n\n The minister's response was also unclear on what level of access may remain for the public fisheries. She stated, \"A revised salmon allocation policy will not take away [anyone's] access to the resource\", but she failed to state whether anyone's access and priority of access to the resource would be increased or in fact reduced. It is easy to say that no one's access would be taken away, but this does not mean that access would not be further limited or reduced in priority ranking. \n\nCanadians deserve clarity from their government, especially cabinet ministers, on what the government has planned for their future access to Canada's shared public resources. What are the government's plans for the economics, the activities that put food on the table and that build family and heritage connections to the lands and waters we all value so highly?\n\n Will the minister confirm that the public would not lose ranking in priority of access to chinook and coho salmon, and that wild Pacific salmon would be maintained as a shared public resource for the use and benefit of all Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:426112","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in this House as the elected representative for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, and as the associate shadow minister for fisheries for His Majesty's official loyal opposition.\n\n I am here today to debate the response to the question I posed to the Minister of Fisheries on March 26, 2026, when I asked if she would reaffirm a principle that is foundation","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fa68248a34cbaada0240725f500cb798eea67bdf3548c4c72cab73f827c3de5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33c54cc20d41381a8521a724","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":426113,"date":"2026-04-16T23:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the parliamentary secretary for that attempted response, but he still has not clearly answered the question that Canadians are extremely concerned with. It is the public access and the priority access to chinook and coho salmon and the ranking that they currently have.\n\nHe said that no one will have their rights to access extinguished. Being extinguished is one thing, but having someone's access reduced or losing that priority ranking is what has so many Canadians concerned. That is not just on the west coast, but it is also inland and through the prairie provinces. It extends to people in other areas who travel and spend their resources in our great province. They are looking for certainty. The minister and the parliamentary secretary have failed to deliver that certainty.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:426113","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the parliamentary secretary for that attempted response, but he still has not clearly answered the question that Canadians are extremely concerned with. It is the public access and the priority access to chinook and coho salmon and the ranking that they currently have.\n\nHe said that no one will have their rights to access extinguished. Being extinguished is one thing, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036716","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Prairie ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47478","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Inland waters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036716","label":"Prairie ecosystems","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47478","label":"Inland waters","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb18a2351f81fd1c6eda0c211cd4295f916d8a2ded1e5a4e16ead52ed4d46298"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a59b4ee1324b1f6ec0190012a4f73070600c4570069984006efea9eb16c12490"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1268a976c3268db92ccf4f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425426,"date":"2026-04-17T16:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after more than a decade of Liberal policies, life is unaffordable. The latest MNP consumer debt index report states that 70% of British Columbians say rising food prices and gas prices are straining their finances. The Liberals voted against reducing taxes that increase the cost of gas by 25¢ a litre. They voted against removing taxes on food that drive up the cost of groceries.\n\n Why will the Liberals not provide Canadians some relief by adopting our Conservative plan to cut taxes on gas and food, and make life more affordable for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425426","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after more than a decade of Liberal policies, life is unaffordable. The latest MNP consumer debt index report states that 70% of British Columbians say rising food prices and gas prices are straining their finances. The Liberals voted against reducing taxes that increase the cost of gas by 25¢ a litre. They voted against removing taxes on food that drive up the cost of groceries.\n\n Wh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5cdda174030b1603bdc26af678ee36fdec48587013fb09d7ceeb2f4512c31a84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1130911c64351d31b2903b15025461ba7d712402c2834506d6015918c15f3ef2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4aebbbb2ef60e6e56679ee63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425427,"date":"2026-04-17T16:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal plan is making life unaffordable. Of respondents to my recent survey to every household across Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, 94% say life has become less affordable over the past year. Rebeca replied that she works full-time at a good job but can barely afford groceries. She does not have any kids, because she cannot afford to.\n\nWhy will the Liberals not provide some relief by adopting our Conservative plan to cut taxes on gas and food, and make life more affordable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425427","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal plan is making life unaffordable. Of respondents to my recent survey to every household across Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, 94% say life has become less affordable over the past year. Rebeca replied that she works full-time at a good job but can barely afford groceries. She does not have any kids, because she cannot afford to.\n\nWhy will the Liberals not provide some r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c3a0c38158144c6d7606f144fbc2cae7162c84bdc3fb750520c28017501ee23"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63868552cbe5f25111354c460790eb71ddcfad41cbfe3ede3e56ff6030ecc988"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9e8718d46c6f2f5b1cdb288","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425428,"date":"2026-04-17T17:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present the first petition from residents of Salmon Arm, British Columbia, a community I am very honoured to represent and live in. The petitioners are calling upon the House of Commons to support Bill C-218, to exclude mental illness or disorder from MAID, and to invest resources into mental health services.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425428","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present the first petition from residents of Salmon Arm, British Columbia, a community I am very honoured to represent and live in. The petitioners are calling upon the House of Commons to support Bill C-218, to exclude mental illness or disorder from MAID, and to invest resources into mental health services.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d065a85c44a98bb63fa68aa26693810b31140d369ddf940d57ba720d5c14bc7c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0dfffac8cc6849e132347c96","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425429,"date":"2026-04-17T17:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I also present four more petitions today on behalf of residents of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. These citizens call on the Government of Canada to reject any amendment to Bill C-9 that removes the religious exemption from Canada's hate speech provisions, to protect Canadians' constitutional rights of freedom of religion and to ensure that legislation does not criminalize good-faith religious discourse or teachings.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425429","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I also present four more petitions today on behalf of residents of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. These citizens call on the Government of Canada to reject any amendment to Bill C-9 that removes the religious exemption from Canada's hate speech provisions, to protect Canadians' constitutional rights of freedom of religion and to ensure that legislation does not criminalize good-fai","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e17742ed2931d1570d81aecdd28af75dffa9667c688def4f779c5a945dce6431"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["85b397c25c4a8dce91de5720f3a797d7431d1cc8e0905011f4a08146d0d879e2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1bd8c02d66c64225d3eb6330","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425430,"date":"2026-04-17T18:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise as the elected representative for the new riding of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies and the associate shadow minister for fisheries for His Majesty's loyal opposition. Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies is a new riding that was created as of the last election, and I believe it is one of the most majestic ridings across this country, if not the most majestic one. It starts at the Great Divide at the Alberta border, where the last stretches of the CP Rail mainline were completed to connect this country from coast to coast back in 1885. I was a proud employee of CP Rail for a short time in the 1980s and got to see some of those important sections of track. \n\nI want to recognize the importance of all the people who still live in the area and are descendants of employees who built that nation-building railway, which linked us from coast to coast to coast. It is an incredible piece of our history. I am so proud and honoured to represent an area that was so important in being able to complete that link. \n\nI rise today to speak to Bill C-22. This is the third iteration of legislation introduced by the government in this 45th Parliament dealing with this issue. I raise this because it is an obvious indication of the failures of this government and former Liberal governments to recognize what is needed to bring law and order to this country. It is also an obvious indication of the inability of the Liberal government to draft legislation that is effective and properly worded in order to pass the scrutiny of this House. That is the purpose of this House: to scrutinize legislation that is being proposed by the government to make sure that it is the best we can do for Canadians. That is an honourable job we are all elected to do, and we on the Conservative side, as members of His Majesty's loyal opposition, will continue to do everything within our power to make sure legislation introduced by the government is truly the best it can be for Canadians. \n\nThe Liberal government first introduced Bill C-2. It has basically been shelved because it was so problematic. Last fall, it introduced Bill C-2, which fell short of protecting Canadians, while overreaching in other areas. Conservatives forced the Liberals to back down on Bill C-2, successfully blocking the Liberals' infringement on individuals' freedom and privacy. We stopped the Liberals from limiting the use of cash, opening mail without oversight and demanding that any service provider, including hospitals, financial institutions and even dry cleaners, disclose user data without judicial oversight. Those are important pieces that have been removed from this bill because we heard from Canadians how important it is that their privacy be respected and, which I would say is the most important piece, that government overreach not be extended to the Liberal government. \n\nNow the Liberals have taken parts out of Bill C-2 and reintroduced them in Bill C-22. Bill C-22 is void of the provisions that Conservatives opposed in parts of Bill C-2. Law enforcement requires the tools they need to combat crime and keep our communities safe, particularly as threats become more sophisticated in the digital age. At the same time, these powers must be accompanied by strong safeguards, clear limits and independent oversight to protect Canadians' rights and freedoms. Conservatives will carefully review this legislation to ensure that the Liberals do not repeat the past failures. We will also ensure that we hear from experts to further evaluate and improve this legislation. There are experts in the field who know best how a bill will be interpreted, how it may be implemented and what unintended consequences may lie ahead if a poorly drafted bill is allowed to pass. We have seen incidents like that in the past.\n\n I want to take a bit of a sidestep right now to talk about some of the crime stats that have been the result of previous poorly legislated bills passed by a former Liberal government. I will talk about highlights and percentages that are increases since 2015, when the Liberal government came to power, through 2023. Total violent crime is up 49.84%. Total homicides are up 27.75%. Gang-related homicides are up 78.35%. All three levels of sexual assaults are up 74.83%, and for sexual assaults, 90% of the victims are women.\n\n This is concerning. The increase in crime is all in the realm of the past 10-plus years of Liberal governments. I am quoting stats from 2015 to 2023. Those increases resulted from bills like Bill C-5 and Bill C-75, from the first Liberal Parliament, when I was first elected to this place.\n\nI will talk about some of the stats in British Columbia. The total number of violent crime violations was 26,062. That is up to 33,926, an increase of 30%. Extortions went from 359 to 1,592, a 343.45% increase in extortion. Just in British Columbia, we have seen how the Liberals' soft-on-crime policies have led to these problems and increasing problems that continue under the Liberal government's realm. Using a firearm or imitation firearm in the commission of an offence was affected by Bill C-5. Bill C-75 rolled back the issues around bail reform.\n\n I want to step back a bit to earlier in the interventions today when my colleague from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola referred to the echo chamber that seems to be in this place today. Even though this bill is a government bill, the government members are not rising to speak to it, not even to ask questions of Conservative members during the questions and comments phases of today's interventions. I raise this because I fear that it is what law enforcement authorities may be perceiving while waiting for legislation so they can do their jobs. Empty echo chambers, from a government that has had over 10 years to address the crime, fraud and corruption, are increasing the impact on Canadians after 10 years of inaction, while criminals are treated more leniently than victims are supported by their own government.\n\n I revert back to how our debate today echoes with what witnesses repeatedly tell us at committees. The citizens of this country often provide input and good direction for the government, but the government continues to be an echo chamber.\n\nIt is high time the government took what it is being told by Canadians and addressed the crime, fraud and corruption that have become a plague in our communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425430","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise as the elected representative for the new riding of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies and the associate shadow minister for fisheries for His Majesty's loyal opposition. Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies is a new riding that was created as of the last election, and I believe it is one of the most majestic ridings across this country, if not the most majest","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","label":"Railway networks","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1f297f2967c304050b4d5133cb51bcc3723bcf82062629730fcdacb470fb1c1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad255f78d265ddf589b6d1bb6c731671e8701089239b3c31f95e84ecf50e0206"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-48329f246adccbf5b2293849","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425431,"date":"2026-04-17T18:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we will be looking at this legislation very closely, scrutinizing it closely, like we do with every piece of legislation that comes before the House, to make sure that appropriate amendments are proposed, and hopefully passed, at committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425431","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we will be looking at this legislation very closely, scrutinizing it closely, like we do with every piece of legislation that comes before the House, to make sure that appropriate amendments are proposed, and hopefully passed, at committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecc368aa3969a6af6a1a1c2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425432,"date":"2026-04-17T18:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for Oshawa for that really interesting question about the echo chamber. I will mimic my colleague from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola when he spoke of the echo, echo, echo chamber in here.\n\n I think it is telling that today there are no questions and no interventions coming from the Liberal side. We can only surmise why that might be, but understanding how the Liberal government operates, there are some members in this chamber at times who are the only ones to speak during the intervention process or present speeches from the government side. Its backbench members are basically muzzled. It sounds like the entire government side is muzzled today on these interventions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425432","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for Oshawa for that really interesting question about the echo chamber. I will mimic my colleague from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola when he spoke of the echo, echo, echo chamber in here.\n\n I think it is telling that today there are no questions and no interventions coming from the Liberal side. We can only surmise why that might be, but understanding how the Liberal gov","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec34cf14aa164b282c7afd6c38310c55620012aa1dd62b8926dd017756d5dab9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8805bd53f5bc1142b43bca58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":425433,"date":"2026-04-17T18:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member from the Liberal side for finally being one to stand up. I think he has been the only one in the last while here to present questions.\n\n I am not going to take the liberty to talk about what amendments might be put forward at committee. We will carefully scrutinize the bill. We will listen to the witnesses who are called to committee to testify on the bill, to the stakeholders and to law enforcement, who can hopefully guide all members of the House and the members of the committee on the best way to improve this bill if it needs to be improved.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:425433","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member from the Liberal side for finally being one to stand up. I think he has been the only one in the last while here to present questions.\n\n I am not going to take the liberty to talk about what amendments might be put forward at committee. We will carefully scrutinize the bill. We will listen to the witnesses who are called to committee to testify on the bill, to the s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba1861b7a39d1b1d98822cdf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":426111,"date":"2026-04-17T18:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, those amendments would be developed during the scrutiny of the bill. \n\nWe can see where the language in the bill needs to be clarified, whether with respect to the definitions or how the bill is going to be interpreted. I spoke about that in my intervention. \n\nWe could hear from enforcement authorities and from individuals who have been affected by not having this legislation in place so that we can improve the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:426111","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, those amendments would be developed during the scrutiny of the bill. \n\nWe can see where the language in the bill needs to be clarified, whether with respect to the definitions or how the bill is going to be interpreted. I spoke about that in my intervention. \n\nWe could hear from enforcement authorities and from individuals who have been affected by not having this legislation in place","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9280b52a6d969fcafbea519b037a02f86aaa2ec8b4cb65baff428da47023e5a6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-183e155ac118352d78424700","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300689,"date":"2026-04-24T16:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to pay homage to World War II veteran Alvie Burden. Alvie was a resident of Armstrong, British Columbia, and was not only Armstrong's oldest veteran but also Canada's oldest Black veteran of the Second World War.\n\nBorn in Tisdale, Saskatchewan, in 1922, Alvie Burden joined the Canadian Forces at the age of 19 and was posted to the Saskatoon Light Infantry regiment. Alvie served more than 21 months in the Italian and Dutch campaigns and was the only Black member of his company. In Italy, Alvie Burden was nearly killed in action by shrapnel wounds to his head and wrists. Thankfully, Alvie made his recovery, lived on and helped younger generations understand the realities of war, until he passed on March 26 at the age of 104 years old.\n\nAlvie Burden's service reminds us today of the sacrifices that members of the Canadian Armed Forces have made and continue to make on our behalf. Lest we forget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300689","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to pay homage to World War II veteran Alvie Burden. Alvie was a resident of Armstrong, British Columbia, and was not only Armstrong's oldest veteran but also Canada's oldest Black veteran of the Second World War.\n\nBorn in Tisdale, Saskatchewan, in 1922, Alvie Burden joined the Canadian Forces at the age of 19 and was posted to the Saskatoon Light Infantry regiment. Alvie served","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Allied forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","label":"Allied forces","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72e3431a3d7eb41ff24e6aa6f76f2583ffa7c4af7d2c8a788bf147a91b3ab500"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42f9d830a147e15224827cbad07d4f9f1df34536414018bc57809003d18bf282"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4eecc1d672357747ae330724","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300690,"date":"2026-04-24T16:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, is the Prime Minister waving the white flag on U.S. tariffs?\n\nHe sits by and does nothing while U.S. tariffs on steel have doubled, and they have tripled on lumber. He has failed in negotiating the reduction of a single tariff. Sawmills and the B.C. towns that they support are reeling from his failure to negotiate a deal. Speeches, illusions, excuses and failures are not going to cut it for the millions of families' livelihoods that are at stake.\n\n When will the Prime Minister start delivering results instead of excuses?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300690","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, is the Prime Minister waving the white flag on U.S. tariffs?\n\nHe sits by and does nothing while U.S. tariffs on steel have doubled, and they have tripled on lumber. He has failed in negotiating the reduction of a single tariff. Sawmills and the B.C. towns that they support are reeling from his failure to negotiate a deal. Speeches, illusions, excuses and failures are not going to cut ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea91c93ea0ea30e178de05d86e483fa9d57898405e675618a15d79e247e4c080"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3476eb2867d2a691e28b66e9c0914670dd40fe5308774a927a0e7b53e04ba60"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18f5f3c00b466b8bee95ee80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300691,"date":"2026-04-24T16:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister's illusions tactic and excuses are no help to Canadians. Instead of getting a trade deal last July, as he promised, he squandered his leverage with concessions made 10 months ago. He does not even show up to do his job, while Mexico makes progress ahead of him. \n\nWhy did the Liberal Prime Minister make the strategic error of dragging this out instead of using the leverage we had at the beginning of the talks to get tariffs removed on Canadian goods?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300691","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister's illusions tactic and excuses are no help to Canadians. Instead of getting a trade deal last July, as he promised, he squandered his leverage with concessions made 10 months ago. He does not even show up to do his job, while Mexico makes progress ahead of him. \n\nWhy did the Liberal Prime Minister make the strategic error of dragging this out instead of using the le","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c41a2ec8c02b918edd70d9fc5b17ed41dccdda1258ed23c9ce37fd3058ad2a33"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["815f072095aea86bac101487430dfe27c3ee684ca882d044daec01d97dfdbaa2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0ee47fd4e9678d5e34f9a40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300692,"date":"2026-04-24T17:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to present another petition from residents of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. I believe this is my sixth petition on this issue.\n\n The petition calls on the Government of Canada to reject any amendment to Bill C-9 that removes the religious exemption from Canada's hate speech provisions, to protect Canada's constitutional rights of freedom of religion and freedom of expression and to ensure that legislation does not criminalize good-faith religious discourse and teaching.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-110/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300692","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to present another petition from residents of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. I believe this is my sixth petition on this issue.\n\n The petition calls on the Government of Canada to reject any amendment to Bill C-9 that removes the religious exemption from Canada's hate speech provisions, to protect Canada's constitutional rights of freedom of religion a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b21ce55706f78898ede7d85684328bddf55154f036afb02a078778fa437ce1c8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7622f2d8b6d2b01125225805","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725186,"date":"2026-04-27T18:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member mentioned the adjustment of numbers of members on committees. I would like to ask her to explain fully, not just to the members on this side of the House but to Canadians, why the government chose to move to a 60% makeup on committees instead of the 51% that it has in the House. Is this to shut down the opposition completely at committee, or is there some other diabolical scheme behind all of this?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-111/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725186","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member mentioned the adjustment of numbers of members on committees. I would like to ask her to explain fully, not just to the members on this side of the House but to Canadians, why the government chose to move to a 60% makeup on committees instead of the 51% that it has in the House. Is this to shut down the opposition completely at committee, or is there some other diabolical s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-58180d9af4ed7151f6fc84b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109858,"date":"2026-04-29T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to thank the witnesses for being here. I want to start off with this question, though I'm not sure who might be able to answer it. From the time that Environment and Climate Change Canada identifies a possible or potential source of contamination, how long would it take for a sample to be collected and taken to the lab and for it to be determined whether an area is safe or it has to go through CFIA's testing of clams or mollusks? It sounds like DFO makes a decision based on that. How much time would elapse?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109858","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to thank the witnesses for being here. I want to start off with this question, though I'm not sure who might be able to answer it. From the time that Environment and Climate Change Canada identifies a possible or potential source of contamination, how long would it take for a sample to be collected and taken to the lab and for it to be determined whether an area is saf","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c55a6e05a80e7882c92b4b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109859,"date":"2026-04-29T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"From that data, are you able to recommend that DFO close the area? Who makes that decision?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109859","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"From that data, are you able to recommend that DFO close the area? Who makes that decision?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036526","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Offshore area","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036526","label":"Offshore area","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a894a6008355f602a6d4b30fc3aa767817429c07c0094e5200270db64d5c954"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f6af62a9ea455a76f32e236","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109860,"date":"2026-04-29T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"If an area had been closed, how long would it take for the sampling to go through that process and for a recommendation to be made that DFO open the area?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109860","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If an area had been closed, how long would it take for the sampling to go through that process and for a recommendation to be made that DFO open the area?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","label":"Surveys","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f80f3d0ae749494f3043f0022287336818a4e109788bd6aebeaf1d85f6cb9cb5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea91e06a557cc2bacdbfccf3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109861,"date":"2026-04-29T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"It literally takes less than three days to shut down an area but up to three years to reopen an area, even if the testing is clear. Is that correct? That doesn't seem proportionate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109861","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It literally takes less than three days to shut down an area but up to three years to reopen an area, even if the testing is clear. Is that correct? That doesn't seem proportionate.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:137532","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Deforestation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Moratorium","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:137532","label":"Deforestation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64065","label":"Moratorium","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df0aa4a51f55343da8da3190024176297ec89c3eae45dd6623b0ad920b7375c6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-383032687a484dd8cc7cf627","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109862,"date":"2026-04-29T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"It sounded like you said you could identify a potential area and test it within 36 hours, or less than three days—72 hours—to be able to close a site. What I'm getting at is the complexity that seems to be involved here. There are three different government departments and agencies involved that all have to work together. They can shut down an area within hours or days, but it takes them three years potentially to open up an area. Can somebody square that circle? You just said it could take up to three years of testing, but if an area tests clear for six months or a year, why would it take another two years before that area could be opened?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109862","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It sounded like you said you could identify a potential area and test it within 36 hours, or less than three days—72 hours—to be able to close a site. What I'm getting at is the complexity that seems to be involved here. There are three different government departments and agencies involved that all have to work together. They can shut down an area within hours or days, but it takes them three yea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083643","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Time zones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083643","label":"Time zones","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fba6045e29546d6084b46f66213e919ac5155edc099c6722f969610c9fda4c6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-766b9408d12de4d26accc25f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109863,"date":"2026-04-29T21:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109863","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa888d875c0f053da8682091","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109864,"date":"2026-04-29T22:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to bring to light here that in 2012, the Conservative government introduced waste-water treatment standards for municipalities, and those standards were to take effect in 2020 to require at least minimal treatment for waste water from municipalities. Then, in 2020, the then minister of environment and climate change, Jonathan Wilkinson, introduced amendments to the waste-water treatment effluent regulations that allowed the extension of deadlines for municipalities to upgrade their sewage treatment standards. Some of those extensions reach out to 2040, 20 years later than originally planned. Would improved waste-water treatment standards reduce the risk of contamination and the risk to human illness and death, if those standards had been implemented?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109864","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to bring to light here that in 2012, the Conservative government introduced waste-water treatment standards for municipalities, and those standards were to take effect in 2020 to require at least minimal treatment for waste water from municipalities. Then, in 2020, the then minister of environment and climate change, Jonathan Wilkinson, introduced amendments to the was","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea38d1016764a4ab30142e5a03411379bafccacdf540a3e147ce9913319a7ac5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9b5a504c3211cc9bb111691cfa2cacd7aa486def118b65ec66b7c60549a20210"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-148d462d35a4178733ff2251","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109865,"date":"2026-04-29T22:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay. If you can't answer the question, I'll ask Ms. Soo. Would you have to sample fewer sites, or would you be identifying fewer potential contaminant sites, had those waste-water treatment standards been applied?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109865","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Okay. If you can't answer the question, I'll ask Ms. Soo. Would you have to sample fewer sites, or would you be identifying fewer potential contaminant sites, had those waste-water treatment standards been applied?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71c4e577a5879dd70d3c68c870dc40261a4b7a83f887b706aed0cb379d87ee0e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a63da1b505cc5b3d45f50feb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109866,"date":"2026-04-29T22:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Who's monitoring waste water, Mr. Shahsavarani?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109866","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Who's monitoring waste water, Mr. Shahsavarani?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2df0203051433cad84f4d50","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109867,"date":"2026-04-29T22:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Would it have reduced the number of potential contamination sites that you identify?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109867","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Would it have reduced the number of potential contamination sites that you identify?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:255569","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Contaminated sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","label":"Pollution prevention","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:255569","label":"Contaminated sites","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["270ac1435d9cd3b65377fc8f4b80d56b7884f24a5adc71645e2f80c5215f76c7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52120a9ba49f88a8b3374a83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109868,"date":"2026-04-29T22:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"You started out with a statement at the beginning of the meeting. You said that you identified potential sites of contamination. If those waste-water treatment sites had their standards applied, would those have been applied, and would it have reduced the potential sites that you have to identify?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109868","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You started out with a statement at the beginning of the meeting. You said that you identified potential sites of contamination. If those waste-water treatment sites had their standards applied, would those have been applied, and would it have reduced the potential sites that you have to identify?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:255569","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Contaminated sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:255569","label":"Contaminated sites","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3d7a1dcde06250d7a1036db1d7aa3acc60e4d0fd0ecc242d652bf35246d93b2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-646a8e8c213555097f0c3509","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109869,"date":"2026-04-29T22:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I will turn the rest of my time over to Mr. Gunn.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109869","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I will turn the rest of my time over to Mr. Gunn.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ebb4dce4b6dd02f8085630a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109870,"date":"2026-04-29T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"No, not on this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109870","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, not on this.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cfcc75cc5ded1dc3f72e6d8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109871,"date":"2026-04-29T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you Mr. Chair. I'd also like to make a further amendment to the motion. I'd have to look closer to see where it should fit in. I move: That the motion be amended by adding, at the end of paragraph (c), the following \", and that the Department of Fisheries and Oceans be invited at the beginning of the study, to update the committee on actions taken in response to the report of the committee on wild Atlantic salmon in eastern Canada tabled in January 2017, as well as the reports of the committee on striped bass in the Southern Gulf of St. Lawrence and Miramichi River tabled in May 2019, November 2020, and February 2022.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109871","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you Mr. Chair. I'd also like to make a further amendment to the motion. I'd have to look closer to see where it should fit in. I move: That the motion be amended by adding, at the end of paragraph (c), the following \", and that the Department of Fisheries and Oceans be invited at the beginning of the study, to update the committee on actions taken in response to the report of the committee o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5fa0def6c8f8a92acb3f8936","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109872,"date":"2026-04-29T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"It's in there already, but I would like specifically for them to report on actions taken in response to the recommendations in those two reports. The second report on striped bass is report number one from the committee in the 43rd Parliament.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109872","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's in there already, but I would like specifically for them to report on actions taken in response to the recommendations in those two reports. The second report on striped bass is report number one from the committee in the 43rd Parliament.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["032353d138abcf3b7ed2197d2a9a0b97f6051b3bf700f5ee157fb4b1641aadf6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7cc93a88180ad82680707496","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109873,"date":"2026-04-29T22:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"These are reports that were done by the FOPO committee. The Atlantic salmon study was \"Wild Atlantic Salmon in Eastern Canada\". That was tabled in January 2017.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109873","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"These are reports that were done by the FOPO committee. The Atlantic salmon study was \"Wild Atlantic Salmon in Eastern Canada\". That was tabled in January 2017.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ab737c31f244d806d82501768ecfdc74953ca4aaded3968b65d4aac7e63fc1f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcfa6b7b338ec08f321b8e6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109874,"date":"2026-04-29T22:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I want the department officials to—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109874","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want the department officials to—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a3b715accafef2a31006874","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109875,"date":"2026-04-29T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. This motion is going to become public, and I think the public deserves to know that this committee studied the issue of Atlantic salmon previously and studied the striped bass issue previously. I think that they need to know that off the top. I would still support having those two studies in particular listed in the motion. Department officials from Fisheries and Oceans will appear to respond to questions on what actions have been taken on those two reports. The second report was tabled in the House on February 28, 2022, so there's no question as to which reports we're speaking about.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109875","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. This motion is going to become public, and I think the public deserves to know that this committee studied the issue of Atlantic salmon previously and studied the striped bass issue previously. I think that they need to know that off the top. I would still support having those two studies in particular listed in the motion. Department officials from Fisheries and Oceans will ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-524e57a7cbbf954ecd2587ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109876,"date":"2026-04-29T22:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I stand corrected. It appears the striped bass report was actually tabled three times. Because of parliamentary prorogation etc., the final time it was tabled appears to have been in the 44th Parliament, on January 22. The government's response appears to have been on June 22, 2022. These studies, which we've already done, need to be fully disclosed to everyone who is going to be considered in this study. Whether that's the public watching this committee.... I've seen the number of people following this committee grow exponentially over the last number of years because they know the good, congenial work this committee does. Time after time, we put partisanship aside so we can do the right thing for the harvesters and the fish stocks. We have done that repeatedly over the years. There's been good work across the aisles, on both sides. I'd hate to see that sidelined, at this point, because Canadians deserve the best that we can do. Those two reports—the one on Atlantic salmon and the second one on striped bass—are very relevant to this proposed study. The public and anyone interested in this committee need to be fully aware that those two studies and reports took place. If they aren't aware of that, it would be shameful, and shame on us for not bringing that to light. Yes, it can come up in questioning, in one meeting with government officials, but by the time the word gets out that there were previous reports, it may be too late for people to send us questions we should be asking those officials. This would be very relevant to why now—after four years on the one study and eight years on the Atlantic salmon study—we are still in the predicament of studying the plight of Atlantic salmon. If there are recommendations in those two reports that could have made a difference, why would we not want to have them come to light as soon as possible in this study? To hide this, I think, would be absolutely shameful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-35/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109876","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I stand corrected. It appears the striped bass report was actually tabled three times. Because of parliamentary prorogation etc., the final time it was tabled appears to have been in the 44th Parliament, on January 22. The government's response appears to have been on June 22, 2022. These studies, which we've already done, need to be fully disclosed to everyone who is going to be considered in thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["19e3edfaca1e70e4bf583751ff267695deec13f85b29af1fcae5a6763a8f1447"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df8caa018cde443685c71602fd1a27870619e5c35dc50781806793610338b4eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-069fee37102c6cc93cd2f10a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109877,"date":"2026-05-04T16:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I'd like to move that Mr. Morrissey, having sat on this committee for over 10 years, be elected chair of the committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109877","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to move that Mr. Morrissey, having sat on this committee for over 10 years, be elected chair of the committee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad07b7b84fcd1dbf1b66fd6ce6de0f4e080ccbb8888f98e628ec37286fffc4db"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6db72e1dfeb801c847e1d2f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109878,"date":"2026-05-04T16:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Welcome, Madam Chair. Congratulations on being elected as chair. I'd like to take just a couple of short moments to thank Mr. Weiler for his fair and judicious chairing of this committee for the past months. As a vice-chair, it was good to work with you. I look forward to the same openness and collegiality that we've experienced on this committee over the 10-plus years that I and Mr. Morrissey have been on this committee. I think we've done a lot of good work across party lines in efforts to improve the fisheries. When I say \"fisheries\", that means fish stocks and the fisheries, the people who participate in harvesting those stocks. I think we can continue to do that work. Regarding your vision and statement that you would like to see the congeniality that takes place in this committee continue, I very much hope for the same thing. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109878","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Welcome, Madam Chair. Congratulations on being elected as chair. I'd like to take just a couple of short moments to thank Mr. Weiler for his fair and judicious chairing of this committee for the past months. As a vice-chair, it was good to work with you. I look forward to the same openness and collegiality that we've experienced on this committee over the 10-plus years that I and Mr. Morrissey hav","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0524ad7363b9f79decc35402081f9f3a4232bcb373f8cb4472c8b4f30461ab07"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6fc7400ee421e1ce5d497ed5b36d159363993e16fb98c97cb43b13beb17a5b97"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-191e37e3aae2d3174f85e41e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109879,"date":"2026-05-04T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll start my questioning with Mr. Davis, who is online. Last year, Mr. Davis, in 2025, the Fraser River sockeye salmon season was extremely challenging for harvesters in all sectors, with abundance coming back multiple times higher than what was initially predicted. The department seemed to be either reluctant or restrained in opening up access to commercial and public fisheries during that time. What organizations actually have input and influence into the decisions and direction of the Pacific Salmon Commission in directing this binational stock?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109879","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll start my questioning with Mr. Davis, who is online. Last year, Mr. Davis, in 2025, the Fraser River sockeye salmon season was extremely challenging for harvesters in all sectors, with abundance coming back multiple times higher than what was initially predicted. The department seemed to be either reluctant or restrained in opening up access to commercial and public fis","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["840bccb21af30b2c7b845eb0e889b31dfeb17307bab0dbc20f444bdea64c3ab0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a035e8fd51a5c8c928353e062936060de74453393165b0ac544fbfec915073b9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-91c72ef0d4ffd15a4eb06072","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109880,"date":"2026-05-04T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Do any of these organizations feeding up through this chain of recommendations have binding authority on what the final decision will be?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109880","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do any of these organizations feeding up through this chain of recommendations have binding authority on what the final decision will be?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28560acf47f0703023e38e9394fa86bfa9d20337c061b311be19eb9c6b1a888d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18a5f574c520836ae9b682f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109881,"date":"2026-05-04T16:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"No one has the power to veto, if the science is there, that there should continue to be expanded fisheries. Would that be correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109881","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"No one has the power to veto, if the science is there, that there should continue to be expanded fisheries. Would that be correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f25c0e77f6f6cb97935dbd5c1255da2211eb84d327cdc200ed728028faa9b47"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3f99fb3697b04c7041b42ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109882,"date":"2026-05-04T16:30:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Last year, when there was this incredible abundance that came back.... I believe it was the highest on record for that brood stock cycle. We understand that there are different brood stock cycle years, but this was incredibly high for that brood stock cycle year. It was a record number, yet when the U.S. panel members on the Pacific Salmon Commission were recommending an opening, the Canadians were opposed and did not provide any rationale for opposing it. Why was it that the Canadian side didn't provide any rationale for not supporting the opening of the fishery?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109882","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Last year, when there was this incredible abundance that came back.... I believe it was the highest on record for that brood stock cycle. We understand that there are different brood stock cycle years, but this was incredibly high for that brood stock cycle year. It was a record number, yet when the U.S. panel members on the Pacific Salmon Commission were recommending an opening, the Canadians wer","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037228","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Stock markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035593","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hatcheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035593","label":"Hatcheries","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037228","label":"Stock markets","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b75787019b9abeaacc8e239d811e2dbcd7f3d039eaff081d50c3e45a05ea7a4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22a59d0de5abaf55fd128412","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109883,"date":"2026-05-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll start again with Mr. Davis, if I could. The issue around the Fraser sockeye opening, or late opening, last year came up directly to me again. As Mr. Gunn had mentioned earlier, there were calls from commercial fishers and recreational fishers. I had a call from a former DFO management individual concerned with the fishery further up the Fraser River, one that he said actually should have been opened two weeks earlier than it was because there was confusion over which stocks were being impacted. They kept the Fraser closed above the confluence at Lytton. They weren't allowing a fishery further upstream at Lillooet because of a run stock that doesn't even go past Lillooet. Can you explain why that fishery was so delayed? Do you perhaps have numbers on the millions in economic opportunity that was probably lost?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109883","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll start again with Mr. Davis, if I could. The issue around the Fraser sockeye opening, or late opening, last year came up directly to me again. As Mr. Gunn had mentioned earlier, there were calls from commercial fishers and recreational fishers. I had a call from a former DFO management individual concerned with the fishery further up the Fraser River, one that he said a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c88070bd7a08b8358c9b108d4c869ded206214c9fb7f4328289a2cc1ca087818"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["738c9f6be1840802802b2aa0e2ba9b585956650a78e0a3812ef772a3fe3a9d69"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3349092566cf09c455b66989","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109884,"date":"2026-05-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I'm going to interrupt you there because we understand the impacts of comigrating stocks, but past the point of Lytton, there were no comigrating stocks in those same waters that could have been opened two weeks earlier. Can you describe why they weren't?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109884","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm going to interrupt you there because we understand the impacts of comigrating stocks, but past the point of Lytton, there were no comigrating stocks in those same waters that could have been opened two weeks earlier. Can you describe why they weren't?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037228","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Stock markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037228","label":"Stock markets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0df476ac7ee7c576ed7bcfd356b486c7342e292fa9b95c735b5d7d49c15c7c60"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e75f6fae5f08beee648e8422","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109885,"date":"2026-05-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Somebody's not passing the communications up the chain to you, then, because this was highly communicated to me as a member and vice-chair of this committee. It was communicated to DFO staff regularly and repetitively, yet your department delayed and delayed. Basically, there were two weeks lost from the public fishery at Lillooet because of some confusion over which stocks might be there. I want to go back to some of Mr. Gunn's questioning. Are there any governing bodies that have veto power over the decision-making of the minister or the department?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109885","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Somebody's not passing the communications up the chain to you, then, because this was highly communicated to me as a member and vice-chair of this committee. It was communicated to DFO staff regularly and repetitively, yet your department delayed and delayed. Basically, there were two weeks lost from the public fishery at Lillooet because of some confusion over which stocks might be there. I want ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-185d4013985df9357a69c636","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109886,"date":"2026-05-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay. I want to go to a quote from Mr. Griswold, who had been on the Pacific Salmon Commission for 40 years. He said, \"I could no longer be party to and complicit in the panel process whose decision-making power, I felt, was countermanded by the veto power newly granted to the unrepresentative Fraser River Salmon Management Board.\" He left that panel after 40 years because he could not support what was happening there. This was broadly communicated. Can you explain to the public listening to this committee what happened and why he was so disgusted that he left?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109886","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Okay. I want to go to a quote from Mr. Griswold, who had been on the Pacific Salmon Commission for 40 years. He said, \"I could no longer be party to and complicit in the panel process whose decision-making power, I felt, was countermanded by the veto power newly granted to the unrepresentative Fraser River Salmon Management Board.\" He left that panel after 40 years because he could not support wha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9647d540f337607cb4df2723e9dd0a64cc7b9840bf42372249f9e5e587dd1765"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ba4ab3ee19f24a1ca1adff3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109887,"date":"2026-05-04T17:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Why did one side of those discussions seem to outweigh all of the input from all of the other sides, including the science from your own department?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109887","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Why did one side of those discussions seem to outweigh all of the input from all of the other sides, including the science from your own department?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7103d89db6fb7294fda74071","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109888,"date":"2026-05-04T17:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Madam Chair, we quite often provided unanimous consent to go another 15 minutes, and that still gives us very good time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-36/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109888","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Chair, we quite often provided unanimous consent to go another 15 minutes, and that still gives us very good time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-702860208ebb326c743ef981","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791128,"date":"2026-05-06T20:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition to the Minister of the Environment, Climate Change and Nature. \n\nThe long-tailed macaque is the most heavily traded primate for experimental use and was uplisted to \"endangered\" by the IUCN in 2022. Despite the species' endangered status, Canada has allowed the import of over 10,000 macaques from Cambodia between 2023 and 2025. Environment and Climate Change Canada stated in a response to e-petition 6537 that it has seen no evidence of falsified permits. \n\nTherefore, 5,274 signatures have been obtained from citizens and residents of Canada calling upon the Minister of the Environment, Climate Change and Nature to launch an investigation into the legality, traceability and authenticity of the CITES permits used for the importation of Cambodian long-tailed macaques into Canada under the Wild Animal and Plant Protection and Regulation of International and Interprovincial Trade Act.\n\nThe petitioners also request that long-tailed macaques be added to schedule II of the WAPTR to enable the ministry to require and assess its own import permits.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035722","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Primates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-118/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791128","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present a petition to the Minister of the Environment, Climate Change and Nature. \n\nThe long-tailed macaque is the most heavily traded primate for experimental use and was uplisted to \"endangered\" by the IUCN in 2022. Despite the species' endangered status, Canada has allowed the import of over 10,000 macaques from Cambodia between 2023 and 2025. Environment and Climat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035722","label":"Primates"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035722","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Primates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035722","label":"Primates","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3daf2a294e2080221e774ac1891b47338cdab03dcffd83c6a89d38319356a4b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035722","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Primates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c008a2c52a9fbd5c62bbab59f0a84ccf28ecd00f65b0e78642394976928dbc9c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035722","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Primates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035722","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Primates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035722","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f27ca2f7a6e0e45b69b2bf1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109889,"date":"2026-05-06T23:05:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Madam Chair, I'm also surprised that the Liberals seem opposed to some very constructive amendments, one of which simply replaces \"hunters\" with \"harvesters\"—a much more socially acceptable term. Also, in response to their objection to hearing testimony on what's been accomplished, or which recommendations the government has followed through on, from a study we completed barely two years ago on issues that remain relevant, has anything happened or not? Here we have government members who do not seem to even want to discuss what may or may not have been done by their department in the time since that study and report were done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109889","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Chair, I'm also surprised that the Liberals seem opposed to some very constructive amendments, one of which simply replaces \"hunters\" with \"harvesters\"—a much more socially acceptable term. Also, in response to their objection to hearing testimony on what's been accomplished, or which recommendations the government has followed through on, from a study we completed barely two years ago on is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15b225dfc930232aadf863c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109890,"date":"2026-05-06T23:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Getting back to protocol and the actual rules of order for conducting a meeting, Mr. Small suggested an amendment, and we have not voted on that amendment. I think, to be clear, Mr. Cormier is suggesting a subamendment to remove paragraph (e). Rather than trying to lump all of this together, I think it would be far more clear if you, Madam Chair, were to go through the subamendment and have a vote on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-37/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-37/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109890","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Getting back to protocol and the actual rules of order for conducting a meeting, Mr. Small suggested an amendment, and we have not voted on that amendment. I think, to be clear, Mr. Cormier is suggesting a subamendment to remove paragraph (e). Rather than trying to lump all of this together, I think it would be far more clear if you, Madam Chair, were to go through the suba","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f3e2483ac9f155c95dde4b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791122,"date":"2026-05-07T16:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the member for Cowichan—Malahat—Langford.\n\nIt is always an honour to rise as the elected representative of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. As I have previously stated in this place, all of us have a solemn responsibility to provide representation and voice to the citizens who depend on us to do their bidding here in Parliament. Canadians need us to be vigilant for challenges and dangers that emerge and take actions to prevent, mitigate and overcome the challenges and dangers, including unintended consequences caused by the actions or inaction of levels of government. In these times of global uncertainty, Canadians need our vigilance and action perhaps more than at any other time. \n\nToday, I rise to speak to today's Conservative opposition day motion. This motion opens with how the Cowichan Tribes v. Canada decision has created massive uncertainty around fee simple property, not just in Richmond, B.C., where the land relevant to the case is located, but across my home province of British Columbia and other parts of Canada. All this is because the legal basis on which Canadians and businesses alike own their homes and land, the basis on which economies are built, the basis that has provided the general stability for growth, investment, surety and prosperity, has been undermined. The certainty of fee simple property has been undermined, and with it the stability and security of every property owner in B.C. and beyond. \n\nI believe all of us in this House are proud to call Canada home, while we also recognize historical imperfections, chapters of our shared history in which forebears, including the federal government, failed. It is important to recognize and learn from historical failures. It helps strengthen our nation. So does recognizing our historical successes, reflected by the fact that our ancestors and predecessors built a country that others around the globe have admired because they have seen the opportunities that flowed from our stability and certainty. \n\nHowever, the sharp decline in certainty in the wake of the Cowichan decision has caused instability, directly harming opportunities for Canadians, while also putting a chill on those who would otherwise invest in Canada. If others look at Canada and see internal turmoil and conflict rather than stability, they will go elsewhere to pursue opportunities. Instability and insecurity reflect on Parliament, and all parliamentarians should reflect on how we can increase stability and security for citizens, both today and far into the future. \n\nThe Cowichan decision is already having a significant impact on the outlook of citizens. Home values and project financing, not just in the immediate area around Richmond but across B.C., have been impacted. When I meet with people at events and on the streets across the riding of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, people come up to me and ask if their future and title to their property, which they have worked a lifetime to pay for, are at risk. \n\nThe instability caused by the Cowichan decision was compounded when the Liberals negotiated the Musqueam Rights Recognition Agreement in secret, without ensuring that it contains protections for property rights and without ensuring proper transparency or consultation with other potentially affected first nations. The Musqueam agreement covers up to 533,000 hectares, including metro Vancouver and the Richmond lands that are at the centre of the Cowichan ruling. Canadians are asking questions, questions that the Liberal government will not answer.\n\nWhen the Prime Minister stated, \"All federal agreements with first nations, with indigenous peoples and with rights holders protect private property rights and protect indigenous peoples' rights\", did he know that this is not the case? \n\nThe Musqueam Rights Recognition Agreement contains the word \"private\" only once and not in reference to private property. The Musqueam Stewardship and Marine Management Agreement does not contain the word \"private\" or \"property\". The Musqueam Fisheries Agreement does not mention the word \"private\" or \"property\". The agreement that provides the Musqueam with revenues from the Vancouver airport does not contain the word \"private\" or \"property\".\n\nNone of these agreements signed by the Liberal government protect private property rights, as the Prime Minister tried to claim they do, so either the Prime Minister has no idea what is in these agreements or he has been misleading Canadians. If we are to have true reconciliation in Canada, I believe we must also have truth. When we have a Prime Minister who either does not know or does not care what agreements his government is signing, or is willing to mislead Canadians on what is in those secretly negotiated agreements, it is no wonder that Canadians have questions for us, as they have elected us to be their representatives and voice.\n\nCanadians already face enough pressure from high costs and economic uncertainty without having to wonder whether their homes are truly theirs. The Liberal government must provide certainty and stability by openly reaffirming private property in court, and it must make it clear in writing that Canadians' homes and land titles will be protected. Thus far, they have failed to do this.\n\nAs Conservatives, we have urged the federal government to reinstate the arguments before the Court of Appeal that fee simple landownership supersedes all other titles, and we call on the government to take the following steps to protect property rights.\n\nStep one would be to put private property first in the Cowichan case by arguing that this has priority over all other titles and reversing the current position directing federal lawyers not to argue for property rights and the withdrawal of the extinguishment argument from the earlier 2018 decision.\n\nStep two would be to make no agreement without explicit property protection, so that existing fee simple owners are protected in all future agreements with first nations, reversing the government's failure to explicitly protect people's homes in the agreements the Liberal government has signed, which fail to explicitly protect fee simple property ownership, causing confusion, fear and risk, instability and uncertainty.\n\nAt a time in global history when we are all seeing so much instability and uncertainty, this is a time when Canada could be a shining example in which all Canadians, regardless of ancestry, could have the sense of certainty and stability that others used to see in us.\n\nWe cannot restore certainty and stability through secretly negotiated agreements. I have always believed that bringing everyone to the same table allows us to fully understand each other's perspective. Failing to do so only brings speculation, skepticism and distrust. If we are to build trust and respect, we need the government to respect all Canadians and restore confidence for homeowners across British Columbia and Canada, by convening a parliamentary committee to study all legal, constitutional and political steps that can protect private property rights in Canada, in light of the Cowichan decision and the Musqueam agreement.\n\nIn this way, the government can begin restoring trust, the trust that is required to move forward with the transparency, balance, stability and certainty that Canada once had.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791122","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with the member for Cowichan—Malahat—Langford.\n\nIt is always an honour to rise as the elected representative of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. As I have previously stated in this place, all of us have a solemn responsibility to provide representation and voice to the citizens who depend on us to do their bidding here in Parliament. Canadians need us to b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["78f9e029a3946a817c6ea70c60f155ca815701f76bbe72029b23eb7267807b6c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a9d350bc7dfde7fa31f21a72c0b124bfea5744790821f4099c493f5705ff442"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e6ba9c23c08d74f5403f07e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791123,"date":"2026-05-07T16:50:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to again quote what the Prime Minister stated earlier this week in the House: \"All federal agreements with first nations, with indigenous peoples and with rights holders protect private property rights and protect indigenous peoples' rights.\"\n\nI checked those agreements this morning. As I stated, the Musqueam agreement does not mention the term \"private property\". None of those agreements mention private property.\n\nWas the Prime Minister misleading the House, or was he ill-informed?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791123","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to again quote what the Prime Minister stated earlier this week in the House: \"All federal agreements with first nations, with indigenous peoples and with rights holders protect private property rights and protect indigenous peoples' rights.\"\n\nI checked those agreements this morning. As I stated, the Musqueam agreement does not mention the term \"private property\". None of those","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["edab27e9f3e99ac29fb51365ae41f15913d2215708a30ff66b2772bf2e787a91"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c2310ea37b5d5f68f88cd93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791124,"date":"2026-05-07T16:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the question from the Bloc member about whether this could be studied at the indigenous affairs committee.\n\nWith the regime that the current power-brokered Liberal government has now installed at committees with its majority, it is shuttering committees. Any question as to the government's integrity is shut down, turned in camera and voted against by the majority Liberal membership on these committees.\n\nI do not trust the Liberal government to allow any of this discussion to take place at committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791124","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the question from the Bloc member about whether this could be studied at the indigenous affairs committee.\n\nWith the regime that the current power-brokered Liberal government has now installed at committees with its majority, it is shuttering committees. Any question as to the government's integrity is shut down, turned in camera and voted against by the majority Liberal ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["45db02723ba60c479f334da00e356dd0c08e1613698b8391464331ab8b25c3e7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6de631de54be0ef136bf589","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791125,"date":"2026-05-07T16:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member for Cowichan—Malahat—Langford was referring to the risks of secret agreements and asking whether I could expand on those risks. Well, because those agreements are secret, we have not seen them. We do not know what the risks are in these secret agreements.\n\nI have been privy to this through my work, for over 10 years, on the fisheries committee, where agreements are signed with organizations around the country, secret agreements. Due to the rules put in place by the Liberal government in the previous changes to the Fisheries Act, the information in those agreements cannot be made public. \n\nIt is hidden behind closed doors, so the risks are absolutely unknown.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791125","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member for Cowichan—Malahat—Langford was referring to the risks of secret agreements and asking whether I could expand on those risks. Well, because those agreements are secret, we have not seen them. We do not know what the risks are in these secret agreements.\n\nI have been privy to this through my work, for over 10 years, on the fisheries committee, where agreements are signed w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7cabe7769d0ce4040430a0ae8643e7089087155cd515a39f68190ade9a32cae8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c120250f14704499b7576421ef9d93a895ff4e27103208be365de4d4edd47d88"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b8014843d22bb6291ee6356","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791126,"date":"2026-05-07T23:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on April 17, I asked the government a question, and the response provided by the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure and Minister responsible for Pacific Economic Development Canada was unacceptable, which is why we are here now for this debate this evening.\n\nI stated the following:\n\n...after more than a decade of Liberal policies, life is unaffordable. The latest MNP consumer debt index report states that 70% of British Columbians say rising food prices and gas prices are straining their finances. The Liberals voted against reducing taxes that increase the cost of gas by 25¢ a litre. They voted against removing taxes on food that drive up the cost of groceries.\n\nThen I asked the government:\n\nWhy will the Liberals not provide Canadians some relief by adopting our Conservative plan to cut taxes on gas and food, and make life more affordable for Canadians?\n\nMy question was on fuel and grocery costs, things Canadians need and purchase every day. In response, the Liberals decided to put up a housing minister, who parroted preprocessed Liberal talking points about housing. By refusing to deliver reliefs that are within its reach, the Liberal government is refusing to recognize the problem, refusing to make life more affordable, and forcing more Canadians to be reliant on government rebates just to put food on the table.\n\nWhen I had a group of students in my office this week, they were genuinely concerned for their future because of the massive increases not just in the cost of their education but also in the cost of daily living. They have almost given up on the dream of owning a home that their parents were able to achieve. I do not know what it will take for the Liberal government to realize that its inflationary policies are part of the problem these students and other Canadians are facing.\n\n The Liberal government could remove the fuel standard tax and the industrial carbon tax to instantly reduce the cost of fuel and groceries for Canadians, but it continues to make things worse with inflationary spending that Canadians are forced to repay with interest. Speaking of interest, the debt the government has piled up will that mean roughly $3,400 per Canadian family will go toward serving the federal debt's interest this year alone. That is just interest, not repayment of the debt.\n\nI will repeat my question from April 17 once more, this time in hopes that the government will give Canadians an answer they really need and deserve, instead of preprocessed talking points from the minister's office: Why will the Liberals not provide Canadians some relief by adopting our Conservative plan to cut taxes on gas and food to make life more affordable for Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791126","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on April 17, I asked the government a question, and the response provided by the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure and Minister responsible for Pacific Economic Development Canada was unacceptable, which is why we are here now for this debate this evening.\n\nI stated the following:\n\n...after more than a decade of Liberal policies, life is unaffordable. The latest MNP consumer debt","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["915f6e5167529411fd511547cea78cea1f1a15c9bcd8e5e7328a7dec3746285b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21ef438c99bd06bc3d15a440aa93ba3dff04da2e93d14038c6d9731adc9f629e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98b5f629972ac87d8e3cf158","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791127,"date":"2026-05-07T23:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that was more preprocessed talking points from the minister's office and no real answers for Canadians.\n\nThe parliamentary secretary said that they are aware of the affordability issue, but are they aware that the government is responsible for it? There are the ever-increasing deficits, and this year's deficit is two times what former prime minister Justin Trudeau would have had. Billions of dollars are now being paid out in debt payments.\n\nThe member mentioned what they cannot control, the war in the Middle East and external issues, but they can control Liberal taxation and Liberal deficit spending. Why will the Liberals not take the steps that they can take? The Liberal government could take steps to relieve the pressure on Canadians. Why will it not take them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791127","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that was more preprocessed talking points from the minister's office and no real answers for Canadians.\n\nThe parliamentary secretary said that they are aware of the affordability issue, but are they aware that the government is responsible for it? There are the ever-increasing deficits, and this year's deficit is two times what former prime minister Justin Trudeau would have had. Bill","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dbadee6cc89e66749858409e29be57cb20c5afc547a5524236602337003249e0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0fdda9cfa760d702092a8a0c225fcf040b05649bdc9339bcbbe5a6b671d8b75f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-010c9669bd1086b4d725629b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791121,"date":"2026-05-08T16:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, because the Liberal government directed its lawyers to not argue property rights in the Cowichan case, British Columbians who bought their homes, paid their mortgages and followed the law now do not know the status of their home ownership. The Liberal government directive number 14 is still in place. This means that the legal instruction for federal lawyers to not defend property rights remains in place today. British Columbians need certainty of their home ownership. \n\nWill the Prime Minister reverse directive 14 today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-120/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791121","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, because the Liberal government directed its lawyers to not argue property rights in the Cowichan case, British Columbians who bought their homes, paid their mortgages and followed the law now do not know the status of their home ownership. The Liberal government directive number 14 is still in place. This means that the legal instruction for federal lawyers to not defend property righ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7abc2a085a6a73ee9fbf74a8d71c37758568caf73218b55818e1010dc848772f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6356802665fa543f7948e53e92bcb52f2a69783def7799916e927dbaa03ae1b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a0d290e90de4a2d3d27080b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034973,"date":"2026-05-28T23:17:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in the House as the elected representative for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies.\n\nMembers of the House are elected to represent Canadians and to advocate on their behalf. Every one of us is sent here to represent the people, to be their voice and advocate and to work on behalf of the people we represent. These are basic and essential principles of representative government that are supposed to be upheld in this place, but the Liberal government seems to have persistent challenges in fulfilling basic requirements of representative government.\n\nOn May 8, I asked if the Prime Minister would reverse government directive 14. What is directive 14? Well, it is the Liberal government's directive on civil litigation involving indigenous peoples, which instructs federal lawyers to limit their advocacy and arguments in litigation in which they are supposed to be representing the Government of Canada, which is supposed to represent the people of Canada. In other words, even if there are sound legal arguments for government lawyers to make in defending the interests of Canadian property rights, the Liberal government has instructed its lawyers to enter the ring with their hands tied behind their backs. With directive 14, the Liberal government has disabled the representatives of the representatives elected by Canadians to fight for the interests of Canadians.\n\nThe Cowichan decision stated that aboriginal title can coexist with and supersede fee simple land titles that are the primary method of private home ownership. The Liberal government's directive 14 was the central factor in the Cowichan case. When I asked on May 8 whether the Prime Minister would reverse directive 14, the Liberal Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations responded by dodging my question.\n\nThe Liberal government issued directive 14. The government lawyers stood down as directed. The B.C. Supreme Court concluded that aboriginal title can coexist with and supersede fee simple land titles. This has directly undermined the rights of all landowners in B.C. and across Canada.\n\nThe Liberal talking point and response will likely be that the Conservatives are whipping up emotions and stirring up unwarranted fear, but it is the Liberal government directive that has caused the real fear among Canadians, especially British Columbians. When a representative elected by the people stands in the House and asks if the Liberal government will discard its reckless policy that has caused so much chaos and harm, the Liberal ministers dodge the question.\n\nConstituents have contacted me to raise their personal fears for their property rights in the fallout from Cowichan, not because someone else whipped up fear but because of their own fear. The good people of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies can count on me to raise their concerns in the House, but sadly, they cannot count on the Liberal government to provide reasonable answers. The Liberal government is not representing Canadians' interests, nor is it defending the rights of Canadians. It is refusing to answer questions raised by members of the House elected by Canadians. All of this is the opposite of how representative government should operate. Canadians deserve to know why.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034973","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise in the House as the elected representative for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies.\n\nMembers of the House are elected to represent Canadians and to advocate on their behalf. Every one of us is sent here to represent the people, to be their voice and advocate and to work on behalf of the people we represent. These are basic and essential principles of repres","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["de093204602181fb37e50b9348632ee6341f51869bddf7c2e14b427f8ac45d43"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a41a5abea689e339d6d198b179528c813d3c544a2de1ed315e79565954e29548"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57aedb469530fe0a88bfccd4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034974,"date":"2026-05-28T23:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member opposite for attempting to change the channel, but he really needs to go back to his drawing board. I was asking about the Cowichan agreement, not the Musqueam agreement that he referred to. His denial response is exactly what I predicted. He was going to try and blame Conservatives for stoking fear. It is real fear that is coming from Canadians, like homeowners in the Richmond area who do not know what the value of their home is. He asked whether we had specific cases of people who had lost their homes. They have not lost their homes, but they have lost all value in their homes. We have ranch properties around British Columbia that simply cannot find any interested buyers because of this situation that the government has created.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034974","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the member opposite for attempting to change the channel, but he really needs to go back to his drawing board. I was asking about the Cowichan agreement, not the Musqueam agreement that he referred to. His denial response is exactly what I predicted. He was going to try and blame Conservatives for stoking fear. It is real fear that is coming from Canadians, like homeow","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1e4e12034a7e7c3b24650b5b28454d18d0bc705e5ae8545237170de32ab78f84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae6cee07546a1ad5d6fe35c216543634269b4bdb33f4c5ae3efbca4c6830f982"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b06ae7a832b928bbf531045","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034972,"date":"2026-05-29T16:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal Prime Minister is the only G7 leader to push his country into a recession. All other G7 countries are facing the same issues with tariffs and global challenges, but no others are in a recession.\n\n The real GDP fell in quarter one, making it two consecutive quarters of annualized decline, pushing Canada into a recession. The decline was mostly driven by decline in investments. Household savings dropped to the lowest level in two years as Canadians try to absorb the higher interest and debt servicing costs. This is the direct result of Liberal policies and taxes, including the clean fuel standard, the industrial carbon tax and the fuel excise tax, which are making everything more expensive. \n\nThe Prime Minister tried to claim that affordability is the best it has been in over a decade, but families cannot get ahead while paying for Liberal taxes, waste and mistakes. The Liberals have the means to make life more affordable, yet they continue pushing Canadians into a recession.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-125/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034972","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal Prime Minister is the only G7 leader to push his country into a recession. All other G7 countries are facing the same issues with tariffs and global challenges, but no others are in a recession.\n\n The real GDP fell in quarter one, making it two consecutive quarters of annualized decline, pushing Canada into a recession. The decline was mostly driven by decline in investmen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","label":"Excise taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","label":"Excise taxes","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bfdcd163767c4d5f4b99347677f34bc6d4a7b5c29db6376fc1e54c422519b881"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad6c67fadec2f8334537a2dd5253771fb9699783737e5aa6c08761ba61f21ee7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-94aa13f827eb0e7dec8e4bb5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109891,"date":"2026-06-01T16:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I thank all the witnesses for appearing today. This study has come to light as being very important to harvesters of all types, due to safety, access and so on. Mr. Wareham, I'll start with you. You mentioned that the delays in openings have caused significant loss of prime harvest time and so on. What would be a typical time for the season to be announced, and how much of a delay did you see in some of these?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109891","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I thank all the witnesses for appearing today. This study has come to light as being very important to harvesters of all types, due to safety, access and so on. Mr. Wareham, I'll start with you. You mentioned that the delays in openings have caused significant loss of prime harvest time and so on. What would be a typical time for the season to be announced, and how much of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9254a09cff27367a3c2d7ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109892,"date":"2026-06-01T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Are harvesters willing to move to an electronic notice? What are the impediments to going to a faster, more efficient process?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109892","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Are harvesters willing to move to an electronic notice? What are the impediments to going to a faster, more efficient process?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97852","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Astronomical observatories","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97852","label":"Astronomical observatories","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["124e593a9980a2f20a68163796f9a0b2969eca7409ba1a1314c79c7583c437ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66793c24329adad9642f9215","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109893,"date":"2026-06-01T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"You're unsure whether the department has the capacity to move away from the paper type of licences?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109893","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You're unsure whether the department has the capacity to move away from the paper type of licences?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pulp and paper industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","label":"Pulp and paper industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c77616717e1a0c0b186bbef66549f4718fa5229585da94927191cc74bb397ecb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff0591a2b9fafdb6512926f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109894,"date":"2026-06-01T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"We have seen over the years, when seasons were closed basically at the drop of a hat, that harvesters who were on the water harvesting found out that the season was closed. That didn't take two weeks to happen. Why is there a difference, in your understanding?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109894","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We have seen over the years, when seasons were closed basically at the drop of a hat, that harvesters who were on the water harvesting found out that the season was closed. That didn't take two weeks to happen. Why is there a difference, in your understanding?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:137532","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Deforestation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:137532","label":"Deforestation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["736b9d4636c86afbd12558472d493a2e40c3df4f3792f49dd463692f1bdae7f7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d41daee2b2df80518d91b8b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109895,"date":"2026-06-01T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"The department is able to issue closure notices electronically, by hailing boats and so on. It can happen quite quickly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109895","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The department is able to issue closure notices electronically, by hailing boats and so on. It can happen quite quickly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf5021f124470e47127c61b70967e4cd96335e4e1c4389318eb764667ee9e606"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1475d8a4020f4e69b6bed663","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109896,"date":"2026-06-01T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"They aren't capable of doing the same process for opening.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109896","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"They aren't capable of doing the same process for opening.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17b8e7a8a0c010d8a7fa5c33","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109897,"date":"2026-06-01T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"You mentioned that harvesters missed the best opportunities to harvest. Can you elaborate a little on that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109897","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You mentioned that harvesters missed the best opportunities to harvest. Can you elaborate a little on that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4bf17b8b305d793dcf7f030eefb66aa791937fb896226824879b90f0d16b7c39"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a58c15d6168f238a2f19c97c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109898,"date":"2026-06-01T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"We've heard some suggest that if it is late in opening, the season should be extended. Is that as valuable as those prime times at the early opening date?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109898","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We've heard some suggest that if it is late in opening, the season should be extended. Is that as valuable as those prime times at the early opening date?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6d21e7f85f16cff3f14419fff81d95bca84ed437b1933888311264b11f0c59e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa6760f217f8bde2e99b8283","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109899,"date":"2026-06-01T16:20:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. McLinton, are you able to elaborate any further on this, from what you heard from harvesters?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109899","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. McLinton, are you able to elaborate any further on this, from what you heard from harvesters?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c85c0dc5d72ad28db93428630a84e54d5caa04ffc08c0d9d0a24af67ba47e3e8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b44b665eed4087538dd08da8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109900,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll start with Mr. Fisher, if I could. Mr. Fisher, the Fraser Salmon Management Board operates under the auspices of the Fraser Salmon Collaborative Management Agreement. I believe that's what you said. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109900","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll start with Mr. Fisher, if I could. Mr. Fisher, the Fraser Salmon Management Board operates under the auspices of the Fraser Salmon Collaborative Management Agreement. I believe that's what you said. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8d630e2d8361a3dbe0de599e1ddc14e9fd804dfa4d72fed62728057d41e774e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["596d7e55bf509b0de8e44998623fc0d0227a49d750f92f915a81eed9e8bec608"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d505ceaa24ccd530418e60b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109901,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"That agreement was finalized in 2019, correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109901","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That agreement was finalized in 2019, correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d5c935f53e645793a03baac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109902,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Last year, in 2025, did the Fraser Salmon Management Board set escapement goals for Fraser sockeye?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109902","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Last year, in 2025, did the Fraser Salmon Management Board set escapement goals for Fraser sockeye?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["191531db3a077e93924c876f4b8db86a2af0a216d73213c5f3eb2bfacbdc7e8c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83e4830b0c596b1040603d63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109903,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Then the Fraser Salmon Management Board didn't put escapement goals forward? Were those put forward by DFO?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109903","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Then the Fraser Salmon Management Board didn't put escapement goals forward? Were those put forward by DFO?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["547eb62d30a9600c45d3f803f3cb3a46ccdb6f67c63245b16a0a7651ecd70a1f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0f7629ab4cf9ca0910fc07c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109904,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"It was the board as a group that came up with the escapement goals. Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109904","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It was the board as a group that came up with the escapement goals. Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5468a34c63df739982658ce208f598c3eb4fc236b79d88c4de88421d53701066"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6295ba1f505afa6f97b38624","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109905,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Then were the escapement goals for last year set before the unexpected large return of sockeye?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109905","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Then were the escapement goals for last year set before the unexpected large return of sockeye?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035593","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hatcheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035593","label":"Hatcheries","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["013c5e2febc10bab6acd272682174f2c6fa96195d642b5d908630c351102dcae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4e08a0d6b0aa45e6876a248","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109906,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"In 2025, the pre-season forecast for all sockeye runs was approximately 2.9 million fish. What actually returned was nine million sockeye, more than three times greater than expected. Why didn't the board, or the joint board and DFO, adjust the escapement goals to allow for harvest opportunities, despite this return being three times greater than forecasted?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109906","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"In 2025, the pre-season forecast for all sockeye runs was approximately 2.9 million fish. What actually returned was nine million sockeye, more than three times greater than expected. Why didn't the board, or the joint board and DFO, adjust the escapement goals to allow for harvest opportunities, despite this return being three times greater than forecasted?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-980e7b978652298314b3fb1c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109907,"date":"2026-06-01T17:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"However, last year they didn't. They took forever to get that increase in the total allowable catch. Do you know why?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109907","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"However, last year they didn't. They took forever to get that increase in the total allowable catch. Do you know why?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e24f6f26211db427c03478b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109908,"date":"2026-06-01T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Could you provide the committee with the 2025 escapement principles you talked about—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109908","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Could you provide the committee with the 2025 escapement principles you talked about—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Common-law unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034563","label":"Common-law unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c2c1fe479d8277fd08c6505bb24b86aae90b2b8c8cd75ee06c77309901426fb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c9888f4ec40ad03436457d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109909,"date":"2026-06-01T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"—not necessarily today, but could you provide the principles in writing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109909","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"—not necessarily today, but could you provide the principles in writing?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d893273e159236229247c66bcc020d303063b9963cd8b2845462c19c971be264"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fb0e409946557e47c16b344","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109910,"date":"2026-06-01T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thanks. Are you familiar with the concept of overspawning for salmon?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109910","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thanks. Are you familiar with the concept of overspawning for salmon?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","label":"Fish farming","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a39b6452f322eb8f19fd438e09e6d1096fd5edba0c34b883f96cd33540530d2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-598625c22dbc35125a6984e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109911,"date":"2026-06-01T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Was the management board aware of the risks of overspawning that could basically have been predicted if the harvest were not increased last year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109911","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Was the management board aware of the risks of overspawning that could basically have been predicted if the harvest were not increased last year?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80b0b3363afcf39b8d69e2b86d41f5437f9289e9cb961f8b51beb24004734477"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-19d35f2b40ae2c3397a21c62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109912,"date":"2026-06-01T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Good. Thank you. I want to switch to Ms. Mavin now. You talked about the immense preparation and investment in getting ready for a season. I think we understand that, but can you go a little further in depth on that? What's involved? How long does it take you to find crew? How long does it take to get gear? What kinds of dollars are invested to get ready for a season, when you don't know if you're going to get it or not?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109912","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Good. Thank you. I want to switch to Ms. Mavin now. You talked about the immense preparation and investment in getting ready for a season. I think we understand that, but can you go a little further in depth on that? What's involved? How long does it take you to find crew? How long does it take to get gear? What kinds of dollars are invested to get ready for a season, when you don't know if you're","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e257411c2cb1323702a317c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109913,"date":"2026-06-01T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"You mentioned the prep work ahead of time and the packaging on the boat. Do you have to buy the packaging material and other pieces necessary for that process?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109913","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"You mentioned the prep work ahead of time and the packaging on the boat. Do you have to buy the packaging material and other pieces necessary for that process?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036228","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Materials technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945702","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Packaging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036228","label":"Materials technology","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945702","label":"Packaging","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4805ebaa05cc94330372d8f9b7c75723a076a0dc131759e2d756ed400c42fc2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9db5663c2474cd8f856a4ad3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109914,"date":"2026-06-01T17:25:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"How long would that take?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-40/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109914","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"How long would that take?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de4bbb0a748beff47e46943b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109915,"date":"2026-06-03T21:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Counter to Mr. Morrissey's argument, I believe the points Mr. Small is making are very relevant as to what is in the report, what's missing from the report and what should have been in the report. I think they're very relevant, Madam Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109915","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Counter to Mr. Morrissey's argument, I believe the points Mr. Small is making are very relevant as to what is in the report, what's missing from the report and what should have been in the report. I think they're very relevant, Madam Chair.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["913ef42c63d93f79918bafb0942dcf39c1f3595fd6576ab7d46ae9f4f0c4e0a4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e1317f893fa6b4a7811bd99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109916,"date":"2026-06-03T21:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"The scope of the meeting would be the report. I think it's very relevant that we point out what was missing in the report and what work had not been done by the department in providing a report that the government would potentially be making recommendations or decisions on. If there are shortcomings in what has been included in the report, that's very relevant to the report itself because it is lacking. That is why I consider this very relevant.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109916","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The scope of the meeting would be the report. I think it's very relevant that we point out what was missing in the report and what work had not been done by the department in providing a report that the government would potentially be making recommendations or decisions on. If there are shortcomings in what has been included in the report, that's very relevant to the report itself because it is la","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["787ccbd1f287c594e0a5994513a696361111d23b48c6c72eb367ed71a25be91e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8721ac763b4116c40561982","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109917,"date":"2026-06-03T21:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Vigneault, can you tell me if this report is pertaining to a project of DFO?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109917","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Vigneault, can you tell me if this report is pertaining to a project of DFO?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["167d5f17619ffb76a438550ef99b8db1dd4bf5205d173a79a59a924fd7105b76"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-195db0bb31399a100ec4b412","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109918,"date":"2026-06-03T21:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Is this considered a project of the Province of Nova Scotia or the Government of Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109918","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Is this considered a project of the Province of Nova Scotia or the Government of Canada?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3a705c461c253ec1c0f98b335319602a05a4b0c16631a008397d34263907331"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98983646dfeee3dae62a9c1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109919,"date":"2026-06-03T21:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Are you telling me that all of this research and the report have been done but not in response to any project that's being proposed? Is that correct?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109919","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Are you telling me that all of this research and the report have been done but not in response to any project that's being proposed? Is that correct?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f13a8fe53534ec78707f95951fd7ad6e1c380a6b78229210162e1ce2dcc70903"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69e73a872ee2922546fa4ec915f73b02c58239b2f0d64c773954ac9600fc0234"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccd32384cf3b6d68be4665cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109920,"date":"2026-06-03T21:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109920","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d613fa71759926085b138459","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109921,"date":"2026-06-03T21:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"When does a project become a project for the proponent or for government partners in this project?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109921","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"When does a project become a project for the proponent or for government partners in this project?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a64e2fb622314830a13174e24a2f9277846bd85f04731ae5af4ce9d9a2450399"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-825386be238d2fad2e7152b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109922,"date":"2026-06-03T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Someone else has requested this information, then, and DFO has put their time, resources and everything into it. Is there any transfer of funds from the requester of the information to DFO? We hear from stakeholders across this country about lacking resources within the department, and here is a department apparently chasing after ghosts requested by another department. Can you square that circle?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109922","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Someone else has requested this information, then, and DFO has put their time, resources and everything into it. Is there any transfer of funds from the requester of the information to DFO? We hear from stakeholders across this country about lacking resources within the department, and here is a department apparently chasing after ghosts requested by another department. Can you square that circle?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["78e5d1c93ac8967144d2d0da5d713f7d3653d6d8059a3a5de919a5b91e9b3a2c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cae57930198204292c222934","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109923,"date":"2026-06-03T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"That helps to answer my question. We've heard that boundaries were moved for proposed marine protected conservation areas. When does the process for establishing a marine conservation area begin?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109923","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That helps to answer my question. We've heard that boundaries were moved for proposed marine protected conservation areas. When does the process for establishing a marine conservation area begin?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b32418240e8fd6823abbf0944ffd29d73591746caf517089657d7bcbdd5c4783"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28327f48170299139ae4fb5228a88c9b54edb699027bc4804202c3d932543cc9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c2098ae8aa1b6c48a46b932e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109924,"date":"2026-06-03T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"My question is, when does it begin? Who initiates the potential for a marine conservation area?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109924","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"My question is, when does it begin? Who initiates the potential for a marine conservation area?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6d94ab7f7699d084a8d9b1bab1b9129f95a630d176acb35bf3667c2259041e7e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d376178d8d5751e5fda695a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109925,"date":"2026-06-03T21:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay. I'll have more questions in my next round.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109925","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. I'll have more questions in my next round.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-861ffa42440dab12199da2db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109926,"date":"2026-06-03T22:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"No.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109926","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8ed5911372a2462ed8ef1b57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109927,"date":"2026-06-03T22:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. We still have many questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109927","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I have a point of order, Madam Chair. We still have many questions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["075999250d49881f50b24e86d2e45f7a95170c1eba8fa58ac4ad86ce8affddcb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebc45dfd063d97141ce2a8f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109928,"date":"2026-06-03T22:10:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"If the Liberals wish to concede their time, we will gladly take it. We had two hours scheduled for this meeting because there was a series of rounds of questions we planned to get through.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109928","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If the Liberals wish to concede their time, we will gladly take it. We had two hours scheduled for this meeting because there was a series of rounds of questions we planned to get through.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a73e9434b1369743c851978da437342407bf1ef64c0f59d28aa8725603c82f89"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03687c270409a8779311445c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109929,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Yes. I'll also go back to the motion. Look under item (b)(i). It says: (i) all documents, including but not limited to memoranda, briefing notes, and internal communications, related to the decision to produce this report, including any requests for its preparation and associated allocation of resources.... I don't believe we've been provided with the document that provides the request. The committee still hasn't received the documents required, as per this motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109929","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Yes. I'll also go back to the motion. Look under item (b)(i). It says: (i) all documents, including but not limited to memoranda, briefing notes, and internal communications, related to the decision to produce this report, including any requests for its preparation and associated allocation of resources.... I don't believe we've been provided with the document that provides the request. The commit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fa98574cf9c34e62c0b1f37","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109930,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"If anybody can point out, among the documents we received, the document that shows any requests for its preparation, I'll gladly retract what I'm saying. We have not received all documents requested.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109930","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If anybody can point out, among the documents we received, the document that shows any requests for its preparation, I'll gladly retract what I'm saying. We have not received all documents requested.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a501f64edcfd910f26261bf2d939cca337c13f6f4c0f6a27d48acf2f752c4b7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6595084fca0be0077351ce7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109931,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Can you tell me which document shows the request for the study for the report?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109931","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Can you tell me which document shows the request for the study for the report?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["827a499e10e7fc59888496b7c88024c8c65aa0cfb890daabc841da48582ceacb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5df40ac7e44a87c1d38b2709","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109932,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Item (b)(i) states: (i) all documents, including but not limited to memoranda, briefing notes, and internal communications, related to the decision to produce this report, including any requests for its preparation and associated allocation of resources.... Where are those documents?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109932","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Item (b)(i) states: (i) all documents, including but not limited to memoranda, briefing notes, and internal communications, related to the decision to produce this report, including any requests for its preparation and associated allocation of resources.... Where are those documents?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f5d8aa1b400f6d26d6cd1e3bfd73f239068252c19b713c823c605b815f0a94b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c2ae75558cb3b6bc65e1495","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109933,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Can we ask the clerk if any of those documents were titled as the request for the report?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109933","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Can we ask the clerk if any of those documents were titled as the request for the report?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1e33101a22e6c3c7451bf37970ad0faa4ee60cacebc439058e4028bc79d984e0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-269eacba767caf4de60cf02e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109934,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"There was no request for the report, because that's what it said.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109934","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There was no request for the report, because that's what it said.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d86a0e3675f0a031d40dd285","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109935,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"It says: (i) all documents, including but not limited to memoranda, briefing notes, and internal communications, related to the decision to produce this report, including any requests for its preparation and associated allocation of resources.... The last part says, \"including any requests for its preparation\". Was a request for the preparation of the report included in the documents that were provided to this committee?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109935","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It says: (i) all documents, including but not limited to memoranda, briefing notes, and internal communications, related to the decision to produce this report, including any requests for its preparation and associated allocation of resources.... The last part says, \"including any requests for its preparation\". Was a request for the preparation of the report included in the documents that were pro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c087064de19976936a65d263213071e8776a57a609c680561c935976376ab413"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-838a3ff841003411f63ce702","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109936,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"When documents are ordered to be produced for the committee, someone else doesn't get to pick and choose which documents are provided. It was very specific in the motion which documents were to be provided. Who picked and chose which documents they would provide and decided to leave other documents out?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109936","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"When documents are ordered to be produced for the committee, someone else doesn't get to pick and choose which documents are provided. It was very specific in the motion which documents were to be provided. Who picked and chose which documents they would provide and decided to leave other documents out?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8dfedc81fcb545a6cf3e2e0370d37c23c1f10ff081333e664a819584928f405e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65fcc1d724229287b893e378","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109937,"date":"2026-06-03T22:15:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Through all of this debate, we could have fitted in more question rounds and simply avoided this. I have simply two questions. I want to know what data gaps were identified when they compiled the report and how they identified what those gaps were. If I had a couple of minutes to ask those questions, we could have been past mine. Perhaps Mr. Small could have gotten his questions in as well, and we could have been finished.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109937","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Through all of this debate, we could have fitted in more question rounds and simply avoided this. I have simply two questions. I want to know what data gaps were identified when they compiled the report and how they identified what those gaps were. If I had a couple of minutes to ask those questions, we could have been past mine. Perhaps Mr. Small could have gotten his questions in as well, and we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1cd63e381e71ed0e67744f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109938,"date":"2026-06-03T22:35:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. This pertains to the point of order that was raised against Ms. Kronis asking questions about wind farms. I'm seeing a CSAS review panel request. I want to read part of it. It says: The development of an offshore wind industry in Atlantic Canada is likely to impact marine ecosystems and species in new ways that have not been investigated in a Canadian context. Consequently, there is need for science advice to inform anticipated project-specific Impact Assessments.... Wind farms were specifically in the request that was provided to us, so Ms. Kronis's questions regarding the expertise of the department in wind farms is very much relevant, contrary to what the Liberal members were trying to propose.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109938","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. This pertains to the point of order that was raised against Ms. Kronis asking questions about wind farms. I'm seeing a CSAS review panel request. I want to read part of it. It says: The development of an offshore wind industry in Atlantic Canada is likely to impact marine ecosystems and species in new ways that have not been investigated in a Canadian context. Consequently, there is nee","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09d1ab2356865086a23f7c53eb18c945d75d7ce088dc5c14a19daf086f1d260e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-58da7812d5f834cdc723d24e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109939,"date":"2026-06-03T22:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. I have two questions, and then I'll pass my time to Mr. Small so he can add it to the time that he should have. Mr. Vigneault, what data gaps did you identify when compiling this report?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109939","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I have two questions, and then I'll pass my time to Mr. Small so he can add it to the time that he should have. Mr. Vigneault, what data gaps did you identify when compiling this report?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ff0a71548db67d9cb48a480","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109940,"date":"2026-06-03T22:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I understand that, but what data gaps did you identify?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109940","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I understand that, but what data gaps did you identify?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transborder data flow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","label":"Transborder data flow","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dcd59b1a0c6af94426b10aad71aa409e2c15f2bf5ca8638f98a22d5d99b16a3c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28a82f0b44b7001ba908eaec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109941,"date":"2026-06-03T22:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I'd like to move a motion asking that the data gaps Mr. Vigneault just referred to be provided to this committee so we can fully understand what might be at stake here and the good work the department may be doing in this process. As part of that, please provide in writing how the data gaps were identified.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109941","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'd like to move a motion asking that the data gaps Mr. Vigneault just referred to be provided to this committee so we can fully understand what might be at stake here and the good work the department may be doing in this process. As part of that, please provide in writing how the data gaps were identified.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","label":"Data processing","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4ddfbfe009e4529b4501b8ffcd2d904f537b15fd741b0dccabc2652622b0239"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f656adc2c7003781c332dbe0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109942,"date":"2026-06-03T22:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"I'll pass my remaining time to Mr. Small, to add to his five minutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109942","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"I'll pass my remaining time to Mr. Small, to add to his five minutes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8fa778b00d634ffa05d2363","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083793,"date":"2026-06-04T16:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Chair, the minister opposite is arguing that debating the bill itself—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-129/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083793","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Chair, the minister opposite is arguing that debating the bill itself—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6a380e13ece713c750e6f59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109943,"date":"2026-06-10T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I thank all the witnesses for being here. Salmon are very important on all coasts. Chief, you mentioned that you had a positive meeting with Minister Thompson . Did she provide any concrete commitments or actions that could save the Mactaquac Biodiversity Facility?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109943","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I thank all the witnesses for being here. Salmon are very important on all coasts. Chief, you mentioned that you had a positive meeting with Minister Thompson . Did she provide any concrete commitments or actions that could save the Mactaquac Biodiversity Facility?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Biological diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Concrete","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012910","label":"Biological diversity","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","label":"Concrete","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fdd77ec80e705bb9dfb771dcc15064153dcceaec6d9b850c56e07a132a962854"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1913c2339a89a1a7a91a83ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109944,"date":"2026-06-10T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"No immediate commitments...?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109944","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No immediate commitments...?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c0cc8ed4b41b5cf7a1ee1ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109945,"date":"2026-06-10T22:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Okay. Thank you. In looking at the government's \"Canada's National Strategy to Ensure the Future of Atlantic Salmon, 2024-2036\", I picked up on a line that said \"it will not be possible to invest everywhere\". To me, that sounds like a government giving up on salmon. I come from B.C., from the interior, and there were no salmon in the B.C. portion of the Okanagan system for over 50 years. Work with the first nations there, the Okanagan Nation Alliance, across the Canada-U.S. border, established a hatchery there, and now there are salmon returning on their own all the way up into Okanagan Lake, hundreds of kilometres up the river, where there hadn't been salmon for 50 years. How important is it to the salmon population and to your nation that this genetic stock remain viable in some way, so when other factors are impacting the population, that stock can be there to rebuild what was there?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109945","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you. In looking at the government's \"Canada's National Strategy to Ensure the Future of Atlantic Salmon, 2024-2036\", I picked up on a line that said \"it will not be possible to invest everywhere\". To me, that sounds like a government giving up on salmon. I come from B.C., from the interior, and there were no salmon in the B.C. portion of the Okanagan system for over 50 years. Work with","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93f7fbd426bb999eb6a6aef91b8f34c2391d609fda5ecbb2956a1773f874aec3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93848aff41840d6315dc6e20","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109946,"date":"2026-06-10T22:55:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. It sounds similar to a situation that we have in British Columbia right now. We have volunteer organizations that run a hatchery in the upper Fraser River. They have been working with habitat biologists and habitat restoration people within the Department of Fisheries and Oceans for years. They have maintained a facility that has continued the viability of a specific type of salmon: S52, or stream-type chinook salmon. DFO just announced the cuts to those habitat biologists in that area. They now have to travel hundreds of kilometres from Kamloops into that area. Does this sound like a troubling trend to you that salmon—wild salmon—in some of these most endangered areas are being put at risk by the decisions?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109946","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. It sounds similar to a situation that we have in British Columbia right now. We have volunteer organizations that run a hatchery in the upper Fraser River. They have been working with habitat biologists and habitat restoration people within the Department of Fisheries and Oceans for years. They have maintained a facility that has continued the viability of a specific type of salmon: S52","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1081a7ba52957e87b025f401b07c4373d9ef1caff8e75cb0a5009952250edf7e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b2eeb59c6f0465678401ea86c7948b66bc74dfc1101f7dd29c4a575596672497"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67f5801992e5e57e9b50eee9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109947,"date":"2026-06-10T23:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"The vote will be after 7 p.m.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109947","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The vote will be after 7 p.m.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5e95f55a4bac1951e4232e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109948,"date":"2026-06-10T23:40:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"The vote's not until 7:09.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109948","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The vote's not until 7:09.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6db2f31fb48193bd3845bad3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109949,"date":"2026-06-10T23:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Again, thank you to the witnesses. I noticed you were sitting in the back of the room earlier, for the testimony. Thank you for being here. I want to turn right away to all of you. Recommendation number 14 in this committee's report from January 2017 states: That Fisheries and Oceans Canada allow a significant increase in the harvest of striped bass by the recreational fishery by lengthening the retention season and increasing catch limits, where striped bass populations warrant it. Was that recommendation followed by the department? Go ahead, Mr. Wilbur.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109949","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. Again, thank you to the witnesses. I noticed you were sitting in the back of the room earlier, for the testimony. Thank you for being here. I want to turn right away to all of you. Recommendation number 14 in this committee's report from January 2017 states: That Fisheries and Oceans Canada allow a significant increase in the harvest of striped bass by the recreational fish","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-281eb9535e3ae8b6ef530d46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109950,"date":"2026-06-10T23:45:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Was there a significant increase in the harvest of striped bass by the recreational fishery?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109950","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Was there a significant increase in the harvest of striped bass by the recreational fishery?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1aefef4d49ce7d6789685b7a06d54cff635c9476646c8cc772e11134c2e41699"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9bdd616d631951cdd0e3ee89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109951,"date":"2026-06-10T23:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"We have no idea, then, whether they allowed a significant increase.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109951","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"We have no idea, then, whether they allowed a significant increase.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a48cbd1dadac30c3deb961d12ee11cf2978de39270388c0e385a31b1f217393"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3d120cc2c5b6da56f638965","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109952,"date":"2026-06-10T23:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you for that. In the same report from 2017, recommendation 13 is as follows: That Fisheries and Oceans Canada support a grey seal harvest program that emphasizes full utilization of the seal to provide economic opportunities with an aim to significantly reduce the seal populations and enhance the recovery of wild Atlantic salmon populations. That was a unanimous recommendation from this committee. This sounds uncannily familiar to me from the west coast, with our wild steelhead populations in the Fraser. Those steelhead populations are now basically down to zero. Dr. Carl Walters completed a study and recommended management of predation in the estuaries. I believe his report said that we could see a 70% to 80% increase in steelhead returns if that predator management was done. Do you feel that predator management between striped bass and the grey seal populations would be a first good step in this? I see Mr. D'Amours nodding on that. Can you go ahead on that, Mr. D'Amours? I'll then ask Mr. Wilbur.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109952","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you for that. In the same report from 2017, recommendation 13 is as follows: That Fisheries and Oceans Canada support a grey seal harvest program that emphasizes full utilization of the seal to provide economic opportunities with an aim to significantly reduce the seal populations and enhance the recovery of wild Atlantic salmon populations. That was a unanimous recommendation from this comm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e182388fabcc885eae2daeb6acc28b8c5e92c996f2ef621931783caf062b21a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f9d1878a6426ee0011e6dbfe6ae88bf557c61a94cc26299859c4584df5f4b1e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40cddc285406a19f1b385fd6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109953,"date":"2026-06-10T23:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Mr. Wilbur, go ahead quickly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109953","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Wilbur, go ahead quickly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b76ccd475f1e0833902c865","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109954,"date":"2026-06-10T23:50:00+00:00","title":"FOPO","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"FOPO","text":"Thank you. I want to go back to those two recommendations, because those were recommendations to government. Basically what we're hearing.... Please tell me. Did government respond appropriately and implement those two recommendations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/FOPO/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109954","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I want to go back to those two recommendations, because those were recommendations to government. Basically what we're hearing.... Please tell me. Did government respond appropriately and implement those two recommendations?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e3e22a4f3fafe7a5ff5b80adaead7d6c4d2527decdb1e044073c5b1939a3e72c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b873845d8ae2897eec94c88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109814,"date":"2026-06-11T17:10:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"CIIT","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I appreciate the opportunity to be subbed in on this committee. I haven't been here before. I want to touch on a couple of points that I've picked up on over the last few weeks here. One is skills training, and the other is infrastructure requirements here in Canada. I was recently at a presentation regarding marine transportation requirements here in Canada. It was pointed out that over the next few years, Canada is only going to be able to meet about 40% of the anticipated needs in the shipping sector for heavy tonnage captains, crews, marine pilots and so on. If this is such a shortage that's been identified by industry, do either of your organizations play a role in that, whether it be developing private training facilities or private-public partnership training facilities? Do you have any understanding of the identified drastic shortage that we're facing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109814","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. I appreciate the opportunity to be subbed in on this committee. I haven't been here before. I want to touch on a couple of points that I've picked up on over the last few weeks here. One is skills training, and the other is infrastructure requirements here in Canada. I was recently at a presentation regarding marine transportation requirements here in Canada. It was pointed","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3d01ce3597c81a7501d2b79b0b4a7c42f11a37ec556135e8e06388d37277cc5e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a1253be17844839fae19972104f7805a67372e78d9a43f3c664b58966cfa4a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb869e9d9bf3440996984558","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109815,"date":"2026-06-11T17:15:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"CIIT","text":"Do you have anything further to add, Mr. Winterhalt?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109815","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Do you have anything further to add, Mr. Winterhalt?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96236357682a58185eb0b3ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109816,"date":"2026-06-11T17:15:00+00:00","title":"CIIT","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"CIIT","text":"No. What I'm getting at is, even if those companies are ready to export, the infrastructure and the workforce to be able to make those exports aren't going to be in place. We simply cannot meet them. I want to point to another example. My riding, Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, covers over 400 kilometres of Trans-Canada Highway and about 450 kilometres of CPKC main line, the main transportation corridor for western Canada to the port of Vancouver. It's not the only one, but it's certainly the largest one. An Order Paper question I put forward asked what the federal government had invested or spent on planning or engineering for highway improvements through the national parks, which are 100% the responsibility of the federal government. The response for what they had spent over the last 10 years was basically zero for a project that had already been under way. There have been no new projects proposed or even the design or engineering phase started on projects that are going to take at least 10 years to be done. We see highway closures near my home once or twice a week because of the poor highway conditions over the speed of semi-trailers. When these include a fatality, the highway is shut down for four to six hours. It's completely closed with no detours available. It's been estimated that those closures through the Rogers Pass cost the Canadian economy about $3 million per hour. The government has now said that the armed forces are no longer going to take part in avalanche control, but they have put no plan in place to replace them. We're going to see highway closures of unknown lengths at $3 million per hour killing our economy. I want to know what your organizations are doing to assist in making sure that we have the trades, the businesses and the industry ready to build that infrastructure that we need if we're going to be able to export the goods that you're helping entrepreneurs develop.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-43/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/CIIT/meeting-43/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109816","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"No. What I'm getting at is, even if those companies are ready to export, the infrastructure and the workforce to be able to make those exports aren't going to be in place. We simply cannot meet them. I want to point to another example. My riding, Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, covers over 400 kilometres of Trans-Canada Highway and about 450 kilometres of CPKC main line, the main transportation ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","label":"Engineering"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","label":"Engineering","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a84519a30bf424c016c7627effda73f4632a221cfb009c0c9ab192a06a96a9d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4f5b3af2e7ed876279288807653b9d4b097f3f7e3732147e3c28b6bab0e6438f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37993e89cb9d221c5e7b4ac3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085696,"date":"2026-06-11T19:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, again that was an answer that was not even close to the question.\n\n All parties acknowledge that the salmon allocation policy must be aligned with the Ahousaht decision. However, while all Canadians have the right to fish, the minister keeps the public's lives and livelihood on hold, waiting for her to decide whether the public's current priority allocation for chinook and coho, before non-indigenous commercial, will be retained.\n\n Will she confirm, today, that this priority will remain?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085696","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, again that was an answer that was not even close to the question.\n\n All parties acknowledge that the salmon allocation policy must be aligned with the Ahousaht decision. However, while all Canadians have the right to fish, the minister keeps the public's lives and livelihood on hold, waiting for her to decide whether the public's current priority allocation for chinook and coho, befor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18bc31a503761e9229f43488","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085697,"date":"2026-06-11T20:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after 11 summers in the House, it is interesting to see what happens, typically, every year in June, under this government. The Liberals cannot manage their agenda throughout the entire year, so they fall so far behind. They have put us on late-night hours, where we are sitting until midnight, and even then they have to cut debate short with these time allocation motions because they cannot handle the fact that we are here to debate on behalf of Canadians who have sent us to this place to debate the government bills and to make sure they are the best they can possibly be. \n\nI strongly oppose the time allocation motion, which will shut down debate once again, just as the Liberals have been doing in committees any time we try to hold them accountable for their failed attempts at governing this country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085697","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after 11 summers in the House, it is interesting to see what happens, typically, every year in June, under this government. The Liberals cannot manage their agenda throughout the entire year, so they fall so far behind. They have put us on late-night hours, where we are sitting until midnight, and even then they have to cut debate short with these time allocation motions because they ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f6a6d496ca4d60373d8fc40f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085698,"date":"2026-06-12T00:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today as the elected representative for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. As I have previously stated in this place, all of us have a solemn responsibility to provide representation and voice to those citizens who voted for us and depend on us to be their voice here in Parliament. Canadians need us to be vigilant, and they depend on us to be their voice. We have to be ready for the challenges and dangers that emerge, and I accept that responsibility with sincere dedication to the amazing people of Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies and the people of Canada. We must all take actions to prevent, mitigate and overcome challenges and dangers, including the the unintended consequences caused by the actions or the inactions of levels of government. In these times of global uncertainty, Canadians need our vigilance and actions more than at any other time.\n\n As I begin speaking to this bill, Bill C-25, the strong and free elections act, I would like to thank all of the Elections Canada workers, from the electoral district returning officers to the poll workers, the volunteers and the ever-important scrutineers who are such an important part of our democratic system here in Canada. I will speak to components of this bill, Bill C-25, and how parts of it are overdue while other parts need further debate and consideration for what is best for Canada and Canadians' interests.\n\n After the 2021 federal election, Canadians were alarmed to hear of foreign interference in the election of candidates and members sent here to represent and defend this country's interests. The Liberals say they care about democracy, yet they have allowed foreign actors to brazenly interfere in our elections. It was only after the Liberals got caught turning a blind eye to Beijing's interference that they finally introduced legislation to establish a foreign influence registry in Canada. However, two years after passing that bill into law, there is still no registry. So far, we have had date after date promised and date after date missed. After years of opposing a foreign influence registry, including Conservative efforts to create one, the Liberals' latest tactic appears to be one of endless delay. It is time for the Liberal government to finally take foreign interference seriously. It is time to get a registry up and running, today.\n\nI must say that this is uncannily similar to an issue dealt with in my role as associate shadow minister for fisheries, and that is the issue of foreign ownership of licences and quota on the west coast. The last Conservative government put in motion policies to stop the issue of controlling agreements between processors and harvesters on the east coast, where processors were limiting harvesters' choice of where they landed their catch and how much they received for their catch. In the following years, legislation and regulations were put in place to end those controlling agreements and protect local fish harvesters and their communities on the east coast. \n\nIn May 2019, the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans tabled a report titled \"West Coast Fisheries: Sharing Risks and Benefits\". In that report, there were 20 recommendations to government that would have helped meet the aspirations of fish harvesters, especially young fishers, to carry on their careers and family traditions and contribute to building economically, socially and culturally vibrant west coast communities.\n\n In 2023, four years later, that same fisheries committee undertook another study to produce yet another report, titled \"Foreign Ownership and Corporate Concentration of Fishing Licences and Quota\". The testimony we heard during that second report was alarming in that after four years, the government had taken almost no action to identify who the beneficial owners of licences and quota are on the west coast. In fact, what we basically heard was that it has no idea.\n\nIt is now seven years since that first report on the issue was tabled in the House, and the Liberal government has yet to address the issue and put in place any significant measures to protect our independent harvesters on the west coast. That is why I say that Bill C‐25 and the west coast fisheries issues have something in common. It is delay, delay, delay. If the Liberals do not find it important enough to create a foreign influence registry or to investigate whether foreign entities own licences and quotas, and who controls, catches and processes our Canadian seafood, then Conservatives will hold them accountable, and we hope that Canadians will expect that accountability from their government. \n\nAnother component of the bill that I want Canadians to be aware of is the third party financing loophole. Bill C‐25 would create a wide open loophole through which foreign money could still be used by third parties for partisan activity, partisan advertising and election surveying. Specifically, if contributions to a third party amount to 10% or less of its annual revenue in the year prior to a fixed election year, it could use its own funds to pay for, among other things, partisan activity and advertising. A third party's own funds do not have to come from Canadian citizens or permanent residents and do not have to be reported in the same way. \n\nWith fixed election periods, it is very easy for third parties and foreign interests to predict when an election may be. A foreign interest could funnel money into a third party for two or three years ahead of schedule, which would then be treated as part of the third party's own funds. Further, 10% sounds like a small number, but it may not be. There are third parties that have a lot of money. What constitutes 10% or less of a third party's revenue coming from contributions may in fact be millions of dollars. This means that very large third parties would be able to use their own funds for election-related expenses. Disappointingly, the Liberals voted against our amendments to close these wide open loopholes in the bill. \n\nI raise these points as part of this debate because that is what we as elected representatives are sent here to do, to scrutinize legislation and make it the best it can be. What we have seen from the government since I first came here in 2015 is not the best legislation it could be. Conservatives will continue to call on the Liberal government to strengthen Canada's position against foreign actors who seek to influence our economies and our democracy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085698","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise today as the elected representative for Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies. As I have previously stated in this place, all of us have a solemn responsibility to provide representation and voice to those citizens who voted for us and depend on us to be their voice here in Parliament. Canadians need us to be vigilant, and they depend on us to be their voice. We hav","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1dbdfd43c3b1c7a875adce503499aafd1e043b76cd0c7d46f04a8ed504acaab1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d089ad1dae358c6600d553bfb73f68b1b7d8840bcb1939fbcceebed3bae5200"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc4ef446a46691aa429608e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085699,"date":"2026-06-12T00:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, if the member had been listening, she would have heard me speak about the third party financing loophole. There could be millions of dollars spent by foreign entities to affect the nomination and election of candidates and representatives who are elected to ensure the security and safety of our country. If anything, this has to be the one piece that should have been addressed, and the government should recognize that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085699","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, if the member had been listening, she would have heard me speak about the third party financing loophole. There could be millions of dollars spent by foreign entities to affect the nomination and election of candidates and representatives who are elected to ensure the security and safety of our country. If anything, this has to be the one piece that should have been addressed, and the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["30c77a0bb8cdb0e45c2049ae758ea8f73925bf4248f7905652a4e6926ee488bc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a13549361b98abfdad6c226c5dc01cbeea94581be4a982f5374b04f73f4ac628"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d69f186116465b124a381a11","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085700,"date":"2026-06-12T00:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate that question on political financing.\n\nPrior to when I was elected, there was what was known as a per-vote subsidy. If a member got a certain number of votes in the previous election, they got that subsidy from the taxpayer.\n\nWhat has changed now is that there is a maximum amount that individuals, and they must be individuals, not corporations, can contribute to an election candidate. That levels the playing field. To be elected, candidates have to work for the funds they need to use for their campaigns. They cannot just run on the money they raised because of the votes they got in the previous election. It is an incentive for candidates to work hard for their constituents so they can be recognized by and have support behind them from individuals in their riding.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-134/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085700","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate that question on political financing.\n\nPrior to when I was elected, there was what was known as a per-vote subsidy. If a member got a certain number of votes in the previous election, they got that subsidy from the taxpayer.\n\nWhat has changed now is that there is a maximum amount that individuals, and they must be individuals, not corporations, can contribute to an electi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bbda9ff9c7cf6230be00e900e52d1c4188dc7b7515082f3f63461b522a420405"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4393e9520571a5b8aa7d1b5b70ca1a1d822d54f8863b99925d301f1614e9d0b5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0750d6ad52d073a50b4aa35a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087635,"date":"2026-06-16T19:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize the passing of long-time city councillor, regional district director and former chair Kevin Flynn.\n\nKevin's leadership earned him the deep respect of the community he served so passionately, yet for all his dedication to public service, Kevin's greatest joy was his family. He leaves behind his beloved wife Cathy, his proud sons Chris and Curtis, daughters-in-law Katherine and Stephanie, and his three cherished grandsons, who affectionately called him \"Grump-Pa.\" The name may reflect Kevin's armchair coaching and reffing style. \n\nFollowing Kevin's social media during games, when there was a bad coaching decision or questionable referee or empire call, we could count on Kevin to say clearly what the call should have been. Kevin called it like he saw it. That is the way he went through life, and in his role as city councillor and regional district director and chair. His integrity, laughter and dedication will be clearly missed but not forgotten. \n\nRest in peace, Kevin.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087635","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize the passing of long-time city councillor, regional district director and former chair Kevin Flynn.\n\nKevin's leadership earned him the deep respect of the community he served so passionately, yet for all his dedication to public service, Kevin's greatest joy was his family. He leaves behind his beloved wife Cathy, his proud sons Chris and Curtis, daughters-in-","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62f1d62aeb0eb258d67f8c37","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109817,"date":"2026-06-16T20:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Madam Chair. It's a pleasure to be here at this committee. I have been on the fisheries committee for over 10 years now, so it's interesting sitting here. I thank Mr. Weiler for his time as chair of that committee. I have a number of questions on this bill and what's led up to this. Mr. Weiler, you said that since the passage of the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act, vessel owners are finding loopholes and ways to get past the accountability piece of it. Were these loopholes and things missed in the drafting and passing of that legislation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109817","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Chair. It's a pleasure to be here at this committee. I have been on the fisheries committee for over 10 years now, so it's interesting sitting here. I thank Mr. Weiler for his time as chair of that committee. I have a number of questions on this bill and what's led up to this. Mr. Weiler, you said that since the passage of the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act, vessel ow","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4fee76e35cc9203fdf9d55926bd49a01da40f6df96ce6b12efab5286f6b75cb3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["499b2e9ac7dd9d00c5955fd3ee903900c2230832d32506162b54607742ca596d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00a99f46d84e1cdd383bcca0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109818,"date":"2026-06-16T20:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Clause 2 of this private member's bill adds wording that says, \"or allow the disposal\", so it reads: No person or ship shall dispose or allow the disposal Does \"allow the disposal\" refer only to the vessel owner, or does it refer to the vessel operator? Is it anyone who is observing that vessel, who is nearby and may see this happening? Would they potentially be as guilty of an offence by allowing the disposal to happen without reporting it or seeing it happen? If not, how is this bill going to avoid that situation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109818","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Clause 2 of this private member's bill adds wording that says, \"or allow the disposal\", so it reads: No person or ship shall dispose or allow the disposal Does \"allow the disposal\" refer only to the vessel owner, or does it refer to the vessel operator? Is it anyone who is observing that vessel, who is nearby and may see this happening? Would they potentially be as guilty of an offence by allowing","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d40a8e96910a97ebca713f7a058814bac3c6e49d850a51e112af24fcc3b197d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe8112fbd8e5ba23520fbf7c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109819,"date":"2026-06-16T20:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"The court hasn't interpreted your amendment yet. You're saying it's interpreted this in the current act as being disposal directly from a vessel. You're only hoping this would be interpreted the same way. There's no guarantee that it wouldn't implicate someone who observed a vessel being abandoned and didn't report it. Can you guarantee that that's not going to be the case?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109819","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The court hasn't interpreted your amendment yet. You're saying it's interpreted this in the current act as being disposal directly from a vessel. You're only hoping this would be interpreted the same way. There's no guarantee that it wouldn't implicate someone who observed a vessel being abandoned and didn't report it. Can you guarantee that that's not going to be the case?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc5dd5b4b4c39b0c002974c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109820,"date":"2026-06-16T20:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay. Thank you. I'll move on to clause 3, where you intend to change section 34.1 by saying: It is prohibited for an owner of a vessel to transfer ownership of it to a person, if the owner knows that—or is reckless as to whether—the person lacks the ability, resources or intent to maintain Can you describe to the committee how an owner who has a boat...? I come from the interior. There are lots of small vessels sold on the front lawn. Basically, the owners are tired of them. Say somebody driving by on the weekend stops in to buy it. How can this apply to a case like that, where the transaction may take place in less than an hour in somebody's backyard? That's a typical scenario, and I don't see how this bill will cover that. How can an owner—the current seller—possibly be expected to guarantee that the buyer is qualified?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109820","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. Thank you. I'll move on to clause 3, where you intend to change section 34.1 by saying: It is prohibited for an owner of a vessel to transfer ownership of it to a person, if the owner knows that—or is reckless as to whether—the person lacks the ability, resources or intent to maintain Can you describe to the committee how an owner who has a boat...? I come from the interior. There are lots o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af869b3851396e585ca2bce0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109821,"date":"2026-06-16T21:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. I'd like Mr. Weiler to clarify a bit further how a seller would provide the declaration, if you want to call it that, of the condition. You talked about many ways of doing this. I spent about 42 years in the boating industry, and there really is, probably, only one defensible way of declaring the condition of a boat, and that is through a proper marine survey. A marine survey can cost hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars, depending on the size of the vessel, and it's hundreds of dollars just for a small pleasure craft. One way that they can look at a vessel is by determining moisture content in encapsulated wood that may be rotting—they have a number of ways like that. For a vessel that's nearing the end of its life, how do you propose that a vessel owner would provide that declaration of condition? Further to that, how would a seller verify that the purchaser would be qualified to maintain it? Would that require checking financial status, knowledge of vessel maintenance or vessel operation requirements? Please expand on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109821","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I'd like Mr. Weiler to clarify a bit further how a seller would provide the declaration, if you want to call it that, of the condition. You talked about many ways of doing this. I spent about 42 years in the boating industry, and there really is, probably, only one defensible way of declaring the condition of a boat, and that is through a proper marine survey. A marine survey can cost h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb36fab699adb1d1ae89611938249857bf43d348e2ea925a60107faa3581cfe4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e6c684d23c30302b179b143e2d8f7bb03b3951f05f3fea6842438563629d1b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d81f64e3f2fec2596dc2724","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109822,"date":"2026-06-16T21:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Are you simply saying that the buyer has to sign something saying, \"I'm going to maintain this boat,\" and that's it? Is that as far as they have to go?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109822","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Are you simply saying that the buyer has to sign something saying, \"I'm going to maintain this boat,\" and that's it? Is that as far as they have to go?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["463589fa199e9ac1897fbba8f35bf11fdb199f86d74c501b1a605a9d2952390d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-caaa2101fb9b2b80484aa298","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109823,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"If they don't have the vessel operation or maintenance experience, if they're a first-time buyer, how can you expect someone to have that experience? I'll let you answer that first. Then I have another question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109823","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"If they don't have the vessel operation or maintenance experience, if they're a first-time buyer, how can you expect someone to have that experience? I'll let you answer that first. Then I have another question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034552","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Commercial ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034552","label":"Commercial ships","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2802c232bca428066969c2f1b132772621b054bb7c92cb36f8d77191680d099c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-890bf46be2c85ae0332bca3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109824,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Maybe you can just clarify.... You were talking about the intent of the bill. Is the intent of the bill, really, to track who actually owns the vessel, who is legally responsible for it, so that, if it is abandoned, someone can be sought out to be responsible for the cleanup? Is that an intent of the bill? That's not what you were talking about earlier, so please elaborate on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109824","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Maybe you can just clarify.... You were talking about the intent of the bill. Is the intent of the bill, really, to track who actually owns the vessel, who is legally responsible for it, so that, if it is abandoned, someone can be sought out to be responsible for the cleanup? Is that an intent of the bill? That's not what you were talking about earlier, so please elaborate on that.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d562f51aaacc79c1402d13c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109825,"date":"2026-06-16T21:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay. I'm really having difficulty seeing how this is workable in the long run, putting a lot of onus on sellers, who don't have that legal expertise. They simply want to sell an asset that is becoming a liability for them. If you could just elaborate again, how does the seller determine the qualifications of the buyer?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109825","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay. I'm really having difficulty seeing how this is workable in the long run, putting a lot of onus on sellers, who don't have that legal expertise. They simply want to sell an asset that is becoming a liability for them. If you could just elaborate again, how does the seller determine the qualifications of the buyer?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:115951","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trademarks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:115951","label":"Trademarks","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21872a93269e9f3176f875ade8e9c8522be2fd5943586c2bebd6b3dc633fdc54"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8157d7958d205363d6b3f0b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109826,"date":"2026-06-16T22:05:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Okay, so it can't be verified. We're all concerned about the potential damage caused by derelict, abandoned and wrecked vessels. We want to see this cleaned up, but we want to see it done efficiently and, most of all, effectively. Currently, the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act, or WAHVA, has loopholes. People are finding ways of avoiding accountability. If we're creating more legislation, we want to make sure that it is both enforceable and workable for average Canadians. I've heard two different pieces of testimony saying that there are concerns and challenges regarding the enforcement. I believe it was Ms. Verville, from the Coast Guard, who spoke about the challenges of enforcement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109826","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Okay, so it can't be verified. We're all concerned about the potential damage caused by derelict, abandoned and wrecked vessels. We want to see this cleaned up, but we want to see it done efficiently and, most of all, effectively. Currently, the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act, or WAHVA, has loopholes. People are finding ways of avoiding accountability. If we're creating more legislati","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d2d2e658f917aa233d28222b7d0be68034959a4395e5dea11aaca043295f057"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c88f1d7dd1d1825fd229572","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109827,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Would this bill improve that?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109827","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Would this bill improve that?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e188c7cfc7f80cf338ab5209","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109828,"date":"2026-06-16T22:10:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"It sounds like this could be a complicated question, so perhaps you could provide that in writing. I'd like to pass the rest of my time over to Mr. Leslie.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109828","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"It sounds like this could be a complicated question, so perhaps you could provide that in writing. I'd like to pass the rest of my time over to Mr. Leslie.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c8040b1f6ca47cf2936672e4b026414cb24e16e7889dd5e70eca7ff9d1629e5e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-086578467a37983fe915076a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109829,"date":"2026-06-16T22:30:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you, Mr. Ross. I'll continue, but I want to go back to statements about the MV Marathassa , the owner who was acquitted before the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act was passed. This happened in 2019. Ms. Lane, you said that this PMB is meant to prevent the repeat of the Marathassa , so why didn't the 2019 act include measures to prevent the repeat of that incident?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109829","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Ross. I'll continue, but I want to go back to statements about the MV Marathassa , the owner who was acquitted before the Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act was passed. This happened in 2019. Ms. Lane, you said that this PMB is meant to prevent the repeat of the Marathassa , so why didn't the 2019 act include measures to prevent the repeat of that incident?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d19b8fdbe1dc575821eed7d6dbab39c029114f57b0bf4bcb8d701b0bbbf65c45"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb98825fd505335ff01f89136f54ec4e8f0df0873ba26140bd9da666659d35cf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-585b238588cbcc31a6716199","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109830,"date":"2026-06-16T22:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"The owner of the Marathassa was acquitted in 2019, before the Hazardous Vessels Act was passed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109830","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The owner of the Marathassa was acquitted in 2019, before the Hazardous Vessels Act was passed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f061f77677f1a390bbcc349f979f23fd342ec39dacf836217a3b25b8389528f0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cad203386219a8b39dcceaf1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109831,"date":"2026-06-16T22:35:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Why didn't the act, in 2019, include measures to prevent a repeat of the Marathassa incident?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109831","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Why didn't the act, in 2019, include measures to prevent a repeat of the Marathassa incident?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4cc6d4eccd2281197929c417779b461e9053b70b69b2e8f2a620239b3d4ac69"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-396ee308936700254a8f2319","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109832,"date":"2026-06-16T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"However, clause 2 of this act is specific to that. How could you say this act doesn't apply to it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109832","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"However, clause 2 of this act is specific to that. How could you say this act doesn't apply to it?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d7bf7344eed12750ed55de9218711807d77da6dbdfa440aaf9e4b7bd619a8135"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5bf40058c4f969e851db2331","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109833,"date":"2026-06-16T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"The act doesn't say anything about.... The amendment reads: No person or ship shall dispose or allow the disposal of a substance in an area of the sea referred to in any of paragraphs","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109833","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"The act doesn't say anything about.... The amendment reads: No person or ship shall dispose or allow the disposal of a substance in an area of the sea referred to in any of paragraphs","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6390ab0aa91e6df05be20d3a77adb2ceea3383f87c668a7d6e6e77b10feba298"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87f6e8bc3b972d317631326a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109834,"date":"2026-06-16T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"Thank you. I think you've clarified that. I'll go to Ms. Verville from the Coast Guard, if I can. I think your department is more responsible for determining vessel seaworthiness and so on, and the regulations around that. Can you tell me what would be required of a vessel seller, in providing a defensible declaration of the vessel condition, that they would be subject to if this bill takes effect?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109834","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you. I think you've clarified that. I'll go to Ms. Verville from the Coast Guard, if I can. I think your department is more responsible for determining vessel seaworthiness and so on, and the regulations around that. Can you tell me what would be required of a vessel seller, in providing a defensible declaration of the vessel condition, that they would be subject to if this bill takes effect","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["72ad8e3c63005534659c8ef9df7020fbd5819028047f6c6a3c01d634e99a5c1c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["abe636349b385a86234a17012af7eb3f828191a2ff49a2755dad6f91a113e550"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cbb6372c9ce338dd51173aa1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109835,"date":"2026-06-16T22:45:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"There's a big gap in what's in this bill already, then. Thank you. I want to quickly go back to the issue of a vessel being purchased out of the U.S. How could a vessel seller be held accountable in the U.S.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109835","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"There's a big gap in what's in this bill already, then. Thank you. I want to quickly go back to the issue of a vessel being purchased out of the U.S. How could a vessel seller be held accountable in the U.S.?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58d330d81e97ea00a418cd5f8213192ed7f8def9f84c12cf6530f07f593846e9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1d90562e6c71970f15e5f59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109836,"date":"2026-06-16T22:50:00+00:00","title":"ENVI","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"ENVI","text":"That's only half of the equation. What if the sale takes place in the U.S.? That's what I'm trying to get at.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/ENVI/meeting-45/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109836","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"That's only half of the equation. What if the sale takes place in the U.S.? That's what I'm trying to get at.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Auctions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037387","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade shows","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037387","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Trade shows","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037387","label":"Trade shows","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083656","label":"Auctions","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19bf4a340380743519246e63794c092176e4ec5881e78626f463aa3ddd27cea8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9f77054937418e15855849d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087634,"date":"2026-06-17T21:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present two more petitions. These two are on the Liberals' failing firearms confiscation program.\n\n With nearly a $1-billion price tag, barely a third of that program is going to actually compensate firearms owners, while the rest will go into bureaucracy. Therefore, the undersigned citizens and permanent residents of Canada call upon the Government of Canada to end its assault on law-abiding firearms owners by scrapping the massively expensive and ineffective firearms confiscation program, and focus its attention on resources toward criminals and illegal firearms smuggling.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087634","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to present two more petitions. These two are on the Liberals' failing firearms confiscation program.\n\n With nearly a $1-billion price tag, barely a third of that program is going to actually compensate firearms owners, while the rest will go into bureaucracy. Therefore, the undersigned citizens and permanent residents of Canada call upon the Government of Canada to end it","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b979f732d5cb35f9cfcbeef1de57e2852067cf3ef77469c5969f81848a7ada84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["20da3d6706552586094fa2b02b0c4ca2cf3ff806aed1d3c433b134999ea671d8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4bee99a4c7d3f9a54cc3beb8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087633,"date":"2026-06-18T15:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mel Arnold","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member opposite for his speech and actually admitting in his words that we are in \"a bit of a challenging time for our country.\" His terminology for this may be a little bit off when we have seniors having to live in their vehicles because they cannot afford rent. We have record numbers of working people and young families relying on food banks just so that they can survive because of the ever-increasing cost of living over the last 10-plus years.\n\nI would like to ask the member if he would like to clarify for this House, and for Canadians, which government has been in power for the last 10, now almost 11 years, I guess, and is responsible for this challenging time, as he put it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087633","member_id":"bc-mp-89294","member_name":"Mel Arnold","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank the member opposite for his speech and actually admitting in his words that we are in \"a bit of a challenging time for our country.\" His terminology for this may be a little bit off when we have seniors having to live in their vehicles because they cannot afford rent. We have record numbers of working people and young families relying on food banks just so that they can surviv","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9e1c4728534a05a4f79cd482f26d67f98515287ec37051e7dc19b1594b96d1eb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2f3a2e5e9e6c54558f4fc10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77912,"date":"2026-02-03T19:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jonathan Wilkinson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today in solidarity with my constituents of North Vancouver—Capilano, which is home to a strong and vibrant Iranian Canadian community, to unequivocally condemn the Iranian regime's unjustifiable killing of thousands of peaceful civilian protesters. \n\nThe Iranian regime must halt its horrific repression and intimidation, and I call on the regime to respect the rights of its citizens. \n\nI want to recognize the extraordinary courage of Iranian people both in Iran and here in Canada, who continue to stand up for fundamental rights and freedoms despite the regime's ongoing brutality. Canada has been firm and steadfast in its support for the Iranian people and in its opposition to the actions being taken by the regime. \n\nI thank the people of Iran and Iranian Canadians for their bravery. I am inspired by their strength and their fight to shape a peaceful and democratic future for Iran. Canadians stand with them at this enormously difficult time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77912","member_id":"bc-mp-89300","member_name":"Jonathan Wilkinson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today in solidarity with my constituents of North Vancouver—Capilano, which is home to a strong and vibrant Iranian Canadian community, to unequivocally condemn the Iranian regime's unjustifiable killing of thousands of peaceful civilian protesters. \n\nThe Iranian regime must halt its horrific repression and intimidation, and I call on the regime to respect the rights of its cit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d176a8e25e59075005d927fd0202f559bda6f4c2787780e350a0f4f8e793753"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-776c5bc0e0c9043b7b33ead1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083794,"date":"2026-06-02T21:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jonathan Wilkinson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise in the House today to provide some final words after almost 11 years in this place. I want to begin by acknowledging my colleagues on both sides of the aisle, as well as the many dedicated public servants and staffers with whom I have had the privilege to work during my time here.\n\nWhile I know there are some people in all parties who cannot get past the, at times, partisan nature of politics, I have made many friends across the aisle during my time here, folks who are here to serve their constituents, their province and their country but who can also be open to speaking to and even having fun with people of differing perspectives. Honestly, the fact that many of us actually like each other as people across the aisle is something that Canadians should see more often.\n\nI fully recognize that many people have devoted a significant part of their professional lives to building a better Canada and a better world.\n\nAll members of the chamber have been fortunate to have been allowed to play a role in shaping public policy in this country and internationally. It is a privilege that very few folks enjoy.\n\nBefore getting into policy issues, I want to point out that, in the House, we all give a lot, but we also receive a lot.\n\n One of the things I am particularly grateful for is having had the opportunity to learn Canada's other official language. Although my French is far from perfect, this skill I have acquired here is a great gift.\n\nWhen I left the private sector to run for office, many people in the business community thought I was mad, but it has been the most rewarding experience of my life. As an MP and as a minister at DFO, at Environment Canada and at Natural Resources Canada, I have often said I had truly the best job in Canada. As MPs, we know well that the impact we can have on constituents' lives can at times be profound, but it can also be profoundly rewarding.\n\n I do not typically like to use the word \"proud\", as the people who have worked with me know, but today I will. Over nearly 11 years in government, I am proud of several things that I, my team and departments, and government as a whole, helped to accomplish.\n\n A few of the highlights include developing Canada's strengthened climate plan, the healthy environment and healthy economy, the first plan in Canadian history to show in detail not only how we could achieve a climate target but how we could exceed one; launching Canada's first critical minerals strategy and the investment tax credit regime to advance clean energy development; establishing what I believe will be transformational in this country, the indigenous loan guarantee program; catalyzing the full modernization of Canada's aging Coast Guard fleet; creating the B.C. salmon restoration and innovation fund to address the decline of wild Pacific salmon, which is a critical issue in British Columbia; and expanding marine protected areas from 1% to over 14% during my time as minister of fisheries.\n\nEvery member of the House will have heard many times people asking why they should engage in the political process, often saying that individuals cannot make a difference. That attitude is particularly prominent these days with young people. However, I would say, in my experience, that this is simply not true. I entered politics over a decade ago to tackle climate change in a way that creates economic opportunity and is not simply about sacrifice. Over that time, working alongside colleagues, I have had the chance to make meaningful and, I believe, lasting contributions to climate policy that builds a strong future economy.\n\nIndividuals can make a difference through their words and through their actions. That is a message I often share with young people, whether in schools, through my youth council or in communities across the country, many of whom presently feel the system does not work for them. On the climate issue that brought me into politics, while today's geopolitical climate may suggest that progress has slowed, I remain optimistic that Canada, Europe and the world will meet this challenge.\n\nClimate change is not going away. It is a scientific reality, with human and economic impacts that are growing every year.\n\nClimate change is a major challenge, but addressing it and building a strong economy for the future can and indeed must go hand in hand. Looking at actual global trends rather than simply rhetoric, it is clear that the world is moving to a lower-carbon future and that many countries, China in particular, have explicit economic strategies to accelerate the energy transition.\n\n Progress is being made, albeit more slowly than science suggests we need. Growth in energy-related CO2 emissions is continuing to decouple from global economic growth. Very importantly, climate progress is, increasingly, not simply being driven by government policy. It is being driven by technology. Simply put, many low-carbon energy technologies are now cheaper and often much better than conventional alternatives, and this is something we should all celebrate. Climate change and its impacts are a matter of science, not politics. How we choose to respond remains a fundamentally political decision, one that requires foresight, thoughtfulness and courage.\n\nThe past 11 years have been enormously rewarding, and I am grateful for the opportunity to continue serving this country in a new capacity, as the Prime Minister has asked me to take on the role of Canada's ambassador to the European Union.\n\nI accepted this position for the same reason I entered politics: a commitment to Canada and a belief that this is where I can make the greatest contribution right now.\n\nThe Prime Minister has an ambitious vision for what this partnership can become. My role will be to help implement that vision and ensure that it delivers concrete results for all parties.\n\n I love this country more than I can fully express. Canada is the best country in the world, not because we are perfect but because we face our flaws and choose again and again to do better. Ours is a story of resilience, of expanding rights and of building a more inclusive and just society. Whether that story continues is up to us and our willingness to stand up for what we believe in, defend democracy, advance reconciliation, confront climate change and build an economy that works for everyone.\n\n Serving as a member of Parliament and a minister has been the privilege of my life. Serving in my new role will be a different kind of privilege, one that I approach with the same sense of duty and determination.\n\nI will conclude by waxing a bit philosophical. I think most of my staff who are here will probably find that funny. I believe we are capable as a species of enlightened self-interest. In this regard, acting on climate change is firmly in our collective self-interest. However, I also believe that many of us are also very much capable of altruism, of thinking not only about how building a better community or helping those less fortunate may benefit us in the longer term but actually also about how we are morally obligated in the direction of social justice. To all people in and outside the House, I say that we can indeed work to build a better and more just world if only we have the courage and the will to try.\n\nIn this vein, I will conclude by quoting the words of William Blake, taken from his poem Jerusalem. I freely admit that I took these lines from the conclusion of speeches by the great Tommy Douglas. As a Saskatchewanian originally, and as someone who actually watched him in person and met him as a young person, I think Tommy would think that is just fine. These lines, I think, capture the essence of a commitment to community and to public service, which is, I believe, about striving each and every day to make this country and this world a better place in which to live.\n\nBlake wrote:\n\nI will not cease from Mental Fight,Nor shall my sword sleep in my hand:Till we have built Jerusalem,In Englands green & pleasant Land.\n\nIt has been a pleasure and an honour to get to know and work with all of my colleagues.\n\nI look forward to seeing many of them in Brussels.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083794","member_id":"bc-mp-89300","member_name":"Jonathan Wilkinson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise in the House today to provide some final words after almost 11 years in this place. I want to begin by acknowledging my colleagues on both sides of the aisle, as well as the many dedicated public servants and staffers with whom I have had the privilege to work during my time here.\n\nWhile I know there are some people in all parties who cannot get past the, at times, partisan nat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3f9ec124434adceecbd5cb051c2fdbc16991da24f35100df607de61a2c0a273"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4e9457faa2a759b0538118d950cb585887caba9302cbf49a5dbb50866240bea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea548ea49bc2fad9d21c6143","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083795,"date":"2026-06-02T22:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jonathan Wilkinson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is very nice, and it does give me an opportunity to give a few thanks.\n\nI would start by thanking the dedicated public servants who worked with me in various departments, and in particular the deputy ministers, who, honestly, were all excellent folks: Catherine Blewett at Fisheries, Stephen Lucas, John Moffat, Chris Hogan at Environment Canada, J.F. Tremblay, John Hannaford, Mollie Johnson, Michael Vandergrift and Jeff Labonté at Natural Resources Canada. Canada should be very comforted and proud that we have such amazing public servants. \n\nI thank my constituency staff. I often said, no offence to the other members in this place, but they ran one of the best constituency offices in the country, certainly the director, who has been long serving there, Cynthia Bunbury, and the many volunteers in my riding, in particular Duncan Frostick and Kevin Evans, who were great sources of guidance for me.\n\n Of course, I thank the folks who worked in my offices here in Ottawa and the chiefs of staff I have had: Marlo Reynolds, Claire Seaborn, Alexis McIntyre, Kyle Harrietha and a whole range of amazing staff, many of whom have chosen to be here today.\n\nI thank Laura Mitchell, who has been with me for 10 years, and a number of other folks who came with me from North Vancouver. I thank Richard, Kieran, Sandy, who ran all of Atlantic Canada for me very ably, and Erin Flanagan. I hope I am not missing somebody. \n\nI thank Sabrina Kim, who sometimes drove me crazy, but she was one of the best communications directors I had. \n\nIt is because of folks like that that we are able to actually do our jobs in this place, and I was very fortunate to have amazingly dedicated, talented people. \n\n Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083795","member_id":"bc-mp-89300","member_name":"Jonathan Wilkinson","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is very nice, and it does give me an opportunity to give a few thanks.\n\nI would start by thanking the dedicated public servants who worked with me in various departments, and in particular the deputy ministers, who, honestly, were all excellent folks: Catherine Blewett at Fisheries, Stephen Lucas, John Moffat, Chris Hogan at Environment Canada, J.F. Tremblay, John Hannaford, Moll","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f18d933ef2c6b7dd254d4b8907f43c9acf88f42bf64d87d07087be327136f53"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4dc0a67ed43c1a03c68eaee8184ad1cf01b8d06817d6ed5c944b5ff8eb6e0656"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6df05b96c5a44da2f0ae1253","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77913,"date":"2026-02-03T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this year's theme for International Development Week is \"prosperity through partnership\". Canadians are strong when we work together and work with others. While our development efforts are grounded in fighting poverty and advancing inclusive growth, they can also lay the groundwork for long-term mutual prosperity. I saw this myself in Indonesia, where decades of development co-operation have helped cut poverty by half while paving the path to a new trade agreement that will benefit Canadians and Indonesians alike.\n\nThis is how we create opportunity: by building prosperity through partnership.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77913","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this year's theme for International Development Week is \"prosperity through partnership\". Canadians are strong when we work together and work with others. While our development efforts are grounded in fighting poverty and advancing inclusive growth, they can also lay the groundwork for long-term mutual prosperity. I saw this myself in Indonesia, where decades of development co-operati","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9cee2b148bb56e60ebb9820213d0948b4b2a84c3fe0256e42ab8d5dc1bf0919b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5da2a8f62a14fa857fcc87a982e69cd2a396dab4284ed03427527a40cc770f1b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-896a4b4e13723266758481f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77914,"date":"2026-02-03T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, addressing the roots of conflict and instability abroad helps reduce the risks Canadians face here at home. Investing in development helps build stronger allies, new trading partners and new markets for Canadian businesses. Our government is making generational investments to strengthen the Canadian economy, help Canadians get ahead and build a more resilient future for our country. Our development efforts are a critical part of that by strengthening our international partnerships and supporting a more peaceful, stable and prosperous world.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77914","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, addressing the roots of conflict and instability abroad helps reduce the risks Canadians face here at home. Investing in development helps build stronger allies, new trading partners and new markets for Canadian businesses. Our government is making generational investments to strengthen the Canadian economy, help Canadians get ahead and build a more resilient future for our country. O","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b2821224cc9ebf2aebfd7e46d064bc7ece1bf5a7a28c838bf2e40128064eb988"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b5842234c34283b664de699820864018f9593ff48b3ff5cf50482b9237598d2e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-92bbf20e086cabc0db47c21e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287873,"date":"2026-02-10T17:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak about a matter that is of deep and pressing concern to my constituents in Surrey Centre, as well as to those living in the Lower Mainland region in my home province.\n\nThe government's first priority is to protect Canadians and their communities. We are deeply concerned about the reports of people in B.C, in Ontario and across Canada who have been targeted by extortion, threats and violence. These types of crimes are insidious. They sow fear in our communities and prevent hard-working Canadians from running their businesses and sleeping soundly at night.\n\nThis is why we are working with a wide range of stakeholders and law enforcement to ensure that we address these issues head-on. Our government has tabled over six major public safety and criminal justice bills, legislation that is specifically designed to crack down on violent and repeat offenders, strengthen sentencing and modernize Canada's Criminal Code. This is why I find it surprising that the Conservatives have chosen this as their motion for today. Rather than fast-tracking the legislation that premiers, law enforcement, municipalities, police chiefs and police associations across the country have all called on Parliament to pass urgently, the Conservatives constantly delay and obstruct the committee and the House.\n\nBill C-2 and Bill C-12 will bolster Canada's law enforcement tool kit with critical assets, like lawful access, to combat transnational organized crime. For those who might not know what lawful access is, it is the ability to catch digital phone systems like WhatsApp and Signal and track them down to the subscriber.\n\n In fact, there is nothing in the Conservative motion today that has not already been addressed or tabled in the House, or that is not categorically false.\n\nBill C-14, the bail and sentencing reform act, would bring in stricter bail laws to address violent and repeat offending and organized crime, and tougher sentencing laws for serious and violent crimes, including extortion. Combined, Bill C-2, Bill C-12 and Bill C-14 would crack down on intimidation and violence by using tools like lawful access, and reduce risks to victims and witnesses.\n\nIn addition to this legislation, we have held summits on extortion in collaboration with the Government of British Columbia and the Government of Ontario. These summits were a strong, collaborative effort, bringing together federal and provincial governments, local law enforcement and the RCMP to advance a joint response to extortion cases.\n\nIn fact, one of the few parties that have not been willing to collaborate is that of the sponsor of today's motion. Instead, they prefer to mislead Canadians by mis-characterizing our justice system. For instance, this motion calls to bar non-citizens convicted of serious crimes from making refugee claims. First of all, Canadians cannot make refugee claims, so it sounds pretty odd.\n\nSerious criminality is already grounds for inadmissibility for claims to the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada. Asylum claims do not and will not prevent criminals from being punished to the fullest extent of the law. The minute the CBSA suspects someone of serious criminality, like extortion or firearms offences, it suspends their refugee claim. Everyone other than the Conservatives knows a person cannot claim asylum if they are being investigated for serious criminality.\n\nWhile Conservatives continue to rely on slogans and ideological proposals, our government is delivering thoughtful, targeted reforms to strengthen public safety and protect Canadians. We have announced millions in funding through Canada's border plan for the creation of regional integrated drug enforcement teams, which will bring together law and border enforcement resources from multiple agencies and jurisdictions to fight organized drug crime and combat extortion. We have announced additional funding to help bolster the work of local law enforcement to combat extortion, support and provide services to victims and build on efforts already under way through local police task forces in Peel Region and in British Columbia.\n\n The CBSA is committed to supporting the task force through the removal of inadmissible foreign nationals involved in extortion and other serious criminal offences.\n\nFurther, because we know that preventing crime in the long term means targeting its roots, we have allocated $390 million over five years to support provinces and territories with prevention programs and law enforcement activities through the initiative to take action against gun and gang violence. Our government is also providing $250 million through the building safer communities fund directly to municipalities and indigenous communities to bolster gang prevention programming and counter the social conditions that lead to criminality.\n\n These actions build on the national coordination and support team, which was established by the RCMP in February 2024 as a nationwide alliance supporting police and helping to coordinate and advance extortion investigations across Canada. Through the national coordination and support team, the RCMP is working with police departments across Canada and internationally to address extortion and violent incidences.\n\nIn response to the call for more federal resources to address the extortion situation in Surrey, the RCMP is providing 20 additional federal officers and helicopter resources to strengthen local operational capacity. As I have made clear, we are collaborating across all levels of jurisdiction to combat extortion and help those who have been affected. We are also investing in an additional 1,000 new RCMP and 1,000 new CBSA personnel. This funding comes from budget 2025, which commits over $1.8 billion over four years to strengthen federal law enforcement.\n\nTo ensure that members in our communities feel safe, we have introduced legislation; made significant federal investments in enhancing federal law enforcement capacity, directly supporting provincial and locally led efforts; and continued to meet with affected communities. We are using all our tools to crack down on crime and protect our communities.\n\nI would like to take this time to recognize the tireless work that our officers in the RCMP and CBSA do each and every day. If someone receives threats, we urge them not to comply with demands and to report the incident to their local police of jurisdiction. All of us have a right to live and work free of threats and intimidation. We will continue to work together with all levels of government and law enforcement to ensure that all Canadians have safe communities in which to live, work and raise their families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287873","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak about a matter that is of deep and pressing concern to my constituents in Surrey Centre, as well as to those living in the Lower Mainland region in my home province.\n\nThe government's first priority is to protect Canadians and their communities. We are deeply concerned about the reports of people in B.C, in Ontario and across Canada who have been ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8052ffcb5884618a3faab3abcfd6b939826b49ddbcd91893b1b9af0f13c8b44a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b46bb5cdaafd48b47672b38f03487c59c654e227b27ce81793de24c092cc05a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7657b7e7e475440d4f50124","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287874,"date":"2026-02-10T17:33:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I was able to go to Winnipeg to speak to people who have been victims of extortion or who are getting threats.\n\nLet me be clear that, if Bill C-2 had passed, if we had legislation on lawful access, we would not have police and prosecution departments working four to six months to get production orders to find out the source of a threatening call. If we were prioritizing that rather than making slogans and having opposition day motions like we are today, we would have a tool the police could immediately use to find out, when someone gets a threatening extortion call, who is making that call. Then the next level of action could be taken to wiretap, surveil or do other things.\n\nWhen we have legislation that was created so far in the past that it predates cellphones, we need to modernize it to this date and time so we can capture those who are extorting our vulnerable citizens.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287874","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I was able to go to Winnipeg to speak to people who have been victims of extortion or who are getting threats.\n\nLet me be clear that, if Bill C-2 had passed, if we had legislation on lawful access, we would not have police and prosecution departments working four to six months to get production orders to find out the source of a threatening call. If we were prioritizing that rather th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eab8c70817a668e256997bf5ae1aba4b8e2353b57dd8c96d1595858be0d2345b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e4cd2b1f18f9da1a99ece7e8e7fe909d968ed0cdbbe6f6c66842c1af5a8aa272"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7980f9a715208fbd5f935f87","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287875,"date":"2026-02-10T17:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the funny thing is that, in modernizing our legal system, most of the legislation we have had to deal with is because of the violations of the previous government. The Supreme Court gave ruling after ruling saying that all the legislation the Conservatives passed was invalid, was not just and does not comply with our charter. Over the last 10 years, we have been fixing all the Conservatives' errors.\n\nCrime is actually on the decline in Canada. I think major serious crime is on the decline. The Liberal government will continue to work hard to address the root causes and make Canada a safer, more compliant place, where our citizens can live freely, free of crime and free of threats of extortion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287875","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the funny thing is that, in modernizing our legal system, most of the legislation we have had to deal with is because of the violations of the previous government. The Supreme Court gave ruling after ruling saying that all the legislation the Conservatives passed was invalid, was not just and does not comply with our charter. Over the last 10 years, we have been fixing all the Conserv","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0a78a266b16a10e096a37f475498926fcab5ca3a4bcb4a2edd08032760310717"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d6fb8565862167c6d722b580644de05ee8ebcff3e1b13ff73d80fd0bc69fe8e1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2040b100cfcb9d5826b8c98a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287876,"date":"2026-02-10T17:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think the delays, in the criminal aspect, have zero weight, because immediately upon the suspicion that someone is involved in criminal activity, the asylum proceedings suspend. The CBSA will not pursue those. The CBSA goes through the claimant's criminal actions, so it does not affect it. \n\nWhen it comes to anybody who has been living over a year in Canada, under the new bill, if it passes the Senate, comes back here and we expeditiously pass it, they would be ineligible for asylum. That would reduce the timelines in general, but when it comes to anybody involved in serious criminality, the asylum process would not be a hindrance to their criminal trial. It gets suspended. Once their sentencing is done, they would be deported as needed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287876","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think the delays, in the criminal aspect, have zero weight, because immediately upon the suspicion that someone is involved in criminal activity, the asylum proceedings suspend. The CBSA will not pursue those. The CBSA goes through the claimant's criminal actions, so it does not affect it. \n\nWhen it comes to anybody who has been living over a year in Canada, under the new bill, if i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2f4756db73d20e843a592de7adbc36f031fc0a459192bc49f6e012bcb4bc7fcd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fcf099d34d6af082df7044084e8bf2d0840a7c7a1082dd20e628074eaa0efdca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1073594f87d70ea77221c96","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287877,"date":"2026-02-10T17:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we need to pass Bill C-2 immediately so that we can give the tools to our law enforcement to catch the extortionists, who are violating our homes and our communities. I urge, on a non-partisan basis, all parties to please enforce this and pass this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287877","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we need to pass Bill C-2 immediately so that we can give the tools to our law enforcement to catch the extortionists, who are violating our homes and our communities. I urge, on a non-partisan basis, all parties to please enforce this and pass this bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f2f67322fc52a6d3727ab6cd916263ccfd053285e27f91f3c938e86824cea4b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5e0045f02b48b96e991474f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287878,"date":"2026-02-10T19:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I find it pretty amazing that legislators on the other side do not know the legislation that is already here. Nobody can claim asylum when they are charged. It gets suspended. They go to trial, they get sentenced and they get deported. They cannot claim asylum when they are charged. That was the law even before the legislation before the House, which is going to make it more restrictive and even more onerous for those who commit extortion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287878","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I find it pretty amazing that legislators on the other side do not know the legislation that is already here. Nobody can claim asylum when they are charged. It gets suspended. They go to trial, they get sentenced and they get deported. They cannot claim asylum when they are charged. That was the law even before the legislation before the House, which is going to make it more restricti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6dd60660882a0ff0053c26c1c4f7b608d7c61c0ce946f03f0d7c622264e58868"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["591b4ef93b37c33274abeabd953b3553194c729bd763399fad95fcb61cf4420a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a53d8902651b74f42f4ef3b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287879,"date":"2026-02-10T19:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when I speak to the police chief in that jurisdiction, when I speak to the mayor in that jurisdiction and when I speak to the premier of that province, they ask, can I get the Conservatives to pass Bill C-2? Can I get lawful access passed? Can I get them to pass the bills in the House? They do not want this obstruction.\n\nI urge the Conservatives to support all this legislation so we can give the police the tools they need to prosecute, enforce the laws of this land and kick these extortionists out.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-83/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287879","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when I speak to the police chief in that jurisdiction, when I speak to the mayor in that jurisdiction and when I speak to the premier of that province, they ask, can I get the Conservatives to pass Bill C-2? Can I get lawful access passed? Can I get them to pass the bills in the House? They do not want this obstruction.\n\nI urge the Conservatives to support all this legislation so we c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6646a527f16a66f1c93e218","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287872,"date":"2026-02-12T20:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the premier of the province, the mayor of Abbotsford and the police chief of Abbotsford have all said to please go across party lines to get Bill C-2, Bill C-12 and Bill C-14 passed. \n\nI used to think that maybe it is obstruction that Conservatives are doing, but I really think they do not even read the bills. If they read the bills, they would know that it would be very impactful to pass them, legislate them and get the tools to the police, who need them right away.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-85/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287872","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the premier of the province, the mayor of Abbotsford and the police chief of Abbotsford have all said to please go across party lines to get Bill C-2, Bill C-12 and Bill C-14 passed. \n\nI used to think that maybe it is obstruction that Conservatives are doing, but I really think they do not even read the bills. If they read the bills, they would know that it would be very impactful to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["39d9719ee6a74368c4be76285fa9b628ddd193619365e767f9f78952d04ba0fc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d55d1810a98ddfd47f54d1db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":426114,"date":"2026-04-17T16:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Speaker, when I speak to British Columbians, including Rachel from my riding, they thank me for the Canada child benefit. Rachel also remembers that when the program was under the Conservatives, she had to pay taxes on it when it came to April. She also thanks me for the dental benefit that is helping her and her children get dental care. She is also looking forward to our affordability measure that is coming out for her groceries in June. In addition to that, the 10¢ tax relief at the gas pump is helpful.\n\n We are listening to Canadians, and they are getting what they need. The Conservatives are not listening to Canadians and should—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-105/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:426114","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Speaker, when I speak to British Columbians, including Rachel from my riding, they thank me for the Canada child benefit. Rachel also remembers that when the program was under the Conservatives, she had to pay taxes on it when it came to April. She also thanks me for the dental benefit that is helping her and her children get dental care. She is also looking forward to our affordability measure th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","label":"Oral health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","label":"Oral health","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8309b4d86a6b05a67c57cd5f238c9741ccee698dd40ad81bd35ce4f45465374f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["529e8dbffa6b8864af33899ae17b6de8e5cdf53ff05b093a0b810ff841bebbd7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7dd86f14645bf7b41860b12","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300695,"date":"2026-04-20T17:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to have the opportunity today to speak about Bill C-22, the lawful access bill. There is no issue more pressing in the law enforcement legal framework than lawful access, a tool that is essential for police and prosecution to do the work to expeditiously catch people accused of many violent crimes.\n\nThe world around us is becoming increasingly digital and networked. Much of our day-to-day business communication and overall lives relies on the Internet. Smart phones, emails and instant messaging apps easily and instantly transcend provincial and national borders. Unfortunately, this also means that malicious actors, such as organized crime groups and violent extremists, can exploit the borderless nature of cyberspace for their own benefit. Canada's law enforcement agencies and CSIS need modern tools to help keep communities safe. We must close the capacity gap in current legislation that prevents law enforcement and CSIS from having lawful access to data, and must ensure that they can properly execute their mandates and protect Canadians.\n\n\"Lawful access\" is a term we will hear a lot in association with the bill, but let us be clear what it really means. Lawful access covers the tools and authorities used to legally obtain certain information, data or communication during investigations. This information is often essential to generating leads on national security threats and serious criminal activities, such as extortion and organized crime, as well as to identifying and prosecuting the people involved.\n\nFor decades, law enforcement and CSIS have had to operate without a legal framework requiring electronic service providers, ESPs, to develop and maintain lawful access capabilities. The current legal framework dates from before the invention of cellphones and has not kept pace with the rapid advances in technology. This is important because law enforcement and intelligence investigators need basic subscriber information, such as a legal name or an address, to identify or exclude suspects, particularly during preliminary stages.\n\nBill C-22 would establish a legal framework requiring electronic service providers to have the capability to respond to legally authorized requests, such as a warrant or a production order, while respecting protecting privacy interests and fundamental rights. It would introduce provisions to support law enforcement as it cracks down on crime in an increasingly complex technological landscape where the vast majority of evidence is online or electronic.\n\n Law enforcement groups have sounded the alarm about the obstacles they encounter in their investigations. For instance, imagine a person getting a call from an extortionist demanding money and threatening their family if they do not pay. They call 911, tell the police who called and show them the messages they received. Under the current framework, it would take weeks or even months for the police to find out basic information such as who or where the call came from.\n\nThis is just one example of the many challenges law enforcement officials face in obtaining the information they need. Often they do not know which service provider holds the customer account associated with the subscriber information, which also means they do not know whom to serve with a production order. This challenge currently stalls and delays real-world investigations. In many cases, law enforcement is required to seek multiple judicial authorizations to seek very basic information from different service providers, just to confirm which service provider's phone number or IP address the call was made from.\n\nThe current framework causes significant, unnecessary and potentially harmful delays. Timely access to the basic information is crucial in all stages of an investigation and can mean the difference between securing evidence and allowing criminals to slip through law enforcement's fingers.\n\nHere is another example. Police are aware that a provider holds certain information, but the company cannot provide it because their systems do not possess the capability to do so, as there is no legal requirement to carry such capabilities. We have heard many stories of law enforcement tracking a missing child or attempting to stop a terrorist attack, knowing which service provider to obtain the information from but being stonewalled by the provider's lack of lawful access capabilities.\n\n We cannot hope to fully protect Canadians and our communities if law enforcement and CSIS are unable to do their jobs. For this reason, Bill C-22 would introduce new legislation to close that gap, whereby certain ESPs would need to develop and maintain the technological capabilities to respond to production orders. To be clear, this aspect of the legislation intentionally and explicitly would not allow for backdoor access or any direct access for law enforcement or CSIS into electronic service provider systems. A legal authority to access that information would still always be required.\n\n Bill C-22 proposes two ways by which an ESP would be asked to develop and maintain lawful access capabilities. First, those designated as core providers, such as traditional telecom companies, would have to abide by specific requirements set out in regulations. Second, the Minister of Public Safety could issue a ministerial order to develop specific capabilities based on operational needs as new technologies develop.\n\nWe have heard the concerns from parliamentarians and stakeholders around privacy and oversight. I want to reassure Canadians that Bill C-22 includes safeguards so ESPs would not have to abide by any demands that would introduce systemic vulnerabilities in electronic protections, such as encryption breaking or backdoor access. This would also require that the Minister of Public Safety obtain the approval of the intelligence commissioner before a ministerial order is valid, and it would be subject to further review by the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency.\n\n Bill C-22 is about removing harmful barriers that impede active investigations and delay justice as well as put Canadians in harm's way. It is about bringing our legislation up to date with modern technologies and those of our closest allies and partners. It is about ensuring that alleged extortionists, child predators, cybercriminals, hostile state actors and organized criminal networks have nowhere to hide.\n\nLaw enforcement leaders have been very clear with us. I will quote the National Police Federation, which said, \"For frontline police officers, the ability to lawfully identify who owns an online account is often the first step in investigating crimes such as extortion, child sexual exploitation, organized crime, violent offences, and national security threats. Bill C-22 will help ensure that longstanding court orders and warrants remain effective in a modern digital environment.\" They need us to act now to eliminate these gaps in our legislation. I am urging hon. members to support the bill for the crucial public safety measure it would be.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300695","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to have the opportunity today to speak about Bill C-22, the lawful access bill. There is no issue more pressing in the law enforcement legal framework than lawful access, a tool that is essential for police and prosecution to do the work to expeditiously catch people accused of many violent crimes.\n\nThe world around us is becoming increasingly digital and networked. Much ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["046204182bbf304481cf2d705ee5ba34d1a143ccde8937f793effdebf855b46a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0060d92cfd777c5258aa5cd1af58d30e1adb1c27a8a47087a69f5fa4a3544d4b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d3ddebdcc3ce81e1adefd4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300696,"date":"2026-04-20T17:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, we could have amended Bill C-2. It was the second bill introduced in the current session of the House, which shows the importance the government places on law enforcement and getting the tools that are needed. It was after those consultations that the government listened to, and that is why we have Bill C-22 now. Therefore, now that those consultations have been done, I urge that we pass the bill as fast as possible so we give the tools to law enforcement agencies.\n\n I also met with the commissioner, the deputy commissioner and the regional police chiefs of all the areas around my riding, and all of them have stated that we need lawful access and need it now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300696","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, we could have amended Bill C-2. It was the second bill introduced in the current session of the House, which shows the importance the government places on law enforcement and getting the tools that are needed. It was after those consultations that the government listened to, and that is why we have Bill C-22 now. Therefore, now that those consultations have been done, I urge that we p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d3687015f1e6c9fb2256578b96e7f3fbc07595f9260916429cdc70d83a908993"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5f955087f08153e0549e1888f833fa1e73e1fb37d058a9f321cedd306e0e269b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eaafafa015f1c897a8f6881d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300697,"date":"2026-04-20T17:42:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the threshold is to get subscriber information. The first step when someone gets a call or a threat is to find out who the number belongs to. It used to be very easy. We could pick up a phone book-like thing in the library that had every number in it. It used to be published every year. When somebody called, we could tell where the number came from. The world has changed drastically from that. We are now on VPNs. Even normal office phones are. Land lines do not actually communicate with a direct line. They go over the Internet.\n\nGetting the subscriber information is the first and fundamental step so law enforcement can take subsequent steps to get production orders to tap phones. Those would come after, but the initial step of finding out who is calling, where the information is coming from, is vital.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300697","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the threshold is to get subscriber information. The first step when someone gets a call or a threat is to find out who the number belongs to. It used to be very easy. We could pick up a phone book-like thing in the library that had every number in it. It used to be published every year. When somebody called, we could tell where the number came from. The world has changed drastically f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c70dc98581f70810b2ead17500b3cff04961a277937874584bd3adf02fc1f833"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d2aa3da522de7fa3c247624bfc8d0b22594bbc9495a8ea2f4cabe42c80b13cc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-630e96b5f34448d2e5f39d40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300698,"date":"2026-04-20T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a very valid question. It is a big concern. People facing extortion threats are wondering why it takes the police so long to find out who is responsible, when sometimes in the private sector they may be able to get a private investigation or a digital firm to find out where the call was coming from.\n\nUnfortunately, law enforcement has been handicapped without those capabilities. It has asked for the bill to pass immediately, as fast as possible, as the threat is really hindering people's lives. Normal business people are not able to go out. They live in fear. It is finally coming to fruition, and I am hopeful they will be able to live their lives in a peaceful manner.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300698","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a very valid question. It is a big concern. People facing extortion threats are wondering why it takes the police so long to find out who is responsible, when sometimes in the private sector they may be able to get a private investigation or a digital firm to find out where the call was coming from.\n\nUnfortunately, law enforcement has been handicapped without those capabilitie","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a7548afb0d44b957464e67743f9ddf9fb5e95a7d7e25091eaa47097df0bd01f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e99f314047f40ddc1973bd8f2262bcf26caf5e17cac47fa3ed49c43605be4b39"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9079d65ff69fd8f5343e4b58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300699,"date":"2026-04-20T17:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think the minister did a very good job in getting consultation from a broad sector of stakeholders, such as from law enforcement and the prosecutor's office. One of our former colleagues, from Victoria, gave the NDP's insight formally. I think there was broad consultation. I am sure if the Privacy Commissioner has some concerns, they are able to table their opinions as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300699","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think the minister did a very good job in getting consultation from a broad sector of stakeholders, such as from law enforcement and the prosecutor's office. One of our former colleagues, from Victoria, gave the NDP's insight formally. I think there was broad consultation. I am sure if the Privacy Commissioner has some concerns, they are able to table their opinions as well.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["86a3240bc991adda9c5f5c0c084e5b7ab1208ea0880ab45d62ebaa6d54f17bfd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d6da25865587c17432de26c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300700,"date":"2026-04-20T19:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada's support for the people of Sudan has been unwavering since the beginning of the conflict. Last week, our government announced more than $120 million in new assistance to support the people of Sudan and others across the region. This is about getting life-saving support to those who need it most. It underscores Canada's commitment to addressing one of the world's worst humanitarian crises. \n\nThe people of Sudan deserve protection, dignity and a path back to stability. Canada will continue to press for the conditions that make that possible.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300700","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada's support for the people of Sudan has been unwavering since the beginning of the conflict. Last week, our government announced more than $120 million in new assistance to support the people of Sudan and others across the region. This is about getting life-saving support to those who need it most. It underscores Canada's commitment to addressing one of the world's worst humanita","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["62705f071766bcaa1342fe0a3b4f60ac4e91281659758c19ea644735744048a2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43dde3f1d3b0a0356ed1bab4634931b2dbaa5d75672f0cc92e468ed0beefb6d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0961a5e07a15bdb60d89f8ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300694,"date":"2026-04-22T19:48:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, another unique feature of the Waterloo region is how technology intersects development. KA Imaging is a great example of how Canadian innovation can have an impact both domestically and globally. \n\nThrough Grand Challenges Canada, our government supports innovators that are developing and scaling solutions to some of the world's most pressing health challenges, from improving maternal and newborn care to strengthening health systems in challenging contexts. Our government reaffirmed our support for GCC to ensure that Canadian innovators continue to turn bold ideas into life-saving solutions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-108/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300694","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, another unique feature of the Waterloo region is how technology intersects development. KA Imaging is a great example of how Canadian innovation can have an impact both domestically and globally. \n\nThrough Grand Challenges Canada, our government supports innovators that are developing and scaling solutions to some of the world's most pressing health challenges, from improving maternal","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7de04bd6b3af083ab3a5cb1db80705262c5a72f21dc8db0c2cff49622ad1a9d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9897dff43a9716ba9a963c65087cd330dc6f2170c96b9c00a6f59179dae27934"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-655bf30a95922872e1c7bd8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300693,"date":"2026-04-23T20:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada's humanitarian assistance is making a real difference on the ground. Through trusted partners, we have helped provide nearly 5.7 million meals to families in need. We have supported emergency medical assistance to almost 16,000 patients and health services to 35,000 more. We are helping 40 primary care health facilities across Lebanon stay open, and improving access to essential medical care for the most vulnerable. \n\nThese are just a few examples of the life-saving support that Canadians are helping provide. For families fleeing violence and facing displacement, hunger and loss, it makes a real difference. It is something Canadians can be proud of.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300693","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada's humanitarian assistance is making a real difference on the ground. Through trusted partners, we have helped provide nearly 5.7 million meals to families in need. We have supported emergency medical assistance to almost 16,000 patients and health services to 35,000 more. We are helping 40 primary care health facilities across Lebanon stay open, and improving access to essentia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fda6167486b3f29fcb477d707fe4327708fd6c7c750d97fa031373fd52b08174"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["751ae68735bc86a680c485415419471851456708b788f4be06ac138956e06c24"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a6ae0ace3c98dc14795c4e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":791129,"date":"2026-05-07T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let me be clear. The federal government is defending the property rights. The property rights are not at risk. The only people who are saying the property rights are at risk are the Conservatives over here and their counterparts in the province of British Columbia. They know it and we know it.\n\nThe Canadian government will always defend private property rights. None of the treaty agreements take away those rights. We will defend the rights of Canadians. \n\nThey are just disseminating fear in the hearts of British Columbians and Canadians for the wrong reasons.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-119/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791129","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let me be clear. The federal government is defending the property rights. The property rights are not at risk. The only people who are saying the property rights are at risk are the Conservatives over here and their counterparts in the province of British Columbia. They know it and we know it.\n\nThe Canadian government will always defend private property rights. None of the treaty agre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["88b2f7ef55f8416abf46cf9e9f13d4f97607e26701d78334987da11ef235083b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c0df303a56ca3f6fb1425f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034975,"date":"2026-05-25T19:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the only party in the House that is bringing that fear is the Conservative Party of Canada. The only party in British Columbia that is doing that is the Conservative Party of British Columbia, and the only reason they are doing this is to instill fear. Everyone knows that their private property rights are not at risk. The government is defending them as we speak, and that is how we will always protect the property rights of all individuals in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034975","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the only party in the House that is bringing that fear is the Conservative Party of Canada. The only party in British Columbia that is doing that is the Conservative Party of British Columbia, and the only reason they are doing this is to instill fear. Everyone knows that their private property rights are not at risk. The government is defending them as we speak, and that is how we wi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e0a1add26fd32566ae7f8dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085707,"date":"2026-06-09T17:34:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise in support of Bill C-20, the Build Canada Homes act—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085707","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise in support of Bill C-20, the Build Canada Homes act—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["78fbb21f05cd42380e736150b2c62e114c1f1661f3393c9be310d2a6e15fd88b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-775463e131f34d2ba75c5360","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085708,"date":"2026-06-09T17:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member from Nanaimo knows a lot of the issues that are particular to the island. Market housing works really well in places like Nanaimo, and can probably be the solution that she is expressing would be valid there, but urban markets with the missing middle are a challenging place. Regardless of the red tape and other things, it is very hard for builders and developers to develop there.\n\n How does the member consider developers should be incentivized to build in those areas without a Build Canada Homes-like approach?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085708","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member from Nanaimo knows a lot of the issues that are particular to the island. Market housing works really well in places like Nanaimo, and can probably be the solution that she is expressing would be valid there, but urban markets with the missing middle are a challenging place. Regardless of the red tape and other things, it is very hard for builders and developers to develop ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e5adb5881415f2cce19a40e7d3095cb4ecdef4eae86ffeecc6ed8f187fce4e33"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8c01c52cabde1cdc830c1f1fa3c8dd06c45934b7526e3d2b7d4f0c24d3698753"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b1b63e1d5efc173e63116f3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085709,"date":"2026-06-09T17:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this is a great opportunity for me to rise in support of Bill C-20, the Build Canada Homes act.\n\nThe challenge before us is significant. Too many Canadians are struggling to find a home they can afford, and too many communities are facing housing shortages that continue to drive up costs. That is why our government launched Build Canada Homes in September 2025 with a clear mandate to build affordable homes, support builders with financing and encourage innovative construction methods using Canadian technology, workers and lumber. In just a few short months, Build Canada Homes has already begun advancing projects and establishing partnerships across the country.\n\nBill C-20 would build on that early progress by establishing Build Canada Homes as a Crown corporation, providing it with the operational autonomy and dedicated governance needed to scale up efforts to address Canada's housing crisis. By transitioning Build Canada Homes from a special operating agency to a Crown corporation, the legislation would strengthen its ability to deliver on its mandate at scale while maintaining accountability to Parliament and to Canadians.\n\nAll Canadians deserve an affordable place to call home. Housing is a fundamental need, and the growing demand for housing across the country requires urgent action, which means that this is about more than creating a new institution. It is about giving Build Canada Homes the tools it needs to build more homes more quickly.\n\nAs we consider the legislation before us today, it is worth revisiting exactly what Build Canada Homes was designed to achieve. Build Canada Homes was created to build and finance affordable housing at scale while helping to catalyze a more productive and innovative homebuilding industry. It makes it simpler and faster to get large-scale affordable housing projects off the ground, attracting public, private and philanthropic investment. thus maximizing impact.\n\nBuild Canada Homes does more than fund individual projects. It is a new way of doing business. Its goal is to unlock opportunities across the country by partnering with governments, builders, non-profits and investors to identify and scale high-impact housing solutions. It is also helping modernize Canada's homebuilding sector by supporting innovative approaches, including modern methods of construction. Build Canada Homes is helping create the conditions needed to build more homes more quickly and more efficiently.\n\nThis is particularly important at a time in Canada when Canada needs to significantly increase its housing supply. Build Canada Homes is helping build the capacity needed to meet that challenge. As a Crown corporation, Build Canada Homes would combine access to federal lands, development expertise and flexible financial tools under one roof.\n\nIt would work alongside non-profits, indigenous organizations and all orders of government to help move projects from concept to construction and to accelerate the delivery of affordable housing. It would also work in close partnership with developers, investors, manufacturers and housing providers focused on long-term affordability. This includes non-profits, co-operatives, community housing providers or organizations that promote a variety of housing options for Canadians.\n\nThese strategic partnerships would create homes that are affordable to a range of households across the income spectrum. These partnerships are about building capacity, supporting innovation and creating the conditions for more homes to be built across Canada, which is what makes the legislation before us today so important.\n\nBy establishing Build Canada Homes as a Crown corporation, Bill C-20 would provide the agency with the operational autonomy and governance structure needed to pursue its mission more effectively. It would also provide Build Canada Homes with the flexibility needed to hold assets, make investments and make long-term decisions that support the delivery of affordable housing. Together, these tools would strengthen its ability to deliver on its mandate and build more homes for Canadians. These are exactly the kinds of tools needed to increase housing supply and accelerate construction across the country.\n\nPartnerships with provinces and territories are central to the success of Build Canada Homes. Whether through land financing, housing expertise or construction-ready projects, provinces and territories play a critical role in increasing housing supply and helping more homes get built.\n\nAllow me to use my home province of British Columbia as an example. Build Canada Homes and BC Housing have partnered to deliver at least 1,100 homes, including supportive, transitional and affordable rental housing. This partnership will make use of standardized designs, Canadian-made prefabricated components and modern methods of construction to reduce costs, improve quality, shorten construction timelines and help increase housing construction at scale. These approaches demonstrate how innovation can play a critical role in addressing Canada's housing shortage.\n\nThis is only the first phase of a broader commitment between Canada and British Columbia. By aligning federal investment with construction-ready projects, Build Canada Homes is helping move projects from plans to shovels in the ground, while laying the foundation for thousands more homes in future phases. This is exactly the type of collaboration Build Canada Homes was created to support. It demonstrates how governments can work together to increase housing supply while helping to modernize the homebuilding sector.\n\nImportantly, it also demonstrates the potential of Build Canada Homes as a national institution. In just a few short months, it has advanced projects and partnerships representing thousands of homes across the country. Bill C‐20 is about turning that early momentum into sustained long-term results. By establishing Build Canada Homes as a Crown corporation, we would be strengthening its ability to support more projects, deepen partnerships and help deliver more homes for Canadians.\n\nHowever, that is not all. In addition to helping build more houses, Build Canada Homes is also helping build a stronger Canadian economy. By prioritizing projects and partnerships that invest in sustainable Canadian materials, strengthen Canadian supply chains and create good jobs through the homebuilding process, Build Canada Homes is helping advance the federal government's buy Canadian strategy. This means Canadian lumber, Canadian building materials, Canadian manufacturing and Canadian construction expertise.\n\nAcross the board, Build Canada Homes is helping ensure that public investments create economic benefits here at home. In a changing global economy, strengthening domestic capacity matters. Build Canada Homes is helping increase housing supply while supporting Canadian workers, Canadian businesses and Canadian innovation. The partnerships and projects already under way demonstrate what Build Canada Homes can achieve. Bill C‐20 is about scaling up what is already working. It is about building the partnerships, capacity and innovative construction approaches needed to deliver more homes for Canadians in the years ahead.\n\nBy establishing Build Canada Homes as a Crown corporation, the legislation would provide the governance, flexibility and financial capacity needed to build on that progress and to deliver on its mandate at a greater scale. It would allow Build Canada Homes to hold assets, make investments, deploy innovative financial tools and pursue long-term opportunities more effectively, while maintaining a clear accountability framework to Parliament and Canadians.\n\nAt a time when Canadians need more homes built more quickly and more affordably, Bill C‐20 would help ensure that Build Canada Homes has the tools it needs to deliver. I urge all members opposite to support it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085709","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this is a great opportunity for me to rise in support of Bill C-20, the Build Canada Homes act.\n\nThe challenge before us is significant. Too many Canadians are struggling to find a home they can afford, and too many communities are facing housing shortages that continue to drive up costs. That is why our government launched Build Canada Homes in September 2025 with a clear mandate to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75e0f8b6038ac44c855645d61cd5ee4c1623fed85befefd913a33a8895458ec2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0340a821fba394bb9157a85a4cf211af395284cc00003f8693068fa3223bec9a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6584c2b87a64fb173ba3b7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085710,"date":"2026-06-09T17:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think this is a Crown corporation that would take a lot of federal lands, provincial lands and municipal lands and build quickly and efficiently. It would actually hold, in a lot of cases, those assets in the Crown corporation, and the revenue from that would hopefully help build more homes going forward. It would also help expedite a lot of the process.\n\nI think it is much needed. Canada has tried many other things, and I think this is a time when more homes are needed more quickly. We need an agency like this that has the agility, the financial firepower and the power behind it to build these homes much more quickly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085710","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think this is a Crown corporation that would take a lot of federal lands, provincial lands and municipal lands and build quickly and efficiently. It would actually hold, in a lot of cases, those assets in the Crown corporation, and the revenue from that would hopefully help build more homes going forward. It would also help expedite a lot of the process.\n\nI think it is much needed. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["34c302e2bb08b7965447edfa36b53643dbe5e2a82b4846f430af767ba6255ed0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33395fab79a5b6b60eb3f6a0540d6fb611a8627500aa3243e92b9577e20b4bc3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-880ccae4b2d11756418edb4d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085711,"date":"2026-06-09T17:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a great question, and I apologize for not being able to answer in French.\n\nI think it gives, first, the financial tools. There is $13 billion seeded in it, so it has a lot of financial capability. It has the necessary vehicles, whether that is using CMHC or its own funding, the new building code with pre-approved designs, and encouraging modular design and working with modular providers. These are the types of tools that give it the assets and capabilities to move much more quickly and much more efficiently, and also to innovate in the industry in a time when sometimes the private sector is a little hesitant to do that. That is the ability it has, and as a Crown corporation, it would have more power than a special body.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085711","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a great question, and I apologize for not being able to answer in French.\n\nI think it gives, first, the financial tools. There is $13 billion seeded in it, so it has a lot of financial capability. It has the necessary vehicles, whether that is using CMHC or its own funding, the new building code with pre-approved designs, and encouraging modular design and working with modular","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60bb856eb7eda93f92b2f30cf732dee1fe78813c93d974654e923d1e39fa83e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aa0907520daa61afe0f7c8dc120b995bfec9cbdafa4a2ed8f0110e85ed826b98"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e6defc98eb8679118e5fc03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085712,"date":"2026-06-09T17:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is a great question. The affordability measurement is, I think, 30% of pre-tax income of a household, as a means of affordability. That is the test case, so it varies, obviously.\n\nIn areas where perhaps housing costs are lower, there might be less of a need for Build Canada Homes, but I think that in most cases, Canadians are feeling the pinch in having to pay a lot more than 30% of their monthly income toward housing. The goal is to build the type of housing for which people do not have to pay more than 30% of their household income.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085712","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is a great question. The affordability measurement is, I think, 30% of pre-tax income of a household, as a means of affordability. That is the test case, so it varies, obviously.\n\nIn areas where perhaps housing costs are lower, there might be less of a need for Build Canada Homes, but I think that in most cases, Canadians are feeling the pinch in having to pay a lot more than 30%","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6ff18da6e6e6d93e0a4997690667dcd76a92d1c11e708fe25f3279a7f1c4423c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3941201d21e1978ca7973695fb01de09bca1ef1b673ab5b2b6cc8185b9f3de57"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-953e06ff669d5b4a46197085","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085713,"date":"2026-06-09T17:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I would disagree with that. When Build Canada Homes makes its judgments, including for the 1,100 homes that are being built in British Columbia, it uses a varied metric of all types of housing, such as three-bedroom units in these buildings, two-bedroom, one-bedroom and accessible units. It is designed and built for a mosaic of the families that need them. If that needs to be adjusted, I would welcome the Conservatives' comments at committee to make sure that Build Canada Homes does that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-132/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085713","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I would disagree with that. When Build Canada Homes makes its judgments, including for the 1,100 homes that are being built in British Columbia, it uses a varied metric of all types of housing, such as three-bedroom units in these buildings, two-bedroom, one-bedroom and accessible units. It is designed and built for a mosaic of the families that need them. If that needs to be adjusted","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:732108","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Architectural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:732108","label":"Architectural heritage","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eddaf6aef06b5d50e9810381bf5a369dd3b9bf685c61bc3d57bd2055cc5d48c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["675120830919a0b623a84d3d7116c530f7b804d054b37e3cedb5cf1777502252"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bda3921ce62426889dcb5f9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085701,"date":"2026-06-10T22:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved:\n\nThat a message be sent to the Senate to acquaint Their Honours that, in relation to Bill C-14, An Act to amend the Criminal Code, the Youth Criminal Justice Act and the National Defence Act (bail and sentencing), the House:\n\nagrees with amendments 1(a), 2(a) and 3 made by the Senate;\n\nrespectfully disagrees with amendment 1(b) because subsection 515(13.1) of the Criminal Code already requires courts to state on the record that they considered section 493.2 in making a bail decision, rendering the additional provision unnecessary;\n\nrespectfully disagrees with amendment 2(b) because engagement with relevant partners and stakeholders is already permitted, and the additional statutory consultation requirement could limit flexibility in the preparation and tabling of the report.\n\nHe said: Mr. Speaker, I seek unanimous consent to share my time with the member for Ajax.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085701","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"moved:\n\nThat a message be sent to the Senate to acquaint Their Honours that, in relation to Bill C-14, An Act to amend the Criminal Code, the Youth Criminal Justice Act and the National Defence Act (bail and sentencing), the House:\n\nagrees with amendments 1(a), 2(a) and 3 made by the Senate;\n\nrespectfully disagrees with amendment 1(b) because subsection 515(13.1) of the Criminal Code already requi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6976a7df039847b096e8216c910822b5fbac8dfe58020bc455c9a79681a92eee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e998cdb6e54b57e99f8bdc1f6460d83e22b803eca0a750fccb83df4bf22ef150"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e70a44001d3ff1ceb12bc51f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085702,"date":"2026-06-10T22:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to the message received from the Senate concerning Bill C-14, the bail and sentencing reform act. At the outset, I would like to thank the senators for their careful study of the legislation. The Senate plays an important role in our parliamentary system. It provides sober second thought, hears from witnesses, reviews legislation clause by clause and proposes amendments where it believes improvements can be made.\n\nThat is precisely what occurred with Bill C-14. After reviewing the bill, the Senate adopted four amendments. The motion before the House today proposes that we agree with two of those amendments, amend one of them and respectfully disagree with another. I believe that this approach strikes the right balance. It recognizes valuable contributions made through the Senate's review, while ensuring that the legislation would remain faithful to the objectives Parliament has pursued throughout its study of the bill.\n\nBefore turning to the amendments, I think it is important to briefly remind members why Bill C-14 was introduced in the first place. Across Canada, communities have been raising concerns about public safety. Premiers, mayors, police leaders, victims' advocates and frontline organizations have all called for action to address serious violent offending, repeat offending, organized criminal activity, extortion and human trafficking.\n\nCanadians have seen a troubling rise in violent extortion targeting businesses and families. Communities have experienced growing concerns about organized crime and repeat violent offenders. Transit workers and other frontline workers have called for stronger protections. Provincial and territorial governments have repeatedly asked the federal government to review the criminal law framework to ensure that our laws respond effectively to evolving public safety challenges. Bill C-14 is that response.\n\nThe legislation would strengthen the bail system for certain serious offences by expanding reverse onus provisions in carefully defined circumstances. It would create new tools to address violent repeat offending. It would strengthen sentencing provisions for serious crimes, including extortion and arson committed for criminal purposes. It would respond to the growing threat posed by organized criminal activity and human trafficking. It would improve public safety while preserving judicial discretion and maintaining consistency with the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.\n\nThe bill has been studied extensively. The House committee heard testimony from witnesses. Amendments were proposed and debated. Members from all parties contributed to its development. The Senate undertook its own review and proposed several amendments for the House's consideration.\n\nThe first amendment before us relates to sureties. As members know, during the House committee study, an amendment was adopted to prohibit individuals who had been convicted of an indictable offence within the previous 10 years from acting as surety. The Senate amendment would maintain that prohibition while providing limited judicial discretion in circumstances where no other surety is available and where the court determines that allowing the surety would be in the best interest of justice. The government supports this amendment, which would maintain the fundamental objective adopted by the House. Individuals convicted of serious offences would continue to be prohibited from serving as a surety.\n\nAt the same time, it recognizes that exceptional circumstances may arise. Witnesses who appeared before the Senate raised concerns regarding the practical impact of a complete prohibition in certain remote, rural and northern communities where the pool of available sureties may be limited. The amendment provides a narrow and carefully structured mechanism that would allow courts to address those exceptional circumstances while preserving the overall intent of the provision. For that reason, we believe the Senate amendment represents a reasonable refinement and should be supported.\n\nThe second amendment concerns the annual reporting requirements related to bail data. Members will recall that the House adopted an amendment requiring the Minister of Justice to table an annual report respecting bail data. The Senate amendment proposes two changes. First, it would require that the information respecting rates of detention before trial be included in that report. Second, it would require the minister to consult individuals and organizations with expertise in data collection and the criminal justice system, including Statistics Canada, when preparing the report.\n\nThe government supports the first part of this amendment. Information relating to pretrial detention can contribute to a fuller understanding of how the bail system operates across this country. Reliable data is important. Evidence‐based policy is important. Parliamentarians would benefit by having access to meaningful information about the operation of the criminal justice system.\n\nHowever, the government does not support the second portion of the Senate amendment. The minister already has the ability to engage with relevant partners, experts and organizations when preparing reports and evaluating criminal justice data. Creating a specific statutory requirement is unnecessary and could reduce flexibility in how information is gathered and reports are prepared. As a result, the motion proposes an amendment that would retain the reporting component while removing the mandatory consultation requirement. I believe this approach appropriately balances accountability with operational flexibility.\n\nThe third Senate amendment concerns proposed subsection 515(13.2), of the Criminal Code. This amendment would require a justice to ask on the record whether section 493.2 applies, even where neither party has raised the issue during the bail hearing. The government respectfully disagrees with this amendment. The reason is straightforward: Existing law already addresses this issue.\n\nSubsection 515(13.1) of the Criminal Code already requires courts to state on the record how section 493.2 was considered in making a bail decision. In practice, this requirement already necessitates consideration of whether section 493.2 applies. As a result, the proposed amendment would not create a new substantive obligation. Instead, it would duplicate requirements that already exist within the Criminal Code. For that reason, the government believes the amendment is unnecessary.\n\nThe final amendment relates to the coming into force of provisions respecting access to youth records. The amendment would provide that these provisions come into force on a day to be fixed by the order of the Governor in Council. The government supports this amendment. The amendment reflects a practical implementation approach and would help ensure that all relevant partners have sufficient time to prepare for the coming into force of these provisions. It would not alter the policy objective adopted by Parliament. Rather, it would support effective implementation.\n\nAfter careful consideration, the government believes that the package before the House today strikes the right balance. It would accept Senate amendments that improve the legislation, propose a targeted modification where appropriate, and respectfully reject an amendment that is unnecessary because its objective is already achieved through existing law. Most importantly, it would preserve the core purpose of Bill C‐14.\n\nCanadians expect Parliament to respond to serious public safety concerns. They expect us to provide law enforcement and the justice system with effective tools. They expect us to address violent offending, organized crime, extortion and human trafficking. They expect us to work collaboratively and move legislation forward when consensus has largely been achieved.\n\nBill C‐14 has now been studied by both chambers of Parliament. The House has done its work. The Senate has done its work. The amendments before us have been carefully reviewed. I encourage members to support the motion before the House so Bill C‐14 can proceed without any further delay and continue its path forward for royal assent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085702","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to the message received from the Senate concerning Bill C-14, the bail and sentencing reform act. At the outset, I would like to thank the senators for their careful study of the legislation. The Senate plays an important role in our parliamentary system. It provides sober second thought, hears from witnesses, reviews legislation clause by clause and proposes ame","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1f42aede348de290577da786bc89c6baed27da951bc4da3f9a17563c6bb9e5b5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3f425cd8cdaded7e0f80b2706b2ae8c0647cbd6bbdf55ca9c23df9e2462399e6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3196c94dfc3322e4dec8804","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085703,"date":"2026-06-10T22:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, first of all, I think the member should read the bill. The whole bill is about offenders, people who have broken criminal laws. The bill is about strengthening our bail system so there would be a reverse onus and so criminals would not get released if they are violent repeat offenders or have committed crimes like extortion. It is to enhance the sentencing on them. I think everyone knows that the Liberals are on par to creating tougher sentencing laws for those who need it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085703","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, first of all, I think the member should read the bill. The whole bill is about offenders, people who have broken criminal laws. The bill is about strengthening our bail system so there would be a reverse onus and so criminals would not get released if they are violent repeat offenders or have committed crimes like extortion. It is to enhance the sentencing on them. I think everyone kn","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["43869a75798ae0ca1fd82228852f80512f1ac99dac0922ed679e766994d63ed4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["86fe1f8468399178db7b5d888105801deaea5d5c3609d44d9fbd2150ba3c2672"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-107ba9debe5723eaeef32477","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085704,"date":"2026-06-10T22:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is extremely important. As we all know, in Surrey and places across the country, crimes like shootings and extortions have been rampant and are on the rise. This bill would help in two ways.\n\n One is the reverse onus so that those who are charged would not be given bail. Serious offenders would be kept behind bars so that others in the community can feel safe.\n\n The other would give the power to the judge to give consecutive sentences, rather than complementary, concurrent sentencing. If somebody were to be sentenced for multiple crimes, they would serve them on top of each other, with the cumulative time together. It is very important.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085704","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is extremely important. As we all know, in Surrey and places across the country, crimes like shootings and extortions have been rampant and are on the rise. This bill would help in two ways.\n\n One is the reverse onus so that those who are charged would not be given bail. Serious offenders would be kept behind bars so that others in the community can feel safe.\n\n The other would giv","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71030dd6a2b19860d70f0f62e35faaa55ac141f680f2afb4ff89484b4e290890"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["62c7569b672e77bf79c411c7b2b76708774420a50894b89b7c05c044d8ad95c4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9a3d78a85f28fc56f9a846c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085705,"date":"2026-06-10T22:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think the intent is not about whether someone is indigenous or not. It is about rural and remote communities, where a person seeking to get a surety has very few options. There may be 20, 30, 50 or 60 people in those communities. It is a matter of that small pool. If there is no available surety for that person and they can prove it, the judge would then have the discretion or liberty to allow someone charged with that offence to provide a surety.\n\n When there is an abundance of people who can provide a surety, there would be no carve-out.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085705","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think the intent is not about whether someone is indigenous or not. It is about rural and remote communities, where a person seeking to get a surety has very few options. There may be 20, 30, 50 or 60 people in those communities. It is a matter of that small pool. If there is no available surety for that person and they can prove it, the judge would then have the discretion or liber","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:180149","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wetlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:180149","label":"Wetlands","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7f93cbb9e20a60f881ab4b162104f4629171a0be50f8f3a1f1559693ddec0d92"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7ac1faf57cfc5a52bc19d1022dbb141311e91afbb09daa551d6f52ef397bc885"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c7162b1ceef0c1aee297936","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1085706,"date":"2026-06-10T22:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randeep Sarai","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, this has been very favourable among the police forces across the country, the law enforcement agencies and virtually every province. I spoke with the Solicitor General and the Attorney General of British Columbia, who are both very supportive of this. They gave their consultation and their comments.\n\n This is reflective of what Canadian law enforcement, Canadian Crown councils, the Canadian legal community and, most of all, the Canadian public have been demanding.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-133/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1085706","member_id":"bc-mp-89339","member_name":"Randeep Sarai","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, this has been very favourable among the police forces across the country, the law enforcement agencies and virtually every province. I spoke with the Solicitor General and the Attorney General of British Columbia, who are both very supportive of this. They gave their consultation and their comments.\n\n This is reflective of what Canadian law enforcement, Canadian Crown councils, the Ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28aebacc17d46247b591a6ccbd72a7319be44d6a746d79c25a78fc5fa35488d2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57ab00ea580f3a3a08844aa8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77926,"date":"2026-02-02T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister said in Davos, \"there is a strong tendency for countries to go along to get along\". Well, the moment for Canada to show up is here. Canadian-made parts have been found in weapons killing civilians in Gaza, Sudan and Yemen. A Canadian-made armoured vehicle was seen in Minneapolis the day ICE shot and killed Alex Pretti.\n\nWill the Prime Minister live by his words \"to stop pretending, to name reality,\" and support Bill C-233, the no more loopholes act, so that Canada is not complicit in these horrific acts against humanity?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-77/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77926","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister said in Davos, \"there is a strong tendency for countries to go along to get along\". Well, the moment for Canada to show up is here. Canadian-made parts have been found in weapons killing civilians in Gaza, Sudan and Yemen. A Canadian-made armoured vehicle was seen in Minneapolis the day ICE shot and killed Alex Pretti.\n\nWill the Prime Minister live by his words \"to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0cdc75830aec6398d2e9fe00445290a43624069117f027a91854728a6120c13d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ccff517b03f3090af8f95a1fdcdbd73b07f3000ec673b371b0a4e5d98bf1dd05"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-92e1d0bd53711445bee8010c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77923,"date":"2026-02-03T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, maintaining existing affordable and co-op housing stock is essential to address the housing crisis. China Creek Housing Coop in my riding was shocked to learn that there is no funding in the coming year in CMHC's budget to cover the housing charge subsidies. That means low-income families, seniors, single parents and people trying to get by will be made homeless. They are not alone; approximately 300,000 more homes across the country will be impacted.\n\nWill the Prime Minister tell these families they do not need to fear losing their home, and confirm today that ongoing funding will be in place for their housing charge subsidy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77923","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, maintaining existing affordable and co-op housing stock is essential to address the housing crisis. China Creek Housing Coop in my riding was shocked to learn that there is no funding in the coming year in CMHC's budget to cover the housing charge subsidies. That means low-income families, seniors, single parents and people trying to get by will be made homeless. They are not alone; a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b3d1a1736a2093f5e62060de6952a51713315582b8d83de40b64ff13f8db2932"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cfd969076316e5f85702035923937a1cb1bbc8f59e715eb37cd1102d4a132d7a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f01696174fa9116341a2e53c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77924,"date":"2026-02-03T23:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, for more than 30 years, successive Liberal and Conservative governments have relied on the private sector to attempt to deliver the housing Canadians need. The results are undeniable. Canada's non-market housing stock has dwindled to just 4.5% of total housing, well below the G7 average. To be clear, CMHC has indicated that Canada needs an additional 3.5 million affordable homes by 2030. The PBO's report on the Build Canada Homes plan found that the government will deliver only 26,000 new units of housing over five years. That is 5,200 units per year. At this rate, it would take 673 years to reach the goal CMHC has set out. Based on the life expectancy at birth for a Canadian born in 2023, that is eight and a half lifetimes.\n\nHousing costs have soared, homelessness is rising, and deeply affordable homes are disappearing faster than they are being built. Despite the scale of this crisis, federal housing spending is projected to drop by 56% by 2028-29. At the same time, funding for existing affordability programs is set to expire in the coming years, with no clear replacement. This is not a serious plan as it is currently laid out.\n\nBuild Canada Homes was presented during the election as something akin to a postwar level of federal investment in housing. Instead, the Parliamentary Budget Officer has confirmed that it lacks the targets, funding and safeguards needed to deliver affordability at scale. Build Canada Homes includes no minimum requirements for affordability across its projects. Of the sites announced so far, only six are expected to achieve affordability targets. Without clear targets written into the program, there is no guarantee that future projects will deliver homes that low- and moderate-income Canadians can afford.\n\nBudget 2025 indicates that CMHC, the federal agency formerly responsible for delivering housing programs, is facing cuts of $860 million per year. Canadians do not know which programs will be cut and which will be saved by Build Canada Homes. There is no transparency or accountability. Let me be clear about what this looks like on the ground.\n\nAt the China Creek Housing Coop in Vancouver, residents are facing the possible loss of housing charge subsidies that keep their homes affordable. Earlier this year, the government announced an extension of the federal community housing initiative, creating the impression that affordability protection will continue, yet the most recent federal budget contains no provision for the continuation of these subsidies into the coming year. When the co-op contacted CMHC for clarification, it was told there is no information beyond what was presented in the budget: no timeline, no transition plan, no assurance that existing subsidy recipients will continue to receive support. CMHC has effectively told residents to contact their member of Parliament because it cannot provide answers. The residents affected include low-income seniors with serious health concerns, single parents with children, and indigenous and Métis families.\n\n Without housing charge subsidies, many will be unable to afford their homes not only at China Creek but anywhere in Vancouver's rental market, and for that matter across the country, where rents routinely exceed the total monthly income of those most affected. The fear of imminent homelessness is real, and it is taking a profound emotional toll on people with nowhere else to go.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77924","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, for more than 30 years, successive Liberal and Conservative governments have relied on the private sector to attempt to deliver the housing Canadians need. The results are undeniable. Canada's non-market housing stock has dwindled to just 4.5% of total housing, well below the G7 average. To be clear, CMHC has indicated that Canada needs an additional 3.5 million affordable homes by 20","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e22e51eb56ed632f131217c75e1c8a980ff12cda6530ce8815305422decdf1a1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e98080a60de62dfb2282ddd3eb72cb39e85473bc1a1f26987ca6fea8811ed675"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a70bec015ed41345d3f71b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77925,"date":"2026-02-03T23:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, currently, operating agreements for approximately 300,000 units of existing social and co-op housing are slated to sunset. If the Liberals do not renew those operating agreements, their housing charge subsidies will end. That means there would be, potentially, a loss of 300,000 units of already built affordable homes to add to the acute housing crisis. That means that the Prime Minister is not only failing to build truly affordable homes at the scale that is needed but is also failing to protect existing ones, homes set up to ensure that coordinated affordability is at the centre of its operation so it can deliver deeply affordable housing at scale.\n\nMy question is, will the Prime Minister correct this fundamental flaw and commit to ensuring that Build Canada Homes is doing its job to ensure that core funding is in place to ensure affordability, and will the Liberals commit to contribute funding for housing charge subsidies, including for the residents at China Creek, so no one is pushed into homelessness because of inaction by the federal government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-78/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77925","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, currently, operating agreements for approximately 300,000 units of existing social and co-op housing are slated to sunset. If the Liberals do not renew those operating agreements, their housing charge subsidies will end. That means there would be, potentially, a loss of 300,000 units of already built affordable homes to add to the acute housing crisis. That means that the Prime Minist","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e2ce6a276e0fda91c545d08ad07c9003ed454d2505da6c75761537e4f9b7c7e8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5838a62c7545f325d9c1e9d84dcfb36d7f67d79449f3c98d5dbbfa2715ff3759"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dea9c77bdb4923e7fe3fcd0d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77915,"date":"2026-02-06T15:43:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak to the need for the reform of the Standing Orders governing the House. What I want to raise today are not partisan concerns but rather structural ones, issues that go directly to fairness, accountability and the equal standing of members in the House.\n\nAt a time when we see democratic backsliding around the world, Canadians are rightly asking that we demonstrate responsive parliamentary procedures that keep up with the times and stay abreast of the democratic innovations and best practices happening elsewhere. I will briefly touch on several Standing Orders that merit review, but I want to be clear at the outset that the most serious issue before us is the current restriction on who may trigger a recorded vote.\n\nFirst, on private members' bills more broadly, I believe that PROC should examine whether the balance between the House and the Senate remains appropriate. We have seen cases where the Senate's ability to delay or block private members' bills has effectively nullified decisions taken by elected members of Parliament. Romeo Saganash's Bill C-262, an act respecting the UN Declaration for the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, is an example. Despite all odds, Romeo got it through the House of Commons, only to have it stalled by the Senate and to see it die on the Order Paper.\n\n Jack Layton's climate change accountability act met the same fate. Rona Ambrose's bill requiring federally appointed judges to receive mandatory training in sexual assault law was stalled for two years. We have also seen extended debate on Senate amendments to private members' bills, which occurred with the Bloc Québécois's supply management bill.\n\nSome of these issues, essentially and eventually, were resolved because they were brought back to the House, and some of them were adopted as government bills, but the Senate should never be allowed to stall a private member's bill in such a way that it dies on the Order Paper. That has happened to all parties. PROC should consider whether reasonable limits are required, both on the Senate's capacity to obstruct Private Members' Business and on how long the House debates Senate amendments to those bills. Private members' bills already operate under constrained time and opportunity. They should not face unlimited procedural delay in the red chamber.\n\nSecond, PROC should revisit the rules governing dissenting reports. At present, only the official opposition may table and present dissenting reports during Routine Proceedings. That limitation no longer reflects the composition of the House or the reality of the committee's work. All parties should have the ability to formally express dissent and table their dissenting report. \n\nRelatedly, committees should be empowered to table bills following the completion of substantive studies. Committees frequently identify clear legislative gaps or solutions. Allowing committees to initiate legislation in these circumstances would strengthen Parliament's policy capacity and better connect study to action. Too often, committees do a study and come forward with recommendations that, frankly, just sit on a shelf without much action. We should actually empower the House of Commons and members of the committee to be able to move legislation forward.\n\nThird, opposition days should not be scheduled on Wednesdays or Fridays. These are already shortened sitting days. Scheduling opposition business on those days diminishes its effectiveness as an accountability mechanism. PROC should examine whether this practice aligns with the original intent of supply days. I note that the NDP, given where we are, does not actually have opposition motion days, but I raise this because it is important for democracy.\n\nFourth, we should consider increasing the number of late shows or at least extending the period during which they can be scheduled. Late shows are one of the few procedural tools available to members to pursue answers when initial responses are inadequate. In an era of increasingly centralized messaging, this mechanism deserves strengthening, not contraction. This would allow us to probe questions more thoroughly and more deeply, heightening democratic accountability.\n\nFifth, the rules governing committee of the whole require updating. Committee of the whole should always last four hours, and participation should rotate in a manner similar to question period. Too often, these proceedings are dominated by government members, despite the fact that committee of the whole is fundamentally an accountability mechanism. PROC should restore balance to this forum.\n\nI want to turn to the most pressing issue, which is the right of members to trigger a recorded vote. Under the current standing order, specifically Standing Order 45(1), only members of recognized parties may request that the yeas and nays be entered into the record. Members without a recognized party status may ask that a motion be carried on division, but they cannot insist on a recorded vote. This is not a long-standing parliamentary practice. It is actually a relatively recent change.\n\nThe restriction emerged during the House's transition to hybrid sittings in response to COVID-19. Similar language was adopted in 2021, extended in 2022, and made permanent in 2023, following PROC's recommendation that hybrid-related changes be entrenched. However, what is striking and concerning is that this restriction does not appear to have been fully examined as a stand-alone question to members' rights. It was bundled into a broader package of hybrid reforms, many of which were necessary, but their long-term implications deserve more granular scrutiny.\n\nThe practical effect of the current rule is stark. For example, an MP without recognized party status can introduce a private member's bill. They can win a spot in the Private Members' Business lottery, a process that is already governed by chance and scarcity, but when the House reaches the moment of decision, an MP without recognized party status cannot compel a recorded vote on their own bill. From a procedural perspective, this is indefensible.\n\nPrivate Members' Business is already one of the most constrained elements of House business. The lottery system means that members may wait years for an opportunity to have a bill debated. To deny a member the ability to trigger a vote after clearing all of those hurdles is not merely inefficient; it is inequitable. It creates a hierarchy among members that is not grounded in parliamentary principle. PROC should be particularly concerned about this because the ability to trigger a recorded vote is not a courtesy. It is a core accountability mechanism.\n\nRecorded votes are how members place themselves on the record. They are how constituents assess their representation. They are how Parliament signals collective decisions. There is no democratic rationale for restricting that right to members of recognized parties only, nor is there compelling operational justification.\n\nThe House has now demonstrated over several years that recorded votes can be conducted efficiently in a hybrid environment. Whatever concerns may have existed during the early stages of the pandemic no longer apply. What remains is a rule that centralizes power in party structures and diminishes the voice and role of individual members. That should be a concern for all members of Parliament, particularly at a time when democracy is being undermined in so many places around the world.\n\nPROC has a responsibility to ensure that standing orders do not erode the equality of members over time, particularly through incremental or convenience-based changes. In this case, the effect is clear: Some members are being denied the ability to force a vote and force the House to decide. If PROC is serious about protecting Private Members' Business, about fairness and procedure, and about the equal standing of all elected members, then this standing order must be revisited.\n\nAt a minimum, every member of Parliament should have the right to trigger a recorded vote on their own private member's bill. Anything less undermines the credibility of our procedures and the legitimacy of members to participate in a fair, democratic and transparent manner, no matter what political party they belong to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77915","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak to the need for the reform of the Standing Orders governing the House. What I want to raise today are not partisan concerns but rather structural ones, issues that go directly to fairness, accountability and the equal standing of members in the House.\n\nAt a time when we see democratic backsliding around the world, Canadians are rightly asking th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social structure","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","label":"Social structure","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9133716a884de74693ef5b9883f93dd4f6b6471b367e4625f126c5a1fe38e6c0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e22807ed74d4de7def1b161e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77916,"date":"2026-02-06T15:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I want to be very clear. What I am raising is the issue of a member of Parliament being able to trigger a recorded vote. That should be afforded to every single member here irrespective of their party standing or what party they belong to. It is our fundamental right to be treated equally, to have that right and to have our voice be counted and recorded. \n\nI am not sure how this was advanced, as I did not sit at that table, but I do not think it is right. We have an opportunity to revisit it right now to correct that wrong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77916","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I want to be very clear. What I am raising is the issue of a member of Parliament being able to trigger a recorded vote. That should be afforded to every single member here irrespective of their party standing or what party they belong to. It is our fundamental right to be treated equally, to have that right and to have our voice be counted and recorded. \n\nI am not sure how this was","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f08beca6b675eb21c23253411cbe2590200ca8bb7dfcbdb73ce60ed39b8f048"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c970342a227340e6eb9eeb3b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77917,"date":"2026-02-06T15:55:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, those are valid questions to be considered, as are all the issues the members of the different parties have brought up. The purpose of this debate is to raise these issues and to have them examined thoroughly by PROC, so it can come back with a system that is fair and just. I urge the government members to consider the points I have raised, particularly around triggering a vote, but all the other points as well. \n\nThe way that the Senate is filibustering or stalling on private members' bills is just wrong. It has happened to the Conservatives, the NDP and the Bloc. It is supposed to provide a sober second thought, but deliberately stalling to obstruct is not sober second thought.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77917","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, those are valid questions to be considered, as are all the issues the members of the different parties have brought up. The purpose of this debate is to raise these issues and to have them examined thoroughly by PROC, so it can come back with a system that is fair and just. I urge the government members to consider the points I have raised, particularly around triggering a vote, but","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64868e26bc20de964c230f59d2db11f118f44a21e76ab3089b36c4e544550c81"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84d052f2f105959644b27bc2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77918,"date":"2026-02-06T15:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I raised the issue of the points the different parties have raised, which are valid points for consideration. I think they should be given the time to be thoughtfully considered at PROC. It should invite the members of Parliament with different points of view to come forward so they can advance those perspectives and we can come back with standing orders that are effective, fair, just and equitable.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77918","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I raised the issue of the points the different parties have raised, which are valid points for consideration. I think they should be given the time to be thoughtfully considered at PROC. It should invite the members of Parliament with different points of view to come forward so they can advance those perspectives and we can come back with standing orders that are effective, fair, ju","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-82b637fe61d001106958d267","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77919,"date":"2026-02-06T15:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I agree. I think there needs to be restrictions put in place on the Senate. I cited some examples and there are many more. Randall Garrison's bill on transgender rights was another one that was stalled in the Senate. That should not be allowed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77919","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I agree. I think there needs to be restrictions put in place on the Senate. I cited some examples and there are many more. Randall Garrison's bill on transgender rights was another one that was stalled in the Senate. That should not be allowed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","label":"Transgender people","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ca7c5300c47a469b5299018ff51feef521c2eed27a744fb6288cf50a847b46f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04da9f80698df7a3809f071f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77920,"date":"2026-02-06T17:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Prime Minister says he wants to build Canada up, yet he is slashing over 30,000 PSAC workers who deliver core public services like EI, tax credits, food inspection and more. Admin funding for friendship centres across the country will come to an end this fiscal year. The Vancouver Aboriginal Friendship Centre Society is also being forced to fight for the survival of its gender-based violence prevention programs and its urban programming for indigenous people.\n\n Will the Prime Minister stop the cuts and protect the well-being of our communities with ongoing, stable, permanent funding for friendship centres and their programs, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77920","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Prime Minister says he wants to build Canada up, yet he is slashing over 30,000 PSAC workers who deliver core public services like EI, tax credits, food inspection and more. Admin funding for friendship centres across the country will come to an end this fiscal year. The Vancouver Aboriginal Friendship Centre Society is also being forced to fight for the survival of its gender-b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","label":"Gender-based violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","label":"Gender-based violence","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d1f3600f59e07c85f263f38af917b79896a8037a5de6422a7cf28e456324d36"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["405b112138ef504e33b266ad520ea5ad8a8d5b7e2e03331b5bd1c04ba9a47936"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2abf1fa6912d506c5b8e9fec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77921,"date":"2026-02-06T17:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, on behalf of the NDP, I rise to pay tribute to the late Hon. Kirsty Duncan, whose life was defined by an extraordinary commitment to science, justice and public service. Regardless of the partisan antics that happen in the House, we all collectively know, admire and are touched by the incredible strength of Kirsty Duncan. Today, I want to recognize a great Canadian who gave so much to public life in this country no matter what sphere she was working in, from sport to science to community to academic research to a life in politics. Kirsty Duncan was exemplary in all these areas. She has been taken from us far too young. Our thoughts and condolences go to her family, her husband, her friends and colleagues.\n\nBefore entering public life, Kirsty was already a distinguished scholar. As a medical geographer with a deep sense of moral responsibility, she devoted her academic career to understanding the links between environment, health and human well-being. Her pioneering work on trying to understand the origins of the 1918 Spanish flu, culminating in an ambitious and ethically grounded expedition internationally, reflected both intellectual courage and an unwavering belief that science exists to serve humanity. Even when the expedition did not yield the outcomes she had hoped for, she was transparent about the process and generous in sharing its lessons, exemplifying scientific integrity at its best.\n\nKirsty also spoke with rare honesty about the abuse she endured as a young athlete and the lifelong consequences it had on her health. That lived experience profoundly shaped her later work and gave her advocacy a depth that was impossible to ignore. As minister of sport, she brought a depth and embodied understanding to the work that supports Canadian athletes. As a parliamentarian representing Etobicoke North for 17 years, Kirsty brought her scholarly rigour into the House of Commons.\n\nAs the minister of science, she played a central role in restoring respect for evidence-based decision-making in federal policy and re-establishing the position of chief science officer. She understood that democracy is weakened when science is sidelined, and she worked deliberately to rebuild trust between researchers, government and the public.\n\nHer tenure as minister of sport and persons with disabilities was marked by courage and compassion. She made ending abuse and harassment in sport a national priority, convening governments across jurisdictions and pressing institutions to confront systemic misconduct. This was not abstract policy work; it was deeply personal, and it mattered. Her insistence on accountability, safe reporting mechanisms and enforceable standards changed the national conversation on sport safety.\n\nKirsty was also a champion for women and girls in science. Her later work, including The Exclusion Effect, challenged institutions to confront how systemic barriers continue to push women out of scientific fields. She was unafraid to name uncomfortable truths, and she always paired critique with practical solutions. Across party lines, Kirsty was known for her seriousness of purpose, her respect for colleagues and her belief that public office carries an obligation to do better for those who have been excluded, harmed or ignored. Even when we disagreed, she engaged with integrity and care.\n\nKirsty Duncan leaves behind a legacy that spans academia, public policy and advocacy, a legacy rooted in evidence, empathy and courage. Canada is better because of her work. She will be remembered not only for the offices she held but for the principles she lived by. Kirsty truly was one of the good ones, and we, all of us in the House, mourn her loss. I know my colleague Richard Cannings particularly mourns her loss and will send his love to her family and friends, for they were both scientists at heart, and that bonded them in an unbelievable way.\n\nRest in peace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77921","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, on behalf of the NDP, I rise to pay tribute to the late Hon. Kirsty Duncan, whose life was defined by an extraordinary commitment to science, justice and public service. Regardless of the partisan antics that happen in the House, we all collectively know, admire and are touched by the incredible strength of Kirsty Duncan. Today, I want to recognize a great Canadian who gave so much ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","label":"Gender discrimination"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","label":"Gender discrimination","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f8a13b078a75a26879eb5bc605b68556b0888ee61404b080109f77577882992d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80ba5f92ef7324786b1d234ef5a76926b9a07f35cdac8d49c40d5a334dedc887"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f35e3d4f8a2ed27dd1ce4411","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":77922,"date":"2026-02-06T17:49:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise to table a petition signed by over 4,600 Canadians who are deeply concerned that Bill C-2, the strong borders act, contains provisions that would threaten fundamental rights and freedoms protected under Canadian and international law; that the bill would grant law enforcement and national security agencies warrantless access to Canadians' historical associations with organizations and businesses; that it would allow authorities to compel the disclosure of sensitive personal information, including geolocation data and contact details, based merely on suspicion of relevance to the investigation of offences under acts of Parliament, regardless of individual involvement; and that the bill is designed to facilitate Canada's alignment with the United States CLOUD Act and the United Nations cybercrime convention, raising serious concerns about foreign access to Canadians' private data, including by regimes with poor human rights records.\n\n Petitioners also note that Bill C-2 would undermine Canada's obligations under international human rights instruments, particularly in relation to privacy rights and the fair treatment of migrants and refugees.\n\n Therefore, the petitioners call upon the House to immediately withdraw Bill C-2 in its entirety; reaffirm Canada's commitment to privacy, civil liberties and international human rights standards; reject any legislative or policy initiatives that would enable foreign states, including the United States, to gain undue access to Canadians' personal information; and, finally, ensure that legislation related to national security and the border upholds the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and is subject to meaningful judicial oversight.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-81/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77922","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise to table a petition signed by over 4,600 Canadians who are deeply concerned that Bill C-2, the strong borders act, contains provisions that would threaten fundamental rights and freedoms protected under Canadian and international law; that the bill would grant law enforcement and national security agencies warrantless access to Canadians' historical associations with organiza","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a8b2b2dc902ad67631860fd1f869d8f48a3ddaa138704215986ec4172f0c272f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ebe4b01bee55ef480a737b85bd77219ab3a01ca8c410937cff23ca69ad08062"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5bd69eabc5d999d04019adb9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287880,"date":"2026-02-09T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, when my colleague, the member for Nunavut, was asking her question, a page actually walked across the aisle in front of her. I just want to bring that to your attention and ask whether we could have the member repeat her question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287880","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, when my colleague, the member for Nunavut, was asking her question, a page actually walked across the aisle in front of her. I just want to bring that to your attention and ask whether we could have the member repeat her question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f27880f8004068bd9102fc39","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":287881,"date":"2026-02-09T20:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table a petition in support of Bill C-233, which would close the arms loophole. It is signed by residents of Thunder Bay, Ontario, and gathered by Palestinian Solidarity Thunder Bay. The group says that they requested to meet with the member for Thunder Bay—Superior North, hoping that she would table the petition, but could not get a meeting. Therefore, they have asked that I table their community's call for the House of Commons to enact legislation to close existing loopholes in Canada's arms export laws, including removing exemptions for the United States, strengthening oversight and reassuring that Canadian arms are never used to commit or facilitate human rights abuses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-82/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:287881","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table a petition in support of Bill C-233, which would close the arms loophole. It is signed by residents of Thunder Bay, Ontario, and gathered by Palestinian Solidarity Thunder Bay. The group says that they requested to meet with the member for Thunder Bay—Superior North, hoping that she would table the petition, but could not get a meeting. Therefore, they have asked that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8168bd7f078f530db5b2b92600ec4470dca87ba216c312af122987a343dd63d0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-38aca16c8a6ccaf442af40ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306841,"date":"2026-02-24T16:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, with respect to the comments the parliamentary secretary made earlier, he is absolutely correct that the Conservative approach is divisive and penalizes the people who are most vulnerable in our community.\n\n To the point on interim federal health policy, the Liberal government brought forward a copayment system in the budget. For those who are suffering mental health challenges with trauma, people who have escaped persecution, violence, gender-based violence and so on, access to mental health and access to medication would be critical. A $4 fee could be prohibitive for them. A 30% increase in copayment fees could be prohibitive for them.\n\n Would the member agree that the government should not go down that track because it is edging right into the trap that the Conservatives are setting?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306841","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, with respect to the comments the parliamentary secretary made earlier, he is absolutely correct that the Conservative approach is divisive and penalizes the people who are most vulnerable in our community.\n\n To the point on interim federal health policy, the Liberal government brought forward a copayment system in the budget. For those who are suffering mental health challenges with","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic sanctions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","label":"Economic sanctions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40119825168a419389d10b574aa8533eea6bcff8886d5b864753b50ccc18ac3b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8fdf3b00f085dc3708266f6d2fb573220e1f8da5c6ec8600fa81d4da6287810e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d03692cc9bbdc1c8d4bcfcd5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306842,"date":"2026-02-24T16:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the member is absolutely correct, in that part of the issue around escalating the cost of the system is the Liberal government's inadequacy in providing the necessary resources to get the applications processed. In the case of the IRB, for example, it needs the actual resources and the capacity to be able to process the applications so applicants are not just jammed up in the system. Equally important would be for Quebec and the other provinces to receive the additional funding that is required in the delivery of health care. That is absolutely paramount.\n\nMy question to my colleague is this: Would he also join the NDP to collectively demand that the Liberal government do what is right and honour our international obligations to refugees, and also support provinces and territories, including Quebec, in getting the necessary resources to do the work that is required?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306842","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the member is absolutely correct, in that part of the issue around escalating the cost of the system is the Liberal government's inadequacy in providing the necessary resources to get the applications processed. In the case of the IRB, for example, it needs the actual resources and the capacity to be able to process the applications so applicants are not just jammed up in the system","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083664","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083664","label":"Resources management","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c92c02eb36832939825d1eb1ebccefc9ed17ffa18597c27dbd3f651391a92252"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55a3b87232bbbb1e275aed4772f862373116627fdb5bd515d8099f3b6f802a06"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb4f3621abf51e798e34390d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306843,"date":"2026-02-24T18:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am splitting my time with the member for Marc-Aurèle-Fortin.\n\n I rise today to speak in strong opposition to the Conservative motion targeting the interim federal health program, and this is after the Liberals have already rolled it back.\n\nLet us be clear about what the motion does. It scapegoats newcomers and refugees. It suggests that denying preventative care, prescription medication, dental treatment and mental health services would somehow produce savings. It would not. It would simply shift costs from preventative care to emergency rooms, from primary care to acute care, and from federal responsibility to provincial systems, where treatment is far more expensive and outcomes are far worse.\n\n The Conservatives and the Liberals are approaching this challenge in the wrong way, and they should know better. Their previous changes to the interim health program were struck down by the courts because they were deemed unconstitutional in 2014 under the Harper government. This is the same playbook, same narrative and same fearmongering.\n\nThe Conservative leader keeps saying that he turned over a new leaf, but he is back to the same old games of politicizing social issues for political gain, whereas deeper nuance and compassion are necessary. It is disappointing watching the Conservatives walk the same path over and over again into a dead end.\n\nThe evidence is unequivocal: When governments adopt an emergency-only model of care, health outcomes deteriorate and long-term costs increase. Preventative and primary care are the most cost-effective interventions in any health care system. Denying early access to medications, mental health supports, dental treatment and assistive devices does not eliminate the need for care; it delays it until conditions become acute and far more expensive to treat.\n\nWe have seen this before. Under former prime minister Stephen Harper, supplementary coverage under the interim federal health policy was restricted. The result was confusion, suffering and documented harm. Courts found the cuts to be cruel and unusual. After 2015, those restrictions were reversed because they were harmful and counterproductive. Canada learned that lesson once; we should not repeat it.\n\nNonetheless, taking a page from the Conservatives, the Liberals have now introduced copayments under the interim federal health program in budget 2025. They frame it as modest fiscal restraint, but decades of health policy research demonstrates that even small user fees deter access to health care, especially for low-income and medically vulnerable populations.\n\nThe population covered under the interim federal health program is among the most vulnerable in Canada: refugees and refugee claimants who often arrive after suffering war, persecution, torture and prolonged displacement. Many arrive with trauma, and many arrive with chronic conditions that have gone untreated for years. They have extremely limited financial means. For some living in deep poverty, a prescription charge is not symbolic. A 30% copayment for mental health counselling is not modest. A copayment for mobility aids, dental care or vision care is not a small inconvenience; it is prohibitive.\n\nIn practice these copayments function as a denial of care. The consequences are not hypothetical; they are predictable. When people cannot afford medications, hypertension goes untreated, leading to stroke, and diabetes goes unmanaged, leading to amputations, kidney failure or intensive care admission. Untreated infections escalate into hospitalization. When people cannot access mental health supports, traumas worsen, crises escalate and emergency interventions become necessary.\n\n Each avoidable hospital stay costs thousands, sometimes tens of thousands, of dollars. The savings generated by a small copayment are dwarfed by the downstream costs of acute care. Instead of containing costs, this approach escalates them. Instead of relieving pressure on the system, it intensifies pressure on emergency departments and provincial health budgets. It undermines newcomers' ability to acquire language skills, to work, to contribute and to feel like equal members of society.\n\n If we are serious about fiscal responsibility, then we must focus on the actual cost drivers within the interim federal health policy. One of the most significant drivers is the prolonged enrolment due to backlogs in the immigration and refugee system. The IRB needs resources. When claims take years to process, individuals remain on the interim federal health program coverage longer than necessary. That is an administrative problem, not a refugee health problem.\n\nThe solution is clear: Accelerate fair and timely claim processing, invest in adequate staffing and resources for the IRB, ensure early comprehensive primary care upon arrival and maintain full interim federal health program coverage without copayments during this transition period. Let us remember that the interim federal health program is a temporary program. Early care reduces long-term costs, and timely decisions reduce prolonged enrolment. These are structural, evidence-based solutions. Punitive copayments are not. Moral obligations and economic logic align.\n\n Protecting access to essential health care for refugees is not only a moral obligation; it is also sound economic policy. Healthy newcomers integrate more quickly, enter the workforce sooner, contribute to taxes and support their families. When we deny care, we delay integration and increase long-term public expenditures.\n\n The Conservative motion seeks to frame this as a question of fairness to taxpayers, but fairness requires facts. The facts show that cuts in copayments in refugee health care cause preventable harm, increase long-term expenditures, shift costs to provinces and undermines integration. That is neither fiscally responsible nor socially responsible. This is not evidence-based policy-making.\n\n Rejecting division is what we must do. At its core, the motion divides. It suggests that refugees are a burden to be managed rather than human beings entitled to dignity and basic health care. Canada has chosen a different path. We have chosen evidence over ideology. We have chosen compassion aligned with fiscal prudence.\n\n New Democrats will not support measures that scapegoat vulnerable people or repeat policy failures we have already corrected. We have to learn from the past. We know that restricting refugee health benefits causes preventable suffering and greater long-term expense. We know that even small user fees deter access for people living in deep poverty. We know that preventative care is more cost-effective than emergency intervention.\n\n The Conservative motion is misguided, and the NDP will reject the motion. The Liberal government's decision to impose copayments under the interim federal health policy risks repeating a costly mistake. The responsible course of action is clear: Maintain full coverage under the interim federal health program, eliminate copayments, address administrative backlogs and invest in early comprehensive primary care.\n\n For these reasons, the NDP will oppose the motion and any other attempts by the Conservatives or the Liberals to roll back this important health care delivery for all.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306843","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am splitting my time with the member for Marc-Aurèle-Fortin.\n\n I rise today to speak in strong opposition to the Conservative motion targeting the interim federal health program, and this is after the Liberals have already rolled it back.\n\nLet us be clear about what the motion does. It scapegoats newcomers and refugees. It suggests that denying preventative care, prescription medica","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["355f4743ce75c1d0c024bd4e77c42084165a1366340abe636349902caba1f8e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3c54b2db4f517d22ec073a7ff8302b06dbc1e851019dde4c3f963d89ccd5679"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-771fccea3ee18a9d292d3865","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306844,"date":"2026-02-24T18:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member knows very well, in terms of refugee status, what the requirements and eligibility rules are. Those would apply to the individuals who are applying. That determination should be made independently and not by politicians. It is made at the IRB.\n\nThe government should be properly funding the IRB so it can process the claims accordingly, instead of creating a huge backlog like the one we are faced with right now that, as a result, is having an impact on the interim federal health policy. That is what the government should do, and the member knows it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306844","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member knows very well, in terms of refugee status, what the requirements and eligibility rules are. Those would apply to the individuals who are applying. That determination should be made independently and not by politicians. It is made at the IRB.\n\nThe government should be properly funding the IRB so it can process the claims accordingly, instead of creating a huge backlog like","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bb0a313e359d4c1c2b52fdc866d16c2fee8f56fc02d2d53d6855d00678155aa3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c777fc21fbeeda1fb65c0266635417a07894d31895b858d5e33a6bccf7f2e6ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84a91cafa36a323aeddea5af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306845,"date":"2026-02-24T18:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I actually know the motion very well, as well as the intentions behind the Conservatives. Let us be clear: What they are also talking about is denying access to care for people who are under an appeal provision. In Canada, there is a thing called due process.\n\nBy the way, the federal court and the Harper government already did this. The Harper government took away interim health care provisions for supplementary benefits for refugees, and the courts ruled this to be unconstitutional. Apparently the Conservatives have not learned their lesson, because here we are talking about the same thing with the same old approach again.\n\nWhat the NDP fights for is head-to-toe care for every single person in this country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306845","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I actually know the motion very well, as well as the intentions behind the Conservatives. Let us be clear: What they are also talking about is denying access to care for people who are under an appeal provision. In Canada, there is a thing called due process.\n\nBy the way, the federal court and the Harper government already did this. The Harper government took away interim health care ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a2b795b3cb37dd794d19ed13ef9469a993740ed2f93d1e008e4d5192f76bf2e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eeae69c7cddabeb0052dc3a570d9ee4859f4c2d6905766b0802500c1e53575b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9e2a56a4fa3250708226524","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306846,"date":"2026-02-24T18:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the member is absolutely correct. What the government must do to address the situation we are faced with right now, which is a problem caused by the government's inaction, is to ensure that there are adequate resources to process the applications in the system. When the Liberals do not, they create a huge backlog, and that has implications and ramifications.\n\nQuebec, for example, is in fact faced with a situation where health services are being impacted because there is a huge backlog. The government must be fair and just. Quebec and all provinces deserve equitable treatment. They deserve support from the federal government in support of immigration and for refugees so people can access health care when they need it, and at the same time, have applications processed in an expeditious manner.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306846","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the member is absolutely correct. What the government must do to address the situation we are faced with right now, which is a problem caused by the government's inaction, is to ensure that there are adequate resources to process the applications in the system. When the Liberals do not, they create a huge backlog, and that has implications and ramifications.\n\nQuebec, for example, is i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d91040b2c13f878a0b41ed39177ef36faefab2fd53db741809ce8750b1f633b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["586795202e2b4ee583f9fabc6cc315cd8fa65f5412dff33b7017f7cb47ab688f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e6ab2024bd72fb8b887740f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306847,"date":"2026-02-24T18:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Conservatives are preying on the most vulnerable for their own political gain, and frankly it will escalate anti-immigrant and anti-refugee sentiments in the broader community. That does not do anybody any good, so I call on the Conservatives to do the right thing: Stop the rhetoric and stop trying to gain with their fearmongering on the backs of refugees and migrants.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-88/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306847","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Conservatives are preying on the most vulnerable for their own political gain, and frankly it will escalate anti-immigrant and anti-refugee sentiments in the broader community. That does not do anybody any good, so I call on the Conservatives to do the right thing: Stop the rhetoric and stop trying to gain with their fearmongering on the backs of refugees and migrants.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-deb0f1c1a134482b40cae35a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":306840,"date":"2026-02-25T21:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to table an e-petition signed by more than 3,300 Canadians who have joined the call to support Bill C-233.\n\nThe petitioners say that whereas Canada acceded to the Arms Trade Treaty in 2019, committing to prevent the transfer of arms where there is a substantial risk they could be used in human rights abuses, war crimes or crimes against humanity, a significant loophole in Canada's export laws currently allows Canadian-made weapons, parts and components to be exported to the United States, from where they may be transferred to third countries engaged in armed conflict or with records of grave human rights violations.\n\nPetitioners further note that this loophole undermines Canada's international commitments, risking making Canada complicit in human rights abuses abroad, and allows Canadian arms to be used in conflicts against civilians. They also note that international bodies, including the UN Human Rights Council and independent UN experts, have called on all states to hold arms transfers where there is a substantial risk of their use in violations of international humanitarian law.\n\nThe petitioners therefore are calling on the House of Commons to enact legislation to close the existing loopholes in Canada's arms export laws, including removing exemptions for the United States, strengthening oversight and ensuring that Canadian arms are never used to commit or facilitate human rights abuses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-89/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:306840","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to table an e-petition signed by more than 3,300 Canadians who have joined the call to support Bill C-233.\n\nThe petitioners say that whereas Canada acceded to the Arms Trade Treaty in 2019, committing to prevent the transfer of arms where there is a substantial risk they could be used in human rights abuses, war crimes or crimes against humanity, a significant loophole in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aaf47916ed901bbd756ce635db612bb92f31d18ae8aaf0f0a54d141244a5d169"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["641b8732ffe28d96cedc97e3e3b70a0200ee676dbde3f49fa04a4dffedeca569"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb2835562e2e7d0cf0af865a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336029,"date":"2026-03-09T16:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, let me begin by addressing the central claim we have heard repeatedly, which is that Bill C-233 would somehow decimate Canada's defence industry and disrupt integrated supply chains. That assertion is simply incorrect.\n\nBill C-233 would not prohibit exports. It would not restrict production. It would not alter the list of controlled goods. It would standardize permit requirements for items already listed under group 2 of Canada's export control list by applying to U.S.-bound exports the same permit review that already applies to exports to every other destination. Canada already administers a global export permitting system. Extending permit review to U.S.-bound exports would not create a new regulatory regime. It would remove a destination-based exemption.\n\nRegulatory oversight is not prohibition. Conflating the two is simply misleading. Other state parties to the Arms Trade Treaty manage highly integrated defence supply chains while still applying oversight mechanisms, including open and general licences where appropriate, and the United States is part of that regime. Administrative efficiency and legal compliance are not mutually exclusive.\n\nWe have also heard that this bill would weaken Canada's role in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and delay support to Ukraine. Nearly all members of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization are state parties through the Arms Trade Treaty. Aligning Canada's export controls with our treaty obligations would strengthen our credibility within the alliance. Military assistance to Ukraine is transferred through Department of National Defence mechanisms, not through the commercial export permitting processes that Bill C-233 would address.\n\nThis legislation would concern commercial exports primarily to the United States. It would not impede direct government-to-government military aid. In fact, ensuring that Canadian-origin components are assessed before entering the U.S. supply chain reduces the risk of diversion to high-risk end-users. That objective is entirely consistent with NATO's collective security framework.\n\nThere is also the claim that Canada already exceeds the ATT requirements. Yes, Canada applies vigorous human rights criteria when issuing permits. That is not in dispute. The structural issue is that most conventional arms exports to the United States require no permit at all. That means no individual risk assessments and no comprehensive reporting.\n\nAnnual reports tabled since the 1990s do not capture the majority of U.S.-bound transfers because those exports are exempt from permits. A reporting framework cannot be considered complete when most of the exports fall outside of its scope. We are told that the U.S. exemption is not a loophole and that it reflects a long-standing bilateral defence relationship. That may be true, but its practical effect is that most conventional weapons exports to the United States proceed without permit, without assessment and without detailed transparency. This is, by definition, a regulatory gap.\n\nCanada and the United States do not apply identical risk thresholds. The United States may authorize transfers to end-users that Canada would deny directly. Without a Canadian permit requirement, Canadian-origin components can enter the U.S. system and be transferred onward without Canada ever conducting its own risk assessment. We have seen this concern in reporting by CBC News, which documented that Canadian-origin military goods moved through the United States and onward to Israel during a period when the Minister of Foreign Affairs stated that Canada was not exporting arms to Israel. This example underscores the oversight gap that Bill C-233 is designed to address.\n\nFormer Liberal cabinet ministers Allan Rock and Lloyd Axworthy recently argued in a Globe and Mail op-ed that Canada's credibility as a champion of the rules-based international order depends on aligning practice with principle. They reminded us that Canada played a leadership role in building global arms control norms, from the Ottawa Treaty to the Arms Trade Treaty. The exemption shields the majority of our transfers from scrutiny and undermines that legacy. They were clear: The issue is not whether we trust the United States but whether Canada exercises its own sovereignty and responsibility to assess the risk that Canadian-origin arms could contribute to serious violations of international humanitarian or human rights laws.\n\nI urge all members to look at the facts and vote in support of Bill C-233.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336029","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, let me begin by addressing the central claim we have heard repeatedly, which is that Bill C-233 would somehow decimate Canada's defence industry and disrupt integrated supply chains. That assertion is simply incorrect.\n\nBill C-233 would not prohibit exports. It would not restrict production. It would not alter the list of controlled goods. It would standardize permit requirements fo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2544f939a8d7a48dd7c48753b40d17556f46368e3221b5ffe4e54220f829c3bb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["350b4edc84b763343f57a7f1dfca3127c56b44335eaa0c7c5969f14415b776a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8be43916c769065ad3b4ff9b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336030,"date":"2026-03-09T20:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table a petition from the residents of Victoria. They asked me to table this petition because the MP for Victoria would not do so.\n\nThe petitioners note that Canada acceded to the Arms Trade Treaty in 2019 and that the promise was made to Canadians that Canadian arms, components and weaponry would not be used in human rights violations and against humanity. However, they note there is a significant loophole, in that exports to the United States do not require any permitting. In fact, the vast majority of the exports to the U.S. do not require any permitting and therefore do not require risk assessments. There have been credible reports indicating that Canadian arms have been used in various conflicts, including in Gaza, Israel, Sudan, Yemen and so on, killing civilians, which is in violation of international humanitarian law.\n\nTherefore, the petitioners are calling on the House of Commons to enact legislation to close the existing loopholes in Canada's arms export laws, including removing exemptions for the United States, strengthening oversight and ensuring that Canadian arms are never used to commit or facilitate human rights abuses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-92/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336030","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table a petition from the residents of Victoria. They asked me to table this petition because the MP for Victoria would not do so.\n\nThe petitioners note that Canada acceded to the Arms Trade Treaty in 2019 and that the promise was made to Canadians that Canadian arms, components and weaponry would not be used in human rights violations and against humanity. However, they not","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["88a1abe0e2addd72d2a943367155545c32c3036940d3c23692bb027afbfb5966"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19b7ea164f26757bdec884ad7be240405705a550f802c2d3ebaae41c8c3b5a3d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc1ddea42a4d9fa945ccc2c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336028,"date":"2026-03-10T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP strongly condemns the U.S. and Israeli bombardment of Iran and the devastating impacts on civilians, including the deaths of children at school. This marks a dangerous and reckless escalation that risks plunging the entire region into catastrophic conflict, which will have global consequences, and there is no end game. \n\nMake no mistake, the oppressive regime in Iran, with its human rights abuses and repression of its own people, is appalling. This includes reports of tens of thousands of killings during recent protests. \n\nThe Iranian people deserve democracy, peace and justice, and the future of Iran must be decided by Iranians themselves, but military strikes are not the answer. International law is clear under article 51 of the UN charter and under the International Court of Justice.\n\nNew Democrats oppose these attacks and call on the Prime Minister to condemn them, end any complicity through arms exports and make it clear that Canada will not participate in this war.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-93/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336028","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP strongly condemns the U.S. and Israeli bombardment of Iran and the devastating impacts on civilians, including the deaths of children at school. This marks a dangerous and reckless escalation that risks plunging the entire region into catastrophic conflict, which will have global consequences, and there is no end game. \n\nMake no mistake, the oppressive regime in Iran, with its","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e57d8c6da95ce56da573eff78cb0dc9afbf6caa19b7b24c568d84d2db0d74373"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["153d0a41e23c6cb02d06ee2d50cf239a1d562b17eda829000654b5c8cd198811"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e768b88bdbda5b1cf32d3df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":336026,"date":"2026-03-11T20:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister told a story about living within a lie in Davos and said, \"The power of the less power starts with honesty.\" Former Liberal cabinet ministers Allan Rock and Lloyd Axworthy, who have been honest about Canada's complicity in the killing of civilians, have come out publicly in support of Bill C-233. They said that Parliament now faces a clear choice to maintain an outdated exemption that undermines Canada's credibility or adopt a modern principled statement that reflects our commitments and responsibilities.\n\n Will the Prime Minister be honest with reality and vote yes to Bill C-233?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-94/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:336026","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister told a story about living within a lie in Davos and said, \"The power of the less power starts with honesty.\" Former Liberal cabinet ministers Allan Rock and Lloyd Axworthy, who have been honest about Canada's complicity in the killing of civilians, have come out publicly in support of Bill C-233. They said that Parliament now faces a clear choice to maintain an outd","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7725765dcd01cf9ba3fc3d5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384536,"date":"2026-03-23T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, after the last atmospheric river and flooding in the Sumas Prairie, the Liberals promised support, but those were just empty words. Last week, there were two atmospheric rivers, but the Liberal government continues to delay action on flood protection in this nationally significant corridor for food production. Ottawa has yet to deliver the millions needed for flood mitigation plans, leaving people, infrastructure and farmland at risk.\n\nWhen will the Prime Minister deliver the funding needed to protect this vital economic corridor?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-97/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384536","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, after the last atmospheric river and flooding in the Sumas Prairie, the Liberals promised support, but those were just empty words. Last week, there were two atmospheric rivers, but the Liberal government continues to delay action on flood protection in this nationally significant corridor for food production. Ottawa has yet to deliver the millions needed for flood mitigation plans, l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["196133386c35b08e93f29c963115a2f0b92287a854785f9f7c599a9ff0be820a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efe9ffcd73cad771ba1470eefdb121d439867afc0acda916e076afce954c6576"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ef0000da7e363651e76f098","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384535,"date":"2026-03-24T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, in the middle of a national housing crisis, the Liberals have quietly pulled funding for the Right Fit program, a program that directly connects wheelchair users with accessible housing. With just days' notice, funding is being cut as of April 1, leaving some of the most vulnerable Canadians, people with disabilities, without support, without housing options and without answers. \n\nAt a time when accessible housing is already in critically short supply, how can the housing minister justify abandoning wheelchair users in such a cruel manner and cutting the very programs designed to help them find a place to live?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-98/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384535","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, in the middle of a national housing crisis, the Liberals have quietly pulled funding for the Right Fit program, a program that directly connects wheelchair users with accessible housing. With just days' notice, funding is being cut as of April 1, leaving some of the most vulnerable Canadians, people with disabilities, without support, without housing options and without answers. \n\nAt ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d907bae69213c0e803f8d86fbb5f0e5167175999c69075ad6810723ee8b977f6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["709d37430d8e5d9fc8c7b258e61258d3a1331a4fea574ac0591c379e88f4358e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fac9b3fbbf94592027bfee6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384531,"date":"2026-03-25T22:47:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to affirm a central New Democrat principle, which is that we must take real, meaningful action to confront hate in Canada without undermining the fundamental freedoms that define our democracy.\n\nThe Canadian Civil Liberties Association and more than 40 civil society organizations raised a red flag with respect to the language in Bill C-9. \n\nIt said that the bill:\n\n ...could be used to criminalize peaceful protest and silence unpopular expression. Instead of meaningfully addressing these concerns, the truncated Committee process did very little to improve the bill and actually made the bill worse by removing the Criminal Code's good-faith religious defense without putting anything adequate in its place. \n\nNew Democrats could not agree more. We understand both the urgency of addressing hate and the necessity of protecting civil liberties. Let me be clear. Hate is real. It is rising. It is harming communities across this country: racialized communities, indigenous people and members of the 2SLGBTQ2+IA community. \n\nHowever, the legislation must be precise, effective and just. It must target the actual sources of harm, not cast a wide net that risks criminalizing legitimate expression and dissent. That is why we continue to have serious concerns with the bill before us.\n\n In fact, the member for Nunavut, on behalf of the NDP, tabled amendments at committee to try to address some of those concerns, but all of those amendments failed. The NDP position, as articulated by her, remains the same.\n\nShe stated:\n\nThe NDP believes the federal government must take comprehensive action to fight the rising tide of hate in Canada.\n\nShe went on to say:\n\nYes, we need to combat hate, but we do not need to criminalize people speaking up, and we definitely do not need to keep them jailed for longer.\n\nI am disappointed that this bill does not address the violent activities of the growing white nationalist movement. The Liberals' failure to include that aspect in this bill leaves racialized communities, indigenous communities and the 2SLGBTQIA+ community without the necessary tools to combat the largest source of hatred in Canada.\n\nWe are in polarizing times, for many reasons. People are either for or against Palestine. They are either for or against Israel.\n\nShe continued:\n\nOur public discourse must not give us fear that we will be criminalized [but this] bill seems to be more about criminalizing people who speak out than it is about addressing the growing racism against racialized people.\n\n This is a profound critique and one we must take seriously. In fact, at committee, this important question was asked of the minister by the member for Nunavut.\n\nShe stated:\n\nWet'suwet'en land defenders were criminalized. Nunavut land defenders were on the verge of being criminalized. Why? It was because they were protesting government decisions.\n\nShe went on to say:\n\n In about a week in 2024, between August 29 and September 8, Canadian police killed six first nations people. Racialized people in this country have a similar experience with law enforcement. This bill requires that Canadians trust that the police will know when an action is motivated by hate and when it is not.\n\nCould the minister respond by sharing what safeguards protesters will have that ensure that law enforcement does not use these new powers to criminalize protesters?\n\nNo satisfactory answer was provided by the minister.\n\n This is not just theoretical. Just yesterday, the CBC exposed the RCMP's \"Native extremism program\", whereby dozens of first nations leaders were put under surveillance by the RCMP and labelled as extremists, based not on credible threats but on a sweeping, intrusive campaign that treated legitimate political advocacy for land rights, self-determination and fair treatment as something to be monitored, controlled and even disrupted, with jaw-dropping intelligence dossiers stuffed with documents, wiretaps, paid informants and covert operatives with code numbers. The operation aimed to divide movements, withdraw funding and interfere with organizing in violation of their right to freedom of association and political expression and privacy.\n\nLet us be very clear. In a democracy, disagreement is not a threat; it is a necessity. Protest is not a crime; it is a right. Indigenous leaders fighting for their land rights for self-determination and fair treatment is not extremism. Bill C-9 would open the door wide for Canada's institutions to continue to engage in these nefarious operations. How can we be certain that those who dare to oppose the government's Bill C-5 on major projects, which has already trampled on the rights of indigenous people, would not be criminalized under Bill C-9? \n\nAs the member for Nunavut further noted: \n\nNew Democrats are concerned with vague language in this bill, because once broad definitions are on the books, they can easily be weaponized against groups.\n\nShe also noted: \n\nOn freedom of assembly...any protest that is loud enough or disruptive enough would be seen as meeting this criterion.\n\nPeaceful protest is a cornerstone of democratic engagement. If legislation creates a chilling effect and if people begin to fear that speaking out could lead to criminal consequences, then we have fundamentally altered the nature of a public discourse. Canada already recognizes that free speech has limits. We recognize that free speech can go too far and cross a line, like when it incites violence against an identifiable group. That threshold exists for a reason. Lowering it, as this bill proposes, risks capturing conduct that should remain protected. We must be cautious not to conflate offensive speech with criminal conduct.\n\n New laws in Canada must protect communities without perpetrating or creating new injustices. Bill C-9 would create new criminal offences based on vague and subjective standards, particularly based on the idea of causing fear. Let us be honest about what that means in practice. It means police officers deciding in the moment what counts as fear. It means broad discretion. It means inconsistent enforcement. \n\nIn this country, we know exactly how that story goes. It is indigenous land defenders who are arrested and surveilled. We have seen, historically and recently, how activists have been monitored and movements disrupted by law enforcement. It is racialized communities that are overpoliced. It is activists and protesters who are treated as threats, not because the law says so explicitly but because vague laws are applied unevenly. This is not justice. \n\nThe member for Nunavut is correct to say, \"This bill, in its current form, gives too much discretionary power to law enforcement, allowing for subjectivity.\"\n\nI should note that Canada is not starting from zero when it comes to addressing hate. As pointed out by the member for Nunavut, \"There are existing laws that address hate, [and hate] is already an aggravating factor in sentencing.\" In fact, the Criminal Code already contains robust provisions, including offences related to disturbing religious worship, mischief against religious property, criminal harassment, uttering threats and intimidation.\n\nWhat, then, is this bill actually doing? The member for Nunavut rightly pointed out that the bill would increase maximum sentences to five years, 10 years, 14 years and even up to life imprisonment. Let me be very clear: There is no credible evidence, none, that longer sentences deter hate crimes. What reduces crime is prevention, stability and investment in community housing, mental health care, education and opportunity. Evidence-based policy requires us to ask whether these measures would actually reduce harm or simply expand the reach of the criminal justice system in ways that may be counterproductive.\n\n I conclude by returning to where I began. New Democrats are committed to fighting hate unequivocally. We believe in protecting communities, confronting extremism and building a more inclusive society, but we also believe in getting this policy right. We believe that legislation must be targeted, evidence-based and consistent with the charter. It must address real threats like organized white nationalist violence and not cast overly broad nets that risk infringing on fundamental freedoms.\n\nThat is why, as noted by the member for Nunavut when she wore the NDP banner, \"With all the alarm bells going off about this bill, the NDP cannot support it in its current form.\" That remains our position. The NDP will not support measures that compromise civil liberties, expand punitive approaches without evidence, or fail to address the root causes of hate. Canadians deserve better. The NDP will remain principled and firm on the issue, and we will oppose Bill C-9.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384531","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today to affirm a central New Democrat principle, which is that we must take real, meaningful action to confront hate in Canada without undermining the fundamental freedoms that define our democracy.\n\nThe Canadian Civil Liberties Association and more than 40 civil society organizations raised a red flag with respect to the language in Bill C-9. \n\nIt said that the bill:\n\n ...cou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b023215991ca4521da463088e9f55b299883ed4368b7beb295e2dbb9fa1b1eb3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["20a736cf8754b43da70ce61e90ab1b1eb71fad3d879581418fd61625f7486b85"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f59a6f125b134d67191c84b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384532,"date":"2026-03-25T22:58:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the reality, of course, is that we already have laws in place. The Criminal Code already targets hate and the incitement of hate. What is needed is the government investing in the enforcement of those kinds of activities. What we have seen is the Liberal government cutting budgets for measures that make sure enforcement is in place. We need to make sure that what goes to the courts results in justice for the people. \n\nChanging the laws, though, and then further criminalizing people who want to exercise their democratic right to freedom of speech and freedom of expression is wrong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384532","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the reality, of course, is that we already have laws in place. The Criminal Code already targets hate and the incitement of hate. What is needed is the government investing in the enforcement of those kinds of activities. What we have seen is the Liberal government cutting budgets for measures that make sure enforcement is in place. We need to make sure that what goes to the courts re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["21d1c07d388a1b463e52ee1e42f5ee6ea2d170c3868994f5ef079bb7d1393a01"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bea8a34a72ce9c25e7812b1602c71ecf250570386a7eb1ce28116ad4cf657aad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-445021374df201ab0d5e6c86","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384533,"date":"2026-03-25T23:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as a New Democrat, my principles do not change. People change their political colours. We have seen it in the House quite regularly, both Conservatives and an NDP member crossing over to the Liberals. The question that remains for them is this: Do their principles remain intact? Are they true to what they believe in? \n\nI believe the comments by the member for Nunavut that I cited in the House. They were valid criticisms of the government. More than ever, we need principled stands, and the New Democrats and I take principled stands on Bill C-9. I hope those who cross the floor will do so as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384533","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as a New Democrat, my principles do not change. People change their political colours. We have seen it in the House quite regularly, both Conservatives and an NDP member crossing over to the Liberals. The question that remains for them is this: Do their principles remain intact? Are they true to what they believe in? \n\nI believe the comments by the member for Nunavut that I cited in t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2f0ebaf48fd5c98b2e8c9f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384534,"date":"2026-03-25T23:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the rules and laws are there, and the judges will make those decisions. The problem with Bill C-9, of course, is that it is so subjective and vague that it allows for law enforcement to interpret it however they want to interpret it. There rests the problem. \n\nIf we want to bring in precise law, let us do so. Let us not rush this through. Instead of whamming it through and bringing in the guillotine, let us have honest, true debate on the issue.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-99/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384534","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the rules and laws are there, and the judges will make those decisions. The problem with Bill C-9, of course, is that it is so subjective and vague that it allows for law enforcement to interpret it however they want to interpret it. There rests the problem. \n\nIf we want to bring in precise law, let us do so. Let us not rush this through. Instead of whamming it through and bringing in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6307a4ebc2fe3b19bd8f3df1bea2cb65ccbc7b201a79058eb543343991dcb794"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b72c10c3e1ab0a51222e9d25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384526,"date":"2026-03-26T17:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank members of the House for their grace in allowing me to speak to this important bill today. \n\n I rise today with ongoing and deep concerns about Bill C-12. Behind the language of \"efficiency\", \"integrity\" and \"streamlining\", the bill would do something very real and very harmful. It would take rights away from people who are seeking protection, handing more unchecked power to the government and scapegoating newcomers. The intention in the logic behind this legislation is not just flawed, it is dangerous. That is why New Democrats cannot support Bill C-12. \n\nLet us begin with the refugee system. Canada has long prided itself on offering people a fair hearing and an opportunity to present their case before an independent decision-maker. However, Bill C-12 would weaken that foundation. Under this legislation, people would be found ineligible for a full hearing before the Immigration and Refugee Board, not because their case lacked merit but because of some arbitrary timeline. Instead, they would be pushed into a pre-removal risk assessment process. The government says that it is fine, but the process would deprive individuals of the opportunity for their case to be heard by an independent tribunal. Under the pre-removal risk assessment process, decisions are made by an immigration officer. There is no meaningful right to appeal. \n\nDue process is not a luxury. It is a fundamental principle of justice, and the bill would erode that. This is not a concern just raised by me in the House. The United Nations Human Rights Committee has already sounded the alarm bell. It has warned that Bill C-12's new ineligibility provisions would deny refugee claimants adequate procedural safeguards, and it has called on Canada to ensure access to fair and efficient procedures in line with our international obligations, including the principle of non-refoulement. Civil society organizations, including the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, have said the same.\n\n There is no evidence that the legitimacy of a refugee claim is linked to how quickly someone files it. The introduction of a one-year bar is particularly troubling. Refugee claimants are expected to navigate a complex legal system, often without legal advice, often in situations of trauma. Under this legislation, they would be told that if they do not act within an arbitrary timeline, they will lose access to a full hearing. This is not fairness. This is exclusion, and this is procedural duress. Frankly, this is a system stacked against the claimant. \n\nWho would this actually affect? It could affect a child who once visited Canada with their family, a human rights advocate who came to Canada to speak about conditions in their home country or a survivor of gender-based violence who needed time to process trauma before coming forward. All could be captured by these sweeping exclusions, and it gets worse. These provisions are retroactive. They would apply to people who entered Canada years ago, going back to 2020, who had no way of knowing these rules would one day be used against them. It undermines the very principle of legal certainty. \n\nHowever, that is not all. Bill C-12 would also grant sweeping powers to the government to cancel immigration documents, potentially affecting an entire group of people. Under the broad and undefined concept of public interest, legislation needs to be precise. It must include clear limits and safeguards, but the bill does not do so. Instead, it would open the door to decisions being made without transparency, without independent oversight and without adequate recourse. This should concern all of us, because when power is concentrated without accountability, mistakes are not just possible, they are inevitable.\n\n We do not have to look far to understand the risks. Canada has a history, one we must acknowledge, of making decisions in moments of fear that disproportionately harm marginalized communities. We have seen exclusion justified; we have seen rights denied, and in hindsight, we have recognized those decisions as wrong. The question before us is simple: Have we learned from that history or are we just repeating it, but this time under different language? \n\nAnother serious concern is the expansion of information sharing. The government argues that this is to improve coordination, but coordination must not come at the expense of rights. Under this framework, personal information, status, identity and immigration history can be shared more broadly across government systems. While the government says that safeguards will exist, many of these arrangements would depend on agreements that are not transparent. \n\nThis creates real risks, because migrants rely on public services, health care, housing and legal supports. If there is even the perception that accessing these services could expose their immigration status, people will hesitate. They will delay seeking care. They will avoid reporting exploitation. They will withdraw. That has consequences, not just for those individuals but for our communities. Public systems work best when people can access them safely and without fear. This bill risks undermining that.\n\nThe Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology, after studying the bill, called for the draconian measures in part 5 to part 8 of the bill to be deleted. The Senate wanted amendments to restore some balance so that measures to block refugee hearings; the arbitrary, retroactive one-year bar; the breach of privacy to share information about applicants; and cabinet's ability to cancel or suspend documents en masse under vaguely defined public interest terms are done away with.\n\nUnfortunately, these amendments were voted down by the Senate committee on public safety. In the end, the Senate passed amendments to limit the sharing of personal information from citizens and permanent residents and to make mandatory annual reports on asylum claim processing times, ineligibility data and statistics on post-one-year asylum claims. Even though the amendments from the Senate are significantly pared down from their original form, the Liberals want to reject the Senate amendments to respect the privacy rights of citizens and permanent residents.\n\nThe Liberals have introduced this at a time when migrants are increasingly being blamed for broader social challenges. We hear claims that migrants are responsible for housing shortages, for pressures on health care and for affordability challenges. I will be very clear: Migrants do not create these crises. These are the result of policy decisions about housing supply, public investment and economic priorities. Blaming migrants does not solve these problems. It distracts from them, and legislation like Bill C-12 risks reinforcing that narrative.\n\nThe bill is an attack on people who are already vulnerable, such as refugees fleeing violence, migrant workers facing exploitation and families trying to build a life in Canada. These individuals are not statistics. They are members of our communities; they contribute, they work, and they care for others. They deserve a system that treats them with dignity and fairness.\n\nThe consequences extend beyond individuals. Denying refugee claimants due process puts people at risk of persecution, torture or worse. It also damages Canada's credibility on the world stage. The same UN Human Rights Committee has raised broader concerns about the state of civil liberties in this country, from surveillance to systemic discrimination and barriers faced by marginalized communities.\n\nNew Democrats believe there is a better way. We can build an immigration and refugee system that is both fair and efficient, that processes claims in a timely manner, that ensures access to legal supports, that upholds due process and that recognizes the humanity of those seeking protection. These are not competing goals. They are complementary.\n\nWe must uphold the principles of fairness, accountability, human rights and due process. The legislation does not meet this standard. For those reasons, my colleagues in the NDP and I will oppose the Liberal motion and will also be opposing Bill C-12.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384526","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank members of the House for their grace in allowing me to speak to this important bill today. \n\n I rise today with ongoing and deep concerns about Bill C-12. Behind the language of \"efficiency\", \"integrity\" and \"streamlining\", the bill would do something very real and very harmful. It would take rights away from people who are seeking protection, handing more unchecked power to t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a112a11f1e4dad53c61e6f8aa598ae4456294a4eaa9265f51d6ef9c50db7ab2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e8704da73e7c6a66f99902208145cabe756fa2983213b2502ec706f4d153c51e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4261d6adb6295b7324c3a6b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384527,"date":"2026-03-26T17:22:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is funny that the member cited the United States because, believe it or not, the United States actually has a slightly better system, although not perfect by any stretch of the imagination. Its one-year bar actually applies to the last date of entry. Canada has chosen to apply it retroactively. This is what the government is doing. It is racing to the bottom instead of respecting international law and basic human rights.\n\nOn the issue around the pre-removal risk assessment, in my speech, I amply outlined the flaws within that system. The government is now depriving individuals who are not able to meet the arbitrary timeline. People who face trauma, who escape persecution, may not have the wherewithal to file the claim within one year for a variety of reasons, not the least of which is a lack of access to legal supports.\n\nThe member seems to think this is okay. The New Democrats take a different point of view. We do not think it is okay. We think that this is a draconian piece of legislation and it should be withdrawn.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384527","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is funny that the member cited the United States because, believe it or not, the United States actually has a slightly better system, although not perfect by any stretch of the imagination. Its one-year bar actually applies to the last date of entry. Canada has chosen to apply it retroactively. This is what the government is doing. It is racing to the bottom instead of respecting i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd5cb01e8c8fa3c7a3288150e67710351b53aff229f2b89c17c39ef10c1a3df4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8091dfb0dc5f75ed20bd0aaf90d066ba6f8e9b88abacbb44ba42fff851f65b29"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1eaf6fb46a8fa7627d4a94cf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384528,"date":"2026-03-26T17:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am not quite sure which clause the member is talking about. If he is referring to the one-year bar issue, I have already cited the issues related to it.\n\nThere are many other components within the bill that I and the New Democrats cannot stand behind, and we are not alone. The UN Committee has made comments about the bill and its measures that should be changed. Civil societies have raised these issues. Those who work with refugees and migrants have continually raised these issues. I wish that the members of Parliament would listen to them and to the stories of real people.\n\nCanada once upon a time had a great system, but it is being eroded bit by bit by the Liberal government and the Conservatives on an ongoing basis. Now it is a shadow of what it was. The immigration system has problems and needs to be fixed, but not this way.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384528","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am not quite sure which clause the member is talking about. If he is referring to the one-year bar issue, I have already cited the issues related to it.\n\nThere are many other components within the bill that I and the New Democrats cannot stand behind, and we are not alone. The UN Committee has made comments about the bill and its measures that should be changed. Civil societies have","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca44a20bf92e7745f00a286b3b4e457024d187db6c4c89d4ce4be7b1f603ad34"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["424a15ed450fbdb5e27e70eb279adc2112eb3f665702950ad5de55a1a8615e88"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e07ae27c8a72c6cd66d8aad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384529,"date":"2026-03-26T17:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, yes, the Auditor General has come out with a report that highlights the government's inability to ensure that the immigration system is operating efficiently and fairly.\n\nThere is no question that there are people who take advantage of international students, who are faced with exploitation and abuse, but the government has turned a blind eye to that. Instead of fixing the problem, it is blaming international students and coming in with a cap, as though somehow the victims are to be blamed. That is the false narrative the government is perpetuating in the broader public. It is, frankly, dangerous.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384529","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, yes, the Auditor General has come out with a report that highlights the government's inability to ensure that the immigration system is operating efficiently and fairly.\n\nThere is no question that there are people who take advantage of international students, who are faced with exploitation and abuse, but the government has turned a blind eye to that. Instead of fixing the problem, it","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Propaganda","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44850","label":"Propaganda","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f0c0417e868137e2e1d574fc8603979077beaadf7f400951e1416ab744a2ddd4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["152d8757d24f0229efdf5e89dd2d51caafab17c84f2455ec8ddbaaefc5189f20"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89f159aebe505008650b1865","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":384530,"date":"2026-03-26T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister is patting himself on the back about reaching NATO's 2% defence spending target. Budget 2025 saw the Liberals impose a 5% target, $81 billion, and now the government is promoting its defence procurement strategy as a way to turn Canada into a major arms exporter. This exposes Canada to further undermining international arms trade commitments through existing loopholes without scrutiny.\n\n Will the Prime Minister admit that this new direction demands accountability and commit to a full parliamentary review of Canada's arms export policy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-100/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:384530","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister is patting himself on the back about reaching NATO's 2% defence spending target. Budget 2025 saw the Liberals impose a 5% target, $81 billion, and now the government is promoting its defence procurement strategy as a way to turn Canada into a major arms exporter. This exposes Canada to further undermining international arms trade commitments through existing loophol","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f861cd455f4b950ffad7b073a37aca5d3df0e9b6acfe39cb3d62fa4b7d911aef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb3d172cc5aa1f8476e37bf3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":426116,"date":"2026-04-14T19:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are being squeezed at the checkout counter like never before. Families are cutting back on essentials, skipping meals and struggling to afford groceries, while a handful of grocery giants continue to post massive profits. This is not a free market working for people. It is a system tilted in favour of corporate power, where Canadians pay more and get less. The cost of groceries is not just a household issue; it is a national affordability crisis, and it demands bold action. \n\nUnder the leadership of Avi Lewis, New Democrats are ready to take on grocery price gouging head-on. That means tackling surveillance pricing, building real public options in food distribution, strengthening local and regional supply chains and supporting Canadian producers. We have done this before. \n\nFrom protecting farmland in B.C. to building public systems that put people first, the NDP knows that when we act in the public interest, we can lower costs and improve lives. It is time to take back control from grocery giants and put—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-102/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:426116","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canadians are being squeezed at the checkout counter like never before. Families are cutting back on essentials, skipping meals and struggling to afford groceries, while a handful of grocery giants continue to post massive profits. This is not a free market working for people. It is a system tilted in favour of corporate power, where Canadians pay more and get less. The cost of grocer","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29b1ee62efa2d7069ff3d110dce235446bdf786dc42f987a6e63bd445fce920c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["97fb59b8e5be7f0d3db71c40888bdc5821ca716d7deefd23f71b2e994e0ed573"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c611d94d0d749af98f8d0da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":426115,"date":"2026-04-16T20:08:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, yesterday, the NDP moved a unanimous consent motion in this House to ban surveillance pricing, and every party agreed except the Liberals, who blocked it. Meanwhile, Canadians are struggling with the cost of living and corporations are using algorithms to figure out how much more they can squeeze out of family budgets and seniors living on fixed incomes. \n\nWhy did the government block this common-sense measure, and will the Prime Minister commit today to banning surveillance pricing in Canada, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-104/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:426115","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, yesterday, the NDP moved a unanimous consent motion in this House to ban surveillance pricing, and every party agreed except the Liberals, who blocked it. Meanwhile, Canadians are struggling with the cost of living and corporations are using algorithms to figure out how much more they can squeeze out of family budgets and seniors living on fixed incomes. \n\nWhy did the government block","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["12a0a095513d79f01f862d3bdbf914711d116c86c135c47689627df7b6dfa444"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["68c1504e99dc1fdc27be8ffa89a977315c657b85c1b7c8f13dc9990f8a93489d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d14b06493be55de20a5b21f3","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1148653,"date":"2026-04-20T15:13:09+00:00","title":"An Act to amend the Citizenship Act and the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"An Act to amend the Citizenship Act and the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-274","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.parl.ca/legisinfo/en/bill/45-1/C-274","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1148653","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"An Act to amend the Citizenship Act and the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0cec2f131d1fc557ed3b5c82","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300704,"date":"2026-04-20T16:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear about what is happening in this country right now. Canadian families are making impossible choices at grocery stores. Parents are skipping meals so their children can eat. Seniors on fixed income are choosing between food and medication. Food banks usage has reached historic highs, and people using them are not just unemployed Canadians. They are working people, people with jobs who still cannot afford to feed their family.\n\nMeanwhile, Canada's grocery giants have posted record profits. Billions of dollars are flowing to shareholders and executives, while ordinary Canadians struggle to put food on the table. This is not a supply chain problem anymore. This is a greed problem. Increasingly, it is also about a transparency problem, because new technologies are making pricing even more opaque and harder for Canadians to trust. Bill C-226, the national framework for food price transparency act, is one step, a modest but necessary step, toward restoring fairness and transparency in our grocery sector.\n\n I want to acknowledge and thank the member for Fleetwood—Port Kells for bringing the bill forward in the current Parliament. I also want to thank my former colleague Alistair MacGregor, the former member for Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, as Bill C-226 is a carbon copy of Bill C-406, which was introduced by Alistair because the NDP wanted legislation to establish a national framework to improve food price transparency through standardized unit pricing and public awareness for consumers about shrinkflation practices.\n\nRight now, grocery pricing in Canada operates like a black box. Prices go up, and Canadians are told it is because of inflation, supply costs or global pressures, but when those input costs come down, do prices follow? They rarely do, and consumers have no way to verify what they are being told. Anyone who has tried to compare products at the grocery store knows the shell game that is being played. Is a 750-gram box a better deal than the 1.2‐kilogram bag? Is the sale price actually a saving, or has the package quietly shrunk? Shrinkflation is real. Canadians are paying the same or more for less product, and without clear unit pricing, it is nearly impossible to catch.\n\nThe bill would establish national standards for unit pricing displays, making them accurate, usable and accessible. That means clear, consistent labelling that lets a working parent on a tight budget quickly identify the best value. It means accessibility for seniors, for people with disabilities and for anyone who deserves to shop with dignity and clarity. This is consumer protection 101, and frankly it is long overdue in Canada. Many European countries and Australian states have had mandatory unit pricing for years. We are playing catch-up.\n\nFood affordability is a national crisis that requires a national response, and the framework would create a structure for that collaboration. In addition to addressing pricing transparency, there is also a new and deeply troubling layer being added to this lack of transparency: surveillance pricing. Retailers are increasingly able to use personal data, such as person's postal code, their purchase history and even their online behaviour, to estimate what they might be willing to pay, and to adjust prices accordingly.\n\nThis means that two people could buy exactly the same product at exactly the same store and pay different prices, not because of a sale and not because of cost differences but because an algorithm has decided that one of them can be charged more. This undermines a basic assumption Canadians have always relied on: that the price on the shelf is the price everyone pays. It also makes comparison shopping nearly impossible. If prices are being personalized behind the scenes, how can Canadians make informed choices? How can markets function fairly when the rules are hidden?\n\nThe United Food and Commercial Workers Union has already raised concerns, noting that these systems are beginning to roll out in real time with little transparency and no accountability. We know who will be most affected: seniors on fixed income, working families, people in rural and underserved communities, and anyone an algorithm determines has fewer options. That is not a fair market. That is digital age price gouging.\n\n Surveillance pricing needs to be banned in Canada. Our leader, Avi Lewis, has called for clear guardrails to ensure that personal data is not used to squeeze more money out of the pockets of people who are already stretched thin. In Canada we are already seeing leadership in Manitoba on this under Premier Wab Kinew, who has taken steps to ban surveillance pricing practices outright, recognizing the risks they pose to consumers. Innovation should serve people, not exploit them. It is about setting boundaries. The Liberals should bring in a national initiative to ban surveillance pricing from coast to coast to coast.\n\nMeanwhile, Bill C-226 would address part of the broader problem by requiring transparency on price increases, adjustments and fluctuations. This is not about the government's setting prices. It is about ensuring that Canadians have the information they need to make informed decisions and to hold corporations accountable. When grocery chains know their pricing practices will be scrutinized, when they know Canadians can see when and why prices change, they will think twice before padding their margins on the backs of struggling families.\n\nWould the bill single-handedly solve the affordability crisis? No, it would not. New Democrats have called for much bolder action: excess profit taxes on grocery giants, stronger competition enforcement, measures to break up corporate concentration in the food supply chain and a public option for groceries such as what Avi Lewis has long argued for. However, the bill is a beginning. It would give Canadians tools and information. It would establish the principle that transparency is non-negotiable in our grocery sector, especially as pricing practices become more complex and less visible. We should not let the perfect be the enemy of the good. We can pass the legislation while continuing to fight for deeper structural reforms.\n\nThis comes down to a simple question: Whose side are we on? Are we on the side of grocery executives and shareholders, who have enriched themselves during a cost of living crisis, or are we on the side of the single mother comparing prices at 10 p.m. after her shift, the pensioner stretched thin on a fixed income and the family choosing between groceries and rent?\n\nCanadians deserve to know that the price on the tag is the price that everyone pays, not a number quietly adjusted based on their personal data. Bill C-226 is a vote for transparency, a vote for fairness and a vote for Canadian families. New Democrats will be supporting the bill, and we urge all members of the House to do the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300704","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, let us be clear about what is happening in this country right now. Canadian families are making impossible choices at grocery stores. Parents are skipping meals so their children can eat. Seniors on fixed income are choosing between food and medication. Food banks usage has reached historic highs, and people using them are not just unemployed Canadians. They are working people, people","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b5eda58ed8fc52e9db23f968cfdc1fbb04c155088d6f613a3473230550eb881b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["17d0e701d2690fe1c56e112ce7dfb690d719f974563fde873f6b6093df4bb8af"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e75d440660d1d7356d48d652","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300705,"date":"2026-04-20T17:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the government omitted to properly consult the Privacy Commissioner. It is a curious thing, why they did that. Would the member support an amendment to the bill to, prior to it receiving full authority, have the bill brought before the Privacy Commissioner for consultation and recommendations?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300705","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the government omitted to properly consult the Privacy Commissioner. It is a curious thing, why they did that. Would the member support an amendment to the bill to, prior to it receiving full authority, have the bill brought before the Privacy Commissioner for consultation and recommendations?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb791f0687a55281d6e16f20","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300706,"date":"2026-04-20T17:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I think everyone agrees that the modernization of investigative powers in the digital age is required. The question is about getting the right balance.\n\nIn the interests of getting the right balance and protecting privacy and civil rights, why did the government not consult with the Privacy Commissioner or ensure that their input was incorporated in the drafting of Bill C-22?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300706","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I think everyone agrees that the modernization of investigative powers in the digital age is required. The question is about getting the right balance.\n\nIn the interests of getting the right balance and protecting privacy and civil rights, why did the government not consult with the Privacy Commissioner or ensure that their input was incorporated in the drafting of Bill C-22?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa8819ee3a6c66c4d86d025110865647e3fd59a8a32d62f7a6cd5977f9241207"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["576510b5b2aa4715042ae86ca0dfa5c72a2ec6169ced2d6725ab9f5fffccee88"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b81b1a12dca2b227c507c2a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300707,"date":"2026-04-20T18:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I absolutely agree with the member that the government screwed up the tabling of Bill C-2 in trying to force through an omnibus bill that was resoundingly, as a result, rejected by the Canadian public. \n\nHere we are now with Bill C-22. The government says it has consulted widely and has learned from its lesson, yet it has deliberately excluded the privacy commissioner in that consultation. \n\nDoes the member think the government should have included the privacy commissioner on the development of Bill C-22?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300707","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I absolutely agree with the member that the government screwed up the tabling of Bill C-2 in trying to force through an omnibus bill that was resoundingly, as a result, rejected by the Canadian public. \n\nHere we are now with Bill C-22. The government says it has consulted widely and has learned from its lesson, yet it has deliberately excluded the privacy commissioner in that consulta","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["935b792e24c65d51ad2ef61d8022a97889892fe656e50351b60f416d31f6df1a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-74083e61485f2063395d843a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300708,"date":"2026-04-20T18:44:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-22, the so-called lawful access act, is being presented as a necessary modernization of investigative powers in the digital age. To be clear, there is some truth in that framing. We do need to modernize.\n\n Law enforcement and national security agencies are operating in a rapidly evolving technology-driven environment. Serious crimes, from human trafficking to foreign interference, are increasingly digitally distributed and difficult to detect. Human trafficking networks now rely on encrypted messaging, anonymous accounts and constantly shifting online identities. Foreign interference operations depend on coordinated digital campaigns, pseudonymous actors and infrastructure that crosses borders in seconds. In both cases, the central challenge is attribution, identifying who is behind an account or activity, quickly enough to act.\n\nParliamentary findings have confirmed that agencies like the RCMP and CSIS face real difficulties accessing communications data and that, without some form of data retention, information sought under warrant may no longer exist, so the problem is real and the need for tools is real. New Democrats recognize that law enforcement officers must have the ability to investigate serious crimes and protect public safety, whether that is child exploitation, human trafficking, terrorist threats or foreign interference. However, those powers must always be balanced with strong protections for privacy, civil liberties, cybersecurity and meaningful consultation. That is the test before us. We have seen what happens when the balance is lost.\n\n The government's previous attempt under Bill C-2, the so-called safe borders act, an omnibus bill, was widely rejected by over 300 organizations and tens of thousands of Canadians because it would have been an attack on civil liberties, on privacy rights, on due process and on the rights of asylum seekers.\n\n Bill C-2 has now come back in different parts. The attack for asylum seekers lives on under Bill C-12, which the NDP vehemently opposed. The part about lawful access continues in Bill C-22, and I would say it does include some improvements. The removal of blanket warrantless \"information demand\" powers matters. Replacing that with a more limited \"confirmation of service\" tool based on reasonable grounds and restricted to a yes or no response would be a step in the right direction. The requirement of judicial authorization for further access would remain, which is essential. Therefore, yes, there has been some movement. \n\nHowever, we should also be clear about what this legislation would do. This is not simply a modest update. It is a significant restructuring of how the state, private companies and individuals would interact in the digital space. There are serious concerns, particularly in part 2 of this bill. Part 2 would require electronic service providers to build and maintain interception capacities within their systems, and would introduce the possibility of mandatory metadata retention, potentially requiring the storage of location data, device identifiers and communication metadata on all users for extended periods. It would allow the government to require companies to retain metadata for up to one year.\n\n Metadata may not include the content of communications, but it reveals patterns of behaviour, who we talk to, when we talk to them, where we are and how often we interact and for how long. In the digital era, metadata is often more revealing than content. It is the skeleton of a person's private life. Under this bill, that data could be retained, not because it is needed for a specific investigation but because it might become useful in the future. This would be a profound invasion of privacy law. It would replace targeted suspicion with generalized collection.\n\n In addition, the Minister of Public Safety would be granted authority to issue secret orders requiring providers to modify their systems to facilitate access to user information. These orders would not require judicial authorization. They would not be subject to public scrutiny and in, many cases, they may never be disclosed. Instead, they would be approved through an administrative process involving the intelligence commissioner. Now, while that office plays an important role in oversight, it is not equivalent to independent judicial authorization in open court.\n\nWe are told this is necessary to ensure that data exists when investigators need it to reconstruct networks, identify victims or attribute foreign interference. Those are legitimate objectives. The question is not whether those objectives matter, but whether the approach is proportionate. Bulk indiscriminate data retention risks treating every Canadian as a potential suspect rather than focusing on targeted investigations. Metadata is not benign. It can review deeply personal information, patterns of movement, associations and behaviours.\n\n Mandating its large-scale retention also creates cybersecurity risks. Concentrating secret, sensitive data makes systems more vulnerable to breaches, misuse and exploitation by malicious actors. We should be cautious about requiring companies to build surveillance capabilities into their systems. Even where the intention is lawful access, these kinds of systemic access points can introduce vulnerabilities. Experts have repeatedly warned that there is no such thing as a perfectly secure back door that only works for one purpose. It exists for everyone. \n\nThe committee report on lawful access is instructive here. It acknowledges the operational challenges, gaps in data availability, coordination issues and the need for lawful intercept capability. It also makes clear that any framework must be grounded in necessity, proportionality and legitimacy. It found no support for requiring back doors to encryption. It highlighted a lack of clarity in the government's overall approach. It raised concerns about the absence of a coherent, transparent strategy. That raises another important question. Why was there no more meaningful consultation with the Privacy Commissioner and the independent officer tasked with safeguarding the rights of Canadians? At a time when trust in digital governance is already fragile, that omission matters.\n\n We should also look internationally. Broad data retention regimes have faced legal challenges in other jurisdictions. More targeted alternatives, such as quick-freeze models, have been explored, preserving data tied to specific investigations rather than requiring ongoing generalized collection. Again, the issue is not whether tools are needed. In fast-moving cases, whether it is locating a trafficking victim or identifying a coordinated foreign interference network, timely access to data can make a real difference. The issue is whether this bill strikes the right balance between effectiveness and rights. Does it provide law enforcement with the tools it needs without overreaching? Does it maintain robust judicial oversight? Does it avoid creating systemic cybersecurity risks? Does it respect the charter principles of necessity and proportionality? More importantly, will it withstand constitutional scrutiny? If that balance is not right, the consequences are not just legal, but democratic.\n\n Privacy is not an abstract concept. It is what allows people to speak freely, organize and participate in public life without fear of constant monitoring. When surveillance becomes more expansive and less constrained, it has a chilling effect. That is well documented. Therefore, the question before us is not whether we act, but how we act.\n\n Bill C-22 reflects an attempt to respond to real and evolving threats. It includes improvements over what came before, but it also raises serious, unresolved questions, particularly around the scope of data retention, the role of executive authority, the risks of cybersecurity and the adequacy of oversight. Those are questions this House must examine carefully because effective policing intelligence work can and should operate within robust legal frameworks that preserve judicial oversight and limit data collection to what is strictly necessary. Getting this wrong would not just impact investigations, but it would reshape the relationship between Canadians and the state in the digital age. \n\nAdvocates for civil liberties and privacy have very real civil liberties concerns that the bill represents one of the most serious proposed threats to privacy rights in Canada in the past two decades. That is not something we should take lightly because our civil liberties are the cornerstone of our democracy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300708","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Bill C-22, the so-called lawful access act, is being presented as a necessary modernization of investigative powers in the digital age. To be clear, there is some truth in that framing. We do need to modernize.\n\n Law enforcement and national security agencies are operating in a rapidly evolving technology-driven environment. Serious crimes, from human trafficking to foreign interferen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["363f646b4a45505311a68f9dd2a01945648e091530d4b93ff9666fe83e23e769"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f76aed81e80da2e6ba2864a7ecb7c2af338afbe47d70aa2e450628b5ba154042"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ac4c42095825d85555907e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300709,"date":"2026-04-20T18:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, as I have noted before, the government keeps saying that it got the balance right. If it is so certain about that, why did the government not ensure that the Privacy Commissioner is incorporated in the consultation process with the development of Bill C-22?\n\n Why did the government deliberately exclude an independent officer who would give Canadians the assurance that it has got the balance right? Perhaps the government could actually bring in an amendment to ensure that this takes place and that this bill does not become law until that happens.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300709","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, as I have noted before, the government keeps saying that it got the balance right. If it is so certain about that, why did the government not ensure that the Privacy Commissioner is incorporated in the consultation process with the development of Bill C-22?\n\n Why did the government deliberately exclude an independent officer who would give Canadians the assurance that it has got the b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["750adfa2bd66d17e9d200a110e510abe5ee1965576b1edfc43f4469a26b10473"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90536ea4bca94c927d92f515","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300710,"date":"2026-04-20T18:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, to that point, if the government was so sure that it got the balance right, why did it not ensure the Privacy Commissioner could provide their views and recommendations on Bill C-22?\n\n The government was sent packing on Bill C-2 because of overreach, because of the omnibus bill and because Canadian public civil society organizations, civil liberties organizations and privacy advocates all said that the bill was wrong and it was an overreach. The government went back to the drawing board and came back with Bill C-22 on lawful access, but it missed a huge step, making sure the independent officer is incorporated into that consultation process. Why did the government exclude that step?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300710","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, to that point, if the government was so sure that it got the balance right, why did it not ensure the Privacy Commissioner could provide their views and recommendations on Bill C-22?\n\n The government was sent packing on Bill C-2 because of overreach, because of the omnibus bill and because Canadian public civil society organizations, civil liberties organizations and privacy advocates","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a855e969021ce4c61cd1d64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300711,"date":"2026-04-20T18:57:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, of course I am very concerned that there could be overreach.\n\n That is an alarm bell that civil liberties organizations and privacy advocates have actually rung, saying that this is an overreach. They are very worried that instead of targeting a specific act or a specific investigation, this applies to all Canadians across the board as a generalized collection of metadata, of retention and of it being kept in place for a year, with no specific ties to a potential criminal activity. Those are real concerns.\n\nThe government needs to make sure the balance is right, and hence the requirement, in my view, to ensure the Privacy Commissioner's views and recommendations are incorporated into Bill C-22.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300711","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, of course I am very concerned that there could be overreach.\n\n That is an alarm bell that civil liberties organizations and privacy advocates have actually rung, saying that this is an overreach. They are very worried that instead of targeting a specific act or a specific investigation, this applies to all Canadians across the board as a generalized collection of metadata, of retentio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b61a6a9a15b9150252ea01a9d49c0f0ad36416714029b1c231696a7656de3d75"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ded105af06e10372e63ffa0ef7f8398475aeec9a96665d5cf59164ccec1479a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a679ec008f36a2d6d563d427","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300712,"date":"2026-04-20T18:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, on the issue around surveillance, indigenous people bear the brunt of it. We just recently learned that there was secret surveillance of indigenous leaders and indigenous community members. This is happening right now, and we are just learning about it. As we talk about expanding surveillance activities and capabilities, we absolutely need to make sure all the checks and balances are in place and that our basic rights enshrined in the charter are protected.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300712","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, on the issue around surveillance, indigenous people bear the brunt of it. We just recently learned that there was secret surveillance of indigenous leaders and indigenous community members. This is happening right now, and we are just learning about it. As we talk about expanding surveillance activities and capabilities, we absolutely need to make sure all the checks and balances are ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01afaac9aed35333ee7d37165fb78c9bed50cc2e49d69d311051f9a1f8b8b5eb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5ecc2cc39a75d6318621493c841a59f723754a6fa9305d17ea34ee1ca18080c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f868fc737c53ba06dda450d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300713,"date":"2026-04-20T20:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-274, An Act to amend the Citizenship Act and the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.\n\nShe said: Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to introduce an act that would amend the Citizenship Act and the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act. I thank the hon. member for Winnipeg Centre for seconding the bill.\n\n In the previous Parliament, now retired senator Mobina Jaffer brought a bill on this issue, Bill S-235, through the Senate at all its stages. I would like to thank Senator Jaffer and the Our System, Our Children, Our Responsibility coalition for putting a light on this urgent gap in child protection.\n\n Every day an estimated 61,000 children are in and out of care homes in Canada. Like all children, they deserve to have the rights of the child fully respected. They deserve the best of care. When the system fails in its responsibilities to these children, they are exposed to harm.\n\n It is the responsibility of the government to apply for citizenship for children in care who came to Canada as minors, but the government routinely fails to do so. It leaves these young children vulnerable to the cruelty of deportation to a country that they left long ago as minors or that they have no connection to at all. Refugees and protected people face even more severe harms.\n\nThere is a temporary policy in place to address the citizenship of children who are the legal responsibility of the child protection system, but it will expire January 7, 2027. This bill would enshrine a clear path to citizenship for children in care who came to Canada as minors. Children aging out of care already face too many extraordinary barriers.\n\n Parliamentarians should use their powers to protect the rights of some of the most vulnerable children. I urge the government to adopt this bill and see to its swift passage.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-106/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300713","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"moved for leave to introduce Bill C-274, An Act to amend the Citizenship Act and the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.\n\nShe said: Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to introduce an act that would amend the Citizenship Act and the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act. I thank the hon. member for Winnipeg Centre for seconding the bill.\n\n In the previous Parliament, now retired senator Mobina Jaffer b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c788143eec129646f7d394421dce20fc069b604cb7334313f22fa1a2c6032c4d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8ba50f795d9e617d97eadff29ac7342bff8ff80a6d09a95ede17be4c6a330d94"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a82f8e0828763769da130e6c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300703,"date":"2026-04-21T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the high cost of living is fuelled by greedflation, and the Liberals know it. The top 1% now holds nearly a quarter of all wealth, while the bottom 40% scrape by with just over 3%.\n\nOil companies are on track to make $90 billion in windfall profits from Trump's illegal war. Half measures, like a temporary federal gas tax suspension, will not stop this growth inequality.\n\nWill the Prime Minister bring in a windfall profit tax and price caps on gas to stop oil companies from price gouging Canadians, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-107/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300703","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the high cost of living is fuelled by greedflation, and the Liberals know it. The top 1% now holds nearly a quarter of all wealth, while the bottom 40% scrape by with just over 3%.\n\nOil companies are on track to make $90 billion in windfall profits from Trump's illegal war. Half measures, like a temporary federal gas tax suspension, will not stop this growth inequality.\n\nWill the Prim","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["330824e25e607d45be1aa1de90b08afbc4a61c8f0cefce5d121aa41cb364c525"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["002de9afe4acb7654b3733ed36d824b3cf97f33dae593b021b8684f7b5ba800c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b158d77217be9a5f267ebdc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":300701,"date":"2026-04-23T20:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, at a time when gas prices are skyrocketing, the Liberals are quietly slashing $5 billion from promised transit funding to local governments, all part of the Prime Minister's cuts, funding that cities rely on to keep people moving and to fight climate change. That means fewer buses, delayed projects and higher costs for commuters.\n\n Why is the government abandoning working people and municipalities when they need support the most? Will the Prime Minister reverse these reckless cuts in the spring economic update and reinstate the promised stable long-term transit funding, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-109/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300701","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, at a time when gas prices are skyrocketing, the Liberals are quietly slashing $5 billion from promised transit funding to local governments, all part of the Prime Minister's cuts, funding that cities rely on to keep people moving and to fight climate change. That means fewer buses, delayed projects and higher costs for commuters.\n\n Why is the government abandoning working people and m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e776ef3b646278680d072fb5956b133945ae1c5372932016bc3a5a0b890292b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e59ea3ae8271f2d60b8a0990aa2cd0f8295a0f374e81f22292b76b5023dac847"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4ee050f78e759e3b17ad3f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":725190,"date":"2026-04-28T21:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is nothing in the spring economic update on surveillance pricing. There is nothing on excessive tax profits, as oil companies are set to make some $90 billion in excess profits. Meanwhile, two-thirds of the $140 billion for housing is actually for developers in lost revenues. The government does not, in the economic budget, have the wherewithal to ensure that the Right Fit program for people with disabilities will be funded. Only $500,000 is needed to keep the program going for people with disabilities to find a home. \n\nWhy did the government not support people with disabilities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-112/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725190","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is nothing in the spring economic update on surveillance pricing. There is nothing on excessive tax profits, as oil companies are set to make some $90 billion in excess profits. Meanwhile, two-thirds of the $140 billion for housing is actually for developers in lost revenues. The government does not, in the economic budget, have the wherewithal to ensure that the Right Fit progr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","label":"Profitability","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ebdebb487738f93836c741ac25b6884bdf8abe437727280dba9c97a38ab82dda"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba8be8fb2538a3b538ffedf0fa8ab49afd3363c4828cc84586823523354dcdac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Profitability","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036763","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e656afda9ad7666d0162cf2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109956,"date":"2026-05-04T16:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I'm standing in for my colleague Leah Gazan , who was here previously, to add some comments on these amendments. Amendment NDP-12 would change the bill such that the accused must make an application for production, where possible, to the judge before whom the accused is to be or is being tried so that having the same judge is not mandatory. Legal experts have shared with us that this requirement may not be realistic in all jurisdictions, given different capacities and resources, and it could lead to unnecessary stays. That's the motivation behind this amendment, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109956","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I'm standing in for my colleague Leah Gazan , who was here previously, to add some comments on these amendments. Amendment NDP-12 would change the bill such that the accused must make an application for production, where possible, to the judge before whom the accused is to be or is being tried so that having the same judge is not mandatory. Legal experts have shared","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["45bc266c0246eab4da0f6ecfd16c5215065298c8712e5c54c0c2ab01aae58d55"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["305525ef1d20a56928f74213558443f2d4440739351f8386b7825afaee37673e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-732de1cd2201de356214743d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109957,"date":"2026-05-04T16:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Mr. Chair, as with the previous NDP amendments, this would ensure that the complainant has the right to independent legal advice, ensuring that this bill would truly uphold victims' rights and not leave them without protections in court proceedings.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109957","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, as with the previous NDP amendments, this would ensure that the complainant has the right to independent legal advice, ensuring that this bill would truly uphold victims' rights and not leave them without protections in court proceedings.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2ff623e898d9ec31736c2f0d25f19b48d4e8a5b3a20497d817fed7e65b617bc3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a89ffd9123ce972f0e46ed87e5a436ec7ab0c23ccfce8a97a952aae486e6d5b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6d49cada3b505a04b7d29b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109958,"date":"2026-05-04T16:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"It's a joint application.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109958","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's a joint application.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-572e7d141b80cb8f0363c130","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109959,"date":"2026-05-04T16:20:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Once again, this will ensure that input and consent from the complainant must be considered before their records are disclosed in legal proceedings. Many of these amendments are in the interests of the victims, which I think is an important component. While I understand there's a need to expedite, at the same time protecting victims' rights is critical as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109959","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Once again, this will ensure that input and consent from the complainant must be considered before their records are disclosed in legal proceedings. Many of these amendments are in the interests of the victims, which I think is an important component. While I understand there's a need to expedite, at the same time protecting victims' rights is critical as well.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["529bed49d87dbcfadb2de20063f988a757b906dd4f50bd4e05d66420814fe390"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f303a1f704327120c22373e1d5808f1769dd44f0a076e2fa35335f4646d8cbfb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f520077bd22103ef31162f5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109960,"date":"2026-05-04T16:30:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. NDP-15 is related to an earlier NDP amendment. This amendment provides complainants with a clear statutory right to counsel from the outset of the joint application process.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109960","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. NDP-15 is related to an earlier NDP amendment. This amendment provides complainants with a clear statutory right to counsel from the outset of the joint application process.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["57c9d8c9968173f7bd5b5b77500b3ae3cf3e9f5089c727a5de040a4db8c588f1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-baa80c88b43f9c3a6fecc6b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109961,"date":"2026-05-04T17:00:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"NDP-16 is similar to an amendment previously moved. This would extend the procedural protections to all those who are victimized by an intimate partner and would not restrict procedural supports to a limited number of offences. What's important here is that these protections and legal proceedings are in the context of domestic violence and not the particular offence. I hope the committee members would support this, as this request for amendment follows the recommendations of experts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109961","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"NDP-16 is similar to an amendment previously moved. This would extend the procedural protections to all those who are victimized by an intimate partner and would not restrict procedural supports to a limited number of offences. What's important here is that these protections and legal proceedings are in the context of domestic violence and not the particular offence. I hope the committee members w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db3fc649a95201a524126fab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109962,"date":"2026-05-04T17:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"This amendment is based on a recommendation from the National Association of Women and the Law to ensure that victims are not at risk of criminalization for breach of a publication ban whose purpose is to protect the victims themselves. While past legislation has responded to concerns raised by survivors about this issue, experts tell us that these measures have proven to be overly narrow and that this remains a major risk for victims. With this in mind, I urge colleagues to vote in favour of this amendment to uphold victims' rights and to ensure that survivors of violence are not criminalized due to the same publication bans that are supposed to protect them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109962","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This amendment is based on a recommendation from the National Association of Women and the Law to ensure that victims are not at risk of criminalization for breach of a publication ban whose purpose is to protect the victims themselves. While past legislation has responded to concerns raised by survivors about this issue, experts tell us that these measures have proven to be overly narrow and that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a4b7081be84ea5305ce2fb3d1ae65e6d2d32195b00dcc690c578860b4ad61222"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ef57d79b61f36d577a8fa26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109963,"date":"2026-05-04T17:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"I'm sorry, Mr. Chair. I want to make sure that NDP-17.1 is under clause 59.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109963","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm sorry, Mr. Chair. I want to make sure that NDP-17.1 is under clause 59.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036624","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal digital assistant","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036624","label":"Personal digital assistant","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["63edee61f0051b67c97d439f962ff8baf40a4b94028161d5824505d5e0499523"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-364a52c13cede828922d4e3f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109964,"date":"2026-05-04T17:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"I want to make sure that NDP-17.1 is in the package. It comes in clause 59. I want to make sure you have it. It's an updated package.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109964","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to make sure that NDP-17.1 is in the package. It comes in clause 59. I want to make sure you have it. It's an updated package.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945702","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Packaging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945702","label":"Packaging","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1b7355126c8cfc750f190bf61e4316b0ee531946359047d7f77c12a436653698"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d48fa7215fad4513e6bea9af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109965,"date":"2026-05-04T17:05:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Yes. I see the legislative clerk nodding. Thanks.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109965","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes. I see the legislative clerk nodding. Thanks.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-84483961092cc05a5d94a886","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109966,"date":"2026-05-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. This amendment follows a recommendation from the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs to explicitly list indigenous diversion programs as one of the options of alternative measures in the restorative justice framework. This will ensure that alternative measures are culturally appropriate and responsive to the distinct needs and realities of indigenous peoples accused and indigenous victims. We know that successive governments have embraced carceral approaches to public safety, ignoring that indigenous peoples are disproportionately impacted by these approaches, due to a pattern of systemic—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109966","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. This amendment follows a recommendation from the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs to explicitly list indigenous diversion programs as one of the options of alternative measures in the restorative justice framework. This will ensure that alternative measures are culturally appropriate and responsive to the distinct needs and realities of indigenous peoples accused and ind","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f492d47e37ed6e331936cc69762aeda4ed9a20fdec8a2eea9f0f80c9393240a7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c42cedbcac17d06c3634e189a14a41479835d4c146beef480fc993ed9df9e636"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b83683de788b79e1c6c334f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109967,"date":"2026-05-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Sure. I'll just finish up that last thought. I was saying that successive governments often have ignored these approaches due to the pattern of systemic racism in our criminal justice system and the ongoing legacy of residential schools in Canada. While it's reassuring that this bill contains a restorative justice framework, it is essential that we do not ignore the voices of indigenous peoples and that alternative measures incorporate culturally appropriate practices for all indigenous communities. This would help ensure that this bill does not contribute to the systemic racism experienced by indigenous peoples in the criminal justice system. Given the duty of lawmakers to ensure that all legislation aligns with the advancement of reconciliation, I urge my colleagues to vote in favour of this amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109967","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Sure. I'll just finish up that last thought. I was saying that successive governments often have ignored these approaches due to the pattern of systemic racism in our criminal justice system and the ongoing legacy of residential schools in Canada. While it's reassuring that this bill contains a restorative justice framework, it is essential that we do not ignore the voices of indigenous peoples an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["17c0de5c1b90f1439fcb719ef45665c3c54d195075dd9baad21479f76e371587"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["187956ea80d9c9f48ce568fcdb0127adb99125d7f34e2d5da5e0c2a2bd141d99"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-062a18bffca76271e196fc73","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109968,"date":"2026-05-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you. I'm disappointed that—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109968","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. I'm disappointed that—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a156a554316df3553ccd8e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109969,"date":"2026-05-04T17:10:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you. It was disappointing that the last NDP amendment did not go through, as it was really important for the indigenous community. NDP-18 also relates to alternative measures in the restorative justice framework. This amendment would broaden protections for participants in alternative measures so that any statements made by persons alleged to have committed an offence, or by victims, would not result in their criminalization. It is essential that the alternative measures lay this out in the restorative justice framework and that they are not jeopardized due to participants' fears that the statements they make while completing these programs would be used to criminalize them or others. If we're serious about non-carceral approaches to public safety—particularly for indigenous, Black and other people of colour, who are overrepresented in the criminal justice system—we must ensure that these solutions work and are trusted by all who are participating in them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109969","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you. It was disappointing that the last NDP amendment did not go through, as it was really important for the indigenous community. NDP-18 also relates to alternative measures in the restorative justice framework. This amendment would broaden protections for participants in alternative measures so that any statements made by persons alleged to have committed an offence, or by victims, would n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8d320d828b463ad713187359e15a9b06003687d56f0ac15e9f9db4f0dbd67d73"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ee038c15665eb1693ac90e07b09164e9cba39eec15fd8b94cc19828f925325f7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-558267c775c42d052c5a8d40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109970,"date":"2026-05-04T17:15:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. This NDP amendment reflects concerns raised by a range of experts and stakeholders about the Liberals' reinstatement of mandatory minimums, which have repeatedly been struck down by the courts for violating charter rights. This change would ensure that Bill C-16 's safety valve would include the Gladue principles in order to consider non-carceral options for indigenous people and the protection of their charter rights in all cases. This would mean aligning this legislation with the government's commitment to implementing call to action 32 of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and to upholding equality for those overrepresented in prisons, including racialized people, victims and survivors of abuse, and those dealing with mental health and addiction issues. This committee has heard from several legal experts who have recommended amendments to broaden the safety valve in Bill C-16 , including the National Association of Women and the Law, the Women's Legal Education and Action Fund, the Canadian Bar Association and Quebec's bar association. Elected representatives have a duty to uphold our charter and our commitments to reconciliation, so I strongly urge my colleagues to follow the recommendations of legal experts and vote in favour of this amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109970","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. This NDP amendment reflects concerns raised by a range of experts and stakeholders about the Liberals' reinstatement of mandatory minimums, which have repeatedly been struck down by the courts for violating charter rights. This change would ensure that Bill C-16 's safety valve would include the Gladue principles in order to consider non-carceral options for indigen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9b9578be8f8663b9446ba958bd9a58e6d277e5f654931a5077411bc1d09ae625"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["89fbecad5e72f40386a513ea791440f52a65f86d0375cdcc472e01a60e32ae50"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-134ccc17e79b5fec9ce27c41","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109971,"date":"2026-05-04T18:50:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. NDP-20 is similar to the last NDP amendment. This would eliminate Bill C-16 's exception to the safety valve for particular offences, which currently increases the likelihood of charter rights violations, particularly for racialized people, who are overrepresented in the criminal justice system. We cannot pick and choose when it comes to charter rights. We must ensure that they are upheld for everyone, so I urge my colleagues to vote in favour of this amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109971","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. NDP-20 is similar to the last NDP amendment. This would eliminate Bill C-16 's exception to the safety valve for particular offences, which currently increases the likelihood of charter rights violations, particularly for racialized people, who are overrepresented in the criminal justice system. We cannot pick and choose when it comes to charter rights. We must ensu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35f2f42b5069288ba8c274f48b412be69b92b17bcf072d7c2ed1ff35512b13da"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ec70e4d63d0304bc4349a4cd1e8a1066252ddf6caf85ce5b7ab0df6ad34c44c4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1bb02790d2d03ac4f084b6c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109972,"date":"2026-05-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. NDP-21, as with the previous NDP amendments, would extend protections in legal proceedings to all those victimized by intimate partners and not just for a limited number of offences.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109972","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. NDP-21, as with the previous NDP amendments, would extend protections in legal proceedings to all those victimized by intimate partners and not just for a limited number of offences.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bb5b81e6361d2d4caeaa2dabc7243ba1e4e4456362d07ce88386198ebfc5dbc0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["052d8afcf0159b0866516a62ee95f8b0f629ae6b2edd3ead21612ccbe38e2d43"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-506bcf92bfdaaec6fa45688c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109973,"date":"2026-05-04T21:30:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Again, similar to previous NDP amendments, this would extend protections in legal proceedings to all those victimized by their intimate partners, and not restrict protections to a limited number of offences. In echoing the recommendations of the National Association of Women and the Law, New Democrats are committed to ensuring that survivors of all forms of intimate partner abuse are protected while testifying in court. We urge all parties to vote in favour of this amendment to ensure these protections are in place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109973","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Again, similar to previous NDP amendments, this would extend protections in legal proceedings to all those victimized by their intimate partners, and not restrict protections to a limited number of offences. In echoing the recommendations of the National Association of Women and the Law, New Democrats are committed to ensuring that survivors of all forms of intimate partner a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4c7d2e3ac6870028146da1892258e517e60b5556dc53b50ec7c7a413bfe44914"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1433fe127d71d5adb93591ea05cbb91b936cc2f226505f1b7ba3a2c8d978e8b8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99fa806903d90a4b92ab4082","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109974,"date":"2026-05-04T21:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. This amendment reflects a suggestion from the National Association of Women and the Law to strengthen language in this bill around weapons prohibitions as a condition of recognizance for offenders in intimate partner violence cases. Experts from the National Association of Women and the Law have told us that it is essential to close loopholes in the Firearms Act that continue to endanger survivors of intimate partner violence. I urge my colleagues to support this amendment and protect women and gender-diverse people from gun violence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109974","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. This amendment reflects a suggestion from the National Association of Women and the Law to strengthen language in this bill around weapons prohibitions as a condition of recognizance for offenders in intimate partner violence cases. Experts from the National Association of Women and the Law have told us that it is essential to close loopholes in the Firearms Act tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["460401c8e9961a110603237acdaea130476edb9269deadb699deba5a8ee7ed1f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28aba6bad24b8e06c6353306","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109975,"date":"2026-05-04T21:40:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Amendment NDP-24 would create a \"for greater clarity\" clause so that measures surrounding procedural protections for victims come into force on the same day as the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109975","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Amendment NDP-24 would create a \"for greater clarity\" clause so that measures surrounding procedural protections for victims come into force on the same day as the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d357135bf0d0408ad5b705231fc0c0b70f8ca55a7d52a04abb9b203fc91305c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0a7642f5db72384440cc31c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109976,"date":"2026-05-04T21:45:00+00:00","title":"JUST","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"JUST","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Legal experts and civil liberty groups from across Canada have raised strong concerns about the implications of clause 46. That includes the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, the David Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights, the Criminal Lawyers' Association of Ontario, Barreau du Québec, the Women's Legal Education and Action Fund, and the Canadian Bar Association. This clause would violate the Supreme Court decision in Regina v. Rahey, which clearly determined that a stay is the minimum remedy for a section 11(b) charter violation. As currently drafted, Bill C-16 sets a precedent where the government can decide what the remedy is for a charter violation and overrule a Supreme Court of Canada decision in doing so. This is a threat to our Constitution and to our democracy, where the government itself dictates the consequences, if any, for its violations of charter rights. The most recent comprehensive parliamentary study on trial delay in Canada, the 2017 report by the Standing Senate Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs, explicitly recommended that the Minister of Justice seek a reference from the Supreme Court on any proposed changes to the remedy for section 11(b) to ensure that they would be constitutional, which is what this amendment would require of the minister. If the government is confident that this legislation is constitutionally valid, it should have no problem accepting this NDP amendment to Bill C-16 .","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/JUST/meeting-28/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109976","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Legal experts and civil liberty groups from across Canada have raised strong concerns about the implications of clause 46. That includes the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, the David Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights, the Criminal Lawyers' Association of Ontario, Barreau du Québec, the Women's Legal Education and Action Fund, and the Canadian Bar Association. This ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["61a5569ece2ca3d890b59cefb38cf194ac5e831b700171b92298f1a688febbda"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd87df012053ccbd3a26d2bea786a647d70c2ee7b0a53127daa3e2864d2d6a71"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47f191725070d034f4083cca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035000,"date":"2026-05-25T20:10:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister told Canadians, \"we don't want to hear what people are against; we want to hear what they're for\". He has abandoned the environment. He is gaslighting environmental groups that have been calling for renewable energy for decades. No wonder the former environment minister resigned and Liberal MPs feel they can raise their concerns only anonymously. This is an authoritarian approach, not democracy.\n\nWill the Prime Minister stop his bullying tactics, the sidelining of indigenous leaders who dare to disagree with him, or do they need to do what Danielle Smith is doing: threaten to hold a referendum to separate from Canada?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035000","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister told Canadians, \"we don't want to hear what people are against; we want to hear what they're for\". He has abandoned the environment. He is gaslighting environmental groups that have been calling for renewable energy for decades. No wonder the former environment minister resigned and Liberal MPs feel they can raise their concerns only anonymously. This is an authorit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cdfead4144b1a119379102cb9e1e609bc0c907bbfecbb64422125a754c0cdd87"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc760a526a1b581eefbbb465","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035001,"date":"2026-05-25T20:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP agrees to apply the vote, and we are voting no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035001","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP agrees to apply the vote, and we are voting no.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b65943cb58171497ab2759e7ebddf6bd35927ccf97639308bd10b8cfac2144dc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf1f34893b94ae6ac17a65a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035002,"date":"2026-05-25T20:31:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP agrees to apply the vote, and we are voting yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035002","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP agrees to apply the vote, and we are voting yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e295e0357fdd2fd1a8736d914b88049a062c68004913833b232330881412706"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ed98c73bd8f354a7e8c3b98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035003,"date":"2026-05-25T20:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition signed by over 13,000 people about prolonged security screening delays for PR applicants.\n\n Internal IRCC projections reveal that PR applications referred for comprehensive security screening are projected to take nearly 65 months, which is over five years, to complete. I have so many constituents who are faced with this problem.\n\nThe petitioners point out that the applicants from certain countries of origin face indefinite, non-transparent delays, that these delays cause severe harm, including prolonged family separation, mental health crises and significant financial burdens, and that the applicants lack meaningful recourse or transparent case information.\n\n The petitioners call on the House for a number of measures to ensure accountability and transparency, so that people will know what is going on with their file. They want the reporting of data and for an independent immigration ombudsperson to investigate chronic delays and provide a formal escalation channel.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035003","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to present a petition signed by over 13,000 people about prolonged security screening delays for PR applicants.\n\n Internal IRCC projections reveal that PR applications referred for comprehensive security screening are projected to take nearly 65 months, which is over five years, to complete. I have so many constituents who are faced with this problem.\n\nThe petitioners point out","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["168b9d6e0b6f77dc279e9c702df371c971601c4477659603df3ad92e33b54dc3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55447502d354461e8e06cecd30f693f91a16d798c5c4b01a0fa0d06a8a1fd313"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6597eddf4c8f662e26df36a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035004,"date":"2026-05-25T23:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am sharing my time with the member for Trois-Rivières.\n\n Let me start with a quote that says, for all my life, I have been a Liberal who believed in rights, equity and an independent foreign policy. Since 1982, the charter gave us something that transcended party...courts that could check governments, refugee protection as obligation, reconciliation as shared responsibility. \"The story is being re-written. The language hasn't changed. Ministers still invoke the Charter, the 'rules-based order'.... But...what's actually happening....\" Asylum seekers are cut off before they reach a hearing, immigration detention is relocated into a federal prison, climate architecture is quietly dismantled, indigenous funding is eroded by inflation and international law is treated as optional when inconvenient. \"The Liberal convention in Montreal confirmed the direction...security, defence, and major project....\" Election reform was rejected. \"Small-l liberals...are running out of political space. Their values haven't disappeared. The party that used to carry them is just moving on.\"\n\nThose are the comments of the Hon. Dr. Lloyd Axworthy, a former Liberal foreign affairs minister. I think he is reflecting the views of many progressives in Canada. \n\nAfter the tabling of the spring economic update, the headline of Althia Raj's opinion piece in the Toronto Star, which names the Prime Minister, reads, \"[He] has forgotten who helped get him elected\". Her article opens with this, \"If one thing is clear from [the Prime Minister's] economic update this week, it's that he's taking progressive voters for granted.\"\n\nIndeed the months since the fall 2025 budget have confirmed a hard truth. The Prime Minister is governing like a centralizing conservative. The warning signs were already in the budget itself: public service cuts, reduced immigration targets and a growing emphasis on sovereignty spending including defence. The NDP flagged it as an austerity-leaning framework at a time when Canadians were struggling with unaffordability, unemployment and rising costs. \n\nSince then, the direction has only hardened. This government has overridden labour action, forcing striking workers back on the job, drawing fierce backlash from unions. It has pursued international trade and so-called nation-building legislation with Conservative support while sidelining indigenous rights and environmental standards. It has cut or constrained programs in areas like science, foreign aid, community support and public services, all while expanding military commitments and giving big corporations significant tax incentives and benefits as they continue to make record excessive profits. Day by day, it is becoming clearer that this is not progressive governance, but the consolidation of power, decision-making and priorities that tilt toward the market, megaprojects and militarization over people. It is a government that asks its working people to tighten their belts while opening the fiscal floodgates for defence and corporate-led growth. That is not balance; it is a political choice, and one that looks increasingly conservative by the day.\n\n The spring economic update saw health care spending cut as Canadians continue to struggle to find a doctor. The provinces and territories that did not sign on to the pharmacare deal that the NDP forced the Liberals to move forward on before the last election will likely not get an agreement. Meanwhile, mental health funding will not be renewed. The chronic underfunding for mental health and addictions continues. The highly touted dedicated funding for transit has been axed. Support for many critical services, including the Right Fit program for people with disabilities, will sunset. \n\nCanadians are worried about their future and are facing an everyday emergency to keep costs down. Instead of taking bold action that would actually make a difference in people's lives, the Prime Minister is relying on the private sector to save us. In fact, the spring economic update ensures the private sector is the biggest beneficiary in this affordability crisis. With the creation of a $25‐billion sovereign wealth fund, Canadians will see public funds shuffled into privately owned projects that will make a few wealthy investors and CEOs richer than they already are, including big oil and gas companies that are poised to reap over $90 billion in profits this year alone. The Prime Minister's approach is to take public tax dollars to subsidize private projects all while income inequality is at a record high. \n\nCanada's wealth inequality report by Oxfam Canada cited that in 2025, there were approximately 89 billionaires in Canada. The report further noted that the richest 1% have a net worth of $7 million and above, and they hold nearly $3.9 trillion in wealth, almost as much as the bottom 80% combined. This is just plain wrong. The Prime Minister invoked the example of Norway's sovereign wealth fund, and the banker PM is doing the mirror image of what Norway did.\n\nIn contrast, Norway's success is built on state-led development. It directed its resource revenues into a sovereign wealth fund that is now worth over $2 trillion U.S., investing in green energy and initiatives and securing Norway's social safety net. Canada once had a similar opportunity with the state-owned Petro-Canada, but the Conservatives began the privatization process and the Liberals finished it off, costing Canadians a vital source of national wealth.\n\nInstead of filling the pockets of big oil and gas companies, the NDP wants to see a windfall tax on oil and gas companies that are projected to make over $90 billion in profits this year alone because of Trump's illegal war in Iran, and use that money to grow the sovereign wealth fund to benefit Canadians.\n\nThis past week the Prime Minister told Canadians at the Greater Vancouver Board of Trade, \"We don't want to hear what people are against. We want to hear what they're for. And if you're for something, we will get behind [it].\"\n\nHe is delegitimizing the work of environmental groups and climate defenders who have been calling for green energy and infrastructure for decades. He is also threatening provinces and sidelining indigenous rights at the same time. Is it a wonder that the former minister of environment, the member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie, resigned from cabinet? Now 14 Liberal MPs have written a letter anonymously, raising their concerns. If the Prime Minister can make such a comment to the Canadian public, one can only imagine how his cabinet is treated behind closed doors if any of them dare to voice their opposition.\n\nThe Prime Minister was the UN special envoy on climate action and finance, which championed integrating climate risks into mainstream financial decision-making. He called for faster decarbonization.\n\nIn 2015, Canada played an important role in the signing of the 2015 Paris Agreement. We agreed to lower emissions by 45% by 2030, a key deadline and organizing principle for the climate strategy. To achieve this, the main pillars of Canada's pan-Canadian framework for climate change included carbon pricing, an EV mandate, an emissions cap on the oil sands and clean energy growth. The consumer industrial carbon pricing was to reach $170 per tonne by 2030. The EV mandate was to see that 60% of vehicle sales were EVs by 2030 and 100% by 2025. The emissions cap on the oil sands was to be 45%. \n\nThose targets have all been cancelled or delayed by a decade. Clean energy growth was watered down. Deadlines were pushed back. Instead of faster decarbonization, the Prime Minister signed a new agreement with Danielle Smith to build a new pipeline that would emit 160 megatonnes of carbon dioxide, 10 times more emissions than with its carbon capture project.\n\nCanada will not meet its climate goals by 2030. The Canadian Climate Institute is saying Canada will not get to net zero by 2050. The Prime Minister has abandoned climate, plain and simple, and what did we get for that? It was not unity but a referendum for Alberta to separate from Canada.\n\nMoreover, Canada is on a path to significantly increase defence spending to 5% of GDP. We have barely had public debate about this, nor was this talked about during the election. National security matters, but so does economic security. At the very same time as we are considering major increases in defence spending, we are also hearing about fiscal restraint, about the need to limit spending in other areas.\n\nLet us be clear. When the government makes these choices, it falls hardest on people who rely on affordable housing, on the health care system, on income supports, on child care, on mental health and on accessible public services. It falls on middle-income and low-income Canadians. It falls on renters and on young people trying to get ahead. In other words, without careful and deliberate policy design, those trade-offs can deepen inequality.\n\nWe know policy choices can make a difference in people's lives. This is what the Prime Minister is doing. He is trading off the needs of Canadians for the oil and gas companies, which are already making billions and billions in profits.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035004","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am sharing my time with the member for Trois-Rivières.\n\n Let me start with a quote that says, for all my life, I have been a Liberal who believed in rights, equity and an independent foreign policy. Since 1982, the charter gave us something that transcended party...courts that could check governments, refugee protection as obligation, reconciliation as shared responsibility. \"The st","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80ab04a79755ae6ac9b422dda37f6544429c61c9a8e47acb7d96ebcd46606431"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6a9cac5440d860c6b6926a0a7981ed934bad686cea8968761972ac448e77215c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04308295a10c0219ea9eae0c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035005,"date":"2026-05-25T23:35:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will tell you what the NDP stands for. The NDP stands for calling on the government to actually impose an excessive profit tax on the oil and gas companies, which are poised to make over $90 billion just this year alone in profits. That money should go into the sovereign wealth fund. That money should go into green energy initiatives. That money should be going into supporting Canadians who are struggling with the affordability crisis.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035005","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will tell you what the NDP stands for. The NDP stands for calling on the government to actually impose an excessive profit tax on the oil and gas companies, which are poised to make over $90 billion just this year alone in profits. That money should go into the sovereign wealth fund. That money should go into green energy initiatives. That money should be going into supporting Canad","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b78e413b007dff0abb2e8a8011677c0ff81e35cb7b13e484de0670cb9ee36033"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d84e7d7810044d2b2f62da5456271001162cf5c74ba2fb82438f1e0e30deec0b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7437e8fc86910e57e5a65e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035006,"date":"2026-05-25T23:38:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is no question that the affordability crisis is hitting everybody. In my riding of Vancouver East as well, people are struggling to get by. What the NDP cannot accept is an economy where wealth continues to concentrate at the top, where opportunity narrows for too many and where public policy moves in ways that risk reinforcing that divide. This is not inevitable. It is the result of the political decisions of the Prime Minister, and it is within our power to choose a different path. The NDP chooses a different path. We say, let us levy an excessive profit tax for those who are making billions of dollars at the expense of Canadians who are struggling to get by.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035006","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is no question that the affordability crisis is hitting everybody. In my riding of Vancouver East as well, people are struggling to get by. What the NDP cannot accept is an economy where wealth continues to concentrate at the top, where opportunity narrows for too many and where public policy moves in ways that risk reinforcing that divide. This is not inevitable. It is the resu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["95d82c2c7b912d8837865012ab4aae867099e096733b356cdcac07d660c15c34"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f911f87b8f7201865582a1e7d224c554333999a936362f9bf3de1e3aa4177df9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-92f1e9226049086edf9b0511","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035007,"date":"2026-05-25T23:39:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, there is no question that I am deeply disappointed and deeply concerned that the Prime Minister has abandoned the indigenous community. He is riding roughshod over and sidelining their indigenous rights, as have been enshrined in the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. On the housing side, the government, in the economic update, actually ensured that the private sector would be the biggest beneficiary of the spring economic update. Of the $140 billion for measures toward housing, two-thirds is actually targeted toward the private sector in the way of benefits, tax incentives and so on. Only a small fraction of the money would actually be invested in building housing. So much for building faster and more for the Canadians who need housing the most.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035007","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, there is no question that I am deeply disappointed and deeply concerned that the Prime Minister has abandoned the indigenous community. He is riding roughshod over and sidelining their indigenous rights, as have been enshrined in the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. On the housing side, the government, in the economic update, actually ensured that the private sector","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["18326f63d1db100a51ee594df88215e26fafe375403f5a086921d9cd5baa80e3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["442e515dc7140c152313b729c7a9638680c321a0b97ebe1357c9e40754661405"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b960371f6b50243c10a096d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1035008,"date":"2026-05-25T23:41:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, of course the NDP supports workers. We are not the party that will legislate them back to work. We are not the party that will run roughshod over workers. We are not the party that is pretending to engage in a consultative process about major changes to the Canada Labour Code without the meaningful participation from labour. This is what the Liberals are doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-121/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035008","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, of course the NDP supports workers. We are not the party that will legislate them back to work. We are not the party that will run roughshod over workers. We are not the party that is pretending to engage in a consultative process about major changes to the Canada Labour Code without the meaningful participation from labour. This is what the Liberals are doing.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6e5960f7407f5faf543a90fefd68b079cadcd59ace4580f49705c8e978412e0f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["963b93dba8ef90ba1b4ae4eead5d031ffb2a77c3e44ccd0aaf03a0e639f03045"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9be92ff4e5c58e241394c9ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034998,"date":"2026-05-26T20:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the fossil fuel lobby had at least 17 direct meetings with the Prime Minister and environmental groups had zero. The Prime Minister axed the carbon tax, abandoned the emissions cap, killed the EV mandate, signed a deal to build a new pipeline, stepped up on greenwashing, took a sledgehammer to regulatory reviews, created a $25-billion wealth fund that will no doubt benefit the oil and gas industry and refused to impose an excess profit tax when companies are poised to make over $90 billion in profit this year alone. \n\nCan the Prime Minister tell Canadians what else the oil and gas industry wants?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-122/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034998","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the fossil fuel lobby had at least 17 direct meetings with the Prime Minister and environmental groups had zero. The Prime Minister axed the carbon tax, abandoned the emissions cap, killed the EV mandate, signed a deal to build a new pipeline, stepped up on greenwashing, took a sledgehammer to regulatory reviews, created a $25-billion wealth fund that will no doubt benefit the oil and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["952c52c4809ec1faca5561f5d7c73d95c36591331b8a43ac11622237bd8cf86e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ed2060e50f2bbd0598bfd0677522daf59492ef17f8cf29b78b3f5967c3a2cbe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc2c9f5207e7d4190130fd2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034996,"date":"2026-05-27T21:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table a petition from constituents of the riding of LaSalle—Émard—Verdun, because the constituents tell me their MP would not table it. \n\nThe petitioners note that Canada acceded to the Arms Trade Treaty in 2019, committing to prevent the transfer of arms where there is a substantial risk that they could be used in human rights abuses, war crimes or crimes against humanity. They also note that a significant loophole in Canada's export laws currently allows Canadian-made weapons, parts and components to be exported to the United States, from where they may be transferred to third countries. They note that international bodies, including the UN Human Rights Council, and independent UN experts have called on all states to halt arms transfers where there is a substantial risk of their use in violations of international humanitarian law. \n\nTherefore, the petitioners are calling on the House of Commons to enact legislation to close existing loopholes in Canada's arms export laws, including removing exemptions for the U.S., strengthening oversight and ensuring that Canadian arms are never used to commit or facilitate human rights abuses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-123/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034996","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table a petition from constituents of the riding of LaSalle—Émard—Verdun, because the constituents tell me their MP would not table it. \n\nThe petitioners note that Canada acceded to the Arms Trade Treaty in 2019, committing to prevent the transfer of arms where there is a substantial risk that they could be used in human rights abuses, war crimes or crimes against humanity. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b63a99e8de83f59486583cd9575cad2a9f13d0871f32eeb30811805a89523433"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6539bb59f8da8c9f714600b47c92980eae239ba1aeb74fee2220ad88b94e613b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be791db8c34865255889c77e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034976,"date":"2026-05-28T15:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise to table two petitions today. The first is in support of the Indian Residential School Survivors Society.\n\nThe petition has been signed by more than 2,600 people calling on the Government of Canada to honour the TRC calls to action and the national inquiry for women and girls.\n\nPetitioners are calling for the government to respect residential school survivors, their families and their communities. They call on the government to keep its promises to avoid gaps in survivor-centred services. They call for sustained and stable core funding for the Indian Residential School Survivors Society to prevent program lapses, including funding for indigenous-led healing, wellness and crisis support programs related to residential school impacts. They also call on the government to work with the society, the indigenous community and partners for a stable, long-term framework that reflects the actual service needs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034976","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise to table two petitions today. The first is in support of the Indian Residential School Survivors Society.\n\nThe petition has been signed by more than 2,600 people calling on the Government of Canada to honour the TRC calls to action and the national inquiry for women and girls.\n\nPetitioners are calling for the government to respect residential school survivors, their families ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3ed23c50b332da2e8628ade100834d84edc34c1ee2be2e4d20c4e93761229e4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c6dd6850abc9f7db44ceeea0ea8cdd6c94404315018e0440755bce834db31c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d30e97eebdb4ede9053f2ad6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034977,"date":"2026-05-28T15:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the second petition I am tabling is signed by Canadians from communities including Vancouver, Surrey, Toronto, Ottawa and Gatineau.\n\nPetitioners are concerned that Trump's military is bombarding small boats and their crews in the Caribbean and in the Pacific Ocean, claiming without evidence that they are narco-terrorists. Such actions are illegal, they have noted, yet Canadian-made equipment has been used to commit these extrajudicial killings, due to the massive loophole in Canada's arms export laws.\n\nWhereas Canada respects the rule of law, the petitioners therefore call on the Canadian government to require the same rules of licensing of Canadian military exports to Trump's military that are applied to every other country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034977","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the second petition I am tabling is signed by Canadians from communities including Vancouver, Surrey, Toronto, Ottawa and Gatineau.\n\nPetitioners are concerned that Trump's military is bombarding small boats and their crews in the Caribbean and in the Pacific Ocean, claiming without evidence that they are narco-terrorists. Such actions are illegal, they have noted, yet Canadian-made ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","label":"Hazardous materials transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1b5cf7437ba1f2e56a88a23e9c95ae7f0acdc732c1d475bb3f506a844d99787d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9e80f949837ff03dd466060b00f4ec29c5914d122c5e9ba185f912f27d60fc85"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9396af2227d4c7f187a14b0c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034978,"date":"2026-05-29T03:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, there is a requirement for cabinet to ensure an ongoing review of the safe third country agreement. Has cabinet reviewed the safe third country agreement since the U.S. implemented mandatory detention without review by a judge for large categories of the refugee claimants returned to the U.S., third-country pass-through deportations and deportations under the dubious asylum co-operative agreements?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034978","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, there is a requirement for cabinet to ensure an ongoing review of the safe third country agreement. Has cabinet reviewed the safe third country agreement since the U.S. implemented mandatory detention without review by a judge for large categories of the refugee claimants returned to the U.S., third-country pass-through deportations and deportations under the dubious asylum co-operative","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e68615166d9232be123569df24a8cab37dbdf0517c2ed20bd51f83cffc1f2f16"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9939ff81895b05256fc61786","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034980,"date":"2026-05-29T03:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, it is a yes-or-no question.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034980","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, it is a yes-or-no question.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc375f5099e49490dcb3e928","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034982,"date":"2026-05-29T03:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, all the minister has to say is that, yes, they have reviewed it or no.\n\nIf the cabinet has not, and it is a requirement of cabinet, can the minister confirm that the government has delegated it down with it going to cabinet when the circumstances warrant?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034982","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, all the minister has to say is that, yes, they have reviewed it or no.\n\nIf the cabinet has not, and it is a requirement of cabinet, can the minister confirm that the government has delegated it down with it going to cabinet when the circumstances warrant?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec837e97c598c7cf17609762f739bc0079012e1f1cf9b2c568ca6405728b6a58"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-942917306c527574a9a61409","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034983,"date":"2026-05-29T03:24:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"That is a no, then.\n\nMr. Chair, is the minister maintaining data on ICE detention for individuals Canada transferred to U.S. authorities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034983","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"That is a no, then.\n\nMr. Chair, is the minister maintaining data on ICE detention for individuals Canada transferred to U.S. authorities?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a186a02d91fb9c65b283616b5e88c777d91d75169aee0338d3441ffc364f8d74"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e2397f603e0d4a0e45702046","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034984,"date":"2026-05-29T03:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, is the minister maintaining the data?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034984","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, is the minister maintaining the data?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f5bc80dc9397663d6ffeb58f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034986,"date":"2026-05-29T03:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"And the answer is also no.\n\nMr. Chair, is the minister monitoring the use of ACAs for individuals returned to the U.S. under the safe third country agreement in violation of the safe third country agreement? Has the minister requested assurances from the U.S. authorities that ACAs are not in use for detainees?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034986","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"And the answer is also no.\n\nMr. Chair, is the minister monitoring the use of ACAs for individuals returned to the U.S. under the safe third country agreement in violation of the safe third country agreement? Has the minister requested assurances from the U.S. authorities that ACAs are not in use for detainees?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d10bb5abde3b9849ffaaf7b709f83ac4d2e75a7e79b9dae3d188ed3acfc5c31e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a56142cde21a8f96a2be4fde","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034987,"date":"2026-05-29T03:26:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, 130 highly qualified Palestinian postgrad students have waited for two years for their study visa with no decision or timeline. Many face requirements that are impossible to meet under the war conditions, including biometrics and extended security screening. \n\nFrance, Ireland, Belgium and Germany successfully evacuated students who received university scholarships without pre-departure biometrics. They granted emergency entry travel documents and deferred standard biometric collection. Will the minister do the same?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034987","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, 130 highly qualified Palestinian postgrad students have waited for two years for their study visa with no decision or timeline. Many face requirements that are impossible to meet under the war conditions, including biometrics and extended security screening. \n\nFrance, Ireland, Belgium and Germany successfully evacuated students who received university scholarships without pre-departure ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","label":"Scholarships","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["49971aabf7faf61c3390684117a726abb93f6904a456534d7725abd85c105905"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a1c86265cde668a575d6f52cb51e32103dab9896f00c63e3e13f2a260fa6cbd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77397d74cb0ed365f93e9271","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034989,"date":"2026-05-29T03:27:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, with the special immigration measure for Gazans to date, how many names has the government submitted to the governments of Israel and Egypt to request official exit clearance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034989","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, with the special immigration measure for Gazans to date, how many names has the government submitted to the governments of Israel and Egypt to request official exit clearance?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5601593bdd42de40a555fdaa80cf2d327d5aec9333255daa28eb20fd623bbd3e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ec5cd3c9b68e2d21ef0f10c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034990,"date":"2026-05-29T03:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, that was not my question. I am asking how many names have been submitted to the Israeli and Egyptian authorities. Maybe her officials can help her.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034990","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, that was not my question. I am asking how many names have been submitted to the Israeli and Egyptian authorities. Maybe her officials can help her.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f9a3d1fa808bee6cf8eb1ae57233a44a8e90d3ad00e8673288f5b672fa82a57"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b92e2897d7c9ef2a5b22cbb9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034991,"date":"2026-05-29T03:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I would ask the minister not to waste my time, I only have seven and a half minutes. I would like her to answer the question. \n\nWhat was the last date the government submitted names, and how many have been processed since the ceasefire?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034991","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I would ask the minister not to waste my time, I only have seven and a half minutes. I would like her to answer the question. \n\nWhat was the last date the government submitted names, and how many have been processed since the ceasefire?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be6cc4b2048009ec71afb97d38ff090490b2e8a9a362aaaced9c68281ddc870c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fcd3c1f1b83fd013d200ad6f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034992,"date":"2026-05-29T03:28:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, will the minister offer biometric solutions and alternatives for this program?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034992","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, will the minister offer biometric solutions and alternatives for this program?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73b11e98aec7827cb834e2b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034993,"date":"2026-05-29T03:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, the minister is having trouble answering questions, so let me try a different tack. Can the minister advise us on how many applications are in the backlog for the special immigration measure for Hong Kongers for stream A and B and for the special immigration measures for Ukraine and Sudan?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034993","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, the minister is having trouble answering questions, so let me try a different tack. Can the minister advise us on how many applications are in the backlog for the special immigration measure for Hong Kongers for stream A and B and for the special immigration measures for Ukraine and Sudan?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["157ffb29231510990841a2bf9a1d6b331b20c145ee3dc8dd96375c08981ac68e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1b06af18ece13202b05d02e4e3b4fdaa1d365944999965643352afc07a0e30b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be90b0ac709e96dc59c112a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034994,"date":"2026-05-29T03:29:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, I am getting a migraine. I am actually asking for the backlog numbers. Will the minister answer the question?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034994","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, I am getting a migraine. I am actually asking for the backlog numbers. Will the minister answer the question?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8f6e791cb53b3f570a89349","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1034995,"date":"2026-05-29T03:30:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Chair, it is no wonder the Conservatives are calling for that minister's resignation. She cannot answer one question in seven and a half minutes. Since the immigration levels plan has put all three of these groups under the H and C and other category quota, how long does the minister think it will take to process all these applications?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-124/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034995","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mr. Chair, it is no wonder the Conservatives are calling for that minister's resignation. She cannot answer one question in seven and a half minutes. Since the immigration levels plan has put all three of these groups under the H and C and other category quota, how long does the minister think it will take to process all these applications?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e1688055942af58d4b854b80cfdbf2866d0a8c44681a0b36a6eff606fbd6f0c1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7bd064cb18a3a0232ebd67a73388eef771953374d4c7f5073c00290150f3ab70"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e17efd229d64ebd8ed0b14f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083807,"date":"2026-06-01T20:11:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, Canada signed a police co-operation agreement with China behind closed doors. The RCMP reportedly revealed that Canada cannot publicly disclose details of the MOU without Beijing's approval. The foreign affairs minister said she spoke frankly with the Chinese foreign affairs minister about human rights abuses, foreign interference and transnational repression activities last week.\n\n China has a history of weaponizing shared intelligence such as Operation Fox Hunt. Will the minister be frank with Canadians and tell us whether she asked China's permission to release the MOU, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-126/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083807","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, Canada signed a police co-operation agreement with China behind closed doors. The RCMP reportedly revealed that Canada cannot publicly disclose details of the MOU without Beijing's approval. The foreign affairs minister said she spoke frankly with the Chinese foreign affairs minister about human rights abuses, foreign interference and transnational repression activities last week.\n\n C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","label":"Security intelligence","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be1aee551f5078bdb48795f1d612b74abb3fd4101a606c09ac0ee9d537e54d44"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5229d1edbf73a649c6bbcbf1050bb5d24b5418a8c7a31c327921da54a1c48799"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ef94975a672a81c7276ca3d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083805,"date":"2026-06-02T20:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I asked the immigration minister if she would do what France, Ireland, Belgium and Germany had done and evacuate 130 Palestinian students with university acceptance and scholarships with deferred biometrics and grant them emergency travel documents. The minister said, \"we have directed officials to accelerate the student visa processing for people in Gaza, and I can confirm the decision will be made now, and in fact all...will be completed in the next 10 days.\" \n\nI am now learning that is not true. Either the minister was deliberately misleading, or she is inept and has no clue what is going on. Will the Prime Minister just fire her already?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083805","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I asked the immigration minister if she would do what France, Ireland, Belgium and Germany had done and evacuate 130 Palestinian students with university acceptance and scholarships with deferred biometrics and grant them emergency travel documents. The minister said, \"we have directed officials to accelerate the student visa processing for people in Gaza, and I can confirm the decisi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["27bcdf67c5aa55c8da0a42f1f9342a03b9064509cb9ee842af981c041396593b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21bd002b5a9b2033080b7e5dd4c96d2702a1ab2bc701ebf31d9dabd0c416c0a4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4860d09b808cf1c033051df4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083806,"date":"2026-06-02T20:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on a question of privilege concerning information provided to Parliament by the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship during committee of the whole proceedings on Thursday, May 28, 2026. During those proceedings, I asked the minister about approximately 130 Palestinian graduate students from Gaza who have been waiting for nearly two years for decisions on their study permit applications. I noted that many face requirements that are impossible to satisfy under war conditions, including biometrics collection and prolonged security screening. I further noted that several countries, including France, Ireland, Belgium and Germany, have adopted flexible measures to facilitate the arrival of scholarship recipients from Gaza. \n\nI then asked the minister whether Canada would do the same. In response, the minister stated, \"we have directed officials to accelerate the student visa processing for people in Gaza, and I can confirm that decisions will be made now, and in fact all...will be completed in the next 10 days.\" While part of the minister's answer was delivered off microphone and is not fully reflected in the transcript, it is audible in the video recording of the proceedings. I heard the minister make those comments in the chamber. Given the significance of the statement, I subsequently reviewed the recording and confirmed what I heard. The minister's response was not vague. It was not aspirational. It was not framed as a hope or expectation. The minister informed Parliament that officials had been directed to accelerate processing and that decisions would be completed within 10 days.\n\n As members of Parliament, we are entitled to rely upon information provided by the ministers during parliamentary proceedings. Indeed, our ability to hold the government to account depends upon it. Following the minister's statement, I understood that decisions on these applications would be forthcoming within the time frame identified by the minister. I communicated accordingly with stakeholders and advocates who have been working tirelessly on behalf of these students. However, information subsequently received has raised serious concerns regarding the accuracy of the minister's statement to Parliament. \n\nJust today, I have learned that officials in the minister's department are saying that the minister's response regarding a completion in the next 10 days is not the case, as I have been contacted by Canadian advocates for the students who wrote me today to say, \"We just met with an IRCC representative this morning and it doesn't sound like they will follow through on this.\" The students' advocates told me that officials said to them that there is no 10-day timeline. This was further confirmed by advocates and university professors at a meeting that took place from noon to 1 p.m. today. Therefore, this is my earliest opportunity to raise the matter. This information shared at this meeting with four members of Parliament, including myself, from the stakeholders suggests that officials are not proceeding in accordance with the commitment communicated by the minister during committee of the whole and that the applications in question may not, in fact, be completed within the time frame of 10 days that she identified. \n\nI fully acknowledge that findings that a member deliberately misled the House may be rare and require a high threshold. The authorities establish three conditions: first, that a statement was misleading; second, that the member knew it was incorrect at the time it was made; and third, that there was an intention to mislead. \n\nThere are several factors that distinguish this matter. First, the minister made a specific and verifiable representation to Parliament concerning the processing of a defined group of applications with ministry staff at her side. Second, the representation included a precise timeline: completion within 10 days. Third, the statement concerned operational actions that would necessarily have been based on the information provided to the minister by her department officials, who were sitting right in front of her. Fourth, the information that has emerged since the minister's statement calls into question whether the commitment communicated to Parliament reflected the actual status of those files.\n\nMr. Speaker, I am not asking you to determine today whether the minister deliberately misled Parliament. Such determinations are not made lightly. Rather, I submit that the circumstances raise sufficient concern to warrant further examination by the House. Members must be able to rely on ministerial statements when carrying out their parliamentary duties. When a minister provides a specific assurance to Parliament and substantial doubt subsequently arises as to its accuracy, the House must have confidence that the matter will be examined. \n\nThe privileges of members are engaged when our ability to perform our parliamentary functions is undermined by information that may be inaccurate or misleading. In this case, I relied on the minister's response in exercising my responsibilities as a parliamentarian. The House was entitled to rely upon that information. \n\nThe integrity of our proceedings depends on the accuracy of the information provided by ministers when answering questions from members. Accordingly, I respectfully submit that there is a prima facie case of question of privilege. \n\nIf you so find, Mr. Speaker, I am prepared to move the following motion: That the matter of the statements made by the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship during committee of the whole proceedings on May 28 concerning the processing of study permit applications for Palestinian students from Gaza be referred to the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs for study and report.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-127/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083806","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise today on a question of privilege concerning information provided to Parliament by the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship during committee of the whole proceedings on Thursday, May 28, 2026. During those proceedings, I asked the minister about approximately 130 Palestinian graduate students from Gaza who have been waiting for nearly two years for decisions on thei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","label":"Scholarships","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8df7d9282eb76214952ff9f289f1f522b684c8ace0b193137957b4bba662dd65"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d87181fae8c7402f18178f667b0decb080a0495173b84bda1b42efd2662e3d6c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60d106c6740396cfc8681708","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083802,"date":"2026-06-03T19:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, people in Vancouver East want the federal government to stop the \"invest now, regulate later\" approach of the Prime Minister's AI data factory strategy. People are deeply concerned that the proposed AI data centres in dense residential neighbourhoods would bring constant air pollution from on-site diesel generators, 24-7 noise and impacts on water. It makes no sense to have water-intensive AI data centres on valuable land near their homes while historic drought conditions and water restrictions loom. \n\nPeople in Virginia, home to the largest concentration of data centres in the world, learned that industrial-scale data centres are incompatible in residential neighbourhoods. In Ireland, 22% of the power supply is now reportedly used by data centres, adding hundreds of dollars to home hydro bills.\n\n In the middle of an affordability and climate crisis, Van East constituents want people's rights to housing, quality of life, water security and affordable home power supply to come first, ahead of tech giants.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718539","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083802","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, people in Vancouver East want the federal government to stop the \"invest now, regulate later\" approach of the Prime Minister's AI data factory strategy. People are deeply concerned that the proposed AI data centres in dense residential neighbourhoods would bring constant air pollution from on-site diesel generators, 24-7 noise and impacts on water. It makes no sense to have water-inte","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718539","label":"Air pollution"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718539","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718539","label":"Air pollution","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["57e1a3bbe1617e5a73f814baf844e3fb20cdee2aa2039efcccb90926c11af5da"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718539","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea4cc21f4c94e001e86869c47c9e2df127cf7082cb09728cb22626705bb072b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718539","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718539","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718539","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1037ec7f8bbed23cc5e4c197","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083803,"date":"2026-06-03T20:18:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government has sidelined Bill S-2 as amended, despite a court-ordered deadline to end sex- and race-based discrimination and the second-generation cut-off in the Indian Act. The UN has called on Canada to fix this by adopting Bill S-2 as amended. The majority of first nations agree and do not want more consultation. Officials and ministers say it is up to the Prime Minister.\n\nWill the Prime Minister stop the delay tactics, meet with first nations women leaders, as requested, and pass Bill S-2 as amended, now, to end the discrimination and violations of the charter and international law?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083803","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government has sidelined Bill S-2 as amended, despite a court-ordered deadline to end sex- and race-based discrimination and the second-generation cut-off in the Indian Act. The UN has called on Canada to fix this by adopting Bill S-2 as amended. The majority of first nations agree and do not want more consultation. Officials and ministers say it is up to the Prime Ministe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e9ae27c0f62fcf242972a204b81d5fbee7faaa6c8e2936703231f7f1f38eab2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cd6488deedb307df3f8e0fe24975cdf76bd47bd442fb0c8e09a8040da42f6085"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9c6b115fd5261ff24a94a89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083804,"date":"2026-06-03T21:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague raised a number of very important points and amendments that should have been considered but were not, at the committee.\n\nI wonder, because she was running out of time to finish her comments, if she could further elaborate on some other issues that she thinks members of Parliament should hear.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-128/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083804","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague raised a number of very important points and amendments that should have been considered but were not, at the committee.\n\nI wonder, because she was running out of time to finish her comments, if she could further elaborate on some other issues that she thinks members of Parliament should hear.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-729481aa2d5f07bff011b350","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109977,"date":"2026-06-04T20:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, and thank you for allowing me to present the NDP amendments on Bill C-22 . Relating to clause 3 and our amendment, I'll note that this is the government's second attempt at lawful access, after widespread outcry about Bill C-2 , which the government was forced to abandon. Here we are again. Some of the legal community's and civil society's concerns about part 1 were addressed, but I think it still misses the mark. With respect to the issue, I note that the Canadian Chamber of Commerce has raised concerns on behalf of its members with respect to the scope of and access to computer data. There are a number of legal experts, lawyers, scholars and business leaders alike who have raised these concerns as well. To that end, this amendment would strike language permitting access to data \"available to\" a device, to ensure that warrants remain targeted and avoid broad or general searches of remote data. That's the element of the amendment I'm proposing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-41/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109977","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, and thank you for allowing me to present the NDP amendments on Bill C-22 . Relating to clause 3 and our amendment, I'll note that this is the government's second attempt at lawful access, after widespread outcry about Bill C-2 , which the government was forced to abandon. Here we are again. Some of the legal community's and civil society's concerns about part 1 were","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["748b2bd7417f5fc657834bc45bbb6dd1df0fdad021eb16848bf8c95334a5e8ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c6aca1b2fb78d2b13e6e7731687667d1b135b7a490395b15097ab1916ca2656b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bdad8b708423b86b4db2868d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083796,"date":"2026-06-05T17:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, my constituent suffered a debilitating vaccine injury. He is in constant pain and permanently disabled. Oxaro approved his $26,000 medical and home support costs back in February. He has yet to be reimbursed. He is now broke and being evicted. The health minister says to contact the Public Health Agency of Canada. PHAC says it is in transition and will not even look at the file until July. This is unacceptable. My constituent will be homeless and may not survive if he does not get help now.\n\n Will the minister immediately put in place a system to address urgent cases?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083796","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, my constituent suffered a debilitating vaccine injury. He is in constant pain and permanently disabled. Oxaro approved his $26,000 medical and home support costs back in February. He has yet to be reimbursed. He is now broke and being evicted. The health minister says to contact the Public Health Agency of Canada. PHAC says it is in transition and will not even look at the file unti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","label":"Chronic diseases","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e0fc40cc385225d373ea5884113bc4c5364b325bb3d7445e4fc53537965faa6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9772ff8346c12f3d26da289fc9df3fc9c682fdfa999525d0328bc1e9f52ddcad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d580e6c763e7a096ceeb105","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083797,"date":"2026-06-05T17:53:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I am sharing my time with the member for Saanich—Gulf Islands.\n\nI rise today on behalf of the people of Vancouver East, and on behalf of millions of Canadians, who are asking a very simple question. In one of the richest countries in the world, why is it becoming harder, not easier, to afford a place to live?\n\n What an opportunity this is to do the right thing and to build truly affordable housing, once and for all. The government has a chance to step up to the plate and finally deal with the crisis of runaway housing costs. Instead, it is just tinkering at the edges. Behind the hype and the Prime Minister's rhetoric of re-establishing the federal government's direct role in building homes at speed and scale to address the housing crisis is just another repackaged intervention that reserves most of its funding for the private sector.\n\n As shown in the spring economic update, the Prime Minister promised Canadians that he would build more housing faster to address the housing crisis, but instead of investing in the development of public community housing, over $93 billion, or two-thirds of the $140 billion in housing measures, would be gifted to real estate developers through special treatment and low-interest loans with minimal affordability requirements to help Canadians. Only one-third, less than $10 billion a year over five years, would be spent directly on building homes. \n\nThe Liberals are continuing to bank on the private sector to solve the housing crisis. We have seen that show before. It did not work 30 years ago, and it will not work now or in the future. The legislation contains no affordability or supply targets, no performance benchmarks and no regular reporting requirements beyond infrequent statutory reviews. To date, the government has announced just six sites that would meet affordability criteria. Without binding requirements, there is no assurance that future projects would do the same. This lack of ambition is especially concerning given that total federal housing spending is projected to fall by 56% by 2028-29. \n\nFunding for existing affordability programs is set to expire, and CMHC is facing cuts of $860 million per year, according to the Parliamentary Budget Officer. In addition, there could be the loss of up to 300,000 units of already built social and co-op housing if the government does not renew housing charge subsidies that are set to expire. \n\nMiloon Kothari, the former UN special rapporteur on housing, visited Canada on a national fact-finding mission and wrote a report in 2007 with recommendations. The point is that every government, Conservative and Liberal, has ignored his advice since. The report called for a continuum of housing to be built, including non-market affordable housing on scale, so that it could push the market into more affordable terrain.\n\nWhat are we seeing today, more than 30 years later? Why are seniors being renovicted from communities that they helped build? Why are young people working full-time and still unable to afford rent? Why are families forced to choose between paying rent and putting food on the table? Why has this affordability crisis gone on for so long?\n\n This did not happen by accident. This is the result of decades of political choices that have allowed housing in Canada to be transformed from a human need into a vehicle for profit. During the election campaign, the Liberals said they were going to have a wartime intervention in building affordable housing. What we see in reality is a program focused primarily on market incentives. History has shown us that true affordable housing, social housing and co-op housing, can be built by government with non-profit partners, and they know how to do this well.\n\n The Liberals have a choice: stand with working people crushed by rent and unaffordable housing costs, or protect a system that keeps housing unaccountable and out of reach. Sadly, they choose the latter. Liberals are continuing to approach the affordability crisis through market incentives rather than building affordable housing directly with non-profit partners that guarantee affordability. That is the world view of the Conservatives as well. The NDP takes a very different approach, and that is why the NDP is calling for development of one million public homes over five years. That is the scale of ambition we need, to ensure that everyone has a safe, affordable place to call home.\n\nAt committee, I proposed something incredibly basic: an amendment to Bill C-20 calling for transparency, measurable targets and a clear definition of affordability rooted in reality, which is that people should not spend more than 30% of their total income just to keep a roof over their head. The amendment demanded data and required outcomes on how many homes are built, where they are, who they serve and whether they are actually affordable.\n\nAt a time when millions are one paycheque away from losing their homes, Canadians deserve more than announcements and market incentivization. They deserve accountability and clear affordability targets. The Liberals and Conservatives, by voting down the amendment, send a clear message that they are not interested in transparency and accountability. They do not really want Canadians to know the facts.\n\nHere is the truth. Building more housing, on its own, will not solve the crisis. If we do not address who the system is built for, we will simply produce more housing that people still cannot afford. When we do not set affordability targets, it is déjà vu all over again.\n\nThere is a profound lack of urgency and priority by the Prime Minister to build a new supply of truly affordable housing for everyday Canadians. What is worse is that we will leave the most vulnerable even further behind. The Minister of Housing once had the ambition to end homelessness. Now that he is the minister, where has that ambition gone?\n\nThe Right Fit program did something very simple and very powerful. It matched wheelchair users with accessible housing. Over the years, it helped hundreds of people find stable homes, and yet despite its success, and despite a growing wait-list of people in desperate need, it lost federal funding as of April 1.\n\nThat means that in the middle of a housing crisis, we are not just failing to build enough homes but failing to ensure that the housing we have is accessible to those who need it most. It is not happening. This is not just a policy failure; it is a moral failure. It exposes a fundamental flaw in the government's approach.\n\nThe Build Canada Homes act focuses heavily on supply, but it is not asking a critical question: a supply of what, and for whom? Accessible housing is not interchangeable with market housing. This is a bureaucracy being built without adequate affordability targets. We cannot simply build more units and assume they will meet the needs of people with disabilities.\n\nThis is not simply an outlier situation. It is a warning. It shows us exactly what happens when we rely on a market-driven approach without strong public leadership and targeted investment. We get gaps, we get inequities, and people are left behind. This happens because it leans on the same idea, which is that if we incentivize developers, reduce barriers and speed up approvals, affordability will follow.\n\nHowever, we have tried that for decades, and what has it delivered? It has delivered luxury developments instead of affordable homes, record profits for investors while renters struggle, and housing treated as a commodity, not a human right. The private market builds for profit, not for need. If luxury units generate higher returns, that is what will be built. If speculation drives higher prices, that is where capital flows. This is how the system is designed, but it is our responsibility as parliamentarians to ensure that the system serves the people, not just the profits. Right now, it does not serve the people.\n\nWhere in this bill is the bold commitment to non-market housing? Where is the large-scale investment in co-op housing? Where is the expansion of public housing that remains affordable for generations? Where are the protections for renters facing eviction and unaffordable rent increases? Where is the action to stop the financialization of housing?\n\nThe housing crisis is not separate from inequity. It is a direct result of it. When wealth is concentrated, it flows into assets like housing and drives prices out of reach. If we are serious about solving the crisis, we must be serious about addressing inequality. This is not just about opposing development. We need to build, but we need to build the right kind of housing. We need to build housing that is affordable, accessible and secure. We need to build housing that is protected from speculation.\n\nHousing is not just about supply. It is about dignity. It is about stability. It is about a basic human right. That is why the government needs to take action in a serious way. That is why there need to be accountability measures in this bill and we need to address the housing crisis for all Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083797","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I am sharing my time with the member for Saanich—Gulf Islands.\n\nI rise today on behalf of the people of Vancouver East, and on behalf of millions of Canadians, who are asking a very simple question. In one of the richest countries in the world, why is it becoming harder, not easier, to afford a place to live?\n\n What an opportunity this is to do the right thing and to build truly aff","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["076762c4f368dc17d08fdcf4c82901cae0c1394109b38885145263ea45fe1f09"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e0369cfd4020ba06042b375a98ae9ae07f732b534c4a88b604430a19ac74232"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7c58f9c3c67587dd302b2ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083798,"date":"2026-06-05T18:04:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the NDP has been a strong advocate of the federal government's getting back to building social housing and co-op housing like it used to, before the Liberals cancelled the national affordable housing program prior to 1993. That is what I want to see in place.\n\n The build Canada homes act fails in its blueprint and the details on how it would actually deliver affordability, social housing and co-op housing for Canadians. By the way, my amendment called for accountability, to set baselines, to set targets and to set reported measures of what the government actually achieves. The Liberals voted against it, because they do not want Canadians to know the truth. They want to hide it from Canadians. There would be no accountability measures under the act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083798","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the NDP has been a strong advocate of the federal government's getting back to building social housing and co-op housing like it used to, before the Liberals cancelled the national affordable housing program prior to 1993. That is what I want to see in place.\n\n The build Canada homes act fails in its blueprint and the details on how it would actually deliver affordability, social ho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3bced771c100725d7573d8f986e8ddd350c7e92ea9364cd216d748230e0367f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a2f9aae953ff2d6e0af634dbbec4e24cc582efb6d9fd951f41cf6593fb8e823e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb2876c74c4fa06ae841ed34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083799,"date":"2026-06-05T18:06:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, that is exactly the point. There is no accountability in the bill. It does not even name the minister responsible for ensuring the deliverability. It does not actually say what the government is trying to do. How many units will it build and in which provinces? What are the targets the government will set? The bill does not even ensure that the government delivers on letting Canadians know what the outcomes are, and there is no affordability measure. It is just like, \"oh well, whatever\". If we have a plan like that, how is the housing crisis going to be solved? History has shown that what the government has done over the last 30 years is rely on just the private sector, and that has failed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083799","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, that is exactly the point. There is no accountability in the bill. It does not even name the minister responsible for ensuring the deliverability. It does not actually say what the government is trying to do. How many units will it build and in which provinces? What are the targets the government will set? The bill does not even ensure that the government delivers on letting Canadia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["08aaf36e22a5df6a83759e220c453a8d8bef07d05d5aa7ddbc6305f51181c7d5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["082939e3fc099f36ccd8a015413078aead9541b6b21318fe36d7f78f0f1bbd46"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3c8ada718da69d24f3c6471","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083800,"date":"2026-06-05T18:07:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, there is a great need for a full range of housing, and that includes supportive housing. The truth of the matter is that building housing in and of itself is insufficient. We have to have the supports in place as well for a certain segment of the community, for example, those who are faced with multiple health issues, including addictions issues, mental health issues and so on. Supportive housing is what helps ensure people are successful in that housing, and that is what we need as well. We do not have enough supports from the federal government in that regard.\n\nBy the way, the spring economic update did not renew mental health support funding, and that is going to create greater problems for communities like Nanaimo and mine, and across the country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083800","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, there is a great need for a full range of housing, and that includes supportive housing. The truth of the matter is that building housing in and of itself is insufficient. We have to have the supports in place as well for a certain segment of the community, for example, those who are faced with multiple health issues, including addictions issues, mental health issues and so on. Supp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9b28424ed2c4e251bf699e08de33e8accecb9956e4eb49da1d24319cac0da7b8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["968696df42b82d79c15868e50990d7e69b86df2d2eaf07b95389020b9d1f10a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b6f8fe1850c69eff9e0d793","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1083801,"date":"2026-06-05T18:20:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, in Canada we have CMHC specifically designed to deliver housing. Now the government is coming forward with an act for Build Canada Homes, another Crown corporation, to deliver housing, yet in this bill there are no accountability measures, no targets and no affordability requirements. Meanwhile, the Parliamentary Budget Officer projects that Build Canada Homes would only build around 50 to 100 units per year, a fraction of the annual 500,000 units, at least, that are required to address the housing crisis.\n\nMy question for my colleague is this: If there are no accountability measures, what is the point of creating yet another Crown corporation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-130/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083801","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, in Canada we have CMHC specifically designed to deliver housing. Now the government is coming forward with an act for Build Canada Homes, another Crown corporation, to deliver housing, yet in this bill there are no accountability measures, no targets and no affordability requirements. Meanwhile, the Parliamentary Budget Officer projects that Build Canada Homes would only build aroun","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fec750dedd09e24ec3e536dbe20cd3e3b2a2fbc3a4e48f0fd3704613d151b8c9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bb6ec7290840a404ed03ff5d3e89dddba239777e4138141da399bcbb57f0782b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebd1541232de8c74e044bc51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109978,"date":"2026-06-09T22:35:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. With regard to this amendment, I note the International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group and the Canadian Chamber of Commerce have raised concerns with respect to production order thresholds, saying that \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" is an unreasonably low standard, particularly given the Supreme Court of Canada's findings regarding the high potential sensitivity of subscriber information, which has been described as \"narrow in scope\" but in fact is incredibly revealing about \"personal aspects of an individual's life\". With respect to the standard, this amendment replaces the language \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" with \"reasonable grounds to believe\". Doing so in all provisions regarding subscriber information, production orders and real-time device tracking authorizations will set a standard that requires the probability of a crime rather than a mere suspicion before they can map a citizen's movement or demand identifying logs. I hope committee members will support this amendment. I note that others have also advanced exactly the same amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109978","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. With regard to this amendment, I note the International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group and the Canadian Chamber of Commerce have raised concerns with respect to production order thresholds, saying that \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" is an unreasonably low standard, particularly given the Supreme Court of Canada's findings regarding the high potential sensitivity ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f6dbe5463efe105bec58ce90a1be4f702b9d042c80d781a0eb81353bc9ff117c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac65bca11ec0b098b64be750","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109979,"date":"2026-06-10T00:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. This is NDP-3. With respect to this amendment, the NDP has received comments from prominent lawyers, legal professors and so on who are concerned about the impact of this bill on privacy and constitutional rights in Canada. They say: As affirmed by the Supreme Court of Canada's decision in R v Spencer, Canadians have had a strong privacy interest in anonymity online. The existing general production order—available since 2004 and readily obtained by telewarrant—already gives police an effective tool to link an IP address or phone number to a named subscriber, and requires them to establish reasonable grounds to believe that an offence has been committed. Bill C-22 creates a new, dedicated subscriber information order that reduces that standard to reasonable grounds to suspect. The courts have held that this distinction is not semantic: in R v West, the Ontario Court of Appeal excluded evidence obtained through a production order precisely because the officer had established only grounds to suspect rather than grounds to believe. The scope of disclosure under the new order is a further concern. Although the definition of subscriber information has been narrowed compared to Bill C-2, the order still allows for production of a broad scope of information, including the types of services provided—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109979","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. This is NDP-3. With respect to this amendment, the NDP has received comments from prominent lawyers, legal professors and so on who are concerned about the impact of this bill on privacy and constitutional rights in Canada. They say: As affirmed by the Supreme Court of Canada's decision in R v Spencer, Canadians have had a strong privacy interest in anonymity online","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8bff2eba8b1b5ff344076f047556b29bb7b523fb7ed96fe9b2e4a48f3d6bc2eb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94529fc677b6ecd033223ed79ebcfdd6c6dbdb9a437ec68382645a5d66e2918d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c73f0f66402ec2e9d5510abb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109980,"date":"2026-06-10T00:50:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"SECU","text":"Sure. My apologies. I will slow it down. I think my staff have gone home for the day, so I won't be able to get them to send it to the interpreters. I will start at the beginning of the first sentence and go more slowly. The scope of disclosure under the new order is a further concern. Although the definition of subscriber information has been narrowed compared to Bill C-2, the order still allows for production of a broad scope of information, including the types of services provided and the identifiers of every device associated with the account. This goes well beyond what is needed to connect a name to an IP address. It can be directed to a physician, a cable company, or a platform like iCloud, requiring disclosure of what cable packages a person subscribes to, what medical services they receive, or what devices they use. Much of this information carries a high privacy interest and calls for a higher legal standard. If Parliament seeks to create a subscriber information order that can withstand scrutiny under section 8 of the Charter, it should narrow the scope to basic identifying information—name, address, and the specific account identifier in question—and raise the threshold to reasonable grounds to believe. To that end, they also note: Including analogous powers in the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act (CSIS Act) raises even greater issues. Unlike criminal defendants, \"persons of interest\" to CSIS are never given an opportunity in court to challenge the intrusion of state power into their private lives. The Charter concerns are more acute with CSIS, and the Service should have to satisfy a \"reasonable grounds to believe\" threshold for all of these authorities. This amendment would narrow the scope to basic identifying information—name, address and the specific account identifier in question—and would raise the threshold to \"reasonable grounds to believe\" to withstand scrutiny under section 8 of the charter.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-42/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109980","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Sure. My apologies. I will slow it down. I think my staff have gone home for the day, so I won't be able to get them to send it to the interpreters. I will start at the beginning of the first sentence and go more slowly. The scope of disclosure under the new order is a further concern. Although the definition of subscriber information has been narrowed compared to Bill C-2, the order still allows ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c1420ecf3c90de2fc2d3824294193d9bc6b835b3ec70d90aec12560523f941ad"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e3e752d9a362f0d128a0a5eafedf8c93084507ff6534fa72e188776151c9182b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f3363547d39a41de65fd7a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087657,"date":"2026-06-17T03:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-26, at 10:33 p.m. This will be the last time members of Parliament will get to debate the bill because the government has brought down the guillotine to shut down debate.\n\n What is this bill? It is an act to authorize certain payments to be made out of the consolidated revenue fund for the purpose of improving housing supply. That sounds good.\n\n At the outset, let me say this clearly. Canada is not just facing a housing crisis; it is facing a housing affordability crisis. It is not a future housing crisis but a housing affordability crisis right now, which has only gotten worse on the government's watch. Across the country, people are working harder than ever and falling further behind. Young people who have done everything society has asked them to do, studied hard, gotten a job and saved money, are wondering if they will ever be able to afford a home. Families are spending larger and larger portions of their income on rent. Seniors are being priced out of the communities they helped build. Students are sleeping on couches and living in overcrowded housing. More Canadians are finding themselves on the brink of homelessness. In cities and towns across this country, homelessness continues to rise. This is the reality. This is the crisis. It demands serious action.\n\n New Democrats believe government has an obligation to act. We believe public investment has a role to play. We believe Canada must build more housing. We believe governments must be ambitious, but ambition alone is not enough. Public money must achieve public outcomes, including affordability. That is where this bill, Bill C-26, fails. This legislation would authorize the expenditure of $1.713 billion of public funds, yet despite spending more than $1.7 billion, the bill itself contains almost no meaningful safeguards, no measurable affordability requirements and no clear accountability mechanisms. \n\nThere are no requirements for affordable housing. There are no requirements for non-market housing. There are no requirements for co-operative housing. There are no requirements for public housing. There are no requirements for indigenous housing. There are no requirements for accessible housing. There are no requirements for rental affordability. There are no requirements that any homes created as a result of this funding remain affordable for future generations. There are none whatsoever. Instead, Parliament would be asked to authorize $1.713 billion dollars and then hand enormous discretion to the Minister of Finance to determine where the money goes and under what conditions. \n\nThis is not accountability. This is centralization. Parliament would be asked to write a cheque and hope for the best. New Democrats do not believe that is good enough. If Canadians are investing $1.7 billion, Canadians deserve to know what they are getting in return. Would rents become more affordable? Would homelessness decline? Would social housing waiting lists shrink? Would more co-op housing be built? Would more affordable homes be available to workers, seniors and young families? The bill does not answer any of these questions. This is because Bill C-26 reveals something important about how the Prime Minister understands the housing crisis.\n\n The government says this bill is about supply, but Canadians are not suffering from a shortage of supply. They are suffering from a shortage of affordable supply. These are not the same thing. A luxury condominium counts as supply. A speculative investment property counts as supply. An empty condominium tower counts as supply. None of those things necessarily creates affordability. The question is not whether units are being built. The question is who those units are being built for. The question is whether ordinary people can afford them. The question is whether housing is being treated as a home or as a financial asset.\n\nIf members read the government's own background documents, something very revealing emerges. The government is concerned about inventory. The government is concerned about sales. The government is concerned about construction activity. The government is concerned about market conditions. The government is concerned about what might happen if inventories increase and housing markets slow down.\n\nThose are all legitimate matters for economists to discuss, but where in the government's framework do we see the issue of affordability or the issue of homelessness? Where do we see social housing wait-lists? Where do we see renter poverty? Where do we see overcrowding? Where do we see indigenous housing needs? Where do we see housing insecurity? Where do we see affordability outcomes? What we see instead is a framework built around market indicators. That tells us something important: that the government is measuring market distress. New Democrats are measuring human distress. Those are very different things.\n\nCanadians deserve honesty from this House. The concern reflected in Bill C-26 is not simply that people cannot find housing. The concern reflected in Bill C-26 is that inventories are rising. The concern reflected in Bill C-26 is that sales are slowing. The concern reflected in Bill C-26 is that construction activity may decline. The concern reflected in Bill C-26 is that housing markets are cooling. Those are not the same thing.\n\nA family facing eviction is experiencing a housing crisis. A senior who cannot afford rent is experiencing a housing crisis. A young worker paying half their income to a landlord is experiencing a housing crisis. A worker sleeping in their car is experiencing a housing crisis. A student sleeping in their car is experiencing a housing crisis. A student couch surfing is experiencing a housing crisis. A developer sitting on unsold luxury condominiums is experiencing a market problem. Those are not the same thing, yet this legislation increasingly treats them as though they are. \n\nThis is the central flaw of Bill C-26. The government has confused the health of the housing market with the well-being of the people who depend upon housing. \n\nCanadians have seen this movie before. For years, Canadians have been told that if we support the market, affordability will follow. When housing became increasingly financialized and profiteering became the name of the game, we were told affordability would follow. When corporate investors expanded their presence in housing, we were told affordability would follow. When housing prices skyrocketed, we were told affordability would follow. When rents exploded, we were told affordability would follow. When an entire generation found itself locked out of home ownership, we were told affordability would follow. \n\nToday, Canadians are hearing the same message once again: Trust the market, support the market, subsidize the market, and somehow affordability will follow. Canadians have waited long enough. The evidence is in: That experiment has failed. It has failed young people. It has failed renters. It has failed workers. It has failed seniors. It has failed communities across Canada. \n\nThe private market builds housing where profits are highest. The private market does not automatically build housing where the need is the greatest. That is why we can have luxury towers sitting empty while homelessness rises. That is why we can have speculative investment properties while families struggle to find housing. That is why we can have thousands of vacant units and thousands of unhoused people in the same city at the same time. This is not a natural phenomenon. This is a policy choice. It is the predictable outcome of treating housing as an asset class instead of a human right. \n\nLet us consider what is happening in metro Vancouver. According to publicly reported figures, approximately 2,500 completed condominiums are currently sitting vacant and unsold. The number has doubled compared with the previous year. Analysts estimate that it could rise significantly further. Think about what that means. Thousands of homes already exist, thousands of homes have already been built, yet people cannot afford them.\n\nAt the same time, homelessness remains a serious challenge, renters are struggling and working families are being priced out. The problem is not simply a lack of units; it is affordability. The problem is that housing is increasingly being built as an investment product rather than a social necessity, and that housing has become financialized. Unless we address the financialization, we will continue to produce housing outcomes that fail ordinary Canadians.\n\nThere is another example that deserves attention. A major residential tower development in Vancouver recently entered receivership after significant financial difficulties and a loan default involving more than $100 million. An institutional lender stepped in, receivers were appointed and creditors moved to recover their investment. Now, I want to be clear, I am not criticizing construction workers, pension beneficiaries or workers whose retirement savings are invested through pension funds. However, this is an example that reveals something important. Parts of the housing development sector are experiencing financial distress. Sales are slowing, inventories are rising, financing is becoming more difficult, projects are becoming riskier, and Canadians have every right to ask a simple question: Is Bill C‐26 designed to solve the housing crisis Canadians face, or is it designed to stabilize a development model facing increasing financial pressure?\n\nWhen I read the government's own rationale, I see repeated concerns about inventory, market conditions and construction activity. What I do not see is an equal concern for affordability, and that should concern every member of this House.\n\n There is another problem with this bill: the allocation formula itself. Ontario received $875 million, Quebec received $320 million, B.C. received $284 million, meanwhile, Manitoba received $10 million, Saskatchewan received $10 million, New Brunswick received $10 million, and Newfoundland and Labrador received $10 million. The government has chosen to distribute funding based largely on housing market indicators. Imagine if we allocated funding based on need, homelessness or renters' needs. Imagine if we allocated funding based on social housing wait-lists, housing insecurity, indigenous housing needs or renter distress. The results would almost certainly look different. This formula is not built around human need; it is built around market conditions. This is an ideological choice, and New Democrats disagree with it.\n\nThere is a larger issue at stake. For decades, governments of different political stripes have steadily reduced Canada's commitment to non-market housing. When I say different political stripes, I mean Liberals and Conservatives. The result is that Canada has one of the smallest non-market housing sectors across many developed countries. We sold the idea that private markets would deliver affordability. Instead, we got speculation, financialization, corporate concentration, rising rents, rising home prices and a housing crisis. Surely the lesson is obvious. We cannot solve a housing crisis created by excessive reliance on the market by relying even more heavily on the market.\n\n We need a different approach. We need a major expansion of non-market housing and co-op housing. We need public housing construction, acquisition funds to preserve existing affordable housing, indigenous-led housing solutions and stronger tenant protections. We need affordability requirements attached to public funding, and we need to ensure that every public dollar creates a lasting public benefit.\n\n At the end of the day, this debate comes down to a simple question: Who is the government supposed to work for? When renters are struggling, government should stand with renters. When young people are locked out of home ownership, government should stand with young people. When seniors are worried about keeping a roof over their heads, government should stand with seniors. When families cannot afford housing, governments should stand with families.\n\n That should be the test; not whether inventories are optimized, not whether markets are stabilized and not whether investors are reassured. Whether people can afford a place to live is the key. Government programs should not be designed to bail out big developers. That is the test, and Bill C-26 fails it. This bill tells us how much money would be spent. This bill tells us where some of that money would go. However, it never tells Canadians what they would receive in return. There would be no affordability guarantees, no social housing targets, no public ownership requirements and no measurable affordability outcomes, nothing. It is just $1.7 billion and a promise that the market would somehow work things out. We have heard that promise before, and after decades of hearing it, Canada now faces the worst housing affordability crisis in generations. When a former central banker designs housing policy, it looks like Bill C-26 and it clearly misses the mark. It misses the human impact of housing affordability.\n\n New Democrats believe that there is a better path. We believe that housing is a basic human right. We believe that public money should serve public purposes. We believe that housing policy should be judged by outcomes for people, not outcomes for investors. We believe that if taxpayers assume the risk, they deserve affordability in return. We believe that if public money is invested, the public should own part of that outcome. We believe that if government is serious about housing affordability, then affordability cannot be optional.\n\n There are two ways to spend $1.7 billion. We can spend it protecting the housing market or we can spend it protecting Canadians from the housing market. Bill C-26 chooses the first path. New Democrats believe parliamentarians should choose the second, always putting people before profits. That is what we are here to talk about with respect to this bill. Somehow, the government misses the mark.\n\nBefore this bill came to this critical stage where the government is bringing forward a guillotine motion to ram through the bill without proper debate in the House, I had a briefing with officials. I asked the officials, \"What is the funding allocation? What is the formula? How did they determine who gets how much money?\" At that briefing, they said that they could not provide that information to me. They were actually not going to share that information. What they really wanted was for me, for the New Democrats and for members of the House to agree on a unanimous consent motion to pass through all the stages—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087657","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-26, at 10:33 p.m. This will be the last time members of Parliament will get to debate the bill because the government has brought down the guillotine to shut down debate.\n\n What is this bill? It is an act to authorize certain payments to be made out of the consolidated revenue fund for the purpose of improving housing supply. That sounds good.\n\n At the outset","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c1b1dc6ce930d4ac21b9b87229bc1fad9699c50311f537f1b523b531f5c24ffc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9080ce9406357ba1ec5e2a09b5111919ed7871aac4363989633a1bf1fa0a39f7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0487e3dd6af8635fd8a05ead","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087658,"date":"2026-06-17T03:51:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for that intervention. It is kind of outrageous, is it not? We are here at 10:50 p.m., and the Liberals are partying in the lobby area.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087658","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for that intervention. It is kind of outrageous, is it not? We are here at 10:50 p.m., and the Liberals are partying in the lobby area.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e90aeac471b3420404898121","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087659,"date":"2026-06-17T03:52:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, to the point where they are making disruptive noises that interfere with the debate in the House, that is inappropriate.\n\nLet me just conclude my comments here. The government wants to ram this through. The Liberals want unanimous consent from all the parties to somehow magically just support them in whatever they want to do, but we actually want accountability. We want the government to deliver results for the people, for Canada, for Canadians who are struggling with the housing crisis, not just to hand over cheques without accountability measures. That is the difference. The market will not fix the problem. What will fix the problem is a policy choice of investing in the people and for people ahead of profits.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087659","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, to the point where they are making disruptive noises that interfere with the debate in the House, that is inappropriate.\n\nLet me just conclude my comments here. The government wants to ram this through. The Liberals want unanimous consent from all the parties to somehow magically just support them in whatever they want to do, but we actually want accountability. We want the government","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["530d5af626f9fedd3c26c0c6a982608843f09d93c9bf86ee50b9a08e5462b078"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b9d4fd66fcecbab43c900f2442f57eadb4d7adb69114b84c7f626c7293d4600b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0494ee42ce36dd537151af1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087660,"date":"2026-06-17T03:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I was once actually in government at the provincial level, at a time when the federal Liberal government cancelled the national affordable housing program. What did New Democrats do provincially? We continued to deliver housing in spite of that. When I was elected and became a cabinet minister, what did we do? We actually grew the money from the Province of British Columbia alone, with the private sector, with the non-profit sector, with municipalities and with everybody else who would partner with us, except for the federal government, which walked away.\n\nGuess what. We grew that money from 600 units to 1,200 units and then to 2,000 units, with the same amount of money. Yes, we believe in the market, but what we also believe in is making sure that we drive the market to deliver for the people, especially when it gets a benefit from taxpayers. That is unlike the current Liberal government. What did it do? It gave money hand over fist to the development sector, to the market, and thought that somehow, magically, affordable housing would appear on its own. Guess what. It did not.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087660","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I was once actually in government at the provincial level, at a time when the federal Liberal government cancelled the national affordable housing program. What did New Democrats do provincially? We continued to deliver housing in spite of that. When I was elected and became a cabinet minister, what did we do? We actually grew the money from the Province of British Columbia alone, wit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d8b0d0dd77cebd647d7b1932006dcdd9dbe53ac67f66435063e6d38edac9e293"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54aff0ec5f3f15e56162e1dbff1c511a84550dfec77f38d8f8663c8aaf1c7d1f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d45d3fd300b35c33183c2011","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087661,"date":"2026-06-17T03:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, that is precisely the point. There would be no accountability measures. There would be nothing to which one can say that using $1.7 billion of taxpayers' money would generate a specific return for the people in Canada. There would be zero accountability measures and zero targets. There is none of that information whatsoever in the bill.\n\nAs I was saying earlier, I was trying to get from the government what exactly the allocation would be and what the formula is that the government used to decide how to divide the money between the provinces and territories. The Liberals could not even give me that. It was after much to-do, when they were desperate to try to get a unanimous consent motion through, that they then came forward with that information.\n\nGuess what. A whole bunch of provinces would be getting only $10 million out of this. That would not address the housing crisis, would it? The government just says, \"Trust us. We will fix it.\" Oh, will it really?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-137/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087661","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, that is precisely the point. There would be no accountability measures. There would be nothing to which one can say that using $1.7 billion of taxpayers' money would generate a specific return for the people in Canada. There would be zero accountability measures and zero targets. There is none of that information whatsoever in the bill.\n\nAs I was saying earlier, I was trying to get fr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9a10851e6c83a89c4e7a0a3ab8a937e9cd2c9533d1ddc735b43bcaeeecb5fe04"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1413eac5a74f593d39ece2b9e7fb77ff563211f372219649b5113cd3373a4b7c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-adf94deedbed8a608115b0e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1109981,"date":"2026-06-17T04:55:00+00:00","title":"SECU","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"SECU","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. It seems to me that everybody was nodding, so I take that as an affirmative. I want to thank committee members for allowing me to do that. I apologize that I wasn't here when this amendment came up. I had run into the House to deal with yet another guillotine motion on Bill C-26 . I wanted to get my comments on the record in the House with respect to that. I'm back here now, and I think the guillotine is soon coming down on this one as well. I should first say that the premise of this amendment is actually something the Canadian Chamber of Commerce brought to my attention. They raised this issue with regard to the timeline for responding to production orders. This amendment that I tabled would restore the 30-calendar-day default, as is generally the case with the Criminal Code standard. I would welcome and support the amendment that has been brought forward by Mr. Mantle. By the way, the Chamber of Commerce itself also noted that it would welcome shorter periods. It would welcome them with written judicial reasons in exigent circumstances. That is the premise behind the amendment here. It's to allow for that flexibility in that way. I heard officials comment that if they can't meet it in those 30 days, then the default would be that they just won't meet the order. I would hope that this is not the case. I would hope that people would work really hard to meet the order, because the Criminal Code standard is 30 days and people work toward achieving that. In this instance, bringing that forward is an important benchmark, if you will. Part of the problem with this bill and the approach that's being taken is that there's not really good collaboration about what needs to be done and how to bring the best bill forward. These are substantive changes to Canadian culture that would impact privacy and civil liberties. I get the importance of doing it so that we can facilitate the work of law enforcement, CSIS and the people who keep us safe. I get all of that. As a target of foreign interference, I get it. Please, I get it. I want to make sure we get it right, but not at this sort of breakneck speed of trying to push it through. When I say breakneck speed, I'm talking about not engaging in a process that would actually allow for fulsome engagement, input and meaningful consideration. I know that the government has gotten itself a majority, and it is going to ram it through. I don't think that's the best way to make law. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/SECU/meeting-44/evidence","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1109981","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. It seems to me that everybody was nodding, so I take that as an affirmative. I want to thank committee members for allowing me to do that. I apologize that I wasn't here when this amendment came up. I had run into the House to deal with yet another guillotine motion on Bill C-26 . I wanted to get my comments on the record in the House with respect to that. I'm back ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc65fad6e716633c8fa951ab9a1103c5cf82aa5f74e6ce1e7c1367cbe8690be4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ef0bf0ecc4b7532916b25a55e954826b775013b7f92d68de33b94ff0d651ad32"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-177da64dd122509a9afbbc89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087649,"date":"2026-06-17T21:45:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to table a petition, initiated by Ms. Sharon McIvor, calling on the House of Commons to adopt Bill S-2 as amended by the Senate without further delay and to end sex- and race-based discrimination in the Indian Act, as well as the second-generation cut-off, now. A similar petition with the same language, e-petition 7200, was sponsored by the member for Nunavut and filed with the Clerk on May 7, though the member did not rise to present the petition in the House. That petition was signed by 14,298 people. \n\nThe petitioners note that the second-generation cut-off and the 1985 cut-off rules in the Indian Act, which determine eligibility for status, will result in the legal extinction of status Indians, according to Statistics Canada, and cause harm and divisions in families and communities. In the 40 years since, consultations resulted in repeated calls from first nations for its removal. They know the Senate amendments to Bill S-2 would effectively remove the second-generation and 1985 cut-offs and return to a one-parent rule for transmission of status, which were overwhelmingly supported by the majority of witnesses at the Senate committee, including first nations' leadership and organizations, women's organizations and affected individuals, many of whom took part in the government's collaborative process on the second-generation cut-off. \n\nThe petitioners know that Parliament has a responsibility to uphold the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms by eliminating sex and race discrimination, and the legal extinction scheme in the Indian Act. They, therefore, call for the adoption of Bill S-2 as amended by the Senate without delay.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087649","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to table a petition, initiated by Ms. Sharon McIvor, calling on the House of Commons to adopt Bill S-2 as amended by the Senate without further delay and to end sex- and race-based discrimination in the Indian Act, as well as the second-generation cut-off, now. A similar petition with the same language, e-petition 7200, was sponsored by the member for Nunavut and filed w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083649","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Non-Status Indians","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083649","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Non-Status Indians","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083649","label":"Non-Status Indians","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f67901b5deffd246227214e97b1336a65b648a89b8b579e13a2f048301c9d6e5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["43e899dc0436766423565aebd6d44697f999631626b2521d01662fe708a2a86a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79f2b936c8945d11ca0ad4fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087650,"date":"2026-06-18T00:32:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I just want to acknowledge and thank my colleague as well.\n\nI am not a regular attendee of the SECU committee. However, on Bill C-22 I listened to all the exchanges and debates. I have to say my colleague from the Bloc was superb in many of her interventions.\n\nWith respect to the amendments that were made, the NDP also moved an amendment related to the issue of \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" versus \"reasonable grounds to believe\". However, the NDP amendment was defeated. The Bloc similarly moved an amendment in that regard, in accordance with the Quebec bar association. This was also an important issue that did not get support.\n\n Could the member elaborate on the rationale behind the Liberals' objection to that important amendment?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087650","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I just want to acknowledge and thank my colleague as well.\n\nI am not a regular attendee of the SECU committee. However, on Bill C-22 I listened to all the exchanges and debates. I have to say my colleague from the Bloc was superb in many of her interventions.\n\nWith respect to the amendments that were made, the NDP also moved an amendment related to the issue of \"reasonable grounds t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-763e9e3bb544e9c4e001b25b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087651,"date":"2026-06-18T00:36:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise to speak to this important moment regarding Bill C-22. Of course, the government has brought down the sledgehammer, the guillotine, to shut down debate.\n\n Bill C-22 is a version of its predecessor, Bill C-2, the so-called strong borders act, which was an offensive, omnibus bill that was dead on arrival. It immediately generated widespread opposition from the public, with tens of thousands of people advocating against it. More than 300 civil society organizations, communities and legal experts soundly rejected the bill, and the government was forced to shelve it. Now, the government has decided to recklessly ram Bill C-22 through. Rather than take the time to listen carefully and hear concerns thoughtfully, the government is plowing ahead because it thinks it knows best. Its reputation for centralization, frankly, is well deserved. \n\nDid the government take the time to listen to the Privacy Commissioner's perspective, or those of legal experts, civil liberty advocates or privacy rights experts on this legislation? I should note that the government did not even consult the Privacy Commissioner prior to tabling this legislation, so the short answer is that no, it did not.\n\nThis is a deeply flawed piece of legislation that is being rushed through in a haphazard and, frankly, unsettling fashion. Members of Parliament across all party lines have put forward amendments to Bill C-22, and there were a significant number of amendments tabled at committee.\n\n The NDP put forward a large volume of amendments at committee to address legitimate concerns raised by experts and businesses alike. I will provide some examples. The NDP amendments aimed to ensure that Bill C-22 could withstand scrutiny under section 8 of the charter; to strengthen and clearly define \"systemic vulnerability\" to explicitly rule out any requirement that would weaken or break encryption, mandate client-side scanning, or otherwise introduce any security weaknesses; to anchor the definition of \"electronic service provider\" to a primary function test, ensuring obligations would apply only to entities whose core business is the conveyance of communications between persons; to address the concerns of threshold from the legal experts who have pointed out that Bill C-22's \"reasonable grounds to suspect\" threshold is unreasonably low, particularly given the Supreme Court of Canada's findings regarding high potential sensitivity of subscriber information. They wanted to see that language amended to \"reasonable grounds to believe\". The idea behind the amendment is to require a probability of crime rather than a mere suspicion before a citizen's movement can be mapped out or identifying logs can be demanded.\n\nThe NDP amendments also sought to replace ministerial secret orders with judicial warrants; to ensure warrants would remain targeted and would avoid broad or general searches to remote data, and mitigate charter and cross-border legal risks; to remove the requirement for broad long-term metadata retention mandates and to, instead, use targeted time-limited preservation orders for specific metadata when needed to reduce costs, security risks and section 8 charter violations. For context, the EU Court of Justice has repeatedly found general and indiscriminate retention of metadata to be incompatible with fundamental rights. I should note that the United States imposes no general mandatory data retention requirement.\n\n Sadly, today, the NDP amendment that was debated and moved before the committee failed. The sheer volume of the amendments tabled by all parties at committee, I think, tells us something about the bill and how flawed the bill is.\n\nInstead of giving us a chance to fully debate the amendments, the government rejected many that were put forward by opposition parties, and it is now choosing to use the closure guillotine with its new-found majority, from floor crossers, to ram the bill through without proper debate or scrutiny. Canadians will be appalled at the government's approach to pushing through the legislation. \n\nIf the government wants to have public policy that is durable, and that will meet the test of time, then it should take the time to do it properly in the first place. Instead, the government has moved full-throttle over its critics. This is a completely unsustainable way to run a government. Will the Liberal caucus just support this approach like a bunch of sheep, or will they call it out for what it is? \n\nBill C-22 would add sweeping new powers that would allow for any digital service provider to retain data on every single person in Canada, without cost. It would compel the redesign of digital systems in ways that would make Canadians more exposed, not more secure. \n\nAs the Canadian Civil Liberties Association rightfully pointed out in an open letter to the government, Bill C-22:\n\n...could force the creation and installation of privacy-compromising surveillance tools and backdoors in an enormous and ill-defined set of \"electronic service providers\", including telecom providers, social media and cloud service providers, AI tools, and any \"smart\" device. The law could even be used to force Canadian companies to build backdoors into their products before they export them abroad. The result creates an untenable threat to privacy and cybersecurity....\n\nAccording to the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, Bill C-22 represents one of the most significant expansion of state surveillance authority in Canada in years.\n\nIn the words of Tim McSorley from the International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group:\n\nThis legislation presents one of the greatest threats to privacy in Canada of the past two decades. Its provisions will weaken the rules governing police access to personal information, all while facilitating a vast expansion of government surveillance. This is another clear case of the decades-long trend of governments using national security as an excuse to erode civil liberties and human rights.... We are encouraging all members of parliament to oppose these new powers....\n\n Matt Hatfield from Open Media states, \"Bill C-22 is even more dangerous than the bill it replaces.\"\n\nThe Centre for Free Expression says that it is \"an unprecedented and extraordinarily dangerous surveillance architecture\".\n\n The Citizen Lab said that the legislation could \"weaken the rules governing police access to personal information, all while facilitating a vast expansion of government surveillance\". It goes on to say that the legislation is \"enormous and poorly defined\".\n\nThe Canadian Chamber of Commerce, representing nearly 200,000 businesses across the country, a network of over 400 chambers of commerce and boards of trade, said that it fundamentally opposes breaking encryption and other essential zero-knowledge security tools to provide the government and law enforcement with unfettered access to digital systems.\n\n At a time when trust in digital governance, data security and state surveillance is already fragile, the government is bringing in legislation that would significantly change the relationship between individuals, private companies and the state. Basic due diligence when considering such sweeping changes to the privacy rights of Canadians is required, yet the government is in such a hurry to violate the civil liberties of Canadians that it did not even take the time to consult with the Privacy Commissioner. Why? Is it because the government is afraid that the Privacy Commissioner's analysis of the bill would have given the House the necessary non-partisan perspective on the implications on privacy? \n\nBill C-22 would expand police and intelligence access to personal information, reduce judicial oversight and introduce mechanisms that could require private companies to retain and expose sensitive user data on a systematic basis. This is not speculation. It is built into the structure of the bill. \n\nThe legislation contains two main components: timely access to data information and the supporting authorized access to information regime. Together, they would establish a framework that would allow government authorities to compel access to data from a wide range of electronic service providers far beyond traditional telecom companies.\n\nUnder Bill C‐22, the Minister of Public Safety would be granted authority to issue secret orders requiring these providers to modify their systems to facilitate access to user information. These orders would not require judicial authorization. They would not be subject to public scrutiny and, in many cases, they might never be disclosed. Instead, they would be approved through an administrative process involving the intelligence commissioner. While that office plays an important role in oversight, it is not equivalent to independent judicial authorization in open court. It would not provide the same constitutional safeguard against unreasonable search and seizure. It would move us away from a warrant-based system rooted in charter protections and toward a model of executive-initiated access to private data.\n\nThat is not all. Bill C‐22 would also introduce a second deeply concerning feature: compelled data retention. The bill would allow the government to require companies to retain metadata for up to one year on every single person in Canada or abroad. Metadata may not include the content of communications, but it reviews patterns of behaviour, who we talk to, when we talk to them, where we talk to them, how often we interact and for how long.\n\nWhy is the government looking over the shoulders of Canadians? In this digital era, metadata is often more revealing than content. It is a skeleton of a person's private life, damaging the privacy of millions, not because they are suspected of committing any crime or posing any security threat but because it might become useful in the future. This is a profound invasion of privacy. This is precisely what overreach is. The legislation would create democratic deficits by design and has features that are far more characteristic of a neo-authoritarian regime.\n\nThis is not an exaggeration. The government is continuing a backward slide into centralization. A government run by a former central banker is moving toward centralization, and it is the wrong direction.\n\nWe also need to address the risks created when governments require systemic access points or infrastructure modifications. When companies are forced to build mechanisms that enable easier state access to encrypted or private communications, those mechanisms do not remain confined to lawful use. They become vulnerabilities. We have seen this repeatedly. Systems designed for access become systems exploited by hackers, foreign intelligence services and malicious actors. As pointed out by the Canadian Chamber of Commerce:\n\n[Encrypted zero-knowledge digital systems] would require technical measures that alter the security architecture of these systems, including changes to how encryption is implemented and managed. As a result, any requirement to facilitate this form of access would introduce systemic vulnerabilities by design, exposing both private and public sector systems to unacceptable cybersecurity risks and potential liability in the event of a breach. We need look no further back than the FINTRAC breach of 2024 or the Salt Typhoon attacks that same year which led the Canadian government to join a dozen governments in advising greater adoption of encryption, to truly appreciate the risk that our secured systems face on a daily basis.\n\nCompounding these concerns is the increased potential for cross-border data exposure. Bill C‐22 would open pathways for information sharing with foreign governments, including jurisdictions where civil liberty protections are weakening and surveillance powers are expanding, some with a history of abusing cross-border police authorities to persecute diaspora communities.\n\nConcerns do not stop there. Canada may also be implicated in transnational repression. At a time when digital rights and due process protections are under strain internationally, expanding these channels raises serious concerns about accountability and misuse of Canadian-held data.\n\nWe must also be honest about the historical context of surveillance in the country. It is not theoretical to say that expanded surveillance powers have, in the past, been used disproportionately against activists, organizers, journalists and communities advocating for social and political change.\n\nOversight bodies have repeatedly documented concerns about intelligence gathering that extends beyond legitimate criminal investigation. We need to look no further than the RCMP surveilling and actively undermining indigenous activists and movements, as the recent news from a few months ago revealed with the release of documents. When surveillance powers expand, they rarely remain confined to their original intent. They expand in scope, in use and in impact.\n\nThis brings us to an important point about precedent. What we are seeing is an expansion of surveillance powers that were previously rejected due to legitimate concerns about privacy, proportionality and charter compliance. At a time when global political conditions are unstable and civil liberty protections in some jurisdictions are eroding, Canada should be strengthening privacy protections, not weakening them. The government may argue that these powers are necessary for public safety and effective law enforcement, but necessity must be demonstrated, not assumed, and proportionality must be proven, not implied. We do not need to choose between security and privacy. This is a false choice. Effective policing and intelligence work can and should operate within robust legal frameworks that preserve judicial oversight and limit data collection to what is strictly necessary.\n\nBill C-22 fails that task. It lowers thresholds for access to personal information. It expands executive authority over digital infrastructure. It mandates or enables large-scale data retention and increases systemic exposure of private communications to risk. Businesses are considering withdrawing services from Canada should Bill C-22 be implemented. For these reasons, this legislation should not proceed in its current form. If not withdrawn and sent back to the drawing board, at minimum, it requires substantial amendments, such as restoration of judicial authorization for access orders, strict limitation of data retention powers, removal of secret system modification orders and clear prohibition of infrastructure changes that compromise encryption or system integrity. A clear understanding of the implications of system vulnerabilities needs to be incorporated with amendments to the bill to ensure those vulnerabilities do not put Canadians at further risk. Absent those kinds of changes and more, Bill C-22 represents a significant step backward for privacy rights and constitutional protections in Canada.\n\nThis is not what Canadians want, I do not believe, from a Liberal government. The question before us is whether we are willing to accept a shift towards generalized surveillance infrastructure as the default condition of digital life in Canada. I am not, nor are my constituents in Vancouver East, so I urge the House to reject this path. We still have a chance. I want to be surprised. I want to be shocked. I want to see the government members not just roll over and do what they are told. We heard from other members in the House earlier who say there were not even robust, meaningful and fulsome discussions at committee with witnesses. Witnesses were not able to attend committee. Briefs were not transcribed or provided.\n\nThis cannot be a path forward, because the structural changes are so significant and impactful for Canadians that we cannot afford to get it wrong. Let us take the time to do it right. I urge all members of the House to do what is important and what is right for Canadians. I urge them to not just follow the orders of what the government whip tells them to do but to do what civil society organizations, advocates and experts tell them must be done. They must examine these issues with their own mind and make that determination. I urge members to do that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087651","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise to speak to this important moment regarding Bill C-22. Of course, the government has brought down the sledgehammer, the guillotine, to shut down debate.\n\n Bill C-22 is a version of its predecessor, Bill C-2, the so-called strong borders act, which was an offensive, omnibus bill that was dead on arrival. It immediately generated widespread opposition from the public, with tens","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da9caf827ae0a6f0ad232b664e8f9ed98411fc4aae0b8e1e0868236855ca40ed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa45a321e10941deca2d45389687c01034540261ec845f13fe542772a0dfbbdf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57501d03c7bca11feeca675f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087652,"date":"2026-06-18T00:56:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the NDP submitted dozens of amendments. I believe that those amendments, along with some from other parties, would achieve that goal to develop proportionality and bring some balance to this legislation. The amendments would not fix everything, but they would be a good start for the government to adopt opposition member amendments, and not just go forward with government or Liberal member amendments. That is the track record so far with what has happened at committee, and I think it is the wrong track.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087652","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the NDP submitted dozens of amendments. I believe that those amendments, along with some from other parties, would achieve that goal to develop proportionality and bring some balance to this legislation. The amendments would not fix everything, but they would be a good start for the government to adopt opposition member amendments, and not just go forward with government or Liberal ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e560153d6b1afc4b868c856","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087653,"date":"2026-06-18T00:59:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, the Privacy Commissioner actually appeared as a witness at the committee and offered suggestions. I also contacted the Privacy Commissioner after Bill C‐22 was tabled and asked whether they had any comments about the bill. They provided comments on C‐2, which the government took into consideration. However, I think that there is much work to be done. I wonder why the government rejected the motion that was tabled by committee members to bring the Privacy Commissioner back to committee to ensure questions were answered by the Privacy Commissioner as the committee went through clause-by-clause. That was rejected by the Liberals.\n\nTo the member's point about the filibustering, I went to committee and watched what was going on. What happened was members were asking legitimate questions and then there was a motion to split the bill, by the Conservatives, into part one and part two. The Liberals rejected it. I then observed that the filibustering started to happen. It is a tool. When members get frustrated with the government's approach, they use that as a tool to send a message to the government that it cannot run roughshod when trying to make laws. That was the message, I believe, the members were trying to send.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087653","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, the Privacy Commissioner actually appeared as a witness at the committee and offered suggestions. I also contacted the Privacy Commissioner after Bill C‐22 was tabled and asked whether they had any comments about the bill. They provided comments on C‐2, which the government took into consideration. However, I think that there is much work to be done. I wonder why the government reje","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["51dcddbcfe7e1a5211786d4650463afa496d09747f06a956e8c903b246686813"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9898963c175095adafa80089","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087654,"date":"2026-06-18T01:01:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, it is very unusual for me, as a New Democrat, to agree with the Conservatives. On this bill, the Conservatives, the NDP, the Greens and the Bloc are all offering the same voice. What message does that send to the government? I think the message is that the government got it wrong.\n\nTo the member's question about businesses being worried, yes, some of them have indicated to me that they would actually leave Canada should Bill C‐22 proceed because it would put their companies in jeopardy on the privacy protections for their customers. Equally to the point, it would put them in a liability situation should there be a breach. The backdoor mechanism would create a breach that could actually violate people's privacy and put those companies in a liability situation. Once the cat is out of the bag, we cannot put it back in. That is why we cannot ram through this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087654","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, it is very unusual for me, as a New Democrat, to agree with the Conservatives. On this bill, the Conservatives, the NDP, the Greens and the Bloc are all offering the same voice. What message does that send to the government? I think the message is that the government got it wrong.\n\nTo the member's question about businesses being worried, yes, some of them have indicated to me that t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6e69848c5c47c79dc89c6482e64591a4bd39eb705beee65acf5f1a832b4ee8e5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cafdd1263b09d9efc270e29b059c3b020246327b2264fae1dbc225896fb346a2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d86a6a58bad07ecf98d81241","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087655,"date":"2026-06-18T01:03:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate what the Conservatives are trying to do, which is to bring more debate on part 2 of the bill. However, the premise of the amendment is still framed in terms of bringing in closure on debate. That is what I am challenged with. I do not think we should be bringing in closure to any parts of this bill. The two parts go hand in hand and are important, so we should take the time to do the work.\n\nThis is what I am urging all members to do, take the time to do it right, because it is significant in terms of the changes for Canadians and for us as a country, as a whole.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087655","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I appreciate what the Conservatives are trying to do, which is to bring more debate on part 2 of the bill. However, the premise of the amendment is still framed in terms of bringing in closure on debate. That is what I am challenged with. I do not think we should be bringing in closure to any parts of this bill. The two parts go hand in hand and are important, so we should take the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c093eee66e9e4f800e7daa78a3b28a213a85c7d566a20f5f782fa5188b38f862"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d665686d6cde1086304edcee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087656,"date":"2026-06-18T01:05:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I have been a parliamentarian in this House for 10 years, and prior to that provincially for 19 years. I have never seen a government embark on this kind of process in such an aggressive way, setting aside the basic rights, civil liberties and privacy rights of Canadians, setting aside valid legal experts' concerns, civil liberty advocates' concerns, privacy experts' concerns and a whole host of community concerns. This is from a Liberal government that pretends to listen to people, but what I have witnessed in the last two weeks with the volume of programming motions the government is bringing forward to ram things through on significant bills, such as Bill C‐22, is unprecedented. I have never seen anything like it.\n\nIt is not a democratic government. It is an authoritarian government wielding its majority, not through legitimacy and democracy but through floor-crossers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-138/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087656","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I have been a parliamentarian in this House for 10 years, and prior to that provincially for 19 years. I have never seen a government embark on this kind of process in such an aggressive way, setting aside the basic rights, civil liberties and privacy rights of Canadians, setting aside valid legal experts' concerns, civil liberty advocates' concerns, privacy experts' concerns and a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31dd0a62c04c5c81a9a7cc5f5dc0ef85ef9d8f189fbb05fca384b0cf30d5dbfc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c21be4dfeaaeaba8e93fb311a2be059e694a2fcd6037991a52381dccb27ceef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7a613a7afce719e6f980515","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087636,"date":"2026-06-18T15:09:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table three petitions today.\n\nThe first petition is signed by electors of Vancouver Fraserview–South Burnaby and Vancouver Quadra, who brought their petitions to their local MPs but had to ask for my assistance to table this in the House.\n\nThe petitioners have raised many concerns about fracked methane gas and liquefied methane gas, or LNG, including the severe emissions and health impacts to people and the disruption of LNG to clean salmon rivers.\n\n They know there is no business case for LNG, and these fossil fuel projects will become stranded assets. They note that Ksi Lisims is 100% American-owned, LNG Canada's phase two is 60% foreign-owned, not Canadian-sovereign, and the Ksi Lisims and Prince Rupert gas transmission pipelines early investors are U.S. private equity firms linked to Trump and Jeffrey Epstein. The petitioners are concerned that hydro subsidies for these American-owned projects have been promised and will increase household utility costs. They also note that these projects violate indigenous sovereignty, as the Gitanyow and Wet'suwet'en hereditary chiefs, as well as the Lax'yip firekeepers of the Gitxsan have clearly said no to consent.\n\nTherefore, the petitioners call on the House of Commons, the Government of Canada, the Prime Minister and the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure to rescind the referral of Ksi Lisims' and LNG Canada's phase two to the Major Projects Office as projects of national interest; to not fund, subsidize or in any way support it, but instead refer indigenous-owned, shovel-ready solar, electric and other renewable energy projects to the Major Projects Office for funding as green projects of national interest; and to fund affordable housing through the Canada Infrastructure Bank and other monies.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087636","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to table three petitions today.\n\nThe first petition is signed by electors of Vancouver Fraserview–South Burnaby and Vancouver Quadra, who brought their petitions to their local MPs but had to ask for my assistance to table this in the House.\n\nThe petitioners have raised many concerns about fracked methane gas and liquefied methane gas, or LNG, including the severe emissions and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11e87a6fa7a21677260a384656a6273ceaf747f137dad30f941dc0aeb8a89f8f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f743f62d1a8d9377205107240a1cb9620e6b751212b6f738b7749e33464c63a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80a7015412ac6222be95efb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087637,"date":"2026-06-18T15:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition is signed by Canadians who are concerned about Canada's safe third country agreement with the United States. They note that Canadian law offers safe haven to persons with a well-founded fear of persecution. They also note that a continual review of all countries designated as safe third countries should be required to ensure that the conditions that led to that designation continue to be met.\n\nThe petitioners say refugee claimants in the U.S., including those who enter the country regularly, are being arrested, detained and deported without due process. In his recent speech to the World Economic Forum, the Prime Minister called for the creation of agreements that function as described, yet Canada is a signatory to the 1951 UN refugee convention and its 1967 protocol, which violates the refugee convention and its own laws by implementing the safe third country agreement.\n\n Therefore, they call on the House of Commons to instruct the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship to immediately report to the governor in council that the U.S. no longer meets the requirements for designation as a safe third country, notify the U.S. in writing that Canada intends to terminate the safe third country—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087637","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the second petition is signed by Canadians who are concerned about Canada's safe third country agreement with the United States. They note that Canadian law offers safe haven to persons with a well-founded fear of persecution. They also note that a continual review of all countries designated as safe third countries should be required to ensure that the conditions that led to that des","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af0a4aa8fe179e206b50aa4405c0898d1bf64bdeb1338be793f7a34ddbe7f97d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cd84f093ac5b5493654be2ef9d2e58bb041afccbed0cbcf66c3ee5b50d37130a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77f0170a4f60bddf6db03dbd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087638,"date":"2026-06-18T15:13:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the petitioners are asking for the government to terminate the safe third country agreement in accordance with article 10 of the agreement and, finally, to instruct the Canada Border Services Agency to change its policy so that it no longer enforces the safe third country agreement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087638","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the petitioners are asking for the government to terminate the safe third country agreement in accordance with article 10 of the agreement and, finally, to instruct the Canada Border Services Agency to change its policy so that it no longer enforces the safe third country agreement.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["36ea60d9f2ce4b872187b618784f14acbafc97c3ac2876613fc56e1dbedb7502"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["472b815d212feb8150b446f19300fda6418f4f69688590f1ea9bc85c1ae1ce83"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-885db1e046f0374c55eb244a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087639,"date":"2026-06-18T15:14:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the last petition that I am tabling has been signed by 25 people, including several constituents of my Vancouver East riding, who share with me their support and calls to the House regarding Bill C-218.\n\n The petitioners say Canadians with mental illness should be provided with treatment and support, mental illness is complex and can include suicidal ideation as a symptom, and they are concerned that the lives of Canadians with mental illness will be at risk when they are eligible for medical assistance in dying on the basis of mental illness alone, especially when treatment and support are not readily available.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087639","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the last petition that I am tabling has been signed by 25 people, including several constituents of my Vancouver East riding, who share with me their support and calls to the House regarding Bill C-218.\n\n The petitioners say Canadians with mental illness should be provided with treatment and support, mental illness is complex and can include suicidal ideation as a symptom, and they ar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6877aa5368382857ba205e3c6faea603ce9e8fccf43c3a497a525ddd157fb77d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a54c6ce9c8543c6b0374dd32be911b7c89951d269c96d7a924e6ac7dcc5ea5e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee03f530489ab6edcb94cadc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087640,"date":"2026-06-18T15:37:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Indian Residential School Survivors Society has provided support to indigenous peoples harmed by Canada's colonial systems. They were promised by Indigenous Services Canada that they would receive confirmation for their two-year funding by mid-May. Today there has been no action and their funding ends on July 1.\n\nCan the parliamentary secretary explain why?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087640","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Indian Residential School Survivors Society has provided support to indigenous peoples harmed by Canada's colonial systems. They were promised by Indigenous Services Canada that they would receive confirmation for their two-year funding by mid-May. Today there has been no action and their funding ends on July 1.\n\nCan the parliamentary secretary explain why?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ac5b1a73d9476dc4e13661c075162862a72c5c824e160fca6b9a8c33b5111909"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d164e377ca61fe2653963b00176150c41b681ca28d616470fc5ad25b1965ce23"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c2df9dfdd2b8c1fe6c385cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087641,"date":"2026-06-18T16:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP would also like to make sure that it is on the record that the NDP members do not support Bill C-22, likewise to my colleague from the Greens.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087641","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the NDP would also like to make sure that it is on the record that the NDP members do not support Bill C-22, likewise to my colleague from the Greens.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c563cc78517a7df7db4c345","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087642,"date":"2026-06-18T16:54:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-30, the spring economic update 2026 implementation act. As parliamentarians, our responsibility is to examine not only what the government has chosen to include in an economic update, but also what it has chosen to leave out. \n\nBill C-30 would implement selected measures announced in the spring economic update, but budgets and economic updates are not technical exercises conducted by the Prime Minister on his own or by his narrow circle of advisers. They are statements of priorities for all Canadians. This is the hope and vision of what our constituents expect of us: to take off our blind spots and look at the bigger picture. What we ask of the Prime Minister today is to review what the government values, where it is prepared to invest and whose needs it is prepared to postpone. \n\nThe question before us is not simply whether the measures contained in Bill C-30 should proceed. The question is whether this bill would respond to the realities Canadians are living every day. This is where my concerns lie, which is that this legislation does not not meet the moment of the challenges everyday Canadians face. It does not live up to the hype of the projected progressive Prime Minister that was portrayed during the election or what we have come to read about him. There is a dissonance between words and action, and therein lies the problem. In my constituency of Vancouver East and in communities across this country, the gap between policy and lived experience is widening, and the concerns around the centralizing tendency of the government are being noticed across the country. \n\nIn Vancouver East, constituents are facing housing insecurity, food insecurity, gaps in health care coverage. uncertainty in indigenous housing initiatives, delays in compensation programs and rising affordability pressures across every essential service. They are also increasingly concerned about federal priorities shifting toward expanded military spending while social programs remain underfunded or delayed. Across all these areas, a pattern is becoming unmistakable: announcements without delivery, commitments without timelines, programs without certainty sunsetting out of existence, and decisions increasingly centralized in Ottawa, far removed from the communities they affect. \n\nCommunities know what they need, municipalities know what they need, indigenous housing providers know what they need and frontline organizations know what they need, yet funding decisions remain concentrated in Ottawa while people on the ground continue to experience delays, uncertainty and shifting eligibility rules. This is not administrative complexity. This is a failure of delivery, and Canadians are living the consequences of this unfortunate reality. \n\nI will begin with first nations education. In B.C., first nations education is supported through the BC Tripartite Education Agreement between first nations leadership, the province and Canada. At the centre of that agreement is the First Nations Education Steering Committee. This is not a symbolic structure. It is the core funding architecture for first nations education in B.C. It determines staffing, curriculum and infrastructure. It determines whether first nations children have stable access to education. It is in effect the backbone of educational stability for first nations students in this province. \n\nDespite early assurances that a renewed long-term agreement would be included in the 2026 spring economic update, first nations partners were instead informed that only a one-year extension would be provided. A one-year extension does not provide for stability. It produces uncertainty, and uncertainty in education is not abstract. It affects staffing, planning and children's outcomes. The First Nations Education Steering Committee and first nations leadership have been clear: What is required is a 10-year renewal agreement that provides predictability, continuity and proper fiscal planning. Reconciliation is not achieved through short-term extensions, but is achieved through durable commitments that governments keep. Right now, that certainty is missing.\n\nThe same pattern is evident with support for survivors of residential schools. Many indigenous leaders, survivors and advocates have repeatedly raised stable funding for the Indian Residential School Survivors Society. For decades, survivors have carried the trauma inflicted by Canada's residential school system. They have carried grief, loss and intergenerational harm resulting from policies designed to erase indigenous identities, cultures and communities. Today, many continue to rely on the Indian Residential School Survivors Society for culturally appropriate counselling, crisis support and healing services. \n\nIn fact, for 30 years, the Indian Residential School Survivors Society has provided support to indigenous people harmed by Canada's colonial systems, the sixties scoop, the ongoing missing and murdered indigenous women and girls and 2S+ crisis, and more, yet despite repeated commitments to reconciliation, despite having been told by Indigenous Services Canada that the organization would receive confirmation for its two-year funding by mid-May, to date, there is still no action. The funding will end on July 1. This delay is going to have serious operational impacts for the people it serves. The organization continues to seek certainty regarding its long-term core funding.\n\n Reconciliation cannot depend on year-to-year uncertainty. Reconciliation is not a slogan. It is not a press release. It is not a commemorative statement. Reconciliation requires action. It requires resources. It requires government to ensure that organizations serving survivors have the certainty necessary to continue their work. If the government can find fiscal room for subsidies for big oil, it can find the resources necessary to provide stable support to those serving residential school survivors.\n\nTurning to housing, the \"for indigenous, by indigenous\" urban, rural and northern indigenous housing strategy was something that the Liberals committed to in the last Parliament. It was something that the NDP prioritized in the confidence and supply agreement. I fought for that. We fought for that and won interim funding of $300 million and long-term funding of $4 billion over seven years for FIBI URN, and an equivalent amount of $4 billion over seven years for distinction-based funding, yet the funding of the long-term component has yet to flow.\n\nIndigenous housing providers continue to face uncertainty about governance, timelines and implementation. Even as funding is referenced in the federal announcements, there remains no clear guarantee that delivery will remain indigenous-led in practice, nor a firm timeline for rollout. While policy frameworks evolve in Ottawa, indigenous communities continue to experience the highest rate of homelessness in Canada. In Vancouver alone, indigenous people represent a disproportionate share of those experiencing homelessness, despite being a far smaller share of the population. They are the predictable result of decades of underinvestment and policy delay. \n\nHousing providers are ready to build. Friendship centres are ready to build. Indigenous-led organizations are ready to build. The problem is not capacity. The problem is execution. People cannot live in promises of affordability. They cannot sleep in frameworks. They cannot raise children in consultations.\n\n Constituents are also increasingly concerned about rental assistance for co-operative housing members. Co-ops work. They provide stability. They provide affordability. They provide community-based housing that has proven effective for decades. \n\nPhase 2 funding under the federal community housing initiative will sunset. This subsidy support is critical to co-op housing members whose household incomes would cause them to pay more than the current 25% rent geared to income. If this program is not renewed, more than 14,400 families across the country will lose their homes. Rising Star and China Creek, for example, in my riding, will be hit hard if the rental assistance subsidy is not renewed. The expiry of the FCHI phase 2 funding without a successor program or extension risks undoing decades of investment in this model and displacing established community members, including families with young children and seniors who depend on it. Access to rental assistance is necessary to enable co-ops to be a deeply affordable housing solution. FCHI cannot, and must not, sunset.\n\nAside from housing, Van East constituents continue to raise serious concerns about the Canadian dental care plan. I have written to the minister regarding applications for medically necessary procedures, including crowns, that are being rejected using template language that provides no meaningful explanation of what criteria were not met. Patients are left without clarity, providers are left without guidance, and appeals are effectively blocked.\n\n Even more troubling are cases where some of my constituents were previously approved for the Canadian dental care plan, received care in good faith and are now being told that they are not eligible after all. In some cases, they are even being asked to repay benefits that they already received. These are often seniors who opted out of private dental care insurance years ago because premiums were unaffordable on fixed incomes. At the time of approval, they met eligibility criteria and were approved. They acted in good faith. They made irreversible financial decisions based on the government's approval. Retroactive reassessment after reliance undermines trust in public programs. A system cannot function if eligibility is uncertain at the outset and reversible after the fact. This is not fairness. This is instability.\n\n Health care affordability is another glaring omission from this bill. Many Canadians welcomed the promise to establish an expanded universal pharmacare, yet constituents increasingly tell me that they worry that those promises are being quietly abandoned. They see that the Prime Minister is abandoning the provinces and territories that did not sign the pharmacare agreement prior to the last election. People do not care about talking points. They care about whether or not they can afford their medication. They care about whether they must choose between prescriptions and groceries. They care about whether universal pharmacare will actually become universal. The Prime Minister sent a clear message that universal pharmacare is not a priority for him when the spring economic update did not provide additional resources to this key initiative.\n\n On affordability, Canadians are increasingly concerned about surveillance pricing. This is the use of personal data, behavioural tracking and algorithmic systems to charge different prices to different individuals for identical goods and services. It means two Canadians can stand in the same digital marketplace and see different prices based on what a corporation believes they can pay. Even when legislation such as Bill C-36 references algorithmic pricing risks, it does not actually prohibit surveillance pricing. It does not even name it. It does not stop it. Instead, it leaves Canadians exposed to opaque pricing systems that they cannot see and cannot challenge.\n\n Premier Wab Kinew has taken decisive action in Manitoba to stop it. The Prime Minister and this government have refused to take a stand. What side is the Prime Minister on? Unlike the Liberals, who will always be on the side of big corporations, the NDP will stand on the side of the people. That is why I will be introducing a private member's bill this fall to ban surveillance pricing outright.\n\n Food safety is also at stake. Proposed changes to pesticide regulation have raised concerns from environmental and public health organizations, including Ecojustice, which warns that reforms risk weakening scientific oversight and transparency. Canadians expect food safety to be grounded in independent science. They expect precaution where health is at stake. They expect transparency in regulatory decision-making. Anything less undermines public trust.\n\n My constituents have also raised concerns regarding the Prime Minister's intention to privatize ports and airports. Even Stephen Harper would not dare to touch these critical assets. They are strategic national infrastructure essential to supply chains, trade and economic resilience. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission repeatedly flagged concerns over monopoly pricing, noting that user costs, passenger charges and parking fees surged dramatically. Airlines passed escalating landing fees directly to passengers via higher ticket prices when they privatized. The Shipping Australia industry association noted that private port operators prioritized maximizing shareholder returns, implementing heavy rent increases on terminal tenants that trickled down into standard freight and consumer goods. If Canada goes down this track, this is what Canada can expect.\n\nThis neo-liberal playbook seems to be from another era. A broad pattern is emerging. We are seeing the increasing centralization of decision-making in Ottawa from the Prime Minister. We are seeing delays in social program delivery and increased military spending, alongside constrained social investments. Budgets are about choices, and choices are about priorities. Canadians are asking, what does increased military spending mean for housing, for pharmacare, for dental care, for indigenous housing, for transit and for disability supports? These are not abstract fiscal questions. They are real-world opportunity costs, and Canadians deserve transparency about them.\n\nIn Vancouver East, the consequences are very real and very visible. Seniors are relying on food banks. Families are skipping meals. People are delaying medical care. Housing is increasingly out of reach. Affordability is being eroded not just by prices but by systems that are less transparent and less responsive. One constituent described losing weight because they cannot afford enough food. Another, a 77-year-old senior, said they are relying on a food bank for the first time in their life. These are not isolated cases. They are becoming systemic. As one constituent put it, on the issue of transit, we need our transit to green commutes more than we need another pipeline.\n\nEvery budget decision involves trade-offs. Canadians deserve transparency about those trade-offs. We are faced with deep drought conditions across Vancouver Island, the Okanagan, the Chilcotin and the South Thompson regions. Climate change is real. Instead of investing in transit, the spring economic update cuts it by $5 billion, while the Prime Minister signs an agreement with Alberta to build yet another pipeline. Canadians deserve to know why the Prime Minister would prioritize pipelines over funding for transit expansion, especially when B.C. faces the highest and most sustained fire risk in the country.\n\nSimilarly, Canadians deserve to know why billions of dollars can be found for military expansion when communities continue to be told to wait for desperately needed social investments. If the government believes military spending must increase, it should explain why the same urgency is absent when it comes to homelessness, poverty, housing and health care. Increased military spending is happening when there has not been a robust public debate on it, during the last election or thereafter. It was just announced by the Prime Minister as a fait accompli.\n\nMany constituents have raised concerns regarding military goods and components exported to the U.S. that may subsequently be transferred elsewhere without the same level of scrutiny that applies to direct Canadian exports. Those concerns were reflected in proposals such as my private member's bill, Bill C-233, the no more loopholes act, which was defeated by the government. Canadians want robust risk assessments. They want transparency. They want accountability. They want assurances that Canadian-made military goods are not contributing to human rights violations or breaches of international humanitarian law. Economic policy and trade policy cannot be separated from human rights obligations.\n\nMany constituents have also written regarding the humanitarian crisis facing the Cuban community. They have called on Canada to increase humanitarian assistance; support access to food, medicine and fuel; and pursue constructive diplomacy. They have urged Canada to work with international partners to ensure that relief reaches those in need and to maintain an independent foreign policy grounded in dialogue, co-operation and respect for self-determination. Canadians understand our international role and Canada's proud history of our commitment to peacebuilding, humanitarian assistance and international solidarity. It is not time to turn our backs on what has historically made Canadians proud.\n\nLet me close with this, Mr. Speaker. This bill reveals clear patterns. Housing is delayed. Indigenous housing remains uncertain. Health care programs lack transparency. Dental eligibility is unstable. Survivors are waiting. Disabled Canadians are waiting. Families are waiting. Waiting has become the default policy, but Canadians cannot wait indefinitely. The crisis is before Canadians. It is time to act for the people, not for corporations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087642","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill C-30, the spring economic update 2026 implementation act. As parliamentarians, our responsibility is to examine not only what the government has chosen to include in an economic update, but also what it has chosen to leave out. \n\nBill C-30 would implement selected measures announced in the spring economic update, but budgets and economic updates are not technic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4e94cbf2caa39e97540df04b45d076ce7cadc0245aab6c49f9d47dd10e832080"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["273d0e125397b9117e8464e9f4e392a25bbcb794c0dfb06ed09df66a02a93314"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0add339b73e2dbd97e6196d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087643,"date":"2026-06-18T17:15:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the people sleeping outside tonight cannot wait. The seniors choosing between food and medication cannot wait, and the constituents facing administrative collapse in a federal compensation program cannot wait.\n\nBudgets reveal values, and this bill reveals them clearly. Canadians deserve an economy built on fairness, transparency and delivery, not on delay and indifference. They deserve a government that is willing to govern for all Canadians, not just for the hedge fund managers, the private equity CEOs and the finance bros who hang out at the Empire Club of Canada in downtown Toronto, such as the Prime Minister and his narrow circle of insiders. Everyday working Canadians deserve better.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087643","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the people sleeping outside tonight cannot wait. The seniors choosing between food and medication cannot wait, and the constituents facing administrative collapse in a federal compensation program cannot wait.\n\nBudgets reveal values, and this bill reveals them clearly. Canadians deserve an economy built on fairness, transparency and delivery, not on delay and indifference. They deserv","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06d8d53b2a387e93433d653547401e0da9324f43de9d81516d90953ed962c8fe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["472473dd8e69c9cbde2914a3025b14394f9bb9ca83f155ca6339a0c6c958a5d2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3965d9f6a136e97bffe121d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087644,"date":"2026-06-18T17:16:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, it is quite interesting, actually. In this sitting, in these last two weeks, the government has brought down the guillotine for significant major legislation, including Bill C-22, and we are poised to rise, probably by the end of today, I suspect. What is left on the agenda, which was not actually a priority for the government to push through, is the bill on apprenticeship to support union workers, so there we go.\n\nThe Liberals are pretending they support unions, yet at the same time, they are ramming down back-to-work legislation. They are invoking section 107 to take away the rights of unions to strike. My colleague, the member for Winnipeg Centre, has a private member's bill on that. Will the government members support it? If they support unions, they will support my colleague's bill on actually banning the use of section 107.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087644","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, it is quite interesting, actually. In this sitting, in these last two weeks, the government has brought down the guillotine for significant major legislation, including Bill C-22, and we are poised to rise, probably by the end of today, I suspect. What is left on the agenda, which was not actually a priority for the government to push through, is the bill on apprenticeship to support ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca170ffe6e252c54be568a9d19395544f90fb0580d645954d0e01b7c15079ad4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["37120efab91332f852778e992b71c6bad15e150ace17d0ad3180b9ae76edb066"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d886c7a20c6b6d6de574e5bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087645,"date":"2026-06-18T17:19:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his advocacy for his community. It is absolutely essential that all parliamentarians stand up for all workers. Migrant workers have been abused in this country. Frankly, both the Liberals and Conservatives, when it was convenient for them, brought in temporary foreign workers so they could bring down wages, suppress wages. In fact, the UN rapporteur actually said that Canada's temporary foreign worker program, with the approaches the Canadian government has taken, is equivalent to modern-day slavery.\n\nMany migrant workers are subject to abuse and exploitation, and the member cited an example from his own community. Even when abuses are found, the penalty is so small, so minimal, that it is absolutely outrageous. What the government is doing is allowing those kinds of abusive practices, and sending a message that they can actually continue. What the government can do, and what the NDP has advocated for, is to have people get landed immigrant status upon arrival. They should get status so they can be protected and not be subject to exploitation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087645","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his advocacy for his community. It is absolutely essential that all parliamentarians stand up for all workers. Migrant workers have been abused in this country. Frankly, both the Liberals and Conservatives, when it was convenient for them, brought in temporary foreign workers so they could bring down wages, suppress wages. In fact, the UN rapporteur actually s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ff169d0bb30ffbadd346fcdee89d223c861248797749307ce5f29d766f14b37"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["53e637166f4fe7b0693bfbbcd2402a5505833df4548be6ce8701cf719c01d4ed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5253cc72315012880fedea66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087646,"date":"2026-06-18T17:21:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will give an example of the challenges that, in British Columbia, and in Vancouver more specifically, we are faced with. With the francophone community, particularly in the education sector, the federal government actually can ensure that provinces receive significant increases in funding to backstop this. Do members know what we are reduced to in our education system for children who want to have access to language training in French, in French immersion classes? We have to go in for a lottery draw. If someone is lucky enough, their name will be drawn, and then they can actually enrol in that particular school.\n\n Many students did not get that chance, including my own children, by the way. When they were little, I submitted their names into the draw, but sadly, none of my children's names were drawn, and they could not get into French immersion. That is the reality Canadians are faced with. That is the reality British Columbians are faced with. That is the reality Vancouverites are faced with. I would call on the government members, instead of patting themselves on the back to say how swell they are doing, to look at where the problems are and to take action.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087646","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will give an example of the challenges that, in British Columbia, and in Vancouver more specifically, we are faced with. With the francophone community, particularly in the education sector, the federal government actually can ensure that provinces receive significant increases in funding to backstop this. Do members know what we are reduced to in our education system for children w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33e7e35ee3d1bb36fc0736e484fe1b456f0070bb985b6edc1f01e275b002e2f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e2585a5dbd76905d0481e84ccce67e26bb72a666dde896bbf8c617d383bcbb8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34392da14eb0abf4f6c75be2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087647,"date":"2026-06-18T17:23:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague is actually on top of so many of the issues, and he is absolutely spot-on. The Liberal government and the Prime Minister snuck into an omnibus bill, Bill C-30, a tiny sliver of reference that they would be taking away critical regulation and regulatory practices that ensure that our food system is safe with respect to pesticides. This is what the government is doing. Supposedly it is looking after Canadians and our health, but, my goodness, what it is doing is just trying to hide this information, and there would be absolutely serious consequences for Canadians.\n\nThe government claims that it supports science, but it would be gutting science. It is actually not relying on science, and it is putting in jeopardy our health and the scientific knowledge that is there. I would say that the government absolutely needs to pause this insidious action, do the consultation and reinstate scientific experts in every part of the department.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087647","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, my colleague is actually on top of so many of the issues, and he is absolutely spot-on. The Liberal government and the Prime Minister snuck into an omnibus bill, Bill C-30, a tiny sliver of reference that they would be taking away critical regulation and regulatory practices that ensure that our food system is safe with respect to pesticides. This is what the government is doing. Supp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","label":"Tax fraud","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8f2ac584b3127da8da6c9af7c7f11485fceb4e306c66fb21a23d05564fb1f7f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9794b613a1ecd8fe54ded2ee69742f7213cb63f74f776e1cefdb5c9bd9454ac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e9f90fba80735abf9eb4870","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1087648,"date":"2026-06-18T17:25:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jenny Kwan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are patting themselves on the back and think they are doing so well, because their focus is all on the big corporations. It is about the CEOs. The government is shovelling support to all of them, but everyday Canadians are all being left behind. The fact is that the divide in wealth is becoming greater and greater between the haves and—","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/45-1/house/sitting-139/hansard","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1087648","member_id":"bc-mp-89346","member_name":"Jenny Kwan","month":"2026-06","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are patting themselves on the back and think they are doing so well, because their focus is all on the big corporations. It is about the CEOs. The government is shovelling support to all of them, but everyday Canadians are all being left behind. The fact is that the divide in wealth is becoming greater and greater between the haves and—","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","label":"Inequality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","label":"Inequality","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6144e9626fdabb8621ae830e2bf6224651711bf3118b8d77a5752bbdc17bff55"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f6bc3bf85402c30ad9489152473fb55a0b0d032160b931be4a7805b283256d69"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}}]}
